001e e e right welcome everyone the Board of Education meetings called to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liy and justice for all thank you everyone for being here welcome secretary Torres please take rooll here's all board members are present thank you colleagues let's now move on to the approval of the agenda unless there are objections tonight's agenda will be approved as printed all right excellent colleagues let's move on out to this very exciting part of our agenda the oath of office for our newly elected members um this evening we are pleased to welcome the honorable Judge uh a dear friend of this board to administer the oath
002of office to our newly elected members Elizabeth McGregor and Kim sran thank you so much for joining us um members McGregor and son if you would please join the honorable Judge at the podium thank you president ristic are you ready ladies you have been provided copies if you'd like to follow or you can simply Raise Your Right hands and repeat after me if you'll come kindly Raise Your Right hands and repeat after me I do solemnly swear I do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the state of Michigan and the constitution of the state of Michigan and that I will Faithfully discharge the duties of and that I will Faithfully discharge the duties of office
003of member office of member of the Board of Education of the Waterford Michigan school district of the Board of Education of the Waterford School District according to the best of my ability according to the best of my ability congratulations to each of you [Applause] welcome if I can just jump in here yes sir U I don't know if anyone realize that U judge is a graduat of Waterford I believe 78 from kry thanks Rob I'm here to help I'm here to help Rich that is C but again it just it's you know people say well what do people do what's happening this is a a graduate of waterr schols so thank you a point of personal privilege then I'd like to uh not only me my my dear wife is a graduate my three brothers
004and sisters uh my wife's brother as well uh but more recently of course my four kids two nephews and nieces and you know just kudos to the Waterford School District not only have they prepared you know my generation and other Generations but my kids' Generations three of them have completed college two of them are teachers one in Gran blank uh one in Clarks and one is a high school head coach for the swim team in gr blank and uh the kids have done wonderfully and I attribute that to the Fine staff and administration here in the Waterford School District so kudos to you and the and the board thanks Rob there's Round of Applause and Susan if we could please get the telephone number of Judge C's um uh children so we can bring them
005here that would be uh that'd be terrific so thank you so much Jorge we appreciate you um okay we are now going to welcome up principal Kyle Schultz to introduce some very special guests from Pierce Middle School and I'm intrigued all right guys thanks for having us today um in honor of the January being board appreciation month and us and at Pierce recognizing what a service this job is and and how important it is to our community we wanted to give you a gift that highlights the programs at Pierce that that you support so so uh importantly if you look Mr Martin there is passing out uh salad that is procured from our Greenhouse as part of our aquaponics class that our students Harvest um the lettuce and carrots come right from that Greenhouse the
006bowl that is in the wood bowl although it looks like generic if you look at the bottom of the bowl thank you so much Shell's always a distraction go this is awesome it's the story of my life right now if you if you look at the bottom of the bowl if you hold it up I know it's kind of dangerous but you hold it up you've got the Pierce um School District school name on it and then the new logo that was designed by a student last year um is part of a logo contest done by our art teacher Miss dman um that was student designed and that was um put in on there laser engraved by Mr barov um one of our other um elective teachers who has a great program we we found
007out today that him and Shelly and our office manager are the only ones that were there when the Time Capsule was put in 25 years ago at pi so we established that but' been running for a long time um and do a great job so I'm going to hand it over to Mr Martin who is is super talented and super passionate um does a great job with our with our kids in running a oneof aind as far as I know um program over at Pierce yes thank you Mr Schultz um could we possibly get a light off I don't know if or maybe not that's okay um yeah so I'm I'm John Martin uh you I'm at Pierce Middle School I've been teaching 8th grade here in Waterford district for the last 23 years uh
008started at uh at crer for eight years and then I've been 15 here at Pierce and back in 2007 my principal at the time Linn kazinski had said hey we're looking for some more eighth grade electives uh do you guys have any ideas and I'm like well my master's degree is actually in agriculture uh before before I came to Waterford I was a a research specialist at the University of the Virgin Island's agricultural experiment station uh and so from then I came up with the the aquaponics class and so what aquaponics is basically it's a combination of aquaculture and hydroponics you know like it says aquaculture is the culture of aquatic organisms as an Agricultural Product uh whereas Hydroponics is the culture of terrestrial plants without soil instead using a nutrient solution as the growth
009medium and aquaponics is the combination of the two technologies uh where the fish waste is used as a fertilizer for the plants and the plants uh as they absorbed the waste from the the flow of water helped to clean it up for the fish it's a bit of a symbiotic relationship and so in the greenhouse um you know as you can see from Hatchery Road if you've ever driven by you'll see the lights on in there uh we have four different systems uh the greenhouse was built I believe five years ago was it with the farm to school grant that the district had Acquired and so we have the traditional aquaponic system that I had even in my classroom at crary uh which contains the fish uh but we've also have some other systems as
010well we have what's called a nutrient film technique system uh or the tube system right here uh there's a a Betto bucket system and so those two systems are both uh hydroponic systems which rely on just nutrients that we mix ourselves and then there's more of a traditional raised bed system because I wanted the students to have you know multiple different systems to experiment with because the the fanciest is the aquaponic system but in reality if if they're going to transfer any of this to their lives it's really going to be the raised bed system the traditional system that they can then do in their backyard and a big component of what we learn is just gardening really and so things that the students learn in the class are you know system operation and maintenance
011um the aquaculture industry where that stands in the state and the country and worldwide uh fish anatomy and morphology that's always one of the big Thrills is when I bring a bunch of fish in and we do the dissection we learn all about the anatomy and morphology of the fish it's gets pretty squeamish but that's part of the fun uh nutrition and feeding of the fish uh water quality management growth characteristics like food conversion ratios and survival and that sort of thing uh plant life cycle and propagation you know because we do raise all the plants really the bulk of our work is with the plants probably 75% of what the kids do is working with the plants uh plant care and nutrition uh plant lighting and these are brand new installed these this past
012summer these are new LED lights that took over for the old metal hay lights and this was through the my latest Waterford Foundation Grant which I'm always thankful for when they pitch in and and help with some extra money and they've been working well these new LED lights uh sales and marketing and you know at the end of each year we sell the fish and it's a big brewhaha um but part of it is the kids will come up with ad campaigns they'll they'll do commercials they'll put up posters that kind of thing so this is something that this girl Jazz Hall did a couple years back hi I'm Jaz Hall from the class and this Friday June 3rd we selling um we are selling goldfish they're in good condition and and they are only
013for two fish and they [Music] come so she's pretty quiet but that's the gist and sometimes they do like a serious commercial or sometimes they try to make a humorous commercial and then we'll do that in the morning announcements so a cou like about a month month before with the fish sale we'll start doing the commercials for the morning announcements to get the kids kind of you know Juiced up for the sale I and like I said traditional gardening is a big part of it these are my current students this semester's students and you know we went down to the the you guys I'm sure have seen this big yellow tent the van hoit uh farmers and so we went down there uh just walked down from school and got pumpkins and gourds and you
014know some other fresh veggies and you know I like to stress to the kids also that you know agriculture is a business it's a very big industry especially in the state of Michigan so we talk about aggro business and we do Enterprise budgets and that sort of thing as well um so other things the students do in the class uh just kind of routine maintenance um you know they take care of feeding uh each day we'll take water samples to measure for total dissolved solids and pH and then you know we'll make a judgment say okay how much uh do we need to add to this system or that system and the kids will weigh it out and put it into the systems uh keep track of production data and then of course is the
015big fish sale uh you know planting a lot of seeds you know we in front of you the lettuce you have that was just harvested uh today it's a mix of Roma and green leaf lettuce and that was in the tube system or the nft system and in your little basket or your bowl the carrots they're a little bit runty but that was done in our um our raised bed system so that that came from the greenhouse today so plant seeds uh transplant seedlings uh Harvest produce the CES you have aren't from our system uh we had lots and lots but those plants have kind of petered out with the the cold weather and the lack of light we have new seedlings coming along inside the classroom so once the new seedlings are ready to
016transplant we'll get those guys doing in the Betto bucket system but typically I mean we'll Harvest I don't know probably six or seven pounds of lettuce in about 40 cucumbers each week and this prepare lettuce for market and what's really cool is we'll eat some of it or we'll give some away but most of it actually is taken up to the cafeteria so we'll weigh it out and then at the end of the year I'll come up with an invoice I'll agree with the price of the invoice and then they'll actually give money from Food Services to my program it'll just be like an interde Department transfer which helps with expenses and then they serve it on the lunch program uh and so what makes it fun for the kids is it's you know a
017unique modern technology something you're not going to come across every day especially at the middle school level uh you know they're doing almost all the management you know they check the water quality they feed the fish they harvest they plant they transplant uh and a big thing for me has always been that they gain an appreciation for agriculture and where their food comes from I mean a lot of kids you know if they live in a suburban area there there's no connection to their food except for hey I'm going to buy it from the store or get it at at the cafeteria and so here they really get to see how it's done and so that they they're into that and so that's what they do with the aquaponics and I hope you guys enjoy
