001okay like to call to order tonight's Charter Township of Oxford Planning Commission regular meeting Thursday February 13 2025 we will start by Rising paying strs to the fled States stands Nation God indivisible liy and justice for thank you very much and just as a reminder everybody make sure your mics are on and close enough to be heard and as a quick reminder to all the gentlemen in the room tomorrow's Valentine's Day throwing it out there okay uh can we get not the rooll please noted there is a forum and it's full thank you um item number four approval of tonight's agenda can I get a motion to approve tonight's agenda motion to approve tonight's agenda okay we have a motion we have a second uh any discussion seeing none all in favor I any opposed
002okay that motion carries item number five conflicts of interest exper take contact does anybody have anything they need to disclose or share seeing none uh we'll move on to number six approval of the minutes Planning Commission regular meeting January 23rd 2025 motion to approve minutes Planning Commission regular meeting January 23rd I'll second the motion okay we have a motion we have a second any discussion seeing none all in favor I I any oppos motion carries item number seven public comment on items not scheduled for the public hearing or on tonight's agenda does anybody have anything they would like to bring up that is not on the agenda or not for public hearing seeing none we'll move on to number eight commissioner's comments does anybody have anything before we uh get started all right number nine
003public hearing uh purpose of the public hearing is to receive public comments regarding petition PC 24-4 applicant Oxford real estate LLC 10503 Citation Drive sweet 100 Brighton Michigan requests for special land use for a skilled nursing home and rehabilitation facility on parcel 04 342000 025 along West draer Road near Pontiac Road and just to remind everybody um the way this will work um any members of the public that wish to address the the commission um start by giving your name your address uh and your position that you'd like to discuss um you'll be given 3 minutes um everybody will have a chance to discuss in all Direction comes to the chair um nobody will speak twice until everybody's had a chance to to speak um so does anybody have anything they would like to discuss
004regarding this petition think you should have um Mato speak first because then they'll know what this is you have to open a public hearing a motion to open the public hearing you want to start and then we'll sure hey good evening good Even's see here good evening M lock Carman Associates for the toship planners um so tonight uh you have in front of you for your public hearing a special land use a preliminary site plan um it's anli for a 90 bed uh cute Acute Care and Rehabilitation Center um I'm going to kind of go through just a generalization of my notes uh we'll go through kind of the standards uh for development for these types of projects uh and then we will look at the special landu standards and then after that I'm happy
005to answer questions and I can M off to JB um so the facility would be a a 90 bedroom nursing home as we discussed uh nursing homes are special land uses in the R2 Zone um so if something is permitted and meet standards you technically must approve if something is a special land use it does give the plan commission a little bit of discretion as far as uh requirements that they may have of the site so long as they are reasonable and tied to the finding facts in your ordinance um as a relates to that those standards are in section four and 5.14 of your ordinance and I've referenced them tonight in our report uh the building will be uh 51550 ft um and occupy approximately half the site um there will be 72 resident
006rooms and nine semi-private rooms amenities will include a beastro salon a kitchen some living area uh the project is is proposed to employ about 107 employees uh with the largest shift being approximately 50 and shift Changers being at 8 a.m. 400 p.m. and midnight the South and Eastern portions of the site are remain in their natural state um however we do kind of bring up at the side portion the Eastern portion of the site will still be of of a developable size for future consideration nothing's being discussed tonight nothing's been proposed it's just worth you understanding that um other portions of the site will be of a developable size uh if in down the road uh those opportunities present um the plan in front of you tonight does reflect um some changes that the applicant
007made to the plan uh after we met with them uh all all site plans require a pre-application meeting it's an opportunity for us to give them some feedback they had some the site was arranged in a couple of ways that uh we requested some changes on and what you have in front of you tonight reflects those changes so we was kind of like to acknowledge that uh in the process of things um and for order of process special land uses preliminary site plan and then final site plan are all approved by the Planning Commission uh there's no part of this that will go to the board uh with that looking at the site description the site's uh 19.2 Acres gross 18 Acres net in the development area where they'll be building is is 10 acres
008um your future land use has the site designated as Vis Village Residential 12,000 ft lots and the surrounding uses include single family housing and institutional uses single family housing along the east and south with institutional uses to the West there's no issues with placement as far as site setbacks height placement uh they're all good there natural features the site does have some slopes and Mild depressions uh there's a wet land along drainer Road uh that is likely regulated by eagle uh so the applicant has acknowledged and we've called out the fact that they'll need some permits to do work in and around that area um for the process that we put them through in Oxford preliminary then you go get your permits everybody all your agencies sign up on your permits you come back for
009final so they don't need it now but they do need to acknowledge that they'll need it which they have um there are Woodlands present along the western half of the site uh this is the area that will be affected by the development itself uh there are scattered tree clusters um kind of on the remainder Eastern and Southern portion of the site um the site plan does indicate where existing trees and vegetation will remain and or be protected during construction uh again is kind of the the development area is kind of the western northern half or I guess the better way to say would be the Northwestern portion of the site is kind of where the development area is uh there will be some extensive grading required in that area um to accommodate the building and
010the improvements access and circulation uh the site will be accessed by a 27t wide drive off West draer Road um rcoc did provide some recommended improvements to the access for the site which they have incorporated into their plan um they did provide a traffic impact study which kind of highlighted was specifically designed around nursing home uses which accounted for the type of traffic that they were looking to generate um and there's an 8ot safety path uh shown along West triner there are some safety path considerations tonight that the plan commission need to make as it relates to Pathfinder heroy um I'm going to let Mr Sharp go through that um parking standards they've met all of the parking standards as as it relates to Dimension placement count Ada all of that um essential services and
011utilities again I kind of defer to Jim on that one the one point that I'll make is that from a service perspective we do have the fire department review all plans uh and with the exception of citing some issues about wanting fire suppression and circulation they did not cite any concerns with um the potential increase in Life Safety Services uh these types of facilities typically generate they've acknowledged that they will likely need to service the site as needed but they did not s concerns with their capacity to do so um Landscaping Landscaping isn't really due until final you you only have to provide minor information at preliminary however they have kind of given us a full Landscaping plan um and they've met those standards associated with it um the again the areas outside the development
012plan are proposed to be left as is um as I had said their Landscaping standards have been met one of the things that um I've kind of put on their radar and we can discuss further tonight but again isn't due till final is along the west side where they provided their buffer requirements um it looks as though the new Landscaping is actually kind of at the lower end of the area where they'd be grading so I've kind of asked if we can't move those further up the grade so that they you know if they're too far down the grade and the building's up here what's the purpose of landscape screening um and we've discussed it a little bit I know the applicants here tonight can speak to those things um but that was the only
013thing that we kind of noted in the Landscaping that we thought was worth conversation um lighting again lighting is due at final they did provide some preliminary cut sheets for the types of lighting that they plan to use um and those light temperatures are set to the new lighting standards of 35 uh 3500 Kelvin uh they have indicated they're aware of the requirements of 10.2 e which is your lighting standards and that they will provide a photometric plan um that gives us the information necessary to assess those um I would say as we kind of work through this evening one of the conversations for these sets of facilities and again I'll let the applicant kind of speak to it as well is um obviously there is kind of a 247 nature about these sites not
014in the essence that it is hustle and bustle of 247 but this is a nursing care facility that will provide services to their residents who are staying for an extended period of time um and so with that I guess it you know we kind of want to just have the conversation about site lighting parking lot lighting and things of that nature again there are your new lighting standards are a big improvement over your old ones and do kind of highlight standards as far as when lights can be on when they can be off it does offer the Planning Commission some discretion when it comes to that again we will we will say yay or nay to that in final not tonight but it's worth tonight you asking questions if you have them up the applicant
015as it relates to those things um from an architecture standpoint uh fiber cement board glazing metal parit are the primary exterior materials textured stucko and Brace metal canopies to find the building's entrance um and they will they will need to provide elevations of all sides at final um during preliminary what they've provided is appropriate so those are the site standards as we discussed um now I'll we'll kind of take a look at the special land use standards it is never my intent to sit here and read you for beta my review uh so I'm I but given it special land use I'll kind of try to paraphrase and then kind of provide you the responses that we we looked at um as it relates to your standard special land use requirements uh the site you
016know it must be compatible with adjacent uses of lands in terms of size character location uh reduction of negative impacts things of that nature um provide service provide a a service or fulfill a need for the township so when we looked at this we we did see that the proposed nursing homes do provide services of need in the township and the region as a whole um the design is conducive with that of a residential function they've tried to provide some residential Design Elements to the site um lighting and Landscaping considerations we've kind of discussed that'll be important to kind of figure out what the applicant as we go on as it's based on 24 hours operation and screening requirements um the proposed land use must be consistent and promote the intent and purpose of the
