001it is 6:15 we will call to order the uh January school board meeting for district 518 uh 1.1 roll call let the record reflect all school board members are here 1.2 recognition of visitors and guests thank for everybody that has attended tonight I'd like to welcome Darla an and Eric to the hot seat 1.3 Pledge of Allegiance flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible Li and justice for okay 1.4 correspondence and recognition 1.41 uh public participation I have not had any is there any from the crowd no uh 1.4.2 recognition of students staff and community I believe we don't have any this evening that leads to 1.4.3 presentation on the district fist fiscal model by Mike hoisel from beu you can handle it
002all right MERS of the board uh District administration uh Mr chair my name is Mich I work with a company called and we have had the pleasure or I have had the pleasure over the stops at three different firms in my 35 Plus year career to uh to be able to work as a Financial Consultant for the district um usually you see me when we're talking referendums when we're talking building plans when we're thinking about how we're going to put the puzzle together uh for one of your construction projects this is completely different so um encourage you uh if you want to wait with your questions if you want to ask them uh during uh I'll just put a single caveat that we have put together an operational business assistant assistance model and the idea
003came from a good dear friend of my wife's at still our schools uh he was when he was in okah hampen as a young uh administrator uh they cut three years in a row when he was at Stillwater Public Schools they cut eight years in a row and he had a person in the community that was known as a real brilliant person and was the probably the most negative public education person you could run across so Dr Ryan logger met with him and said you know I'm listening I'm hearing what you're saying and I got an idea that idea has morphed to this model but the idea was that hey when we're looking at educational budgets when we're looking at whatever he had a group of students that he had that he was teaching his
004finance class I believe at at St Mary's and the St Mary's group he had them do a study of uh a peer group analysis and they were to tell them where they would make or how they would go about going budget adjustments where would they put money where would they take money away where would they adjust and um he had been talking to me for years while he was a super while he was assistant at Stillwater when went to about plane and I said I can automate that you're going to see you're going to see this presentation in a 30,000 ft look what Ryan does for my firm is he peels back the onion and looks at different pieces in a true peer grp peer group analysis to say hey how are you doing things
005differently than others do you want to continue doing it that way if that's what it looks like this is what it means or would you like to explore something else and what could that mean as far as budget adjustments and thinking a little differently so we have I think 12 to 14 districts that are using this model in the state we have I believe we may move up to 40 in the next uh year and I say that because we have had 14 new districts enter statutory operating debt statutory top operating debt for the folks around the room is - 2.5% uh uh deficit spending in your general fund and then you get put on a a state workout plan from there so uh that little speech took care of three slides so we'll rip
006through this but we call it Oba operational budget assistance service offering um as when I was a young man my father was the superintendent of Cambridge n santias uh from he started two years an assistant and 23 years as superintendent and and I remember him talking about salaries and benefits of your school budget being close to 65 to 70% now that first bullet point now you're closer to 85% salaries and benefits make up your general fund budget so we are a people profession that's where the money should go but we've greatly lost where other dollars can help out your budget so many districts are faced with a challenge and painful process of making reductions but when you make reductions it's the quickest thing to erot a culture it's the quickest thing to anger folks and
007um and it especially is hard to take if you don't understand the why so the last story I'll tell you is we were in Ruth Minnesota with a $4 million fund balance it got driven down to two and we had two choices we could pass an operating Levy and referendum our way out of the problems or we could look at a new class schedule and various pieces there were 56 red shirts in the room and they didn't bring me one and they were all their teaching staff was in the room and I said well uh my wife is an iron Ranger we buy our car up in Virginia and I hope I have four tires that aren't slashed because I everybody knows where I'm from uh we left the room and two hours later they
008they were hugging Ryan Dr logger and they were saying we know you're going to cut 1.3 million over the next two years and help us run a referendum and we understand and we thank you for doing that we're giving us H okay so hopefully you'll see this arise here but many districts they make lists we reduce we change we adjust what can we live without usually these are the heart strings this is the emotional pieces okay but what Ryan talks about is hey it's the old as you tell you're a college kid that's going if you're going to boil a pot of spaghetti it's done if you throw it over against your fridge and it doesn't fall off right that's not the way to do budget cooking or adjustments what people learn through this process
009what might be important to one person might not be important to other so it gives a good cross-section of exchange of ideas um the other thing is uh you may pick things that are one time adjustments we're looking at so if you pick one time adjustments and it's not in a salary benefit or it's a program or you don't have a long-term plan with that you're going to roll back into it each year so use an example of this if you had a million doll fund balance you you want $100,000 deficit spend the first year what are you deficit spend in the second year many of you probably would not and say 200 Grand right with the way Minnesota Finance works and schedules you're looking at about oh another 250,000 the second year it's a
0102 and a half to three times difference so by the time three years rolls if you don't make adjustments on a little bitty 100,000 you've just eroded your fund balance with the course of three years by a million dollars 950 Grand so here here we look at we concentrate almost entirely on general fund expenditures we look at what you have in reserves we look at how you're spending we look at plans and then we look at how much you get for local optional revenue and how much you get in for operating Revenue just so we get an idea of how are you positioning yourself with money coming in versus how much you have to spend versus how much other districts have to spend so where does the district use their general fund okay largest category
011is that gray on the right weird regular instruction okay that's a good thing folks that's where that's we're here for a reason so if you take the gray and round all the way to the right with pupil pupil Services instructional support special ed career and technal all those instructional pieces that's about 3/4 of your budget is going to uh those components you'll see District level Administration School level Administration up there and then Capital expenditures that changes year by year depending on what is rolling through on your facility plans that usually go EVs and flows a little bit lower but we hit a little higher expenditure year for the district in 23 uh by the way we just got State data in for fiscal 24 uh this this last week so we'll be reprogramming everything for