018your lettuce and carrots thank you Mr Martin that was uh amazing thank you so much and thank you uh for for the all the goodies this is incredible this is awesome colleagues I want to give you m tus question M tus um so uh what grades can do this is it typically it's an eighth grade elective I I usually have about 18 to 20 students in there uh which is enough to to do the jobs that we need to do you know each day we'll divide up you know the jobs like okay I need you guys to do these transplants I need you guys to check water quality some days are busier than others and there's always the classwork component to it as well and we do the stuff the Hands-On part keeps them interested
019but there's some technical aspects to it as well you know as we're you know calculating you know food conversion ratios or or or that sort of thing or if we're looking at the budgets um so and is there a greenhouse then at the school oh yeah yeah it's it's right behind the building it's I think that's why I've been in the same classroom for 15 years because it's the closest classroom which I'm thankful for it's the closest classroom to the to the back doors uh where the greenhouse is so we we go back and forth between the classroom and the greenhouse okay fantastic wow very impressed thank you yes please well I have always loved this program I was always sad that my three children it didn't work out when they were all in eth
020grade it appears to have taken it because I love the greenhouse and I've had the coveted goldfish we've had them at our house okay wanted to let you know that we had a friend that it survived 3 years mine did not um biggest goldfish ever was amazing but this is such a phenomenal program I I want to let you know that I brag about this to people outside of our district because I've always been super proud of the program that you brought to pierce and I think that this is such this is one of the cool things that we do that people don't recognize and I just kudos to you for doing this and it's it's just very exciting to see and to actually get some of the lettuce so thank you this makes sense
021because my boys came home last year and they're like Dad we need to buy a fish and I was like sort of show of Schultz running over there that's uh but now you know what what now I know now I know that's about remember McGregor please he I just want to say I love this so I actually am in the process of setting up Hydroponics at my house okay so I love that the kids are doing this because I was amazed at how much I learned through gardening and um as somebody who's trained as a scientist and engineer I'm very excited because this is so important for kids to see how science affects their everyday life and it's F because we eat the the things to like in the raised bed which you didn't see
022I mean we'll also grow like basil uh and so we always we'll pick the basil and then I'll make pesto pasta for the kids in class or what like this year I had sunflowers growing at my home in my garden and it's not something we grew but I had these huge sunflower heads and so brought the sunflowers in and we we you know took them out what's the term for it anyway we removed the seeds from from the the head and then we we baked them ourselves I sent some home with the kids and I baked a lot at home and so I've got a big bag that you know when we're if we're working on some classwork assignment I'll just come around with a little cup and give them the sunflower seeds and we'll
023munch on them while we're eating remember pucha please all the lettuce is very very good oh just pick today but do wash it though okay it really matters to me well thank you uh you three for coming and Mr Martin for for um showing us this amazing program we're so lucky to have you so thank you thank you thank you we appreciate that okay don't have to colleagues let's now move on to public comments on action items I do not it uh there's a lot of stuff up here but I do not think that I have any green cards at the moment um is there anyone who would like to address the board this evening on items that we will be voting on okay very good okay we're now going to move on to president's
024update which is uh I'm going to go down there more you like do you want to take your take your snacks he probably wants to Rin off yeah all right um so it is January 16th our first meeting in January we all know what that means it is our organizational meeting um uh I know a couple of you have seen this a couple times over the years um but it is um it's a time to welcome our new board members on it is in our bylaws that we provide a new board member orientation um this Pro also provides us a really great opportunity to speak to our community about the role of a school board so that's what this is um so I will move through this as quickly as possible Kim Elizabeth if there
025are questions please ask um and you don't just have to ask me you can also ask your colleagues your new colleagues um okay so here we go um so we know here in Waterford we are inspired educated and empowered to thrive we are coming up on the end of our 2026 strategic plan um and we will make sure to get this uh to to Kim and to Elizabeth because that is a hyperlink to our strategic plan um we know in that strategic plan we have this Mission we provide exemplary educational experiences for each student to thrive and we have these strategic goal areas um and as we go through the year together our administrative colleagues will be sure to update us on their goals in these areas um as well as Prov a little bit
026of a snapshot of where we've been over the last almost five years um since we started this whole thing our strategic goal areas are our academics and our programs personnel and Leadership our operations our Communications and Community engagement and our learning environment and culture so those have been our our five areas of focus um it's important um because our strategic plan it drives what we do our vision our mission and our strategic plan and the accompanying goals um that's that's how we make our decisions right um it gives us all of us seven um uh a point of reference things to talk about we have these goals and so what we spend so much of our time deliberating on and working with our administrative colleagues on is how do we make these goals um come
027to life so again we're going to go over um a couple things really quick we're going to talk a little bit about process um we're going to talk about the dis dis roles of a board of education and the superintendent um as I already said our bylaw specify a new member uh orientation so we'll check this off the list when we're done it is Board of Education appreci appreciation month so um gives us a good chance to talk about and reaffirm our our roles and commitments it's our organizational meetings and most importantly understanding the the sort of unique role of a school board and doing it well contributes to student Student Success and that's that's why all of each of us is here so we're going to start off a little bit by taking a
028look at the law so this is um this comes from uh Michigan law and it talks about the essential duties and roles of a super um excuse me of a board of education and then we're going to compare that to our board policies because some things change so just I'm not going to spend a lot of time on these I'll read the Bold Parts here but uh um this says that Boards of Education are granted a lot of power to oversee to run a school district okay um and here we go here are the specifics Board of Education duties your job our job to educate pupils provide for the safety and Welfare of our students we acquire construct maintain repair renovate dispose of um uh transfer school property we upkeep our infrastructure our buildings our
029buses um the things that we owe we also hire contract for scheduling supervised terminate employees independent contractors we receive money we invest money we expend public school money so uh according to Michigan law these are some of the things we do um we enter into agreements contracts or cooperative arrangements with other entities Township private um companies um we know that boards have to vote on things um and no action is lawful unless it's been voted on and um passed by a majority vote that's why we're here we vote um and we know too that any district has to adopt bylaws rules of the road ways for us um to do our business and we have this whole thing called our board policies um those are online U I'm sure all of us you know those
030who have been here for a while are familiar with these um but these are the parameters for board action Administration um administrator decision making and general teaching and learning within the district and I'll give us an example here in one moment so often uh I know I've always I had this view when I first came on so if you read what Michigan law says we have this impression that wow Boards of Education they do it all well they don't and they can't because we have to follow um well federal law and again I know this might seem obvious um we have to follow federal law state law and the open meetings act um we have local law we have our own board policies and then we also have Robert's rules um which are really our
031uh our rule book for how we conduct our meetings and if we take a look at our board policy there's this really important passage the Board of Education vests the primary responsibility for administra administration of this District in the superintendent of schools the appointment of that officer is therefore one of the most important functions the board can perform so if we compare what Michigan law says Hey Boards of education do all these things and then you take a look at what our board policy says it says that we hire and pay a highly qualified administrator to oversee the day-to-day functions of the district our Board of Ed policies also spell out the role of the board and how we engage with our administrative colleagues um so our policies it is the primary duty of the
032board to establish policies and that of the superintendent to administer such policies so we come up with the big stuff and then our amazing uh talented team over here um they talk about how do you make those big things um actionable and Implement them throughout all all the levels of the institution the superintendent as the chief administrative officer of the school district is the primary professional advisor to the board so at the end of the day the board interacts um on a regular basis and most often with the superintendent they are according to to our Board of head policies um and best practice they are our number one employee our only employee and consequently serve as the liaison between the board the administration the principles and the rest of our district um these are some
033responsibilities of the superintendent we know that the superintendent has to be at our meetings they serve as a consultant um they help get us information um and then we do the deliberating um the debating and the voting they are our Council when it comes to issues initiatives and things that we need to take action on um the superintendent is our chief representative of the board for the purpose of uh negotiation and bargaining for our um our collective bargaining units and unions so they are our primary representative the board is responsible responsible for determining the success of the superintendent and meeting the goals established by the board through annual evaluations of the superintendent's performance so understanding that the board vests the superintendent with um the the great responsibility of overseeing the day-to-day functions it's our value
