001the time is now 7:03 good evening and welcome to the January 16 2025 Prince George's County Board of Education meeting and welcome to 2025 I am Brandon Jackson chairman of the Prince George's County Board of Education to hear the meeting interpreted live in Spanish please call 508 924 5155 again the number to call is 508 55 please Focus your attention on the screen to hear the announcements in Spanish for those who are unable to observe now the meeting is being recorded and can be accessed on the PGCPS YouTube channel for later viewing lastly for recording purposes the chairman reminds all board members to ensure their microphones are turned on when speaking board member Robert Brown please lead us in board prayer thank you chair Jackson here's the school board prayer oh God we pray to
002administer that which is just in all educational policies being ever mindful of your guidance steer us to action with love wisdom and understanding amen amen please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance Miss Barton please call the r good evening everyone Dr anderol present Miss booer strether present Mr Briggs present Miss Brown present Mrs Goen MCC present Mr jongo present Dr Moss present Miss Walker present Mr Jackson here we have nine present thank you aarum is present if there is no objection the January 16th meeting agenda will be adopted as amend there being no objection the January 16th 2025 meeting agenda is adopted as amended moving to item 8.0 are there any corrections to the December 2nd 2024 annual meeting of the Board of Education December 5th 2024 second session of the December 2nd 2024 annual
003meeting of the Board of Education meeting minutes and December 5th 5th 2024 border of Business board business meeting minutes there being no Corrections the December 2nd 2024 annual meeting of the board Education meeting December 5th 2024 second session of the December 2nd 2024 annual meetings of the Board of Education meeting minutes and December 5th 2024 board business meetings are approved let's pause for a PGCPS uh Spotlight the chairman recognizes the superintendent house for the PGCPS Spotlight thank you Mr chair and uh Happy New Year to to everyone out there uh i' really I'm extremely extremely excited tonight uh to really share uh with our PGCPS community and family an update from the CTE department on the 47th student-built home I've actually had an opportunity to to get by that home on a couple of occasions
004and see our students in action over the course of the last four months so I think you'll enjoy this thoroughly when they first come though they're stressed out they're not they're nervous and but by like I said third fourth trip yeah they get off the bus what's today we give them and way they go uh the student student built house is as an opportunity for a number of our CTE students in the prince Georgia County to to really have have the being there experience really digging in with developers construction workers uh their CTE instructors to understand what it is from start to finish to build in a uh very high-end Community uh to make a difference you can teach me you can you can show me all the diagrams which is helpful but I learn
005the best when I do it myself and that's how I learn and master whatever craft i'm doing just knowing that we're building this house for a family and putting on the market is amazing you see the kids change like drastic and it and instead of them being overwhelmed with have to build a whole house we just tell them just you know we do this today this the next day and eventually every time you come out you'll see everything starts to come together so it takes a stress off the kids why do I do this this a great job I have the greatest teaching job there is you know I get to be on site every day uh teach kids how to pound nails teach kids how to put Plumbing in the walls teach them how
006to do electrical circuits uh and it's a really great job I mean it's a it's a dream job for me uh this is a real house that will be sold and real people will be moving in so it has to be up to code and you know we always say that you know you can put our houses up against any of the other houses down the street here and ours is buil better when the when the kids first start coming out they're kind of intimidated they're kind of like afraid to use some of the tools especially the nail guns in the big saws until we go through it with them a couple times by their third or fourth trip they're fighting over the nail guns they're fighting over who gets a run the saw just
007because they're in a carpentry class doesn't mean they have to be Carpenters they could be interior trimmers they could be drywall guys they could be painters there's a lot of different things that they get to see they don't get to see that in the classroom the students are here and they're asking questions and they may find out that they don't want to do HVAC but they might want to do a different phase of this house that we build and you know they're learning from their experience and it's great to see that every year that we do it thank you superintendent house and the communications team for the presentation now we're moving on to item 10.1 report of the chair welcome to 2025 we hope you all had a restful winter break break and are ready
008to push ahead in this new year the New Year is a time of Hope renewal and opportunity it's a chance to set new goals and embrace growth let's make this year a canvas of vibrant possibilities painted with resilience kindness and determination together we can make this year extraordinary supporting one another striving for excellence and cherishing the moments that truly matter let's welcome the new year with joy success and boundless potential at the last business meeting the board voted to undergo a pilot program to have the next three meetings at the County Council building this has been referred to the staff for investigation and what I've been told uh by our executive director that they have been approved so next month's uh Board of Education meeting will be held at um the Wayne Curry building in
009Largo Maryland as you know we we have uh several new board members also um so consequently the chairman uh must appoint new committee chairs and um committee chairs and here are the committee uh assignments for the academic achievement um the new chair is our student board member Jamal Jango let's give him a round of applause to stepping up stepping up um so Al on that assignment we have Lolita E Walker uh Dr Tiffany anderl zaka go mckin and Brandon Jackson um so congratulations to everybody who's been appointed to the academic achievement um committee um next we also have uh the board audit committee uh it will be led by Dr Tiffany anderl Pamela Boo struther as Vice chair uh Robin Brown Jamal jongo and Brandon Jackson the OB bafa committee will be chaired by Zakia
010Goen mckc Robin Brown will be the vice chair Dr Felton moss and Jonathan PRS policy and governance will be policy and governance will be uh chaired by Dr Felton moss and the vice chair is Jonathan Briggs Lolita Walker and Pamela booer strs uh climate change action plan AOC committee uh will be chaired by Pamela booer strs uh p C board liaison will be um Lolita E Walker and the disability issue Advisory Board will be uh the board of liazon will be Robin Brown so at this time let's give a round of applause for the new committee assignments looking looking forward to everyone's leadership at this time I would like to call for a moment of silence as we honor the memory of the following PGCPS staff family and community members David Romero Carpenter Building Services
011Erica Romero banila student at bellsville Academy kln Ramirez student at Walen Woods Kyler Ferris student at Barberry Heights Elementary School Michael Clemens student non-traditional program South Jean elong lingu student non-traditional program South James Fitzgerald non-traditional program South K IA Gray Building supervisor Martin Elementary School Raina Corbin teacher at Pon Elementary School Steven Mitchell par professional Parkdale High School thank you moving on to announcements uh go ahead thank you I also also wanted to make mention I didn't hear her but uh another scholar um Ariana roses Sal um for her moment of silence as well thank you so much thank you for the addition we'll make sure to add her to the next next agenda as no problem and thank you the other thing I had a little earlier I apologize if we can double back
012on the chair's report whenever you get an opportunity I can do it at new business if you like I don't know when you want to to do it I just had a question around the um the movement to the Wayne Curry building okay um thank you yeah we can do it in new business thank you thank you all right I'll ask everyone to please uh Focus your attention on the screen to see the list of upcoming meetings over the next two months please note our next board business meeting is scheduled to occur February 27th 2025 at the Wayne Curry building all righty please continue to check the board web page for updates and more information next we'll be moving to uh public comment the chair recognizes the registered speakers registered speakers have 3 minutes to
013make their Pres presentation and may not relinquish any part of their speaking time the board will recognize your comments but will not address them speakers may not address individuals or issue issues with profanity or derogatory terms you'll be warned once if you continue your comments will be muted and you may be removed from the meeting speakers are encouraged to use titles rather than names for example chair board member superintendent principal Etc there are 15 live public commenters tonight our first speaker is Isaiah Smith second grade student Maya Angelou French ersion special education where hi my name is Isaiah Smith I am here to talk about being a student with special needs my mom asked me if I can pick any teacher in the whole world who can it be I told her someone who is
014nice and understands me I love learning new things and I try to be my friends in sports I like when my teachers help me understand new stuff it might take me a little longer to get my work done right but I try my best I like to ask a lot of questions sometimes I have challenging days or I have a hard time sitting still but not just doesn't mean that I don't want to learn one thing that helps me is when people take the time to just understand me I like to to be a leader like a team captain and I am very helpful connecting with people is really important because I think it helps us work together being different is okay everyone has something special about them if we can learn to understand each
015other and help each other out we can make our school a better place I hope that you can help make sure that every student like me gets a chance to feel understood and to learn in their own special way thank you for listening to me today I [Music] [Applause] am thank you and his mom Miss Teresa Smith I want to recognize you next thank thank you good evening everyone the meetings were perceived as hostile because the staff took offense to the questions that I asked instead of being taken as a tool to obtain Clarity I recall a meeting at the secondary level where I had just heard the word combata for the first time I couldn't even actively continue in a discussion because I tried to comprehend what was being said and whether it was
016a tactic used to deflect the issues being disc discussed if this wasn't bad enough there was a time when a staff member stood up exerting her voice to bully me while everyone sat there and watched this was a direct quote from my published piece of work I want to begin by acknowledging that this was an experience that predate both this board and this Administration for those familiar with the IEP process you know who the meeting participants were but do you know what I was up against one word can sum it up culture in an effort to improve the experience for all parents and students in special education I began advocating here in April 2024 in just nine months I am grateful to say that this Administration and the board members took immediate action I finally
017felt heard understood and like a true contributor contributor to shaping what families need from this system let's be clear changing a culture takes time but I believe in acknowledging both the effort and some of the initial outcomes earlier this week I had an IEP meeting and the team opened up the discussion by asking for my input rather than dictating the course of action following the meeting I received a call from the Family Support Center these small actions made me feel valued and that the team cared guess what this can change the entire tone of a parents experience I want to take this opportunity to thank you all thank you for not silencing my advocacy thank you for understanding the true intent of my efforts thank you for recognizing how advocacy can create positive change for
018over 16,000 students in their families and I thank you for allowing me to simply be a parent in the process there are times when I have to remind the schoolhouse about policies regulations and statues and why this may be necessary it sometimes overshadows the small winds that my child and others achieve I recognize that much work remains addressing the immediate issues was a strategic step and we've gained some traction families now feel empowered and confident that their voices matter I ask that we continue this collaborative approach and most importantly I ask that we continue to genuinely care about how our action shape the culture of PGCPS thank you so much Miss me uh before I call the next speaker uh I want to uh stop and make sure that we do proper protocol I think
019we have two elected officials in the audience today so I want to recognize former State Board member Clarence Crawford um as well as uh State's Attorney I is your Brave boy thank you so much and from our understanding that uh current current oh current board member excuse me and um States Attorney um from my understanding you want to speak we'll give the floor to you thank you thank you so thank you so much Mr chair and members of the Board of Education and of course members of Prince George's County Public School um I am so proud to be here as not just your State's Attorney but a proud graduate of the Prince George's County public school system and I want to thank the many superintendant and administrators and principles Vice principls and Educators and support
020staff who made my experience in Prince George's County Schools one that I will always remember and also help to prepare me uh to lead the criminal justice system here in our great County on December 31st uh of last year I sent a member a me sorry uh a letter to the board and I wanted to just read that letter for the record here today dear board members as you approached the 2025 bargaining agreement open discussions with the Prince George's County Educators Association I want to extend my sincerest wishes for Success there can be no more important negotiations than between Prince George's County public school's most critical Partners nor a more meaningful subject than our schools which county taxpayers fund at at 62% of the County's general fund budget I support and urge you to maximize
021transparency during these talks my experience is that transparency where possible cultivates trust between negotiating partners and amongst the important stakeholders we serve which are the parents and taxpayers of Prince George's County I can think of No Greater bargain than the one reached by the partners whose joint decisions establish the framework for success of the Prince geores County Public Schools My Hope Is that excuse me my hope is that the talks conclude with agreement that will be a source of Pride and satisfaction for the board and for pgcea in that both parties leave talks confident that a bargain has been struck that is also a road map to success for the prince Jorge's County public school system and for the students and families it serves again I wish you much success in everything you do and
022as always I look forward to partnering with you thank you and have a wonderful evening thank you the next speaker I'll call is uh Camila house from my Angelou French imersion PTSA good evening superintendent house um members of the board thank you for this opportunity to speak to you this evening um and the urgent need for the increase on behalf of uh Maya Angelo French imersion parents about the urgent need for increased Staffing training and support for special education students at Maya Angelou French immersion our school currently serves approximately 30 students with IEPs but we have only two special education teachers for the entire um School K through 8 this Staffing level is simply inadequate to provide the individualized support and interventions these student students are entitled to under the law under the individuals with
023disabilities Education Act idea teachers are mandated to implement IEPs and accommodations but many classroom teachers also lack the training and tools to do so effectively this leaves students with autism ADHD and related executive functioning difficulties as well as other learning challenges struggling to access the support they need and in an Environ M where they're also learning a second language for example students with executive dysfunction may appear disorganized or enable to complete tasks but these behaviors are direct results of their disabilities and require specific strategies to address them but if the teachers don't know they don't do it without proper training these teachers often misrepresent the needs or fail to provide adequate accommodations negatively impacting uh these students educational experience es this training issue also applies to 504 plans to address these challenges I ask uh
024the board the school system to re-evaluate the needs of Mya Angelo French immersion conduct a comprehens comprehensive assessment of the special education and 504 plan needs at Mafi including Staffing Resources and training gaps increase certified Staffing hire additional certified special education teachers and Pa professionals as needed to meet the needs of students with IEPs um and ensure proper implementation of accommodations uh regularly train classroom teachers and Par professionals to provide ongoing provide ongoing professional development for classroom teachers to recognize and address student um special with special needs particularly executive functioning difficulties and other learning and behavioral challenges and Implement IEP and and as well as 504 accommodations effectively strengthen accountability and ensure that both IEPs and 504 plans are consistently and effectively implemented through regular monitoring and oversight with additional resources training and support uh
025thank you thank you Miss house um next we have and and forgive me if I say your name pronounce your name WR joh johnia King individual special education you actually said it perfectly thank you I practice it a couple times before came back okay good wonderful good evening everyone um again my name is johnia king um I have two boys that 10 MPG CPS um they're a sevene spread so please pray for me um so I said one is in high school one is in elementary um my journey at PGCPS started when my oldest transitioned into the second grade he started off in private school from K3 through first grade however the difficulties that he had with executive functioning and um you know with learning in the manner in which he learns was a a
026struggle for him um we later found out that he was asd1 so autism spectrum um one um but was not aware of it at the time um we started off in second grade going into um Capital he Elementary he struggled there quite a bit um the principal I talked with the principal I asked for resources I didn't know the exact terminology to use um however I asked I said my child needs help I want him to be successful here and um so they said well we'll help you we'll give you the resources but didn't get the resources I didn't even get a meeting with the um staff until after the school year had ended and my son had already already had issues whereas um that was not his boundary school so the principal ended up
027signing you know that he needed to go to his boundary School in which I didn't want him to go because the school in which I placed him was the one that was a better fit for him educationally CU I didn't want him to fall short with um with that now moving forward I have my son that's now in elementary school meeting the same baras he is asd2 and however it's just a problem with getting IEP meetings they started getting a 504 plan but I suggested that he still needed the IEP in which there I met many barriers so I had to go through sending emails and you know to the board and everything just to get you know a meeting with the staff which I feel like it shouldn't be that I'm going above people's
028heads where I you should be able to talk with the staff there and be able to get the um resources that we need I ask for things like a dedicated aid for them because they were having issues with the executive function issues with um with um as far as I guess VI of environment social you know aspect you know things of that nature but they were learning they were doing well academically and they were still met with a no teachers basically were saying that they were overstretched the classrooms are overcrowded they weren't able to best Fe um meet the needs of the children and they trying their best with everyone but they have some children that fits in one barrier and another children that needs extra help so basically just been advocating for my children
029just to meet no to get nothing and the resources that I'm asking for I've been told a hard no and so I just wanted to you know impress on the board that we need a revision of the 504 plans of IEPs and the children with disabilities thank you thank you Miss King next speaker we have is uh Mr Timothy Meyer Mount rer elementary school PTO president fully funding the blueprint thank you very much and welcome back from spring break to everyone first sorry winter break uh first thank you to the superintendent and whole the whole PGCPS team for all your hard work getting our buildings ready for a safe return I emphasize safe because many of you have heard me say over and over every child has the right to get two in school from
