001all right good evening the time is now 6:02 PM I would like to call to order the December 9th 2024 board audit committee meeting welcome everyone my name is Pamela booer struther Vice chair of this committee and the district three representative of the Prince George's County Board of Education I will be acting chair of the meeting this evening tonight the committee will listen to the capital Improvement program overview process This falls under the audit committee responsibility of oversight of risk assessment and risk management and compliance with law and regulations uh agenda item 1.2 roll call Miss Barton please call the rooll good evening everyone Miss Pamela buther present Mr Briggs present Mrs Frasier Mr Jackson here miss Lolita Walker we have three present thank you so much Miss Barton we have a quorum present we
002will now have introductions of committee members starting with board members then administrative staff Board office staff and and any other guests I can I can K it off my name is uh Brandon Jackson board member district 6 um Jonathan bricks uh board member for district 2 Mia Barton administrative secretary for the board office good evening Shas kakoma Chief Operating Officer good evening Jason Washington associate superintendent of supporting services good evening Shayla Jackson director of capital programs good evening Lisa how Chief Financial Officer and I see we're also joined by ah there she is Miss Walter simple good evening I'm Janice Walter SLE the acting internal audit director thank you everyone and I would also like to acknowledge that uh board member Jackson is now chair Jackson of of the Board of Education and board member
003Briggs is now Vice chair of the Board of Education and pleased that they are both serving on the audit committee uh agenda item 1.3 committee oversight mission is as follows the primary purpose of the Prince George's County Board of Education audit committee is to provide oversight of the financial reporting process the audit process the PGCPS system of internal controls and compliance with laws and regulations item 1.4 adop adoption of the December 9th 2024 board audit committee meeting agenda the question is to adopt the December 9th 2024 board audit committee meeting agenda without objection there being no objection the December 9th 2024 board audit committee meeting agenda has been adopted item 1.5 approval of November 4th 2024 meeting minutes the question is to adopt the November 4th 2024 board audit committee meetings meeting minutes without objection
004there being no objection the November 4th 2024 board audit committee meeting minutes have been adopted agenda item 2.0 public comment 2.1 registered public comment we do not have any registered public comment speakers this evening agenda item 3.0 discussion action items 3.1 the capital Improvement program overview process I recognize Mr Jason Washington the associate superintendent of supporting services to give us the capital Improvement program overview process presentation uh thanks everyone uh this presentation will be presented by uh director Shayla Jackson for the from the Department of capital program okay I think that's my CE to go ready yes okay um so thank you for the opportunity today to spend some time examining And discussing a few of the processes behind our Capital program at PGCPS I'm going to jump right in with the note that I'm
005going to attempt to move pretty quickly through the area we've recently covered in depth so that there's time for some of the newer bits that I haven't had the privilege of speaking about with the board and so there's time for any Q&A that might Advance our mutual understanding and shared Mission around these facilities uh next slide so the road map of our time today again we're going to swing by that major project prioritization study we're working through that we call the efmp or master plan cycle one we'll pay a quick visit to the major project prioritization effort we're about to work on next then for cycle 2 plus and then we'll spend a little bit more time with the minor project prioritization we haven't discussed in any recent form and with our general project timelines
006and related oversight uh next slide just prioritizing for improvement there we go so this is the bit that hopefully is familiar from our October presentations the current master plan was prioritized primarily around three factors the first was facility condition uh we said that this is what we see right the conditions and dis repair that is visible as well as what's hidden behind the walls so we covered that this is Quantified into a facility condition index or FCI that is the cost of repair over the value of the building and the example I always go back to is it's like a house needing a new kitchen sink would have a low condition index because the cost of that sink should be very small compared to the house value so it's worth it to fix the sink
007but our facilities if you recall are third worst in the state by condition on average and that in every District so they are at such high indices because the needed repairs which are HVAC roof Plumbing Windows Doors ceilings electrical all add up to a value that combined is above half the facility value in most cases so we said then at that point what's indicated is more of a wrecking ball and less of a renovation so this index is always a a starting player in any Master planning to decide where to invest as well as what to invest in um next slide so that that wasn't very brief so I'm going to try again here with educational adequacy So This Is The Stuff Beyond condition that makes a school inequitable and requiring investment so unsafe parking
008lot configurations missing gymnasiums Underside classrooms by square footage and not by number of students um no steam Labs um it's also very very helpful to decide what to do as well as where to do it so you don't renovate a building with a significantly low EA score you just knock it down because what the low EA score is telegraphing is that even were it in perfect condition this building would still be inadequate for our students and inadequate is inadequate whether we can't heat it or we can't teach and it so this is just another phe of failure that's an important pillar for um responsible Master planning next slide okay so uh utilization so this is whether under utilization or over utilization we noted um back in October that both contribute to inequitable educational environments and
009therefore both have serious ramifications to that same question what do we do and when do we do it um that is educational facility master planning underutilization in one school suggests maybe a program location can be evaluated whereas a persistent underutilization in a region requires consolidations to get students into modernized seats and that this is because there are real and severe Capital funding eligibility penalties when empty seats are present in significant numbers in any region and and that's just baked into that state formula um and then of course when a square footage is significantly higher than the enrollment warrants there's a concept of right sizing that exists universally because there's such significant ramifications to the maintenance budget the general operations budget the school-based budgets and and all that translates to different flavors of inadequacy and that
010all directly impacts the experience of our Scholars to the point that these factors again are the star players you'll see driving any responsible Master planning or priorization effort pretty universally um next slide actually think I covered that in this one um so one more forward please so all these points were then synthesized into our current modernization plan or efmp the highlights were that 8.5 billion in $ 2014 and that was $425 million a year of investment that was required again in$ 2014 it was 29 consolidations in order to get us into all modernized seats and it was 140 projects spread out in three cycles of approximately 30 to 35 projects each originally envisioned to be seven years and that's how um it would be a 20-year master plan next slide so I just want to
011remind here that what we noted here was that you know there's been some legit miracles of innovation and political mountains moved for this cycle one to be where it is without that $425 million a year uh and and really I should start saying $570 million a year in 2024 but there's just so much recognition built in around those original numbers that that $8.5 billion became such a marketing cry that it gets hard to change it but nevertheless um even with the P3 um even with all of that really Collective energy and advocation to move this um forward it still wasn't it's still not enough when you consider the vast amount of facilities we still have in poor condition and the number of Decades of underinvestment that that represents next slide and this is cycle two
