001good evening everyone like to welcome you to the grps Board of Education meeting for February 10th um we respectfully request that you turn off cellular phones and ref refrain from clapping cheering or making audible comments um we invite you to make formal public comment during designated times on either agenda items non-agenda items or both and those comment cards are in the back of both by both entrances so if you would like to make public comment and haven't filled one of those out please go ahead and go get one of those and um we'll make sure that we get you up here um Julie our board assistant is over here and she collects those comments are limited to 3 minutes and um we always will make sure that our students get a chance to speak um
002at the beginning of of the agenda comments start with roll call all right hopefully you all can hear me um uh truste Moreno trusty Melton here trusty Rodriguez here trusty Wade present trusty Williams s trusty Williamson present trusty Davis present uh truste Kilpatrick pres and president Davis here all right we have a quorum all right can I get an approval of the agenda so moved support all in favor I any opposed okay and moving forward with c celebrations so I'm going to invite um Miss K Moore down to talk about the annual 20th anniversary of the Martin Luther King Dr Martin Luther King Jr social social justice contest winners this more can everyone hear me good evening Dr Ro president Davis theps board members thank you for the opportunity to celebrate our Scholars this evening
003of course my name is and I'm the director for the office of equity and inclusion for GR schools I'm sorry K could you use the microphone just so that they can hear it on the recording thank you so much all right can everyone hear me now is that better okay thank you so this is the 20th year that the MLK social ju social justice contest has been held in that time we've celebrated a tremendous partnership with Warner Norcross and Jud they have been our sole sponsor and we want to give them a hearty thank you for that but more importantly now to this year's winners congratulations to Isaac Chris Colin if you're in the um audience please stand Isaac I know you're in the front row [Applause] there and Isaac I do have your certificate
004and your Hamilton tickets oh okay analin pedo she here is anal here no and Caris [Applause] Davis but now let's hear from our winners [Music] over the past two decades this contest has really grown both in participation and in scope of the work in the beginning the students were asked to reflect specifically on the legacy of Martin Luther King Jr in an essay format and over the past couple of years we've expanded that to include a variety of submission formats and the students are able to reflect on a range of social justice issues that are important to them and we've really seen the way that this just really ignites the creativity of the students and allows them to bring history really close to where we are in the present the partnership between the firm and
005Grand Rapid Public Schools over the past 20 years has just been incredible the participation of the students the dedication of the staff the way that the community shows up to honor these students is just always so heartwarming and we at Warner are just so so incredibly proud to have partnered with him over the years the legacy of Dr Martin Luther King is just as relevant today as it ever was and we are so proud to have played a very small role in continuing the legacy of Martin Luther King through the incredible work of these [Music] students I created the drawing I did in that format because I like drawing and I think that I could draw something to express the way I feel and how Trayvon Martin could have felt in my piece I think
006my writing and my art my drawing symbolized that it was okay that to be angry or stuff like this does happen to people in African Americans and all people it does happen and that I D Drew my my drawing because I thought it might mean something or show people that it wasn't okay and police brutality is not a good thing it's supposed to be trayon Martin and the Skittles is covering like his eyes and I have Skittles there with like blood because he was bleeding and I have the red and the blue for like police and it says I don't have a gun cuz he didn't have a gun the person that shot him thought it was a gun but he had Skittles and how I just wanted to represent what happened to him to
007me my song means a lot I really I wanted to write my song because I wanted to show people that it doesn't matter the way because you don't get to choose how you're born and what you look like it's not like you're you're you come to life and then you're like okay I want to be this tall I want to look like this I want to have this skin color you don't really get to choose everyone's equal do we have to fight Mar Lu King fight for us to get Al Mar Lu King fight for us to get along why Luther King with J for us to get along why Luther King with so much to get along so can we just not repeat our history and stay in peace please don't repeat our history
008Martin Luther King work for equality the message I was trying to send through my song is that everyone's the same and you don't have to change yourself for other people's likings U other people can adjust to the way you are but when you change yourself you start to look down on yourself even more and then you just you just crumble the two things that inspired me to participate in this contest were my teachers and the poem The Mask by Maya Angelou um the mask is pretty much about how she felt her race had to hide their true emotions to get by a message that I was trying to convey with my poem is that people like me have a privilege and instead of abusing that privilege we should use it for the greater good and
009help the people who don't have the privilege I cannot heal their wounds alone nor tread the trail they've gone through but I can stand not dismiss the truth and I can lift the light high above my head for in this light they too belong and their fight is one I must defend so we must all walk together heads lifted high for justice must be shown I would like to thank the two teachers that most definitely taught me how to write a good poem my fourth grade teacher Mr dolphin and my teacher right now Mr Matthew Mr dolphin taught me and sparked my learning of how to use metaphors and similar Le and other vocabulary stuff Mr Matthew also taught me how to like give some meaning to it too so thanks [Applause] I just have
010to say their work is amazing and Exhibits the thoughtfulness and Brilliance of our Scholars the Grand Prize winners just want to say what they did receive um first prize was a Apple iPad and two tickets to Hamilton the first runner up got an Amazon Fire HD Plus tablet with a wireless charging dock and the two tickets to Hamilton and then the second runner up got a $100 gift card to we are lit Multicultural book shop with two tickets to Hamilton um this year we received 185 submissions in addition to the three winners and we have 46 Scholars who received honorable mention the honorable mention Scholars each win a $25 gift card to we lit Multicultural Bookshop I have slides with their names on it I just want they're Group by school but I wanted to
011share what schools did participate um we had Scholars from Aberdine Center for economicology Dickinson Grand Rapids monu Harrison Martin Luther King Leadership Academy North Park Monas rmore Park Riverside and University Preparatory Academy so these are the students who won for um honorable mention and you see the competition was pretty stiff I would like i' like to send a sincere thank you to all the scholars and teachers who participated this year their work again was amazing and a final thank you to our partners at w Norcross and judge Jud and as a final highlight I'd like to share with the board that for the second consecutive year the grandpa Public Museum will be exhibiting all of the artwork for our ml Scholars um throughout the entire month of February to celebrate Black History Month so take
012time to go down and see that as well it's a great honor for them so thank you for allowing us this time thank you so much congratulations to all of you that was [Applause] wonderful okay moving forward we have report of the student Representatives Rema thanks for being here um thank you uh just a quick thing quick couple couple quick things so this week we are having our superintendent advisory council meeting this Wednesday um I'll give you updates on that next month on what we kind of talk about and some of our topics uh NHS is also having hosting a blood drive at Union there is some appointments available that will be next week Wednesday February 19 and then this past Wednesday and Thursday February 5 and 6 Union High School decided to dedicate those
013days to waa testing and that helped finish a lot of testing and gave some students a break with a couple packets of work to catch up and continue to learn while they are not testing and afterwards the weita testers got a little reward for finishing the test and the hard work that it did but that's pretty much it thank you thank you um we have noticed that we have a lot of Scholars here from it looks like you're from the stem um and we do have a couple public comment I have two public comment from those Scholars we're going to go ahead and let them give their public comment before we move into closed session are there any others I have two up here okay so um Jay Levi Alfred and samage okay okay and
014then I have another one as well so I have three right up to that Podium yep I'm sorry good evening to you all thank you for having my Scholars take up three roles of the school board meeting today um I'm Jay Levi Alfred I'm the director of the stem scholar program at stem greenhouse and our mission is to create an environment where we have proficiency and confidence and math and stem and not just that but Leadership College exploration it's kind of just a wraparound program and we want to thank you guys for your support of the program because hopefully one day we're able to fill this entire sea of blue with stem Scholars uh students so I have two Brave young men who want to give some comments for the whole group and we'll be
015out your way cuz their bedtime is coming up so and can you just share your name before you give your comment as well uh my name is Kyler Jackson uh good evening members of the Grand Rapids Public School Board my name is Kyler and I am so grateful to be here tonight to share how the San Kofa STEM Academy and stem Scholars Program have impacted my life before joining these programs I knew I like stem but I didn't realize just how many opportunities were out there through Hands On Learning amazing mentors and exciting and exciting challenges I have gained skills and confidence that I know will help me in the future one moment that really meant a lot to me was my first time arriving in college I was in sixth grade and I was
016at GRCC everyone was welcoming and the first week of me being there I met so so many new people the experiences and opportunities helped me realize what I wanted to do when I grew up shova had a big impact on not only my academic life and also my social life I wouldn't have these opportunities without your support your generosity is helping students like me dream bigger and work harder towards our goals you are making a real difference and I hope to one day Inspire others just have you inspired me thank you for believing in us and investing in our futures I also wanted to thank the Amway foundation and Mr and Mrs DeVos we appreciate you so [Applause] much good evening members of the Grand Rapid public school board and honored guests my name is
017s Coleman and I am honored to stand here today I wanted to thank the Amway foundation and Mr and Mrs DeVos I have had the amazing opportunity to participate in the San Kofa STEM Academy and stem Scholars and these programs have truly made a difference in my life through these experiences I've learned so much not just about science technology engineering and math but also about teamwork problem solving and believing myself the hands the handson projects the nonstop encouragement from mentors and the chance to explore new ideas have helped me see a future where I can make a difference one memory that stands out to me is last year when I was in seventh grade we were introduced to a team building activity called Blind retriever this was a fun and very challenging blindfold activity that
018builds confidence communication and Trust skills one person is blindfolded while the other acts as their guide the guide verbally directs their blindfolded partner through an obstacle course of path preventing them from bumping into obstacles or other people the the Blindfolded partner must listen carefully and follow the ex instructions to be be successful uccessful not only did I learn valuable skills from this activity but my sze hurt for a few days from laughing so hard I know that none I know that none of this would be possible without your generosity and commitment to our grps Scholars like me the stem program has made me more confident in my abilities and excited about what lies ahead one more time I like to say thank you from the bottom of my heart for investing in in my future
019and in the future of so many others I hope that one day I can use what I've learned and give it back to others just like you have done for me thank you so much to share that with us and thanks for being here tonight to all of you okay trusty Rodriguez can you read us into close session all right so uh I move that the board go into close session for the purpose of a strategy strategy negotiation session connected with the negotiations of various collective bargaining groups at the request of the superintendent as permitted by the open meetings act section [Music] 81c have so move I mean support my bad support we do have to take um rooll by name y truste moo I just need to say I support yeah support trusty m
020i don't love the timing but I support the idea of going into close session yes trusty Rodriguez yes trusty Wade yes trusty Williams yes trusty Williamson yes trusty Davis yes trusty Kilpatrick yes and president Davis yes all right okay are we staying in the auditorium then are we staying here um it proba easier for us move to go downstairs okay so we will excuse ourselves and go downstairs okay we are moving forward with our agenda um next up is public comment for board agenda items only we will have three minute comment tonight and are there any other comment cards before we get going okay um Matt Marlo you can come on up followed by Jane nean that's fine yep I rad policy and Union reps get to go first so go for it take went
