001e e e we have a roll call please Sandra Bradford here Barry uler here Leah collister lazari here Katie carum here Ain Chand ding here Steve Wang here Diana [Music] Clapton all right would you please rise and join me for the pledge of allegiance algi to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all all right welcome again to our um special um Committee of the whole meeting this evening so we're set up a little bit differently tonight um because we it's a it's a more of a discussion um and this is the meeting that we set aside every January to discuss the the budget um we do have a couple related items that we so we
002will have a couple presentations from the administration as well um but they all pertain to the budget um conversation as well um and we will have a consent agenda that we will um vote on in a few minutes as well um um the other thing I have to report board is that um the barington area Development Council has invited us and encouraged us to do CPR training together so um um having a family member in my past that recently went into cardiac arrest I know this is I can personally attest to the importance of this um this kind of life- saving training and it would I look forward to us finding a date and Leah has volunteered to help coordinate and Dr Wiman if you can help us find someone from in the district to
003provide the training I think we've got a few qualified people um that would be great we can um we can uh have some have our our board social and and uh do some CPR training maybe at dinner or something yeah we can maybe do that as well send your ideas to Leah I'm I'm the person for this I guess so that's cool we'll figure it out we'll figure it out you're hired can we invite others to come from the admin I mean or we can talk about it we don't need it's not a discussion for tonight the only other thing I wanted to U mention is that uh the place to be this week is to is to stay warm obviously but tomorrow night there is a a JazzFest for the middle school and the
004high school at 7:00 p.m. in the auditorium and that concludes my report [Music] um next up is public comment um so um with that I'm me just introduce our public comment section um uh we this is a portion of our meeting that we set aside for public comment our board values your thoughts and opinions and we will ensure that all voices are heard and respected in accordance with our board Equity statement that states we recognize Embrace and defend the identities abilities and voices of um everyone in our school Community the board has set forth the rules in our policy in which public commenters have agreed to abide by um I don't need to go through those rules at this time but I will remind everyone that this is a board meeting that occurs in public
005it is not a public meeting therefore public comment is not a conversation and does not necessarily reflect the views of the board and if any comments require further attention we're going to ask Dr winman to follow up and report back to the board Okay so with that we have two people signed up for public comment this evening so first up is Kristen Strickland I think there's a sign there that says come right to that chair welcome hi uh due to the broad nature of special education parents rely on the school district to maintain open honest transparent lines of communication that is not how the district has approached approach the dissolution of the social academic support SAS program The District's proposal to shift the landscape of the student support and place students in a more comprehensive
006therapeutic environment will essentially segregate disabled children with behavior deficits individuals with Disabilities Act idea sought to end this form of segregation in public schools idea requires that students with disabilities be educated to the maximum extent possible with their non-disabled peers I've witnessed firsthand the benefit that this can be for our children um this has also not been my experience here at barington 220 that we maximize the extent to which our students are educated with their non-disabled peers and I am new as of August 2024 um students with behavior deficits require um they require this interaction to learn appropriate behaviors and and social skills from their non-disabled peers a districtwide team whose sole responsibility is addressing Behavior con concerns expands the likelihood of discrimination not based solely on ability but based on race and there are
007statistics to back that up um the manner in which the district has approached this policy change is in direct violation of their Equity statement which states the Board of Education will be equitable inclusive transparent there was no transparency here respectful and impactful parents are in need of transparency I am a parent I need transparency because I have a child with an IEP is this this change uh in policy financially motivated um or is there research-based success that backs it if so what is the cost can the district provide research used to determine um that this will be beneficial for our students are there more long-term are there any long-term effects for children from removing them from the classroom uh how does this District intend to maintain equity for disabled children uh there are statistics that
008uh support minorities who are removed at higher rates than their counterparts how can you assure me as well as other parents that this is not going to happen here children with behavior deficits are often stigmatized they're labels as bad so are their parents what are what the district is forgetting is about the why and sometimes that can be beyond the parents control and um programs like SAS and instructors like Miss Lind blo we need those the programs and the parents I'm almost done thank you Kristen can you wrap it up please yes um and in spite of their deficits Miss limo was there every day and she loved my kid for the few months she was he was in her class and but our children go to the next speaker yes okay but our children
009need normaly consistency and academic support and they're not going to get that if we dissolve this program thank you so much thank you next up is Kylie Humbert hi guys I haven't seen so many of you in so long thanks for having me um for those Those whom I have not had the pleasure of working with my name is Kylie Humbert I have a son in Chinese immersion he is a sixth grader and loving his time at station and I have a daughter Carson who's a second grader Chinese immersion student at Rose my family is not native speaking Chinese so it's been incredible to have this opportunity um for my kids to not only learn the language but really just to be exposed to a you know a global culture so outside of our everyday
010Norm so I thank you for offering that program um and I thank you guys for all of the time you spend here advocating for our kids and the families and the constituents of the community we really appreciate it us parents I know that this is often a forum for us to kind of complain but we we do appreciate you in the same breath so the reason why I wanted to come tonight was just simply twofold one I've sent the board an email outlining a request for a special ed Advisory Board committee um to have board members join the special ed Advisory Board committee um just to increase transparency to the board with all the great things that are happening inside of the district with regard to special ed um and obviously to shine light on
011areas of opportunity as things are always in flux and I think having board members involved in that special ed Advisory Board committee could really give the committee some oomph and just get more buyin from you guys and more support and all around couldn't hurt um so that would be my first request the second request I have is just for an increased amount of transparency Within the barington d220 special education kind of arena for lack of better words right so just if changes are being made like when a SAS program is dissolved and an email is sent to SAS parents right let's let's make sure the board knows about that change let's make sure the parents who have kids in that program know about that change let's make sure the whole special ed program knows about
012that change because it causes a lot of alarm and distress and an already really fragile Community um with that being said um Pro lots of things happen in a special ed environment you know under the guise of law but a lot of things happen just because they can happen because that's the way the school is doing that when procedural safeguards are changed you know for only some families that email sent out when we don't have streamlined policies and procedures that go out it creates chaos and these families are already really really stressed and it's really hard to advocate for a kid when things happen so inconsistently so just by increasing transparency hopefully by partnering with the board and creating some sort of more intense special ed Advisory Board committee we can mitigate some of these
013problems before they happen we do a lot right so I think that's that's really important you know so let's let's talk more about the winds and and some areas of improvement so holler at me if you have questions love you guys you're all really special um so that actually concludes public comment um Dr mman I know you've you've given some updates to the board on the SAS program and um on the the special ed Advisory Board maybe you could just give us another update in the packet this week absolutely because I think I thought we did have a special advisory committee underway so we do and I will absolutely keep um the board informed just like we've already started that process proc and just a general comment that you know we're starting the process at
014this time of year to allow the ample conversations that need to take place for our students and the family you know those occur in an IEP meeting because it's individualized to the students needs and we absolutely will make sure that we take our time to have those individual conversations over the next several months right so that's part of it um and I want to make sure that also the board and Community knows we've we've served students with a variety of needs including um some of the behavioral needs that um our students have in our SAS program but we're going to continue to meet their needs um just like we have as a district for a number of years I started as a special education teacher serving students with behavioral needs in this District um different
015model different program so while we're looking at the program and how it's helping meet the needs of our students and how we deliver I want to make sure that the board and Community knows it's not a one-sized fits-all we're going to work with students figure out what the right program and placement is for those students and what the right fits so it's not necessarily that we don't have this program and all students are removed from our schools we will have those conversations in those individual IEP meetings and determine what's the right um programming for each of those students but more to come on that I just wanted to make sure it was clear to the board tonight um with some of the comments that were shared excellent thank you you're welcome all right well with
016that why don't I turn it back over to you to give your report yeah keep going all right absolutely so we get my report up there okay my first slide is about kindergarten um each year at the start of February we are excited to welcome our families beginning their child's journey in barington schools through our Kindergarten Roundup process uh this year our Kindergarten Roundup will occur on Monday February 3rd at each of our eight elementary schools and then we will have additional evening information sessions for our individual kindergarten District programs that exist throughout the district um I encourage our families uh to attend um our Roundup on February 3rd or one of those individual District program even events and I just want to reinforce for our community you know if any family has specific questions
017regarding the Readiness um of their child or the supports that their child may need um we have a lot of of information and and and clearly this is our first year as a district offering full day kindergarten and access uh to help support our students at a variety of Readiness levels they don't come to us all in the same manner but we work really hard especially in kindergarten to figure out the right level of programming and supports for our kindergarteners so if our families have specific questions in addition to those Roundup events I would encourage our families uh to reach out uh to our elementary principles and start those conversations so that our principles can start to understand the needs of some of the students that will be entering uh District 220 all right uh
018next um we had conversations uh this past fall around uh Title 9 policies and our conversations um as Administration and Board of Education uh we had noted and promised to the community that we would continue to Monitor and if any updates occurred that we would um bring those conversations back uh here to uh the board table um on Thursday January 9th uh in a case of the state of Tennessee versus Cardona the US District Court in the eastern district of Kentucky struck down the 2024 title9 sex discrimination regulations that went into effect just at the start of this school year on August 1st 2024 the court vacated the regulations Nationwide and that means that they are no longer in effect those new 2024 guidance so as a result our district will revert back to the
01920 20 Title 9 policies and guidance um should we have a situation occur within our school district uh we do not presently have any ongoing Title 9 investigations as a school district so in addition to using the guidance uh I also want to make sure our boarding Community isn't aware of that um in addition we will formally update our district policies back to the 2020 uh policies that existed prior to new regulations at our next policy committee meeting and then bring that back uh to the full board for conversation some more to come on that we recently learned that our district once again has received the meritorious budget award from the association of the school business officials International so according to asbo this distinction is a testament to our commitment to sound fiscal management and
020budgetary policies I want to congratulate Sarah logger and her entire team on their continued recognition and success for preparing our District budget at its highest level so congratulations [Applause] Sarah and I have one more slide this evening so sorry it's okay uh weather right this has been the topic uh that we've all been um discussing so I I want to start with just I was raised that when you don't meet expectations um you don't make excuses but rather you take responsibility and apologize um and then you take steps to improve and earlier this afternoon I sent a message to our community expressing my apologies and offering additional insight into what occurred uh today because our process did not reflect the timely communication uh that we have provided in the past and so a written message
021I believe only conveys so much um so I felt it was important that our community actually hear my voice and hear from me directly tonight on this important topic um our team has worked throughout the day today to review what occurred and we have already identified ways to make improvements and build some different systems and redundancies and practices um into our work moving forward um in addition our review has revealed some information that we can actually utilize to ensure information is received by our families for example as we've reviewed the process and what um went into our Communications we learned that in the last 30 days over 800 individuals have selected to identify our district Communications as spam when earlier messages went out to the community and thus removing themselves from all Communications including emergency
022communications so we learned that as we've been trying to uncover why did certain messages not go out why was there delays in the timing of it and so forth one of the things we learned that we had no idea that that that had occurred so again continuous Improvement we're going to continue this is just within hours today we discovered something we're going to work with our families to get them back in our system uh so that they're not missing messages and that's just one example of things that our team is working on uh to identify ways that that we can and will improve and I just felt that it was important that our community knows that we understand the importance of timely communication and the disruption that it causes for our families and we will
023work hard to restore that communication um like we've been able to provide um in the past uh the of the school year moving forward so and with that that concludes my report unless there's any questions from the board just want to clarify talking about kindergarten since we got an email about that somebody who turned six summer of 2026 is not disqualified from enrolling in kindergarten in the fall of 2026 right true statement right right so it's the state guidelines indicate five by September 1st or before for kindergarten six by September first or before for first grade so yes there there is some confusion in the community um we became aware of that and that is really why I wanted to one annually I mentioned that it's kindergarten R it's an exciting time it's the start
024of a journey for so many of our families and so forth so we highlight that but Barry that's what I was getting after that if anyone has concerns about the age of Entry what the process is how do we support kids and so forth we welcome those kind conversations and they're probably best served by those individual families working with our principles to really create the right plan and supports um for those families yeah I'm sorry can you say that one more time it was for first I'm sorry for kindergarten it's five and September 1st or after September 1st or before oh I'm sorry before and then six for first grade on September 1st before okay I know it's a weird way to say it but I hope we're all thinking the same thing but yes
025those are the two age cut offs that exist throughout the state and have been part of our you know practices as a school district but again I think one of the things that makes our district great is that that's the starting point of the process you need some guidelines we follow the state expectations but then we want to be able to work with our families to make sure we have a full picture of what their students need and I know there's been some concerns or communication around is my child ready or not should we be making other decisions for my child I want to start with those conversations we have a number of supports and as I mentioned we have a full day program now where we can layer in and build in um different
026ways to support the programming for our kindergarteners that help yeah yeah thank you Dr thank you for addressing the uh communication and timing around the weather I know it was very very stressful for our families and cause a lot of confusion um I appreciate the apology and taking it ahead on I think the question I was getting over and over again today was could we clarify what happened between the time that n the extreme cold warning went out at 3:30 and then our message at 6:58 a.m. to families was it entirely due to the infinite campus problems in terms of delivery and if so I know you said you're we investigating and looking through is there a thought to maybe okay we need to blast this on social media do you know do alternate forms
027of communication maybe at 5:30 a.m. or 6:00 a.m. continuously until people get it or like what so could you explain you know clarify a little bit more around that and then maybe some of the initial thoughts sure um so right so the timing we were working with our guidelines and continued to use our guidelines throughout the day yesterday um um continue to watch and monitor the National Weather Service updates to see if any conditions had changed or if the attempts contined to drop necessitating us to move from one level of our guidance right of an advisory to an actual extreme cold um we continue to monitor that up to and I think the community is aware um past 10:00 uh because we were sending out messages because unprecedented we had a uh a fake message
028go out that was not from the school district and our team was working after 10 o'cl to make sure we communicated again to our families at that time so we continued to watch Aon as far as a timeline all the way you know into those late evening hours because we were already responding to something else um we then went to bed for a few hours and woke up early to realize that after a few hours of sleep the National Weather Service because the times had continued to drop had changed the status which again necessitated us going back to her guidelines as soon as we read that early morning message our team started to work to put together our communication plan to go out to families um and that's where I've stated that the timing of
