CorpusRecord 208442

January 27, 2025 - School Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / ISD624
Date
2025-01-31
Location
Ramsey County, MN
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,798 words · about 94 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001- I'll call this meeting of the School Board Independent School District 624 to order. I'll ask the clerk to call the roll. - Skaar. - Here. - Streiff Oji. - Here. - Thompson. - Here. - Arcand. - Here. - Beloyed. - Here. - Daniels. Here. - All right. Our first item tonight is B.1. Mr. Wall, the fiscal year 2023-24 annual audit report. - Thank you. Annually, the district contracts with our public auditing firm of Malloy, Montague, Karnowski, Radosevich & Co., MMKR, to complete the annual audit for the school district finances for the previous year. Throughout the spring, well, throughout mostly the summer and fall, auditors from MMKR work with the accounting staff, White Bear Lake Finance Department, and our director of finance, Andy Johnson, leads that team working with the auditors to prepare for the

002annual audit. Tonight, we have Jim Eichten, who is a managing partner at MMKR, and he's been with us for a lot of years in White Bear Lake, and we welcome you, Jim, to another school board meeting. - All right. Thank you. - Jim will present the annual audit report. - All right. Well, thanks for the introduction, Superintendent, members of the board. My name is Jim Eichten. I'm gonna jump right into some clarifying items of that presentation. Some of you are aware of this, but as of January 1st, which is 20 days ago, my firm of MMKR did actually merge with a different firm. We are a firm called LB Carlson as of that date. All of my auditors and partners are moved to that particular firm, so we don't anticipate any changes in the way

003we operate and the way we do things, but it is important to understand I'm representing MMKR because I did issue this report under MMKR, even though I'm really LB Carlson at this particular moment. I think... Here we go. Am I good to go? There it is. So, I do have a PowerPoint presentation, so I'm gonna quickly go through the PowerPoint presentation that will probably reference some of the other documentation that I have here. So, it is a requirement, as mentioned, that the district have an annual financial statement prepared, that particular annual financial statement requirement. The district takes to another level and prepares what's called an Annual Comprehensive Financial Report, an ACFR, which is submitted for recognition by certificate of review programs. That particular document, if you haven't looked at it, is about 152 pages long.

004There's a lot of data in that particular report that really is prepared by the district and is recognized for certificate of excellence in financial reporting. As part of the particular audit, we do implement any sort of new standards that are required to be implemented. This particular year, we did implement a standard on group capital assets, which I'll touch on a little bit during a later presentation. And then, so for purposes of this audit, we are also required to, as part of our particular requirements, audit the internal controls over the district's financial reporting. That would include many various aspects, but mostly things like payroll and cash receipts, cash disbursements, those types of things. Okay. So my audit results are also summarized in a document that's called the management report, and I believe the document was provided

005to you. That particular management report does go through the audit results for purposes of, really, purposes of reviewing a much less lengthy document and getting an idea on how the audit results went. And I'm gonna go through that particular document, not in full, but touch on the highlights as it relates to the audit. So in that document, I did provide a summary of the audit results. And as I mentioned, the Annual Comprehensive Financial Report, we did issue what's called an unmodified opinion. That was a clean opinion on that particular financial statement, the opinion you were looking for going in. We did implement that group audit standard. As mentioned, it did impact the district's financial results and slightly added some capital assets, specifically those that were purchased in a group setting, which is what the standard

006required us to implement. I did mention the internal controls over financial reporting. We did have one audit adjustment this year that is reported as a finding, specifically related to the recording of, I will call it, construction in process. As you all are aware, there is a significant volume of transactions happening in this particular environment, given the amount of construction happening, in the accounting specifically related to capital asset record keeping and the continuing accounting for construction process was reevaluated, if you will, this year. We did find some adjustments that got recorded as part of the audit particular process. I think it's important to understand that the finding specifically relates to what I would call financial reporting finding. The day-to-day aspects of payment of bills and the reviewing of invoices and the payment and overviewing of contracts

007was not the finding that we have here. That was all found to be adequate and appropriate. In this case, it mostly, if not all of it, related to the accounting and the wrapping up of the audit in terms of how that relates to capital assets and the recording of those. That's a significant differentiation when I look at that particular finding. The audit results of this particular page, I did mention or previously mentioned, we do audit your compliance with Minnesota laws and regulations as part of this audit. It's required by the Office of State Auditor. They provide us with a list of all the laws they want us to audit. The list changes depending on their needs and what they find at their audits that are causing findings at school districts. We did not have any

008findings to report in that particular space. As part of the audit, we also audit your schedule of expenditures of federal awards, what's called a SEFA. The district does receive a significant amount of federal awards and as a result, the federal government requires us to complete what's called a single audit. The total federal awards this year is about $7.6 million. You can see we also audit your internal controls over those particular grants. We also audit the compliance with those particular grants which are described as major programs. We don't audit every program in that federal space. There's a rotating process going on. And so depending on the major program, we test the compliance of each individual major programs really on a rotating basis based on federal rules. In that particular summary of those three particular areas, we

009didn't have any findings to report. Continuing on, it is an important element of a particular finding of an audit to follow up any prior year findings. I'll describe it this way. We are here to audit and because of that, we find things. It's a learning experience. It's part of the process to learn and find things and improve on them. We don't actually have everything that we found in this process. Some of the things that we learned as part of this process were just communicated to staff. They weren't significant enough to actually put in a report but there's a lot of things we find and ask about that are just, hey, maybe the best practice here is to do it this way. For those findings, particularly the one on construction process, there is a finding written.

010There's a corrective action plan. And as a board, you should be focused on that particular element of the finding. What are we gonna do about this? How are we gonna correct it so that the auditor doesn't have this finding again next year? So that particular finding corrective action plan, you'll see in some of the data that you've received. We've talked about it as far as in our exit meeting about how we're gonna go about improving that particular accounting so that it doesn't happen. There was some turnover in district staff in that space during our audit year which is probably primarily the reason for some of that finding. But that being said, how are we gonna correct it? There is a corrective action plan. When I look at last year, there were two findings and both

011of those findings were eliminated. The result that we would hope for as a board. Yep, we had those findings, we made a corrective action. Here we are presenting the next year and they've been corrected. They're listed up there. They related to collateral on the district's bank accounts as well as advertisement for bids in one particular contract last year. So I'm going to continue in my presentation. Hopefully I don't go too fast, which I just did. There we go. So my management report does then go into what I would call the second part of the audit results specifically related to the district's financial results collectively. And the report goes over almost every fund, if not every fund, but it really starts with some comparable data from the state. This particular graphics presentation, which is on page

012six of my report, shows statewide operating fund balances as a percentage of expenditures using MDE's formula, not the district's formula, the MDE's formula. Very important distinction. You can see on that particular graph, fund balances statewide have been about 20% for almost a decade. That's a number that has been very consistent. Prior to the pandemic, you can see that that number was very solid. Until we got to the pandemic, actually, fund balances went up statewide, mostly related to changes in operations. Spending patterns were much different. More funding became available for federal grants, those types of things. Once we got post-pandemic, you can see in the yellow graph started to go down as federal money became less available, student populations declined a bit, and just the change in operations made that occur. We anticipate, at least I

013do anticipate by the number of audits that I do, that yellow line is gonna continue to go down when we get here next year. You'll see that. The district's fund balances there, you can see, are in red. Most of the early years relate to very planful spending of some additional resources that came from the Old Prep Trust Fund back in probably, what year was it? 2014, '14? Yes, one year off that graph. And since 2014, there's been a consistent spend down that is very planful to the point where we got to 2019, 2020. For 2024, the year that I audited, you can see that there was an increase in fund balance as a percentage of expenditures on the statewide level, after a couple of declining years, the past two years. And I'll get to these

014more specific general fund data in a later graph. This particular graph's on page seven of my report shows revenues per student. It does show information for the district on the right, and then it shows statewide metro area averages as well. What that's stating there is in 2024, the district spent $22,206 per student, excuse me, they have revenue of $22,206 per student in that particular year. Some of the things that stand out in that particular revenue category, there was some significant increases in state funding. You can see at the state line for both the basic formula allowance, which increased this past year, but also in special education formulas and special education programming shows up. You can see the impact the bond issues have had on debt service fund showing up in that the bottom line there.

015You can see the debt service fund revenues being increased over last year based on new bond issues. Revenues in the food service fund actually increased pretty significantly. Most of that, if not all of it, relates to the additional state funding that came to you for free meals, you know, free meal program. You can really see it showing up in that particular area. Lastly, the federal line has been going down. Most of the pandemic related funding that came out of that particular timeframe has declined as you use them and they just don't replenish. Many districts are struggling with that as federal funds have gone away, some of their financial impact is hitting them pretty hard. So you can see some of the trend lines there. On the expenditure side, you can see, this is expenditures per

016student again. So in total, in the governmental funds of the district, you're spending about $21,633 per student, which is reflected in this particular graph. Some of the areas that stood out, you can see that regular instruction is a pretty big or large category there. $6,799 in regular instruction. There was some increases in that particular category for curriculum purchases. One-time curriculum purchases are in that particular category. Special education is also increasing due to just continued increased costs, both for salaries, benefits, purchase services are also in there when you're utilizing other staffing methodologies. And then lastly, the debt service fund, the bottom there stands out in terms of the additional debt service funding, excuse me, expenditures that are happening for the bond referendum and the like. Continuing on, the general fund financial position is on page nine,

017which is this particular page gets into the individual fund analysis. This graph shows the general fund financial position utilizing cash as, excuse me, cash and fund balance as indication of equity position where you're standing from an equity position. And then expenditures really just trying to reflect how the changing size of the operation, if you're getting bigger or smaller, which you're seeing a slight increase over the timeframe noted, but pretty slight overall. At the end of the year, the district's fund balance did increase about $2.6 million. That particular fund balance increase was roughly $931,000 above what was projected for the year. So very close to expectations, the operations that your district is running a general fund that is, what was it, $142 million operation in total. And it's a pretty sizable organization when you think about

018it just for that one fund. And you came in, your end of the year, you came in within $930,000 of those budgeted expectations. There was a balance there. Revenues were higher than projections as well as expenditures were higher than projection, but the net was about $900,000 for the year. This particular graph, which is on the next page is probably the most important part of this presentation, showing some benchmarking in terms of decision making on the part of the board. At the end of the year, the district's fund balances as a percentage of expenditures using the district's calculations ended the year at 7.5%. It was an increase from 5.9% the year before. Why is that important? Well, the district does have a fund balance policy in place. The board has adopted such a policy. The policy

019strives to maintain a minimum unassigned fund balance of 8%. That's important. That's a very important benchmark that, I see some shaking of heads. That's a place that you should focus your attention as a board member, both from just a standpoint of understanding what that policy is all about, but also at the end of the year, utilizing that percentage and say, well, either we need to adopt a change in our budget going forward or just understanding where we are from a baseline perspective. So at the end of the year, the unassigned fund balance, like I said, is at 7.5%, just slightly below that particular policy that you have in place. Somebody asked me, well, now what? What are we gonna do once we know that fund balance policy? Well, that's up to the superintendent and the

