CorpusRecord 196188

NMRSD School Committee 1/16/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / North Middlesex Regional School District
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Middlesex County, MA
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,178 words · about 74 min
Collected
2026-06-25

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001welcome everybody to the North Middle sex Regional School District school committee meeting on January 16th the time is 6:03 it's a Thursday the re the meeting is being recorded the next scheduled meeting of the school committee will be held 6 p.m. Thursday February 6th 2024 all all right can I get a motion on the consent oh roll call hold on Lisa blooms in the okay hold on once Lisa joins we'll do roll thanks for the help will thank you all right we have Randy Rous William BD June mcneel will Hackler Lisa Bloom Nancy Haynes Brad Morgan Robin Ivy and Dr Reese not may I have a motion on the consent agenda we have two Lisa yes sorry uh with the consent agenda I was reviewing the um school committee minutes a second time uh right

002before the meeting and I caught something uh that I don't think was correct um so if we can maybe pull them or I can just say what's you know I don't know if we can correct them on the spot or not um is it one of the Motions that's incorrect yes because I don't believe it was the plan b um and it says in the event that plan a a full override fails I don't think we had the word full I think it was just if the override fails because at that point we hadn't even discussed what we were doing for an override so why don't we just take the minutes off and um we can take review them yeah I apologize for missing that okay the first time that's okay so now will I

003now can can I take a motion and we're excluding December 3D's minutes from the consent agenda uh so moved second all right so that was Randy and will all right Randy yes Bill yes June will yes Lisa Bloom yes and myself yes all right we have four people for public comment I will allow three minutes or that is our policy that we allow three minutes per speaker first we have Patrick MC if he could raise his hand and Robin willot him one second can you guys hear me yes we can hear you um just state your name and address Patrick MC ashb Mass um basically I am a little concerned that people are reacting too quickly to the school closing of Ashby and they think it's a quick reaction if you really look back when

004the public safety building was done Brad had approach the school the um select board offering to make Ashby with a complete renovation a primary school within the district that was never done what I would like to see is something similar to that put on the table I don't have a problem paying another $500 $600 a year for the kids and if the school is willing to allow that to keep Ashby then I think we should look at it unfortunately the town select board reacted again too quick like they did last time when they wanted the public safety they said we'll get to the school committee request of what needs to be done and they never did um so they reacted and they took all the money out from the a um the funds and what

005they did which is really sad is they gave it to the highway department and the Police Department of Public Safety both of them combined with $700,000 that would have been a lot of work for the school if they had done it just putting it into the school but instead they reacted and then they took more money out of what they were going to do um and that's what's sad about this whole problem they the originally when the school when the public safety was going to go in the argument that we were given by the supporters was they were in Ashby more than they were out those younger kids now they're going to be out more than they're in because we have no school which is wrong we should have addressed the kids first not worried

006about people having a big building for at the time it was only four people which is sad $9 million building um and and that what I'm wondering is if the motion can come up Brad if you're willing to consent to half of the school being redone and keeping it I think we should look at it um and that would be because they're already looking at doing a Grange hall and they're putting up they're putting out bids for over a million $2 million for that why not do this for the school for the kids that's my answer sorry taking I took more than my time no you were okay Pat thank you Pat the next speaker is Shelly Jones Shelley just state your name and address please yep Shelly Jones Ash bass um good evening I

007think it would be beneficial for the school committee and superintendent to understand the long bus rides you are suggesting by moving Ashby and townzen middle school students to peil I hope hope that you request debus to set up a trial bus route from the furthest away home to nitis middle school so that you can all experience firsthand what you are asking of our students the decision to bus students further away from their homes and communities should not be taken lightly and all efforts should to understand the impact on students social and emotional well-being should be considered this decision is more than just longer bus times it's less time at home in participating in after school activities it's further drives for parents to pick up and drop off kids for appointments the winter weather difference between

008Ashby and peil is significant these are just to name a few of the challenges parents and caregivers will face with this decision all of these issues need to be considered and addressed before a final decision to move middle school students to peil is made thank you thank you Shelly the next speaker is Melissa boand Melissa just state your name and address please sure um good evening my name is Melissa boand 1392 West State Road in Ashby um good evening thank you for the opportunity to speak I just have two brief things I wouldn't even go through minutes um the first is in conversations with other families in the district I've been having I'm hearing a lot of them say even if the override is voted for there's no guarantee that schools will remain open now

009I'm not sure who they are um however since you guys are the decision makers I think it would be great if you could put out some clarifying information either way um because the uncertainty of those statements will impact voting um and then the second thing I just wanted to check in on is um I know a lot of public of the public asked for it at the budget hearing um and then I along with others had sent emails um it was great that you were able to provide us with the potential cost Savings of Plan B building closures but I think we're all still looking for um potential costs assuming that there's onetime costs to get buildings ready um to handle the reconfiguration I mean I'm ass and again no one should assume but there

010might be changes needed to a middle school to handle the younger Learners um and then any potential reoccurring costs I know decisions hadn't been made about school start times but you know would there be would the tears of the busing system change do we need to have additional bus rides I know um Shelley just spoke about like the longer bus rides but due to ridership and time on the bus will additional buses be made um I am assuming again we know what that happens um that you had that information when you voted for the school closures so it would be great if that could be made public that would just have an impact so again um thank you for your time thank you Melissa next speaker is krie Battersby batterby Carrie just state your name

011and address please hi good evening guys I'm Carrie back be I live at 391 Frost Road in Ashby um actually some of my concerns were already addressed by previous parents um I do just have just a quick thing about I know you guys did a press conference and I know that Brad has been reaching out to the state and with an override looming which I believe you guys said during the financial budget meeting that it would possibly be in April are we going to have any information as to what the state has said or will there be any decisions before we have to vote on the override I think that would be kind of important too for voting for the voter base too just to see where we're at um and that's pretty much all

012I have to say thank you so much thank you krie and there were no other public comments correct Robin that came in last minute I didn't see any all right moving on to the reports um our student representative report we're not having one tonight she um Meredith could not make it for a chairperson's report I do have one request that everyone please there was a spreadsheet sent out of available times that people could make potential meetings for our school committee please fill that out as time is becoming very important and that everyone on the school committee can attend these important meetings that are going to be about the budget and over to the superintendent's report yes I so I will address mine um later on in the meeting with uh goals and other topics on

013the agenda okay all right we have as new business we have outof State field drip trip request by Miss Smith or Mrs Smith is she on I believe she is yeah I just promoted her so okay give her a few minutes okay thank you okay Lori go ahead hello um so new uh we have our New York Service Learning um program is looking to go back to New York uh sorry New Orleans um and there's 36 students in seven um chaperon that are looking to go during April vacation they've done this for many years and it's kind of the same itinerary they don't know exactly where they will be helping out yet because that happens a couple months beforehand based on the people in New Orleans trying to figure out what what their needs are

014so their requests is to be approved to be able to go out of state and to go on this trip again any questions or comments from the committee I know that this is a great experience for several of our kids and I was actually talking to someone in the community and they had said something about the new New Orleans Service Learning and how their kids had gone on it so it was very enlightening chair Randy I move we vote the school committee approve the North Middle sex Regional High School students trip to New Orleans from April 18th to April 25th oh okay so we have will and Randy yeah and I was just going to say that I I know many many students that have gone on the New Orleans trip and I have not

015heard one bad thing about the experience I know parents that have chaperoned it um and um it is it really enriches the children's lives um it's it's a wonderful trip if uh people have the opportunity and the means to do that any other questions before we take a vote all right we will go with Will Hackler yes Lisa Bloom yes Bill yes June yes Randy yes and myself all right and the next topic you have as well Mrs Smith it's the program of studies for the high school so um I'm here to present if you would like or just go over the changes that we're going to the program studies or answer any questions it it's kind of how you would like to do it we do have some change the pro program studies and

016uh I don't know if you want me to go over those if you want me to go Department by Department what would you like H well it depends on how long we want to make this meeting highlights would be great highlights let's do highlight so just a couple changes in the program studies this year that we um are we're looking at enhancing what our students can their offerings and what they can choose from and also looking about what kids are looking for into college and what they're trying to Aspire to in their careers so there's some classes that have been taken out um but not because that we're not pre-lingual for kids for the electives a lot of times we have all these offerings but we only have one or one section and the kids

