CorpusRecord 198642

Board of Education - Operating Budget Work Session #1 - 1/14/25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / MCPS-MD
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Montgomery County, MD
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,402 words · about 103 min
Collected
2026-06-26

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] all right good morning and welcome to the board of education's first FY 2026 operating budget work session I'm going to do a roll call uh to establish a quorum I'm going to start from my left peral sna student member of the board excited to be at my first operating budget uh work session good morning everyone bosz Carla sylvestri School Board member at large good morning wz Grace Reen district one good morning Brenda wolf District 5 good morning thank you everyone for being here and for watching at home read them on Twi at large good morning Laura Stewart here District 4 welcome to operating budget Pala good morning Julie Yang District 3 all right um may I have a motion to approve the agenda for today so moved second all in favor raise your hand

002that's unanimous with those present all right so before we begin today's important budg conversation I want to take a moment to highlight this board's commitment to ensuring that our schools remain a place of opportunity growth and support for all and creating a budget is more than just crunching numbers it's about investing in the future and strengthening our programs this process reflects our values and the hard work and dedication of this board the administration and all the staff in our school system we remain committed to making inform thoughtful decisions that serve the best interest of our district and uphold the trust that you the community have placed in us thank you for joining us and we look forward to a productive and collaborative discussion today our topic is mcps revenue and nonis discretionary requirements and overview

003of the blueprint staff should point out pertinent issues that may concern the board as always board members are free to ask question at any point now due to the large quantity of the information I would like board members to focus qu on questions that will help you make decisions for this budget a second word session will be held on January 22nd and our third and final word session will be held Monday January 30th in addition the board will have two budget hearings and three other budget Community information session the first hearing will be on January 16 2025 and the second hearing is on January 27 B's hearing begins at 6: p.m. I want to remind everyone that board is scheduled to take tentative action on the proposed budget in February now Dr Taylor do you

004have any comments before we begin today's conversation just really excited to be here and uh look forward to a rich discussion and some uh thoughts and direction from the board all right so um then let's begin thank you so much uh this this morning uh I'm standing in for our CFO who's away on family business today uh and uh we've got a number of guests who are also with me today who will chime in uh depending on some of the questions that the board may ask we're going to give a very brief overview and give you some highlights of some of the changes that are listed in terms of Revenue as well as some of the changes that are listed for non-discretionary requirements in the budget in addition to the blueprints so some really exciting

005topics for today kind of said that as a little humorous maybe I'll get a smile okay very very good um but uh but we will dive into some really important topics this morning just as a reminder this is not a budget of cake uh this is very much a budget of vegetables and uh some tough things that we need to address uh not a lot of uh the things that we're going to talk about today are super exciting uh there's many things that are actually quite frustrating in this particular budget that we have to address but we have to address them and they are going to be persistent challenges that we have to deal with for the next several years I really appreciate the the Board of Education and the guidance that you gave me

006very early on in terms of setting the stage for uh this budget process uh you made it you made it easy for me actually to hone in on some of the community feedback that we've received already and uh how we might uh create the conditions to move the mcps forward uh so this budget is really about a handful of things and uh to distill this down to a handful of things uh and to give it meaning to our community this budget is about focusing our energies and efforts into supporting schools making sure that we are taking care of what happens in the classroom being very focused on our fundamentals and the things that we know work exhibiting good fiscal stewardship and then sharing out in a very transparent way way I'm very proud uh that

007yesterday we took our very robust table 1A document and uh online uh we updated this document yesterday and sent out notice to this effect uh when we did the original budget presentation as well that we added exhibit so that our public can kind of drill down on each individual line and see uh what what comprises some of the the numbers that apprise in the budget this is new um this is a new level of transparency for mcps and we are thrilled to bring that forward this first work session as we pointed out is largely about revenues about blueprint expenditures and non-discretionary expenditures uh and to translate a little bit of that our non-discretionary expenditures are the things that are tied to contract tied to law tied to policy and Regulation and then of course robust

008board questions answers and discussion our next board uh work session will focus largely on discretionary expenditures and more board Q&A and then our final work session uh talk about changes to our base budget reorganization and uh close out our budget discussion and giving direction to the superintendent and staff on on what the final budget adoption should look like on on the board's behalf so just to revisit very briefly our strategy our approach um our approach is very much uh focused on a handful of things uh that we aim to do in this budget to leverage better outcomes for our students and for our community we do need to return to higher expectations for academic Excellence we do need to invest in our team we need to have learning environments that are safe welcoming supportive and

009inclusive uh we need to have systems structures and processes that make uh for a continuous Improvement environment we need to provide a different level and layer of support than what we have been doing already for schools we need to organize in a way that supports our schools and we need to recognize that not every student who walks into our school houses uh comes with the same uh toolkit um when they when they show up and that we need to adjust our approach uh to meet the needs of our various Learners and then finally we need to have a big old plate of fiscal vegetables uh we need to have some discipline and some internal controls on how we manage our money and how we plan for the managing of our money over a multi-year period

010of time that recipe is simple um and it brings us to our Revenue picture and what we are looking for and what our request is I will say that there are a lot of variables on this page and uh that in the past we would have a much clearer picture of what some of these variables might look like um and uh we don't um there is actually a lot of question marks uh that lay ahead both in the federal landscape uh granted the the federal fiscal calendar is a calendar that starts January to December and our budget calendar is July to June uh but looking ahead at what our fiscal landscape might look like at the federal level has some question marks the governor is set to release his uh budget proposal uh very soon

011as well that should also illuminate uh some of our uh Revenue picture and then of course uh our County government has its process once uh the board concludes with uh your process uh we have a number of things to to to keep in mind as we are trying to put forward a proposal that both meets our needs and also lives within our means at the same time um going into a little bit more detail you'll see uh that by comparison from last year uh to this year uh we are projecting a decrease in federal revenue uh a slight increase in state revenue and a very significant increase in local Revenue all of this is subject to change as I mentioned earlier and uh just as an artifact for our friends that are viewing at home

012uh that we are looking very intent at things that are happening at the State uh Federal and local levels and uh the the decisions that are made in Annapolis the decisions that are made in Washington and of course the decisions that are made in Rockville that have an impact on our Revenue picture um looking at our blueprint uh which is a big component of our budget and uh is uh um a focal point of this year because we have a expansion that is planned uh tied to the blueprint in particularly in pillar number one which is early childhood education uh as well as um meeting the uh national board certified teacher requirements in pillar two and some of our College and Career Readiness uh assessment requirements in pillar three uh we do have some expenditures

013that are tied uh to the blueprint this year that are planned our current totals uh that we have committed uh to blueprint expenditures reflect $30.1 million now I will say that that that is in a in addition to some of our already existing operations uh that if we were to tie uh much of what we do in terms of College and Career Readiness that number is actually much much bigger because we have um a lot of our existing efforts prior to the the blueprints conception that are also reflected in uh our our blueprint Outlook uh some things that uh that we are still looking for some clarity uh from the the state uh about have to do with uh the uh the regulations and roles that uh different state entities have in terms of blueprint

014there seems to be a lot that's still in the air and there is also some advocacy uh even in uh the board's legislative agenda about addressing some of the things that we think could be tightened up a little bit tight to blueprint when we look at our expenditures this year and what we have proposed we are looking at uh the potential of adding 13 general education and 15 uh special education uh classrooms in addition to 10 special education collaborative classrooms into our uh Early Childhood mix uh this is uh both really exciting a tremendous and positive investment for our community but it also comes at at at a significant expense moving on to the next uh focal point and this may actually be a good time to to pause if if you want Madame President

015to have a discussion about the blueprint components and we could kind of go back and and hit the next section if you want um Janine of course is here our our blueprint director and uh resident expert uh and uh there are also some materials at your desk that reflect some of our blueprint outlay as well I I do think this is a good place I'm going to turn to my colleague to see if there are any questions and when we come to the staff before you answer the question introduce yourself okay I'm going to start from the right hand side uh board member Stewart hello uh Laura Stewart here I needed to know uh more about the blueprint uh I see you know I see the money that came in from state aid 39 million

016and I see that we had um the the 3 30.1 million that you mentioned on your slide um I'm a little unclear uh how much are we spending above the state aid for blueprint go for it um I think that we um have some ongoing costs that actually haven't been completely tallied so when we look at the 30 million we're talking about things that we absolutely need to do in terms of mandates but some of these pieces have been in place over the last several years so there have been some ongoing costs um that are associated with the implementation of the blueprint because it's a state law so it I would say it's much more than that um I don't have the exact amounts right now and just as one illustration for example one of

017the um requirements of blueprint was an adjustment to the salary scale for starting teachers that for example so some of those like big embedded pieces don't necessarily stand out these really are the more sort of discret requirements as Janine was mentioning and as Dr Taylor said we really um have a lot of our ongoing work that is either pre-existing or responsive to blueprint but was not necessarily a specific add-on for a specific piece so this is really sort of an enumeration um and those blueprint dollars from the state also support some of the very specific restricted funds such as Community Schools right so so there there are a number of layers to that um to those aspects as well so um um M Stewart I think I um actually sent an email to the administration

018asking for a more detailed number and we will be able to share once we get that number well and it's an interesting question too for a couple of reasons because um we compensate in the compensation question there is an expectation in the blueprint that we comp compensate teachers at a starting salary above 60,000 well we do that um we are uh one of the few districts in Maryland that does and so the the question then comes would we be doing that anyway because the labor market directs that or are we tying that back to blueprint and it's a gray area so it's hard for us to discern whether or not that is a blueprint expense and the expense of that difference between $599 9.99 versus when we've crossed that threshold every nickel beyond that does

019that then now be tied to blueprint or is that just us meeting the labor market demand I think there's probably a way we could we right for instance we know that we were already going to pay our teachers a premium um but some of the other areas are a little more gray I feel um so yeah I just I'm trying to determine um how much of the unfunded mandates do we have so anyway that that's where I'm thinking yeah I just wanted to provide another example of that under the teacher compensation between 2019 and 2024 we were required to increase teacher salaries by 10% so would there likely be some teacher increase during that period of time yes would it have achieved the 10% I'm not sure but we were mandated to do that I

020think the other thing is that um Montgomery County is also subject to the wealth Equalization and because we've had a few increases in wealth in the county then our share becomes larger um I think on average the prek is funded by the state at about 30% of what those costs are and then the teacher compensation at about 36% so there is a local and state share but our share is is sometimes much greater than it might be in other jurisdictions and so that those account for some of those additional costs um but I think there's a way that we can work to be able to calculate that but I would say that that's the case across all of the pillars so when you look at what we discreetly have to do from year to year

021and then what we've done over a period of time I would calculate that as a much greater amount but I think we can work to to um determine it an approximate cost those numbers you just gave help us have a fuller picture so I appreciate that thank you right miss m thank you for that with the percentage breakdown that was actually really helpful and that was one of my questions as well um so thank you and if you have any more information like that that would be really helpful for us um in regards to on your slide so two things um you said that there's a possible major reduction in state funding so I'd like to learn a little bit more about that yes um there is we've just started the new legislative session for

022FY for 2026 and the um Governor has proposed that we freeze for four years the collaborative teaching time portion or requirement of the blueprint that that those funds would be frozen for the next four years the accountability and implementation board which is the entity that oversees the blueprint um and has jurisdiction over msde concerning the blueprint has also published a statement that is very closely aligned with what the governor's recommendation is so essentially um what it is saying is that the amount of funds that would be given to each school district for the teacher collaborative time is um estimated to be calculated at approximately $163 times your student enrollment so for mcps if we have an enrollment of approximately 155,000 there is a potential for us to have a reduction of $25 million so we