012as it currently is in the current plan um and here I'll just remind that the prioritization factors we've covered and that are represented in cycle one will be maintained because they are still solidly best practices but uh we do want to get better condition assessment data than the 2008 indices we built our current plan on um we want to update our educational adequacy store temp score template um to revisit it against modern standards and then to score our schools against those standards but we also want to build into this master plan some new pillars um some of the interrelated concepts of equity and sustainability as well as the blueprint mandates around CTE expansion and Universal prek next slide and this is just the road step to do that so in order to revise your EA
013scores you have to have new master Ed specs um and then we really launch that update project and we start to work through it with Community involvement until we're presenting preliminary plannings to the board and the community think we can go to the next slide okay so here's some of the fun new stuff that I didn't have in October and there's a lot that happens that's not new schools and I realized reading the board shar's questions for tonight that part of what was being asked was also this right what about everything else that's not a new school and how do we prioritize that so on this first slide in this category of projects that range from major system upgrades to roof Replacements or playground Replacements you see items that come from our maintenance shops so
014the 700 shop or the the ground shop knows for example which parking lots are in such disrepair that they're really becoming problematic for safe pickup and drop off the 300 shop knows which switch gear um or fire alarm is on its last leg maybe where there's strobes that aren't working the 900 shop um our HVAC shop they know where a boiler has truly taken its last stand so you know I would say the Wizards and the magicians in these shops are our boots on the ground and like hear me I can testify that they canque equipment so far beyond the manufacturer's best case for life expectancy um in a way that really should generate some Shock and a so Capital programs has always placed a great and appropriate weight in their word on what comes
015what should come next so um even with that said though predicting failure is more of an art than a science so yes they use data factors like they know the equipment age and they know the number of work orders that are being performed to keep the systems operable but it's definitely an area where our building service colleagues who just live with these systems day in and day out are the experts who know where that duct tape and Magic has come to an end and capital replacement funding is just truly imperative um next slide on this slide these are a little different because they come from instruction or schools to say hey maybe we have a student who needs this accessibility Improvement or maybe we still have an old pod classroom that has survived our efforts
016to address them all and the disruption to learning from partial height walls um is such that pod conversion is requested or maybe there's a population shift that warrants a standalone classroom and I and I just note here not additions because the process for a temporary structure is different in process steps from a permanent addition and even though right now we are working through some repercussions of our previous approach to Temp classrooms impossible with current permitting requirements we have to subject like permanent additions to that Master planning process and these two slides are meant to show you how we prioritize projects that are not in the efmp they're below the threshold of Master planning um but if you recall the October presentation when square footage is allowed to be added in properly without checks and balances
017it can really be used to perpetuate um intentionally or unintentionally inequitable Investments for decades so this check and balance process really is fair and reasonable so we tried to include permanent additions within our Master planning process that's a bit of a digression there but I'll just add that the other items here come from other departments in supporting services but similarly all pose a threat to the service provision in our schools whether kitchens might be failing on a code issue and we wouldn't be able to feed kids um maybe our facility condition has something that's outside our current um security guidelines or maybe it's just an unmet long-standing Transportation need that affects our abilities to pick up students um the only other thing I'm going to add on this slide I'm going to try to do
018it quickly is that minor projects um get slid into the CIP based on like I'm telling you the these these factors coming up as priorities but the prioritization once they're in there that part is a bit tricky that's a bit of a war because how do you dictate whose roof goes before whose window goes before who fire alarm replacement and and and that there is no perfect answer there I will say our general practice has been anything with prior funds is what you'll see at the top of the list so anything in mid construction gets first dibs on funding and after that it just gets trickier um because you know even to be considered for this list you're critical so um one of the ways we combat that is in every CIP we show a
019list of what we said we were going to do like maybe we said we were going to do Valley views boiler um because maintenance said we think this is going to fail but sometimes if Capital funding is delayed um or any any part of the process is delayed the fact that they were predicting failure and it was that critical might mean they had to go ahead and replace that with operator in dollars so we wanted to be transparent when instead of replacing valy fuse boiler two years later we actually replace another school's Chiller because we were worried that that wouldn't be cooled so we were trying to introduce an element of oversight that hadn't um existed before so I just wanted to make that note there um next slide h capital project timelines keep going
020so this is going to be a bit of a Moment of Truth our project management Supervisor was going to cover this for you tonight but he's recovering from a recent car accident so you're going to have to settle for me and it's been eight years since I was a project manager in our system so let's see how this goes um so this is a highly theoretical timeline for a theoretical new elementary school that has theoretically also been already approved for a high prioritization in the efmp just so we can get to the place where we're going to talk about the process of that timeline to kick off planning activities and request funding with and a CIP so any step that has that little clock next to it is indicating that there's an approval of an
021agency outside of PGCPS and it represents what I'm going to call um an external delay potential so as briefly as I can do this the first planning and design row right well the first planning row um is that request for initial planning funding um and that takes a year because that's that's the CIP cycle from request um to approval the next step is the AE firm solicitation um there you go sorry my my screen blanked out I don't know if yours it but the AE firm solicitation to do early planning activities Andor start design tasks takes around two months for a second when I put this together I thought this was the only step that didn't require an outside approval but that's not actually the case the state now participates in planning and design funds
022so there's a contract award approval step right here um so that's that's just an another approval that occurs the feasibility study um that's more if it's a existing school and we're trying to decide whether to renovate or replace uh but if it's a new school on a new site there's still a test fit study that goes right there and then that goes to msde for approval after that you would do the ad specs you would really get into which programs are going to be there what the space requirements are for those programs that goes to M for approval and then we drop down to the design process um these are pretty easy at just at each stage whether it's schematic design roughly 30% design development roughly 60% done with design construction drawings about 90% all
