001all right thank you I want to call the meeting to order for December the 17th 2024 of the Shen tech school committee and if you think nobody watches these meetings I actually got a request last night via email somebody asking for the link so people are watching our ratings it might be because of some of the people we have joining us tonight quen got an honorable men own um so uh first of all the quick roll call I it appears that everyone is here and accounted for so we have everybody is present for the meeting and I'm saying that is H are you is Karen she Corner okay good all right uh First Act is the Pledge of Allegiance everybody hand up Al to the flag of the United stes stes of America and to
002the repu for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all all right our student representative report from Sophia it's pleasure to be here again um I'll be uh I'll begin my report by highlighting our clubs Esports had 35 students participating in the fall session they created four groups of students to play a popular game called valerant these students were able to compete against many other schools on the East Coast through an organization called the high school Esports League further they had two groups for a game called smash ultimate which took part of the state Varsity Esports program hosted by playvs considering the group displayed fantastic sportsmanship and teamwork they plan to run run another session for the spring season however for students looking for a less competitive experience we
003have a video game club Wednesdays after school regardless of the Season about 20 to 40 students utilize this program the robotics team attended the Vex V5 High State qualifier Tournament located at Whitman Hansen Regional High School last Saturday December 14 the Rams were United with Coach Matt Natalie whom LED Cape Cod Tech the team members displayed outstanding sportsmanship yet again and teamwork align with Cape Cod Tech um Pro proved to be wise as the team proceeded to the quarterfinals semi-finals and finals which they were defeated after a hard-fought battle ultimately the Rams and Cape Cog groter came in second place oratory Club was scheduled to speak at the bcka allance club last Wednesday December 11th however due to weather conditions the contest has been postponed to January 15 there are three shashing contestants two sophomores
004including myself and and a senior as well as one student from boera Memorial High School this wonderful opportunity allows the winner of the contest to face other Regional winners this February we are those students who win regionals they will continue on to a state competition in April the anti-bullying Club held a successful cocoa and canvas night similar to like a sip in paint earlier today the club although under new advisory is creating a strong Community particularly for freshmen who may be looking to get involved at school the student cabinet is still tackling ways to best support lowincome students by identifying barriers and solutions to best Aid this group and will meet again this Thursday newspaper Club released their first paper which highlighted student literature art and events such as our open house Turkey Bowl fall
005Sports and Super Bowl last Tuesday skillsusa hosted their annual officer installation ceremony which highlighted seven student leaders narah Oscar Spencer talot Devon Donnelly Carmela DC McKenzie Miller Karina Palencia and Gian manues other than clubs many of our construction shops including Automotive Electrical Graphics plumbing and metal fabrication are in the process of creating displays for stone Zoo's zoo light event this hard work part put in by these students contributes to a magical experience for hundreds of local students who reside in hansam Air Force Base were able to attend a youth center shopping trip last Friday the 13th it took place from 5:00 to 10:30 p.m. at March Valley Outlets these students are also eligible for a study club which meets every Wednesday the goal of this program is to provide a quiet study space for people
006but also offer assistance with things such as SATs time management and college interests academically students utilizing Rosetta Stone World Language program's fall session which started in October must finish their courses soon the session ends December 31st in order to be reflected on the students transcripts although through my experience it is nothing compared to an inperson Spanish class it is an exceptional way for students to earn college required Spanish classes while working around our tight schedule yesterday 86 students in the class of 2025 were rewarded with John and Abigail Adams scholarships for having top mcast scores this week freshmen are finishing up their eighth explore cycle and only have six more until they um choose their permanent shop and last but not least Quarter Two midterm grades are now finalized as of last Friday the 13th
007and I hope everyone has a wonderful holiday that's all you so much have a good night it's a tough act to fall uh it seems like a particularly appropriate year to have a fall sports report uh from athletic director Al cerel uh who was joined here tonight by some folks that have done some great things in the fall sports team I'm GNA turn it right over to Al thank you Mr chairman I appreciate it and thank you all of you for all the support you've given to our athletes and our teams Through The Years last year just uh I'm going to give a quick overview in intro into it and we'll let each of our coaches uh and the uh athletes speak as well a quick overview last year we set a School record winning
008the Markham award and winning nearly 75% of our games with all our Varity Sports combined that's a tough act to follow last year we're off to a great start this year and we have we had three championship teams this fall we have our repres our head coach and representatives of our VA girls volleyball or co-ed volleyball team and also our Championship golf team and I'm here with my three football captains for our championship Super Bowl team so I'm going to give them a chance to introduce themselves and each coach to talk a little bit about their Championship season um Katie and I and were were honored with being named coach of the year in appropriate ways we owe it all to these young people and that's why I want them to speak because you know
009I get credit with a lot of football wins over my career I haven't made one tackle of those games I haven't blocked a single person in any of those games I haven't caught a pass no wait one did come out of bounce and I got it on the first bounce but it's these people that do it your support the support of everybody around us the community was so honored and me I'm very lucky 27 years head football coach 20 years as ad I'm a lucky guy I came to a great place I'm hanging around because I really don't want to leave it's a great place so without further Ado I'd like to turn it over to our volleyball Coach K mcginness who was also Coach of the Year this year for CAC and let her
010go from there thank you um this volleyball season we went 20 and0 in our regular season um one uping our season from last year where we went 1901 we made it to the state V tournament for the second year in a row and this time we came away with the championship um this is the best recorded season in volleyball history here at josen um and like Al said it's all because of these guys right here and the hard work that they put in um so I'll have them my captains introduce themselves hi I'm I'm making a Larry or Mo you could say a little something tell us about volleyball Frank um I'm Frankie Reen I don't know can you tell us what shops you you represent so I can go first um I'm in health
011assisting here I'm a senior I'm also I'm a senior in electrical I'm a junior in draft nice crosssection um yeah that's that's that was our season girls congratulations and I know you learned a lot of life's lessons through fing for your coaches and with the sports I'd like to turn it over to our Guru of golf the gur of golf Tom strs yes hello everyone um I I have to kind of Replay what they both said um I've been very lucky as well um this is my this was our 20th my 20th year on the coaching Golf and I have to say I've had some fantastic athletes over the years it's always been geez in every Tri out there's always been like three or four kids that come in they just they shock you they
012surprise you at how good they are and um these two these two are one of those or two of these kids that happened um this is this is Max Carpenter he's one of our captains he's a junior and this is Larry col he's a senior Captain for us as well um these two led us to our 20th straight CAC Championship which is nice um like I said we're we've been blessed I think we finished the season 14 and one we lost uh our only one to Burlington which was a tight one we had a couple of our people out sick but um you know as I said is always next year um we won our CAC tournament again this year I think that was probably out of 20 that was probably our 16th time that
013we've done that um we we've been very blessed we've been very lucky we have great support from athletic director Al uh from the school the business business uh office so they support us very well and we we're very blessed Bo you want to I already did introduce you you just want to say hello a great season C do all to like coaching we helped every kid that need help and hopefully we continue once I leave to keep on winning when they yeah definitely wasn't just us though definitely had uh more kids on the team so yeah it was a good group it's like a little family what shops I'm an electrical senior same electrical junior thank you hey guys do you play any other sports I play baseball that's it I got a hockey and
014Lacrosse hockey and Lacrosse you play others I do volleyball basketball and Lacrosse I do track um I play softball multiport athletes here all multiport athletes um I'll I'll bring up the uh end here and my captains turn it over to my captains um we were CAC Champs these three seniors we've done a whole lot of winning with them uh with 37- two our last 39 games over the three years um three straight CAC titles uh three straight final fours two trips to Gillette and we were fortunate to get some Revenge this year on the team that knocked us out last year thank you um it was cold Sharon um before I turn it over to my captains I just want to say that these three and all these athletes here are hard workers but this
015group in particular I've been coaching football nearly 40 years 33 years as a head coach the hardest working group I have ever coached and they came back with this leadership to my left determined to avenge what happened last year and by far the hardest working group I've ever had without a doubt and in all my years and I'm so proud of them I think you can tell how proud I am but uh they're multisport athletes I'm going to let them introduce themselves take it away I'm a senior I'm in plumbing I wrestle I play football and I do track in the spring what's your name who are you the world theam what you Bray Carbone Plumbing senior football wrestling and Lacrosse uh Zack Timmons senior I'm an eack and I play hockey lacrosse and football
016and last year you hockey went to the final four during the maram year and we have uh wrest Champions here to my left state champions New England Champions allamerican so very very honored to to have coached these people very honored I'm very lucky I'm very lucky I don't know if I mentioned that earlier a lucky guy we should mention um since we have some of the folks here um yes obviously the Super Bowl was great and it was 60 degrees today which is about 50 degrees warmer than it was that night um but in addition to you what I want to appreciate the uh principal cook and superintendent and Kevin and some of the other staff members who brought a bus load of folks down there and those sections 105 to 108 were pretty well
017filled up that night with people from the Shashi Community everybody to my knowledge was well behaved it was very very well received and and people really appreciated it it was a great sort of culmination of you know excellent Sports season and uh it's also interesting to hear what else what else you all do thank you very Brian I just wanted to say and because Sports have been a big major part of my life ktie Katie we love what you're doing in the library you have brought such life back to that volleyball so proud to to follow it ladies you did an incredible job put us on the map they did and I hope it's going to stay golf we got I wish I could play as good as you guys you amazing you're amazing and
018you got a great coach and guys I got think about this the coach knows this when you get to the mountain you got to get it done and I'm I was playing my play I hope they wi this game because you know said when you get to that championship match and you lose it they don't care 10 years from now they say he gota wion the Super Bowl and that's it I saw it in 2010 but that think was harder this time because it's a better form different format so congratulations congratulations to everybody and U so I'm just very proud be part of the school thank thank you very much we appreciate that all right thank you thank you all of you how you gonna do now that be bigo they are they're big shoes
019to Phil they they don't come along like this often you know you're right about that they'll well what a ride what a ride good we got a little more left too two more seasons you'll be back for a winter uh summary I'm sure winter sport sum I will look forward to and by I didn't me ask Katie since you had to share the um Coach of the Year Award with your sister right yes um is there going to be a Bila High School versus shaen match at some point we always say we're do it with no Spectators No cameras no one can ever talk about it my parents are very worried that we'll never sleep again in a hall she also went 20 and0 it was yeah it was a fun season lot of wins
020in that family together pretty good pretty good we also did both Go 23 and one in total so was been fun unbelievable family competition yeah wow all right impressive ladies gentlemen thank you everything thank you thank you all of you we appreciate all you do you there bye everyone thank you thank you thank you we should do that Katie we'll sell tickets okay sister versus sister don't have any uh anybody signed up for public comment tonight so we'll move to our next item uh principal cook is going to speak on the uh climate survey School climate survey not climate as in general not not here to talk about global warming School climate I can stand this is fine so thank you everybody for having me here um I have some folders that just have a
021lot of data if you're interested in digging into it um and a copy of the um presentation if it's easier to see from your seats but thank you for having me here to speak about this our school climate survey window closed less than a month ago so you're actually the first group who's formally seeing um the data that's been put together and so there'll be more meetings to be had following this but I will jump right in uh with some background so the rationale for doing a school climate survey um it had been a Mas recommendation at our last desial visit and then our five-year Focus visit we'd had some plans um to implement that and then Co hit and threw everything back and so in our school Improvement plan last year we had a
022goal of researching and selecting a survey and making a plan to implement and the goal for this year was to implement the survey and use that data to identify priority areas to Target for improvement so briefly I just want to talk about how we selected the survey so last last spring I reviewed and shared a number of resources with our admin team thankfully um the re the uh Center of excuse me Center for safe and supportive learning environments which is funded by the US Department Department of Education had put together this great resource um included over 25 options for student surveys 22 for staff 13 for families and it really broke down and described how the survey was used in practice and research and what you can get out of it so we had reviewed
023all of those OP options and then we selected a few and looked at the actual questions in the surveys um some of them were incredibly long 60 plus questions um we opted for one that had been implemented more recently between 2017 and 2020 and had um some shorter surveys for example the student one was 36 questions as opposed to like 68 and um there were so many options in terms of how you could administer the survey if you had to pay for the survey so ultimately I won't walk you through our whole process but what we did select was a survey that is hosted by the center on PBIS positive behavioral interventions and support and they adopted the Georgia school climate survey um which uh had a student staff and family component so we felt