021down yeah my name is Matt Marlo president of gr um thank you president Davis thank you Dr Roby and distinguished board members um I've provided a packet of information um with regard to similarly situated public school districts so essentially uh Rochester Community Schools which serves about 14,000 kids are similar size also waren Consolidated um in addition to cumad zooo public schools and last one was Plymouth Canton um so they all range in about approximate 14,000 students what you'll see at the first part um basically breaks it down by Staffing so is it how many administrators they have how many teachers they have how many PA pros and AIDS and also how many non-instructional staff so it kind of gives you a framework of a comparison okay similar situated districts this is kind of their Staffing
022um I've also included at the end of the packet all of the properties owned by Grand public schools and I noticed on the website um you know it mentions that grand rids public schools has 67 buildings that equal approximately 4 million square ft um which is a lot of property cuz when I talk to other um presidents of the local unions you're talking about approximately 26 buildings in order to you know to have 14,000 kids um you know I understand there's a long history with with the district and having you know 28,000 students at one point I just over the years I mean I don't think it's anyone's fault per se but I think we do have a lot of property in the district that we could probably utilize um for future use um as
023far as I know when selling properties there's always a concern well we don't want to sell to a charter school for competition and we don't know we don't just want to sell it and have anyone do what they want to do with it you could de it out to be residential there's a possibility there so when people say well that would only be a one-time sale um yes you'd sell the building two you would take away the cost that you have to do in order to keep it warm or from being dilapitated the plus of that is you sell property you have a developer put homes on it residential and then you're having families move in and then these families are having children more children you're looking at an increase in enrollment because we were
024looking at you know our enrollment numbers are are pretty steady right now but they have trended down for many decades now so these are just some possible solutions to kind of look at um you know for the board like I said I'm excited about this new board you guys have already went in close sessions just to talking to to problem solve so that's a that's a great sign so we really appreciate that and um so if you have any questions about this it was from my school data and the other real estate information was from local um grandits website so for the city of Grand Rapids so thank you for your time appreciate it thank you Matt Jane nean followed by ises Nunes good evening Madam superintendent president Davis members of the board uh I'm
025Jan nean vice president of G um I wanted to uh shout out my colleagues at Union High School first of all uh our student rep mentioned our weeda testing last week that we piloted for the first time um we had students take over 2,000 or roughly around 2,000 weeda tests each student takes four and we were able to accomplish quite a lot in a couple of days which in ultimately uh decreases disruption in learning it decreases um it increases the consistency of students being in the classroom and not being pulled out and just allows them to have that extra um content learning time especially before our spring testing window in April with PSAT and the SAT and spring map so I want to shout out my colleagues for that um I also uh saw the
026collective bargaining uh Clos session on the agenda and wanted to reiterate once again GRE is asked to make bargaining open at least the meetings between the district and the union and allow um either it to be live streamed so that people can hear and see what is going on at bargaining and and or have uh a small audience be present there so that people wish to uh witness the process and how it goes that they could do so um it is allowable by law and if both sides agree to do that and gr is making that ask um I think that would be beneficial also um just wanted to reiterate the value the wonderful Educators we have in this District um and the value they bring to this district and obviously our first concern is
027students but if you don't value and take care of your Educators it's harder for them to value and take care of your students and it is definitely become a hardship we hear about a lot of hardship from our members with the increase in health care um the bargained raises in the last three years in the current contract have not kept up with inflation or the increased in healthcare and we have a lot of Educators looking elsewhere for jobs and we know that we had over 200 vacancies last year so I just want to reiterate that while the district may say that can't afford more than a 1.5 increase I would like to remind this board that 16.5 million was transferred into Capital funds in the last two years and that we will not see a
028huge decrease in Foundation allowance and while the federal stimulus is gone um Ronda cribs our financial officer is doing a great job budgeting so that so much so that we've had a $40 million surplus in the fund balance so I just want to put it out there uh if we want to stop the churn we need to show that we value our Educators financially and them cover costs thank you thank you you smes I wish I was that tall uh good evening y'all um my name is isalis Nunes uh and I sent you all this letter earlier and I feel that I it's my responsibility to also address address Us in the public um and I am a concerned Community member um and someone who personally signed the Action Network letter advocating for grps to
029become a sanctuary school district and I'm deeply disappointed that at some point a decision was made based on certain behaviors to suppress these voices rather than engage in meaningful dialogue as leaders in the governing body of this District the public entrust you to listen to the concerns just as you expect your Educators to listen and do for their Scholars yet you set the standard of how grps operates and what I witness at the recent working board meeting was dismissive behavior when it came to this critical issue that was raised especially as it relates to our undocumented families and students becoming a sanctuary District means implementing a policy that ensures that Protocols are followed and that the board can measure its impact and hold the superintendent accountable you all have repeatedly emphasize the board's role in
030setting the what while the superintendent determines the how why this process is being handled any differently I don't understand I have seen districts avoid adopting a formal policy because they believe all their educators will want what's best for their students unfortunately that has not always been the case recently in Fort Worth Texas a substitute teacher went on social media to alert ice about undocumented students in his school I want to believe that all educators are committed to the well-being of their Scholars families and communities but experience has shown that we cannot always assume that this is true I all sent you an article if you did not were not aware of that situation in Fort Worth Texas and so my question is if a situation like this were to occur in grps how would the
031district handle it what policy assures me that our Scholars their families and our educators are truly protected without a clear measurable policy there are no guarantees a commitment is not a guarantee the community deserves transparency accountability and a commitment to ensuring safety for all students you committed to listening to your constituents but that did not happen will there be accountability or a conversation about why this happened and and why this decision was made I want to trust you I really do but that is difficult when commitments are made and then broken I urge you to reconsider consider how you engage with this process honor the voices that have spoken up and clarify how grps plans to protect its Scholars families and Educators thank you thank you Erica ham followed by jinda Swanson good evening Dr
032Roby and Board of Education um my name is Erica ham and I am the G representative for your Grand Rapids Public Schools nurse group my nurses have asked that I come to you today um to speak with you and take a moment to acquaint you with grps school nursing the nurses along with our health services leadership like to say that we are a well-oiled machine the staff RN comprise a group of 19 experienced nurses who come from diverse nursing backgrounds such as the niku the neonatal Intensive Care Unit the piku the Pediatric Intensive Care Unit pediatric emergency home health and hospice and Rehabilitation as professional nurses we are members of the Michigan Association of School nurses and the National Association of School nurses we oversee the health offices of all grps school buildings each of
033us assigned to between one and three depending on scholar Acuity such as tube feeds and medical complex Medical Care your registered nurses organize the school's Medical Emergency Response teams which are your mert teenss we train staff in the use of aeds and stock up an nephrine for Anil axis allergies grps is unique in that each School building is also stocked with emergency Naran for opiate o o overdoses and Albuterol for Asma attacks not every district has this the next time you are in a school building I encourage you to step into the health office meet your RN and ask about the A and the yellow emergency medication boxes we manage acute conditions such as asthma attacks injuries fractures rashes and illness we monitor assess and care for Scholars with chronic conditions such as diabetes asthma
034and cystic fibrosis and we do all of this through the lens of Health Equity with awareness of implicit bias which exists in healthcare grps nurses also provide staff education across the district including CPR training sudden Cardiac Arrest uh response training for school staff and stop the bleed tourniquet training for Scholars our health education includes HIV and puberty classes and vaping education as the top medical personnel in our buildings we work to monitor the health and safety we work to monitor the health and safety of all Scholars staff and visitors just this month one of our nurses noted subtle changes in a young child's breathing and directed that they go to the emergency department where this student was subsequently admitted into the hospital with RSV we are trained and ready for emergencies and we care deeply
035about the health and safety of our student population to support their academic success and we often do this with less compensation than other local nursing professions I appreciate your time and listening to the value that your school nurses bring to grps and I'm always available for consults and questions thank you thank you Erica jinda Swanson followed by Bo Torres good evening my name is jenda Swanson I'm a uh resident of Grand Rapids for 20 years I'm a retired political science Professor from Western Michigan University so public education is something that's extremely close to my heart um I'm speaking tonight on the agenda item 12.3 on the statement about immigrant families at the January 26 uh 27th meeting several trustees echoed community members calls for Grand Rapids Public Schools and its superintendent to work with local
036groups like gr rapid response and cons coneta gr I'm wondering if you all can address if that's begun um at the January 27th meeting also superintendent Robbie stated that grps has been working with the ACLU of Michigan and the Michigan immigra immigration rights Center other known as uh MC I hope the superintendent and the board can explain to the community in detail what they are doing to implement the very long list of specific concrete recommendations uh laid out in the ACLU of Michigan and merc's uh January 22nd letter to Michigan school superintendant and it's a 10 15 Page Letter um for example is grps educating all staff about the difference between administrative versus judicial warrants uh for example will all GPS staff be trained to not allow immigration officers in nonpublic areas and to not
037allow such officers to interview students and the list goes on I'd also and finally like to ask whether the superintendent and board will follow the example of Lancing school district and remove info about students addresses place of birth and telephone numbers in its directory information which could be used by immigration officers and this is also consistent with ACLU and Merc uh recommendations thank you for your time thank you Bo good evening all Dr Robie board tonight I'm going to share a story of an immigrant student who moved to Michigan from Puerto Rico not knowing any English and was lucky enough to have a caring empathetic teacher the first time that I ever spoke in a classroom after learning a little bit of uh English was in Mr Bob Eagle crout's third grade classroom in Battle
038Creek Michigan wilon Elementary School no longer exists it was knocked down he asked a question he asked who is the president of the United States my dad being a CNN junkie at that time we used to watch the news together every evening and I knew the answer to that question and I raised my hand for the first time ever in a classroom and I said Ronald McDonald all of the kids did what we just saw happen right they laughed I cried the first time I took a chance and he said no no no no no relax he's right he is a clown Ronald Reagan right that moment changed the course of my life in my relationship to education it is because of those actions that happen daily in grps in different school systems those are
039the impacts that we can have every single day and if we as a community can see what's happening nationally and federally the federal government is going to do what they want to do whether we say we are Sanctuary or not they are going to try and close the educational system of the US and privatize it for profit in these moments where we're asking as a community of caring individuals to do what is right to make those impacts it is not about what would happen or about divisions in black and Latin and lgbtqia communities it is about coming together in an effort to say we will not stand for this so that students that do not know English feel that they are supported in a way that is way more than will ever be known by
040you all individually every single day I work with parents of the Latin and Global majority communities and the fear is real as they walk into the those classrooms as they have the Bob Eagle cruts that exist in grps and they are welcomed with open arms and they say you are going to be successful it changed and it made me want to be a political science major it made me want to work in public schools in Detroit it makes me every single day want to be a part of this community because I know that we have the capacity to make these changes happen so I urge you all to do what is correct not in semantic ways with real policies so that all of our students that are in these rooms understand what those policies are
