001time is now 5:05 PM um good evening and welcome to the new year um and the January 14 2025 policy and governance committee meeting I'm Jonathan Briggs I'm chair of the committee and vice chair of the board and District Two board member um I want to welcome everyone to tonight's meeting um Miss adelen please call the role um I believe you're muted yeah my my computer just been black all right Mr BRS I'm present Miss Walker present Miss bu TR present Mr Jackson we have a c okay thank you so much with President the policy and governance committee meeting will come to order we're going to move on to agenda item 1. three um adoption of the meeting agenda um and I would like to advise the public that agenda item 4.2 policy 4113 Community
002involvement in the principal selection process will be addressed immediately following agenda item 2.1 public comments to accommodate our visiting speaker um so if there are no objections the committee shall adopt the January 14 2025 meeting agenda as amended okay there being no objections the January 14th 2025 meeting agenda is adopted as amended um we're going to move on to item 1.4 approval of the meeting minutes um so if there are no Corrections the committee shall approve the December 10 2024 meeting minutes as distributed right there being no uh Corrections the December 10th 2024 meeting minutes are approved um we're now going to move to public comment and I just want to say that registered public comment speakers can be live pre-recorded using video audio or um written communication there is one ridden public comment um
003this comment can be found on board docs um and so believe we can let in Miss um Alita Jerry cart uh with qu qual Equity access LLC uh she wrote to the board about uh board policy 4113 um so we will now turn it over to well at first I'll just see Miss ad and if she in the waiting so she just sent a r to um comment she didn't a speaking person oh yeah yeah yeah okay y that that connection wasn't happening for me um so that is on board docs for us as board members to review um and we want to thank you uh Miss Jerry Carter for your advocacy on these issues and bringing attention to some really important topics for us to consider um we'll now move to agenda item 4.2
004um policy 4113 Community involvement in the principal selection process um and I want to recognize Mrs Welsh for an overview of a policy 41 13 Community involvement in the principal selection process good evening everyone um so the um and and um I have to say that uh Cindy asked me about the policy and I said yes that's up for today I didn't realize Cindy you were saying the policy to be posted it is the one that we posted at the last meeting uh which I just pulled up to look at which I think was like one this our September meeting um but the the the comment that we received on the Community involvement in the principal selection process had to do with and I'm going to share it with first and then we are very
005fortunate to have uh Dr Christie uh Baldwin with us today because she is and she is our Chief Human Resources officer and she is going to actually talk about the process and then um give feedback to you on any questions that you have and and actually um the the recommendations so this particular parent who does have two disabled students she said that who receed the receiving special ed services that she is requesting an amendment to the uh to the to the policy and the two areas that she's the most concerned about is equal representation for families of students with disabilities currently we did revise that policy to say that one of the parents that would be selected um to uh be on the interview panel would be a parent of a child with a disability
006and she is um actually requesting that um instead of just one that we allow two parents or or um to Guardians um to be uh or family members to be on the uh to serve on the panel um in order to make sure that our students with disabilities are represented represented and then the next thing is there was a conversation at one of our meetings about the training that um uh if these parents are going to be on the on the uh panel um they maybe they need training in the area of like the rights of students with disabilities things like that and so had added language related to um Stu that these parents receiving training by the special ed citizens advisory committee seesac and she is recommending that that be removed from it that
007um first of all she doesn't feel that CAC is an accredit authoritative body for disability rights or Special Ed training um and that um that they certainly that they request that all Community involved members not just parents with students with disabilities but all parents receive training provided by uh U cred credible entities such as the Arc of Maryland disability right rights of Maryland parents place in Maryland or other recognized organizations uh specialized in displayes and special education uh rights so I believe these are the two main amendments that um we're having a conversation about that that came up in public comment uh to the policy so saying that I thought I think first would be helpful for Dr bwin to talk about the process that we go through anyway and when they're selecting the panel
008and everything and then the conversation related to these comments my turn y you're good all right uh good evening everyone happy New Years thank you for allowing me the opportunity to come and talk about my favorite hiring process which is the principal process um we know teachers have the number one impact on children but the next impact is the principal um so this is a process that in 2018 we updated the administrative procedure to actually include community members um that was not a part of the process prior to 2018 and we revamped it to include them it was very important to Administration that parents have an input and say that would then be passed on to ultimately the superintendent to have the final say and presented to the board so I'm going to go through
009the administrative procedure so that you know each step and then open it up for questions um Cindy I don't know if I have a time frame so I'm trying to practice staying because you know Vice chair Briggs is real big about being in a time frame so if there's a clock to follow just let me know otherwise I'mma just you know cut me off if I go too long okay so we start we have an administrative procedure that outlines every single step of the way we start the posting for each Academic Year the year to come on the first Monday in October so right now we are in in the 2425 school year so we have actually started the principal process for the 2526 year and we opened the pool the application process up on
010the first Monday in October and it closed on December 31st when we returned from winter break the first we do two screenings right now we're in the process of doing our first screening which is to look at those applicants who applied to determine do they meet the state requirements to be a principal in the state of Maryland um we have finished that process and now we have moved on to the second Pro uh screening which is to um go through a leadership screening because although someone holds a principal certification they may not be ready to be a principal um so our office of transformation uh leadership and continuous Improvement are in the process of doing the second screening to see if the individual is ready to um take the to do a leadership screening and
011ready to be considered for principal once that concludes we start first round interviews first round interviews are held with all with all instructional supervisors or leaders who were former principles and those individuals there are former principles and Human Resources academics School support and Leadership the instructional directors Who oversee principles as well as accountability we pull as well as the office of professional learning leadership we pull all those individuals together and we hold first round interviews for all of our candidates typically um going through first round we have probably about a maybe 50 individuals once we have our first round interviews and from there the indiv individuals who um progress past first rounds they then will be identified as an applicant in our principal pool which means they are ready to be interviewed for a school
012school specific opening when we get to the part where we're ready to go to a school specific interview that is considered second round interviews when we are ready to interview for a school specific the first thing we do is we send out a community notification to the community to explain to them the process in that notification we provide them the opportunity to complete a leadership characteristic survey because we want to know what are they interested in for the leader of their next school we also invite them anyone in that Community to be a part of the interview process we do not put limitations as far as criteria the only things we ask is that you have a flexible schedule you which means that you have to be ready at any moment in time we try
013to give 48 hour notice before the interview well for the candidates but two weeks for the at least a week before the community members to make the adjustments the interviews typically last from 8: to 4: and we you have to have uh be um have access to a very strong Wi-Fi because we do it virtually we also ask that you maintain confidentiality that is extremely important because um as you know it's a Personnel matter you're talking about selecting someone for a job the administrative procedure because and I look at uh Dr Moss because I believe he's a former principal so he he he has been through this process we do not want to overwhelm our candidates with an interview panel of 30 people so we do uh try to limit it to the average um
014where we have the potential to have almost up to 15 people on a panel which is not um unusual for a principal ship some school districts do actually go up to almost 25 but we do say no more than four faculty members from that school and anyone can ask to be on the committee uh we do say four community members we say community members because not every school has a PTA or a PTO and you have some people who don't participated in it but they are active in the community so we do say four community members we actually work with the PTA president or PTO president if they have one or Community leader to say who are some of the individuals that that we should have on here but anyone can sign up we then
015have two support staff members and then for high school specifically we do allow for two high school students that was a change I think we made uh the year before last to allow two two high school students we have those second round interviews in that interview we make it very clear to the committee you are not selecting the principal for this school you are taking very copious notes and providing us authentic feedback so that we can make a decision on who progresses to a third round so they get the candidates resumés the community panel actually makes up the interview committee questions so the instructional director will work with all the stakeholders to develop the questions we use those leadership survey characteristics to kind of fine-tune those questions and then we actually go through the interview
016after every candidate we talk about what the strengths of the interview were and what were the challenges or opportunities at the end we ask each individual member to say do you recommend do you highly recommend that this candidate move to a third round do you recommend that they move to a third round do you recommend with reservation meaning they didn't say something in the interview that you would like the superintendent to follow up with in a third round interview or there's some things that I'm a little concerned about so how how will the instructional director help this candidate and then there is do not recommend like don't even waste your time having this person go for a third round we take all of that we put it in a folder we present it to our
017chief of school support and Leadership on behalf of the superintendent and then we hold our third round and it could be in that meeting we interview reinv everybody again we could look at the person who had the most highly recommended we could look at um a mix uh depends on what we get in that um portfolio of feedback from the community the leadership characteristic surveys that the community has completed as well as any other resources um or feedback that we've received about the candidate um from there the chief of schools and I discussed the candidates with the superintendent and then a final recommendation is sent to the board for hiring so that concludes our process um I would have to say that I want to just stress that anyone can be on the committee as
018long as they can meet the criteria of being flexible and maintaining confidentiality um and I think I'm going to stop there and see what questions you might have for me okay thank you so much uh Dr bwin um colleagues are there any questions for Dr ball before we move forward here on this policy um and want to say for just new members that I'm going to recognize you in the order of your raised hand so please raise your hand if you'd like to speak um if for some reason you can't raise your hand then come off mute and then I'll um Q you in line um so I'll go with um board member Walker first thank you so much um Dr Balwin thank you for that um I didn't realize all of the different steps
019in the process so appreciate that when you talked about Community input and that there is a notification that goes out advising the community How does it go out um because I've had a couple of principles inside of District 9 but I don't remember getting anything however I'm wondering if it goes out to the school Community or did you mean like districtwide thank you it actually goes out to the school community so we work with uh Communications to posted on the school website we also work with the ID and the principal of the current school to send it out in their um whatever format they send out information to their community so it's open to the larger Community if they pursue the website but open specifically to the individuals within the community because um they're on
020the principal list serve and so we s got it so it's probably things like Class Dojo or their Google pro through or if you're on the PTA distribution list got it thank you so much okay um we're going to go to board member sh next yeah thank you so much um so can you uh talk about some of the average time frames from knowing there's an opening to having to host the panels to make a decision because I certainly have seen from a lot of notice because there's been an interim comes in during the year to a rush situation after that final date where a principal can say they would they're leaving or transferring if you could cover that a little bit because that impacts a mass aspects of the preparation uh of the individuals
021from the school school-based Community individuals thank you sure so just to uh clarify there is no final date on which a principal can inform an individual whether they're going to separate from the district whether through retirement or resignation there is no no date um it is a challenge when people retire midy year um just because it is although we have a principal pool um to pull together community members and if we're talking about some of our high school students to put them on a committee it can be a challenge um and so what we do try to do is actually wait to the more optimal time to u f the position and we really Human Resources really relies a lot on the division of school support and Leadership on when is the best time um