024it made the most sense to go forward with that and with this survey they allowed you to host it on your own platform or use theirs so we piloted it using uh Google forms last year with just staff and what we found from that is some folks felt it was too easy for them to be identified by the school and we ultimately decided that we'd probably get better participation if we went through PBIS so that people felt safe that their um their feedback would be anonymous so um in terms of the three surveys so the student survey um broken into eight survey topic areas School connect connectedness peer social support adult social support cultural acceptance social and Civic learning physical environment school safety and Order and discipline listed out the number of questions in each
025section because it gives you a score per question and per section and we had 180 students participate um the recommendation is to have at least 100 students so we had uh more than that which was awesome for our staff survey um oh sorry and the student survey had 36 questions it was the longest one they also had a short nine question student survey but we decided we wanted the most the more robust one with the 36 questions um the staff survey and I won't list all of these categories in each one I know you can all read that but that was broken into six question uh six sections with 29 questions we had 97 staff participate and then for the parent Guardian survey um by PBS referred to as the families survey had 21 Questions
026broken up over five sections and we had 327 uh responses to that which was pretty awesome all of these were voluntary we sent links out to the communities um so as with any service survey you have some selection bias there you have to wonder like who Ops in versus who Ops out um and as we look through the scores all the questions were based on a fourpoint ler type scale ranging from strongly disagree to strongly agree and so for all surveys when you look at the score a higher score represents a more positive um perception of school climate all right so on the student survey results um I you each have like a very detailed packet of all the data I put together but for the sake of this I'm giving an overview I'm not
027giving every page there but if there are any data dorks on the committee I figured you could dive in on your own time so um these are the mean scores for each of the eight sections in the student survey the mean score overall was 2.94 the national samples new score was 2.92 so we're consistent with that um going through you can easily identify areas of strength you can see social and Civic learning a 3.57 out of four was strong for students and then it ju I just showed the actual questions from this and the scores within that section so for example I treat other students fairly 3.62 doing the right thing is important to me 3.63 and so on so this was an absolute area of strength in respons for students and then on the
028opposite end the lowest score was for the category cultural acceptance with 2.34 so thinking like a two equates with disagree and three agree right because the the scale goes from strongly disagree to strongly agree and so under cultural acceptance you can see um this is the category where pretty much all the lowest question scores came from um so for example students at my school treat each other with respect the mean score was 2.17 on that for example and so this level of analysis alone lets you quickly say hey this is the area we have to continue to celebrate this is the area we need to dive into for improvement there's a lot you can do with the data so on this next slide there were 36 um student questions so I just ranked by score
029highest to lowest the top 16 questions that's something that you want to look through and in the column all the way to the left it tells you the survey section it's from so the top five were from section five it's the one on the last slide that was our highest area and then on the flip this scale over on the right um has it is ranked from lowest score so the bottom 16 scores and we can see you know section four a number of those questions are obviously in there because that was the lowest score so so this allows you to see the mean score per question um when we look at this data a bit deeper with the admin team when I bring it to school council other teams at the school um one
030thing I was able to do that they give us the raw data but they don't have it all compiled together like this so you have three packets um in your folders one for each survey so the student data survey this is just section one and what it does is it has the questions all the way to the left it gives you the mean score but then and this is based on self-reporting by the student you can look at subgroups by gender by race and ethnicity by grade um the grade zero is just a student who didn't say their grade um by IEP status and by sexual identity one of the limitations with using the PBIS platform um that I didn't anticipate I didn't realize they wouldn't give us raw numbers around Dem graphic data so
031I can't the only thing I can tell you is each subgroup up here had five or more respondents if it was five or less they didn't include it so for example you'll see that we have some parents who responded identifying as multi-racial but no students did so that let me rephrase that if students did it was fewer than five so that category is not here so I always like to see raw numbers in addition because if they there are five in one category versus 95 in another like that's not really an equal playing field so that is one limitation of using theirs so that first packet you have does this breakdown of the data for each of the eight sections in the student climate survey and then has an overall mean score for each subgroup
032actually I'll say one more thing about this this so with all the data that we look at school accountability data for example we always look by subgroup just to identify know we could be doing well overall and see that one group is far lower than another or higher and so that is one of the things we'll dive into deeper so shifting gears a little bit our staff survey results again we have the mean scores by the six categories overall the mean score was 3.12 um the mean score from the national sample was 3.05 uh the high score for staff was the category of school safety so again the questions from that section um you know the highest being question 16 I feel safe when entering and leaving my SK School building 3.63 you know if
033we wanted to improve in this school safety section we can see question 15 is the lowest at 2.95 I report unsafe or dangerous behaviors I can be sure the problem will be taken care of so even within the section we did best we can delineate where maybe we need to look um if there are some things that we can improve and then parental involvement uh was the lowest mean score on the staff survey uh with a score of 2.73 so for example parents at my school attend PTA me meetings and our conferences a 2.67 um for the staff this just ranks from highest score to lowest all of the questions on that survey similar to the student slide on the left it shows you what survey section it's from I try to just show a
034couple different views because I know people process information differently and then similarly the second packet um is Staff data by subgroup uh the only questions they asked were based on gender race ethnicity and by grade and again it only shows white or no response for race ethnicity because if anyone chose another category there were fewer than five people who did we'll just do the same thing with the uh parent guardian or fames survey results uh this had five categories if you notice the parents mean scores are the strongest overall um 3.48 3.47 so the top four categories are all just very strong so I didn't break any of them down but I thought it was worthwhile breaking down the lower one parental involvement so um it's interesting and and I'll ask about this on the
035last slide but you know depending on what is asked in these surveys and they differ so much you know this is asking up they are involved but there aren't questions like you know does the school offer you opportunities to get involved which is a very different question right so um that's something for us to look at again the mean score for all sections 3.32 compared to the to the National sample at 3.4 and um you can see all of the parent questions except two the mean score was a three or higher so agree or strongly uh excuse me strongly agree so the parent surveys seem to be the strongest in terms of results and then again just one example from the first section um we can see for the family survey we can see by
036gender by race ethnicity and by grade and that is the third packet in there has for all five sections in the m so some immediate takeaways you know Tony Tony had asked me to do a brief overview today like I said we're just at the start I just finished getting all this data together this week um we're going to be meeting in different groups about it for instance a school council there are some immediate takeways you can get just from a quick glance at the data so students value being positive members of our school community and we need to highlight and celebrate that section five on their survey will all questions about them as an individual and what they contribute and those were all well over um three is an average in contrast student scores
037reflect that students do not find the student body overall as being accepting and respectful of one another as they perceive themselves to be to their peers right and that's where we saw section four cultural acceptance be low so it's interesting most students are rating themselves high on some of these things but they're not viewing the student body as a whole that way I think that's something interesting for us to dig into overall students report having peers and staff they can turn to for support which would you'd assume would mean high scores for like wanting to come to school but the scores in the school connectedness section for example looking forward going to school the average there is under a three um don't match this very high you know 3.4 3.3 scores they're putting about students
038um and staff they can turn to so that's something that for us to dig into um sta feels safe at school they feel connected to their colleagues those are two very strong sections but in the section on PE adult relations that's where we see some of the averages below three some of the things about the behavior of students towards staff or some perceptions so that's something for us to dig into and parents and Guardians report high levels of positive feedback across all categories despite low scores on Parental involvement from both staff and families and maybe that's um maybe that's just true and it's what it is or maybe the questions that we're asking aren't getting us all the information that we need there so just a few example of takeaways we do need to dig
039in deeper so what do our next steps look like well PBIS recommends um based on the research that they've done that you administer the survey two times per year within the first 45 or 50 days which we did and then within the last 45 or 50 days so one thing the admin team will be talking about is how and when we want to administer this next um we need to share with key groups for feedback um the numbers are all the same but people interpret them differently and bring a different lens to it so we're here with you today um if you have any feedback from me if you look through some things I'd be happy to hear it and we have some questions to ask what is the survey data telling us in the
040key takeaways talked a little about some areas of strength areas to Target for improvement um do we need more information to understand the survey data better so some of these questions maybe will prompt us to asking more questions are the questions in the survey giving us what we are looking for and how does this data intersect with data we collect or how does it not intersect with the data we collect from other sources um we do uh the buus health screener with students we do um various um pieces of collecting data from staff on um surveys throughout the year PD and other things of that nature obviously they're looking at different things but when we think about data it's not just this we have so many other things that we can look at too and
041is this working and Jing the things that we're collecting and how we're collecting that information so do you have any questions for me Terry thank you for presenting I'm glad you guys did this I think it's a great thing to have I was wondering a couple things um roughly what percentage of the staff responded you said was nearly 100 staff over 50% yeah I feel like probably like 40 something per so we have roughly like 220 staff and we had uh 98 respondents so just under half yeah which is a pretty good response rate yeah um and I know that you were happy with 180 student responses you really were hoping for 100 but knowing that there's about 1300 students in the school yeah um have are you guys going to think about or discuss
042ways to get more students to respond to get more families to respond that's a great question so with the student survey you obviously have not obviously you have the option of having them take it while they're in school we had discussed that at the start of the year we had so many things we were pulling students out for exploratory surveys um the health survey all these other things that we were like we don't want to disrupt class further but we told ourselves when we went through this we're going to consider it for the next round and I think that's a way that you can in potentially make sure you have a more representative sample of what the student demographics look like um because we don't know for sure thank you yeah thank you other comments
043questions are you going to do another one in the spring you said you were yeah so that's something that the team as we go through this is going to solidify but um I believe our intentions are to um that's what we talked about at the start so um I didn't want to ahead we haven't spoken I'm was presenting to you all first we haven't spoken as a team but yeah that had been the intention yeah um you may have got into this with your media takeaways but um as the principal was there anything in particular a particular data point that really surprised you like I you know you would have thought yeah X would have turned out differently based on what I've seen at the school I think the the biggest thing that surprised me
044was the significant difference with how students rating themselves as community members versus how they rated the student body as a whole and I think the positive thing in that is a lot of students have very positive self-perceptions and values about who they are but clearly for some reason that's not being seen through all the interactions and so um it didn't necessarily surprise me that section four was a little lower but the difference between the two did um what didn't surprise me and I was Happ happy to see and had already shared with staff is how highly students rated the one about having a staff member they could turn to um one of the things I love most about shosen is I truly believe every kid can find a staff member that they like can connect
045with see themselves becoming and um I know the staff Pride themselves on their connections with students so that was like a happy surprise not a surprise you know what I mean so yeah happy affirmation I guess yeah anything else uh before we I'll go home and read every no this is incredible way of breaking down the data and um I think you the points you've identified for followup are very important too um because yeah there may be a little disconnect there and hopefully is I wasn't able to sort of follow for each of categories hopefully some of what you just described evolves a little bit as kids move from the grade through the the 12th grade yeah absolutely I'm just curious is this entire thing come as a package are you able to make adjustments
046to the questions you take it as it's given so if we if we wanted to do it through Microsoft forums which we had piloted that way we can change whatever we want but theirs theirs you can't change um the one benefit of that is they help you um group the data together through their platform there's still quite a bit of work I had to do to put those packets together but um they already have it grouped by the subgroups and things of that nature so you don't have to go and set so it's a good first step absolutely and then you know down the road maybe you'd make adjustments and the questions a little bit more reflective yeah of the student of this personality of the school and if the feedback we're getting you know
047from the groups that look at it and even through the second time running it we might decide hey moving forward we want to use a different one all together um since seem as a little yeah since we had uh selected this one the the research the document that listed all the surveys that we were choosing from um was updated March 2023 and this month when I went back on their website um the US Department of Education has adopted like a new school climate survey that they're using um that wasn't the same version as last March we're looking at things so even then there are other things that we can look into that weren't there then yeah you're welcome good uh it was 180 students are they able to break it down into how many from
