001yeah now now we're just I didn't um trying out I got a um tablet for myself okay I'm trying out annotating on it do you like it I am liking it cool but it means that I didn't unstaple this like I nor so we'll see how that happens it works or doesn't [Music] work yeah I just it's handy having it okay this meeting of the board of education is now called to order please stand and join us in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge alleg to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all the welcome welcome everyone to our meeting this evening and we'll get started by approving our agenda are there any changes to the
002agenda as printed I have one I would like to add an action item to uh pass some resolutions of appreciation for our retiring board members and uh we'll put that in the action item session is that okay with everybody yes okay very good all those uh who approve the approve the agenda as presented please say I motion passes and uh w move on to the superintendent's report great thank you our our major uh report for tonight we just have one is the bond project update and Johnny Edwards will lead with that thank you superintendent be Lang as well as uh members of the board Public Schools Board of Education um we're going to do a budget pres I'm sorry Furniture presentation but before we get into that I just want to share with the board
003that um we're taking the staff of HH Hill and Central Elementary to through their school tomorrow after school after the construction day ends uh Central's walkthr is tomorrow and ha Hill's walk through is on Thursday uh both uh walkthroughs begin at 4:30 and being in both buildings staff are really excited and looking forward to seeing the inside of their schools uh in terms of Woodland uh Woodland uh the uh construction work is out for bid and we plan to open the bids on Monday December 8 December 16 looking forward to that and then our third portion is related to our furniture presentation I'm joined tonight by Shelby ice minger he is the senior interior designer and Paul Henry who's the senior Furniture designer designer both from Tower kingster in the audience is Doug Milbourne who's
004our project manager uh we have held Gallery Furniture Gallery walks for both staffs we held one at uh on December 2nd for Central Elementary School and there teachers had an opportunity to see the presentation that we're going to give you tonight uh and then also the following day December 3rd we had another gallery walk for the staff at hah Hill both events were well attended and staff had great questions and they really love the furniture Concepts and as you get into tonight's presentation my colleague Dr Kelly jinius reminded us reminded me of a conversation we had with a student at HH Hill actually two students as we were concluding our presentation with the staff a young lady came up to Dr jinius and she had a huge smile on her face and and as uh
005the interaction went uh we asked for about her excitement her excitement was about the new school at hayil and Dr jinia has asked her what's your favorite part of the building and she says the cafeteria and we say well why and she said because we'll have Circle tables um few seconds later another young man came up to us similar what's your favorite part of the building the cafeteria and why cuz we're going to have Circle T uh I think that's a good segue absolutely Furniture presentation um tonight all right thank you Johnny I appreciate it uh so along that we could dive into the psychology of table shapes and why circles excite kids but that's really not why we're here tonight exciting nonetheless and great that our youngest Learners and our youngest users are excited
006by what they're seeing in the small glimpses we're giving them ahead uh what is our goal tonight like Johnny has shared is to give you the same update we gave staff the last couple of weeks and then also give you a little more insight into the process we've followed so far and what's next for purchasing Furniture so uh from a very high level where we've been what process did we take where are we now and where are we going hopefully quite simple um we will share this presentation that has a lot of detail please ask any questions we're happy to answer any you might have and make it as discussion based as you wish or we can run through and if you have questions at the end we're happy to dive in from there uh
007from that end um we do talk a lot about our process and our goals so if you'll remember from the architectural project there were design drivers that you all set in your edpc and similarly we set those goals for furniture they follow the same vein and the same key principles but they're more specific to the goals of the furniture itself and how the furniture shapes the interaction of the kids in the building uh so from that end we can be boiled down in four simple ideas needs to be uh Dynamic and fluid meaning it is not rigid it does not limit and it does not inhibit right we want our kids to be able to move we want things to be able to adapt uh engaging because we know that sitting in rows and staring
008forward forward is not how our Learners are learning today nor should they be there's a lot more movement there's a lot more Project based learning and it's just a very different environment Forward Thinking is much like we ask the community to invest in 50-year buildings this furniture may not last 50 years but does need to have a very long life cycle and plan for Learners who haven't even been born realistically and then lastly collaborative not only do our students need to be far more collaborative than ever but also our teachers and staff do as well so those are our key goals we dive into a little more detail on each of those on how we defined those both with the leadership team as well as with the pilot teachers which you'll hear a little bit
009more about from Paul so uh to to help validate some of that process and what we're doing want to make sure that we're getting voice of uh teachers and of students throughout this process so we uh put together a process uh we started back in November of 22 um we started to test fit classroom and what furniture might fit in those spaces hear from our leadership team on what their thought process was going to be uh for the furniture and start to engage with some of the teachers as well we talked about the idea of putting together a pilot so that we could actually test furniture out in classrooms for the students to see for the teachers to see and get their feedback in that um we started that out in September of 23 um
010identified what that would look like in November we put together those plans we used the teachers that were identified as pilot teachers to help develop what those classrooms would look like like uh and then in December we purchased that furniture installed that furniture over Christmas break and then really started the actual pilot process in January of of uh 204 that process included opportunities for us to um observe how the students use the furniture listen to what their thoughts were what their favorite pieces were which ones they thought really helped them learn which ones they also identified as potentially not the best choices to be sitting in which was great to hear from the students uh the teachers gave us their feedback on how easy the furniture was to use in the classrooms um they gave
011us verbal feedback uh during interviews we set up online uh resources for them to share feedback anonymously as well so that they didn't feel like they were on the spots giving us that feedback we met with students and uh some of our leadership team to get their feedback in small groups we also had the teachers that were piloting the furniture um do presentations to the rest of their teachers at their schools so that they could share how it was using that furniture lots of the teachers would see the furniture in the classrooms but not fully understand what was happening they got to hear the feedback of how it was being used from their cohorts they weren't hearing it from us or from anybody else that was a nice element for them to hear um once
012we got through the school year we compiled those uh results and then really sat down in Earnest with the leadership team and the furniture team to kind of dive into where our Solutions are at we we were able to take away key points that helped us validate those four uh bullet points that Shelby talked about at the beginning the most important takeaway from our fourth grade students was apparently fourth grade is when back problems start and the data to back that up now at least from an experience standpoint so we learn something new every time um but when you look at chairs the type of movement that the chairs create that was a really funny one it's not actually documented on the summary here those are much more research-based but a fun tidbit to share
013as we talk about how students were woven into the process from start to finish uh this slide is a lot of small text I apologize it was um set up for our staff Gallery where they were able to come up and interact with it on a much larger scale But ultimately the goal of this was really that we are looking at the edpc and changing our environments and changing how both our students and our staff are interacting in those environments and sometimes a key component of success with that is also establishing new language and new vocabulary and getting on the same page so of course staff often ask many many questions about where is my storage and how can I store it because for many many years resources and resource uh procurement has been a
014huge top for educators and certainly underfunding um so with that a lot of these FAQ questions that we shared were really just establishing what can I expect at a high level what does it mean when I say this is a learning community what does this mean when I say we'll have a kit of Parts well really what it means and what Paul will walk us through in the following slides are we are not Furnishing identical classrooms we are establishing a whole toolkit that will speak to each grade level or each space so for example if if we were to have a four-section building we are not Furnishing four identical classrooms we are Furnishing that entire grade level and our teachers are able to push and pull pieces based on how they're teaching collaboratively equal resources
015access for all students but no longer copying pasting rooms that are honestly less engaging and less stimulating as we're moving from one room to another that might be identical uh as I said uh you know kicking this off with the staff these boards much like the architectural galleries that I think you all had seen along the way were really setting out to highlight for our staff where their input uh really was able to shine so the stickies and the what we heard were connecting feedback we heard directly from the staff and from the students of this grade level into how the design and the outcomes were really shaped as a team of course we hit them with very important data how big are the chairs how tall are the tables we want to make sure
016it fits all of our Learners from the youngest to the oldest um but really just starting to give an idea in this plan for example of kindergarten and y5 everything in the red ink that you're seeing in the first three rooms on the left is that kit of parts so even at first glance without having to digest the plan or fully understand it staff were able to get a visual cue that we are able to change this we are able to move this but these are not the same and that's on purpose and there's purpose behind it as we going through the process uh the two pilot classrooms that we did were a second grade and a fourth grade classroom which helped us to inform second and third and fourth and fifth in those pairs
017uh we met separately with first and Kinder uh to get their feedback specifically and some of the key elements that they had uh uh desired to make sure that we were considering as we were putting some of these plans together was making sure that there was plenty of movement in the space whether it's for the furniture to move out of the way so that students can move around in the space but also identifying that the movement the space was not distracting we kept storage close to the students so you might see like a table uh in the upper left has the totes in it right at where the students are working so that they don't have the opportunity to get distracted in the process they're a little bit more efficient with their time uh Shel
018be mentioned a little bit but also making sure that the furniture was right sized making sure that we have the right size chairs and desks uh and seats for the students it might not be a chair it might be a floor cushion it might also be a table that's a little bit taller for students to stand at uh but making sure that we are right sized across the board so that Kinder and y5 have the smaller Furniture uh that would be a little bit more suited for them also things like considering sight lines and making sure that the teachers have the ability to see through the classrooms knowing that they can set these up in any fashion that they want making sure that they've got that transparency in the space as they're going through uh
