CorpusRecord 198296

Board of Education Redistricting Workshop, Phase II, January 27, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Anne Arundel County Public Schools
Date
2025-01-28
Location
Anne Arundel County, MD
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,402 words · about 36 min
Collected
2026-06-26

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] uh welcome to this Workshop of the Board of Education van County tonight the board will hear information related to the second phase of comprehensive redistricting phase two of the redistricting process covers the Anapolis Arundle Broadneck cofton svera Park South River and Southern clusters information on the redistricting timeline will be available at www.aacps.org phase2 redistricting beginning at the conclusion of the workshop while this Workshop is open to the public no public comment or testimony will be taken tonight's Workshop is being broadcast live on aacps TV which can be found on channel 96 on Comcast and Broad straight and channel 36 on Verizon High Definition broadcast can be seen on channel 996 on Comcast channel 496 on Broad stripe and channel 1961 on Verizon it is also being streamed live on AAC cps's YouTube YouTube channel

002so thank you for joining us Dr badell thank you Mr President uh good evening to everybody who's here today board members community members and some of our staff members who are here to uh participate and present uh this is probably the one of the top two least enjoyable parts of my job between calling weather days and having a redistrict I will tell you they both are very difficult cause to make but I think it's important that everybody in here understand that when I came on board in 2022 one of the charges from the school board was that we needed to undertake comprehensive redistricting several reasons for that is uh the growth in this school district and the fact that we've had to build new schools which a policy requires us to have to redistrict um

003but what I've also shared with people when we went through phase one is this is really a good problem it's not a comfortable problem uh it doesn't feel good that we have to do this but I know a number of school districts that are having a redistrict because they're closing schools because their enrollments are declining we are not in that situation in anoro County uh and so it does require that we have to take full advantage of the open seats that we have as we continue to grow and today you all will have an opportunity to hear from both Bill Heiser and Kyle rof around the process that would be very similar to what we did in phase one we recognize that we have new school board members here who weren't a part of that

004process as voting members we wanted to make sure that we are thoroughly taking you all through the process that we did in Phase One um and so at this point I will pass it over to Bill uh for you and Kyle to take us through this presentation good evening everyone thank you Dr badell president silkworth vice president dent and members of the board of education for the record I'm Chief Operating Officer Bill Heiser and I'm joined here with Kyle rof the director of facilities we're going to be com covering three topics for tonight's redistricting Workshop we want to give the board and Community an overview of the planning design and construction process talk briefly about redistricting policy and procedures which guide our efforts and finally wrap up with our redistricting plan and timeline and so

005at this time I'll hand it over to Kyle roof to walk through the planning design and construction process so there are several acronyms used to describe various components in the planning and design process I'll pause briefly so that you can all review them on the screen so our Capital planning process is Guided by three primary documents the long range study the educational facilities master plan and the comprehensive maintenance plan collectively steer our Capital planning process each document plays a role in ensuring that our capital projects are well prioritized our facilities are adequately prepared for future demands and our existing infrastructure is properly maintained the long range study published in 2005 and updated again in 2015 prioritizes major capital projects over 10 years we aim to complete the next revision by this fall this study guides

006long-term capital Investments and aligns them with our goals updated annually the educational facilities master plan or efmp addresses capacity and enrollment planning presented yearly to the board of educ ation it analyzes enrollment Trends and outlines necessary infrastructure to meet the educational demands the comprehensive maintenance plan or CMP also updated annually and presented to the board details our Capital renewal program it ensures longevity and Optimum performance of our assets helping us manage resources efficiently and to maintain op operational integrity as part of the planning process we review enrollment Trends our county is growing and we expect to add 5,000 students over the next decade enrollment was 79,000 in 2014 and is projected to reach 91,000 by 2033 an increase of 12,000 students in years aacps has several schools with available capacity as previously noted the efmp

