001Okay, it's 5:30. I will call the meeting to order and ask everyone to please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Give everyone a few more moments to review the consent agenda items in your packet. Whenever someone's ready, they can make a motion to approve the January 27th, 2025 regular board meeting agenda as presented. So moved. Support. Any conversation? All in favor, show of hands, please. Okay. Up first, we have a Huron Pines presentation. Hi everyone. Hi. I'm just going to get my presentation up. All right. Good evening. And thank you so much for the invitation to be here. I'm really happy to be here
002tonight. Uh my name's Amy Nowakowski. I'm the senior project manager at Huron Pines, right here out of our Alpena office. We also have an office in Gaylord. Um and a quick little background about myself. I grew up right here in Alpena, and I went to Alpena Public Schools. And I moved away for a long time. Uh lived in Alaska, Colorado, Wyoming, all over the place. And I'm really happy to be back here in my hometown. And I have two young children who also attend Alpena Public Schools. So, Huron Pines is a nonprofit conservation organization. And we've been established for over 50 years in Northeast Michigan. As you can see the map on the screen, those uh the dark green color is our traditional service area. So, we have a pretty large area that we cover.
003Um and I get asked this all the time. We're not a government agency, and we're not a regulatory agency, but we're a a nonprofit. Um so, we offer technical expertise in many topics. Um where we collaborate a lot with other organizations and uh municipalities and partners. And we really are experts at um identifying projects that meet multiple organizational goals, um securing funding, and managing projects that benefit both communities as well as our natural resources. So, the Alpena High School parking lot was identified as an excellent opportunity to manage stormwater, um which would protect water quality in our community. Uh, would also provide educational and hands-on opportunities for students and improve parking lot safety. As you can see from this photo, the parking lot is deteriorating and it's in pretty poor condition. So, a quick note
004about stormwater runoff. Um, traditionally stormwater is collected in what's termed gray infrastructure. So, as rain falls on the ground and snow melts on the ground, it'll flow over any impervious surface where water cannot soak into the ground, such as parking lots or sidewalks or turf grass. And that stormwater will pick up and carry anything on that impervious surface. So, road salt, um, we see a lot of that this time of year. Um, oil and grease sediment, the list goes on of potential pollutants that are on those surfaces, which can be carried directly into the stormwater system. It's working. I'll keep going. So, the the main point I want to make is that the stormwater, as it flows underground through the gray infrastructure, it does not get treated. It does not go to the wastewater treatment
005plant at all. It flows directly either into Lake Huron or into the Thunder Bay River. So, in 2022, here on Pines worked with the city of Alpena to make to come up with this map. And this is a map of the underground stormwater system. And the blue dots are manholes. And the light, kind of orangish dots, which may be hard to see, that are along Lake Huron as well as the Thunder Bay River, um, those are the stormwater outfalls. So, the point at which the stormwater exits the gray infrastructure system. And if you can see on here, and I can give you a copy of this, too. Um, there's a red box kind of in the left-hand corner, and that box is around the Alpena High School parking lot. So, any stormwater that is originated
006from the Alpena High School parking lot, it goes underground and it flows down 3rd Avenue and out to the Blair Street Pier. And you've probably all been to Blair Street Pier. I hope so, it's beautiful. But the reason the Blair Street Pier is there is it's actually um protecting that storm water outfall. And just to the south of that is where our public drinking water intake pipe is. And so when we talk about protecting uh water quality, um our drinking water system here in Alpena is one of those uh really important things to consider, as well as the public beaches surrounding all the storm water outfalls. So green storm water infrastructure, um it functions differently than gray infrastructure, of course. Um it basically acts to mimic nature. So it's meant to capture and filter storm
007water right at its source. So wherever rain falls on the ground or wherever snow is melting. Um and what it does is it um when it collects the water, it's not meant to hold water. It doesn't pond the water, provide flooding. Um it's meant to capture and treat that storm water runoff and it passes through the rain garden um ideally less than 24 hours. So for a couple of years now, Huron Pines has been meeting with Alpena Public School staff, as well as their engineers at IDI. Um and we've been talking about this project and the possibility of collaborating. Uh Alpena Public Schools has been wanting to replace the parking lot since it's deteriorating. Um and Huron Pines said, "Hey, if we can collaborate on this, we can help provide you funding to implement the
008project and also capture and treat naturally the storm water runoff and protect our water quality in our community." So we received a grant recently through the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation's Sustain Our Great Lakes Grant Program. And the Alpena High School parking lot is one project um within five projects across northeast Michigan. And so the amount of funding going to Alpena Public Schools for this project is $150,000. And we also have some funding from Walters Family Foundation um to provide match to the project. So if this project is approved, I see a lot of great opportunities for students. Of course, place-based stewardship education is on the rise. You know, getting the students outside, taking what they learn in the classroom and walking right outside their door and implementing, you know, steward the education that they
009learned in the classroom. So the current, I would say underground part of the rain garden and the parking lot itself has been engineered by IDI, but the surface of the potential rain garden has not been designed yet. So the students could really design that. They could choose the native plants. They could develop pathways through the garden. We've talked about fencing around it. And potentially developing some educational signage as well. And we've done a very similar project here in Hinesburg. We have staff that goes into the classroom and works with teachers and students and helps these projects, you know, become reality. And we've done a recent project with Aubrey Sims schools where they designed and implemented both a rain garden on their campus as well as a bioswale which functions very similarly as a rain garden
010and that one was on city property. So they presented to their city council and really were the drivers of this of this project and they also grew the native plants in their school greenhouse. So there's a lot of benefits if this project moves forward. Of course, the educational benefits to the students, hands-on learning and really creating a sense of place and a sense of belonging for students that go to AHS. Of course, the parking lot safety would be improved, flooding would be reduced. And as you know, the parking lot is not just serving the students, but it's a it's our community parking lot for any events that you might have at the high as well as the public pool. And when we work with our engineers and we develop grant proposals, we always have to
011calculate the volume of storm water runoff that would be captured by this rain garden project. And so this is a really big one. So it's estimated that 445,000 gallons of storm water would be captured annually at the parking lot. So all of that volume of water would be filtered naturally through the sediment and the rocks in the rain garden before it flows out into Lake Huron. Um so because of the size of the gallons of storm water that would be captured, it really would be a great example for other locations not only in the community, but across the region of Northeast Michigan. So potentially, you could have this gravel parking lot turned into a beautiful garden. And that's all I have today and I would be happy to take any questions that you might have.
012Is that the overflow lot we're looking at? Yes. That was one of my questions. The first photo you showed us of the parking lot, was that I can go back if you'd like. I was trying to picture where it was and So yeah, the main paved parking lot is to the left. And this picture is looking south. Kind of toward the intersection of third and Okay. That way. I wasn't orientated for that. I'm sorry. Yeah. So the question may be more for Dave than Amy. If we didn't do the rain garden, what's the alternative? Is that going to be paved or is that going to be dirt? How's it broken out? That is going to remain what it is right now. Gravel parking lot. But the remainder of the parking lot would be paved? Correct.
