CorpusRecord 202224

MAPS Board Meeting of December 16, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Marquette Area Public Schools
Date
2024-12-17
Location
Marquette County, MI
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,968 words · about 45 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right we're calling the meeting to order it is 5:30 December 16 2024 and the first uh matter on the agenda is a pledge of allegiance and we'll ask our student members toist stes America and to the rep for it stands Nation next matter is the roll call Christen cenzi Glenn Sara here James H here Jennifer Cliff here Jennifer Ray here Cheryl madx Smith here Jason zadun here thank you and I'll entertain a motion to approve the agenda make a motion to approve the agenda Jason zun made the motion second from jennif clip um all those in favor say I I I the agenda is approved next issue on the agenda is superintendent report thank you Mr Sara two parts to the superintendent report do part one and then we'll have a little recess and

002do part two shortly thereafter here to talk a little bit about Mr huitt Jim huitt has been a dedicated member of the Marquette Area Public Schools Board of Education since 2015 born and raised in the Marquette area Jim has a deep connection to the local community and his lifelong commitment to marquette's growth and success has shaped his perspective as a board member he has been actively involved in various aspects of the community advocating for educational improvements and promoting programs that benefit students and families Jim's professional background includes extensive experience in the banking industry since 2008 where he has developed a strong skill set in leadership finance and strategic planning this experience serves him well in his role on the maps board where he works collaboratively with other members to ensure sound fiscal decisions promote effective

003policy and maintain a high standard of Education as a board member Jim has helped steer map's efforts to improve our facilities enhance our curriculum ensure the district remains fiscally sound he's helped build a program at Maps which truly addresses the Myriad needs of our students those academic and in many cases much more a mission of Paramount importance especially since the covid-19 pandemic Mr bu huitt believes that every student deserves access to a highquality education and that the maps Community plays an essential role in helping them achieve their fullest potential in his free time Jim enjoys spending time with family watching his kids sporting events cooking and exercising he also helps coach and manage his son's soccer team Jim has strong family ties to education his parents are both retired teachers from the district his father

004taught math and English at graat middle school for the majority of his career and in his final years became an assistant principal of GRE verett and then moved to Bothell when the two middle schools Consolidated where he later retired Jim's mother taught math initially at Bol middle school for a few years before moving to mshs where she retired after retiring from maap she worked at enmu for many more years as part of the agent faculty in the math department his grandparents both worked for Manistique High School his grandfather was a drafting and Shop teacher and his grandmother was an art teacher Jim's wife Melissa has been a Maps employee since 2007 and is currently an instructional coach at bthl Middle School Jim and Melissa's three children attend maps at the elementary middle and high school

005levels Melissa's father is a retired PE health teacher and was a longtime wrestling coach at Iron Mountain public schools and her mother retired from the iron Mountain Kingsford Community Schools preschool program both Jim and Melissa have a large number of additional aunts and uncles who are retired Educators this is something they are very proud of as a good education plays a significant role in the development of children and that ultimately shapes communities on a personal note it's hard to summarize my appreciation for Jim's role on the board his calm demeanor and strategic approach to board business is something I've leaned on heavily throughout my tenure as superintendent through the celebrations and some challenges Jim has remained a voice of reason he is intelligent well informed reflective and honest most of all Jim is wise so

006in closing I say thank you Jim hwit for your incredible talents which you've invested into our community's children and for your leadership through the last 10 years of service to the market Area Public Schools board Board of Education and our district you will be greatly missed here then you can give so on behalf of the uh the board uh Maps board uh the administration the staff um and I'm sure a lot of parents and students in Market Area Public Schools we'd like to present you with this uh plaque in appreciation for your 10 10 years of service uh in a job that's often referred to as thankless I'd like to thank you for all those 10 years and officially give you back at least one Monday a month um several Tuesdays Wednesdays Thursdays Fridays and

007hopefully give sporting events back to you not uh taking questions from the public so it's been a personal pleasure working with you and I know board other board members would stay the same and I just say you've been a great uh asset for the administration as well thank you [Applause] thank well thank you guys very nice very kind words um I did I made a couple of notes of things that I just wanted to mention I'm not going to make this long um but didn't want to forget anything so um first special big thanks to my wife Melissa uh as it's already been stated um many Monday evenings that she has had to um bring kids to and from sporting events you know dinners missed things along those those lines and um thankfully I don't

008believe I've ever missed a Monday night game our kids never had games on Mondays it's always been practices so it's always worked out in my favor um but again I I don't want that to U go without being mentioned and uh more importantly on that side again the dynamic of being on the board while your spouse is a member um of one of the teach you know of the teachers union is not an easy thing to to navigate um not going to go into any details but just know that she deserves a ton of um praise for enduring uh these past 10 years with a lot of patience and Grace so the additional thanks to want to certainly extend also goes out to uh the board and um previous superintendent Bill Saunders he served Maps

009well in my first few years and should be praised for for his service thank you of course now to uh Zach in the in the past years where he picked up the torch and has carried our district onto the path of continued success Maps has been very lucky to have had Bill and continue to have Zach going forward similarly similarly thanks to former superintendent Deb Barry and current Jim Lampman both Bill and Zach I think would um certainly want to make sure that those two people were recognized for for their service and certainly cannot go without also thanking Linda Hopper um without her our top administrators would not perform at the level they do so thank you Linda um a few things I'm proud of you know as for the district as a whole over

