CorpusRecord 197353

Planning Board Meeting: February 18, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / MyMilfordTV
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Worcester County, MA
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,445 words · about 47 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] good evening and welcome to the planner board meeting of Tuesday February 18 2025 uh the first order business of the meetings uh the minutes of the meeting of uh I make a motion to accept the meeting minutes as written second been mov in second to accept the uh minutes of the last meeting any further discussion there are none all those in favor right opposed unanimous of five got a couple of minutes to to wait public here in [Music] there's a seat back up front here okay okay Larry put that in yeah continued public hearing uh on the application of Route 85 realy Corp per special permit approval regarding construction of 191,00 ft² wholesale facility Associated parking on a 116 acre undeveloped property uh on the west side of East Main Street Southwest of Wildwood

002Drive known and numbered as zero East Main Street cessor map 30 Block zero bot 34 it's in a BP business park zone I remind everyone this is a continued public hearing from uh last month's meeting and it's uh Cas is on remand from the land Court uh I'd like to point out to the members that in your packet uh other than a draft um uh decision uh with uh conditions um I copied you with the email that was forwarded to you this morning uh from bowler uh dated February 14th 2025 uh it's a multi-page uh response memo to the comments that were received at the last meeting uh also included was U an email uh from uh Jerry Edens uh and that was forwarded to you as well by email thank you Larry Anon you

003want to open the uh good evening to the members of board Joseph Anon Allis on behalf of the applicant uh we have our team with us again tonight um we pres we we perceive this meeting as an opportunity to review with the board the uh comment letter that we prepared very extensive um it's my in my opinion based on my experience um with this applicant and my experience in in permitting sites that the application has presented and the supporting information has been uh prepared in accordance with the town's bylaws in accordance with the standards set in the Massachusetts Environmental Protection laws regarding sound and mitigation and uh the applicant is confident that it has met uh the criteria that are required for the grant of a special permit I recognize obviously recognize the significant opposition

004to this project um that is not surprising um that is uh manner in which permitting goes these days uh we have talked about this uh at a great length this is not a warehouse facility this is a building that will be used for wholesaling with storage as I informed on the board in the prior meeting and has been uh resubmitted in the application and the update that was submitted with the application the distinction that needs to be made between the warehouse use which is not allowed in this district and wholesaling with storage is very very simple distinction but a crucial one in a warehouse the trucks that come to the warehouse and take product from it can go directly to Consumers which creates the type of traffic that the to of NOA has seen as

005a result of the large retailer uh distributor Amazon which as you all know deals directly with household customers a wholesaling facility on the other hand does not and cannot deal directly with consumers it deals with end users that are commercial users and it is limited to the distribution of goods and products to users that are commercial or industrial I have used the example before and I will share it again for just purposes of the record I think the best description would be you have an O'Reilly's auto part store on Route 16 in Milford assume arguendo that Riley's Auto Part company was looking for a facility to distribute its product to its stores they would be what we considered a possible tenant because they are not dealing directly with consumers they are dealing with retail operations

006the same could be said of other types of companies um I I've also used the example in um a particular uh situation where you might have CVS or a facility like that that has trucks going to its pharmacies those are not always large trucks and they don't go to your house they go only to the pharmacy so the facility that we are seeking to permit is wholesaling with with storage that will not be allowed and cannot be used for direct uh contact with consumers uh additionally um we have spent significant amount of time uh doing the research relative to providing barriers and environmental u sound barriers for this particular project to the best of my knowledge there has not been a recommendation from any of the town's peer cord here Consultants to improve the wall

007other than as we've shown it again we put a significant amount of effort into the design of the wall it's a substantial expense we do it with with full and complete understanding that it's necessary and uh we're prepared to do it uh relative to the safety issues I believe that the uh response letter that was submitted by bowler properly references the proper codes for for calculating the number of traffic trips that will be generated by this facility and the study of the various intersections in and around the facility were completed in the manner that is set forth under the the standards that is set by the uh National associations that deal with traffic counts I understand very well that all traffic like politics is local and that there will be an impact on the town

008of Milford for the development of this property and I will tell you that it's my opinion that there'll be an impact on the town of Milford for the development of any property that's left in the town of Milford so this is not a question in my opinion of of whether or not there will be an impact there's going to be an impact from any development of this property and again I think that the proper mitigation has been set forth in the manner in which we present it to the board with that I will stop talking give the board the opportunity please to ask direct questions of The Advocate um I recognize that the residents have every right to speak I have long championed the rights of the residents to speak however um I I do

009think at this point that we've heard them and so have the board um so I would like to focus on what we've done to answer the questions that have been asked by the residents and to that end I'll turn it over to John kusich who prepared the letter and John you can bring Mark in or anybody else as you want going along um and again I appreciate the board the opportunity and the patience the board has had with the applicant we've been in front of you uh attempting to develop this Pro property now for quite some time and again I'm confident that we have taken into consideration all of the bylaws of the to Milford and we have done our best to meet the concerns of the residents to develop the prod property in the

010manner which it was zoned is his zoning was approved by the town of Milford by a 2/3 majority every use that's in this spot in this in this area in this Zone was approved by 2third of the residents of Milford if it we're not we wouldn't be before you so with that said I'm going to let John take over thank you thanks Joe uh for the record John cusk with bowler I've been before you a few times now um the last hearing uh you had taken a bunch of public comment and there were some letters submitted as part of that uh and it was asked that we could just address some of the comments that were U that were raised rather than just having along back and forth at the end of the hearing um

