CorpusRecord 198829

Board of Education Operations, Budget, and Fiscal Affairs Meeting - December 11, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / PGCPS
Date
2024-12-12
Location
Prince George's County, MD
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,555 words · about 42 min
Collected
2026-06-26

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001which will impact resource needs. at the school level. This is another area that is deeply impacted by Blueprint. We are required to ensure that at least 75% of state and local share funding across applicable Blueprint programs are allocated to schools. However, we know that a good portion of the 75% will be services and staffing provided to the schools but managed centrally. Now let's discuss the requested cycle. that really involves all board member understanding and participation. So there are three interrelated phases in this process. Phase one is our question and answers. Phase two is the Board of Education amendments, which we're going to go over that process. to the superintendent's proposed budget. And then phase three is the finalization or adoption of the budget. Of course, throughout all of that and throughout the entire annual budget

002development process. There is continuous community engagement. In the next details sections, the highlighted items are important dates that are new to this process which were approved in previous fiscal years. So let's keep going. Okay, so after Mr. House presented the superintendent's FY26 proposed budget. The budget book was released electronically on the Budget and Management Services website. The budget book contains details of the proposed budget and will be your guide to understand what is being proposed and to prepare follow-up questions for the administration. We will review the structure and the contents of the budget book later in this presentation. The highlighted row represents the official kickoff of the FY26 requested budget cycle. So that official kickoff is today in this meeting. And so we are now in the requested cycle. So we will have group sessions

003with board members and administration at the beginning of this requested cycle and throughout the cycle. That way, as you develop your questions, we can provide answers in a timely and orderly fashion. From December 8th until January 16th, board members will have the opportunity to review the proposed budget and submit questions to administration in preparation for the first work session. A second round of questions will be due by January 30th for work session number two. The administration will provide responses to process or clarification questions during the work sessions on January 23rd and February 6th. For data-driven questions, the administration will prepare and submit responses to those questions in advance of the work sessions. Board members are expected to review the written responses to the questions prior to those work sessions and come prepared with any further

004discussion or queries. clarifying questions you may have. for either fellow board members or our division chiefs. Following the question and answer process. In the first two work sessions and public hearings. Board members will submit their proposed amendments using the amendment template that I will demo for you shortly. Board members should confer with the respective program office or division chief to verify whether a portion or variation of the proposed amendment is not already in the budget, already accounted for. As well as to confirm feasibility of implementation and full scope of resources needed. Please keep in mind that we have a $42 million operating budget gap that we have to close. Any increase to the budget will have to be offset with a decrease somewhere to ensure that we have a balanced budget. The board's amendments, along

005with any initial administration comments will be discussed by the Abatha Committee during their February meeting, and the committee will determine which amendments will ultimately move forward for discussion by the full Board of Education. During the third work session. The third work session will be an opportunity for the board members to discuss each amendment and come to a decision, either by consensus or informal vote. on whether or not it should be included in the Board of Education's requested budget. Because administration will know ahead of time what potential amendments will be discussed, the subject matter experts will be at the work session If any questions arise during the board's conversation. Following work session number three, the agreed upon amendments will be added to the superintendent's proposed budget to become the Board of Education's requested budget. The board

006will vote to adopt this budget on February 27th. And then the budget will be transmitted to the county executive and county council on the following day. As noted earlier, there is continuous community interaction, input, feedback, and opportunities. Outlined in this slide are the various engagements for public participation. So now we're going to go over the components of the budget book. A separate budget book can be produced for each cycle, proposed, requested, and approved. Depending on the number of changes, the requested cycle may not be accompanied with the publication of an updated budget book. However, the approved cycle will incorporate all final changes approved by the board to include revisions during the requested cycle. Budget expenditures and FTEs are summarized throughout the budget book into 15 state mandated categories. There's a glossary in the supplemental section

007of the budget book, which provides an explanation of each of these categories. So the information included in the budget book is intended to provide transparency to our stakeholders and the communities we serve. To navigate through all the content, I would recommend getting familiar with the layout of the budget book and what's included in each section. Then you should review the systemic org chart to understand the operational structure of the school district. Central offices and schools. You can then begin to focus in on the fiscal highlights and pupil population pages Which is an introduction section. Description of revenue sources, changes in revenue and budget highlights, which are in the financial plan section. These area are the roadmap to understanding what is actually in the budget and will help guide your review when you want to dig

008deeper. The organizational overview and analysis were not initially included in the FY26 proposed budget book due to volume and time constraints. These pages are being developed currently and will be inserted into the existing budget book on or before December 20th. In addition, we will also add in the school-based expenditures and staffing. As noted earlier, the systemic org chart provides a good overview of how the district is structured. Each of our divisions are noted in the dark blue boxes with the respected departments and offices listed underneath. So we won't take time here to go into each of the recommended sections, but I want to briefly walk you through the fiscal highlights section as an example of how you can leverage this as a way to navigate the other areas of the budget book. The fiscal highlights