013Yeah. The current paved parking lot would be Okay. Uh wait wait a minute here. You said at the beginning you would do projects based on organizational goals. Are you referring to your organization? All the organizations we collaborate with. So in this example, the goal of APS was to replace the parking lot. And our goal is to find projects that are going to be done in the near future and implement green storm water infrastructure along with those and provide funding toward that effort for the project. Okay. If we go forward with this garden, who maintains it? That's a great question and I was hoping somebody would ask. So a lot of our past green storm water projects, well, they all have a maintenance plan and this one will too. So this could provide that long-term opportunity
014for students to maintain it and that's a critical part of the design. So you can design a rain garden that has very limited number of types of plants. It's easier to maintain. Um, so the maintenance will be a factor in how that final design goes and what the look of APS wants to wants to achieve. And also a part of this grant is developing Herm Piñons is developing a business sponsorship program. And so we're trying to find a way to have local landscapers come out to these projects like maybe once a year, you know, that the project hasn't been developed yet to provide that expertise and maintenance and landscaping. But usually once these projects are planted, it takes a couple of years for them for the plants to get established and then the maintenance is
015really low after that. Amy, do you have any pictures of other examples like that have completed the projects so we know what it would actually look like? Yeah, that's a great question, too. So Huron Pines just partnered with NOAA at the Great Lakes Maritime Heritage Center, the museum there. Um and we did a rain garden project with them cuz they're they were working on their outdoor infrastructure. Um So, same kind of thing. They had plans to to do some work and we helped provide funding to develop a rain garden. We had pose and students come and plant that rain garden. So, that one was just done, let me think, last year? Um so, the plants are still establishing right now, but it's right outside the museum on the walkway um between their parking lot and
016that the walking bridge to Rotary Island. What happens if we Go ahead, Sarah. There's also two more. There's one at the uh Duck Park, which is now Island Park, which is maintained by the Garden Club. Yep. And then there's one at the the skate park. Yes. Mhm. Thank you. Um what if we don't maintain it? What if we can't? Do we get in trouble for the uh I want to say loan, but that or for the uh the grant. Thank you. Yep. That's a great question, too. Um no. So, even without the plants, the rain garden would still function to capture and filter stormwater. So, it would still be meeting the grants' deliverables or the grants' goals. Um we want to have plants maintained and beautiful and make your campus, you know, um look nice.
017And they also provide that opportunity for students to care for for plants, maybe grow new plants um uh and provide the maintenance to kind of that, you know, hands-on learning, definitely. Um so, nothing bad would happen if the plants weren't maintained, but it would also be a goal of ours at Huron Pines to make sure um it's maintained for all time. Uh what native plants? What's on your list of plants? That's a great question, too. So, I'm not the plant expert at Huron Pines, but we have a whole staff um that is. So, we don't have a list, but we can um for this specific project, of course it depends on um all kinds of things, right? Soil, sun, that kind of stuff. Um but we have I can't remember the name of it right
018now, but we have a guidance document for native plants, not just for rain gardens, but for all different locations across northern Michigan. Um but that's one thing that Huron Pines staff could do is work with the teachers and students and come up with a list of plants. Cuz I wish you could have answered that a little better because what plants you would be promoting would make a big difference on the downstream side of this. Whether it gets designated wetlands or is as soon as one cattail shows up or one wild dwarf iris shows up. It's it's a wetland. So, it won't function as a wetland. Um I'm glad you asked that question cuz it's not meant to hold water. It's meant to have water pass through it. And the plants would be similar to this
019on this photo, you know, black-eyed Susans, um plants that don't want their feet wet like cattails. Um it's more plants that are found in um you know, sunny areas. And again, this one here is you can see trees and shade and different plants, but yeah, I can provide you a list too of other plants that we've planted in rain gardens. Um and it I liked I wanted to leave it flexible for this project cuz it is really up to what you want as a school board and as APS to determine what the rain garden looks like cuz in some cases you know it could be more of a native wildflower garden. Flower garden. In other cases it could be have have a more manicured look or a landscaped look. Do you know what the difference
020in height between the bottom of the rain garden and the outflow pipe is? I would have to look at the engineering plans so I don't know off the top of my head. So Simon, do you know? Yeah, the overflow Okay. No, that's And do you know the size of the parking lot right now? I I'm guessing it's a 4-acre parking lot. Is that Um the engineers calculated 2.2 but I didn't do the measurements so Okay, I'm I'm just going off what's in my head and I don't know what that specifically included. Don't we park there now? I mean it's overflow parking lot. We use it correct? Yeah, yeah obviously the majority parks the existing parking lot. I understand that but for any events it's still used. It's quite full. Uh Yeah, I don't know. I
021mean I guess that would be the other question is that we have a parking lot for the purpose of parking if we're going to put a rain garden and I'm not against that. I'm just asking questions here but if we're going to uh give up parking space for a rain garden are we shooting ourselves in the foot when we have a limited spot to begin with? to park? Ro- Romeo, if you want to talk, can you come up though? Yeah, the overflow has been used for years. Oh, okay. Just so you're on camera too. Thank you. Um well I just want to congratulate This is one of my She is one of our former students and one of my best runners for cross country. So uh and and I was out there with him when
022we first when we first looked at this so the overflow was used years and years ago. And the irony was that it was one of those places where nobody ever wanted to park. Uh same thing as years beyond that or even when we were larger, we'd park at the stadium. So, it was $10 less to park at the stadium and walk in cuz we filled all those parking lots. At this point, that area is not used uh I can't remember an event that we've had even with the dance studio when I was there. Uh when I drove by, I didn't see any of the overflow. Actually, I I I work with Jason during winter to plow it and and block back it in so that people don't park there. It's one of those areas we
023don't have great supervision uh with the cameras. And and it's and it's and it's typically uh they're spinning uh I've had it raked about four times by kids. The one time they dragged it, I said, "Nope, you're going to use a rake this time." I made them rake it by hand uh only because it just it's a it's it's it's not necessary. So, my hope was that that's that piece would be used because we don't need we don't need that overflow. Even for the greater greater good, we have our parking lot right now is probably at 75% on a good day uh with kids coming and going. I I had there's plenty of parking yet, and that's why we just don't need it. So, I would I would propose not to pave it only because
024I don't see it increasing and in the largest activities we have, I haven't seen it full. Thank you. Yeah. And and and and to prevent the traffic from coming in too because there was a gate there and then and then we have cars that sometimes think that you just come in the wrong way and then come in so we had to put we actually had to put barricades up at one point to stop kids from coming in that way because it was easier to go in off Bagley. So, to make that infrastructure stop would be would be a I I believe a positive influence for parking. Thanks. Question. Uh is this uh an action item tonight? Yes. As part of Part of the the It's Yeah. Okay. Do you have a number, Simon? From the
025out- from the drain to the outflow? Is that what you want? Well, just you know, is the outflow pipe sitting at the bottom of this rain garden, or what's the height between those two? Cuz you're saying it's not holding water, but if we're talking about a a 2-acre parking lot, 1 1 in of rain on that parking lot is uh 50,000 gallons of water 60,000 gallons of water. So, while they're looking it up for this project, for other projects we've installed, yeah, the stormwater pipe is at the bottom. So, if you get a severe storm and the rain garden fills up, it's able to drain. And again, therefore, it won't hold water and it won't function as a wetland or or hold cattails or any other type of wetland plants. Um so, we'll see what
026they say on the designs, though. Yeah, it's at the at the bottom. It's at the bottom. Like 616 the bottom of the rain garden is 616. Quick, I don't follow. 616 ft on the plan, so that's the bottom of the the out- the outflow. Parking lot is 621. It's about a 5-ft 5-ft difference from the parking lot to the outflow pipe. From the bottom of the rain garden. Thank you. Anything else? Thanks, Amy. Thank you so much. Thank you. We have Romeo coming up next for our H A H S good news presentation. It is a good picture though. I was going to say, did you have fun? It is a good picture, so I need to pull this over. Right here I have like 3,000 tabs open, so do not be shocked when you
027see that. So I pull it over here and then there we go. Get out of there. Here. Sorry guys, I didn't prep because I thought I was all ready to roll. And then I don't even know how I did that. You can drag that tab to the right. Yeah, that's what I was just trying to do is pull it out and close it, but there it is. Pull it in. Typically you just pull. I haven't used this one before here. It's not pulling in. Right there. There we go. Should pop in. Try Try dragging it. I'm dragging right. So like this. So far right. Hold it right there. No, I have nothing. Put it back over there. Yeah, that's good. Pop it out. Hit the area here. Hit it right there. You can come back
