001okay like to call to order tonight's Charter Township of Oxford Planning Commission regular meeting November or I'm sorry Thursday January 9th 2025 if we could start the meeting uh with everybody Rising pay respects to our flag FL United States of America to the rep for it stands one nation thank you if we could note the role note it just a reminder make sure you speak into your microphone and make sure that the green light is on if you if you think it's on it's probably not it will be bright green you you'll know it's when you hit the on button I do intentionally okay thank you very much uh moving on to number four approval of the agenda for tonight Mr chair I'd like to make a motion that we approve tonight's agenda January 9th
0022025 for the Planning Commission regular meeting no second okay we have a motion we have a second any discussion all in favor I I any opposed seeing none that car carries item number five conflict of interest expart contact anything anybody needs to disclose this evening okay seeing none we will move on to number six approval of the minutes Planning Commission regular meeting December 12th 2024 Mr chair I'd like to make a motion with we approve the December 12th 2024 Planning Commission regular meeting minutes I'll second the motion okay we have a motion we have a second any discussion seeing none all in favor I I any opposed seeing none motion carries moving on to number seven public comment on items not scheduled for public hearing or on this agenda seeing none we will move on
003to number eight uh commissioner comments anybody have anything they'd like to go over the you guys want to introduce themselves that would be great yeah sure Dave Wagner I'm one of the trustees that was recently elected from this last election look forward to working with everyone here on this committee uh you know to to work with you and do better for for Oxford I'm Mark lincol ship I was appointed last night and the seasoned veteran yeah there's another new guy to me I'm sorry my own bus there another new guy who's not here tonight I do know that yeah he's not starting off good missing the first night we'll have give him next uh time okay moving on to number nine public hearing which I do not believe we have uh anything on the agenda
004this evening so let's move to 10 unfinished business Master Plan update good evening good evening Commissioners M Paka car Wartman Associates with the planning consultants for the township happy New Year get that out of the way and the new Commissioners welcome um you know as I worked with the other Commissioners if there's anything we can do or explain or as we go through the evening you know the materials this evening whatever questions you have I'm happy to answer um so for tonight's Master Plan update we have two items uh to go over the design guidelines draft as well as the safety path priorities uh portion of the master plan let me just see which one's queued up first in the packet here almost there design is it design okay all right so for design guidelines
005so um a while back a few months ago uh we had highlighted the fact that your current master plan does not have design guidelines and had gauged interest in whether or not you would like the upcoming master plan to have it uh you did so we kind of went through it and outlined uh some specific areas as well as kind of descriptions of those areas and what kind of you know aesthetic Design Elements we might want to incorporate into those uh so tonight what you have in front of you it's not the first time you've seen it we've edited this a few times but this is kind of the final draft that we're putting forward uh for the current master plan and so I wanted to kind of go through the questions that we have
006in the memo um and again we'll kind of I'll kind of work my way left to right or right to left so get new Commissioners any questions you have whatever comments you may have you know happy to work with you on those I know it's uh we'll get you up the speed uh but it won't all happen tonight so we'll do what we can um the questions really relate to the general language of the of the guidelines was really this first page and then as we kind of go through it the specific descriptions of each district and the design objectives you know I'm essentially looking feedback for uh feedback on all of it um so I'm happy to kind of do it in sections I'm happy to kind of do it all at once but
007we'll kind of start with commissioner n do you have any thoughts or comments on the design guidelines I have a couple thoughts and comments on uh we talk about the Aesthetics development goals I think we need to write that out as a definition if we're going to use that term and that's in your cover letter but that those are the questions that we were asked uh later in the letter right above you respectfully guidelines are not required but if Incorporated the master plan can provide reference for developers on community goals as well as informed Township decisions upon zoning requirements for building materials landscaping and parking Etc I think we need to be very conscious of that and carry that through the three different areas and you want to talk about the three different areas now
008or you want to start how you want to handle things no we can discuss so the the design guidelines are broken out into three separate areas correct the first the first one that I that I'd like to add comment to is the design guidelines for M24 on the initial page of that the bottom is the enhanced signage requirements now I know we did a a signing ordinance update so what what does that mean enhanced signing requirements or we doing more are we just referring to the what is the ordinance of today or which which specific part of M24 are you referring to it says design guidelines oh the front page okay is yeah no I mean I think it's I think it's you can make reference to where if like you right we redid the
009signage um but if we're going to in incorporate design elements into the structures do we want those design elements complemented into the sign requirements as well as far as you know the signage theme or the colors of the materials matching that what the building because currently we don't have that not saying we have to but that's what it would be referring to we the Planning Commission did a field trip had a launch out and then we we drove 24 and in driving 24 was part of that was dividing up into the three sections that we have today but the other part was that we took a poll on what poll what type of signs we had whether it was a poll sign or different the many different signs throughout each of the three districts so
010all that I hate to see that work that we did on that afternoon out and all the discussions we had go to not be identified in this uh master plan so if we're going to if signage is important then we need to expand that signage a little bit in the master plan so that the possibility of a of a renovated piece of property can't use the existing sign unless it meets our design standards and we address that in the ordinance but do we need to talk more about that I don't know that it necessarily needs to I mean I'm not saying doesn't need to find it way to the master plan but the new ordinance itself I mean has the the the non-conforming language and you know the variance option language this would really just
011be speaking the form and the function of it which would enhance what you have not necessarily um water it down if that's what the the what I what I'd like to see is the nonwater down master plan so that that's my first issue I don't know if you want to talk to the other board members in regards to the the verbiage there but I have a few others if you want to continue no I mean let's M sorry Mr no would it satisfy you if we had Mr pasaka in parentheses behind the enhanced sign requirements reference the ordinance by number that is a really good thought I don't know if we want to go to that detail because if we were to change something and the number were to change now we have to go
