001recording in progress good evening everyone welcome to the Wi school committee meeting and uh please stand if you can for the Pledge of Allegiance in the national anthem United States Amica By the Light sooud we at the Twilight last whose and bright stars through the the streaming and the [Music] rocking in Pro through the night that our flag was still there oh [Applause] [Music] [Applause] for the of the the of [Music] the Roll Call member Alvarez here member banaria here member Benda here member Guardiola here Vice chair Johnson here member mailman member McCulla member Roy here mayor Petty Here uh we have the consent agenda e uh R call member Alvarez yes member banaria yes member Benda yes member guardio yes Vice chair Johnson yes member mailman change your name yes member Mulla member Roy
002yes mayor Petty uh yes we have the held items member being carried made a motion to quar a survey of the pickup and drop off at the Roosevelt School and other congested schools and request visibility of police to move traffic along motions approving the file just quick just quickly uh um to to talk about the fact that at Roosevelt um hopefully this spring the project will begin and we should have some help in how this is going to work in the parking lot and so on and it was due to the uh collaboration with the city and the school department to get this done so looking forward to some of the construction and I know we have other issues at other schools so we can discuss them in in further time okay thank you motions
003to approve the F those in favor oppos so order um M being carry me a motion to receive a report of the H handson learning taking place within the program by grade being carrier we're we're fine with this item um this item can be filed filed okay I'm sorry did it ask is that supposed to go to fog I'm sorry about that want go fog sure okay all those in favor M being carried made a motion to receive a report on the financial demographics for students in this program I'm sorry before we do that M Johnson Ju Just in regards to it going going to fog I I thought this was um it was a report of the super report of the superintendent she asked for feedback on so we that wouldn't go the report
004of superintendent wouldn't go to fog it would just be approv and file chairman okay that am I correct member um being carrier am I correct about that the report of the superintendent wouldn't go to fog unless we wanted to further discuss it however um it doesn't have to go to fog I can if we find any questions on it we can certainly bring It Forward at another time it's fine we can file okay motion to approving the file those in favor oppose so ordered next one a motion to receive a report on the financial demographic of still in this program approve and defile all those in favor oppos so AED request that Administration survey all the school sites for the safety purposes while valuing the number of crossing guards assigned to each School proving the
005file mov being carrier that particular item um when we look at what who we have on our sites presently there's always room for improvement and I was hoping that we could um take a look at a few of the sites such as wor the technical high school so we don't have staff continue to be out there with their vests on and maybe we can take a look at uh Belmont Street also even though we have the overpass there are times that the overpass isn't utilized as it should um so I I'm looking for more of a discussion on that piece and I'm hoping it could whatever committee suggested it could go to so we could have a further discussion on um maybe coming up with some funding for in budget this coming year to enable
006us to um add to that area we set the fog I guess okay okay those in favor proposal order present the administration survey all School sites for the safety purposes while Val the number of Crossing guides assigned to each school that's a response to the administration we oh that's the one that's going the F okay I missed I'm sorry start's going on the for all those in favor post order public comment any member of the public May address the uh school committee for 2 minutes any my item on the agenda it's your name and item number good evening Maria Montano um this is my first time here so I'm just trying to understand the agenda a little bit it's different from the school commit I mean city council just have to Whatever item you want
007to talk about just mention it okay um I'm not sure of being chia's um item as far as the crossing guards go um but that's an issue with all the schools right now where they're under on school crossing guards so I'm not really understanding that petition um I want to agree with um mailman on GB 54 I think if I said that correctly no GB 53 um seven and eighth grade I do feel that there should be a way to explore uh more ways of having um Sports for the younger kids so um I just wanted to chime in on that one and I'll get better on public comment okay practice makes perfect come to a city council meeting okay okay we'll close that P the meeting and uh sorry wasting Sor I apologize I
008was getting my glasses does your name say your residence in the item number sure good evening I'm Dina teski um a Mr resident I'm also a parent of a South High graduate uh and a current seventh grader at Godard Scholars at Sullivan Middle School excuse me I want to thank Dr manaras and her team for their continued work to engage families and their children family engagement as indicated in the US Department of Health and Human Services and Department of Education is pro it promotes children's learning and healthy development as a part of their policy statements it is no surprise that Worcester struggled to get our buildings in better shape in response to the pandemic and covid as almost half are pre-or War II 1940s I encourage and ask the school committee to support our students
009and structures with whatever resources are possible healthy safe accessible and maintained schools and learning spaces are critical the effort to do better all the time for students and caregivers is obvious with how students and staff are recognized and honored including on social media this matters we are proud We are so proud of our students and staff achievements and we want and should celebrate them when we think of facilities it is also important to think of in school library spaces and Staffing as well also in regards to GB 54 want to make sure that we support our soon to be graduating students with the new change regarding mcast and really to look at students more recently who would have graduated that perhaps what kind of support can we give them to finalize that uh and lastly
010many parents here tonight and online look to the school committee to support the superintendent which supports our students and families thank you thank you [Applause] okay so uh we are going on to the next item um okay so we have the repor the superintendent from here to anywhere uh together facilities planning prioritizing implementation Mr Allen Madam superintendent good evening through the chair um happy New Year to everybody happy official New Year in the school World We believe uh start of the school year is the happy New Year um tonight you're going to hear a very thorough presentation on where we are currently in our facilities and the work moving forward next slide please um so I want to introduce our team that has really taken um just just a very heavy lift and moved um
011um a mountain in a very short amount of time Mountain still needs a lot of work but moved it so um first and foremost Deputy superintendent Brian Allen Chief Financial Officer Chief Operating Officer just keep adding commas after his name um our newer but not totally new anymore uh director of facilities uh rich ien and then our newer but not totally new also assistant director of facilities um Ryan hacker this team has just made a huge difference in what was going on in The District in terms of facilities and I'm eternally grateful as as our staff and our students and our families we know there's a whole lot of work to be done burn coats all kinds of schools right but um the responsiveness is uh to be commended so tonight committee you you will
