001good evening the uh finance and law subcommittee shall come to order today is Wednesday December 18th uh 5:45 p.m. I believe time is 5:46 uh first up uh we have a attendance we have Mr Vieira Mrs shavs and myself uh first item on the agenda we have a special education expense uh service report see attached memo uh Mr M Monahan please thank you Dr damelo again this is our monthly update for contracted Legal Services um from Lions Law Group for fy2 we have a budget of $50,000 for September of 2024 for the services rendered with $ 6,468 which totals up to $ 22,616 year to date which leaves us our balance currently at $ 27,38 for special ed and student services related matters excellent any questions concerns wishes of the committee motion to accept the
002report second is all in favor I I opposed eyes have next up we have item two BO which stands for Board of Health update report C attached memo uh Mr Vie thank you Mr chairman I have a question um I the vote that we took at the last school committee meeting I thought it was to get an update from the Board of Health at the first of the year and long range planning and and public property report uh my recollection of the vote was to include Board of Health inspections when the board of health comes in inspects that would be part of the facilities update so you're talking about the subcommittee when we met yeah okay yeah I I I also I was there of course I'm a subcommittee member of that committee I don't
003know if there was any ambiguities or I mean clearly there I I think the concern if who else is on that committee myself uh Mr he was we were absent that day or were you there I'm sorry okay so I I think the recollection was that we couldn't get a complete report until after the holidays because there was some missing items that had to be done while school was not in session correct it was in a high traffic area and the work couldn't be performed and uh during school hours so it would either a have to be done on the weekend or it would have to be done during the school break and it would probably take a time frame till the first of the year if my if I could I would love to
004read out the report a little bit so you can understand of what we presented um correct it was what we discussed at the meeting at the long range planning so during that long range planning all the Board of Health um items are listed in here in that behind it and the only item that is outstanding like you said it was going to be done um in the hight traffic area is one is going to be done at the high school and it's actually going to be done this weekend so so again I thought the purpose of the vote was to be informed not to when the Board of Health was here and what the report entailed and what the work was required to be part of the facilities not so we may have we may
005have misinterpreted um the motion so what you have in front of you and this is just one this is a sample of what you'll be getting moving forward and we can provide the appropriate backup because this will this conserve as a summary as in addition to all the reports so am I hearing that instead of coming to finance and law those reports would just go to the long range planning meeting not Finance in law well well I I I think the intent was to kind of uh again this all started with a public uh citizen reaching out to me I I don't know if you got the same call regarding issues with our schools uh where there were Board of Health reports now being publicly advertised in the city website okay and when the question
006was asked to me are you aware of these violations I said I had no idea but I look into it I prompted a call to the superintendent uh and then of course we came together as a subcomittee to better evaluate the reports that I believe you Mr Vier went down to the Board of Health to collect I I did a series of reports were the last three and I printed some off the off their website off the website but I they weren't all there so I I think the intent is uh to start the Academic Year in January when we came back with a clean bill of health and eventually have have the food service director come before us I think that was mentioned too to give us a report because I don't think we've
007seen the food service director here for a while so I'm still so pardon my ignorance so we're not to bring this report you don't want this the the committee the finance and law committee does not want this report as part of markus's facilities update which that was my interpretation I with Mr frus does his monthly facilities report that we will go if if the Board of Health had conducted inspections that we would attach that to Mr Fred's facilities report so it would be one encompassing report covering all facilities but if I am I hearing something different that we rather have this go through long range no I think the only the only step that it's missing is go through the long range and then we report out as a subcommittee to so it's not coming
008here okay well no hold on hold on superintendent then then we eventually get the master report right that because they come out four times a year yeah absolutely again I thought it was pertaining to the the Board of Health reports themselves when they were conducted we have an awareness of when they conduct it other than uh through that process right so we would bring them to finance and enough as part of the facilities report but again some of these violations went back you know six months nine months did the last Academic Year we never heard about we talked about moving forward right so so if they're going to happen four times a year so again maybe we should talk offline on how the committee wants to streamline this sure because for transparency purposes this meeting
009is televised so anyone who's watching the meeting will see this they're not going to see this they're not going to see long range planning they're going to hear the report out absolutely for transparency purposes we thought this would be more transparent for the public but we'll accommodate the wishes of the committee no uh and again we're that's why we're here because we want to be transparent that's why we called the subcommittee meeting because we had public out saying that our schools were not in the best of state of of sanitary conditions not all of them some issues that were there and was brought to my attention we convened the subcommittee and I don't want to drag this on but you know I think we're we're circumventing a subcommittee but we shouldn't because there's an action
010item that's not complete within the subcommittee that met that is re is expecting a deliverable from what IOD after the new year and I just want to be clear that the the intention was not to circumvent right because this Our intention was not to circumvent Our intention was to provide you with the report in the format that we interpreted that we were going to use moving forward when Mr freedus provides his monthly facilities report we were going to put it all together so you would see the work orders as well as the Board of Health reports when they're completed but we'll go through the long range planning committee that's fine and and so the public also knows there's many subcommittee meetings that aren't televised but I'm more than happy to televise all all subcommittee meetings
011going forward oh maybe that's a conversation we have to have with Mr Jake to absolutely and they are public so they can definitely come down at any time so on item two Board of Health update report what are the wishes of the committee do we want the report reported out today or do you want to wait until the first I I I actually we did say the first meeting in January we were specific right so we were specific I want to do what we said we were going to do you know it's up to you Donna and Mrs shavz and Mr Vieira if you want it out tonight or if you want to wait for the actual completion of all the outstanding items which was supposed to be delivered by the first meeting in January
012I personally don't see a problem with it being put into this report because I to me it makes sense but I understand what you're saying that this was something that came from your subcommittee so it may need to be reported back to your subcommittee so I'm I'm motion to table the item okay I'll second it then second in favor I I opposed eyes have it item three facilities update see attached memo Mrs monan um director of facilities Mark frus provided us with um the work orders from July 1st through December 12th the work order throughout the city of 60 buildings um over just over a thousand work orders were placed and 785 of those work orders were um done by taught in public schools so 78 % of all work if you look on the