034it's our responsibility to make sure they have clear goals the resources to do those things and we give them feedback and let them know how they're doing because we we want them to be successful because that also means we're being successful um and we will have uh uh our annual training around the superintendent evaluation in February it's a robust year-long process um and is a really great Point uh Touchstone for all of us to be able to talk about goals revisit our strategic plan and to have some really great conversations with the superintendent about how we're always advancing towards those goals so in short the Board of Ed and the superintendent have distinct roles and responsibilities and this is uh you know as as we get into it we're always sort of learning more we're
035navigating these things and understanding how to do each of our roles more effectively so this is uh this is from a couple books here and um a school board's primary responsibility is to oversee the education of the students in its District Individual board members work together in order to reach decisions that may have a lasting impact these decisions are generally Broad in scope and ideally the board will rarely have to delve into the district's day-to-day operations the reporting of building level matters to the board will generally be generally be left to the discretion of the superintendent so a pretty concise um statement here of our distinct roles so to clarify um I know I I I assumed this and I think often members of our broader Community assume this structure um but if we think
036about the role of the board in relationship to the superintendent board members should view themselves outside of the district chain of command rather than at its apex once the top of the chain that is the superintendent has been reached without some sort of resolution board policy usually dictates that the individual can then bring the matter to the board but more of as an appeal mechanism boards are encouraged to review the decision of the superintendent as to whether or not it followed existing policies and procedures in order to achieve an acceptable outcome not substitute its own judgment for that of the superintendent so when superintendent makes a decision and if there's uh if there's a sort of friction between superintendent action and board policy that's brought to us and that's where we provide our in input
037and feedback it's more of this it's more of this super intendent overseas the day-to-day uh um uh of the operations of the institution and we're an appeals body again we set the policy they go make it happen and when policy comes up against some sort of challenge we review that and say keep going revise it whatever it might be okay um and this is important for us to think about because it it makes clear our unique and distinct responsibilities um fortunately uh understanding our unique responsibilities also means that we're able to focus on the most important work increasing student achievement um and conversely if uh if if we step out of line people get uh confused we we don't understand where our lanes are um that can harm student achievement and it should go without
038saying cost the district thousands of dollars so there's lots of research on how to be effective how to be effective I'm not going to read this whole thing um but I will talk about here in the next couple slides some practices okay so we know there's research we know too as a group we've been a highly effective and highly functioning board and we do these things so eight traits of effective boards 1 through 4 we know that effective School boards commit to a vision of high expectations for students student and achievement and quality instruction and Define clear goals towards that Vision so at the end of the day we have to demand that our students learn that our staff does all within their power to make sure that our students learn that's why we're here
039to hold high expectations for student achievement we also have to have shared values and beliefs about what is possible for students in their ability to learn we have to recognize that all students can learn and it's our job to make sure that we're helping each and every one of our students to learn um effective boards spend less time on those operational issues and more time focused on policies that improve student achievement again thinking about our distinct roles the super and the administration um oversee the day-to-day and we should really be at a 50,000 foot talking about policies that help our students um Rec uh achieve their goals effective school boards have a collaborative relationship with our staff and community and establish strong communication structure to inform and engage both our internal and external stakeholders about
040what's going on in the district and how we're advancing towards those goals we know too that effective boards are data Savvy they Embrace they monitor data even when that information is negative and we use it to drive continuous Improvement and we've been really good over over these last couple years of of of of having our administrative colleagues bring us that data having really focused conversations about that data and brainstorming and helping um uh our administrative colleagues go and improve our student achievement we know that uh effective School boards align and sustain resources such as professional development to meet District goals we have a strategic plan we need to make sure that the decisions we made make are aligned with that strategic plan and our goal goals because those goals and strategic plan um well they're
041going to fail if they don't have the resources we know that we have to lead as United team with the superintendent each from their respective roles with strong collaboration and mutual trust um so the relationship between the board and the superintendent should be one where we're collaborating where we push each other to get better um and where we have Frank and honest conversations about our goals and how best to get towards those goals that trust peace is so so important and we'll talk more about that here in a moment we know that effective school boards they take part in team development and training um our touch points our touchstones around the evaluation of our superintendent give us a chance to talk about goals we know that we take our masb training we know when we
042have masb come in to do our annual superintendent evaluation training those are opportunities for us to talk make clear our our shared value values our goals as individuals and our shared goals as boards as a as a board so that's how those are some common practices for Effective boards here's a little bit about how that works for us so here's a little note about process and how things uh start and how we get feedback and how they actually take shape when they get to us on the board table so what's the typical process for us so the super intendent in their team they have discussions about some issue that needs board approval again these are aligned with our strategic areas um they develop some goals to help us realize those strategic areas and they say
043hey uh in order to increase student achievement we really need XY or Z the superintendent um will sometimes ask the board president to pull members of the board to better understand all perspectives hey if we need to buy this school bus there's this model of school bus what do you think about this model of school bus um the pre uh excuse me the superintendent will also do the that sort of Outreach in our monthly or weekly check-ins um so again the superintendent is taking that information taking it back to their team and the team is refining um uh um learning more giving the board more information if we need it um and we have they answer questions that part of that that question and answer is essential to the process um so that proposal is
044refined so the board president Andor the superintendent may ask individuals for more feedback um we uh I skipped a really important Point here when the administration the superintendent has uh put together that will come to us sometimes at a committee of the whole meeting if that needs in-depth discussion or often times it will appear as an information item at our business meetings so we have two moments in a more form setting to talk about those proposals um and Elizabeth Kim I know we' talked a little bit about this but our first meeting of every month is our committee of the whole meeting where we're able to have those kind of in-depth conversations um Megan uh the board president and the administration schedule those so we're able to really have a deep dive into those those
045uh proposals or ideas after those those proposals are refined we may have some more feedback a final proposal is then brought forth for Action at a regular business meeting our second meeting of every month the board votes so then the administration gets to work making that happen so a few things to keep in mind throughout this process if a member asks for information related to any board uh resolution policy or or goal within the Strategic plan if one member asks we share that that response is then given to every board member so that everyone has equal access to that information and the shared information because again um we are a team of seven a board of seven and we need to have uh the same information so that we can help make these proposals as
046sharp as they can be and throughout this process we know confidentiality is so important um breaking confidentiality not only violates the law but it erodes trust we get together to talk about these things and when we do we would expect that uh what what happens in the boardroom or in close session stays in those um those spaces throughout the process to uh we always observe masb and the nb's best practices that board members amplify District comment without providing commentary as it can muddy the waters right um and part of our job as board members is to get together as a collective of seven to talk about these things so it's good for us to amplify con uh District content hey we know we've got backyard battle on Friday it's going to be great right but
047avoiding that individual commentary members should um never provide directives to District employees other than the superintendent the superintendent is our employee they are employee the board speaks through its minutes and no individual speaks for the board the president does act as the spokesperson but the board speaks through its minutes those are our votes so what is the board's stance look in the minutes um the president can serve as the spokesman to say here's the board St um and this really helps to make sure that our messaging is clear around the board's actions it also um just helps to make sure that we're leading as a unified team um and I know this is hard uh we have to be mindful of the superintendent's time and focus um we want them to not only uh you
048know do a good job in their relationship with the board but we also want to make sure they've got time to do their job too which is uh the good work of implementing District goals um so a couple things to keep in mind here in front of us now an important part of all of this too is the agenda and that's in front of all of us um our board policy spells out that our agendas they guide our actions and really importantly they serve as the official records of our work the agendas that we have in front of us are so important they are our voice they are what we choose to work on um they communicate with our broader public about what we're up to so as you'll see in front of us we've
049got a couple things we have our introductory items we had a really great presentation we do our pledge we welcome people we have our public comment on action items so those are the items that we'll be voting on we want to make sure that our broader Community has a chance to offer their input and say on the things that we'll be voting on so that's always done as our first public comment we have our consent agenda so these are our minutes retirements resignations so these are the um um action these are the items that we take action on that we include in the consent agenda uh and consent to us passing them we have our information items um we've got a couple of those so again those are opportunities for the administration to bring things
