001uh I'd like to call to order tonight's Charter Township of Oxford Planning Commission regular meeting Thursday December 12 2024 if we could all rise pay rests to the flag flag of the United States of America and to the repic for stands one nation indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you thank you than you very much uh can you note the role uh yes first I'll make sure that your mic is on when you are speaking so that means the green light has to be on and then speak into it so uh roll call Ballard spizz Berger president Wagner BLK president Turner here Bailey yes there is a quum thank you um moving on to number four approval of the agenda um if everybody has the updated agenda um we do need to amend
002tonight's agenda to add items A and B so we make the motion please not that I'll make a motion to approve the agenda of tonight's Planning Commission meeting of December 12th 2024 with the Amendments of A and B added to the agenda do I have to those second okay we have a motion we have a second um any discussion seeing none all in favor all right any opposed that motion carries item number five conflict of interest xart contact does anybody have anything for this evening seeing none moving on to number six approval of minutes Planning Commission regular meeting November 14th I make a motion to approve the minutes of the regular Planning Commission meeting of November 24th 2024 and submitted November 14th November 14th okay I'll second okay we have a motion we have a
003second any discussion seeing none all in favor I I any opposed motion carries uh number seven public comment on items not scheduled for public hearing or on tonight's agenda does anybody have anything uh that's not on the agenda seeing none we will move on to number eight uh commissioner's comments nothing for tonight okay number nine public hearing we have none for this evening 10 unfinished business Master Plan update good evening Aqua Carl wman Associates for the township spending Consultants uh so yes so for this evening uh as it relates to the master plan at our last meeting if you recall we went through the implementation Matrix and discussed some both formatting changes um and language changes and so what you have in front of you this evening is the redline version of that um you
004can see with the format that we took the the funding and responsible party columns out and just noted them in the description that those would be identified when appropriate um and then from there we added the or made some language tweaks um based off of the comments that we received at the last meeting uh and then also went through and added the high medium low uh priorities uh to each strategy uh again noting that this evening uh or knowing that this evening we were going to have two site plans for review um our intent was to try to keep this um I guess as condensed as possible um so it wasn't my intent to go through every single page or Page by page but to merely just ask if there was anything in the red
005lines um that the commission had any concerns about wanted to change was good was bad um I Happ to answer any questions I mean we we can go through this in any depth that you wish to um but I'm really just here to solicit feedback on the the red lines for the implementation Matrix okay any comments or question I just had a couple comments going through it there's some language that's obviously changed from 19 2019 to the current um uh in general or the red lines uh in general like okay as an example um the uh Community character section there's three um obviously one objective but three strategies and in the 2019 there were seven strategies as I started to look at the seven strategies to try to look at how they might have been
006condensed from 7 to 3 um I think there's opportunity maybe to add some additional language in there but I wasn't able to formulate good clear concise take the time to to to summarize and see where there might be gaps between the seven and three and try to improve upon that without being too wordy so um I'd like to get back with you at some point in the future and you know we can maybe have further discussion or uh I can send you an email on my comments so we don't take a lot of time on topic if that's if that's acceptable to the chair if it's if you can email that would be great yeah for sure it's just going to take a lot of time to go through it like as I mentioned it's
007hard to take the 19 and the current and put them together and go okay what's what are the changes um and really try to be no I precise to the point trying to be as cognizant about that that comparison as possible when I'm when we're putting stuff in front of you guys I know we're kind of at the tail end of it but um yeah I'm definitely trying to be cognant of that but yeah if you got you know take some time put an email together um definitely reference those that comparison for sure thank you y any other questions comments um yeah I appreciate you being brief with it tonight um I did spend quite a bit of time reading this uh as I had quite a few flights this week so it it gave
008me good reading and um I think it makes a lot of sense I I appreciate the high medium low category I think it was well put together so thank you sir thank you any other questions none for me okay okay thank you thank you okay moving on to new business we will start start with item a um do we need to read that letter Susan or no he just need to accept it or not accept it okay um because I'm assuming everybody has received the the resignation uh from Mr spizz um who is currently our vice chair um so we will need to make a motion and uh approve the resignation going forward uh Mr chair i' like can make a um motion to accept the resignation of Vice chair Michael spiz this evening I'll