022often times we find that we'll have an assistant principal who's already at the school that may be in the principal pool and this is a great opportunity for them to get some hands-on experience and we can watch from there or we ask one of our retirees to come back until we can go to the spring because also when we open up our pool we want to make sure that we are allowing for external individuals to maybe also come and join us in PGCPS so our end goal is always to be fully staed in the principal Ship by July 1 um because the summer Leadership uh Institute always is the last week in July uh one of our challenges is make is just getting our current principles to give us enough notice of their separation if
023we don't have adequate notice it can become a challenge to staff in a time frame um that we would prefer yeah that's that's very helpful so sometimes when we've seen these August rushed panels that's just that's rare is what you're saying that there we shouldn't expect too many many times that that would happen correct so I will say right now we will be ready to hire um by February 15 right now I only have two vacancies at the principal ship so if I have a a principal who decides that they're going to retire in July but we don't get the notice till July um it can become I mean we have a pool we'll hold the interviews but trying to get everyone together and people are on their family vacations and things like that it
024it can be a challenge all right thank you so much you're welcome okay um just want to clarify that we tend to go to board members first um but board member Walker since you've had your first round if you are okay I'm going to go to Dr Moss and then come back to you um okay so Dr Moss yeah I I don't really have a question but I think it's always important that we uh that we highlight our work when it's actually really good work uh I just think this is a really good process I just want to highlight Dr ball and her team and thank you all for this work particularly the stakeholder engagement process um I actually have seen uh notices um I think it was one for suland high school when we
025were getting ready um so I just want to appreciate that that work and just kind of highlight and Elevate that I I felt it before board member but I also want to give accommodations when it's good so um I don't have any questions um but I did want to to raise that at this at this Junction and I apologize board member bra it I didn't raise it as a question nope no problem at all I'm we're going to head to um board member Walker thanks um yeah uh Dr Balwin just a real quick one if um thanks for mentioning assistant principal pool so if an assistant principal is in the pool is the that is from that school is there a different type of consideration that they get because of familiarity or of the school
026or are they in the same pool um in criteria as other Vice principles who also apply from either within our district or outside of our district I got a question about that before and I just it's a it's a good time to ask thanks um it's actually a great question um and something we run up all the time so we do have everyone who's in the who's in the pool um if we have a opening at Snow Elementary School and there's already assistant principal there that is in the principal pool um with conversation we will if it's determined that we will go through the full process because the one thing I do want to appoint the administrative procedure at any point the superintendent can appoint someone um if it's one of those things where the
027assistant principal is kind of already leading a lot of stuff and has done an excellent job the superintendent could exercise his or her right to just appoint that assistant principal if they're in the pool um because there's also parts of the Union contract that we have to follow as well um there's but we do like to have the interview process so the community members have their input but also sometimes believe it or not you will find assistant principles are not always uh willing and again you know Dr Moss may want jump in they're not always willing to follow behind their principle um because they want to establish who they are as a leader and and their opportunity so that also becomes a challenge and I know that I've experienced that with some of you as
028board members where your constituents are saying we want X but what you may not know and I know is that ex is like I don't I don't want to be here I want I want to establish my own self and my own school so um that's why we try to have the panel so that it allows um for a mutual agreement okay hearing a pause I'm assuming you're done bmer Walker we'll move to uh bmer bo Str and then I did have a question myself okay thank you um so one of the things we were resolving in this September version is um one the very important addition of being very specific that a parent of a student receiving 504 or IEP um other student receiving those Services be specifically added you know as a criteria
029for the for the makeup of the committee and then but there was this line in there that we were dealing with an e um when possible the parent should have taken advantage of training provided by special education citizens advisory committee prior to participating in the interview process and I think what you know what we were pointing out is that the idea that there's time to even be trained in any capacity is just not really there like trained to participate as an interviewee might happen sort of like right in the moment but this added criteria that you've been to a secac meeting or some type of training Robin it's my understanding that uh I'm Sorry Miss Welsh it's my understanding that this is still sitting in the the draft right and we that yeah I mean
030I I of course you know spoke you know previously that you know in support of the spe specific seat but I thought the um having been part of cak just may not be realistic in a lot of school communities for the same reason there may not be PTO or ptas access you know having had access so I just wanted to make sure we didn't lose sight of that um that that that's some of the things we're trying to resolve here and so I guess Dr bwin what I was getting at is the re the reality of when you were invited into this at first you see the announcement you put your name in this this is very quick process right like the the concept of being trained if you could explain what being trained for
031this process is sure so um I'm actually happy about that conversation just if you don't know I'm a former director of special education I know Robin is as well so you know that's one of the things that will be always near and dear to our heart as our our babies with disabilities um I did see that in there and I would gently give push back on that just because if you go back to what I said what happens during the school specific interview that parents is only giving input on who should go to a third round so to require um that parent to go through a specific training while I I I you know as a former director of special education running cak meetings it's great but at theend end of the day I'm not
032clear as to how that training would help them to be a quote unquote better panel member as much as um making sure they participate in the sense of like do we have a special education question was that individual in their interview did they talk about the students with disabilities did they talk about our L population what is the data on that what is their entry plan going to look like um those are things that we're looking at because you know at the end at the end of the day you're interviewing someone to see are they ready to lead this charge so I'm not really clear on how that training would make someone able to give feedback on whether they should go to a third round because at the end of the day they're not selecting
033the principal all right thank you so much for going a little deeper with that I appreciate it okay thank you so much for that um seeing no other hands I'm just going to chime in here Dr bwin I wanted to clarify a few things see I know you said that I have this down as a note that I wrote so likely you said the correct thing and I'm trying to clarify what it is there's the first screening of applicants um and the requirements for being a principal what group is that that's actually um a part of that first screening um they meet the requirements for being a principal the first screening is done solely by human resources because you have to make sure that you meet the state requirement okay and then the second uh
034screening is also done by human resources or is it different group the second screening is done by the office of transformation leadership and continuous Improvement who run Who oversee the principal leadership programs that used to be under human resources in our office of professional learning and Leadership but that transition to transformation Contin leadership and continuous Improvement okay all right so that's the vetting process of like do they just meet the basic kind of like requirements of what the JD says what they should be able to do okay and then the first round is that just the um the you know um the experts the foreign principles academics there's no parents and community members in a part of that first round of interviews right they're all for they're all former principles who are in leadership position
035so they're principles of principles got it okay and then finally that second round is where the community members come in they do their part and they're kind of participating and then finally that third round has nothing to do with the community members they've given their feedback on what they think about the candidates and then you all are just like holding them how long for that third round are the candidates like held for consideration before they like they sign their contract they start um so just to clarify also one of the things I want to point out for the second round is that human resources we do have a HR partner that sits on the interview to make sure that it is our expectation that second round is for that community no one from the the
036the associate superintendent and nor should the instructional director be asking questions it is solely for the parents to ask question questions and give feedback um once we conclude that interview we send it to the chief of schools um to say who do you want to meet within third rounds it could be we've had normally we interview between um probably about five people um and some for some schools there's a shining star where everyone highly recommends that person like everyone else is are do not recommend that can move very quickly we call them in for a third round in those third rounds the chief of school um as well as myself we dig a little bit deeper into what the community was asking and for example if someone didn't answer some special leg questions or didn't
037speak to it that's where we take that opportunity to dig in based upon the survey that we put out to the masses um but that can go very quickly but if it's one where and we've had this happen where at least two people were highly recommended for a school or three people were highly recommended for a school and then we have to we often times that my experience is that we bring all three in and based upon the leadership characteristics that the community said what people said in their interview we dig a little bit deeper and make a decision from there um but usually that can take um probably this probably about a maybe a two week turnaround less than two weeks or less but we do try to move it's a very fast process
038okay okay which is very which is fast for like jobs because I feel like you know jobs these days can take mon just to get hired I mean for a lot of stuff um but I just had a question for you as we're thinking about this policy and like revisiting it like are there things that you think um could be improved and one of the things that I was thinking as an idea but just curiously what you have to say as my final piece um was like you know a lot of times I think the integration into the into the the school Community is where the success lies and I was just talking about this this morning um with a colleague about like you know the impact that a principal has on school right impact
039that teachers have on schools and their effectiveness and I think part of that is like the relationships that they have and The Bu The Buy in from the community which doesn't always like G to happen um so I'm just curious my thought was like could there be some way to like in that in between time at the end like really give them an opportunity to kind of get a Vibe check of if there are two really good candidates you know um where where just one more piece of feedback but do you have any like additional things that you think we could do to just strengthen the process now that you've done this for some time um I do one of the things I also wanted to bring up that I'm not sure if you're aware
040is our Charter Schools although they have to follow AP 4133 they can make modifications um but the main step as far as it has to be approved by the superintendent is is is non-negotiable so I do work with each Charter operator to outline their process and so I have learned from them some of the things that and they really pretty much follow exactly what we do they often might have either either larger panels or they um will have an additional round so I do want to just give you that so that you're aware I think the only thing that I think to recommend is you know at the end of the day we've talked about it board members come and go superintendent come and go people come and go your policy is your policy um
041I'm a big proponent that we can't do this without the community so I would just make sure that you're policy while the administrative procedure is really up to the superintendent that you have a policy that says no matter if I'm here or not you will engage the community they will have some type of say in this process and I think what we have gives them a say without taking away um the autonomy from school support and the superintendent to pick their leaders um you know at the end of the day you could make the you know say you know the community panels could be larger but I can tell you it it becomes a lot and people can become nervous but I do think your policy should definitely say community members in there just very
042much I've appreciated leading equity in the district and knowing that you have in the policy we will have one professional development day dedicated to equity so that has been very helpful to me if um you know other things need to come up and people say no we don't need that day no that is a board policy and we will have that day so it's those types of things where I would for me I I don't know your policy as well as I know the administrative procedure but I would just encourage you to make sure that your lasting Mark in this district is that you're going to make sure the community is sitting at that table thank you so much um board member uh Walker this the thir well actually we're on the third round so
043I'm not sure if folks um if we need to vote on this but um if there are any objections to a third round then speak now or we'll keep moving forward okay I'm board member Walker two minutes and 30 seconds still thank you so much um I just have as um as Robin and you take notes for the enhancements I do have just three proposals um for the enhancements based off what I heard today the first is under section four standards to in include where it has school um School website to also add and other school and parent communication mediums because we know that it can include things like Class Dojo things like that the second piece is under letter e um I am in alignment with the um commenter that given that it's like
04415 people there I think it's okay to say at least two um you know no more than two maybe we can say to not have to have two in case we don't get um to uh folks with parents with IEPs but I'm I'm absolutely happy to say um no more than two or at a maximum two um I'm line with that and then also if we could add in something around I know that there's three rounds and it doesn't have to be super inclusive but it could say like first round Community specific second round school specific third round chief of schools in HR however the best way to do that is in talking to Dr Balwin I think that'll um make sure that we're we have some continuity in um the process those are my