041how those policies will be input and what those outputs will be for our students thank you thank you okay I believe that ends our agenda related public comment so we will move forward with the secretary's report all right so excuse me I'm so sorry um we've got the ad hoc facilities committee meeting um they are scheduled through December um on the second Monday of the month at 4:30 p.m. um in conference room 112 in the library building over there across the uh parking lot the next meeting will take place on March 10th um and then finance committee meetings will take place on the fourth Monday of the month at 5:00 P PM the next meeting will take the next meeting will take place on March 24th um and that is here in the auditorium so
042again ad hoc facilities March 10th in the library um at 4:30 and here in the auditorium is Finance on March 24th thank you committee chair reports finance committee so we will be um uh voting for them in our action items under the uh budget but the committee is bringing forth um some general fund items which include instructional supplies equipment and services support material and services as well and then there are uh several Bond projects which will be voted on later in the meeting okay thank you and AD hack facilities sticking with you trusty Williams yes um so for ad hack committee we pretty much had a an overview meeting just to get our new uh committee members up to speed about the work that has been done and then there um will be an opportunity
043to review the schematics for the plans for Aberdine and there will be opportunities for board members to visit construction sites so if there's interest please reach out and let me know he thank you and I think we're sticking with you because we have a conference report out for the National Association of school boards advoc advocacy and Equity Institute okay wonderful well um I'll keep it pretty brief um one of the um we of course went over um different things that are taking place with executive orders uh things that we have been advocating for a long time proper funding for idea um and um those things did happen we did meet with um we were planned to meet with one of our Representatives however we met with her staffer instead as she was not able to
044make her flight um and uh we did that in conjunction with other districts from the uh Kent ISD um and we again just lift up those uh talking points U we received advisement again on all of the executive orders um and uh different changes that are going to be taking place so it was more like um we have to really kind of let that stuff go through the court processes to really understand the full impact um of where that is but then there was a a particular presentation which came for with regards to um uh marketing and branding and um this kind of stuck out with me as it really um uplifted uh the board's responsibility as well as a being a part of that plan and marketing um and that takes place from the
045way we conduct our meetings um to how we speak well of our district and the issues and it came up you know like there's um while every there's always room for improvement always room for growth but that is not where you lead in uh discussing your branding you lead from your uh places of positivity and assets and um you work toward improving areas of deficiencies uh and I think sometimes um it's a message that should have been should be uplifted here so I am bringing that forward but um that is pretty much it mostly legislative things thank you um we do not have a foundation report tonight so we will move on to the superintendent report good evening everyone and I'm going to bring forward um our lobbyist um Stephany seismos and John Hol to
046talk about some legislative updates and they can also provide an overview related to some of the things that are taking place across our state with immigration information and um and such welcome good evening [Music] power all right just going to pull up our PowerPoint here real quick but thank you for having us so we'll get started just as a brief intro while that's coming up um it's been I'm sure as many of you know a Ever Changing political landscape federally and at our state to say the least um just as a reminder for everybody here and the board members um at Melby mer and Associates we only handle State um legislation and politics so obviously what's happening at the federal level um comes down and affects what's happening at the state level so we'll tie
047some of those things together but as far as um you know executive orders and what's happening at the national level we're following but it's not a um something that we directly handle so our efforts are with our state representatives and um Senators here in Lanay so with that being said okay we're going to multitask so with that being said um this week some of you might have seen the governor came forward with her budget recommendations I will start before we kind of go into detail as we saw one of the executive orders um that came through that was reversed was Federal funding being freezed and the budget that was presented from the governor's team it was with the preface and the notion that we would have all of our working dollars um over 40% of
048our budget from the state of Michigan comes from the federal government so if that happens to be frozen again even though that was quick reversed but if that decision comes back the budget recommendation that was brought forward obviously will look very different and kind of have to go back to the drawing board if 40% of our budget is not at the table so today um we're going to go through some of the highlights of her budget recommendations the political climate in laning which um is often does it's kind of following suit from the federal level um but it is a divice government in laning as you all know um we have a Democratic governor and Senate Majority Leader um and Senate but we have a republican um house caucus and a new speaker and that
049has been a new political landscape and Lancing as we see that speaker kind of form his caucus and sign his committees and um create what we're also seeing federally here at the state level kind of a new level of um oversight has been something that's been introduced by the Republican party in Michigan um usually we just see our typical committees and um in addition to our uh you know like your education agriculture your your uh kitchen table issue committees there's been about 10 different oversight committees and that is something that will be new um this time around when we're looking at policy and and how that um successfully goes through the chambers in Lancing so with that let's go through just a couple of the details of budget recommendations from the governor um as you
050all are probably aware these are um just budget recommendations right this is the governor's Christmas list if she had it her way tomorrow this is what the budget would look like it will look very different it has to go through the Senate it has to go through the house lots of negotiations will take place and um this weeker has made it pretty clear that he suspects that the budget will probably go all the way through October which is um not favorable for us because that's a whole fiscal quarter without knowing the type of funding or programs that you're going to see or not see so I I for our sake I hope that changes and I hope that we you know finish up in May or June like we typically do um but right now
051it's looking like it might be going to the fall so can before you um go further on that just so that people understand kind of the timeline of how that impacts schools from um schools budgets are from July 1 through June 30 and so if we don't know what our funding is I just want to make sure people understand if you don't know what your funding is until October it does make it harder to kind of know what your what your money and your resources are because and obviously school starts in August so um and this was something that happened years and years before and then over the last three to five years they've moved the budget um closer to the spring so that as schools are detered termining their budgets they knew what their
052resources were mhm and that that's the high hope as at least hopefully it will be June but um it will be something for us to watch and monitor going forward for sure um so with that um like I just mentioned the exact number is 41 .7% of our 83.5 billion dollar budget um is from the federal funds so the governor and her team again just made that abundantly clear that her recommendations are based off of thinking that you know we have 100% of the funds on the table um with that being said um a large emphasis over all of the governor's budget recommendations positively for us was an increase in education and in many um pockets of education so a couple of them and I apologize because it's just a lot of numbers to go
053through um but we'll go through some of them specifically and then we included a couple of just examples for you all to have and if there are questions on those we can certainly go through them too so the budget represents a 1.2 increase from the 2024 2025 current fiscal year um which is a 2% general fund the K through 12 budget is 21.2 billion and 18.5 billion from the school aid fund which was a 2.7 increase and a 4.8% school aid increase so we're heading in the right Direction with school aid funding and per people allowance um you'll see here the foundation allowance was an increase to at least 10,000 per student under this funding proposal so it was a 4.1 increase per pupil funding um and a major focus of the governor's overall Investments
054was to include more funding for literacy supports it targeted interventions and best practice incentives for schools these proposals um came as a recent report showed that 7 5% of Michigan's fourth graders and 76% of eighth graders do not read above grade level proficiency standards do you want to do the next one you want me to keep going I keep going okay so another emphasis of her Investments were to continue to fund free preschool programs for all fouryear olds in the state with $676 million up from 6283 the budget further includes 61 million for pilot programs that provide pre uh free preschool excuse me for three-year-olds and the one thing that was lower with her budget recommendations which receives some push back especially from the um other side of the aisle that she is on was
055proposing a lower PR per pup funding level of $88,000 for Cy uh cyber school students and it was a total reduction and 36 million a key part of the governor's proposal and funding strategies the administration hopes will help the state get smart on education one of the things that she's taking on is her kind of new brand by focusing on students metrics and results with transparency and funding for this effort included 232 million 107 being ongoing for a district implementation of best practices high impact tutoring and the budget also requires 10% of combined atrisk and discretionary Foundation allowance to be utilized on bus practices and tutoring as well this next page I won't go into detail I am going to hi highlight just one bullet point because it was for our um returning board members
056you'll remember last year um 31a received a big cut and that received um bipartisan backlash and even for those of you that were not serving you probably heard that was a pretty big moment in our state um Democrats came back with a supplemental last year and increased that funding so the governor kept that supplemental increase funding in in in addition to the 31a funding which is another 150 million for mental health and student safety efforts in the state of Michigan so going on to the political climate while we were setting up I touched on some of this already um I'm going to go into it a little bit in more detail and we'll stop at the end and please feel free um to ask questions and we'll answer them as um you know matter of
057fact as we can our job as lobbyists is to advocate for grps and our um teachers and students and admin the the best that we can with the political lay of the land in front of us and we always do so nonpartisan so I just like to remind folks of that that we work hard to work across the aisle but um you know folks on both sides of the aisle make decisions and our job is to inform you of those when they happen so um one of those has been recently by um speaker Hall who has um like I had said pretty quickly followed the national rhetoric and decisions being made out of the White House um you know he he doesn't have the ability as speaker to do executive orders or things like that
058but he does have the ability to put forward um resolutions and rules within his chamber and budgets and bills have to pass both ch chers they have to go through the house and the Senate and then make their way to the governor's desk so um he has put forward a new rule in his chamber that um I will go through here um in response to the governor's budget so um his new resolution would be in communities with Sanctuary policies and those that refused to cooperate with Federal immigration officials from receiving additional State funding the rule would prohibit any jurisdiction that refuses to comply with Federal immigration enforcement measures from receiving additional State funding the resolution does not prohibit municipalities from receiving constitutionally required Revenue sharing although those are slim and Hall Define sanctuary jurisdictions as
059mun any municipality that does not help enforce Federal immigration law so you do not have to use the word Sanctuary um underneath his meaning and definition in his resolution so this is a political reality that the speaker has made it clear that um this type of verbiage in any Bill including budget bills will not pass his chamber and funding will be withheld so um this just came forward last week so um important for all of you to be aware um while you proceed in making um timely decisions in this District um in addition to that one quick thing sorry excuse me yeah I just had a clarification too yep um because I also was reading about that bill and and I just want to make clear that it's only for municipalities correct at this point
060so I see I'm reading the bill right now municipality means a County City Village or Township not school districts that's correct but think about how school districts are tied within cities and supported by that so yes you still could be getting your state funding um you may not federally that's still up in the air um but again um as of right now yes I think it's going to be interesting to watch to see um because the speaker is also issued official letters on his letter head to counties and cities with that one um and I think ferally we're seeing um other steps being made and I would expect the speaker to take them closely behind but as of right now you are correct okay just wanted to make that distinction thank you absolutely Richard yes
