CorpusRecord 209845

School Board Meeting December 17, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Worthington ISD518 Events
Date
2024-12-30
Location
Nobles County, MN
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,029 words · about 51 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001we will call the December meeting of the district 58 School Board to order roll call is let the record reflect all members are present except tom Prince recognition of visitors and guests we welcome all you here this evening 1.3 Pledge of Allegiance we stand to the pledge allegiance I pledge allegiance to the United States of America the for it stands na indivisible all 1.4 correspondence and recognition public participation we had a request from Lucy odonnell to address the board is she here okay you can come forward good evening um esteemed schoolb members I'm speaking to you today to express my concern about the proposed schedule change and the effect it will have on our student body more specifically on the students involved in music and multiple extracurricular activities my name is Lucy odonnell and I'm

002a senior here at whhs even though I will not be affected by this change I will not stand by and allow my peers to be affected by it the music programs have changed my life I am one of four commanders for the marching band the choir president and a senior member of our Orchestra our district website says this about the impact music has on students quote the confidence gained in performance on ensembles excuse me compliments student leadership an academic achievement at whs end quote not only does participation in music affect the emotional learning of a student but also as stated by our district affects their leadership and academic achievement therefore by using District stated information one would come to the conclusion that by cutting back on music programs which seems inevitable with this with the

003change schedule a student's academic success would be strongly affected furthering the discussion on academic risks imposed by this schedule I would like to share why I find the current schedule beneficial the current block schedule gives students in regular classes adequate time to work on homework well in the presence of a teacher who can give them active response to their questions and to their school work I have I have appreciated the amount of work time in class because it means my workload doesn't pile out up outside of the classroom the 30 minute advisory period at the end of the school day is also beneficial in this respect advisory is a set aside time for students to work on homework to make up tests and to spend time with peers and their advisers advisory has been very

004beneficial to me in many times because of the chance to catch up on assignments and tests that I had missed when being sick or when out of the classroom for other activities advisory is also a time for students to create strong connections with their advisory teachers an adviser can provide support and encouragement in meaningful ways that most students would not have been able to achieve otherwise because of the block schedule and advisory period i and other students have been able to give time to work schedules the shortened periods in the new schedule would would reduce a student Ava availability to work and because of the Class Days Later end time athletes would be forced to stay later for practices leaving less time for homework and less time for working a job yes the proposed schedule

005change will affect students in activities but it will also significantly impact the students who are the primary care for their siblings or students who work to support their families in conclusion I'm speaking to you today because I want you all to know that if this schedule is implemented this choice will affect teachers it will affect worthington's historically successful program and it will affect students thank you for your time thank you Lucy for your concerns 1.4 point2 is recognition of student staff and community and Aaron will address that all right I I want to um just make some remarks regarding um upcoming retirements tonight marks the last school board meeting for three of our school board members which also marks the retirement of some key District 518 School staff that we want to thank in appreciation

006and to recognize and honor as well um these are some so the following comments were um submitted by the The District administration um first of all we'll recognize our three school board members who are leaving the board at the end of this year um Tom Prince he served on one term on the school board um we thank Tom for stepping up to serve our community providing a listening ear and providing an important Agro business perspective to the board Steve schneer Steve has been on the district 518 school board for over 27 years our district has had the advantage of having Steve be part of some integral committees or and organizations during his tenure Nobles County integration collaborative joint Powers Board of Worthington TV3 Southwest West Central service cooperative and the Southwest Regional development commission Joel

007Loren our chair Joel has been on the district 518 school board for over 30 years he has been a key leader as a school board member that started his tenure in making many budget cuts for staff and programs when he first started to now having positive cash reserves his economic background and Agra business has brought a level-headed perspective to many discussions so thank you Schoolboard members let's give them a round of applause furthermore um two members of the school district leadership team will be retiring at the end of this month Dave skog director of operations has been with the district since 1997 Dave's responsibilities have changed maintained and built the many different facilities that have been and are a part of the district over 27 years Patrick morphew District accountant has been with the district

008since 1993 in his over 31 years the changes in computers technology and recording business transactions have been dramatically adjusted from many pieces of paper to online from mailed to uploaded so thank you Dave and Pat for um your your service and they're not here tonight but let's give them a round of applause um thank you all um who we who we have recognized for your hard work and dedication with a collective service of 119 years to our district students families and the communities that are part of the district thank you thank you a okay we're going to 1.4.3 presentation on the high school by Tony Hastings our principal thank you I also like to acknowledge um Mr schneer Mr Loren and Mr prince who I wish was here um just thank you for all your