010the last 10 years uh just a high um the first one that came along with my tenure on the board was the one to1 initiative uh that was um certainly a huge thing to undertake and and continue um it's a big commitment financially uh but it obviously I think you know pays pays off for all of our students and and their success on top of that the passing of the bond and the sinking fund uh the work with the community to uh really sell the importance of those those fiscal agents to be able to um basically sustain our our distri and and keep keep the door not only keep the doors open but keep it thriving so um on that same kind of financial side of things the continued this kind of a broad one

011but the continued facilities improvements that we have made while still being able to settle uh contract increases uh regularly and um increasing Staffing at the same time not cutting you know the balance of all that uh it's a fine fine and delicate balance to to navigate so that is something I'm very proud of um most recently which seems you know maybe small but I think is has actually been a very huge thing for uh more of the community side and the students themselves but allowing the free entry to All Sports uh for students and faculty and and reducing the overall payto pay fle pardon me fees I think has been U something that was long overdue and hope we can maybe even continue more uh improvements in those areas uh personally when I was trying

012to think of like one thing I was proud it's kind of hard to you're part of a board you're not here as an individual so but I am proud of the fact of my attendance record at meetings over the last 10 years I think I've only it's either five or six over 10 years that I missed which if you don't pay a lot of attention that doesn't sound phenomenal but I think it's been on the higher end of of attendance rates so I'll take that with me um and my last sales pitch just goes out to The Community as a whole in that uh we we do you'll see tonight in the budget hearing we have and continue we've had and continue to have a very strong fund balance uh over these last 10 years

013and a lot of that goes to what I already mentioned the the bond and the sinking fund but it goes to the state of Michigan and the governor's office and the state house and legislature they've been very friendly to education and historically if you pay any attention we know that goes in uh the pendulum swings in different directions and it's bound to come back sooner than later and we as a district just like anybody else cannot survive solely on the per Pew pool fund uh allowance so I guess I'm just reaching out if anybody's listening in the community to when that time comes uh please be prepared to help support maps and uh cuz again if you're a supporter of Education um the only way to get by is to have have great teachers great

014facilities great curriculum it's all you can't neglect any one of those things like I said earlier it's all about the balance so I think that's all appreciate it and um I'm sure you won't see you know the last of me yet so I'll see [Applause] you and we'll take a 15minute recess uh there are uh cookies I understand and drinks uh as a reception for uh for gy something EX not be done a pleasure give [Music] oh no he's [Laughter] coming once a year I think I'm going to take Thursday and Friday off I'll get I'll get i'll get Tuesday and Wednesday off and Thursday Friday for what Friday off you guys [Music] I feel like usually we're there Monday Tuesday no it works really nice to be yeah very nice I is it all

015Central stuff yeah we get Christmas Eve [Laughter] Ro snow days yeah for sure oh my gosh I know I think of you every time they and this year they've been really calling weird real doozies for you yeah yeah so you do that and then you have to work all day cuz you don't you cancel school you yeah [Music] next on the agenda is the superintendent report thank you Mr Sara going to pass along to Mr Lampman for our December budget amendment good evening I've been asked by Mrs clip to make this as long as possible this evening that is not at all what I said oh oh sorry not even not even a little misheard you um so in your packet you have um should have a document uh PowerPoint presentation that's being cast behind

016you so I'm here tonight to present the 2425 budget amendment number one and uh let me just say that um the budget is an estimate and it's an Ever evolving document throughout the course of the year and to highlight that point um it's my understanding that we've had some some uh major changes coming down the line for Public Act 152 regarding health care costs I believe the State House passed a bill and the Senate passed a bill and they're in reconciliation at this point that's going to have an impact on the budget uh but that will have to be brought to a future Amendment that's not factored in here today so I just want to highlight that fact that you know we're always always uh looking at this and reviewing it so later this evening

017we're going to have a presentation from Michael Grant's um partner at Anderson tacin he'll be here presenting the uh 23 24 audited financial statements and I think I'm going to Veer off topic a little bit not that I want to draw this out but um on page 63 of the audit report there's a budget to actual uh statement with the general fund and uh when we B budget we try to be a little conservative on our uh Outlook to budgeting we try to be a little conservative on the revenue side maybe a little conservative on the expenditure side and so looking at our budget to actual for 23 24 um our revenues came in 272,000 higher than our estimated final budget that's about a half a percent so we were within a half % uh

018on the revenue side of of where we thought we were going to be coming into year end last year on the expense side we came in about 510,000 lower on the expense side than we' projected um so that's about a percent less uh than we thought we'd come in so that's that's kind of where we want to be when we're when we're budgeting and I just thought I'd point that out before I get into all the nuts and bolts of this budget amendment so you've heard me say this before the general fund um is comprised of several different funds we have General operations grants coffin planetarium Father Marquette and uh Athletics um various other funds so it's it's it's kind of a a mashup of different parts of the operation so looking at the general

019fund uh local revenues and interdistrict revenues um currently we're yielding about 4.67 on our uh Investment Portfolio uh we thought uh when we were putting the uh the original budget together this year that we'd see um some more significant rate uh decreases come through the Federal Reserve uh that didn't happen again we were trying to be a little on the conservative side we thought they were going to cut rates faster I think they're meeting next week to talk about rate Cuts we'll see what happens but um at this point in December uh we think uh we can uh increase our estimate by about 148,000 property taxes again when we're projecting out we're just using estimates um we're amending our property tax revenue uh based off the most recent data that we have the taxable values