061um speaking back to the governor's uh budget proposal does her proposal speak to universal student meals at all it does as of be sustained as of right now it's included but that is one thing that the um thank you that is one thing that um House Republicans have made pretty clear that they would like to see removed and that they do not support um but um through political conversations and negotiations it'll be interesting to see if that stays um but to your point that is one thing that the speaker and Republicans have universally expressed a lot of displeasure okay with but the governor has it in her the governor has it in her budget right now y absolutely so in addition um to this rule that the speaker has brought forward after the governor's budget
062uh proposals the main three priorities that he wants to see which the governor um you know listed several he narrowed it down pretty simply in his perspective and that should be a funding a public safety trust fund reducing the personal income tax and providing 3.1 billion toward a long-term Road Funding Solution he's made it pretty clear to the governor and the Senate Majority Leader that he doesn't have a lot of interest in doing much of anything else um legislative priorities for his members are not a priority for him and these are these are the three things that he wants to see get done so with that um again members that um we here last term you'll remember briefly us talking on house bills 6058 um there is a little bit of a political update here
063as well so um to the best of my ability I will explain this lawsuit um if there are questions along the way please stop me um but um name duck as many of you will recall serving or not um it was a little bit of an unprecedented session last cycle um when our all of our Republican members left the chamber and with that also pulled one Democratic member with them um and the house did not have the majority of members present to move any legislation in lame duck so they only had a day of lame duck movement and then it all came kind of closing down around them um due to that though there were several house bills that moved over to the senate in time the Senate Majority Leader ran I what I do
064believe was the longest session in Michigan history um almost two straight days uh of a session um we were all a little tired in laning after that one and uh she moved hundreds and hundreds of bills um out of the Senate chamber and um with those be bills being moved they had gone through the house chamber they have gone through the Senate chamber no changes were made to those bills so they did not have to go back to the house chamber the next process in government is for them to be presented to the governor for her signature um the current Speaker withheld bills and did not present them to the governor um at a certain time uh things transferred over to the new legislature and we had a new speaker Matt Hall and there were
065nine bills still REM that were not presented to the governor and he continued to choose to not present them to the governor and one of them being um house bill 6058 which I won't go through all the details today on that you have it in front of you um but it is a um real just real briefly um it's supports public employees and officers it deals with compensation benefits um in the public employer contribution percentage to the medical um benefit plans that they participate in and that's a very general summary there's lots of detail here but all of that to be said I I go through all this process with you because the Senate majority leader in the Senate Democratic caucus has um chosen to bring on a formal lawsuit against the speaker um for
066him to present these bills to the governor which you can imagine has created a bit of a um you know political um dynamic in Lancing and lack of um you know wanting to come to the table and work on issues so it will be interesting to see when we have major issues like paid sick time leave and Lancing right now and budget items coming forward how those conversations between Chambers um proceed with that law suit pending and again um really just for you all to review these are um not major bills and as I had mentioned the speaker has really um just formed committees within the last week or two um and has not given a lot of um rope for his members to go and start introducing legislation policy committees are quite slow with
067that the senate members have started introducing a few more bills but most of them in the minority and meaning they don't have a lot of leg or likelihood to move um but a few new bills for you to um review and if any of them um you cut your eye or interest and you want to engage with them please um let Dr Robby know or your board president and John and I can help arrange those meetings and talk with Bill sponsors and um and I should just say for new members as well that's something that um we do so if there is an issue as a board that you are passionate about or concerned about you would like to see past something that you would not like to see past um some members will let
068you know we we did a great job um and your former board members did as well of making themselves available to either get on a zoom or come to laning and meet with legislators and have those conversations so please know that um that's something that stands for your board one last thing just to bring um new board members up to speed as well so as Richard um asked the question about the Michigan meals program um Grand IDs formed unique Partnerships that helped consolidate services and dollars for the state of Michigan with um numerous schools and around grps including um for example um East Grand Rapids East Rapids and the Aviation Academy and because of that how the bill was written um it removed some funding That was supposed to come from the state of Michigan
069due to those Partnerships and it created a deficit for grps and and we are working very diligently to try to get that funding back through a supplemental line item and if lame duck would have happened and not had half the chamber walk out on the gem um that would have happened successfully we were in um in a supplemental Bill ready to go we had a vehicle but we didn't have Chambers to move it through um this time around just this last week there was a supplemental bill that was introduced in the Senate that this could go into but the question is is Speaker Hall going to sign and accept a supplemental budget right now or not um but we are working with the governor's office and the Senate majority leaders office to include the 1.2
070million that was a deficit to make grps whole and with that I would just add just for drama's sake during the whole lame duck it was like highs and lows when we were going into the lab last couple hours last couple days and Stephanie had teed this up to have this onetime supplemental to solve this onetime problem and so despite our best efforts and the highs and lows of the oh wait we're back oh no we're not so anyway in the end your your laning based lobbyist went to bat all the way up to the Wi hours so you know we're going to continue to fight it but so not for lack of effort just lack of attendance that that did not happen so um with that um any questions or further discussion on some
071of those items could you speak more to uh the governor's budget proposal in terms of the transparency language and what that would entail and how that would affect us here on the ground yeah that's a good question um I'm going to have to dig into it a little bit more I'll get back to I can email you um I will say that's been um a topic of conversation as you're aware in laning um and not only from the governor but really coming out of the Senate chamber and there's been some you know disagreement on how far that transparency should go um so let me uh dig into that before I speak further and I'll let you know thank you absolutely anyone else thank you for your work thank you thank you all right H moving
072forward with the bond update right yes yep I'm gonna um ask Mr Alex Mark to come forward to provide a bond update and then right after he'll do a quick summary overview of the real estate owner representative um services along with Mr um Luke Styer L Luke [Music] St well we you this uh good evening uh everyone good evening uh president Davis Dr Roby board members um while we do this I just want to give a quick little shout out to our newest uh member of the facilities steam Mr Dell cinga uh he's sitting back there wave Hi D he d uh he's our new director of uh uh design and construction uh he he joined us back in December so he's still learning quite a bit um but uh we're happy to have him
073um so I believe that um Dr Roby sent a quick little summary update with the letter on Friday um which we prepared to try to bring up to speed the our new board members as to some of the things that we're doing uh so I'm not going to spend a tremendous amount of detail on my presentation but of course feel free to ask questions however they come up um so but most of these projects are referenced here all right thank you Luke so so um what I would like to do is to um briefly go over some of the active and summer construction projects and those are the ones that I would like to be focusing on um we're going to talk briefly about sibl renovation KO 6B Housman field and Bricks field uh few
074parking lots Central Auditorium Chavis and Dickinson those are the projects that we're planning on starting construction some of them are already going like uh 6bit but the other ones will be starting construction as soon as uh um school gets out um the auditorium we hope to start construction even before that if if at all possible um this we will not dwell into it yet um which is a design and programming uh we have uh the new aberin which we will be planning a presentation uh Riverside monory Kent Hills Ottawa Hills renovation aler Union Auditorium City Auditorium Aro High School auditorium Union High School renovation and Union swimming pool so as you can see we have a lot of projects going on right now uh I don't want to keep you here too late so uh
075I'll bring those back uh to you uh in the future um so starting with Sibly uh we're our plan is to complete phase two uh if you recall uh last year we started phase one and I want to talk a little bit about the facing uh I I know that this board um has has agreed and and and and and tasked us with trying to do construction whenever possible without students in the building uh now sometimes that will not be possible uh and then we will work through that uh but when whenever possible we try to do that so that's the reason why you'll see some phase one and phase two uh is because we're trying to scope the work so that way we can get it done in the summer and not affect School
076uh the school year so uh sibl and qu are on phase two um and uh as you can see there we're pretty much uh gearing to complete the project this is last phase uh where we're going to be replacing drinking fountains uh doing some improvements for lighting flooring uh HVAC um and uh uh painting and temperature controls and I apologize I have lighting up there twice uh at any given point if you have any questions specific about a project uh please let let let me know um uh K uh phase two this uh uh this one is a little bit more robust uh because we have a lot of HVAC upgrades we're replacing uh also the uh uh emergency uh generator uh for for the building uh parking lot resurfacing and you you can see
077the list I don't have to read this this to you um both projects uh were working with the construction managers uh and uh we have not identified any concerns as of right now uh when it comes to the supply line and getting the materials and products that uh we're expecting to have so as of today uh we're good to go so 6B this one is exciting because it's under construction right now in fact that photo that you see right there is the current state of our 6B building um we have pretty much uh demolished and uh down to the STS as you can see um and uh we are in the process of putting everything back together and uh and getting the building ready um construction is moving really quick uh our intent is to
078be receiving our Scholars uh next fall so when come to August uh August will be uh opening the doors to receive our Scholars from uh that are currently at Jefferson um this is the one that I I I think trusty uh Williams mentioned that perhaps uh we'll schedule a a tour uh we work through Dr roby's office uh to create form small groups we can't have large groups and uh we're also going to be working with the construction manager to to identify what would be the best time for us to do that so that way we don't um uh distract or interfere with their construction and the schedules that they have going um justtin 6p for or or or or new board members um the the intent is to really transform the school to receive
079High School age students uh this building used to be a Elementary School uh and pre uh preschool programs we had there uh and uh we are making all the necessary changes to to uh right size and and create brand new space for for Scholars we're pretty excited about this one uh Housman fi and Bricks um we're we're again we're ready to go uh we receive all the bids we've had already uh coordination meetings with with with both contractors um and um as soon as graduation is done uh that following week we'll we'll we'll start mobilizing and starting construction at Housman field uh bricks we're going to be moving in a little bit earlier uh the request has been for us to start in March early March and uh that one we we have natural grass
080and we're replacing that with Turf so that takes a little bit more time to take so we want to be able to get ahead of that so that way we can use uh Brickfield in in the fall uh if that was a change later on late in the project originally we had seats but that was going to put us out another year so we made a change to make sure that the building is available uh any questions so far okay uh Now parking lots um we we had six schools uh parking lots originally designed and documented once we receed the the the bid we narrow it down to the top three that we believe have the the greater need right now based on the condition uh of the uh um parking lots uh one is
081innovation Central High School um J monori both of those are going to receive a new layout a new Surface um and Congress Elementary um probably will have the biggest impact because we're taking the opportunity to develop a parent drop off and pickup area right now it's tough uh it's pretty tough um we make it work we've been making it work for years but we're we're really optimistic that this change is going to greatly improve the side circulation and the safety of our Scholars and and parents and staff uh we hope to come back for a later phase for Congress to see if we can develop the same thing for busing right now busing is on the street uh and we are uh we've had some initial conversations with the city of Grand Rapids to see
