CorpusRecord 198814

Board of Education Academic Achievement Committee Meeting February 10, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / PGCPS
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Prince George's County, MD
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,337 words · about 69 min
Collected
2026-06-26

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001the time is now 5:33 p.m. I would like to call the February 10th academic achievement committee meeting of the school year 2024 to 2025 good evening oh shoot I Jamal J janga the chair of the academic achievement committee and the student member of the board for the Prince George's for Prince George's County Public Schools I would like to welcome our committee o yeah I would like to welcome our committee members um and board Representatives Dr Tiffany androld Mrs Akia G MC and Mrs Lolita ew Walker a special welcome to Dr Judith White the chief the chief academic officer the supered design along with her team who will be leading tonight's presentations before we before we begin we will have introductions starting with board members administrative staff and board office staff thank you this this committee

002will virtually meet on on Mondays at 5:30 p.m. each month with topics posted in advance on board doogs okay members to introduce themselves Mr Jungle uh okay it's fine um so we just have the board members introduce themselves at this time no problem Zakia go m board member district 8 hello I'm Dr Tiffany Ander for board member district one okay um so tonight so tonight we will have three presentations including two res scheduled from the December 16th 2024 meeting for those unable to join us live a recording will be available on the PGCPS YouTube channel and board docs now we will proceed with r call Miss Lopez can you please call the role Mr jungo present Miss Walker Dr anderle pres Mrs go mck present there are three members present okay um a quorum is

003present if there are no objections the committee shall adopt the February 10th 2025 meeting agenda there being Noah objections the meeting agenda is adopted if there are no if there are no Corrections the committee shall approve the January 27th 2025 meeting minutes as distributed there being no Corrections the meeting minutes are approved there are there are no um registered public commment speakers for this evening all right well thank you um then we'll go ahead and get started um I'm filling in for Dr White our chief academic officer my name is Kia McDaniel I am the director of curriculum and instruction and so as you mentioned we have uh lots of information for you all this evening uh including two previously scheduled presentations so we're going to get moving um before we do that though I

004will ask if everyone can introduce themselves um so you know who all of our presenters are and then we will turn it over to miss Leona Smith after we have um introductions so I'm going to turn over to my team Victoria and Shannon to introduce themselves and then have other teams introduce themselves good evening Victoria Holmes coordinating supervisor for language and literacy in the office of curriculum and instruction good evening Shannon leld yasi instructional specialist I'm sitting Ino supervisor Simone mcage for elementary Reading English language arts good evening I'm Jamie Bowers I'm the director of Testing Research and evaluation good evening Anthony Whittington director of monitoring and accountability good evening Leona Smith I'm the Innovation officer for transformation leadership and continuous Improvement and I have three outstanding principles here with me that let them introduce

005themselves uh we'll start with Dr Stoddard by followed by uh Miss Smith and then Dr fuler Jones good evening everyone my name is Anita stard I am the principal at Daw Le Brooks Elementary School good evening everyone Brandy Smith proud principal at Samuel P Massi Academy good evening everyone Lisa fauler Jones The Proud principal of Bladensburg High School all right I think is that conclude our introductions we're ready to get started I'm going to share my screen now give me one second okay all right can everyone see my screen okay wonderful great good evening everyone we're excited to be here to talk about our comprehensive support and Improvement or CSI schools so I'm excited to share we have this evening we're going to do some reconnect inting on what it is our our office along

006with other offices do to support our schools um remind everybody including our public and our parents what a CSI school is um share a little bit about our current work and then we are pleased to have three principles here to share the strategies that they're implementing in their schools followed by some future work and some questions again thank you for having us here to the board members and the members of this committee we'd like to start with this graphic you may have seen this graphic before if you watched the previous academic committee when we presented in the fall this is a graphic that we like to ground our work in when we think about the question what is it that we are going to intentionally do to support our CSI schools this is the graphic

007that comes to mind that we know that real change happens when these four three four things are in place strategy Innovation leadership and where we might transform or transformation of our practices and so research says that really when these four things come together that is when we see real change for our students so we will ground our conversation in these terms this evening ultimately what we know is that we want for all of our schools including our CSI schools is that we want all of our students to acquire the skills they need as outlined in our student learner profile and really for us to meet the goals of our strategic plan in the t26 here in Prince georgees County County Public Schools we are so fortunate that we have a robust system of supports this

008is a districtwide effort Although our office is leading the conversation this evening we are um working in collaboration with many departments who are on this call including the department of accountability including academics our area team Title One all of us come together to support our schools to make sure that they have the resources the professional development all the tools they need to be successful as you can see on this screen it really is a group effort um different offices are playing different roles in the way in which they engage in our schools and so one thing that our office does the office of transformation leadership and continuous Improvement is to help bring some coherence to this work bringing all of these offices together ensuring that there is connection there's collaboration considering where we might find

009Innovation Innovative practices or strategies and helping us to become aligned um in a large and vast District such as ours we want to make sure that we are eradicating any silent unintentionally and that we are all working together to support our students our families and our schools and so again this is a districtwide effort so what is a CSI designated school and forgive me if you've heard this before we want to make sure everybody on the call hears it and for our families and our public who's watching so a CSI school stands for a comprehensive support and Improvement school and this is a designation that is given to schools by the Maryland State Board of Education or msde if you've heard that acronym there are four ways for that a school can be identified as

010a CSI school as you can see on the screen a school can become a CSI school for being a low performing school a school that has a low graduation rate a school that has not exited previously in a different status or a school that has a low performing student group that we would like to Monitor and support currently in Prince George's County Public Schools we have 24 CSI schools we have 15 elementary schools three middle schools three K8 schools and three high schools all of our schools in Prince georgees fall in two categories they are the two that are highlighted yellow on the screen our elementary schools our middle schools in our K8 um have been identified for a specific low performing student group and our three high schools are working towards an increased graduation

011rate so that is what it means to be a CS High School in order to exit this status just making sure our public knows and our families know um there are two different ways for our for our high schools who are focused on low graduation rate there has to be um a greater than 66.7 graduation rate consecutively in two years to exit that status for our schools that are working on a specific low student Performance Group and what we mean by that might be a specific demographic of students such as students with disabilities students are multilingual Learners those are the two that are predominant in our district um those Stu those schools have two Targets to meet um the state of Maryland ranks all of our Title One schools and they identify the lowest 5%

012of schools and so our schools in Prince George's County Public Schools who are CSI have to be above that low 5% Additionally the the student group in which they were identified for must meet annual targets that have been set by the state so incre incremental increments every year and it is unique to every school so this is what it means to be a CSI school so let's talk a little bit about the current work of our CSI schools so again in collaboration with lots of people on this call across our district and external Partners we're excited to share some of the work we've done to support our schools when we think about the connection of strategy leadership and innovation in order to transform our schools all of our CSI School leaders and some of their

013team members have participated in institutes to really think through high leverage strategies leadership moves and to learn more about Improvement science through our partners at the University of Maryland and what cycles of improvement looks like there is a science behind How We Do improvement work in organizations such as school systems so this summer our leaders came to a three-day Institute and we're pleased that just um last week we finished our winter Institute where we brought our leaders together to engage not only with our partners at University of Maryland and our partners in curriculum and instruction but also we had members of the MSD or the Maryland State Department of Education team there to really ensure that we all had the same understanding and Alignment about how to work through the improvement process together and how

014to exit we also know that leadership is a key part of this work and so we are pleased to work collaboratively across many offices to ensure our leaders have all of the skills they need and the resources and so some of our principles have engaged in principal coaching and they have a coach that they work with um all year long to support them in understanding improvement work or working with their leadership team every month we bring our principal leaders together who are designated as CSI principles for professional learning where we talk through high leverage strategies um compliance um efforts that we need to do learn from our curriculum partners and really connect with one another as thought Partners also in Prince George's County Public Schools to really support our CSI schools all of our CSI

