001[Music] good evening is a Milford planning board meeting of December 17 2024 it's the pleasure of the board make a motion we accept the meeting minutes from uh our previous meeting on the 19th of November second the motion moved in second we approve the me meeting minutes uh any further discussion here none all those in favor I I opposed ous of five we here I know no you wer I don't think I was that's all right still vot anyways it's procedure I'd rather obain if I was not here four in favor one exstension okay we got no 81 [Music] uh in the minute we've got left um let me just note that our meetings uh next month are on January 7th which will be a joint meeting with the ad hoc plan committee and then
002on January 21st uh which would just be a regular planning board meeting and if you're hearing tonight needs to be continued it would have to go to the 21st I take up a minute yet no pretty pretty close pretty close 7th [Music] 2 there should be a calendar there for the the year yeah okay L you want to read the uh public hearing Milford planning board of Milford Massachusetts notice a public hearing on Tuesday December 17th 2024 room 3 Milford Town Hall 52 Main Street the Milford planning board will at the Times designated conduct public hearings regarding the following 7:02 p.m. application of Route 85 realy Corporation for special permit approval regarding construction of 191,00 ft² whale facility and Associated off street parking on 11 16.87% developed property located on the Westerly side of East
003Main Street and Southwest of Wildwood Drive known and number to zero East Main Street assessors map 30 Block zero lot 34 it's in the business park zone full application Andor maps of the above items are available for public inspection at the office of planning and Engineering Town Hall 52 Main Street Milford Mass at the following times during un business hours uh this uh notice was published in the daily news on the 3rd and the 10th of this month okay if you like I can quickly paraphrase my report to get things roll [Music] okay as we just heard in the notice this is a special permit application of Route 85 realy Corporation for a wholesale building at zero East Main Street this m matter is on remand from the land Court subsequent to Landing board's August
00413th denial of the original application for this uh for this development copies of the appeal and the joint motion and the land court order of remand are attached in your packet for your convenience the uh applicants requesting special permit approval to construct a wholesale building and Associated parking on the subject property uh those uses are allowed in the business park Zone by special permit from the planning board um they as long as they don't exceed the 25% overall acreage of the Business Park District within which they're located given the size that's limited to 10 acres uh specifically the applicant proposes a construction of 191,000 wholesale building and approximately 200 Associated parking spaces on the subject property the overall size of the development is 11 16.87% uh it should be noted that although this proposal is
005substantially the same as the original submittal there are two notable additions the first the preparation of a sound assessment and the second the proposal to install a 350 ft long sound barrier along the easterly perimeter of the truck loading area I reviewed the application materials and site development plans and have been that have been submitted in this matter and offer the suggestions that for special permit findings and conditions that are listed in ra packet the U my estimation a peer review of the traffic impact study does not appear to be warranted for this matter therefore I recommend the special permit be granted subject to the conditions I've noted in my report at minimum uh and any noted item relevant items from the departmental comments the uh various uh staff report from other departments are included
006in the packet that we can get into later uh there should be an attachment there uh there was correspondence uh uh from a Butters uh that I just got so uh it uh it's just a copy of of what was sent in um and as I mentioned the decision the land Court uh remand notice and all the relevant documentation is included so with that I would assume you'd want to turn it over to developers Council yes good evening for the record Joseph anelis um attorney licensed in the conal of Massachusetts my office is in Framingham Massachusetts formally in Milford uh good evening everyone it's nice to see you hope you're all well um I think um Mr Duncan's recitation of the procedural aspects relative to how we are back in front of you was very
007comprehensive I can answer any further questions that the board has but I don't think need to uh explain what Larry I think has already properly explained um I am not counsel to the litigation I I'm basically just as as I was in the past representing the developer as it relates to this particular permit um we have the same team that we had with us before uh uh Tariq fad who is the principal uh applicant of from Route 85 realy is in the front row with you as is uh John kusich from B and um I'm guessing that Jason uh the Tim Hayes from bowler is also there as well as Mark Wallace who was our sound engineer and Jason Adams who did the traffic report I think Jason uh is there um and again uh
008I think that it's probably best for this board to hear um the uh significant aspects of this plan that have changed which are primarily as Larry noted the installation of a 325 uh 350 foot sound barrier on the property uh and I'll let obviously John and Mark talk to you about that in Spec specifically um the uh plan that we submitted to you previously has been functionally not changed except for the sound wall uh I believe the drainage calculations have all been uh reviewed and are are appropriate I also believe that uh we have reached out to all of the Departments necessary for the purpose of making certain that we'll have adequate water Supply at the at the property and to the extent that we get to uh use for the building we may have
009to go back to the fire department to identify anything that would require additional Water Supplies but at this point we we don't we don't have that as I stated in the last go around we do not have a tenant identified for the property uh you will recall that we did spend significant time at the last meeting discussing the issue that this is a wholesaling facility with storage that means that it will primarily be one company that is Distributing to uh perhaps um you know uh subsidiaries I I used the example last time uh you have a Riley's Auto Part in uh in town I did the permitting for that quite a few years ago assum arguendo that Riley uh wanted to have a facility to service its autopod stores this is the type of building
010that they would look at so the traffic would be limited to uh their particular customers uh and the storage would be for particular purposes now I I don't know that it's an autopot store but I think that provides you with a good example of what this building is uh we made the distinction last time between a wholesaling facility in a warehouse I I hope the board was pleased with that distinction last time if they have any further questions about it um I'm I'm more than happy to answer it but I I don't want to take up your time with Joe anel's talking about a lot of stuff that you've already heard so if you're if it's okay with the chair and the board I'd like to turn it over to John for the purpose of
011showing the change to the site plan and then you can go from there as it relates to how you want to uh discuss have Mark discuss the sound uh analysis that he did on the site so if the board's pleasure I'm going to have John kusich take over and uh share the plans for the for the development as as the board knows this is a a dual application it is an application for special Purp for the particular use and as well as an application for site plan [Music] approv uh for the record John cusk with bowler as Joe had mentioned uh you're all very familiar with the plan from the last um process so I won't go into the details that were already discussed unless you'd like me to go back and I will uh
012I just wanted to point out really what is new on the plan is this pink line here which is a sound wall it's essentially 15 ft uh it was a sound study was performed U by by Mark and his company uh they pretty much that here's the limits of what a wall would be to uh block the any necessary sound coming from here they provided the elevation that elevation 340 you know relative to the building that all shows on the plan here the limits and the elevation uh there's a note on the plan that the S wall needs to be of a density of um four four SI um 4B 4B per square fo 4 lb per square um square foot it's essentially what you'll see what you see in a highway right some of
013the those barriers so it's not a it's not a like cedar fence or something like that it's it's a heavy duty structure that will block sound there's no gaps or holes in it so that is um really all that's changed on the plan the plan is um the same there some minor conservation issues we've gone through um through that process that um frankly I won't bore you with those details we can get into them if you want but they don't change any of the plan the layout the parking any of that type of stuff um with that I'd be happy to go into any detail that you would like to hear uh any questions for the board right now we want to hear from the okay I got one so how do we pick the
014length of the wall to have yeah engine for that right Mark speak to that we have I just wonder how we determined that 350 ft is enough um so for the record my name is Mark Wallace I'm with tech environmental and I'm the project manager for the uh sound study so there are two uh sort of steps in the process when we're doing our uh sound study the first is to establish what the ambient condition are and the next is to do uh acoustic modeling sound propagation so when we do that we included any kind of sound sources are related to Rooftop equipment as well as any trucks idling in the loading dock areas um the trucks were the were the main concern um so when we did our acoustic modeling basically it's a three-dimensional
015model the takes into account Topography of the site the building elevations um the site rating and when we include that the sound sources we propagated that sound to the nearest homes and Wildwood Drive and along East Main Street um so with our analysis it turns out we needed a a sound wall uh that would block the sound from the loading dock area primarily um when we did our analysis um the sound when you have this 15t wall and as John has mentioned it's sort of the same kind of wall that you would see along the highway uh it's got that same kind of density because we're trying trying to block as much of the sound energy as we can from the uh from the uh trucks um so when we did our analysis A lot
016of the sound is either being blocked or being sh or being deflected away from the homes so when we did our analysis we sort of um evaluated what the length and the height of that wall would need to be to make sure that we're in compliance with the mass DP noise policy and the policy is based on um ambient plus 10 IES above above that so um what we're trying to do is make sure we're either you know below that number which we we are well below that at the nearest homes in Wildwood Drive and as well as along East Main Street and so that was the basis of our of our sound study I don't take any questions to [Music] that enough question was the sound study based on just idling vehicles or do
