CorpusRecord 202838

Portage Public Schools Board of Education Committee of the Whole Meeting - January 13, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Portage Public Schools
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Kalamazoo County, MI
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,148 words · about 51 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001uh this meeting of the board of education is called to order please uh stand and join us in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag of of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank everybody for being being here this evening happy to new here and we'll get started with approving our agenda are there any changes to the agenda as presented there are no changes to the agenda there are a couple of attachments or uh uh replacement uh documents in front of you at the table one is just a typo that was in ends policy 11 page five so you have that there and there was also a date incorrect date on the uh Board

002of bed meeting schedule so you have both of those attachments but it doesn't impact the the agenda flow glad we're going to meet on Monday and not Sunday let go it easier yeah is there a motion please to approve the agenda Mr President move the approve the agenda as presented thank you Emily that was hard to get is there a second second thank you all those in favor please say I I I opposed the motion passes we'll move forward with our agenda as presented and of course this is our organizational meeting and we have Bo Terry Mary Lou and Mark Stevenson who are elected to the board in November and all four have officially completed their acceptance and oath of office however as a ceremonial procedure the uh recently elected members will affirm the oath

003of office and the oath will be read out loud by superintendent beang each member name will be asked for his or her response Mark all right how do you want to do this you uh I guess maybe the new newly elected board members or all the elected board members probably stand up and get in front of the uh table here and I'll come around and read this another photo off too I won't get your shoes shoes are fun are we good right so after after uh after administering the oath I'll just you know point to you and you you will uh your appropriate response is I do like getting married all over again all right um do you Bo Snider Terry novaria Mary Lor and Mark Stevenson solemnly swear that you will support the Constitution

004of the United States and the constitution of this state and that you will Faithfully discharge the duties of the office of member of the Board of Education of port page Public Schools cazo County Michigan according to the best of your ability do I will I do I do thank you you're officially in you're stuck okay our next order of business is the election of officers uh the board's past president will officiate during the election of the president following election of the board president that person will conduct the election of the vice president and secretary the person conducting the election of each position will ask three times for nominations for each position the nominations will then be closed the person conducting the election or his or her designate will compile the votes and announce those candidates

005receiving two or more votes and how each board member voted election of off officers should be by a majority of the full board if only one person is nominated for an office the person conducting the election May declare that person elected by acclamation the nominee is elected to each position by a majority support of the board I'll start by asking for nominations for president Randy I would nominate Randy B for to serve as president people is there another nomination for president is there another nomination for president then by acclamation uh Randy van ANP is elected president all right hey thank you moving along are there any nominations for vice president Mr President I'd like to nominate Bo Snider as vice president thank you is there a second nomination for president vice president is there a

006second nomination for vice president and hearing none uh B Snider is elected vice president by acclamation congratulations B is there a nomination for secretary I'd like to nominate Terry novaria for secretary thank you is there a second nomination for secretary is there a third nomination for secretary then by acclamation Terry naria is elected Secretary of the board thank you and now we'll move to the superintendent's report mark thank you first item we have is a bond project update and uh Mr Edwards will provide most of that update thank you superintendent belang as well as members of the Board of Education uh first just wanted to uh share with the board that uh we had our staff walk through noting for Central uh Elementary School Central Elementary School was able to tour their building on Tuesday

007November 10th uh the vast majority of their staff uh were in attendance uh they were excited and the overwhelming response uh was the building is much larger than they had imagined which is a good thing uh havers Hill H Hills walkth through was re was scheduled for that Thursday December 12th unfortunately there was a snow day uh haers Hills walkth through has been rescheduled for Monday January 20th in terms of construction updates uh at Central L pretty much uh we have drywall throughout the school it's almost completely installed uh at the first floor the learning studios are classrooms uh the walls have been primed the first coat of paint has been apped painters have now move to the second floor learning Studios to work with painting um the exterior windows and all of the learning

008Studios have been installed uh you can really appreciate the different sizes and locations of the windows within those classrooms uh there will be an abundance of natural light throughout the school but particularly in the learning Studios um as well some casework has arrived that's being installed first floor learning Studios uh if you look at the ceilings the ceiling grids are also being installed along with some some of the classroom lights um the flooring is being installed in the restroom uh and electrical work continues throughout the school just moving over to ha Hill drywall the first floor learning Studios have been pretty much installed U they've had an opportunity to start and Prime and painting of the floor of the first floor Studios learning Studios uh drywall installation continues on the second floor uh as well

009as throughout corridors and hallways and the cafeteria uh exterior windows and all of the learning Studios have also been installed and uh electrical work continues throughout the building uh and then for Woodland later in today's agenda we finished our um our bid process and bid interviews and so later in today's agenda Anastasia and I will talk about uh the Woodland contracts that will come before you for a later recommendation that concludes my presentation and wonder if there are any questions I can answer for the board is there heat in the buildings yet no not official heat uh they have I would call temporary heat for the construction workers uh but much of the HVAC unit work particularly at Central ra has been installed um so no no official heat yet though okay thanks Johnny thank

010you and uh piggy backing on his report today was uh Bond sale date uh so Paul is here to give you just a little synopsis of what happened good evening board ofet and superintendent beling Mark ask me to give the board a quick update on the status of our bond sale today it's a very special day uh today was the planned third out of four series from the 2021 um ballot that went to the voters um we sold over a little over $43 million in bonds so 43.6 million if you want to be exact um they were all sold at a very competitive rate uh we will sign closing documents tomorrow and we are scheduled to receive proceeds in early February so just as a quick update to the board that is that the last

011series that's going to be sold or we have one more series any other questions all right I'm I'm always curious do you have a statistic as to how long it took them to sell out um we sold for about an hour and a half two hours this morning and then they had to go back out to fill the like the middle term length of the bonds so um that happened like over lunchtime and then we had a one 30 uh conference call back with people and everything is everything is good less than a day and they're all C thanks Paul than you and lastly uh this month is School Board member appreciation month which we fully intend to uh celebrate at our regular meeting in January and give our newest board members a chance to