009second it okay so we have a motion we have a second uh any discussion um I would just like to say you know appreciate all the dedication and hard work and everything that uh that Mr spizz is has given to this community I know with some of his added responsibility at the county it's made it a little difficult but you know I I one appreciate everything he was been a good resource and uh somebody that I've gone to many times to ask advice on how to do things so I will truly miss his presence um with that all in favor all all any opposed seeing none uh motion carries Mr chair I okay I do have a question for you okay so at this point last night at the Township board meeting Mr n was
010appointed as Mr spiz replacement so at this point Mr n can come up to the Das speak thank you my question is with him being the vice chair do we need to now pause and nominate and vote for a replacement Vice chair or how does that move up in January um you'll do your officers again so at this point since you're here to run the meeting you don't have to rely on the vice chair okay there just won't be one until January when you make your appointments to the full board okay thank you very much um and then Item B is uh the 2025 meeting schedule um has everybody had a chance to look through that calendar is there any concerns or questions not for me none for me okay with that I will take
011a motion to accept the 2025 meeting schedule Mr chair like make a motion we accept the 2025 meeting schedule as presented I'll support okay we have a motion we have a second any discussion um all in favor all right any opposed seeing none motion carries um one thing I would uh bring on to the the new guy is um Susan is real particular about the microphone so um you know being your first meeting and all um make sure that the mic is close and thank you sir thank you I'll duly note that okay moving on to item C uh PC 24-3 Baron Industries additional final site plan proposed addition to existing building at 3020 Adventure Lane o Michigan parcel number 3766 the proposed addition is approximately 17,600 Square ft modification of the parking lot is
012also proposed the applicant is to sewick president hns United construction 12555 North Sagar Road Caro Michigan 48420 is the applicant uh available did I pronounce the name correctly yes Tom sewick HS United construction I also have uh Red Baron with Baron Industries here okay um what we'll do is probably start off with with both of you guys doing your information and then we can ask questions of the petitioner okay does that work yeah you guys to come up after all right good evening um again so tonight we're going to look at the final site plan for Baron Industries um this one's pretty fresh I mean we weren't up here too long ago talking at the Limon area um so I'll just kind of give a quick recap but stop me if you have any questions
013you know whatever you need let me know uh again so this is to put an addition of approximately 177,000 ft on an existing 9,000 ft building that's zoned industrial um on the corner of Adventure Lane and Oakwood uh Road um so at preliminary there were a few things that um that we reviewed as it relates to um they did need to go to the zba for some setback variances they went to the zba they got those variances uh so the building's placement and the parking placement does conform uh based on those um and that the you know they would need to resubmit a plan that address the deficiencies uh we do still have some additional information that's needed but I'll kind of ping on what that is as we go through it um and then
014there was a conversation about some Landscaping waivers and the the planning commission's General support for those waivers just given the sit's limited geography to meet buffer zones and there's already some natural landscape on the site um so we'll kind of go through those uh as um as we get through the review um again just as a refresh the site's about 4.2 Acres uh has about 500 fet of Frontage along Oakwood and 330 ft along Adventure Lane um in looking at the site access and circulation um you know we've met as far as the on-site access and circulation we don't have any issues with that uh one thing that we have noted through the process is the potential for recommending some improvements at the intersection of vent land and Oak Wood Drive um so our we
015had noted that if that intersection the oak wood concrete stops in the middle of the intersection of the road um and the wash out where it converts to dirt uh is pretty bad um given that the site will be reactivated we recommended that there be a conversation with RCC about some potential improvements at that intersection um I'll get to it at the end of it but RC's review has come in it just came in after the packet was um was formulated and put together so you do not have that information as a yet but the township has rcoc did flag that intersection for some recommended improvements um I'll let the applicant speak to that more um but we are call you know we we are bringing attention to that our Co has brought attention to
016that as far as recommending that at least the concrete be extended past Adventure Lane to make the make it no longer this transition from concrete to dirt and to better accommodate the traffic that might be coming and going through that area or cross site because we know that they have uh the site directly to the South as well um continuing on through the review uh we did note we went through Landscaping um and they did indicate the different waivers that they were looking for um and the these were waivers that we uh supported as well again just given the limits of all the different standards for industrial Lots but these lots are actually relatively small so it's hard to meet these standards uh so there is a waiver request um excuse me for some Landscaping