048each grade is that something that's broken down so that's unfortunately with through their platform and it's funny I was going back and forth an email with them trying to get it and they were like to protect student anony anonymity we won't release those numbers and so that would be the benefit of putting it through our own platform um um and that's going to be a question if we look to other surveys that I'll know to ask now because when they said we share all the data I just assumed it was all I didn't realize that they didn't share that demographic breakdown okay no I think Teran had a good point like as far as like like the the one for staff like 50% like Wonder that's hopefully it goes up like that's a pretty good
049population sample of the population versus like the students like you said like you're saying like only like less than 10% so be good to see as it grows you guys get a better reflection of you're never going to hit 100% or maybe 50 right yeah and I think the other benefit if we did decide to do it in house is you can choose the same students to take it both times whereas we don't know if the same students if we offer it again are going to op to to fill it out so yeah I think the one like kind of is parents said because that's like probably the more difficult want to get like to measure like a like the other two you have a population Target whereas the other one you don't necessarily know
050yeah yeah like as far as like parents and uh Guardians we have well over you know 2500 for a current student so um yeah anything else I just follow 180 kids they chose to do it on their own we sent a link out so yeah it was on their own wish it was a little more parents were great you were happy if we had certain that's awesome yeah staff maybe we can get the 75 I don't know that's good you'll do this in the spring again yeah that's yeah okay great just get get the vibe what's going on here thank you that raises also the issue whether there's any selection bias that someone who chooses to take a optional survey whe whether he or she is more inclined to be someone more inclined to go
051on one end of the spectrum or the other Absol absolutely because you have to have opened your email clicked on the link spent the time to do it right so um absolutely thank you very much okay all right our next item should be relatively quick uh the consent agenda consists of the following items we have two legal bills for attorney greenpan and from km educational law for special education legal assistance and the minutes of the meeting of November the 26 2024 we can have a motion motion to approve the consent agenda second motion and seconded any discussion of any of those items the legal Bills or the minutes as prepared hearing none um all in favor of approval of the consent agenda I uh any abstentions any opposition okay approved all right recomendation by Mr
052Fury I said good recommendation by Mr Fury a very good recommendation um business manager report Jenna so everyone has four items in front of them or at their seat the only one we're going to talk about right now is the one that is blue with munice on the front the other three will revisit when we get to the subcommittee reports so this is the same um up todate usage by Department that I give you every single meeting but I'd like to turn your attention to the back of the page so you can see what I've given you an addition and I'm going to make this cumulative as the year goes on as far as our fund balances go uh One Fund balance that I added citizens I did not have that the last time so
053citizens is actually how we pay people and pay our bills our money has to go through them to actually make those payments so that's our citizen balance at at the end of November the other thing I added that you didn't see last time is the operating budget which is part of mmdt the treasury this operating budget is where our evolving accounts live it's where Ian D is it's where money is deposited to us from the state it's where money is deposited from the grant so there's a lot of funds included in that operating budget when we when we need money in citizens it's a transfer from that operating account to the citizens account so that's the account that has the most movement with these funds all the other accounts like the trust you're going to
054see that they increase by the interest they're earning and um Student Activity that could be pretty volatile as well as like night school and the revolving accounts because they're fundraising and spending fundraising and spending or doing something for the community get that money spend it on something else so that was a couple things I added that I didn't have at the last meeting and I'm also going to include going forward this year is this snippet on grants if you notice um I just put them in in order by title there's no numerical order here I'm going to change that re remaining column every time we meet so that column will change by date but this is to show you what we've spent so far on the grants that we've been awarded some of them like
055title one we've spent nothing because we're still spending our Title One Grant from last year so we haven't dipped into this one yet because you can carry it into the next year um like the skills lab mod modernization that's the Metal Fab project that we got a million for and then um a lot of these are special ed grants and entitlement grants versus competitive grants any any questions about I think giving the fund balances and the grants gives you a full picture of everything that's going on in the district and you'll be able to see it change as the year goes on and then the other three you're going to want to hang tight on these packets because we'll get to these during subcommittee reports so this one you're done with for now you can
056slide it away keep up the other three for when we review those sub committees okay any questions on firstand out is it possible just for people's education I mean it came out of the audit like just the outside accounts like what basically which trusts and how they work and is it possible like one of the next meetings that you could have some type of like for just kind like how they work purposes we do have like a bunch of new members like how they're like how they're you know administered who administers them you know what the purpose is you know how they're reconciled how they're review just be kind of like a like just so people understand that there's this outside you know OPB and just to kind of like so you know Bob's new
057Stacy's new just a kind of show for each maybe like a PowerPoint that has like sorry I'm have to give you more no no no no you pay me to actually work so as much work as you want I mean it'd be good to just I have a very good general idea but it'd be good for people to kind of understand the purpose of each one and if you want more try that but I think it' be good for people to know because it's this outside huge chunk of money that people don't always you know know what they're they're for yeah it's for and I actually don't have OPB in here because it's an external account but I'm going to add it for the next one so we like how they're how they're what what
058they're held best yeah what their rates are good to have that just because it kind of gets kind of left not left the way side guys want room but I'll bring some detail on each account for the next meeting the meeting after whatever whatever agenda you put it okay anything anything else for this uh item all right thank you Jenna we'll be hearing more in a few minutes and now we move to the superintendent's report okay I'm gonna try I'm gonna try to get through this quickly um see how it plays out by 26 budget timeline nothing has changed here um in subcommittee reports coming up we did have a joint facilities budget meeting um before our regularly scheduled meeting tonight so there'll be some information coming on of that some of the items around
059the budget that were discussed uh enrollment update uh I'm I'm happy to report we are still at 1277 so we're holding strong from last month's numbers um we still have 350 nth graders which I think is is a uh is a great tribute to the things we've been doing and the supports that have been provided to those kids and um I'm I'm hoping that that number remains strong and we stay um again our our Target was to have 340 um by this time of the year um so we're we're definitely ahead of that moving forward Co-op update UH 60 up we're up to 62% 200 of our seniors are out on Co-op working for local employers uh 49,1 157 total hours worked uh eight $1 23,796 uh in Gross earnings year to date so um
060again that number continues to increase you know every time we beat and I report on this uh I think you know again these are all great great statistics about you know what we do and how we do it and this is this is a big part of our mission um is you know is to provide the the next generation of people to support the local Workforce and to help local companies and businesses grow um by Community breakdown we have five Bedford 71 R 13 Burlington 46 tuber and 65 Wilmington like I said that's 200 out of our current 321 students so again I'm I'm hoping I'm hoping to get that a little higher before the end of the year but I think um you know it's it's it's going up slowly class of 2029 applications
061um you know if you look way over to the total you uh two years ago for the class of 27 we were at 303 at this time of the year last last year um class of 2028 we're at 462 and as of today actually yesterday's numbers I'm sorry as of yesterday we were at 482 for the class of 2029 um again I I my my sense from looking at these things we got a lot of applications I think earlier than we did the last couple of years um so it has kind of tapered off a little bit and I do have an update about some of the visits and some of the other stuff we're going to do on one of the next slides um again the uh percentage and parentheses underneath there is is
062the percentage of the eighth grade class that is applied here so um almost 36% of the eth graders from our combined sending districts have applied so um we're we're creeping up on 40% of the eth graders applying here and and hopefully by the time this is all said and done we'll be close to that number we want to be we want to be somewhere around 525 530 in that range would be nice visits to shaen hansom has here already John Glenn Middle School has been here we were finally able to uh finalize a date with Marshall Simmons Middle School he'll be here on Thursday January 16th um I also reached out to bcat to see if they wanted to be here for that event I have not heard that I do have an update for
063you do okay okay yeah which is fine and so again we you know we've invited them in as as part of this thing um there's a new the new uh not new superintend excuse me new principal at the middle school over there so there was um you know opening those communication ch channels and getting all the stuff worked out took a little bit longer than than we had hoped but um they're on the books they'll be here that actually falls the week before we do our eighth grade open house uh so the timing might actually work out well if there's some students that are interested you know bringing their parents back and kind of showing them um the things that they're excited about and the things that they they saw that they that Peak their
064interest Road Show dates we've been everywhere topy is actually scheduled for Thursday of this week it'll be the last one that we complete um but at this point again some of them we hosted here we had Bedford and hansum uh we did them in our building it was just um logistically easier for them to to do it that way but um we we're at Thea Memorial High School we were in Burlington at Marshall Simmons we'll be in tberry at the at the middle school um and we're in Wilmington at the Wilmington middle school as well so we're we're wrapping up the road show uh that should all be done before Christmas Vacation which I think is a great thing again just a just a reminder if people are asking um applications you know are due
065February 1st um acceptance letters will go out in March April 5th is placement testing and June 1st we switch to that ranked order list regardless of which Community kids are in so if one or two of our communities don't fill their quota um we can then backfill those seats with with whoever is uh on our wait list um allocation seat allocation seat distribution by community and then also the scoring criteria um how what we use to to rank students and to kind of place them on our our weit list um quick update this was a I know this was a topic of conversation at the LA at the November meeting we had 36 students uh that signed up for and utilized the fan bus um I do wanna I do want to throw a shout
066out to the three chaperon Ariel zern jeie Callahan and Dan derazio um step forward um I I told Al that they actually had a a more difficult job the night of the Super Bowl than he did um so it kudos to the three of them um without them you know stepping forward um we wouldn't I mean we just can't put you can't put 30 or 40 kids on a bus and I expect them to to self-monitor so um thank you to those three staff members that that uh step forward um the uh policy subcommittee and Brian and I have discussed this a little bit the policy subcommittee um is going to review that process and make some recommendations back to the full committee as to um exactly you know kind of how we want to
067structure that in the future is it you know is it state championships is it League championships is it playoff games um will there be a cost incurred for students to utilize the bus you know so all all of those things will will kind of be worked out and hopefully we'll we'll come back with something um for the committee uh in the relatively near future and then um one of the other things that had come up um and I know uh coach Costa and and I have talked about this a few times he's working on player recognition Awards um whether that ends up being jackets or Rings or whatever it is you know to kind of celebrate the state championship so um him and I talked last week he's he's got a couple of different options
068he's pursuing um he's trying to do a little fundraising with with some um local community donors so uh it more to follow on that but he is he has taken the lead on that and he uh he he assured me that that will happen in the near future so uh msba update um last it was I think there was four or five people from the committee that were on the meeting last Friday um we were invited into the eligibility period the board the msba board of directors voted Friday the 13th I don't know if that's a that's going to be an ominous sign for us moving forward or not uh to move us into the eligibility phase they did send us a date our start date with them for the eligibility phase is is August
0691st of 2025 so we do have some time between when they when they invited us in and when we actually have submitting stuff I know Brian um has gotten the information as well there's I want to say there's eight or nine deliverables that we have to we have to complete within that 270 day window my intent is to start working on that stuff now um and try to get as much of it done and much of it drafted and created as we can so that when that August 1 date hits we're not we're not starting from scratch so as we move forward there's going to be a lot of stuff there's gonna be again we need input from the committee if you look through the stuff they're the Ed plan piece of it they're asking
070about you know are there additional programs you want to add to your facility uh you know so that there's a lot of stuff that that the committee is also going to have to weigh in on and kind of uh give give some direction as to what what your vision is and what what all of you think uh should be in the new school um there were 47 statements of Interest they they announced on Friday we were one of 22 schools that were recommended to move forward uh I was a little encouraged we were we were one of four vocational schools which I thought was good especially after last year where they did zip um so and the year before I think it was only one so again I don't know if there was some pent
071up demand or you know they've just they've just kind of realized that this is this is a pending issue that they they need to start addressing so I was happy with that and um there are if you go on mba's website there are nine they call them modules so this is module one um and nine is is uh post post uh it's not inhab it's not inhabiting the building there's a term that they have for but essentially that is like the wrap up and the closure of the project you're talking it's probably 10 12 years from start to finish with everything being all done um but anyways so and then um we're also gonna We also plan to start um preparing for module two which is the deliverables within that 270 day window um after