017who want it can't always get into it because it doesn't fit into their schedule so with some of our electives we're now changing to every other year and we're putting that in the program studies saying exactly what year it's going to be so that way students can plan so they'll have two chances to take the class and that way we'll have more sections one year so the kids who want it hopefully will be able to get it and get into their schedule and you'll see that that throughout the program studies that's a lot of the department shairs have done that this year so we can make sure the kids get what they're looking for um one of the main things in the English Department that's being added this year um is What's called the unified

018into the future course so we are a big inclusion school and we have a great Athletic program with the unified um unified course things we have offer here so we're now going to add some classes during the day called for unified into the future this is a class that's going to be joined both special ed students and um Regular ed students and where they're going to learn about you know just different things that are out there and how kind of like get some skills to be successful um and just just prepare for Life After grad like after graduation Beyond and it's great to to see them working together in this it's going to be the same kind of best buddies model that we have for UniFi basketball UniFi track in our new unified strength and

019conditioning so that class is going to be new this year we're only going to offer one section of that because we want to make sure it's successful and we're still getting this from the you know the ground up so that's uh one of their new offerings um and looking in also our Performing Arts uh section when we have two new teachers to our building not new to the profession and they're looking at changing some of the offerings we have in the music and the Performing Arts area to get more students into the music program and not not exactly performing but just into the the courses and trying to get learn a little bit more about music so we've made some additions to you know history of the some history of the history of jazz music

020technology which is and Sound Engineering which a lot of our students are interested in um and we're bringing back stagecraft and we're just going to revamp what what we're going to do for our curriculum for that um when we look at the physical education department we're also um bringing a unified course there called unified learn practice play exact same thing is that it's going to be based on the best best buddies model in our other Unified sports we have here and it's all about meeting health and wellness curriculum and allowing students who know always go into the regular class spit fed classes to allow them to do that but at a modified version with some of our other students that's going to help them along we really think those two courses in English and PE

021is going to bridge the gap even more um about Unified sports and inclusion and we have a lot of students that are very excited about looking forward to taking this when we started talking about it um in the science department same thing as we've done a lot of every other year type thing um we brought back astronomy we have a lot of students that are interested in that so that's going to be a um halfe course we've also introduced a new course called marine biology um marine biology and animal behavior will go every other year we have a lot of students that look to take marine biology after school will go to college for that and we have a lot of students that take marine biology as a VHS course so now we're bringing it

022into um the school and hoping we get a really great turn up for that um see what else social studies we just um changed our course description about engaging our community we had a lot of students that were interested that want to do stuff about our community um the teacher that's looking to teach it is actually going to use our TV media studio um to try to do some videos and engage our community so we're looking forward out to see how that turns out um special education department we're changing our the way we do our academic assistance class right now it's an inclusion class and that's how some of our students on IEPs receive their services that they need other students take that as they just need some extra help so instead of having it

023all together as one we're um kind of splitting it up a little to make sure the students that are in certain classes for academic assistant are the students on iups so we can make sure that their IEPs are falling and they're getting the service you need why we're still going to have a course called academic Essentials which will be um an in an in inclusion um Services regarding how how we do different things and how we help students so that's just a little split that we're making this year we're going to try it and see how that works and um make sure that we're all we're all good for the students and what they need that's kind of the overall everything else is pretty much staying the same um then the math department we are

024making the one change too we're taking out um Algebra 1 and geometry as we're moving away from having different different levels in that aspect and all just going to algebra and geometry for all students having College Prep or accelerated and go to Algebra 2 geometry at the college prep and the um the accelerated so we started that this past year and it's working well so now we're just taking it to the next grade level any questions that was a lot I apologize it was a good summary you have a lot of things there's a lot of offerings any questions any concerns all right does someone want to make the motion to accept the program of study please chair I move we vote uh to approve the 2025 2026 North middlex High School program is studies

025as presented second oh second June got June beat you Bill okay so it was Will and June all right but I will start with you for the vote Bill yes Lisa Bloom yes will Hackler yes Randy Ros yes Jun Neil yes and myself yes all right thank you thank you Mrs Smith and congratulations on being announced to the principal at the high school we are very pleased with that and or I am pleased with that I can't answer for the committee but thank you so all right moving on we are going to the 2025 2026 School District calendar Brad did you want to present this sure sorry just going between screens I opened up the calendar and didn't mute myself or didn't unmute myself sorry about that so just going back to this this is

026something that we started on uh at this point probably about four weeks ago um and obviously looking to begin the school year in August as we have in years past graduate the first Friday in June whenever possible and just like this past year excuse me just like this current year we are minimizing the number of uh professional development uh whether it be late start or early release days uh so that we're able to maximize our time with students this has been looked at by the Teachers Association and again it's it's very similar to years past um you will see a number of release days on there but four of them are for parent teacher conferences which has been consistent in years past um and then also a handful of days for uh teacher professional development

027on top of that but overall if you were to compare North Middle sex to other districts our early release time whether it be half days or late starts um are really limited compared to other districts but again we like it because it does maximize students um time in the class and also you know maintains consistency from from one month to the next because I can get a little choppy if you have too many um too much release time so certainly open to questions on my calendar anyone I know that we had the two and a half hour start this week I can tell you that I had to ask several times on what time school actually started because that half hour throws me but we're good and honestly just if people aren't aware the reason

028we do the late start in the winter as opposed to the early release is that if you have an early release and we had to do a two-hour delay because of weather you'd have to cancel the entire day whereas doing a twoh hour or two and a half hour late start excuse me um allows us to call a delay if weather um calls for it and still get a half day of schooling regardless anyone else have any comments and I know around December the December the the um vacation time um the dates where we're not coming back on the second we're going to extend it right where it's just coming back for one day this year you know there were a handful of districts this year um that came back uh excuse me that that

029did not come back for Thursday Friday the majority of the school districts in the state did come back Thursday Friday um where New Year's was on a Wednesday but next year when New Year's was on a Thursday coming back on a Friday doesn't seem to make a whole heck of a lot of sense where it's just one day so uh recommending that we're allowing uh families just to get a little bit of extra time in together and then restarting on January 5th the Monday if there aren't any more questions I will take a motion to approve the 2025 2026 school calendar CH I move the that we approve the 2025 2026 School District calendars presented will and Randy second all right we will June I will start with you yeah billberg yes Lisa Bloom yes

030will hackin yes Randy Rous yes and myself yes right now we are moving on to Dr Reese from the curriculum office good evening everyone can you see my screen yes okay um so as you may be aware back in November there was a ballot question regarding the mcast testing and whether we would continue to use it as a competency determination um as part of graduation requirements um the ballot question as a result of that they took out and I've got the language in here which I'm not going to read completely but essentially the competency determination in order for students to receive a diploma they have to meet both our local graduation requirements so and I I'll show that on a subsequent slide but we have a series of requirements as well as competency determination which

031is really just a determination that students have met what we would consider grade grade 10 level standards in English language arts Math and Science and technology and the way the state had been determining competency was through the mcast that no longer is an option and so the language of measured by an assessment instrument has been replaced by satisfactorily completing coursework that each district determines Rises to that level of um certifying that students meet those grade level standards in grade 10 um so there's been a lot of discussion both from the superintendent group I'm sure from the school committee Association as well as just between districts on how each district is going to handle this um and what the state has asked us to do is come up with a short-term solution for those students that

032are in are currently trying to graduate and how they're going to meet competency a midlevel determination for those students in class of 2026 and then a long-term solution for the students moving on as well as prior school years so this evening I'm going would like to share what we would like to propose as our short-term solution and seek school committee approval for us to move forward with that where there is some immediacy need to to have for students that are trying to make competency for this year and then ask that the school committee refer the proposals which we're still trying to flesh out for 2026 and Beyond uh back to policy because there are some policy implications and also to the administration just to have some further discussion as we continue to get feedback and

