001good evening the uh finance and law subcommittee shall come to order today is Wednesday December 18th uh 5:45 pm I believe time is 5:46 uh first up uh we have a attendance we have Mr Vieira Mrs shavs and myself uh first item on the agenda we have a special education expense service report see attached memo Mrs Monahan please thank you Dr damelo again this is our monthly update for contracted Legal Services um from Lions Law Group for fy2 we have a budget of $50,000 for September of 2024 for the services rendered was $646 which totals up to $ 22,616 year to date which leaves us our balance currently at $ 27,38 for special ed and student services related matters excellent any questions concerns wishes of the committee motion to accept the report second is all
002in favor I opposed eyes have next up we have item two BO which stands for Board of Health update report C attached memo Mr Vie thank you Mr chairman I have a question um I the vote that we took at the last school committee meeting I thought it was to get an update from the the Board of Health at the first of the year in Long Range planning and public property report uh my recollection of the vote was to include Board of Health inspections when the board of health comes and inspects that would be part of the facilities update so you're talking about the subcommittee when we met yeah okay yeah I I I also I was there of course I'm a subcommittee member of that committee I don't know if there was any ambiguities
003or I mean clearly there I I think the conern if who else was on that committee myself uh Mr re he was we were absent that day or were you there I'm sorry okay so I I think the recollection was that we couldn't get a complete report until after the holidays because there was some missing items that had to be done while school was not in session correct it was in a high traffic area and the work couldn't be performed and uh during school hours so it would either a have to be done on the weekend or it would have to be done during the school break and it would probably take a time frame till the first of the year if my if I could I would love to read out the report a
004little bit so you can understand of what we presented um correct it was what we discussed at the meeting at the long range planning so during that long range planning all the Board of Health um items are listed in here in that behind it and the only item that is outstanding like you said it was going to be done um in the hi traffic area is one is going to be done at the high school and it's actually going to be done this weekend so so again I thought the purpose of the vote was to be informed not to when the Board of Health was here and what the report entailed and what the work was required to be part of the facilities not so we may have we may have misinterpreted um the motion
005so what you have in front of you and this is just one this is a sample of what you'll be getting moving forward and we can provide the appropriate backup because this will this can serve as a summary as in addition to all the reports so am I hearing that instead of coming to finance and law those reports would just go to the long range planning meeting not Finance in law well well I I I think the intent was to kind of uh again this all started with a public uh citizen reaching out to me I don't know if you got the same call regarding issues with our schools uh where there were Board of Health reports now being publicly advertised in the city website okay and when the question was asked to me are
006you aware of these violations I said I had no idea but I look into it I prompted a call to the superintendent uh and then of course we came together as a subcommittee to better evaluate the reports that I believe you Mr Vier went down to the Board of Health to collect I I did a series of reports for the last three and I printed some off the off their website off the website but I they weren't all there so I I think the intent is uh to start the Academic Year in January when we came back with a clean bill of health and eventually have the food service director come before us I think that was mentioned too to give us a report because I don't think we've seen the food service director here
007for a while so I'm still so pardon my ignorance so we're not to bring this report you don't want this the the committee the finance and law committee does not want this report as part of markus's facilities update which that was my interpretation what Mr frus does his monthly facilities require that we will go if if the Board of Health had conducted their inspections that we would attach that to Mr Fred's facilities report so would be one encompassing report covering all facilities but if I am I hearing something different that we rather have this go through long range no I think the only the only step that missing is go through the long range and then we report out as a subcommittee to so it's not coming here well no hold on hold on superintendent
008then then we eventually get the Master report right that because they come out four times a year right yeah absolutely again I thought it was pertaining to the the Board of Health reports themselves when they were conducted how else would we have an awareness of when they conducted other than uh through that process right so we would bring them to finance and La as part of the facilities report but again some of these violations went back you know six months nine months did the last Academic Year we never heard about we talked about moving forward right right so so if they're going to happen four times a year so again maybe we should talk offline on how the committee wants to streamline this sure because for transparency purposes this meeting is televised so anyone who's