012fiscal year 24 because everything was due by December 31st um with that we look at a potential peer group analysis so the idea is we can do a peer group and say okay on this particular peer group if you look at all grade en rment everybody's in that lower 4,300 to 3900 across the board if you look at percentage eligible free and reduced your good comps are you and Albert Lee okay everybody else is about half in that category you look at English learner count well we know out here that's going to be you're you're not going to comp with anybody in your equal size uh special ad Services oddly enough you're the Lost students exrain homelessness okay once again High e population possibly uh also homeless and then of course nonwhite enrollment uh different
013things public school open and open en rolled in students public school open and rolled out we want to know if you're a Gainer or loser to your biggest competitors your biggest competitors are public schools so that number right there doesn't include charter school and home school okay so you're 130 134 positive Albert Lee and Alexandria are negative Northfield New prag Sock Rapids are very high positives and then sarel St stepen is a is a a a loss so we look at that quick Revenue look and if you look at 58 very top you've got an operating Levy dollar of $500 so between L local optional revenue and the operating Levy you're getting in about 5.5 for your 5.5 million and your rank is a four all this is telling me is that if we get
014to Sock Rapids rice and sartel uh rank one and three that they get less money than a word so the highest amount is going to be uh 659 which is going to be Northfield okay what is Northfield college town right so based on a just looking at size districts and what we've been doing is we've been two been doing two analysis one we do a peer grp who you do your test scores against and other things that you use and then we look at uh some of this information so you'll notice that we uh concentrate on these seven pieces of the general fund so there's actually 11 components but why we only do these seven is we don't have special education in here we don't have Career Tech uh we don't have capital expenditure uh
015and I'm forgetting we'll hit the next one the reason we do that is there's a lot of transfer in and out so if somebody's transferring dollars here and transfer we won't get good data when we're looking at that 30,000 look before we start calling making the calls and asking for other districts to participate and give us their give us their information um here here you will see uh it looks ugly on the screen and I apologize but I know the board has a has a copy um here uh here's a ranking in each one of these different areas but if we were to look at if we were to look at Worthington down here you're going to see that you're going to see 3,376 sum of students now you saw a different figure on a
016previous slide okay wonderful mde does their kelks and in some spots they do adjusted puple units where they're weighted others they do who's enrolled by Head this is happens to be who's enrolled so um with that you'll see regular instruction pupil support and instructional support are all red okay in the heat map you will get District level Administration and well I should say School level Administration and transportation you're getting ones that means out of that peer group you're spending the least amount of money per pupil so you're looking at regular instruction pupil support and instructional support as on that Continuum you're averaging you have a score of a um I will tell you that if you were a bell plane and Esco and a Jordan they would all be if we rank them against you
017with 2,000 kids the 1300 kids those are three of the three of the top 10 lowest spending districts in the state now because mde and their wonderful wisdom has has messed I'm going I'm just going to say they mess around with your Vibe program some of the data when we do look backs because we started doing this in in in 19 and we've we've kept all that data going forward your data kind of abs and flows because of uh this enrollment when we know that we can we can we can on peel that onion so with that the top two uh least expending per student in new prag and Sartell with Alexandria being being the third socer rage right being the fourth and worington being the fifth so you're getting uh fourth most revenue and
018you're spending the fifth highest so you're you're in that range so what we what we do is then we've got a separate model that we hit the button and we go line by line I'm in your e far codes and we'll say what sticks up okay so something might be uh the one that I got to call in this morning uh I believe ad Dina Hopkins and St Louis Park are all looking at the model and there is one out of three of those districts two of them are spending they're allocating 1110 to 17,000 in nursing cost of the regend fund and the Third District is allocating 700 Grand and most of that is allocations coming out special ed fund so the key to this what I leave you with is when you're looking at
019things at a high level you have to drill down because not everybody codes the same to find out what the you fars a standard it seems pretty easy yet when you look at how many codes are in here it's it's pretty easy to see uh there was a stud stud done 10 years ago uh for uh resource officer and the 13 superintendents that were chosen across the state all had a resource officer all 13 had a different eers code for that one single resource officer and every officer was doing the same thing so although we try to make it standard in Minnesota it really is so with that our approach is meet and discuss learn your long-term goals establish those comparable districts here's your peer grp group analysis here's your power six meaning we take
020the three districts larger than you in population and three districts less than you we combine that all up we provide the Oba model examine expenditures rank of side by side and then start to examine comparable District costs what's out of line what's in line what are we seeing and for that initial approach it's $10,500 um we then many of our districts many of our districts use something like this it's a little little different format in other model and so when they get their or organizational meeting like Jordan has called twice now and said there a data already as a data reading or organizational meetings next Saturday or our um they go in know work work session for six hours on a Saturday and they review that and say okay if we change if we want
021to move an assistant principle to a Dean or if we want to do this to that how's it going to affect our numbers here where we at how's it going to do and all a sudden they start using that as a model to keep to keep hey how does that fit in the big picture if we do decide to do that if we do decide with a contract negotiation if we do decide to add that program how does it fit why would we want to do that oh okay yeah we want to put more dollars in that category then let's do it but then everybody's aware where we're everybody's seeing that that goal and then uh the annual fee we call it a magazine subscription uh most of those 14 districts that I talk about
022uh get the they get the model it's on a their own special folder and then they can play with play with the model uh how they see fit and then we help them if they have questions or us to investigate anything and then with that uh I already I put the names of my three colleagues in house in beard and uh Dr Ryan logger who's Allowed by the B play school district can sell with us to provide the like I said peeling back the onion and walking through I don't know see if how long it takes here but I wanted to show you a so remember when I said little bit up and down on pupils your adms are across that black case you had a high of 3900 again we're back to 3 3600
023last year in 22 23 down a little bit uh but I wanted to show you because of those pupil units if you concentrate on this Statewide rank uh I want I don't want state wde rank I'm going to go rural rank you're 86th lowest spender in the state in 2018 fiscal year which means fall 17 spring 18 86 42 that's that anomaly year you got the V now you got to count the kids okay now 147 well they took them away okay 108 so that just gives you an idea and the last piece I wanted to show you is if we ranked you see how much you're spending you'll see high and if you if you were if we were suggesting an adjustment so if we said um instructional support okay you got the highest
