001[Music] good evening with this is the planning board meeting of January 21st um was a pleasure of the board with minutes motion to approve second have moved in second to approve the minutes of the meeting all those in fa uh he in any further discussion hearing none all those in favor CL four favor one exstension we're going to take uh jump out of order and take the amended site plan review 161 East Main Street uh first this is a mended site plan 161 East Main the requesting approval for the proposed change of use in a portion of the building on the subject property specifically The Proposal is to change the previous Dollar General retail use to a church the proposed church is to occupy 9940 ft of the building of which 6100 sare ft² will
002be Sanctuary area uh with expected seating for approximately 200 the balance of the area will be utilized for classrooms Parish Hall and offices the existing Auto Zone uh the Tran Redemption Center and the concrete mortar packaging uses are to remain in the building the former Dollar General uh use required 63 parking spaces compared to the proposed Church Sanctuary uh that generates uh by calculation 62 spaces uh primary use of the church will be on Sunday and on Thursday night rather than normal weekday business hours adequate parkings provided via a shared parking agreement with the planes realy on uh the adjacent uh Plaza parcel recommend approval subject to relevant agency comments and subject to the dumpster location with screening being shown on the plan I believe a lot of that has has been addressed on the
003plan uh you have a favorable from fire uh it'll have to meet the fire code and the building code uh so that'll be what that amounts to is to be determined as they proceed um Building Department basically said the same thing it's got to meet the building code um water department uh has no conflict John all right great um just for the record John feder with G Ern helon um I know Dale had forward a copy over to Larry not sure if that made it out to the board apologies I didn't um make some smaller copies here but we did have a dumpster detail um with the appropriate screening um added to the plan and we are proposing that location essentially at the edge of our gravel area um and where our pavement area is
004going to be met um relatively close to the existing tree line that's there um that shouldn't be in any sort of conflict with the parking spaces that we had and um that dumpster would just be to service the uh the church use that's there um we do have on the plan a couple other dumpster locations uh for the trans recycling as well as the AutoZone dumpster um the dumpster that's being utilized for the uh the concrete um is um part of the adjacent property um since they are sharing con ownership common use out there um so we believe everything um should be uh relatively addressed um and then we also did just throw in a uh note up at the top over here um there was this one section of parking uh if I'm seen
005that correctly it's eight stalls plus an extra two that were there um striping in that area um was a bit faded um so we are going to have those refreshed every place El on site was in good condition yeah where the dumpster is any carment from the [Music] board or that's what putting it anyways not in the way of anything really I'm all set I'm good pleasure of the board make a motion we approve the amended site plan second the movement second that we approve the amended site plan any further discussion every none all those in favor oppos unanimous of five thank you so much I appreciate it you guys have a good night church okay going to our public [Applause] hearing you intro this is a continu public hearing on the application of Route
00685 real de Corp for special permit approval regarding the construction of 191,000 square foot store wholesale facility and Associated off street parking for 116 acre undeveloped property located on the Westerly side of East Main Street and the South and Southwest of Wildwood Drive known and numbered to 0 East Main Street accessor map 30 Block 0 lot 34 it's in the BP Zone this is a continued public hearing from the December uh meeting thank you Larry okay we're going to we open the public hearing uh we're going to hear from the applicant we'll hear for comments from the board and then we'll hear for the public again when the the the people from the public get up to speak give us our your name your address and address everything through the through the chair please ah
007no debating uh gentlemen good evening for the record Joseph Anon also on behalf of the applicate with uh with me tonight it's Ari fad who is the applicat representative Mark Wallace and John Cage uh if you will recall at our last meeting the board we spent a a significant amount of time discussing uh the impact of sound in the neighborhood and the construction and types of construction that would be used in the sound wall uh the board asked us to provide some additional information regarding uh the sound study and the manner in which sound would be controlled by the wall and to that end I'd like to uh have Mark Wallace address the board with the updates that he's provided along the way uh John cich is also here to discuss any civil issues uh
008civil engineering issues regarding the board I think we've worked through most of those um I think that Liz has a a question lingering about uh the fire suppression system at the building and uh uh I can address that as well as uh our uh architect who's been working on it um so with that said if uh if Mark could have the floor I'd like him to go over uh the sound analysis that he had done and uh the little further description about how the Wall Works to offset the sound in the [Music] neighborhood so for the record my name is Mark Wallace I'm with the tech environment Al I was here back in uh December 17th to provide an overview of the sound assessment we had done in our October 31st uh report that was
009sent to you uh the board and the public had a number of questions and some additional requests to be included in that sound assessment um we prepared a revised uh report uh I believe the board has a copy of that um that's dated um January uh 15 15 thank you 2025 so as part of the uh revised report there were a number of things that were discussed at that uh last meeting uh the first was to include an evaluation of facility daytime operations um we did that we looked at the uh Ambient sound levels during the daytime uh the quietest hour was during the 1 to 2:00 in the afternoon a sound level of 36 DB if we recall the mast GP noise policy allows a 10 D allowable increase over ambient or maximum allowable
010limit um so we did an evaluation to look at Trucking activities during the daytime those sound levels uh projections and calculations demonstrated that the sound levels would be below 46 DB which is 10 DB above 36 um at the nearest Residence on uh East Main Street as well as uh Wildwood Drive and the other surrounding neighborhood locations and I'll touch upon uh some figures that I have in the report sort of demonstrating that um evaluation excuse me um and in addition there was discussion about well what is sound it what what the sort of common outdoor sound levels are just to give some perspective we added some language in the report that that says that a quiet Suburban uh nighttime area is 40 DB approximately um and for a busy suburban area it's approximately 50
011DB having this kind of conversation I'm having with you folks about 3 feet away or so is about 60 DB so it gives you some kind of perspective of some of the sound as I as we had uh demonstrated in our last meeting we had measured sound levels of 30 DB was the lowest uh Ambient sound level that we measured during the night time and as I just mentioned a little while ago 36 was the quietest time uh during the daytime so we're again sort of even below that quiet Suburban uh nighttime condition even during the daytime um that with that being said the projected sound levels from the facility are actually going to be lower than that um at those nearest residences due to propagation of sound the shielding from the sound barrier wall
012as well as from uh the building itself and again there's a couple of figures in our report that demonstrate that and I'll touch upon that in a moment um there was a question regarding how does sound travel or are impacted by the sound wall uh we included a figure one in the report and I'll touch upon that a little bit um so sound barrier walls uh reduceed Sound by either absorbing transmitting or reflecting it back uh forcing the sound to take essentially a longer path uh the longer path is referred to the defract path pathway and the defraction or bending of sound waves around the barrier can occur both at the top and and on the sides of the of the barrier you sort of think of it as like light or water waves that