023don't know what the legislative outcome is going to be we're still also waiting this week um to see what the governor releases in his budget but there is a potential for us to lose $25 million and I think mcps over the last few years and including this year has really invested a lot of time and energy on this topic of teacher planning and working with mcea and so the potential impact on us in terms of our efforts our existing efforts for Teacher collaborative work um as well as the impact on the foundation funding formulas could be sign ific so there is a there is a likelihood that that will happen but we don't know until the session plays itself out okay and so do we you know if if that happens do we know then

024how we're going to move these things around because even if we've already been doing that we can't then just say well it's on pause now um you know that in itself could be disruptive um it could be and I think they've they've just put this plan out for this week so I think as we have had to do in past years will'll have to sort of regroup recalibrate make sure that we are in compliance with what the state requires of us um also how that will impact our potential planning for the for the roll out of a career ladder level four that leads to teacher lead positions as well as as administrators we'll have to reconsider all of that um and take a look at that and and sort of regroup our plan for meeting

025those requirements okay and then I have one question about the um AB IB fees do we have any information about how many of those students whose fees are being paid for by mcps or and even for dual enrollment as well are farms versus non farms and then also um and it could be by percentage if you'd like how much percent of the funding of that is the state covering because that is something we are required to do by state law right thanks oh we are required to do that by state law um I think and I believe that we can get the numbers to determine how many of those students are eligible for free and reduced meal services um but the state law requires that we cover currently it requires that we cover all of

026the costs for those students who are eligible for the AP IB and dual enrollment so the state provides a certain allocation and they have sort of an estimated number but anything that exceeds that or any additional cost that we may have are funds that mcps has to provide in order to meet that mandate it it is quite a bit a large amount and how much I guess that's what I'm wondering like even if it's just a ballpark I'd like to know how much you know kind of what M Stewart's question was is how much is unfunded right we're required to do this but how much are we having to come up with on our own so a couple of things um this is also something that's a part of the board's legislative agenda at the

027state house and and it is one of your legislative priorities that we have the flexibility to address this and differentiate our approach to funding um this is reflected as a$ 2.1 uh million increase in what we currently expend uh for AP IB testing fees it's important to note too that there are uh some inadvertent pieces that kind of come with this because uh there is an expectation that students that take these assessments that they register in the fall and sometimes those students don't uh fulfill that that expectation in the spring and that we are on the hook for the cost as well without a lot of recourse so um us adjusting uh that expectation and us uh complying and having different guidelines might actually be a huge relief to us and create some Financial benefit

028okay and I I'd like to hear too and it doesn't have to be right now but also then about how much again ballpark are we losing to students that are registering and then not um that don't end up taking the test thank you uh all right um I want to um in the interest of time let's each have one question first if have we have additional time then we will come back thank you m Miss Mo that's a little bit unfair at this point in time yes I I understand that I understand that I'm going to ask what I I really didn't have a question but I wanted Janine to talk about the philosophy of the aib because I think that will help people understand that there are a lot of UN funded mandates here

029we don't have answers every district is complaining about the same thing and until their the legislators start talking about it we won't have any real ideas but their belief is that the the school systems have not been educating students the way they need to and therefore they're going to take control the difficulty is that they are not they're not in the counties working in the schools to know all the issues they are sort of educational experts but I think it would help Janine if you shared that the aib really at this point isn't interested in whether or not we have the funds they want this done um thank you for that comment good morning um I think you asked me to introduce myself earlier Janine Becky um from the blueprint office I think that um

030as as I meet on a monthly basis with all of the other local school systems all the other blueprint staff um we have a running agenda of questions that we have regarding guidance or lack of guidance that we're getting from the accountability and implementation board and some of these questions have been on running list that we've had for more than a year um getting some of the guidance in a timely fashion and getting some of the guidance in a way that sort of explains exactly what we need to do has been a challenge um we received guidance last spring at the beginning of June by the end of June we had we had to submit career Lads level one two and three so it was a very short turnaround time for us to be able

031to make adjustments for us to be able to negotiate with unions um and so it caused some difficulties and for all of the pieces of the guidance that they provided there were probably at least five or six questions that came back from the school districts asking them to sort of explain um some of the guidance or there were different scenarios based on how different systems have their contracts negotiated with their teachers and so again we're having frustration with that uh for example we are supposed to be rolling out a tier 2 for pre level next year 300 to 600% um at the poverty level for our prek students for full day we still have not received the guidance on that most school districts are starting their Recruitment and enrollment processes in March so in order

032to be able to implement that or to determine if parents whose income is above the state uh guidance would pay tuition there's been no information on that so one of the recommendations was that they put together a committee and the committee would quickly make recommendations to roll out to us we don't have any answers for that another example would be the waiver process for administrators um should they have to receive their national board certification or based on their experience and education and local training would they be exempt from the nbct process and specifically asking for the correlation between the outcomes for nbct and the administrative parallels we they're not going to address that for at least a year um we did just get some guidance regarding the prek par education waiver um whether they have

033to have a a Child Development Associates or an associates degree we've been asking for that for two years so I think there's a lot of frustration and response really is we're going to have to meet these mandates and there isn't one District in those conversations that isn't interested in meeting the mandates that isn't interested in in closing the achievement Gap and moving our students forward in terms of wellness and achievement but it's very difficult to do that if our hands are tied because we need time to meet with various offices it's certainly impactful for us in mcps because we're the largest District in the state so for the smaller ones and the very large ones it presents even more of a challenge because we have to even for prek it involves multiple offices Transportation Food

034Services facilities in order to be able to implement these plans so I I just want to just reiterate and sort of corroborate what you're saying that there are some frustrations I also think that we do the the aib does rely on numerous experts that they bring in and they they cite a lot of educational research which I think is important but what it actually looks like on the ground in a school system in Maryland it it can be frustrating sometimes trying to work through all of these pieces and see how we can make all of that fit so I think that's another challenge and the response to that really is it's a state mandate you've got to meet it so even when school systems um propose um some Alternatives what about this can we do

035this or that it's really we're met with you have to meet the Mandate if it's unfunded they're saying you have to look in your budget and cut something else because you have to do these mandates but school systems are saying we have fixed costs we have transportation we have fuel we have heat we're you know getting school systems are getting funds from their County government some of them are saying the in order to implement this it would compete with the funds that may go for transportation or fire or health health department something like that so really we have very little flexibility in being able to make any adjustments or to look at the timelines and suggest what is more reasonable and I understand and their concern there's the urgency of now for our students but

036there has to be some flexibility in how we're able to be able to C carry out these mandates with our other requirements okay want to thank you for that Janine because we spend hours talking to the other 23 districts and flexibility is the word that we're all going for and so far it's falling on death ears so I just wanted you to share that to so that people would know that we don't have a lot of opportunity here or even questions that we can really answer thank you thank you Miss wolf Miss River Alin thanks Jennie nice to see you um I also want to Echo um somebody who sits on the mave uh executive committee I hear this from the other counties um the the lack of being able to do what you have

037and our population numbers are very different to some other count population so the way this was implemented was one glove size fits all and we are finding out very quickly that that's not very well fitting for counties like mongi County so with that being said um uh you know with the prek uh roll out that we're doing I just want to make sure that the community understands and folks who are funding mcps that there's a lot of things like you said only like 30% of it is going to be funded by the state which means 70% of that has to be funded by us so when we are you know making now all those part-time positions into full-time right there's a lot of cost including transportation that comes along with it and a lot of

038folks don't understand that pre transportation is not even part of the formula of the state that that we know the the state only is required to fund transportation for kindergarten to 12th grade so when we talk about prek and starting early and and we all know right and science supports it and we have all this evidence of learning that when we start prek the kids are much better off long term but yet there's still you know and this is something you know that has to be um made better at the state level that they have to take into account the transportation especially for counties like montari County um is a huge part where we're going to have to do the funding on that and like you said it has to be done um and I

039think this is a frustration for you know for for a lot of um a lot of counties so with that being said um when I look at the college plus career Readiness pillar number three um I think it would be also good to know like in these pillars where we are doing the funding it would be good to know how much of the funding that we're putting in to it is so the so everybody knows exactly the cost to to monari County and the investment that we're putting in um and that you know that dialogue has to be done because I know we have an issues with Community Schools with with lack of flexibility on what some Community Schools can do based on our reality of mtgy County versus the reality of another County that

040that is you know um 10,000 students right this so I know that the blueprint commission is looking at making changes but like you said it's it's very slow moving we just you know we just got um uh uh Clarity on on the waiver process for our par Educators and and whether or not they needed a degree and that has a huge effect on rolling out all day prek because then it's very hard to find providers with those qualifications so these are things that I don't think we discuss very much but I think it's important to tell the whole picture so anything that you guys can give us that we can educate the public where we're doing this budget forums because it just seems like you know this is easy pey and it's something that you

041know it can it can be done you know with a snap of fingers but it really it's not the process is is kind of complicated and it's very unforgiving for flexibility I think we had asked last time um the the the you know the farm students who who do AP and IB versus those who do not to see if we can have some savings there but again even if we know that number we cannot change the formula that the state gave us we still have to pay for all so that is again something that maybe our legislative um friends and delegates and Senators can actually take you know and and take that fight to to Annapolis where it needs to be but thank you thank you and I just say the board um legislative recommendation

042I I think that's in good company with what I hear from the other school districts who um are you know struggling to make decisions about funding that for the families who are able to afford the dual enrollment and the others then they should afford that and then we should still have safety nets for students who are whose families are unable to afford it because we don't want that to be a barrier to them to hire education but clearly there are some families who could well afford it and perhaps the cost savings could be redirected to another area of need thank you thank you Miss Sylvester thank you um I have a comment and a question and um just want to reiterate what my colleagues have said about additional information so that we can show the

043public the full picture of the blueprint what we have invested in in past years the percentages of local investment versus State investment um and then of course the ask that we're um that is is in this budget I just think it's super important be for the main reason which you stated which is we are being asked to cut some fundamental things of teaching and learning in our budget to pay for new things that frankly have not been prioritized it was do this do that do this these are all great educational reform efforts but they have not been prioritized and we are now finding ourselves in a situation where things that we want to continue to expand like prek uh is coming out a comp competing with other things that maybe could have waited a couple

044more years so I just think it's important for the board and for the public to have a better picture of what uh the blueprint entails and I think we have a council session still uh to be scheduled on this topic is that correct Miss uh yes the council um is will hear a report about this on the 28th 20th 28th 28th okay um so my question is about this um what you started out with Miss Becky about the collaborative planning time I just need you to explain it to me the implications for Montgomery County because I didn't capture U what you were saying the the the state is is going to re delay it um and it's going to have implications for our not this budget that we're working on now but the next year's

045budget would just help me understand uh in layman's terms what this means for mtgi County there actually will be implications for this year's budget for FY 26 and there is a potential for a loss of about $25 million this budget not fy2 FY 26 excuse me I'm sorry um the the proposed budget budget we're working on today the budget we're working on today that's right so um the state requires under the blueprint that we develop a a teacher and administrative career ladder one aspect of that career ladder is that we develop a plan by this June that over several years we allow for teachers to be teaching in the classroom 60% of the time and then the other 40% of the time that they would spend tutoring students uh working on the curriculum conferring with

046other staff meeting with parents all of these things to support the student achievement and well-being and so we have to have a plan in place um by June 30th that incorporates this collaborative teaching planning time over a period of time and we have to start to implement it next fall so what happens is if this the governor has proposed that we freeze that portion of the career ladder the development of the collaborative planning time and that those dollars also be removed from what each of the school districts is receiving and so our existing efforts already with teacher collaborative planning time with our Unions would be impacted by the loss of those funds as well as our plans to roll out um teacher collaborative time plan for the future so um we would have to sort