024rank at a seven if we came in here and said hopefully I can do this with [Music] keybo if we were to look at 200,000 you stay at 7 okay if you were looking at $1.2 million difference you moveed to a for and you just by that simple thing you see that it all of a sudden hey there's our adjustment over there it clouds it over here now you're at 28 now you're in the lowest you're in the three you're four okay that's the start and now what we do is we write up every one of these sections of District level and then the last piece comparable data this is where I want to show you you got your test scores I want specific District there's your career in Tech special education Student Activities and
025capital expenditures those four green ones are the other general fund ones that we don't put that are in the Minnesota report card okay so anybody can come look on this online we just have available to one touch okay we put any District in the state immediately in here just by just by uh coming in here and and changing a district number so if we looked at a little little District um that's running a referendum here just the north of you who go minota and we'd get 552 all great enrollment okay we' never comp them with you unless you wanted to see test score results okay once again we never come because you have such a Divergent demographics might be good to know but beyond that not a good comp so you kind of get to
026see the model there too okay any questions for Mike from many of you I have a few if that's okay yeah go ahead Ty all right so if we go back up and you were just talking about that potential peer group yes I've got some questions on that y um one how do you determine that peer group is it are you starting with the size of the school because I look at the potential that you have up here for peer group and I don't see a lot in common other than the size of the school we are I believe a bit of a unicorn so how do you do an Apples to Apples comparison against other districts given we look at okay who who who when you make your presentations on test scores who do
027you see yourself comparing to so we'll talk with Administration and say okay what what do you feel closest to and then we come in and say we start plugging in numbers we look at that we look at this group and say who should we be comparing to or are you all right with that so it's a g it's a it's a separate meeting where we decide who we should compare to and if we're doing in this instance this is pretty close to your three districts and people units above and three districts units below so we'd start there based on total enrollment then we'd go see if we can find better comps okay so in your case we're going to need to do both we're going to need two separate Oba models to get to peel
028back that under okay so you started with enrollment and then you went from there um the reason being we want people that are we want people that are making decisions and we probably wouldn't choose a two High School District versus your a single High School District no you probably wouldn't choose somebody that has five elementaries versus your couple elementaries that's fair but I'm asking is if you're going to go out and find six districts that are comparable to us as far as English learner students correct that's going to be a it's going to be a challenge absolutely and if we're making budget decisions and decisions on who's interacting with those students I just think that that's maybe a more important Factor then the size of the school and that will be kind of how we
029compartmentalize and say okay when we look at the service offering here here's how they're set up versus okay um maybe that's not the whole we we can't just put a number in and say this is a great model and go fair enough that's that's the beauty of this model is we can use it to get get a start and then we're going to have to go and say okay looking through our data who is who is higher than 55% for elgible free and reduced or higher than 30% for eel because this sweet from a comparison perspective the closest there for English learner is a third of what we have and homelessness as well so not super close Noom John was there was close but that'll all enrollment would be an issue and again you can
030based on this model how I understand it works you could do a couple different comparisons so that you can and to answer your question we can judge then based on our student population and that and in that Cas for instance uh thief of Falls same square footage per building is Jordan Bell Plane and uh I think they were a little bit smaller in TCU South Southwest Metro okay most of those districts are running 9 to 14 custodians The forer Falls are running they had 27 positions of which 24 were filled so our recommendation for adjustment was why are you why so it came to it came to a few components that they could work together with students during the school day maybe garbage was only every other day uh but it really came down to
031we recommended an adjustment for increase in pay for custodians you're having trouble keeping and retaining cuz you're in you're in you're in complete competition with Digi key and articat so if you want to retain and get these people you need to retain at the 12 to 14 Mark you need to raise that and then you won't have all these open positions all the time so there's a given and take here is what that's what came out of peeling that onion back I have a couple more on the data points um you said that you're using seven of the categorical Focus out of the general fund and you said that there are other data points that are available and does that include test scce I think you mentioned is that in the model as well T
032yes that was in that Excel model that I had up okay so the breath of it goes beyond these seven pieces yeah like uh we we used this in gim Fairfax winter when they decided to get down to a single site and are building it right now two years later and the school board said wait a we come back to that we had their peer group up and they and I said you know you're hearing how bad your school district is you're hearing this you're hearing that but look at your test scores compared to your neighbors I flipped over and said look at your test scores to your peer group we're really not that bad are we Michael nope you're you're doing just fine and they said we need to communicate that with folks now
033when you have the challenges that you have have here in Worthington are your test scores going to show a percentage that people are going to frown upon and can't understand meaning if we go around the state and I plug different districts in quickly you're going to see most everybody 48 to 69% and you're all going to go those are pretty low nobody's at 100 so you need to take that in mind when you're doing when you're doing these different sanitized tasks and comparisons and who's taking them but all that like I said all that kind of comes up okay and then you also mentioned peeling back the onions so I presume there's secondary and tertiary levels here of what we can dig into from the data points yes we'll get okay we ask for when
034we establish the peer group or the districts that we are we may even have some of the data already on hand but we'll get every contract we'll ask questions like how are you how are you staffed in each one of your schools uh we'll see where that where are you coding your it expenditures what are you doing here we'll see in the model where that sticks out so some of that is clean up behind the scenes as well if we're going to be giving you advice and say here's our recommendation for a possible adjustment or solution we want to make sure that we're we're giving you a good good advice so like a blue Earth School District had two full-time persons that on in the custodial that also did on a given day were fix
035things and we said you need to get down to one of those people you need to reinvest your ltfm at your high school your newest building you need to do a project here and you need to hire kids summer help to cover that Gap so it was a so it was a 50 Grand here 50 Grand here was a $100,000 cut in the custodian or an adjustment in their custodian and their head custodian has been there for 35 years and Al gizer is one of the best in the business and he's kept he's kept that school district running like no other o boilers everything and he said huh I can use those I can that one that g a hog last question I promise all of this data is available publicly that this model is
