001good evening everyone welcome to the January 28th 2025 Board of Education meeting sure thing could you please stand for the [Applause] pledge to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all [Applause] thank you James would you take attendance yep president geez o p president mcdna here vice president ald yes uh secretary Summers here treasury Whitney here trusty Edon here trusty Sarah Beth here and trusty Gibson here I will work on your last name tonight I don't know all right item number two changes to the board agenda I do have one uh I would like to move to add item 7B policy committee to the agenda could I get support yes M aldred thank you any discussion
002what what is this for just an update or we're not doing any first readings tonight right we would be doing a first reading tonight we just had policy committee okay prior to this that I have a problem with that because you guys just did it and I would be reading like off the cuff and trying to find out what you guys looked at and stuff and I don't I don't like that that's just similarly to people coming up and presenting that night and having us vote on it I know it's a first reading but I don't I don't think that's right um I don't think we've have we ever done that in the past okay um that's fine no I think as Ryan still here because that's okay with this law if we did first
003reading the law will go into effect on February 21st either way so we still have two meetings on February 21st you said the laws effective February 21st so we'll have everything in operation and then we'll adopt is it um it would be the 25th that we would adapt so we'd have the first reading before then it would go into operation and then we would essentially ratify or approve the policy afterwards okay all right yeah I I yeah and I might be a solo person on that I just that's my feelings and my thoughts on the discussion especially because it looks is it multiple Pages it is there it's not a 01 it's straight from TR reflecting the law change for Michigan earned sick time okay and I completely respect that yeah I respect that opinion
004is it uploaded in board book right now or not even in board book for us to look at so it's on policy it's not even in our board book for this okay yeah I I stand with what I said I don't feel comfortable doing that today but okay that's me okay well we do have a motion so would anybody else like to discuss though before I agree with okay so I guess my only question is this if it is a law that regardless of what we decide or not decide it's not a choice we're not electing we're not trying to create something right correct now regardless of what we do this happens yes and there's no major impact because we're already in some cases over emphasizing the guidelines in some cases yes so we're already
005above the meeting requirements that are being enacted by this law for the majority of our employees yes and we'll have everything in place um for the go live on the 21st and then the policy will just follow on the thank you for the clarification okay that's helpful yeah I'm absolutely good if we push this one to the next meeting so that to move it or you going to do that yes we can just vote on the motion now we can just vote now we can either withdraw the motion can withdraw yeah you can withdraw it or we can vote and either way okay I'm sensing unless anyone has any other opinions I'm s I'm sensing that we could just withdraw to me a first reading but I'm not like we need to have the first
006reading so doesn't matter just withdraw the motion okay I'll just with I'll withdraw the motion okay sounds good thank you all right moving on to school presentations we have Mr Jeff Brown um good evening uh my name is Jeff Brown I have been the Principal of Oxford Elementary School going on 16 years um at the Point um I am excited to share on behalf of all the people that you see on that screen behind me today um I guess I get the big picture as principal but there's 40 additional staff members that are in that picture standing behind uh if you look closely at that picture I feel that picture is a pretty good representative of who we are as a staff uh if you notice you'll see Katie uh dressed as an elf uh
007for those of you that have children at OE when you did your drop off uh that week you noticed that Katie was on the roof outside the school and her elf in the Shelf outfit if you look really closely at that picture you will also notice that we're all in our pajamas um we did do the underground spirit week uh leading up to vacation in December and so you can see just great staff participation and while we of course have incredibly serious jobs um part of our job is making sure that kids are happy and comfortable and it's a fun environment where people want to be and I think that picture does a pretty good representation of who we are as a collective group um I know that you're coming to visit OES in late
008February but I wanted to take another minute and just tell you a little bit more about our building um we are made up of 13 uh traditional Home Room classes uh you can see our number of students for our enrollment um over my 16 years at OE this is on the lower end of where our enrollment has been um we have at one point approached 500 students within the building and we're a little bit more on the downside um I live in Waterstone um I'm opt Mystic as I look around my neighborhood that I'm seeing more little people running around and I'm seeing some of the people that are my age starting to like kind of get out of there a little bit and so hopefully those numbers are headed in a in a growing
009Direction uh we also have three resource rooms in our building and this is our first year having a classroom for children with more severe autism um and so we we're growing and changing and even though we're smaller we don't seem to ever have any vacant rooms they always seem to get filled um with something unique or something special or something interesting when I presented to you last year um it was a little bit later in the school year and so we were actually presenting our goals for this year and so I thought it would be appropriate as part of our presentation tonight to give you some updates um sort of on where we are uh the number one thing that I presented to you last year was our attendance numbers um on the next page
010after this you'll actually see the data but I wanted to give you a reminder of some of the things that we're doing to increase attendance over the course of this year um first and just most basically our classroom teachers are reaching out to the families when the kids get to five absences um the relationship between the family and the teacher I think is the most important one that we have in our building and so for those families to hear from the teacher right out of the gate when attendance is becoming a potential concern um kind of one of the most basic things that we could do to keep families engaged with attendants um the second one is historically and we've done this the time I've been in Oxford parents get letters about attendance when they
011have 10 15 and 20 absences prior to this year we would send those letters on a monthly basis so for example if a child missed their 10th day at the beginning of the month and we just run those reports we wouldn't be running another round of those reports for a month um Believe It or Not There were actually times where a child would go from 10 to 15 within that span and then we're stuck as a main office do we send the 10 letter do we send the 15 letter we don't know which is appropriate and it always caused a lot of difficulty um one of the things that we've truly appreciated in our buildings is getting that extra halftime secretary in our main office it's made a lot of things easier and more efficient
012one of the benefits to that is we now send an email the minute the kid hits the 10 15 and 20 absence so there's no more lag um in that system anymore which I think is helpful for families I think that immediate notification is important the other thing that it's allowed us to do we used to do attendance meetings anytime a family would hit 15 between the family schoola on myself sometimes classroom teacher social worker other trusted adults that were involved and the way we used to do those is we would take a day every month or two and we would go through those meetings but that also meant that there was a delay or lag sometimes with having those we now do our best to schedule those as quickly as possible typically within a
013week of when that 15 letter goes out and I think that's another piece that helps um just to make sure that people are aware as in as timely way as possible the other piece that I presented to you last year um I'm not sure I don't have students in the office or in the audience so I'll use attendance Club is what we're calling it with adults um Pizza Club is what we call it when we do meet with uh children we identified kids who for the last two years had missed 15 or more um days so that's a pretty considerable uh amount of absences uh one of the challenges with Elementary School school kids is they're not always the ones that are responsible for getting themselves to school sometimes they're at home because a parent
014couldn't get them there sometimes they might have overp because they were the only one there um so attendance it for my 8 n 10 and 11 year olds is often times at least a little bit outside of their control and so you might wonder why we're calling it Pizza Club when it's something that kind of has a negative um you know sort of connection to it but our main points are if you Google how to increase attendance right now you get almost nothing um it's all over the place there's nothing concrete if there was a concrete plan we would be doing it at Oxford Elementary School um right now but one of the things that's consistent in the literature is making kids feel connected making them feel welcome um Pizza makes it fun um and
015so it gives them a reason to smile uh when we show up in their class to pull them out for it um we're trying to kind of keep it quiet we didn't know if kids would be embarrassed if they were part of it and they jump out of their seat and they're happy that they're going to Pizza Club once they get there um there's a few different things that happen first we sit down in a circle and we just check in you know how's it going welcome we're happy to have you here today uh the second thing that happens is Miss overh hold our family school liaison does a lesson with them um the example that I put up there has to do with circle of control so for example if I wake up tomorrow
016morning and I'm sick I don't really have a whole lot of control of that if I choose to stay up late tonight and I play fortnite and I'm really tired when I wake up tomorrow morning I do have some some control of that and so we sat in the circle there were a whole bunch of sentence strips that were cut up with different examples like that kids would draw one explain whether they thought it was in their control or out of their control and then put it back into the circle so we want to make sure that there's an instructional component to each one of these meetings the last thing that the kids do is the kids are tracking their attendance this year um our goal is to have them Miss less than 15 days
017this year obviously our goal is for them to miss way less than 15 days this year but we also wanted kids to be successful most of the kids that are on this list to be completely transparent didn't just miss 15 days we have a lot of kids in this group who have historically missed 20 plus days and so while 15 isn't an incredibly High bar it is a pretty decent improvement from where some of these kids have been um so I want you know that we are doing some things to tackle that issue from last year and if you take a look most of this data was presented to you last year uh you can see that 1819 so we're going pre pandemic with that attendance rate you can see our Rock Bottom so this
018is both post pandemic and post 30th um that is our worst number that I can present to you um I included last year's number just because I presented it to the board last time and I wanted to make sure that sat there and then you can see our rate um as of mid December for this year and so when you look at it it's it's about a 1.3% improvement from last year to this and I don't know I mean if you got a 1.3% raise you'd be happy with it but it wouldn't be life altering but 1.3% in this context is pretty significant um that represents 827 student days um that represents almost 5,000 instructional hours which I think is pretty significant and if we're to continue this pace over the course of the year
019the average change for all students in the building would be 2. seven less absences over the course of the year and I'm pleased to say and I hope this number holds true if you look at the students who are participating in the attendance Club um it'll be a little bit over four potential impact and so this is based on projections um I just did a quick multiplier to get from where we were in December to what I'm hoping it'll be at the end of the year and so my fingers crossed the or cross that that'll hold true um but it looks like a promising Trend and so I hope that we're headed in the right direction with what we're trying to accomplish attendance and the main reason I wanted to keep putting in attendance before
020in front of you is personally I feel like it's the main thing that's impacting um this next slide uh we have a lot of good teachers in our district we have tremendous teachers at Oxford Elementary School but they are not so good that they can teach kids when they're not there it's just not possible um so the second piece that I wanted to show you today was a little bit of our history of where Oxford Elementary School is at um academically and so I used the same years that uh were used for the attendance um and so just to make sure it was kind of an Apples to Apples piece so if you look back to 2018 um you can see the first set of scores are Oxford Elementary School in bold uh you have
021the county and then you have the state um across the board in both reading and math um for all of the grade levels you can see in 20189 with the exception of one spot in fifth grade ELA we are exceeding or tied with the County and state um in the I don't know quick math in my head here the 12 years that I've been at Oxford Elementary you know prior to pandemic that is very representative of what Oxford Elementary School looked like um I can guarantee you that it's been less than five times in my whole career at Oxford Elementary that we had any mstep score that was below the state average and very rarely is it happening below the county average um unfortunately when you fast forward to that 2122 year um again we
022are coming post pandemic post tragedy um this for us I hope is rock bottom and it'll definitely be Rock Bottom at least in my career um you can see that we are below the county in several areas at that point uh you can see that we are even with the state there may be one in there someplace that is even below the state at that exact moment in time um but again the good spin to that is if you fast forward to last year's mstep scores you're able to notice that we are back to being above the county and state in almost every area which I think is a great sign uh everybody's talking about are we back where are we going and it's nice to see that we are very much headed um in
023the correct direction I want to take one minute to explain what you see in yellow and then what you see in blue so even if you look at what I'm calling the Rock Bottom in the 2122 in yellow the kids that are highlighted in yellow in 2122 are the same students that are there in the fifth grade piece and so if you notice for example in the third grade ELA those children were below the county average and barely above the state average but if you fast forward a couple years in their careers they are now exceeding the county and the state by the time they left as fifth graders so even that group that came in certainly lower than we would have liked they finished headed in a fantastic Direction and that same thing can
024be said for the math um the other piece that you notice with the math that's in blue you'll notice that the state average changed considerably from how many kids were passing in third grade to how many kids were passing in fifth grade but the Delta between us in the county and us in the state increased for that group in math as well which I think is a great positive thing and I think it shows that over the course of those few years not only were kids starting to recover and get back closer to normal um I do think we have to be honest with ourselves uh some of this was adult generated it was kind of hard to be at school some of these days um I know our adults came and gave it maximum
