CorpusRecord 203179

Oxford Community Schools Board of Education Regular Meeting: February 11th, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Oxford Community Television
Date
2025-02-13
Location
Oakland County, MI
Material
Transcript
Extent
25,571 words · about 143 min
Collected
2026-06-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening everybody and welcome to the February 11th 2025 school board meeting if you could please rise for the pledge Alle to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with Li and justice for all thank you James could you take a 10 minut yep president Gana here uh vice president pres aldd here secretary Summers here treasury Whitney here uh trusty Gibson here trusty aeson here trusty korney here C campor ca joury ca Journey it's a think of it is a j instead of a g all right thanks okay all present thank you any changes to the board agenda all right well let's kick it off with our OVA presentation we we have Janet Jordan and Marie so good evening Board of AD

002we're so glad to present to you a new board and lots of things for OA to share so we're glad to be able to um present overa tonight and explain some of our wonderful programming and all the great things happening at our school so we here's our overview we want to begin with who we serve uh we want to touch on our Oxford virtual Solutions which is our shared time and Consortium program we have our points of Pride and that overview we're going to focus on some great Elementary and secondary data and areas of improvement and our Focus there we have um our school quality survey to address we want to talk a little bit about that we want to share a few over in pictures and then looking forward um so sorry about that

003we serve approximately 8,600 students um as you can see up there I I list them out there's part-time full-time our osc program is full-time we serve 600 seated students in the district so that's under the 21f law 12 tuition students as of fall and 5100 sharetime students not in this number is our Consortium schools though that is um Portland High School where we are their course provider so that's about 235 so that's how we came up with the 8600 students so our teachers in Oxford deliver content instructional support and curriculum to all of these students and all these different Pathways we're a school and a course provider um OA enrolled over 800 students between April and September for the 2 for 25 school year so this spring and summer we were pretty busy in the

004middle of a move but we did it um but there have been questions we are in our third year of additional targeted support um that is a designation that came up um for three reasons one kind of tipped us over um but I just really want to just read so I get it accurate um we were identified by the mde for needing additional targeted support with our students with disabil in three areas one was attendance so these are students with disabilities right low State Testing participation and low test performance on state assessments from the 21 2122 school year so um just thinking about that time frame um the progress we've made has been really good um successfully improved attendance documentation systems and that was our Achilles heels that we learned how to capture when our

005special education teachers were working with their students because that counted for attendance and we hadn't documented that even though we did it um we increased test participation through enhanced family communication um some of our families were getting ready to come back in person and test a lot of them we struggling to do so um we have ongoing work to boost student performance using evidence-based interventions so the current status is that while this is a six-year designation we are approaching our third-year revieww promising data for potential early exit from from this designation this program is likely so we're we're hopeful so we will we'll keep you posted on that um so on the flip side OA is named as a top five online public high school in the state according to Niche OA is named to

006top 20% middle schools um in the state according to its news and World Report so exciting news um I'd like to touch and lift up Oxford virtual Solutions um this is our Shar time program we have a team um that are just so dedicated you can see them at their booth there um our leaders are a couple of them are here tonight Don and um and Lisa they um really have um developed this program over the years um Christy used to be the director and now is our communication director but handed off quite a program we have 32 non-public partner schools approximately like I said 5,100 students 998 FTE in 2024 um approximately 8,700 course enrollments um our Consortium which also falls under Oxford V virtual Solutions um we Service Portland High School Portland reached

007out um will Heath the superintendent over there is in our um Co-op friendly with him he really liked our product and our reputation he said hey we're moving from um like a six scheduled day to four blacks and a skinny would oxer be interested in delivering the elective class to all of their high school so that's kind of how that started so we have over 235 course on Consortium enrollments this year with Portland um like I said they're the course provider we are and they are all taught by Axford teachers so um what we are able to provide is you know the curriculum and the teaching and the instruction all developed by teachers who have been through axford's uh professional development and um their master online teachers um we often get questions about Finance Oxford

008sharetime Services um is their operating model uh we staff the non-core courses for private and parochial schools we can include the kids in our state a FTE and an incentive is the excess revenue generated um over prog program costs oa's operating model is similar to Shared time model except for that we can offer both core and non-core electives that's the difference so um points of Pride we are um experiencing continu to experience growth and increasing Community engagement um we're super proud of our school Improvement and the collaboration with OIC campus so my other schools that fall under my leadership uh Bridges and Crossroads we're starting to come together as the alternative wing and Innovative wing of the district and align practice practices and professional development data mining things like that and working together often you're

009in a silo as principles and the alternative schools so now we're beginning to share more and that collaboration is really enhancing our work and we believe in the long run will enhanced student achievement um we're super excited as I've said a few times about our new facility um and I believe that um through that and our staff wellness program we're seeing some gains there um so I am going to introduce Dr Dennis he's our elementary um assistant principal and he's going to take over the elementary portion and then Mrs Murphy will take over the secondary thank you Janet friends and colleagues of the board um so I am going to briefly talk about uh the elementary program at Oxford Virgil Academy um at fall count we had roughly 700 full-time elementary students which makes us

010the largest Elementary School in the district uh so part of our uh myip plan our continuous Improvement plan uh we are using local and state data to drive instructional strategies and resource allocation we are a school that has around 10 programs uh scattered throughout Southeast Michigan and so we need to operate as a district we have a finite amount of teachers a finite amount of PA professionals so where are we sending staff and Pa professionals to have the most amount of impact on the most amount of kids what curriculum are we investing in what uh interventions are we investing in to make sure that we are using our resources wisely and that it is in alignment with our local and state data um we in that continuous Improvement plan we have identified math and the

011need for math interventions as something that we're going to continuously work on and I'll talk about that in a bit uh we are exploring new writing curriculums this year uh teaching writing is hard um it is also hard um so looking looking at some of our current writing curricular offerings how easy is it for a parent to take that writing curriculum and help facilitate that learning to their child at home how easy is it for a student to do that fully online in a blended format so we are taking a good look at writing curricular offerings just to make sure that we are doing our DU due diligence on that front uh we are empowering teachers through plc's uh this year it's we've done some grade level uh groupings in the past this year we're

012taking uh teacher interests and passions and um areas of focus and we are grouping teachers up that way and that's been a it's been a pleasure to sit in and watch that happen uh phonics and reading comprehension professional development we were able to receive some funding uh through a 35j grant uh which allowed us to implement secret stories professional development in notice and note um I'll talk a little bit about phonics instruction and reading comprehension and how that affects our different grade levels um in the next slide as well and then our seal our um you know our whole child uh continuous Improvement plan how are we facilitating uh online students to interact with each other form connections form a community something that we always worry about uh or and that we always think about

013is social isolation we want to make sure that children in our program are not feeling isolated from peers uh academics and that side of education is great it is one component of of a school education so how are we facilitating connection friendship um how is your child given the opportunity to be a leader a communicator a team player um and we'll talk about that in the local community vendors so uh oxu Virtual Academy is an alternative school it is a school of choice and it is a school that you have to pick I believe no there we go um we serve a 60% at risk uh population so whether that be um homelessness special education elll past failures um low socioeconomic status free reduced lunch that type of those are the different qualifiers uh and

014we have over 60 60% of our students fall into one of those buckets uh compared to 15% of our students are identified as an individual for an individual reading Improvement plan and IRB so we for the population that we serve uh we do a good job making sure that we are identifying those students giving them the resources that they need anding intervention uh to ensure that they are um performing adequately compared to peers who are uh not identified as at risk uh from the 2023 2024 end of uh year irps if we we have we have a fantastic data specialist um and we had him pull data throughout the years students who stay within our program as the years progress they are less likely to have an individual uh reading inter Improvement plan uh students

015who uh begin the year with us even if they only stay with with us for a year students who begin the year with us compared to students who end the year with us are are also likely to have an individual reading Improvement plan so um we take in a lot of new students as uh Mrs shelle uh said and so what are we doing within our school year and within our programs to address those needs we track student data by geographic location um to make sure that are also using that information when we think about the needs of students uh we have programs that are adjacent to Flint we have programs that are in Detroit the needs of those students are going to be very different than the needs of the students that areed in

016Chester or Farmington Hills is this cutting out a little okay this second year implementing Delta math and mobimax is a systemwide elementary math Intervention Program a little bit more about that and then also understand yes you know I would I would love going but it's it's very disor my colleague Marie Murphy is very happy that this is happening to me instead of her I can tell little so uh we understand uh that as an alternative R um we have students who come to us uh and they make it very clear when they arrive that hey this is a oneyear thing my child has experienced some s social situation in the past studing my child has a medical condition we are getting we're getting life sorted out we have a lot of families who come to

017us and let us know that we are a transitional setting we are a transitional solution for the family for the child um and so we we have um put a lot of effort and a lot of thought into that this year um and how we approach students who are using us as a transitional educational setting so meeting with the families understanding the background understanding the context um what was the situation that Grove you to come to us what is your future plans and how can we make sure that your time with us limited though it may be is the best that it can possibly be to make sure that your child is still getting educated as you transitional as you transition through this life event um hopefully uh it it we take in quite a

018few students the district from local communities um again hoping hoping to see some sort of temporary solution for whatever uh situation that day may find themselves um our Ela mstep uh grades 3 through five for the elementary program we test slightly above the district average for third and fifth grade our fourth grade cohort last year um they uh tested lower than the district average um on par with other online schools uh with a similar demographic uh but however that state data does not correlate with our local data um we were made apparent that we did have uh some groups of fourth graders last year who finished their ELA unep test in 12 minutes uh which is unfortunately probably not indicative of their skill level we do take the endstep very seriously so it is something

019that we are hoping to address more this year as we prep and as we talk to students about taking safe assessments um and what the implications are for them and for our school um but we will uh get those results in and hopefully we'll we'll see if we can Rectify that c but third uh third and fifth grade last year again did very well um we see a trend every year our first graders are coming into first grade not prepared to read at a first grade level so 77% of our first graders came in to the school year this year reading below Benchmark the vast majority of our first graders are new enrollments um however again so we have to spend the first first half of every year really targeting those first graders um again

020the the students who stay with us uh you'll see a downward trajectory of being identified as being below Benchmark however you know this is uh something that through first and second grade we we Implement a lot of reading interventions and by the time our students get to third grade we do see a a greatly reduced amount uh fourth and fifth grade are even less though uh but we do see you know that that's where that early fonic comes in that's why we've invested time and teacher development into early bonics our first graders are showing that is their biggest area of weakness um and that is our biggest area Focus for first and second grade for uh math uh math we test pretty well uh grades 1 two and three for math uh grades four and

021five this is where the MF does corate with our local data we are seeing that students are coming into fourth and fifth grade and they leaving fourth and fifth grade uh with with deficits and ma uh that we have focused a lot of time and energy and school resources in addressing um while it's on par with other online schools we want to hold ourselves about that um and make sure that we're doing comparable to the seed schools in the district as much as we can um but what we're seeing is our fourth and fifth graders again they're coming into fourth grade they're not ready for fourth grade math when they when they enter in fourth grade same with fifth grade they're entering into fifth grade with uh whole PS in their skill sets and deficits

022and so we have to spend the first half of our year just getting them ready so what what are those um missing skill sets how are you like are they able to do three-digit addition are they able to do subtraction you know um well before they start getting into division it it's a it's something that you'll see Across the Nation grades four five and six um but it's something that we have noticed more more over the past couple years we've invested a lot of time and energy into Delta math interventions making sure that those kids are getting at least two two days of math intervention each week um as we continue to see kids coming into fourth fifth grade Upper Elementary just missing skill sets uh Missing skills to be successful in fourth and fifth

023grade B and then we have our elementary students in the hybrid program on the left we have a student at Oxford hybrid uh locally here at Lake Point Church uh doing reading intervention we have kiddos in the middle doing a science experiment at Lexy hybrid in Rochester and then we have Mrs emenheiser in her kindergarten class down in Farmington Hills so again even though we are Oxford Virtual Academy the vast majority of our elementary students are in person with peers two to three days a week uh it's a it's a point of Pride it's why we do so well it's why our students have friendships and peer connections and we have such a good relationship with communities uh we have D Detroit African Youth Development organization they operate out of a uh religious uh Center

024down in Detroit they they serve uh mostly first and second generation immigrant students uh they are a fantastic group to work with um down on the bottom right they had they took a recent field trip down to the Department of Natural Resources in Detroit um up in the top right Mr wbor who was the elementary teacher of the year for Oxford Community Schools uh goes down to meet with them to work with them it's a fantastic Community they really embraced the partnership with us uh and they really embraced having our teachers go and work with their students on site and then classes in our local community Freedom kitchen one of our more popular local electives uh again students who are learning healthy cooking uh Art Studio 86 who um again opportunities for students to do

025Hands-On art uh with peers and then Shenanigans Farm uh another one of our popular uh Partnerships in the local community students are able to learn about uh working on a farm learn about horses learn a horse back ride again Hands-On fun electives that students look forward to while partnering with local community businesses who may have uh times where they're not very busy during the school day so how can we partner with them uh lean on their expertise as a community member and how can they benefit from partnering with us local school district and then we have M Murphy thank you um so I'm Marie Murphy I started oh than thank you just have that stand by um I have been working at OVA now for the last six months I have been in Oxford now

026for five and a half years so I started at the middle school specializing in special education and served as their teacher consultant and being at NOA these last six months has been amazing I honestly didn't realize um this Hidden Gem within our district and how much we offer our students um this Continuum of services and opportunities that we offer families oh I think I may need that other microphone um so really looking at that Continuum that we offer our families and our students um who maybe that Traditional School setting is not the best setting so it's it's finding those different options thank you so looking at looking at the last six months um and some of the things that I really wanted to focus on coming in uh we are looking screening system so our

027it's called an early warning system for our students so looking at what are the academic and non-academic factors that we take into account when looking at our students and the interventions that they need uh our professional development is really housed around improving our courses and our Conta content and that engagement within our online classes so meaningful feedback is one of the biggest um pieces that we're working on in our professional development time with teachers on Friday mornings really talking about what meaningful feedback looks like that's the connections that we're building with our students and then looking at that action oriented feedback what are the students taking from that and how are they improving their work within the courses so that's been a core Focus within our um professional development with our teachers and practice this

028year the second layer of our professional development has been Universal Design for Learning so this is um this hold wear and dear to my heart because it really does create courses that will be accessible for all students so coming from special education seeing where we need students that have uh we students need different ways to show how they Master the content or apply the skills that Universal Design for Learning really offers that approach for our students for that those courses to be accessible to all different types of Learners whether they struggle or whether they're Advanced for need more enrichement um engagement strategies this kind of Falls in two Realms the engagement strategies is we can look at the mtss approach so looking at our students who may not be engaged or they may be struggling

029to keep up in their courses so really looking at how we are reaching out building these success plans for them really taking the team of teachers and the mentor teacher and creating this um a team of people just to lift this child up so they stay engaged within their courses the other side of it is looking at our courses themselves and looking at what we're doing within the curriculum and increasing those engagement strategies within the curriculum um improving intervention processes is a big project I kind of talked about that with the early warning system I'll talk about that on a later slide in a little bit more depth and then our plc's are working hard to not only reinforce and model the work that we're doing with professional developments and helping lead their teams and