007outlines annualized capacity and enrollment projections the information presented reflects actual enrollments from from September 30th 2024 and projected enrollments as of September 30th for the school years 2028 and 2033 available seats and U utilization are key indicators reviewed before initiating a capital project or redistricting effort as shown on the screen there are 14, 581 available seats districtwide in 2024 with a projection of 9,21 by 2033 utilization bans determine the extent of school occupancy categorizing schools over 110% utilization as inadequate and those below 75% as inefficient districtwide utilizations are expected to fall within those bands by 2033 the note at the bottom of the screen is significant portable classrooms are not included in these numbers and provide additional capacity currently there are 160 Portables deployed with 92 located at elementary schools to put this in perspective

008an elementary school classroom provides a state rated capacity of 23 seats the 160 Portables deployed can provide up to 3600 additional seats projected utilizations at schools vary throughout the county schools expected to exceed 100% of the state rated capacity in 2033 are shown in red while the green shading indicates schools that remain at or below 100% it's important to note that this chart does not account for existing portable classrooms that provide that additional capacity previously mentioned according to the County's 2040 plan an annual efms growth areas are primarily located in the northern and western portions of the county where development has continued steadily other areas of the county have more limited development due to due to zoning regulations such as those near the bay the availability of seats and enrollment directly impact the capital Improvement

009program this influence includes updating the long-range study to understand revised catchment areas and school capacities major Capital funding requests depend on enrollment at both the school Under Construction and those adjacent if neighboring schools have excess capacity funding decreases proportionally Capital renewal schedules depend on the system age and condition for instance an HVAC project in a building scheduled to be replaced within five years would be scaled back to conserve those Resources Staffing allocations require sufficient space without it adding Personnel is a challenge to expand prek in elementary schools sufficient educational space is necessary instead of spending more Capital we can reallocate seats through redistricting annually updated enrollment projections based on catchment areas are affected by redistricting we monitor annual enrollment projections to determine the need or ability to add capacity when a building's life cycle limits

010expansion especially with high projected enrollments we collaborate with our County Partners to secure future School sites or replacement sites this process is inefficient without a clear understanding of redrawn catchment areas I'd like to transition now to talk about the guiding laws regulations and procedures that outline redistricting section 4109 of the education article allows leas to set Geographic School boundaries in an County Public Schools policy Jaa and its regulation guide the redistricting process why do we redistrict there are five main reasons to redistrict First enrollment patterns we currently have over 14,000 available seats and project to have 9,000 by 2033 second programmatic changes driven by blueprint necessitate reallocating space within buildings third balancing enrollments through redistricting helps optimize future funding and fourth both the state and County are less likely to fund Renovations or new buildings

011when there are empty seats available in the district lastly redistricting enhances our case for future Capital funding for building additions Replacements and alterations here's a quick recap on phase two of the redistricting process in June 2024 we advertised for redistricting consultant which the board approved in July of 2024 from July to December the consultant developed three risting scenarios and the interactive web tool today we are outlining the phase two plan and timeline phase one of the comprehensive redistricting plan was implemented in August 2024 with the affected School clusters marked in Blue on the left side of the screen phase two aims to better balance enrollments at schools within the Annapolis Arundle Broadneck cofton sna Park South River and Southern clusters the recommendation is to implement phase two during the 2026 2027 school year the process

012for determining phase two r districting runs from February to November 2025 an interactive web tool with scenarios for Community feedback will be available from February 1st to the end of April staff will consider feedback and make recommendations to Dr Bedell in June including updated enrollment projections in the 2025 efmp the superintendent will present his recommendations to the board in July initiating the Jaa process the board will select options for public hearings in August and the vote on them in in November the timeline this timeline allows enough time to inform students and families and plan for a smooth implementation three scenarios will be available on the web tool users can switch between the redistricting scenarios and compare them to current boundaries similar that we that we did last last time in Phase One the scenarios were

013developed and evaluated using metrics such as utilization distance to school you see in the center and assignment stability each scenario adjusts lines to balance enrollments the public is encouraged to visit the website and use the interactive tool to provide feedback on the scenarios this input will be valuable in developing the superintendent recommendations the comment section will be live from February 1 to May 1 for more details please visit the website shown on the screen www.acps.org redistricting as a reminder of how important this is during phase one our engagement was 33,000 uni unique website users 86,000 website page views this is for phase one 15,000 unique address searches 2200 survey responses that we took into account and took seriously and 461 map comments when they reviewed that tool so once again that will go live on