047of take a look at completing the development of the career ladder without that piece but that's really an integral piece of what is the entire career ladder that we're developing teacher leads that then those teacher leads are mentoring other teachers and they're working with them to develop them as teacher leaders and and looking at ways um that research-based ways to help support student achievement so I think not only will there be could there potentially be an impact in the work and how we develop the rest of career latter level for but that $25 million potential loss of $25 million would be significant because it would um look it would not allow us additional money for teachers and other resources in order to implement a strong teacher collaborative planning time so it it it would impact

048us in a negative way both in our planning as well as in our funding and the $25 uh million is really significant okay thank you um so at this moment uh what G is talking about is the potential is not a done deal we need to look at the governor's budget release and this legislative session and in the past uh it has been announced that uh uh 2026 2027 blueprint money is uh safe there has been conversations like that and but this is one area for us to keep an eye on because Montgomery County we often are the head of blueprint schedules so uh this is a a point that we when we work with when uh the board my colleagues work with uh State uh we need to uh reiterate sometimes we are ahead

049of the times so that um when they adjust that they will take into consideration the people who who are already underway with the work all right Mrs zberman good morning um thank you for being here um I have questions about Community Schools it looks like we're projecting it says eight or more potential designations for Community Schools correct and then with grant money attached to that okay um so that $280,000 is that specifically for hiring Community School Liaisons and the nurses or is that for hiring across like Community Schools we also then designate a parent Community coordinator and um a wellness trainer are those positions included in that does that money come from elsewhere I'm curious we're inviting some audience friends to join us oh [Music] great hi Peggy Pew Chief academic officer uh Community Schools

050actually rolls in in a phased in approach the first year you're required to do the community school liaison and the nursing and then it isn't until subsequent years that you get the per pupil allocation okay so um adding in those other positions are we expecting to do that for other schools in um FY 26 that how you start talking about that rolling in yes there are new schools added each year as the threshold of poverty that the state uses is determined but they send us a list and say who's identified right so if we're projecting to identify right these schools so I'm assuming there are other schools identified in fy2 and you're talking about that there's that rolling basis so we're expecting that rolling basis so we're expecting to hire right parent Community coordinators and

051wellness trainers with that rolling in correct okay thank you thank you um now uh let's move on to the next section please I just had a one one quick um question um channeling Miss Harris this was her question that she always asked and that was about the utilization of our existing prek seats um she was under the impression that our here we are expanding prek but our prek seat our classrooms were not fully utilized so um I I think that the issue was about the half day programs versus the full day programs but uh would appreciate just some understanding are our are full day pre-ap programs fully utilized in terms of capacity in the classroom or is there space that is not being fully utilized as we look to invest more in this we want

052to make sure that families are utilizing the service and those those classrooms are full yeah our full day programs are are fully utilized and they're done also on a rolling basis so if students drop then we add invite more students to the full day the halfday programs are not fully enrolled because it's an inconvenience I for families the transportation is an issue um and so that's part of the design for the expansion would be to take some of those half day programs make them full day and be able to qualify for what is allowable under blueprint blueprint we we do not get any funding for those programs that are half day we only get it for a full day program so rather than um creating whole new programs the idea is that we take a

053halfday program that's in a particular School make two full day often there's not room for two full day in that same school so some work with facilities is needed to be able to do it in a close area and will this finally get us out of the half day program or do we'll still have with this expansion in this budget we we still have half day programs out there we will still have half day programs mostly for our special special education programs for whom that's appropriate okay and we still will have some that are nonsp special ed with this budget thank you Mr just following up on that is transportation going to be part of that transition because one of the biggest issues even when when parents were able to get full day prek but

054their prek was full in their home school they were giving the option of going to another school but they had to provide their own transportation which created an equity issue so now that we're transitioning all half day to full day pre um if that's the situation are we going to provide transportation yes transportation is included in the budget for the expansion it's still you know to your point won't get us to every school every local home school having a program every student being able to go to their home school so it is a very technical process to map out the the bus routes and how to get them and that's part of the consideration of location of where we um put the programs Miss yes thank you um so I'm I'm not expecting it now

055but when possible can we have the information on the number of half dayss that we have current number of half day uh preschool uh or early childhood education things that we have right now versus the number that we expect in the future so we can understand what the difference is how many we're shifting from half day to full day thank you thank you Miss saana I know that each one of these chapters probably can be a full uh full uh B meetings in uh discussion so I want to remind my colleagues um um focus your questions on that will help you make decision for this budget cycle all right let's proceed to the next chapter sorry I have one more followup question to what let's wait to the end at the very end we still

056have discussion time thank you okay so the next section of our uh conversation has to do with our non-discretionary requirements and uh and those kind of components that are in fact uh tied to the law regulation guidelines or contracts that we have and we're going to do our very best to take a lot of lines in the budget and give you them in smaller chunks this is a summary by section of some of the things that we'll talk about and so the very first one is compensation and uh this is the biggest part of our budget request expansion is looking at compensation when you take a look at the big uh budget document the table 1A uh this is a reflective of uh lines uh 15 through uh 19 um right up at the top

057so we've kind of condensed that into to one line for you to look at right there these are placeholders uh for negotiated agreements uh with our associations as well as uh encapsulating uh funds that we set aside for working conditions and stiens but these are negotiated agreements that are not in place and these are placeholder numbers for that assuming uh some preliminary discussions around 3.25% plus a step which is on par uh with uh what County government has made assumptions for for FY 26 uh this also reflects a reclassification of two employee groups a reclassification of our athletic directors or athletic Specialists as they're called and in our high schools U moving them from mcea positions to map positions and uh also differentiating the compensation for our par Educators because they have a variety of

058work assignments but are compensated through one dimension at this time and we would advise that we uh differentiate them differently in terms of how we compensate them in the future so it's a good pause Point um and this one this one's pretty easy and pretty big at the same time moving on uh to the next one has to do with fiscal stewardship and a big uh priority that the board had laid out for me was uh for us to put ourselves back on the right track in terms of fiscal stewardship making sure that we are covering our expenses and that we are financially solvent this is reflected in a complex way and I want to spend a little bit of time talking about it the first item here is our health benefits uh plan and

059making sure that as a self-funded health benefits program for our employees that we are in the black and presently we are not um we do have a deficit that is reaching 60 million um and this is problematic if we do not uh make changes to our structured plan the this is also something that does get negotiated with our association Partners we are going to find ourselves in trouble and granted this is a planned or a a projected deficit we do know that we need to make changes to our plan and that we also need to backfill uh the the the the plan itself to make sure that we're solvent it's a big chunk of change this does not solve the problem I want to reiterate that it does not solve the problem but it does

060put us on a pathway and the road to solving this over a two-year period of time uh working with our partners uh and providers in terms of our health benefits that is uh an an acceptable solution but we do need to focus and make sure that we have a plan that is solvent in the long run uh this is one of those big fiscal vegetables that we need to take a look at probably the hardest thing to explain in the entire budget is salary lapse uh because it is a 10 million doll increase uh to our our fiscal control but it's represented as a negative number uh currently right now you have $75 million committed to salary lapse and what we are doing is reducing that salary lapse by $10 million or what what we

061are proposing that you reduce it in a perfect world you would have this be a zero number or a very small number salary lapse is taking uh into account uh that not every position in the district is filled at every pay period And so you ask yourself the question what on Earth happens with those funds uh when they accumulate month after month when you have unfilled positions and uh where does that that money go well effectively uh is what becomes your fund balance over time and if you had a zero uh dollar figure in your salary lapse you would have a projected Savings of around $75 million a year uh that would be fantastic that's a enough to do a lot in terms of uh Capital Improvements onetime expenses you could use that for a

062whole host of things that would actually be the sign of a really fiscally healthy organization you shouldn't end a budget year with $0 in your bank account unfortunately because of some of the tough decisions that you've had to make over the last couple of years the board has leveraged some of its salary laps to fill some of the holes in its budget so you've encroached on that amount of money over the last several years and now uh we we need to start uh creating some fiscal controls to to uh give us a little bit of flexibility and a little bit of room because as we reported sadly earlier this year we were projecting a deficit at one point because we had uh over extended ourselves in a number of budget categories thankfully we are no

063longer projecting a budget uh deficit uh that is thanks to us implementing some fiscal controls and the hard work of a lot of folks in our central office to Titan belts mid year uh but we need to be a little bit better with our planning uh so this is really a function about how we plan uh and how we plan over time multiple years this is something that will'll have to come back and address next year it is something that will have to come back and address the year after that and the year after that and the year after that and chip away at this block uh over time how this became a big crisis is really twofold the first issue that came about is that you are actually really well staffed this year you

064actually have one of the highest uh Staffing percentages uh that you've had in a really long time we have filled a tremendous number of our vacancies which has actually reduced our salary laps and that cushion has been eroded because we have filled so many of our positions unfortunately one of the reasons that you have filled so many of your positions is because you had to cut vacant positions because of a budget shortfall last year and so your fill rate would is in a lot of ways artificial higher than it normally would be um and you have historically used salary laps for other purposes and your budget effectively double budgeting for the same dollar uh this is just a practice that is uh accepted it is a practice that is useful on a short-term basis but

065on a long-term basis uh this is one of those fiscal vegetables that we just need to eat uh and and address a little bit more deliberately uh we do have uh planed increases to our uh retiree plan um our retirement plan uh is committed to the Educators and staff who have given a lot to mcps and so U making sure that we keep up with our premiums uh to that plan is particularly important uh the next big section has to do with maintenance typically how we have addressed maintenance in uh our budgets has been to look at some of the major capital projects uh and to address this through the Capital Improvements plan and yes we need to continue to do that and yes that is critically important but there are ongoing maintenance needs that

066often times get neglected this really is a way more significant issue than we probably want to admit uh this is upwards of 179 million that we should be budgeting for on an annual and ongoing basis for pay as you go or payo maintenance needs uh we have not really uh impacted our uh maintenance staff in terms of making increases to our maintenance staff uh over the last uh 20 years yet we have added a number of new schools and millions of square feet uh to our footprint without increasing our maintenance staff or materials uh budget in that space as a matter of fact we have actually reduced our maintenance our ongoing maintenance budget uh just so that we could balance the classroom needs this is a pretty significant issue um we have heard uh from

067a number of our parents and uh from folks during the CIP process looking for Relief uh for some significant Capital needs the reality is is that many of the capital needs that they brought forward to us could have been fixed by ongoing maintenance and us being a better stewards of our facilities we do have an idea uh that we would like to approach um and that is to create um some multidisciplinary teams of electricians Carpenters painters uh engineers and such uh to address and clear uh pending work orders um at some of our more persistent schools uh and for these teams to go out to sites and uh with the with the intention to plan and execute work this is an effective strategy of preventive maintenance and to address ongoing maintenance needs that a lot

068of other school districts have adopted uh it's high time that we address that and we'd like to commit 22 uh uh Personnel to to that uh to that effort um and feel like that would uh make a significant dent in some of our issues we have programmed in at this time $7 million now I mentioned uh just a moment ago that this is really $179 million issue this is really something that we'll need to come back and add address for the next 10 to 12 years every year adding to a maintenance fund every year um to build up so that we are keeping Pace with the maintenance needs of of of all of our schools uh one of the challenges that we have is that uh in the diversity of the portfolio of our buildings