036based on from the Minnesota Department of Education in some way shape or form it's out there okay it's not easy to get in mind and understand where you're getting it from like I said there's very people can go into the categoricals and say okay what makes up what makes up District level admin versus School admin and how are you coding okay we have the model the next model behind this which would bog me down in here we have a but drop down button where I can see all 170 codes Under District level Administration and then we can compare that to your per so it's there it's just not easy to get to okay any other questions uh Mike just quick how does a training work the ongoing fees every year um is there training to
037admin stream to the school board and then so we can fully utilize all the different peels of the onion so to speak how do a training piece work it's been different in every District um usually spend more time with the with the superintendent and the finance committee and then they ask the questions and how will this help and how can we set it up and then like I said it's on that joint drive that the school district has access to with a code uh from be okay and then um for instance uh Dawson Boyd has just started this model and I think they signed on December 5th 10th something like that and I know they've had three finance committee meetings already and walked through everything yesterday morning and so then we'll based on how they
038want to use that we'll write up or answer any questions and then um Houston Public Schools very very much a headliner in in online services much like yourself uh we built them a special model a side model I said hey um how could we maximize the amount of kids on some specialty subjects and yet keep most of the dollars at the district that you're getting the student from and so we wrote a program that said hey if you're you need this money to pay this teacher and then we wrote that up for them so we had an offshoot of this and we just includeed in this model so if there's something that comes up and we can program it for you that'll be additional help for your District we'll do that to okay and that's
039included in the in the annual fee whatever that is okay so along those lines you've mentioned giving advice and recommendations um the I understand that the subscription to the model or to the data is $10,500 but what is the fee structure like for you to analyze it and give us recommendations if that's something we're looking for we wanted to make it as transparent as possible you have a model that you can see the result of your decisions as you make them or as contemplating what that would do and so we once we get it set up and we see the points and have our comp group um we can we can do our thing and that uh for instance just down the road paramont and I say down the road pretty flippantly because I travel
04030 to 40,000 miles a year with be so down the road does seem like Fairmont to me but um they have a wonderful fund balance but they see they see many pressures hitting them based on where enrollments go the what F scenarios and so they're using it and uh then they have started using this at the board level to say Yep this is what we're still there and they also use it as a a thing to tell the community hey we're we're pretty good stores of your money look what we do Mr chairman a question on that what is the the community available platform or how does that look is there a uh do you develop a platform that the community can access this or is this is only for us to access and then
041decide how to disseminate uh probably the latter in that you'd have you have the file folder and you can have it up for the public and uh we usually have the people that we work with they'll say hey can we can we have this where we can grab it off the website we'll say hey we'll PDF that to you so that it can be showing however you want to show and if there's a special print out or something that somebody wants we just customize that real quick okay anyone else okay thanks Mike for your presentation and time for coming tonight thank you so much for having me have a good rest of your meeting and a good uh kick off the second half of your school year okay moving forward 1.4.4 presentation on AI by
042Amy Ernst thank you I um Michaela Massie and I were supposed to do this presentation together however she is running the scoreboard at the basketball game tonight so it's just me we did this at guanas today and um before we got started they cheered foris so the bar is pretty high right thank you I'm going to start by sh you video that's a minute 43 seconds so don't don't worry that it's going to be super long done completely in AI so this is not her and I talking it's just an example of what can be done in the realm of AI because what AI presentation wouldn't be created only by AI right so here we go imagine a classroom where each student receives personalized attention tailored to their unique learning style AI is not a
043distant Dream It's reshaping education today making this Vision a reality AI can automate administrative tasks freeing Educators to focus on what truly matters teaching this shift allows teachers to engage more deeply with students fostering a more enriching learning environment AI driven tools adapt to individual learning styles offering realtime feedback and support these tools Empower students to learn at their own p enhancing their educational Journey AI Fosters critical thinking and problem solving skills preparing students for future challenges by integrating AI we cultivate a generation of innovative thinkers ready to tackle complex problems concerns about Ai and education such as data privacy and ethics are valid it's crucial to implement strategies ensuring AI is used responsibly safeguarding student information and maintaining Trust teacher training is vital for Effective AI integration by equipping Educators with the necessary skills
044we ensure AI Technologies enhance rather than hinder the educational experience ai's transformative potential in education is immense by embracing AI schools can better prepare students for a tech driven World equipping them with essential skills for the Future Let's explore AI initiatives and pilot programs together by taking these steps we can revolutionize education ensuring our students are ready for the challenges of tomorrow so neither She nor I spoke any of those words in that video at all so that's just an example of what AI is and what it can do and what it may look like in the future um and just kind of give you pause if you see something you need to make sure you ask questions about it the validity of it the source of it and where it came so what we're
045going to do is go over three slides worth of terminology that you may have heard um in the world of AI artificial intelligence the first one is generative AI a lot of us have heard of chat GPT which is like writing letters of a respond to a prompt answering questions that type of thing uh DOL which is something that it's like creating artwor ations and actually in Chad TBT I said create an image of uh dad in his son ice fishing and it created one with a crayon that that looked like a crayon like a four-year-old drew it um like a four-year-old drew it and it created one in a black and white lines so you can ask it a question you can say that's not exactly what I meant and then then um it'll
046just keep changing it for you deep fake generators basically making videos where somebody else's face appears to say or do something you it didn't that's what we just watch we use a program called synth Asia chat Bots you guys have all used chat Bots even if you don't realize you did um chat now on a website you've gone to a website can I can I help you a virtual assistant it'll try to answer your questions if you ask too hard of a question do you want to speak to a real person yes yes I do um Alexa Siri Google Assistant Healthcare has uh chat box as well and then llm we hear llm as a word that gets thrown around quite a bit in education it's a large language model um do use this when