020from uh August 8th 2024 so we're looking at sorry let me flip my page cuz I can't read that from this distance uh 577 th000 uh increase into uh into our uh property taxes based off taxable value changes and then our interdistrict Revenue uh for maresa we're looking at about a $211,000 increase um from maresa uh for our special ed reimbursements and again we just uh we're basing this off the most most recent data that we have available um updating our projections from last uh May and June moving on to uh state aid this is where it gets really interesting I'm sure you're going to find this fascinating so um one of the one of the big changes that we have in our um uh projections from the original budget is our per pupil Foundation

021uh the data that had at the time that we put the original budget together we were looking at uh an increase to our per pupil Foundation I believe it was $241 is the uh estimate that we' used in the budget so we thought we'd come in at a a per people Foundation per pupil Foundation of $984 and then surprise surprise we did not get the foundation allowance increase um so our our per people Foundation remains at $968 as it was last year so that was about $771,000 in uh per pupil Foundation allowance that we did not receive for this fiscal year now the state being the state said in Li of a per pupil increase we're going to do a one-time um uh cost offset through the mier's retirement system and they did they gave

022us 1.18 1 million which would equate to a$3 $69 per pupil increase remember we budgeted for $241 per people increase but then the state being the state and and I'm not knocking the state they've been very generous to the school district in in all school districts in the state the last few years but um sometimes they giveth with one hand and taketh with the other and they reduced our normal miers cost offset by about 627,000 when they gave us our one- time uh U um uh dollars so really that that equates to about $173 per people increase so a little less than the $241 foundation pup increase that we thought we were going to get initially uh when we formulated this budget um another thing that uh that happened was the um recently the state

023lower beginning in October the um unfunded liability stabilization rate so that rate was 16.89% and the state has dropped that to 10.58% and really that percentage represents the amount that the state is paying into the pension system um on on behalf of the districts um for unfunded liabilities for um for for current future retirees and really for us what that represents is an in and and out we record the revenue that the state gives us and then we record the corresponding expense so the the the the net is zero on our books um but it does have an impact on our budget so when the U Got reduced uh by about 6% well that shows up as a reduction in our revenue and a corresponding reduction in our expenses so um that that 6% reduction

024does have a a a pretty big impact overall another thing that happened was um with mpsers the speaking of the unfunded liability uh the state recorded a $494,000 payment to the pension fund on behalf of mar Public Schools um to go towards uh the unfunded pension liability they've done this previously so this was number another one onetime deposit this year but again we have to reflect that is an in in and out so it increases our Revenue increases our expenses by $494,000 net effect is zero on the books um as I mentioned previously we had an increase in property taxes based off the um updated uh taxable values when our property taxes go up our other uh 22 prop funding goes down uh so it kind of balances out so no no District gets um

025uh to benefit too much out of a a large increase in in property tax revenue and then interestingly um we had some additional funding that that showed up this year for transportation costs we received another 275,000 uh in transportation costs we received this uh in the prior year as well we thought it was going to be uh just one-time funding but the state granted it to us again so um we're happy to have that so looking uh looking at this and I promise I will speed up Mrs clip I'm going slow now I will speed up so looking at the general fund Revenue looking at the general fund Revenue I I'm not sure when our auditor is going to be here he' said about 6:30 so I'm I'm I'm trying to get us to uh

026to the point that the the auditor will be here as well so um sorry so looking at our our general fund Revenue overall um uh we're looking at an overall budgetary increase to our local Revenue reduction to our state revenue um uh slight uh decrease to our federal revenue based uh largely on timing issues between last year and this year um so overall we're looking at uh a reduction of Revenue of 4,18 or8 $817 which is about a 83% decline to our Revenue so less than 1% decline to our Revenue overall um from where we were on our original budget so looking at this graphically you can see the uh the largest share of our Revenue comes from the state uh currently that's about 65% we receive 33% of our revenue from uh local sources

027uh largely property taxes uh we receive 1 and a half% of our funding from uh the federal government and then half a percent from from other um so that's just shows you the uh uh original budget to the proposed amendment graphically moving on to general fund expenditures um as you're well aware uh we uh we settled contracts as year with all of our bargain units that had an impact on uh where we thought our original budget was going to be back when we put this together in May and June we weren't I don't uh we weren't in the really deep into negotiations we weren't sure exactly where we were going to be um so this this amends for that so we're looking at an increase of salaries of about 3.9% based off the SLE bark

028units uh we're looking at a decrease in benefits of about 4% largely that's that's due to the changes to mbers that I discussed and then operations and maintenance um overall we're looking at about a 5.6% increase based off of various uh uh supplies and and purchase service changes that have happened or going to happen this year so looking at the breakdown again overall we're looking at at um going from 47,7 31,000 uh expenses in the original budget to 48,1 76,000 in the proposed budget that's an increase of 445,000 or about 93% so again less than a percent change on the expense side and looking at that graphically you can see salaries and and benefits is the largest expense to the district we're looking at about 80 and a half% on uh on salaries and benefits