011so much of which was uh was raised the last hearing has really been part of the process from from the beginning it focused a lot about traffic a lot about sound a lot about zoning so what we did is we took the comments and there were five or so different um comment letters we essentially reconciled them we put them in one response and if there were six comments that had to do with one aspect of traffic we bunched them together and provided a a response you know if there are five comments about sound we bunched them together and and just put a put a response and speaking just from a from a high level and we do have the experts here to talk about that if you have specific questions with traffic again this was

012fully uh peer reviewed by by your peerreview consultant we went through multiple rounds and addressed everything and satisfied their um their comments uh We've reiterated that and for the record we've reattached those in the response letter just so you you had that I think that was part of the first um process uh same with sound a bunch of questions were asked about the sound those were included in the the submitt that um the tech had provided previously but we've broken those out and responded to that accordingly and then similarly with zoning with with um that Joe just just touched Ted upon there was a memo that was prepared early on just to say how this does comply with the use from a zoning standpoint again we just reattached that memo and and addressed it um

013so I can have folks get into this one by one Whatever detail you want or just ask any generic questions but essentially what came up really wasn't anything new it was a lot of what we heard before relative to the methodology of the traffic study where it was done did it include x y or z uh those types of things so that I'll if we go however the the chair and the board uh would like us to board members have a reference I've gone through the answers to the comments I they were pretty much as as I would have expected in terms of of what the answers were but you know I we knew probably all of them but I think it's good to have them in here um you know high level points obviously

014this project is zoned for this location the thing that says that this isn't zon for that is there's nothing that we can do about that it is that's what the zoning is for this area as to you know High Cube Warehouse or whatever it you know you use the best terms in it to try to get a traffic count if they're not exactly there and we knew that going in and it was an agreement between the consultant and our consultant this would be the uh the best approximation of what traffic would be and I think we all agreed that that that that's what that was um and they went through the other noise things to indicate what they had or had not used and and what the options are in terms of that so I

015think the major the major items that were brought up were addressed in the letter that came back to us okay Mr chair yes yeah I have to agree with you Joe you know yeah we kind of went over the generic site plan traffic noise uh just kind of we we've heard from the neighbors um Marthur brought up what other uses would potentially be be governed in this area um Larry I'll just ask you quickly uh has this um property ever had a 40b application on it yes it does okay yeah it has had it approved for Approved now right right so I just wanted to yes yes wanted to be clear on that how many okay could I ask you to ask how many units uh between 268 and 300 units yeah as of phase

016one I'm 268 to 300 you said yeah at 30 trips per day per home mhm and I don't want to go too far down there and that's using that same parcel of land that you have kind of the site plan on or to have extended even more so there was opportunities for for more but the the approved portion was a phase one for the existing land that we're using then again I heard 250 to 300 residential units correct okay thank you appreciate that so thank you for that so I think that you know that needs to be kind of talked about that what other potential um you know buildings could be put on this this and the impact again with noise and with traffic especially traffic um so it's why that is something that uh

017a 250 to 300 unit apartment building at 40b is going to have a very significant impact even more so than a wholesale facility any else at this time I'm still I'm still a little stuck on the um uh on the uh noise study um I know it's difficult to do that I understand Gathering the Baseline you know getting some senses out there and and uh getting an idea on what the Bas line is today and obviously it's um there's quite a bit of noise already um and I know it's difficult to predict what the noise will be I mean I used to be in the rock and roll band I mean different frequencies different frequencies act differently uh you know you're standing inside the guitar players too loud you go outside it's the drama in

018the base so I I really don't know how a 15 ft high wall maybe 10% is going to mitigate the noise can you explain [Applause] that uh for the record my name is Mark Wallace I'm with tech environmental um so in our sound study as you mentioned we did do a baseline to establish ambient conditions um and that's on the basis of that is based on the mass DP noise policy so you establish what the existing ambient conditions are and then you're supposed to project or propagate what the sound would be from a particular facility so in this case we looked at rooftop equipment idling trucks trucks moving around the site to uh evaluate what those potential sound impacts would be at the nearest residences and the the policy allows for two things one is

019uh up to a 10 dcel increase over ambient conditions that's the maximum um and then it doesn't allow for what you were talking about for example different frequencies no pure tone conditions from from a source or from a facility um and we look at both of those uh parameters as trying to demonstrate compliance with the noise with the noise policy so you know we establish the ambient conditions uh during the evening and the daytime conditions uh then we used a uh computational model a three-dimensional model that took into account um the sound sources the buildings the um uh the S the how much sound would be propagated from those different sources operating all simultaneously at their maximum sound level um and then we project what that sound level would be at the nearest homes um

020not only at the first floor level but if they had a second story we looked at those Second Story locations as well so when we did our analysis of that um we saw that there was you know we were getting right up to near the limit um at the closest homes so we then looked at what could we do to reduce that sound um and we we uh did different evaluations of different barrier uh designs and and um dimensions and Heights um and what we proposed was a 15t tall wall to and approximately 340 ft long sort of in an l-shape to reduce primarily the sound that's coming from the loading dock areas cuz that's the that was the sound that was the you cuz we can look at different sound parameters not only the