082what other options we have so so we're starting that we'll bring that back to you if we move forward with that uh future projects uh CA Frost Middle High uh Kent Hills and lion street parking lot th those were were waiting um there is a note on Kent Hills um we do have a project a renovation project for Kent Hills and we're just starting to put all the numbers together and we're hopeful that the budget that we have for that project will be able to support doing the parking lot as well and if that is the case we'll move forward with that one on that project innovation Central High School auditorium so um we received the last bit package uh uh for this and and uh right now we're in the process of evaluating those
083we have a meeting with the with the teams uh later this week and uh we are trying to reconcile sty all the scope of work uh and uh and the budget and um we're hopeful that um within the next uh couple weeks uh we'll be able to identify and develop the schedule for construction and start right away I know that the last bit package uh has been brought for your approval uh so uh once we have that we'll move forward with this as well and uh we're also trying to replace the seats so that's going to be a big big big Improvement there uh Chavis Elementary um phase one um this is one of the ones that we're looking at how much work can we get done within the summer and um and in reality
084the number one thing that we really want to achieve uh this summer is replacing the entire flooring in that uh all the classrooms uh the carpet is uh is in pretty bad shape and uh we would hate to have to go another school year with that so uh that is going to be part of phase one and uh we're also pushing hard to do the playground surface upgrades that was another ask from this board that all our playgrounds eventually become very much Universal Design uh barrier free accessible uh and uh uh if you guys have an opportunity to go to KO you'll see a project that we did last summer and that one is absolutely awesome uh and uh the kids love it uh and we're very proud of that so we're hoping to be
085able to get to the surface in here uh also this summer um and the last one that I have is Dickinson and uh the emphasis for this one in the summer is to complete the secured entrance uh for the school that has been a top priority for us um and uh The Architects are already uh developing the documents for for us to uh do that work and get it done before our Scholars come back in August uh um so with that if you guys have any questions I'll be glad to uh do my very best looks like we're all set thank you Alex thank you so I'll wait till the next till you tell me to proceed and this is just um with regard to our real estate owner represent rup um conversations that we've
086been having and this is just to provide a quick update so I'll let um Alex and Luke take it from here okay um for the real estate uh Consulting owner representation uh process we have uh we did Issue a request for proposal uh it was out for um roughly three weeks uh we receive four responses uh we receive responses from Community uh Wealth Partners uh jll uh plant brand real point and CBR we are right now in the process of interviewing firms we completed two interviews last week and we're going to complete the other two interviews this week and we hope to be able then to come back with a recommendation to uh Dr Roby uh within here within the next uh week or two so we can proceed and bring that to finance will
087you talk a little bit about um the rubric that we've asked you all to use please I'll I'll be glad to um in the request for proposal that was submitted we actually included the selection criteria so all the applicants uh all the companies that were submitting had that information um and we also included the scoring weight for each one of these categories uh for example you know experience and similar projects you know that would be at 30% of the weighted score um so I can make this Avail actually this is in the website uh you guys can take a look at that uh I don't know Dr Ro if you want me to go through the whole thing but it also includes you know makes a reference to local representation and that has been a
088a a board policy I believe that it gives our local and minority uh owned companies a 5% Advantage uh from from other applicants so you want anything else to ask um I have a question about the the 30% for experience and and I'm wondering about how does that um open us up to an opportunity to have a a more inclusive process with such a weight on that at 30% um given that um we definitely want people to have some level of experience to do the work but at the same time that could box us into The Usual Suspects so how do we um how can we work and look at that to get um beyond the usual suspect sometimes I think we get um we do business with some of the same people a lot
089of time because of those type of things how can we be more inclusive well the 30% is is one of them I can I can I can share the other ones you know the approach and methodology that's 25% on how they approach the project uh we have a 20% for Community engagement uh and uh 15% for the fee structure and uh 10% would be for project outcomes and and and and references so so I guess when if we you take the whole thing together there are other opportunities for companies also to uh to stand out uh you know if maybe the experience is not as high maybe they're excellent when it comes to community uh uh engagement and strategies um I'm not so sure how we can change that at this point um I'm open
090to suggestions I don't know Luke if you have a well with this one it was in the RFP already it was in the RFP so but are you asking you know moving forward to for us to look at that we can certainly do that I think so because I think as a district we can do business with the same vendors repeatedly and because of that weight of 30% that's pretty significant um to put just on experience and um versus the full scope of the work and whether or not they have a capable ability to do the work um so I'm just I'm asking about that because again I think it's important if we want to create opportunities for people to be able to come to the to be a vendor with us if we have
091a weight that heavy that could give us again The Usual Suspects and um how can we get beyond that or how can we try to bring make room for the the little guy uh to some degree um and not just have the same people we do business with because we keep doing business with them and we get the big box versus the small business if you get what I mean yep I understand I think that's a good feedback for us to look out yes thank you any other questions on this I do have um you you mentioned that the uh RFP that that document that you've got in your hand is available online I I'm looking online and I just see that it says that it'll be announced in January says it hasn't not been
092uploaded yet if you scroll down further I believe that might be the first thing and it's now I scroll down and it's got um scope of work for kenos Riverside Monas and new Aldine is it no it's expired now because it's closed it's possible to be it's close it exp okay okay I was just trying to look for it but yeah if you could just yes put that back we can make this available we can yeah thank you so much through through Dr Ro to me again and we'll make sure that and then we can distribute that so can have it thank you so much thank you okay thank you so much thank you very much we're all set thank you that concludes my reports thank you okay so we are moving on to action
093items um up first is the purchasing agenda are there any questions see none do I have a motion to approve the purchasing agenda so moved support all in favor say I any oppose same sign okay motion carries um moving on to approval of Kent intermediate school district schools of choice resolution are there any questions regarding this one is there a motion to approve the approval of Kent Intermediate School District School of Choice resolution so moved support all in favor say I any opposed same sign okay and moving on to board statement of commitment to support our immigrant families um I would like to give each board member um a chance to uh ask any questions or share what they're feeling about this um we're going to just kind of try something new and um Let
094each member speak um without commentary from other members and then we can discuss afterwards for a little while before we take a vote um I am just going to follow the order of our roll call tonight which just for public knowledge that changes every time we just rotate that so I'll start with truste Moreno I just want to uplift all the work the District staff have done to uh create the website uh to send out uh to engage our families through communication I just really want to uplift the work uh through your leadership Dr Roby to Luke uh for the communications I've been pointing whole bunch of people towards the website for all those resources so thank you so much for all that great work I really appreciate it um and our families really appreciate
095it too um I I know our last meeting uh as a board was uh very uh tense uh but I appreciate uh the really great dialogue we had uh just really want to uplift also Jose's work uh the last few months um around the resolution and kind of talking through you know what what that can look like uh I know it's been a hard conversation and then seeing uh the presentation today of uh that uh some how critical language could could harm us uh I was like I'm not fully committed to uh I know the legal had to kind of clean it up to kind of appease some of that tension we're feeling uh because of some uh backlash our district could receive um but I I know that we're really committed uh as a
096team to continue uplifting uh making sure that our district is safe and welcoming and folks feel like they belong I'm the most excited about uh The Advisory uh group I really you know my work is in policy uh and so I I'm really hopeful for what we can do uh with our partners with school staff and the board members who will be represented um it really will match uh that some of that culture shift to ensure that it goes beyond just this group and Beyond the staff so I'm really looking forward to that work okay um truste Melton yeah I mean I would Echo what truste Moreno just um shared and I've appreciated the time even for our board to meet with ACLU and actually several organizations um what I want to point out tonight
097is um a lot of push back has come about this idea of making a statement from public from you know from each other we kind of dig digesting how to do this in a way that's appropriate so of course I turned to the policies and um in policy section 9,000 we have policies for so much um just because I have three minutes I'm going to take that time we have directions as to what news outlets are to do if they want to speak to any of us who they're specifically supposed to go to and under what parameters we have direction or policies about what volunteers are supposed to do if they want to start volunteering in our school who they talk to what the parameters are if they want if anyone wants to use our
098facilities it even dictates the attitude of the board it says we are to encourage people to use our facilities under these parameters this is who to go to this this is what you pay to use it we have policies about how to accept gifts so that we need to thank people in writing it tells us where to put that money if it can't go to the intended Place uh student teachers where they can work that there has to be um a written agreement so we dictate to the university how they can go ahead to use our spaces for their student teachers agency is doing research there's actually a four-point list dictating what the agencies shall do most importantly we have um we have policies about interviewing students and that not only do parents have to
099have or give permission but the superintendent has to give permission for interviews for students going to the next step it would be uh our relations with law enforcement and in investigating authorities it specifies who we speak to under what conditions and it is not clear in this situation with immigration what to do despite all these policies so I want to reiterate that a statement is not anything revolutionary what we're asking to do is a statement of intent to say we're going to be clarifying this through a collaboration with our community so a statement should not be scaring anyone this is in complete alignment with what we've been doing for decades so I just want to encourage us to not be worried about doing some something outrageous if we all are kind of agreeing that we
100want to make sure to be our language is in line with what we're being ushered into but that the statement is nothing unusual and I would encourage you to look at all of I mean there's more that I didn't bring up under Section 9,000 on our grps website uh so I want to encourage us to continue with the statement of intention around creating a policy with a collaboration of our community members those impacted and those caring out the work to me the easiest way to start that statement is to give the directive at this point that law any law enforcement starts with our Security Office to me that's the most logical place to go it also allows our community who's saying we're nervous that we're going to be picked up at school to at least
101have that buffer of saying this will not be something intera happening in our own offices in our own schools so to me the two pieces is one the statement should be written again not anything outrageous just giving the the intention of the board and then two the procedure in my opinion should be that we ask those who are federal agents or state agents or official law agents to go through our central office where people can be trained really specifically around what the paperwork needs to look like for that next step to happen that's it justy Rodriguez I like that you tried to I didn't try actually oh okay well sound good sound good um so you know I uh I'd say I was in rare form the last time we were all around you know
102these tables um but you know a lot of that I want to just say to to the board to the public um you know this is something I mean I'm very passionate about a lot of things but this is something that I am am also very passionate about is is protecting our immigrant communities our Refugee families um it's something you know back in 2022 that I campaigned on actually I was looking back at some of my stuff and it said hey you know that's that's one of my um you know one of my goals right and so um I I appreciate the work and the conversations that have led us here um I do think that if we're we're going to make a statement um you know I would like to have something that that