029as part of the budget 8.8% is uh purchase Services 5.2% is supplies so on and so forth um but but really it's it's salaries and benefits that are the the lineon share of our general fund budget so looking at this overall we started up out uh the uh this school year um with a fund balance totaling 18,35 th000 in this amendment we have 47,6 191,000 in revenues $48,750 in expenses resulting in a net loss of $485,500 balance of 17,8 17,000 and an unassigned fund balance of 10,455 th000 so we're still over 10 million in our unassigned our original budget had our unassigned fund balance and our unassigned is what we have available for use um our original budget we were at 10.7 million so this just spends down that unassigned fund balance uh by about

030300,000 and here's that picture I promised you uh sorry I'm having some fun with Mrs clip tonight um moving on to the Food Service fund so the uh Food Service fund uh overall um we're looking at an increase in revenue of $265,300 higher utilization in meals coupled with uh an increase in our reimbursement rate um so I think in our original budget we were being a little bit conservative in in uh the revenue that we were going to take in we we took a look at it we we feel comfortable right now that we're probably going to be closer to the $996,000 mark in in state revenue looking at the expenditures so in the expenditures um we're looking at um an overall increase of $168,800 in the food service fund we have revenues in this

031budget amendment totaling 244,000 expenses of 1,998 th000 resulting in net income of $ 46,2 15 and an ending fund balance of $792,000 now we continue to have a challenge that a lot of other districts are facing right now and that is um an excess fund balance in the in the Food Service fund and we uh are continuing to find ways to spend this down ideally we want to be around the $450,000 Mark in in fund balance um but it's it's been a challenge trying to uh um to to bring that fund balance down so um you will uh you will see at Future meetings requests for um new investments into the Food Service program uh looking at some of the other funds fund 32 is our uh debt retirement fund 41 is our our capital

032projects fund 42 is our syncing fund which as Mr hwit pointed out our syncing fund was renewed so we're into our 2024 uh syncing fund so we're we're tapping into the new uh the new millage so looking at The Debt Service fund uh this one is pretty straightforward um we have a a millage to collect Revenue to pay the annual Bond payment on the 2016 Bond so uh this is this is just to um uh amend the revenues based off taxable values we actually decreased the uh the millage rate from the 23 24 year to the 2425 year uh last year it was 042 Ms we brought that down to 38 Ms um which should be enough still to cover the bond payment um so really it's just in in and out we collect the

033revenue repa for the bond payment so looking at this overall we started the year with a fund balance in The Debt Service fund of 186,000 we're projecting tax revenues of $588,500 uh resulting in a a net loss in The Debt Service fund of about 69,000 but an ending fund balance of $16,988 by the way feel free to stop me at any point along the way if you have questions so moving on to um I go the wrong way uh let's see no capital projects I'm sorry so moving on to capital projects F so the uh the big change with capital projects from our original budget amendment is um the purchase of the planetarium projector that the board had uh approved earlier this year uh we spent about 775,000 on a new projector um that projector

034is being uh paid for through a combination of Grants and and a fundraising campaign uh so we'll see those dollars flow back into the capital projects fund so this amendment basically uh updates for uh for that change so we started the year with a fund balance in capital projects of 5.7 million uh this amendment has revenues totaling 2,1 156,000 expenditures of 1, 145,000 resulting in net income of 1,10,000 for an ending fund balance of 6.8 million and this is probably the point that um I'll get on my Soap Box a little bit and I I'll um just reiterate the point that um based off a recent study we do have over hundred million do of identified infrastructure needs within the district and um well we're very grateful for the community um approving a syncing fund

035millage the sinking fund uh brings in about 1.3 million a year and um that level of Revenue uh just is not sufficient to maintain the 700,000 uh square fet of um uh facil ities that we have and so we've been trying to set some money aside in our capital projects fund uh to address some of the emergency situations that may come up that the syncing fund um isn't just able to cover so I'll climb off my soap box now thank you moving on to the sinking fund um so we had uh we had various projects paid uh paid for out of the syncing fund um this year and really most of them are projects that began last year that carried over into the 2425 school year such as the science lab project the CTE rough

036at the high school um some work on the mshs boiler and uh the HVAC system at Bothwell all those projects were started in earlier years and and um um wrapping up in 2425 so again uh Revenue change in the syncing fund largely due to changes in the tax revenue uh taxable values so we're adding 990,000 to revenue in the syncing fund expenditures in the syncing fund we're increasing our estimate uh by 220,000 to 1.7 million in expenditures this year out of the syncing fund and again part of that is just T trying to time these projects because they're they're moving from one fiscal year to the next you estimate how much is going to be one year how many much of the expenses are going to carry over and we're not always exactly right on

037those estimates um and the contractors are always optimistic and you know we we run with their estimates and so this is just updating um updating for those projects that had occur so we started the year uh with a syncing fund balance of $93,700 we uh were projecting revenues of 1.3 million and expenses out of the syncing fund this year of 1, 755,000 resulting in a net loss uh or a spend down of the sing fund of 434,000 uh $83 resulting in uh projected ending fund balance uh as of June 30 of $95,900 and then um um the private purpose trust fund um this amendment is is basically just bringing our estimate in line with where the 23 24 actual was we're predicting a similar year to 23 24 so we're just amending accordingly uh so

038private purose trust budget started the year with 37,2 186 in fund balance we're looking at revenues of 118,00 ,500 expenditures of $6,500 resulting in that income of 2,000 and a projecting projected ending fund balance of $309,250 presentation moving on with the superintendent report Item B under the superintendent report for the maps to consider hourly and daily Service rates if you look at your in your packet there's a memo from our HR Director Regina rollstone who was unable to make it this evening uh describing the proposed increase in rates this is for are non-union non-contractual employees who do not receive benefits and the proposed increase of $3 an hour is the same as what we provided our substitutes which seemed appropriate any questions on the proposed hourly and daily service rate increases moving on oh sorry

