001[Music] good afternoon everyone welcome to the January 9th 2025 Bard business meeting is our first meeting of the calendar year and after a 3ay snowstorm break all right welcome to my board colleagues and welcome to mcps staff and community members we have some little ones joining us today both in the room and online Okay so let's first all stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you now I will do the roll call to recognize board members to establish that we have a quorum I'm going to start from this side for Neil suarna student member of the board hoping all the students enjoyed their three and a
002half day uh extra long weekend happy New Year uh Natalie Zimmerman District 2 good afternoon everyone when start this I'm Carla sylvestri School Board member at large good afternoon bu good r representing District 1 good afternoon happy New Year Brenda wolf District 5 good afternoon Rita Montoya good afternoon Laura Stewart and I'm representing District 4 welcome back thank you everyone now before we go to the agenda I here I want to uh give a shout out to all our staff who have been working in the past few days uh at the food distribution site uh sites we have 18 and then more the uh Wednesday and also to all our emergency um staff who actually worked through the night last night in this cold weather so that we can open school today so can you
003join me in giving all of them a round of applause so now we are going to begin the meeting with the approval of the agenda move approval do I have a second second all in favor that's unanimous all right so um as meet we meet today um services are being held for Jimmy Carter the 39 president of the United States uh following his passing last month now you might not know but President Carter began his political career as a member of the Board of Education of Suter County Georgia and devoted significant time to education issues and he once said I remain convinced that education is one of the noblest Enterprises a person or a society can undertake so please join me in honoring President Carter with a moment of silence thank you all right we
004are going to move to uh through our agenda this next one is Dr Taylor do we have appointments today thank you madam president I have two uh recommended appointments for the board's consideration today uh when I call your name if you could please stand while I say some wonderful things about you and uh the board reviews your your appointment consideration first up is Mrs Julie a Morris for the position of director in the department of plan planning design and construction in the office of facility management and operations Mrs Morris has been employed with Montgomery County Public Schools for 15 years as a planner and most recently as a facilities manager um in the office of District Operations Miss Morris uh looks forward to collaboration with internal and external stakeholders in the division's current and upcoming
005uh planning studies design and construction of new facilities I have a motion move approval I second the motion all in favor that's unanimous [Applause] congratulations thank you Madame President our next and uh final uh person being recommended for appointment this evening is Mrs Brooks P Kemp for the position of principal of Bradley Hills Elementary School joining her today are a whole crew of people uh led by her husband Rob her children Bobby and Josie as well as some of her administrative colleagues Mr Chris nardy Dr Stacy Smith and Dr Jennifer Webster uh Mrs Kemp has been employed with mcps for 23 years as a teacher resource teacher team leader content specialist assistant school administrator and most recently as an assistant principal at Bells Mill Elementary School she is excited to return to the Walt Whitman
006cluster and will be dedicated to serving the students staff and caregivers in a nurturing environment that promotes social emotional well-being and academic Excellence for all shout outs to her parents Tara and Joseph Pomo and the uh Thomas W pile Middle School running group who are watching online move approval I second all in favor that's unanimous congratulations [Applause] we also have some special recognitions today yes uh thank thank you Madame President um I have uh two uh resolutions that I'd like for the board's consideration and I'm going to be reading uh a truncated version of uh both resolutions for the board's consideration the first one is a resolution uh recognizing teen Dating Violence awareness and prevention month and uh it goes uh uh to this measure whereas the national Resource Center on domestic violence has designated
007the month of February 2025 as teen Dating Violence awareness and prevention month to raise Community awareness about teen dating violence and whereas teen Dating Violence is also called uh Dating Violence is an adverse childhood experience that affects millions of young people in the United States and is preventable resources are aail available for teens families schools and communities and uh therefore be it resolved that the Montgomery County Board of Education and the superintendent of schools hereby proclaim the month of February 2025 as teen Dating Violence awareness and prevention month and support the choose respect Montgomery respect Fest to be held on April 6 2025 through continued uh education in health classes and motion of public service announcements um uh at a public service announcement contest Montgomery County Public Schools continues to work towards ending teen Dating
008Violence by empowering young people to develop healthier relationships assist students and families in accessing information and resources and engage in discussions with family members and peers to promote awareness and prevention of teen Dating Violence may I have a motion move approve I second the motion all in favor unanimous thank you thank you madam president my uh Second and last uh recommended uh resolution recognizes National School counseling week and I'll read a truncated version of this uh resolution as well whereas National School counseling week in 2025 uh with the theme School counseling helping students Thrive will be celebrated February 3rd through the 7th 2025 to focus public attention on the unique contribution professional school counselors make in helping students achieve academic and social emotional success plan for a career and become ready for college and whereas
009National School counseling week highlights the tremendous impact that professional school counselors have in helping students achieve success in school and encourage students to pursue challenging academic ources to prepare them for college and careers therefore be it resolved that the Montgomery County Board of Education and the superintendent of schools hereby proclaimed February 3rd through the 7th 2025 as National School counseling week in Montgomery County Public Schools and recommend the uh observance in all of our school communities move approval I second all in favor that's unanimous thank you uh our next item it's public comments I think that's why we see so many little ones in our borro room today and uh before we start that I have a stand standard pretty long passage to read so please bear with me public comments is one of our
010opportunities to hear the views and receive the advice of community members board members will take your comments into consideration but it is not our practice to take action at this time on issues that are raised we encou we encourage public input on policy program and practices this is not the proper Avenue to address specific student or employee matters so we encourage everyone to utilize existing Avenues of redress for complaints this is a public meeting and we expect the conduct of all speakers and members of the audience to be with within the bounds of proper etiquette inappropriate personal remarks rude retorts or other such behavior is out of water and will not be tolerated those who demonstrate disrupted or disrespectful behavior during public comments may be asked to leave the room please check our website for
011information about upcoming board meetings hearings and work sessions including any changes to our meeting start time so today we have 14 people sign up to provide inperson testimony each speaker will receive two minutes for comments when your name is called please approach the table speak clearly and directly into the microphone 30 seconds prior to the expiration of a speaker's time a yellow light will go on accompanied by a beep a red light and a buzzer signals that your time has expired please push the flat button below the microphone to turn it on and begin speaking push the same button once more at a sound of buzzer to turn it off uh we also have three people sign up to provide audio and video testimony who will play these submissions once the in-person testimonies have concluded
012copies of the testimonies can be on board dogs where they are posted with the other materials for this meeting so I'm going to invite the first six speakers to come to the front and they are anua mulu Amando Grandy Gomes Lauren cudia Jennifer bra bill Victoria Hill and Aaron burger please proceed to the table looks like we have five I'm going to call one more Philip Hill is Philip Hill in the house Lua you may begin good afternoon Dr Taylor members of the board and my fellow students my name is Ana Malo and I am a junior at Montgomery Blair High School in October 2023 the Montgomery County Police Department identified the student responsible for sending bomb threats to paint Branch High School earlier that year mber high school had experienced three bomb threats in
013a single month in September 2024 mcps police were dispatched at Walt Whitman High School due to a bomb threat in the spring of 2024 Wooten high school was put into shelter and place mode and Einstein High School's Administration evacuated students while police searched the area it wasn't until the fall of 2024 that mcps decided to implement the ID policy and although this policy was an important step in the right direction from a students perspective this ID policy is still not enough depending on the school IDs may be checked every day or the policy may be ignored altogether while the idea of an ID policy is great in theory its implementation is ineffective because there's little motivation for students to consistently wear their IDs without an incentive yes you may explain that the ID policy is
014for safety but simply telling students that it's for their own good from my own perspective is not enough to make them want to wear it in addition to ID serving as a safety measure I want to propose a secondary function to them which will incentify students to wear them regularly at Blair we already scan the barcodes on our IDs to print passive or check out books if mcbs could build on this system and expand it to all high schools in the county by creating a checkout system containing free hygiene products Narcan and school supplies with this system students would have an additional reason to ensure they have their IDs with them this would allow students to discreetly access products they need to threat to treat drug overdoses and hygiene issues while also motivating students to
015wear their IDs consistently and encourage others to do the same thank you thank you you may proce um is Amando here no so then is uh Lauren Kilda hello my name's Lauren Kai my daughter is a student at Seven Locks Elementary School last month a third grader with a documented record of assaulting girls in his grade threatened to bring a gun to school in his backpack and kill everyone I've been shocked at the lack of response from mcps since that happened I graduated from Virginia Tech and I've seen firsthand what one deranged person can do to a community thanks to restorative justice practices the student received no consequences for his threat he could bring a gun to school and still not be expelled or even removed from the classroom even if the student could not
016get his hands on a gun I'm sure there are items like knives in his home that could be weaponized yet our school is refusing to perform even a search of his backpack going forward it's bad enough that mcps holds disruptive kids as accountable as Hollywood in the 1950s our girls are being forced to accept fake apologies and rationalize the behavior of the person who assaulted them I should not have to tell my daughter to tiptoe around a boy in her class in order to stay safe if you're going to remove consequences for threats of violence and force my daughter to be in class with kids who make these types of threats then I implore you to spend our tax dollars on safety measures that will keep her safe I know you are aware of the
017security gaps Mrs Hill has brought them to your attention repeatedly I'm here to reiterate her demand for the ability to call 911 mandated infrastructure security assessments security buttons and school resource officers while younger children are less likely to engage in criminal Behavior elementary schools still face the possibility of external threats such as Intruders or targeted violence the presence of an SRO in elementary schools would ensure a rapid response to any potential danger would I rather have an extra teacher in smaller class sizes sure in a perfect world I would but our world is far from perfect and the reality is you can't teach dead kids you've chosen to send the message that these kids can do and say anything and get away with it at least have the integrity and honor to protect the rest
018of the students who are being forced to sit in classrooms next to the person that assaulted them perhaps in the meantime you can invite these violent children to come sit in your offices for a day while you work make sure no one checks their bags on the way in fire your security officers and leave your cell phone at the door then you'll have the experience that our teachers and children have every day you work for us and these policies have done nothing but make schools more dangerous thank you for your time thank you Jennifer brabel thank you um and thank you for the opportunity to speak according to every town for gun safety in 2024 there were at least 205 incidents of gunfire on us school grounds and the K through2 school shooting database reports
019that about 20% of those school shootings last year happened at elementary schools given these statistics it's irrational to think that a school shooting couldn't happen here in Montgomery County or that it won't happen and I know you can't change the culture of guns in this country um but you do have the power to make a difference and you can allocate resources for some very simple safety measures in particular we need an appropriate crisis communication system with emergency alert buttons available to elementary school teachers and administrators currently there are many elementary schools in our district that have no selfservice in large sections of their buildings and this leaves teachers without the ability to call 911 from their cell phones in the event that there is an emergency when they often have less access to landlines if
020they're lucky enough to even have landlines in their classroom but Montgomery County is lucky to have experts on hand such as the district chief of security and compliance and the director of the office of systemwide safety and Emergency Management they can provide guidance on which crisis Communications tools would be the most coste effective and beneficial given the limited cellular capabilities on behalf of so many concerned parents I ask that you allocate the necessary resources to be able to have these crisis communication systems in place which would include emergency alert buttons and this might be just an initial step to solving a larger problem about Security in our schools but it really could mean everything thank you next Victoria H I'd like to welcome new board members Stuart Montoya and Zimmerman I have testified multiple times
021on the lack of essential security measures in our elementary schools including the ability to call for help during an emergency today you have heard testimony about the incident at Seven Locks Elementary where a student threatened to bring a gun and shoot everyone in the school the only thing worse than the lack of action taken by the Seven Locks principal and their director is that Seven Locks is defenseless should this student or any other student choose to make good on their threat there are board members who do not believe what I say about elementary school security when they inquire about the veracity of my testimony they are told half truths or outright lies I'm here today to beg you not to take my word or anyone else's on anything security related and please go see for
022yourself you can begin at Seven Locks Elementary there you will find there is no cell phone reception throughout the school and there are no emergency call buttons cameras are unmonitored and are not connected to the police there are no alarms on the doors sure the classroom doors lock but there is a large section of particle board right next to them that a person can kick in and crawl right through and no one knows these vulnerabilities better than current and former students then talk to Montgomery County Police they'll tell you that their radios don't work in elementary schools either and they are begging to work with mcps to make our school safer after you discover the truth for yourself please direct your office of systemwide safety and Emergency Management to conduct standardized school security assessments beginning
023at Seven Locks and covering all 136 elementary schools including schools like bri Grove that has no cell reception and only one landline for 12 classrooms at the end of a hallway everything I've brought to light over the last year has been ignored I am looking to you new members some who have children in mcps with hope that you'll work with me and other concerned parents to save our most vulnerable students lives thank you thank you next Aaron Burger good afternoon as an mcps parent I'm here to today to ask that more funding and resources be allocated towards Safety and Security improvements within mcps I implore you to listen to The Experts within your leadership Community such as Chief Jones and director Michelle as4 as well as the parents in the community who are bringing such
024much needed attention to the topic of school safety safety shouldn't be a topic that members like myself and the community should have to raise with you safety and well-being of all students and staff members within mcps should be without a doubt your number one and absolute highest priority each and every day when lifethreatening risks present itself you must take action for example and not to be dramatic the tragic events of 9/11 changed our country forever in the aftermath of the destruction and morning there was an intense period of reflection assessment and evaluation of our safety and security measures Nationwide in the months that followed air travel concert goinging Prof professional sporting events and more changed dramatically security has increased almost everywhere even at meetings just like this one an elaborate screening processes have been implemented
025in many areas to prevent more attacks and any further loss of life I'm going to repeat myself a risk was identified so safety measures changed when the threat of covid-19 emerged and case numbers began to rise everything shut down our schools were closed but when you eventually allowed them to reopen you did so with requiring masking distancing and testing protocols again a risk was identified and you then you made the approp appropriate changes to safety me measures when the weather drops but a few inches of snow um salt is sprayed parking lots are plowed and school is closed or delayed a risk identified safety measures implemented then why as an epidemic of school shootings that's running rampant across our country are our safety measures within mcps not changing dramatically um that's about it thank you
026you can send us your testimony thank you um Philip Hill on December 18 at Seven Locks Elementary my daughter a third grader was sat beside a student when he threatened to bring a gun in his bag and shoot everyone in the school this student has a documented History of Violence towards his peers yet it took until the following evening for a message to be sent by a principal that only went to parents in the class that message downplayed the threat calling it an inappropriate comment my daughter said that's not an inappropriate comment an inappropriate comment is saying someone looks odd how is it that an 8-year-old can have a clearer sense of what constitutes a danger than Elementary School principal the following day the same student was allowed to go on a field trip no
027consequences no safety checks despite parents concerns requesting simple actions like checking the student bag for weapons nothing has been done how would any of us feel if someone came into this room today and made the same threat would we just let them back in tomorrow without taking any precautions the same student last year physically assaulted my daughter twice when he made his declaration for violence my daughter displayed more more bravery than her principal as Shen stating what you said is not okay it's against the whole world's rules my daughter was instructed to go into the hallway with her bully unsupervised where he then threatened her police officers have warned me that she will now be targeted by him for further violence yet when I asked the principal to move this student out of my daughter's
028class or at least conduct a bag search I was told the safety plan would not involve any class changes or searches how much more danger does my daughter have to face before mcps Acts how far does a student need to go before something is done my daughter loved going to school now she's afraid she feels abandoned by the very people entrusted to protect her classrooms are not safe the lack of action and consequences cre has created an environment where Bullies Are emboldened and victims are left to offend for themselves children are taught there are no consequences for violent Behavior if this culture continues I fear it will lead to a breakdown in trust and safety and encourage vigilante justice I'm asking you to take real immediate action to keep my daughter and all students safe
029thank you thank you I'm going to call the next six speakers uh to come to the front Patricia serin Melinda chassid F Esther Wells Allison Williams ad leer and Ja Cole enjo Patricia you may begin good afternoon my name is Patricia Surin I'm a parent of a second grade student at Harriet Tubman Elementary School in gburg and the president of our Tubman Tigers PTA I'm here today to speak on behalf of the parents staff and community members who are growing increasingly concerned about the safety of our children particularly when it comes to the lack of proper fencing around the school grounds since opening in August 2022 we have seen numerous troubling incidents that highlight the urgent need for a secure environment the exposed black top playground and turf field have all become areas of concern
030the general lack of security during recess and the free movement of people across the school grounds while children are playing have left many of us feeling anxious there have been reports of open drug use and adult relations after dark creating unsafe environment for students and staff additionally we've had multiple occurrences of community members both with and without pets walking across campus while students are outside on more than one occasion these individuals have refused to leave school by the staff they're simply unacceptable it's not an environment that supports effective learning or the peace of mind that parents deserve earlier in 2024 we were told that fencing had been approved and would be installed soon yet here we are with no fencing in place the lack of progress has only increased the frustration and anxiety that parents
031are feeling we've been told that there are ongoing discussions between mcps and the City of Gaithersburg regarding the turf field but we are still waiting for Action what we are asking for is simple we need the entire play area enclosed this includes the playground the blacktop and the turf field we do not want just a small inadequate barrier that leaves our children vulnerable to the same problems we've been experiencing if you look at the fencing of nearby schools of gaitherburg Elementary you'll see examples of safety me measures that should have been in place at Harriet Tubman we deserve and are asking for a solution that ensures the same level of safety for our children thank you for your time thank you Melinda Melinda Melinda good afternoon good afternoon my name is Melinda Chik fruar I
032am the parent of a first grader at her element as well as the vice president of the Tubman Tigers PTA I'm here to speak on behalf of the Tubman Community about the fencing around the school there is no fence enclosing the area that our children play on which includes a playground a black top area and a turf field which is for shared use with the city of gaitherburg a small sign from the city of Gaithersburg states that the turf field is restricted to school use during the hours of 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. the present fencing proposal by mcps office of facilities management is insufficient it proposes to enclose only the playground and the black top area in a 4ot high fence and requires gates to access the turf field Tubman students play on this
033CH field during recess gym class field day and for before and after school activities we feel strongly that a placing a fence between the black top playground area and the turf field will restrict its use rather than encourage it also if the students do continue to have access to the turf field during school hours the lack of a fence around the turf field leaves us in almost the same situation with community members accessing the field when scho use should be restricted to the school not only do students use the turf field for recreation building code requires access to the turf field in the event of an emergency situation while Gates can certainly be opened will all staff who need to open these Gates have the key or the code available in the event of an
034emergency we in the Tubman Community feel that strongly that a better choice would be to put a higher fence enclosing the playground black top and turf field to continue to allow students open access to this great recreational facility we understand there are discussions that need to take place with the city of gaitherburg because of the shared use agreement of the turf field as this is now the middle of the third year of instruction at Harriet tman Elementary we recommend these discussions need to take place immediately so that a sensible and safe fencing solution can be put in place at our school as soon as possible thank you for your consideration thank you Esther good afternoon board president Yang board members superintendent Taylor staff and community members my name is Esther Wells and I'm the proud
035mom of 2 mcps students I've reviewed the superintendent's proposed FY 2026 operating budget and need to share the following transparency please provide the community with how much the maintenance of effort ore for FY 2026 and Trend analysis ofe over the last three years this will this will help community members digest the big ask of $ 3.61 billion any incremental state revenue funding should be offset to local Revenue funding as the proposed budget is requesting $285 million or 13.4% increase year-over-year that is a big ask can mcps share its plan to recruit and hire 688 FTE at 46.7 million in recent years there has been a consistent theme of requesting an operational Workforce of fdes that did not materialize please revise the budget before board tenative approval to only ask taxpayers to fund mcps operations at
036levels that are achievable and please reduce the level of transfers out of instructional salaries categories accountability while we are always working to improve Bud budget formulation we remain laser focused on what the taxpayer is getting for their money according to Bethesda today literacy shows that the number of kindergarteners that reached the Benchmark decreased overall from almost 50% in Fall 2023 to 47% in Fall 2024 the the presentation will also show that for math proficiency kindergarteners showed a significant drop in the number meeting the benchmarks for map what is mcps planning to do to address some of the declines in kindergarten scores summer enrichment programs will summer enrichment programs be By Invitation Only or made available to all of Elementary School and Middle School general education students what is the plan for incoming uh kindergarten students
037to have access to summer school even if it's at a fee access ability delayed release of special education Staffing plan please ensure it's released at the same time as the budget thank you thank you next is Allison hi thank you for hearing us today um I represent kindergarten teachers who are strongly suggesting that self- selected Center social emotional learning time be reinstated to the schedule and made a requirement for kindergarten classes um honestly play should be a part of grades K to 12 to enhance learning once children stop liking school it is hard to get them to like it again and once they do not like School their learning rate is adversely affected how do we teach children to love learning in school well number one is relationships connections between teachers and students and students
038to students but effective learning is when students are doing what they want to be doing and it is the same as what their teachers want them to be doing children Thrive when they are able to experience Wonder curiosity and joy in learning Hands-On learning Discovery based learning and play based learning provide venues for children to be immersed in Wonder curiosity and joy the new CK La curriculum is a 2-hour whole group reading lesson with two table work breaks and maybe 15 minutes of Hands-On learning with letter tiles it's not developmentally appropriate to expect any child to sit in one place and sustain attention for such a long period of time needless to say this curriculum does little to promote Wonder curiosity and joy but play is the common language of children children Master relationships creative
039thinking critical thinking conflict resolution sharing taking terms how to work together as a team but play also has deep connections to academics research demonstrates that links between play and acquisition of academic skills deepen content knowledge in the domains of math reading science and computer technology science research explains that when you play certain parts of the brain are activated chemicals are released and they focus on memory and attention so why have we removed such an important and Powerful piece of a child's learning seeking Equity we do Drive children to learn to read earlier but this deprives them of social emotional learning and is that Equitable to Foster children's reading skills and stunt abilities to work with others let's reinstate Joy by allowing self-selected centers to come back thank you thank you um next I think is
040adate did I say your name correctly I I I okay all right go ahead thank you board members for being given the opportunity to speak today every day in our classrooms I see teachers doing their best to reach every student adapting lessons for different learning styles and providing extra support where needed and trying to challenge those who are ready for more but the reality is our educators are stretched thin and some students especially those with learning differences or those just learning English aren't getting all the support they could be technology has transformed how we teach and learn and new digital tools offer a real chance to help both our students and teachers Thrive think of a student struggling with reading comprehension who could get instant help breaking down complex texts or a teacher who could
041quickly generate practice problems tailored to each student's level these aren't far off possibilities schools are already using these tools successfully to give students more personalized attention and support what we need now is your support to bring these learning tools to all our students in a thoughtful way with proper training for our teachers and clear guidelines to protect student privacy and ensure equal access we can give every child in Montgomery County the personalized support they need to succeed thank you for your time thank you next is Jack good afternoon members of the Board of Education and a special welcome to the newer faces on the board my name is Jax Kobe I use l them pronouns and I am a proud mcps Alum as a graduate from w I've always valued the education I received but
042it's important to acknowledge that not all students have access to the same resources or opportunities looking at the school profiles and data dashboard I found major discrepancies that raise serious concerns about Equity across our schools specifically after using GIS to display School data geographically I've been able to see the large extent to which a student's geography impacts their opportunity I've compiled all of the information into a document which I encourage you to take a look at with the link or QR code I'd love to explain it in more detail but I only have 2 minutes as the board begins to undertake the boundary study I urge you to proceed with caution while boundary adjustments should promote diversity they must also address resource disparities in meaningful ways diversity alone will not eliminate the achievement Gap if
