001okay calling to order the meeting of the Oxford DDA for December would you all rise for the pledge of aliance I pled aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all a roll call Mr Charles okay P Schultz is excused so I noticed uh the agenda that U there was going to be a viral attendance is that correct so he is here to help speak on the crosswalk project so officially not here correct so Rod Charles here um Marie Powers here Ashley Ross here jccia here Scott Taylor here j chy y here J chy and holer has an excuse okay thank you any public comment on non agenda items no okay um item number five
002is check presentation by Oakland County this uh item is going to be postponed to a later date should we uh append it yeah have an amendment to the agenda okay well we could do that when we in the next item agenda okay uh the consent agenda agenda item number one approval of the proposed agenda may I have a motion to modify the agenda I like to modify the agenda showing that the check presentation County will not happen tonight s by Ashley okay any discussion any discussion all in favor I any oppos uh approval of the November 2024 meeting minutes as written and submitted I move that we um approve the November 2024 meeting minutes support okay any comment all in favor I any oppos okay that's approved and if I could have a motion to
003uh accept and and file the police report and code enforcement report Mo motion to approve consent consent agenda item CN the police report vote enforcement report I'll second that all in favor I opposed all right it's approved uh it number seven of financials if I could have a motion to accept and file the financial statements and R Revenue expenditure reports please Mo motion to accept financials items A and B um bills in for November 2024 in the amount of 9,688 and2 okay can we have a roll call on that do we have a support support y I'll support okay roll call or discussion first any discussion just a favor to ask in the future can the financials also just be on the the total bill on the agenda yes I know it's in there too
004but that'll just I couldn't hear you I just asked if the total um bills can be the number on the actual agenda in the future [Music] thank you all right we need a roll call for that sorry okay I well you need read the names roll call for okay uh Charles yes Powers yes Ross Yesa yes Taylor yes Joy yes okay motion Carri motion Carri all right uh item number eight DDA reports start with the or committee report oh it did not meet this month so I assume there's don't report I'm smart item 7B the EV committee you were pres would you well I just go through it real quickly ver without reading for here first of all and all the committee reports I men to well in the future everybody who attends the meeting
005should have recorded attendance that's not another um just to make a note the EV committee met after we put the board packet together so that was the reason for the EV one this is their agenda not their meeting minute um promo I will fully acknowledge I missed that this month okay but the point being is we should record attendants and then record how people vote those kind of things when we have some issues thatp up com so we need to go back and amend that the next month okay U just to summarize real quickly we talked about with the EV committee we went through the usual tring right that can be a permanent part of the any committee uh we also discussed the movie theater what we do to help the movie theater which we
006discussed the p uh the past meeting there too um the idea of bringing more pedestrian traffic into the village help some of the businesses in town um CJ gazer who theair he gave him credit made some effort to meet with the movie theater folks and a theater group to possibly look at doing some presentations or some shows at the theater uh he also talked with some business owners Mr Schneider in particular about some ideas to uh bring more traffic into the Village area give CJ credit for taking the time and effort to do that that primarily was what the discussion was L you want you were at the meeting if you add something no those are the main topics discussion thank you uh did you want to give a synopsis on the pr sure so
007most of our um time was spent talking about the soup and sweet stroll and any feedback um that we got either through the promo committee or through what they heard that evening um overall very positive um a lot of good changes this year closing off verdict was a very good move I think um having more garbage cans was also a really good move um there was some feedback around changing the colors on the lanyards because there was somebody that had mentioned that maybe there was some Shenanigans going on with using past ones that maybe looked similar and businesses weren't checking very closely obviously it's a busy night um and then we talked a little bit about you know what we could do differently for next year maybe um offering a um for people that maybe
008can't afford a ticket for them and or their family there's like a donation type scenario where people could donate a ticket um we had a situation in the volunteer group I think that posted that topic and made somebody question whether they were volunteering for the right reasons or just to get a ticket so um that kind of prompted that um and then just more on the planning side I think there was some some feedback there we talked a little bit more about volunteers and having more of a strategic um process around getting volunteers maybe having quarterly meetings to solicit uh volunteerism and having a calendar of events that people could sign up for ahead of time so that they could know you know if something struck them as a passion that we could get them
009signed up ahead of time just kind of have a better understanding of what needs we have from a business standpoint um we also talked about the poer express which took place yesterday at that time that we had the meeting we still needed volunteers um so h was going to reach out to the soup and sweet volunteers to see if we could get any which we did so she did great there um Angie stepped in and was U Mrs Claus for the event so that was wonderful and then Holly donated from Oakland Corners donated the costume to the DDA so that we could use for future years as well um Holly is going to be taking over as a lead of the promo committee starting in January um and then just a reminder to the team
010that the accreditation is on February 5th um our biggest focus in January at the promo committee is going to be talking about kind of the calendar of events and also our work plans in preparation of the accreditation okay thank you uh next is the design committee I can speak to that one as well because Catherine's not here um so we had a I'm trying turn for a minute since this meeting we talked about the historical um Let me give it a meeting minutes here I apologize um we talked about some of the open items around the decorations we still had to decorate for the Santa The Polar Express event so we talked about dates for that um we talked about this historical sign project I was not involved in that so they were bringing me
011up to speed and kind of pointing me in the right direction of where to look for that information so we could continue to move forward um we did talk about the trolley about um how to m not NE necessarily how to maintain it but some of the challenges that we've had around volunteerism getting it decorated getting it started keeping it on the road um no grants were submitted we didn't discuss anything around the budget although we did talk about um workshops that we probably will need to have as we move into the budget season upcoming events we talked about this was two weeks ago I think so it was before the soup and sweet stroll we talked about that the parade Holiday Market in Santa at the dealership Polar Express um in regards to plac
012making we had some lights out at that point so I was working with exile to get those um up and running in Washington Square um The Patio we talked about the activities that were happening through there um yep so yeah moving forward undecorating the truck in Washington Square and then um Catherine had announced that she may not be part of the DDA going forward so we were s to hear that okay any questions or yes um a couple questions on design committee the historical historical science I guess I didn't understand that aspect of it so there was a project that was kicked off over the summer that the interns started from my understanding and that was something that Kelly worked with them on I was of that but I believe it was to highlight different
013um buildings in the downtown and have images surrounding that and then having those put on like a leard onto the building somehow or near the building okay um D I'm sorry no you go ahead and finish I'll just add on I don't have honestly I don't have much to add to be honest oh yes a little bit there I was not that committed either but um as you know I try to support those ideas of of some of the historical significance of things in town the idea would be or is to use the present tense to have some markers on buildings with background each individual building you know uh built in 1901 maybe some history of who the owners were at different times things like that which I find you know when I go to
014certain towns I'll sometimes walk I'll look at these kind of things myself so if looking at economic Vitality committee when we talk about trying to get more people into downtown for shopping or walk you know what are they're going to do people like those kind of things I don't many people when you go on vacation you see these historic markers sure so that's kind of the motivation for doing that and I can't remember if we had the idea but instead of putting a brass marker there that can't be changed somebody had the idea of putting some kind of marker with a QR code on it so that way it could be changed as we get new owners and things like other different buildings oriented something yeah oriented something like that downtown but that's actually that's
015kind of the the the the overview of that sort of thing and then with our economic Vitality committee that I mentioned earlier that Mar brought up something during that me I neglected to mention that is um one of the appeals of the village of L to a lot of people is the the word the word that Reus was quaint got I give a credit for this stuff see but but it does bring people into town you I've heard that for many many years so the whole idea Kimberly is to do something that ties in with that quaint feel they walk around and buy a pizza from Scott or something like that while sh do you know cuz there's something on here that there was a question around if it was a grant funded activity do
016you know I don't know anybody grant funding it might have been something that was being looked at but it was never discussed that I'm a okay um I guess follow up to that and just putting it out there for all committees with the New Start Plan versus our motto bridging home in history and then we're talking about historical signs maybe there's some time for discussion or maybe it's in all of the Committees about how our strategic plan and our motto fit with that because outside of that I think this is one of the first times I've seen did we lose soundid kicked off or something okay anything about that so just kind of like a pin it for later to keep thinking about and then I had one other can I ask a question before