029that message of the process starting for us to where families actually received messages is much longer than normal normally we make that decision around 5:30 six o'clock and the message is out within minutes that didn't happen um and that's where we're investigating right now to find what occurred that those messages were delayed why did it take so long that some families received them earlier some it took all the way up till almost 7 o' some didn't get them at all as I was reporting on that were trying to investigate why did certain individuals not receive the messages so that's the Gap that I'm trying to gather information I've only had a few hours to do it today but we're already working hard to try to figure out how do we Shore that up if there
030is a problem with infinite campus's system is there another method that we can use and that's what I'm speaking to redundancy so if we realize one system isn't functioning and being as automated as it's behaved in the past do we have another system that we can go to can we start to implement another method to get information out are the text messages run through the same in phone calls so text phone calls messages that's all baked into that process and obviously we also experienced some challenges where text messages weren't going through to some individuals some were receiving it phone calls didn't go out because of the density of those messages um as far as just the system being able to process that so there was a lot of concerns going on with the system that
031we were trying to identify this morning in that gap of time to try to gather as much information as we could as to why is it not working like it normally does as you can imagine there's a lot of phone calls going back and forth between our staff our different departments are trying to investigate to figure out what is the cause of the problem and identify it and then try to send an additional message in a different manner there was a lot going on in the early morning hours that's where in the past we haven't experience that but because we did this time we're not okay with that we're going to look for ways ways to improve identify like I said additional systems and so forth so if one thing's not working we can go
032to something else so we did initiate that process at around 5:30 or 6 is that lag time took an hour plus yeah okay it was challenging for us to even understand why they weren't going out because the system I mean this is not our first rodeo we've actually implemented just in the last few weeks a number of messages where it's worked seamlessly where we learn that Grove also as an example we had a busted water line and we had a quickly switch we wrote messages we sent them out using our normal systems and they were out in minutes we just did that again a week or so ago for lines I mean things have been very reliable and we've been able to deliver on our community's expectation as well as our own to let families
033know as soon as possible we ran into problems this morning we're not making excuses we're owning and we're looking for ways to improve thank you yeah and not that you're not doing enough but also to assure the community we are going to try to we are figuring out how yes thanks for thanks for bringing that up I didn't mention that tonight but I did mention it in the CommunityWide Written Letter that went out today that's never happened before uh of us having a situation like that in the middle of our Communications um we have started in addition to try to understand what happened with messages not going to people we've also started to use our staff to investigate what occurred do we have any data breach what email list serves were potentially utilized um outside
034the district to to do that type of um mass communication that went out um as I indicated in the letter we um are working with barington Police Department uh we met with officers today to file a report of what occurred and to start the investigation not only as a school district with our resources but also to start an investigation uh through the help of um our local law enforcement and so as soon as I know something more about that I'll be right back here communicating to the community because I think it's important our community knows what transpired with that because they need to rely on our communication and anything that deters from that um causes problems because obviously last night like I said I pulled the whole team back together after 10 o'clock say we're
035working again and we need to get these messages out to everyone because this can't just sit out there that there's a a message that does not represent barington 220 is official communication something people were bringing up to me today was it doesn't seem to match that initially we were going to have school but no outdoor activities but that would still mean kids standing at the bus stop and that that doesn't seem to match and so I'm wondering if we need to relook with those policies reevaluate them yeah absolutely there is um I've been Leah also trying to help educate and inform our community about the existing policies because all of the decisions that we were making along the way are consistent with what our procedures state so and that's why we linked them for parents
036now I know not everybody clicks on them to look at um there's a whole host of things that occurred yesterday we're on the phone with the fire department to make sure they part of that advisory status that we were going to enter today in of just bringing students in and remaining inside part of there's it's dense it's all on the website if you click on the link and attachment we don't take field trips we don't put kids back outside or to other settings that we don't have control over the facilities we contact the fire department to say if we have an emergency we're not going to immediately evacuate students to outside we we will identify a location inside the school to move the I mean there's a whole host of things so our policy states
037and the weather conditions stated that we were in that advisory which means we have school based on the temperatures and the status from the National Weather Service um once that changed overnight then we moveed to The Next Step part following our procedures right now if the board and you know wants to direct the administration to revisit our procedures that we did follow and make adjustments have lower thresholds um versus the status that we were in um we are more than you know willing to have those conversations to make adjustments to if there's an interest in doing that does that make sense that it does those are the questions I was getting and I didn't have the answer that you have at your fingertips but it also that's a visual that people are saying that doesn't
038seem to match so but there's more of looking at it and I and it's not in the agenda tonight but it's something that's coming up right now so yeah of course you know when you're in that minus 20 to minus 30 with the wind chill yeah you our current procedures say you come to school and then we do everything about keeping you inside and so forth but you do come to school when you get over that or National Weather Service updates it to a warning we make an adjustment and so um you know I I definitely think we can take a look at that if that's a direction we want to head as a community and change those thresholds I would say as you go through your investigation bring back anything yeah anything that you
039guys talk through okay you like to bring to us is that do that that sounds we want to get it right the biggest thing is we have I think in the past demonstrated I hope to our community that we understand that that our community doesn't believe that we don't take that responsibility seriously enough or that we're not trying to communicate early enough we know all of the the changes the disruption all the things that occur in our households um if I can make the decision early for the past two years while I've been sitting in this Ro I've made it early last night I didn't have the ability to do that because our procedures didn't indicate the ability for us to make that shift at that time as soon as I knew that we move
040forward um but we're going to be better at it well and I think other districts said the day before we're not going to have school and and their procedures are probably different you know so it's something to think about yeah actually in my opinion know I'm looking at it for what's best for our district to clarify for the board I'm on a group with every Lake County school as well as our conference schools 211 and 214 they all make their decisions as of like last night there was two districts in Lake County that were going to do late starts two so I had wrong information you had wrong information showed a lot of people I apologize because I'm looking at a document where every superintendent is updated we had two okay many districts as soon
041as that new guidance came out shifted like we did because we were concerned about you know now the weather has actually gone less the national weather service has updated our guidelines say this some districts didn't Leah um 211 and 214 which are part of our Athletic Conference uh ran school today um so they made that decision apologize I'm going to make the decision for what's best for our district but I do want to clarify because I was hearing some of that same feedback of no one's in school tomorrow and I'm like okay but that's you know that's one piece of information we make our decisions based on our guidelines and and following the guidelines and the direction from the National Weather Service so I just want to reassure the community again more than anything we
042leave this conversation with an appreciation that we are sorry that we weren't able to deliver on that and we're going to work hard to try to figure out ways to make sure that that doesn't happen again thank you yeah of course so much was on the cusp too I know got our our procedure was I think up through minus5 actual temperature minus5 we would have school and at that that point it was minus 10 but then the National Weather Service had issued the extreme cold warning so that changes our direction right so I think an investigation as a procedures timing communication I think that will all help and look forward to recommendations based on that absolutely agreed all right thank you thank you Dr thank you board um next up is um our consent agenda
043do we have a motion to approve the consent agenda as presented moved second okay thank you on our consent agenda this evening are minutes from January 7th both open and closed um several Finance reports the December reports for wage and payroll treasury report and revenues and expenditures and the Jan AR Bill list as well as a revised Personnel report any questions or comments on those all right let's do a roll call Sandra Bradford yes Leah kis lazari yes Steve Wang yes Katie carum yes Ain Chand ding yes Barry Al Schuler yes all right motion passes let us jump into our um discussion topics before we get to our committee of the whole and budget planning awesome all right so our first discussion item tonight is our transform 220 um this is our first uh presentation
044to the board of education and our community and we are certainly um so excited uh to be able to kick off the next phase of uh construction and new spaces uh for our students uh in District 220 and with that I will turn over to uh Josh and Sarah who are going to lead us through the presentation the first trying to fill there while I was getting up there Jos the first first first of many first of many thank you for the opportunity tonight to give it just a brief update on the work that uh work that we have done thus far since the passing of the referendum in November and the work that and the work that we're doing um in the very near future relative to transform teach so with the passing of
045the 64 million doll Bond referendum in November of 2024 we' set in motion a series of meetings to prepare for the successful execution of transform 220 in late December District administrators met with daa Architects and pepper construction to discuss the transform uh 220 project including initial discussions of a timeline tonight we we will review the tenative timeline schedule for each project the most recent meeting was our inaugural transform 220 steering committee uh that occurred just last week timeline is up on the screen and was also included last week in your packet but this is our tenative timeline of the nine projects spanning three to four years and uh what you'll notice is um on the left you'll see a series of black uh bars that is our design period uh that includes developing plans and
046reviewing Concepts resulting in the uh construction of uh documents School Board authorization will be required to move to the bid phase which is the gray box and that allows prospective biders to obtain drawings and submit bids for design it also provides time for the construction team to analyze and make recommendation for school board approval and the final bar is the Red Bar very exciting that is the build bar what everybody's been waiting for waiting fores in the ground so design bid and build um common Concepts that I know this board is also very familiar with the bill f which is a red bar is the time needed to award contracts purchase materials construct and once completed turn over to turn over the facility to the school district for occupancy including punch list items and closeup
047our expectation of substantial completion of each individual project coincides with either the start of the school year or at a semester break while some projects as you will notice on the timeline extend beyond the start of the school year or extend beyond a SE midyear semester break this additional time that you will see on during the build phase is really connected to additional closeout items and punch list items but again our expectation is that these projects would be completed prior to the start of the school year or after ready for like after a semester break so I'll stop there and see if there are any questions related to the timeline that I can answer or Sarah can answer I just I know we are keeping the current Auditorium open why we build new Auditorium and
048then the conversion of that so is that all lumped into the community Auditorium tab no okay so the community Auditorium needs to happen and then you'll see as you go down a little bit then we're doing the music rooms which is the renovation of the current Auditorium and then we'll be doing the steam lab which is the renovation of the music gotta what I figured but yep thank you that's why we see the red bars at different time frames right no it's kind of hard to see this so yeah it's a little bit small and before we get too far I want to um just introduce our um architect and our construction manager Lance krie and Steve who are here to support us on our very first board presentation for transform 220 so thank you
049guys guys for being here and and thank you for helping us get started on this and this is on our website so people who can't see this we're gonna get there bar one sorry I just don't want people LIF The Strain too much it will be will be we didn't want to get ahead of the discussion tonight sorry you never want to get ahead of your boss is bury we want to make sure a chance to see it first absolutely so we're looking at a March 2028 open date for the new Auditorium well it would coincide with generally January for a break but yes we're in 20 the the the red bars also include like any followup items so it might not it might not um reflect exactly when be occupiable occup where we can
050have an occupancy and the person that's really going to help us get there is our golden hard hat I can't forget that she's here as well awesome exciting so when you look at it it's it is kind of easy to see that all the gray bars are all at the same time frame so could you just talk to that quickly yeah so we uh that that in our next slide so you will notice uh so not only the gray bar it's actually awesome for me because we've done this for four years and look at how look like look at the work of the board you're like I know what we're doing we know how to do this like it's great sorry you can answer as you get to it and if I don't please bring
051it back wor so one of the things that we noticed right away was that all the um all the design bar the frame time frame is January 25th to January 26th for all nine projects uh so to accomplish and and meet this timeline we have we have really begun an Earnest uh full meeting schedule that includes already calendared um already calendar meetings and a plan to add additional meetings as the project design teams begin to meet and so the slide slide that you see is just kind of a flavor of the rhythm of meetings that that have already been that have already been scheduled from the monthly steering committee that I mentioned earlier to weekly internal project status meetings and then also weekly status meeting with our project partners of uh from pepper and also
052with d across the bottom though is really our next l of of work as we uh really start to understand what the design process would look like and start to bring those design teams together for each one of the nine projects so um again go back to the timeline thank you Sarah you'll see along the left hand side you know we have we have a relatively short timeline in order to accomplish you know the design for all nine projects and then Sandra to your point also we have a very similar um we have the same bid process timeline for each one of those projects so if you want Sarah if you want to talk a little bit about the bid process sure so there's a lot of value one because these projects are so intertwined
053to be doing this design work at the same time so that you know everything is following the sequence also there's value financially in bidding these projects together by having our trades have an opportunity to see what's coming up they can bid these things and we can have a better Financial value which will be of course a positive for we like that yes so it's it's twofold and I'm sure that our partners could probably come up with a number of other reasons why there is value in doing that but ensuring our projects are streamlined and we're designing things that make sense together as well as the financial piece are really important to us just the final piece on on on this slide is the ongoing meetings uh it's one thing to have meetings but the important
054important piece is that we we're receive an ongoing feedback that was Central to the success of Bill 220 and that that will be a core component of transform 220 as we move forward so um Wanted did you say that again I couldn't hear you I'm sorry so I'm sorry um so uh importantly as we move forward we know the importance of ongoing robust communication it was centrally um you know important to build 220 and it will be just as important as we move forward with transform 220 so lots of opportunities to provide input feedback loop refine and continue to work through that process both with our staff with our board with our community very similar to what we we found it very successful getting individuals lots of eyes lots of perspective involved in that design
055phase so that whatever the outcome is that we build it's really been informed by a variety of um our stakeholders and community so for example like the Middle School um science rooms is something that we talked about maybe when my people would get done a little bit earlier but we really want to go through a robust design time frame to make sure we get all the input I mean I know when when I went I think it was the station for that communication you know I started hearing ideas about this and that um but really want to make sure we get all those stakeholders involved right and here and get their feedback before we put shovels to the ground MH absolutely makes sense is part of this communication and looking at um you know re-evaluating
056those additions at the middle school and if they're meeting the expectation that we had before we built them and when we toured and visited and now people are visiting us and to with the science rooms it's science so we know those teachers are going to be in there but with those rooms it was like we didn't know who was going to be in those rooms and then it became sixth grade and so it was a little bit of a okay did we train the right people who are the people in those rooms who are and is the whole school using those rooms kind of thing like do we do some looking back on that and reevaluating to make sure that this that those are working and that this will be more uh planned that's not
057the right word but thoughtful and you know yeah I know exactly what you mean yeah we're going to take advantage of we now locally have more insight into some of the designs that exist in the Middle School editions right we're going to drop on that you know when we did the work as you alluded to we were visiting sites we were looking at research that we used a number of things to inform but we didn't have the ability to have a full grade level configuration so yes individuals that are currently using the space that have insight into just the flexible what works what what are the best examples what are we taking full you know advantage of what do we not have that we wish we would have built in so that's going to be