013sort of can go around uh an object the similar thing with with sound as well so the defraction or bending of sound effectively reduces the intensity of the sound and lowers the sound levels in the community so have to have an effective sound barrier wall uh it's got to be tall enough and long enough to do that um you know the rule of thumb is that you mustak break the line of sight between your receiver and the Sound Source uh to reduce that sound and as I mentioned figure one in our report uh demonstrates that and I can answer questions afterwards regarding that figure uh another comment from the board was with regards to uh elevations between the site and the closest Residence at Wildwood Drive uh the proposed barrier wall will be have a
014top elevation of 340 ft which is approximately 15 ft above uh the proposed grade of about 30 25 ft uh the sound barer wall would effectively block the line of sight between the idling trucks and Wildwood Drive which has an elevation of approximately 310 to 320 ft um as I uh discussed at our last meeting when we did our evaluation we not only looked at the first floor but also the second story of uh all the homes that have a second story again that's part of the mass DP noise Poli policy evaluation and again we want to break that line of sight to to reduce sound um at that top elevation we also looked at whether increasing the height of the barrier would uh generate any additional uh sound attenuation um and we uh found
015that it would only be an imperceptible change of sound approximately one decel change if we were to increase that height um there's a figure two which illustrates sound propagation calculations this was a common from the board looking at saying could you present some Contours showing how the sound um is uh propagated and actually attenuated by the the barrier wall uh so we have two figures uh two sort of side by-side figures one is uh without the sound barrier wall and one with the sound barrier wall on the Eastern edge of that uh trailer parking spaces the figure shows that the defraction of sound over the barrier wall would reduce the uh perceptible uh sound from the facility particularly in the Wildwood Drive neighborhood the figure shows that the 35 D and 40 uh d ible
016sound Contours and how that sound bar well we reduce that sound at Wildwood Drive so you can see in the figure um that there's uh a definite uh reduction in sound with the with the wall there um again the green line represents 35 DB um and the yellow line represents 40 DB um so it's basically diffracting that sound either to to the north um and a little bit down to the to the east as well um um uh figure two also shows that the building itself acts as a barrier itself so again reduces the sound from East Main Street and from Zane Circle again there were some concerns about sound in that general area I'd like to point out that the sound measurements that we took in those locations were higher than the 30 DB
017we measured during the uh uh late night nighttime that we took at Wildwood Drive um that's due primarily to traffic on East Main Street and on Interstate 495 um so again that's sort of a summation of the changes to the report it doesn't change any of the conclusions that the predicted sound levels would be uh in compliance with the mass DP noise policy and in most hours would be uh either imperceptible or barely audible at that time and uh so I'll take any questions from the board two seats on any questions from the board yeah go ahe go go ahead okay sorry so Mark um so this study that was done was on the existing noise I mean have you done anything on 40 tractor trailers loading all day long and yes the propagation is
018sound those those contour lines that you that I'm showing in the figure figure two in the report okay that's the sound from the facility itself so that's the idling trucks the trucks driving into the site the uh HVAC equipment on top of the roof um all that equip all that energy of sound uh simultaneously uh occurring at the same time so again that's a sort of a worst case assumption you know from the standpoint of we're assuming all this all these things are happening simultaneously to give a maximum sound projection okay so it's a theoretical it's not it's AC it's an acoustic modeling analysis and again we did that with a three-dimensional model uh we take into account terrain atmospheric conditions as well as the surrounding buildings to generate those those Contours that I uh
019that I'm showing in the figure Chris uh thank you very much for the additional information I think it was important appreciate you you know going back and and and kind of answering these questions for us you know appreciate that um you know I think in perspective of with and without it does show the the what the purpose of that sound barrier is and how it does bring in the the kind of that that sound level so uh and and and it helps to attenuate that sound from the from the neighborhood so now I I appreciate that and we'll certainly take all this into consideration so thank you um I should mention I'm sorry um there were some imagery that and some uh information information that Boulder put together with regards to the the barrier wall
020itself that wasn't part of the uh my report that was a separate submitt um hopefully that gives um again some a cross-sectional view of the um you know the train in the area the the wall and the and the nearest Home on uh nine Wildwood Drive good else from the boy yeah it's a little silly but I live near Jean variety and when they have their dumpster emptied in the early morning that the sudden noise awakens me are there any of those kinds of noises that would be emitted from this facility like you know banging of I don't know truck doors or something like that because that's the kind of thing that awakens people in my experience so we did not assess that in in this particular study um but there are some you know
021measures good man best noise best management practices uh sort of what I sort of identify as good neighbor policies that could be uh implemented at the site um I've talked with the client about about those particular measures that I've seen at other Warehouse projects again you want to make sure that the all doors are closed you know from the loading dock operations making sure there's no jake braking going on um you know those kinds of things as well as trying to make sure that you know when the trucks are backing up into the loading dock here they're sort of rubberized you know and they don't have the backup bumpers kind of things and that kind of thing going on so okay so maybe if the board is in agreement with this concept of the those
022sudden loud noises at night um maybe Mr anelis or someone could draft language to that effect I obviously I'm not you're only hearing from one member in response to that I think we had anticipated that the uh Good Neighbor policies would be adopted into the decision that have been set forth by Mark um and we could certainly accept a condition that that there be no dumpster uh recovery um other than between 9 to 5 but there's no need for that most of those companies don't work after that anyway there's no need for that so A stipulation regarding the restriction on when dumpsters could be empty to be fine and and similar again loud sudden thank you and also then back to what Mark mentioned I I forgot to state that bowler did uh Mr Calon
023asked a specific question at the last meeting regarding the uh uh get some specifications on the wall and I think that uh John kusich can address that for Mr Cajon and the board we did respond to that request yeah we just provided the detail you wanted to know specifically what it could be as I mentioned there were multiple types of of walls that would provide the density needed to mitigate to so we did provide the detail for yeah can you just go through that cuz I didn't take my magnifying glass with me I I can't read it it's actually it's an it's an aluminum wall um really it's you know the height doesn't change really show the material of the wall I think you wanted to make sure it wasn't something that was is it
024a is it a concrete type material is that this one's metal it's aluminum those are those are aluminum panels aluminum panels with uh with steel h I believe so yes are the panels um is it like uh insulation in between the P that makes more sense yeah they they normally the normally um sandwich you panels have uh usually about a 2 to 4 in uh spacing of material in there to absorb the sound um a lot of times the panels also have perforated metal on the inside to absorb the sound um so there's different you know there's different kinds of design there there's been a lot of um you know improvements in the in the design of certain types of materials nowadays for you know for getting quite a bit of Sound Reduction um depending