014February 1st and it's important to get the community and everyone's input through that process next we'd be happy to answer any questions that you may have at this time and thank you for listening thank you so much so we are going to be going in roll call order this evening ladies and gentlemen so first of all we're going to start off with Miss McFarland I don't have any questions just a comment if that's okay um I just want to thank you for this um redistricting is never going to be easy um there's always going to be a lot of people upset over their child moving and things like that um but I can be assured knowing that everyone in this room car us about our kids and then we're do the very best we can

015for them so thank you okay um Miss Dent so thank you all for getting us started it's this time again to where redistricting is at the Forefront and unlike U Dr Bell I don't lose any sleep at night about redistricting because I know that everybody out in the community knows that we have to redistrict we've talked about it talked about it and talked about it and we've had people send us emails about overcrowded school buses about overcrowded classrooms about the pain that our Educators go through um but I'm joking when I say I know that you understand it in all seriousness I know that along the lines there are people that have Legacy Schools Legacy High Schools I hear Mr silkworth talk about and as my very first day he explained to me how Park

016Elementary was such a significant impact in his life and how um from day one to currently how North County means so much to him as as even as late as Saturday morning so we know that there's going to come uh there's going to come with that a lot of emotions that atted to that so we hear you and we understand you but I ask for you all also to understand that this has to happen in order for us to create better facilities for our students but also better working conditions for everyone all the stakeholders for the Educators there for the students that attend there for the maintenance individuals that work there so that we can do better by the people that work in in and live and play in our school districts secondly um this

017is a question in comparison to redistricting maybe you have this information Dr Heiser um you or Kyle maybe one of you all have it in comparison to redistricting um phase one how many schools what's the difference I this one says there 41 schools um but six high schools so what's the comparison so there's um there's about 53 schools in the phase two study um not everyone is is touched in the various scenarios that are put out there um it's a relatively similar it's a relatively similar number of uh students we had 45,000 in phase one and we have roughly 39,000 in phase two so a difference of a little over 6,000 students okay and the second question for this is that I know it's going to be a full year for 20 for all of

0182025 we're going to be talking about redistricting and the I guess it's the software that we're using if that's the right terminology when we open the portal up for the comments and everything that we're using um in that scenario is there any time that you see that there may be um potential problems like too many people trying to get on to the website at once or anytime that it may be down any complications that we you think there may come about as a result of us trying to get the information onto the website and I ask this for two reason one because I want to make sure everyone knows that the website um is up and running but i' also want to make sure people realize that is technology at the same time and then

019if there is some technology glitches are we going to extend that time frame I I could speak to that I mean I I I feel confident number one that we'll do a really effective job at communicating out after this in terms of so that people are aware not we we're aware that not everyone is watching right now and they're going to be notified and we want to inform as many as we can we want this to be a transparent process to to that point um we're really excited about our our new website uh that's out and so we're we're confident that the bandwidth within that website working with um our Communications office is going to be make sure that we're well prepared and we've had several meetings already about making sure that it's up and

020running of course if there are glitches we're going to adjust and make sure that we fix those as quickly as possible working with our um not only Communications but it department and go from there we'd like to stick though because we're on a tight timeline we like to stick to the February 1 to May one timeline to get to your specific question but we feel confident that we'll um we'll be able to Showcase that website very well thank you guys for your time I'm looking forward to not only the comments but to note of note is that we do take every comment seriously I can tell you that from going through phase one uh we spent a lot of time not just the board members that were going to it but all board members to

021it took a lot of time to make sure that we read through the comments and make sure that we do our due diligence and implementing those comments into the redistricting process so thank you uh Dr Tobin thank you Mr President uh and thank you gentlemen for the presentation uh to pick up on something Miss Dent said uh It is Well redistricting is always a difficult difficult issue um and in the case of my own District as I represent within my district lies the city of Annapolis so when you have communities that are very tight and generations in families who have gone to the same schools it's it's difficult uh I simply want to say that the goal here as Dr badell has laid out is to ensure that every student has the best possible setting