020business office to make some understanding how that impacts the overall budget going forward. That's not my job, I'm here to reflect on the audit results. Most of the administration will bring that forth to you in future meetings if they haven't already, maybe even at the last one. Continuing on, we do have some reflected information here as well on general fund revenues and expenditures. The next one's expenditures. The general fund revenues, as mentioned, were over budget by about $3.8 million. There are three categories that stand out to me. Other revenues were conservatively budgeted. There were some other revenues from billings to other districts that impacted that particular revenues. Tax collections were better than expected. Typically, you see that because there's usually a built-in contingency in collections. You never know how collections are gonna be on a

021tax perspective. And then overall, state sources were over budget based on just approved funding from those two particular categories, including transportation. On the expenditure side, we did have expenditures over budget this year by about $3.3 million. Three categories, again, stand out. Supplies and materials specifically related to a one-time curriculum purchase that I already referenced. That was the district taking advantage of the pricing for particular curriculum materials that weren't an original budget but felt like it was important to buy that just to take advantage of the pricing in that particular area. Salaries were over budget by about $800,000. Most of that, which was actually very close to budget given the size of that particular category. And then lastly, purchase services for things like student tuition, billing and transportation were more than budgeted this past year. But

022all in all, like I said, the overall budget was very close to expectations, when you get to within a million dollars net, you're doing a good job of doing those budget expectations and holding the audit true to some of those expectations. I will continue on and I will follow up with questions that people have when I get done. This particular page is 14, shows the other governmental funds of the district. Food service fund as shown here, did increase to a fund balance of about $3 million. Most districts' food service funds financial results were better than expected, giving the new funding that's coming from the state. You're no different in that particular case. You're seeing food service fund increasing fund balance this past year and you're at about 46% fund balance as a percentage of expenditures,

023which is a good place to be when it comes to the food service fund. You can see the community service fund I would suggest is not where it needs to be. Nobody wants to see a deficit fund balance in the community service fund. It was better than expected by about $150,000. So it could have been worse. There was some increased participation for school aged care as well as youth enrichment programs that helped that fund. We did talk at the exit conference, if you will, or some of the things that are ongoing and happening to improve that particular fund and turn that around so that we have some fund balance going forward. But at the end of the year, it sits at about a deficit of about $322,000. Let's see how I go here. Now I'm

024just pressing buttons to press buttons. All right. Continuing on my presentation, the district does have a very healthy fund an internal service fund, which is really a self-insurance fund. The district is self-insured for health benefits and an internal service fund is utilized to fund that particular program. In 2024, you can see that the fund did increase by about $800,000. As you can see in revenues, it's about $15 million of revenues in that particular fund for health benefits. At the end of the year, that particular fund is at about 33% of operations. I believe the experts in this particular area would be hoping for something closer to 50%. And I know that you're working to improve that particular area, as you can see in the improvement for this particular, this past year. Other funds the district

025has, you have a capital project building construction fund. This past year, there was about $71 million of spending in that particular one fund or utilization. Why I bring that number to the forefront is mainly related to my observations of the work that's happening in the business office. you don't take a district office and move from a spending of zero really generally, that's probably exaggerating, but from zero to $771 million and not expect it to be impact. There's a lot of work that goes into processing all of that particular work. And to process that, it takes personnel and resources and sometimes you just don't have it and other times you do, but it does have an impact on the district and is something that should be recognized because it's probably gonna go away eventually. Right? Continuing

026on, you have the debt service fund as mentioned, I mentioned that there is a self-benefits dental plan, which is sitting in good financial position. And the district also has what's called the OPEB trust fund. That particular trust fund was issued some time ago where bonds were issued to finance the OPEB trust obligations of the district. At the end of the year, the district has about $31 million sitting in trust for future obligations in the OPEB area. I think that's the end of my presentation. So in summary, I was able to issue an unmodified opinion as mentioned on that financial report. We implemented the capital asset accounting standard this particular year. We issued a certificate of achievement for excellence in financial reporting, which will take some time to receive from the organization. We did have the

027one finding, which ultimately will hopefully be corrected in the future. You're seeing improving general fund financial position. I did mention the importance of the district's fund balance policy as a guideline for decision making on the part of administration and the board. I did analyze all the other funds as I went through, talked a little bit about the significance of the construction activity. And then lastly, I just wanna reflect on the audit process. The audit process for us starts in June and really ends probably in December. It's a long process, especially at a district of this size. It takes a lot of effort by auditors as well as administration. And my words there are very two point. This district is very dedicated to this process. Rarely do I not get the information that I need. And

028if I'm not getting the information I need, I'm well aware why I haven't received it yet because somebody's working on it. So it's a very healthy process, healthy from two fronts, healthy for me as an auditor, but healthy for the district as well. There are people that are dedicated to this process and making sure it goes right and is effective as well. So with that, I'll open it up to questions that you have for me on the audit results. - I know Ms. Beloyed, you had a question? - What would you say is one of the, in all the times you've been doing this, a red flag for anybody when they're looking through the financials to say that something is off? What would be one of the... - Talking about now or forever? - Forever.

029And anytime you're looking at budgets this large, what are the red flags to look for if something is off? - Yeah, generally we get, we as a firm immediately get concerned with turnover. Turnover and personnel is a huge challenge. And I'll just probably talk about the last maybe three years to four years, post-pandemic probably. Very tight available resources outside of, in the finance world, both in the audit world, but also in the business manager world. Whenever somebody leaves the district or leaves a hole, it's very hard to replace that person. And your district has been, I will say, you know, at times impacted by that. There was a opening and there's a controller position at one time, if I remember, it was a couple years ago, roughly. And you can see it, you can almost

030see it, you can feel it almost in the district when you talk to the personnel here. They're just, things slow down, things aren't moving as quickly as they should. And so whenever you see open positions at a district, you should be aware of it and help, or, you know, help to understand what's happening. This year there was, like I mentioned, basically the construction account. Is that right? - Yeah. There was an opening in that particular area and somebody else had to take over. Well, transition means things slow down, there's a change in understanding, and it leads to things that are cause for concern. Are they red flags? Probably not in this case, but they can be. - Were there any, this audit was completed on time, correct? - Yes, it was. Yeah, it was submitted...

031- [Board Member] Is that a red flag to look for if audits go beyond their due by dates? - A red flag, no, but it is something to be concerned about, you know, in terms of trying to get them back on track and get them done timely, for sure. But I wouldn't define it as a red flag. Sometimes there's just things that happen that cause it and it has nothing to do with, you know, something concerning. - [Board Member] Okay, other questions? Mr. Skaar? - Thank you. So are schools subject to partner rotation? - In particular on an audit? - Right. - They're not? So how long have you been partner on this audit for White Bear School? - I've been the partner for some time. I probably came in, in a severe financial crisis,

032whatever that was. We talked about it. Remember that? Ted Blaesing era, for sure. I'd have to get... - So there's no partner rotation required for school districts for an audit company? - [Jim] There are not. If requested, we certainly adapt for that. - Is it something they merged with? Do they have partner rotation requirements? - They do. - Okay. Maybe before, I wanted to circle back a little, maybe on the nature of the findings from this year as well as last year. But I've got something on the board. Can I go through that? That's okay? It won't take that long ? - How many questions? - Pardon? - You just got a few questions? If we could keep it brief, yes. - Well if you go to page 26 out of 260, this is the

033annual comprehensive report. It says the district has adopted a four way equity decision making protocol, only those three questions there in the paragraph under that it says in comparison with other school districts that state districts ranks high as educational programs and it scholastic ability of graduates, which I think is great, but are we grounded in any kind of a statistic with that? I don't mind if it's bold, but I just thought maybe there should be something grounded in that. - And I'm wondering if those are questions about the audit or those are questions... That's what I'm thinking is. - We want, you know, this is to the public. So we want it to be accurate. We want it to be grounded in, you know, accuracy, right? - Yeah. I just wanna make sure that we're

034questioning about the audit, not something that's above and beyond. - Well, this is embedded in the audit report. That annual comprehensive report. So I wanna also on page, I think it's on the same page, 26, it talks about the effort drop in enrollment caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. District enrollment has stabilized. But then if you go back down to page 27, it says, the bond funding will be used to address projected enrollment growth throughout the district. So I think that language there, if you can clean that up a little bit. So it kind of is saying, you know, what you're saying is declined, stabilized. And then at the other end, you're saying, hey, the bond funding was used to, you know, for an increase. So that would leave a question in my mind. If I

035could have a review of that. - [Board Member] Can I get a clarification on what that means? - So I think when we're talking about the projected enrollment growth, we're thinking more about long term projected enrollment growth. And that's certainly was the, we certainly did project enrollment growth when we went for the bond. So I think that's kind of why that's in there in that way. - [Board Member] Right. Well, I would suggest either remove it or explain why. - Understood. - The bond, we projected this and now we're at this. So we either have to explain it or I would suggest it- - These are just friendly suggestions. I would say on page 28, 260, it says, as demonstrated by the state of the state's schedule, including the financial section, the district continues to

036need its responsibility of sound financial management. And I would just say, you know, that's great to self-proclaim that. But I think you could say, it needs responsibility for financial management, and we believe our procedures are sound, something like that. If you go to page 50 of 260. No, we can skip that one. 54... I think, this, you have the address is the old address for the school district. You should drop or update that... - No, that was the address of the time of the audit. So that's the... - Oh, but it says, if you have questions, you're supposed to follow that. So that's just a little bit confusing. I wanted to ask you about that debt. It's on page 178, 260. It has to do with the debt limit based upon the market. How does

037that, you guys calculate that or is that something that the district calculates? - The district would calculate that... - And then you look at that... - We look at it to validate that the calculation is done correctly. Sure. (indistinct) - The debt limit is in statute. - Yeah. - Right. The district doesn't really come up with the debt limit. It's in statute. - Other one had to do with that OPEB where we had assets, I think, of $37 million, but we have obligations of like $78 million. So we're upside down on the funding, but that's probably typical, I'm thinking. Is that true? - You're talking about the OPEB trust fund? - Yeah, we have assets of $37 million, but our obligations are like $78 or $80 million. I think it's on page 229 of the

038book. Let's go with that. It's your note number eight. In the finance. - So the OPEB trust fund, right, based on right now, the total OPEB liability is $13 million, where the assets are $31 million. So you're not upside down. You're actually good. - There's another one left. - Right. - [Board Member] Lemme just, was that in note eight? - That was in note eight. Yes. - Mr. Skaar, while you're looking for that, can I open it up to other Board Members? - And then it's back... - Any other questions? - I just had one, just for my clarification. One slide talked about the unrestricted operating on fund balance and that's 9.6, and what's the difference between that and the unassigned, which is 7.5, which is the one we followed our deal with our policy.

