001okay I'd like to call to order tonight's Charter Township of Oxford Planning Commission regular meeting Thursday January 23rd 2025 we can start by Rising paying respect door FL United States America to the stands indivisible withy and jusice for all thank you very much um can we note the role noted there is a forum just want to remind everybody make sure that when you're speaking you speak into the microphone and make sure that that bright green light is on and that's it thank you uh number four approval of tonight's agenda uh note that we do have have to amend the agenda to remove number 12 at the request of the applicant agenda for a motion please thank you I'll make a motion that we uh accept the agenda minus item 12 which was removed at the
002request of the applic second we have a motion we have a second any discussion do you know why it was applicant chose to remove I do not know um we don't have to know okay well I have no idea was this followup from last meeting no this is just their uh their Master deed this is sanctuary last meeting you did on claves okay great it's just um it's we're just a littlee of schedule on that it'll be back on your agenda once the documents are actually ready there was just a little jum on okay okay so we have a motion we have a second U all in favor any opposed motion carries number five conflicts of interest xar contact does anybody have anything to report or discuss seeing none move to number six approval of
003the minutes Planning Commission regular meeting January 9 2025 Mr shair make the motion to approve minutes for January 9th 2025 second okay so we have a motion we have a second any discussion any thing that needs to be changed in the minutes seeing none uh all in favor I any opposed okay the motion carries number seven public comments on items not scheduled for public hearing or on this agenda no in the audience we will move to number eight commissioner comments anything this evening no all right number nine public hearing which we do not have this evening let's move on to number 10 unfinished business Master Plan update good evening plan Commissioners Mato Paka Carl Workman Associates with the planning consultants for the township so this evening um what you have in front of you are
004the draft uh Community profile and background chapters from the master plan uh so if you sorry if you recall and if you can believe a little over a year ago when we were kind of assessing the format and the structure of the 2019 plan your current plan we discussed the fact that that the background um the background studies chapter was 50 plus pages and was it it was just a lot of information crammed into one chapter and so we discussed breaking it out at that time into two chapters which is what you have in front of you this evening the background chapter and in the community profile the best way to kind of explain these two and the differences between them is that the background really is kind of a narrative that tells a story
005of kind of leading up to this point and some glimpses of what's coming and the community profile which would be an appendex is kind of like hey if you're looking for numbers and stats and things that nature the graphs not that not that that's where all of it is but that's kind of where you would go they tell kind of the same story in different ways one's just more Technical and one's a little bit more narrative where we duplicated the information between the two chapters some of you may have noticed there's the same Maps or the same references in both chapters what we tried to do there was we tried to duplicate the information that has kind of risen to the top of the priority list as we've gone through this process both with the
006commission and the public and so you'll notice there's there is I don't want to call it redundancy because it's not necessarily word for word but natural features and preservation show up in both sections traffic you know as it relates to development and safety and things of that shows up in both um what was the other the other one Scapes the you know the different ways in which all these things affect development shows up in both um and so tonight what we have in front of you is both of those chapters as drafted uh we provided a clean and a red line for the background chapter and that was really just with some notes to say where did we take from 2019 where have we changed it the community profile is all new because that's where
007we data allant we wouldn't use data from 2019 unless we just could not find anything more updated for today so you have the memo in front of you this evening regarding some of the questions that we're looking for and per usual it's it's feedback you know are we is what we're saying the way it should be said is there anything that's missing um is there anything that should be moved is the background chapter still too big are there some things that we should just move over to community profile um and at the end of the background chapter we kind of we end it with some planning implications and that's really the those are kind of meant to paraphrase what you would like to see this master plan accomplish and be used for as the tool
008it becomes once it's adopted right and is really to kind of guide policy guide decision uh guide Direction and even guide resources you know if there's studies or projects or things that the township wants to undertake the master plan serves as a good um justification for undertaking those things um so with that this evening I if there's if there's some general questions I'm happy to kind of start with those and then we can kind of work I'll go right to left you I've work my way across the room so I won't start with you Mr Aon we we'll start with done but just in general there any general questions or any clarifications I can offer before we start while you think about that the one other update I wanted to give you is we're like