021total sound from the facility but we can look at different sound sources whether it's rooftop equipment trucks you know other types of sound sources um and so we wanted to make sure that we uh had a you know a sound wall that would minimize the noise at the closest residences in our January 15th letter we had a figure in there or two fig figures that showed um contour lines which are basically the sound levels that are projected um you know you know at um from the facility itself and in those images you could see that the wall took in the Contour and basically reducing that sound um so you know we did quite a bit of evaluation on trying to minimize the noise from that so it's a two-step process you know it's establishing what

022the ambient conditions are and then doing a a model assessment to demonstrate whether the facility is going to be in compliance or not we would you even be open to a condition where once the facility was constructed and operating we would go back we could perform another sound study ensure that what we presented is it is actually what's being produced and if not we would further mitigate to ensure um that what we presented is what's being produced we we also I just want to add one other thing I think we also put in our package I believe Good Neighbor yes policies so there are a number I think 13 or 14 items that we had listed in there that would help to minimize noise um one of those is for example I know there's concerns

023about backup alarms there are white noise backup alarms that are that can be used on equipment um at the fac at the at the facility uh the difference between you know white noise backup alarm say then the traditional backup alarm is um the White Noise spread sprs that sound energy so that it's not going as as far away it's basically what it's supposed to be doing is protecting the employees from a truck backing up or or or a piece of equipment backing up so it spreads that energy out it's the same amount of energy but you're not putting it in one particular frequency which then can travel quite a bit so you hear that sort of beeping sound so the white noise is something you might hear like you might see from an Amazon truck

024it makes a squawking sound or you know uh that type of thing or shushing sound there couple of different kinds um and they're they're very effective in reducing um those kind of sound impacts that the neighbors are concerned about um again it's an ooser require you know again it's not regulated by the mass DP noise policy but it is something that could be used to help minimize you know nuisance noise conditions so with the with the plan to go 24/7 I know that you had a baseline for worst case in the morning worst case in the afternoon was there something done in the evening it was it was done um we so when we set up the sound meter we did measurements over 24 hours over 7 or 8 day period um and so what

025when we did our analysis we actually took the quietest I believe it was at 2:00 in the morning that was the quietest sound level during the night time and we used that to uh do our evaluation and then we did a a subsequent evaluation due to comments from the board to look at daytime operations which obviously have a higher uh sound condition um and we we looked at that as well and and and showed that we comp the mass DP noise policy oh I'm sorry I was trying to direct the gentlemen to the one available [Music] seat any other comments questions the board right now okay I'm going to again I'm going to open up to the public please state your name your address and all all the everything goes through the chair not the

026debate and Society here please yes ma'am my name is debah Romero I live at for Wildwood Drive so I'm really upset about this um I spoken a couple times so I'll make it brief but I do want to say that um I I've said this before I'm sure that their eyes are daughtered and their te's are crossed and the sound wall I'm I'm sure it's all like part of it's part of life and letting a company do what they want to do on the property but ultimately honestly no matter what they do it's the wrong thing for I live and the people around me it's the wrong thing no matter how much sound barriers they have no the from from the traffic to the sound I like I said I can hear 495 when someone

027beeps their horn because it carries I mean it's just it's brutal as it is I hate living where I live pay taxes there for over 35 years I'm a single homeowner I I have to put on AC's and white noise to be able to sleep as it is now never mind with a facility there um and I'm also concerned while I I don't want to say the wrong thing but when we had the meeting in the summer it was denied and the attorney rushes up and says if we change the time from not 247 will you allow this then the planning board gets sued individually I mean it's they want what they want and and no matter what they do they might be right the sound the studies they might be right but it's the

028wrong thing so that's my plea it's the wrong thing people have two little kids on this cross the street two little girls it's just disastrous it's I was late today and I apologize walking in late and you know trying to disrupt things but I lived there and I couldn't get here it's brutal just as it is and and somebody has money and that's what they do for a living they want to uh you know get properties and build them up and do things good for them but it's the wrong thing in that particular area huming Brook and hollon denied it and they're an industrial park we're a neighborhood that it's just it's just it's just horrible and um it's just it's just the wrong thing to do so I just want to ple with the

029board it's the wrong thing ultimately no matter what they do and please deny it thank [Applause] you hi I'm J Goan I live at Zan Zan Ridge Condo um I didn't realize this was going to go this is a 24hour day thing 365 that's that's crazy the town ordinance 7 to7 noise ordinance you cannot make any noise prior to 7: a.m. after 7:00 p.m. you'll have the police called on you all night long yes [Music] sir excuse me um Jim Flanigan at 8 Whispering fine Drive been there for 27 years 28 28 years um well unfortunately the public has not seen the memo that few people have so it's a little hard for us to reut that information but um the lawyer for the applicant said that no one in the town has challenged the

030sound study I'll challenge the sound study because the sound study that that I was sent to by Mr Duncan does not have any the modeling dating and I I asked for very specific information about their assump ions they drew the lines but they never showed what the source of and how much sound they were projecting it as a decibel level and what assumptions they made in the model so none of the modeling information has been presented to anybody they just drew some lines on there and say this was the output of the model how can you how can you judge that I challenge that and I want to see the data the other request that was made by the residents here prior was there were meetings from the between the Town Council and the lawyers

