CorpusRecord 198815

Board of Education Policy & Governance Committee Meeting, Feb 6, 2025.

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / PGCPS
Date
2025-02-09
Location
Prince George's County, MD
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,446 words · about 36 min
Collected
2026-06-26

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001We can't get food out. They won't have blankets. I don't know what that means. Like, what does that tangibly mean? Yeah, well, each school develops their own needs assessment. So what one school may do with their per pupil grant may look different than what a different school does with their particular grant. Okay. So it's not that they all get the exact same thing with the resources. They develop a plan based off of the specific needs that are unique to that school. I appreciate you answering that question. Sounds like our bottom line here is that we have about 11 schools that will be able to have somebody doing community schools work, but they won't have any dollars to do the work going forward. So whatever that work is. It seems like a tremendous impact. Are there

002any board members that have questions? Oh, I'm sorry. Ms. Welsh. I was not intending to overlook you. My apologies. I know you wanted to clarify something. Yes, I did. And now I got distracted because of your question and I was thinking about thinking about that in terms of what that impact would be. The question, the interpretation, I think I maybe wasn't very clear it's so it what's really what's happening is by pausing the expansion of the grants for the per pupil Amount for those two years, that will save the state about $473 million. Over the original blueprint of what the estimate had been. But they'll still put about 2.13 billion statewide into the program. But because they'll have that extra money, I shouldn't say because I'm not, I shouldn't make that link. So they're going

003to have this extra 473 million. They're not spending. However, the programmatic changes that are they're going to invest in where MSD now is going to be supposedly providing supports reviewing and assessing each school's data making sure they're doing what they are supposed to be doing. That actually, well, this bill allows $8.2 million over a four-year period to go into MSDE's resources To be able to do that work. So if you think about it, I'm just making a connection for you. It doesn't say that in the bill. But their money is now going to the local schools. It's going to MSD to do some of the same things that we were originally responsible for. At the system level, the MSD will do it. And they evidently their oversight will then be pretty critical because of the

004fact that if they want to, they can actually um They don't think that school's meeting the criteria that's been set, they can pull funds. So that's pretty serious oversight. Your funding's at risk for not doing what you're supposed to do. Not to say that we're not in favor of compliance, because absolutely we're in favor of compliance and do what you need to do. But there is that relationship there. Yeah, I want to bring, I know Board Member Briggs has a question. Chief Howell, I want to be hyper cognizant that you have two meetings and so um I want to ask board members to make sure if we have questions specifically for Chief Howe and then Dr. Thornton will come in and give us another view on this holistically. But if you've got questions, please jump

005back in. I'll entertain another round before she goes. Board member Briggs. So I don't actually know if this is appropriate because this isn't really what you just requested a question, but it's a statement to Ms. Howe because I wanted to just, one, I wanted to lift up for everybody that Strong Schools Maryland actually released a really good visual on the impact of the decrease in collaborative time funding, the impact that it's going to have on schools across the years until they reestablish the funding. And I think that if we had some way to really, I feel like this discussion is about when we go to Annapolis, when we're Pushing this for our elected officials, they need to understand, I think the very real essential question that board member Walker asked, which is like, how does

006this impact our schools? How does this impact our students? What does this look like? And I feel like that's the piece that I love the idea that Chief Howe mentioned around like the 22 million, because I think that figure is very clear. But if there are some other things too, if we're thinking about like even that 163 that'll eventually compound to larger and larger amounts, what impact will that have over the amount of time that we'll be looking at our most vulnerable students, our students that are most high risk and most in need, not getting the essential resources that they need while we're also still navigating this deficit. And I guess the question I have for you, Chief Howe, was too. How does this align with the, because right now we have a 42 million

007deficit. I know we probably projected out a potential possibility of not getting funding next year, of course, with the sunsetting of the federal funds. So I'm curious with that 22 million, is that in addition to or is that just the projected amount overall? Yeah, so two things. Number one, with regards to your statement. We do have a high level projection. Again, we're still sort of validating and confirming the impact of this pause and what it's going to mean over the next 10 you know through 2033. And for us, we're looking at a loss of North of a billion dollars between the impact on ml comp ed And the foundation over that timeframe. So again, we're still validating and doing our own calculations, but it's around a billion dollars, a little bit more than a billion