023of these uh go to msde and or dgs for approval there's also a project planning committee so the community can begin to weigh in on the designs and participate in that process and then I didn't put this in here but right around the DD submission that is where the state would expect to see your construction funding request so that that's another step that's not in here and of course if that funding was delayed well then the project would incur a delay there um and then once the construction documents are approved by DJs um you would see us enter into the permitting phase I'm going to put a year it's a reasonable number but it's by no means guaranteed to be an upper limit think with that we can go to the next slide construction I
024think is pretty straightforward assuming this is a design bid build excuse me we would put the permited drawings on the street for about 21 days for a competitive solicitation which then requires approvals before award um and then the construction phase would launch but this is um to answer chair Jackson's questions this really is the most monitored section of the timeline for any project execution in terms of there being such tight contractual requirements for the Builder that is directly tied to their pockets with oversight baked into so many different processes so for example the monthly process you pay them is based on progress-based Billings so it's a by line item payment application where the architect of record the construction manager we've hired and our project manager must agree in a monthly s sidewalk that for example
025drywall is 37% installed before we will release 32% of the drywall fee um we hold 5% retainage to ensure compliance with any punch list requirements at the end of the project and then we do that in the progress based building for every single trade uh another example is weather events right they have to be documented with Noah data and in fact they actually have to project out based on Noah's projections at the time of their bid for what the rainy season and the snow season is going to be like so those are baked in and only if we um exceed those projections would PGCPS even consider for example forking over more money to recover time or accepting a late delivery were we to find that unfounded for any reason to be late we would then
026access liquidated damages that's when those would come into play so in other words the contractor would be docked for every day past the agreed upon completion date so um truly uh just by itself in this topic we could do an entire presentation of some of the oversight steps that are really baked into a construction process contractually and we would be glad to dive into that um preferably one of our subject matter experts present so I'm going to move on and note that post construction is pretty simple you know construction legally ends when a building is done enough to occupy or for systems upgrade it's installed enough to use as intended so that's what we call substantial completion and then everything after substantial completion then is in this postc construction phase so punchless closeout occurs here
027that's where we held that last bit of retainage that 5% for drywall well we'll hold that until we're happy that every single wall meets our standards um and then we'll pay that out Um this can drag a bit depending on how well coordinated everything in the end is um things can happen like a drywall punch list occurring before the furniture move um and you know then there's definitely some finger pointing but we try to make sure every process benefits PGCPS right um commissioning is the next step that can be surprising because it can drag on for at least a year and that by Design so for example hva systems must be commissioned but they must do so in their proper season so if we turn it over in summer we still have to go through
028a whole cycle of Seasons um Landscaping at this theoretical new elementary school well has to have sight stabilization which means those that Landscaping Shrubbery and grass has to grow roots otherwise we're still a storm water runoff threat and we can't finalize that project and that list really does just go on and on and it's actually longer now because a lot of the green and that zero projects now you have to have a step of extended commissioning where you determine over a year that you're truly operating in a net zero or a positive state so there's all sorts of documentations and approvals required um in that commissioning step just so you can move into the closeout um phase and for the warranty phase to start um what else can I tell you there I think that's
029about it I think that brings us basically to the end of the presentation and we can just answer questions or provide responses when the rest of the team is available depending on how detailed the questions might be great yeah well thank you so much director Jackson so now I will open the floor to my colleagues to ask questions and then when they're finished with round one I will ask um board member uh uh Vice chair Briggs to um take the take the floor while I ask mine thanks any questions colleagues okay uh Vice chair Briggs right thank you so much acting chair Boozer Str um so I just had a question uh for Miss Taylor Jackson during the planning uh phase of the um presentation specifically for the ad specifications U my question was how
030closely does the developer or whomever worked with school leaders um for that for that specific phase or during the design phase um and I asked this question because I actually spoke with a principal who was like I love the school it's great you know we love it but if I had it my way like we would probably have less of like a kind of a community space cuz we need more classrooms and so we didn't have the space for that and um and we would have like maybe moved something else around so it was like she she brought up really kind of you know when you're building your house and you know how you want it like really specific nuances that she in hindsight realized didn't really work so I was just curious how closely
031that happens if at all AB it's a great question so the edpe process is John like that that committee requirement is very fascinating like it has all of our leading like academic leaders I'm not going to get their titles right um if it's a CTE space it has the head of CTE if it's special education they're there if it's like I mean down to if it's a um cosmetology space the teachers are there so the edpe process is really um involved so we also have the Prototype ECT so since this was in elementary school in my theory so that's a little harder because that's kind of General but you have this this Baseline which is really helpful because it helps us ensure Equity so I do like having a prototype but then when you're in
032a specific School building school specific ects you're looking at what programs that school has maybe that school is actually a regional tag center in it need special spaces so we work through that with the school-based staff we work through it with the academic staff and then that goes to well actually goes to the board for vote and it goes to msde and then the design actually really has to follow that aspect like you can vary like 10% um if it says a classroom is 900 square F feet you know you can go from 810 to 970 but like that's not right don't don't quote me on the math but that's the general idea um and then you really have to have a valid reason for varying from your aspect and then at that point the
033design has a project planning committee again there's teachers there's the principal there's those same leaders there's the community um and we're trying to show them the concepts as it's coming out we're showing them the floor plant as it's coming out but for that that specific issue I think sometimes there's a confusion about how that process works so we know from the insect how many classrooms are going to have and we're going to build those classrooms regardless of whether or not you have a community space um the community space is a different requirement I forgot where it originates but you'll see it in almost all our buildings A lot of times we haven't gotten theou and the contracts in place for them to be ready to go um when the schools open but I know some
034of our schools that we just opened some of those were envisioned to be community health clinics so that's why you see that community space is like on the front so you can have their own egress point in and out but there was never a calculation where it was like well if you don't have this space you would have more classrooms because the classrooms was built on the design to capacity and that's where all of those support spaces came out I will say we have a lot of principle turnover so it's not always the principal who was in the design process who then inherits the building and I know that sometimes that's part of a a bit of a conflict because now you own a building you didn't get to um participate in its design and