072the first of the year after we come back from vacation so they have any idea how many of the 47 were actual V schools is that not disclosed any idea it wasn't disclosed during the meeting I can probably go back and find out but I know again I know there was four that would move forward I anecdotally I don't know of anybody else that put in for a building project um but that mean that doesn't mean that it didn't happen I do have a question so is it possible after the eligibility period that they turn you down if you do your if you do your homework the chances of that are very slim um based again not I haven't been I mean I haven't been through the whole process myself but based on what I've
073been told um people that are usually moved out of the pipeline are because they don't complete the required documents and or the school committee or somebody along the way decides that it's not that's not what they want to pursue at the time and kind of almost self- withdraw from the process he said last year's population was like pretty low right like it's only a couple I got of what of vocational schools there was no vocational schools last year was only one the year before Metro was Northeast right that was that was sever years ago they got approved yeah last year was n the year before it was it was Franklin Tech okay um going back before I know all old colony was around there Tri County was 21 or 22 um so I mean there
074there's a few Bristol plmouth was around that same time Diamond I think was around that same time Northeast Tech is one of the ones that's back on the list now but with a plan to go to possibly a different location and no that's Wittier witi Whittier I'm sorry I whiter is back on the list now for uh for those reason alternative location for an alternative location with Northern ethics Community College Nancy uh just refresh my memory we are applying for replacement or repair or both or that is that is beyond the scope of our authority to decide so we just apply so as we go through this process there will be what they what they call a feasibility study in the feasibility study they will they will go through this building with a fine tooth
075column and make recommendations about what they think is I thank you 20 the timeline you mentioned 10 that's that's with all of the finalized stuff so msba um the thing with msba is if if you're ready earlier than their deadline they will move you along faster so um again you know I think they're based on what I know from other schools you you're looking at two two to three years to go through the whole planning process the feasibility study the recommended design piece so I think we're I think we're looking at at two or three years to get to a potential funding vote based on you know what and and I mean there stuff coming up again I don't know who's interested or how we want to structure this but we're gonna have to put
076together a building committee um there there's a lot of stuff that they look for in this initial phase to show that we've done some planning and and some we have some foresight as as to the direction we want to go and how we want to do things so that'll that'll come up as well and design bidding with pre-qualification of all the contractors and construction is probably two to three easily three years I would say so there's probably no child in the building currently who will which is we're going to get to with with some of the subcommittee reports is an issue that we're going to be dealing with constantly the years ahead that was a un my when I was watching my I had a connection issue but that is unanimous vote on the mspa
077correct there was a woman who was speaking I got really concerned yeah and was she a voting member is she a voting member voting M yes okay she was going off on a tangent for the for the whole board here she was going off in a tangent about the emissions thing that and I was going to I was going to send a text Mage out like shut this woman up but I just bit my tongue she's like well you know why should we fund this these School these HK schools well we don't know what kind of kids are coming in there the missions program and I'm thinking she the board she had she had commentary on every single item was on the agenda it wasn't just us I know it was interesting t for me
078I to sit through this and see what this is all about and everybody gets up there and says yeah we need a school I need this and they go thank you and I don't tell made a comment about should we have brought uh the uh Representatives some towns and districts brought their representatives in but who knows but anyway so tone we're at the table we're on we're on here we go matching forward and I will say that woman was negative but the response from the moderator of the meeting was we're not going to worry about that like she kind of she very polite about it but she dismissed it immediately right ex Treasurer Goldberg's coming us there will be an educ plan developed that's part of those deliver process but it's not going to be
079at the granular level of whether we have a it's really GNA make a difference way of a lottery or the current missions process we're still going to teach the kids We're Not Gon to stop teaching them just because it's a different process to get them in the building it's not going to affect our instructional approach it's not going to affect the programs we off it's not going to affect any of that stuff sounds good um so I again I included this in in in my report I didn't do this this is separate agenda items if people prefer that way please tell me and we can we can modify this going forward um we did get a request from the town of tuxbury Council on Aging to do some um I'll term it as some interior
080renovation work at their facility um so I guess I'm looking to the committee to to a yay or nay on on whether we want to uh uh move forward with that that Community project request and then also um actually I think it was just this morning I got a request um we have a an alumni owned company that wants to that wants to donate um jerseys for the girls hockey team which is which is a a co-op between us Bedford and L High School um and my understanding is now they all have different jerseys depending upon which school they're representing um so this this uh this company has offered to uh purchase those jerseys so that everybody has a standard kind of look and kind of format to them for the team so uh these
081are two things I'm looking to the committee for a yes no feedback is it correct to assume that this town of tuxbury COA application if the school didn't feel it was matching with what the kids are learning and doing it would not have come to us absolutely yes so I have a recommendation from Dave norwitz to move forward with this he's already been out there um with our um construction department chair look at the project it it's going to involve carpentry it's going to involve electrical um they both are uh theyve both advocated that this is this is a good fit for our kids and it's something that they want to get involved with so do we like are we Equitable as far as what towns get our projects what am I asking you wouldn't
082do five for tuxbury and how was that how was that done that's managed through Dave's office um so I mean last year last year we did a project for b r Housing Authority now you know this year I think we're working with tubry on one of their projects um yeah again we we try to balance those as much as we can yeah I think Dave mentioned at some point that they have uh early they have a request from Bedford related to the American Legion Center that they're trying to work out some details and a lot of times people will reach out to us initially and get some feedback and then whether you know whether they have to go back to their board or whether they're looking for grant money or whatever so sometimes it takes
083a while for these things to develop yeah but I yeah it's it's a hard thing to be fair about because projects vary and it job or a little job and you know and but the flip side of that is you know those those are really engaging projects for kids and it's you know it's re it's a real kind of Hands-On it's not a simulation it's not AUP it's not a and it's a community effort yeah and again we want to do as much as we can to support the communities because again you know if they had if they had to pay somebody to to to do this particular project it's it's a lot more expensive than our staff and students working on so do we need to make a motion to approve those well what
084I don't probably don't need to but why don't we I mean motion to approve the two items to support the project tub and the receipt of the hockey jerseys some Z all in favor we support elders and we support hockey players we ask the hockey team if they do one one one Shir the request came through the athletic department so I'm assuming that those conversations but I I can verify that before I I think they actually did have a jersey that that combined Bedford and um and shaen but now they there's a third member of the co-op of know I didn't know Lo was when do they I think this is the first year this the first year VI I've read in the globe through the Mia website there are so many Co-op teams really
085not only in girl Sports wrestling and everything some of these towns are having trouble Fielding a full team yeah and our girls I mean how many girls did chash playing any idea 10 or 12 they had some some time last year where they had relatively small squads they had you know due to injuries and things like that so so girls from Bedford are joining us obviously low High's numbers were down so it's nice to have been a joint hockey team for at least four years those two programs are strong we just got new jerseys too so it's funny had consistent jerseys girl was strong Tony work girls my my my niece played for the Chelsea two strong programs num is were now they're together you know and and that's it you know so that's what's
086going on out there not all towns um my uh um in Burlington I know the Coach Rick Sheen he's got like 10 or 12 girls he has got eighth graders playing so unfortunately sometimes are hurting you know so but this is nice to we can combine so they're gonna get an st B and an L just squish them all with the three colors that's awesome Tony that's great the alphabetical order B should go first B not that the represent from Bedford is is biased in this convers that's good okay nice that that comp's and then we will and again I'll bring back a recognition to to all once we process but again I wanted to get the approval before we can we actually vote yeah didn't we Sorry a question up after the vote that
087was that's all right so um I'm gonna I'm going to do a high level evaluation update here if people have questions please please um ask I did send out um or I should say Karen sent out I didn't send it out I think it was last Thursday or last Friday it went out um there are six different goals on this so I'll just I'll just kind of go through the first one has to do with the new superintendent induction program um I've attended all of the meetings I intend to you know continue attending all the meetings this is year three um the format has has shifted a little bit they're more um I think I call them consult consultany groups um there's four or five of us from this kind of particular region that get
088together and meet with the our two mentors um and talk about you know ongoing issues and things that we have um going on you know in our schools and our communities that you know we all try to support each other on um the U Massachusetts Certified Public public purchasing official they are in the process of changing their uh registration system so the last time I was on there um it gave me a message that um you couldn't register for any classes until the end of December so I will I will continue to to re revisit that and get registered for uh one of the spring classes I I I did take one last year there's two other required ones for that um so I will continue to work on that um the book that's the
089the flip book that's kind of a prototype um that's going around part of uh well goal three is to um you know kind of fully implement this career tree initiative those of you that were here for open house or have been here for any of the parent events at night um those those uh career trees have been on full display when the road show has been out they've they've been taking three or four or five of them with them um so that the standup displays are out there they're talking about them as part of those events our guidance our freshman guidance staff is working um we're going to do another um shop interest survey coming up after vacation and part of that is going to be them them introd introducing all the career trees to
090the students and talking through the different levels um we talked about this at the middle school guidance counsel lunch in we put this out there we showed them what it was um that resource wasn't ready but our our intent is to have copies of that for our own counseling staff so that again when they're talking to kids and they're talking about goals and where they want to go and what they want to do in the future they can reference it we also want to want to start pushing that out to our middle school counselors as well so um when when we get a finalized version what we realized was um I'm GNA write kind of an introduction to that you know about about why we went and did this and and what our goals and
091aspirations are around this and then um our director of guidance and Health Services and our director of data and admissions are working on um kind of a I want to call it frequently asked questions but kind of a guide to how it's set up and and what the different categories mean how they kind of connect to each other so we are going to add a few more things to that but again I just um that was kind of our first run through it to see what that would look like as we went on um the uh I goal number four was U training that focuses on supporting English English Learners multilingual Learners former English Learners there's all kinds of terms that are you being used now I did U complete a course called welcoming and
092supporting newcomer students um so that that is complete at this time goal five is to do uh 15 minute class or shop room visits per week and then bi-week le as a team review that leadership team has been doing that all of us have been out in classrooms and shops um so that that is that is an ongoing um goal and then U Jess was actually here to report on the um implementation analy an analy analyzation of the school climate survey and again that will continue we are looking for um a time frame or a Time window to re uh not redo that but do it again in the spring so that we have some comparison data from the beginning of the school year to the end of the school year and that's um are
093there any questions on that is there anything in there that maybe I didn't under that I didn't explain or that that people want more information about um any questions comments the only one I would put forth is um I think particularly of some of the things that Jess said you know that the school climate surveys as it relates to staff will be an interesting opportunity presumably for you and the administrative team to have some um good hopefully honest I'm no honest not I hope honest uh detailed discussions about any concerns about um atmosphere issues relationships within the building um getting a you know 97 staff members is a pretty good turnout but obviously hopefully there's enough information there that you guys can talk about it and I think uh everybody would love to see these
094all come back and you know every 3.9 all around but that's not realistic and to the extent that there are a couple of items that are on that uh rubric that maybe are a little bit on the not not on the deficient side but a little less than we would have likeed now is a great time for some candid conversations and um be interesting to see where that that leads anything else for the evaluation process okay um maybe just along these lines reminder as to where we will be I think our goal was to have the evaluation instrument it was it in March or April February February to be returned for the March meeting March meeting okay so before before if if anybody rolls off join us organiz yeah thank you for reminding me before
095I leave yes yeah that's the goal yes the the instrument is built um have I have one question that no matter how many times I've reformatted it for whatever reason Microsoft form has decided that the way that I had it set up it doesn't like um so I'm I'm I'm actually G to try to delete it again for like the third or fourth time and recreate the question but outside of that it is ready to go it'll be the same format that we used last year um Kar you know Karen will send it out to everybody she'll compile all the information it'll be the same exact thing that people had the last time around so it's all set up as questions and kind of walks people through and gives people the chance to comment if