030departments but we're also looking at work into the future for next year and how we're going to to improve our practices for next year and what's great about all of this is it overlaps with our school Improvement plan so it's not as if our school Improvement plan is separate from the work that we do it encompasses all of the great things and the and the improvements that we want to make um so looking at the dat over the next few slides you're going to see our Middle School data and our high school data um one thing I want to point out with middle school is the um the majority of our middle school students are in hybrid sites they get more of that in-person experience on site a couple days a week whereas our high

031school students we see a higher percentage that are in a fully online program so when we look at the number of students testing and the performance there's just some different factors to take into place not only with the type of instruction that they receive but also just looking at the demographics of where they're located like Jordan has spoke to we have schools in Farmington Hills Detroit Rochester Dearborn so taking all of those into account um when we look at our endep math scores for sixth and seventh grade I like to have the comparison of the Michigan Connections Academy if they have comparable numbers to our middle school students and then I like to really point out and highlight that well we want to improve our math scores we are staying above their threshold so we're

032looking at that 23% and they're sitting at that 177% 6th grade and then um we're at 35% in the seventh grade and then 39% in e8th grade um language arts I really want to point out the pride in language arts especially when we get into our High School courses we've really been inre in those scores um for our Oxford design courses which I'll speak to a little bit more on another slide but um looking at our numbers in comparison to the Michigan Connections Academy um really wanting to look at that sixth grade but if we look at seventh and eighth grade we are staying above those thresholds when when we are comparing the Apples to Apples it's hard for us to compare ourselves to a seated school when we're offering that virtual instruction um here

033on the SAT I really want to highlight the um the evidence based reading and writing it's the erw Benchmark looking at that 60% um proficiency on that test and it's higher than you know our state testing score so we are seeing above that threshold I really have to give credit to the work that we've been putting into language arts and those Oxford design courses really been highlighting the writing processes um which that work started before I was even at OVA so seeing that work come into play and seeing those scores increase is um essential of course our math scores are something that it's not just an OVA concern but we're looking at a Statewide national uh Nationwide um concern with math so through our our math courses and our math and instructional leadership team that

034we're building with an Oxford that work is going to continue to be at the Forefront and improving those scores bs8 just want to highlight the um percentage of the evidence space reading and writing again consistently staying above that threshold with um with the city and same with PSAT 89 really proud of that 82% in the evidence-based reading and writing but then also looking at the math that PSAT 89 were were solid in that 8th grade um math curriculum so really looking at what's working with an eighth grade and how it can compare to our other courses and and improving those coures as well as well so the Axford design courses this is where we are trying to create these courses that increase the rigor within our online instruction so it's going Beyond just multiple choice

035assessments things that are easier to Google in in um increasing that academic Integrity we're really wanting to increase that rigor through that performance-based task so giving students more of a Project based assessment um versus just multip Choice assessments um it gives students an increase of choice and agency in their work they can be they're more proud of their work when it's something they're creating with the skills that they have versus just clicking A B C or D we know life is not a multiple choice test so really um increasing that rigor for our students and also it aligns with our seated schools a little bit more we're using that writing process that's taking place within our seated schools and aligning that so if our students are going back forth from the seated to the virtual

036they're getting that same level of um experience within the curriculum the mtss and intervention Improvement so the early warning system is a spreadsheet tool that we're using to look at multiple different pieces of data so we're looking at student grades progress there's um District benchmark scores wanting to pull in that Statewide data get teacher input and what this allows us to do is create a plan an intervention plan for students by looking at the whole child so it's not just one piece of D data to determine what intervention they need so when we see that pattern of their strengths or weaknesses within that data it helps us really determine a plan that's suitable for that student um our tier 2 and tier three we've made some adjustments to this next semester really trying to increase

037that engagement with our Intervention Program called Freckle Freckle is in alignment with our district Benchmark assessment called star so the pathways are created through their star scores and so we're working on embedding those within our court classes because we're noticing when they're embedded as assignments in the court classes the students are engaging in that intervention um our past class is more of our tier three level approach it stands for personalized academic success strategies so this class is we really took a turn this semester trying to increase that engagement with our students where we're taking um the teacher who's primarily teaching the class she's going onto hybrid sites delivering interventions we're partnering with our different hybrid sites we're also getting that face-to-face Zoom interaction with our students through um our National Vendor students which are the

038fully online students so really just increasing that teacher engagement within the intervention because when our students are struggling at that tier three level it's they really need that direct instruction approach and also increasing executive functioning skills when we look at our data set through the early warning system one of the big things I'm noticing not just in OA but even in the seated worlds um our students are struggling with those time management skills organizational skills things like that so embedding those lessons within the interventions a lot of times will meet their needs rather than just focusing on math and language arts so a day in the OVA Learning Centers you may have heard them as the learning labs in um previous presentations we're really trying to shift into this becoming a Learning Center where students

039are coming and the teachers are building um these strong relationships with kids it's building Community when the kids come in they're sitting with the teacher working on their online classes engaging in um like we have a picture here with Mr chrisy engaging in Game Club with our kids which is a great time to build those relationships have that time to just get to know our students as people um um and then we have different environments for the learning lab so students can come in they can go to a collaboration Learning Center where it's more working with each other and maybe um collaborating with each other and then we've got our quiet code for students who need an environment that's more um adaptable to just studying on their own or needing that quiet time to work

040on their cours workk we're also increasing the community events at OIC um through different we have we have a valentine day um event this Thursday fingers crossed if we have school but we've done um Christmas like little um holiday events around Christmas and we have a little um Fall Festival so really increasing that Community within the building and having that those events as well I really want to highlight dragonfly it's one of our local um hybrid sites it's actually right in the same parking lot is the central office um here on the left you'll see students engaging in experiment uh the first time I went out to dragonfly to visit the passion and energy and the directors um just their energy around having that Hands-On learning and making them learning engaging for the kids they

041were very proud of and so we see that in action with our kids over at the dragonfly hybrid site and um it's really beautiful to to watch and and see the kids interact um this is another hybrid site in Farmington Hills they they have a great musical theater program they offer various electives for kids around musical theater D singing um the production behind the scenes of building the props and so the kids really get to experience a whole multitude of that musical theater program and what it is to put on um a great show so this is from last year I didn't get to see it so hopefully this year I'll go go out and see their show this year but this is Beauty in the beast from last year all right and then this

042brings us to our school quality results um you um so looking at 2023 to 2024 we really want to highlight the amount of people who responded getting that engagement is challenging in that virtual setting but we're constantly trying to increase that those responses and that engagement but looking at we had more people respond last year um compared to 20 23 just seeing that the um the decrease in that strongly disagree or disagree which is a good thing so um highlighting the uh how students see lessons relating to their life and that feedback I think that work with how we've been improving that feedback within our courses is really starting to show within our school quality results as well yeah just um speaking about the the encouraging families to volunteer so like when you're when you're

043a oop viral ging parent you are a learning coach you're working alongside the teacher you're looking you're working alongside instructors again we're not just popping kids in front of the computer um for six hours a day so again encouraging families I know a lot of our H sites are very parent driven parent volunteer driven uh we invite a lot of parents in we we're having a lot more parent meetings this year um so doing what we can to encourage parent participation because if you have an online student and you are not a parent who's participating in the educational environment that is a concerned as you can see uh we've had a good trajectory with that and then again um you know how do how do life how do lessons relate to a student's life outside

044school encouraging students to get out into the community go out to a farm go out to a business learn from a career individual um how can we make it so that lessons are um number one getting you out of your house getting you into a professional environment um and then hopefully allowing that student when you know establishing those relationships with those professional environments and those professionals setting them up for a better resume and hopefully uh better job prospects once they leave our program close to the end here so um our exper education and Innovation campus collaboration I talked about earlier um this is again such a a cool thing that's happened a by product of being together in one building so we will continue to focus on school Improvement professional development are screeners and intervention

045even today we did this work right here data analysis and protocol so we practice we took a set of data one program Legacy in Rochester and looked at TH that group of students because essentially we have 10 different schools different curriculum different programs for our flavors different culture all of that so our data analysis is looks looks different than a traditional seated school so we are we are modeling how to do it at OA so that we can spread it to our other campuses that are alternative um and it's it's a lot of work to dig into Data Dean I know I'm sure you with your de R it is a a science I mean you got to look at the data wrestle with it what you see what are your outliers what are the

046trends what what does it mean who are you looking at what's the anecdotal all that quantitative qualitative so um I've really been pushing to stay hard to um Jordan I have actually Dr Venice that's his growth goal we were working together to get to lead be the lead Learners of how to do this this hard work it's important right um lastly one of the final things is um staff and student I won't read this whole um slide but we really have tried um we introduced a pilot survey this year it was called alpaca and um we had a really great turnout um the survey is very different because it's it gives them a lot of choices it's not just 1 2 3 4 5 and so it gave us a lot of actionable data and

047so we saw um common themes of they felt effective valued informed aware and committed those really meant a lot to me as a school leader um when we lift these up fully aware that we have struggling teachers all over this country get on any social media platform look at if you're I'm not a Tik tocker but I see the people sign me things all the time teachers are struggling all over the country it is not the same world right and we recognize that we recognize that our our teachers have been through a pandemic over kept working through it all um we took in 2,000 kids during the pandemic our trade it's just been a lot so we I'm always trying to balance the pressure you know it's they've got full loads um 190 students per

048teacher at the secondary level they're capped out so we are um trying to balance that and so they the one thing that came up with communication with Administration I'm trying to balance pressuring my AP teams because it is a very complex organization we run we're in like I said all over the southeast Michigan so I'm building capacity in our team to respond um maybe more timely and maybe more visits so we're starting to get in a groove of more visits and more um just ways that we can make sure that we're keeping that communication flow going so it's it's been good so far the feedback um supporting in Fridays we have the wellness approach we intentionally build a time to work on their growth plans we say we value your growth plan we give you

049time to do it we say we value this PLC work we give you time to do it so um we had to really focus and be intentional um we're responsive um weor respond and we have St participated in the Ling committee with Ryan office um this is just celebrating a new space this was at the beginning this just shows all the joy of the L Bridges that's of OA um Al together there so thank you and really appreciate your support as always thank you do we have any questions comments s yes um on your slide regarding the fact that to serve approximately 8,600 students further down it says 600 are seated how many of those 8600 are actually residents in the community um ior 162 fulltime resident 34 part time yes sorry did you see

050that she responded to your question okay all right um the other thing is I'm sorry to m i it was that's okay I didn't get chance to look at the Q&A list afterwards um the other thing is um I I I talked to a fifth grader at Clear Lake and she told me that the there's 26 kids in her class and there's no one helping that teacher and I feel like the resources for these non-district students could be better used on our district in hiring or having um parents come in and help in the seated classes first um and like the whole thing about Renaissance how many of those older students were Oxford residents that were participating when we have our own theater here um it doesn't to me it doesn't help the community that

051if these programs can be done through those school districts that they live in why are we spending all this money is my question well we I I did answer today um I gave some feedback on that our school provides we are able to provide all these options for students all over we have a great program it does generate excess Revenue goes back into the general fond but why do we need the excess Revenue because last I looked we were kind of in debt and so then it sounds like this is more of a moneymaking thing instead of really helping our community but our program is helping our community because we're providing access Revenue that goes into the general fund I mean then johnald here can speak a little bit more but the work that OB

052continue to do since 2011 has provided they we provided many benefits to the district seeded students seed students so not to bring up the presentation I did at the last meeting one of the flight spoke to purpose program the vir programs a good example of as a district we're helping students beyond our own borders but at the same time we're doing it in a way that they're getting a great education it's generating some excess Revenue that goes back into the seated programming in this District so when it comes to pay to the programs associated with the virtual programs they're all paid for by the revenue generated by those program so we for example if we turned all those programs off we would have a big hole in our general fund budget for in District program

053so it's a win-win across the board in ter of that presentation make sense yes it does but I still um don't see how it all of these families that participate that our non-district students they don't contribute as far as uh supporting our churches supporting our our uh fish and Love Ink they don't don't participate um in our sports program so they don't support that they don't support our Merchants so I don't see how this yeah I I can speak to that specifically so actually our students who are from outside the district do support our community we have school choice students that come to Oxford to go to all the different businesses in Oxford so all of our businesses are supported not just by Axford students but beyond Oxford give that kids that come from other

054areas um we've had our hybrid programs during the tragedy donate a couple thousand dollars to to our families to Ox schools many I can name all kinds of ways that our community has come and give back and and you know come out here to Oxford when we were in the plaza the plaza owner told me oh my gosh like they're not buying Pizza we we do have people that pour into our community and our families do come out and participate in sports even if they don't live in the district they can't so just some examples okay thank you any other questions first off you guys have awesome thank you amaz this whole team um I I know two years ago we talked about the black bird curriculum I just want to status of how that's

055how that's going because I know we talked about it quite a bit two years ago um it has quickly become our most popular Ela program um again the what we heard again you have to choose oord Virtual Academy and so we are Grassroots by Nature um and so we listen to parents as they decide educational options and parents told us we want books in hand we want paper pencil we want Tac title uh we want and so Blackbird has become our largest Elementary Ela woman uh option for uh students it's grown significantly for Middle School uh I would have to pull those numbers exactly uh but again it's uh our kids are reading more um it's less uh digital reading it's more paper pencil reading it has allowed us to have a balanced approach of

056screen time which is another reason why parents have liked it um in terms of acad data uh it's still you know if when when you do academic data for um overa we we have a great data specialist but we we were able to pull like on a 2-year Trend like 46% of our students stayed with us for more than two years and so we lose 54 so tracking tracking Trends is a little bit difficult we do do that but uh black we're still relatively new very popular um as things th far um I'm hope your own children like it but I hope like this onea is on the anybody else I just want to thank you for everything that you do fantastic presentation um I personally have extended family members that have benefited from um

057the OVA program they do not live in the area they it it was definitely a transitional opportunity for them um and they chose to continue to drive a considerable different distance to participate in the hybrid opportunity and and just can't say enough wonderful things about that and how it has benefited their three children that they chose to continue through that program so I just want to thank you personally as well as how much you pour into this professionally I would just like to Echo that uh black bird is fantastic is my favorite curriculum so far my kids are doing very well in it and appreciate all the support to them um I want to thank you for your format of your presentation the level of detail the data but not only the data your strategies

058and explanations relating to that were incredibly helpful and I appreciate all the time that you put into that so thank you unless anybody else okay thank you again have a good night you too all right moving into our next presentation North Oakland Community Coalition Todd and Tanya good evening your wonderful presentation by OA um I want I just want to take this opportunity um we we are so fortunate over the last couple years we've really been able to grow several of our community based Partnerships to support various aspects of our district from prevention to recovery to uh case management um I have given past presentations where we can outline all outlin all of the different Partnerships um and tonight I get the privilege to share with you uh our executive director Tanya Hamilton from North

059Oakland Community Coalition uh and we are continuing to grow our our relationship and partnership with nor North Oakland uh many people refer to them as NOC and um I want to take the AC tonight to have time just kind of walk through not only some of the programs we've been providing uh at our high school the last two years but some of the exciting opportunities that we have for uh our middle schoolers and even our fifth graders that are transitioning up to the middle school coming up so with that I will turn over to good evening everyone some of you I know I've met before some are new faces so it's nice to meet you and for new appes my name is Hamilton said I'm the director of North Oakland Community Coalition uh if you're