025on the uh you know the design of the wall [Music] is it this time this one yeah it's just yeah some sort of all core panel in it it's it's it's an engineered noise reduction well it's specifically for that purpose have any any anything for the but right now no no no I think I think for that you just wanted to make sure it was in the plan set that's why we added it the uh other issue that I see to think was lingering was regarding the uh fire suppression system at the building um and uh we we've had our architect review it it and I would just point to the board that the uh the installation of automatic fire sprinkle system is controlled by Massachusetts general laws chapter 148 section 26g and U it
026specifically references that a building over 7,500 sare ft must be equipped with a uh automatic sprinkler system and must be uh equipped in accordance with the Massachusetts building code so in any and all these circumstances one looks first uh to the to the size of the building here obviously we're over 7500 Square ft and then secondly to the Massachusetts building code which has different regulations within it relative to the installation sprinklers based on the use category of the building I can tell you from my experience with the statute that the use category of this building will fall within the uses that require sprinklin but then when you get into it deeper uh the manner in which the sprinklers are installed how many are necessary Etc will be related to the type of product that is
027stored within the building so we have a little bit of a catch 22 because we don't know exactly how many sprinkler heads we will need because we don't yet have a tenant we do know generally that we're going to need x amount of sprinkler heads for the size of the building and we're going to need x amount of gallons uh per minute and so on and so forth but we don't know the final I would state to the board that a condition in the decision that the building uh must be equipped with automatic sprinklers in accord with the statute is certainly understandable and acceptable but again we don't know exactly how many sprinkler heads we're going to need until we get get to that point so I I don't know that I can give to
028the board any further information that we've given relative to the predictions we know from our uh examination of the water system in Milford that assum argumento that the building was built and never occupied that there's sufficient water in the fire hydrants in the area to put that fire out um I think that's just a hypothetical but again as it relates to the specific use user the building we know the use is wholesale with storage so you can therefore presume that there'll be storage of something there and then again whatever is stored the types of material there are different requirements for different materials we don't anticipate anything that would require anything extraordinary in that regard but I don't think I can give you a complete answer as to exactly how many gallons we need permitted and
029the other thing as I I want one more thing to the extent that there was an insufficient flow if we had a user that required more than what's there then the alternative is to install tanks and tanks can be installed either internally or externally to the extent that a tank had to be installed externally then we would certainly have to come back for a minor modification of the site plan to show you where the tank was going to be installed how it was going to be installed and what impact that tank might have if any on the uh calculations for storm water again we wouldn't think it would because it will most likely be underground and again from my personal experience I'm going through a situation now in another town where exactly what I'm SP
030speaking of is going on a tenant has been identified we've been able to uh um to calculate the use we know how much how many sprinklers we need and we need to put a water tank in and it's been ordered so um again that's we can't occupy unless the sprinkler system works so all of this falls on the applicant owner of the building to make sure it all flows to use the term I hope that's [Music] helpful on that are you concerned more with the water man out on the street or the water or the the service coming from the street into the building my I understand that the applicant is going to have to meet all of the regulations and will meet them my uh reason behind having a concern with this is that
031I think there's better ways for the town to supply additional fire flow if that is needed upgrading the main in the street would give them more firef flow and make our water system better so I'd like to see a win-win rather than just a win and we we're stuck with deal with what we have yeah okay so um and I under I completely understand that they don't have a tenant that they can't give us final answers I'm not asking for final answers I'm not asking for uh I'm just I'm not asking for something to go into the permit and say well if you're if it's more than this you can't be there I just want I'm just looking for an a a guesstimate I guess that because the fire code calls for having um you
032have the the water system has to be able to provide the fire flow at the hydrate or the sprinkler system if required whichever is greater so I'm just looking for pick a commodity I don't care what commodity is pick a commodity and tell me approximately whether you're at 1,500 gallons and the 2,000 is is the one that's uh controlling or if you're at 3500 I I just want want to have some idea of where it falls comparatively to the to the 2000 okay thank [Music] you Joe you get that uh yes I I think is um is is that scha was that the architect there no I'm going through his email today um yeah what of the other situations is that depending on how things are stored so if you have racking that's 35 ft
033or 10 ft and if you have one material on one side of a building versus another it just the Architects weren't able to to like gener like I have no problem calculating trying to provide it the 6,000 so that that was a miscalculation the 6,000 was if the building what didn't have a fire suppression system which isn't allowed that's where the 6,000 was calculated so that was that's for the for the building of that size with nothing in it correct Without fire that was our fault if somebody had explained to me that that's where the 6,000 came from like that's I've been I've been trying to get some information so I have some scope of where um yeah that was our complete Mis and I and that's regulation yeah I don't um I never thought
034that 6,000 was a realistic number anyway so it wasn't it was just that it seemed to me that that was including something inside the building but I see now that it wasn't and that's the same way we generated the 2,000 gallons per minute at 20 psi so I I I guess I still it's I understand that there's a lot of variables and as an engineer I I've had to make assumptions that maybe I'm not even comfortable making some of the time but um I just I'm I'm looking literally for personally for a ballpark as to is it is it is the sprinkler system typically over the fire hydrant requirement or so that I can I can kind of answer that because I knew you were going to that would be helpful did ask the architect
035that like can we just say what it would be it's like tell you what I can't say it's because it depends on the commodity the racking there's so many different variables you have to do an exact calculation which I said for a traditional Warehouse from what you've seen is the 220 PSI for 4 hours does that cover it he said for most traditional warehouses that would cover it so that's that's what I got from him cuz that's I wasn't sure if it was you had that then you added it but you take whichever one high whichever is greater right and then he specifically said for traditional wholesale warehouse facility that is what you would do I mean I I guess where you're going in in to a certain extent is we all know there's an
036existing you know existing pels that are there if they're that close I guess we can't we can't tell the applicant what to do but it would seem to me that the applicant may want to behoove himself to try to figure out what he may have to do in the future because he's got very little water that he can do anything else going forward and and upgrading the main honestly might be logistically the best option just we're not there yet um so we're we're fine with a condition on or offsite improvements as required or or anything of that nature yeah there's no way for us to require it after you've gotten your approval that's my problem if you want to put the tank on site because that works better for you you can do that are