017adjacent to Oakwood Road and Adventure Lane um some standard site my apologies as it relates to residuous trees and ornamental trees and shrubs uh there's also a waiver requested for the East property line and that's more or less just because they're they're going to be leaving a lot of the mature vegetation along the east property line it already kind of meets the intent of a buffer um so given the waivers that they've outlined um again we we support those waivers and they have even though they were waved or they had the the approval of the Planning Commission to proceed with requesting waivers um they have made a fair effort at Landscaping the site um maybe more so than what someone granted waivers would have done um um so we appreciated that the only thing we
018cited with Landscaping is that they have a pad for a chipper and that equipment by the ordinance has to be screened they did screen it we just noted that I I whatever the plant material was was a little low make them taller yep so we're just asking you whatever you're going to screen the plant's got to be just a little bit taller than that um with lighting um the they had a their lighting plan is is good we don't have too many concerns about it we just need some more information items from them um as it relates to the lights not exceeding the 3500 Calin um we need a little bit more information about the parking lot lighting coverage averages and then the ordinance does allow for them to request uh light poles to be
01925 ft instead of 20 um the standards for that really revolve around adjacency to residential and things of that nature they're nowhere near residential um and the site lighting isn't it doesn't spill over into the neighbors uh so we don't have any problem with the requested 25 ft um after that um I mean really those are that's the bulk of our of our issues with the final sight plan the one the one thing to note with this as you may have read in our reviews is that uh we're going a little bit out of process here that the typical process and Jim hope I think you speak to it a little bit better than I can but is just that we you go for preliminary you get preliminary then you go get your Outside Agency
020permits you're coc's your Eagles your water commissions whoever else may be involved and then you come back for final the thought process always being that if if one of your Outside Agency permits changes the site plan then when you come to final we can get through that and understand it um you know the applicant is obviously on a and I don't want to put words in their mouth but kind of on an expeditious timeline to get this project going and it's kind of opted to come in front of the plan commission tonight without all of their Outside Agency permits in place um with kind of the understanding that should one of those permits change this plan we could end up back in front of you guys to review what those changes were um so with
021that that's that's kind of the bulk of my review I'm happy to answer any questions well I have a couple of questions Mr chair please I mean out of basically when you looked at items that needed to be addressed within their planes three of the last ones out of the seven are all dealing with basically uh the sections with Che 16c oh I'm not on excuse me it was green but dimly so uh you know with those foot candle calculations and the controlling of sight lighting and such and plus we're not near any residential I didn't have too many concerns with those three items there one of them in your seven was the ever green plants that would just need to be a little taller which he just talked about and said that's no problem
022the ones that I would be concerned about would would be maybe from Mr Sharp's engineering comments that he had in a letter that I reread again CU he's had a couple now one that's updated um just making sure that if there were any requirements from those items that might be with his concerns they would still then have to come back to us TR I wait for I was going to say do we want to keep these questions for Mato and then because otherwise I don't have any problems for for approval I mean from based on what I've got from the documents in front of me right now okay okay does anybody have any questions specifically for MATA yes John has his hand up also John you want to go we'll let the new guy go
023first thank you appreciate that on page two of your report you talk about approval requirements for uh the zoning board of appeals and then at the bottom of the page at the 12th meeting of October they they did approve are you keeping tallies on what they asked for what they approve from zoning Z from zoning board of appeals yes so they fulfill those requ requirements yep so when I go to review final I pull the I pull it was approved by zba and that's how I say yes or no and then the back the last page on page nine you talk about the Landscaping screening requirements and it alludes the fact that the Planning Commission gave the waivers are we Apples to Apples and what the Planning Commission promised at the preliminary yeah so it's
024it's kind of tough because land fullblown Landscaping isn't required until final correct but what I wanted from the EC's board was so that they they could adjust their plan accordingly would you be open to waivers the plan commission said yes they made plans that follow those waivers so yes we are in line we have a lot of pro process issues going on I just want to make sure that we keep track of dot the teas and cross the eyes yeah yeah we're good that was thank you you'll learn as you go John it'll come easier to you okay thank you sir on the LI side the light fixtures the controls you mentioned that would have to be addressed later um in the c16 document is that is that the idea going forward that that would