035director Jackson as a part of this question can you also speak to once the building has been constructed some of the follow-up feedback you get from users uh as to how it may impact future designs yeah that's something we're really excited about because we haven't formalized that um we haven't had internal design and and planners who I I just wanted it to be a really documented process but what we do is we do an enduser survey because a lot of times our Architects are very Innovative and they have these Grand ideas that are being deployed Across the Nation and sometimes internationally like um teaching stairs like the ones at Ooa or um breakout spaces in the hall and they've got these Visions for how the school is going to use it and how the children
036are going to benefit and sometimes when you go to the schools they're like yeah that's really just a nightmare like it's a nightmare like they're in the hall it's not a good breakout space since so we try to take that back you know so then in our next um design we either 86 that or maybe we build upon it or we fix it um because that's you know that's such a good opportunity to find out like we want to innovate but we only want to do it in a way that furthers an advances the educational experience of our students in those spaces I feel like my time is up but um acting chair boo strle let me know if that's the case yeah I I I I've guess I've suspended time I didn't ask for
037a clock to be set for everyone so I understand that answers to these questions are not going to we already understand that these if you want the full answer right now that we will have more than the 2.5 minutes so if you agree with that um we could keep going well I just have one last thing I don't want to actually hog up a lot of um air times but I just wanted to say like so I wanted to just understand better with the architect and the developer what's the distinction do they compared are we like going Contracting with an architect and then the developer is really doing all of the kind of the planning there and the reason why I asked that question is because I still think it's really important to the point
038that you made that the design fits you know like I just think about like that you know if the principal is there for some time and the teachers that there is that buyin to the space um and if as we're going forward if there's some way to kind of make that more efficient or just more effective maybe in how we how we're planning I'm sorry I what was the question part are the so is the architect that's what I need yeah so um we don't have developers per se um on the traditional projects like they did on the P3 projects what we do is hire an architect who does our planning so they'll do like our edic and usually that's the architect that actually then designs the building at that point we bring on who's
039going to be our Builder um for us that's either a general contractor or a construction manager at risk and then they just build what's in the design so where we spend a lot of time getting our principal and our teachers input is in the edx which is what programs will be in your school how many square feet they'll have what kind of Furnishings they'll have and then in the design process which we know in the early design process how the floor plan's going to work out you know we know where your core classrooms are going to be where your special classrooms are going to be and we know where that community space is going to be there might be also some tension because the community space requirement is of like a it's not really a
040requirement but the space the state contributes to a community space and we tend to always um try to maximize our state input so if they're going to pay for a space even if we're not 100% sure if it's going to be in like before after care if it's going to be um a community health space we're probably going to take that money and build that space out but I just think there's some misunderstanding in that that situation with that principle because that space wasn't Tak taken from another space she could have had she was always going to get the program spaces in the Ed speec and that's what's in the design okay thank you right board chair Jackson thank you um I appreciate that so this question is about the maintenance piece um can you
041can you help um walk me through and I know you kind of covered it a little bit but walk me through how do we prioritize maintenance like which um I guess things like whether it's like a boiler room or like heat or Windows like how do we prioritize what school gets um the maintenance piece first like you know as far as their problems addressed based on severity like how do we calculate that okay so I'm I'm going to do the H right because that's one shop that's the 900 shop and those was I'm sorry I thought I heard something okay um that's the 900 shop so they provide the capital programs a list of what they consider their most imminent failures um places where they can't Patchwork anymore where they need a system replacement that
042might just be the boiler um it it tends to be from the haac shop you know just the specific piece of equipment that's about to fail and we don't really question their prioritization so if there is any opportunity to put it in the capital budget you'll see it you'll see it in AC upgrades um this year because there was a indication from the state that there's going to be additional funding available beyond our major projects we changed our normal process with the state and we put a lot of systemics um before the state and those came from either the shops um for the roofs they came out of the roof inspections those were the ones where we were having the most water infiltration and the most mold issues and there's just nothing more or hazard
043this material guys can do and there's just nothing more that patching can do for those roofs so when they tell us that these are the worst ones that they're worried about we really do just put an extraordinary amount of trust in their knowledge for living with those facilities like that definitely right rightfully so I I'll would just say so when it comes to like let's say you have like the you like you said like the 900 shop or the 700 shop like so when you have like different shops saying these are our priorities how do which priority becomes the I guess the most imminent or like you know priority like the top priority I guess yeah that's a good question so that part does not have a satisfactory answer um because we just don't have
044one right we don't know how to prioritize one person's boiler or or another fire alarm system that might fail so you'll see that the capital budget is going to request all of it it's going to request the fire alarm Replacements it's going to put the boiler in the AC upgrades category um the only thing I'm mentioning we did different this year was We shoved some to the state because we're always looking for available funding so they have a healthy schools fund we threw some roofs on there because really we should be replacing 15 roofs a year but that's $37 million that we don't have um but so unfortunately though of course that means once it is approved by the board it then goes through like the county process and right now you know their main
045concerns are about their debt cealing and afford AB ility so it doesn't always feel good to us like yes the the requests are there but we think the likelihood of them funding AC upgrades which got zero dollars last year is probably low this year but yes the Board of Education requested the funding um I'm just less confident that that will get it and I will say the prioritization of those projects isn't as clear in our our CIP presentation as our major projects because if you notice our major projects are 1 2 3 4 5 six but then there's a whole category called AC upgrades and it's not in that priority order there's another project fire alarm Replacements there's a project hazardous material abatement Ada upgrades and we don't as a system present those as do
046this Ada upgrade and then do this fire alarm and then do this boiler we just ask for the home money for those categories I think Dr Coman were you did you want to chime in I didn't mean to cut you off I thought you came off mute I did thank you so much board chair I was only going to add that in addition to just the history uh that our maintenance teams have with our facilities they also utilize our work order system to help develop that priority order so they're basing it on true data that is tracked on a consistent basis gotcha thanks thank you and then um and um the last the last question I have for this round is uh about the if it's okay to proceed P okay the last question I
