001e it is 601 on uh December 10th 2024 is um this is our special meeting the truth and Taxation hearing I'm calling it to order um first thing is to approve the agenda the only thing on our agenda is number three discussion on truth and Taxation hearing then we have sorry there should one more thing public comment if there's anybody here which so far I don't see anybody here I'll make another request when we get to that point then adjournment so it is recommended that the school board approve the agenda for the special meeting truth in taxation December 2024 as presented we have a motion move vilia do I have a second second by Taylor um all those in favor say I I any oppos pass 60 all right let's get to the truth and
002Taxation part here with director um Patricia Magnuson to talk to us about what she wants to talk to us about good evening uh chair CL and members of the board I'm here to present on behalf of the board our truth and Taxation hearing so here's why we're here tonight um the law in Minnesota requires that we hold a public meeting about uh property taxes between November 27th and December 28th at 6 p.m. or later and it can be part of a regular scheduled meeting we have to allow for public comment and we can we are able to adopt the final Levy at the same meeting which we will be doing um which we have a recommended on the agenda for tonight we also have to present the current Year's budget and the proposed tax levy
003for taxes payable in 2025 so here's what the agenda looks like I'll give background information on school funding we'll talk about the current Year's budget we'll talk about the um proposed taxes payable in 2025 not 24 and then we can take time for public comment so the legislature basically sets school funding that's all this slide is about Mo every line item in the tax levy and in school funding um revenue is basically set by a funding formula so the state sets the form foras for most of the revenues a lot of them are based on amounts per pupil the state also sets tax policy for local school districts and other taxing jurisdictions but for us as a school district and then there's maximum authorized property tax levies so we can Levy less tonight as a
004school district um but we cannot just choose to Levy more than those formulas allow um oh and we can also um authorize voter approval for certain line items we did not have any voter approvals between last tax levy and this tax levy there's a couple of things about school funding um that we want to make sure that we're clear about the the general education funding formula which really isn't part of the tax levy but is the majority of revenue for school districts um lags behind inflation and we've been talking about some budget reductions we have next year year and that's a major portion of the of the reason um that Revenue just does not keep up if you look all the way to the right um on this funding formula grid this is a widely
005used graphic in the state of Minnesota for school districts and basically what it shows is that had funding kept up with the costs inflationary costs for school districts we would be receiving 8,645 per student and as as of current ly the the state law is $728 per student the difference between those dollar amounts is $5 million for St Louis Park so it gives you an idea um as that accumulates over time how um constrained our budgets are as costs push um push us higher way more quickly than Revenue another part is the underfunding of special education there's been a huge effort in the state of Minnesota to to fully fund the state's portion of special education costs the federal portion has has not um come through but we're very thankful for the increase in special
006education funding it frankly saved our budgets in these last couple of years so ultimately any change in the tax levy we're talking about tonight doesn't really mean our budget changes and there's several reasons behind that there's a bunch of state determined formulas that are set in state law it um we can't really just spend and then decide to to Levy there's formulas that determine most of that and some of the tax levies are Revenue neutral so we talk about equalized formulas so some funding formulas the state says if you get $100 50 is paid by by the tax levy 50 is paid through state aid and so sometimes the the legislature might make a change and say 60% of that is now going to be coming from the tax levy and only 40 from state
007aid so local levies go up but we didn't increase Revenue it's just shifting sort of from one pocket to the other we still get 100 bucks so that's one of the the biggest reasons that levies can change and no Revenue results from that our expenditure budget is limited by state formulas and those levies and fund balance and so we don't always um see an increase or decrease in taxes changing the budgets that much there's differences in different taxing jurisdictions school districts um budgets begin on July 1st so these taxes payable in 2025 that we're talking about tonight our Revenue not until next year so we record these revenues for 2526 different than the city um and County whose budget year begins on January 1st so they correlate um so here's our different budgets we've talked
008about this several times um these are the different budgets that the school district budgets within we put an asteris next to the ones that have a tax levy component so the general fund community service and Debt Service we Levy we have the authority to Levy within School nutrition and building construction are not levies this is an overall picture of the budget um it includes actuals for fiscal year 2024 and a budget for fiscal year 2025 um and it just shows that we are ending um last fiscal year at 8.27% fund balance we talked about that at the last board meeting we're very um thankful that we held our expenditures down and that we had some increases in Revenue particularly special education that helped us balance the budget and we intend to continue a balanced budget
