001welcome everyone to tonight's meeting of the North Middle sex Regional School District it is February 6 2025 it is 603 the meeting is being recorded the next regular meeting of the North Middle sex Regional School District will be Wednesday February 26 2025 in attendance tonight and I'll take a roll call vote we have Randy Rous here Lisa Bloom uh Patrick MC Phillips I here June mcneel here Tom Casey William Hackler here uh and Jill twig here William Berg he's here I didn't hear a here but and myself he's here hand sorry and then we also have Brad Morgan superintendent Nancy Haynes here Gary Reese Dr Reese and Robin ivy all right tonight um we have two public hearings I'm going to explain first what the public hearing is the public hearing is an input of
002from let's start that again to gather public input on a specific proposal before a decision is made by a governing body tonight we will have two public hearings we will have one about school choice and we will have one about the 2025 26 North Middle sex Regional School District budget the format will be superintendent Morgan will do his presentation on the two proposals and all interesting interested parties shall be given the opportunity to voice their concerns first we will start with comments from the committee members and town officials and then we will go to the public the public will start with the pre-registered citizens who pre-registered and then I will ask ask audience members if they would like to speak and then we will follow up with the citizens that supplied written statements questions are
003allowed during the public hearing but they are to gain clarification aspects of The Proposal votes pertaining to the proposals will not be taken during public hearing I ask that everyone be respectful of each other's time and of each other please also be patient with our technology as when we ask you to speak it may take some time for you to be brought into the presentation all right now I am going to take a motion to open the public hearing for school choice for the year 2025 2026 according to chapter 76 section B of the Massachusetts general laws so moved that was will Hackler second and I have a second by June mcneel all right Randy Rous yes Lisa Bloom yes June mcneel yes will Hackler yes William Berg yes Patrick MC Phillips yes Tom Casey
004yes Bill twig yes and myself yes the public hearing is now open I will hand it over to superintendent Morgan and he will give a presentation and an explanation of what school choice is okay can everyone hear me okay so school choice uh basically allows students from outside the district if there is space to come into the district and the district receives $5,000 um from the sending District um so if they reside outside of our three borders in the past couple years we have not um we have not gone with school choice just because it really does not match up to the per pupil cost and it has been used historically to fill classrooms where we're currently at a point where next year's budget is in flux I am recommending that we not have school
005choice next year the benefit of a no vote at this point is that we can change um at any point in the spring and go back and allow for school choice a yes vote locks you in and you cannot change from yes to no but the no you can change to yes so at this point again where the budget is um still up in the air we're not sure of what direction we're going in with regard to buildings we're not sure what class size is going to be like I am recommending to the committee that we not move forward with school choice at this point in time any questions from anyone on the committee Randy um I completely understand and agree for next year um I would like in the ne within the next year
006to have um an analysis done on the uh choice that we've had in the district to see whether it's actually worthwhile to think about in the future should we have room um we we definitely had choice in our district for many many years that we can pull some information just to see if uh getting that money actually helped us out or not it would be a very interesting thing to do that if we have some room in because we've had one you know one space in this class one space in that class uh over the years and if we can bring in a few students and it actually benefits us financially um it'd be good to know that for the future sure we can do that anyone else Patrick yeah I I understand that you
007said that it you know $5,000 is clearly less than the costs per student I mean those costs cover the overhead you know and Etc of every building does does it actually cost if we bring in a student another $5,000 more than I should say $5,000 for that student because I mean the teachers paid for the buildings paid for what are what are the actual cost there versus like is there profit made or or does that help so it it's really totally dependent on a couple of issues first and foremost and what this is something that was happening previously um is that if you end up say with a class of um 28 students and a school takes in an additional two historically the class then were broken up into two classes and an additional teacher
008was hired um so you have to make sure that if you are bringing school choice students in that it's going to pay for the additional Staffing the other piece is is is that when students apply for school choice um you don't get to pick and choose the students it's it is based essentially on first come first serve and what you don't know is whether or not that student is coming into the district with needs okay um so you could have a student with a district gets $5,000 and you know in a year or two we may have to place the student out of District um and that is going to cost uh far more than the $5,000 that the district is taking in but once it's school choice um they're they're part of the North
009Middle sex community at that point okay thank you Randy uh just a little known fact that I just learned this year um just so everyone knows as we get 5,000 per student if that student has an IEP um all of that information does get reported back to um deese and there is an Adder for if they have do have needs and they are covered just like any other student for out of District uh placements um so the extra money we get for that does come in which is why I asked for uh an analysis uh to see whether it truly is covering our costs um and whether it's worthwhile for the district we should have enough information um from the years that we can do that analysis now and unless I'm wrong Nancy I could
010correct me on this um if the student does come with needs is that circuit breaker money that we would be awarded uh we actually do have a sped increment um submission that we would submit for the students um like out of District costs or um other you know things that are related to their IEP so we can request uh through the school choice process that those to be reimbursed and what about in District programming I think that's a little more difficult um again that usually it's you know I think I think you don't capture all those costs when you're doing that but everything that you're able to capture um you can submit for reimbursement on them so I think the issue is whether you you tip over the the um number of students in a
011classroom to that's a biger issue right and and then that student stays with the district all the way through Middle School to potentially High School right um so I think it may not happen the classroom they're in currently it's possible it happens when they get to say seventh grade or something like that where the the number of students hit the threshold and require some additional teaching right any more questions from the committee all right and I see we do have one hand raised from the audience um mie I'm looking for you you're all set I I allowed them oh you got it okay thank you all right Kathy just state your name and your um can you hear me address please yes okay uh Kathy bores Ericson Road Ashby um I have two questions first
012is if we prohibit students um opting to come into the district does that then also um mean that we can't that our students can't opt out to go to other schools no it's not a reciprocal thing no every district has it has the ability to opt in or out of school choice as a public school okay okay so our students could still go elsewhere yes okay um secondly um how would this impact how we use the school choice revolving fund we would not have money coming in other than the students that are currently in school choice right currently would potentially have to use some of that money um and spend it out if we had students leaving correct Nancy do you want to explain how it works when a student choices out how it's funded
013uh we don't the school choice revolving fund is separate from what we're charged for our students that are choicing out of District so they're not in one bucket if that makes sense we actually get an assessment for those students which is in the budget so right down towards the very end of the budget school choice assessment okay all right and the revolving the money is coming in going to a revolving fund the school school committee can uh use those funds for you Ed education purposes for the school district related yeah okay thank you sure um I have an em that has raised the hor they should be all set okay thank you hi can you can you hear me y just state your name and your address please hi my name's Aon m 168 Warren
014Road in towns and um is there a cap to how many students like does the does the town have any control over how many students can opt out you know when they're if they're applying for a school choice which with the condition of the district I'm guessing is going to be a bigger concern at this point no we don't have any control over students opting out for school choice okay so if a large amount opted out would that still be covered by the budget line item for the kids that are going to be leaving Nancy do you want to take that you want um oh during the year if students if more students opt out than we're anticipating um or than they were projecting right now actually that's part of the um the assessment um
015that those numbers can change they can be adjusted and it's usually based on the final actual enrollments in those schools but the gating item for people opting to attend another school would be that there has to be room and they have to have an um school choice um hearing and allow school choice students to come in does that Mak sense it does yeah and I know like swallow Union has a pretty high application rate already um but other towns I is it correct that a town employee has um has some Advantage when they go into another town so if say we had a somebody who didn't live in town here in Townsend and it was a town employees child did they get any preference coming into North Middle sex I are you are you speaking
016say of a teacher a teacher a firefighter a police officer or something like that so um teachers we have in the past allowed students to come in if there is room um again we're not putting ourselves in a situation where um where we're going to um have to hire another teacher or additional staff but if there is room we have allowed for it in the past just because um the teaching profession has become so competitive and teachers are so hard to find that we do try to make it um possible for them again if there is space the problem with that is is that if we do not take if we do not vote school choice in that year the district does not receive the $5,000 okay okay thank you appreciate it you're welcome thank
017you anyone else from the audience is it over what I have what he should be El okay thank you all right Pat just say your name and your address please not unmuted yet okay there I go my question is pretty basic once they opt out to go to Community Choice meaning to others can they come back in the middle of the school year and then we have to put more money out or do we still have to fulfill that obligation to the other school district and still let them back are they also allowed to stay come back the following year also so so what you might have is you might have an individual that might have taken school choice to another location and then they didn't like to commute so they stayed back they came
018back but then we've already made an obligation to that of the school district and how do we handle those funds because it's going to be this is going to be a flip-flop for a while until people get that under control then the last thing is are they allowed to um do they have to stay in it the whole all the way up to the 12th grade once they make that school choice that's it for me so Nancy I'm going to need help with with just a part of this question I believe yeah uh school choice students can come back at any point um the issue is that after October 1st the district is not that student is not counted when it comes to um the per pupil cost so we don't get any credit for
019that student returning um so Nancy I'm not sure what happens to the 5K yep yep so what happens is in April uh we sh up the numbers essentially we report to this um desie how many students are choicing into our district when they started choicing in by date and when they've left by date so that somebody could come in for the beginning of the year and then leave or come back that's that's fine and they don't have to stay through um a certain grade or 12th grade so there is a Shoring up process and then those numbers are adjusted at the end of the year does that answer your question questions p uh yes thank you thank you and there is [Music] another Amy should be okay to talk all right Amy just state your
020name and your address please it's Amy kader 172 Pierce Road um question if you have a a student who's not yet registered in North Middle sex and you choose to have or you applied to school choice them out of District does the town still pay the 5,000 towards that other District even though they're not in the like registered yet um if they're not registered yet I I I don't believe so uh because they'd have to accept the student through school choice I mean registered at North Middle sex so they registered it go ahead go ahead yeah so when you re when the child registers in another District they would report that student um and if there were a SLE Choice student they would report it um and then like I said in April if that
021student came back we we would report it so it just depends on where the student is any given day up through April basically that um would adjust those school choice funds coming in or going out okay thank you thank you Amy um anyone else all right I see no one else else I will take a motion to close our meet our hearing our public hearing on school choice some moov second and Randy is a second Randy yes June mcneel yes will hackin yes William Berg yes Patrick MC Phillips yes Tom Casey yes Lisa Bloom yes and Jill is having difficulty I believe we're trying to get her back on hold on I'll see if I can see her I didn't I can't see her um Pat MC can I ask you to drop and join
022back in because I think I have you promoted as a panelist I I can change it can you change it okay thank you Robin all right now we are moving on to the public hearing for the FY 26 proposed budget do I have a motion to open the public hearing for the FY 2526 proposed budget so moved will Hackler second second and second by June mcnam right um I will allow superintendent Morgan oh sorry need to take a roll call sorry Randy I'm sorry Lisa I I was doing that's okay I have to take roll call I have to take roll call so we'll open Tak I'm sorry I didn't hear the the motion are you taking a vote on to to opt out of school choice are you closing we closed it you closed
023but now what this motion are you voting on the school choice to opt out that's usually what we've done in the past you have the vote um to opt out of um the district opt out of participation in the school choice program and not in role in school choice students for the 25 26 school year due to budget restraints and space ability availability as usually care I that we opt out of school choice for the 2025 202 school year second thank you okay thank you so that was William Hackler and Patrick MC Phillips so this is to opt out I jumped forward on my sheet sorry everyone teamwork all right thank you this is to opt out of the school choice for 2025 2026 school choice Randy Rous yes June mcneel yes will Hackler yes
024William bird yes Tom Casey yes Lisa Bloom yes and myself yes is someone missing Just J all right now I have to go back to the motion that we had to open open the public hearing open the public hearing which I a motion on the floor that was will andil all right roll call Randy Rous yes June mcneel yes will Hackler yes William Berg yes Tom Casey yes Lisa Bloom yes Patrick MC Phillips yes and myself yes so now we are open to the public hearing on the proposed budget I am going to hand control over to Brad and Nancy thank you just waiting for the U slides to pop up okay thank you I am going to read through the slides because I know we have SE people that may just be listening via
025phone or on their computer so I will just read through them just to clarify um so that if you're not watching you are able to see them but with regard to FY 26 as with every year it's a superintendent's job to advance our mission with a budget that provides the people programs and appropriate facilities supports energize instruction and engage learning pushes innovation in all aspects of the school experience and remains aligned with our core values the timeline for this budget was that we began meeting with Town Administration in August and we had follow-up meetings in October November and December we requested budgets from our departments um by November 15 the governor's budget proposal was released with mlc the minimum local contribution and the foundation enrollment on January 22nd public hearing is tonight uh school committee
026budget adoption I believe has been scheduled for February 26th so in a few weeks and then finally the potential for special Town meetings on March 10th potential budget adjustments with regular and special education Transportation with the potential of buildings closing all Transportation needs are being reviewed FY 26 is in year two of the renewal contract for transportation services unemployment cost increases uh those are pending final reductions that may be needed retire health insurance through the GIC assessment is available and came in much higher than anticipated uh staffing needs the district has some positions that we have been unable to hire for they've been filled with more expensive contracted Services there are a number of positions that may be hired or contracted in addition the number of students in each grades and the consolidation of Ashby
027and Townson grades May Impact Staffing enrollments our actual numbers are fluid uh the projected K enrollment we never really know for sure until the first uh first couple weeks of school that's a moving Target homeschool returns um home we did have several students returned from homeschooling this year um and then we have movein uh over the course of this year and over the summer and uh Department of Children and Family placements in the district as well which could increase our numbers special education tuition uh the increase in the number of referrals for evaluations and eligibility this is something that has um gone up over the course year over the past year it's been uh particularly at the lower levels it has gone up for students impacted by the interrupted and incomplete learning due to the
028pandemic that is something that all school districts are still dealing with in out of District tuition rates for FY 26 are not available yet but as you may have heard last year those did increase by 14% our property and Workers Compensation Insurance are estimated to increase by 10% our Elementary School enrollment levels especially the kindergarten again that's not something that we are um fully aware of until the end of the summer and the legislature makes Revenue changes uh for instance increases in transportation reimbursement Chapter 70 or other funding ongoing Staffing drivers that impact the budget new students federal and state mandates the influx of prek students who are special education eligible the increase in special in our special education population out of District placement transportation and social emotional student needs and multilingual needs are have
029basically um had the district responding by hiring additional counseling staff to support our students hiring English language teachers uh which is a Desi mandate those are the multilanguage teachers that we have in the district hiring additional special education a teachers power professionals Behavior techs and service providers to support our students and maintain compliance with individualized education plans or IEPs the result is an increase in mandated staff which ultimately means that if the district does have to make Cuts we are making those cuts uh to general education content teachers as opposed to um other areas cutting in special ed is not something that we can do cutting in multilingual is not something that we can do per state and federal mandates if you look at our per pupil costs we are still um below the state
030average by just over $1,500 per student uh you look at some of the comparable districts um that North Middle sex has been compared to in the past and that is how we measure up with many of those districts now State averages again just over 21,000 per student initially the budget we were looking at to provide level services so not level funded I just want to be clear on that our level service budget initially was at 5.58% or a $1.6 million increase we have reduced that to 3.16 so we have made about $1.6 million in reductions um it's an increase in over $2 million for FY 26 and it results in a reduction of 10.36 Staff members over FY 26 which means a total of 44.6 full-time equivalencies in the FY 26 general fund budget the
031reduction of one building is also included in this budget Nancy do you want to take this one yeah am I am I on mute pH no you're good okay great uh so are the as Brad mentioned the 3.16 budget increases in these following areas um and on the left are increases to the budget and on the right or decreases that have happened uh for the projected FY 26 budget uh the vast uh majority of the increases relate to either outof District tuitions or salaries and benefits so 2.77 of a 3.16 increase our salary out of District tuitions are 1.75 uh transportations going up Point uh uh is 88% of the 316 suppli substitutes Athletics classroom changes other lines are increasing 1.16 our middle sex retirement assessment is increasing uh .16 and on the right hand
032side um things that have been reduced from fy2 we reduced Capital funds and our stabilization transfer so we reduced that as. 29 we reduceed curriculum and Technology lines3 we with the building closure um being presented facilities and utilities reductions of 36 um an additional $400,000 due to the building consolidation 61 our debt Services Lower um at minus .1 or 83 and our Charter and choice assessments are lower also at negative .17 thanks Nancy so in looking at the reductions how do we get from a 5.58% level service budget to 3.16 and I do just want to be clear that these numbers have been rounded um so just to make it easier to read um so in some cases it may be a little more a little less and the total reductions made it's listed at
0331.6 but it's really 1.5 in change okay so we are just using round numbers here uh so generally speaking um we would be reducing our Capital repair fund by $94,000 Capital repair would go into any type of upgrades that the building may need any of the buildings may need so we'd be cutting that by 94,000 reducing uh technology and curriculum lines that's $160,000 um eliminating our transfer to Capital stabilization again our ability to maintain buildings by by um the $250,000 that we always Target to put in we'd be taking that out Al together Closing one building um would result in a $4 to $600,000 savings that's dependent on what building um ends up being closed as part of this um budget proposal in addition that closing of building would lead to staff consolidation again depending
034upon if it's a close to $400,000 building or $600,000 building that would determine um Staffing that we would need to reduce whether it be400 or $600,000 so if we close a building that's $400,000 we would have to cut staff by $600,000 through consolidation vice versa if we close a building at $600,000 we would have to cut staff by $400,000 um we we have also seen um also a savings there in um in homeless um retiree Insurance Debt Service savings and choice and Char of school assessment so in total this brings US savings to $1.6 million again this is no longer a level service budget and the impact is that it would reduce and eliminate funding required to support our lengthy lists of capital needs making our ability to stay current with technology more challenging and
035the loss of important supplemental curriculum and instruction and assessment programming so they are all cuts that the district would feel um and when you're looking at things such as class size it wouldn't necessarily have a large impact on class size at this point it would lead to more Equitable class sizes across the district through the closure of a building but in some cases we already have some high class sizes I just want to put that out there the impact of cuts to reduce again as I as I already went over the total reduction of 2.19 million do would provide the towns with a 3% excuse me I'm sorry I I jumped ahead over the summer uh the towns had reached out and requested that we um that they not receive assessments north of 3% so
036a 3% increase in order to make that happen we would actually have to have um a negative increase over this year's current budget um to so to get us to zero um or to get us to 3% Town assessment option one would be to make budget reductions which would be 27 additional staff members reducing a second building or or reducing a second building in 23 staff so it would be 27 staff or closing a second building in 23 staff the second option would be the hope that we get increased funding from the state increased funding from the town or increased funding from the taxpayers through a prop two and a half override so that is a situation that we are in in order to get to zero and um a budget that would satisfy what
037the towns had asked us for initially back in back in the summer or late spring we would be looking at making significant cuts um and quite frankly our our class sizes without option two if we we did have to follow through with option one our class sizes would go significantly um would become significantly high would be well north of 30 per class in K to8 and we would likely see as we'll explain later some additional consequences of having to make those types of cuts but I will get into that a little later in the presentation Staffing changes for FY 2026 um we have had to add therapeutic and medical staff um speech and language Pathologists 1.6 staff members power professional staff 1.31 and again uh this would be for FY 26 not this current year
038and then reductions would be the potential of and this is closing a building uh quite honestly uh it would be a building that would be in the $600,000 range having to reduce um seven uh teaching positions um 1.37 um other teach teaching positions of specialist adjustments and then 4.7 uh custodial or um other positions in the district as well as a loss of 02 FTE um nurses in the district so it would be a loss of 10.36 positions and that is again if a building of $600,000 is closed if it's flipped to a um a building that's not as much the reduction would be higher fair to say Nancy yeah um any questions at this point am I am I being clear is everyone okay we can go on to historical enrollment projections Nancy go