028next month. There it is. Nope. All right, so let's go into settings and see if I can do this. So grab that tab. Oh, I just pull it Pull it off right there. Look at that. There it is. Look at this tech department. I'm telling you. Good work, guys. There you go. You guys are it. It's always a slide. I have it set for the high school, so I don't have to drag and pull. Just cast. There's nothing worse than casting when you're doing that. And when you have 20 tabs open, you don't want the other 20 to show up. For sure. So, I want to thank you guys for having me here. I want to welcome Monica. And Sarah's not here, but I want to welcome you. And I'll keep this to you. I
029think Summer said 45 minutes? It was 20 on me. It was four or five. Four or five. Five. Okay. I saw the three. I said to Lisa, she says, "Good luck with that three people." So, anyhow, welcome. You know, this is I think this is a good idea. We used to come to the buildings. It was more difficult. I think this is a good idea. And to have us all come in and and do our piece to share what what is happening at our buildings. So, we call it the good news. So, you see our good news every time. So, what I want to do is I want to focus on what what I believe we're trying to achieve at the high school with staff and students. And the two pieces that we look at
030are the positive culture and positive climate. So, build a positive school climate, which is how they feel, and create a positive school culture. Uh one of the drives we're moving towards is how do you build a positive climate? So, what does it mean at Helping High School? So, when you look at this, you can see keywords as you read it. You can see safe, respected, supported, engaged, fostered, uh and in relationships, community, uh minimal disruptive behavior, trying to create a a place where kids feel kids and staff feel safe and comfortable. Uh when we look at the strategic plan and we look at all the work that was done here, you see where it's tied in with community, it's tied in with welcoming the all the different pillars that we that we identify. So, when
031we look at this, it's a piece that I find is very important. I think one of the things I talked today when I took the job was I wanted to bring up that positive climate. I wanted the students to feel like they really belonged. And when when basically I had to build my team because we had to pick new principals, it was it was do you have those same beliefs? Do you feel that the students need to feel like they belong and want to be part of it? Being visible, working with them, making sure that they feel they have a voice. One of the pieces that we worked through is looking at student staff voice. I pushed my first year and our admin team to really get student voice, to make sure that students felt
032that they could be part of the part of the solution. They could bring questions, didn't have to be afraid of to locate an adult to talk to. And and also to do that with staff. So, staff felt heard, valued, and respected. For me, that was that was trying to really be there with the students before, you know, being being in front of them, being visible, and fostering that environment where they feel like it's their it's their building. I tell students that all the time. This isn't my building. I'm here to help guide it. This is your building. You This is yours. You determine When you break something, it's yours you broke, not not mine. I just have to make sure I manage it. And And these are the pieces that that our team looked at
033doing with all the different pieces from school pride, which I'll show you pictures of, the belonging, like they want to be part of the change in climate. They want to be in that positive atmosphere. The teams that we've had we've had created since since I became principal was a student climate team. They started with promoting kindness, not only in the high school, but their their main goal is to do outreach within the elementary schools, too. Is we need to start before high school. Students need to feel that they they have a they have a say in in in it's important to be kind. Student council was another thing that we worked on on resurrecting last year. Our Our student council used to be present, and then it became more of a leadership. They helped with
034a lot of the positive activities in the school, but we also needed a student voice, a governance body. And so, we we elected a president. We had actually all student driven. Students at came forward and asked to have this done. And so they started all the pieces of it and put it in play and now we're in year three of that and I'm very proud of it because that team comes together every week and every other week to determine what are the what are the positive pieces we need to do, what do we need to bring forward, how do we hear students, what do we do to find avenues to make sure that they have a way to share ideas or thoughts that they have, any complaints, what can the what can we do to
035help? Doors always open in our our offices, our prin- my principals, myself. Kids come in and I'm going to show you an example of that, but the big thing is giving them a voice was important. We do it in athletics and extra extracurricular activities all the time with band, choir, maskers, all those different clubs and activities including sports that that help kids find pride in what they're doing. You see some pictures here. The the one on the top is is our elementary students at Wilson. You can see they went in and they did projects, arts and crafts before Christmas with them promoting kindness. And it was it's fun. They find it super rewarding. Our student council does at the bottom left you can see the student council doing a popcorn fundraiser. So all their money
036goes back to the students. The parking the parking spots that I fund go into their account which helped to provide opportunity for our students in some ways. So it's pretty awesome. They've done and this is this has been well received. I mean, smell of pop- Monica knows. The smell of popcorn through the school along with great lunches is unbelievable. On the top right you can see Izzy. She's the head of the climate team and she leads all the all the events that we do and and just outstanding young lady and just couldn't do it without her. She's going to be in her second year on the team and she's just a junior so we get another year with her. Last year she was brought on board as a as a 10th grader and was uh
037role model by all the peers she had to to say this is what I want to do. At the bottom you can see our staff. This was pre-Lions. This is a sad picture in in retrospect. However, it was our event to try to show support within the communities and they and and and idea of uh our team comes together. Our students feel Our teachers feel valued just like the students and and it's real. Uh here we have the senior sunset. So every year we try to do something new with our seniors. This was a sunset senior senior opportunity. We did it at uh at the Prescott Lighthouse. It's pretty awesome. Uh I lost a couple of them for a little while but I got them there for the final picture of the sunset. They took
038a wrong turn at the lighthouse, the wrong lighthouse. At the bottom we have our capstone events. That's uh activity night. Uh we do dodgeball, volleyball. Try to try to get the kids and parents united together to do our activities for our students. Again, highly invested highly involved. They love it. National Honor Society of course is a great opportunity. And at the bottom that's just our some athletics saying, "Hey, we're going to do our best costumes practice volleyball." It's a great opportunity just to get involved, show some spirit, and just just go that extra mile. Our spirit days are are widely I mean you see them on Facebook. Our kids they go outstanding costumes, outstanding outfits and really try to celebrate the opportunity. In the middle is our powder puff. That's how we open up homecoming
039week with activities. We do a volleyball tournament, a volleyball show, and a football activity. Uh it's a it's just a great opportunity for those two classes to come together to represent the starting of homecoming. Uh then our assemblies are are typically uh one of the highlights of the whole week of both homecoming winter fest. Our activities are are all week. The hall decorating, if you haven't been to the high school it's just as Serena shows our last judge. Uh we had an upset. We had the seniors lost. I they they probably It was not rigged. Uh we don't So, I I'm pushing them to do even a better this year, but it's just an opportunity for them to to know that being part of the the culture change is doing and being part of these
040activities because we all know that high school is fast and it's only a small section of our lives. And one of the things that I find is our dual enrollment students come back and they'll say in December, "God, I wish I was here for gosh." More than just one hour a day. And and they don't realize it till after they're gone because we all know that high school comes, college is here, our lives begin, and then all of a sudden we're like 57. Like right now. I think I'm like 21 like last week. But we are now 57. So, it just time flies like that. So, it's really important for them to get involved, be inspired, just be part of of a of a climate that's positive. And and do good things. You know, I
041I preach all the time, "Don't do something that's going to get me fired, please." Just because just because they're they're they're they're just they're excited. They're excited with times and end of the year is exciting. So, this is just one of the pieces that I think is really important to have a better culture. To get to that, you have to give them student voice. Ironically enough, last night or yesterday when I got home, I was finishing We're going through emails and I found this and I said, "Here's a great example of student voice." So, I deleted what I had and this student these students emailed me this email. And if this doesn't show student voice and student climate and culture, I don't know what does. He was in I agree with him, too. Yeah, it's
042it's unbelievable. I mean, but this is this wasn't solicited in any way. This was emailing me on a Sunday. And and that's what students do. They come into the office. Not just mine, they come into Mike's, they come into John's, they come into Eric's, they go into the counselors. They're going to adults, they're going into classrooms. They are not afraid to engage with adults, and that's the positive climate that we want. If we want culture to increase, if we want students to to realize they want better and they want more, we have to give them that opportunity. School culture is about about the positive cultures, not only having a positive climate, but if we want to increase rigor, we want to increase the value we want students to do, we got to give them a