009captures changes, increases or decreases from the current year's estimated budget to arrive at newly developed a newly developed budget for the coming year. It summarizes changes in expenditures and FTEs. Mandatory costs are expenditures that are required by law or contractual commitments such as union agreements approved or proposed for the current budget cycle. The cost of doing business supports the ongoing operations of the school district. student-based support, technology, transportation, fuel, new school opening costs that are not included in CIP, et cetera. And then we have our redirected resources, which are reductions in the central office operations, which are redirected to invest in ongoing academic programs, program enhancements, as well as mandatory costs and cost of doing business. Changes in restricted programs, which are our grants, are also captured in this section and align with the change

010in restricted grant revenue. Finally, this section may also capture reductions In systemic budget assumptions. such as unemployment or workers' compensation. The summarized change in FTEs may not always align with the summarized change in expenditures. That is because the change in expenditures includes the summarized impact of discretionary and staffing changes. And then our organization improvements, our investments in instructional programs and district operations. New organization improvements are summarized in the introduction section of the budget book, which you will see on the next slide. This summary provides more detail on the breakdown between the impact of staffing and discretionary changes by department. And then the 930-24 actual enrollment count is utilized to project expected revenue funding. I know we've said this over and over, but it's really important to make sure that we understand that although our revenue

011is based off of 930-24, our revenue projected for 26, The 930-25 projected enrollment is used for expenditure planning of school operating resources. So just remember, we only receive funding for eligible enrollment counts as of 9-30-24. However, in the past, we've allocated school resources based on projected enrollment counts by 930 of the respective school year. Please also keep in mind that Blueprint challenges this practice and might force us to rethink how school-based resources are actually allocated to ensure we are in compliance with the legislation. And then finally, this is the organization overview and analysis page that you will see in our budget book that's republished next week. So you have your mission. Supporting strategic plan, your core services, and your budget plan. for every organization. We have our staffing and expenditures summarized as either restricted, which

012is our grant funds, or unrestricted. Some offices have one or both types. There are summaries of changes in grant funding captured in the financial plan and supplemental sections of the budget book. Please note that the FD is to determine if there is a change in staffing in this area. Are salary and wages and benefits year over year budget changes are primarily due to FDE changes, if applicable, salary changes as a result of negotiated agreements, or changes in benefit selections or rate increases. In addition, budget to prior year actual changes may also be impacted by positions that were vacant in the prior year. which are budgeted to be filled. And the discretionary changes may be the result of program enhancements, continuations. Cost of doing business, mandatory costs, or redirected funding for that department. Less common, but

013it does occur are restructurings with shift costs and FTEs from one organization or department to another. Again, the fiscal highlights or major change document is a great resource to put into context. Incremental impacts to the budget. Program enhancements noted on this page actually relates to the special education office, but it's captured here as an example of how it will appear in the organizational section of the budget book. So are there any questions? Before we move to the template. I just wanted to make an emphasis around the slight change in our process for the requested cycle that Director Smith presented and that relates to The format of the Q&A that will take place during the work sessions So similar to prior years. Board members will have the opportunity as she reviewed to submit written questions and

014administration will come prepared to answer those questions at the board meetings. Not necessarily in writing as we've done in the past. What will be provided in advance will be response to questions for data or reports that obviously we want to be able to produce that and provide that in advance. But we really want to leverage the work sessions as an opportunity to have a conversation and dialogue So administration will be aware of the questions in advance they will be prepared to answer those questions in the work session. And to the extent that there's follow up or clarifying questions. that format and form will allow for those discussions to take place. Thank you. And we'll be sure to relay that to our colleagues. A couple of things. So thank you so much for this presentation. I

015just wanted to make sure that we had two components of the board incorporated into our process for this year so We are hiring a board budget director And that person is going to be supporting the board in developing amendments to try to ensure that the amendments that we do create Keep in mind that $42 million deficit, right, so that we're not adding to that and You know, finding areas where you know the board members work with the administration to accomplish some of the amendment goals that they had. So I want to make sure that we incorporate that person or that group into the process as well. And we also have a citizen oversight committee that is being finalized right now. It's a budget oversight committee which They're going to be getting off the ground this

016spring and meeting and looking over the budget and providing board members with feedback. And recommendations as well. I don't, I don't think the ideas for them to be able to as targeted and specific questions and request data. So that's something that we are going to need to navigate and i think perhaps at the next meeting as the group is more solidified. We can talk about how they will most likely interact with the board And if they may have some questions of your team as well. So I just wanted to bring those two things up. Jamal, did you have any questions here before we go to the next? No, I didn't have any questions. Thank you. Okay. Okay, great. We'll go forward. I had a question about the blueprint impact. on the budget this year. I

017forget the slide where you were talking about leasing. You were mentioning that the blueprint, there was a component of that slide you were mentioning the impact of the blueprint on that funding base. I don't know if you could repeat that again. I'll reshare. Okay. So… Chair Adam Stafford, you're talking about the least Was it this slide? Yeah, so I think as we're… In the planning process now for our school-based budgeting, the process for developing our school budgets will be governed with a framework of blueprint which outlines how much of our funding at a minimum needs to be allocated to schools. This is a multi-year phase implementation. But the expectation, the requirement. is that ultimately at the end of the implementation. 75% of the funding intended to schools a minimum of 75% of the funding intended