012experience a meeting before they get celebrated um however um there were a couple of student there were some students in a couple of classrooms at moorsbridge elementary school that wanted to share their uh appreciation for you and so there are two rather large envelopes here thank you PPS School Board from Mrs jillick second graders and Mrs Walsh's second graders at moorsbridge and there's probably probably 25 or so uh letters in each one of these packets so I'll let you guys decide how you want to uh uh take a look at those and enjoy what they have to say but we'll have a more formal appreciation in at the regular meeting I'll and that's all I have on the report thanks Mark okay we move to um board education and that's the final presentation on Mon

013report 1.1 we've received presentations already in November on high school and last month on Elementary and uh this is a summary of what we've done right and just historically for the uh for the newest board members uh this report in past years has been broken up into three reports uh starting with elementary middle and then High School um this past year there were some changes to uh ends policy 1.1 uh as well as the some of the introductory statements um so we ended up diving the report into two and as Randy said one was presented in November and one in December this is a summary report and I should say this is more or less a draft summary report because um at The Retreat next uh at the end of the month uh it's on

014the agenda of the retreat to talk about this report to make sure that it's conveying the information that you're hoping to get uh and uh that we've interpreted it properly uh to uh capture your intentions as a board so uh there's there's still wiggle room on this it's a but it's it's what we would present now based on what we presented in November and December and how we uh would like to proceed but um these reports are usually followed by an approval by the board of the report um we've held off that approval until after you've had a chance to talk about it at the retreat then we can do it either that day or uh at the regular meeting or we can approach approve it at the first meeting in February so U hopefully

015you'll you'll have a that'll give you a chance to absorb the report today and uh and analyze it on your own and then you know coming back during the retreat I think will give us some time to to dig deep more deeply into it I appreciate that so Dr Pasco it's all yours thank you Mark good evening superintendent bang trustees um tonight we'll present the final summary of mr11 as Mark just mentioned uh congratulations to Mark and Mary Lou to your appointment and uh welcome back Bo and Terry we're glad you're back and and Randy as well so um we look forward to working with you as the school year progresses so we'll get into it um I'm going to take us back a little bit to the fall when Dr jinai presented on elementary

016middle and high school uh we reported on similar schools and kesa schools for the proficiency measures for all of our 13 buildings excluding Community High we don't include our alternative program in our data so there's three things that we looked at percent proficient so that's simply looking at how we did in a spring cycle meaning spring of 2024 uh we looked at percent proficiency Improvement so where we looked at current scores compared to a previous three-year average and in this case it was 200 um 19 22 and 23 and then we also look at growth so that's determined by the percent of PPS students within SGP that's that's an acronym for student growth percentiles of at least 30 so my school data defines average growth as sgps from 30 to 69 and above average growth

017for sgps from 70 to 99 so that was kind of our what we had to go off of I think it's important also to kind of step back as to how this criteria changed with our conversations not only with our administrators and some of our school teams but also within our Retreats that we had so we appreciate that dialogue that we had throughout last year coming into this year um and I just wanted to kind of walk back to see how those uh weights have changed and how those similar schools are um comprised so similar schools criteria is based on recommendations from our PPS schools and really preparation for our district data reviews um they had previously noted that the schools in our comparator districts so we were all kind of fitting all of our

018buildings compared to the same districts probably just over a decade or so and and some schools were saying it was very different in terms of their makeup demographically and that the comparisons weren't helpful at the building level so we made some changes and you saw the presentations in October and December so you can see on this Slide the breakdown of the Criterion weights compared to how we used to do it in monitoring report 1 so on the top is kind of that new criteria where we put 35% on total enrollment we at 40% economically disadvantaged we put 5% on some race and ethnicity and then students that receive specialized services for 5% so that's kind of the breakdown and then also we looked at per pupil expenditure not to exceed 125% of any our any

019of our schools meaning some of that hold harmless districts across the state that are still well overly funded than compared to porsh Public Schools we made sure that they weren't in any of these lists okay so essentially what we did was instead of comparing all of our schools to the same 10 districts and the schools within we found schools across the state for all 13 of our buildings that are most similar to them based off of that weight and that makeup so that was the big change so we'll get into some of the data so the first metric in mr11 summary looks at how each of our schools rank among its top 10 similar schools in percent proficient uh strictly on the spring 2024 State assessment so we use fifth grade for elementary schools we

020look at fifth grade mstep 8ighth grade for middle schools we look at PSAT 8 and for 11 grade at high school we look at sat and then we developed um these categories so the ranking in the top three uh are considered above expectations and those are shown in blue um fourth to sixth grade so fourth to sixth uh ranking they're considered at expectations so somewhere in the middle of the group and uh are shown in green and then schools ranking below six are considered below expect expectations and you see that in the red um on the right of each of these tables you see the kesa schools which we've included but we did not Define any expectations for them but you do see just as a comparison where we fell within the county and we

021also presented that uh back in October and December um you also notice that there's a couple elementary schools that don't show up on the kresa rankings and that's because my school data was not available so may maybe they had lower cohorts in terms of numbers or if they had a lower cohort with low Proficiency in there they wouldn't be reported so that's why you see 28 and 26 in terms of the ELA and the math rank for kesa schools but all the other middle schools and the high schools were accounted for when we look at kesa um so overall when we look at percent proficient uh we had eight of 13 schools at or above expectations in ela and we had six of 13 schools at or above expectations in math and that's within the

022similar schools list okay then the second metric and mr11 summary we look at how each of our schools rank amongs its 10 similar schools in percent proficient Improvement on the Spring 20124 State assessments and this ranks based on the difference between 2024 per proficient and the three-year average from 2019 2022 and 2023 perc proficient so essentially kind of how are we growing over time is what this one looks at again the top three are considered above expectations fourth through sixth are at and then anything below six would be below expectations and you see the colors accordingly so overall we had seven of 13 schools at or above expectations in ela and eight of 13 schools add expectations in math as it relates to percent proficient Improvement and then finally that third metric we look at