039So what was slide eight on? - Yes. - Slide 10. - I just wanted- - Great question. Yeah, so the slide that we're utilizing was, that was 9.6 is the state of Minnesota's calculation. So the state of Minnesota Department of Education uses the calculation of fund balances, the percentage of expenditures for their own internal use. Most notably, they use it for statutory operating debt calculations. So when districts fall below zero and get to two and a half percent, I think is the number now, you're considered in statutory operating debt. So you're far from that. But that's their calculation utilizing the Department of Education's calculation. The calculations that are on page 10 are district calculations. And the using your own fund balance policy. So we're taking certain fund balance categories and comparing them to certain expenditures

040to come up with a district calculation. So they differ. You might ask yourself, does every district do it that way? They do. They all... Every district has their own fund balance policy and their own calculations that fit their district. And so there are two different calculations on pretty much every district that I work with. Great question. - Other questions? Okay, Mr. Skaar, have you found your... - Yeah, no issues. I just read it wrong. Sorry about that. - No problem. - Getting back to the material weakness, you know, since there's a lot of capital transactions, what was the nature of that? Was it a classification issue? - So what we're doing with the construction process is when you're counting for capital assets in this particular financial report, first of all, capital expenditures, when paid, are

041expensed in the fund. So they get expensed in the fund. They get recorded as an expenditure. In the financial report, we convert that particular expenditure into a capital asset accounting, into capital asset using, really trying to get simple here, but they have a separate set of financials called the entity wide financial statements that account for capital assets. Right? So in the capital asset record keeping, we are, the district is calculating construction in process. So you do that because anytime there's a contract that goes or a contractor or a project that goes multiple years, you don't wanna capitalize that particular contract until it's complete. Correct? So any contract that's multiple years, they calculate or use a spreadsheet to summarize all the construction process. Right? That particular spreadsheet, when we analyze the beginning balance, which would have

042been kind of a roll forward from last year and we started comparing them to the accounting records, we noticed ones that weren't consistent. Didn't seem, they were off based on this year's spreadsheet. So last year's spreadsheet didn't necessarily mimic this year's spreadsheet. So we did some analysis to determine where we are. What contracts got off? Why is last year's different than this year's? And we came up with some adjustments. So we made those adjustments. - So the internal control weakness was related to reporting, not actually scoring the numbers and reviewing the numbers, things like that, or the invoices? - It had nothing to do with payments out to contractors at all. It had to do with internal accounting. - Did the auditors look at the change order process? - [Jim] We did not. I mean...

043- So on the prior year finding with the, where you didn't post the, did anybody complain about it or was it just a finding that you found? No complaints? So there's no harm really? Right. All right. That's it. - Thank you. Thank you very much- - Thank you. - Some of us are always excited to have you come here for this information. I know this side of the table is. I appreciate you taking your time. - [Jim] Thank you. Thank you. - Yeah. And I also just wanna underscore what Mr. Eichten said about the heavy lifting finance office with that construction, just managing the construction fund and the pressure on us to just stay on top of all that. It's really been a heavy lift and really kudos to Andy Johnson, who supervises all that

044very closely. Does a great job. Thanks for your time. As well as Sarah Andre, who is our controller and new to public accounting. So she came from the corporate world and then moving into public education and public accounting is a really heavy lift. She's doing great work. Big learning curve. And then Stephanie Wendel also... (indistinct) Thank you all. - Thank you. - All right. Thank you for coming. - Thank you. - We're gonna go on now to discussion item B.2. Dr. Kazmierczak. - All right. I'd like to welcome Peter Leatherman. Wanna come up here. Peter conducted a community survey for us back in December. And he's here to share the results with us. So... Peter, take it away. Good to see you. - It's a pleasure to be here with you this evening. In my

04531st year I've heard hundreds of those auditors reports and I still don't understand education funding. (laughs) God bless you. I'm waiting for it to pop up. - [Board Member] You're all right. - Perfect. All right. To review with everybody, what we undertook with the district, we spoke with 400 randomly selected residents across the community. And then within that sample, there's a percent of parents. We had 30% parents. So you have approximately 120 parents in that 400 sample. So I called an additional 280 parents. I pulled that 120. Put that together. So now we have a sample to look at parents that's also 400. 400 samples projectable to within plus or minus 5% in 95 out of 100 cases. Once again, the margin of error is determined by the size of the sample, not the percent

046of the population. So a 400 in White Bear Lake School District, a 400 in Ramsey County or 400 in the state of Minnesota is plus or minus 5%. Interviews were conducted last year before the holidays between the 3rd and 19th. Average interview time was 12 minutes. People were thrilled we were past the election and nobody was voter IDing them. So they were more than happy to talk. Refusal rate was only 6%. And to put up some demographics, we always start... Cell phone only 59%. 8%, they still exist out there, our landline only households and then the remaining third have both landlines and cell phones. Continuing with the demographics and the demographics are, of course, two purposes. First off, we wanna validate the sample on key demographics, whether households with children, households with seniors, homeowners versus

047renters, those sorts of factors. But then we can look at statistically significant differences between groups. The typical resident has lived in the school district for about 12 years. You have 41% that are 10 years or less. Well, you have 36% that have been in the district for over 20 years. You have a large group of settlers and newbies, we call them. Part of it is obviously the growth on the north side of the school district. 15% indicate that they have a preschooler or an infant. 30% have a child attending the White Bear Lake Area School District. And 68% are empty nesters. Once again, empty nester does not imply an age. It's lack of presence of a child. So it could have a 24 year old in here. For the purpose of the survey, it's there,

048an empty nester. So your core constituency is about a third of the population. 45% have a relative attending the White Bear Lake Area School District. 17% are renters. Self-assessed home value. 29% at under 250K. 27% at 250K to 350K. And then 26% are over $350,000 homes. Continuing with the demographics. The typical resident's about 46 years old with 25% 18 to 34 year olds and 34% over the age of 55. Just short of a majority of folks are college graduates, that includes postgraduates, at 48%. 22% are high school graduates or less. And 30% have some college experience. The key factor for districts over the past two years looking at funding requests is the financial situation of the household. The financially stressed in your district is the same that we have in the fourth quarter of '24,

049right at about 45%. It has come down the high since the pandemic was in the first quarter of '23 where we had almost 60% across the state of Minnesota indicating they were financially stressed. So it has backed down. You're right at the norm. But to give you a historical indicator, before the pandemic the norm was about 26%. So we're still about 20 points higher. - [Board Member] Can you say that again? I'm sorry. - The norm before the pandemic was about 26%. So we're still about 20 points higher than what we were historically before the pandemic. And part of it is, you know, the pandemic, even in '20 and '21, we didn't get the increase in financially stressed. The recession of 2008-2009, we got to about 65% financially stressed. By the winter of 2020, we

050were only at about 40% financially stressed. It was really odd. And when you own your own first survey company, we do internal surveys, we went on and asked people. And folks were telling us, okay, yes, my income might have been impacted, but my expenses have been impacted. You weren't able to go on vacation. You weren't able to go to restaurants, all those sorts of things. So it didn't impact people until things went back to normal, where their income was no longer keeping up with their expenses once all of that discretionary spending was back in play for folks. And then finally, women outnumbered men by four points. And then you can see the geographic distribution. City of White Bear Lake, 35%. Hugo, 20%. 18% each in Vandals and White Bear Township. And then 10% in the

051remainder of the district. So before I go on, I always ask any questions on methodology, demographics? - [Board Member] Go ahead, Mr. Skaar. - Where did you get your universe to sample from? - It's a database with every voter or every resident in the community. And then I just pull a random sample off of that. - Oh, so it's not something from the district? - No. - You get it off? Okay. - Correct. Yep. - How are they, who comes up with the questions? - [Peter] It's developed with the school district. - Okay. Thank you. - You're welcome. All right. Survey says, for the purpose of the presentation, I put some data on from before the pandemic. Now, keep in mind, it's an apples to oranges comparison pre-pandemic versus post-pandemic. But we can see some

052trends that we see everywhere. The overall quality of education of the public schools, you can see, is at 86% this time. It was 81% back in '22. It's actually, it's not statistically significant, but things are moving in the right direction. What we have seen consistently across the state since '23 is a drop on the quality of education. The norm before the pandemic was what you were at in 2019. You can see 90%. We're now down to an 80% norm. Okay? And the shift is not only gone from excellent to good, but from good to only fair. You don't have that in play here. You actually have the excellent rating going up from 20% to 25%, which is a move in the right direction. That's where districts took a historical hit post-pandemic. The excellent rating currently

053is 11%, is the norm. So you're two and a half times the norm on the excellent rating. You don't have the shift from good to only fair that a lot of districts have. So the challenge, the discussion in the district is how do you get people, you don't have to change people's minds, that it's only fair and move 'em to good. The key is gonna be more of how do we make go from good to excellent again. Now a couple open-ended questions. They can ask us anything... And we code them into categories. First off, what do folks like most? Teachers at the top of the list, 25%. If we combine some categories, though, if we look at variety of programs and broad curriculum. So we have 21% reacting to what is being taught in the

054classroom. And then we combine good academics, excellent academics at 22%, the quality. You basically have a statistical tie between those three. Who's teaching, what they're teaching, and the quality of the teaching. Now, some districts vary. Some are very, the focus is on curriculum. Some it's on the academic quality, other it's personnel. Your folks historically have always been kind of equally distributed between those three categories. If we ask what they like most, we always follow up with the most serious issue. What leads the list? 20% say lack of funding. That's becoming the constant of pi. Somewhere between 18% and 22% across the state now are saying it's lack of funding. You have two other issues that hit double digits. High taxes at 12%, lack of discipline at 10%. The lack of discipline is typically somewhere around

0558% to 10%. The high taxes, you're on the lower side. That has grown with property tax hostility since '23, where the norm is a top of the mind response is between 15% and 20% typically. So you're a little bit lower on that. We're gonna go into taxes a little more in depth in a few charts. What other things come into play? Large class sizes, poor spending, declining quality, scattered are idiosyncratic responses that are 1% or less that don't fit into any category. We just collapse them down. The key at the bottom of this chart though is the nothing. The 22%. These folks think there are no problems in this district. It's utopia. That is about four times the norm right now. The norm right now is dropped to 6%. Before the pandemic, it was 11%.

056I just say before the pandemic all the time. Before the pandemic though, it was 11% or 12%. It's been cut in half. So you do have... And these folks are positive throughout. Whether we're looking at financial management, governance, administration, the quality, these are your boosters. So you do have a very large cell of boosters in the school district in comparison to most metro school districts. We talked about this shift over in the quality of education, but how about a historic comparison? And for this question we ground it in comparison to three years ago. Because it's not fair to tell them to ask to think back to five years ago before the pandemic. Do they think things are improving, getting better, stay the same or getting worse? Well, residents, it's 38% to 13% that things are

057getting better. Amongst parents, it's 37% to 9%. So by a three to one and a four to one margin, you do have folks telling us that there are actually though things are moving in the right direction. They're getting better. The norm right now is two to one. And there are some districts and over the past two years where you have more people saying worse than better. You do have a sense of momentum that things are improving coming out. How does the district do on meeting the learning needs of all students? Most, only some, or very few. You're back to a majority saying you're meeting the learning needs of all students. And that's a real stringent standard to be held to. 53%. Now, that has dropped down to about 44% over the past three to four

058years. So a very good rating. Now we followed up, I didn't put it in the chart, but we followed up with those that said most or some and asked, is there a type of student whose learning needs are not being met? And you have the same array that districts have right now, and that is the struggling, the underachiever and the average student is where the concern is at. How concerned are they about learning loss during the pandemic? You have 50% that are indicating they're either very or somewhat concerned. 48% not too or not at all. Pretty much what we're finding right now is the split on the perception of learning loss of coming out of the pandemic. If we look at intensity, it's about 50% higher of not at all concerned versus very concerned currently.