018for schools is actually allocated to the school. And so what that means for us is right now, as you're familiar We have a process that we go through to develop our budgets at the school level and those budgets are developed by the principals We also have centrally managed resources that are allocated to schools And we have program managers responsible for that process as well. But the third component, which is a change for us and all the LEAs across the state. is we also have centrally managed school-based resources that are not currently allocated to schools. They benefit and the work is done on behalf of schools But the budgets and the expenditures for that are in a central office cost center. So Blueprint requires us to actually have the budget and the expenditures for those items

019captured at the school level. So that is going to be a change for us to make sure that we're capturing all school-based costs, whether they're centrally managed or not. at a school level. Tell me what the impact of that change will be in your opinion. Will there need to be additional training for school leaders or What do you think the impact of that change will be? I mean, the impact of the blueprint implementation is a major effort across the state for all school systems because of the various compliance requirements associated with it. There's the financial component. But there's the programmatic component. Ultimately, it's about improving academic achievement so what I think I'm just specifically talking about that component with the school-based component. Sure. Yeah. So it absolutely is going to require additional training and support

020for our principals. to understand how the flow of the money following the student and the development of the budgets will be changing for this year relative to years prior to the process in which they go through to which build out the budgets for the resources that they have responsible for have responsibility for. That process will be very similar to what they've done in the past. But having the full insight into the entirety of the budget that is actually going to be at their school that aspect of it will be different. In the past, they've always had visibility into not only obviously the budgets that they developed. They also had insight into those positions or resources that were centrally managed But they were still at the school level so they could see that in their budget

021and they had insight into that. The other component that will be new and different for them is essentially managed resources that they did not see in their cost center prior to. So just understanding the requirements of Blueprint, how the budgets have to be developed, how the resources have to be utilized. absolutely is going to be a training an education effort. And we've already begun some of those conversations with our principals and principal leaders. But we're at the very early stages of that planning process. Okay. That's good. I'm wondering… with the school, do we have, we have um school-based budget committee, like community committees Let's make peanut butter. Superintendent. Will they be part of that discussion? So Superintendent Howes has a principal's advisory board We actually met with them on Tuesday of this week and we

022went over the proposed budget and some of the changes relating to blueprint. We have engaged with them earlier in the fall where we completed a survey to get their input around some of the changes Oh, go ahead. coming out of blueprint and how it was going to impact the development of budgets and so that That ongoing engagement with the principals and principal leaders. has already started, has already begun. And they've made it very clear that they want to continue to be involved in that process and sharing their input into resource allocation decisions. I'm sorry really quickly. I just realized, Cindy, can we bring over… Vice Chair Briggs and Board Member Moss to the discussion as well, because they may have questions as well. I just realized they're in the attendee section. I guess I hear

023that and that's that is good. That's great. I'm thinking like at each school level. I just remember working in DC and they had a local school advisory committee And when budgeting came down to the school-based level, this committee had a very strong input in how those dollars were spent. at the school. And I know that we have a similar model at our community schools with their steering committees. So I guess, if you could just clarify for me if that's happening with this new blueprint implementation. There is… across the board or yeah, I think that's what I'm trying to get at. Thank you for answering this question too, by the way. Sure. So when we actually roll out the school budgeting process There's actually a timeframe different stakeholders in the budgeting process led by the budget

024office. We also have our other partners here as well in the HR side. We'll actually meet with the different principals and the school IDs. to go through the actual process. The principals have the autonomy and the responsibility to develop the budgets for their schools based off of input from their school teams or school leaders. There is, in addition to the budget that they manage where they develop their own budgets based off of the needs for that building. There are additional resources, as I stated earlier, that's managed centrally, but there is ongoing engagement between those program managers and the schools To make sure that the resources are aligning with the needs of whether it's a program Or a particular area within that school as well. So it's a collaborative process. There is a part that's centrally

025managed. But when it comes to the principles developing their budgets. they get a pot of money and they develop those budgets. The change for them this year is that they have to develop it in accordance with the blueprint that defines that the funds have to be used on a very broad basis. So as an example. If we get funding for special education. They have to use it for special education. They can't use it for something else. Now, how they use it for professional education, that will look different. they will have some flexibility in how those resources are defined. But, you know, they do develop their own budgets at the school level. Yeah, that's what I was going to say. I had the privilege. Good evening, board chair and board subcommittee chair I've had the privilege

026of serving as a principal in our district in three of our buildings for a total of 14 years. during most of that time, we had student-based budgeting in effect. And during that process, there's absolutely an expectation for principals to have a community engagement component with parents to present the budget process, engage in a exercise with them to identify their priorities and to take that information back as a part of the development of the budget once the SGB has been released to them, as Chief Howe suggested. Thank you so much. I'm going to call on um board member Dr. Felton Moss Thank you, Subcommittee chair stafford uh just a just a follow-up question With respect to the various school principals having to have school-based budget committees to serve in an advisory role. Are there a set

027of guidelines or principles, and this may be for Dr. Coleman. to ensure the integrity of that process? And are there follow-up processes from this office that would ensure that principals are doing that with a great deal of fidelity. And also layered with that, as a former principal, I remember my first year That might have been overwhelming for me. So there are a set of guidelines and principles that are guiding that. To be able to support principals on their journey. And just connected to that. Do we have uniformity across the district with that process? Yeah, that's a great question. And we do have various touch points with principals, especially new principals, with regards to the budgeting process. That actually takes place well in advance of school budgeting it takes place When they become a new principal.

