CorpusRecord 199399

Bangor School Committee Meeting, December 11, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / BangorMaineSchools
Date
2024-12-12
Location
Penobscot County, ME
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,032 words · about 45 min
Collected
2026-06-28

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001welcome everyone to the regular meeting of the Bangor school committee today is Wednesday December 11 everyone to please stand for the FL United States of America the and do we have any adjustments to the agenda superintendent robon yes we do have um an adjustment in the superintendent update and one item in EC this is an additional it but not a change to the agenda okay and um could I get a motion to accept the adjustment Mo second all in favor El and uh public comment members of the public May address the school committee for up to three minutes on school and education matters public comment shall be directed to the school committee and be brief and non repetitive the school committee's practice is not to respond or debate to speakers uh during the public comment

002period we are here to listen the superintendent or her staff will follow up on comments outside of the meeting as appropriate the committee will not permit profanity or shouting and request that the speakers be civil discussion of specific Personnel or student matters and complaints concerning specific employees or students will not be allowed but will be addressed through established policies and procedures before speaking we encourage speakers to review uh school policy AC which provides that the committee does not and will not discriminate nor tolerate discrimination against students or employees on the basis of membership in a protected class speakers who share these comments uh contrary to this policy will not be allowed to continue before starting please state your name and place of residence and do we have any public comment tonight no okay moving on

003we have ended proposals and updates first do we have any action items this evening no we do not moving on uh to informational items first item is superintendent update okay I will uh provide you with my update for this evening um starting with uh communication uh within the schools um we had very successful parent conferences the week before Thanksgiving um I was interviewed by uh Lindell Smiley regarding snow days um so that was fun and uh what we talked about as a staff is U maintaining the traditional snow days um and then um monitoring that if it becomes excessive rethinking potentially but um that's the consensus uh and there's some additional information uh about administrators central office staff custodial maintenance technology all of those staff do come to the buildings um on snow days unless

004um city hall is closed and then we do not parents continue to appreciate the newsletters that are coming out from all of the schools and the communic is at the printer um and if you were able to click the link we do have um the digital copy available um I think it looks great hopefully you'll um find that it's a a wealth of information um and a great way to highlight uh many of the things the wonderful things happening in the Bangalore school department um in terms of safety uh director Ray finny has been conducting tabletop exercises to ensure that all of the schools are able to solidify their emergency preparedness so he goes to the schools they work through um scenarios with the crisis response teams to ensure that they are well-versed and and

005confident in the event of an emergency in terms of curriculum uh Dr Harris Smedberg is beginning work with department heads at the high school to take a look at our K12 uh curricular alignment so more information will be uh forthcoming in that area in terms of Community Partnerships uh we have several but one I'd like to highlight is um Dr Butler is meeting with staff at husten University to strengthen that partnership as well as um several staff members and principal moing um in terms of uh recruitment but additional to that looking at updating the Business Academy curriculum um in partnership with husten and there's been many many events um but I'll just highlight a couple uh this week yesterday was a lovely High School winter concert um that was um wonderful I was able to

006participate and and see all the kids um the orchestra the band and the and the chorus and tomorrow night at the high school here we'll have the middle school concert in terms of the district the budget timeline uh we have the plan in place U right now to conduct that uh process uh we are looking at um December sending the later later this month or or within this week probably at um getting that budget template out and starting to populate the budget so uh that'll be coming up uh the survey for staff will close on 15th and Dr Harris Smedberg and I will be conducting an analysis of that data and that will be reported out uh when that's complete and I will be meeting with uh the student Advisory Group again next week on

007December 19th at 7:30 in the morning and continue that conversation in terms of of the region and State uh the UTC um Regional uh group is working on uh the crosswalk and we're coming together to discuss uh the core content credit being awarded to UTC students um in the past um there were questions around the core content and this is also in line with the recent uh legislation that requires us to ensure that students are getting the the core content credit for that so there'll be further information once that whole um process has been solidified but that's happening at this point any questions so up next we've got a approv for presentation thank you hello my name is Ryan Parker I'm here with with food core which is a national nonprofit and I'd just like

008to talk to you a little bit about what we do who we are and uh why I'm here today so essentially I've reached out to the superintendent when I found out that she had was here uh because we worked with her previously in a different district and we're really successful and uh essentially I just want to give you a very high level overview of what Food Corp is and what we're hoping to help accomplish in the district so as I mentioned we're a nonprofit we're part of the americor service network which means we essentially are allowed to place service members directly into communities throughout the country we serve in seven or an increasing I think 22 now states around the country Maine was one of our original states where we had Partnerships back in 2011

009and our entire reason for being essentially is to connect kids to nourishing food and connect them to experiential learning that's based around that food so that's anything from being outside uh getting their hands dirty and school garden to conducting cooking classes and cooking lessons with kids uh we do a lot of work in school cafeterias as well to help improve menu so I've been meeting with uh the superintendent with your school nutrition director some of your principles as well around different things that they want to see in the cafeteria that would help kids uh more kids participate in your meal programs and then the last thing that we always try to focus on is bringing community members into this programming and the reason for that is foodcore as I mentioned is a nonprofit we're part