058a piece of it but then also these are for science that we want to make sure we get our science Educators and research related to science instruction right because we want these rooms to meet our needs now and into the future we're going to pull all that so all the those different sources um but we are going to take advantage of the fact that yes we we now have the ability to actually lean into our staff a little bit more because we have those spaces and we've been able to use them with students yeah including student voice of what works where do we right where do we see you how and how you're using it and getting the middle school boys to help inform that as well because I don't want to make more work
059for you but probably the high school too how is the use of the the you know the atrium working how is the new cafeteria working you know it's early but it's still like we want to make it the best for our students that we can and we can't you know there's not unlimited money we can't make everything perfect but to make if we've got these spaces to use them to their fullest to the best use for our kids right absolutely so because there's mixed feedback it's it's always that way you know yeah well and you get in a space and then you also start to use it and learn how you're using it so you know there's there's no replacement to that like when you get in a space how you use it where people
060start to find benefits we may adjust hopefully we're designing them to meet the variety of needs but we also will learn along the way and then make adjustments as well okay so we are at Ground Zero on our referendum therm ometer for spending so the dollars are generally added to our thermometer when they've been committed which means that you have awarded a bid for example so we are still early in the process and of course we are at $ z0 committed right now I just want to make note that the bond issuances so when we're issuing a bond that's not connected to this thermometer that we're looking at this is truly about the spending that we're doing on the project so the bond that we issued in December would not play into this since that
061was so early and kind of out of sequence from our last referendum I just wanted to mention that we don't have a thermometer for that we want to see the progress on the shovels to the ground yes exactly and shovel St I know we'll see more before we get Shovel St yeah let me ass this do you anticipate two more tranches or just one more withu the BS now it likely to it kind of depends on uh any other leases that we might engage in if we don't engage in any additional leases over the next several months PMA might recommend that we take advantage of another under 15 million to take advantage of the Arbitrage so likely a a possibility of two and finally in addition to ongoing board presentations will'll continue to be transparent
062and open uh regarding uh the ongoing work and the process related to transform 220 so as you know um we have we now have a dedicated site U website U on our district website relative to our most recent initiative which is transform 220 um there's not a ton in there right now but um there will be uh so thank you Sarah for launching it you'll see the nine projects um you'll see the nine projects along the right hand side U and just kind of some overall information about transform 220 but as we move forward we'll continue to up update the site with presentations and timelines and and all those all those good things so um that has worked for us in the past with various initiatives so this will be you know an aligned approach
063in terms of communication even Beyond board board presentations so with that that concludes my uh my update unless s you have anything else to so maybe one more quick quick question as we update the the website you know as we showed the timeline it didn't show when the students be able to occupy that space will be also be able to include an anticipated date for when the middle school science rooms Auditorium I'm sure is on everybody's mind when um we might expect to have students occupy those spaces yeah yeah we we've actually we've had some very some very recent conversations about how to sort of showcase that on a timeline um but as you know we're very early on in the process so identifying you know a month um but as I shared earlier our
064expectation is that these spaces would be you know ready ready to go for the start of the school year or at a semester break yeah and that's something like a date for a date is good too it is um you know we've we've put now the different projects on the website and then there's gonna be a page dedicated to each you know we could add some narrative language now that we have the general timeline I'm sensing from the board feedback there's no concerns with the timeline or adjustments but I don't want to before we leave and go to the next agenda it I want to make sure that that is the the case right and then we can look at those individual pages and say for like middle school science classrooms you know anticipated you
065know substantial completion students moving into those spaces follow F the blank the auditorium I know is a lot of people are interested how does that line up with concerts musicals plays produ I get off we totally are mind Bo Mee right so we can do some of that work on the individual Pages as well so it's on a timeline graphic it's in narrative form just we know we need to communicate to our community everyone's been waiting this team has worked so hard in a very short turnaround um to get us to the point where we can answer that first question that is everyone is asking when do we get these things we tried tonight to be able to deliver that because obviously a lot of this work is connected to budget planning and our other
066timeline and Facilities which we're going to go to in a little bit so I guess I will bring that question then is it okay to give some feedback uh from the board timeline we're just very excited we're very excited of course we are too yeah so yeah we're just like sooner sooner sooner but you know reality it's like air conditioning in the gym man I just want it right now even today wait a minute stay tuned there are some updates there stay tuned B can't capture the cold air for summertime serious is everybody comfortable with this General great timeline considering we just passed this referendum over two months ago we're right really doing great we we're good good sounds like an opportunity for more green check marks eventually it'll have to be like green Lego
067piece oh a green Lego and I really like the thermometer too so we can see where we are yeah yeah it does I think we're a little different but it's a lot of the elements we're able to draw Upon A lot of the experience of the leadership of this board being familiar with the process our administrative team and certainly our partners I really do I I want to I want to thank stepen Wright and Carrie mattlock from da in Lance T from Peter construction for taking the time tonight and working so hard uh with our team to get us to a point where we could share this with the community because we did have conversations about those were some of the efficiencies and things that were baked into some of the conversations we were having
068thank you is there anything you guys would like to share because we're going to be seeing more of each other now for the next several years so tonight's the kickoff we're very excited to be here thank you we are too we're excited to have you all right so hearing no other comments looks like we've got a timeline we can publish okay and um thank you board appreciate it thank you so much all right so one other discussion topic before we jump into budget planning correct related M next up we've got some individuals that are going to come up to the table and join us uh for long range Capital planning speaking of green check marks this was part of our strategic plan so excited to have our team provide this update to the board tonight
069as well well we are returning as promised from our August meeting where we talked about long range Capital planning and we made some promises to the board and and we're here to talk more about that so as always we're starting with our mission statement of empowering personal excellence in every learner and as Dr winlan mentioned this aligns directly with our stewardship priority specifically the infrastructure faciliity strategic objective which states in alignment with other strategic priorities maintain and develop facilities infrastructure for present and future needs to empower learning so we've talked a lot over the last couple of years about long range planning and it's taken us some time to get here because we've we've sort of changed the process on exactly what that meant to us and what we needed to be most successful so
070Nicole's going to talk a little bit about what are we doing now to get to the point that we're making recommendations for our facility improvements what are what have we created which is a new inventory tool for the district which is then guiding our long range facility planning and that's going to help us not only maintain our buildings but be really thoughtful in um thinking forward about the work that needs to be done in our buildings and how we can accomplish that so I'll start a little bit talking about things you've seen and things you already know that we have a lot of space to maintain in our district 12 schools transition F facility our admin office and a number of vacant Parcels we have over 200 Acres of property and about 1.4 million square
071fet under roof which as you might remember equates to about 700 homes if you are internalizing this to your own personal um experience so our buildings are aging as you know we've done a lot of great things over the last several years that we want to keep um maintaining and keep looking great and um that of course takes takes a lot of forethought in our planning and it it takes a financial investment to be able to do and um you might remember that the replacement of our district is approximately $779 million which is a very large number to be considering so as we talk a little bit about the great work that we're doing we're then going to get into the tool that we've created and and how that's sort of going to guide us
072in our thought our thinking process to move forward with our Capital planning so I'll let Nicole talk a little bit about what she does now with her team to make decisions about capital projects which um we sort of interchangeably use the phrase summer projects or Capital project so we can kind of blink those together here so our current capital process includes there a few different factors we take building input into account we use um maintenance records and failure rates with the input of our maintenance team we also use some thirdparty assessments on all of the areas of of our buildings and properties so we do those things now we will continue to do those things going forward as well um we then make we prioritize our projects each year based on the needs as well
073as our funding that's available to complete projects once those projects are identified we bring them to the facilities committee for approval and then eventually any fits to the full board so all of those things will continue to do but as SAR was mentioning that does that did lead us to the point where we needed to develop a new tool so we had um better long-term planning so our new tool um has taken some time as you know there's been a lot that's gone into the development of it we partnered with uh da Architects and Berg engineering and did a thorough assessment of our district from top to bottom um The District staff was involved and we looked at everything from mechanical systems all the way down to Faucets in every bathroom so literally everything was
074inventoried in the entire District um we received all of that data and then we took it and analyzed it and we needed to um format it into a tool that was useful for our district so it took a lot of um work manipulating the data and getting it into a place where we could make it use ful for us as well I'll just sneak in for a second so Dr B came and talked a lot about this with us over the last couple years and we talked about a number of different tools a number of different approaches and methodology so that's sort of what has evolved to get us to this moment that we're in here so um as Nicole mentioned that it's taken a lot of meetings with Carrie thank you so much for
075for all the time that your team has put into this and Nicole spent a lot time in the buildings my joke was kind of you look down at the floor and you look all the way through the roof that's what's evaluated so everything from the ground up and Beyond is what is part of this tool and now available for us to see and this tool actually functions as a living tool that continues to grow and change as we grow and change and as we update things in the district for example if we were to add air conditioning to the gym at the high school that then go on the equipment list so we we would as we add a new community Auditorium all those things continue to go into the document or into the tool
076so it's a living document that we can continue to use ongoing for years to come and help us better long-term plan and better prioritize our projects over time and this goes well beyond 10 years it goes beyond 20 years I think we have things on there for 2072 is the furthest year out so so we are we we are looking far far into the future so the result of the tool is not only the tool itself but it gives us data on what we're looking ahead to so we need an idea of of what's coming of course we're talking about that all the time we always have an idea of that but this sort of puts it into a little more digestible data I don't know if 13.5 million is more digestible but it's easier
077for us to of course predict and plan for you're going to see a variety of um I don't want to say Peaks and valleys but um it it's not a nice clean flat line that you're going to see here and that's what you expect we're of course doing work at different Paces over the years which means that we're going to have different needs year after year so I'll let Nicole talk a little bit about what happens in 2728 when we have a $13 million year so what this is representative of is our tool and the useful life of everything that's evaluated and goes into the tool so um for example in 2728 there is about $5.5 Million worth of flooring in there but that is because that's its projected end of useful life does that
078mean we need to spend that money in that year not necessarily we're going to continue to use those Capital planning tools that we use now and do an evaluation of all all of these items that come up to their useful life in those years do an assessment and if it's still in a condition that we can continue to maintain it use it we won't replace it at that time we'll push it to a different year in the future but all of the things all the 13 A5 million the 5.2 million every year will take an assessment of everything that's projected for its end of useful life or in that cycle just like we do now we're selecting projects based on the funds that are available we'll continue to do that and Our intention here that
079you're seeing five years was not by accident we talk each year about a fiveyear projection we do a five-year forecast each year right now today tonight so Our intention is to sort of align these processes to have an opportunity to talk about resource allocation at the time that we are talking about our fiveyear forecast so here's a view of five years out as we continue to talk about that exact thing this evening so we will continue to do that on an annual basis we'll talk about what's coming up what do we think doesn't maybe need to be done in 2728 that can be pushed into a future year and then we'll continue to make recommendations based on the funds that are available and the projects that need to be done I will also mention there's
080years out from this that the bar is much much much lower so in some years yes sorry yes you know we have had a very consistent two and a half to $3 million projection for our summer projects this might lend to a little more flexibility in how we're spending those dollars if we have a larger year coming up and we have a small year behind us maybe we're spending a little less one summer and we're spending more in a future summer and this helps us plan for that this chart here is um sort of an adjustment to one that you have seen a few times so you you've seen the chart that shows our investment of the referendum that we just did the investment of repairs and maintenance which comes out of our operations and
081maintenance budget and investment of our Capital which we generally refer to as our summer projects and if you remember there were two bars on the chart that we were seeing before based on the model that Jen had evaluated and we came up with our threshold of what's the low end and the high end of what we should be spending based on the recommendation of the model so this is showing consistent spending if we were to make no changes other than CPI over the next 5 years to our current spending and then the dotted line is based on the model what the recommended spending is so you can see the variation between where we are and where we would love to be and just a reminder that our capital investment is generally based on issuing duub
082which we've had the fortune of not doing over the last couple of years um so it would either be issuing DB or prefunding with a surplus that we have had the benefit of but generally are not anticipating in future years so as I mentioned uh this process we'd like to align with our committee of the whole with our fiveyear forecast planning reviewing what we have coming up over the next 5 years for our Capital needs we will update our new inventory our new tool consistently throughout the year so we'll be adding our AC in the main gym for example and any other things that are replaced or repaired or added to the district and then we will continue to bring project recommendations to the facilities Committee in the spring what questions can we answer I
083just want to say thank you for this work because I think the board and the community has been asking for us to have a better plan for budgeting for our facilities and this gives us a strong clear view of you know are five air conditioners all going to go in like five years or what kind of things are we going to need to budget for and so it's very responsible and it seems like it's been an awful lot of work and I appreciate that and I think the community does too um and then you know as a board we're going to have to figure out where we find the funding you know but this is a good step and and sorry I interrupted I was so excited that some of the years were not 13
084million weren't on the chart I was like okay but yeah and I think you've explained it in the past that you know it's like your home you you look and you say how old is my roof how old is my Plumbing you know how long can the ugly floors stay in my kitchen that I don't like but are they going to be functional you know so this is kind of it makes sense you know and that's a way to explain it that I think makes a lot of sense so I think this is really good work and I'm glad I didn't have to do it I'm glad you did and this will help us plan so thank you thank you for saying that and the thing I did not mention on the $13 million year
085is there are always more projects than there is money we know that that's expected so when you saw that I'm sure you gasped but we expected to see those things because we know that that just like in a home there's more things that you'd like to do more things that you'd like to upgrade than you um have funds for you guys have been really good about prioritizing and you've really made the the numbers the amount of money that we've given you so far you've stretched it the best you can but the bottom line is it's not enough what we've done over the last 10 years or longer is not the model that we need to follow and you know our commit of the holes can discuss where this money is going to come from but
086the bottom line is we need more money in our capital projects in our maintenance fund would it be fair would it be fair to say that um you know because every year is a little bit different in your forecast if we took the average of the five years which I think is right around 9 million 8.89 would it be fair that it would put us in a more comfortable position around facilities if we were to average that allocation every year definitely that number is rather close to the recommendation on the next slide with the um dotted line or maybe the slide before sorry that is can you put it up so we can oh sure so sorry I'm pointing um the dotted line in the first year is about the average of what you're seeing
087on this chart but as with everything it escalates with CPI so the model that we're using in includes an increase in duub every year it includes an increase in our operations in maintenance repair and maintenance budget it includ it it assumes an increase each year so yes that's sort of where we're starting and and then it's increasing now $9 million every year for a number of years would certainly be much more than the 2.5 to3 that we've been investing certainly but um that's pretty in line with with the recommendation so the recommendation is to increase from 2 and a half to three to 4.2 to 5 annually correct make sure that we're all I read I'm reading things right yes I believe that was in the memo is that accurate I believe so yeah without