00990% there right this road's been longer than I think anyone anticipated um however I don't think it's uncommon for a community in your position you really are coming up on the crossroads between the development pressures that you're feeling but then also the many reasons why the community enjoys Oxford and wants Oxford in some ways to stay the same so it's not uncommon for this to get drawn out I think all of us you know we're excited to kind of get this finished but we're about 90% there and we are we are shooting to have you a full front to back draft in mid to late February so now with that in mind are there any general questions before we get into the the nuts and bolts of the memo so is General what's the other
01010% that needs to be done formatting right so some of it's technical just Technic things up here and there and then there are just a few tweaks to some of the other internal chapters as it relates to like the future land use map where that's pretty much done but we still got to get it in front of you probably in the final draft form um but it's really more or less just few small items of future land use um we want to concur a few more items with Township engineering um and after that we've pretty much got the book for you thank you sure all right why don't we do you want to just you want to start working our way through the memo sure um let's do that so Mr chair going through this
011I found a few like um some spacing some spelling ER some do you want me to go through and read of those things that I noticed and maybe trigger thoughts on other Commissioners minds or um this might just take me a few minutes to go through maybe five 10 minutes if that's okay yeah take your time okay um so I reviewed some of this with Mato ahead of time because I just thought you know kind of formatting stuff and on page one um where the word it says Regional context it's underlined that just a space above that for um commissioner W can I may I sure answer something totally to the pleasure of the board or the commission as it relates to some of the spelling spaces if you're comfortable with me having you know
012taking your draft and returning it to you've found done I'm happy to okay I will find an intern tomorrow and they will be fixing all of those things but the context if you I me again I'm happy to follow it however you want to if you want to go through those those as well I'm all yours well I thought if I did if I said those things it might prevent or not make other planning Commissioners feel like they have to done f the same thing and okay they catch it so I'm comfortable whichever way I just want I'll try to move as quickly as I can yeah go ahead and then we'll we'll stick to the meat and potatoes after that okay um so moving up with page one moving on let's see page um
013page three at the very bottom that bottom bullet point we talked about the font being a little bit larger than um the previous um text uh let's see I'm on page four there at the very bottom says figure two um that figure two relates to the figure on the next page just moving that over to the next page and I'll give this to you m at the end so you can um move those things around um on page seven the the map size map two if I was asking if Mato could move the legend maybe to the bottom or the top um the wording on the right side so that the map could be increased in size just so for the benefit of the reader that I think it's easier to read that way having
014a larger map um excuse just a second I would second that and I would say that none of the maps should be any smaller than at least a half a page because there's difficulty reading them and reading the Legends as I went through this I think what Don and I discussed like basically I we'll see if we can get it to look right as every map and Legend being a full page if we can get it to set right like that then we'll see what we can do is there a need to keep it to certain number page no okay no I mean I I can yeah that's that's completely agreeable I'll see if I'd like to see him full page to be able to read okay y so yeah that comment kind of goes
015to all the maps that we went through so um excuse me let's see um page 11 there was just a a spelling error I'll say to you on the word or it's not a big deal or of um page 13 at the top um second sentence or second line down talks about incentives I think you incentivize was the word maybe we're looking for there the um the map number five or map five on page I found interesting you know of course this will get blown up um and this talks about um having priorities one two and three of these uh natural features this inventory of areas that we're trying to maintain and you know I kind of noted um this is kind of for the other Commissioners um that we uh where the village is
016outlined in black on that map to the bottom right of that there's an area in red like touching the black line I don't know if you can go to that in the pack at night it out better but um you know that was a development that is actually underway right now that we voted on the preliminary site plan a few months back and um having this map to look at to work with the developer on the Pud or in a PUD in that case um seems like it would give us some room to argue we would like to preserve some of those natural features in that area having a map like this included in the master plan I think you indicated that it was not in the original the 2019 I don't believe so okay