017you do anything based on the you know um the sound of of the vehicle 18 wher basically coming off of East Main Street or going to East Main Street yes it did we did include you know a truck driving along along uh along theout area uh but the the main Sound Energy was really coming from from the back from the back area so with that based on what that study you only have sound mitigation going on in that staging location so the roadway why wouldn't the roadway have any because the sound energy is moving along here so so the sound energy is being spread out over the along the length of the roadway um and when we do that it you know if we're having a truck or truck's idling in here uh you're basically
018concentrating that sound energy in one particular location so we wanted to make sure that we were accounting for the fact that um the the main concern would be the loading dock areas um but we did include a truck driving along here as I mentioned before rooftop equipment um and the trucks uh idling either in this area both in this area as well as in the um um the storage area as well and then looking at from an elevation standpoint the why how was the high of allall determined so when we do our modeling we include receptor Heights for home so each of the homes we looked at we want wanted to make sure we're either at first level or second story because you know again we're trying to focus at night time so our study
019was really based on the quietest hours of the night um and so when we did our analysis we measured uh 30 DB which is a very quiet number you know during the night time which was on Friday night 1 to 2:00 in the morning so that makes it a very conservative approach that we're doing we're we're looking at the quietest hour and we're assuming all all this energy is happening when we do our analysis the other thing I'd like to point out is the um the Ambient sound level is based on what they call an L90 metric it's the quietest 10% of a measurement so when we're taking a 60-minute measurement for each hour it's the quietest 6 minutes in an hour so we're taking the the quietest period in an hour and doing this
020conserv you know doing this conservative assumption with all this equipment operating at the same time getting back to the receptor locations we want to make sure people if they have a bedroom or whatever on the second story that we're taking that into account that's sort of a part of the policy by the mass D so we want to make sure that if we have sound you know if we have sound sources in here how is that sound being propagated so we want to make sure that the wall is tall enough that we're blocking the sound even to any second story or a taller buildings I hope that answers your question yeah so if I look yeah just from elevation standpoint right if the if the house is up here but my wall is only so
021high that sound can go across the top of the wall it could do that right in your report does do you guys take an elevation at the what would be considered the warehouse site and then another elevation at the houses that's correct and that's in the report it's not in the report but it's in our modeling analysis yes okay I think it probably should be in the report right because that's going to be important to know from my standpoint that again sound can go over still go over the wall the idea of that wall is to basically prevent the sound waves from getting to those house correct but the house the second story of the house is and a direct sight line than that sound wave can can can carry in so I would prefer
022to see that I think it's important absolutely I think it's going to be important to the the all the people in the gallery here to see that okay I think U John may know off the top of his head there's a substantial elevation difference between uh the finished grade of the parking area whether there's a wall it's significantly higher so it it it would be virtually the you go ahead opposite of the example exactly so yeah we're actually higher with a wall and these are I think proba 30 30 which is great great everybody's telling us that so let's add it to the report that simple elev it's just it's a check mark understood yeah that makes sense to me those right now I was just looking through where's the detail of the design for
023the sound wall so that we don't have an actual detail CU there's multiple walls that can provide that essentially what we provide is is the density of the wall cuz that's that's really what what dictates it so it could be either a cement wall it could be a Timber wall uh it just can't be like a flimsy wall so ultimate gets built sent it out to the contractor to figure out which one's the most you know the most economical for what they're they're doing but the important part is the density which is why it's kind of like a highway grade wall it's just based on the thickness of the wall yeah I understand that I guess at some point I'd like to to see in the plans what that wall is we can provide I
024I you know we we lose control at this point in time and all of a sudden something's up there so I I don't think that's the we can do that and if it changes you you come back if you want to change the wall design later on or whatever you can always you can always come back but I'd rather approve a plan that actually shows a design yeah so just like we do for retaining walls yes basically if I may when you when you say come back you mean to amend if there is an approval to amend that approval and they may have to anyways just because of the traffic we had talked about that previously which is still the same outstanding comment so to be clear that they understood that you all set yeah
025okay we open it to the public again when you do it your your name your address and everything's adjust through the chair it's not a debating uh thing yes ma'am my name is Deborah Romero and I live at four wild Drive I've lived there said lived there for 30 years you know paid my taxes it's a community small Street and there's you know there's Whispering P different streets added over the years but you know I raised my family there and there's people with children there so it's a neighborhood so this addition just basically makes it you know a business Zone next to our next to our street and I said last time like when they had the studies with the traffic you know and people very knowledgeable and you know talked about how you know
026nothing we could do but there's a sound there's a sound a wall of sound I I took a picture of someone doing something in my yard and you just hear this noise and I'm like what's that when I played it back what's that noise it's a sound so that exists already it's going to make it worse um I can hear 495 in my bedroom um with an AC on and a fan which I put on to block all the sound I can hear 495 and the people zipping around there's no way and no disrespect that a study is a study it's going to it's crossing the te's and darting the eyes for and this is my opinion for all it's worth Kevin mean to put Amazon in there there's no oy going in there you
027know and I don't appreciate I I I'm surprised that they get a second bite of the Apple to come in here again for a special permit um it's also a safety issue with the traffic which you guys address nothing we can do as the traffic increases but that's a family Street and it has been for a lot of years my neighbors people have died they got so old that they live on that street this is changing the whole environment and it's and it's not quite Fair it's a safety issue and I know at the last meeting I wasn't pleased to see the attorney run up and say if we change the time can we can we have you know a yes vote from everybody after it was voted one person voted I know um you
028know so it's going to be this operation that's just going to change the community in many different ways from the traffic to the sound to safety and um I just don't think it's fair um I know that you know life goes on and people own companies and they buy land and hopping Brook you know got them out of there and in hariston they didn't want them um and I and I and I can hear the studies and I can understand that they did the sound barrier walls I get all that but that's again just a you know part of growth in the community but it doesn't belong behind my house and the other people's houses that have four five-year-old kids the sound is just crazy the sound that comes already this is and and a
029facility that's going to be from what I understand 247 trucks coming in out Amazon trucks idling maybe refrigerated trucks what do I do call the police and the milary oh they did it again it's too loud once it's in it's in and like something it could be amended you know all that kind of stuff I'd like to ask the board and I I I I thank you for your time to to to deny this I don't think it's the right thing to do for the community the person the people that own this this land well maybe they have to wait a few years and just sit on and do something with it when I'm dead I don't know but it's uh I just don't think it's fair I think it's not the right thing to
030do and I'd like to ask you to deny [Applause] it anyone else right there subit yes ma'am um Kramer I live at 469 East Main Street um my concern again is the traffic I know it's been brought up sorry I'm having trouble hearing [Music] you my hearing isn't that good go ahead thank you thank you she couldn't hear you I was having trouble hearing you can you go to the microphone or speak to the group so we can oh okay do you need my name and address again we just need I before and my concern is with the traffic and upon further research a matter of fact we in your meeting for tonight this person who the developer is looking to put in apartments up on Fortune Boulevard and also on beer Street on the
031corner where McDonald's and Burger King is and you've got these major intersections that will be a nightmare with the trucks with this warehouse and you're going to throw in apartments which is going to create more traffic um so I just wish you would really consider the traffic impact on this that's it yes sir back um Jim Flanigan Whispering time Drive um thanks for having us we're all a little confused while we're here we understood that you as individuals were sued we understood that was the case and does tell us something about what kind of a neighbor we're getting into our neighborhood that turns on us and Bullies people when we're not they don't get their own way um first of all with respect to the sound studies um there was a good question about the
032wall um and what wasn't really uh explained very well by the sound engineer is sound is waves you understand a waves were I can take a piece of cardboard and put a light behind it you don't have to be straight in front of it to see it because waves diffuse and coming over that wall with whether it's higher or lower the wave will Ripple and come down and go up and you'll still hear the sound it'll be diminished but that's the way Sound Works that wasn't really well explained so although the walls do minimize sound they do not eliminate it and we didn't really get to hear uh and we haven't seen the report and in fact from where we were sitting we actually couldn't see the site plan on sorry um but we really