009um hard work and dedication and support over the years it you have made a difference in the lives of students here um it is fitting that I follow Lucio odonnell um for this presentation um I know when I presented to instructional committee a couple months ago um there was um some hubub about the the possible new schedule um I know some school board members got some feedback on that so the one thing that I want to present to you um I think everyone has a copy of it and this is um just a projected is is the timeline um for kind of revisiting um the high school schedule um what I would propose is that we um for next school year um kind of hold tight to what we have or very similar to what

010we have this year and then kind of go through the timeline of what we want to do to possibly have a change um for the up then the following school year so um this is kind of a general timeline and then on the back it has a a a bit more detailed um description of what we're looking at doing um in the winter of 25 so nowish we I've had um conversations with my leadership team and the next step I'd like to do is um work with our our different departments and staff within the building um and then in January February uh create a committee consisting of students parents um staff and administration and then uh again I'd like to gather some some data from the teachers that have taught um we have during our

011second block we've we've created skinnies to see how um purposeful they have been and see if there has been benefits to having that second block skinny um in the spring create a survey um for uh our stakeholders um again it would be sent to our students our parents and building staff um and then do some more research and development of uh of our schedule by looking at other school districts that are similar to us in size and demographics just see what other schools are doing when it comes to their schedule they uh I've done a little bit of this research and there are a variety of different schedules whether it's period day um block schedule hybrids of those so again just doing more research and and looking at what what is best practice out there

012when it comes to scheduling um in the summer um committee makes determination the scheduling needs again influenced by our stakeholder input our research um just Gathering of data and then we begin to develop a draft schedule um again this process does take quite some time um Fall Again coming together um Gathering stakeholder feedback um and and starting to do a draft schedule um with obviously revisions to come and again looking at um our what our stakeholders are asking from us as well um winter uh of next year um Identify some of the curriculum needs if we would switch from um a period or from a block schedule to a period schedule just what are the needs going to be for our staff especially our teacher staff when they shift from um a longer period of

013time teaching the different um the different classes so identifying those needs and again just determining upon um what direction we go if there is additional time for summer curriculum writing um in January I I would present um the daily schedule to our instructional committee um for for approval um spring um is registration so again getting um students registered for um that following year um and then again creating a master schedule this is this would be our daily schedule and our master schedule is the Big Grid with all of our classes with all of our kids that would fall into it um again I I think a revision and Contin tweaking that master schedule that's something that I work on all year long um from when we do registration in the spring up until probably fourth

014quarter is when I I continue to work on the master schedule so we can fit the and meet the needs of all of our students and again continuous development of our schedule curriculum writing for staff and then in the fall of 2026 the implementation of the schedule and again continuous conversation with students parents and staff about the um how how how well it is working for our our student body so that is what I'm proposing um that's what I'm looking at doing um so we have more input from our students and our staff and our stakeholders in um in the creation of the a new schedule obviously we have um students that are passionate about uh of of the things that we offer here um but again reexamining what we're doing and see if we

015can do better questions Mr Hastings how many uh skinnies do we have in the schedule now is it just one during that second block second block we have it's it's split in half and we have um like six and it's typically it's been freshman classes from geography geometry Earth in space there's an art class that's in there a music class that's in there as well so we've split that so it has been typically our it's been some of our freshman classes our intro classes right there and that that's where I want to gather data get input from the teachers to see if this has been if that has made a change because it will be over a longer period of time um to see if we see a reduction in failure and increase in scores

016thank you Mr Hastings um how will the committee be formed the committee that you mentioned um for winter of 2025 made up of staff and parents and teachers and administration yeah good question I would like to obviously email would to the staff would be one one thing and then obviously I'd like to have a connection with the students and then reaching out through probably our talking points um to get some parent involvement as well I think a lot of times we skip that component so I think that's an important piece and having diversity within that group as well too is something that I'm looking for so just kind of reaching out making sure people are aware of it getting it on social media cuz I know um an Foley could assist me with that just