023is student growth on the spring 2024 State assessments and again that's determined by the percent of PPS students with an SGP of at least 30 so schools with 70 % or more students having average or above average growth were considered at expectations and you see that in green and schools with less than 70% of students having average or above average growth are considered below expectations and you see that in Red so it was either you got to 70% of kids meeting that student growth percentile or you didn't um so overall we have 11 to 13 schools at expectations in ela and a to 13 schools at expectations in math you saw this graphic in our last two presentations and it just gives a good summary of kind of our Focus around continuous Improvement and some

024of the branches that are connected to that professional development alignment curriculum review Cycles our test prep plans uh professional learning communities and PPS coaching framework uh but we want to go into more detail as to what the data is saying and kind of what it means to us and particularly implications in terms of what our work currently is and will be in the future so we're committed to ensuring all students achieve academic success with a particular focus on improving performance and Mathematics uh while sustaining and building on gains in English language arts Ela so when we look at percent proficient and percent proficient Improvement data uh we know that our students are continuing to per perform higher in ela than math and that our percent proficient improvement over the past few years we are seeing

025some bright spots occurring in comparison to similar schools schools uh some schools may have had a strong year in terms of straight proficiency but may be much lower in performance compared to the previous threee average so what does that mean it means that we need to keep our sense of urgency and we got to stay the course with our initiatives that we have in place when we look at growth summary uh we see even more positives in growth summary report we look at individual students making growth but we also know they're still not at the proficiency level yet so that's so important for our students who struggle and need to expedite their learning and show more than typical growth in order to reach proficiency at some point so this one we really pay attention to

026because this really tells the impact of our school system on our students as they go through our Continuum so our goal is to increase the trajectory of student performance in both Ela and math we want to ensure that all students have the opportunity to achieve proficiency and Beyond so two of our focuses efforts to address declining performance in math and leveraging ongoing initiatives with instructional coaching training professional development we want to empower the teachers to drive improve student outcomes so I remember Bo asking well what does this really mean to us so I want to give you some really um specific things that we're doing in both math and Ela around our strategic actions that you would see in the 2425 school year that will also lead into the 2526 school year so I'll start

027with Ela so we have the implementation of the new Ela curriculum and instructional strategies so right now K9 we're in the initial stages of implementation grades 10 through 12 we're currently in phase three of the curriculum review cycle and we're getting ready for that initial implementation so even though they say don't expect any big changes in data through to five years we're going to continue to monitor the data not only through mr11 but both in our district and our data uh reviews as the years go on and measure the impact of some of these changes um again this is why we have to stick to our plans as our teacher are they're all engaged in this intense learning uh the biggest shift is that our Ka students are engaged in daily reading and writing integrated

028lessons that's happening now consistently which may not have been happening in the last few years the second difference is we're using coaching to engage in complex text uh the teacher helps to guide students by stretching their thinking and their skills so we have reading Specialists and our El Ela coaches they're engaged in unit launches and coaching Cycles to support teachers with implementation of some of these new resources and then lastly in ela we're in the process of getting all K through five teachers and administrators trained in letters uh this is a big accomplishment and it's more robust training than you would receive in undergr in terms of teaching and supporting kids on how to read and write and you guys have heard of uh some of the letters initiatives that we have so I think

029we're one of the leading uh districts in terms of the amount of teachers that we've trained um talking to Courtney Huff one of our um uh instructional coaches we've had 80 teachers trained already and we have another 80 that are currently engaged in training so at some point we'll have over 160 teachers that have gone through that so essentially it's a comprehensive professional learning that's designed to provide Early Childhood Elementary Educators and administrators with deep knowledge to be literacy and language experts in the science of reading so that's the gist of letters in terms of math uh through the curriculum review cycle process we've researched standards of mathematical practice we've identified next steps that will help us focus on developing a strong instructional framework with accessible practical and actionable resources so uh Dr shien and

030Dr uh speaker GTH Simer are lead Network as we speak um one of the activities that we'll be engaged in over the next few months is learning walks so District as well as building learning walks so a kind of a combination of of teams uh we know that students are changing the way that they learn and maybe some of our past practices May no longer be effective um so the shift NE uh necessitates kind of a re-evaluation of our practices and strategies so additionally not every administrator feels confident or prepared to work and support uh our Math teachers uh where the content may be more rigorous outside of their areas of expertise so we're hoping that these walks will help address some of those challenges and uze this as a professional development tool for all

031of us um these will focus on specific themes instructional practices we'll look at student engagement questioning techniques and formative assessment and by implementing the learning walks we can collect some baseline data to identify some of the needs that will have implications for professional development for the remainder of this year and going into the 25 26 school year and this is being done through our own math instructional coaches but also in partnership with two of the kesa math coaches as well so we're excited about that um another identified next step is with our K5 teachers in building intentional practices that incorporate student talk and engagement through our math learning Labs that allows students the opportunity to discuss and show their thinking so K5 math learning Labs will provide the opportunity to see practices learned from our

032professional development implemented into our own classroom so we're excited about that as well and then Nath lastly as it relates to math our six through eight teachers they've been engaged in Cooperative learning professional development ment where they learn Hands-On approaches to having students in any content area collaborate with one another so this ties into the focus of student discourse and math and other areas and we know that students who can discuss math concepts quickly they form deeper connections and a better understanding of the concepts so by maintaining some of that momentum we've seen in ela and addressing some of the challenges in math with targeted strategies we can ensure that all students have that opportunity to succeed so together our goal is to drive meaningful progress across all areas and continue the work so that's

033kind of the mr11 summary in a nutshell I have my Superstar team with me here as well so if anyone's got any questions or comments based off of what's been presented up until this point we would love to hear it could you explain what a learning walk is you've explained the benefits of it but what is it yeah so um I mean I know Tracy if you want to I can describe it a little bit or if you want to give more detail yeah so what we're going to do is in a small group we're going to visit every math teacher in our high schools that's where we're going to begin so we'll use a rubric that's derived from the mathematical practices which are like high high leverage instructional practices that we want to see