050to us we can have some conversations uh to help them understand how best to implement these things and how they might work around the edges to make them um all the more effective we have our new business so those will be things that we actually take um our votes on we have also our public comment on non-action items so this is a really kind of forward-looking moment where members of the public can come and say hey this thing is going on want to bring your attention to that um that item our public comment is never a time for Q&A because uh often times we don't have the information to even respond and because the superintendent is our primary representative um uh they need to hear that so that they can go to work figure that
051out and we um are very diligent in in collecting our Public's um information item so that the superintendent can follow up this is a chance for the public come tell us and then we tell the superintendent go fix this we have our board reports and board reports are a chance for each one of us as a board member to talk um in a relatively narrow way about our committee work so tonight we'll be uh joining our new committee so this is a chance for us to give updates on hey I'm on the Dron Plains Nature Center committee here's what's going on um this is also a chance for us to um talk about any public uh excuse me professional development we may have done so if you've taken your CBA classes that's a great thing
052to Come Share um and to talk about here um because again our community is interested in our professional development the things we're talking learning about best practices um we often uh talk to we want to amplify District content so always uh around the holiday season we make sure to get out all of the information around our holiday concerts football games so that's a chance again to amplify some of those really important goings on in the district um this isn't a chance the board reports we don't want to uh we want to make sure that we don't um hedge towards deliberating that we don't offer commentary on things that we're doing that we're taking up or possibly will deliberate on so that board report is is is narrow in scope and and for a good reason
053right because we don't want to be deliberating in moments where we shouldn't be um and then we always end of course with the superintendent report and uh similarly narrow and focus they they get to tell our broader Community about the things that are going on and and provide reminders to our broader Community about important events they should be going to we know we follow Robert's Rules up there couple uh you know we're doing a quick quick little primer here um as we deliberate when we when we're at our board table we want to make sure to ask to be recognized by the board president um that just gives the president a chance to really be an effective facilitator um when we are deliberating it's important to remember that we always address ideas not people um
054you know so uh you know member Wagner says something outlandish and crazy um you know I'm going to address not member Wagner but um the idea or the proposal that member Wagner might be putting forward okay so we address ideas we don't address people um the president works to recognize speakers in an alternating fashion so through discussion we know where people end up standing on an issue and the President should work to provide opportunities for alternate um alternating views so that we actually can work towards a consensus uh or some revision um we don't interrupt ideally member comments uh again according to Robert's Rules the president has some discretion around on this issue but according to Robert's Rules member comments should be limited to two rounds with according to Robert's Rules previous decisions are not
055admissible when deliberating because we are to take every resolution on its own merits and finally the president is our spokesperson these are um that one is not only codified in Robert's Rules but also in our own board policy so the president um is is you know serves as our spokesperson is often works with our com Department to um issue statements on behalf of the board okay so where are we at we know that through this process there are plenty of opportunities to listen to ask questions and to gain answers that's why we're here in order to make the best decisions we got to have the best information this process um gives us board members and the administration an opportunity to collaborate and build trust it allows the board to stay focused on its Mission and
056role and to recognize the expertise of the district's staff and Leadership um we've got such a talented Community here and we should rely on that expertise the process also tells us there's no surprises when it comes to voting because at the end of the day if we follow the process we're faithful to that process when that comes in front of us we should be well familiar with it and it should be a 70 vote and a 70 vote is really a report card it should be a symptom of a good of a good illness one that says that uh we're working together we're working together um uh there are no soak boxes monologues because that process facilitates consensus and at the end of the day student achievement Remains the focus we represent our community by
057creating the conditions for a thriving school district and behaving in ways that honor the work of our staff and students um after all that's what our community wants um and I won't go through all of this but um those best practices well they can increase student achievement that Focus that's that connection is explicit it's documented um the evidence presented suggests public governing boards can improve their organization's performance by focusing on strategic planning openness and accountability with and between board members partnership with the government executive honesty Community input board development and member stability in short Boards of ads set the tone and create the conditions for gainful and rewarding work robust and meaningful learning and Lasting and Community Pride um this is a team that's been Comm committed to decorum respect and student achievement this is
058after all and at the end of the day about problem solving not partisanship and uh I'll end it here um I you know I've used this quote before but a leader is anyone who takes responsibility for finding the potential in people and processes and who has the courage to develop that potential so that's the work of a board um and that's your new orientation congratulations um before I jump back up there and we move on Kim Elizabeth do we have any questions of that your colleagues can help answer not right now not at this time I'm good for right now you're good okay then we've done it we've done it you could have done that with just [Laughter] them patri I know you all right all right let's now move on to our organization items
059excuse me our election of officers colleagues we're now going to accept nominations for the office of the president what nominations are there member donu Nom you other nominations okay excellent all those favor of member Wagner serving in the president's role please raise your hand thank you congratulations member Wagner oh thank you D I'm going to give this to you you are up all right you are up nothing thank you nothing like taking I have big shoes to fill member Rich has been our president for many years and he has set a presedent that I uh will do my best to follow all right so where are we at all right we will now accept nominations for the office of Vice President member Patricia I'd like to nominate member Torres do we have any other nominations
060all right all those in favor of member taus for vice president please signify by raising your hand all right oh yeah like yeah like John Paul all right congratulations member Torres 70 all right let's move on to the next page we will now accept nominations for the office of secretary I would like to nominate member istitch are there any other nominations all right all those in favor of member richet for secretary please signify by raising your hand all right 70 and now he immediately takes over so John Paul do you have any Pages you want to give to him nope we're good all right we will now accept nominations for the office of Treasurer I will nominate Mr Pat Donahue sorry do we have any other nominations all right all those in favor of member
061Don who for Treasure please signify by raising your hand all right 70 all right moving on so our next um business would be the Board of Education appointments so the board is seeking appointments to various committees as listed in the packet Oakland schools the previous representation was representative was member Southerland with member Wagner serving as alternate um I would be I would be happy to be now the representative since member Southerland is no longer with our board of education is there anyone that would like to be the alternate for the ocba scho the Oakland County School Sorry probably should have said that the Oakland County School Board Association meetings I would like to member McGregor is there anyone else that would like to be an alternate all right so I will be the representative with
062member McGregor being the alternate all right moving on our next one would be the Oakland County school board's Association government Relations Committee I was the pre um representative and member Taurus was the alternate I would be happy member Taurus if you would like to be the representative I can step out of that role uh yeah I would uh like to do that okay is and who would like to be the alternate for the government Relations Committee I I would be happy to be the alternate if there isn't anyone else that would like to be the alternate and be the be alternate okay so we will have member Torres as the representative and McGregor as the alternate there's the hes haway Advisory Board the previous represent representative is John Himel Spa with member Patricia serving as
063alternate are we happy as a board to keep Mr himl Spa in that role um and you m petricia do you want to stay as the alternate I would like to stay as alternate but again it's have we talked to John find out I me I um I can yeah yes um M Heros Spa he did reach out and said that he's obviously good with whatever the board wants to do okay so he he is in the not okay well I would like to see a a member of the board again it's John took that's these as pad pointed out earlier this week these things are time consuming they seem like they're kind of nothing thing but this is part of our community this is part of what we do it's part of what gets
064us involved uh in the butt sometimes I've been part of all these committees um but I I really think it is important that we actually have a board member the has half way is something that especially if you if you have younger kids or something because you're working on the farm when they have the Sheep sharing and all the different events going on as a board member you're usually there helping to volunteer I would I would be interested in serving okay all right member Patricia would you like to stay as the alternate unless someone else wants does anyone else want to be the alternate for H at the way all right we will have anybody and Patricia is the alternate all right Waterford youth assistant the previous representative was member jocin who's no longer with