088it being right in front of me I apologize right here 4.2 to 5 is what's in the memo so that's where you'd like us to get to this evening as we budget that's your recommendation that's in order to um be able to make the Investments that we need every summer well typically we do them in the summer because that's when it's least disruptive to our students right um and then the other half of the promises we're not going to ask for another referendum for a very very long time because we're going to budget for some of these things thank you Leah yes that would include these facilities like a referendum wouldn't include right annually better so that we're not asking for referendum for a longer time period is what we're trying to communicate with our
089community as a board if I I don't want to speak for all of you but I know we've talked about this before yep um at the risk of not getting too deep in the weeds here I'm noticing that you have repairs and maintenance and capital separately but there's a threshold for something to qualify as capital correct like there's a dollar amount correct the capital that you're seeing here is generally what we call some sum projects so repairs and maintenance is coming from the operations and maintenance budget whereas capital is coming from the capital fund so if we have like a minor equipment replacement that would that fall into repairs and maintenance yes generally it we're always doing repairs and maintenance and we are doing Replacements throughout the year like a water line at lines is
090the gray okay what's coming out of the capital projects fund is approved by the board might be an easy way to um sort of draw that distinction but there's no other you know replacement or equipment type needs that are not reflected in this forecast is that a fair statement no there's always more that needs to be done than we have funds for but if you're just looking at the pink and the gray for example that is what we would be spending if we had no change to what we're currently doing sure right understood there's more projects that could be done beyond what you're seeing here so maybe this is not the right slide because the prior slide showed um what was it 13.5 or something like that in terms of um capital projects how does
091the uh maintenance then or I'm sorry I should say how does the repairs and maintenance budget change because obviously we want to try to you know I don't know what the number is right but I'm assuming it's call it 2500 bucks to qualify as capital everything else would be considered an operating expense that's all taken into account in your math is that accurate well I'll just make one comment before Nicole speak so anything over $5,000 is considered capital in our accounting structure that doesn't necessarily mean it's being paid out of the capital projects fund we do capital projects within the operating budget as well okay so the real distinction essentially between the gray and the pink would be is it coming out of our operating funds or is it coming out of capital projects okay
092but in other but but they are doing capital projects and they might be unexpected throughout the year out of the operating budget I'll let you talk a little bit that's exactly what I was going to say I was just going to define the CATE how we categorize a capital with $5,000 um just to reiterate we have an operations budget where we are doing daily operations repairs maintenance rate fix things like that there are capital replacement like piping at lines that needs to be replaced that is a capital Improvement so there is a difference between what we're spending daily in break fix repairs and maintenance out of the operating budget versus what we're spending as a capital expense in the operating budget so there are there are differences there and there are things in this 13
093million for example that will be accomplished through the operations and maintenance budget okay large so so everything is under here not just things that are five grand and over is me painting is on here for example so yes just want to make sure there's not going to be any surprises where you know obviously the line is different we Steve I think it's great you're asking these questions because we're introducing a new tool we hav had before and I think it's very important for the board to get into the Nuance of how this is all fitting together because this is a real benefit to our community okay to have something like this and certainly the board's leadership is going to be warranted as we're having these conversations so clarify away yeah okay I appreciate that thank
094you yeah I'm just trying to make sure I'm wrapping my head around this appropriately and then okay and the other other concern I might was probably going to bring up was just I would assume that any sort of because again if it's if it's all capital and non- capital that could fall through on the operating side then I'm not worried about bundling so in other words things that wouldn't hit the threshold these are under five grand you've captured in here as well right yeah I mean for example we talked about how this this inventory includes mechanical systems that are hundreds of thousands of dollars as well as a faucet which is much less than 5,000 because we're definitely not spending that much on our faucet thank you we're not spending that on our faucet not
095to the labor I just thought of something that the repair and maintenance that we're doing from our operations and maintenance budget is also extending the life of some of these things as well so it might extend the life to the point that we don't have to replace it in that $13 million year for example so just I don't want to get too deep in weats I guess on this one either but when you do that you know break fix I'm sorry replace fix analysis MH um what type of what type of assumptions do you use like are you trying to say we want to extend it for a certain period of time so on a present value or no this is really just based our budget and our spending knowing that some of the funding
096that's in this sequence here is going to help extend the life and may even replace some of the things that are in this one sure let me ask the question maybe differently um if it's a let's call it a $500 item but we can spend $100 each year to replace it or I'm sorry to maintain it do we look at do do you do any sort of discounting to say like $500 in the future is more like you know I find a present value basis it's more like $400 and because we're now timing out each of these cash flows over the next five years to to keep it from an additional five years instead of replacing it we're now gonna PV that back too or how do you do that analysis I'm just curious so
097that's something we actually do in the buildings and grounds department on a daily basis anytime that we have an item that needs repair or needs maintenance we're evaluating does it make sense to make that repair or do we need to look at it and put it on our capital projects list in the near future right like take a flush valve for example uhu I'm going to check and see if it's not working is the wiring bad is it battery operated whatever the issue is do we flick do we fix that that little part or piece do we change the wiring or do we have to replace the whole flush valve if a coil breaks on a mechanical unit are we replacing the coil or is that unit coming due this summer and we need to
098think about replacing the whole unit we just did this for some boilers in our district the boilers needed some repair work done we needed to put new tubes in them so we assess the value of the replacement of the tubes versus the life of the boiler and it made more sense for us to do the Tube replacement because the life of the boiler was so so far out it doesn't make sense to us to replace the boiler now and lose that life the value of the remaining life on that unit so we are doing this da in our department with everything that comes up okay understood great thank you well and to your point it's a living document too so obviously it's not perfect like there are going to be things that come up and
099so it's can be literally changed at all none of these is none of this is set stone effect I mean yeah predict everything I think the real benefit is that flexibility and the living document part of this rather than we had good information in the past but it was contained to a snapshot at time and it didn't evolve and change and be dynamic where our team can be updating it and making adjustments and then the benefit of bringing that to this conversation annually in fiveyear you know time frames that coincide with some of our forecasting as a district that that is huge that is a huge accomplishment from something our community identified in 2022 with our strategic plan and I know we heard loud and clear over the past year as we've been trying to
100also address the concerns of the community of monitoring maintaining but also the investment and is that keeping up with the ability for us to preserve our facilities and keep them knowing the dollars don't go as far so it's a real benefit that flexibility and that living document piece I think is one of the real benefits to our district you know what I'm sorry actually one more question too agreed um this is your the replacement timing is based on accounting useful life is that correct based on what accounting useful life so in other words you said you mentioned floors needing to be replaced in 28 we're assuming that floor have a useful life of let's call it 25 years so therefore it's now hitting at 28 right yes but to your point the useful the actual
101useful life could be something north of 25 years okay correct so everything is based on accounting standards and then we'll adjust as needed on an annual basis exactly and and then as as far as the tool goes to Katie's point then I don't have the numbers in front of me but um the 5 million that's being projected for the next school year if we only spend a percentage of that that that residual now gets pushed to the following school year or correct or okay yes either it gets pushed out to the useful life we've now determined or new useful life or next year yes and then what we did spend is pushed out into the variety of years that it would have a useful life for okay and do we have a reserve then for
102I guess we have the fund balance F yeah just in case we have like an emergency okay corre all right okay that's it thank you which we tapped into a little bit obviously right to make some of those decisions in August for some of the projects just to be clear when it says annually in March project recommendations that's for the summer like this March will be summer of 26 exactly we've already decided what we're doing in summer of 2025 correct good point because we got to design and got to bid and all kind of so sooner we save more money right right right absolutely yeah you were on an earlier timeline for our summer projects than we were a few years ago so that we can go out to bed dinner we appreciate all of
103this hard work to get us to where we are would be a very useful tool for a long time to in order for us to evaluate and appreciate any extension of useful life as as much as sure which I know we've done we have a long history of doing that so we have yeah we really I and that's a credit to the maintenance if you put more care into it you get more life out of it and that's where the the value of our team um it's why Nicole has a golden heart hat uh because we do try to work no I'm serious I mean your your department does need uh recognition for that because there's a lot of schools that you know they wear faster than others because we're not doing that ongoing maintenance
104and so forth um and so we have I mean look at our turf one of our largest Investments the initial purchase was a life expectancy of 10 years but through the care of that um we got 12 years out of it 13 yeah I think we got two extra years where other districts didn't have that and that's again attributed to we work hard to maintain our facilities and do the things along the way necessary to get as much value on of them so thanks for bringing that up yeah I was thinking about the turf too so thanks to community for helping us keep that Turf longevity of life too there's reasons we've got rules and things like that how to use how to use the turf and so forth so yeah appreciate everybody's help all
105right are we ready to move into budgeting as we leave though I just want to make sure we've got the numbers right 4.2 to5 is our yeah do you just mind if I look at my memo really F you can correct us as we the allocation no it's but it's good I know why you're you're trying to clarify that because it's a target for us for the next conversation for the next conversation we're looking at the same Target um and just green check mark coming your way thank you just to be clear delivered on that one yeah so 4.2k you in FY 26 and then it escalates Beyond so our initial goal when Dr Bine was talking about this way back when was to get to a $6 million investment and that would be if
106we were to increase the same amount each year would be in 2030 so in 26 yes the recommendation is 4.2 and that would get us to the dotted line starting point so what I think I just heard you say is that it's an extra million to two million every year and for the next five years no it it um ends up being about 300,000 additional every year from what well if we went to 4.2 million that would be an additional 1.2 million in FY 26 and then it's 3 00,000 each year if we were to do what is on the screen which is a aggressive goal okay be 4.2 plus 300,000 in the second year yes and the third year 4.5 plus another 300 M the next year yes 4.8 plus another 300 okay that's
107helpful and that's the dotted line that's the dotted line in other words once you've added it the assumption is it remains and you're just continuing to add on to it not some of the fluctuations we've saw where we've done onetime contributions this is a Evergreen contribution in order to meet that goal just it's a little bit of a shift of some of the decision making we've done at this meeting in the past right when we shared in August we shared sort of a every year we were going up about5 were doing more in summer of 25 than we had done before but then each year we were sort of going up to get to that 6 million Mark in six years from our and that's with duub factored in every year correct correct so in
1085 years it will be when we would reach that uh just over six million in um 2030 203 maybe at six million okay everybody following yep y might be good to to draw us a picture after this I see what you're doing yeah yes s and I will work to give that broken down so that we can see that visually I just want to make sure it's very clear yes that this what we're talking about tonight is going to get us through the next year but but we're going to be doing this again to get another 300 yes every year and again it's it's every year again and again until 230 and that's based on everything lining up like it is just there may be a year that something else occurs where we need to
109make a different decision absolutely which is so if we put aside five million and and we only have to spend 4 million that summer we would take that million and put into capital projects exactly does so we're ready for this 6 million the next year exactly that's kind of what I was talking about how the years fluctuate so I mean we can always find more projects to do early but let's let's hold on to the dollars and use them as we need them so one year might be higher than another so we can get extra credit if we get to 5.3 tonight yeah well go compounding effective it as well absolutely right so you know we are overachievers right so um all right okay Welcome to our uh Committee of the whole five-year forecast we
110we have hit the moment of the evening so do you want to your presentation oh yes thank you I do that every time I said so if um anything is aligning with our framer 220 and our mission statement it is certainly the budget and what we are spending to educ edate our students so to get us started I want to talk a little bit about our revenue and expenditures and starting with the FY 25 budget as that is our most recent funding for the district so our operating revenues very consistent with what we're what we would expect to see 88% of our operating revenues come from local funds which is what our state mandates of course our state is um tasked with creating a structure to fund our schools and the way that Illinois works
111is that property taxes are the largest source of revenue for any school district in the state what you also of course know is that any money that we're getting federal state or local money is all derived from property taxes of course or taxes of some kind any of the federal money we're getting is coming from taxes same thing with the state so of the dollars that we're getting are coming from our community supporting our district similar to our revenues this is exactly what we would expect to see on in our expenditures our salaries and benefits are of course our largest expense we are a peoplehey business of course we need staff teachers support Personnel to educate our students so seeing 74% in salaries and benefits is very consistent with with what we would expect our
112next largest object is purchase Services which of course is attributed to our transportation cost just verification that's also food right Food Services food services in there as well there's there's many things purch Services yes but when you see such a one large yes absolutely thank you for mentioning that so as we're talking about what is our driving factors for our budget I wanted to break down our spending for our staffing costs so our teachers and professionals are of course the largest for our about $110 million in Staffing and this is not benefits this is salaries alone so about 70% of our um Staffing costs are attributed to our teachers and professionals then we have our classified which includes our AIDS and support Personnel in our education fund as well as custodial grounds and maintenance and
113that comprises about 15% then you have administrators at 8% and all of our other so that would be extra Duty longevity overtime double time stiens Subs all of the extra things that we need to support our districts comes in at about 7% so I know this is very small but when we talk about allocating our resources we want to get an idea of what are we spending our dollars on overall so I know that Dr bran has shared this with you in the past so I thought it was beneficial for us to take a look at for fy2 so you can see that the bottom 20% of our expenditures is just below line six so again the majority of our budget is tied up in salaries benefits and then again the next largest thing is
114transportation so again we are people heavy with salaries benefits um everything below that if we were to make large significant cuts you can see that would be a significant portion of our budget that would need to be impacted in order to make an impact Beyond programmatic so I'll pause here and see if there's any questions on this because I feel like we we often talk a little bit about this chart not seeing any questions okay I'm sure we'll come back then so what we have here is our tax rate for us as well as our neighboring districts you'll see that the high school districts also reflect their feeder districts so of course we're a unit district and don't have a feeder District so um when you look at Stevenson for example you'll see that their
115tax rate is reflective of killed year 96 so each Elementary School just like each High School just like each unit district is going to have their own individual tax rate so add Stevenson and kild deer for example we're adding both of those numbers together to get the overall tax rate we are you can see number four so we have gone up um just a bit as we knew we would with our referendum and likely the other districts below us have maybe had some debt roll off in the last couple of years so we are still significantly lower than our neighboring districts so what does that mean for a taxpayer if for example a taxpayer owned a home in barington worth $500,000 and then moved to a neighboring District essentially anybody but Glen Brook Leon and
116Elmhurst they're going to have a higher tax bill than if they were to stay in barington so in this example I have on the next slide I took the average of the districts that you saw on the previous slide I didn't want to single out any single District and say Here's what the difference is so here's the average which is about 120% of what our tax rate is so you can see a $500,000 home in barington with um a an assessment level that's even across both examples a state equalizer which is equal across both examples as well as the homeowner exemption in barington would be about $6,300 and keep in mind this is just for the districts um taxing base this is not an individual's total tax bill which of course would vary somebody in