059What's the most important indicator of a high quality education? For this in the next few charts, we're gonna look at your overall community versus the parents. And there is a lot of unity between the results of both. Oftentimes there's a difference between parents and the community as a whole, but especially on this one. What's the most important? A broad curriculum serving all. Followed by college graduates going on for further education, reasonable numbers in classrooms, standardized test scores, and then technology at the bottom as a priority. Now, on standardized test scores, this has come back over the past three to four years. Quite frankly, it has to do with, it's the only touch point into a school district, especially for a non parent, to judge a school district. Coming out of the years of George W.

060Bush and No Child Left Behind, people got testing exhaustion. And so it was not seen as a good measure. It's back though in the mix as something that people are looking at when they look at the quality of education in the school district. But you can see there really is a symbiosis here at the top four of what your community and your parents value. That's what they value. How do they rate the district on those indicators? Well, number one was the broad curriculum serving all, 77% favorable, amongst parents, 85% favorable. College grads going on for further education, 79% and 87% favorable. Reasonable number in classrooms has the highest unfavorability. Now, reasonable number is in the eye of the beholder. Okay? Oftentimes in some districts, especially when we're looking at facilities for class size issues, we

061give them specific numbers to react to. So if you hear 25, is that too high, about the right amount? This one is just what's reasonable. What's reasonable to one person who grew up in small town Minnesota is very different than somebody who grew up in Maple Grove for reasonable class size. And that's why there's such variation on this. But you can see parents are more satisfied than the community as a whole. Standardized test scores, 78% and 74%. The highest level is the least important. The state of the art technology. So overall, it's very positive on all those indicators. General open ended question. Are they concerned about curriculum? A lot of discussion about curriculum over the past three years. Basically, you're what we find in the seven county metro. About 75% have no concerns. 25% do

062have concerns. So the community, 72% say no, amongst parents, 74%. Following up with those that said they have a concern, you can see too liberal and gender identity tie and then we go to LGBTQIA plus, DEI and then various scattered categories. But on this one, you're right at the norm that we see. Some specific perceptions that we've tested historically. First off, does the district spend taxpayers' money effectively and efficiently? Unchanged from '22, 76% agree with the statement. Norm on that right now is about 59%. So you're about 17, 18 points higher than the norm on spending taxpayers' money effectively and efficiently. Do you ask for a tax increase only as a last resort? A little bit of a drop on this one. You've had funding requests over the past few years, but still 69% agree

063with that. The bottom question for districts looking at potential funding requests is really important and that is the schools are a good investment and I would support a property tax increase to protect that investment. The key on this is the no, because we're not telling them if it's an operating levy or a bond referendum, if it's $50 a month or $50 a year, the no are just against everything. And so that's the core opposition in the school district. You can see that's at 25%. Over the past 18 months, the norm has been about 30%, core no, it's gone up over the course of the last few years, which is why we've had so many unsuccessful funding requests from school districts. So you're on the low end of what we would see. Once again, this doesn't

064mean that people could be thrilled for a property tax increase. The lower the number, the more willingness there is to have a discussion about it. Continuing with statements, the schools are a good value for the investment. Absolutely, unchanged. 89%. Does the district do a good job of involving the community? Unchanged. And this is unique because this took a hit with the pandemic. It was hard to involve the community for two years, in, you know, virtual or what have you. And you could see even in '22 it was very high at 78%. You're at 79% right now. Have you spent past referendum funds responsibly? 75%. Do they trust the district to do what's right for children? Back to where we were before the pandemic. '22, things had settled down. If you'd have done this survey in

065'20 or '21 had been very different because people were arguing about masks or virtual versus in person, all of those things. But you've settled in at a better than seven to one ratio on the trust issue, which is the norm on this right now is about four to one. And then the satisfaction with the decision making. Here you can see the pandemic effect back in '22. Still coming out the trust and the decision making. But you've gone back now to 75% satisfied with the decision making. If we do so look at some job performance ratings, the school board, 69% to 25%. Norm on school board right now is 58% to 40%. On the administration, 71% to 25%. On the administration it's always a ratio that we're looking at. It's almost three to one. The norm

066on the district administration is two to one. And then the closer you get to the kids, the higher the ratings. And we see that 75% on principals and teachers at 88%. The 88% of teachers is very strong. Teachers have taken a hit in ratings over the pandemic. The norm being before 90%, we're down to about 80%. So that 88% is very strong rating of teachers in your school district. I mentioned property taxes as a top of the mind most serious issue and that it was on the lower side. This question asks folks to think first about your total taxes and then your school taxes. On total taxes, 49% think they're high. You're one of the few districts that's actually below 50% saying my taxes are high. This has gone up, like I mentioned. With the

067new assessment in the spring of '23, everybody was thrilled. Nobody realized what that would do to their tax statement November of '23. And the norm went on property on my taxes are high to 60%. It came down a little bit, but now since November 15th of this year it's going back up again. So you are on the low end at 49%. Now on school taxes it actually drops to 44%. So this tells us that if they have animus on property taxes, it's not focused at the school district. That's great news. Bad news is you're really the only show in town that has to go to the public for a funding request. You know I always joke, you know, back when I started doing this in the '90s we always asked who do you blame? And

068then cities and counties got really mad and so we don't ask it that way anymore. We ask it this way, so it will tell us where the concern is focused at. It's not focused at you. So it's a tax sensitive environment, not a tax hostile environment. Is the district adequately funded? This is really interesting right now because we are getting very different results between the seven county metro and the rest of Minnesota. For the most part of '23 and '24 it was 45% yes 45% no and 10% don't know. What we're seeing now is a drop in the seven county metro and you have that. You only have 41% saying you're adequately funded. Where the out state norm is almost 60% saying, yes, we are adequately funded. So I'm not quite sure what's going on.

069We're gonna do another internal survey that we'll share with school districts just to get a feel of what's happening around the state. But there is this bifurcation right now on the perception of the adequacy of funding on the schools. People are confused. They've heard the governor talk about the wonderful things that were done. They've heard the legislature do their victory laps. And then they see districts making cuts all over the place and they don't know what to think right now. Overall assessment of financial management then, 64% favorable. Norm on this right now is 52%. So as we look at a whole with all the battery of questions we've asked around finances and spending, the district does have strong credibility when it comes to financial management with the community. If they heard the district was gonna

070ask for a property tax increase, are they for all, against all or are they persuadable? You actually have 3% more core support than core yes. So that's the highest that I have over the last 18 months. Where the norm over the last 18 months was minus three. 3% more opposition than core support. But obviously with these numbers the vast majority are in the persuadable category. And that's where decisions will have to be made on funding requests in the future. On our let's make a deal question, what would be a reasonable tax increase to provide additional funding for the school district? Well, 24% say nothing. And we always want that number to be under 35%. So you're well under that number. Once again this doesn't mean they support anything and everything. It means they're willing to

071have a conversation. 19% come in at $5. 23% come in at $10. And then we have 23% at $15 a month. The median, if we take out the nothing, they're not gonna support anything. The typical residence at about 12 bucks a month or 150 bucks a year. For those that have heard me present for bond referendums out here or operating levies you know that number is not set in stone. It's based on, you know, it's not only, this is the tolerance but then what is the funding gonna be used for? That can that could increase a dollar amount support but it can also decrease depending on what's included in the funding. Switching over to just the parent sample and getting a gauge on what parents are thinking. We went through a series of descriptions and

072asked do they agree or disagree with the statements about the White Bear Lake Area School District. And on this one I'll make this simple. There's vast agreement. The highest level of agreement you have with the statement is the district has excellent teachers at 95%. The lowest, excuse me, the lowest amount of agreement is preparing students for life and students succeeding at high levels at 86%. So very few parents are disagreeing with these statements. The opportunity for districts is to make parents feel strongly agreement on it. Because there's a lot of soft agreement on this because it's a four part. They can strongly agree, agree, disagree, or strongly disagree. So once again, the challenge and it's a challenge everywhere is to bring more enthusiasm and to make people feel more intensely about what's happening in these

073schools. Of those descriptions, which is the most important description for the White Bear Lake Area School District is preparing students for life. Followed by using effective teaching practices, students succeeding at high levels, support student needs and partnering with families. The red is what is the least important. And you can see the pandemic has left a sour taste in everybody's mouth. You're not unique on technology. That is the least important option for the description about the White Bear Lake Area schools especially for parents. They don't wanna hear about technology unless it's in the classroom. What's the reason they sent their child to the school district? So they could tell us anything. We collapse them down into categories. You only have two items that hit double digits. So there's not really like one brand, shall we say,

074that's in the decision making, close to home and the good teachers. If we combine kind of the location response like my kids go here because we live here, you have close to home at 18%, live in the district at 9% and family and friends attend at 6%. So about a third are making a decision basically on convenience. That's a little bit lower. Most districts are in the 40% to 45% range. So you have more people making a decision on a value outside of just a demographic, shall we say. So good teachers. The programming. And then we also have down the list the curriculum. About 10% basing it on that. The quality of the education, whether it's high quality, the achievement stats, the reputation, the strong academics, about 15% in that category. So, you know, once

075again, if you think back to what they like most, this kind of reflects it overall too on what parents are valuing. All three equally. Who's teaching, what they're teaching, and how well are they teaching it. A rating on characteristics of the district. Once again, they can say excellent, good, only fair, or poor. I've collapsed the excellent and good into the green and the only fair, or poor into the red. You can see it's 76% or higher favorable across the board. With a high on the quality teaching staff at 94%. You actually have four other items that hit 90%. Extracurricular sports opportunities, the variety of course offerings, music, theater, arts, and access to technology. You then have a group in the high 80s: academic achievement, basic academic coursework, character development, responsiveness to student needs, and access

076to the pre-k program. Then the state national test scores, overall college prep, community service opportunities, student behavior, and personalized education. What we're seeing across the metro and across the state, your bottom two are the bottom two pretty much everywhere. There is a desire on the personalized education piece. It's seen as a way, if you have concerns on class sizes, to overcome those concerns. So the kid isn't just a number. So the desire for more. But that 22% unfavorable is about 10 points lower than we're seeing elsewhere. On the student behavior, you're about 15 points lower. Well, it is the second lowest rated. We're seeing somewhere between 35% and 40%. There has been a concern about discipline and behavior, especially in the seven county metro. Some statements about the district. Vast agreement, from 87% to 97%.

077They feel welcome, accepted, the teachers care, they feel respected, they get help when provided, the district does a good job of informing, meeting individual learning needs, they challenge their student, the school is safe, they support learning at home, and the one that's most difficult is the communicate about progress. That's typically around 20% because there's just a certain group of parents, my wife being one of them, who will never be satisfied with the amount of information they get about the child living at our house. Start school before Labor Day. This is a fun question always. Someday I'll never have to ask this again, just like I'll never have to ask about chickens for city surveys. 50% support school starting before Labor Day, 39% oppose. These are parents. It's a statistical tie, basically, with 12% are unsure.