012back and do another revision on our master plan is that correct you wouldn't necessarily revise your master plan it just would have it wouldn't have the correct information in it maybe the terminology could be the the latest U signs signage ordinance sure and then that would help us with the numbers if that's all right with you commiss I'm trying to satisfy what you think is your requirement well I'm just bringing it out for conversation if we change a sign ordinance does a number change yeah version one version two version three and it get goes from there gotta yeah I think reference to whatever the late latest ordinance is would be appropriate you don't want to you don't want to get yourself in a in a mode where you're having to update multiple documents every time
013you pass a new ordinance that's fine I just think the current sign ordinance does not speak to you you got to make it out of brick you got to do it this way or that way which is really kind of what design gu might speak to I'm not arguing for signage is very important corre we need to okay well you could also say uh enhanced signage requirements per the latest sign Orin okay so you don't lose the fact that we already have an ordinance okay that's good thank you I like that okay uh going on page 28 now we're into the M24 South District SCD drainer uh minak and drive we call out some specifics in your design objectives the last one on the right is encourage use of brick we we don't carry the
014brick throughout the other three districts We Carry Out generalities do we want to call out brick in this specific area from uh South Center District drainer to minaka or do you want to be not so specific you're asking yourself that question I am no no I know I'm trying to no no I and and it brings up a good point because guidelines are guidelines and so they they can be I guess as specific as brick or they could be as general as high quality materials which has found its way into the document a few times right and really more or less what the what the guideline element does is it can be a reference for a developer to say gosh if I throw this stuff in here probably gets me a few brownie points and
015we can kind of go from there but if it's not in a zoning ordinance it's just not required but what this can do is if this is adopted these design anales are adopted it then gives the township the ability to go forward and say okay when we do our zoning maintenance where we do update our ordinance we're going to incorporate some of these design elements into it and we're going to apply some technicalities to them so one of the examples I used earlier what today was um like window coverage requirements you know 30% of your facade that faces M24 in this District must be window must be glazing you know or 50% of your facade must be brick you know and then the other 50% can be uh you know fiber cement boards or treated
016wood or something of that nature that part doesn't need to be here the language about a high quality material needs to be here so so the encourage of brick I think was just more of an attempt to to follow in the Aesthetics of what is in the village but it it does not have to be here incourage brick could come or no let me build on that a little bit in the other ones you talk about quality building materials you talk about desired building materials and Landscaping do we need to take brick out of here and make it more General to high quality materials no no I like buzzword tell yeah no high quality materials is a puzz word it just offers you the generality so that when we get to the point of adding
017the technicals to it we've got some leg room to say this that and the other okay is there just I think there's a proposal to to replace that with high quality materials I take brick out okay because we can't hold anybody to it no that's fine is that a general we'll get to everybody's comments but for now is the take the brick out of the first one well I think encourage the use of brick is what it says doesn't say need to use brick or anything like that right so I mean encouraging it I don't see the language I think would encourage the use of high quality materials I think to John's point is to kind of open broaden out a little bit and then if we go technical with the zoning orience we could
018then say brick or we could then say whatever all right is that you're getting at yes thank you and can you put approved instead of high quality who's approving it yeah we can't my understanding is my only thing is my interpretation of what's considered a high quality product in your qu version of high quality could be the difference between OSB sighing and no 100% and that's why if the design guidelines go into the final of the adopted master plan with generalities we then have the the position to say okay now we're going to update the zoning ordinance this says high quality materials orc gets together what's high quality it's brick it's wood it's this it comes to you guys you know you know the process right expand um other notes uh commissioner n uh 30
019we talked about desire building material I think we've covered that yeah I think we've covered that and then on page 32 uh in the second paragraph the right hand side it says the stat of multif family and dense housing options and close proximity to new developments design can be Town Homes attached residential my comment to myself was we need to make sure that the zoning gets changed if we're going to call it out in the master plan we need to have the zoning maps and the zoning change to allow that do you want to get that tight in in describing that and I think that's a fair point of feedback for all the Commissioners to offer yeah I think John once the master plan gets approved then we need to go back and take it
020and go against the zoning ordinances and have the orc look at updating correcting do whatever to make the two in line with one another and maybe if I can commissioner n tell me if I'm right or wrong what you're displaying is you're saying if it's here and we decide to move forward with it that would mean that portions of this Northern M24 area would obviously have industrial or large commercial zoned but then adjacent to it we would be opening the opportunity to zos as a denser residential adjacent to it absolutely okay so for or against that kind of thought process for that area I think that's one of the points that commissioner n is making so the wording in there is specific about a denser style of Housing and it references the missing mle from
021the perspective of if we're going to promote that type of you know that type of development up there this type of housing might support that um but again it also comes with zoning implications as well and then the last one I go back to page 28 the top paragraph intent we referenced The Village uh consistent top paragraph consistent design principles with flexible long configurations and amending will complement the style of the village while maintaining the distinc enity of the township I've had the opportunity to sit on the village Planning Commission we work very hard at maintaining the Aesthetics of the village I'd like to see us uh complement that on the township side that we want we want to complement the style of Village as well if it applies in that in the in that
022area okay it's just a comment and I I close the book and that relates us kind of just with your role and the the relationship between the two just being that of of a higher importance the coordination okay okay great thank you um commissioner wager no I have no questions I'm good okay nicely done by the way thank you appreciate that commissioner Bailey just a a question on page 34 oh this is the time for compliments Mr wag start okay that's fine I'd like to have oh yeah John we want to go back to John I got nothing to add there then yeah turn go for it what you got just just out of curious page 34 or uh the township should consider the cost of construction and developing guidelines my only concern with that