039Mr SED just popped into my head but did the the budget amendment adoption for tonight is that take into account these increases Mr lman you want the mic uh this does not we did not Factor that's that's one of the items uh that came came up late as we're putting together the budget amendment that we did not factor in this evening so this would be this would be included in the future Amendment sure okay next up another proposal from our HR Director this time for our sub rates when posing sub rate increases earlier in the fall there was an exclusion of one I guess I'll call it classification within mespa one and this proposal which you see in your packet identifi that one classification it's for retired kitchen workers with our mesel one group we

040often times hire our retirees as subs and they come with special skills and experience which allows them to fill those those unique roles and we have rates that that are you know aligned with with that need so we did have that one classification that was left off and and she is proposing that we increase them by the same amount that we did everybody else any questions on that moving right along Mr Wheeler if you'd be so kind as a step to the podium in the event that we have questions about new course offerings for mshs this would be this proposal would be effective for the 2526 school year but due to the nature of sequence of event events to get to the fall our our course listings have to be updated now so that they

041can be available to students who are signing up for next school year so Mr Wheeler did you want to say anything about these this proposal certainly um members of the board Mr SED Mr Lon Linda um thanks uh for for taking a look at these courses for us here this evening uh Mr sedick is right I mean we're in the phases now where we're trying to plan uh next year's schedule um we've taken a lot of input from staff in terms of electives that we could potentially offer at Market Senior High School you know with the sentiment that that's one of the things that we do best is we offer a lot of opportunities for our students and so um with that in mind um asking our our staff to put forth some recommendations for

042new courses and we've got some some really good ones here um just for some context too as you're looking at the uh graduation requirements we are increasing ing that to 26 and the reason for that is that the state as many of you probably know has required a personal finance component as part of the graduation requirements beginning with this um this freshman class class of 2028 um and so subsequently we had to roll personal finance into our econ and our current econ class um we only had to add a couple of uh state standards in order to do that so um that's kind of the reason for that there um but I'd be happy to answer any questions about the courses or the graduation requirements if you have them are the preap courses new or

043is that what what's the change in a preap course versus absolutely that's a great question Mr zunic there's absolutely no change other than that name allows us access to the College Board resources so that's that's all that that is we already have a world history 10 it's been called a pre AP course um for for the for the resources reason so how many credits was it previously 25 and a half 25 and a half and so it's just that additional finan correct okay I did thank you forgive me if I it might be on here I just didn't see it um for the uh personal finance course under economics is that's a senior that course is taken senior year or is there a year that that needs to be taken another great question so if

044you look at our social studies credits there you'll see that now it's three or three and a half and that depends on the different route you take through the the social studies curriculum so uh let's say for instance you take preap World assuming that's adopted this evening uh and then you move on to apus then you would take AP Gov which in and of itself is a single credit course per the college board but we're also including a half credit of economics in there because one personal finance and also it's a graduation requirement so we rolled that in to try to be as efficient as we could within that so effectively if you take AP go and E account you're getting one and a half credits does that answer your question Mr thank you um

045so it it doesn't there's not a set year that the personal finance course will be taught like it has to be taught a particular junior year or senior year there's no stipulations or that determine when that course needs to be taken that's there's some latitude with the districts there's latitude obviously you know the way that we have it written in there is that the inherent intent is that econ and government are taking in the senior Year from the standpoint that that's when it's going to be most relevant to our students on their way out the door into the real world having that personal finance component we felt that that was probably most applicable given our current curriculum yep and then we also have it as a standalone course uh obviously the personal finance to be

046able to ensure that we're meeting the state standards thank you Mr Wheeler any other questions before we move along okay thank you thank you so one last item under the superintendent report under other I just want to and this seems to be an appropriate meeting to to announce that our own James Lampman recently met the requirements for certification through msbo to receive his CFO designation certification which re which uh reflects excuse me a high degree of academic professional preparation as as set by standards by the msbo board of directors so not an easy task to accomplish something I think that's worthy of some praise so congratulations and Well Done Mr lman [Applause] we'll have an auditor here later tonight that will give a little bit more information on the year end budget we'll see if

047Mr gring confirms Mr grants confirms uh that that that is in fact the case so I think he will so that is all I have for the superintendent report thank you thank you and the next agenda item is approval of the consent agenda which includes minutes the board meeting November 18th uh minutes of the Clos session assistant superintendent contract personal report dated from 202 uh December 2024 and financial Personnel report and the financial reports of uh November 2024 I would uh entertain a motion to approve the consent agenda I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda as presented support motion made by Jan clip we have ch Cheryl M Smith is in support all those in favor say I I I next item in the agend is uh student School Board Representatives report uh

048thank you so um here at mshs we are nearing the end of the first semester um that is like uh mid January um so although uh most of us are checked out for winter break um there are a few tests this week for all classes that um we're still thinking about um we had uh the winter formal dance on uh December 7th and uh that was really fun uh a lot of a lot of students had a lot of fun there and the decorations in the auxiliary gym um were really cool and there's a huge inflatable so people were having fun at that and then on the ninth um there was a chorus concert uh that uh went really well um there's a great turnout of both parents students and the community and um so