065our Board of Education with member Southerland as the alternate who is also no longer with the board of education so is there another member interested in becoming the representative of the water for youth is member Sonic all right and who would like to be the alternate for Waterford youth assistance don't all raise your hands at once I I can't okay thank you member Patricia Head Start policy committee the previous representative was member southernland with members Wagner And risti as alternates with member Southerland no longer um being part of the Board of Education I would be happy to be step from being an alternate to be the representative member ass would you like to remain as the alternate yeah all right so we've got that one covered and on that Head Start committee uh I think
066you can only do it for five years yes so it did something and it's through the day it's an afternoon Friday afternoons usually isn't it I could remember Frid okay I enjoyed that one a lot because they fit me yeah but I T I've Ed myself over so we next up have the drton plains Nature Center the previous representative was member Donna with members Tores and wrist Stitch serving as alternates um would you like to remain in that role sure I'll do that okay and do you two want to remain as the alternates same okay I'm just going to put same all right well thank you to all of the members for representing this board and further serving our community through these appointments did did we miss one Waterford Township Recreation oh where did that
067one go right there the third one the third one I think we missed that one hi ironically it's not on my page so the Waterford um Recreation Department I believe remember patr was the representative would you like to remain as that yes okay and who would like to be the alternate I I was the alternate I'll do that again all right thank you all right so now thank you to everyone for serving on your on your um perspective committees it's very much appreciated so next up is the Board of Education operating Norm Ms so I move that the Board of Education reaffirm the operating Norms previously adopted by the Board of Education second all right the motion has been moved and supported are there any comments or questions would you like me to read those
068Norms or do you all feel confident do you want me to read them out I think yeah just for the sake of the public we should read them out I would be more than happy to do that I just have to find them hold all right here we go are you ready it is recommended that the Board of Education reaffirm the following operating Norms previously adopted by the board we will speak with one Voice once decisions are made Serv as the community's eyes and ears and communicate information that may not be well known to the administration in the form of a non-directive heads up be visible in the community ask questions be willing to learn be prepared govern in an atmosphere that encourages and respects free expressions of opinions and ideas whether in the minority
069or majority not surprise one another admit what we don't know keep our minds open to change remain responsible to all students and members of the community communicate openly honestly and constructively maintain confidentiality model stability demonstrate a clear distinction between the roles of the board and the administration speak as one voice not as individuals when giving direction to the superintendent as individuals not direct actions or request information that requires significant amounts of additional work or time from the superintendent or staff actively listen to complaints or concerns regarding District activities and then advise the individual on how best to proceed communicate effic with the staff through the superintendent as much as possible delegate to the superintendent responsibility for all administrated functions except those specifically reserved to the board through board policy I believe the motion had been
070supported um are there any now are there any questions or concerns all right all those in favor please signify by raising your hand motion carry 70 all right the 2025 2026 Board of Education meeting schedule I move that the Board of Education regular meetings and Committee of the whole meetings for the 2025 2026 school year be scheduled for the listed provided at 6:30 p.m. regular meetings are held at the Waterford Township Hall Auditorium 52 00 Civic Center Drive Waterford Michigan unless posted otherwise Committee of the whole meetings are held at the kurman administrative Administration Services CER campus 501 North cath Lake Road Waterford Michigan unless posted otherwise do you so move all right y support all right the motion has been moved and supported are there any questions or comments are we good with the
071schedule everybody did you get a chance to look at the calendar okay all right all those in favor please signify by raising your hand all right motion carries 70 consent agenda are there any unless are objections the con the consent agenda is approved as presented are we all good with tonight's consent agenda all right information item so next up is assistant superintendent Ela she's going to fill us in on the t5p systems sounds super exciting oh and I see that we also have Mr Jim Beaver and and we have Elizabeth kie as well thank you very much for having us to to bring you some information about the new PA system or public address system that we are proposing that the board approve at the next regular board meeting I'm going to have Elizabeth coochie
072and Jim Beaver provide the information that we we collaborated on with the people in the district and through Paul twig who is our technology adviser from Barton mow and they're going to go through the process and what we have found thanks Andy good evening board um going to kick it off here with the uh uh present um uh we're here tonight uh information to present information about the the PA system project that we've engaged in uh as we continue to review our security assessment that we conducted in 2022 uh our ability to communicate with staff is critically important um as our PA systems as our primary form of alert we are Enga we engage in a process to review our systems so before I turn it over to Elizabeth I'm just going to give you
073a little bit of history of the process that we engaged in um in February 2 of 24 we surveyed all of our schools to determine what method they use to communicate with classrooms and primarily you know we want to know are you using PA system are you using the phones there's options in both and we want to get a sense of what folks were using in uh in May of 24 we created a committee of diverse stakeholders to develop system needs and and and Implement implementation priorities um the committee included Administration principles teachers maintenance staff and Technology staff um Paul twig as mentioned from Barton mow was also uh there as a a technical consultant for us um from that committee we had a subcommittee that uh reviewed what systems and features are available out
074out there in the the tech World um the group participated in in a demo highlighting features of different types of systems so we could get a sense of what options might be available for us to consider um a follow-up meeting with the large committee occurred after that where we presented our findings uh subcommittee findings and um we we just wanted to make sure that you know the committee knew um what features were available that that were beneficial for the buildings and um it was determined that a survey was going to occur at each school over the summer so essentially Paul twig um went ahead and visited every single school and walked the entire building to find out where all the speaker locations were what each individual had uh school had for features and their PA
075systems he documented all that so he could bring it back to the committee for us to review and to help start to to build our bid document um in the fall uh individual meetings were then scheduled with every single building to sit down and talk with the building administrator to talk about the survey that occurred over the summer to uh make sure were all on the same page and to get more feedback from them to determine if there were um any concerns that they had about the PA system and and to review speaker locations and see if there are any additional things that we missed or that we might not know um and then in October uh a small committee did a site visit at Bloomfield Hills Middle School to uh to really review a
076newer system see how it works in in the real world and then finally a bid specification was developed calling for an IP system which Elizabeth will talk a little bit here in a second um but you know an IP system would tie into our Network and allow for much more flexibility for the building and potentially districtwide communication if we decide to go there with it um it also has the ability to add on features in the future and serves to offer a solution with a speaker and a display which uh will help us um display clocks so we can have accurate clocks throughout the buildings and um strobe features and and I mention that because I think as I mentioned to the to the board uh there is pending legislation out there for more stringent
077um uh alert uh requirements especially as it um pertains to color coding and alert messages so going to an IP system you know is is going to put us in a position where uh if that does become law we'll we will be uh in compliance with that so with that I'm going to turn over to Elizabeth good evening everybody so as Jim shared the IP address system essentially is an Internet Protocol so we talked about an IP address system when we adopted our new phone systems last year as well so it'll integrate with that as part of this component um one thing that we did when we brought the committee together and Paul went building to building to look at what we have what works what's not um what areas need a speaker and then
078we went back to each building as Jim shared this fall to talk with principles to figure figure out how that would look and what they needed um our first thing is we looked at our current state of our current PA systems we know right now the ones on the left hand side have a system that is no longer supported and or manufactured um the ones on the right we put out to bid is alternate buildings because systematically our hope next board meeting is to bring forward a proposal to have all buildings updated the reason for that such as like Jim just pointed out is that one we would be on all on the same page but then we would also have the same secur Safety and Security features that we would be implementing in the
079buildings that no longer are supported um so just to share another tidbit to that is when you look at the buildings on the right under the alternate buildings Grayson Schoolcraft and Mason currently have what we call a traditional analog system which is a little bit of an older system it's not an IP address system which means it doesn't have those security features um bont and are on a completely different system different manufacturers so as you can see we kind of have different systems throughout the whole District um and you know one thing we've been really working far on with especially from the tech side is kind of a streamline of ensuring all buildings are on the same platforms for a variety of reasons um this is picture is essentially of a traditional analog PA system
080um the lines are showing you how they go from a speaker system there is the you might remember these when you were students the call button on the wall where you would push um yes we do still have some of those and then that would ring down to the office and then someone else would have to get the phone so it's kind of this game of telephone um the Pas as you can see are in different spots and as you can see we have our digital clocks there not digital regular so this is the difference so an IP network-based system obviously runs on our Network it is a Technology based system um it runs runs from your phone it'll run from a computer our new phone system that we adopted last year we put into