008dollars. So we do have kind of that Broader insight of what this actually means over the long term, not just fiscal year 26, which is what we're planning for right now. But to answer your second question around And so I just had a brain phase You had a question. 22 million, is that like the projected deficit? Yeah. Yeah, so the 22 million for 26, that is in addition to the impact of Our current budget, which has a deficit of 35 million. So, I mean, when you think about the loss of funding for foundation In addition to CompED, in addition to ml At least 75% of that funding goes to the schools. So with that kind of reduction. It has a direct impact on schools. There's no way around it and so when you have that

009kind of a change, the foundation is used for staffing our school buildings and maintenance and all the things along with ML as along with compensatory education So there's going to be a direct impact to the resources that will be allocated to the schools, what that's going to mean, how that's going to look it will vary, it will differ by school, but you can't have that kind of a change without it having an impact across the district at the school level. Thank you, Chief Howe. I know Board Member Boozer Struthers hand is up and I want to make sure we bring you in. Oh, thank you. I was just going to go to that point of the total dollar amount over the years, because even if you just use today's student enrollment and do quick math,

010you get up to at least 634 million over the eight years, but what you described is we get up to the billion Because every year the amount is lowered, which means it's residual into the other categories. It's compound. And so we are expected to implement the blueprint for Maryland's future with a billion less dollars than projected by the Kerwin Commission. And I think that's like basically what we need to implore our legislators to understand that their expectations of the blueprint of the blueprint are now we're being asked to meet that by the billion. And I know Dr. Thornton is going to describe this in Detail, but I mean, this is It's absolutely untenable. And I think what's going to happen for us here in PGCPS This has wiped out this has the risk of wiping

011out are the hard work we've done around equity And that there's going to be the equal equity Debates again which schools have the funding which students, because we're going to be under this tremendous financial strain. And I don't think any of us want to lower the expectations. I think many of us believe in the five pillars and how they work together. But it is untenable to think that we can do these five pillars with a billion less dollars over the next eight years. So I just want to make sure that we're mindful of that we're being set up to be fighting internally again in what we've worked so hard to stop doing so Those are my big concerns. And just… Appreciate you. I want to allow Chief Howe to give some final remarks so that

012she can get out. So do you want to offer some final remarks so that we can get you To your next space. Thank you. Yeah, I appreciate that. I think… One of the challenges with the implementation of the blueprint goes to her point of having equitable funding at all of our schools. And it is an implementation, so it's not expected to happen In year one, and right now the policy allows for us to be able to ramp into this process where we're getting our schools at that 75% minimum threshold. You now you know do a haircut in that funding it makes that reallocation exercise that much more complicated to ensure the funds are being equitably distributed amongst all of our schools. So it's one thing if we were already there, but we're barely in year

013two of being able to begin to phase this into practice. And so now it just puts all of that in question about how do you do that With fidelity to ensure that you're still on track to meet that minimum 75% threshold within the next two years. So a lot of challenges to come. We have a lot of fixed costs that's tied to this change here, right? We are, as all districts are we have our labor partners we have negotiated agreements which have been settled or in the process of being negotiated based off of what we understood was outlined in the legislation. To make this kind of a change is going to have a fundamental impact on the structure of our budget for the district, not just for this year, but for several years to come.

014Well, Chief Howe, we appreciate your labor. We know this work isn't easy in turbulent times, but we appreciate you offering your expertise. And I know my colleagues will reach out if they have more defined questions, but we appreciate you leaving your meeting and coming to this one. To make sure the general public can understand the financial impact But I don't think we have anything else for you and you have to go. So thank you so much and have a good day. Thank you. You too. At this time, we'll bring our forever board member, Dr. Alvin Thornton, who is no stranger to this board, no stranger to our community. Who has been a long fighter. Board Member Walker, did you have something Okay. But at this time, I want to make sure you have the time

015and space to present and offer testimony for us. We just thank you for agreeing to this call. Board member Bruiser Struther was like, we can't do this without Dr. Thornton. We're excited to have you here today. So the floor is now yours. I want to thank you and your colleagues for allowing me to join you in this space, a space that I've served in for many years. So I want to thank you all. You know, this is very important to me. I call it the three Bs that we're dealing with. I was so happy to be able to hear so Ms. Walsh and uh chief Chief, what did I get wrong? Chief Howell's testimony because they really gave you the great details of what you all are facing. But equally important is the context. Because