025effort but it wasn't always easy and I think some of this has to do with the recovery of adults and some systems in place as well U but beyond the emotional piece there were some other things that were added in this window that I do feel like really impacted um academics at Oxford Elementary School so one of the things at a tier one level and increased importance was placed on word study ad phonics even in the Upper Elementary grades prior to pandemic that would not have been a high priority at Oxford Elementary School that wouldn't have been an area that bubbled up in our data as being one of concern um with some of the challenges for instruction in that time per in that time period phic based instruction was something that became a little
026bit more of a focus um the tier 2 level so children who are being pulled out of their classroom for assistance we added wind time during that time period I know several administrators of you know made presentations on the win time the short version of that is what I need it's a 30-minute period that happens every day where no new classroom instruction is happening and so all of our children that need reading and math support get pulled within that 30 minute window that also lessens the load on the number of kids who are actually in front of the classroom teacher as well and so that those students are able to get a little bit more of what they need during that time period as well and so that was launched um I believe three years
027ago which Falls very much in line when we started to see some improvement we've always had great reading teachers in Oxford we've also always had great pullout reading teachers in Oxford but over these last few years we've gotten smarter at the medicine that we've been giving to kids um a lot less one-sized fits-all and a lot more prescriptive based on all the great assessments that we have to really make sure that that 30 minutes that the kids are outside of the classroom it's targeted very precisely at what they need um I know you've heard what irips are and all the reading plans and I think this is a result of that that we were able to really Target um specifically where kids are at that moment in time um and the last thing I just
028wanted to do a quick plug for um when the pandemic came we stopped doing our big research paper along with fifth grade exhibition fifth grade exhibition has still been a great thing but the rigor was reduced just a little bit from not doing that report I'm excited to share that we're going to be doing the reports again with this year's fifth graders um I think it's an important part of that process I think it definitely raises the rigor quite a bit um and I also wanted to share uh because I haven't seen you since pre um pre- exhibition uh We've added an art show to that uh and so if you also noticed uh we had art that was out in the community last year in the springtime and carried into the summertime and so
029we're really working on spreading the word and the action of what our kids are doing within exhibition um to really push and make that a bigger part of not just what we do with the school because it's always been a huge deal at school but to make it a little bit bigger deal in our surrounding Community I think that these four data points really go along very well with everything that you've heard so far tonight in terms of us being back us setting a high bar being proud of the building where we are um if you look at the 2023 data those are all data points that have been presented to you before as being things that we were proud of what I'm even more proud of is if you look at the 23 24
030data all of our areas that we were proud of before got better I think that's a pretty neat thing and in terms of talking about are we back and where are we at in recovery the fact that we have 90% of families rating their OES education is high saying that expectations are high saying that students are challenged by their school work that's definitely one of the main things that we're all about and it makes me happy to see that not only our families recognize it they recognize it even a little bit more than what they were even just a year ago uh the last one is up there because that was one of the things that was presented to you also last year one of the things that we were working on was increasing parent
031involvement um as you can see 95% of families either agreed or strongly agreed that OES encourages families to volunteer um to be totally transparent we have more Volunteers in the building than at any point in the 16 years that I've been at Oxford Elementary school so not only are we back we're by far exceeding the number of volunteers that we've ever had and I wish I had like a a hard data point to like prove that to you I don't but I can tell you from the it test we have way more people in our building than what we've ever had before and not just there to watch a Halloween party we have people that are actually there making positive contributions to all the kids that are there and so we're we're incredibly proud of
032that data point so I present this because I have to we have to show you a challenge um we are not perfect at Oxford Elementary School um but I am at least a little bit proud of this one uh I know that other buildings have presented this very same data point to you before um discipline is fairly enforced I want to make sure I explain this well because I know some administrators have changed the headings at the top and so I just want to make sure that it's really clear why it's displayed this way so 50% 58% of people last year um agreed that discipline is fairly enforced so 42% not good 58% said we were doing okay with that um that number increased in the last survey to 78% of families saying they agree
033or strongly agree that discipline is being fairly enforced um but that's still 22% of families that say that this is an area of concern um I feel very confident with making the statement we're never going to make everybody happy with how discipline is enforced is just it's just not possible but we did do some very concrete things over these last couple years that I think has helped um one as a staff we've developed our Continuum of consequences and so it's never going to be perfect when adults dealing with kids but we've laid out pretty clear guidelines for what an adult response should be to a kid's issue I think that's helped a lot um our FSL level of support went from none to halftime in the building to fulltime um a lot of behavior Can
034Be Stopped if when the kids start to have a disagreement we have an adult who can be there and be present and help guide them through it it prevents the bigger things from happening that we would actually call discipline so that FSL support has been you know absolutely fantastic um I'll also take a minute with Mrs prince in the audience behind me and I know I presented a lot of the data on adding the parpro last year but being able to have that be Behavior Support par educator has also been just a a real benefit to us to have an adult that can immediately on the spot always be able to help a kid process what's going on and again sometimes sending someone to that position proactively prevents them from getting into a potentially bigger
035situation um and as you probably remember just from December when we recognized our students we have another piece that we're just now adding where we're going to have students trying to support each other uh with behavior we do take a lot of time at Oxford Elementary to make sure that we're getting and keeping track of our student voices as well uh we do the ovea survey which is that National level survey we also have our own in-house survey that we do as part of our PBIS program and so these numbers that you see here are coming from our PBIS uh number now I'd like to tell you that 100% of kids uh like coming to school every day um I wish sometimes that I had the K2 kids in the building because I think they
036would help bump that number up a little bit um and if I could just move my fifth graders to the middle school I think the numbers could be even a little bit better um but I will say as our kids get to Upper Elementary um sometimes fortnite might win out over wanting to come to school that next morning but I will say that 70% is very consistent over the last few years it's up a little bit over our 60 something percent I think that was reported out last year and so that number has been pretty consistent um I'm very proud to share that 94% of students report that we have clear rules that's something that we've been working on uh really hard over these last few years and the ultimate thing and the most basic
037thing uh 95% of students reported that adults that teachers are treating them with respect uh we do have to deal with challenging things sometimes but it can always 100% of the time be done with respect we do have some challenges that we're working on and both of these connect back to something that was presented to you last year as well um and I'm going to touch on that a little bit more in just a second um 31% of students said that they're still having trouble with with kids inviting them to play games at recess 39% of students reported that they're having a hard time solving problems on their own which is where the program that came from that I showed you on the last slide that that's what's generating the need for that um so
038last year towards the end of the year one of the things that I presented to you was the playfit recess program um if you remember playfit it was a set of organized games that we make available to kids and I'm being really careful with my language we make it available to kids kids don't have to play any of these things out there free play is still great running around the track doing their thing just hanging out and talking with buddies is still totally fine but we did take the time to bring in Kurt Henson from the playfit program at the beginning of this year we had our first games day that we've had in probably a decade where kids learned a whole bunch of games outside we launched all this at the beginning of the
039year uh we ran into a few roadblocks along the way making sure that nades were properly trained making sure that we had enough support for it outside it worked okay um but we need to do a new launch of it come springtime um you know as it's obvious when it's 10 degrees outside uh kids aren't exactly raring to go and play all these different games out there and so we have had to take a little bit of a pause here in the winter time but we are going to do a relaunch and I think that program will still very successfully address both of the challenges that you saw in that previous slide um I talked about the student L conflict groups already and Oxford Elementary School was one of the pilot schools to formally introduce
040a program for the first six days of school uh during that time we went through rules and expectations which you know the kids our kids are good but they do need all of that information but we also made sure that part of the first six days of school was all the fun stuff so it was the playfit launch it was our PBIS launch the kids made their duct tape wallets we introduced all the fun stuff that they could buy with that um the students met in circles multiple times throughout the day for those six days it was a lot of get to know you type activities um because if you like the person next to you it makes it easier to work with that person next to you and so this is actually I guess
041kind of a curriculum that we've been developed that we should be able to just roll out again next year um to help make sure that our kids are comfortable that they know what expectations are and the goal is to share that with the rest of uh the elementary part of the district here moving forward and to conclude tonight um just a fun picture but kind of a meaningful picture uh for those of you that don't know uh Miss Williams who is the dressed as Santa in the very back Center of that picture uh she retired mid year um for those of you that don't know Shany Shaney does and has done a lot of really cool things for kids over the course of her career she's never been one of those adults that's looked for
042that public recognition for that and I'm sure that there are countless stories from families and kids who would share examples that even I'm not aware of but for those of you that knew Miss Williams she's a little bit shy in front of a group I know it's not obvious from that picture um but she's always been kind of a more quiet more shy more reserved person in these type of group settings um leading up to her retirement uh I believe that we'd had maybe our first snow day our schedule had been thrown a little bit off oh no let's see I guess I'll share this why not uh one of our teachers who was supposed to run the sing along had an accident on her Drive-In and was not able to make it in that
043day and so we cancelled our school singalong that was supposed to happen on the Friday um I was not aware that Miss Williams had this plan to be dressed up as Santa Claus and wanted to do all this stuff and so I just said look there's no way we can't put together a sing along when we don't have the person with all the stuff we just can't do it and with maybe an hour and a half left in the school day um Shaney came in and said but this is what I was planning on doing this is supposed to be my last thing in front of kids and we did our best we put it together um we actually had a very fun sing along the only thing that missed was the staff skit um
044but all the rest of that day was able to happen Shaney ran around the cafeteria and jumped up and down and pumped the kids up and we made sure that we got a great picture of it but I think she's kind of one of those perfect examples of not every teacher is the face of the fr franchise they're not always the ones that are out in front getting all that recognition but even those more quiet teachers as you can tell from the smiles on kids faces we're still incredibly excited to send her off and third to fifth graders are old enough to know like what retirement means and they were excited for her and they were excited to show that and I think it's just one of those small pieces that really sums up OES
045very well and my last slide just says thank you I appre apprciate the opportunity to present to all of you um 16 years has been a while and it's been an absolute blast and it's always fun to have my moment of Fame to get to share a little bit more about OES thank you before we get to any questions I do just want to reiterate congratulations to shanie and I know you said she doesn't love the attention but I do know she loves hugs so thank you again for that congratulations uh Shaney on your well-deserved retirement did anybody have some questions from Mr Brown Shane I don't have a question I have more of a comment if that's okay um I can tell you I've never that where I grew up we didn't have volunteers
046in the schools like we have here um I'm very impressed with the way that this community steps up and volunteers at our schools to the point where I kind of get a little upset that when I go to volunteer it's already filled so I kind of feel like oh man I missed out I can't do hot chocolate you know or whatever it is so um it's amazing um you guys obviously have a very warm uh and welcoming um environment there and that gets a lot of community involvement and I love that second point if you don't mind um is uh the Paw bucks I can tell you my son the first thing out of his mouth when he comes home is how many paw bucks he got uh and when I was able to volunteer
047uh the one time it didn't get filled up on me um I was volunteering when they were able to cash their paw bucks in and I was blown away at the fact that on the iPads they were keeping track of who had how many paw bucks and I thought that was more of a recognition like oh you got the most you know you were celebrated for getting the most and one of the teachers explained to me that it was more of a tracking of who maybe didn't get as many and not as to point them out like they're deficient but how they can help raise them up and I thought that was amazing like that that warmed my heart so um thank you for all you do thank you for your staff and um just
048keep up the good work thank you anybody else I did have a couple quick ones uh on attendance Club it looks like it's for their attendance record of the two previous years right so so does that adjust for students real time that may be missing this year do you do you pull them into attendance Club as well because this was the first year that we've tried this we made the decision that the kids that were in attendance Club on day one are going to be there until day 180 this year and so we're not adding nor are we subtracting um any kids who are being successful this year I think it's something that we're going to look at next year if is it something that we want to do but just to keep it simple