043systemic inequities persist I encourage the board to ensure that this process does not become a Band-Aid solution but rather part of a larger strategy to dismantle structural racism in our schools ultimately if mcps is serious about addressing racism in schools it must collaborate with with the County Council to tackle housing segregation the connection between housing and education is undeniable where students live largely determines the resources they can access but breaking the cycle requires bold action policies that promote affordable housing Equitable school funding and inclusive zoning policies the legacy of segregation is not just history it's a living reality that affects students today by addressing these issues headon mcps has the opportunity to lead the way in creating a truly Equitable education system one that gives every student regardless of their race or zip code an
044equal chance to succeed thank you thank you um we I'm we are going to play some uh virtual um testimony so can we roll Mr Sterling High's testimony oh are you here in person wonderful Mr Sterling High come on good afternoon president Yang Dr Taylor and members of the board I'm here as an MVA parent now with two blp students and as an advocate for students and teachers who need access to public Virtual School in Montgomery County I'm deeply concerned that a budget claiming to be zerob based and focused on meeting students basic needs does not include a virtual school with more than 300 million in additional funding requested including 2 million for a program with the same flaws as hht how is there no room to ensure every child has access to a school
045not just coursework but a school that benefits the entire system and will not be dismissed on the whim you already have the per pup allocation to make this happen leveraging them will satisfy the need and attract more students and more funding in future years one of your legislative priorities is advocating for a Statewide virtual school but we know from our own advocacy that is not realistic the state lacks the authority funding and the appetite to create one however Maryland law already allows local districts to establish virtual schools alone or in Consortium funded by the same per pup allocations as any other school the power to act is in your hands not Annapolis and in this budget proposal mcps is leaving kids Behind mcps is already using virtual learning in for enrichment for advancement but not
046for Baseline access to reference Dr Taylor's popcorn analogy there are students who can't even get into the popcorn bag without a virtual school don't they matter too kids who can't attend brick and mortar schools because of medical learning or circumstantial barriers are left behind isolated and underserved they jump through hoops to get scraps let me be clear kids especially young ones need more than peac Mill schedules they need full-time teachers who know them administrators who support them and a community where they can collaborate and grow segregating kids into fragmented programs is not Equity it's neglect we we seen virtual schools work we've done it and we've done it well if this budget is truly about filling gaps and meeting needs the absence of the virtual school is a fatal oversight let's not miss the chance
047to do what's right by establishing a secrist virtual school we can once again ensure that every child has access to the education that they need to thrive thank you thank you we have one last inperson testimony from Mr Amando gry Gomes come to the front I I start Gomez Gomez thank you can you push the button there is that on yes can you hear me now yes okay thank you thank you so hello to the new members of the Board of Education and all of you that I've seen before and Dr Taylor thank you it's a pleasure to be here my name is Armando gry Gomez as a member of this community I'm also representing BCE black Coalition for Education excellence which I noticed doesn't seem to get on your radar screen too much or
048seems to get equable treatment when it comes to giving testimony but I still want to talk about some things that we know about I find it very very interesting and very disconcerting when we come here and we're having issues that have been going on especially with the issue of Wooten that is now going Nationwide that should not only be a slap in the face but this is not new the timeline we know is not new it's not new to many of you that have been on the board it's not new to some of you that have been around for a while but it seems to be all of a sudden a shock and an awe I remember the last time I was present with you one of your board members was Miss wolf brought up
049an attention of another issue that was disconcerting when it came to issue of people that happen to look like me black people and it was newes or racial pajor or what have you the word and I'm not going to say the N word I was going to say it today but I'm not going to say it because we all know what that word is and it's not the word no it's a pejorative that seems to be very comfortably used at Wooten high school and probably many other schools within our district but I don't see any of you the outside of Miss wolf that seem to have a problem with it it seems to be business as usual now I assure you if it was another side of I mean because I also happen to be
050Jewish and Hispanic as well so if it was one of our other groups of people if we were part of the aapi like my like my stepfather is would that be an issue if racial prorities were used this should not be comfortable it should not be common place and also I want to bring up something to else to your attention when we had our schob uh representative last month had a meeting there were hardly any black faces or hardly any Hispanic faces or students do you mean to tell me that they're not a part of this equation and this this this discussion why we can't find anybody outside of Caucasian students Asian students or Indian identifying students I don't believe that we need to do better and I encourage you to do better thank you
051I won't go over thank you uh can the staff play the three video testimony will go first to Andrea McDonald good afternoon members of the school board administrators and community members my name is Andrea McDonald and I'm here to advocate for a vision that will Empower every student in our district a vision for a virtual school that serves all students not just those who are medically fragile but every student who can benefit from the flexibility and opportunities that online learning offers as we continue to adapt to the evolving educational landscape we must recognize that one size does not fit all students learn in diverse ways and many may find a traditional classroom environment challenging for a variety of reasons whether due to health concerns scheduling conflicts family situations or simply a preference for a different
052learning model a virtual school can provide the personalized flexible education that some students desperately need to thrive funding a virtual school is not about replacing our brick-and Mar classrooms it's about offering Choice it's about providing an alternative pathway for students who need a different way to engage with their studies this model can help reduce Dropout rates improve student satisfaction and support diverse learning needs from students who need more time to those who need a more rigorous challenge moreover a well-funded virtual school can be an invaluable resource to the district expanding our capacity to reach students who might otherwise fall through the cracks it can be a model of inclusivity and Innovation that reflects the future of Education not just for those with specific needs but for all students who will benefit from a more flexible
053self-paced and tailored approach investing in this virtual learning model is an investment in equity it's about giving every student the opportunity to succeed regardless of their individual circumstances I urge you to consider the potential impact of this initiative not just on today's learners but on the future of our entire School Community thank you for your time and consideration all right let's move to kber Kain happy New Year Dr Taylor president Yang and members of the Board of Education my name is kber Kane kindergarten teacher and the Montgomery County Education Association Treasurer before the winter break superintendent Taylor laid out a bold budget that called for among other things much needed investments in educator Recruitment and attention special education and emergent multilingual learning after two decades of teaching in Montgomery County Public Schools I have witnessed
054how attempts to minimize investment in special education affect all students at the elementary school level this year across the county we see many kindergarteners are making progress but some are still demonstrating the impact of misplaced special education students that we discussed in the fall most affected are our multilingual learners students who entered kindergarten with IEPs students without prek experience and students demonstrating learning or social emotional difficulties many of these students would benefit emotionally and thereby academically from self- selected centers that were removed from the instructional guidelines for kindergarten to accommodate the 2-hour daily requirements for cka language arts teachers and students are struggling under the almost non-stop mandated assessments we we need more special Educators and paraeducators in schools to tackle these huge workloads and help students learn and feel seen heard and supported as
055any early childhood expert will tell you assembling the building blocks to help our students succeed academically and to successfully navigate life with other humans is most effective and efficient when Children Are Young with the adquate levels of caring adult guidance so they start middle school with a solid foundation this budget invests in the addition of special education experts both teachers and Par Educators to classrooms where there are none or not enough we need your help to turn this bold proposed budget into a bold reality for Montgomery County students thank you next we'll do Ricky RoR hi I'm Ricky rero I'm president of the John of Kennedy High School PTSA I'm a member of the Leadership Council for the black Coalition for excellence and education and I'm the vice chair of the mccpta safety and climate
056committee the New York Times recently published an article that um explored and reported how there's a rising problem of fights in secondary schools across the US fueled by social media and cell phones these fights are have increased both in number and severity in neighboring Prince William County a student was jumped after SE by several students at Patriot High School according to local media reports and this assault was documented on video and distributed through social media and cell pH messaging platforms bringing it home here to mcps by searching on social media I was able to find a number of active and inactive school-based uh fight accounts for numerous mcps middles and high schools the existence of these accounts is not new and some actually date back to 2019 this Behavior makes students scared to come to
057school and parents reluctant to entrust mcps with the safety and well-being of their children just recently at my daughter's Middle School Odessa Shannon in fact we had a student attack another student with pepper spray the situation brings up several things that mcps needs to address one you don't have enough Safety and Security staff to deal with this Behavior while I'm grateful that Dr Taylor is recommending an increase in security assistance for next year's budget those positions aren't guaranteed to survive the approval process um and we can't stop there two we need a team in the department of systemwide safety and Emergency Management to monitor digital threats these individuals should also be in a position to liaz with technology platforms such as meta and Snapchat to quickly flag and take down concerning posts that can inflame
058or spread conflict in our schools three your digital citizenship curriculum needs an overhaul we need something that's effective and relevant to students making them click through can modules on canvas won't cut it as mcps goes through its Safety and Security update at the board today I hope that plans and interventions to disrupt this concerning trender at the Forefront for the school system we need to prioritize the safety and well-being of our students and staff with actions and not just words thank you right uh that concludes today's public comment um the next board business meeting will be on Tuesday February 4th signups for public comment will open on Tuesday January 28th at 6: p.m. in addition to the online signups for public comment we allow for iners same day signups when space allows unallocated slots may
059be filled on a first come first serve basis on the day of the meeting in order to sign up in person please arrive at least 15 to 20 minutes before the start of the Open Session and sign the form inperson sign up will close 15 minutes before public comment begins or when all slots are fill I'm now going to turn to my colleagues to see if there are any comments and questions I'm going to start from my right hand side um Miss Montoya thank you um we heard several things today that raise a concern and I'd like somebody to talk about the fencing around Harriet Tubman because I thought that issue had been taken care of I don't know if if anyone can speak to that right now but that's important and wait I've got
060one other thing oh they can come on come on if you can tell us the the only the staff thank you yeah good afternoon first introduce yourself sure Adnan Mamon Deputy Chief of facilities uh for mcps uh the fence um at Harriet Tubman um around the playgrounds is being installed currently um I we uh on from the public comments we heard the question about the height of the fence the 4ot fence around playgrounds is the standard we usually use higher fence when we are at the property line or we have to put some kind of a barrier between existing um you know um neighbor neighborhood neighboring properties between and um our schools um so the fencing is going on right now there was another comment about the uh the gates those are actually required by
061code because there is public um RightWay that leads from the school um out of those F fenced areas into public right of ways and per code we do have to provide uh exit gates those are going to be um you know equipped with exit devices that allows people in case of an emergency to be able to get out so that's the update on har Tubman okay thank you um I also heard the security concerns raised today and I'm actually offended that somebody would think that we did not take that seriously security is our highest priority in this system and it didn't take new board members coming on to reflect that because I personally have a grandson in mcps an elementary school and so yes I am on board with the idea that security is one
062of our highest concerns I also want to say that we've been dealing with the issue of access to cell phone service in our bill buildings now for some years and I thought we had been working with Verizon to try to address that issue and for some reason they don't seem to be able to help very much and our buildings some of them are old but we were working on that and I don't know if anybody can speak to that but it was also a concern as you know at McGruder with having access with the police having access to being able to talk to each other inside our buildings thank you Mr Miss motoya thank you um I just want to thank everyone for coming today especially our students our parents and caregivers many of you
063took off work or time when we've already had such a challenging week so I want to say thank you and to all of our staff that are here as well um I also want to address the Safety and Security just in the sense that I do hear you I I am a parent my kids go to schools these are things I worry about as well um I don't in any way think that any of my colleagues sitting at this table don't care about that um it is something that I know everyone has at the Forefront of their mind including racist incidents um I don't have to be a new board member to know that these things are happening or to care about them um I absolutely care that there's racism in our schools and I
064know without speaking for them that all of my colleagues do as well so I just want to be very clear that these are things that we're thinking about these are things that are important to us irrespective of how it may seem or how anyone actually may feel which I do understand um but these issues are at the Forefront of our mind thank you Miss Stu sure um I want to thank um the parents from Seven Locks to come out to talk about some of their issues um I do appreciate um that there's a lot of asks there and we do have a very tight budget so I would like to um do some analysis or ask the system to see um where uh there could be improvements um uh that's cost effective so that's something
065I would like to follow up with in the future um and also I want to reiterate uh what Miss monela just said we do take racism very seriously and there is no um instance where I think that word is appropriate in any way so I wanted to um I think everyone here would probably agree with me so um also I wanted to um Talk uh uh to mention the concern from the kindergarten teacher about um play based learning and the select the centers um I know that there is uh research out there that play-based learning is uh very effective especially in kindergarten so um let's uh look into that um I don't know maybe there's other uh ways it's being implemented instead of the centers but that's something I'd like to follow up with um
066in the future because uh we need to follow the research so thank you very much thank you I'm going to go to my left Miss Rivera Ain yeah I would like to revisit the Harriet tman um uh concerns as the person who did the walkthr a Hara Tubman when I did the walkth through quite a while ago it was one of the the first things that I did as a board member uh the concerns were for for there to be a gay put up but can you just explain a little bit more about the other concerns about access during the school time and the fencing how tall is it because they there were two suggestions back in the day when I did the walkth through um and one of them was to have much higher
067fence so I don't know which one is being currently put in two um when I did the walkth through I actually saw community members walking through the fields of the elementary school which is one one of the reasons why I remember this so clearly of the urgency of putting that up and how is that going to be handled and um and three for the black top it the aess during the day um our kids are going to be able to have full access to it and how is it being worked out then after school hours yeah so I can provide the details to you after I um get the more uh further details from the the building operations because as far as the gates are concerned again you know those need to be put in
068place because of the the code requirement we have checked with our um architect of record and that's what their recommendation was as far and um as far as the fence around the playgrounds those are um being U installed as at 4 feet um we are also talking to the city of Gaithersburg regarding the fence that that was being requested around the field correct now the field is not our property so it has to be something that we coordinate with the with the city of gburg and we have started that communication okay and the access then during the day to the that is not going to be an issue correct okay thank you all right um Mr Sana yes thank you um I just wanted to thank all all the students for coming out and sharing
069their concerns uh you know we always appreciate hearing from the students um in regards to the board of ed meeting with student leaders you know we encourage all students from all backgrounds to reach out these opportunities are open to everyone um we were lucky enough to have an incredibly diverse uh set of students at that board meeting the meeting is live um on the YouTube right now so if you want to go check uh it's 12224 um Board of Education meeting with student leaders but again um there's a lot more opportunities for students uh to be able to engage uh with mcps staff to to have their voice heard uh this is not the only one uh by and by and large uh so I I really do encourage any students who are interested from
070any backgrounds again uh to reach out because uh my my email is live live on the website um and again these opportunities are open to everyone Mrs Inman thank you um I also want to thank everyone from the community for coming out speaking before us today it's a really important part of the work that we do is to hear from everyone um I also want to thank the colleagues before me um because they asked and shared a lot of sentiments that I was hoping to Echo so in the interest of time I am going to say that thank you for um sharing I share a lot of the concerns with the community um and I look forward to hearing more from everyone else Miss Sylvester yes likewise thank you for everyone that came to provide
071your testimony today I will be following up on your concern concerns during our Safety and Security presentation uh later in the agenda thank you everyone um with that we are going to move into our next agenda item which is the tentative um action on policy GAA right so oh did I skip the whole section okay let's go back to consent these are important business we can okay so um we are going to do our consent items um consent items uh this month we have uh included uh the human uh monthly human resources and development report uh in the consent item and it's going to be where it's going to stay from now forward all right I want to ask my colleagues are there any items you would like to pull Miss Sylvester 612 612 any
072other items Miss St 6.5 6.6 and 6.7 6.5 6.6 6.2 I oh 6.7 uh anything anyone else I would like to pull 6.2 so all right can I have move the rest in blocks so moved I second okay so all in favor raise your hand all right we will go with item 6.2 first that is item I pull I have questions about uh two of the items in this uh area and I'm going to one of them is strategic implementation of absenteeism I understand I want to understand exactly what does this item what does this contract would it give us what would he [Music] provide greetings uh Dr Taylor president Yang uh vice president Rivera ubin and members of the board I'm Damon monleon associate super the office of well-being and student services and within
073our office uh we have the office of international emissions and and enrollment oh excuse me in attendance this is the other one attendance services so this is actually works with our community schools uh as well as our Office of Pupil personnel and attendance services so just this is for attendance works this is something that is coming from the community schools budget which is not part of our base budget but from from the state State um and attendance works is a national leader in addressing chronic absenteeism and promoting equal opportunities to learn and advanced really parent and Student Center practices um they're known nationally as as a leader in research-based activities and so what we were able to do is work with them and pilot schools within the community schools program right so we started with
074a number of schools last year we expanded that this year um and it really was a a an opportunity for our principles and our people Personnel workers and our counselors right and everybody who provides wraparound services our our parent Community coordinators to work with attendance Works along with the ossi directors to um identify strategies right to communicate with parents to create a sense of belonging for students in schools so they see themselves and they feel valued in school to promote education for parents around why it is so important for students to attend school certainly in the first few years for that being able to read uh by third grade and then read um to really understand complex texts um Beyond just learning to read right by by fifth grade so providing information on that and
075so when we looked at our um our data in our our chronic in our schools and our community schools um what we found last year last year was our first year really pushing out a a comprehensive program to reduce chronic absenteeism and while we did see some gains districtwide just about 3% District wide and a decrease in chronic absenteeism we saw within our community schools that participated in this program 6.2% reduction in chronic absenteeism in those schools so beyond that we've taken some of their best practices we've expanded them across the district um they're not something that are that can only be used right just just for the schools that they're serving and so we started as a district with um in 22 23 school year like many schools around the nation and the state
076at a 26% iic absenteeism rate we ended last school year at 23.1 and currently we just pulled the data we're just a hair over 20% so we are seeing gains right in reducing chronic absenteeism districtwide in addition to those Community Schools that participated so this is a a a grant basically to work with Community School which are elementary schools to reduce chronic absenteeism Dr Taylor yes thanks Doc um I would appreciate it and I think the board is looking for uh a little bit more information and you can just use an example of like one strategy that uh they use in exchange for uh the money so it's kind of like what are they getting for this expenditure and a couple of the strategies that that you're using with this program sure so I think
077F first and foremost through through attendance works it's about bringing in parents and understanding from their perspective some of the challeng they may face and as you said at the elementary level we do have a couple middle schools right that were involved as well um but we know that at the elementary level it it's not quite like high school where students are making decisions at the high school level right to come or not come so for um at the elementary level it's meeting with parents and understanding all of the challenges they may face whether those are language barriers or cultural barriers or just wound service barriers right is there rent insecurity are we have are there issues with um perhaps winter clothing so getting that voice data from the parents bringing them in having the
078parents be part of the solutions and this fits well with our community school model with every every community school has a steering team of parents and students that helps develop their overall Community Schools plan and how those funds will be used so that is one thing right training all of our staff on meeting with parents and bringing the parents in and utilizing really the information that they're sharing with us something else is about constant and consistent communication right so communication to the entire Community um about why attendance is important um about who you can contact if you need support with attendants but then also intervening and speaking with parents and reaching out to parents in real time when we see um when we see students who are hitting certain thresholds right on their way to
079being chronically absent so these are a couple of the strategies that that they've shared that have proven very beneficial thank you um I also would like to have a question about 55.1 Judy Center uh this is a long list of a Wares for the Judy Center and some of them are out of state um how do they provide services to promote children's Readiness for school good afternoon Nichelle Owens director for the division of early childhood and Title One programs and Recovery funds so our Judy centers um have to reach out to a number of vendors in order to implement their services they serve children uh actually um from birth until 5 years old or just before they enter kindergarten and to do so we need to outreach to a number of vendors including uh those
080who support support our field trips for transportation um we also reach out to vendors who support other aspects of our Judy Center Program um guidelines do you need a little bit more yeah I like give me an example there are some companies in California what what do they do for us did that list get updated I know yeah is Miss yeah it did get it did it did all right so I'm not aware of the company in California am I am I missing you have some in Colorado color thank you perfect okay so this one is a very unique one it's actually with um I believe the and while you're while you're looking at that um I'll give you a good example of one um Wegman's Food Markets Incorporated and it's noting Rochester New York
081well that's actually where the corporate headquarters of Wegman's is not our local Wegman's okay or the future Wegman's on Rockville Pike you know fingers crossed right um okay I don't and yeah the the other one I believe is with um the National Aquarium so the National Aquarium does not allow food to be brought in to its facil when we take our youngsters there instead we have to order lunches and the place where we order the lunches from which is through the National Aquarium is Catered and their headquarters is also in Denver Colorado Okay so so all of them has some connections to the to the program the address might be the address listed as their headquarter addresses okay thank you um within the 6.2 are there any items for members would like to ask thank
082you so much um I have a question about uh bid RFP number 1201.1 um which is the LA and transformational learning by national kades Network Incorporated and my question is is what is the deliverable I know this is a company perhaps incorporated or sorry a nonprofit Incorporated out of California good afternoon Nikki Hazel associate superintendent in curriculum so uh that uh they do provide professional learning for our our teachers are uh ELD teacher English language development teachers okay and can you just give me a little bit more what does that look like are these online modules are they coming out for trainings are we doing workshops or how does that I will get you more information in the past we have done in-person um training for our El teachers um to provide instruction on how
083to um meet the needs of our English Learners um and just to make sure that the um learning is more accessible to them but I will get you more information on specifically what the training is about for teachers okay because I I did take an opportunity to review the um vendor and some of their offerings and I just need to understand better how this fits in with the needs of our students and families um because that's not very clear to me at this time we'll do thank you so much thank you I'm going to go to item 6.5 so these will be pretty quick um first of all I just want to point out uh that 6.5 replaces the HVAC at Monocacy and uh this is actually really good news because it was first in
084FY appropriation and so we are now in fy2 and it is uh I believe a $6 million project um and we have I believe others we also have backlog on and so these are the kind of things I know that we want to work on in our CIP coming up and I didn't know if you have anything um since you're at the table um if you want to talk about any other um HVAC projects that are large like this um that we can expect yeah there were add additional hbac project requested in our uh CIP request that was just approved by the board back in November um I unfortunately I didn't bring my notes so I'll have to provide that list to you we are also um we did discuss during um the the CIP
085review that we're going to be reassessing our schools so that would also inform our future project so when we have our um full CIP ask um next year then we're going to be re introducing additional schools for the AG replacement well I know this was long overdue and the maintenance people have been working really hard at that school to keep um that HVAC going so that is really good news and so that brings me to um can I go to the next one yes please 6.6 which is the Eastern Middle School um design um The Architects was up picked and again that one has been on the books for a very long time and I know that we are looking to uh refresh our facilities condition index to help inform us um for the next
086project after Eastern and so uh I just thought um I'd bring up that uh that will be uh coming up soon and I didn't know if you had uh a timeline when we're going to start the refresh of the facilities conditions index yeah thanks for asking that because we do have that RFP out on the streets right now we're expecting to get those proposals back next week and we will bring the recommended vendor to help us refresh those numbers um in February excellent and so that brings me to the last Point uh and this is really a personal privilege 6.7 uh we were able to uh say that Woodland is ready to open uh for the public which is very exciting and that is something that I've personally worked on for over 10 years and
087I know the community is very excited to finally have that done and I just want to congratulate mcps for I know that was a a long road to get that project done so thank you just to piggy back on that we both did the the the site visit and I want to thank the staff and everyone involved for making such a beautiful building for our staff and students and community yes that we can go to your 6.12 okay uh if we could get the budget uh office Mr Riley maybe to come talk about the fiscal report uh that is um on the agenda for this month just a highlevel overview as the chair of the fiscal management committee what do we need to know uh on the the state of our budget as of November