017so it's this have so we got this area here I believe that's the um telmore Peninsula is that right uh Village telmore youing about the name of the development or the area the well whatever the development is called I believe it's it's part part this is part of it it continues over this way I believe but um anyway I was kind of surprised to see that I know it's a priority three but it appears that there may be an opportunity to try to maintain the natural features of some of these um developments as they come through the community or to the community so maybe some information like how how can you use this map like right maybe some stronger language to help us um when making a decision of say a development PUD whatever it
018might be okay so quick question what is the consequence of having priority one two or three areas does it mean we may ignore for development purposes some develop you know priority two or prior let go ahead and let develop over well it's so I believe it is basically the concentration of several different items between mature vegetation species Wetlands habitat you know the more the more you have into an area kind of aligns whether it's considered priority one two or three whenever you're doing development really whatever is law is what is what you can and can't do so this this puts these areas on the radar of a Township if a Township or Community wants to take proactive steps in putting either some sort of reasonable restrictions over the development bed area or purchase development rights
019or set up conservation easements things of that nature would it make sense to Define these out what the priorities are as far as like what is it that makes something a priority one and priority two and priority three yeah I recall the developer even asked for modifications to the standards in that same red area that we um we talked quite a bit about during that 4our meeting that evening but um okay thank you I appreciate the discussion on that point um let's see rolling through um we talked maybe about page 14 thead Network second C St about M M24 versus M59 again I'll give this to you for your uh your benefit um to just go through um so I guess this is kind of a discussion point I'd like to get feedback from you
020Mr chair and others on the commission um on page 16 um there's a a large paragraph under the graph that um at the very bottom of it talks about um however however if those connections have not been built the township should consider the impact on the safety of the road Network when evaluating development proposals particularly those requesting density bonuses or land use changes I'm just wondering again how do we how do we make that I don't know if it's not an argument but how do we have language that helps support that that we don't get ourselves into trouble if we're trying to really highly encourage it but they say no they're not going to do it I well this is so in this specific it does speak to the two instances of you know your
021zoning ordinance has some instances where and I think it might just be the P where if you meet certain things you can grant them a density B meaning they're allowed more Lots than what normally would be allowed on the conventional plan and then the land use changes are resoning essentially so this this really relates more or less to those two instances where the plane commission does have some discretion to say yes or no not yes or no to the development but more or less yes or no to certain proposed improvements or aspects of the development that you feel do or don't meet your concerns so if a developer brings a preliminary site plan in front of us is it reasonable for us to request that they do a traffic safety study when presenting that of
022safety is seems to be the focus of this it depends on what they're pres it depends on what they're presenting so like again if they're presenting a an R1 project that meets the standards of R1 depending on how big it is it it we would likely require an engineering traffic study anyways and that's going to generate a report that then basically says levels of service and what they think it'll do to that um so you do get that information and you can use that information to say you know hey this is saying you should have a Dell Lane going into the development or this road currently doesn't have a a left-hand turn lane that needs to be a part of it and if the projects it's tough because only the county or M depending on
023the road would have the hammer to say you will do this or we won't give you the permits being the township you don't have jurisdiction over the road information's power you can put it in front of the developer to say like this traffic port's ugly what what are you guys going to do about it or what do you plan to do about it and they can sit here and say nothing they're going to hit a wall when they get to rcoc but that's if it's permitted by right you you really your power is inquisitive but it isn't necessarily denial unless you have Jim Sharp or your engineers telling you this is an absolutely awful design like we have we have very serious concerns about the safety of individuals is a handful of fender benders a
024year constitute safety that's where you get that's where you got to really look at the report and see what is it telling you and we would rely on Jim Sharp to kind of say when does it tip the needle into a s Health and Welfare conversation and they might the RCC might say you got to put in a left- hand turn lane and offer says no problem you know what I mean and then it's ass sign the next thing levels of operating service is a tough one because D is acceptable it's like the only place in the world where a D in your life is acceptable I'm just framing it to say that telling us the traffic isn't is going to get worse doesn't always stop the county from issuing the permit and isn't always