016you're speaking to the people of Prince George's County. We have to do two things. We have to get into the minutiae the details and the operational stuff that you all have to deal with. But we also have to empower the people to understand the context of what they're dealing with. And hopefully the people will then speak to their legislative and senatorial leaders and the governor about the moment that we are in. And old heads like me, they need to share, right? I was listening to the discussion about the foundation amount, right? That's a very important concept that was stood up in the history of Maryland public education. And anything that destabilizes it, right, undermines it for whatever reason, a momentary budget crisis or whatever. Needs to be done with great care. Before 1999, There was

017no foundation concept in Maryland public education, right? This concept which says that in order to pursue the obligations of Article 8 of our Constitution that every student needed a foundation amount. That's a very recent concept, which we shouldn't play around with and we shouldn't easily allow it to be deconstruct it because of a momentary budget crisis, which must be dealt with. So people will reduce it by $160 and just say we'll reduce it, right? No, it took decades to come to the notion that every child Notwithstanding their proximity to wealth Notwithstanding the proximity to valuable property and income of home, notwithstanding the county in which they live. Need a foundation amount. That came out of the Bridge to Excellence concept. Because before that, you just had the politics of the politics who's most powerful? And

018what county is most powerful and what county has the most senators or the most delegates Before that, you had 50 different buckets into which we dumped education money for our children. There was no such concept as a foundation of us. So let's to the people and to you all Let's be very protective of the foundation concept. The foundation concept said that this is what you need to adequately and equitably fund the education of our children. No matter the county in which they live, because Article 8 does not speak to a county. It doesn't speak to a city it speaks to children. So I'm most protective of this notion of the foundation amount. We clearly, this is politics, we all understand that. And as I always say, when I go to Annapolis to the legislators and

019now to the governor. Make the right decision and the people will have your back. And the right decision is to make sure that our children's education is adequately and equitably funded In order to achieve the high, nationally high performance expectations that we have of them. Those decisions are very difficult. But we know the equalizing results of excellent education. We know what happens when we don't adequately fund it. So make the right political decision. Sometimes we have to march to keep the promise, as you know, right? When we did Thornton. Which we call bridge to excellence. We went through exactly what you all are going through now. There's nothing new about this. People don't do right necessarily unless they have the support of the public, informed public. We did Bridge Excellence where we create the foundation

020amount create the compensatory categories from poverty to limiting English proficiency in special aid. Those were all new concepts. We didn't even have classifications when we felt an obligation to educate our children as they presented themselves to us in different categories. We've stood that up and I'm asking this community, the board, the people, the politicians, let's protect that. The biggest mistake we can make is to deconstruct the blueprint framework structure uh and it's Because statutory connection to the Constitution requirement for our children in pursuit of meeting a budget crisis. That budget crisis is there my own personal view. Is that we can do more to have fair share In terms of funding public education, we are not doing what we should do in terms of taxing those who have and corporate responsibility and wealthy people's responsibilities.

021That's a whole other discussion. I'll leave that there, right? But we're not doing And that's soaking down into our school systems. And so we must deal with that. I saw what happens when you saw what happens properly fund public education. We saw it. We had in 2002, when we did the Bridge to Excellence. And Marilyn went to nationally high number one rankings and we were celebrated in all national publications as a model. It was a very revolutionary thing. And after we backed off of that in the same way that I'm seeing signs of now, right? We backed away from that. And then we went back to what we were doing prior to the bridge to excellence. Segmenting ourselves into Eastern Shore counties, into counties that are more Republican. Into counties that are less diverse And

022you know what happens when that happens. It happens what you're seeing right now. And that is a situation that we did not recover from. The blueprint allowed us to recover from that. Several years of intense development of a consensus around what's required to educate our children. The blueprint needs to be protected as a result of that. You don't easily create consensus around the education of children that cuts across geography, race, and class. That is a very difficult thing to develop. Once you get it. Let's be protective of it. Now, I do not think personally that we should allow politicians, elected officials have operational responsibilities you all do. Less so because you are on raising the money. So you have no power to raise a dime. But others have a responsibility to not deconstruct a consensus