033don't know how much the sound is reduced in terms of decb we did hear uh that we talked about very very low at night um the other point that I would like to make is for those of us that live on withis Spring Pine Our concern is really the truck traffic on the street I understand the people um in other areas have to deal with the perhaps the idling of the trucks in their facility but um if anybody has been in that area you see the trucks queue up to go into the gravel gravel pit and they idle in the street I know because I sit behind them every morning every morning to have more trucks here and it doesn't show up in any of the traffic studies that these trucks sit and idle there
034pulling in and so if this is a going to be a 24-hour operation or Opera in the evenings those trucks are going to be idling on Route 16 and I will hear them and no wall is going to stop that because there not going to put not going to put a wall between me why why would why would these trucks be idling on Route 16 because they they have you seen how a tractor trailer turns he's got a separate entrance to his own property though I I mean let's try to keep this at a at a point okay so I understand I have no idea why the gravel does it and that's a totally different story but I mean because trucks coming they slow in idle I see it I see it all the time
035every morning I see it and so I'm you're saying that's the way track the trails they have to slow and stop before they can turn because it's a narrow driveway it's not like driving down the highway so I can see you're poo pooing it but it's just a simple I I I don't know how there's there's a lot of issues and I understand that but there's there's certain issues that we can evaluate or not and that and that becomes very difficult to evaluate those types of issues I mean you're telling me that somebody is doing something illegally so I can't tell somebody else he can do something cuz someone else is doing something illegally they're not illegal if they're if they're parking on 16 they certainly are parking so you change my words I didn't
036say parking I said the truck idles because two trucks when one tractor trailer is turning truck behind stops traffic stops all the time yeah when traffic is heavy it stops at 495 it's heavy so when one truck goes to turn the traffic stops with the second truck to turns and they sit there and idols and it happens every day now and adding more of that kind of traffic it's only a simple traffic count it's only a few TRS but that that's a it's a very real case and I wish you hadn't pooed it and dismissed it when it's very real for those of us who live in the neighborhood it happens everywhere in town though it's not unique to there and so we don't have this kind of development being put in we're not going
037again just not debate here yeah okay so you're right that's that's a good point and so those are the only points I had to make thank you for the time I'm sorry that it didn't seem like a reasonable argument but for those of us that live there I think other people can confirm whether they've seen that or not anybody so per you have those of us who live in the area see it every day yes sir Joe gr for Dogwood Lane been there 25 years um like people said great neighborhood been a construction over 35 years working in Boston I know what construction's like this is a huge project just the start of this project with the access of that road with these construction vehicles cranes this that going in and out of there probably
038for 2 years would be crazy in itself then the ongoing trucks for the access of that road like these gentlemen have spoke would be very noisy and heavy traffic it takes me I leave at 5:30 in the morning it takes me at least a minute to get on the road that hour with this operation 247 and the workers it it's it's crazy these developers should access another way in if you prove this building that is not the correct way in the environmental thing about it is ugly the sound wall does nothing does nothing in my opinion I think you should re-evaluate the access to this whether it's off 495 in the back RS of Fortune Boulevard the reason they chose that access is the ledge more money that's easy access but it Disturbed the whole
039neighborhood everyone knows that for a fact these gentlemen know that you could access it and through the back way if you approve that plan but this project is huge it's huge it's a warehouse does it do anything for the town does it help it in any way I don't think so there's so many vacant buildings of properties maybe not that size that this developer could consider I really think the ward should take that into consideration thank [Music] you I your hand in the back excuse me I can I ask you said access from the back way the only back way is off of 495 and they're not going to do a new interchange I mean other to have done it not for one pro not but that access is not very feasible for for neighborhood
040friendly wise with all them trucks coming in off that roof like uh Christopher said it's still noise they're going 20 25 mil hour down that road they're not piling I just don't want people to be left with the impression that there's an alternative access other than talking hundreds of trucks hundreds okay very well yes sir in the back again my name is am aich I uh neighborhood uh in the time Circle so uh I would like just to verify with the engineers I'm engineer too I'm with heavy equipment industry for 20 years now uh I would like to point out that maybe uh we are looking into the wrong uh numbers when we are talking about the uh sounds uh when which are coming out of the trucks because idink is uh the silent uh
041period of uh work of the vehicle itself so having said that we are looking into the warehousing and there will be a lot of maneuvering into that area backing to the to the dog to to get unloaded and loaded there is a big big problem with the sound of backa power you have it on a heavy equipment you have it on a trucks you have it on some uh smaller vehicle as well you have it on some forklifts as well as uh as the gentleman just pointed out we will see a lot of dust and noise while this will be uh in the building section like when we are when we when we say the construction itself of the of the of the premises but it will be even worse for us who are living
042there to hear that beep beep beep beep sign some uh every every now and then especially evening and night and we are talking about 52 trucks per day or what was the number so I mean that's irrational to to to to think that you can live uh in the house with with such a such a s so I don't know uh you have to re think this real good thank you anybody else yes I'll get back to you hi I'm so in Casta I live in 17 Zan Circle um I was wondering as far as the sound wall you talked about it being in One Direction but in Zay Circle we're in the opposite direction so what about the sound um going in other neighborhoods and also it seems like you only did the study
043at one neighborhood what about the rest of us um and then also um I wanted to mention also about the trucks I agree that it's you there is a lot of traffic sometimes it takes me a couple coule minutes just to turn left out of my street um so trucks are going to have that same problem they're going to be sitting there waiting to turn left as well um and [Music] so thank you anyone else yes [Music] sir I live over in zaye circle and actually I'm one of the trustees for the a homes over there and I have a couple of questions name uh oh I'm sorry Steve Steve uh was was talking about the sound and a lot of people touched on stuff already but is this going to be 24 hours a
044day business going on or is it just daytime hours or do we have any idea is sound going to be all night or more likely to be 24 hours it will be okay well as far as sound goes like the one gentleman said you got forklifts going in and out of trucks Non-Stop and it makes a lot of noise going into a truck and you got the forli backing up and then you got the uh tractor trailers backing up every night into a bay uh they have Jake brakes coming into the entrance Jake Brak is very loud so one wall may not do what you think and I don't know if your survey was done with that type of noise added to your OB Oban sound uh old Machinery so that you got that uh
045coming out of Zane Circle I don't know if any of you people have ever tried that like making a left at least is the problem I can sit there 10 minutes and wait for tra it's like those traffic lights of time just cause to come by is there any conc consideration for a traffic light at death location and or with Spring Pine or any other place that's something that you know I haven't heard anything about I'm just curious if that was a thought by the board or by the construction company or anything like that but getting in and out is ridiculous there uh basically that's about it okay thank you yes ma'am his wife tell me about the traffic when you go Main Street to be Road and try to get sto and Shop I
046don't know if any of you shop there it especially with Amazon there now it could be that you sit there three or four lights to make a left all those trucks are going to be coming that way to go on to 495 it's ridiculous now half the time to get anywhere has that intersection I don't know what kind of traffic study you did people going in and out but the board has you you really have to go see how long it takes for anybody to get anywhere around that area it is ridiculous I mean those Amazon trucks you can waave three lights before you can make a love turn and Beaver Road it's backed up all different types of the day Beaver Street backed up all different you could go 3:00 in the afternoon and
047it takes you 2 or 3 minutes just to make the turn it's it's ridiculous there's so much traffic in that area between the trucks for the stone quarry and everybody else it it's just a very high traffic area we don't need more trucks in that area thank you anyone else yes [Music] sir uh my name is Wilson Valdez I live in I will with Drive uh I think you know this is the most affected with that you know night with the end of the house and I agree with you saying you know like when I bought the house I B thinking you know is I'm going to be in a quiet place and we pay the taxes and uh you know like uh now everything changed and uh like everybody talking about the traffic and
048just this morning by the way before like last year or two years ago I got I was trying to make a live in the in the night while we drive and somebody hit me and from behind and this morning I'm trying to to you know in the morning try to get in the ear in the morning try to get up from there while we drive I spent like almost 10 almost 15 minutes because a lot of traffic so imagine this you know with all the trucks that and by the way you know when I try to pull from the night from the white drive going to left or or I mean going to right or left uh you know I cannot I can see the the the people coming from the right but I cannot
049see people from the left and you know the is not like straight road it's you know like like this so how how can you figure it out and I ask you guys you know like hey if you live there are you concerned about your family about you concern your children you concern their noise their talk and everything so ask this question yourself so if you leave here you vote for that thank [Music] you yes be back hi I'm Janet Calon I live on 61 East Main Street and I agree with everything that people are saying but a couple of things I did want to reiterate was the 247 it's just too much too much we can't handle that when you looked when we looked on I looked online for uh the hours of construction and