117a another District would be paying $ 77600 so that's an increase of about $1,300 from our district to the average of our neighboring districts around us so we talk about um you know districts that maybe can build a community Auditorium out of their fund balance for example how are they doing that it's with a higher tax rate they're generating more Revenue than a district with a lower tax rate so I think it's pretty commendable to barington for all the great things that we're able to do and we can do it at um a value to our community so wrapping up fy2 we've talked a little bit about the budget how it's comprised how are we trending for this year while we are we're we're tracking well interest earnings continue to remain high so we're continuing
118to benefit from that of course that's a bit of an unknown we're rather conservative when we're making our assumptions which we're going to take a look at in a minute but we were conservative when we wrote Our assumptions for fy2 and we continue to benefit from higher interest rates Esser funds are fully spent um I'd like to give myself a round of applause for that finally wrap in up so we're very excited to say goodbye to Esther thank you for all the great things that you gave us and and we we put you to bed thank you for service thank you for your service would you say we don't have to account for it anymore yes oh sorry I just I had a we sorry um as Dr winlan mentioned we've had some water issues
119at some of our schools some electricity issues so we have had some unexpected facility spending but we've been able to manage that within the budget so as of right now our spending is tracking well um if anything again we're seeing some higher interest earnings but overall things are um trending just as we expect so we're going to talk a little bit about our assumptions but one of the biggest items that drives the assumptions that lead into our budget is CPI we talk about this through out the year every year um at the final hour of getting all of these documents out last week CPI was released so I had been using the Assumption from November which was 2.7 and then it was released at 2.9 so it's slightly higher than what I had been using
120for my assumptions but I was able to update this and bake it into everything that we're going to continue to look at so I've updated the Assumption sheets and I've been able to put that into the models that we're going to review but CPI is is so important because it drives all of our property tax increases of course and it also drives our salaries based on the contracts that we've engaged in so CPI is a really important piece of course we've been on this journey together as we have seen incredibly High CPI and watching that come down and just a reminder the FED targets 2.5% so you can see that we're getting closer to that as we get further away from the pandemic so I will bring you to our for our forecast assumptions which
121um our finance committee has seen the last time that we were together and we made some decisions around that so if you open up the red folder that you have on the right hand side you will see our FY 26 assumption [Music] sheets so I'm just going to talk through this cheat a little bit and you can um stop me with any questions or um anything that you want to dive into a little bit deeper so each year when we look at this we always get a little bit confused of course about what year CPI is driving what right so uh you can see that the CPI year that's listed at the top is what is driving the revenue for the fiscal year that we're in so for fy2 um six actually now I'm confusing
122myself here we are um going to be using the 20203 CPI which was 3.4 for part of our fiscal year and then we're going to be using the new CPI of 2.9 for the rest of the fiscal year because our Levy of course spans multiple fiscal years so how can we complicate this any further of course but you can see the 2023 CPI was 3.4 4% so that's sort of what we're using to start talking about the levy for the year but we also know that it's going to be split over to fiscal years which you can see in FY 27 of the 2024 CPI which is 2.99% so everybody with me there all right so you'll remember that we had an expiring T Tiff and we also had a tiff that we needed to
123account for that we also accounted for in the prior years so you're going to see $20 million in new construction which has been our assumption for the last couple of years and I have set that out for the next five and then you'll see the Tiff in our um tax increment financing the 8.5 million that we've also added question you want questions as we go or you want to wa till the end go ahead I'm just wondering is 20 million reasonable over the last five years is that about what we're seeing yeah so we were doing about1 million for a few years and then each year we go through and check the average of the last 10 is usually what we're doing and 20 million has um served us well for the last two years
124and of course each year we'll be evaluating based on the prior Year's Levy so is there can we just make can we agree on each line item as we go through them so we don't have to go back through them again sure so is there any changes anybody wants to make to either the CPI take the CPI assump given well but the out right for the mod out so in the out years as I mentioned the FED targets 2.5% so 2024 is now known and the out years I have at 2.5% right so is everybody comfortable with 2.5% great and and the 20 million will continue to be evaluated after each year if that doesn't suit us any longer based on our actual new construction then we would change that moving forward is everybody comfortable
125with that 20 20 million sure so the next couple of lines are uh essentially accounting for the new construction and seeing what the overall Levy assumption would be so it'd be the 3.4% plus um the new construction in the Tiff which brings us to 4.3 and then our tax collection rate has been rather consistent at 99% so I left that flat just going to pause and make sure everybody's okay not hearing any nobody's raising their hand make sure we're all so far so good in sync here we actually did change that tax rate one time we did and uh yeah we were concerned we weren't going to be colting yeah we thought we W going to be getting it and we did so we did yeah so another change to CPI of course um this
126is what is now driving our salaries so I have uh known information for CPI for 26 27 and 28 and then in 29 and 30 for our teachers I have used C actual CPI to make that adjustments because we would need to go back into negotiations for those out years okay everybody understand that how long our contract is year 2028 right and uh same application for our classified staff and for administrators I use CPI in each year and of course that will come to the board for approval once we have finalized a recommendation for you for all of the administrators and the exempt staff in medical insurance I have flat at 3% in all years is that pretty standard uh as far as what we've seen historically the 3% yeah so the 3% is contractual
127oh okay great it's not what the teachers pay it's what we're paying right that's what I'm saying it's what we're it's what we're paying and that's contractual that's contractual okay that's right okay yep so I'm making the assumption that that wouldn't change in our negotiations and I do have the TRS cost shift on here this is an item that um the legislature kind of has kicked the can on many many many times but in order to be prepared for that we have sort of a a gradual adoption of it if you will in the forecast because I think it's important in case it does creep up on the US that we have considered it in our out years it's funny Dave B had it in four or five years ago so as you say kicked
128the can down the road yeah as long as they keep doing it we we can do the same but you've got it in the model I do some at some yep 28 29 and 30 so I do have um D listed for your reference on what that would look like based on our CPI assumptions and then investment rated of return is one that we generally talk a little bit about at the finance committee which we did earlier this month interest rates are still tracking high right now but um as the approach we've taken in the past was to be on the conservative side because we know that could change at any time so I have an assumption in here of 3.5% this comes from talking with other districts this comes from talking with PMA um
129on a long-term assumption we are still in the mid fours right now we have a lot of Investments that are locked in at even higher rates that will of course be maturing over the next several years so we'll continue to benefit from that and then I have a decrease to 2.75% FY 27 2.5 and then flat at 2% in 29 and 30 any questions or any concerns there concerns there s conservative yeah okay so cppt we might remember a number of years ago we had a large uh I don't love the word windfall but that's basically what happened unexpectedly um we then learned that the state made an error and they reduced our cppt pretty significantly a couple of years out so we're still seeing some of that adjustment this is the last year that
130I'm reflecting a decrease in cppt from the prior year which is bringing us closer to our historic level over prior years and then you'll see that I have that flat in in the following years so once we get back to Historic levels I think it's reasonable to assume that that will remain consistent ebf changes approximately $7,000 every year so I have that remaining flatted 100% And then our state aid categorical growth so this is our categorical payments on Transportation is our largest one so we are have been um heavily receiving four payments over the last several years one late payment from the prior year and three current payments so might they catch up with that one extra payment one year maybe hopefully they just stick with four and and then everyone knows what to expect
131I have no change to Federal Aid or um any other Revenue growth that we're aware of can you just explain the acronym cppr I can never remember what it for please uh corporate personal property replacement taxes so um it's generally comes to the state based on profits of our of Corporations so they pay a percentage of their profits to the state and then it's distributed to taxing bodies so it it changes with the economy of course so we thought that's why we were seeing such a huge increase over Co Co when we got all of that new money part of it may have been that there was also an error at the state which inflated it but as you see high economic growth you might expect to see a bit more cbpr but it shouldn't
132be spikes in ebf is that evidence-based funding yes okay and we get we we receive you said 7,000 we get about 6.5 million is our base funding and that increases about 7,000 which is why 100% so we're basically figuring 6 and a half million a year uhuh it doesn't grow exponentially we're tier four District so we don't expect for it to grow tier one and two districts are who'd be receiving the additional funding but we're happy if we continue to get our minimum the six and a half okay and that is the minimum that's been yes for tier four well for us for us it's based on prior years worth of data but the state has consistently been funding the 350 million that they are statutorily required to do so as long as they continue
133to do that we'll get our the six and a half uh plus we don't have a crystal ball but we are being told that the state is kind of tight right now so do we do anticipate that that's not going to decrease as of now that's correct okay everybody comfortable there does anybody want to make any changes there to maybe Point go ahead no I was to ask a more general question I mean as far as the bottom line goes can you point out and maybe we've already gone through some of them but can you point out what some of the more sensitive um assumptions are so for example if you know that evidence-based funding goes from well I guess 6.5 million not going move the needle but assuming that it was a larger number
1346.5 would make a significant difference if we lost it that would be that would be a lot of money for us well fair enough I guess I'm speaking about the over 100 million but sure I mean property taxes is of course going to be the biggest impact so CPI if that were to have my assumption was 2.7% based on November CPI if that would have gone up five basis points or down five basis points that would have changed the work that I was doing to get to tonight so that would have been significant um with the majority of our dollars going towards salaries again CPI is really driving a lot of that cppt um we're getting back to our about a million dollars annually so you know would that make an impact absolutely um ebf
135if that disappeared that'd be a problem state aid state aid would be a problem if we miss a payment we get about 7 and a half to 8 million in in transportation reimbursement annually so if we were to miss a payment on that that that would be significant and it would be very unexpected but to at least up to this point there's nothing that you're looking at that you're saying to yourself there's a risk here you you're feeling pretty good about all these okay y okay so everything coming into our Revenue side is there any assumptions that anybody wants to make a change to any things we just talked about changes nationally with the education department does that affect any of that 3% at all would you think the 3% the from federal that we
136get from federal sorry it's not on here I just meant the percentage that we that we receive from federal so the um money that we're getting from the federal government is tied to Grants so okay um and that's not tied to the education or Department of Education well it um now uh idea is a huge Grant that we receive the um individual disability Education Act that would take dismantling a lot of those laws as well as the education department of education so I think that there'd be some additional steps but that would be significant you don't think we need to factor that in right now I guess it's so unknown right yes I understand why why you're asking there's just not any new information as of meting tonight but you know I think it's something
137to consider and we're going to watch but want to make a change tonight ands Now's the Time to do it right or maybe at least understand that sensitivity Steve that you were talking about right right what's a sensitivity if if it goes down you know what's what do we want to know I mean if there's some sens we want to know then we should ask we can um we're going to review some models so you'll be able to see what an impact like that might look like have we is there a way in let's say something happens in a month and a half that we can amend the budget certainly so our remember we're not even adopting the 26th budget until September right so we would be yes we would be having some addition convers
138before we even got to the point that you're seeing a tenative budget if something significant were to happen Okay however there was one year that they Vine did give us an amended budget I forgot if there was more 2021 because of Co because of covid and we issued another referendum bond that year yeah my first year yes we did two budgets I was just going to say but a big portion of our budget that we just talked about is salaries right so that's why we're having this conversation now because we have to make sure we understand our staffing for the coming year MH so it's more difficult to make those kind of changes after um back in September after the summer definitely so keep that in mind as well we are we are keeping our
139ear to the ground on on oh my gosh all things Department of Education and we have looked into the grants and the federal impact so we do know what those dollar amounts would look like okay so I'm going to ask again any changes to the revenue section of Ed fund that anybody wants to make trying to catch everybody's see the whites of their eyes I guess that okay okay so expenditures are very consistent from Ed fund operations and maintenance and transportation they are following the CPI assumption for 2024 if except for um purchase services in transportation is 5% which is the increase for our BTC contract and then all of the out years I have tied to CPI remember a couple of years ago we did talk about um increasing the Assumption for transportation so
140I wanted to bring that to the group and see if that's something you wanted to see as well when we did that a couple of years ago we were seeing some pretty significant increase in the market for transportation and our contract was up um 26 is our last year so we'll be talking about a contract renewal in 26 for 27 with BTC and right now there's nothing indicating the significant increases that we were seeing a couple of years ago coming off of covid and increases to Staffing costs so we and as we did with our most recent renewal we will um do our best to align that with St are there still issues with hiring enough bus drivers or is that leveled out because that was a that was a concern right it was part
141of the cost of Transportation still an issue but it's we're able to we have enough drivers to do our routes every day okay because I know even some September or August that was like yeah we're not in a good place so that's okay that's good news and again we have a contract so it's yeah but if they can't find any drivers we an issue right that's I mean yeah their issue but yes well it affects us that becomes our issue it's kind of you know I don't that's true but we're one of the lucky districts we don't run the transportation like some of the other districts right I I I think it's more they're more sensitive than we need to be but yes we we don't want to put our heads in the sand either
142and know that it's issue so any questions around assumptions for expenditures any changes anybody wants to make just the clarification actually so I I I I understand that you're aligning the fund expenditures to CPI um were there is there anything driving that spend and that that would suggest we're going to just see increases there's no opportunity to look at what we're spending on and perhaps you know from a cash flow standpoint just deferring certain expenses we look at that every year of course if there's something that doesn't need to be done is there something else that needs to be done are there staffing needs that we have the creation of this was to get to the base model so that you could sort of see where we are with my Baseline assumptions and then we
143could make adjustments from there but are we doing a zero based budgeting at this point no this is what's getting us to the budgeting process which will then um lead to a lot more of those conversations if that yeah I'm just I'm just remember because at one point and I think it was maybe two years in a row um you know your team had committed to doing basically 0% increases but you're saying that was during the budget process after you've had several months to you know kind of determine what the you know needed elements are rather than I just don't recall if we did here the commit the whole if we did it budget meeting we did we did it here um either we came to you with a 0% because that was the only
144way for us to get a surplus that'll keep us within our fund balance or we made the decision here at the table to change the Assumption sure yeah I don't recall what the um driver was so okay so then we did possibly we did come at this meeting this is the meeting yes so then Jen essentially starts budgeting as the next of course I have a slide on what's next and sure one of those things is the 25 26 budget so this is really sort of day one of the board making some decisions to then drive the next steps for the budget creation okay so okay so this gets the Surplus all right is that okay well I guess I'll get to the next Pages all right no change for now then okay great okay
145so we can move into our forecast models so I have two models prepared for you the first model is a base model based on all of these assumptions that we just reviewed and you'll see at the top it's a little bit it's um justified in the middle of the page is our base model and it says base model at the top okay and this reflects what our fund balance would look like with this base model and of course the top and bottom line are reflecting the 25 to 40% which is our fund balance policy so taking a look at the first page that you have in your packet they're stapled together the second page is the um model that you're seeing on the screen you can see at the bottom of the page it's showing
146the fund balance as a percent of the expenditures that's not how we calculate our fund balance but it's rather close to the way that we do that so I left it in here so that you could see rather close to where we might be landing for 26 and Beyond so we are um still within our fund balance policy of 25 to 40% in the 5year forecast 29% is a comfortable place that the board has been over the last couple of years with some surpluses we have increased into the 30 range you can see that the Assumption on this page if all things remain equal would be that we're ending the FY 25 year um in the low 30% range again this these numbers on here are not exactly what it would be the calculation is