037are we talking about Zane to Holliston it would I don't I don't know where I don't know depends where the water company ends up having I would say it would it would be from your T to um yeah and I think what what what Jo was saying though I'm sorry to interrupt you I think what what Joe if we needed to do a tank or something like that we would have to come back as a minor modification to you so at that point we would we would then have a calculation we'd know there was an issue we'd have to come back to you to say hey we actually need something more we think we might need this and then there could be a dialogue of well I tell you what is it better to do
038X Y or Z instead of that so but we don't think we need that based on the conversation with the architect again we don't know know what goes there but from from hedging bets and going under probabilities we think we're good with with what we have however if a condition comes where that is not the case and we have to go through full building permit review so it's not that we can sneak it by right it's fully reviewed um then if there's a condition that says if that's the case we want to talk you know you'd like us to talk to you about a minor modification then I think the board would have the ability to have some conversations on that and as a condition so so you're going to have this building built and
039want to occupy it and you've got two or three other building pads in the business park to go and if you Max everything out with this building without improving the main and now you got these other buildings in the back that require even more you're going to have what are you going to do to replace the main then I mean doesn't that kind of comp necessary pardon I didn't mean it's rup I'm sorry but it's the hypothetical is is is is certainly poignant and and we're paying attention to it and and and as the land owner and the person who wants to develop the property they will have to respond appropriately at the time but we have we don't know what the future holds for the the rest of this property we don't know what
040the development opportunities are it's been slow to be developed in the first place we've had this conversation the number of users for large pad sites is is decreasing significantly so to the extent that we're lucky to find additional pad site then we'll have to address that when we come back and and further on that you don't know how much water is going to be left at the time and whether somebody else in Milford has taking it so it sounds like to the trigger is whether whether how big of a fire suppression system they're going to need now if it triggers a larger one than what the water man can handle does then what they can't get a building permit so so it goes to goes to the building department that's that's why kind trivial question
041Trier at the end of the day it's not our decision it has nothing to do with us it's the building department unless they give them the calculation or I mean if they in order to get this to begin with if they're going to actually build this before they have a tenant then they're going to have to make assumptions otherwise the building P's not going to give building permit if the usage then ends up not being that usage or they want to go to multiple racking systems within that property or whatever they don't have a building and it's not can't be used for that use they got find another tenant they can't put that tenant in or they can make changes to the building the fire that you put up a firewall in the middle of
042a building and then you can it's just more of there is a trigger there is a stop point if we exceed that capacity that that's kind of my fundamental question just to make sure and to appease yeah I'm more worried I'm more worried about the future in terms of if there's something they would make sense to do now but that's their choice but i' be less less likely when they come in next time if they're peace mealing this thing to continue the peac mealing process I'm going to want to see what's going on because if there's a way that this can also help the town if that's needed then then you know exactly that you that should be done but I mean it doesn't sound like right now we're in that situation and if it
043had to be done in the future it's going to be done on the existing on Route 16 not in not in the their feet not in this development here so we're not going to tear up something we just put in correct we're going to take care of something what could be a number of things they could tie in another section from inter interconnector there's a number of ways to do it the solution is one thing but as long as the trigger stop points that's that's what I want to ensure of the biggest thing Mr Wilson from the I'm sorry from the aspect of the trigger point um the fire suppression systems are controlled by Statute the statute provides for the enforcement of that by the building inspector and the fire chief in the town it
044is a part of it is overseen by the Department of Public Safety and there actually is a separate automatic sprinkler fire appeals board that sits in Hudson Massachusetts and I've been before that board on numerous occasion and I can tell you from my experience that if you seek a waiver and or an appeal you really are not very welcomed at that board okay so it it is very difficult to move forward in the Commonwealth without properly sprinkling sprinkling the if whatever the word would be without installing the proper sprinkers in the building thank you any questions comments from the board not at this time not at this time okay we're going to hear from the public again your name your address and again speak through the board thank you yes sir my name is Carl
045leaders for Bal CLE I I think Mr chairman we're walking past a few issues that I'd like to address one is the warehouse the other is traffic proposed building has been presented as a wholesale facility the description of the building was 24/7 41 Bays 191,000 Square ft 40 ft High two football fields The Institute of Transportation Engineers defines that building as a high Cube Warehouse even if the traffic study describes even the traffic study describes this building as a land use code 154 High Cube warehouse and it's really not economic to build a building with these characteristics and use it as a whole sale Facility by contrast the former Amazon facility at eight Industrial Road is only 145,000 ft 40 ft High 25 Bay it's classified as a warehouse it's also in an industrial park
046not in a residential area section 2.2.2 of the zoning bylaw states that where an activity might be classified under more than one use more restrictive use shall govern because the tenant is not known this would be land use code 155 High Cube Warehouse on the basis of this information the planning board must reject this proposal should the planning board accept the incorrect characterization of this building as a wholesale facility who's it going to pay for and monitor the ongoing compliance with the conditions as set out by the town plan there's no place for a high Cube Warehouse 24/7 and a residential neighborhood regarding traffic the traffic study was conducted in November 2022 in this time frame traffic was greatly reduced due to co the study concludes that approximately 13,000 Vehicles go through the Route 16
047Beaver Street Fortune Boulevard intersection on a daily basis Milford 2024 comprehensive plan traffic study lists the volume at Route 16 in Beaver Street at 177,000 vehicles and at Route 16 Fortune Boulevard at an additional 11,000 Vehicles the traffic study substanti understates the traffic at Route 16 be Street and Fortune Boulevard intersections the accident rate at this intersection is already 150% of the state average further the intersection at Beaver Street and Route 109 was not even considered as a part of the traffic study the Milford 2024 comprehensive plan lists traffic congestion as the most significant Transportation issue in Milford these intersections rank near the top of the most congested intersections in Milford the 2022 study data says that approximately 154 actual or greater vehicles per day move through this intersection it's likely greatly understated as the
048traffic volume in the study is greatly understated versus the actual conditions and the the the the 2024 Milford plan was based on mass do 2023 data and we all know traffic is up substantially since then as more and more people have gone back to work further the study uses land Coast 154 the zoning byog requires that the most restrictive use be used as the basis for evaluating the project of this nature this would require using land Co code 155 which is high Cube Warehouse The Institute of Transportation Engineers guideline says that a land use code High Cube Warehouse with these dimensions would generate one vehicle every 5 minutes 247 this number could be higher based upon the actual use of the building which is unknown at this time there are safety issues at Beaver Street