060not familiar with NOC I'll just take a brief moment to explain what we do we are organization uh that serves the communities of Oxford and Lake orian specifically our focus is on supporting the mental health of our youth and also preventing substance misuse in that same Health all right so the nlcc does use What's called the Strategic prevention framework this framework was developed by samsa and is a national model prevention so we like to just address this with people often times um people might look at our team and think oh they're The Vaping ladies they go around and just tell the kids not to vape actually there's a science to what we do so we do follow this um F step process and make sure that we're constantly evaluating our work as well we do

061have many Community Partners we take a community approach to prevention so we work very closely with the schools we value our partnership with you but we also work with other organizations law enforcement our healthare our healthare providers our businesses to make sure that we're all having the same conversation around what we need to do to keep our kids safe we are a te4 this picture was actually taken at the Community Education fair in November uh and so we have a team of four we have Jill mcum is our our mental health coordinator on the team she was hoping to be here with me this evening but she is under the weather Amber Rush is our ition coordinator and handles all our our substance misuse programming and then Sam Anor is our Communications coordinator okay so

062we'll just get started when we first um started our partnership with you our goal was to build a youth action board so we knew we wanted a group of students involved in the prevention um programs that we were going to be running so we have a group of students from Oxford High School who work with us and what's fun is that sometimes we also collaborate with the youth action Bo from lorian high school so this these pictures were actually taken from an event um this fall where the kids got together and they were working on some positive social norming posters that they then display in their high schools so it was fun to have them all together and these pictures were actually taken at the resiliency Center who courageously offered their space to us that

063evening okay so we work with our youth action board to do a lot of activities in school a lot of the kids might know us from our lunch activities that we bring in it's a really good time to engage with students on different campaigns and programs that we run um but we also do some inclass work with students at at Oxford High School U we run what's called QPR gatekeeper suicide prevention training and this is a wonderful new partnership we've developed uh for the last I guess spring of 2024 we started running these trainings in all of the H classes this is a 90minut training so it takes us two class sessions with each of the health teachers we go in and we talk directly with students about suicide prevention um between last spring and

064then this fall we've served a total of I think it's 304 students who are now Suicide Prevention certified and within four years our goal is that every student will graduate from asford high school with a certification from suicide prevention training what's really great about this is that we're also in the process of these trainings students who really want to become a part of the action board and become peer leaders and support to their fellow students so we're looking for students with the leadership qualities the visibility and the connection to their peers who can really be um a force in the building okay and then here's some data from our last survey so from this last fall survey we had 154 students who participated in the training and and we collect some data from them we

065run a post survey after the training is complete so we add them compared to your level of knowledge before you PR do prevention training do you now feel more prepared to recognize signs and symptoms of Crisis and we found that 96.2 of the% of the students said that they were which is very important because we always ask the kids you know or tell them if you see something say something but they need to be able to identify what they're seeing in order to really know that it's time to speak up we also ask them um do you feel more likely to ask someone who's showing finds of Crisis if they're considering suicide and 85% of the students told that's yes this is a big part of uppr training is really just empowering the kids to

066know why it's important to speak up this age group in particular has different barriers reasons why they may not speak up so we run through scenarios with them and explain to them we kind of um about the myths that might are common in suicide thoughts um and that kind of tells that it shows them that they really need to be the ones to speak up they some um let an example for you so one of the myths is that if you talk to someone about suicide it may make them consider it you may put the thought in your head so we teach them that that's actually admit that is not the case and that when you talk to someone about suicide it actually kind of gives them a sense of relief because you're instantly showing

067them that you care and it can open the door to communication so we go through a lot of different scenarios with them that makes them more comfortable bringing up the topic okay and then in addition to QPR trainings we also uh work on substance prevention activities so some of you may have heard of noake November that's our big November campaign to PR prent B but we actually work on that all year long and we bring in education for students um throughout the year and then wise wild cats don't drink is our underage drinking prevention campaign that we run we have a couple of pictures here of our youth action board members are working with students in the cafeteria on your left that's a novate November table where we had a trivia game where students came

068up and there were buzzers and the buzzers got broken it just got really Rowdy because they were very competitive but the kids had fun they could win prizes and then on the right hand side we were working on an activity um that helps you might see the kiddo and the goggles and they had some um coordination games they had to play and it was an activity to teach about um not even in the car with someone who has been drinking and then we're doing something new this year that we're really excited about our um nlcc staff has a onour VAP presentation that we can we take to fifth graders sixth grade classrooms seventh grade classrooms this year we're rolling that out in our fifth grade classrooms so this spring our staff will go in as

069a group and we'll go to individual classrooms and give a bit presentation to every fifth grader in the district those presentations are going to discuss what a VAP is what they look like what's inside of them what are the chemicals that make up the VAP liquids we're going to talk about how they affects their physical health their mental health their behavior help and their goals we're going to talk about VAP products and how they're advertised because we want them to be what we call Savvy consumers we want them to know and be able to identify different strategies that companies use to entice them because of course it's all about the money right we want them to understand and not fall into those traps um and then we talk about refusal skills by helping them identify

070their personal goals uh and that we discuss the power of those social Norms that we were working on with our high school students as well and how they really have the power to kind of change the culture and the attitudes and the behaviors around creating a bit three School culture and then this is fun so level up camp NOC has nol has been running this camp for years um actually down in Lake Oran and we're bringing it to Oxford this year which we're really excited about so it is for Rising fifth graders a Middle School prep Camp some of the pictures you're going to see are Lake oring KS but next year when I do this it's going to be full of bunch of your Oxford students with they Smiles on their faces um but

071we follow a curriculum we use what's called B and life skills training it's an evidence-based curriculum and throughout the week long camp we actually cover eight different character building skills we talk about self-esteem we talk about decision making we talk about vaping we talk about those advertising strategies that they need to look out for we talk about dealing with stress communication skills which is actually a lot about listening and becoming good listeners we talk about social skills and conflict resolution and then we talk about assertiveness which we love I love this because we talked to them about powerful eye statements and how they can advocate for themselves and we do this while building in a ton of games and crafts and activities they're able to build friendships with students that they'll be in school with

072the following year that coming from all different elementary schools in the district they become familiar with their new building because we hold the camp right in their new Middle School they practice opening lockers and doing a lot of the things that they might spend the summer having a lot of like Jitters about but we swel those in the beginning of the summer they open that locker and they're able to just knock some things off of their to-do list know they've mastered the locker they mastered knowing how to find the band room or the art room so they can relax a little bit um it's really great because we use volunteers from oord high school so Oxford High School students are able to Mentor them throughout the week and then when it's possible we also ask

073staff from middle school to come in so they can get to know their principal or their assistant principal or the SRO and SRO has a very different role that's noodle lot of elementary school students so it's a great time to let them come in and learn about what they do at the middle school level and it's just a really great start in the middle school years we get great parent feedback and I'm excited to hear the feedback we get from your AER parents this year and here are just a few pictures like I said from those kids down M24 the way but next year next year it'll be here on students so we do a lot of f the lockers I talked about this bead project here the kids make call me jars one day

074we talked about dealing with stress um if you've never seen call crafts they're really cool so come see us we make those on Wednesday during camp um they're a lot of fun to make um we love the parachute love the parachute it was the happiest day when I to order the parachute when I was a kid I always wanted one of my own and now we have one at our office um and then here are some pictures of our great volunteers we love working high school students have any questions what any comments questions yeah thank you pleas all right um sorry it's always tough to speak to you and still get it in the mic um so unless I missed it I just had a quick question regarding um the 90minut training that you spoke

075of is that also made available to all overa students as well it is not yet so our our hope is to grow that and make it available to overa students um our goal is that everyone has a training we want trained um and we're also future looking at a a program at the middle school not not QPR training but something similar to kind of the kids for the they get to high school sh just real quick um we just started to intervie some of ncc's uh resources to the over program so they did do the Vape uh program actually with our with our uh overa students and that was our first first kind of venture into that area and because of the structure of our over programming uh introducing some of these opportunities it takes

076a little bit more time because we've got uh different processes in order to make sure parents are on board and things of that nature uh with that old program so we are we're very interested but we have offered it through Community parent universities and things of that nature uh where we've had parents and children come to those trainings as well in the evenings so that has been an opportunity also well thank you guys very much for excuse me what you do um I work in addiction recovery uh in my professional life so um I I can't tell you how important I think it is to get started at such a young age to help prevent these issues from manifesting later in their life so thank you thank you thank you I think maybe we should

077have coffee there any other questions anyone well I really love that love love camp that was fantastic and great to hear about I love how the inct is really leading into these mentorship program so thank you for that and great presentation I will say that the M Camp is limited to 100 registrants and Tiny said we've got 25 right now I don't think we pushed it out yet as a district so yeah it is filling up quickly so yeah it's a great opportunity okay thank you very get on that thank you okay scheduled public comment we had two is that still correct all right Danielle [Applause] cek good evening um first I appreciate John taking the time to educate the board and Community last meeting on the basics of school funding um I do recognize

078and value his knowledge and experience that he's ringing to the district so as we prepare for the budget amendment um he has also laid the foundation for asking the community for a syncing fund so um the truth is many community members like myself in the moment would not be willing to open their wallets in these times for a district that has mistreated victims of the shooting refused to accept responsibility for their role in the tragedy failed to meet a number of commitments made to students staff and Community with the money we do have and have demonstrated some fiscal IR responsibility so I think it's important for us to look at these examples and learn from them um we eliminated a qualified head of safety position due to budget constraints yet Dr Markovich enjoyed a $350,000

079per year salary Hopkins was on a 9-month paid leave the district used evolved to protect the former superintendent and board numerous times yet we're still in a position where we are not consistent with how we use it for the safety of our students for after hours events we're over $10 million in counting on the the drainer property um and now it needs two boilers so I'm not really sure what the plan is to maintain the spending there we may have taken our eyes off the middle school and now it needs an electrical overhaul the monthly credit card bill is anywhere from $150 to $200,000 a month almost $2 million a year maybe we could cut 10 20% of that and get some more supports for our students $1.3 million in general admission which includes an

080increase of $200,000 for legal and audit fees we need some transparency on that a million do was approved well over two years ago for a mass notification system and a rush approval in June for Raptor only to find out that during the lockdown in October neither had been successfully implemented despite the community being told so putting safety at risk so these are just some examples so before asking for a new sinking F syncing fund it would be absolutely appropriate for the district to bring further transparency on how the prior syncing funds have been used transparency on all funding provided as a result of the shooting provide a plan of how you would spend a new syncing fund and how you will ensure proper oversight and how they will be used and finally bring appropriate closure

081to the civil lawsuits with the victims families taking accountability for the trauma experience by all 1600 students and staff members without this transparency we cannot rebuild trust and confidence and how the district will move forward I for one would vote no if that was on the valid right now without this information thank you thank you Danielle we have one more the prince hello I sent you all an email because I saw on closed session that um you'll be talking about the EOP so um since losing Hana I've tried to learn as much as I can about school safety and Emergency Operating plans and kind of how how this all works in an effort to understand um kind of what happened and um what I've learned kind of boils down to the fact that the EOP

082um is like a living breathing document so it's more than words on paper so when you guys go into close session and you're going to have eops for every building this time for the first time so that's the commitment that was made at least and those eops were written by building level teams I assume collaborative cross functional teams that um came together and did vulnerability assessments as a team and then put together an EOP as a team and they update those eops and they train their staff on those eops and everybody understands what's in them and everybody's on the same page working towards the same goals to protect against risk and threats to that particular building which is unique from other buildings and so um in in addition to I emailed you I printed some

083stuff out that I'll give to Justin for you to take in close session the first is just a copy of the law that explains why you're looking at this every two years it's legally required okay that's that's why you're doing it the next is an excerpt from the guidepost report that explains where the commitment was made for school specific eops and it also notes that um the district is required to train all staff on signs of trauma so so I assume that's happening um the next is this all Hazard emergency operation planning guide I have some excerpts in here about um the school level EOP teams and what those teams are like or should be like okay the next is the SEC report that the district used for the district level EOP I want to

084make sure everything in here has been addressed in the last three years so I highlighted a few things guide post report number two just some reminders of their findings in regard to the EOP and the responsibilities of the board which are great very great responsibilities that you have in regards to the op and the last is a 2013 FEMA guide it shares very clear guidance that Oxford didn't have in place in 2021 so I want to make sure you all understand it and that all of our staff has been trained on these warning signs that F bratu our attention over a decade ago thank you thank you Marissa thank you both for your input moving along into consent agenda we have the minutes for January 28th open and close session and HR updates can I

085get a motion Mike thank you move to approve the consent agenda as presented support far thank you any discussion all those in favor I opposed motion carries all right next up Dr Milligan all right good evening everyone how we doing there we are okay um first thing I want to do is say I did it that time say turn it on all right thank you so much to all of our community members our staff who participated in the strategic planning um community meeting back in January we had 82 people in person on a snow day that was pretty impressive several students as well got out of their pajamas and came and participated that was amazing we had 21 um participants on our survey and all of that information we're going to talk through here in

086just a minute all of that information was reviewed uh in terms of what our vision mission and core values should look like so again thank you so much for taking time I know everybody has a really busy schedule and a lot going on so to carve out time to do this was much appreciated as just as a reminder strategic planning it's a structured and comprehensive approach we started this back in October looking at our current strategic plan and what changes needed to be made in order to bring it up um to speed for what we are today or who we are today so it's very comprehensive it um defines our long-term Vision where are we going and and it sets strategic goals very specific goals on how we're going to get there there are actionable

087steps and these steps uh are intended to improve the overall quality of education and operations within the district so it serves as a structure to help our work and help Define what we need to do how we need to do it and how do we know that it's happening and is having the impact we want it to have so it's a very comprehensive approach it takes a long time fortunately we have a decent strategic plan in place um that has been guiding the work for some time we just need to essentially give it a facelift and bring it up to you know 2024 2025 um school year we started in phase one phase one was a lot of the behind the scenes work that we did in looking at our current strategic plan and one

088of the things that was very evident is that it didn't fit who we were today and so that was the beginning of the preparation so we started in October we were preparing for several months we partnered with our ad team our cabinet went back and forth to get additional information um and we presented that at the community meum uh community Forum in January so that was our vision mission and core values to get information to modify those and now we're going into phase two phase two we're looking at um finalizing our vision mission and core values we're looking at developing our goals we just had a wonderful ad team meeting where we had lots of conversation and dialogue around goals what goals need to look like what's important what we're looking at our vision mission

089and core values so thank you to our ad team for participating in that um we will lead into our phase three or phase yeah phase three will be our community meeting we'll have another one on April 9th um bring a friend that was the the homework assignment for everybody who was there and just keep our fingers crossed that the weather is good um so that'll happen April 9th and we'll present the goals action steps um as much work as we're able to get done before then to get as much information from the community as possible our goal timeline is to have the Strategic plan completed by June and presented to the board in June for approval so lots and lots of feedback this is this is from the in-person um meeting that we had we

090do have quite a bit of data from our online surveys this was what was typed up from those meetings um again the vision is where what future do we envision for our students right so that's the end goal so I'm going to have our team come up and talk to us how they took the feedback into consideration when coming up with our vision draft based on the fabulous feedback that we got hey good evening and I want to reiterate as Dr and said thank you to everyone who participated and provided feedback Alison and I had the pleasure of working on the vision which is the future we imagined for our students we had great dialogue over at OIC in the afternoon and in the evening with our stakeholder groups and we really appreciate all of