047you start typing and it wants to auto a sentence for you that's part of a large language model each large each business company that has their own vocabulary like education has its own vocabulary Healthcare has its own vocabulary um we need they all have their own llms with their own vocabulary and um specific uh language that that that model uses so it also uses like Google Translate for translation and then search engines when you do a sech put a anything in Google for example it does a little synopsis on top that's a so where are we going the district has put together a committee that is looking at Ai and how we can use it um we can educate our teachers about what it is because there's a lot of questions out there can we
048use it in everyday life and not realize it yes but how are we going to work with it with the students so right now we're working on an AI guidance document maybe a onepage letter to staff um March through June we're looking at training needs and hopefully in the fall roll out some training so that's where we are with AI any questions I think I should just get like kudos for not taking 50 minutes right [Applause] Mr chair I have some questions go ahead Eric um what um research or kind of U knowledge based you have about how our um furpa and having miners using these AI tools um impacts our district and what's our liability in that have you done any Research into that specifically U with our student data we're looking at a
049program that will take all of our student data help create a individual eventually indiv individualized learning plan for every single student potentially creating an assignment for each individual student based on where they are um we have a meeting on Friday with a company that addresses those fura you know all Copa laws and we need to have that conversation to make sure anything that we use does meet those guidelines yes because my understanding that that once that data is submitted it's it's going to an unknown collection agency and so we really need to be aware of protecting our students 100% Y and that's part of our job as it is to make sure that when we choose something like that not only do they say they're they're going to do it but they are going to
050follow up on what they say they're going to do so we know exactly where our data is going potentially we would like to Outsource it some if we can't potentially we have a llm on site where our data stays on site so it's it's to be determined it's fairly new right I have one more question um do you know if um any of our it like liability or Insurance structures protect us from that kind of data or what and if we were hacked or anything like that are there is there an AI like piece of that in our policy cyber security insurance which covers a lot of you know if we're hacked what happens to our data um I don't know that IT addresses AI specifically because student data is student data and we need
051to protect it at all levels um but that is part of our cyber security I would I would be interested to see in years like as we move forward if insurance companies are requiring uh AI clause in that in the insurance good question yeah okay anyone else questions okay thanks Amy okay 2.0 approval of agenda I need a motion to approve the consent agenda and Main agenda move to approve motion by Matt seconded by Lori all those in favor of the agenda item say I I all those oppos same sign motion passes 3.0 I need approval of minutes for the December 24 school board meeting and the reorganizational meeting January 6 and the committee meeting minutes as included do I have a motion all moved all moved an second seconded by Aaron all those in
052favor of the minutes say I I I all those opposed same sign motion passes okay need a motion to approve the items on the consent agenda I move approval of the items underneath the consent agenda motion by Lori second second by Matt all those in favor of the consent agenda item say I I I all those opposed same sign motion passes okay 5.0 main agenda 5.1 monthly Financial overview and that will go to Carman um the board should have um the district Revenue expenditure report for the period ending December 31st um 2024 um we are 50% through our fiscal year so halfway through um so as you look through um our actual budget um percentage compared to last year um our Collective revenues are running very close to where we were last year um at
053this time it's 46.219559 last year at the same time um there have been no unusual revenues or expenditures at this point and things are moving along as expected with our budget and our numbers okay any questions for Carmen on the budget review financial review Thanks Carmen okay 5.2 approve the first reading of policy 2113 School Board committee so the policy 213 was presented to the committee and there was recommendation for approval on that um I did get an email from Aon in regarding a couple uh items that she wanted me to look at I did not update any of that that she brought up for tonight's meeting just because it was this morning and not a not a good thing to update it that close to the board meeting um those are probably things the
054committee will have to talk about as far as potential updates again I'll remind you this was typed up done and the school attorney did review it at this point doesn't mean it can't be adjusted but I just want to be careful how we adjust if we do anything so um I would recommend you approve this one and if we need any adjustments before the second reading that would be a good approach and the second reading will be next month right correct move to approve first reading of policy 2113 School Board committees motion by Matt to approve policy 213 do I have a second I'll second the motion seconded by Lori all those in favor of the first reading approval of policy 2113 say I is there discussion no discussion yes go ahead Aon um I
055I just think that it's valuable for the board to have a discussion about um you know how much guidance we want to put in a district policy regarding what should be open what types of meetings should be open versus what um we should leave ambiguous and up to the discretion of the administration um or to the board when something comes up I understand that um the superintendent or District administration have authority to establish ad hoc or temporary committees and it's not clear to me in this policy whether in that situation um an a meeting must be open I think that there would be the possibility that this policy would leave room for a temporary or ad hoc committee to be established for it to be determin that they're going to have a closed meeting and
056the rest of the board doesn't even know about it and so I if that if that's something that as a board we are comfortable um with you know having that ambiguity then we can move forward with this policy but I think it's worth having a discussion as a board in terms of what how clear we want this policy to be okay and this was an instructional committee item correct okay is there any more discussion from the board on this on the policy otherwise it's going to go back to instructional committee and the three of you that are on there can discuss the change that Aaron has brought to us you're you're on that right Aon instructional I'm on operations you're on operations okay it was my understanding that if we have like when we have
057instructional meeting when we have even if we create and and I'm not saying I'm right I'm just saying that this is my understanding that that ad hoc committee would also have to follow the open law meeting if it were an established even a temporary established committee I mean we're not talking about people just getting together someplace that that it has to follow the open law meeting and is that anybody else's interpretation I I think that's the the spirit of open meeting law um but that's not what is clearly written in this policy but what did our school attorney discuss or so basically he shared with me that the open meeting law has some flaws in it and is not truly clear and so an ad hoc committee depending on who if you as a board