08830th 2024 high level before uh Mr Ry speaks I I do want to point out something absolutely critical and joyful is that this is not a negative number in this report anymore and we are very thrilled by that and uh Mr Riley can uh illuminate some of the details that have helped lead to that yes Dr Taylor you pointed out some uh some measures that we've taken to uh correct the course so I wanted to make sure that we took some time to uh highlight that today yes good afternoon uh board members uh Rob Riley uh Deputy Chief of Finance uh at a high level this is the monthly Financial report that we present every month um to give you the financial status of where we're at um so as as uh Dr Taylor mentioned
089we are um out of the red we're into the black and slowly but surely we're we're trying to build up that that number on page two or unassigned fund balance some of the ways that we're doing it is that we are uh tasking uh departments and divisions to not spend over budget you would think that would be a a you know an easy accomplishment but it's not because some in some cases for years we have uh been spending over budget because we had the luxury of having a fund balance so uh at the end of the year some of that overage uh covered those negatives but now we are tasking everybody with looking at your budget line by line for FY 26 we went into our zerob based budgeting so along this those same lines
090we're looking at every line item and everybody in the the system is doing that we also looking at um hiring um and our hlas and our um because uh we're we're getting special approval because we're looking to see if there's a definite dire need to to make that higher in this year because as you can see we are very tight hlas are higher level assignments um so when somebody uh retires or leaves the system uh often times we'll have an a higher level assignment to and I I think you guys have seen these as well too because it's um if it's a long-term HLA we need we're looking for approval from the board but those are some of the areas as well as individual line items throughout the system thank you Dr Taylor anything you
091wanted to highlight yourself just very excited that it's working and that we're moving in the right direction and I have to give High Praise to the central Services team uh and uh to our school fiscal managers who really have taken it very seriously um the the board and the fiscal management committee have given us some clear guidance and some direction and um I'm just glad that we're following through with some internal control that uh that have taken route and have found some meaning and it sets a clear path for the course that we need to stay ahead one of the changes we are doing to Once once we identify savings or the the uh the system leaders once they identify savings we're actually putting them segregating putting in a separate account to address any uh
092shortages or throughout the year so that that's new we we've never really done that before thank you all right thank you um that's all the items for discussion may I H may I have a motion to move them in Block so moved second all in favor raise your hand that's unanimous with those present thank you everyone now we have spent all this money let's move on to our policy items all right so um the next is uh policy GAA um now mcps has faced significant challenges in workplace culture environment over the past few years underscoring the urgent need for transformative action the board is Resolute in its commitment to cultivating a Workforce that's highly effective deeply engaged and fully supported we have two priority for the 2425 school year first the board will hold mcps
093accountable for establishing a safe inclusive and welcoming environment where every student and staff member experience both physical safety and emotional well-being second the board will support the system to fortify the educator pipeline by advancing the grow your own initiatives driving Innovative Recruitment and Retention strategies and ensuring equity in Staffing decisions these priorities represent a collective pledge to build a stronger more resilient future for our schools and our community now together consistent with these priorities the board is also working to review and amend board policy GAA positive work environment in a self-renewing organization or as it would be named under the proposed amendments Workforce Excellence to support the reasons I just named above so as the com the policy management committee revealed draft amendments to this board policy at its meeting on November 14th uh that's
094what happened on November 14th so now as the chair of the committee I recommend that the draft amendments to this policy be approved by the full board and for tentative action and sent out for public comment now I want to hear especially thank former board member Rebecca SMI and shabra Evans for their work on this policy now with that I would like to pass the mic to Dr Taylor and the staffs here to walk us through the committee recommended uh draft amendments go ahead team thank you good afternoon president Yang vice president Rivera oven members of the board and superintendent Taylor my name is Leslie Turner P I'm a legal director in the office of general counsel with me is Sally Davis and of course we also have the chief of ohrd um who will
095lead off the presentation next slide please all right pick up here so our assignment from the board policy management committee was to reenvisioning GAA and first off you uh likely agree that the title was a mouthful and our read of the 2005 policy that it was diffuse in its objectives it needed a clearer Focus Focus to achieve thoughtful strategic and continuous professional growth processes for mcps employees and So based on our review of GA the writing group recommended keeping its original commitment to professional growth but building out what that should look like and so um let's go to the next Slide the board's stated purpose is to prepare all students to thrive and we think ga should recognize that all mcps employees are essential for making this happen whether they are directly engaged with students
096in the classroom and other school places or among the many employees whose contributions are more indirect who keep the schools running and running well we're all mindful today about getting our schools open when there were miles of sidewalks to be plowed uh so who support our families who keep us in compliance with various requirements and who keep the resources flowing to support the work so our first objective for policy GAA was to emphasize Workforce Excellence as a requisite for Student Success and simultaneously to recognize all employees play some important role in student successes secondly we want a GAA to see the life cycle of an employee as continuous from recruiting and onboarding to keeping employees skills sharp and to looking ahead to the many ways employees move into greater areas of responsibility and Leadership and
097when needed it also supports employees who are struggling to intervene effectively when performance Improvement is needed I'll turn to miss Kei and can we have the next slide please good afternoon president Yang vice president Rivera oven Dr Taylor members of the board we know we are a student centered organization but something we struggle with is consistently recognizing and supporting how all employees contribute to the mission next slide we also know that the professional growth system is experienced differently across all of our employees some employees only think of professional growth system as a sign that something has gone wrong performance is not meeting expectations while this is one function of professional growth it is only one of several and let's be clear if the two other components of professional growth are working and an employee never
098never need never ever needs to experience it as a sign that something has gone wrong a truly systematic approach to professional growth is much more than that that it is as much about onboarding and skill development for an employees current position as it is for encouraging employees to think ahead to where their careers in mcps might take them a truly resilient organization draws out and retains Talent nurtures employees to respond imaginatively to unfamiliar or challenging situations to persevere and to collaborate when we grow our own we return the investment we make in our employees many times over next slide please our writing group put these issues before focus groups and here's what kept coming up our professional growth system should live out our values of being antiracist supportive responsive collaborative but what does that mean
099and so we pushed the discussion to ask what makes a professional growth system anti-racist supportive responsive and collaborative and this is where we think we've improved this draft over the previous version if we really want to see the values lived out in our workplaces we need to articulate guiding principles and strategies for a professional growth system that gets us to the values that we hold next slide we know that an employees immediate supervisor has a bigger day-to-day role and getting the best from everyday employee actions for cultivating work environments that Inspire us all towards excellence and so the implementation strategies of this policy on our routine support learning focused supervision and comprehensive professional learning to raise awareness of of identifiable patterns of implicit bias in evaluation processes and disrupt such conduct within mcps we also
100know that the individual professional learning plans are more routine for licensed employees than learning plans are for other employees for licensed employees learning plans are even required in state regulations but employees in all spheres of MC PS need to be encouraged to develop professional interests develop new competencies and seek leadership opportunities and this just this isn't just how we live out our commitment to equity it's how we build a resilient organization I'll turn it back to Miss Davis okay next slide please so so in short here's what you'll see in the revised draft a new tile that we think captures what we want for mcps a clear emphasis on students as the center of our work a clear articulation of our values with respect to professional growth system and a professional growth structure with three
101connected spheres onboarding training and keeping employees skills sharp for the jobs they have now career advancement to draw out professional interests and Leadership potential to retain talent and yes should we need it a structure that fairly and effectively responds when employee performance fall short the new draft has a clear statement that supervisors are Forefront in employees daily lives where employees and supervisors alike share responsibility for Workforce Excellence so we have two recommendations today can we move forward on the slide please okay and then one more please we we would like to revise and retitle GA to emphasize a systemic approach to Workforce excellence and we would like to take tentative action to send it out for public comment I'm happy to take you through the draft and highlight but otherwise we're ready for your discussion
102next slide please does any board member need us to go through the highlights or we can go proceed to your questions and comments okay I'm going to start from this time Miss Okay no Okay Miss Miss sylvestri yeah I I was remembering um the climate survey the last climate survey and in it um it shared that staff want to get more feedback on their performance more um so I just wanted to make sure that this policy captures that spirit that feedback that we've gotten from our staff directly in the climate survey just just wanted you to speak to that I can point out lines 9091 microphone I don't know what it is today I'm so sorry it's cold okay uh if I can take you to page three so this is where we want to
103focus on this uh Point number one and the sub points that follow that um it is a shared responsibility among leaders and providing the I'll jump down to 90 and 91 providing learning focused supervision that includes routine support and ongoing feedback for staff and then uh 98 99 and 100 um evaluate employees and provide actionable feedback in a timely manner consistent with established timelines and required core competence these that's an elaborate structure of timeline as employees are new and move through um those various levels and I wouldn't begin to push it further than what I know there but just to point out that that's what that 1D is highlighting there is a process we just need to raise it up and say this this process is extremely important that employees do want that actionable feedback
104regular learning supported feedback that we move forward great thank you Miss Rivera ens thank you on that same page um in lines 101 through 104 which really e which is is create and Implement comprehensive culturally responsive professional learning to promote awareness of potential sources you know the rest of it it all sounds really really great I'm just trying to understand how that's going to be accomplished I'm going to begin that and then I'm going to turn it over to April um all supervisors have been through a lot of training recently to focus on these kinds of processes I think putting it in a pro in the policy says keep doing it so I don't know if April you have anything you want to add to some of the training bits we've all experienced I yes
105I think it is important that it is in there and we value being culturally responsive and I think that is important in every aspect of our jobs and with our employees I think it's great and I'm just wondering how we're going to evaluate that that's actually working with our employees like is there because you know when you go to um the feedback that uh Sylvester was talking about of our employees I'm just wondering then how you're going to evaluate some of these items to ensure that as is well received or that the employees might said actually this needs to be you know there needs to be a little bit more meat on this so this is so I'm just wondering if that needs to the exciting part about this is the new ATM system will
106have evaluations as part of the system and so we'll be able to pull reports and look at data points that will either verify that we are doing the work or confirm that we aren't and we need to be elevating the work thank you to to speak uh uh directly to your question and using cultural competency as a as a good example um and being something that we should evaluate there there are actually states that require cultural competency in an an employee appraisal system and some best practice involves having uh portfolios where uh Educators or staff members can showcase either lessons or activities or things that they've been involved in that demonstrate their cultural competency Beyond just training how they're really applying cultural competency in their work and uh this really provides an opportunity uh to
107to Showcase that as uh as a point of Pride as well as a point for something to be in our appraisal system Miss wolf uh I just want to thank you for your work on this as a member of the policy committee I know we spent a lot of time on this and I just have two thoughts skilled development has always been in our on our agenda but what I'm glad to and what I want to point out is lines 131 through 144 where we talk about what's what's happening if the staff are not meeting the standards because that's been a question that I've been raising for ever and it was never actually in the other policy so I'm glad to see that in there I'm also glad to see that you mentioned the employees
108who indirectly impact students because that's one of the things that I've always known that they did in Boston it didn't matter who you were you had the exact same training on the mission and the goals so that everyone was going on the same train to New York that's all I wanted to say thank you for your work on this Miss matoya thank you I also just wanted to thank all of you I know that espe all of our policies take a lot of work but especially something like this where you're trying to meet the needs of so many different staff members who do so many different things across the district um and all of the thoroughness and input that you had to gather and kind of try to find something that fits everyone's needs so
109thank you so much I really appreciate it and for our policy committee and our other board members from prior years who have done the work to get this up and going too thank you m St sure um I was wondering if I didn't see it in here unless it's I just missed it um are there exit interviews that are done um because that could also give us a view into how to improve our um work conditions an exit interview is provided through the office of strategic initiatives they collect that data but then whenever we have executive staff I do personal exit interviews so I understand better the reason for choosing to go somewhere else or what obstacles they may have faced doing their job is there a reason why it's not in this policy is
110it just in another policy I don't know that this policy really speaks to exit interviews okay thank you all right seeing no other lights um Can the staff member read the resolve for B actions thank you resolved that the Board of Education take tentative action on committee recommended draft board policy GAA positive work environment in a self-renewing organization and be it further resolved that committee recommended draft board policy GAA positive work environment in a self-renewing organization be sent out for public comment okay I don't think this takes a vote it would just go up for the public comment thank you so much for your work Mo approval we do have to take a oh okay okay all right all in favor please raise your hand right thank you so much everyone thank you to staff
111and just as reminder to the public usually the open comment period is 45 days so that uh you will be on our website so we love to hear from everyone uh the comment period is 21 days 21 days yes I need to get that straight thank you so much 21 stop yeah another all right so uh we are going to move into our um uh data talks and first we'll be having our 4 2024 literacy data and progress update um I will invite the staff to come to the front and I'm going to pass the mik to Dr Taylor thank you madam president today we will focus and continue our discussion on literacy uh with our fall 2024 early literacy data highlighting notable progress in grade two and providing a strategic update on the return
112on investment of for targeted interventions and data informed strategies uh this update highlights the how the district is working to improve our literacy outcomes for students by ensuring alignment with the science of reading uh research implementation of high quality instructional materials professional learning and accountability models you'll see some really exciting and positive uh changes for our um our early grades in elementary school and you'll also see uh some persistent achievement gaps that we are working to reduce we are really excited about bringing this update as this is uh really encouraging news about our future moving forward and at this time I'll turn it over to our chief academic officer Dr Peggy Pew and team uh to lead us through this conversation thank you and good afternoon next slide please um we are excited to share
113with you uh in response to your request about is it working you know we invested a lot of funding in early literacy and we want to know is that investment paying off and so we're happy to bring to you some results in our K1 and two today as you know literacy is the foundation of all future learning and it's critical that we get it right early um all of our uh elementary schools have moved to uh using the core knowledge language arts curriculum which is new and it's a huge lift and a huge thank you to all of our teachers and our leaders who are working to implement it so that students in all schools regardless of where they are have access to a high quality curriculum our teachers were trained through this summer and
114our uh administrators also were trained and many of us attended the training alongside of our teachers so so that we could truly do a good job in supporting we are working um together across offices and having teams of content experts go out to each of the schools uh and to coach and to give ongoing feedback because we know onetime summer learning isn't going to be enough to help Implement a brand new curriculum they need ongoing support we also uh just a reminder the data that we're going to be sharing with you today is the dynamic indicators of basic early literacy skills if you hear us say Dibbles that's what that refers to um and that's the measure that we want to make sure that we're using so that teachers can see what their students know
115and still don't know in order to plan instruction in a really ongoing way um as they use that data what our goal is is to show steady Improvement both through the early Investments that the board has made over the past few years and then we're hoping by the end of the this year to begin to demonstrate uh Improvement in our literacy scores in all of the elementary schools based on the implementation of our new curriculum uh next slide please and now I'll turn it over to mikica Brown who is our supervisor of Elementary literacy good afternoon president Yang and vice president Rivera Evan um my name is again Malika Brown I'm Elementary English language arts supervisor so three years ago we began to shift the way that we teach reading across our elementary schools we
116started in a pilot in 19 School focusing on grades K to2 the pilot focus on really explicit foundational skills instruction which is one of the key components of effective reading instruction the pilot during that time it serves as intended purpose and as a result during the 22 23 school year we implemented really great reading which is a foundational skills program across all elementary schools with again a continued focus on grades K to 2 during the same year we also implemented dipples a dynamic indicator of basic early literacy skills that's the last time I'm going to say it I promise um assessment as well so the teachers could be able to monitor effective reading instruction and determine the progress students were making we also provided professional learning on the components of reading again so the teachers
117continue to build their skills and knowledge around what is effective instruction and what does that look like and how children learn to read the following year during our 23 24 school year we continued with really great reading um again across all of the El elementary schools and continue to provide professional learning for our teachers because we've heard earlier that one and done is not enough and so we wanted to ensure that they have that ongoing professional learning to support their knowledge and capacity in being able to deliver effective literacy instruction we also um increase the emphasis on monitoring that reading progress in the early grades um not just only using our dibles assessment for the three times a year in which it's administered but also utilizing the progress monitoring component to continue to check in
118on how students are doing this school year we were able to expand Beyond foundational skills and really move towards our language comprehension which is another critical aspect of learning to read um and we did this by adopting a knowledge building curriculum to support the implementation all teachers were trained on the new curriculum as Dr PE mentioned as well as administrators and teacher leaders we also increased the accountability um with our dibles assessment and so we expanded Beyond K to2 but also utilizing the assessment for students in grades 3 to 5 so that we can continue to gain additional information around those explicit skills and areas of growth for our students in 3 to five and finally to um in in true collaborative fashion and partnership we work closely with the office of school support and
119Improvement um to provide that direct aligned support to schools through a school support team model which we're going to expand into the upcoming school year next slide please and so today I wanted to share the impact of these changes over the past 3 years as reflected in our diples data the alignment to the new Maryland comprehensive literacy policy and our current literacy field test project one more time is a refresher we do administer Dibbles three times a year students take it in the fall they take it again in the winter and then one final time in the spring and that's again for all students in K to 2 and then for selected students in K to 3 our ultimate goal is to have students reach that grade level proficiency by the end of the year
120and or demonstrate at least one year's worth of growth next slide to start we're going to take a look at our overall K to2 data to orient you to the slides you'll see the grade levels as well as the number of students that were assessed and the percentage of students demonstrating at or above proficiency one thing to note is that these not cohorts of students so these are different students from that fall to to um fall um 22 23 23 24 school year and then fall 2425 the current school year and so the blue bar that represents last fall and then the green bar that represents um this fall for this school year we can go to the next slide in grades one and two we see a higher percentage of students that are demonstrating
121at or above proficiency there is expect variability in kindergarten um because again some of our kindergarten students not all of them are enrolled in prek there's a variety of different experiences for our kindergarten students and so similar here you see to our second grade similar to first grade from students um are demonstrating a higher percentage of proficiency from students second grade students last year than they are to this year we can go to the next slide so now we're going to take a deeper look at cohorts so the same group of of students um so this is our current grade 2 students who um looking at them from kindergarten their first grade year and then now their current second grade so this group of almost 9,000 students experienced two full years of the shifts that
122we made in Reading instruction focusing on foundational skills through the use of really great reading as well as the dibles assessment from the fall of their kindergarten year to the fall of their grade 2 year the percentage of students at or above the Benchmark increased from year to year so how did we get there over the past 2 years we invested approximately $ 1.84 million in literacy programs that impacted this cohort of grade 2 students based on the changes to the assessments as well as the foundational skills program as a results you can see here the percentage of second grade students meeting the reading benchmark increased by 18 percentage points which is considered significant Improvement this 18 percentage coins gains means that nearly 1,600 additional second graders are reading at grade level compared to 2
123years ago these gains represent real progress in helping students develop the foundational skills when we look at the cost to achieve each percentage point in proficiency it's about $102,000 across the entire group of students because we know that helping students meet those grade level benchmarks is in second grade is critical because it sets the up for reading proficiently in third grade and Beyond we are proud of this Improvement but recognizes there's still more work that needs to be done and we will continue to monitor these Investments to ensure they provide the best value for our students next slide we also see the gains across our racial and Service Groups including our black and African-American students and with the highest gains for Hispanic Latino students take a moment to pause here next slide and we also
124see a high percentage increase for our emerging multilingual Learners as well again the same group of students their kindergarten year their first grade year and their second grade year we can not yet for every dollar spent we've achieved measurable improvements in Reading proficiency positively impacting thousands of students this represents a meaningful return on our investment next slide looking ahead we know again there's still a lot of work for us and as we continue with our foundational skills and begin to enhance our reading instruction by building knowledge and support of language comprehension which is essential for developing skilled readers this is also supported again what we've heard earlier around the implementation of our new Elementary Ela curriculum in October the the state of Maryland adopted a new comprehensive prek to3 policy the policy focuses on four
125critical standards support for our teachers which includes that ongoing professional learning in literacy and effective literacy instruction reading instruction assessment and intervention through a multi-tier system of supports um the framework and also utilizing implementing highquality instructional materials parent and guardian um notification creating a meaningful partnership with our family in our communities a process for demonstrating Readiness for promotion including adequate uh reading Proficiency in providing that intensive reading intervention as needed I will now turn it over to Dr Moran to share an update on the K to3 policy it says prek it should be K to3 policy and the connections to the steps that we've taken and that we will continue to take to improve our literacy outcomes for our students thank you Miss Brown um good guess we're still and after afterno good afternoon president
126Yang vice president Rivera oven and a warm welcome to our uh new board members my name is Peter Moran I'm the chief of schools um very happy to be here with you uh this afternoon um so as mentioned um monitoring and accountability will be key um and I I do want to as we talked about cross office collaboration I I also wanted just to um recognize the collaboration that we've also had with the black and brown Co Coalition throughout this process with the field test um it has been um extremely beneficial in um enhancing this work um the field test uh supported the full system alignment to the MSD literacy policy that Miss Brown just uh talked about uh part of that policy per um comar is that each uh prek uh through grade three
127student who exhibits difficulties in Reading uh shall receive supplemental instruction aligned to their identified needs through the mtss or the multi-tiered system of support historically mcps educators are are very used to using this system to document and plan for Behavior interventions and we are now requiring all academic interventions to be documented and monitored through this field test the five schools uh helped us to identify barriers to successful implementation identify opportunities for enhanced parent engagement and partnership using this system and leveraging the Synergy mtss platform for streamlined tracking and support through this implementation we are collaborating with the team in the office of strategic initiatives on a few deliverables that will include monthly data chats and progress reports sent to families Synergy generated parent reports showing student progress um each School in the field test and
128this goes back to um a conversation that um we had had with Miss wolf at a previous meeting um each School in the field test was found to have solid processes in place for the following uh evaluating data as a team to determine needs and place students in interventions scheduling intervention groups communicating with caregivers about entry and exit into interventions um at the conclusion of the the the field test or a component of the field test was a community meeting was held with each school with caregivers of students receiving interventions additionally caregivers were surveyed to provide additional information if they could not attend just a couple of uh results from that survey that I wanted to highlight 70% reported that they knew how their child was doing in Reading 30% had some idea or no
129idea how their child was doing reading at the field test schools 59% of the caregivers reported to receive frequent emails about progress 61% reported to have conferences about intervention progress as a result of the surveys and conversations with families it's clear that we need to continue to enhance family communication um part of that will be ensuring Clarity and messaging and usability of tools like Dibbles through the parent view reports and align parent communication with mtss reporting I do want to just highlight from the data that Miss Brown was sharing um an analysis of the quarter one data uh demonstrates a correlation between the um efficient and an effective use of the intervention system and gains that we're seen at specific schools so essentially schools that are uh implementing with Fidelity um and monitoring these interventions
130utilizing the system um following up with parents um we are seeing a uh growth similar to how the cohort growth was shared students from the Spring to Fall at schools that had over a 100 uh plans um entered just want to highlight Germantown Elementary School had a 32% uh increase in their performance uh that's K to2 composite um performance on Dibbles um gallway a 27% increase um in our paint Branch cluster Summit Hall had a 22% increase uh strawberry NES had a 21% increase um and Broad Acres who is a field test school had an 18% uh increase um our goals moving forward is to increase consistency with mtss structures and utilize it effectively to develop and Implement student interventions um directors are uh currently engaging with principles in monitoring and accountability discussions per our