023once you get it. So once we got that blue blueprint consensus, and it was a fight, as you know Those who opposed it before it was passed are now coming out of the gate to oppose it again. For the reasons that have nothing to do with a budget crisis. They do not believe in the equalizing dimension of the blueprint. They don't believe in its premise. They don't believe in its central role in meeting Article 8 obligations of our state. And they are out in gangbusters. We should do nothing to empower That initiative that is coming after us. I do believe, and I'll be quiet, that we need to in terms of advocacy, the fair share of proposals that are coming forward. We need new revenue. Locally, we need to look at ourselves. This is heavy

024politics I'm saying now. We need to look at ourselves locally and see what we're doing locally. To not properly provide the resources for our children. We have accepted the premise that we are doing all that we can do to provide the resources for our children. That is not true. Some of us can do more. And we're not doing it. I know that's difficult, especially for those who are running for office, right? But there's some of us In terms of the local share, because part of what you are describing is going to do what? It's going to revolve down to what Prince George's County can't afford. We have, ever since 1978, we have started to disinvest in the education of our children's education. And it's a structural issue now. It's a mindset issue now. It's a

025part of our politics. We just accept it. And so people like me who can do more I'm an example of who can do more. People like me are not doing more. We're running away from our obligation. The first thing that people said to me when the government created the Bridge to Excellence Commission But they said to me, Dr. Thornton, why are you sitting here asking me for more resources when you won't provide it yourself? That's what they said to me. And that's what people are going to say to us Now, as we try to provide resources for the blueprint, which is going to require us standing up giving our share of what we should to our children Of making sure that the 65 or so of children that are low income. And we only have

026maybe 25% or so of homes that have children in our public schools that we can stop the stampede away from public education Which is what is happening And so when we try to get the politics from statewide senators and delegates. Do not allow the blueprint to be deconstructed, underfunded. There's less power to do that because the whole concept of the equalization of public education and our obligation to fund it has in fact been deconstructed. We did it before, my colleagues. We will do it again. When Thornton dropped in 1999 in December, we had a $400 million deficit and people were going to use it as an excuse. We have strong legislators who stood up and funded it. They stood up. Nothing different. And then when people wanted to severely cut the bridge to excellence program,

027the people came together. Went to Annapolis and said, do not. They cut it somewhat right But they didn't cut it to the level that I'm seeing proposed here. We must not allow this to happen. And for those who want to use public education as a political Statement, the best political statement they can make is to do what? Is to fund the blueprint adequately and use it as a national model. Of what we do for our children. Thank you so much, Dr. Thornton, for your deep reflections and your testimony. I want to extend it to my colleagues to Ask follow-up questions or use the balance of their time. I think we have time for at least two rounds of questions. If not another round, but I know we do have time for two rounds. So I'll

028start with whichever my colleagues want to go first. I'll actually start with a question. One of my parents actually wanted to know the true impact of there's a message out there that we're cutting taxes, Dr. Thornton. And we're raising taxes on the wealthy. But it doesn't seem to be translating to our kids, which is one of our most precious commodities. How do we talk to parents about this language, this political rhetoric that's out there? That we're lowering taxes, but at the same time, we're decreasing the revenue that you get to your schools. Parents are really contending with that. They're hearing this notion that Oh, my taxes might be lower for at least 35% of Marylanders, 85%, there won't be any change. I got that question. How do parents grapple with that? Or what would you

029say to them as that rhetoric has been… The most hurtful thing for me as a 50 some odd year resident of this county is how the people of Prince Charles County has been played with when it comes to the question of taxation. And the end result of it is the unwillingness to fund the public sector. Whether it's health care, whether it's police, but primarily schools. And so we give the impression that we are spending all this money on public education. In 1978, the people of Prince George's County, which was not diverse at that time, decided that they were not going to fund the public sector. They made that decision. The school system was not 95% non-white as it is now. It was not Latino Latina and it was not black. And it was not low

030income. And they made that decision by passing a law was insulated wealth from the public sector. This is after the Brown versus Board of Education decision in 54 and then the 1972 decision was ordered, the desegregation of public schools people said that the population was going to disperse away from Prince George's County. It was going to become more diverse and the public sector would not be funded. It's called trim the average person who comes to you all about public education, they don't know anything about TRM. They don't know the history. What they know is their taxes are too high in their mind, right? They don't know how this thing of no building schools after 78 for 20 years, not one school being built. Results in your schools being an average age of 50 or so