091the feedback that was given especially the feedback that helped us stretch our and really go back to what was written in our options and make to make sure it fits what we're envisioning as Community moving forward for students so Alison would you like to share a little more about particulars um so we kind of way Ryan described it earlier it's a little spoiler alert this is where we ended but um we had presented three different options to everyone and part of the discussion was what you liked what you wish was changed what you think should be added in different spots do these words work does it still apply here um and so as we went through the first division that we had um the strengths that they said with the first example was that it

092spoke to everyone all of our stakeholders it captured a changing future and it really highlighted the unique strengths and aspirations of our district but some of the criticisms was it was a little wordy and it felt more like a mission statement and it was too corporate and so some of the the language that was in there go it was worth keeping and so that was the discussion that we had within the group so we kept that in mind as we went with option C and then option b we had really rich discussions again where our strengths were that it was growth and journey or oriented and that it emphasized resilience opportunities in the future and then in same respect the criticism was the word resilience so it was interesting to have that discussion um and

093using the idea of Learners because as a learning community just our students who are Learners we do want our staff to be Learners as well um and so our vision C which is what we took um feedback on the strengths for that it was short clear powerful and marketable and we even had someone that said Put it on the bus um so I think that's a an interesting way to look at it some conversations that we had around this vision is the the use of the tents whether it needed to be empowered versus empowering and so we wanted to look at that continuing in future um as we're building a community it's not just as you're in if you're at o oelc that it's works until you graduate but really as your part of this

094community you're continuing to participate and build that you're continuing to empower yourself um and a a good conversation we had also was about the level of vocabulary that we had that it was a good balance between it didn't matter your education level developmentally as a child as an adult these were words that are are powerful to be able to use in your everyday language but at the same time be something that's understandable and developmentally appropriate to acknowledge everyone and so that's that's kind of the big takeaways from this um and and I really enjoy to put it on the bus because that's a great great way to think about it I was always taught you know your vision should fit on a t-shirt it's something that we can Embrace and then every other step kind

095of explains it along the way yeah absolutely I think um one of the critiques of this was that it was maybe too concise but in our conversation and really thinking through the vision is a future we imagine and the mission will tell us how we're getting there so with that I will turn it over to our mission team thank you I had the privilege of facilitating um the mission posters and I say privilege because I really enjoyed that experience so thank you to everyone who part participated and um also with the survey because I love we love diving into that and really synthesizing that so um my partners back here helped me go through all the feedback and help organize ideas but if you were there and you recall the mission had three different options

096that were rather lengthy paragraphs and as uh people got to the posters we saw that it wasn't necessarily somebody saying I like a better I Like A over B I like C it ended up being um being that were lifted up we really liked this and then we would have a discussion about what that meant for our students I really liked this so it was really great but I wanted to step in and recognize the initial feedback um that all of them were too wordy and then um I'm going to shout out our ocv friend over there who joined because he that really resonated with a lot of the groups and he was talking about film and this is just the powerful part involving the community and something like this and he's talking about film

097and how you create an elevator pitch am I yelling this yeah so create an elevator pitch that's two minutes in an our case that would be two sentences that really the both motivate and capture and so that really resonated with us so thank you for that feedback that was awesome um so we lifted some strong central themes through the dialogue and you know reviewing the survey and the focus was was really more on the ideas um that were listed as important and not necessarily the words like I like journey I like pathway but we were talking about opportunities for kids right so we really tried to lift those them so the four things that came up uh most often and most strongly and passionately were the first was opportunities so how do we capture the

098vast amount of opportunities and Pathways that we provide kids whether that be elective CTE internship virtual hybrid extracurricular and I'm going to plug special that even our Contin continue M supports so all the vast opportunities we offered was one two was the idea of community the idea of belonging to a community and then fostering connection between the community three was the idea of contributing so again some language but we we the the groups really lifted up the idea of our students giving back making contributions and um even providing ex of service so that was the third and then the fourth was that we help students to believe that they can succeed that we encourage them to be confident in their skill set and to persevere despite challenges so the word that was there that everybody

099you know that I think it connected with people was selfefficacy so that word is included but I will say with the draft watermark on there we received some feedback today from ad team that maybe there's a better word that will capture that idea of confidence building skill set and perseverance so we're still work on that but um reveal shall we fight that's fun okay little ly uh providing a supportive safe an opportunity Rich educational experience that Fosters belonging builds self-efficacy and empowers Learners to contribute to a connected community so that's where we me it but like I said you know feedback this is a draft is there a better word for self efficacy still think that you know I'm going to extensively text my team over so and with that I will hand it over

100to good job you're just a Psy in the B very nice job so um our core values I do want to thank and I as I listen to Pam talk she she's a hard act to follow here but I do want to just say that we are just kind of facilitating this process is how I feel and I was absolutely Amazed by the participation uh not only by our ad team our cabinet but then when we got to our community forums it was such a diverse group uh Dr moan mentioned our students that participated our parents our teachers our administrators I I believe you know most if not all of our board members were at one of those two sessions and so this really is reflective of our community and we just get the privilege

101to kind of bring it together look for those themes and really try to capture what our community SE our core values at this point uh so uh let's see sure yeah we started out uh we had five uh posters and we we really looked at five values and they included empowerment inclusivity Integrity Innovation and supportiveness and uh as we kind of work through the themes and the information both from our electronic survey uh our ad team as well as um some of our feedback from the forums what we found is that we saw themes and so a lot of people felt like these were a couple of these were repetitive core values and so we really wanted to look at those themes some of the repetitiveness and we ended up combining the core values and

102we made four uh it's important to look at the first core value here number one is empowerment and some of the things that we saw that uh resounding themes included risk-taking that people wanted included in there they wanted to see our students and our staff taking risks and learning how to do that effectively uh they wanted us uh they wanted our students to feel empowered and um and they wanted the supportiveness our original core values of supportiveness and empowered uh they felt like those should be combined in one way or another and so we did look at some of the similarities there and how we could combine those um and then we took that looked at meaningful challenges that was a theme that came up our students should experience meaningful challenges something that they could

103relate to their life experience and um and people asked initially we had supported in here as a part of our empowerment and people felt as though that should be removed it didn't necessarily fit with empowerment and so we did we looked at that and we voke that out of there um our second um core value around belonging um it started out as inclusivity and some of the things that that people referenced is they love the sense of belonging that inclusivity referenced and so they said why don't we just make it belonging as our core value we want our students to feel as a sense of belonging in our schools in our learning communi so that's what we did rather than inclusivity we we included belonging there as our core value uh and this this anyways

104as we continue to develop it and then we we talked about embracing diversity was a theme in there um a number of people reference liking the theme of diversity and having that as part of that belonging component having different Learners um in in our classrooms and how do we support that um and one thing that stood out is that um the the term Community might work better uh in this particular uh form of belonging uh some of the other terminology that we initially had and so we included a community at the end there so um as we move into our second or third core value of innovation what we ran into was uh all Learners and all levels that was really important that all Learners are able to innovate and um at all levels so

105we we included that there uh in our statement and that the word race continuously came up so embracing that Innovation so embracing changes and teaching our kids how to embrace change was really important uh part of innovation and then the term ignite or spark was one that our that we saw that that our community uh voiced and thought igniter spark was really an important part uh of innovation for our kids to be able to uh ignite students passions and equip them for the future so we we included that as well and then our fourth core value was integrity and one thing that I'd like to just stress around this is that uh we had some some very vulnerable and Frank discussions around defining some of the terminology and integrity was one of those because as

106we've moved through the last two or three years some of our terminology means different things to different people in our community and we wanted to be really sensitive to that and so when we get into Integrity uh we talked about accountability what what does it mean for different people in different places where they're at we talked about what does it mean in the classroom accountability in a learning setting so we wanted to really talk about learning and personal growth uh as part of that being accountable for their learning and personal growth and um challenging yourself in cour for taking accountability like um s this read as far as promoting honesty accountability and ethical behavior in all aspects of learning and personal growth um we started uh with a bit larger definition of integrity uh and

107that's really it kind got narrowed down through some of those discussions as I look around the room I see some of the faces that were part of those discussions in the community forum and I really appreciate everyone's vulnerability with with regards to that um Jen we focused on that this isn't just about our students it's about us as our staff right leaders staff all of us all you know kitchen Transportation this applies to all all of our values that we all live in it together johs good okay all right thank you team appreciate that um it was really important to us to make sure everyone knew that what they shared was really appreciated and I wanted the team to highlight how they process that information right they they are thinking we are thinking very deeply

108about about the feedback because we do want it to be representative of the community and I don't want it to to be any one person or small group we really want to make sure that it meets everyone's needs so I appreciate I have an amazing team they have really um you know put their effort into getting it to where it is and we still have quite a bit of work to do but we'll get there so thank you appreciate that um so right now and this is our getter done sort of chart uh we're going to go back to Cabinet we've done um the initial review we've brought it to ad team today to share we got some additional feedback there on a few things and then we started with the goals uh reviewing some

109goal Concepts and next week we'll start into cabinet developing those goals trying to bring all the thoughts to bear on creating those goals um with the intent of having the goals and action items um measurable action items brought to the community in April April 9th to be exact 1:30 or 1 to 300 p.m. uh similar two sessions 1: to 3 p.m. and 6:00 to 8:00 p.m. we'll start um putting out the invitations um here towards the end of the month where people can sign up it's very important to sign up mainly because we need to make sure the space is appropriate for for the number of people so we'll give multiple opportunities to have people sign up all right so and getting it's a long journey let's put it that way right so getting to

110the Strategic plan getting it developed is a long journey but it's not the end of the journey here are all of the areas after we get the Strategic plan that will need to be reviewed based on the new strategic plan so we'll need to look at our curriculum we'll need to look at our instructional Frameworks um these actually you'll you'll hear from Anita kja Collins tonight about uh some changes in our instructional Frameworks but essentially we're looking to align our teaching methods learning objectives um and curriculum to make sure that they support our strategic goal so we'll be reviewing all of that we'll need to look at our policies and procedures making sure they're aligned budget and resources staff roles and professional development stakeholder engagement assessment and accountability measures teach uh technology and infrastructure student

111Support Services governance and Leadership so quite a few things so this this will be after our strategic plan is in place we'll need to review all of these these areas to make sure that they're in alignment with the new strategic plan so it's a it's a long journey but it's an important Journey um I do want to talk about where we're at with snow days so this is the chart that we keep the data that we keep um all of our schools are maxed out um by six so all of our elementary schools uh are at six the state gives us six days um um OS is over by two days Crossroads Bridges and over are over by one now we can apply for a waiver for up to three days so we obviously will

112be doing that and um those aren't always guaranteed but fingers crossed um and we will also be looking at ways to make up dayss um we are looking into some virtual options but we don't have those approved yet but we be looking into them fingers crossed all right we had some Transportation challenges to say the least so um I sent messaging out Sunday night uh I recognize that in my attempt to be proactive I did not really think through that and I apologize for that I was really trying to avoid families having to scramble when our buses get stuck on the unpaid paved roads right they're very large um they rear wheel drive we have parents who are waiting to have their kids picked up and buses are stuck on some of the unpaved roads

113so we have those situations so um my suggestion was you know we we'll you know do our best but we most likely won't be able to transport the unpaved roads let's just say that did not go over well so I apologize that was not my intent so as we thought through it um we have transport about 1,700 students uh 30 uh 360 from unpaved road so about 20% so when we are unable to transport when we cancel school because of the unpaved road roads we're we're talking about 20% of our students right um 80% of our students we can get to school now I just want to be clear right we safety is number one I want to make sure all students are safe um we also support students in a multitude of ways in

114our schools one example is our our meal program right some of our families really depend on that meal program so we're looking at possibly figuring out a way um to do a a plan where families have options right everybody likes options and so in many cases families are better they do have vehicles that are better suited to the unpaved roads right they live on them they know what works what doesn't work uh our large rear wheeel drive buses can become stuck as we found um and so one of the things that we are thinking about is possibly um if we do have to uh not transport for unpaved rad roads giving families the option you can transport your student to the school yourself if you feel it safe to do so um you can also

115um we're also looking at a possible Hub program where the nearest paved Road where you if you feel safe to do so bring it bring your student to that location we're working on that plan um that we would have specific times and locations for elementary school middle school in high school that would be listed out and the locations um the other option is you you have the option to keep your student home if you feel it's unsafe and we absolutely respect that these absences would be marked as excused um some of the questions that I got was if it's excused does it count against the high school um exam exemption and the the way that we have it now is the way that it would be set up so excused and unexcused absences do count

116towards the 9-day limit nday you know I got a lot of comments that people are like nine days I only had three days right so nine days is is quite lenient when it comes to attendance um so it would count in the that nine-day limit right so that's a a family decision to make and I absolutely respect that um our priority is always student safety while ensuring educational access when it's safe to do so right so it's balancing the needs of all of our students and making sure that families have options um and our hope is that we don't have any more winter weather but that's not going to happen um but this would only be a situation like we dealt with last week where for whatever reasons the unpaved roads were not treated right

117we made lots of phone calls we tried to figure out how we could get them you know taken care of and it was just uh not happening um and the paved roads were in good condition so it's just it's a tough decision to make right because we our families do rely on so many of our resources at the school um so I apologize again if that messaging landed um in the wrong way but we will continue to work on improving that um we are going going into uh we will be looking at our EOP and I appreciate Marissa lifting up some of the concepts um so the US Department of Ed defines EOP as a document that outlines how a school will prepare respond and recover from an emergency so I just wanted to make

118sure everyone knew what that stood for and what the intention is of the of the plan it is under revised code is law that schools have to have this in place and it must be reviewed every other year these are the components that by law must be in the EOP so this is definitely driven um by our uh legal by legal aspect and then we have new templates this year we've received them I think in October so we've had to revamp the EOP and the structure of the EOP and these come from multiple programs um to ensure that it is in compliance so we are using that template so that's what what we'll be looking at this evening and going through I think it's 300 and some pages so it's very um very indepth all

119right um our government committee met and one of the things that we started we talked about is how can we leverage our board meeting the days that people have car carved out to come to board meetings to be Community opportunities um for Community forums um one of the suggestions was when our our schools present having the the board meeting at that school and so our first proposed meeting would be March 11th when Daniel Axford is due to present and so the recommendation is that we would have a would push the board meeting to 7:00 we would have a Comm a community Forum between 6:00 and 7 p.m. to discuss school safety and talk with board members and the superintendent um and then we would start the board meeting at 7 with principal Boyd presenting about

120da so this is recommended um at the with the governance committee and then we would have to vote on this um at the next meeting if this is something we're interested in doing lots of great school activities taking place and this one is actually happening at Lakeville but all this is for all families throughout the district um so this is it's February 27th 5:30 to 7 it is a literacy family literacy event information and strategies targeting all reading skills will be discussed and activ activities around that there of course is pizza at 5:30 um and then a live Zoom with author Jacqueline Woodson and she talks around the concept of grit in her story so they'll have an opportunity to learn about that so great opportunity thank you for all the staff who uh put

121hard work into setting that up and some of our school highlights I absolutely love these newsletters when the principal send them out so this is clear Lakes Elementary um students IB students of the month we have lots of highlights from Leonard we have our happy 100 days that's the staff dressing dressing the part and then we have our students of the month uh for each grade level and then at the high school I wanted to highlight I really appreciated this they're lunch and learns and these are opportunities for students to uh discuss different professions and opportunities in different professions um and so they can sign up for during their lunch uh to talk about all different types of career Explorations I thought it was really cool that that students had a chance to do this