058appoint an ad hoc committee it would be subject to the open meeting law as an administrator if I put uh or superintendent I put together an adock committee um it not necessarily is subject to the open heating law if the board appoints or the board chair I should say does an ad hoc committee such as you did uh well it was done a couple months ago that could be open but it's not necessarily subject to be open we the meeting was held as an open meeting but um it doesn't have to be so there's not a in the law that when it comes to committee meetings there's not a clear defined um um practice the policy is meant to try and clear up as much of it as we can um but and again I
059don't care whether it's this District or any other District nobody's intentionally violating the open meeting law that's not the goal it's just we want to be as clear as we can and not every meeting is subject to the open meeting law I think Aaron had two different points it was the establishment of an ad hoc committee and that be done either by the board or by a committee a standing committee making That explicit and then also making it explicit that that standing committee or the board itself would determine whether that would be open or closed that ad hoc meeting is that were those the two points you one point is that we should be clear on when we as a district want open meeting law to apply if uh an I'm talking about ad hoc
060or temporary committees because that's what I think is ambiguous here you know what is going to be the policy on open meeting law for ad hoc or temporary committees as as established by the board established by a committee or established by the superintendent and as a board do we want to make a differentiation in terms of whether open meeting law applies when it's a a temporary or ad hoc Committee of two or a temporary ad hoc Committee of three because in in when I read open meeting law I don't see a clause that is um you know that creates uncertainty or um you know interpretation when there's a committee of three or more to me if it's three or more open meeting law applies no matter who sets the committee I think where there's more
061ambiguity or discretion is if there's a group of two or fewer board members so that's my interpretation of of it and I'm interested in what the other board thinks and whether or not there should be more clarity placed in this policy well is there an instance that you're referring to that we've not followed this Aon or yes typically correct me if I'm wrong John we usually don't have a committee without it's usually three people isn't it um there are some that have been less and there are some of the committee assignments example curriculum any committee you have two board members great um so there are committees that do exist that you came assignments to at the organizational meeting and I don't disagree for the most part if with Aaron on if we we have three
062board members more than likely it should be an open meeting it's when you have less than three and I if that's not clear in here I need to make it I I can see making an adjustment so I think go back to the instruction committee for the second reading and make the adjustments and if you want if they agree to make it clear I I don't see a problem if any of you guys if that's what we're asking for okay is there anything else any other discussion okay we'll just bring it back to instructional committee before we do approval of second reading next month and make the policy more clear Mr chairman we do have a motion on the floor that was moved and seconded yeah no I know you made the motion and L
063second it so all in favor of the first reading of policy 2113 say I I all those oppos same sign motion passes okay 5.3 discussion approval of the district fiscal model so basically this was the operations committee they reviewed this and of course Mr H Heisel was here tonight and did a presentation about it it presents a lot of options for you to consider and of course the you're aware of the cost of 10,500 for the upfront and 2500 after that and uh at this point I believe it presents a great opportunity for the board or The District in general to provide some good information in the future and address some things um so I would tell you I'd recommend you look at approving this I move to approve the district fiscal model motion B
064made by an I'll second the motion seconded by Lori is there any more discussion yes um I would like to see more of it based on what we saw tonight and the 30,000 foot view um I'm not real comfortable unless I can actually see what would be considered peer schools um I'm not quite sure what the value be would be to US unless we can do those comparisons and what I saw tonight was not in okay it didn't provide me the type of comparison I would want to see if I were looking at these spreadsheets and trying to go through the numbers and make decisions off of that okay was my understanding that what we saw was just you know a quick snapshot and and we or superintendent assistant superintendent board chair I don't they
065they get to choose who the comparisons are so we can compare like sizes we can compare El populations we can compare whatever parameters we decide are relevant to being able to make decisions on the model is that was that anybody else's understanding that was my understanding might as well and I don't think that everything needs to be compared to another District we are an anomaly we are different out there so just in my mind to see something that looks like a red flag or out of whack not even compared to another District makes sense to me just to see it and compare the different categorical items and expenses that may or may not just pop out without having to compare it to six other peer groups I think that's that in my opinion has value
066you as well any other discussion Mr chairman to me it's a tool we're providing to our staff and to me it's more important to ask Mr Swanson and Mr Noble if they had a chance to look at it and they feel that this is something that would uh allow you to use the numbers better and provide a accomplish some of the things that were discussed earlier we haven't been able to play with it necessarily we see kind of the same information you guys had but I would agree with an and Lorie's perception um and I agree with Darla like it I would enjoy the opportunity to kind of choose certain school districts and it may be for different reasons um but to Mike's Point about like MCA data the reality is I would stack our
067district up against any District that's similar to ours and e um when it comes to some of the achievement data and to me that would be interesting to see I know that's not the initial intent it's more financial reasons but um some of those things would be intriguing to look into and I believe it has that capability I think there's drop down in that drop down we're able to pick different districts um so as I you know like he's using the report card and stuff I mean there's places to pull that data obviously this puts it all together in a nice a nice format which would be easy um for a lot of us to use I mean if you're not familiar with going out on the MD site and other um National sites to
068pull that data this kind of puts it all there and as long as we have the ability which I believe he said that we do um where we could go in there and pick different schools just in that drop down pick a different district and compare that and I agree to like um obviously El numbers are important in this District so as we're comparing things with other districts um that's important to look at that diversity percentage um even as I was trying to work on some superintendent negotiations as we move forward with that search that's a key that I'm looking for is some of those are key points but I think this model this um lets us do that um we just have to get used to it but I agree that I think there's
069multiple things we can use it for maybe not just for financial um with the test scores and that information would be helpful and I think you know like in Josh's um Department with like you know as we're working on tests it might be easy for them to pull all that data together in one spot it's it's a to me it's it take be less time than as I'm going going through and searching multiple sites and mul multiple reports and then entering that data into an Excel spreadsheet um I can see the benefits of it as well um to use it that way and then when it comes to demographics we will still have a really difficult time finding any school like us because I've tried so um there are some and we would have to