069is that we have uh buildings at various States and various facility conditions a lot of which is tied to age and also Al the building codes of the time that the the buildings were built and our newer buildings have very different uh needs than our Cur uh are some of our older buildings and uh we we need to have a a diverse enough toolkit to address both of those things and um our our portfolio of buildings is is aging and uh to maintain that is going to be a significant uh battle um we have some other uh annual costs that are that are worth some uh discussion and worth some evaluation uh from uh Transportation uh to um uh Building Services Staffing to facility costs one of my favorite ones uh has to do with

070utilities um our electric bill is not $6.1 million it is much much higher than that um we are uh set to realize actually a $4 million increase to our electric bill that is an increase of $4 million to our electric bill and then we have some anticipated costs to one of our energy uh savings contracts uh in the amount of $2 million that we are expecting uh this year as well um it is hard for a lot of people to Fathom uh the size and scope of maintaining uh roughly 230 campuses in addition to our school buildings we also have building builds that we are maintaining for things like food service technology um everything from printing to materials distribution and even the building that we're in right now and with that wide portfolio we pay

071an electric bill just like everybody else and it is millions of square feet a year um and so when we have an increase or a premium increase and I think it was um I'm trying to get the percentage here 85% increase to our utility costs um that is representative of $4 million just in increased costs to uh utilities a couple of uh other big things that we are looking at uh you may see systemwide safety appear uh in a couple of different places in our budget uh the next uh budget work session we'll talk about discretionary expenditures where we talk about adding some security assistance to some of our schools but we are also investing in um we might provide uh additional training and uh improvements to some of our uh uh systems and structures

072regarding safety this is a high priority for the board and something that matters to us a great deal uh similarly uh making sure that we are in adherence and compliance to the actual number of costs that are tied to our uh ADA compliance that's the Americans with Disabilities Act and making sure that we are are fulfilling uh the actual costs of doing business not uh just what the budgeted cost of doing business might be um I I will say how important this is because this is a particularly important fiscal vegetable um if we budget for an ADA uh line and we exceed that ADA line that is not actually acceptable by law so um when we have an uh an ADA expense that exceeds our budget we are still expected to fulfill that so it

073is in our best interest to communicate what our actual needs are in terms of ADA costs and our actual needs in terms of um some of the other uh components that are that are listed here as well um you may or may not be aware but uh we we do um have to work with financial institutions especially financial institutions uh that that are managing our funds as well and we we do have fees that are associated with that um and those are delineated of course in our in our macro Budget on table 1A as well um we uh we also have some reporting expectations um as Miss Becky pointed out just a few minutes ago uh the the expectations are quite extensive for blueprint as well as for um our state and federal governments so

074when we have Grant Management and things that we need to do um we we do require a lot of hands uh and a lot of effort to make sure that uh that paperwork is correct um one of the things that was a little bit of a surprise to me as somebody new to uh mcps is um how little support we had for Grants and uh and what we were doing to uh leverage additional monies outside of our our current Revenue mix so adding um two additional support positions for Grants is a is a great way for us to leverage other uh Revenue sources in the future and we see this as a as a as a pretty compelling ask and potentially something that could pay for itself actually it's our expectation that it pay for

075itself uh even though it's it's listed as a a debit on this particular um component uh we've gotten into uh some of uh the other fiscal vegetables that we we have to eat um one of the bigger ones here is uh Chromebook repair uh this is not a $4 million increase in uh Chromebook repair but rather a reflection of what we actually spent so uh this is the programmed projected cost uh and again um we are no longer a onetoone district in mcps uh because we have not kept pace with our repair and replacement uh budget and as a consequence of that um you know we we do have some limitations uh one of the questions that I uh enjoyed getting from uh some folks in the community is why can't you just have a

076virtual day when it snows and the reality is twofold um one the state's expectations for virtual days has changed uh and there are some restrictions and limitations um and then the second reason is not every student has a computer or access to a computer and so we do have some limitations in that space um this is one of those components that um in today's day and age it is a competitive Advantage for our children to have access to computer technology it gives our kids a leg up and an opportunity for their learning environment but it is an asset and it is an asset that gets retired after four to five years of service and we need to keep up with maintenance and replacement cycle and um if we don't uh then we are only perpetuating

077inequities uh in our academic program so um this is uh one of those components that is a reflection of the true costs and not uh necessarily something that is uh an extension beyond what we are currently doing similarly tuition reimbursement is one of those things uh presently right now we do have negotiated agreements with our associations that provide tuition reimbursement um we are short uh and we have not budgeted accurately for the things that are in contractual agreements and we do need to do a better job of that um so uh those are those are definitely things to highlight um one of the things that I picked up in having some conversations with uh our community uh during my entry uh was the lack of support that we are really engaging in uh in terms

078of community engagement and areas that we really do need to invest in to make sure that there's adequate interpretation uh and that uh there is a support and recognition for our staff and the work that they are doing um and uh we fall short in many of these areas and enhancing our interpretation and enhancing uh this space uh with a focus on community engagement would be a real uptick for mcpa so I'm I'm closing out here with uh just a couple of items that I want to draw your attention to and and one of uh the the bigger ones has to do with Staffing uh we are projecting to be relatively flat in terms of our uh enrollment projection for next year um we are anticipating a little bit of a decline in elementary school

079and uh some increases in middle and high school uh the net impact is uh 33 and A2 positions um in terms of classroom positions the way that that falls uh in terms of uh how how those uh how that uh enrollment uh lays in terms of uh by school um the biggest uh Staffing adjustment really has to do with special education and meeting our guidelines uh for uh special education um this is an area that really does need a tremendous amount of attention and uh does need a focus and it is something that every meeting where I attend with parents gets brought up um because we need to be providing services that are better than what we have been doing in the past our teachers and our parent educators are working very hard um but

080we are falling short in and meeting our own Staffing guidelines and so what does this look like um the this looks like 180 8 teacher positions and 500 par educators of the 500 par educator positions we already have 366 of which um that are already part-time positions or uh temporary part-time positions that we would make benefited positions one of the things that the board has already acutely observed is that this is a high turnover position and it's a high turnover position for a couple of reasons it's a high turnover position because the wages are not differentiated uh for the job assignment and uh several of these positions are not benefited 366 of them to be precise uh so retaining this Workforce and supporting this Workforce that are in some pretty tough uh situations is a

081top priority for us and making sure that we have uh what we need um additionally and I'll and I'll button this up pretty quickly um our fastest growing student population are our emergent multilingual Learners making sure that we have adequate support and meeting our current Staffing guidelines will have an impact we seem to be playing catchup with this group of students in terms of meeting their needs when really we just need to be proactive and forecast a little bit better about uh what the student population is all of that to say that this does not reflect an enhancement to class size it does not reflect an improvement to class ratios that needs to happen that needs to be a part of our future that needs to be a part of our planning um our budget

082request is very robust as it is right now uh this will by far be one of the most expensive initiatives that we consider in the future but it needs to be a part of our future planning but before we can even get to improving our class ratios we actually have to get to our class ratios and this is a reflection of getting to our class ratios and actually Staffing to the standards that we currently expect um closing this out a little bit um I uh we already know that we need to adjust our our funds for materials and supplies that get allocated to schools U making some adjustments for things like paying for scho sports officials and maintaining our uh athletic fields and providing Transportation these are really just reflections of the true costs of

083doing things and making sure that we are budgeting with a very transparent lens uh to to actually have a number in the budget that reflects what we actually spend uh to me that is particularly important you'll see also a reduction uh here uh this is a reflection of uh the reduction in federal funds so these things are aligned uh you may have uh you may recall that uh we mentioned earlier when we were talking about Revenue that we were projecting a $5 million reduction in federal revenue this is that $5 million reduction in federal revenue and uh and where this is aligned in terms of uh that space and how those funds have to be committed so what on Earth do we do in that space um well we have a number of choices um

084we backfill with local funds or um we align our programming uh to to meet um uh what the projection is so um closing out uh the last couple of components here uh have to do with teaching and learning uh one of our biggest Investments last year was the CK curriculum and uh and uh launching our early uh or excuse me our Elementary uh literacy uh improvements utilizing the science of reading except that we did miss out on a couple of things uh we did not provide print materials to all of our Educators uh we need to correct that we need to make sure that all of our Educators have the print materials that they need uh we are also looking at secondary literacy and uh uh some stem curriculum in in this budget it's time

085for those things so to uh recap and to uh briefly talk uh a little bit about what we can expect in some of these non-is are requirements is uh that that these are the things that are tied to law policies regulations guidelines and contracts uh the vast majority of our budget requests are to represent the true cost of doing business and uh to fill some of the holes that we have uh and to address our fiscal position uh and to provide solvency um many of the things that you will see in this budget proposal are really just the beginning of really long-term multi-year investment ments but that is really what we need to do is we need to think not just in one-year isolated points granted the board can't hold future boards accountable to to

086Future budget decisions uh that that's not how this works but uh but you can uh plan ahead and uh and even though you can't hold future boards accountable uh you you absolutely um uh does not absolve us of the responsibility to plan ahead and so uh what we are targeting um for this year is really to uh make some of these initial Investments that will put us back on the path to fiscal solvency and uh to give us a little bit more fiscal discipline but also uh for us to plan and uh and to design around how we can structure things a little bit better and a little bit differently in the future thank you superintendent um for member now we can do questions there are many uh chapters cover here so we probably will

087go several rounds of questions and and each round uh let's keep to two questions each board member first then we'll come back I we have time for questions and and this is important I would like you to be able to ask your question I'm going to start with Mr savan yes thank you um I see in our kind of in our projected Revenue we have a uh an increase from $1.1 million in uh state grants to 1.4 $4 million and then we also like going back to to one of the earlier slides we had um two two more full-time positions dedicated to to Grant work uh is this like kind of that you know um like paying for itself that we expect to see within the projected in the revenue and then also within our

088full-time expenses yeah so a couple of things and and I'll I'll let Miss Maguire oine on on some of this as well uh even though we would expect for Grant positions to um to pay for themselves so to speak in terms of additional revenues that they could bring in we still from an accounting standpoint have to represent the debit um on our expenditure list um and and so really what this this should be as a budget is to represent a net position of expected revenues coming in and expected expenditures going out and uh the number at the bottom of the page should always be zero and terms of of how we are planning for that um and even though additional Grant positions um might bring in additional and unanticipated revenues we don't have that realized

089uh as part of our financial plan that we propos because we may be unaware of what those potential revenues could be yes just to confirm the the revenue change that you're um highlighting Mr sua um those relates to those relate to actual changes in state grant funding that we're aware of at this time these are projections but they're projections based on uh on sort of actual events um our Our Hope certainly is to increase um as we were saying through our efforts to to increase our um securing of Grants pursuing grants um but also some of this is to to manage the grants that we have and also to provide additional support to our schools in their fiscal work as well so it's a multiple it's multiple layers of of Grant Management and that is

090of course until our very moving Target moves uh which could be as soon as this week um with uh a state budget uh proposal from the governor uh these numbers could shift and uh that is the fun in the budget season is that everything is really subject to change got it okay so so just just to kind of confirm so the number that we see here in the projected revenue is what we kind of basically more or less know uh right now in terms of what we're seeing in terms of the grants and then the number that we have there that we expect to pay for itself is you know unknown as of yet thank you Mrs inment great um so from a classroom perspective um seeing this special educator um Staffing increase is really

091exciting um it would be a huge relief to our schools um but we as a community as a nation we hear all the time about you know our educator shortage our special educator shortage um um do you believe that we will be able to fill all of these allocated positions and if so give us a little bit more about how yeah that certainly is the aim um and I would say that the sooner that we have uh relative certainty on what we are expecting to to have uh the better that opportunity becomes um I will say that with uh how we compensate our staff we do recruit um and and this is not great for public education this is not great for um the the the region or even the state of Maryland but it