031years, right? That it doesn't change into the federal government and I was sitting right there with Judge Massetti in greenbelt where it said that you all are not willing to fund your schools because you got trim You've tried to change it politically. No one will change it. Why? Because students don't vote. And most of the homes from which they come, the parents don't vote. They don't vote, so you don't have to deal with that, okay? I will make you do it as a result of if you want to end busing, I'll make you do it. You will build schools. This is where WISE comes from. This is where flowers comes from. This is coral rice. It wasn't the politics that did that. It was the advocacy of the parents right And then when we got

032the bridge to excellence, which is where the concept of foundation comes from. Which is where the special categories that we talked about, poverty, limited English proficiency, all that came from, that came from litigation. The Bradford cases of Baltimore. And it came into Prince George's County. The governor looked up who was Paris Glenn Denning and said, look, if I don't do something. The federal courts are going to do exactly to me what was done to what? To Prince George's in 1998 when we had the settlement of the case. So you always have to have this pressure. And now we're at a point where the people are feeling rightfully so. That they're being overtaxed One of the reasons they're being overtaxed is because those who should be paying or not paying. So everything rolls downhill okay Brooke,

033I left the Board of Education just to personalize it for a minute. I left the Board of Education. In 1999, December. And I left the board after serving chair for three terms because I knew that as long as there was what I call a creating of education within municipalities or what we call counties. And you would put babies in counties because the Constitution of Maryland does not mention counties. You won't find counties, the name of counties in the Constitution of Maryland. You find counties in what? In the statute. The General Assembly creates counties. And what we did was we said we're going to put babies in counties White folk in Somerset and Allegheny, black folk in Baltimore and Prince George's. We're going to create different economic groupings, and then we're going to allow education to

034be funded As an extension of what? The economic realities of those communities That's what you're dealing with. Now, what I said was that's not going to work, especially for Prince George's County. Because it's becoming what? Less diverse, lower income, and the trim phenomenon had just grabbed us by the neck. We couldn't spend virtually anything to support our children. And I said, we need a state solution. That's when I resigned from the board and went to the state and chaired that commission. The first thing the commission said was that what you must attach Performance expectations that you have for the children Which is some of the highest in the nation. That's the first thing you got to realize. What you're chasing after some of the highest, it's not like Mississippi, Alabama, whatever, Texas or Florida. This

035is Maryland, some of the highest in the nation. You must attach those performance expectations to what? Resourcing that is equally statutorily based. See, there was nothing spectacularly based about resourcing. It was about politics. You go to Annapolis, you have 50 buckets. And the most powerful people would do what? Pull out the bucket and send it back and then come back and brag about how much money. It had nothing to do with performance statutory connectivity. Now the bridge did it and the blueprint doesn't. So when you begin to pull back. Money for community schools a teacher or a teacher Training, professional development i call it When you begin to pull that money back, the next question you have to ask is how does that Relate to what? The performance possibility or the performance that you have.

036You can't change one without the other. And if you do, it's not political, it's morally wrong, politically unwise. It makes no sense in terms of education. If you change one If you reduce the funding in the way that we're talking about, you must change the performance expectation. That's what you must tell the people of Maryland. And if you don't do that, which is what you all have to be careful about. Because people will say, oh, I can reduce the money in the way that's been described by your colleagues. But I don't have to adjust to the performance expectation. Why? Because you don't really need that money. It's just waste. They've just been wasting it. Than near in the first place, right? That's what you have to not allow to happen. Because nobody wins that kind

037of narrative. That kind of waste and mismanagement, and that's the reason it is not the budget cuts Stay away from that. Nobody wins. That's a losing battle for everybody. Politicians as well as the board and our children. Thank you again for answering my question. And, you know, one of the things I really appreciated your explanation around And do any of my colleagues have any questions? I want to make sure I make space for you all. Or I remember booze or Struthers. Yeah, thank you so much. And thank you, Dr. Thornton for You know, for… giving us the history and history repeating itself in these moments, we find ourselves in again The one issue that when it comes to talking to constituents, whether they have their parents or otherwise is this Issue of funding adequacy. And