045ads thank you so much okay all right so seeing no other hands um if there are no objections the committee shall recommend policy 4113 to the uh the policy sponsor for revision approval um with the inclusion that was just made by um board member Walker okay uh Robin Mrs Welsh before you go you're you're muted one question the uh convers ation about seac are we going to remove that statement about the training can I can I chime in here I'm happy to remove it and I think that's the suggestion um from Dr Balwin is like we shouldn't have that as a requirement for sure um I think I like the idea of having it optional so that families know that that's available to them if they want to do it um and that's my suggestion
046is like we just have something in there where it's just a it's naming it as like an example or for example you can participate in you know this opportunity um so that they're aware of it but otherwise I don't think is is a requirement no we should remove it and that's the um the um expert advice of Dr bwin um board member Walker yeah um I think the only concern I have about that oh Dr Bal one was to talk yeah she might answer your question oh I just wanted to make sure that if that is something you all want to move forward with I would make sure that you offer that to every parent who chooses to be on the committee I would also want to make make sure that you think about um
047our L population too um like what opportunities um when we're talking about our English um our English language Learners which I know we've got a new name so I apologize it's late um you know I think when you open the door for one of our populations you have to be cognizant that you can't leave another population out so and our students who are second language Learners do have some of the same exact um instructional requirements like direct instruction um doing a lot of vocabulary and content and things like that so one of the things when we do interview principles we definitely want to know you know do you know those special populations and our students who come from um homes from um low in lowincome communities too so I just want us to be cautious
048that when you open to one specific Community you do need to think about all of the vast communities that are in PGCPS um and I'm I'm happy to also if you think it's appropriate to work on maybe our own HR training video to kind of make all parents aware of something that they they need to you know take a five minute watch this five minute video as they prepare and think about our students with disabilities our second language Learners and um our children who suffer our families from F food insecurity um I'm happy to just do that whether it's in your policy or not but you think it's a good idea yeah thank you so much for that context um I want to go back to Bor Walker who had her hand thank you thank
049you so much um great thank you for adding that uh Dr Balwin I had two watch outs the first uh I think you answered with um if we are going to put training in I'm a proponent to take it out I think that if it's um optional then it gives people a leg up um unnecessarily uh to say that they've taken that train training so in the event that it does stay in I think it just should be a requirement of all that's on a committee or either we take it all the way out um so that's one and I think Dr bald when your idea to do an HR video um if if it is something that we are asking um or folks to take before then it should just be a requirement that
050if you sit on that committee everyone has to to take that specific training otherwise I I don't think it should be an optional training either is a training because it's necessary information they have to have to do that job adequately or it's not um and we can make that but otherwise I I my my recommendation would be to remove it from as a requirement or optional thanks optional gives us uh subjectivity which we don't want okay um board member or I'm gonna go to board rather then go to you Dr Moss his H up first though um okay thanks um yeah I'm glad we're back around to this around the diversity of the population I mean and we have used the terminology like if we say parents representative of the of the school population and
051then and then that way that um can help guide uh that that the parent pole does not uh look all the same um with all the diversity factors so that would be one phrase to put in there um and then the other is I don't I think getting back to this training idea there isn't really a specific secac training like what we discussed was that cak is a participatory environment with a different presentation training options there's no specific training in secac to prepare you to hire a principal and I think that I think that's what the the issue has been for me um but for Dr Balwin you you got to what what it what I what didn't clarify is you should be trained to be able to hire a principal just because you've been
052on the panel and you're identifying through this that you were missing that that that you may need to upgrade your materials around hey you're about to be part of this process we really want you to think about these things and I think that is that you you got to you know what I you know a solution that I didn't think of that I was like there's something feels missing here and and so you just you clarified that so appreciate that welcome all right thank you so much bu sh um going to Dr board member Moss um I so appreciate you I think there's something uh to be said about um having a training opportunity I don't know if this is already embedded in our practice or not around bias and sensitivity um if folks go
053through that training or not if so if that training is already embedded into being in a on the committee may be such an opportunity to make sure folks who are on this committee are able to see through language that a principal candidate might be using that might be adversarial um toward students who identifies as lgbtq students who have disabilities um so I'm curious if there's anything around inclusivity that's part of our normal standard operating procedures that would cover this um if not I would be open to um a bias sensitivity or inclusivity training U for folks who are on the committee to make sure we're not hiring principles who would be adversarial to uh a number of populations that we named our students with disabilities um our students who speak English as a second language
054our students who identify as lgbtq plus whatever that is so um can you speak to the way in which we onboard these committees to do this hiring work sure so um I do have the ex the distinct pleasure although individuals know that Staffing is under me that I have four other departments that are also under me and one is equity uh divers Equity belonging and diversity um so I've always appreciated having that um because it's very unique in the sense that we want to create Equitable landscapes for our children but that starts with the adults and there's only one school district that has that works with all employees and that is human resources so with the support of the equity board policy and the fact that you all mandate that once a year you know
055that once a year we have to have Equity training um I think Robin can deely testified that every year we have one systemic day completely dedicated to equity and through that we've done implicit bias training we've done our LG um our LG I get stuck on my acronyms because I talks really fast LGT plus Community um we've done training on that we've done our black and brown boys um right now we're focusing on special education and we'll probably continue that because we've gotten a lot of good feedback so one of the things um when before we start the interview we go over the basic parts of the interviews what you can and cannot say what you can and cannot do um we also talk about things to think about like this candidate is very nervous
056you know we go through the question so we do a lot of prepping but one of the things I can do is work with one of the depart work with our Equity diversity and belonging to kind of speak to what you all are asking like a little maybe three minute video on how to think about what you're asking asking um the the biases you may bring and really listening to the the responses versus what you see on the resume and are they speaking to the special communities that are within there I'm I'm committed to doing that whether you you know put it in the policy or not because I think it'd be a good practice War Bri I know I'm out of time but I want say I know I don't have to say this
057to you but there are gender dynamics that comes into hiring female principles times um and I know my own male privilege can get in the way but I've watched it show that some female principles don't get a shot so as you build that training out I know three minutes is a short time um but I would I I think we need to hit on a number of things which is why I favor a full training for folks who are going to be hiring principles um because although sometimes this is a a female dominated profession men get principal jobs over women uh far too many times and so I just want to make sure we look across the board at all of that and I don't know what's the best way to approach it sounds like
058my colleagues doesn't support a training um but for folks who are outside the profession who don't do this every day I do think they need to hear some of this stuff around um how bias can show up in hiring practices I agree well oh yeah thank you so much I think that was a great Point um I just wanted to chime in here before uh booer who I know you're probably hot on wanting to say something about this but I just wanted to say and there is where I was going with this is that I think the trainings are necessary cak you know great and obviously we know this just a kind of a body that does some advisory work and other things but um I think outside of that you know there's I've talked
059to a number of parents who have reached out to me and they're like my child's been in I for years and I don't even know you know like what how what this process is or like what's supposed to happen at the school and these are things that I think implicit in that process is the assumption that because I'm a active parent who's signing up who has a child who identifies in some way I understand it there are tons of people who have lgbtq kids who don't understand their kids or don't know how to you know address it or there tons of people who don't you know know how to talk about or address the disabilities and so I think some way to some Avenue for parents to have access to information um especially I think
060we all can relate to being in a you know whatever it is a program or an opportunity or interview and you're like what question should I ask so I think that that's like a precursor to like planning some seeds giving them an opportunity to say like you know what I do want to say that and I do remember that experience so I do think whether that training video is you know holistic and that it also has um the equity piece to it which I think is really important um I would just want something that's going to kind of get them up to speed like what types of questions can I ask you know what am I looking for when I think about a principal and likely they'll have a lot of great stuff that comes
061from um I think that that primer um I'm gonna go to board member buther yeah I I just want to be very clear I feel like uh someone spoke for me and misspoke for me absolutely the training to that that we are discussing cak does not offer that training and so it's written into a policy and it cannot offer it but I think uh uh you did not hear clearly the support that we are expressing for appropriate training on hiring a principal along these lines of a diver diverse School populations oh and want to make sure Bo mov was that to was that to me or was that to uh do Dr Moss said my colleagues don't sound like they support a training I just needed to to that is not true okay got it
062so we're we're not that was a misunderstanding okay um board member Walker yeah thanks for saying that because I literally just wrote down to say that I don't want anyone in the public walking arid with that we don't want training the appropriate training for um folks that's doing interviewing this specific policy is around interviewing for um it's about the principal ship and so we want to make sure that we have the right training for our folks but specifically when I was talking about either we do the training or not it's really around that one section on if the the the the f FKS that are joining in um specifically for IEP have a specific training that's what was written into the policy draft and so as we talk about the policy draft as a whole
063it's not that we don't want training for folks please don't walk away with that anything that I said anyway is that or anything that anyone has said we want the specific training but it either is going to be it needs to be appropriate for hiring a principal at that school hiring a principal for the district and so because they need to have their mindset around the different typ of population that is there then it needs to be something that not only the 504 parents are taking but the entire community that is on the panel is also taking so I just wanted to make sure that I double back on that one as well because it could be misunderstood that I'm saying no training at all all right I just wanted to be thank you CLA
064all right thank you so much for that and thank you for clarifying that because actually I was I was interpreting that way too that we were saying no to the training in there um and I love the piece around like the fact that we're also being really inclusive of intersecting identities you know there's not going to be kids who just have one identity so that think is inclusive so I think Mrs Welsh likely you have clarification here um can I make a point of order a clarification can we pull that up because maybe the issue is I'm looking I went back to September and I'm looking at it on the screen I know exactly what I'm talking about like should we pull up this policy and show that line to the public you talking are
065you referring to the cak training yeah I mean because the the thing is cak like literally does not offer that like no yeah no no no Bard member boo Str if you're saying I should clarify I think what you're saying yes it was in there and you're right so I don't think we need to pull it up at least for unless you want to just have it to see like I know it's in there and I know I'm not crazy that it is is definitely in there um so yes and I think some people are jumping in here with like not having as much EX um exposure as you've had up to this point so there we might be talking like in different ways about the same about the same issue um but the CAC
066training was in there and it was suggested that parents do it and that was also the feedback we got from um one of the written comments that we got back in December um about this issue so I appreciate because I just didn't want there to be any confusion about this issue that that literally we were at saying that a particular entity offers something that they do not so it should be under HR yeah yeah exactly exactly yeah so we're um yes I think we're on the same page there um Dr bwin I think we probably can move forward here so I just want to make sure so e is what you're going to vote on to either keep or remove or yeah yeah yes so I think to wrap this all up with a bow