017you move on yes are you are you saying that we don't we're not like the motto is bridging home in history and that we're not as a DDA kind of fostering that history piece yes okay but I also think that's what bubbled up in the Strategic plan is that didn't seem to be a priority from everyone right so I think it's just a bigger conversation where I love home and history but that can't be as passion project that has to be coming out right of the whole Community sure um my only other thought I already shared this with Kimberly on these um first I obviously haven't been here in a while so this is like the best everything has looked ever so Kudos team um my only other thought was maybe I'm consolidating what is
018official agenda and official notes um just to be very concise and then rely on I guess the reports um I think some of these are kind of too far in the weeds and then you get me asking all these wild questions that maybe we don't need the whole group inut in are you talking about the uh committee reports I'm kind of talk too detailed or a little bit of both I'll use EV for example it was there at this last meeting but since that's been my home for a while um we're talking about stuff like lacks Conta lacks funding um La you know certain knowledge and I think there's ways that we could just say we're going to connect the theater group with this theater group you know actually at that point we discussed that
019RB committee meeting if you remember and we actually the most recent we never got a copy of meeting members CJ had it we never um but I agree with you they could be more succinct but I still no we need to have minutes recorded too by the way I agree I 100% agree I just I think this is done with the best of intent yes I just don't think if somebody picked this up and somebody I'm I'm whatever business and oh I don't have contacts I don't have Grant knowledge I don't have business knowledge like that doesn't make me feel good and we're really trying to uplift no I agree with you Mar and I were commuting and we never got a copy of this is the first time I saw it okay I think
020it actually all lives in my Google Drive so I will reshare that link okay okay any other discussion on the above committees I just wanted to say yes sorry sometimes I just talk a lot um I thought the soup stroll was was the best one thus far I think that the um DPW really shined uh um obviously they came out and with getting all the snow out of the road cuz you know 8 hours before I thought man I'm going to have to go buy some shovels and we're going to shovel this full um the parking spaces I mean the the sidewalks have been great but um they took care of that the burning barrels there was always wood there it was I mean they were constantly around and I just they need to know
021that that goes notice that they didn't just work overtime and then they were gone cuz they were there um but no I thought everything else was great and then it was kind of I kind of had the same thought on if somewhere there was a repository of people's extra suit passes um I had several people come up to me and say I bought four and my kids didn't want to come and they just handed them to me so I was able to hook a couple people up outside cuz like they were from out of town they didn't really know what was going on and they're like we want to be a part I'm like here you go you welcome to Oxford so I mean and I don't know if that means maybe we even each
022have four or five for something like that but um I know last year that was a lot bigger issue of number one people not knowing about it and not knowing the whole card thing so I think just time has shown like folks know what's up and they also knew they needed to buy their tickets early so they automatically bought them for their family and then they had extras so I don't actually know what the answer is but I think it would be cool to be able to Foster that as far as hey if we've got them and they're extra and somebody already paid for them you know get amused somehow absolutely okay thank you Scott uh executive director all right so it's been a whirlwind of a month um lot of events over the last
023month since I've talked to y'all um you can I won't read through them but you can see all of the different um um events I'm working on what I wellas that I will be working on putting more structure around uh recap so having more details around the data of how much money did we bring in how much money did we spend do we think it's worth it to continue we can pull um data analytic data from Oakland County around the number of people that came into town where they came from how long they stayed um so looking at that when it comes to re and how we can better promote some of the events that we want to Target outside of just Oxford um a lot of meetings also in the last month um I'm
024also working on personal development as you know just general wanting to but also as part of my role and being new into this position um just a general day-to-day things um yes supporting board Okay so support board and committee openings by soliciting interest so yes we did obviously know you know that we had some openings on the board we had some openings within our committees as well so um just reaching out and talking to people to see if they were interested and we have some new faces here um so that's exciting I did have a meeting with a property owner who that went very well it was good insight to see that perspective um help to support the businesses through some of the things that they were trying to to do uh on their own
025over the last month I met with our consultant for the Strategic plan so she walked me through in detail the strategic planning kind of with the change in Staffing how that might look over the next year kind of pausing on maybe moving forward with some of them and recalibrating on organizational um improvements and kind of structure uh downtown decorations Skylight reimbursement which we'll get into it's on the agenda so I'm going to skip that one um trying to continue to Foster relationships with the village and the boards and the council um participated in Village recognition events and appreciation activities so to speak to Scott um a very long time coming provided some recognition from the DDA specifically to DPW as a thank you for all that they do for us um and they seemed I
026don't know if you've heard anything Joe but Don was very appreciative of that so that was really it made me feel good because I it's always been something that's been on my mind but it was it was nice to be able to do it um so that was nice um and then looking at 2025 calendar and priority planning very initial stages of that but just more talking thinking um communicating about that but thinking about what our our priorities for 2025 are um we may or may not have full sponsorship for the trolley for 2025 so that's something to consider um we may not have full participation from our current current Partners in Lake gorian from a financial perspective for 2025 so these are things that we need to think about uh what what that would
027look like um because we did talk a little bit about maybe re reallocating some of our stronger together funding to Move It from event Focus to more development focused for the businesses maybe some trainings um or development opportunities for for the business owners instead of events to bring people into downtown that's not to say that we're not going to have events just really looking at maybe rep redistributing the mix of resources for 2025 and then from a staffing standpoint I'm going to pause on that as well because that is also on the agenda okay I have a question on the charie yep um what are the next steps for that as far as determining the involvement with like Gan who's paying for what and sure kind of where do we go from here so they
028are having and also this is on our agenda as well which I thought was an amazing idea they're having like it's not a strategic plan per se but it's more short-term maybe over 2025 with their board um in January so they're going to be looking at what they want to do over the course of 2025 how they want to allocate their budget what they think is most priority priority driven um I think that might be a good option for us to do as well as a group I know we have the Strategic plan but that was a longer term term bigger projects when we're looking at deliverables for 2025 I personally would love to hear your input around what you think priorities are for for the DDA um so I think once they get through
029that first phase they'll have a better idea from a financial standpoint what they're looking to do to support uh the trolley is offline until probably the end of February so we do have a little time um and if we want to Pro proceed on our own trying to to obtain sponsorships that's an option okay so it sounds like maybe in January we would start to devolve a plan for how we're going to keep this rolling pun intended yes um the other thing to consider is it's going in for maintenance um and so as of right now I'm being told that the bill is not going to be that large but if the bill is a substantial bill that might be something we will obviously need to discuss from an approval standpoint but also a does
030this make sense standpoint I mean I know a lot of our committees touch on the trolley in some way form so I'm just wondering how all those efforts are going to be coordinated so that we have a plan going forward in 2025 yes just to kind of you know last minut I mentioned the trolley because you know we bought it at a pretty good price the issue is the uh maintenance cost and originally we uh SED with know have operated cuz they the drivers and the place to park it and or was kicking AP but they're backing out of that so that's where we have to look at what we're going to do in the future do we end up selling it or whatever else but if we keep it we have to understand that's
031going to be a financial obligation our part you know or if we bought a new one those are when I looked to that maybe two three four years ago those are you know $253,000 unless we bought another used one m and if we keep it do we keep the same format of running it between Lake Oran and Oxford or is it going to become an Oxford only trolley and if so what are we where where are we going to run it when I talk to the mayor one of the gross points at the time he actually had two trys because one would work and one would so he can flip that I will say you know just through my experience through the Polar Express activity we had a little snafu last minute where we thought
032we might not have the trolley running for that event we had unfortunately Lake orian had their event Saturday we had our Sunday and the Charlie did not run for their event so they had to have two Nota buses instead of the trolley and the feedback both from Lake Oran and from Oxford is that it's the you know the novelty of a trolley so it's not necessarily the you know the the transportation from here to there that people need to have that it's more of like an entertainment activity so I don't don't know that if we don't have a trolley I don't know that we would need to replace it with something first I guess I would suggest maybe this goes into EV committee because I think a lot of it came out of EV committee