049and Route 16 as many times trucks must use the oncoming traffic leftand lane to make the turn this does not even account for the Slowdown and acceleration of vehicles that would that would be coming into and out of propos set the traffic study used for this proposal does not form an appropriate basis for evaluating the traffic impact of this proposal section 1.10.1 c of the Milford zoning bylaw states that the uses of the special permit will not create undue traffic congestion or unduly impair ped pedestrian safety given the already high accident rate at lout beber Street Fortune Boulevard combined with potential increase in traffic volume on top of an already congested traffic intersection this proposal runs against the Milford zoning bylaw and must be rejected by the planning board Mr chairman I'd like to submit
050this to be included in the minutes if I may thank you anyone else I have a question uh Raymond low 7 pine needle Circle um I think M white brought it up about the beeping the backup beeping noise um I'm assuming if 24/7 use that I don't know if the backup beepers are regulation that the trucks can not disable but you know if it's in the middle of the fall when it's nice out and there's no leaves on the trees that beeping I'm I'm assuming the leaves make a difference in the sound propagation because CLE where we live 495 is much louder now than it is in the summer that is that beeping going to be going on 24/7 when trucks are backing up into the loading base commercial vehicles don't have beepas commercial vehicles
051don't so a tractor trailer backing up to the dock to load or unload strictly construction vehicles [Music] okay but construction well during the construction no I understand during the I understand during the construction it's going it's a whole different right you know we're going to have 9 months of whatever and then my concern is 3 4 years from now that you know I know the construction is going to end at some point it's the continuation forever and ever yes sir my name is Norman poon I live at live in West Spring Pine Drive I'm here to discuss the East Main Street health safety General and Welfare impact section 110d of the Milford zoning bylaw state that the that the use for which a special permit is being sought will not cause substantial harm to the
052neighborhood or create a nuisance or Hazard affecting the health safety or general welfare of the citizens the noise study is inadequate because it only addresses trucks in idle it does not address backup noise or acceleration of vehicles out of the facility 24/7 further it does not address the use of multiple yard dogs being used simultaneously to move trailers around the yard the proposed sound barrier wall is 15 ft High the sound will simply travel over the wall things that move the trailers Additionally the proposed wall does nothing to mitigate sound toward Whispering Pine East Main East Main Street or Zay Ridge residents particularly at night lastly the sound study is based on residents being only two stories some of the res are three stories the Amon warehouse at eight Industrial Road received a number of
053noise and traffic complaints which have been brought before the planning board and at that area and and that area is less residential in the proposed [Music] site as we know Amazon left that facility but still Parks a number of vehicles off Route 16 next to Route 90 495 which creates significant [Music] congestion another thing is no light impact study has been performed the proposed facility will have light towers that impact residents at night the headlights of vehicles exiting the facility after dock would shine directly on houses on the other side of Route 16 which would be a nuisance for residence simply put dropping a twoot a two football field size 41 Bay High Cube Warehouse in the middle of a residential area is in conflict with Section 1.10 D of the zoning bylaw for this
054reason the planning board must reject this [Applause] proposal yes sir thank you I'm Jim Flanigan 8 Whispering Pine Drive [Music] uh first I'd like to thank the planning board and particularly the uh planning and engineering department for trying to protect the citizens of Milford but I think you're not really doing a very good job of protecting our neighborhood and that's why we're here I'll read this uh petition which has been signed by about 70 of uh the East Main residence organization so you can understand U basically our position and I I'll leave this uh these signatures with you Mr chairman we the following understand UND signed Associates of East Main residence organization and neighbors to the proposed Route 85 realy Corp development on East Main Street Milford respectfully request that our objections to granting of
055a special permit are considered one the original denial filed on August 14 to 24 states that quote development will not create undue traffic ingestion or impair pedestrian safety end quote with which one board member took exception numerous local residents have noted the disagreement with this conclusion their cases supported by Decades of daily occupation and travel in the neighborhood not one week of study two the original denial filed on August 14 2024 states that the proposed development will not cause substantial harm to the neighborhood nor create any nuisance or hazard affecting the health safety or general welfare of the current citizens of Milford end quote with which one board member took exception and numerous neighbors have noted the disagreement about 70 here three The remanded Proposal is not quote materially distinguishable from the original proposal and
056should not be allowed under current bylaws of the town the only change is off fence to according to the applicant redu sound levels on site towards some neighbors its Effectiveness is questionable and it provides no Sound Reduction from trucks on East Main Street at all so I present this chairman thank you and um I won't get into defense of of some of those because I have some other things oh I'm sorry there are a couple more there are 70 plus people in the neighborhood that have already signed um I have a lot of information I'm going to try to go real so I don't use up the time but this is important and I'm not representing just myself traffic study problems do do you want individual copies Mr chairman so you can read along no
057to you okay all thank you number one the town it's already been mentioned Town's comprehensive plan input from residents list of traffic is a major concern and this project only contributes to that so it's in complete conflict with the comprehensive plan two peer review by the town's contractor of traffic study and I've spoken with her only reviewed the methodology and it did not verify any data it didn't update for any accounts three Mass do traffic study projection practice is generic it's not specific to this site a 01 growth factor was used by agreement with I'm not sure who but someone in the town however local conditions probably vary significantly from a generic Factor due to the specific changes um as an example the Amazon parking lot is very specific to that to that area short
058distance away the continuing increasing Amazon traffic heavily skews the traffic on East Main Street a specific study showing recent history current levels and projections based upon local conditions should be required note this traffic using this growth rate of 1% uh traffic in Boston Boston traffic is reported up 14% in 18 months from November of 22 to Mid 24 traffic is up much more than the projected area what's in this stud four it's not clear from traffic City how the Synchro Capacity Analysis software included single unit trucks or track to trailers there's no information given about that typically trucks have significantly greater impact on traffic flow on the highways Engineers use 10 to 20% slowdown that's a multi-lane highway not like East Main Street the real world impact of tractor Trails attempting to turn in and
059exiting from the pros development site are not mentioned in the study the mix of su that is the single unit trucks and tractor trail trucks and their impact on the traffic signal west of the proposed development is not discussed in the text of the traffic study this analysis should be required five the study is the same study presented before with a new cover page it it's so out of date it still mentions the 555 project in holl should be updated reflect current conditions six environmental impacts of truck traffic are not addressed recent studies show and if you want I can provide copies of literature recent studies now show that a warehouse of 100,000 sare ft or more can affect the health of those living 1 half mile to 2 mil distant that includes my house