010of the Americare service network which basically means we're not meant to be in any place forever uh we come in when we're invited we build up infrastructure we help use uh build up the culture of use of that infrastructure so School Gardens green houses whatever your District or schools would like uh in that vein and then we leave and we don't want to have all of that build up over a number of years and then drop off a cliff when we're no longer putting a service member in your district and so what we're always looking to is our exit strategy before we we ever put a service member through the front door and I've spoken with the superintendent at length about this and this is what we were able to do in Kaden and we've

011been successful all around the state I'll just give you we have three different graduation Pathways we call them which is essentially that exit strategy graduation pathway number one is your existing staff kind of invibes the culture every teacher is taking their kiddos out to the school garden uh all of the meals in the school nutrition program are fresh and scratch cooked and from local farms uh graduation pathway 2 we essentially take the work that Food Corp has been doing with that added capacity of service members and shift it to a local nonprofit some place in in the Bangor area and they continue that work while we go somewhere else and option number three is your District creates a position or positions in the budget to carry on the work I am always very candid that

012the first two don't work here um so apologies if you were looking forward to that I'm not saying it can't I'm just saying it never has in the state of Maine uh the only part of the reason for that I think is if we could get your existing staff to do all of that they would already because everybody understands the value of experiential learning but I think we're already asking too much of everybody in schools uh so asking them to do one more thing especially something as big as managing a garden building raised beds those sorts of things is usually a non-starter and the second one is outside of Portland and Leon we really don't have a lot of non-profits in Maine that can provide that people power capacity that you'll get with food Gore

013and so my experience has always been that it's much the only way to sustain this programming is to have a hub of the wheels somebody who can do all of the coordination not only in terms of infrastructure maintenance but also in terms of connecting it to the curriculum so that's one other thing I want to mention is that we are based around food and I mentioned school garden lessons cooking lessons and things like that but what we really try to do is get our service members to connect what they're doing to what your teachers are already teaching so your existing learning standards so as an example in the fourth grade in the state of Maine kids learn to calculate area and volume we all know there are some kids who you can stand at a

014chalkboard you can hand out worksheets until you're blw in the face and their brains just don't work that way but if you get them outside and you show them a square foot uh grid on a race bed they'll instantly understand what you've been trying to teach them for the last month so that everybody's mind works differently everybody learns differently and we try to take advantage of that with these Hands-On lessons so that's really what we're trying to do and uh I think the superintendent and I are in agreement that we would really like to see Bangor participate in this program we've already kind of identified a couple schools in the district and uh I just you know wanted to let you all know what's happening and also really just be upfront that we are here

015for the long term this is our core members only serve for a maximum of two years but often you'll have multiple years where different Bo members will rotate in and out but um we really aren not going to be here forever so I just want to be very upfront about that that at some point in the future the superintendent and I will probably be back here uh having the same conversation on the other end saying you guys have done all this amazing stuff all the new infrastructure is built up a lot of schools are really excited about using it it's become a regular part of your curriculum it's time for us to move on and there will probably be a position proposal in the budget at some point several years from now so any questions

016about anything to this I'm sorry number thank you uh no question specifically other than to just applaud the initiative I am glad that we're talking about this I think that we are as a society especially our kids chronically uh over sugared under nourished chronically sleep deprived and then kids are irritable or struggling in the classroom and we wonder what's going on so we are responsible for feeding these kids twice a day certainly lunch but also breakfast for many of them uh so we have a responsibility ourselves to make sure that we're providing nourishing meals and I think we do pretty well as a school district now I'm not critiquing but I think to partner here and to expand our understanding of this uh will not only be good for physical and mental health but actually

017improve academic results which I think is what we're here for more specifically so it is all tied together and I'm very happy to support moving moving along with it initiative here thank you thank you thank you I also want to Echo member spr thank you for this presentation Ryan um excuse me I have a few questions um you want me to say them all at once and then totally up to you I'm likely to forget near the end um talking about the infrastructure I again I appreciate um this opportunity because I think that all of us are in agreement that this is something that our students would greatly benefit from and any different pathway that students can take to learn is um such a a gift that we would be so honored to give to

018the students um but from a logistical standpoint the infrastructure that food core offers you say Max two years is that something that food core funds building that infrastructure is it they fund the person to come in create that infrastructure sort of build up the then the funding piece has to be figured out by the district can you talk about that pathway a little bit yep that's a great question so essentially it costs food for well it's different across the country but in Maine it cost us about $67,000 to put a food Corps member in a district and we raise the majority of that money and so that goes to their living stien it goes to all their trainings goes to my salary just the overhead of running a National Organization uh but we ask the

019districts to pay what we call a partnership fee which is $5,000 a year and then there's a per service member fee that helps um goes towards their their living stien and that's $155,000 per member so um the discussion that we've been having uh with the superintendent is that would look we're looking at two uh core members to be in this District uh starting next year they and it's a 11-month term and they have to get to 1,700 hours to be fully eligible for all of their americore benefits so that essentially is 1,700 hours over 11 months they start in August and end in sometime in July and so place them in the district we do a lot of training with them both up front at the beginning of the year but then ongoing throughout and