131standard supervisory uh protocol and we're going to continue to work to support principles with observing interventions and providing feedback to Insurance structure strategies are being delivered um I'd be remiss if I also just didn't acknowledge uh the commitment and uh efforts um hard work of our teachers to um be constantly implementing this data reconstructing these intervention plans um uh meeting with parents to share the progress um they are they are doing an outstanding job and we're certainly beginning to see uh results from from interv uh intervention systems like this being implemented across all of our schools um one one other just key piece that I wanted to share in terms of of of a piece of data is at a previous meeting we talked about the percent of students that were implementing intervention data um
132we are now at 100% of our elementary schools that are inter that are putting intervention data into the system there is certainly more work to do but we are now at a place where all schools are U utilizing mtss for academic interventions not just behavior intervention so I'll turn it back to Dr Pew y next slide please um I think Montgomery County Public Schools has made literacy a primary focus for a very long time we're pleased to be able to say that your Investments are paying off for our students and our families we're also happy that we have parts of the Maryland state literacy policy really already in place and for us it'll be some work to put it together with our um associations and partners to be able to really uh refine how we
133do the implementation here um but we're excited to bring this data to you and we open it up for your discussion thank you so much um I'm going to open it up for board members I'm going to start from this side of the table um Miss Montoya well first thank you guys for being here today um and for all your hard work I know these kinds of things are not easy to get off the ground um I happen to have two Elementary School students one who's a third grader who was in the pilot program at their school so I'm very familiar with Dibbles and we absolutely were pouring through data at principles coffees every time um and seeing that growth which is always exciting to see I also have a child who's a little bit
134older who did not receive this uh curricula and this way of learning literacy and so I've lived through both and I think it's great that this is what we're doing and we have easy ways for parents to see that growth um I think one of the questions I have is as parents how can we support our children maybe they're not getting flagged because they're not far below grade level but we can see it home that maybe they could use some support or whatnot and understanding that there's so much need in our system um what are we doing or what are we working on to help parents not just to receive the progress and to know where their child is at but to then at home here are some concrete things I can try to do
135um so we have a variety of resources to be able to support families at home the first piece is part of the dibles home connect report it does have suggested activities that can be done at home and there's also Al links to the website that has those activities as well one really exciting piece of our curriculum is that there is a parent Hub that has additional resources families can have access to the text that students are reading to continue to reinforce that at home um when appropriate the activity pages from the students activity books can go home so the parents can get a glimpse into what the students are learning they're also um parent letters at the beginning of each unit that we expect teachers to share so again that uh families can see um
136and have some examples of what students are doing in the classroom as well okay and are those resources available in languages other than English so they are available in English and Spanish um We are continuing to get the letters translated across all languages we have them already um translated in prek and we're working to build up there are a lot of letters because of the number of units and the number of grade levels um but it's something that we're putting in place to ensure the website um amplifi parent resource Hub that's also available in English and in Spanish okay and I'm very familiar with the letters we get those as well and they they are helpful um it helps to be able to have conversations with my kids during the week um I am concerned
137one that mcps is having to translate all of these letters and that the company has not provided this in the very multilingual environment that we all live in here in this country that was something that we um that we looked into but the timeline for them to be able to translate versus the timeline that we would be able to we would be able to do it faster and so that's something that we took on okay thank you so much thank you for that work as well you miss wolf uh yes I also want to thank you for your work on this I have a question about implementation I think you said that uh you could see great Improvement where there was Fidelity of implementation am I correct about that okay well what I want to
138know is are you able to identify those schools that need support with this because their data is not showing the kind of improvement that we would expect to see and if so what what exactly are you doing so uh absolutely um and one of the things we we just conducted a quarter one analysis of of all of our data and compared uh that same correlation to schools that are not seeing that that level of improvement or growth in Reading um some of it is related to um or could be connected to the intervention system not being implemented properly um dors have gone out to those schools had conversations with principles and one of the things that I'm really excited that we're doing is we're we're networking schools and we had talked about this previously at
139another meeting is schools that are implementing things with Fidelity um them coming together those principles of schools that may not be implementing them in the same way to spread best practices so that um we're building those networks so that we can you know um have some social accountability structure so that people can see great work that's happening in one school and just duplicate it maybe even just right across the the street so um absolutely okay I guess I'm just trying to figure out if how long we give a school how much time we're going to allow a school to continue to not make Improvement and if and what happens what what do we expect to happen if they don't make Improvement what's going to happen well I mean for for starter and I didn't know
140if I you were going to chime in but because we have a a lot of money going into this so I'm trying to figure so absolutely so I I want to I want to make sure that one thing that I'm clear on is so we're not this is not we're not this is not a choice first of all in terms of if we're doing this or we're not doing this which is why we've gotten to 100% of our schools in the implementation phase um as we've gone into the implementation phase we're learning you know a lot and that was the purpose of the field test was to learn a lot of the strategies that work best um but what we're doing is and and and I think it's also an indication of of the future
141work that is to come is already starting to build the uh building blocks of cross functional teams to go into schools and begin to work with schools that are not demonstrating that progress so that you'd have a literacy person coach working side by side with someone in curriculum someone in special education to go out and begin to do that work and we have seen Returns on that preliminary work that you know we're hopeful pending the budget will be more structured as we move forward in the future so that is something that we're doing and and have been doing actually since the the beginning of the school year okay I think I'd like to just have a a meeting with you to to look at those schools in particular that are not making the kind of
142progress that we want to make because as I say we're putting a lot of money into this so you want to see something some kind of movement thank you yeah I'm going to come to this side and um go from Mrs mman thank you um I'm really glad to see these gains and improvements in foundational lit it's something that's really close to my heart and I can speak to how essential this work is so thank you very much um in the presentation I noticed that our farm students were not disaggregated and then when we look at the raw data our farm students um are still far behind an achievement so what specifically is being implemented to help support our farm students in their reading development so our farm students fall into some of the other
143categories or so we didn't disaggregate and pull them out separately because they are embedded when we're looking potentially at special education across racial groups as well as our merg multilingual Learners um it's also the teachers they that's no longer data that we're showing as well so teachers don't have access to that um that that label and so what we are doing is ensuring that there's effective instruction across the classroom across all of our schools um and it goes back to speaking to what Dr Moran mentioned how we are engaging with schools the work that we're doing with the reading specialist to ensure that uh our teachers have the skills and the knowledge and capacity to be able to do and using that data to be responsive and make those differentiated changes as part of instruction
144so not necessarily something that's called out specifically for um Farm students that are sitting in individual classrooms but the overall effectiveness of the work we do work closely with our um our Title One Partners to make sure that our Title One schools have the support they also have um Specialists that are assigned to those schools to work with those reading Specialists again to ensure that the teachers have the skills and the knowledge and the capacity to do yeah I I understand your point I just don't want this to become a trend that we are seeing over time abut um and related to what you were just saying I think it would also be really useful when we're looking at those big data sheets if we're able to pull out our Title One In Focus schools
145um or at least have them marked or if we're able to put them all together so we can see how our Title One schools are performing how our Focus schools are performing as a whole um also as Dibbles testing is now um coming up right it's that new time um I'm so sorry to any Educators that just lost days and trying to get that done it's really stressful um so I'm I'm looking forward to see what growth that our students are making um but I'm also wondering how are we guaranteeing that we have appropriate time to get that testing done although the tests are theoretically short it's not as as short as we might think um how are we working with um the way that we you know put our curriculum guidelines out and our
146County pacing guidelines how are we making sure that we have enough time for all the things that have to get done that's not a your question um so we do have the testing days as part of our pacing calendar so it's built in so teachers aren't trying to figure out when they are built into the pacing guide um we are making some decisions because we know that we lost three days this week because don't worry it's a snow day happened it's for you um and so you know we are making some decisions around the extension again you know coming back on a Thursday and Friday no one wants to jump right back into testing last week same thing we lost you know two days like coming off of the break and so we are looking
147and making some adjustments potentially extending the window um so that they might have more time because we want meaningful data and so we want to be able to provide the time for that to collect that meaningful data absolutely those pausing points and testing days um you know pausing points oftentimes are used for other things so to to have that testing space is just really essential want to make sure that we don't lose any absolutely um I'm so sorry the last thing I want to ask is about letters training um it is extremely difficult to get into that um so I'm wondering like do we know what percentage of our Educators have taken it how are we planning to expand it cuz I see it in you know in our our road map but you know
148if it's a great training I want to make sure a lot of people can have access to it so that is a um a phenomenal question um it is very difficult to get into letters uh language Essentials for teachers of reading and spelling it's a comprehensive training um it's and it is a it takes a lot of time and so we've really only had the capacity to offer it optional um because again it's it's also very expensive it's very time consuming there's not only paying for the training but there's also paying for the compensation for teachers if they take it outside of the duty day finding substitutes and things like that so we have about 1,500 Elementary Educators that have completed letters um which doesn't sound like a lot but it is a huge investment
149to be able to provide letters training to so many teachers both um volume one as well as volume two it accounts for eight total days of professional learning um We are continuing you know again budget pending to be able to continue to offer it um on fortunately we're only at a place where we can offer it as an option again because of um you know the budget around it the state um they have rolled out professional learning um designed to do essentially the same thing and so we and that's opened up so we send that out to teachers it's up in our newsletter and our updates um for teachers to be able to take advantage of it I just received a report today with a list of teachers from mcps that have enrolled in the
150training so that's something that we're hoping it's a little bit easier to access it doesn't cost us anything on our part um and so we're going to continue to push that aome I think it it would also be you know if we think about our reading specialist and their role could be a really creative way to help maybe add some access to that while it's not the official training that maybe that's something we could explore as well and um we've worked really hard to make sure that all of our reading Specialists are letter strained thank you Miss Sylvester I have a lot of questions um so I'll try to be succinct and this is why I appreciate briefings because I can process the information before I get here um some really just succinct answers to
151this um this grade level K to 2 gets dibles and map is there another test or just those two k to2 we just administer Dibbles I'm sorry in K to2 it's Dibbles no map no that's the only literacy that's the only literacy only external literacy assessment okay what are the three to five three to five continues to use map map okay um is sbles useful to teachers in terms of instruction um so um I think I remember correctly you do an assessment at the beginning of the school year and then there's a a fall assessment is that no it's a winter assessment so they we administer Dibbles three times a year in the fall winter and spring and teachers the data is extremely useful between each Administration so between the fall and the winter there's
152progress monitoring to determine looking at specific skills to see how students are responding to the instruction so it is extremely useful the one that you were presenting today is was administered when it was administered this fall September September October SE um the window it's a few days into the school year and it closes around the end of September early October so if I'm a teacher what do I do with this data that I just received on my classroom and Dibbles so they analyze the data and they can tell the specific skills and areas in which students need additional support and so you know if I'm a a second grade student and and it's primarily around the word recognition the foundational skills piece so I can look at the data and see I mean down to
153like letter sounds that skill that students know if they're able to read fluently it tells them that and then I take that and I put um if it's students are demonstrating significant needs that's how they work to identify an intervention that the student may need and then the intervention would Target the specific skills that are showing are in need on the assessment and then there's a progress monitoring component so as students are engaging in instruction teachers can continue there's pieces of the dibles assessment that they can continue to administer based on the guidance that we provide to see are you learning what I'm teaching Dr Moran when do teachers get to do this and what support do they get and how and accountability how do we know that they are you don't utilizing this data
154to modify interventions or instruction so that would that would take place during um what what some schools call collaborative planning other schools call curriculum study where they engage and look at at at data to plan for you know specific individual students it also would be a component of the intervention piece of planning for interventions so um that would take place during you know monthly or even sometimes weekly data chats depending upon the the the school and the level of of needs so K through 5 um really pre prek through 5 each has that that structure built into their master schedule where all those teachers come together with the support of a of a reading specialist sometimes a staff development teacher um to support with the facilitation of that provide them with the data on the
155front and so they're not trying to organize you know all of that data to have those meaningful conversations thank you I have more questions but I'll wait we come back okay Mr Rivera Alin thank you as thank you for asking us questions so now I have less questions but I do have I want to I want to follow up on my colleague's um comment from uh Mrs wolf about how we monitor progress so from looking at the data it looks great uh even with the farm students because I'm looking from 2023 it was in the I think was 38% I'm looking at 2024 I'm just looking at second graders just to an example and it went up to 49% so that is great progress right but I want us to going back to miss Zimmerman
156this desegregated data like I I just want to have a true picture of of you know of where those um where that progress happened and where it didn't happen and how we going to support it so if I'm looking and I think lot of of you guys were here um I had used the example of Gasburg elementary school cuz was very low for some of the for for some of the kiddos right it was like 11% so I'm looking now that there's been an increase huge increase in fact in some of the groups but I'm concerned about our black students um because I'm seeing that in some instances we have lost some of that uh advancement that we made in reading for them and I'm trying to understand why in a sense um and how
157we can remedy that and how we as a system are monitoring that to make sure that we're not losing ground on reading but we should be moving right the other way so so can you help me out yeah I I appreciate the question because it is multi-layered and it is complex as we're trying to break it down um one of the pieces that happens first for us is that we get together with the vendor and the vendor presents our comparisons to the nation and our comparisons to ourselves over the years that we have used Dibbles so each year we've been pleased to see more students at or above grade level and fewer students at below and well below so they do that by the big whole student group and then something that we just did
158um was it I can't I'm a little lost on time but it was before Christmas and that we got together the offices to actually look at the data from a variety of Assessments so we have the dibles assessment which is very useful to a teacher who can go right in teach the skill reassess and see that they so it's it's adaptive and it's moving on we're using that same data at a high level to say do our teachers and staff have everything that they need to be able to address the needs that students have um and then that leads to the student support teams where we're working individually with schools on what they have chosen as their goal to support where they might need your point in the monitoring is that the reasons why students
159or schools are not performing in the way that we think they might are vast there's a variety of reasons everywhere from uh brand new brand new and not not always new but brand new teachers sometimes you know it is an issue where they're learning a new curriculum and learning a new school and learning classroom management so they need a little bit more support and support from their peers um may be that it is uh language right if if we saw even our um our language Learners they are making great progress because they're early in their career right they're learning their second language and we're seeing those um gaps actually close because they're they're learning it at at an early age so the system is that we look at it as a as a larger system
160we look at it as a cross office group by school and by um cluster and then the individual work that happens in the school so progress monitoring happens in a variety of places and spaces I hope that gives you a little bit of context to see the pattern of how no no it it does um but I'm still I still kind of need a little Clarity than um the fact that you know we're we're moving in the right direction but then we're we're in some instances we're not we're kind of moving a little bit backwards so that means it's working but then it's not working for some kids and so I just want to see how we evaluate that and make those connections and we give the support to these individual schools because I'm sure
161you're monitoring right if you had a school that the kids were performing at a 60% and now they're only performing at a 45% then right and everybody else is getting better then what is it the disconnect that we need to work on so I'd I'd love to just give a specific example because this is one we actually just had a conversation about and it is about um Little Bennett Elementary School so Little Bennett Elementary School has the um most significant growth for black and African-American students in the entire system for elementary school students K through 12 I mean k through 12 K through 2 um and so you I'm a big believer that if you can do it at one school you can do it at all schools um so finding out specifically working with
162that principle that team around what it is that they did to get that level of growth from Spring to Fall one of the things that we're finding out is putting race and having conversations about what we're what we're talking about right now about how we're teaching black students what inter what interventions are working across a grade level and putting race on the table within the curriculum study the collaborative planning process to really have those conversations in terms of the planning for how we're teaching teaching students you know based off of of race and what it is that they need culturally but also just based off of the individual needs of a child um and I think that's the power of curriculum you know curriculum study is you can get to the place where you're talking
163about individual students um not necessarily the package curriculum so much but teachers sharing what they're doing and what has worked with individual students and then applying that across a uh a grade level so again I think it's about finding where where we're seeing significant prog ress and then just duplicating those things that we've that have been proven to work and just a quick add it speaks to the work that you know that was elevated in the equity audit right as a system we need to ensure that we have culturally responsive practices and they're utilizing it in the classroom and so there are places where you know teachers need support with that leaders need support with that and that's something that's ongoing um we're also that's the other piece of our curriculum right our curriculum is
164culturally responsive it does promote engagement and so the goal ideally is to be able to see the gains just coming out of the curriculum but then also continuing to be responsive to what was you know what was elevated in the audit okay thank you um I have uh some questions first of all I want to um say thank you these graphs are really easy to read the end number is on it wow it's really uh wonderful um now um as we are looking at the great games that second graders made um and also look at the uh the graph for kindergarten which one of our uh public comments uh refer to a slight di so my questions are um one what are the exact thing you contribute to the second graders game that you can
165pinpoint and what do you contribute to the slight dip of our kindergarten nurse performance so I think what we could contribute to our second grade is explicit foundational skills instruction um that cohort of students that you're seeing they received it for two years in kindergarten in first grade and now getting some more of it is in their second grade year so I think that's a huge factor in the increase kindergarten is a little tricky right because that's kindergarten fall data so those students were in school some of them maybe a couple of weeks before they were assessed um and you know there's again a variety of experiences for our prek students and so we have students that are in mcps prek um we're also rolling out new curriculum with prek but then we have students
166that are in private care so the the kindergarten it's a little bit different because they their experien is in prek it it varies um and so we can't really look at the kindergarten that way because these they don't have a history of receiving explicit instruction in mcps as a whole okay so it is our change of our practice and investment in the uh instruction okay then I want to ask um this data is for dibles right uh but we have invested in the core knowledge language art which is assessment reached curriculum it comes with a lot of assessment our teachers and School District looking at those stas and how does that inform your practice so that's another great question we actually with the reading specialist went through the curriculum assessments today and how to look
167at that data to be able to inform instruction and so looking at how students are doing from unit to unit or um domain to domain um considering the practices the content that was learned the strategies to then be able to make informed decisions so when we're looking at students for example who are demonstrating that they're doing very well on those knowledge assessments you know teachers could sort of make some shifts instead of when they're engaging in those whole group lessons they can have the students read and respond to things individually and be able to utilize smaller groups to be able to provide targeted instruction and so we went through a process with our um reading specialist this afternoon on a protocol that they can use to analyze the data and then different steps that they
168could take to be able to support their teachers directly with their practice so dios happens how many times a year three times a year the fall winter and spring right but the ongoing curriculum assessment happens every day right so like not every day like ongoing all the time they teach in the classroom our theory of action I think sometimes say we invest greatly in a curriculum and we provide teacher support and then we should see Improvement but I think in the middle there is a big area of implementation abut and then the ongoing uh realignments of our practices addressing the needs in the students so I'm glad to hear that we are looking at our curriculum buildin assessments okay then one last question about this then I'll will go for my colleagues questions is dibles
169or even the building curriculum assessments are assessments for Progress monitoring what are we doing for accountability monitoring what assessment do we use for accountability purposes so we use the same assessment for accountability we can utilize our Dibbles assessment and we look at it systemwide um for accountability both in the utilization not just in the benchmarking beginning middle and um end of the year but also the progress monitoring we can see which schools are progress monitoring students how often they're being progress monitored and which students are being progress monitored to be able to again partner with our office School support and Improvement to increase the accountability in the places where it needs to be we also have access to the C assessments as well and so we can see how students by school by class by
170grade level across the district are performing on those assessments as well so we can use the same assessments to serve both purposes so here is uh uh a little bit puzzling to me and I I I I am glad to hear this accountability so if we look at um Maryland state when they rate our school they rate it based on mcap which are grade three students take uh grade five students Take mcap 2 for reading right and in your budget presentation you mentioned that in 2035 four or more four or more um are we ever going to talk about those data because that's what we holding ourself accountable for and that's how the whole world um uh look at our schools I'm I'm wondering so I'm just going to start really on it so the
171what MCAT measure it's around standards right it's our literacy standards students are resp Reading and Responding to text um I'm not going to get on a soap box about the assessment because it is assessment that's used to measure you know schools and districts um the challenge with an mcap assessment is that the content of it is agnostic so it's not necessarily tied to the content that that students are learning and that's the way that students demonstrate comprehension right it's they utilize their background knowledge vocabulary they're immersed and engaged in the content they read a passage and they're much more able to to demonstrate their comprehension and understanding that being said our our curriculum it is it does have standards right so the learning is embedded in the standards and so again part of what we're
172doing is how do we look at the K assessments how do we look at the content as well as the skills that students are expected to know and be able to do to give us a glimpse potentially into well if I'm presented with a literacy assessment that and and I have to read and be able to respond to it how may I potentially show up so not necessarily teaching to the standards because that's not how we teach reading uh but how do I use that data to then think about what change in practice how do I continue to monitor what are the potential factors that students May um be demonstrating areas of needs to then think about well what other preparedness can I do for the state assessment because we know that it's it's there's
173a heavy weight around the state assessment yeah I I I hear you and I agree if we teach our students solidly and they gain skills they should perform well no matter what skill is by the same token Matt M Matt R Matt P they're not aligned with our whatever ever happening in our classroom every single day right that's not what we teach in our classroom are being assessed in those uh which we use we just didn't discuss it today this is what we use to evaluate uh fourth and fifth grade but however as a system I do think it's important for us to look at alignment uh of what we teach and what we are being evaluated at uh I think it's a important thing for us to look at um Miss sylvestri do you
174have further more questions Miss sure you guys had so many great questions I only have a little followup um so uh you mentioned Little Bennett and I would love to see uh have that as a case study and have you come back and review uh what you found worked well there and also um I would love for families to be engaged as well because they might have other insights um from the home perspective and not just uh in the classroom uh because they they you know as you know um families want that engagement anyway so be a good way to um Circle have a full circle there and the other is um the cross departmental teams that will be it sounds like you're already working on setting that up for a deployment I presume there
175will be a pilot of some sort is that the case so I I would say that we the well I I don't we're trying to get away from from Pilots we got a we got a lot of planes in the air right so um we I would say that we have the uh we are building the foundation for the cross functional teams right now they are already deployed to about 20 schools that were working collaboratively with their principles um couple of those schools were were named around the the growth um so um we're we're building the infrastructure to be prepared so that come July 1 um you know that we are ready to uh do that work um in a very collaborative way with our schools so I'm having a hard picture my I have
176a hard time myself picturing exactly what that looks like and how it works in the school and I think um I heard that from a couple colleagues I would love to have again a presentation at some point showing us actually how that works in the school um and then um what's the takeaways on on the ones that worked well so we can really highlight and and try to um multiply that through the system thank you it at a very basic level I can say that currently we're working hard to make this work because we see the value in it the numbers are not the same so like I have I have one Malica I don't have 15 mikas so um it's a it's a matter of making sure that we have people that can really