033um in terms of making recommendations but I you know I'm disheartened to hear about the partnership but not surprised but I do think it opens us up for other opportunities and I do think yes we're the DDA District but we've been hearing lots of feedback from all over that people are interested in it but for like you said novelty not necessarily private events and what not private events or you know moving something into the township to bring people in you know we've talked about that water stone stuff um but I'm wondering if EV committee could take the first crack at it and see me a note uh email or something make look into it I I that might be the direction sorry to talk about this too much that might be the direction we goes
034within the Township area be a legacy center or water stone or whatever else that might be appropriate if for's not Desiring of continuing that yeah and just to be clear it has not been solidified that they're not participating but it's just it's been thrown out there as a possibility so well I I want yeah I wonder if there's data to support I I know we've talked about this before data to support how people use it and who uses it and I'm wondering if perhaps they they are not seeing the benefit they to their residents they do so It's Tricky let me rephrase that they have the data so I got a a kind of a summary over the last couple years from Nota of the writers ship and so I shared that with them um
035It's Tricky though because you have to think that they're they're clicking a button to say this are the number these are the number of people entering the trolley at any given time so in theory one might say cut that in half because if you're getting picked up here and dropped off there you're assuming that they're going to get picked up there and dropped off here um I can have that prepared for the next board meeting so you all can see it um but they're not and we can't tell what's in Lake Oren versus what's in Oxford they're not to that level it's just a number okay uh I mean I would I would support the idea of having the EV committee take a stab at it and take the lead on um you know looking
036at Future usage and how could it be best utilized I mean I would as a downtown business owner I I would be very sad to see it go because I think it does help bring new people into town and um so I think there's the novelty aspect for sure which we already know is very popular but I I think there is some benefit to the transportation aspect of being able to go into Lake Oran and Oxford and back again uh to bring you know new people into town so I as a business owner would hate to see that go away one of the statistics that we came across we had this discussion last year that's hold on go ahead okay Scott no I well just to finish up on that uh previously we looked at
037where in the committee where uh a lot of people from outside of ox were coming from or a lot of people coming from Brandon I think that was number one of all the areas around here so your church now I was just going to say it's almost like there's there's two different you're talking about two different things like you have these four events during the year that are trolley focused right like you can't have a Polar Express if it's not a cool vehicle but I think that um also being a business owner where they drop us drop them off behind me and in front of me um I think it's a huge piece of having those people being able to come in and park down there you know keep their car out of here but
038you know you know the people still come so that's my suggestion had been um is it the novelty of having the actual trolley or is it is it the convenience of having a vehicle to get you from Oran to Oxford and Oxford to Oran and I think it's more B but um I mean especially when you're talking about St Patrick's Day and things like when the things pack right because then you can be very choosy if we're just if we're not worried about a trolley and I'm not anti trolley but if let's say the trolley was gone and we were worried about getting people from orian to Oxford and Oxford to Oran or Waterstone or wherever you can pick those days you know and not just you know on a Saturday in February when none
039of us do any business you know and nobody's out because it's Z degrees you can say hey we probably aren't going to run the bus today but that might be a reason to run the bus so it's not going to start anyway I'm not talking about that talking about a real that's warm right oh all right so so to kind of summarize this are we proposing that we uh ask the EV committee to to take this on and see what logical next steps are for 2025 with or without Lake Oran partnership okay all right thank you uh agenda item number nine is unfinished or old business and first item is seven excuse me 9A Staffing so just really quick before just one more thing I wanted to share I got some feedback from one of
040our newer businesses in town after the soup and Suite and this is what they said what a fun night thank you for all that you do I just can't get over all the community support Oxford has I wish we had that in their town that they had a different business in so that was lovely to hear that they feel that Oxford is a great place to have a business and have a good Community from a business owner standpoint okay thank you um from a staffing just wanted to give a quick update on that I went through a process a couple weeks ago with the initial um applicants and scheduled some phone screens unfortunately several of those didn't work out um various reasons uh commute time uh some people thought it was more marketing website type
041driven versus actual job description um or they felt like it might be a remote option more so than being in the office so my plan over the next two weeks is to go through the next group of applicants and select more to do phone screens with and that's where we're at okay any questions on that I think it's time for Mr scholes 9B crosswalk proposal do you so this is GNA be in tandem Joe and Pete I think Joe's gonna kind of kick it off and then Pete can make any amendments go wait do he you there Pete you ever hear everything just to make it easier communication wise to um Pete and I were both there and walk uh the areas together can you give us background since we haven't been here okay so
042me too then just so openland County had some upper funds they they came down to ways to spend those upper funds one of the ways was reaching out to their downtown communities for plac making and those type of activities so the grant process I mean it was probably January of last year I remember walking in to be OB us and Scott PR was in there with Kelly and looking at one of the sketches in their application is some of those early sketches um west of the intersection east of the intersection on East ver kind of where the arch is now where the proposed sidewalk or crosswalk is kind of plan initial Concepts there um and then it it went through the process through last summer um where Kelly and the VA were putting together applications
043for the upper funds through the county August it came to the Village Council to say Hey you know yes these are your streets we would like to uh go through a project and apply for a grant um to put two crosswalks in one on West verdick one on East berck and there was other aspects of the grant to and part of the reason that the council had to get involved is because the AR funds are federal dollars that were float to the county and then come to us using our Sam account our Sam account system for reward management for federal dollars right yep and then they also have a a unique identity identifier number which was all the stuff was going to flow flow through in the name of the village of Oxford and using
044our number because the DDA doesn't have its own tax ID number isn't an entity in that sense right where it has a Sam account and stuff like that so for those reason we we ensured that hey it's got to go back to the council to accept this premise that you're going to the D would apply for our grant because there's always someone saying on the bottom line that says yeah we will spend these FAL dollars appropriately and all that went through that process um the grant was put in um everything went through Kelsey and I even sat through an online version with a couple folks from the county going over all I had some questions about David bacon and things like that when they're using federal dollars of the procurement process and things like that
045there's a lot of red tape a lot of fine print so I think some of those initial questions were answered just fine and they moved forward with funding as a matter of fact I was going to look today I looked in your revenue and expens report I don't see the funds there yet because it's kind of odd normally you do a grant you spend all your money you get your ducks in a roll you return your paperwork and you get some reimbursement and this particular Grant within like 90 days of being approved they were going to send you like 75% of money up front which is so backwards but I guess some of the communities needed the money up front because they're dealing with a lot of them around the county um you know it's
046they needed some Assurance the money was there to get the ball rolling and start on their projects um so gosh is Oakland County sending the money or okay is yes so it was probably two months ago I'm going to say maybe first part of October that Pete myself and Paul who is our engineer from Ro Professional Services walked the sidewalk and the crosswalk area so on the map I have a marked out um East berdick and West verdick the yellow highight lines the locations of the crosswalks as proposed and we walked all the spaces in between them as well so when we ask Paul from roow too so look as you're walking through let me get back up one more a little bit to get some context when M24 came through M came through did
047the M24 project they could only go around the corner and replace this sidewalk and the curb and the brick papers stuff within the RightWay as you come around especially on East berd there on the South Side there's a lot of wavy bricks a lot of broken concrete there's tree Wells that are now been filled with dirt between there and that that crosswalk over on East bck there's a lot of spots that need repairing on the North side and the South Side same thing on the south side of the museum and and then across from the museum too so we walked all all of that back and forth and for north north and south side side and while you're there with SM Crews removing and replacing and stuff there's no time like the present to hey
048there's busted there's he so a lot of marks and thoughts are notes were made to that's got to be replaced that's got to be replaced as well so we asked row to break it down what is it just the crosswalks you know the ramps and Ava ramps everything for the crosswalks and the markings and then break out what the other remove and replace repair areas where Pete and I walked those um you know and ier Fe I'm like I'm not here to spend your money but he would bounce it off with me we would talk about those the old wavy bricks cavers along the curb as you come around 24 say heading towards the monogram shop there and East um that would be removed and replaced with the stamp concrete so it looks like that
049kind of like was done in the Northeast and Southeast um projects they did in the last couple years wouldn't be new paays it be the stamped concrete color C ribbon along the edge um and as well as removal B tree walls that have now kind of filled in removed and replaced broken and cracked stuff as well is this entire Grant just for crosswalks like what did we apply for various things placemaking in general walkability connecting the downtown getting people to areas to more sit more walk more um if you look at the grant U and I just reviewed it today the application there was even something a crosswalk proposed down across from Marketplace Mall like by the new car wash again I don't yes in theory that'd be great but I don't think that's ever