020then they will also partake in training that you all offer as a district so your professional development hours and things like that we ask that they be permitted to sit in on that because a lot of what they get out of this is professional development and as an organization we're trying to essentially create a a generation of people that goes into education that goes into school food with the ethos that we have as an organization and kind of change the Paradigm uh slowly so that's our investment and then in terms of the physical infrastructure of raise beds soil for them Building green houses that's something that the District covers however americore rules allow our members to spend up to 10% of their service hours so that's 170 hours fundraising and the only limitation on that

021is that they can't fund raise from any federal agencies so as an example if the district wanted to go for a USDA Farmers School Grant the service member is not allowed to be involved in that until you got it and then they could be involved in carrying out the project itself uh but other than that our service members especially in Maine do a lot of fundraising that's writing grants from main agriculture in the classroom to going to the local hardware store and asking for in kind Lumber to build raise beds uh we have great relationships with Johnny seeds and fedco and they provide a lot they love the programs that happen in schools so they provide lot of seeds and little TRS for little hands and things like that so that infrastructure does come from

022the district but again we do a lot of fundraising uh through the core members in conjunction with their site supervisors on the ground which will be I think the principles at the two schools and so that's all done in coordination and then the last thing I'll say about the uh once food for is ready to leave and you all are ready to create whatever the next state step is um my vision for that in all the the positions that we've helped create around the state and there are a number including in the Ken region um the what the board usually approves is the salary and benefits for that person and then part of that person's job description is to go raise the money to run the programming and that can actually be I would love

023it if dist districts also put in $10,000 but I also was on a school board and I know how hard that is so it's actually pretty beneficial to have that be part of the job description because you can usually end up working that into your programming and the kids learn business skills marketing a great example is Troy Howard Middle School in Belfast they actually run a successful seed saving business where they grow the plants they harvest the seeds they do a lot of counting measuring um to market the seeds the kids design the artwork for all the seed packets and then they're actually sold all over the country and that money then goes back into the program and as an example they just bought a new green house um with the money that they earn

024from that and selling produce at the co-op and things like that so that's kind of how that works and actually I just want to show you a couple things here sure so these are kinds of things that you'll see your kiddos doing uh in food cor schools so this is actually in the Katan Elementary School where the superintendent used to be located is this uh this is a service member Gabrielle um who was actually trying a new recipe with these kiddos so we're really big on our motto is try new things so we never Force kids to try anything but uh we take advantage of the positive side of peer pressure and usually by the end of the term they're uh they're all happy to try stuff and then um this is down in Portland

025so this is an example where in Portland even though it's a massive district and no school garden is going to produce enough potatoes to feed 5,000 kids a day what they do is ENT essentially is every year in every school garden they plant potatoes in the spring then in the fall they have a harvest day and all of those potatoes get delivered to Central Kitchen and then they're able to legitimately say some of the potatoes on the menu today you guys screw and their participation goes up on that day meaning increased revenue for their Nutrition department and then this is down in Belfast this kiddo has a really hard time with a lot of different things and um she's helping build rais beds so these are the types of things that we really go to

026uh and again rais building a raised bed there are I'd probably bore you with all the curriculum connections you can get from that building a compost bin and then actually using them so those are the types of things that we do and again those that's how we kind of connect to the curriculum thank you thanks for that what's the uh retention rate between for food for members and individuals that actually stay on with the district is there that typically happen meaning so meaning like the retention rate really depends on how fast you go you get to the point where we're ready to graduate so as an example I'll use Katana as an example we were there in Partnership for four years they had two core members each for two years and four years is actually

027a relatively quick partnership for us uh but it's also a very small district with only one Elementary School uh we were import and so when we were ready to graduate the second the final core member stepped into the role that they they created okay um in Portland we've been there since fuk started so since 2011 and um it's take it takes a long time with a district like that so I imagine Bangor would be somewhere in the middle of that okay so I thought you said two years Max it's two years per service member so americore rules basically say if I'm going to be a service member I can only serve in the same place for two years got it maximum got it so the program doesn't end the individual right sorry for that yeah

028no no thank you so much for clar like we have two years to get all of this done two schools that feels like a lot and my last question can you clarify food core is just prek through five grade five we three we f for the partnership the type of partnership we're going to do here we're Elementary School okay and we don't we kind of Define that as building so in some schools in Main Elementary School is k through eight okay and some schools it's K through four so um here we're going to be looking at a prek to three and a four to five right so we're going to be essentially running that whole gamut and then um the other thing about a district like this where there are multiple different uh neighborhoods and

029different buildings and things like that is we tend to want to enter into Partnerships where we're able to serve everybody in a district and so one of the challenging things is actually when we go when we start looking at what's the next school the school that we're leaving is usually like well what we don't want you to leave um so that in addition to coming back to you in five six seven years however long it ends up taking um there may be some discussions about how are we going to fill that gap between uh when Food Corp leaves our school and when food Corps leaves the district okay and that can be challenging but I've seen some pretty creative ways for schools to um manage that up until we get to the point where we're