033um support from the state so in terms of action steps the there's the Board of Education they've got they need to make adjustments to their regulations that refer um currently refer to the mcast as the competency determination within the within the regulation language there is a section that says they might add on additional requirements so we're waiting to see if the board of education does add any additional requirements which we would obviously need to comply with uh the department of Elementry and secondary education they're no longer issuing competency determination and we're waiting to see if they provide some further guidance for districts on how to best identify competency um and then for our level at the district level we need to develop a policy so that goes to the school committee on local competency determination

034requirements and we're also looking for further guidance as well on just making sure that we're doing it and doing it um with with intention um this slide just shares and this is accessible on the district website as well as in the high school in the handbook you can see the graduation requirements so again at the local level students had to meet this graduation requirement they also had to meet the competency determination um at the state level in order to receive a diploma um so what we're looking at for the students we have a handful of students who um first the pathway one is that they've taken and passed the mcass so most of our students for the class of 2425 have met the mcast or the competency determination requirement through passing the mcast so they're

035all set we do have a handful of students that um did not pass it and we're planning to take the retest options which no longer are available for students to use towards mcast uh competency determination so what we're looking at for this year for those students is that they've completed two years of English two years of math and a lab science completed and successfully passed um so that's what we'd be seeking tonight for school committee approval um to move forward for this school year and then in terms of that mid option this is a class of 2026 again this is just our Min Ary thinking we still want to work it through with the school committee policy subcommittee and also at the administration level but those students some of them will have already passed taken

036the mcast and passed because they took it in their sophomore year and their freshman year um pathway two for students um that didn't pass the mcast testing that they've completed a couple English courses a couple math courses and a lab science um and then looking at a pathway three which is something that some districts are exploring at this point that involves a um compet competency determination assessment panel so these may be students that took two years of English or two years of math but it might have been a lower level course um as well as a lower level lab science and doing some type of portfolio submission so that we'll be able to determine and assess that they've met grade level standards for at at that minimum threshold of grade 10 again it still needs

037to be flushed out but this is just what we're initially thinking and what we're seeing from many of the other districts that are also exploring this um other districts are also exploring what we do for students from classes of 2003 to 2023 um who may not have received their diploma because they didn't meet the competency determination of the mcast and perhaps we're looking at some type of potential of doing a transcript review and working through the competency determination um assessment panel as well and then moving into the class of 2027 and Beyond these are students that have not taken the mcast well we have um they may have taken the science mcast in grade nine so we'll have to flush that out but um this is similar to the pathway two and three that you

038saw for class of 2026 that they had the two years of English and math um and the one year of science at a certain um um level College preper accelerated or that they've um have those years of um instruction and submit a portfolio and work through the competency determination panel um so really what we're what we're looking for tonight is approval from the school committee for the students um for the short-term plan for the students in classes of 24 and 25 again it's a very small group of students um that that this would be applicable for because a majority of them have met competency through the mcast already um and then referring the second thing that I'm looking for is just referring this back to the policy subcommittee for further review and discussion as well

039as waiting kind of import that we're going to hopefully get from the state on this that is the competency thank you Dr ree um any questions U not really a question I just wanted to say thank you very much for being so thoughtful with the students with this major change that they um got thrown at us um I think it's great that we're working with the students to make sure um that they are meeting competency and have a way to graduate so thank you for that and uh look forward to working this out on the policy subcommittee thank you anyone else have any questions I do have a question Dr ree um would they ever replace it with some kind of other test so I my assumption is they would have to go back on

040a ballot question because they've changed the the statute to take out using an assessment so we couldn't even as a district say that we want to use an assessment tool to make that determination because that that would be contrary to what was voted on in November okay makes sense any other questions does someone want to make a motion chair the short term yep uh I motion that the committee accept the short-term compy determination proposal as permitted excuse me as presented and then refer the other part back to the sub commit to the uh policy committee for review second seconds all right so that was Bill and Lisa all right Randy Ros yes uh Jun McNeil L the bloom yes billberg yes and will hack yes all right on to the next one I know that

041we're taking off the farming one yes we can hold on that until next meeting um and then the other item that I had this evening was just a quick uh highlight of the Strategic plan work we're doing um we have been um starting a strategic plan working group group to review the plan that was approved by the school committee at the beginning of the school year and to just start to really re-evaluate and assess what do those um initiatives and actions actually mean making sure that we all have a common understanding and that it's clear what we're looking to do what adjustments we might need to make just based on uh current budgetary constraints um and um how to move forward in terms of just making sure that everyone has voice and has been involved

042in the process we in December had an introductory meeting where we just my I highlighted just went over did an overview of what the Strategic plan looked like um on January 8th we had a meeting where it really was a working group where they we focused on the climate culture and Community strategic initiative and got some feedback from the people that were there we also put out a survey that went out to every one um it also went to the um we asked the libraries as well as the senior centers if they would share that information with uh their consentuous and we've given hard copies as well that we're going to be making sure we're just hoping to see that we can get access and opportunity for feedback from everyone um our next meeting will

043be on January 22nd at 6: pm. um if those meetings do happen at the high school and they really need to happen in person because of the nature of how we're structuring the meetings um in order to get everyone's feedback and input um but I would encourage and welcome anyone to participate and attend it's it was a lot of fun on the eth I think the people that attended enjoyed it and I'm looking forward to increased participation at the next one I do have a question how many people attended the first meeting and your second meeting so the first meeting it was virtual and I so don't know the exact number I wasn't I was presenting I wasn't controlling that um but the meeting the Jan January 8th working group meeting we had 16 people

044attend and there were representatives from all three member communities which was nice to see um and we had um a student there that attended um so it I'm hoping that it'll continue to grow but even if I recognize that some people may not be able to attend those meetings so that's why we're also putting out the survey so that if you're not able to attend you still have an opportunity to give some feedback it's a large task Karen it it is but it's important and I think it's it's helpful for um hopefully helpful for the community members that attend to be able to see kind of the work that went into the process as well as still having a voice as we move forward thank you does anyone have any questions yes to confirm that

045was said so January 22nd is the next meeting yes and I there will be a um tomorrow we're sending out a reminder for that as well as the registration link and we just ask that people register because that helps us know kind of the groups that we're going to plan and coordinate great and thank you and we also have to be careful as a committee to so that we don't get a quorum there or so so do register let me know if you're going to be attending I'll keep you posted on that good point okay anyone else have any questions there is nothing we had to vote on for this right just an update now we will go back thank you Dr Reese now we are going to public records request Robin is going to

046give an update on this area well I just wanted to um let the committee know that um we're seeing a significant increase year-over-year for public records requests um in 2024 we um we received 54 requests compared to 32 in 2023 and 34 in 2022 uh the increase represents a 70% increase over 2023 and a 68% increase over 2022 and uh while these requests are initially are submitted to the records access officer uh many require the efforts of multiple staff members to gather the necessary information um and the process involves identifying the requested records reviewing them for sensitive information and then making them available to the requestor um it often requires coordination between different departments and can be very time assuming um it many times we need to uh to refer to our legal council so

047um the requests place a strain on our district resources diverting attention from regular responsibilities incurring additional costs um the rise in these public records requests reflect the growing demand for transparency but it also emphasizes the need for adequate resources to manage these efforts without affecting the district's primary functions um and I also wanted to share that as of January 1st we've received four public records requests um in this early increase uh requests further underscores the ongoing demand for transparency and the continued need for efficient management of the inquiries all right thank you Robin any questions comments all right we will move on to the next one is IB you have this one as well Communications and public relations yeah so I just I wanted to share with the um the committee some of the highlights

048um and the you know the things that we've been working on over the past year I won't go through the whole report I shared it with you in your packet um but um I think when we put it down in paper we're talking about but when we put it down it it it really showcases the efforts that's going into um sharing the the uh success stories of our students and our staff uh with our community and helping the community better understand um what it is that our our students are doing and um the difference that it's making so you know you you're going for it you'll be able to see the um the difference in this the social media growth um you know our media placements and um some of the the the different things