039ahead so this this uh this chart um certainly you can just take a visual look from 2016 to 2026 what the district the top line is the district total enrollment changes and the orange top line is pe's enrollment the green is Townsen and the blue is Ashby down on the bottom the actual enrollment for 2026 uh decreased by 104 students um that is uh a reduction of 0.11% in the district for Ashby a 0 44% increase for peil and a 33% decrease for Townsend um you can certainly see see the the over overall percentages uh this leaves Ashby at a 133% of the district um pil 48.6 eight% and Town's in at 38.3 to for FY 26 calculations uh we're sharing um each year we do a report uh we send our October numbers to
040NASDAQ which is a organization that can run a his future and um different scenarios on our enrollment and this is just the chart that they provided us after giving them our enrollments this year this past October uh it goes from 2025 the fiscal year 25 all the way to fiscal year 35 is their projection so we can see that it's fairly flat um it has uh the the actual reports are available on the District budget website and they break out by town the enrollments and um it's kind of interesting to look at it that way if anyone has time wants to dig into that data so the budget um has a number of sources of revenue uh the first one that we look at is the state aid which is has three three areas that
041we um receive from the state Chapter 70 and chapter 71 which is our transportation reimbursement and our Charter reimbursement Charter School reimbursement um this year the governor's proposal has a $75 per student um increase for Chapter 70 so that's a 1.06% increase over fy2 um the chapter 71 Transportation get sometimes we see changes in that depending on um what the legislature does uh that could change um but this is the proposed number that's in the budget right now and our um we had a year where we were in we had no increase in our transportation costs because it was our fifth year of the contract we had a z% so it is based on the cost of the transportation contract as we've spent it the prior year so that's partly why that is going down
042and then the between the charter and the transportation um the state aid section of the the revenue is going up 0.48% or less than 1% on the bottom half of the chart the district Revenue we we use typically some end D to help uh offset the budget and this and last year we ended up voting the entire end of 2,674 which is right um um in the green column um in the blue column 1,872 226 is what we were certified for f for the result of our FY 24 activity and that's what's available to use for the FY 26 budget so we see a reduction of $800,000 from end just due to the fact that that changed our Medicaid um we're increasing slightly these are reimbursements we get for submission of services for students we're
043anticipating utilizing 450,000 in school choice and increas and we increased our investment income as well but overall the revenue is down 75484 the last component for the revenue sources are are what what are assessed to the member towns that's broken up into different areas um the state um allocates something called a minimum contribution minimum local contribution which is based on a number of factors and I can um I have another slide for that a little bit later but essentially they they give us those numbers as part of the governor's proposal um and there's an above minimum contribution which is the portion of our District budget that is over the contribution minimum contribution and resulting in the total operating assessment this operating assessment gets um combined with our usually usually the way it's looked at from
044the towns is it gets combined with the transportation assessment so I've just um if you take a look at Transportation it's going up significantly and it's gone from um up almost 20% 19.15 and that's partly due to um increases in cost in the contracts for the transportation but also due to ridership especially on the special education side and we're continuing to look at that because um those do those those can change over time but but at this moment this is a our safe um number and then we obviously subtract from our transportation costs the portion that the state gives us up that we mentioned in the very first um Revenue slide um so combined with the transportation and that operating calculation and it does get a little complicated but the total local Revenue is um
045going up is is an increase for the member towns of an average of 9.13 and those um differences in enrollment and differences in minimum local contribution are why those why that's not even between the two the three towns the 9.13 just showing that here um and I think we already covered this on the prior slides but um to get to where we the towns would have would prefer to have a a 3.0 assessment 3% assessment would be 2.19 million um or increased revenues um so in the I don't know if how much detail I need to go in here but the foundation budget that the state provides um has been changed over time um through the student Opportunity Act They do change um like the uh they look at at our where we are located
046for wages sometimes wages could be higher in certain areas of the state they apply an inflation percentage to the overall budget so that they accounting for the inflation it's 1.93% for FY 26 there's a number of there's a number of assumptions and calculations that are adders to our number and those are the areas where the student Opportunity Act has um has added so for instance special education students is 3.97% um or for our number is 118 students but in actuality our number of students that are in special education services 686 so you can see that that's making progress towards um assisting with those costs but not fully covering obviously um our out of District students um in the calculation for the foundation budget is at a 1% calculation of our of students or 30 students
047for North Middle sex and our out of districts are currently approximately 74 um in addition to this the um Foundation budget again the foundation budget sort of like the minimum um threshold of spending for Stu for schools um we're we are obviously above that with most districts in the state are above that so it it becomes um sort of part portion of the calculation not the entire calculation um other things that contribute to um the Chapter 70 calculation is the local contribution and they look at a Town's property values um the income in the of the residents um and a municipal growth factor so Municipal growth factors are uh essentially the some of the local receipt changes so if a town has a lot of cars purchased that might impact their Municipal growth factor and
048that's set by um Department of local services uh I mentioned earlier we were using excess and deficiency or end this is this is the essentially like free cash for our school district and this is a historical chart of what we've been certified for end and how much has been used for the subsequent Year's budget and you'll see the the last couple years we've been using 100% of the excess and deficiency to offset the budget um I did include a slide that shows what we're projecting for 2026 enrollment based on buildings and uh this particular budget proposal is is assum assuming a closure of one building which I we've represented with balding here um and that uh kindergarten grade and grade one would be at Ash Elementary for 205 students varnam Brook would be K through
049four as they are now 559 author Brook would be 5 through 8 448 Nissa tiit um 5 through 8 at um 518 and the high school 646 um Squan cook would be Ashby towns in um grades 2 through four plus prek so 452 um and then I'm just listing out of districts and special placements Brad I don't know if you want to weigh in at all on this slide or keep going I'm good right now thank you so some of the challenges um is looking at we we try to look at the uh impact of class size um and right now until we're sure where everything's going to land it's hard to predict the class sizes at the elementary level um but the Middle School um these are average class sizes for Hawthorne Brook at
050the top um grade five a 19.33% two grade 7 2.17 and grade 8 20.5 High School enrollments we do usually look at the students in grade eight and then adjust because um every year a certain percentage of students um leave uh the district maybe they go to uh vocational school or uh charter school or or something so we do Inc we have Incorporated that possibility in these numbers but the projected for next year for 20126 is 646 so overall the budget summary we're we would be increasing from FY 25 to FY 26 3.16% or 68 mil 176 423 um reduction of 10.36 FTE over fy2 and then fy2 appropriation categories the bulk of the cost of the district are instructional support which is Teachers um anyone working instruction um in addition to that if you
051add the 44% for instructional support you'll see Insurance retirement at 18% and uh between the two you're you're well over 60% of the budget is is Staffing related we have 8% pupil Services pupil services are um transportation and nursing and um things associated with that we have operations and maintenance at 7% Debt Service at 5% are out of District placements and and the state assessments 15% uh we can see the reduction from the stabilization fund going that it's just under it's under 1% for other post-employment trust fund transfer and then administration at 3% thanks Nancy uh so just in closing the FY 2026 spending proposal for North middle sex represents our best e effort to continue and mind you it is with reductions a strong educational agenda and a challenging fiscal environment continued examination of
052our priorities and beliefs and at a time where we're conduct where where we are contending with costs of serving our students and families at a level that North middlex Regional School District demands of its public school system and I talked earlier about the potential impact of having to make reductions beyond what we've presented tonight we would be looking at large class sizes in K to8 making instruction and management extremely challenging with both the number and diversity of Learners the loss of experienced staff who during a national educator shortage will move to districts that do not face the challenges of a small Regional District which will impact our ability to fill those vacant positions an increase in fees for extracurriculars at the middle and high school level continued loss of students who take advantage of better
053opportunities elsewhere the loss of key curriculum instruction and assessment programming which will impact student Equitable access to essential highquality instructional materials resources and supports the inability to keep up with our lengthy list of capital and Technology needs in multiple building closures could handcuff the district if there is residential growth that does not line up with the nesda projections and again this is what could happen if we have to cut beyond the 3.15 so it it is not um certainly not a a good story or a good outlook and we can go to the last slide and it's on a positive note I can say that as superintendent I am very proud of the committed and energetic staff we have here in NM our building and grounds office staff power professionals counselors teachers nurses and our
054building and central office of Administration I'm proud to be part of such a fantastic group of individuals it's truly the best and most dedicated group I've ever been a part of it is this group that give our most important assets our students the Knowledge and Skills to be successful both in and outside of our school walls what is clear from both our school committee and Community is that everyone everyone on this call tonight everyone that's participating in the meeting is passionate and supportive of our schools everyone one wants what's best for our students but as we know there are different paths to achieve our goals what is most important is that we work together to determine the best Avenue forward thank you thank you superintendent Morgan and Nancy hes I am going to ask if
055there are any Town officials on the call that want to join in at a joint meeting would they please raise their hands I'm going to ask the others to lower their hands until we're done with the the the towns is that okay thank you yeah just let me know who you want and I will yep you can um we can promote them all there they all Mary should be all set Andrews should be all set Nelson and the SL board Chambers all right I'm going to ask if any of them have to open their meeting because of who has joined the call Purple does not okay thank you Andrew select board Chambers um the f want to open um we can yeah um this is the towns and finance committee um calling the meeting to
056order at 6:58 p.m um everybody is here in the room I don't see anybody in our team online so uh we'll still do roll call U attendance JN bazik is here Mary Jane Churchville here Carol Hof is present ha's present that is a quum so we are so we don't have any additions or deletions to our agenda and so we're having the The Joint meeting with um North Middle sex uh school committee and the select the towns and select board we are called to [Music] order thank you Mary Did You Have To Call any boards to order um I can't see if any all of my board members are here so I'd leave that to Dave NATO okay Dave all thanks Lisa can you hear me I can hear you I don't know if uh
057Mr Lee or Miss Callen are on if you could tell me they're on then we would have to call it I think we're all at separate locations Jessica K is on okay so we will have to open the meeting so I open the board of selects meeting at 7M with uh at least myself and Miss Callen present all right so we have their boards open and peil is okay all right any questions from the committee members or from the people of the different select boards that have been opened or finance committee from Townson Nelson you have your hand up yes uh we need to call um the towns and select board U meeting to order um Veronica and um Lori are you on the call I I think she has gone to the mrpc meeting
058lri has gone to mrpc uh this is Veronica Cal I'm present but we don't have enough for Quorum then so we don't have okay but then your select board does not have to be called Nelson we are good all right yep we're good thank you thank you Nelson um Andrew uh thank you Lisa I was a little confused by your instructions are you going to call us out to speak individually because the way you said it I thought everybody would start speaking at once well I will call you out individually okay you raise your hand all right but your hand is up Andrew my hand is up so are you ready for comment I you can go ahead and comment you're you're the first hand up I appreciate that go ahead um so first I
059want to say uh thank you to the uh superintendent and his staff uh for this presentation I've been working closely with them for several years and in particular this year and I know it is a incredibly complex uh problem that we're trying to solve together um and uh I don't have any uh any real comments or or questions uh to add to this conversation I just wanted the community to hear that uh at least on behalf of peil um I am I am happy with the effort that the school has put into uh keeping this budget as tight as possible thank you Andrew anyone else or any questions from the school committee Mary D if I'm gonna say that right from D thank you um I'd like to Echo Andrews from peil and I thank
060uh superintendent Morgan for this presentation this evening um Nancy Haynes the business manager and all the school committee um I first off um I know you dove into the numbers and and broke them out between peil towns and in Ashby um the only thing I wasn't clear on I didn't see the number for The Debt Service what that breakdown would be so so I'm just looking for what the true cost would be to Ash because that assessment and the transportation I think it's just missing that last Debt Service that would be assessed to the towns Nan yeah and the de serves um on the we have that all the documents posted in their entirety including the revenue sheet which has The Debt Service we're still waiting for the final um ban uh interest calculations um
061this is our best guess right now but that might change slightly I know I'm sorry I know you had all the assessments broken out I was just curious as to why that wasn't maybe included in the slideshow yeah just Well because most of most of the time they're look the towns are usually looking for the um the not excluded The Debt Service is completely excluded but yeah we can add it and um when we post the slides that's not a problem yeah it posted okay I just wanted you to be aware it might change so yep and the and the budget numbers could change conceivably too until the school committee will adopt their budget not until was it February 26th for yeah because you know as as the towns are facing the same increases and
062whatnot we're trying to iron out our budget as we have to present to our board and then to our people by May the 1 uh satday Satur in May so I appreciate that and again I appreciate all the efforts thank you thank you Mary um Nelson hi good evening I also would like to um you know um mirror what um Andrew and Mary um you know um and thank the uh the school committee for all the work you've done um you know superintendent Morgan as well as NY Haynes for all the hard work that you've done to create this budget so um my hats off to you guys thank you Nelson uh the select board Chambers um this is I'm assuming this is you're asking us um this is Veronica Cal Townson select board um
063my question is given that the budget will not be adopted until February 26 um is the is is it possible that there's any change to the building that's being closed or is it solid that that Spalding is the school that's going to be closed how definite is that is my first question [Music] um nothing is definite on this budget until it is adopted is that the way that I should CIS this Randy you've been on the committee longer than I have been really wow uh yes um basically at this point this is uh the administration is putting forth the budget um that they feel that the school uh the school district needs and um asking basically asking for the support of the school committee um but the school committee has not voted and um I
064would say this year in particular um there are a lot of different different views about what needs to happen and we have not ironed that out yet so nothing is definite until we vote all right because there are other considerations that Townsen has to um consider there are other considerations for Townsen if in fact we have an empty building and so the sooner we know what um what you guys are doing as far as the buildings go the sooner we can start to address things that we might need to con take into consideration in our general government budget given uh what you're doing that is understood Miss Kel as we would all like to come to a consensus and give you a budget and move it forward as quickly as possible any more questions from
065the select board Chambers any I I guess my next question is um has any consideration been given to a budget five years out for example or even one year out um so if we we did vote as I believe all the select boards in the towns did to uh have a special town meeting regarding an override question on March 10th um uh I am hopeful that we are not in the pattern where every year we are asking for an override in order to make the school budgets um so I guess has any consideration been given or any projections been made going out further than you know March 10th or whatever February 26 I'm going to hand this to will Heckler as he is a finance chair well I could probably help you with this great
066thank you uh just from my perspective we do keep a fiveyear projection uh worksheet um a lot of the numbers in there until I have 26 finalized I can't really roll it forward but we do project um we need to look at some of those assumptions um a little further but we do have that document ready to go with uh the review of you know whatever assumptions people would like to look at you know if we get end that's level what do what it might look like if the towns have a 3% for the next five years what is that look like so it's kind of like a what if um fiveyear projection and again that takes uh knowing where where we're going to settle I think first but and we could look at a
067scenario based on this budget also for the finance committee well that would be helpful so you could provide those scenario budgets to us then and that and that won't tell you you know any particular Town whether they're going to be able to afford the the budget in that year just will give us a way to look at the revenue sources and make some asss going forward okay thank you any more questions from the select board Chambers no that got questions I think you get nothing else thank you very much thank you and I'm gonna just put you guys on mute and then Randy you have a question yeah I I had a question for I'm sitting here thinking about um going forward in the question of um will we need an override every year um
068correct me if I'm wrong um but part of the money this year uh that hit that's going to hit the towns is $800,000 that we spent in end that we don't have this year because we had less in our end so um next year that's $800,000 that are not is not going to come right off the top for what we need that's $800,000 of an increase that we actually can have for some of the things in our budget that usually go up and for us things that we can spend for the students without having to increase the town assessment next year so like basically this year um our budget can go up really small amount because we had to add that $800,000 in so that won't carry over does that make any sense it does
069I think part of the issue is trying to figure out where we're going to end this year because that number for next year would be based on where 25 will end and as you think are all aware the numbers are have been challenging this year with special education and out of District placements especially Transportation so they're all running way over uh what we were expecting this year so I'm going to be continuing to watch it uh hoping we can close out at least what we' closed out this year so the million 8 if that that happens but we'll be talking more about it as we go for sure okay but again that's one example of an assumption you're making an assumption that we're going to close out at least what we closed out last year
070carry forward the million 8 then there' be no loss of that revenue or uh excess in deficiency there'll be no loss of that next year so theoretically that would be certainly would be a good thing that's obviously you can see real issue with that when you look at that Revenue page of of um a one-time money um infusion thank you sure any other questions from board members or the joint boards that have joined all right June mcneel uh not a question just a a very quick comment I just wanted to thank Brad and Gary and the admin team for their creative work on the budget and trying to find solutions that are most Equitable for all three towns um it's it's difficult because in our position our goal should always be to be looking at
071what we can do to improve things for the students and due to the budget crisis we're in our goal has been to have essentially the the least of the worst impact on the students it it's a very tough situation when instead of trying to make things better for them we're trying to have make things like the least possible bit worse for them because our only option is to keep taking from the students and it's not fun for anybody on the committee and it's certainly not fun for the admin team either um and it's it's something that we're just going to have to really keep working together and thinking of all students to move forward but my hope is that with the advocacy of the general public that's listening in right now and putting some more
072pressure on the state maybe at one point we won't be in this position um but I just want to thank everybody for doing the best that they can in the position that we're in thank you June I am going oh okay Dave NATO dropped his hand Patrick MC Phillips did you have your hand I dropped my hand as well at this time I don't think the question I was gonna ask is pertinent all right all right is everyone satisfied in the Comm committee right now and we can open it up to the public okay I'm going to move to the public comments and questions we're going to start with the people that had pre-registered I have a Caitlyn Mar Carl maros Caitlyn if you would raise your hand we will allow you to join the
073call Caitlyn go ahead just state your name and your address please hi can you hear me we can hear you okay hi um Kaitlyn Marcos 27 High Street in Peril um I'm speaking to you as a high school graduate of North Middle sex a Community member a taxpayer and my favorite role a second grade teacher at Spalding at NM we pride ourselves by saying we rnm which means that all of our students in Ashby Townson and Peril should receive the same educational experience and opportunities if we go with the option to close balding and move move our K And1 students to Ashby and our two through four students to sanook this poses some inequities within the district my hope is to keep Spalding a k through four school but if we can't my hope is
074that we can move our staff and students to Squan cook and still remain a k through four school one thing about keeping us as a k through four model is that the teachers have opportunities to collaborate and vertical plan across to discuss to discuss curriculum excuse me identify common learning goals and coordinate lesson plans to ensure smooth progression of Concepts at the elementary level each school has an instructional support team we call it isst we tap into the expertise of the teachers from each grade level in order to develop goals and monitor student progress academically and socially the majority of these student students that we bring up um are K one and two students if we aren't in the same building this will impact our ability to communicate and ensure consistency for the next steps
075as many of you know transitions can be very challenging to some of our youngest Learners and can directly impact their social emotional and academic success it's possible Townsen and Ashby students could attend preschool at sanook then go to kindergarten and first grade at Ashby and then go back to Squan cook and attend second third and fourth grade at Squan cook they could transition up to three times before attending middle school students could face a temporary setback as they adjust to new routines expectations and environments the anxiety and stress associated with such changes can lead to a decline in their academic um performance focus and motivation this poses inequity with the model in peil as opposed to the model in Townsen in Ashby peil students will have five years to develop rapport with counselors teachers admin
076and other staff members before transitioning to a new building I urge you to reconsider closing Spalding and taking the time to think through this pivotal decision that directly impacts our youngest Learners I understand that closing Spalding would be a recurring savings each year but have you thought about the onetime cost it will create for the district to move an elementary school to move our playground to make the school that we're moving into Elementary friendly I value class sizes more than anything as a teacher I know the importance of a smaller class size I also value the teachers I work with they are amazing I don't want any Cuts I just don't think splitting up our school and breaking up our school Community is worth the minimal amount of savings thank you thank you Kaitlyn next