012hear about the current state of the facilities planning prioritization and the implementation of the various initiatives to upgrade our school buildings and you'll get an update on the progress toward goals to date um as they relate to the Strategic plan uh excuse me strategic plan aims and so I'm going to turn it over to Mr Allen to connect it to strategic plan just because it flows nicely that way thank you thank you and through the chair the district's work on facilities is directly tied to the current strategic plan the modernized and safe facilities is one of the six key priorities of the Strategic plan again these key priorities emerg through the initial initially through the feedback from many stakeholders as part of the superintendent's listening and learning to her there are many reasons that this
013is one of the priorities of the Strategic plan mostly due uh to years of underfunding many of the district schools have significant deferred maintenance needs extensive research on school maintenance shows that school condition can positively impact student learning Behavior attendance and achievement tonight's presentation will look at each of the four aims associated with this key priority ensuring that each of our school facilities has the infrastructure to support um Equitable access to 21st century teaching and learning environment the road map for this key priority starts with the districts completing a comprehensive facility assessment and long-term plan increasing funding for maintenance and repair and implementing improved maintenance systems next the district will continue to expand funding for school renovation through current and alternative funding sources and engage and involve community members and stakeholders for support the ending
014goal of this work is for all schools to be adapted to provide flexible learning spaces full technology integration energy efficient or net zero energy consumption with health and well-being focused that is safe and secure with spaces connected to the community inclusive and accessible for all students and staff in using resilient building materials to reinforce the importance facilities improvements are also part of the 2425 goals of the superintendent the goal is to scale and Implement facility improvements to include safety protocols procedures monitoring the allocation of necessary fiscal resources through Equity lens we will show progress in this goal using the four key performance indicators throughout this evening's presentation before we discuss the progress of each aim let's begin with by setting context or a foundation of the current state of facilities the district manages 57 buildings
015consisting of schools and District administrated buildings there are more than 4.6 million interior square fet Within These District buildings there are about 1,700 classrooms in The District in fy2 we are spending $361 per square foot on maintenance safety improvements and capital spending on school buildings you will see in the upcoming slide that this level of spending has significantly increased in the past 3 years in fy2 we are spending $683 per student on school maintenance this is still well below the funding per pupil in the foundation budget formula even with the four-month-old dhy Memorial High School the average age of WPS buildings is currently 77 years old while reviewing the 5-year building plan for the district from 100 years ago many of the buildings still being used today were discussed in this book 26 of the
01657 District owned buildings almost half of the buildings were constructed before 1940 with 11 buildings or nearly one out of every five built in the 1800s the teror building on Main Street is a District's oldest building built in 1842 at 182 years old was built 6 years before Worcester was incorporated as a city 37 years later in 1879 Grafton Street building number one is the district's oldest school building at 145 years old Ruther Rutherford B Hayes was President the day the doors opened at Grafton Street the same year Thomas Edison demonstrated the incandescent light bulb to the public for the first time in 19 years before this building City Hall opened there are 19 buildings in the district that are at least 100 years old due to World War II there were no buildings constructed
017in the 1940s 23 buildings of 42% were constructed between 1950 and 1999 seven buildings Roosevelt the forest grow renovation project was the Technical High School North High Nelson play South High and dhy high were constructed Ed since 2000 let's look at two of these schools excluding Nelson place the next newest Elementary School Roosevelt is now 24 years old when we think of Wester Technical High School as one of our newest high schools this year the school will be in operation for 19 years in 2016 the Massachusetts school building authority The Authority that provides a majority of funding for a new school and uh select accelerated repair projects conducted a second Statewide needs assessments uh from the 2010 survey of every school in the Commonwealth this study consists of design and Engineering professionals sent to each
018school in the state to evaluate several key factors including Building Systems conditions General physical environment and space utilization schools are assessed with a rating of 1 to four with one being a school in best condition within the 2016 assessment more than 1,400 schools or 84% of the schools in the state were either a one or a two meaning they were generally in good condition with few Building Systems that needed attention 245 schools in the state were rated a three which indicated they may need moderate to extensive renovation to address physical deficiencies finally a total of 20 schools across the entire state or 1.2% of the schools were rated a four or in poor condition in Worcester 19 schools or 45 45% of the schools about half of the Statewide percentage were rated one or two
01950% of the district buildings were evaluated rated a three again indicating that they may need more moderate or extensive renovation to address physical deficiencies 9% of all the schools rated a three in the state were in Worcester finally two schools in Worcester of the 20 Statewide were rated a four or in poor condition one of these schools was Dy Memorial High School and and as we know has since been replaced the msba has announced that this study will be conducted again in 2025 we will see how the needs assessment ratings change for our buildings 9 years later in 2017 the district completed a partial facilities master plan the master plan surveyed 28 of the 44 school buildings with only schools built before 1980 being examined of the 28 schools 22 of them were identified as
020needing to be replaced or in need of major renovation the study identified $70 million in Urgent repairs in just those 28 buildings some other current studies and assessments that the district have completed are in the process we are currently working with the federal Head Start program to develop a proposal that could replace all of the district Head Start locations into new or leas spaces and funded by the headst Start program we have the 2023 guidepost school safety audit have begun to address the highest priority recommendations we have a 2022 Honeywell energy infrastructure assessment which identified more than million in HVAC repairs needed we're able to complete about $20 million of upgrades using Esser funds and finally we also completed a modular unit uh survey in 2019 that identified a cost of $7 million to replace
021the existing units all currently about 37 years old plus additional costs that would be needed for current building code upgrades and compliance looking at progress made in each of the four aims of the Strategic plan around modernized safe facilities aim one is to increase spending on facilities better to maintain the schools grounds and District buildings um primarily as a result of increased funding from the student Opportunity Act the district has more than doubled the spending on maintenance of school buildings since fy22 from $4.6 million to $10.7 million this year the district has increased spending on school safety equipment by more than 1,000% from $125,000 in FY 23 to $1.4 million in the FY 24 and FY 25 budgets despite the $22 million deficit in the current year budget spending facilities and school safety was at
022least maintained at last year's spending levels the city has increased the funds for building renovation funds this year from $3.5 million to $4.5 million overall the spending on school maintenance school safety and capital spending has more than doubled from 8.2 to $16.6 million between fy22 due to the current budget year we continue to spend below the foundation budget allocation for operations and maintenance but we continue to close the spending Gap the goal is to continue to make investments in facilities maintenance to close this Gap each year aim two of the Strategic plan of the modernized and safe facilities key priori is to expand identification and prioritization of building renovation and replacement projects to support Future Ready learning uh spaces for students the district's year Capital plan as contained in the district's budget book is our