019when you jump up into first grade again maintaining that element of movement in space where where uh transitioning a little bit as we go through this so we want to make sure that we're balancing the choices for the students needs that we're always considering that we're changing grades with the furniture uh and building on a little bit of uh opportunity for them to uh start to learn and engage in Independence and that Independence is going to build some Agency for them as they're in the space um we're still considering a lot of things like student transitions as we go through this but you'll see that we start to move away from some of that On Demand Storage and it moves to other parts of the classroom a little bit building in a little bit more
020responsibility for the students as they're transitioning it to second and third grade those kits as we start getting into those grades uh you can see some examples here it's still a variety of furniture for a variety of learning styles we know that not every student learns the exact same way so we want to make sure that we're supporting them as much as we can and the variety of their learning needs um that the furniture supports the work needs at the same time so that we're not giving them the wrong Furniture to work at even if it's the right furniture for them to learn at we want to make sure that their work is supported and then also that we're still encouraging that choice uh and that student agency in the space and then once we
021start getting up into the older older Studios uh giving them more uh engaging spaces and collaborative settings uh building in Furniture that's adaptable to the needs of the moment knowing that some of those older students may be collaborating on the Fly rather than taking more instruction from the teachers um and building in more posture support So jokingly we talked about the fourth grade problems uh but including spaces for students to stand at and work at stools to perch at but also still not losing opportun for sitting on the floor uh in the older grades as well having some of those opportunities and really building in that whole spread of opportunity for supporting posture I think that was one of the most rewarding things about the pilot so we uh were able to do at H
022Hill three sections of second grade and at central four sections of fourth grade and with that a lot of the surprise and reactions we took what we call a temperature check at the time we kicked off the pilot to at the time we've completed the actual pilot in place and to hear lot of the staff react with I really wasn't sure I'd like that and after using it hearing about how there was Improvement in engagement or that they were able to surprise themselves with how the different tools because Furniture is a tool uh how those improved learning was really really rewarding I think for our team and for the curriculum and leadership team U for fourth and fifth grade as Paul said you know that standing and that that stool posture allows for a lot
023more contained movement and a lot more Reg ation when we're no longer asking all of our students who maybe are productive wigglers or who fidget to be able to maintain that focus and effort through the day um so you'll notice as we moved from y5 to fourth and fifth grade that you may see less floor seating and more stool seating as we move through those grades but still enough flexibility and enough interchangeability that that furniture allows for everyone to find a smart spot and those were words that were coined by the second grade at hah Hill smart spots uh the slides we walked you through initially were really focused on the learning Studios or classrooms because ultimately most of our educators are most highly focused on those spaces but the change management team at Portage
024with the coaches has done an amazing job with working through these teachers and understanding that the spaces Beyond a studio door or a classroom door are still main course they are not dessert we've used those phrases along the way so we did still share some overall plans of course we're looking at first floor Central here right now and helping them start to understand how those toolkits for the grade level learning are then supported by the commons kit of parts or the small group rooms or some of the educator workshops where it's not just looking at classrooms but again taking that Focus to how the entire building is for learning not simply classrooms flipping through these quickly we had first and second floor for of course C Hill as well so at a high level when
025we share these with staff of course we get where's my room and what's this and remind me again what storage was in the building package and all of that's very natural it comes from excitement it comes from nervousness and we're happy to support all of it at the end of the day really uh digesting in these small chunks through these Gallery walks as well as through the tours that Johnny mentioned as we kicked off we're able to walk them through the process with without it being uh so overwhelming on day one or upon orientation when they come back to school so change management being just as important as the design itself in a lot of ways to have that successful first school year so the very fun part is getting the the prices together for
026all of the furniture um we submitted our RFQ for furniture to multiple dealers uh at the beginning of November uh they uh returned their initial information to us right before Thanksgiving and we are currently in the process of going through and auditing their information um we are looking at likely three uh dealers kuster Michigan office environments and Great Lakes Furniture uh you can see that several of them have multiple uh manufacturers that they would be representing uh and sourcing for us the highlighted ones represent about uh 80% of the anticipated total Furniture uh purchase uh it's spread out nicely across those three it gives the district a minimal amount of dealers for touch points to help manage uh any kind of uh warranty issues or concerns as far as that is concerned uh we also
027have all the dealers that are utilizing uh different uh National purchasing contracts so those allow us to uh go after aggressive discounting uh with pre-negotiated contracts uh and also uh Levy additional discounting on delivery installation and various Freight and Service uh costs in that process uh right now as we're getting through it we're starting to uh get a sense of where we stand at at this point uh we're happy that we are trending under budget at this point but we are still finalizing there are definitely some adjustments that all three of the dealers will need to make to their quotes uh which we are in the process of getting that information back to them this week uh so that they can start to update that our goal is to have a recommendation with numbers uh
028for the board uh at the beginning of January in general that tells you a little bit about what we've done and where we are today as you can imagine with all of those kits of parts and many manufacturers there's quite an audit ahead of us we're very comfortable with where we are today which I'd say we have the first initial pass for quantities and making sure the right pieces were specified uh complete so we feel very comfortable uh timeline ahead just as he mentioned so we'll have recommendation information early January that will come to you all through Johnny we're really looking to issue our purchase orders by February um so that's really the timeline ahead with your your blessing and recommendation from then Furniture installation actually begins end of April so it's coming fast everyone
029uh so that'll be phased installation of April through July at both buildings happening with a little bit of an overlap as you'd expect which is another advantage of having three dealers involved is they're really able to cover uh that time and that overlap and that bulk of work because these are quite large projects and it can be a pretty large undertaking uh so that will take place as I said April through July um with the ability to complete our punch list or on-site review and hopefully make any necessary Corrections before students and teachers take occupancy for the new school year so a lot of excitement ahead we're very very excited to feel like the feedback that we've received from the staff from the leadership team and from the edpc are all coming together in a
030package that was uh on budget or below budget we proud of the work that went in and the compromises that were made and the very very thoughtful analysis not just we want this but also why do we want it not just I don't like that chair but what does that chair offer to our Learners I think it was an incredibly thorough process and we're very very excited to share it all with you as we move forward there's a lot of information uh you know to pause and and be able to answer any questions that you may have about either the process proc or some of the ideas or concepts that you've seen tonight not a question but an appreciation for how you took into account um providing greater inclusion for especially for our neurodiverse Learners
031love what we do yeah thank you for your work we're really pleased that you're in charge of the process um some of us who have toured the the rooms with the pilot furniture in it it's just amazing how kids are using furniture I mean you know this stuff but it was all new to some of us and thank you thank you for your work thank you and look forward to a a recommendation at the turn of the the new year thanks CH than the the only other thing I'll mention is uh um I know that cat Frank usually comes up and uh and during public comment and recognized a few things going on in the district and I think she shared that with you electronically because she's not able to make it today um so
032I won't repeat the things that she's already stated but I will just uh you know kind of bring to your attention and uh kind of thank our student body for the work they did with bread lift um you know bread lift uh is a uh is a student operated function that raises money for a cause this year the cause went to the uh CSM children's hospital and then in particular I think they pediatric heart transplant uh department and between Portage Central Portage Northern and some help from Gull Lake I think about $45,000 was raised towards that efforts uh we will be having a uh uh ceremonial uh check uh presentation on Friday at noon so any board members that are available to uh stop by there and uh shouldn't take longer than 15 minutes but
033uh um acknowledging the efforts of of those people on what ended up being two beautiful Saturday afternoons that they uh they had weatherwise so yeah kudos to the kids for doing that that's all I have on this part very good thank you Mark we'll move to a board education presentation of monitoring report 1.1 Elementary so Kelly Jen sis is here to present that and uh just to put it in context uh monitoring report 1.1 has presented this year over two presentations you heard the first half of the presentation I don't know if it's appropriate to characterize it is half but the first portion of the presentation uh last month that involved our high schools and middle schools uh this month we focus on Elementary and uh and this is um again the the revised end
034statement that the board has and our revised interpretations and and hopefully as you're you're listening you're also analyzing is this kind of the intent of what your policy changes uh were uh intended to uh to to do differently for us I mean obviously our reports are looking different the data that we present is different uh and Kelly is going to present the elementary part so well thank you appreciate it so good evening superintendent and trustees so as Mark said I'm going to present that new approach to interpreting mr11 um by looking at each Portage public school elementary school's top 10 similar schools across the state so we get more um accurate where our buildings are landed so this is similar to what we did with high school and middle school but at the elementary level
035um so all the information you'll see this evening is pulled from our my school data with criteria based on total enrollment uh the economically disadvantaged percentage in demographics uh with a cap of that 125% of our highest um schools total for f expenditures at each level and for the sake of mr11 that expenditure is pulled directly from my school data as well so that you're aware very similar to what we did earlier in November and know that this approach eliminates groupings of all schools into one average and provides each School a true apples apples comparison to aike schools that have a similar makeup the difference here is we have eight Elementary so that's where tonight you know letting me know and really might have to dig back into it after you he tonight's presentation and