050going to get approved by m that um so it's those type of things that uh were in the grant do better the walkability and stuff how much money did we get 325,000 I have it right here I think it's in I don't know if was in your packet I wrote down my little cheat sheet here we have to match to way it's 6040 60% daa 40% County for a total of 335,000 so I'm sorry can you say that again yep 335,000 total 2011 from DDA 134 from the county and the counties represents 40% of them yes R question what we said these crosswalks on the map here what what is that going to be what is it going to look like physically papers across the road I don't no it would it would well you
051can't just have a step off curve right so that curve would be removed in place with the the proper a slope down you might have to go back okay so you got so you don't have a curve that's one thing yeah you got to put the C Cuts in there you got to get the uh the notification pads you see down there the brown pads with the bumps on them that are going on there you have to have the uh the striping on the pavement as well you have to have signs mounted and directional signs poining indicating there's a sidewalk there for the drivers in the area so and there was a lot of debate at Council whether these were needed whether it's at the right spot and and chief so basically said look Kelly
052knew it as well and anybody that's out there during C certain nights will see that people are crossing there already so and if you go back to the design standards Ro shared them with us and said there's a lot of ways you can determine where crosswalks are and you can observe traffic patterns well we know this pattern is where we're using it so if they're already doing it by by labeling it with signage and and and marking the pavement markings across the street is just going to make it safer so answer my question it's more the physical changes to the itself is the answer of the question yes it it again the infrastructure the sign signs painting pain fixing the curve so people what well to make it meet yeah design standards right in addition
053to that again the walkability the plac making aspect of their their application and Grant was to you know you're not going to leave a 100 foot of sidewalk what half if it's broken and cobbled and messed up there's two places that we're talking about and that's going to cost 300 and some OD th000 to do put some signs up and break so in addition to that no the breakdown is there there's this is only well you see the cost in front of you when you pack it from Roll what the ests are for that I don't have in there so in addition to that part of the grant was to redo all the wooden uh artwork and mill work on Gazo because if you look at it it looks great so you get close to
054it you realize a lot of it is rotted and and and Beyond its life so project two the street skate okay I'm sorry I'm just trying to follow along you yes okay I believe we have two different questions being asked I guess sorry the overall project is what I'm trying to to explain to Ashley and Jay because there's a lot more to into into the cross the crosswalks in this particular part is a part of it and if you see what are those amounts 4,000 for the cross uh 184,000 see you're looking at what was that P 184,000 for the crosswalk project and the sidewalk so if you look the project so that would be one and two yeah one and two yes now well you'll see a third column and I asked that put
055in there for discussion because when we did our paining project on East berck you we did it October is we went from M Street over to glassby we did mostly in the in the northbound lane because it was some bad areas there we replac some curb and stuff along that north side as well when we came to the radius around the intersection at Mill Street my BD Street equipment parking lot we had to replace that curb and stuff cuz the drain structure was really bad and failing in there we didn't have into our project to go back and up the sidewalks and fix that 88 ramp area so you'll notice it's black top behind that new curve because that wasn't a part of our scope but we when we did that project we like that
056needs to be addressed maybe we'll do that next spring so when talking to Paul putting this together he said look you know if we're going to do that that's all fully within the DP District that kind of work that type of work falls in the scope of what this grant is from County and if if they're going to pay 40% of it why not do it then you're going to get a much better price to do it so that's something that I am asking you to consider as well that number three which is strictly related to the ada8 ramp area on the northeast corner of Burg and Mill you'll see the new curb and everything that we put there um but that that sidewalk probably three two or three flags either direction plus that ramp
057coming down is out of compliance pretty far that's why you got to go back two or three flags or so to get the right slopes down to that intersection that's something that only came to light in the last couple months and then only thought well why not see if can be rolled into this because there are parts of the larger parts of the grant again what Pete mentioned that's 184 doesn't count the 22 that we were possibly looking at for Mill Street doesn't include the work on the Gazo doesn't include there's also if you look at the application there was some talk I think it's kind of gone to the Wayside of putting an ADA ramp accessible ramp on the Gazebo the gazebo's God it' be really burdensome I think and hard to get that
058there some mockups done you can go through all this back and forth ramps to get somebody up onto that what is it 15t square area for you know and we even talking talking to the difficult iness of that when we were uh Kelsey and were on online meeting with the county that that's you taking historical structure you're going to make it look really funky put a big old ramp in the side so that cost may have been rolled in there I don't remember what that cost was in rication could be $16 $18,000 that was kind of all R snowball this larger project to come up with a 335 you already did a Northeast area behind the schools you already did the southeast area behind Victoria's there was a thought and a highlighted area in your
059application like behind um 24th Street and Evergreens Evergreens I was want to say big boms but Evergreens about we're doing something similar to that you know maybe screen up that area maybe get some more additional seating there and then was there like way finding was that part of way finding might have been part of as well as the SS and stuff so all those things were all rolled in to the larger project come up with the 335 so all these projects I'm going to say you're talking Gaz and everything else is very summer here yes it's very in there who can figure out what you just said the only there must be 50 things you just mentioned yeah those are all submitted on your behalf last summer I'm not asking who behalf I'm just saying
060they're not delineated here just Mor M well I'm going to politely disagree I just don't think has this board seen that Grant application I don't believe so because I until today have not seen it either and so um I think that would answer a lot of questions cuz I don't think it's anybody's nobody here can answer that because I think that well well but only one person submitted and that's we that hasn't been shared with so I think that'll answer correct he was involved I say as a Committee Member helping some of the design work layout so that's but I don't think that he correct if I'm wrong I don't think he went it's not brought to the board I had seen the grant till it was already done un approved which think why we
061have these questions and feel a little so let me back up as to why this is in front of you now when it was first brought to the council August and we said okay sure great and you know the desire and Hope from and Pete K was hey let's get out there and get this thing roll get these in by Fall wasn't going to happen by the time you design work contractors already backed up and busy barely going to get the work done that they had planned and working on this past fall already so you want to get ahead of this and if you like this cost or if you don't like it if you want to get the project done and you want to get some design work done you have to approve the
062design work you have to get those estimates out there January February you have to get them out bid you have to come back with bids get approved in the spring and then you have work done in the summer this manager I have a question yes sorry yes try to follow okay um question for that so say we move this forward here having worked with grants my assumption is we'd have to go to Oakland County and have it okayed by them since this The Mill Street was not initially in our grant I I don't think so I think we just heard it wasn't no The Mill Street has only still been hit my radar since our project in October and we said you know we're going to with this in the spring well why not roll
063it in with the SM work that's happening 150 ft away for the 40% yeah right and again it's all within the district it's all part of walkability which is overall umbrella which was already approved by the Grant walkability Place making um way finding things like that uh to get people to come in and sit down and enjoy get around the downtown better I think so there's no additional are you sure I can look I can look at I feel like this some of this is going to change our scope rather dramatically that leaves us with $129,000 and a gazebo project you're saying we can't do well the work is one aspect of it the ramp just the ramp was are we allowed to do the woodwork without doing an ADA Compliant project yes can you
064recognize Pete because he might have some all right thank [Music] you we did start a project last summer um um we walked through with [Music] Kelly Jim Shar engineer and myself and at that point was just the cross and that's the same prject that we took to the E back in September and August and talk about and explained it and showed the drawings and moving forward with that the village needed to approve it which they did at that same time Road engineering was too busy to get to with me so it was going to push it off to 2025 gra in the stain soap as part of the gr was doing the sidewalk repair along ber Street both sides of so I said why don't we combine this crosswalk project with the street skate as
065far as the sidewalk and hope to get a better price because contractor will be doing it so we walked everything September October walked through everything pointed out the areas that needed to be done so rway istically from the driveway there behind M next to the re all the way west early to H Street both north side and southide so you will have the crosswalk project um which they're saying is approximately 49,000 is what their estimate would be which includes engineering and then the and a sidewalk portion of it is roughly the mil Street project that Jo was talking about was not part of project is not part of the the grant application to begin with definitely if we want to bid at the same time for The Village to get a better heal that's fine