049in our first year we've just stayed with the same cohort the whole way through okay be very open to that idea and something that we've talked about okay and that you said this was a monthly meeting yes and during do they leave during wi time or when what part of the day do they typically towards the end of a day on a Friday um I wish we could do it during wi time but that would mean the Miss overhal and I would have to be doing like potentially up to 13 different meetings to hit all the kidss and so the way we've typically done we've done a third grade group then a fourth grade group then a fifth grade group and it's typically been on a Friday afternoon okay so yeah they are missing a
050little bit of class time in order to get that gotcha makes sense okay I'm good well thank you again very much appreciate you being here tonight absolutely thank you so much [Applause] all right moving along scheduled public comment I didn't receive any did you no [Applause] okay and moving into the consent agenda we have minutes bills payable and HR updates can I get a motion for that James move to approve the consent agenda as presented support Shane thank you any discussion all those in favor I any opposed motion carries thank you and moving into superintendent report Dr Milligan all right thank you very much good evening everyone we have had a very busy couple of weeks um we I want to start primarily talking about the phenomenal Community Forum that we had last week um
051we started our Forum with a video because I wanted people to think about their why why are we here why do we do what we do why do we want a strategic plan [Music] and I probably have to turn this on get me every single time Aon all right so this is a video that we showed uh to start the Strategic uh planning forum and um it's our students and we had an opportunity to hear their words and think about our why so Aaron if you could play this [Music] I think that something that would describe Oxford is exciting the best thing about being an act is probably like having a strong school and a strong School District the teachers are very supportive here so the staff the schools are very very fun L school
052is amazing I'm proud to be Ro wild cat because of our strong Community the school is like all like well knit I feel super well so C I would describe oxer as being really creative and welcom how everyone includes everyone time caring princi our school district rewards people for being kind and caring there's so many people who are caring you can really be whoever you want I can just be myself I really like how our school really appreciates good behavior tiets just make you feel good there's so many open-minded people here that whatever you say won't be judged the schills are very cool like the paintings behind me and all around the lunches they're nice and like the teachers are like really nice I would definitely say we just have a great overall reputation with
053academics Sports and just a amazing learning environment and everyone's included it's a great place to find I really love the cafeteria tables that we got the dogs are my favorite part like do that and then and sometimes you can show your mom and dad and then they may be surprised so I'm glad that um I'm a DA wild cat there's a lot of different opportunities that you get to have whether it's band swim the leadership program Art Club acting all the IV units drama club AP and IV class robotics s program Early College Spanish choir musicals Sports cheering basketball I'm looking forward to a football and um band I'm very excited cuz my brother does band and I'm very excited and he does football too and I want to my brother is a very cool
054guy and yes I would love to do those two things I think we can make the schools even better by having student counsel again and getting the students opinion on what we do I would definitely approve the am lount of tutoring programs we have because I think um another thing that would be great would be like eighth graders helping sixth graders with after school tutoring programs that they could do if they actually help and I don't like how when I'm sitting at lunch I see everybody on their phone not communicate anym that's scary maybe adding somehow heaters outside in the winter I think the district can help support the students even more than they already do um by really more scholarships for college and really advertising other routes to go instead of just College I
055think kids me if we could like have separate cafeteria and um another gym like have the gym open for like IND recess especially during winter time it gets a little colder I would hope to add more fi trip opportunities like different Career Centers or different like not as welln careers see if students would like to think about those careers in the future something that I think we can do to make it improve is having teacher PA tickets so the students can nominate teachers there's the new exam policy put into place where like if you get certain absences I do feel like for seniors they should get like maybe um like days that count cuz I feel like college teers are really important and sometimes it's hard to do it on a SAT Saturday or Sunday
056a couple of things I'm hoping to keep in middle school and high school is the field trips going to C Point ma Island and DC I hope we don't go all technology but it's what's starting the be like that I hope that students coming out from the elementary schools and M schools will be able to feel like they belong and are able to participate in any of the clubs and sports that we have to offer I don't know but I think that we could do like sometimes we could like change to playgrounds and like put different things on them to make it like fun like funner something I hope that the district teams is like the mentor program for middle schoolers and like web day and like web leaders something that I really help that
057is really unique about Oxford that I really hope continues this light up Oxford with love it brings everyone together I hope that the half days never change cuz it makes people have something to look forward to at the beginning of the week I don't know what we can make SCH school pretty good mhm everything's perfect I I don't think they change just like the way as is oh this is a tough thing because I feel like this this school is very very good I feel like I can't even think any changes it's so good I hope the younger students have the same positive experience that I had and that Oxford stays the welcoming community that it is and just Mak students feel happier to come to school I love just how like the community always
058steps up for each other if it's academic social mental anything o is always there for you I think the best thing about being an Oxford wild cat is what's a wild cat always is a wild cat I feel like Oxford is like that place where you might you might have went to it but you're always a part of it so you can always go back [Music] so that's probably the seventh or eighth time I've seen that and every single time I start tearing up because the the voices our student voices are so powerful and they say such incredible things and we just need to make sure we're listening and that is a part of the Strategic plan is we need to listen to our student voices we need to lift those up during the community
059Forum we actually had several of our students on a snow day come to the community Forum so I was incredibly impressed that that happened um and then the next um well it was happened just yesterday we had our eighth graders at the high school um Miss Anita uh kanja Collins and myself were able to go there and it was so mov moving to the point where Anita came back and we were talking through it and she was just she made the connection she said this is our why this is why we do what we do so I couldn't help myself I had to put the pictures in and ask Anita to kind of speak to the eighth graders experience going to the different programs in the high school yes so on my way out yesterday
060from the high school I saw Mr Big in the hallway he's like are you okay and I was like I such a dork I am so tearing up about this experience it was so great but we had over 300 of our Rising soon to be freshman at the high school come to the high school yesterday and you can um see that they started their day with um lunch provided by the high school they started the pizza luncheon at the luncheon they were able to meet the administration the counselors the fsls and just kind of get their eyes on who works at the high school um and then after that they had 10 different sessions and rotations around the school to go to and so we didn't capture every single station but you can see they
061went into the Robotics and um megatronics I think I this is like not my Mike's like yeah thank you Mike um room where they got to see the class classroom see students in action um I followed two groups the grapes and the sizzling or dazzling watermelons they had like fruit group names um they went to they were led by OS students and there were students there showcasing what they're doing in the electives classes or the CTE classes um you can see here a student um he actually took over the teacher presentation about speech and communication he just hopped right on the stage she has in the front of her class and gave her presentation we went to the marketing class and students were working on various projects um into the auto shop the girls didn't
062really like that they were all sitting off in the corner and I said what's going on and they're like it smells really bad and there this is not for us but I'm like that's good you know that um and we went into the theater where they had um they were actually practicing for the Mary Poppins play so they got to see them and um the teachers talked to them about it's not just about acting but actually you can be in the stage crafters and build the stage being the technical part the backstage um the art teacher had pottery wheels set up um in the cafeteria so students got to Showcase that so there were again 10 different stations for the students to learn all about the various offerings um at OS and honestly the kids
063were so excited so engaged and it just I came back to Tiny I'm like my heart is like literally bursting this is why we do what we do and I'm just so proud to work in a place that has all of these offerings for kids it goes to that video um when we were doing the strategic planning um because I don't want to forget anything I think it's important to really give credit to Lisa Butz um she's our CFE uh director and Leslie flet Meer who is our career navigator at the high school they really played an integral role in putting this entire event together um and yeah it was amazing I just it showcased exactly what the kids were saying we want for our future here that's great thank you Anita and I think
064it was how long ago when was the last time we did something like this it was quite a long time ago and it has not been done Lisa said in her 14 years here so like our minds are spinning now of like how do we make sure we do this but also Mr bigal and I talk today about a potential open house for family so it's not just the kids that get to see it but can families come in and have a SAR experience so maybe that's coming not maybe in the immediate future but near future yeah that's awesome thank you appreciate that right so that just kind of brought the whole why to life it was just really incredible to have that opportunity so um so after the um Community Forum uh group had
065a chance to see the video we had lots of great dialogue we had groups of individual we mixed and matched so we had different perspectives um whether it be a parent whether it be a teacher an administrator central office um we had quite a few community members uh Lieutenant Patterson was there Chief Majestic was there and and all contributing to the dialogue and essentially the first question was what are your top three hopes and aspirations for Oxford Community Schools and just the dialogue alone was really energizing just to hear all their thoughts and ideas and here are some examples of of um things that came out of this uh they really H for student voice and student Choice um they wanted multiple Pathways which is what Anita just presented right the the various opportunities that
066kids have um mentorship you heard our one of our students talk about mentorship as well um and a safe inclusive School environment with a sense of belonging we heard Jeff talk about that sense of belonging and how critical is about students wanting to come to school if they feel they belong um so that was great I mean it was it just got so loud in there when they were having dialogue so that was really energizing and then after that um they had a chance to do a gallery walk and have additional conversation around draft vision mission and core values um they had conversation they placed group thoughts as well as individual thoughts on each of the draft um proposed vision mission and core values um and then what we did um well the the dialogue
067was around what do you like what resonates with you what do you dislike and what is missing what's is still missing in this um statement so lots of great conversation um the feed back that we received um some really great feedback um actively listening and engaged different modes of sharing ideas um different groups moving around coming back together reconnecting we had um opportunity for all voices to be heard and one of the things that is really important to me since I got here everybody's voice is important everybody's voice has value and it's critical that we hear all voices right and so I appreciated the fact that everyone who was there leaned into our Norm of lifting everyone's voice up and valuing everyone's voice so I appreciated that comment um variety of perspectives this is a
068long one but essentially you know having an opportunity to come together to engage in uh reviewing the hard work because it was hard work we we had cabinet and we had um our administrative team we did iteration after iteration after iteration and came back even for some more input right because this is really important that we get this right this isn't something you can just toss out there because this is going to be our driver this is what we're going towards and so we want to make sure that it is a clear um and well vetted um Vision so I appreciate appied this comment um that they appreciated all the hard work that had been done ahead of time um both being heard and hearing what everyone else had to say and finally the cookies
069yes we had to make sure people were wellfed and they you know Patty and her team make great cookies I do need to say that um some things that we're looking to enhance um they like the format however um we wanted to bring additional community members into the conversation and so we asked everybody to bring a friend so when we have this in again in April bring somebody right whether it be a significant other whether it be a peer a cooworker bring them to the Forum and so that we can increase the voices that are being heard um facilitators they want a little more facilitation to help the flow of conversation um in their smaller group so we're thinking about how we could structure that and then a little more time to debrief some of
070the statements and so we're thinking about how we might structure that a little bit differently um and making sure that staff has additional opportunity for input just beyond a survey so we'll have to think about what that might look like it might look like presentations during staff meetings getting additional information during staff meetings um so we'll have to think through that um and then I think we're on a good path and looking forward to seeing the plan to back up what we'll be decided on so we'll continue to present it to the community it is a um uh continuous growth opportunity and um development it's a work in progress so it was a wonderful wonderful event and then um we did send a survey yesterday there were um about 35 people who had signed up
071to give input uh in a survey we tried to mirror as much as possible the experience that people had during the actual Forum itself so that was a little tricky but I think we got kind of close um and then give them an opportunity to give input so we sent it out to those individuals but we also sent it out to individuals who may not have been able to attend because of the inclement weather and so we just wanted to give them an opportunity as well so I encourage you if you received that in your email please um send us your thoughts it'll take about 15 20 minutes but it'll be 15 and 20 minutes well worth it I promise um our next steps in this process we got to roll our sleeves up lots