030to and from school safely that certainly applies in snowstorms as well so thank you very much last week was a vivid reminder of how a school's impact goes far beyond the classroom for many families schools are the centers of our communities a critical source of food especially at our 100 plus Title One schools a source of belonging and friendship and mental health for us kids and let's be honest those hours at school each day are the structure helping so many parents do the work that provides for their families now think about the many vital roles that our schools play then look at the budget challenges we now face and some Anapolis politicians who are basically saying the blueprint is too hard so sorry but never mind if we don't fix our budget issues at both
031the county and state levels our schools won't suddenly close but make no mistake the impact will be felt a scaled back blueprint without full funding would make it even harder to retain teachers and staff it would put School construction CTE programs and wraparound Services especially for early childhood and special needs students at risk and take away critical extra funding for schools with the highest concentrations of poverty I have been a title one PTO leader title one schoolto leader for six years and I know that the blueprint is working remember we have the blueprint in the first place because our students faced a $7,800 adequacy funding Gap investing in Maryland students St is not a line item in a budget and the blueprint doesn't have an asterisk that we only support our students during a surplus
032it's a decades long commitment that here in Maryland education is the priority and it's a promise that we expect our elected officials to keep we've built parent coalitions before on pedestrian safety on climate change and so many other issues parents in this board must come together and we must work together speak as one PGCPS and make clear keeping the promise of the blueprint isn't negotiable it's expected and I ask pgca also to please use your voice and help make sure that full blueprint backing is a baseline requirement for your support for politicians a fully funded blueprint must be our joint priority and that campaign has to start right now thank you all very much thank you m thank you Mr Mar next is Michelle Clark individual bargaining let's go let's go good evening everyone I'm
033Michelle Clark I am a Early Childhood special educator at Kenmore Early Childhood Center and I came tonight to talk about the collective bargaining process and how it needs to stay transparent we have over the past asked two presidents starting with Teresa Dudley back in 2018 and three years ago under Dr Christie used an open bargaining process and one of the things that I personally did the last time actually the last two times around is invited members of the board to come out and watch the negotiations the school system represents you you're the ones who make the final decision and the best people to see what's going on are the people who have to make those decisions now I understand there may be some barriers but we need to work through them and we need to
034get to that point the issues that these parents have brought up about special education those are the types of issues that we can bring out in open bargaining by inviting parents and students to speak who knows better what's going on in our school system than the people who are in it it's very different being a p Sasser or in another administration building than it is being in a classroom I can tell you personally this is now the second day where my co- teer because of an emergency has been out and the PA professional my classroom has been out I have not had a fourth person we're supposed to have two PA of Professionals in a preko talk classroom for four years it's not a new problem it is a continuing issue with Staffing with case
035loads which I know can't be bargained but but it can be talked about and we need to realize that the reason why some of these students aren't getting what they need is because your educators are so dang stressed out that we can't provide what we need we can't emotionally give our students everything they need my students I tell my parents every year your babies are my babies and I'm going to treat them as such and I do I never knew there was such a thing as a prek autism classroom but somehow this year I seem to have one with students with more and more intense needs it's happening more it takes a lot you have to give a lot and if we at least had our extra person in our classroom it would help us
036a lot I understand what these parents say I see it every day I am at my Wit's End I was up all night last night doing reports and I can't do my work during the student day ever because of these conditions thank you thank you Miss Reed next public speaker we have is uh Mr Stanley Martin Athletics okay uh moving on to miss Phyllis Wright individual Safety and Security welcome back happy New Year everyone my name is Phyllis right to those who don't know me I'm here today because of two things you had a town hall meeting just yes day before yesterday and what we did not like was the calls was scream before the people was able to ask you a question so if I wanted to call in to make a comment to
037you I had to talk to someone else if they didn't like what I had to say they will move on to the next caller I I like if we have a town hall that each and every person wants to speak to whoever on the board or superintendent they're able to ask their own questions and not go through a third party um number one number two school safety you know I'm I'm big on school safety I have two beautiful daughters here Prince George's County Public School System my heart broke for that baby in batonic I work with chair Brandon on the school safety Pro um project where I went out there and I volunteered a lot of hours I volunteer a lot of hours in our school system we need more security we need teachers to
038be able to break up a fight but they said it's not in their contract they won't do that so if a child is being assaulted they just sit there and watch and won't have so we need to put that in place we need to have someone able to go in the restrooms or to monitor restroom on how many kids is going in the bathroom CU we know a lot of fights are happening in there as well um I volunteer at whim Hall and I volunteer at at um flowers flowers High School where's my daughter um we we need to have you guys got to do better we have to protect and secure our children when our parents are dropping our kids off to you all you all have to make sure that they're safe the
039baby that was attacked my heart goes out to her because that could have happened to my daughter we need to do better with security we need to make sure our children are safe when they walk on our property we need to do that we need to get more parents as well to volunteer I can't get find my app on my on my um my uh my phone it said it's not available so I know we just coming back from a new year so all this week I couldn't pull it up so maybe we can look into that as well but we have to do better we have to do better and the next town hall meeting that you have sir please let the people speak don't let them talk to someone else if they don't
040like what they have to say that they won't be able to speak to you I don't think it's fair to the public I think we all have a right every everybody in here have a right to speak and say whatever they need to say when it addressed to our children and to Prince George's County because everybody don't want to sit I don't have bad children I have very good girls and we need to recognize our good children as well as we recognize our bad children as well so we need to do that as well too so thank you all so much and have a nice year thank you thank you Miss Ray I want to recognize Miss Shannon Reed individual examining process to improve learning good evening I'm a teacher who has taught in PGCPS
041since 2001 and a parent whose youngest child is currently a senior in PGCPS the quality of Education my oldest child received from fourth to 12th grade in PGCPS was remark remarkably better than the education either of my younger children children receive from K to 12 and PGCPS it is my responsibility as a parent to know about my children's education and to engage my child teachers and the district in meaningful ways to improve the quality of that education children who have this level of support are more likely to become readers writers thinkers and creators I also think that this level of Parental engagement strengthens communities since Empower parents actively participating as responsible capable beings create a model that invites others to do so this is critically important for students whose disengagement may be a reflection of
042their parents' disengagement engaging parents in upcoming negotiations for teachers contract also allows parents to hear actual teachers speak about the reality of current education and consider how they might work better as parents and Advocates 5 years ago I could not imagine nor grasp the changes I now see in teaching and learning it is no wonder that people outside of the classroom cannot fathom the demands and the stress teachers have endured I do not believe most parents understand the level of teacher sacrifice because teachers voices have been significantly muted by fatigue practices and structures in in at least the Last 5 Years there has been one single in-person teacher Town Hall at that one where real teachers spoke clearly about real issues the district resorted after that one the district resorted to Virtual Town Halls where
043VI very few teachers spoke the teachers who speak often present trivial matters instead of speaking insightfully about the issues that have created a shortage of licensed teachers listening to these teachers it as if the 10 long years I spent in a high school dealing with nonsense did not exist however I know for sure that every single principal at that High School chased hordes of teachers out of the school during that long 10year stretch these principles demanded childlike Obedience of adult professionals instead of modeling respect as adult professionals my first year there was marked by shingles and my last year there was marked marked by foolishness in education as is often the case in life failure is often rooted in Dysfunctional social and environmental conditions the upcoming negotiations for a new teacher contract is an opportunity
044for teachers to speak to their professional and extended Community about things that M that can make education better retaining and attracting quality teachers in this new year with a new board and new possibility seems possible if PGCPS uses this opportunity to begin working with all the parts United to make the community better thank you for your time and [Music] attention thank you next speaker is Kyra Marshall Walker my Angelo French immersion PTSA agenda item pgca I thought that was her all righty um Annette Jones individual agenda item [Music] pgca good evening everyone I'm here to ask that PGCPS reconsider your decision to meet with pgca to facilitate an open bargain process this process creates a win-win for all both parties it builds trust which is needed in any negotiation please be reminded that in the
045last two negotiations were an open bargain negotiated strategy which was extremely successful for both parties pgca received critical Acclaim and was sought after for consultation to mirror the success and positivity that was displayed in the process this strategy Prides transparency in exercising a democratic process that is crucial for both parties such approach offers firsthand and personal stories which makes a difference to provide an ontime response on issues open bargaining allows each party to demonstrate fairness and reasonableness and allowing everyone to witness the negotiation this method will Elevate our leaders and reinforce the trust in both parties to arrive at amicable agreements open bargaining diffuses attempt and open to positive intent and honesty in processing of the negotiation please understand that it is an inclusive strategy that aims to problem solving collectively to meet the needs
046of both parties openly where respect and honesty are exercised openly what this does is to build relationships and ideal Partnerships for the good of the county I'm asking to consider open bargaining and urge all board members here who are knowledgeable of pgca priorities to encourage PCP PGCPS to open bargaining this to consider the strategy open bargaining offers a safe space to negotiate differences amicably and to reach the solutions that are purposeful and effective my voice is going traditionally open bargaining is a is redund traditional bargaining is redundant open bargaining now provides full disclosure and always allow everyone present to discuss explain offer accepted or rejected this strategy would be encouraging to Future hes and place our County in a positive direction of being transparent providing clear communication in the bargaining process and build and preserve
047workplace relationship this would certainly boost our retention deficit as I said before the days of negotiating behind closed doors finding the cultur of secrecy is over consider open bargaining [Music] [Applause] please thank you Dr Susan Windsor individual agenda item pgca greetings distinguished members of the board superintendent house esteemed colleagues and Superstar students parents and community members I am Dr Suzanne Windsor and at large director of pgca graduate of Gwen Park High School and pupil Personnel worker completed my 32nd year here in PGCPS speaking as an individual in support of open bargaining oh gorgeous Prince George's County we stand at the precipice of Uncertain political times with an incoming Administration that is hostile against both public education and labor unions our opponents stand at the ready to assail us on every side through a formal National
048agenda laid out against us in such writings as project 2025 but in the words of Nea president Becky Pringle when they go low we go loow because when we fight we win so we as a community must be on one Accord and walk lock step together against the swelling tide of misinformation and the censorship of Truth transparency builds trust and Trust flourishes into Unity through which we may continue to progress together this is why it's vital that we continue with open bargaining for the common good of all of our Educators students and the families we serve we cannot turn back now we cannot go back to dark private room deals that here clandestine and only benefit the employer we must continue to receive open input from staff students and parents as we are the actual
049experts and the educational and social emotional needs of those we have a duty to serve and represent why such a tax on education because as we know education is the great equalizer in preparing our students our babies to have a successful and fair chance at the future a free and appropriate public education provides the roots to the foundation on which the bricks of Civility culture and critical thinking are laid open bargain for the common good ties education with Community growth and financial success as we strive to not only educate our students but to uplift the whole of our people in our community so that our students may stem bud and Blossom into productive citizens that not only touch the state but touch the world illustrious board members I humbly be you to honor your constituents
050the Educators that are counting on you and our most precious resource our children we are depending on you to enact and uphold policies and procedures that keep the lines of communication open and transparent to ensure for a negotiation process that is beyond reproach please protect promote and support open bargaining so that we may continue to bargain for the common good of us all thank you thank you Mr Felix Lazaro individual agenda item pgca good evening esteem members of the Board of Education superintendent house PGCPS officials and staff my name is Felix Lazaro a special educator at C Elizabeth R Regional School and the product of alternative certification route via Notre Dame of Maryland University we have 154 students with profound or significant cognitive disabilities and the number is still increasing they function similar to two
051or three year olds although they are in the elementary levels middle schools or even high schools students start coming in at around 7:30 in the morning they eat breakfast after their book bags are hung up in the cabes communication journals are read for parent messages if there are any they need to be uploaded into the merland online under parent contacts and replied to immediately thereafter during winter the sweaters and jackets and all extra layers of clothes need to be taken off and hung in the cabbin as well all these layers must be put on when they go home exactly the same way they showed up in the morning otherwise I will get telephone calls from the parents during instruction the classroom teacher has to implement the whole group and the small group centers with the
052supplementary AIDS and accommodations contained in the IEPs of our students if the students IEP annual review takes place before November or December of the school year the IEP annual review will have to be scheduled again before the end of the current school [Music] year these are only a snapshot of what is done in the classroom every day members of the board I invite all of you to come to my school our superintendent has obliged so please do so and consider Open Door bargaining for negotiation by the way the title of my speech is CRI and Regional programs go for open bargaining thank you very much and maai thank you uh next uh Mr Brian Glover individual agenda item uh PGC good evening and protocol has already been established I am Brian Glover I'm speaking as
053individual pgca board member at large vocal music teacher at what the Barack Obama Elementary School Mr Ms hope to see you soon visit my school I want to address the importance of engaging in opening Barner with our Union first before I became any of the leadership I've observed open and bargaining and really enjoy just observing we couldn't comment we could watch and see to see the players fighting for my job our Scholars it's a it's a thrill it's really rewarding I had a lot that I was going to read and write but my colleagues already went over and I don't want to bore enough but I'm speaking from the heart and plus I'm excited my Scholars just we just did a concert at school for a Martin Lether King essay contest we need you we
054voted for you we marched for you we went door too to make sure you were here and we are thankful for each and every one of you everyone but we need this so we can feel as though our voice is always heard that we're not forgotten we love our Scholars I've been teaching 24 years 11 years back in Prince George's County and love being a vocal music teacher and the course director for my elementary Scholars we are mentors we are the leaders we help BR we help build their strength they come to us for the support think back of your vocal music teacher your dance teacher theater the Arts the things you weren't able to do in regular class you could do in a performing arts class we're counting on you we're glad you're here
055representing us do not forget us please do not forget we are all in this together yes this is 2520 2025 and happy New Year if I didn't say that I just wanted us to make sure I had the additional points just remember this and I'm not going to bore you this is my first time ever speaking at a school board as an educator and I'm thrown hon it to have that chance to do this but we are you we represent you in the Forefront with our parents and they see us first before they see you please remember us God bless and have a great successful school year and please be our team player with pgca and remember we're all here for our Scholars God bless everyone thank you Mr brother uh the next speaker is
056filamina oan sorry if I mispronounce your name uh I will tell you that my husband of 31 years will not be pleased and he's here somewhere today so it's a good evening everyone may I begin okay good good evening Mr chairman members of the board superintendent house Happy New Year to all of you my name is filamina oana I'm a 25-year veteran educator this evening I'm here to address the issue of open bargaining collective bargaining should be transparent inclusive and collaborative that has been said several times tonight but it Bears repeating to ensure that educators who are directly impacted by policy decisions voices are heard and are valued keep in mind that our working conditions are our students learning conditions our open bargaining is vital in a broader campaign to make changes we need in
057PGCPS PGCPS has real challenges ahead vacancies blueprint implementation that we have to continue to fight for ETC so a lack of of transparency during negotiations is not in our best interest Educators students families and community members must have a voice in addressing challenges in our schools we are all interest holders pgca and PGCPS have used open bargaining since 2018 that brought about many real changes that positively contributed to teacher retention that impacts student achievement every educator brings ideas and value to our profession because student needs vary you heard from Felix um you heard from our parents and by the way they are from my school those are my students I didn't know they were going to be here um but PGCPS needs to meet with pgcea in open sessions providing public disclosure of all our
058negotiated proposals and an opportunity for public comment I think Brian said it best when he spoke from the heart this is an opportunity for us to really collaborate all of you here we appreciate what you bring but we are on the Forefront every child is different and we are the ones who deal with these students we have to come up with all kinds of strategies we have to come up with different things and sometimes we don't have the resources but when we can come up here and tell you that what we need and you listen in collective bargaining that means a lot I remember standing in front of this board some time ago and talking about resources that we needed in restorative practices and other things and this very board telling us that it didn't