066but at this point my personal opinion is this is still a village responsibility for that for project number three the total Grant talks about work isable from doing railings to roof to making everything it's all right everything there was a portion in there as mentioned about doing the handicap whether or not that will f it also includes some wave finding around town so as far as where parking lots are located and everything so people find them and then also mentioned about doing the L project you find the Southwest buildings so roughly $335,000 the DDA 21,000 responsibility is in the budget and then the other portion of it is in the 2526 budget that she was $21,000 this portion which we're looking at doing like mentioned is doing this portion of it so we can get
067it out to bid because most of this has to be spent by 2026 so it just takes a while to get put together everything so that's why se6 de sep yes yeah I think and you're right the the the obligation is done and and the funds have to be spent I think it's September October of 2026 so you have you have your construction season 25 and construction season 26 and so that giv you two things so and and the this is the larger probably of the cost depending on what you come up with behind ever um and you don't want to wait to get we we were kind of at approval of August not even having talk to our engineer and get that walk about and stuff it was just really late in the year
068to get it done Engineers they were backed up contractors backed up so getting ahead of now you don't have to approve anything tonight we're just saying hey here's here's the first time we have some costs on this particular portion of the crosswalks and B the additional remove and replacement stuff um Pete you said you had talked to um Jim Sharp about this I'm just wondering did he pull together bids for this J sh actually did drawings for the cross and I believe he put some of the specifications together and I think he gain approximately 4000 4000 okay so I I do have a little question um Ro is coming forward saying that they're going to charge 12,000 for the engineering of the process so some of that stuff from Jim was U usable he did
069have some Topo on it and he was CLE talk to Jim right and shared Jim's initial design on the East was different um it was on angle from the archway angling across on an angle which come and Ro came out with us and and I talked to Jim Sharp about this as well he said that really isn't not only not best practice but it's really not allowed in a way because it's you need to shorten the distance as much as possible especially for crosswalk Walkers across the road and and I came to Pete look Road set up ro road design engineering Village and they said if we wouldn't do it that way and if you want to do it that way you're going to have to find somebody else to do it CU we won't
070do this angle thing as much as great it would be to come out that Archway right there and walk across it's I don't know to the RR shop it's what 30 40 ft and then go straight across it's much better designed it's shorter distan it's safer so minor changes what presented but Jim you know he he did what he was asked and so some of that stuff is usable again but not full design and bid specs so part of that design and Engineering cost uh is put together the bid spec in the contracts and bid them up do the EV of the bids get the bids in analyze those bids issu the bids now if you want them onsite engineering onsite inspections those costs are different those are here at all but it's the design
071bidding believe and then the analyzing the bids and put into the bid book we just do c contract um do we have for this ARA project we was it delineated what activities and budget is spent in 25 versus 26 or I I think it was a plan of what they hope to do but not you so when we say from a DDA standpoint we have it in our budget does that mean like we could go out today and like start taxs for $200,000 yeah okay some of it it's already in this year correct P okay yeah and what isn't in this year you could have that the following year what the but the ARA money was money that the federal government gave away to local municipalities across the United States states counties Villages townships Etc
072everybody got money based on population for example the township got 2.1 million Oran Township I got I believe got 3.8 million Jo I think the village got what 380,000 so that money then and Oakland County got I think $600 million Wayne County got about a billion dollars but all that 600 million that Oakland County got uh we went for some of that money to come back to the DVA so it comes from the federal government or taxpayers let's say federal government they gave 6 million bucks to Oakland County and then as a group of D folks we asked for some of that money to do the things that Joe F yeah the county come up with a program to try to push some that money out cuz they needed to spend it they knew there
073was a time it's it's it's not money that's to show up again to answer your question cly you know but that was the food chain right your match obligations what you're well I'm yeah I'm wondering if we have a specific amount in this bu this year's budget and then a different amount in next year's budget and we have to use it or if it will roll over even if you had it in this year's budget reason you didn't spend it then you have that plus whatever you're going to budget next year next year's budget if you don't spend it it's gone got it after municipalities so they're not going to be able to spend all the money in which case they give it up okay so one of the things the questions I had concerns
074I had with you know taking these dollars was a lot of spine print you know you have the prevailing wage laws you have things like that you have purchasing procurement procedures that you have to follow using these so part of the conversations I had Mr razen I think his name was Brett razen from the county um was you know are they beholden to some of those he did respond back to me in the file share with everybody his responses um I think they were exempt from the Davis bacon PR wage laws with this fund this funding um you know there's obviously if you're using State funding then you have to report with State funding that and G capture is it's not State funding it's comes by way of a state statute but it's not State
075funding and I don't see any issues with that so that helps a little bit on the procurement and and the bidding of it you don't have quite as much red tape to deal with um just to clarify for my own knowledge we are not obligated to go with row this is one bid and we would put it out for other companies to have their estimate is that correct that is true we we we stick with our same engineering company for our infrastructure projects because again for 20 years they did all the sewer and water projects they did all the prints and things like that and then there was a time where they had a different management here and they used a different engineering company kind of like you don't switch out and take your turning
076out for bids every time you have a project and you don't take your Auditors out every time you know you kind of stick with them and build in that professional relationship so we stick with ro for our projects and that's what we would prefer for our standards because again now that's still an option you could go and take that different route if you choose because it's you know it's your project not necessarily ours um and a matter of fact we The Village did that a couple years ago too with our um crosswalks that we did here on West verdick and down by the OES school on South County U bro was doing some things they were tied up whatever like well we got with sharp engineering and we went for those crosswalk projects I just
077I guess that was my only question is if Jim was already doing some of these specs and hey we don't want a diet we want a crosswalk and if his price initially seemed less why would we spend he didn't do complete engineering either okay for one he did preliminary engineering just enough to fit on one paper put on one sheet you know and there are certain you know he's technically in the DDA District right yes okay just as so all we we've engaged role for this to because we were asking for a couple months now hey we need some cost estimates people wanted something to bring back to the board to say where we at 5 grand or 105 Grand so that's what's in front of you tonight you mention safety that's the purpose of
078crosswalks right yeah what's the status of those things that M put up there M24 those we can talk about that outside the meeting it's not on gend SC you you mention safy mention CR I did but you want to go down to M4 which we have no jurisdiction what about um not in the lane I wouldn't suggest them so the road question now was taken over because they do the maintenance for M24 they are contracted through the state of Michigan we have no jurisdiction on that road those have been a problem and finally someone from M from Road Commission called us a couple months ago me and D he said what is the deal with these they keep getting hammered and broken he's got a new plan he's going to redo them once to put
079them up on the island more so versus down in the uh curb areas do they get wiped out all the time again we don't plow that road it's not our jurisdiction um so there's problems with those but now again that stuff is being put off to the county and that I don't think it's going to replace them anymore it's going to fall to the county and the County's just like well who's are these and how do we do them okay so so Joe what's the ask here is it prove the engineering cost is is just to get that's a yeah this from is an estimated cost of what their engineering cost would be and then it's an estimated what they think the construction would actually be so we would be approving road to move ahead
080with the engineering put it off for bit and then they would bring the bits back for the actual work and that gets approved by us and it gets approved by the actually gets approved by us because this yes the village not appr you just got to follow our Pro our purchasing procedures guidelines anything over 25,000 has to do with the seal bid process and obviously believe we better out one project so it's well over that so you would have to follow know it has to be advertised in certain areas road is advertising and again he right now they really this is just cost estimate what I would I would suggest that you these are for more for Peter I don't want to get slow you down but I don't want to get ahead to either
081I would request from Ro a a an agreement in place of a design you know that they do with us we give them uh they give us an estimate here's what we here's our scope of what we're going to do for you it's all laid out design this bid this analyze the bid go over the bid documents provide the bid documents all those things they do all that stuff and here's our our proposal you approve that proposal I think you're a little shy tonight under that information to do this if that was there and you guys are ready to do so sure I don't these numbers I don't think are going to change but to have a better document in front of you of what their responsibilities role responsibilities are in front of you it's