023is and and I could be reading this wrong is do we want is that going to say that if it can't look a certain way we don't want it or we should settle for a lesser thing because it's affordable to whoever is going to build there yeah it's it's a great question so both both some of you know and or know or don't know but in a former life I worked in commercial real estate development and and I also work in some communities right now who have design guidelines that they implemented converted to zoning ordinances were very very very particular about what they wanted which I don't have any problem with at all I mean that's the point um but some of the requirements are so specific and in some ways challenging to today's design
024and construction methods that the cost of development in that area is somewhat prohibited for the market that they have and it has either a stifled projects coming to them or when they come to them they are flooded with waiver requests so it's not my comparison of you to the other communities that I work with is not Apples to Apples in any way shape or form but that's the point is that you you should establish some standards for these districts if you want them um establishing materials for facades or percentages that is not not unreasonable saying you want everything to look like 1880s you know Baroque America that might be a problem okay and that's not what the other community does because this is public and I don't need them watching and getting mad at me
025that's not what they do but that's the example okay it's all okay okay Turner uh on page 32 in you see it on your map on page 33 my question is this area you indicate goes from Dunlop to THS and my question is why that doesn't go in state all the way to davidon Lake Road which is the upper end of the township if I'm not mistaken it's the the types of development that we're talking in this section are much larger format and once you get north of Tom it's Tom Thomas Road there's a lot smaller lots and it's not it's not really conducive to these large scale things that we discussing um that's not to say it couldn't be redeveloped as such someday um but I guess that would be the reason for why
026it was left out I would think you'd put it in just to make sure you've got it I mean on the south and on the township you went all the way down to Indian Lake Road yes and there's areas down there that are hard to develop what's left yeah yeah I'm just I I think I think from a design guideline perspective M I don't think it's any harm to run it up there I think if we start digging into zoning ordinance we got to dial them a little bit more just to make sure we're not generating bunch of non-conformities or something I'd like to suggest if I might that I I don't I'd like to see a map of that and see how would fold in into the M24 Highway View District and take Mr
027Turner's comment and if it if we can fold it in let's by all means do it up to Davis Lake but I don't have a you're talking about like you'd like to kind of see an areial of well to to make a final determination on this to see you know we have a very nice map that you've given us with property lines and we can we can kind of tell the largest of the properties and things like that I don't know what it is right off the top of my head from Thomas Road up to Davis Lake let's take a look give me a second here every now then when they use this and I type in Oxford it takes me to the United Kingdom and it's like this visual shock I'm like no no
028that's that doesn't look right like that looks a little dense for what we're dealing give it a second here oh you know what there we go once you get north of Thomas we actually don't have a lot of properties that actually front leir roads the property back up that's why I wanted to see it because I thought the same thing yeah could you go up a little further go all the way up to big bed Davis SL right this or no y yeah so Mr Turner how does that map look to you try it like I said it's a little lagged but I'll try to zoom in a little bit more just so we can yeah we just we past Thomas we don't have a lot of properties in front so my question is do
029we need it well the only thought is it could change property I'll reverse the question what would it hurt to include it well that's my point i' like to see it included I think in a lot of points and things of items we tend to forget the little village of Thomas and the activ in that area is there a majority thought either way of expanding it one way or the other I mean I I I will tell you that I don't think from a guideline perspective because we aren't talking about something that's required that there's any harm in extending it there's obviously a reason why we didn't but when but it's just something we're going to be cognizant of if the orc takes it on and starts applying standards to things I have no problem
030extending it yeah I'm good extend in it will this affect any of the property owners today if we extend it and they decide to try to sell property is there going to be a oh this is changing as a master plan guideline no okay it's it's just the fact that you've kind of set the path for you know you guys are all gone there's a new group in front of you they want to update the zoning ordinance they looking at the master plan you put together there is grounds to start thinking about applying those requirements to that area okay I would just my only hesitation would be somebody not being able to sell a five or penny for parcel because we've changed it yeah other than that I'm good for that reason I would concur
031okay to to expand it to not oh to not okay again I I don't think we're I I would think we are in a in a better position at this point to to not extend it it's something that can be it it's something that doesn't stop you if you want to think about it later up goinging about other mechanisms to consider it that's that's my that's my thought that's tough I mean think we got to I think now I'm starting to be a little worried about any unintended consequences so I'm going to withdraw my extended the done is that zoned up there residential R something sorry that's fine want to hear from your planning consultant R something uh it's it's residential um I think the larger the R3 is what we have up there just
032wonder if there's a ripple effect of some sort that we're not making out at this point in time I I don't see because of the because of the time it's going to take for utilities to get up there to support the kind of design for the types of businesses that we're talking about you will get another run at this master plan before that kind of development pressure gets that far north I think this master plan good for five years five years sorry yeah well with with that comment a question I would have is would that prohibit us from saying hey we should run utilities up there why it's residential already you're asking should you run infrastructure up there because there's residential already um no I mean I think the I think the expansion of of
033infrastructure of mid peer is more Economic Development based on Industrial and Commercial diversity than this residential development okay feel like we're humbling around a consensus to to leave it as is does that your recommendation is you drew it to that point for a reason yes if your recommendation is to leave it there Bob how do you feel I have no problem either way yeah I can I can leave it there I was wanting to understand why yeah was a fair point we didn't take it all the way to the end of the township okay thank you did you have other comments on the design guidelines no that was the okay commissioner blanken sh I'm okay for now is I haven't had a tremendous amount of time to I was going to say you should like