036when we come back in January so we'll see how we do tonight with this but know that this approach also includes schools compared to our other K reses schools as well so with that we'll get started there all right so we are reporting on the same three areas with the addition of kesa comparisons as well as true comparators in the state for proficiency measur and I want to just do a quick reminder um percent proficient is simply looking at one testing cycle of data and for us that's the spring of 2024 so when we look at that data that's what we're looking at when we move to percent proficient Improvement this is where we're looking at current scores compared to previous three-year average to see if we're improving over the past essentially is what we're
037trying to do there and then when we get to the growth part that is determined by the percent of Portage public school students with an SGP of at least 30 I know that remembering that my school data defines average growth of an SGP from 30 to 69 in that above average 70 to 99 so we'll go through that a little bit more but I think it's good to start with some definitions there um as Dr Pasco had presented in November very similar side slide here that the similar schools criteria based on recommendation really from our reportage schools saying uh during their District data review it was hard to compare to those comparator districts so they really as we said earlier more of an Apple's to Apple comparison for them and so we wanted this St
038to hopefully help them dig a little bit more deeper talk to those similar schools and start getting some information there um so know that the slide the breakdown of criteria and weights um you can see what we're currently doing compared to what we previously did so just is Dr Mas said all right so getting into it here we go so we're going to start with our percent proficient in ela and math and then move to our percent proficient Improvement in ela and math so we're going to go Ela math Ela math but we're going to start with just percent proficient for the 24 uh 2022 2024 school year um so if you want to follow along with in your um in your packets it's page 28 that would match these graphs your figures just so
039you have that um you'll start to see figure 19 there and we have three categories at the top of that table that you can see in blue you see that above expectations green at expectations and then red below expectations so that really is if it's um from 1 to third we're above most we're in that fourth to six in within our comparators we're going to be in the middle range and if we're below maybe that 7 the 10th that's below most of them so when what is different on this report than middle school and high school is when you look at let's say Amberly there that column that bar there that's Amberly compared to Amberly similar schools and angling that's compared to angling similar school so while we have it on one page we're trying
040or one slide we're trying not to give you 24 slides here so for easability but just needed some clarity so this slide in particular is Ela fifth grade ELA perc proficient and what we can start to see here is that Lake Center and Woodland are above expectations compared to their individual similar schools and as a reminder that is found on figure 20 in your packet so you can see there similar schools there um angling Road moorsbridge and 12th Street are at expectations while Amberly Central L and hah Hill are below expectations and that is compared again to their own individual similar schools might be good to note um that some Portage buildings have other Portage schools in their similar listings but not all of them do so fun one is Amberly has Lake Center in
041their similar schools but Lake Center does not have Amberly so that it fell off there so you see that um like Woodland has angling Road and HH Hill but HH Hill only has Woodland so you'll start to see that if you really dig deep into those similar schools listings but I wanted to make sure you know that okay so we'll do the same thing here for math we start to look at the math percent proficient and angling Road in Lake Center are at expectations compared to their individual similar schools but then when we go to Amberly Central L hah Hill morb 12 Street and Woodland they are below those expectations there and again you have that list in figure one or figure 21 of your packet so again compared to their comparators this is where
042we're ranking and as we've talked in the past why math is so important that it's risen up to the top of our list of we got to get moving so um when we start to move now into kesa and this time since we can pull all of them into one slide we're looking at kesa which is figure 22 in your packet we can see where our eight Elementary School f School fall amongst the county based on the 2024 spring data for mstep And So within those 28 schools with Ela data available moorsbridge Lake Center 12 Street Amberly and Woodland rank in the top 10 as first 2 fourth 6th and seventh respectively angling was at 11th in central L 14th so they ranked in that top half and then we had hah Hill ranking at
04317th um the number just as of awareness the number of kesa schools will vary in this report due to sep's data suppression rules where that protects that individual students so we could have schools with maybe one or two students where you could identify them so their data would not be publicly available at that point so we start to see here where we're ranking um which I knew that was something we wanted to see how we were doing in comparison within our County so this is where we are in our Ela and if we go over and the math and this now is among 26 KES of schools with math data available so we dropped off two there um Lake Center moris Bridge Amberly and engling Ro rank in that top 10 third fourth sixth and
044seventh respectively then we have Central L at 11th Woodland at 12th a hill 13th so those are ranked in our top half and then 12th Street at 16th um with one little piece of data that I pulled up uh and I looked at was was trying to see do we have any kesa schools that are also in our school PPS schools individual similar schools lot of words there uh 12 Street actually has King Westwood which is the only similar school that is also a kria school and not a p PPS School so I thought that was interesting there that came out of that um so we are what what we're really seeing is we're getting a good um um pool to see where different people are located seeing how we're comparing against whether in county
045and out of County and we're starting to see that so those are this is just how we did in proficiency right so now we're going to move from proficiency to percent proficient Now we move from and that is that percent proficient Improvement so how are we improving with Sim amongst our similar schools and remember this is how we're comparing three prior years specifically looking at that percent proficient that's going to serve as our Trend data and then we have all those similar schools in figure 24 for you so let's think about that we have 2024 is the Year we're looking at and we're going to compare it to three previous years so that's going to be our pre pandemic year 2019 we're going to take that year and then we're going to take two years
046post pandemic so we're going to have 2022 and 2023 that are going to make up those years and with that that's a weighted average based on the number of students who took that test each spring which is that same approach we've done in past so we've not changed that process process at all so if we compare our 2024 data to the previous threee average for ELA percent percent proficient you can see that Amberly Lake Center and Woodland looking at this graph they are above expectations compared to their individual schools when we're talking about that Improvement when we look at angling Central Allen hah Hill they're at that expectations level and then moris bridge and 12 Street are below expectations so when you look at this at first glance you go this is a lot of
047data now what what does that really mean to me right and we're starting to say well why would we drop that low and and be at expectations so that's where when you take your similar schools if we use for example example in figure 24 if we were to pull hah Hill who's at expectations and that's a NE 4.3% Improvement you're going whoa how can that be expectations but five of their similar schools dropped even more compared to hah Hill over from that threee to this year and all the way down to a negative 14.9% so when looking at this again you have to look at each one individually by school then take it and look at that graph um figure 24 to really see that's why that's what's happening there compared to other similar schools
048did you repeat HH Hill one more time yes yeah so HH Hill is 4.3 but five of their similar schools were dropping even more so they were lower than that when the lowest one was at 14.9% of a Improvement so that's where that's what you really have to look at this graph here really doesn't do it justice this is just kind of giving you that snapshot here it is really um figure 24 that allows you to say that's why that's what's happening and that's the work that every individual school has to do right they have to take a look at that their data and say what is it that I want to learn and then which one which data set helps me to answer that question of what I'm trying to do so each one
049of these provides us a very different different answer to a very different question and that's the beauty of the schools being able to dig down into this and say how do we know so was it over these three years what happened these three prior years compared to this year um and that might answer oh well this was X or this was Y and so that's where our work coming back to in January as well is we can give you some examples of that of what schools learned in each of these graphs and I think that would be really helpful for you um so if we do the same thing yes so what you're what I hear you saying is that figure 24 that's in your monitoring report in your board packet on page what 37
050this is a summary of how where our school's placed if you want to look at the detail on that refer back to figure 24 yes definitely okay that would have been a big one to put on a slide deck right and we're just talking about Improvement here yes percent talking about whether the school is actually proficient or not but how much how many more kids were proficient correct that Improvement piece right the first set of slides was this is our percent this is the data now we're looking at how much did we improve compared to these three years this average so even these negative Improvement could still be proficient they just have less yes so I think this is is a good example on the next one which is the math right so if you
051look at math Amberly Lake Center and Woodland are above expectations compared to their individual similar Schools central Allen hah Hill are at expectations compared to their individual similar schools but then you see angling moorsbridge and 12 Street are below expectations so I think another good one to take a look at is maybe moorsbridge there and you would say hey I remember back on percent proficient on the very first slides they were right up here and they're at the top so now the question is okay previous three years we dropped this year why what happened what's going on here for them the answer it doesn't mean to your point that we're not doing well is that this piece here this Improvement wasn't here so we need to look at one more very tricky on that to
052look through it so you can't just look at this real quick and say make not judgments at all um there's a lot of conversations that have to take place in our schools are doing that okay so now now we put it all out here for our kesa schools so we look at this Ela percent proficient Improvement compared to kesa schools in figure 26 that's this again and here now we have 27 kesa schools with Ela data available and there we see that Woodland Amberly and Lake Center rank in the top 10 at third Sixth and Ninth respectively and percent Improvement and then Angley at 11th Central L at 12th so they rank in that top half followed by 12th Street at 17th C Hill at 18th and moorsbridge at 21st so again you have to
053start taking a look at what's happening here where were they percent proficient and what and how did they the rest of the PESA schools could really nerd out on this for quite a while he really wanted to um and so we do exactly the same thing here in math and we start to see that and this time we have 25 schools with that math data available in our kesa area we see that Woodland Amberly and hah Hill rank in the top 10 at Fifth Sixth and eth respectively angling at 11th so they're in that top half and now we go to 12 or sorry Lake Center 13th Central L at 15th 12 Street 23rd and Morris Bridge 25th okay so lots to think about here and lots to analyze for schools I'm going to give