081the bid specs that it was a requirement that whatever IP system we go with will be able to integrate with our current phone system we wanted to ensure that was a streamlined system um and then as you can see all the the speakers kind of feed off each other so these are kind of those security features that Jim was talking about one thing that this will allow us to do is to do programs targeted Communications what I mean by that is if I'm in a building we essentially can make hallways into what we call zones so say we know something's happening in zone one we can make an announcement just to Zone one we can make an announcement to the whole building from a district level we'll be able to make an announcement to all
082buildings if we needed to we don't obviously without an IP system that's not something we have right now um it also as Jim shared will allow us to have digital clocks strobe lights which is quite important especially if that legislation does go through and then emergency alerts so as you can see it's hard to see but there's different colors um these IP based locks and speaker systems allow us to put a message out in a colorcoded system so we know and we've looked at a couple things Jim showed me the other day that are adapting some color systems from even purple yellow red and if if we looked at that we'd be able to adopt that within our system so that the message would come out in those colors and that our students would get
083to know what those colors mean as well um so again it's looking at a PA system but also looking at it from the Safety and Security lens what can we do we know our Pas need to be replaced but we also know these features are probably going to be coming down the road so that's why we took this committee and saw how we can marry the two together so here's our next steps so today this morning bid opened at 11:00 you do have the bid tabs that are fresh off the printer that's why you just got them today um T5 information is coming to you right now on January 28th we are going to be having an on-site review so we looked at the committee and we decided we are going to run this pretty
084very similar to what we did with our interactive display boards So based on today's bid Burton mow has worked and contacted the vendors and they're going to be coming in on the 28th with the product to show us what it looks like what the features are along with everyone from the committee and we're inviting principles who wish to attend but on top of that we also know oh kind of attending in person is always tricky because that's a kind of a whole day event so Jane's going to be videoing just like she did with the interactive displays so we'll be able to share that with you we'll be able to share that with all of our stakeholders and then we'll have a survey open from January 30th till February 7th for people to put in
085input as they wish so that's a choice thing but then providing that input then the committee will come back together look at that and then on February 20th we will bring our recommendation to you on what we wish to go with then the hope would be if something was approved by summer of 2025 which is this summer installation work would begin our targeted buildings will be those buildings on the left the ones that have the not not supported right now um and then we would add our alternate buildings to the end of the project any questions for jimy or Sandy does anyone have any questions member rusia I ha asket but uh I don't see stansky in here stepansky is not on there because they since they're building is brand new they haven't upgraded system
086that's what I was hoping so okay thank you um member Torres um so the uh the analog systems CU I remember those from way back when so how long did those last I mean we're talking decades right a little bit longer than they should have um um what we're noticing is we have some who have been around for a while and they're slowly they're still working um but we're slowly having things that it's taking us a while to figure out how to fix and so the digitals um so there's there's so much intricacy involved with those so I'm thinking about anything digital a lot of times has a lifespan of only three or four years like I think of like an iPhone or something so how does that work is there like um capacity for
087upgrade considering that this is digital and yep so there's a capacity for upgrade there also since it's a server based system we can add additional servers if we needed to um surprisingly they last roughly about 10 to 12 it depends I mean obviously you know there's cases where they don't um we do in the bid have a 5-year warranty though so we have that built into the bid as well but again it is Tech and we know Tech in 10 to 12 years is going to look completely different right it's going to look different 5 years from now so we know and recognize that but like we shared the sa and security pieces that could be added to this it it opens a world for us that we don't have so will will the these
088systems um you know the the ones that we need to replace immediately and then the secondary so will they work in collaboration with what we have at stepansky or will it be it'll be a little bit different so stepansky is a different bit of a plan because it's a different type of a building but it will be different so then with all these um uh all all the the syst systems in the schools then would they be able to kind of like talk to each other or how how does that work from a central office or a programming standpoint yes are we going to give a building that ability probably not so muchal okay but is is the capability there yes thank you all right member Dan Hugh uh a statement and then a question
089um uh the IP these um network based systems are awesome we and installed ours in about a year and a half ago and uh um the ability to make contact UM individual classrooms individual hallways the red and green lights uh we actually had a demonstration this summer where uh there was we called it it was a drill during a lockdown situation and um in one part of my building but then they um had the green lights go on and uh to lead the kids and staff out of the other part and it was just follow the green light and uh so one part of the building was still red and then the other part was green so it was a really cool setup um so yeah so that's awesome it's great I'm glad to see
090we're going to this now for the question I I'm I'm why are we why are we doing just the the ones on the left and and holding off on the alternate buildings what I I know I'm sure I missed it no you're fine so we're not holding off on the alternates what we did was because we didn't know where the pricing was going to come in So within the bid itself what you'll see is we um put the buildings that have to be done and then we put the ones as alternates but when we come for recommendation we are going to be recommending that we do all of them understood thank you y um member McGregor did you have a question uh yes so I Love Actually the idea of going to this because there's
091a lot of features that are important and especially for kids with special needs um that's great one of the things that's really important with intern of things security how is that going like do we need to get additional stuff is that all included so pieces of that are included and um as a new member to the board I'll share with you last year we had a pretty extensive cyber security audit which we pass with flying colors so we really are not worried about that from our standpoint does it mean from my Department's end that we'll have a lot more work to do yeah it sure does but we're willing to take that on because we know that's what's right for our buildings so thank you yeah Mage so Build Off both M tourism B you
092said so what sort of understanding the intricacies of this as well as the importance for the Safety and Security of our our buildings I imagine this will all be accompanied with some sort of professional learning what what's what is the the scope of that so the scope of that is a little bit different and it's going to probably roll kind of like the promethium based on install so when your building is installed we would come and train on on within that plan um so it's not going to be everybody's trained at the same time right it's going to be a rolling training based on as install but from our perspective at a district lens we're going to be professional learning all the way through this right um because we also know just because we set
093up this way for Emergen we may need to tweak it we may need to look at this so we're going to be doing that all along the way uh who who would receive that that that PD um because because this is located in central office of every building yeah so it'll definitely be in Jim can jump in from his perspective but I know it'll definitely be the office staff the principes will probably have the teachers to appoint and then some key teachers within their Bert teams um would be trained on there obviously Jim's teams will be trained my teams would be trained central office would be trained um I can't think of no it's really going to involve all different levels of of training obviously the office staff are going to have more intense training
094with the you know the headend of the the system um but you know you know we expected the feature uh that that are offered in the systems you know there is going to be some some classroom uh training to go along so our teaching staff knows how to use the system and um yeah it's it's it's really going to touch pretty much everybody because you know as we all know um when when something goes down you know communication is is critical so we want to make sure everybody's on board y um that's question uh remember T asked about um so they what we approve here if we approve this will be integrated with stepansky so these systems will be seamlessly integrated because I heard the districtwide communication so if there we'll have to work on
095that we'll have to work with the vendor to see how we pull that in um but that is I I wrote myself a little note to uh to make sure that that happens all right do we have any other questions well as always thank you so much for bringing the information to us and always making sure Safety and Security is top of mind I so appreciate that and I think it's huge that we're we're being very proactive in this and not waiting until it goes into law so thank you we're excited to bring this to you we really hope uh I'm excited for the digital classs all right so next up we have our elementary playgrounds with assistant superintendent Ela thank you very much and Carla yes I'm car Ramirez is coming up to help
096me if there's any questions I can't answer I do want to thank Jim and Elizabeth for their work with the PA system um it was a lot of work they took it on they ran with it and um it's not something we had planned on doing but we're really excited about the opportunity that we'll have working PA systems everywhere we want them to be not just in a lot of the central areas but also to have working clocks that was very exciting and then some of the security features that we've been talking about since the SEC came through and did our um our our assessment you know these were things that we we wanted to have such as the strobes and be able to get some of those in one system is pretty exciting for
097all of us so thank you very much so tonight I'm bringing an info item for Elementary playground improvements so as part of the 2020 bond that was approved by our voters we made um included it upgrades to the elementary playgrounds so um we brought that up from really serious Series 3 to series 1/s series 2 because what we were finding during our inspections that we do annually but we also do on a regular basis with our custodians that a lot of the equipment we had we were having to actually remove so we were reducing the amount of equipment that these students had to play on on a regular basis so we started moving it up as part of the process we had our architect bring in a actual playground designer to work with all of