013next page you'll see as we do each month um Mr freed has provided us with a number of work orders that are open which is 168 and work orders that are closed 843 and then below you'll see the work orders open and closed per School excellent make a motion to accept the report and place on file second all in favor I opposed eyes have it uh next up we have item three uh state championship soft ball and wrestling team see attached memo I didn't find a memo in my packet anybody have a memo no no does anybody have it in the Imp the wrestling I have the softball it's soft it the wrestling oh yeah I have it talked about a field trip they were invited to a Celtics game that were invited I did
014see in in uh my packet M but I can't place okay so I I guess I I can read it I mean because this is the first time say maybe it wasn't in my packet I don't remember seeing this um from finan to the finance and law subcommittee from Brenda mon assistant superintendent Finance operations authorization of expenses for state champions recognition uh I'm pleased to share that the Toton High School softball team has achieved an extraordinary uh Milestone by winning the state championship additionally we are thrilled to recognize our two-state champion wrestlers who brought home individual titles ear earlier this year to appropriately honor these achievements uh we have planned several recognition activities these include number one commemorative items such as Championship jackets and Rings to celebrate their success number two an invitation to attend
015a Boston Celtics home game on December 27th versus the Indiana Pacers where the softball team and the two state champion wrestlers will be special guests uh as these expenses fall outside of our standard budget allocation I'm requesting authorization from the school committee to cover the costs asso with associated with these initiatives which we pay through the athletic revolving account thank you for consideration I appreciate your support in this matter and please join me in extending heartfelt congratulations to the team their coaches and the state champion wrestlers for their outstanding accomplishments and there's a a note here that this is uh athletic what is this superintendent I'm sorry no just in case there was a question regarding the balance of the athletic involvement account $2,000 in the atic involving so there's plenty of funds to cover
016the six okay what is this going to cost do we know all in probably be with the jackets and the Rings and the tickets probably be probably 10,000 all in okay questions Mr Vieira are you is a cap on it appropriate or do you want to just you think it's good the way it is presented yeah I mean if you want an itemize break down I can provide break down but we're just looking for authorization to use the funds that we include in the athletic revolving P to cover all the expenses and it's not going to be anything anything I mean we're not covering their food it's just going to be Transportation the tickets the jackets and the state championship rings make a motion or approve is presented I second it uh all in favor
017I I opposed eyes have it great Indian Indiana Pacers that should be a win for the Celtics uh next up we have the DECA field trip chaperon C attached memo I guess Mrs Monahan um so on January 9th in 2025 158 students from taau in high school's Deca chapter will be attending Regional Deca competition in hyanis per our fi trip policy which requires one chaperon for every 10 students this event will require 15 adult chaperon to minimize the impact on day-to-day operations at Taunton High School Mr mcao which is the Decker um advisor plans to bring five staff members from his Department to serve to serve as chaperon the remaining six chaperon slots will be filled by caregivers of students participating in the competition this reason for this is to significantly reduce the number of
018THS staff required to attend ensuring that classes remain covered by content certified teachers rather than substitute which will directly benefit student learning right now our current policy which is outlined um in The Mask web the masc website does not explicitly address covering cost for caregiver chaperon therefore I'm requesting that the finance and law subcommittee authorize the school department to cover hotel costs for these caregivers from the THS cvte budget the estimated cost for the accommodation is approximately $1,750 for these six chaperon it is not worth noting that while this type of expense has been approved in the past is not occurred in this scale as such it is important to notify the city auditor that this request and payment will require the committee's authorization additionally I recommend that the field trip policy be revised in
019the near future to address situations involving care caregiver um chaperon this would provide greater Clarity and guidance for similar events for the future and reduce need for Case by case requests finally of course all this jargon I definitely want to go ahead and join me in Wishing our students the best of luck this competition will determine who advances to the state level and potentially to the national competition and we of course are proud of their efforts and are comp and are committed to supporting them on their Journey good wishes of the committee I can make a motion that we approve it okay second uh on discussion so just to clear things up uh you mentioned five chaperon I believe it's a total of 15 chaperon including our staff correct five teachers 10 10 gotcha okay
020and this 1750 figure is for those 15 chaperons including our teachers because it's only one night right they're only staying there one night so it's only 100 some doll7 for the 10 sh rooms for for the 10 sh room5 a night per room gotcha okay and uh just for the public at home when the uh agenda was published the amount uh approximate amount was stated as $1,650 and there was a revision uh which was made on the 16th of December uh to clearly state that it was $1,750 okay so people at home that they saw the agenda online it's the $1,750 uh number we're approving tonight so that's my first point of discussion the second point of discussion uh the blanket authorization uh I'm not in favor of that for a couple of reasons every
021trip is unique uh we don't know I mean we could be going to a whole that's costing 400 bucks a night we don't know what that is so I I I guess the best course of action as the motion was made by Mrs shave is we're just approving the 1750 for this trip is that correct just this trip gotcha okay ask okay and no blanket authorization going down the road okay great uh you want to have a policy that will covers moving forward yeah but I mean the policy again you know every trip is unique this happens how many times a year no the policy we cannot specify anyc you might have regarding any iank get like the policy could state that we bring it to the committee and get you authorization like we're doing
022right now right which which is fine I guess I mean you know we don't we have one of these a year I think deca's once twice a year they they're going to have they're going to have their Boston trip and then they're going to have the international trip and then we also have other organizations like skills USA so just to have something in place whatever protocol will follow just so we Mrs moam the business office and also the people at the high school organizing these trips they know the procedures and you got to follow that way they just don't take it for granted or just assume right yeah and the policy is one per 10 the ratio right so I guess that's covered as far as granting a blanket uh something to be discussed in
023the future so the motion was second in all in favor I opposed I have thank you next up we have the bills payable uh first off we have bills payable for FY 25 and for the folks at home there was a typo on the bills payable uh it was listed as 1 million there was a one missing so the uh amount that's uh on discussion for tonight for approval is the amount of 1 mil1 11,415 wishes of the committee motion to approving the amount stated seconded on discussion second on discussion Mrs shs um I have four questions page one the first one that Bell for it says graduation what was what was that for those um the diploma covers okay um page five base 10 assets L LLC for the $1,590 55 cents it says