031for the applicant and we have not seen any of that data what was discussed who attended those meetings we should know what that information is we have a right to know that information is being kept from the public and it looks a little fishy when you don't give the information you received correspondence explaining that that's privileged information I did not receive that well the email was sent out responding to the request I check the emails again today it was not there this was back when you asked the question that's that's privilege information client attorney client privilege either on their end with that attorney and these guys are on this end with Town Council and the planning board okay well thank you for that I didn't receive it the first thing I did after the meeting

032mon the next morning is I talked to Larry I asked as him about it because you asked for public information and that's he checked into it and that's when he came back to a response and he said he was sent it out so that's okay so clarification I got that again we did not ignore it we go right into it to make sure that we weren't holding something back that was supposed to be out to the public and that's yeah okay I will make a a comment about that now that I have that information that um client lawyer privilege seems a little suspicious I thought the town is I thought we were that's right I thought we we are the representatives it seems funny that the Town Council is supposed to be representing us no

033Town Council represents the town represents the planning board in this instance and and the individuals that were and the individual so thank you for the clarification um I do have uh another comment I I already talked about the Contour and the sound study and the traffic study uh and I understand the traffic study methodology is okay but as I requested the last time from the from the residents there that the traffic data is not accurate as of today and it needs to be updated so uh you know if you take data that's old and you use progression data growth data that's old it shouldn't be applicable that's all I have thank [Applause] you I know it's worth it yes sir said no okay yeah I just want to give you a quick outline what's your

034name Raymond AIS I live at 53 Zay Circle and um I was Ill at the last meeting so I was unable to be here to voice my opinion um I come from Framingham Massachusetts born and raised uh my wife's grandfather build framing Union Hospital Keith Tech South High School his his name is on the wall of the memorial building so I have a history there but things got through what you would call gentrification out of hand too noisy too busy too crazy I packed up my family we have relatives here myad is Chris Foley we moved here for peace and quiet now this is coming across the street and it's 247365 when you buy a property real property law not law but s law says that you have the right to quiet enjoyment of your

035property I think we're going to lose that it's 365 days a week I mean a year 24/7 if you care about us find a normal use for the property that's normal business ours that's not going to infringe upon our quiet enjoyment of our property we're all Zay circle is a 55 community we're in our West Lake we just want peace please I beg you thank you [Applause] hi my name is Alison I live at um at the last meeting the applicants attorney stated that the planning board has a responsibility to the town to manage long-term growth including generation of tax revenue there was also a intimation that this should occur even at the expense of some Town residents meaning us the planning board also had a responsibility to the town resident this should be self-evident

036and not have to be stated it is however explicitly stated in the section 1.10 D of the zoning bylaws that zoning bylaw states that the use for which the special permit is being sought will not cause substantial harm to the neighborhood or create a nuisance or Hazard affecting the health safety and general Weare of the citizens also us the planning board permitted a number of residential houses built in this area people own these houses are raising Families how can the planning board now permit a 41 Bay two football field size High tube Warehouse wholesale facility to be built in the middle of a residential area there are no other examples in the town of a large High Cube Warehouse wholesale facility existing in the middle of a residential area these are all in industrial parks

037this is good stewardship on the part of the planning board don't change that now let me ask you a question if this was going up in your neighborhood or your parents' neighborhood or your children's neighborhood would you want that for them protect our neighborhood as if it were your own reject this proposal thank [Applause] you yes uh first of all I'd like to thank the plan board for allowing us to speak here today um my name is Scott Harding I live at 19 Zay Circle I'm the current president of the Zay Rich condominium trust and I'm here to speak on behalf of the 70 homes in our community I have with me 40 four additional signatures uh along with the signatures that were attained in previous meetings uh which I believe brings our total to

038116 um signatures um so i' just like to make a couple of points because people have talked about this on a regular basis at the previous meetings and I don't want to go over deciples and noise and walls and things like that we all know what's being presented uh I would take a little bit of an issue with the uh applicant's attorney and his uh describing a what the the difference between this Warehouse uh distribution fac whatever you want to call it because it doesn't uh distribute directly to Residents it's irrelevant who they're Distributing to the point is what's going on at the warehouse how that's going to apply um I took a a look at the uh town of polman's uh recent situation with their applicant for warehouse a lot of it does not

039apply here but a lot of it actually does and in the end their point was that in their denial of the applicant was that regardless of whether they met the criteria that was outline excuse me excuse me in the uh in the bylaws describing what was allowed and what was not allowed that their facility and I believe this one as well would be a negative U impact on all of the surrounding uh communities neighborhoods uh around there and it's not just whether or not they meet the criteria that's put in the bylaws but how it is going to affect the health and well-being of the residents that are already there who also already pay taxes to the town and I think we all have a right to expect that we can have a normal use

040of our and enjoyment of our homes as others have pointed out and I would uh bece the board to consider what the actual impact will be on those of us that live [Applause] nearby yes sir if I might I'm sorry can I um present the signatures uh that I have [Music] thank you Chim thank you yes sir my name is Carl leaders I live the four pineal Circle um I agree with Jim that if this information is available that explains the way the questions that we had in the point would be great if it be made available to us to uh go through of our understanding but in the meantime at the last meeting the town engineer did state that the traffic study that was done both as a wholesale facility and a warehouse and