096they want to um so yeah it's it's it's ready to go great um I don't have a lot of pictures this month but I did uh Mr Fusco had forwarded me some photos these These are the railings that are students built and installed at the Bia Elks again this was one of the projects that come to the committee for their approval let's get to the Finish Line I was so proud as a school school Comm member and also an elk they are so pleased with us uh masonry Auto Body carpentry uh mlef thank you of course that midle the railings are awesome they're in place um and uh it's it looks great Tony so thank you and Dave for uh cooperation it's uh great I will have a donation I'll put it put it on
097the um January agenda I was told on Saturday yes uh they have money from the state that they um would like to give to organizations you know organizations of course and schools so uh it'll be five under the sum of $500 and I will I'll put that on the January we'll accept it I think we'll have the check by then and we could put that Jenner in um we put the last money into the um uh Metal Fab roling we can put this in masonry or whatever you want to do it's good so they it's good it's just great Community relationship and most of them there's so many members there who are graduates and so it was so good it was so nice to do this job and we fixed the ones in the right
098last summer Alex Corino I have to really hand it to him so Tony thank you so much for getting this to the Finish Line questions I know we answered some as we went and everything the add is to get how to design out issues yet yes so the the permit the permit has been issued um there's actually a meeting I have a meeting at 8:00 on Thursday morning with our project manager architect and the representative from the company that we awarded the contract too uh I'm pushing for them to start the project on the 23rd um I got a little resistance from them because they told me it was a holiday week and I was I was out of my mind to think they were going to come out in stack but we'll we'll see
099what comes out of our conversation on Thursday morning so uh if it's not that week hopefully it's it's the the 30th the 31 So within the next few weeks they should be out here and St jump over so the sprinkler thank you y that that's all set the the building permit's ready to go yep everything's good yep and so hopefully things will start moving thanks that's the plan yeah that's good just uh not to I guess to close this dead horse on the audit I guess you guys were what's the final was the final report issued who signed it so Brian and I tonight signed like an I want to call it an acknowledgement document but I don't think that was the title of what it was called um which will go back to them
100um and then my understanding is once they have that they're gonna issue the final audit you know I threw at my office after after the two signed that was the like the process going forward like who was signing past year superintendent chair who So based on our research the former auditing form a former auditing firm never required anybody to sign um acknowledging the completion of the process so um we had a little conversation back and forth and and TR I kind of landed on the school committee chair and the superintendent would be two signatories on on that moving forward I thought it was Mark Mark was going to provide some type of you could circulate like what the takeaways for improvement were going to be because you said there be some I think they're looking
101for this document so essentially we signed off that to the best of our knowledge the information was provided blah blah blah my understanding is once they have that then all the other stuff will be finalized or issue whatever you want to call it okay so hope hopefully we have that no but I mean one of the followups they when the guy was here was going to provide was basically like you said there was G to be significant not significant but like recommended changes to like no we haven't got those yet okay is that something we can ask them like now again I think I think this is what was holding it up um and we were we were back and it was a was a one piece in there we had to clarify around cyber
102insurance and some other things but it is sign now I'll make sure make sure it goes out first thing in the morning and then I can always can always reach out for a bug in his ear about when they're yeah they can provide that and then just like as far as like to close loop on where you once that's you starts circulating it's like appropriate can provide like an update on that too do you want I mean does that does the committee want that to go back to the audit subcommittee at this point in time or is it something you just just want to release like at our January meeting if if we have the final report why we go back I think we I don't know if they want to review it first I
103mean I think we already they kind of AR mentioned what we're going to be in it my feeling is so I mean unless there's some crazy changes from what they presented I would say I don't think we need to okay so I think I think more just maybe like an update of the January meeting like what you got back from that maybe an update like what the parties were as far as like you know markham's like follow up like what are going to be the changes recommended and then maybe you can just provide it like that all the appropriate counterparties have been provided you know so run the same non to like yeah just like maybe a list just to provide statement when we did it it came to the audit subcommittee was the final
104and we made the recommendation so when it came to the committee he just recommended it you know I mean so we wouldn't have to rehash all of this again all okay and that was my understanding when he came to present my understanding was we were going to get the final document and then after the fact was like oh yeah by the way we need you to sign this N9 page 11 page document and so the yeah I think I think we're still kind of working out the Kinks with with how this is processed which they sent out like at a Wednesday at 4:30 and said we really would love to have this back on [Music] Friday finally I find it overly concerning for two decades that basically that the auditing firm didn't request that final
105sign off and we didn't that's kind of bizarre thought we did sign off on it so maybe they did never maybe they did we couldn't find any record of I I went I went back to Jenna's J we met with them and I thought we signed off yeah I remember that my because they did the same thing they would come and they present presenting get approved I also remember them bringing the final audit to those meetings too so I'm not sure if that's I don't again I don't I don't have enough experience with that to say one way or the other that this is right or this is wrong it's just um you know hopefully we don't find ourselves in a similar situation again okay uh we have four subcommittee reports starting with the wellness
106sub committee yeah oh so Wellness met last week and actually we tried to meet uh there weren't enough people and then we started with the chair and two of us or three of us and then the chair had to leave so the three of us he said why don't you discuss so actually the three of us were able to have a pretty good conversation I think um don't ask me was there that I know I can't remember the staff person but besides myself we have a community representative who is from Ley and she is awesome she comes with a whole bunch of ideas and uh suggestions so um one of the conversations had been and again I can't there was discuss about disruption in the cafeteria and really interesting it coincided with Jess's report respect
107and acceptance that seemed to be the low point on survey and it seems to be a lack of respect and kind of a bullying because kids are not accepting of the other the this is coming from a staff person I can't tell you who it is I'm not not telling you because I just don't know who it was but I think it was really interesting that it coincided with her statement and that was really very anyway they were talking a lot about it this has got to be addressed they all felt very strongly about it so I think once this gets out that together when sta gets into it it'll it'll be part of the of the vernacular and hopefully solution um and I have to say when I first started doing Wellness couple of
108years ago I was told oh it's no biggie it's not worth going to and whoever it was that I never went and anyway I found it fascinating I'm I'm leaving I think I had my last meeting I don't think there will be another one before I leave and I urge you guys that are going on with it you learn a lot about the staff and food and the health issues that don't come up here uh and there's a lot you guys know it but we don't and uh I really urge you if you're all interested to get on to Wellness they only move four times a year maybe five and it's really really worthwhile so if you want to know the innards sh it's a good way to find out thank you nany thank you
109for being on the wellness committee for a while now grateful I enjoyed it all right um negotiation subcommittee uh Patty you're our de facto chairperson we met on the 11th with the superintendent and he updated us about his meetings with the St leadership and we will have another meeting probably next month we think it's going good so yeah I think I people wondering if there going to be any issues I foree but you never know but it's like some of these other communities have recently had one alleviating worries people that are watching might be concerned that about I think we'll be fine and we should point out this was really focused on the teachers um which is why three of us were there and then there will subsequently be negotiations issues regarding other collective bargaining
110groups that are up this year but we we seem to be moving along fairly well with our uh most important asset the teachers um right now which is good okay uh the budget subcommittee which met briefly uh before this meeting about an hour yes Mr chairman budget subcommittee met tonight at six o'clock and we went over the fiso 26 capital budget recommendations from our businessman manager and superintendent and also previewed the fiscal 26 operating budget um that will be that I think everybody has uh been hand it out okay facilities met jointly with the budget subcommittee and um and as he said he went over to capit the budget as well and I think Jenna might want to do some presentations here well little I don't you handed this out well I the rest of
111the members might want have questions that he obviously has you given it to everybody you may want to they may have questions I'm promised us you were coming back later in the meeting I thought I was gonna get phased out you did a great job just I appreciate you just kind of giving us another I'll give a brief overview compared to the discussions that we had two hours ago um so the first thing I would draw your attention to is just this little summary page I know it doesn't look like much but it gives us where we are as of now compared to FY 25 so our Capital as of today we have a 67% increase our operating we have a 3.67% increase and then overall the percentage increase is 3.57 that ends up being
112a weighted average because capital is funded differently than operating and then transportation we have um the contract still with Christensen for 1.7 million next year and I'm estimating a reimbursement of ,000 sorry a million doll that's not do well I lost a couple zeros there a million dollars that's a much bigger number that was a big mistake and then we have 533,000 in our transportation fund which was the excess reimbursement for last year that will be applied to FY 26 so the next thing other than the summary we have the FY 26 Capital draft that's the one with the five years on the front so we have met with Department chairs lead teachers admin Tony and I have met a couple times to teir down this capital budget and there were some issues that I
113don't know if the subcommittee wants to bring to the group right now or you want to wait until the next meeting about items that wait until they're ironed out you want to wait till it's ironed out okay yeah this is still draft so it's not the accepted listen to the draft and and need some recommendations make recommendations that will be brought to us back in January 14 okay perfect I think the one sort of theme that we can identify um and this is connected to item we already touched on and later on the agenda um particularly with the building project thing circulating around and people becoming aware of it um that there will be times we're going to look at the capital budget and say if there was no thoughts of a school building we
114would go for that but in light of the fact that we have a school building that's being discussed we may do something a little different or modify whatever and we have and we have to to anticipate our sending communities F Finance committees are going to be having that mindset every time we meet with them why are you asking for X hundreds of thousands of dollars for this and yet as we touched talked about a little bit during our meeting we have to be sensitive the fact that going back to a question Stacy raised earlier we have several years of kids who need to go through the school with a a good well-functioning school um who will never see a new building and we have to things that are necessary to keep up the building so
115there's going to be some some trade-offs along the way all right so that is capital you'll notice it goes out for the five years um the five years is always a work in progress anyone that H got this shared spreadsheet had to look at all five years so either moving something to a subsequent year um removing it completely because maybe we purchased it with a grant keep as is and all those notes I have actually I have in that spreadsheet that we can refer back to so I've kind of memorialized every file this year so if there's ever a point you want to know where did you start at where Did We End I'll have I have all that information with notes can I request something sure I always like to see what FY T5
116was okay the year before sure because that would you know then it makes sense I mean I know and our files we have it yeah and it's on this one too just for Capital but not with all the detail right that you want you don't want just the total amount you want the the breakdown I want the breakdown because you know you'd be like well this one's not getting any money this year but then you see last year they had you know 50 Grand right like we spread the wealth every okay okay yep so you want fy2 with next document yeah the next one you ready for the next one no next time you print this okay top sheet just the top sheet summary okay sure sure most these like when you look these numbers
117like um capital is over $5,000 per item with an estimated lifespan of at least five years okay that's that's how capital is usually defined okay and some of the items on here if do have a new building we can bring some items with us like anything Furniture wise is stuff that we would be able to keep even our um new announcement system that is something that we would bring with us so there are items on here that we would bring to a new building and items that would obviously have to stay if it's a permanent structure may I just note that there was one item here that Bally jumped off of me at Ka I just just described I thought it was interesting culinary arts Hospitality management description the smell coming from the grease traps
118is unhealthy to breathe Y and prevents student recruitment I thought that was a very candid observation and that's a good example something we need to deal with right now we cany I'm happy to explain what's going on because I I go down there almost every morning um the grease traps and the drains when let's say they come back Monday morning and start getting everything running they have an odor so um Brian conine who's the lead teacher went to the plumbing shop just to get an estimate for how much it was going to how much to replace it and those plumbers teachers came down they gave them the estimate and they did a temporary fix right so there is an improvement a marked improvement I can tell because I go in there my nose works and
119I can smell it too especially on a Monday morning um but we are we've handled the temporary situ situation but now we're going to have to have a permanent situation so that's why we want to put it into the next year but at least our plumbers were able to do something to remediate it in the meantime so that was good news but I that is a great that's the most entertaining on here some entertainment and then the next budget is the operating budget um this this I did include FY 25 we have our operating budget I assumed a 3.5% salary increase but when I adjusted those salaries because that's the that's the hardest thing to project right now with all of these negotiations so what I did is I looked at every Department salary line