082probably better but I think we need to make a decision of what package we want them to put the proposal together yes and I I was going to I had some notes at my comments at the end about sidewalks and general stuff as well and and the head of time with the state statute which will kind of circle back to this um sorry derailed everything no that's okay no no no it wasn't going to come up right now anyway about about the role of ddas why they exist and infrastructure being one of the main reasons why they exist and that's why I I think even though this was outside of that delineated scope is still well in the purview of the D to do the Ada ramp repair into DDA District so we are you
083are asking for a motion to I'm not okay so I think we are we need a motion to say which package were I mean obviously I think you can decide that you're not prepared to make the decision tonight but the decision would be of these three projects what package we would want to move forward with for a formal proposal all right I'll make motion reques toit a formal proposal yes oh right so either way we would want to have submit I have noide to said I'm sorry I'm sorry he said the motion would also include having informal proposal okay for the RO I make a motion for row to prepare a formal prop proposal that covers projects one two and three as presented in this memorandum support all in favor we have to do we
084have to do fin fin okay Charles yes Mar yes yes Jacob yes Ashley yes okay yes okay chair did this clarify what what what that will meant prepare proposal for your ination at next month's meeting or prepare prepare these bid documents and to go out to bid I guess is my appication need I said proposal okay because I think that covers that was an agreement that we would do projects one two and three in this I can amend I think your intention was do a whole for um I I just want to be very clear though my intention was I would love to see it get out to bid for all three projects I'm happy to go and prepare is what he brought up prepare and your saying we can post because we are on
085we are time constrained on this right um yeah you want to bit in the spring for sure so to move forward okay so if we're going to do it if we're going to change this then we to vote down the first amend the first proposal well she defines what her proposal was no we have to vote it down and then re then redo it it's what she was we need clarification yes that's all I need if you're happy with that being the clarification verbally otherwise we have to vote it down then redo it let's vote it down and I'll reward it okay okay Charles uh we're voting no means get it off the table Yes means keep it right just so don't clear so I'll say no Mar no Scott no Jacob no Ashley no
086no motion fail so redo your I am going to make a new motion I am going to make a motion for row to create a proposal and bid packet to for projects one two and three as proposed in this memorandum to start the pro process with engineering costs to be no higher than $47,000 support does that does that mean am I missing anything thank you I'm Rusty know you okay call call Charles yes Howard yes yes yes yes yes all right tting am all right moving right along thank you thank you thanks Pete thank you all right agenda item 10A Skyline light reimbursement so this is um I wanted to bring this up for discussion so when the skyline lights my proposal is we need to have come to an agreement on a process for
087reimbursement for the skyline lights and the downtown patio lights unfortunately it appears as though um none of the businesses have been reimbursed at this time for an agreement that was made over a year ago um so I have gotten all the data together and I'm ready to proceed with making a payment for the last year my question would be how would we like to proceed from a payment standpoint do we want to do quarterly twice a year annually yes I mean I've received uh comments from business owners as you know I but no one said the annually or monthly it's a relatively small amount isn't it um it depends on the business some of them are much lower than others what's the high and the low the highest one we have is 145 and the
088lowest is 19 for year year year year do we want to prepay or postpay postpay postpay so once a year we will pay for the prior Year's cost incurred okay perfect and if I may ask can too I don't know how to affect your business but just we need to communicate to the business owners you know just because of my interaction with different business owners I they politely by the way no one's been crabby or anything like that but they've asked about it which is fair just I'll just make sure we tell people hey where we are paying AED sure and we'll pay at the end of the year just in case utility rates go up or down yeah communication right and I think that's the biggest challenge sorry um I was ask just I
089think that's the biggest challenge is we have some business owners that are a little well I should say one that's more vocal she's no longer in the district anymore so we didn't have a reminder that was going to be my question is the only playing Devils have because I think through I inherently want to say a year but I don't know if we want to do twice a year just in case there are any bus small small amount what's not F around I don't know 145 can be I I I'm playing double zate here well you were successful and I don't I mean I don't even know if they're plugged into my building I'm guessing they're not okay yeah cuz I reach out to all of the business owners that are on the list and
090none of them have received reimbursement they didn't you know they were like oh thank you you know we haven't awesome so they know what under anything they they because they were they were told that they would be reimbursed they just haven't been for the record I'll make a motion for Skylight reimbursement program to be reimbursed on an annual basis by the DDA to the business owners support okay any discussion all in favor call it's Mone oh it's money yes okay Charles yes Powers yes oh yes yes Jacob yes Ashley yes Jay yes J it's okay what's about say you know by way do you see him scooting further you have a 30-day trial for you can retire tonight well this one should be a lot less controversial oh yes uh January board meeting agenda 10B
091yes so um our next board meeting is scheduled for January 20th I believe which is Martin Luther King Jr day um the office is closed um so I didn't know if that would we wanted to keep it on that holiday or if we wanted to reschedule I'll say this we've always kept it it's never really affected anything here I won't be pres you might not be able to get the door if I don't I'm not here there's another reason have it I won't be here that's the point neither will I oh that's a good point I'm gone that we too I'm gone that week also what do our bylaw say when we run into a situation like this say what's that there's nothing in there that I'm familiar with in the bylaws I don't remember
092we usually disagree we' always met with that dat I just want make sure never never use that date as a reason not to meet or any holiday orolay Christmas we had that conflict yeah but I don't think you you were you weren't taking our meeting minutes I'm sorry for K day uh last year was the first year was a holiday for us and I didn't come to that meeting Kelly Kelly did the minutes to do the minutes that was the case paron the minutes if that was a situation yeah I can so AR for keeping on the 20th is just because it's part of our schedule but whatever works I yeah I don't care one the other you're gone in Australia forek gone what two weeks I can't make we can zoom you in okay
093don't said we can't do that anymore so what have decided keep the [Music] 20th is the building going to be open is the building going to be open um no we have to get it I get it I get someone with a key oh be careful temporary okay whoa she's getting a key cool just does your contract follow Village employee like for Holiday okay well then I think we have to move in then that's so that's easier Mo Scott wants to celebrate inauguration day he just said so all right I know get sitting in a bar maybe the 27th I will be going on the 27th but I mean we'll just pick a date it's we're all going to have con 13 that's fine I but at the same time how much new stuff is
094going to be by the 13th right um I'm hoping not a lot I'm hoping the next month is the slowest month ever that's fun so we're missing two people on the 20th or just one if we keep it on board members and your staff right and we need a key what do what do you propose Kimber pardon me what do you propose I don't have an opinion I don't mind coming in on the 20th because I think we've we've kind of have an understanding that I you know I work when I need to work and then I take time off and I need to take time off so I'm not opposed to coming in on the 20th I don't like what making somebody on one of their contractual I agree with you holidays oh okay
095yeah okay let's move into the 27th then okay good got thank you st an aeration all right January 27th is the next board meeting you have a motion for that or no I think so well so you approve your we approve our we we approved it 20 depending what years was so I would I would for a motion that you guys change the January 25 meeting I'll make a motion that we change the next DDA board meeting to January 27th support all in favor I all not approved e easy yeah all right um next agenda item is 10c new board members we have two new board members present with us today Ashley Ross and J how and if you would just take a few minutes and introduce yourselves please s you can say time again
096my name is j Choy um I've been a resident of village for 7even years or so and I got married two years ago we were living actually right above Scott's pizza shop and it was a temporary thing and then we're like man we love it here so we stayed we started our own business this year and now we're just hunkering down and you know all the plans to move to Romeo or Rochester or out the window and we're just settled down here and we wanted to be involved and so here we are and uh I guess first of all thank you guys thank you to this committee to make you know make this town so awesome as it is and I do hear that word quaint quite a quite a bit that word yeah from
097my clients from Rochester they love coming up here because it's so different than every other little town and I do see how much is being invested back in by the business owner by the residents um on all the even the trolley the trolley I think it's it's adds so much flavor and little things like that um we've definitely noticed and we want to be involved in um helping that level level up a little bit more I guess awesome excited to be here thank you you're welcome thank you ashy hi everyone I'm Ashley raw stop right there thanks for letting me come back um I am member at large this time so just a regular old member with my own opinions I'm happy to be back I love the DDA you know I do so thanks
098for letting me come back and welcome to both of you all right uh 10d uh or committee appointee so I will speak on behalf of um the ddaa we talked um I talked with Pete and M I haven't had a chance to get connect with you yet but um with Ash ley's joining we would like to um have a motion for her to join the boorder committee as I'll make that motion the organization committee second okay all in favor or any discussion on that all right all in favor opposed and then we'll know about J next month giving him a minute if he comes back if he comes back yeah all right great uh 10 e board training and planning session so that was what I mentioned earlier um wanted to get your thoughts around