092is good for us uh that that we do um receive a lot of our employees from other districts uh because we are an attractive place to work we are a great school system and um we are a preferred place to be um so we certainly have high hopes and expectations what I don't want to do is I don't want us to ever be in the position to where we find somebody and we are not meeting a need but we can't hire them because we don't have the position allocation available and that is really in many ways we have found ourselves in that position even this year um where we do have a need that need has been articulated but because of a budget limitation we have not been able to secure uh Personnel in the

093right places at the right times because we haven't had the position allocation available um we do need to do a better job of forecasting our needs needs and um getting our staffing a little bit more consistent what I really would hope uh that we could accomplish this year is get up to that level set so that any future changes that we make to class ratios seem a little less dramatic and uh don't look like we're uh actively recruiting massive classes of employee groups at one particular time that we really find ourselves up to level um and then we can build from there um i' I've speaking of that um kind of you know um forecasting a little bit so currently there are zero CK materials that are in other languages whether that's classroom materials or

094the Cent home at home materials unless they're like mcps or educator created um is part of the budget like us making that ask of CK to you know of amplify to produce those materials or is part of that like if we're asking our our Educators or part of our staff to do that right there's a cost to that is is that included or could we find out what that cost might be I'd love to get back to you on that great um I do know that what we have programmed in is making sure that all of the Educators have the M the print materials that that's the biggest component of this as to whether or not they're in other languages or there student materials in other languag I'll have to get back to you on

095that okay um relatedly when we we um allocate for these materials um often times we don't forecast well for new students that we get I can speak from my own perspective I've definitely been in the position of running around the school saying does anyone have a unit three book and thirdly like and asking friends at other schools it's just one more thing to do right um so if we're able to forecast that well I think that would be really beneficial for our classrooms too thank you thank you Mrs sylvestri um wanted to go back to the big ticket items the uh benefits um the finan the financial correction health benefits plan and the the salary Labs well so just for the viewing public we can't assume that everyone's been keeping up with uh budget bloa

096so how would you explain to the viewing public how we got into the health benefits the need for a correction M again really high level so that uh anyone can understand um we'll start with health benefits for sure um we are self-insured meaning that we cover uh the cost of doing business so to speak for how we administer our health insurance plan uh that is not uncommon for large organizations to be self-insured uh and as a result we are the the financial responsib party for covering the cost of the benefit that we offer to our employees the way that our employee benefit uh for Health Care is established is that it has some benefits that have some cost that are associated with them that are higher in terms of their utilization than what we have

097um budgeted for so for example if uh we think that um uh 10% % of our employees are going to utilize a medication that costs $100 and really 20% of our employees utilize this medication that costs $100 um our costs are out of whack so there's a couple of ways that we can respond to that um we can adjust how we have the plan structured which will likely need to do that um and we can also adjust what we invest as the employers into that plan uh so that we can keep the cost low for employees this represents really a combination of those two things the need for us to have a plan that can sustain itself over time and doesn't exceed the costs of doing business and then also backfilling the areas that we

098we did not uh plan for and budget correctly so a lot of this is financial forecasting um a lot of this is also um trying to anticipate um medical costs relative to the experience that our uh um employees have in terms of how much utilization they have and uh how we find that right intersection of providing great health benefits to our employees at a cost that we can afford and that they can afford so our projections have been off the last several years and we find ourselves in a and we haven't adjusted the plan or our cost structure to accommodate for those changes so if anything we're we're trying to play catchup when we should be a little bit more proactive and the total investment in health benefits is I understand $400 million yes this

099is just what we're budgeting for this year so um this example and the example you gave about utilities reminded me this is just the money we're adding this year there is the budget and this is what we're we need more to keep uh maintaining a high quality School District so where can the public find where is that $400 million for health benefits where is that millions of dollars that we spend in utilities that we now have a $4 million increase this year so we actually can share a couple of those things I know in particular with uh utilities if I'm not mistaken it's on our macro sheet that we just released and we have an exhibit um that details some of those costs and outlines uh some of that component but I may also call

100on Cary you want to come up and and point out in our in our budget documents where we could find that I had forgotten how big that noar 400 million it's an eighth of our budget no no no no what we actually pay for health insurance increase is $400 million 1/8 of our budget we're adding 40 million this year but that is a huge number so it just reminded me these there are huge numbers in this large budget again just to help people understand people say you have $3 billion dollar that's enough money you should be able to why are you asking for more no these things I just want the public to understand the real costs of running a highquality school district District of this size today and and it's reflective of uh the

101carrying costs for 25,000 full-time employees and so it it is a component that uh um after the affordable car it's not really a choice for us to offer health benefits uh as a as a mechanism uh for for Recruitment and Retention we we have a benefits package that we would like to think is very competitive um and attracts uh employees as well so it feeds into that Recruitment and r attention component as well so I apologize um Miss Thompson is going to see if we can pull up some of those numbers right now those are numbers that typically are published in our budget book every year um in terms of that we have a we have a table of all of the benefit contributions um both base and increase um I do regret that that

102has not yet been printed um however as you know um many of our materials in fact the rest of the materials will be available by the end of the month and so it will be available um and we will continue to update that if we can Circle back so that um the public can know where to find that information ideally if ideally if you can have that before our next budget Workshop stion that will be great I'll wait for the next round sure miss Rivera Alin um thank you thank you for that thank you for explaining salary laps I think that was very beneficial um and uh huh no no no no previously pre pre previously before before your comments um I think that was very beneficial to why because we had fill or our

103prisions now we we don't have um a cushion necessarily um I wanted to um just make sure that um to thank you for making uh maintenance um one of the focuses of this budget because I think in any community meeting that we go to uh any ptas any some of the schools that we even our kids go to maintenance has always been an issue so that would be item 44 and your budget right which is combined right which is combined both pay as you go and the facility task for teams I'm trying to understand um the facility task for teams so you're going to be adding 22 positions to that Dr Taylor that is correct okay and and then they're going to be working as a cohort group of help me uh ageback electricians this

104this is a great question and and uh uh pretty exciting because this is an idea that we've borrowed from other districts that have tried something similar um imagine a team that is looking at uh the unfulfilled work orders that are in our school system which we have many um the reason that they are unfulfilled is not because we have an ineffective or um a lazy Workforce but because there's some capacity limitations in terms of getting to everything and there's also uh that that expertise isn't always in the building um and uh our some of our very hardworking building service staff may not be experts in HVAC or may not be experts in plumbing or may not be experts in electrical that we have a team uh that is multi-disciplinary meaning that they do have that

105expertise in those areas and uh they plan uh on how they would go go about clearing work orders and go school by school to clear work orders uh and to to bring a school back up to uh our expected uh levels of performance um thank you again I I I think that's because one of the things we hear about is these work orders go into this abyss of we don't know where it's kind of like the berm triangle of mongi County Public Schools and some of them are a year two years and they keep putting in for the same work order so this is going to alleviate that and then you're adding three positions for Building Services Staffing which when I heard you you give us a description of it is something that we have

106not increased in 20 years so it's literally we're we're adding new schools we're adding you know um but yet we have not added adequate Staffing to be able to replenish that so we've been doing more with less in a sense that's a very accurate description and sadly um not only have we not added in that space But in in often uh lean times it's also been an area that we've turned to to to find some efficiency um this is an incredibly hardworking group of folks they are the people that get deployed on snow days to clear parking lots and to clear walkways um and our our most recent snow event is a great example of how stretched thin uh we really are in terms of uh making sure that we can have adequate resources out

107there um and we get to every school campus and it and it is not the responsibility of one or two people per campus but it really just needs to be a team uh approach and uh and how can we leverage some some centralized expertise um everything from from keying buildings to uh paint to electrical and carpentry all of those things uh need to happen in our our over 200 campuses on the school-based Staffing and support if we can go to that page the special ed Staffing is long overdue as as you know and as as we can see by the amount of teachers that you're projecting that we need to just be at the the adequate class ratio I think is what you said not even to add but just to be at a place

108where we can actually just do the basic work for and I Echo um Miss Zimmerman's you know uh point that this is great news so just to be clear with the 500 total par Educators 366 that we currently have as part-time and special ed will be offered to um kind of like our pre- right we'll be offered to be full-time right um which leave would leave us to recruit about 144 additional uh special parent Educators and with that but finally after many years of advocacy we're going to see that there's going to be a differential pay with those PA Educators yeah th those are great observations and it seems like a monster number when when you're looking at oh my gosh how are they going to find 680 positions we hire well over a thousand

109people a year every year um for a variety of roles but it it is noteworthy to point out that there are in in 366 of those positions and actually that 46.6 million would be more if they were brand new positions um the we are already leveraging the part-time pay that uh that we've already committed to those positions as part of that budget equation so the the net is reduced a little bit um it would be a a substantially higher uh dollar figure um this really is a way for us to reduce some of the churn in that space um finding uh 134 new pair of positions and 188 new teacher positions to miss Zimmerman's Point um although that that is challenging we actually think that we'll do quite well um and and it's not outside

110the bounds of of our recruitment abilities based on what we have to do every year think about it this way it's less than a position per School in terms of teaching positions and definitely in terms of pair of positions it's less than one per Elementary School uh in terms of the the volume that we have it's long overdue and I think going to make us more competitive as well as a system because we can losing incredible part-time par Educators to other systems that do have the full-time option for them and many of them are bilingual trilingual so this is really I think a game Cher so um thank you to you and the staff and the em Staffing just to be clear even though we're adding 47 new teachers the ratio the ratio of um

111classroom size right now is like one to 41 I think right this is not an improvement this is just to make level you're absolutely right so even though we're seeing some of these and we're saying oh they're adding new teachers they're adding new staff this is just really adding to the point where it's adequate so support in the classroom so I had an interesting conversation um with a couple parents recently who said oh my gosh you're adding teachers but you're declining in enrollment how on Earth is that happening and I I said you know that that would be a challenge for sure for me to understand if I didn't understand how our student population is changing too because what we've noticed over the last several years is that our student disability our students with disabilities

112population has increased inreased our emergent multilingual uh student population has increased and even though our student population has been relatively flat or has even declined in some areas um it does not account for the fact that we have students with diverse learning needs that need to be accounted for and we account for that in a in a slightly different way than just general Ed Staffing the other other question that I have in this scenario here is um when you are on the road and some of the community meetings I went to to listen to the parents in different parts of the county there were many parents to brought the issue of support services for special education or for children who had an IEP or 54 plan with speit therapy and others that um seems that

113we're having a really hard time being able to comply and even in those schools what we know we have children with severe disabilities or having a hard time complying what is the scenario in this picture to be able to support those positions yeah they're they're included for sure um in that 188 uh educator positions uh but in addition beyond that there there are some clever things that we can do uh had a great conversation with the board president actually this morning about this exact topic and uh this is something that resurfaces in our community uh time and time again uh when we don't have a speech uh pathologist or someone to provide speech servic it does not absolve us of the responsibility to still provide it so what we have typically had to do is

114is contract that service uh with a third party provider that is more expensive than us providing that with Staffing so we need to come up with an approach uh that honors the role of our speech pathologists that uh allows them to focus on that work with uh with out ancillary responsibilities with uh really trying to find ways to make that an attractive position it is a it is a national shortage uh every time that I have appeared before County Council I have uh begged Sydney Katz for his wife to come out of retirement because she was a speech pathologist because we could use all the speech pathologists that we can get um I think at some point I will wear her down and we'll get one more um I'm hopeful at least but the reality