122and you we have very um very diligent students that do not like to miss class so the fact that it's at lunch is actually a bonus and then at the high school that's a picture of our robotics team they had a prototype they got a a challenge um five weeks ago and they developed a prototype and then on Saturday was their first time rolling it out onto the actual um uh playing field so they were very proud that was our programmer on the right and our driver on the left and I have never seen so many people so excited about an event they the whole room was just buzzing adults and students so it was it was really awesome to see they have a competition on February 28th and March 1st in at ketering University

123so best of luck to them I had an opportunity to attend Hana night um Thursday February 6th I was just so impressed just with everything I was impressed with our students I was impressed with our staff that's our girls basketball team um they spoke so eloquently of their friend and you know how much she influenced them um you know just beautiful heart-wrenching stories of their time together it was it was really lovely um and very articulate they had uh flowers they had the Lays they had shirts the staff was handing those out it was it was really touching so I appreciated all the effort that went into that to celebrate Hana all right and that is my update thank you any questions or comments for back mail again I just had a quick one about

124the Hub Transportation plan uh do you have an expected timeline for that just want to make sure that's not something that you know we're getting snow mageddon for the fifth time this week right uh Michigan weather is that on the table for this week no no no no no yeah we're still we're still and it wouldn't be it would only be in a situation in a rare situation where for whatever reason the back roads are not treated but all the paved roads are in good shape that's the only time we would use a plan like that um and so with snow mageddon coming it sounds like all the roads might be bad um and it's something that we really want to plan out it's not something you can just toss together because safety is really

125important and any type of confus confusion in the morning right people parking in random places and not really having a sense of um you know where kids go and where we wouldn't want to set that up without a good plan so we have a we have a draft we're working through um with Mike strong and the transportation but we're not anywhere near ready to roll that out yet okay but thank you that was a good question thank you anybody else I just I mean back to the strategic planning I just really appreciated the whole process I I will um I appreciate like I mean I know Todd said it but being your team all being like facilitators of that and taking all of the inputs and trying to decipher some of it right trying to

126work through some because there was a lot there was a lot I mean we had to break down or you y'all we didn't we just we just gave our input we had the easy job so um I just appreciate that whole process and U looking forward to how that is integrated in the entire I guess being of oord school yeah thank you yeah and don't forget to bring your friends at the next one because Mike's right it was a great experience bring those friends I just want to make a a quick um thank you and give my appreciation for your dedication you and your team um the diligence that you've been putting the the care and thoughtfulness into navigating some of these recent challenges that have been unexpected and they just kind of keep coming

127so um really really appreciate all your efforts thank you okay thank you again are you also presenting on field trips okay then we'll let you keep roll yeah so we have several field trips in preparation so as the robotics season gets started the challenge is that um you won't know if you need to travel until you qualify in certain competitions and so they're being proactive in submitting um field trip requests for several competitions um but they're only if they make the they they win those events right so last year they did go to worlds in Houston so our hope is that they'll go again um so the first two are the um those competitions and then the third and this again it's for first reading tonight um is OMS the DC trip that isn't happening

128till uh next November that happens every year so it's kind of a staple of middle school so those are for first reading our second reading or excuse me our field trip approval the only one we're looking at for approval is for the leadership um conference that I presented uh at the last board meeting perfect thank you does anybody have any additional questions about the OS leadership that we are approving okay well then can we have a motion James I move to approve the field trip request as presented support an thank you any discussion all those in favor I any oppos motion carries all right moving into our next item which is the masb board of directors election you have all re received a lot of emails over the last few weeks uh regarding those who

129are running for district 8 and there were bios they each sent us personalized emails uh masb provided us a link where they were all in the same place and you could learn about each candidate and then additionally this morning the four that participated in the Forum they sent us the recordings of those interviews so you've all had a a pretty good chance at getting to know most of these people so with that said is there somebody that is stuck out to you would anybody like to nominate one would we like to have a discussion regarding our our top maybe two or three an uh I really appreciated um Mr Colin Paul Colin from Bloomfield Hills I appreciated his interview um he's got 10 years of experience you know impressive masb certification I I feel like

130his experience in what he was able to speak to albeit it's a very brief interview that they have um I I thought that aligned with with our our values here in Axford and and what we focus on and our concerns great anybody else like to say something Shane uh yeah I just wanted to mention uh Dr Anisha Hannah um I really enjoyed reading her take on uh Dei and how important it is to make sure that education opportunities are Equitable for everyone so I really liked her idea and her her I guess vision of inclusivity thank you yeah I think I actually came down to two and I agree with you and I think Paul uh resonated overall student and staff Focus the history but I also so um one of the things with that

131caught my is Corey M Loflin I think one of the things there with him is that it's CTE Focus um I think that's a big deal from what my field is and what I do and the the technology part so I've definitely support Paul um and then Corey was another candidate that stood up to me any other Jam Corey is mclin that's region seven so that wouldn't be our region we're region eight y I mean great great for region seven right all right so we'll take him off the discussion for now anybody else I would like to say I also agree and that I thought Paul was an excellent choice I've had the pleasure of uh meeting him at a few events as well and he is very focused on safety he is he's upset

132obsess with data so of course I love him for that and uh I think that he would bring a lot of experience and a different perspective as well to like he said in his interview uh to help align Schoolboard members to the services of masb and I think that he would be a great representative so with that said would anybody feel comfortable moving to nominate at this point and I will okay I move to nominate Paul Collin the masb board of directors I will support and discussion all right all those in favor I any opposed motion carries great we will let them know that our vote was for Paul we we send somebody to vote for that on our behalf right in person okay do we know when that is or do we just send

133them that's not in person uh Justin will be okay just sending it on our behalf all right thanks yep okay we have two policies tonight for first reading as you can see in the board packet one is a very standard um pertaining to time off and we made no changes to that the other one the changes that we made were Oxford specific regarding graduation requirements and academic credits so if there are any questions we could take those we would have more policies for you to bring um drun has been a bit backed up with all of the recent uh Law changes and executive orders and things like that so it's unusual for us we have about four weeks worth of questions waiting for them that we hope to have resolved by our next policy meeting

134in the beginning of March so at that point we will hopefully be bringing you a lot of policies uh but we just have them looking over quite a few at this point so had a question yeah so looking at the 54901 and trying to understand the stuff and not being in the meeting I see a lot of green and I see a lot of red so if I remember I read is what we're taking out or is that what's changing and then what is the green part sorry I'm loading uh yeah Anita if you want to also come and get yeah there because I got a few other questions that I apologize yeah I'm very sorry about that it was like a lot of collaboration and so the red and green is all recommended so

135the I'm sorry say that again the red and green is all Lang recommending okay so we just had a couple of different people working in it and we didn't change the colors over so I was tracking in red and then someone else is tracking in green so um as it is the red and green is what we're recommending to be accepted okay and then my other question was remove everything below this point is that the everything the credit may be earned by and through the internship the EDP those are technically not state requirements and so when we comparing the original policy we just felt it would be better to streamline and stick to the actual graduation requirements and then um integrate those into handbooks rather than actually be a policy so with the internship stuff

136so if someone's in one of our CTE programs they get to the end of it and they're going to do an internship within that program we'll say uh Emergency Services right we're no longer going to count that as credit when they do that internship is that my understanding I'm going to be very honest with you I can't answer that question because I think that's a different scenario like if they're in the EMT program is that what you said as an example yeah I think that's a very separate piece than an actual internship and so I would have to actually take that to the subot to to clarify that but um we technically are not really running any formal internship type programs right now so I feel like that falls under a different practice well I

137know there's other part of the work based learning that's green that you guys put wording in there so that would be I'm sorry internships crossed out as listed as work based excuse me work based learning opportunities approved by the mde and the school board so we're no longer going to give credit for that that's I guess would be my question it's not that we're no longer giving credit for that it's it's not matching our current practice right now we could revisit it but we wanted to make sure that what is in the policy actually matching our current practice okay and that section I think you caught that that section will be moved into you know handbooks and such so there will still be documentation of this just not living in policy I'm sorry explain that

138a different way where you're looking at the credit may be earned by right right that is going to be placed into student handbooks as a guide but we are not going to have that in policy because as Anita said some of those are not aligned with our current practice and so the ones that that are will be moved over by ad okay yeah I I was a little confused as I was reading I was like we're taking away a lot of different areas or ways that that kids can earn credit especially I'm thinking about CTE and some of our our like osc programs and stff like that I just trying to make sure that we're not eliminating or moving that way so I I appreciate definitely not a opportunities for kids we're just keeping that

139policy to the actual graduation requirements and so is this going to stay in line with what we currently have as our policy as the 549 currently or is there I guess because I know it's an 01 so we're making our own right we're not doing it already was an1 yeah okay so we had worked on you were on the committee with me actually when we worked on this with uh Steve wolf okay prior okay and so during the course of this year were some gaps identified with that policy and so awesome that's I I appreciate I was trying to remember and there are so many policies that we went through so yeah and I appreciate the pH too because this is all so there are you know very vulnerable and say that I don't know

140everything yet um and so if there's anything I can't answer I'm happy to get it from the people that do no that's and that's I guess first reading I I looked at it and I had questions and I was typing them up and I didn't get submitted over so I just figured I'd ask it and I appreciate it and um I you know we follow up after we still have another reading so thank you so much sure thank you Anita all right would anybody like to make a motion there Shane great uh move to approve the first reading of board policies 4113 and 540901 as presented support Mike Whitney thank you any discussion all those in favor I any opposed motion carries fantastic next up we have our letter that has been back and forth

141since November just as a a quick recap um we passed our resolution want to continue our advocacy work on those points within the resolution and as we all know some things have changed some up to VAR this week that um have brought us to the point of changing the letter slightly I sent you all a draft and I just want to go over for full transparency uh we unintentionally violated the open meetings act through that email as the reply all was used and so just to to kind of recap what happened and to make it right I sent the draft to everybody and there were replies that came back to all which of the nature thank you for following up the first or the last paragraph of the first page still needs it reads like

142it was from last year added for change and then another um email came in that they've read the letter fully support it and then we had another revision attached one more suggestion came in as the as we approach part of the letter that they would like removed and so at that point we stopped the communication but I just wanted to make everybody aware that that happened and we certainly didn't intend to do it that way of course when you are um it it's natural to want to speak to everybody and not go in a vacuum so sometimes I know that Oma it it's counterintuitive to how we respond and talk to one another but it is something that we have to work better at and so we have put in a couple mechanisms in place

143to avoid making that mistake and the fact that we will be doing the BCC all and so that when even if you hit reply all it only goes back to the original sender and on sensitive time ICS like this I will again put a reminder in there to only reply to me so with that being said you have the letter that it is now I sent it all again to everybody last week on Thursday and asked for any edits or suggestions I received one that was to the effect of asking the governor to physically meet with us so that we could discuss these points further further so as you will notice in the letter that is included now uh I did not receive any other edits and so with that would anybody like to say

144anything about this or move to a motion yeah I'd like I mean um so and I see you looking so you don't have the current format of the letter right that was uploaded okay right well you read what was there from last week and what got uploaded today at 6116 today is something a bit different so I I think it's important to know that while I understand the intent behind this letter and stuff I think it's important that we all have the opportunity because I I myself as I was coming in looking at this for earlier today didn't see it and then I just saw it about 10 minutes ago when I was scrolling through the rest of the stuff um that I need time to look at this and I think it's only fair

145for anybody else that didn't see this attached that they can look add it and read through it um and then I know we had some some you know you you sent out the the kind of uh proposed draft and asked for for updates and stuff back but um did we ever get opinions back on this as well yes okay were those shared to us from what they said uh we received one approval because I don't I don't see the email from them with that information in there that's why I was looking for that too just now okay I can tell you that this was approved as is by Bradley delat and the only change again is the very last line that says we would like an opportunity to meet with you if you are willing

146to further discuss these issues okay I'd still like to see the emails from them on that for transparency so understand their concerns on that okay anybody else yeah ahead I was just GNA ask can you forward that now I mean most of us have computers in front of us but I I'll I'll conceded do you oh go ahead man okay I was just I was just I know we've been working on this as we mentioned for quite a while now and I really appreciated the work that went into it um as Amanda mention as I'm looking at this I mean this is 95% of what we had already reviewed I certainly appreciate wanting to make sure I mean want to do our due diligence as far as clearing it um but if we can get

147that information now I think we can review it and have any discussion um I would I would like to see us move forward with this or something very similar to this tonight if possible so what's the difference between this and our resolution that we already passed and sent out like I'm I'm as I'm reading this and going through and looking at this draft I mean a lot of it brings up things that we we talked about in our resolution that we agreed upon as the board that we put out there as an official resolution of the board and such and then I get to the end of it and and it takes a tone of almost like a political action group requesting and not the partnering with and and advocating I guess being here on

148the board like first and foremost for students here in our district with our teachers our staff our teaching community and I definitely has some of that in here but um you know there it it's I feel like we're going beyond the scope of what we are as board trustees I mean we did a resolution we put that forth we agreed upon it but then this is taking it further and and I'd really like to point back to previous board members one of Aaron and Mary and other people going to state legislators on their own time taking their own time off to go meet with the legislation legislators excuse me going to Washington DC and advocating that way you know on their their own time but from the perspective of our board and stuff and this

149one is to the governor but it doesn't include anything to our Representatives or any other government officials as well as anybody from the local government that might have some control over some things or have some influence in there like I feel like it's still lacking stuff but again I also want to be respectful to what we're supposed to be doing here as a board um for our students here and and we're spending a lot of time on this and we we did the resolution and and I feel it's kind of repeating that that's yeah uh fair enough um my perspective is and and being new to the board the amount of time that we've been looking for asking for seeking support for our children the four that we lost the many many all all of

150our students families and staff uh without action the the final resolution passing in August of 24 was a Monumental step the continued delay in action is the angle that I'm taking and what we're looking for in my opinion on this letter is the encouragement of our state leadership to support us in our resolution to support our community the four families that lost tremendous I can't even finish that sentence and then the rest of our community just as a whole so the fact that we have had a resolution pass with little to no action and then discussion about potentially supporting we're going to support I'm with Mike I i' prefer not to continue to Kick the Can down on the street and if we can get a resolution supported by the governor at the highest level

151than the other agencies the other supporting entities would follow a suit um and the the opportunity to to meet I think that's a a valid point because it's have we had our day in court have we had an opportunity to talk to her does she understand who we are do she been here uh I haven't been on the board before I wasn't involved in any of those I absolutely volunteer to have a ation with her and representing our community as a whole um so I mean it we can continue to delay we can continue to discuss and deliberate um minor changes can take place as we learned through the passing of the resolution relatively quickly especially with a minor change or addition that has been added I just I'm with you um if we can

152get it ped we can agree to move forward as a board which what you know what we're here to do this would be great invitation to have an engagement at the highest level which I think has been missing but there has been movement since our resolution from the state legislators passing the bill her signing stuff in there so I don't want to undercut that as as nothing's been done um with with I think our resolution is part of it but then also at the county level and stuff so I mean to acknowledge that part I just yeah do you think that there was wasn't enough acknowledgement in the in the letter I'm just curious I know I asked some for some feedback and there wasn't any but um we do acknowledge the changes that have