049the annual district report that we put out uh the new District website that was launched last year and the efforts that went into that uh the uh budget portal website um which has received over 25,000 visits uh since it it it launched um all the budget development presentations that um that were held last year um helping to educate the community on the budget process and um and understanding uh the funding formula Etc and um the press conference that we held and then all the the press releases that were um written and published uh last year so I thought it would be um nice for you all to see see it in writing and and see what's happening from that perspective it's a lot it's a lot good stuff it is good stuff and it's and

050it's shown some positive things for us too which is great for our district and showcases our district and our students and our staff so thank you for the work on this and and the other people that help to participate in getting the public relations done any questions on this piece all right we will keep moving on we are on to the superintendent goals for 2024 25 sure uh so thank you in the past um sometimes I've gone over the goals other times I have not uh does it make sense that I just uh go over the goals just the um I guess the main goal and um I can do the key actions too I mean I'll do do whatever the committee would like but I can certainly just present the three goals as is

051and leave the action steps out to questions if there are questions I'll do whatever the committee would like here the highlights please I already read it so okay sure so again um state of Massachusetts requires superintendant to set forth two to four smart goals annually I do have three to present to the committee the first one is a district Improvement goal which is coaching Andor working with the new high school principal where I'm working directly from the high school this year as an additional administrator to help coach Miss Smith um and this is in part due to some of the budgetary considerations that we looked at coming into this year as well but overall overall my goal is to successfully Mentor Miss Smith um during the next several months we've been working well together as

052a team um since the summer and since she's been named um since she's been named the principal that that work continues we continue to work together on a daily basis and we were able to collaborate um pretty much throughout the day through a wide variety of things again whether it be through working on discipline issues educator evaluation um special education in and the budget even it it's been it's been a great experience so that is the first goal the second goal is also a district Improvement goal and that is working um again with the high school team um both um on site at the high school but also the central office team on the neas accreditation process that the high school will be going through U this coming year they will be coming to visit

053the high school in March and working on establishing three to five big priorities um as we again prepare for that site visit but also prepare for the next step in that accreditation process and the last goal is a student learning goal and again focused on the high school where I am there working with students um and supporting them in their engagement on the leadership and positive modeling opportunities through a variety activities I'll be engaging with and have been engaging with the students in since the beginning of the school year um I'll take questions if you have any questions on the key actions themselves but again it's it's two to four goals or are three here to present to the committee and um certainly open to feedback um Brad could you explain or Mr Morgan could

054you explain um neasc what it is for the public a little bit yes so so the neas accreditation process um that is it's a New England agency that accredits um it it really accredits all types of schools throughout New England uh private schools colleges um public high schools um so part of that process is that they will be coming to do a visit um in looking at things such as our strategic plan looking at the school Improvement plan looking our curriculum what we're offering the students um making sure that that we're doing what we need to do as a public high school in Massachusetts um to be a successful institution and they they are who accredits um North Middle sex Regional High School um as a high school I know oftentimes there you know people

055have talked about accreditation is the High School accredited the high school is accredited but it is something that comes up um for review on a fairly regular basis um and it's our it's our turn for a review and we are in we are in that process now and it is something truly that the entire um High School Community is involved in students have been surveyed parents have been surveyed staff have been surveyed um there are multiple groups of the high school who are working on um going through the self-reflection and identifying areas of strength areas of weakness and then all of that will be presented um when the neas team it's a it's a six-person team from people all over New England uh that will be visiting the school and determining where we stand uh

056with regard to not just being accredited but where we stand with regard to other public high schools in the Commonwealth all right thank you thank you for the explanation any questions from the committee on superintendent Morgan schs June um just a quick comment I do um understand and support all of these goals but I do notice that they're all very high school based which makes a lot of sense because superintendent Morgan is in the High School this year so um I do think that makes sense for this year um but perhaps next year we can go back to more overall District based um goals but but I I do understand this and this all does make sense so absolutely that that is certainly the plan thank you anyone else here a quick question Mr Morgan

057the U that the naesc accreditation is that similar to an audit or is it just a survey to accredit it actually in many ways it is similar to an audit I mean they're essentially coming in and I guess in some ways they're assessing Andor grading where we stand um in a variety of areas um and and they again they're looking at everything from uh pro programs Staffing um they're looking at uh curriculum offerings um and again those School Improvement the school Improvement plan how it relates to the district stct Improvement plan they're looking at a variety of aspects so in many ways it is like an audit but but it is not just for public high schools it's it's private high schools colleges go through this with neas as well um it's really a New

058England based organization thank you any more comments questions if not I can take a motion to approve I move to approve uh the superintendent's uh goals for 2020 or fy2 I'll second that is Randy andv will yes June yes is oh Lisa Bloon sorry everyone keep Randy R yes Bill yes and myself yes your goals are approved thank you for working on these all right now we're on to are we on to the North Middle sex band Yes all right and will has said that he will read this so but I'm going to let Nancy is going to explain what this is sure it's a it's really a quick um update this is a renewal ban for the high school the remaining High School borrowing and the accelerated repair borrowing we've been rolling this ban

059for quite a few years and this will um I think probably be our fourth or fifth maybe longer than that year of running rolling the band it goes out to bid and we received um five bids for the renewal the renewal is going to expire we're going to actually have this end in October with the hopes that the high school project the msba um close out is completed by October that that's the Hope um and then we would roll this into a more permanent borrowing not just a year-to-year ban um we got a really good interest rate we got just under 3% with our our renewal I think that the yet if anyone had any questions before we'll read the language okay go ahead will J I move the school committee vote we hereby determine

060in accordance with GL chapter 70b that the cost of the I new District High School project uh authorized by a vote of the committee past February 10th 2014 to vnam Brook School feasibility study project authorized by to vot of the committee pass September 12th 2016 three author and Brook School feasibility study project authorized by a vote of the committee passed on September 12th 2016 for varnam Brook Elementary School Renovations project authorized by a vote of the committee passed on September 12th 2016 five Hawthorne Brook School Renovations project authorized by a vote of the district passed on April 3rd 2017 and six Squan cook Early Childhood Center Renovations project authorized by a vote of the committee passed on April 3rd 2017 each being financed with proceeds of a portion of the notes defined below together with

061all other bonds and notes of the district previously issued to pay the cost of these projects does not exceed the portion of the total cost of the projects that are not being paid by the school facilities grants and and we hereby approve the issuance of notes and bonds to finance these projects under GL chapter 70b further voted to approve the sale of 17,9 $1,984 uh 4% General obligation Bond anticipation notes the notes of the districts dated January 30th 2025 and payable October 30th 2025 to tr a Securities Inc at par and acred interest if any plus a premium of $146,300 74 further voted that in connection with the marketing sale of the notes the preparation and distribution of a notice of sale and preliminary official statement dated December 30th 2024 and a final official statement

062dated January 8 2025 each in such form as may be approved by the district Treasurer beat and hereby are ratified confirmed approved and adopted further voted that the district CH Treasurer and the chair of the committee B and hereby are authorized to execute and deliver a significant events disclosure undertaken in compliance with the SEC rule 15c 2-12 in such form as may be approved by the bond Bond Council of the district which undertaking shall be incorporated by referencing the notes for the benefit of the holders of the notes from time to time further voted that we authorize and direct the district Treasurer to establish past issuance federal tax compliance procedures and continuing disclosure procedures as such forms as the district Treasurer and bond Council deem sufficient or if such procedures are currently in place to

063review and up State said procedures in order to Monitor and maintain the tax exemp status of the notes and to comply with the relative relevant Securities laws there further voted that any certificates or documents related to the notes collectively the documents may be executed in several counterparts Each of which shall be regarded as an original and all of which shall constitute one in the same document delivery of an executed counterpart of a signature page to a document by electronic mail in a PDF file or by other electronic transmission shall be as effective as delivery of a manually executed counterpart signature to such document electronic signatures of any documents shall be deemed original signatures for the purposes of the documents and all matters relating ther to having the same legal effect as original signatures further mode

064that each member of the committee the district secretary and the district Treasurer B and hereby are authorized to take any and all such actions and execute and deliver such certificates receipts or other documents as may be determined by them or any of them to be necessary or convenient to carry into effect the provisions of the forging votes well done seconda a second all right Randy yes June yes the yes Lisa yes will yes and myself yes the ban is and I was in yesterday and signed the papers and I think um thank the treasur was coming in today right yes yeah we're all set all set okay I am going to skip back um it wasn't highlighted the school committee goals I Randy and I had had a discussion about the school committee goals and