034hit me with just start going on this huge list I it's impressive just thank no no that's fine any questions along the way let me know I appreciate it commissioner W um so you know we spoke earlier today just kind of going through some of these and um as I'm going through it I'm thinking about traffic and pester and safety the whole time right and how as this Corridor starts to become more and more say we'll call it developed but or redeveloped that could bring more residential more people into the area biking walking whatever um in there safe and you know 24 is a pretty heavily traveled road so um those are kind of I always had that base of thought as I'm going through thinking about you know how are people in this community
035going to enjoy these amenities and and do it safely and um so I kept on as we talked earlier I keep on thinking about traffic studies and traffic and yeah congestion and all those things so um but back to the guidelines um the uh let's see we'll go to the uh page 28 I had a few comments um just looking at this um we talked about that comprehensive traffic study happening um in another way right would help us make decisions or help us um steer our thoughts when um developments come our way um in the uh the loss or the um level of service of some of the traffic lights that we currently have and how some of these um these designs adding more traffic might affect current levels of service that are already um
036but you know the overall building design um on 28 you know looking at the um more brick I actually I put a check mark next to that because I thought of that and the high quality materials however we want to work that as fine but I do like encouraging um the use of brick um one of the questions I had about residential uses on upper floors it's the last bullet or the second from last bullet point in the uh design objectives promote ground level commercial retail with residential uses on upper floors is there a high demand are we finding there's a high demand for that and I'm just thinking if we you know promote this but there's no demand or high level of vacancy does that I think aesthetically it looks great for kind of
037a downtown field but you look up and down that 24 Corridor there's a lot of breaks in those types of buildings um so I'm I'm in favor of it I just as I'm you know speaking with the Commissioners and Gathering our thoughts about it is you know how far do we want to push that design style um this is basically between minak and drainer right yeah just south of the village okay and there's just some large gaps in there that would there it seem very choppy and not a lot of continuity yeah it's it it's funny because the first development that would be done in that area like this would stick out like a sore thumb the 10th one that gets done like this will look perfect so it's kind of you you are kind
038of in a position to see if you can't get the ball rolling on it as far as the mixed use element is concerned I mean I will say this much as far as I mean everybody knows housing is in demand right but I will say that again either working with other communities or in a formal life running Pro formance for develop ments with the way housing is right now um the residential element of it is what makes the development work that the developer isn't the developer is almost there pitching the retail because it's required they want the residential above because the rental for the residential outpaces the retail um if you make retail too much of it it starts to screw with the numbers and and it falls apart but as far as a demand
039for it I would say that a yes from a an economic development standpoint there's demand for it also it helps bolster what retail you are looking to promote there um you know bodies on the ground feet on the sidewalk things like that and again and then and I as we talked earlier you know buildings that might be vacant or vacant space you know message that sends you mean if if if it gets built and that leased up right yeah I mean it's it probably doesn't come to you as a speculation type of project if it if it gets to us they've probably got their tenant um but yeah know I I get that you don't want to build a bunch of spaces that could be challenges down the road um I don't I think residential
040allowing residential above or in some form of density nearby um can only help the retail element and the downtown development of it I don't think it could hurt it and again being guidelines where you kind of put your rubber to the road on this is if we decide to go you know if we decide to develop a mixed use zoning area in your map um or like you know some sort of overlay that would allow this because right now you don't have a mixed use zoning District excuse me not sure if it matters but I'm aware that there's kind demand in the village of O currently there is demand yes okay I just see some vacant buildings you know when I'm picture driving up 24 and I look at you know the corner of drainer
041as an example it it's there's vacant buildings yeah um and I know we can't solve that here but I just want to be kind of aware of that um as we're looking at making recommendations on building types um the uh on page 30 there is a comment about um design objectives of for first PLL up Point develop commercial areas to complement new and existing residential um I just I think about roof Heights and other things that could impact existing structures or existing um people in the area and being you know conscientious of the buffers that to to afford those and um building Heights for views depending on you know elevations of course and um in particular I think about you know they're building those phase two and phase three right now um I think the
042gentleman with Deion claves might be here tonight but they have a beautiful view treey view looking to the South and the the West and um you know building buildings or um two three story buildings in that area or maybe Zone and be okay to do it um it might change their views a little bit so I'm not saying we have to do it just for that area but I want to be just aware of it as we're we're looking at some of these guidelines okay um and I think one of my last points on here is really about um it kind of goes back to pedestrian safety again about you know there's one bridge that goes over for the pan Trail over M24 and if there's opportunity through if not this may be our next
043topic about safety paths about looking at either some sort of a pedestrian bridge or a tunnel under M24 and I know that might sound for pedestrian traffic and it might sound very challenging to do that but it seems like they would only become more and more challenging to do something like that in the future um and I I think about the Ray Road area by Stony Lake as development happens up in that that area there may be the need to get across 24 and with speed limits being what they are it seems like it would be a good idea for us to take that into consideration and look at so would you across all three districts would you kind of be looking for something that references you know pedestrian Crossing safety you know I mean
044like what like for the Village area it would be something like crosswalks for something like North lier we probably do start talking about as farfetch is it may seem a bridge or a tunnel but you're just thinking maybe a reference to a context appropriate like pedestrian Crossing in each one of the districts just some reference to it yeah it's hard to put that a design guideline right that's more of a safety path item isn't it yeah uh yes and I I would say yes and no I mean it's not to say that it as part of a a pedestrian connection requirement that if development proves to if someone wants to put in a really big development along 24 and we know it's going to generate some crosswalk traffic and speed limits are 55 then it