025give us the ability to say no unless there's something inherent in the design someone either a vehicle or a driver or pedestrian is is going to get hurt like you can foresee it just because it's that poor of a design this language speaks to puds and rezoning which again has more discretion you might say no we're not going to up the zoning because then you're going to bring a 500 unit development and there's no way the area can support that um so that right there though how do we make that don't we need a traffic study or something how do we make that statement I I would want to rely on folks who've done this more than I have in a rezoning you may be able to depending on the size of the lot and
026the type of deny that they want to go to you you may be in a position to require a traffic impact study as a part of that reone application but I would want to I'd want to talk to some folks before I came back and said yes to that for sure yeah it just sounds like that could be a feeling like we should have data that helps us drive that decision of we're we're not letting this happen for following reasons that that is supp not because I feel that the intersection is too busy that's all Y no like that's a good argument okay we have to be careful though causing extra cost on the developer or imposing extra cost on the developer something you may not really need to do so it's just something we'd
027have to be careful this study kind of blazs it out like you guys if I mean if you'll get more used them as you see that the traffic St these are thick but go to the end and at the end that that's where they line out these are the things you should do and they did that for that development from a few months ago yeah yeah and um and that level of service at drainer in 24 and that was just the county you know right now that particular development is trying to work with M that because of its proximity to M24 so okay thank you um keep on moving on try to get through this quick um we Mato we talked about see page 20 um the sentence at the bottom of page 20 where
028it says however there was not strong support for increasing the lot size of lots and it was referring to the community survey yeah and I and I mentioned that I thought that that was that word um not a strong support for increasing it really should be not a strong support for decreasing the size of lots so I was confused when I read that and based on what I remember of the the survey that there was that those were in conflict with each other that sentence and uh yeah and if again if my memory serves I do feel like I remember seeing those contradictions and the responses and again I mean we did those back in Mar we almost did those a year ago so if it was a response you was it like a written
029response that someone put in there because um I'm looking at well I was going to say all all of most of our responses were were select from you know the number of yeah it was make a selction not type something in so it's not it's not left up to interpretation as how someone wrote it or answered it it's really what they selected I just feel like there was a conversation about that question being worded in a way that may have been misunderstood by the people using it but again I want to go back I want to look into that further and if it's a typo on our end it's a typo on our end if it's not then I want to bounce back with Megan and see does this need kind of a note in
030parenthesis indicating that the question may have you know what I'm saying but but we have to be we have to be careful because if we can't see that for sure then then I can't put it in there okay yeah I just when I read it I thought it conflicted with the overall responses that is and I I'll repeat myself just for clarity to the other Commissioners that my interpretation of the serving results were as lot sizes were starting out 6,000 were small the smallest lot size there was less Desire by the overall Community to have that size of a lot and as the lot sizes got larger and larger the community was more in favor of those lot sizes yeah so like I said we'll I I'll look back on that one and as I
031think about that I think it was in our March uh 2024 or April um packet was the survey results for other planning Commissioners if they want to maybe go back to those packets and look at those survey results to help um maybe give you a an idea of how the of the new guys on the on the commission um to to look at those survey results it might be helpful I believe the survey results are on the township with s right down the front page oh are they it's listed survey survey okay great thank you that's thank you um page 21 um in the middle there there was a uh that Cobalt community research talked about number 164 million yep that seem that number I I question that it seems very high but um I'd
032be interested to understand a little bit more about that at some point point of um give you the opportunity to look at that um see along couple spelling things on page 22 just small stuff not a big deal and then on page 26 um we talked about there's five goals that are outlined and the first two goals are a repeat of each other yeah um it would be I'd like to know what those are if um if they redundant if there's one missing um yeah I'd have to dig back in the master plan from 2019 to see do you know if there were goals in that also similar to this were they transferred over from 19 is that well yeah I mean so we use those as the basis for how we develop the goals
033going forward so some of them are carry over and some of them are added in okay those seem pretty important right for our um as as I should think about well we everything we're trying to accomplish right when we went through like the implementation chapter a month or so ago oh it was in it was part of that I mean this is kind of derived from all the work that was done on noce it's almost it's almost like a summation of them see I think that that yeah that's that concludes that's it for me thank you okay thank you all right for commissioner blankinship any thoughts on the background uh chapter NOP I'm okay okay thank you commission F I made my request in the enlargement of all the maps so that they read in