017zoning ordinance and all other applicable codes with the exception of a few conditions we've put in tonight they have met the standards of your zoning ordinance excuse me uh this proposed special land use um must not POS an unreasonable impact upon the natural environment so obviously I mean there is a portion of the site that will need to be cleared in order for the development itself however the applicant has um you know a plac the building uh in a nature that's further away from the single family homes and at least for now is and I say at least for now because there is a portion of site that's big enough to be developed in the future but for now has called out that those areas are to remain in their natural state um and has
018outlined that in the plan um the special landies must be compatible with the capacity of public services and Facilities so again you can talk to utilities I've talked to the fire department uh I think that they are sufficient in that nature um sorry just getting through here the proposed special land use must be consistent with vehicle turning patterns traffic flow intersections view obstructions inly guess off street parking they've met the parking they've met your access standards we all know traffic is an issue right it doesn't really matter what development we're looking at where traffic is an issue um again that's kind of why we go through the process with rcoc that's why you have traffic impact studies that we look at um but as it relates to obtaining the necessary permits for traffic and the
019way that they've designed their site they have met your standards in that regard um the proposed land use must be designed located pled and operated so the public health safety and Welfare are protected the site's been basically in the placement of the building some of the screening requirements um that they've provided um and just kind of the consideration again of the of the mass of the building the placement of it as it relates to single family residential nearby um we do feel as though the site has done its best to address kind of the welfare needs uh of the community and then the proposed special land use must be consistent with the goals objectives and future land use described in the master plan so your current master plan has this as Village Residential um which
020is more accli to a single family style use development um obviously the property has a there's a residential character about it um and there isn't a residential use to it but there's a character about it and it is outlined as a as a special land use in R2 so we don't see any major conflicts with the future land use map um and the future land use or the master plan also speaks to the provision of diverse housing options um and aging and place facilities again it's not a senior center home but it does provide you know services that are in need for an aging population in the to sh um so those are your general special Landes requirements whenever we get a special Landes we go through all those ones that relate specifically to these
021types of facilities uh the nursing homes is that all Ingress and shall be directly on a County Primary Road check minimum land area per person cared for shall be 3,000 square ft the numbers are in your review but check um and all buildings are set back at least 75 ft from all property lines check they've met that so with that we've got our standards we got our special land use gym will go up next but I'm happy to answer any questions you may have at this time I'll I'll kind of work my right to left with Commissioner of WS at first not to put you on the spot no even though I did at all at all that's fine um let's see so construction entrance location we talked about that briefly um is there the
022opportunity to make sure we don't have Pathfinder that road be abused from a construction standpoint there from a Zone ordinance perspective no however I do know that the building department and and Jim's team kind of work with when when sites are under construction do work to make sure that certain standards for the reduction of nuisances like dust with silk fence making sure the roads are washed or up um you know the the the drains are backed and swept things of that nature the applicant will have their time in front of you and you can definitely have a conversation about what they may be able to do in ways of construction traffic um there isn't anything in the zoning ordinance that I could enforce building Department's on top of things and we do work with them
023on it it's all about I'm thinking about being a good neighbor as if construction were progress that's all sure no appreciate um let's see on the site lighting we talked a little bit about that earlier you know I'm picturing if I live on Pathfinder looking out my front window and I'm looking at this new facility to the to the West there'll be parking lot polar lights there and that maybe as we go through this process there could be opportunity maybe to screen the the light that would if if I'm looking up at a 20ft pole say that that could somehow be Shel blocked I'd be maybe potentially asking the applicant if something could be done to um to be respectful of our neighbors um in the area and and shield that light somehow I know
024that there excuse me there's trees that will be um elect to some sort of a screen in the distance quite far from there but um this would be a kind of a shock I think to that area to say you know it's all trees now and all of a sudden there's going to be parking lot and light poles and um I I know that um there's been some discussion about dimming of those fixtures past a certain time and that will be part of the final um but that that's also an art ordinance I believe yeah and again those the lighting uh standards were updated with the RC last year and our are a b improvement over what you had before so there is they will need to provide us with a lot of information photometrics
025um and you know and information about light angle glare reduction all that kind of stuff so we can make sure the lights are faced in the right direction and potentially depending on what they put forward a conversation about dimming at certain to and things like that the um the screening with trees I believe I saw some trees are being added along that um between Pathfinder or um and and the existing trees that will remain but there's some additional added up did I read that right there were some yeah those yes and actually those were um that was something that they uh added for us because the way they have their plan quadrant out it sometimes it's hard to make sure what lines up with what but they that extra trees are actually there to assist
026with additional screening of the like the dumpster and the generator pad um and that that part of the facility um and that is that is along with what will remain on the site speaking of the dump and the paded I noticed that those are moved to the front or they're in the front not close to say residential which is to the more to the South and um East so I think that that's a a benefit to the community around that area that those were moved to that location um the traffic volumes um I I didn't quite I'm not sure for someone I can speak maybe the applicant can speak to the um the traffic volume study that was done some of the numbers didn't quite make sense to me and I didn't understand the peak
027the peak hours or the peak Trips Trips during peak time maybe so that we to put it yeah I think I can't I know know what they have can speak to it if they can and I would welcome Jim's feedback as well but I mean that the the way it was structured is around a nursing home style of use but whether or not it whether or not it accur I don't say accurately we've talked about like shift change you know what I mean in the generated there and those numbers don't seem to be reflected in that but I don't want to get too far ahead of it without at least allowing the applicate to discuss it um you know and or whatever thoughts Jim may or may not have had about it and from what
028I was reading the shift changes what happened at 8:4 and midnight a.m. midnight and if there's about 50 people working during the day that could be potentially 50 Vehicles right and then shift overlap they may be between 7:30 a.m. and 8:30 a.m. you know there could be 50 Vehicles entering and 30 leaving plus minus um and I didn't quite see that those numbers in that uh that study so I some further explanation would be helpful there okay um the uh let's see emergency response um and maybe I'm not sure if you're the appropriate person to talk about that or it's the fire department you know how would they respond to emergency on a site like that and I know that they've reviewed for um fighting a fire for example their fire HS and all that
029stuff and maybe I should be asking the chair's question I don't know was you're a firefighter aren't you I was okay but um do you have any information on um how emergency response would be happening to this site I'm thinking about sirens and that type of stuff yeah I mean all I can all I can speak to is that again fire departments involved in prea they're involved in preliminary review and I know that even even after their review came out I I made time to talk with the uh the fire marshal to just kind of again pick his brain about it and he said you know yeah these sites typically require uh an increase in Life Safety Services but he wasn't concerned about the capacity to do so now as far as the procedures as
030you know do they do they come in full Sirens all the time do they not that I that I couldn't speak to sure sure okay TI ially when the guys are coming in to these types of scenes if they're coming in off drainer once they cross Pathfinder they're going to be shutting down the sirens as they come in one because it wouldn't disrupt these neighbors and wake up everybody in the nursing home so I mean when they're pulling in that driveway they're going to be shutting them down typically thank you um just a couple more things um neutral colors you know I think we we read something in the um in the the special use about um blending with the surrounding neighborhood and um at the exact language i' have to find it but um
031I noticed in the pictures of the the front of the building kind of have a they're not they don't appear to be neutral they seem to stand out a little bit more maybe some more modern colors if there's opportunity um by the applicant to potentially adjust that so it's maybe Blends a little bit more and it doesn't um maybe go against any of their uh if they have a corporate you know theme for their you're asking McDonald's to be whatever that yeah I just it would be something that I think would help it blend with the community and less less of an impact so um that's just uh let's see and if if homes were built in the area it's my last question um start to take up so much time if if homes were
032to be built in that property do you have a ballpark what that might look like you read my mind on I was like this is this is going to come up yeah no so under the current zoning of R2 with the net developable area of the entire site mhm accounting for uh roads and things of that nature I calculated you probably could get 26 to 27 single family homes on the site um I I don't think I'm out of my way saying that they would require a site be clearcut and even more grading be done um as it relates to your master plan and if you were ever to follow the current master plan and go to the Village Residential you're probably looking at closer to 50 single family housing units on the site okay
033so under your current zoning just be clear you probably could get 26 to 27 homes on the site but that would again that would be clear cutting the site grading the site thank you yeah no problem commissioner blon yeah that okay but my questions have been addressed so D's good at that that's where we let go first think clear everybody thank you sir sure not a problem commissioner bayy um just a couple questions um with Pathfinder being right there um I know we've got the safety path running along drainer and it kind of is the the path to nowhere because it stops you know the end of their property but across the street is where the the main path picks up um is it out of line to request some of those motion lights or