067what we hear you saying is there's going to be a training video what we're saying is we're going to take cak out um because one if we're going to have CAC we need to have all the other things it sounds like you're agreeing to all the other things are going to be part of that training video that you will do in your office and that'll include a suggestion to cacs advisory piece if parents would want to participate in that um so I think we're all on the same page here um Mrs Welsh if you've got that and you're clear on like the updates of the policy I think we can move forward you can just give me a thumbs up if you you're muted we're going to include two parents that are have a student
068of with a disability or 504 they're receiving 504 that we're also going to ensure parents are representative of the school population and third that we uh that train there will be appropriate training for the interview process and the hiring of a principal so I just want to make sure that I'm clear the administrative procedure right now says four community members is The Bard policy the recommendation you're going to say other four two have to be parents with dis parents of students with disabilities or are you going to allow the process to play if a parent wants to be on it um because I think I go back to the point that you all raised when we start saying if there's only four and I was saying where's two have to be um parents of individuals
069with disabilities and they may some may not want to present participate but then what about our larger Community um that have very large L populations like Mary Harris's mother jums are we going to then say that of two sped and then two parents of our students who are English language Learners that's a good point that's my question yeah that's a great Point um I want to be respectful of the hands that are up so I'm going to go to um board member Walker first and then board member Bo thank you so much um you know what thank you for saying about the four because for some reason I had 15 in my mind so the two I was saying at least two um at a maximum of two earlier but with four I think you're
070right I think we can say um that uh it's extended to whatever that special population is of that school um for for that specific one so it doesn't need to be necessarily 504 specific but it it could be 504 specific but some type of speciality if it's for instance rosaryville they have an autistic population so maybe it's something around a specialty of that particular school or uh something that fits within our criteria for um special needs something to that effect um but I did want I didn't hear the other pieces about first round second round third round um recommendation Robin um that I made earlier the first round second round third round like Community specific school specific chief of schools and HR whatever guidance Miss Balwin um can give and then the other uh thing
071oh under uh section for the piece about it says schools website just to add in and other social and parent communication mediums into that line right there because we heard today that it could be Class Dojo all those things it's beyond just the school website but it is to that school population if you can consider that in the Revis thank you I did include the other school system Communications but I did have a question uh when we're looking at board policy versus administrative procedures so we do have language that says the interviewing process shall include in addition to other interview activities an interview panel of stakeholders uh that and then as for that particular School um where there's the vacancy and then it goes the next one e talks about a maximum of two parents
072and the reason I asked this question is because the purpose of the policy has to do with the community involvement in the principal selection process so the administrative procedure itself would be addressing all the other panels because they're that's unrelated to the community involvement but certainly we can put it in if you like it I just I no that's fair that's fine because at the top of it it actually defines um the the school population it actually defines stakeholders as a school population so I'm okay with that as long as the um the administrative procedure Dr Baldwin um also has just the three um rounds that you talked about today so that is there for perpetuity thank you okay um thank you so much for that um board member Bo Str yeah thank you so
073much and uh chair Briggs I appreciate you expanding this discussion I know we're we're out of order but I I really appreciate it um the um I I was say administrative procedures are changed after policy you may want to move from four to five and I thought we had gone back to what Miss Welsh said of um up to two um as so there would be a maximum of there'll be at least one a maximum of two um because it's required so um but you may want to consider expansion of the the parents um because of the diversity of our our schools so that that was just my my final feedback okay um and or member moss and I think we may be ready to move forward here yeah I just have a clarifying question
074so are we defining uh the parents or are we allowing the process to play out I think I kind of missed that one defining like the parents there was some going back there what are we doing here I think so I'll clarify here so I think what we're going to do is the administrative policy goes into more detail in depth um so I think what Mrs Welsh is saying is just like what are we as the board tasking this is really high Lev stuff right what are we what are we tasking this uh Community involvement group with doing and and that's it and and then I think when you get into the nuances and the technicalities if they want to have that language in there then they can do that sounds like that's not something
075that would be helpful but what I would say might be helpful from what I'm hearing from like the group is the whoever those community members are up to two reflect the the diverse representation of that school community so cuz I think that Dr bin brought up a good point which is we were talking about disability but there may be e or there may be something else right that that exists in the community and we don't want to kind of pitch and hole oursel into like this narrow box um that doesn't fit for every context so Mrs Welsh I feel like you are you are the guru the legal scholar here around like how to craft the language um based on what's being requested do you have questions well I I guess so I think at
076one point I thought we were saying a maximum of two parents receiving special ed or 504 and then I had also added and parents represented of the school population shall be on the panel with the idea of thinking I wasn't actually and I'm sorry Dr bwin I wasn't actually thinking we were only limited to four I was thinking there might be a couple more if uh um if need be if depending on the population of the school so you know if we're in a school that has a you know a a large Hispanic population then you know we certainly want to be representative there too correct I think but what I heard a board member boa Struthers is saying that if you all do that I most likely will talk with the superintendent of do
077we need to raise it from four community members to six um just because I I just want to make sure that the community is well represented which I will say um that that'll be another rock we have to um encounter because as much as we advertise and ask people to be on it we don't get people who really want to to participate it's a very long day um and I'm oh Dr I'm in climing agree with you I feel like I just don't want us to like hold up the process like I don't want it to be where we're trying to be so thoughtful that we're like not getting interviews done because we're you know wanting to make sure we capture everyone I feel like the language we have fits um and it is addressing
078it in the process you all have and I think that we're addressing the issue and clarifying um board member Walker thanks um you know with a membership of four I I'm inclined not to add it to six and the reason I say that is because we struggle sometimes with even getting a four that we need for the for the total population so with that what if we maintain it at four and then we say at least one of the panelists need to be um we we just change it to one um of the um of the special population that's represented at that school and then the other thing is honestly if you're getting it from the school then most likely you're going to be representative of that school I think that the key here was
079that they wanted this parent wanted to ensure that the special needs population was met with a 504 um representative there because there's so many questions around that so I think if we say that this person um this at least one person um needs to be representative of that population and or a 504 um parent then I think that that fits the need of us being um representative of that Community that's that's my input on the verbiage I think two is a stretch and I only say that because I think we start to pigeon hole ourselves and we might be already getting that population so checking the box for that one already because it is so school specific make sense that's my input it it does but I wanted to just oh I don't know if
080you were talking to me but I was Robin what you could do when you come to wordsmithing um is just saying that human resources will make sure that they do their due diligence to know the special community of that particular school and then hold the interview committee responsible for making sure that there's one individual from the community that represents the whatever the majority is because I also want you to you all to remember that we do have we also make sure that from The Faculty members if for example Rosary Bill I'm going to expect to see an interview committee with at least one special ed teacher on that committee um again if it's a Mary Harris Mother Jones I'm going to expect to see one of the uh um elll Educators so we could just
081you could also hold Human Resources responsible because at the end of the day um when it comes to carrying out your policy you do need to make sure that somebody is being held accountable that it's done correctly so I'm willing to take that on all right thank you so much Dr B win and I think the last thing if I think we can move forward because I saw a lot of hits nodding and I think we're at a good place here um as far as crafting the language you want I did just want to say that um to wrap all of this up Dr Balwin um one thank you so much for joining um this evening for providing the perspective that you offered um which would think is really helpful to drive this discussion um
082and then I think also like with any interview you at least the Assumption I have is that there's questions that are crafted and cultivated so if there's someone way that if we don't have the representation that we're requesting and their due diligence includes we didn't get the parent but we have questions that are targeted towards specific populations that might be another way so I'm just hoping that we can I want to leave that last parting thought of like creativity like there's other ways that we can kind of you know get to the same um goal without doing it explicitly the way that we want if we're trying to mitigate a lot of different challenges um so with all of that being said and if there are no objections um the Community show recommend policy 4113
083to the policy sponsor for revision approval with the inclusions that we've discussed here um Mrs Welsh if you feel that you've got all of those inclusions from every party's um perspective you can just let us know and then I think that's what we're voting one is your understanding of what you're going to be updating in the policy I think I understand okay any objections okay there being no objections policy 4113 will be recommended to the policy sponsor for revision approv um Miss Adeline Adel did you want to say anything really quick um I was just going to say that we should call for the questions since we had so many um adjustments or Amendment to the policy we may have to call for the question okay I I I I feel like because we didn't
084have any objections to Mrs Welsh's uh agreement and Ascent to like understanding everything that we discussed um I think we'll just move forward with that and then next time I think we can do that there was a laundry list of things there so um we're going to move on um to item 3.0 but I want to say again thank you Dr Balwin if you want to stick on and be here then feel free to do that otherwise feel free to hop um and we were going to have a legislative update um Mrs Welsh perhaps we can keep it um short since we didn't have it request to have it removed from the agenda so I want to recognize Mrs Welsh for the legislative update item 3.1 okay and I will keep it short I will
085let you know that we did right now we're tracking 39 educ ation bills that have been that have come through the G General Assembly um and of those we have received requests from the Department of legislative services for uh fiscal uh worksheets local fiscal estimate worksheets for 29 of the bills so where currently they have been sent out to each of the bills have been sent out to different Chiefs across the system uh We've forgotten probably about half of the bills that we've sent out received back and we do have a spreadsheet that any member on this committee will have access to if you don't already have it h to see what bills have come in and then what the positions are so what happens when the fiscal notes do come in um they usually
086lay out the the opinion of that division related to the bill as well as what is the impact for the school systems is it is it like operational is it Financial whatever and then based on that of course I compare to what our legislative platform States and then we look at we and see like let's say uh gotten several bills that definitely have a money it's not we're not receiving money but it's going to cost the system money so one of the main things that we've talked about in the legislative um platform is unfunded mandates so that's one of the factors you know that we certainly we look at but as we as they come in we get more information then you'll start to see where the bills are listed and what the positions are
087and then also I have included the rationale for that position so you know exactly why it is that way um there are a few bills that have come up for committee uh this week not many at all though but there will be uh as we move in further into the session they'll start coming up much faster and then we should have much more information as we move forward the other thing is I do want to point out that we were an attendance at the ma meeting and Jonathan you were there also so if you certainly uh you know chime in but I will say that big part of the conversation in the Maes legislative uh uh um meeting was it had to do with blueprint and I many of the school systems are very concerned
088because they feel strongly that there needs to be more flexibility within the the requirements of the blueprint because school systems are different so what they require let's say a Prince George's County and what it might really not work in Coward or vice versa you know with the large systems versus the small systems and the locations of the school systems and but there is concern though about board members across the from board members across the county in terms of by at requesting more flexibility does that mean we don't want to be held accountable and of course that is an important piece because if you're going to receive money you certainly should you know be willing to be held accountable for receiving that money and doing something with it so I think it's and I you don't
089feel you know don't hesitate to say Jonathan what your perspective was but I got the sense that the all the board members on that committee are really working to try to feel through it and figure out what they really want want to say about the blue blueprint at this point in time because they want to be careful but at the same time they're very concerned because money that's the other issue is with a $3 billion deficit that the governor announced they're very concerned about the fact that if the blueprint is hit in any way then you know that we still have those requirements sitting out there but there might be a lot less money that we that we have to to try to meet those requirements and that's that's pretty scary right now as it