043voice, we got to give staff a voice, and we need to be able to do this. And and one of the drives that we have is to make students successful. That's it. We need to put We need to put the best in front of them, and I and I believe every day we try to do that. And and and I want to keep kids at school as long as I can, uh you know, I always tell kids you don't have to take four or more courses, you can take two. We have we have everything we can give to you that you you can do at the high school. And I think as as we move forward with with uh the strategic plan, all the five pillars encapsulate what I'm talking about. They they they grab
044it and say, "This is the culture we're trying to do. We need to get families involved. We've got to talk to our personnel. We've got to do the whole child." You know, with our PSTs, which are problem-solving teams, we're diving deeper into every piece of data that we can to find out what we can do to make every student better and the high school better. So, I believe in this that that with a strategic plan, our climate and culture are going to build. What we're doing at the high school right right now, led by our instructional coaches, and it's it's ironic because uh I collaborate with uh Petoskey, Gaylord, and Cadillac every other week with the principals. And and so I I just filed away in my notes for our next meeting was uh Deidra
045from Petoskey says, "Just tell me how you got those instructional coaches. I need them. How did you do it?" So, I called Matt, and said, "Matt, where did that come from?" We know the funding. What is it? Just came from last year. Yep. No, 30 31. Oh, you got to go back in time. Back in time. And they became creative to find us this piece. And our instructional coaches, along with the principals at the high school and the junior high, are working on team time. That's a great That's probably the best thing we've had where our teachers are coming together on a regular basis led with direct guidance on on how we're moving forward. You can see one of the things I'm really excited about next year is we came up with a guiding guiding
046practice grading practices this year where they're truly an accurate reflection of the knowledge. It's not just a grade. The grade really has value and it has meaning. And we need to make sure that all of our teachers are doing that and we're setting up consistent grading basis and grade grading practices. And the next steps are common assessments and building building-wide retest policies for 25-26. So, excited about this work. Working with Matt and and Stephanie on totally different professional development that's going to do this. And and and we just have to move forward and I'm excited about this work. I really am. One one that, you know, when I leave, I I can know that these pieces are in place. So, that we're working on a program just like the strategic plan. These are part of
047that and it's necessary for us to be great. Lastly, student recognition. We all know that you see the Wildcat Way, you see the student of the week and and Rotary students one that we we started up again this year thanks to Rotary. Dave normally gets to recognize our students when they come with their parents. It's a great opportunity to recognize students that Rotary that we choose. But, this year, which what I was really excited about, our climate team, our MTSS team, worked to say, "What are we going to do to make kids try even harder?" We used to have huge assemblies and recognize students and it just went fell on deaf ears. This is was our opportunity this semester for each teacher to award three achievement awards that would too fall on the grade on
048the report cards, but to do the presentations in front of their peers. So, that top left one right there, every teacher chose three kids per grade and gave them an award with their signature on it that needed to go home, and those will be on the graduation tables. And this will push kids to want to strive to do better. We did it in front of their peers. They explained why they got the awards to the kids in front of their peers, and and it was received wonderfully. I tried to get every picture on Facebook parents could see it, but also just so that they could feel like I did do better. I did more. And what are you going to do next semester to maybe get awarded that, too. And that's what we need to
049do. We need to strive to not only be on the student of the week, the Wildcat Way, but but what can you do to make your imprint at Open High School? And that's what culture and raising culture will do for us. So, I'm excited about that, and and it was well received, and and so that is my good news. Any questions? Good. I I would just like to say I'm very lucky that I'm there every day and I get to see this, and I think you are doing a phenomenal job. Aw, thanks, man. You know, you're very open throughout the whole day. Students can talk to you whenever, and I I know you enjoy what you're doing, and we're lucky to have you. Thank you so much. Thanks. And it does make a difference. You
050know, when you go to work and you enjoy what you're doing, it really does. And and kids do I mean, it's infectious. You go into a building into an elementary building, junior high, or the high school, it's infectious. I you know, I say when they when people come in and have lunch with us, I said, just come out you know, we we have we call principals' corner where we eat lunch. So, feel free to come in. Kids just come up, you know, and and people come up Well, you're on a duty-free lunch. There's no duty duty-free lunch here. This is supervision. We're in the hallways, so kids can come up to us. And it is cool. So, thanks. And I appreciate And I encourage you all to come to lunch. There is no better food,
051seriously. Our school lunch is phenomenal. And the salad bars rocks. Yeah. So, anyhow, thank you for having me. Thanks for letting me do this. Hope I didn't run over the 3 minutes. Hang in. Yes, sir. One one more question. Um so, uh this week we were sent some information on uh cell phone policies in Broward County. Um and which was kind of interesting. Um they were talking about a real cell phone ban and how it's improved the student culture and climate. And I'm wondering, with the cell phone restrictions that we currently have in place, uh have you Do you feel like that has been a positive uh influence on the climate and the culture? And do you think it'd be worth going further with those sorts of things? I think you're 100% right. And and
052to be honest, I was very afraid to do the cell phone policy cuz I didn't know how we were going to be able to enforce it. And all that worry was for naught. It with with a great how we how we rolled it out was perfect. The families, uh you know, they're a little little unsettled cuz they want their student to have that phone. And then we started with putting them in the backpacks, which was more difficult to monitor and police because it's in the pocket. It's like I had uh Jesse Patterson who moved to uh to Where is he left? Penn State. This kid. I tease and she knows. Penn State. And uh and and like it's in the pocket. So, are you staring at the pocket or you looking there? So, out of
053sight, out of mind. All times during class. There's no reason to pull it out and look at it for for that. But it has increased our engagement, I would say threefold. And our culture. Because guess what we're not having to deal with now. You know how many problems happen because of this? It it How much How much lack of engagement there is? I mean, I know that most of us have to I mean, we have to look at meetings and we have stuff popping up and we have to try to do that. But to put that phone down and not worry about it. And the reason we thought the bag was so they don't feel the vibrate cuz then they automatically get this jitter that they've got to look at it. And and the watches.
054You know, we just finished final exams. We had I had one lose her phone during final exams. And and the mom was angry. I explained to her. I said, "We have no way to know whether she cheated. We have no way to know. It's We don't have to give warnings because it was warned warned before you walked in. Now, the first day we covered all this, and they have been very receptive. Kids that don't want to turn their phone in, they go home. And and we give the parent the phone and say, "Two choices. They can come turn it in to restorative center, or they keep it out of sight, which is probably not going to happen, or you just keep the phone home." And we're pretty stringent upon that. It's worked, and we do
055get some that won't turn it over. They just It's It's a one It's not an argument. So, it's really been It's really been beneficial. Uh I have read a lot on the bans, and and the policing of it would be tough. I think we've done a good job of finding that balance right now. I mean, I'm comfortable with it. I think our our our engagement's increased, and that's and that's the most. And and the the social media piece is out of play during the day. You don't have that. Uh that's nice. And they can't take it to the bathroom with them they leave. So, if they go to the restroom, you got to put it there. Uh earbuds are the same thing. If you got earbuds in, uh no earbuds. So, like I'll walk by
056class, and I'll see it. I'll just come up and say, "Uh can I have your earbuds?" I make a point of the case. Seriously, I had one day I I touched a night you know, This is This is not a good idea. So, I took the earbuds. I NEVER THOUGHT OF TAKING THE PHONE BECAUSE REALLY THE EARBUDS ARE NOTHING without the phone. So, like Eric says to me, "You got to take the phone, too, Romeo. You can't just take the earbuds." And so, then I realized that. But, it was enough. I I very seldom have I get a kid say no to me, but I know the teachers do. And then And that becomes a power struggle, and it ends, and they just call for admin, come get the Or security, come get the kid
057or the phone. And then we And then it ends. And they They've been really good conversations, actually. And with the parents, it's just reeducating. They think they got to have that. I had a kid using the phone today. They just have to remember the number. Think about That's the biggest thing is remembering the number. Cool. So, thanks for asking. Excellent. Thank you very much. Very helpful. Anybody else? I could stay here with you all day. you guys. I think we've passed our four or five minutes. Thanks, guys. I appreciate it. Thanks, Romeo. Oh, you're welcome. Thank you for the kind words, too. Romeo. Yes. Goodrich has to be looking at the instructional calendar and instructional approaches at Goodrich. At Goodrich, but but I had a written note. 31 and we'll see how we develop. And