023roadmap for ID identifying and prioritizing building renovation projects the plan shows how the district leverages city of Wester msba and other available resources to address building renovation projects within the available funds using a portion of the annual building renovation funds from the city the district funds 22% of msba accelerator repair projects Windows roofs and boiler projects since the S of the accelerator repair funding and 2012 the district has completed 39 projects consisting of 22 window projects 10 boiler projects and seven roof projects for a total investment by the msba and city of Wester of $88 million on these projects next year msba will expand accelerated repair funding for the installation of new heat pumps for schools and we anticipate our 5-year Capital plan will reflect access accessing 78% funding from msba for these energy efficient
024methods for heating and cooling of our schools otherwise the remainder of building renovation funds provided to the by to the W public schools by the city has Prim primarily been used such as restroom Renovations flooring Renovations parking lot and walkway repairs masonary repairs intercom and fire alarm repairs and other non- msba HVAC related work the city has also partnered with uh DEC and now msba to fund school replacement projects in the past 18 years the city has repl four high schools and one Elementary School through this partnership the investment in these five schools has been just under $750 million each of these buildings has significant Improvement for learning spaces and Technology as compared uh to the previous slide as we know burnod high is in the next uh the next project in the funding Pipeline
025with the msba will we expect a state-of-the-arts school for the district's Fine Arts programs in new related chapter 74 programs will complete the replacement of all of the city's quadrant high schools and Technical High Schools since 2006 we expect that the new school will remain in the current location and will swap buildings in athletic fields and parking lots on the existing 31 acres of land while the high school is uh the school currently in eligibility study with the msba the city and District continue to work with the msba to include the Middle School in this project while the middle school was not selected in the 2024 SOI process this year we will enter an enrollment study analysis with the msba during the next phase of the high school project the feasibility study to consider both
026a grade 7 through 12 and a 9 through 12 enrollment for the school for a total school size and the basis of construction funding we are finishing the I sorry we are finishing the eligibility period for the new school and expect to be invited into the feasibility phase of the project in April in this phase which um is based on the three prior msba projects we think will take until about 2028 which begins with the selection of a design architect owners project manager determining the grade configuration of the new school documenting the educational program generating an initial space summary document existing condition I establish design parameters develop and evaluate Alternatives and recommend the most costeffective and educationally appropriate preferred solution to the msba board of directors for their consideration during this phase the dish will
027submit a preliminary design program and a preferred schematic report we expect the new school will be open by 2031 during this year the district is reviewing School boundaries and quadrant assignments to look at Street assignments to schools and school assign assignments to feeder middle and high schools we will look at space utilization and program placement for special education preschool and other specialized programs for the best use of existing space into to ensure equity and access to related Services also we will look at the current School tier times to see if any changes would provide programmatic improvements in equity across the district we are also looking uh at school names to make sure that the current names align with actual program offering such as former schools the district is also collaborating with the city Side on
028a comprehensive city-wide facility master plan for all Municipal and school buildings the superintendent and team meet monthly with the city manager and his team to discuss the needs of facilities across the city this Consolidated comprehensive master plan will be the blueprint for future funding discussions with the city for facilities repairs Renovations and Replacements the district expects this master plan to be completed by June 2026 it's expected that the master plan will consider all of the existing studies and assessments to determine a facility condition index to be used to assess the condition of our a building or group of buildings and help formulate future 5year Capital plans through deferred maintenance prioritization the report will also consider enrollment Trends and demographic composition of the student enrollment for an equity lens of future building projects aim three of
029the model modernized and safe facilities key priority is to increase responsiv the repair and maintenance of school grounds and District buildings the district goal is to respond to high priority projects within 72 hours by completion or with an action plan despite many heating challenges this week through the increased funding for facilities maintenance and through improved systems and structures the current year dashboard shows that 100% of high priority projects have both responded to and completed within 42-hour 72-hour window aim for is to expand Future Ready opportunities for students through alignment and partnership with community- based learning resources and spaces the administration is working with several Community Partners to look at Mutual opportunities space needs and requirements and funding requirements we will likely see partnership opportunities in early childhood Community School tutoring wraparound supports adult education and
030Mental Health Services in summary the highlevel next steps involving facil projects will be the in the current year with the launch of the facilities master plan completion of the eligibility phase of burnod high school with mspa in transition to the feasibility study and the completion of the district's space utilization study next year the facilities master plan field work will occur along with the start of an in-depth feasibility study for burnot high and the administration will bring forth the recommendation of the space utilization study finally in FY 27 the implementation of priorities of the facilities master plan continuation of the feasibility study for Burn High and implementation of the space utilization study recommendations much has been accomplished within the facility's maintenance renovation and replacement projects over the past decade with a significant amount of work to
031go Worster is not alone or unique there's reported more than $85 billion annual spending Gap nationally on needed facility maintenance we know that this is a shared local state and National responsibility for adequate funding for school buildings thank you Mr chairman uh great job and uh a lot of investment made into the schools a lot needed so uh look forward to working with the administration of the city uh on with the city manager and the council to make sure that we go forward with this and I think one of the best slides I couldn't really read it Mr alen think maybe passed it out to the council and to the school committee on the Accel repairs 5year Capital plan because you have all the is in there and uh if you maybe send that separately
032to everybody so because it shows that Sally acceler repair program I figured how many schools you said but um was $88 million in the last 12 years the chair that's correct I think this is a great slide I just make sure people understand the investment we made people should realize too back when these schools one of the big issues back then were the PCB time frames when these schools were built not the same with pcbs in the schools but pry much eliminated the windows in most of those schools and with burn being done that'll probably be maybe one or two left in the school district during that time frame or so the chair that will complete all the buildings uh K through2 correct all of them yes K through2 perfect and U know that was