047have is about the um the CIP or like the backlog or whatever right so it's like um H how much I don't how much um how much will it take to clear out um the backlog of like the CIP projects like how much money would it take to bring us up to speed completely I have to Define um backlog we we've defined it a couple ways there's a backlog of funding that looks like it's on the books that we haven't spent um some of that is allocated to specific projects we're waiting to get to a certain um point where they can spend others is old funds that has strings attached to it that our team has just been this year really trying to um cut through that to make it available for us to spend
048another definition of backlog though is like our deferred maintenance backlog and that's the list of needs that we have so that is where when we talk about that 8.5 billion 5.5 billion do of that is considered the Deferred maintenance backlog um I mean that's the short answer but that $5.5 billion was in$ 2014 and that's what that would take okay thank you sorry it's not a satisfactory answer I'm GNA hand the meeting over to I was like um recognize um board member booer Str yeah thank you so much um I really appreciate the presentation and your um framework in moving with us as we sit as the board audit committee and as we move towards the the language of uh risk assess and risk management and um internal controls and I appreciate the preview around
049internal controls because uh I believe this committee will be asking uh the team to come back and do exactly as you had suggested with the internal experts um on that financial and uh operational internal controls um when we look at CIP from the vantage point of the board in this committee it is one of the areas risk that is very visible you know we you know some of our risk like around Safety and Security and cyber security you know would be less would be more difficult to present um you know because of for safety concerns so I appreciate you're working with us to reach this point that we're speaking this language of internal audit as a board and you know and so when I look at these risks it's the Decades of underfunding which which
050has been presented you know in multiple Avenues to the board that we understand but we haven't really been telling our funders the the Maryland general assembly and the County Council we haven't really been presenting I think as much in this this risk speaking about it as risk and so I was wondering if you could talk through just a little more again about some of those some of those real risks like when I think about the risk of um you know a review of a building and that the um that it is deemed structurally not safe as we were surprised with Templeton and Woodmore um where what happens like at this point do we have any more swing space how would the students be educated I was watching closely today the you know the the issue
051of Colum po um had to close because of a a major pipe burst and there's space into schools to move those students temporarily but what if what about the risk of a full closure like what what what kind of pressure has that put on your Division and so I'll just uh have you expand a little more about what this means right now to this board yeah that's a good question because you know our swing space is so severely Li limited that we don't have a lot of backup plans in terms of where can you definitely where can you relocate an entire school without breaking it up and disrupting the educational experience and straining um transportation as well I do want to um note that we feel confident that there aren't any structural um like like
052life safety structural issues that would cause us to close in the next couple days it's couple days couple years that's why the the assessments were done for the structures um but we worry about that in part because as we talk about things like roof Replacements that that continued water infiltration and those window replacements those can water infiltration um it destroys your structural Integrity over time in addition to making it a sick building and so some of the areas in Risk are keeping the buildings healthy enough to be occupied despite that much water being infiltrating um Heating and Cooling I think is our biggest risk like I think I could see us um you know when an HVAC system gets not just beyond its useful life but like our maintenance team just can't do anything else
053it has to be replaced we've we've rented boilers and we've rented chillers it's pretty expensive to the operating budget but that's how we've kept schools open um we've definitely I think gone through Great Lengths but it just feels like you know there's a breaking point where if you don't modernize those risks aren't so much risks they're just eventually going to be um our reality and what's what's scary to me is since you can't do you remember when um I think did we close Forest Heights um for a structural issue I think yeah I think you then so there's no there was nowhere for them to go so you had to shove them into already filled schools already over capacity schools you're teaching in stairwells and you know that that that is a risk too right
054because we don't have the swing space we just gotten a little operations um friendly friendly very friendly uh argument about um Forestville because we we we value Forestville in metal Burg so much because it's we we are constantly trying to swing everybody into our two available you know and ins sizable um swing space options one of the things we want to do with the next master plan is not just have this is how we're going to approve the um improve the buildings but where are we swinging so how do we build in a swing plan because that definitely slows down our modernization ability and not just the new schools James Madison really really needed that systems upgrade and that limited renovation but they needed a place to swing and so we we are trying to
055work on having a swing SP plan too hopefully it is to improve schools um and not to just house because of failure right that yeah that would be heartbreaking yeah I I appreciate the response and more depth to this discussion that that I think um as we as we talk as we begin to pull this Al together as a risk assessment um this is very helpful to head in this direction so I will now uh go to round two I will now resume chairing the meeting and I saw board chair Jackson had his hand up are you ready for round two absolutely um thank you so much um chair Bo strs so um my question was um well before I think uh I go I think uh Chief how had her hand up oh my
056apologies Chief how you're good Chief how my hand was up I see board member bricks his hand is up but not mine okay cool so I wanted to um talk about um oh yeah risk we were talking about risk um in regards to how we prioritize so it's like I don't know if this is a uh Mr Washington question like a legal question or not but just if we're just doing like a SWAT analysis um and even I don't know if Miss Walter simple have you looked at this um either from an internal audit standpoint um just about like how susceptible are we to like lawsuits and stuff like that for um you know like having our buildings um in certain positions like for example like like I know like some of our buildings like
057for example like Sasser for example has like you know it has brown water coming out of the faucet um and I think there's you know a degree of mold in the building right so you know not saying that it'll happen but you know house like it could happen where you know employees uh can potentially Sue PGCPS to get sick um I don't know do we take that into an account when we're like formulating our risk and how we move and prioritize things um I didn't really hear us talk about like hedging risk as far as like what leaves us vulnerable um to like lawsuits and things of that nature so I just wanted to I don't know who that I can pitch that question to but I'll would lay some feedback on that I'd like
058to start and then somebody um can provide some of the holes because I think you know what you're on to is something that has happened um I do want to say the pillars that we build our our master plan on are really um unassailable in the sense that these are just such generally uh accepted Master planning strategies like Prince georgees County isn't doing anything out of pocket there those are the things that you must consider um in in any system universally to come up with a prioritization order I think but I don't think the the risk from our perspective comes from the prioritization order it comes from that speed with which we're doing it or the despite all despite all the Innovation the lack of sufficient speed um because yes we have we have scholars