078Look at intensity. Surprisingly, this is waned. This was more intense about 10 years ago, where it was like mom, apple pie, and school starting after Labor Day. For parents, it's kind of that strong opposition has started to wane, but it hasn't transferred over to support at this point in time. And then finally, communication. Where are folks getting their information? This one looking at the community, blue, parents, green, amongst the community, it's the website and the newsletter at 43% combined. And then follow the word of mouth, local newspaper, social media, email. You can see parents are an entirely different world for communication. 32% indicate email, 31% the website. Almost two-thirds of parents are relying on one of those two sources as their primary source of information. Now, how do they prefer to receive information? If we

079look at this print versus electronic, do they wanna hold something in their hands? 31% say the mail newsletter and 11% say the local newspaper. So you have over 40% that want something traditional to be handheld. Very specific demographic over the age of 55. Parents have completely made the transition. So between the email, the website, social media, and an e-newsletter, you have over 75% of parents preferring something electronic. If we flesh it out a little bit more and ask, do they get a lot of information, some information, not too much or not at all, what's the rate on this chart is the a lot and the sum. And so for the community, it's the website, district mailings, but that goes to first place if we add in the secondary of some. But what goes into second

080place if you add the secondary is the informal discussions with friends and neighbors. The grapevine is alive and lush. You are unique because on this chart, the most credible source, where are folks getting their information? You had 11% indicating that it was word of mouth. The norm on that right now has gone up to 20% over the past 18 months. As newspapers like in Southwest Metro disappear or newspapers don't cover school districts like they used to, there's a very specific, the grapevine has grown specifically amongst people like me, old guys over the age of 50. We used to read the newspaper, it's not there, not gonna go to the website, not gonna look at social media, we're gonna get together for breakfast and gossip about what's going on. The word of mouth used traditionally was

081parents revolving around ECFE pre-K athletic associations. It's expanded. You don't have that as a primary. You still have a viable newspaper. Unlike other communities. That has helped mitigate that. But you can see the impact of the grapevine and amongst parents also. And district employees for parents are a critical piece of the information network that they have, taking it all the way up to third place. So I think across the board, from what I've seen, with districts making comparisons to two years ago, three years ago, the district's moving in the right direction. The challenge for the district, and it's a good position to be in because a lot of districts are in the position now where they're going to have to change people's minds. That something they disagree with or they rate unfavorably, they can agree

082with or rate favorably. You're not in that position. You have the challenge of how do you increase the enthusiasm, the intensity of the agreement of the ratings. So I'd be happy to answer any questions you have. - [Board Member] Thank you. Do we have any questions? - Excuse me. - Mr. Skaar? - I have a question. One thing that Wayne told me in our financial comprehensive report is the close knit community that we have here in the White Bear area of Hugo. And I'm wondering how much of that influences the, you know, statistics. But I don't know how you measure that. But I got to believe that if you're a close knit community, you're gonna have a lot more pride and a lot more touch points with the community schools than you would where you

083have a higher transient population. - It's a great question. You're absolutely right. I mean, this community, this entire area is a small town in a suburban oasis. It always has been. I did a survey for the city of White Bear Lake last year on housing and this incredible desire that people want to stay here. Whether it's when they move out or they wanna have housing available for their kids. So that does bring that connection in. So in that sense, it is more small town than a suburban oasis, shall we say. But we're seeing declines on it everywhere. It really doesn't matter whether, you know, there are a few other unique communities in the metro area that I would call the small town in the metro area versus just straight suburban. And even those communities have

084seen declines. - Declines in the results? - Yeah. Yeah. - Thank you. - All right. - Any other questions? Ms. Thompson. - Well, I was just gonna say it's very interesting. I just love hearing your reports because they're always just fascinating to me. All the questions and the information is very helpful. - [Peter] Thank you. - I was gonna pretty much say the same thing. Just seeing the data come in, it just shows that things in the district are going the way that we had hoped they would go. And the work that we've done and the work that is happening here is probably seen in the community. So I always appreciate this one and seeing the numbers this year. And then hearing I can touch on the comparison between us and other areas is promising

085and helpful. So I appreciate it. - You're welcome. And I would love to have these results for other clients I'm gonna go talk to that are actually looking at a bond referendum or operating levy like tomorrow night. Not gonna be as positive. They're actually going. So I mean, it really does speak well of what's happened. Absolutely. - Thanks very much. - You're welcome. - Other questions? Yes. - I just have a comment and that is to thank our district for these results and to see how we are kind of bouncing back. Is there work to do? Absolutely. But these are very promising and I appreciate the work that goes into it because I know it's not easy on district staff, our principals, our teachers. I love seeing that as we get closer to those that

086touch the kids, we get that higher rating. So I just wanna thank those that are working in this district to make this happen. Because it's not been easy. - I mean, they're expanding. In '21 and '22 in many districts, it was actually the community was more positive parents. So you don't have that in, now your parents are, you know, and that's important. That's the constituency. And that also helps build momentum. If your key constituency is talking about it, that helps intensify feelings. - Oh, I was just, you kind of reflecting what Chris said. I just hope the teachers see how favorably they can rate it. I hope they get a chance. I mean, I know it's gonna be on the website, it's in our minutes. - Tiffany's probably already sent an email. (people laughing) -

087I just don't think they hear enough, just how important they're to families in the community and that their work is appreciated and the sacrifices and, you know, all the things that do that are unseen by most people. But parents see it and so it's so great. - Okay. And I just wanna say thank you and I know one of the things, I'm one of those that we never, we won't leave. My family's been here forever. It's just this is our home. We've enjoyed the community. We supported the school, we've been in the school for all my family. A lot of us have come through. So we're really tied to this community, this school. And I think that helps the positivity because it's our home and it's our school. And we have pride. Go Bears. Thank

088you. - It's not transient, shall we say, that if I don't like it, I'll just go elsewhere. You wanna stay here and fix it. Yeah, absolutely. - Right. - Super. A pleasure. - Thank you very much. - Next on the agenda is B.3, Lincoln Elementary update. Dr. Gillespie. - I will introduce Brian Morris, principal of Lincoln Elementary and then Christine Belford who is the instructional coach. They're here to share more about their great work. - Thank you, Dr. Gillespie, Dr. Kazmierczak, Board Members. My name is Brian Morris. I'm the principal at Lincoln Elementary. Lincoln Elementary, three short blocks through the snow that way. And this is Christine Belkor. She is our instructional coach at Lincoln and at Vadnais Heights Elementary and a key component in our success. But just, I'm in charge of clicking. Okay.

089So just to give you a quick snapshot, take a look at the crests. We are Lincoln Elementary. One of the things that I'm gonna talk about is our house system. I am a member of Quantum, House of Respect. Mrs. Belford is in house... - Compasio, House of Empathy. And we'll talk about that a bit lately, but it's one of the components of our school. It's one of the ways that we are working towards meeting our strategic goals at Lincoln. As a lot of you know, Lincoln is a vibrant neighborhood school. We're close to downtown, close proximity to White Bear Lake, Bald Eagle, Otter and Birch. We're known for our commitment to student achievement, our welcoming atmosphere and active parent involvement and just a passion to partner with families as we prepare children to reach their

090hopes and dreams. We have about, well, exactly right now. 470 students served by 56 staff members. And that's all staff. We have 20 class homerooms at Lincoln, 17 in K-5. So that's pretty much three classrooms at every grade level and then three classrooms in the explorations program. Those are multi-age classes of our district wide gifted and talented program. And we'll talk about that a little bit more later. The specialist rotation that we offer are PE, music, art and Spanish. We also have a small but very strong special service cluster, providing emotional and behavior support for students. And like I said, the explorations program for highly gifted students. Like I said, about three classrooms at every grade level. And I know that the staff members, it is just incredible, not only our teachers, but our skilled

091and supportive staff in nutrition, playground, cafeteria, our paraprofessionals, our custodians, our professionals and student support services. It's a real team, a real student focused, family focused team that I am incredibly proud of. Christine was giving me a hard time about rocking it old school with paper. Paper. It's pretty professional up here. Slowing me down. Okay. I'm just quickly... I mean, you can read it. You've got the board notes, but our mission and our objectives and our strategic tactics... Those are mission objectives and tactics that we updated two years ago. I really want to point them out because some of the programs or the work that we're doing is really, two components are really focused on showing you how we are working towards our strategic tactics. The highlighted, things we're gonna highlight tonight. One is tiered

092academic support. So how do we support our kids? How do we work towards that personalized learning experience? Another is our house system. That is our main tool in the tactic of creating a connected culture within our school. And then third, we're gonna take a look at the explorations program that is a district wide program that is housed at Lincoln. And also, again, our books. I was behind a click. There we go. Notice that within our first tactic that will nurture the whole child through a personalized learning experience. That's where you see our tiered academic support. Right? That's where you see how we address equitable access to learning, differentiated learning and high academic standards. At the beginning of this school year, at the beginning of every school year, all of our schools create academic goals, equity

093goals, family engagement goals and social emotional goals for our student. Just to give you a flavor of sort of how we're reaching towards our academic goal, what we're going through right now at Lincoln... Our Lincoln academic goals for all students are that from fall to spring, Fastbridge screening. So Fastbridge is a standardized test system that we use for screening kids fall, winter and spring. From fall to spring, beginning of the year to the end of the year, 90% of all Lincoln students will either increase a risk level band or remain in low risk or make sufficient progress towards their IEP goals. And again, it's measured by these tools that are aReading and early reading for the younger grades, aMath and early math for the older. - [Board Member] Mr. Morris, just for a few, can

094you explain what a risk level band is? - [Brian] Yes. - You found it. - I'm on it. So when we think about risk level, it's the risk of not performing at, not meeting grade level standards. So if I am high risk of not meeting grade level standards, that's where we don't want to be. Right? High risk means there's a good chance that at the end of this school year, I'm not gonna meet grade level standards. If we are at low risk, that means there's a small chance I might not make grade level standards, might not perform at grade level standards, but it's a pretty low probability. So we want kids to be in that low risk category. All right? And again, if you think about, so back to sort of what this academic goal

095means. And I gotta get it explained now because when we look at the next slide, it's gonna be even more confusing. We want our kids in low risk, we call it the low risk band, or you can think of it as a bucket. We want our bucket of students to be in low risk, or they also have a grouping called advanced that's above that. And we want our kids to be moving up, right? If a student begins the school year, high risk, so a student is very probable of not performing at grade level by the end of the school year, there's a big difference between being at high risk and at low risk. But we want that student moving up. Like student growth is a pre-K to 12 and beyond process. And we want them

096always growing and we want accelerated growth. If a student is just growing sort of the same year to year, they're gonna stay in a band, right? A risk band. If they are having increased growth, they're gonna be moving up in those risk bands. So we want 90% of our students to either move up in a risk band, in other words, become lower risk for performing below grade level. Or if they're already at low risk or advanced, we want them to stay there, right? We don't want them dropping down. All right. So think of that. Think of that idea of swooping up from left to right. When you take a look at the next slide, this graph, all right? Green is low risk. Blue is advanced. This year, and this is just a snapshot of our

097fourth grade. When we talk about our goals, we think about every grade level. Snapshot of our fourth grade students. We began the year with 76% of our fourth grade students in reading at low risk or advanced. So in the green or the blue, where we want them to be at least. All right? So, excuse me, 76% are starting there. By the end of the school year, we want 90% either there or at least having moved up, having, went the wrong direction with my hands, having moved up from red to yellow or from yellow to green. All right? So maintaining low risk or moving up in the risk bands. Like I said, we do screening three times per year. We just completed our winter screening a week ago. And just again, looking at fourth grade and

098reading, we began the year with 76% of our fourth graders in the low risk slash advanced, at our winter check in, 82% have moved up in their risk band or remained in low in advance. And like I said, our goal is 90% by spring. I love this graph, even though it's super confusing because it shows you where kids are going. All right? If you look if you start at the red, okay? We started the year in fourth grade with three students down in the red. Two of them remain in the red. One of them swooped up from red across the yellow and into the green. That's super impressive that that student was able to accomplish that. If we look at our yellow, right, that's the sum risk. That's sort of a medium range. We had

09910 students that started there. Of those 10, three moved up, which was great. Of those 10, two moved down into the red, which is not what we wanna see. That's not the direction our kids should be going. If you look at our green, we started out with 17 in the green, 17 in the low risk. Three moved up into that blue in advance. We did have one move down from the low risk into the sum risk. So down from the green into the yellow. But overall, our kids are moving in the right direction. And like I said, by spring, we're shooting for 90% being there. So that's just a snapshot. Just to give you numbers, math is similar but different. We started out with 69% in the low risk and advanced. They are moving up.