072of work so we are going to be starting um next week our cabinet once we get all the feedback the feedback from the survey we need that back by Monday because starting next Tuesday our cabinet we're going to roll up our please dig into the feedback and start making those adjustments and get to a final version of that vision mission and core values so that then we can start moving on to the goals so the cabinet will be working with that feedback on February 4th um we'll again finalize that on the 11th as well as start working with our um our goals and aligned actions um sorry flip that we'll work with ad team on the 11th to give them a chance to see our final versions and then on the 19th we'll get into
073our goals and aligned actions so we go back and forth between cabinet ad team cabinet ad team um again as many eyes as we can get on it and get it to a point where when we have our next session which is April 9th that we will have some some aspect of it worked out a draft that people can sink their teeth into um and give feedback again our ultimate goal is that we have the plan finalized by June and that it's presented to the board in [Music] June so again now notice I used a spring theme this time I think I did myself in I had a winter snow theme for this one so I think that maybe I manifested that so it's you know flowers and it's going to be beautiful um so
074Wednesday April 9th similar time frame 1 to 3 and 6 to 8 um we'll send start sending out the invitations the signups in March we'll have a large window of time for people to sign up um I will need RSVP by a certain date probably by the end of March because I will have to make sure the location is appropriate for the numbers um so we'll make sure that we get that out and communicate that so thank you to everybody who participated thank you to my cabinet thank you to my ad team um who helped facilitate the dialogue and facilitate the gallery walk it was excellent so thank you all right um this past week we had some new executive orders that kind of tripped us up a little bit um that we're still trying
075to figure out um a reinstatement of immigration enforcement in sensitive locations this includes our schools um where historically that has not taken place now that has been that that safety net has been removed so we've been working very hard to better understand how we support our students in a situation like this and support our community so here are some things that we're looking into um this week and I'm hoping to have something sent out very soon um working with the policy committee making sure that our policies and procedures around furpa um which are Privacy Information around student information um that those are in place and do have solid policies around those and making sure that we are in compliance with that that's something we're pretty good at that's not we don't tend to give out
076student information outside of those parameters so I'm confident along those lines um and then working with school leadership and safety teams to make sure that we have a plan in place that they understand if ice does um come to the school what are we doing right having clear a clear plan laid out to make sure that they know that they are supported um collaborate with local law enforcement to understand their requirements um I've had conversations with Lieutenant Patterson as well as Chief so um regarding what are their roles if this were to happen if um an ice agent did come to a school or did want to um serve papers at a school and so we had a great conversation around their responsibilities and then um what this has to do with furpa making sure
077our directory information in our schools for students uh is aligned with furpa and that we're not outside of those parameters and making sure that families know they can opt out of having any student information in a school directory um so we'll be working with that as well um language access for interpretation and translation during school and after hour so I'll be working with my team with that um and then finally gain awareness of plier versus doe um this is the um this is the case that essentially sets the stage for schools to educate all students regardless of their uh immigration status we do not ask are you legal uh are you a citizen no we educate everyone in public education um and that is the case that sets that up um and finally collaborating with
078our legal team we've already been in contact with our legal team regarding um what are what is required if papers are served what are the process um and so again I'll have a clearly delineated uh course of action for these uh for this aspect um I know this really caught some people off guard I know it caught me off guard a little bit but we've had a lot of dialogue throughout Oakland County um I've worked collaboratively with many superintendent so I appreciate their input um getting to see what they're doing and how they're supporting their students and their families um so I am very appreciative of that um some safety updates that we have um we had there are several bills that have been passed um in December of 2024 um the first one is
079House Bill 495 and this is for public and non-public schools we must adopt and Implement a standardized response terminology plan good news we're already in compliance with that right we're ahead of the curve we've already adopted a standard response protocol and standard reunification method as a part of the Emergency Operations plan um another law enacted is 4096 Department of State Police shall establish a standardized response terminology plan and provide it uh to public and non-public schools um as a part of our template our EOP template we will be bringing that to the board um to review en close s session um in the not too distant future um the um the Michigan State Police office of school sta safety already adopted a standard response protocol and standard reunification method and because of that our uh
080practices are aligned and we are in compliance a few other ones is uh our uh House Bill 5549 requires schools to established threat assessment teams again we are 100% in compliance of this because of our bam teens across the district that are trained in the entac model of threat assessment so the work that we've done over the past several years is already ahead of the curve when it comes to the law the law is kind of you know behind what we're enacting so we are in great shape as far as that is concerned um House Bill 5659 and um 5660 no action are needed on our part they have to do us with a school safety commission um and that's a a state level um aspect so I just wanted to give everybody an update
081on that I know when we get new laws enacted oftentimes District have to scramble to get aligned with them we don't have to do that we're in great shape um safety updates um I talked previously about updating a response to guidepost recommendations um I'm still working on that so what's we have updated it on the website but I'm still making adjustments based on feedback so I appreciate the feedback that I've been getting um the QR code will take you to that uh guidepost update as well as as the tiny URL some of the key updates that have been reflected in this um latest iteration have to do with uh our Mass notification uh system which was updated to align with the standard response protocol which is aligned with the law so that's pretty great um
082we have threat assessment and suicide risk assessment process we also have trained multi-disciplinary teams research we use the entac which is a research based model mer our EOP which again is is going to um come to the board in a closed session to review um next month we did transition to fortnite fordus away from another agency so we uh that is a great partnership with our foris Personnel um installation of not lock nightlock sensors in restrooms and locker rooms so There's an opportunity to uh lock those spaces when before we didn't have that um and it also has a sensor so if you uh do lock that because we do want to make sure appropriate things are happening in those spaces um that there is a sensor that goes off so people know hey that
083space has been locked we need to make sure everything's okay in that area um and development and implementation of the building vulnerability assessments so all of those areas have been updated um it's not a perfect document there's 40 some odd recommendations that we try to to keep on top of um there are some areas that are just not feasible so I will um update those areas um but for the most part it's been updated and is accurate where we are currently um another thing all the kids are like Yay snow days and I do love these pictures because look how happy those boys are on the right and the girls on the sled they're just so happy um your superintendent not so happy um you know as much as I love a good snow day
084for students unfortunately we've gotten to the place where we especially at our high school um we have maxed out our um snow days so any more snow days at the high school we're going to have to figure out how we're going I know right we're going to have to figure out how we we make those up um so that's why I got a little cringy last week when when we had to call those days that was not something uh I preferred to do but as I tell people the number one thing is safety um I think someone sent me a picture of a bus that had turned over somewhere um and not too far away and that that is your superintendent's greatest fear as well as Mr Fitzgerald um this is not something we ever
085want to have happen in our school district so we want to make sure we are being cautious about getting kids to school safely so um we will start thinking about and planning how we have to make up those days if we get another snow day but who knows maybe spring is right around the corner and we won't have to worry about it yeah um due to the snow days um Oxford Got Talent was moved to March 11th so it's still happening we still get to see our kids fabulous Talent it's just going to happen a little later um so I wanted to make sure I updated that um I'm going to share some really cool things the schools put out newsletters and I get get a chance to review them and there's so many cool
086things happening in our schools I I clearly cannot show them all so I just kind of pulled out some individual things so this is at Clear Lake um the Clear Lake student council are I just thought this was such a clever title super B and they're doing a can drive um a soup can drive to donate for families in need I just thought that was so clever those kids they're so clever um as Jeff talked about at OES the awesome art happenings so kids just being crafty and having fun and being creative uh om this might have a little bit of an oo Factor here not an oo as an oo OB like ew um they had a visit from Great Lakes fishery commission and the the students were studying ecosystems and the impact of
087invasive species and they got to hold a live sea lamp Ray if you know it if you know what that looks like they are super Ooey and they have like this big round mouth full of teeth that just bite into fish and H h on there so they're they're a little slimy but look how excited the kids are to you know manhandle them so um they got to do that so that's pretty cool um that was a great activity at Leonard um Elementary we had the green team they wrote a grant for a sensory garden which is super cool and they won the Grant and so um Detroit Zoo presented a check to Mrs bensman and the Leonard group Green Team um so congratulations to them that's amazing a sensory garden I love the concept
088um and finally at the high school we have our girls bowling who are County Champions whoop whoop well done um and Chase Beal a wrestler for our high school is on his H hundredth win very impressive so those are our highlights um for the last last two weeks just a few things going on you know never a dull moment here in Oxford but showcasing so many awesome things in our district it is just such a joy to be out in our schools um and just the energy and the activities and the creativity is just phenomenal so thank you again for the opportunity to be here all right that's it for me any questions or comments for Dr Milligan Mike I do have one um the eighth grade to the high school career um have we
089I guess did we or have we thought about opening that to the eighth graders of OVA and giving them maybe more exposure to that in person because some of them like I mean for us personally we just kind of I mean we do what's works best for our kids right and so I think some of that exposure certainly seeing you know the shop and the robotics lab and whatnot I know we can like from the from a club standpoint we can be involved in all of it right but from like autoshop have we thought about in inviting those kids I mean I don't know what the take rate would be but it would be interesting yeah I think it definitely would and especially if we end up having like an open house that Anita spoke
090about um send it to the families that they could bring their kids up to see what what is offered um so as Anita mentioned this isn't something we've done for some time now so the feedback is really helpful and something to think about thank you anyone else well I just want to say thank you again for the strategic planning session I think for all of us who attended from the board we really found a lot of value in it and appreciate all the hard work you and your team have put into that thank you so I wanted to say thank you to them loved the eighth graders going into the high school I heard from multiple parents at CTE classes were huge hits and they were so cool and excited to be at so great
091job with that uh and then I just had the one question regarding the guide poost update I know you had discussed about potentially I don't want to get into all of that tonight as it's a living document but having potentially a forum for that yeah thank you for bringing that up um so it has been recommended that we have a community safety Forum um and just to have dialogue right so no super strict structure or anything just you know having people have an opportunity to talk through um things that they appreciate about our safety protocols things that you know they'd like to see changed concerns that we still have um and so one of the suggestions was at one of the upcoming board meetings having some time um ahead of the board meeting where families
092could come um especially if we have a presentation at that school right so I don't I don't know who is on the next um I know OA is presenting next and then we have another school presenting so I'll have to see who's presenting but I'd like to have it at that school so we might change the location so instead of being here at Lakeville it could be at the school who's presenting um and then we could have the safety Forum ahead of that board meeting um to give U families a chance to see the school have the conversation talk through some safety pieces and then they could stay for the board meeting that' be amazing but thank you for bringing that up definitely um look at for uh look for some communication regarding that opportunity
093thank you fantastic thank you yeah are you also presenting on field trip okay yep we are we have one field trip request um it is our leadership um Team um at the high school uh the Le uh the uh adviser is Emma shriber they are looking to go to Grand Rin for a conference for a leadership conference uh from February 22nd through the 25th and the details of the the trip the opportunities for students um is to network with other uh student leaders around the state engage in team Builders connect uh connection activities breakout rooms and hear from keynote speakers um it's and the um adviser says that it's an extension of the classroom and inspires students to be leaders at their own school and organization so it's a wonderful opportunity um for our students
094so I'm just presenting it tonight um and to have an opportunity to vote on it at the next meeting thank you did anyone have questions regarding that field trip okay we will vote on the next meeting for that moving along to board matters we have our board leadership code we as you remember last time looked that over we're now at the point where we can move to adopt it if everybody is comfortable so can I get a motion James yeah move to approve or excuse me move to adopt the 2025 board leadership code AS presented support Mike Whitney thank you any discussion all those in favor I any opposed motion carries um I just need to get signatures from everybody before we disperse tonight on The Forum thanks thank you James all right up next