025get updated eventually yeah so what typically what we'll do is if there's a few small items left that we are comfortable reviewing administratively okay and saying okay to we have to stamp like so they would adjust the plan one more time with these minor changes we would look at it say it's good and then all of the agencies that are reviewing approve it then they can go get building permits and things like that but if if the building department doesn't have something stamped by Jim and I saying they did the things you said for them to do they don't get building per so to move that forward we'd have to approve it based on conditions yeah so you would give a conditional final site plan approval okay with that the township can administratively approve these
026things and it doesn't have to come back to you um so is is there any kind of risk you think this brings to the to the township no if if there was risk I wouldn't I I wouldn't bring it to you I'm just asking no no no I no it's a fair question just so you know like we if we if there were big red flags you know Jim and I wouldn't have it in front of you tonight well it's yeah about the Outside Agency permits I mean again that's it's not it's not our pick to do it that way not that there's anything wrong like they they're just on an expeditious timeline and and kind of accepted the risk associated with doing it this way okay I guess but I don't I guess from
027is the important piece I guess right yeah and I don't think I'll let Jim speak for his end of it I I don't in my mind I don't see anything coming from the outside agencies that's going to turn their world upside down but but there's that Asis of of CA if it does you got to come back sure sure I just want to make sure that we're not put in a bad spot the Township in that way yeah no we wouldn't we wouldn't bring it to you if we wouldn't do that to you how many outside agencies are we waiting for R they have R we have permit from County okay yeah so RC's in SO waiting for health department for their septic system and for their new well septic so we've been we are
028in count speaking with open County Health commission and we have SE architect design in the septic field it's going in the same exact location as their existing one so won't be it won't be making a change to what we have on the site as is it's it's the plan is go right back in that same location as in the well we're just we're we showed the new well on the back side of he shows where the new Well's going so we are working with them to get that okay M Mr chair yes for the other Commissioners the F item number one if we were to have a positive motion on this would be they have to obtain all the required approvals from Outside Agency so we we've got that as a blanket coverage so we're
029we're we're doing our due diligence on our side too okay commissioner perfect thank you I did have one more question in your report yeah um on page nine um there's uh sheet C4 talks about the uh underground tank said we deferred to the fire department we did get the letter from the fire department that just says everything's addressed and they gave approval but it's vague is there it's safe to assume that yeah I did I did reach out to BJ the Fire Marshall okay in between the two reviews to make sure that you know because that on-site water storage was kind of a real big thing for them and they confirmed that yep they looked at F sight plan they're they're still good with what the guys are proposing okay we we also spoke with
030the fire fire chief on that to get the exact tank and size that he wanted so we're we're going with exactly where he he request it okay yeah we got the letter that says you know he He suggests approval but with your deferral I just wanted to yeah just check no I always Snoop around township hall before and make sure everybody's on the same page thank you that that was the only question I had Mr Sharp um yeah so I think a lot of this is going to be a reiteration of what's already been said but a lot this is just basically out of sequence so that's a lot of our uh concern we did do an engineering review um and there there were some items that need to be addressed that being said I
031don't think that the items that they um need to address are going to alter the overall site plan minor items some grading issues some things like that but nothing that is going to change the site significantly um other than maybe the uh the health department saying you know something about the well or something about the septic which we have no control over that um you do have the RO Commission in your packet as well again that's a recommendation um it is an off-site improvement so we can't tell them what to do but it sure would be nice if the applicant would step up to the plate on that one and maybe finish up that roadway there but again that's a recommendation from the road commission we cannot you know direct the this to what to
032do um with regards and you know you should have my um should have the letter there that's stated November 22nd talk about San ter while the storm sewer there'll need to be a storm water agreement that needs to be put in place but as far as all of the other uh items regarding the payments sidewalks things of that nature everything seems to fall um you everything meets the township requirements there is an area that they're showing on the plans where there's a retaining wall That's necessary so again an engineering related item where they would need to provide us with some structural drawings on that um but again really that's that's about it um again it was just out of sequins and we do like to have those reviews that's the new process that the township