009watching the meeting will see this they're not going to see this they're not going to see long range planning they're going to hear the report out absolutely for transparency purposes we thought this would be more transparent for the public we'll accommodate the wishes of the committee no and again we're that's why we're here because we want to be transparent that's why we called the subcommittee meeting because we had public outcry saying that our schools were not in the best of state of of sanitary conditions not all of them some issues that were there and was brought to my attention we convened the subcommittee and I don't want to drag this on but you know I think we're we're circumventing a subcommittee we shouldn't because there's an action item that's not complete within the subcommittee that
010me that is is expecting a deliverable from what I unod after the new year and I just want to be clear that the intention was not to circumvent right because this Our intention was not to circumvent Our intention was to provide you with the report and the format that we interpreted that we were going to use moving forward when Mr frus provides his monthly facilities report we were going to put it all together so you would see the work orders as well as the Board of Health reports when they're completed but we'll go through the long range planning committee that's fine and and so the public also knows as many subcommittee meetings that aren't televised but I'm more than happy to televise all all subcommittee meetings going forward maybe that's a conversation we have to
011have with Mr Jake too absolutely and they are public so they can definitely come down at any time so on item two Board of Health update report what are the wishes of the committee do we want the report reported out today or do you want to wait until the first I I I actually we did say the first meeting in January we were specific right so we were specific I want to do so you know it's up to you Donna and Mrs shavs and Mr viir if you want it out tonight or if you want to wait for the actual completion of all the outstanding items which was supposed to be delivered by the first meeting in January I personally don't see a problem with it being put into this report because I to me
012it makes sense but I understand what you're saying that this was something that came from your subcommittee so it may need to be reported back to your subcommittee so I'm the item okay I'll second it then second all in favor I I oppos eyes have it item three facilities update C attached memo Mrs is mon um director of facilities Mark fedus provided us with um the work orders from July 1st through December 12th the work orders throughout the city of 60 buildings um over just over a thousand work orders were placed and 785 of those work orders were um done by taught in public schools so that's 78% of all work if you look on the next page you'll see as we do each month um Mr freed has provided us with the number of
013work orders that are open which is 168 and work orders that are closed 843 and then below you'll see the work orders open and closed per School excellent make a motion to accept the report and place on file second all in favor I opposed eyes have it uh next up we have item three uh state championship softball and wrestling team C attach memo I didn't find a memo in my packet anybody have a memo no no does anybody have in the not the wrestling I have the softball it's softball the wrestling oh I have I I talked about a field trip they were invited to a Celtics game their families were invited I did see uh my packet but I can't put place okay so I I guess I I can read it I mean
014because this is the first time say maybe it wasn't in my packet I don't remember seeing this um from Finance to the finance and law subcommittee from Brenda man assistant superintendent Finance operations authorization of expenses for state champions recognition uh I'm pleased to share that the Totton High School softball team has achieved an extraordinary uh Milestone by winning the state championship additionally we are thrilled to recognize our two state champ champon wrestlers who brought home individual titles ear earlier this year to appropriately honor these achievements uh we have planned several recognition activities these include number one commemorative items such as Championship jackets and Rings to celebrate their success number two an invitation to attend a Boston Celtics home game on December 27th versus the Indiana Pacers with the softball team and the two state champion
015wresters will be special guests uh as these expenses fall outside of our standard budget allocation I'm requesting authorization from the school committee to cover the costs asso with associated with these initiatives which we pay through the athletic revolving account thank you for consideration I appreciate your support in this matter and please join me in extending heartfelt congratulations to the team their coaches and the state champion wrestlers for their outstanding accomplishments and there's a a note here that this is uh athletic what is this superintendent I'm sorry no just in case the question regarding the balance of the athletic revolving account there $320,000 in the atic roling account so okay what is this going to cost do we know jackets and the Rings and tickets 10,000 okay questions Mr VI is a cap on it appropriate
016or do you want to just you think it's good the way it is presented yeah I if you want an itemized breakdown I can but we're just looking for authorization to use the funds that we include in the athletic devolving to cover all the expenses and it's not going to be anything anything I mean we're not covering their food it's just going to be Transportation the tickets the jackets and the state championship rings make a motion to approve is presented I second it uh all in favor I I opposed eyes have it great Indian Indiana pesic that should be a win for the Celtics uh next up we have the DECA field trip uh chaperon C attached memo I guess Mrs Monahan um so on January 9th in 2025 158 students from TT in high