098our buildings so they worked with the buildings and the principals to develop plans of how they wanted equipment how they wanted layouts and a couple things that came out of it was just being able to have mulch instead of peak gra um PE gravel which I know um it's an oldie goodie but um there was just too many issues with the PE gravel it was not staying in the areas with the equipment it was really a hazard to the adults as well as the students so that was something um but they also wanted walking tracks so we were able to include that as part of the design so there are some playgrounds that did have them there are some that did not have them um so we made sure that that was just part of
099the design so that the students as well as I know the staff during lunchtime also enjoy that being able to walk around the playgrounds and get that exercise in but also to include equipment so the information that we gave was the um playground um one of the blueprints that we had as well as equipment um so we have um worked with them as to the equipment so in some places we have new equipment such as um there's certain pieces of equipment that the students just didn't like using anymore and I'm not going to use the right words I know what they look like but I don't know what they're called and they had other equipment that they they were able to look at and decide that was really something the kids would enjoy more and
100so that was uh very successful last year when we did our first round we had to split them because there was no way we could do nine elementaries um actually this summer is going to be fun because we're going to we're recommending five elementaries to be done but um last year we did four and um the feedback that we've gotten from staff and students and um parents has been fantastic they love it I know um we'll give some pictures in the next month we'll have some before and after pictures from last year but I think the one that impresses me most is Grayson because it was it felt like a field before now it feels like a really comprehensive playground with the walkways and everything a little bit more grass it just it feels like
101a more uh interactive thing than we've had in the past so that's what we're going to continue on with that one of the extra things that I did include is last year what we had done a lot of with all of these plans was looking at what we could either keep or move and we did inspections on anything that was kept any of the um older equipment and with the idea is we would repair it what we found is the cost of repairs for some of these was just so much that it didn't make sense to to repair them them it made more sense to replace them so we have three buildings that we did last year that we're going to replace a couple more pieces of equipment so that they'll have more new equipment
102and more of the equipment on the playground will be have the same life so we expect that this equipment will last about 20 years um not to say that we're not going to have failures before then but we'll we'll the idea is to last for 20 years so that is the information that I gave you was the plan we have been working with the principles there's a few that few things that changed so we might have another year of a couple changes one of the changes that came around this last year that didn't affect last year's um projects but does affect this year's is if the project affects a area of over I think it was an acre then we had to have um an environmental site plan we had to do a lot of
103extra things so since it only really affected the walking Track we reduced the walking Track for a couple schools and then in the future we will look at expanding it as a separate project which because they're separate projects doesn't hit that limit so that was a little bit of a disappointment but we worked with the principles that it affected and we're just keeping that as a item that we'll do in the future nothing we're doing now will prevent that and or keep it from you know we're not doing more work by moving it out one more year are there any questions remember Taurus with the playground equipment um with the old equipment I know we can't repurpose that right for liability issues correct so what happens to that equipment it's usually because a lot of
104that's metal um it'll get uh salvaged if it's plastic it'll just get thrown away any other questions member oh I didn't see member pcia go ahead expensive it's expensive last time yes it was yes it was it was expensive as it was last time talking millions of dollars for yes build them a little Hill they down the hill over at they love that uh a little track in let it just seems I mean the site work plus the expense of the equipment um and again I'm concerned because this is all of our elementary schools and we I would like to review the the status of their future um I I hate to again putting pH systems in and you know spend a couple million dollars on a building that could close in 5 years if
105the if our student population doesn't come up it just terrifies it seems like waste of money and I understand where you're coming from and we have talked about this the last couple years but since we have not made a decision and we will probably not make it for a few more years we had to look at where we're looking at short and long term and we believe and like I said I'm not putting anything in your mouths but I'm thinking you're probably talking a good five years that these students will have these playgrounds to use and if we don't we have done a lot of things in between we've gotten more um soccer goals for them we've gotten some other things that will help them but we felt that we needed to move forward at
106this and of course the board has the has the um opportunity to say if they do not want all the buildings to get the new um playgrounds but um we did move forward with giving the board the option to look at it I hope that we won't look at that again they have PE gravel they can throw it so they work in their arm right left it's fun all right member witit uh you might have said this so forgive me what is the material of the walking Track so the walking tracks are actually concrete right um the ones that that's why I remember at Grayson um some of our existing ones had asphalt depending on where they were but the new ones had cement right there's a variation between concrete and fall but yeah at
107each School how long are they they're all different but we can definitely give you guys a layout um with the yeah at award because do have a design layout yeah it is I didn't show you that because I wanted to really focus on where the equipment was going to go a lot of times it it will go around the playground or in some places like go around the edge of the whole area so um like Canen you know they have that play area that's um to the West of the building the idea is that the walking goes all the way around that fenced area right any other questions oh member Tes how long does the playground equipment last so how many years we're anticipating about 20 years okay yeah that felt like the playground equipment
108we have now has been there a long time yes it has been about 20 years and that that's with us continuing to do all the annual inspections and and like I said our custodians are regularly expecting are um inspecting them as well um we expect obviously you're going to have to do small um adjustments in the way but the idea is they they should be lasting for 20 years yeah and as a as a parent of an elementary school student I can tell you that my daughter looks forward to playground time I mean it it really is a nice break from the academics and all of that uh for the kids um so it's it's really cool to see all the Innovations and the different kinds of list of things that are available so and
109I think there was even a deep for appreciation during the pandemic when you know you had to be outside and all those kinds of things but um yeah 20 years and it's pretty good longevity so thank you all right well thank you very much we appreciate oh I didn't see I didn't see your hand just question um do we have Astor on any of these projects no no it's natural grass okay thank you all right thank you again thank you Carla for coming and answering our questions thank you Miss Ela moving on to new business secretary wrage you are up well I have moving on to new business secretary yeah sorry do we have it do we have it for okay but do we I'll find it okay find it let tag you have to
110forgive him it's a new position for him so he's trying to figure it out he has to do something we can sing to fill the time did you find it got it okay um recommendation 40 2425 food service contract with waterf for Township senior center it is recommended that the Board of Education approved the proposed food service contract with Waterford Township and authorized the assistant superintendent of business and operations to sign on the board's behalf and I so move support all right the motion has been moved and supported are there any comments or questions all right all those in favor please signify by raising your hand all right motion carries 70 and now we are on to Treasurer Dany Hugh for consideration of certain purchases superintendent recommendation 41-24 d25 districtwide controls bid it is recommended
111that the board approved the district controls bid to Metro Controls Incorporated in the amount of $283,950 funds for this award are included in the 2020 Bond ISO move support all right the motion has been moved and supported are there any comments or questions and just uh quick want to um thank our community again um another really important project um that is made possible thanks to the 2020 Bond all right all those in favor please signify by raising your hand and the motion passes 70 and and still with our lovely treasur danah Hue the masonry matal all right superintendent recommendation 42- 24-25 Waterford Mason Middle School remodel it is recommended that the board approve the Waterford Mason Middle School bid to the biders an amount listed below for a total Award of 72 funds for this
112project are included in the 2020 Bond ISO move support all right the motion has been moved and supported are there any comments or questions just really quick for our listening audience um we're talking uh new bleachers um track Service uh excuse me surface um electrical I mean it's pretty really exciting and really substantial excuse me GRE and again we want to thank our community because these are much needed upgrades that we needed at our our Middle School athletic area so again thank you as always for supporting our bonds all right all those in favor please signify by raising your hand and the motion carries 70 and we are on to our Pierce Remodel and field replacement with Treasurer Donahue superintendent recommendation 43- 24-25 Waterford Pierce Middle School Remodel and field replacement it is recommended that
113the board approve the Waterford Pierce Middle School bid to the biders and amounts listed below for a total of 3,260 78159 funds for this project are included in the 2020 Bond ISO move support all right the motion has been moved and supported are there any comments or questions regarding the Pierce Remodel and field replacement member Patricia the turf field uh sh have we used them before is that who did redid uh Ms or not you know that is not who did Ms but they've been in business for well over 20 years okay I think we used AstroTurf oh that's who I think we used originally and when we originally did the fields we had gotten prices from someone else that was cheaper but we didn't use them so Carla could I'm so sorry Rob interupt