090is we in this school system we're juggling you know moving money here and there to meet all the requirements that we have to meet so um that is a concern so I don't know if you thought if you got something different from what they were talking about on M Monday uh chair Briggs please say so uh yeah thank you so much Mrs Welsh um I I Echo everything you shared I think you you got it right um I think flexibility was really the biggest piece um and and a big concern about the um looming no l looming deficit that is very real um but I will say that another part of the meeting was kind of uh just agreement and ratification of the confirmed four priorities um that the the got together and so those
091were the um big pieces and just as an FYI those include um sorry my computer is moving a little slow but governance and author governance Authority for local Boards of Education to adopt policies that reflect local priorities and assets um modifying the pre- expansion um modifying credentialing initiatives incentives and sustain and increase local government Investments and education and really the goal was like all of those those four buckets those four big buckets would be all encompassing and not competing priorities um for all the counties that have very different um you know things that they're also advocating for so those are where we're we're really going to apply the pressure um and um Mrs Welsh I know there was also an aib U meeting that was last week so just wanted to flag that for folks
092that you can check that out if you haven't um there was a discussion around again talks about the deficit um talks about um discontinued um increases in funding for certain categories of the blueprint um and the implications that'll have on um teacher credentialing and other things which is kind of tied to some of the made pieces um and then the last thing I'll say is that board member boo struther also shared um with the um board and this is just for the general Public's awareness but there are going to be there are in fact tomorrow there will be a Prince George's County delegation um or County Affairs um meeting uh that's going to be at 8:00 a.m. um to talk about some bills or propose bills um for um Prince George's County and then they're
093going to be ongoing meetings um across various committees with the the house delegation um going into next week and the following week so be tracking that on the delegation website um you can always go to the Maryland um delegation website. goov to to learn more about that um so if there's anything um else Mrs if there's nothing else Mrs W I think we can move forward but if you had something looks like you do I I did want to say we do have there right now we have seven local bills that we're tracking but they have not moved uh into the general assembly at this point so it'll be interesting to see what they say tomorrow y oh and and the last thing I guess Mrs Welsh didn't highlight this but she did highlight this
094with me is that cell phones um they are a few four four polic four bills onell funds and because it is the legislature mandating that you must have a policy and then it's each of these policies there's different aspects of it that they're saying You must do a school system we would need to oppose all four of those bills only from the standpoint that the legislature should not be doing the job of the Board of Education which is governance and developing their own policies yeah I I asked the uh I asked the um the governmental relations guy ma today about this if May was going to uh what May's position was around this because there are four different versions of the bill three of which mandate that we ban them and the other one gives
095some autonomy so curious to see um where where where other boards are landing uh behind it thank for that a Hot Topic it's a hot topic for sure I see a raised hands I'm gonna go to board member um Walker thanks so much um you know from also sitting on that call one of the things I did hear was um the word flexib ility around the blueprint um just talking about what that word really meant and just being um really mindful of that word of flexibility so I know that when the um original um speak I forget her name um I think it was Tiara but when she was originally speaking I think she was really talking about the flexibility in The Spence so we get the money and it's mandated or regulated for a
096specific area like the flexibility and a creativity within that um spending for that pool um the other piece that I wanted to uh say is the cell phone for us in Prince georgees County specifically I think we have an opportunity because we have multiple um folks that are putting in cell phone bills and opportunity to really sit with them to understand what their goals are and then to really talk to them about it and and have it on our side versus it being legislation as a whole it also comes with a fiscal note that I don't know that they truly understand um in the writing of these amazing bills that they have right now so I think it's it it behooves us to actually bring them in to really have those conversations early before those
097hearings start absolutely I completely agree with that and just for clarification because I know you're going fast because we're short on time but um uh T Tiara who was from Baltimore County was saying that they're already able to meet the 60k threshold which is the base funding for uh teachers by 2026 so they really don't need additional funding for that because that kind of is that that requirement is met and the question came of could we use whatever funding we get towards other buckets um and have flexibility those dollars um and as far as the cell phone policy absolutely what that means for for us is we'll revisit our policy again um but I think Mrs Welsh is very clear as we all are um about our legislative platform and about the fact that we
098um you know really don't try to have any unfunded mandates or anything that is requiring us to do curricular things um coming from um you know legislators because we we would prefer that we come from the Maryland State Department of Education or other um expert bodies so um just want to clarify that we'll likely be addressing the changes but we've probably got a lot of great things and their pilot programs that are happening at schools across Prince George's County with ruling out various cell phone policies so that's happening too that the superintendent is tracking um with all of that being said um I'm going to we're going to move forward to item 4.0 policies for first consideration because we got a lot to talk about um so there are now three items for discussion and
099each person will have two rounds per item during the discussion which will be the two and a half minutes um so we're going to move to item 4.1 policy 3100 Investments um I recognize Mrs Welsh for an overview of policy 3100 Investments okay thank you um Cindy would you mind putting that up on the on the um screen so we can look at it thank you so this so This policy it we already have it so this is a revision of the policy and it's to bring it up to date especially in terms of our formatting and everything but also to ensure that we're clear about what the goal of the policy is and what where does the Board of Education stand and I and this was also in the old policy um um anything
100that's in black is the old policy language um but what's probably the most important uh piece of this for the for the um for the for the for all of you to to realize is that this um the if we're going to invest money well first of all the board has the right and by law to invest money and it's actually they um are required to give that authority over to the superintendant but that it's the money that is actually in excess of daily operational requirements so that would be the money that would get invested um and the what um we're saying in the policy statement is that that you're committed to ensuring that when there is an investment that um it meets the primary criteria of prudence safety of principal liquidity and market rate
101of return and if you go down to the definitions each of those are are um uh you know um defined so for example liquidity we're just going to make sure that you know we don't have all the money tied up in Investments and we need money to for some operational expense we don't have it so that's the first thing and maximum return is to try to uh to work to manage those the whatever funds or uh Investments that have been made so that they uh get attain a a a good rate of return that's consistent with legal restrictions risk and prent in investment practices at the same time they're protecting the invested capital and uh taking into account constraints on risk and cash flow requirements so it's it's conservative in its thinking and rightly so
102because it is public funds that we're dealing with and the money is ultimately there to work uh provide um instruction for our students and then the next piece has to do with safety of principle and that is the investment of operating funds to be undertaken in a manner that seeks to ensure the preservation and capital in the overall portfolio and protection of investment principles um and um so then it goes into um the and again part of this hope good part of this comes from the old policy the policy applies to any unexpended surplus funds and it can be in the following funds that's coming from current expense funds School construction funds food nutrition service funds group life and health and vehicle self-insurance funds and other funds that may be created from time to time
103um and the authority uh is um to invest redeem sell exchange reinvest um any of the funds uh shall be with the superintendent SL design um and so the primary objectives number one is to object is to protect the capital and then to make sure there's sufficient liquidity and then to maximize returns um and in terms of standards of care all the Investments that are made should be made in pursuant to state law um again exercising prudent judgment um a discretion and Care um and not speculating but actually looking at the prevailing circumstances um yes okay sorry can we can we have I think just for the sake of following along can we actually know where you are in the document oh I'm sorry I got so so involved in going over this policy that
104I I apologize okay I discussed what what it applies to so those right there the listed funds are the ones that are actually going to be uh um the that we can money if there's excess funds from these areas that they could be used for investing uh and then it does say that the authority does um lie with the superintendent to do the investing redeeming selling exchange and reinvesting and then the primary objectives we go scroll down Cindy are um the safety of principal liquidity and maximum returns so um we want to you know keep safeguards with the capital we have but and we want to be able to Li liquify liquid liquidate it if we need to because we're a state we need the money or and at the same time we want to
105make sure we get a maximum return then in terms of the standards of care if you scroll further down Cindy um the Investments uh of course the state law there's numerous laws and they're listed in the in the back of the policy that are are you know that we must follow if when any Investments are done and then in terms of just ensuring that there's the standard of care is exercising prudent judgment discretion and care and then and the uh superintendent in acting with the um uh in accordance with the state law that he um and then he also administrative procedures which if you go to the administrative procedure it goes into great detail about all the a aspects of the investing um and that um but he that he must do all those things
106but at the same time he or does he need but and and exercising due diligence they he or the or he or whoever shall not be held personally responsible for a single security credit risk or market price changes provided deviations from expectations are reported in a timely manner and appropriate action is taken to control adverse developments so if there in if the funds if the Investments there's some issue coming up or whatever and it's not meaning the expect and it is the responsibility of superintendent design to report that immediately um so and then another important piece is that in in this process of investing though that superintendent design must act in accordance with the PO policy one uh one ah 0107 ethics regulations as well as policy 4116 which deals with conflicts of interest gifts
107and financial disclosures and of course must file Financial disclosures statement annually to to pick up um you know any of these uh transactions going on as far as investment strategy um uh in accordance with the state law and regulations they should be limited anything that's being invested should be limited to uh in insured or fully collateralized funds uh including obligations to Federal Government Federal agency agency obligations and repurchase agreements secured by direct government or agency obligations and then quarterly the superintendent of design shall hold investment strategy sessions to evaluate the portfolio for compliance with current investment policy discuss market conditions cash flows and identify appropriate investment vehicles and the most effective means of generating income so it's critically important that um that he is he and his staff um are really taking the time to
108evaluate this and ensure you know that um that everything is moving the way it should be moving and then in terms of monitoring and controls um that the superintendent design shall be responsible ensuring that the school systems investment program is consistent with Kar 25303 and the local government investment guidelines adopted by the Marland State treasur um and the um then the uh also the independent ERS so the school system hires an independent aitor and they need to re re re viw the investment program as part of the annual Financial audit and then confirm the board's Investments and policies and then they would actually be publishing that uh each year in the uh report that they provide um so that is about it in the nutshell um okay thank you so much Mrs Welsh colleagues if
109you have questions for Mrs Welsh raise your hand and I'll acknowledge you in the order of your raised hand okay seeing no hands okay um board member Bo Str yeah sorry sorry about that delay um Miss Welsh has this board ever discussed around investing from any values based investing in terms of this maximum profits are often companies that are actually like not even working in the interest of our of our diverse population here in Prince George's County and certainly our viewpoints on climate action and are we investing in fossil fuels do you know in the past if we've dived into that type of conversation but I can certainly discuss that I could ask I could ask that question has there been any uh are we looking at companies or or groups or whatever that areas
110that that align with the values of the board ex yeah exactly and I know this is you know to could take some significant work in the the options available but I just wanted to know if that's been raised from the board in the past if there's anything if there's any response that has happened in the past that might guide some future thinking I'm not making any um policy change um modifications in this moment um chair Briggs okay all right well thank you so much for that comment though um and Mrs w sounds like you're didn't get back to board member Bo St and the committee on that question for you and I know we really don't have any Financial Scholars on here um but around the standards of care is something that I you know