049yeah yeah that was fun um the snow day was nice thank you Mr Cedric um I think the band the band concert got rescheduled uh due to that and then the orchestra is tonight and um yeah um for sports I think all of our win sports right now are in kind of full role I think we offer around like 10 to 11 different sports have to make sure with Mr Engles but it's really cool just like the amount of opportunity involvement we had during the winter for the M students another thing I'd like to talk was our Esports our Esports plays a game called Rocket League I don't know if any of you guys know what that is but they just won Regional finals two weeks ago and they got the opportunity to go down

050to Michigan State and compete for a state championship they lost but that was really cool mber does a great job running that program and then this week for student council has been like our main focus we're trying to just make it like a smooth transition into wi break and give the student something to look forward to so we're doing dress up days every day this week and then Friday we have an assembly um there's like I don't know we do different like grade competitions and then Friday night is three home games and it's hockey girls basketball and boys basketball and we're kind of we're trying to make it like so if you go to all three games it'll be like a incentive you can offer your name into a drawing and have a chance to

051win something so yeah so speaking of that assembly uh starting at 11:35 a.m. on Friday we'd like to invite the board um to show up and um if you guys can and it's fun um it's a lot of school spirit and everyone's psyched for break and um yeah and of course the the games the sports games um if you want to come out to those those will be filed the students as well thank you 11:35 on priday yep G the hockey game is at 5:00 and then the girls basketball um 6:30 and the boys basketball is to follow thank you for your cander and hopefully we'll get inflatables at abort meeting if they were that popular uh next item on the agenda is comments from the public I don't have any yellow sheet so I

052don't believe we have any comments from the public tonight uh next uh uh item is uh new business got several items to consider the first is adoption of the amendment to the 2024 2025 budget I entertain any motions should we is our uh representative from Anderson techman here should we we did do the audit he'll be giving a separate okay discussion uh under item 13 okay we I I would recommend it making a motion to the okay budget at this point gotcha I'll make a motion that we adopt the 2024 2025 budget amendment support all right we have motion by motion by Mr hu support by m Ray all those in favor say I I I motion passes next is it considered an increase in not hourly and daily Services rate effective 2024 make a

053motion to consider the increase in the 2024 2025 Maps hourly and daily Service rates effective 1216 2024 support we have a motion by Mr zadun support by Miss Ray all those in favor say I I I motion passes um next item is consider modification of sub rates for 2024 20 25 make a motion to consider the modification to the sub rates for 2024 support all right we have a motion by Mr zadun support by Mr hwit all those in favor say I I I um next approve new course offerings of Market senior high school I'll make a motion to approve the new course offerings that unless say just get to support now we have a motion by m Ray support by Mr huitt I should have asked on the previous uh items if there was

054any comment I'll ask for comment on this item any comments hearing none um all those in favor say I I next is consider nomination of christen cenzi for region one MSA masb on board of directors I'll make a motion to consider the nomination of Christ cenzi for region one masb board of directors second right we have a motion for M second from this clip any comment hearing none all those in favor say I I um next item is consider adoption of a completed year end of valuation for the uh superintendent make a motion to adopt the completed year end evaluation for the superintendent Mr Cedric second was that Miss clip all right we have a Patrick for Mr zunic making a motion and we have support by Miss clip any comment hearing none all those

055in favor say I I uh the last item is consider ratification of uh superintendent contract I'll make a motion to uh consider ratification of superintendent contract support so we have uh motion by Miss Ray support by Miss CL I believe miss m oh I'm sorry Miss madx Smith um any comment hearing none all those in favor say I I motion passes next item on the agenda is the audit report uh thank you for the mic Mr Sedwick um we have here with us tonight uh Mike Grant he's a partner with Anderson tman and Company uh his firm uh audited our uh 2023 2024 school year and he's here tonight to present that audit report and each of you should have a copy of the audit report in your packet Mr Grinch would you mind taking

056the podium please I'll try and make it short and sweet starting on page four is the opinion now you have a unmodified opinion so with all the Gally accept close excuse me Mr grin could you do me a favor and press the button on the mic and there you go now your mic's live now we can so page four is the opinion you have unmodified opinion so you complied with all the generally accepted accounting principles it says they're your statements not ours and we take a sampling of transactions we don't look at every transaction um looking at page 17 when you roll the district up in total um you ended up with a deficit of just over 9 million um an unrestricted deficit of 31 million but if you come up the page a little

057bit you'll see the net pension liability is 63 million so once you offset that with your shortfall you're sitting in a good position you're in the same boat everybody else is I've had the same Spiel already twice tonight this is my third so once once you take that into account you're in the same spot everybody else is um the nice thing to see is your opep liability which is basically retire health insurance that's actually a benefit position so you're actually overfunded in that bucket for the first time as long as I can remember being in that spot and that's the same with all schools um if you look at page 18 you actually added $9 million to the bottom line in the current year um if you look at page 20 for those that want

058to actually delve into more details I'll just kind of skim through it quick but it's like the changes in your bond Bond payments it's um a big piece of that is $3 million benefit because your pension and op opep costs were actually less than what you paid out during the year which is good to see um the other big thing of it is capital purchases come out of expenses that get capitalized to come up to the top of the page of a $3.8 million gain for the year which comes back to page 21 which is what you're more used to seeing when you're getting your financial statements um the general fund had a gain of about 2.6 million all your other funds had a gain of about 1.1 million um looking at page 66 a