045opens up a as long as it makes its way into some part of the zoning or it's a conversation opens up to say okay we we need this Improvement out of this well wherever you think we'd recommend putting it maybe in some of the master plan orings somewhere if the Commissioners don't have any you know comments either way um good or bad but I think you know as I see things like that that there's that um Boulder Point has that c pass tunnel 24 and to build something like that I think that was there from you know history right from uh gra activities and right that's a huge asset and um not that it's used frequently by the public but a tunnel like that you I see tunnels like that under major roads in other
046cities other areas to get pedestrians to lakes ponds other walking paths things like that sure just helps connect it all okay safely especially right yeah okay isn't that the one that uh Amazon tried to uh yes drive through that that's a different one that's a different one but that is a good one that goes underneath Market Street yeah that's a good picture Mr chair sure I i' like to make a suggestion of Don put that on page 26 the design guidelines for M24 that would cover that as one of your bullet points the following elements are incorporated into the defign guidelines as we put a general statement expressing that of Don you're talk about here gotcha got and and then Mr chair if I might I have one more comment that I'd like to have
047cover all three areas yes the comments on page 30 on the right hand side incorporate the use of service drives and de acceleration Lanes deceleration Lanes I'd like that to be put on design guidelines for M24 on page 26 along with that that's fine the only reason that the only one that it's not a part of is the part just south of the village and only because from from a development standpoint if they were to develop corners of M24 and take down three or four buildings then that might be a time to have a service truck in in the area just south of the village yes okay I mean we can put it in there I I cover it covers it in the event is there any any anyone against that idea I'm not saying
048that they should I just want to make sure if I'm in that we kind a consensus what was the question to add a what add incorporate the use of service PR and de deceleration Lanes as a bullet item on page 26 which references all of the district not the three individuals the whole stretch I don't is there room to put a service dri if they were to do a massive development of some sort you would want that we have situations where Culver is where that uh in that area that we have problems with the service Drive matter of fact one of the service drives is a parking lot but I I think we need to cover those bases so when the developers come in and decide they're going to do a massive change we need
049that needs to be covered in that okay good all right well that's I got one last comment for you hold off the um well the recognizable and subst ual benefit is a term that was used in some other documents in some of our previous reviews and that wording I really like that wording and seeing it in um in our design guidelines so if you see opportunities to put something like that in there as you know development guidelines that they we want to bring recognizable and substantial benefit to the community um with that I I don't know exactly how you would word that but um if if we if find spot work that's yeah like lean on that language when we're doing a review and um and thinking about the community as a whole and something
050when a adult comes along okay thank you yeah no problem thank you okay all right with that we move on to safety paths so again as we work our way through the master plan and the different sections that need to be updated and reviewed um the safety path priorities section um is another one that we've identified uh and so tonight what you have in front of you is a memo that kind of highlights um we basically took the draft or the U the priority map from the 2019 plan we checked off all of the paths that have been developed we highlighted the paths that are in that 2019 plan but we're also identified in the community outreach uh event um and really are just looking for your feedback on I'll get to it here um
051you know what routes prioritized in the 2024 master plan Community openhouse should be added to the priority safety path extension table again not all of the routes identified in the community outreach uh or in the community openhouse um are on the list as it is now um we did label them from kind of a high priority to a medium priority we can kind of go through those um what routes from the 2019 plan that have not been built should stay on and are there any revisions to that sections language um that you guys would recommend um from here tonight what I'm hoping to do is get the planning commission's feedback on these items uh and then with that I'll kind of take that feedback along with this information and it will go to the safety
052path committee for their review as well um so I guess this is maybe this is kind of the most relevant piece to take a look at of the gate is this is the table from the 2019 plan all of the routes with a strike through have been built the two that are highlighted um the community identified uh past this past March in the openhouse as a high priority routes that they would like to see developed and then this is the map from that event um and then the routes that were identified in the open house that are not on that map or I'm sorry that are not in the 2019 plan our M24 from drainer to Indian Lake uh Bar Road from Lakeville Road to East drainer tan view from Seymour Lake Road to West
053Riner and Baldwin from Seymour Lake Road to West Riner Road um but again those were those last three are median priorities um and I do know that the safety the sa so one of the considerations or the more recent consideration for the safety path committee is um I believe trying to extend the path from where it exists um as opposed to picking certain El portions of the township where it might not it might be building new from end to end not to say that there isn't a strategy there um but I believe the focus is shifting a little bit more towards building off what is existing extending what you have um so with that uh I went left to right last time so we'll go right to left you're up down so adding um say
054if the main paths are H Trail and there some main arteries that are um the most traveled and branching off of those seems to makes the most sense versus building say a mile or half mile long safety path that connects to not much that would be my my input on that I I think adjusting the priorities you know Crossing off the ones that have been complete um it seems like the public although I think it was voted down in November but Priority One that connection the public still still seems to want that so my my be Del leave that as number one um and then just adjust all the other priorities up um looking at the Sanders Road that's supposed to be paved at some point in the near future isn't it does it make
055sense or do those projects work together um excuse meow um I would have to double check what the engineering as to whether or not if if the township works with rcoc to pay a road whether not the safety path goes in as well or if it's strict strictly developed vment specific so I will have to double check on that okay um let's see and I you know the whole comment I made earlier about just pedestrian safety in general and trying to connect um either across 24 somehow safely and just looking at it as a maybe like a tree with branches versus small tree here and a big tree there if that makes sense mhm thank you y commissioner blanket ship yeah I think I'm good with what I see here right now and I concur