024other Student Activities it's yours yeah that I'm sorry base State interpreters base base 10 assets on page five down to the bottom obviously so here it is sorry about that um these are for the other Student Activities is they are for the robotics Club um supplies okay uh page eight city of Boston programs with others I didn't know what the program that was these are for um specialized programs it's for one student for September and October tuition oh it's a tuition one oh okay that one I didn't know and the last one was on page 23 that Rugby Architectural Building Products um for $99,999 999 that is for the THS wood shop supplies wood shop supplies okay that's all I had for questions thank you thank you Mrs sh Mr VI thank you Mr chairman
025uh page four attune education partners LC in the amount of $1 16,667 they are professional development and that was for development that professional development that was provided for us um in July July okay and then on page 29 Vex robotics Vex robotics again those are um robotics Club supplies so the the supp ER for robotics class robotics excuse me not not Club um class and if I could just add if anybody happens to be at the high school tomorrow or Friday in the middle of the lobby you'll actually see they have the ring for the robotics team to practice with with their robots well that's excellent I was there today it's wonderful news thank you for sharing that superintendent those uh those conclude my questions thank you m thank you Mr VI Mrs mon I
026have just a few uh on page four uh again we have the uh voucher uh number oh was voucher zero but PO number 250 2159 the amount of 12,500 uh I think I've repeatedly asked for an update from this organization uh and I don't know when they're coming in because I'm G not going to vote Yes on this okay sorry Mr Bara I've actually had uh two meetings in person and one virtual with AHS uh identifying when they provide services to what students provide services and they provide with monthly reports so if superintendent directs me I can release it to the monthly reports and I will continue to follow up with them uh especially they want to make more inroads with supporting our um overaged or older students uh multilingual Learners they're in um registering
027at the high school because they want to reach out and support them as well as part of our task force so uh you you'd like to provide us with monthly reports they provide us with they're providing me now going back to October they're providing me now with monthly reports we'll put it in the next financing all right yeah again because this was a concern last year they came in uh the end of the Academic Year with a presentation that I think was put together the day of that deal didn't give us any information and I'm not going to be signing off on something that we're not getting a return on so um I guess I'll wait for the next report Mr bar thank you thank you so much uh page number eight oh Mrs sha
028city of Boston I had the same question page page 10 so we have one of our employees that went on a conference I believe uh that's the item for 1325 .95 uh hotel and all that why didn't we use the PE card for the hotel um this sometimes what will happen is they will go ahead and put forth a a PD form and they did not request um the PE card I didn't see this one so but I could always go ahead and work with um the curriculum office to see if there's um when a PD form comes and there is asking for pricing or some um amount to be reimbursed to reach out to the staff member to use the PE card instead okay but that would be after the fact right well no
029because they have to get the approval from the curriculum office and then so when they review that we will go ahead and reach out to the staff member to use the PE card to pay for the program okay all right so this one slipped that's okay but as long as there you know there's an education component to this to the traveler so that they're aware too I mean I hate people waiting for money this is 1325 that they've been waiting for for a while so you know we have to give it within 15 days anyway so we do a lot faster than they used to but again we'd rather use the peard absolutely and let's see one last item I have let's see uh page 20 I've already addressed an item with the superintendent on
030page 20 uh so that's good and last but not least page 29 we have a couple of uh of PDs to University of Florida University of Kansas Center for research um I I just get sometimes not upset but better understanding of why we're going out to to Florida and Kansas we have so many prestigious universities uh within almost walking distance uh I know sometimes some of this stuff is pretty specialized but um Mr can speak to so the University of Florida actually has to do with the literacy component it's called youly it's a early intervention pheic awareness structured learning program which our title one uh teachers use so that PD is directly with them for the resources we've purchased the University of Kansas actually has to work with Lisa deaker she us used to be
031at another site she's actually now University of Kansas I believe uh that's through the 240 Grant and she's actually making site visits with building principles and such going through looking the inclusion model along with providing PD and actually she's doing a study of Tom public schools and the effectiveness of co- teing which I don't want to speak for Miss moam but I think the end of this year maybe early next year he just going to produce a report on behalf of Taun and public schools to look at what progress we have made great thank you Mr bar and that's it for me so the motion was made and seconded uh I'm going to uh just vote uh to uh record my vote on um page four uh vote p number 252 2159 the amount of
03212,500 I'm voting present on that so if the make of the motion could kindly include that in the amendment I'm sorry so you want me to just just so amend the motion to just amend the motion that I'm voting pres that you're voting present for that 12,500 correct yep okay second made the motion oh I'm sorry you made the motion I'm sorry I'm sorry I don't know I thought I motions been made amended by Mr Vieira seconded by Mrs shavs yes is that correct yes all in favor I I opposed eyes have it good that was fy2 now FY 24 the amount payable is $83,900 standing yes a few here and there but we have really driven down the FY 24 um open posos that we outstanding okay great okay uh all in favor I
033I opposed eyes have it thank you uh motion to adjourn be in order motion seconded all in favor I I opposed eyes have it we are adjourned thank you the uh second regular December meeting of the taunt school committee shall come to order if we could kindly stand for the pledge and the national anthem Al United States ofice say can you see by the Dawn early night what so proudly we held at the Twilight last gleaming who Brad stripes and bright stars through the perous F or the real parts we watch so gly streaming and the rockets R glare the bombs bursting in air gave Pro through the night that our flag was still there oh say do that Star Spangled then I yet wave or the L of the free and the home of
034the brave Mrs Fagan Lord as we begin this session let us acknowledge your goodness and mercy and ask your blessings on all our deliberation we thank you for this opportunity to be of service to our community and to the young people entrusted to our care if you could remain standing we have um two um two more obituaries here for people that were associated with the T public schools first one is James Richie age 87 of rham passed away peacefully on Tuesday December 10th surrounded by his family he was the Cher cherished husband of Carol J McCarthy Richie with whom he shared nearly 66 years of marriage he'll be remembered for his positive outlook on life that kept him young and at heart he always greeted everyone with a hug could always find something to joke
035about and had a passion for helping to shape the hearts and minds of young people although his health failed him he continued to maintain his passion for Youth and positivity born in Pennsylvania he spent his formative years there graduating from harrick high school and after graduation joined the US Army serving in the Army Security Agency stationed at Fort devans where he met Carol on a memorable blind date he pursued higher education at Boston University earned a bachelor's degree and later obtaining a master's degree from Bridgewater University he dedicated his career to teaching to education teaching at Totton high school for 32 years in addition to his early years including included coaching the Taun in high school basketball team he and Bob Daly who also passed away not too long ago were the best of friends