034in the classroom it's not going to be for the purposes of evaluating the teachers but rather for us to identify Trends see what we need to do for professional development and plan accordingly fantastic thank you I like that you have a plan and targets and you know are proceeding forward so you've identified needs and you're going right at it and that's great thanks Terry I know there's a there's always been a sense of urgency on our team and I think the more that we're in tune with the building needs are what our administrators and our teachers need I think we'll have that Collective sense of urgency to help see improvement over the years um there's I have no choice but to have a sense of urgency with these here but we have wonderful folks so

035it's just a matter of staying Focus stay the course there's a lot of great things in play we have a lot of great people in the right positions and I think it's just a matter of time before we turn some of you know that data around that you've seen over the last couple years I really appreciate the focus on supporting teachers because we have amazing teachers here who have such a heart for children um knowing that they know that they're support fantastic absolutely agree with you I think um so what our retreat in a couple weeks we'll have a chance to just kind of talk through this more and I I think for me um a key part will be kind of you know making sure we know what the board's are and you know

036we we chose the word favorable comparisons to peer districts and making sure that that's embedded um in here and we're kind of all on the same page and um kind of all you know working out of the same Himel um on that so could be one of those you know three-hour discussions where we're quarreling over four or five words well we want to make sure that we're interpreting what your intent is properly um we also want to make sure you're getting the right level of information without you know spending days and days and days organizing I mean we're already spending a lot of time providing information gathering information but you know we want to find that balance with what works at this board level for the district um without getting too far into the weeds

037um well yeah I mean you you kind of know what my preferences are I know us I thought the level of detail in November and December and tonight for me really good I mean because it it tends to bring you know these these data points together and they're they not a million of them but you had them in nice grids kind of like by by educational area by building I mean that that really worked for me um you know I would I would just I mean you know uh making sure we're all on the same page in terms of How High we're setting the bar and I mean you know my preference is to try to stretch right uh but it's also to be fair um and kind of striking you know striking the right

038balance so I just I really look forward to any conversations we have about that and just trying to figure that out as a board and an admin team yeah so picking up on your uh issue of fairness you saw the the red and green uh so far um and you know the these reports um and play into this superintendent evaluation so um I have a for one and a vested interest making sure there is fairness here um but yet satisfy the board and and not make it look like we're we're we're where we want to be in uh our student performance so um yeah I think that discussion on the 27th will be good and I've always really appreciated I mean over the years you guys have been really Frank about when there's red on

039the scorecards um I I mean I appreciate it we appreciate the willingness that the board has to invite us into the Retreats and just have that open dialogue to to to get it to the right Point uh just to piggyback on what superintendent bang said and we look forward to those four conversations and any tweaks or changes that you know we'll need to make we'll be more than open to do that and uh just for all of us to be on the same page I think is extremely helpful so thanks for that I want to clarify I'm not appreciative of the red on the scorecards I'm appreciative of the frankness of just the frankness I mean that's that's super important we want to see more blue um but but yeah but yeah the frankness is

040good the other goes with where we set the bar I mean it's easy to set a low bar and be green on everything um but we're trying to find that stretch area that will push us to uh to do better the other thing we didn't mention is um you know since we've been presenting it in this way uh we've had so many buildings reach out to us to say hey can you relay that data to us we want to take a look at that we want to look at that similar schools list we want to start reaching out to folks and uh I Dr shien's put together just a spreadsheet for our Middle School administrators for example and we're just starting to kind of formulate and organize when people do reach out to see what

041kind of things that they have in place whether it's curricular whether it's intervention um Etc and so we're going to start to learn from the folks and like we talked about in The Retreat hopefully you know we can keep these similar schools lists play for a few years so we can kind of see how it plays out as we learn from other districts as well um the red up there there's some really competitive and some really wonderful communities comparing to some of you know our porsh public school so you know hey you know every now and then we are going to have some red because if you look at who's in the similar schools list like Mark said we didn't set this up to for us to be all green it's it's actually the opposite

042of that it's put all of our schools in a really challenging similar schools list but one in which they could look at and say all right demographically makeup wise we are very similar to these nine or 10 so now let's let's learn from one another so I think what we intended to do at the start of this I think it's it's trending that way again more than open to making tweaks along the way and and looking forward to those conversations in some of the upcoming RS with all of you I think you highlighted the best part of this data that we can have numbers and charts and graphs and colors and it'd be absolutely useless and this data with especially with the way it's been reworked um what I'm hearing is that this is being

043used to benefit the students and that's huge great thanks k i uh just appreciate the way you're responded to our new end statement with the monitoring reports that you did I think the monitoring reports are excellent and I'm really pleased we added growth as part of what we're looking at rather than how did our kids do on a test on one day I mean these growth numbers are they show that there's a lot of learning going on here so very good to see thank you we look forward to the conversation uh at The Retreat yeah thanks to these ladies and also thanks to Melissa O'Keefe our office in CIA just helping you know she's the the lady behind all the numbers and and again I say it every time but she's the reason why we're

044able to come up here and somewhat make sense of all the data for all of you and so we really appreciate her and I really appreciate these three ladies cuz it's you know Kelly and I may be up here doing the presentation but there's a lot that happens behind the scene in order to get the slide deck and and the monit report packeted to you guys so just appreciate everyone on the team that's all involved in this so thank you all right thank you okay we'll move to our comments and communication section I believe we have one speaker tonight and that's Katie pic okay Frank sent her in to talk to us in this lousy weather so we appreciate um so I'm Katie pic I am here on behalf of the Pea um and I'm

045one of the negotiators as well um I have this for you to if you would like um so I'm only here for the good news so she did send me for good stuff um so we have been collecting as you know um but for our new board member we've been collecting stories from throughout the districts of all the good news that's been happening um so I have a few that I will highlight here on this um the one that I believe was highlighted in the district memo was the very first one um in December uh Portage Northern student Senate and Portage Central student council presented um representatives from the Pediatric heart transplant team from University of Michigan CSM children's hospital with the the check for 4,861 and2 um which was according to them the single