115is is that this is a high needs area it's going to continue to be a high needs area so we really need to approach this from two different lenses how do we keep the speech pathologist that are already in our system and and support them so that they want to stay with us and two how do we re recruit and create the conditions for that to be uh a a position within mcps that's fulfilled okay Miss wolf thank you um this budget is very clear as far as it goes um my question is our budgets sort of reflect our values and what's important to us and when I look at this budget I'm reminded that we continue to have data that is predictable by race I see the struggling categories in this budget but what

116I don't see is intention intentional activities that are going to address the uh gaps that we are seeing with African-American students and that's going to be a question I'm going to ask in every section we cover because I don't see that and I would like to know what is intentional in this budget that's going to address that issue well I'm glad you asked and um I I will expound on this again when we meet again to talk about discretionary expenditures and that's not something that we call out us specifically though we call out a great many things uh with great specificity um I will say that one of the things that should trouble Us and something that troubles me is the disproportionate identification of students with disabilities for our black students uh the disproportionate identification

117of students with disabilities for Hispanic students and making sure that we are not only providing great services to students with dis disabilities but that we're also making sure that our identification of students is appropriate and that we're providing adequate supports uh in our non-discretionary requirements Beyond providing instructional materials and providing uh some of the things that we've uh enumerated and making sure that there are enhanced opportunities for materials and supplies this budget does not do a whole lot to advance mcps or to innovate mcps but what it does do is it helps to stabilize what we say that we should be doing and so this is a a budget that is very much trying to put the train back on the tracks and to give us some stability so that we can create the conditions

118for Innovation and Improvement uh I absolutely hear you that we should call out specific things that trouble us I am delighted that we are addressing exactly uh your concern in a couple of different ways even though it may not be spelled out in words okay I I understand what you're saying and clearly disproportionality is a result of over representation and special education but we have a number of African-American students in general education and the Gap is still there that's what I'm trying to understand I I know those in the free and reduced lunch price category those special ed but I'm not seeing intention in the budget for those general education students and the Gap is still persistent so a couple of things in today's topic and and I'll give a little bit of a preview

119on what to expect in your next budget work session two um one of the gaps that we aim to fill is to to make sure that schools have adequate materials and supplies it's not something that we've been particularly attentive to we haven't done a great job with that um and it is definitely an issue um making sure that we have Educators in the classroom and that we don't lose them that is actually a critical strategy for us to be successful if we have high educator Churn it is going to have a negative impact on general education if we don't have adequate materials and supplies it's going to have a negative impact on uh what happens uh in the classroom for general education as well this is a lot as best as I can describe it

120is to create the conditions for those to be less of a variable moving forward um I think that we need to invest in a couple of areas that we haven't invested in the past uh in particular and this is the preview to the next budget work session into how we create a level playing field uh for school resources and and what the principal has available to them one school with an overactive PTA that provides a lot of additional support shouldn't be um uh a concern of somebody who has a school that doesn't have those financial resources without us H creating a mechanism to level that playing field we do that in this budget um we have been very successful in a number of situations provided some uh industry certifications and uh some GED support for

121students at night through our CA program but we feel like that shouldn't be limited to one group of students our EML students we feel like we can expand that to a lot of students who need that additional support and we see an opportunity for that as well so can't wait to talk about that in addition and that absolutely in both of those scenarios encompasses black students and other students who have not found success in the general education environment you know I'm not trying to take away from any other category don't misunderstand me and I do believe that special education requires special attention at this time but I also think that par educators are needed in the general education setting and that would go a long ways towards helping uh improve the opportunity Gap thank you

122Miss wolf miss m thank you I have so many questions um so I will likely have to follow up afterwards but I'd want to kind of piggy back on what Miss wolf said um about our Latino students because often times it seems they get put into just we think all Latino students are EML right emerging multilingual Learners and that is just not true and not all of our emerging multilingual Learners are Latino right so I like Miss wolf um don't see I think what she phrased as intentional activity which I like um geared towards our students who are in general education we see that even when you control for socioeconomic status and various other variables that our Latino students are not meeting proficiency scores sometimes those proficiency scores are in the single digigit numbers um

123and especially for our younger Learners I'm extremely concerned because that piles on as they get older and so I hear what you're saying about maintaining staff and the supplies uh increases which I think are great um and crad doesn't really affect our youngest Learners um but is there anywhere in here where we're looking at high-intensity tutoring or you know we see these models in DC I think Baltimore just got a bunch of grants that seems very similar to the DC model the data shows that it works it I know I know we're we're scraping for pennies here but am I missing something is that here somewhere and I don't see it or is that something that we have to put on the wish list um it's not reflected in this budget uh that that is

124uh that is not identified and and candidly I think you're you and Mrs wolf are are really approaching this from the right lens which is I'm a parent at home how do I see in this budget the impact uh to my child's experience and uh and you're going to see an impact in a number of different ways um and it may not necessarily be like this is what we're doing for black students or this is what we're doing for Latino students or this is what we're doing for Asian students but what I hope uh you can see is a noticeable and intentional uh investment in making sure that learning environments are improved uh that expectations are clear and followed up on which is actually not a budget item but critical to our path moving forward

125um that there is not random shortages of materials and supplies because of a budget line that reflects one way but our actual needs reflecting something else and that there is a a qualified educator in front of the classroom that doesn't change every year so for us those are the critical pieces that we see as part of the strategy to to M maintain that continuity um I would say that our our general education investment is not as reflective of the changes in the budget as much as it is uh how we Sher up the things that are already existing in the budget but no tutoring is not something that we've added in um we we did have the blessing through uh Esser funds uh post pandemic and towards the the end of the pandemic uh that

126augmented an a lot of additional support that we we just don't have and uh so unless we build it into the base the base budget it's not going to be in there okay because it seems like some schools might have various programs or Community Partnerships and I can appreciate that perhaps those schools are Title One schools or Community Schools or Focus schools right there's various levels of support that come with that but we also know that across the board a lot of our schools have increasing Farms rates um and you know we talked about special education and so I'm just you know those students need assistance also and a lot of times they get overlooked which then can perpetuate this falling behind one of our hopes and uh this is really more of a topic

127for for next time but it's great to preview it is um to relook at uh the the principal's allocation for each individual school and how we differentiate that to provide additional support could a principal use uh some of those resources to to augment with some tutoring absolutely uh do they have the discretion to use that for uh additional other Support Services absolutely uh I think that that's our intention is uh to to update where they are in terms of their financial standing it's arguably some of the best money spent in the budget is what we provide to the schools for their use uh as long as we paint uh the guidelines for for them and give them some structure and some support on how they might utilize that for the best return on investment okay

128wonderful thank you um and my second question for this round relates to exhibit 22 which is the division of Transportation um I see here that there's a line for electric buses at 1. 285 million and it says funds are added for rate increases on the leases for 236 electric buses currently in the fleet plus the lease of additional electric buses in fiscal year 2026 and then I also see a service vehicle repairs $482,000 um so my question is whether the service vehicle repairs are buses or other mcps vehicles and then with the electric buses is this a new increase from the prior can you just explain a little bit so we all understand what's going on there I'll uh I'll let somebody else opine on the service vehicles I don't know the answer to that

129but um most of our contracts especially the ones that are multi-year contracts do have some inflationary value uh that's baked into multi-year commitments um and this is certainly reflective of that but if there's anything else anyone else wants to add so we anticipated sorry so we anticipated based on the contract that we had that in this year the rate would then increase and the pardon my language for anyone who may feel offended the prior bad performance does not change any of this corre okay correct Miss Stewart oh I'm sorry I just wanted to add you have something to add that second line is uh for for our non-bus Fleet okay thank you we will have a second round though right yes okay great um so my first question is uh has to do with special

130education and um I notice on I think was item n uh where you listed the extra um support for special education but in the second part of this item there's the special schools listed and there's a projected um less enrollment are special schools um just based on what I've hear I hear from the public I have a hard time understanding with the incredible need that we have that we are projecting less enrollment in our for special schools listed here C could could I get some explanation on that so um Miss Pew uh is coming up to the table to speak more specifically to that but again as um what you're seeing here is just uh changes in in the projected enrollment um as as we go through those projections and it's not uncommon for us

131to have a cohort of kids that matriculate in and out and uh trying to adjust for that um that's not to say that there aren't projected identifications and new students that get enrolled that that routinely happens but what this I think in general and and I could be mistaken here is also trying to reflect a net number so you may also have a cohort of students that is leaving that school or matriculating to another school as a consequence of that that's not it's not irregular that's that's pretty normal and that's 100% accurate it's based on the known students that we have that are identified that would be either leaving that school or coming into that school just on a a regular basis throughout the school year students are moving in and out of those schools

132routinely and unidentified students come in get identified and then maybe uh move to that as well it's a pretty complicated formula that I wish Julie Hall were here to explain to you but um that's basically what it is is that it's an ongoing enrollment and what you're seeing here is projected based on the known so the question that brings up is are we identifying properly so I and I don't know if that's even a staff issue that's related that's in this budget like staff to identify it's not really a budget question although I I will say that there's always room for improvement and it certainly is a challenge that I think that we're looking at um I think thinking more globally and and thinking bigger picture about special education that we really need to take

133a a step back and look at special education in general from the 30,000 foot view about what can be improved overall um and really how do we want to evolve our special education services to provide better Services just in general um I don't dismiss or even reject the notion that that there are individual circumstances that blow our minds and we're like how on Earth and um what what why did we end up where we ended up with a specific situation um but it is something that we have to look at it is something that we need to take into consideration but we also need to take into consideration the entire Continuum of special education services not just the identification piece there's a lot of areas that need to be improved and that's been pointed out

134to us on a on a pretty regular basis thank you for that answer um so my second question um was from exhibit 21 uh the taxi services for the mckin the mckenny vento program of almost $1 million um this well I'll let you explain um what that program is for the public our mckin vento students are the students who are temporarily or permanently displaced from housing and uh there are some uh Federal rules and regulations uh that govern um uh Transportation as well as some other support needs that we provide uh to some of our our students that are are homeless and need uh support uh one of those things is making sure that they that we provide continuity of services so if a student is temporarily or permanently displaced from their their housing situation

135uh to make sure that we can um uh still provide services at the school that the child is familiar with and that is considered their home school and uh from their home school that sometimes means that we have to transport long distances and it's a and it's an irregular Transportation pattern uh based on what they need either in a short or a long-term situation uh we do utilize taxi services for that in addition to other Transportation uh to make sure that we get kids to inform School uh and even though they may be many many miles away from uh where their home school may be on on that temporary basis uh and as a result of that this is one of those items that is a reflection of what we actually spend uh not uh

136not necessarily an increase per se but uh but a reflection of what the dollars that are typically committed in that area so that was the next part of my question um are you projecting a particular number of increase or percentage increase not a sharp increase no but but but part of our responsibility in this budget and what I hope is it comes across is that um we have been we have been married to budget lines that are not a true reflection of the the need and are not a true reflection of the expenditure and we are hoping to correct that in this budget by telling you that this is what we actually spend in this area and there's a reason for it and and largely due to the fact that we do have an increase

137in farms rate so we do have an increase in needs across the county and that we need to start accounting for that in a really meaningful way um well I have heard that there was a 70% increase in unhoused um people in Montgomery County so we we are a reflection of the county right so if there are more people losing their homes being evicted um unhoused we will see that in our school system so I think it is you know we need to be ready for that eventuality and also um work hard with our County Partners to keep kids in their homes um so then we wouldn't have this problem of Mobility is a huge factor in academic success Etc so it's not exactly a budget question but I just wanted to drill down on