036and um were both hilarious together I remember them being here because my oldest son was at tton high school when they were here um and they they were the two of them were just always joking wonder and and everybody who knew them knew that that they had a lot of fun together um he carried his passion for sports with with coaching his son's little league and Babe Ruth teams he coached with enthusiasm emphasizing the importance of sportsmanship and having fun he ended his career at his teaching career I'm sorry at Taunton High Schools the head of the business department upon retirement he ran for a cessor in the town of reham and I guess with his winning ways he served there for six years and he ex he um he found a lifelong friend in
037Roger howlet and er EX their friendship ex exceeded their years as assessors throughout his retirement he cultivating loving relationship with his grandchildren and great grandchildren who called him da playing significant roles in their day-to-day lives he was he could always be found sharing his granddaughters in AC cross country and track meets and often with a stopwatch in hand to shout times and encouragement you could also see him standing along the Outfield fence at gr grandson Travis's ball games away from the crowd um his great-grandson James brought him joy as he watched James begin his journey in organized Sports and he was deeply committed to making a different in the difference in the life of his great grandchildren until his death James remained an active member of the pilgrim Congregational Church of Taunton he served on
038most boards and committees the last being the Board of Trustees beside his wife he survived by his three children four grandchildren four great grandchildren and as well as a fifth great grandchild HOA Moren Richie expected this April um in accordance with his his um wishes his Services were all private but he was really uh an intrical B of our Taunton High family and we we keep his family and our thoughts and our prayers the next one is Maran D Thompson Kelly maranne um grew up in in Norwood Massachusetts passed away on December 10th at the age of 81 and will forever remain in the hearts of those touched by this by this precious presence in their lives family and friends are were welcome to leave their condolences on this memorial page and share them she
039was predeceased by her parents she is survived by her husband her children one of whom is Jeffrey T Kelly who is the Martin School assistant principal her siblings and she also leaves four grandchildren and several nieces and nephews and her visitation was is already gone by she had a funeral mass um actually today at St cathine Church in Norwood so please keep this family in your thoughts and prayers it's very difficult time of year to lose family members but we really really wish to honor the people that that have been of service to us and to their families when they pass away so moment silence for these two individuals thank you all righty thank you secretary Fagan uh now we'll start with our roll call certainly Mr Reus president Mrs shabs present Mr palowski present
040Mrs Fagan's present Miss Santos present Mr Vieira present Mr um oh my God Mr Laura present long day and Dr Dello present thank you Mr secretary Fagan next up we have approval of minutes of December 4 2024 wish the committee motion to accept as presented December 4th 2024 second uh on discussion uh Miss Lasser on page four just a a a quick uh typo I know I was coming in Via Zoom so I I guess it wasn't clear but on the paragraph that starts with Dr dallo page four uh the part that says careers uh you know it starts with involvement careers in phonics it's actually photonics oh I got instead of phonics it's photonics and I know I was coming in Via okay via Zoom so it wasn't very clear so just just with
041that correction and all in favor opposed eyes have it next up we have our student advisory report and with us tonight we have Natalie Duncan welcome hello my name is Natalie Duncan and I am a member of the student advisory committee we are approaching a relaxing Christmas break but T in high is still as Lively as ever National Honor Society acceptances will be released this week for qualifying junor Juniors and seniors also this week Deca students are taking their exams that will be calculated into their scores when they compete at the district competition on January 9th tunon high band has been especially busy recently last night there was a band concert for small Ensemble bands tomorrow night Thursday December 19th there will be a band concert for all of tonh high band ton High's band
042also performed at the lighting of the green and March and taunton's Christmas parade tomorrow morning there will be a term one recognition breakfast to celebrate 12 students who had ex excellent performances this term each department in the school selected one student to recognize winter sports have begun and the season is off to a great start the winter track team had their first meet last night and placed third girls and boys basketball have their games against North adoro today and our hockey and swim teams have games today as well the hakok winter sports Captain conference took place last Friday and captains from Toton High were in attendance today there were triy outs for the tier leading team and the tri outs will continue tomorrow as well clubs at T high are doing very well there has
043been a club Spotlight during lunch recently where clubs advertise themselves during lunch time clubs like drama club interact club and active Minds have participated we also have a variety of new clubs including medlife HOSA an indie animation club and a genealogy club we have two upcoming spirit days to prepare for winter break tomorrow is ugly sweater day and Friday is denim day in memory of janitor James dwiki the cafeteria introduced two new menu items recently a chicken bacon ranch sandwich and a Nashville hot chicken sandwich on Friday morning the Mr THS contestants and hosts will be announced that's all I have for you today and if you have any questions feel free to ask thank you Natalie Mrs Fagan secretary Fagan um the cheerlead is that's the Chile is for basketball right yeah the win
044separate from separate from the fall ones well that's how we get so many girls into cheering right yep and how long do they when when did the basketball game start Prett first ones were today against North adoro oh okay all right thank you I open up to uh Mr PSI about the chicken sandwiches any input on the I mean you're the affectionado of chicken right I haven't had a chance to try him yet okay maybe next time uh Natalie we can get some chicken sandwich Samplers I met at the deputy SI as my daughter she'll she'll try it for him sounds good sounds good okay wish of the committee motion to receive and place on file all in favor hi all oos eyes have it thank you Natalie have a great Christmas take care happy
045holiday happy holidays next up we have public input do we have anyone signed up for public input tonight no one signed up thank you Miss Lasser no public input next up favorite part of the Agenda superintendence Report uh which is the governance Corp School boards superintendents and schools working together by Davis Campbell and Michael fulan uh superintendent yeah so we are almost done with our first book study and we are on chapter seven and chapter 7 focuses on systems thinking and strategic planning so there were five key points if you read the summary that I provided in the packet and I appreciate those who read who read the chapter but the five key points in the chapter focused on establishing strategic directions and outcomes providing policy Direction and approvals offering Steward stewardship and support for
046district efforts ensuring oversight and accountability and exercising community leadership of the five uh during my reading of the five four really resonated with me as far as the work of this group which was the Strategic Direction and what I thought was key was and I think this board does a really good job of this is not mistaking aspirational beliefs as actual strategies of the board or direction of the board I also enjoyed reading the portion of the chapter regarding stewardship and support so I think that's something that this board does an excellent job of as well Community leadership I think this board does an outstanding job as far as modeling and working as a group to message all the great things taking place in our district and bringing to my to me and my team