009for this year and end the year at 8.25% we're working on that um as we speak this is what Revenue looks like um for all of our funds and the the reason for this is to just show that the majority of our revenue of course is in the general fund that's where the majority of our activity takes place so general fund is where all the the teaching and learning in our K12 school schools happens transportation of students the lights and the heat um some deferred maintenance costs um all of the administrative costs come out of the general fund Debt Service pays for a voter approved Debt Service principal and interest majority of that fund is um tax levy Revenue the community service fund pays for before and after school Child Care um the senior program
010and lots of other lifetime learning programs for adults and students after school and the school nutrition fund um pays for all of school nutrition so if you just look at that 73% of Revenue that's the general fund here's how the general fund breaks down the majority of Revenue is state revenue comes through state aid a small portion um we're back to a very small portion postco of federal revenue and then property taxes which we're going to be talking about tonight is about 30% of our overall Revenue there's a small part of local fees and AD and interest Revenue um that the general fund also receives on the expense side we are a salary organization um over 75 nearly 80% I didn't put percentages on here of our budget goes towards salary and benefits we hire
011teachers custodians other staff that's the majority of what we do purchase Services is the next largest portion um a large part of purchase Services is transportation we're an organization that outsources Transportation so that comes through as a purchase service um not as hired staff and then the the other portion is supplies and equipment if you then split that same expenditure budget by program instead of by um spending category you can see that the majority of our um funding goes into either direct classroom instruction or classroom support so for instance the elementary and secondary regular instruction is 43% of the budget special ad instruction 18% of the budget and then um pupil support Ser instructional Support Services first at 6% of the budget and then pupil Support Services another 11% that's mostly transportation and and then
012you can see the other components of the budget District support services and administration um District support are things like the business office um other departments that support um programs custodial that kind of thing so I'm going to talk a little bit about the tax levy how the levies is determined we'll compare last year's Levy to this year's Levy and the reasons for the changes and how that might impact taxpayers on their individual property tax bill so every owner of taxable property pays different taxing jurisdictions and you've seen your property tax bills there's the city the County watershed districts and we are the the school district the taxing jurisdiction in the state of Minnesota so we set our own Levy with limits in state law and henen county in our case sends out the tax bills
013and collects them so we work with the Department of Education and the county to compile um that data so they can complete the tax bills this is what a a tax um statement look like obviously it's not an invoice or a bill it helps um Property Owners know what their taxes might look like so they they can come to these taxing um these tax hearings and either make comment or ask get their questions answered our phone numbers are on those on on those statements so we can get phone calls as well so here's um School District property taxes are levied in about 40 different categories there's a bunch of really um detailed funding formulas but maximum Levy amounts that are calculated by de which is the Department of Education they're either set by state law
014or they're set by voter approval in a in a few very specific categories so these are the steps that happen in the property tax process so in the early part of um the calendar year the city or the county estimates the market value for each parcel of property and then the legislature meets between about January and May and sets um for formulas not only for taxes the legislature might change the way property taxes are levied but they also set Levy limits and formula limits and then the counting auditor calculates the tax capacity so the value that taxes are levied against and then the Department of Education we work with them right up until September 30th to set the levy limit for the school district and then we get to this part where the school board
015adopts the final Levy we send the final um calculations off to the county auditor and then they can actually Levy the specific taxes once boards and other jurisdictions have approved tax levies so here's a way of looking at that process for our district so on September 8th we we got the first Levy limits um on September 24th of this year the board approved the preliminary Levy that helped the county produce the property tax statements that came out late November tonight we are at the public hearing and then following the hearing if the board approves the tax levy later in the business meeting we'll certify the levy to the um state of Minnesota and to the county and that has to be done by December 30th so here's an overview of our Levy this is really