059in schools that we wouldn't want them to be then we have staff in schools with conditions we wouldn't want them to be in and we know that there's precedent and if you guys remember DC definitely was sued for violation of civil rights based on what they were providing for public education facilities so I just want to say I understand where you're coming from and I think it's a a really good and responsible train of thought to evaluate thank you uh Miss Walter symol did you want to come yeah I was just gonna um make a little contribution here regarding the risks and so um when we when we perform our biannual um risk assessment um these are some of the factors that um I guess we can build in until since this is you know
060a topic that has been um raised here we can Factor this aspect of it into our risk assessment I know um generally we look at the operational controls um um and more financial controls when we conduct those risk assessments but from this standpoint we can incorporate these um risks because um I guess legal risk is significant it can have significant financial impact on on the board um and Prince Georges county public schools as a whole so um I think this is one thing or one aspect that we can will take back to our I will take back to our um investigative auditor who performs our biannual risk assessment so that we can ask the relevant questions and evaluate how um or what impacts they will have and um in order for us to gather that
061information we'll have to you know ask the relevant questions of the Personnel in leaders ship positions and then hopefully we can get that the appropriate response and we can have that documented and reported back to you thank thank you so much because I mean I see you know board members responsibility you know this is what I what I Envision is like Protectors of the Enterprise as a whole you know um and I'm just thinking about opportunities or um that people um and I'm not saying like nefar seriously but I mean like people can get sick or get hurt or I know you say like from a structural standpoint we're pretty sound right but like these these little things like mold or you know Brown water or like these things can lead to you know many
062lawsuits that can even put us further behind the ball and um in certain areas and financially I think these things will all turn you know to financial you know ramifications at some point so I wanted to know is how are we like like considering those risk um while we're prioritizing but it seems like they're they're there is a from my understanding um Dr J is there seems like there is a um like a generally accepted um way of you know you develop your prioritization this um may not be included a part of it is what I'm getting but could it be because I don't know if like the legal risk are a part part of the prioritization piece I guess that's where I'm getting at so I don't know if they kind of live together
063or internal audit is saying that they can look into it to see you know how we can address the risk but I don't know if you guys are already doing that per se I would say only in the sense that all of those factors represent a risk for like those lawsuits so you know when you look at the ones that have happened around facilities and other systems it was things like severe overcrowding because that gave you a inferior educational experience um buildings that were in the condition issues that would make you have a low facility condition index that's those are the stuff where you'll see mold and inadequate air quality and inadequate daylighting and a sick building and that's that same thing you're saying like yeah that is a risk so um some of that
064I think really truly is already um baked in and we can certainly like explode each of those areas and look at what that exactly means but yeah we don't we don't call it that um we we just focus on the risk of education but is it I don't think it's wildly different thank you so I think Jonathan yeah thank you um uh Vice chair of the board B thank you so much acting chair boo Str I'm just gonna keep saying it because you know why not um so my question is for Miss Taylor Jackson and I did want to go backwards um at some point just back to the initial question so I can get clarity but um the question was for for that second piece in this is around um the post construction phase
065and so just wrote down are there costs that build up in the post construction phase that could be more efficient in the updated educational facility master plan I know you talked about like sometimes that can take the longest where you're trying to get all these kind of final pieces at the end after the construction is over um obviously it wouldn't be the longest the construction will be the longest but I I imagine that there might be costs that are associated with that is that tracked and if so could we have something in there around efficiency to cut cost as we're now having all these discussions about limited dollars um in the potential future trying to come up with an example of us incurring cost in the post construction phase and I haven't been to do
066it I will say like with projects like font Heights High School which is still in its post construction phase um there there is a like a litigation type risk and liabilities when there are multiple faults involved between a designer and a contractor and as a school system it can be very it can be very hard because sometimes we take a stance okay we don't want to settle because we don't want to make a precedent that PGCPS settles but then it does kind of it drags out right and now we're not um paying the contractor we're not necessarily seeking um because we feel like maybe there's shared fault um and and it could be a whole media litigation exercise so there when things go wrong I think that's a different type of risk that we could
067discuss when it comes to with when legal action occurs on our standard projects um no because what I was talking about with the commissioning and stuff that's built into the process so everyone is expecting it to take um that amount of time it's just when there's defects and the contractors like I built it according to the engineer specification and then the engineer is like I don't think you did but you know there's this this this argument and it's in a gray area um there's some liability to our system so you could see if you went back on our projects for the last 10 years you could see that we've constantly refined our contracts to try to protect the system increasingly um and more and more and there's always I feel like there's always you know
068we talked about Lessons Learned From how did the school like the building but one of the lessons learned from our project management team is where did you feel like you didn't have enough teeth in your contract to fight for the system and its interests so that's one of the ones that's constantly ongoing that I know our project management team would be delighted to talk more about and then I think I just want to make this comment and I'm not sure if Dr Coleman wants to share anything but I just wanted to make this comment because I hear this from my colleagues and I feel like this is also what I hear from the community side of it which is I feel like there's this perception that like once the educational facility master plan is like
069you know ratified and obviously there are updates that can happen throughout but like it's locked in it's like the train is moving it's left the station like you know we've taken into consideration all these different things nothing's changing it's static and so wherever your school was in that lineup is probably where it's going to be unless there's really some like significant you know reason as to why you changed the that and I just wonder if like that's a piece a component that's I know you talked about during our um board meeting a while ago like some of those things are going to be shifting because it was about overutilization in the classroom space and so now we're talking about deferred maintenance but I was just curious about that new that that perspect their perception that
070exists around the efmp and if that's going to be included in the the new version of it absolutely so that that perspective is spot on like it's not just a perception that's yeah that's the definition of educational facilities master plan you go through these hard studies and these hard choices and you tell the community these are our priorities and you kind of fight it out as a system and then you dig in your heels and you stick to it and the part where you said you know unless there's something that that is um something we can really point to tangible to move those priorities I think that's responsible that's how it should be but we should do that right we should update we should say like Whitmore right we had the structural issue it got