077we will have uh Debbie McMasters or McMaster she should be all set awesome thank you just state your name and address Debbie Debbie you're still muted Debbie are you on mute I'll try there you go I done it okay demy McMaster 77 holl Street peppol I was saying dear school committee members and superintendent Morgan I'm a district resident taxpayer mother of two NM grads and a teacher at Spalding I would like now to read a letter to you from the members of Spalding staff as many of you know Spalding was gifted and dedicated to the town in 1932 from Huntley and Roland sping brothers who built the school as a tribute to their parents a parade Adorn the road in celebration is a school doors open with anticipation hope for all the students who walked
078through that day and ever since over the years many Renovations have occurred always keeping in mind the importance of preserving ing the historic features of the school there's even a small meeting room as you enter with the original doors and a vintage Pine chalkboard hanging on the wall from one of the very first classrooms Spalding is more than a building it is part of the History part of towns and's history but aside from the very personal connection we all have to Spalding we feel it's vital to keep it open as a K4 school for many educational and logistic reasons a K4 configuration at Spalding provides many benefits that have been found to be an important part in creating a sense of belonging engagement and Care within our school spalon is an anchor in the town
079and has been a driving force for creating a strong family school and Community Partnership the closer a student lives to their school the more access parents have to the resources at that school and the more involved they become we are fortunate Spalding to have such a high level of parent involvement this has allowed parents to become more engaged in their child's education it allows them to stay connected to one building for a longer period of time it's difficult for parents with children in multiple schools to attend conferences performances PTO meetings and volunteer activities having siblings in the same grade range attending the same school is so crucial it allows for easier transportation for children it also Fosters social emotional support especially for our little ones it provides a sense of security and predictability kindergarten is
080a giant transition and often children will experience some separation anxiety from their family having an older sibling in the same building offers comfort and encouragement during those challenging situations this year we had a little one having a very hard time the first month of school missing his family quite a bit it was tough for him but we arranged for him to be able to see his sister in second grade for a few minutes every day it made a big difference and gave him confidence to get through the rest of the day Spalding truly has a feeling of family where older students serve as role models for the younger ones all our younger students in kindergarten and gry one are paired with learning buddies from the upper grades creating a positive powerful experience for all students
081staying in one school from kindergarten through fourth grade allows students to build stronger relationships with teachers counselors support staff who better understand their needs and can provide a more consistent and supportive environment finally if keeping Spalding opt open is not an option we really plead with the committee that you reconsider the option that would allow the grades K through foreign towns in to relocate to San cook Al together as a community school this would keep equity and consistency in the district with a K4 School in all our three member towns peil Ashby and town zoo thank you very much thank you Debbie all right next we have Roberta Flashman Roberta if you can raise your hands I do not June do you know Roberta it say she's from Ash uh yes I Juno Roberta um
082I don't see her on the list okay maybe Circle back okay we'll come back and see if she joins again Pat MC that should be to talk all right so I just State your state your name and your address please hey we're in this again this year and we're talking about closing whether it's balding or whether it's um HB Elementary or whether it's another school in the district what is the guarantee you're not going to do it next year to us also I mean you're asking for us to sacrifice this year down to two grades what are you going to give us for a guarantee there is not a guaranteed path we don't know where this budget lands this year we certainly will not know where next year's budget or budgets will land but there's
083got to be a percentage because you're we're always on the block with you guys a percentage there's got to be something that you got to say because every year you're putting us on the Block and you're causing these reaction by three towns and so you got to figure out something that's going to stop this yes and a lot of it would help if the state would fix the funding formul so okay all right I just had to ask for at least a commitment and when that's that's all I wanted thank you okay thank you Pat the next person on our list is krie batter BSB Carrie if you would please raise your hand all right go ahead Carrie please state your name and your address hi this is Carrie Battersby I live at 391 Frost
084Road Ashby thank you for letting me speak I just wanted to touch on how grateful I was to hear that there were new proposals put out there by Brad thank you rad Morgan um that would keep ashb Elementary open even if it's not K through 4 I mean obviously I would like things to stay the same but I obviously understand that we are in a financial crisis um with that being said I also want to touch on the fact that by keep by having those proposals put out there it made me breathe a little bit of a sigh of relief because as you all know Ashby is the only school we have in our town closing that school would devastate this community um it is the Hub of our community um a lot of parents
085volunteer as you know I'm sure a lot of parents volunteer in both in all three towns um but it would ruin property values families would not move here and I understand that we are a small community especially compared to Townson in peil and I understand that but I was really grateful to hear that we could possibly keep that school open um I all I have two kids I have one in Hawthorne Brook sixth grade I have another that is in first grade at Ashby Elementary I like the fact of keeping Townsen and ashb together at an earlier age as it was a rough transition for my daughter going from K through for Ashby into Hawthorn Brook with towns and kids I'm sure you know that that age group is can be a little rough and
086you know combining those two towns can be a little rough it was a little bit easier for my daughter because we do have towns in Ashby sports but not every kid plays sports or does any of that kind of extracurricular activity so I liked the fact that there would be some cohesion between townzen and Ashby as we are already kind of intertwined with other things as well like towns and Sport towns and Ashby Sports so with that being said I really just wanted to say how grateful I am and appreciative of all the hard work that you guys are all putting into this um and that is my piece thank you very much thank you Patrick do you have a question sorry that was for um the last Pat that was on just to say
087that until the state fixes their funding formula for Regional Schools until we do a better job inhouse with um all of our costs and transportation especially this this is going to be an issue every year we said this last year that was going to be worse and it's going to be worse next year unless something changes so regardless of what happens this is going to happen again next year without a major change all right on to our next Community member it is Selina alone okay you're adding them right Robin yes yep uh she should be also at to top just state your name and address please I assume it's Vincent Aon or Aon are you on mute no they're not we can't hear you are you able to message oh there we go there you
088go now we can hear you all right sorry about that had to get up the a hi my name is Vincent Aron um that was my wife's name Kay Lana Aron that you called she's here with me we live on 84 Mason Road in West Townsen um I'll try to be as succinct as possible first off I want to say that I 100% agree with everything that Mrs Marco said with uh urging you guys not to consider closing Spalding um and I have a number of reasons first off I understand the need for a balanced budget I understand the need to cut costs but by Closing one of the biggest buildings in the center of town the amount of Revenue this town is going to lose because I guarantee you families will move out and
089families will not move in um you also mentioned in your presentation Brad that um you will reduce cost by emptying the building I don't believe that for a second the building will still need heat it will still need Landscaping it will still need facility repair and upkeep unless you guys plan on boarding it up and allowing it to fall down um which would also cause people to leave this time the other thing I wanted to bring up was that um you know you guys mentioned all the children all the numbers but let's take it away from numbers right we're talking about busing five and sixy old children most lik L over an hour by themselves with nobody but a bus driver um I personally do not feel comfortable with that as well as the fact
090that in the event of an emergency the ability for us to be able to get to our child is so much more you know increased and made more difficult um one of the main reasons we came to this town three years ago was because of the proximity to the schools and the community that surrounded it Spalding school is a part of this community the Memorial Day parades it's in the Commons it's it is a a very visible permanent part of this town um in terms of the students transitioning I feel like having Ashby kids come to Townsen for K through four is a lot less of a of an impact than having our kids go to Ashby for two years then coming back here to a different school for a couple years and then um
091like was mentioned before we're going to be moving kids three times in their first five years of schooling um I don't know if you guys remember as far back as when you were that little but it is a very scary and trying time for these children and now we're adding more unnecessary you know fear and uncertainty um to their day-to- day so with that said I feel like we can't blame this all on the state right I feel like we have a lot to say in this we have a lot to uh a lot of accountability has to be taken not only by the community by this Council um this is this is absurd that we're talking about closing a school like like Spalding like I can't even wrap my head around it at this
092point um so yeah with that said I I I will strongly be one of the families considering leaving this town if Spalding closes because I will not put my children I have a child at sanook and I have a child at Spalding my my child that's at sanook is over the moon excited to be able to go to school with his brother next year they want to be on the bus to get together his brother has paved the way and will be able to help him transition into this new part of his life this new phase of his life um and I'm sorry without that that this there's the the appeal of Townsen as a whole is drastically dropping for me and my family um so with that said I that's that's basically all I
093had to say anything you have to say you said everything I said it all okay that's it from us I do have to correct one thing that you did State the school district does not own Spalding the building would be released back to the town of Townsen and then what would be done with it I didn't see that in your proposal we will close it and then what that would be up to Townsen to decide that would not because it is not a school district building okay well I have a I have a follow-up question the okay the proposal I don't understand we've already closed the scene Center at sanook there's room over there for these children to go and consolidate them in one building which sounds like what is your your goal here is
094to combine and reduce you know costs then I don't understand why that isn't part of the proposal and I didn't see any other proposals for any other schools you did mention that it's not definite it's not final that it is balding but I'm sorry your slide deck in your presentation did not mention any other school and factor that into the budgets I'd like to see what is the cost savings with closing Ashby what's the cost savings with closing Squan cook where are all these numbers as opposed to just let's close Spalding and save some arbitary number of dollars will I'm going to hand this to you so uh just to answer that question we did have a public meeting on it we had did display options on closing multiple buildings I believe it's up correct
095me if I'm wrong Brad but it's on the budget FAQ that's on the site those different options that we had gone over before is that correct I believe it is you we did look at uh the cost of operating uh several buildings okay so then I would I would urge you to come to us as a community with the truth where there is no other school being considered at this point than Spalding correct if you've already assessed the others and you've already looked into all those numbers this is a this proposal is to close Spalding period am I correct or incorrect in that assumption this budget includes closing Spalding this as Randy discussed earlier the school committee still needs to vote on a final number and a final decision that will you know part of
096this discussion will come later part of it will you know come at the end of the month well will may I speak to this as a school Committee Member Lisa you're muted Lisa sorry go ahead Patrick I was saying go ahead okay Vincent so so your question about all the other schools we we did look at that we had we had six options available to us we had a we had a big open meeting where where all the towns came and asked a lot of questions uh we voted option four option four would have closed uh Ashby as well as Spalding uh it would have kept towns and students in Squan cook through K through one and then they would have gone to Haw Brook two through five um since then at the last meeting
097there was a recension vote while all the members weren't present to bring put Ashby back on the table so this does impact Townsen but that just answer your questions we have looked at all these numbers um we did have a vote in place um those are all available online you can take a look at that no I appreciate that but that but the the first person asked the question and the answer was you didn't know that it was still a proposal still to be voted on but I just want an honest I want us all to be honest here right you looked at those schools great you assessed them okay but this meeting this topic is about closing Spalding correct it's not about anything else at this point and I feel like you guys are
098had misled the First Community member that spoke up who asked you point blank if it was going to be Spalding and you danced around the answer so I appreciate that Patrick and will for finally giving us an honest answer and treating us like adults that's definitely appreciated um but I don't understand if you just what you just mentioned Patrick is is to me moving children from K from first grade to second grade across the street as opposed to down to a different town is much less imp impactful than what you guys are proposing right like I don't understand how we wrap our head but that's it I don't want to keep going I am against F and it's a two-parter because I understand why you're fighting for your town the same way I understand why
099Ashby is fighting to keep their school open they don't want to send their young children to Townsen and I understand that busing is a large concern and something that would definitely have to be looked into but there was there was a large open meeting where we did vote to close Spalding um a few months ago so so it is yes currently the building that is being discussed um I believe why Lisa was a little vague earlier is we're still F numbers could change some to State something could happen I highly doubt it but it's not finalized until the vote and we're not there yet so I think that's why there is a just a reprieve of yes it's definitely happening but it's not looking great you mentioned last thing you mentioned that you you guys
100had originally proposed closing Ashby and Spalding and then there was AE where all of the committee members were not present and then ashy was taken off the table is that is that what I heard that that is correct okay so how how is anybody allowed to take a vote without everybody present did you have absentee voting weren there we had a quorum we had a quorum and that is how that works when you have a quorum you can take a vote it was not a generally held practice to make such an important vote with without members present but they it was they had Quorum it was what they did was legal yes just a correct doesn't make it right I'm sorry to cut you off legal is one thing doesn't make it right go ahead
101Vincent um it was not all members were not there what the um statement peil peppol reps representatives were not present we had six of nine three of the peol um Representatives that were elected from perol happened not to be able to make that meeting so there were six members of the full school committee and which is forum and so to have Quorum we needed five members to help hold a school committee meeting understood all I can do is urge this committee to consider all of the impacts not just financially but the impacts to families to children to the community like this is the ripples that are going to come from this are like ugly overwhelming and ugly at this point I understand yep I think we all understand the impacts Vincent and I thank you
102for sharing your comments with the committee thank you thank you moving on we have Sandra Lord Sandra Lord I do not see who her raising her hand I'm going to move on to Kathy has her hand raised and then I'm just going to move down the list Lisa um just we can do these but we don't want to forget about the statements that people submitted yep do we want to read the statements now or do we want to wait until all public comment is done yeah why don't you take why don't you take the public comment people that are here waiting and then we'll read the statements after if that's okay yep that works for me okay all right um Robin yeah can you Kathy exit the exit the people y okay and then let
103Kathy enter yes thank you everyone for your patience Kathy you should be all set okay Kathy just state your name and your address please yeah you got me yep okay uh Kathy Bor Ericson Road Ashby um as a member of the finance committee um I want to make a few points regarding the FY 26 budget uh first and foremost um I want to extend my gratitude to superintendent Morgan and his team for conducting a deeper dive into the budget um and building closure options compared to those that were presented on December 3rd the vote that occurred on December 3rd was presented with no opportunity for the committee to research the details a vote in my opinion never should have been taken and certainly an option should never have been approved by any member the options
104presented on January 16th provided a greater opportunity to best utilize the available funding and have allowed the school committee three weeks to review these options up until today and specifically the K to1 ashb Elementary option recommended by Mr Morgan over the previously approved options I ask the committee and the community to note the inclusion of the K1 option was approved by the finance subcommittee to be presented to this entire school committee by a vote of four to one um I'm not going to get into uh the names um but the fact remains that four of the five members did approve this I now want to take a moment to clarify some statements regarding the repairs needed at ashb elementary and I'll ask June mcneel to jump in if I'm Incorrect and anything but I don't
105believe I am um a lot of these misconceptions are in the public domain um and I must emphasize that AES does not require any major cafeteria repairs and most of the cafeterias in the district requires require repairs of some sort currently mobile Refrigeration units are being utilized which is a common practice in food service and not an indication of any significant issue using equipment from other buildings that will not be needed can be used to decrease the overall expense Additionally the oven at Ashby Elementary um simply needs a new thermostat and that's a standard repair that is not excessively costly or uncommon in early December I took a tour of Ashby Elementary during the visit I was both surprised and impressed by the condition of the school the areas visible to the public were well
106maintained and even the areas behind the scenes were in good condition this firsthand experience reassured me of the school's current state and the Practical measures being taken to maintain it I want you to think about the fact that um someone mentioned earlier about a collaboration between um grades uh would be better and if Ashby and towns and in K and one were together that's an even better collaboration if you look at the students overall um keeping them separate um for the sake of a collaboration within one building to me just I don't know does doesn't it didn't quite seem consistent um and although buildings may change towns and kids will then be together uh K to so I mean it's it is a more consistent way of of keeping the kids together even if you
107change the buildings the other thing you need to consider is that the NBTA housing mandate that's coming through from the state will likely um was likely not taken into account by the nesda study by not doing that um if if you close any school but certainly if you close the only School in a town you're not going to be able to reopen that when the kids when the population starts increasing again once you close a school you don't just re you know give somebody the key and say okay let's go open it back up that's not how it works um also in terms of um other Cuts please do keep in mind that Randy roou has suggested um that other Cuts can be added back in um when funding allows and those would be the
108probably most sensitive and appropriate cuts to try to make so certain programs that can be cut but when finally the state funding eventually gets fixed uh be able to um to add them back in again it's not something that's that goes away forever whereas when you close a building it goes away forever um lastly I don't I don't know how else to say this but school committee members are elected by their town of residents or in the case of our at large members by all three towns the fact remains that those elected are charged with representing the entire District not their town of residence that's only one-third of what they represent there is no Ashby Townsend or peil school committee there is a North middlex school committee and I believe that each of you that
109I'm looking at here on my computer screen should take very seriously the suggestion that you're supposed to be representing the entire District you don't represent just your town it's anything else any other kind of behavior I believe diminishes the ethical impact that you have on the district and it should be discouraged so in conclusion I believe that with the proposed budget and The Prudent measure measures being presented we are well positioned to ensure the efficient use of all our available resources it's important to dispel any misconceptions and focus only on the factual conditions and the Practical solutions that benefit all of our communities communities and students thank you thank you Patrick do you have uh just some follow questions for Kathy um have you in all of your research on ashb Elementary have you have
110you read the um the khabib have it right here the khabib and Associates architects facult facility condition assessment is that part of the college study it's its own it's its own study it's about 66 page it goes in great detail on everything in the building I've looked at I I took my own person in person tour her do you that's yeah all background you have a robin or Patrick I'm gonna stop here for a second okay the Collins report and the khabib study is available online yeah and that's what I that's what I'm going to ask people to look at those were studies that were done the Collins report covered all of our tones and looked at all of our schools right khabib was a report that was done how many years ago Brad or
111Randy do you remember down in 2020 yeah 2020 five years ago five years ago all right so before so that was so that was done June before we started a lot of the repairs in the building committee was assembled correct the Habib study was done before prior to that yeah and it estimated $5 million in repairs that's if you did everything to make it look like a brand new school no yeah yeah Patrick you haven't read the study I'm going to I'm going to stop Kathy we do have can ask I have two follow on questions for Kathy and they are different and relevant important okay um Lisa can I ask a question was I supposed to put my hand on the Bible before I started talking I feel like I'm feel like I'm being
112intimidated no Kathy all right can I ask one follow on question just wait what is your question Kathy I was done okay I was done but I didn't think I was attacked these are I'm using an indoor voice and asking very legitimate questions okay Patrick question is if if we do not close any more schools where does the money come from do you expect there to be an override because I know in the past you're very passionate about no overrides I was passionate about no overrides based upon the original numbers that were put forth I felt that there were some cuts that could happen without closing buildings and without the total override that was originally put forth there's a difference if you were at the Ashby toown meeting when the override did pass you would
113know that I stood up and I said this was an honest effort to decrease and Lisa was there in fact she came up to me afterwards um this was an honest um uh piece of work to decrease the amount decrease the override ask and I encouraged people to vote for it thank you Kathy okay Patrick you're finished as well okay we're moving on to our next citizen member Jen AR Arsen she is our next thank you Jen Jen should be ready to go all right thank you you're on mute Jen hear me yes we can hear okay um first I would like to say uh much like Vincent from Townsend I was disappointed by the recent meeting that was held to undo the vote that was taken back in December when I was one of
114many parents and residents who made sure they had child care to go and sit through a meeting and look at everything that was presented and walked away feeling as though at last after listening to this be ping ponged back and forth for a very long time a plan was at least in place um I know that just because you can doesn't mean that you should I don't think that taking a vote without all of the pepper representatives were being there was the right move I think that it's only fair that every town if you want to be quote unquote NM every town should have a voice in the room and I don't think that vote should be taken or undone without all those voices present uh that being said I would like to know if
115everyone wants to talk about equity and they want to talk about what they want for their town and what's right for them and we're all supposed to respect each other's needs and how different these towns have grown is there any type of process in which we could formally request that the district not renew the current School District agreement and instead conduct Research into k through eight for each Town separately and then possibly keep just a high school regionalization agreement as other towns do and consider the fact that everyone could keep their schools and the way they want things to be in their town and we could all come together for high school and maybe everybody would be better off if we could all just focus our energies and our overrides into the town's schools themselves