028So summer time frame. We actually go through that process and we actually take them through a mock development of a budget, obviously it's almost a year in advance, but we want to at least get their feet wet in how that process works. And they have an opportunity to kind of develop a mock budget and kind of really work hands-on in the development of a budget for the very first time. Now you fast forward to the spring time frame where we actually get into the budget process. There are very detailed budget guidelines that are shared with the principals. And there's actually training that's provided. I forgot exactly the timing frame associated with that, but it's before the school budgeting process kicks off. Our budget team will actually facilitate those sessions with the principals, with the instructional

029directors, and we will go through that budgeting process and help to facilitate The answering of questions and also support them as they begin to work on their budgets. Principals are more seasoned than others. They've been through this process You know, many times before. So sometimes during those sessions, they will actually be well into the development of their budget and it's an opportunity to maybe ask clarifying questions Whether that wears others may just be starting their budget and waiting for that instruction before they kind of dive in. So you've got a wide range of experience when it comes to the budget development process. And then we try to try to be there very supportive throughout that entire process to ensure that they have the right level of guidance that's needed There is an extensive review of

030their budgets. So once they've actually completed their budgets, it's submitted to their instructional director. It is reviewed by their instructional director. And then the process also begins with the review of the budget by The budget office, by our HR partners to look at the integrity of what's being submitted to make sure we're considering the impact on staffing. on employees and if there's any changes or edits that's required, the budget has to go back to the principal to make those adjustments. So there's a series of reviews that take place. There's also the review of the budget by our different specialty program areas. So there's a lot of hands that touch the review of the process or touch the review of the budgets. Throughout the process and working with those principals to make changes and adjustments as

031needed before it's ultimately approved and finalized. Thank you so much. Now let's go to a second round with Dr. Moss, and then we'll move on from here. Yeah, I just appreciate you again, Board Member Adam Stafford. Appreciate your response, Ms. Howell. I think I had a question really around the process. of engaging in that process where we do stakeholder engagement. Are there a set of guidelines for the principals around what that process should look like? how many folks should be at the table. What does it look like to build consensus around a budget? I appreciate all the other components. They sound extremely Amazing. I would love to hear around implementation of the process of engaging stakeholders and what does that look like and if there are guidelines from the district team to support principals with

032that stakeholder engagement component. One thing that we have provided in the past is a shell of a presentation. And that includes some initial information around the budgeting process, some key metrics to consider, whatever the, you know. budget challenges we may be facing for that year that the principals can then take and then they begin to customize the remainder of that presentation as they're engaging with their parent-teacher community organizations or other stakeholders. around gaining their input or their insight or their um contributions in terms of priorities about that particular school and that schoolhouse and that building, what they're looking for and so We do provide them with kind of a standard template that they can start with. that has a lot of the great information that's necessary to make sure that message is consistent. But then

033we give them that flexibility to kind of layer into that and make changes as they see fit, as they're engaging with their community that they support. Thank you so much, Chief Howe. Chief, how would you be willing to, after this call, perhaps if we could set up like a follow-up call with Dr. Moss? to just talk a little bit more about community involvement in this school-based budgeting process. Just to, because I'm sure that he has some more follow-up questions. I know I do as well, but I think what we're wanting to know and see is a model where the budgeting that is happening at the school-based level is really rooted in a community framework where they have like some norms and protocols by which the budget has to go through an approval process from the

034community and from the certain stakeholders that maybe are elected by their community. And I mean, that might be something that may take several years to build up to that infrastructure ultimately, but perhaps we could just talk about what is in place Currently, and then some things that we think would really help with that community-based budgeting. Sure. I mean, I think I'll just kind of close out by saying there's a standard framework that we provide for the principals. But we really give the principals a lot of autonomy And the way in which they engage with their communities because it is different and it does vary About what that actually looks like. But I'd be happy to meet um Separately offline and kind of talk through that process. And if there's a need to kind of develop

035some more norms that the principals can follow. But I know that many of them do start with kind of the general framework that we provide and then they kind of build it out from there to To determine what's best for their school. Thank you so much. I think we can go now to the next part of the presentation. Thank you. So this hopefully won't take long. I just wanted to present to you the amendment template. So that you guys can just look at it. And then if you have any questions, we can go there. So let me share my screen again. Okay. Can you guys see? the template. Okay, so trying to simplify just to And just a little bit basically just a little bit You would just enter, so for example, Chair Adam Stafford,