065that we are going to move this to a future meeting is that correct Randy that we're moving into a future meeting yeah um I actually think uh we're kind of past the point that the school committee is really gonna be able to get some good goals going and we don't have a great process we've been trying to do this for a couple of years to get a good process and get good goals that relate back to the Strategic plan with everything going on with the budget right now I think getting a process in place and setting them in at near our organizational meeting for the following year probably is going to be much more worthwhile than trying to um quickly come to some goals right now is everybody on the committee okay with that any

066concerns I see everyone shaking their head they are all good with not setting goals this year all right thank you all right moving on we are on to Old business there's no actions under old business we are moving to sub commmittee reports there's no report from the ashb elementary building committee no report from The Accelerated repairs building committee we are on to finance I'm handing that to will thank you uh [Music] um I mean not did we want to cover anything on 2025 I didn't think I had anything Nancy Brad not in 2025 other than it's just very tight at this point um you know the administrative team met today uh special education um numbers are continuing to climb um especially with regard to a District placement and we've had to add staff over the

067course of the year as well to remain in compliance so um again that's that's something that we're going to have to carefully monitor uh also we'll likely be talking to the finance committee about a potential U budget freeze um at some point early on in the spring but even that a lot of that is not within our control because of contractual obligations and and things of that nature so this it really would not freeze up a lot of money but it would it would freeze up some to potentially help with um some of our increases again in that area of special education but it certainly is not going to solve the problem good on the 2026 so we have the budget hearing the joint committee is coming up February 6 2025 um for discussion there

068on that that um I'll go down a couple just you know quickly run through a couple of the pieces here so uh finance committee got together last week we were looking at you know some items for uh one-time use of funds um the first thing we dug into was the solar project so uh the high school um you know we have the solar that's on the high school there we have the option to buy those out um just a you know quick comment Terry there is that uh we looked at that there's still some pieces we still need to learn on it uh but generally the cost of buying it out the cost at this point would be uh $542,000 uh right now we're spending $30,000 a year so our payback ISS in that 18-year

069R range uh with some unknown factors so at this point the finance committee is not recommending you know using any one-time funds for the solar project the turf field lease uh if we want to use some one-time funds there is some savings there the the buyout would probably be in the $350,000 range I say probably just because it's based on timing um each quarter uh we have a you know we could potentially buy that out 350 is the next one that's coming up that's uh possible in that direction savings because we are spending uh $93,000 a qu uh a year uh would save us about $25,000 in interest costs if we were to take some one-time funds um and buy out the turf field um the other issue that came up uh which we're recommending

070um really for the full school committee here on a vote side of it is that the peil rec department is talking about making some changes to the tennis courts located behind varnam Brook um and uh Patrick uh MC Phillips volunteered to be the liaison with the peal wreck um to work on that uh whether that's feasible you know obviously you know take that down do something else with that area so um our recommendation to the full committee here on this just be that we appoint Patrick as Lea on to the pil wreck to work on that uh situation and come back to us with some recommendations any questions I have a one quick question the $225,000 um interest on the um the turfield is that for the term of the um of the lease or

071is that an annual interest pay it'd be for the remaining term so we pay roughly $93,000 a year the buyout right now would be uh roughly $350,000 which would end up with a $25,000 Randy yeah I just want to add along with the $25,000 in savings uh right now uh $93,000 is being used from some revolving funds and that frees those revolving funds to actually be used uh back in the budget so essentially it's $93,000 for next year that we can reduce um the budget or add more Revenue to the budget um for next year um so that's another added benefit to the 25,000 overall any more questions anyone want to make a motion we'll start with the Patrick mcf Phillips as a Le on wreck yeah I mve to appoint um Patrick the Phillips

072as the Le leaon second second so that is billberg and Willam H will yes Lisa Bloom yes Bill yes J mcne yes uh Randy Rous yes and myself yes right so Patrick has approved on the turf field Le and I mean I um not looking added motion or vote on this one yet I'm just saying if we get to the point on the budget of using onetime funds that the finance committee would recommend that that would be a good use of one-time funds I guess that gets us back to the 26 budget discussion Morgan sure um so again really really not much has changed um I I believe I notified the committee at the last meeting that that I've been put on a small task force with um with Mars in Project 211 uh to

073work on um trying to make some inroads with the state I do actually have a phone call scheduled tomorrow with uh Michelle licio who's the Ed policy analyst for the uh speaker Mariano um who I have been trying to get in touch with um they did get back to me yesterday and asked me for my availability on Friday which I told them I would make myself available at any point over the course of the day um I still have not heard back from her since that email I responded immediately um to the email so I am hoping um to to get the opportunity to get the speaker's ear at some point over the next couple of weeks based on based on my conversations with representative Scarsdale and and Senator Cronin um I am hearing that

074the Senate would be in favor of looking at Regional funding it's really the house um which is the obstacle at this point in time and and the person that really controls the house would be the speaker so I I think it would be beneficial to hopefully get a conversation with him explain the situation that we're in because I although I I I know that they realize it was struggling I don't think they fully realize why we're struggling and again this is not a North Middle sex problem in speaking with uh rep Scarsdale today um our problem mirror uh gd's problems um so it is something um you know Pentucket Triton other Regional School Districts with similar makeups to NM are struggling across the state and what we really need to do is get their ear

075on the funding formula and looking at some of these partially funded mandates and how we can be supported more um even the project 211 piece uh there's a lot of schools in that project 211 um that are doing really really well uh financially um and again although they're held harmless they're in a very different financial situation than a lot of the regional school districts are in the state so again that's been a goal of mine I've been trying to get um the speaker's ear for a couple of months now um and I'm hoping that I make some positive inroads on that tomorrow and just correct me if I'm wrong Nancy but our next big piece with this is the governor's numbers come out by the end of the month yes I think they actually I

076suspect by the 23rd or 24th we should have most likely the Chapter 70 workbook which has a lot of the information we need in order to go forward with our calculations for towns and um the assessments and will you do have a you have scheduled a finance meeting January 28th am I correct thanks for I don't remember what that is but yes sure I think that's when it is Robin Robin stepped away for a minute but I think we got that put on I'm here yes it is it's scheduled for the 28th okay all right okay that's see it for my section all right anything else all right we are moving on to policy Randy um with the FY 26 uh budget just wanted to go back to that sorry I was a little slow

077on raising my hand um we gonna go I thought we I don't know if it's in a different section but I thought we were going to go over some uh other possible um uh configurations or um options for uh the budget and changes not at this point I mean I think you know all of our you know so much of our stuff is estimates the next step we were waiting for is some of these Governor's numbers and we can look at it at that point with the finance with the finance meeting I think Randy would be a better discussion of some of that and figure out it's not listed on our agenda tonight for more of that um I do know that we're going for and that's where I think the finance committee needs to

078come up with the override amount that we're going to be asking and that budget piece of it I'm probably not wording it correctly I don't know yeah I I I understand that um but I I guess I misunderstood the email that came out that we were going to be talking about some other options and that time was kind of of the essence uh that we start um trying to come up I mean if we're going to change anything we need to change it as soon as possible um and I'm I I guess I'm you know you're talking almost two weeks now before the finance goes and um I'm not sure when the next school committee meeting is after that that we all have to vote on that so all of a sudden everything is slowing

079down and I'm not sure why I mean if it's all right I mean I have a little update on the liaison portion of this I can you know that is somewhat relevant here if you want me to share on that side go go ahead so um I am in been invited and I'm uh attending the Townsen uh selectman meeting next Tuesday uh to talk about some more of this stuff and part of that discussion is certainly timing of um you know as far as the getting a vote in this spring for the override so that's part of the discussion I think you know from the three towns what we're hearing you know they'd like to do it at the same day right now I think you know sort of penciling in something in March 10th