153been made and we thank her and our legislators within the letter for as we all know um you know the mental health funding and security funding in her is in her budget proposal and we appreciate that and make sure that that that's known in here so is there a specific acknowledgement that you think is missing no I'm just I'm saying that the way that I interpreted what what Mike just said is that that since our resolution there hasn't been any movement and I want to acknowledge that there has been movement in different Avenues and different different venues for for stuff for that I'm sorry reading your email from the other thing okay here yeah yeah an I just want to clarify the origin of this letter because to the commentary that we've been working on

154this letter for a long time doesn't really accurately Define where it originated from this letter was prepared in response for the the um news conference that was held in November if it was needed if the media was asking the board for a comment and it didn't so it wasn't needed so I'm I'm not of one to make it a best practice to reach back to a stale document to try and just put lipstick on it it's very disjointed it it needs work that's just very obvious it doesn't really make sense currently and I also don't understand where it's coming from there's no momentum there's [Music] no political strategic reason and it's clear in reading through that letter and I drafted it and I'm reading it knowing what the legislation that was just passed January 22nd

155makes no sense it feels very shallow feels very opportunistic I don't know who it's meant to serve but it doesn't feel like it's serving our 5,000 seated students and 8600 overa students how is this aligned with the effort currently being made for the Strategic plan how does this deserve to pull our Focus right now it doesn't read that it does I don't like to reach back into the recycle bin just to pull something out just to put the governor's name on it to send it out I don't think it deserves our attention right now now I think it's really I'm not putting my opinion on anybody but to me it seems insulting to all the work that's going on right now in our district here for our students I don't I don't think this serves

156them so if there's another strategy that we're not aware of please present that to the table I guess what I'm to talk to that point I guess what I'm trying to where are you [Music] seeing I think this is naturally a Next Step as we talked about from the original resolution as far as advocating my my main thought or I mean from since the beginning even before I was on the board right we had talk talked about having a something at the state level a multi-discipline Ary team um that can facilitate you know come alongside any any kind of these tragedies and and help those districts move forward doing a full after action and when I'm I guess I'm not saying that the district isn't isn't continuing to do I mean many things and I

157think we're we're showing here that we very much appreciate some of the Mental Health Resources support that there that the legislation is is passing right I mean we're increasing 31aa I think we're or they are rather not us um so I think we're we're we're recognizing that and still advocating for Michigan students General so I don't know how I I'm trying to understand how how you're taking it the way you're taking it I guess I don't know I don't know I don't I don't quite understand why how you read through this and and take it that way when I ran for the board was transparency here within the district looking at our policies constantly we ask our students to learn from the past and and I think you know that there's been a lot of

158work done since just even the three of us that have been here the longest right now currently on the board that we've moved towards looking at policies refunding policies um the the op that we're going to look at later on today from what it was to even when we approved it before and and the further changes that we're probably going to see tonight you know there's lots of things that we could do and a lot of work that has been done within the district and to echo which what an saying I you know I don't I don't want to diminish that but that's that's in our scope of us as board trustees all right and and that's what we continue to do and drive and and i' much rather continue on that Focus for our

159district for our students for our staff and have that be an example and I and of you know what we have learned and moved and and done and and in that way but I don't with with this letter I don't you know I I feel like it's going to dist distract from what we're doing and and now people within our district are going to be taken away from the jobs that we want them to do and the focus we need to do away from our kids and our staff and and and go this way I don't it just it doesn't seem appropriate for our board at this level we we passed a resolution we steadfast we uh voted as a board to get clarification on our insurance policy because we wanted to understand what that

160meant in the legal Arena and we stood by those things and I fully stand by those things and and I continue to think that we we're not done with our work work by no means with our policies and what we're doing here there's lots of things still coming the world is ever changing and and back to the Strategic plan what we're looking to do and continue to move forward I just don't see how this helps us in that and and the recycling of the document where where originally came from I guess when it was on the board agenda last time I was looking I was like here's something that's not not relevant anymore it was just kind of piec meal together and it just it it looked horrible and I was like I don't want

161to put my name by that it looks like crap and and looking at this now I mean there's there's a couple things the couple paragraphs that kind of talk to each other but I don't again regardless if it goes out or not this shouldn't stop us or we shouldn't be held up like this to be able to continue to do the work that we've been doing and will continue to do until we're done serving and focusing on the kids and the district and and just that stuff in in the areas that we're responsible for I just think that to take this time on this that that to not have anyone be able to articulate why we would publish something that doesn't address a direct and current need for today's purposes 2025 and it this I

162just have to repeat it feels very shallow it doesn't it doesn't speak to what we are currently focusing on as a district okay so I have two two thoughts 100% respect all of the opinions and we're entitled to those part of this letter talks about advocating we as Oxford have and are continuing to advocate for all of the aspects that our students are going through on a daily basis in my my opinion is We Can't Stop advocating for safety from across the state and for situations that we went through and getting a chance to potentially meet with the governor and and others even if she punts and says go meet with this team for groups for a voice for change for learning what we went through um having that opportunity to do that and having

163a conversation is where things start so the continuation of advocating all of our legislative powers in the state of Michigan to continue to support the resolution that we as a board passed to get past this doesn't change what we're doing today tomorrow yesterday the Strategic plan visiting the schools there's a lot of work that we do and this doesn't necessarily add or diminish what we're doing today for all of our staff most importantly and our students most importantly um so it doesn't change change anything it further accentuates the opportunity to get in front of our leadership to voice the lessons that we've learned to changes that we've made as a district Echo those to to someone who can take those and run with them at a greater scale than we can while also echoing the

164support of the very resolution that this board approved um and it's been a long time coming do we like this letter being requested to either one by all means respond with some ideas on making it better or to pun it down the street which has kind of been the me the mentality that we've seen thus far so I I'm I'm with all of the options all the opinions M matter on this board as a as a professional and as a human if there's recommendations that we need to make then let's make those recommendations to have an audience with the governor to speak on oxer's beh have to make change as well as get the ball down the road from uh other legislators on the current investigation so people have gone to to Lancing and have

165spoken um before the resolution and and since then have gone multiple times to get in front of legislators and and they haven't changed what their agenda is and what they're doing right it unfortunately sometimes it feels like this isn't a topic that they want to address we we put together the resolution but I think I think really I we need to focus back to what we can control here and and I I see this as I'm reading through it again I mean it feels like a cheap check mark so we can clap each other on the back and say yeah good job we sent a letter we did a really good job and stuff and and I don't like that I don't I you know it shouldn't just be that you know I I think

166you know the governor's had opportunities or or has the ability to if she's wanted to meet with us and I'm not going to be to understand what her schedule is but they haven't made a priority for us we did a resolution to reaffirm what we believe in here as a as a district um you know and I guess my question is like so we do this we send this letter and we get nothing then what we send another one and another one and we keep on spending time on it or do we get back to the work that we're doing here within our district within our confines of what we're elected to do and focus on that and then take the time to go up to Lancing or you know other other things like I

167just I I feel like this is going to go out and in one year out the other or not even make it there right and and and it's just it's it doesn't align this I don't I want to echo on what James said that even if the decision was agreed upon to to send a letter whether it be this particular one that it still at this time comes out of left field there's no momentum there's minimal relevance at this time there's no political strategy behind it no strategic timing or anyone articulating why any pulse for effect now no one is no one's been able to articulate that so that's why I'm like why this letter I don't agree with with the wording why now no one's been able to articulate that and I don't think

168it's an adequate reason to say because I want to or because we passed a resolution I don't think that articulates it I think there needs to be a little more substance there instead of people want it or do you hear what I'm saying like that's not a reason yeah I appreciate that and I think that with the passage of the governor you know her proposed budget recently that includes a couple of these things the momentum would be to encourage uh that to continue that that stays in there because attached to the safety and mental health funding it was that districts must accept a state funded investigation should they experience a tragedy such as we did and so as we know sometimes in these sessions the proposed budget looks a lot different from the end budget

169and so right now I think is a great time to really reinforce that to our leadership in the state that these items that we listed in the resolution that as as of right now are in the proposed budget we would really like to stay there and further that in her budget she has also allocated to attorney general office for her piece in the investigation and so again I would have to say that it would be a good time to really make our voice heard in Lancing and if we could get a meeting and just go over some of these things I know that Aaron and Mary like you had said had great success with the sitd downs and so I think a sitdown would help not only our students in Oxford but those in the

170state keep this momentum going on the great safety measures that as we know the threat assessment has passed as well um you know we all have certain feelings on that and so I think it is a good time has anyone reached out to our lobbyists to gauge whether this is this particular mode of communication is effective or if this is just going to line the bird cage of her staffer that screens her mail and it's not likely to get past that has anyone reached out for a political opinion from a lobbyist that would possibly be able to point us to a direction where it would actually make an impact uh no I have not I guess I don't what I don't understand is the risk of this and that's I guess that's what I don't

171understand that risk why when when we're when we're looking at I mean not to repeat Amanda but when you're looking at what you wanted timing I guess Amanda gave you some reasoning for timing and so if we send this and reach out to our lobbyists and try to advocate for again not only our community but the students in Michigan I don't I don't see the risk I'm actually kind I don't I don't see the risk here I was kind of surprised we're having this conversation honestly I don't see it as a risk but we are elected for Oxford Community Schools right and we need to put our students and the student Community First and and the time that we spent here is now taken away from that for other things that we need to do

172and we we spent time and I think very very useful time of putting a very thoughtful resolution together together as a board and approved it and S sent that out and and now to me it's it I I don't want to say it's sent out and forgotten it's in the back of my head but we need to refocus to to hear I feel like with with continuing with the letters like this or sending any statements out is just attracting from what we are elected to do for here for our students and I mean we spent what 20 25 minutes on on this alone I mean I'm not keeping track but you know it and and I don't I don't understand the why like I understand that we want something be done at the state level

173but um you know I never even thought like it could just we email it or send it and a staffer looks at it and it goes into the recycle bin and and nothing's done and there's got to be a better way to do it in light of the time I suggest we table this for now because the changes were done at 6:00 tonight so some of us have not been able to review thorough had time to look at how those changes were done but we have people waiting to talk and um I would suggest we table this until our next meeting and in the meantime we do do the emails um yeah I I won't take up too much more time I'll just say um as far as my opinion when it comes to this

174letter this situation um um I think not just the students in Oxford but any student in the state of Michigan or across this country is worth the investment uh of time effort sending a letter if if they don't happen to respond that doesn't mean we just pack up and go home right we continue to Advocate we continue to do everything that we can because every life is worth that so I kind of agree with the premise of what's the downside of sending it if they ignore it so what's the downside because I don't feel like it's wasted effort I don't feel like it's wasted time feel like everybody's opinions and what everybody has said here tonight is valuable I think anybody that's ready to speak and wants to speak here in a few minutes it's

175valuable so I again don't see the harm necessarily in sending this maybe we don't get the outcome that we hope but you learn and you change strategies and you keep going forward so again that's just kind of my two cents and I I just don't see I I don't see necessarily the harm in moving forward okay is there anything else we can either table we can someone can make a motion uh you know what's the sense of the board and how you want to proceed if we table we can bring this back up in the next meeting correct yeah Absol so if we want to table it for further discussion we can like she said share the emails we can come up with the I guess a consensus as far as just your personal View

176and and your feelings on the letter itself and actually provide feedback then I think we could you know come back to the next meeting and maybe everyone will feel a little more comfortable anybody else okay we will go ahead and table this I would highly encourage anybody with edits I know I've asked for a while um and there a lot came out tonight uh if you could please send those over uh I know I had asked a few people repeatedly and so if we could get that moving and understand that as a board we are going to come to the next meeting and try this again um I would really appreciate all of all of your input before that um as like I said up until now there was just the one so um please

177send I will do with it as you would like as far as legal opinions and anything requested I'm happy to do so and I look forward to sending this in two weeks so moving from there I just asked that when when we get ready when we have the proposed wording stuff that it's before 6:15 the night of the meeting and that way everybody has adequate time to look at it to process it to to do it um nobody likes the last minute thing brought in or put onto the agenda especially something that I mean there's a lot that is that is in this right you know I think ultimately I think we all want what's best for for things but the wording and stuff I mean that's why we work so hard on the resolution

178so thanks of course did you have something yeah yeah um I would just to speak to that I would just say then we need as board members to make it a priority to give our feedback within adequate time and not wait till the last minute to send it over appreciate that okay are we good to move forward yep okay all right committee updates uh I I gave you the policy one as we discussed that uh that's pretty much the gist of our policy meeting so far we have a lot stuck in limbo just waiting for legal opinions on them there really isn't much else to discuss regarding that but I think we've had both finance and governance meet so who would like to speak to those James yeah so being the chair of the governance

179committee um we had our first meeting with the new members uh keep me honest last Friday right um we've already set up our next meeting for March um to continue the work on there um a couple things that we handled or that we went through on the governance thing was reviewing the purpose of the government's committee um if you've seen in the Monday memo there was um a survey that was put out am I right on that making sure that I I speak and tell survey put out of the governance committee and some questions of is this part of the governance committee or is this not or you know Falls within the realm of that that uh operation of there um moving forward as we have a more regular Cadence on our meetings we'll definitely

180be working on the Board of Education operational manual um you guys had a great start to it you guys did a big undertaking with that and got that out but there's some uh some tweaking to do in there um some of which being adding policies that are referenced inside there so if anybody was to look at it be quickly referenced for that um we also talked about and and this is kind of food for thought for everybody on the board um a little bit change on the structure of our upcoming board meetings Dr migan to discuss a little bit on the site visit or this School visit when there doing the presentation of a shorter meeting um some districts do uh that have two meetings a month they'll do one is a working session so

181they'll do that where they have a bunch of presentations they'll have like the field trip first readings the policy first reading stuff and then they'll have a meeting of the whole or the uh larger board meeting where they're taking action on things um that seems like it might be a good way to move as we have the two meetings that that shortened one we take that extra time at the beginning of it to meet uh the building be able to talk to the parents the the um PTO at the building and stuff people that are invited there and that' be uh I don't want to call it a shorter but nothing urgent or pressing on there right school presentations maybe student awards stuff like that and then the larger meeting more more pressing things now

182in a perfect world that's great that's not always going to be the case but you know some things that we're kind of thrown out there of you know changing things around especially getting around more to the different uh buildings within the district with the school presentations um we talked about upcoming learning opportunities for board members um there's a bunch of um level 100 uh learnings that are either virtual or some of them are learn at your own pace that it's highly encouraged for the new board members to go through and to look at a lot of great information in there I know there's a lot of stuff that I went through amand I know when we were going through it like a lot of things that we learned that you know was kind of eye

183openening and then once you get done with your uh level one certification there you can move to the 200 level ones that are more detailed um and on that same note looking to have both Sarah Beth and Shane you guys signed up for the masb superintendent evaluation training because that will be coming up towards the end of the year um that's something that you guys will need to go through the rest of us have gone through that and understand the evaluation tool and and how that looks um the other thing that we discussed um I'm just trying to think there was I forgetting anything um the superintendent evaluation that Shan yep just said that okay all right anything else that I forget I think that was that covered everything so overall it was a good

184start of the meeting we plan a meeting monthly um more if needed but definitely you know the the operation is manual to make sure that's upd date there's a couple spots in there that need um some filling in and some stuff and then um hopefully I would say by the end of the next meeting we should have some things to kind of present again to you guys as the board as a whole so you guys know what we're doing so thank you okay okay thank you very much I'm really looking forward to everything that comes out of governance committee this year really like that one and um just excited just a quick question did you discuss the board self-evaluation and a timeline for that or not yet we had not but that might be we