047the concerns so that we can address them at the building level and then obviously uh something that I talk a lot about with my leadership team and we'll be discussing tomorrow during our all admin meeting is like we are really navigating uh an everchanging world when you think about AI uh mental health and everything that's going on in the world today to be part of a school board during these you know trying times and also during times where there are such rapid changes and how it's impacting education uh while trying to maintain our moral imperative and stay focused on teaching and learning know those are these are challenging times so those are just my thoughts and my key takeaways and obviously I provided you with three discussion questions so if anyone wants to elaborate or
048just discuss their feelings this is what the time is for if not we can just approve and move on thank you superintendent I know that uh some of our members are anxiously waiting to share their thoughts uh regarding this chapter Mr Santos I know you definitely yeah I go for the guys that's yeah I just I I know Mr Santos was enthusiastic yeah I I just want to thank the superintendent for putting this uh book study together with consultant Anthony Ben I'd like to thank Donna shavs Christine Fagan and Melissa Santos for articulating so well um you know the chapters and the points in the chapters that are notable so thank you so much and I appreciate the work that we're doing as a committee there's two more chapters I I can't wait to so
049again from the bottom of my heart thank you ladies Mr Vieira check the amount of chapters before you you make get closing remarks on the book study but good effort good effort back to you Mrs Santos anything you want to share um uh just a couple of things that came up to me I mean some of this thing I felt like it was started repeating itself after reading you know what we've read so far so one thing that I think I was a little confused on right because it says that our goal as a board is to come up with strategic actions and strategic goals so I was just wondering how that separates from what your strategic goals are separate they're separate so are we we're supposed to come up with our own kind of
050and I think there was a mention of that at the Last Retreat but we never got to it because we went over yeah so I think that's something for the next Retreat that we can maybe start with something like that like so that we have like kind of a clear goals for all of us yeah so I think Dr bent really did a nice job of articulating that my goals or the district's goals are separate from the school committee goals and you're right during our Last Retreat we ran out of time so our second Retreat is scheduled for January 29th and I think back in the summer one of our earlier Retreats we talked about using that time uh to work with our Police Department our local responders on uh how they would respond um
051to a crisis so we can either go down that route or we can shift and work on developing school committee goals so that's something that we can talk offline about what the dire the school committee wants to go cuz we haven't had one of those um exercises uh I want to say almost seven years when we did one at and I'm looking around the room I think only two people may have been there or three people may have been there from this board when we had that last round so it might be we might want to maybe look at how we can try to squeeze 10 pounds into a 5 pound bag yeah and I mean some of that stuff could be like a Google dock or what have you you know like as committee
052members we can add to it without having um without having to do like a separate meeting I mean something to think about but then the other thing I just wanted to mention was on uh towards the end but they um talked about the major part of the job is to educate and inform the community regarding the work of the district I know how you loves newsletters um I was just wondering I don't know it could be something to think about as like a school committee newsletter so in the the newsletter that we do put out which will probably be going out beginning of the year or right after the New Year well something for us to like add a section for the school committee oh okay so if there's something that uh maybe that's something
053Dr D Mrs Fen can reach out to the other board members for any there anything that you'd want to add okay thank you thank you Mrs Miss Santos Mrs shavs anything you want to add I I'm not picking on you how we calls on I noticed now we're getting called on here I didn't ra my hand you can goate if you want toski s uh thank you Dr mow uh so what resonated uh with me uh in this chapter was the uh oversight and accountability so I think I think we're starting to do a much better job uh with this where it's literally speaking about using data to evaluate whether policies and programs are effective so we have to have a long-term view of a lot of the stuff not just of this board but
054the board that will exist in two years from now you know we're voting to implement certain policies different things we're approving things uh it will be nice to see after a year after two years after three years the actual data to see how things are are working and and the thing that comes to mind is you know we've recently implemented the the reset rooms at the various different levels and um you know in the school Improvement plans we ask the question like well hey you know what what's the outcome what what have you seen like it sounds like a great idea in theory but it will be really nice to see the objective data hey before we had these things in place these were the suspensions or the disregulation or or whatnot at after a
055year of having it here's where those things have gone down after two years three years so I think if we really start asking those questions like hey yeah we like this thing it sounds great in theory put it in place when are we following up is there a report a year out or six months out or or whatnot because then we can actually look back and say hey the choices that we made were they effective or hey the choices the last board made four years ago is that effective and and if not then what do what do we do do we pivot do we we do we try something else so that's a that's a responsibility of ours that I think it's uh it's difficult to have that uh that thought that or that long
056longterm view but I I I can see that we are are making strides towards that so excellent point Thank you Mr palski I'm not going to pick on anybody but if anybody wants to add I I know Mrs Fagan does because she called me at 6 in the morning looking for a copy of the book so she got it well I think they were pull together around taking the books um I was troubled by a lot of the things in this chapter to be honest with you I I think it was all over the place with some things at first I felt like they were saying you've got to be a bobblehead dull and whatever the administration said you go yep yep yep yep yep and I said well that's not right that you know
057we can't be like that and then I got into the book a little bit later and they started talking about the responsibility is that we have the fiduciary ones and the ones concerning staff and and whether or not staff is happy so there was some things in here that I was very conflicted with I don't know how anybody can talk about moral issues because moral issues are personal and when you start saying who moral issues are we talking about here when you're talking about things like that so I found a lot of the stuff in there in here was very very conflicting um it says here it says this is I guess for you your future success as a superintendent of schools would depend on how well you can adapt to societal change there's so
058much stuff changing in our society right now that it would make your head spin what's the stuff you pay attention to what's the stuff you don't pay attention to the worth of the educational process to the children you serve will in large part be dictated by the way in which you and your board can change your system to meet the demands that Society will Society will place upon on your students I'm not sure if I like some of the things that are being placed upon students you know what I mean so I was very conflicted reading this I could make an argument about a lot of the things that are in here but I also know that um there's stuff that we just have to do that we have to be part of and one