046greatest student Le fundraising donation for them ever in their history um which is incredible um and that was from bradli that they did back in November um in addition to that from Sarah not at Portage Northern she actually wanted to highlight the art teacher here at Central High School Liz Honeys set they did a popup art show um during the last few hours of the week I believe right before um winter break and classes came out to look at all the jewelry their students made um and they were able to just kind of trade and and buy things and it worked out really well for them um the last list is a lot of things ha Hill has been busy they have been up to a lot um Mark hagaman was saying that they have

047they adopted some families for the holiday season they donated canned goods at the Portage Community Center um they did their first peer-to-peer movie night and it was a smashing success they started a form for parents to fill out that's posted outside of classrooms where they can express why they're thankful for teachers um and last but not least Jeremy zance um received the award for outstanding administrator of the year um by the Michigan music Education Association because of his support for the music program so there was just like a lot happening between November December so I'm really excited to share that with you yeah thanks so much for having me here and D here tonight it's a good reminder of all the things that teachers do in this District besides just teach they're involved in a

048lot of things and we appreciate that so thank you thank you for having me that are there any comments from board trustees this evening well I just want to welcome the new board members looking forward to working with you guys glad you're here thank you no uhuh I just want to say it's great to be here I'm really happy and excited to work with the board and I just thank everybody that helped make it possible that's sitting at this table tonight good good you know else Randy I'll have a quick go um thanks to you for agreeing to continue as board president um well thanks for to you for continuing that's my pleasure um but people you know people watch the meetings and they watch how the chair behaves and kind of how you handle

049things and you do it so well but what people don't understand is that's about that's the tip of the iceberg of everything that you do um and the seriousness that you take our governance model and the ongoing education and the research that you do with other school boards that use that model and we kind of Steal ideas from them and adopt them you do all that kind of stealing you do that at your computer at 11:00 p.m. um and a few of us know that and I just wanted to acknowledge that so thank you Terry well thank you um thank you for for your hard work Kimberly thank you for your ongoing engagement on the board and our newcomers Mark and Mary Lou welcome aboard um Katie yeah she's there Katie and Cat really appreciate

050the reports that have been given here um this year it's a breath of fresh air honestly it's our part appreciated so appreciated and then I want to thank an individual who I think um slipped out but Tom Tarlton who's a citizen um who is just really into Local School Board elections and he just really thinks that um the local school district is a very important part of the community and he's he's very engaged and very helpful and then kind of nerding out um did you notice during the oath that we do not take an oath to serve this community we take an oath to follow the Constitution that's what the oath is and I like to remind people that because I mean we're trustees we're not legislators we're basically trustees over an important local institution

051and our number one job is to follow the laws and sometimes that's really unpopular there are a whole lot of things that are constitutional that people just don't know about and we have to do certain things and um so anyway just wanted to nerd out for a minute so I think that's it Randy thanks well thank you thank you for your kind words B and uh I too look forward to working with everyone on the board and having another successful year at Portage public school so thank you thank you very much I wanted to also welcome Mary Lou and Mark it's always nice I think we have a nice blend of people who have been here a long time and people who are new so that we get that differing perspectives in such an amazing

052way and welcome okay very good um we'll move to the consent agenda it's pretty lengthy start with the organizational items a designate deposit the following depositories for school funds comp one Flagstar Bank Horizon Bank Huntington Bank JP Morgan Chase macala Bank mertile Bank pfm investment management and Southern Michigan Bank and Trust B approve the 2425 and 2526 board meeting schedules as presented C designate persons authorized to use the safety deposit box as the superintendent assistant superintendent of operations Director of Finance and board secretary D designate the electronic transfer officer as Paula Johnson Director of Finance e appoint the board recording secretary as Barb Atkinson F approved trun Law Firm PC as the boards and districts primary legal counsel and G pre-approved the 2025 board member attendance at board related classes conferences workshops Etc and approve

053reimbursement for actual and necessary expenses incurred to attend set events as per bylaw 0 175. one and finally uh the monthly consent agent items the December 9th 2024 special meeting close session and regular meeting and the Neola policy revisions 1130 3110 4110 6110 6111 6112 6114 6325 7310 7450 31208 53 3.02 5340 and 8321 as presented are there any exceptions to the consent agenda items super the consent agenda items are approved thank you now there are boards that take those one at a time with a motion for ease you know we just flew through this you kind of enjoyed rattling off all those section see if I can still do it yeah yeah okay um next we go to page 36 Assurance of District performance monitor report 2.9 emergency superintendent succession is there a motion

054please on page 36 president I'm an answer I move that the Board of Education accept as presented the monitoring report on 2.9 emergency superintendency session as of reasonable interpretation and evidence of compliance with policy thank you Terry is there a second second thank you Mark this is uh a rather routine uh policy that's or monitoring report that's presented and uh basically says that there are in case of an emergency there are a few people in the district that are um able to step up and and do the work um primarily uh Dr Pasco and Mr Edwards uh two assistant superintendents in the district uh and they're supported by uh several members of the executive team who also contribute uh quite heavily in the uh monitoring report process and are very familiar with policy governance as

055well so uh we also have some administrative guidelines that uh um that address situations where I may be incapacitated for short periods of time um so we've I think we've got all the bases covered if there were to be an emergency so happy to answer any questions if you have them well it's an EXC excellent report and it's it's so important if you need it you know it's really good it's there and there is I forgot to mention there is our current organizational chart here that kind of gives you a sense of of the Who's Who uh at the higher levels of administration and who uh which departments and programs they responsible for questions all those in favor of approving monitoring report 2.9 emergency superintendent succession please say I I opposed the motion passes thank