059have money to do so and now you see what it leads with discipline issues and several other things we need to collaborate so please consider open bargaining for all of us thank you thank you that concludes our uh public uh speakers for Theon night there is one written comment the written comment can be found on board dos it is as follows M Carwell individual special education has been uploaded to board dos when we receive no pre-recorded videos thank you for all the comments moving on to item 12.1 the chairman recognizes Dr Donna Christie for the pgca presentation thank you all right good evening thank you for allowing me the opportunity to present tonight I am Dr Donna Christie president of the Prince georgees County Educators Association representing your 10,000 professionally certified Educators and I'm here
060to discuss how open bargaining and bargaining for the common good have transformed negotiations in our district together these approaches ensure trust equity and collaboration in decisions that impact our students Educators and Community when we talk about bargaining we're talking about the future of our schools and our state's attorney used the word transparency I think you heard it from several other speakers as well transparent and Community centered approaches bring people together let our par they let parents Educators and community members see how decisions are made and ensure those decisions reflect shared priorities and transparency is not a luxury it's a necessity when decisions are made in secret rooms we risk losing the trust of the people we serve these principles are not just effective they're necessary to maintain the trust in our Public Schools so what
061is open bargaining open bargaining is about inviting everyone with an interest in our schools our Educators our school board members our parents and the Community into the process it allows them to witness negotiations firsthand removing any room for misconceptions or misinformation instead of hearing secondhand accounts they see the real issues being discussed and the challenges we face and the thoughtful rationale behind each position transparency strengthens trust what are you afraid of open bargaining shows that you have nothing to hide hide and everything to gain trust unity and solutions when interest holders observe the process they see the mutual commitment between the board the Educators and the community to work together and resolve challenges collaboratively open bargaining doesn't just address the what of negotiations it shows the why fostering understanding and Alignment across all parties bargaining
062for the common good goes beyond wages and benefits it's about addressing the issues that impact our students and families like housing and security mental health and Equitable school funding bargaining for the common good ensures that negotiations reflect the broader priorities of the community building schools that serve everyone equitably and these principles are not new to us since 2019 we've successfully used open bargaining and bargaining for the common good to negotiate two agreements these agreements delivered real benefits like improved working conditions safer environments and better supports for students and our commitment to transparency and collaboration has proven that when everyone sees the process they believe in the outcome we recognize that the Public Employee relation board also known as the perb has been has issued a regulation requiring closed negotiations however our legal council believes this
063regulation far exceeds the pb's Authority Under Maryland law the law is clear the perb cannot adopt regulations that restrict or weaken protections for public employees and closing negotiations does that it undermines transparency trust and the progress we've made it's not just bad policy it's bad governance this regulation from the perb doesn't just violate trust it oversteps the law and undermines protections meant to safeguard fairness and transparency the power of open bargaining lies in its ability to create trust and unity by allowing interest holders to observe negotiations it dispels the myths and misunderstandings that can arise in closed door processes they see the complexity of the issues and the collaborative effort required to solve them the transparency reassures both the board and the community that decisions are being made with integrity and mutual commitment open bargaining
064replaces suspicion with Clarity conflict with collaboration and doubt with trust it's actually a much less adversarial style of bargaining because when you know that your constituents are watching everyone comes to the table with the attitude of problem solving instead of just we're going to get more and you're going to get less bargaining for the common good ensures that our negotiations align with the community's priorities by expanding traditional bargaining uh to address issues like housing and security Mental Health Resources and equity and funding we create schools where every child can Thrive this approach has already delivered results and continuing it will only deepen the trust and collaboration we've built with our community our community understands the importance of transparency in negotiations that's why thousands of people signed a petition to keep open to keep bargaining open
065sorry there are there's thousands of names here when thousands of people sign a petition it sends a clear message Our Community Values transparency and they are demanding accountability and a voice in the future of their schools they know that when interest holders can observe the process it Fosters trust dispels that misinformation and shows a unified commitment to addressing challenges together here are some responses we received from the community on the petition one Community member shared in my opinion we need to continue to work together Schoolboard students and parents for the kids another shared doing negotiations in closed door manner is not a way to build relationships with your community transparency builds helps build trust as an Administration there should be nothing to hide this underscores how transparency strengthens the partnership between Educators families and the
066Board of Education and again our legal council is clear Herb's regulation to close negotiation is inconsistent with their statutory Authority maryn law explicitly states that negotiation procedures are a permissive subject of bargaining and the law that created the perb expressly prohibits it from adopting any any regulation that restricts or weakens protections for public employees adopting open bargaining aligns with both the law and our shared commitment to transparency the decision before you is about values transparency over secrecy collaboration over conflict and Trust over division by supporting open bargaining and bargaining for the common good you honor the voices of Educators parents and community members who are invested in our schools together we can assure ensure that negotiations reflect our shared priorities and serve every student teacher and family in our district open bargaining isn't just about
067keeping negotiations trans transparent it's about honoring the trust our community places in the process when interest holders can observe negotiations they see the dedication and effort that goes into resolving challenges collaboratively by continuing to support open bargaining you ensure that trust Clarity and mutual commitment Remain the cornerstones of our decision-making process so let's move forward Guided by trust and Equity tonight you have a choice to stand with transparency the law or turn away from the principle of trust and accountability it's not just the right thing to do it's the only thing to do if you want our schools to thrive please keep bargaining open thank Youk thank you Dr Christie so I do want to uh recognize the superintendent house uh if you have any comments what I'd like to do is is turn turn
068the mic over to our general councilman Mr Darnell Henderson uh for any comments here uh good evening can you hear me uh thank you Mr house and good evening board members uh regarding our ongoing labor relation negotiations with pgca um it should be clear that in May of 2024 the Maryland Public Relations Board the perb um enacted regulations um regarding negotiations set forth in comar 14301 1301 which now requires the PGCPS to negotiate uh in good faith in close session and so that has been the administration's position that in good faith in close session is the law and that is the way that we've chosen to move forward in compliance with the law so with that being said Thank You Darnell I will move into my superintendent's report thank you Dr Christie and and members
069of of pgca and community that are here as well we appreciate you welcome back again and and thank you uh chairman I think we have um board members who have a question Dr Chris if you want to get back to the absolutely thank you so the board chair recognizes uh Dr Moss uh thank you both for being here this evening um that there's no question about where I stand on this matter as someone who's been an educator I wore my red tie tonight on purpose um as an educator Mr Henderson I do want to hear your perspective on uh what are the consequences of not following uh the comar regulation uh given my strong stance in open negotiations and I would also love to hear pga's perspective on how uh perb actually oversteep the statutory
070Authority and to what extent do you disagree with uh that conception from pgca attorney Henderson yep thank you very much board member Moss for the question so as relates to I'll answer the the last question first um has the perb overstepped its boundaries question that's for the that's for an argument for the perb for pgca to make for PGC PS to make but the risk here is one of unknown consequence and so there usually when there's a a issue with the perb there's one side the board against the the the um Labor Relations and sort of having that conversation and trying to figure out the conflict the the issue here is is that any attorney worth their weight and salt could not advise their client to actively go against the plain language of the law
071and maybe the perb overstepped its boundary but that is not for a school district or for um the labor union to make that decision is for the perb to sort of figure out whether or not their take or stance is not in line with the law and I so so there is an unquantifiable liability here that if we go down a route where we open up negotiations what kind of consequences that leave us as relates to the agreements that are created based on actively breaking the law to enter into those agreements thank you all righty thank you um Dr Moss for the question and if it's okay I'm going to let our legal council do the rebuttal uh good afternoon Damon felt and attorney with MCA and pgca attorney so in this particular case it's
072very clear and I I would say that I'm very certain that the regulations this is not law the regulations that were ProMag by per have violated the law the law restricts them from actually weakening or restricting the protections provided by the public employees um or employee organizations so what we have here previously the current contract was negotiated under open bargaining that's something that the negotiations and the association had the right to previously therefore the perb who was subsequent to or the pro the regulations which are subsequent to that negotiations cannot interfere with what occurred in the past cannot interfere with the organization's right to open negotiations and it is very certain in my opinion that the regulations when looked at again will be overturned I would say to you this I believe that the perb
073did not have the history that we have here of open bargaining we're not aware that this occurred in Prince George's County propagated the statute or the regulations again not statute but the regulations and when they get an opportunity to learn all the facts and review the Law and Review everything that we've sent to them previously they are going to come to the right conclusion so therefore what we're asking for you to do is come to the right conclusion at this point in time that is something that you have the right to do there in my opinion are no consequences for that and again you have your recommendation from legal counsel but if if recommendations from legal councel were always accepted I wouldn't have some of the frustrations that I have at my job all right
074thank you so I would say to you to do the right thing you have the ability to do this I'm saying to you that the perb will subsequently do this when they look at this and consider it fully and understand what it really means but we want to be able to do this now so that we can get the negotiations started and get things moving thank you thank you thank you I'm not sure do you need that was Damon Felton by the way I don't think we introduced his name for the record thank you um board member B strer yeah thank you so much and thank you for the presentation um and uh M uh Mr Felton you just hit on exactly where I wanted to head was how quickly the board could address this
075because it as a board member who's been on this board for six years and has uh and you know there's been two very successful negotiations in this model this has been quite upsetting to me because it's created conflict that we don't do not need right now at all so when I look at this board and I see Judith rivlin renowned attorney in labor I see a former Nea advocacy Services director I do not understand how this happened number one and two how they cannot move quickly like when I see you know two at least those two people whose reputations I know can we ask them to move more quickly and resolve this and and that would be be my request of the attorneys in the room B Walker thank you so much for um the
076presentation you know the the the small piece that I'll add to this is that you know I don't believe it's the Board of Education who has the expertise to decide where the law is and where we move next steps we have our attorneys who are here in order to guide us on what the law and regulation say and so what the regulations say that are based on the law um tells us um by way of what the expertise says is that we will not be following the law should we choose to move forward I as a board member have don't have any issues at all with the amazing um negotiations that we've had over the last couple of years whether it's in good faith or for the common good it has always resulted in something
077that is favorable for um our unions and pgca in particular um with that said I guess um what I'm looking to to to see one I thought we were under negotiations already are we not in negotiations as we currently speak okay um thank you for that confirmation um but what I'm looking to understand is the perb or our once they decide on where it is we go forward once they overturn what it is they said then we'll move swiftly in order to make sure sure that we um entertain the law and we follow that law so from my perspective although I have seen the amazingness that's happened in the last couple of years I have no reason to believe that that won't continue even behind closed doors while we follow the law when that is
078overturned if that is overturned unless someone tells me differently or shows me differently I haven't seen that what I've seen is the last two um successful uh negotiations happen um so with that I am under the um perception and the belief and the vote should it come to it that we will follow the law and that comes from the attorney jne um that that guide us in our everyday but thank you so much for the presentation it was very helpful thank you seeing that there's no more lights we will move on to the next section superintendent thank you Mr chair uh first I I want to start off by acknowledging that January is national board appreciation month uh we know the work uh that you all do the commitment away from your families uh that
079you focus on on a day daily B dces and and today is a an opportunity to just say thank you for all that you do uh not only for our students but our families and throughout the community uh n PGCPS let's let's give our board members a big hand for all that they do thank you very [Applause] much also I'd like to to welcome back everyone after a very I'll just call it snowy uh winter break uh it was great to see everyone ready to embrace the uh the start of the uh the 25 25 section of our school year um I'd also like to express my most sincere gratitude to my operations and Communications team as we all uh saw during this uh this winter storm it was hard work and took quite a
080bit of patience to to Really navigate keeping everything uh in front of us and every individual safe uh and and I'm I'm eternally grateful for for our team in the weather in the uh during this weather event we really appreciate you so I want to shift to uh to weather uh being that I've shared a little bit about the appreciation of our teams that the focus on weather and given that the inclement weather um that we've all experienced I'd like to ask my chief information and Technology officer uh Andy Zuckerman Dr Andy Zuckerman to really speak a bit about our virtual learning and uh and where we are Dr Zuckerman sure thank you Mr house um so as board members may know we have a virtual learning plan for a prolonged state of emergency that
081is required uh for us to submit to the state of Maryland every two years um and that allows us to Pivot for an extended emergency such as a pandemic um a significant period of closure uh we are not prepared to Pivot uh on a dime for virtual learning for inclement weather uh we have 104 of our schools that have um Chromebooks for example in carts uh in schools and so um you know for example on last Thursday if we had wanted to Pivot to Virtual learning we have to assure that every student has a technology to be able to do synchronous virtual learning because the law changed a year ago that um if you're going to do virtual learning after you've exhausted your snow makeup days in the calendar you can only do it after
082you've exhausted your snow makeup days um it has to be synchronous and so that's just something operationally logistically uh even educationally we had questions about the efficacy of that um and so we opted this year along with many other counties uh some of our neighbors Charles Howard for example to uh pursue just a traditional uh snow makeup day plan uh and that's so that's the that's the process that we're using this year and I just wanted to provide an update on that thank you Dr Zuckerman I'd like to shift to to discipline updates uh as as we move into the new year we've uh reviewed at this time every year we uh take a look at data and both discipline and chronic absenteeism is is something that we've truly tried to focus on um current
083data suggests that disciplinary removals are are down compared to the previous year this specific time uh we're seeing a reduction uh we've seen a reduction so far of about 652 fewer disciplinary removals which rep represents a reduction of about 12.8% uh the highest number of disciplinary removals are are originating within middle schools quite frankly uh of course 6th through 8th grade with sixth grader suspensions ranking the highest and it's interesting because the research tells us quite frankly those transition years sixth grade and 9th grade are typically the the most difficult year so it's definitely something that we're paying close attention to disruption in subordination and failure to follow policies are the new uh incident types uh in our code of student conduct this year about 15% of all suspensions this year were due to these
084incident types alone uh there have been recent concerns shared over uh safety and schools uh and I'd like to note that violent uh discipline incidents have also declined by 21% compared to this period last year which is a reduction of about about 607 uh incidents incidents involving guns and weapons are also down from last year perhaps due to the increase of our security enhancement equipment that we've placed in a number of our middle schools and high schools uh from a school culture and climate perspective the survey data from 2024 showed a slight Improvement in students perception of feeling safe in PGCPS schools now shifting to Chronic absenteeism uh current Trend data suggests that students are attending school more consistently than this time last year chronic absen absenteeism percentages have reduced by 4.4 percentage points respectively
085the goal uh with principles uh starting this year out uh was a 3% um uh 3% um goal and we've gone over that goal which we're very proud of but we still know we have more work to do K middle uh schools span the the lowest chronic absenteeism data uh which is about 15% now shifting to Summer Schools chair finally you may recall a uh a few board meetings back that there was questions uh regards to summer programs and I'd like to invite our our chief academic officer uh Dr Judy White to share a brief overview of her summer school programming including the timelines uh summer positions and the site locations uh as we move into uh that that portion of the Year Dr White happy New Year and good evening to all of our
086board members um I don't know if we are going to have the presentation up awesome there we go so I'm going to I know this is posted so you've probably already reviewed but I'm just going to quickly go through to kind of set the stage of what happens as it relates to Summer programming my office has the privilege to facilitate summer programming for the entire District that means whether it's a systemic program whether it's a school program we put a process in place so that we're not operating in isolation so we're going to talk about timelines quickly the type of positions and all this presentation is based on school year 2024 so right now just so you know how the process works right now we would send out a memo this happened last January um