033a big issue several years ago and uh and I want to thank you Mr Allen for working with the msba and thank the msba for really contributing that was $88 million forth to make sure we don't have that issue we probably only one I guess probably one of the own school districts that really handled this and uh so good job and why you here I just mentioned I know we had some heating problems at burco can you just give us an update where we are with that start Richard through the chair uh thank you um this week we've had some challenges at burnco Middle School obviously with um in the h-wing we had an issue with the supply fan being down that was repaired on uh in this week and we also discovered that do
034with some additional work outside the scope of that um that needs to be completed which is being done right now um in the meantime I brought in a or the department brought in a heating trailer to provide heat to the to that wing and that is uh went into place this morning and has been uh functioning all afternoon okay so this weekend we should be caught up and hopefully yeah thank you I appreciate it they'll appreciate it so uh thank you any questions M being carer thank you very much for the report um I do want to add that a good page here was um how much we're putting into safety so we we've increased that dollar amount a great deal which I think is terrific so I certainly agree with you mayor on uh
035your page but I also would like to say U that uh it's good to see that safety and facilities are uh weaving together and the dollars are being spent in the right Direction um thank you for the update on the um repair system for Bronco School certainly appreciate appreciate that I did not hear of any other issues were there any other issues with the exception of the burn coat issue overheating systems uh through the chair yes there has been a number of issues uh due to the the severe cold weather we had issues at clock Street tatnic mag burncoat and that's those are the sign significant ones we those those the significant ones okay and how do the other two schools look you talked about burn coat the other two you feel as though will
036fall into place through the chair what you're doing repairs have been made I'm sorry repairs have been made in all the buildings now excellent you know that goes quickly and of course being New England we have to be concerned with not only cooling but the with the um Heating and am I correct in hearing that burnart high school was accepted but the Middle School hasn't been how how is that going to work Mr Allen so through the chair so we had a uh prelimary meeting with msba um just before the holiday break um and so we're going to enter into an enrollment study with msba to consider both a 7 through 12 and a 9 through 12 configuration so as part of our burn code High application we had identified a grade reconfiguration to include
037seventh and eighth grade so just because the SOI was not accepted um doesn't really impact our project or our plans with planning with the msba all of that the actual grade configuration will be determined during the feasibility phase of the school it will be determined by the city with msba support of either a 7 through 12 school or 9 through 12 school based on the work that we'll do collectively as part of Fe ility study in the time frame for that through through the chair through the chair so we will enter um feasibility uh study we expect to be invited to enter feasibility at the April msba board meeting um and then instead of going into a design study right away we'll go into that enrollment study the time frame of that decision we don't
038know yet um we'll work with the msba on that determination would that be under consideration for 2026 so you would would be looking at 2027 when the decision would be made or would it be this year again we'll have to get clarification from msba as we enter the feasibility study phase however enrollment is a driving force of the funding of the schools so we will need to identify the grade configuration of the school in order to then determine funding and how steps that are included the enrollment size is the most important part to determine the funding for the school okay if you could I'd make a motion that we we're kept up to date as a school committee on when the meetings occur um so we are then able to have discussions in the city
039when when necessary and be prepared for that um and then um as we look towards our future with our school buildings and so on um I know that we look at our buildings and even in my district there there are a number out of the six there are a few that are definitely old um but the um old does not mean that they're not presentable they're not workable uh they're not appealing and they don't get the job done so we certainly want to bring that up also that we may have older buildings uh but they are serving us well at this point with our students and our staff so thank you very much thank you um member mail thank you um thank you Vanessa um City versus school um through the chair this you the
040two different reports I'm thinking about the redistricting as one and then what are we call in the report with the city the facility master plan facility master plan so what is the how many buildings do they have versus or square feet or how do you look at is it a 6040 70 I gotta believe it's 7030 I don't know does any do we know what that difference is the chair so I'm not entirely sure which of their buildings yet they're actually including in the master plan I'm not sure if they're doing fire stations or not so we'll have to get back to you on what is included on the city Side we really been focused on the piece for the School site so if we're looking at the enrollment numbers and the population numbers through
041the chair how and when do we expect to have that report complete through the chair which one I'm sorry I don't know what you're calling it The redistricting enrollment the one with enrollment the numbers for Mr for the so we're we're doing the analysis this spring with the expectation to bring that to the school committee in the fall of this year for public discussion um consideration and then implementation for the following year am I recalling that that's a little bit of a slide had we hoped to see something at the end in the springtime no the chair um no I think think we had anticipated um working with schools this spring and bringing a recommendation to the school committee okay this summer or fall so then next C school calendar year through the chair you'll
042be working in conjunction with the city to determine priorities no through the chair that would really be the school committee let let's say we're talking about changing School boundaries yes we want to give families as much notice as possible right that full school year right so we can implement the changes for the FY 27 school year but doesn't that mean you're going to have to have some of those um facility decisions made beforehand I I through the chair so since we've identified so since burn coat is going to take until 2031 y we don't we know we've I assume the vote will continue that wi SM is the next replacement School y if we're talking primarily around elementary schools it will be several years years before there might be new schools as part of uh
043new construction for elementary schools so the changes we will recommend um can be implemented because you will not probably see an elementary school um until after burn code and after wh smle are constructed and through the chair did the date did 20 was 2031 always the date through the chair it's it it's been the date we've estimated all along only based on the prior experience particularly around dhy and South High that is not a fixed date we'll know once we get into feasibility get into the preferred design go through the process we'll get a better date that's just a placeholder based on experience with South andori I think that in one of the slides the um through the chair the um it was $680 per student that we spend but we're under Foundation do you
044know what the foundation number is it's about 1,200 per student okay that's that's absurd that's huge and in any of the things that are being discussed through the chair at the state level is nothing is this item doesn't get looked at separately or does it so the chair so it's part of the foundation budget formula so if there's um proposal which I've seen I think both uh Senate President and the house Speaker have indicated they are receptive to reopening the foundation budget formula discussion that's where would be part of okay and I would imagine our state is probably in as many would be in agreement that this is a number they'd like this is a portion of the foundation budget that they would like to see increased is that fair through the chair I I