034whatever for people that are walking down that path to be able to cross drainer pick up the other side of the path and then kind of with that if you're going to have 30 40 cars pulling in and out of here every eight hours for shift change have they thought about putting some type of motion light to maybe control traffic at shift change that would blink other times I don't know if that's normal yeah I mean I would when Jim's up I would solicit his comments about the safety path okay and as it relates to the traffic is that something Jim have we ever seen RC come back with a recommendation like that some they wouldn't put one there because it's too close to Pontiac Street okay okay so that's I my reference was like
035I was wonder if rcoc did think that was appropriate for that would they ever call it out yeah I can address it when I get up there per okay thanks that's all I commissioner attorney um I know they they show on their drawings three handicap parks parking sites but if you could put the plot plan up so we could see it I'd like to see those I'll keep going no yeah I don't trust it's going to take a minute page nine is this a fair enough one to use that one's okay if you can see it and you see where they are there you go yeah there's a handicap parking right there and those be moved to the opposite end of that parking lot they'd be much [Music] closer to an entrance into the building
036are you are are you saying that these three spaces go over here over there the main entrance is here okay you're saying move them over here I saw make show well I was thinking over there because there is an entrance at the end of that Wing right there would would that be an emergency that's a e exit only okay okay so as as they're placed now they are the closest they could be to the main entrance understand got second item was with the type of res residents you're going to have there some of them are going to be there for quite a while is my understanding um right now I don't see any kind of a patio area or anything on the plan external that would allow those people to go outside and set in
037the Sun or or things that way I is that considered would you think about something like that the petitioner is going to have time to I was going to say can I keep his notes and the last one that I had was along what would be the west side of the property it shows on the page that I'm looking at that were at least 15 ft short of having the 75 ft setback from the property on um you mean for wondering if the whole thing can be moved over are you referring to the building h you're referring to the building I'm on the be the west side of the building right so just so you can see so this dash line is the 75 ft side back side setback line and this the closest point
038of the building to the West property land is about 80 ft well what I'm looking at shows a 75 foot line inside of that driveway well yes the driveway is within the 75 ft but the building is not but do we do we have enough room to book the landscaping and stuff outside of that or should we look at moving the entire building a little further to the east to get within the 75t requirement well to be clear they have met the 75 ft requirement the building is is is more than 75 ft back the drive is can be within that setback it's a building setback it's not a parking not or not a driveway setback it's only for the building that's what the setbacks refer to okay I didn't gather that from reading the
039documentation for the setback that's I mean duly noted section five so sometimes your setbacks um are not the standards that you would find in your R2 the standard for this one is that all buildings shall be set back at least 75 ft from the property lines okay that that's where that comes from um okay well I looked at it there was pling room on the other side just move everything over a little bit and your point being in an effort to to even get the drive out of the 75 okay yeah because you got traffic that's going to go around there and you'd like to have a a good uh buffer along that side of the property agreed and just because the buffer is an important part of the conversation to the West are the
040institutional uses um they are not residential I'm not saying good or bad I'm just making a point um okay did you have any other comments or questions no I'll let it go with that okay thank you Mr chairman commissioner wager yeah my concern or my only concern I guess one of my concerns is the idea You' got single family homes in the north the South and the east of the property and the question will be you know and when the lighting gets pulled together what what is it these homes are going to see or going to be forced to see from their properties so there's nothing nothing more irritating than the light going coming into your your window that's on 247 so I would be a little bit concerned about that or at least want
041to understand that the um the other piece was an in touched on it was this traffic study seem to really understate the uh the amount of traffic that would be going in and out of that property okay that's it good commission Austin just a couple um mostly the entrance there's only one entrance and due to EMS and everything like that normally what they'll do on these fac still have a emergency exit out the back or emergency exit so they can uh and it would be locked but it would just be for emergency purposes because of the obviously during the holidays or there's a lot of cars and those Vehicles can't get in and out so having an emergency vehicle to be able to get there uh quicker um might be something that we might need
042to look at and then also to I didn't see but do we have a storm water management plan for this property I didn't see that in there um yeah okay all right I was just curious with that because I didn't for some reason I must overlooked it but uh it was only 105 pages I don't know how you could have missed and and so obviously I was just concerned with the Run runoff of the neighborhoods so I just wanted to make make sure that we're very careful on that just due to obviously water flow sure and I Jim will go through that yeah I'll ask him that stuff too and then also too with it Pathfinder uh they're going to be putting obviously eventually some houses on Pathfinder are they going to put a fence
043down that or a um privacy fence um I didn't see it in the plans but uh to put a privacy fence there so when they build the house they don't have to build a privacy fence when they do that it's already put up are you talking about on the Eastern portion side so just to be very clear there is no proposal to put anything on that site right now okay my the purpose what I was calling for in the in the in the review was just pointing out that the remaining portion of the site is still of a developable size but there's no proposal at this time for that um if they were to bring some proposal forward it would have to go through the standard zoning review buffer standards Lance all that kind of
044I didn't know we had to cover that now due to them putting that building there due to the houses on the Pathfinder to seeing everything if they wanted to have a privacy fence or something addressed to that yeah all you all you can look at is all all you can consider is in front of you um and again my purpose of bringing it up is that just so that there's kind of this understanding that the that that site that remaining portion of the site being like that may not be in perpetuity they could bring a proposal forward later to develop that site and again at that time again these conversations would start up again about views screening things of that nature um also to uh the entrance in where it has the circle um the
045turning radius might be a little too tight for our fire and EMS to get around there um without backing up and going through just I know we I believe I know we provided circulation it's just really tight no no no so like having a instead of having the fire truck have to back up a little bit and then go um that's takes some time so maybe widening that out um in just giving it a little bit more openness towards the uh Circle or maybe even widening it out just a little bit more so they can make that turn yeah I mean these so these these are all things that you can discuss with the applicant as it relates to standards to force the CH Force the change require the change we would have to rely
046on zoning Andor feedback from the fire chief about I don't like I mean you're bringing a bail points we all kind of stay in our when it comes to expertise as to what we can push and what we can but again it's all fair conversation with the African when those are the only concerns that I real thank you commissioner no questions been answered okay now next time I start left so just so up all right thank you very much I'll let Jim come up and all right um thank you planing Commissioners Jim Sharp the township engineering consultant um you should have our review letter that's dated January 28th in front of you and with regards to um you know the special land use we're just really looking for uh items that are components to the
047infrastructure and so forth my comments in here are more about the preliminary site plan aspects of it so with regards to the special name you know all the requirements from our perspective have been met from an engineering perspective there I'm not going to reiterate what Mato has already gone through um so I'm just going to kind of go pretty quickly through my letter here and then open it up to any comments there um with regards to all the site grading all the site grading requirements have been met um for preliminary site plan again as Matteo indicated you go through your preliminary then you go through all your we'll call it you know final engineering and go get all your permits and then you come back for theile so for what's required for a preliminary site
048plan um they have uh adequately done all the uh all the all the stuff for the grading aspects with regards to the sanitary sewer um this development uh there's sanitary sewer that runs down Pathfinder and also down uh qu and there is a adequate sanitary sewer to be able to service this type of of a development so we don't have any issues with that um we had a couple comments um when we do our reviews we also provide a Redline markup of their plans and we provide that back to the applicant um primarily to assist them as they go through the final design stage but again with regards to the sanary Sewer uh we have no issues there same with the uh the Water distribution system they're planning to connected two locations on there one
049on Pathfinder and then looping it around the building and coming back out to iroy so they're completing a loop system there so no issues with water capacity in this area or with regards to the uh you know being able to provide fire protection or anything of that nature it'll be fine um Brian with regards to the storm water I mean that there's a storm water plan right there so yeah they're taking everything into a series of catch B and so forth running it back into a pond that's in the southwest corner of the property which then Outlets to an existing sewer that is on uh on Pathfinder again so they have met and will be able to meet the storm water requirements for the township even with the elevation Changs yep okay yeah I mean
050we saw a preliminary thing you know going in there they do their final profiles and so for detail so but you know from what the information that's been provided to us yeah they'll be able to you know when they do their land balancing they'll be able to uh you know collect all their storm water run it back to those ponds and so forth to meet the township requirements for that um with regards to our pavement sidewalks and curbing um all the payment they did submit a lot of payment sections on there so we're happy with all of that it meets the township requirements for that um I think standard heavy duty integr curving the parking spaces meet the requirements um they did speak to the road commission they do have preliminary feedback from them so