056you you and we'll now move to a required action item the ha Hill public easements and bill of sale a motion please on page 41 Mr President I move that the board of education grant a water main easement combined water main and sanitary sewer easement and bill of sale at the H Hill site to the city of Portage as presented thank you well is there a second second second thank you thank you again um this is our recommendation for um water M easement combin water M and sanitary sewer easement as well as a bill of sell at the H Hill site the city of Portage I'm joined tonight by Jeff Paulson uh Jeff is the senior project manager at Hurley and Stewart hurle and Stewart is a major partner with us uh by way of

057Tower pinkster with a lot of our engineering type work that occurs along with the construction uh obviously um they work with us but in addition to their work with p schools they also work closely with the city of Portage because of his uh in-depth work with the city of Portage he has a profound understanding of the requirements related to this work this is a uh recommendation that um you will be needed in the future for Central Elementary School as well and down the road for Wood Elementary School and uh I just want to pause because you have some documents in your possession and there are four areas that uh Jeff has helped us to lay out this is work has been done with plant Moran real point this is also uh our owner rep St

058as a mentioned civil engineering firm uh We've also consulted Dr law fir our attorney and this work with the uh city of porage to plan design and construct the water main and utilities I just ask Jeff to be here just to give a high level overview of what the technical terms mean and if there are any questions he can get okay good evening um appreciate the time here today to kind of button up these loose ends on the ha Hill project so essentially the point of these documents is to transfer the owners ship of the materials that were purchased and installed by the district purchased by the district and installed by the contractor so that's the bill of sale document that you see there it's kind of listing out those Public Utilities that um the

059district currently owns because they paid for them um and transferring the ownership of those uh those items to the city then the other two documents that you see there are the water main eement and then the it's really a combined um water and sanitary easement so those are essentially give the city rights to enter the the district property um to own and maintain those public utilities which by the bill of sale have been transferred to the city so that's a really high level view of um kind of what's needed here there's there's multiple other documents that have to go to the city to kind of close out the construction process associated with those Public Utilities so um just happy to answer any questions that you have now if you remember going back you know we

060had to relocate Water and Sewer on that site because uh it was further onto the property and interfered with where we wanted to put our school and so we moved those utilities over and had to redo the easement that existed so that's a little background on that one too yeah and as John mentioned too this will come up on Central and um Woodland and other schools um if they progress is even though we're not relocating utilities on those projects we're still putting in a new public water man around the building so we'll come back for the same same signatures on on similar documents and so just to clarify this is a very common thing for situations like this this is just how it's done exactly yeah whether it's an easement for a water main on

061a a commercial or residential development this just happens to a school that needs the and it needs your your signatures on it so yeah it's a very very typical we pay for it to go in then we sell it back to the city so it's all part of the city's infrastructure exactly well it's good that all this is being cleaned up at this time because we ran into some things that weren't cleared up 50 or 60 years ago so this is good and all we could get was a dollar from the city unfortunately we did the best we could okay all right any questions okay all those in favor of approving the ha Hill public easements and bill of sale please say I I I opposed uh the motion passes thank you and now we'll

062move to our action items and uh the next three I think uh Ryan is going to be at the podium and I think Ryan already went through these with us uh last year so uh I think it's just a little review for us Ryan thank you last year sounds so long ago so on page 60 on excuse me on page 55 there's a motion to approve the video switching devices for Central and havv there a motion Please Mr President I move that the Board of Education approve as presented the purchase of Altona at Lona video switching devices from live space for the new Central and H Hill Elementary Schools in the amount of 79,2 the funds for which will come from the two 2021 bond fund thank you Kimberly is there a second second thank

063you Ryan any questions those so these these devices are the little magic boxes that do all the allow the the teacher to display from multiple devices not just the like keep pointing back there because there's a teacher station back there but there's already a computer hooked to the teacher station but if if they want to show from document camera or their Chromebook or laptop or whatever device they bring that little magic box allows them switch between that's what it does any other questions on that okay all those in favor of approving the video switching devices for the new Central and H Hill please say I I oppose the motion passes next we have an action item for teaching desk for the new Central and H Hill there's a motion please on page 48 president V

064the Board of Education approv presented the purchase of Technology en teaching tests from Teel systems for the new Central and hah Hill Elementary Schools in the amount of $195 627,000 the funds for which well I read that wrong um $195,600 note that this vendor and this specific desk is the same that we ended up using in the new middle schools and so it's a product that we're very familiar with you might have noticed that the the bid came in higher but that's why we made the intention to come in and say really meet our specifications and and what we know works well and we've had very good success with those good good any questions for Ryan all those in favor of approving the teaching desk for the new Central and haill please say I I

065opposed uh the motion passes our next action item is video surveillance equipment for the new Central and ha Hill there's a motion please on page 61 president V answer I move that the Board of Education approve has presented the contract with Parkway electric for video surveillance equipment and installation at the new Central and H Hill Elementary Schools in the amount of$ 67,341 cents which includes a 20% contingency the funds for these video surveillance projects will come from the 2021 bond fund thank you Terry is there second second thank you so V surveillance just a fancy term for security cameras right so following the standard of what we have in the other schools and and uh we like the approach on that as well but any questions let me know hearing none oh those in favor

066of approving the video surveillance equipment for the new Central and H Hill please say I I I opposed the motion passes thank you thank you and we move to our next action item which is the Central and ha Hill Furniture purchase and if you recall we had quite a lengthy presentation on that I believe last month there's a motion please on page 64 Mr President I move that the Board of Education approve as presented the purchase of furniture for Central Elementary and HH Hill Elementary Schools in an amount not to exceed 2,764 738 32 the funds of which will come from the 2021 bond fund thank you Kimberly is there a second I'll second a motion thank you as Randy mentioned U last year December uh Paul Henry and Shelby from our Pure uh went

067through a pretty Leng the presentation related to the furniture and that furniture is primarily exclusively um around the classroom Furniture the student Furniture within the learning Studios uh but the recommendation that you're uh we're asking for approval tonight includes uh furniture for the larger communities or Commons area it includes offices uh the educator workshops which is where that will be the learning spaces for the teachers and then also for the uh Furniture that's going to be in the cafeteria as well so it's it's pretty much all inclusive uh as we've shared in the um in the previous presentation the furniture is dynamic it's fluid it's engaging it's Forward Thinking and collaborative there will be an array of different Furniture choices for the students uh throughout their learning Studios and then we'll have kind of what