054you some more data so again that was about percent Improvement so that's like what are we what are we doing as a school how does that work as a school that's really school focus but once we start talking now about student growth that that is going to be more about how individual students performed in fifth grade compared to their peers with similar prior test scores so when they were in third and fourth grade that these current fifth or those fifth graders they got scores and they performed at a certain level so what happens is we grab these other kids that perform similarly to them in third and fourth grade and then we compare them to their fifth grade school so we want to see did Barb and Kelly grow similarly when they went to fifth
055grade because we scored similarly when we were in third and fourth grade so are we doing it am I outscoring Barb is Barb outscoring me how much growth are we doing so now it's about the individual kids at this point whereas before I didn't talk about individual kids we were talking about how we doing percent Improvement so when we do that know that a school and you're seeing this weird thing where people are up and down and all over the place so a school can Show Low Improvement in proficiency but still show high growth and that since Improvement in proficiency is a school measure which is what I was just saying and growth is that individual student me measure um so then it's important we said this earlier average growth as SGP is that 30
056to 69 and above average growth is 70 to 99 you would never look at all this data at once right as a school you would just never do it you would pull it apart bit by bit um maybe some people would but uh so just know that we're really looking at academically academic growth we look at this a lot right we want to know are there kids really growing how is this kid growing and if they're not really growing why not and what can we do in structures can we put in place to support them so statistically Norm for the percent of students with average growth or above average growth is around 70% and that's important because what we're going to say now in this next graph is any Portage school with at least 70%
057of their students in these ranges are considered to be at expectations so we want to know are we growing these kids here are they growing at a good rate and any of them with less than 70% considered below expectations so we're going to look at figure 26 seven so on this one shows the 20 24% of students with average or above average growth for each school and we also included in there because we didn't think we had enough data um the 2023 data for you for comparison purposes so you can kind of see where we were and the 2022 is not available because of the pandemic that word keeps coming out um so for ELA what we see is angling Road Central L Lake Center moorsbridge 12th Street and Woodland are at expectations hitting that
05870% with four of our schools angling Central L Morris Bridge and 12 Street having over 80% of students with average or above average growth we want to see that like that's really good to see that um Amberly at 69 and HH Hill at 68 are below expectations but they are within that 2% of meeting that goal of 70% so they're just eeking by they're getting real close to that 70% so we're really proud to see that these are our kids are moving here when we look at math what we have here same thing Central l ha Hill Lake Center and Morris Bridge they are at expectation with three Schools central L hah Hill and Morris Bridge having over 80% of students with average or above average growth and then Amberly and angling 69 and 68%
059are below expectations but they are within that 2% again of meeting 70 and then we have 12 Street at 62% and Woodland at 45% that are below that expectation so with all of that we start to say okay what is it that our kids need from us and what are we going to do next here um and that's this right like and we're not going to get really into the nitty-gritty today but what I want to share with you what does all this mean mean it is a lot I just said that a ton of to unpack um we have to you know examine it from different angles what is your purpose are we looking at individual kids are we looking at curriculum what is it that we want to know and what are we
060going after so I want to focus on these today but really if we start at professional development and Alignment we've talked a lot about this over the past couple years that our work is grounded in our continuous Improvement so we're starting with that K12 professional development and long range planning that's been a big Focus for us um we're starting to have our Educators really see how it's not a oneandone kind of PD but it's ongoing it's connected um and that they are things that they can use in their classrooms it allows them to go a lot deeper into their practice instead of just really absorbing a bunch of broad information um that's really disconnected from what they want so we've been really intent about our PV we move over to the second circle of curriculum
061review Cycles um CRC you'll probably hear us say that quite a bit the CRC process um we are import it's important to highlight our transition to go into phase two for mathematics who we've been in phase one from last year to this one where we bumped that up and said okay what do we need to do um we have been working with those teams Tracy and McKenzie have been huge on getting them to together walking through the research asking you know all the important questions of of the work um aligning of the standards um and instructional expectations are coming up like that's where we're at now like what is it that we need to align in our standards K12 how do we how what do we expect our teachers to do in mathematics and making
062sure that every single kid gets that advantage that that teacher is using those um instructional strategies um so even though we are in that early stages of math CRC uh we know that certain especially an elementary instructional priorities just couldn't wait and so we have been initiating that PD um for our teachers focus on structural strategies specifically fact fluency um which really what that is is that com it is a fundamental component of number sense um building their number sense understanding how numbers work um and so the review and selection of instructional resources for math do not occur until phase three so if anybody's like they're picking this book we are not we are really in what is what are the standards what are we have to do that deep knowledge work first because we're
063not even close to that yet that comes into phase three um by having a phased approach we're establishing a strong foundation and standards pedagog um before exploring materials that best supports our goals so um Ela if we move into Ela with in the CRC process they're in phase three of implementation so they're implementing right now and that's full integration of The Curriculum by all teachers and to do a successful implementation implementation at elementary we know that they're supported by their reading specialist um through coaching with helping them refine their instructional practices because when it's new you have to work on it it's hard to try something new and you're going to you're going to stumble over it and you're going to get better and a coach helps you do that um plc's we use those
064for ongoing professional learning and collaboration and problem solving together so them coming together with their coaches in there it's a huge important piece of it they're prepping together they're asking questions they're grappling with information um and then we have our grade level team collaboration where they come together as a district and they align strategies they share those best practices what's working what's not working how can I do this differently what did you do that's really important for them um so this comprehensive support framework really helps to ensure that consistency Effectiveness and delivering the curriculum ac across all our classrooms and when you're in initial implementation it's really important to be supported and help help them move through that um moving to to the next one is our mstep prep plan so we are really working
065on having a comprehensive plan at each of our buildings um the teachers are engaging in data driven planning so this data here they're going to pull pieces of that out and examine it they're going to look at there's even more data shocking that mstep can provide you around critical areas that you can start to look at um and we were able to identify already in our curriculum hey what is happening in fifth grade here are we teaching multiplying and dividing of fractions and as we Unearthed it we were not yet and so there's some moves that we can make in our curriculum and and that's just part of the learning process right and that's what you do so so they're working on that implementing curriculum with Fidelity um again teachers supported through coaching and feedback
066and then the principles are working towards that optimal testing condition and ensuring right that our families are part of the process of collaboration Readiness putting your kids to bed on time having a good breakfast all the good things before they have to come into a situation which you know testing is hard and we know that it's hard and it's hard when they're little but we want to give them the best Advantage we can to be successful um if we move around to the coaching framework that's really a critical element still in supporting teachers as I mentioned earlier enhancing our instructional practices we have our reading Specialists our engagement specialists at the elementary level District coaches they're all dedicated to increasing student engagement by collaborating with our teachers to help improve practice and student outcomes um
067this year our focus on coaching has really been around two specific areas um opportunities and support for partici participation and meaning making as well as student talk so those two key areas for students to be active participants so it's great when you hear about the furniture and the opport unities and how we can utilize space to allow students to have um meaningful conversations it it's been pretty cool to watch how Furniture impacts that so um and you can do it without Furniture but it definitely helps when they um finally we do recognize that professional learning communities as I mentioned earlier is a driving force in this work um I think it's important to note that teachers team uh with their Elementary with that reading specialist the engagement specialist they engage in those deep conversations the
068analysis again of that data um looking at the for inst structal components what do we do if they know it what do we do if they don't have it yet um in the Fidelity of curriculum implementation how do we support how can we help you and then through focused discussions they serve as that platform for identifying areas where are we're strong right in certain buildings well we've got this or other areas where but this is where we're going to work um compared to other buildings right they're going to pick and choose those areas based on the data where they need to focus um on their strengths so and then as we know if we get back to the middle there this is all continuous Improvement and if we're not going around the circle and looking
069at the data as we go through it we're not going to really get anywhere so it's really important that the teams that we have the time together that teams work together um I think said it multiple times between the reading specialist the engagement specialist the principal that leadership team working alongside the teachers who have that time together in a PLC it matters so much that allow them to have that time um with their colleagues so we are just hopeful and we've been working really hard to to ensure some good systems that's been our myip goal and these are the systems that we're using and strengthening and that with that work work and with the data that we continuously improve and know that I look forward to come back in January to go further in depth
070but maybe not on the data per se but maybe a little bit more some examples of the analysis of what we've done with this data from there so um we'll have a 12 so Dr Pasco and I and going not what questions might you have and how can I help you tonight I appreciate so much the difference in data um I appreciate that this is data that is used by the schools is not just um put together for the board but it's useful data and I'm looking forward to January when we getar more to kind of sum it up now we've seen the data but it's nice to have more conclusions more what we're doing as we move forward um so thank you and looking forward well yeah I'll go ahead Kelly thank you you're
071welcome um this was enlightening and this is um so I go back to the retreat we had last spr where we got our first haste at looking at this and I think we were all pretty excited and so you know last month and then this month we're seeing some of the the data live and um and just to connect the dots so this data comes back to NS 1.1 which and they're ordered that way there's only five NS and this is the first one um so this is really I mean the board has said this is kind of the most important stuff so it's good to have this and have it presented this way um the um so I mean I I would ask you and Michael to I think I said this last month