138that a little bit to see um if we were preparing for that and I do see this line item so that helps thanks it's not something that we can uh uh ignore either we we will have to address this um by by law and also by our our morals and ethics to address this need thank you um I I in terms of drilling down on some data and numbers um I have uh some numbers I would like to have uh one is about the special education Staffing about the 688 positions and $46 million Michael is this $46 million salary and compens uh salary and benefit Al together or just salary it's both salaries and benefits it's compensation okay uh so I I I do a little bit of math regardless position and level that's about

139$67,000 per position now my question is uh Dr Taylor mentioned that uh you have already counted for the TPT money that we budgeted before so I would like to know what that number is um number two uh drilling down on exhibition number 10 exhibit 10 uh about substitute bus drivers and attendance um so uh I understand we have 1300 bus routes right we go around the globe four time four and a half times each day but I would like to know because it's a $1.5 million increase for substitute bus drivers we need them but tell me how many positions you are looking for uh in that category okay and then uh in terms of the number 14 exhibit number 14 about contractual Nurse Services of $2.5 million increase in that um categories um can we

140have any reimbursement in terms of itinerary nurse from the state through the medic K programs so I wonder whether this number has Tak into consideration of any reimbursement we might potentially have some of those expenses would qualify for Medicaid reimbursement not all of them um and we'll get you an answer as to whether or not this that's reflective of that or not but but some do qualify for Medicaid reimbursement okay uh continue to drill down on the numbers uh for the extended school year program um is there this is not a new program we do the program have been number of years I see a big jump in the number for this year is it because we have more Title One schools but I thought we don't have more Title One schools so um help

141me this was previously uh Grant supported and no longer Grant supported so our eser money has dried up and this is part of that fiscal class you can hear my okay uh last droing down on the numbers um I see that we are hiring more people to uh work on our buildings and they are all good now one question I always wonder is our musical instruments we hear from students all the time uh actually I think won High School sent us a video clip of you know uh uh some of those conditions of our musical instruments as I understand now right now we um we contracted out to be serviced and fixed um have we ever done a financial forecast or projection to see are we getting more by Contracting now or creating some positions

142within our system and which way will get us better um return of investment I hope I can do a good job of answering that question because um musical instrument replacement is definitely one of those things that tends to suffer from year to year uh because the the cost of repair and replacement tends to go up pretty pretty significantly each year um that typically does require a lot of expertise and uh a work space um that that we don't currently have that being said it's not to say that we couldn't do that comparison it it's probably worth taking a look at uh the volume is significant and the needs for uh uh Orchestra versus the needs for brass and a band there's some differences um and that's definitely a fund that is worthy of additional investment

143and look at in the future in terms of just even supporting it in general regardless of us even looking at the comparison of In-House versus contractual Services just because that that is something that we have an asset those assets do take a beating going on the bus going home coming back um they they really uh uh the useful life of the instruments really is diminished um in particular some of our bigger instruments taking even more significant beating uh so making sure that that's properly invested in is sometimes a limitation you you answered it and I'll just add that we have multiple contracts with with multiple instrument repair locations throughout the county to be able to accommodate what is needed there are only so many piano tuning places that can accept and do the specialized work

144that's needed um so to your point it's multiple instruments multiple specialty areas that we're Contracting with our local businesses to support in the model that we currently I understand that but I I also know that um the highest number of our instruments is probably Viola violin you know there there a number you you can say that these are the 90% of our what we use what we have in the system so I just put it out there to see if you analyze the the numbers and see if what is a better way to approach it now board members so real quick we have an update on a couple items I can go through and give you some of the numbers in response to your questions and also miss Sylvester's questions okay um so you asked

145about the um dollar amount for the TPT positions the temporary part-time positions that we're converting in those par Educators there's $1.6 million of local funds that we were able to uh repurpose towards the positions and $1 million of Grant funds so that's $2.6 million total of the TPT TPT dolls we will have to get back to you on the bus driver Subs that's a little bit of a different calculation we'll need to get back to on that um in terms of the um utilities funds uh that increase that we were talking about of $6 million is on a base of 52 million so our base utility bill um in this current fiscal year is $52 million and we anticipate that going up um next year by that amount in terms of the benefit costs um

146this is one where again we do have a detailed table that we will print U before uh before the board's action but I can tell you that um you are correct Mr sylvestra right now our um benefit uh contribution to the fund is just under $400 million and so this $40 million increase would take it to about 435 in total when you look at our employee benefits our retirement benefits our workers comp all of those uh that sort of required set of employer funded uh contributions comes to nearly $800 million and I guess my question was more about where can I find that information myself can the find that information so they can see what is in the budget not just what we're adding this year and we will absolutely have that when we complete

147the exhibits by the end of the month okay thank you all right time chat well member we still have time this is schedule uh so I'm going to go around for the second round I'm going to start from Miss Stewart side okay um so big big picture big ask um um thank you so much for this budget but there are I would like to know how much it would cost to uh look at our class sizes for kindergarten um I'm thinking about a I'm thinking about this as a triage approach but not just kindergarten also our early grades so kindergarten first and second um broken down um so we have an idea uh and again uh part of what brought me to ask this question is from our last meeting and we highlighted how the

148kindergarten class their Baseline is significantly lower um kindergarten classes I hear a lot uh from the public from teachers that they're not um manageable and we're having these increased needs coming up and so I just think I would be remiss and not at least asking what would it take uh to deal with kindergarten in particular and also um first and second grade for that information yeah we absolutely and we can we can absolutely highlight that as part of a a future work session for you um on the budget I will say that something to to look forward to is that it won't be a static number so it you are likely going to be uh a different cost to lower class size by one than a different cost to lower class size from one to

149two uh just because of how the classes May split and how precise we will get by School uh to identify the impact if we were to to change the ratio by school so that that's absolutely helpful um another thing that uh I think sometimes might be helpful for the public to understand about class size is that um when we adjust the class size we're not just talking about Personnel uh that we are often also talking about some of the facility needs that come along with that and uh what the classroom capacity is uh in some of our schools we may have a very tight school and we may think it's a great idea to add an extra classroom and we may do just that but there may not be a classroom in that building physically

150for that teacher to operate out of so then we have to make some other facility decisions as a consequence of that and we'll reflect that as well um speaking of facilities uh these teams very excited about that um and I know we talked about how these maintenance orders just drag on and on and at some point there was going to be a public facing uh system for to track that is is that somehow reflected in this budget yes it is um and to to do that does cost uh some money and we we are reflecting that as part of this proposal as well okay so I did see that line item I wasn't quite sure if that was the public facing part so uh and my last this is big so I apologize it's just

151something I want us to uh look at and I I tried to see where they were quickly in the budget but we haven't had actually the full thing for that long so um we have the our uh from um you covid money we had social workers added and we absorbed that into the budget because we really do need those social workers okay I get that um but we also have you know nurses that are under um the county HHS and so this you know I know there's a dollar amount um associated with those social workers uh this adds to our maintenance of effort so this adds to our overall budget um which I I don't know if people understand what maintenance of effort is but you can't uh reduce uh per people spending from year

152to year so as far as I know this adds to that and I just plus you know we are uh trying to be uh do what we do best right uh and again we need this service but have we talked to the county about um balancing who has uh the budget and the management of uh certain services that we provide and this was added to our portfolio yeah I think that's an ongoing conversation I think one of the the struggle points too is um you know the need is always going to be there and whether it's County Services that picks up the need or whether it's the school services that pick up the need it is something that we need to map out as to what agency is the best at providing a certain service

153um as somebody who became an educator in the late 90s I can tell you that um education in general has changed quite a bit um much of which for the better because we are more attentive to the needs of the whole child uh but what we've given up in in that exchange has been maybe a focus on what happens in the classroom as a consequence so we are we are in many ways far away from um what our our Core Business function is or our core function as an organization is when we adapt some of these other ancillary Services even though we know that it helps and supports our kids uh but it is something that we will need to figure out it's not an overnight switch either like you take these positions we take

154these positions you do this we do that uh but but something that does need to be sorted out and and needs to be a part of our our dialogue together with our County decision makers as well well I I'll look forward to hearing about that dialogue um I'm thinking strategically as well so uh well thank you so much for answering my questions Miss Montoya hi thank you um I want to ask a question about utilities and specifically electric um I my understanding is that we all should anticipate our electricity bills going up because of some ongoing things at a much higher level that has nothing to do with schools and I'm not I don't have a complete understanding of all of that so I don't know if it's just residential or residential and Commercial I

155want to know if the increased amount that we see is that because we anticipate our rate going up in that regard just so that the public is clear about you know or are we just leaving the lights on before we leave no it's a it's a planned uh ass making the Assumption on on our current utilization what the plan rate increases thank you um and then as it regards to the Chromebook repair I I saw the the table that you included which is really great thank you I appreciate that so you can see this really large increase from year to year of the past three years um is this what we would call normal wear and tear or maybe some of it or are we are there other challenges to having these Chromebooks for our

156students this is a relatively new phen phenon in mcps uh having personal Computing devices that are assigned to students assigned to classrooms and assigned to schools in the volume that we've been doing and since the pandemic it is a little bit of a learning curve but this is not a regular from normal wear and tear um if anything uh some of the normal wear and tear seems to to have leveled off more or less in terms of the the volume of of things that happen but it is something that you have to plan for it it's a huge expense uh the things that uh become a little irritating are the same things that regular consumers find irritating that the cost of one thing one day is different than the cost of one thing tomorrow and

157uh and keeping Pace with some of those inflationary impacts that that really are are very very difficult to manage sometimes and to forecast for and as a related question and perhaps it actually can apply to the instruments as well that Miss was asking about um because especially I know at the elementary school level they're a a lot of instruments and a lot of broken instruments um and sometimes they happen even right before the big performances and we're scrambling to try to figure out how this child can still perform because they' worked so hard um and I'm wondering I know we have many contracts with various vendors across the county for all of these things but is there a way to partner for example I just quickly I remembered that some mcps students were learning how

158to repair laptops and getting a certification um is there a possibility to collaborate more with Community Partners or maybe have some sort of In-House training where they can receive SSL hours it also gives them a great marketable skill um to have their own private services to offer that um and just whether or not we look into these types of things not withstanding all of the things that all of you have to look into I think it's a great aspirational goal it's not something that I've accounted for in this budget um uh or in the last few months but I I think that that's 100% a a a good thing for us to lean into over time time uh for sure think it would help a lot and even if it even if it didn't uh

159improve our financial standing what a great experience opportunity for our students and uh a a great learning experience for them thank you all right Miss Rivera Ain um thank you for that um on uh the grand riter positions I forgot to mention this these because to me this is these are very key positions um so you are budgeting for two positions um just wanted to hear division of what what do you think these folks are going be going after what kind of Grants So currently this would be a 200% increase to our grants office of one person um which which we know that there are things that we pass up on because we don't have the capacity to apply and then later to manage uh some of the grant ations there are very large uh

160federal grants that we could be applying for that are competitive uh that we have passed on because often times those very large federal grants are 100 200 300 Pages just in the Grant application and then there's the management on top of that those are definitely lucrative opportunities that we forego um there are also smaller uh Community grants that are less of a maintenance burden in terms of a management expense that we also feel like we could pursue but again the volume is prohibitive to us and we really have to be selective uh about what we go after and and and how this may also necessitate us to revisit this and maybe even expand in future years to to having a a broader grants foot footprint uh there are finite dollars in the philanthropic space um