051I know traffic has been uh discussed a little bit uh Road Commission came back and said that they need to put a bypass lane on the north side of the road and then acceleration deceleration Lanes on the south side which they have provided for us um 8ot wide safety pass so there is a safety path I know Mr Bailey brought that up briefly so um there is one in front of the condos that are on Pathfinder right now so they are extending the safety path across the fronts of their property per Township ordinance and they are have submitted for a waiver request um for the sidewalks that are supposed to be placed on Pathfinder and yoy and doing a inl of contribution which is um allowed the Planning Commission has to approve that and pass
052committee Planning Commission have to approve that and I believe that the Township Board is the one who gives the final go-ahead on that uh we provided a cost estimate it's in the range of I believe $64,000 in order to uh um in order to negate putting the pathway slidewalk on Pathfinder and iroy so again that would be a I believe a condition of approval here tonight would that be accurate yeah would it would be a separate motion okay regardless of whether they do recommend or they do not recommend so it's a recommendation ultimately it goes to the Township board for final approval is that a concrete or an asphalt walk W because I know it's the on the other side it's concrete is it was estimated as concrete okay was estimated at concrete about I
053know that you're into the numbers there so uh $920 a square foot roughly so that was the number that we used there and came out to be about $644,500 um what was that so that was it that would be so they would still be putting the 8ot wide asphalt safety path on drainer road along their Frontage to hopefully continue this this down the road in the future and um but they're asking for a waiver on the other two with regards to the comment about Crossing you know to try to get to the other side again that was something that would have to probably be petitioned to the road commission I I I don't believe that they would that they would allow one there um the road commission would prefer that it be at the intersection
054of Pon Street or a place where people could safely cross you know there's a stop sign at least on one side of the Road there but they don't want people going across the street there we had a hard enough time getting one right here at dlap Road believe it or not but when we told them our nearest Crossings are two m a mile that way and two miles that way they said okay we'll give you one but they don't like Crossing at nons signalized intersections so um and again Pontiac Street does not actually come to their property so I think that that would probably be a challenge to get something to go across the street there um we talked about that construction access I noted that um Don and that would be something that we
055could I guess ask the applicant um but that would seem to make sense that the construction access be off of Dino road to try to minimize the traffic on Pathfinder there they just put in their temporary Stone Drive and they would use that until they get to a Time final payement and then they would tear that out and and PVE it in there so that would seem logical to me um and that's I guess we'll leave that to the applicant with regards to the traffic um again that's been discussed a lot and I know that there's shifts and so forth that are going to be happening at certain hours of the day you know as Mato said you got theoretically you could have 26 homes on the site if it was constructed under the current
056zoning average trip there's 10 average trips a day if you do that that's 260 so whether it's 26 homes or whether is this facility here of 50 people leading during the shift or something um I I think it's a toss up there really um the road draer road is obviously a primary County Road so again Road Commission we kind of rely on them to do that traffic study and to uh to look at that so if they have any issues about some of the peak hour flows or whatever you had they would look into that maybe they did and that's why they were requiring the bypass Lan in the acceleration decelerations as well Traffic Safety path Cross emergency taxes and Stor water so I think that that's my steel there and I would open it
057up I'm not going to go down the road down the line like he does so I just open up to everybody with any questions that you may have regarding engineer aspects maybe one quick question if so part of this property is undeveloped Mato indicated that maybe you know 26 single family homes could be put in there would there be enough water and sewer capacities to support those additional homes there would be um we been working from past uh reports and from new reports that we're working on um we definitely have had a certain amount of we call them Reus set aside for this property and so yes you could certainly build that many homes I believe there's even more that are allotted to this particular development or to this particular property okay thank you uh
058for the parking there I think there's roughly around 79 or 80 spots um are you guys concerned with if there's 50 people shift change having people come and be able to find parking spots do they have an overflow or an employee parking lot so visitors have guests they if they if they come they don't have to worry about waiting for a spot to park or they're not now parking on Pathfinder and walking in or on the main entrance yeah again I I would probably have to defer to the applicant on that the way that the ordinance and so forth reads you're required so many parking spaces per square foot and if there's an issue during their shift change and people got to wait and stuff then that's something that they're going to have to work
059out I believe so we don't specifically look at that any other questions engineering related at this time thank you no all right I'll be right over here do you have any more thanks okay so the way this will work is one we'll have to have a motion to open the public hearing um but before you do that uh we'll give an opportunity for the applicant to present or ask any questions or answer any questions if you'd like hi I'm John spitzky one of the Architects for the project um and and do you want me to just talk about the special land use or the entire if you just want to kind of give an overview of what you're what you're looking for and maybe address some of the questions that you've already heard yeah for
060the the special land use the three requirements um per the ordinance we have met um the 75 ft setback that we have along Pathfinder and iroy um 75 ft is required and from Pathfinder we're providing for about 425 ft and on iroy we're providing around 375 ft rather than this 75 ft that are required so the owner has requested that the building be put in the north west corner to put it as far away from the residential uses that are adjacent to the site and um so we have done that and um some of the other the the company has eight properties in southeast Michigan many of the properties are on sites that are larger than what is needed so if you if you have been at our uh Romeo facility or the pink KN
061facility you'll see that there is um undeveloped land there and they it's been undeveloped for ever since those projects have been built so um we the owner has no plans to develop the excess property on this site um and the traffic um study we did a traffic impact study that the road commission requested and they reviewed it and said it meets the requirements as far as distance to the inter section they've recommended extending the passing Lane and adding the deceleration Lane on drao road um which we've done um there's a wetland which complicated things originally we had the drive further away from Pathfinder but we had to swing it around the Wetland uh and the um 8ot safety path we've also so um gone around the Wetland and provided the um setback from the Wetland
062as well um and I I I couldn't hear some of what the conversation was earlier but if you have any other questions as far as the special land use or the prary site plan um I also have the civil engineer on the project here so um he'll be able to answer any questions on the Civil um side of the project can I ask I was going to ask Mr chair if is okay for us to address it yeah go ahead question please so can you divulge a little more on how the quantities of traffic for peak times were were developed so we understand the 14 FP times can you can youate on that a little bit how those how those numbers were generated the traffic impact study was based on standards for a nursing home
063um and generated using those standard tables for the um um uh the number of cars per hour and stuff do do you have some information on traffic impact sure study yeah I am Tim Zimmer I'm with Livingston engineering and um so the traffic impact St I hesitate to call the study because those can be that means uh a lot of things um this this information that you have there is was a warrant analysis and that was based on warrant analysis and I I'll explain for anyone who doesn't who isn't familiar with this stuff um it for purposes of the dra way design and establishing the setback the the the amount of uh passing Lane and all that that is Incorporated in the driveway entrance the warrant analysis takes the what John called tables they're from
064the from the international traffic um Engineers um not International it's it's it's called the it manual I'm not a traffic engineer but I authored that because it's basically a preliminary analysis of of from based on studies that that the that this group of Engineers has published and it's a it's a known it's a known manual that all Traffic Engineers use and it has very ious categories and in that one of the categories is for uh for um nursing homes and it's based on the number of beds um and it's this is aggregated information from a bunch of studies that they've done over time and that's where the where the factors and it's based on the factors you apply for left turns right turns turns in in and out of the out of the site is
065all based on is is those factors are multiplied by the by the total trips on on drainer road that that are in there there's a number of places you can find that information but one of them is Oakland County Road commission's website I realize I'm going into the weeds here but I'm trying to answer it your question yeah I appreciate it does that account for employees as well the the studies the aggregated studies that they've done all over the country includes employees yes it's not but just keep in mind it wasn't done specifically for this site it's based on studies that they've done all over the country and boiled it all down to uh methodology for for warrants whether not you need a a right you know a deceleration Lane that was the purpose of
066this so it's not really a study it was a warrant analysis a traffic study can be I'm sure you've seen them sitting on the on this you know it can be 100 pages long this was just a a a an analysis of that the grow commission asked for to to determine the geometrics of the of the approach okay so this is in a summary of a road study and it's not really looking at the traffic pressure that'll come from M24 at trainer making left turns you know from from people that are going to come to this facility on a Northbound travel I did notice that in the analysis or what a claimed a study um that 45% or so would be coming from the East and and that that gave me some concern because the
067drainer to the east before you get the baldwi is dirt and I don't find that a lot of people travel that part of the drainer very often they prefer to stay on paveed roads and would probably be putting more pressure on on M24 and the reason why I have that concern is because uh drainer in m 24 is one of our busiest most dangerous intersections and putting more pressure on there from Northbound traffic heading west to this facility uh would obviously be a concern so yes that's as a local person and that's good information the the warrant analysis strictly took the traffic counts directional traffic counts coming from each direction that are on the road commission website and took up the overall um the total traffic volume in both directions and and put put a