050it says that we're limited um to um if the construction I'm sorry let me go back a second here I'm reading um there's a limitation of construction hour you have to stop between certain times Well if you have to stop for construction why after that can you have 24/7 going on and the other one that's very important to me is the 107 Acres that are left what is going to happen with that with more traffic and more noise when that gets developed [Music] Environ thank you [Applause] I just wanted to follow up to what this fell up front here was saying about another entrance when the Cino was going to try to get into there the casino was going to have an entrance out on to 495 so why can't they go through the motions
051with the state to do the same thing for another exit also the mag the magnitude of the things are totally different and the casino wasn't actually putting a new exit in they were they were doing a bypass lane sort of connected the two that were in Milford with a with a slip ramp that got them off but it was to alleviate some of the traffic all just the state wouldn't do it for this project there's no way it's there's not enough traffic what about 85 they don't have access to there's no access to 85 so you're telling me the only access oh okay then my I just quickly say also I think one of the one of the other meetings I was here we talked about getting the correct speed limit posted which is 30
052mph in there not 40 as the sign is now the state put that up when they repaved 16 the correct speed limit there is 30 m hour and there used to be signs that were 30 m hour you were going to look into it with the state because the state maintains that section of 16 and also a request for no Jake breaks in that area I just don't want that to fall through the cracks and I did not recall the speed limit but I um but I but I wrote it down now and I will um I am going to follow up on the all right thank all right that's it I ask Elizabeth I ask Elizabeth the question certainly is and the no jake break is that a a request that can be made
053that to the state to the state yes okay the state has to approve it thank but we can bring it up yes okay anyone [Music] else I just would like to just want J plan again I I just like to make one final comment I the planning board has to um act within their bounds and represent the town and we are the town's people that you represent as well as the applicants request within the law and I'm just asking that you represent the town's people that have lived here for decades [Music] [Applause] [Music] quickly going back in on the topic of 16 is yeah we've acknowledged that is a state road so realistically the town of Milford has no jurisdiction on Jake brake signage speed limit signage and also any additional um added traffic enforcement
054traffic lights and all that so I know that that is a concern for lots of you out there but it's out of the out of our control out of the town's control that is a state issue and I know it was brought up a lot last time it was brought up again tonight but again just to let everybody know this board in this town really can't do much Liz can send yeah I can make a letter of request but I think that just really needs to be understood out there that again we we can only do so much in regards to how the that Jake breaks and lights and things of that sort um and just you know to point out you know and we looked at this traffic we had the uh the traffic
055report and I completely understand where everybody's coming from but we do we've we've gone through this um and I think we've also looked at the fact that the parcel is uh 116 acres and the in this the um the request is for less than 10 acres I believe or 10 acres we call so in a lot of that land is not buildable if I recall too just because it's Wetlands yeah topography so there is there there are some limitations on that land too for future development so I think that some of the things need to be told everybody like this isn't going to be a giant business part because simply it can't so I make sure every you guys are all set first [Music] okay um did you guys file with meepa yet no because
056that so um meepa just so that you're all aware when they go through the meepa process it is an evaluation of the entire ire property um so it may it won't be specifics of what they may be considering for the rest of the property but it will um include some generalizations of how they think they might do um something with the the rest of the property um so it's it's not just ignored it's it it's just part of a different process [Music] gentleman have anything else uh no councelor you have any uh closing um I at this point um I don't know if if the anybody wants to respond to any of the specific questions that were asked I I believe that we made a complete presentation um I I do think that uh there
057was a question regarding um whether or not the um sound went in the other direction and I think that perhaps Mack could tell you that he's done the analysis based on uh standard procedures that are set forth by the Department of Environmental Protection in the conwal of Massachusetts that tells him how far out he has to measure from the project yeah so you didn't you didn't measure down at Jan at uh Zayn Circle correct we did do measurements down that way we did some short-term measurements at that location so that's even better than I I was thinking you did East Main Street no so when we just to clarify when we did our Ambient sound monitoring program we set up a long-term meter at the end of Wildwood uh drive that collected measurements over 7day
058period so we were collecting hourly measurements over a 7-Day period in October um in the during that same time period we also took measurements along down on East Street and down by zaye Circle and the measurements there when we compared them to the background were actually higher because of 495 so when we based our sound study we based it on the lowest measurement that we got that Wildwood Drive for the whole for the whole area so when we included our sound when we did our sound calculations and and acoustic modeling we included you know receptors that or receivers or homes down along these Main Street along Zan circle area um and again what we're seeing is that a lot of that sound is either being stuck in between the building and the wall area or
059um has been propagated or pushed away from from the homes either on Wildwood driver or East Main Street thank [Music] you Mr chair just quickly on that topic Larry was able to point out to me so the um loading dock is at 329 ft and the um over at Wildwood is at 320 so it's actually a 9t difference so so it is not not significant at all it's not as significant as I thought it was yeah so I just want to point that out so to the point of let's see what that line of sight and and why a you know is it a 5ft wall or is it a 500t wall right like what's what do we truly need in you know adding this wall is is an addition to to really helping in
060that sound mitigation and and and I hope what you know would be a good neighbor um I just would like to see just a little bit more analysis I can understand the the thickness of the wall and why you would need that um I'm just trying to have a better sense of How High that wall needs to be and again for that line of sight of the of the of the sound WS so again from a from a uh yeah so um maybe I can just add to that so again when we did our did our analysis um you know we have to include the heights of of the trucks and in that so um and a lot of that sound energy is within the engine itself so it's down a little bit lower it's
061not at the top of the top of the thing so the top well but the other thing is that a lot of trucks nowadays have to because of the new EPA air quality standards have to put on uh what they callr units and a lot of that um Sound Energy I've done measurements of of newer trucks sound sound energy is much lower than what is typically used in Federal Highway Administration St um and I've been in contact with with those folks and you know and they understand that the the data that they're using from the 1990s is is kind of old but that being said uh you know the sound that we the sound measurements that we took or monitoring we did here was based on that sound energy and then that wall when we
062did the when we did the analysis we played with the height of the wall to make sure we're getting maximum Sound Reduction um and so going back to someone else's concern about sound propagation that the model takes into account How Sound Energy either goes through the wall or around the wall and a lot of you know there is some sound energy that does go around the wall but majority of it is blocked and that's why we're we're recommending 4 lbs per square foot so it's a thick wall that knocks down the low frequency noise um and so something that might help other than a one page of text explaining the results are some graphics because it's over 1,000 ft from the wall that you're proposing to Wildwood Drive only a thousand you're going up and
063downhill uh you know over the W over wooded areas so there's it's not like it's totally wide open and totally flat there's at least a 10t ultimate difference between those grades but in between there's a vast variation so Graphics to explain that a lot gets lost no funding tend in in the distance so so again we did take into account theography of the area in our in our sound analysis um the model can produce sound Contours and shows how the sound uh either gets blocked pushed away or moves a certain way to show a crosssection talking about just get a cross-section through the just the too cross-section the wall with the wall well through the wall all the way down to the property so that we can see that cross-section looks like from the parking
064lot all the way to the to the Wildwood Drive should be you should be able to cut yeah so yeah the the the civil engineer can do that yeah correct and then if you if you do have a uh if you're able to uh um take the content of the uh the analysis and show the uh um degradation of the sound as values across there it would be good to have that as a as a sheet similar to like a lighting yeah similar to a lighting lighting [Music] diagram because yeah that distance I mean we can see the distance in in in knowing the degradation and sound over that distance just naturally the the the amount of sound that goes down is is significant yeah the uh we're projecting that the wall is going to
065get more than a 10 D Sound Reduction which is a significant Sound Reduction you know when when you're thinking about three debel change in sound is barely perceptible a 5 deel change is noticeable 10 is is having of loudness so we're talking about you know the wall doing a substantial amount of sound ruction but we can show that graphically as well it would it would probably I you must have this information but it would also be I understand doing the analysis and and taking that it it points in time where the where the background is low it would also be interesting in terms of of um on a Friday afternoon at 2 or 3:00 in the afternoon what the sound value is at that point in time because it's it's tough to evaluate some of