015schools are also designated as a community school and so they have received additional funding and resources through the Community Schools Grant through the state of Maryland to support that wraparound approach to ensuring our schools and our communities have what they need and we'll share a little bit more about that later in this presentation new since the fall if you were here in the fall we have also launched our Cross departmental School plan review protocol so we have members from various different offices working together to review all of the school plans that our schools have worked hard and diligently on to ensure they are aligned to their needs provide feedback so that we can design support and professional development to support them and then finally Innovation where have we added new things to support our schools

016and on top of the ways in which all of our schools get support there is now a team that meets regularly bi-weekly it's a cross Department collaboration and steering committee where we come together and we plan the professional development we talk about monitoring School Improvement all the things and the resources that our schools need so that's one thing that has been launched this year to really align this work bring some cohesion and monitor and support our schools our high schools participate in District level support teams where they get targeted and strategic support on a specific problem of practice and it's a wrap on approach from many departments come to their school meet with them do walkthroughs and provide resources this year our area teams so if you're unfamiliar all of our schools are under the

017supervision of area teams and our area teams which consist of an associate superintendent and instructional directors meet quarterly with our CSI principles to review current student data um enact through reflective activities to really ensure that we are meeting the goals outlined in their comprehensive School Improvement plans we are building our leaders capacity to coach others we know that really if we want to improve practice of our students we want to ensure that our teachers have all that we need so we're supporting our leaders and building their toolkit around coaching practices and then finally an Innovative practice we've added this year that I'll provide an update shortly on is we've launched and implemented the oap math um professional development series which is a formative math assessment Series so lots of great things to support our CSI

018schools happening so what is oap just want to ensure that everyone knows so oap is a formative assessment learning U process so teachers participate in a 4-day professional development and one of four areas that really aligns to whatever grade level or grade span that they're teaching whether it's their direct classroom or through some intervention and Remediation and so they may attend an addition strategy an addition professional development multiplication fractions and proportionality this summer and this past summer we had 86 teachers from our CSI schools participate in that 4-day Institute and following that Institute 100% of the participants said that this will enhance their their teaching practice and that they're leaving excited so much so that we've added on a winter cohort so we've just finished um the first week of our winter cohort we we

019have added 60 additional teachers many have requested that they want to attend additional sessions they're so excited they want to know all four content areas our math our math PRP our principles of our CSI schools have participated in an overview session and our central office leaders have as well all of our teachers who have engaged in this professional development which is also um vetted from the Maryland State Department of Education receive ongoing coaching so they receive coaching in two ways they receive coaching directly from the ogap facilitators who come multiple times a year to provide them coaching sessions as well as members of our office have gone out and provided um School visits as need as well so we are very excited about our oap initiative what we know in Prince George's County that many

020of our students do need support with math and so we are hopeful that this is another strategy to help teachers look at the way in which students learn math and think about the next step in their math instruction so you've heard a lot from me now I think the most important part is this is that District appro approach but what does this sound like um on the ground in our school so I'm very pleased to have with us this evening three schools with us three principles um an elementary principal an academy principal and then a high school principal each to tell you a little bit about just a few of the strategies because they are doing a lot to support their students so they're going to share a little bit about a strategy that's I'm

021being impactful for them um and then we will come back and and wrap this up so we are going to start off with Dr Anita stter to introduce herself and share a little bit more about the strategies that she is trying this year at her school as a CSI principal Dr Stoddard well good morning good morning good it's not morning good evening everyone I'm thinking I'm at school sorry about that good evening everyone I am so excited to be here with you to share in reference to our school and what we are doing um in reference to CSI so as I stated earlier my name is Dr Anita Stoddard I am the principal of Doswell Brooks Elementary School I have been in Prince George's County for 33 years and for the last 20 years I

022have been the Principal at Doswell Doswell is a comprehensive school but it's also a very unique school we do have a large deafen heart of hearing population at Doswell e Brooks so I want to share that with you um Doswell Services all of the students in the county who are sign Lang dependent or their parents may choose to send them to Doswell if they are non sign language dependent and they are in the regular classroom so in self-contained classrooms we have 44 students that are either DEA or heart of hearing I have nine students that are in the regular classroom so that means that student is hard of hearing but they have enough hearing with an amplification device that they are able to be in a regular classroom with modifications accommodations and some type of

023hearing device most of our teachers wear um microphones that Bluetooth into the hearing aid and then we have eight students in our Early Childhood Program and then we have 32 students who are regular Ed resource students so our special education population is 29% we are in a CSI status because of special education scores so many people when they look at our percentage of students that are special education students they are like why why is their percentage so high every student that is a DEA and heart of hearing student also has an IEP and so we have from birth to grade five about over 60 students who are deaf in heart of hearing and then we have our regular education students who are being served regular education special education students who are being serviced so I

024want to quickly talk about three things that we are implementing in our building when it comes to CSI number one our stat days so we have stat days at Doswell every quarter just like we do in the county for our schools our stat days mirror what it is that we do in our CSI stat days doing the stat days this way it allows it to it allows the teachers to take accountability for their own data so they have about 10 minutes to speak about their data just like we do I think we may have 15 minutes as the principal and then you have people that can either ask you questions or give you suggestions and then you do a wrap up and so that's how our stat days are structured at Doswell and again it

025mirrors our CSI stat days the next thing is our CSI aison um we are building her capacity in a way that as she would say she never thought so number one she has insights into all areas of schools many times people's lens are very narrow when it comes to schools but she gets to see everything so making the connection with the budget the SBB budget the CSI you know funds that we get for CSI Community Schools she is boots on the ground with all of that schedules and helping us come together with the schedule and understanding the impact of a schedule when it comes to our instructional program the CSI plan can't say enough about that my CSI um liaison is the person who is the leader when it comes to the plan she makes

026sure that that plan is a living document in our building every day I have a million things to do and I'm GNA be honest she is the person that says starter we need to do this I looked at the plan in fact today one of the things that she said she said something we said we were going to do in our plan we just haven't done we need to make sure that we do X Y and Z she is the leader when it comes to cxi the last thing is with my CSI vaison I am coaching her but she is coaching other teachers and I love that Mom so when first of all she leads the meetings I do not lead the meeting I am a member of the team I am the leader of

027the building but I do not be those meetings she does so so when it comes to after the meetings and we do our debriefing then I am coaching her with our C it name it do it structure that we have all been learning about this year and last year in our leadership meetings and then she can use that same structure when she's giving feedback to teachers using the exact same structure but I think the big thing for the CSI liaison again is we have built her capacity lastly you heard Miss Smith talk a lot about oap and what that is I have to tell you we love the oap task in our building and here's why I know that we have Milestone task and expert task and we have all of that built into our

028curriculum that is true but in school buildings everybody is not in the same place at the same time so when we sit to go over those tasks and look at student work when it comes to those tasks people are in different places when we are doing the oap tasks we are all doing them at the same time when we then take those tasks in order to do the protocols and talk about our students with disabilities and talk about our ml students number one we are not separating our deaf and heart of hearing students from our regular education students in terms of special ed we are just looking at them as special education students number two everyone in the building on that grade level has done the same task as you all know when the T

029when the kids take mcap and other um standardized tests they are taking grade level standardized test it is a time for us all to look at a great grade level task all together and look at the misconceptions for all students in the building at the exact same time and we do absolutely love that the tasks are about they are reasoning task um they are tasks that you let me see how do I say this the tasks are reasoning tasks that everyone can look at and they're on different grade levels and so we are super excited about that and then lastly our teachers that have gone to the oap training although close your ears Miss Smith it is not set up for them to do TurnKey but because we have decided to do all of the