034detail yep 100% commissioner Bailey uh a couple things on page 15 there's uh a table that talks about the high frequency intersection crash ranking um I know there was a reference that the most notable was leir Road and drainer question I had and the the next three I'll say M24 Oakwood Road West M24 Oakwood West 24 Oakwood West if you total those up that's substantially more than drainer and then if you look down M24 railroad M24 railroad how come we don't just put one with the total there is there different rankings for the accidents or it it may just be an error in the way that the that the table downloaded because a lot of this information comes from a lot of this information comes from sod and the county and it may have just
035been it may have just been a way in which it downloaded from there I mean obviously the the average crashes number changes but everything else in the column stays the same so let me let me look into that okay just because I mean we say that leir and draer is you know the most notable but yet you look at Oakwood and 24 there's 48 eight accidents which is if you add almost double what drainer is and then one other thing I had was page 20 you know we talk about the vacant uh land being developed we give percentages 69.3% of the vacant land in 83 has been developed there's 20 I'd be curious to maybe add acreage to kind of put that to perspective that hey there's 10,000 undeveloped acres or you know what what
036do that 20% make up so you're just saying the percentages of the Bacon Land also given an Acres yeah just kind of give it a a perspective that you know there's still so much and then um the other one that I would like to see is 23 P 23 you know we got a a small paragraph about the Township buildings the police fire schools uh senior programs Library things like that um I mean obviously people come to Oxford because it's Oxford they come looking possibly for jobs but the big thing that really draws people to this is one our community but two the schools and there's nothing really highlighted it's just yeah there's two districts there's 10 schools 12 schools whatever I almost think that needs to be a big highlight that you know the
037schools you know this Sur ification or what draws people to that Oxford school you know no offense but this would get somebody to go H they have a school and I think that needs to really be a focus is it like what is it that defines the quality of the school exactly you know are they you know in the top five or you know they're just you know where does it stand if somebody's outside of Oxford looking to come to Oxford they're not going to come because our police department has you know so many calls or the fire department does CPR again you know not a big deal but people are going to look at what does that school district have that's going to draw people in okay and uh same thing parks and wreck
038I I think there needs to be a substantially more highlight than that you know why would you want to come live here and come Recreation here so and and we can look at that facilities is really just to highlight how many like the services that you have and how many they are because you could argue right you got good police you got good you got but let me I don't think that there's anything in there about you know the harm in referencing the quality of of those Services sure so um yeah I me I will take a look at that I mean we do we have great police insired yeah that's what I mean but it's you know at the same time people that's the first thing they look to is if I'm moving to
039that Community what are their schools look like and what do they have to do outside of school let me I tell you what let me take a look at that those those remarks are valid they might just be valid somewhere else okay because this is talking about facilities and buildings but noted okay and next it for me on that part Comm Waker yeah so just to follow up on that I would certainly avoids platitudes saying hey we've got great police or or great whatever make sure it's fact base or some data be sure I did have one thing on page 27 water system um and it makes you make an interesting commment the water district was cly in good condition what does that mean to me it seems that seemed like a platitude well so
040and I it can be expanded upon expand on an as to why why you know that's it's I mean I don't know water quality is all this you know meets or exceeds expectations you know I don't know what you know whatever whatever the facts are that make it good yeah so like water quality or age of infrastructure yeah that's all I have so I was on the Planning Commission the steering committee so I have a little background on this stuff but to go off Corey what you were saying about obviously the Oxford Schools it might be like I just typed in a couple things why you would come to Oxford for the uh schools it's like highquality education inter baloria program focusing on Career technology Ed ation uh strong extracurricular programs small town fi excellent
041resources I don't know if that has to be in there or something like that but that's what draws people to a community so I don't know if that's exactly what they're looking for but as a as a parent of four kids you know when I came I've been born and raised in Oxford so I know what Oxford's about you know so like for me I can sell it to a lot of people and what it is but the thing is is like to have that in there that might be something that we don't have to say it's just good but why it's good why do they come no and again I think that there's I think there's a place for it this is I mean it this can be I want to say this can