033has and so that was uh that's the primary concern that that we had um at the time but any other questions Mr Burger had one that well the only thing that you I've read your summary your project summary so you kind of confuse me a little bit because in the project summmer you said we would not recommend Planning Commission Grant final approval on the site plan and as it relates to to the engineering items but now you're saying with the engineering items that are left to be completed you're okay it's just that we're out of sequence we're out of sequence and that's the primary reason is cu generally that was the only primary reason excuse me that was your only primary reason correct okay then I'm okay with it correct okay all right and then
034you mentioned something about the recommendation for cementer finishing up that I mean is that something that we as a Township can require or for not for an offsite do that again okay not for an offsite we can't recommend an offsite we could recommend but we can't make some we talking about the roadway yeah yeah yeah again it's it's a recommendation from the road commission so we can't make them make off we can't force them to do the offsite okay the rural commission said you have to do it that's plain as day but this is a recommendation not a requirement so that's the difference Mr chairman sir I believe there's a onepage letter from the county that that basically says they wouldn't do anything till next spring any were beyond the date where they would take
035things up this year yeah that's included in their um their permit basically they approv the the application the actual permit has not been pulled the contractor will go P that go pull that permit from the county post the bonds and things so right now it's really just a uh preliminary approval from the county they've approved the permit appc but they contractor will have to go pull that yes but there can't be any Paving done this time of year and we have already paid for permits already through Road Commission we had the bond we had to put up a bond and we paid for the permit so we have everything in hand with the road commission right there and if um we are talking with them about the recommendations on exactly how they want it finished
036and and working with them to see how how that will work out so we are actively looking at making those recommendations is uh again back to if this is to be approved tonight a condition would be that they meet all the engineering requirements because we did Issue a um a review letter to them back on the 21st like literally the day before this this review came out um suggesting that not suggesting but requiring that um revisions be made to the engineering plans so that still needs to be resubmitted to us okay okay okay that's okay any more questions for Mr Sheriff Mr chair being sir new on this I'd like to make a motion if I could try make an attempt okay I move to approve the final site plan for partial number ID 0404
037376 d006 Baron industry expansion located at 3020 Adventure Lane subject to the following conditions item number one applicant obtains all required approvals from outside side agencies including all approvals set forth in the township Engineers report number two applicant obtains final engineering approval number three submission of a revised final site plan addressing any outstanding deficiencies identified in the reports from the township consultant the Township Fire Department and the township Administration ensuring compliance with the zoning excuse me ensuring compliance with the township Zone in ordinance and appical County state and federal regulations and number four approval or waiver of a development agreement by the Township Board of Trustees as required under section 16 16.1 n of the Oxford zoning ordinance if not already completed I'll support that motion for discussion okay we have a motion we have
038a second and any discussion amongst Commissioners seeing none uh roll call vote please bow sec I'm here I'm you are you asking for a vote or a yes I'm here yeah Turner you said roll call threw me off approved berer yes n yes Bailey yes motion passed thank you thank you thank you well you did uh you did really good on your first thank you yeah a problem y you guys too we'll move on to item D see go to work on it sir okay item D PC 24002 onclave of Woodbridge phase three final site plan parcel number 04 2 200025 is located on the south side of East Market Street East of North ler Road applicant enclaves of Woodbridge LLC 51410 Milano Drive S15 mome Michigan 48042 applicant is proposing nine new buildings consisting
039of seven duplexes and two Triplex buildings this phase of the condominium development consist of a total of 20 units so we will start off with you again okay uh so this is another one that uh we saw not too long ago uh so this is the third and final phase of the enclaves of Woodbridge uh development um so you know again this is kind of to round out the total project uh phase three consisting of the 20 units uh that were just mentioned um one of our items is just that again when they when the time is to submit for permits uh architectural drawings need to be stamped um that's formality uh just as kind of a review that the total sight is about 10.2 Acres uh phase 3 is about 5.2 Acres um again
040the the units with the exception of some triplexes are the same as what you've seen in Phase One in phase two um on this one getting to final I think on uh the only thing that we kind of ended up with was uh there's a note there that the applicant shall disclose the allowed um dimensions for rear decks and this just relates to that site has a lot of utility easements that in the early phases we were running into problems with having to deny deck uh permits because uh contractors just and owners didn't know we got around it it's all been figured out but that's just been kind of a rolling thing through all the phases is like now you just got to let the owners know and they're they're Fair parameters I mean there