030task in the building we had to do some TurnKey training so that they know what it is that they're doing I do understand the process is not to do TurnKey and they need to go to the four-day training got it but when we deci decided to do all of the oap task as a school to go through the protocol and to talk about special education and ml students and we decided that we were going to do that we had to do some Turn Key Training in the building so that people would understand what it was that they were doing why they were doing it and what the process was for doing it thank you thank you Dr starter I was trying to find my mute key I appreciate that comprehensive explanation of the ways in

031which you're leading your school through this process and for our public who's watching when we say the word stat it's a way to come and look at our statistics our data so thank you for that so next we will have principal Brandy Smith to share more about the work she's doing at Samuel Massie Academy Smith good evening everyone um thank you for this opportunity again I am Brandy Smith the proud prin B Samuel pumi Academy we are a prek-8 Academy located in Forestville Maryland we are a neighborhood school and we serve as approximately 480 Scholars our CSI designation is for students with disabilities however we are low performing overall this is my second year there and two of the major areas of focus for us include chronic absenteeism and improving academic performance through professional learning

032for all staff our chronic absenteeism in school year 23 was 50% at the end of school year 24 we lowered it um to 40.7% and we are currently sitting at 28% chronic absenteeism right now um I will be completely honest it is an exhausting task and there's no way I could possibly do it without the support and the funding um from a multitude of sources and so my strategies tonight include how I align my f funds from SBB Community Schools Title One in Community Partnerships to address chronic absenteeism as well as professional learning um so the first first thing that we did for Middle School specifically as that was our targeted area from last school Year's data is we um established a middle school mentorship program and that is held weekly and as a result

033our Middle School chronic absenteeism has decreased by over 20% for this upcoming school year the children just have a great opportunity to um Bond and build relationships and they find a reason to want to come to school secondly we are very heavy on incentives for in attendance we are looking to have 94% attendance or higher but we are also looking to incentivize those Scholars who have shown an improvement in their attendance for each month and quarter our um incentives range from field trips out of the building to guest speakers brought into the building um and just different rewards that we get to learn what the students want through student surveys um next we focus a lot on family engagement and we bring we try to bring the community into the building as much as possible

034we're able to offer parent conferences parent workshops and um in addition to that we have really been able to expand our staff this year by purchasing two student Advocates and a parent engagement assistant this allows us to have a richer attendance task force team that we're called at my school we conduct home visits daily we have students on attendance contracts uh we reach out um to different Community Resources and support to see what they can provide free resources for our parents and we also have different services and programs come into the building since our parents don't necessarily travel outside of the community very much um and finally we are looking to increase our students attendance by providing all school supplies so whatever supplies they need they are provided on the first day of school and

035they are replenished again mid semester and again finally at the end of the year we are looking forward to bringing in motivational speakers and to increase our family engagement for next semester so as I said in the start it's exhausting and it's ongoing something that might work today doesn't work tomorrow so we just have to continually act assess and adjust um and then secondly we work on improving academics performance for all members and we do this through our partnership with in aages they come in to do capacity building for our staff and then the ogap math initiative has been huge and while it's very new to all of us through the partnership with transformational leadership and continuous Improvement we have been able to have multiple staff members from Gres prek the whole way through I'm

036sorry K through 8th um participate in the training and they're able to bring it back and do turn and talks with our staff members and share out in that way so a lot of excitement which I didn't think they would honestly have but they are super super excited and most importantly they're starting to become more comfortable with building their math capacity um it's as I said attendance and academic achievement go hand inand and so we're always continually assessing what we can do better we are work in progress but we are very blessed and thankful to have the funding and the Partnerships that we have thank you thank you so much principal Smith so that for that robust explanation and the family engagement in your intentional strategies we're excited to hear that your families and your

037teachers are excited and so lastly we're pleased to share Miss fauler Jones who's is going to talk about her work at Bladensburg High School and so again I'm Lisa fauler Jones The Proud principal of Bladensburg High School Bladensburg High School serves a diverse and dynamic student body with an enrollment of approximately 2164 students in with 2,164 students in grades 9 through 12 we support a highly transient population including many students with interrupted education our demographic is about 75% Hispanic a little less than 20% black or African-American um or let's say black African and or africanamerican um we are about 84% of the students are economically disadvantaged highlight and it it um highlighting the need for targeted supports and resources Bladensburg High School is committed to meeting the diverse academic needs of our students a significant

038portion of our Scholars are overage and under accredited and they are essentially um illiterate in their first language so therefore it's a slight lag in their acquisition of their second language and for some of them they've had interrupted education so many are also faced with language barriers that require support in acquiring English proficiency while earning credit toward graduation mathematics continues to be um an area that requires our most growth to address this we have implemented the ongoing assessment project oap which supports the development and reinforcement of key mathematical Concepts although you see the grade bands often times we have to divorce ourselves of grade bands and look at where students needs lie and so it allows us the opportunity to you know remediate some of the foundational skills while contining their mathematical growth um we

039know that those skills are aligned to about 80% of the Common Core State Standards for mathematics across all grade levels at the core oap uh it oap is teacher knowledge and professional development gra grounded I'm sorry in mathematical educational research and the office of transformational leadership and continuous Improvement has been instrumental in this work by providing targeted support and professional development rooted in Improvement science the Strategic approach approach has equipped us as leaders and um Educators with datadriven methodologies to identify and address learning gaps ensuring continuous REM refinement of instructional practices to better serve our population our multilingual Learners a standout successes our academic initiatives which we have a schoolwide initiative which is C R which is actually claim evidence and reasoning to support them as they acquire the language we try really hard to

040equip them with the strategy in which they tackle um academic based tasks and the initiatives have uh supported the performance of our multilingual Learners who have outperformed all other uh subgroups in rela this achievement has been made possible through strategic funding from Community Schools which has afford Community Schools and Title One in conjunction with our SBB which affords US the opportunity to do Extended Learning opportunities which allows targeted support for the different groups in the areas in which they need the tailored resource the impact is evident it has it has really impacted their ability to score very robustly in comparison to when we started it is also instilled in our students the ability to build confidence which has led to um the students consistent acquisition of the sale of biliteracy which has increased every year

041that I've been in the principal ship and this is year five and it's also increased their confidence to take on advanced placement courses uh so we have seen students successfully getting the Seal of biliteracy in both Spanish and French um in which has in turn enabled them to challenge themselves academically while demonstrating Proficiency in multiple languages throughout our Focus areas in mathematic intervention language acquisition and culturally responsive instruction Bladensburg High School is actively closing achievement gaps and empowering students with skills necessary for success in College and Career with the support of the office of the trans of transformational leadership and continuous Improvement our strategic Investments targeted supports and commitment to it are yielding tangible results although it's a marathon and not a Sprint it's ensuring that every student has the opportunity to thrive wow thank

042you principal fauler Jones we appreciate that commitment to our students being ready to enter the workforce and be ready to be College and Career ready we want to thank our principals for joining us this evening we're going to go ahead and excuse them so that they can get ready for school tomorrow thank you principal for your time and your leadership and your commitment to Improvement in culture and families and students I will keep going on we just have a few more slides thank you so much and so um you know we are still a work in progress working together across our district it's not just our office there's many great offices supporting this work um we will continue with the oap initiative we're continuing with coaching and professional development we're working with our area teams

043to continue our quarterly data reviews that's the stat day you heard about um we are pleased that our partners and accountability will be offering data literacy professional development for our school leaders and their school teens we work to launch a progress monitoring tool this year that we're working collectively in that steering committee to monitor the success um in the impact of our strategies at our school and this summer we will be bringing our leaders together again um to talk about leading this work we know we have more to do in the future we want to continue to build capacity we want to continue to add answer that question what are we intentionally doing to support our neediest schools and students and how are we leveraging our community and our business partners we want to talk