111was curious about because um it made me think about um you know large uh in investment firms that may have an executive officer that makes Investments um and and there's a great deal of trust that goes into ensuring that that director that you know executive officer um is acting with the standard of care they they're you know doing all the the the things that are necessary to be ethical in their um Investments um and it can get tricky because you can make investments in an area where you may have lots of money or lots of benefit in investing there um and and I'm just wondering with the standards of care piece if there's something that we could do to really strengthen the language around um something that's comparable to that field um around what types
112of accountability measures exist for the superintendent because I know that we're putting a great deal of trust you know in him with millions of dollars um but there's also lots of protections that exist um and I think actually like in the investment world I there's like a veil where there's just an assumption that most of these investment officers and directors are going to do the right thing so it's really hard to hold them accountable if they um for whatever reason act um you know unethical um I'm wondering what we could have that exists here for um a superintendent and really just moving forward in the future um and then the other piece was um any report outs from to the board I know that you said that there's the report the quarterly report out um
113to his team his investment team but I would love to know and obviously he'd need to let the board know if anything you know if there's like any um issues with the Investments we need to be made aware of that but I I feel like there could be something in there around like quarterly or two yeah we could we put a section in there for that and sure that it's that becomes you know part of the routine to report on that um okay other questions um board member Moss um to board member booer str's point would that would we need to put it in a specific language that they include where those Investments are going or would the superintendent just say this is how much this is how much we're investing or should we codified
114in language where the superintendent also is expected to show us the portfol FiOS of which we are investing those dollars I think that would get to my colleague's original concern not necessarily request um but I I share the same concern around where we invest and if they if it runs a file to the interest of our students I so I mean certainly are you suggesting that you have the opportunity to hear where we're investing so you know whether or not it's aligning with the with the the values of of the board yes that that's what I would like to see if there's a way to codify that in language um to be able to do that so let me I'm going to um you know we have a school system treasur that has evidently I
115it took me a while to track down who does all this stuff in the system so let I would be go I think maybe I would like to go back and take these questions back to them and get this information for you so that you could um so you better know knowledge about how this all works okay board member booer struther yeah thank you so much yeah continuing along those lines the um annual comprehensive financial report gets as far as the breakdown but not into the depth of the domestic like domestic Equity large cap small cap Global e Equity so there is there's those Cate categories but the depth of which companies are in that portfolios is not I I have not seen in the annual comprehensive financial report so the that first step of
116understanding what we're doing today is exactly kind of what I was I was getting at so thank you Dr Moss great um board member Walker thank you so much um I I do believe that all of these are significant for us to have um an outline to the superintendent about our expectations of what he keeps in line I'm just wondering if that that type of detail probably doesn't need to go into the policy per se but in the policy as an umbrella perhaps we could um identify that the the the Investments need to be in line with our values uh principles and diversified or something to the umbrella effect and then make sure that we um let him know the expectation if there is the breakdown that we want to see for the Investments and
117how they've grown that that be in a proper documentation that's my recommendation Dr you look like you are processing or don't understand or something so I want you to feel free to come on back but that is what my recommendation would be might I that you just the question to him so he's on your time what you say you can give it to Dr Moss you can have the rest of the time no problem you look confused or that you didn't agree or something like that I couldn't really tell what it was yeah not necessarily that I disagree with you um but r rather I try to think for the Long Haul about policy and that policy can outlive the current Administration and so in what ways can we codify it doesn't have to be
118in this policy if there's another venue by which we could could do that uh I'm happy to do so but um policy outlives uh people and so this is the only way to ensure that the next board is able to get that information and the next superintendent is able to do that um but yeah sharing my one minute and two seconds I want to go be able to go back and forth with you on it so we can keep it within the minute is that I do agree with that I also agree that this this committee takes all policies and looks at them on a continuous basis so we just got to be careful with how detailed we go into the weeds for for such things because in the event that it does shift for
119anything or you want to change and it's divested like your Investments you want to look different for uh diversification this isn't the policy that we want to put it in um but anyway whether it's right wrong or indifferent I think Robin has the information and you can feel free to use my remaining 26 if you're responding to that I think sounds like your Doney has a separate question so I'm going to go to Dr uh to board member Moss yeah um I think that uh my my request here is that that I I would appreciate some codification but Robin I'll certainly wait to hear a little bit more from you around the way we the way in which we've approached that in the past and so um I think in my previous conversations with my
120colleague um I was thinking I was thinking about how how policies develop and articulating that but I would love to hear more information around how we do that with still a commitment to codification uh to ensure that that expectation is laid out um for future leadership that we laid it out in a portfolio I think it's particularly Germaine in this conversation that we're looking at excess funds that are being moved and so U that means this is what's left over from something else and so where that is particularly invested I think is is just as important as our other Investments but um I can hold off on the action until we have more information with regard to that yeah and I think that's actually going to be the the the spirit of what we're going
121to do moving forward is um we need more we're GNA have a second round anyway with this um so I'm going to posee this question um the question is shall the committee recommend polic 3100 Investments to the policy sponsor um for revision approval um for revision approval um without the any objections cut out a little bit can you repeat that please yeah um shall the committee recommend policy 3100 Investments to the policy sponsor for revision approval um without the recommended suggestions um discussed here today without so the I think we're objecting to that and saying no um great um so miss Aden please take the roll call on that Mr BR no Miss Walker no Miss no three notes all right um so um policy 3100 investments will be um I'm sorry um um uh
122so I'm calling a new question the question is shall the the committee postpone policy 3100 for to the next policy and governance committee meeting um any objections with modifications with modifications yes any OB okay hearing none um the uh policy 3100 will be postponed until the next policy and governance committee meeting we're going to now move on to item 4.3 policy 5111 legal age of admission um I want to recognize Mrs Welsh for an overview of policy 5111 legal age of admission okay um thank you um Cindy could you please put that up on the screen so this policy um it actually says legal age of of admission was the the um actual um original name of the policy however when I read through the policy it's really not talk it's not it's really about
123early admission into prek kindergarten and first grade it has nothing about like if you want to register and come into the school system you know um and all the requirements for when you're coming into the school system and and um except to say that of course the to start kindergarten you must turn five uh Bice uh for September one by September one or whatever so it really the whole focus of the policy is a discussion about uh what needs to happen if you would like to be if you would like to have your child admitted to school early so um what I did talk about is in the policy statement is that the um the first years of school are really essential for successful long-term educational experience and so the board of education is committed
124to every effort to make to be made to ensure that early years of students educations provide a solid foundation critical to ongoing academic success so that's sort of the underlying uh part of this and then the purpose of the policy is really to provide guidelines for the early admission of students to prek kindergarten and first grade so um first evolve in terms of students who are age El eligible for kindergarten children who will turn five by September 1st of the school year they're age eligible to start and for first grade children who turn six old six years old by September 1st of the school year so that sort of lays it out in the definition then eligible to apply for early admission um it has to be children who meet one of the following criteria
125for pre kindergarten children who will turn four years old between September 2nd and October 15th of the school year in which the child applies for entrance and then for kindergarten it's children who will turn 5 years old between September 2nd and October 15th of the school year um and then if um for when they apply for um and when they apply for entrance and then for oh I left the number there I didn't mean to do that and for first grade children who will turn six years old between SE September 2nd and October 15th of the school year in which the child applies for entrance so that gives you the standards not really standards but like who in terms of age wise could get early admission then in terms of uh standards and again this
126is all stipulated in comar um that children um lays out they have to be four for the first year to enter Kinder pre kindergarten 5 September 1st for uh kindergarten six years six-year-old for first grade and then we are required to establish procedures to offer early admit to kindergarten and or or first graders to four and five years old years old respectively if the superintendent Desy determines that the child demonstrates capabilities warranting early admission so basically kimar is saying these are these are the regular requirements but we do need to provide that option for and it's just kindergarten and six years old however we have also included um pre kindergarten and the system has provided early admission for pre kindergarten students also um so the but the goal here is to ensure that the children
127that are offered the uh opportunity to be early admitted that they meet all the requirements and to demonstrate exceptional ability and social emotional cognitive and physical development and able to successfully learn in setting in a setting with children who are more than one year older um and so to do that the superintendent will establish an application process in which the parents of children who are eligible to apply for early admission um must complete um and only children who uh successfully meet the application requirement shall be accepted for early admission and the application requirement does entail testing um so that they're um they're looking at readiness and you know what developmentally is appropriate at those ages and do they meet are they meeting a higher criteria so that they could be early admitted to the school
128um you know before the the age of when they are mandated to um do it so it's really it was just mainly just a reorganization of that policy and like basically making it um named so that we know what it's really about because I honestly thought it was going to be all about just coming to school when you're when you're in fifth grade I mean when you're five years old or six years old in first grade um but this is more about just early admission so I did check other school systems also just to look to see and there's several systems that also have these early admission um policies that basically say almost to to you the same information awesome thank you so much um Mrs Welsh um colleagues if there are any questions for
129policy 5111 please raise your hand and I'll recognize you in the order of your race down okay seeing none if there are no objections the committee shall recommend policy 5111 to the policy sponsor for revision approval there being no objections policy 5111 will be recommended to the policy sponsor for revision approval we're now going to move on to item 4.4 policy 9354 board members vouchered reimbursement of expenses uh I'll recognize Mrs Welsh for an overview of policy 9354 board members voucher reimbursement of expenses okay um 6:44 someone's talking to me wow um anyway um so this this is a policy that we've had and it U was actually worked on I think in 2017 I do want to um probably the most important piece of it is that um so this policy is in great
130detail it almost reminds you of an administrative procedure uh for the Board of Education it is an internal policy it was originally a bylaw and now it will sit under the 8000s as an internal policy for the board um and it's basically um B um first well first of all state law allows the board members each board member in Prince George's County's Board of Ed to be reimbursed up to $7,000 no more than $7,000 each year for allowable expenses so that's that's very clear that you are not supposed to go up beyond that 7,000 Mark however this also then lays out what is considered allowable expenses and what are not considered allowable experien expenses all the things that you see as you start moving forward like your daily meal expenses expense limitations that's from your
131old policy that laid out specifically what what the you know how much you could spend on each of these things and then in terms of local meals like uh if you're within 30 miles or less from the board office you could uh get reimbursed for that and then it talks about the non-local travel um which is anything um more than 30 miles away from the board office and then your standard mileage rate which we just just recently got updated which is the IRS uh rate that they um that are were required to pay our employees as well as board members for you know traveling using their own vehicle to go to different school events and board uh events so then if you keep scrolling down um and then it goes into into the standards and
132it is section 3-13 B of the education article that does um clarify very clearly that there are no that there a board member may not be reimbursed more than $7,000 in travel and other expenses incurred in a single fiscal year um and that any of the unspent money if you are a board member that you don't spend all your money then all that would just be revert back into the operating budget um uh for the benefit of students um the other thing is it does say that the board member is not allowed to possess a board issued credit card to cover board related expenses um again it says that you're not authorized to go beyond $7,000 um and if there's any expenditures that you end up going above $7,000 then the then um um they