058it all comes out here. 8:30 Which is which is an awesome opportunity. Just because just because the the instructional coaches are Thanks Romeo. Ma'am. Uh we have reached the point in our agenda that citizens or delegations may address the Board of Education. According to Board Policy 0167.3, public participation at Board meetings, individuals addressing the Board are asked to state their name, address, and or group affiliation, shall direct all comments to the Board, not staff or other participants, shall not make personal attacks against a school board member or school district employee by name, shall be limited to 3 minutes duration, shall not speak more than once on the same topic unless all others who wish to speak on that topic have been heard. The portion of this meeting shall be limited to 30 minutes, but the
059time frame will be extended if necessary so that no one's rights to address the Board will be denied. Okay, come on up. Do you have a Do you have a remote for the timer? If not, I'll use my phone. I Goodrich Paving, uh representing Goodrich Paving. Uh my address is 8215 US 23 South, Austin. Uh just here to talk about the parking lot bid that you you have received. And I got some paperwork here. Uh I was not a low bid on the parking lot. I was within a half of a percent, and your bid documents leave that open for you to choose whoever you would like for doing the parking lot. So, I guess I'm just here as a sales pitch for myself anyway that we're local and we're here and we've worked with
060you I don't even know how many times over the years doing a lot of pavement for you and we just hope you take that into consideration. Thanks. We don't really respond during public comment, but thank you. Thanks, Bruce. Anyone else? Okay, well, we'll have another opportunity later on if anyone else wants to come up later. We'll keep moving on to our action items. We have a handful of consent agenda items in front of you. We need a motion to approve the consent agenda items as presented. December 9th revised workshop meet meeting minutes, December 16th revised regular meeting agenda, approval of the December 16th regular meeting minutes, December 16th closed meeting minutes, December 23rd special meeting minutes, and the January 13th monthly workshop minutes. I move to accept the or approve the consent agenda items. I
061would support it. Okay, any further conversation? Okay, all in favor show of hands, please. Thank you. Okay, up on our additional business requiring board action are the Wildcourt properties. Paper in our packet, same one that we were given from the workshop. Everything kind of spelled out in that lengthy uh the motion which has all the details. Do we want to hear from Mary again on this or anything new? No. Okay. Okay, if not, we would need to have a motion to approve the sale of Wildcat Wildcat Court properties as follows. Would Would anyone like me to read the entire section? It states the the lots, one of them being the price of 25,000 and then the other four lots at the 28,000 and then the building restrictions as follows. Single-family stick-built homes, two story not
062to exceed two stories, single-family permanent real modular real property modular, the private garage, three-car garage maximum if the slot permits, any style of dwelling. Lots of details on that one. Taking care of your yard yard in terms of siding and mobile manufactured homes are not allowed. It's all spelled out there. When would these potentially be hitting the market? Okay. ASAP. So someone quits getting phone calls? Uh yeah. Mary Froste would be handling the listings. And forgive me, we don't have the map in front of us, but just to verify we are maintaining the lots along with Thunder Bay Junior High, correct? Yes. Okay. I think keeping those, yes. I would offer the motion to approve the sale of Wildcat property Wildcat Court properties as stated with the restrictions. I'll second that. Any further conversation? Okay.
063All in favor, show of hands, please. Are you a no or a yes abstaining? No, and one no. Well, no, Monica's a no. Okay, thank you. Okay. Up next we have our summer phase 2B bids. The first one was the consideration of 031A earthwork and utilities. This was to award the 031A alternate one and alternate three earthwork and utilities contract for the amount of 1.38452 Champagne and Marks for the work needed at Alpena High School as part of the safe dry and warm on. I have a question, but do I have to wait till discussion? So, my question stems on this one from the Champagne and Marks which actually I looked up. They look like a wonderful company, however, they were sold in December. And so, I was wondering if we did background on the
064company that purchased them. Is that If that's right, right and if I'm wrong, please correct me. I'm Tony Nathaniel with the Clark Construction Company. In terms of them being sold, I'm I don't know anything about them being sold to be honest with you. We post bid them or work with them currently at West Branch Schools doing an excellent job for us. So, they they went through our pre-qualification process and we post bid them. They had a complete scope and they're good good contractor to work with. But, I think Eric's question is is the same people that you're working with now going to be the Yes. Okay. Yep. Yep, same project manager, superintendent that we proposed that will be part of our project. Okay. Thank you. Yep. Um which uh which of these three is the
065one with the uh grant, rain garden grant? I don't see it anywhere. So, the rain garden grant, that'll be alternate number three. So, Champagne and Marks, they included $100,000 um for alternate three. And Hunt Brothers had 1,600 for some little bit of concrete work. I would have a little reservation uh voting on the rain garden since we just received really bulk of the information on that tonight. Personally, I don't know how I feel about that. I would have to agree, too. I'd kind of like a blueprint or a map exactly how this is going to be, where it's going to be. A little more information. Yeah, I I mean, it's been a conversation two or three years in the works, so we've had conversations over that time of what it would look like. But Dave,
066I've been here 2 years and I I don't recall many of those conversations. Um so, I mean, maybe they're happening, but this is the first that I've really seen the nuts and bolts of it. Yeah. Okay. I would offer a motion if uh it wouldn't mess things up too badly to uh to award the 031A and the alternate number one with the uh exclusion of any any decision on uh the alternate number three if that would be possible. I mean, if this needs to forward, just uh can talk about this grant perhaps at another meeting or or even right after, but just I'd like to see if we could separate that from the discussion of the rest of the work. Does that sound reasonable? Do you have any thoughts on how it that would work?
067Nope, and that's why we bid it this way to keep those numbers separate, so I don't have any issue with that. Okay, well, that would be my motion then to support that. Okay, so you want to uh motion to award the 031A alternate one and just a mail alternate three. Is that Is that Right, to exclude alternate three, the rain garden, from the from the current vote. Yep. Okay. Did you get that, Summer? The motion? Okay. Eric Lawson, Eric Hanson, you had supported that, correct? Okay. Okay. Any further conversation? Okay. If not, uh Let's do a roll call on this one, please. I do have one thing. How long have we kicked this can down the road about the rain garden? When do we need to have a decision on the rain garden? I'm going
068to ask Clark. Uh in terms of the project, it's, you know, the material associated with that phase is not a long lead time, so as we get closer to summer, you know, it will become an issue, but right now you have time to look into it, make a decision. Okay. Thank you. Yep. Okay. Sorry. Sorry, Sarah, for cutting you off. Okay, sorry. Any further conversation? Okay. A roll call, please. Uh member Fritz. Nay. Member Lawson. Aye. Um Member Hanson. Aye. Member Dezinski. Aye. Member MacArthur. Aye. Member Minehart. Aye. Okay, that one will pass forward. Thank you. Up next would be the asphalt bid but uh the Payne and Dolan and then the one that Bruce mentioned. Currently it's stated it's a motion to award the 032A asphalt work contract in the amount of 681,400 to
069Payne and Dolan for the work needed at Olympia High School as part of the safe, dry, and warm bond. Nathan? Was it Nathan? Uh Tony. Tony, I'm sorry. Uh what were the numbers on the asphalt? Cuz right now I have is the final. And you had I seen your you had the tab sheet did Yes. Yep. So um base bid uh Payne Payne and Dolan was 681,400 and Goodrich base bid was 730 713,950. Um Bruce did provide alternate. And the alternate was approved by IDI, the engineers, and that got Bruce down to 685,000. So he was Bruce was still 3,600 high. I'd like to make a motion. I have a question. So is this a firm cost on the asphalt with no adjustment for the fluctuation of the asphalt binder because it is a petroleum
070product and this is going to be like 6 months down the road before we Do you see what I'm saying? I do not. Okay, so asphalt uses petroleum or oil base thing and that that oil fluct the cost fluctuates. What I want to know is is this a firm bid It's a firm bid. So this if it is any fluctuation in the cost of the of the oil for the asphalt binder. Correct. No, they're they're they're at this number. Yep. Okay. So the firm bid is 685 for Goodrich. Yep, the firm um No, for um Painton. Painton, yes. Painton 681. Okay, so 713. 950 for Goodrich. 950 but he said something about that 685. Yes, so Bruce offered at bid time an alternate to use a different asphalt product, different mix, um which brought his
071value down to 685,000. What is the I'm sorry, go ahead. What is the quality of that mix then compared to what the more expensive one would be? Bruce, do you want to speak to that? I know the engineers did approve it with the IDI. Um I don't know if there's any more to say on that, Bruce, or it's been a product that's been used before. Just for an example, it's the same mix we used at the main road was paved in 1990-something. Tony, this uh piece of paper that Did you get this one that Bruce gave us? I did not get that one. Is this uh So this is included in the the bid lighting or the bid request? Cuz you That's your name on it, right, Tony? That's correct, yep. Okay. So basically just