038I mean, you definitely have touched on it around like disinvestment in the purpose of the Thornton Commission and currency But there's a piece of it that I find has been difficult to convey that PGCPS has never been a funding adequacy because of the state and county Sources. Those are the sources and then some federal that we as a board cannot make taxing decisions to get to that adequacy. And once the budgets are determined for this board it becomes… you know this limited pie issue that we continue to have every issue. So I was wondering if you could discuss just a little more in depth what those moments in time since the 70s meant when money flowed to Howard County and Montgomery County and how those districts have just never understood. This funding issue. This under-resourced

039issue. Well, we… Because I find myself fighting this all the time that that this is a reality, that we, just like school construction that we're digging out of a deficit. It also plays out in the actual Yes, we made a fundamental mistake in the state of Maryland in 1983. When we said that wealth different differences In terms of providing students education is not a suspect classification. Which can be adjudicated in court. Now, that's a very important principle. We have tried to politically deal with because deal understand what that means right That means that you're going to have lower income white children in Somerset County And lower income white children in Allegheny County And as a function of the homes in which they live and the communities, the value of the property around their homes. They

040can receive constitutionally acceptable what? Less money to educate their children. Now, anytime you adjust the foundation amount which is the amount that all children get no matter what county they live in you back into that conundrum I just described to you. Nobody wants that. We're one maryland You do not want that, what I call Somerset versus hornback, that's the case. You don't want that principle to take root in our state. And if somehow the taxpayers and the people that you represent I suppose it's rather, we must educate them about that principle because that's what we're playing with when we begin to unravel the foundation amount And we begin to disassociate adequacy The concept of adequacy is not just something a board member comes up with adequate funding. No, it is a researched, documented, statistically based

041determination of what it requires children to have in order to be in order educated at the level that we expect of them. It is not just a political kind of statement, right? Now, the moment that we begin to begin distance ourselves from a definition of adequacy which we studied it. Avin Blake. Did it for us and did it for the blueprint. Over several years, and we come up with a definition of adequacy. And then we attach money amount to that. Any dollar that you move away, whether it's $163 or whatever. You're beginning to do what? Unravel that nexus and you begin to hurt children. And I always say that when you do that, that is morally, politically, economically and politically unwise to do that. We must find a way to educate the public as to

042what we're saying. Because if you don't, the public will easily say what? Especially a public that does not have children mostly in the public schools. Most people don't realize that, right? You know that. Many people are like me. Old heads with no children in schools. I got concerns. I can talk about you all right i can write emails about you. I don't have one child. I have four grandchildren in the schools. Public schools educated my children well, but most homes are like mine. Right? I just want to appreciate your… your reflections there as well. You talked a lot about education. So I'm going to recognize Board Member Walker, who's always going to talk about educate, advocate and act together. So… You already knew. Listen, I already wrote my little question over here. I'm ready. I'm

043ready. Thank you so much, Dr. Thornton. I sincerely, sincerely appreciate you bringing the perspective. So, you know, we have been talking narratives as a board and how we exactly what Dr. Felton already said, how we educate, advocate, and act together. So how we educate ourselves, which is what we're doing right now with new information, our constituents, our legislators. How we then engage our parents and our constituents to advocate, right? This is the time And then how we act together. And so my question is. Can you just arm us with three things that you would say to our Board of Education as strategies on how to engage based on what you know, based on what you've done. You've talked to us about this bold leadership. That you had at the time and how you were able

044to get some things moving. So we have a number of members that are new. We have a mix between parents and professionals. And so now is the time. We've done a great job at really working with our legislators and creating these amazing partnerships. And so this Educate, Advocate Act is big and bold right now. This is the time. And we want to do that. So please help me with, you know, what are three strategies that you can think of that are actionable that you would say, you know what, Board of Education, based on what I hear and based on what I know, this is what boldness looks like and this is some recommendations I would have for you guys consideration. Well, one of the bold things, my dear colleague, is what I'm seeing here today

045and what I see the board doing. And that is to be what I'm seeing, which is a collaborative working together advocacy group on behalf of the children. The face of what we want to happen in terms of our children. So I want to thank you all for that. That is critically important because one of the ways one of the best ways to undermine funding for public education is the question those to whom the funding is given. That's the easiest way to do that. So the first thing is to not let that happen. The collegiality, the working together, the advocacy, collaborative advocacy is absolutely indispensable. So please continue to do that. The other way is to claim This will be difficult to do because it requires education. Playing the criticality, the importance of What we are