133then that would be something you'd have to reimburse as well as it's prated so if you're not in the school if you're not let's say you did not complete an entire School year as a board member then or the fiscal year I should say then um what you would be prated and that's the amount of money that you would be able to spend um I did put in language that if a board member has any doubt about whether an expenditure is allowable the board member shall obtain preapproval of the expenditure from the budget analyst um and then um um the expenditures that a board members authorized to incur consist of the following so if you just look through here it's like um all all year installation monthly charges for home office office telephone fax computer
134seller phones other telephone devices used to con uh conduct board related business um and um then education related materials for books Publications subscriptions then office supplies Postage and other materials necessary for discharging the duties of the of a board member um and this board members do have access to the school systems Norm procurement and Supply system for the purchase of office supplies and also for printing if you if you you are putting out a newsletter for your District you could get that printed through the through the school system um and then it also includes local and non-local mileage a reimbursement uh for use of your personal vehicle and reimbursement rates um uh for like um you know actual cost for parking tolls taxis buses airfare things like that if you're traveling outside of your IM
135mediate area and of course we're always looking for the most economic means uh to be able to do these things um also um to cover the costs for convenient uh and uh or organization of education and board related activities and events so say you set up a meeting yourself and bring in members of your District um those costs can the money can be used to cover those costs goes into printing I mean it's very in great detail printing distribution of letters just newsletters other materials um which again I said you can use certainly you can use the board the school systems printing services now the expenditures that shall not be incurred are the following um and I'm I'm not going to read them for you but they're right here pretty lays out pretty much uh
136in great detail um all the different things that you C that that $7,000 you cannot use um this to buy or pay for these types of services and then if you can scroll down a little bit further Cindy um and then um there was there was language um in the in the policy uh and I wanted to clarify it saying producing and mailing a newsletter posting signs purchasing advertising Greetings or any other expens that may be construed as campaign activities um because we also have another policy that talks about political activities and that's not um that for employees and board members that's not something that um you know this should be happening so then um the next section has to do with local meal reimbursement um and that you can be re reimbursed for no
137more than two local meals weekly um and then um local um meals may only be paid via expense reimbursement and then the re re um um the members may be reimbursed for C the meals while attending business meetings with constituents leaders P PGC staff so it's board business uh board members are authorized to be in reimburse for the cost of their own meals between board meetings and other official board business when it's not feasible prent or cost effective to return home in the interim um and then uh all the following information is required on all meal receipts so you must have names of the meeting and the participants and the purpose of the meeting so again it's documentation just support why you spent the meal spent the money on those meals and then board member
138meal expenses should be within the daily meal expense limitation which we had in the definitions um and then it goes into non-local travel and what is considered to be allowable and non-local travel costs it lays all that out for you right there um and then it also goes into uh the daily meal expenses when you are on local uh non-local travel um and it doesn't encourage uh board members to if you are like say at a conference and the conference itself offers um meals that encourages the the board as part of the conference board me they recommends that you use those eat those meals versus spend additional money to go out and buy a meal um and then let's see also board members May obtain a cash advance of uh for non-local travel to cover
139the cost for meals and other allowable expenses and to receive such Advance the board member must provide all receipts for credit uh so if a board member is unable to provide receipts to show the proper expenditure of a portion of the advance then the board memb is personally responsible to reimburse the board so that and that's no different than even for any of our employees or anything that if you do incur a an expense that is reimbursable the only way you're going to get reimbursed is if you can uh provide the um you know the receipt in the proper proper um um uh documentation to be able to get that then uh board members must sub submit um and I want to say something about all these allowable expenses and non-allowable expenses those pieces are
140not in law those are just things that the board had come up with previously and I think um I I'm guessing and I of course I don't know this is back in 2017 so I wasn't doing this business but I'm guessing that it was just something they came to agreement so these seem to be reasonable as board members and of course always thinking in terms of the fact that these are public funds as well as the fact that from a sense of transparency and you know what what does the community if they knew what you spent your money on what would they think is considered reasonable and not reasonable so I'm guessing that's how they came up with these types of things but certainly there have been for discussion if you think there's something that
141should be allowed or not be allowed whatever um and then Poss processing expenses so the board the um all board me Members um need to submit to the director of the board office uh uh all original receipts and supporting documentation for reimbursements on a monthly basis and no later than 30 days after the date of the transaction and that's to ensure that we don't have you know all these receipts and things are coming in and then it has to be processed um the same thing actually just so you know applies like to uh uh employees like they're getting reimbursed for mileage they're supposed to do it every 30 days and then the director of the board officer Desy shall process the reimbursement report checking with the budget analyst to ensure that sufficient funds exist in
142the board members account and referring any discrepancies or questions about individual expenditure account balances to the budget analyst should a question arise um the budget analysts May refer disputed amounts to the board chair who will refer the question to the full board for a ruling um so it would not be the board chair's decision to determine if this was an allow something was an allowable expense um uh it would actually be the chair would then bring it up to the full board to have uh to for the full board to make that decision um and then the director of the board office shall then transmit expense uh the expense form to the office of the Chief Financial Officer for processing and payments so all the initial work would be done in the board office now
143I do want to point out I have there was this a previous language talked about the board office liaison and also the board the budget an no the board financial analyst I did check with finance and they don't have any position like that and then I did talk speak with uh Mr Fitzpatrick also and he he didn't know who did what and but he did say that you all are also getting I think a budget analyst or budget someone so I think those details and I don't know if you want that written in here or not but I don't know those details to know who it is that you want to be able to do this work but you must have someone like a budget analyst whether it's out of the finance office or whether
144it's someone that is working in the budget in the board office to do that type of work then as far as the implementation responsibilities um that it talks about the fact that all travel arrangement for board members to attend conferences and participate in other business activities outside local are be made by the director of the board office design and also that all requests for reimbursement must be submitted to the director of the board office and accompanied by receipt and other appropriate documentation as well as an explanation for purpose of the expense and it is the responsibility the board member to provide appropriate statements to the full board when supporting documents are not uh provided so again if there's any question about an expenditure and there's no documentation to support it then again that would be
145something that would go to the the full board um and then board members are subject to denial or re of reimbursement or request for restitution when either appropriate documentation is not provided or expenditures are made that are not deemed to be allowable by this policy um the director of the board office design shall provide a full report to the board each month containing each board member's updated monthly status account report monthly uh telone statements will be also be provided upon request and then the last one is any questions um um of whether an expense is covered under these Provisions shall be referred to the board for a ruling if the board has questions regarding impropriety or undo influence then the board will refer the question to the ethics panel for an advisory opinion um and
146that was it so the majority of this policy is definitely what was in the bylaws previously um the only real changes that I did add to it was um you know it's um It's Tricky business about who is responsible for ensuring that the monies are being spent on what they're allowed to be spent on and and what they're not be and if they're not being spent on the appropriate things um and then who takes on that responsibility to ensure that um the person is informed or the board members are informed or they are um um the right steps are taken so that I felt that having it go to the full board probably was a better way of handling again if you think differently and I think of that only from the standpoint of ensuring
147there are no conflicts of interest that if it's with the full board to make a decision then that's probably less likely for a conflict of interest but if you think differently you know this is your policy so you know please you know please let me know what changes you'd like to see in it okay um we're going to start off with board member booer struther all right thank you so much this is really an important accountability policy I know the Public's very interested in uh right now so when it comes to the term campaign um can we get more specific there around campaign for political office or something okay really clear because one might say like say me as someone very interested in full funding of the blueprint I might look like I'm on a
148campaign like campaign use is heacy okay so if we could be very clear we're talking about political office campaigns for political office or whatever proper term elected office would have you know I'm sure you have you know that terminology that would be one I would like to see Clarity on I'm also and tell me if I'm just missed it or not seeing it but very specifically that these funds cannot use you cannot use these funds in order to conduct other business and I I was trying to find something that's really clear about that because I do know I do feel like that shows up somewhere you know this board has certainly discussed that when you are funded to go to nsba you should not be conducting your own profit making business and and we have
149certainly discuss discussed this you know that line with colleagues before if that could be added if it if it that can be that's not there but we can definitely add it I mean there's sort of language within the ethics regulations but since this isn't specific to this I think we absolutely can add that yeah so that that felt missing to me because I know as colleagues we've certainly informally you know said like oh yeah you got you know you really need to be careful about that and there's policy um the um let's see I had one more and I apologize I will come back for a second round on that all right we're going to go to um board member Walker and then board member Moss thank you so much I had a couple things
150thank you um uh Miss Walsh as usual the first thing is the perum I I would you know in the beginning I couldn't tell if that um per day when it said lunch and dinner um totals were for local or non-local so if we could just uh make sure that we say that there's a perdum if it's non-local travel and then the per day amount um if it's local travel in the beginning that's good I think it was under definition um there was a section B um about a credit card but I do believe that we're piloting the pro cards and so maybe we just want to find out where that is going to go long term just so we can not have to come back can update it we probably can ask um Miss
151how about that you're talking about the the purchasing cards yeah okay there's a pilot right now to use the pro card that's using the pro card so let's just talk to her about if there's any that it'll come thank you so much the next one was um also right now our 30 miles all come from Sasser however I live in akake where the where the deer reside therefore it takes me more than 30 miles to get to Sasser so I would love to see um it be 30 miles from your home um because for me to get to Annapolis for instance is very different than leaving from upam Marboro so um I'd love to see that switched from to be from Sasser to be from your the the board memb home address that's on file
152you know all the things in your disclosure the other thing is Section 5 C um talks about this new inclusion I don't know where this came from but the director of the board office shall provide a full report to the board each month containing each board member's updated monthly status account report um and here's the thing we actually individually get our budget line item from the audit department is it the audit department or from Finance like I get mine every month every board member gets it every month so we can keep track of that I just don't think it's value added for us to now add that I can see Pamela Boozer strs when she can manage her own budget we know we have $77,000 we know we can't go over or else we pay
153um um and it's not business for us to talk to each other about how are you spending your money effectively we do that with our cost account in BS okay that's what I have now if I have anything else I'll come back for a second round thanks so much um board me or board member Moss um yeah the particular section I I can't find it again that speaks to being able to use your um money for events um I don't know how appropriate here I just saw we talked about campaign activities and I know one of my colleagues asked for clarifying language somewhere around what campaign related activities are um I I would like some restrictions if possible during the campaign season or additional clarification um so that U sitting board members aren't using District