095our finance and operations Mr Fitzgerald John would you like this yeah yeah [Applause] so I want to apologize up front if I have my back to anybody I'm trying to flip some note Pages as I can go as well clicker is going to help with that there we go so um first of all we're gonna we're looking at some um Baseline Public School Finance issues from a 30,000 foot view so I'm counting on Dr Milligan to pull me out of the weeds if I drift off into something so as as we keep moving along with that said this can't take more than two maybe three hours tops to get through this whole slow show uh not really that see that was that was Finance humor I mean look at the shot on but all right
096so these would be the uh the items we want to touch on as we uh go through the presentation so we'll be uh looking at primary funding sources for public schools in general what makes that up what's and the big pieces of it such as the school aid fund and the foundation allowance model and which is came on board in the mid99s and it's the basics of how that works and where local property taxes and state school aid all come come together in that piece um also from a revenue and expenditure budget basics of the budget and really when I'm talking to this I'm really have the general fund in mind we've got we use multiple fund structures the single largest is our general fund by and far the largest and that's the one that's
097really in mind when we're talking through this these slides so with with that in mind um we'll end up in the end looking at a overview of some millage stuff School bonds syncing funds all that kind of stuff how how that interplays in the school U operating world and then a quick 30,000 foot view at some of the programming that this District runs that that is above and beyond our base programming that goes on in the quote quote unquote seated environment um and with that we will get started with what are the primary revenues that actually fund a school district so the first and foremost is I'm sure everybody's heard the expression the per pupil Foundation allowance so that's a model that in the next slide or so we'll get a little deeper into but
098that's the single biggest funding source in our district our general funds roughly $100 million a little bit a little bit higher maybe 75 million of it is produced through this calculation the balance of the funding comes from federal state and local grants and when I say State it's there's state aid funding that feeds the foundation allowance and then there's state aid funding that we call categoricals that's another form of a state Grant so that's a little different than the actual state aid piece intermediate Source funding and that's funding that really comes through um the intermediate District structure in the state um in our case at through Oakland schools and p8 funding is is the name the common name for Special Ed funding that's dist distributed to all the local districts within Oakland schools boundaries um
099Oakland schools itself levies that tax and then distributes the funding to the local districts based on an established formula and then the other the infamous other sources of funding those are really things like investment Revenue rental fees um transfer res is another kind of it's a name used driven by the Michigan public school accounting manual that's really money moved from One Fund to another that's related to indirect costs and things like that so that's that's on the edge of getting the weeds and that's all I'll touch on that piece um by the way if you have any questions please please ask as we go um so this with respect to the foundation allowance funding piece there's really two big pieces that fund that state aid piece and then the local property tax that the district's
100Levy that's the 18 Mills that get levied on the quote unquote non-homestead properties that's predominantly businesses within the District so these are the different funding sources that actually fund the state's school aid fund that turns around funds the local District's Foundation allowances so this is from fiscal year 23 so it's a little dated on this uh breakout of the major pieces of the funding sales and use tax has always been number one federal revenue because it's FAL year 23 is number two because there's still a lot of covid related funding running through the State pre 2019 it would probably be in the fourth position the other big piece is state income tax the set property tax and I kind of you see the word set that's short for and that's actually the language that shows
101up on most people's property tax bills it's the school education tax and I want to be clear on this piece this goes directly to the state it does not come to the local public schools only the 18 Ms tied to local business and non-homestead property comes directly to us and then there's funding that the school aid fund gets related to the state lottery funds and that's really the net profits of the whole state lottery program they fund about 6.2% of the uh of the whole school aid bucket so to speak all others about 8.5% and those are those really tiny little slices that the one would it go up there 8.5 up there miscellaneous that you can if you got a desire to look I can show you where to find the other 50 million
102little tiny things that kind of trickle into the the big pot and one is the state aid fund so I've used the phrase Foundation allowance a couple of times now I I like this kind of picture it's got a bucket in it though and I think in a previous board meeting I'd used a water bottle as the example of what the foundation allowance representative so I thought I'd shake things up you know it's Finance this means shake up for us we'd use a bucket right so if that bucket represents the foundation allowance for the year we're in the fiscal year 25 and that's $968 per 1.0 student FTE the FTE is an acronym for full-time equivalent student FTE does not equal student headcount student headcount is usually a bigger higher number the equivalency piece is
103a way of calculating students as if all students 1.0 FTE for a student is is equal to one student in school for a 6-hour day set of programming so that said we may have um a mix of some homeschool kids that come for some non-core classes here and they're doing homeschool programming so they're counted as a fraction of an FTE but the numbers you see and what we get paid on they do this math with it and that's going on in our enrollment area Barb does a great job with it it's a it's a uh it's a it's a master degree in itself to understand the way it's all put together but so once you figure out um the pieces that feed that bucket our 18 Mills that are levied on our our business properties
104predominantly in the district it generates this the year we're in now about $852 per student so the point here is that the balance 8756 is coming from the state aid fund and this is always a point out that when in the old days you used to uh refer to when the state and when the state get an economic downturn the school aid fund catches pneumonia because if you remember the first thing that fills it most is sales tax and that's usually the first thing that takes a nose dive shortly followed by the income tax we haven't experienced that in quite a bit and I probably shouldn't bring it up um hopefully that's been stabilized from a going forward point of view so this is actually how the funding model works literally the F the foundation
105allowance amount the 9608 times the the student count the FTE count and currently is 7428 for our district so every District now has the same Foundation allowance amount 9608 10 years ago that was different every District had a different amount and over the years the state's been trying to harmonize them so now everybody's on the same number on that side of the equation but you know every district has has a different student count so the quick ma there for us is roughly uh about 75 million so it creates this liability the state's guaranteeing that we're going to get for the starting piece of funding and that's funded by joint funding through local property taxes and then the school aid fund one of the things I always want to point out is this to do the
106math on the student count within this calculation for the year we're in is fiscal 25 for public school so it's 2425 we start in July of calendar 24 and we end in June of calendar 25 so that's referred to as fiscal 25 the state's year ends in September so there's a three-year differential which just as a side note always causes Havoc from a cash flow funding point of view because the last our last two Els of our state aid payments show up in July and August after our fiscal year is done question I think you meant three month not three year three month I'm sorry three month thank you very much um that would be a problem so um so for the year we're in the the student count that was done in February of
10724 you know last fiscal year is used we take 10% 10% of that number we add it to 90% of the student count that goes on in October of the current fiscal year so that becomes the 7428 that we get paid on some districts that helps some that hurts depends if you are growing stable or declining in student count so just as a quick composition when I st say student FTE I'm talking about all the Resident kids all the school choice kids all our sharetime service kids and our virtual program students so that's that whole big picture of what feeds that whole big piece that state a comes in on so from let me get caught up here real quick so in terms of the public school budget structure itself it's really driven by two
108main sources state law and the biggest of those laws the uniform budgeting accounting act the Public Act of 1968 and then the general property tax act Public Act of 1893 now 1893 has been amended a number of times over the years so it's really not that old but um and then the other state law that's tied to the budget world that we as a school district and want to always keep an eye on is a set of laws known as the early warning laws this was a set of laws that was put in place I want to say 10 or 10 12 years ago now they really designed to help the Michigan Department of Treasury spot a school district before they get into serious financial trouble as opposed to waiting for them to be in
109what's known as negative fund balance position and that's that's a bad spot to be in so those are the things that from the law point of view we look at most there's there's there's several other laws that have little pieces that feed in or are specific to specific items but these are the big the big three that everybody keeps on their top radar and then the other Big Driver that tells us how to do our accounting and and not just accounting for the cost but how to structure our budgets it's the Michigan public school accounting manual that can be found on the state the state school aid website MD school aid website it's um probably like the seventh bullet down it's actually the appendic that we look at most because that breaks out the actual
110account string structure and which which East P which piece of that string so picture I want to say there's 12 elements and I'm going to get this wrong so there's you know there's four dig digits then three digits then three digits then four digits and four so each subset all all strung together create the account string and you're telling me to get off there you go you just gotta wave your hand at me and say move move on so anyway that's our Bible the Michigan school accounting manual so the other thing that defines us how we do things are the general Accounting Standards Board that's a gasby versus fby if you're working in the private sector and you're in the finance side you operate under fby the financial Accounting Standards Board gasby we live in
111the biggest difference between our world and private sector world I mean everybody's familiar with cash accounting it's literally it's cash in your pocket cash out of your pocket you're pretty much done in terms of accuracy of how much cash you got then there's the cruel accounting which is in the private sector that falls under fbe school districts live uh live in the world in between the affectionately referred to as modified acrel accounting some things they do the cash some things they do the full acrel and it becomes an an entirely hair pulling out event if you're not familiar with the process but once you get it down under your understanding it just you know becomes second nature as to how to do this stuff and I kind of Point those stuff out because for me
112it's always amazing to me that um when I wasn't working in public schools a long time ago I would look at and wonder why why do the schools do do that that way as soon as they started working in public schools is like oh it's all these laws and this and that that make us do different approaches to things that may not seem logical but because we're you know the duty of law there we're doing it that way kind of thing so uh from an operating Surplus a few definitions so we you'll hear the phrase operating Surplus or operating deficit so that's in any given year uh for instance the budget amendment that's coming before the board next meeting that has a a budgeted operating Surplus oh I can't remember the specific number it's roughly
113$150,000 that means we're recognizing $150,000 of Revenue over expenses if it had an operating deficit of 150,000 then the revenue would be 150,000 short of covering all our current budgeted expenses that end of itself is not a a big a big warning thing to see if there's an operating deficit sometimes boards will say hey we want to take this chunk of fund balance and spend it on that project and that outside of normal operating to spend it you'll end up in an operating deficit for that year the thing you got to worry about with operating surpluses and deficit deficits are if it's a deficit driven by a single decision of the board or some other event as a it's not something to have the alarm Bells go off but if it's an operating deficit because
114of the cost of your actual everyday operations are exceeding your everyday revenue is in that's when you got to take action and that's the purpose of forecasting and all those kinds of things to see ahead of time when things are starting to go off tracks or if there's a particular element that's out of the norm and it gives you time to go figure out what's going on and how to react so the difference there too the other highlight there difference there too is fund Equity because you can have a positive fund balance and we call that fund equity and you can have a negative fund balance that's when the early warning laws and everything that Department of Treasury will do they will be your best friends if we ever got near that so that's typically
115a 5% trigger point in terms of your fund balance if you get down to 5% so it's you know that 5% is different for every District that gets gets you on their list real quick kind of thing um and then adopt the phrasal here the adopted budget versus amended budgets so and this is another thing that is a a problem because the state's fiscal year is different than the school fiscal year under the law under the uniform budgeting act boards for public schools have to approve a budget for the upcoming year that's called the adopted budget by June 30 of the current year so on this June you'll be adopting the budget for that starts the following July the challenge there is it's about a 50-50 shot if the state has actually approved the state's
116school aid fund budget so my point here and I can't emphasize enough is that a lot of times adopted budgets coming in are built on educated to assumptions experience of years in business or just an outright guess because you just don't know what the stage is can end up doing for for example the Year we're in now coming right into June all the talk coming out of the the house the Senate and the governor's office was probably something in the neighborhood of a$2 to $300 Foundation increase and some other things so everybody conservative people went two you know historical people would do a big regression analysis come in at you know 2. 2 275 or something well the the budget that actually got approved had a zero increase at the last minute they decided to
117change all that increase in funding and put it in a specific categorical a state categorical AKA State Grant and everybody's budget from a presentation point of view was just was just wrong so in the amendment process and you'll see some of that in terms of what's highlighted and what we identify the big changes when we come through the budget amendment process and you'll see that in the documents going into the February 11 meeting so that's when you get the First Amendment piece that most districts will do mid year to catch those things and clean those things up and get things to reflect what actually happened um so those the those are the real distinctions of of what goes on why an adopted budget why the amendment budget changes the amounts they do the midy year