041that the result was an acceptable level of traffic I sent an email to the town engineer asking for a clarification to help me understand and hopefully this this information will but I never heard any reply back so to summarize my questions maybe they're Ed in this study the study was based on 2022 data based on milford's 2024 comprehensive plan the BLS are like more than twice what was in the set is that correct further the land use code 154 was used since it's the least intensive code that could be used that's .1 trip per th000 ft per day if that is in fact that was what used in the study if that is in fact the case why isn't that in the conditions of approval for this I don't see anything that limits the traffic

042volume to what they use for the study the zoning bylaw 2.2.2 states that where the activity might be classified under more than one use the more restrictive she'll govern this would require using land use code 155 which is orders of magnitude greater in terms of the volume it translate to a trip every minutes um wouldn't this greatly under State the impact of the traffic at Beaver Street Route 16 and Beaver Street Route 109 lastly the study only considers the impact of peak hours now I understand that's how these studies are done however it doesn't take into account the impact on the neighborhood 247 as others have stated earlier uh I did make a call to uh bass doot and speaking with a representative there I learned that before permit to GR access to Route 16

043from from the propos site would be granted Mass do will do the following they'll use their own current traffic site and not rely on an out ofate traffic site they'll look at the proposed facility and view it as a high volume 24/7 41 Bay IQ warehouse and not a wholesale facility they will identify it as a high traffic volume 155 land use code which is a vehicle every 5 minutes not a low volume volume 154 they will include Beaver Street and Route 109 intersection in their analysis and then not ignore it as this proposal has done and there are as they advise you there already issues that be speed 109 also with the with the noise study if in fact it's not going to impact us why not codify that in there with specifics like

0440.1 the land use .1 traffic volume by cautify specifically what the noise volumes will be in the in the conditions so that we have something against which we can measure how this proposal is performing in summary I I would just say it's going to be hard to measure all this just deny the proposal before it gets to this point Thank you thank you yes ma'am um yes this is Diane Goen from Zane Circle again and um I just want to congratulate or thank all of our neighbors neighbors from Wild Wood working PS we're talking over 500 families and we're aware that the proposed project will increase traffic congestion sewer and water concerns I mean how many times do we have water brakes and we turn on our and it's just a triple fire safety interference

045sound pollution and light pollution they haven't even addressed it like daytime daytime 247 you know noise 247 this is ridiculous um and then the i i commute um I take that road F 16 every week 8:30 in the morning it's already crawling and you're going to add these massive trucks um we have health issues and safety issues and it will decrease all of our home values so you're you're you know you're creating health issues on top of financial issues for all of these residents um this level of daily frustration will Elevate our stress to the max for decades and it has been proven by countless medical communities that chronic stress like this impacts the body um longterm effects of chronic stress it it elevates your cortisol heart disease stroke heart attacks it can that much

046stress causes caner you're going to make all of us sick and it's a very litigious Society people you know we will be coming after you people so the two questions I have do you not care 500 families will have to deal with prong stress and severe hle health issues and my other question is do you not care that 500 family homes will lose property [Applause] value Charn Flanigan 8 with Springtime drive and some of what I'm going to say has been already uh brought up but um I kind of like everyone here to um in at home to imagine um bringing a project of this scope into your neighborhood imagine IM you're being forced to move out of your home to avoid exposing your family s to such untenable conditions as the noise pollution from

047the blasting heavy equipment and diesel tractor trailers safety is issues most of those that we cannot even anticipate at this point the possible cracks in your foundation um think of the health issues that may include trouble breathing allergies sleeplessness headaches and overall stress from large trucks moving in and out of your neighborhood 24 hours a day 7 days a week 52 weeks a year every year is there even one holiday [Music] off imagine how your property value will be affected your most valuable asset for most people perhaps you're planning to pass your home down to your kids or your grandkids would you or they even be able to rent property under these circumstances turn your attention to the traffic on Route 16 which is already slow and way too congested how much worse will it

048be if the Route 85 realy group project is approved I think we all know that the traffic studies are not always accurate it took us about to 40 minutes to get here from 4 miles away today um most importantly let's imagine that there is someone on the planning board that sympathizes with residents and not with the developers and that they would and that they would do the right thing and they would vote against this project to protect the Milford residents that have worked long and hard and pay their taxes every year to preserve their home and property value would any of you honestly vote for this to be in your neighborhood thank you for the [Applause] consideration yes sir my name is I live at 11 Whispering line drive and basically I want to ask

049question why are we here we are here because we have an applicant who wants to build a high Cube Warehouse that would run 24 hours 7 days a week inid in the middle of a residential neighborhood and when the planning board rejected their proposal the applicant took the board to court to scare them into not following the town bylaws that are in place no matter how many times the concerned residents and taxpayers recite the bylaws that would that should and would put a stop to this project it seems that it seems to be unheard by the board because they have concerns about the lawsuit what is the importance of adhering to bylaws bylaws are established to maintain order safety and quality of life in a community they reflect the collective interests and values of the

050residents and are designed to protect the town's environment infrastructure and public welfare ignoring these bylaws could set a dangerous president undermining the rule of law and the Democratic processes that uphold Community standards if we are not going to adhere to the bys maybe we should try to use some Comm a common sense approach in doing so I would like to mention it seems both the traffic and sound studies are fulfilling the applicant's needs which are not realistic and do not protect the residents from actual traffic and sound volume volumes generated the traffic study provides the applicant provided by the applicant is from 20 22 in last month's board meeting our group provided the board with the information from a massive do traffic study which was completed in 2023 this traffic study details much higher traffic