099having a session outside of a board meeting to talk through 2025 strategy I realize we're all very busy so I want to keep it very short and sweet I know when we did the strategic planning that was a very long session I have zero intention on having it that long thinking an hour maybe just really to understand from a board stand Point um what the priorities are as we've gone through a staffing transition as we're you know redeveloping and fostering relationships with the Village um just looking at what we want to prioritize for 2025 so I just wanted to bring that for discussion I think it's a great idea as long as it's short and sweet any other opinions yes Here Comes one his it's not my opinion it's the Attorney General's opinion that all
100meetings like that will keep workshops or not need be posted properly posted noticed and documented and minutes taken okay doly noted and open it the B and open to the public now and you're more than welcome to use like we do in our work sessions for our budget meetings right you can post it in the community room it's it's it's more productive to get out of this setting and sit around that table and have those conversations it's lighter right room there's plenty of camera yes but just just keep that and again you only need 18 hours to post it to be legal if you guys are in here you know what how about Wednesday evening it's great that's 20 that's 48 hours away you could do it then and you just the property post thank
101you Kimber can you propose some dates perhaps and email them to us and then we can do it that way rather than sit there good yeah we can look at our calendars and that just to clarify will be in 2025 because than you we are done the D as also do she's out for the holiday I I I told I told the village earlier I may physically be here for the next two weeks on occasion but please don't assume that mentally I here in any capacity we never have oh listen you're just my public record the camera guy is laughing come on all right 10 up soup and sweet reimbursement okay so I wanted to bring this for discussion I had so historically I have data from last year I'm trying to gather data from
1022022 that was my first year here um I don't know that I was as involved in the reimbursement process for soup and sweet um I do have one of the numbers but not both numbers for um our reimbursements but I had a business owner reach out to me to have some discussion around the division of the pool of money surrounding soup and sweet so I wanted to bring that for discussion historically what we did last year is we had a larger payout to our soup vendors versus our sweet vendors and the rationale for that was because we recognized that making 20 gallons of soup was Quite a feat and that sweets It's hard to put a value for us to make a judgment a value judgment on how much effort money is being put into
103a suite when you have one business who's going to the store and buying baged candy versus another business who's spending a lot of time in a kitchen making homemade treats um so I wanted to bring that for a discussion and see what the thoughts were from the board um if we want to make any changes last year the student soup was the payout was 475 per business and the Suites was 125 the data that I have from 2022 the Suites were 100 so we did go up I do not have the data for the um soup for 2022 just a couple of comments um I think you need to consider the amount of Labor that's involved because labor is money in a restaurant and um I don't know exactly how many hours it would be
104but it's it's pretty pretty substantial and you know that includes buying the ingredients storing and prepping them properly actually making the soup storing it again uh reheating it and so there is a there is quite a bit of labor involved as opposed to purchasing a suite and putting it on display now if they're going through the trouble of making a suite I I guess that would be another option for them whereas we as restaurants don't have the option to really buy soup and just have that they're hot and ready to go so there's always going to be labor involved so I I think that should just be considered I'm not saying that you know the one is worth $500 and the other one's worth A1 um I just think that the the whole picture has
105to be factored in and uh maybe going forward we whatever we decide as a suite reimbursement maybe we give a dollar amount that you know buy X number of Suites and that's what you'll be reimbursed for and you know that it is what it is you know whether with with but with soup it's every every recipe is different all the ingredients are going to be a little different I spent $637 on making 22 gallons of soup so that's with labor that's not labor just ingredients just ingredients so I mean that's um I I can't imagine that anybody's making cookies or that's coming even close to over a couple hundred bucks so I think it's apples marges that you're you're I mean plus technically those people aren't even supposed to be baking things and having them
106at their place right CU they're not in a they're not in a licensed kitchen so technically they should be buying stuff from Costco or whatever I mean to be official R go ahead what if they just sorry I was um what if they do have a kitchen and that is their business that was going to be my question cuz I think that's what's prompting the question is that we do have some yeah I wasn't thinking I wasn't even thinking of that so yeah that would be like a restaurant I would mean labor there's I think the there are the cost discrepancies but I think if we're talking about for example bakeries in our district who are going to be making they're going to incur the same costs labor right yeah I I wasn't even thinking
107I was thinking of the retail shops that put out you know purchase sweets really that was mine can we amend what they were paid this past time because I know if you're saying $637 no labor and we gave one no labor no lights yeah I mean that's none of that and we gave one group who is a commercial kitchen 125 even though they did the labor and all that in comparison I don't think that is fair for well you know part of it I'd say this in previous years we didn't do anything right we gave zero refor so before somebody starts whining or complaining remember that but we also had a lot of businesses that dropped out because of that because and that was a great idea I'm not saying that it wasn't I'm I'm
108totally an in to cover the full cost necessarily it's it's a a contribution support so I would say by going back to what Ashley said I would say going forward as opposed to back because we have not made any payments for this year as of yet because I wanted to talk so we can Define the strategy for 2024 well part might be that there's a kitchen invol I buing from from Maria from Scot that would be one of thein factors and and I'm going to repeat this for emphas remember in the past we've never done any reimbursement that's like in the last couple years yeah but we won't have participation with col no that's that's not the issue we won't have businesses if we're asking them to donate the point is made that decision right
109right so if I'm hearing this correctly it's like instead of doing soup versus Sweet let's do commercial kitchen versus non-commercial kitchen no if you if you're serving food that you've made it has to be made in a commercial kitchen whether you're a restaurant serving soup or Bakery serving B even if you're a restaurant that wants to serve a sweet you should you should only get reimbursed so much right yeah yeah and there's a there's a higher cost producing 20 gallons of soup than there is right X number of sweets so so would you say then there would be like three levels there would be the suit makers the commercial kitchen Bakery sweet makers and then the non I don't know the cost but I don't like I I I'm going to rely on the two
110of you who know the most I feel like that for my end not knowing anything about this that seems very awkward because we're essentially calling out currently one business right right and I know they have labor costs I know that they have food costs but I don't know how that compares into making soup versus however many sweets we asked folks to make but there could potentially be several more in that category there are you know we have a number of businesses in the District that produce food on the premises that's a business whether it be a bakery a sweet shop a coffee shop coffee shop that's very true you know I mean that so that category grow how much money is available Ian is the typical pool and we could divide it I think last
111year it was 15 and we're looking around that time that same amount this year we have money to do this this yes it may not we have more people participating this year so as we div it out the actual number per business might be lower than it was last year but the full pool is slightly higher than last year and keep in mind folks on these uh the weather's a huge factor in all this I mean I've worked at it for years and years and years there's times we had very few people it was cold and rainy mean people aren going to come out to go soup and sweet you know like that stuff freezing their hands and their fingers you know all kind of stuff off and it rain so had it was cold
112but it was pleasant yeah it was great well I I don't think any business expects to have all their their costs covered you know because it is it's a community outreach it's marketing it's you know so I think we just need to decide how to divy up the pool I think you're right with the three then soup one level commercial made sweets one level store bought one level why have why would we even have store bought all the retail all the retail shops they want to par all the boutiques and and insurance agents they're out it goes back to marketing too right well yeah but you could say that about everybody yeah you could that's my point I think oh joke Sor yeah did you want to sing something so as a person brought my
113wife and son down here enjoyed it it was a very great event um and you buy your ticket you get five punches and it was 17 things you had to kind of be strategic where you're going right so I like to help spread it out better um but I know the one particular brownie Shop North of town that we attended and I would have bought some stuff and well got her handouts and I think that's probably where you're leaning towards say look she's got ran overhead commercial kitchen ovens staff making all this stuff I can't imagine being a lot different from where you were at as far as her Allin CA because sweets I don't know what their Market is but I know they're pricey to buy but know what I don't know I can't
114I think the only versus let me I just wrap up my point versus you you they got cookies they bought a costume that's and to your point I think it's a good idea to say look if you're giving out those sweets here's your 125 buy whatever you want give out what you want you guys are in a whole different ball game your suit is 40 bucks a gallon yours is 45 a gallon mes is a 25 a gallon you're so you're not trying to compensate evenly you're just trying to enough to make it good for everybody yeah and I think the the other piece of that and there's not too many of us but restaurants that don't have a bar mhm I did 30% Less business that night because I'm going carry out pizza place