116and know where our money is going it seems as though these overrides are becoming a more constant thing um the plan doesn't ever seem to be something anybody can agree on and regardless of what Kathy just said looking at all these members and and you know taking people you know and saying well you're not supporting everybody in the district it seems as though it's because some people want you to only support what their agenda is and that's not fair either and if that is the case maybe it's time to say hey it's been a long time and these towns are vastly different from when this agreement was put into place and I know there are people on my street even that have moved into pril and are questioning what we're getting for our money when
117you're buying a house that's over $900,000 it's really frustrating to feel like a district can't get it together and have a school system where I even want to keep my kid and I don't so I can understand where towns and people would be disappointed feeling as though they're investing in a property and they're looking for the feeling of a town and they're talking about kids being busted all over the place we have a lot of issues that don't seem to be something that are resolved can be resolved or that the state even cares to resolve because they don't have a formula that favors regionalization like this and if that's the case why are we continuing to play into it just because something is always been a certain way doesn't mean that's the way it has
118to stay so maybe it's time everybody say Equity is standing up for your town individually maybe Ashby would thrive on their own maybe you get some funds from the state fix your building bring more people into your town have a little bit more energy focused just solely on your town and then everybody has two high schools to choose from you've got NM and you've got a vocational school and those are two really great options but I don't think towns want to see kids leaving because they feel as though they're lost and I'm telling you cutting buildings I understand the need because numbers don't lie and if we need money we got to get it from somewhere I don't want to see teachers go away teachers are a valuable asset and if you ask me they
119put way more into kids than any building ever and I know as a as a parent who has a child who's on a 529 plan he's not getting as much attention as I would like for him to get and if class sizes get bigger he's just going to be another kid that gets lost in the shuffle and I don't want that for him and I'm doing my very best he's got two applications right now to get into private school and I hate to leave the district because I moved here thinking this is a great neighborhood and everything's going to be great here but you know what I don't want to see class sizes go up so if it comes down to a choice between a building and a teacher I'm going to vote for teachers
120but I do understand the plea for towns wanting to keep their buildings I do understand your concern for your property values I do understand all the things you want for your community but that's everyone standing up separately saying I want for my town I want for my town I want for my town we don't even agree on the overrides why can't we look at separating k through eight and keep your town make your town more vibrant put more into it raise it up have people be proud to be there and let's have we are NM be something we can come together for a high school that we're all on the hook for anyway financially so let's let's stick with that but if it's not working it's time to re-evaluate that's all I have to say
121thank you Jen Randy so I will just simply address uh the question about leaving the district that is not something that is the district's responsibility or that the district will ever spend any money on on looking to separate that is something that a town can look into and there is a provision in the regional agreement for a town to pull out that um that provision typically has uh a town will need to settle up any debt that it owes for buildings that it's not keeping um and then there are other agreements to separate I will tell you that just about every District single districts and Regional uh districts are experiencing um huge budget crisis this is not something that's exclusive to a regional agreement as far as the money that you get from the state
122and the money that you need to put in um so just going on your own uh may not be economical but uh you should feel free to have your town uh have town of peil or a group of citizens take a look into what that would cost Regional agreement Regional School Districts usually together for the economy of scale uh for such things as the central office and um other um shared uh resources between the three towns um but there is a process to leave if you choose but it is not something that the district will be paying for or looking into thank you all right anything else all right moving on Jerry bear is next yes hi can you hear me yes just state your name and your yeah this is Gary bear Wheeler Road
123and Ashby um I think if you take a step back um a lot of us remember the discussion when the high school was proposed to be built and there were graphs shown about declining enrollment a lot of extra buildings and structural costs going up faster than inflation and the prop two and a half so the flags were on the wall decades ago right and somewhere along the line and I don't think it's any one person's fault we've end up in a situation where we're pitting Town against Town um there are some truisms we know this state is not going to give us more money we're going to get less as a regional system so if you do strategic budgets and you've run multi-million dollar things you can see what's coming we know there's Cuts coming
124from the federal level we know based on the presentation in Ashby last year that the negotiated contracts that we're negotiating for salary for busing and everything are going up way faster than the town two and a half prop so We've Ended up in a place where many people that I've talked to in towns in in ashp and Peril have lost confidence in that there's any kind of strategic plan we're just doing Groundhog Day and neighbors are digging in I'm not saying that Closing one or two schools is the right or wrong thing I'm saying strategically when you go to town meeting there is no belief from the people I've talked to that any one-year override is going to do anything but piss in the wind so the problem we have this year is now we've
125got neighbor against neighbor people are talking willfully that some State Rep somewhere is going to convince the state house to do something um we all call BS on that we know the federal is going to cut us like no tomorrow and we know the towns Ashby when I first moved here was at 30 some odd percent of our budget this year we're at 47% we've thrown pretty much everything overboard we can right and I'm not saying this from an Ashby voter I'm saying from a person approaching 40 years here so strategically if you want to get the voters that I've talked to on town there has to be a plan that say realistically here's what we got to do to write the ship and if we do this back to an earlier comment that Nancy
126said we have a three or five year projection this will write the ship because anybody that's been through this know if it's not Squan cook this year it'll be Squan cook next year if it's not AES this year it'll be AES next year and that's why the voters have said noas you know we're done so the problem you have is a political problem because there is no credibility that the current options are going to do anything but plug a hole in a sinking ship so if I go back to First principles that I've had to do when I've cut big budgets you say Okay first principles are we all know that neighborhood schools are good for young kids and bringing kids together at some point in a Central High School makes sense great we all
127know that unfunded mandates should get the attention they deserve unfunded means we don't do it we know when we negotiate contracts that are more than two and a half% the school committee has got to take ownership for cutting so that the overall budgets back in the two and a half% envelope so those are truisms that the voters are looking at and saying if we have a plan that meets those strategic things yeah we don't want to cough up more money but we will but right now I got to tell you I've looked at all the options and again no disrespect for the committee I know you guys have put in a lot of hard work but none of the options say we're going to be back here fighting harder against our neighbor next year that's
128what it's telling us so that's why I'm saying even if you put a plan together you're going to come to town meeting and you're going to get cut down by a buzs saww so until we solve that problem you're not going to solve this your budget problem and a lot of us have talked to people in the three towns in the common sense voter I'm not talking about the people that are give the kids everything or the other people that are saying burn the schools down you you discount those people but in the middle what we have here is not a plan what we have is Groundhog Day and we're all tired of being in Bill Murray so again I appreciate the work but I think strategically you have to take a step back back
129and come with a strategic plan that this budget fits in and say if there are three more schools closing and if we got to lay off 20% of the plan the staff we don't like it but this is the reality so over the next five years here's the Strategic plan here's where it fits in here um you don't have to like it but numbers don't lie so and again thank you for all your hard work but you know this is we're all taking a tough pill right now and I think the way forward is together because as the old saying goes we will all hang separately if the three towns don't figure out how to hang together so again thank you for your work and appreciate you taking my comment thank you Gary all right
130comments from Randy or Patrick which one was up first I'll just be fast Gary can you send me a a a private email through my um school account it's available on the website's PMC Phillips nmrsd.org just send me a private email I'd like to talk to you some more if that's okay sure and most people know how to find me especially the people I owe $ five dollar to thanks I'll I'll reach out to you Randy um first I'd like to say thank you Gary um one I really appreciate your calm demeanor um and how you present everything uh it is a very welcome uh change to some of the stuff uh that I have heard uh so thank you for that one thing I would like to just kind of add in it always
131seems to kind of get lost is um year overy year if you take a look at the last 10 15 years the school commit uh the school district has presented a budget somewhere in the range of an average of 3% we do fairly good at after you know doing manipulations in the cost efficiencies uh some cutting here and there getting our budgets to within 2 and a half to 3% on average over the years the problem is the state go back 15 years and Nancy you can correct me if I'm wrong here if I my memory is wrong to go back 15 years when I first came on to this committee the state actually um was giving us 60% of our budget year over-ear we have gotten less than 1% of an increase in 60%
132of our budget and so the towns end up making up more we could be at 2 and a half% but the towns end up paying more to cover what the state is not for that um we are currently now at 40% of what the state gives us in our budget because of that attrition and what the towns have picked up over the years honestly as far as a year-over-year um you know um increase the towns would be so much better off if we already had the entire budget in their base and all we had to worry about was oh the school budget went up 2 and a half percent the town budgets go up two and a half percent and things would work a lot better but we con constantly are in trying to make
133up for what the state is not giving us eventually we'll get there but uh that is one of the huge problems that we have and I I appreciate your comments and I fully agree with you um but the reality is the state ain't going to make up the money they're just going to cut us deeper right the town is required by law to stay within 2 and a half% if a school is owned by the town like several of my friends live in yeah you all meet and you come together with the selectman it's voted when it's a regional you have this kabuki dance that's like a circular firing squad right so the problem is you have to start from Basics we know the towns have to live in 2 and a half% full stop
134we know we have unfed unfunded man Ates full stop we know a lot of the contracts that were presented last way are way over 2 and a half% right and we know we have more buildings we've known that for a while then we have people and enrollments declining right so given those the hard facts you're got to square that Circle and none of us like it but we just don't want to be back here next year right so if I saw a plan that says if you give me X and over the next four years right this is what's going to happen we don't like it either but we don't predict any of this stuff's going to change right and we know inflation's not under control so all that being said this is going to
135be tough and it's going to be tough for five years the voters appreciate honesty they appreciate a strategic plan even if it's three to five years and we might not like it but we're all living that reality we just want the North Middle sex proposal to have the same thing we all have a budget for what's going to happen the next couple of years we have a budget for this year right so again I appreciate all the work but I think that's politically where we are at Town meetings this year the voters are in no mood to say yeah here's three million two and a half million and oh by the way no guarantees we're back here next year right that's going to go down in flames so I don't have the answers I just
136know what the constraints are and having run you know multi-million dollar budgets um this is the time where those constraints are going to hit us in the side of the head nobody's going to like it I don't think anybody in any of the towns are going to like it but and again thank you very much for all the work you're doing I appreciate it thank you Gary and I may have to reference your your saying about kabuki dance to this budget so and thank you for the conversation thank you all right em you are next em is all set they'll just need to unmute I think it's yeah so it's Aaron Miner Warren Road towns in Massachusetts um a lot of my points Vinnie uh earlier in the call actually brought up um and I
137appreciate it um so I do want to sort of reinforce that um I have significant concerns about our our children personally um going to School in Ashby for us it's not feasible um already our son if he were to take the bus here in Townsend um it would he would not get home until 4:05 p.m. um and there's no bus monitors on the buses um for safety reasons we could not feasibly send our kids even further away um we have one child who's in Spalding and one child who would have been coming into Spalding um or or maybe if we're able to keep Spalding open um for us for personal reasons we we could not send safely send our child to Ashby um for reasons I won't go into here um so I guess sort
138of the big comment that I want to make here is um it's been brought up that we had the public meeting lots of folks somebody else had mentioned you know you have young kids you get child care for your young kids you go the vote happened lots of the the public you know made comments we came out of that meeting thinking that we were going to be closing AES and Spalding and the children were going to be going the youngest children were going to be going to sanook not ideal ideally we would love to keep Spalding open of course but at least that was something that I know for for our family we could wrap our head around and logistically we could make it work again we have multiple kids we're thinking about school pickup
139School drop off volunteering I volunteer usually at least once a month at Spalding um it wouldn't be an option if they were out of town um and certainly if my kids were further apart um and I guess my my big grievance is we had that meeting we left it thinking that we had a certain plan and then I know that you had a quorum I don't agree with the fact that a number of folks from the school board were missing it was not the big public meeting that we had already had and the the script kind of flipped and suddenly it was ashb is staying open Spalding is still closing they're sending the towns and kids out of town again as other people have said is it legal yes do I think it was the
140right thing to do no um and I just want to express that that I do not think it was the right thing to do we have the complete School Board here tonight um and I do hope that that there's some consideration to revote on that um and I think that's why a lot of folks are here tonight um and I know that that myself and I I personally know many other people who sent emails to the school school board over the past few days as we begin to find out about this um because again we left that public meeting thinking that we were on one page and were shocked to find out about this new vote and that then they were talking about sending our kids to a different town at five six years old
141um so again I would just urge you to to consider rev voting on that tonight um consider keeping Spalding open but if nothing else um I certainly want to express um that I strongly object to sending five and sixy olds from Townsend out to Ashby um for kindergarten in first grade thanks thank you all right moving on to Tara Smith all right Tara just can you hear me yes just stay y Tara Smith I live and um the whip Switch Road and Ash and I apologize uh for my voice um I I appreciate all of the information that you've provided and I appreciate um that this has been a much more um I feel like dignified meeting than the what last one I attended um looking at the actual financial statements that you have audited
142and presented on your website I'm seeing every year year-over-year for the last five years um there're being a negative net position of $7 million or up coming up to $7 million so um that's Year over-year we're short $7 million in the North Middle sex District um finan not statement of financial position what difference is $600,000 going to do to that and it's not going to be a lasting change right I'm and I'm I'm from Ashby so I'm thrilled that currently the school that my two boys are going to start going to school to shortly um is still going to be there next year but are you going to ask it the next year for a 1% change in the negative net position you have every year like this is again a Band-Aid right like this
143is not solving the problem that we have here and so my question do actually have a question sorry guys is there some kind of like law that says you have to have a balanced budget in order to go to the next year like is there something that says you like is the state going to instantly not give us funding next year that's what I want to know like we're sitting here and we're going to permanently close a building that clearly those in towns that are you know really passionate about and I feel for for no lasting e you know change is is there something that's stopping us from just moving forward and maybe putting more of our efforts towards getting the state to give us Equitable funding that's my question Patrick you raised your hand
144uh I just wanted to take a second and say that I agree with that statement that this is a bandaid on a very long-term solution and just to answer something that I'm going to bring up later on in the school committee meeting is cutting Transportation costs by not listening to the state and not having seats for for every single student because there's so many empty seats it's it's a waste of money it's something I'm bringing up tonight so I am thinking of ways forward that may irk the state and I know I've discussed it in the past and Brad has said it's it's not an option because the state says no you will have a seat for every student but maybe it's time we just say you know what state we've had enough if you're
145not going to fund it we're not going to do it and that just seems like the least impactful way to kind of fight back it's not impacting special ed services it's not impacting anything of that nature just empty seats it's just logical all right anyone else all right moving on to the select board Chambers so board Chambers from Townsen oh okay yes um Mary Jane Churchville um from Main uh Main Street town and I I was just going to uh question you if there were plans to decentralize but that's already been discussed so you can ignore my presence thank you okay we are going on to Brad Han Brad hi are you able to hear me uh I can't speak up again are you able to hear me yes so my name is Brad Han
146I'm from one Brown Road in Townsen um you know you guys definitely took an ethical hit by reputation by uh you know going ahead and doing an underhanded move by making a vote after we've already voted on something so I applaud that great great job thank you um with that being said I'd like to make a motion that we take it to a revote if possible you can't make a motion as you're not a member of the board okay so I would like you can make a comment you can I'd like to someone from the board to do that I'd also like to thank everybody at Spalding um it's really unfair to them to be honest with you such a great staff um I'll be honest with you I don't know why you guys stick
147around but I'm really thankful you guys have for this long um so so thank you and then the uh last question that I I really have is you know kind of the same thing that everybody else is saying what next but more importantly what's going on with the asbest in Ashby and the reason I asked that is because if you're asking me to send my kid there and he comes down with something as simple as asthma you know just as adamantly as some of the ashb people have talked about going to litigation there I would be just as adamant to do the same so I'd like to understand some of that as well we have a facilities question June um regarding the asbest this um the tunnels were just Abad so the tunnels um in
148the hallway had pipes for plumbing and heating um and one of the the big questions was what can condition were those pipes in and we would not be able to access them if they were not Abad so the town of Ashby did just pay um a few months ago to have all of that abated and so we could get in there and it was actually good news when when we got in there because the pipes were in better condition than um than anyone realized because no one had been down there before so that was that's all set um if you're referring to the aestus and the old Wing the old Wing is sealed off um students haven't been in there for many years now the town of Ashby has expressed interest in repurposing that Wing
149at some point so no decisions have been made by the town as far as whether um they want to take down the wing or repurpose the wing yet at this time but that is not a part of the school that that students are in and Ashby Elementary is one of I believe three schools in the district with known asbest and at no point would students be in the building if it wasn't safe um and Brad Morgan can probably speak to that a little bit more um but I will just say to regarding the last vote um it it's kind of clear who listened to the meeting and who didn't listen to the meeting because what happened is the superintendent brought two new options that were not presented at the December meeting um both options which
150did include keeping Ashby Elementary open he said he recommended that option over the previous option so the committee having a COR removed well rescinded the previous vote another piece of that discussion was the vote did not make sense um TimeWise because the wording of it was to proceed with option four as Plan B if the override didn't pass and the the reason it was pushed to to hurry up and try to decide this vote is the state would have to be informed by March 1st there is no possible way to know by March 1st if an override would pass or not pass so the actual wording of the vote did not even make sense so by resending the vote we did not make any new decisions we just took a step back and said there
151are more options on the table we asked a lot of questions such as as um is the possibility of sanut closing rather than Spalding being explored more um and personally that would be my hope because if we could sell a district building then there would be revenue from that sale um the problem is or as of three weeks ago uh we didn't really know where that money would go from the sale um and there's special legislation required the building is also tied to hawor Brook so there was a lot of information to find out um which we were told we would not have that information for at least three weeks um so there's still a lot of factors at play by resending the vote it was not voting that we would close Spalding it was
152not voting that we would not close Ashby and it was not voting that we would not close Ashby or not close Spalding it wasn't any of those it was taking back that V to put the options back on the table to get further information based on the recommendation from the admin team who has been working tirelessly on the side trying to figure out the feasibility of these options and the added cost of these options so at this point it is not set in stone in any one way or another the finance subcommittee did have a meeting um about a week ago where four of the five members of that voted to proceed with recommending the budget as presented tonight for superintendent Morgan to present um with that is the approximately $600 of U excuse me
153$600,000 from the one school closure fding and 400,000 of a reconfiguration which was the option that the admin team recommended but again the school committee has not yet chosen um and not voted on so Jun with with all that being said why wouldn't we move everybody from Spalding over to Squan cook and then leave Ashby as is as it stands today well say that I actually just sent an email unfortunately it was a little close in time before the meeting because I was trying to get more information about that same thing and um ideally it it it sounds good so and just before you answer that if if we're going to close a school why would we close one that's in pristine condition like Spalding is especially when you're telling me that there's a Wing
154of Ashby that does have asbest and we're all in the same boat with this MB MBTA Community if you think that's not going to drive more families with kids here and we need room for expand expansion you're sadly mistaken and then again we're going to be back in the same boat with piss poor planning okay let me answer your question first of all I don't want to close any building so Le let's start there closing buildings is not a good option we're not in a good situation right now every building in the district could use 5 million in renovations there is not necessarily one that's in much worse conditions than another hon Brook has a great need right now um Ashby we did address any of the safety concerns with the asbest in the hallway
155um under the hallway excuse me where the tunnels were and with the boiler redundancy um but there aren't any other major there's no safety concerns at Ashby at this time and there's as far as the amount of money for the building every single building has a a wish list like that so going back for just a second to your idea before and I'm looking to the side because I was just trying to pull up the email where I said this but I really would like to explore a different option that we haven't talked about um and explore uh let me see additional exploration of sending West Town only to Ashby um K through 4 so let me tell you why because it would help with the class size balancing which is one of the the