056with the gentleman before me that you know setting it up as a larger tree with branches rather than subv areas is probably the best and in getting walkways to the polyan trail people um enabling access right easier access to get to that trail that's all I have thank you your well certainly I think the the Seymour Lake Road Trail ought to be number one and you identified it although the uh safety path committee has got to figure out where finances will come from because that's got a lot of swamp land to go over and go through yeah uh then the other thing that I would say and I really couldn't tell that from the from the map on page three but it would be good if we had a loop around the town so kind
057of as the as this extend if this extension strategy kind of prevails kind of looking at that as possibly a loop right in Cross in 24 and going on the east side as well as the West okay I agree east to west okay any other comments no other than they need to work out a convince people to give them more money I mean to to explain the process as I know it um so there was the millage um the ordinance as it is structured right now does if if you are going to do a development in anything other than a single well other than a single family home Standalone but a a single family condo development or an industrial development or commercial you are required to put in a safety path along public and private
058roads the way the ordinance is written right now is there is also a payment in blue option although it's come it's it's being debated as to if that policy needs to change yeah so to get what you really want you need to remove the option of paying so much en force them to actually put a path in yeah we had sever several places on 24 uh south of town uh down almost where men Tron is on the other side where there's a car dealership and when they redid that and went in there instead of putting the safety path in they paid the money now maybe it's a requirement that the safety path committee takes that money and actually puts the path in at that point something needs to be done there to make make it
059happen instead of just wish for it and then go to the taxpayer and have them cough up some money to do it yeah like I said I I can't speak to it with any with any certainty but I know that that part of the ordinance has has come up in conversation Well we'd be happy to look at it and change it Mr chair if I might when they come with a site plan they have to come to this board make a request and we recommend to the Township board that that safety path in question we recommend to the board to see if that's in P pay pay in lie of putting a safety path in so when those Master plans come in the site plans the site plans when those site plans come in then
060it has to go through this board before it goes to the trustee board to be approved the second thing is is that there's a village line and a line for the township that menak drive is in the village and that particular example you can bring that to the Village to to to talk about a safety path that's little points of clarity there for us yeah that's it okay thank you commissioner Dailey um I think I kind of have a a little different opinion um while I would love to see the the Seymour Lake done I know the cost that's going to go into that one and my fear is that would be the only one I would almost say that we need to look at you know some of the other options like East drainer
061and 24 to drainer and you know some of the other ones were like taking that all the way down to Indian Lake Road where it can tie into um uh what's the trail that goes all the way down into Rochester to tie in those two together I think we'd get more bang for our buck um the cost that's going to go into Seymour Lake Road I think that's going to be it and you're and you're talking about taking the M24 from drainer to Indian Lake yep that high priority that was in the on this map that one and and putting it in in this table correct um on this on that list that you have the high priority semour Lake the second one is East draer to Bar the third one is 24 uh from
062drainer to Indian Lake Road I would put Seymour Lake Road at the bottom of that list only because again with what money is available if that one is the priority nothing else is going to get done so maybe so you you would look at it from the perspective of of taking it out of the out of the number one priority or maybe the potential of having there maybe be some discretion amongst the state you've had to look at B for your bu right okay I mean I like the idea of of taking Seymour Lake out um my only concern was it goes to Baldwin um yeah I guess I would get you to the park um but I don't know I think getting people to be able to move in and around downtown more or
063that area connecting drainer to Indian Lake Road and drainer to Bar up to some of those uh developments okay I think would help especially I mean you've got those two new developments that are going in down drainer having something where people can ride their bike into town I think it's a little more important but no that's fair Mr chairman sir would breaking that seam or Lake Road Extension the smaller projects that maybe assist that because they start to move that way and then do others like as a dlap to Sanders and then Sanders to something like that I mean again I I I'm soliciting feedback It Go and we'll make sure Saun sees it too I only ask that just because your points of getting to the park would be advantageous right but if it's
064never going to get done because we can't get all the way to ball shame right so I just thought I'd ask the thought process okay let just take it out here commission wager yeah um I really do like the idea of building off of existing safety path and expanding what we've got as opposed to sticking stuff out in the middle nowhere um on the SE on the priorities getting people allowing people away to get to and from the park you know either walking or on their bicycles I think is important which is probably why folks devoted that Seymour Lake Road to to Baldwin is is number one and so I I would continue to keep that as a as a high priority and not reduce it maybe talking to the safety path committee maybe there's
065a way to phase it in better so it's more cost effective or or you can at least make some progress over time but yeah you know and it's funny as I come to think of it the like I said it's they are required as parts of development and not too long ago we were talking about the the likelihood of some development on the other side of dlamp which would probably make its way down there so there might be opportunities in that but yeah I you're kind of piggy banking off of the consensus of one way or the other getting down Seymour would be good yeah I think it would be key okay anything else no let's good commissioner n all of our points are very good we've have results from the survey and we have
066results from the Gathering up at the uh Legacy Center and we have this document all three of those need to go to the safety path committee checks and balances put in place place of the township I don't want to be any part of trying to tell the safety path committee what their priorities are or not I think we can feedback to the safety path committee all this information they have a master plan and somehow we need to work with the safety path committee their master plan and have that directly reflected in our master plan for the township so I my vote would be in favor of pushing this towards the safety path for their review and their feedback to be folded into our master plan and the same thing would apply to the Pana Trail
067uh that we have there's a poana trail committee and if we're going to think that uh we want to add or take away or connect to that then we need to have their participation in this information to see how their feelings are at the Pana Trail Council with that being said are there any like as I kind of collect the notes and the thoughts from the Planning Commission are there any so thoughts or I that you have about this that you would want as part what I've been hearing amongst the building the number one item here is the number one possibly the number one item uh of discussion to get the safety path out to the park and the second thing is is the payment Li of has been discussed many times and I think