120let's say I was 20,000 under this year I would add 20 to last year's number and then increase the whole thing by 3.5% and then I also exported everybody's salaries from munice and just make sure everything was within range within like a one one or two% estimate so those are just projections that I assume could might even change when we have this meeting the next time so then I have the difference between fy2 and FY 26 then the percent increase or decrease so I didn't do a blanket increase for every item I looked at each item individually um lead teachers Department chairs and administrators they submit what they want for supplies and Contract Services we've yet to cut anything from this this is precut um admin hasn't seen this yet it's a new newer document
121as of today because I like to date it it was printed today and then you'll notice some things if we didn't need to increase it I just left it the same and if it was an item or a category that I didn't get any items for I just left it blank brought it back down to zero so those percentages in that column they vary as you can see some of them are very high some of them are very low some of them are negative some of them are zero so so if there's anything in here that you're questioning and that doesn't have to be tonight feel free to send me an email I'm happy to explain how I came up with a number and I'm I'd like people to look at this because there's a
122lot of information here and I want to make sure there are not any mistakes I spelling errors included Taran because I know you're going to find them I I did spell check on this before I printed it it said there were noen B any yet we had a problem last year maintenance the word the word maintenance I had to spell different everywhere than I fixed that though I fix so any other questions about this please reach out you'll you'll see a new version the next time we all get together um based on what Tony and the admin team and I and your feedback where we land 100% thank you thank you so the problem with that anything any of the admin salaries and fy2 yeah they weren't we didn't go back and adjust those and
123make those moves so I carried so there was a some changes between the budget approval last year and this new budget so those numbers do look big but it's based of what I showed you last year even though there might have been a change through the year I'm thank you I I love that any that any further questions either for the committees or for Jenna on these items okay all right thank you Jenna um under new business I think we covered first item msba update unless there's any other any questions or comments no um the one thing maybe I should we should I hadn't even really thought of it till right now on the msba as Gwen was kind of enough to alert us to uh last night um various communities will report on this
124development in whatever way they want to um obviously personally I think it's great if if members com you know in that case they just reported on our meeting um I think as long as the information that any news sources or public officials is accurate and I um I know over this past weekend um I saw two communities out in the birk shars that were on the same list we were and this was like front page on their in their newspapers oh they made the list and some of them were on one case they were reporting as if it was all done they were about to have a new building and the other one was very cautionary like whoa long process slow down um but obviously to the extent that any of us if we get
125any requests for information you know we should all I I think we should feel comfortable commenting on our knowledge about the building's needs if there's something technical that we think needs to be referred back to the superintendent or the business manager or the facilities director um and obviously as our I last week I sent out the notice to everybody when we got it from from uh msba because copied on there as you saw with the town managers Andor the school Committees of or select Boards of each of our towns so they may start to have questions St people asking you and you don't know the answer it's behooves all of us to check with somebody who does so just as a followup to that I've already I've already spoken personally with three of uh three
126of the five Town managers um one uh told me that he intends to um provide an update to the select board the next time they meet um he is a very experienced Town manager has been through numerous projects like this was very knowledgeable uh his questions from me more around timelines than they were anything about the process um we have been invited um by the bcka town manager to attend an upcoming select board meeting um to again start start the conversation with them um I I deferred till after the start of the school year because I mean the start of the calendar year um so we will we will look at something there um we uh we got congratulations from the third Town manager um who did Express that you know his his one reservation
127is is the you know the whole funding process and the other which I completely understand um I have a fourth call scheduled I believe for tomorrow afternoon um we have one town manager we have not heard back from yet we'll continue to try to reach out as of this morning um Karen sent that we actually sent hard copy letters to all of them um to all the town managers and to all the select board chairs saying that you know we invite we invited into the eligibility timeline um you know sharing that we were we were looking forward the opportunity to work with the communities to have conversations about building needs and where this project was going to go so we've already we've already started from our end to communicate that stuff um and again we
128we'll see as as requests come in we'll definitely respond to them in timely manner Tony can you tell us what three Teng you spoke with I've spoken to Burlington Bill R and um tberry at this point I I do have I do have a call scheduled with Bedford tomorrow okay great uh the next item leave of absence insurance coverage this is a followup from the last meeting uh superintendent presented an issue that kind of a cleanup item on long-term health insurance coverage uh I think people have concerns about how many circumstances and how it might have to be communicated if we made more radical changes to current existing um we had a brief conversation about it I believe it's fair to say the number of people expected is only about six if I recall but
129they also ranged in ages from whether it was the staff member or former staff member to a a spouse or uh widow or widower of of a former staff member people in their age ranges from their 50s to well into their 90s um so and out are concerns that I think we had all shared about making sure nobody gets cut off from some maybe Arrangement that was made in the past that may or may not have been reduced to writing um or there were a variety of things going on um the superintendent has come back with this recommendation um to double the time to to keep all of the existing agreements in place to um have this go into effect in 12 months I'm sorry have it go into effect next march and increase the
130length of insurance coverage from 12 months to uh to 24 months and otherwise the policy that you have here is basically the same one that was presented at the uh November meeting um I just just one quick correction that I I actually just picked up on I didn't catch it earlier under eligibility the last sentence should read the employee must have worked for the district for at least 12 months um it's it's going 24 and have worked at least 1250 hours over those 12 months so for for some again I'm just I think that when we went through it we changed all the 12 to 24s that one should have stayed 12 so they're got to be here for a year essentially so the six people that are affected by this would have 24 months
131to no no no we will make no changes to existing coverages for people that are on this plan starting March 5th after March 15 2025 anybody that that that falls under this umbrella would have two years of coverage after they've exhausted all their Le so if somebody had 300 sick days they could get paid for 300 days and then have two years after that of coverage before they have to find something else and I think the majority of the affected folks are in an age bracket where they where this health insurance might be a secondary insurance they're X yeah if Med you know the Medics eligible already um there there's always some risk you know keeping even those folks in the pool but it seems both the most uh decent and honorable thing to do
132and the other caveat that as we started to look at that so so teachers are different um if you teachers an administrator well yes they are but teachers and administrators are treated differently from a from a health and dental standpoint I should say so when a teacher and administrator retires um we are required to go to the GIC plan we do not have the option of staying on shashi's health insurance that's that's not open to us all of the employees that we have that are middle sex County retirees we own their health insurance um regard so if they retire through middle sex they are still on our plan they still pay you know they still pay through us they they get build through through Jenna's office um and when we looked at this a lot
133of those people lot of those six or seven people on that list were met were middle sex County retirees or spouses anyways so we would have been I don't want to say on the hook but we would have been responsible for their coverage regardless um which again I think it was it kind of led us to that conclusion where anybody that currently has this coverage and again this will not affect so if you're a middle sex County retiree this will not affect you this is just somebody that goes like it like it says uh disability leave sabatical leave extended maternity those are the only three qualifying factors so if you retire this has no effect on your health insurance coverage it will not impact that at all so This only affects current employe working EMP
134the employees and employee and family some somebody that was an employee on honor after marage 15 2025 but not after they retire if you're a middle sex employ no it regardless of who you are it's not going to affect a retirement because a teacher is forced to go on GIC administrator is forced to go on GIC in Middle sex retirees were going to own their health insurance regardless because that's the way that their retirement system works yeah see is good I'm on SO the middle sex are if they're not Administration not fact teachers they middle sex is maintenance um edtech clerical calf workers essentially anybody that doesn't have an Educator's license okay that's the difference I mean I just totally blanked out all right so so the people who get really sick and have to
135take a leave of absence right and then some of them are out for years they still pay health insurance so we're trying to take that away right no we're just trying to we're trying to limit our liability right so that somebody can't go out on long-term leave and stay on our stay on our health insurance for 25 or 30 years I don't know I tried to explain this to somebody and I I changed my mind but I think okay this what happened was D the consultant came in and said they should be they should be going tomorrow we're not gonna be consultant said after FMLA eligibility you don't have to carry I think that's a little onlys we're kind of gonna be forgiving here a little bit P you know what I'm saying so these
136are current employees who for whatever reason are not currently coming into work every day and working because they have a medical issue only one of those three conditions they they have a disabling condition or they're on illness an illness they've requested a sabatical or they're on an extended maternity leave when those leaves end so if you're on a sabatical for two years at the end of your two years you're can have 24 months if you decide not to come you come back you're reinstated it's it's no big deal you're going have 24 months to find another plan for coverage if you are an extended attorney leave and decide not to come back to your position at the end of your extended attorney leave you're still going to have 24 months of coverage by the district
137at the at the current split they're only going to pay 20% of the premiums uh and again if you're if you're on disability um once you've exhausted all of your sick time all your vacation time everything else then you still have 24 months after that date to go out and find addition these are people that will no longer be employees because they've chosen after their leave has ended to not come back so they may be finding another job but they have still got health coverage this is just health coverage for another two years that's not true no think so but you did mention two types of employees that actually could come back to work I thought this had to do with someone who anybody can come back to work at the end of their week
138well I thought this had to do with people who are long-term illnesses that's but again if if somebody's out for two year if somebody's out two years with cancer and has 450 or or has sick days and then hits the sickly bank and covers all of those things that doesn't count towards this they're still an employee okay so that all right so this is something different all this this is very different yeah and this this is happened a whole lot this this is only a handful of people that I think this has ever pertained to ever but again we were told because we're because we're self-insured health health trust that if we you know if we end up with five or six people and we have to cover their health insurance for 25 years that's
139$2 and a half million dollars you're G to tell me somebody takes a sabatical and doesn't come back and he's still on our health insurance well according to this policy they'll be able to stay on for two years even though they no longer I think when we looked at the actual circum contract as to what what were the believes in the teachers contract that's what that was based on yeah I think in the circumstances to taran's question about a current employees I think three or four were surviving spouses of people who worked here at some point in the past and I think in some cases I mean these leaves went back to superintendent Lions um period um one or two maybe much more recent but um you know these were agreements that were ENT into
140presumably in good faith um but so the the goal here was to begin to wean us away from from this future liability issue without doing any harm to any of the folks that have been sort of taking been able to take advantage of it um so the people C covered under it are not affected by this they can stay on it for another anybody that's on it before March 15th of next year will whatever whatever their agreed upon premium split was that all of that stuff will stay in effect we're not touching anything that's that's that's currently exists grandfather okay see I thought I misunderstood this well we just added that because the last meeting that wasn't in there yeah but I mean I thought these people were out sick you know I didn't know
141they just some of them just took a sabatico and then never came back most of this is going to be people that are out sick that this is going to affect again if they if they if they exhaust so somebody somebody gets sick they exhaust all of their sick Le right at the end at the at the end of that and if they've used all the sickly Bank time they can get everything else at the end of that they can have two years of coverage the the flip side argument that I'm gonna make to you Patty is if we don't do this okay they can hit our stop loss is $100,000 so if they have 20 25 years in front of them that we have to cover them on our insurance it's $2.5 million per
142person that we that we've now exposed ourselves to liability on 100,000 a year again if they if they have continued medical needs we pay the first $100,000 and then the stop loss kicks in so it is people who are sick I mean the sabatical the actual case I don't think there's a sabatical on that no not I think they were all long-term disability um spouses of retirees I don't know the SP but I I'm just thinking I mean if they were employed by us they get really sick and then tell them and by the way you lose your H and J I have a hard time with that so all right I think two years is reasonable when they are no longer employees the the other thing that I will say is um looking back
143to some of the time frame that a lot of these came on here there was no um Universal Health Coverage there was no Mass connect there was no so I mean it's it's a little different in this day and age I I'm not saying they're going to get the same quality of coverage it may you know they may not have the same deductibles they may don't have those same things but there are a lot of options out there um and again I I I absolutely agree and and I I would not advocate for you know people in need but again trying to put on on the fiscally responsible hat of being the chief executive officer of the school district that's a lot of liability and a lot of exposure for us and if we don't