147a bit different but I left it on here just so that you could get a sense so you can see on the Surplus deficit including other Financial sources our projection for FY 26 based on these assumptions of where we would end uh or where we would prepare the budget to so I'm trying to remember your recommendation is that we sit right around 2930 for at the end of the 5year forecast that's ultimately where we want to be long term the middle of that around 30% is is what the board has been comfortable with over the last few years 30% 29 to 30% is where we have been for the last four years I believe so that's a place that we are comfortable being and you're assuming that the full Surplus goes right into the fund
148balance correct cuz in the past I think we've deed up a little bit some to Capital some to okay yes yes it's always going to be important that we're still maintaining the fund balance so yes if there if the Surplus was higher then maybe we would still have that opportunity I don't want to talk too much so please let me know question and let me know if you're ready I can move on to the second model I see some have taken a look at can you just comment on your base model why five years out we end up with a deficit sure that's pretty consistent to what we see in a fiveyear model it's it's um what FY 29 looked like in last year's 5year forecast is not what fy9 29 looks like in this
149fiveyear forecast same with FY 28 every year things are evolving our CPI assumptions are changing what CPI actually is is going to change there's a lot of things that might fluctuate any resource um reallocations that we might be doing is going to obviously affect the 5-year forecast in fy3 uh let me back up we have some um benefit of retirement Savings in the next couple of years fy3 we are just starting to get some of the notifications of retirees those aren't due until February 1st I think so that will impact fy3 I of course have an assumption in there but that could change as well so we we generally are seeing a a deficit in years four and five sometimes even three four and five and we we know that that's something that we're keeping
150an eye on but not to be alarmed it's helpful but not to be alarmed it's helpful for us in planning and knowing what's coming same thing with our capital projects anything looking five years out is helpful but what fy3 looks like now is probably not what fy3 is going to look like when we're sitting here together next year but it does give the board some indication of we're making some decisions today and if you want to look ahead those decisions are we flush at the end or are we trying to run it close to even or even a slight deficit that gets reflected in the curve that's why we see this okay any any questions on the base model you want to use an education term you can say eyes on me eyes on me
151of whites of their eyes like don't tell her that okay you know sand another one I've heard is uh any everyone who hear me clap twice yeah right that's up to you if you want to go there I was just trying to make sure sander was getting I want to make sure we're good response move on to the next so a question and you know surpluses are better than deficits but it it's you know millions of dollars and I know it's the percentage of the budget and that's a small percentage of the budget but as the you know know sensitivity question came up here with Steve you know I don't know I look at that and think you know is it it's better to break even closer but we also don't want to like guess
152wrong and then have a deficit well breaking even predict draw not guess well forecast the reality of any sort of assumptions and projections is you are making educated guesses of course to to to make that decision breaking even would reduce our fund balance and doing that multiple years in a row would be problematic to our fund balance and then we'd be having different conversations so we do need to maintain a surplus in order to even maintain our fund balance because it's a percentage of our Revenue so as our revenues are increasing every year your Surplus needs to increase every year in order to maintain your fund balance so if we were to have a0 Surplus $1 Surplus at the end of that year we'll have reduction in our fund balance okay that makes sense well
153I think your question though I think is a good one for the community as well since because since we're talking about it I mean I think another way of explaining this is if we look at the Assumption sheet the assumptions for fiscal 25 I'm sorry fiscal 26 carry out for five more years and there's really no I mean there's minor adjustments on certain elements but for most part they're pretty consistent and so I think the takeway is that without intervention you know all things being equal at as at the rate that our revenues increase it's lower than the rate at which our expenses are increasing so without you know us and the administration intervening and making adjustments this is where where where we're going but of course you know 5 years out it's very hard
154for us to say we're going to pull this lever we're going to pull that lever so it just stands to reason I think that by year five or in this case fiscal 20 I'm sorry fisal 30 we'll see this decline but hopefully within the next two years when we have fiscal author being only 3 years out we'll have them being at the same level that we have right now what we have at fisal 28 I think that's the way I'm viewing it yeah that's a great way to look at it and then you are hopefully still seeing a consistent fund balance even with those adjustments that made because I think your goal overall like while our Target is 2930 I mean it's pretty evident that even the base model here is showing 33 so you
155you want to have cushion to to keep us because that because right because that fun balance amount while the percentage is pretty stable the amount has to grow too right because it's a function of Revenue it does and this percentage is is a function of the expenditures whereas ours is revenue so it's it does operate just a little bit differently which makes it actually a little bit lower than the numbers that you're seeing here but still within our range still a comfortable place but I think Dr Brian used to say I'm your business manager I'm always going to um be conservative sure for you so of of course I'm certainly not going to recommend something that I believe is going to put us in a position that we are are not going to be able
156to pay for the commitments that we've made and and to continue operating The District in the way we want to so this base model assumes the two and a half to three million um for capital projects every year this base model assumes that we are issuing DB for FY 26 this does not do any reduction in the district's operating funds to put money into Capital so no no oh make sure that we all understand so no that's a great point I guess I didn't think that this two and a half to three this is if it was right so then the reality is our Surplus just using the base model as an example in fiscal 26 we have to find I guess between 1.2 to another 1.2 to two we need to deduct that from
157that Surplus is that right in order to fund at the level that we' discussed if you were to do no reallocation of resources and you were just to transfer money straight from the education fund that would reduce the Surplus correct okay so then and it would reduce theend balance the percent un balance percent mm so then what is that we took so so this does include those 3 million that we yes assumed would be going towards Summer project yes so this this assumes a 2.7 million D issuance and spending that 2.7 or three what so I guess if we want to get to five we going to be looking for 2 million somehow over a couple years so in 26 yeah the recommendation is not five but yes 4.2 so what is the recommendation so
158okay 4.22 okay is everybody comfortable with that guessing that's where we're going with this next model the next model actually is a concern I did not model that not knowing okay where we might be reality resources okay um the next model is a conservative assumption using a 0% increase on supplies purchase services and capital in the education fund okay so that's just what I was asking yep okay it's not that big of a change so that gets us$4,000 yeah like 300,000 this is still the two 2 and half to3 million correct this is yep mhm so I'm just ballparking it but just I'm sorry just going back to the base for a quick second um if we're just doing the straight line 61 I'm sorry no 62546 690 the the projected year ENT for fiscal
15926 and dividing it by the 191 that gets us 32.7 it is um not all fun that are used to do the calculation sure so it it um it'll be a little lower than the than the 33% I apologize I don't have the math okay I did a envelope it's certain funds for the revenue and then certain funds for the fund balance yeah no totally get it yeah I'm just doing back of the envelope just so we have some point of reference but if we were to take away two million bucks from that it still gets us to 31.7 so it's really just 1% or so so it's actually not that big of a lift I mean I guess that the question is how comfortable do feel losing that 1% I we you got there
160doing basically nothing it will be a reduction in the fund balance from year year so well but I'm saying no additional intervention at this stage right so if you went with the conservative assumption mhm and then made a projection of a $240,000 surplus is that what you're recommending 240,000 well I'm sorry or you're taking 1 million away so You' be a 1.2 million I took away 2 million actually so it comes down to 60 54 I'm sorry I'm looking at the um Surplus not the fund balance away then you ,000 Sur right uh just your 26 wait a minute I'm sorry where are you seeing 200,000 so in uh on the conservative assumption if you're looking at Surplus deficit including resources you have a $2.2 million surplus so just for clarification I am recommending a
161uh 1.3 million investment I'm sorry I don't have my note in front of me into um let me pull it up I'm recommending a $1 million additional investment for FY 26 so if you were to reduce that by $2 million right out out of the gate you would either be banking that for a future or you'd be adding on to that investment if if I I guess I just want to understand if DB for fiscal year 26 is 20 20 2.7 million and we want to get to 4.2 why are we not looking for 1.5 two it's 2.7 million plus the $500,000 in operations and maintenance that we invest each year so D was about 2.5 for many many years so we had 2.5 in DB and 500,000 in operations and maintenance so what we
162have not been doing over the years is as that's been escalating we have not been investing more to to sort of offset those dollars so I was taking of numers each year and escalating them by CPI which really should be part of our calculation so we can generally do more than the 3 million right out of the gate because we're factoring in the true value of DB plus the 500,000 from operations and maintenance Sarah's filling in a little bit of the Gap that has existed and being more specific with it in calulations than maybe what we've done more generally in the past we've been very consistent with the two and a half to three million number for many many years right this sort of helps us yeah escalate that so we've gone from 2.5 to
163zero on purchase Services yes I have two assumptions I have made some assumptions for things to escalate that we don't have control over such as food service or maybe our outplacement costs so this is not saying that all things in the Ed fund will remain at 0% because that is not possible for us but our essentially department and building budgets would remain at the 0% for purchase Services supplies and capital and and I know we've done 0% multiple years in the past I'm just wondering if a district can sustain that year after year when there is inflation paper for example you know I I don't want the teachers to say I can't give you a written test because we ran out of paper our paper budget is not or um so I just think we
164want to be careful that we don't cut too much in that category and maybe look at some other categories to help um you know allow us to to keep it comfortable you tell me are can we sustain another couple years of 0% on purchase services not including like you said food service and comfortably do that without jeopardizing our educational product that we're offering to our kids it's certainly challenging and we've talked a lot about CPI and how that increases year-over-year and our our value of a dollar is not what it was a number of years ago um we are we are making decisions that allow us to do that and we would continue to do did you want to oh you're we would continue to make decisions based on what is a available to us
165to spend it it is certain certainly challenging as we've talked about the value of a dollar only continues to increase sorry so where's the 0% in purchase I'm saying so 2.2 to 5 1.5 am I looking at the wrong thing the two different models CL you have to look at the purchase service line there right the purchase service it goes from 29628 to 29405 for example and then the next line down goes 8695 to 8561 I right so the deduction does it we're not it doesn't go to zero though right or just well it's the growth it's the growth oh the growth oh oh I see okay and as I mentioned I did account for a number of things that we need to account for increases on so that we aren't reducing someone else's budget
166we're not wiping it out Aon we're just not letting it grow got it right and you can see the differences in the percentages too yeah right in the two models right okay so again so the growth is zero we're not adding to it sorry I'm so sorry explain no it's it's a lot make sure that questions clarify but any of the decisions we made right there's an impact and I just want to clarify that you know when we make one decision there is an impact it's I think what you meant was it's maybe a manageable impact Barry you asking a question can we sustain that impact we're all trying to you know work through ways to look at our model to meet all these different needs that we've identified in our community has also identified
167for us to be mindful of so with the 0% growth get us the 1 million that we're looking for no no it's like 400,000 okay yeah I'm just curious so the philosophy that 220 has as relates the budgeting is is more of a top down approach right so we in this room effectively create the budget and then we kind of push it down to the individual schools and they're basically they basically need to correspond with that is that correct um yeah I guess I would phrase it just a little bit differently the board establish its policies that then inform our budgeting process so like we've been talking about that expectation that's dri like fund balance expectation that's derived from decisions the board past board has made and this current board has reinforced that same expectation
168and that is in policy that we need to be at those levels the board always reserves the right Steve to revisit those policies or maybe change those practices and then we would take that new information and build it into the models tonight is US using those available decisions that boards have made but um that's how we're building the budget collabora between I would say it's more collaborative uh the administration and board working together to find the right combination that meets the goals yeah that we've identified well Barry just said something that sparked something in me um you know I'll just take it offline with you okay okay okay all right so this base model gets us to roughly 400,000 of the the conservative model conserv sorry so we would need to find conserv I conserv
169we need another right to get to the we would need to look for another 600k to get to the 1 million is that okay maybe not understanding I thought it was a it was a bigger number from when we started with without he it's only it's only 1.2 incremental is what we're trying to find because we already have the established three or two and a half three that's the D oh well Ino yeah okay because we have we're starting with 3.2 right with the 2.7 million in d sub plus the 500,000 yes and so then to get to 4.2 we only need a million so then we' have the 400k with 0% growth so we'd be looking for 600 correct yep unless of course we want to hit 5 million in which case then we're
170looking for then you're looking for yeah for more Leo the number is bigger as it's compounding okay all right but 4.2 is our starting five years you want to find a lot more money okay okay because I was yeah I was thinking the 1.5 to two is what we needed to find okay I was too until until all right so and and yes each year right each year is growing and each year you're needing those numbers so cter pounding well I think you should also take into account that that $5 million today is going to be worth less than five years so in other words if we do you know three equal siiz projects this year that those same three projects in five years is going to be you know find a little more that's
171why we need to keep finding a little bit more now what actually help that's a good point no that's a very very good point yeah because the more we do now the less we have to do tomorrow but 4.2 is the FY 26 starting point I think that's the if I read the if I Rec from like that's the yeah recommended starting point right and with a conservative model we need 600,000 thank you and so are we are we asking the administration to go and find make some recommendations on that 600,000 yeah can we I would say can we find between 600 and 1.4 since that's the other 800 to get to that's the 5 mil that's assuming that we're going 0% I I still I mean when we talked about maybe going instead of
1722.5 going to 1% or something still giving them a little bit of of leeway on their purchase services so so hearing them I hear you but what I'm hearing them say I was looking at their whites at their eyes we were talking if anybody yeah to see if anybody struggling they're they're telling us Barry that they with this conservative no one has a concern is this true I guess I was looking I was guess I was you have no concern I was looking over there so no I I I I was looking at Sarah so I guess I didn't look at the whites of their eyes my God so weird s this is weird no I just want to hear that you know that's a fair question I just don't want to tie your hands
173I want to make sure have some freedom to be creative and and and you know not not say no to people um when you really want to say yes I mean obviously you're going to have to say no to to keep a budget but you know where in your heart you're like yeah I really want to give it to you but I can't because the board's tied my hands and I'm not trying to words your mouth but I guess I do want to hear that you feel like it's okay to to keep it at zero Barry we we made the recommendation um to the the board with the B with the conservative model I almost did it too sorry um the base conservative with the understanding that yes we can do that in our budgeting
174today right as I said earlier it's manageable but there are some downsides to it but it's manageable to answer your question so can we do it I mean these are hard conversations they're hard for our staff to answer too but we understand that there are compe needs of where are we building the budget to flow our dollars um you know our responsibility and charge from the board back in August was figure out a way for us to have all the information available to to budget plan so this is the board's opportunity to inform us um with that direction um we're not trying to be koi or evasive I think I said there's a there's impact and some of those impacts are negative but that it's manageable I think I speak for a team we've spent
175six months preparing this um trying to give information uh for the board so we wouldn't bring a conservative model that we didn't believe we could live with there's no perfect I wish there was perfect where I'm like that I could really believe what maybe Steve's comment earlier of like oh we can just we can we can go that direction there's always going to be some trade-offs there's no way to avoid that um in these conversations well and if we can cut costs with with that viewpoint on that topic and not you know be talking about programs and staff that's where the board has directed you I believe in the past that let's save money on pencils and still you know keep a lot of staff and a lot of programs and it's and keep the
176buildings good I mean it's an impossible ask but it is impossible but we're trying to figure out how to shift costs really we're still working with those dollars we're shifting them to meet different needs that have been identified and I think the need we're trying to to discuss and figure out is this need of we're not funding our ongoing facility needs at the rate that we need to right right so there are going to be adjustments there's going to there's going to be but manageable I guess is the only way to say it because it's not favorable we don't as ad you know as the administration but it's manageable the reality is this a yearly budget so if in a year we are sitting here and they're like it's not working we my back in