087asking for any school any program anybody in our district that wants to do a program will apply to us so that we know so that we can put them in contact we can have we have monthly planning meetings we have office hours with every single program we connect them to food nutrition services Transportation if necessary our budget team so that we're making sure that their budgets are right and so we're moving them through the process to get ready for summer school that means we're hiring starting in May and June we're working with human resources the program takes place in January some programs in August payroll is continually being processed and then the program once we're in session and out of session we have recordkeeping because we're asking them to communicate to us what happened in
088their program and then we're planning a debriefing document for you so realistically summer planning and or summer school is a 12mon cycle my clicker is not moving Charles if you could help move me to the next thank you here I just wanted to point out we really look at 214 positions to run summer school so this just list if you're interested in all the different type of positions over the entire system that's what this slide would show here we are talking about across every single program every single grade you have opportunities for either acceleration enrichment transition intervention Credit Recovery or original credit depending on what grade you're in depending on what type of program it is some of our programs are face to face and some of them are online and the delivery models could
089either be inperson virtual asynchronous or synchronous so last year for the first time our School System created in um English Spanish and French programming four weeks worth of programming a comprehensive book where parents could work with their students at home to really set a program for all summer long was very interactive it had videos um it had icons it was on the internet and later on I'll show you the amount of views that we had the reason that we chose to go this route is that prior to that we were doing hubs in the summer and we had maybe a thousand students who attended and the average day out of 20 days absent was 5 to six days and so we identified that number one we were not touching every single Elementary student and even
090those that came were missing day so we really wanted to find a process by which at home especially for our youngest Learners families could put a child on every single day work with them build them as our partners and so that's what that looked like for our elementary our Middle School we did have a small systemic Intervention Program for our students in Middle School who were identified as demonstrating learning loss based on assessments and based on grades in our high schools of course we are looking at Credit Recovery those students who have failed a course that they need for graduation and acceleration those students who choose to take some um original credit courses that are geared towards graduation those were face to face and online here are just some of the course offerings for high
091school so that you know what was offered for original credit and what was offered for credit recovery then we in addition to our programming that talks about acceleration we just wanted you to know that we have a lot of enrichment programs that happen these are listed here for you to see um every year that changes but that these are the ones that took place last year many of them are around our early um middlee colleges and we offer Bridge programs for those programs especially to make sure that our students are ready and geared up to enter those programs in the fall when you look at those programs that are not systemic here are the numbers 18 schools offered programs in elementary level five at the middle school five at high school and seven cross level
092programs so that would be your K8 programs summer school funded location we wanted you to kind of have idea so that if you're looking to see if a school fell in your District this these are the schools that offer those programs and again this is in addition to what was done systemically support we want you to know that every single summer we provide support for our special education students our English language Learners and our earliest Learners through our Judy Center programs now we create a summer website for our families we um promote that out on all of our our um Partners we make sure that they have the logo even if it's our faith-based partners here is where everything exists it's where our families can tap into the Elementary programs for every single week it's
093where they can find a listing for all the programs it's where they can find the phone numbers for all the programs if they need to have contact all things summer school are at our PGCPS summer learning spark website on that website we also want to make sure that our Community Partners that our parent and that our students understand and have summer tips for support so what are those things that you can do at home with your student those everyday um opportunities to make sure that they're successful what are those things that our Community Partners as they're running their own programs can focus on in terms of the standards and uh objectives we'd want them to cover we also on that site have what does your child need to know to be successful in the next
094grade so our parents can be reviewing that as well again we debrief when summer program is over we just stop we say what went well what do we need to work on what can be better as we move on we work with all the external Partners within the school district to talk about what could go better in their departments to help our schools facilitate summer here I wanted you to say so you heard me mention that we only had about 1,000 students that we touched so this goes to show you that even more of those students what you see in blue is the programming that was in English the programming in Spanish and the programming in French um me talking about it doesn't do it justice I would love at some point to show you
095what that website looked like so you can see the richness of what we created we could probably um bottle it up and sell it to other districts that's how good it was we really like Tyler Perry Studios that's how much work it took to uh make that come make that happen but you can see the number of times and the number of hits that we had from all of our Scholars at every single grade so we're excited about that this is what you'd be interested in so for every single program and we work to get this every year they identify on their own um an attendance Target and then what they want to Target is terms of success so on our website you all will just click the link and you'll be able to find
096a complete report that shows every single program and what they targeted um we're working to make sure that they're picking goals that make sense and so again because I facilitate we try to make sure that we review them that it makes sense and and that they move forward with that any questions I want to recognize uh board member Brown thank you chair Jackson and thank you Dr White um great presentation I just have two questions the first question I have is can students who do not go to those schools are they still able to have an option to still enroll in those summer programs so a school that offers a program usually is for their students so every single school if CH if they choose can put money towards those programs a lot of schools
097offer opportunities because we are CSI schools but we have so many schools that are title one they offer a lot of after school programs during the year because they believe that within the 180 days is where we really need to hit students versus that 20day window in the summer so when they're choosing to offer in the summer it is normally for their site that's if it's a school-based some of the programming that you saw where was enrichment many of those are cross collaborations you can apply to go for example we have the William Schmidt Center that any student could sign up to go and have weeks of enrichment to go and do the confidence course and learn about stem so it depends on what program it is okay perfect so CU I feel like every
098year the list kind of changes and so I was kind of curious as like how are schools chosen you know in a sense so every school has a budget and some schools determine based on what's taking place in their building that they want to put a certain amount of money from their SBB in place so they would have done that last March for this summer coming thank you okay next up I want to recognize uh board member Zakia uh then Pam then Dr Moss thank you chair Jackson and thank you Dr White I just had a quick question about the data that we get for those pre- and post tests are the teachers who are the teachers of record for the next year do they get access to that information how are we connecting summer
099learning with what happens during the school year yes so normally um they don't because when the schools choose what that data source is well let me say this if it's a school-based program it's possible that they could because they're in their own buildings so their teachers normally apply they're hired it could be additional teachers the school has that data source the school also builds their own pre- and post test so that is a possibility my office does not facilitate that process um for many of our programs when it was systemic we use um for like high school we know it's original Credit Credit Recovery you would know that because it hits the transcript for our middle school program we make sure that our staff receives that information because that was the difference of an eighth
100grader failing to move on to High School versus not Elementary School because we were using when we ran systemic we were using our platforms of I ready and those that information was already there available for the teacher so I don't want to say that our schools that are running their own programs do not because it's possible that they do because they're within their own [Music] building thank you uh Dr White thank you so much I did uh click through to the data reports and two things really stood out one I want to say thank you to our Educators and congratulations to the students on the Progressive uh completion rates are are great um I did notice that for the and that's high I'm focused on high school apologize High School completion rates and then the
101um my question is it's also about a thousand less high school students in these classes and is that also good news that fewer high school students need to go to these summer school classes yes so if you um last school year and uh if he wants to jump in uh Chief ster shared that when you looked at our our grades the grades were getting better from when we were in a pandemic and so that means the more students who are passing the less students who need to have credit recovery we offer credit recovery for free uh because we want to make sure that our students have an opportunity to regain the credits that they need for graduation so it means that during the year we absolutely we're getting better the other thing as you will
102notice we minimized original credit because we wanted to make sure we had enough teachers to cover any student who needed to regain a credit yeah that's that's great and then a question uh this more directed towards uh Dr Coleman I I've been a proponent of additional transportation for summer programs and I wanted to um you know I I guess ask if the lack of Transportation has any impact on students who participate at the high school level and if there is an opportunity for more transportation for summer programs thank you for that question and we don't have uh an issue with supporting the capacity needs of the academics office if you could imagine we transport 87,000 students at this current time and it'll be a much smaller number during the summer months so we can support
103it yeah so I would need to go back uh Dr Davis and I can work with the high school office again every program that puts funds in place puts funds if they need transportation in for that so we would need to find out the reason that they chose not to for our original credits some of them they run so many different schedules of who's during the day who's in the evening because we want to accommodate those students who also have jobs but we can find out why specifically they didn't report back out to the board I appreciate it I guess that would that would overlap with questions for our budget um hearings as well so I'll gather that information for you thank you Dr Moss um thank you so much for the summer summer learning
104presentation Dr White I had a question in another portion of the superintendent's report that I wanted the superintendent to speak to um I don't know if other colleagues of mine experienced this but um I I appreciated the work that I our district team did to ensure we were responding to parents around weather the weather update that you provided I think we did a a great job trying to make decision with a very in a very tough situation um but a number of our parents and community members don't always understand how we make these decisions so if you just take a moment to educate them on how we actually came to those decisions I appreciate the team bringing that virtual learning report together um but I think it would it would benefit our parents and stakeholders
105if we outline how we actually make these decisions around I really appreciate that that opportunity and I'm going to have uh Dr shirasa Coleman uh we spent a lot of early mornings and a lot of late nights uh talking to each other um and uh but here we are so I'll let him hit him him go through it because his team is is responsible for the process and providing a recommendation eventually to me yeah thank you so much for that question it definitely is a lot of work uh in preparation for what could turn out to be an inclement weather day uh we try to gather as much information as we can in real time that includes National Weather Service uh updates we coordinate with our Community Partners uh Department of Public Works and Transportation
106uh we also are part of an emergency weather team uh with the entire County government leadership uh along with director Balwin and myself and our security group and so we meet prior to any weather event so that we can get a collective understanding of what is expected to come uh and what the preparations are from both the county level as well as from our school district level uh we coordinate uh with our uh other local jurisdictions so that we can get a prediction from uh from their vantage point of what they're expecting and what their potential outcomes could be uh sometimes we have to deviate because what's happening further north may not impact us the same way uh but we certainly do try to coordinate in our responses and lastly if I would say if
107I would say uh we try as best we can to make the decisions early enough that families can respond right we know that it is a challenge uh when we call school off uh that families still have to go to work they still have to make preparations for their children so we're trying to balance that uh collecting enough information while also giving families enough notice to make other arrangements and that's actually what I was going to follow up on we um uh Dr Coan and I had a number of uh conversations around making sure that we give our our community enough time uh and uh those are sometime tough calls simply because weather patterns shift uh they move uh they don't bring in what they say they're going to bring in and you never want
108to be wrong uh but uh I think in in the instance of this past storm we got it right and we kept our patrons safe I appreciate that response take just 30 seconds I just want to say the district didn't run out of salt so folks were blaming us for it so I just want to make sure we clarify that the district didn't run out of salt somebody else ran out of sou hirer than the district all righty thank you so much I want to recognize uh Vice chair bricks thank you so much chair Jackson um my question is for uh Dr White and first welcome back back Happy New Year to everyone thank you for the well wishes um and also thank you for the presentation I did have a question CU I know
109that we've had a summer enrichment program for several years now there's been great success things happening there um but was just curious if you could speak to some of the results for academic performance coming out of the online program for students so this year we you talking about elementary the elementary program yeah and also I just wanted to also add in if you can't speak to any of the things then if we can have like maybe some data shared um after this could be a subsequent thing but whatever you can speak to right now sure I can speak to it actually the online program for our elementary Scholars was to keep them engaged it was not to look at did they grow it was about how do you as a parent every single day not
110have to think about what to do for your child to keep them engaged we want our our elementary Scholars reading we want them um manipulating we want them to be entertained we want them to have tax tile we want them to to be totally engaged in just keeping the love for learning so we didn't put into that platform ways to Mark where they were and did they keep moving what I will say is that when we look at our Dibbles data and we'll be bringing that to academic achievement in February it shows that our students did not decline and so for that we're thankful so I can bring that data at some point and share that data once we have that report and I let academic achievements see at first to share that with you
111but we did not have a summer slide okay okay yeah that would be helpful if you that thank you so much thank you board chair recognizes board member jungo okay um good evening um first I want to say um first I got to address the students of Prince georgees County um thank you so much for all the students that um that messaged me during the four days of our I guess extended winter break I got over like I think 150 messages mainly um concerning the ice on the road um I first just want to say on record um I'm pretty sure only PGCPS is only allowed to clean their property not the entire District's streets um because I definitely I think that was one of the main things that I um I seen and I
112was just trying to you know make sure that students understood it um I was also able to you know um email um I know I emailed um Chief boy and superintendent house mainly um kind of giving photos um of streets and um buildings thatu um students had texted me and said um oh there's ice on this road I don't think I'll be able to go to school um and a lot of students did feel um kind of frustrated with the fact that they weren't um their neighborhoods weren't cleared and I as much as you know as much as that you know makes the um our transportation you know harder at the end of the day because of the fact that if their roads aren't clear in their neighborhoods they're not able to leave their neighborhoods
113to go to school and um um I definitely seen um a lot of I could definitely say I seen a lot of improvement within the past couple of days of our roads getting cleared um and I just wanted to um ask when it comes to um making these decisions are there is there um is there student input allowed to be added to that that decision can be um I don't want to say made faster but definitely like just so that the students can heard because I think that was one of the biggest things um that I seen in my comments when we did um end up opening up our schools um on Friday so I didn't I don't know how that process works but if there is some type of way to have students um
114implemented into that process or into that team I would love to know how what I will say and and Mr jongo thank you uh for your support and the the 150 individuals that reached out to you during this particular time um we we take everything to heart uh quite frankly it is a process we have a number of individuals that are actually in those neighborhoods that are actually on County Roads working with the county working uh within the school district uh so there are a lot of players uh in um in the game already in terms of weather and and what it looks like uh what I will say is that uh any feedback uh that I get from from board members uh take to heart and make that a part of the conversation uh
115that I have uh with my Ops teams doing our Ops calls uh so we uh continue to uh uh welcome uh that feedback as we move into hopefully no more uh winter events over the course of this year but we can't promise anything and superintendent house if I might might add um thank you so much board member jongo we have to superintendent House's point six Transportation supervisors that when we have inclement weather they're on the road they're assessing our neighborhoods they're into the trips and routes so that they can determine if there's ice if it's safe and they feed that information back to Transportation director Baldwin that then comes to me and then to superintendent house so I can just assure you and also your constituents that safety is always our number one priority and
116I also want to add that uh one of the things that I was really pleased with uh as we moved into this weather event is that the county um connected with us and asked for specific routes uh so that so they actually focused on 40 or 50 of our routes where they were going through to ensure that our buses had a a safe a safe pathway so that that type of teamwork is extremely important and and we're thankful for that we know it wasn't perfect at all because it was quite a a difficult scenario uh we would have loved for for every route uh but uh but U uh they did everything that they could we did everything that we could and uh and I think we're in a in a good safe place as