022for school that children are not in situations where there terrible overcrowding and that we are as fiscally responsible as possible and use every seat that we can um and so those are some of the considerations as we move forward I have a couple of initial questions um with regard to uh the data that we're using it is my understanding that in a recent uh red districting I believe in Montgomery County one of the pieces of data that was included in looking at redistricting was uh free and reduced price meals um which I think is actually an important piece of data which I I'm not sure was part of uh the first phase of redistricting and I know I've had conversations with Dr pedell about this so I just wanted to ask uh you Dr Heiser

023and Mr rof is is has that been figured into uh the scenarios that are going to be presented it is not figured in um one main reason well two main reasons one would be we wanted to stay as consistent as possible with phase one and have the same process same variables which we're staying true to um second in point you and and the public to Jaa um policy and that is you know on page three of that policy it points to the factors at which we're Guided by and it lists um close to 15 factors that are listed um actually 12 factors and so on that you'll see the the variables that kind of we look at everything from um efficient use of space to long range enrollments um to fiscal responsibility to your Mrs

024Den's Point um and walkable access to school all the things that are in this regulation so we wanted to stay consistent with policy okay okay um I and I understand that I do think we had a conversation uh in the budget Workshop it's become very clear I mean I think we've always known that it's not good to have speaking of sort of General Health to have a school that's a 98% farms uh blueprint has made it clear for the first time I think it's always been the case but I think it's become apparent in Blueprint that it's not healthy to have a school in the same district that's like 5% Farms right you that's incredible imbalance um so that is a an ongoing concern of mine um my next question is about using it's my

025understanding that prior enrollment is generally Trends in Prior enrollment are generally used for projections is that correct uh to a certain extent it is uh we also look at Large Scale developments that are happening in the area we look at resale versus generation of students uh there's a number of factors including birth rates and other things that play a factor and that's why we update them every year because socioeconomic conditions change and can create many variables I raise this because as we pursue our strategic plan and um watch the wonderful work that Dr Bal is doing to move our school system from good to Great the goal is to have some changes in enrollment in other words we have areas in Annapolis for example where there are no families in some neighborhoods that send their

026children to public school as it now stands I think that may well change as we continue to um grow our school system the way we do um we have recently Hills Elementary is now a five-star School Germantown Elementary is now a fourstar school Tyler Heights Elementary is now a fourstar school we are we are steadily certainly in the Annapolis cluster and others we know Hilltop has just jumped two stars um and I would not want us to make projections assuming and as Mr rof has said there are a number of factors that go into this but I would not want undo weight I I mean I understand Prudence I understand what has generally been best practiced to make sure that your projections are as tight as they possibly can be but I wouldn't want to

027assume those kinds of past historical trajectories to be the trajectories of the future because I think the work we're doing every day is precisely something else and so um I would just put a plea in to to leave openings for those changes and make sure that we're not um cutting ourselves off at the knees in some way so yeah we're I I think that's a valid point that you rais um and probably something that we absolutely will probably need to take a look at as we're going through the process I think uh bill made it very clear we want to be as consistent as possible but there are some developments that have changed since we went through phase one and I could tell you personally from some emails that I received from um a parent

028in a broadnet cluster to be to be exact this parent sent an email saying because of the new curriculum in particular the uh changes with the uh core knowledge language arts curriculum there were several parents out in that area Cape St clear I believe who were looking to enroll their kids into private school and made a decision because of this new curriculum and we have a new math curriculum a new reading curriculum at the elementary level have made a decision to enroll their kids into the district so I do think you some of these instructional changes that were were really being um I guess developed in conjunction during with phase one are already beginning to pay dividend so it's something that we would absolutely have to take into consideration as we think about future interests

029in our school district thank you very much thank you Dr badell thank you gentlemen um I will look forward to I'm sure we'll have more questions for you as we have time to dig into this but I know this is a huge amount of work uh I appreciate it I appreciate the transparency of the process and the opportunities that the public has to to weigh in and I know Dr Bedell in uh phase one you took a lot of what you received into account and in fact adjusted one of the SC the scenario you presented as I believe was your final presentation was it one of the scenarios adjusted based on what you had heard yeah you're absolutely right and it's great because uh that you brought that up because I was going to mention