059of them is to question whether or not so I often times I feel like when we start to question something people want to perceive you as being negative but it's not you're doing your job and I I mean that's the job we have to do and one part in here I remember reading that they said if if the system one of the things I work worry about a lot is when the money's going to dry up because I'm afraid of that I'm continuously afraid of that I've been very vocal about that but you know you keep hearing about all the money and everybody's looking at money now I guess interest rates are going to start tanking in at Banks and stuff like that for for right because know everybody's a little bit frightened with stuff
060but I wonder what happens to us us and I don't want to they say if if you go belly up that is a tendency excuse me of the electorate to say well was the school committee's fault so we have to be careful so when we argue about things sometimes it's the monetary part of it sometimes it's whether or not you know the people you know in the community buy some of this stuff there are people that are concerned about things in this community and some of them is the behavior in schools some of it you know the cell phones in the school and I know people feel differently about cell phones excuse me but I've heard that they they've got done away with them in Brockton I guess the behavior has changed quite a bit
061because of it so we have a lot of things on the plate not always good for the students as a whole so that's that's why I I struggled a lot with this chapter and I hope I didn't say too much I probably did but no if I could I think that's the beauty of a book study is you get different perspectives and I agree with you 100% Mrs moan and I we were every day about last year's budget the budget within this year and thinking about the budget next year so everything that you articulated Mrs Fagan especially about where what do we prioritize because in the life of a superintendent life of a school board I mean I'm sure the new members didn't anticipate that being a school board member would be as difficult or
062as taxing as as it is because you're dealing with so many different issues that pop up every day so that's that's why I enjoy having these deep conversations that we can get to to the root of these issues and do what's in the best interest of our district and our students well I always I I always try to present myself as I I ask a lot of questions because I do worry about a lot of things but when you've been here a long time you start to see patterns that you know things that have gone bad and things that haven't worked right I mean we've we've done programs that haven't worked well but I think we can I would like to see some honesty and like they say you know you only do well if
063you're getting if people are giving you the right information if people aren't giving you the right information then you're going to struggle with knowing what's really going on so I think I think do we have some problems yeah I do I I worry about the flow of parents that comes in here and and we've seen it several times with concern about student behavior and we know that because they've been in here they've been in here with the teachers when there's been an issue and and the parents would say their kids aren't happy at school we we heard that up at modern school when we were up there there was a lot of concern about the behavior you know in in different schools there there are issues with that you know and how do we handle
064that and how do we deal with it you know so I think there's an awful lot of stuff there and uh I think we just have to keep trying to do the best we can and I'm all for once once we have once you establish something well you know that that was the vote of the committee I may not have agreed with it but we're going to go with the vote with what the committee did but I think people have to understand we are all different we all bring bring a different moral value to things and it was when they sto putting in words like morality I go what is that doing in there you know so I you know there was a lot of confusion thank you thank you secretary Fagan so uh anybody
065else before I comment so ju remk if I could one of the continuations that we do as a board member myself speaking in different forums in the community and radio and so forth is I continue to promotee the our leadership as a team because we work well together there are problems that we confront on on weekly basis and issues and so forth but as a committee we may let the community know that that we're working together on issues of pros and cons on different agenda items but that we continue to promote that we understand we listen to people uh if I talk to people whether it's educ is whether it's at the elderly I I explain to them on a regular basis how important it is that our job is not not that we are
066elected as one member of the board we are collectively working to better our school system so in our leadership I mean whether I'm on the radio whether I'm at a school whether I'm here or at the University or the college I continue to tell people that yeah there were problems every school system has them but it's how well we work together as a team to make sure that the majority of us move us ahead in a positive way and that will be continued to do so thank you thank you uh I I mean you know I I joke a lot about the book and you know sometimes we we have some laughs but this is all serious stuff right but I I think you said it best um as we read these chapters we always
067have our say in this and honestly if if we I think there's nine chapters there's eight members and the superintendent can be part of this we each took a chapter and dissected it and kind of uh like peer-reviewed it right in the academic world we peerreview and counter points and so forth I think we could actually publish our own book which would have some value so something to think about I mean it's not that hard I mean you know uh something that we should definitely think about what do you think superintendent no I again we presented at that conference last month and from there I've heard two superintendents have told me that they're going to start the same book study they've asked me for the book and copies of our summary so that they can
068lead that work and I like your jigsa idea because we'll get through the book faster yeah no no I mean it's valid you know like superintendent said I mean there were there were multiple superintendants in the room and I'll tell you they have no clue I don't want to disparage it but I they have no clue sometimes you know of the relationship between a superintendent and the school committee members they don't talk you know the they're afraid to talk or they're told not to talk whatever it may be I don't know any member here that doesn't pick up the phone or text the superintendent that he doesn't get back to right I mean we all know that so I mean we're doing something right and I think people could learn from us so if we
069have some time over the summer maybe we could do that and each take a Chapter and uh peerreview it and put some thoughts together and try to publish it okay thank you that where's where's Waldo no no no seriously I mean listen it's not that hard to to kick out that could be a school committee goal yeah it could be part of your your idea too right continue grow and growing exactly so that's my thought for today uh so we're just going to motion to receive and place on file what do we do with that can I just make one last silly comment sure I just really appreciate this board modeling to the public and to our students and to our staff members what it means to be like long laress absolutely good motion made
070second all in favor I I opposed eyes have next up administrative business we'll start off with Staffing report see enclosure any questions comments let me get to that page I didn't see anything out of the ordinary file second thank you all in favor I opposed eyes haveit next up we have the taunt Public School Staffing update see en closure yeah just to give committee a quick update we 96% staffed uh three remaining districtwide positions two vacant positions at pole we have one vacant position at fredman one at Parker middle school and two at taon high school and you have the breakdown on the backup rece them plac on file all in favor I I opposed eyes have it thank you next up we have the TA Public Schools district enrollment update so I just wanted