041good size decks uh just save us a little bit of administration time and uh when the uh the deck applications come to us so that was one item that we just wanted to make sure was addressed after that um everything else looked good um their Landscaping looks good uh the the only thing for us was that uh the Planning Commission has given them approval through the first two phases to use the decorative lighting and so we're just citing that the the lighting that goes in for phase three needs to conform to the lighting that they used in the other phases um and then honestly after that um that's all we had so again happy to recap or answer any questions I have one small question Mr chair sir um in regards to the master deed
042and bylaws that's obviously presented to the attorney for their approval where do we do you know where we stand with that right now is it we're working through the process currently we're working through that process so that would have to be part of the condition of motion no I I mean not for Sight plan not for site plan I I know Britney assists with the Motions I guess uh not having it in front of me I'm not sure if she called it out in a motion I don't know either that's why I was kind of bringing it up no that's fair I mean yeah typically I mean we do have to get through Master deeds and bylaws but it's it it's not always part of final site plan review um because the board has to
043approve it as well tell you board to board yeah yeah so we don't know where we're at that right now well no I know we're in we've we're in conversation with the applicant about it I mean it's not um there was just email not formalized not yet but again it also will just to add it will be more or less an amendment to the documents that exist for phase one and two for continuity but we're asking for final s plan rule tonight correct and to add on to his question I see on page 11 it says they are required for final site plan application yeah that's why I was confused okay well Jim the answer I believe it is required for final s plan now because again we've changed that process where they go preliminary
044engineering condo docks permits everything and then you come back for final that being said that being said there have been some uh emails that have been uh going around since the packet came out um and the seventh it will be the seventh amendment to the enclaves of Woodbridge Master deed um has been reviewed I know our office has reviewed it and we have no objections to it I do not believe that the uh final verdict from the attorney has come through um but as Mato had just indicated there if it's not it's not officially approved but it's very very close to be completed well then I guess I it directs me to another question we could put a condition as to final approval as long as the master deed is accepted and approved through the
045township correct you could make that part of your condition do it might have to be part of a condition of motion Mr chair yes ma'am it it is listed as one of the items on the sheet so as long as it's listed as an item and I think Mr n has this also oh he may have it I don't I don't have it okay the new guys hold out on us yes uh in I have a question and then I can verify that the question is is that we've done this is what the third of three phases correct correct so is it safe for this board to assume that it's pretty much the same M uh Master deed across the first two yeah as I had said like we like our note in the draftings
046going back and forth is that it should be an amendment to the existing Master bylaws to the other two phases for continuity and I believe that's that's what is in process yeah so there's similarity in language correct yeah okay and then to answer the board's question is uh approval by the PC of the master deed and bylaws is ited number three on a motion and you'll read that into the motion I'll be more than happy to if I have the opportunity all right okay well that answers my question anything else for myself any other questions for Mato I I have a general question whether it hits both bases um this utilities that are buried and the property coming up to them and you were concerned with decks and post and things after they did their
047final grading and everything we have is there's ample uh depth to all that um utilities that there won't be a problem after final grading you are you referring to like is there a fair amount of space for the decks for deck to be installed that as well as the dep I think talking about the oh they're not going to be great 4 in is below and hit power wire or anything no not to my knowledge they're all the grading in phase two has already been completed actually the grade in phase three has been completed we did approve the grading plan we had a preconstruction meeting and back in I believe October they went so all the depths are substantiated and known so when an applicant comes in for a deck on the back of his
048property they they know that the utilities are far enough down that they're not going to put a post well they won't even be allowed to they won't even be within the easement our big thing was understanding where the easements are I'm I'm sorry I've been gone for three weeks right you still have sprinkler systems underground fence possibly which you know applicants are going to do is that going to be a concern or no okay can't put anything permanent right that's our utilities are deep enough to yeah the utilities aren't a foot below the ground they're much deeper than that no gas Expos so I was just going to step in and go through my review real fast and um uh this one is in sequence they have received their all of their permits they have