044about retaining our students keeping our families engaged in this work so that they are aware and most importantly how do we leverage the space for our students to have a voice in this work and own some of this work as well and that concludes our presentation we thank you for your time thank you so much Leona and team we appreciate the principles I know they had to go but we do appreciate everything they had to share I know we have to transition to our next presentation but if there are any um questions from board members um for Miss Smith about the CSI process or anything that was shared we can take those now um while Mr wington is getting set up more members are there any questions oh okay um Dr anul thank you um

045chair jongo um thank you all so much for this presentation um this is really um helpful um to hear about um I was actually looking for the list of all of the schools that you all work with is there somewhere that I can find that I see that they're 24 and the actual range of them yes Dr Andre I'll be sure to um get you a direct list and also the list also exists on the Maryland State Department education um as well but I will make sure to get um us a list as well so for our community that's watching um your school leaders should be telling you that your school is a CSI school as well as we will ensure that we get a list to our board members and you can also find

046information about your school and how they're doing academically on their school report card as well which is found on the Maryland State Department of Education website thank you and Miss Smith um is there a reason why it's not on our um on the PGCPS website I don't believe so and I'll make sure I'll I'll double check on that and follow with the right parties about how we might communicate that okay thank you and I only say that because you know I think this is this is a great um offering right that we have when we talk about supports we want to you know I'm often having conversations you know I'm a parent the school system myself and you know we have these um different you know programs that are providing supports to schools I think

047we need to make sure that parents have access to that information um and that they know that these are that there are some great things happening in our schools to offer support report to those who need it so there's one of my children there so thank you I'll onute is there any other questions okay um I I will do one question um so first um I kind of I had kind of the same question as um board member andul it was more just basically of like where could we see where the schools are so that um if parents or um if like you know just you know Community leaders around wanted to be able to reach out you know ask more about the program what could they um they could know which schools are actually

048um have the pro program implemented um another thing I was asking because um I heard like um I think it was I can't remember her name um one of the principles had said something on chronic absent um chronic aism and I was wondering like um according to like the data like how bad has chronic um aism effected the program and um maybe you could maybe I missed how long the program's been going for but um from the link of the program how um do we see a increase or decrease in The Chronic aism and is it improving our scores or is it still kind of the same and there are many great people on this call that can also jump in on the specific data um but I think you're you asked a really great

049point you have to be in school to learn and so attendance is a really important Point piece I know we have a goal to reduce our chronic absenteeism rate at a district by 3% um as well and the school that you heard say that was Miss uh principal Smith at SEL Massie when you heard her say she went from 50% chronic absenteeism to under 20 around 20 I think she's at 25% so um I don't have that specific data right now per school but I will say you asked another question in there about how long has this been going on so all of our schools who are currently CSI they are in a three-year cycle so they're in year two so at the end of next year the state will re-evaluate the progress our schools

050are making to determine their status moving forward and one of the things all of our schools um are measured on is our chronic absenteeism rate and and our attendance rate and I know uh Mr winton's office does a great job of sharing that information as well um but we do have some of that information available I just don't personally have it in front of me right now and while we won't be sharing it specifically for the CSI schools this evening um that's what Mr won's uh presentation is going to cover um Mr Jango so you'll hear a little bit about that in a few okay great um thank you so much um board member Goan mck thank you shair Jango um Miss Smith you kind of answered uh part of my question already I was

051going to ask about the length of time if this is you know CSI is nationally normally a three-year cycle where we were in that but then also when we're provided that list um to board member Andel and the rest of the board could we also get the list of just how long if any of those people if any of those schools excuse me are repeat um CSI schools absolutely we'll make sure to get you that information thank you if there are no additional questions then we will move on to our next presentation from the office of monitoring and accountability so good evening everyone I'll jump in to um yeah so I just want to let everybody know I've joined so Anthony H go ahead go on with your slides hey when the boss speaks we

052will be quiet no worri good evening good evening board members Anthony Whittington director of monitoring and accountability and uh coming behind me will be Dr Jamie Bowers she's the director of uh Department of Testing Research and evaluation but today I want to talk a little bit about chronic absenteeism and our Pass rates within our school district um through quarter one grades next slide as you know chronic absenteeism is a measure that identifies when students have missed at least 10% of their membership days let's think of them as their school days and is regardless of reasons this includes excused as well as unexcused absences and as well as suspensions those two count towards your chronic absenteeism rate now in addition schools receive points on their Maryland accountability report cards for students not chronically absent things that

053can contribute to Chronic absenteeism or affect the chronic absenteeism well chronic absenteeism leads to uh more poor academic achievement um it can lead to potential dropping out of school and high chronic absenteeism rates makes it very difficult for students to achieve at a high level the next three slides Compares our District's chronic absenteeism rates this school year versus last school year during the same time period which would be quarter one now as you can see this first slide is an elementary school breakdown where we're experiencing a 5 percentage Point reduction rate good news next slide middle school grade span we're experiencing a 5 percentage Point reduction as well and in high school we experien roughly a 4 percentage Point reduction in chronic absenteeism although these results are early this is still good news more students

054are coming to school the next few slides provides a clear evidence as to how chronic absenteeism can contribute to your academic achievement as I look at grades 2 through five I see a stark difference in the grade distribution of students deemed not chronically absent versus those students that have missed extended time in school 76% of the students that are not chronically absent are receiving a grade of A or B which is represented in the blue and the orange now as we look at the next grade span Middle School grades 6 seven and 8 this comparison is even greater as 65% of the not chronically absent students are receiving a passing grade of a or b and as you notice only 38% of the chronically absent students are receiving similar grades again within the high school

055ranks We're experiencing similar results as middle school with 61% of the not chronically absent students receiving a passing grade of A or B while only 29% of the chronically absent students are mirroring those same results this certainly points to your attendance playing a vital role in the students academic success lastly I would like to look into the passing rate of our core content areas or classes when I reference pass rate I'm referencing the data represented of students receiving an A B C or D meaning they have passed that particular course the core content courses will include mathematics English language Arts science and social studies the passing rates are broken down by student Group which represents race and or ethnicity and the passing rates of a few of our Service Groups multilingual learner and students with

056disabilities in elementary school grades 2 through five as you see almost all students groups are passing at a very high rate of 99% in Middle School experience very slight decline but as you see overall 96% of our middle school students are passing their core courses keep in mind core courses are English language arts science social studies and Mathematics while in high school we start to see or start to notice a number of students failing at least one of their core courses our District's overall pass rate has moved from 99% in elementary school to 96% in Middle School to now 88% overall in high school now one reason for this drop could be because High School is an exiting entity or this is the first time students are bearing credits meaning that you must pass your

057classes in order to graduate from school whereas middle school and Elementary School they are receiving grades but this is the training ground in preparation for them moving into high school and then passing their core courses the next three slides simply reference the same information but simply looking through the lens of a few of our Service Groups our multilanguage Learners and our students with disabilities but as you see we see similar Trends the majority of students in elementary school are passing at a high rate in these two service groups in middle school we see a slight decrease but the majority of them are still um excelling or passing their core courses next slide this represents the middle school where 96% of all students are passing their core courses and Within These two Service Groups 93 and

05895 respectively are passing which is a very high rate a high pass rate and then High School is where we see more of the students having some challenges passing one or more of their four courses which would be our next slide dropping down to 88% overall and Within These two Service Groups 81% of the multilanguage learner and 86% of the student students with disabilities I will now turn uh this is information if you need any further uh contact with my office and our team and I will now pass this information over to Dr Jamie B awesome thank you Mr Wedington and before Jamie gets started um with our Benchmark and dibles data were there any questions or comments from Mr Whit um I see that I think all board um board committee members have um