177yeah we need more growth we will definely we have to adjust something else bring that to the board for consideration well yeah that's a great point I mean there there are you know midyear adjustments that soon be made because if you know there's a there's a burning demand for something I'm sure we'll have to authorize it from your from your guys' standpoint and then we'll just have to find an opportunity elsewhere that happens to of course but I mean you know if one of the operating units goes over budget so be it right I mean as long as well and I like I see where var's concerned locking in for five years I get you're I get what you're saying but I guess done the last couple years too so it's I guess in my
178mind can you address that it doesn't have to be so keep it's not for five years right it's only for one it's only for one year and the savings is the compounding from this year's decision so the assumptions assume an increase in all of these areas to a lineless CPI each year in the remaining years okay right so this is a one you're not deciding tonight it's zero increase for five years you're deciding zero increase for next year but I think my six years on the board I think we've already done this I mean we we've picked on this topic and we you know maybe there are others we could look at and and again I but again I defer to our Administration if you guys say we can do it that's I I'm not
179going to fight the battle yeah and it's not I just feel like this is what we pick each time and and at some point it's like we need these supplies we need these purchase Services we can't keep you know holding the line on that when there may be other areas where we might be able to hold the line for a year or two so I'm just well just trying to play devil's advocate well Barry if it makes you feel better if I'm look at the presentation right I mean we're talking about 300 call $400,000 on so we're really it's $100,000 of the total expense but when we look at purchase services and and supplies and other that's you know in excess of looks like about $40 million in total cost so really impacting I'm sorry
180not 100,000 a million dollars worth of that $40 million everything else is still growing or increasing with contracted rates or other assumptions right yeah and it's more like 50 million more those mhm oh I'm sorry cuz you have to all other objects to right of course a piece of that is transportation which I have in sure um so so yeah I mean it's like a million dollars of that 50 thank you and to Dr wilman's point we we have been talking about this for a long time and we had agreed as a team that we wouldn't bring anything forward that that we couldn't manage so I I prer to the administration we may not have this recommendation next year but right now this is something that we're comfortable I just want to emphasize too it's
181not exactly zero I know it's hard to every it's following along but it's not exactly zero it's zero where you can take the zero it's it's a zero where Sarah is accounting for there is still growth right in that category yes but we're trying to use that as a general yep guine so Steve you threw out um asking the administration to come back with 600 to 1.4 million um is everybody is everybody good with that kind of a range and then there's a couple things that we talked about last year I just want to review again make sure we're I see we've got our our uh class size in here want to talk about that a little bit there are other if now I'm getting greedy I guess but uh if we're going to do
182this anyways I mean why don't we have a stretch goal too and I don't know what that stretch goal is but if if our range is one I'm sorry 600 of 1.4 I don't know can I just I'm just throwing out a number can we propose a stretch goal being 2 million is everybody willing to do I I mean I'm indifferent to what it could be 1.5 I don't I'm I'm just throwing out a number what number gets us there again 1 Point 600 600,000 so six wait 600 to 1.4 would put us at 4.2 to 5.6 right no 500 500 five I'm sorry 5 million 4.2 to million because it's the additional 800,000 oh okay if that's all you if we don't want to do stretch that's fine too I'm just throwing out an
183idea I'll just mention as we continued to look at the budget and what makes up the budget you know this is one opportunity that is a non-programmatic impact yes as we continue to evaluate our options that may not mean that way sure right I'm most comfortable with the 600 1.4 okay I likeed your range do we does anybody want to go deeper to have us go deeper I'm sure if you find something starting point sure I think 1.4 is a good good goal you get there comfortably can we and you said we could maybe do that through non-programmatic no no no I'm saying that you expl this is a non-programmatic already but yes the deeper of course we're getting into Cuts based on our budget and what makes our budget we're getting into programmatic you're
184just saying the 0% growth on purchase Services is obviously non programmatic right yes okay but not necessarily the 600 to 1.4 correct so I'm taking notes trying to follow the conversation MH so what I'm hearing is we've identified the conservative model of a 0% calculated uh zero growth in that category 400,000 earlier tonight as we were starting the conversation we had a discussion around what's the target number we're looking for we're looking for another 600,000 to to get us to a million however the board is giving direction of can you actually look at a range between 600,000 and 1.4 we're not going to two just so that I've got clear direction of the work that our team is going to put together is that accurate oh I on Craig get us to a 4.2 to
185five million range I don't know why I did that math all wrong but yes tops out at five I'm go about it I'm just proposing an idea since we're all here talking about it if we want to try and get a little more cushion for FAL 27 because we'll work hard to meet whatever guidance we get tonight from the board this is about the board's ability to make some preliminary budget decisions to then help guide and we'll work hard to do the work uh to meet that expectation I I like 1.4 being the top B but I'm not opposed Steve if we because we're just looking right I don't I'm not opposed to seeing it higher to see what it would look like then we have a broader range if it makes other people really
186uncomfortable to go above 1.4 well the reason I say stretch is because you know with what comes back you know respectfully you might have you know a half million dollars of expenses in there that we're like no way we can do this right you're saying us more options give us two million of options and we can hopefully come up with 1.4 that's reasonable and not going to you know maturely impact what we're doing here that's why I say that but otherwise like I said I'm not you know pushing that hard today what a different way to ask be to say does the board want to consider programmatic options or do we want to not I think we're already going to have to consider programmatic options I guess and to Steve's point I don't want to
187not consider a $1.4 million change because you guys come back with only 1.4 million and we all agree we don't like one of the things on there yeah whereas if we have maybe two million worth of choices we could eventually get to 1 million or 1.4 million did you say what I'm saying or even 1. I don't care 1.6 well and we have that low range too so that when we see it if we say oh wait we want to stop at 600,000 that's an option too I'm okay with 600 to two but if we could see that range like the 600 the 1.4 and the two that would be help is next qu meetings in two weeks is two is that enough time or you going to need more time to get to 2
188million well to be clear to get to 2 million or to get to 1.4 or to get to 600,000 we need more direction from the board tonight we need to understand where the other categories you want us to consider and so forth um because our team has worked hard to try to get us to this point and provide information um but I need more direction from the the board tonight to understand where are we spending our our time in other words we've spent last half an hour 45 minutes talking about non-programmatic adjustments there are other categories that one of which was already mentioned do we want to look at programs right do we want to look at class sizes and you know those those other categories I need some direction from the board tonight okay
189so how can we talk about class sizes let's put a pin in our 1.4 to to two for a second okay and um talk about classes because last year we talked about um making uh you know Staffing to our guidelines but allowing I can't remember how we phrase it last year but allowing a bit more red right red being red being more over sections that are above the guidelines that we use as far as the range of number of students and sections across the the district yes but within our contractual obligations 100% we're meet we're going to meet our contract obligations and we're going to look at those guidelines of class ad yeah right so last year we said no we're going to stay let's continue to staff to guidelines so is the board um
190have that same um thoughts the two that are here is there a difference between the two yeah Tina would you um sorry Dr River would you mind um sharing the resources in the folder on the top I need my glasses for this there's at the top that gray bar we'll talk about sections section and the other one is just the projected traditional so I'm sorry so one is so the traditional projected does not have just as usual Staffing two guidelines that's yeah yeah tradition when you see that it's a gray box at the top the title says traditional the one says projected I had to put my glasses on to read it so okay so look so the traditional is as it has been so Staffing to guidelines that's right and then the other one
191is um possibly would be above guidelines but below with the contract yeah we would stay within the contract right we're going to honor the contract but we would staff differently using our guidelines okay let everybody absorb that for a moment ex you see I'm looking it's a few more red but not doesn't it's not catastrophic correct there would still even by Staffing um differently for next year um there are still a number of of sections in the blue is just the way that we note sections that exist that are under our guidelines um several still in guidelines but it it would increase um a small number of sections that would go over the established guidelines okay green and I'm sorry Kaden green is what green highlight is what just over plus one right additional section
192oh additional the number of sections is increasing EUR right gotcha yellow initial sections are decreasing EUR thank you you know just for the benefit of those listening can you Dr winman um mention um um you know what would Trigger or or what would what would make it so that we would bring in an aid or something along those lines yeah we have a mechanism in place again through the contract um do you want to yeah it would be 29 students okay which I don't see any yeah which I yeah I was say I don't see any I I hear either actually again keeping within the contract right but of9 triggers another section right that no triggers possibly an aid an an a oh an aid okay um but of course Administration has the discretion to
193say well we have a need based on filling the blank and so even it's 28 we can add an aid we always have that discretion and keep in mind we're looking at projections for next year on January 21st every year we're monitoring this between now and August 20 um and we may make adjustments along the way this spring as well as during the summer months um you know this this current year we added sections even into the summer because we were seeing some enrollment growth and they got too too big for uh at C at certain schools and at certain grades so I just need General guidance of we try to get give you an example sure knowing this is going to change like what we see tonight kids are going to move out kids
194are going to move in we're going to continue to Monitor and manage that but I need some general guidance tonight you can see kind of a an example of what if we changed that assumption a little bit what that would look like uh for our district and I just need some direction of Are We pursuing that do you want our administrative team to to use that that board Direction tonight do you have a ballpark of what this financial impact is um that's okay just curious yeah we could probably ballpark it I was looking for a totalu our current 75,000 what is our I'm I'm not gonna I'll do it for you 85,000 with a four it's like 300,000 so 340 is yeah I mean that's half the equation Y and that's this is just looking
195at one level as an example what we could do we could look at that across levels using the guidelines across middle and high school as well the board wants to give us that direction well I mean I don't know maybe the guidance should be we obviously we have our preferences on what we want to limit it to um but should we just raise any restriction on the administration so they can just you know hit the ground running and see what they can find I think I think he's asking I think he's asking are we comfortable this could if this if this was one of the or be comfortable with Staffing um at the guidelines but within the contract so yeah I think the answer is yeah right say well I want to make sure without
196restricting Administration to say we have to because I feel like that's you know if the last four years have taught me anything it's when you put too many constraints on you don't get the result you want well last year we put a constraint here so this is different sure just want to make sure that we've got four people that are willing to to look at this level of Staffing yeah with respect to the guidelines I mean you me I I hear one you me THB across Elementary Middle we could yeah you have Elementary as an example it's a typical sheet we have at meetings and we're going to continue to bring something like this back but I think the guidance would be helpful if we knew across level so this is not reducing programming at
197this point this is this is um optimizing optimizing our staff to the guidelines within the constraints of the contract do we have four thumbs up to look at this across all levels I mean just keep in mind we're not committing to it it's just a matter of looking at look at it I want to look at it I'm willing to look at it so I count one two three okay okay um can I make a suggestion let me ask one more question while we're still looking at this I still see some blue right that's on here yeah um are we okay with looking at other avenues to um um you know reduce the amount of blue blue being under the guidelines right if there's any Creative Solutions we can get to um to move the
198blue to Black like basically basically move the blue to Black if there's any way to do it I don't know if there is or not but I I had thrown out when I was talking to Craig like a multi-grade kind of option which that would get North barington did frequently when my kids were in school so just wait what what is it what would you suggest so a multi-grade um are just district has utilized other districts have utilized um you do a four five combination classroom so teacher would be assigned students at two grade levels not saying we're doing five just before everyone runs out says four five I'm giving it as an example I know that we have done that as a district in the past there's a lot of considerations that go into
199that we would start with just looking do the numbers make sense but then we would also want to ask and look at a lot more depth to that of do we have staff at that building that have familiarity with the curriculum for those two grade levels and experience working with you know what I mean like there's some there's a lot more work that needs to get done but if the board is giving us dire give us more flexibility we can take a look at it is everybody comfortable with that I would say across you know across all districtwide programs across all grade levels CU everybody come looking at those options options to move more blue to Black basically mhm yeah I'm hear I'm seeing at least one at least four heads oh yeah okay it's
200helpful guidance thank you board for both of those so as we're looking at just general overall categories to look for 600 to 1.4 to two we're probably backing off that now this is I know I know well that's why I said hey we're not done yet tonight I need a little more direction from the board in order to to know what's in bounds and out of bounds and we'll bring op we'll bring options to you but this this is helpful are there any more guard rails that you want together this evening you know I think another category we've talked about during the committee of the whole in the past is our programs and the size of our programs do we want to use the same parameters and logic around District programs should also utilize the
201same guidelines that we use at our different grid levels and so forth meaning District programs whether they're at elementary middle or High School those programs in the size of the student enrollment those programs should also be in line with the established guidelines for all sections that we use again this is just highle gu I would say yes I would I would say yes I would too me I think we we um we should hold all to the same all programs to the same level and we're just looking for now nothing concrete right yeah did you see thumbs do you want to see more thumbs are you nervous I don't know if we're at four are we at four are we at four Mr look at the guidelines often yep okay all right thank you board
202I appreciate that that's helpful for us to know these are options we can work within and I want to I want to reassure the board you know we're going to do the due diligence we're going to look at this carefully um you know and we're GNA continue to monitor it right and bring that feedback back so I don't want the board to be concerned that we're so locked in that we can't look at these things right now so I mean let's just take high school as an example there's sure there's only three people interested in underwater basket weeding right right we cool um you know we have traditionally not offered that course then if we if the enrollment is too low so if we see trends like that um look for ways to or maybe
203it could be done through the virtual high school so you know there's options possibility that's a good point Barry that we could look for other options like a virtual learning experience for our students if the board is comfortable with that we could also look for other ways uh to adjust the way we deliver that program than a traditional inperson sign you know to a teacher role in a classroom especially for sections that only have three students in underwater B sounds really interesting I know I want to take that class never heard of it but sounds cool and board we okay if we look for options that may consist of that yeah have a new as well you know what I was going to suggest too is you know having spoken to folks in this industry
204um you know rather than finding ways to reduce expenses can we find ways to increase Revenue so you know for example you know you know our website for example is really really nice I mean why can't we just do what Google does and say you know if you want to pay us to put a b your you know Banner on top so that it says you know shop at X Y andz store I me that might be a way to get a couple hundred, a year I mean that was one thing that came came through to me as a recommendation there were others like I don't know if we if we engage our staff on grants but maybe if we you know provided a stien to a faculty member and said if you were to
205pursue this grant this District would take a piece of it you would take a piece of it for your purposes something along those lines but I mean there are you know ways for us to generate Revenue I mean we already have some of them right like you know we have marketing at our football stadium I can we find some of those examples without you know of course um you know making us like a soccer jersey right with all the other with all the uh yeah there's things but but something along those lines could we I think we can generate I would think we'd be able to generate hundreds thousands a few million over over a 5-year period doing something along those lines so what we could do is we could look at the boards existing
206policies around advertising and marketing because we do have and actually we we updated that a few years ago years ago as a community and we did expand some in some areas where we didn't traditionally offer those opportunities you know we now have Steve to your point more physical ways to generate we also have like in-game advertising announcements we have digital display boards we have different mechanisms that 20 years ago we weren't having those conversations so if the board is interested our team could look for some additional opportunities again we would need to have the board consider updating maybe some policy language to reflect those changes Sarah were you gonna add something sure I can comment on grants uh last year we received the 2 million for PFA so we that is certainly something that we