068ratio to that okay um there was no traffic counts done you know all those things that go into a fullblown traffic study okay thank you sure yeah just about to get more confused now than I was before I'm reading this page 53 in the packet and it talks about good it talks about six right turns and eight left turns peak hour left turns entering the site I so eight left turns at peak hours I'm really having a hard time understanding I I just need clarification um I understand the ratio you're talking about but it just doesn't make sense when 8 am is the day shift 400 p.m. and for 50 employees I I I'm not a traffic person but I don't think of much people ride together that many so um I guess I just
069need some help with that you know traffic is a big thing in this community um and uh the the level of service that drainers Mark mentioned level service is very poor right now and um there are quite a few accidents there so we're trying to understand how we uh um I know you can't fix that from it's a road commission issue but um yeah good data helps us I guess and I don't look at look at the stat and it just doesn't make sense to me right now yeah we well we're in contact with the road commission they've reviewed the plan on already uh and made those suggestions for the deceleration Lane and things so um we haven't had any issues with the number of parking spaces in the other eight facilities but the um
070um I guess we can have a conversation with the road commission I'm not really concerned about the parking spaces can you hear me okay my my voice is coming through this I'm not sure too close or too far away on the microphone um it's just the number the report that we have in front of us it's the numbers are very dis even or hard to understand that's all um so I'm looking for some clarity I don't know if we can get that at some point in the future or uh can you help us understand when we might get that yeah yeah I I'll try to get clarification with the help of the road commission as well to see what what their input is on it well okay I I don't know if it's a road
071commission I Mr chair am I if if I'm hearing you correctly I think what the question is going to be is have we looked at like shift change if you got 30 cars coming in 30 cars going out potentially you have 60 cars that are going to be making turns at drainer every eight hours in addition to what we have now is that what a yeah and drainer 24 is obviously a concern but also right in front of that right in front of your future facility if it was to be built the number of turns from what you're saying compared to what I see on the report is drastically different eight left turns during peak hours six right turns I I don't I just I need help understanding how maybe there's um it's just my
072level of knowledge but if you have 50 employees showing up I help me out help me out here U Can we go to page 53 real quick on the packet can you scroll on the computer page 53 do you have control of the computer right there is that is that your yeah let me let me scroll I'm sorry which page are you looking for is it oh wait I have the packet up um I have the site plan up let me get to the packet you're looking for the page 53 push on the packet if you have that I'm not sure if I can plug in quickly or not look is this the page scroll down to the bottom of that page please it's highlighted the numbers might just be off looks like they put
073those a little further yeah right there see the Box six right turns and then highlighted eight left turns during peak hours I I just need help understanding what what what does that represent yeah I I'll have to get clarification on that I'm not a traffic engineer this is so this hasn't come up at any of the other facilities that's why I don't have okay a good answer no problem it just you know when I we look at this and reading through some of our wording that you know the uh the development that negatively impact the sty neighborhood this is a piece of information that's very helpful to help show the community that we're doing the right thing by the community for for instance at a Romeo facility it's 124 bed facility and it exits onto
074Main Street or vanand um we put in a deceleration Lane and um It's a larger facility and there's been no issues or comments for left turns or right turns yeah I I don't doubt any of that I'm just looking at the data trying to make sense to the that that's all it's just a simple question about that that information that's all I I think the confusion is if they're saying there's 30 employees but yet there's only six right six left that's 14 but yet there's 30 employees that are going to be turning at Peak time going in and 30 going out so maybe 50 actually that total should be 60 right there should be some I don't know but yeah and that's something you we get take a look at I mean I think it's
075I if I may I think it's I think it's fair that there's information in the in the analysis that um that could use further explanation as to whether or not it accounts for employee traffic or whether or not this is strictly visitor traffic is on that nature and that that's something that could either can be prepared for review and final I mean if that's if that's a fair step for the commission to take I I will say that if from Gemini's perspective when we do these reviews if our COC is coming back with with concerns or recommendations and they implementing those and they have met the standards of the way that the sites are to be designed um there isn't necessarily an Avenue for us to I hate using this word but to deny this
076project because now if RCC was coming saying you have massive issues here massive problems then we are in a different Crossroad than where we are now however I do the it's fair based on what the plan commission is saying and what your report says and the discrepancies between the vehicles that further analysis or explanation from you guys at final is warranted to try to understand where where are these gaps do these gaps exist is there something that this did not account for or did it account for it and how right is that I mean is that fair commissioner it is I'm just wondering if we can make that a condition of um you know as the township consultant if that can be a condition yeah I mean I think that we can make like a
077a further analysis of of traffic generation would be part of a conditional approval that to clarify the information to provide yeah to come yeah when they come in final yes we can make that we can add that to the condition would that clarification then go back to the RO commission for further analysis once they have better numbers in front of them I think it would be fair to see what the clarification is and based on that if we warned whether or not R cooc should look at it again okay because I don't want to question the Integrity I'm not I'm not qualified to look at this and and stamp it with Y or nay neither is Jim but I think that if there's something in here where they say you know maybe if the numbers
078have changed based on looking at it this way then we would want R cooc to to see it if the numbers stay the same but there's further clarification as to why they're staying that way RC's already seen it does that kind of make sense yeah so our so the RC the rcoc and there they have a dated October 10th I don't know if that is or is not in your packet should be so they've G they've granted preliminary plan approval they haven't granted final approv right then yet they still have to go back and do all the you know the full engineering design and if as a condition of this preliminary site plan you say hey you got to update your traffic study or whatever report whatever they're calling it that would be submitted back
079to the road commission at the time of the final approval from that so they when you go to the road commission so that they don't spend hours basically are submitting more than just a concept plan you know but they kind of do a quick review of it and say yeah preliminarily we approve this thing just kind of like we're giving preliminary site plan and then all right finalize everything and then come back for final they're doing the same thing here so that information could be rovided to them so can I ask a couple five questions for you then um so once we get if we get better data about how much traffic comes in and out of this facility do you know Jim if if then the the rcoc looks at that and works on
080a plan to mitigate that separate from this development right because I'm not I'm not sitting here asking these questions to have the developer mitigate these issues but only to provide enough information for the county to understand what the traffic impact is going to be so that they can analyze it further and and make necessary improvements if that's what's required right is that what would happen yes okay yes and likewise if the road commission if they gave them updated data and the road commission said uhuh this isn't what you gave to us the first time and made to make additional improvements or said this isn't going to work then they're back here again for you know another preliminary site plant they have to move their entrance around to the other side or go through the Wetland
081or do something then they're back here again okay thank you yeah but moving the entrance wouldn't impact how many cars or no no it would I'm just I'm just giving it as an example right the road commission says no go on this then they're figuring something else out and they're coming back to you yeah but that I I would believe that it's the road commission that would flag if it's an issue um because there's I don't see any standards you know if if if the study that we had say there's 30 cars leaving in one hour 15 cars might be turning left 15 cars might be turning right I can't judge whether that's um acceptable or not acceptable yeah I understand I was just looking for clarification on the information iiss I don't know at
082what point are there too many cars turning left that I think would be the road commission's um venue to say you know yeah I I agree I'm just looking to see how we get that information in front of the road commission that's really what I'm yeah and that the road commission approval has to happen before the final site planine approval so okay very any other questions talk about dumpster um pickups your typical operations there dumpster pickup and uh dumpster pickup trash pickup and um deliveries on the uh on the uh the site plan shows that you have a couple of loading areas um can you can you describe to us um the typical operational hours for something like that I I don't off the top of my head know we have rules within the city
083that um require you know material not your had oh something else okay yeah I thought you had your the answer no my apologies keep going I I would just like for our neighbors that are close by you know large trucks trash trucks picking up at 5:00 a.m. obviously is not that would negatively impact the surrounding community and we don't want to do that so how do you operate um your typical facility to help prevent if you are close to a residential and other your other facilities um can you help us and I know you're the architect so as as I say these things um you're here to represent so um can you help us understand how that operates deles and trash out I do not honestly know when the trash pickups are scheduled at the
084other facilities um but our the other facilities most of them are much closer to the residential areas you know than this one is um okay so the the owner if if you want clarification for final site plan approval I can find out from the owner when they they will schedule the yeah I think it's important to have that so we have a clear image for a final site plan if it did go that far to ensure the community that again it's the the wording in our master plan and our documents special you talk about not negatively impacting the community mhm y and you're a trash pick up you know very across the street it's but that would be a negative impa yeah there are um two loading spots for the um the township requirements and