156perks of H of the configuration that they were talking about the K through 1 and then 2 through 4 um part of the issue is with Ashby you may end up with classes with six students um based on say maybe two classes of or a class of like say 32 in a Grade that were bro broken up so you might have some really really low classes at Ashby right now or you might have those maxed out classes like 30 say in a class where towns in having you know being able spread it over five um five classes or so per grade can keep a more balanced thing you know 23 what it can be more balanced where we don't have that option in a right now so the potential to to just add some more
157students in there can help balance that um but let me just see uh so with that balance is the staff reduction so that's where that 400,000 comes out of the budget that was presented today because um balancing the class could reduce some staff kind of organically that way without overflowing the casses um and with that option bus times would stay in check we wouldn't have people on the far side like the Shirley end of towns in coming all the way to Ashby we wouldn't have people on the ashram side of Ashby going you know all the way to town in or Worse peil which was what the option was was um voted on in December before um so I really would be interested in the savings of that option as well so it's something that
158we can discuss typically during the hearing that we're in right now that's the opportunity for everybody to give feedback and then for us to kind of the school committee to whittle down what our options really are is based on on discussions in our regular meetings so I believe later tonight we'll be discussing some of the pro and cons and we may not vote on any of that tonight because we're still Gathering more information and we might have more questions for the admin team um June I I appreciate it I just want to say thank you it sounds like there are some more options that we can explore so maybe it was a little bit uh premature to put up on a slide that Bing is going to be the one that's closing like we did
159today so I really appreciate that and that there are some other options um I would really urge you you know as people have talked you know you want to go far you go together you want to uh go fast you go alone uh We've created a lot of great synergies within that that staff over there at Spalding and I think it's imperative to find a way to keep that staff together um so if that's moving them over to another school in Townsen then fantastic and then last thing I'll I'll say is uh you know to Mr Brad Morgan really appreciate everything you do I appreciate all the effort that you put into this and uh good luck my friend thank you I thank you I am going to remind the committee that we do have
160another meeting after this a regular meeting um and so I'm going to remind the public too we do want to hear all of the comments but we do need to consider time all right next on the list is Michael Kelly hi Kelly Kelly five tourist Lane in Townsen first of all I just want to say thank you to everyone I know this is a thankless job and that you've been hearing from all sides of every community and whatever decision you make is not going to be the correct one um in some people's eyes um I did have a question um first of all a comment that I will always stand by my belief that teachers do have to come over buildings and whatever we can do to mitigate as much of the loss of teachers
161and staff as possible is the route that in my opinion has has to be done because we can't teach these kids if we don't have teachers and buildings are great and buildings are wonderful but we need teachers so that is my comment my question is as a towns and resident and I had sent this by email as well under the proposed plan of sending townzen over to Ashby schools that would mean that townzen would assume 75 to 80% of the upkeep and the repairs to Ashby Elementary June just mentioned that all of the buildings could potentially need about $5 million worth of work Talon knows that haor needs work and it stands right now we're responsible for two buildings Spalding and Hawthorne in the new reconfiguration as proposed we would be responsible for 80% of
162Ashby 80% of hathorne and 80% of sanook have the towns and Reps considered the financial implications this would have on the towns and budget because those debt exclusions would massively impact Townsen where we are now would be responsible of taking on the repair of yet another building the lion Shear the vast majority and so I caution the towns and Reps to be very very cautious about how much we're willing to take on in terms of repairs of other buildings and really consider that impact that it will have on towns and's budget thank you thank you um was there a question Kelly sorry um primarily just a a a comment um and whether or not the towns and Reps have really looked into the reports and have an understanding of what town would be assuming if
163we went through with sending towns and Kwan over to Ashby how much of a financial stake they would be putting Townsen into if we are going to be assuming that building are we looking at also now taking on if we're using June's $5 million $4 million unexpectedly of buildering appears for ashb Elementary in addition to 4 million for Hawthorne Brook and 4 million for sanook um I I know that's broad numbers and I'm going to assume hopefully that sanook doesn't need $5 million but again if we are responsible for 80% of now three buildings that will affect the finances of towns in long term so I'm just asking I guess the towns and Reps have you considered that anyone want to answer that from Townson Randy I I am an at large member so I
164am from all three elected from all but I do live in townend and we all do represent every single town uh yes uh that has been taken into consideration um there are a number of different options we can take a look at to do that as I understand it right now um all the buildings are safe to operate all the buildings are aging um all the buildings due to that natural aging will have things that come up that either um should be on a list uh because they could break some things are maintenance are uh keeping uh repaired but uh Parts because of the age of some of these things may need uh to be upgraded because I can't find parts anymore and that is for every single building in the district uh bar the
165high school as far as aging um and not finding components because that was just recently built um so uh given that those repairs are not something that is anything that we have to do right now it's something to be cognizant about because when you get to a certain point having a coordinated project is easier to uh get some of these things completed um but there is nothing on the horizon that absolutely has to be done right now um I know haon Brook is one that the district is uh very much looking forward to I believe that's the next one on our uh radar that needs some major Renovations and that will be shared uh by uh towns in Ashby because those are the uh students that go there um Ashby also is a smaller building
166than uh either Spalding or sanook um and they will be joining and taking on about 25% of those costs um is it one for one hard to say because we never know what's going to be done uh but there is some comparison there as well as Ashby has been paying for haon Brook uh for decades now um and they've uh and any of um roof repair I believe was in 2005 they voted and um paid for that they've also had repairs on their own building in 2012 they did a roof and windows uh project that they paid for uh Townsen paid for Spalding uh it kind of washes out I can certainly take a look into it and we can also take a look at um you know possibly having a fiveyear reprieve that Ashby
167doesn't pay for Squan cook or Spalding wherever their student wind up and towns and doesn't pay for Ashby for the next five years for any capital projects there are ways to work this out I I think it really kind of washes out in the end um with the size of the buildings um but we can certainly take a look at that okay just as a t a towns and taxpayer in my head I was prepared for Hawthorne um everyone in towns and kind of knows it it's due for some upgrades and to now also realize that we could be sitting at town meeting voting for substantial repairs to Hawthorne at the same time as voting for substantial repairs to Ashby is kind of hard as a taxpayer and while I agree that Ashby has been
168paying into Hawthorne they've been attending Hawthorne for four decades so the building has aged as their students have attended so it makes sense whereas we're kind of being picked up in the middle here and now being responsible for repairs that have accumulated over the last 40 years where our kids haven't been attending so I do understand your point where hopefully there's ways of balancing this but as a towns and taxpayer it's it's a little concerning that it also is um just as likely that you're voting on haon Brook and voting on Squan cook for repairs we don't know what's going to end up happening sanana cook um needs has repairs that can be done and has things that are aging and that will need to be done at some point as well um there is
169nothing on Horizon right now we're not doing any studies at Ash um to find out uh costs to go forward with any projects we're not looking at Squan cook at the moment as far as I know for any studies to go forward with any projects and it's a very long process usually because we have to get a feasibility study then we usually try to go to the msba for money um which could take a couple of years and then it comes to a bigger study and then uh votes so there there's nothing that's going to be coming anytime soon well we might not be planning on it but I think we all know these buildings need repair so just because I might not be looking at the roof doesn't mean that the roof that we
170all Ju Just because we're not acknowledging that repairs on paper need to happen I I think it'd be foolish of us not to realize that PS are going to need to happen to to these buildings and for Townsen you know right now we're responsible side of the high school for two buildings and this new plan makes us responsible for the line share of Reb buildings of repair so I just want to make sure the towns and Reps were aware of that and what you're voting on and the financial implications that you're voting on because yes while as a representative you should be thinking of the entire district and all the kids and all of that but the ual reps to also answer to their taxpayers of their specific communities and that's why each Community also
171has reps specific to you know I don't fault June for advocating for Ashby she's a phenomenal rep for Ashby and she is advocating for Ashby and I just want to the towns reps also need to remember that by and large they are elected not not talking about the at large reps but the towns and Reps were elected by the towns in taxpayers to represent their interests that's it thank you uh Patrick I I was just curious about how Randy said it it would be a wash just based on the numbers Ashby's 13% of the the population of of schools so if if Townsen takes over ashp as well the buildings may be a washing cost but that's still an excess cost for Townsen isn't it it's a 2575 split when you're talking about Ashby and
172towns in in the same school over at hoton the the 133% is of the full District we do capital projects per enrollment in the school what uh Kelly was talking about is the enrollment in the schools that towns and and Ashby are occupying or will occupy depending on the um build or the configuration that we vote okay can I interject in here can we take our discussion of between committee members to our meeting and allow the public to vote if everybody on the committee is okay with that fine with me okay thank you Kelly is done um we're moving on to Andrew D yep can you hear me State yep just state your name and your address please of course my name is Andrew der roer I'm in jwi Hill in Ashby um I just
173want to take a few moments just to address a few things that I've heard today um and the best way I can kind of address these is tone deafness um now you know I've heard things about I don't want to send my kids over to Ashby from Townsen because somehow it it's going to add an hour to your commute while negating or missing the entire point that we would be also sending Ashby to Townsend um going upill doesn't make things automatically more time than going downhill it's the same distance either way um when also looking at all this you know we're we're talking about integration you know we are North middlex apparently so you know integration is great in terms of trying to get all the kids together as early as possible between towns and
174and Ashby you know I know peppol is a part of it as well love to have peppol part but to be honest sending Ashby to peppol and I'm sure the parents of peppol are not going to want send their kids the Ashby you know I get that one but trying to integrate everyone early is great for the community and for the students and bring some kids over to Ashby kind of get some awareness of where Ashby is what ashb is about and trying to integrate them early on um you know I've heard a few things as well about you know what's you know worrying about closing one school in Townsen whereas currently Townsen sends all of their kids for all grades in towns and for the whole duration of their schooling whereas Ashby has AES
175and then we send over to towns and from then on and to be honest the way the current state of things are between the grades you don't have a fuss from Ashby but what we're asking for and what what I'm hearing is sending just for two grades to make sure that AES stays alive other things that I've heard today is you know the teachers in Ashby from the school that is being or the the teachers in towns and that the school is currently being proposed to close is somehow you know I'm sure they are great but from what I have heard is negating the fact that you would also be dismissing teachers from Ashby and you know I have a daughter who's currently in first grade and we've had great experiences going through the AES
176system you do not need to worry Townsen for missing teachers in Townsen for Ashby or I'm hoping there will be integration between the two towns when consolidation comes um also going in sorry I made a laundry list here as I was kind of hearing things down and I just jotted things down and I've reorder things time and time again um so you know I've heard a few things about the vote and how things were kind of upended June you did a great job you know summarizing that and you know letting that go through I really do appreciate that um and what I've heard is that that the peol representatives were not there however the decision here even though I I value the peppo's opinion the decision is going to be impacting the Two Towns the
177most will be from Ashby and townsand so that vote is very reflective of the decision between the two towns where this impacts the most and then lastly I just want to make one comment about uh well I guess I have two more comments I I apologize um because I did hear one of comment to about blaming Ashby for not putting uh all the oomph and volunteerism and trying to make our town vibrant and going in I just want to make a note that you have great volunteers here in Ashby you have great Community uh you know we have the bonfire we have you know Weekly concerts much like you know towns and goost and we're not going to say pull your game together towns and because you were talking about closing one school that that's
178not what this is that that was a ridiculous pitting between two towns lastly and I I do say lastly in this case is that the best deal in negotiation or compromise is when both sides of the party are not happy and like I said my daughter's going to first grade I currently go in annually to teach meteorology to the kindergarten class you know so I I'm well aware of what AES is um you know both sides are not happy with this decision I can guarantee you that I don't want to have to send my kid over to the towns in at second grade however this decision here that you guys are eventually going to vote on and make is a great compromise and I I do appli you know Brad I I know you and
179I have had you know comments back and forth on email you know having some discussion you know this this plan this this way that you guys laid it out makes it so no one really wins and you know it's what's needed in order to make a Community Regional District work not one town wins everyone kind of works in the benefit of everyone else trying to integrate everyone in early so I just want to say thank you um and just want to leave it there thank you all right we're moving on to Caitlyn Kaitlyn should be ready to go okay Kaitlyn Kaitlyn okay there whoops we're on to Tyler Tyler good evening how you guys doing good Caitlyn disappeared so it's your turn Tyler Point Blank I want to say we got to show up for
180our kids and with this old override vote that's the first that's the first thing that needs to happen um I understand that's not the popular opinion but um we're talking numbers here and and that's and that's what needs to happen um in terms of Tyler can I ask you a question what town are you from and or what is your address Townson yeah okay I guess when it comes down to um decisions that need to be well the other thing I want to talk about is the three members that didn't show up to the last meeting I'm not sure who they were but like that seems that seems shady I'd like to know who are the three that that didn't show up to the last meeting for the vote it was Tom Casey Patrick MC
181Phillips and Jill twig okay so essentially um you know when we have important meetings like this to discuss um decisions that impact all three towns you know I just think it's it's a priority to show up um anyways um end of the day I just want to know what makes the most sense to the close um Ashby versus because because that's what it seems like it's at it's like it's like Town versus town it's like Ashby versus Townsen and like peppol is not on the Block right now so what is the cost associated with closing towns and and what is the cost associated with closing Ashby Tyler those are um disclosed in the options that were presented earlier in different meetings and those numbers are continuing to be developed as Brad and his team are
182working on them um Randy or Patrick which one would Randy you can go first I just wanted to um just address as far as three members not being able to attend the meeting um life comes up you know we're volunteers um I don't hold anything against anybody who can't make a meeting um and votes were not necessarily on the agenda to be done we were talking about things um so unfortunately things came up and it seemed like an important thing to vote on at that moment to open up the options because the administration needed some direction just like they needed a direction in December on what to start looking at they needed direction from the school committee about whether they can go down the new uh recommendations that they had be due to uh things
183that they found out and more information that they had the vote happened um not with their knowledge that they were going to be missing a vote that said by law committees like these and lots of other committees um have the right to uh conduct their business when there's a quorum present and that is what we did thank you uh Patrick yeah I'm sure just like a lot of other people in here um finances aren't the the greatest thing I mean not only for the school district but for all of us personally as well I picked up a second job so I work most Thursday nights I had to get coverage tonight to be here um if you go look at my track record I've been at a large number of the meetings if not close
184to all um I did check the agenda I called ahead and spoke to Lisa there was nothing there was nothing of that on there um it was brought up through old business which I get it it came up that's on me uh this is a volunteer position it does not pay uh trying my best I've spent well over a couple hundred hours just researching every every budget every every meeting between reading the policy stuff that this is this is a lot and and like everyone in here nobody wants to close schools I I I want to be voting on who gets the next playground upgrade we have no funding there there's no money left um that's what I've walked into for two years in a row now so uh Tyler I'm sorry I wasn't there
185um I had I known that that vote was going to happen I would have taken work off and been there um and that would have made the difference but that that's my answer so you know as a Townsen resident uh in both in both decisions Townsen was voted to be closed um it's just that um you know it's it's uh this is this is just pressing on so many parents and families and trying to figure out what's best for their kids and um to take a vote in the interest of saving the most and and doing the best for our district and then a couple members don't show up and then there's another vote you know what I mean it's just a um it seems like there was Mal intent but I understand life comes
186up and we're all here to talk about it um like I said I think we have to as Citizens like as this region like we we got to show up for our kids we got to vote and and and we go to um we got to fund our school and you guys are tasked um to come up with a a backup plan essentially um it doesn't look good in in either direction but um I just uh I don't know I just I just really hope we can we can figure out something that works for the majority of the students in this district and not necessarily based on geography thank you Tyler all right moving on Craig Hansen I believe that is you coming in next am I correct Craig does it not say my name
187it just says Craig G oh okay so just state your name right H I'm from peil um I'll make this quick just a a few comments so first I I do want to thank superintendent Morgan Miss Hayes the rest of the admin team and school committee for your your diligence during this um difficult process to put it mildly I know it's an iterative process I appreciate you continuing to explore options and ensuring we get the uh the best bad option um there there are no good ones but I appreciate you can continuing to look at uh other ways coming out from different angles um just a couple observations I I I strongly hope and urge the committee to to as been talked about tonight formulate a long-term strategic facilities plan and and marry that up
188with enrollment projections so you know where Investments are needed versus not there there may be some buildings that need work today but um if we may not need that building four years from now based on projections then then maybe we foro some things uh and in put that investment elsewhere so I think having a strategic approach while Nancy spoke right that we may not know exactly what budgets are going to look like I think we can uh we can have a good idea on on that with the facilities plan and enrollment projections and and come up with uh with a more strategic approach to things um may also help shift our mindset in terms of what buildings our kids are in they are NM buildings um a lot of talk of this Ashby building this
189town Zone building Etc but we've got to look at this as as NM um and and if we send uh people that live in a certain area to an NM building that happens to be far west of where I live so be it um but it shouldn't be an Ashby building just for Ashby students the towns are building just for towns and students they're they're all NM buildings we're all NM students um and I think that mindset needs to shift um our communities are are really looking to all of view as the experts um you're in the fortunate or unfortunate position of needing to make the tough decision um not going to please everybody obviously um but I do ask for a little greater transparency and advocacy um for what you as a group collectively
190feel is in the best interest of students um I don't want to pay more in taxes um but it feels like an override right now is critical to keeping our district focused on serving our students without it as we talked about the state f funding issues and it's something has to give and I'm I'm I'm concerned that there are no even close to good options right now um we've talked about this fiscal cliff for many years here we are it shouldn't be a surprise to anybody um but we're out of Runway and and and a drastic Cuts or changes in how we operate or both um need to be made without additional revenues and I think that's that's the piece um we're focused on what building is closing but but the override is an important
191piece to prevent that and if that's seen as an option or the best option um I think there needs to be a little more advocacy for that um because without it a building will have to close uh it sounds like so um I think that just needs to be able to more clear um and I guess lastly just from what I've seen tonight maybe um um it'd be good for Miss mcneel Miss Rush Mr MC Phillips put your heads together three of you have had a lot of input a lot of good ideas tonight I think a lot of varying opinions um and maybe there's a um again a middle ground a collaborative approach to respectfully find a a path four that uh that is agreeable across the board and and again unite behind that
192and and have uh have the committee provide a a united front rather than a divided front because the divided front it it pushes itself into our communities and is dividing our communities we're looking to you again as the experts and if if you're United and and you unite behind a recommendation I I think you'll you'll get some folks from all three communities to be behind you so I thank you for all you do I I've I've been on that side of the table for years so I know it's not easy um your efforts are appreciated um keep fighting the fight for our kids and uh again I appreciate it thanks good night thank you Craig thanks Craig all right um we are no more hands raised we are going to the public statements that Miss
193I is going to read we have four of them the first one is by Jen Silva of Townsen are you ready Robin uh yeah let me just okay find which one I'm just going to read them in in a row that I have them so I know okay and it's late so forgive me if I make a mistake uh this one here is from Jen Silva resident of Townsen dear members of the school committee I'm writing as a parent who is deeply invested in the well-being and education of my children I want to express my concern about the impact school closures and reallocations may have both academically and socially for our children I the mother of two girls a second grad and a fifth grader both of my daughters have been lucky enough to attend
194Spalding Memorial School they have developed meaningful connections with their teachers and peers the teachers at Spalding provide a safe nurturing environment that makes children want to come to school I would hate to see such wonderful community of teachers and students be broken up additionally my fifth grader has had a wonderful experience beginning middle school at and Brook her teachers go above and beyond to teach with enthusiasm and passion often using project-based learning and real life experiences as a teacher in another District I cannot say the same about other schools and communities while I understand that difficult decisions need to be made we must consider how displacing these students from the nurturing environment they've built could hinder their progress and cause unnecessary anxiety these school closures would result in Long bus rides separation of peer communities