117of today Dr anul oh on go ahead and finish your question oh okay and then um also I think well yeah within like the past 21 hours I did have students um email me and reach out to me about um ice still being like on their school property like during in the sidewalks um and I think one student said that like a teacher slipped I'm I'm not 100% sure because of the fact that I don't go to that specific school but if um I guess cuz I'm going to definitely screen record this and post this um later um where can students um or teachers well I guess teachers have their own way but where can students um be able to reach out to um your team or reach out to the transportation team or reach
118out to um our clean um just reach out to anybody about um I still being on their um school so that there's able to be an assessment made if they need um if we need employees to come back out if it's at a particular site we need to start at the site level with the administration at the school and report it to the office uh if that information comes you know directly to you please feel free to to send it uh send it to me and and we'll get it down to our Ops Team but we want to start at the site uh because each site uh has a specific responsibility in reference to keeping their sidewalks uh keeping uh portions of of their build uh their building walkable to ensure that there are no
119uh no accidents but we do want to start at the site okay thank you thank you does that inclose your question questions okay Dr andil good evening um happy New Year to everyone um thank you so much Dr White for your presentation um I want to some Echo um Vice chair Brigg's request for data um specific to some of the outcomes of the summer programs um but also add on to that I'm curious about um the support being provided for special populations in our summer programming um and you know this is news to me but I'm glad that you know I'm learning a lot as I'm as I'm going through this um that schools have the ability to choose whether or not they offer um these summer programs they have the ability to also create
120their own surveys and so I'm just really curious about what we are capturing in terms of outcomes um if we're disaggregating that data and then sharing it back with schools because you know I'm thinking you know as a parent um as you know a former educator you know I'm thinking about our school leaders do they have the necessary information that would help them make informed decisions about how they are allocating funds in the school year I'm wondering if we shareed data to show that you know um some of these programs are actually really benefiting our students especially those in our with special populations that school leaders would make different choices about how they're allocating their funds so I'm just I'm interested to see the data and also hear a little bit more about how we're
121sharing those outcomes with with school leaders across the board sure so as in terms of our school leaders just know that all year long we talk about data um Chief Davis has a process in place where every single quarter we have stat meetings uh principals have to come with their data they build a school performance plan they have to identify within that plan what their goals are for the year they usually have to pick three one must be around reading and one must be around mathematics as a part of that plan and it will be good for you to see what they have to do they have to really do data um analysis to get to root causes and then build a plan from there every every month and then every quarter in front of
122the chief their associate superintendent instructional director talk about what's hitting the Mark what's not wrapped around that is content to make sure that if if they're struggling with like their English Learners or they're struggling with a specific population that we're supporting them in terms of our CSI and atsi schools they too have different Summits that they have to go to their plan based on msde is more extensive way more extensive if you see it where they really have to dig into what is the root cause we've built in some programming this year um oap and some other things around specific content strategies to work with our schools I only I'm only giving that context extra because some of you know so many are new and I want to make sure that we're I'm making sure
123that you have the knowledge I say that to say they know their data the 15 days in the summer isn't going to help them plan for what they need to do what they need to be planning for are the benchmarks we provide where their students are performing where we as a district work with them to say these are the standards that systemwide we're not doing well in and this is how we need to work together to build for that and this is how we need to look at every individual student's data point work on grouping and work on how to make it better for them throughout the year summer they know their data they see it if it's an individual program middle schools get theirs back high schools we know for performance but when you
124have a chance to look at the document and you want to talk more I would love to talk more offline if you like to in the partnership and then maybe that's something we can also talk about an academic achievement thank you Dr White thank you um does that conclude your question question Dr an okay great um say no more lights uh we will move on to uh the report of the Committees the chairman recognizes the board committee chairs for their committee reports uh policy and governance the chairman recognizes uh board member uh Dr Moss for the policy and governance committee report uh thank you chair Jackson I think it's befitting given the scope and authority of this committee um Jackson we do have one of our state officials in the building who just walked in
125uh delegate Kent Roberson uh who represents the 24th district in the general assembly for Prince georgees County so just wanted to make sure we recognize him uh the policy and governance committee is charged with facilitating short and long range strategic planning for the school system providing oversight of board policy and legislative and government matters involving federal state county and Municipal governmental agencies and officials the committee shall ensure that board governing policies are current and compliant with federal state and County laws and consistent with best practices in public education school year 20124 through 2025 committee meeting schedule the committee has maintained its monthly meeting since August the 20th of 2024 um during the school year 2022 through 2023 the committee work plan and progress is laid out as follows the committee's approved work plan for the
1262425 school year was introduced and reported to the full board in October of 2024 the committee continues to focus on the recommendations received from the board and superintendent for board policies that required review due to legal ramifications citation Corrections recessions and cycle updates and to be in alignment with existing administrative procedures to be enacted the status of those said policies based on 2425 work plan are as follows out of 49 recommended policies 22 policies are enacted nine policies have been rescinded 14 are currently under review and 24 are scheduled to be reviewed the list of policies and their statutes can be found on board docs in accordance with board policy 9340 the following suggestions are for board consideration policies for public comment is where I'll begin um our policy developing curriculum documents for instructional programs
127in elementary and secondary schools policy focused on possession and use of alcohol and drugs on school grounds policy 1113 informational materials and announ announcements policy 3323 purchasing policy 5168 automated external defibrillators policy 8265 evaluating the superintendent of schools these six policies were revised to align with state laws or had reached their 7-year Mark for review policy 5204 bus transportation for cheerleaders majorettes Etc recession policy 5205 proms recession policies 5204 and 5205 are being Reed Ed following the annotated code of Maryland education article 4402 which highlights that the superintendent of Prince George's County Public Schools is responsible for the overall Administration day-to-day management and oversight of fiscal Affairs of PGCPS including the management of activities related to each of the school systems areas of operation policy 9110 number of members and terms of office policy 9310
128adoption of policies policy 90 policy 9330 adoption and Amendments of administrative regulations all of which were in recession policies 9110 9310 and 9330 are being rescinded due to their language redundancies and other policies and finally policies for first consideration the following policies are being recommended for first consideration evaluation of Library materials policy 2566 student identification cards policy 5113 attendance absence and truancy policy 5143 bullying harassment or intimidation policy 6153 field trips policy 8101 policy development on behalf of the policy and governance committee I recommend the policies for board consideration thank you Dr Moss if there's no objection the board will adopt the recommendations outlined in the policy and governance committee report there being no objection the recommending are adopted recommendation are adopted moving to 15.1 the chairman recognized the superintendent house for the transportation action
129plan second quarter update thank you Mr chair uh as as promised to this board we want to provide a a quarterly update uh in reference to Transportation so I'd like to invite our chief operating officer Dr shirasa Coleman to the microphone as well as uh our head of Transportation Mr Kea ke Ballwin gentlemen thank you so much superintendent house for this opportunity to provide a brief update regarding implementation of our transportation action plan good evening board chair of Jackson Vice chair Briggs board members and members of the public formative a third-party independent Transportation consulting firm completed an audit of our transportation system in school year 20 2023 24 and has continued to provide technical support and assess the progress of the implementation of our transportation action plan on a quarterly basis they provided a detailed
130report and today's presentation will first be a summary update of those findings focused on the implementation of the phase one prioritized recommendations and second we will introduce the focus of the phase 2 prioritized recommendations that will be implemented in school year 26 this school year we are focused on implementing the five prioritized recommendations listed here we are encour we are continuing to encourage all families who use buses to do three things one sign up for the parent view the parent portal for the student information system called Synergy two activate a stop finder account when an email link is sent to them and third set up Geo alerts to be able to track the bus as it travels and receive push notifications to their phone when students are dropped off or picked up this Transportation action
131plan has a multi-year implementation time line as such we are committed to making progress while recognizing that our system still has challenges here is a brief snapshot of our data director Balwin will go deeper into this data on the next slide director Baldwin thank you Dr Coleman happy New Year everyone this comparison slide displays the progress of our transportation action plan we are in the second quarter of a multi-year plan for the transportation improvements and we are seeing progress in many areas but we're also continuing to confront challenges to start our review of the data plan trip utilization is six trips assigned to each bus 3 in the morning 3 in the afternoon as of the second quarter our plan trip utilization has improved from 5.3 in October of 23 to 5.9 as of December
1322024 which means we're achieving maximum utilization by uring we have a bus assigned to a trip on all three tiers with the increase in student assignment to our buses which was 52.9% last year and is now 66.4 as of December 2024 we're using buses more effectively by placing them more by placing more students on each bus while not overloading them the number of students assigned to a bus has increased by roughly 1,400 students this has contributed to adding 43 routes and 131 more active Vehicles however even though routes and vehicles have been added bus trips have been made more effective as we have been able to safely eliminate over 25 200 stops One Challenge remains is the average walk to stop the goal was to increase the average walk to stop from 24 mi 2.46
133mi however as of December 2024 the walk to stop distance is at 22 mies while we're committed to this goal throughout this process we have not jeopardized the safety of students so where stops had to be maintained for safety of students they were Staffing remains a key challenge to increasing the overall capacity and efficiency of our transportation system from October 2023 to December 2024 the number of available drivers 858 roughly has not changed this is not enough drivers to have an assigned driver for every existing route as a result drivers are doubling trips and doubling trips at each tier to provide safe arrivals to home and [Music] school as a followup to the audit completed by formative they conduct their independent data review on a quarterly basis the second quarter data analysis revealed the following
134PGCPS has achieved many for progress in seat utilization and stop consolidation and again through their second quarter data analysis it shows that we have also improved on our btime alignment and balance for both the AM and PM here we talk about our efficiency challenges is Staffing the second quarter data analysis for informative also shows that Staffing still flat from the 23 24 school year while Riders ship demand has increased the number of open routes still remain at 189 as a result drivers must continually double trips at all tiers this increase of RI times affects our performance our on Time Performance and lowers morale of our employees due to the extra workload in phase two we are continuing to refine the implementation of our phase one prioritized recommendations and also enhance Transportation Service delivery by expanding
135in several key areas recommended from last year's audit findings some of the phase 2 enhancements have already begun others will be implemented at the start of school year 2025 26 recommendation two listed here we will continue to make bus trips more efficient based on actual ridership count this includes the continued consolidation of bus stops where appropriate recommendation three over the past 6 months the Department of Transportation Department of Safety and Security Services members of the Prince George's County Board of Education and parents have worked in collaboration with the Department of Public Works and transportation members of the County Council and Municipal leaders as part of a school pedestrian safety workg group to develop recommendations to improve appr pedestrian safety in addition PGCPS also has has two approved safe passage coordinator positions that will support District
136Rod pedestrian safety efforts recommendation four we have approximately 7,400 students who have opted out of Transportation so far this school year we will continue to stress to families the importance of opting out when they know they don't need transportation services recommendation five since the start of the school year parent engagement with the stop finder app has steadily increased we now have approximately 28,000 subscribers which is 2,000 more than at the end of school year 2024 as a new feature within the stop finder app the transportation team will assign Geo alerts to families that have not created one this will allow us to com to communicate with over 20,000 families who have not previously received push notifications related to their daily bus status recommendation six last year we introduced alternative passenger vans and non CDL Drivers
137into our multimodal transportation mix this approach proved effective and we are now expanding this Fleet with 25 additional non-cdl drivers and 20 new passenger vans once the expansion is complete our Fleet will consist of 50 non CDL Drivers and 36 Vans recommendation seven in a moment you'll hear from our Human Resource Partners regarding efforts to attract and retain bus drivers and bus attendance recommendation 12 a cross divisional team was established in November 2024 to identify ways to refine the student enrollment and registration processes to include specialty programs and early childhood centers at this point I will turn turn the presentation over to Mr Eugene to discuss Staffing in Greater detail good evening everyone and happy New Year once again um I first just want to take a brief moment to just thank all of the
138emergency service Personnel staff for the tremendous work that they did last week um ensuring we were returned safe and sound um they're truly appreciated as relates to the slide as summarized um total driver headcount has increased and open FTE have decreased we remain committ to ensuring we have the staff necessary to safely transport our scholars in a timely manner while the style references a December busz driver fill rate Improvement of 82% versus 74% at the beginning of the school year the great news is that fill rate continues to increase and is currently at 84% as of today also the December bus driver vacancies was at 183 versus 231 at the beginning of the school year today we're actually at 178 vacancies which is a continued reduction of 53 if we go to the next slide
139as noted in the formative report PGCPS is Recruitment and marketing efforts were diverse and strong with the lack of qualified CDL Drivers and the training required for the majority of their traines hired we recognize that the recruitment period had to be modified and implemented a yearwith and geared towards individuals that are interested in Pay training to become a school bus driver with PGCPS a recruitment office in collaboration with Communications have Incorporated an aggressive recruitment strategy which not only includes various media and radio buys but also marketing billboard placements outfront media which is advertising on buses Mall placements and paid external social media advertisements this is an interesting slide because we with a continued focus on transparencies there are often questions raised about our bus driver salaries the next slide represents a buzz driver pay comparison
140and competitive analysis that was completed by a comp ation and classification office this illustrates that PGCPS is very competitive relative to other neighboring leas or school systems more importantly it reflects that we are above the market at the midpoint and maximum pay table ranges this illustrates the ability for our employees to have an increased earning potential the longer they remain with PGCPS we can go to the next slide some of our next steps include the process of creating a strategic bus driver Staffing plan in partnership with the office of strategic plan planning and resource management and transportation services as to why while our recruitment efforts have been positively highlighted the Strategic plan will be focused on benchmarks applicant tracking building capacity and a focus on retention via an enhanced work environment and climate and culture
141survey feedback I just want to thank Dr Baldwin Dr Coleman director Baldwin and superintendent house for the continued collaborative efforts thank you so much this concludes our presentation and we look forward to taking your questions thank you thank you I want to recognize uh board member Brown thank you chair Jackson and thank you Dr Coleman and and your team I really appreciate you all taking the time I know transportation is not the easiest job and it is a very forward-facing position and so I want to make sure that I preface and saying that I appreciate all that you all do I've been a parent for PGCPS since 2014 and so I know about the stop finder app so I was very shocked when I heard that there were 28,000 additional parents who signed up um
142unfortunately my experience has not been great with stop finder um I will say on Friday when the students went to school there was um a no subscriptions available alert that came out every time we tried to see what time the bus so essentially it was almost like we were rolling a dice to figure out if the bus was going to come where it was going to come um because there's multiple buses that come in our neighborhood I think I my kids just ran across the street to take the bus um and they were able to go to school and they were on time so that was a good thing um and so I I think my question is I'm asking because we want to ensure transparency right with our community what me like as far
143as like do you know what happened um and how can we prevent these errors I know it's not always going to be perfect but what actually happened that it got to an error that we we couldn't contact anybody we didn't know what to do and this is let me also explain this has also been a problem pror to you all coming here stop finder has always just kind of been an issue um that I've dealt with over the over a number of years and so but when I talk about this specific problem um going back to school and and I understand like I said the logistics with the snow days can you kind of explain what happened and and what met tricks are we going to do moving forward to to ensure that that doesn't
144happen thank you thank you for your question to explain what happened uh it was actually within our programming in which uh a service was turned off and so once we discovered that service within the system we were able to activate it um and try to send notifications out of the change that we did catch the issue and that we have rectified it from that standpoint so hopefully you got a stop finder message um within at least this week that explain the issue I did not you did not yes so I I want to make sure that I'm I'm clear on that as well absolutely the other I did have one more other question um Dr Coleman mentioned a emergency weather team I still believe honestly that the school bus is probably the safest way to