103really like because if we're going to put ourselves in any sort of peril if we're going to put ourselves in any sort of hot water I want us to go all out um and I think this I mean I I appreciate the statement I appreciate that all of us had hand and crafting it um you know as I read it it it kind of reads as okay well you know we follow furpa we follow the law but here's here's a a commitment that we're focused on um and that's fine I think the work is a lot more important than the uh the statement itself um that's something that I have continued to say you know and I I try to use a resolution as a vehicle for the work I try to use a resolution
104for a vehicle toward uh policy that is really clear on what we do um with you know Homeland Security immigrations and Customs Enforcement um I agree with trusty Melton that you know possibly the first place that we should direct him you know direct any federal officers is to you know either Franklin campus where where Safety and Security is or you know someplace away from from uh you know direct student contact and I know that um you know this might not even be a possibility in our schools and I don't ever want to um you know act like it it wouldn't be a possibility ever because I believe even one one you know incident at our schools is is going to be a tremendous shock um to our community um and so yeah aside from that
105I don't really have too much more to say I I really do appreciate the work of the advisory committee being formed um again I think that's a great first step I don't think that that requires a statement statement of commitment um so I don't know if I would necessarily feel like I would need to support this to continue that work though I appreciate the work that has been put into this um and so those are my thoughts thank you trusty way no comment trusty Williams yes so um one of my primary concerns is that again um we put a Target on our district um and I'm not sure if this statement does or doesn't frankly it's is is like w w West so frankly I don't know what could happen um I do think the
106district has made a similar statement so I'm confused as to why there's such a push for the board to make a different one when they work at our Direction um but um the other part about what we have before us that is a concerning for me is an abdication of Duty for this board when you say you're giving someone else authority to create policy when that's our work I have a concern about that um I don't think that's a great precedent to set it's one thing to make a policy recommendation it's another to say we're giving you authority to create policy um and for me that is a problem um and that goes in direct violation of what we have been sent here to do um so I definitely am open to uh review refined
107and updated policy recommendations I have a problem with language where we're giving someone else the authority to do our job um so um but ultimately um if our our board is in support of it it's in support of it and I if this makes our families feel better great um I am just again um just really want us to just be intentional about the work as I said before it I want I don't know if a statement does anything but I know the work does and so that's what I'm concerned about most trusty Williamson yes thank you um I want to start by saying for me a priority through this has been making sure whatever we do as a board and whatever the district does is very thoughtful intentional actionable and meaningful and I think
108the work that we've been doing so far really addresses those points um you know working together to create a statement to generate the idea of having an Advisory Group and I actually agree with my colleague I do not believe it's our place um it might not even be legal for us to abdicate the responsibility of that however The Advisory Group um and and I support making changes to the language because that isn't clear in there The Advisory Group exists to make recommendations that we as a board can act on and I think that's a great thing um and this is a little separate from the purpose of the discussion but uh speaking to The Advisory Group I I think that is a great thing um to those points I highlighted at the beginning to bring
109in people who are affected by this groups that work in this space to make recommendations for us that way going forward our district response is thoughtful actionable and is actually going to keep students and families safe um to the language of this I think there is Merit to us as a board um endorsing effectively what the position of the districts has been um you know the I've proud that the district's been um responsive to this this is really unanticipated and unprecedented situations we're dealing with and um you know we can always move faster and we can always work quicker um but all of that said I think the response so far has been appropriate and I think there's Merit to us as a board um endorsing that and acknowledging that there needs to be continued
110work and we need to continue pushing forward and in some cases moving faster so uh I you know I could get into the language right now maybe I'll hold it until the discussion there's some language that we could change in the statement um to uh trusty Williams Point um but overall I do think there is Merit to the statement and I think as a work product for us having a statement and an Advisory Group to make recommendations um positions as well to respond respond to this thoughtfully thank youy Davis I think the work that um I've seen all of us do is extremely important and I do want to just like you know show appreciation and gratitude for the progress that we've made on this issue fairly quickly um I have not been particularly excited
111myself to make a statement I've been very excited to do the work and to have us get together and like have these conversations and address a lot of the things that have been outlined from the community I want to see the result of these families in this community like feeling safe um I'm not against the statement um I've heard some of my other colleagues say that the statement might not be necessary um but I do want to see us continue to move forward and hold each other accountable to not doing this work and making decisions rashly but definitely like moving swiftly and really protecting the people that we're here to protect trusty kpatrick I want to Echo a lot of what's been said and just Express gratitude to our superintendent and her team for getting
112Communications out in an urgent and meaningful way um I also want to say that um I I'm deeply grateful for the energy the time that the board is also putting into not only the statement conversation but into the work of creating that advisory committee so again reiterating a lot here um and I I also want to say that um clear Comm communication matters and communication is our words and also our behaviors and so I think this is a both and with um the statement uh as well as the policy advisory committee and the policies that will come forward from that that um I think that each additional gesture that we offer by way of word and by way of behavior um is a reaffirmation of our commitment to our Scholars well-being to their safety to
113their inclusion and really help strengthen the message that we believe that everyone belongs here and that we stand with our most marginalized members okay and I am up I I just want to thank each of you for your thoughtful comments and I um I feel like there were Snippets of each of yours that I that just um that was in tune with what I want to say um I think first of all I'm so proud of our district I feel like we're really leading the way we have sent out a lot of communication thank you Dr Roby and to her team um and also have begun trainings for staff and have things on the website where really responding to um even the the pamphlet that came forward in public comment the ACLU a lot of
114those things are things our district has already committed to and begun doing so um I feel like a statement um I I do get a little worried about uh how that will possibly put a Target on us especially hearing the updates from um the State House and and how that might come down we don't know um I do think it is somewhat well very repetitive of what has gone out from the district um outside of this the advisory committee uh I'm not I'm in support of everything this statement says um and if if it benefits our community to hear it coming from the board versus the district as a whole that's fine I do want to make a statement that I My Hope Is that our board and our district are working together that we
115you know the district wouldn't present something that the board isn't in alignment with um and I I feel like this very much mirrors the work that has already taken place um and as far as the advisory committee I agree with you Miss Williams I don't think any of us um meant for it to be that group deciding on policy but rather advising the board and then the the board members that are represented at that advisory committee would be voting on what to present or recommend to the board for a vote so if we need to clean up language as far as that goes I would support that um and very much um in line with what Miss Melton said we do have a lot of Po policies already in place that address all of these
116issues so it may come up in that committee that we need a policy specific for this that it's not addressed in other policies or it may be that we're revising and adding to current policy um we'll leave that up that work up to that advisory committee but um yeah as far as this statement goes if there's any other dialogue you guys want to have before I ask for a motion now would be the time for that I have a question as we're as we're sitting here discussing these two we have two different versions um which I guess which one are we focused on which one are is are F I mean they're not too different the language the words are a little different but so one of them I guess is just an updated recently
117given some attorney updates so is that the one that we're focused on part of the I mean it's up to us what what do we think do we want to just focus on that copy that's what I've been looking I think we could we I move that we uh now consider the updated version can we discuss the language that we just talked about speaking the policy language yeah yeah yep he's just ask right moving that we consider this update so we discuss yeah if I can just add so that people know what we're talking about on the 27th um we crafted a draft draft of what a policy excuse me what a statement could look like and how we left the meeting was to want because we understood that it was a first draft um
118to send it through the lens of um Communications for clarity syntax you know all of those kind of um editing kind of things and then also ask um our immigration attorney to also review it the cleaned up version of what this meant and the recommendations around um impact for the district and other things to kind of consider and so that's what the white copy is the cleaned up edited version from the 27th and the orange copy is the attorney's version with um some legal ease or through the lens of of the law so to speak if that helps so Richard I I think this is fine I think um trusty Williamson is moving that we just focus on this orange copy so do I have a second for that all in favor say I I
119any opposed okay so let's just look at this newly revised addition any discussion regarding that yes to the point brought up I think can I be heard um to the point brought up on that second to last paragraph that reads G grps will uphold this commitment etc etc um I'll read the sentence out if that's okay we'll hold this commitment by establishing an advisory committee to review refine and update policies and resources um I think after before the word update we should add the word recommend and then have it say recommend policies excuse me update excuse me recommend updates to policies and resources that way it's clear it's not in on there's no ambiguity around the fact that this advisory is making recommendations for the board to consider that's point of clarity I just want
120to make sure who's thinking are you taking okay thank you I just want to make sure that somebody's capturing and I need to reiterate thank you thanks you said and recommend updates to palac and resources cor yes anything else I'm still wondering about the paragraph above that um I again I maybe it's appropriate I guess I'm asking do you think it's appropriate for our Advisory Group to review and then recommend the procedures or you maybe not the procedures isn't the right word but the policy to dictate where people go and we leave this in for now I think if you if you're speaking to your idea of having them go to Security First all the other policies we can't make a statement that says something that isn't happening like we can't say this is what
121is going to happen when we already have gone through trainings I do think that it's possible for that to come up in that committee I also think it would take talking with Dr Roby and her staff about what are the implic implications of that is it even possible like how would that look um because ultimately they would be the how um of that so I just also want to clarify so with the work of the yet to be fully formed advisory committee one of the things that we are trying to collect are um as Miss mton referred to some of our kind of current policies that address and I'm saying address kind of visitors so that we can see where are there holes or where there needs to be some refinement of certain things and
122and provide Clarity over it and so what this Advisory Group is is a very kind of a the scope is just around um looking at systems excuse me at current policies if there things that are not as clear to make sure that we're reporting some of those those items based on the desire and will of um what has been shared and then that group will come forward or those recommendations will come forward for the board to make a decision voting up or voting down um what's been recommended and so being even clear being very clear to members of the advisory committee they're making recommendations on current policies we're not asking them necessarily to create policies um but to look at our current policies and things that making sure that it is in alignment with our