071elevated into cycle one that's responsible too because those plans are made at such a high level that sometimes as you're marching out even through 10 years some things do need to be considered differently maybe you were called for an addition but population shifts and Trends and you no longer need that addition should we still build the addition of course not we should still think and we should still be strategic um what we're doing now is not kind of trashing the old master plan we're just updating it we're looking at you know it it was done 10 years ago now so there are some places especially around cycle two and cycle three where we should look at um and mind you cycle two and cycle three weren't prioritized so they're just a big data dump for
072cycle two I'm I'm sorry it's late there you might see kids soon um but cycle two and cycle three um weren't prioritized and I think cycle 2 is like 37 schools so like even that by itself it needs to be subject to a rigid prioritization process now and some of those cycle 3 schools just have a TBD on them they weren't even really nobody was saying they could make it to cycle 3 they were saying they need to be Consolidated into a new building so we really want to look at that and I think once we do if we do a really really good job together between us and the Board of Education and the community and we all have some buy and even if we're not 100% satisfied and we wished a couple more
073of our schools were there but if we feel like it's fair and Equitable yeah I hope we dig in our heels and we just March down that list because that is part of how money comes when people see that Prince geores County isn't Whimsical but dedicated in marching down a really firmly established in data and equity and and need um priority list so I I do hope we achieve that again yeah that's very well said U director Jackson because otherwise board member Briggs we run the risk of it not being about the data but instead being about who which Community is the loudest right and so part of the success that we've been able to achieve through cycle one has been staying focused on those same priorities in order to stay on track to meet
074the goals that we've set to meet oh and I hope I'm not out of order I just want to add that once you start changing your priorities and you submit it to the state the state decides Prince George's County doesn't know what they want and that money now goes to Cal or it goes to Queen an and we we just really don't want that yeah okay I just want to say yes thank you so much um Miss Taylor Jackson and Dr Coleman for the explanation because that makes that makes complete sense right that's how again to your point like that's what we should do and I feel like your office is always walking the tight rope of having to like you know navigate the political Nuance of like what the community's perception and then what
075we have to do right the the the work the task that we were that you were given to do some mandated by law but um I just know that that's a piece that like a lot of times is you know the narratives matter right because we have if just blast of the past last year we had all of these elected officials battling over $10 million more for this program in the South because the South County doesn't get funding and then that that that presents a public perception of like well is construction not going to get done like why are we doing this and it's like why are things so static did you all get it wrong and so those are the parts where it's like when we're boots on the ground we got to explain
076like well they really took that into consideration back in 2014 that was 10 years ago right like none of that to them is so it's like I just think with the educational Phil master man like that's still a Nuance that exists right where even if we are Marching forward and it's probably probability wise like very effective plan it's going to be successful there's that human aspect of it so I just wanted to throw that in there whatever way that can be kind of mitigated yeah and you're right and because part of that that that tension that we start to feel becomes because of the pace that's what uh director Jackson was talking about right so we can be on the right track but if we're not getting to my community for another 15 years then
077that becomes problematic and I need you to look at your priorities again so part of that's part of why the ACF is so important is that coupled with our major Renovations coupled with our traditional Capital programs plan is accelerating our ability to modernize our facilities on three different tracks Mr Briggs could you share the meeting now so sorry uh board M thanks um so I I want to thank my colleagues for looking at legal risk and I think the you know it's not just our Board of Education that would be I think at this legal risk it would be I mean the the state would have to seriously consider what you know where we're head like that this is becoming so untenable um and I Look to You Know The Bradford case out of Baltimore
078um which came to an what I find is an unacceptable and by the appell court but Bradford went after the funding of equitable inequitable funding of you know the city schools city of Baltimore schools and it's credited with bringing about the blueprint for Maryland's future legislation as a as as a response by the legislature because this lawsuit is pretty significant and this lawsuit is suggesting that school construction is a state that that the you know the state is by law to fund public education in Maryland so it's not just our legal risk um and I think you know we could also be saying we may we may be the the legal risks to the state as we face as a board this untenable situation where we may have our employees and families attempt to use
079the courts on us so I I think this this is that all in it together moment that our all elected bodies in County Council should recognize that this is not under continuing to underfund school construction is their legal risk is as well um so I think you know we we definitely have to raise raise this issue um the one question I do have is around the move toward sustainability and resiliency in our construction program and if we W if we are able to measure the risk of say um the new Ellen AOA middle school as a as a building built within some of these the Frameworks of resiliency that that building could withstand a severe weather event more than say Nicholas orm Middle School a much older school like are we able to me are
080we able to positively measure the risk from that Vantage Point as well or is that for future discussion is that for me I don't know that is I'm looking at anyone who might be who has the I mean if this is for future discussion I'm fine with that too we are talking about it though I definitely will say um with that group and maybe that's what Jason came off to do it's one of the things we're talking about is where are we putting those um Investments and that's why I feel like those those are specifically interrelated um our director of sustainability uh always talks about how sustainability is always meant to have been Equitable and so she's very interested in where we can invest to um address that very thing but that's fascinating Jason were
081you gonna say yeah that's I was gonna say it's too early um Ju Just from from a standpoint uh of as uh director Jackson has said is going through a full uh year Seasons uh one and then uh and and how uh the building uh adapts to you know to live conditions versus uh plan conditions uh but that's not stopping us from uh implementing these design choices as we go forward so so we this is the framework that we will utilize uh going forward and um that's and we will continue to refine it as we as we move forward great thank you that's that's my final question it it looks like we have an appetite for a third round if there are no objections to a third round we'll move forward see no objections um
082chair of the board Jackson thank you uh this this will be my last question for tonight um so my question comes to our Community Partnerships um in general and I had asked this question back in October and I just wanted to you know follow up on this um is there any um any like organized effort to get the private sector or even the public sector companies that are located in our footprint um or even have uh employees in our footprint whether it be um in local you know neighboring jurisdictions to help with um some of the shortcomings from fight Financial standpoint or like you know helping with different parts of buildings that may need help or you know structural issues or you know anything they can do like from a financial contribution like do we