145transport to school I mean it's it's huge it's yellow you can't miss it it got big wheels if somebody hits it you know it it's very difficult for as far as a car is concerned um our drivers certainly go through rigorous training and accountability but as community members how what does that look like as far as being a part of a weather team do they have to get up in the morning is that something that volunte parents or uh community members can volunteer for because I know a lot of my constituents they want to know how they can contribute to PGCPS but they don't know how um and I think this might might be an opportunity to see if they could be a part of the emergency weather team over so one of the things
146I want to assure them app parents of is that we have a diverse team already assembled uh to support coming to the best possible recommendations for superintendent house around weather we're looking at our vendor managed care for before and after care programs we're looking at transportation from all 500 uh square miles of our district we are in communication with the Department of Public Work works as well as our Community Partners um uh with Community leaders from our Municipal side we also have Athletics being considered our Building Services team maintenance so and many of these F these members are also parents so they're are parents that are actively a part of the conversation each time that we meet and we actually would ask them um how does it how does it feel for you in your
147neighborhood with your children and put your hat on in your official role as you know director of or supervisor of and give us your official spin so I just want the to assure the public that we take into account all aspects of the decision with safety being the lead priority no and I I really appreciate that I think I wanted my kids to go back to school so we appreciate that thank you board member Brown and and if I could just add uh if if it's if it's okay board chair just going back to the stock finder app uh we haven't talked about it in detail but director Balwin as a part of the entire Improvement effort with that being one of our five prioritized recommendations has redeployed staff from the central office into each
148of the bus lots to help make certain that we are substituting the buses uh with the proper trip so that the stop finder app works more effectively so that's been an ongoing Improvement effort Dr Moss um first of all thank you all for doing God's work um and we know Transportation issues don't have Humanity to Prince George's County it's happening all across the country but I I do have a question it appears that uh stop finder stop finding children a long time ago and we've consistently had issues with it um have at any point at any juncture did we consider a new vendor um to to be able to do this uh my granddad used to say if it's not broke don't fix it this seems to be broke and so how do we actually
149find a way to fix stop find do the good folks in West failure blew me up um about this issue with stop finder and my second question is um it appears that it's still taking too long to get to get to school although we've changed school start times is that working thank you so much director Balman can you just speak to the functionality of the stock finder app ver um as we talk about the Geo alerts versus just the basic signup and how we're trying to move to that greater level of functionality and then we'll address the second I think what might be helpful on top of that is that if we can provide um a um just just a reflection back of where we started because there was a lot of conversation before a
150number of our newer board members came on about this things have been going much better until until the the storm most recently much better uh the improvements have have have really really come around so what we'd like to do is maybe develop a small group of those of you that may not have had an opportunity to see kind of where we came from to to where we are uh I think it will be extremely helpful to to give some insight around uh stop finder and just the whole process as a whole I can certainly respect that superintendent house and and the last piece thank you for that superintendent house the other piece is when um director Balwin put up the executive summary uh that's in the presentation that looks at us from school year uh
151uh October of 23 to present you can see tangible evidence from a third party independent Consulting Group that is looking at our data and assessing whether or not we're getting better staying the same or getting worse and there are clear metrics in the numbers that are showing that we are getting better we're utilizing our buses more effectively with putting more students on without overcrowding we are uh creating trips uh uh that are maximizing the amount of trips that we can do for each bus we're reducing the number of routes so that or trips so that they're becoming more efficient as well I I think we we've got to make sure parents actually feel this in some way so I I don't know how if if we're having this success how do we actually get parents
152to actually feel this in some way but good okay well good I I trust you all but the good folks in West can you turn the mic on and say that I want to hear that with the mic on I said trust me it's way better so yes thank you for the they told me they told me to trust black women so that's two of them down there so I got you board member [Music] Zakia thank you so much I know we said that we could have a separate conversation with new board members I just want to clarify for all of us here is stop finder something that we own or is stop finder a partnership with a vendor how does that work yeah it is a partnership with a vendor it is tied to
153our rounding system and to what we've said they we have had a tremendous improvement from where we were last year to this point and so uh there's some steps that need to be taken in order to maximize the use of the app and I think from that standpoint we have seen that significant increase it's technology though right and and it's as good as what we use and so we want to make sure that we push out to our families to our schools on how to use it what it takes to be used um at maximum capacity so um as part of that we've made an initiative to go out to our schools and participate in plenty of PTA meetings uh we've talked to our PSAs um to help with schools and help with parents to
154sign up because uh we need that assistance is it's a collaboration kind of with the Synergy uh component because we need a verifiable email address in order to invite parents to participate in the app and then that second part is activating and creating the jeers that's the big push uh that's needed to really maximize the the stop finder app thank you first sh thank you so much chair Jackson um so I want to start by saying echoing just the praises to the transportation team you all have been responsive from the minute that parents have been blowing our emails up saying you know this and that and at the beginning of the school year you all were really responsible and I think that that is a hard thing to do and it's um definitely gotten better
155cuz we don't have a thousand emails coming in um I do want to say though because I've made promises to you know my constituents that I would uh speak on their behalf and um and so I just want to say these things these are things that came in whether it was in September or October um that are the stories that we don't always get to hear but it's not just the numbers it's the lived experiences of people and I have a quote here that says I understand that it's a big win to go from arriving at school 30 to 45 minutes late to arriving at school 5 minutes late but could you think uh but do you think uh there is any chance to put a bit more pressure on transportation to see students arriving
156to school before class starts that was September 20124 so some things have improved um I had another parent who talked about her son who went to one of the schools on my district he wants to be an engineer um she said that since he started the school um he thought he'd be a great fit for the science and technology program but he's missing almost the entire first period every single day because it's bu bus is late um and that how she's frustrated and you know it's ridiculous and it's disappointing um um and one of the things that she mentioned was some Creative Solutions so she said you know one of the solutions is a centralized drop off area or a couple of them um it may not be a solution that fits everyone but you
157know that might be something that may fit so I know that I'm bringing all this up to say that thank you for the things that you're doing to improve the system I guess I see this is a bit of like a scientific approach where it's like you know you don't you have a theory and if it doesn't if it's not 100% then you got to go back to the drawing board and see what can I improve to get it better and I'm seeing that you know some of the feedback is how can we continue to uh improve some of the Kinks and I'm hoping that we're not just moving forward but that we're also looking back and saying these things may not be working can we rethink how we're approaching it so I'm just curious
158if you could speak to any of the Creative Solutions that you might be thinking about um yes thank you so much board member Briggs and and I just want to make certain we appreciate the um acknowledgement of progress but we're certainly not satisfied right we have a lot of work to do uh superintendent house has acknowledged this as as Transportation has remained one of his areas of focus uh with respect to the budget um there are two pillars uh when we think about Transportation one is gaining operational efficiency and the second is Staffing we're very clear that we still have nearly 200 open routes every single day a route is made up of six trips so those are staff members that have to loop back after they complete their normal run and pick up students
159and that pushes the efficiency down for for the entire system so we have to close both the efficiency gaps that we have as well as the Staffing gaps that we have to make our system run effectively and I think that will as we as we bring those of you that would love to learn a little bit more about um kind of where we started and look at some of the data from the beginning that's one of the things that will jump off the page from you still behind you know 180 drivers so uh as we approach budget season I I I urge the board to to Think Through kind of what that looks like and uh and knowing that even though our wages are are in a place where they're competitive we've got to do
160more to ensure that our uh and then we'll be thinking through uh other strategies we've you know talked about possibility of hubs and a little bit of everything but but we'll be thinking through all of those strategies but in order to truly improve uh the and get to a place where we uh are comfortable across the board uh we will have to invest in my opinion more okay well I want to say thank you for the uh for the comments and really quickly I just want to say I do want to Echo that I think it's important that we're thinking about Creative Solutions we can't solve the teacher shortage issue by wishing that there are more teachers we can't uh solve the the bus driver issue by wishing there were more more bus drivers so
161we have to be creative and work around the issues we have and I agree we are doing some of that just one example would be we created last year the non- CDL driver position that didn't exist before last year so if we couldn't find CDL Drivers we said well let's hire drivers let's create a classification and hire people who have a basic driver's license and we can transport children so we we bought the vans so that they they could uh utilize those and we picked out those trips that were specialized that would underutilize a full bus and we placed those students on those vans we've also use contractor support to help also provide uh additional uh relief from our bus drivers and so we're looking at different multimodal ways to provide more access for our
162students board member Walker yes thank you so much again kudos to the transportation department um and Dr Coleman um in overall operations you know thanks uh Vice chair Briggs for um talking about the metric as far as the reduction in not only emails but text messages door knocks uh all of the things so we appreciate our constituents continuing to write to us but one thing that I am continuing to get outside of the just for your consideration I don't need an answer tonight just my goal is to have you think through this so that we can steadily improve is um one is getting there right on time for the Bell start right we're getting to school which is great but just getting there a little bit earlier so taking a look at those routes I
163do recognize that they're continuously being um improved I know my son's route has changed multiple times either ad routes or stop route stop bus stops so thank you for that but just looking at that um continuously and then the other one is the special needs population for those specific buses because I am getting um a number of calls where those are popping up either um the access to where it is or it's shifted a little bit and it's not the the parents aren't able to get their student to that exact new bus stop so if we could just take a look at our special needs population specifically around that and optimize that I think that that would be amazing and bring us to where we ultimately want to be for operations and transportation thanks thank
164you Dr uh andil um to Echo everyone else thank you um for this presentation I I did have a question about so so looking at the at the U presentation I see there's a note that speaking to the mean trip duration and stating that it's it's essentially remaining comparable um so says 68 minutes to 62 minutes um from last year um and a lot of people here are obviously speaking to the delays um you know I'm hearing this a lot not only from constituents but also from friends um I'm you know lucky enough to live rather close to my son's school and so we don't you know experience extreme delays uh you know I understand what it feels like to wonder where your child is right and what I've had to do is put an
165air tag in my child's book bag because even though I'm extremely close to the school the app is not stop finder app is not showing me accurately when my child is left um and that's again we we're just 5 minutes down the road um but I I'm asking about this wondering if in the um the data that we're tracking are we actually tracking progress around school arrival times and delays I'd be curious to see um year-over-year um if th if those numbers are going down as we're talking about the improvements that we're seeing and using stop finder or you know just more broadly the the the progress that we're seeing with transportation and and our bus routes are we tracking that data and is that something that you could share so go ahead yes we
166are tracking that data uh we are working with our consultant formative to create um a data dashboard so that it has all of our key indicators so that we can monitor and our Trends and look at that so uh right now we are fine-tuning the data we're having to clean it up because um it is something new and between the vendor uh and the application and our current reality where we don't have enough drivers and we're having to double up it skews the system and so we had to scrub that data to make sure that we can provide the most accurate uh and and what's been showing so thus far is is an improvement um it's not where anywhere we want to be right now but it is an improvement and I feel like keep
167working um adding those components of operations and Staffing to it we can get to that point and so soon we'll be able to share with you this data and and and let you see the trends that we are are seeing thank you this will conclude our um transportation audit thank you update mve yeah we can give him a round of applause thank you gentlemen yes moving on to 15.2 special education overview of the iev process thank you Mr chair I'd like to invite uh back to the microphone our chief academic officer Dr Judy White to provide an update in reference to the IEP process and in special education Dr White thank you so much for that now the good news is that I'm not going to do all 89 slides yes because I want to
168get you out of here um we're going to cover the IEP process however I wanted to make sure that we provided a lot of information for you to look at um when you look at this next slide Charles I think I need help at first there we go okay thank you when you look at this slide this is what's in the entire presentation today we're going to talk about the IEP process but we wanted to provide you with some context of who we serve we wanted to make sure that you have information for compliance and monitoring so how are we audited how do we monitor what takes place in the district uh how many complaints do we have to go to the state what do we have to do when that happens what is our
169dashboard look like um I've also provided you with collaborative partnership information you heard one of our parents actually share tonight that last year she came and they had recommendations for us many of the things she talked about were things that we did in Partnership and and um approved improved additionally resources and um activities for our families like the amount of professional development we're doing because I always like bringing gifts you will you will find that I bring gifts to you all what you have before you you don't have to open it now but many of the links that we put inside I just wanted to make sure you had a copy the biggest thing um our strategic plan is in here but we created a toolkit just for you so we have one for our
170families that's way thicker than this but we wanted you to have the quickest the other thing I'll point out and then we'll get started is just how do we communicate with our families uh a QR code if parents come to you and they need help to the Family Support Center the email address so this these are resources for you the links are also in the pre presentation tonight I have the honor of sitting with tranell Bowman she's our associate superintendent for special education you will see us go through different slides throughout the presentation to make sure that we cover the IEP process and to make sure we talk about uh ways that you can have an advocate for your families if they reach out to your your constituents to get them to us so that
171we can help solve their problems so I will turn it over to you on who we serve thank you so much can you hear me yep I think that's um so I wanted to start by um sharing with you our demographic data as of October 1st 2023 the October first enrollment data is always our official count of data for the school district um we served 16,43 a students across the district we are a birth to age 21 state in Maryland so you can see how that breaks down through birth to five elementary middle and high school you also have on the left hand side of your folder what we call a special education program location chart we do provide a variety of services or specific specialized programs across the district so again on your leftand
172side you do have a special education program location chart it provides you with information across the district where our early childhood specialized programs are our social emotional academic development programs autism extensions autism programs our regional special education programs our comprehensive special education programs we also have a deaf and heart a hearing a parent infant program and our community reference instruction program so I wanted to make sure that you had that information um for your reference the next piece we're going to get into is the IEP process and I'm just going to provide you with a high level overview and before she goes I just want to stop really quick just to make a note um I know autism a lot of our families are asking about autism what we also have and we'll provide it
173to you I don't think we have it in the folder is the district that overlays our program so that you can see that we have autism programs all over the district and then that way you'll be able to see what boundary serves each program and you'll be able to see which programs based on this list is in your District um I know sometimes parents think oh we only have one or two the way we have specialty programs that is not the case with autism they are all over the district and as we have more students that come in um to our system we make sure that we look for schools where we have seats another thing just to note um is that our numbers for autism Trend have gone up so in 20 slide eight
174I just want to just show this really quick so when you look here in 2013 2014 look at the number of autism students we had 1,600 roughly look at 2425 if you look at 2013 2014 look at the number of autism programs we had then and if you look down that row look at where we are now if you look at just from 2020 look where we are now so I just wanted to give that context because I know many of you get a lot of questions about autism now this doesn't even mean the autism students that are in our comprehensive schools this is simply the autism students that are in our specialty Pro special programs for autism all right so when we look at special education there's two laws that govern what we do
175in Maryland first we have our Federal Regulation which is the individuals with disabilities Education Act and then we have our code of Maryland regulations Maryland is very unique in that there are several regulations that we have in Maryland that govern special education process that you will not find in other states you also may find that in Maryland we start certain services at an earlier age so for example in Maryland our secondary transition Services if you look at idea those services start at age 16 when a student must have a transition plan but in Maryland they start at 14 so that's just an example of some shifts that we have in our code of Marland regulations that you will not find in idea this um just provides you with the flowchart of our special education process