030ready to leave okay thank you thank you very much MERS yeah first thank you very much for this and total agreement with what Ben and Katie said and very excited for this initiative I and this sort of piggybacks on what you were just talking about with the schools you mentioned a few times I I think that it would be two schools would be the primary sites is there a goal to to get more schools what what does that look like in terms of starting with two schools and then moving on to other schools if that's a part of what food Corps does that generally is what we do so we don't like to go into districts where there are multiple schools and only serve in if there's five we only serve in two right that

031just doesn't usually end well um so but that's also the way the majority of districts are set up in Maine obviously with RSU system which again vangor is not an RSU but a similar situation so we would really look to the long term to um kind of finish quote unquote at the two schools that we're talking about starting at and then Leap Frog to some other our service members are allowed to serve at a maximum of two buildings at a time but uh we found that that's sort of a an americore food rule I found that being in one building is more than enough and the first the first few months of service is really about building relationships getting the trust of the kiddos um learning all their names you know a lot of times

032you'll have a service member who's from the region but sometimes you get one from California or do are you know all over the country we recruit from so some of that is it takes a little while for them to kind of get their feet under them and get to know folks and then that second year they really just take off and the impact that you have is great and so what we sometimes do is instead of sort of a fold turkey clean break from one school and go to another we will sometimes take the second part of the second year and start making inroads into that other school the next School in line um maybe it'll be a two days in the new school and 3 days in the current School type of split we

033kind of work that out based on how things are going in the first school a love excitement in the in the second school and things like that what you will find I think is um once we establish this at the first two schools everybody's going to want this kind of programming um so we again we're here for the long term um and that's you know we've been pretty successful at doing it that way slowly going around a district but again the big challenge is when you leave that first School how do you keep that programming going um so we'll have to work through that as we get closer to the end of any individual school that we're serving in do you know how Portland's navigated that question well Portland actually created nine full-time positions um

034which is the most that any anybody's ever created in a country and that the problem with way they did it um not trying to say anything negative about Portland but they used Co relief money to fund those positions so they're gone um so we actually have had to kind of go back to square one there um really discourage that and I really discourage districts from using temporary Grant funds even to pay for food po um because I again I was on a school board I know how School budgets are built and what I'll say is we kind of encourage the cost of food core being a stepping stone to the cost of a full-time position so if you're if you're able approve a $335,000 expenditure for two full-time Food Corp members then you'll you know

035be able to have to raise that much less when it comes time to um Implement an in-house position yeah that makes sense thank you car um I want to hop in line and that I'm excited about this program as a former americ remember I'm familiar with Amer and I think it's a fabulous program in general and I'm glad to see that it's still I'm going strong um so I have a question this might be too granular or in the weeds um but You' referenced several times that depends on the particular school district and the needs of the school district how long um you would stay in that District in order to get to on their own um how long do you think it it would take Bangor to do that without knowing what are the

036steps that we need to complete in order to reach that and if it was just dragging on is there a moment when you're like we can't sustain this any longer I heard that you know you said Portland has been for the longest that um you've been in Main um is there a point where like guys get it together or is it just continue on until their needs are met and you feel comfortable leaving uh yeah I've only ever had one guys get it together conversation in all the years I've been doing this because it's usually an ongoing conversation so I actually sat down with the principal the superintendent uh the school nutrition director a couple days ago and we actually do have some tools that we use to lay out a road map of what

037is it we're trying to accomplish what are the specific goals that the district has that we can help with and then about once every year in the around actually we'll do around January February I actually go around and meet with everybody at all of our Partnerships and check in on okay where are we on goal a where are we on goal B do we need to roll this back because this one's taken priority those types of things and then we revisit them again in the summer every year so it's an ongoing conversation there's really no we don't have a we'll be here for five years but um we usually I part of my job is is to push uh and part of your job is to be realistic and recognize that Rome wasn't built in

038a day and this stuff is really hard and um I just really want I thought I saw yeah Mr forer here I really applaud his leadership at his school because he's very conscious of it's very easy with school Gardens to go too big too quickly and then you're going to end up with an eyesore in front of the school with what something that could be a wonderful tool could be beautification and if you if you don't have a methodical way to sustainably build things slowly that's what will happen and we really encourage that so it may you know I could give you a we'll be in every school for two years but it it won't work that way um we might be um you know I think we're going to start with fruit Street and

039Fairmount we might be at Fruit Street for two years and Fairmount for four years uh it really depends on the school I will say though that if we get to the 11year mark we'll probably be having a different conversation thank you thank you other comments thank you very much well thank you so much and thank you for your service and I know you all don't do this for the thanks but I was a school board member and I know it's a thankless job so thank you for everything you guys do for the kidos here the city thank you thanks Ren up next we have um DED 279 update director Hyman will provide uh the school committee information about the uh Ed 279 um this the EPS formula is what determines the um state and local