066those things but the you know the ambient in that area as in a lot of areas I mean I can hear 495 from my house and I'm 4 miles away sure uh it just happens and and the ambient is there there's nothing you can do about that and you certainly can't ask you to to mitigate someone else's sound so it you know there's very little at at 2:00 in the morning on a Friday evening but at 2:00 in the afternoon on Friday what that ambient is is is would be an interesting number to know yeah I can I can tell you at least it's about a 10 D difference or more time so so that if you were going to look at the ambient the noise from the facility with the wall and everything else
067that'll be even lower yeah I know that yeah yeah I should had one I'm just not sure if we I just had a question about the wall so if if sound is hitting that wall is it not echoing more into the other direction are you taking that into account like the fact that it's probably going to be bouncing back more to the other direction and the other houses along East Main Street that are there and Whispering Pine and zaye ridge will we'll probably be getting more sound instead of less so the the acoustic model takes into account what type of property the sound barrier is um and so it it does take into account any kind of any kind of reflecting of sound um and that's why we sort of turn the corner here and
068put the sound wall around the corner here to make sure we're blocking any sound that's going to be escaping out this way towards East Main Street so the model does take into account reflection of sound when it does its calculations of of the the Ultimate Sound uh number that you get at each home and it takes that into account about just thought since you said you were just looking at the one street that you you're you're taking into account reflection but are you taking into account that at all the other locations as well yeah so the building itself also act acts as a barrier itself going going this way so it uh it helps to block that sound going down from you know on this side of of the of the site as well what
069is the distance between the building and Wildwood Drive you I I I don't know if to think it's 7 or 800 ft but John will 7 or 800 ft that's it from the building to East Main Street no Street [Music] oh um I me you have a scale right there yeah it's probably close to 1,000 ft I can measure it though it's probably close to 1,000 ft but I can measure it in a second um 20 21st is the first with all that property you couldn't push that building back a little lot of wetlands yeah wet ones on the other side looks like whole buildings around Wetlands surrounded Wonder be is that going to be [Music] okay yeah to the end of the road it's about 940 ft give or take [Music] a [Music] distance
070really is in yeah de Romero I just wanted to say that you know we're focusing on the sound thing it becomes like the new issue as as the you know permit's going process here um but the other stuff stands I know you did you all addressed all the traffic last time that's why I didn't say anything about it but um what was I going to say I have such a headache I'm so stressed um that you know uh that the operation itself like I said I just want to reiterate that the attorney ran up to the person that said nay and said if we make it till 6:00 at night and we end we end their operations will you you know approve the permit so that something I want to bring up too that even
071whether the sound cuz the sounds just going to it's I don't care how many studies they have it's going it's going to be disruptive and it's not going to be pleasant for me living there or anybody else in the area um that the the the time of operation at 24/7 and a neighborhood zone is is totally off off Mark there and um I just want to reiterate that that if they were willing to do that to try to get the permit then why can't they do something now in the sense like if you guys do approve it and there is a lot of sound and it stinks for all of us and our lives are even worse um you know for living there that um maybe that could be part of it too that you
072there was a fin night time that they can operate cuz if they're there at 11:00 at night 2: in the morning there's just no way on a especially during in the summer months 3 or 4 months when windows are open I have to keep my windows closed 24/7 495 it's just not fair so again please just deny the permit during the construction of this building would the wall be built first to no well construction is loud it's probably louder than that's why the that's why there's a limit on the construction hours [Music] okay uh so John you want to try to one more address those I'm sorry I was just thinking last sorry Wendy pouncy to a spring fine Drive um I think I brought up the whole like we talked about the traffic I
073was just curious about the I brought up the school bus system because our kids get picked up on that street and I thought somebody wrote down that they were going to look into I mean I don't know what you guys were going when they were doing the traffic stud first we can just that was included in the stopping and going the bus because there's at least I think stops on our on Main Street that I can see anyway um if that included with including adding new trucks as well turning and then as you can see with Whispering Pine Drive being like semi close to where they would enter so taking lefts with the traffic and then if someone's pulling in you I in terms of stopping like adding to that traffic I'm just curious if
074that bus the school bus um stopping and going will obviously add to that traffic [Music] issue you want to say something yes I'm waiting for him to look at me so um I my only uh outstanding question is I I know uh Mr anelis attorney antonellis mentioned that there was conversations about um the fire flow and I just wanted to know if um if there was any additional information that you received beyond the correspondence that the uh the board has um anything we we prepared or have received anything anything other than then so I'll paraphrase the the correspondent says that the current system can provide 2,000 um gallons per minute uh and the correspondence from your fire protection engineer or somebody from I don't know exactly who it was but basically said that that was
075the bare minimum needed for the construction of the facility regardless of what was going to be stored inside yeah I think it was the opposite and and I think what was prepared the fire a fire protection engineer just ran a hypothetical if the building was filled with something super flammable per se just to run a number and just see it was 6,000 right which that isn't going to completely completely agree that the that that number is not reasonable and should not be considered correct the low number the best case scenario for the building is is How It Was Written best case scenario was that they needed a minimum of 2,000 yeah and we can provide some but T typically what ends up happening is once you know the tenant then you can actually run the
076calculation cuz you know the height and the racking and and all that I understand so that's but yeah this this one this one's a big one if this is a bare minimum because yeah before we go anywhere we you'd be you'd be installing a bigger Main in in 16 and if we needed to do that that's something we would or or we need to limit what the types of usages are in the permit to begin with so you we're not we're not going to give you a blanket if only certain things can go in then then then that needs to be as part of our our approval so we need to straighten that out a little B we'll provide a calculation yeah [Music] Absolut continue is the 21st going to be enough time to address
077all that stuff it will be Mr chairman it's Joe Joe oh yeah Joe I just I I I thought that this point might be appropriate for the applicant to request the continuance till the uh second meeting in January that uh Mr Duncan talked about earlier this evening I believe that's the nth the 21st yes January 21 yes um I've taken some uh fairly comprehensive notes regarding the sound study and the questions that were asked relative to the um the wall and the uh comments made regarding seeing some kind of specifications for it also some further information from Mark Wallace relative to how the Ambient sound travels and and further measurements um also in response to uh lizz's comment regarding the fire flow again we can supplement that and uh I think there were a couple
078other questions I took notes for I do believe that we have significant time between now and the 2st to uh supplement the application with the requested information from the board tonight and uh I'll stop talking if there's anything else the board thinks can think of that I missed uh please let me know but uh we will address it in in that if the board is willing to Grant the continuance and again respectfully requested till the 21st of [Music] January pleasure of the board make a motion we continue to the 21st of January at 702 two second we moved in second we continue this public he until 2 first of January any further discussion here and none all those in favos thank you thank you very much appreciate it like to thank the board night happy
079holidays everybody thank you you Joe okay if you can carry on your discussions in the hallway please we have other matters we're discussing [Music] that for that facility that facility unless depending on what well yeah now right now well I don't know if you're aware of it I was an instructor any different than what we had in front of us same as what I had okay no I just want to make sure theyve going over this one yeah okay what fire what fire engine is yeah okay stay there I was done there I can't good how are you Danelle Sal yes 96 Purchase Street uh the applicant request site plan approval to add an accessory Ying unit to the subject property zba approved a variance and special perment for the property at their 11 1424
080meeting I've included that decision in the packet the variance was needed due to the substandard lot area and yard setback and the special permit was needed due to the house being non-conforming as to setback requirements specifically The Proposal now the site plan review is to construct the 24 by 36 twostory addition to the north side of the existing rolling 864 ft of the first floor portion of the proposed Edition will create an accessory dwelling unit under the recently adopted zoning bylaw amendments for such uses uh second FL portion of the addition will accommodate the remodeling and expansion of the existing bedrooms and bathrooms that are already in the single family dwelling all apptical zoning requirements appear to be met therefore recommend approval of the site plan as requested subject to relevant agency comments um attach
081the uh decision from the zba uh there are comments favorable comments from water uh building official noted that the plans currently don't uh meet the building code so by the time they apply for special permit they'll have to have updated building plans but they would have needed that anyway uh and the fire department uh noted that the existing propane storage tank may have to be relocated they'll verify that the scheduled inspection I had included and they also putting in warrant have the eight standards that are newly adopted for John's here good evening John John N Out with DNL Design Group here representing my client Danielle Zulo um just a little background Danielle lives at 96 um Pur Street it's a a house that was built in 1900 it's extremely well kept extremely well landscaped um