161but one of the things that this community clearly values is that when we work with other community agencies in concert and we're able to do things together uh it's a very powerful thing when we can work with some of our nonprofit Community to apply for some of these grants in concert but they also have limited capacity so there's really some win-win opportunities that we envision but my uh immediate need or my immediate proposal is really about not giving up great opportunities that we see that we really could be very competitive for just because we don't have the capacity and right now we just don't have the capacity with one person in a district our size to to manage grants and to apply for Grants is just it's just a huge limitation for us and thank

162you for doing that Dr Taylor has always puzzled me even before I joined the board um of Education why in such a large District like ours because I know for a fact we also leave a lot of money of f use grant funding because we have the lack of management and and and and these are dollar amount that can have a significant impact on the education and and um in our system so I think that is great some of the issues that we're talking about I think could be focused the tutoring issue you know we don't have any more extra funding but we do have local foundations that are very focused on equity and education and we're very fortunate to live in the in this area where they are foundations that do want to make

163a difference and want to support in equities in our system so my hope is that we also kind of go after some of those fundings to bring some of those areas that we know that worked during Co one of them being tutoring for our children um even the fixing of of the instruments for for our kids having maybe a grant funding that be able you know uh be able to to do that um there are things that I think we can we can do a lot with but having one person do it all is just it was just such a lack of vision and anyway we'll leave it at that but um one of the things that um Miss wolf touched on where was uh that we need to be intentional activity about is that

164looking at the special ed um increase of budget one of the things that is has concerned for the last few years is the increase of EML special education and that has been a significant increase across the board and I hope that with this budget we can actually intentionally look at why we're having that huge disparity um in that area and um one of the things I'm a little bit uh confused about was the nurses the the what Miss Yan brought up with u uh the 2 point whatever million5 million 2.5 million correct me if I'm wrong is this I saw the nurses were uh County employees and that that was something that was in the budget of HHS so I'm trying to understand what is what is the cost to us yeah so we we

165actually have a population of nurses that serve our students with disabilities um with some really unique needs and uh so a lot of this I think is reflective of that if I'm not mistaken so okay so we're talking not the School nurses but we're talking about the special nurses in special education that some children need to have them 24 hours so they need to have them with them in order for them to be able to attend school so we're talking about two different things yeah and we're serving thank you so much for that question and yes um we we are serving uh some students with some really significant and severe disabilities that uh require um uh feeding tubes and and even some surgical equipment uh that that travels with the student uh in in our

166our educational setting and uh and this is in our comprehensive schools as well as some of our special schools and so uh that that's a that's a need that actually continues to grow so that is a cost that we cannot uh we in other words it is what it is and we need to to serve the students by law we have to provide those Services I just want to say that on that on that point um nurses is another area where there is a huge deficit off and so even the county has a hard time providing the nurses that we have our schools um and they're contractual uh and so on so this is an area that definitely is an area that it would be great if we can grow our own and support what

167we already do in the high schools with our early nursing you know nurses program that we have in different schools and be able maybe to have a path of scholarships for those students that they can actually come back to mcps and serve you know um this huge need um I would love to see that um and just to reiterate the $800 million benefits right and this is to cover not just our current employees but also all those folks who have worked so hard in our system so this is to include our retirees as well and is that number also going to include the transition of the 366 par Educators who are now going to get full benefits does that number reflect that are we thinking it it does in the budgeted amount it is reflective

168of that that's a good question thank you thank you Miss sestri um back to the big um compensation number um could you restate the increase that we are proposing for this year percentage wise and what it was last year might have to have someone look up the last year percentage I was not with you at that time uh this year's uh percentage is right around uh 5% total a little over 5% total uh three and a uh three and a quarter per increase is the uh effectively the uh um the inflationary offset uh cost of living offset and then the step uh for uh a Year's worth of experience Merit uh credit so um those two together are just a little over uh 5% increase and it and it varies depending on the employee group

169and uh where someone is on a specific step scale uh some percentages are higher than others but uh the ballpark is Right a little bit above 5% if I'm not mistaken we're giving you the answer from last year year last year there were a few different things going on um uh so there was a there were some increases to the salary scale for SEIU for example to of 3% um there were salary scale increases for MCA as well um so if if this time around it's around 5% is it was it more than 5% or less than 5% and I'm sorry the structure was so different last year that I'm having trouble sorting that out in my head at this moment but um that's okay I I the number looks stru very differently last year

170the 192 million looks bigger than what I remember the placeholder was last year so I'm trying to wrap my head around in terms of the increase in relation to last year hi kly Thompson acting budget director so last year we had a mix of flat amount increases in percentages and then if you'll recall um in terms of a general wage adjustment the gwa for our MCAT mboa Union they did not not have a gwa uh for FY 2025 um but there were step increases for that Union for mcea um it was a flat rate increase for gwa um for our 10-month employees that was $2,918 uh plus a step and then for our SEIU union um it was a 3% gwa increase in a step um can you repeat the um teachers sure so the

171uh 10-month employees it was $2,918 for the GW UA and for our 12month employees that was about $3,428 and then the step increase I'm just I'm not um I just I need you to follow up and just tell me um is it a bigger number this year than last year sure thank you um and finally Dr uh Taylor um going back to class size because this is a a popular item in the community could you give us your vision for how you would like to handle class class size in the future I know it's not in this budget for this year upcoming year but what do you see happening in the next year or so so that we can address class size in the future thank you um I think to really do a good

172job of addressing class size we need to to do a couple of things from a system standpoint first um the the first thing that we need to do is uh to make the shift from having Staffing guidelines to having Staffing standards and here's what I mean by that because they are two radically different ideas uh the current structure that we have right now as guidelines are flexible um there is uh no expectation uh when a guideline is stretched that uh there is fulfillment of that guideline after the start of the school year so if class size magically balloons at a school um there is no mechanism uh within the school district right now to respond to that other than us and and our attentiveness to a specific issue and the amount of funds that we

173have that we could apply to that issue having standards and funding those standards sets hard and fast rules in terms of what we would expect from classroom to classroom to classroom based on whatever environmental conditions that we would want to put in place um and that really does need to be the what we would expect what we have right now is a great uh amount of variability from one campus to the next across the county and there is not a whole lot of continuity in terms of what a parent could expect in one corner of the county versus what they could expect in another corner of the county in terms of what class size can be there's also not great continuity between what a parent could expect from one grade level to the next based

174on whatever discretionary Staffing uh the the building principal has in place at the at the time and I'll give you an example um a building principal may have nine teachers allocated to two different grades and they put four in one grade and five in another class sizes will be inherently smaller in the uh grade that they have five and inherently larger in the class size that in of class size in the grade that they have four we can probably do a better job of uh setting what those expectations look like that being said that work um should take place uh when it's not in the middle of a budget season should be very deliberate should involve our Our Community Partners and parents in that discussion as to what should a class size be at at

175specific grade levels in mcps and it will likely require us to take an it ative approach where we tackle segments of uh our class size each year where theoretically we would attack uh Early Elementary grades then late Elementary grades or high school and then Middle School uh to really look at how we staff our schools and what our expectations are and to make that this this the expectation for the county we don't do that right now um and what what one of the major criticisms that we experience and rightfully so is that the experience at one school is dramatically different than the experience at another school and this is one of the things that would provide a little bit more of that continuity thank you Mrs in awesome um I also have kind of a

176compensation related question um when we are talking about our position reclassification and looking at um exhibit six um I know know that all of this is right our proposed budget but I'm I'm curious um where have we gotten these numbers from have we worked with our partners to get them um just a little bit more background about exhibit six in in particular yeah we had we did a full reclassification process um and so with that we take actual numbers of uh the the employees that we have and we take their actual uh salary and benefits figures and and differentiate them that way so uh it is a reflection of what we actually have in uh in terms of positions and who does what okay um so this is like the financial impact part and um

177seeing increases in salaries this is something that our our partners um find agreeable that they're they're interested in um are in this case um for at least um for the par educator reclassification they this this is something that SEIU has advocated for that we do a reclassification study um SEIU or any of our association Partners don't have influence over dollar figures or amounts or anything along those lines uh when it comes to a reclassification other than a request to initiate uh that process and we've we've done that similarly with uh the athletic specialist athletic director position whatever you want to call it it's still the same position for whatever that's worth um you know making the transition of a supervisory position um from uh mcea to the map scales that there's a translation cost a

178switching cost and uh reclassifying that position given its level of responsibility there's there's a cost to that and that's the real real dollar figure cost okay um it's not specifically in the um chart so then how many like I I get that you can't rattle off like for each position like how many positions were moving that way um but but maybe for the athletic director position do we know how many are moving that's easy that's 26 okay or or 25 I think um yeah but for a pair of professionals we can get you that number okay great um my other question um in the Chromebook repair section um for the public can you explain why it's mainly concentrated in elementary and not across Cas I defer to you on that I don't know sure um

179I think it's just a technical aspect of not breaking being able to break that down by level and then splitting the budget between elementary middle and high um we can take a look at that but it's overall it's reflective of the costs that we incur um for schools um as it relates to Chromebook repair but I can take that back and look into a potential breakdown between level yeah CU right now it just shows a huge Chunk in elementary okay so then there is there are other expenses in middle and high school that yeah yeah that's a that's an expense that is that is spread so we can look into that okay great um and then my last question um in exhibit 32 um when we're talking about translation services um I'm wondering um have

180we considered in this as well like um translation serviceses that staff already provide and that some of that is stipended are we looking to increase that that um cuz that could in a little bit maybe if we're increasing that stipend or in increasing the number of people that can qualify for that stipend that we might see a lower a lower cost overall in those translation services and and so so there are a number of factors here and absolutely this is one where again we are adding the funds to reflect what we actually spend here so this is just but to your point about how to address this more broadly this is an area where we want to look globally and take a different approach at looking at it because we do know that the needs

181are increasing and we want to be sure we can meet all of those needs to your point about the stipended um working with staff that's an area that we um want to continue to expand um the amount is negotiated and we're happy to continue to have those conversations but we um will uh continue to look at how we can expand um that aspect of our program okay because if I'm not mistaken it's that it doesn't look like the stien amount is included in this chart maybe it's included somewhere else and I'm sorry I haven't read all the charts yet no no that's okay this piece does again reflect our actual costs and tring up our budget so this is an area where the budget line as as we've been saying this is an area where

182the budget line has been at a lower number than our actual spending every year so it's encompassing um a large number of increased costs that we're again accounting for okay thank you all right so I'm going to um as the last question it's just a request and then I want to remind everyone that we still have two more word sessions so Dr Taylor thank you this year earlier You released a contractual Services uh to the County Council um and to to the board and to the general public I'm just wondering with that piece of information I know we're structuring this completely different however if there's an in increase and decrease on that chart of contractual service I think there's a general interest out there that would like to know so if we can provide that

183that will be helpful um uh in terms of our or being transparent uh uh institution I think that's a great idea um and for the viewing public that that's looking at this this is something that uh even as a new superintendent coming to mcps m uh trying to get my head wrapped around what we are doing internally and what we uh enlist the the work of contractors or partners and consultants in that space um has been really fruitful for me to to get up to speed on and uh to to have a better understanding so to the extent that we can communicate what we were what we were spending what we plan to spend and why uh that that's a that's something absolutely we can do I think that's a great idea thank you so

184much now u i I said remind to uh our second word session will be held January 23rd and the third one will be held on Monday January 30 um and then we have two budget hearing and three Community engagement set up so I encourage everyone check out our website and the notices will be going out and thank you everyone for such engaging conversation this morning I look forward to more conversation on the budget thank you for the administration uh may I have a motion to adjourn the meeting so moved second second all in favor raise your hand that's unanimous with those with all of us meeting ajour [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.