045would say likely but as you saw in the 2016 data schools across the Commonwealth are in much better condition in whole than the Worcester schools are okay it was opposite all right I thought I heard you that's interesting so that'll be another fight then through the 84% of the school buildings in 2016 across the state were in the best two categories okay um through the chair the the head building this is because I don't recall that we've talked about this in the past few years so that is a federal decision can you help us so we were made of a potential funding opportunity from the federal Head Start um to look at improving their spaces so they are currently in three locations Milbury Street Greendale and mil Swan we're actually working with them on a
046proposal this is still just in the very early stages of a proposal to see if Federal Head Start would fund either a new location new construction or new location through like lease space which federal Head Start would um pay for and so we're looking to consolidate the Head Start programs into one location yep to be funded entirely by federal Head Start can anybody through the chair maybe to the superintenden see a world where Head Start and Universal prek might come together in some way mam superintendent through the chair that's actually a lot of the conversation we keep having why do we keep them in these separate Arenas how do we make them come together and a big part of it right now is um in space so having this opportunity kind of can open up
047we can dream programmatically um but then we don't have location for them to be so in the long long term that would be ideal for for our families and for our our youngest Scholars that's exciting okay thank you um I think that's it thanks thank you robbert Johnson thank you to the chair thank you for this um report um actually I really appreciate it I just have um a couple questions and I think I might have a motion here um just in regards to um the schools I remember all you know during covid we couldn't go back HV you know HVAC you know not healthy um and I know they put the air purifi are those still currently in all the schools that don't have upgraded HV Mr to the chair um yes I'll let
048uh Mr ien and U maybe expand on that answer Mr Ian through the chair uh we do have these units still in place they are being utilized and and AD Park kind of situation as they seem fit um they are not they are in the buildings but they are not always utilized in fully throughout the buildings um but we are maintaining them okay and the plan would be to keep them there in case it's Ever Needed moving forward is that correct through the chair through the chair absolutely okay thank you um and I was um I went to go visit a school the other day Gates lane and then just hearing about um I think it's Roosevelt is it Nelson and talking to the superintendent yesterday and and looking at some of their program in
049there where they have the sale program um and I actually had a little bit of a concern um in regards to um some of those students are in your what you consider your regular classroom right uh hard floors you know they don't have the the the equipment and stuff in order to keep those kids safe and some of those kids are in different tiered level rooms where they need added support so I'm just wondering and I I think I'm going to do this in a motion um a motion to kind of take a look at the sale program throughout the district and find a way to try to make some of those rooms more um convenient I guess um for those students more appropriate um for the students that we're dealing with in the seale
050program so I make that in a motion um Mr um Mr Mayor um other than that uh again um thanks for the report appreciate the work that's being done done throughout the district okay thank you madam uh member being Benda yes thank you uh thank you uh for the report I was wondering on that that msba study that we all have to meet with some consultant that they hired I have mine tomorrow but is that going to be the new study that is replacing the old one that was done Mr Allen yes so msba did a study in 2010 2016 and then 2025 will be the next update to that so that's the information that you would use for that okay great it it's asks a lot of questions and surprising I thought that the
051msba would have some of that information already documented especially for new schools but you have to go through it all over again with them my next question is um the money like I looked at the 150,000 that we used to get for safety and we used to have to fight to for the school committee to get that 150,000 so um I I like that it's increased and I'm just wondering where are we going to get the money you know from now forward to be able to fund everything that's on the sheet Mr Allen through the chair so specifically if we talk about increasing in facilities and safety as I said in my earlier comments it's really attributed to the increase of SOA dollars that allowed us to increase both of those accounts we have two
052more years of s SOA funding and then we will revert back to the traditional inflation and enrollment adjustments in the foundation budget however the base is now set at that higher level so as long as the foundation budget can sustain what we are spending then the the level of spending for facilities and school safety should remain at what we're spending in today's dollars or what we increase it in FY 26 and FY 27 and going forward through the chair in addition budgeting is always about priorities so if if it's a priority for safety and maintenance of our facilities in the school district which in this current Administration it is then we bring those recommendations forward to the school committee in the budgeting process so that's how this additional money has has been in place is
053that it's a priority for this Administration um through the the chair I agree with that but when there isn't enough money to fund positions uh sometimes uh what's most important is that the students have a te in front of them and you have to work around the building repairs as best as best you can um thank you very much thank you well thank you so much for the support I really do appreciate the survey data as you my colle showing 8% of the rest of the state schools being that category under two as where we're at 45% two categories uh so we all understand that this is Old City with old buildings and I appreciate the fact that we continue to invest in our facilities especially in the safety of our schools with that 1.6
054million which is so uh dly needed in in the city of wi um some of my concerns that I have is just maybe just a the chair the administration are especially in my district they really stem from the neighborhood elementary schools uh they seem to be the last on the list so how are we addressing this going forward as we continue to invest money into the high schools which is obviously a priority and then into the middle school but the neighborhood elementary schools are really uh in some sort of fashion where they're going to be probably in that three or four category uh what are what are the plans there to make sure that while we're doing the other projects we continue to address some of the element thank you Mr alen to the chair
055so that is either where we would be leveraging msba accelerated repair dollars to do R spoilers um in Windows although we I think we've done most of the window projects that we're going to qualify for um and then using the rest of the city dollars or leveraging other sources to support other needs of those schools so while a big amount of dollars are being supported by the city and the state to to build the new schools we we're essentially leveraging the rest of the dollars available to support schools like you mentioned good I appreciate that again obviously uh neighborhood elementary schools such and obviously as you started your presentation that you know school facilities are you know big hand in hand with success of students and at that age it's so important to make sure