185we did discuss at a high level um one of those small working sessions uh that we do at a a school visit taking one of those and and chunk it out of time that we do that self- evaluation that way it's open transparent um in front of everybody here to see how we self- evaluate everybody and and things um to cut down maybe on the additional Saturdays and stuff right people's times are are valued and stuff like that and if we're already scheduled for two meetings a month maybe we look at one of those as a section of that that shortened um site visit as the self- evaluation of the board members as an option thank you okay um before I start on the finance committee I appreciate the moving and having meetings at the

186various District or various schools I know we had did done that before um and it was nice to be able to get to the different schools and and really see what they're doing where they're doing it um I would encourage we need to make sure we broadcast that very well because it's a lot easier when the board meeting is always at the same place for the community to be there right and so I remember before when I was a Community member trying to figure out where the board meeting was tonight um in that so just make sure that we coordinate that or maybe it's every other is that what we're kind of thinking yeah so like one sorry not no not to be loud in the mic um yeah so like what like if we

187look at like the first meeting of the month be like a school visit meeting if if it makes sense for the school presentation stuff it definitely be communicated as well as because we've already approved our scheduling for the next calendar year it'd be something that have to come in front of the board we have to make a motion for it and be approved and then it would be publicized in not only our minutes but you know on our our official thing on the website and then that that that larger meeting the secondary meeting would be in a central like here or hopefully at AIC one day yep um something like that okay finance committee meeting uh so it was an and Shane's first committee meeting um we reviews the the reviewed the revised budget calendar

188and kind of understanding the road map there uh we were fresh off of John's riveting uh presentation so there were a lot of questions some questions from that which was good I I like that we we had delayed the the meeting and we went behind the the John's presentation so I was I was actually I appreciated that timing because it allowed them to kind of get that 101 um and then revisit some of some of that uh discussion in the meeting um the uh admin building plan discussion we we had and what that looks like moving forward uh we had a budget amendment one first discussion um talking through how the 147c pass through money has decreased um but that is that has passed through some of the high points there um and uh let

189me see kind of focused in on the percentage change uh on that on that first page that we had received um I really kind of appreciated how he how he worked through um how he presented it I guess um we did touch on the uh some the general operating millage and some what that might look like um what it currently looks like more and then moving forward uh we had some like I said I touched on this already Finance 101 subjects uh we talked about a workshop um coming up actually uh we're going to kind of piggyback on our next finance committee meeting um and then uh just general updates on projects and bids so part of that uh the finance committee we we talked about focusing more on the facilities and and such last

190year and so as part of that um we we talked on updates on the o OIC roof the the boilers um answered some of the questions from the previous meeting on uh their um touch base on the some of the changes in atorium on the in the high school and possibly looking at uh a future Early Learning Program some kind of how that might look like moving forward in our buildings so um kind of that's the the high Lev summary Shane and anything else okay okay thank you well sounds like three productive committee meetings so thank you everybody and it's like we are moving on to Anita presenting on the future of IB thank you all right so yesterday the community received a communication that um Oxford Community Schools will no longer be seeking reauthorization

191for the pyp and the myp program so that's the primary years program and the middle years program moving forward next school year um we are going to be maintaining the DP the diploma program that uh services our 11th and 12th grade students um and in fact they actually have a reauthorization visit next month and we prepped for that with our evaluators coming from uh Kansas City um on March 12th there's actually two of them but we met with with one of them so um as there are new members on the board and I think sometimes um it isn't widely understood exactly what I is and to kind of know what we're moving away from we should know like what it was um so um IV essentially is the how to the what we do so

192IV provides a framework and the the what is the standards of the board approved curriculum that we put into the framework so um for example and I'll use an elementary example we have um literacy curriculum math curriculum science curriculum social Stace curriculum that you have approved as a board um that we fit we take that curriculum and we fit into the framework so it kind of tells us um this is how you should do it and so um IB offers four programs the primary years program which is DK through five uh the middle year program which Services uh 6th through 10th graders um the diploma program which is for 11th and 12th graders who left to be in that program and then there's a career related program that we actually uh have not historically had

193in our district um but it is there as an offering from IB um IB tends to look at three major pillars so the learner the student um the learning and teaching so our practices in teaching the learning and the learning community and some parts of the framework that we plan through include transdisciplinary them so you maybe heard your students say like we're in the uh theme or unit of like who we are at elementary as an example key Concepts lines of inquiry um IB has provided us with a Common Language a framework to the learner profile and the approaches to learning so self-management skills communication skills and so on um at the myp it's really probably the hardest to implement um there are additional standards of practice especially around assessment um and Criterion and so

194again IB is more the framework for how we do something not necessarily what we're doing really toy our standards in our um separate GRS for them so the rationale um to the decision and I will tell you that uh it probably was one of the hardest professional decisions I've made in my 26 year career I and I shouldn't say I me it was a collective um decision that was probably in the works for since I started here I think each year has come up that are we still doing this do is still serve our needs and every year we kind of like yes let's keep going let's keep going um and I would say in the last few years it's become a little more difficult between the pandemic and um the experience of the high

195school the tragedy of the high school and so regaining that momentum and getting back into it has been a little bit more challenging but it was implemented 15 years ago so long before I was in the district I was still previously in a different District um and when it was implemented I do really brought a sense of enhanced instructional practices and standards that weren't really available to us at that time 15 years ago since then and over time our national standards and Frameworks have greatly improved and they have themselves have brought the same rigor um in standards that IB mons brought um multiple years ago we do have to acknowledge that we are Chang landscape in Oxford we've had two major events that have reshaped our Learning Community um and our needs have evolved um

196oh you know I do want to go back to the strategic planning I think you could see today from where the Mission Vision and the core values were going that a lot of the global aspects of of the language that we're in our vision and Mission have really been recentered to community and turning more to our more core community and IB is really about the global aspects um I think it's our responsibility to adapt our practices and align with the current culture and climate and student needs I think that we have had great internalization of practices across our system um but we've also continued to have some resistance and and um compliance practices that we've been working through um IB really works well in a private setting we continue to have challenges with implementing the

197IV framework in a public education um and so we believe in the philosophy we believe in its um practices but we feel that it's still challenging and we continue to be met with constraints and I want to give you a couple of constraints that are an example so um the middle school at the beginning of the year Mr bigo a shout out um came and said I don't feel like we're meeting all of our students meets I have kids that really want to double up in the area of Arts or stem and they can't and the reason they can't is because the nyp says every student has to have 50 hours of instuction in eight different subjects every single year in the Mi and So my answer to him was we can't do that but

198it breaks my heart because I have kids that want to do that right and so it came back up again and I said it came back again a few weeks ago and I was like all right let's just do a book these on advertise that you can't put it on paper we'll lose our reauthorization and I'm being very vulnerable these are the types of decisions we're having and to me it was more important that a kid's need is being met than jeopardizing reauthorization and so those are the types of little constraints that add up to big things when we are trying to meet those constraints in our in our setting and then just looking ahead to the future again our community and our students we saw that amazing video during the strategic planning the kids

199that were part of the process all said we want different paths and opportunities and removing the IB framework doesn't take that away um in fact maintaining DP maintains that ability for us to offer students a pathway should they choose to go in that direction um this probably will make me a little bit emotional because with change comes a lot of emotions um a lot of people in this organization for their hearts and souls into the IV framework including our IV coordinators our administrators all of our teachers and to working so hard to make our curriculum fit into units and using the format that I wants you to use and housing it in a certain way they for the most part have really internalized these practices and really believe in them I don't really think they

200need the franchise to say that's still a part of who they are and so I do want to acknowledge that that we are where we are now because of all of their hard work that started way before me um and since the announcement we have had various emotions we've had people that are devastated um people who are like you've done so much work how could we do this but then some of the same people who said that to me yesterday came back around and said okay I'm over I'm excited now so we're I'm letting people just kind of have their emotions they're entitled to that and then I've also had people say I'm really excited about what's next this is long what we do so lots of different U emotions within our organization and it's

201important to allow everybody the space to feel what they want to feel because I need them all on board for the next PE the other thing I do want to say and this is not a criticism I think sometimes leaders have see an opportunity and make a decision but 15 years ago the superintendent at the time actually just said to the district this is what you're going to do um and part of the challenge that 15 years later that we're still facing today is that we are in some areas still in compliance mode because of that people were done to rather than brought along and so our approach moving forward has to be that everyone has a voice in the next framework that we move to because the more people that internalize it and have

202a say um and are engaged with it the better we are for our kids so what this means in the immediate future is that we're going to preserve as much as we can for as long as we can some of our schools are still authorized for the next couple of years and so we don't want to mess with a good thing we want to go slow in order to go fast and so teachers have reached out and said can we still keep our units 100% you can keep your units but now maybe you might have a little more flexibility where you wanted it right another example is at the elementary Level Elementary teachers are prohibited from departmentalizing and so as an elementary teacher I loved departmentalizing I loved math and so I often doubled up

203um with my partner and she took a different subject um and so they might have that flexibility now to ruce their love a little bit so we want to maintain as much as possible our common language our routines and the best practices that we've internalized or ID while operating with fewer constraints and then we're going to turn our Focus forward to the future to develop a cohesive framework together I think it's important to capture how IB has made us better and what we value about it want to consider maintaining this was a very easy list to generate um IB has really brought a sense of agency to our students and our staff so that idea of voice choice of ownership um students taking action uh commonly anguage we know organizations are stronger organizations and they're

204all using the same language so the learner profile the approaches to learning the Criterion work um all aspects of common language having an inquiry Focus which again um most of our standards now have gone to more of an inquiry focus a lot of growth through reflection one of I strengths is they force reflection through like at the end of a unit you all the teachers sit together how to that go um stronger written curriculum and planning and then again the transdisciplinary themes helping kids make connections across different subjects and for fifth grade the exhibition project at the end of the year is something that has really made us better and I think a lot of our um staff we want to keep and so um I I put here like what would you add to

205the list and the reason that question is there is because this question needs to be asked of all of our staff too they might say yeah this sounds really good also forgot this this and this um or actually we don't value that as much as you did so I might take something off um the good news is these are not limited to I inquiry is not owned by ID reflection isn't owned by IV and so these are just practices regardless of the FR framework or program and we can preserve them and do what values what we value most and that or without the constraints so of course with a big decision there are always implications um in consideration so we have I coaches and coordinators um there are three at the elementary level and three

206um at the high school miip and um DP level and so those coaches will be maintained the DP coordinator Julie will maintain her position as a DP coordinator um and then the miip coordinators they shared kind positions they teach half time and Coach the other time and then our um pyp coordinators they will just move into an instructional coaching position so their positions will be maintained I think there's a lot of fears of them losing their jobs we know strong organizations are supported by instructional coaching so we'll move into a bigger instructional coaching model um Staffing right now wor offerings all of that's going to stay the same so again you want to move slow to go fast there will be no no changes to what our kids are being offered for next school year

207and maybe not even until not even the following year so we'll just take it real slow and see where we land um but for as much as possible we want to keep business as usual um this does refer to a Q&A document so when this went out to staff um I created a video so they also got a video they also got a Q&A document and then they they got a form for asking questions and so far 16 questions have been submitted I'm proud to say I've answered all the questions that have come in and I keep just putting them on the Q&A Doc it's really important that our staff feels supportive um through this transition so here's just a little tenative timeline of where we're going next so um again for this school year

208we just want to maintain our current programming what we're doing is still great and still working so we want to do that and reduce as many um interruptions as possible and I see now that there are two periods after I sorry for that um we at the beginning of the year started a committe it's about 60 people deep K 12 which is pretty impressive um that is centered around looking at strong effective instruction does that look like in Oxford so we have a framework but is everybody doing the same thing I'm think think that we would maintain that committee maybe invite others um to be the core committee that starts doing this work for the district so again it's a DK through 12 committee teachers of different subject areas different grades principles coaches um we'll

209probably maintain that an invite to see if other people want to come and we will start defining what strong instruction looks like what do we want for our kids what do we want to preserve from I and then start researching future Frameworks together and so really have their voice in um what's resonating with them and where we can take teaching and learning forward in the next school year continue researching actually develop the framework um possibly pilot it depending on the timing of how fast we can um move and then really be thinking through how we could bring in other people so let's just say this team grows to 7 how do we make sure everyone else's voice um is being heard and they're able to offer feedback and then really plan for roll out the

21026 27th school year so it feels like it's long process but I guarantee it's going to go by fast um we'll really tightly plan it and um again I think the key here is that we bring people along rather than doing something to people and so again um I mentioned these already so supporting our administrators our teachers our instructional staff and the transition is really important to me into our team and so again they received a very lengthy Q&A back it's on continues to grow um they I they I sent them a form to ask questions that were not on the form or not answered in the video that I made um and so again the committed questions I was checking it last nighted or a little bit AG 16 so we're good um we've

211encouraged people to talk directly to their coordinators and administrators um for us to get more feedback on how they're feeling and what they're thinking and a lot of people have expressed feelings to me and I'll just say like tell me more I'd like to understand what you're feeling why you're why you're feeling that way because I don't want to have any blind boxs as we move forward in our future attending and then again I already did it earlier if I don't know the answer to something now we will work through it and get it together um I don't pretend to know all the answers we're stronger together and um I know it won't necessarily be 100 100% SM but I will do everything in my power to make sure people feel H and supported in

212the transition thank you um yeah just a quick comment um I want to thank you guys for taking the stance of going to our subject matter experts and getting not only the opinions but the feelings of our Educators our teachers and it sounds like at least from what I heard tonight and correct me if I'm wrong but at least at this point there's going to be no one that is going to lose their job during this transition so um I think that's really important so I again I just appreciate the uh tactic and and the strategy that you guys had so thank you any other questions comments James I I I know it's been a long time that we've been doing this but I'm also uh know that we've learned and grown quite a bit

213through this process and just because we're not going to be accredited for it um you know kind of rest assured that we can take the best of IB with maybe not some of the restraints around it and and I think it's just going to make us even much stronger more stronger I'm probably not saying that correctly but it's going to be it's a win-win I see it right that we can keep those those aspects of it in there and stuff um I know my son in particular struggles with some things and and was limited on some of his choices and electives and so he heard this and he's like so I can do these other things now things that I want to do and I was like yeah possibly we just got to see how

214it works out and stuff so I'm sure if he's one and like you said there's others that are out there and stuff um but yet we still have the program for the ones that want to do the IB diploma and so you know I don't think it's a total loss and stuff so um I know it's a lot of hard work and it's probably a piece of you feels like it's going away but but just know I think it's just going to grow and be bigger so thank you for putting the time along with you and everybody else in this the Middle School a few of the middle school kids kind of like worked on a back end you know right there close again the back end um in the background they did a little

215survey and like surveyed each other and like approached a couple of their teachers like how can we do this and that was presented to be by their Administration and so I mean when kids do stuff that like really hard so yeah I appreciate that James you're right all of this is not for none right we this is internalized we are only better because of it yeah I'll just Echo and and thank you for the presentation you can tell how deliberate a lot of the questions that I had you answered like preemptively right going down and so I just appreciate I I could see how deliberate and thoughtful you were because I know it's close to you and I appreciate that so thank you you learn in life the right thing and the hard thing are