040funding uh for the saus and that is the essential programs and services that's the EPS [Music] formula all right there there's a one pager in your packet and um in a moment it'll be up the screen but I did in essence I was asked to take a look at the uh six page Ed 279 and start interpreting what it's saying to us so what I've done on your one pager I did a six-year analysis I looked back starting with the uh 201819 year and brought it all the way through to the 23 24 year and we can see the bottom of the SC let go the other way that's it that's all there's nothing above that well it was it's but is that yeah that's part of it keep going up um interesting well I'm

041not quite sure what happened to my Excel document was beautiful um but we'll carry on so the uh the very top of the ed9 takes a look at the um School attendance and the first thing you should know about the Ed 279 it's to look back so the um most current year is the 23 24 year and what that's actually looking at is the um October 1 attendance from 2022 and 2021 so it's a it's a look back but it gives you a a snapshot of what's happening over time so um in your packet um what the attendance is looking at is the uh prek and K then it looks at a column for first through fifth grade 6 through 8 and then 9 through 12 and if you look at the attendance of the

042bank of school department back in 201819 it was um students and it was down to 3,450 students in the year 23 24 which is a decline of 252 students so like a lot of the districts in the area in the state of Maine we are um slowly shrinking so I wanted to um let you see that and it was not really isolated to one one of those bands it was um throughout so for instance the first two fifth grades went down 86 children all the high school went down 77 children so it was spread throughout but overall was increase of 252 students the uh second thing on the first page is um a bit of good news it's the calcul rate per pupil so while our attendance is um slowly decreasing the amount of state

043of Maine is um attributing to each student is increasing so in 201819 elementary students were $7,850 and secondary was $7 532 and that's gone up so now the elementary is 8,316 and the secondary is 8793 so that's gone up over $1,200 in each of those so um that's helped offset the um the de and students and I think every school district in Maine is enjoyed that um should directory on the per pupil CA all right is that um uh higher than inflation or is that kep with inflation like the amount that it's increased over that time I did not take a percentage so I do not know that question um I could get back I simply went with a raw data and they're all dollars G can I stop you sorry sure can you explain

044why we have half numbers with some students I'm not sure I'm not sure that I can I can explain that that that happens when students may be um homeschooled but they partially enroll thank you in in various courses and then they could be a 0. five or a 025 thank you yes I have a quick question yes I'm sorry um the 8316 and the 879 the elementary secondary per pupil is that is that Universal or is that specific to Bango specific to bangal they look at each School District they look at um the makeup of every facet of school and that's what they're assigning to us is did they take a close look at special education population and growth in special ed population is that a part of the algorithm special education is on the

045um second page and I have not got there yet I look forward to having the numbers because well that's what I do thank you yeah thank you right nowor thank you Jerry please please keep F okay thank you the the third um section um of the spreadsheet in your packet talks about the number of teachers and the um state of main is once again looking at the makeup of each School District including the bber school district and they're determining exactly precisely how many teachers they think should um be teaching in a district and they actually break it down by those categories 3K Tok 1 to5 Etc and they also have a line for the actual FTE in the district and um current over the course of time as you would Suspect with a fewer children

046um those numbers have shrank as well the um what the state is saying um you should have is gone from 225 teachers down to 210 which is a decrease of 15 students 15 teachers I mean and once again that is not U weighted in um towards one of the weight age bands that's pretty much uniform across from prek right through to high school it's pretty even and the actual FTE while that is decreased as well we've gone from 240 teachers down to 2 32 teachers which decrease of about eight teachers over that same time and they give a percentage um and anytime percentage is below one um the one ideally is you're right on the mark you're doing exactly what the state thinks you should be doing but if you're below that you're um um

047heavily more heavily weighted in that area than they think you should be if you're over 1% then um um you're you're applying more teachers to an area where they think you should be so right now we're below we've gone from .94 down to a 0.9 so that's a decrease over six years the third section takes a look at Beyond teachers looks at the other um categories there's seven other categories that they list from guidance Library Health atex uh Library text cicle and Student Admin we have um slowly um decreased those as well over six years um but once again a lot of the numbers are below that mythical 1.0 um however in those areas the um we all teachers are over 200 um the um accounts in those areas are quite small as you can

048imagine so um guidance for instance the um recommended for the by the state is 11 and we're currently at 15.8 um the one we're under is the one where you always have trouble hiring which is our Tex the um the atex they should say we should be at 20 and we're at 12 and a half so we this shows you we we we try to hire them but we've had little luck over the last few years and finally um also good news the um the amount that is um the state calculates by those categories including teachers it's also gone up over time so the um this the teachers is the biggest category so I'll look at that one it's gone from um uh 11, 700,000 in the year 1819 all the way to 13, 300,000

049in the year 23 24 so overall I've given you um the increase by category but they're all positive they've all gone up um if the ratios were a little bit more or the student count was a little bit more the dollars would be a little bit more but overall it's trending in the right direction so that's kind of a very brief highle overview of what the Ed 279 page one is telling us any questions I was interested in that special education piece are they taking into account percentage of increase in special education population in the in the determinations I I'll um I'll get to that next like I said it's on the very next page it um it's quite detailed about special education they don't have that here I don't have that page no I