051volume which is more recent and is more accurate to present day traffic patterns why are we not using the data from a more recent unbiased traffic study the sound study taken accounts for sounds being generated by hbac units on the building's roof in trucks in and trucks in idle which are the lowest sound producing elements of the facility this size if the trucks are backed up and idling at the loading docks how did they get there did they not make any sounds when pulling into the facility's lot and when backing up to the Loading Docks did they not did they not make the mandatory 95 de backup sound we all know there is there are going to be more sounds produced at higher Deb for a truck to maneuver to the loading dock so it

052can sit and idle to summarize the lawsuit to bypass local bylaws and approve a special permit based on misleading traffic and noise studies stands to undermine the principles of fear and informed decision making it is imperative for the planning board to ensure that any develop event developmental align any development aligns with the established standards and truly benefits the community as a whole for these reasons the proposal for the applicant's request to build a high Cube Warehouse that would run 24/7 in the middle of a residential neighborhood should be [Applause] rejected go the record please thank you thank you too couple more com yes sir thank you um speed find Circle um I think all the people in this side of the room know how often you lose power really isn't so bad probably use lose

053electricity and lose my water we know how often water it really sucks doesn't it FL your [Music] toil now we have a facility that look be put in across the street and I'm just concerned what happens when the water goes out they close down if they can't power up if they can't if they can't wi the the the sprinkler system do they shut down I mean it just seems logical to me we not talking about I mean this where else in town has a single thread of water any any place no certainly not a warehouse there are lots of fire regulations that say how sensitive something like this is when we look at stuff in the news about train wreck and people are just stuck because they happen to live next to that we don't

054know what they're going to be putting in this facility could be anything water can go out at any time all due respect to the Milford Fire Department they can do Miracles but not this one I just think that that should be a a major a major consideration in this project please now this isn't just some crappy place in Milford this isn't some flood plane off of the Charles River we're talking about a neighborhood that we neighbor million doll houses in hollison hopkington and Milford and you're you're looking to put a facility there that doesn't belong and you know it's zoned for that we have no choice but we do we don't have to say yes this is a special permit you we already knew enough to say no and they came back but they didn't

055change anything put 42 Bays of trucks coming in now 200 parking spots that's 400 entrances and egresses a day if my math is correct to your point I would take the 200 residents in a 40b that all go to sleep at night amen and may respect the [Applause] neighborhood and they don't drive 18 wheelers 24 hours a day 24 365 keep it down there's one person speaking please thank you for your consideration we don't have to say yes we do not have to say yes we have a choice why we're here thank you for listening [Applause] is anyone else yes sir in the back it's um Scott Brickley from 433 East Main Street and I don't really have too much of my own things to say here tonight because pretty much everybody said everything that

056I feel in my heart and it's just I I can't believe we're still this is still uh a possibility because it's like craziness like over here said uh this it's one of the worst uses of this property it really is I know it's so important but I think more like this gentleman said here a 40b or something like that would be much better even though you're going to have more cars the thing that concerns me is living on uh 433 for so long 25 years I've seen how the tra truck traffic can get and to think that you're going to have trucks coming out possibly two at a time or maybe three at a time and they're all going down the same way coming down 16 towards Beaver Street uh it's it's just going to

057be too it's going to be too much for that area it really is it's just it's this is a really bad choice for the use of property great that's pretty much all I have to say [Applause] anyone else one moreor just my name isz I right and I would like to ask people present here like symbolic vote who agree to can't do that so yes yes I would like to add you know the we and tear on the road because of the incre traffic what was your name please s kwami 32 Z hey I'm [Music] good the board all right for a matter of the do we close a public hearing and then vote I just you can we got to close yeah make sure that ask attorney an for Joe we just have chairman

058thank you yeah if I may if if the board is considering closing the public hearing and I do think it's time to close the public hearing um I would just like to take the opportunity first of all thank staff at the Town Hall uh for their continued cooperation in the processing of the application i' like to thank the board for the uh amount of time that you've spent reviewing this application your review has been diligent um and um I also want to thank the residents for uh having um the time taking the time to uh support their position uh position that they have a right to support um I just want to make a couple of comments regarding that um we're we're not in we're not in a residential area uh I understand that there

059are residences residences around this particular piece of property but this property was rezoned by the town of Milford by a 2/3 majority of a town meeting for the purpose of developing Business Park uses throughout the community of Milford the plan in the town of Milford was to designate certain parcel of property to be developed residentially certain parcel of property to be developed industrially commercially and and for retail uses you have the business park zone there are limited uses available there this is one of the uses that you expected to have permitted in this Zone because you added it I don't mean you the board the town added it specifically in the list of allowed uses I recognize that it requires a special permit I certainly recognize the requirements of a special permit um and I

060I believe that the applicant has demonstrated compliance with the technical provisions of the Milford zoning bylaw um I do not think that the applicant has ever threatened this board uh and I know that that comment has been made publicly and I know the board doesn't feel I presume the board does not feel threatened the lawsuit is a technical request to have the remand for further hearing based on the uh preliminary hearing and what what took place there that is not unique from the United from the Massachusetts land Court the land Court prefers to send the matters back to the local boards to have them reexamined and have this board have the opportunity to make a decision with additional information and again the additional information has been provided by the board I would also point out