036you would enter your name here and then you don't have to worry about this part at all yet. And then you would just go into the first tab is for program is for positions. So for example, if there is a position that you would like to see added to the budget, you would go in here in the first line or role number two is just an example to kind of give you a guideline on what it could look like or what it should look like. So you will enter the parent call center name. And if you don't know it Feel free to feel free to feel free to either reach out to the board office or reach to me and we can help get this completed. We have people in place that can help complete

037this if you're not sure. the organization, the specific program, and you'll see some of them have drop down menus. So you're just selecting. It's just a selection. Let me see if I can make this a little bit bigger. Same with organization. drop down the specific program you would like to add the position to. If you don't know the cost center, don't worry about it. It might auto properly, actually. Whether it's a new or existing position. So does this position already exist and you just want to enhance the number that we have or is it a new position? And again, there's a dropdown menu. You just hit new or existing. The fund type, most likely it will be general funds. And then the new position title. Or the position title. If it's a new position, you

038would just keep new position title. But if it's an existing position, you can search for it. And there's a whole dropdown of our existing positions. And then from here, you're just going to enter the change, whether it be one position. two positions, three positions, whatever you want here. Everything else. may auto populate. And then the only other part, and this is primarily due to blueprint One, priority ranking, because again, we still have a budget gap that we're trying to close. So we want to understand the importance. And I know this will probably be discussed in some of the work committees. justification for it. the type of expense. do you think, is this for central office or for school? Can it be allocated to a school? And again, this is because of Blueprint. If so, which

039schools? And it's high level. You don't have to specify each individual school, but is it for elementary schools? Is it for our middle school, our high schools, our K through eights, our pre-K through eight, regional? There's a couple of options. And if None of these options work. You can just hit other. And then provide more specification in the next column here. And then you can, is it is this item tied to blueprint? And if you're not sure what that means, yes or no, we do have over here some high level guidance on what the five pillars are for Blueprint. and what some of the programs are. And this is, again, just for staffing. The next tab is for discretionary changes. any type of contractual service you may want to add. And again, it kind of

040goes through the exact same process. And just a description of what it is. that you're trying to do. In the amount, how much do you think estimate that is estimate that it's going to cost we do ask that you, and I think I said it in the presentation please work with, we asked board members to please work with the respective program office Just to have a full scope of what this is actually going to cost because we want the budget to be a true representation of this enhancement. We don't want to under or overestimate as much as possible. So we want to get as close as possible. And so Please work with the office, our subject matter experts to better flush this out. And then also for feasibility, because sometimes we have great ideas that

041are important and it But the feasibility, we're not going to be able to implement that in one year. It may need to be a phased approach. we may need to, you know what I mean? So just to get a better feel. And this is all we're asking you to complete at this time. And then if we have questions. we can discuss it. We can reach back out, we can have conversations during the work committees but Do you guys have any questions about the template? So far. Thank you. No, I think this is a much more simplistic view and I like how it has the sort of two tabs here that we can toggle between. I think one of the things that I'm hoping will happen is that the board's budget director we'll be able to

042support board members with this so that they can… accurately fill it out and understand sort of what would be taken away for the initiative that they're trying to put in. Or, you know. where there may be where there may be some hidden costs maybe they're not considering so that when we're working together, the board members can have a more robust understanding of the impact of the amendments that they're proposing. And so I'm hoping that when we have those four by four meetings, and I know Reveille, we're in the process of bringing on the team that's going to be helping the board members. If the folks that are going to be supporting the board in that can be included in those four by four meetings. Which also brings me to the question of board members talking

043directly to the administration in terms of different staff members. And I've heard you guys mentioned that a couple of times today. You know, typically board members communicate just with the superintendent. So as so that we're not you know emailing different chiefs and over we have this new system where we're putting in requests So are we When you're saying communicate with program officers and department leads, you're referring to the request system or you're referring to us emailing them directly? Because I just want to be clear So that board members have levels set their expectations on that. Yeah, thank you for clarifying that. It will be through the new board tracker. Okay. that's being utilized. So you'll submit the request. It'll go to the appropriate chief and then they'll have the opportunity to respond to that request.

044Which may include a request to meet. To have a conversation if you want to dialogue about something that's easier to talk through Just through email, but that would be the starting point to initiate that engagement. Great. Everything should go through that system. Okay. Okay. Great. Great. Okay. All righty. So let's, if that's it for that one, Dr. Mosser, excuse me, sorry, Jamal jongo, do you have any questions? on the amendment process, Dr. Anderfel And Dr. Moss. I just… I just like the… the form or how did I say the Google sheet? I think it was actually really simple and it's easy for board members or anybody really to use. I did have a question. You're ready to come. mainly surrounding the part where We choose the grade levels for like, I guess like if you