068that needs to be looked at but that's not for this that's not for conversation tonight okay all right and I would defer to the safety path committee to make the recommendations on the prioritization for a master plan yeah like I said it's on its way to that next um Mr chair if I can a couple more comments real quick um tell you on page on page two of that um item number four the old RR R railroad RightWay EAS Rainer to Indian Lake that is part of that bridge would the bridge be removed at Indian Lake that old bridge that is like 10t high I believe 10t tall U the cars have to drive under I think the train tracks used to go over that right well that's a historic yeah I was going to
069say I think that's historic hist I don't think you can take that down it's okay it's a state Landmark is it yeah okay well that not that I want to destroy that because of the the age of it and it just seems that in the natural progression would be to uh to take that into consideration if redoing the path in that area um if that's most beneficial to the community in that area well the path actually goes right over top of over top of it it goes up past that uh right that development and then just kind of dies where uh the lake is right there okay I was just thinking that bridge won't last forever and kind of to your point about cost Effectiveness I agree with you and your point about that safety
070path through the wetlands and everything to get to se more Lake it seems to make sense um to have maybe that section one that's on you know the safety path from uh Dunlap to Baldwin maybe be chopped off and stop at the park and maybe that reduces cost by some and makes it a little more palatable to it's still buildings for Wetlands or whatever the challenges are are cost is the wetlands which is before you get to the park right right which is the most probably most AC cost most expensive to build right um but I think I I think it's still because the community just you know they indicated that and it seems to make sense to connect that part to the rest of uh the township to leave that as Priority One but
071if we could look at cutting off maybe several hundred feet of it for B maybe that makes it more less expensive okay thank you yeah no problem thank you um okay if there's no other comments with safety pass I think I get to take a little break all right thank you for your time okay moving on to new business uh election of officers um as stated in our bylaws we are required to have a commission chair Vice chair secretary and then uh the various committee positions um Mr spiz left the end of the year and as our vice chair uh we haven't had one for that last meeting but uh I've been chair for this year um as I've said many times I'm willing to serve anywhere the community needs me um but with that
072um I think we have to have a nomination for that role if anybody are you looking for a nomination for the vice chair are you looking for the nomination to start at the top and down or the bottom up chair did we start with chair chair okay so it has start with chair Mr commissioner sir I would like to nominate Corey Bailey as a chairman for the upcoming year that nomination just for a point of order do we do you accept it I would accept if that's what the committee would like the question is do we vote on that or do we see if there's other nominations or you you ask for any other nominations see none and then you will just serve as chair um by unanimous consent if there's no other nominations okay
073then next would be Vice chair wow everybody's quiet don't all volunteer at once I was going to nominate you oh I can't then I would nominate Mr n as voice chair I'll suck with that any other nominations does Mr n accept that nomination I'll accept the nomination okay seeing none uh by unanimous decision uh then we need a secretary anybody would like to serve in that capacity just FYI that's the easiest position because the only thing you have to do is chair the meeting if the chair and the vice chair are both gone can I change my mind no I would nominate Mr Turner for that role I'll second that if you would accept that rule yes seeing no other nominations uh you will serve in that uh by unanimous decision all right then moving
074on to committee appointments first one being the economic development committee I reminded who was on this before I know it was Mr spiz it's been inactive for a couple of years and I know I believe at one of your earlier meetings you discussed letting it rest okay um because it it's been two years at least is there anything in the bylaws that say we have to fill this committee or can it sit that's a Cheryl question I mean I think it's I think sure will be able to quote but I think it just states that you appoint I don't know that dictates when but is it something if we don't appoint somebody can we go without a committee my my thought would be again I'll let Cheryl back me up on this is that if
075and when the the purpose for this community comes to at that next meeting you could then appoint okay the individuals in that meeting that that group would become active again I'm like 80% sure yeah I think it's not a committee that's in the bylaws it's yeah it is not in our by I believe it when it was created it was created for a specific purpose so we could table that one until the need arises I think so yeah okay so then the next one would be the ordinance Review Committee um which historically one of the members is also the Le is onto the Township Board correct it's a member of the Township Board okay so would that be of interest yeah okay sure so then Mr Wagner I know that Mr Turner Mr n and
076I were on before um Mr Turner you were the chair of that correct right would you be willing to stay on sure that was enjoyable okay um glad to hear that um I would also prefer Mr n on this and me as an alternate um we've spoken several times I think he brings more value to it than I if you would stay on that roll sir that'd be fine okay um zoning board of appeals liaison um for the last several years that has been me I don't know is anybody interested or have a burning desire for that or or not getting stuck with it again I don't mind it I actually enjoy it but if somebody else had a burning desire and wanted to but in just FYI they meet the second Monday of every
077month if necessary so I think they met six times in 2024 correct so it's not an every month thing excuse me were you wanting was I volunteering no okay not that I could but so then we will just leave that one as is um gravel inspection in the past was myself and Mr n um I'm assuming you would like to stay that's fine in that capacity is there anybody that would like to serve as a representative of the gravel inspection committee I would be interested okay I'll get with you afterwards to spell your name properly for the it's okay and if it's something that you would prefer to stay on I have no issue with that I just I'm I'm interested in that no no it's uh it it it's good it's it's a great
078opportunity I learned a lot um but I'd be glad to step aside and let you you know I'm the same way I've I've been on that for quite some time it's an appointment by the chair of the Planning Commission maybe Mr blank ship would appreciate I think it's done once a year or twice a year Susan okay you go out to the gravel yards well Cory can explain what you do yeah we go to the all the gravel pits we go through we get a tour um we get an update uh not a sales pitch but a a presentation on what they've done um it's it's a great experience to see what goes on day to day um and then you get to tour the facilities with them you see the expansions you see the