059comments um board member go mcen thank you so much committee chair JN go uh Mr wington can you explain especially for some of uh the public here what is constitutes as a passing grade for uh PGCPS passing grade would be a letter grade of an a a b a c or a d thank you and then my other question you might not be able to give us the specifics on it now but is it possible that we could get the core content Pass rates for students with disabilities and multilingual Learners specifically by grade so when we get to like we have them by elementary middle and high school but especially for for um high school can we see those numbers by freshman sophomore junior seniors so that we can better pinpoint where we need to

060provide additional interventions thank you um Dr Andel thank you yes um thank you so much for this presentation Mr witon um I think in a in a similar um of thought as my fellow board member um Miss go MCC here um there's a lot of dat here oh there's an echo can you hear that did you hear an echo no ma' okay let me know if it okay um there's a lot of data here but um and while I see it disaggregated in a couple of ways I think they you know I'd be curious to see it disaggregated a bit more right and so um board member going mccant mentioned kind of breaking out year year to year I think that would be helpful um in addition to that I think we're you know we're

061talking about the core content areas like could we break it out by core cont like by each um um each content area um I'd be curious to see um and I have some I have some assumptions um but I'd be curious to see um a little bit more um about which specific areas we're we're seeing um students having challenges or where we're seeing students um pass like where the rates are higher um I think that could be helpful and I'm also just curious to know you know I understand your office is the office of monitoring and accountability but what do we do with this data right like I see some opportunities for it to to be used to inform you know strategies but I'm wondering if there is some additional work that happens with this

062data um some additional analysis you referenced one potential reason for you know a drop in high school a decline in high school but I'm just wondering what what then happens with this data next so I know those were a couple of things but great so I referenced um year toe as it relates to content grade and areas and also by grade level specifically with high school around the court content um as it relates to the collaborative effort um well one in our office we've uh built several dashboards that are internally facing that shows like chronic absenteeism discipline and a number of other uh attendance things of that nature with schools as well as central office um Can chart their progress on a regular basis um and it updates in real time we also have an

063outward facing from the division of accountability we have an outward facing um dashboard that also looks at some of the these same indicators now as far as the collaborative nature our office sends out monthly chronic absenteeism rates by school by grade span and overall as a whole when it relates to um how students are doing with grade distribution these are meetings that happen on a regular basis with academics as well as the area office leadership so conversations continue to see the trends in our data um but what you specifically asked for we'll work on that and get that back to you I hope that anwers your question it it does thank you board members are there any other questions okay um Mr Wedington oh I actually do have one question real quick real quick um

064so I heard um um when you were talking about the rat of um I guess you could say of passing um I heard you say um something on the lines of where High School is more course um I can't remember the exact term you used but more course or credit binding and while middle school and Elementary School is more the you know the training I guess you could say um cycle um I just wanted to kind of like ask a question about that because of the fact that I was like um so if that's the case in elementary school and middle school or those you know training Cycles you basically like your training wheels of your school experience um then how does it work with retention in like middle school or like even elementary school

065because of the fact that couldn't that be like a you know um I can say kind of like a an argument arguing Point basically that if Elementary School and Middle School according to our data that's used as like our training wheel years think could we really classify like any student being you know being St um staying back for us um a grade level or so um currently within our school district um there isn't a metric or tests that students are taking to move their classification from one grade to the next so for example when the students starting at third grade take the mcap assessment if they're not proficient or deemed proficient they can still move on to the next grade level now are students retained in our school district or just any school district students

066are retained but they're very few the percentage of students retain nationally K to 8 is less than 1% but my point was when you get to ninth grade you start bearing credits which now they need 22 credits to exit School along with a few other things community service hours testing requirements Etc to exit school with a a diploma it starts to count in ninth grade um when you start taking these four courses and the other coures in order for you to pass so those credits those 22 credits are those classes in high school that will exit you from school whereas in middle school and Elementary School the class that you're taking doesn't count towards you exiting school does that make sense yeah yeah that makes sense I just wanted to get a little bit of

067clarification on that so you can be retained in the elementary middle but it's very rare that we see large number numbers of students being retained right it's mostly in high school yes sir okay thank you so much um I think I have one second um second round question for Dr Andel yeah we can't hear you just realized that okay um I'll be quick thank you so um I think part of what I was also getting at my first question will align with this one so you know you said that there's some internally facing and externally facing um data via dashboard and otherwise and then some reporting that you all share out in recurring basis who then does the analysis whose responsibility is it is there any analysis that's done whether it's um and thinking about

068you know again like I mentioned if there's data that's disaggregated where schools can kind of look um at their own data is it is it the responsibility of of the school you know like some of the principal that were just here is it their responsibility um and I'm also wondering when we think about um you know chronic absenteeism and some of the other data that you're showing here have do we do schools actually have information or do we have information about how we compare um with neighboring school districts or with others um in the state just to kind of get a better sense of you know what is our data actually showing us and how are we fairing in regards to others who does the analysis and do we have access to that data as

069well right our comp comparison point with neighboring school districts um is uh the Maryland State Department of Education website and there's a wealth of information there around attendance uh around graduation rates um mcap scores Etc when we wanted to compare ourselves even down to the student and Service Groups that's a comparison point now as far as our collaborative efforts and the analysis of that some of that is done when we have have these quarterly stat days um within our area office and area office brings together different Central offices um to be think partners and collaborate with leadership within the schools because the principles come to those meetings with a number of key leaders within their building and they have to walk through a number of items uh that move into the school Improvement round so

070um our office does do some of the analysis uh Jamie's going to uh Dr bows is going to speak next her office has an analysis arm within her office as well and I know academics can speak on the analysis that they do um within the data from a day-to-day basis as well Dr ster wants to add to that no that's fa comprehensive uh so one of the things we're tasked with is trying to put the data out there in a digestible way so that all end users can be able to do their analysis so it's not requiring any high level of psychometrics or anything of that sort uh so if you go into the uh dashboards and you take a look at it you can filter you can download into Excel you can do all

071kinds of wonderful things so we would encourage you to get into uh those dashboards and take a look for yourself thank you and we are now at 637 I want to make sure that we have enough time to get Dr Bow's presentation through so we can conclude at 7 um just putting a reminder out there yep yep yep let's get this on the road Dr bars good evening um so this evening I'm going to be sharing two sets of data I'm going to be sharing our Dibbles uh fall Administration data and our Benchmark one data just as a point of note we currently just closed our Dibbles winter Benchmark Administration and we are getting ready to close our Benchmark winter Administration uh hopefully next Tuesday and then when we meet again with the academic achievement

072committee later on in the spring we will be sharing our winter dibles data and our Benchmark 2 Data updates just some background information on our Dibbles so we do use the Dibbles assessment as our Universal screener it is required by Maryland law that each local school system has a universal screener to identify students who are at risk for reading in a minimum of grades kindergarten through two printeres County also administers the dibles assessment to students in grades three so we are seeing a comprehensive view of our early Learners in literacy in grades kindergarten through three so when you look at the schedule for the year we have a beginning of year that's our Boi we have a middle of year that's ouri and we had an end of year assessment our eoi and you can

073see each of those windows and across the top you can see the five different subtest measures that are given on Dibbles we have our letter naming fluency for our students in kindergarten uh and first grade we have our phon name segmentation fluency for our students in first and second grade we have our nonsense word fluency for students in kindergarten first second and third we have our word reading fluency in K through three and then we have our oral reading fluency subtest in grades 1 through three just some information on our participation rate for our beginning of year assessment this data was as of the end of October that's when the beginning of year dibles assessment closed we had about a 97% participation rate uh like I said this is a required state assessment to look