050I haven't done that anal that's what you're saying has done that d279 is about six pages of data nothing but data and it takes a while to um look at it all and do the six year comparison but I'll I'll focus on that next great thank you yeah all right thank you thank you next we have a special education update director Babin special education director Christy Babin will give us an update um on the state of special education in the department good evening unlike Jerry I have numbers that have gone up not down um in student population I'm going to quickly just highlight some of the things that are in the PowerPoint that you do have in your packet I just gave you the timeline of special education law I'm not going to read through

051that it's just background information for you the current law that we're um operating under are these two laws the individuals um with disabilities Education Act that was reauthorized in 2004 and those are the current special education laws that we operate in special education in the state of Maine under muser or chapter 101 that um book is on my desk and I refer to it constantly throughout the day and school year every school district school department has a child find responsibility we're currently responsible for students um kindergarten up until the age of 22 if they have a disability we're also responsible for students who are um placed in private schools and if the private schools are located in the city of Bor so we have that responsibility and that's um holding um a meeting to talk

052about concerns that parents may have teachers may have case managers may have are actually the Physicians also and due to the lack of resources in our area we have seen an increase to phys referring parents to the school department to have those evaluations done what is special education it means especially designed instruction at no cost to parents to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability means that we have to offer the services at no cost to the family it means that they can't progress or access the general education sing there are three prongs to eligibility for special education and these are things that the IEP team have to come to the table to discuss students have to have one of the 14 disabilities that are listed there um the disability has to

053be adversely affecting the students educational performance the state of Maine actually has an adverse effect form that we have to go down through at an IEP meeting to determine eligibility for special education and they must need special education when because of their disability they are unable to access the general education curriculum so tonight I wanted to update you on on the October 1 to 2024 um student count for special education as of October 1 of 2024 we have 834 special education students that are identified under IA that is 24% of our current student population that number has increased and you'll see in your other document that you have from 2016 to 2024 um a significant increase after Co with special education referrals you'll also see that um the two um biggest areas that we've seen

054in increase are disabilities under autism the autism category and also other health impairment which would in include our students who have ADHD um for comparison I only have the 2023 24 we don't have the 24 20 24 data from the state of Maine but for the state identification the state is at 19.9 so the Bangor School Department is higher than the state average Not Unusual because we are a service center give you a little bit of background knowledge on the IEP which is the individual education plan when students are referred to special education we have to go through that child crime process do evaluations come to the table determine eligibility under special education we have the responsibility to come to the table on an annual basis to discuss students needs parents concerns students strengths and

055come up with a plan to meet those needs for their education we also have the responsibility to come to the table anytime that there's a concern whether it be a teacher concern a parent concern or a case manager concern those are some of the considerations that we have to talk about at that IEP meeting it's a comprehensive meeting that takes about an hour to an hour and a half depending on the student needs one of the highlights here is assist of Technology we in the Bangor School Department because our students um with the disability category of autism has increased significantly um we also are seeing an increase in our assist of Technology we've gone from um 12 students utilizing a communication device to 53 students currently using using a communication device we have the responsibility

056to program for students in the least restrictive environment um I'm proud to say that 73% of our students are accessing their special education either in the general education setting or in a resource room setting every school in the Bangor school department has a resource room for students to access specially designed instruction we do have 22% of our student population whose needs are a little bit higher and the IEP team has determined that they need a more restrictive setting and they're receiving the majority of their instruction in a self-contained special education setting there are um classes in every building um we do um have to meet the needs across the district and some buildings have more self-contained classrooms than others and then 3% of our students are educated in a separate school to the Bango Regional

057therapeutic day treatment program which is a public day treatment program that's regionalized Spruce and then we also have access to special purpose programs in the area so still water Academy is one of those in kids peace and Oldtown is another we do have a small student population also it was 0.05 in your packet um that are educated either in a homebound setting or a hospital setting and that that changes because we have the responsibility to get them back into school sry before we move on um question about the previous slide um what what are those numbers comparing to um the rest of Maine you said like the rest of Maine has 19% and we have 22% I would interested to know what I don't have that information but I can get it thank you y

058can I ask question on this slide thanks on the the 22% and the 3% 2020 to now increase in those percentages stable decrease the one that has increased is our um students receiving instruction in a self-contained classroom because our our students with um more I want to say more severe but the needs are higher has increased over time so both of those C both of those categories the the self-contained and the separate school have increased 2020 not signic not significantly I can go back and look I did look at that but I don't have the data in front of me so I don't want to misse um I think last year it was 2% of our students were being programmed for outside but I can look at that I'd be interested and I think others

059would be particular when we get into budget season on that piece of data yeah and I think um city council too we had a meeting with them today and these are some of specific questions that they asked about so it would be nice to have that information yeah and and it is important to not 3% is a small student population right but those programs are at a significant cost the Bangor Regional therapeutic day treatment program because it's a public day treatment program um is a cost-saving for us um and that's the first we always try public day treatment before we go private um but that program is about 48,000 a year compared to approximately 100 to 150,000 for kids pce are still undering any other questions before I move on I have questions but um