072when you come back in January it would help me if you could among other things that you're going going to do is shave it down to a point um and and give us your main takeaways um and kind of go from here and just I mean I'm just interested in your honest uh unvarnished reflection on this because I mean you can and and we've set ourselves up for this we said we want to see the data this way and you put it out there and some some stuff looks really good and some stuff is humbling and I had to really work to find that word I mean cuz some of this stuff it's it's in red um right and it it's not where we want it we need to to move it but um but
073at the same time I wanted to make a statement but it's also a question is um is no defensiveness I mean we can't point fingers it's this is right this is teamwork focus and moving forward and we we shouldn't be defensive about what's happened it's it's all moving forward and but at the same time not denying right cuz some of this stuff it's like right it it needs it needs kind of a fresh a Fresh Approach I mean I'm curious here's my kind of unfair question but just in general how are people inside kind of reacting to this um you know can people own it I mean this might be new for them to see these comparators um and we did that to try to be fair but it doesn't always show that we're comparing
074well right to these to these other schools so I'm curious about that and you do do not need to get a deep answer I'm just it I think it Mark and I talked a little bit this morning I think it depends on your I was joking with your strengths right your strengths finder if you have competitor in the you know in your top 10 man you're like who I'm going at it and one of our principles at the secondary level he was like all right I'm calling up that District I know who the super you know and he's like this is what I'm going to do others of us right that maybe that's not one of your top strengths and you're more of a learner you're going to take time to dig into it a
075little bit deeper and understand it more and that's how you're going to work through it so I think they all have varying levels of of what's next but I think what we've done is said these are similar and now we we go okay and you have to sit in that a little bit and I think that's where we're at is just kind of sitting in it for a little bit and not sure I know what I I say not sure I know they're doing the things right for our kids every day and they're making changes in the mstep prep and they're analyzing it and they're doing that but not sure in this terms of what does it all mean like the same thing they did when they sat down with us they were like oh
076that's a lot of data so you have to pull each type apart for different purposes and that's where we're at so we're also in the beginning stages I think as a whole team of pulling apart the data and knowing what to do with each individual type um but yeah the competitors in this yeah we're going to go after it yeah well and it can be overwhelming there's so much here and I know you have so much more and it's and that's why I ask it I mean especially for me or for the board to bring it try to bring it to a point uh for us I know it'll take you all some time um I think um I'm good you're good all right well thank you all I appreciate it okay we'll move to
077our comments and Communications section is there anyone who wishes to address the board this evening thank you thank you have three speakers this evening I believe you've all been here before so you know the three minute rule so we won't go through all that and we'll welcome our first Speaker Lindsay zer my name is Lindsay zerber and I'm here to ask you to recognize the overtly biased nature of the initial review of the bread winner and call for an objective evaluation to take place this committee was made up of nine members including only one fifth grade teacher out of 29 in the district who also happened to be an early adopter the rest of the committee included only one other teacher who again was an early adopter admin that have a clear bias in this
078matter and only one true Community member there was not a single member that even had there was not a single member that was solely a parent or educator outside the district and only one member that even has an elementary student as I researched educational institutions handling of these types of conflicts I consistently found policies in which committees were formed with even representation on both sides of the argument and open communication was encouraged not a single policy involves separating complaintants or putting them in situations of obvious intimidation where a single individual is forced to voice their concerns before a group of people that disproportionately represented only one side of the argument overall this committee has the appearance of being handpicked to ensure that the only result would be the approval of this novel this is a
079gross abuse of power and clearly was not handled properly the entire review was Guided by the curriculum director who brought the curriculum to the board for approval in the first place she extended the invitation to the committee members thereby giving her the power to choose the makeup of it and thus ensure its outcome she also took the minutes of the review allowing what was included in this report to be at her discretion after reading the notes it's abundantly clear that the information included intentionally skewed the argument to one side I question why the curriculum director was directing this committee as she has an obvious bias in this matter the entire process was clearly decided before it even began also the committee was informed that the purpose of the review was to ensure that the curriculum
080was grounded in their four pillars one of which states that it is fit for all students based on the number of parents upset at various schools it is clear this is not the case the group was additionally instructed that the purpose was to evaluate the book considering its educational Merit the complaint had nothing to do with the educational value of the book but rather the violent nature of its content and whether or not it is developmentally appropriate for this age level our stance has always been that this book has value when used at the correct grade level according to the dozens of teachers counselors and parents I have spoken to that grade level should be seventh or 8th grade as you review this matter please consider this the inclusion of this book at a fifth
081grade level has brought harm to students causing nightmares fear and anxiety it has harmed the relationship between the district and parents creating anger and distrust the exclusion of this harms no one parents who wish for their child to read it can still provide those opportunities parents who didn't want their child children to read this did not have those same rights they were not given essential information about the content or an option to opt out why when there are so many quality books that can teach about the same regions and ideals can we not find a solution that works for all thank you thank you Lindsay our next speaker is Bethany Meer welcome my name is Bethany mker and I'm here to talk about about the committee's failure to properly evaluate the violence in the book
082the bread winner one Committee Member stated that there is violence but in the context of the lessons it's not about the violence in our research we have found this to be blatantly untrue as Lesson 12 specifically asked the question why is parvana losing hope to answer that question students would have to reference the events directly preceding this those events are the graphic murder and dismemberment of the character homeless family is this nonviolent another Committee Member said the bone scene with Mr skull while the topic is rather maob bones are not indicative of being graphic the addition of having a mascot may seem a bit disturbing but comes across as a moment of humor or lightness on a dark subject I personally find nothing humorous in the children Digging Up Bones of people as a way
083of making money to even describe this scene in such a way makes me question the people in charge of presenting this to the children in the conclusion of this scene parvana is so disgusting with herself for doing this work that she repeatedly washes herself in an attempt to wash away her feelings of being dirty from this traumatic experience this certainly doesn't sound humorous to me another Committee Member stated that discussion of landmines is also effective in discussing real world situations parvana smiles when Shazia jokes about not walking on one which gives the reader a non-verbal indication of ease of verse versus fear inducing to describe the scene as being one of joking or ease has me questioning if the committee even RIT The Scene goes on to describe parvana's overwhelming anxiety over simply trying to
084use the bathroom she goes on to explain how her brother was killed by a landmine she is try trying to decide if she should risk using being killed by a landmine to use the bathroom in private I feel to see how this is light-hearted or and not fear-inducing finally one participant references the arena scene and says there's a clear slide projected with a disclaimer that the topic is violent while reading the scene I didn't actually find it as bad as what it seemed while it is traumatic to hear there are worse things shown on TV and movies first do we honestly expect children to read that slide in class and inform this teacher in front of all of their classmates that they are concerned about it this in particular is a tough age for children
085where the way their peers see them matters and can lead to ridicule also this particular Committee Member said that she did not find it as bad as she thought however she is not a 10-year-old child that has not been repeatedly exposed to this to say that there are worse things on TV is a poor argument for several reasons first it assumes that most parents allow their children to watch such things as a teacher that knows many parents I can say that this is not true for most people like us they still value their children's innocence secondly the parent is ultimately responsible for what their child watches as it is their right they they alone get to determine what is appropriate once again we return to the school system thinking that they have the right to
086decide what level of violence is acceptable for the children we are asking the board to ensure a proper nonbiased evaluation is done that this book receives the review that it should have had in the first place thank you thank you Bethy our last speaker is Steven Z welcome sir hi my name is Steve zerber and I'm here to talk about several issues I have with the review of the breadware in the review it stated that the students are not reading these texts without the support and guidance of the teachers it was also explained to us by the administration that in September in a September meeting that the teachers have been properly trained to handle these tough topics we however discovered that the first training actually held by teachers took place November 1st more than a
087month and a half from our meeting which we were told it had happened furthermore the statement also establishes the school as having the right to direct students understanding and not the parents parents rights are able to support their children's emotional well-being when dealing with extremely confronting topics should always take precedence over the school system this right was made Impossible by the schools lack of disclosure of the violent content of this book the review stated that the committee explored possibility of substituting the bread winner with another book but decided it was Irreplaceable they offered no evidence of what other texts were being explored and never referenced a single title as there were only four working days between the initial meeting and the second meeting I sincerely doubt due d diligence was done in this regard as
088the committee members are mostly working members within the porish public school district and this entire process took place during a single Work Week our we to believe that had time to read the book explore all the lessons of the book including enhanced lesson plans um and research other books of That Could Teach the same subject in four days while working full-time another Comm Committee Member stated students will uh learn through debates that there are different opinions and that is okay and to talk about it it is ironic to me that we are trying to teach our children that yet the administration does not want to hear the difficult the different opinions of the book there has been no parent meetings only bureaucracy and isolation of those who offer opinions different than theirs other than a