177fully dedicate theirselves to a cluster model to provide that ongoing consistent support and not uh a numbers game so in the very rudimentary it's about getting enough people to be who have expertise in both special education English language development content and then um that they can work together as a team very very consistently they're trying very hard to work together as a team but we have the same team member in many of those areas so um that that would be the alignment but of course more to come on how that's to work thank you okay great I'm I I look forward to learning more thank you yeah Miss MTO thank you and just very briefly um I just wanted to emphasize the point that Miss Yang made about the various assessments um it's also just
178really confusing for families I don't know what I'm supposed to look at what am I am I supposed to care am I not supposed to care um my hope would be that for all of our kids that when they're going to school at whatever grade level they're in that they're gaining the skill sets they need so that it shouldn't matter if the content of the assessment is in alignment with whatever curricula we've chosen for that particular grade and content um that would be my hope I understand that's very oversimplified um but I do appreciate all the work that you're doing thank you I do try to simplify it in my head this way because we do have multiple data points and they all have different metrics and values if our goal is that we have
179outcomes on our state assessments each of the other things are just indicators along the way of our progress towards that so we can take map and get some information from that because it is correlated to the mcap the state assessment we can take these small uh pieces of information that we're getting in the curriculum where the students are taking uh quick formative assessments to say how we're doing um along the way so those are in my head in order to simplify it State assessments a priority all of these other pieces are additional pieces of information some in the dibles which the teacher can use immediately to adjust instruction some which give us an indicator as a district of areas that um all schools may need support if that helps but are we seeing that progress
180I guess is what because again as as a parent I get right I get all these homes M and I'm just wondering on the whole or even school to school or demographic by demographic are we seeing what you're hoping is happening that these smaller not smaller assessments these other assessments are translating into progress on the Statewide assessment and I'm not sure if I feel that we are seeing that I would say at this point two things one k 2 when you're teaching foundational literacy skills there is not a state assessment on foundational literacy skills as soon as you switch into grade three those are reading standards that the child's able to read and respond so there isn't a way to see a match between the K2 and the state um in the other areas I
181would say we absolutely have work to do because some of these are new in terms of the cka assessments um to determine whether or not we see progress along the way the thing to think of is the state assessment is a one point in time assessment each of these assessments overtime collectively should give us a sense of of how a student is doing but each one individually probably won't correlate to a state assessment okay yeah no and I agree I like that we're looking at the progress and the growth and I agree that the mcap is one point in time but unfortunately that one point in time is what everyone focuses on so thank you and I think I can answer your question a little bit more directly if you could go back a few
182slides to uh the year-by-year comparison uh see if we can go back a couple slides whoever's the magical person controlling the slides one one more uh would be great there you go um and you take a look at actually let's go one more back before that um if that there you go and if you look at the current uh second grade students they were the previous year's first grade students and the year before that they're kindergarten so next year we'll take a look at this group's second grade mcap performance and that would be a wonderful measure of how they're growing and we would we would expect there to be a certain level of proficiency but their trajectory is going in the right direction uh just year over-year that that change is what we would hope
183to see we would be very very concerned if the uh trajectory was going in a different direction um or if there was a an irregular year or something along those lines those things would be concerning but the excitement about some of these these data um are reflective over the fact that our early grades are showing the kind of promise that we would hope that it would translate to in the mcap for next year um and as we look at this year's kindergarteners we're we're really three academic years away from seeing how their mcap performance is but the future looks bright right and I did notice that trajectory and even in randomly just selecting random schools to see well last year there second graders did this way and this year there are third graders which may
184not be exactly equivalent but gives us a ballpark so I do recognize that and I appreciate the growth that all of our staff are putting into making sure our students they progressing thank you okay let's um short on time but I'm going to miss Sylvester for the last question yeah just real quickly um the pilot that you spoke about I thought I in my head it was all about communicating with parents about kids scores and so forth but I also heard a strong component of applying the multi-tier systems of support so it just wanted to clarify it was both both the communication with families and the schools implementation of the multi-tier system of support which means applying the right intervention to this student both academic and behavioral social emotional because I've heard that term also
185used in um you know in the more the social emotional context as well you so I I'll just start with an overview um yes we originally started with our literacy pilot focusing on um Community engagement and our our involvement of families and how could we do that better understanding we weren't reaching the families that we needed to reach all of them and the literacy policy dropped and we shifted at that time as a group um the team decided let's look at what we do have in place to accomplish this literacy policy which is where the multi-tiered system of support comes in and why the renewed emphasis on using a system the teachers are already familiar with to now use for at the academic data as well as the Behavior so for the just the elevator
186speech what is a multi-tier is just that just picking the right intervention that the kid needs at this time oh I'm going to let the expert just real real big high level it's just a three levels of support that's provided so it's that tier one that instruction that everyone receives that core grade level instruction and then there's the tier two and the tier three where it's a supplemental or more intensive um intervention or support a student needs and so it's being able to utilize your data to identify you know or does a student just um need only tier one or do they need a tier two or a tier three and documenting that so providing a space for the to admin to deliver the appropriate intervention and then documenting that the intervention is taking place
187so that you can track progress and see is the intervention working or do we need to do some reconsideration around it okay but there's also some behavioral interventions that are part that is a component my focus is just on the academic the literacy piece but there is a component where there um documenting behavioral interventions that's being put in place to support student there dashboard that allows you to see all the big picture of everything that's happening to a child yes yes yes yes okay thank literacy peace yes thank you and just uh just to close out I just want to thank you for this this is great news and this is the direction that we want to be going in of course we want to see it faster and uh throughout this SCH whole system
188but thank you great news thank you for your hard work yeah and I would also like to say thank you for the slide seven that tied our academic return uh on investment uh the dollar amount to the increase in our student uh achievement so thank you so much okay um we have been at this um for almost three hours I I believe I would like to call for a short recess of five minutes before we dive into the math data okay continue with our math data discussion um let me take a scan off the room to make sure we have the people we need here all right Dr Taylor part two of marching through the board's uh academic goals we covered literacy now we get to talk about mathematics performance and we're going to do
189that through the lens of our fall 2024 uh measures of academic progress or map uh data and uh at this time I'm going to pass things over to our chief academic officer uh Peggy Pew and team to walk us through and introduce uh today's presentation very exciting good afternoon again and so to start off with the difference between what you just heard in literacy and what you'll hear coming up is that this is K to2 so we're going to give you all of the information that you need and it's focused around the measures of academic progress assessment in mathematics that's given in all grades from kindergarten through grade8 and it also includes algebra and unfortunately next slide please what you'll see is that the overall data remain flat year toe compared to last year we're
190not seeing the progress we'd hoped for across the board but and what stands out most this year is this year's kindergarteners starting even further behind with fewer students coming in entering kindergarten uh at the proficient level compared to previous years it is something that we'll need to pay close attention to because those early skills are so important for long-term success in the sequential nature of mathematics there are some bright spots that we will highlight today across our district we're seeing promising growth in specific grade levels in schools that have instructional math coaches this shows us that when we provide targeted support it can make a real difference for our students and for our teachers as we move forward we need to dig deeper into why some areas are making progress and others aren't and look
191at ways to expand what's working like those instructional coaching programs prams supporting our youngest Learners and ensuring every student has what they need to succeed will continue to be key priorities throughout this year to get us started I'll turn the presentation over to Carla Britt who is not Sheila not today thank you good evening next slide please one tool mcps uses to monitor mathematics academic progress is the map testing for all students in grad K through 8 these assessments administered two to three times annually measure growth in mathematics and are used alongside classroom and curriculum data to guide instructional adjustments they are also correlated with the Maryland comprehensive Assessment program mcap scores next slide this data shown delves into fall elementary math performance by race providing a breakdown of of math scores for kindergarten and
192grade three students the data reveal persistent disparities across racial groups underscoring the need for Equity focused interventions I will now turn the presentation over to Jennifer loznak co-supervisor of secondary mathematics to briefly highlight fall data for secondary mathematics next slide please the data here shows fall grade six Math performance by race highlighting both areas of progress and the ongoing challenge of achieving equity and student outcomes next slide please these data focus on Fall Algebra 1 math performance by race and level on the left we see middle school and on the right High School this presents Trend showing Improvement and disparities the slide also emphasizes the need to increase support to high school algebra 1 I'd like to introduce to you one of our amazing centrally assigned Elementary instructional math coaches kylen Tumi she will share
193about her multi-year partnership with one of her schools and their joint success next slide please I would like to begin by thanking the board of education for funding the instructional math Coach position I am one of eight centrally assigned elementary math coaches who directly work with teachers in their grade level team structure in 35 elementary schools each year instructional math coaches work directly with each School principal to identify the grade level team we will provide real-time job embedded professional learning too I'm excited to briefly highlight my work with both the first grade and second grade teams at strawberry Elementary excuse me at strawberry null elementary school last year I coached the grade one team and this year I was able to loop with the same student cohort and follow them to second grade we are
194finding the student cohort experience allows us to continue to raise the bar for planning and instruction while also allowing us to track student progress over time with the same group of students you will notice on the slide the presentent percentage of strawberry n students meeting Proficiency in Matt p as first graders last fall in blue and next to it in green we see the percentage of these same students meeting proficiency this fall as second graders we celebrate this success with both the first and second grade teams of teachers because we recognize that every student deserves high quality instruction every year and our teachers deserve high quality realtime professional support to accomplish this and when both are in place consistently planning and instruction improve which in turn helps improve student achievement while this is just one
195school example and one data point we are seeing a clear return on this investment we also have centrally assigned instructional math coaches supporting identified middle schools I will now turn the presentation over to Patty Swift one of the secondary math instructional coaches she will speak about her successful partnership with Math teachers at Dr Martin Luther King Jr Middle School good afternoon superintendent Taylor and members of the Board of Education next slide please I am one of four Middle School schol instructional math coaches as a team of coaches we support 15 schools and we primarily support teachers that are teaching math 6 math 7 and math 8 with their planning instruction and data monitoring while proficiency is one way to examine return on investment we must acknowledge that many of our students need to make more
196than a typical Year's growth to meet that Benchmark I'd like to highlight how the secondary instructional math coaches are using growth percentiles to indicate student progress towards proficiency when looking at the nwaa map M growth percentiles we see that Dr Martin Luther King Junior Middle School is making gains as a result of the work with the instructional math coach for clarity a student with a growth percentile of 50 is staying on Pace with their peers we can see that our grade eight black or African-American students are in the 72nd percentile meaning they are growing faster than their peers this growth is essential for students to move towards proficiency I would attribute these gains to the conditions that have been established in collaboration with the math team and the school administration led by principal Miss Brandy
197Overton and content specialist Miss Valerie kobitski at MLK jior Middle School teachers come to planning with an openness for the curriculum implementation coaching these conditions and teacher mindset have allowed us to restructure the planning process where teachers now look at the cool down which is an exit ticket and the lesson synthesis which is where teachers ensure that students understand the conceptual part of the lesson next the teachers choose the activity that best aligns to how students will be assessed at the end of the lesson the teachers then discuss what scaffolds are emergent multilingual Learners and students receiving special education services will need during the lesson and throughout the unit in order to be successful on the end of unit assessments and District assessments teachers then reviewed the math language routine that suggested for the lesson
198as was referenced in previous Board of Education meetings math language routines provide students an opportunity for student discourse using their native language we practice a routine during that planning session we talk about what students need for the language routine and we also discuss the teachers Comfort level with implementing the routine within the classroom these conversations have led to either me modeling the routine within their class period or co- teing the routine with the teacher finally the teachers discuss next steps if students are not successful on the cool down prior to instruction so that teachers are prepared to implement any adjustments to their lessons collaborative planning time is also protected from emergency class coverage when I'm in the building to support them this gives the teachers that much needed time in order to study the curriculum
199in preparation for Effective first instruction I will now turn the presentation back over to Carla Brit next slide please thank you Patty and kylen they're awesome aren't they Dr Taylor talked a lot about at the budget presentation about the broccoli I see our instructional math coaches as the farmers who make sure that our broccoli is an excellent crop the two schools highlighted today demonstrated Success Through following the cycle shown on this slide with your funding and support the math department has been able to provide some dedicated expert math Staffing that Elementary would otherwise not have had this is in contrast to the elementary Reading specialist allocation available at every Elementary School in order for this cycle to occur schools must establish the conditions and expectations for consistent curriculum study through planning implementation of those plans
200inclusive of curricular routines and Strate strategies and progress monitoring to make adjustments during instruction and for future lessons this was the explicit focus of last Summer's professional learning for all elementary schools and our team has been supporting schools with this shift all year historically any support provided was limited to just planning and many years of data show that's insufficient the data show it's equally crucial to ensure the person supporting teachers as they follow this cycle is again a Content expert the instructional math coach brings expertise to support teachers in understanding the complexities of the math as well as differentiating and Scaffolding lessons while maintainer maintaining rigor and pacing during instruction instructional math coaches are able to model and co- te instructional routines to implement them with Fidelity and give teams specific feedback in real time
201to improve effective independent instruction finally through data analysis the instructional math coach can guide teachers through making integral instructional decisions related to the following day's lesson ultimately the goal of any job embedded professional learning is to change practices and in this instance release the teachers to be able to plan collaboratively and teach effectively and independently making sure the planned content and strategies are carried out properly is just as important as the planning itself when we establish and maintain effective Central Services and school-based Partnerships we create the condition for our teachers and students to thrive the central office guidance and oversight ensures that the Integrity of the position and the support is maintained ensuring teachers are secure with the math content is essential Jennifer lnac will now share with you some MSD updates that will impact
202both Elementary and secondary math next slide please as we review first quarter data reflect on the impact the coaches have had on student achievement and determine how to Foster and continue improved math achievement it's important to keep in mind that the Maryland state of Department of Education is evaluating what it means to be College and Career ready msde is making significant changes to the secondary math course sequencing in the coming years rather than offering three distinct courses Algebra 1 geometry and Algebra 2 Maryland Public Schools will transition I to an integrated math course sequence integrated math Algebra 1 and then integrated Algebra 2 through this shift it will be imperative to continue direct support to teachers from coaches and Specialists as they unpack the new standards from msde and study a new curriculum currently msde
203is determining the major content for each grade level and course next year the Maryland State Department of Education will communicate and begin professional learning on the revised prek through integrated algebra standards in 2026 2027 implementation for prek through 8 standards will be rolled out in the following year integrated Algebra 1 will begin and will be followed by the integrated Algebra 2 for the school year 2029 this process of providing schools with ongoing support and content expertise from centrally supervised math positions such as the instructional math coaches and Specialists will be essential to ensuring a smooth transition to course sequencing changes and the continued success of our students here in mcps I'll now turn it over to Dr Peggy Pew next slide please I think in uh closing our portion of the presentation and getting ready
204to turn back to you in for discussion it's important to know that there is a lot of work that needs to happen in mathematics and I think that what we have seen is typically when you have a new standard or set of standards that it schools and systems don't do great on it but over time they learn the ins and outs of the content learn the ins and outs of the assessment and you see things start to improve what we have not seen in Maryland is Improvement um year over-year and so it's important to know that the the state is looking at those standards and really instead of having multiple standards assessed in multiple years with lack of clarity about when students Sol ly have to know it hopefully what is it's developed is much
205more clean much more clear um and we're able to help our teachers understand exactly what how students will be measured for their understanding and with that we'll turn it back to you for discussion thank you thank you everyone um I'm going to turn to my colleague to see everyone has questions or comments uh um let's restrict to two questions per B member this round I'm going to start from this side thank you I just have one question to start um can we go back to the MLK slide for for a second I think it was a couple slides back that's slide eight slide eight yes um but so so when we're looking at this this uh growth percentile evaluation uh were magnet students disaggregated from this data or is this the entire School including magnet
206students as well no the magnet students were not disaggregated out of this data all right thank you Mrs Inman thank you um so as we're looking at our math proficiency you know either declining or being kind of stagnant across grade levels as our kids are getting older um I want to like ask a little bit more about um what we're doing with map and how we're looking at the data um I'm going to for the sake of the like explain a little bit um I'm not trying to talk at you I know you I know you know um so right measured academic progress map test they change um actually each juncture that we're looking at right that um with nwaa that their their tests right their map tests they each change like for kindergarten right
207that they're being tested on prek to3 skills um and actually that test is read to students that Matt P test is read to them then it changes in third grade and they're being tested on like second through sixth grade skills so at each juncture that we're looking at we're looking at kids changing the entire assessment right that it's not just um map is not the same across from K to 12 it changes at each point my question is have we considered looking at um changes in data from kindergarten to second grade within the same test and are we seeing Improvement there same with like third grade you know like look at third grade and fifth grade that's the same test they're taking have we considered looking at it that way to see if we're seeing
208improvements across each test as we're changing each one each time I wonder if we're just spinning our Wheels we looking at different things for comparing apples and oranges so I'll speak to particularly the slide on MLK so when we looked at the data for MLK Patty worked closely with the math 18 team last year and so what we did is we looked at the cohort of students um from seventh grade into 8th grade because it would be the same map test and the stud students more students were proficient from the same set of cohorta students from 7th to 8th grade and so we're like that's wonderful that helps to understand you know um the kids are growing and doing better and we also just decided Well what does it look like when we look at
209one year's eighth graders to the next year's eighth graders and we also noticed growth there and so that's one of the things that we were looking at when we were looking at some of this map growth for MLK um and I think Patty spoke really wonderfully about the conditions and the expectations the principal set up in order to allow for Patty to coach the teachers on regular basis there's no hey there's a sub out can you come and cover this class it's this is curriculum study it's important we're dedicated to this and this is the outcome of that dedication and support so it it sounds like this is something that maybe we are seeing improvements across that so maybe it's something we should look at um as a whole right that if we're if we're
210seeing we not seeing Improvement maybe where can we find that Improvement to help us better understand um what we need to do so speaking of that what do we need to do um what do you all believe is is the barrier that's making it difficult for us to see greater improvement in our our math proficiency for students well at the elementary level um many schools have may feel like they've had the math curriculum for 5 years um it was across uh the pandemic and now they're being asked to learn a new Ela curriculum as well and so our elementary teachers are now being asked to become content experts and you heard that phrase at least five times um as we were presenting and so again having our math leaders in the building is one tool
211but we know at the elementary level over 60% of our named math leaders are dual Ro uh serve dual roles they're actually the staff development teacher as well and so when we look at having our instruction math coaches there again they block out the noise they are there in in in Team Planning consistently and following up with instruction as well that's where we've seen that needle move is again we we find that teachers are able to agree and find common understanding in planning but then it takes more time to see those those agreements transition into instruction and so by having our instructional math coaches in classrooms seeing instruction happen in real time modeling in real time with them building that job embedded professional partner not someone just saying do it this way but let's talk
212about this how do we make this work for the children that are in my room at this time on this day that that's really showing success and so now that we've seen that can we have those conditions and expectations for agreed upon curriculum study time the frequency where that we we not only have the grade level team uh Team there but we also have those staff members supporting special education our um EML students as well that are part of that conversation as well so that we we see that these are integral pieces to improving our craft and improving the outcomes for our students okay um so I feel like that that spoke to where we're seeing success I I don't feel like I've heard like where where do we think the barriers might be well
213and because of this because we are in our second year after our first year with this implementation we saw such good return on this investment that we actually planned our entire summer learning for schools around this model and so again shifting that looking at curriculum study and instruction along with data monitoring that it can't be that that math leader is only at planning that we have to see them focusing in on maybe the top two grade levels in that in that building that need that most support and the principle is key in identifying those two or three grade levels so that that math leader or the coach if they're assigned can follow up with instruction as well so again we're seeing that this is a model that is showing Improvement and I'll just add to
214to to address the barriers right what what the part of it about the work that they're doing one of the biggest barriers is understanding and know of the actual content what does this standard mean what does it assess how is it being measured what when you know doing this work sometimes we find that we're not even giving students access to a full grade level content question uh or we're giving it to them but giving so many scaffolds that we're not building them towards independence of being able to meet that math skill or standard so at the elementary level lots of times because elementary teachers are generalists and we are asking them to know deep level of content the math content is is how the team is actually supporting them in looking at uh at the
215data so I would say content knowledge is sometimes a barrier understanding of the standards is sometimes a barrier at that level I know if you want to talk sec I think at times the barrier comes in um the opportunity for unit planning and curriculum study and so Patty talked about um the teachers choosing the best activities they going to support students attaining what they need in order to answer the exit ticket at the end of the day and sometimes when we don't give teachers the opportunity to really study the curriculum they don't see that they aren't always able to see the big picture and so those little decisions that they make every single day sometimes take you a little further off of where you need to go and so sometimes it's about protected planning time
216it's about the principal um partnership with us around there's a math coach in the building is there a way to you know not have them do plan um coverage around the building or um what's the expectation for planning in the building and having a really great partnership with them all right um I'm going to move on from here miss Sylvester um thank you the the last time you presented on math data I think uh asked the same question um what are we going to do differently to have a different outcome and I believe the answer was to continue to do professional development as I'm hearing today um um and I'm I'm happy to hear you're having success with the math coaches but there's only how many in the whole system six eight something like that
217so um 12 12 12 okay thank you so what's our strategy to reach we can't we just can't you know we can't wait for uh 12 people to get through an entire um school system so what's what are we going to do to do what we have to do to reach more teachers so that they can have you know as you the the support and content knowledge increase that they need and curriculum time and planning so that uh we can see some of the outcomes that you have uh presented today we're so glad that you asked um and uh they'll they'll opine on some of the more specific strategies uh and while they're kind of collecting their thoughts around that I I will say that um we do have some expansion of math coaches in
218uh the budget proposal uh that's before the board for consideration into cross functional teams where they'll work with literacy Specialists School leadership uh as well as other domains to meet the needs of a specific cluster and to to rearrange their work on a cluster basis and really hyperfocus so that they have a set of teachers that are known to them uh that are their teachers and uh every teacher across the uh the district is accounted for in that model and we'll expand to have enough to cover that uh but to approach it from more of a cluster basis but we we see great efficacy in the work that uh the coaches are doing right now and see an opportunity to expand that and to have a a focus that is cluster based and utilizing our
219cross functional team approach in the future but they also have other specific strategies and they'll tell you all about it and I'll just add another large District strategy is clear focus on what the outcome is that you're measuring and valuing making sure we have cons assessment literacy right so that people understand the point of each of these assessments that we're giving and what they can get from them um the other piece is the alignment of professional learning professional learning should include content um and content needs to be a part of so there's an opportunity moving forward in looking at how we're delivering professional development uh by including content as part of that professional development at the appropriate grade levels I'll expand on that a little more um in the month of December we provided professional