100But right now in winter, we've got 78% in math in fourth grade that have moved up or remained in those risk bands that we want them in. All right. So that's my sort of snapshot of how we progressively measure over the course of the school year how our kids are growing. The next part is what do we do about it? Right? Christine is our big what do we do about it person. I got to click the slide. Here we go. - I'm the action girl. - She's the action girl. - [Christine] Having tiered instructions, not unique to Lincoln... Did you have a question? - I was wondering on the Fastbridge of the session, is it, I can't remember the terminology of the word. Is it the same set of questions across the board or does

101it go up and down based off of the answers that the students are giving? - It goes up and down based off the answers. So it adjusts. - Really determining it all. - It's determining sort of where you are. So if you get the first problem wrong, it's gonna say, well, let's try maybe something a little bit easier and see how she does on that. If you get the first problem right, let's see... And that's a simplified version of it. But it'll, you know, let's challenge her more to see where she's really at. So it really narrows in on that. Yep. - Thanks. - [Christine] So having a tiered plan isn't unique to Lincoln, but it's something we really are focusing on this year because we want to hit that goal of having all of

102our students show growth. And so just just to kind of go over what the tiers mean, a tier one is all of our students, no matter who you are or what your needs are, we consider everyone tier one and everyone gets what we call our core instruction. And then some students we call tier two. And there are some students that they need some additional small group instruction in order to show some progress. And then we have a few students who need tier three, which are some additional more intensive instruction. And so what we're doing this year at Lincoln is we just finished up all this Fastbridge testing with the data guy I just went over with you. And last week during our PD day, all the grade levels did some data driven dialogue and they

103looked at their grade level data and they figured out which students were tier two, some risk, not reaching the year end grade level standards, and which students were tier three high risk or not reaching the year end grade level standards. And so then this week, we are going to meet as grade level teams and we are going to look at now some diagnostic data that they have given their students to figure out why they're not reading at the level we would expect them to read. We're gonna analyze all this data about each of these individual students and come up with a plan for instruction so that we can get these students to make this progress with the school that we have as a collective group of staff for them. And so we're gonna progress monitor

104and every six weeks we're gonna come back as a group and just keep talking about these kids and not letting anyone forget about them because they are important. And we're gonna make sure we work together to get them to get the goal. - Awesome. Thank you. And yeah, and Christine is really the person who organizes, especially not so much the identifying who needs support, but the what to do about it part, right? She is our specialist in coaching the staff and to supporting the kids with differentiated personalized instruction. All right. So again, these tiered systems, this data review is done similarly in all of our schools. I just thought, A, little bit of a deep dive into what's going on right now and B, it's what's in our heads right now. So it's easiest to

105present about the thing that's most, the biggest thing that we're doing at the moment. The next part that I wanted to... So that's an example of one of the ways that we're working towards our tactic one. Our tactic two is to create a connected community within our school. And we are doing a lot of work with that through what we call our house system. Our house system is based on a system... A man named Roy Clark had created this idea at a school... I forget what the school is. But we have a teacher who had traveled to this school, Roy Clark, where they have really looked at a way to make everybody feel like they belong, not just to a large school, like 270 kids, is a lot of kids, not just to a classroom,

106but to belong to a larger group within the school, and within that larger group, a smaller group. So we are organized into houses. And like I said, there are five of them. And, you know, like I said, at its core is to create a connected culture. Our overall goal is to increase and strengthen student adult relationships and student to student relationships sort of across all grade levels. If you think about a student in an elementary school, like the number one adult for that student is the teacher. And then you have, you know, I have connection with all the kids in the school, but I'm like a second tier guy, right? I'm the principal. I have a lower level than the teacher with all of them. But some students have the reading specialist is another teacher

107that's big in their life. Every student in the school has the PE teacher, the music teacher, the art teacher, the Spanish teacher as being an adult in their life. When we create the houses, now these children also have the other adults in their house. So I have, you know, I spend more time with kids in quantum than I do with kids across the building. And within each of these houses, we have a house family. So I have a house family that's, what, next slide. We'll go back to this one. The giant house family selfie. My face is bigger than everybody else's, but they are more important than me. I was just holding the camera. But that's just a snapshot of my... And Leah Armstrong. She's a fifth grade teacher. Our house family within Quantum. That

108house family has done... We do a service family service project or growth activity every quarter. We also have a whole school house assembly every quarter. But just this idea... So this snapshot was last year. Each of our families made those cool knot blankets for Serenity, for the senior center. We've also packed snack bags for kids at other schools. This year we also, for Serenity, we created sort of a holiday gift candle for adults at Serenity and one other adult care facility. But just that idea that these kids are building these relationships both vertically with students across grade level. They're having more adults that are like their adult trusted adult contact. We think is gonna really bring that connected culture to Lincoln that we hope to gain. And then the third piece that I wanted to

109speak to was the Explorations program. I don't have this in my notes. The Explorations program has been part of White Bear schools for 10 years, I think. Since 2015. It's a program for highly gifted students from every school and some open enrollment students. This year and last year as well we have three mixed grade classrooms. Right now I think we have 74 kids across the three classrooms. The Explorations program has an accelerated curriculum. So for instance in math, everybody is at least one grade level up. We have instruction that is tailored to the gifted learner. A lot of our learning, especially around literacy and social studies are around themed explorations. We have things like Exploration Academy where students have opportunities to explore areas of their interest. We have a monthly maker space. This next slide

110just our Explorations program does a lot of their learning and especially history learning in White Bear. So you will see them going to farmers market on Fridays when the weather is nice. You will see them here traveling to City Hall to learn about city government. You will see them traveling to the History Center or the Historic House in downtown White Bear to learn more about, you know, not just their passions, but also sort of their place, learning more about the community and their place in the community. And that's what I think is really one of the strengths of the Explorations program, and it feeds nicely off the fact that we are so close to downtown. But like I said, it is a district wise sort of a school within a school. We do provide bus

111service for students from anywhere within the district and it's a great program to serve a portion of our student population that really needs to be pushed in ways that sometimes could be difficult in your general classroom. That is it. Questions that... Thank you for listening. Questions that people have? - The Explorations program, are they also part of the house system? - Yes. Yep. - I know that at least from my understanding the Explorations program used to be invited into... So parents can either opt in or opt out. - Correct. - Do you know what the factors are? What they're looking at? What those letters are sent out to? - You mean like how we decide who we invite? It's based on a an assessment called the CogAT. The cognitive, cognitive assessment test. I think that's

112what it stands for. So we administer all second graders in CogAT. So it's everyone gets screened. So this is, it's a program that is not just you know teacher recommendation by any means, right? So everyone is screened using the CogAT and then a second component, our house achievement component is how students in second grade have achieved on their aReading and aMath so that Fastbridge assessment, and then the third is the LISI. And I don't know what LISI stands for but it's a teacher assessment or a teacher survey in how self-directed a student might be, sort of outside of the box creative thinking, things along those lines. So take those three components put them in to a formula, right, and then we essentially invite about the top 5% of students that are in those categories using

113those three tools. Usually we invite about 40 to 45 students to start in third grade and in 20 to 25 decide that that's the right choice for their kids. And yeah, it's a very strong program that's been strong for years we've had you know it has in the past sort of flopped back and forth between two classrooms and three. We've been at three for two years now and I hope that's where we stay, about, you know, kids in the, 70 to 80 kids would be great. - One other thing with... I love the information on growth because I think that tells a much better story than when people normally are just, the 56%, you know, at grade level and I think the growth tells a much more intricate story. What I would like to see

114is what I think would be even more helpful would be to follow the cohorts through. Because just seeing one snapshot of you here really doesn't tell you anything other than just that one year. It would be really helpful to see that same group over a series of years. Does the risk, high risk go up? Does it keep continuing to go down for a couple years for the same cohort? I think that's information that would be really helpful as well. - Yeah, and that's what I mean- - And I know you guys are looking at it. - Right, and my goal is just to give you sort of a snapshot of what the work looks like. But yeah, and that is something we look at like and students take a Fastbridge assessment every year from kindergarten

115through fifth grade so that we can identify what their needs are in real time in any given year and how are they growing over that you know that entire six year span of elementary school. - I mean it's a great thing because you can do interventions real time as opposed to a lot of standardized tests where you don't know until after the fact. So there's nothing you can do until basically a year later. - Yeah. - Jen and I will bring some more overall data to all of you and I can't remember the exact meeting but we're working on that with the screening and trying really hard to get better and better and making sure that we're looking good. We'll make a note and do what we can do. - Ms. Streiff Oji. - So,

116one, I love that your mission statement says that you nurture the mind, body and hearts of your kids. So thank you for that. Can you share just how you determine your interventions? Is that determined at the district level? How is that training done? Like... - So at the district actually we've been doing a lot of work on kind of aligning our interventions and making sure, and doing some learning on what type of interventions are appropriate, especially... Do you know that we have a new literacy? Yes. And so we've also done all this learning with letters. And we know that our students need an aligned experience and have been a part of a really great team where we have taken a look at our new literacy and all of this learning we've done with letters. And

117we are coming up with, as a district, an intervention plan for these Tier 2 and Tier 3, so that our students are going to get learning that when they leave their classroom, it's not going to be new learning because we know that they're going to learn best when, oh, I've been doing something very similar in my classroom with my teacher. And so we are, we have a really great team working on that and those are the things I'm using with the teachers that I work with so that they can get a head start on those things. I'm really excited for it. - I just wanna say LETRS is, for people that maybe don't know, student outcomes looking at LETRS. - LETRS is, that approach- - Nice. - It's not spelled right- - It's not spelled

118right. Yeah. - It's not. But it's a- - It's a cute name. - You're not looking at LETRS. You're looking at the strategies you use to teach reading as designed by Read Act and many other great research things that we, anyway, that wasn't a question. That was a comment. But I was gonna ask you a question, Christina. When you're looking at all the data driven discussions and drilling it down to individualized students, which parents really appreciate having individualized instruction for their children, especially struggling with children, how is that impacting when you finally feel that you need to make a referral with special education? I'm guessing that you're referring to kids that are the right kids that might need more instruction in that area, that qualify for those kinds of special services. So you're working with

119kids a lot before they get to that point, right? So maybe the kids are the right kids that qualify for special education. I just thought you should comment on that, being a former special education teacher. - So actually, so this year is when we've really had all these tools in place, the curriculum resources and some of these other diagnostic tools. And this fall, we started really using them and we had some referrals and we're like, let's wait, let's see the progress that we make. And two of these students, they moved up and showed us that they're not having these concerns anymore, because what we've done is showing that they're making the progress. - [Board Member] So you give the right instruction and they're basically maybe not having- - They're not showing the need any more.