085that's basically just food service trucks uh for the kitchen you know for breakfast lunch and dinner they're at set times um you know from like 8 until um 6 that that Whole Food Service um system is over with so the shipments okay would happen during those hours okay and I think as far as the garbage truck I think we have some type of rules for hours of operation okay um but I do know that garbage trucks come through my neighborhood over on drainer at 6:30 in the morning they're they're coming through so right they mess up all the neighbors as long as it's getting picked up hey thank you okay yes I I didn't see any thing on your drawings that might represent a patio area where people that are I'm going to use the
086word stain but our patients Within your facility had a small area where they could go outside to enjoy the nice weather not the snowstorms but nice weather we have in the summertime have you given anything like that a consideration in in the um corer area see this area see that yeah probably the landscape plan yeah that's probably sorry this is this is there there you go yeah the area where we will have outdoor seating is this area right here cuz the dining room is right here and there are two doors there's a door here and a door here and that's what the sidewalk is showing but this is where the patio or Terrace would be is off the dining room in that enclosed Courtyard space okay thank you and all the other at the end
087of each Wing is an egress store those are only for emergency erass there is no one coming or going the exterior doesn't have handles on them um and and this this is the a secure quiet place right off the main dining area day room and din having had a family member that spent five years in a nursing facility it was it was very nice for them to be able to get outside a little bit with our help you know you go to visit when you took them outside to visit in the sunshine and stuff Y and so I didn't see anything that I recognized to be that yeah the patios are usually developed late in the game you know with different papers and SE I didn't want you to forget it h I just I
088just did not want you to forget that no and we at the um at the Clarkson facility there's a patio out the back with a fire pit and it's right by well what I call pinea but the DTE theater whatever so when there's a concert at the theater they're seating outside around a fire pit for the residents to go out and enjoy the concert for free thank you I think that's all I have any other questions okay what we will do is uh make a motion to open the public hearing we will then take public testimony uh and I've already kind of gone through the rules uh once that's completed we'll close a public hearing uh we'll get any further comments from the uh consultants and team review any correspondents that may have come in
089uh the Commissioners will discuss and eventually make a motion to approve or deny with that I will entertain a motion to open the public hearing okay motion to open the public hearing second okay we have a motion we have a second any discussion all in favor any opposed okay the public hearing is open at 7:48 again any members uh wishing to address uh will come up give your name your address and the position you'd like to discuss and you'll be given three minutes and all discussion is directed towards the chair so with that um hi my name is David Bas I live at 1884 Deer Path Trail I'm also a director for the lakes of Inwood subdivision Association on the board just had a few comments or questions for your consideration I'm not expecting you
090to address them here but one concern I have is that the entrance to this facility is very close close to Pathfinder looks to be about 150 to 200 ft there's quite a bit of traffic that goes out on Pathfinder every day there's three subdivisions that use that uh Pathfinder entrance you have wood Brier Lakes of indiewood subdivision and manou Hills so during 8:00 and 4:00 when the shift is going to change at the nursing facility they'll be competing traffic for the two driveways and being that close to each other I would foresee being some conflict or or perhaps safety issues second thing is there are a lot of people on bikes who leave on pathfind or cross over to the safety path I recognize it's not an official crossover but there is no safety path
091that goes down drainer on this side of the road to get you down to Pontiac to cross over and so with the two driveways people crossing on bikes again it could be a somewhat unsafe situation just depends on on the time of day uh last thing of course is that uh there's with additional people leaving this facility we have a lot of people who cut through use the paved roads through the subdivision of lakes of indiwood to get down to drainer uh or down to a Jaslin rather this would create a little bit more conflict I don't think you can do anything about it my main concern is just the safety of having the entrances too close to each other I'd request that in addition to some addition some screening for the lights that you
092are requesting along Pathfinder you also request some along iroy trail uh it's largely a meadow on this property there is there are trees um but the light will come to the South as well and we have some residents down there uh we' prefer some additional brick on the exterior of the building I think we've already asked about that if you could match the architecture on the facility that's over by PAB that would be great um and then just in in general comments that we've had from homeowners as they've learned about this has been favorable um in the neighborhood about having a nursing facility they were considering or expecting a subdivision um could very easily still be a subdivision in the future so I think people would prefer not clearcut we realize we don't control that
093but in general the facility looks pretty good then the last thing we request is please uh ask for no construction traffic to go through the neighborhoods just to use the main roads to get to the the area thank you thank you time the H back 109 ay um I guess I would just like to compound Dave's uh comment about the lighting the South lighting that would be great I take that into consideration um I there was one comment made about that the East was still developable developable even with the facility there I'm curious about this have let's see other than that uh when the rcoc when you have them looking at the uh the plan I think the the point about um 24 and drainer is is a big one that's all my name is
094Sam white I was I at 957 Maloney Avenue um my concern here is that when I was looking through the plan I saw that there was no hazardous materials expected to be on the site healthc care facilities generally almost always generate Biohazard Waste which US Department of Transportation has tagged as hazardous material and I was wondering what type of environment impact it would have and packaging and moving that material I'm quite sure would be Onre and that is my question tonight that I would like to know the environmental impact in how they propos to dispose of the hazardous materials that they will generate whether it's just from batteries Mercury bandages needles Sharps all that stuff thank you anyone else okay seeing none uh we'll take a motion to close the public hearing motion to close
095public hearing I'll second we have a motion uh second uh any discussion all in favor Mr ch a couple things I wanted to talk about okay if if there is um you know as I look at some of the conditions that we've been discussing um does it have to do with the motion your comments have to do with the motion he's just closing public hearing yeah this is just to close the public hearing I thought it was comments for amongst the commission no not yet no this is just any the discussion to close public hearing no no no thank you for the clarification all in favor I any opposed okay public hearing is closed at 7:54 um now we will take some more comments or information from the township Consultants um so if you have
096any further questions we'll bring the experts back up we we just you know talking about um some of the conditions that could be placed on this yeah um I just want to make sure we clarify this um we would add this traffic clarification well let me do this cuz I taking notes and so let me read kind of the way I've crafted some of these potential conditions and then we'll kind of get a yeah that's what we're talking about or let's tweak it this way and then we'll get a consensus that that condition is something the board feels is appropriate so the first one I had is that an additional condition would be clarification on whether or not the traffic analysis accounts for employee uh departure and arrivals during shift change that's say I got
097it right that's just kind of the note that I've taken the board I just want to add to that um about I think that was me I'm not sure does that need to be resubmitted to the road commissioner open cting here's here's what I would say if if for some reason we you know there is a there is a in that clarification changes the numbers then it would definitely go back to rco I make sure that happens right doesn't there's not a gap there point however if the if we find that the what they Prov to you does does provide for those things and they can provide clarification as to how it provides for those things our COC wouldn't see those numbers again because I think the numbers is what our cc is looking at
098yeah okay so is the way I crafted it appropriate though where think I think so yeah I just want to make sure that it doesn't get lost from home yeah very important detail to the community no no no I agree and this is as it relates to employees coming and going and shift change that's the way I've I've crafted we good on the way that one works okay thank you yeah uh the next one I have is um information on trash pickup and delivery times of day is that a a is it a condition we want to put on B is I have I worded it correctly is the condition that we want to put on I guess I would ask is there an ordinance already enforcing I am not familiar with one in zoning
099but that but it's not always going to be there sometimes it's in your general ordinances and my apologies I cannot speak to whether or not it is um so I I cannot speak to that I mean essentially we're asking for the information they'll provide it at that point in time I will then I can look into the general ordinance to see if it complies um and at the very least it's available for you at final if there's any kind of major concerns with it I think it's worth asking a question okay okay um uh another condition that I put on there because they have alluded to it and I think it's an improvement to the property but we want to see on the site plan is that they they show all outdoor amenities on the
100final site plan good and then a last but now here somewhere um no those yeah those are the three that I have from comments that I've heard from the commission are there any this is only my second week doing this so I might have to I'll ask the chair the questions from the public comment are we allowed to address those um to them about concerns that I have too that they have you you can address them with Matteo yeah that's what I'm saying yeah that's what I'm saying so obviously one thing that I would really like is no tra going through obviously ending would um maybe having a sign put up that they maybe a road closed for through traffic for construction um I want to make sure I understand because I heard this come
101up before and if I'm if I a missing something you tell me I don't I don't see where construction traffic or the site design allows any kind of through traffic cut through no but with construction and and they're going to be using Pathfinder with their construction if we could just have the construction guys stay off Pathfinder because ultimately it's going to take you know the road's going to be damaged it's going to have to be cleaned it's going to have to be all that so who's going to be cleaning it and all that vice versa so I again I think it's a I think it's a a concern that's fair to put out there and I think it's fair for them to hear it's not anything I have control over through the ordinance but I