072so everyone uh from the community can understand here, the highlighted section says the school district board of education reserves the right to accept or reject any and all bids either in whole or in part, to waive any informalities or irregularities therein, or to award the contract to other than the bidder submitting the best financial bid low bidder in its own absolute discretion. So that all all bidders received this, correct? That's correct, yep. Okay. So we're looking at uh Goodrich is within a small margin, $5,000. Correct, yep. And we we did post bid, Bruce. We have no issues going with him as well. Pain and Doyle, there was no reason to disqualify him. He was a low bid, so but we would support going with Goodrich as well. You know, I I I I I have
073nothing against the the other company, Pain and Doyle, but I know Goodrich has provided exceptional work for the district in the past. It's a local business. Um you know, I personally would support that move myself. Um Are we able to entertain a motion for that, or does that we just keep talking for a second? Sure, sure, absolutely. I mean, cuz I I think we all probably feel the same way. Like, we really respect Goodrich and Bruce, and probably nothing would make all of us happier than to support Goodrich and his family. I think my one concern um is what kind of precedent we're setting when we kind of start handpicking our um our bids based on who our friends are and who we like when um like if the tables were turned, you know, if
074like the MacArthur family was the lowest bidder and we picked another bidder because we like them better. I just worry like about what kind of precedent we're setting, and I don't know Mary, I know you had said at the workshop um that with you thought legally this wasn't okay. I guess I'm a little confused because of the paperwork that Bruce gave us, it makes it sound like it would be okay. I just if you have any more information on that about what happens like if we kind of start handpicking our companies based on loyalty versus bidding amounts. So, your bid process is supposed to be fair and equitable, which means that everybody has the information that they need to apply for the bid. Everything that they need is put out on the table in the
075RFP. They're able to ask questions. They're able to Those things are then added as information to the other bidders so that everyone is on a fair playing field. Ethics are applied, which means the bidders cannot offer gifts or any kickbacks to the district or anything like that. It's supposed to be transparent, completely transparent to the public. You are supposed to gear this so that the community that you work for that has gifted us with this money receives the very best value for their project to the qualified bidder. So, if they're both qualified for it, you're supposed to go for the best value. And I appreciate Bruce. I mean, I know that he's done a lot of things for the district. I get that. I also know that there will be other jobs that come along,
076but I think it's very important to maintain our ethics and maintain a fair and equitable bid process. I don't see where where we're not being fair or ethical here. It's not like we're in a back room saying I mean, this is up front and above board. that we're making a decision based on a contractor coming and speaking to us tonight. No, I'm not making a decision because Bruce stood here for a minute. Because we we've made those decisions before. Um and when we've chosen to not go with a low bidder or someone along those lines, there's been a reason why based on their performance or our satisfaction to those sorts of degrees. Not too long ago, we didn't get any bids and we needed to uh expand our nets of where we're bringing potential contractors
077in from. Um if the word on the street is they're just going to go local, that, you know, that severely reduces the potential of people that would um bid on these projects. We've gone through this just in my short time here where we had no bidders and we had to rebid and you know what happens when you have to rebid, the price goes up because they know you haven't gotten any bids. So, we want to cast a wide net. And I would say, "No, we don't want to." Yes, Bruce, we are eternally grateful. I met you on Sunday at Besser and thank you for doing that work and all of that. That's not what this is about. It is about can districts, when they see an APS bid come on the the system, can they
078trust that it's going to be a fair and ethical and transparent process? We're we're not talking about a huge dollar. What did Did you say, Tony? Was it half a percent? Yep, it was a $3,600. But I mean in the overall, I didn't do the numbers, but it's Yeah, pretty Yeah, pretty close. Yeah. percent. So, that's the difference between the two bids now. Correct. Yep. So, Tony, did the other vendors have the opportunity to adjust their bids with the next? They They did not. No. Yeah, it was it was done prior. Yep. Yep. Bruce had his in his bid submission. Correct. Yeah. For an alternative, you mean? Right. I I I know it may be a small amount, but it's still money that we've been entrusted with to do the best and the most equitable
079and the most equal to to the district. I mean, $3,000 is $3,000. Well, I mean, if we're going to say that, the argument can be the same that that money then stays in the community for local employees. Uh you know, and I understand and first of all, I I take a little bit of offense to the insinuation that we're we're biased or that we're we're um we're bribed, if you will. I have taken nothing from Gooderich Trucking getting this or Gooderich asphalt getting the contract. Um and to Dave, to your mention, we've seen this both ways. We have. If you also remember the BC Pizza issue, which was the lowest bidder and we excluded JJ's, which has provided excellent service to the district because it was the lowest bidder and that fell on the face
080and they had to come in and save us. So, from an administrative purpose, knowing that there's a business that has provided a history of quality work and can follow through, does have weight. And so, we know without a doubt that Gooderich uh Trucking or Paving, forgive me, uh has provided quality work. I think that that does hold some weight. And if we don't have the option as a board to whether then that should be taken out of our contract or our bidding thing. I mean, it clearly says we have the opportunity to choose what we want as a board. Well, I agree. I don't think anyone said you received a kickback or anything when she was talking about bribes. That's that's just a description of the process that we're expected to follow. I understand and
081this is an open meeting. All the community members are listening to us right now. Uh the numbers are out there. We are not trying to hide anything. Um we're simply express uh the the fact that there's a a contractor that's done good work. So, excuse me, Anna. Do we do not have a motion on the table, correct? Okay, just making sure I didn't miss one. Nope. Well, I'd like to go ahead and make the motion that we award the asphalt work contract for $685,000 to Goodrich. I'll second that. Was that the exact amount? Yes, that's correct. Okay, AJ, did you second that? I I did. I'm sorry. Any further conversation? I did mention this before, but I'm just going to add my voice to the those who were confused by um I guess being told
082that you can't choose anybody but the low bidder. Um and then seeing this here, which certainly seems to give us a certain leeway, um that uh that kind of doesn't sit well with me. But, um I do think in my own mind uh my own mind in in this whole process, I'm just thinking about uh again a contractor who is a known quantity, who's done excellent work without any feeling of loyalty, oh we must reward this to this person, you know, just this just because of uh prior uh you know, relationship. No, I just on the basis of the work itself, um and uh you know, the I think the comment about the junior high parking lot is an is an excellent point. Again, that doesn't influence me because it was made after my mind
083was already thinking about what direction I kind of was hoping things would go. So, uh I that's kind of where my reasoning is on it. Again, I I don't uh have any uh uh anything against this other contractor other than um I think Goodrich has just proven themselves time and time again. I don't see any reason not to. And it since it's such a small amount, I feel like it's not that big a deal. I mean, I'm crazy, but Okay, we motion on the floor, anything else? Okay, can we do a roll call on this one, please, Summer? Yes. Member Lawson? Aye. Member Dizinski? Aye. Member Hansen? Aye. Member MacArthur? Aye. Member Fritz? Nay. Member Meinhardt? Nay. Okay. Motion carries. Contract awarded awarded to Goodrich. All right. Next up is motion to award 003D alternate
084one and was alternate three again, that rain garden one? Correct. Okay. Alternate one and alternate three site concrete work in the amount of $578,580 to Hunt Brothers for the work needed at Alpena High School as part of the bond. Do we need to pull that number three off? Yep, the new motion would pull that one off. Okay, I I thought you were I'm sorry. Yeah, no, I was just clarifying as I read what it was, yeah. So, I would offer the motion to award 003D alternate one. Is that what we're doing? Mhm. Only alternate one. Mhm. And omit alternate three. Okay. That's right. Okay, Eric made the motion. Is there any support? Second, I'm sorry. Okay, thank you. Okay, any further conversation on this one? Okay, if not, uh roll call again, please. Uh member
085Dizinski? Aye. Member Hansen? Aye. Member MacArthur? Aye. Member Fritz? Aye. Member Lawson? Aye. Member Meinhardt? Aye. Okay, motion carries. Thank you. Uh annual summer tax resolution. And thank you, Tony. Uh this is yearly process, a motion to accept the preamble and resolution as presented to impose a summer tax levy of 100% of annual school property taxes on property in the school district and request each city and or township to collect the taxes. I would offer that motion. I second. Okay. Any further conversation? Okay. Now, all in favor to hold hands, please. Okay, thank you. Okay. Up next, human resources staff update. For our new hires, we have professional staff, Rachel Smith Hanson, second grade teacher, Kate Misuraca, our math teacher, Amy Whitey, title one teacher, Veronica Engel, a special ed teacher. We hired some staff