082very very nice house um she's a single working mom she um has one child just had a second child last week is she's not here today her mom is in the audience this is addition we kind of caught the time between the in-law apartment byw or the supplemental apartment byw and the new Adu this is for basically an in-law apartment for her mom to live in the house and help her with the children she also has a special needs brother that lives with her um so we got caught kind of in between um it's a simple addition 24x 36 the reason it doesn't meet current zoning is because in 1937 there was a taking a Purchase Street they took approximately 15 ft of the front yard um that's the setback that we're not we're not
083meeting and they've also took all that area so we're not meeting that area it's a 15,000 ft um zoning area we have 11,200 it got taken away by the a taking of purchas Street in 1931 like I said the house was built in 1900 the first floor of it's a 24x 36 Edition the first floor is 864 Square ft it's just under the 900 ft for the Adu that's an in-law for the mom and upstairs of course this is an older skinny house the bedrooms are very tiny they're going to be incre adding a a home office for her increasing the size of the bedrooms that are there and doing a master currently there's no bathroom upstairs they're adding a full bathroom upstairs and a half bath to make the house more livable that's the
084gist of the entire uh site plan yeah the zoning deficiencies so uh would have needed to be addressed whether there was an Adu going in or not however they were addressed in the context of coming here with the site plan uh so that those issues have been overcome otherwise uh they would not have been able to apply for an Adu because they needed to have a a compliant parcel uh and building to start with uh but as I say those have been overcome so the the eight uh items uh under the new Adu section of the bylaw under 319 uh they're coming for site plan approval that's number one um it's being created either with it's this case is being created within the single family dwelling that's number two um it would have separate entrances
085or at least uh availability for access from the outside which this one will uh number four shall not exceed 900 square ft John's addressed that um number five uh shall comply with all applicable regulations concerning setbacks that's been overcome as I mentioned uh number six one additional off street parking space should be required uh there's a wide driveway existing uh that's uh for all intents and purposes wide enough uh I'd have to go back and scale it again but I think it's wide enough for three cars and side by side in a residential setting uh of course short-term rentals are prohibited um and the the last point in in our Amendment to the bylaw uh had eliminated the very thing as John mentioned that they had thought they were going to apply for which was
086a supplemental Suite so those don't exist anymore um and that's why it's before you the way it is the parking area I've added to that packet is 27 by 20 so it's good for three spaces actually a little bit bigger than three car spaces P for wood yes what did the lot have I'm sorry too much hand raising um you mentioned that I I believe if I heard you right the the setback was compliant with zoning until Purchase Street was widened I'm not sure because there was no zoning in 1937 but they did take they did take 20 I have that's they did take 25 F feet it's from the wall it was originally 25 ft from the wall and 40 ft from The Edge pav that's okay it it it foils that answer foils
087my second question thank you you're welcome Mr chair yes Larry quick uh or even Liz quick clarification uh John Erikson's letter here by saying that it needs to meet certain requirements is it I guess I I didn't quite understand what he was getting at my I the best I understand it and I and I don't quote me on it is it it has something to do with like f oh does John know the answer John knows the answer so it's it's the building plans the building plans are are basically a layout in sketches there's no framing plans there's no insulation plans they don't meet the new energy code once we get permitted for that then she needs to have a full set of plans to submit her build okay just want to make sure yeah
088I didn't quite understand what Mr Ericson was getting at so but that makes sense now so GL to ask the question thank you well Joe this is one of possibly say there is a h CH yeah yeah I don't have anything with this one well with the adus I mean it's it it's actually not a bad one for say with the with the front yard being taken that was yeah uh thing any other comment of the board what's the pleasure of the board I'll make a motion to accept the site plan with the relevant uh comments that was second that motion we moved it second to uh approved the site plan any further discussion hearing none all those in favor I I poos unanimous five thank you boy thank you John thanks did I miss
089calling you in the day I know I miss you babe you can call me anytime you know okay here you're getting better with your presentations here no not when I was there not when you were there not when you were here I was well you don't have to lie okay we got a zba referral for 21 Beaver Street for Town view all that work I did John going to tear it up that's that's cousin I had included a list of uh of the current 40 BS in terms of what our uh percentage is for time and um when I the approved developments first these pending that are hanging fire so I think that's somewhere in your packet there's a single sheet so for 21 Beaver Street Town View [Music] um Town view 21 Beaver Street
090the above reference 40b is being proposed uh it's located within the be Hill industrial park and it's in an IB industrial Zone consists of one four-story building with 100 3 1 two and three-bedroom residential units as residential units as rental units all the units will be eligible to be counted on the town's Shi which is recently updated to 99.5% the 14.6 acre lot is located southwesterly of the intersection of Medway Street and R 109 in Beaver Street uh I have reviewed the subject proposal and note the following deficiencies um number one the only access is from Beaver Street which is one way Northbound number two southbound 495 ramps are located only 475 ft to the east of the site number three residential traffic will compete uh with existing heavy truck traffic from the industrial park
091number four the current traffic counts on Beaver Street are 478 adts that's based on a tetratech analysis in uh June of 20 uh 23 number five the driveway location uh has been moved 120 ft north of the existing Town approved location which was put as far south as possible to avoid uh uh what the next item is number six the driveway location will result in delays caused by stacking from the Midway Street intersection number seven there are only 157 off street parking spaces for the 103 dwelling units so they're not coming close to the two per unit requirement that the zba has maintained uh number eight the units are proposed close to existing commercial industrial uses number nine there's inadequate screening and buffering provided or from adjacent commercial uses and the gas station of number
09210 very minimal usable open space or Recreation Area being provided 79% of the of the 11 or 11.57 Acres of the 14 Acre Site uh is wetlands and or flood plane so if you want to go out and use the open space you're going to sink up to your knees at least uh so therefore based on the above noted deficiencies I recommend an unfavorable report be forwarded to the zba I've attached a portion of the materials the developer had submitted to the zba uh just so you can get a quick idea of the size and density of the development on such a small portion of the site [Music] so I'd recommend unfavorable we forward it to the zba they're uh I think they're holding their hearing uh I got the wrong calendar I think they're
093holding their hearing uh next week 23rd yeah yeah next yeah next Monday January 23rd January January 23rd oh they they bumped it out yeah yeah oh all right [Music] anyway pleas of the board any questions for us of all I agree with Larry's comments I mean you know I'm not sure how you how you deal with putting something like this you know it's one thing when you're putting in parking SP for Amazon Vehicles when you're putting people's life safety in Jeopardy at the end of a one-way Street um just to me does you know I know the state 40b group will probably say oh it doesn't matter cuz we don't really care they'll if they die they die in your town not mine good uh but uh I I I just don't I I I
094mean to me that's that's probably the most critical one but I in this one I mean there were a couple of comments on the other one that I did have on this one I agree with Larry's you know each one of them you know some of the parking makes no sense whatsoever I can't see people walking especially up that's you know to the distances and um so I I I agree with Larry's comments I you know and and I would uh I certainly make a motion that we send an unfavorable recom unfavorable report to the zoning board I'll second that just one thing to add on the discussion if you don't mind mind is obviously um as I said on school committee also that's always something that we're looking at uh school committee is going
095to uh also send a letter uh or discuss this and send send a letter um from our Thursday night meeting because I think it's important to know that you know 30 students are coming from uh Stone Ridge we don't you know Stone Ridge 2 is even bigger uh or has more apartments and now we're looking at these additional um residential buildings and what the impact going to be so even beyond what the impact is going to be within that General are I know that there is also an impact to our school system which also impacts our taxes so I think that all of those things need to be considered when we start looking at and whether we approve or disapprove or un favorable unfavorable that there are uh cascading impacts throughout town that we need
096to consider one being like I said the schools that were already at maximum capacity in that some so okay I moved in second any further discussion all those in favor opposed un okay moving right along item five is U same same deal on Blooming Hills 40b at 310 porun Boulevard um it's being proposed uh in Granite Park industrial area in an IB Zone consists of 14 four story building with 52 rental units consisting of 21 I'm sorry 28 1bedroom 18 2bedroom and six three-bedroom units again as rental units all the units will be eligible to be counted on the town s hii uh and as I mentioned we're at 9.5 currently uh the 7.8 acre development site is to be subdivided from the existing overall 10 acre parcel which was the Overflow lot from the
097Toyota dealership uh previously I reviewed the proposal and note the following deficiencies uh this one only has 10 uh only one access Drive is proposed on Fortune Boulevard uh the access Drive is overly cous uh the access lacks vertical curve and clearance analysis for fire trucks number four there's no fire lane around the building that is along the southeasterly side of the building number five there's a 20ft grade change within the 60 ft between the building where proposed and the parking lot for 420 Fortune Boulevard which is the adjacent site to the southeast uh there are only 98 parking spaces for the 52 units again they don't meet the uh two per unit ratio number seven 22 of the parking spaces are located down along the access Drive distant from the building number eight there's