115and nobody can even get there so I'm cool with that like I'm fine with that I realize that it's for the betterment of all but like yeah so many buying Costco cookies yeah Costco cookies and and uh Hershey's Kisses like you know did they even spend 100 bucks you but I mean I appreciate having real data so much so thank you yeah I just wanted to make point that that causes similar candy can candy are expensive Nott this but no I think that's what he's say I think right it to me it sounds logical I think it makes it more complicated for me cuz I didn't I can't if you're something from your commercial space for this event you get a middle ground somewhere in between there I think only see two categories if you're
116making that commercial if you're making something in your commercial kitchen in your business here in the district you get that 475 or whatever you're getting the H gotcha and then or you're getting 125 whatever it works out to be I think the same the only here's the only thing is and this is where it becomes kind of more complicated so not using names I know of certain businesses that what right wrong or indifferent made or hired someone to make items for their Suite they do not have a commercial kitchen in their business that is not their business but they contracted that out to make that happen because they wanted a higher value treat and then we have other businesses to your point that go to the grocery store and get a bag of chocolate kisses
117or little small candy bars and they're currently getting the same amount yes it is a a it's a choice right but that's where it comes back to we need I for me I think we need to have specific criteria because it becomes to it becomes like a judgment call and I don't want to be that one making that judgement you have a commercial kitchen in the district this and you made something in it you get it because I do think to Scott to Scott's Point not only did he lose all these extra things that lose volunteer gave them um but you're losing business and where other folks might you're doing that say I'm a real estate or whatever I paid somebody to do cookies with my brand on them that's marketing so that's me dipping
118into my marketing budget after you gave me 125 and I haven't really lost any business I still put an investment in but I could have done the same thing with 125 does that make sense I think we still saying three TI I think that everybody who makes soup is going to spend more than 475 and anybody who buys sweets will probably try to stay under 100 I mean I think taking away from the 125 and giving it to the people who make soup I mean that's that's what people want people want souit they don't want Hershey kisses and starb Candy they could get themselves they just had two months ago on Halloween yeah good point and that that would promote people making suits too if we have more suits I think that that will go
119better but we also want to promote said bake shop to work for two days and make all those sweets cuz I know like just going back in a previous meeting um she had said you know I did all these Canoles and I SP all this money and all this time and I think the answer was well you need to do less but have more varieties of things for people to buy if you have a smaller sample but I think she did and I heard R reviews and there was a huge line over there so she must had something good I couldn't even get away she always does I mean she always has a long line than a half asset no and I think 125 is not enough in comparison to what everybody else yeah so
120bumping her up to the commercial kitchen level I mean it would make sense I would agree with that I think that um and you know like only three people would fall into that right you're talking about them Bagel bombs and the ice cream place like that's a commercial kitchen right so and they did have sweets I mean that would just be my thought just there me I know they pld out within an hour within one hour said she made like 500 sweet like pieces of sweets and within an hour the table was clear cuz you were those were punches they were just out for the T yeah right yeah yeah people are like yeah so the other question this might be I want to ask this one before you make the motion but for businesses
121that did both that may both that's a choice that's a choice okay cuz they didn't sign up for both what does what do you mean exactly what if they did like when we had to send you are you going to do a super or you going to do a sweet there wasn't an option to do both okay right I don't I'm just saying what the reimbursement is why are we deing around with this I because I know that that's decision you know it's like you can't figure out do you need a decision from us on the amount for this year or okay no I just need a decision on the strategy okay so if someone could make a motion for a three tier I think is what we were saying it was two no I'll
122make the motion I think make it myself uh I make a motion to have a three tier reimbursement program for soup and sweet uh the three categories being commercial kitchen soup commercial chick Chicken commercial kitchen suite and storebox Suite support all in favor what Financial you have to vot individually well we don't know what the amounts are we just have a strategy all in favor all opposed okay uh next agenda item is uh items removed from consent agenda don't believe we had any and then we have board member comments so Ron I going to start with you since we're talking about money I'll I'll give you some good news to leave with Before Christmas is the township I was talking to Township Trader Ferrari H the day the township will be contributing exra $35 to
123$40,000 that range next year okay thank you good but we want some soup and some sweet soup how follow delivered we need to do a pizza and beer shroll that but that's that's a chuning change so that's some good news com next year thank you okay um I want to welcome our new members and um thank the the departy members lean and uh Bryce um I thought this month was great with activities um soup and sweet is always a a fantastic event so I think we as we continue to make it better and better each year uh it'll just continue to grow and and really give our community a big big gold star um wish everyone a Merry Christmas and we'll see you in the new year at some point ditto on everything I think
124I talked a lot this meeting so um Happy holidays and we'll see you in January um thank you all for having me Kim I want to say I really appreciate in your executive report um the ROI looking really strategically at what we are doing moving forward um I think that's very important especially for you to be able to have white space do some of those really critical things to the job I think I'm just so impressed that You' jumped in and are thinking through all these things so thank you and nice to meet you welcome yeah it's nice to be here looking forward to it I don't have any ideas right now I'm sure here Joe did you have a comment yes yes as as you're only a non voting member um which I'm happy
125you um I made some notes here so and and thank you St for noticing some of the efforts by our DPW staff super sweet scoll because you know we kimberland got together a couple weeks earlier and sent out an aerial of okayy here at the downtown people here's the parking Bays we would prefer that they push the snow all the way out into those parking Bay so DPW can push that away with their things as with drivers who can't drive every time it snow the first time of the year sometimes takes remember they have to settle first time that snows in the so down as crew recognized um there was a lot of undone sidewalks not just the parking base but sidewalks on that Friday morning and they spent significant amount of time throughing the
126quad and and Manpower down there to clear those off to ensure that it was much better for everybody that evening as well as coming through then putting salt and stuff into the parking B trying to get those C out as well they weren't asked to do so they just recognized that and and did it so thank you for no and again on other parts you maybe didn't see up in your neck of the woods other parts there was a fair amount of sideb had not seen a shuttle so that was true that they did that I appreciate that um and I was making some notes as you were talking about the shuttle and you know the trolley versus the the shuttle I should say um and yet to your point it's the it's the Nostalgia
127of it or the uniqueness of it that kind of people want to ride it it's riding an not bus is riding not bus but if that's what's better than nothing I would still say so if you have problems with that trolley you know maybe down the road but I did want to speak to it my interest about you got to go back to kind of what I talked to back in August about the state statute and I touched on it earlier the statute is very specific reasons why these taxing entities are given up money to fund the district and for very specific reasons for the state statute of infrastructure and removing and collab structures and things like that those are first and foremost what the statute was in place for there are certain restrictions you
128have to contend with about spending that money within the district predominately um so when you start talking about running the shuttle out greater Oxford I think that's something I to have a really close look at on again the county sometimes the people in the county downtown park they're not DDA districts and and sometimes they want to tell outside the lines I think in my opinion um but going from the one downtown to the other downtown with the shuttle probably can find a way to make sure that's importance with the state statute but you always got to keep that in mind how are you you guys have been um challenged to to rewarded with this funding from all these different entities predominantly the township and the village and couple of County agencies so you just got
129to keep that in mind with those lawful expenditures making sure that they they fit the statute things like that um and so and every now and then I'll see some of the committee reports like I need to stop them where they're at now because they get these ideas or we do this we going do that like we have zoning ordinances we have RightWay setbacks and things like that so every now and then I'll maybe I have to just chat with some of them and um like in the drawing and Al I can share it with I with kly I showed her where the U full application is that went to the open County for these AR funds obviously you guys should all see that and be aware of it there was some initial drawings in
130there as you go over East berck here by the archway that Scott had drawn the curvature of the uh new curbing coming inward to to make it narrower there would be less to go across my first reaction is like no that can't happen we're not going to take that wide Lane and and narrow it with curbing coming in we have to plow it you have people traveling it no leave the curvs where they're at deal with the the width of the road so every now and then you know I got to be Grinch but uh that's my job so other than that I think it was a great event I think everyone loved it you know good suit I didn't get touch them all but it was great so thank you and merry Christmas thank
131Pete are you still away sorry here I will not get J or either um I have my surgery Wednesday so I'll be in quarantine for a couple months um try to support you as much as I can Kim really I to talk back and forth quite data and everything keeping things going um welcome the two new members Ashley welcome back look forward to it um wish everybody a happy holid thanks a motion that we meeting yes the December 16th meeting of the Oxford DDA is now complete