083are we like targeting companies to help us with these efforts because it seems like we have a bit of a shortfall and so I just wanted to know is there any effort organized effort around that I would say the the only effort like that I've seen is a push to for them to uh get business with us which is you know very very much um paid work not not um volunteer work I do know some I've seen Community Partnerships but they seem to be limited to maybe like a playground replacement um I definitely haven't seen like um anyone come in and and help us like heat or cool our buildings um Dr Coleman Jason have you seen something different there I haven't but what I would say is that you know we are um trying
084to augment the available funding through Grant dollars uh and we have been very very strategic uh about looking at any potential grant opportunities to help support uh the Gap uh that we know we have in our deferred maintenance our Renovations of our [Music] schools yeah thanks thanks for that Dr Coman it's just it's just to me is puzzling like how like for example like the Redskins well the the commander are you know a few hundred feet away from goson and coold rice um and who can use you know significant upgrades um in different spaces of the building and I'm I'm just thinking like how how we aren't leveraging those relationships I know all I know and even speaking with the administration on staff is like and I'm and I'm not even going to call out
085any I didn't even mean to say the res call out any business particularly but it's just like how we're so invested into these different um groups private or public sector and they're not pouring or paying that Corporate social responsibility um and I just don't know if if it's something that we just don't know they could be doing it behind the scenes or um they're not just doing it at all and so I think when it comes to a community um there there's give and take and you know there's you know Partnerships um that should be forged and I'm just trying to figure out how we can leverage it rather through Grand opportunities or you know um philanthropic efforts or you know even volunteerism like just figure out how to bridge that Gap so that's that's
086just the reason why I asked that question some reason you saying um the commanders triggered something but I will say they they have committed they do have grant funding and they are only specifically interested in stadiums um and the tur fields and they have um spend I don't have a dollar amount but they have invested in different turf fields over the last last decade or so um but it has been very you know specific to that I would say okay Mr Washington yeah I was gonna say a couple of comments on that one um at at one time the the SL commanders they provided um uh at the uh the school systems assistance washing machines for students that do not have washing machines at home and so there were washing machines installed at at Walker
087Mill and at Kenmore uh and so uh very discreet ask uh but a lot of times these corporate Partnerships are tied to their specific request they'll come to us and say we're willing to fund this or because it's in our mission or in our objective so with the commanders it would be Fields it would be you know it and and so that's that's the only thing I would I would point out is that a lot of it is tied to their specific objectives of how they want to uh invest in the community not to say that we we should not and I I believe that uh the the Education Foundation uh for Prince George's County I think uh diaa does a great job of of of shaking trees to see um not just money but
088but in terms of uh in kind uh opportunities and donations as well um but you know definitely more can be done but I I think that's what you know we we have to plug into is is that a lot of this is tied to discreet um foundational or philanthropic um like organizational objectives that they have uh but I do know uh specifically because we we had that issue with the washing machines for instance uh at those schools when we built the P3 that that's what I was told at the time is that uh a direct request was made and they provided uh uh a multiple number of washing machines for for those families that did not have access to them at school or or in their in their homes brother thank you does that conclude
089your round okay um so uh Mr Briggs you'll have the last question it looks like okay great um I just wanted to go back to the initial piece and you answered it Miss Taylor Jackson Dr Jackson but I just want to just say I want to put it out there that um with the architect and the design plan and the layout and just you know it made me think about um fun fact I was actually watching this documentary about the World Trade Center and the Redevelopment of it and how they had like all of these Architects kind of bid and you know their designs and things like that and it's was a lovely idea because they wanted everyone bought into what would be the the future of like what that space looked like and I
090feel like you know as we're going into this next cycle and cycles of the um construction and also the redevelop element of the education facility master plan like it would be really nice to have that as a consideration too is like who are the right Architects and is there some way to get you know just Educators perspectives on like whatever those General layouts are it sounds like you were saying there are different plans that they have floor layouts or things like that that you can pick from um and just something that like I think gets more not to say that there's not buy in but that if there is some way to be more effective with what the floor pans look like and who the architect is I I would love that to be a
091consideration I will say I think that is what the P3 did right you guys had the bid process include Concepts we we have had a hard time doing that from the traditional program I will note because we weren't offering quite the lucrative potential package so some of our smaller especially our our minority businesses and County based businesses were like look we can only put so much design time on a solicitation that's not guaranteed but we want to do something at a very at a smaller skill like just Concepts even with just Crosslands addition right cuz we want to encourage somebody who's really really um excited about the project and is going to do something unique um so we are trying to figure out um how to do that and I hear what you're saying because
092even though sometimes our educators are in the room I think they definitely get the Ed specs because it's you know what do you need to operate this nurse is suite and it's well I need this many beds and I need this equipment and I need the door to be this wide to fit this type of wheelchair like I think that part communicates well but I will say sometimes um having them look at a flat floor plan like for schematic design I think they can see that and still be surprised by the building that is built from that so you know um we don't quite have the ability to use some of the Private Industry ways like we can't do the virtual reality where you can walk through cuz that that actually costs more in your
093design fees you know and it's great for law firms but it's hard for school systems but there are some ways we can try to improve so they understand what they're looking at so they're not prize on opening day when they've truly been involved um in every step of the process and the other piece I would just add to that is I'm also excited that director Jackson is excited about the end user surveys because we've opened a number of buildings now and so we have users who are in these schools using them and they can give us realtime feedback around what worked well where are the pain points and we're applying that learning to this next tranch of schools that's going to be coming online great thank you Dr Coleman um so I uh just want
094to thank the entire team for the presentation and for the the Q&A um the uh next agenda item is 4.0 followup and Next Step so any any follow-up questions specific to this meeting that were captured or can be added by board members to um our um system of communicating with Administration uh please please do so and we will align those uh to be to come back um 5.0 um closing remarks from the committee Vice chair and adjournment so again thank you to everyone for a great meeting uh the question is to adjourn the December 9th 2024 board audit committee without objection there being no objections the December 9th 2024 board audit committee meeting has been adjourned have a great evening everyone good night