059big piece of that gain 1.4 million of it came from the capital projects fund so there was a large transfer into that fund you didn't spend that you're kind of saving that for projects coming down the road so kind of looking at it from that perspective that's what's causing the big gain there um going back and kind of focusing on the general fund on page 63 you know you kind of looking at the budget the First Column was your original budget and you're projecting almost a $700,000 shortfall your final budget projection was a gain of 1. 8 million and you ended up at 2.6 million so a nice big swing from the beginning of the year to the end and a big swing of that was grants coming through and what grants are coming and

060spending them you don't always know what those are going to be at the beginning of the year so at the end of the day you look really well in that perspective of I don't see issues I don't see problems some people could look at that and say well that's a big swing in original budget versus final and actual but in all actuality with how many grants that are flowing through and all the eser money that's com through that makes a big difference and I would I would think um the board is not a stranger to me saying that we've been trying to hit a moving Target the last few years uh we uh we had a lot of Grants come come down the line mid year that weren't planned or expected at the beginning of

061the the year um which is the case again this year we um earlier this year applied for a safety Grant uh the state's coming through with some additional safety dollars uh that are going to have to be spent this year but there's still a question as to how much we're going to be allocated and what the timeline uh for those dollars are going to be so so yeah we try to be conservative on the front end but we don't when we adopt the original budget but we don't always know what's going to happen during the course of the year and there's been a lot of Grant activity that's occurred so we've been we've been trying to try to hit that moving Target as we go along the year M and you can see the nice

062thing is you're making those adjustments during the year you're accounting form so that's what I'd like to see um your fund balance is sitting in a good spot the question I always have now is now that we've kind of gotten through the covid hurdle and how is that going to affect funding you know the Esser funding you've gotten a lot of Esser dollars and covid dollars coming through now that those funds are going to dry up how is the funding going to be going forward nice thing is with a lot of those grants you were able to do things that normally would come out of operating dollars that you're not going to have to worry about for the next few years so it's kind of looking at that future budget and how are things going

063to look at one year two years three years down the road in funding and expenditures for next St um this year when we were doing the single audit um we did have two findings um and if we look on page 70 79 is the actually we had one this year um we had one finding so when we were testing one of the grains we noticed that there was a payment for another organization that was made by the school um it wasn't a significant dollar amount by any means um but it was $144 so it's one of those things because it was in the compliance realm we took our sampling we have to know if we did find this we have to extrapolate that out to the population and once we did that it comes out

064to roughly $1,300 that if it was a Progressive issue that's what it would be small in comparison and the amount of invoices coming through it's easily mixed um but we have to obviously report it and I think just going forward it's when those pay vouchers are coming through just double-checking and making sure that hey I got a stack of them are they all going to the right spot are they all for us um nothing that I'm jumping up and down say we have big issues on that at all well and I guess I will say in response to this um we we have added an additional layer of review uh in in our uh accounts payable invoices so um again there's no perfect system of internal controls that that's going to catch everything but um

065you know our goal is to have zero mistakes and and try to minimize those as much as possible um so we we have responded in in uh um in regards to the issue at hand y so I think that's as best as you can do you know mistakes happen it is what it is but other than that that's the short version does anybody have questions we like to go into more detail anyone they do have a couple sorry ahead did you say sorry to me I'm here I'm still awake bab do um page 63 the business services looks like it went over um about 136,000 um what types of costs would be wrapped up into that particular category um Business Services that's going to be I'm trying to think of what it would be here

066off the top of my head yeah the budget might have actually have a better break out of that Wonder um I don't know that I have that level of detail with be um but I can certainly get that for you uh what the breakout of that that particular um function is okay yeah that'd be great if we could get if I could see something um potentially share that with the board of where the variance would be and what might have constituted that um particular area yeah and and um when uh when uh the Michigan Department of Education reviews this they're looking at expenditures in in total they're they're not looking on a um uh a per function um line item uh as presented here um so um but I can still provide you with that

067that breakdown I'd appreciate that thank you no problem um second question is in regards to the special education millage um is that reflected or those uh is that millage reflected in this audit report or is that something that's going to be coming down the line soon so we're already collecting off the special ed millage um and that is reflected in the audit report and the the budget amendment that was um approved this evening okay thank you um and the third and final question I had is on page um 60 uh where it goes over the pension costs where in 2015 that was approximately um under the uh statuto requred or uh statutorily required cont contributions was about 3.3 million and that went up to 8 million in 2024 um is that a standard increase that

068you've seen across the districts is that unique to us no it is not th this we could go down a big rabbit hole on this I'll try to keep it the state comes out with the formula and says here's what you're going to contribute and it's pretty much a flat schoolwise every District sees the same thing so it's not Marquette has one Gwyn has their own it's here's the standard percentage from the state and then it's what Matrix do you have of the population of your employees and teachers are they on the defined benefit plan or are they on the defined contribution plan and it's all driven based off of that that's the short the short answer so it's not just us it's not just youart thank you and then Mr lman do you know

069what the 14414 was spent on I uh I remember I I do recall the invoice yes yeah um did it have anything to do with nutrition or was it just a it it was um it was in our Child Nutrition program and um one of our vendors uh with whom we do a lot of business uh accidentally included a charge for another one of their clients on one of our invoices and I can see uh how it would have been easy to to miss in a review um so um again we've we've added an additional layer of review uh in place um so hopefully uh that result resolves any issues going forward um my my take was it was an isolated event uh well with you know when we looked at other invoices we didn't