045want to classify something like if you want it for pre-k high school elementary school um Is there an option where we could like select all like if it's like a thing where it could be… chosen for all levels of education And if so, or I mean, or is it like When we click the other button, did we just type in like all levels of education so that it's more classified then? Yes, exactly. So, and there is an option for all. It's all including charters all excluding charters. if you're talking about the type of schools that the amendment can support. But if you want further clarification, there is a column where you can just free form and type in a response that could provide a little bit more context. Okay. Thank you so much. If there

046are no further questions, we're going to move forward from here. Give me a second. Okay. All right. Thank you so much, Chief Howe and Ms. Smith. We're going to move on now to Chief Item 4.0, Chief Operating Officer Updates. And so I'm going to recognize Dr. Coleman, Chief Operating Officer for the Human Resources Audit and Bus Driver Challenges. Thank you so much. Thank you so much board subcommittee Chair Adam Stafford. At this time, I'm going to turn the presentation over to Dr. Christy Baldwin, our Chief of Human Resources. Thank you, Dr. Comey. Good evening, everyone. Good evening, subcommittee Chair Adam Stafford. I am here with our senior HR partner that one of the areas of staffing they oversee is transportation, and that's Mr. Curtis Eugene. And so Mr. Eugene, if you want to… Start your

047PowerPoint. That'd be great. Thank you, everyone, and thank you, Dr. Baldwin. So good evening, everyone. We're here just to provide some brief updates regarding transportation. Specifically as it relates to the formative transportation audit that occurred recently. and its implementation for this fiscal year. So in terms of just providing some updates. Currently, from a bus driver fill rate, we're currently at 82%. And this is in comparison to being at 74%. at the beginning of the school year. Also, as it relates to was the driver of vacant FTEs. We're currently at 183 versus being at 267 at the beginning of school. This was a reduction of 84 FTEs. One of the things that occurred this school year is really an expansion and of the diverse recruiting mediums that we were utilizing this year. It included, similar to

048before, radio, television ads and so forth. But some of the areas, and you can see the illustration that we really expanded to, and I really give a tremendous kudos to our recruitment office. As well as communications included the Mall of Prince George's Beltway Plaza. One of the things that was pretty unique is out front media marketing, which is bus advertisement. And you can see that there. Bowie Town Center, as you can see in some of the malls, in some of the food court areas, we had different announcements and publications. So we really try to be very diverse in the different areas that we recruited and let individuals know. that we were hiring and specifically hiring for bus drivers. One of the questions that's come up quite consistently has has been bus driver compensation. And so

049this detail analysis was done by our compensation and classification area, just looking at what the market comparison is. for neighboring and other LEAs from a comparative standpoint. And as you can see, Prince George's County Public Schools is really from a minimum wage, a minimum pay range standpoint, we're actually the third highest in terms of what we start individuals at. But when you look at our midpoint and our maximum, we're over 100% from a market comparative standpoint. I think that's really important to note. As well as looking at the maximum pay range where we are, we're actually second. to Fairfax County, which means and which means And what's significant is that the maximum pay wage, we're actually $10 more, approximately $10 more than some of our neighboring LEAs. So an individual has the ability from a

050longevity standpoint and an earning potential standpoint to earn significantly more with us as they build in their retirement. And to be in a much better situation going forward. So again, the summary states that PGCPS is within the market at the pay range minimum and above the market at the pay range midpoint and maximum. So again, this is something that consistently comes up as it relates to compensation. In terms of where we are relative to our competitors. Within the DMV, it's a very competitive area base. in comparison to the private and public sector, but we're very competitive from that standpoint. Where it comes into play, where there are some opportunities the minimum right now for a bus driver is six and a half hours versus some of our competitors, their minimum may be at an eight

051hour workday. So that's an opportunity that exists. from that standpoint. There were several key audit recommendations that were made as a result of the audit that we wanted to denote where they had been implemented. And the subject areas are As noted, economic support and opportunities. One of the things that was done is to minimize economic barriers Candidates do not need to pay for fingerprinting and background checks. This also includes D or T physicals, TB tests, drug screenings. which are completed via various partnerships. Candidates can be temporarily hired as a bus aid during the CDL training period. So that way, once they're once they're learning and looking to get their learners, they have the ability to be hired with us, acclimating themselves to the transportation environment. And making sure that this is something that they want

052to pursue and having a very supportive structure around them and encouraging structure around them as they pursue their learners so that they can eventually transition into the actual bus driver CDL training class. But we want to thank the board again is with the most recent contract negotiations effective of July First, there was an increase in the pay for bus drivers, but also there was an increase in pay for the CDL bus driver trainees, which is not covered under a bargaining unit. But these are individuals that are trade. We actually do have paid driver training. and paid driver cdl prep class training as well. And so that was increased from $15 to $18 just to allow us to be more competitive in terms of recruiting. and attracting individuals to pursue that career path. And another section

053was regarding concurrent processing. That was an opportunity that was presented. So where possible. Items such as new hire paperwork, medical tests, CDL theory prep. They're done in parallel versus having to do them sequentially. And that definitely minimizes the onboarding and processing time for our candidates. Another area that was put forward as a recommendation was the enhanced candidate tracking and support. We're actually in the midst of finalizing a system to track each phase of the hiring process from the interview to the actual start date in the training class so that as individuals come in and inquire. We can know exactly where they are, know where to follow up from that standpoint, just to expedite their transitioning from an applicant to somebody that's actually hired with us and able to start into the training class. Another section