207are invested in I will just comment that a competitive Grant is incredibly hard to write sure and does take a significant amount of staff time to do so and we don't have as large of a free and reduced population as maybe some grants would be looking for so that often can impact us but we do like get the pi Grant and a number of other things that help with um staff supplies and things like that so that's something that we are exploring that in a way that we can manage great yeah no I have no doubt that yeah you guys looked into I'm just saying are there other opportunities that perhaps we've you know deferred in the past maybe we look at it now because I mean the Educators we have are fantastic and I'm
208sure if we engage them you know I'm Sorry Miss sberry and her team maybe they they'd have folks that would be willing to engage um and I have a couple other ideas too that have been Shar with me that I can throw you away as well just something you said is spk my memory too like if we're going to increase revenues in some areas I think we talked about this a little bit we when we updated the policy last that could take some more staff to to do that as well so we might increase expenses so I just want to make sure that that we're not completely blind to that um um no I mean I I think I mean I'll just tell you another idea that come my way is you know we have
209I'm just using our our School Countryside we have a gymnasium maybe we can rent it out on the weekends when kids aren't using it and granted it would require you know somebody to go and let folks in maybe we'd have to hire a clean company but if you build into the cost of the um lease cost you know perhaps you can still make a margin on it I mean it's we do that we do do that we have a policy for that as well sure what I'm saying is just can we do that more so sure I mean we can I mean I I know for example I but we can actively right pursue be seeing if there's any other interest or appetite in the community for space space I mean I know we have
210excess space in certain areas too I mean it's going to sound kind of crazy but you know maybe we can offer like Verizon or Sprint or somebody to or to put up a cell tower in one of the one of the back areas that's the least cost that we can andc we do nothing nothing for that except the cost or except the space that taken I think there are like I said dozens of ideas that have been thrown my way that we could Matt I know we've expanded with Verizon I believe school and also at northton yeah so we've we've done two examples of that great Steve as well absolutely these are all good ideas and some we've already done and some we want to increase yeah we out there anticipating with the new Auditorium
211that we will probably be able generate some rental dollars there because we have more freedom to use it on more days or weeks or whatever so let me ask this question if the administration comes back and says oh gosh I'd love to do this but we need to add staff are we willing to look at increases in expenses in order to augment increases in Revenue I think the caveat for me is as long as we can have more in collections than expenses of course of course otherwise I I'm assuming you wouldn't bring It Forward no right yeah I mean I have no problem like increasing our cost profile as long as we have an offset and plus some yeah we want to see a positive gain yeah well we want to keep in mind our
212primary focus is education we're not you know advertisers we're not marketers sure you know we want our staff focusing on that right we don't want to cheapen the product well that's why I bring up that it cost us money to to gain that money so that's where I might be uncomfortable like if it means that you know if we reducing some kinds of Staff while bringing on other kinds of Staff be a little bit I might be a little sish so I think we'd have to be really careful well but but I think to your point too I mean I think another consideration and this is actually a expense increase too but sometimes it's more cost efficient to bring bring certain services in house versus buying it and I don't know what those are that's
213obviously something you guys need to evaluate but I don't know I'm just thinking for like my business it made more sense for us to hire our own custodian versus you know using a third party because even with Benefits it was cheaper to have someone in house because then then we can allocate that individual to other you know sites that we had so I don't know I'm just putting that up there as an idea are there and again I know you guys do this but are there other things that we can consider that we're not doing right now sorry this just can I I'm asking more of this clarification because I get asked this a lot through the community and I but like when we host an ihsa sports event and we have to pay tickets
214like I know especially with playoffs and stuff we do not get all that money correct and I think right definitely the community thinks that we do uh like with football games and basketball G clarication money goes back to the organization um and I think that's a very big misconception over and that we're also being forced to charge yeah like very clear unfortunately we can't make money on that Steve sorry maybe not that but someone else right no but I it's it's un unfortunate I mean I love the fact that we rent or we utilize phhs for the nter every year I mean I don't know how much we make there but are there other opportunities like that we run out like the station stage at cafeteria to local monasa who want to have plays there
215oh was that right that's cool I didn't know that yeah so I don't know just if there's any if there's any excess fre I'm not sorry capacity for that I think you know maybe not with two weeks but some sometime in the next you know 12 months something for us to look into okay because I don't think any of these need to be you know next two weeks type deals I think a lot ofies are probably going to take some research and have some phone calls quite frankly this is this is good information as we're doing our annual budget planning for us to look for areas again to allocate our resource to meet all of our needs in the different categories right and I'm very intentionally saying that I mean I do worry about what
216we have terms like cost cutting and stuff like that this is about budget planning this is about allocation of resources because we're shifting some dollars from one area to the other like we do with everything we're always evaluating our needs and where those monies can be best served so it is important I think we've identified a number of categories that that helps an Administration then with Direction interest and desire of the board we've also identified a few areas where our Administration will go back and look to see if there's any Revenue generators as well um that maybe help us I just I'm looking at our framework 220 here I keep looking over there and I'm like wow we've asked a lot of this Administration already and we've got a referendum um that we're um embarking
217on um for Bill 220 we ended up having to augment the staff a little bit so I I I want to make sure that we think about that too and if we need to do any augmentation for transform 220 we consider that as well um but I I want to see some thumbs up from the from the board if that's okay to go that direction as well I'm sorry s say it again what what is your ask for Bill 220 we added some staff we add some temporary staff right to help us get through so because we've got framework 220 we've got now transform 220 um now we're talking about marketing Revenue like like we we're adding on adding on um I just want to make sure that we're cognizant of that right I see
218and what's our Focus Leah you brought it up like what what's our core competency here and I think that's what we're talking about with framework 220 too it so yeah no and I appreciate you bringing that up yeah no I mean I agree I think our goal though is whatever cost savings we generate or additional Revenue we you know we you know are able to collect it's all going to go back toward towards the students and the Educators right but you know but it can distract yes it can distract I mean people ask me in my everyday life oh you know should I sell my house buy a different house and rent the old house and and I'm like well what's your day job and you know they might say oh I'm a doctor and
219I work 80 hours a week and I'm like do you really want to be a landlord too and you know what's your primary focus so it's that's that's where I'm coming from with that it's like know that's a great idea but how much time do you have in your day right and what's our Focus here you make you make a good point and I and I think this is again something that I I know I've done in my private life and I I don't know how the rest of the board feels about this but you know I've hired chief administrative officers in the past and said you need to your job is to do X Y and Z so so if the focus of the administration is education and you know educator management that's fine
220I have no problem if you hire I I this is me speaking for myself I would have no problem you hiring an expert in marketing and pay them whatever the market rate is for that marketer provided that the marketing Revenue they bring in is projected to be something something greater than that because any incremental they bring in would still benefit the students and the Educators in their District I I understand I just I just want to make sure we're we're continuing to focus on framework 220 which we've already committed to we've already focused on transform 220 which this community just asked us to to focus on um if there's any other things we need to consider as you're looking at these reductions I also want to be able to consider any any additional staff that
221might be needed as well to get us through that yeah bring that forward I think that's fair whether it be whatever be yeah I S with there I think that's fair because you know I don't think anybody who is hired to be a marketer right so I mean if if we need to bring in something outside to do it provided that they can cover their costs right I think we're talking about two different Steve talk talk about different thing you're talking about the same thing right it's part of it but I think what you're also alluding to is that the common phrase you know we can do anything we can't do everything agre and to Sandra's point we have a lot this is maybe one of the busiest times in the last decade for our
222district that I can recall where we have a successful referendum and all the work that entails a successful referendum at the same time that we've launched probably one of arguably our more holistic ambitious great word Barry uh strategic plans with 28 objectives and we're still working through all the things deliver on the promise to our community of rigorous academics in safe and inclusive environments right and so when you take all those things I appreciate you pointing out there are some needs for us to make sure that we're focused on those we can pick up some other bottom line is the bandwidth of your Administration is is maxed right now I don't want to constraint and say you can't look at marketing ideas but I would I I personally would want us to prioritize what we've
223already have on our plate first sure but if you tell me that that's fine you can then I'm all yours no and that's why I was no I was reiterating our bandwidth is is very very uh tapped right right now to meet all these competing things and continue to get green check marks that are not just done for done sake but actually done well um yeah you're getting a lot of mileage not just a check not a black check but a green check no I really mean it it's it's good but it's a it's a good product it's going to benefit the district for years to come like some of the things we've been able to accomplish like full day kindergarten new programming models for our students a long range facility planning tool like those
224things that's high quality like and it's accomplishing what we set out to do at a certain point that's going to diminish if we keep adding I mean to answer your question I think it is wise right to see I think if we're maxing out on the bandwidth and we need to also take on transform 220 which is like super exciting like we talked about I think it would be wise to look at you know some like more resources if we need to bring people on I think at the same time we also need to be really um clear with our timing and our messaging um because I can see some push back with folks saying at the same time you're considering bringing folks on to help you're also considering things like class sizes that you
225know that could cause staff adjustments as well and so I think that you know we just need to be really thoughtful about it and and clear to our community as we're kind of thinking through these things yes well said agreed yeah semi unrelated question in the past I thought we had somebody in the administration that was kind of responsible for grant writing do we not have somebody who's who's who's part of their job description is grant writing I'm just asking they write the grants that we have so they're not necessarily writing for new grants not that we don't from time to time but we have a number of grants that need that we've received the IDE Grant all of our title grants we then have to write for those okay if that makes sense but
226yeah the writing and and management in terms of the expenditure reports yes all of our that is done in house we have earned and received several competitive grants over the last several years including but not limited to the freedom schools grant that Sunny Hill received including our a incentive Grant through isby and our three circles Grant through ISB so that is work that we are constantly exploring and committed to doing but we forget about the second half where you have to report back how you went how you follow through right and there's work with that yeah time and that's part that we don't think about got it we don't really think about that it go yeah good point can I throw another idea um since we're going on the topic of um you know our
227core which is obvious education I know I I had run this by you at the beginning of the year somebody asked this question but why don't we allow is is there a is there a regulatory or a law that prohibits us from allowing students from mide District to come and have them pay a market tuition it's generated by our policy um that we for being a resident of our community um I think with that as well we just had a long conversation about class sizes there's an impact you collect that money right that feels good because we now have more Revenue but there is the management of that and I think yeah you know we have a high quality product that may be desirable we'd have to think that through all the way as to
228how do we manage and continue to maintain paying our class sizes at the same time that I don't know I'm I'm going to brag about our district I think that may be something that would generate a lot of Revenue but also generate a lot of interest and generate a lot of students and I don't know if we're equipped to to actually manage that or that we have facilities that could significantly increase um in order to meet that demand I'm not saying it's impossible but there may be we could be selective right I mean granted it's just an elementary roster here but there are quite a few that are below below guideline I mean and if we just said hey you know what you don't have a choice you have you must go to this Elementary
229and you must provide your transportation and if we charge I'm make up a number but we we're saying the cost per student is 20 grand maybe we factor in a reasonable markup I I don't know I feel like that could be a opportunity if we get 10 15 20 kids to fill in these gaps we do allow for some school right we do um but we don't make money on summer school I'm just I'm just saying another thing that we talked about the last couple of years is um the law that change allows us for our staff to bring their kids here as well and we we agreed not to do that at this point in time sure um you know for for same kind of reasons right yeah a project of that scale would
230we just got to have a conversation about what are we focused on what's our bandwidth yeah so you're saying that would be a very complicated that would be a very complicated and I would not want to rush that because if you're going to offer that and bring kids into the district I believe you honor your commitments and we'd have to commit to that so I'd want to really make sure we've got a welldeveloped well thought out plan uh in order to meet that expectation and be able to sustain the expectation and like I said I'm not opposed to it it's not part of our framework objectives there's no restrictions around sports with it I can see that opening up a huge it there's that there's so many it's going to be a recruiting thing honestly
231use the Expression you pull that thread you get the whole sweater uh and there's a lot to all of those pieces it's cold outside sweater on right so I'm not opposed to it but I that would really I think take a lot of um time to get it right uh to introduce new students to to our district I would say that would have to come out of a strategic discussion even right the next framework 220 or what have you and I would want to do a serious Community engagement on that too I think the board would if we look at how we make those type of scale decisions usually that yeah our process has been an advisory committee we're not we're not right now planning to do any of that because we have little less
232than half of the objectives still to go with framework so I like the idea Steve I just I want to be honest with the board that yeah no and that's fine I'm not I'm not saying these are things again we need do in two weeks or even just mons see I mean we just passed this awesome referendum and I I see enrollment changing and keep finding myself thinking about you know what what this it's even more of a destination destination District you're saying in starting in 28 no I think people are smart enough to know starting now right we've just improved on every one of our facilities right and we're going to improve them even more and there's some subdivisions that are happening in our district that's a great Point yeah some new ones that
233are popping up yeah but that did come up in policy that question of do we allow staff's uh children to come and that's exactly why we didn't Advance it to the full board because it could we did we did talk about it the board we did talk about it yeah but we we decided not to but we decided not to right for the same kind it unravel so much it is and there's lots of really good ideas just not right now um maybe later maybe through another strategic planning initiative right um for our District's needs may also change so I just want to be I mean I always want to say yes but there are certain things want to make sure that the board understands it's a heavy lift but if you want us to
234invest that that type of time and energy I would really need to work with the staff to understand that so and it's great to brainstorm Steve eny things out there it's cool yeah I mean there something that Barry and I talked about that we wanted to bring to finance at some point so I know they're talking about it now all right so I'm going to circle back to our 600 to 1.4 okay are we wanting to ask for more than 1.4 but all the the things that we just discussed I'm I'm seeing do you guidance if we were to go to two or could we could we stop at where we gave what we gave you I believe we have enough guidance tonight with what was provided for our team to go back and actually
235look to see examples in areas I'm not doing enough napkin math right now there's no Aaron but I could our team could work on that and I could get I could get that back to the board so what do we want to leave here saying at least 1.4 but if you if you'd like to go further we in interested in hearing more is that a good way to put a okay yeah yeah okay fair I know it's been a long day I'm looking for some thumbs that's great good okay I can take my glasses off the good one all right all right okay Sarah let's see have you reached your final slide I'm G to take it home okay oh yes I I should have added another uh bullet now that we were talking so
236I will will update the Assumption sheet to reflect the conservative base model that we have landed on I will um finalize the model as is for now and then as we offer some different options for you to consider I will then finalize the model again once those decisions are made uh Jen and I will begin the 2526 budget planning process and then Nicole will work on Capital recommendation for summer of 26 and the final budget we do in what September y so you'll see a tenative in uh July Well Finance will see it in July and then the whole board will see it in August better bring us up okay all right um thank you board for the guidance great discussion thank you board um I'm not going to ask for adjournment because we do
237need to go back into Clos session we don't anticipate taking any further action or having any further discussion we will come back to the room to check to make sure nobody's here but with that are we ready to go back to close board yes yes all right thank you all very much thank you thank you good discussion yes