074at screening of all students so we typically have between a 95 and 98% participation rate across all of our schools in kindergarten through three so that gives us about 38,2 65 students who completed 30 of our schools had a 100% uh completion rate not all schools are going to have a 100% completion rate uh we do have absences we do have students who are special education uh who may take another assessment uh we do have some students who are multilingual learner that are newcomers that may not uh enroll in time to take the dibl so we do have some reasons why there are not 100% completion rates across all schools but for the majority most of our K through three students are taking this assessment uh we also have a lectura version of Dibbles which

075is the Spanish version of Dibbles that is given at our immersion schools that is not given across all of our elementary schools of students who Spanish is their native language it is only administered at our emergence schools that teach Spanish as another language so over those schools we have an 86% participation rate so that's about 931 students who are completing that Lector version and two of our schools uh that are immersing schools had 100% completion rate just some background information on the different subtests uh that dibles administers so when you see these three-letter acronyms this is kind of a glossery of terms that you can use to go back and look at what each of these acronyms means uh but most of these are relating back to the subtest that I mentioned a few slides

076ago of the different U measures that dibles is giving to each of the four grade levels so looking at our beginning of your data we are looking at beginning of year Sy 25s so if you look across the bands you're looking at four different colors that's how Dibbles reports students who are well below the Benchmark who are below the Benchmark at The Benchmark and above the Benchmark so ideally we are looking for a majority of our students to be in that green which is at Benchmark or the blue which is above Benchmark um they don't say that students are at grade level or below grade level because Dibbles is not measuring students grade level it's actually measuring where they are in there for subtest on those early literacy or reading skills so that's why dibl

077uses the terminology Benchmark so if you look at our grade kindergarten you're going to see about 44% of our students are at the at or above Benchmark so we're closing in on that range of about 50% of our students at the beginning of year are at or above Benchmark about 46% of our first graders are at that measure of at or above Benchmark same with our second grade population and about 43% of our third grade students at the beginning of year were at or above Benchmark so when you look at a comparison because dibles has been administered in our district for three years this current school year is the third year we've administered this assessment to students in grades K through three so if you look at a threeyear comparison Trend over on the right

078hand side you're going to see arrows so our kindergarten students are performing about the same as where they did last year at this same time with those kindergarten students so our kindergarteners from school year 24 and our kindergarteners from school year 25 are performing about the same as far as measuring students who are at and above the Benchmark that's why you see that yellow sideways Arrow the other three grade levels however you see green arrows pointing up that means that each of those three other grade levels are performing higher than their peers in the prior year so our first grade students this past year performing higher than our first grade students last year uh by a few percentage points same with our second grade and our third grade students so this is a trend that

079we would expect to see um especially at the beginning of the year uh The Benchmark for Dibbles at the beginning of the year is a little bit easier uh for students to meet that at and above when I come back and share with you the middle ofe data or thei data you may notice some other Trends our middle of year uh Dibbles assessment is a bit more challenging for students the expectations grow uh increasingly as you go throughout the year uh and then our end of year typically shows um some growth as well because it's not as rigorous at the end of the year as it is at our middle of year point for dibles but definitely pointing in the right direction of the signs that we want to see at this point in the

080year for our students at the beginning of the year in their early literacy skills when we look at our Lector uh we're looking at very high uh rates of students in all four grade levels of students who are at and above Benchmark as you can see with our green and blue bars so we always like to look for those students who were in that yellow band or students who are below Benchmark so they're not quite at Benchmark but they're not quite below they're kind of in that between area so for the last three years we've looked at students who are about six composite points uh or less away from being identified at Benchmark which is that green band so when we look at our table we're looking at number of testers in that first row

081so you can see uh across Ross each of those grade levels we have between 1100 and 1,600 students who are six composite points or less away from that green or at Benchmark band which is great um that's a high percentage if you look at the third column that is the percent of students who are you know six composite points away from that so in first grade we have almost 65% of those students are six composite points away um which is great we definitely want to see that trend uh we would like to see a little bit higher in our kindergarten and third grade Trends but our second grade trend is almost nearing that 50% uh as well if you look at the trend data from school year 23 and school year 24 this data for

082the six composite points away more closely mirrors uh where we were in school year 23 than it did in school year 24 uh last year we were seeing uh a little bit higher rate of students who closer to that green at Benchmark so if you look at the sy24 column about 34% of students were uh six points away from Benchmark in kindergarten whereas this year there were only 24 so you can look at they're not huge differences but there are slight differences across each grid level uh for that Sixpoint composite so we always like to look at the highlights of our subtests that are given for Dibbles so you can can see across the board on our subtests that are given we're looking at uh nice increases across the board for each of our grade

083levels with the exception of a slight one percentage Point decrease for our kindergarten students uh in pheic awareness and just to kind of share a little bit more about the pheic awareness uh so how that's administer on dibles is the teacher will uh have one minute with each student and the examiner will say a word that has uh three or four phones or sounds so for example the teacher might say cat and the student is supposed to say The Sounds in that word for example they would say at the examiner marks each correct sound segment that the student says and so the student score is based on how many correct segments they are able to get in one minute and so why this is important is this skill is very very key in determining students

084uh future reading success and so that's a little bit of a concern that we're seeing a decrease in our kindergarteners on that particular skill but 1% is not a statistically significant decrease so it's something we'll just keep an eye on but we definitely want to make sure our kindergartners have that uh phon awareness skill set to be able to hear sounds and differentiate them in words but other than that you know we're seeing pretty steady increases across all of our other grade levels and our other Dibble sub tests when we look at our district in comparison to the nation so we have about 370,000 other students across the country that are taking this assessment so when we look at our comparison to each of the four grade levels and those other students as a whole

085when you see the arrows uh a down arrow doesn't necessarily mean it's negative so if you look at the First Column of red where it says students who are well below Benchmark uh the first Arrow of kindergarten is below but that's actually good sign we actually want our numbers in that red column to be going down we want less students in that well below category as compared to their peers Across the Nation so you see that in kindergarten uh however in grade one grade two grade three they're slightly higher uh numbers in that well below than in comparison to their peers Across the Nation if you look at the yellow below Benchmark we also would like to see uh a decrease in those because we want more students to be in that green or at

086Benchmark or that blue above Benchmark so you do see across all the grade levels with the exception of grade three which is similar numbers to comparison of their peers in the nation that those have lower numbers of students in that below Benchmark and then if you go across to the green uh we see even numbers of students in Kinder Garten Across the Nation in grade K but lower numbers in grade two and where we really want to see the upward facing arrows is that last column our above Benchmark level in blue so we see that our students in kindergarten we see that our students in grade one are above the number of their peers Across the Nation in that above Benchmark so that's definitely a positive sign we want to see more of those arrows

087in that last column pointing up so I'm going to share just some brief uh I ready data our district also administers the I ready assessment to students in uh kindergarten through grade eight now this year so we're going to look at some data for our I ready Trends uh from Summer regression and then our beginning of your data so we're looking at the state of student learning last school year uh you're looking at the percentage of students on Gray level by year so if you're looking at the Historical trend is that gray bar the one on the left for each grade level and then our spring 22 is the lightest green the medium green is our spring 23 and the dark screeners are spring 24 so what you can see here is actually our on

088grade level uh percentages are kind of at a stagnant level and in some cases they are actually slightly declining uh and so this is National Trend data so we're seeing students across the nation that are taking this I ready assessment which is also a very large population of students that take this assessment uh are either trending about the same or slight um declines there are a few grades that show slight um increases but across the whole uh we are seeing about the same uh prepandemic in those you know grade four to grade eight as far as where students are uh in Reading so how have our district uh looked from Fall to fall so we have been administering the I ready assessment for several years however we're just looking at it from a three-year perspective