154dollars um to host vents during the election cycle um um I I I don't know how we clean that up um but or if the intent of the other sections that my the other section that my colleague spoke about actually clarifies that um but I would like some stronger language uh particularly during the election cycle that um you know I don't know how we do that I don't have the right language built in front of me now but I think we can get somewhere to to tighten that up um to to ensure that board members aren't used using dollars from this account to host events that are camp that events that are essentially campaigning the events need be consistent or maybe we clarify the kind of events to reflect um stakeholder engagement around policies or
155something like that but I don't know how we get there but that's just my initial thinking here yeah that's oh go ahead oh I'm sorry I was just going to say that's important language because of the fact that it really is a conflict of if you're using dollars that were designated for school system work and now you're using it really personally to advance yourself so um now we can get that stronger and I think folks will I think folks will blur the lines and can can blur the lines um and so as tight as we can get that language and as aggressive as we can get it I think it's not going to be perfect but I'd like to see it really strong so that sitting board members um aren't using District resources to advance
156their own campaigns okay um I didn't see a hand from board member Boer Str who I know s so I saw a walker first I'll go there and then board member Boer oh she can go first it's fine no worse well you raised your hand first she mentioned that she wanted to go but I think it's no problem sounds good I'm all in thank you um just on that piece I I totally agree with you um Dr Moss about not being able to leverage this for campaign funds which is where Pamela was going to you know just in that um for instance in District 9 I have events all the time and so there's going to be something happening during election season I'm sure just because of the nature of the when I do events
157that are unrelated to campaigning but some type of way we just have to put the language around it so it to your point it uh make sure it delineates that I'm having this I have been having this and it just is you know what I mean some type of way we have to do that because I don't want to have to stop all things in District 9 as a result of there's a campaign season because campaign season is like a year long quite frankly right but I I do get to the point of where um Pamela booer Str was going and I think where where you are too but the language um Robin we just have to kind of take a look at that because my ongoing um services that I provide I still want
158to be able to provide that to the community um a member booer sh uh yeah thank you I mean I was going to ask Miss Welsh you know your recommendation to remove within 45 days of an election um because that's you know one parameter to help with what uh chair Walker is um I'm sorry a board member Walker is um noting that maybe you know that could be one that we keep the 45 days5 days because then a as board member Walkers know noted that there you you know you could be a candidate for reelection in 2026 now today you can become a candidate the calendar is open um so that would leave a board member having to do that for for two nearly two full years so the 45 days was a was a
159parameter um I certainly am not opposed to keeping it but I would be interested in hearing from Dr Moss if the keeping the within 45 days of an election as one parameter that that that you think gets to this okay um Dr Moss or board member Moss yeah no I I I I love that language I just would hope that we we may want to put both primary and general because some folks might you know abuse the language uh I'm not saying that any of us would but you know this is the Poli icy person than me I I try to make policy for the future too I don't see any of my current colleagues abusing this but we probably should say primary and general election but I do appreciate the 45 days but that
160still doesn't solve to take care of not necessarily uh board member Walker but the concern that board member Walker has around she has consistently done these kinds of events so we would need to figure out how to not grandfather in but make sense of the fact that she's consistently done these things and should be able to continue doing those maybe it's no new acttiv something but I I appreciate the 45 days I just don't have the language to get us there but I also uh am hyper aware and and Bard Walker I got two minutes you can take mine thank you yeah you know maybe it is the 45 days um yeah this is a tough one let me think about it a little bit because I do want to be consistent in these because
161what does events mean does that mean my community chat too does that mean events that's like physical at the school you know I get not wanting to add on so maybe we have to have a freeze mode like maybe we need to put together our calendar and submit it I'm I'm not sure but something around how do we ensure that there's a frozen period and you can only do those because I I think that's where you're getting to the point is don't increase your visibility as a result of you knowing that you're going to do this on our dime right that's where you're getting to absolutely like we all know you've been doing these events like yeah all along like it wouldn't be it's not new for you I don't know how we there but
162I think I like where we're going here uh appreciate yeah but I like a frozen point so we just maybe we can play around with what that looks like um yeah I love was that was that your intent uh board member boo St there a frozen Point well I I mean the Pol existing policy at the Within 45 days of an election I think primary or general election day I mean to your specificity but you know I I just I'm fine with it staying in there and it's but you know my question was is it does it is it enough you know in terms of in terms of um some of the concerns that you had expressed I think we're at time looks like it started over a bit um Mrs Walsh did you have
163a comment I did I just wanted to explain why I took it out the 45 days because when I thought about like if let's say you're running for in the primary and you get you get chosen in the primary so now you're going to move forward to the general election so that period is a fairly long period of time from I think May to November and it might be a board members thinking in the back of their mind well I'll do this because this will look really good because I'm you know it's all a process in terms of moving forward to eventually get elected in the general election so that's the only reason I had included it but I I certainly don't have any I mean took it out but I don't have any problems
164putting it back in all right thanks for that context uh um board member Moss I haven't seen a board member do this but I'd like to preclude a board member from doing this um you know dur I don't know now I hear your point I still have the concern but I don't think there was an exception for like a Miller um in in the board policy that like you can't use it for mail I could be completely wrong y'all tell me if I'm but I I wouldn't want to I wouldn't want a Schoolboard member Mel and a Miller uh they somebody could hold a whole $7,000 um and wait to use a Miller somewhere I just just don't think that's cool well that feels okay so I think we're um I think we're we're we're
165we're we're cooked here so um I want to say U Mrs Welsh that um it sounds like you have some information but that feels explicit like that feels like that would just be a very obvious like abuse of of dollars I do think some of the Nuance that exists is if you're which I'm was thinking about as you were talking was like if you're campaigning and then you meet with the constituent while you're still a sitting board member but you are campaigning and they're like wanting to have a conversation with you and you get coffee together and maybe you pay for your coffee you pay for their coffee um and how do we differentiate between like was that a campaign you know conversation was that a just personal like I'm dealing with the constituent discussion
166um when do you get reimbursed for that cost and so I'm wondering Mrs Welsh if this like pivots to accountability um and you talked about like whether it's the budget analyst or I think that was a question you initially posed like who's the person that is going to be kind of making those determinations um around that information and that's where they would get those those lines of questioning because I even had a question that came to me about like I think a hotel call said it was like you you got two candy bars and like blah blah blah something very random but I was like I understand and it was the thoughtfulness of the discussion that could have been problematic so likely that would be the case is that that person would be whoever that
167person is would have the um the lean in to some of these other considerations because I don't think that we're going to be a to capture all this in a policy like it's just there's a lot of what ifs um that could happen um that could be problematic and it could be $5 dollar but even if it's $5 versus $7,000 it's still a problem um if it's used for campaigning um so you know I just want to mention that if that helps us to maybe get uh some traction like with moving forward um but I saw some other hands um and I want to go to the current committee Members First and then I'll come to you um board member Moss um board member Walker yes I actually oh let me put down my hand
168actually was going to say that piece on mailers is pretty good because I was just thinking about the notion of I remember at one point when I first got here and I and I'd been elected for four years I wanted to send out um to some people who came to one of my events my first events a thank you to them and as a mailer and um as I talked to the board director at the time we decided the answer was no to that because we just have too much technology like why you goingon to weigh some stamps and have a segment of your population when you can just send it out and so I I'm all in for I don't think we should be leveraging our funds for any mailers we had too much
169technology for that um and there's no need for that so I'm a fan of the no mailers I do think that sometimes we think it's intuitive but it it's not intuitive if it's not explicit uh the same way as for instance um our campaign colors we can be consistent all the way through or a whole bunch of stuff so there's so many different ways to campaign I think the point of this conversation is not to leverage Schoolboard dollars to campaign you can campaign on your own use your own dollars but not with the Schoolboard money and I think as long as we get to that we we we made the point thanks all right and board member Moss yeah I appreciate that um I just wanted to say and the whole like meler thing for
170me wasn't just during the 45 day window it was like across the board I just didn't want to be misc conscrew there like I I I don't want to see people sending mailers at all it happens in other races in other places sometimes in Prince George's County uh but I I think we need to be good Steward the public dollars um as as board members particular particularly in a place where we're asking for more dollars to to make more sense of realities for our young people so again I won't belabor to point whatever um you can do miss Welch to to really make this language strong um you know I stand in full support of okay sounds good all right and Mrs W I think to answer your question I'm not sure if uh colleagues
171are on board with it but maybe audit the audit um office is if there's no financial budget analyst in the finance department um then maybe is the audit I'm thinking like Miss simple or something like that I can ask her yeah party that like reviews these things and she seems like she'd have an eye for that so um okay so the question is shall the committee recommend policy 9354 board members vouchered reimbursement of expenses to the policy sponsor for revision approval any objections I I think we're going to object to it simply because we're um yeah we're we're uh we want to have those additions so miss Adan please take a roll call vote Mr BRS no Miss Walker no Miss no three next all right so the question is shall um the committee now
172shall the committee postpone policy 9354 to the next policy and governance committee meeting with the additions discussed today um Miss atlin please take a roll call Mr BRS hi Miss Walker hi Miss hi three the affirmative all right so um policy 9354 will be postponed until the next policy government meeting we're now going to move to item 5.0 um which are items for second consideration there are six items for second consideration um the first is uh item 5.1 policy developing curriculum documents for instructional programs and Elementary and secondary schools item 5.2 policy possession and use of alcohol and drugs on school grounds um item 5.3 policy 1113 informational material and announcements I 5.4 policy 5204 bus transportation for cheerleaders majorettes Etc this is a recision item 5.5 policy 5205 proms is also a recision and
173item 5.6 policy 5168 automated external defibrillators there are no objections to the committee uh the if there are no objections the committee shall recommend the policies under agenda items 5.1 through 5. to the full board for public comment consideration and any objections uh looks there's a question um board member Walker thank you so much I was just hoping for the record that you could just give a on liner on the two recisions on 5.4 and 5.5 while they're being resed thank you yeah so um yep throw that to you Mrs wsh 5.5 5.6 yeah so um we there is a memo um from Mr house and basically first of all that um because the law does say 4-42 that the superintendent is responsible for the administration overall Administration day-to-day management oversight of fiscal Affairs including
174management activities related to each of the areas of operation and the fact that the purpose of board policies are really to provide a framework or guideline for the operation of the school system and not to direct day-to-day management of the school system it was appropriate to have them both resented because they're really about the details like the proms and bus transportation um which um I I mean like we have we do have transportation policies in terms of conduct things like that but um to have a a policy about proms is like um that you can have Pro that about every little thing that the schools do so that I just I felt that it was inappropriate to to continue having those as policies because they're not really going to the governance of the school system
175they're going to the day-to-day activities of the school system thank you Robin I do agree with you I wholeheartedly I think that what we do owe when we have recensions is just the one liner of why it's going to be resented for the public the same as in our um share Briggs the same as in our um report when you do your report if you could give a oneliner um for the people thank you um so if there are no objections the committee shall recommend the policies under agenda items 5.1 through 5.6 to the full board for public comment consideration there being no objections the polic is under agenda items 5.1 through 5.6 will be recommended to the full board for public comment consideration we're now going to move on to policies for third consideration
176which there are none um so uh this brings us to adjournment the next uh virtual policy and governance uh committee meeting will be on January 28th 2024 please continue to check the Prince George's County Board of Education web page for meeting information and updates um there being no further business we would like to thank you all for uh the great discussions and attendance um to our viewers thank you for watching um and The Time Is Now 7:22 um in the January 14th 2024 25 policy and governance committee meeting is adjourned take care you all thanks good night thank you