080time frame um to get all those meetings scheduled at the same time obviously coming up we have the budget hearing February 6th where we're going to come down with some firmer numbers to just you know to hand out to those Town Representatives at that point so so between Tuesday in my spot of you know talking with towns and Selectmen we have our finance committee the following week and then our budget hearing the week after that okay um then I'm going to ask Brad um I guess I'm confused that uh that some other options were not are not being brought up tonight that I thought were going to be brought up okay um so as as far as the other options that is still something that we are working on and that we're continuing to work

081on but at this point I think there was an issue because of the fact that we did not have the full committee that voted the last time to discuss it I mean I'm sorry one more time that we didn't have the full committee to vote what or to discuss these options on there tonight that we don't have tonight so there's not the full committee as we had several members not in attendance um is there any way that we can maybe discuss them and then not vote on anything tonight but uh it gives it if we bring it up tonight then we can have possible feedback from uh the communities oh Jun we do have a quorum of members right now so I don't think having every member necessarily comes into play since Tom hasn't has

082only been at one meeting in the past year or the past um year of of this committee um since May so to try to hold to wait for a member doesn't that seem right I say at the very least we've never held up talking about things because members can't make a meeting I think talking about it but voting I think we want to be careful because of voting on any option without representation can cause issues am I in agreement with people with that that I mean I don't think we've ever worried about it in the past but I understand that this is a larger decision than we've made in the past yeah uh but again uh you're avoiding talking about the and bringing this up for anybody to understand it and for us the ones

083that could make the meeting tonight be able to at least start the discussions Jim uh just one more comment I think this is part of the transparency piece that um has been discussed where you know there are kind of emails going back and forth and conversations happening but not happening in a public unit so I think if you want to reduce records requests this is one of the ways to do it by having an open discussion with everybody in a public meeting um Brad do you want to put for the option sure uh so an option that was being considered and just again really just in full transparency we um this is something that we've been looking at it's not something that that we ever stopped looking at we we're always looking at options because

084we never truly know what's going to happen with the budget until the governor's numbers come out and um we get a little bit more clarity um and then you know looking at the whole override piece but in looking at it um one of the options uh that a a group of us worked on at central office would be an option that would maintain um an operational Ashby Elementary School um and uh the group um and again it was it was a small group but but we did feel that the best way to go about it would be looking at um really one of two options um first option would be similar to what we currently have um except Ashby would be K to five um and with that um you know there there's certainly issues

085with that because it it doesn't address class size Equity um and it does create that issue where because you only have one or two sections of a grade level in a school and not much space if you go to two sections across the board um K to five and there's not much there's not much space after that and then you have the two sections say in grade three Eclipse 29 and go to 30 there's really no place to put that third section because it's one or two sections K to five and the same thing would would potentially hold true if you kept it K to 4 there's just not a lot of flexibility with one to two sections where when you're looking at Spalding and haw and Brook you've got four in some cases six

086sections and there's a lot of flexibility if you have students moving in to break into another section if need be um just because of the number of sections so it would be Ashby k to5 um all of Ashby um Squan cook would be prek districtwide K to3 Town Hawthorne Brook would be four to five Town 6 to8 Ashby tent um so U really again moving grade five to ashb Elementary um as opposed to just having it be K to four if that makes sense um potential savings um or I should say the potential or projected enrollment for Ashby would be 186 right now it's around 140 um and the potential Savings in staff would be about four um FTE because you'd be merging um emerging some grade levels so there would be a built-in Savings

087in staff which would lead to some reductions automatically through attrition um the other option would be really a pretty significant change um and this is where it kind of gets at the number of sections by making it somewhat similar to the other schools um in this one would have Ashby Elementary DEC to one all of Ashby all of Townsend um so it's not West Townson it's not a section of Townsen it's Ashby Elementary would essentially become an early childhood K to1 all of Ashby all of Townson and then Squan cook would maintain the prek districtwide and then would be two to four Ashby Townson all of Ashby all of Townson hathor and Brook would remain the same grades 5 through eight Ashby Townson again this makes the the enrollment numbers a little bit more balanced

088where Ashby would go from 140 students to 204 again this these are just projections um potential Savings in staff rather than it being four would be upwards of seven again through attrition and merging grade levels and balancing class sizes um it has a um a couple of other benefits as well and again I realize this is somewhat of a radical change but um some of the benefits would be um the way it would work is if you had grades 2 to eight at Squan cook in hawtho and Brook that would essentially be a campus so the K to one in Ashby of Ashby and Townson would be a tier a busing tier so that would be you know again that first tier the second tier would be a drop off um at Squan cook for

089two to four and then a subsequential drop off at Hawthorne Brook so you would have students in Ashby and Townson grade 2 to8 on the bus together maintaining a singular tier because they're on the same campus um and not adding a tier which would add money um to the districts budget by adding a fourth tier um and then the third tier would be the high school so that maintains a three- tier system um again the the rationale would be to still keep the prek and at Squan cook and not move it to Ashby because maintaining one of the critical pieces of the prek program is that when you're looking at um you have to have a plus one of typical students versus special education students um in the prek program so when you're looking at

090a class of 13 prek students six of them are on IEPs and seven of them are typical having the pre program be centrally located for typical students where they're being driven in most cases by their parents so they excuse me they're being driven in all cases by their parents makes it uh gives us a better opportunity to remain a balanced program um there's also some built-in um assistance with this in that we would be merging the Ashby and Townson students immediately at grade k um so they would be um you know meshed basically and um you know know each other uh very well prior to getting to Middle School which may be helpful um this change does not impact the structure at hawthor and brook or the Middle School uh for for ashb students and

091to me if this is an option that goes forward I I feel as though it would eliminate the what has become the annual ashb question um because it's not one or two sections 140 kids in the building now you're looking at 204 students in the building the building would be full um and you would have multiple sections of kindergarten again three to five and three to five sections of first grade um which would allow for again that balancing between uh throughout the district um but also the ability to have some flexibility with that number of sections if that makes sense this would obviously um you know anything along these lines would require um the school committee to take action on policy jca which is the student assignment of school assignment to schools um and then

092we obviously have to look at um you know other aspects um of the of the lease of Ashby Elementary School but that that would certainly be an option um you know I I I would say that in full transparency that um that the group that worked on this feel as though the option I just described would be the most beneficial to the district because again it it it fills the buildings um it balances um class sizes across the district and I again I think it makes if if you're looking to keep a viable Elementary School in Ashby this this option fills it it fills the school it doesn't have vacant classrooms other than the other than the vacated WI questions Randy or Lisa which one first or who go ahead Randy okay uh first I'd

093like to say thank you to um superintendent Morgan and your team for continuing to look at uh the issues that face the district and the best educational um opportunity for the students in face of this um budget crisis uh that we're trying to navigate so thank you very much for um keep keeping the options open and finding new ways um one thing I wanted to bring up is I did a a little bit of an analysis based on the school capacities that were given to us um and the projected enrollments uh with the different um options that we had the option that we already voted on before for that closed both Ashby Elementary and Walding Memorial and I was looking at percentage of the buildings that it that it would um occupy uh so basically

094how much free space we have uh there are some concerning numbers at varnam Brook and nisit um their enrollments would be projected at 684 and 702 uh which puts them right about uh 90% of capacity um and that is with really taking the special education programs that they have there and condensing them down to much smaller spaces than they're using right now I understand they are using larger spaces than what would be um normally afforded to them so uh because they're uh special education at small classrooms uh due to regulations and they're using a full classroom size um but it still does create other issues trying to consolidate those into you know twoin one room or however you do that um and having having just one or two classrooms or three classrooms in each of

095those buildings is very very concerning going forward for the future um you also have Haw on work would be close to 80% uh filled with that option of closing two schools um looking at the two options that you uh gave us tonight I too along with your Administration like the um the K to one at Ashby uh Elementary School um some addition reasons why I like that is it's bringing the two communities uh together earlier uh two communities are already joined uh with sports they do after school there's a lot of the after school um you know uh Tesa and tabs or two that I can think of right away this really kind of helps the communities come together a little bit earlier and for the kids to get to know each other better and