220learning for all school-based lead or for school-based leaders so a school can invite three people with them to professional learning and the professional learning was solely on secondary mathematics everyone engaged in an Algebra 1 Lesson they experienced a math language routine um they understood like the components of a lesson and what you should be seeing when you go in there and so what we did as a secondary math team is we we were hoping to align our professional learning that was scheduled for yesterday with math leaders to say you had professional learning with your principal now here's how we're going to support you in coaching and seeing that this change happens and so that we're not just accepting something stagnant but from the secondary math team we push in Specialists where there aren't coaches to
221support the math leader in ensuring that change happens what's your school Improvement plan what are the micro changes that you're making along the way throughout the school year to get to that end goal of your school Improvement plan and so I don't know that we've connected our work always the same way with the school Improvement plan and so that's been one of the major pushes for our team is to say when you go in there as a specialist or coach you should know their school Improvement plan what is the change that the content specialist is making how can you support the content specialist to have coaching conversations with a teacher who maybe isn't making the change along the way through the the professional learning that's being provided okay um yeah I'd love to learn more
222about this process it just seems so hard and it's takes so much work across such a large system and um you know putting more money into it doesn't sit well with me it it feels like we're I think you've said this before right we're still learning this curriculum because of the pandemic wasn't a fair shot to say that we've really had it for this long so um for a follow-up conversation I just I just really want to understand why it's it's been so hard for the system to really benefit from this curriculum thank you yes Miss Rivera Al thank you so um going by the the example Dr M by the way I love the math coaches I seen them in practice I think they're great but I do have a couple of questions on
223the Dr Martin Luther King slide so the that is from 2022 to to 202 think to Spring of 2023 to 2024 correct and then the latest data that we have for the um nwaa that I have here is 2024 to 2025 so if I look at Martin Luther King for the sixth graders for this year am I wrong that there's been a significant decrease so we looked at um we we're thinking Patty worked with them during the 2023 202 for school year and so we wanted to know how did they end the school year in the way nwea looks at growth you should look at growth from one the same Administration so we looked at them in the spring of one year and the spring after Patty had been working with the teachers at MLK
224and what we see is that their growth percentile not their achievement but their growth percentile is 66% and so I'll give you what that means is that if I scored 220 um I the what they do is they take all the kids who scored in that same percentage or that same score and say all right if a 100 kids took it and scored 220 let's look at a 100 Kids those same 100 kids and see how they did and how much growth they made and so on average if we were to put those kids in that you know line them up one through 100 they were at 66% top and so they're growing faster than 65 other students in that same testing rank of whatever they started with and so that's what we're looking at
225here um growth because when we look at some of the achievement with the schools where there's a coach needed there's a lot of need to get the students to proficiency and so sometimes we look at growth to find celebrations and to see that the needle is moving for the student even though we aren't yet seeing the needle movement proficiency so you're saying that for since they just took the new sixth graders MLK just took the test as fall that the next time they take the test we should see a significant increase um compared to the numbers or even more than what we're seeing as the final test takers for these sixth graders just to make it clear okay so so so then that goes to the point of the need of math coaches in elementary
226school and and this is maybe an if question if these kids would have had that kind of support in elementary school the kids who went into MLK where their scores be better taking it in this fall and when we will see an increase um but then I look these kids go into senaka Valley correct okay so the kids in eighth grade and and one of the things that I had an issue with is although the these are the general numbers I don't see the EML numbers and the farm numbers which are significant to me because there is a significant number of kids who are EML and there's different levels of EML so I was looking mainly looking at the EML Force where are the kids who are about to finish EML and transition into regular
227classes and the kids in farms so if we look at eighth grade those kids will go into senaka Valley High School right so senaka Valley this this fall right had 400 plus kids who took the test and MLK had 230 so half of them came from MLK but I'm looking at their scores for at least the black kids and Latino kids and only % right were able um to score in the in the maps and for Hispanics it was only 48% and then if we look at EML it's 18% and then um IEP is even worse it's like 133% so I'm trying to see if the other kids who are not part of that group did not have that kind of support which then goes into US looking into advocating for M math coaches because
228if half those kids had that support right at MLK in eth grade and we saw that they were that they were performing at a 72% but then we're looking to the kids you know who who took the test I'm trying to see why was such a big decrease of almost 20 in some cases 25% so when we look at the 8th grade students at sen at MLK who are in this um 73rd percentile for growth correct this includes all eighth graders whether they're in math 8 whether they're in Algebra 1 or whether they're in Geometry okay when we look at the cica valley what high schools were asked to do was only to assess this algebra 1 students I got you and so we're not really looking at the same group of students um and
229so I would say that's would be only looking at probably the kids who were in math 8 in the previous year and um we know our data tends to not be the same for every for students in the different courses and then there is is there a way for us then to get that data to see how those kids are doing like to see the kids who were in this cohort of 8th graders whether they're taking algebra where they're taking different math and so are they doing as well as were expected or is it that we need to put more you know math coaches to support the trajectory of those kids in high school to be consistent with what they had in middle school that's something you guys are the experts so you tell me
230so that's something that we can look into I think another thing as I sit here is looking at as our students um go from middle to from elementary to middle school and they have a coach it's a coached school at Elementary and then what does that look like when they also have a coached school at the middle school yes and how that over time supports students um so those are some data points that we can look at okay um I also wanted there was something else that you said I'll come back the emls do this how poorly they're doing in every level they would be included just into whatever demographic they are we pulled this um data through the nwaa website and currently we I don't know that we are sharing that level of data
231with nwaa that I was able to pull um other subgroups of students it was just by race to your point though you're looking at trying to follow the sequential story of our impact and I think it's really right on point when you're looking at we want to measure students against themselves first of all and then we want to know what they actually had access to what supports they had access to so these instructional coaches are working with the teachers so that the teachers no longer need an instructional coach right it doesn't need to be there their whole idea is to coach the process to give the support and and depending on what level of support is needed and then to move to another group so I think we will have to track where they're assigned
232and how to get the information that you're asking for but your interest your point is interesting you know the we want to prove what is working for these students and what will work for these students is our teachers all having solid understanding of the content the time to plan together and collaborate the time to react and respond to the data that they see in planning what's next and I think that's really important because how sad would it be that we're making such a great gains with having you know these coaches and then when they go to high school we lose all that ground right that we're supposed to be building on and I think I use this example very quick quickly when I was when I was actually um in one of the classrooms um
233I went to the when they did the whole you know they were like teaching the teachers pretty much you know and and there was all this all all of these about fractions and the way they did it it made so much sense to me that I wish somebody have taught me that way when I was in seventh grade because I would have gotten it so it it it makes such a you know such a difference but I'm just my concern is that by the time we spend all this funding and so on right we we get it and then when they move they transition into high school and then there's nothing right right thank you Miss Miss wolf I think my question has already been answered but I'm getting a little brain dead so maybe
234not I think it's the same as as Miss Sylvester's question the math coaches are making progress but but we can't afford but so many math courses math coaches so what what we going to do and I I heard you say cross functional teams but I'm not even sure that I understand why that would be why that would work if there's no math coach um I can say how that would work um that would work because we're all giving the same information to the teachers and to the to the leaders of the building we all understand the context under what let's just say sixth grade they're studying sixth grade and working with sixth grade if we are addressing the needs of of the students we are all doing that as a team the special educator is
235going to learn math but they also come bring an expertise with them that says this student has an IEP goal for mathematics and they're missing this preliminary skill and so I can work with them here on on this preliminary skill the ELD teacher would would know the level of EML language to know what accessibility to build into the routine so it's it's rather than everybody coming in separately only teaching what they know about ELD support or only special ed support or only math support this is an opportunity for everybody to learn what each other does and actually synthesize it so that it's clear and can you imagine being a sixth grade teacher hearing from five experts um you need to hear the same thing and you need to be working on the same thing so
236this will simplify I think our approach it will make it together a little bit more unified with a very clear end goal so in addition to the four middle school math coaches at the secondary level there are two instructional specialist at the middle school level and two instructional specialists at the high school level and so what the Specialists do is they AR a big difference is that the coaches are able to say every Tuesday I am at MLK with the math 8 team and we are planning and we are curriculum studying and so the um support and coaching is weekly sometimes bi-weekly and so they're able to know that every Tuesday Patty's going to be there without a doubt um for some of our schools that don't have coaches a specialist comes out maybe to
237their monthly department meeting and provides professional learning some of our Specialists come out and plan monthly or when they're come when the PLC is when the planning team is coming up on a unit they might say hey I'm going to come in and I'm going to do unit planning with you and we're going to talk about what's necessary for kids to get out of the next 6 weeks of learning and so there are coaches and they're being effective uh we also have instructional math Specialists who are supporting the other schools who don't have coaches it's just that they're not able to consistently be there every Tuesday and it's a difference in not every school needs the same level of support and so we have to determine these are schools that need intense support they have
238a coach these are schools that don't need as much int support and they would get the support of a specialist thank you and if I could add I hear what you're saying I'll have to wait for the result because I'm not I'm not exactly seeing that because I thought the math coaches also have the ability to go into the classroom and observe and model and I think that is a key element of it so but there is one request that I have the um the charts by school that you gave out don't always have the n in it I need the N yeah okay if somebody could say because it's missing a lot it has the data but it doesn't have the N okay um miss m thank you that was actually one of my
239requests as well I think just this year's data doesn't have the end but last year's did so maybe it just got got left off um my I have two questions um and one is well one first thank you all the work that you're doing especially with such low levels of Staffing I know that this is challenging especially with a new curricula so I do appreciate it while we don't see the gains that we want I mean at least looking at you know grade six we do see some slight gains so hopefully right we stay that path um my question is given how little staff that you have and there's only so many hours in the day um what's happening with schools where maybe on the whole it looks like everything's okayish or it's not bad
240but then when you break down certain to demographic there are still demographics that quite frankly year after year we see the same pattern of not quite reaching the levels of proficiency that we would like how if in any way are we able to address that um and then the second question is similar to with literacy what can we do at home because I can say as a parent when I've asked and I've heard from many many parents from parents who have ridiculous numbers of degrees in education to parents who don't speak English um The Homework Helper just isn't helpful so what can we do at home I I would if we could go to the next slide please one thing I'd like to address is when we're talking about breaking down the subgroups if we
241look when we had our summer training with all elementary schools we had our um school teams that were represented choose one area that they were going to focus on so again that way they could see what is their need and they also PRI prioritize one maybe two grade levels to focus in on so again to your point thinking around where is that group of children that we need to follow for example we had a um for uh Flower Hill was here and they shared how they focused on their grade four uh class uh of students and so looking at what are they doing in particular if it's a curriculum study are we having that time to make sure we have that minimum of 45 minutes to really dive into what is the know of the
242stand and how do our students need to show they understand that and then having that time to look at by those different groups how are we performing what are the shifts we need to make in instruction so that we can be sure that our students are able to demonstrate their knowledge in multiple ways so that we are not overs scaffolding as well so we want to make sure that we're doing that now to your point at home um uh again we we know that there are some materials that do come with our our vendor that we want to make sure that parents have access to as well and there are also um additional resources that the schools have that they may be um able to provide with particular students or student groups as well um
243but again uh we want to make sure that math is a happy event at home and not a point of frustration right and I think I would just like to encourage and and I can appreciate each School sends out information differently and communicates differently and whatnot um but I think that then becomes also part of the challenge right is because then we hear things from different people from different schools and so maybe similar to the way we have the resource Hub that mentioned on literacy is there something there where parents can know where it is independent of their school I I can just say you know the the curricula provided resources and helpful they're just not that helpful right we didn't learn this math either just like you guys didn't so great thank at the
244secondary level we also have iel um from math 6 through Algebra 2 and so I excel proba at times maybe shows some um supports that may be a little more traditional that a parent is accustomed to how they would have learned mathematics and so I would always encourage if there's a parent out there who is a middle school math 6 through Algebra 2 to jump on Exel and Exel gives videos it gives supports to students to help them along the way um and so I'd really put Elevate the support thatl can give um and around the schools when you disaggregate their data and determine that there might be a subgroup of students that needs more support if they don't have a coach that's when we would send a specialist out there and think about what
245does the math leader in the building what capacity building do they need what supports do they need to have conversations with their teachers to say you know we're looking at our data and here's where we notice things and so that's part of the role of a specialist is to help math leaders within the middle school and the high school have those conversations and Elevate that data with their departments all right thank you and for those that that don't knowel is an online learning platform um it's actually outfitted for kindergarten through 12th um for core subjects you can add on things like Spanish I actually use at home for my kids um begrudgingly at times but it is it can be helpful thank you Miss St okay so uh we really haven't talked about this kindergarten
246cohort too much so what what your plan I mean this is a big change and it's you know it's going to be um a project right so anyway I want to hear about your plans before the math team jumps in about their plans about what to do for this kindergarten cohort one of the other strategies is to increase the access to highquality prek programs that are in alignment to what what we're doing um in the kindergarten program so it's often you don't know who's coming to you as a as a school system when they come to you and it's a natural entry point for school at kindergarten they're still very young very adaptable very eager to learn many of them um and so I I advocate for as much um prior care as possible where
247there's activities that are involving numeracy even life activities and I think we used some examples last time measuring C those types of things that that can happen in a structured way but for the students who have come to us in kindergarten I'll let Carla respond it it's funny you should ask that um a gentleman who had shared out earlier um in public comment was sharing how um he was stressed out about trigonometry and I said well if you think trigonometry is challenging try teaching kindergarten math um and I and I say that in just but in all seriousness um as we look at when we implement Ed the new curriculum several years ago uh kindergarten primary teachers would often say oh we can go faster we can go through this much more quick quickly and
248it was like no again understanding deeply understanding the standards do they understand what is the expectation when we're looking at those primary age students and the depth of understanding they need to understand it's not simply being able to count one to 10 it's understanding what does one mean what does it represent how can I look at this and understand these are two objects and if I take away one there's one remaining so there's all of these different components to this and to go back to you Miss Montoya um we also have zern which is an online free tutorial that I love to see that you're smiling and that's genuine smiling right a little bit we about that later we'll take that um but but to your point it's it's not enough just to provide the
249parents with resources we also have our math leaders who are staffed in the schools again often many of them are also staff development teachers but as part of our math leader learning which we have uh most every month um throughout the year we are providing um training and and professional learning to look at a standard or a group of standards as they progress for example from K to2 so that they can understand this is how this learning progresses from kindergarten to grade one to grade two so that when they are supporting their teams of teachers at school and a kindergarten um team may be says oh we can we can move through this AR kids can do this already they have that background knowledge now to ask those questions of well can they show it
250in this way are they understanding this let's really dig into the standard have we gotten to that depth of the standard for the children to understand thank you now um I had one more my second question it's not too complicated but um what I mean from this data like we can't wait a whole another year right um so so what's the priority today I mean we only have so many math coaches we have these teams just if you could quickly let me know what is what's the the bang for our buck right now to change some of these Trends ensuring that every student is seeing highquality instructional materials every single day in class from prek through Algebra 2 and that the purchased approved Board of Ed curriculum is what students are seeing because there is
251alignment between the curriculum our mcap and College and Career Readiness thank you and and supporting schools so that they can develop a master schedule that allows for teachers to have that time to go in and study this again this is this is a science and an art it's not simply I love children therefore because I love children I can teach this we know that that our our teachers are very committed to this um for an example we had a a teacher who was at a school a coach supported school that moved out of the state for other reasons and emailed their coach this year to say I so miss mcps and the coach and the way we looked at curriculum study and unpack this and I am teaching my team how to do it as
252well so when we provide that support and we are there not simply coming in to tell but we are building these relationships and it's a true partnership these these teachers see that they'll see it in their math leader at their school as well if we can make sure that we honor those conditions and we set those expectations thank you Mr Sana all right thank you uh I just want to say I appreciate the work that you guys have been doing thank you so much this has been a very well-informed presentation um kind of going back to to to one of the questions I had asked earlier regarding the aggregation of the inform uh of the data uh between the magnet programs um I'm looking through the the rest of these schools and there's a lot
253more schools where I think the data still is not disaggregated between magnet students and and students and I'm concerned that you know this might be used as a way to uh that this might not be showing the true facts of the data and is maybe covering up spaces that we know we need to work more uh and we can't really see that because this data is being covered with you know magnet student data as well I think when you look at the MLK data we do see that African-American black Hispanic Latinos are above the 50th percentile for growth and so I I think that that speaks for the students in in all of the school um and so we can get back to you and look at some of the data but we tend to
254keep School data at times um aggregate we want to include when a school has a magnet program we also want to include the data when a school has a special education program and not start saying well only these students are my students um and so that's why when we present some of this data that we don't do that um I do want to elevate that Patty is working with grade 8 math our coaches are working with Ong grade level students and so many times the magnet students aren't the students in our on grade level courses and so the growth that we're seeing while maybe a magnet school is um representative of the students there that's their home school okay thank you I think I think that uh pretty clearly answered my question I appreciate that
255but um I think there like I I understand the the concern around you know not wanting to differentiate students based on you know this is my student this is not my students everyone in mcps is our student right um but really just making sure that we're understanding where we need to you know keep making progress and keep working forward right and not just you know looking at the data a at a whole and then missing out you know pieces from the back because we're not you know really digging deep into this uh that's kind of my general Point that's all I have to say thank you um I have a question or more of comment so um it's wonderful it's showing that the mass coaches the the investment of the system is working right it's
256clearly demonstrated by the data of these schools however our system also have other um investment we made on secondary level I believe every school have a Content specialist that are released for two periods of of the day or one period of the day okay they get um two they're released two periods this just the same as all teachers and then additional perod out of that is an investment uh too over this many schools we also have investment in our staff development teachers however when we talk about the work I hardly whether in reading or in math I hardly hear what efforts uh what results are from these Investments we have made in the system so sometimes I'm not convinced putting more people or or or giving people more free period because I haven't heard the
257evidence that actually work so that's my comment so maybe in the future in our math or literacy uh conversations I can understand a bit more of uh what they do now second thing is um um we renew the curriculum wonderful and everyone in agreement we should renew the curriculum now um I'm sure there are math walkthroughs that happen in our buildings okay and then but are we really looking at the implementation of the Integrity of the implementation of the curriculum are they using it are they using it well are they getting better what can that tell us who's supposed to do that I can't say all the Mass coaches all a few of your Specialists are going to do all this so what other staff are we involved in this work um so um I
258don't think mine is really meant for question for you to answer mine is meant for a comment for us to think about uh what existing people we use and how do we use these existing people uh for future discussion given that we have time constrainted um another thing is I want to thank you for in the data that EML levels English language proficiency levels uh are included uh school by school I will really appreciate if we can have that data also a systemwide so that it's it's better to to understand uh the group as a whole uh is it am I missing it or is it somewhere so that would be in the first line of each of the charts is the all total are you saying okay okay okay okay thank you thank you
259that that will help um me to get a bigger picture thank you so much are there any closing J I have a question oh okay I just have a question um when you read the the sort of us news we're not the only one struggling with math has anyone looked around to see if there's any District with similar demographics it's having success and if so what they're doing so um we've opened some conversations with other districts in Montgomery County I mean in the state of Maryland to kind of see well what are you doing at um your schools and different things like that we also are a part of a partnership with learning forward in which we um are a part of a cohort of Montgomery County Public Schools Nashville and Philadelphia um and where
260we talk about curriculum implementations where we learn the other best practices of the other counties that are trying to implement the elative math curriculum I'll let Patty add anything she wants to that because I think that's been pretty beneficial so I've been also a part of that Network um there are three mcgurer County public schools that are part of that Network is neilsville Middle School Gaithersburg middle school and Shady Grove Middle School um and it's been really powerful for the teachers in those buildings to have connections outside of Montgomery County that are implementing the curriculum um to one recognize that their struggles are also the struggles of others but also to hear the best practices that Metro Nashville are coming out with or the city of Philadelphia is coming out with as well well thank
261you but I'm I'm not asking about just best practices is there any District that you're aware of that's actually having success because I mean their best practices here in Montgomery County their best practices in Philadelphia but their numbers are poor Nashville's numbers are poor I mean you go and look at the um National assessment of educational progress and you can tell they're not doing any better I'm trying to figure out who's doing better and if we know that what are they doing and if there's no one that you know that's fine so I first started with we are we have reached out to a couple of the other counties who have been successful on their mcap data to hear a little bit more about what they're doing about the curriculum about how they uh deploy
262support to schools and different things like that you're talking about the counties here in Maryland yeah correct and I they don't have similar demographics to us I'm looking for somebody that has the same I know that fur fact demographic FFX has done quite an improvement on their math and reading and I think f is pretty comparable FFA Fairfax does somewhat yes yeah so we can look at their best practices and I think we brought this issue up already like a a year ago okay but they they definitely are and also not just with the general population but also with EML and and special education all right so thank you everyone for your presentation on math um I think my chief of staff keep showing a message we're one hour behind schedule all right so thank
263you so much and I would like to move on now uh to our safety and security update thank you Madame President um we are ready to move to Safety and Security as we switch gears uh from the board's academic goals and agenda to uh making sure that our schools are safe welcoming and inclusive uh this commitment is not just a statement it is our guiding principle that helps to shape our actions and decisions as a school system the collaborative efforts created by our team to coordinate safety plans and strategies that impact individual facilities within their communities are crucial to the success and positive outcomes of each of our schools uh by dedicating our attention to such uh critical areas we affirm our unwavering commitment to fostering a safe atmosphere where students can learn and Thrive
264without compromise I'm excited to uh welcome several uh folks uh to the table I'm going to introduce um not just Mr Marcus Jones but the Miss shaa K jorab uh to lead uh today's presentation and tell you about details uh on how we are moving mcps forward in safety uh you'll also see today that this is a reflection of a couple of things one our multifaceted view of uh the safety needs in the district and uh as we mentioned at the start of uh my time with you on um uh as your superintendent that we would be revisiting this topic multiple times a year and this is the second time that we've had the chance to do that so Mr Jones thank you Dr Taylor and good evening to president Yang and members of the
265board uh thank you for the opportunity to engage in the dialogue today about the critical work of ensuring that our staff students and families are safe mcgomery County Public Schools is committed to providing for the safety of all persons on M Montgomery County Public Schools property and to creating and maintaining safe peaceful schools and workplaces where students and staff can do their best work achieve and Thrive uh the next slide please please it is essential to understand that Safety and Security is a multi-dimensional is multi-dimensional and requires a layered approach effective results with less incidents showing uh with staff visibility across many of our schools have proven to be effective consistency I would say is a key word as we work towards uh decreasing variance across our schools to increase Effectiveness administrations that are leading