195and large class sizes it will force children into schools that are not built for their ages it is not fair to send young children to a school with no prayr I ask that you carefully consider these factors as you weigh your options thank you for your time in consideration I trust that you will take the necessary steps to ensure the best interests of all students are kept at the Forefront sincerely Jen Silva the next is um from Lori Kingston and good afternoon this is Lori Kingston 65 West Street in Peril I would like to submit a comment in support of the north M SE Regional School District budget for fiscal year 2526 I would prefer if the total amount was smaller but I know the board has done a tremendous amount of work to maintain
196level services within budget constraints those budget constraints are not going away it was extremely difficult to pass a town budget override in 2024 and downright impossible in Ashby the school committee should do everything in its power including closing facilities and consolidating resources to provide the best education possible for our kids while living within a very tight budget I fully believe we will not pass a districtwide tax override vote again in 2025 we continue to need more funding from the state which I know is in progress thank you for your time the next is from uh Kala meman uh hello first I would like to thank you for being part of our school committee and for doing what's best for our community I would like to express my opinion about the rescinded vote about keeping Ashby
197open and shuttling our towns and student kindergarten through first grade to Ashby I grew up in Townsen my whole life and decided to buy a house and start my family in Townsen I have two children one will be a kindergarten next year I would like for him to go to school in the town that we live in my expectation was when I bought this house that my children will be going to school in towns and from kindergarten to 12th grade I understand that residents of Ashby still want a school open which I get because I had a young child who I would not want to shuttle to another town but logistically uh shuttling all the towns and kids up to Ashby doesn't seem to make sense it seems like there would be more blessing costs
198associate with this option thank you for your time the last is from Caitlyn Russell hello I am unsure if I will be able to log in at the meeting uh it's smack in the middle of dinner and bath time at our house but I wanted to share my frustration at the proposed closure of Spalding my son is kindergarten student at Spalding my husband and I both grew up in Townson and graduated from NM to say we are disappointed in this community and its continued refusal to fund our schools is an understatement Spalding is a sweet Elementary School with Exemplar teachers administrators and a cozy safe atmosphere my son loves going there every day we live approximately 10 minutes from the school but Finn doesn't get home from school on the bus until between 3:45 and
199400 p.m. we are worried that sending him to Ashby would double the length of his bus ride considering it's double the distance from our house we are actively looking for other options such as school choice or neighboring districts not only are we upset at the prospect of our six-year-old having an hour plus bus ride every day we are horrified at the thought of a first grade class having 30 plus kids in it this is an impossible situation for our teachers and students and the only solution is to pass a measure to Ade adequately fund our schools likely people with no no students currently in the district won't log into this meeting because they feel as if this matter doesn't concern them but it concerns all of us if our schools suffer we all suffer our
200property values will decrease people won't want to move into town and we won't get the revitalization that we desperately need thank you for listening and for the work you do to support our schools as a high school teacher in a neighboring District I know that being on school committee is a thankless job and I appreciate your effort and your time P.S have you ever considered a later start time at the high school our school starts at 8:15 a.m. and it has been life-changing for all of us and contrary to popular belief sports are fine thank you Caitlyn Russell thank you everyone submitted um I do have one more hand raised over in the audience and hi yes thank you um can you guys hear me yes uh first of all um I wanted to say
201thank you and can I have you state where you live I live in Ash and your address uh 420 South Road thank you um first of all I want to say thank you for allowing me uh to speak up tonight um I have children in more than one school in this District um some of my other kiddos go to a different town um so I'm definitely well aware of how long a commute is uh from ashb to other towns um so I want I also wanted to say that um I feel like the fact that um Mr Mr um Brad Morgan has um sorry I'm a little bit uh on the edge right now a little bit nervous um it's okay it's okay you're doing fine you're doing fine so I I wanted to say
202that I appreciate the fact that um he um mentioned the option of keeping um of of keeping ASB Elementary open and bringing the our towns and Kos over uh because I feel like that actually makes us feel like we belong to this District uh that we are part of this District that we are North Middle sex um slogan um and um I wanted to say that I've heard everyone tonight and every time I hear something that I triggered me a little bit is that I heard some of our neighbors from towns and saying oh sending our five and sixy old little kiddos to Ashby it's going to be triggering it's going to be scary for them but how about the kiddos that Liv in Ashby they go basically to Townson uh their entire career because
203they're only in town from K to four and then we will be sending there to thwn like kidos from the very far end near ashram five and six year old kiddos their commute also matters their fears they also matter and um as I was trying to express uh when I first started talking the commute time I am very well aware of how far it is um from Ashby to other towns so um if they're concerned about about an hour ride in the bus imagine those kiddos that live like near ashram um that's something that I really feel like everyone should think about I don't even live that far into Ashby but I'm thinking about those kiddos because I feel like we all should think about the kiddos in the district um and I've heard people
204talk about property values in their Town um but yeah they they have other schools we only have one one Center um just wanted to leave this out here thank you very much and have a good night thank you then there is one more person on the list um it's a zoom user can they please send their name to to my email address because I do not want to admit them oh whoops Robin did admit that sorry I thought that's okay so Zoom user can you state your name are you on mute no they're not on mute can you hear me I can hear you can you state your name please yep I'm Terry Gardner from Turnpike Road in Townsen okay thank you so I'll be quick I know it's been late or it's getting late
205um you know I just paid my second mortgage payment here in towns and we just moved to town we just uh we we settled on towns and I don't mean to say settled but we we were lucky to find towns and a nice house with a nice piece of property that we wanted to raise our family at and being on Turnpike Road one of the main selling points is being right down the road from the the school that you know our children are going to soon be attending hopefully um looking online and I know Facebook isn't real life but looking online and some of the comments that are being made about people in the same boat as us young families that are feeling like they kind of are having the rug pulled out from underneath
206them after making a major life decision a major purchase um that they're not really getting everything they bargain for here and I know it's you know it's nobody's fault but uh I would just um I don't know it's just concerning because now I I think the ramifications go beyond I know we're all here thinking about the kids but the ramifications go beyond um the the just the kids but the health of the entire town if you have an complete Exodus of every young family in town um that's going to make the issue it's going to exponentially make the issue worse year after year after year um that's all I have that one thing I would just like to to say Patrick's idea about kind of um not doing the busing I don't know how much
207money that would save but if we are paying for empty bus seats right now because the state says we have to but the state's also not willing to meet us you know where we need to be to keep the schools open then I I'm totally in support of his idea of starting to just not follow their mandates if it helps the budget situation at all thank you thank you all right Patrick make it quick so quick um just in case anyone's not making it to the next thing project 211 Lisa you're involved in it we have a lot of local people involved in it if you are mad about this and mad at the state pay attention look for updates for that that that is what we're doing to try to get the state to
208update and change our funding formula so if you unaware of it just keep your eyes out for that um Robin take a minute of that last one of the notes because I don't think anyone's ever said anything nice about me in one of these meetings so take that all right okay I'm going to take a motion quickly before anyone else raises their hand not that it's getting late and what's the motion Lisa you got to tell me what the motion to close out to close out the public hearing I Lisa the chair I would like to make a motion to close the public hearing thank you will do I have a second oh who was the second I'll oh okay William bird is sorry all right I'm going to take the vote Patrick MC Phillips
209yes Randy Rous yes Tom Casey yes June mcneel yes will Hackler yes uh William Berg yes Bill twig yes Lisa Bloom yes and myself yes the public is public hearing is closed and I thank everyone for their comments and their questions all right now we're moving on to the regular meeting um I am going to ask that we remove the minutes from the consent agenda we will bring those back at another meeting I am going to not do a Chairman's report superintendent Morgan do you have a report to do I do not do we need to vote on the rest of the consent agenda yes please oh all right teamwork I know I was trying to make it fast here all right so let's vote on the uh consent agenda minus the minutes from 12304
210and 1116 2025 as well do I have a motion so okay so that's Randy and will do you want a second yes yes okay uh Randy yes Tom Casey he's saying yes I am okay mcnail yes will Hackler yes Patrick Phillips yes William Berg William I think he said yes yes I did say okay Lisa Bloom yes and Jill twig yes and myself yes all right so there's a consent agenda moving to the new business can I ask I just I'm sorry Lisa I just wanted you to know that the valley collaborative fy2 budget in tuition rates was just put there so that the committee um knows that it's there and they can access it it's just for review it's really not for any discussion okay so I am going to ask the committee if
211we can bypass the new business because it is getting late um and bring the school committee Norms back to the next meeting and the valley collaborative as it is just a placeholder for you guys to review would that be okay with everyone yes all right all right now we are going down to the Sub sub committee reports um finance will Hackler with the budget you have it we haven't discussed the budget well we have discussed the budget we need to give next steps for the budget and how to proceed all right so uh finance committee meeting last week we voted we were discussing the 3.16 budget that was proposed by superintendent today in his message um obviously recommended to bring that to the committee to discuss that and put that out there so I guess
212that's our starting point for right now um I have lots of thoughts but um Jun mcnail so um we have been receiving a lot of feedback um from multiple towns both in favor and not in favor of the new configuration um and I spoke to it briefly earlier um that I had another idea that we hadn't talked about but I think um it's it's smart of the committee to kind of entertain every idea and look at every option and gather as much information as we can um um to try to find a solution that essentially works for everyone um again this is not one town against another um we really need to find a a solution that we can work together to move forward um so I did have an idea and again it's not
213perfect and we would need a lot more information from the admin team if we were to explore a whole different idea but it my idea was to take um the West towns and students which is approximately 60 give a take give or take 60 to to 70 even um students to add to ashb Elementary um K through 4 model and then keep town in K through four model in one school or another um I know there there's probably not enough room in Squan cook for a full K through four um so we might need to get creative potentially moving central office moving the preschool um I'm not really sure if it would work but my idea is would help still help balance the class sizes which may still allow for that class reduction it would
214still keep um reasonable bus rides um possibly even shorter bus rides for some students um we wouldn't have people come from Far Side of one town to go to a Far Side of another town um it would still include one building closure um and I I just think it it's worth discussion and I I really hope you know whether whether it's this idea or any other idea cuz anything's kind of on the table at this point but I really hope that we can have some discussion about the pros and cons of different options um and that if there is more information needed that we can allow the admin team the time to to look at that and not necessarily have to take a vote today um the budget has already been presented to the towns
215at this point at a certain number so we would want to hold it to within that number or you know bringing it down further is favorable for the towns as well um but I think everything should still be kind of everything should still be fluid while we're gathering information um so anyway I just wanted to throw out that new idea because it does check some of the boxes it might open up a new can of worms it might open up more issues that we have haven't considered but um I I just want to put it out there for people's thoughts um again would still see that savings from the closure and we may see some saving staff reduction savings from a consolidation um in that manner so I just want to start by just putting
216that out there all right all right others others wanting to make comments Tom Casey thanks um so Brad it's uh more for you um so it's February 6 now um we initially voted kind of two months ago on you know kind of moving forward and I know you were looking for a decision you know pretty quickly in December two months later you still don't have it um definitely want to consider all the options if if there's things out there but like where where are we at because I know from last meeting there was discussion about you know notifying mbca uh msba and like logistically what do you need for a decision timeline wise to move forward so um I think the timeline is is important to make a decision sooner rather than later um really
217on a few different fronts is that first and foremost we we absolutely want to give families an idea as to what next year is going to look like for them because uh families will need to plan secondly we want to give our staff um the ability to plan as well if in fact this consolidation is going to lead to to any staffing reduction to make sure uh that we don't leave people in a situation where it's where it's too late to start looking for a job because jobs are being posted now um and thirdly I I think um the other piece that we have to consider is that um msba does does ask for or does require a six-month notice prior to closing a building where a project or any Project work has been done
218um so again all of those types of things are are I I think to me are more pressing I think uh the option that that um June brought forth is something that we could probably plan in short order um it really is it's thing it's something that has been discussed um you know previously as far as redistricting um and that's something that the school committee can certainly it's within the committee's purview is is as as I understand it but at this point I I do think that we we do need to start planning for any any building closure is going to involve some planning I don't see any anything we've discussed up to this point we have not um seen anything significant from the busing company with regard to increased costs um we have not
219seen that though the one the questions that are out there realistically as far as cost is what is the cost going to be for a move um if we do have to move a playground those discussions have been had with our own buildings and grounds department but we have not put out um an RFP for a move or anything along those lines at this point because quite honestly we're just not sure of the direction so I think once we get the direction we can start taking action if and if and when you know the whatever the decision is requires it so I would like to see a decision made soon I would like to see a decision made um in advance of our budget adoption meeting if at all possible I do know that I've
220got a lot of staff that that are questioning um their future and that's even that's with this 3.16 budget passing if that that budget doesn't pass um and you know and it's not adopted and an override is not successful if that's the route that's chosen by um by the three towns then I'm I'm going to have a lot more questions to answer in a very uneasy s uh faculty and staff right Patrick MC Phillips uh I'll defer to Randy first if that's okay okay Randy sure uh one I just uh as far as uh the busing um you asked about the closing the two schools and busing over to um peil for all three towns that did not increase uh any transportation issues and what were the time for that and are times going to
221be over an hour for any of the options oh the time um so it's our understanding that it's not going to increase cost other than potentially one additional bus um but so so that would be an additional cost um just based on the ridership as far as rides being over an hour um both options that the school committee has in front of them now there are going to be rides that are over an hour both there are eight options um unless we just take a look at the option four that was voted and the two new ones and that would bring it down to three but so the only options I'm talking about at this point are the initial option that was voted that uh option that closed two buildings and the option that was
222discussed at the last meeting um that that um that seemed to be the one that would would at least balance the class sizes out uh to the best of our ability there's um bus feels very strongly that uh the students that live in uh on the Shirley side of Townson would be looking at minimum a 70 to 75 minute bus ride the K1 students so I I think um many of these options are are are over an hour already but Ashby doesn't have over an hour going to nissitissit for Middle School oh they they would they would have over an hour yes all right and do we know how many buses it would be to get everybody under an hour I don't think it's possible to get everybody under an hour Ju Just with stops
223I mean there are certain things that the bus company has to consider right now um you know for kindergarten drop offs they do you put few enough kids on a bus and you can get there under an hour um that's usually how it works is you just add another bus you have less kids on there there's less stops they can make it there quicker yeah that's that's not something I don't I don't honestly believe that would even be affordable for the school district to be adding that number of buses okay so that that's not something that's been explored because quite honestly we're trying not to add buses and add tiers because that's going to come at a cost and it's going to make closing buildings and mot point over time Randy can I jump in
224with you on this one here as a team player I agree that a bus ride for Ashby or towns and students of that length is unacceptable would what I was discussing earlier maybe shifting some buses around that if you're not using seats like I understand it's a state guideline currently it's not working it's it's it's it's a cost it's it's a wasted cost we're talking about closing schools when we have buses with empty seats because we have to have a spots for every kid I mean if the state's not going to pay attention to us maybe they will if we break a rule I don't know what else to do at this point so I I I really think as a school committee it's something we can consider um and I know it's not going
225to be a fun popular option but I like it's a common sense option like logically why why do we have seats for kids that aren't taking the bus I mean the high school alone how many cars are in the parking lot every one of those cars has a spot on a bus that's two or three buses right there that'll help towns and and Ashby kids all day just just my two cents on that thank you um June McNeil um yes I was wondering if there was any additional information yet about the potential sale of Squan cook rather than closing spaling because again I know there's special legislature required um we were kind of unclear as to where the money would go um I'm also curious the value of that building and potential revenue from a
226sale um do we have any additional answers since the last meeting on that front I reached out to our legislators um also reached out to the msba and and I know that our legislators are looking into it on our behalf um I don't have an answer at this point in time but I I did I did do the Outreach and reached out to msba as well um did you find out any additional information about um disconnecting the lines I remember I know that's a concern too as far as um electricity water whatnot um or if it would have to be disconnected to cell or how that would work so it's my understanding that um that the lines cannot be disconnected it it is a it is a shared line but it would not be something
227that would prohibit um like if we're talking about Squan cook Squan cook being used for another purpose and and figure and and then drawing up some type of language around usage um so it's not something that would be that would prohibit um you know the sale of the building potentially or the or the leasing of the building that's my understanding um I did um reach out to a couple of people on that um and it does not appear as though that would be an obstacle okay thank you for that um and I mean I yes do we have any sense of a time frame as to when we might hear back regarding the legislature pce we don't I can certainly reach out again um but I I I know that they've they've reached out in
228our behalf and I just don't have an answer at this point I mean because overall if a a solution again that would be favorable for for everybody for all three towns would to be to close a building that's I don't want to say not being used but it would be likely easier to shift central office to perhaps the high school and shift prek to maybe each of their own towns again or um for the high school with some kind of cool Co-op program where the high school kids could have some you know handson with the little kids something like that um and then essentially Ashby could stay in Ashby Spalding could stay up Spalding it it's just I I really want to find a solution that can work for everyone so I don't want to
229leave that untapped and again the the bonus to selling a district building would be the the revenue again only onetime Revenue but we would not have that expense of the building anymore and then bring in the revenue from the sale and that might be enough to to help us through a little bit of time anyway if if again if the money could come back to the district or if it was going you know to all three towns somehow and they could use it to help offset some of the the district costs something like that um so it would really be great if we could get more answers and I know you know trying to get answers from the state what that's like but but that would be so helpful to find out I can reach
230out again all right Patrick I don't want to be negative off of that but we we we have meetings sometimes where we talk for two hours and plan to vote at the next meeting on a thing how many years do you think it would tell us take us to actually sell a school building I just I just don't see it being a possibility even in the next two years yeah actually I know there's been multiple offers um for that building for uh at least made uh inqu inquiries made to the town towns and Senior Center um for that building per Squan cook for a um I think it was a uh El not elderly but the assisted living senior housing yeah yeah senior housing there has been multiple over the years I'm sure there'd be
231lots of suitors for it but how long would it take to vote for it get the towns to vote for it they get it I'm sure approved at the legislative level I assume that's not something that happens before we need this budget approved that's all it's unlikely we're going to have the documentation that we need to sell a building before um before the budget moves forward um but it is my understanding that um that that property there is some interest in it as far as housing goes to its proximity to um the police department uh the library and the senior center yeah and and in the short term we we get exactly what we're going to get out of closing uh Spalding uh if we have to wait a little bit to to get the
232money from the building we have the reduction and the operating costs like we're counting on for Spalding just with potential of having money do do we have like a resale value on that building I I I'm not aware of the building's worth so how how do we find that out [Music] um by actually paying for an assessment or is there another way to determine the value of that building I would imagine that there's an assess value at the Town Hall um okay but I I'd have to look into it we can certainly do that I mean I think it would be worthwhile think it is an option that again could bring some money back to the district we could take that building offline and I I don't think anybody from any of the towns would
233be overly upset about it um it's an idea but but that I'm glad this dialogue is happening and that we can you know kind of bounce off different ideas and really try to come to a solution anyone else will yeah I mean I think you're just you're wishing and hoping for a solution that that could be years away here um from the comments that I've heard from the logistics of this piece of it I I can't vote as a towns and Resident a towns and you know representative for this for the option that keeps Ashby open and sending towns and students to Ashby when for years Kick the Can down the road on capital projects that need to be done and haven't been done and now you're going to populate that school with towns and
234kids and now because of the regional agreement you're Townson is going to become responsible for sending money to fix that Ash school because Ashby hasn't done it for all these years let me finish June please hey June what I'm saying everyone's gonna speak one at a time one at a time with that being known I cannot keep I cannot vote for a situation that keeps ashp open and sends towns and kids there because now because of that Regional agreement the towns and residents are going to have to spend money to for capital projects that may or may not come up whatever but that have been kicked down the road for years when we know it's happened Craig made the point about talking about strategic planning well Lisa and I and others were on the building