061that the applicant has been very willing to accept conditions on the property specific conditions regarding justifying the traffic counts so again we spoke openly and cooperatively about having a condition in the special permit that would require the applicant to identify the tenant PRI prior to occupancy and to demonstrate to your board that the traffic patents and the traffic trips that would be generated by that tenant would be in accord with the projections that were made by the studies which were reviewed by your independent consultant were not um were not rejected that yes they asked for additional information that information was provided the applicant is also stated that it would be willing to return to the planning board for purpose of demonstrating that the sound wall and again a significant expense for the development of this

062property will be the building of that wall that the sound wall is functioning in a manner that keeps the decel levels within the state mandates so to the extent that there is concern of the residents and I recognize their concerns that they don't know what's going to happen there the fact of the matter is that the applicant has been willing to agree to conditions that will will require the applicant to return to the planning board and to give the planning board another bite at the Apple to make certain that the very things the residents want protected are in fact protected again this board with the experience of the board members recognizes that no project is perfect and that there is impact on every abing piece of property in any kind of development that's made that

063is the nature of Land Development um and it it doesn't change whether it's a residential use a commercial use or an industrial use there will be impacts and the board has been concerned with minimizing those impacts I believe that the applicant has been Cooperative with the board in reaching a um consensus relative to how those impacts can be reviewed and um and sub be subject to further review by the board so I I I want to again thank the board for the incredible amount of time that you put into this and um again I think that the application has been properly submitted and meets the four corners of the Milford zoning bylaw I don't think there are any deficiencies in it I understand that there are criteria that need to be meet met and that

064there are conditions that would be placed on the use of this facility one thing I'd like to say not knowing what whether who the tenant will be it may be and we don't know it may be that the tenant that we get might have less impact on the neighborhood than a retail use or a residential use because many of these distribution centers and again I know that the residents have continually referred to this as a high Cube Warehouse it is not that it is that is not allowed in the zone that is not what the applicant is present presenting for approval and it is not what the building inspector and the planning board will allow to be in that building that would be a violation of the zoning bylaw so we don't know who the

065tenant's going to be but I know from personal experience that the type of tenant that we're seeking and the type of tenant that may fit into that building is one that might not have a significant impact on the neighborhood because it may be Distributing products in a uh smaller trucks to outlying facilities and again we don't know that but I'm confident that when we do come back we'll be coming back with a tenant where we can prove that we meet the uh the uh criteria of the traffic study that we've presented and with that again I thank the board for your Dil and your intention to to each and all of the deta of the many details that we presented thank you I guess I would say something if that that's okay if the residents

066are done and the applicant is done it's the board's turn yeah anytime you want okay well I'm going to going to kind of I'm going to end with a motion huh I'm going to end with a motion we ready for that oh to close the public hearing no you can you don't have you you can [Music] talk um the okay so I'd like the the residents you've done a great job very well informed and um impassioned arguments and I assure you that I'm I think I can speak for all of the board members that those those really are taken into consideration a lot of respect for the work that you all have done um Massachusetts laws favor the owner's right to develop absent site constraints such as Wetlands or um ledge something like that the

067land is going to be developed and there are things that could go on this property that are worse you could have a helicopter landing spot in the Am I Wrong oh okay I thought you were correcting me which I would please do if I speak wrong if I yeah the helicopter Larry am I mist a helicopter landing pad excuse [Music] me um am I correct Larry that a helicopter landing pad could be developed here without special permit just checking site plan review only I believe yes that that that's my recollection as well yeah hell a hella stop yeah which I assume is a weird word for landing helicopter yes yeah Landing a helicopter and granted that may be farfetched certainly um Route 16 um until a short few years ago I commuted Route 16 to

068NAIC from I live near the hospital through town to NAIC it's 14 miles it could easily take over an hour I know Route 16 it's a nightmare um but it is however a state highway and state highways even though you know they were designed 100 years ago whatever and could never predicted today's traffic volume and big trucks and all of that that state highways are where the heavy traffic is supposed to go um it that's just kind of how it works [Music] um there's so much more I wanted to say anything that's developed there is going to have an impact on the neighbors um this has not been an easy decision for me I have felt some weight that perhaps I didn't need to feel that um mine might be the Swing Vote because if

069the rest of the members vote as they did before mine assuming they do mine is the Swing Vote I'm a new member to the board for those of you that aren't aware and was not able to vote the previous time um this is not been an easy decision at all um but I will make a motion to close the public do I have to close it first close the public hearing and vote um and make a motion to approve the project um I think I need a second before I go on take your done okay I do that's excuse me that is subject to adding the condition as suggested by the sound Engineers that if the wall does not the the noise barrier wall does not achieve the stated goal that it be modified until

070it does and I I would ask that that be added as a condition in in the board in the board's decision but again um I've really struggled with this but in the end um I moved to approve the project subject to that condition a second moved in second that we approved the project one quick discussion yes uh and uh Martha in your uh motion obviously you had the uh additional condition are you also including all those conditions that Larry had previously set yes 22 conditions very well written if if I me and has been keeping track so I just want to make sure that the motion does carry these 22 kind of pre-drafted conditions along with your 23rd condition regarding the sound thank you for that clarification if I could clarify as a as a