089which is similar to our uh Dibbles data and so the I ready assessment looks at students who are in that green band at the top mid or above grade level so this assessment is a bit different than Dibbles this is looking at students who are reading at or above grade level in the current grade level that they're in that light green is early on grade level the yellow is one year below the light red is two years below and the dark red is three grade levels below so if you're looking at uh our Dibbles I'm sorry our I ready data uh as a three-year Trend we are kind of holding steady uh at the number of students who are respectively in each of those categories so I ready is measuring um not only some of

090our early literacy skills but it's looking more at fluency and comprehension and so you know looking across the distribution we are starting to see as you get into third fourth and fifth grade uh more students are increasing in those numbers of you know two plus grade levels below uh reading where they should be at this point in the year in the fall uh and then one of the things our board members like to look at last year is how much did uh summer learning or summer slide impact our students and so if you look across uh the bar chart the light blue is the prior year gain uh the dark blue is the current year start and so if you look at the arrows everything is kind of circled in Orange uh is comparing to

091that National summer gain loss in that Center column um so we're not really experiencing uh too much Summers slide at this point as measured on the I ready uh and this is something that our partners and curriculum Associates kind of meet with us uh each time we give the ey writing kind of talk about where we see our district and how much we're impacting over that summer slide or from the fall to the winter winter to the spring uh where our students are as far as uh reading on grade level early grade level uh or below so it's something we're definitely keeping an eye on um we did talk earlier about our CSI schools so I wanted wanted to show an example of looking at our CSI schools we're seeing a very similar Trend uh

092as far as our summer slide and I'm going to let Dr McDaniel speak to uh the next two slides and then I'm going to share some information regarding our Benchmark one assessment data yes I'll be very brief um because I want to make sure we get to that Benchmark data but as you all have heard this evening we collect a lot of data um but the point of collecting this data is to be able to make in sound instructional decisions and so that we're providing the support the intervention the acceleration whatever is needed for our students for where they are and so um the dibl status is telling us what support a student might need um what interventions might be needed and so we know that the regular communication with our school administrators training our

093teachers on um what they student data means um and how that can impact in their instruction make sure that we have sound um datadriven decisionmaking and so our department shares um information we can go to the the next slide Jamie um we just wanted to share with you all an example of what a school gets on about a six week um rotation regarding the progress monitoring of how students are performing on those indicators Dr bow shared earlier and so an individual school is going to get their school-based data sheet um to see how students are performing um on one of our our interventions our Lexia Core 5 that helps students as they're progressing throughout those uh various indicators that were shared and so we are letting them know how their individual school is performing how

094their students are doing and some of the instructional implications um for making sure that students move forward and if the appropriate number of students are not involved in the intervention they get that information as well so that principles can follow up with their teachers instructional directors um also receive these data sheets for the schools that they support so that everyone is on the same page with regards to what the data is um how students are performing what needs to be done and what needs to be changed instructionally so Jamie I'll turn it back over to you for our Benchmark data thank you so uh we'll be sharing Benchmark one results for our Elementary uh Middle School and High School reading and Mathematics from our fall like I said we are currently administering our Benchmark 2

095Data um with the snow coming it kind of keeps pushing back our test Administration window a little bit so hopefully we can close our window on Tuesday and get our data for Benchmark 2 that is coinciding in with Quarter Two so just some um background information on our benchmark assessments so we do have benchmark assessments in all four core contents uh we're just going to be sharing our English language arts and Mathematics this evening uh but we do have very similar to how we report out for Dibbles similar to how we report out for our state assessments four different performance levels uh we look at emerging Learners developing Learners OnTrack Learners and advanced learners uh and our benchmark assessments are not uh designed to give us information for a student being on grade level which

096is why we don't refer to in our performance levels as a student being proficient or on grade level our benchmarks are meant to be at the end of a quarter of instruction to look at if a student is uh gas gaining the concepts or standards that was taught in that 45 days of instruction so the repor uh has 150 Point score that each student gets a scale score which is very similar to Dibbles is very similar to our mcap that 150 point scale score range uh coincides with one of those four um Four Color band performance levels for our benchmarks we had approximately 164,384 by about 1,900 assessments from the prior school year so we have almost 165,000 assessments um and both reading and Mathematics being administered um in our schools at the end of

097quarter 1 uh two things of note for this year uh as we look at our Trend data over the last five years we've been ministering our district Benchmark program this is the fifth year that we are administering these assessments at the end of our quarter uh we had some shifts in Middle School reading there was a curriculum sequence change uh for Benchmark one so when we're looking at Trend data our Benchmark one data for this current school year cannot necessarily be compared to our Benchmark one from prior school years because there were some curriculum sequence changes and in high school mathematics this current school year our firsttime 9th grade students uh took geometry and in the past our firsttime nth grade students have taken algebra for one so when you're looking at the test taker

098count for each of those courses uh you have to take that into consideration because you have different groups of students who traditionally would have taken Algebra 1 as nth grade uh we had very very few students take the algebra 1 benchmark this year because most of our 10th grade students had already taken Algebra 1 uh in ninth grade so we had a significant up Tick in uh the number of students who took geometry so that is the first time n9th grade assessment dis School looking at our overall data analysis for Benchmark one across all grade levels and courses there was a slight decrease uh and that was about a 1% decrease not statistically significant uh but nonetheless something that we want to keep an eye on I'll talk about in a few slides uh the

099reason that we've pinpointed that we did see an a decrease across the average of all grade levels um and that second bullet starts to allude to that our performance of our students on the overall written constructive responses had a measurable impact on the overall score uh of our benchmarks and we'll talk about that in a few slides in Reading we did have uh some overall Improvement and our high school grades English n and English 10 and then grade eight uh remain unchanged for mathematics uh we're looking at a different story from mathematics we did see overall Improvement across uh all of our mathematics Assessments in the district we saw about a 4% increase in our Benchmark one uh from school year 24 to school year 25 which is great uh we've been spending a lot

100of time as a district focusing on mathematics uh and so this 4% increase is definitely a sign that that impact is being felt in schools and students are able to demonstrate higher uh learning on our benchmarks and Mathematics the last bullet uh if you look at students in grades 2 78 and our accelerated mathematics one and two courses foundations for algebra algebra 1 quantitative modeling and Algebra 2 all saw increases in our Benchmark achievement from last school year to this school year grade five in Geometry um didn't see Improvement but remain unchanged so U being unchanged isn't necessarily bad it's you know we're holding steady in those two courses so if you look at our comparison from last school year to this school year you're going to see uh very similar reporting as dibles except

101it's um a little we're looking at a little bit differently but we're still looking at those color bands so we definitely want to see students moving away from the red and the yellow so we want to see students moving away from that emerging and developing Learner in those left uh color bands more into the on track and advanced learner so if you look at each grade level you can see how many students are scoring um at the on and advanced Learner in each grade level um and you can see across the grades we're not seeing significant shifts so for example in grade three last school year we had about 15% of our students who were on or ADV Advanced Learners this year we had about 13% so we're not seeing you know High significant uh

102declines in percentage proficiency or not proficiency on on track but we're we are still seeing some small decreases so we're definitely keeping an eye on that and what that means uh when I shared some information on I ready that's some of the same Trend that we're seeing in I ready as well as students not reading uh on grade level or that early on grade level so definitely keeping track of these percentages over time in mathematics it's a similar uh story unfortunately we do want to see less of our emerging and developing learner but in mathematics um we do see across most of our grade levels most of our students currently are achieving in that emerging and developing learner for Benchmark one uh however we did see improvements um in some of our grade levels so