079safety measures um but uh all right I can I wouldn't mind doing that okay that would be a great experience I think yes I'm Cory have Mr and blank ship Mr BL okay okay and then there's not anything on here but I know in the past I've sat in on the safety path committee meetings um I think we like to have somebody on there um I will be honest that a lot of the meetings have fallen when I'm traveling so if anybody else would be interested in that I'd be interested in that possibly okay when do they meet you guys can't appoint it's not your committee oh it's not okay it's not a PC committee it's committee it's a to town oh it's a Township but do we do we we have I mean they
080sent me to go to those meetings I think they've already made their I think they already made you oh okay then okay then congratulations thank you and your first meeting is next Wednesday the 15th at 11:30 yes yes I was actually accepted for something else but can I speak for a second come to the podium state your name your address B my eyes um just as it relates to the orc um the orc was scheduled to meet uh earlier today and review work plan uh the work plan that had been put together by the former orc um and to start to work on presenting at the Planning Commission we felt that since those appointments could change uh we held off on the meeting today um but now that you've made those appointments I just wanted
081to reach out to the or members and say that we'd like to schedule a meeting for either the 16th or the 23rd of this month um so that we can review that work plan confirm that it is what the URC wants to work on in 25 and then we can get it from the Planning Commission at the next available meeting um so I just again I can send out an email we can we can set it up that way but just as kind of a quick heads up I'm probably looking to get you guys together on the 16th or the 23rd and maybe the 23rd makes the most sense because that's because that's our next PC me PC meeting um that has worked very well in the past is can Mr Wagner meet during the
082day yep either day is fine with me and pretty much anytime during the day we typically meet at noon okay and maybe go for an hour hour and a half that's fine that works okay all right does not bring lunch I knew it I knew someone was going to say something about how I don't bring lunch and and just also for clarification if one of you cannot make it let me know I'll free up my schedule and be there but just for clarification I can't be there if the other three are because then it constitutes a quorum right yeah for they are technically public meetings we do take minutes they're as good as I can do but um but yes they are public meetings so there are quum requirements um so on and so forth
083so and correct me if I'm wrong nobody else from the committee or the the Planning Commission can attend that right because then we got ourselves a plan then you got for me okay so okay I will send out an email we'll get on the books thank you okay all right well thank you um moving on to item C PC2 24-2 7th Amendment to master deed of enclaves of wood Bridge condominium applicant enclav of Woodbridge LLC 51410 Milano Drive sweet5 mome Michigan 48042 Seventh Amendment to the master deed recorded in Liber 5655 page 672 Oakland County records as known as Oakland County condominium subdivision plan number 2341 we will start with the petitioner question well I came all this way you never mind yeah you come on up and good evening Mr chairman and honorable planning
084Commissioners uh thank you Happy New Year uh I'm Daniel spatap for on behalf of I'm claves of Woodbridge LLC address has noted um on the record uh last month we here December 12th where the final site plan was presented for consideration and approved by the Planning Commission and in one of the Motions uh indicated that the Planning Commission was to um you know make a determination and review of this the seventh and final amendment to this master deed for our development on claves of Woodbridge this is our pursuant to the last phase where we've added uh the uh final 20 uh units in there and uh with this master deed Amendment uh you do have um the replat number three which is the uh engineering condominium drawings of those last 20 units within there and
085as well as the sanitary storm and water easements uh the way that was presented uh to the best of my knowledge a Township attorney along with our condom minting attorney carefully reviewed uh an approved and uh uh Britney the Britney Ellis the township attorney social counsel for her office was uh was satisfied with it and I believe she's approved it I've not seen anything negative it's been reviewed a number of times so um with that I'm uh respectfully requesting uh approval by this Planning Commission tonight uh for the Seventh Amendment and I'm happy to you know for their answer or any further questions that you might have thank you okay do you have anything you needed to add or bring up just that the planning and legal have reviewed it um and it's you know
086if there were red flags it wouldn't be in front of you tonight I believe Britney's written a motion that provides approval for the condominium and this is really a technicality of just crossing teas and dotting eyes and having the plan commission approve if you've read and have questions like I said I'm here Mr SP Force here but that's all okay okay well we can open this or no we have to have a we just have to have a motion there's everybody should have gotten this you have Britney second page look on the back side done you can it so yeah we in order to even discuss it we have to open it up with a a motion Mr joh MC okay um make a motion to approve the Seventh Amendment to the master Deed on
087claves of woodb condominium and direct the developer of the project record St in accordance with the state law and town importances am I reading that correctly that's not record to record it yes okay I'm sorry I got to that's fine okay so we have a motion be a motion okay we have a motion we have a second um any discussion any questions from the [Music] Commissioners okay seeing none we can have a roll call vote n yes Wagner yes blank yes losk yes Turner yes Bailey yes motion pass that motion carries thank you and uh don't leave I uh I truly appreciate that again I know we talked beforeand I apologize I thought the way we redid the motion that it wasn't a technicality but I appreciate you coming back no that's fine because I
088reread your ordinance and it does give the authority to the Planning Commission to approve it having been subject to further sure review is a long time and current planning commissioner myself and my community I I can appreciate I thank you gent ladies and gentlemen for your service Public Service doing that and your involvement in the community so I know uh what that takes it's something to consider uh in the future these are my recordable documents for final execution that will start that process will start tomorrow thank you thank you thank you okay moving on to committee reports we obviously don't have one for the economic development um anything from the orc I know you didn't have a meeting today no our meeting will be on the 23rd at noon yeah let me get the email
089going but that sounds like the way it'll be okay report at the next meeting okay and we have Mr Sharp's report in our packets um does anybody have any questions or anything on that all right anything else you would like to add uh sir uh no just I we're we're working on a site plan right now um we're in a Revis and resubmit period so we need a few things cleaned up and clarified but we'll probably again have that on one of the February agendas okay all right thank you very much um with that uh we don't need a motion I'll make a motion Mr chairman to close our meeting okay we have a motion second all in favor I okay we are adjourning