071runon from that point out that there was a phrase in uh proposed condition 17 in in the draft uh that the uh uh the applicant needs to submit an executed copy of the lease with the tenant uh and uh I added the line that all financial terms set forth in the lease may be redacted uh because we originally when we looked at this uh uh proposed draft it didn't have that language in there uh that was a concern for the applicant uh so I added that but that really doesn't have effect on thank you in in going through in terms of traffic somewhat noise and stuff and the usage that is permitted I was thinking one way to possibly address that is that in a wholesale environment we had talked about these these sites being

07224/7 but my my standing in any of those is that it's 247 mostly for receiving that you may get trucks in at whatever time they need to go in and whatever but that the shipping portion of it being a wholesaling and those other places on the other end they're not open 24 hours and considering that all of this is relatively easy to get to in terms of the Manifest for any of the trucking I was thinking that one thing that we could do in terms of Trying to minimize the amount of usage 247 is to say that no no shipping Vehicles would be allowed between 10 and 6 in the morning or some some hour you know I'm throwing that out as a possibility it it could be different but that um you know if

073if we find that that there's stuff going in at all points in time we can ask them to come back in and let's see the the shipping manifest not to look at what the hell's going in and out but to say at least find out when the times are and making sure that the only thing that's arriving are things that are coming in and not things that are going out and I don't think that puts an undue burden on the applicant again because I believe that these facilities aren't running they're not running to a distribution there CVS isn't open at 3:00 in the morning to accept distribution and neither is O'Reilly so I don't think that that if those are the types of people that they're truly trying to get in that that would affect

074so um that would be another another article that I would suggest that we could possibly put into the decision and again that wasn't part of what Marthur had put in but I would I would think that adding that would not be a would be appropriate and again the discussion in terms of time I'm just throwing out 10 to six it could be different but you know I think that that's appropriate or at least that that feels appropriate to me that's a good idea with Joe there you got that uh no vaguely I'll have to watch the tape you want me go through it again lry or you want to watch the tape I think sure the other the board's comfortable with what I said I think it's a good idea and I think based on

075what you said it's when they come back that second time for the next step of the process if we get to that point I should say well it'll be part of any decision that anybody going in that would see that as part of whoever is thinking of leasing the property too I mean that's already in there so I it's important to be now but yes they would have to abide by that certainly right that would be a an add-on to the statement that's the in number 10 you say accept that and then so may I amend my motion would that be an order for me to amend my motion to include Joe's suggestion no Joe suggest okay it's he's amending an existing condition okay yeah I see it will be part of the okay good

076I'd like to say I want to thank you you've been very good about your presentation I realize it's very emotional for you uh and the board has was uh the board listens to what you have to say we try to put what you have to say in if we make a decision into the decision to protect you as much as possible again this is a special permit special permit doesn't give you the reason to deny it special permit says this is the only thing that can go in that area they have followed all the zoning bylaws in the town and it's hard not to give it to him legally they do not sue us our names are around there because we're PL the board members we're not sued individually so we're not under the gun

077as far as monetary problems or anything like that uh but again listening listening to what the uh the experts and that's that's what they are they are experts and what the field they do what they present and how how the protection is for you is uh I think they they've covered as much as they that they can Route 16 is a pain you should have seen Route 16 before 495 was built when everybody had to go that way it was worse uh Pike so that's again I want to thank you you've been very you you come in with a very emotional uh subject and you've been very very pleasing to have as an audience and participants believe me thank you very well thought out arguments yes so do we all get to pay half the

078property tax taxes no no excuse me I just I just all property are hearing I know excuse me I just said been very good partip participation by the audience has closed down once we made the motion so just continue the please continue to be that way oh we should just be do do no that's not what we mean that's not what we mean that's not what we mean did theard did the entire board vote no we haven't voted yet not voted yet we haven't stopped talking long enough to let vote we haven't voted yet okay Larry easy I'm all set I'm all set all set all set all those in CL the public just the motion to close the public all those in favor that's with mat's and Mayan yes my motion has amended yeah

079and and Joe's suggestion yeah yes all yes yeah yes opposed it's four in favor one opposed carries uh thank you again thank you very much Carri Carri yes thank you very thank you very moving right along Joe asleep the other Joe as you can see from some of the paperwork uh FEMA that was and DCR uh is updating the flood rags and the flood m there's a new FL study Town's required to update the zoning bylaw informed all of that so for the town to be able to offer residents the ability to buy flood insurance we need to get these updated as soon as possible so U I've included a copy of get S some okay sorry I know I don't know if you know my we're in the middle of CAS okay okay so

080the uhp different the text that you have uh is uh based on the model that's what DCR is requiring I would ask that you uh let me send the uh memo to the select board I'm Sor uh to remand it for hearing any so that would be motion order me to send it send a remand request to the select board they're updating them again Larry or is this based on the last flood flame ones that we had no this is new again yeah the yeah the last one was 2011 and these uh I forget what the date is it's right in the Preamble there um under District delineation uh the dates are updated july8 2025 I thought we I thought they had updated recently the maybe I'm thinking the one down the cape yeah no

081the our last one was 2011 so anyway make a motion we uh send it to the selectman to uh put it on the upcoming warrant oh second move any moved in second do we uh move uh this to the selectman to be redacted back to us yeah I know weird thing uh any further discussion here and none all those in favor I I opposed and motion to adjourn oh second moved in second to adjourn any further discussion here none all those in favor I opposed unanimous thank you good evening

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.