049all the eagle permits everything that is necessary to actually begin construction out there so really the only outstanding item in our review were the um final you know revisions to the master deed and the condominium documents which is very well in process okay any questions for Mr sh no he covered thank you any questions for the applicants or any other questions um the only comment that I had we U did the preliminary site plan was the lighting and we approved it and I agree still to approve it I think one of our strategies is for Dark Skies as we move forward in time um and the location of this site is in other areas that are very well lit at nighttime so if a site like this were further away from the village and the
050outskirts the lighting may be more of a concern but I don't see any issues with that in this case no I think the football field will keep that pretty well sh the school Mr chair if I might attempt a a second motion tonight yeah please I move to Grant final site approval for PC file number 24- 002 partial number 0025 known by the project named phase three of the enclaves of Woodbridge project condition upon the being condition upon being completed by the applicant item number one applicant providing the information required by the township zoning order orates as set forth in the report submitted by the township Consultants the Township Fire Department and the township Administration item number two approval of by the Oxford Township Board of Trustees of a development agreement for phase three or
051an agreement to the development agreement dated September 5th 2023 and item number three approval by the PC of the master deed and bylaws I'll support the motion for discussion I have a question of my own uh the ma does this mean they have to come back to this board for the master deed and bylaws to be approved and recommended to the Township Board I I mean the way your motion was just read I believe you would you like to speak sir yeah he has his hand up any grade school if I may uh please good evening Mr chairman and honorable plan planning Commissioners I'm Daniel spatap for with enclaves of Woodbridge LLC we the um developer and applicant in this Mr Burger to address a lot of your questions within the last week myself and
052our cond attorney has been in communication with uh Miss Ellis the township attorney and previous drafts that were submitted were reviewed and at least verbally ascended to and approved however our attorney went to the Oakland County plat engineer you know for a pre-approval so we can continue to expedite this as far as getting the condominium documents approved and recorded and the plat engineer had uh noted a little tweak in um in in one of the uh text in one of the texts I think in one of the drafts in The Proposal 7th amendment that the reference to a Liber uh made mention in like a preamble first paragraph and the fourth paragraph there was an error it has since been corrected and today I received from my condum attorney um you know the correct version
053he submitted to uh the township attorney the correct version we expect approval from the township attorney with that consistent with the previous verbal approvals so when we can get to go ahead to um you know resubmit which I believe our attorney did today with uh Cheryl and the planning and zoning department you know for circulation for the appropriate uh approvals and once that's done we can expedite and record it if if at all possible you could perhaps make the condominium documents at Seventh Amendment you know uh as a condition of site plan approval as opposed to making another trip I would appreciate your consideration with that but whatever you decide um that would be fine we're in agreement with uh Mato as well as with Jim with their comments the lighting will be consistent in
054phase three as it was uh in phases one and two um as well as the uh when the uh building permits are assigned or even if it's required beforehand a stamp and sealed uh architectural uh prints will be done and submitted as well U as per the requirements for that I'm not sure if the planning Commissioners have ever seen any exterior elevations maybe if you driven by the community out at East Market Street but I'd like to uh if I may just show and circulate you can just circulate around what uh the development looks like It's the Final Phase of completion with the 70 units this is our exterior elevations you can circulate that these are the these are the duplex or the tri these are the duplex we have the two Triplex they're not
055in there but this is basically I didn't see documents on the triplex I have seen arit views of those after okay and this is what the model looks like as well too Mr chair okay so we have a on the floor motion on the floor we have a motion on the floor like I'm sorry the motion's been made and seconded so it has to be acted upon we have to call it we have to call it yeah we have to we have to call like to make we're still in discussion so one question I would have in discussion on that is is your motion written in a way where he does have to come back or can it be I I would like to offer a change to the motion so I think we probably
056should have to vote this motion now vot it down but what I'd like to change item number three approved by the PC of the master deed and bylaws once approved by the township attorning then correct me if I'm wrong I think that motion has to be voted upon before your correct motion can be redone correct yes so all in favor all opposed I'm going say no okay so that motion is denied correct okay now he's going to make a new motion bear with me folks I be I move to Grant final site plan approval for PC file number 24-2 partial number 000025 known by the project name phase three of the enclaves of Woodbridge project condition upon the following being completed by the applicant act provide the information required by the township zoning ordinance is