144if we don't have something in place um it hasn't happened to us yet it hasn't been an issue but looking forward could it be it could be we could end up with 10 people on this and and and have and own them for the next 25 or 30 years has Howard come down on this at all yeah Howard was part of the initial conf so that we I talked to the the the Insurance Consultant that we have that carries our long-term disability he made some recommendations when I talked to Howard Howard pointed me back to him again um so and and then Howard did review this before before I shared it at the last meeting right so T most of these current U cases are middle County retirees all but one I or maybe two
145one or two so they're going to be fine going forth if we vote the starting March and again this doesn't refect it doesn't affect it so Patty also somebody can get sick and if they decide to retire that's a different scenario because then they're either eligible for GIC or they're eligible for a coverage through middle sex so I mean you're really you're really talking we're talking about very very small sample size of people so you're Tony you're basically cleaning up something that should have been done a while ago so I know I applaud you for that and the consultant says you got to look at this know anyway is that the way everybody else does it so when I when I talked to the consultant he said there's districts out there that when your FMLA
146expires your health insurance expires on the same day I think that's a little harsh um he said he said most schools fall somewhere in a N9 to 12 month range which again the first proposal I brought back was 12 months that seemed like it was a little bit of too short of a time frame for this group which is which is fine um so that's why you know we came back with we looked at you know grandfathering and everybody and then going to 24 months okay we have a proposal before us with a recommendation from the superintendent do we have a motion in support Nancy has moved in support of it do we have a second second Bob has uh seconded all in favor of the proposal please indicate yes any opposed um want to
147oppose any extensions okay thank you all right the next item um I sent out um the guidance five pages of it from to Desi um which was I also the subject I think of an article in yesterday's Boston Globe if anybody found it confusing you're large company um many people have found and particular it's draw what's drawing attention is the Retro the um retroactive element of this but anyway the reason I wanted to bring it up tonight and I have brief discussion with the superintendent when we're going over the agenda that we may need to hear have a more uh a fuller discussion at our January meeting because some decisions need to be made with regards to the classes of 2025 most importantly and then 2026 even um and as I think the superintendent touched
148on previously um the question two said schools are no longer mandated to have the mcast passage as a requirement for graduation but as um Desi indicated one of the relatively clear parts of their memo was the part where they said but any school district can choose to keep it as a requirement um some of you know uh particularly those that have been around the Shen Ro to VOC work for a while um many vog schools have their own sort of special history with mcast requirements because many felt um Ron probably experienc this as a teacher and Patty is our senior member that fought we fought um the mcast completely yep you know but then our kids did amazingly well so it's all right many vocational superintendents and school committees have felt that this has been
149one of the best ways to highlight the fact that our our students are good academically as well as into their their trade areas and that having this as a requirement has been has also provided a comfort level to our sending communities oh they look at those scores coming out of whether it be shaen or minut man or Keef or many other schools they say that's pretty comparable to our sending communities are doing and many times better and nonetheless we know how the vote went and I don't personally know how um any of our sending districts are going to what they're going to do with this yet um as some of you know the numbers of kids overall in the state who were not getting a diploma I believe it's been estimated around 700 per year
150which is relatively small number but I'm I'm forgetting the number of graduates who who could not get a high school right who could not get the diploma because they couldn't because and that includes kids with with obviously significant learning disability assment cases and English language Learners other cases anyways um so but we are left with the real question which is do we want to keep it as a requirement I'm suggested that Tony this might be something where we really do want to hear from our our vocational uh sorry our academic director and our vocational director um just to clarify again uh before anybody says um you know well this does this mean we'll have to take the mcast if we keep it we're gon have to the mcast is gonna be is gonna be administered
151one way or the other and the incast scores are going to be available it more gets into an issue of what's sort of the attitude and the vi and I did not realize till Tony mentioned it to me that apparently the day the vote was of course on a Tuesday night the Wednesday after at the mcast was administered here at the school which might have been our first uh mcast being administered without everybody thinking the graduation dependent on it I think this is a tough I don't I don't know if it's a tough call I think it's a an interesting call for all of us as to whether we think it's in the interest of sha Sheen um to say well we still like we like that requirement we like what it says about our
152school or do we want to sort of defer to the to the will of the voters um and as you saw what I think is most in addition to the whole retroactive which I I personally never expected Desi to go there um we were worried about the classes of 25 and 26 and Desi said well why don't you go back to the class of 2000 um or and um see if kids that's something Desi is going to have to work out but then they said well every District can sort of still have its own policies um so I did suggest to the superintendent it' be interesting to hear how many kids because right now is when kids have now taken the 2025 retake if you will um there are math and English yeah math and
153English and there are people within the building who are gearing up to um help the kids that need another opportunity to take the next one and the next graduating class I thought the Desi language around the class of two 2025 was a little bit awkward to me at least about well no they can't take the mcast you can't anyways um I've meandered around too much so turn it over to you I think there's a couple of misleading things in this um the first one I would point out is is competency determination and graduation requirements are two vastly different things in this document so as a committee you can decide to to maintain the passing the mcast as a graduation requirement but it cannot be used as a competency determination moving forward so that that to
154me is a whole another conversation um and the committee then needs to look at what is the competency determination for kids that do not pass it and that has to be separate and Standalone criteria and it can't involve mcast scores so that that's one conversation um it's my understanding that we only have one student in the class of 2025 um that has not passed all three exams at this point and I believe there's 12 or 13 in the class of 2026 um but we do need to have a plan to support those students uh especially as this is in flux there is a meeting Friday um with with the principal the academic director and all the academic chairs and myself um for us to kind of start having some preliminary conversations about this um my
155my thoughts on this would be um that maybe we get um the curriculum subcommittee together um with the principal the academic coord I mean we include the vocational coordinator if you guys want I don't know who it maybe we have an early January meeting with them um after we've had a chance to meet with the academic Department chairs and get their feedback and input of what it should look like um and then hope we can either make a decision at the January meeting or maybe at the latest i' say the February meeting about what what this is going to look like and where we want to go with it I have a question have have we ever had a child not graduated ask think we've had one really because we used to work really hard
156with you know you can the file and everything yeah you can do the portfolio yeah yeah and so when you said you know like 700 I think I think that's awful and that yeah and then say especially with special needs because we work really hard to make damn sure those kids graduate you know and do a ton of work and whatever they have to prove themselves but they have so and have we ever gotten kicked back from you know pushed back from parents or anything until this discussion came up do you know yes yeah yeah their kid doesn't I mean you don't have to give me details yeah without getting into a lot of detail we we have some pretty active parents that were very vocal in support of um question two because of the
157vote I mean prior to that they they were actually the ones that kind of pushed this through um to become a ballot yeah all right we busy so they wanted to go away as a they wanted to remove it as a graduation requirement yeah yeah so am I correct somebody this came up after this the election somebody was telling me the only two things you have to pass are history in Jim yep s really according to the St and again local committees have the ability to implement their own local requirements but yeah as at when that law passed in massach Massachusetts actually has the lowest graduation standards in the country at this point in time because all you have to do is pass US history and fad well I know how I got high school
158but every school system had their own graduation I mean we had requirements so that's why when everybody went a little crazy like oh gosh what are we GNA do about requirements like you should already have them well yeah you have them I know we know Charlie one the uh students that so so right now there's one student that can't graduate in June and you said it was like 12 yeah 12 or 13 I don't but they have another full year but they can't so if you read that guidance document they can no longer use they can no longer retest so if they if they took the retest in November passed they're fine if they took the retest in November and failed or didn't get a chance to take the science test because it's not till
159later in the year they cannot they cannot now pass the test based on mcast scores as a committee we have that we have to decide or you have to decide what the competency determination is for the district for those students so MC cannot be how they get graduation right and do we have the results of those November scor test maybe February usually February is so there gota be ways around it though I mean the kid comes to school all the time and does his work I mean well I mean you can do you can do a port you can do a portfolio appeal um the earlier on in the mcast process those were easier um the last two or three years the department of Ed has really cracked down on what they'll approve and what
160they won't approve yeah but if this child is has failed the mcash you can't do a portfolio anymore and send it to the state no that also says so it has it's G to have to be something internally you guys yeah you guys determine what that's gonna be yeah that student that one student from class of 25 did they take mcast retakes in November that I don't know because I don't I don't know what exam it is that I don't know if it's all three I don't know if they've passed one and not you know or past two and not one of them I didn't I so it may be that it's a moot point because the student took the retest in November and passed and we just don't know it yet that that could
161be but it could be that we're gonna find out in February that this student cannot graduate so I think we have to have a plan so what is the third they have to P pass math English and science or yes third Muse yes yeah so it's it's it's English language arts it's math and science was added later yep yeah and our kids do biology our kids take the biology ex Tony I knew this was gonna get messy we talked about it like down the cape and I said oh shoot when they voted this in and you knew it was going to pass but Des so desie says okay figured out it passed yeah figure it out yeah all right they released their guidance document late this was about a week and a half later than
162they said they were going to send it out and I'm going to be honest this doesn't really say anything more than the first one they sent out except for the fact that you can't use mcast as a graduation requir it's I keep reading the only thing it says I mean I'm sorry as a competency determination as a compation I'm sorry yeah yeah this this this was not helpful at all the test will still be given the state is paying for the contract okay great all right realizing think Federal requirements yeah necessitate that an mcast or something comparable but um the folks that put together and even the port one of the things I think we talked about briefly the portfolio issue is kind of an interesting one because I'm not sure to what degree the
163portfolio is equally representative of both say the vocational side of the house here and the academic side and we I think we have to Res we want to make sure we're being respectful of both it would be kind of easy for us to say well we're a vocational school all our kids are you know doing trade they're doing Hands-On things certifiable skills oh yeah and there's academics but I think we've had mcast has given us a little bit of the luxury of saying no we we've got competencies demonstrated on both sides so um again to the extent that we have members of the of the shashing community who are partic who thought that this is something that should be limited ated from you know we can be sensitive to that we don't necessarily have to
164agree that's in the best interest of the school but um don't what one of the reasons we want to have it on the agenda tonight that you know people may again hear from folks who have strong I found it Nancy um I'm what does competency mean if it's not a requirement so competency determination is criteria that's established by the school committee that is essentially essentially you're becoming the the portfolio approval yes yes so again that can be uh completion of a certain number of classes it could be GPA I mean it so competency means we set the standards basically as opposed to M essentially essentially Department of Ed has just pushed this back to 3 I thought it was that simple but districts across the state yeah yeah and I think the Dey had I
165didn't see this portion of I think they had a meeting today where they discussed our other favorite issue about admissions offw but they also discussed competency determinations I don't have no idea what they came up with but obviously there's nothing they came up with today that's ready for implementation as quickly as we need to have this implemented could they come back and tell us they don't like our competency standards the way that the memo was written I it sounds like they washed the hands of this whole thing I think so think it doesn't look like there's any reporting requirements it doesn't look like there's any any kind of information to the states huh let them duke it out so we could give diplomas based on what we want to give diplomas for he you at
166schol right right there anyway like I said that meeting on Friday I think is gonna is going to be eye openening to see um you know from the standpoint of the academic Department shairs what they think is appropriate and and in a validation of a student's abilities um and and again you know the academic director and the principal will also be en the conversation too so I think it would be behoove us to have curriculum subcommittee make very sure that they meet early in the month so that if necessary there has to be a second meeting we can squeeze it in because it does sound like it would make your life a lot less stressful if we could come to a decision in January it may be impossible to come to a decision at the
167January meeting but if that could be our goal yeah assuming we can get input from the staff which we should be able to get if curriculum meets that mean that makes a huge difference that meeting will happen Friday so we have one a one off and that's it one meeting is gonna do it I mean we'll see we'll see where it goes but I mean we also we also have some pretty bright academic chairs um and I mean I could walk out of a meeting on Friday and somebody kind of comes out with a a shattering recommendation that you know none of us have I mean at least I haven't thought of um I mean that's a distinct possibility too I mean they're they're way more intimately involved in this on a day-to-day basis than