016good news for our um taxpayers keeping in mind that a flat or lower than normal property tax levy means lower revenue for fiscal year 26 in the category of tax levy it could mean that some of these are equalized levies so our state aid might go up but just keep in mind that there's another side to to every story um and that there's lots of reasons for the changes and we'll go through some of those so our tax levy itself the dollar amount is increasing by 98,6 less than one less than half of 1% 45% so here's a breakdown of that 0 45% in those three funds for which we can Levy in the general fund the property tax levy is actually going down by $35,000 in community service the levy is going up by
017$179,000 and in debt service it's basically flat going up by $54,000 and you can see in the chart on the side the largest portion of the levy um creates Revenue in the general fund then Debt Service and community service is the smallest portion of the levy these are a few of the line out there's an attachment in tonight's um um packet in the packet for the for the tax hearing that gives you a few more line items so you can see a little bit more detail around this but really I wanted to just highlight a couple of things so if you go all the way to the bottom you can see that the general fund Levy is going down the driving thing behind that decrease of one is11 n6 million that top line for the
018operating referendum generally that number goes up because it's it's by voter approval connected um to inflation but we had a large negative adjustment in this year's taxes because what the tax levy does is forever correct itself so we have to um in the summer send our predicted enrollment numbers to the state and then come fall um as the actuals are known in the following two years those are corrected to actual so what this tells us is that we over levied in the operating referendum and if you recall our numbers in the last couple of years our enrollment numbers were below what we had anticipated so our we are paying back that tax levy to our taxpayers because we over levied in those categories um keep in mind that this summer we also turned in numbers
019for this fall and as you know we are 100 students ahead so we will see an adjustment but it'll be the other way so in a future tax hearing we're going to be talking about an increase in the operating referendum because we under levied this year for operating referendum and so I just wanted you to be aware of that I also highlighted the capital projects Levy um for technology which is voter approved as well going up by only $198,000 that Levy is connected to growth in adjusted net tax capacity and while our tax capacity is continuing to grow the pace is not what it has been in these last few years so as we think about the way this District uses and most districts use the capital projects Levy we're paying for a lot of
020staff and with staff come cost increases for salaries and benefits so it's just a caution that I just want to speak out loud out that we want to be mindful of that we have a healthy fund balance in our capital projects referendum but as we have onetime you know Capital needs that we pay for we're also funding a lot of staff that if we can't continue to do from cap from the capital projects Levy it comes from the unassigned general fund so it's just something for us to continue to think about as we build the budget in the Community Education fund um that Levy is going up by $79,000 there's a couple of things some good news in on the second line item there is the Early Childhood family education Levy um has gone up
021and that's because that's actually an increase in funding that funding formula is connected to the basic funding formula and so when the state calculated the levy the state is estimating currently a 2 and a half% increase in the funding formula for next year that's subject to change we don't know what that inflationary amount will be and the legislature could change it could increase or lower it but because the ECFE Levy is connected to that that's the increase that's where that increase comes from so it's a dollar amount per zero to foury Old we have um a flat number of zero to four year olds so it's that's all attributed to that connection to state aid or to um the general funding state aid keeping in mind that once that funding formula is known there will
022be an adjust adjustment to this Levy in the future so it's just one of those things that we'll have to explain at a future time but many levies are made based on estimates school age child care is increasing that's the majority of the increase and that's the cost to serve students with disabilities in our before and after school care and that is a dollar for dooll um tax levy so there's two things happening one is we had a back a an adjustment a back Levy because our estimated cost for school age child care was too low um two years ago and when the actual cost came through it was higher so we are able to Levy for the difference so we two things happened we have this adjustment happening in here and we also increase
023the base Levy for this year so we don't have an adjustment in the future we hope so that's what's happening there um it's just the way that that funding comes to us and then in The Debt Service fund our debt service principal and interest payments are set up to basically be flat so um since we have no changes in debt our debt service um Levy is flat so I want to talk a little bit about what's happening to individual property um taxes um and you know this is basically some public service announcements a lot of things can change an individual homeowners tax levy and we'll talk about that in a little bit I'm not sure this this is the best visual but it's a way we've been talking about the levy if you think about