086support, Leah Colon as a GSRP professional, Barbara Wightman as an office assistant, Nicole Nicole Hulan as an instructional assistant, and Tiffany Sheets as a food service float. We have the following resignations, Nicole Guy as an instructional assistant, Joyce McCoy as CTE director, Karen Lowry as food service helper, and Daniel Axford as a bus attendant. We had Sherry Hertzog as an instructional assistant as a termination, and we'd like to say congratulations to Christina Coping as our online teacher retiring after 30 years. That one's a heartbreaker. Oh, yeah. Wow. And now we just need a motion for the four professional staff. I'll make the motion. I abstain from this nice and proper. Yeah. Someone other than Eric can support Monica's motion? I will offer that support. Okay, thank you. Any further conversation? Okay. Um all in Can
087I have a question, I guess? Yeah. Um did you post for the CTE director any A handful of interest, but uh Okay. It's big. Big position to fill. That's why I was curious. Yes. And that's one that kind of important to keep everything rolling. Yeah. Yeah, and we've got uh between Mary and Ron Worth and the rest of the CTE staff, you know, they're moving it forward to we want to make sure we get the right person. Yep. Okay. Um any further conversation? Okay, all in favor, show of hands, please. I And then Eric is abstaining. Thank you. I thought Rachel already worked at Wilson. She's been there 2 years. Oh, okay. That's why I was looking confused. Okay. Uh gifts, charitable contributions. Yes, um another wonderful bounty of uh uh contributions uh to the
088district. Patty Buck gave a monetary donation valued at $500 to the Edward L. Buck CTE Scholarship Fund. The Bradley Agency gave a monetary donation valued at $100 to the AHS Knowledge Bowl team for an upcoming tournament. The Dance Center gave a monetary donation valued at $500 to the McKinney-Vento Homeless and At-Risk Students/Families in Transition. The uh Dennis and Ruth Rebo uh gave a monetary donation valued at $30 to the McKinney-Vento Homeless and At-Risk Students/Families in Transition. First United Congregational Church donated winter gear for students at Lincoln Elementary valued at $125. DTE donated winter mittens and gloves valued at $100 to Hinks Elementary. The Lapin Agency gave a monetary donation valued at $563 to the AHS School Success Program. The Kiwanis Club of Alpena donated a dictionary to each third grade student at Hinks Elementary valued
089at $100. The City of Alpena gave a monetary donation valued at $151 to the AHS School Success Program. Luanne from donated a wide variety of school supplies for students at Hinks Elementary valued at $100. I move to accept the gifts listed above listed above with gratitude and thank the donors in writing for their generous gifts. Support. All in favor show hands. Okay, thank you. Okay, we are at our second opportunity for uh citizens or delegations to address the board. Okay, seeing no one coming forward, we'll move on. I don't believe we have any letters and communications. Is that correct? Okay. Uh reports and information from the superintendent and staff. All right, January is board appreciation month, so I want to uh publicly say thank you for everything you do uh for the community and the
090schools. Um and we have a small token of our appreciation. Yeah. So, APS swag. Uh Sarah. Which Sarah? I know we have two Sarahs and two Erics. Yeah. Monica. Eric, you're I guess I should grab pages, too. Thank you. Eric and Eric. Thank you. Night Tony, thank you. Good night Amy, thank you. Again, thank you all for, you know, giving up your time. The The pay is spectacular and the hours are commensurate with the pay. I don't know, but we thank you for everything you do. Thank you. My pleasure. Uh next item is strategic plan summit planning. And so I did not hear any objections to us doing it on the February board meeting night. So if that works for everyone, what we're trying to do right now is keep that February agenda light so
091that the majority of the time is dedicated to the strategic plan summit update. Um there might be a few topics that have to be on there due to time, but the goal is to spend the majority of our time that night working on the strategic plan. And that is the 23rd 24th 24th 24th of February at 5:30 and that would be we would believe we will hold it over at the high school hopefully anticipating a large community presence because it will be two-way conversation through most of it getting feedback from staff, community, whoever you know, wants to come and be a part of it. So, it'll take on a little bit less formal of a board meeting structure at times. So, um we will officially pencil it in today as February 24th and at the
092high school. Great. And then in my update, and I apologize I didn't send one this weekend. I went home sick Friday and then I was um I was sick all weekend. So, uh hockey too and uh but the previous one um I told you that I was having lunch with Dan Wakeman tomorrow. Now, everyone except Monica probably understands why we're having our relief bus driver and he's a custodian or teach sub right now for us. Um he's a retired CEO of health number of health care systems. Um he was working with us and came to some meetings, saw some strategic plan working. And so, we all um you know, met with him a couple of times. I think he's a board um and he's been with us through this whole process. So, I meet with
093him and just kind of give him an update and get his thoughts on how to uh move this process forward. So, that's why I'm having lunch with him tomorrow. Just to he's done these before and he'll just kind of give me some pointers on how we want to structure it. And then we'll build the agenda uh for that meet the summit. So, Great. with him tomorrow. So, I'll have some updates there. Uh and I guess two um just two quick updates. We had a great session today with our central office administrators where uh we now have a war room. It's a room down at the end of this building with a cork board that's the length of a wall and we've got the years mapped out and we're starting to identify all of our long-term
094planning projects and initiatives. Um so we've put those on there. Next is to overlay our anticipated enrollment numbers over the next couple of years. Our you know, anticipated funding, you know, as best we can do that from the state of Michigan. And then, you know, really talk about those are the expectations of launching this in you know, next year, next semester, whatever it might be. Um which that wall will ultimately come. A lot of that detail will go on to the strategic plan document that you've got with the yellow and the green and it'll be providing those timelines and and more detail than that's on that original document for the plan. Um so that was productive meeting there today. And then last week or two weeks ago, our administrators, you know, you saw the activity
095that they were working on where they take what they're currently doing and align it with our strategic plan. And so they turned that in to us two weeks ago. Uh there was a lot of similarities, which was good. People felt that they were strong in certain the same areas. Greatest areas with need were for a lot of similarities. But then we take that and we start customizing those into our school improvement plans across the district. Which again is that detail to many of those components on the strategic plan. I think that activity was very well received from our administrators and staff that were involved in it. And they're starting to see that connection to you know, what they're doing now is connected to the strategic plan. And then the strategic plan is giving them that
096vision of where we're going with all of this. Again, we'll provide more detailed updates when we get to the 24th, and uh that's my update. Thanks. Okay. Um information and questions from board members. I just had a quick one that I I had gotten out. I don't know if everyone got this in their mailbox or did I just get it? It's just uh um a sales company, but it just it's about water filters, which made me think of our water at Wilson. I've wondered how things were with our water update at Wilson, and if that was resolved or Well, it is managed. Managed, yeah. Uh resolved would be, I think, tearing out the wells and all of the pipes and everything. Yeah, and We're not still using like Brita filters or No, we aren't. Oh,
097we are. Well, we're doing the the big ones, not like little hand-held ones. They've got the In the kitchen, they've got the filter, but they're getting um Amway Scepter. Oh, okay. Yeah, we're getting, you know, kitchen we're getting Culligan bottled water. Um we do have a pure water filter on the kitchen faucet. And we are moving forward, there's the new filter first legislation, which requires um every consumptive faucet to have a uh at the point filter on it, so so that's moving forward, that's going to be implemented by 25 in the 25-26 school year, or so. Great. Kitchen staff, I haven't heard that they're not happy, so it must be going okay, and Yeah, it's not ideal. Yeah. And that's everything to remedy the situation, yes, we would have to remove all the lines from
098the well throughout the entire school to get rid of the lead. Switch out the faucets. Yeah. It is managed at times, so Yeah, all the the drinking faucets have filters on them. All the bottle those things fountains filtered. Any water used for consumption is is filtered or comes from Culligan. Great. I just saw that and it made me think of it, so. Yeah. Anyone else? I had a question. So, I did I'm getting used to the new superintendent update format and I did find the the um teacher of the the uh staff meeting information the the schedule. I did find that, thank you. Is there a separate schedule though for like specifically for teacher trainings on really just anything? Is that Yeah. Could could we find that somewhere too? So, yeah, it would be like
099we have structured days coming up. When's our next PD day? It's in March. We have a half day. 13th and 14th. And typically the agenda gets sent out 15 days prior to that. Great. Could we be copied on that? Yeah. Yep. That would be super thank you. Yep. So, we've got March days and then what a May day? Um So, there's two where you know again the whole district is doing that PD and then there are um uh the team times that Romeo talked about where the teachers are working in small groups on data and various things like that. Um we do have those schedules available but it's typically you know at the elementary it it might be two teachers. Yeah. You know working together or something. Quite a different animal. Yeah. Okay. Thank you.