103that's a positive sign that what we're doing in schools is having some impact on on students in quarter one and instruction so one of the things we pointed out earlier was you know what could be having an impact on the slight decrease in reading that one percentage decrease and so we started looking at how are students doing overall in writing so writing um takes up a large portion of the assessment um specifically in reading and so on our reading benchmarks we have anywhere from 10 to 12 items and writing is one of those 10 to 12 items however uh the writing number of points is about a third sometimes a little higher than a third of the overall points of the assessment and so when we looked at uh for grade three as an example

104uh we wanted to look at how many students are actually scoring a zero on the writing item which means that they are getting zero out of between 12 and 19 points so about 40 % of our students earned a zero on that writing item just for example in grade three and so they missed out on 12 points on that Benchmark one and the total number of points on the entire test was 30 so when you look at how that's weighted about 40% of the assessment was weighted in that writing item just as an example uh in mathematics very similar we have two different writing items however they're not weighted as heavily as on the reading assess we have a modeling item and we have a reasoning item on each grade level so for example in

105Benchmark 3 for grade three uh the total number of points on the test was 15 we have a modeling item which students need to have a written or constructed response in addition to usually solving an equation providing an equation or providing a an answer uh so that was worth three points the number of points for reasoning was three points so when we're looking all the way across the table how many students were earning zeros uh on reasoning and modeling items again almost half of our students are earning zero points on those items and so you know what does that mean uh when we're seeing a decline across our reading certainly um that means that a lot of our students are either writing nothing for a writing item uh they're writing very minimal which means they

106are not earning a score uh on the rubric or they're writing something that's completely inaccurate and then earning a zero score and so same thing for mathematics students are either not answering the modeling and reasoning items or they are answering the item wrong or they are not putting enough information to Warrant a score on the rubric above a zero and so this information has been shared with principles it's been shared with assistant principles uh we shared it with our CSI and atsi schools last week at the winter Institute which Miss Smith um discussed uh so this is definitely something as a district that we are keeping a close eye on and making sure that we are sharing this information with schools uh when our office meets with school test coordinators and data coaches we make

107sure that this data is at the Forefront because we want to make sure that students are having every opportunity to answer these writing items and our benchmarks um to make sure that we are gaining as much information about how they can respond to reading or write about a modeling and reasoning item as possible so those are my slides I know we're eight minutes past the time but I'm sure there may be some questions so I'll pause for questions um thank you for the [Music] presentation um board member going M thank you so much for that presentation I just had three well three main questions and I'll just give them all to you at once for Dibbles and I ready which one are we using as a district to progress monitor towards mcap and is that

108information shared with parents I know that was technically two questions but that was what I was counting as question number one and then the um second question was specifically with correlations how are the benchmark assessments correlated with mcap as well and then my third one was kind of related to the first question but specifically how are those numbers communicated with individual parents at the elementary level and then students at the high school level especially considering our new um third grade reading decision that parents are having to make how are we giving this information to parents so that they can make an informed decision so um we do not use Dibbles to correlate to mcap because Dibbles is used to screen students for early literacy skills um we do however our I ready assessment our curriculum

109Associates partner who is the vendor uh that supplies our I ready assessment is doing a long range study on I ready data and its correlation to mcap Performance so that's something that our district is not participating in but the vendor is and sharing that information with us uh what our district looks more closely at is benchmarks which you alluded to uh the setup of our Benchmark the test form uh with the multiple select and Technology enhanced and constructed response items uh mirrors exactly what students are going to see on the state assessment in a much smaller version so where you have 12 items on a benchmark for quarter 1 at the end of year summative mcap assessment you have about 35 items so it's about a third of what students are going to see but

110those benchmarks um when you look across the year we have a benchmark one we have a benchmark two and then an optional Benchmark three that schools May opt to use uh when you combine all of those three assessment standards together they make up almost what is assessed at the end of your summi of assessment on the mcap uh we also do have a data management and Reporting um office within my department we do have a psychometrician on staff uh we have looked at several um year trends of our benchmarks in relation to our mcap we definitely do see correlation so when we have seen spikes and Improvement in mcap specifically in high school in grade 10 two years ago we saw the same thing in our Benchmark data um I'm not going to say it's

111across the board that our benchmarks are you know exactly equated to mcap but we definitely have seen um some strong correlation to over you know all three benchmarks being administered you know how that could potentially be a predictor for mcap uh and your last question about parents um so when we do our trainings with our school test coordinators and our data coaches we share all of the resources that uh we have available we also have a parent portal site where parents can actually go in and download and view Benchmark um individual student reports which are very similar to our mcap reports uh we give schools some tips uh and some strategies uh when it's parent teacher conference time to kind of speak to parents about their results uh we work with Dr Jackson's office and

112do some Zoom sessions on looking at uh the individual student reports uh and then as schools request our present um for example I'm working with Lake Arbor Elementary school this week they're actually doing a data night for parents so we love when you know schools invite us to come to school whether it be virtual or in person uh last year we did a great parent seminar at one of the um Spanish Immersion schools and so as much as we can in my office we like to get out in front of parents and kind of share this information but when we can't we like to help support schools with some of those resources too so they can as well thank you so much can I oh Dr andil yes thank you am I on mute nope

113I'm not okay thank you so much for that presentation um I just wanted to start by saying um quite honestly thank you I think this was a really um thorough um and helpful presentation and I appreciate did the way that you um outlined the data um and also provided um National comparisons and Trends um and I thought it was really well done so thank you so much for doing that um there were a few slides that I think we just didn't have um uploaded in board do so I just wanted to make a request that um the updated presentation be be added um I know there was one slide that like some I like to follow along on my on my big screen um there was one slide I think slide 19 that showed some

114trends that I thought was a really interesting slide that we didn't have access to and so just wanted to make sure um that that was added um and then thank to um um board member goes mcc's last question about parents um and how they're receiving again like I said I'm a parent I appreciate receiving the dibles print out um getting that even if I don't have the opportunity to speak with um you know my son's teacher because I don't have that opportunity every you know every time it's released unfortunately um so the the online access that you mentioned um I'm actually not familiar with that maybe other parents are so I guess my question there is you know how do we like how is that how is that offering like made known to parents um

115I don't I'm not familiar with that sure so usually that U we communicate with our school test coordinators at each building and so sometimes when we have a new school test coordinator uh a school test coordinator that's really overwhelmed um that that's our cue that maybe we need to do a little bit better of a job communicating with them but uh when the platform um is populated with Benchmark individual student reports usually a parent would get an email and so a lot of times that's predicated on the district having a valid and current email address for each parent uh sometimes we don't have that um but I I agree I think that that's probably an area that we could strengthen a little bit um because it's hard last year we had about 5,000 parents of

116the you know 130 plus thousand students that access that Benchmark platform to look at their students individual student report so that tells us you know the message is getting out there but not as widespread as it needs to be and so that's why you know hopefully our office can have some more presentation time with Dr Jackson and her family community um engagement sessions uh as well as you know working more closely with our school test coordinators to get that information out to parents to make sure um and that can also be something from my office that I put in a memo to schools to make sure that if that information can go out on like a school's website or Google classroom or canva um the canvas site that we um push that information out there

117again to make sure it's getting down to parents and families okay thank you so much I appreciate that sure okay um I do not have any questions um board members do you have any more questions and um always remember um if you have any questions for any of the three presentations you can always send them to Rosa and Rosa will send them to the admin um so that you guys can get a response but if there is no um if there's no more questions then I we'll just move on to the next thing but I believe there is no further business so so I would say thank you so much for thank you so much everyone for the great presentations um just like I wanted to say um just like I said before any follow-ups

118from tonight's meeting um could be shared um to Rosa so that can be shared to any of the um administrations have um I would like to thank the public the committee members PGCPS Administration staff and the board office for joining us this evening there are being no further business the time is now 7:18 p.m. and the February 10th academic achievement committee is now adjourned thank you for everyone for the great meeting tonight thank you all

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.