123handbook and procedures and processes as well as what we currently currently have if that makes sense if there's a hole they might point out if there's a hole or something they might point out a something needs to be yes that's how I've understood what this group desired this this group desired because we also we also don't want to limit it to immigrants if needed right which is why as we were talking in conversation um specifically resources for marginalized groups because also keeping in mind there's six of you know six of one half a dozen of another it's like if being clear on what you're looking for but then not so narrow in scope that we creating policies or statements for every possible scenario and to the point of even prior to where we are nationally
124and with all the the changes that have taken place um referring to policies on how visitors are brought into our buildings that predated some of the things that have taken place in 2025 and so I think um it's important that when you look at policies it has to be um in a place where it can adjust for current conditions but also understanding that conditions will change and there will be opportunity to adjust for new current conditions it won't so not to be so narrow but then to also offer flexibility and that's how as an example we got to marginalized groups if that makes sense okay um I will share briefly um that um being in um DC with these other districts they it was uplifted that the work that the district has been doing has
125been um guiding the work of other districts and that they are really um looking to the leadership that has taken place at um grps to help um advise their own policies and work that they're doing so I wanted to share that with you all anything else in regards to this okay is there a motion to approve approve the statement of commitment to support our immigrant families given the changes in the second to last paragraph I move seconded okay all in favor say I I I any oppose same sign I okay motion carries moving forward excuse me I have to find my way consent agenda group grouping is there a motion to approve the consent agenda so moved report all in favor I any opposed all right motion carries and moving on to board president announcements
126that's Me Maybe sorry okay so on the topic of our advisory committee um I I um not sure if all of you have heard through the gra Vine but I did appoint VP Wade to be the chairperson for that committee and I also appointed trustee Davis and trusty Moreno to be on that committee um Dr Roby is working on uh appointing people from cabinet to be on that committee they are working on Gathering a couple building leaders and then also um Community Partners so we are close to having that finalized and then we will work with Julie Julie will help us figure out a time where we can get all of these people together so sooner the sooner the better I know we have a lot of work that we are anxious to get started
127so um March 4th is a Tuesday we are going to have our first coffee with the board of the year um that evening from 5:30 to 7:30 I have trusty Moreno trusty Wade um myself and Sarah thank you trusty Melton are going to be there we are working on more of a casual place for that so we know it will be on the southwest side um and Luke is working on a couple of places I pointed out we we're waiting to hear back but we should know shortly I wanted to announce it tonight but um unfortunately that wasn't the case but we will get it out in social media and on the website as soon as maybe as soon as tomorrow so um but that will be from 5:30 to 7:30 on March 4th um
128and then just a reminder to my colleagues to fill out the survey and communication styles for Deborah Key's right for our Retreat I'm excited for that work I think it's needed and uh just excited to know each of you a little bit better and to build this team and also a reminder to take the online trainings with masb if you haven't yet um lots of good information in those so helps us just do our work even better if you can get those under your belt and that's it for me um public comment there any other comment cards Julie are we good okay okay we have John Vanden huil rior to do you want to read into the um as a matter of process um truste Rodriguez oh sorry I apologize feel like we skipped that
129the first time didn't we yeah I've been just kind of given the basics all right so this is the second portion of our public comment section um individuals must completely fill out the front of the card indicate the specific business on which they no that is during public comment individuals will be invited one at a time to the podium to address the board before beginning your comment please State your full name at that time we'll start the timer allowing each individual 3 minutes to make their comment uh please take note of the timer um behind uh vpa Wade um board members do not respond to comment concerns will be brought to the attention of appropriate staff we value your input and thank you for sharing with us and thank you trusty Rodriguez and also can
130I get a motion to extend the meeting since we are up against that 9:30 Mark motion to extend the meeting pass 9:30 Mark support Second all in favor I any opposed okay John Bon huil followed by Venita Morgan Smith dear board members of the educa or members of the Board of Education and Dr Roby my name is John vanen hoval and I'm a teacher at City High Middle School I'm coming to you today to appeal on behalf of myself and my colleague in the district about specifically the status of our pay currently we and grps are one of if not the lowest paying District in the Grand Rapids area and with that one of the lowest paid districts in the state all other school districts around us are paid at least 10% more than we
131than we are at the lowest levels and up to 40% more at the top levels of the pay scale for example I make experience and education at Forest Hills earns $49,500 or 11% more than I do teachers often times do not go into the profession for the money but many are leaving the district and the profession overall because we simply cannot live on the amount of money that we earn and teachers at the top level that are teaching with 20 years of experience Masters plus 30 credits make $85,000 per year as opposed to that $94,000 at Forest Hills so it's another 10% difference and the Gap is pretty much across the board we as mentioned before have seen a vast number of vacant positions and teachers who are planning to quit or move districts at
132the end of the year and the primary driver of this movement is because we're simply paid less than other districts around us if grps truly wants to reimagine the district then we need to make steps to better serve our Scholars then we should be leading the region and salaries in order to attract the best professionals and to keep our best teachers around because ultimately what happens on a daily basis for our children is dependent upon the classroom teacher for teach if teachers are paid more for their work then they'll be able to focus more on their duty of educating our Scholars instead of worrying about if they have to get a second job to just to make ends meet having a higher salary signals an increase in respect for us so we are appreciated by
133our district and it'll be a lot easier to feel better about the work that we're doing every day we're living in a time of rising cost of living across the board and our salaries have not kept up at all we're being paid less money every single year because our salaries do not keep up with inflation I believe that grps should move to yearly steps instead of every 3 years in order to help with the changes and cost of living as well as be enthusiastic to work with our Union and making a contract that the educators are excited to sign on to teachers leaving uh preparation programs are looking at each and every school district pay scale when whenever they're graduating to see where should they work which schools respect them the most and so I
134believe that grps if they want to attract the best talent should be leading the region in salaries so that they're signaling to Future teachers we respect you and we want you here thank you it's my time Bita Morgan Smith followed by Jolene Andrews good evening board members my name is Venita Morgan Smith I am here tonight as a parent deeply concerned about the quality of meals provided in Grand Rapids Public Schools my daughter was recently served expired molded food at school because of this I had to arrange for a meal to be delivered to ensure she has something safe to eat instead of acknowledging or addressing the issue the schools response focused on why food um deliveries are not allowed completely disregarding the fact that the only reason the delivery was needed was the school's
135failure to provide a safe and edible meal in the first place Grand Rapids Public School students wellness policy 8453 states that the district must provide affordable nutritious and appealing meals that meet students Health needs federal laws including the Child Nutrition act and USDA guidelines reinforce this obligation serving expired or molded food is unacceptable a direct violation of these policies and a risk to Student Health this is not an isolated incident um student dissatisfaction with School meals has been well documented yet instead of addressing the issue the district is making it harder for families like my own to step in when the system fails them in Grand Rapids Public School if Grand Rapids Public School cannot guarantee that its meals are safe and nutritious families must have the right to intervene without unnecessary restrictions hunger is
136a a far greater disruption to learning than a student in picking up a meal from the office I urge the board to take immediate action number one investigate meal quality concerns to ensure um complex with District policy and federal food safety guidelines number two increase transparency in Mill oversight including clear reporting mechanisms for students and families ensure the students prioriti excuse me ensure that schools prioritize student well-being over RI rigid policies that limit access to Safe meals no parents should have to worry that their child is being served unsafe food at School Grand Rapids Public Schools must do better thank you Jolene Andrews followed by sine Turin [Music] good evening Jolene Andrews I teach at Southwest Elementary believe it or not the hardest part about making public comment at a board meeting is not public
137speaking but deciding which topic to select do I want to make public comment on the fact that all of the safety drills changed this fall yet School staff still haven't been properly changed trained so now not only am I not sure what to do during drills but my students also don't know God forbid there is a real life emergency and we're all confused us should I bring up yet again the fact that nothing is being done about student attendance after 101 days of school I still have only had one day where all of my students have been here all day and five days where all of my students have been present at some point during the day should I bring up how difficult it is to get paid for any additional work we do for
138elementary teachers to get paid for the 180 minutes promised to us by the contract we have a new procedure we now need to fill out a paper form then put that same information online and then upload a PDF of the paper form online we are not trained on the new procedure and most people in my building had their additional work form rejected at least once I guess I'll use the opportunity to discuss how the district continues continues to add insult to injury in terms of not giving its Educators a much needed raise instead of giving us a raise or even providing an offer above a 1.5% raise which doesn't even cover the increase in insurance cost the district is other ways to spend money most recently it's a way that I haven't seen approved by
139a purchasing agenda despite rumors of how costly the program will be we received an email last week asking us to take a survey survey as a new partnership with opportunity Thrive it told us that they wanted to develop more resilient Educators who can face the stress in education in healthier ways this is a program that provides Wellness coaches for educators who may be on the verge of burnout the coach would help Educators identify barriers let's save us all some time do you know what Educators need in order to not feel overwhelmed and burnt out more pay fewer students follow through from the district on attendance issues more adults in the school buildings and more planning time perhaps the planning time that was promised to us as the contract was signed two and a half years
140ago but has not been fulfilled and no progress has been made what is not helpful is being made to feel that it's your fault if you can't handle the horrendous working conditions of grps upon taking the survey you get results with scores and suggestions of how you can do more work work in this area again no changes from the district just how you as an educator can work even harder at your job it gives you tips like if you don't feel supported make sure to collaborate with others with what time if you're struggling with trusting your admin ask more questions we work in a district that where asking questions can lead to retaliation I don't want to sound like I'm not on board with mental health but when this many educators are this close to
141burnout this is no longer a tier three support something needs to change if you want to fight educator burnout pay us more give us planning time and take something off of our plates thank you good evening Dr Roby president Davis and trustees of the board my name is Salen Tron and I am a teacher of grand arpit monor High School every day I find myself asking my colleagues how I can support a scholar or how I can how how or help a scholar better than I already am every day I see Mr malero giving snacks that he has personally purchased out to Scholars every day I see Mr Brent giving engaging and relatable science instruction to these Scholars every day I see Mrs o providing dierentiated work for the scholars below at and above average
142in math class classes every day I see Mrs D young reflecting on her lessons what she did well what she could have done better how she could reach a scholar better every day I see Mr Matt sitting with a scholar to calm them as they are frustrated every day I see Miss Kate eat lunch with scolars so that they have a safe space to eat every month I see Mrs aard plan our monthly Grace meetings Grace for growth responsibility acceptance courtesy and empathy I then see her meet with each of the five Scholars that were awarded one of those characteristics for the previous month she takes a statement on what those characteristics mean to them and gather their photo she then takes these statements and photos and updates our hallway bulletin board to celebrate these