030that as we closed out today we don't we take every um piece of input seriously in this process and it did result in us having to make some adjustments based on the 80 something thousand comments even to the point where on several occasions we went out into the community engaged people in those respective communities and then made some adjustments and so this there is a human element that goes in that that will be factored in but I will say this too everybody can't get everything that they want this is the reason for redistricting there are going to be some tough decisions that have to be made but we will take those comments in into account as we do everything in our power to try to do this in a very fair and transparent manner thank

031you thank you very much uh before we continue just like to announce that our YouTube and broadcast videos are down uh we do still have audio and they're working very hard to get it fixed President silkworth we do also have a full audio and video intact that we will upload to the website tomorrow as planned thank you okay moving on to uh Miss mcdermit thank you I don't have any questions right now I look forward to digging into the new website um and I encourage everyone in District 4 to do the same and offer your public comment thanks uh Miss P thank you so much this going into this journey as a firsttime as a few of us are um I think now even more than the last phase your feedback is so important but

032I I do want to remind you growth is not comfortable um I also want to remind you and I see the stoic faces so I see you I've heard you I've got I think between snow and this incident here this this new project or that we're about to embark on I've gotten more more calls of concern not Hi how are you doing on the board so I hear that but what I also want to say is we just went through a round of town halls uh for the budget and it's we're overcrowded our facilities aren't where they need to be especially in district 7 um and there's a whole Gambit of different concerns this is one solution to help us get to where we need to be one your feedback can make it a more

033comfortable process and please the calls are great but also put it in the form of the tool because telling me doesn't share it with all my colleagues I am a great voice but I need your voice to go across all these different tools um again I I I just want to thank you but I do think and especially for our our our Southern High School parents who have asked me numerous times we need a new building this is one step to getting on that list be a part of the process is what I'm asking you not be we don't want we don't want we're going to do everything we to to make it comfortable but also the best for each and every one of you and our children so thank you uh thank you so

034good news our YouTube and broadcast videos are back up and running thank you for our Tech folks for that uh I knew they would get it quickly uh okay Miss shaan all right first thank you so much for the presentation um I do have a question or two when you were talking about the seats available districtwide and the utilization and um the fact that that doesn't account for the Portables on on site it does doesn't account for the Portables which there are many you said across um is that countywide or just the phas firstly uh 160 is countywide countywide so do you do we know how many exist in phase currently of phase two of R distric I'd have to get you a specific number for phase two I'm sure dozens though um just at

035Annapolis High School alone there's quite a few but we will definitely get that data for you but I could tell you it's a lot out of that yeah yeah I would I would like to know that because I wonder is that are those factors taken into account when the consultant is trying to balance enrollment I mean the one of the points of this is so that everyone can be in the building not in a portable although I thought they were cool as an elementary school student as an adult I do not you know in the building um so that they can be a full part of the of the community reap all the benefits of the facilities Etc yeah so uh src's State rated capacities uh are based on the building itself so if you

036have 110% that means 10% of the students aren't allocated sufficient space inside the building right now okay so we do do account for that great um other than that at this point I mean unfortunately this is not my first radio um phe one was um um how do I put this politely immensely better than anything we had prior to that because cofton and Broadneck those were not fun um at all it was uh traumatic and so the process that we employed in phase one was Leaps and Bounds better and Leaps and Bounds more fair and Equitable and Leaps and Bounds more transparent and provided all of the constituents far far G access to the information uh to all of the information and to uh be able to provide feedback so for that I'm extraordinarily grateful

037and I know there were a few Lessons Learned here and there uh around the edges for this phase and so I I anticipate it'll be smooth and I just um asked District 5 um you know I'm listening um and I'm watching all of this and you know obviously my vote's not just for District 5 my votes for the whole of phase 2 r districting as our all of our votes but um my phone's already been ringing the conspiracy theories are wild y'all got to stop with that right now we're stopping with that now we're starting with what the facts are and what is on this um presentation and what it will be on the website in a couple days so let's go from there and let's not spread wild conspiracy theories because it'll only make