176so it always starts with a referral and a referral can be made by a parent or Guardian it can also be made by a staff member for students who are in our impis and toddlers program a referral may even come in from the pediatrician um so referrals come in a variety of ways particularly based on the age of the child when we look at the referral we have to then determine if we have to conduct an evaluation based on the referral so if the referral comes in that they suspect that a student has a disability we look at that information there may be outside assessments that the student or the family has already gone through that we can actually use so we have this evaluation process that that we look at also doing the evaluation
177process we're determining if we need additional assessments so do we need a psychological do we need an educational assessment does a student have fine motor difficulties that may call for an occupational um therapy assessment so we look at all that during that evaluation process then we determine if the child is eligible we have 14 different disability categories around eligibility we're really looking at educational impact so just because a student has autism does not mean that they may require an IEP so it's really about educational impact that requires specialized services for us to also Implement specially designed instruction such as accommodations simply AIDS and services Etc each year um we do also have to look at other things part of the annual review process which I'll get into if the student is found eligible again under
178those 14 different disability categories we then have to develop an IEP for that student we also have to get consent to implement the first IEP so a parent actually has to physically sign for services to implement the initial IEP we then Implement that IEP and then we progress monitor the IEP um I want you to know that each quarter just as we give report cards in addition to giving report cards if a student has an IEP we also have to give an IEP progress report that gives parents information around the progress that their child is making around IEP goals and then every single year we have to have what we call an annual review meeting where we actually look at the IEP and services and determine if any adjustments for goals related Services accommodations Etc
179are needed the other important piece around the annual review is that we have to determine every single child so you saw the number earlier 16,43 students with IEP every year we have to determine if they qualify for extended school year Services those are services that happen as part of our summer school program in the district and so every student has to be reviewed and then once a student turns 14 we then have to develop a transition plan to talk about postsecondary goals and outcomes is a student going to college is a student going through a CTE pathway Etc there are a lot of timelines associated with special education processes um this is a flowchart that gives you all of the various timelines we are required to follow remember some of these most of the timelines
180are under Ida but some of them are under the state of Maryland code of regulations we have a very active family and advocacy in the state of Maryland and years ago they advocated for what we call the Maryland five-day rule we are the only state that has a 5-day rule the five-day rule means five business days before an IEP meeting is held we must provide the parent with a copy of data assessment reports anything that we're going to review with the parent we have to provide that to them 5 days before an IEP meeting after the IEP meeting is held any updates to the IEP any amendments to assessment reports Etc we also have to provide that 5 days after the IEP meeting that also includes what we call a prior written notice which is
181basically the me meeting minutes of what happened what decisions were made what actions were proposed what actions were rejected and what any next ups are concerning the student um also highlighted here is that we do have to provide notification for an I meeting 10 days before 10 calendar calendar days we do have to uh make sure that the families are aware of a meeting taking place there are Provisions um to wave the 10-day notice if the parent does give consent in Maryland again this is another Maryland code of Maryland regulations that you won't find in idea there are certain parameters that we have around consent that is beyond the initial implementation of services so for example if a student is going to be on an alternate educational framework parents must give consent um as part
182of the IEP process if we're going to use seclusion um at our non-public schools or restraint in our non-public and public schools a parent has to give consent for that to be implemented as part of a behavior intervention plan those are just two examples that I can give you that are beyond the traditional idea regulations we also have um 30 days to convene a meeting if um we're looking at um suspected disability for eligibility um we also have to make sure that we translate um IEPs into our highest languages in Prince George's County so this is another Maryland regulation you won't find an idea if 1% of our population is reflected um as English Learners in our district we have to translate upon parent request the IP and prior written notice in our district those
183two languages are Spanish and French and we look at that data every year if a third language emerges as 1% of our population we will be also translating those documents upon parent requests um when we look at the calendar timeline from consent again a parent must give consent for assessments it is a 90-day window um to through that development of the IEP and then every three years we have to look at continued eligibility does this child continue to qualify for special education services that has to be done a minimum of every three years for continued eligibility it does not necessarily mean that we assess the student at that three-year Mark but we do have to do that evaluation sometimes IP teams May request an evaluation to be done year L um and not at the
184threeyear mark But at minimum we have to do it every 3 years and then again yearly we have to determine eligibility for extended school year services and then what I just want to point out here you see the timeline when later on in the presentation when you're reviewing it on your own you'll notice for any um findings that we may have it could be that we missed anything in here it could be something simple that we didn't do it in 5 days we did it in six so just keep that in mind with the tight timeline and again the referral process I did highlight this we are obligated if we suspect that a child has a disability to convene an IP meeting and have that discussion so keep in mind a staff member or parent
185and guard or Guardian can refer to the IEP team if they suspect that a child has a disability the other important piece around our referral process is that a student could be going through our respon to intervention or multi-tiered systems of support and also going through the eligibility process for special ed and so those systems are not synonymous with one another but um students could be going through them um at the same time again once the request has been received an IEP meeting will be schedule to discuss the concerns and any pertinent information at times we are able to qualify the student without doing our own assessments particularly again students have outside assessments so we take that all into um account so we just want to quickly that's that is the IEP process these additional
186slides here these are just sections that are in the IEP we wanted you to be aware if you look so every time we do an IP the teachers must complete every last one of those sections additionally um dismissal from Special A quickly just talk about that part so I just want everyone to know that um if a parent or the IEP team believes a student has made um progress and no longer requires specialist Services we must do an evaluation before we dismiss them from special education services um and so that just is giving you a little bit of information about that and then we document that decision as part of the process we did provide you with a link so you can go on our YouTube channel and watch a deeper dive of the IEP
187process um to get more information all right here we know this is what you really want to know when your constituents are emailing you and they want to know how to resolve these are the steps that we need you to help them with did they contact their case manager every single student has a case manager at their school if that didn't work did they communicate with the principal so we just wanted you to have that there we've also provided and it's in your folder a resolution contact list here are ways that we resolve disagreements formally we can we have mediation we have due process and or they can go to the state it is a parent right to go to the state we don't stop them from doing so myths so these are just a
188couple of myths and facts that we wanted to share with you that we often hear um one is around the school district is in charge of the students placement and making those decisions all decision that govern a student's placement in terms of where the IEP is going to be implemented must be made through the IEP team process um sometimes we often get or hear that a 50 plan 504 plan is the same as an IEP um and we want you to know that under Section 504 of The Rehabilitation Act of 1973 it does apply to looking at students who may have a substantial limit of a major life function and only require accommodations with special education and IEPs it really looks at specially designed instruction and additional services that the I that the 504 may
189not be able to uh provide the other big piece is that a student who is provided with special education services must receive comp services or compensatory education services um if there is a vacancy for example um not all students may qualify for compensatory Services if there are Miss Services we have a very robust data analysis process that we follow follow that we look at um and again if the student has made pro progress in spite of a vacancy as an example they may not be educationally impacted and just to give you a glimpse of um percentages when we went through covid every single child in the district had to be reviewed with an IEP and only about 20% of them qualify for comp services and then the last myth is if a student has an
190IEP all issues should be resolved by the IEP team of the Department of special education and we want to make make it clear um that not all issue all issues that may emerge with a student with an IEP requires the department of special education to support or requires the Family Support Center um for example if there's issues around grading or extracurricular activities or the interaction with a staff member and a student those really should be addressed and handled at the school level rather than through the IEP or Department of special education all these wonderful things I know you all are going to ask me questions about later on CU you're going to have a chance to review and learn but here I just wanted to point out again because we appreciate all that you do
191for us and we want you to understand this was built solely for you this was something that we did this year to make sure that you all had tools to understand we made it really simplistic um as we could to just give you support here we just want to talk about so how can you support families right and we talked about this earlier encourage them to reach out to their case manager um if the school isn't responsive every every school has an area office we have the Family Support Center we've provided you with that information and you all know a way to get in touch with me if all else fails there is a way to get to me and I will ensure it gets to the right office here it's in your folder is
192the QR code for our families this is posted here's the number to the Family Support Center just a note about the Family Support Center Maryland msde make sure that every single Lea in Maryland has one Prince George's County is the only one that puts three additional staff to our family support center and with that that wraps us up about the IEP process thank you for your presentation board members um before we start taking questions I want us to be uh cognizant of the time and we will not be doing two rounds so um the time that's a lotted um the two what is it two minutes two and a half minutes um will be the time to ask the question and for um the rebuttal um so thank you so the first person I want
193to recognize is number seven on that is board member Brown yes thank you so I saw I did go over this the slides two slides 35 and 36 uh discuss violations that were trending can you kind of talk about if it was operational if it was a training like what areas of opportunity do we have to I I guess limit those violations so what I can share with you is we do have a top five that we shareed with principles in terms of as we look at our complaints I'm happy to share that information with you in terms of our top five um violations we do have what we call procedural and substantive violations procedural things like the five-day rule as Dr White alluded to earlier we might we probably did not meet a specific
194timeline and then we have U substantive violations where we make may have a vacancy um for a special education teacher and that might have caused us to have to have an IEP meeting for educational impact but I can definitely provide you with our Trend data we do share that each year with our principles and really help them focus on what is the issue how do I plan for this issue how do I implement this issue and how do I monitor it so I'll be happy to share that presentation with you so that you can see what our Trend data looks like m brown okay thank you uh next I have um board member booer Str yeah thank you so much I just I wanted to understand better why Section 504 services are under Department of
195student services and not special education department because I keep running into a circle of that and I and honestly I keep forgetting and so uh can you just give us clarity about why that is in the organizational chart and supervisory structure thing you I would say since I've been in this District uh off and on for 28 years they've always been under the department of student services if you even if you look at the state level um they are actually operating under the division of like Family Support Services um and so I probably couldn't I'm probably not the best person to articulate why they're sitting under student services I will say districtwide it's pretty much an even split in some districts they are under the department of special education and in some districts they are
196under um the department of student services and that's pretty an even split even throughout the country I would say historically I I when I came to the district it was that way yeah the other thing I would add to it um and chief Davis I know um may want to add to it is that the professional school counselors are kind of like the case manager of the 504 which could be another reason why as a district they're under student services because it's the professional school counselor who does serve as the for coordinator at every single school so that's another bit of information I could share yeah that's helpful and I I think it's just kind of holding on to that path that organizational pathway when it would seem so logical that it it would be
197under the special education division completely and there are a lot of things that cross cross both and so our associate superintendent Elizabeth fison and Trel work hand inand because there many things coming from this state that are split but together that's helpful thank you that's my only question tonight thank you uh board member wer thank you so much awesome presentation as usual ladies um first question I have two questions and we're going to knock it out in two and a half minutes okay the first is around the measurement of compliance and the second piece is around monitoring our Educators so the first one is for the measurement of of compliance what is the review process in the school at the school and District level to ensure that we um are following the processes and ensuring
198that our IEP process meets the federal standards okay so that's the first one around measurement of compliance and the second question that I have for you if you get to it if not you can email me because the first one's really important um is around special Educators I get a couple of questions around you know these special Educators they might not be there they might have left and then the the the scholars the general population for the general teachers and so I was just wondering if we kept an eye on that and then especially as we move into budget season is there anything that we should look at for the need for our special Educators if they're lacking um and if they're if our Scholars are really going into general population if they need to
199be specialized so I'll take I'll answer the first one the quickest answer I would give you is Prince George's County unlike most districts created our own data dashboard that in a moments we can go in like this and look at all of our compliance data we also as a system through our um Chief uh Zuckerman are able to send out an email every single week that goes at every school for every IEP that's out um uh out of compliance right and so we're able to quickly say as soon as I see it I'm like how are we helping this school how it allows us to know the other thing I will say is that we have an seis assigned to every single school so the average case load in our CSI schools is probably about
200eight and everywhere else is probably about 12 and they're meeting with those principles they keep Google um docs rolling agendas where we can go in at a moment's notice and look up a kid's case we can look up the conversation but the data Dash board you all have um sample in your folder of the type of reports that we keep and then we also provided you with just an example of our January special at accountability checklist just so that you can take a look at to see what some of the items are that are included on that and then I think your second question was just around how do we support so we always make the best decision as it relates to program and placement which is through the IEP team process there may be
201support plans that are being implemented that may look very different because of our vacancies but we continue to look at that um and to to really be able to think about how we can best support our students in spite of the vacancies and we've leveraged if you go to um one of the last PowerPoint slides it talks about our challenges I think I believe it's slide 88 it does give you some of the things that we've done um to really look at our challenges and how we overcome that which will give you I think some information of the things that we have tried thank you as it relates to that thank you all right so uh next I have uh Dr Moss followed by Dr andul followed by board member Sakia yeah first of all
202I want to say as complimentary as you all were of the transportation department I want to be of that of the special education department these good folks spent their Christmas walking me through all of my questions uh and reing me in where I was wrong and I so I so much so appreciate them for their work um but I there was one thing that you all did not highlight that I think is super important um many of the issues that we face with regard to special education uh are really around customer service and I'd like for you all to talk a little bit about the process that you have to ensure that we have better customer service and parent relationships what we heard in public comment today was really parents not having a good experience
203not issues of compliance and you've done some good work to rectify that so uh in the balance of my time I hope you all can do that so the quick answer to that is number one we have the Family Support Center we do professional development um for all of them with Dr Davis we're really working at the school level is it's if you look at all the complaints even the ones that you get into your emails it's I would say 90% don't even talk about the education experience it's about how they would talk to so one of the things based on actually parent Smith that's in the audience is do we surve a parents so at the end of every single IP meeting they're able to take a survey out of over 600 parents that
204have filled out that survey with the highest rank being a five we're averaging a 4.5 when I get that every other week and I look at it where I see ones I look at that school and I go down and I look at that school to see if I see other ones or twos and what we're seeing are isolated incidents but it allows us then to work with school teams to find out how we can support and how we can work collaboratively with those families that's a quick answer of of an example of how we're supporting our families and I'd like just to to add as as mentioned earlier we we have a few different Focus uh areas that uh that we're uh really pushing in our principal's meeting is on top of math and
205literacy uh as well as attendance uh building uh capacity through coaching and feedback as I indicated but uh to really speak to what you're talking about there is a major Focus this year on strengthening School culture uh and climate uh and this is a a part of what customer service is so it's a concerted effort throughout the district with every principal with every principal meeting that we're working on uh is to uh improve uh that experience that parents have uh coming into our buildings Dr anille um yes thank you so much um for this um I have a specific question um about a slide that I know you did not present on tonight so it's slide 11 on the number of students who exited special education that Trend data um so ages 14 to 21