060in light of these data emissions should be studied to protect the health of the neighboring [Music] residents thank [Music] you oh wait there's more I'm sorry oh that's great the sound report although limited time for review because as was mentioned the sound report was dated January 156 days ago I find that we find that many of the details are not provided therein although some were provided by Mark um this evening which you appreciate however the report doesn't talk about the specific sources of of sound that's what some of the people were questioning Does it include this Does it include that what is include what's not include only truck engine was presumed to be a source that was corrected tonight it's likely that more than one truck will be on site at a time but we
061don't know we don't know what the deciel levels were we don't have the data are diesel truck Refrigeration units included or not unknown what decel level was used for the site for truck or trucks unknown in the report trucks generate more noise when beginning to move forward than an idle was this considered we don't know truck backup alarms and as mentioned not all tractor trailers have them but single unit trucks do pickup trucks rack body trucks I don't know what kind of trucks are there because we don't know they do have them they're um they range between 97 and 112 DB legally limited to to a minimum of 95 DB what about two trucks backing in what are the other source of sound that sound intensity we understand there's some consideration of that but we
062don't know exactly what it is like the root toop hbac traffic walls reduce sound intensity by 5 to 10 best dis according to the Massachusetts do so what factor is this wall supposed to be reducing it by we don't know what factor was used in the applicant's model for for that moving trucks allowed than Island trucks what impact of sound can be attributed to the additional tracks on East Main Street and on the site access and driveway where there's no wall the proposed sound fence provides no mitigation for that item the proposed sound fence provides little no Sound Reduction for homes on East Main Street for these reasons we view the sound study and provot sound fence inadequate through an analyses and Remediation is required to protect the neighborhood for these reasons the application is
063materially indistinguishable from the prior application and should not be allowed if you look at all the sheets and submissions there's only one or two and if you look at the sound report you can barely tell the difference between the two before and after I have one more thing this is short it was disclosed in the joint motion to remand the case that quote the parties have had several discussions end quote the parties refers to representatives of the town of MILF in the Route 85 realy we request the content of these discussions and and the attendees be publicly disclosed we request copies of any minutes and notes be made available to the public because in the view of transparency we'd like to know who is negotiating and what they say that's all I have thank [Applause]
064you anyone else yes yeah Jeff Howard 23 Zay Circle just a uh just a question you know I respect the uh the assumptions of the estimating that was done the calculations that were done about you know projected noise levels you know consideration of these other comments what what uh remediation is available should their projections be woful underestimated once the permit is established based upon based upon their estimates their you know their calculations does the town have any recourse if those uh if they can't really control the uh sound levels that their facilities providing anyone [Music] else yes ma' hi my name is Nancy brenel I live at 24 zann and I appreciate all my neighbors doing all that great leg work I can't site any codes or anything like that I can just tell you
065from experience that there are times getting out of zann the traffic is so intense it can take me 5 minutes we're a community of infants to several over five um condos and I have a tremendous fear that it's an accident waiting to happen when we increase the traffic flow I've lived in Milford since 2019 uh at the intersection that you cited I have seen so many accidents I have been in the turning lane um on Route 85 and almost hit so many times by an 18wheeler trying to negotiate that turn and fortunately like when that did happen there would be nobody behind me and I could back up but it's just from a safety perspective from a common person who doesn't know the codes I do see this as being a real uh Hazard and
066I would um you know hate to see an an accident happen um I also think that uh from a sound perspective 18 wheelers are loud when they shift gear some of that sudden noise that you were talking about that just that jolt can actually be very loud um I could for see the roads getting a little torn up having that volume of those heavy trucks on the roads they hit you know a pothole that's very loud if that happens in the middle of the night it's going to wake you up it's really jarring um they honk their horns I mean there's a reason that you have a horn you know but they honk their horns things like that so just wanted to share that as well thank you anyone else yeah I'll do it um
067Frank H them 47 zann and I just I don't have all those numbers either but same thing she just explained trying to get out of zann circle and taking a left is really hard because me someone mentioned line of sight line of sight coming from the East as soon as you start to go the C comes and the other thing I want to say is that the end of that street is also a Milford bus stop for the the kids getting down in suan circle they stop on East Main Street and then they get let them out so again it's another you know problem with traffic and I've seen again really close calls with vehicles not stopping now I can imagine when you got a whole bunch of traffic Trails on [Applause] yes ma'am my
068name is Jean krer I live at 39 Zan circles according to the zoning bylaws of Mur the purpose and intent of these laws is to conserve the value of land and bu yes now I understand the houses around there especially closer to where this is being built there is no way that their land is going to be worth what it is without that building built I know this from personal experience because where I lived they built um across the street for me they built a large building the value of our property plummeted so now you're talking about our area somebody comes looking to sell the house somebody comes in they look at the house they love it they try to get out of our area takes them 5 minutes to get out of the area
069you're not going to buy the house it it's a losing point for everyone and I I I've been through that I sold my house because of it before I don't want to have to do it thank you anyone else yes hi I'm Jan Caron from 461 East Main Street and I want to thank all the people who came up with so many of these factors all the codes the numbers I really appreciate that one of the things that really upsets me about the not only the traffic and the sound is the fact that it's going to possibly a 247 project and I don't think anybody would want to live 24/7 with noise like that in their neighborhood and I would appreciate you taking that into consideration if this project goes through that it not be
070247 thank you how you doing my name is Paul Hines I'm 459 East Main where is the road going to be coming out I never saw the plants that's why I'm asking almost directly across cuz I'm on the corner of whisper Pine e you know where the um the soccer field and and volleyball court is yeah right there cross street part of so I grew up in the plains I'm 61 years old I've been living down in East Main now for 9 years almost 9 years never once have I opened my front window now when I was up on F road we open the windows all the time but the traffic there is non-stop it never sleeps when I say it never sleeps it never sleeps it could be 1:00 in the morning it's just
071like 1:00 in the afternoon there's always something going by whether it's trucks cars it it doesn't matter I don't back out of my driveway when I have company come over I come and pull over in the grass and go out straight now we're going to add to that there's no sidewalks down there I I haven't seen a trick or in 9 years there's no sidewalks so for this building to come in you know we were hellbent on the casino and when we wanted to not have the casino there was protected wildlife in there where'd they go did that protect Wildlife leave so I guess my thought is this if these guys don't even know who they're going to put in that building why put that building up I I'm lost with that one so again