118and then the final the final come June you you'll also be you'll not only be adopting or approving the adopted budget for the coming year you'll be approving the final Amendment for the year we're in that's another law that basically says and this is what I guess from the private sector my colleagues from the private sector I don't know if they're mad or jealous or just don't get it because the actual law says we have to amend our budgets to reflect what our actual expenditures were and that Eve itself is is it may sound like well why aren't the budgets exactly on to what the expenses are that's another case too that when you're doing your final Amendment there's still three months two three months of costs lagging that really don't show up until July
119or August when you've got to close everything so there's a bit of professional um you know educated guessing and projecting and all that kind of stuff built into that piece too where in the private sector you'll be adjusting and most most organizations will have a standing budget that adjusts on a monthly or quarterly basis relative to exam reality so they can adjust their production or whatever they're involved with we have these static timelines and static dates John before move on I have a couple questions on this one what is our current fund balance percent our fund balance percentage is 16% 16 16.8 that's a little over 17 thank you yes yeah thank you and then you had mentioned uh the operating Surplus that you expect to bring in February and I just had a question
120does that did you build in that the board would be approving these two projects in that and and still maintaining an operating Surplus yeah okay the the the the kitchen project is actually funded from the vast majority of it funded from the Food Service fund um a little piece mayor may not end up out of the capital project fund which is in our in our district because we we don't have a sinking fund anymore our general fund funds that Capital project so indirectly the state that's already accounted for and they'll be coming in with that okay thank you yep so from a a budget structure the types of funds we use again defined by the the Michigan school accounting code there's a general fund and that's really the big one that everybody uses and that
121you can the general fund's uniqueness is that you can do any activity that goes on in a school district and account for it and budget for it in the general fund but but it doesn't work the other way for example the service fund where we track costs and budget for our Early Childhood Program a district if it chose to can have all those cost be part of the general fund even the food service can be recognized in some of these funds and that kind of things but the reason you put them in the Standalone funds is a they're a different kind of of business they're a special Revenue fund and B from a business management point of view you want your structure set aside you can actually see how that organization's doing how is how
122was there Childhood Program doing same with food service that kind of thing so we'll use general fund the special Revenue funds up there are the ones that we do use the Food Service community service School activity funds are really related to the uh the differ um money that's collected and spent at the school level for they used to be called trust and agency funds they they were of course gby changed the rules because they gota they got to change the rules to keep themselves in business kind of thing and so they all had to convert into a representation and be presented as school activity funds and then there's Capital project funds and debt funds so Capital project funds are pretty self-explanatory that's where you track your big project costs and keep them segregated so you
123can track if you issue a bond you have to have a separate Capital project fund tied to it most Sixers have a standalone Capital project fund just to track smaller projects or like in our case we we'll fund out of general fund and track them in there and then the debt funds themselves are just where we account for how we're paying back our debt on our outstanding Bond debt so you'll the biggest expenses in there are going to be principal repayment and interest payments um and those are done those are paid out twice a year uh tied to existing debt structure so then from a revenue budget point of view and every fund has really two funds I mean excuse me two budgets every we all think of as one budget there's really two there's
124a revenue budget and there's an expenditure budget so the revenue budgets the sources of revenue are are accounted for and described as the following Here Local Source Revenue State Source revenues intermediate Source Federal sources and the great than never the all Collective other sources and uh so local Source a typical local Source would be the local prop or the local property tax investment Revenue things like that that are locally generated fees that kind of stuff anything coming from the state the state aid piece of the foundation allowance any categorical grants those things they show up in are accounted for under State Source revenues as in incoming funds the intermediate sources again is that that Oakland Schools transfer over to the local districts of the special special ed funding our single biggest piece there is the
125the p8 special education pass through funding there are a couple of smaller ones associated with some other programming that goes on that the that the ISD itself may be sponsoring some istd level grants and it'll come through that it'll be categorized as that Federal Source Grants idea title are the big ones big names uh all the covid stuff from the last four or five years Fell in This category um and then the other sort of stuff is is really just that they're they're in District they're called operating transfers there's not a lot in there um you'll see in our case when we're funding a capital project fund with general fund money the transfer of the money shows up as a the expenditure version of this other source and then shows up as this Revenue Source
126in the capital project fund so there's a onetoone relationship there so that's the Revenue side of things this is the expenditure side of the budget house on the left side of the screen it's function code structure and this is the presentation that under the uniform budgeting act you'll see the budget documents they'll show you know here's your revenues then you'll see the different line items for you know instructional basic instruction costs all of these things here and this actually that's listed here mimics are our financial statements so how we present them in the financial statements so from a function code point of view that's really saying this is the kind of activity so under instruction basic programs and added needs you'll see things like the elementary the middle school the high school those are function
127111 112 113 those are all instructional cost related program so they show up under this categorization as opposed to the Transportation uh to get the kids to the schools and back that shows up in its own Standalone line called transportation services operation and maintenance is just status or facilities group so they make a they make a distinction in the way they want it reported by activity and on the other side the object code they they part of that big long account string is the object code and that makes that has us make the distinction the the type of cost whether it's a wage a fringe benefit a purchase service supplies materials Capital outlay dues fees and of course the other there's always another so this is depending upon how um you want to use and
128present internally you'll see some of the funds that may be presented from a budget amendment point of view using the object code approach like food service and typically community service the community service The Early Childhood self the cost may be presented on on the object code approach the reason that it's not following the function approach is the uniform budgeting act makes us do the functional approach the object code side doesn't it's not it's not directed by that there's no specific specific thing that says You' got to present the budget under this format for those other funds and historically it's always been easier to understand on the object display and as we do the presentations and when Courtney is doing the presentation at the next board meeting we'll point out the like the difference between them
129just see if you're paying attention uh so this is really the the big pieces on how you'll see costs and budgets come through so tomorrow our internal budget cycle and planning timeline so these would be some key dates in the cycle we do publish uh a what I refer to as a budget calendar that includes more than just budget dates but a lot of the key things that affecting the budget and these are the key some of the key dates off that schedule so in January there's a consensus Revenue estimating conference done at the state all the stakeholders from the house the Senate and the governor's office and usually from Treasury Department sit down and take a look at how much money they actually are collecting in the school aid fund and that's their first
130look at okay we thought we're going to have X and we're at y so you hopefully if Y is bigger than x that's good if it's less than x it's not good so this last one they just did in January y was bigger than x so so far so good so then in February the governor will typically the governor issues their state of the budget address wrapped up in a bigger state of the sometimes State of the Union sometimes state of the budget Standalone and and whoever the governor is in this case Governor Whitmer will present her budget priorities and in there we usually glean out what does that mean for the foundation allowance what does that mean to us in the school world because it's the whole state budget so we just peel out
131what's hitting the school World followed by that and then in terms of the February ourselves that's what we generally we're going to try to get as a practice here to do our forecasting in February prior years I think it was a little later in the year so we're proposing to go in February at the end of the the February I want to say 25th meeting so knowing by that time we know what's going on from the January consensus Revenue meeting by they by the way they refer to that as the CRA meeting if you hear that expression it's not crack it's CRA and um there's one also in May but that's another acronym that they'll use so if you ever hear that you're like okay it's you know so anyway the um between February and
132April there's usually a House and Senate they all they all publish their own budget so now there's three competing budgets out there three how everybody wants to spend it so usually in May they'll all stop take a look again into another consensus Revenue estimating conference and did did the money show up great yes that's always good and then they'll sit down with representatives from those stakeholder groups and C after What's called the conference report and that's really just the negotiated budget of the three pieces they get that settled they send it up to the governor and hopefully the governor signs it all the governor always commit to signing them by sometime mid June so when our boards are all approving these things they're approving it knowing what they're actually getting they have a less than
13350% delivery on that so and I suspect it'll be a little same way this year I can see the look on your face uh so so they usually will come in with a budget that's based on what's been talked about 50% of the time it's not actually been passed by the state yet but it's in the process usually ends up in July kind of thing and so that goes on and then again in June you'll see our final budget amendment for the year and then adopted budget coming before the board for the coming year so moving away from the budget piece one of the things that actually impacts budgets a lot are the different millages that occur um this is just a 30,000 foot view of what you'll see in our in our Public School
134world the State education tax of course again that's that's a direct State millage so that shows up on everybody's taxes I point that out again because most people take it with us I just want to say it again it goes to the state it's not ours it's not us um the general operating millage is that 18 Mills on on the homestead that's we do we do Levy um we are only legally allowed to Levy up to 18 Mills other districts because of an amendment called the headle amendment that came online when proposal a came online in the mid 90s its goal works almost like it was supposed to in the end each year the an analysis done and it calculates a factor called a the millage reduction factor and if it calculates out less than
1351.0 then whatever your millage was coming into that year you've got to reduce it by that amount so if it came in at 98.5 and you were leving 18 Mills last year whatever 98.5% of 18 is 17 whatever that's all you can legally Levy for the year in your the year you're in so over the years Public Schools have devised a defense mechanism if you will to get voter voters to approve to authorize a millage number bigger than 18 say 20 so as and they and they last for roughly 10 years in most cases these authorizations for these these millages so as this Headly Amendment goes on year after year if it starts knocking down that 20 it hits the 20 not the 18 so you've got the the whole 2.0 amount to be reduced
136before it even breaches your 18 so the key thing about leving 18 Mills at a minimum the state assumes all the public schools are leving 18 Ms when they fill that Foundation all allowance bucket so we are actually a district that's in the condition we're less than 18 because of the Headly Amendment so just from a from a radar screen kind of thing as a school district we need to be looking at a uh a millage approval for the general operating millage that goes on the the eight goes on the business world to make sure we get something back up to the 18 level in my ideal world I would love the community to support authorizing something above 18 knowing we can only legally Levy 18 so it kind of it's that defense piece how
137to deal with the quote unquote flaw has been referred to as the flaw in the Headly Amendment proposal a changes of the 90s and for whatever reason nobody wants to go back in and open that box back up otherwise they should have fixed that long ago but so that's one of the things that'll be coming you'll see the syncing fund millage is a millage that's uh voter approved it's similar to a bond millage in terms of the approval process you have to go out to your community give them the case why you want you know either a sinking fund or a bond or whatever the case may be and convince them to support it they go out and do a vote if things go well they'll support it and it'll be coming online for whatever
138length of time for a syncing fund is limited to I believe it's 10 years kind of similar to the general operating Mill life a bond millage is is um its life is based upon the underlying debt so when your whole underlying debt piece of the aggregate debt structure of your school district drives your aggregate life of that so there's a little difference there syncing funds are a pay as you go program so you'd Levy once a year whatever revenu comes in there's no debt tie to it you take that revenue and you go buy and spend it on the things that are legally allowable for a syncing fund bonds are are they just that you're asking your community to support the issuance of a bond so that's a big project orientation and there's outstanding debt
139tied to that the bonded debt so the millage that you'd be Ling would be funding used to pay off the The Debt Service if you will of the bond so that's your principal interest payment each year for the life of the bond so those sometimes run depending upon how you structure those those could run from 15 years to 25 years those are really bond issue timing specific so the real difference between them from a from what you're legally allowed to spend that money on is there there old used to be an old rule of thumb for syncing funds if you took a school building turn it upside down and shook it whatever didn't fall out you can spend syncing fund dollars on the laws changed a bit in the last few years so that rule
140still applies meaning you can HVAC units you know brick and mortar you can't buy maintenance items you can't pay people with that kind of money you can't buy supplies for you know teaching supplies or anything like that but the last few years they've added to allowable expenses you can buy buses and you can buy technology so those are the two caveats that go along with the other piece in the bond world you can buy everything in a building in both of these cases you you can't pay salaries with them you can't pay for anything that's maintenance related so if you've got a a maintenance contract you can't you can't legally use Bond or syncing fund dollars because it's maintenance that should be that should be in your general fund side of things but if you