056that we have good facilities for them as well as that this is really where they start to begin to become other formative years for them to become successful so uh I want to thank you again for the report I think it was very uh informational and I continue to support all the things that you're doing and hopefully we can continue to move forward with you know this includ thank you what that member Rory hi good evening um first of all thank you for the presentation it was was wonderful um going through the list of um the proposals for next year um under doors and hardware it's it's listed at $250,000 which seems a little high do we know exact and I know it's part of the safety plan and it has to get done do
057you know exactly how many doors need to be replaced Mr alen through the chair I don't have the exact inventory uh with us we certainly can um include that as part of any facilities updates uh that we're doing in our quarterly reports thank you very much have a good night okay um all set so we have a couple motions one from um M being carrier another from Member Johnson motion was approve all those in favor oppose so AUD and for this report the motion is to approve just want Mr Al just want to thank you for the report um and the Investments that we've done here in the city so uh motion approved all those in favor post supported okay Mr I did have one quick question for I just when you said like the
05884% the school districts were better than us or I forget what the exact stat is what is that including the urban school systems like if we just the comparison of the urban school systems where would the city it wish to be you think so that was a aggregate of all schools in the entire State now but also that was 9 years ago so yeah what we could do is wait for the 2025 study to be completed and see where we stack in relation to the state and uh other the Gateway cities okay thank you okay we have report of stand committee on fog any so we just got motion to approve these items motion to approve collectively the uh several items here roll call member Alvarez yes member banario yes member Benda yes member Guardiola
059yes Vice chair Johnson yes member mailman yes member Mulla member Roy yes mayor Petty yes we're on N to consider the acceptance of the Desi um multi multilingual newcomer and home homeless support Grant in amount of $100,000 roll call member Alvarez yes member banaria yes member Banda yes member Guardiola yes Vice chair Johnson yes member mailman yes member McCulla member Roy yes mayor Petty yes to approve a list of schools and grade levels um for the pocket teachers and to discuss the funding for additional staff if needed make member Banda I wonder if we could um hold on this item until we discuss what's going to happen with the 7.1 million I'm just wondering if there is a need for more teachers at some schools I know we all received letters from University Park Campus
060uh regarding the removal of their assistant principle and um one of the messages that they did State there is that you know they felt like they needed a a mail that was not a teaching staff that could help support some of the students that are there that so just wondering if this there's any money left in the pocket for uh University pack campus so they can get that support they need for the students that they say really need it and they are shot a Personnel Mr oider has gone to the Crea Center so I wonder if we can hold that until we get to the 7.1 million how we're going to do that's coming up in a few minutes you want to do them together the reports yeah can that move down to that one
061when we do that report just do them right now what's what number is it yeah what's the number do it now yeah what's the number of the report 55 okay to make the adjustments to the fiscal year 25 budget to ref an increase of $7.6 million okay that's up anybody want to discuss that that one I through the chair um I I want to discuss it and tag on to member Johnson um I too have uh received a a lot of phone calls uh from some of the people at Gates Lane and uh their feeling is that there's not enough bcbas there to support the students that they have so that's another I know we let a lot of bcbas go um I do think they they the students that they have there are unique
062uh they do deserve to have that extra support so I I would like to see um maybe two bcbas added to that and again uh somebody to help a non-teaching position over at upcs um to help with those students that are really experiencing stress and I I don't know if we can say that it would be nice if we had uh um uh they seem to say that they needed a mail there because the the student students that were experiencing difficulty um really needed a male figure in their life okay member Johnson yes thank you through the chair to um Administration I just have a question regarding um and I'm I'm on the five five um number one um instructional materials um the purchase of Elementary science in secondary math textbooks that $3.4 million um
063just it's is that like something that's current like truly needed now and and is that like for like years to come like that will sustain us for I don't know three years five years whatever it may be so the chair's shorter answer is yes we either need to fund it now or in the FY 26 budget we figured since this is onetime money we can make an investment now and then not have to deal with it in the FY 26 and it's a six-year commitment for that textbook perfect that makes sense thank you um can just explain the what what are the virtual Tut tutoring services for the elementary students I think that was was that something we talked about before that we actually had to cut did we have to cut that out of
064the budget um last year this past fiscal year as well I can't remember I'm sorry can you repeat the question the the tutoral tutorial Services what number tutoring Services it's number two number two yep what's the question I'm wondering what what those services are through the chair so there are some um so this would be new it would be a new service um there are some new programs available through AI believe it or not that are yeah that are available online that we'd like to look at um we've been monitoring it that would be specifically for elementary children and and then this the additional would be for um some social emotional counseling that we've already had in place for the secondary and what would the tutor and service be um identifying what what would it
065be the conton area uh language arts and math perfect thank you um overall I I I think um this is great you know of course I'm happy to see the increase of um the per per pupil instructional supply stuff um I think that's great um I also think that the building Subs are great because again I was just out at some schools this past week and they talked about the need for the building Subs that how impactful um that was for them and um I did tell them to look at at the agenda that that was coming back so I believe everyone throughout the district hopefully will'll be happy um with that um as well um I would also agree with member Benda um in regards to the bcbas um you know they did talk
066about that we did talk about the financial um implications of that um I just don't think that's something that we could potentially do with this current money that we have here but again I know in talking with the superintendent um regarding that um we know that's important that's something that we need to look look at for bringing back some of those um supports for our students next year um so again um I'm in support of um the recommendations for this money thank you okay remember B I mean being carrier thank you I've had an opportunity to briefly speak with Mr Allen in reference 278 and nine and I certainly would appreciate um that discussion to be uh public uh the transportation pieces we've talked about it several times in the fact that we had additional
067funds and we were able to put those funds back into transportation and hopes that we wouldn't uh be looking at additional monies going into Transportation because it was holding its own however we're looking at 789 uh which is 50,50 and then 155 so um that's two that's three another 350 going in if we could have a little explanation on that Mr Allen I would truly appreciate it because it's been a neighborhood discussion um so your Insight on this would be appreciated Mr Allen certainly uh through the chair so for uh line seven uh that was a position that we intentionally froze to balance the FY um 25 uh budget we are now in a position where we're taking over a majority of 70 uh Transportation we're ramping up to have our 40 routs in place