235committee we were trying to put strategic plans together years ago that got all blown up because we have no money for Capital we H so it's not worth doing a strategic plan for Capital situation when we don't have the money so I'm just letting you know I'm not voting for an option that keeps Ashby open and sending towns and kids there Randy I would like to dispel the myth that Ashby won't pay for their school um the towns the schools are in charge of the towns the towns uh we bring capital projects to the towns the towns don't come to us and say hey I know you've been on in our building for 20 years we're we want to go ahead and do a big project we don't know what needs to get done we're
236not in those schools every day um so it is up to the district to bring capital projects to the towns for the different schools that being said the in the last 15 years I know of and probably maybe before then okay there hasn't been a capital project that a town has turned down with the exception of adding the turf to the high school uh project that being said Ashby was we we brought a capital project to them in 2012 for new roof and windows and doors they approved it we brought a um project to Squan cook which was for all three towns in 2018 for Ro and windows all three towns approved and are paying for it Spalding uh we brought a um Capital project to Spalding for a roof in 2012 they approved it
237uh for Varner Brook just recently in 2019 we brought a capital project to them for roof and windows they approved it haon Brook has been a little bit longer but in 2005 ashb and towns and approved a new roof in 2018 approved windows and doors in vac Nissa tiit was built in 2002 peil approved that Capital project okay so to say that Ashby is not keeping up their school is a lie if we don't bring the capital projects to them they don't have an opportunity to put money towards it okay if anything it says something about the district not bringing it to them okay we have not told them or they have not told us we won't invest in the school they recently were going to put $300,000 towards the feasibility study and we talked
238them out of it and so they were doing projects to bring the safety up to get another boiler and do some of the asbestos on the pipes and a few other projects they are willing to spend money we have not brought these projects to them as far as towns and paying for it fine go with my idea let's talk with the two towns and see if we can get five years six years that townsman won't be responsible for any capital projects that come up if that is all that is keeping you from sending uh towns and students there we can solve that issue but don't put it on the town that they are the only one that's not approving and improving their schools every town has accepted and taken on the cost when we've brought
239them to them he I do have to correct you on one thing Randy and it's when we went to them through Ashby three years ago we asked them to do a feasibility study Ashby said no we can't afford the feasibility study or their selectman and um who was the chief at the time the fire chief I think he was the acting admin said no we can't afford it please we will give you the arpa money and move forward with that and that's when the building committee was created in Ashby to move forward with those projects so we have talked the district has talked to Ashby saying they do have you need to take care of this Wing we need you to look at it the wing has been shut down for how many years 12
240several years that Wing has come up in discussions with facilities ever since I have been on the board that Wing has been brought up this district has put money into the wing to keep it from falling apart they've replaced the roof or helped patch up the roof we've put the sighting or the windows which I know was paid out through Ashby putting the um the plywood on the windows so the district has done things in Ashby and Ashby when we asked them to do a study three years ago they said no that they did not need a study then they became reliant on Nancy Haynes and Dave Amari to be project managers which has taken away from the rest of our district because we have had seven buildings to be responsible for Nancy and Dave
241are great and will do anything for the district but they are not project managers that can control one huge building project so I don't like to hear that the district has not paid attention to buildings because we have and we have asked people and they have turned around and said no so I'm going to clear that up from that and you can go back and you can look at the recordings and even the big presentation that Ashby came to with to us and said we will give you this arpa money if you don't do a study on our building all right that being said I'm going to June mcne okay that's not exact ly um what happened but the the the building committee did recommend a feasibility study it was going to go before the
242town the acting Town Administrator at the time and a select board member perhaps select board chair at the time met with superintendent Morgan and discussed you know what what are the biggest concerns right now disc discussed the safety concerns and essentially came to an agreement that if that Ashby could Supply arpa funds to address the safety concerns and that it was something that they mutually agreed on to bring before the committee to present to the committee the committee um was in agreement with that but again the town's people never had a chance to vote on it it was not that the town said no we don't want to do a feasibility study because the town's people did not have that opportunity it was Town leadership saying hey why don't we address any concerns for the
243students now and make a plan to go forward in the future and it it was something that everybody was in agree with with at that time but we still have not gone back to the town and said okay we've addressed these concerns let's to a feasibility St it's never ever come before the town to vote on anyhow that wasn't why I put my hand up in the first place um I put my hand up because at the last meeting um Brad made a or brought forth the two new options and at that meeting I asked do you recommend this option over the option that was previously voted on and they said yes they would recommend not closing two schools so at this point I would like to turn it to Brad and to Gary to
244elaborate on the options before us they've been exploring the feasibility of these options and I want to hear more about why it was recommended the plan that was presented to the finance subcommittee that again the finance subcommittee approved to bring forward for this presentation um so Brad if you could kind of run through the options again and the benefits pros and cons for them so that um everybody on the committee can have a full kind of glimpse of this not and everybody who is on the call still please sure so um I was asked by um a few school committee members to come up with an option that um they kept Ashby Elementary School open so I I met with a small group from central office and we started looking at some potential options and
245the option I just have to change my screen here so I can go back to it we were looking at two potential options um the first of which would be um keeping Ashby open using it it being a k to1 Ashby Townson U model uh both uh again all of Ash all of Tansen Squan cook would remain open with a prek being District wide in grades 2 to four ashp and Townson and then hawth and Brook would be 5 to8 ashp and town as it is now uh there would be a potential Savings in staff as we talked about um there would have to be a staggered start time uh with the shared Campus of Squan cook and hawtho and Brook but it would be a singular bus run uh grades 2 to8 um again
246keeping that prek centrally located is is pretty important in that um it allows us to ensure that we have uh typical students in our prek programs they max out at 13 you have to have seven um typical students so students that are not on individualized education plans and six students that are on individualized education plans in order for it to be considered a an approved integrated uh program by DEC um again another potential positive would be merging students early would create more of an Community between Ashby and Tanson um there would be no changes in the structure at Haw and Brook it may help eliminate the annual question around closing Ashby um the other option that that we presented was the uh keeping ashb K to 5 again that really does not um eliminate um
247the issues around Equity um when you look at Ashby and compare it to um both Spalding Memorial and varnam Brook uh keeping Squan cook prek districtwide and then K3 townend and then hawo and Brook be four to five tonson 6 to8 Ashby Tanson um and again this would uh you know increase Ashby's enrollment much like the first model but not not by as much you be sure about 20 students a potential Savings of four staff as opposed to seven in the first model um keeps Ashby open but little changes and less savings and then Ashby and students will be entering Haw and Brook at different grade levels in that model uh because again Ashby would be K to five uh all Ashby uh so uh Ashby students would not enter hawthone Brook until grade six
248and Townson students would enter Haw Brook in grade four so those are the two um things that were presented part of that was um you know certainly still concerns around the Ashby Elementary lease um with regard to um the water supply um having to be tested which is which comes at a pretty significant cost to the district and then the vacated Wing um still being on the lease as well as other parts of the property that the district does not use um school committee would have to take action on policy jca Student Assignment to schools uh in redistricting in um at least in option one and again uh option the first option I shared provides more Equity with regard to balancing class size the second option really does and it just adds another grade level
249moving West Townson would likely again um it it certainly uh would would fill ashb Elementary but I think it's um moving West towns and it's not an exact science every year I think we'd have to look at it from one year to the next to make sure that we're not putting ourselves in a situation where we're going from Ashby can really only handle uh if you're going K to 4 to sections at each grade level um it would leave them with one extra classroom I believe so that if you get to a point where a third classroom is needed at more than one grade level it it would not be doable um so that could create issues um with moving West Townsen so we may have to look at the um the map and how
250West Townsen is defined on an annual basis based on space and Ashby from one year to the next if that makes sense Patrick MC Phillips what what concerns me most about what Brad said is that we had already voted on this um and then other members have just decided that Brad should give us more options I mean I I feel like we had to pull off a Band-Aid that was for lack of better words a decision it was what we voted um just to have to do it again now is just very frustrating to have to have this talk again when this is such a small part of the budget when we have millions of dollars that we have to find for for teachers and staff and cuts to it like I'm just annoyed that
251we're back here can I just say something real quick just as a point of clarification um I I I'm often asked um and have been asked by multiple school committee members on multiple occasions through this process to look at ious models um so in looking at this model it was no different really than any of the other models um you know that have come up in conversation um you know I I'll get emails here and there consider this and and we consider all options so I I do think in this particular case um you know in coming up with two new options it was no different than anything else um I've been asked to look at options and if a school Committee Member quite honestly asked me to look at an option I'm going to
252look at an option um I feel is it's my job to do that and to exhaust all options um and that's really how we came up with um all of the other options or people sharing ideas and opinions uh so I do want to clarify that um the coming up with these other two options was no different than any of the other options we've come up with I'm asked to explore something and I ask um I ask the team to work with me on it and explore it okay and I just want to make sure June said that you you personally prefer this new Option over the old option four or you think it makes more sense so I I what I would like to do is find a way and again I don't think
253there's any exact science in doing it is find a way so that we can balance class sizes across the district um I think that that's very very important and right now that's not something that we have is is k1 the best answer I don't know could 34 be a better option possibly is moving West townsin into Ashby another option to consider yes but it does create potentially an issue if you need a third section at a particular grade level but I do think what's very important is that when when you have three elementary schools it's very hard um when some when some schools have classes of 27 25 24 and then others have class sizes of 16 and 17 that that's a significant difference in an elementary school classroom not that it's not at the
254middle and high school level as well but at the elementary level it it's significant um so and it's always been something quite quite honestly that has come up from um from town leaders um when we present the budget um to them as well so just trying to find a way to best balance um balance class sizes but also recognize the fact that all three communities want to maintain a school in their Community as well which I fully understand I get I would want the same thing um if I was a member of any one of the three communities to maintain a school in the community in which I lived especially at the elementary age thank you all right um Randy were you I think it was you or J June is okay if I speak
255[Music] um one of the jobs of the school committee and it is in our policies is that we must look at the long range educational plan for students okay um it certainly is a tough job especially when there are immediate budget issues and immediate needs um but it is our task and our task alone to make sure that the long-term feasibility of quality education can occur five 10 years from now with that said you know what um with that said we need to take a look at that so uh my two other comments after this um basically pertain to that is one in December we had very little information on um even having time to sit down and take a look at what the capacities in the district were we were given a document but
256even to be able to sit there and look at what that meant for the future we didn't have much time there's been two months since then the Administration has been able to look into a lot of different things as they go down on how they can make that feasible uh committee members have time had time to look down to kind of come up with some other ideas and look at and uh put things together and process everything that's been happening we've had a lot of time to sit uh listen to the community members and hear a lot of different things to sit back and say we made a decision in December we must stick to it no matter what information we get we must stick to it no matter what else comes up is irresponsible
257for this committee looking to keep the quality of Education as high as we possibly can there is nothing that a committee can do worse or a group can do worse than to ignore new information when it comes up and better information when it comes to us um I have had the opportunity to sit and create a table on what the configurations and the um and what the enrollments at each school would be for each configuration if I'm allowed to share my screen I will share it with everybody so everyone can see a visual okay see all right I believe everybody can see that is it big enough for everybody okay this first box has our current configuration a is Ashby T is Townsen p is peil um so Ashby kada Ford Ashby Elementary has 152
258students uh sanook currently just has the prek with 89 Spalding has Townsen K to4 with 4113 haam Brook has Ashby and towns in 5 to through eight at 449 varnam Brook is peil K to four 606 students ntis it um is peal 5 to8 with this second box here is the option for configuration that was voted in December um that closed Ashby and closed Spalding what it would create is Ashby and towns in K to one with the prek at Squan cook would increase the enrollment to 295 hathon Brook for ashb and Townsend would uh convert down to an elementary school um 2 to five with 400 98 peil in varnam Brook would have K to five instead of K to four increasing their enrollment by 80 to 684 and a districtwide 6 to8 at
259Nissa tiit would increase their enrollment by 200 up to 702 all of these uh enrollments keep all of the special education programs that are there now and the statistic will be getting a new LEAP program Middle School LEAP program starting next year all I hear from the um community members and even some of the uh school committee members is varen Brook and Nissa tiit are overflowing they are full to capacity so that's fine um our numbers from the administration say that they can fit in these schools but it is adding 80 students to varnam Brook and 200 to ntis it over what they currently have um which which means a lot more buses um and we'll ignore all the other uh issues that we've already talked about as far as busing Ashby to towns and
260things like that looking at option one of the two uh new ones keeping Ashby open um peil and of Barner Brook and nit in both of these cases remains exactly as they are now K to four 5 to8 uh with the special education programs um with the same enrollment uh it's 548 and 484 because that's what the predicted um for 2026 it goes down a little bit in all the towns um Ashby and towns in K to one in Ashby the enrollment goes up to 204 Ashby towns in two to4 and the prek at sanac Cook and it goes up to 466 this um model also could work going at Spalding whereas Spalding and sanook are basically the same size um but the current option has spalled in closing um hathon Brook would remain the
261same with Ashby and Townson 5 to 8477 uh the last one is Ashby k to5 at Ashby with 186 Townsen K to3 and the prek at sanook for 423 um hathon Brook would have towns in 4 to5 ashb towns in 6 to8 um for an enrollment of 538 eight um and like I said the the peal schools remain the same all right um my concern with closing two schools is the capacity issues if we uh have expanded um students in our IND District um special education programs do we actually have rooms available to create another special education class do we have rooms in the district to bring in new special education um programs that can reduce the budget for the schools okay that's a budget reduction um year over-year uh that is sustainable if we
262can bring programs in that's why we have these programs inhouse now they have saved us money from out of District costs do we have room for uh any increases in population in any of the three towns due to uh the MBTA due to just an expansion due to um you know peol had a 100 unit um uh uh complex that was not approved but doesn't mean that it won't come back and get approved in another year or two or three do we have the room for those students for any kind of expansion in the next five to 10 years and I would argue that we don't um and I think it's irresponsible from the long range planning that we need to do for Quality education to sit here and take our our um space capacity
263to the point that we cannot um handle anything new or any cost reductions in the special education um Arena um that is my concern with closing two schools do we have excess capacity in the district yes we actually have excess capacity in just about every school including the uh peil schools because and that's why we have the special education classes there because they had the room if you take general education most of the schools are 50 to 60% full so do we have excess capacity yes special education does take up a a different type of space which we need to take into consideration so some of that excess space for general education is being used for cost reductions in the district right now and I think we need to that two schools cuts it down
264too far and that is my concern with the two thank you Randy any more all right um I'm going to let Jill twig where did she go Jill um she's not able to raise her hand and so I'm gonna allow her to speak here thank you Lisa can you guys hear me okay it's a little loud where I am yes yeah so one thing I wanted to say about special education as a special education Advocate and a special education parent one of the things in Ashby that the steps program had was K was in a classroom by itself one and two was in a classroom by itself and grades three and four were in a classroom by themselves which only took up three classrooms it allowed for Less transitions for the kids uh less teachers
265for the kids more paraprofessionals and therefore would add a ton of extra space in a school that you're saying is way too crowded you know now you're freeing up three extra classrooms which are super large anyway you know if you go ahead and look in the barn and Brook schools it can more than capacity hold two different grades so you know that's my two cents about special education you know we can definitely start pairing them up save with you know teachers ad pair of professionals and save space so that there is extra room sa for grade five at V that's it all right thank you Jill um Patrick MC Phillips you're on mute yeah sorry question back for Randy when when you did that that spreadsheet did you work with Brad and his team to
266go over those numbers because I know when they came up with these options they looked at all of that and I just concern going through your first two options quick is the sums don't even total the same amount I don't believe so I'm just I'm just like I have more faith in Brad's numbers that that the option works then those numbers were straight from uh projected enroll Romans from uh Nancy okay it's just strange to me that they change okay the current configuration is fy2 numbers the other ones are FY 26 project okay that makes sense as far as expansion as far as expansion for Peril if peppol gains more students H that having Ashby open doesn't help us at all with that because ashp only has room for like three more class classrooms if
267it's already at you know four or five classes they'd be going to towns and so if it comes to growth capacity expansion I just assume keep Spalding open and then close ashb like that that just makes more if if growth is truly your concern there's not much space in Ashby and and just my last question just based on I know I asked Kathy earlier do you like have have you read the hban associates report like I know you keep saying that there's nothing wrong with the building but I mean that that that seems like a pretty I I've read the whole thing several times now and and it just it just appears that like I feel like what what is being said that the building doesn't need work versus what a third party you know
268engineer report says are completely different answers and I acknowledge the other buildings also probably need work in repairs but if they hold more students it just makes more sense I'm sorry was that for for me yeah did yes I I have read through that as well and um there's a couple couple caveats in that is it was a preliminary study um and it said so that it uh did A Walk that they people did a walk through and then re U read had documents as far as the age of things and they had interviews with people in the district um and then the maintenance so that wasn't a full going through and um doing a full study that was a preliminary study two um they had three different Scopes scope one was um needed but
269not imminent okay um there were only one or two safety actual safety issues on there and those have all been addressed and there's some others that are being addressed um so all the rest of them are staying in there as needed not imminent which pretty much all of our buildings are in that state once you get up to scope two and three um you start getting into more um would be nice um um things to have or to change or to enhance so uh yes there was a lot of things in there as well as scope one on what is needed was only $2 million okay and then you had the others on would be Nies so yeah I have it open here it's yeah scope one was necessary not yet critical scope two is
270recommended and scope three was does not meet current code so scope two was 2 million scope the C and the current code was in there because uh when you hit a certain threshold in renovations over a three-year period you have to bring things up to code yeah so those are all grandfathered in there's nothing wrong with those things unless we hit that threshold in that last column but the code exists for a reason so I mean yes you don't it's grandfathered you don't can I ask when your house was built uh it's I'm on a fairly new build so that's not going to work I I understand what you're saying and I understand how that works but some of those things that are code that we we our grant fed in on could still be
271a safety issue if they were a safety issue they would have been called out as a safety issue well this report still you know five years old now postco constructions up 40% so these numbers are are are larger now than they were then like okay it's just a risky building and I feel all the all the buildings have those things in them you have um I believe uh varnon Brook just had a major uh um renovation and they still weren't able to address the of the building Y and that may be coming up for another um study on more money to put into that building because that couldn't be done peil tends to vote Yes for their buildings uh gee they wouldn't have an opportunity if we don't put it in front of them okay
272we're you've been here for years stby y we're going to stop right there um we do it is getting to it's 10 um we need a plan to how this committee is going to move forward because the clock is ticking and our families and our teachers and our especially our students need a decision on what this committee is going to move forward with that being said I'm going to hand it back to will that's what a chair person does is they hand it back to whomever they feel is the best for suited to help with this situation like me to do chair well I'll start if you like we can we need to come up with a contingency plan of if we're not handing this to the towns and if they're not going for for
273the overrides things of that nature where do we go next I think I think buses we should talk about that again and just vote on that of yes we should cut those seats if anyone has no problem with that that's an easy one that's not gonna give everyone too much urn and then I think we have to talk about Ashby again we have a a budget that was put together by the uh superintendent for um Ashby and Townsend uh at a for K to1 option we know that budget um will reduce 1.6 million down to a 3.15% increase we don't have um the only thing we have as far as the option for is the that a possible $900,000 uh reduction I don't know what that would be uh kind of hard to compare apples
274to apples as far as if you're just going to look at dollar signs I would argue um that when you're looking at education um dollar signs cannot be the very first thing at the top that you look at because you're going to end up um just cutting off off your nose to to spite your face um you're looking just at the immediate for the money um I think there's other places that we can cut and that we should look at cutting that we can actually uh easily get back if we get more money uh versus uh things that are permanent and that impede us in the future okay uh Jun you have your hand um yes at this point Point um we did put some more questions um to the administration it's nearly 10:30 um