072I don't have the numbers like these guys thank God for them I'm just a truck driver that when I back my truck up it beeps like okay so that beeping is a real thing and at 1:00 in the morning it's a piercing Noise Okay so I guess my thought is simple think about what you're doing that's all we we live there I can't get over this Zan Circle you how far way that is going to be and it's impacting them I wish the people hollist knew what was going on they'd be hearing droves as well because it's going to impact them all of Route 16 it's a nightmare truly is a nightmare so one more I've had more deer get hit in front of my house and EXT trct the trailers right thank God it's
073not little kids but you don't get little kids out there no little kid crosses to go play with their friends on Whispering Pine from Wildwood they won't do it I hope not there's no way cross all right 16 yeah anyone else I just Joe gr for I would just like to elaborate on that woman's comment about the value of our homes I bought mine in 2000 20 25 years old now I hate to see the value of my property go down or the resale being howed to resale I get it's a five-bedroom house it's it's going to be hard to sell that to a family with three or four kids in an area like that um I think the house is that neighborhood is made for family and everyone has a right to get a
074little extra money for their their home and have it easier to sell I think just to even sell the house after this project is built might be tough never mind what you're going to get for it so I think everyone should kind of look into that a little bit all right anyone else good thank you any the comments on the board yes oh sorry uh my name is Wilson uh valz I live I drive and uh thank to the neighbor to the neighbors for the presentation you know but uh I don't know the numbers I don't know I know the technique numbers but they talking about but as simple like that um the board I think has to be you know like a protect to people and you know the a lot of uh neighbor
075the whole neighbor and imagine this you know like I everybody talking about the noise everybody talking about the traffic and you have to do the consideration of that because right now it's hard to you know everybody explain how the traffic is and how how worse will be with this project and somebody mentioned the casino and you know before the board Deni that project and you know the people vot in me for deny that so I think you know our neighbor we had to now colle maybe we get an or get you know technician because this we this in you know they they they propos but we don't know you know the neighbor outside we had to fight to see if they telling the truth how this going to because you know somebody present different numbers
076so the town has to verify you know what is the exactly effect or how it's going to affect the neighborhood this project and lastly you know it at least should be this come to the boat you know like a before like a casino did and they let let us know both for that project thank you [Applause] anyone else M you thank you um do I understand correctly this land used to be Zone residential yes right9 2009 okay so around 2009 it was changed to the BP District okay that's just was I'm sorry it was res zoned in 2009 to the current zoning okay thank you that was that's all I was wanting to know right now thank you BP now but it was originally it was it was residential it was residential at one point
077in time Street okay yeah it's been it's been multiple you yeah but the wasr BP okay around that time just making clear I think it was originally I see I industrial and then then it got changed to residential and then and then business and okay no across the street was a commercial def Zane Ridge Zane Circle we buying all that that was commercial before we made it we made it residential and then we went on the other side yes yeah but this was the the car that was originally planned to be industrial yes and then got changed but it's been been BP for over a [Music] decade quick question on Clarity and refresh my mem the first proposal was was was it only for the special permit or was it for special permit and site
078plan cuz right now we're looking site plan ex times it was both it was both okay all right so they if it were to go through they don't come back to us for any other conditions unless something changes on the site plan correct for the site for the site right the special permit they tell they when they identify who is going to tenant the tenant they'll have to come back that's okay for the special perit all right that's want to be clear on that cuz I I thought there was an additional time with the come back so I believe I stated on that that's why the language says it's it's issued to the applicant it doesn't run with the land yeah cuz I I recall stating that in that past meetings on that first proposal
079that based on that tenant it would be great to be able to review operational hours because if it is a company that all their vehicles have backup alarms then of course we're going to put restriction on their hours of operation so just to be mindful of the people in the area that if it's a by coming back to us it gives us that ability to understand who the tenant is and potentially put restrictions on them for hours of operation based on if their vehicles we understand that their vehicles would have backup alarms yeah because I would I would I would Envision is a warehousing which you know there's a bunch of stuff about high Cube warehouses and all that they can't it's is a wholesale use it has to be a wholesale use he can
080do whatever he wants but it has to be a sale use right that that's that's what's in the bylaw that's what's permitted so if there's something else in there then the town has the right to close it down it's a it's it's a wholesaling use that being said most of the wholesaling usage you're going to have the deliveries that we would expect late at night are large tractor trailers that are backing in and unloading not a bunch of trucks that are leaving that have backup things or anything like that so yeah at that point in time when we know that you could say that is is the type of uses that we want from 12 to 6 9 to whatever whatever whatever the discussion is but you you could do that at that point okay
081no thank you for that Clarity the traffic analysis was done both ways so right oh sorry the traffic analysis was done um as the the use that you're saying for the warehouse and it was done as wholesale and neither case did it trigger any um requirements for upgrade on the race just want to let you know that was done again when yeah that speaking not having the debating Society sorry [Music] than I'm good for I mean for the moment you you had something [Music] okay what's a pleasure of the [Music] board I'm just wondering if there were some outstanding questions that yeah that you may be able to answer or answer going forward the next at the next meeting only because I mean I you know I understand where some of the people were saying
082I also believe that a lot of those things were taken into account and we should at least close the loop on on whatever those questions are such that you know we can run those things through so I I for for the sake of uh trying to make sure everything is answered it would I think it would be good to go back through and just whether that's a sheet of paper or whether you have them all down and you can answer them all now or however you want to do that but um there were points at least that should be answered yeah I I'm sorry do that's were you did you want them to respond to you no go ahead I mean you can [Music] umry well let me just add while you guys are deciding
083who's going to talk next the next meeting available if you're uh considering continuing the hearing would be February 18th because we're locked in on the February 4th meeting with the adoc subcommittee for the comp plan the Consultants will be here on the 4th so if everybody is heading toward a continuance it would be the February 18th meeting would be the first U available meeting I'm wondering if I'm wondering what is allowed in this District by right that is if any uses that some of the neighbors might find similarly objectionable would it would be allowed by right I.E they would not even come through this board there will not even be a public hearing for you to voice your concerns and I'm just not sure what if anything I don't have a zoning bylaw with me
084anything would have to come to us it's a new site plan at a minimum this is site plan that's true but not a right not a public hearing and no notification to a butter still public hearing public hearing plans are not site plans aren't public hearing no a site plan but but if it's if it's permitted as for the permit yeah if it's if it's as of right which is what uh Martha was was questioning uh it doesn't require anything other than a site plan so I happen to have my by law if you want me to read through uh so just starting U obviously residential uses aren't allowed but uh uh getting into uh recreational uses golf courses are allowed um business incubators non- retail business incubator uses uh business or professional offices uh