071to make the committee aware since October 1st 2024 where we had an enrollment of 8 , 3115 students as of last week we stand at 8,358 students uh the greatest gain in enrollment was in preschool which that'll be ongoing throughout the school year as students agent to the program so we can expect to see those numbers increase we had 14 students enroll in our preschool program and we also had 12 students enroll in the fifth grade we also saw enrollment increase at the TA Alternative High School and taon public Virtual Academy which accounts for the decreased enrollment in grade 12 at Taun high school and I provide to do with the backup and the breakdown on the second page and for anyone who's wondering what the acronym SP stands for those are students on the
072backup uh which is the fourth fourth line from the bottom SP are 18 to 23 18 to 22 year olds who are housed at ttan High School in the alert program thank you Mr procedure sorry to accept and place on file just a couple of questions so the TV the tpva and the T TS are those just for 12th graders I believe the taon alter the Taunton Public Virtual Academy 8 through 12 8 through 12 and the to Alternative High School we want the students to complete their ninth grade year so 10 through 12 10 through 12 so between 10th 11th and 12th grade um there's approximately 23 students that we lost do we know of those 23 students do they make up the 30 extra students that have gone to those two places based
073based on the I mean I can drill down deeper and get those actuals for you but I believe yes I just worry about um students dropping out so I was just hoping that they were going to one of our other schools versus just dropping out of school and I think that's why you'll see the numbers are taught in Alternative High School especially come March that'll be like the next enrollment cycle and taught in public virtuals that's ongoing that's rolling okay thank you excellent wishes of the committee received them placed on file second second all in favor I opposed eyes have it thank you all next up we have the field trip request the DECA competition uh in your packet you have a field trip request by trip supervisor Jesse mcf and Molly Sullivan taking 158
074students let me repeat that 158 students to the competition down in hyanis uh taking place from January 9th to the 10th and I reviewed everything everything looks complete there was an amendment uh that was added today when uh the original cost was published for the chaperon uh it came in a little bit higher it was initially uh $1,650 and came in at $1,750 it was uh just cost of doing business I guess but we are in compliance with the student per chaperon ratio which is very very important and uh what are the wishes of the committee motional approv is presented second second all in favor I all opposed eyes have thank you next up we have uh subcommittee reports we'll start off with curriculum subcommittee chairman Santos thank you um so the curriculum subcommittee uh
075meeting met on December 5th uh Thursday December 5th the meeting was called to order at 4:05 uh subcommittee members and attendance were Miss Fagan Mrs shavs and myself also in attendance was superintendent John cabraal assistant superintendent Chris Bara Dr John Harrison th s principal Tracy mannard math curriculum supervisor Mike Atwood Ela curriculum supervisor Danielle Koy director of humanities and um deloza director of English language Learners as chair of the subcommittee I felt it was important to meet regarding the most recent passage of the yes on two Campaign which eliminates the mcast as a graduation requirement this was also recommended by superintendent cabal soon after with the addition of the Desi memo reference during the November 20th school committee meeting meeting um it was a robust conversation to say the least that centered around the changing
076competency uh determination based on this ballot measure which is now law in the state of Mass Christopher Bara provided a slideshow to help facilitate the conversation including information about voting rates for the ballot question in Taunton consideration of how the community faculty and students feel about the decision current statistics about students who have not met the requirements of mcast and number of retakes necessary due to not meeting those requirements issues facing District accountability and of course possible rotes the district could now take of these roots we discussed the following possibilities a school committee vote to retain the mcast as the main competency determination a legislative rehearsal of the ballot question in the implementation of the mass core as the competency competency determination there were several concerns regarding the implications of all such Roots um some
077of which were issues presented by the mcast in a more General sense uh in the words of superintendent cabal the mcast assisted with equality and assessment not Equity also referenced by Ms mendo's experience with elll students in Mr Atwood's reference to incoming migrant students and in my own and others concerns that it not only takes time away from content class time but that is not always the best indicator for student learning uh concerning replacing the mcast there were also several concerns uh Miss Sha's concerns over whether students would even take mcast Series without the graduation requirement as well as how we would confront inqu inequalities between districts ultimately CH challenging what a diploma would mean across the board without a standard assessment last lastly when considering Alternatives there were some ideas for creating portfolio assignments
078but with an eye to maintaining grading consistency among courses faculty uh Mr barata had mentioned the imple implementation of professional development for common assessments there was also an important conversation about the implementation of mass core as ceton determination which was implemented in 2007 and amended in 2018 the mass core offers a more holistic approach to curriculum but there were concerns raised about how it would impact students in the CTE programs questions regarding flexibility regarding Mass core requirements were raised uh despite the conversations no initial decisions were made the plan is to wait for further instructions from desie which is now included in our packet for today and then meet again once communication has been received the meeting adjourned at 5:00 p.m. excellent chairman Santos received in place some all and adopt the recommendations okay good
079uh All In seconded by Mr Lura all in favor I I opposed eyes have it thank you next up we have finance and law uh I chair that subcommittee uh the finance and law subcommittee met today uh with consisting of uh Mrs shabs Mr viir and myself uh first item uh on the agenda was a special education expense uh report uh based basically it's just an ongoing um number of how much we're spending on our legal services for uh special education student services related matters our budget is $50,000 for fy2 we expense $ 6,468 in September and our present balance remaining for special education and student services related matters uh remains at$ 27,38 nothing out of the ordinary uh basically uh consistent with years past uh that was voted unanimously to accept the report next
080up we had a board of uh health update report uh there was some some communication regarding uh where this report should have landed and it concluded that it should have been uh uh uh at back at the longterm long range planning and school property subcommittee so the item was tabled uh it will be brought forth in the first meeting in January uh after some outstanding items are to be completed over the break so this item was tabled voting nously uh nothing to report there uh item three was a facilities update uh as Mrs Monahan uh brings us up to speed with the work orders uh what's outstanding what is the responsibility of the schools what is the responsibility of the city Side uh nothing out of the ordinary the work order and uh Mrs Monahan's
081report was received and placed on file voted unanimously uh next next up we had the uh state championship softball and wrestling team uh field trip considered a field trip superintendent uh uh so basically what's happening in your memo uh we are hoping to take our uh softball team and the two state champion wrestlers uh to the Boston Celtics on December 27th uh versus the Indiana Pacers along with that we are also uh supplying commemorative items such as Championship jackets and Rings to celebrate their success and uh in the athletic revolving account I want to again reiterate the athletic revolving account uh remains a balance of approximately $320,000 this anticipated cost would be uh around 10,000 or less so uh again it was voted unanimously by the subcommittee to approve this uh anybody has any discussions