100Um and my other my other thing was really just a shout out to Summer. Um I've been enjoying the meeting minutes. It's there's quite a lot of detail and I know it takes a lot of time to do that but I I really appreciate the level of detail. I just want to thank you. Thank you. I had two questions. Um can we talk about the Mary's wish for a sinking fund? Uh Well, I didn't Well, it I didn't put a name on it. Sure. Uh but could we get that on a on a workshop agenda to or am I barking up the wrong tree? No, absolutely. Um I I mean, we see that like a 2-year project of preparation for it. Uh so, it's uh cuz there's a lot of community awareness uh that needs
101to be done to get to that point. Um so, it is in fact on on our wall in the war room that we we know eventually we need to get there. Uh so, we can have conversations, but there's a lot of like information that we need to put together, I think, to really then start having um conversations about it. I I'm confused then. So, when I was in my mind I think we take money out of our budget. Sorry, two different things. You're talking the Yeah, a sinking fund would be a millage. Okay. And that Yeah, that would be different. years of preparation and explanation and you know, planning and everything. So, yeah, we did have some conversations about um what you had mentioned at the last meeting. Um so, we can put that I
102think it's already on February's um workshop agenda. To talk about setting aside money uh from our fund balance for various projects. That's what you're talking about. that's what I was Yep. Yeah, I wasn't on the whole passing another tax Yeah. wagon there. Okay. Uh the other question was about the sewer pipe. Did you get an answer? Has anybody seen it? You what? Because I just I just voted and I forgot to ask during that vote. I hate to spend half a million dollars on concrete and asphalt and then have I have for your answer. I have Skip is coming Wednesday to camera the line. Okay. Sewer and sanitary, not storm. Do Well, our we're replacing the storm back there, correct? Uh I would have to I think we're leaving some we're changing some of it
103and we're replacing but that's I think the storm and we're talking the storm underneath the school and the sewer underneath the school. Okay. That's Yeah. Well, my concern was and then Dave just kind of flipped it out there at after you left as a sinking fund need was the sewer pipe out to Washington and then it clicked that we're paving over top of this. Correct. So, we're not So, we're going to we're going to camera it from the back towards the railroad tracks from the stadium that's at all the way back up to between D and E house. Okay. So, that's that's Wednesday's on Wednesday's agenda. Good enough. And once we know that, we'll be able to make an assessment and Yeah. go from there. Okay. Perfect. Thanks. I do have one thing, too. Yeah,
104I'm sorry. Um after that email I I would like to maybe at our next workshop talk about the personal communication devices and look into it a little bit further and see if we can revise our policy. I know the policy is different between the high school and the junior high and maybe invite some of the high school and junior high staff to kind of give us their thoughts on it. Uh yeah, I mean, they were involved in the development of the current plan. Yep. Just to take a look since it's been so helpful just to make sure if we need to refine it a little more. I think it's shown great improvement. If we we show more improvement, I think that would be Yeah, so hey Romeo, uh the personal device plan, do you do
105an annual review of that policy as you're preparing your handbook? Yeah, we did a tweak this year to include the we added I believe the watches weren't in there before we added the watches. And is there staff input on that? Yes, it's part of the MTSS team. So, the team works on that MTSS. It depends on the classroom management and discipline So, it's all referred to the So, at the end of the year probably part of this probably May agenda and then that's what you bring to John when we start revising that that piece of the handbook for how we start the year. And so, we look at handbooks, the board will I was trying to remember you approved the handbooks in July of last year in case there were any last minute changes. So,
106we start having conversations about handbooks and policies, that kind of thing in, know, April, May. Um and so, that I would ask that we kind of put it along that line since it's already a part of the process that they do. a few months. Yeah. As long as we visit it. Yep. Did you have a question about the COVID one still? Oh, yeah. And then I didn't know if I had to bring that back up, but um I know you guys already got rid of a few of the COVID policies. I did notice that 8450.06 was still in the policies and I just wanted to review that and possibly get rid of that one along with the other ones. Yeah, and I did reach out to Neola, our rep, and they said right in it
107it says it expires when the ETS expires, but I couldn't find anything that said the ETS expired, but my guess is when we moved out of emergency state that all the ETSs did. Um however, he uh said there's no concern with rescinding that policy cuz it kind of did it itself, so. Okay, we'll maybe add that Yep, let's you that one then, please submit it to our workshop in um February. What did? I submitted it today. Oh, they Well, they haven't even taken action on it. Yeah, well they'll take action on it, but okay, perfect. So, we can add that one to the February workshop. That'd be great. And we'll keep that personal communication device one, make sure we bring that up in the spring. Mhm. The only question I had is I know we've
108got all the applications in for the sex advisory board. I assume we're going to get some guidance on that process coming soon. Yeah, we figured we'd do it on at the February workshop. Okay, that's it. Very good. Thank you. And I did send out an email um you know, based on the emails we had, just letting them know we received their application and that the board's going to be taking action soon, so. Thank you. Are we going to get a full updated list on that or Yeah. Okay. Yeah, cuz I think after the workshop meeting a couple more came in, so. Yeah. Yeah, we'll we'll send out one clean sheet um cuz cuz again, there's the two different versions, so maybe we'll just do a master spreadsheet with everyone. Um it we'll figure it out.
109It's way easier. Yeah. Yeah, if we can get a little bit obviously I think if we are closing it officially officially closing at the end of this month, we get it sooner when it closes rather than close to the workshops since so we have a little bit of time to actually go through it. Okay. Didn't the policy say we continuously accept it, didn't we? Yeah, once someone is has applied, we keep it on the record for I think it says 2 years or something. So, yeah, we we could keep it rolling. The challenge is if that night someone applies Right. That's not really a challenge, but yeah. We would just have to say you are in the queue. Should there be any ones that applied earlier don't meet the Okay. Anyone else have anything? Okay,
110if not, um, we'll be heading into a closed session. Are we staying in here for a closed session? Yeah, we're staying in here for a closed session, uh, not taking any action, just an informational closed session. So, you're more than welcome to wait in hallways or wait outside, but we won't be taking any action while coming in and, um, closing the meeting. So, thank you everyone for coming if you're not coming back in. We will need a motion to meet in closed session under section 8C of the Open Meetings Act to hear a report on local negotiations and information on the process. I would offer that motion. Second. Okay, anything further? All in favor show hands. Okay, thank you. Okay, we are back in open session and for anyone tuning in just want to apologize
111that we actually do have some action to take. We were not correct in our statement that we didn't so we are back live with a motion. Uh do you want to read the motion for us Summer do you have it? Okay, we you got it. Okay, AJ go for it. Go go for it AJ. You got it. I move to accept the ESP 1 contract as presented. Perfect, thank you. Okay, anyone supportive of that motion? I'll support. Thank you Monica. Okay, any further conversation? Okay, hearing none all in favor show of hands please. All right. Motion carries for that contract. Thank you and yep, Bill Heimel said yes, we are working. So, I thought that was a good one to check. Um, okay, with that, uh, we see our upcoming meeting February 10th, we have
112a workshop back here. Looks like we see the SPAC meeting that Dave will be hosting on the 19th and then regular workshop or regular meeting on the 24th, which will likely be at the high school. Yes. Uh, so we can tie into strategic planning and with that we can adjourn. Thank you.