089few times through civilan board uh school board meetings and all their discussions have been held independently um even though we know there are many parents that are concerned if this text is so above reproach reproach why are we afraid to allow an open honest discussion to take place I'm asking the board to take a further look at the proper review that took place one that's free from bias and overseen by a neutral party prove to the parents that it can be handled in ethical and professional way thank you thank you Sten there any comments this evening uh by board trustees I just wanted to say that this is my last board meeting um that I have been honored to serve on the board and so I appre appreciate all of the trustees that I've served
090with I've learned so much about this district and um I just realized that you know it is all for the students and that everybody has been really dedicated and very passionate um about that goal so we will miss everyone but I have been happy to be on this journey thanks an we'll miss you your insights have been so valuable and I have appreciated that you are willing to ask questions in a way that makes you think makes us think instead of just having an opinion it makes us analyze our own opinion and you do it in a very friendly way that it's just amazing and you will be missed thank you Mr chairman can I reserve my comment time to the special agenda yes sir yes sir well honor your last wish a cigarette too
091it's ugly I guess you didn't get to pick your last [Laughter] meal any other trustee comments well I I mentioned it uh during our earlier meeting but uh owner linkage meeting this Wednesday and uh talking about um some topics to cover us key Communications in the community in the next six months thank you V anyone else I have enjoyed um some of the holiday concerts that have occurred and look forward to the ones that are still yet to occur um if you have the opportunity either those in the room or those who are listening online to attend them they are incredible for sure yeah okay very good uh we'll move to our consent agenda on page 46 we have two items tonight approval of the November 18th 2024 special meeting and regular business meeting and
092to approve the purchase of 377 passenger buses one lift bus and 177 passenger bus with air conditioning all from Highland bus for a total of $727,500 will come from the 2019 bond fund proposal one unallocated contingency there any exceptions to the consent agenda as presented now hearing none the consent agenda is approved and we'll move to our first action item which is to approve the PAC Committee Member and um there's a motion please on page 83 president vant I move that the Board of Education approve as presented oh wait that's the wrong thing uh the nomination of Kendall new house to the special education parent advisory committee at kesa for a three-year term which expires in 2027 thank you s second second thank you yes and we have uh Ann Gordon here who is stepping
093in for uh Janine Dr gearheart Who is uh who was absent this evening so an I'll let you make any comments yes thank you superintendent beling and trustees I'm just here to ask for the nomination for um kennel new house to the pack and wondering if you have any questions that how about just a hearty thank you we do appreciate her this will be her second term special education is so important to make sure that everybody's support needs are met so this is a continuation of her existing uh or adding on to the term that she already holds it's not newly new position new person to that another three years we appreciate her service and we're thankful that she's willing to re up to do this important work thank you all those in favor of
094approving uh Kendall new house as to the special education parent advisory committee at K Reesa please say I I opposed the motion passes um our next action item is classroom technology for the new Central and CER Hill elementaries and there's a motion please on page 85 Mr chairman I move that the Board of Education approve as presented the purchase of light speed Tech microphones with media links and LG 75 in flat panel televisions the amount of $2 27,2 funds for which will be drawn from the 2021 F thank you B is there a second thank you Ryan welcome good evening people so this recommendation was about those the light speed microphones and the flat panel TVs and so this is uh as I mentioned before the first of a few classroom technology recommendations that'll be
095coming your way in upcoming reads so any questions about tonight probably not because you explained it so low the last time you precursor to it all right well more coming in the future thanks all right let's make this happen all those in favor of the classroom technology for the new elementary schools please say I I I opposed the motion passes and technology is on the way I wanted to add uh the next item which is a proclamation and recognition and appreciation of distinguished service for our retiring board members and there is a um motion at your places if you could if we could have a volunteer to read the one for Keith please well I would be honored super um this is a resolution in recognition and appreciation of distinguished service by Keith croll uh
096whereas Keith croll was most recently appointed at the Portage Public Schools Board of Education on February 13 2023 fill a vacancy created by the resignation of trustee Kurt droppers and served on the board through December 2024 prior to that on January 4 2021 Keith was appointed to the board to fill a vacancy created by the passing of trustee Joan Wilson and served through December 2022 Keith has served on the board for nearly four years whereas during his board service Keith served on the board's owner l AG committee policy committee and audit committee and he continues to serve as a member of the boage Educational Foundation whereas as a board member Keith has served graciously tirelessly with the utmost care and compassion even through the most trying of times including the covid-19 pandemic he also served
097during times of celebration for our district and Community including the passage of the1 175 m725 th000 elementary schools and districtwide Improvement bond proposal in August 2021 as well as the building and site syncing fund renewal in August 2024 he has provided invaluable Insight perspective and guidance to the Board of Education now therefore be it resolve that the Portage Public Schools Board of Education acknowledges and extends its gratitude to Keith croll for his dedication and service to The District staff students community and to the Board of Education be it further resolved that this resolution is saved in the permanent minutes of the Portage Public Schools Board of Education and a copy is given to Keith grow adopted on this 9th day of December 2024 Portage Public Schools Board of Education and uh signed by all of
098us uh and Mr be thank you V is is there a motion please to approve the resolution I move we approve the resolution thank you Emily is there a second second thank you Kimberly all those in favor of approving the resolution and recognition and appreciation of distinguished service for Keith cro please say I hi hi very good Keith it was unanimous [Laughter] all right you have any comments I do well thank you both you know and I hear what he has to say and it's like gosh this has been a really successful time and I think in an awful lot of ways it has been not because of anything I've done but because of everybody in this room and I mean starting with staff and it just guarantees success really the way things came together
099and it you know just um to have a finance person that can even make me appreciate numbers which is hard to do and it happened and to use Kelly's words to have a curriculum people who geek out over this stuff you know that's just wonderful and uh you know Johnny you have become such a fixture in these things these meetings for me that I think come Monday nights as I'm setting my calendar it's like musty TV 6:30 tune in Johnny and uh it's always fun to hear reports and especially tonight some of you I knew before you know you know early in my journey through the schools um before I ever got on school board Jeremy was one of those people I wish he was still here um but you meant a lot to me
100on the board Barb you made it impossible not to to mess anything up you know you you did remember to oh of course and right away um but then to all the veterans who came before me thank you so much my board buddy Bo who uh um I me had to make a motion in the proper way so that I at least didn't have to sweat that too much my first meeting here um and then finally to to um Mark and Randy my leader my leaders my mentors um again it would would be impossible not to succeed under the leadership of both of you so thank you so much well thank you Keith for your service to the district we appreciate it sir and we'll have a certificate presentation to you at the end of
101the meeting with a photo wonderful thank you all right I mean and and can we say nice things now yeah with just so I mean Keith um consumate professional gentleman calm big picture person to serve with um Keith and I probably met 25 years ago in Marshall Michigan we're both working in healthcare and our pths crossed there and you moved to Portage and um good to rekindle that relationship and I think before you even were on this board you were serving on the Portage Education Foundation yes and that's where we kind of got reacquainted there and um and I was so thrilled to to find out that you will still remain on that board so I look forward to continuing on that board where I oversee and this is talking about the joys of evaluating
102all the scholarship applications that come in and uh that's been an enjoyable thing um and as far as community service goes I'm just looking forward to other opportunities that come up my work is done now with the schools but who knows what else may be out there aside from the foundation so yeah thanks this be a pleasure to continue working with you in different areas when you have lots of expertise to offer thank you Terry oh my we also have a resolution for Ian somebody please uh read the resolution and recognition and appreciation of distinguished service by Ann Hilton I will be happy to read it resolution and recognition and appreciation of distinguished service by Ean Ian Hamilton whereas Ian Hamilton was appointed to the Portage public school's Board of Education on December 12th 2022
103to fill the vacancy created by the resignation of trustee Rusty Rathburn and served on the board through December 2024 whereas as a board member Ian has served graciously tirelessly with the utmost care and compassion she served during times of celebration for our district including the building and sight sinking fund renewal in August 2024 Ian has provided invaluable Insight perspective and guidance guidance to the Board of Education now therefore be it resolved that the Portage Public Schools Board of Education acknowledges and extends its gratitude to Ian Hamilton for her dedication and service to The District staff students community and to the Board of Education be it further resolved that this resolution is saved in the permanent minutes of the Portage Public Schools Board of Education and a copy is given to Ian Hamilton adopted this 9th
104day of December 2024 page Public Schools board education thank you Terry is there a motion please to approve the resolution I move to approve the resolution excellent thank you is there second second thank you Terry all those in favor of approving the resolution and recognition and appreciation of distinguished service by trustee Ian Hamilton please say I I I oppose the motion passes again unanimous can't believe it and Ian I can't think of a finer individual to walk out the door with yeah I already gave my comments but I know that it has been a short run but I appreciate everyone um I'll still be watching and listening my kids as you all know go for to public school so I will be around listening and appreciate everyone when I just appreciate how we came to
105get you yes yes you did you would have known that your picture in an article about your family in a magazine would have would have led us to you but uh knowing that you were my neighbor and we've had some great conversations prior to your moving somewhere else and it's just been really fun to get to know you and your family and just appreciate your professionalism and expertise and um Viewpoint too that's different than some of the rest of us so we appreciate that thank you yeah and uh I don't have a 25 year history with you I have exactly a two-year history with you and it started when we met in this room probably two years ago and uh it it's been a blast and I would have to say to describe your style