102do know because there's preconstruction meetings I might want to question that if it does get dirty due to construction are they going to bring sweeper trucks in there to clean it for the residents of the community Jim I probably part of the soil erosion permit we see dirty roads then we'll enforce that and we'll get on them and it's just excuse me so I know they have that but sometimes it's just not enforced properly so I wanted to make sure that was enforced and then also to with the questions for the lighting uh I know I know that they do in these uh these communities they have light screens that they put on so it's not as bright for the community so maybe uh maybe you can take that back to maybe have a light
103screen put on the lights so the light screens oh yeah you know yeah for final sight plan approval full photo metrics are required and we will have that yeah because I know that was a concern with the the committee here and so obviously we heard it twice now so I just wanted a little bit more verification obviously that you guys are looking into that I know they're going to have to approve it and stuff like that but that's a valid concern from everybody so I think that's a good one let me just so that we can process this yeah what I would say is they they've L heard lighting they'll put their plane together we'll run it through our ringer we bring it to final and if there's a few additional things here and there
104that you want to see out of it that they're agreeable to we can make those conditions at final just so we understand and that's it no okay um okay yeah so I had my three conditions that I crafted I don't think I heard another condition we address some concerns yeah um couple things um I know with like the the question about road construction I mean obviously we can bring that up during the pre-construction meetings and the the general contractor can really stress that their guys use it I don't know with Pathfinder being a county maintained road that we can say no commercial trucks through there I mean it's County Road technically they can but we can really stress to them to keep them on drainer and then to uh just this driveway yeah not in
105my apologies I'm not I'm not vers enough to give you assurances either way what can and cannot be required um obviously they've heard it B said we have some mechanisms in place through the building department to ensure certain things are happening a certain way but doly noted right and and as far as the lights I mean yes I I definitely want to you know make sure we have all those I did drive through there I went all the way down Pathfinder iry drove around I think there's enough mature trees that don't think it's going to be an issue but yeah I would like to see those measures put in place yeah well we'll we'll give them the uh to F CH call when the wedding plan comes through I had a question not to put
106a make a condition of any kind but more of a clarification about the hazardous material um can do you have an idea the note on the documents talked about that um no hazardous materials and I don't know the definition clearly am I had of you know biohazards versus hazardous material and um and how that's addressed right can you provide some clarification there I can't other than the notes that they provided if the the applicant wants to speak to it at all you can I'm not sure if you're able to speak to hazardous material transporter on site the only thing the only thing that I can think of would be possibly oxygen tanks even though they have fewer of those because of the concentrators that are available now but there is uh room for the oxygen
107tanks um but um other than that I don't know of any hazardous other hazardous materials that would be B fluids would that be considered no but I think I think blood if there I looked it up it's used like dressings bandages wounded contaminated personal protection like PPE um sharp needles body fluid soaps materials those are all biows considered that's what they say but I can have the owners provide the um their protocols to handle all that at the other facilities be perfect yeah that'd be good I mean we can it's a claric we can piggyback that with the other garbage pickup question to also yeah I think we I think we can craft a condition that that accounts for additional information thank you on the garbage pickup do you have hours that you would prefer
108or or that would be allowed so let I can tell the owners let's let me look to see standard already and we'll go from there okay if that's yeah no that's good all right thank is it okay the construction um uh comments we have um can we go back to the which one page two the one with the aerial photograph C2 no uh page two and the set talk just it's just going to take a second um yes the next one yeah here we go okay on the site the original intent was the whole area here along Pathfinder and iroy that whole L-shaped area is going to be left undisturbed untouched uh and so what we set was we set a Development Area outline which includes the entire area that there is regrading going to
109be done where construction is going to be done and so we set this line here and uh in in talks with the Douglas company the general contractor they felt that they could handle all of the construction work coming up this entrance and being stayed in this area during construction at the first submitt that we had we were taking all utilities off of drainer Road uh directly into the buildings water sewer and everything after some initial comments uh from the engineer um we rerouted all of the water and sewer now is coming off of Pathfinder in iroy so what we've done is we've shown what I'll call an easement just a a defined area that will have to be used to trench the hole for the drains and everything so these areas here also will be
110disturbed during construction but just to put the utilities in um but the rest of this area should not have any construction activities going on at all the intent is to keep keep that in its natural state and talking about the mature trees on site um this area here this has a stand of mature trees right here originally we had like a double lane parking lot in this area but the landscape architect identified this stand of trees should remain we moved the extra parking spaces over to this area along the back road so that this stand of trees could stay and one of um the engineer's questions was about how some of the pipes were um angled across um we have water and sewer lines coming out of the building here we've angled them across here
111to go straight down so that we could maintain that stand of mature trees so that answers one of the questions that the engineer had so um and and what we've done was we've calculated the number of trees required for the full um um Frontage on Pathfinder the required new trees and we've placed them along this Development Area so and a few extras and so the the actual buffer is going to be denser around the developed area so the number of trees that the the ordinance requires for this whole length from here to here will be planted in this area so it will be a denser buffer and as well as the iroy the number of trees required along this property line will be planted in this area here and plus we have the existing mature
112trees so we've we've um which technically I think we could get some credit for the existing trees but we're we're adding the number of trees required for the full Frontage to be condensed in planted here providing additional buffer and the on the West Side here um there was a question about um the trees along here we asked added some additional trees buffering here and there is enough room for the additional trees between the road and the property line there's a sale that goes down there and the evergreen trees will be planted on the actually the West slope going up to where the existing um the existing trees that are there oops the the buffer trees will be planted on the west slope from halfway up to the top um creating a denser buffer from the
113adjacent property towards the the new facility um and someone earlier had a question about the fire trucks turning radius and stuff um we um talked with the fire chief a couple times and he actually gave us the model of their largest ladder truck and their largest pumper truck we've used that information for the Ching Rus on that one sheet where we had the um the circulation pattern shown and um the the Fire Marshall is is um fine with that they they had some other comments about Knox block KNX loot boxes and and things but um the circulation meets that requirements for the exact vehicles that they have thank you um so as it I think as it relates to us finishing up to conditions I think the other one that we talked about that we
114would add is information on the handling of hazardous materials that for condition materials byways you might get yeah don't want to get box on biow waste and hazardous materials okay so with that I got I got four additionals that we just went through when the time comes to make a motion if if the Planning Commission does conditional approval um we'll have we'll work with you guys on reading through through uh what Susan has prepared for motions and stop you at the right moment give you the conditions to read let you finish go on from there okay any other questions anymore um I know the one other discussion was the uh inl of payment for the sidewalk that yeah touch on you guys will need to make a determination tonight as to whether or not you
115are recommending um the payment in lie of the placement of sidewalks of safety pass on Pathfinder inter quy and the safety path committee did recommend is that correct to B okay right okay so we will move on to number seven commissioner discussion any questions concerns topics you want brought up any more further questions good good good any question okay and and just to clarify um I'm sure everybody knows but the the in LW payment was to not have to put it's not on there along along Pathfinder and iroy to put a a sidewalk uh down there safety path down there um that basically would be going nowhere um and basically what it would entail is clear cutting the section just to put in a sidewalk um which I know we've talked several times about you
116know the inl of but in this case um I know I was on the safety path and I was in favor of it so um you know if that's something you guys want to discuss or bring up or any questions no I think it's a good good idea there are no there are no sidewalks or safety paths within the whole indianwood development you know what it's going to do is it's just going to draw people there and we don't want them to to go there and then have it end so I think it's yeah agre well that and down the road when this does get developed it's just going to be torn out so it's that is an important point though is that you are your payment in L applies to this development if those
117other portions of the site came the development down the road they need to show the sidewalk and safety path and if at that time payment L is still an option they could request another waiver at that time but this is not waving a future development's right to do it as well correct that is just for this development okay well if that's all the disc question then number eight um I'll entertain a motion um it appears to be very lengthy and we're going to want to stop after number five to include if you items if you go through your yeah so if what I want to do is the motion relating to wellbridge is going to be all of this so when it says facilities in the R2 District conditioned upon the applicant addressing any deficiencies
118loaded by Township Consultants the Township Fire Department and Township administrator in addition to and then that's where in addition to I'm sorry I'm sorry and Township administrator okay and then after administrator would be in addition to in addition to and when you get to that I will read back to you what I wrote so you can repeat it okay and then after all we get through all those lists then you can say prior to submitt for final site plan approval does that sound okay Susan M okay now we just get to see who wants to read this lengthy motion all right with that I will entertain a motion uh one way or the other all right I'll go for it so I move to approve the special land use for for wellbridge of Oxford located