216the same so thank you anybody else have anything for oh sorry okay uh thank you very much I appreciate the thoroughness of your presentation all right I guess we're up to the riveting Mr Fitzgerald oh oh Courtney you have big shoes to that both technically you okay sorry about that um good evening and thank you for having me tonight for those of you who do not know me my name is Coury mowy I'm the budget director um I'm here to present the amended budget for the fiscal 2425 school year um in your board packet you have um some summary sheets that are um that look like this you have four of them in total they for each of the four funds that we're presenting a change for um the funds are going to be general

217fund um community service which is our child care fund food service and then our capital projects um so the purpose of these amendments is to uh give you a midye update um now that we have some updated information for both the revenue and the expenses when we present the original budget in June there are a lot of factors that are unknown um so we take this opportunity to um give you like I said a midyear update to give you an idea of where we're at um on this document you'll see that the First Column is the adopted budget that's what we proposed in June and you adopted um at that time for our original budget uh the third column on this document is the amended budget that we're proposing tonight um the revenues and expenditures

218are broken down into subcategories the revenue is listed um in the four different categories the local state federal and other sources and the expenditures are broken down between instructional and um student services so um each category you'll see that um there's going to be explanations of maybe some of the variances we use the um we use a range of anything that's in excess of $100,000 on any of those budget categories you'll see an explanation for um the purpose of using that number is just kind of um show like a materiality um some of the impacts like you can see on other support services and Community Services they have their net $50,000 range and they're at 20% whereas basic programs you're seeing like a million dollar change and that's only a 2% change so just keep

219in mind the the bigger the expenditure line the um the less impact the change is going to make on that percentage um also included in your board packet you have the executive sum um that's going to give you a little more detail about the information that we use to um produce the changes and kind of make the predictions that we're um using um I'm not going to go line by line but I did want to highlight some um some of the big items that we're seeing um so you'll notice that the budget surplus did change from just under 600,000 to around 150,000 that is a net change of all of the things that were changed in the budget so it'll be the revenue changes the expenditure changes as well as the transfers in and transfers

220out um one of the biggest Chang changes that we saw were um the 147c allocation that we received um this is a pass through allocation that the state provides to us so the state will give us money in our state aid allocation and then return the office of Retirement Services send us sends us a bill so the um impact that we're seeing this year is the revenues went down but so did the corresponding expenditures so it looks like a big number but the net change was Zero for that impact um you'll also notice that the beginning fund balance has been adjusted to reflect the audit in um when we presented the original budget we had had our annual audit yet that happens in September so um that that budget line or I'm sorry that line

221in the budget has been updated to reflect our automed financials for um P 24 um and then again the explanations that we're providing are for those changes that are over $100,000 um so some of the revenue changes um the revenue budget is just over $103 million uh we did see a decrease of just under $3 million and one of the biggest driving factors of that is that 147c money so you'll see that as a common Fe throughout the changes in your executive summary because that is going to hit many many lines thousands of lines um another thing that we um recognized is that when we did the original budget we anticipated a foundation increase of $253 per people um we recognized 0 per people so that was um a change that we had to update

222um the federal Source Revenue did decrease a little and I just want to explain that um when we received money to grant funding we have to close the revenue in the year that we receed or that we uh recognize the expenses so the Esser and the ad grant were both multi-year grants so once we had our final audit numbers for fisal 24 some of the expenses we anticipated going in 20 in um 25 ended up being in 24 so we had to put the revenue in 24 so it looks like there's a decrease in funding but it was just a swing to the prior year um the change in the other Revenue other source Revenue uh we did have some changes in some transfers in and transfers out from the other funds so um we

223are looking to transfer money capital projects fund and then we also have indirect cost that we charge to our other funds like community services and food service and that indirect cost is used to offet the expenses for um things like Business Services HR curriculum and all those things that we don't directly post R for those um the expenditure budget like I said we decreased Revenue we also decrease the expenses um so I outlined a few of the the big ones that we've um see that we see the change like I said again the 147c is one of the biggest factors so that um every every expenditure category we have has salary infringes in it so every category was hit by that um that categorical um like I said the other support Serv and the community

224services you're saying that those numbers the net impact or the net change is a small number but it's a big impact to those percentages just because the amount in that line is so much smaller so I know that was a question that came through from the board did that explanation provide what you're looking for yeah okay um okay so the other funds that we have um the community service special Revenue fund is the fund that we used to track our child care program um this program received um a substantial increase in funding this year as part of the free preschool for all initiative um coming from the state so um an Rob our director of um Child Care was able to open three new classrooms and expand three classrooms um so while she received additional

225Revenue she also is experiencing additional expenses for those um she did have some one time um expenses to get those programs started so there were things that needed to be purchased such as furniture and teaching supplies the curriculum for the programs so those expenditures were increased as well as um their salary and fridges to be able to sta the building or St the classrooms um the Food Service special Revenue fund um that also had um change in the expenditures that is reflecting the um kitchen you know that you haven't um officially approved that yet but we did put it into the budget because we're anticipating that that cost is going to be more accurate than what we had in the original budget um a few things that came up in the finance committee meeting that

226I want to talk about later um the Food Service fund has um aness fund balance and part of the reason why that fund balance is so large is because um the free um free meal program generated more Revenue than what we would normally recognize if we were Charing our families so that meant that Cy was able to put more money into the fund balance um the state recognized that that was a common theme across many districts in the state and they are requiring them to do a spend down plan so they're allowed to have in their G or I'm sorry in their fund bance they're allowed to p 3 months of operating expenses and anybody that's in excessive bu that that um cap they need to have a spb plan um submitted to the state

227Patty's spb plan includes the capital expenses that we have asked for approval for the kitchen and then also the um improvements that she made to the midle School uh we need to be careful to use that spend down plan with onetime expenses because although we think for Prem meals for everybody is going to be WR forever it might not be so we want to make sure that we're not extending into um expenses that we can't maintain in the [Music] future and then the um capital projects fund um there was an increase in the revenue based off of what we had originally budgeted that is um Mr Fitzgerald worked to setc to get uh insurance settlement so that was the revenue that we recognized from the insurance settlement that we received from s so that is

228included in the amendment and then also again like the kitchen renovation that has that been approved I believe it's on the agenda be approved tonight those expenses for the boilers are also included in this um this amendment because of the anticipation that those are going to be recognized this year that is all I have is there any questions I just want to say John as I under my 10 minutes was timing me to make sure that I was faster than he was last week at the last meeting on his Finance 101 excellent job thank you very much does anybody have questions or comments for Courtney I just want to say that I really really appreciate the level of detail that you guys provide us in the executive summary it makes it so much easier to

229digest and understand so really appreciate that great work you all right yeah all right yeah and J are you talking about the thank you so also on the agenda is the two B awards that we first read last meeting so will be second meeing and request for approval um one perating to boilers boilers at the OIC facility and one for Lakeville um it's might a little followup there's a question on warranties and how that's set up we working with then there was a oneyear warranty on the labor and installation fees for all the units and then there's a 10e limited warranty for all un as well and then also there is the the kitchen renovation fit award that we spoke to last week as well uh we did work with some of the plans on

230that and did a preemptive adjustment to the the outside the overall scope of the project so in terms of we're still asking for the same authorization level but we think we're going to get it down 1,000 B some some uh equipment changes and alterations along those lines um we can if you'd like can amend amend the dollar amount but or just authoriz and number any any questions any additional questions anyone you a question um I had a question that was regarding the Middle School schol if we had an update on the um continual rental of the machinery and yeah we had the the insurance firms been out the review they've authorized or approved Insurance event so now we're in the process of identifying um the plan for repair putting a budget to that feing it

231back to insurance people that also moving forward with it we're going to treat it under the Visions in terms of purchasing um the other point the underlying cause has been brought forward with that in the main if you picture there's a huge main power transformer out on Lakeville Road com back behind Lakeville Elementary feed all way back through um three4 of the way it's in a casing prop casing last qu of the way into the building it's which referred to as old school barel it's just cable there a break there and also the tree has grown up right over the top of it so one of the ti is going to be extending the casing all the way through there reparing the braks extending the casing we're looking at conceptual approaches to how to get

232a new Transformer plant probably next to the site because it's the the the actual existing equipment so out of date that kind of thing so it's going to be a a new formation of a plan to do it we're still a to get it done in six weeks two months um we're also looking at measuring the actual flout amps we're using on the generator we may be swapping head on the smaller unit to start cutting back on that we we cost there's also a very Dynamic fuel usage so that cost also would come down so it's still it's moving forward um just an unfortunate timing of everything uh but it'll get fixed and we'll probably a new model I'll probably be talking two months saying that it's all going them talking less than two months

233it's all back to normal it's still been on the state to sign off and stuff but we'll be under the emergency done um sorry just one follow to that is um you said the insurance company said it's an insurable event yes so therefore the money that we've spent thus far will we be able to recoup that uh we'll recoup some I'm not sure I'm going to get the details of an insurable event but to what exact coverage I don't know if it's going to be dollar dollar there's a dedu involved and so we're going to the the ideal is Jordan funding that so all right thank you soon as we get that soon as I get that clarified what they not cover thank you any else thank you all right thank you John would anybody

234like to make a motion I can do that move to approve the bid Awards as presented support Shane thank you any discussion all those in favor any opposed Sarah Beth nay thank you all right motion carries moving into Allison School of Choice any additional questions for Allison and see any this week okay anybody like to make a motion I can move to approve the first schools of choice for fall of 2025 as presented support Mike Whitney thank you any discussion all those in favor I any opposed motion carries thank you Alison all right moving into schedu thank you all right we'll move into Renee upam good evening uh an the letter to Governor Whitmer serves no purpose how dare you as evidenced tonight this district will spend hours talking about the correct terminology for mission

235statements and themes yet spend zero hours talking about the worst thing that ever happened in this District James I have never seen you stand up more than when you stand up for putting obstacles up for families trying to get accountability that is about the only time I see you fight for something just a reminder please address I don't understand it I don't understand this board thank you for those of you that did stand up for the letter you talked about kids today students today what you owe them okay you owee my student you owe the 1600 that were in the building that day you owe the four Families how convenient to forget them your little core values uh slideshow Todd mentioned accountability the students should show accountability I'm a teacher I ask that of my

236students every day I'm sorry can't do it you have to take that out when you're not willing to show it yourselves it's hypocritical I haven't been here in a while and I'm totally reminded tonight why I sat coming I don't understand your thinking your arguments were dim I don't respect them if you have a better idea where have you been where have you been for 3 years we've been here we've been waiting we've been advocating we've been looking for a solution here's a solution a letter a letter stick it in the mail there's your solution you haven't come up with anything better send the letter outside of Oakland County the way this district has handled the shooting is a joke and this is why my son was home from college this weekend I told him

237a little bit about what's going on with the district I told him I was coming tonight he's like Mom they're not going to listen he knows his friends know you owe them as much as you owe the students here now thank you Renee Corey Vander okay so I came um originally to speak on another topic and so if I have uh more time I'll go back to that um I also find it very disgraceful that you would suggest that the victim should not pull Focus From the current students shame on you for your indecisiveness and making a crucial decision because one sentence was changed which raises serious concerns for me about your ability to handle the EOP tonight you also pointed out that it the issue took up 20 minutes of time and I can't

238help but wonder why you impeded the issue instead of read the letter or sentence and send it within that 20 minutes you could have done that this request to approve a letter to the governor is still very relevant my kids are going to be here for another five years well one of them will be here for another five years so I am very invested in this in this school in this community the request to approve the the letter to the governor is still very relevant and must be addressed promptly we have a moral obligation to advocate for all students who were here on November 30th even um or especially for those we lost especially for those that were shot especially for those that were in close proximity and it just keeps going out you discussed

239the OVA and nonresident students extensively yet you say an investigation is irrelevant to the current student population and you specifically mentioned resident students it is evident that you miss Atchinson and I'm I don't know if I'm allowed to address you are completely disconnected from the impact I apologize and you can strike that or whatever uh your completely disconnected a person on the board is completely disconnected from the impact of the tragedy your actions display a lack of empathy towards the most vulnerable members of our community I think you've demonstrated tonight why an investigation is necessary so that's um what I have to say to you in response to um the governor's letter tonight um I originally came here because um we've been receiving email Communications from OMS that I think are um I don't uh

240I want to say they're they're lacking in um some important information um if you don't mind I could just go for one more minute try to wrap up I know I'm completely um I'm I don't know I'll have to come back I just I I think that the tone of the messages need to reflect this severity of the situation I think I'll just wrap it up right here in the explanations in the emails that you've been sending out I think it's time to provide a clear succinct explanation of the incident this explanation should be honest um honesty does not mean revealing every detail we understand that you can't tell us information such as names of individual students however minimizing or distorting the facts of what happened will only create mistrust and doubt which I have

241among those receiving the messages if the school is at fa you know apologize um immediately as needed but however I just would like to know we've we've had three uh Communications sent out from Ms about one was about a threat another was about a student who fell um and then there was another one about an okay to say um message and the communications that were sent to the parents didn't tell us what was what was done to a student who made a threat I guess like what I want is I want an email sent to the whole school community that tells us what happens if a student makes a threat are they suspended what is the consequence I don't think there's a c a clear um message that the school has sent on on what

242happens if a student makes these these threats okay thank you I don't know thank you I think we would all appreciate if you would email or maybe give us some I know you didn't have enough time to wrap up but um we're we're happy to listen and it sounds like at our next in March we'll have open time before two and I would love to have dialogue so thank you again all right I am going to float something here by the board um that maybe we do not go into a close session this evening to discuss the EOP and that instead in order to give it the time and attention and brigh eyed bushy tailed thoughts that we would have at not 10 o'clock at night um that everybody would make a an appointment with

243Allison to review the EOP on their own time and for as much time as the as they need and that we reschedule this closed session after everybody has had a chance to do that and I think it would be a little bit more productive what are your thoughts on that are we time barred by anything that needs to get approved we have until April agree okay so according to Robert's Rule would be next next meeting the intent would be and there there are a few things we'll need to think about and um so we have a few options because we had discussed a potential Clos session at the next meeting for a separate matter and so depending on our agenda how we create that how long that will be uh that is another option to

244add to that close session alternatively we could call a special meeting and just come here to just go into close session and do the EOP starting at a more reasonable time um that's another option and a third option is if our agenda and close session at the next meeting are still going to lead us well into the night um that we potentially do it on the first March meeting still giving us you know enough time to approve by April obviously that I think would be my least desirable option um but what I would really like is everybody to to be able to really sit with it really digest it ask all the questions that you need and and have a better understanding than we'll probably get you know 10 o'clock at night yeah I mean

245I agree um maybe able to knowing Alison's busic schedule as well maybe able to do blocks some blocks we multiple of us oh absolutely I think that would make it easier so I planned on not taking Monday off it's our midwinter break but I was going to be here so we can easily talk about like that or even mesday perfect thank you for that that would obviously within the next week or so make sure we're down yeah yeah ideally I would like everyone if uh so what we can do Justin can you work with Allison to get blocks of time to recommend for the board um and then we can send invites and if you can attend great if not there'll be other options like we've done with various scheduling events will that work Allison

246Justin okay thank you thank you okay so according to Robert's Rules as long as nobody objects to me proposing that we we don't make the motion to go into Clos session we are good to keep moving forward are there any objections thank you all right we'll get that plan more formalized like I said and get a handle on that um so thank you everybody we have some scheduled activities uh as Allison mentioned the midwinter break which may not be a break for some people it sounds like and uh uh any administrative clarification no any final board comments no okay it is 1011 this meeting is adjourned thank you for coming

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.