068by the end of the year um and the recommendation is to reinstate the Frozen position in order so we can properly manage not only our own 7D but contracted 7D Services uh for the oversight of the program and finances associated with the significant amount of money for outter District special ed mckin vento Transportation I'm going to skip one for a second just uh answer nine next so nine is uh the ability for us to provide a um an after school or a late bus for every secondary school for the remainder of the school year there's a petition from Sullivan middle in finance operations um to provide this late bus and so this is a service we did provide through Esser funds but had to cut because of the FY 25 budget deficit this year so
069if this were to be approved this would provide a light bus for every middle and high school 3 days per week um from now through the end of the school year so that's line nine line eight is uh connected to the re uh anticipated receipt uh for next school year of 20 uh essentially free electric school buses which will allow us to expand transportation services so this is going beyond the level of services that we're providing now now this would allow us to add 15 more school bus routes to support student transportation next year that would do a number of things um first it would provide some additional athletic Transportation uh needs but most importantly um we are looking at the I'm just cautious on saying this because I don't want to necessarily commit to
070this right now we are looking at reducing the walk radius for middle schools from 2 mil to 1.5 miles with additional routs and I don't have a number on this yet cuz we're still evaluating reducing the walk radius for high schools from 2 miles to something less than two miles so by adding because we're getting 20 electric uh school buses for free we can go from 101 big bus routes that we're providing this year which was full Staffing to go up um to 116 Big Bus routs next year maybe looking at some tier time adjustments and again allowing with those buses some tier time adjustments reducing the walk radius for students so we're looking at um that part of it affecting not 25 but it would it would take effect in 20 26 27 through
071the am I correct on that no through the chair this would this the plan would be to have these drivers in vehicles available for next school year 26 27 25 26 25 26 okay okay so as we look at um that piece of it um do those electric buses will be coming and we have a time frame of because I know I was at the celebration to say we were delighted we would be getting these but we weren't sure of a time frame so do we have a time frame narrowed down at this point Mr through the chair So the plan is to receive the vehicles for next school year we do know that they are not even being constructed until April so um but in order to be prepared this funding will allow us
072to onboard in train drivers it takes many months as we learned um over the last three years to get driver enough drivers in place uh to be available So the plan is to use these dollars to begin hiring bus drivers so we do receive the electric uh school buses we can then expand the number of uh routes from 101 to 116 big buses I'd be thrilled if we could then change our walk radius to the 1.5 I think that would certainly be a beneficial to many families and many students um I do make a motion that we kept up to date on when the arrival of the electric buses will be occurring so then we we would know exactly what we need to do and how we need to do it because we're going to
073be looking at additional Roots which I think is terrific so I look forward to that thank you very much thank you member Benda uh through the chair um also um we had received a report um regarding the alternative school wer alternative school and they still have not received a place to have gym classes and it in in our memo maybe I think it was from the superintendent they were going to look at the cost of that in place to have that happen so I'm wondering if that money should be included in this too because um there is a need there for them to have it's suppos first of all it's a state law it's supposed to be having fizzed and uh what they're having is in fizzed so I'm just wondering about where you have
074this money now and that's such an important thing if we also add that there so I understand um Mr Allen's you know request to hire these people early but we have needs right now that I think should be a priority talking about bus drivers before we need them I know we have to train them but to me we have needs in our school right now that we need to fill and we didn't have the money to do it so I'm wondering if there's some way we can hire the bus drivers a little later still squeeze some money out so that we can take care um some of the other current needs um that we do have have and I don't know um am I right Mr Allen that the with the bus driver with the
075buses coming the electric buses uh we have to still pay for was around 250,000 for the for them to be plugged in or H how are we doing that with the bus electric buses Mr Owen the chair so can you just restate the I'm not sure I understood the question oh is there an additional cost for the electric buses as far as um there to plug them in is that so through the instead of paying for gas we'll be paying for electricity yes so we we'll be paying for the electricity but how about the plugs themselves the charging stations we are anticipating those to be funded through the mass CC Grant oh okay so it's not going to cost us anything for that great thank you m that everybody so the motion is to approve
076roll call member Alvarez what's that yes member being carer yes member Banda yes member Guardiola yes Vice chair Johnson yes member mailman yes member Mulla member Roy yes mayor Petty yes let's see we left off okay so 4- 94 motions to file those in favor OPP post so ordered we are on 5-1 to authorize additional expansions to continue Legal Services related to work uh visas for two existing employees up to $4,495 recommendations to approve and to file roll call member Alvarez yes member B carer yes member Benda yes member Guardiola yes Vice chair Johnson yes member mailman yes member Mulla member Roy yes mayor Petty yes interview during the budget monies that are set aside for equipment and uniforms for Middle School sports member McCulla member Johnson yes thank you Mr Mayor on on can
077we take these two together so I can sure to EXP expanding Middle School sports with high demand into the seventh eighth grade teams or they give more students the opportunity to participate thank you so member MV had left me um just a little write up um on why she had these petitions put on these items put on the first one as Middle School sports continue to expand I want to ensure that as available budgetary funds are set aside for equipment and uniforms to adequately support our middle school students in an event of budgetary constraints that Community Partners are leveraged to support these athletes and then the second item um member mlla um said with increasing interest in participation in athletics at the middle school level to explore providing both seventh and eighth grade teams for
078sports that have higher interests during my time on the committee I have consistently advocated for the expansion of our Middle School sports programs and it would it has been great to see the expansion that has taken place over the last several years Middle School sports plays a vital role in fostering personal development teamwork and a sense of community among the students by providing opportunities for middle schoolers to participate in sports and schools help instill valuable life skills additionally Sports offer students a healthy outlet for energy promote physical fitness contribute to to improve mental health ensuring a access to these programs can make a significant difference in students academic performance and social connections and overall well-being Paving the way for the future success athletically academically and socially thank you so that looking for that to go
079to fog I believe y both of those items yep member Roy thank you I I'm completely behind this 100% as member Johnson spoke about um Sports brings about uh feeling of Team togetherness how to work well with others um it does help in so many ways to um let the kids blow off some steam let them um work together with a goal um discipline is involved in team sports and I really hope that we can get this over to fog discuss it and move it along thank you M member mailman thank you um I won't ask for a friendly Amendment because the the person's not there but when I read this item and I thought about you know putting out our you know our hopes for the next budget and what we want to think