141need to replace Motors in a system that have burned out that need repairing you can spend either dollars on those that kind of thing so this world from a 30,000 foot view that's about as about as deep as you want to go because it gets it gets into the weeds quick because they all have their own nuances and one of the new nuances that we actually have here in the district is called the school loan revolving fund that's that associated with our bonds in the district and I think I've touched on this in the prior meetings a little bit of an overview but this is kind of a restatement of some of the information I've gone over before really um the program is the Michigan State program that was created a long time ago I
142want to say I want to say in the 50s comes to mind I could be wrong on that the goal of it was to help smaller tax-based districts afford bigger Bond projects so in today's today's age I mean it's you're going to spend $100 million doll to build a new new high school maybe more and then most districts the tax base in them cannot afford it so the idea when this originally came out back in this day was all right instead of having to come up with a millage that you would ask your community to pay like 15 Mills I could you imagine that can come vote for a bond we're only going to charge you 15 Ms they have this program in place that says if you charge a certain level like you have
143to be charging or leving at least 7 Ms and we're at 7.9 in our district they'll you can belong to this fund there's an application process there's actually an actual contract related to it that's somewhere along the line and that allowed you to borrow from this program so and the reason you want to do that say the say that 7.9 Mills that we're living only generates 90% of the debt service we need for the amount of bonded debt we want to borrow to build whatever the other 10% you borrow through the school Loan Fund to pay your debt service and as you let's say that the life of the bonded debt was 20 years so for the next 20 years theoretically you're borrowing a little bit of school bond loan money and you're leving your
144taxes and you're paying off your bond so in years 21 and 22 you would still do two full levies you'd use that to pay off your outstanding school loan revolving fund loan debt money so in effect what it's doing is stretches out payments on a bond to keep it quote unquote affordable for districts that don't have bigger tax bases you know like a Troy I mean they they issued a half a billion dollar Bond a couple years ago they got no problem supporting bonded debt and you go north of us it's that's a whole different story so I mean that's that was the idea and thinking behind it so this gets us to um from a from a overview of program and budget how it inter interacts with the the budgeting process and some of
145the finance World our district I think I touched on earlier we run our our our seated regular programming at in our schools we also have a o we have a sharetime program that we run a Virtual Academy program that we run and we're connected with Lighthouse connection Academy that we authorize so from a 30,000 foot view the Shar time service again all of these programs have their lots of ability go into the weed so I'm from a 30,000 foot view from a share time program Point of View schools have different classes that are categorized as either core or non-core so if it's a non-core class like an art or a music or a gym they qualify under the sharetime service program so for St Joe's for instance if they have a a gym program and
146they need a gym teacher we can give them a gym teacher that we're paying and the and the trade off is or the tradeback is we get to count the kids that that gym teacher is teaching in our state aid so in the grand grand scheme of things it's really a win-win for all kids involved a lot of the smaller privat and parochial just can't afford a lot of the stuff that public schools can so the program over the years has kind of expanded so from a simple point of view it's really boils down to we'll staff these non-core courses we we'll get to count the kids in state aid and the goal is to do it where we're providing them a service that is very beneficial to those smaller organizations of priol and the
147privates that can't afford it we get to count the state aid uh we we generate an excess Revenue over that that excess revenue is plowed back into our facilities and our kids programming here in District the the virtual program here it's it's Sim in terms of of the the big picture of operations but you can have different variations of the type so so our virtual model here provides Educational Services and curriculum to support the needs of our resident kids as well as kids across the across the state because it's virtual you can literally go across the state so in terms of the same kind of concept we we incur costs associated for teaching we incur cost and associ for virtual curriculum that kind of stuff some of some equipment costs we generate a state aid
148count because we get the count those kids the state aid dollar value that's generated generates an excess excess Revenue over the total cost and we turn around and take that access Revenue to support our seated in District standard programming ligh house connections is a little bit different um public schools are one of the agencies that can authorize a a an academy universities and public schools do it across the state we've authorized and this has been authorized a while back I can't off top of my head now I'm thinking about can't think when we actually started doing this thank you so Lighthouse Connections Academy is we've authorized them so the difference here between the other two kind of programs is we're having a compliance oversight role so for having that oversight role we get to charge
149them a fee and the fees is based on upwards of you can go up to 3% of the state aid that the academy generates every District goes up to 3% and so for Lighthouse academy they'll generate state aid it passes through us so we can that's the state given control from our point of view so whoever is authorizing them the academy state aid passes through them so there's a control point so that they know that the authorizer is getting their fee and then the balance gets transferred from the authorizing District to the to the Lighthouse academy in our case what we do with that fee Our obligation is a bunch of is there's a set out amount of compliance activities that we have to do and we do annually Allison falls under that falls under
150Allison's territory and that's another type of program that we accomplish those compliance activities at a cost that's less than the fee we charge again that excess Revenue gets plowed back into our District operating and buildings programs and regular regular curriculum programming so that's the 30,000 foot view um at a future date or maybe the finance subcommittee if you want to tear into a deeper level on any of this stuff I would be more than thrilled to take you way into the weeds because that's the morning that'll be easy to put everybody to sleep um Andor if there's anything like uh that you want we can add to a future presentation for if there's more desire to see something different but the goal here and I hope hope I aside from getting everybody to KN off
151the goal here is to get some basic understanding of terminology why we do what we do that kind of stuff any any questions and if there are no questions that means I did my job fantastic job that was very very thorough and educational and we appreciate it now I do you want me just go right into the good stuff yeah if you don't mind that'd be great we do have two two bid first readings on on the agenda tonight first one's related to our boilers we've got two boilers at the o o OIC facility and one at Lake View um we we approach them from what's known as the emergency status point of view because they are boilers they're the means to keep the buildings warm and in the middle of winter that gives you
152the authority to streamline some activity If This Were the middle of the summer and we were doing this we would have to draw plans pass it through the state you've heard this story before it would take them 12 weeks to approve the plans and then we can go do the fixes the emergency model allows you to go go do the fixes and then simultaneously start the the state approving plans because boilers are pretty pretty cut and dried in terms of what needs to be done so those are the kinds of things you'll typically see even the roof is um been done under that model the only problem with the roof is that it took forever to to turn around at this date because we did start in the summer on that as opposed to if
153that occurred in the winter we would have had an argument to do otherwise but uh so those boilers are out there there's um the pricing of the boiler itself is off the the Omni Cooperative contract pricing so the this contract is uh meets the state's compliance rules for purchasing pricing and meeting uh bid bid bid aspect of the equipment piece the overall bid really is covering the cost of those that equipment and the cost to install them so that's why they show up as they stand alone bid before the board tonight so uh we did get three installation vendors who were invited to make proposals we got two um excuse me we did get three back on that because we pulled them out through the Omni group and we were working with our our our
154architect to coordinate that piece working through all that the winning vendor or the proposed the recommended winning vendor is thermal I always kill the name here thermal thermal netics and based on the the way they read it on their paperwork I could never wasn't quite sure if that's two words or one from the name of their company point of view so so from that perspective the these projects would be funded out of our capital projects fund and so it's recommended that the Board of Education authorized to execute the contract with Thermo Thermon netics in the amount of $299,825 for a total authorization of 24183 to the contingency is not TIY to the contract that just pre-authorization that we're requesting that if as we're because this a boiler replacement is tan amount to renovation you never
155know for sure what you're going to find so it's a it's an ask to say okay if we find a problem that we didn't see until we actually tore the equipment out that's the pre-authorization to use 22,000 to get it all done instead of stop and coming back to the board and that kind of stuff so that you'll see that too and some of the bid stuff going forward and then the other one is the OIC k kitchen project so the scope there was um more complex than than just boiler pieces so it addressed the kitchen hood and all the venting work um I'm not sure if anybody's actually T has gone through any the actual kitchen there but you'll when you walk in you see exactly what what it is what we're talking about
156so there's a hood venting work equipment replacement going on there's grease traps and any kitchen those grease traps these need to be replaced and moved so that's a big piece of the actual tearing up tearing up of the ground because they're in INR grease grease traps there's a little bit of wall movement from one a very small movement but that's it's in the it's in the mix there's going to be some ceiling tile replacement going to replace the roof lighting fire alarm systems and some other physical upgrades it's it's very it's very clear the that area of the building much like probably the rest of the building hasn't been addressed from a physical update or physical needs point of view for a long time so in this mix also there's an alternate to do the
157subsequent floor tiling work tearing out the old stuff putting in new stuff so the bid itself is a request to approve both pieces the main piece from a cost point of view is 695 let me pull my number out here I didn't bring that here it's 695 associated with the main construction work and then 79,000 associated with the tile work and that's referred to as alternate one because we're tearing so much of the floor up it's it's almost T amount that we have to go with alternate one we just want to have the ability to peel a piece out so the pricing along with our contingency request gets it up to an $800,000 cost issue that's before we've got a planned we're working with the vendor to get a planned reduction we're changing some scope
158so in the end there's going to be a reduction of that about 75,000 associated with the pricing um from a planning point of view we estimated in the ballpark for the main piece the first piece about $500,000 for the project it came in $695 that was the low bed the other one was I want to say it was between the two was about a $50,000 difference between the two vendors that actually um put a u put a bid on we did have 12 different vendors come in and have interest and typically this time of year typically or used to be typically pre pre-co this would be a slower time for this size of a for a vendor and You' get you better better price ring and you get more people react you know providing bids
159and reaction we got two and in a great degree we're happy to get to because it's work that's got to be done not happy with the pricing being a prisoner of the moment and being a prisoner of what's going on in the markets there I I want to think that when we talked what we had estimated the pricing to be we were we were thinking still 2019 as opposed to full scale 2024 and I think that there's more work out there so this time period is probably not the slump time period in the old old days pre pre2 days it used to be so that is the that is the U the uh first reading piece on that one more than happy to ask any questions or answer any questions on that one were there
160any questions on those two items I had one on the boilers and maybe I missed this somewhere but for the thermal Medics what is it the warranty is it only 30 days of Labor warranty or is there an equipment warranty there's any there's any equipment warranty because the the the equipment is being purchased through the Omni contract that comes with its own set of warranties they're giving a 30-day warranty on their work do you know what the warranty is the other just because the other quote included that that there was a 12 month warranty but there wasn't that was not included on the thermal Medics one so do you happen to know that or could you get that I can find that next time I can find that out yep perfect the uh the big
161Focus that we did have on that was the equipment warranty piece of it when it comes to the installation piece you know right away if it's working right um so so and then let me give you a couple of quick if if you don't mind a couple of quick updates a couple other things are going on in the district so there's good and there's bad so I'm going with good for first yac roof project status thank God on this one the trusses are delivering at the end of this month the target is January 30th of the actual trust is coming on property work is scheduled to begin on January 31 weather permitting if it starts within three or four days of that I'll be thrilled and then they're targeting completion by end of February if
162everything goes good it'll be mid-February but you know how things go it'll be end of February and that piece will be taken care of and we can take that off the off the radar so to speak the bad piece this the Sunday January 19th we had a electrical equipment problem at the middle school um for lack of a better description the the power coils a Transformer that's inside the building there's a primary and a secondary where the main big huge power lines come in something occurred somewhere along the way that caused a problem with those the more we're digging into it and we've been working with uh um our our electrical contractor and the insurance company's going to send their people out they're actually probably going to be out by the end of this week
163to look at their perspective on stuff I did get a little bit of good news there that our equipment small chance it's not burned out small chance it can be repaired this is a um a very challenging project we did get a tractor trailer size generator brought into the back of the building by the end of day that Sunday so the building's powered our Network systems are powered all that's good so we don't we won't have an interruption for power reasons The Continuous renting of the generator is expensive um so the sooner that gets done original timelines that have been talked about getting this fixed could be up to two months um there are doing other tests to determine exactly what the specific causation issue is to repair it and then also determining if our