096move through all the different schools I think the savings that we have from busing um the two to grades 2 to eight um could possibly be uh some great Savings in that I know back in 2012 when we moved Ashby over to Squan cook for their um roof and windows project uh there was a savings in buses then when they were on the Middle School tier so I'm hoping when things work out here that we're going to see some bus savings as well which um is a nice savings that doesn't affect the education of the children um I think having you know like you said educationally this is probably the better option um whereas we have more um sections for Equity um and I I really would like to see much more work uh done

097on this option and brought back to the school committee hoping uh that it looks like a much better option uh than closing two schools um so that that is what I have to you know say so keep up the good work keep looking at that um great I would love to hear from the communities now that we have this out there um and has some time to get some feedback before the full committee is going to uh hopefully look at this and maybe vote on it um time is of the essence like we've been saying so we need to make some decisions so we can move forward um and um and I you and then we'll go into um the finance subcommittee meetings and start looking at a possible level for an override and hopefully

098have that sometime soon for the communities as well thank you I was on mute sorry um what I was saying is this when the State numbers come out that's when we have great numbers to go to our towns and get that override vote that everybody is anticipating so a little patience with the state or not with the state but patience in US developing the fully budget all right Lisa Bloom um I'm Sorry Brad I didn't you your voice cut out so I didn't hear the option that you suggested was it [Music] one yes okay it's a second one it's the second one so just to repeat it it would be Ashby Elementary K to1 all of Ashby ol of Townson Squan cook 3K for the entire district grades two to four Ashby Townson and then

099hawth and Brookwood remain the same okay all right thank you you're welcome June thank you um first thank you to the admin team for looking at this again and trying to find a solution that is Equitable for all of our students um the both of these options would not negatively affect one subset of students like the option that was previously voted on um so I do appreciate you going back to this um I do I just a a quick question then I have a couple more things to say I know uh superintendent Morgan you just said that you would recommend um the K through one option over the K through 5 option would you recommend one of these options over the option that was previously voted on would I recommend would I recommend one of

100the options I just discussed over the other options over the option that was voted on on December 3rd so so just to clarify I I I would always recommend um maintaining um the current model that we have in place to a point um you know again I I do think the equity and the balancing is important so if if the option I just described was something um that the that the committee can get behind I I would absolutely um feel as though that that would be an option that would work very well for the students in North metal sex um you know I I in looking at in looking at the options even the option that were shared previously something that we don't know is what if a Housing Development comes in um into any

101of the towns it doesn't matter what town it comes into um if it comes into any of the towns and I know that you know it's been brought up before we would have capacity issues in our buildings um you know B if a certain number of students came to North Middle sex through that housing development so closing two buildings is absolutely I I don't I I agree with what Miss Rush said puts it would leave very little room for growth um so I would if possible prefer to close one building as opposed to two because it does give us more flexibility thank you I I do that answer your question it does I I have one more question before um I share a couple comments um so closing the one building I we're still talking

102about Spalding but I know you were looking into the feasibility of um closing Squan cook instead of Spalding if that was possible and is there any new information regarding that so the big issue between the two is that um and again this is not um this is the information I have now I do not have anything that's definitive but the challenges that we Face are Spalding is rented um so it's leased I shouldn't say rented the school district leas leases Spalding um and the district owns Squan cook uh the issue with sanook is that we also um have a sewer line that is shared between Squan cook and Hawthorne Brook that goes to a leeching field um and using sanana cook as a potential rent Ral property or selling it could be potentially an issue

103because of that because of that shared line the district um also between Haw Brook and Squan cook shares all of its um fiber networking between the two buildings it's shared so that could also potentially create an issue um you know honestly there in looking at the two buildings um Spalding is larger um it does have an operational kitchen um where Squan cook again is District owned and it's got you know a better HVAC system uh it is more up to date but it's not as large but I think the challenge is going to be is that either way a decision is going to have to be made with how the vacated building is handled so for instance in Spalding um that belongs to the town what does the town of Townson do with it are

104they able to do anything with it and then if it's sanac cook what can the district do because we would require special legislation to sell the building or to do something with the building than to use it some for something other than a school so again I think I think we're looking at all options and part of those options are the space the costs of moving Spalding to Squan cook the cafeteria issue um I don't think it would have much of an issue on on that busing on the tiered approach because Spalding and haw and Brook are still very very close to each other it's about a you know a three four minute ride it would still be a single tier and we'd have to adjust start and end times a little bit but it's

105not something that would that would impact the busing as far as from from everything that I've looked at so it really comes down to just um trying to get all the information which I currently don't have uh because it's also been put out there that Spalding was gifted to the district and it must be used as a school if the district is going to or gifted to the town of Townson um it must be used as a school if that is in fact true and that's again something we're working on trying to get to the bottom of then that may make the decision for us um or it may not I don't again it's there's just some challenges between the two buildings and I think that we really have to be cautious if we are

106going to close um a building that we making the decision on closing the right one does that make sense it yes and it leads me to another question sorry um so where with the lease building again we can walk away from and a Le the lease we say lease but it's really zero dollars the district's not paying the town anything um however if we did decide to sell a building and sell swanic cook um I know you said it requires special legislation um do like what exactly does that involve and I know you said in the pass that we don't know where the money would go but if it's owned by the district I would think it would come back to the district or the towns if it was sold so is that a potential

107to bring in Revenue by selling the building um whether it does come back to us as a school district or to the towns which would clearly also be helpful if the towns received um revenue from a sale so I so I did speak to the msba about this and I do not have a definitive answer um and the other thing that muddies the waters with selling a building um or decommissioning a school however you want to put it whether you're selling it or moving out is what happens um is there any penalty um if msba dollars were used to improve that school and it's no longer being used as a school um and that's something I I've gotten some different answers I have been told by some that in in a budget crisis they would

108likely um move off of the penalty because the district was left with very few options but that's coming directly from Mars that's not the mass Association Regional Schools that is not coming from msba but people at Mars do have experience in dealing with these types of things especially out in Western Massachusetts where um having to close schools does happen um in areas where msba project projects were conducted so it's really not just getting the special legislation to sell the building I agree I think the money would likely go back to the town but is there a penalty for the msba work that that was done um Spalding I can't speak to there there has certainly been some pretty extensive msba work done at sanook it's been uh was going on um when I got hired

109a superintendent for the first few years anyway okay um when when would the committee have more information on on this I know you said you're looking into what you know selling would entail I know you are meeting with people regarding um the lines and the shared lines and whatnot I I would say it's probably going to be a few weeks um and again that that's not necessarily helpful to us and the the other piece is that six-month window of uh having to give the msba notice if you're going to close a school for all intents and purposes that's that's March 1st um so I would say that we that between the budget hearing and the budget adoption we don't have a lot of time but we do have some time and hopefully during that time

110we'll be able to get some answers but um if you're asking if I plan on um delving into this to get answers I am I I will certainly do everything I possibly can to get the answers that the committee is seeking um for sure if we don't know if an override will pass before March 1 how would we be proceeding with the previous plan the the last vote was for Plan B based on an override however if we don't have an know if we have an override by March 1st how would we proceed with that plan B I would say that to me it whether it's the option that was originally voted on by the school committee um or it's the option that I just shared shared with the entire committee um um either way

111if the override doesn't pass um it's not it's going to entail substantial reductions as we talked about before if Ashby were to close and if Spalding were to close if those were the two buildings we are looking at a savings of approximately $900,000 we don't have a $900,000 problem we have a $3.6 million problem so if the override doesn't pass um I don't necessarily think that um keeping a building open is necessarily going to have a huge impact on what's going to have to happen um with regard to Staffing uh because again it's um if you're looking at Ashby it's it's under 400k if you're looking at sanook it's under 400k um you know Spalding's a little bit larger closer to 600k but that these are um you know a quarter of the problem um

112you know closing the buildings doesn't even get us it gets us 20% there um and the rest is going to have to come for from from reductions so I I think either way we have to proceed with a plan a plan is is if the override passes and then a plan of if the override doesn't pass the this is the building or buildings we are going to close and these These are the reductions that we're going to have to make um that's ultimately up to the committee to make that decision on um how far to go um at least from from the closure standpoint um that's not within that's not within my decision-making power um the only thing that really is within my decision-making pow is is that when it comes to the point where