168I am that' be nice that would be yeah and there's there's also possibility that what we think is right to do for these media to classes 25 and 26 is not what should be done long term because just because where we are on the calendar now where the kids are right now and their plans to graduate and where we are or aren't on determining competency determinations the other thing obviously we'll all you know might good time to check in on our sending communities in terms of what they're doing we you know we could have the situation where five surrounding t five sending Community say we're just getting rid of we're just not having that as a requirement at all it's being dropped from all of our and shashin is the one place in the district
169that says no we want to keep it if people feel that strongly about it um and how would that impact us I think we have to think about that exactly have to take the test no matter what so but I mean we have to respond have an answer ready for this because that's what I was thinking that if that comes up we have to know in advance what we're gonna say we can't be reactionary we have to be proactive and I I think that can come both ways because if we're the only one that has it then the sending districts can say well my kids's not going to go because it's a requirement but if we're the only one that don't have it then they're going to say why would I send my kid because
170they don't care about this so I I think it's going to be a balancing act one can we direct you to reach out to the five sending superintendent before the January meeting and hopefully be able to tell us yeah I I know they're all I I was actually I was at a meeting with the tberry superintendent on Monday and I know they're they have the same similar struggles and everybody's frustrated with the lack of diretion that the department of is given but yeah I I can I can reach out to everybody willing to give it for statement that can be shared I seemed particularly odd that this that the department chose to say oh you could have it and then they the language they put in about this year's graduating class and again for another
171day we the superintendent will inform us again as somebody you saw the globe picked up on they also said oh any of the kids that graduated in the last 15 years 15 the 20 years who did not get a diploma which again fortunately as I understand historic if not a lot of kids for for shaen we're lucky and every kid we want to make sure this treated properly um but they're saying the school districts all over the State child could come in who graduated who did not graduate 10 to 15 years ago and say I want a a shot at it you know or maybe retroactively they should just get a diploma if that's the case so here here's the complication with that the only record that we have to keep after a kid graduates
172is their transcript so it it shows what classes they took and what grades they got so if if each if each sending Community now has to go back and research for every single kid that comes forward and says I didn't graduate what do I have to do to get a diploma I think you know for us obviously it's not it's not that big of a discussion but if you're wer Public Schools or Springfield Public Schools or Boston Public Schools that's a whole another department that you're now going to have to employ in your school district just to respond to those requests and that's why this is at least two meeting item this out yeah I think we need a a what do you call it a retreat for this meet for the subject alone so
173Mr chairman we'll we'll wait to hear department chair Tonia meeting and I will I will reach out um let us know please who is is Nancy you curriculum Patty you're the curriculum chair now okay so I I'll reach out and we'll try to set something up out yeah because we this I I know this is on we got to do something because F kids gr well I put that on that plate thank you when referenda pass it should at least be uh an appropriate well not at least an appropriate phase in um but that's notice when they did the ads for that they'd have one for and immediately after one against I was the weest thing yeah well if that was the second that might be the second most no that's the most confusing item
174or the last item we have on our new business um see if we can try to do this in the simplest form possible it's called revisions to fy4 transfers to health insurance trust fund why are we revising something related to the fiscal year 24 trust rund it was brought to the superintendent attention by um very Eagle eyed readers of minutes of meetings and observers of of uh school committee meetings that in uh June and July of this year and two consecutive and Tony will fill in any and Jenna will fill in any of the gaps what I'm about to say in successive meetings there were votes taken to make transfers to the health insurance trust fund now we have a little bit Fuller record of the discussion that took place at the June meeting because
175it was it was on film we have a little less uh of a record of the second meeting because we have wonderful minutes but we don't have the full context but one of the things that happened is when uh Jenna describ the transfer and keeping in mind this is before the end of the fiscal year there were a lot of estimates as to how much money would be transferred and but there was a figure based on so there was a discussion about transferring money into the Health Trust Fund based on estimates at that time on the school bus transportation reimbursement and I think there was another reimbursement item so there was an amount offered at at the meeting of 400 and I I'm don't have the sheet in front of me I had it oh
176thank you 4 and uh yeah the first one was 719,000 uh to be transferred um and then we voted for that however I want to make it clear Jenna said at the meeting that this was sort of a you know a placehold placeholder or a budgetary approach you know based on what was expected and what was going to be finalized etc etc we took a vote in support of that transfer 7 um $199,000 plus then at our July Retreat meeting when further numbers had come in including the transportation reimbursement Jenna had what what I would call essentially final numbers um and again these guys will correct me as soon as that need need great keep going all right um and the actual number was somewhere around $462,000 but if you looked at just the minutes
177of the meeting it looked like we did a transfer one month of 719,000 and another transfer the next month of 462,000 when the actual transfer got made it was a little less than the 462 was like 442 or thereabouts but someone reading the minutes as someone did and we we want to be thankful to our followers and people who read all it looked like we' approved two separate transactions and yet roughly $719,000 had never been transferred um which would be that would be a real problem but no transfer was made after the June meeting because it was all temporary and what was being asked for was oh would you approve a transfer in effect up to $719,000 if all of these other numbers all of these estimates Transportation reimbursement Etc come back as anticipated then
178in the July meeting again the one business item I think we did at that meeting was Jenna had further numbers and what we actually authorized was $462,000 but what we now need to do and we any questions and comments people have is we need to sort of clean up the the public record of of those two meetings and I think the the motion that would probably come out of all this is we need a motion to clarify that the amount out of the FY 24 uh budget that was being transferred to the health insurance trust fund is actually 400 and um 42,000 something like that okay do we have to resend the first vote um I think we yeah I think if we do that the second vote would take care of it right it
179wasn't the exact amount it wasn't the exact we have to resend both votes and take another vote for the actual accurate amount and I I did send the physical trans so Tony and I don't know if Tony the actual transfers it's just a a sequence of votes that I think would be um well technically you resend the the June transfer transfer vote which really was never intended to be a transfer vot that was a draft supposedly right essentally yes and then we technically should TR we should resend the July amount because that did not become the final amount um and then we would actually approve the transfer of the actual amount does it need to be three separate votes or can it be all one I think it could be done as one vote it's
180a little clunky but it's gonna be clunky either way so but be yeah I think it could be done if somebody wants if I make a motion that we resend the nove the June and July votes of health insurance transfers and approve we looking for the exact number an exact number to be determined by I thought I already moved it no we we have that actual number because we actually moved it already right it's yeah that's but it's not it's not that number it's that's what we're trying to find out it's like 40 yeah I think it's all yours if you want me when we met yeah I know make it more official can find office I'm trying to follow so if we can just we have a motion do we have we have a
181second my motion completed where I don't have the number what's that did my motion get completed where I didn't we need we need to we need the number to clarify to complete thank you it clarified this before we vote is I get the point about the first one from June we shouldn't be voting on estimates that's a whole other so that's one piece of it but the secondary question becomes why did we vote on a number in July that we thought was a final number but wasn't the actual final number knowing that there wasn't a huge Delta in between the two but the one from June is like I said that's just like I said it's more just Jenna recommended right you really need to vote but I guess the question is why at the
182July meeting do we vote on a final number that we thought was final but it was not final right the actual number so get before we get back to Ken's point the actual number um was 393 so like $220,000 less than the number we we actually had presented to us42 3209 393 393 um so uh do superintendent or the business manager want to address right this question we had so we we now have a we have a motion do we have a second second second it's part of the discussion here do you want to explain the difference between the 462 and the 4 42 which is the actual transfer that was just some items that closed and were paid out from the time we met till the time the numbers are final p out of
183the general fund I I do think that there was some discussion at this is something we we want to be aware of next June to July there was some discussion um at the June meeting about oh there will be some f you know we'll do some final checks on all of this when the school committee comes back in the fall but we W up taking the issue up in July um the second week I think in July first week yeah first week after the July 4th holiday when something things hadn't been quite closed out for the previous fiscal year so I think that reflects the relatively small Delta of $20,000 yeah but I guess that leads into the question of like I get timing but that leads into the context of it this is the
184same as like line item transfer if that requires a Bart V then I guess there should be a discussion because that leads in now we have not just one question we've got two you got the first question which is basically like you're presenting something at a meeting saying okay that's an estimate and I think that that really should be not voting upon it's more just like hey you know this is information blah blah blah we authorize you authoriz we I agree looking back at it both the the minutes and also having uh watched a chunk of the tape of the um June meeting and you you all looked marvelous and it was really great and I I never watched one of those things I don't think at least not that much of one um I
185think we should have called time out and said no there's nothing to vote on here because the numbers are going to be in flux over the next few weeks so we probably should not have taken a vote as I say and I I do specifically the phrase that Jenny used this is more of a budget strategy than it is an actual transfer and yet I think when voted when the motion was made it was it was reported out as a motion it was you know budget transfer budget budget transfer or you voted basically saying I mean throw out the June one basically saying we shouldn't be voting that's confusing but if you're gonna vote on something that's probably not GNA have put that language in the vote that says you know could change pending and
186a final number will be reported out absolutely all right other questions about the process or the meaning or just just help clarify that I think so motion 462 that was so if we can we like you said you still don't have the final number so I how I don't know how soon you need to get the vote in to be able to transfer the money so there's no problems but the money has been transferred forward forward could we like could the motion be like we will motion to approve up to 462 and then if it comes in less everybody's happy I think that's what you did the previous year because it was up to like 250 into compensated absence up to 250 so it could be anywhere from zero to 250 so we don't have
187to go back and do what rechain that's know there's a change basically the July meeting you can report it back in the September meeting so then you get the revision caught up there right so I said like I think it's not only one item it's now two because like to your point it's the confusing about the basically that you're saying okay we're giving one meeting that's informational only and we're providing a vote that's confusing in itself I think that we shouldn't even vote throw that going forward and then to your point anything that's a uh and you know up to to Charlie's point like that would go authorize you know so it's the same thing with payroll or any of the warrants you're not getting held up but then when the final number you'll get
188that you know again give or take there's gonna be like two months in between the July meeting and September a final report comes back based on that nothing really happens fast I'm learning with procurement and paying bills it's always like there's always like a 30 to 90 day lag till it catches up so that's definitely a learning process the timing of everything is a little slow nothing is instant when you're dealing with the public funds well I think to Charlie point I think you want a happy medium between like making sure stuff's paid timely but as we've seen in past years you know basically that it you know on the public record so make sure that basically that you know and it behooves us if we see and because when you when we look back
189at the documents that were present that J presented to us at the June meeting there's this big contingency there of Transportation reimbursement and when we see that we have to again time out if if there's a big contingency we shouldn't be voting an actual transfer but this is different than a budget transfer like you have final numbers we vote that that's not going to delay that's just record keeping if you still need that vote basically to reconcile to balance that but that's like this is like to Charlie's point this is basically the potential that it could delay you know Financial impact so I think that's they are slightly different in the fact that basically you are voting basically for that and we can determine that in the future what that threshold is going to be
190but when the final numbers are reported for whatever it is Health whatever you can cover the list of items then you report out after that knowing you can come to the September meeting and say this this was deposit in op this was deposit in this account this was deposit in this account all right we have a motion we have a second and we have more discussion about the health fair trans fund that we've had in months and we have one amount of 44239 that has already been transferred so having said that um vote to make those changes in our record all in favor please say I I I any opposed any extensions all right the eyes have it all right uh lastly or next to last future agenda items AIT audit upate audit update curriculum
191we already talked about curriculum curriculum in mcast will clearly be on the next meeting organizational sorry anything else we probably should review like because we haven't had a meeting but the safety just because some of the stuff from the climate survey there wasn't a lot of safety but I was going mentioned it be some stuff theair I Taran Nancy and Stacy okay Nancy just said that what I mean is there a specific F which is fine what what be the focus of or just to have them meet I can you can should policy meet before then to discuss a f bus thing or is that not that not urgent enough that's up to you we have we're have a bunch of BU going on lot of meetings do we have a go your house later
192there no other proposed items or people we want hear from the meetings I we I think motion to adjourn motion to adjourn second made and seconded all in favor any extensions any proposition