120- [Board Member] Learning disability or some other other category of special education. - Right. Right. They just needed the right instruction. They're not showing a disability in those two situations. So the work we did showed that intervention was appropriate and it wasn't necessary for a referral. - Thank you. - Okay, go ahead. - This actually might be a question for the house. I'm just wondering in terms of the teacher training for the LETRS... It obviously seems to be working in the cases that they've been presented with. How have we made sure that it's been... How have we made sure the fidelity of the program is across all schools and all teachers? I mean, it goes up and down based on who buys into it, who's got their own way of doing things. - We're working

121really hard on that. So LETRS is the professional development in the science of reading. And so really, it's a two-year process. 95% of our K-5 teachers have completed it. So this would be their first year that they're not also doing LETRS training, you know, really is the sole focus for professional development. - Is there an assessment? I mean, that two-year process, that's kind of my issue with the fidelity of it, is because you're going through two years worth of training. How do we know at the end of that two years training, two years of training, that they know their stuff? - Yeah. I get the question. The two years is really intense learning. I mean, teachers almost have a process because they haven't learned this way of teaching literacy in teacher education programs, of like

122almost morning. Like, this is how I taught four, how do I grow in that? So that's the focus. Meanwhile, we also adopted a new curriculum. And so between all of that, we have an instructional leadership group, our district instructional leadership group with elementary, which includes teacher leaders, principals, instructional coaches. And they talk about how are we observing and really looking at that fidelity. And so they're working, I'm not gonna remember the statistics, but they're really working on how are we making sure that this is happening. Not just hoping that this happens, but diving into it. And so they talk about we're doing walk-throughs. I have walked through many classrooms with that. And so you're really partnering with teachers and educators to say, where is it difficult? How are we aligning the curriculum? And so we're

123knee deep in that right now. And really, that's our focus. How do you go to deep implementation so that we have, we take out the variability? A huge thing that's helping our educators is looking at that data. So when we look across the board, we look at different schools, we look at different grade levels, but people just say, what's going on for first grade, second grade? How do we come together? Because maybe we're seeing faster growth in one area. And so all of that is, when you think of system change, we have been very aggressive. And people have leaned in and we have people, I'm so proud of the work that we've done, but you're in the middle. So you're asking the question that we too are asking, and then how do you partner together

124around that? - [Board Member] So are the teachers, are they working together by grade level within the schools they like, like obviously they normally do, but are they also looking across? - Yes, I feel like I'm stealing all the thunder, Jen is a huge part of all of this. But the principals who are here... I want to hear that this is like a huge team effort. But yes, we have elementary communities of practice that meet every single professional development day, and each grade level across our whole district, every single grade comes together, and that's led through professional development around curriculum implementation with a principal and an instructional coach. And so when you think about, it's really, it's amazing just what they do on those days, and diving in, and people are, that was a need

125that people identified. Not only do we need time in our buildings, but we need to do vertical. So yes. - Thank you. - Thanks, Jen. - One more question. - Very quick, Brian. - Yes. I just wondered how do you find the time for the houses to meet? I mean, when do you carve out time on the busy school day for houses across grade levels? - That's an excellent question. And it's a hard balance, right? So here's a tactic that is going to build a culture of learning and sort of collaboration within our school, this... But that's not something that's easily measured, that's not something you're going to see on our MDE report card and all that, right? And so here's something that we feel is very important, that is going to affect academics, affect

126our students' long term growth, hopefully well beyond our school. But we have to find time for it. So that balance between, yes, this is super important, but no, we can't do it every day. So that's, like I said, we have one all school assembly per quarter. That's about 30 minutes and one 30 to 40 minute house family meeting per quarter. So, yeah, and it's really hard. And that's, you know, when we have conversations, there are some staff that would like more of it. And sometimes we have to push back on that. But really, and it's also doing things that we've been doing in the past, but now in the context of houses. So, for instance, we don't have a student council anymore. We have heads of houses that are sort of our student, sort of

127student leaders within the building. I know that we've got a, February is Black History Month and it's also... - I love to read month. And our reading tallies all have to do with reading enough to earn a star that goes on the outside of your house family door. Right? Something that's happening outside of class, but it's building that community with inside the school. But that is a hard thing. Like we cannot go whole hog into something that might take away too much more academic time. So, it's a balance. - All right. Oh, sorry. - Just saying. I'm Dan Skaar. I'm the new Board Member. I just want to introduce myself and say thank you for the meaningful report. I understood this actually. So that was a good thing. (people laughing) - It's a win. -

128The other thing is... I noticed that you use Latin for your crests. Does that mean you want to become like a Latin immersion school? Probably don't get a lot of people left... - No. And we do know enough Latin to say that really is, or is that, I don't know. Is that just like fake Latin? And I don't know the answer... - It is real Latin. - Okay. Well, then yes. We are White Bear's new Latin immersion school. (people laughing) But yeah, no, I got a few Latin phrases and none of 'em are good. Well, thank you. - Thank you for coming by. All right, next on our agenda is B.4. Dr. Gillespie, you wanna introduce? - Yeah, as John's coming up here, I will introduce John Leininger, who's the principal at Matoska International School.

129I'd just like to give our elementary principals a shout out. They've been at work since 7 o'clock this morning. So thank you for being here today. - Absolutely, thank you for having me. Thanks for sticking around. I don't know if I'm last, but I kind of wanna just say everything that Mr. Morris said, like ditto, because I just, call it good. I appreciate you having me, taking the time. I'm John Leininger, principal at Matoska International. It's nice to meet you, Mr. Skaar. Thank you for that introduction. I've seen you around. It's nice to hear. So there is a lot to share about Matoska. I'm really excited about it. I am not gonna be able to get to everything about Matoska, but I'm sure I'm gonna enthrall you, and you'll be able to stay, and we

130can talk afterwards. But we'll get this through so the people who have families can get home. Do I push the down arrow on here? - No, no. There you go. - Okay, a little delay. - Arrow right. Arrow right. - Arrow right? Gotcha. Ah, there we are. Matoska. So this is our mission statement. I'm not going to read through it, but our mission statement comes out of the strategic planning process, which was done a few years ago and then redone as well. And it's something that I really appreciated about that process. It wasn't a top-down approach. It was about our families and communities articulating what they wanted in their schools, our teachers saying this is what's important. And as we saw in our previous presentation, our families are highly involved. Our families really want to

131be involved. They care about their schools. They love their schools. They love their teachers. And so as part of this process, we work with our, you know, the Matoska families, our PTO members, members in the community, not necessarily even part of the PTO, and our teachers, and we say, what is it about the school that you attend, that you want and hope for. I should probably take a small step back. You know, for some people who are not familiar, Matoska, we are in the south end of the school district near Century College. We're primarily a choice school, so families in White Bear Lake get to choose to come to us. We have a small attendance area, as we used to say, like, if you can throw baseball in a backyard, we wanna make sure that

132you are able to come to us. So we're excited that we can draw those families right in our neighborhood, but as well, most of our families choose to come here and join us at Matoska International. And so our families said that, you know, learning is important. They said that having a developmentally appropriate teaching and learning, using research-based strategies, our families said it was important to recognize and evaluate and have a deeper understanding of each child's cultural and personal identities. Our families said that we wanted a commitment to establish and nurture strong relationships within our learning communities. Our families said they wanted to provide safe, supportive environment through equitable practices, and our families said that we wanted to encourage students and staff agency through meaningful interactions. So from there, then we developed our strategic objectives. And

133I think of note here, you'll notice they're bullet pointed. They're not numbered. They're not in an order of importance. They're not as one is more important. These are things that our teachers and families in community said. All of these things are important. But we know that we want each child to feel welcome, safe, and appreciated for who they are. It was important that 100% of our students demonstrate individualized growth in their learning. 100% of the students are prepared for future learning. And then each student makes a positive impact within the school and broader community. And a little bit as I was listening to Mr. Morris and Lincoln, it's really about growth. It's really about getting each child to that next step, finding out what are their needs, what are their hopes and dreams, what do

134they need in mathematics, what are they need in reading, and then helping us get them to that next level. So many of things that that they talked about are very similar with our our intervention program and how we identify the students, we identify what their needs are, and then how we can meet those students where they're at and get them to the next. As I sometimes say, like I have two children of my own at home. One of them was an early walker, one was a late walker, one of them is not exceptionally gifted, one of them is not developmentally delayed. We know children grow in leaps and bursts and spurts. And our job is to find out where are you at, what is that next step that you need to get to your next

135learning. So we set some goals around those strategic objectives. We know that we are in a constant state of improvement. I hear a lot, and for better or for worse, and I apologize, but the pandemic was a point in time that was really difficult. We had many students came, many of them did exceptionally well, many of those families and students, they struggled. And so we were all over the place. We are in that process of building back in our data, and I'll share some of the data in a minute. We're showing really good success in that growth. So we decided that we needed to spread our academic goals and that Fastbridge reading, as you heard Mr. Morris talk about, into two parts because we knew we needed to get to our 80%, that we needed

136to make sure that our goal was challenging, but also reasonably attainable. So in the first year we're going to get to 74%. We'll be at that low risk, as Mr. Morris talked about in our Fastbridge reading. And then 80% by the next year. We also want to collect and are collecting and analyzing data that to the extent that students feel safe, valued, engaged, and connected at school. We know one of the best indicators to a child's success is being connected, engaged in school. And one of those things is have we asked our children, are you connected? Are you engaged? Let's talk to the people who are actually here, talk to our clients and ask, you know, are you engaged in school? Then we also know that that relationship is huge and that relates directly to

137that engagement, which is our relationship with our families and our historically marginalized families are so important to learning. And we saw that again with our slide before, like our families trust us. We need to keep them engaged. We need to keep our families engaged. Not all of our families are always engaged and it's a part of our job is to reach out and say, hey, we wanna help your child learn. We want you to feel welcome. We want you to know what's going on at school. Let us help you help your children get to school to get that academic achievement, to make it, you know, make yourself propel forward. So the primary focus, we have been in that LETRS training. We are part of that small percentage that is in year two. So our teachers

138are in that second year of that LETRS training. Again, it's a very intensive program. Teachers say it's a lot of work, but it's really rewarding. It's fun to see teachers learning. They are educators at their hearts. They love to learn. They love to know more. What's also exciting is when you hear things like, you know, our world is changing. What we know about learning is changing. We shouldn't be stuck at some point in time. We need to, as we constantly learn about new ways to teach, new ways to engage kids and how our brains are working, it's just incredibly valuable. So our teachers, while they know it's a lot of work, they are highly engaged in it and are appreciative of it. And then we are also in that, our second year of the CKLA