060I was gonna wait until the end do do you prefer that we doesn't matter whatever work well so if we go back um to the slide with the 14 spe specific disabilities um so those are General categories I see that but do so um for example emotional disability or Orthopedic impairment that could be a variety of things right that many branches of those so who um would would it be like a a provider who would um dictate which ones like um I can't think of um you know whether it's um I can't think of anything at the like at the top of my head but um would a provider say okay this would be one of those 14 specific disabilities it's actually the IEP team's okay decision to determine what disability is impacting the most

061okay in the child's ability to access their education um some of those the specific learning disability there's a specific form that you have to complete that the state of main requires and you have to if enough answers are yes then the team has to determine if there's a specific learning disability present um the other one is effect form the state is working on an emotional disability form to talk about that she determine you know do we need to have a form to determine if a child truly has an emotional disability to qualify the other piece is user the state law chapter 101 has descriptions of what falls under each disability category that we have to follow okay so that makes sense so like a a you know a speech impediment um like a list for

062example would not NE necessarily be categorized as one of these because it doesn't adversely affect their educational performance right so that makes sense and speech also has an adverse effect form that they have to go down through and the classroom teacher has to fill a form also to determine if it's impacting them than classrooms I think makes sense and just one more question with the IEP and the elll like this was a question that came up today as well um you know the multilingual um piece um you know are they I think that was a question asked like are they part of special education and I know that that's IEP is different than I mean it's it's complicated but can you explain that please so um students who have um multilingual needs have an ilap

063plan that is developed to meet the language needs um and then there's specific criteria to to look for um for special education also they do have students who are multilingual also have access to special education um we have the responsibility to make make sure that when we do an evaluation that we have an evaluator who can speak the native language of the child um and that that is the most challenging piece right now um thank you see if I can go back um the kindergarten transition we um are one of two states in the state in the United States that offers intervention outside of the public school the public schools are going to be taking over the three and four-year-old special education needs um I think it's the fall of 2026 that we're going to

064become responsible for that I'm personally looking forward to that I'm excited for that to happen um we just got our information from child development services so this slide looks a little different tonight than what you have in your packet because I just got the information from CDs but we're anticipating to welcome 55 students who are currently identified under idea into kindergarten next year I gave you some statistics from the last few years like last year we anticipated 65 students 52 of those students enrolled um students that are um identified in receiving Services through child development services can stay under a medical model with some of the programs that they attend so some families make that decision they do lose their privilege to Fai during that time because it's a medical model um and some students

065also if their birth date is within the cut off they're they call them 676 children but they can remain in the prek preschool system for one more school year so that's where you're seeing those discrepancies where 52 students came in the important piece to note here is this does not include the students during kindergarten screening that are identified as students who need a special education referral right these are students who are coming to us already identified when they're entering kindergarten so can I just um clarify for that fall of 2026 right now a lot of families are utilizing places like CDs to identify if their child needs special services before entering Kinder Garden once the schools take over will the school districts have a responsibility for children what three years old it will be responsible

066for child PR for three year olds and services okay so three and four year olds three and four year olds okay it's right now if I'm understanding it's correctly child find starts in kindergarten okay so it'll be ired in prek and then even before prek in 2026 so that will also that's y thank you to keep in mind for doesn't look like and then the last slide I just put in our Section 504 that's under the Americans with Disabilities Act um the Office of Pupil Services also oversees the 504s for the district these are students who have um a diagnosis where um it's impacting their ability to access their education but they don't require specially designed instruction under special education to progress in the curriculum so we write a plan so that we can put

067accommodations and modifications in place to support the child in accessing their education um for the 24 the start I did an October 1 count for the start of the school year and we currently have 322 students accessing a FAL four any other questions can I I just want to say thank you I know this is a lot of data and numbers and it's very important work um and it's it's not just about us here at this table and the families that receive the services but you know the city is also very interested in how we can best support um this growth so I really appreciate ping these numbers together and so eloquently explaining some really big laws so thank you yeah thank you thank you um up next we have report of resignations I'm reporting

068the following resignations uh Steve Steven Johnson assistant boy swim at the Bangor High School thank you very much so moving on to business action items uh the first action item we have is the uh acceptance of the minutes of the regular meeting of November 20th 2024 can I get a motion to accept the minutes so Mo thank all in favor s off uh next up we have the financial reports so the June budget transfering 23 2024 can I get a motion to except some second all in favor all and now for personnel updates for extra Duty assignments I am recommending approval of the following extra Duty assignments for 2024 for 2025 Tiffany lves JB coach cheering at Bangor High School David CL assistant boy uh swim coach Bangor High School and Sarah holsapple dramatics at

069Williams Cohen School so move second all in favor 70 and next up we have um Committee Member spray will share the following donations thank you madam chair to Williams Cohen School from Beth and art treaties a cash donation to support students having a total dollar value of $250 to William Esco school from Marlene and Frank Susi a cash donation to support students during the holiday season having a total dollar value of $250 to Fairmont School from St Paul the Apostle Parish socks and sneakers to support students needs having a total dollar value of $270 to Fairmont School from Hanford help schools cash Don Don ation to support students having a total dollar value of $368 4 to Mary snow school from Hanford help schools a cash donation having a total dollar value of $374 4