082or anything like that please ask them now uh again vote unanimously by the subcommittee uh the fifth item was the DECA field trip a chaperon um memo and it clearly articulates that our policy requires a one per 10 ratio of adults to students uh like we mentioned earlier it's 1508 I believe students and we have 15 chaperon and we're picking up the expense for the hotel cost for the chaperon which is only fair uh and that expense was mistakenly quoted originally at $1650 for the rooms and it's actually $1,750 so no big deal there we voted anesty to accept that and approve that uh all three subcommittee members voted in favor uh then we had bills payable for FY 25 uh there was a error uh when the agenda was published there was a one
083missing so for the public at home the fy2 bills payable was 1,1,1 51 uh that was revised it was approved and vote unanimously there were some questions and concerns uh I was recorded as voting present on FY on page four I believe it was let me just pull up my notes on a PO number 250 2159 on page 4 in the amount of 12,500 the motion was amended and approved unanimously to uh pay the bills payable for fy2 and the last remaining item on the agenda was FY 24 uh the amount of $83,900 uary still related to fy4 so basically that's the report wishes of the committee motion to accept the report and adopt the recommendations of the subcommittee all in favor I opposed eyes have it thank you so much next up we have
084new business I have a couple of it Mr Laura we had the subcommittee on Elementary this evening but it's not on the agenda next okay very good very so for new business uh if I could uh I believe our student representative NY Duncan mentioned there's a lot going on in Tom Public Schools this week uh last night I had the honor of of being present at the wrestling match I believe Mr Vier and Mrs Fagan were there I don't know who else could have been there but it's a big place uh but uh the championship rings were presented to Ethan Harris and Elijah profit uh it was a great ceremony I think we as a school committee should informally invite our two state champion wrestlers to come before us now one of the wrest is
085is at Rhode Island College I know that we were trying to bring him in him and Elijah in today but there was just some conflicts because there was other stuff going on but maybe in the summer we can bring back these two uh state champions to be recognized before the school committee I think that's only appropriate uh in the same in the same building right up the stairs was the Jazz Band concert which was packed uh I don't know how many kids we have in the jazz band but man it it's it's amazing and and the sound and and the effort that they put in and we have some beautiful instruments those things were shining I mean you know those those saxes and those horns and all that they're not cheap and I know we
086we invest in that but they're well taken care of because you can see them from the audience way up in the rafters almost uh that they're shiny and they're and they're being played very well so uh hats off to us as a school committee for supporting the Arts and the kids did an excellent job and parents and grandparents and friends and neighbors with there um and what else I will be meeting tomorrow with the superintendent myself and secretary Fagan if anybody has any issues or concerns they want to bring to me send me a text tonight tomorrow morning uh let me know and I'll bring it to the superintendent uh we lost kind of track on our bi-weekly meetings so we're going to get back on track for the uh 25y year uh which we
087usually meet the Thursday before the agenda is published for the following meeting so if you keep that in the back of your mind if there's any concerns and of course you're always welcome to reach out to the superintendent directly like you always do but if there's something else you want to mention that's fine uh and that's all I have for new business superintendent yeah the only thing I would just remind the committee to practice uh for anybody that wants to have something on the agenda either email Dr Dello CC me or email me CC Dr Dello and then we'll make sure the item gets on the agenda too in case you you forget to bring something up during the regular meeting that's that has worked really well absolutely that's always uh and sorry and I'd
088be remissed if we didn't recognize one I appreciate the school committee for always authorizing us to purchase laner instruments for our middle schools and our high schools and I also want to recognize the city because they have contributed uh onetime funds to help buy some loaner instruments too and it really benefits our kids absolutely they're their kids too so it's a partnership right uh so that's it for new business if nothing else we'll go on to unfinished business action items update first we have the Chamberlain solar project update see en closure superintendent yeah you have a outline or a timeline of the expected work to take place between now and January 31st where the project will be commissioned and we're going to try to plan a little activity with the kidos at the Chamberlain Elementary
089School maybe actually have a live switch or a real switch and have some of the kids uh flip the switch so uh I'll make sure the committee is involved and hopefully many of you can attend good um uh next up we have the Desi update on competency determination for graduation see en closure the only thing I'll say about this I think Mr barado and I sat through a 1- hour Zoom today and both left with a migraine so uh I provided you with some additional uh backup material regarding the company determination and the local uh policy requirements that we'll be working on so my recommendation as I stated on the second on the third page sorry is to refer this matter to the curriculum subcommittee uh that Mr Santos chairs and we'll continue to work
090and give this some much needed thought and come back to the full board with the recommended policy and the conf determination wish the uh Mrs shz I just wanted to make one comment especially where this is public that part of this um memo talks about inclusivity of former students and I think that's important that um we're required to accommodate former stud students who have not earned the competency determination so even if they've left us and did not get a diploma um there will be something in this for them to come back and um receive a diploma and I think that's important for people that are watching this that may have an interest in it and I think as we work on how that is going to look we definitely obviously bring it um forward but
091I just think that it's nice to sort of let this out now because there could be lot of lot of former students that would be interested in doing this yeah we we have a lot of work ahead of us to really be very Mindful and very thoughtful about how we go about this because there all there as we learned today every time we have a zoom meeting with desie there are new moving parts that we have to make sure that we're accounting for I can't believe that superintendent because we just went through Co and it was a moving part every three minutes I think I had fls y exactly unfortunately but that's desie uh last item on unfinished business is the action item update I believe we can strike some items no not at this
092time colonary kitchen is not done yet no okay sorry the latest update on The Culinary Kitchen we're expecting to have everything hopefully up and running after the final inspections on January 13th that's when we're hoping to have that one wrapped up and we probably should have another long range planning meeting to discuss uh hope well and I'll work with the chairs of any of the of the and I'll work with you Dr Dello regarding the um traffic patterns but uh I'll work with the subcommittee chairs to move some of this work along and hopefully get some of these items uh you know finalized and off this list yeah regarding the uh traffic and parking at Taunton High School I haven't heard any Rumblings is anybody on the committee no it's been a very smooth year
093knock on wood so that's good yeah no I knocked on wood superintendent I knocked on wood so it's all good uh next item we have press any press in the audience none and before we adjourn if before we adjourn on on behalf of all our members of course we wish everyone at home a happy holiday season a very blessed new year with health and good wishes and that we all come back healthy for 2025 and have a great 2025 so on behalf of the entire school committee happy holidays motion to adjourn and be in honor all in favor I I opposed eyes have it we are adjourned thank you everyone