164existing equipment has been damaged Beyond repair if it's damaged Beyond repair that's very old equipment nobody makes it anymore if we wanted to do a piece for piece replacement it's got a year lead time to have it built so if it is that we won't be doing that route we'll be likely buying newer equipment setting up a if you your picture U at the back side of the building dropping down a cement pad dropping down a new modern Transformer running heavy wiring back under the the pavement of the back back drives behind the building back into the building that if we go that route that's what will be done within two two months so this balance of this week we're hoping to identify exactly what happened and exactly what it means that we need to
165do to a not have it happen again and B fix what it damage it did it also damaged the INB building generator it it uh it had a cascading effect to some degree so that's in the mix too that that's an easier fix I mean that's an old Generator but we think we can find a used part part reh uh replacement kit for it so that's all in process as I learn more about that I'll bring that probably keep you know subcommittee brought up to date and any when if there's any big ticket pricing involved you the board you'll be the you'll be the second to know after the subcommittee meaning you'll see it in a bid coming up so that was the not good news so that that's it I probably should have did
166that in Reverse so I could ended on good news oh that the for the boiler for OIC it is it is two boilers yeah there both boilers are being replaced I see it I see it says boilers yeah so there's two two at OIC one at Lake F okay I don't know if I see it like item okay and then we'll talk on Friday okay we get on this we'll dig into it on Friday yeah do we have a ballpark figure for the Middle School um no I don't I wouldn't want to put something out in public because it could no as soon as I get a good figure a good idea of what we really then we can come up with some kind of estimates I'm trying to say think positive about it thank
167you okay I I have a quick question yeah um do we have a um either a daily or a monthly estimated cost for running the generator yes it's about $112,000 a week so the sooner we get a resolution the better that's the the best case scenario right is if it were something that is covered by insurance and those costs would be yeah yeah it's it in my mind it should be covered by insurance but you just never know if they because it's so old equipment there's okay everybody cross your fingers thank thank you yep all right moving on to Human Resources Miss Ryan Reed Arin okay good evening Board of Education and Community listening in at home I am ran Reed and I'm honored to serve in the role of assistant superintendent of Human Resources
168I'm here tonight to give you an HR Staffing update quick overview these are the four main um points I want to um talk about this evening with you so first OCS by the Numbers this graphic represents our total 854 employees and then you can see I've broken it down into group groups we have our oea teachers asme bus drivers monitors Cafe helpers our Opa secretaries PA professionals technology Specialists and everyone they're all important I will not read it all to you because you can see it I would also like to give a big shout out to our thirdparty contractors including ABM who provide custodial will sub for our subs our security contractors with foris our OTS and PTs none of those folks are represented in the 850 54 and it's just important to recognize them
169because we need them to do this important work so thank you to all of those folks and our direct hires as well so far this year we have welcomed 81 new employees since July 1st of 20124 hiring is an ongoing year-round process since I started this presentation at the beginning of January we've already hired at least six more folks to that number um we are glad that they are all here the graphic on this slide is a welcome note that is published to new hires in our HR Thrive monthly newsletter next I'm going to chat with you about retirement and resignations so this is the number of Staff over the last five years and um this is through the 2023 24 school year since we have the complete data set I am not going to
170report on current year and it is ongoing and it might look it'll just look look too low so that's why you'll see 2019 through 2020 all the way up to 2024 this is representative of all staff so it's not drilled down by employee group this is all staff of those 854 you can see we've had an increase in retirements in 23 24 as well as uh resignations um experts from the federal office of victims of crime have shared that after Mass violence incidents there is an increase in faculty and staff turnover we aim to combat this um the effects of vicarious trauma by having consistent policies and practices that are supportive of Staff this slide represents our turnover rate as a percentage a five-year trend from 1920 through 2324 turn excuse me turnover is calculated
171by dividing the number of retirements and resignations by the average number of employees during that year so for 232 4 we're at 14.4% again this is representative of all staff in the district it's not drilled down by employee group but I will share with you in 23 24 school year regarding teachers we had 22 leaves so that puts our teacher turnover rate at 5.65 which is below the state average which was at 10% so we are in a really healthy in a healthy condition in terms of teachers we have had other staff turnover but that is too be expected for a number of reasons um specifically what I shared with you regarding the last slide and we are expecting some more turnover as the last class graduates um this upcoming year so I will continue
172to bring you a five-year trend on that and also drill down more specifically to show you um information specific to teachers I do want to share another fact with you um teachers entering Michigan's public school Workforce in the Years 21 and 22 outnumber those who left left so we're seeing good Trends Statewide people are entering the profession we're in a healthy range we're below the average State turnover and teachers so I think that's important data to share with the board this evening next I'd like to talk with you about the exit survey the slide represents a brief overview of the exit survey as staff depart we ask them to share feedback with us I want to make sure it is known that this is an optional process for staff to participate in with us um
173we look forward to always listening to their feedback analyzing and improving in the future our largest group of respondents are professional staff members so teachers and other certified staff 41.4% respondents on this survey and this is overtime this has been ongoing we revamped the survey last year so this the data includes um from last year forward and our largest group of respondents include staff from Oxford High School at 29.3% top reasons for departure include better opportunities for growth rate of pay retirement great for those folks moving on into retirement and then stress or burnout um I will talk a little bit more about better opportunities for growth in a few slides also again I just want to remind you this data represents all staff so rate of pay we have folks work in hourly position
174so we're always aiming to remain competitive through throughout every employee group uh good news is that 90 or 87.9% of respondents would recommend Oxford Community Schools as a to a friend as a place to work so I think that's a point of Pride for us next this slide shows our pulse survey Revol um results from November 2024 and these are a little bit small so I will just read them to you brief the orientation in orange and red we have strongly disagree and disagree our greens are either agree or strongly agree so number one the district prioritizes my health and well-being 82% of our employees either agreed or strongly agreed two I am aware of resources available to manage stress and to support my mental health 93% of employees either agreed or strongly agreed I
175feel sense of belonging in my workplace is question three and 83% of our employees agreed with that again these are points of Pride that folks are feeling engaged in the red and orange categories we take their feedback we gathered free form data as well from respondents and our Wellness committee is digging into the data at the next meeting we were postponed due to the snow day last week but we look forward to the opportunity as a team to dig into the data and create action steps moving forward this next slide is um just a continuation of that six question poll survey so working at Oxford Community Schools give me gives me a sense of purpose 91% of Staff either agreed or strongly agreed next there are people at my workplace who genuinely care about me
176and my well-being 94% of Staff either agreed or strongly agreed our biggest area for improvement is I am aware of the employee assistance program and the type of help it provides we had 78% of Staff agree or disagree or excuse ex me either agree or strongly agree this was our biggest area of growth on our last poll survey as well and with that rate of turnover we're saying about 9 10% new staff each year this is an ongoing challenge that we will work on to make sure that the word is out about the EAP because it's a great resource it's free it's available to every employee regardless of full-time part-time status and members of their household so anyone living over un under their roof is eligible for mental health support I think that's critical I've
177said it before up here so I'm sorry I have to make that plug again because it's just a great resource for our employees and their families and these are fun photos I wanted to share with you of well-being in action in January we had an underground staff spirit week and you can see the days that um our staff participated in Monday was anything but a cup um Tuesday socks and sandals you can see our teachers there with their socks and sandals then on Wednesday we had our monochrome day you can see the OIC staff out front representing and we had favorite holiday on Thursday Kelly and Rouse R tan there representing Christmas and then Friday was hat and Jersey day and we had some very excited Lions fans over at oelc so that's just a
178fun slide to show you our well-being work in action and our staff have given us a lot of feedback they enjoy the morale building that comes from having monthly spirit days so thank you all for participating um and we look forward to having more of those lastly I'm going to chat with you about Oxford Oxford Community Schools and our partnership with Talent together I presented to the board previously about our partnership it's so unique um it started in the 20 3 24 school year and there's 56 isds supported by the Michigan educator Workforce initiative and 18 colleges and universities um it's such a point of price for me to be involved in this program because it gives staff the opportunity to grow and I I wanted to mention from the other side people leave because
179they're looking for opportunities for growth so this is this is such an amazing program you can see the timeline all staff are offered this opportunity it is for certificated teachers to add an endorsement so they have career growth it could be for a bus driver or a par professional who wants to be a teacher one day as you can see the graphic here shows our latest email from December of 24 and we highlighted some Pathways that are available we always need special education teachers secondary math and science are hard to staff and ESL and we sent that out to all staff so I'm just super proud that we we um promote from within we grow our own and this partnership has enabled us because it gives us full funding last year the 23 24 school
180year we had our first year of the teacher Apprentice program the first in Michigan we had seven Apprentice teachers two of them were hired into full-time positions are serving in the district currently our issue was we didn't have enough open positions for the teachers so we still have two that have have continued on in other roles and three have left for positions in other districts and those are all elementary teachers so we're just really proud of that opportunity for staff to continue to grow and we have this unique partnership with Talent together so finally I just want to touch on our November 2024 we have 24 staff members who are currently enrolled with Talent together they are pursuing math science specialed learning disabilities cognitive impairment emotional impairment autism and Elementary education and again these are
181areas that are extremely hard to staff so we're investing in our own people and growing them which will lead to higher employee satisfaction and hopefully decrease turnover in the future um and applications for cohort 3 closed in January 2025 so we look forward to more staff participating in the program and our future partnership with Talent together so with that that's all I have this evening I am happy to answer any questions you may have any questions or comments from the board just thank you very much Ryan you answered my questions that I had as we went so thank you very much for a thorough presentation great update thank you again R thank you sorry I'm so used to just watching and enjoying uh up next Dr Willman um I am bringing forth the School of
182Choice memo so I don't have a presentation um it is that we are recommending the following enrollment for School of Choice applicants this would be for first semester next school year so the 2526 school year um for developmental kindergarten through 9th grade it would be unlimited and that enrollment would open March 1st and close on August 14th for 10th and 11th grade it would be unlimited for those who would enter the IB health science engineering academy dance Conservatory or early college and that window is the exact same March 1st through August 14th and then developmental kindergarten through 12th grade unlimited for OVA um unlimited School of Choice enrollment will open March 1st and close August 14th and then this is just the presentation tonight and then next meeting you will vote um and then just
183a reminder in accordance with our board policy we do take into account any disciplinary history and um Kathy rastigue our enrollment specialist does an excellent job of reaching out to the other schools when it's School of Choice and digging into it and talking to us and we work with the other principles to ensure that they're in compliance with what our board policy is so any questions all right thank you thank you very much all right we do have a motion for the first reading if somebody would like to Mike Whitney oh well I I took that as yes move to approve the first reading of school of of schools of choice for fall of 2025 as presented support James any discussion all those in favor I any opposed motion carries okay unscheduled public comment do
184we have any no okay I do just want to mention real quick before we jump into the next one that there was an item on the agenda that was removed I'm sure you all noticed the letter and because of developments over the past 24 hours I thought it was best that we table this we will bring it back absolutely at the next meeting but I didn't want any hastily made changes and I think it needs to be um a bit more appropriate given current conditions so just wanted to tell you all [Applause] that so would somebody like to make a motion for Clos session okay here we go meet and close session pursuant to open meetings act Section 8 C for strategy and negotiation sessions connected with the negotiation of a collective bargaining agreement if
185either negotiating party requests a closed session and section 8e to consult with its attorney regarding trial or settlement strategy in connection with case numbers 23-1 1483 23-1 23489 23-1 1565 23-1 1484 23-1 1487 23- 1561 23-1 1490 23-14 91 23-1 1564 23-1 1492 23-1 1493 23-1 1560 23-1 1496 24- MSC pound number four 16 7744 MSC number 16774 624-2111 021 D no o 24- 21120 or 221 - no o 24- 211-225 d no 24- 2112 34- 24- DN and 24 21120 7- CZ pursuant to MCL 15.26% no okay James we'll need a roll call vote yep roll call vote I need a yes or no summers yes Adon yes ald yes serth yes uh Whitney yes Gibson yes McDonna yes all right it is 901 and we are moving into Clos session all right welcome
186back it is 10:16 we are returning from Clos session do we have any administrative clarification Dr Milligan no no and any final board comments no okay there are scheduled activities listed we have men winter break coming up and also a few more Board of Education meetings just want to remind everybody if you haven't had your committee meetings to get those scheduled and it is 10:17 p.m. this meeting is adjourned