038this worse for yall because you know it's not fun anyway yeah Miss xeim um thank you for bringing that up there are no conspiracies all we're trying to do is balance the system it's that simple we have a growing School District we have to B balance the system I've done redistricting in several school districts I've never we've never had the kind of redistricting tool that we have I go look in any district and see if you can find this to that we're going to launch on on for phase two you won't find it anywhere so really does offer an opportunity for us to be very transparent um to try to help prevent people from filling this void of information that they may have with their worst fears because that's what's happening right now and we

039haven't even got we haven't even launched anything you haven't even seen the scenarios I think all of that gets launched on Saturday I believe on the first um and then from there you will have an opportunity to weigh in and to ultimate help us shape remember the superintendent will make a recommendation but then it's up to the school board to then say Okay based on everything that we have we either agree with this or do we kick it back to staff based on the comments that we receed from the community to then massage it a little bit more that is ultimately the way that this process works so that what you may see may not be what it looks like when it's all said and done once this board finishes up with their final decisions

040um as they take action to me that should help eliminate any fear that there is some master plan and as a superintendent I don't even know what the three scenarios look like I have no idea I won't know until they are released on Saturday like everybody else so I I I hope we can help ease them anxiety here yeah that's a good point I haven't seen it either um I you know I saw the the lied like the rest of everyone else at this table with it looks like some bits of data that were pulled out of these are this references the three scenarios that are going live on Saturday yes so like this that's all I know too um I mean I'm trying to make heads or tails with it I I can understand

041that green is good and red is bad and so like I'm trying to figure that out but I'm a visual girl I'm going to look at it just like everyone else I live in District 5 so I'm going to be plugging in my address trust under all three scenarios um and uh and I just I just I want folks to trust the process to provide as Miss poim said um your feedback via the tool via the that collection site you can you can email me or call me on a Sunday too but it's going to be more effective if you put it in so we all see it and so more most importantly so that staff can act on it because um uh those those concerns are are uh are they at this point they're

042best seen by by by staff I will say this before I uh turn this light off there will be some people who will take the comment that I said that's not possible that he doesn't know he has no ideal I didn't have an ideal in phase one until they came out because this process should never be about a superintendent inserting his or her power around what a particular boundary should look like this should be based on somebody that is outside an independent entity that is going to give us a complete objective look at what these Maps can look like and then ultimately allow for us to engage in a very authentic and transparent manner so I just don't want people to be like well how is he the superintendent he's not he doesn't know it's

043because this is the way the process has worked for us in phase one yeah and that goes for board members too and I should then I'll stop talking after after this I can't I can't reiterate enough how much better this entire process was than cofton I left the cofton hearing in tears it was so traumatic and so there was there was just there was a lot that was just wrong and it wasn't happy tears neither um it was it was so much wrong with the way that it used to be compared to the way we do it now so um I'm really just quite impressed with how we we uh um how phase one went by and large and yes not everyone was happy but we have a much better balanced from all of those

044uh criteria listed in the in the um presentation um northern part of the uh of the school system of the county than than we did before and um so I assume that we're going to see this um follow that trajectory for phase two so thank you very much again and um yeah I'll be I'll be logging in on Saturday thank you so thank you Miss shaim um whoa 91,000 2033 enrollment is absolutely going up it's not going to be going down um so I sat on the adequate public facilities Committee in an County for for a couple years and it was really made very clear that we had so many empty seats we as a school system has to do a better job of making sure that those seats are utilized but as someone uh

045mentioned earlier um our goal what is the goal that goal is to make sure that we ensure the best possible educational opportunity for each and every one of our students no matter what their zip code and so here we are January 2025 and we'll be talking redistricting up until November so it's going to be around a while and as Dr badell and a few others said we do not know the specifics of these scenarios we are going to get to know the uh specifics of these scenarios um I did have one question and that is in August of 25 the board after having gotten a recommendation from the superintendent has the opportunity to select options um and if this board is not happy with any of the options uh the board's options are then to

046and I'll let you finish that they're enumerated in the policy but uh the bo can create its own if it chooses that was what I wanted to hear so um I just wanted to make sure that that uh that we did uh talk about that um I also wanted to make a comment that here we are in phase two which is impacting Annapolis oral broad a Crofton S Pork South River and Southern however it needs to be made clear that decisions that are made in phase two could potentially impact phase one is that not correct yeah that's possible okay I just wanted to make sure yeah let me let me make sure everybody hears this loud and clear that is correct and it is on the record I said that when we started going through