017school's Deca chapter will be attending Regional Deca competition in hyanis per our field trip policy which requires one chaperon for every 10 students this event will require 15 adult chaperon to minimize the impact on day-to-day operations at Taunton High School Mr mcao which is the Decker um adviser plans to bring five staff members from his Department to serve to serve as chaperon the remaining six chaperon slots will be filled by caregivers of students participating in the competition this reason for this is to significantly reduce the number of THS staff required to attend ensuring that classes remain covered by content certified teachers rather than substitutes which will directly benefit student learning right now our current policy which is outlined um in The Mask web the masc website does not explicitly address covering cost for caregiver chaperon
018therefore I'm requesting that the finance and law subcommittee authorize the school department to cover hotel costs for these caregivers from the THS cvte budget the estimated cost for the accommodation is approximately $1,750 for these six chaperon it is not worth noting that that while this type of expense has been approved in the past it has not occurred in this scale as such it is important to notify the city auditor that this request and payment will require the committee's authorization additionally I recommend that the field trip policy be revised in the near future to address situations involving care caregiver um chaperon this would provide greater Clarity and guidance for similar events for the future and reduce need for case-by case requests finally of course all this jargon I definitely want to go ahead and join me
019in Wishing our students the best of luck this competition will determine who advances to the state level and potentially to the national competition and we of course are proud of their efforts and are compet and are committed to supporting them on their Journey good wishes of the committee I can make a motion that we approve it okay second uh on discussion so just to clear things up uh you mentioned five chaperon I believe it's total of 15 chaperon including our staff correct five teachers 10 10 gotcha okay and this 1750 figure is for those 15 chaperons including our teachers because it's only one night right they're only staying there one night so it's only hundred some odd dollars for the 10 sh for the sh5 per room gotcha okay and uh just for the public
020at home when the uh agenda was published the amount uh approximate amount was stated as $1,650 and there was a revision uh which was made on the 16th of December uh to clearly state that it was $1,750 okay so people at home that they saw the agenda online it's the $1,750 uh number we're approving tonight so that's my first point of discussion the second point of discussion uh the blanket authorization uh I'm not in favor of that for a couple of reasons every trip is unique uh we don't know I mean we could be going to a hotel that's costing 400 bucks a night we don't know what that is so I I I guess the best course of action as the motion was made by Mrs shave is we're just approving the 1750 for
021this trip is that correct just this trip gotcha okay okay and no blanket authorization going down the road okay great uh have a policy yeah but I mean the policy again you know every trip is unique this happens how many times a year no the policy we can specify any concerns you might have regarding anything like it like the policy could state that we bring committee authorization we're doing right now right which which is fine I guess I mean you know we don't we have one of these a year I think deca's once twice a year they they're going have they're have their Boston trip and then they're going to have the international trip and then we also have other organizations skills USA so just to have something in place whatever protocol will follow just
022so we Mrs moam the bus office and High School organizing these trip they know the procedures and the policy you got to follow that way they just don't take it for granted or just assum right yeah and the policy is one per 10 the ratio right so I guess that's covered as far as granting a blanket uh something to be discussed in the future so the motion was second in all in favor I opposed eyes have thank you next up we have the bills payable uh first off we have bills payable for FY 25 and for the folks at home there was a typo on the bills payable uh it was listed as 1 million there was a one missing so the uh amount that's on discussion for tonight for approval is the amount of
0231,111 4151 wishes of the committee motion to approving the amount stated second it on discussion second on discussion Mr shs um I have four questions page one the first one that Bell for it says says graduation what was what was that for those are her um the diploma covers okay um page five base 10 assets L LLC for the $1,595 it says other Student Activities yeah that I'm sorry base State interpreters base base 10 assets okay on page five down to the bottom obviously so here it is sorry about that um these are for the other Student Activities is they are for the robotics Club um supplies okay page eight city of Boston programs with others I didn't know what the program that was these are for um specialized programs it's for one student for