054that was highlighted was improve administrative efficiency. Our internal processes continue to be and were streamlined. And one of the things we did is that applicants who do not respond within 30 days are no longer considered So resources can be redistributed to be spent on active job seekers. One of the delays that occurred before in the processing and time that it took for individuals to be hired is we were I'll use the word being very generous. with individuals as it relates to if they applied we kept keeping them in the pool, in the candidate pool and kept going back to them and kept going back to them to really see they were interested in pursuing the career pathing. So we really had to determined that after 30 days, if you are not responsive. to the efforts,

055be it via the phone, email, text, the various means that we reach out to individuals, then we would determine that you were no longer interested so that we could spend that time on active job seekers. And that has tremendously helped us in reducing the amount of resources depleted to individuals that are not interested. Another area was that was recommended was to add staffing in the HR department dedicated to recruitment and development for bus drivers and aides and One of the things that was shared earlier from a fiscal standpoint is that we're currently experiencing a tremendous budget gap and fiscal challenges. But one of the things I'd like to thank publicly, Dr. Baldwin. is we were able to execute this recommendation of adding staffing. And what Dr. Baldman did is there was a strategic realignment of

056the existing human capital Whereby we do have a dedicated administrative staff that is primarily dedicated to transportation to follow up on individuals to see where they are in the process, to provide guidance and assistance. And that allows us to also do in-person assistance with individuals that may have some technological challenges. And that has tremendously helped us as well. Moving forward in that process. So although there are current fiscal challenges, that was not an impediment for us to actually dedicate staff from a strategic decision to assist with that. In terms of next steps. One of the things we're in the midst of doing right now is a strategic bus driver staffing plan. Along with the Office of Strategic Planning and Resource Management and Transportation in partnership with them. We're leveraging business area expertise in the development

057of a strategic business driving staffing plan. Not just a short term, but a long term, probably one to three year plan Where we look to see how we can continue moving forward with filling the vacancies that exist, but also strengthening the culture and climate for enhanced retention of current employees. And the reason that's highlighted is As challenging as it is to recruit and to hire for bus drivers, and I've said this before, oftentimes what we are doing is we're recruiting individuals that are interested in being a bus driver because we actually train them and educate them to transition into the bus driver position. The challenge we have is we want to make sure that those individuals that we invest a tremendous amount of fiscal capital in actually remain with us because the more people we

058can retain, the less stress it puts on us in terms of having to recruit and staff positions. And so those are some of the things that we've done from that standpoint. And just again, it was just to provide a brief update. There will be further updates provided in future board meetings. I think the next time we're meeting and presenting on transportation to provide more detailed information is at the January 16 board meeting. I'm just going to open it up to any questions individuals may have regarding the implementation of some of the recommendations from the transportation audit. Thank you so much. Colleagues, do you all have any questions or comments about that presentation? I'll just start off by saying I'm really excited to see the decrease in the vacancies. And to hear about how the implementation

059of those recommendations have led to a more streamlined process. Is there a way to quantify on average from application to you know hiring uh like a like actually giving the job offer and you know hiring folks how much that time span has decreased as a result of the implementation of some of these These recommendations. And then I'll go to Dr. Moss. No problem. Board member Adam Stafford. One of the things we can, I can probably get more detailed information to provide that specific question in the future. I know one of the things that was presented during the formative audit is that it could take up to 12 weeks. for individuals to go from the interviewing timeframe to the actual hiring timeframe. We know that that has been significantly decreased. But again, part of that was

060because of what our internal process was. We allowed individuals to stay in the pool for an extended period of time. Once we committed to saying, okay, if you're not if you don't proceed forward with what's required and what is asked of you to demonstrate a sincere interest in working for Prince George's County. as a bus driver or as a trainee as a once we reduce that, that significantly reached the time from the 12 weeks to last. But that level of detail, we can provide that in a future date for you. we'd really like to see that. I know I can speak on behalf of my other colleagues as well. I'll go to Dr. Moss. One I just want to say incredible work from this team to respond to the audit. Lots have been said about

061transportation, but so much It's so encouraging to see some of the changes being made tonight. So I wanted to just hold space and honor and respect the work that you all have done. to respond to concerns immediately. And my question is, have you all thought deeply about proposing any incentives packages beyond what has already been done? for bus drivers and how the board might be able to support that in the future. You can whet our appetite just a little bit. around what might be coming in the budget process to support the onboarding of more bus drivers. But again. I'm really here just to praise and thank you. And thank you so much, Dr. Moss. So what I would say is what's exciting and interesting at the same time is that we're currently in the midst