047this process that there were going to be some families that would be impacted twice simply because we could not do all of this at one time because of the sheer stress that it would put on the system we had to do it in phases so that is articulated on the record over multiple uh redistricting phase one meetings that we had thank you Dr Bell so um I Heard the word transparency well we we we have to be as transparent as possible about this and I remember phase one when that web tool was put out the amount of input that we got from that web tool was off the charts so I'm going to challenge everybody out there let's at least do as well as we did during phase one and maybe we could do better

048maybe we could double it we need your input um so having said that uh I do see a couple lights so what I'm going to suggest at this time uh rather than have another round I'm going to go by the lights uh for some additional questions uh first of all Miss Dent um so for the record I just want to add that um although we did not lay out all the demographics um areas that would be utilized I know in phase one uh we did talk about demographics diversity um equity and the resources um geography as far as the proximity and the growth um I was on the Planning and Zoning um and planning an Advisory board for the county and this county is growing um I hope 91,000 is probably where it end but

049I think that might be a little bit low for the way this county is growing so I'm thinking that you know I hope I don't have to ever do this again but just in case um I want to hit on one thing uh and the reason why I turned on my light is that Dr Heiser I just want you to get clarification from what you said uh I know that there's consistency in the redistricting but there were lesson learned from phase one um and in your best scenario without being specific Are there specific Lessons Learned in phase one that we'll be applying to phase two yeah absolutely I mean I guess I think I heard you correctly and that is to say that will we learn from the lessons of phase one and apply them

050to phase two and um we wouldn't be great Educators unless we did so no there was a comment that said we wanted to be consistent so I just got a text I wanted to make sure that they knew that the the 100% lesson learns that we got in phase two will be I mean phase one will be applied in phase two uh especially one of the concerns was uh low income uh Transportation restrictions in certain communities uh that are different in phase one that may apply only in the phase 2 area so as I assured them is that all those things are taken in uh to consideration thank you thank you uh M pum thank you okay I do have some questions this time um and and this is more of an education for me

051uh in terms of your community school so it's two-part question as we're going through this process the community schools are a little bit more unique I think because they might live in one ZIP code but then they're going to a community school that may be in a different area how did you approach so I have a this is the first one but how did you take into consideration the process in terms of the students going or attending the Community Schools or was that even an issue or something that I mean was that an issue that you dealt with would did you do anything different how did you approach that one thing that we were sensitive of in Phase One and phase two is leaving enough room in elementary schools that's that's the big biggest uh

052concern that we have at the elementary school level and that was something we were cognizant of when we were going through the various scenarios okay yeah um because as as they're phasing out of the community schools and going back into the middle school um there will be an influx of students going in so I was just wondering how how that process works because right now we're trying to level out based on certain numbers so I wasn't sure if there was how how you went about that that piece of the puzzle um so I so and I hear what you're saying so but I maybe it's offline we can get together offline on that um then the other part uh uh Miss Dent you you you approached you identified that the demographics piece are we going

053to so are you saying we will be provided that information as well if that's part of phase one process or we really stuck to the 12 factors that were were in okay the policy and demographics was not one of those factors okay all right um last I think seniors and juniors so uh that's also been a question that has been popping up um in various conversations if you have a a senior especially the seniors that are about to graduate the next upcoming year um how did you address that for parents who wanted their their senior to stay a school that may be moving because of the redistricting how did you take that into account similar to phase one we didn't get into Legacy students until we provided the superintendent's recommendation this is really end phase

054how it looks at the end of the the transition okay and my last question because there is a so we had phase one we recognize through phase one that there will there will be may be people moving twice um once we go through phase two we'll get to see the overall big picture do we anticipate a 2.5 to H to well I I don't mean in a negative but to do some cleaning up if there is no I mean once we get through phase two we would have uh completed redistricting for the full school district and and it's important for people to hear we we're in year one of phase one redistricting and I think because the process went so smoothly there's not a we it's everybody's moving on with their business like we are