119on drainer road PC 24-4 as required for a skilled nursing home and rehabilitation facility in the R2 District based on the following findings of fact as required by the Charter Township of Oxford Oxford's zoning ordinance number one the proposed use is comp able with adjacent uses in terms of location size and character and will not negatively impact the surrounding neighborhood number two it is consistent with the intent and purpose of the township zoning ordinance and master plan and will enhance the immediate vicinity in the township as a whole number three adequate measures are proposed to protect the natural environment and the use will not not Place unreasonable demands on public services or create excessive public costs number four the use is designed to ensure public health safety and Welfare with no adverse impacts on traffic
120or infastructure number five in compliance with the special land use standards in the zoning ordinance the facility will have vehicle Ingress and egress directly into the county PR primary Road provide a minimum of 3,000 square ft of land per person cared for and all buildings will be set back at least 75 ft from property lines keep going y additionally I move to approve the preliminary site plan for the skilled nursing home and rehabilitation facility in the R2 District conditioned upon the applicant addressing any deficiency is noted by the township Consultants the Township Fire Department and the township administrator sir stop there in addition to clarification on whether traffic analys analysis accounts for employee departure and arrivals during shift change you want me to shorten that up a little bit all right you give already if
121you could read my handwriting um all right so in addition to clarification on WEA traffic analysis in addition to clarification clarifications on weather traffic analysis and WEA traffic analysis accounts for employee accounts for employee departure and arrivals departures and arrivals during shift change you're shift change information on the information on the handling and Disposal and disposal of information on the handling and disposal of by a was Andor hazardous materials hazardous materials information on deliveries and trash pickup times of day information on trash deliveries and pickup in times of day trash pickup and deliveries times of day times of day and to show all outdoor amenities on Final site plan and to show all outdoor amenities from the final site plan and now you can pick back up at prior and then prior to sub the
122final site plan approval good job nice I'll second it you got to read it when you say all over again so we have a motion we have a second uh any discussion yeah no all right can we get a roll call vote sure Austin yes dur yes Turner yes blankin ship yes Wagner yes blik yes Bailey yes okay motion pass motion carries um and then the next topic is whether or not we want to do the inl of payment uh for the safety path so somebody would like to make a motion one way or the other all right I'll keep going so I Mo to recommend approval of the applicant's request to pay a sum in lie of constructing the required safety path along Pathfinder road and erise road DC 24-4 subject to the following
123conditions number one the in payment shall be calculated as a sum equivalent to the actual cost of construction constructing the safety path including permit engineering and inspection fees in accordance with Section 42-15 B of the of the township safety path ordinance number two a condition shall be imposed requiring that any future development of parcels fronting Pathfinder Road and iroise Road whether by the the current developer or future developers must include the construction of the safety path at that time number three this condition shall be formalized in an agreement approved by the Township Board of Trustees to ensure compliance with these requirements a second okay we have a motion we have a second any any discussion on this seeing none can we have a roll call vote Lo yes Wagner yes linol ship yes Austin yes
124dur yes Turner yes Bailey yes motion passed thank you very much now we will move to number 11 ordinance Review Committee 2025 work plan good evening uh so tonight in your packet is the orc review uh the orc the ordinance review committee's 2025 work plan so the ordinance Review Committee is a subcommittee the Planning Commission that will meet once a month and kind of goes over any ordinance um typically text amendments sometimes a map Amendment and works with the planning Consultants the engineers the legal team to draft changes to those either as an internal reaction to something that needs to change or an external response to a petition by a resident or a business um or just something that we're aware of kind of an easy example is if we keep getting zoning board of
125appeals requests for the placement of a debt because the way our ordinance is r isn't clear we would want to bring that through the orc and up to you guys uh so what you have in front of you tonight is kind of the proposed work plan for the orc for the 2025 year and it highlights High priorities medium priorities and low priorities and I guess I would pra up if I got to it here um and so the process tonight is is that the Planning Commission would make a recommendation to the Township Board to approve uh the plan proposed by the orc um after tonight the plan commission does agree with the work plan we will develop a budget for the Township Board to review and consider uh and when the township that would go
126to the Township Board in March and assuming that they approve it then we can get to work on some of the items highlighted the plan uh one thing that you will notice is that the when I get to it the um the high priorities list is a little thin and that's only because some of the priorities that are listed in medium or in other parts of the plan are somewhat not reliant on the current master plan draft but are heavily influenced by it um it's just a better justification for the orc to bring something up after that Master plan's been adopted as opposed to when it's in draft form your current master plan is the best master plan to reference so the reason those things have gotten kind of Knocked Down the medium is we
127want to get the master plan adopted and then once the master plan's adopted the Asters at the top kind of allows us to make modifications to that work plan um as needed um so with that while I'm bringing it up um I'm happy to answer any questions the first one you get computer is not cooperating with this 40 m file I'm almost there but but go on with the question while the question was just clarification of the wording um of the first item in the high priority list um there's some in the notes section yeah I'm just going to go my files I got to I got to make sure now the Bad Emails I read about Jim come up you read or that you wrote yeah get ready to send them still okay so
128my POS but here it is I'm sorry commissioner your question yeah the first one um General requirements for private road section and then the notes talks about current circumstances L lack configurations would prohibit the issuance of a building permit which could be interpreted as a taking can you help you understand them yeah so this is this is really a reaction to um outdated land division practices so in the township we have we do have Parcels that don't have sufficient access to roadways uh we have Parcels that the way that they're sized or the way that they they do access the road isn't compliant and so in the past when people have come in to do building permits on these sites technically they don't meet the standards anymore we can't allow them to build that gets
129into some gray area with taking as far as like illegal you are taking the value of this land from somebody because they can't get a build now because of a a lot that was approved back when but isn't to meets today's standards um we have at least in the year and a half I've been up here we've had two instances where this has come up it hasn't gotten legal but it has been a challenge for the property order to try to figure out what to do with the property um so this is on there to kind of work with the legal council in the in the township to correct this thank you 20 years ago I went through experiencing this situation with a piece of property was on a natural beauty road but it did
130not have electricity and the ability to get electricity onto the property was greatly restricted we finally did it but it took and one thing so everybody understands the process the way that the the work plan is structured is allows us to internally track where it is in the process is it being drafted who's looking at it you know once it's ready for review it would be brought to the public it would be brought to the Planning Commission during a public Hearing in fact you'll have some next month if you guys recommend it then it goes to the Township Board Township Board votes to read it and then has one reading and then two readings so at its quickest once it gets to you guys it's still three to four months from adoption just so you
131understand kind of just it's not like that this form will also be the reporting format that we will pass on to the Township toship Board they can see what things that at and we need to make a motion to approve this tonight so that it can go before the township for Budget if I'm correct yeah it would I whether it's an approval or recommendation I think either is appropriate just so the Township Board knows that the plan commission supports this plan has presented and like I said my firm will put together a budget for the township to approve or deny by they agree with our numbers but it's never been an issue in the past but yeah that's what we'll do for the March Township board meeting okay and there's another another thing we need
132to is there another thing we need to approve or look at for tonight is it for me okay okay okay so motion to recommend uh to the Township Board the Oxford Township ordinance Review Committee 20125 for plan second okay we have a motion we have a second any discussion all in favor I any opposed there's your recommendation thank you very much thank you thank you um all right number 12 communication committee reports um ordinance Review Committee I mean if we no you're fine you're fine yep we met today um went over some just loose ense from last year like I said you guys will see some Anal definition and state regulated uses language in front of you next month at a public hearing um uh most of what you're going to see next month is
133formality uh that not highly controversial it's just clarification on some stuff and from time to time the state amends laws that mean you need to amend your laws and it's pretty much a copy paste of what the state told you to do so but you still got to go through the process of approval but that's what you'll see next month planer and Engineering reports I'm done come on you getting up getting down getting up this is more just for the new planning Commissioners um we provide a report this was initially started for the Township board but we decided to include it in the Planning Commission um packets as well so these are not everything that we're working on but these are just I would call them the major projects that we're working on within the
134community from an engineering perspective um generally one page of it is Municipal projects which has to do with water projects sewer projects roadway projects safety path projects and then on the second page are more of the private development things that you guys have uh generally approved or are in the process just kind of keep you up to date so on this particular one we have McLaren Sanctuary Hills which is a residential development down draer Road um tmore which is another one a lot of these are in the holding pattern right now but they have submitted for a site plan or some type of uh application to this committee here um or this commission so again just an update more for the newer members there and this is usually in your packet with every meeting if
135you ever have any questions feel free to give me a call for email me thank you for this CH thank you thank you thank you okay if that's anybody else has anything else before we make a motion to adjourn motion toj second second all in favor we are adjourned thank you