098no provision for visitor parking number nine there's very limited usable open space provided uh number 10 the recreation areas are again along the the access drive distance from the building therefore based on those deficiencies I recommend an unfavorable report before to the zba and again I attached a portion of uh the applicant's presentation to the zva uh there's obviously more information available but that seemed to cover it for for this purpose it's a recommend unfavorable yes about that um could Larry could you explain number five a little bit better what's what's the importance of that what's what is it about that grade change that's made it notor well if you turn into let's see what page is it it's back in there ways of well there are two problems that uh the the horizontal curve
099of the driveway uh is a switch back so you're going to have uh uh and the driveways on the outside of the curve of Boulevard well what page are you are you looking at just in the plan set anyone just he's talk about the section it's one of the colored back in a ways it's one of the colored uh Graphics it's the easiest to read on oh she's yeah she's looking at the big ones not in the big ones right okay yeah my colleague has found it for me oh there's one there's one in there too but okay that's what talking about so so the driveway is located on the an outside of a curb on Fortune Boulevard which generally is where you'd want to put them however it has very little straightening uh area
100as you turn in so Envision turning in with a firr uh so you got to make the corner and then get straightened out but then you got to start maneuvering the the corner of the driveway itself to get around uh and then and then switch back again to get up the hill to the parking lot in front of the building so it seems like a securious uh uh route to take it's it's more distance from the building than I think they could get if they relocated the driveway but none of that accounts for the change in grade as you come in and there was no analysis done to show uh whether or not a fire truck would be able to get in there uh aside from the left and right turns the vertical distance as
101you drive in and start going uphill uh and how quickly that uh ramp ramping effect takes effect uh because the rear end of the uh ladder truck is going to drag on the on the ground I'm sorry lar but your number five doesn't mention fire trucks it talks about grade changes and just that's what you're saying the grade change fire truck yeah but I guess I have the same question as 20 foot I think your reference that there's a grade change between the Toyota dealership and this posle yeah oh okay I'm sorry I'm sorry I was yeah no the other the others make sense Larry I mean yeah it's it's steep it's steep in there's tight curves and they need to check it but I just I'm not sure that there's I know there's a
1022 foot grade change but I don't know that it's it's critical to the design or not is I'm sorry I I misunderstood the question so yeah the if you look at the location of the building there's no uh fire lane around the building and the edge of the pavement uh just east of the building uh it immediately drops down at least 20 ft to the parking lot next door for God sake so there's there's no way to get to the building from the parking lot next door because it's 20 foot lower and it's 60t away there's no fire lane back uh okay so what you're saying is there's no fire lane on the back side the fire department can't get to the backside cuz it slopes so so quickly down that's we're saying should probably
103amend your letter better reflect what you're explaining because the the points you've stated are really important all the fire access issues both from the driveway both getting into the driveway and getting to the back of the building well number four starts it by saying there's no fire lane around the building and number five says there's a 20 grade change so it's not clear all right well I can TW thank you good those are very good points the other thing the other thing that makes it a little bit tougher is I mean I guess if we're looking at it although sometimes it's tough to figure out which where Southeast is but you know when you're looking at it I you're it doesn't automatically go there I guess the only other thing I I I had a
104comment I had a comment on that one that clears that one up at least uh the only other one that I had a comment on is only one access Drive is proposed I mean I only think I want one access drive here so I'm not sure it may not be in the right location or may maybe a better location but I certainly don't I don't want it to be putting two access drives on fortun Boulevard for this for 50 [Music] units yeah I guess my point access drives me definitely not here yeah I guess my point was with only one being there and and then they're further complicating the issue with the horizontal and vertical curves yeah yeah yeah I I understand that but I mean I guess I guess comment one to me doesn't
105need to be there you you address it in all the others let's eliminate comment one because that that lends me to believe you want multiple access drives and I certainly don't want to see that right all right yeah I can I take that out and rephrase the others it's really fire access that's the issue I think yeah that's all I have yeah I can make those changes because I'll include this with your with cover letter for the recommendation so so is that a motion what's what's a pleasure of the board make a motion we send a an unfavorable recommendation unfavorable report to the zoning board of appeals based on um Larry's original letter plus the discussion comments on uh on items one and five second we moved in second any further discussion here are none
106those in favor I oppose Ina five have a good evening thank you thank you uh if there's ready if there um yeah so um I I didn't bring it up during the um hearing but um as for the Adu um there's just I have some concerns and I'm not sure that I think it's something that the Board needs to think about what how they want to if they want to address it I guess um so typic the the water I know the letters in that um approval were basically fine from the water department but I've had discussions with them separately um and where that's really an in-law apartment I know know it's not going to be permitted as such but where it is they're less concerned about it but um something moving forward is whether
107or not we want to see um it's really about having 2 m for the water and um possibly two sewer services that would be the bigger thing for um for consideration because that could make a substantial change to the site plan um I I spoke with um John my nin about um the services and his um he felt that if there was any ability for them to be in separate ownership the Adu and the um and the main house that he would like to see um maybe to um there's all so but there's also there um and and same it's just it's just something I I think that needs to be there needs to be further discussion before we get um too far along with these regulations well I think the Water and Sewer Department
108have to have to tell us where they want to go or not go I don't know that it's ours to say I mean I think the water department right now could say we're not doing it unless we have two Waterland they don't yes Larry I am fully aware of how you feel no but there I talked to Town Council I talked to Jerry today that the the town cannot regulate ownership with zoning so you have to assume that one way or another many of these in the future can be condo out and they can be owned separately whether we like it or not there's nothing we can do about it and whether you require it on a site plan or not that's another whole issue you can't require it on a site plan unless the
109sewer department or the water department says they want it and that's why we review it that's one of the reasons I wanted to have site plan review I agree that they need to figure out I my recommendation is they need to assume that every one of these damn things is going to get condo out who's going to tell them that H who's going to tell them that who's going to tell who that who's going to tell the sewer department and the water because the sewer and the water department currently as they reviewed this one think that it cannot be I'll tell them so I'm so I don't I just think it's some I think that it's something that the pl regular site plan review which This falls under unless it's uh unless this site plan
110review is identified and defined differently than a commercial site plan review by the bylaw it falls under the same requirements as a regular site plan review in regular site plan review we would know whether or not the sewer department wants certain types of things and we would require them to be shown on the plan I just think there needs to be a conversation or a consensus from this board as to whether or not you want to see it on the plan and if you're not going to see it on the plan I quite frankly don't understand what you're looking at because there's nothing to the site plan review so I just wanted to bring my concerns to your attention and you as a board are completely in control of how you handle it I just
111wanted to bring my concerns to you does keeping it as one water man one sewer is it that a become a deterrent from condo it up because now you've only got one service coming in one electrical one SE one and one um no I think it'ss the other way I mean I mean the at the end of the day if they want to condo it out then they put in two they have they I mean but allow but but you can't you can't do anything about it at that point when you go when you go to when you go to condo it out yes there is no trigger to require a separate Sewer Service there is a there is a trigger for uh a additional water meter mhm but you know for for example the
112the people that were in front of us tonight this is clearly just a an in-law type situation right but you know I have an in-law apartment when my parents pass away um she trying to tell you something I may want uncomfortable f I may want to rent out that facility and and you can I and I can but isn't it in isn't it in everybody's best interest that everybody understands upfront that now I'm going to have to try and figure out how to make the plumbing work so that I can have two meters and not one meter or if the sewer hence a deterrent going down that road right that's what I'm saying so I'm just looking at it from that side that someone someone like you that has some forethought of an in-law apartment
113and May from the initial site plane create all those dual Services coming in whereas the other person now has to come back to us or go through they're not going to come back to us don't have to come back to at the end of at the end of the day I'm I'm not sure it's government's job to protect everybody from doing everything and anything I mean sewer department should be reviewing this and saying they're putting in four more four more bedrooms that that pipe isn't going to be big enough to handle what's in the building and what they're adding the pipe is then then what difference does it make if we have separate utilities then why are we going to require that if if if somebody is willing to take the thing on and they're