068I call the standard um type furniture for our educated workshops but also in our cafeteria space is the uh furniture will have an array of choices for students even in the cafeteria area um the work that Shelby and Paul has done uh has been uh invaluable to us and they've worked with um our R vendors uh in this project and also on previous projects and then we've worked through the competitive bid pricing and this amount also uh includes a substantial savings from what was projected initially so uh hats off to the entire team for working through this uh recommendation collectively that savings was over $600,000 that's really good wow really good yeah any questions for Johnny on this one I said it last time and I'll say it again I really appreciate the care and

069thoughtfulness that went into choosing the furniture that was chosen Rand I I would say you know there are people in our community who haven't been inside an elementary school in 50 or 60 years I think if they walked inside these schools they would be abolutely amazed at what's going on and how they're equipped and how how learning happens today absolutely absolutely and know this equipment has been trial too so work so that's that's great that's great correct um and with great feedback from the teachers that were piloting the furniture in both schools as well as the students who experien it each day um and to be able to have a St classroom uh with Pilot Furniture as well as using the uh the new furniture with the exist with the carpet it's also going to

070be in the Learning Studio so that was a good uh piece and what's not obviously included in this but um by the uh students being able to demo the carpet the teachers also wanted to see how durable it is and so over the last year we've gotten a lot of positive feedback on how the carpet works with the Furniture so that's that's pretty cool for us good any other comments on the furniture okay then everyone in favor of purchasing the furniture for Central and H Hill please say I I opposed the motion passes thank you now have a discussion item revision to policy 6550 travel pay and reimbursement Mark so uh thank you Randy uh 6550 was presented to you last month for our first reading uh we noticed at since that time that we

071we left off an item that we would reimburse for and actually encourage people to gather and that's travel insurance for uh any flights that they may choose so that's being that that's been added and reintroduced for first reading so nothing else has changed and it's this is incorporated all of the other uh language that was previously presented so if there are no questions we'll put this on the uh consent agenda for next month next meeting is there any support for bringing this to action right now I'm willing great could we have a motion to bring this item to action Mr President I move that we bring this to action thank you is there a second second thank you all those in favor of bringing the revision to policy 6550 to action please say I I

072I opposed the motion passes and then we need a motion to approve revision to the policy Mr President I move that we approve uh travel payment and reimbursement policy 6550 uh as amended thank you B are second second thank you all those in favor please say I I opposed uh the motion passes and revisions to the policy are approved and now we're getting to the big discussion item and that's the construction contracts for the new Woodland project thank you again join tonight by Anna sh Anastasia woek she's the assistant project manager for kemell our construction management firm as we have worked through uh the design of um of Willen Elementary School with uh tower pster building International uh our CM firm has helped us with uh putting the work out to bid um in addition

073to the work bid and advertisement of various sites um we also had an opportunity to have an opening of the bids that was public so that all contractors could see uh where their bid came in at and then we also had a couple of days of post bid interview used with all of our uh vendors who were the lowest qualified bid uh in total there were total of 133 different um bids submitted from the various categories approximately 64% of those contractors were within a 1H hour radius of of Port so we average three to four bids per uh or c p per per category uh including in our recommendation is just a letter of support for my owner rep plant Moran and then I'll ask Anastasia to walk the board through uh the various categories

074thanks Johnny good evening everyone um I'm going to run through your bid tab there um kind of pointing out each one and anything that might be of interest to you um if you guys have any questions along the way please please feel free to stop me at any point um first though I did actually want to point out on your award summary um at the very bottom that we came in under budget we came in 1, 15788 35 under our anticipated budget so that was great news ready to see that starting out it's really good yeah starting out with bid category one earthwork uh the lowest qualified bid was from USA Earthworks LLC with a bid of 1,66 $ 68,69 bid category 4 irrigation with a low bid from Summit Landscape Management uh 93,471 moving

075on to bid Category 5 concrete low bid was from Choice Concrete Construction their bid was 1, 12877 se0 bid category six polished concrete our low bid was early in Associates Incorporated with a bid of $134,000 bid category 7 pre-cast structural concrete our low bid was from fabcon pre-cast LLC with a bid of $251,700 with a low bid of $2,833 600 bid category 9 Metals our low bid was FCC construction at 1, 93,000 Mid category 10 General trades was hazelhoff Builders with their bid at $1,412 th000 moving on to bid category 11 metal wall panels our low bid was reliable sheet metal at $394,950 bid category 12 Roofing so this one was a little bit different our low bid was the Trident Roofing Solutions however they had an error in their bid and had a drop

076they did not have the correct product specified in their bed so they were not able to hold their number we then had a um our postfit interview with cni Building Maintenance who did end up having a complete bid and their number was 789,6 40 bid category 13 joint sealant uh slager restoration and sealant with a low bid of 31565 moving on to bid category 14 doors frames and Hardware sa Mormon and company with a bid of 55,940 and there's a couple notes on this one with voluntary alternates that um we recommend accepting one of field welding for Hollow Metal Frames type 9 and 10 for an ad of $1,500 and including one lond Model 1204a E cabinet for an ad of $965 bid category 15 Overhead Doors our low bid was from partition systems with

077a bid of 27,7 125 bid category 16 aluminum glass and glazing our low bid was foring glass with a bid of 1,979 34 bid category 17 lathe plaster drywall and acoustical our low bid was soie Company Incorporated at 1,929 1870 mid category 18 flooring our low qualified bid was Great Lakes floor coverings at 635,000 bid category 19 resilient athletic flooring again to soie Company Incorporated with their bid at 8,490 Big category 20 painting you'll notice here we have another revision as well so heligan painting was the red low number however they also had to drop their bid they did not include all of the wall coverings that were outlined in their scope of work so they were not able to include those and hold their number we then um had a post bit interview with