139Amplify, our new literacy curriculum. What's exciting about that is our, last year was our first year. It was a really good year. With any first year, there is a lot of learning that goes on. Now, it's like, okay, as we are going through our units, we're going through our knowledge units, we're just like, okay, I remember this. I get this. I can figure this out. And our teachers, it's really, it's hard to explain, but that learning curve is super exciting. How it's like, the wheels are just moving in wonderful ways. So, by the numbers, I promised you some numbers, like, you know, how are we doing? So, when we talked about that FAST, the Fastbridge specifically, the FAST, there's a number of different sections within the Fastbridge suite, the CBM benchmark. When we looked at

140our numbers through the course of the year last year, every grade level increased, moving from, you know, moving into that lower risk category. Everybody is growing. Every grade level is moving the right direction. And not only moving the correct direction on every grade level, on average, 11.2% increase at each level. So, we are not just maintaining, but we are growing on average about 11.2%, moving towards that goal. So, more kids are learning, are getting into that low risk at a very high rate. So, when I think about our goals that we were talking about before, we really should be able to achieve that, but we will see. In our student survey, 99.4% feel that their teachers care about them. 96.1% feel connected to their classmates. 89.6% feel comfortable talking to an adult about things that

141bother them. Again, trying to build that relationship and connection. Relationships and connections are gonna really help our students achieve in their reading, writing, and math. But we need them engaged in school. And then as well, you know, the family and parent engagement has been important. And each team held this year a family engagement event. And that was, I had a lot of hopes for that, and it exceeded that. And one of the things that we think about with schools is that as I talked a lot about those relationships, but having relationships with families is really important. And we noticed in our previous presentation, there was some conversations about behavior, right? Concerns about behavior. And one of the beliefs and one of the things that we know is that if we have a good relationship with

142our parents, when we have a problem or challenge, and we call them up, and you have a positive relationship, that parent is gonna be like, on it. Let me help you out because I know that the school is there to help my child out. My teacher wants my child to learn. I'm gonna help out. So we're gonna build this positive, connected relationship. So all of those things we're seeing as we build those relationships is improving our student's academic achievement. They all go together. So what's in our future? We're not doing Latin immersion, although that would be really cool. But we are doing our Spanish dual immersion. We are excited to know that we had a board presentation earlier. We are well on our way to doing that. There is a lot. One of the things

143I've been in White Bear for quite a while, and I was at a recent conversation with Mr. Wald is like, you know, one of the things I've always loved about White Bear Lake, because I've been here a long time, and if you know me as a personality, I'm a risk taker. I will go anywhere, do anything. People are like, why are you still in White Bear Lake? Because every turn, White Bear Lake has provided a challenge and opportunity to learn, to grow, to excel. So just when I'm thinking, well, I'm just poached out of here in five years, they're like, immersion! I'm like, awesome! Let's do it. Let's figure this out. So I'm excited. So we're bringing immersion to Matoska, to Otter Lake, and to Matoska. You know, the enrollment started. Gangbusters, I don't know

144how to describe it, 75 students are already enrolled at Matoska International, both for our English and our Spanish. They're about half and half. But if you think about that, we are 75, which is about 75% of our facility, and it's like we are just at the end of January. We are doing really well. We're bringing students in. When we talk about bringing immersion, it's really important... We first talk about a great kindergarten experience. And as I've toured families for English, as I've toured families for Spanish, the common denominator really is we want a great experience for our kindergartener. It's like, absolutely. And so our Spanish track and our English track, that's gonna be our first and foremost as we move forward. The other thing we talked about, you know, at Matoska is like, we are

145one school, like White Bear Lake, we're one school. So it's not gonna be us and them. It's not the Spanish or the English. It's Matoska. It is White Bear Lake. And it just so happens that we are getting our instruction and curriculum based on the language that those families choose and want to have for their children. We are happy to serve the families. This is what you want. We can provide this for you. So where we're at, our design team, thanks to Jen, is working hard, and Ayan is over there in the background. We have to make sure to recognize the work that she's doing, working on the curriculum, alignment, scope and sequence, trainings, professional development. Our administration team is working on staffing. And one of the things that I really enjoy, and it has

146been fun about the staffing part, because if you've heard much about immersion schools, staffing is one of those things that really come up. And what we're finding out is people want to come to White Bear Lake. People wanna work in White Bear Lake. It's a testament to who we are as a community, to our schools, when educators are saying, I wanna go work there. So lots to be proud of there. All right, so this is where I get to be a risk taker. A few, in our immersion presentation, not long ago before the holidays, my colleague at the high school shared awesome morning announcements that they do videotape and their high school students put 'em together. It's pretty polished. We do video announcements at Matoska. I get to do them. And I'm gonna get a

147chance to share one. But I have to put a couple little asterisks there, because this is not a high budget production. I do 172 of them, and they've gotta get done. And the kids always say, I see your mouth moving, because we do puppet shows. It's like, yeah, it's me with the puppets. But the evolution is kind of fun, because I'm not sure how many of you remember from elementary school, do anybody remember the principal's morning announcements? It was just never the highlight. Right? My wife talks about remembering hearing that she had a library book going on back in the day. I say, well, we don't do that. No one's listening to the principal. So okay, we're going to then get the principal on the screen. We're gonna come to the 21st century. It is

148still the principal doing this. And so as part of some of our curriculum, we had puppets in our second step curriculum, there are puppets, and then we've added puppets to it. And now Principal John Leininger gets to share part of their curriculum message from our second step curriculum, and we bring in puppets. So I'm going to finish... Bear with me with, a three minute morning announcement. The B quality. Matoska students and staff, this is Principal John Leininger with your morning announcements. It is Monday. We are ready for a great week and we are looking forward to getting a lot done. As we usually do on Monday, we think about our week ahead. We can think about what we're going to be learning. All the great things that we can do to engage our learning. So

149I want everyone to be thinking about not only what you're gonna be learning, but like what are the best ways that you can do that. So much of it is about listening, following directions, engaging in your learning, which means eyes watching, ears listening, all of those things that we know help us learn. Speaking of good things here at Matoska, we have bear paws here. Good things happening. Want to give a shout out here to Luca. Luca was a leader when he helped out the sub. Hey, thanks for being a leader and thanks for being a helper. We love those helpers. We have a shout out here to Ramsey in kindergarten. Waiting for a friend to go out to recess. Hey, way to be a great, compassionate friend, like, you know, friends are awesome and we

150treat our friends well. That is really wonderful. And lastly, we are a shout out here to Prince Jaden in first grade who had a super day, helping classmates, being an awesome leader, and caring for others. Nicely done, Jaden. We are so proud of all of you. That concludes our announcements for today. So we want to say thanks. We'll see you all in the hall. - Oh, we've been talking so much about our feelings and emotions. - Yeah, these are really important to talk about. - I have a funny question. Like I sometimes don't understand like what's the difference between being sad and being worried? - Oh that's really a tough one. Like sad and worried are a lot alike. - Yeah, they sure are. - But it's not that hard to understand. Like just think

151about that pizza. - Oh, I don't wanna think about the pizza. It was just, love the pizza flop. - Yeah, the pizza flop. You were pretty sad. - Oh, I was so sad. I mean, the pizza flopped and it was on the ground and I was wanting to eat it like, oh, I just was sad. I lost my pizza. - Yeah, that's sad. But when you're worried is when you're thinking about something that might happen in the future. - Like I'm gonna drop my pizza again? Oh, no. - Yeah, that's when you're worried that you're gonna drop your pizza again. But that's okay. You can make a plan. - A plan? - Yeah, you can make a plan. So like next time you have pizza, you can like carry your pizza with two hands. -

152Oh, plan. I'll carry my pizza with two hands. - And then you can set it on the table and sit carefully so it won't fall off. - I'll sit at the table with two hands facing forward and then it won't fall down. Oh, that's helpful. Now I don't have to be worried about my pizza flop. - Yeah, it's sometimes tricky, but always make a plan if you're worried. And if you need help, you can ask your teacher or friends or parents or anyone who help you make a plan. - Oh, good idea. Make a plan. - Bye. (people laughing) (people clapping) - Thank you for allowing me to be a risk taker. Thank you for letting me share about Matoska. I'm happy to have- - Do we have any quick questions? Because I know that

153we have to stop at eight or we have to make a vote if we go past eight. So... - Do your fifth graders enjoy those as much as the kindergarteners? - Yeah. - We have a variety as well and then we also, in our Bear Paws, we happen to draw some of those things, but we also draw for academic things, kids that are learning something. We say, what are you learning? So we want to acknowledge that, hey, they learned their math. Other questions? - I just wanted to say kudos on your 11% increase, 11 plus percent increase on your Fastbridge results. What else I was going to point out? Just the way that you're honoring every student through your mission and your daily interactions and also the importance of social emotional learning and helping kids

154learn how to cope with everyday situations. So, your participation matters. Good to see you. Thanks for everything that you're doing. Can I say one more thing? LETRS. LETRS training. I just wanna make sure, because I've pointed this out before, but I wanna make sure that this, I say it again, that the statute, I think, was that folks started getting trained this year. And 95% of our teachers are done. So that's a big, huge deal. We are way ahead of many districts across the metro and across the state. So thank you. And I know you have a lot to do with that. - Thank you. - I just wanna say thank you for your years of enthusiasm, years of enthusiasm, and all the things that you've taken on. We should send you to the metro for

155school for you time. (people laughing) - To teach everyone. - You have a classroom. - Any final words? Thank you for coming. - Thank you. Thank you. Thanks for helping us out. - So if chocolate bars are coming up for sales again, let me know. - They are. As of today, actually, your timing is good. - I'll reach out. - We'll be giving you a call. - Okay. Thank you. - Thank you. - Okay. We have one more agenda item. We have C.1. Mr. Wald. - Thank you, Chair. Earlier this evening, or maybe about a lifetime ago, heard from Jim Eichten, the district's auditing firm, MMKR. He presented an audit for Fiscal Year 23-24. That's the next step in the annual process of the audit is for the school board to accept the report. And

156so the recommended action is for the school board to accept the fiscal year audit report as presented. - So in front of us, we have the recommended action to accept the Fiscal Year 23-24 audit report. Somebody would like to make a motion? Ms. Thompson, do you have a second? - Second. - By Streiff Oji. All right. Any discussion? Go ahead. - I probably have to abstain just because it was not my watch, even though I have a lot of questions. - Okay. Any other questions? That means it's a vote for... - This is a roll call. - Roll call? Okay. This is gonna be a roll call, so I'm gonna ask the clerk to call the roll. - Skaar. - Abstained. - Oh, sorry. I didn't know that. Streiff Oji. - Aye. - Thompson. -

157Aye. - Arcand. - Aye. - Beloyed. - Aye. - Daniels. - Aye. - Motion carries. Thank you. - Thank you. - So we're finally to the point of the agenda, so would somebody like to make a motion to adjourn? - Chair, Dr. Arcand, I make a motion. - Ms. Thompson, do we have a second? - I'll second. - Second. All right. This is a voice vote. All in favor of adjournment, say aye. - Aye. - Opposed? Same sign. Okay. We are adjourned.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.