275I don't know about you guys I have have been sitting in front of the screen for f over 15 hours at this point um I think we need to get any other answers that we've asked for um and stick with our standard process which is the hearing night it's kind of put out there and presented we have this discussion or the continuation of this discussion um when it's not very late and we' haven't already been talking for four and a half hours um whether it is at another meeting prior to the adoption meeting or whether it is at the adoption meeting um for the adoption the committee has to vote by a 2third majority correct yes so um as of the last option we were kind of split almost 50/50 you know a five4 split
276um regarding the options my guess is if the the option Remains the Same that's kind of where we land with the budget which would not pass the budget which would mean it would not go forward to the towns um and then we're really kind of spinning our Wheels a lot more so what I would recommend is we kind of all just step back again get any other information have an additional meeting either before then or we just you know know that our next meeting may be just as long as this one and we'll have more discussion um but as it stands I think if we're trying to again Force some sort of vote tonight it we're we're not going to move forward in any direction um and if we don't have a budget that we
277agree on for the towns then we're not even going to be giving them an opportunity to vote on an override um until we do have one that we agree on so I recommend that we do kind of just step back and give ourselves a chance to sleep on this and open the discussion again um on a fresh day we can schedule another meeting no no we just did this for four hours we can't leave with no more results I mean we need to have other discussions but Randy we've been having other discussions since November we haven't been we've been having the same discussion over information more more this again exactly we have just been having the it's the same conversation have conversations on other Cuts uh we need to have conversations on what the number
278uh for the override is going to be we need to have discussions on um lots of other things in this budget other than just the buildings you I understand I understand what you're doing and I respect it Randy is there any scenario where you close ashb or is just just the hill you D on because I don't understand you you said we all need to work together and that about figing best like ripping the Band-Aid off this again pushing this till when till it's too late to do anything this year till we're like no one's even talked about the 2.1 we're still looking for right no one's concerned have because no one's concerned about all the teachers were letting go no talked about the staff at all it's been Ashby for five months now you
279stop that's all you that's all you spoke about not the only way we can cut there's more than two ways that we can cut money out of our budget it's not the last year which kind of caused this even more so like yeah no I get there's other ways but they're not good ways there are good ways then then why haven't you told them to us yet what are you waiting for because I'm waiting for the administration to put them together and give me an estimate on on some of what they were I I have suggested a uh Insurance opt out again we did that in number twice in the last 10 years or so um which saved the district at least the first time it saved this significant amount of money wasn't as popular
280the second time and we're going to try that again to save several hundred thousand doar or actually rather I don't say I don't know if we're going through with it but it is was a suggestion okay we have to put our heads together we have to work together and not just sit back and say staff there's no other good ways $10,000 here $50,000 there H 100,000 won't do anything it saves staff okay and it's worth the work to save staff to find even if it's little things that add up but nobody wants to put the work in the easy things as buildings and staff we all had a sit down together and went through the line items we like we we have Brad we have jerem we have a great team working on this budget
281like you keep saying these things are going to appear when are they going to appear Randy and the answer is they're not going to and I'm sorry well I need the administration to chime in on that because I can't say I can't talk for them they've done a great job on all the budget they have been doing a fantastic job I have no complaints they have been working tirelessly trying to find ways to save staff and save this budget and save education for the students so let's start with an easy one so for for for next year for for 26 we want to look into the option of foregoing the state and busing differently is that something we want to consider that is that could be a big money saver we could we can consider
282it I'm not sure how much of US savings I would need to talk uh find out from the administration because if if there's noing that means we don't get the reimbursement then that's going to be a bigger cost I agree but how's it going to look when the state's not funding and we're closing schools and that's what they're going to pick a fight on again I I'm willing to talk about it if I have the details I'm not going to go ahead and vote for something um as a purely uh thought first time thought up thing without having the details okay that's that's all I need give me information is all I've been asking for here and then we base all over our stuff on information I vote to reinstate option four is our way
283forward I second there is a motion on the floor to reinstate option four which was to remove Spalding and Ashby okay and all those towns and parents who didn't want to send their kids to Ashby are now going to be sending their uh sixth seventh and eighth students over to nissitissit I I want to make sure that all of the towns in residents understand that and I want to make sure that all of the PE residents understand that you're getting uh about 28 or about you know 200 more students in your schools 200 at nissitissit and 80 more in varen Brook so 280 more students coming to your school for closing two buildings in the other towns and it won't do anything for the following budget okay because next year we won't have capacity next
284year we won't have buildings to cut next year um we're not going to have anything and the costs are still going to go up because the drivers are still in the budget and we and if we vote this tonight the override won't save the two schools the override won't uh save any that's being voted right now have you talked to anybody in towns no one's voting for an override that's fine I'm just saying that there are some people who are willing to I don't know how many and probably all depends on how it's marketed and what it's saving teachers teachers over buildings and if you don't have the room for the teachers to teach we're either G to end up getting having them in the hallways having them double up in classrooms eventually or having
285to go and get mobile classrooms we started the night with a plot projection long range planning we started with a plot projection tonight of the last 10 years of of growth in the schools and it's been a decrease it showed the next I think 15 years of growth potential and it was stagnant and we've been filling the space with bringing special education in District so that we can have them in the district which is a benefit to them that we can save on um at a district cost we bring these programs in so that we can save money we're doing that currently we're bringing a a middle school LEAP program in yes bringing yes it will be here next year I understand that okay um you go back 15 years or 20 years we didn't
286have any of these programs or very few of these programs in District we have been bringing them in to save money that's a smart long range planning uh June whoops you're on mute Jun sorry I lowered my hand and forgot the mute um so with that option again we'd be adding 300 kids to peil schools almost including almost doubling up the students in the sped classrooms we would be taking a school away from Townsen taking a school away from Ash we would be losing any support from Ashby for an override ever again we would be not doing any building projects ever again because again all three towns need to pass a building project no matter which town it's in so peil will not have any improvements to their schools ever Townsen will not have any
287improvements to their schools ever and again Ashby would have no school in essential not be part of the district anymore that that's what you just put on the table they telling us so what you keep screaming is we are NM but it's you should be saying it's we are NM as long as ashp stays open as long as ashp is included and and um yes and again they still included admin made a recommendation that they recommended above this plan so you don't want to go with the admin recommendation correct even though that was included in the budget hearing that was just presented to all the towns which sound you would have ADD in add in that million dollars back in which would be more teacher cuts I guess if the only two line items you're
288looking at are buildings and teachers out of all the possible line items well we already made all the other Cuts we can in that one point well it's funny you you've been here for nine months Patrick and the process that we go through year after year you keep saying it it's so much dire more dire this year it's not this is the process that we go through to trim it down we go back and forth we discuss ideas we realize maybe this one idea isn't the best idea we go back and explore another idea how many years have you been here well in the district a long time but um on just about six okay well what you guys Al that meeting what you guys have been doing isn't working because I've been here for
289two years now and it's been a nightmare my two years here with cuts well we haven't been hurting the students the way that this would propose we hurt the students because you guys got to cut everything else and I was saying this last year when you used all the end said it's going to be worse next year nothing's changed saying the same thing you're saying the same hurting a student that's that's just that's an emotional attack without yes yes it students I understand that emal attacks aren't great I'm Excuse me I really thought I I had the floor for the moment I've been cut off all night um superintendent Morgan and Dr ree could you speak speak more as to why you made the recommendation that you did Lisa we have a vote on the
290floor that was seconded yes we're going with the protocol of meetings that's yeah there's allowed for discussion which is what's happening all right everyone I know that it's late and I know that everyone this is an emotional topic I'm going to ask everybody to refrain from talking over one another everyone has a valid point to make so just be respectful to one another all right all right superintendent Morgan do you have more information for the committee I I I don't have more information other than other than what I've shared I think the one thing that I would say um at this point um I I reviewed the two options to keep Ashby open um in looking at everything and having more time to to really look at the to really look at the numbers and
291look at the flexibility I I would not recommend closing two buildings um I I do think that we could end up in a really difficult spot if anything happens with regard to growth um I I mean I I look at peil if housing unit goes in we could end up not only having to move the special ed programs but potentially having to redistrict pots of peil to Townson um you know both vnum and Nissa Tia are you know have a lot of students in them but I know that that 250 unit housing um complex has been put on the table before and I know that that's potentially years down the road but we also don't want to be in a situation where we don't have any buildings in which to use which we could end
292up in that position which I I I would not want to recommend anything that happens in any of the towns with um whether it be you know the Mt MBTA or any type of um any type of housing project that could put us in a situation where we don't have any flexibility at all um I I do think that we need to close a building what building that is is ultimately up to the school committee um you know you know we've shared um some options with the committee ultimately it is it is up to the committee to decide which building it happens to be I know we heard from many parents tonight wanting to keep um Spalding open and I've heard the you know Squan cook put out there as well is something to consider
293um I I would say that if we are going to close two buildings and that's something that the committee moves towards we would probably want to look at Squan cook as opposed to Spalding being closed because Spalding I believe has five or six more classrooms than Squan cook does so would provide a little bit more flexibility um so we would want to look at or you would want to look at Squan cook I should say as opposed to Spalding if we were to close two buildings because Spalding just has that much more flexibility because it is it is it is it is larger all right Patrick whoops you're on mute you're on mute Sor the only concern then we have is growth and it still Ashby makes no sense because there's no room to grow
294there and it's not centralized so then I would assume we keep Spalding open and close ashb like like these are just basic logical things like I I feel like I'm I'm either a crazy person or just like I don't know what's happening anymore like this doesn't make sense uh Randy um one just a a little uh kind of odd point of of uh uh point of order I guess it would be called um the being that we have a proposed budget that closes one school um having a motion to close two schools doesn't seem like the right motion it should be some kind of a change to the budget again just technicality um but wanted to bring that up um the other thing is um flexibility doesn't need to be centralized if we were looking
295at flexibility to be centralized uh then we be closing uh looking at closing either an Ashby school or a peil school because neither one of those are centralized um so uh that logic kind of does not stand um but I will stand by keeping Ashby open because there are multiple reasons why you um why you do things okay money is one thing education opportunities are another um but the communities count unless we are just lying to all the communities that the communities actually um you know are something that we want to preserve that we want to be part of that we want to encourage to grow that we want that all three communities are part of something um and when you're dealing with that you can't just go and ostracize one of the towns and
296say your community is very welcome in all the other in the other two towns um but we're never going to come there we're never going to do anything for you um that does not create a welcoming um opportunity for that Community it's ostracizing them um so that needs to come into the considerations when we're looking at all of these things we're looking at every child are you really going to sit there and say um that Ashby you have to go and travel to get all of the opportunities we value like everybody else but you have to go and travel for all of your grades for everything to come to us because we're bigger we're better and um you just don't have uh enough numbers to to make it a point for us to come over
297there which is what you're trying to say saying that it's a small school there's no room for growth there is room for growth if you take a look at the percentage that you're talking about in each Town they're a small town the percentage that the other towns were talking about the growth they can handle that with two classrooms or three classrooms um so I don't take that argument very well there are many many facets that we need to um consider and I hear all too often from people one maybe two of the facets being considered and uh the others discarded uh June um and we would have a problem with this because closing ashb reduces the budget by 380,000 and the recommendation that was brought forth by the finance subcommittee and presented to the public
298tonight had a million in savings so that leaves us over $600,000 short um from what we just told the public we were looking at so that is that more staff that we're looking at reducing where would that be made up because you're essentially asking to add money back into the budget now to for that closure can I speak now I I don't know who that questions for uh Brad do you want to answer first yeah so the the budget um had again just using round numbers um accounted for either a closure of $400,000 or $600,000 um and then the flip side would be a reduction in staff through consolidation of if it was a $400,000 building $600,000 if it's a $600,000 building $400,000 again we used um round numbers if if Ashby or squand a
299cook with 380 390 we called it 400 and if um Spalding was I think 585 we called it 600 right so still the the million dollars is still a combination of a building closure and staff reduction but the staff reduction was organic due to the balancing class sizes and the reconfiguration IT W wouldn't be just an additional cutting of people somewhere and adding uh making essentially bigger classes I think any closure would account for a consolidation of Staff any any one of them would because it's a combination of um custodial and operational costs so the the custodial costs were um in there as well as some other um as well as some other positions and then some teaching Andor uh support staff were also included in that so the closure of any building would result
300in a reconfiguration or not a reconfiguration but a consolidation of some sort um that makes sense Patrick my goal would be to make as many Cuts as we can and then try to get an override for like a million because that's possible especially if it's to save teachers um I don't know if I'm able to resend the vote I requested just to make more sense based on the budget and based on Randy say against policy I vote that we change the closing building from Spalding to Ashby because that will alleviate the growth concerns it allows us um I know Townsen doesn't want to send kids to Asheville and they made that perfectly clear tonight so maybe they will vote Yes for an override if that's if they're that passionate and strong about saving a school
301and saving teachers that's that's my two cents on it I think we're we're wasting our time um on on the small beans when we need still need to figure out if an override will even pass or if we're just in trouble either way it really is damned if you do damned if you don't so I vote we close Ashby instead of Spalding in towns and Reps I really think you should listen to what your constituent said this evening all right Patrick um I'm going to ask Tom Tom did you have something to say you did raise your hand earlier you don't have anything to say I did but it's fine we've gone on long enough um June so again closure of Ash is the most minimal of savings of any of the options at that
302380 and we are likely adding multiple buses as far as the districtwide peppol I mean I is that I'm not even sure how this would work now what the new option would be I mean are we still looking at districtwide peppol are we looking at or Ashby I think just closing a I think that gives Brad so many options I think that gives them so many options we we'd have to come back with a plan I mean at this point it seems like it would be appropriate to table the discussion until admin comes back with a plan uh they made a plan for closing they made a plan for closing two schools they can make a plan for closing Ashby it's 150 students sorry like you could have also tabled a recension vote and chose
303not to like it's time it's time to vote I'm sorry we're not kicking the can anymore we have bigger concerns than which school closes we still have to find $2.1 million well you will not have Ashby's support of an override I never assumed we would but well you would have before I mean this was on the table last year and they voted no handily no yes towns lost by four and Ashby voted no handily and this was on the table last year so that's not true that's not true they voted to pass the budget which had the money for the school in it Ashby voted approved the school budget it doesn't matter where the money came from whether you're asking them to to pull it from the taxpayers or pull it from department they approved
304the budget and came through with the money all right uh Lisa Bloom I just want to say um that Patrick I really feel that you've been very disrespectful to a lot of school committee members tonight to public um you're putting more division into our our district asp is part of the district it's a three town District each Town needs to have a school in it to be a community that's it so what would you recommend Lisa the new Option One so you didn't hear your towns and constituents tonight okay no I'm an at large seat HRA I represent at all three towns okay my apologies and I always will Randy as far as who we represent it is in our policies that we represent the students um it is in multiple policies um we have
305policy uh ba school committee operational goals North M sex Regional school committee is responsible to the students for whose benefit the school system has been established um uh in policy BCA school Committee Member ethics in the school committee and uh their relationship to the community realize that his or her primary responsibility is to the children okay I understand that we have to listen to the taxpayers absolutely we need to talk listen to them but the very first thing that needs to be on our agenda is the education of these children and looking at all of them to be equal we don't look at a small town and say their children can do whatever we need them to because the bigger towns uh have different ideas every child deserves to say I belong to NM and
306have the exact same reason why they are saying that and the exact same feeling of belonging he having a school in each district helps that um I would be open to looking at sanook over Spalding course what I heard tonight was there was a lot of um uh passion about Spalding um but like uh that gentleman had said any kind of a compromise which is what we have to do here looking at this budget is a compromise means that not everybody gets everything that they want so we can't look at one constituent see and say oh you don't want that don't worry about it we won't give that to you the other the other constituents will do all of the problem and all of the stuff all right by asking Townsen um not to change
307anything we asking Ashby to change everything okay we need to come up with a romise and I think that this comes up with a very good compromise that um maintains um educational quality maintains the long range planning that we need and the flexibility in the district um and it solves a lot of problems that we have with the class sizes and other things so that is where I stand uh June I know I said this already but if we want to pass the budget by a 23 majority to be able to move it to the towns we're going to have to have something that is more agreeable on the committee otherwise we're still going to be on the same split and we're not going to move the budget forward I know everyone is going to
308this because it is getting late it's almost 11:00 and we've been here too long and everyone is getting tired and I think everyone is starting to argue and I know that we need a budget my suggestion is that we reconvene for another meeting and I know that people are shaking their head I get it Patrick I get it I I I move to vote I moved to vote at a second though so I don't understand yeah but I'm considering everyone here well where was that when they rescinded the vote two weeks ago and I made that a statement when a resion was made too I said we need to consider it but we held the vote and I can still hold the the vote if everyone on the committee or somebody does not want to
309table it and get to table it I think that would be the next step is to table it I know people don't want to do that but I do think that people are getting very tired I I will move to table second okay now though there has to be a time that everyone can meet because vote on that we don't vote on that it's just a move in a second no we'll vote on it in a second but I do want to be aware that we do need to have a time where everyone can get back and meet so do we want to schedule this next week sometime because sooner because we do need an answer before the adoption of February 26th I mean we can vote down the table if everybody doesn't want to
310table it we need to vote for that cuz people can continue if we want to continue so on theing and then we'll so nobody is raising their hand or saying anything regarding tbling it I I I thought perfectly no I know but we're going to vote on the table okay yes thank you all right okay Lisa Bloom yes billberg [Music] yes Tom Casey no will Hackler no June mcneel yes Patrick MC Phillips no Randy Rous yes Jill twig no I am going to vote no as well um because we do need a decision and our families do deserve a decision and I'm sorry that this meeting is going to go longer I move to vote we close ashy instead of sping a second okay a motion is on the floor it is to to close
311Ashby and not Spalding it was motioned by Patrick and seconded by Jill twig right I'm going to go down the list again here we go Lisa Bloom no bill Berg bill I can't hear you Bill oh what uh should be able to hear me yep I can hear you now no did what did you say I said no no okay Tom Casey yes William Hackler yes Jun mcneel no Patrick MC Phillips yes Randy Rous no and I think we're sending an absolutely awful um having no discussion on this we're sending an awful message and we will have trouble passing a budget just because we vote this in doesn't mean we have a budget Jill twig can you repeat the options just for a second so I make sure that I'm voting correctly it's yes to
312close Ash no to um and to keep Spalding on the table so yes yes Jill yes yes sorry I got back yes yes did you get that Lisa yes I did okay great I do not make this vote lightly and I do look out for the entire District um my vote is yes it's a a five to four vote in favor of closure of ashb and to keep spolding next steps I think um Brad and his team need to go back and look at the proposal and the budget and we bring it back to the committee I do recommend that we probably have another meeting as we do need to have a budget and we need to have a budget by February 26th to send to the towns I know that this is an emotionally
313charged subject for everyone in involved these are not like decisions that anyone makes but we simply do not have money to continue doing this and the can is getting kicked down the road we need to find a solution to help us and I know that the state is not going to come in and help us at this time we may have to look at closing another school as well so I want the public to know that that's a possibility as well um does anyone else have anything to add all right I think we are going to take a motion to adjourn well I can't I can't make the motion but you can so mov okay that's will Hackler and Jill twig all right we going go down the list Lisa Bloom this is to close
314the meeting yes Lisa Bloom billberg yes Tom Casey yes will Hackler yes June mcneel yes Patrick mcflips Patrick mcflips yes yes Randy Rous [Music] Jill twig yes and my is yes all right good night everyone