070we didn't find any any um uh similar occurrences with that particular vendor when we started spot checking some others um so we we kind of feel like that was just um um just kind of an isolated error that occurred could have been input error or something yeah and it was not and we were credited that amount back so the district did not not eat that cost the vendor did uh refund us that that amount um so we we jumped on it immediately when we um learned of it uh so um uh but again we we've tried to put some changes in place that will uh minimize the likelihood of this occurring in the future and it's one of those invoices from a vendor where you're getting multiple slips daily and it just yeah when you're

071flipping through them all it just it was got allocated to the wrong yeah any other questions thank you very much all right thanks all right the next item on the agenda are gifts some requests we've I received another donation from the cop oh oh I'm sorry uh I would entertain a motion to approve the audit report make a motion to accept the 2023 2024 AIT report by Anderson tman support motion by Mr huitt support by m Ray um any comments note hearing none all those in favor say I I motion passes now on to the next uh agenda item which is gifts and requests uh we received a donation from the kman foundation this is something that they've done for several years now and again we're just so fortunate to have uh the foundation and

072the family in our community they've donated $5,000 for coats for kids um and I sure we'll address thank yous in our board member comments which is the next agenda item some board member comments and I think we start with uh we usually we pay atten she usually starts with Jason and then goes toer and then do next um just uh thank you and uh I know we've talked a little bit about Mr huitt but just thank you and appreciate everything you've done over the last decade to take your time to help out the the schools and your time on the board and um it's outstanding so thank you very much um also spent time uh at the school this weekend with the Marquette challenge wrestling tournament um great job by everyone involved um to put

073that tournament on so just wanted to mention thank you to everyone to uh who put that on so other than that I believe hope everybody has a great holiday weekend I also want to Echo Jason and thank Jim for the last decade certainly our district wouldn't be where it is with about you and um the community owes you deep respect and um thank you congratulations on your free your free Monday nights um thank you also to our generous Community um the $5,000 for the coats for kids that's that's just awesome we live in such a such a great place um I know the budget meeting probably isn't everybody's favorite meeting but it really is the nuts and bolts of our district and it's important um you know we're here for it and and asking the

074questions and I just want to thank uh Mr Lampman and our Auditors and all the great questions from the board a lot of time goes into it and a lot of work so thank you everybody have a great holiday Miss clip again just echoing um Good Luck goodbye we always appreciate I always appreciated your very even and logical to demeanor um I'm a somebody that needs to think things out loud and I really do value um hearing other people's thought processes because it really doesn't anchor mine so thank you so much for that and enjoy time back with your family um thank you Mr Lampman this is some dense stuff and I appreciate uh the amount of work that goes into it uh thinking about our teachers and our kids this last week May the

075force be with you um enjoy the last few days and um especially to Administration and teachers this is a really fun time of the year but oh my goodness it's a lot of energy um Kaufman Foundation where I'm not sure where our community would be without them either uh we're so grateful for them um have a wonderful holiday break and stay safe everybody that's ready um I'll just follow suit here but um really have appreciated you know being on the board with you J it's uh your input and your experience and obviously your your passion and your love for our district goes deep in your family and um you know it it goes beyond just having their kids in the district and that's um of Great Value to our community um need more people like

076that and and just personally your your wisdom and your leadership um as I came on to the board was of Great Value particularly through covid and change of superintendence and so forth I appreciated the the leadership you all you and Kristen and Glen gave to the rest of us um I also really want to say thanks um we take it for granted um what our community does and along with our school systems to coordinate coats for every child is um in a place where it's very cold is um important and it shouldn't be a question it should be a given that every child has a coat to wear um thanks you guys have fun this coming break I really appreciate um hearing about all that you're doing in the schools and we'll try to make

077it up so um happy holidays to everybody thank you yeah make I already had a lot of time to speak earlier but thanks again to everybody uh for all the kind words and just best of luck to the board and our district and our schools and our students and everybody uh 2025 and going forward so thank you thank you uh we were going to name a street after you with that option had already been taken um that was clever oh I tried again personally it's been a pleasure working with you I happen to walk by your office quite a bit and it's nice to be able to stop in have a talk of your so often I still will do that um but now I'm just going to um kind of a vent so and

078as a retired board member you're just going to have to put up with it um but thank you for your contributions and your your sacrifices your family had to make this isn't a high-paying job by any means um there's a lot you have to do in the community while other people are relaxing and you take questions and and uh and reassure people about what the board's doing um and I think uh very appropriate for you to mention that kind of the successes the board has had the last few years and certainly your contribution to those successes has been great so I really appreciate your time I think on behalf of christen Kenzi she would like to thank everybody for the nomination um and I'm just glad I didn't miss the meeting otherwise I might have

079been nominated um uh we have some announcements other meetings um we have December 23rd through January 3rd uh these guys are going to be sleeping in at the end of the table it's winter break and there's no school um also Mr Sedwick won't have to get up early and see how the roads are during those days I'm sure he might do it out of uh out of habit uh January 6th is the organizational meeting uh 5:30 at the mshs library um uh and then uh the last item on the agenda is uh is uh uh to adjourn the uh meeting anybody willing to make that motion how about if you make that motion motion to adjourn okay Mr U is made a motion to adjourn there's support by Miss Ray um all those in favor

080say I I all those opposed

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.