078VOR Brothers Painting and their bid came in at 427 6,000 bid category 21 visual display units our low bid was Sig Jan products at 26390 bid category 22 signage um universal sign Systems Incorporated with a bid of 44867 bid category 23 food service equipment our low bid was Great Lakes West at 247,000 bid category 25 playground equipment um our low bid was Sinclair Rec Recreation at 35,600 bid category 26 window shades product Resource company with a bid of 75,200 bid category 27 educational case goods our low bid was kuster at 53,9 38 b c category 28 elevators our low bid was con Incorporated at 131,00 in category 29 fire protection um our low bid was burgrave fire protection incorporated at 232,000 bid category 30 DDC controls was control net at 74200 800 what's a DDC

079control I was wondering the same it's I'm trying to think of the easiest way to it's the the pieces that control your like HVAC equipment um so it's the yes um bid category 31 mechanical and plumbing our low bid was DHE plumbing and mechanical with a base bid of 4,294 th000 and Alternate one um double wall duct pricing at 17,500 bid category 32 testing and balancing our low bid was Third Coast test in balance at 19,400 in category 34 electrical um our low bid was Allied Electric at 2,8 11,000 they also had a voluntary alternate that we recommend um that was an optional 4 in spare feeder for $7,500 bid category 35 audio visual systems our low qualified bid was Blue Water Technologies Technologies Group Incorporated with a bid of 29,7 in category 36 clock

080systems our low qualified bid was digital age Technologies with a bid of $ 27,9 three bid category 37 public address our low qualified bid was Parkway electric and Communications LLC at uh Datacom Group Incorporated at 163,00 they had a voluntary alternate for adding in the uh paging speaker cabling for $1 16,117 we recommend that as uh cabling for those speakers were not picked up in the structured cabling category so they filled a u missing piece of the scope bid category 39 access control and intercom systems the low qualified bid was Parkway electric and Communications LLC at 68,4 answer any questions the board might have as relates to uh W and construction bid process or packages well we can't offer much expertise on the bid categories appreciate you going through all that and what's important to

081us is the process you follow to get there and we have a lot of confidence in the process you follow because it's worked so well on the other buildings and it's really good to see plant Moran and Oak working together with us and uh coming up with these recommendations we appreciate all the work that went into this so thank you thank you okay our final discussion item of the evening is Administrative updates and handbook changes welcome Brad even belang before you as a memo in outlining uh changes to the administrator handbook and again under uh board executive limitations uh no changes can happen to administrator pay or benefits without board approval so we outlin those here um highlights of course are um listed on the memo you also have a complete copy of the administrative

082handbook at your at your places um the main thing I want to talk about is um we've had some new regulations come into State under the revised school code about mentors and administrators requiring mentors so we've added in pay for that that pay actually is H comparable to what we do with our teachers and our Mentor teachers there so we want to make sure we're in a comparable space there um we also have language around the uh tuition reimbursement that reflects the changes the board approved last year to adopt the um IRS Section 127 regulations with tuition reimbursement and then um we had a recommendation uh Paul has been doing some good work trying to update our 403b compliances and they recommended we add specific language so we literally added the end of a sentence

083there that talks about any retirement Inc of payments would be made to the administrator's 403b account instead of just there would be a payment made so again trying to limit it there and then because of the office of Retirement Services they're asking more and more questions and requiring us to put more and more information and um be able to show when it's been approved by the board I've included the administrator pay scale that's the last page of the administrator handbook so you'll see that in there I also realized that probably means you'll be seeing me up here almost every year up in the administrator handbook to update that set scale so uh more work for me which I'm thrilled about um want to while I'm up here just provide a couple of updates around some

084our administrators uh Katie stole one of mine with uh Mr Zant getting the award from the Michigan uh music educators as as the outstanding administrator so we're really pleased to see that uh one of the things Dr Pasco talked about as well with the letters training so in addition to all of our teachers going through it all of our elementary principles will also be getting trained through the letters so they're going to be able to see firsthand what all is going to be happening in the classrooms in their building as well so we're excited about that uh actually Dr jinius told me today that we had 18 boxes of letters materials arrived today one of those 18 has the administrators with materials in it we just don't know which one yet so I wanted to

085give a shout out to our uh administrators at Northern High School Dylan Patterson Kelly hinga Chris rker as well as Dr Pasco for stepping up in the uh absence of Mr louder who's out on a medical leave right now so we hope to have him back shortly um also talking about uh tuition we actually have a couple of our administrators who are still taking advantage of our tuition reimbursement so we have uh Effie McCarron just started her classes uh this past weekend up at Grand Valley and uh Johnny Edwards is uh closing in on uh becoming Dr Edwards so he is near to the end there so uh we'll look forward to celebrating him there and I'd be remissed my final piece of the administrative update is to uh wish my colleague and friend uh

086Miss Paula Johnson happy birthday with that I will turn it back over to the superintendent thanks Brad I guess the the last update it's it's I guess there's no other way to say it other than you know it's my intention to kind of let you know that my intention to retire at the end of this school year so at the end of June um it's been a great great 12E run here in Portage being able to work with some magnificent people uh including board members who have of uh their hearts in the right place uh with the uh um interest of our children always uh at the front at the Forefront um really proud of what we've been able to accomplish over those years a lot of uh upgrades to facilities and I I think

087sometimes that overshadows a lot of the work that's happening in our schools with changing and improving our culture with looking at improving our systems and uh and you know constantly looking for ways to to improve the things that we do in in service to our students in our community so it's really been an honor uh to to be part of this team I really believe that we've had the right people in the district at the right time to accomplish what we've done and have every bit of confidence that uh that that work will continue uh with someone else at the home so thank you very much thank you [Applause] well Mark there'll be more to say later but we certainly appreciate you being here and it's it's been quite a run we're we're better off

088for having you here and uh we wish you uh the best in your retirement you've certainly earned it thank you very much thank you um and with that um we're going to need the monitoring report evaluation forms and I need the board meeting self assessment forms and we are adjourned thank you okay so it's 2.9

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.