024September and October tuition oh it's a tuition month oh okay that one I didn't no and the last one was on page 23 that Rugby Architectural Building Products um for $9,999 199 that is for the THS wood shop supplies wood shop supplies yes okay that's all I had for questions thank you thank you Mr sh Mr VI thank you Mr chairman uh page four attuned education Partners LLC in the amount of $66,667 they are professional development and that was for development that professional development that was provided for us um in July July okay and then on page 29 Vex robotics Vex robotics again those are robotics Club supplies so the the supplies are for robotics the class robotics excuse me not not Club um class and if I could just add if anybody happens to
025be at the high school tomorrow or Friday in the middle of the lobby you'll actually see they have the ring for the robotics team to practice with with their robots well that's excellent I was there today it's wonderful news thank you for sharing that superintendent those uh those conclude my questions thank you m thank you Mr VI Mrs mon I have just a few mhm uh on page four uh again we have the uh voucher uh number voucher zero but PO number 250 2159 the amount of 12,500 uh I think I've repeatedly asked for an update from this organization uh and I don't know when they're coming in because I'm G not going to vote Yes on this okay sorry Mr Bara no I've actually had uh two meetings in person and one virtual with
026AHS uh identifying when they provide services to what students they provide services and they provide with monthly reports so if superintendent directs me I can release it to the monthly reports and I will continue to follow up with them uh especially they want to make more inroads with supporting our um overaged or older students uh multilingual Learners that're in um registering at the high school because they want to reach out and support them as well as part of our task force so uh you you'd like to provide us with monthly reports they provide us with they're providing me now going back to October they're providing me now with monthly reports we'll put it in the next fin all right yeah again because this was a concern last year they came in uh the end of
027the Academic Year with a presentation that I think was put together the day of the deal didn't give us any information and I'm not going to be signing off on something that we're not getting a return on so so um I guess I'll wait for the next report Mr Bara thank you so much uh page number eight oh Mrs sha city of Boston I have the same question page page 10 so we have one of our employees that went on a a conference I believe uh that's the item for 13259 uh hotel and all that why didn't we use the PE card for the hotel um this this sometimes what will happen is they will go ahead and put forth a a PD form and they did not request um the PE card I didn't
028see this one so but I could always go ahead and work with um the curriculum office to see if there's um when a PD form comes and there is asking for pricing or some um amount to be reimbursed to reach out to the staff member to use the PE card instead okay but that would be after the fact right well no because they have to get the approval from the curriculum office and then so when they review that we will go ahead and reach out to the staff member to use the PE card to pay for the program okay all right so this one slipped that's okay but as long as the you know there's an education component to this to the traveler so that they're aware too I mean I hate people waiting for
029money this is $1,325 that they've been waiting for for a while so you know you have to give it 15 days anyway so we do a lot faster than it used to but again we'd rather use the PE card absolutely and and let's see one last item I have let's see uh page 20 I've already addressed an item with the superintendent on page 20 uh so that's good and last but not least page 29 we have a couple of uh of PDs to University of Florida University of Kansas Center for research um I I just get sometimes not upset but better understanding of why we're going out to to Florida and Kansas we have so many prestigious universities uh within almost walking distance uh I know sometimes some of this stuff is pretty specialized but
030um so the University of Florida actually has to do with the literacy component it's called youly it's a early intervention pheic awareness structured learning program which our title one uh teachers use so that PD is directly with them for the resources we purchased the University of Kansas actually has to work with Lisa deaker she us used to be at another site she's actually now University of Kansas I believe uh that's through the 240 Grant and she's actually making site visits with building principles and such going through looking at the inclus model along with providing PD and actually she's doing a study of Tom public schools and the effectiveness of co- teing which I don't want to speak for Miss moam but I think the end of this year maybe early next year she's going to
031produce a report on behalf of Taunton Public Schools to look at what progress we have made great thank you Mr bar and that's it for me so the motion was made and seconded uh I'm going to uh just vote uh to uh record my vote on um page four uh v p number 252 2159 the amount of 12,500 I'm voting present on that so if the make of the motion could kindly include that in the amendment I'm sorry so you want me to just just so amend the motion to just amend the motion that I'm voting pres that you're voting present for that 12,500 correct yep okay second oh I'm sorry you made the motion I'm sorry I'm sorry I don't know motions been made amended by Mr Vieira seconded by Mrs shabs yes is
032that correct yes all in favor I I opposed eyes have it good that was fy2 now FY 24 the amount payable is $83,900 so there could be some outstanding um outstanding yes a few here and there but we have really driven down the FY 24 um open posos that were outstanding okay great okay uh all in favor I I opposed eyes have it thank you uh motion to adjourn be an order Mo seconded all in favor I I opposed eyes have it we are adjourned thank you e