070probably play with what we're truly looking for but you're not going to find size and diversity um and similar elementary schools within one District like it those they're just not going to exist but we can find specific things that could still help us make some decisions and compare us somewhat others while clearly looking at it it may be a little bit of an outlier like Lori said at times it's just not going to be the same all the time I'm curious whether we could even have like two different peer groups like one peer group that includes schools of similar sizes where we analyze a lot of like infrastructure or financial categories or metrics and then a different peer group that that has schools of similar student demographics to us where we evaluate more of the
071instructional or academic size of things and I think from the board member perspective it would be pretty good information I mean there's five of us that have only been here for two years or less and we got a lot of decisions I think I would have found this beneficial when I get on so I find it beneficial so there's a motion in a second um all those in favor of the district FIS fiscal model say I I I all those oppos same sign motion passes K 5.4 approve the graduation a requirement changes and approve addendum to policy 613 graduation requirements and Josh yes so this was presented to the instructional committee uh there's two main changes in terms of grad requirement that Mr Hastings presented one is in the fied area we're not actually changing
072the number of credits that students would need in fied we're trying to make it a little more flexible currently there's a prere course that all students have to take before they can take any other Ed it really T ties the hands of um counselors when they're trying to schedule so they're trying to make that class um not a required course on the front end so you still need the same number of credits but they do not have to take intro to fied in order to get into some of the other classes so the total number of credits don't change it's really just flexibility and how the students can access those classes the other one is actually a state requirement in personal finance so that will increase the number number of required credits um it will
073not increase the total number of credits to graduate it'll actually decrease one of the electives and increase personal finance okay do I have a motion to approve graduation requirements so moved motion by Eric second second by an is there any more discussion okay all those in favor of the uh graduation requirements say I I all those opposed same sign motion passes 5.5 approve memorandum of understanding with a custodial Association John so this mou is related to the custodial uh group and it's to have consistency with the secretarial um 12 month as well as well as 9 10 and 11 month employees and the number of holidays so it it sets it at five it's consistent with what's in the secretarial group and uh it just needs to happen so I would recommend approval of theou
074do we have a motion for theou with the custodial Association so moved motion made by Lori second an second by an is there any further discussion okay all those in favor of theou with the custodial Association say I I all those opposed same sign motion passes all righty reports one point .1 superintendent report so I'm going to cover a few things rather quickly and a couple reminders um one just so you're aware of it was covered at the operations committee but uh in um providing an application to the assessor um the 80 acres that is utilized by the uh egg learning lab um was approved to be non-exempt and that will happen for this year the 155 Acres of which roughly 75 of that was farmable that will become exempt in 2026 so that the
075application was looked at reviewed after I spent about a week bouncing back and forth and providing information um do want to uh highlight the ice arena um discussion and where it's at kind of at this point um the city council will be discussing it but they've asked for uh information um related to upgrading the existing facility so the city has provided contract they've gone out they've got somebody that's going to evaluate that and um sometime in April May they'll get the potential cost for refurbishing the existing Ice Arena um in my view we kind of at least had those preliminary information which was extremely high and I will be very blunt in my view refurbishing that existing Ice Arena makes absolutely no sense but the city council is going to go back and do that
076and take a look at it and then they'll do the comparison of is there value in refurbishing versus building new and uh yeah so at that point you're going to be looking at May before the city probably makes a commitment and then at that point um they'll start moving make hopefully make a decision one way or another and uh the school district at this point you made a motion here roughly a year ago of committing $5 million to that but that was specifically for a new facility and I would recommend that you hold to that and you did have a fiveyear limit so just to keep you all informed of what was there so that's that one that's the quick update um I mentioned the tax exempt one thing I just at least want to
077bring up the um Southwest Regional development commission has an open seat if any one of you are interested in nominating yourself or somebody nominating some from this board that needs to be considered and it has to go in by January 31st so so if one of you would like to not get put on that Regional Commission we'll send your name in all you got to do is let me know um and I do want to mention because not everybody totally understands the restructure of the district office and we did provide the information to the school board but I'm going to just do a really high quick overview with the restructure of the district office there's the superintendent assistant superintendent HR director and the We have basically eliminated the director of instruction and director of operations
078and um we have as of tonight approved an HR coordinator so there's adjustments there and we'll be looking to backfill the HR uh one other HR position but with all those changes I want to make sure everybody understands there budget Savings in that restructuring the rest of the year currently we'll be saving 87 a little over $887,000 for the rest of this year next year you will see almost an $85,000 savings by the restructuring and as it moves out of course it starts decline based on salaries for every dollar that you reduce and save this is a great example of after three to four years you're going to be right back where you're at so I I bring it up for twofold because as we move through further planning conversations and things over the next
079few months the the savings element is extremely important and it does have a long-term effect and moves things down the road but not everybody understood the total um what I'll call restructure and what it actually did particularly on the financial side and the last thing I'm going to mention to you is um I'll be meeting with the uh facilities committee tomorrow afternoon and we're going to talk about projects but just a few things that I think are out there that I am going to encourage you as board me members to consider doing an ltfm Bond um example we need to do the high school elevator or it will be basically condemned unusable so we need to redo the high school elevator on the North End um in the original project the metal panels and windows
080for example on the North Wing I've talked about in their older been there the compressor that runs the dehumidification over the gymnasium is out that compressor alone is a 25 thou 25,000 cost um needs to be addressed especially for those who have graduates um anyway um that's out I just learned of that a couple weeks ago didn't know that um we have an issue at Prairie Elementary with part of the foundation we need to look at and I have somebody coming to look at it here in the next week and my point is there's just some things that we need to get taken care of you can do this with a long-term facility maintenance Bond and I would take a look at a$3 and5 to5 million for that please remember on a ltfm bond that