266from the front with clear expectations and provide are is are making those a priority and producing positive outcomes um the next slide please in bullet three uh we're going to this we want to talk about the some of the things that we have uh begun um over the course of uh uh this uh school year the middle school camera project is at the top of our list as we have a we received the state Grant 98% of those uh new cameras have been um installed at our at our middle schools we've only we are um four schools from completing that project which should be completed within the next week or two upgraded and new cameras are being installed in the next few months that have been identified from a backlog um as well as our
267current request Vape sensors uh installations are scheduled are being scheduled as we talk um and are being shared will be shared with our high school principls in the next uh week or two um as we talk about our community engagement officers that are assigned to our high school clusters um and support each respective cluster um all of our CEO positions are currently filled except one and that is at Northwest High School um I have been in contact with police leadership um they expect that position to be filled this month so we should be getting notification of the officer who will be responsible for uh the Northwest High School cluster we are also conducting training um for all of our security assistants um our training to include our management of aggressive behaviors for all of our
268security assistant to address um to enhance uh deescalation to deal with crowd control as well as managing physical uh confrontation this is addresses major liability issues for our district knowing that our folks are are properly trained in these techniques um that that training is expected to be to occur within the next couple of months so as you note that there are lots of balls being uh are in the air in which we are um working towards uh many aspects of our Safety and Security plan but I also wanted to note that we also have our panic button um considerations I know there's been a lot of conversation a lot of consideration about Panic buttons as we talk about cell phones at our schools as well as radio transmissions and I just want to highlight that
269uh real quickly because I have noted this uh just a few months ago when I began in my seat that we would explore an alert system crisis alert system throughout our entire system we have been speaking and we are speaking with several vendors um to try to find the best product possible that we would deem that would be um um feasible and it will be productive um in in in the world of security for all of our schools for all of our staff to have the accessibility to be able to make an emergency notification um I know there's been lots of discussion about cell phone coverage at our at our schools whether it be any level of school it's always a matter of discussion I can tell you in many buildings throughout Montgomery County that
270are even outside of schools in my in my um role as the chief of police we found that there's been poor communication there's been poor cell phone coverage and you have three major vendors primarily Verizon AT&T and T-Mobile and all of them work on their own separate systems just recently I was at McGruder High School um walking through the halls of McGruder where I had a Verizon phone that had no cell phone coverage but I did have SOS coverage which means that if I needed to contact 911 that cell phone still allows you to call 911 okay I was standing next to the security team leader who has a mo a T-Mobile cell phone he had five bars why because there's a T-Mobile cellular Tower right next to mcgutter high school so there's a lot
271of dynamics that come um with uh increasing cell phone coverage there's a lot of costs that come with increasing cell phone coverage uh but these are the things that we are examining we are looking at um as we go through and do assessments at each of our high school that we will talk about um a little bit later in this presentation um as we have been working with our High School principles we'll be working with our Middle School principles and working with all of our Elementary School principles to address those needs that they have when it comes to communication um as as was noted earlier today I will also briefly note that about um communication when it comes to uh radios that we have in our schools um I've been in not only working with
272our our current radio system that we have but also talking with um our other partners such as Montgomery County Police as well as Montgomery County government with their Communications emergency communications to look at new technology that will assist us uh for emergency notifications for our schools um that we also look at for police coverage where it has been a common practice for us to for the police department to actually go to the different schools to actually uh work Co putting different types of technology in order for Boost uh signaling to be able to communicate for their CEOs and responding officers for intercommunications we are currently continuing to do some assessments and work on some improvements in those areas as well but again that comes with funding um but we're also seeking other uh funding opportunities
273such as grants that may be able to assist us and uh in improving in those systems so at this point I will now turn it over to miss Sonic K thank you good evening everyone um we're going to be discussing serious incidents today and I wanted to take a moment just to make sure that we all had a common understanding of some of the language we're going to use and why we put a a greater Focus or priority on serious incidents over incidents so I want to start with how incidents are recorded or how they're tracked so staff enter into a system that we have called Synergy any behavior that they think should be noted or addressed can we go to the next next slide next slide thank you and those may include large level
274behaviors uh which we'll talk about in a second but they also include things like tardies or dress code um in fact tardies account for one in seven of all of our incidents um so they're noted because they need to be addressed not necessarily because they have a direct impact on Safety and Security so there will be many many incidents thousands of incidents however some incidents are noted as serious incidents serious incidents according to our mcps regulation um are ones that include a high level of risk harm threat to staff or students or seriously disrupt School operations um um it could also be a concern that could escalate to a community concern or could be elevated to a legal concern or a police matter A good rule of thumb for me is I always think about
275as a principal if I have to call out for support then it's a serious incident um so that's one way to think about it um other serious incidents include weapons they may include some fights but not all fights um and non-serious incidents include things even such as academic dishonesty so when we're looking at it we're looking at a broad broad range so when it comes to matters of Safety and Security we're going to be talking mainly about serious incidents today I do want to say in case it comes up as a question that Trends in non-serious incidents really are also important for example if a school has a high incidence of tardies when students are are in unstructured time that could lead to further serious incidents so they do matter they are important but overall
276in Safety and Security we talk about are serious incidents next slide please when a serious incident occurs a principal or their design makes all external calls for appropriate support and consultation all principles and school admin receive training and guidance on incidents that are required requ ired to be called in so in addition to these trainings they receive regular updates about what incidents are required for example hate bias incidents whether we may believe they're serious or not serious as long as it is in that category it is a required call the serious incident is then directly reported to the office of school support and Improvement and then it is recorded and logged in the serious Incident Management System also in Synergy that incident generates an incident report number and is tracked for follow-up and support measures
277and over the last two years that is a particular in area that we're working on right the the second part of that the followup and support measures that happen with those incidents as of today I can share with you that of any open Serious incidents 78.6% of those incidents are closed out which means that they've received the appropriate followup and the appropriate resp response um one area that we're working on is incidents that may not receive uh are not done by students so if an incident's not done by a student and doesn't require a discipline response or a parent or a follow-up response for example a medical emergency sometimes those incidents are not closed back out because um there's there's nothing attached to it so we're working on how to go back at non-student incidents
278to make sure that they're close back out next slide please so here you have a snapshot of our series incidents for the current school year year to date as compared to last year's incidents year to date and you can see they're fairly similar in terms of the amount where we have some of the difference is that there are less serious incidents this year and it's not a big number it's about 2.5% but you can see last year we were running about 22% of our incidents as serious and this year about 19.5% of our incidents are are serious and we're going to take a a little bit of a deeper dive into that in the next slide all right so again serious incidents or incidents in general are many many many incidents and we're looking right
279now at the top incidents that are reported as serious and if you follow the chart with me um in 2023 in terms of knives and other weapons we had about 75 reports at this time this year and this year it's about similar it's about 71 and you'll see that Trend holds true in several of these categories one that I'd like to note is um in fighting an attack on others so in terms of the number of serious fights not in terms of the number of fights but in terms of the number of serious fights uh we're seeing a slight decrease increase in that category and a little bit of an increase in our drugs and Controlled Substances so those are areas that we're monitoring in terms of how we're continuing to address them next slide
280please so in order to create the conditions for a safe environment we have to consider not just what happens once an incident occurs right the the point is we don't want incidents to occur so the majority of what we focus on is how to create proactive measures to ensure that that incidents do not occur and one area that we really need to work on is our expectations for our students and I think you've heard that again and again and again and and we've we've looked at that year on year on- year what that looks like so in the past when we're sharing expectations with students schools do that in a variety of ways they hold town halls with students at the start of the year and at each quarter they have admin visits to classroom
281there are psychosocial lessons with counselors and this year for the first time in addition to our culture of respect modules focused on bullying and on hate bias which we've done for the last four years we've added in a new model module focused on students rights and responsibilities as well as students understanding of the code of of conduct and so this year that is the first time that has been um something that's been presented to students it is automatically on their canvas pages every secondary students have access to it and principles have received training about how to implement that model module um at this point in the year we have about 60% completion rate across our schools with a higher completion rate in Middle School than in high school and we are working with our directors
282in terms of working with schools with low response rates on how to ensure that all students complete those modules and uh as much as a module is not the simple answer for expectations expectations should be in real time they should be consistent they should be regular it is a step towards making sure that we have a uniform message for all of our kiddos next slide please the final slide that I'm going to share with with you before I turn it over to Mr montelone is a little bit about some of our discipline data I want to start with that we are going to be uh speaking a little bit more in depth about our discipline data uh later on at the end of this month uh so we're going to address that in terms of
283a deeper Deep dive but I did want to make a connection back to Safety and Security so if you see the chart in front of you um these are the number of suspensions that have been enacted for our students um this year year to date compared to the prior year and the prior year year to date um and while we do uh follow msde and comar guidelines using exclusion as the last option I think it is really important to share with our board and with our our audience our families and our communities that we take issues of Safety and Security seriously we we take issues of Safety and Security seriously for all of our kids and we do communicate through alternative practices through teaching methods what those are but also there are responses that may
284include temporary School removal and if you take a look at this chart compared to Serious incidents you'll see a fair alignment to the amount of incidents and then amount of removals uh based on those categories and next slide please at this time I'm going to turn it over to Mr montalone to talk a little bit more about the security assessments thank you very much um so we we've heard a little bit about about you know creating the conditions right that would would would preclude incidents uh from happening such as you know identification implementation The Vape sensors um we're having conversations about weapon detect detection systems we're talking about some technical responses ensuring there's a districtwide um message to all students right across all of our secondary schools about what our expectations are and being very
285clear to them on what the process is for an investigation and possible disciplinary response at the core of any safe school is the fundamentals of how a security team and an administrative team work together that is at its core so so yes our technical work is important yes the new technology that we are putting in schools the cameras The Vape sensors are absolutely important but the fundamentals of fostering a safe welcome and inclusive environment really rest upon people we've heard from our superintendent and many others right we are in a people business um and so that doesn't just involve your super your your Administration and your security team it also involves your teachers and staff it involves your students and it involves working and having strong relationships with your parents and your caregivers in the
286community in addition to our partners in HHS and other partner organizations um so I think another example right at previously the board has seen the office of of safety security and Emergency Management come to the table for a Safety and Security presentation so you're seeing ossi you're seeing the office of well-being student services you're seeing security and we also have a principal here with us today because we have really desired to take this out of a siloed approach and as soon as Chief Jones came on board this summer we took it upon ourselves Dr Moran and I and others on the associate team to to come together and provide really a collaborative approach to this work historically in mcps if you speak with longtime administrators um the administrative Lane would uh is is is over
287here and perhaps the security Lane had been over there and we've done a lot of work this year um to rectify that and a manifestation of that collaboration has been our our security assessments with a new superintendent with the new Chief security coming on on board we talk about what is the landscape of security and mcps and we don't know unless we go out to every single school second starting with the high schools um and then moving on to the middle school second semester to do that assessment right so um over the course of the first semester um uh Chief Jones myself members of Dr Moran's team uh and others have been visiting every single high school um I think we have a few more to go and I could get those numbers uh maybe
288about five or six more to go so what were the OB the objective of this really to assess the current state and the specific needs that schools have right there's some needs that are almost Universal across all schools and there are some needs that are specific to schools right are you in an urban footprint such as a BCC or Richard Montgomery are you in a place that lacks uh perhaps some resources and transportation lines maybe pville uh Damascus paint Branch what are the unique needs what is going on in the environment what type of activity is happening in the Community is that coming into your school building right so there are a lot of specific needs that that folks have and we also want to take into consideration um you know some of the changes
289we've had in the in in our principles we've had a lot of new principles that have come on board I think I don't want to quote the numbers incorrectly but about 70% over the last four years are new to their position and many of them may have come into the position during the pandemic and so we really wanted to turn back the clock and look at some of those fundamentals that we we had uh with administrators Pro so as we've uh talked to schools we're reviewing their their security coverage plans where are your security team members each and every day right where are they period by period what is the the duty and the expectation that you have involved how how often are they checking um bathrooms right uh do they have access to cameras
290are we staggering their brakes so we make sure that everybody is on the floor are we executing all of our emergency preparation plans right what is the status do you have the basic artifacts in place how how specific are these and are do we have accountability and monitoring systems in place to make sure that they are actually being executed right by not only the administrative team uh excuse me the security team but the administrators as well we did walk we've been doing walkabouts with um the principle key administrators security team leaders and others to identify hot spots in the buildings um facilities that may need to be uh facility requests that may need to be elevated um to look at camera needs what what what have you we talked about staff capacity right how new
291is your staff what type of training uh do staff need and we can speak to some of this a little bit later um what about the professional growth system right is everybody meeting their core competencies uh we have then agreed to Next Step so we share a report with each and every school um we hope to finish with with and I think this this week put a little bit of a dent in a couple of those visits but we hope to finish with the high school visits um by the end of the first semester and then move on to Middle School second semester so we will have hit all secondary schools each school is getting a summary report and we want to Bubble Up these reports to the superintendent and to the board so that
292we can share here is what the landscape looks like and we can give some percentages of schools that have certain needs versus other needs um so it's been a really really beneficial process it's been eye openening um we've had some some Trends and takeaways right so some of the big trends we've noticed so far is that is that there is some variability school to school um based upon the capacity of the security team the administrators in the building um how they are implementing this how tight folks are on their security how how closely they're monitoring uh you know doors and checking those IDs what is the plan for the bathrooms things of this nature are we utilizing mental health supports through the student well-being team when students are identified based on a root cause that
293may have um been at the root of of any incident um additional cameras uh were identified as needed but I know that that Chief Jones's team has already has a list and is working on on that the ID implementation has varied a bit by schools we heard students testify earlier about ways to invent incentivize students to wear IDs there are some schools out there right now that are doing just that and and we can dig into that today later but we we certainly are going to be sharing with you all some recommendations on how a couple schools are implementing the ID process and how we could scale that up districtwide um there's a bit of a variance and Effectiveness um a bit of variance I excuse me I said that about the capacity effectiveness of
294certain teams and then a districtwide approach to professional development for both administrators and security staff in the same place at the same time hearing the same messages um we universally heard a request from security team leaders about not end principles about not having enough time with their security teams before school starts they come back two days before school starts one of those days is taken up with with state regulations and training that must occur every single year so in order to provide the professional development for those security team members and to invest in them we don't want to hire them on a Friday and drop them into a 3,000 student uh building on a Monday um so those are some large Trends and takeaways one of the schools that we visited was Clarksburg um and
295I'm going to pass it to Miss Anita O'Neal who has done an outstanding job in in in addressing safety security School environment reducing suspensions really from a holistic approach so we thought it would be nice to to hear from her thank you good evening thank you for uh allowing me to present about our ongoing initiatives uh that impact Safety and Security at Clarksburg High School today I'm going to share some of our key actions from this year and some positive outcomes that we're experiencing uh before I dive into the details about what we're doing I'd like to highlight three guiding principles for the the work that we're doing at our school and I think first and foremost relationships are foundational building and string positive relationships within our community is Central to everything we do additionally
296positive behavior intervention strategies these strategies not only support an individual student in growth but also support our overall well-being of our community and finally it's the alignment of our resources and efforts we are prioritizing aligning initiatives with our desired outcomes while refining or eliminating those things that do not have a positive impact on what we're trying to achieve at our school can we go to the next slide sorry thank you all right so what have we been doing so far this year so again like I said focusing on relationship building and mentorship our staff is actively engaging with our students in hallways and other unstructured spaces fostering trust and open communication to prevent potential issues before they arise we've expanded our mentorship program where every staff member is paired with a student providing personalized support
297and deepening connections throughout our school Community we're focusing on restorative practices and datadriven decision-making we added two restorative approach coaches this year who analyze student data and help us identify interventions and strategies that are best suited for those students so it could be connecting with trusted adults referring them to Services holding meetings with caregivers as examples we're also uh looking at features in Synergy to be proactive in communicating uh through some of the enhanced tools like notes and enabling staff to document um concerns and share those with other folks that so that we can ensure timely support we're really focusing on proactive measures and tiered support systems so behavioral expectations of being re being excuse me reinforced through advisory programs alongside regular staff training and scenario based exercises to maintain prepared Ness uh you heard
298uh a previous speaker talk about having security and admin together we have regular oset meetings which each month and we go through scenarios we look at incidents we uh use the materials that are provided from central office to run our trainings um our uh student Behavior Uh Wellness team um has an implemented a tiered intervention system that allows us to focus on prevention including conflict coaching again mentorship and substance counseling we redesigned our alt one program which we now call our enhanced Intervention Program and that provides Perfection uh flexible support to students and I pulled data today this year to date we have served 71 students through our through our enhanced Intervention Program versus last year for a whole year it was about 20 students um so we really have uh up the impact of
299that program we're also focusing on Community Partnerships and engagement we have Partnerships with organizations like the conflict resolution center that provides students with coaching and mediation to address conflicts constructively um our partners that partner is in our building every Thursday all day and they receive referrals from us or they see students and they'll pull them in so that's been very instrumental in helping coach our students to have positive um social interactions with others uh we collaborate with bridge to Wellness and Street out Outreach Network to offer additional supports for students we strengthened our one-pack mentorship program this year through a partnership with Mentor Maryland and DC um so giving us some advice on how to expand effectively and um have more impact with our students uh We've begun to expand our community outreach initiatives like
300meet and eat at the plumgar community center and some personalized phone calls to careers s to invite them to school events uh which we've seen an enhanced Community engagement we've seen parents come to our building that we didn't see before because now they've connected with uh adults in our building and they feel comfortable they have a trusted adult themselves we had the opportunity um in October and November to share uh our work uh during the uh monthly mccpta Cluster meeting so that was nice to be able to highlight that work uh and we continue to seek new Partnerships and activities they're aligned with our students interest to provide positive outlets and opportunities for them to develop uh life skills and also feel good about themselves so real quick uh what have our what are our
301uh simple results so far this year we have seen a reduction in suspensions our our current suspension rate is less than 1% and we've seen significant decreases across all demographics including African-American Hispanic and students with IEPs um our staff is reporting an increased sense of safety last year um that midyear um survey resulted in only 40% 6% of our staff reporting feeling extremely or quite safe at work at the end of marking period one uh this year that figure is 64% so we are surveying we continue to monitor quarterly we conduct weekly staff check-ins to ensure that we're addressing any concerns that pop up and we're really eager to hear to see the results for the district um survey that will be coming in the spring and we have an increased uh a reported increase
302sense of student belonging our minority Scholars Program students leaders collected data this fall that shows that 80% of our 82% of our students report having a sense of belonging and a trusted adult at Clarksburg High School so again I'm very proud of the work that uh my staff my admin team my security Team all of us working together I'm very proud of our work and we remain committed to prioritizing safety relationships and support systems that Empower our students and staff the results reflect the collective efforts of our team Our Community Partners and our shared vision for a safer and more connected School environment and thank you for your time for letting me share again I'm very proud of the work at Clarksburg High School this year next slide so I would like to basically close
303by noting that you know I think there has been some progress made um clearly with really identifying and I I really do appreciate the board support um along with Dr Taylor um on really identifying the need for Safety and Security and making that a priority for this system without your support I can tell you that it would make it much more difficult for us to to really accomplish this task um I think the sense I get from talking to not only our administrators but many of our staff as well as our students that we see that there has been Improvement Are We There Yet the answer is absolutely not um we have a lot of work to do there are lots of balls that I I often say are in that we're juggling that are
304in the air um but we are committed to to really coming up with uh Solutions that are going to be effective and one of the things that I've clearly recognized in my short tenure here at mcps uh I see a lot of great things similarly to what principal O'Neal just noted and Mr montalone just noted um as well as the numbers that have been um the data that has been placed out about decreases um but I've seen a a commitment on staff to really to move forward to be a part of the team to just not be left up to the security assistance at our schools to create the safe environment is that everybody's playing a role and the more we see that from a leadership perspective and we continue to grow upon that I
305think we're only going to get better because it is about preventing incidents from occurring it's not waiting for something to happen and then we become reactive we really need to be in a proactive mode going along the way um and I do I just wanted to give a couple of updates particularly as I know we we spoke about this as well before when we talked about ACS readers uh similarly at our elementary schools and some of the other schools that need those as well as well as door sensors to provide that sense of security um at many of our schools that we know that people who are coming into our schools who don't belong in our schools those things happen sometimes on a daily basis um and our security teams our administrators are aware of
306those individuals who belong in their schools and I can tell you um by by us going around and doing these assessments and watching the identification system where it does work though it again the big word of the day for me um that I think that I carry with me on a daily basis that I I don't see is the consistency across the board and that's where we have to get to um from a standpoint of Safety and Security across Montgomery County Public Schools we need a consistent system that everybody understands what's the Rules of Engagement and what are the resources that we all have no matter what our environment no matter what uh the culture is at our particular school but that we're all on the same page so I'll uh close there and uh
307we can now have a discussion thank you um I'm going to start a discussion from my right hand side sorry Stuart um with uh time constraint this round let's do one question first okay I'll pick a Hot Topic these um at least I'm getting feedback about the ID program and how it's working or not working and um what I know there's been several models used and how are you determining which model seems to be working how are you getting that feedback um from the full community so I think one of the I mean there there are several models right we have we've had we've seen some schools that require students to wear the lay it around their neck um and to be able to show it uh immediately when they walk into school some schools
308are not necessarily checking it the same way some schools require you not you can have it around your neck but you could also have it attached to your backpack um and again there are some schools that we see where staff is actually checking more times than not uh versus when the student is not displaying it um to make sure that they are displaying it we are having we see some schools where they come in and they don't have their IDs there is a system that's been developed that gives them their replacement ID for the day or if they lost their ID there is a system but again there's not consistency because each school is doing it individually across the board so what we're trying to do is to take these what we're seeing and make
309recommendations that we come up with a holistic approach um of a possible policy procedure that would be beneficial for all schools and based on some kind of result right because it's not just to do it because we just want to see kids wear lanyards right so has there been like less um uh Outsiders coming in the school has it helped you know so have some kind of a measurement as well as you're pickr absolutely it is again making sure those that belong in the school belong to school I mean we also seen it where we have some staff members who don't wear their IDs right so again we you know many schools know who belong in their schools but then you have some schools that are so large right that are so large right that