114could you use the microphone they can't hear you in the back they were just signaling to us thank you okay no I was just saying you're correct uh asro Turf is who was used we've used in the past but we're using the one that's cheaper and it's basically all carpet's carpet yes and and Sh sha is reputable also they've yes they've been in business this a while thank you member McGregor so I know um I just want to kind of say this as a comment not so much as a question I know people are concerned about AstroTurf there were some comments there um and I know I ask some questions and I appreciate the feedback that I got um and I do want to let people know that my understanding is that this was written
115into the bond specifically where we would be approving AstroTurf so this is specifically what was approved by the voters in the bond language um so I just want to make sure people are aware of that because that's not something that we can necessarily change at this point um but I I know people are concerned about it so that's kind of where we are right now so so yes based on questions we got from the board we put together information from my athletic director our prior director of Maintenance and operations who had been here for 40 years and that was part of their recommendation simply because um basically it went down to if we had it as a single sport event we could manage a grass field but because we we start the field in March
116and we use it all the way through fall and we use it for so many sports we use it for classrooms we use it for PE lunch everything we never had an opportunity to really build in that grass surface and to keep it flat and to keep it from um bogging down and having um spare spots so that was really recommendation they felt based on our current usage that this would be a better answer for that field and so that was just that was based on their years of being here and seeing how we use it um so you know and like I said we've had it at high school we have a little bit of an experience with it so that also gives us a lot of confidence that this field will hold up
117for what we need it for so thank you thank you Member pcia One More comment because again there is the concern of you know natural grass or the turf uh when we put the turf in at the high schools uh because we can use it all day and all night it makes it useful it isn't okay the football team gets to practice today marching band gets to use it tomorrow and nobody can use it for the next 3 days this is something when we rent it out to the the little football teair thank you the corers they get a chance to use it and it looks cool again I personally don't like it I I like the natural grass when my son played lacrosse on it the natural grass and kids coming in from the
118other schools that had their turf fields and go to play with the grass they're coming up with you know wads of dirt and stuff and it was just it was a lot of fun it's you know and they you know you fall down you get dirty it's it's nice that part but the the turfield is so much easier to maintain uh and our our staff has done a great job at keeping that field looking beautiful um but it takes a lot of time takes a lot of effort and this is going to be a lot less time a lot less effort and we can use it a lot more so it's you know it's a weight thing what's you just move forward make decisions and I think it's the right to thank you and and
119I would like to say thank you because I know quite a few of us had questions and had reached out and the clarification was very much appreciated and thank you so much for making sure we had the right information because our community is asking so we need to be we need to have that information so that we're able to share that with our community as they do ask and I appreciate it being able to share that with you because the conversation had been a couple years ago with John so I couldn't remember I just remember he convinced me it made sense because I'm like you I I think natural grass is a much better surface but right again if you have one sport that you're using it for it is you can make it work
120and you can make it good but we like to use our facilities so this worked out as a better alternative no we appreciate it very much thank you so much any other questions all right all those in favor please signify by raising your hand and the motion carries 70 all right we will now take public comments on non-action items I don't believe we have any green cards we have a lot of green stuff up here but I don't think there's there's any green cards oh uh Miss McGregor as you are making your way to the podium please be reminded that comments are limited to 3 minutes in duration members of the public are invited to share comments however this is not intended to be a time for questions and answers lastly participants may speak only
121once on the same topic and are asked to avoid statements that are personally directed abusive or obscene um I'm coming today to talk to you about a program that we're going to be doing at Oakland County parks on February 15th it's called fireworks and flannels um Kim I work with your daughter-in-law uh this is something Oakland County Parks has been working on for the last few months it was going to be in conjunction with their Township but that's not working right now but it's something that we've never had in the wintertime we're going to have a 1K for our children a 5k we're going to have a wagon rides with a horse drawn uh lighted um Trails snow art making puppets um hopefully Rory will be there uh sleding down the hills it's going to
122be a great free free family event so if you'd like to come uh for the kids um I've talked to Miss Davis we're going to have a booth for the school district there um we're just going to be highlighting what waterford's all about so please come out February 15th um five or the 1K for the kids starts at 3:30 the 5K starts at 4: um and the rest of the program starts at uh five o'clock so I hope to see you there with food trucks uh the chamers is going to be there with uh cocktails if they want them um it's just going to be live entertainment uh her son again is going to be part of that so it's going to be a great day so come out and enjoy the day all right
123thank you so much for sharing that with us all right we are on to our Board of Education reports does anyone have a report this evening member danu uh first off I want to just thank everyone for the Schoolboard recognition uh definitely not needed but much appreciated uh by all the schools and and staff so thank you very much um Welcome to our new board members Elizabeth and Kim um I'm no longer the new one so thank you thank you very much and I would be remiss without um recognizing Sandy um and congratulations with everything and uh um enjoy retirement so you will be missed I really appreciate you taken the time to really ex sit down and explain to me some of the things with the the budget and uh um questions that I
124had so thank you very much all right member Patricia I also want to thank our welcome Kim Elizabeth McGregor welcome um and thank Mike uh again what four five years as president uh I think you did a great job I'm going to miss you picking on you it's so much fun you did oh I did ien enjoyed it as much as I should have now it's a new one but again I I think you did a great job I truly uh you you stepped up you did a a wonderful job as a new person to come in and be president take that role uh was was absolutely spectacular so and thanks for all the food and gifts and everything else it's a great time of year P you'll get used to it it's fun you
125say oh you don't have to but this is it yeah no it's wonderful thank you member Torres uh also want to just uh congratulate the two new board members um coming on and uh you know you get here in your first meeting and you realize you're getting all these presents and you kind of think like you know maybe I don't you know I'm getting these and I haven't done anything well just wait you're going to so you're going to earn those presents so it's always a nice recognition I think this month um this board meeting is always one of my favorites every year and um only second to the graduation day graduation day is always just inspiring and fantastic so um you got something really great to look forward to in the coming months um
126also I just want to remind everybody uh there's the backyard battle that's going to be happening tomorrow at 700 p.m. um and then there's going to be I believe the Waterford United girls uh um game as well earlier than that I think it's I think it was 5:00 p.m. okay 5 and then 700 p.m. uh is going to be the m versus ketering um I love the the the decal that they put out there was the um engage dark mode it just reminds me of the Lions so it was uh that they put out there so that's going to be tomorrow and then um just uh Go Lions as well thank you member McGregor um I also just wanted to take a moment to say thank you because this is amazing um and also I
127want to give a special thank you um I I asked Sandra a lot of questions about some of these contracts so I appreciate your help and you getting back to me so quickly um and also I wanted to say thank you to Kristen and Mike because I I'm already learning a lot from you too so I appreciate that very much and one more thank you sorry um I also wanted to thank Joan Southerland and Julie Jocelyn for the work that they did and um because they also helped to advocate so that we could learn some of these things before we got into the role and that's a really big deal so thank you um member restit yeah really quick so we've member Torres um picked up on all the great things that are happening um
128on Friday and I also just want to amplify our um Griffin Special Olympics team is playing at halftime and they're playing against the Waterford Warriors Special Olympics team um so we've got a a great uh a great rivalry here um and I say that uh tongue and cheek because because um it's going to be great they're going to play at halftime of the girls game um be there it's going to be amazing come watch uh and cheer on some amazing athletes so our own Waterford Griffins um verse our Waterford Warrior Special Olympics team and just so you know um The Waterford Warriors are often where our Griffins athletes go um so it's h it's going to be a great night and I'm looking forward to it and welcome Elizabeth welcome Kim congratulations so really looking
129forward to this year thanks yes all right and just to kind of summarize for everybody I want to also welcome our two members it's always nice to have fresh faces and and different outlooks and different input so we appreciate that you're both here and and serving your community it's it's an honor to serve our community and this is a great way to do it this is a an amazing district with amazing staff and students and so welcome to our Welcome to our board and again congratulations Sandy I can't believe we're already like this is your last meeting isn't it well thank you for for serving our district and for all you've done we greatly appreciate it so we you will be missed and speaking of our backyard battle on Friday um if you'd like to
130come there's not just the the halftime show with our our athletes there's also the Waterford M dance team which is going to be performing because they are preparing for their first competition at the Little Caesars Arena sat aturday morning so definitely come on cheer them on um if you see the young blonde that looks like me that would be my daughter feel free to Roo her on but also I want to give a little shout out to Waterford caterings dance team because they had their first competition last weekend so our our teams are into their competition mode and they could could use a little support as well and happy New Year everybody thank you so much um for joining us tonight and we look forward to seeing you soon um if there's nothing further this
131meeting is adjourned e e e