042be whatever you want it to be but Master planes are not necessarily marketing tools they're policy documents and so like in your instance with Township the school district is its own entity right the Town School District can do whatever it wants Township this that the other but so what you can do is that you can highlight the fact that you have quality schools and that where possible Township policies should align with supporting you know the the continuation of the good school something along that nature so this is not that not that we don't want people from outside to read this and understand the community that you have but this is this is more geared towards policy than it is marketing but again valid points about that you have quality schools it's not an unfair statement
043to make in your master plan I think that's not work okay all right well let's see so make sure I'm not miss anything before move on the community profile and again as always you know this is this does not have to be the like the book does not close on this once we walk out of here if you think of something after you email us you call whatever it is um you know we do try to like as we move on from the meeting we try to keep tripping away and not going back to things that we've already discussed but again there's anything that comes back to the fact just let us know um so then the other the other section of the master plan that you had this evening is a community profile and
044so as I said this one's a little bit more Technical and there's a little bit more language as it relates to the projections of some of these numbers and where at least the numers say OS for is headed um and so as it relates to that are there any changes as far as contact or formatting you know the commission observed when reviewing it um let's see yeah let's go back to right to left commiss same it's kind of same thing with the map same thing with the maps um oh same thing with the maps Okay the um page 59 in there the the graphic on this I don't know if uh you see which one 59 page 59 yeah the graphics you want to scroll to that yep I get even on page 55 the
045graphics there are kind of you know less than desirable for a uh final I mean I yes you can keep going I I think there's a general consensus about everything you know any any any visual aid needs to be as big as it can without looking awkward the fair state right and having the just the clarity the imagees isn't very clear I'm not sure if it was snipped and dragged over how exactly how that worked but yeah this is an excuse I promise the the this formatting system that we use in design is like an amazing tool it is not user friendly at all so it's not that it was it's not that it was put in front of you this way this evening thinking that you'd be okay with it it was just we
046want to get the content out so you can see where where we're going with it I'd even be interested in seeing a before and after map side by side I Poss before and after as far as like just from a formatting perspective or just uh you know here's where we were here's where we are now you know then here's where we want to be type thing yeah we'll print you out a 2019 man you can from next to each other I walked into that yeah we're getting towards the end of our budget commissioner might just be printing at this point um okay uh sorry commissioner W check I'm good thank you commissioner M I'm good commissioner Turner commissioner Bailey I good with this one I I think you guys did a good job re thank
047but I'm good with commission Austin okay thank you very much yeah no thank you guys um yeah so with that um like I said we can kind of work on these edits um and again I'm happy to I know commissioner wall that has indicated that we can take his notes um I'd be happy to take anyone else's and get them back to you of course K can't I've got my feedback here um but if there's any other questions I'm happy to take them like I said we're open we're shooting for mid-February end of February to have a full draft to you guys um and so the process from there is you take one last look at it again we can edit from there but once the planning commissioner is comfortable with where it is we
048hold a public hearing and then it goes out for 63 days uh to the to your community neighbors and any kind of public utility or infrastructure that runs to the community they have 63 days to respond if they come back with nothing or if they come back with some notes that you want to consider we can further update from there and then from that point it's on to the Township board for its approval and it will be adopted so we are probably on trajectory for late spring if I if you don't mind um just because we have so many new members um I think giving us more time to once you get to that 90 plus% where we're starting to review it I would um ask if you can give us more than say a
049week if we get a packet say on T Thursday for the following Thursday to review a master plan that's 150 whatever Pages no I I agree I don't I don't want to put it in I don't want to set it out Thursday and expect you guys in seven days to come back with it um so let me kind of work with my superiors on how that falls in the timeline but yeah I want to give you more than your standard packet review once it's a full draft you advice on with with myself and new members how we might besides the survey results reviewing those be ready for that ready for that review of the draft final draft yeah I mean that makes sense finding I'm not sure no it'sa right it's tough because it's not