046as Prince George's County See, the notion of equity The notion of adequacy comes from press georges. To some extent, Baltimore City. So don't give that away. Even in the midst of cuts and all these kinds of things. That's why I call it the three b's. The brown concept of equal education for children notwithstanding race, the bridge to excellence concept right statutory connectivity to performance expectations and resourcing. Claim that historical space as you do your narration right And make sure people know that there is no shortcut to the economic future that we want for our state that does not go through public education. And then even though there may be auxiliary educational opportunities for our children. The core must be public education. Because one of the strains that you all see being pulled away from you

047all is what? Private options and vouchers and other kinds of things. I call it middle class frustration. That's what that is, right? And it is something that will take root and it took root starting in the 1990s in Prince George's County. We must pull it back. And say, even though those auxiliary options that the parents may exercise, they should not supplement the absolute core, which is public education. Because everything, residential housing value, commercial business development, perception of our place in the DMV, all of that centers around what? Public education, right? So we need that narrative. The friends that I talk to who have no kids in the schools, they have a negative. Many of them have a negative narrative. We must change that. And then we must do this. We must say that it is

048At the end of the day. It is unwise. To not do right by children. Because and that means funding their education adequately and supporting them. Because you have no constitutional right to not do that. Do you understand what I'm saying to you? That's Bradford. That's Vons. That's people like us who say. Just because politically you can do that, which means underfunding public education. You have no right to do it and you will not be allowed to do it. You know what that means, right? That we will not allow the state as we did not do in 1998. And Vons did not do it in 1972. And Thurgood did not do it in 1954. We will not allow the requirements of Article 8 to be politically undermined. I don't think anybody wants that to happen. You

049understand what I'm saying? I don't think anybody wants Article 8 to be undermined just because people are not willing to share resources with children. But people will do that. So that third thing is to do what? Those are the marches in Annapolis. The blueprint day in Annapolis type stuff that I'm talking about right where people look out of their offices and they say thousands of people. We didn't just get the bridge because people wanted it. They looked out of their offices and they saw Thousands of people saying what? We have your back. Next time you come up for election, we have your back. Here we are. This is, if you do right and fund the bridge, then now fund the blueprint. Do the fair share, we have your back. If you don't do that. Then

050you will have what you will have Just pray that will not happen. And that is that you will have people pulling back from the promise of the blueprint. And not funding children's education and then narrating a negative narrative about public education and blaming people like yourselves. Thank you. Can I just recap what I think I heard for the bullets Okay, I can come back on the second round. I have no problem doing it. Go ahead, go, Barbara. Okay, just real quick. This is what I got. So thank you very much. That's good because I can feel your passion where we are. I wrote down Continue our focus of educate, advocate, act together because we're already on the right path of what it is we're doing. I heard collaboration. I heard unity. I heard bringing a

051message. The second really was owning our narrative by changing our narrative. And really talking about not only our vision, but why is public education and PGCPS the best education. I'm summarizing. This is what I Why? But that story. And so we've been talking about owning this narrative and what it looks like, but really pushing out why PGCPS public education, why this public education is the best education, especially with everything going on. And then your last point on this notion of being unwise to unfund and underfund. Where we are and what that means, not only from the historical framework, but really from historical to where we are in framing that to these marches on Annapolis or the work that we're doing, but really being very clear and helping people understand what it really means It's kind

052of like the questions we were asking to Ms. Howell, for instance. Those type of questions. What does it really mean to our scholars so that we can continue to educate? That's what I took away for the three. And that's what I'm rolling with. Okay, thanks. Very good. Very good. Well, it doesn't appear that any of my colleagues have more questions. Board member Briggs, well, Vice Chair Briggs, who is vice chair of our committee at large and also vice chair of the board, I want to make sure we make There you go. Yeah, yeah. I don't have a comment. I don't want to leave without just saying thank you for offering the just, I think every time I've spoken to you, it's been a wealth of knowledge. And I think it's integral to us moving forward.