057set forth in the report submitted by the the township Consultants the Township Fire Department and the township Administration and approved by the Township Board of Trustees of a development agreement for phase three or an amendment to the development agreement dated September 5th 2023 and approval by the PC of the master deed and bylaws once approved by the township attorney I'll res support the motion okay so we have a motion we have a second any discussion okay can we get a roll call vote on this please Turner yes Berger yes n yes losk yes Bailey yes motion passed thank you thank you gentlemen thank you all right so we have ABC de completed we'll move on to number 12 Communications Andor committee reports uh Economic Development Committee I don't think we have a report for that
058this evening so we will move on to B ordinance Review Committee okay we uh at ATT tenative meeting today Matel and I were present of course Mr n was not part of it and Mr Bailey was absent who to personal needs but we did look at and you will see it the new in January there the new worksheet plan that will reflect to everyone the status of each of the projects coming through and uh we've been working on this so Cory I think you knew about it yes John you had seen it some partially in the past so we think we've got it ready to to come here and then go on also we have on that we have put the priorities of high medium and low and we've got the zoning items listed now
059last night at the Board review the two of the ordinances went through the second reading and were approved uh one was the zoning Amendment criteria uh ordinance 36 and then ordinance 35 which was the electrical vehicle charging stations were both approved so most of the items laid out to be worked on by the orc have been approved the only one that will carry over into next year off of this list is the animal animal distribution and I think that's it and we we are looking for membership next here who's who's on and who's op okay and that and that was actually one of my questions um I'm assuming you don't have any more meetings this year we don't have any meetings this year um so they'll start over next year yes and I know in
060the past we like to have three people right and one of which is preferably the Township Board liaison to the Planning Commission um so something to think about this is mostly for you is going into next year if we continue that with the Township Board Lea on I know Mr Turner and I you were the lia on um I think you bring more value to it that I so going into next year if we have the Township Board liaison I would like to step away and give you back that role but we can talk about that here when we actually do all that but something to think about thank you it looks like maybe the board leaon would be Mr Wagner since he the leaon to this committee okay I'm not sure how it will
061work and and and we can talk about that cuz maybe Susan you know I don't know that it has to be that person but I know in the past we've always done it that way so that the liaison can take back to the board what we're working on in the orc correct so maybe we can get some clarification on is that a requirement or a preferential I can ask Cheryl to to look at your bylaws okay because it is it is a committee of the PC so your bylaw is probably um reference it the okay okay we'll take a look at that when we go through all that next month all right number 13 uh planner engineering reports thank you um from a planning end we've got we've got a few we have a preap
062next week for a project and likely a preap in January so uh you know some interest starting to trickle through the front door and we are currently working on a site plan uh and special land use that you guys will probably see end of January um and I would just take this opportunity that it is not that I don't love seeing you guys but I don't think I'll see you again before the end of the year because I don't think we have anything line up for the 26th I know you're disappointed thanks D um but you know this is my first full year with you guys uh and I've I've appreciated it very much working with you guys and uh look forward to next year in all the fun stuff that we have to do
063I I know that there's moments where I've made you bang your head against the wall and there's moments you've made me bang my head against the wall but it's it's only made me better and I appreciate that so I appreciate the last year you guys thank you have a good nice you follow questions on the report I read it nice report first time huh well a second time so Ser any questions on the projects that are out there right now I think mato gave the summary of the stuff that might be coming up with any questions of no and I I will say I do appreciate getting that ahead of time okay keep doing it agree thank you um any last comments any I would like to make one last comment because I've enjoyed being
064on the Planning Commission for the past 20 years and I will no longer be on the Planning Commission after the end of this year because my term expires December 31st so from the previous people that I've had way back in some of the earlier days and George black and all the different people on the commission uh it's been a fun adventure and I've enjoyed it because I live here I like to try and think that I had a little bit of help with trying to help rewrite some of the stuff been on some of the subcommittees and whatnot and it's been a pleasure so thanks a lot guys thank you and I will say you will be deeply missed but it might be in warmer weather we have your phone number that's okay all right
065well thank you very much um we don't need a motion for adjournment no we don't all right we are adjourned