024the levy being a whole pie our pie only grew by $198,000 so we didn't get much bigger pie this year for the levy each individual home homeowners portion of that pie piece of the pie that they're paying in changes depending on a few things were there more are there more players in the pie so are there more properties and in St Louis Park there are more properties and then what happened to valuations if value if your value went way up or you made a big um Improvement to your property your piece of Supply is going to get bigger if your valuation went down it it will go down we are hearing um in the metro area that there are several home valuations that actually went down this year following a couple of years of really
025strong Market in in housing so many home 's property values might have gone down this year we're hearing a lot about that um and so now we're going to show a four-year Levy comparison so what we're going to show it in two ways one if your if your property values did not change at all and and then one if your property values went up by an average of 11.3% over the the period of time that we're showing here these are for properties in the city of St Louis Park and um it's preliminary estimates um so as you know final amounts can change as tax rates are finally set and Market values are set and our Municipal advisor ERS and Associates prepared these estimates for us so what I want to show you in in general
026is that if property our tax rates are going down so if property if your property value didn't change your tax bill is going down for the school district portion of property taxes um and the way a tax rate is calculated is it's a basic numerator denominator situation the numerator is the amount of the tax levy so remember our our the top of our calculation is only going up by $198,000 less than a half of 1% the denominator is the entire property values across the school district and those are going up not as high as normal but they or as they have in the last couple of years but by about 1 and a half% so if you divide a small increase by a bigger increase the percentage tax rate is going down so if your
027property value went down your your um your taxes should go down because the rates are going down if your property values are flat your taxes should go down because the tax rates are going down um and we're going to show that on a few values here and then we'll talk about what happens if your value changed um at the at the trend TR um so this is a $300,000 home and a $400,000 home it shows that small decrease in school district portion of property taxes so for instance on that on the right hand side the $400,000 homes property taxes would go from 1,789 for the school district to 1,751 for the school district here's a couple of other values 500,000 and 750,000 again on the our right side you'll see taxes last year would have
028been 3,544 um for taxes um payable in 25 next year 3533 so this is what's happening if if your home valuation went up on average 11.3% over this period of time depicted here so in most of these cases the taxes are going down again um so on the right hand side the $400,000 home goes from , 770 to 1751 and again here we've got a 500,000 and a $750,000 home going from 5 3 3505 to 3533 now you can see that one went up as did the $500,000 home there's another small it's big um for lower priced homes below $500,000 in 2023 there was a change to state law for the way property taxes are calculated and it is effective for taxes payable next year and it there's a homestead exclusion so your some portions
029of the value of your property are excluded from the property tax calculation that exclusion rate was increased for values that are less than $500,000 so that exclusion um benefits lower valued properties and pushes that piece the rest of the pie to higher valued Properties or non-homestead properties so if you own a business or um recreational property um it does not benefit those but it the taxes went down so there's lots of accumulating reasons why taxes are going down this year the um the tax levy itself did not go up very much that Homestead exclusion um also changed so um I think it's a good news here for property tax um for St Louis Park public schools so here are the next steps then the board can accept public comment on this proposed Levy tonight and
030then later in the agenda we have we are proposing that the board accept the levy as presented thank you director Magnuson I'm just for the sake of people at home uh does not appear do we have anybody here for public comments I'm just checking I'm orally checking here do we have any anybody here for public comment I'm hearing no one I'm seeing no one so U with that I think question sure yeah and it's not specific necessarily to the ly just to the slides that you shared with us um the federal percentage obviously is a very small percentage of our revenue is that mostly special education and title funds or is there any other categor mostly special entitle we um trying to think if there's any other they're all the the titles and yeah the
031DEA funding for special education thank you how how much percentage the percentage of federal was about 2% I think of our of our general funds it's a small and mighty portion because we need that $2 million okay all right well thank you very much with that I'll take a motion for us to adjourn we're doing it later I'll move move I'll second it all those in favor say I I any oppos passes 70628 we are adjourned and we will reconvene here in a few minutes for