055we're rolling with phase one I think as long as we do our due diligence we take into account all of the feedback and we operate with the transparency I think we will be I think we will be in good shape very similar to how we did phase one but yeah I would hope that the next time redistricting happen will be in 2033 I'm hoping when we're done here that's it for a long time think I'm just it was just a question that I kept I only heard twice um but while we're here I thought I would answer it and then um it would be maybe it's offline just seeing how redistricting has either helped the academic outcomes um from the phrase one and it would be interesting to see how that works in phase two

056but that's something it's looking forward to see yeah can I just say this too I mean there's a lot of factors and we will definitely take a look at what our data you need at least three good years of consistent data to really make a determination if if something really worked out well or not um I don't know if if athletic extracurricular activities count for anything but this fall was our first year our first um implementation of phase won redistricting I've never worked in a district that won 11 state championships in one fall in one particular season now that might be school start times that could be redistricting it could be the academic performance getting better as a district but um I think there's a lot of different variables that may have contributed to that

057I I've never experienced that in my 26 years of doing this work thank you uh Michelle hun all right I'm going to try to go fishing so um do any of these do any of these scenarios include not I mean I know individual families could be touched but but adding additional students to any of the high schools that were previously touched what you'll see in some of the scenarios that in order to balance some of the areas in the western portion of the county we had to take segments of phase two schools and move them into phase one now that's it shows in a couple scenarios um so that would essentially take phase two students and move them into a high school from phase one okay and is that the only part of the county

058that we're that we were that we're seeing that in the three scenarios that are shown again these are not final scenarios but that's what I can tell you final meaning what we ended up what we end up passing in November yeah no I know that I know but as of as of this moment since you've seen them you put together the presentation so I'm assuming you've seen like what so not so the only part of that the only part where we're adding students to a school that has a high school feeder that has already been touched in phase one is on the west side of the county I believe so okay all right thank you Dr toin thank you um just a couple of my colleagues comments uh made me want to add an additional

059comment of my own um and and particularly Miss Pam's uh question about a two a possible 2. or whatever which none of us want to do but um but I think for the public this is this is part of the concern right we want to get this as right as we can get it with regard to as has been noted space in the elementary schools because we know what's you know look look at the projections that have been presented tonight Elementary is a place where there's going to be a lot of growth in particular um because we don't want to have to upend the community any more often than we need to and so there are reasons that at times we're going to uh look at possibilities and possibly decide on them uh that give

060us the maximum amount of space to continue to maneuver so that we don't have to turn around and do another redistricting in a couple of years um that is the hope we know there are portions of the county that are growing very fast um and development is taken into account with that um but just one additional question that I've received and I meant to ask earlier um along those lines I'm assuming obviously but for the public uh that you our offices are working with city of Annapolis planning County you know so that we know what's rolling forward down the line in terms of possible development all of those things that is all being figured into the information that we're getting is that correct 100% we have a planning department that solely focuses on those um

061um those things and making sure that we're collaborating with other experts in the county and Annapolis City okay all right thank you okay uh seeing no more lights uh I would uh i' like to thank Dr Heiser Mr rof and the entire staff that is working on this um so this is where we are we're uh in in the process now of phase two uh and once again I mentioned earlier what do we what do we want we need involvement uh and input from all of our stakeholders that's critical um and we want the process to be transparent and it will be and finally at the end we we need to make sure that we've uh fulfilled the goal that we have to ensure the best possible educational opportunity for all of our students no

062matter what their zip code so awful lot of human effort was placed in Phase One and as Dr Bell said I think it did go rather smoothly the hope is that phase two will go as smoothly we know that a tremendous amount of human effort is going to be put into this and we're all going to do our very best to accomplish that goal Dr Bell any uh ending comments yeah no just thank you uh for your questions today thank you to the two of you for your presentation and those of you who traveled out here tonight thank you for coming we look forward to to hearing from you all okay so that will conclude our Workshop this evening uh would like to mention to the public that this Board of Ed will meet their

063next meeting will be on February the 5th that'll be a day meeting our Clos session will start at 10 uh 10:00 in the morning and the Open session at 12 thank you so much for being with us please stay safe good night [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.