062of negotiations. for local 2250 because the current contract expires during this fiscal year. So to your point, anything that involves incentives. compensation, retention bonuses, anything along those lines are things that are negotiable. So that's going to be part of the discussion. But again. So any support that can be provided with that would be most welcome. But I also want to be very mindful of what was shared earlier. is that we're currently in a very challenging fiscal time. And so it's going to be an interesting time for negotiations because that is something that is definitely going to come up. So it's going to be a delicate balancing act that we have to ensure how we allow individuals to make sure that we continue to be competitive in the marketplace, continue to be competitive with a very

063challenging position to fill, but at the same time being responsible for the fiscal concerns that we currently have as a district. He has to have a minute left. Is there any way to publicly talk about some of these adjustments that have been made? Is there a plan to be able to do that? Folks like to hound on us a good bit about transportation. whatever good things we do, I think it's important that we highlight those to the general public. I'll be sure to say it when I go to community meetings, but is there something we'll be doing to talk about where we are with these updates? Just to speak more generally, we… provided the board with a first quarter transportation action plan update related to the first phase of the prioritized recommendations from the formative

064audit. Our commitment to the board and to the public is to give quarterly updates throughout the year. So our second quarter update will be at the January 16th board meeting that Mr. Eugene referenced. It'll include a deeper look at the HR piece as well as a comprehensive look. at where we are with the implementation of the action plan and even look at the… areas that we're going to expand the plan moving into school year 2526. So yes, sir, that is coming. Okay. Thank you so much. Quick question. This one's for Dr. Coleman. All right, Dr. Coleman. Tell me if tell me if this is too out there. But hear me out. As the school district. looked into the possibility of advertising on our buses. Because as I understand it, we own our buses, right? I've

065done some research and I've seen some districts using the advertising space on buses to then perhaps provide drivers with extra incentives or resources to incentivize people to come and work in their district. Very good. Mr. Baldwin, Ms. Eugene, Dr. Coleman, what do you think? Yeah, thank you so much for that question, board subcommittee Chair Adam Stafford. Human Resources and Transportation has discussed that as an option. Curtis Eugene has spoken to the different advertising campaigns that have been implemented. However. There are guidelines as far as what we can and cannot do with our buses. So I'll turn it over to Director Baldwin to give you the state guidelines relative to putting banners on buses and that sort of thing. You're on mute, director. All right. Can you hear me now? I'm sorry. Comar prevents us from

066putting signs and labels on those school bus So unfortunately, we're unable to do that. That has come up from discussion a lot. unfortunately the comar standards enable us from doing that. But even with that limitation, that's part of why with human resources and the recruitment team, we've tried to look at other inventive ways to advertise to the community for um If you want to drive a bus, tell us so that we can recruit the candidates that we need. But I'm not even talking about recruiting bus drivers. I'm talking about selling ad space on our buses. Oh, I understand. as a way to raise funding to support incentives for the bus drivers. That's what I'm saying. Because I mean, I'm interested to know about the law that's restricting that. I'm interested to know about that. Go

067ahead. Oh, I had a question kind of relating to yours. I was wondering, what is comar exactly and um I mean, first, I do love the idea of us using, you know, having an ad space on our buses. I do understand there's probably some type of regularity of what could be on the bus. Of course, you know. Maybe making sure that the companies that, you know. use our buses for advertisement you know still are still like morality wise are still in the lines of PGCPS code and everything But yeah, I just wanted to know what is Komar exactly so I can kind of get an understanding of how the regulations are. On our buses, yes. So he's referring to the annotated code of Maryland, and I don't know the exact law that restricts this, but

068we can certainly look into it and try to find out. But, you know, we also have our smaller vehicles. Now, the smaller vehicles, are those owned by PGCPS or those leased? Or even like the maintenance the um the maintenance vans or you know, whatever, I guess. Right. Good question. So the Comar standard I can put it in the chat for you. It pertains to just school buses? When we start talking about the white fleet. their standards for the white fleet. They're less restrictive standards for our white fleet and for our school buses. Okay. Well, perhaps… Would you be willing to maybe see what What is permissible in terms of some of our smaller vehicles, you know, if we could sell ad space, I'm seeing districts pulling in Tens of thousands. could get up into the

069millions. If you're a very, very, very large school district and you're allowed to do it on your buses. But that could perhaps be redistributed to raise bus driver pay or add an incentive or something. But it's just something for, I think would be interesting for us to look into. Any other questions or thoughts on that? Before we move forward. Alrighty. Okay. Thank you so much for that presentation. I think we are… Here at the end of our meeting. So again, I want to just thank everyone for being here tonight. So the next virtual Abafa meeting is going to be on January 29th, 2024. If you can continue to check the PGCPS website for more information and updates, just two quick updates. So the board will be pulling in a board budget director and pulling together

070our board, our budget oversight committee so the public can look forward to So those committee members being announced and voted on. And then we also have Hopefully we'll be having our pop-up sessions as we did last year in North, Central, and South County to support the community in understanding the superintendent's budget and the components of that. Any other updates? There being no further business, I want to thank you all for the great discussions. The time is now 624 and the December 11th, 2024 OBAFA meeting has been adjourned. Thank you all so much.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.