053We have to know where we started. And where we've been to know where we're headed and how to get there. And so I feel like this is really helpful because this offers some of that roadmap. And then hopefully some of those relationships that could really help to kind of cushion any blows that may be coming anyone's way. And I don't think that'll be the case, but I just want to make sure that we have your partnership and those things. I want to say thank you. For your time. Thank you. Thank you. Board member Boozer Struthers. Yeah, thank you so much. So Dr. Thornton. You know when when we were together when you were chair of this board and the work we did in 2019 and 2020, you were always very clear of your message to

054the delegates and senators of The Prince George's the county delegation and your expectations of of how you would see them in this fight for our children. And if I were sitting there and seeing that there's a billion dollars being proposed to withdraw from… from the school system I certainly would be… in the fight. So I'm wondering, you know, what you would say If you had the delegation of the House and senators right here. What would be your message to them in this moment? You've always had exemplar warriors who stood in the breach. And defended public education. And when they did that, their colleagues were empowered by that. In my day, it was people like Senator Barbara Hoffman and people like him. Who else? Barbara Hoffman comes to mind. Pete Rawlings comes to mind. People who

055stood in the breach you know and did what was right. And then their college rallied around them. So I would ask members of our Senate delegation and I would ask the delegates and other local colleagues use those models and stand in the breach. History will treat you well. When you do that, when you say, hey, this is what we should do. There must be someone who leads, gives voice, be the vanguard. Because public education is all over the place is being attacked nationally and And there's an organized effort to just what? Destroy, basically. That's the other thing we haven't realized. It's an organized effort to destroy it. The Department of Education, public education itself Because people don't believe in it. And then so it's easy for local politics or state politics to simply ride on

056that bandwagon without knowing. So I would ask elected officials to at least some of them to become aggressive advocates around the narrative that we've been talking about today. Our fair share of resourcing for our children, maintaining the integrity of the blueprint and its funding adequacy, et cetera. And get to doing the hard work as to do what? As to how you're going to raise the resources to make sure it's fully funded. Well, thank you so much, Dr. Thornton. And I can't thank you enough. I echo the same sentiments that Board Member Briggs shared with you. I will never forget my false proclivity to believe that 62% of this county's budget actually goes to public education and your deconstruction of that Which just shifted my accepted wisdom on the reality of funding in our county. And

057so as much as much as… Listen. Yeah, I missed the tune. I'm sorry to cut you off, but I'm i'm I'm glad you have… and your colleagues, we need to get that word out. And when you explained it to me, it just changed my accepted wisdom of so much. And so anytime I get to talk to somebody and someone says it. I try to stop them. So I appreciate you being here to continue to educate the general population about this work. And we'll certainly continue to engage with you moving forward. Again, we just can't thank you enough. Thank you. For your work. I know Board Member Briggs, Board Member Boozer were able to give you their thank yous. Board Member Walker, if you want to say something, I want to make sure I extend the

058same Grace to you. Oh, yes. I've thanked you a million times on here. I did it twice. I've talked about four times every single time. There was a thank you right at the front. But Dr. Thornton. Every time I see you, it's always a pleasure. When we're out in the community, you know, you always, as everyone else said, brings a great perspective. And so we're excited to be able to have you here. And thank you so much. And I'm sure my colleagues We'll be reaching out for sure as we continue on our journey to educate, advocate, act together. I'm going to get a tattoo. And I'm always available to support our public school system and our children. The school system did so well by my two daughters. So I know what can happen. The graduates

059of Central High School. They receive an excellent education there. My three grandchildren are in the public school system. And so that's what drives me because I know what public education can do and is doing for our children. Thank you so much, Ms. Welsh. Do you have anything else on this particular item? If not, we're going to adjourn. Thank you all. No, I don't. But to say that it was very interesting to listen to Dr. Thornton, and I appreciate listening to the history. It was very informative for me. So thank you very much. And I absolutely agree. People say to me, why do you always keep working for public education? I can't think of anything that is more important than public education. It's just so important for us so Thank you very much. Well, the chair

060would like to remind the public that the next virtual policy and governance committee meeting will be on February 25th. 2024, please continue to check the Prince George's County Board of Education website for meeting information and updates. Thank you all for the great discussion and your attendance today. To our viewers, thank you for watching. There being no further business. The time is now 324. And the February 6, 2025 Special Policy and Governance Committee meeting is officially adjourned. Thank you and have a great day. Thank you.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.