106would be and you get away with this um incredibly polite and at the same time incredibly blunt and and you pull it off um you you ask the question you ask the tough question and uh yes I I tell people stories about I know this lady who gets away with doing it and so it's a great that's a great skill and I've had fun watching it and I've had fun watching the answers that your questions elicit thank I will miss you well and we thank you for your service we thank you for your Insight um um it was said earlier that you ask really good questions and you really do make you make us think and um I particularly uh appreciate your comments on how we track and display student data we had never thought
107of that and we appreciate your input there so thank you very much and keep watching okay I will all right and oh we got a certificate for you too so we'll present that at the end of the meeting thank you very much real quickly I want to say to both Ian and Keith um I sincerely appreciate the Insight you have brought to the various discussions we've had particularly the 4:00 meetings as we get to go back and forth a little bit more there um and how differently you think and approach um different situations and I really appreciate you bringing that inside to the board I think it's been extraordinarily beneficial and you will be sorely missed very much so keep challenging us I will good good okay uh we'll move to our final action item
108of the evening and that's the appeal regarding curriculum materials and I'll just uh make some opening remarks to set this up uh this this appeal is from uh Katrina shrer following a decision by a reconsideration committee to maintain a children's novel the bread winner as instructional material for one unit of the fifth grade reading and writing curriculum uh board members have received cop copies of all the following for review we have the minutes of the first reconsideration committee meeting Where Mrs shrer voiced her concerns about the impact of graphic violence on students in the novel The Bread winter we have the minutes of the second reconsideration committee meeting where the committee voted unanimously 9 to Z to maintain the bread winner as part of the curriculum an email from Dr Pasco uh to Mrs Sher
109upholding the decision of the reconsideration committee a letter from Mrs uh shrer to the reconsideration committee clarifying her AR arguments about the novel and responding to comments made during the reconsideration meetings we have a letter from Mrs shraer of the Board of Education appealing the decision of the reconsideration committee on the grounds that the reconsideration committee members were biased that operational polic policies and administrative guidelines were not provided before meetings of the reconsideration took place and during meetings of the reconsideration committee Mrs Shader was made to look like she was the only person who had issues with the graphic violence in the bread winner we have minutes of a policy committee meeting where members of the policy committee requested background information and clarification of the relevant policies from the from the superintendent since this appeal
110is something the board has never been asked to do before we received an email from the superintendent to the board providing background information and clarifying the operational policies and administrative guidelines that apply uh we have public comment received at several meetings and uh most of those public comments uh were uh given to uh our board secretary who made copies for us after the meetings so um everybody has all this correct right okay so there are two motions on page 91 we need a motion on the floor to begin board discussion of this appeal is there a motion please can I ask a question before we make a motion sure I don't know if that's appropriate or not um during the comments this evening the main thread I heard was let's not decide keep it or
111not but can we redo with a different grouping of people and I don't know if that's something that is appropriate or not to consider so just wanted to toss that out there well I think we have to address the appeal okay well President Van Anor I would like to make a motion at the Board of Education move to deny the appeal and maintain the bread Warner in the curriculum thank you Keith is our second second thank you Ian okay I'll open this up for board discussion so anyone can start well I'll lead off uh by saying that I feel like my role as a board member is to review the process we have place to um implement the process I think it was thoroughly implemented um and that is the basis for my motion as
112I've made it I would agree with Keith and uh one of the big pieces of information that we received was that 19 people were asked to be on the Review Committee and so to me that would show that every effort was made to get a diverse group of people that it's not exactly easy to find people to serve so thank you Terry I frequently find myself wearing two hats mom board member and it's a tough role to balance because as a mom I've read the book is that a book I want my kid to read well there's some questionable things I think it's a remarkably easy read for a fifth grader but the content in it is questionable um the visual images that are described are disturbing and I'm kind of stuck in an interesting
113spot because while I want to support and follow the process um I do hear from the perspective that we don't feel like they were hurt by the appropriate group of people um I know if I was a parent in that situation I would be probably following those same steps that being said I don't have the information for myself as far as what else could we have in place for um the kids to be reading that would get that information that they wanted that the reason this book is being included what other source of material can give that same content that may not be as graphic because giving fifth graders and granted yes there are fifth graders that watch horror movies there are first graders that parents let them watch horror movies that's fine that's their
114choice as a parent there are other parents who are much more reserved and much more concerned about maintaining that innocence of childhood and yes in fifth grade we're starting to learn and you know learn more Explore More we're getting more into those adult topics but I find it challenging to be talking with my kid about the horrors of War yes War happens yes bad happens yes it's in the world but this is horrific to be talking with a your kid about a pile of heads in a basket like melons that's one of the IM things that's depicted in this book I don't know know how many of us have read it but it that's one of the things I don't think had been mentioned but that's one of that I read that really resonated with
115me was a basket of melons of that are heads so while I know our job is to say did we follow the process properly um I can see some missteps in there and I could see that being grounds for us to explore an alternate review of the book perhaps to give more parents to volunteer that aren't necessarily aligned part of the school district but are parents in the school district but aren't necessarily working at the school district um I don't think it would be that challenging to find parents to do that I myself would do that if I was a parent in that situation and in fact I have with books at my kids school um so for me I think that we should Grant the appeal and move through that process so I would
116say say personally that I'm would lean to be a conservative parent protective of my kids that being said I had a child in second grade when 911 happened and that was a horrific thing and it was something real that happened that we had to explain to our kids and the war in Afghanistan is a result of that so so the real stuff happened and we do have to embrace it and make sure that our kids know that things go on in other parts of the world that don't go on here and actually as an aside isn't it great that we live here and those things don't happen here so yeah I understand what you're saying but I also feel like we can't protect our kids from all of that's going on out there and honestly
117if there were things in the book that were um sexually explicit or blatant use of drugs alcohol uh things that kids could be potentially drawn to emulate I would be much more upset about that being discussed in fifth grade than something that's going on on the other side of the world so that's just my perspective I respect that perspective thank you Terry want to go next bow or you have comments written or should I I'm open yeah please go I don't have specific comments written I just have some talking points so hopefully they make sense um as I looked at this I looked at a number of things um first of all I read the book because I don't want to just take what someone says about it and make an assumption because I'm one
118who wants to see is what I'm being told accurate it's just who I am um I want to avoid the danger of a single story because if you get only one side of something or you make a snap judgment about something chances are you might not be accurate and so I wanted to come to my own conclusion um I thought about when I first sought to be a board member and I promised to myself and to those I spoke to that I would listen and consider that didn't necessarily mean that I would agree but I would listen and I would consider and I wanted to apply that to this process and looking at this book first of all it's it's a new book to Portage relatively new um when you consider textbooks or instructional materials
119that we have had in our schools this is one of the newer ones it's rather new and for adoption and anytime you adopt something new there will be um wrinkles that you don't expect and when you look at something and say this is going to be amazing it doesn't always work out as well as you do and that's why we review things and that's why we look at them again and that's why we consider as they're in process to see how it shakes out and we realize that nothing that we Implement will be perfect as much as we would love for it to be and as much as we intend for it to be nothing will be perfect so I kind of went with those um the boards role in this is what I looked
120at also um the question is it procedurally correct you know how are we as board supposed to look at this and the board provides accountability and if we don't provide accountability then what is the purpose of having a board and so with that in mind I wanted to take this very seriously as I know every one of us in looking at this has done so um as I have heard comments and listen to comments from others we're taking this seriously and I want parents to know that you have been heard and considered and I want also the acknowledgement to the curriculum team that did a lot of hard work figuring out curriculum in a very short time and there's a lot to be considered so that's kind of the base of what I was looking
121at with short turn around and so on and in looking at policies um there it it stood out to me here um of course I highlighted in the wrong color the Board of Education shall provide instructional materials and Equipment um within budgetary constraints which means that ultimately responsibility is on us and that's a pretty serious consideration to look at um there's also policy um regarding well it's an administrative guideline regarding criteria for selection of materials and uh point on that refers to the maturity Andor comprehension level of the students and comprehension no big deal but maturity especially developmentally for students is this appropriate for them and is this the most appropriate and as I was looking at this a a comment came to mind um it's actually given to me and it resonated so I
122wrote it down just because nine and 10 year olds are going through this doesn't mean that N9 and 10 year olds should be reading the details about it and how we discuss with kids varies depending on their developmental level and you know in education refer to that as dap developmentally appropriate practices um I also looked at this book one we need more books that expose children to other viewpoints and perspectives bottom line we need more books ref represent under represented groups um the number of books related to people and experiences in Arabic countries or the Middle East is minimal as far as in schools in general and I want to highlight that because the fact that we have a book representing viewpoints from Arabic countries and Middle Eastern countries is I feel a very good
123thing and enormous um these are books that connect learning Beyond Ela so we're looking at in this case a book that connects to social studies connects to Human Rights connects to things um all good things but then I go back to those it is only a few pages but those pages that to a reader that is nine or 10 years old who hasn't been exposed to violence in TV shows to movies who reads in a sense that produces imagery in the head instead of just reading a word at a time many kids read that way one word at a time is but for on who produce images in their head as they read to come across that kind of image is difficult and so my question then is is there one that is there a