114and they're willing to set up a condo document that says if the sewer pipe breaks it's your responsibility of both parties or it's my responsibility or whatever why why do we want to get in the middle of that well we wouldn't that's my point my point is that that the the utilities when they review one of these needs to be mindful you know this case that was here tonight it's unlikely that very quickly it would be condo out but 15 years from now or 10 years from now it could be yeah because their lives could change it happens to everybody things change so all I'm saying is that there's no way for the town to prevent those things from being condo out so uh John and uh Dave need to be aware of that and
115if they decide it's in the best interest of the town to protect the town in the future to require no matter what the case is now anybody doing an Adu is going to have to have separate utilities for those two for for that uh so if that's what they want they should tell you guys when you review the site plan Yep they're the applicants engineer will be showing it on the plan but you can't do it the other way around because we think it's a good idea No it should that's not what and that's not what I'm suggesting I'm suggesting there needs to be a conversation so that the water department the people at the water department reviewing the plan understand the regulations and that the sewer department understand the regulations that for the Adu
116so that I can call them and tell them all write him a memo whatever but I don't know what else what does the board need to do what could I make a go ahead could I say something you know my position on this that was a perfect case for an Adu what absolutely so I I'm not in favor of mandating that we have to have separate utilities and all that as a matter of fact I I'm against it I I don't I I I personally my belief is these should be own occupied I understand the state is mandating and I get that but I wouldn't make it easier to sell these and divide them and all that I would just say keep it the way it is but well I I don't I don't think
117it makes it easier or harder it it it comes down to if it doesn't because you can craft a document if you're going to conduit it out you you do a master a master deed in in the condo documents that says this is how utilities are handled that's that's as much as they do they're not going to build anything differently they're not going to do anything differently they write if if you got a lawyer that knows what he's doing they they write it into the document and that's how they handle it my thing is and yeah I I the only thing I think this board should do is make the sewer board and the water board aware of the fact that these can be condo out if you have an issue with this that you
118want separate utilities then let us know so that we can evaluate that when it comes into us that to me that's as far as we go we don't make that decision they make that decision but they need to tell us that way we know they've they've reviewed and given their opinion on it they're elected officials too they have the right to make their decisions I'll make sure they they're aware I talked to Town Council I talked to Jerry just yeah this morning to confirm I talked to him before but there there's nothing that we can do uh under zoning that has anything to do with ownership per say uh but those two utilities can because their decisions can you know the the answer can be different depending upon who own so yeah I'll make sure
119they they get something could we as a planning board write a letter to our state representative to to change to to put into this 32nd rule that they made they're going to have to make changes anyway that we would appreciate if they put in that they have to be singly owned they can't be calized they they specifically put the language in there that way they did it intentionally what did you could quize it yeah yeah yeah I mean you can we can write whatever we want we can certainly say that I I I think that's a that's a big road to Ho because their whole their whole thing was to allow this that that's why they did this I I I never agreed with it with might think to blow the whole thing up would
120not be you know wouldn't you wouldn't have to push me too far to get to that point but I don't know that I'm going to win but you know I I we we can ask that I just I don't think they're going that way I mean there's this there's this overriding thing that that somehow the governor and pow was to be believ this is going to bring down the price of housing in Massachusetts Unfortunately they don't realize that their tax situation and tax setup is one of the biggest reasons why we we end up paying for as much for for houses in Massachusetts another law after this adule they just did another 600 page law that extended all the deadlines so all permit U deadlines the life of every permit which otherwise would have run
121out is now extended two years so there was a second extension beyond the prior extension which was an extension beyond the co extensions so they don't give a of what happens to the towns at all because because the the reason to have the reason to have a timeline the reason to have a an active window so to speak to to do whatever it was your approval uh was granted was to make sure you do it in the timely fashion uh Because by the time you get around to doing it laws will change right but they're not going to be subject to them so so they're they're they're taking well I mean and the problem the problem is and they don't realize that there are other laws that they can't get around like the building code
122that you know when you put in the building permit that's the building code and if that changed we talked about the fire suppression now if the building code changes such that the fire suppression changes they may have to change the whole water setup that that was submitted to us is part of it because you know it just makes no sense to me they have no clue how anything interacts and they don't care apparently so anyway but I mean if you want Larry to draw up a letter that to indicate that I I I I don't I'm more than willing to sign something that says that that we should have our representative look at that but I mean at some point I I don't know where any of these got you know put in it seems
123like most of them are are uh you know at midnight at some night that all of a sudden there there's I haven't heard very very little I mean the adus came out I heard no public comment no nothing um you know there's another one that that you know you think that they would ask the the the planning boards and the Redevelopment authorities in the state of Massachusetts I I doubt very much that they did um you know uh these these things just come up and they don't ask anybody about it you know under the guys that were going to lower housing prices and and they don't address any of those things they won't address them in the end just like 40b never addressed it back to Elizabeth's discussion did you want that letter or or
124that TR that communication to come from the planning board or well Larry and I didn't agree on clear what so I so I felt that it was appropriate for you as a board to decide together how you wanted to move forward yeah well so do I understand Larry that you've now agreed to write a letter expressing Elizabeth's concern I was going to write a letter or a memo or an email to uh the Water Department and the sewer dep Department explaining to them that these adus uh can very likely be condo out that that the none of the zoning stuff that I thank you can change it so I was just going to remind them of that so as they see these things coming through for these site plan reviews when they send comments back
125to you they can you know decide uh I would think they would want to have all of them have separate utilities I would I would I would ask the question Larry I I would indicate to them that that they can be condo and if you want to put it in the planning board is questioning whether you want these to be as separate you it is your choice and the planning board wants to know if you want these to be separate utilities or not that way we we put the question out there to them if they don't come back with anything then hey that that's on them and if they do we can follow it I could even see that uh because the adus be a separate building so you build you build a 24x 36
126separate building those things to me would be obvious separate utilities so I could see that they would say yes on those and no on the others uh but that's their decision to make they just need to understand that they could all be condo out Elizabeth did I understand also you were concerned you wanted the applicant the home the property owner to understand this also that if you think you might ever condo it you need to know you're going to be installing new utilities certainly that's not our responsibil that's not our responsibility it's not bad to have informed applicants and and the other thing is and I've seen this happen on single family houses and certainly It Could Happen a situation like this where the sewer department didn't put a letter in for this correct and
127then they get everything approved they get they're ready to start construction they go to pull a sewer permit and then the sewer department says hey you need two you need two services and now let's not let people get caught off guard so I I think it makes sense for I I absolutely think you know reaching out to them saying you can't you have making sure that they understand that they have the ability to regulate this or at least set a precedent um come up and I think putting to them the difference the the different scenarios of an addition to an existing building and a separate building they may want to have different situations for each of those I you know but they they what the water department what I heard back from the water department
128was there's nothing we can do about it we have to approve the Adu that was that was all right and that was all they but I'm just saying they didn't they didn't think they had the ability to say hey we would really like to see two yeah meters so I just want them to have a better understanding of what this board is looking for okay are you ready I'm ready I just I just didn't think and I still don't think it's Neary not for no I mean you're making now you you want to you want to have the board do something that I can pick up the phone and and done but you didn't say that to me today when when we were when we were if the board wants to make a big deal
129out of would have ADD it okay no I I I I don't think it's either any of that I think I think at the end of the day all it is is we just want to make sure that that we're getting information because we have to approve it that we're getting information back from the Water and Sewer Department that they've reviewed it under the context of whatever the heck they wanted to do so when we approve it or not we We There is much there isn't much not approving of them but anyways prefer it be a memo formally from the board or do you want me to just yeah I would I would just I would just write I would write a memo to each each of the two boards indicating that that that they
130uh that all of these can be condo eyes and that they need to um they need to be aware that they can they can ask for separate services of that and then we get our answer back if that's what they want to do or not do right okay okay Martha oh I already made the motion second second move the second we have Jour any further discussion hearing none all those in favor opposed unanimous 100 good night