310it does require right and it is a change of culture right a change for individuals to wear an identification uh card to show it when requested and it's not just for the fact that we're just saying we want you to have it just to wear it there is a purpose to this because we've had incidents that prove that people who sometimes come into our schools because somebody pushes a door open in the rear of the school school and allow someone who doesn't belong in the school who then gets to walk to halls but doesn't have an ID right those are the things that these are the one time that there's a major incident that creates the havoc and this is the message that we we must uh we must send so people understand that there
311is a purpose behind why we're doing what we're doing M thank you all for being here all of the work that you do especially principal O'Neal I know you've had a full school and you're still here so I just really appreciate that um and the efforts that you're putting in at your own school I actually have too many questions so I will likely follow up with some of you after this um but the question overarching that I have is that we're hearing a lot about the middle schools and the high schools whether it's the modules for bullying and hate bias and expectations or security assessments done in the first or second semester I really want to elevate the frustrations of Elementary School parents and I am one and I will say that I hear across
312the board for all the years that I've been in Elementary School parent now that our student populations are feel somewhat neglected in this area of Safety and Security um and I understand we have such challenges at the perhaps secondary level but in my experience one of the ways that we can curb some of those and we talked about being proactive and prevention and I'm absolutely for that if we're not doing anything for our elementary school family students and their schools then we're going to continue to see these incidents at the secondary and high school levels so it's too much for you to answer maybe a question right now um especially at this hour of the day but I do really want to strongly emphasize we had all of these parents show up and this is
313not the first time they've shown up and they are not the only parents with these concerns on a somewhat daily basis and I would just uh briefly just note to that that it is not lost upon me not at all that we'd separate elementary schools any different from a standpoint of the focus it's a different kind of a focus because of the the the culture the environment you may say but the security uh that needs to be put in place it's still a priority and so we have a plan that we will continuously work with our Elementary School principles and identifying many of their needs of how to best assess that and these are the resources this is a part of the assessment in which we speak of that we need to identify but I'm
314not going to just impose upon my beliefs I want to hear from not only the principles but from the ptas in those communities to be able to express to us what are the needs that they feel like they need for their kids so are there assessments then I guess being happening they will be happening yes they will be Happ and I'd like to add for elementary school just really quickly that um some of our Elementary School principles are doing a phenomenal job in terms of leading the way in terms of sharing expectations with students Farmland Elementary School under uh principal longest is a really good example of this in terms of bringing her community in and sharing with students about those expectations in a series of town halls um and we are cultivating examples like
315that and creating a Resource Bank for our elementary schools to be able to use so that they can share those best practices additionally we're looking at ways to modify the modules created this year remember this is our first year with the code of conduct modules to create a module that is appropriate for grades 3 to five and so those are things that are coming down the pike that we can look forward to on the expectation side for our elementary school students thank you Miss wolf well I'm glad that Rita got to go before me because I was debating between two questions and that was one of them so at first I want to thank principal O'Neal for coming in it was really uh helpful to hear what's going on up at Clarksburg and that you're
316having success my question of course is always about the data I just want to understand what I'm seeing here the serious incident data go back to that um slide seven yeah it's on slide seven I want to know is this August 23 through December 4th is that is that correlating to the suspension data school year 2324 in other words that middle column under the suspension data is that the same time period on as on the number seven slide absolutely down to the day it's the same time period yes well my question is you got serious incidents of but you've got suspensions of 870 am I reading that wrong no you're not reading it incorrectly I I just don't understand that that's what I wanted to that's a good question so for this year and we're
317looking at this year you'd be looking at the 1488 number rather than the the prior year right but we on on slide number nine you only have 857 right because not all serious incidents lead to a suspension I'll give you a good example so some of those trespass numbers that 26 those aren't all students that could be the person from the community that wandered onto the field during the school day right they're not the thing about serious incidents are they're not all incidents involving children that trespassing could be a parent that was trespassed and not allowed on property and came onto property so it wouldn't correlate to a suspension because we wouldn't suspend a parent so it's not a onetoone match in terms of even the fighting that all of the fighting those are not
318all children right that could be two adults that got in a fight in the parking lot over a parking space so they're not going to ever match perfectly because it's all incidents and so we've got a couple other points of context here that I want to add and the largest category is other and uh that involves a lot of medical incidents that occur where a student has a medical emergency or an adult in the building has a medical emergency and so the world has to stop and it's very disruptive to the learning environment so it Bec comes one of these serious incidents this is a really important data slide because we are talking about 1% as a matter of fact we're talking about less than 1% in a lot of context and that's a great
319Benchmark for us because as we look forward we should be looking to shave this 1% even further down let's take a look at weapons um in the First Column we've had over 80 days of school and there are over 210 schools in the district they're that's 177,000 possible uh uh interactions that that could be if I'm doing my math correctly in my head so 17,000 possibilities and we had 71 incidents out of 177,000 possible opportunities for there to be an incident so that's actually less than 1 half of 1% and when you look at 1,400 or500 uh incidents that have occurred and let's assign that roughly to our student body of over 150,000 students that's less than 1% of our student population that's being impacted less than 1% of the time that's wonderful doesn't mean
320that we don't have work to do it doesn't mean that there isn't progress to make but these are abnormalities their irregularities this is not the common place I think it's really easy um when the media Paints the picture of what schools are like or um something exciting happens and it gets reported at home at the dinner table and uh it rules conversation for several days yeah that's serious and there's serious things that happen in school but it's not an everyday every classroom every student experience that it really is limited to a handful of things that we take very very seriously and that we try to measure them um and and pay significant attention to them a lot of work to do lot of room for improvement um lot of room for improvement particularly in the
321elementary space because we spend a disproportionate amount of time focused on secondary schools because a lot of these things happen by volume at the secondary school but it doesn't mean that the things that happen at elementary are any less serious but this is an encouraging sign and something that you know we we do need to take pride in the fact that this is moving in the right direction and that the numbers are still relatively low for us to manage um in a pretty consistent and Fair Way can can I finish my my thing then can can I get some more information I just want you to back out everything that's not a student that's hap an incident that's happened at the school that resulted in a I'm trying to figure out how many incidents there
322have been whether they're repeat offenders and what the demographics are so I need the things like medical taken out things that might have happened at the at the Metro station and came I I'm trying to get a real picture here of what we're looking at and who it is and whether they're repeat offenders and the demographics do you understand what I I do I'm looking for we do I do I think that's something we're going to have to follow up on I think one thing to look at yeah is recidivism like how many students are repeating like serious offenses and I can tell you it's it's typically about 20% but that's data that we can get for you and I think we can talk a little bit more about that when we talk about our
323suspensions and exclusions I think that'll be a good one to well you know that discipline has been one of my main issues discipline of black students so I want that data broken down and I want to know I want to try to figure out what we're actually looking at thank you all right Miss Rivera Ain um so we're going to talk about suspensions another later or I believe we have a strategic planning meeting coming up but we can address it if you have a question then I'll save those questions for then for that question for then then I'll do this one um so what I'm looking at this I really would like to have a better picture of where the incidents are happening whether is high school middle school or Elementary School um just because
324there's a lot of assumptions being made of where things are happening or things are happening more than other places so for me that is really important and the other category I'll tell you why it bothers me not to have a breakdown of that because we had asked in the past that when we have for example when we use Narin or there's a suspicious or we think said overose that that be put in as a category right cuz we want to make sure that we have a grasp on whether we are making progress or we are giving the right tools or the right support so that so to have a, 1,184 under other serious incidents it doesn't sit well with me and I think Marcus knows why because then it's really hard for us to and
325I can and you can say to me well you know there were, 1884 people calls to the Emer mergency well was it because it was drug related was it because we didn't have a nurse in the school I mean are they all right so if we're going to do serious incident data I want to see it break down and one of the and the other slide you go into um the sexual harassment and all that is not included in here and I think that is something that needs because we hear from the public from parents and so on CU we said serious abuse based on sexual harassment racial original ethnic background because we are one of the most diverse school systems in the country I think that data needs to be shared and we need
326to know and again if we could break it down by by um so and can you tell me what serious fight What's the definitions of a serious fight versus a definition of a non-s serious fight what what are the components for that yes couple of things so I wanted to to I was trying to keep track of some of the questions that you asked um so the first where they're happening right most incidents are happening at the high school level so 530 incidents 481 for elementary school and 423 for middle so they're similar but for the most part most are happening at high school um to the second question that you asked about the other category um we can certainly Prov provide that data for you I want you to know it's not labeled in
327the system as other they're all individual so it might be a list that is a 100 long we can't share that on one slide so we just choose to share the highest number but I want you to know that they exist they're just not as common as the ones that you see on the screen and then to the third question about um what makes a fight serious or not this one's a little tricky only because there there are two things to think about the first one is when you put in fight in Synergy that ranges from someone stepped on my toe in the lunch line right I was pushing and shoving over a toy at indoor recess that is a thing this time of year all the way till there is a mass group fight
328in the cafeteria so those things are very different right someone pulled my pigtail all the way to something that is tremendously serious and all of those are categorized as fight so again the ones that are serious uh meet a couple of rules one the state definition of serious bodily injury not our definition so a fight is considered serious if there is serious bodily in injury second one is if there's a disruption to the school so if there's a mass disruption that can be considered serious so a fight in a classroom where there's pushing and shoving maybe not so much something in the middle of the cafeteria that causes A disruption that disrupts the school day yes and then the third one is my rule of thumb is did I have to call for outside assistance
329did this fight require me to call the police did this fight require me to call for other assistant did it require me to call Medical Etc and those are serious we know that the number one incident in schools and not just in Maryland not just in momery County but across the nation has been fighting it's it's it's going to be I think Miss rero testified about it it's going to be students not responding appropriately with their hands right and so we're very of what that is but to be serious it has to involve one of those components just a quick follow up on that if this bodily injury that is not at that moment but that the student requires like a concussion later on would that then be recorded as a serious um incident fight
330so it depends it's hard to say definitively like absolutely right in this moment um so that's not something that we see but if it's reported later that such and such had a concussion there was Medical attention then we would call it in I think Miss Vera ofen has Master B three questions into one question she she has mastered that all right okay Miss uh sylvestri I'm trying to figure out how I can do that um so you will cover the uh state report that was attached to our presentation about disproportionality with black students at the strategic planning yes that's that's that's another topic altogether and a very important one that I think is important to the conversation especially when we talk about the responses root causes th I just want to make sure that's going
331to be covered strategic plan so I don't have to ask yes I believe so I mean Miss wolf is the chair so she has the final say on the agenda but I know that discipline is very important to her yeah it's a it was a huge report just to kind of not talk about it today uh my question is to Dr Taylor um could you help us remember what is in your budget to address Safety and Security as we have heard from both testimony today and the presentation we have a couple of enhancements the the one that's most significant is additional uh funds for uh Safety and Security assistance um we have programmed in the proposed budget right now 52 additional security assistance which is a big number but but candidly it's actually the tip
332of the iceberg it's something that I hope we invest in for the next several years not just in the next year's budget um uh but that we see another 52 in a subsequent budget and another 52 after that because we do have some needs that are widespread what we are looking at is how to allocate um those positions or really any position and what we might look at as a metric or a way to allocate those positions and uh one of the the things that we're talking the most about is where there are Geographic advantages to allocating a position where you have one elementary school or one middle school that's close to other schools where somebody could be uh accessible to multiple schools from one location uh we are also looking at critical incidents and
333things that happen with severity and the frequency in which those things are happening we do have some larger schools as well and making sure that some of our larger schools um are are also uh having some support we have some schools that are in Geographic locations where they need additional support because of where the school is located for things like traffic where they have high foot traffic or they have High um uh access for adults coming on or near the property at an appropriate time sometimes and it makes sense for us to to have uh folks there um but uh but we do we do know that there is a need and that's probably the most significant uh uh I have said this before and and and this is not new to this team is
334that by US changing our expectations and by us following up on our expectations these are things that will also have a really significant impact on school safety and the safety environment the evaluations that have been done to date and the evaluations that are planned they are making Corrections in real time to things that that they see that are um not improving safety or that could be improving safety and already we've seen some of those noticeable changes which really does make a difference last little bit that I'll get into um we do need to rethink how we look at student conduct and as part of uh reorganizing our central office uh we do need to think about uh what that looks like and the continuity of educational services that we can offer to our students that
335are in an alternative placement um and how we can serve our students better just in general and uh and how we can help our administrators become better stewards of student conduct uh through a more consistent approach Mr Jones has mentioned this a number of times and uh it's it's kind of the thing that he and I observe when we are at a at a school facility is the consistency from one building to the next and uh to the extent that we can kind of limit that variation on the the things that uh are safety concerns and we can really celebrate that variation when uh a school is doing something extraordinary from an academic standpoint that's really where our Focus needs to be thank you thank you Mrs imberman um thank you all for all your
336hard work and for being here um I know we're running a little behind so I appreciate you staying to be be here with us um so M Jord you mentioned um looking at you know our pipeline we're looking at other modules and things otherwise that we can engage um so I'm wondering what are some of our student friendly ways that we plan to communicate our code of contact code of conduct and expectations um from mcps that aren't just on a caseby casee basis or individually music videos I'm ready I'm ready to perform I'm I'm open to the music videos um one of the things I wanted to say is you know traditionally if you guys remember um and miss you might what used to happen is the code of conduct used to get printed it's
337lovely it gets shipped off to the schools it's a lot of paper they were distributed and then you would sign that you received it or signed that you received it reviewed it with your parents right and it didn't really tell us much and getting those forms back Were Here There and otherwise so even though it's not a perfect system we really are proud of being able ble to at least have it be on the canvas page and have it automated in a way that we know okay we're not at 100% it's 60% we're working on it but we know how many students have accessed it who has accessed it when they've accessed it and it does come back up again in discipline because we can also say this is something that you knew and I
338can certify that you knew right I think it's a start we talked about Pilots a little bit earlier today and I would I would call it that in spite of too many planes um um so we've done it for the first time and we found lots of things in it that we want to change and that worked and that didn't work and so we're looking at making that for elementary schools however I would never put it past the lessons that we have with our school admin teams in terms of our town halls and our counseling lessons I think those at the end of the day while uniform expectations are great and I'm for them I think those at the end of the day with your trusted adult with a relationship partner are going to be
339the best bang for you your buck and those go back to a couple of things it goes back to how we train our principles and it goes back to the accountability measures that we have with following up right is there a way that we know that those have happened we can't just guess because we saw it at this school or that school there's got to be a way to ensure that not only do we train for those things to happen but that we follow up if they don't and so I think that it's more adaptive than it is Technical and I think both of those things are going to be important and then additionally additional layer right how do we get that communicated down to the classroom level right my principal may not be my
340most trusted adult it might be the teacher that's in front of me that I see every day how do we ensure we're making sure that each and every classroom teacher is reinforcing those expectation messages to each and every child so I think those are some of the things we're we're going to have to continuously work on right thank you thank you Mr saana first of all I want to thank you guys for your report I I appreciate a lot but um to be quite Frank like I'm really disappointed with the lack of data and measurables when referencing some of the uh things that we're talking about like what what type of data was collected in order to analyze the success in the ID policy from what I've been hearing from students across the county it's
341been terrible implementation across the board right so what does that mean for H how are we going to improve from there and find figure out our next steps over a year ago we had our last stent member of the board put up a safety resolution talking about all the different things that we wanted to see an expansion of to student ID policy uh that wouldn't add significant entry delays while still uh making sure that we're being integral on student safety uh we're having increased trainings for students and security staff what was the plan on a school-based Administration elevating the monitoring of restrooms and implementing appropriate response methods and then even past that what was the increase awareness uh being done for student reporting channels for safety concerns and tips the public awareness campaign for uh
342promoting student safety practices in schools uh and all these things that are that were laid out more than a year ago that still haven't really been followed up or addressed here and in that same vein we heard public comment today talking about what is the interaction between our security team and our digital team um about the fight pages that are posting those incidents um does that have any implication on it becoming a serious incident now that that you know students from across the county are being are seeing this incident and it's being elevated more and more but I I'm just really concerned at the way you know some of this stuff isn't being addressed with measurables well what I would note Mr serona is that this is again a part of where when I took
343over it is about the assessment piece much of what you're talking about needs to be assessed the ID policy which just went countywide just really if you really think about it it's just a couple of months ago that everybody's now doing it and so what we're finding is because of the variance of the different policies it's not going to be successful it's hard to measure because really everybody is just getting acclimated there's been Grace periods given for the students to even display them and so each School is doing it differently so when we look at it from a systemwide approach this is why we're doing the assessment because we need to come back to the board and Dr Taylor with our final assessment that suggests that these are the best practices that we think would
344be effective for example when students come to school to make entry into their school in a very effective and efficient way right there are some schools that that are using scanners there are some schools that are using um um um scanners in a way that they are providing tardy slips in the hallways because they're monitoring watching students Walk The Halls without purpose and they're checking their IDs and actually requiring some schools have the the the ID that now you have to go put it in the machine and actually get a tardy slip to go back to class and it's cap capturing the number of tardies that you are actually um accumulating that requires next steps to deal with notification to your parents that you're actually not going to class so there's a wide variety of
345things that are occurring and I agree with you it's not it's not moving very fast it's part of again I understand that it it is it is a process and I think this is where we had to really kind of slow this down you might say in order to really get a good grasp knowing that we're as a system s similarly like with the cell phone policy where there's no consistent policy across the board some schools are doing it this way some schools are doing it that way and so I this is why I live on this theme about consistency because I think this only would benefit all students when we we put everybody into the pile and we we then do the measurements and really get the feedback from the students as you noted
346and we come up with those processes I think that's going to be very important for us to get there Mr saana do you have a question well yeah so I mean my question was was baked into it but I mean what what what data was collected in order to analyze there has been no data collected because again going back and just again I'm just Mak this known about the IDS because we're so brand new into this there's been we're still doing assessments going to high schools we haven't completed that task yet so we're not collecting data as a part of our process right what we're doing is we're collecting the best practices then once we can start collecting best practices we can start Gathering data about for example how many how many schools have to
347on a daily basis may have to require their students to actually get a a replacement ID how many students are actually being located coming through our schools who have no ID those are some of the data sets that we need to we need to come up with but we have not gotten there yet okay thank you um my questions will be my questions will be first of all um when I look at the report um I notice first of all it's wonderful we're doing this we're not wai waiting till the end of the year to look at our serious incident data that we are doing it along the way then we can aligned our practices Provide support where is needed right these datas are captured is captur so we can handle that so I think
348we have made really good Improvement in terms of monitoring and and hopefully that translate to our support and practices on the ground um when I look look at the serious incident data I actually I look at it from a different lens I believe that the most important aspect is how we respond to and support the victims of serious incidents right um so I I often find that there is a gaping hole in our discussion we we talk I think it's important to talk about disciplinary action but actually a lot of me is going to how are we supporting the victims who are the impacted population who are the students we should support how do we better support them after a serious incident right because they were impacted so in the future I'm hoping that's uh
349that's some work we can do um we I am very happy to see there's a 27% drop in the uh fighting and attack on other category can you name one thing that you do an action that you take actually that uh that's helping that's contributing to the decrease of uh serious fighting there's been a great deep focus on two things so not just conflict resolution but also on self-regulation which which contributes to some of what you see around fights and attacks and I think a lot of those therapeutic supports that have been put in place particularly at our high schools and again I'm going back to miss montoya's comment where elementary schools don't have the same level of focus you heard Miss O'Neal talk about conflict Center resolution centers of Montgomery County they're at 15
350of our schools our bridge to Wellness programs at 19 of our schools our wellness centers which we're partnering with on a regular basis to work with students around many of these issues including conflict and regulation um our social workers who have been introduced in the last 3 years of which there are 44 of them primarily assigned to our high schools and then secondarily assigned part-time to our middle schools so once again that Gap in elementary school that we've acknowledged um but those are having a great big deal of impact on our students having somewhere to go having someone to talk to having someone to ensure that what I'm feeling right now doesn't come out in a way that is violent and being able to address that not just after which we get to the after
351but some of the before and I think those are really impactful one of the things I would bring forward next time is the office of shared accountability they did a report on um the impact of the social workers and how principles have seen their impact and those are some of the numbers that you'll see in terms of their servicing I do want to say one of the things that they do do um is address students who have been suspended so as a broader part of the well-being team one of the data metrics that we look at in this office because we look at suspensions we also look at how many of our social workers work with students who have been suspended and so there is a kind of a circle back that happens so the
352short answer to that would be some of our therapeutic supports and some of our services that are provided by our external agencies I appreciate that answer um um and to understand what contribute to the decrease but in the same token our social workers support students who are um who we have disciplinary action I'm wondering what they're doing to support our students who have been impacted a victim of of these these incidents and I I I always feel like um something is missing in our conversation right so um today is not the day but I understand you have a strategic planning meeting coming up and that we might be able to cover some of that and also this is a quarterly conversation so we will be having this conversation again thank you so much uh Mr
353saana yeah I I think the the last thing that I wanted to say is really like the next time we come back to this what I'm really looking for is what are the specific things that we're getting out of number one not just the the programs that we put in place like you know how we're expanding The Vape detectors and the ID policy but what what have we learned from the Pilots The Vape detector pilot what did we learn from it because that is supposed to be our chance to you know GA gather the data and I understand you know there's been um like differences in in terms of how we've been Gathering that data um and but the same thing for the ID policy when we implemented that ID policy pilot what did we
354learn from that what were the best practices and then how are those being applied because I feel like we're kind of you know putting the horse before the cart right now um and or putting the cart before the horse right now and trying to figure out what the best practices are after we've already implemented it when I thought that was what the point of the pilot was um and so that's kind of just been my general thing and then again that that kind of going back to the idea of interaction between security and our digital team I don't think this was touched on basically at all in this presentation I understand there's not time for it today but in the future that's something I would want to see I would only note that we work
355with our partners with mcpd and who has an excellent digital uh informational team when we have threats or we have fights that occur within the County to help us identify individuals that are involved in this so though we don't have that particular um we don't have that particular resource inhouse we do have access to that resource thank you everyone for this discussion very rigorous discussion I think we can go on two more hours if we can all right item 11 is for information only and everything can be accessed in board dos um item 12 is Board of Education items can I have a motion to move item 12.1 through 12.4 in Block so moved I would like to second the motion um all in favor raise your hand that unanimous uh unanimous uh 12.5 new
356business any Bard member have new business to pull forward okay not at this time so number 13 is for informational summary only any any questions no okay so number 14 oh it's uh a German may I have a motion uh H I'll happily move that forward and I will happily motion for a second okay all in favor meeting is a germ thank you everyone [Music]