143Scholars mind you with no extra pay for any of that on top of her full-time teaching job every school day I'm typically the last car in the parking lot leaving after an 11-hour day every day I see these teachers faces after the scholar are gone that just sink a little bit I see them let go from hiding from the scholars everything they actually feel I see the hardships they face them putting their feelings worries and frustrations aside and put their best face on in front of the scholars I feel their sleepless nights wondering wondering how they're going to help that scholar at school who's afraid of ice wondering how they're going to get out of their classrooms fight or hide if the worst thing to imagine were to happen wondering how they paid their bills
144this month wondering if they'll make rent or they just need to move an hour away just to be able to afford to live instead wondering if they can afford that medical bill that will come after going to the hospital finding out that their call from school was actually pneumonia all of these come from just one school in the district 11 teachers I say this all to ask you what are these teachers worth to you are they worth are they worth the lowest pay in the county are they worth 21st place out of 21 districts in the county are they worth just $44,900 raise that was offered while your superintendent got a 3% raise do really believe deep down that that is all we are worth thank you brown followed by Francis Neville good afternoon um
145my name is Frederica Brown um Dr Roby Madame President and trustees board officers I stand here this evening to uplift some topics I first would like to draw attention to what I spoke about last month at the board meeting and that is antiblackness that is seeped into areas of our district that may not be seen by all but does exist in my experience I was acting as a parent organizer and not acting as a parent I could say that it still affected me just the same I would never want any parent no matter what race to feel as if they were not seen if they were not if they are overlooked discounted unheard misunderstood or misidentified it is my hope that the board considers adopting a parent Bill of Rights that is ratified and added
146to the grps scholar resource and responsibility guide this should be done to ensure that there is race equity and parent engagement and parent leadership in each and every building in our district no matter if it is in a primate zone or if it's a school of choice or Neighborhood Place based School creating a culture that is healthy and healing is needed now more than ever and students and families alike should feel that they are welcome and represented and have shared leadership and decision-making at their school secondly as we are all aware the executive there are executive mandates and orders that are threatening not only our immigration immigrant population but also threatens to abolish the history and oppression and struggles of black Americans things like book bands that prohibit Educators to teach discuss or acknowledge the
147400 plus years of Oppression that we face as the people is becoming ever more clear I ask the district what steps can be taken to make sure that our curriculum is culturally accurate based on truth and that there are policies put in place to ensure just that lastly with my here my time here today ID like to take this time to uplift some powerful black parent leaders and staff that have children in or work in the district Addy Conley Donley the power City High who helps other parents use their voice to speak out as well as her daughter Niki Karen Walton a strength-based um interventionist and pow at Al middle who makes a positive impact daily in the students lives Miss Christy Collins a kssn coord at Dickerson Elementary that goes over and Beyond to
148make sure that families have what they need to be successful and last but not least ID like to uplift the dean of students at Shamy Hills Where my Boys attend Miss Jessica who shows up and makes sure she's involved in parents and present every day I truly thank her for her dedication these are just a few of the many many parent leaders we have in the district who engage with parents staff and students and do and do it no matter what adversity or obstacle that has been set in front of them as a fellow parent I thank them as well as other Educators and staff in our district and I hope they know how much they are value seen and appreciate it thank you thank you Francis Neville um followed by Lenora picket a little
149bit short here uh good evening Dr Roby board members MERS and a special welcome to new members Eric Davis amber k Kilpatrick Elanor Marino and Richard Williamson my name is Francis Neville I'm a retired grps teacher during my retirement I completed my education specialist degree my thesis based on Michigan Common Core State Standards for three-year-olds and four-year-olds was published in October 2023 it has two copyrights and is being read internationally I have just completed a first draft for a teach manual I'm coming out of retirement and I've applied to local school districts including grps regarding my applications to grps I applied in October for a position at Harrison which is currently interim when the career's website changed the starting date changed to immediate I called Daisy Romo asking for clarification she indicated that the immediate
150starting date was incorrect and changed it to to be determined I made another applic in December for Aberdine which was closed without an interview even though I applied for the position on the same date as a posting no reason was given for my application being closed without an interview I was also interest interested in a more recent opening for a substitute principal position but was told by Daisy Romo that it was open for one person to apply who had been recommended by a person on the board she then asked me if I knew anyone on the board who would recommend me and no Dr Robbie that's not Roby that's not why I called your office that this suggests that JPS is still using the friends and family plan for hiring employees due to the lack
151of communication not only did I make calls to Daisy Romo but also Christy Atwood Matthew Beford and Chad neelson asking for clarification regarding the jobs to which I had applied in my conversation with Matthew he stated he would investigate why my abine application was closed without an interview I followed up with emails to Chad man Matthew thanking them for their time and a reminder as to why I called that was 3 weeks ago I still do not have an answer from Matthew due to the multiple conversations I had and the failure to communicate a clear message from the hiring team brings into question the Integrity of your hiring process for applicants waiting to fill over 100 open grps openings thank you for your time Lenora picket hello my name is Lenora picket Dr Roby and
152board members I come before you um with a complaint against Southwest Elementary School um over there it seems that um we do have a racial problem I um had an appointment with um the principal and then I also called um her boss um Miss um her boss over at the Board of Education went over there because it seems as though there are some parents that who um are not allowed to go past the office and when I went in in there I was one of those parents I am a volunteer I am also a pal over at muck Park and um my daughter works for the district and she's not allowed also to to go past the office and we were told that the students are afraid of us and is what the reason why
153we can't go past the office or parents can't go past the office and we have to make an appointment in order to go to the the classrooms this is what I was told um I believe that um the school has an open door policy and being a volunteer every school that have gone into I've always gone to the office signed in and told them while I was at the school and I've never had an issue with going into any of the schools as long as I've shown my badge and explained to them while I was there I my granddaughter is there we are involved parents I've always been an involved parent with my kids and also helped within the school districts whatever School my children were involved in I was involved with their classroom and
154helping them out my daughter has also been an involved parent with her child and she's not an ordinary parent her the um the principal had told my daughter that she is just an ordinary parent just like anybody else and she would not be allowed to go within the school and I feel like um I also have had several parents to tell me that they're that this is the same and theyve been treated the same now mind you on Friday day I went to pick up my granddaughter from the school and I was allowed to go into the school throughout the school but I being the person that I am I told him no I want to do the right thing because I want the school to do right by me I told him no that
155need to go in the office and sign her out um also um there were so many things my daughter was um was Ill well no she got injured at school and the school did not call me she was injured a couple different times she had a black eye the school did not call and let me know that she had gotten a black eye and I asked was this policy and they um said that no it wasn't this was not the first time that this happened so just letting you guys know thank you Miss picket thank you for the public comment um that concludes public comment for tonight uh superintendent comments um congratulations once again to our 20 25 MLK social justice Scholars um I always am excited to see young people Express themselves uh in
156various ways um through ART and through spoken word and through written language just to kind of um lift up the the work that we are trying to do and and how they imagine that Dr King's Legacy continues to have impact on us um in 2025 just you know when you do the parallels of what is taking place uh nearly 60 years ago and how far we have come as a nation but how far we have not come and I think it's really important to think about as we talk about equity and um and what how does that manifest itself and so I'm just always excited to have the the voices of our our young people um to talk about the world that they want and then how do we as adults ensure that we provide
157that space even when it feels uncomfortable um and many of the conversations have not felt comfortable but I do think that we are trying our very best in the conditions that we are in to do the right work not for statement not for resolution but because it is a moral imperative and I'm appreciative of that and I think it's important that we lift that up um even as we are navigating some some strange times in our community in in our our nation and the children are watching how we do this so um I appreciate that um just a reminder to our board that we do have our very first my first I'll say not our first um our um state of the school um address and that will take place at Ottawa Hills High School
158later this week we are predicting no snow cuz I've already heard that there's going to be snow but um just looking forward to kind of setting what the work is the work that we have to do and how we'll continue to do it together so um just lifting those two things up thank you all right board member comments I'm just going to move in the same order as we did prior and maybe this will be a something we establish this year we'll see so truste Moreno just want to uplift again uh the students who uh were acknowledged today uh if we can continue to uplift uh student voice and kind of figure out how to fold them in better uh into our work you know that that I think is to me is really really
159exciting uh I know uh trusty katrick and I are excited to go to the museum and check out some of uh the work that's posted there um that's going to be a really fun adventure so hopefully other folks can join us um I think uh wanting to continue to have uh my uh board member colleagues to continue to be bold uh during these hard times I've been really inspired by other leaders across our community uh across the country who have pushing against the grain uh and making decisions that I'm like oh yeah I I want us to continue to in that way uh so I'm grateful for each of y'all today to uh adopt um language of our commitment and our continued practice uh to engage Community Partners uh to to seek out things that
160are different or or push against that grain again um thanks chy Melton yeah I had the privilege of being at a superintendent conference this last month in which I got to hear Dr Roby speak with um some of our partners with plantar and they did such a great job and I was in the audience and heard a lot of accolades for the presentation and just kind of wanted to call that out um I just appreciate when our district can be um not just taking care of our own which we're doing and of course that's the most important piece but also sharing out how we do how we do that with others so it was exciting to hear that yeah thanks vriz no comment trusty Wade thank you uh for sticking with us um I want
161to shout out the nursing staff the work that they do is invaluable I remember being a parent um when my children were in elementary school and they say they don't feel good and I'm like go in there and see the nurse and yep and the nurse was like always on my side like no they're fine they can stay I just appreciate having those resources in the schools and um want to uplift the work that they've done and continue to do um and again congrat rulate the um contest winners and honorable mention students and all that participated I thinkk uh mostly um the teachers and staff who encouraged them to participate and push that initiative um thanking the stem Greenhouse students for showing up tonight that program is something that I've watched grow from um the
162very beginning and um the work that they do in our district to uh um break barriers around our black and brown students in science is amazing work is so important and um so I appreciate them coming out and just just telling us more about their program um and shout out to the Ottawa basketball team because I I I went to the football game football basketball game uh Friday and I have never rooted for Ottawa so hard because I am a polar bear and I just don't root for Ottawa but I was cheering and I was like I was all into the game and I was like dang I'm really sitting here you know excited about Ottawa winning a game and them boys play hard and they came out with a win so congratulations to them
163and their coaching staff and also the Hall of Fame inductees um that were inducted to the a the athletic sports Hall of Fame at Ottawa Hills that's it thank you trusty Williams no comment trusty Williamson no comment trusty Davis I just want to say thanks again for all of you choosing us menend your time here and speaking up and using your voice trusty killpatrick uh I want to Echo that no comment really just a lot of gratitude for the folks who show up to our our sessions who hold us accountable who ask hard questions who bring advocacy forward thank you okay and I have no additional comment tonight so meeting is adjourned