081has no tax impact for taxpayers because you're leving against the allocation you get from the state likewise it actually decreases taxes on egg land so there's two components there that come about and U as I work on this list and have the conversation tomorrow I am going to encourage you to consider a three and a half to5 million ltfm bom part of that we can utilize with the Prairie roof as an example um where you approve the two alternates which is $600,000 above what we have budgeted and I'm trying to actually save on capital dollars I'm trying to save on the assigned and un assigned General funds so that some other things can get taken care of so with that I'll leave it at that but um I am strongly going to encourage that you
082consider next month an ltfm Bond so my question question to you John is if if the city council say we have an answer next month with the $5 million because that's towards new only say they renovate that $5 million is coming back to us and we'll know more at that point too right um would we still have to look at doing this if the decision is made to renovate I'm not sure I got all that Adam would we have to look at doing this ltfm Bond of three and a half to five million if we know that we're not be going to be committing five million to the hockey arena depend it depends on what else you want to do it really does do you want to do a high school kitchen the whole domino
083effect uh Middle School field type things those things yes it could play a big role in that I I would encourage you to do an ltf am Bond no matter what even if the five million came back because we can take care of a number of things on the North Wing that are identified plus some other things okay anything else John good nope that's it Mr chairman a couple questions to Mr languard uh back to the uh we do we still have just you not just you but you as a representative on the discussions with the uh school or with the city regarding the arena and we don't really have a representation from our board um they they did agree they said they would do that on that committee I have not heard anything since
084I I brought it up okay um so I haven't heard anything I did share that with Mr Robinson after that board meeting all right nothing there budget reductions let's that's um I like an update of how that process is moving forward um we're still working on it it's in rough form right now administrators are looking at their building budgets and working through that as well as I'm looking at some of the district options and uh I should say districtwide options and we'll have a list put together um by March for the board to consider and that's based on Surplus now with the Outlook of being greatly Less in one year yes yeah so right now the um budget reserves or excess is looking at 2.4 a year from now you're looking at 960,000 um and
085again that's part of the Domino one of the principles was looking at their budget their budget just in salaries goes up a half a million dollars next year um and again when you start having what we've seen on those type of costs um there's some savings that we got to look at otherwise down the road you'll be you won't be making minor Cuts you'll be making major cuts and again I'll I'll just say it my wife thinks I'm crazy for doing this she said just go away quietly and I go that's not my job it's just like proposing to you to consider ltfm she says why do you do that just go just retire and leave it for everybody that's not my DNA I'm gonna keep pushing on you folks to do the right thing
086and that's consider kids consider your budget and try and manage that all in one big overview and with the the buildings given a uh a charge of what percentage to targets for a reduction yes we're using 2% not a big number and that's their leadership team or primarily the principal and principal is and then what's our timeline to from now through February or that and then we'll be taking action on those proposals you would be looking to take action potentially in March no later than April okay and some of these some of the reductions they're talking about are positions that are currently open or haven't been able to fill they would do without so it's not actually cutting people in a pair world if there were less pairs um we have enough turnover it doesn't
087necessarily mean people who are working now would lose their job just because of the open positions we have those are examples at this point because nothing we don't have a formal list to bring yet and the fiscal model that we approved tonight would help us Identify some of those areas that might we might want to take a closer look at yeah if you look exactly if you look on that we are as a district high in pupil support some of it's due to our population um which makes sense but when you're extremely high compared to your whoever you choose to compare you got to start to balance some of that so how fast will we all get access to that then um again I'm going to tell you on the fiscal model that's not for
088you guys that's for the administrative team but we won't get to look at that model we just approved tonight um okay I'm going to back up just so you I'm clear that's for the administrative team yes you'll be able to look at it they'll show you but again your job is govern and governance and policy not to micromanage and I'm going to be clear about that okay so I I'm I'm gonna throw it right out there right now we need to get these FKS up to speed so that it's an additional tool in the toolbox to say hey once we blank it to 2% across District wide now let's take a step back and say hey let's look at that versus what comes out of this initial Outlook of the model and say where does
089that balance looking at does that make sense it's going to be used to make recommendations to us to make informed decisions too it really is it'll be benef beneficial to us okay um instructional Lor your chair but you were skiing I was not there so an Eric would you like to comment on anything or you want me to I filled in for Lori I feel like we've talked about everything graduation um some initial discussion about iPad replacement but that that's a ways out and Amy didn't have she had very general information about cost just to kind of give us a heads up so that that's out there but no decisions are being made in the near future would you agree with that yes I would agree was was just the presentation that um we you
090know iPad computer device uh replacement will be coming and we just need to remember that that's a significant cost and you can do it in phases or you can do it all up front it's the cost factor and then we kind of cut the or cut talked about the budget reductions and then we had an updated action plan so yeah everything's pretty much covered at this point um operations committee Matt Darla Matt is chair of it Mr chairman fin item I would to share was that Mr languard gave us a watershed project update on the vote property that continues to uh meet challenges but the uh Watershed district is meeting with the uh the DNR and the Bowser board try to find a plan that will work and they still have an aggressive timeline to
091to get it done within this next year and that would be great to give us a chance to really shape that property in a a cool thing okay thanks Matt uh any other reports I just like to take the opportunity to thank the district for allowing me to go to the msba training conference I was there with Darla and an and Mr languard and it was a great opportunity for me to learn and all of us to learn and to have good conversation with our peers across the state about uh our role and just the challenges that are facing us all ahead and so I'm very appreciative of that opportunity thank you okay is there any other business uh future business I guess I would say Lisa sent us a calendar of the superintendent search
092that you should have all gotten I don't believe there's anything else anybody else got anything well meeting adjourned