113I'm given a number and we have to make reductions then I will be PR making presentations to the fincom on what those reductions are and what they look like but again uh aside from buildings there's not a lot of places to cut from this budget I I know I mean there are certainly some small areas but that's not going to get us to where we need to be okay um I I'll make my comments about these new options quickly right now I think they're both far better options than the option that was previously voted on for several reasons um I I do um let's see how do I want to say this um again I think both options are better but I do understand the benefits of the option that superintendent Morgan recommended um it

114basically checked several boxes that have been long-term issues for us there would be a long-term budget savings um moving um Ashby and towns in K through1 in Ashby um between the Staffing reduction and potential bus savings um that that would be a long-term savings it would also help with the community feel an inclusiveness of Ashby being part of a district and not feeling like they're being kicked out of the district essentially um it would also help us retain that building space that we may certainly need in the future um and keep our options open because no matter how the schools are configured and reconfigured at least if we are keeping that building open we'll have that space to use for that um and we'll address balance class sizes which I know has been an issue

115um long before I came on there was talk about redistricting and Rec reconfiguring um so we would finally be addressing that piece as well which has been an ongoing concern and again um the biggest thing is equity with in the district um and we wouldn't be negatively affecting the students with this plan all of that being said um without voting for a new plan clearly we're looking at options we did not have all the information needed in December and we don't have the all the information we need right now um so I make a motion that we resend our December 3rd vote to move forward with option four is Plan B and we explore the feasibility of new options to vote on at a future meeting I second okay so before we do this how

116many members are we missing four we're missing two no we're missing missing three three Tom and Patrick and so I just want to make it clear to when we do this and for everyone to think if we would take any type of vote and not have a member here for instance June if we took a vote with Ashby and said to close it without you being present or any kind like that but again this is not a motion to close anything or do anything I mean besides take back what we said so that we can look at other options which the district is already looking at but it's it's opening up that chance to to have a new OP option that is Equitable to [Music] everyone so I mean we could again and vote for

117the same option as before but we would at least have more information if that's what we wanted to do and we would have an opportunity to give everybody a chance to come to a new meeting with the new information well and I and I think we are there is new information with all of these options that are continually coming out and exploring as where the two I think was an an as I'm going to put it a nuclear option to close two schools in our district that we gave Brad to look into that and I think that's what he has been doing and coming up with more information to give to us that's not what the vote was last time it was to move forward with option b as you said during the press release

118so we don't necessarily want to move forward with it we want to be open to new options we want to step back from what we said we would do and gather more information and make an informed vote I know a couple other people just just a point of order is it like we didn't have a vote for this building options on the agenda for tonight wasn't expected to you know I wasn't expected to you know to vote on this for tonight you know I think he was updating the options that we had is was the discussion but like I don't think it's appropriate to vote on this at this point again we're not voting on a new Option tonight that's not what the motion was you're asking me to vote on reversing a vote we've

119already made which is within Robert's Rules but you can do just to gather more information not on the agenda do do we need is this a you know if if we're reversing a vote is this a majority vote is this a super majority vote where where does that stand right as far as Robert's Rules I I had looked up um and I believe it's just a majority vote um to reconsider or resend a previous um uh vote it's slightly different to um reconsider a vote somebody who voted uh the way that the vote went so in this case affirmative for that would have to bring it back to resend anybody can bring it up and it's a majority vote uh to resend a vote that had been taken before so just just that technical I

120think this just opens up uh the opportunity uh for Brad to continue uh developing the options um I know the intent originally back in December was to be able to give Brad a direction to look into and see the feasibility of um and it quickly turned into a vote for that's how we were going to go uh for Plan B um so resending this right now because there are other viable options on the table I think would be appropriate um and have all the options come back to us um as Brad is looking at the feasibility of uh of the options for us to rec consider can ensure that all members can be present at the next meeting and that we have the information that we need and our questions are answered and I'm I'm

121again very grateful to our district admin to be exploring these options so it will give everybody time again we wouldn't want to vote on one of these new options now because we want to be able to digest this we want to get the information that we need we want to get community feedback and we'll be meeting again very soon so and can put up a meeting anytime within a posting date so I agree all right and regarding the agenda under old business um the budget was listed and said votes may be taken so I think you're covered on we do have a motion me I was that Lisa I'm sorry I feel very uncomfortable doing this and I'm just going to state that for the record that that I do feel very uncomfortable doing this

122as I know that there are options being explored and that the option even that we had discussed and that we needed during our last meeting it had been presented to us that we would be looking at an option to explore further feasibility we were all in a long row on a stage where I could barely hear anybody that was five people away from me and instead a motion was made to proceed with a plan and a press release announc without the majority of the school committee being aware that we were proceeding with that I had to go back and listen to the recording to find out what was actually said so yeah that was also uncomfortable but I think at this point it would make sense to resend this vote get the information we need

123and get everybody together all nine members again and look at the options before us and then pick a Direction and again with what Brad was saying where we need to decide by March 1st yet we won't know about an override I think the last boat didn't make a lot of sense if it was override based and it would be closing based on an override yet we wouldn't know if an override pass when we had to make that decision and in light of that it seems very appropriate to resend it until we can make a new vote that so we are not going to know about an override if it is approved by commit by the communities until April 28th right so how would we be able and there will be possibly three new members on

124this board who can step in the school was going to close or two schools closed by March 1st I think if we went beyond March 1st we would have to get permission from the mass School building authority so I'm not saying don't close any schools I'm just saying let's get the appropriate information let's get the rest of the committee on but in light of the date and wanting to explore other options it's appropriate to resend the vote that was taken on December 3rd SCH and scheduling is becoming a nightmare where several members aren't able to make it and it's members need to show up I'm not it's and I can't be we can't be changing meetings I have changed several meetings for members to appropriate their time and their convenience we can't be doing that

125to the public and I know that June I've changed times for your meetings as well to help you accommodate some and do some remotely no there was one meeting you did change to remote even though we agreed all meetings should have remote access but there was one that I had pneumonia and I did attend that meeting anyhow yes and I understand emergencies come up for members but these are critical votes that we need everyone available Randy sorry my voice is getting a little tense that's okay I was just gonna kind of say um if we sending this right now it gives us a chance to make a much better motion um I think we can probably have a contingency um Brad I think you would have to maybe talk with msba can we um file

126with them you know the intent to close a building contingent if we don't get of um an override vote in the April would that count as the six-month notice uh to be able to do that so that we can make a motion the next time on whichever option we have saying that on April 28th if we do not get the override this is the plan that we're going to do and give Brad um permission to go to the msba um with the possible closing of a building to meet the six-month Mark right now we don't have that with the vote that was taken and we have no way um to have that contingency uh in a timely manner because uh the events are opposite from what the vote was um uh made for any comments

127All we'll take a vote on this um Lisa yes June yes billberg you muted William oh you're on mute sorry yes Randy Rous yes will Hackler no and myself as no all right moving on to policy um for policy I am pulling a few of these policies um there was a um a case against the new title one requirements and they have been uh pulled back so policy ACA acce AC F acfr and AC I'm pulling back to policy because we need to revert back to what we were doing before um for the Title Nine requirements um so for this meeting right now I am going to move uh that we approve IMG animals in school JJ OA field trips and ik student progress reports to parents and Guardians for a first reading second that

128was Brandy and Lisa Bloom uh will yes Randy yes June yeah Lisa Bloom yes bber yes all right you're finished with policies there um and that is all I have for this evening thank you um moving on to Warrant Patrick is not available those are the warranty signs that are listed in the agenda um no report from negotiations and Personnel teachers um no report from negotiation and Personnel non-teachers community outreach liaison any updates I gave mine on okay and I don't have an update from peil as well but they are looking for the March 10th meeting um a town meeting and our next or one of the where we adopt the meeting or adopt the budget is the March 16th meeting which is a Thursday but I'm going to be sending out an email to

129change that possible meeting to the meeting to a last week in February it's looking like a Wednesday the 26th right now but I have a I'm waiting on a few people to put in their dates of availability all right I will take a motion to adjourn so moved second Randy second well yes Randy yes June yes Lisa Bloom yes Bill Bird yes and myself yes all right good night

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.