070to Fruit Street School from Charleston churches for students having a total dollar value of $500 Divine Street School from Charleston Church win quotes for students having a total dollar value of $550 to Vine Street School from Haniford Community bags a cash donation to support students having a total dollar value of $379 to Vine Street School from Haner help schools programs cash donation to support students having a total dollar value $365 Vine Street School from Anonymous cash donation having a total dollar value of $250 to Abraham Lincoln school from Charleston Church winter coats for students having a total dollar value of $1,150 and to Abraham Lincoln school from Hanford help schools a cash donation to support students having a total dollar value of $414 it's a lot of generosity with thanks I'll move motion to accept

071second all in favor thank you and now for introdu uh introduction items you have the first reading of revised policies I'm recommending the um first uh reading of the revised policy revised policy GCA 31 technology director can I get a motion second all in favor s off and moving on to committee updates do we have any comments or questions from the Committee Member jandro hi um I just want to take a minute to say thank you to everybody for the flexibility that we've had during this wacky weather uh period that Dr Robinson has done a great job of making these delay calls um ensuring the safety of all the students and the staff getting everywhere staff and you know our administrators I know it's not easy for that 2our shift in the morning um but

072I think that it's a wise decision and word on the street is that people are pretty happy with having the delays rather than the full snow days um I also just wanted to say again because it's our last uh meeting before the holiday season happy holidays to everybody in the room um and anybody watching online I suppe as well it's been a great year and I'm looking forward to everything that's coming up um committee appointments we have appointments Representatives reports we have drop we have UTC sorry I'm sorry do we have drop you guys W right so we had a meeting UTC had a meeting on December 5th at 6 p.m. some updates on December 2nd uh Life Flight of Maine visited UTC to conduct a ground safety course for EMS and law students the

073Highlight was a helicopter landing in the parking lot followed by Hands-On training on November 21st pre-engineering students toured somic America Inc gaining valuable industry insights technicians provided students with an extensive Showcase of the in-house Machining and assembly processes within the brewer main manufacturing plant uh in business leadership five students from the business leadership program launched a clothing company called main minimal their first limited time product drop open for just 48 Hours exceeded sales expectations uh as a made to order business customers are now picking up their products you can follow them on Facebook and Instagram at Main minimal company or visit their website www main minimal. one other update uh students in grades 3 through five from Bey Community School recently had an exciting opportunity to explore various programs at UTC so UTC is inviting

074schools uh in at even younger and younger ages they interacted with UTC students who shared insights about their learning experiences additionally the younger students enjoyed trying out tools and supplies sparking their curiosity and interest in future CTE PS remember Bri and I were just talking before the meeting and wondering if maybe Bangor might want to do this at own Point as well I think that um it's definitely worth having a conversation I think the engaging nature of the Hands-On experiences um is wonderful we need to make sure that it's available to all students I wasn't I actually wasn't aware of that this is new news to me they brought schools and we did bring our middle schools in to tour um but I wasn't aware that they were bringing in elementary I think they're just

075starting to do that dipping their toe into doing this that's the report thank you thank you um I did get in on that first drop and the sweatshirts are they are very cool I um do not look cool in it but they are it's not the sweatshirt's fault yes they are follow them yes they created the whole business line their website their marketing it's very impressive got me I mean cly bought a sweatshirt really it was very impressive how quickly they got me so great job you to say um do we have any other committee updates right now otherwise we'll move on to student committee updates okay so we just have a couple things tonight I wanted to start off by giving a little reminder to my fellow seniors to meet with your guidance counselors

076for help with future plans and having access to a wide variety of scholarships which is really cool and then another fun little opportunity for parents in the area a kids night out this Friday at the Fruit Street School it's an opportunity for all parents prek through third grade who want to take the night off have a little fun um activities at this event include games in the gym and arts and crafts it's just $15 per student it'll take place from 5: to 7 and all proceeds go to the BHS class of 20127 and then one more little thing uh the Bor schools are hosting a food drive from December to the 20th um help the community by donating non- perishable food items uh their drop off locations at all the Bangor schools I'm going to

077pass it to bring a couple more things we have today um Bangor Bangor hyp basketball won with a big victory over Portland in their opening game we have Phil the alond on the 27 for varsity hockey and per multiple requests from friends and my sister there is hope of a day off tomorrow my [Laughter] and both of us would like to wish happy holidays to everyone as well thank you thank you cannot pressure [Laughter] our decision um do we have any other reports all right so the next up we have are our information dates uh so the next important dates we have coming up Friday December 20th is Bangor day Wednesday January 8th 2025 regular meeting 7 p.m. Bangor High School library uh Wednesday January 22nd 2025 regular meeting 7 PM Bangor High School library

078Wednesday February 12th 25 regular meeting 7M Dan High schol library and Wednesday February 26 2025 regular meeting or High School library any other questions or from the committee I just I wanted to wish everyone happy holidays as well there are many diverse holidays that are coming up between now and when we meet again in January 88th um holidays regardless of what holiday it is that you're celebrating see you in the new year thank you in that case we will adjourn love that get e e e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.