124way to provide a book that provides other viewpoints and perspectives which I even went and pulled out the objectives and lessons for the unit um that that gives those ways of thinking about how others perceive things which like I said Ian you do for me which is amazing and I love it and I appreciate it so much or a book that provides representation for people from from the Middle East that doesn't necessarily provide quite so graphic of an image or even a way to um Pro so that students can read this book without necessarily having to read Those portions is there a way that that can be provided and my challenge then would be have an amazing curriculum team that does amazing work that they would be able to do so um that I have
125full confidence and faith that you guys are incredible and would be able to do that so that we are providing the good stuff without providing the trauma to students that would be traumatized um my every interaction with every anyone from the curriculum team has been excellent and left me with a feeling of being overly impressed and then even more so every future consecutive time that I I interact um does that need to be like Emily said a new looking at it again in order to re-evaluate how can we do that to provide the benefits that are there without the trauma does that make sense have we had any reports of students that have been traumatized and if so how many but how I'm just wondering how many out of the fifth grade students have we
126received more than if we you recall when we toured the elementary buildings we specifically asked principales if they had had any comments and I think out of our eight elementaries we had two that said they had a couple people say things others said they had heard nothing that they were fine right so um just I mean that's as much as we know okay I did observe too when we were at Central um there a class that was reading about Malala and Malala was attacked and targeted to be killed and so that also is violent and I read that book also to be fair uh because I wanted to read all the books in the unit that I could get my hands on to give it a balanced perspective and what was interesting about malala's book
127is that he spoke about being attacked but not in the sense of going through the details of the attack while she was experiencing it um it was not near even though the violence was or even though the overall her story included violence it was presented in a way that you understood that violence had happened without the imagery being in your head as you were watching it so you knew it you knew the gravity of it without the imagery being so descriptive and so present okay but the bottom line really is it's not our job to evaluate every piece of material that's used for curriculum so to to for us to critique and analyze is beyond really our purvey yet according to the statement um the Board of Education shall provide instructional materials the responsibility ultimately
128reli lies on us um we trust those to make decisions But ultimately then it lies on us I apologize continue um I I appreciate the disc discuss um and I wasn't on the reconsideration committee but um I'm kind of coloring outside the lines but I read it too good I think a lot of us did too um I wrote some comments I've scratched some of them out and I've added some others um I just felt it was important enough to try to get the wording right um but um I'm going to support I'm going to support the motion and I'm going to support the reconsideration committee's recommendation um the first two things things I want to do is I want to thank members of the reconsideration committee um for their work and I want to
129thank Mrs shrer for raising the concern and for using the process um some background and I think it ties into some of the conversation here but um so our board delegates matters um related to school operations to the superintendent and we do it for good reason uh these are complicated issues and professional expertise is important and and Mark doesn't make these decisions alone he involves others he he has processes um I see my role as a board member um in cases like these is basically to be a back stop um it's to guard against any recommendation that could come to us or come down that I would see it's clearly going beyond the general sensibilities of our community so I reserve the right to weigh in I do reserve the right to to weigh in
130I'm just saying the bar is set really high and I'm saying in this case I don't see an overstep I don't I don't see the bar being cleared in this instance I would say this um I would ask our administrative team okay so more background we've gone through a cycle of this being taught this fall I suspect we're going to see a cycle of it going through next fall I would say keep an open mind um be open to feedback and be willing to second guess yourselves and if and if you do change your mind um make the change um so anyway I but but tonight I feel it's important I feel that that in my judgment my role as a as a trustee is to support the reconsideration committee's uh recommendation I appreciate your
131thoughtfulness I'll weigh in here um three requirements to be a Schoolboard member you got to be a registered voter you have to be a US citizen you got to be 18 years old and in fact some of us are a lot older than 18 years old uh there's no requirement for board members to be Educators and I think that's one of the reasons board members are so torn here because we're in a role now that we don't normally participate in we have a superintendent who's charged with developing administrative guidelines for the selection of materials instructional materials and to provide a process for appealing the selection of those materials and all these guidelines and processes are in place because of the policies that we have and that's how boards operate through their policies not on a
132whim uh pursuant to the policy the board is required to provide funding for instructional materials not to approve the instructional materials but rather to provide the process or to provide the funds to purchase them a majority of this board approved the purchase of the new reading and writing curriculum not the curriculum itself after being informed at several meetings about the need for a new curriculum the lengthy and prudent processes that were used to develop the curriculum recommendation and the benefits of the new curriculum for our students one of the main one was explained to us is because it ties reading and writing together and as we as was mentioned earlier the board's primary primary role in these matters is oversight and on long-term student outcomes not on the administrative or programmatic methods of getting there
133the board's focuses on what's best for all students not some students and what's best for the community as a whole not what's best for part of the community um maybe some things could have been different on the Recons during the rec consideration process but in general I think it was handled properly I don't think uh I don't think changes would have uh changed the outcome I mean I'm supporting the breadwinner as part of the fifth grade reading and writing curriculum um one of my one of my major concerns here is we've never been put in this position before um our policies are vague as they govern appeals to the board um we talked in policy committee about how to do this and really had no idea and thought we'd try this you know uh we've
134never reviewed these policies for the reason is that uh nothing like this has ever been brought to US during this review process we've learned that a number of boards do not entertain appeals like this and that the appeals process stops with the findings of a reconsideration committee and in my opinion this is something we should consider because I just think this puts is in a really difficult spot and uh I don't think it's a spot we're necessarily qualified to be in so any other comments I will see I really respect what you just said um and that's one of one of the things I've been weighing back and forth because I know we talked about moving forward appeals processes on on other types of appeals and how we would handle that as whether the processes
135were handled appropriately and right here this is where I think we might need to clarify and solidify and that's some work we can do about maybe what the committee should look like what's the makeup of the committee and maybe put that in some specifics for me why I say that um why I be voting against this amendment would be because I don't think that that Review Committee um maybe was as what's the right word do I say balanced as it could have been and that's the reason why I think that we could give it the opportunity to be Recon considered to give that balance I'm not saying that this book does not need to be a part of the curriculum and I want to be really clear on that I'm saying I don't think that
136our reconsideration process was balanced enough to move forward with that decision I personally don't like the book but that's not what I'm basing all this decision on well you have to remember too Emily that we approve operational policies we don't approve administrative guidelines we charge Mark with developing those guidelines agre and we're we're certainly not going to move into that Arena I don't believe but I hear you any other comments from board members this is a hard I think every one of us has battled ourselves internally with what the right process is in moving forward because one it's new and two our children are so important and we all value our children whether they are hours personally or hours in that they attend the school district that's true we're here to do what's best for
137kids every person who has spoken has spoken from the heart and has been vulnerable in how you have spoken and whether we have agreed completely or in part we have listened respectfully and thank you thank you K are there any other comments call the question I think we should Robert all those in favor of denying the appeal and maintaining the breadwinner in the curriculum please say I I opposed opposed I'll oppose just because like Emily said the process of needs to be more or the process needs to be clarified more so I don't know if that should be an oppose or a abstain but it I think we need more clarification now that we've been through and um whether the committee reconsiders or whether that policies reconsider I'd like to see it reconsidered not necessarily
138removed whether that reconsideration is in how it's handled with the curriculum or within the classroom or whether it's how the communication with parents is handled something need to adjust okay so you are voting no then based on your comments I think so yes okay not approving how's that um okay so yeah okay thank you kimy so the motion passes 5 to two thank you uh our next item is a discussion item the Neola policy revisions and that's on page they start on Mark's explanation starts on page 93 yeah well you have several uh policies that Neola is recommending that we make revisions to um the first bunch of these policies are primarily driven by uh the Office of Management budget uh and we have reviewed not only this group but all of the policies uh
139by our various uh departments and Lead administrators and they've they come to us from uh after review with legal counsil as well so uh We've included all those policies in the board packet the uh struckout portions are what we're uh proposing to be deleted uh the green portions is what we're adding uh so that again that first bunch is around office management and budget recommendations uh the remainder of the uh policies that are in here uh deal with a variety of uh uh of act uh Act activities and issues uh one is about um including all of our athletic coaches that they hold a valid C uh certification and CPR and the use of AED machines uh beginning with next school year uh there's some additional explanation about the use of Naran uh in an
140existing policy for opioid antagonists uh a a revision to a policy to make sure that includes the new requirement that we includ a a card cardiac response plan uh in our in our district and then uh updated requirements from the Michigan State Police around uh background checks so pretty root I mean they're they're pretty routine they do involve quite a bit of uh quite a few changes in the policies but they are uh routine and and not unexpected who gained more understanding from Mark's memo than actually reading the policies yes definitely that's a lot of paper mark it is and and the bulk of this fell on Paula and and her staff to make sure because she did to us she did this to us yes well they deal you just got thrown under the
141bus a lot of it deals with federal funds and the administration of the grants the grant monies that we get and there just some some really um kind of technical tweaks to our policies but some that we have to abide by if we're going to receive federal funds I look forward to approving these in January and I think it's appropriate that we assign board members to each policy to explain it to the rest of the anyway uh with that uh we've reached the end of our agenda if board members could stick around to have a photo with uh Keith and Ian that would be great and we are adjourned thank you thank you