050going to be well it can be whatever you'd like it to be although I think you're bylaw say your meetings you have to end at 10 but I'm going through 150 Pages Page by page that's not what it is it's really kind of read it to front to back and did it flow right did it flow the way did it tell the story that the master plan's kind of meant to tell like here's where we are right here's where we've been here's where we are here's where the numbers say we're going here's the stuff that's important to us and here's what we're going to do about it that's I mean that's what this document should read beginning to end and so not to say that if there is something that just strikes you as we
051we still need to address this or we still need to change this or I don't think it was strong enough here we can still make those edits but when it comes time to for that meeting it won't be a page by Page conversation does that make sense again I'm not not that I'm not going to answer questions I just that's we'll look for an empty agenda and you guys can bring some Red Bulls we be here for a while okay there's no further questions I'll thank you take a seat all right well thank you very much thank you okay moving on to number 11 new business I'm sure that everybody has heard and received the resignation notice from uh Vice chair Jonathan n effective January 14th uh in order for that to be effective uh
052we need a motion and a vote by this committee or this board I'll make a motion she accept the resignation of Vice chair Jonathan effective January 14th Mr chair um he dated his letter the 14th but it's not effective until it's accepted so the motion should read today's date okay because like in the minutes you're going to see he's still in the minutes until this motion is adopted okay because he's technically still a member perfect thank you okay Mr chair if I can make a motion to accept the resignation of Vice chair John N Jonathan n the fact of January 23rd 23rd 2025 second okay so we have a motion we have a second any discussion just like to than for service yeah same here um John was a very very valuable asset to this
053board um I learned quite a bit and appreciated everything he helped me uh get into the here all in favor favor any opposed okay motion carries with that with him being Vice chair um we now have an opening in the uh Vice chair position and I think Cheryl you had sent out notice that according to our bylaws uh in order to be in any of those positions it requires one year of service prior um which would leave uh the current secretary Turner and uh Mr Vosk uh as eligible candidates for that um so we would need a nomination um and an acceptance of a nomination for either of these gentlemen don't everybody jump at once just a reminder that commissioner Turner is currently the secretary so if somebody nominates him as Vice chair then we
054will have to nominate a secretary correct I'd like to nominate Bob Turner is question CH accept are you would you accept that nomination would you like that position I'd rather accept secretary position if that is accept okay all right then I'll accept Okay so you also need a second so we have a motion we need a second second okay we have a motion we have a second to all in favor any oppos congratulations now we have an open position for secretary now you can pay back I'd like to make a motion that uh we elect [Music] Don I was going to help you with the last name okay go ahead I'm trying to force your hand no as Secretary of the Planning Commission and I'm assuming you would accept that I would accept that so
055we have a motion we need a second I'll second all in favor all right congratulations that motion carries um the next uh um item is appointment to the ordinance Review Committee I know Mr mold was on that um I'm currently the alternate so I think we'll just leave that one for now um and uh we'll address that down the road if we need to item D 2025 Planning Commission meeting schedule has everybody reviewed that any questions or concerns with that uh may I absolutely I just want to make sure I understand what the orc position is so right now you are going to stay in the alternate role and at a future meeting you will appoint the third person correct and again life happens but you're you're okay with the orc meeting schedule as it
056is now correct okay just want to make sure correct no appreciate that y um and I'm assuming we need a motion for the calendar yes okay anybody like to make a motion to approve our 2025 calendar Mr chairman I like to make a motion that we accept the calendar of meetings for the calendar year 2025 has published I believe we received them during the last meeting okay we have a motion a second we have a motion we have a second any discussion or anything you need to adjust on that calendar seeing none all in favor I any opposed that motion carries um item 12 uh we removed uh earlier so we will move on to communication committee reports the uh ordinance Review Committee the ordinance Review Committee Meed met this afternoon uh basically it consisted
057of the uh Dave here uh Jack Curtis and myself we looked at the workload plan for this this year 2025 mov some things around adjusted them and we will plan on having them here at our first meeting in February for your review and acceptance absolutely one thing just to note and I this could have been part of plan a report too is um after the meeting the I noticed that we will very very likely have a special land use hearing and site plan review on the 13th I don't think that'll stop us from having the work plan on the agenda as well but I just wanted to I just wanted to throw that out there as well as the 13th you will have site plan special land is 95% sure of that I don't think