206while um a small percentage looks like about 12% for the 223 count I'm curious about um this year or in 2023 the increase in the number of students who dropped out um so with that being their exit reason whereas looking like from 2019 until then we were declining I'm wondering if you can shed any light on anything that you've learned about that increase from last year with that being an exit reason and so I as part of our exit data when we look at the students who have dropped out um we do see that there is an increase in the ninth grade year particularly and that Trends with our general ed students who actually drop out in nth grade grade and so we are building some strategies around um looking at that particular population we
207also see with our special data that our um multilingual learner population definitely are are ones that we are really concerned about and part of that is the need once they get to a certain age to be able to help the family and work and so we do see um that particular population is one that we definitely want to focus on that where we see a higher dropout rate and we do have an improvement plan that really focuses on that that I can share okay so are you saying that you believe that one of the contributing factors for the increase from 2022 to 2023 is our um so we are increasing just um as a district with our multilingual population okay so that switches yes got it okay thank you MH I want to EO uh
208board member M's excuse me Dr mes um complimentary statements about the special education department I really appreciate you all answering questions and making sure we are understood several of my questions have been answered my only I guess question request for things like this was slide 11 that uh Dr en just referenced can we get percentages as well so we can better compare how things are changing year-to year and also on that question are we able to get a comparison for the percentages of students in the nth grade overall that are dropping out as well as our um excuse me as well as our um all of the population that you're rep you are referencing specifically just so that we can compare them and better be able to respond to constituents when they have questions thank
209you VI chair all right thank you so much chair Jackson um so I want to Echo the thanks to uh you all on the presentation for special education um and I also wanted to turn just attention to uh I think it was slide 37 and it talked about um violations and legal fees and I think one of the one of my colleagues brought up um that piece and so I wanted to just put two three questions on the record um that are already included in our tracker that is uh concerning the budget that I'm pretty sure Dr White you may have saw earlier today um so the question was can you provide details on PG cps's expenditures to contract attorneys for school year 23 24 um can you provide details of PG P cps's expenditures
210on PGCPS is attorneys sorry my computer just did something weird um and staff and appeals litigation for school year 23 24 and can you provide details of the total settlement cost incurred in school year 23 and school year 24 um and really just CU I want to know more about how that may be disproportionally impacting families that have to go through litigation and legal processes and things like that will when we answer those questions you'll receive that back from um Chief how thank you see as there's no no more lights uh we'll move on to the next section um I want to recognize superintendent house would iend agenda thank you Mr chair uh as as as you noted items 15.1 and through 15 um 4 require board approval of proclamations really commemorating the observation of
211African-American um uh African-American uh read in uh month observation of national African-American history month observation of career and Technology Education Month observation of African-American readin month um also during the month of February 2025 the uh the approval of of the 20 2526 calendar as well so at this time uh I will read off each well at this time I'll turn it back over you for for approval thank you board members would you like to pull any of these items for discussion under general orders pulling an item does not denote a no it indicates a desire to discuss further if there are no objections the consent agenda items 15.1 through 15.4 will be adopted there is no unfinished business moving to general orders there's no general order and then yeah new business um Lolita I know
212you I think we going to do it under new business yeah the part Okay cool so little business um are there any questions about the February 2 7th meeting this is under new business all right recognize board member Walker you asked if there were any questions about the February yes I have I don't know yes I doation thank you yes I did I was hoping that you could talk to us a little bit about so I recall in our last meeting that the board voted favorably to have um meetings at the counc building as we talked about that the original request was for January February and March with the Strategic view to have them their long term and the reason that January February and March came up was because um there were questions around the
213feasibility and doing things on data as far as what the financial and logistical um feasibility was and at that time superintendent house said hey let us take a look at this and see what it's going to cost us Etc so I recognize now that we we didn't have it in January understand because we were still looking at the feasibility at least that's what I understood and so I was just hoping you could help me with um how the decision is made to move there for February and March without the data coming back and then maybe if you you might already have that data there but if in fact we're going there which it does seem like it and I'll be there as well for February and March can you just help me with what the
214Strategic plan is what the long-term plan is so we can recognize the value ad of going there for February and March thank you so much and what the impact is financially and logistically thank you for that question U the board chair recognizes uh R Mr Fitzpatrick thank you thank you chairman Jackson well while of course I cannot speak to the Strategic goals of Shifting to the Wayne Curry building what I can share is what staff did in investigation and working with members of superintendent houses team Dr Zuckerman uh Chief boy and seeing if the pilot was feasible and so we did tour we did a tour of the wne Cory building we have had back I W say back door but back room conversations about if the tech will work and those sorts of things
215and what we have determined is that there's nothing at this point that's stopping us from doing the three um three meeting pilot what has been abundantly clear to to me as well is that that is for the three meeting pilot um our counterpart at the way Curry building said that she is allowing us to use that room for free because as we have learned with their Tech and their security they will have to pay their staff they're not charging us for that for the pilot that will change if it's something longterm so we don't have the exact numbers of the long-term impact but we have determined that the it is feasible to do the pilot and I think that's what I took away as the ask from the last meeting yeah I'm sorry let me
216thank you so much can I re come back to that um because that didn't quite answer the question that I I had yeah we can come back come yeah go I could go to a second round some okay um thank you for that and I really do appreciate that perspective from the meeting last time um the specific question that I'm asking to you chair um and Rell you might be able to help with this is if we don't know the financial impact I recognize that the board voted favorably and I'm in favor because the board voted favorably so don't misunderstand what I'm looking for is if we're moving there for February and March help me understand where do you see our vision long term because we're doing this for a reason we're not just going
217somewhere for two for two meetings and then coming back we have to have a strategic Vision on where it is that we want to go and for the reason now what it was brought to us was it'll be better for our constituents to get there because um it's better for transportation that's that's not true for District 9 and I'm not sure the feasibility for that for other districts because the data wasn't there so I'm in for where we go as a board We Are One voice and I'll be there for the next two or three months wherever we're going I'm just looking for what is the Strategic vision for where it is we're going are we moving there longer term is that the goal that we're not going to leverage this building but to leverage
218that building is that where you want to go and if that is the case then please help me with what the data is that supports us doing that work that's really what the question is thank you thank you I just uh I appreciate the question but I I want to make sure that we're careful of um who the I guess as a board chair um my duty is to carry out the will of the board um the board voted to move um or to do a pilot for three um meetings at the Wayne Curry building uh so I was task with uh seeing the logistics and the feasibility um from a financial standpoint um as far as like the Strategic Vision when the motion was being made uh I didn't make that motion so I
219don't have the vision of what was behind it um I guess I'm left with the same uh ability to make the assumption that the pilot which most Pilots is to kind of test to see if I guess if the if it was more um amable or was it um you know better for constituents to get to a more centrally located um venue um would it be more um you know I think that's pretty much what the pilot was for but as far as like the Strategic Vision overall I think that after the pilot is done we could have data um and then I think we can go uh in whatever direction we uh see fit after we collect data um from the pilot uh but yeah so as far as the Strategic vision for uh
220moving this um operation it was the will of the board so I just carried it out thank you uh for was 13 I think it was uh count uh board member Boer strs thank you so much um so I mean I'm still back at the open meetings act uh question and I need Mr Swift involved here because as a board member my constituents expect me to have a set of data before I vote so this came up as from a dep now a a resigned board member who brought it up on the floor during new business didn't hand out any data didn't provide us with anything before we voted um made an argument that it was better for a constituent access through public transportation which which I looked up a bunch of routes it will
221take two hours from the you know from L lell Elementary is the middle of my district it will take you two hours to get there uh there's no bus to go home at 10:13 so that argument didn't work so uh sure it'll save me 20 minutes of driving but I don't think it changes you know the the it that's not the reason and then I suggested well if we want more uh participation why don't we have a video testimony so you don't have to drive to SAS or yay for the for the constituents in District 3 right more access for parents but there's no argument right now about why to be in that building based on the original but I also think it's an open meetings act violation so Mr Swift when a board member
222Mr Swift point of order Mr chairman M Mr Swift when when word Mr chairman Mr Swift may ask a a a parliamentarian question and it is my I have my time one we can pause it you got one minute left I do because other board members had this information it was clear that not all board members were given the information I would like I would like Mr Swift to tell us about the open meting I understand okay Mr Swift can you uh speak to the violation or possible violation I'm not sure what the question is there you go not sure so during the last board meeting not sure what your question is during the last board meeting under new business a board member brought forward a motion with no data you know as board members
223I think most people know we have at least a document that gives us Data before a vote so we're informed um and the vote went through under new business and I I think it's a you know then we were told we would have information by tonight which we were not we've received no documentation as of tonight which we were told we would Mr chair this an open meeting act violation I've got a point of order Mr chairman point when when I raise a point of order it actually stands over whatever conversation is actually happening I I'm curious if in this moment we are asking our parliamentarian to relegate a vote that has already happened by this body in our previous meeting and if that is in order and consistent with parliamentary procedure I would ask
224that the parliamentarian address that issue because it seems that we're relegating a decision that this board made and and may I might I add a majority of this board actually made and so it would need to be overturned with another motion so could you speak um if this board is in order to relegate a decision it's already been made particularly in new business uh where I don't believe our policy provides for us uh to actually move on an item that was not uh moved forward before the meeting agenda was set which runs contrary uh to the argument that's being made around o uh open meetings act so could you speak to that Mr parliamentarian the answer to the one question about relegating I have no Authority whatsoever uh before any board client so I know
225I don't relegate any votes I'm not sure what the other board member was getting at with the explanation but my point is what the chairman said in that which was correct uh there was a motion it was discussed and it was uh voted at least six in the affirmative since then pilot information or information has been obtained by Mr Fitzpatrick to run a pilot and basically that's the way it stands another member excuse me one minute only because of the size my statement stands they made a motion it was adoped so that's that's I I agree with what you said yes so I have 54 seconds probably not but we I'm going to be courteous because you spoke way more of your time but go for it Go For It Go for the yes you
226did my I was I don't want to too much go go for it I make a motion to re send the motion to to leave our Chambers and go to the County council chambers point of order Mr chairman uh a motion was made and there was no second on so we should we proceed with the remainder of the agenda need a second don't need we don't need a second in this group because of a small group we just vote but it will have to take um seven votes in order for this motion to pass so uh Miss partner oh discussion excuse me first discussion number seven uh number 13 okay so as uh first uh Jamal Jango oh thank you um um thank you Mr chairman um my first um question IAM I just want
227to clarify so um I think the main um point that I've been hearing is if we move to the Wayne Curry um building are we violating the open meetings act um are we violating the open meetings act can anybody answer that question is it a yes or a no he said no no okay um then I wanted to ask okay um I'm I the next thing I heard was about data um making sure that um well the first the re since we since in December when we had um the when the motion um came to the um table it wasn't we didn't have no um relative data to kind of substantiate the um the motion um I do see um us now having that pilot this three Monon pilot being able to collect the data
228that we need so that we're able to come back after those 2 3 months and actually you know make a decision on whether we want to move headquarters huh no no no I was talking oh yeah whether we want to move headquarters um to see if it's you know if it's easier for it I feel like it's based off of our um our part participation because if we look at let's say this board meeting December um and November's board um board meetings we do have a log of every single person that comes into the Sasser building for a board meeting and then in the next 3 months we'll now have um a log of the people that come to a um way Curry building for um the Prince George's Board of Education meeting and then
229we'll be able to see that that's like that's a sense of data that we're I think that I hear um board member R sh and board member Walker kind of talk about I feel like that's the only way we'll really see the benefit of um having a um having our location moved but um that was just really it I think um that could really um we could I feel like it's a good idea we just got to see how it works so that we can know if we want to really truly start um exploring options for a permanent location Mr chairman I have an additional point of order um for the parliamentarian uh would it not be true that the individual who makes a motion to resend it would need to have been in the
230prevailing side uh and in this particular vote the record would reflect that the gentle lady who raised this motion uh was actually not part of the prevailing side uh on the last vote so when you resend the vote I believe it's true that you would have need to been on the prevailing side uh to be able to make that motion for recension that's my point of order um point of order uh please don't call me gentle lady yeah on for excuse me yeah excuse me um First Direct questions to the president to the chair and if he wants me to talk he'll tell me to talk Absolut don't don't direct it to me the motion to reconsider a vote requires that the member voted on the prevailing side the motion to resend does not thank
231you Mr Swift so I recognize uh was number seven is that board member Brown yes than uh thank you chair Jackson I think this question is going to be pointed to Revel um as far as regarding closed sessions did they provide an opportunity for us to have closed sessions where there would be no recording and the that room was Secure to ensure that did did they ensure that for us I think that's going to be important because we do discuss matters in Clos session that cannot be out to the public and because this kind of is a sensitive time in Prince georgees County I want to make sure that our constituents are protected our PGCPS Community is protected and so do they provide a room that is secure when we have closed sessions thank you
232thank you uh number 13 is so are there any more questions did I get everybody okay that was the reveal okay I'm sorry I want to recognize reveal I'll wait patiently it's late man so they did assure us that the room that is provided is secure uh in additional information what is actually interesting is that it is one of the reasons that is secure is that they have a similar concern when they meet in that room that other branches of government because of course the IT people are not always on on the in the council's branch of government and so making sure that the um that their meetings also aren't recorded So they did assure us that that room that is provided for Clos session would not be recorded or and that of course not
233broadcast just a followup is there are we going to have some paperwork to ensure because if we don't like I said this is a very sensitive time in PR shortes County with the politics if something does go out are we protected go ahead what I can do is work with PGCPS staff and our legal counsil both of our legal councils to see if that's something we can uh secure thank you thank you uh 13 all right okay um I just had um one last question um this is mainly for the superintendent team um are we able well I did bring up um when we last when we first voted on this motion I did bring up about um the you know um looking for um a building I think um even superintendent house talked about
234maybe even getting a building and and renovating it into our own um headquarters for um for Sasser so I was wondering um if while we're looking at the pilot is there any like um has there been any progress on possibly starting to look for a new headquarters or no we actually are in the process of setting up small groups to to uh share insight and information and bring all board members up to site on just that okay great thank you Mr chair can I call a previous question we have a motion on the floor so previous question yes which I believe will suspend our conversation and move forward with a vote uh I recognize uh Mia can you uh please call the row question is to resend the uh I don't have the motion in
235front of me but it was the uh take a vote on the previous question first oh we have to take a vote on the previous question first seven and it takes seven to ADT seven to adopt okay please please restate can I do you have the the motion restated I don't have it in front of me point of order we're voting on the motion for a previous question uh which would close a period of debate and move forward with voting on the actual original main motion yeah shall we end debate I guess that's that's what we're voting on right now right the previous question all right I'm trying to understand this nomenclature my bad all right cool so U Mia can you please call the row shall we in debate that can you can you
236speak to this Mr parliamentarian please yes there are making me work hard tonight the Parliamentary term is previous question Jo we ordered the previous question and no one understands what that means in plain language it means shall we end debate quit talking and it takes in this case a vote of seven in the affirmative to quit talking if that's adopted then you go right to the vote on the motion to resend there will be no talking if you get seven votes to stop talking okay now miss Barton can you please call the vote Dr anderol I miss booer Str no Mr Briggs I Miss Brown I miss Goen MC I Mr JN go I Dr Moss I miss Walker I Mr Jackson I we have nine in the affirmative I'm sorry we have eight in
237the affirmative now miss Barton can you call the motion um can you call the rooll on a motion R Dr andero may miss bther I Mr Briggs no Miss Brown abstain Miss go MCC no Mr John go no Dr Moss no Miss Walker I Mr Jackson no we have two in the affirmative M chairman I'm motion to adjourn uh moving to item 20.1 uh so we're going uh motion to adjourn uh Miss Mia uh Barton can you please uh call the row oh we don't even have to so I'm sorry I'm learning no M just say motion the motion is to resend l l okay and without objection the meeting can be without objection the meeting can be adjourned gotcha all right thank you