080about I am stuck in a big way on the after school programs in elementary schools and so I would like to make a ition that we also the sports programs are extracurricular programs I'm in favor they're great of course we want as much as we can get but I am really concerned that in the elementary schools we're jumping over each other and each of the principles and trying to make something happen in these schools so that we can get some after school programming back in our schools and so I even thought it does it make any sense um you know that we think about programs for elementary on a quadrant basis um I think Community Schools got brought up in um Mr Allen's presentation at one point and I so I would like to make
081the motion on top of this that we actually look at um increasing adding dollars making sure we start to um on an equity basis take a look at what we're doing with after school programs for the elementary school kids thank you anybody else so we will uh refer these two remember being carer yes um I'm certainly concerned with the elementary school and the middle schools I think it's great that we're talking about Middle School sports we have for a number of years and they're finally building wer middle is doing great it's in my district um but I cannot look at the motion that was just brought to the floor uh by my colleague to the fact that we need to have specifics we cannot just put a broad brush for the superintendent to then look
082at this and say come up with something I think we need to indulge a little and um have specific programs that have worked in the past been beneficial to our students in the elementary school for the after school programs because it's absolutely necessary that we build on that um but as we build on that we also have to be careful F of what bricks we use thank you thank you so we have the two these two items go the fog motion by member mailman along with I guess being car's motion to amend that a little bit and uh collectively and uh we'll send that to the administration we take those C all three of them the fog or yeah you could okay all three the fog okay okay all those in favor oppos so a
083okay okay next item to receive a report outlining the plan for our graduating seniors that have not yet passed the mcast please include how many students we need to assist with their competency determination if our local graduation requirements take care of the competency determinations uh we're going to refer that to the administration member mailman just a quick comment as I was um talking to member gadola before the meeting and we were talking about that this impacts this Year's students um it also impacts students I think that if I I watched the state meeting which was painful but um I think it also impacts those that have graduated in Prior years that didn't um graduate so those would need to I would like to see those included as well and I didn't know if the superintendent
084could through the chair um provide an update like right now about what we do know since this is a timely item through the chair happy to provide um some of the information we are actually meeting with High School principles next Tuesday Morning we've been asking them to gather the information on their existing students that are seniors to make sure that we know they know exactly who those students are um and so Tuesday we'll have the actual numbers but we're it's looking at a it's appearing to be a very small number of students one of our comp of high schools it's two students for example so it's looking like a small number um and because Worcester has um used the um Mass core as our graduation requirements our children are in a really good place so
085the competency determination um will not be a problem it really tends to be for students who are coming in from out of District maybe coming in as a a senior those are the ones that that it they're kind of coming up so we plan on bringing um revised policy for the committee to consider at the first uh February committee meeting um and in that we'll have the numbers as well thank you okay so the motion here is to is for the um member berand yes um through the through the chair um I was wondering uh who was on this webinar um when the when uh desie um did present it on December 17th from the district mam superintendent through the chair there were a variety of members sitting in one room listening to the webinar
086perfect because this is much more complicated than the slides that are are here these were the slides that were um presented but what it's much more complicated than this what what it says is that um you have to look at the so even the slide that they provided here I I I don't know why they listed you know uh 10th graders in the areas of math science technology history social science uh foreign language in English because it was very clear in the webinar uh What uh he said is that um we have the the seniors that we have right now that have not passed the mcast have to prove competency in only three subjects which were the subjects offered in 20203 spring in English Math and Science and there are only certain you know English
087is of course English but as far as science goes only the science subjects that were tested in the spring of 23 and as far as math goes it you know it's your um algebra algebra 2 and your geometry so then we have to decide the courses so we're looking back on kids that did not pass our 12th graders we have to come up with a plan I'll just reception up with the plant it's not the com it's not the Common Core it's how did are we going to prove that these kids that did not pass met the standards from English Math and Science in the 2023 mcast so it it's a separate document that we all have to figure out the challenge I think in it is that many years ago we were told that
088if we had say we had special ed English who called it special ed English one special at English 2 we were then told that no we can't do that anymore it's English one English 2 English three English for so in setting up the document that we have to do we have to be very clear as to how we're certifying the competency the state is certifying nothing the law took certification of Competency away from the state and so the EPS that kids did all of that is gonna is now on the school committee in the district to decide how they're going to certify that kids have met the competencies just English math and science so the challenge I think is let's talk about life skills students for example if we say that we're going to certify
089anyone that took English one you know algebra one because sometimes we called it that also for life skill students we then would those students would then be able to be certified to say they can get a high school diploma so it it's kind this whole thing with that law being passed and this this competency determination is is really it's a challenge so I'm looking forward to seeing how the district is going to produce that document that is very clear as to how we the school committee are going to certify students that did not pass the mcast in the class uh this class coming out 2025 in those areas thank you okay thank you so f that to the administration those in favor opposed 55-5 we did but going to uh ask for reconsideration so the
090first vote we suspend the rules to ask for reconsideration and uh roll call member Alvarez yes yes this is a this is the first part of the two-part question so the first is the suspend the rules no other reconsideration yeah you have to suspend the rules first then we can reconsider it so the first motion is to re is to suspend the rules roll call member Alvarez so yes member ban carer yes member Banda yes member Guardiola yes Vice chair Johnson yes member mailman yes member Mulla member Roy yes mayor Petty yes the next motion is for reconsideration roll call member Alvarez no member bian carer no member Benda no member Guardiola no Vice chair Johnson no member mailman no member McCulla member Roy no mayor Petty no thank you next is a provide a
091report that includes a description and process of the safety van visiting our schools as well as the opt out option number being carrier I look forward to the discussion once we receive the report from Administration so we can get into further detail thank you thank you further Administration all those in favor oppos to ordered announcements do we have adjournment motion is to adjourn those in favor oppos so order thank you for