058the I don't think that stops the work plan from being on there it may it may hold us back from putting master plan stuff on just because we don't I mean too many heavy lifs in the meeting isn't a good thing all right and your next meeting is the 13th yes all right any uh planner engineer reports pretty much just gave it you 13th would probably that special land use I planed so actually I should for the new members so special land uses require public hearings and the way that that's set up is there are uses in your community that are deemed to be either more intense or more impactful than just what are standard permitted uses so special land uses when they do a site plan for that use they have to give us
059a site plan but then they also have to give us a special luse application in which the ordinance has specific items in which or criteria that they have to meet as well some of that criteria can be subjective right so it is a a lot of what you'll do for permitted uses is objective if they meet the requirements it's pretty much a yes special land use is a little bit of subjectivity to it um but one of the more important things is that public hearings require notice of every property owner within 300 ft of the proposed use so when we inform you that you'll probably have a special land use public Hearing in front of you it wouldn't be unrealistic to think that this room might have more well this this room would have more
060folks in than it does now because there's nobody here but probably you'll have a larger turnout for those meetings um and those meetings can take a little bit longer because you do offer the public um a certain amount of time to come them to voice their concerns in which you can take that into consideration for your decision and I believe correct me if I'm wrong Susan our bylaws we do have the availability to stop a meeting at 10:00 if they're running excessively long to where we can table the discussion at 10 yeah okay I'm not I don't think this is going to run of time but not it would but the point well taken just that they typically are longer meetings and typically you have a few more folks to okay Mr chair yes ma'am
061um I know there's not technically a another comment spot but because we have so many new members and that there will be a site plan special land use just some um procedural etiquette things the Planning Commission does not engage verbally with the applicant or the audience all communication goes through the chair the applicants address the chair it's not a back and forth and the only other thing um just a reminder that a motion requires a second it's not support because you can second a motion that you don't support so it's a second for a motion and then any discussion that takes place is discussion of the commission it's not discussion where somebody in the audience raises their hand and they I have something to say now once a motion is made and it is seconded
062that motion belongs to to the commission and the commission alone it doesn't belong to the public at all so just remember that these meetings the Township board meetings the zba meetings there a meeting of this body the public is welcome to attend the welcome uh the the public has time for input but it's not their meeting it's your meeting to conduct business that you have been tasked to conduct so just kind of keep that in your mind when meetings are going on and to kind of play off of that too we're working with Cheryl on scheduling a training where we'll we'll find an agenda that's going to be light or doesn't have anything scheduled for it and we'll get everyone together for typically a training where our our firm and your legal counsel kind of
063walk you through what can you do and can't you do at a meeting based on what you're reviewing um we won't be able to do that before next next meeting but I don't I don't I'm I'm going to not that would I don't think what's coming in front of you is turn the world upside down it's ESP special a use in a residential area um but the project itself the applicant seem to be very organized and prepared to present to you um one thing I would say that we're working on with Cheryl as well is uh the Michigan State University extension program offers something called citizens planner and it is a online course that you can take and it's I've taken it um it's very it's it is written explicitly for you guys you're not
064planers you're not you know developers you're not you know what I'm saying like you're you're not part of a lot of the folks that you're going to see come and go from this dayas it's it is specifically crafted for folks looking at it from your point of view um and you will go through it and you'll say this is kind of hokey and corny and it is but it is it's a very good program for you to kind of understand again what you can and can't do what your roles are um and so we're working with Cheryl to because we've got another seat to fill it's a little pre I'm assuming we'll be able to get that filled relatively quickly but we don't want to do a training if we're not a full board yet
065we don't want to run anything through systs planer if you're not a full board yet but we'll work with her to get you guys um hopefully signed up for something like that and it's it's self-paced um but it's it's good thank you thank you even at the training though we should think about recording it so we do get new folks that get this we go and watch it watch it you know I gotta feed my kids too you know trying to cut me out here no no I know I hear yeah yeah I mean there there are I mean not even just for art train there are a lot of online tools and if you you know if you want to go down the the Google rabbit hole and say even email us to say
066hey I found this do you know anything about it is it worth it so on so we'd be happy to guide or if you have questions straight up in these instances what can we and can't do on we're here to answer those questions thank you very much with that I will entertain a motion for adjournment Mr chairman I'll make a motion that the planning meeting of January 23rd 2025 be closed a second we have a motion we have a second all in favor I we are adjourned