085computer tech research and development uh conference or convention centers uh electronic data storage centers uh you got a couple special permits let's see uh internet service providers as of right uh life science uh research and development as of right professional buildings as of right uh scientific research and development as of right uh almost no commercial uses uh and then in industrial the only uh as of right industrial use would be radio transmission um in terms of other principal uses a hel stop would be allowed a large scale solar energy system is allowed as of right just site plan review uh let's see did you say helis stop mhm did yeah that would be noising so um water yeah typically you don't just have those stand alone you you would have them with with some other
086development like a hospital or something or research and development which is what this is z for Waters oh like oh like oh so it could be a very so there are some very large um office type facilities that could be built there um but not the warehousing wholesale other than through a public hearing process like this okay yeah this is only a one shot deal with this yeah with this once I just if this is approved there can't be anything similar to this on that part within that District within the that the only bus yeah within the so all the other things that Larry just read could go in the rest of what's there but not one of these right and this this ties up say that this ties up the use in the entire
087contiguous BP District not just the overall large parcel but all the surrounding Parcels as well you can only do one of these if you're using up the full 10 acres which they're doing uh then that's it nobody else uh in that contiguous Business Park District could propose one okay I was just trying to point out the other the things that could go there which while you certainly could come and voice your concerns would is is not the same setting as as you have here so I there's a lot of you know questions and about traffic and sound so I just want to take the time Jo maybe you can discuss some possible conditions that could make Mr chairman um we've obviously paid very close attention to all of the questions that have been asked by
088by the board members and I think that we've responded to them with with sufficient information to demonstrate that we can comply with the standards that are set forth both by the commala Massachusetts and and the town of norford in regard to the uh distinct aspects of a special permit um I think Mr Calon was was beginning to touch on this of the applicant recognizes that a special permit granted for the wholesaling facility with storage will require the applicant to return to the board to demonstrate compliance with the traffic study which there have been comments made about and that traffic study will have to be based on the trip generation that we we assigned to a wholesaling with storage facility um this is not a cube Warehouse I will make the distinction again as I did
089earlier in the process that the significant distinction between a warehouse and a wholesaling facility is that a wholesaling facility does not and cannot deal directly with consumers it can only deal with commercial entities a warehouse your high Cube warehouses your sorting facilities are not limited in where those trucks go to so the number number of truck traffic generation is significantly higher in those types of facilities we will have to be very selective in the tenant and again we have agreed and suggested to the board that when we identify the tenant you will come back to the board to show the board that that tenant's operation of the site complies with and comports to the terms and conditions that your board might suggest most significant of which from the hearing throughout the hearing process is then
090compliance with the traffic generation that we've demonstrated and secondly compliance with the Massachusetts Sound Ordinance again which we have submitted to you can be met or exceeded the standards can be met exceeded by the installation of the wall to the extent that there need that wall needs to be tweaked or there needs to be additional consideration to make certain that we meet the Massachusetts code which is the code that we have to comply with then the board in the special permit will have the authority to impose additional conditions on the applicant from the beginning we have said that the applicant understands that those are necessary conditions because we have not been able to identify a tenant view when we come back and hopefully we will be coming back we will have an identified tenant and
091the board can again deliberate as to whether or not that tenant operation will comply with the four corners of the zoning board's excuse me of your planning board's decision of the zoning decision um and again I I heard the comments that uh have been made by all of the members I've certainly heard the comments by the residents I'm not going to tell you that I think I can answer their questions they're local it's their it's their neighborhood but um your board as a planning board you're responsible and have been for the overall master plan in the town of Milford that yes there's questions about reducing traffic but the master plan is also designed to increase growth in the community to keep the tax base up to have sufficient income to support the community and part
092of that is the proper development of land in different sections of town that sometimes because it's the unique aspects of New England are somewhat incompatible but that's how we've all been brought up in the Milford area and that's what we're all we've all come to see there have been changes I don't mean to make this a light of this but I remember the nights at the Milford planning board when the Zay Ridge project was being proposed and residents complained about the traffic that zaye Ridge would bring to Route 6 I remember all of it because I spent my entire life except for the last few years in the Milford community and I've seen it grow and I've seen the traffic increase and I've seen the land in Milford developed and I was there in 1950
093and I don't remember back to 1950 but I remember from 55 on pretty vividly yes there's a lot of traffic in mord and there probably is going to be a lot of traffic in mord for a long time to come but again this is an allowed use I albe it by special permit we believe it is a fairly benign use because again it's not going to be a high Ice Cube Warehouse it will be a specialized user for the for the building and hopefully with approval we can go out and actively find that tenant but again if the board wants us to come back and answer any further questions we're more than happy to but again I think that the four corners of a of a tightly written special permit decision will provide this board
094with the assurances that this applicant's project will comply to all of the local bylaws and the state uh thank you with apologies to the applicant and the and the residents I don't I don't know if the how the rest of the board members feel that I don't feel ready to vote tonight a lot of information was presented specifically that makes reference to the bi terms of the bylaws that I'd like to review and make my own interpretation of those Provisions I feel like that like a lot of the information presented tonight warrant some further consideration for the review so personally I don't feel ready to vote then again if I if I may interrupt M Mr chair based on the comments from from um member white I would respectfully request that the U meeting be
095continued to the next available [Music] date and I apologize to my former board members and the residents because I know you'll all want to come back but well in doing that I'd like to I mean obviously there was the stuff that was handed in um if the applicant his Engineers can go through that and just put comments next to those I think that would help at least and cling off the distribute to us absolutely email yes good point and Mr Duncan Larry if you wouldn't mind making copies of those of what was submitted and email them out to the members if that's if that's in agreement with the members scan them to the app them too so they so we can look at them before the next meeting so it be the February uh Joe
096the February 18th February 18 motion um move to continue the public hearing to February 18th 2025 MH um did I do that right so far and the time do you need it you don't need a Time 702 7:02 p.m. second moved in second we continue the meeting until February 18th 18th uh any further discussion hearing none all those in favor oppos anous 5 people thank you to the board thank you to everybody for your patience appreciate it