017getting the word out that we are forming this committee and having a variety of stakeholders be a part of it how large of a committee do you anticipate forming I would say seven to 10 members you get too big and then you just kind of don't move forward because everyone will have their opinions so I I think seven to 10 members obviously I'd like to have students involved in it as well I'd love to have Lucy on it but Lucy is going to graduate and move on from us but again student representation is something that I I'd like to have probably students that are Juniors this year possibly sophomores just so they can have some insight and input on what works well and what doesn't work well and how can we improve what we deliver

018to our students thank you have you identified the the goals or the impacts you're trying to accomplish by readjusting the schedule such as uh is a a goal to improve grades or goal to provide more access to more a variety of classes uh at the same time what's what are you what are you trying to accomplish by reorganizing and redoing this what are the what are the primary factors you're going to try and address or fix that would take price by changing the schedule obviously we're always having the student need this first and I I think one of the things that we wrestle with as leaders in the district too is Staffing so how can we appropriately staff uh um the different the different classes as well so I I think um there there's a

019lot of factors that can go into schedules um I think some classes could be longer um like a number of our a classes that we have um some of our science classes that have Labs that I think it's appropriate to have longer periods of time where we could possibly look at um some of our math classes so we can have consistency throughout uh an entire year and they could be shorter periods of time but we have a longer duration um but I I think we just looking at it right now a combination of of of period and um block would be would be probably a best com combination for us and again I want to make sure I get feedback from others as well not just me making this decis decision but I think some

020of our classes fit more of that block model where we need a longer period of time like a welding class you're really not going to get much done in a 45 50 minute period where in a 90minut block you can get some stuff done art classes um typically have need a longer period of time I also agree with what Lucy was saying when it comes to having that teacher within that classroom a lot of our students are extremely busy or they uh don't necessarily have um support so they have that built-in study hall or that support time within a block class um where a period day you you you typically would not have that and then that would would be the possibility of us looking at do we have study halls back in our our

021day because we don't have study halls built in um because it just doesn't fit a a block schedule but if we would go to a period uh a built-in study hall might be something that we need to look at just because again fitting the needs of our students so would this committee then be the one that decides prioritization of what's important and what's less important as you as you start running into conflicts with how everything fits together obviously if you want students doing their homework in school so they can have jobs or participate in after school activities and and then that bumps up against some other priority that you need to do uh who's going to be setting those priorities and saying this is more important than this is and and and we can do

022this but we're not going to be able to do that is that this committee that's your I think the committee could be a strong voice in that as well too obviously As Leaders we have to make final decisions but again I would like to have a great amount of input on what priorities do we have what what is is going to be best for students and again that's where student voice can come in because I think a lot of times we move forward without having that voice and they like Lucy said she has a lot of key points that sometimes we Overlook and that's what we can incorporate into that that schedule for the future as well yeah thank you any more questions for Tony hearing none thank you Tony thank you so much not

023only is Lucy a great speaker but she's an awesome actress as well so thank you okay 1.44 presentation on the egg learning lab by the high school egg Department when he's getting that set up I'll introduce us uh thank you for having us tonight I'm Brett Schmidt uh we have Deb Martin here Matt trip Katie Christopher and a student Autumn lunenberg so we're going to talk about the land lab and uh first thing with the land lab we were very fortunate to have a lot of great Partnerships uh you can see the Partnerships on the board Minnesota West Titan Machinery whiffles uh whiffles hybrd seed Pioneer seed and comper financial so they they all help make it a successful year and we are looking forward to the possibility of more Partnerships in the future so

024far 260 Middle School and High School students have uh been to the land lab and we expect those numbers to go up in the future that's on the next slide here uh there's been a number of classes that have visited as you can see on the slide uh this past year 260 students made the trip um spring of 25 we'll have another 70 plus students make the trip there so our total number of high school students so far 90 middle school students 94 uh Middle School from the spring 76 and we're expecting 70 more students this spring hi I'm Autumn lunenberg and I'm going to be talking about what I learned in the class from the landlab so we're going to go over some pre-planting so Ben cron from comp Financial came in and talked

025about crop insurance which is really important this spring because we had a wet spring so a lot of farmers had to turn in their fields to crop insurance and then we talked about fertilizer Rex with Minnesota West and the high schoolers and we had two great egg professors come in from Minnesota West Jeff Rogers and um Dusty Nar and then they taught their Minnesota West students some stuff about fertilizer and all the nutrients that go into it and then they taught us high schoolers and we got to work in small groups and just base off Knowledge from each other and then next was the field plan proposal so they sat us down and told us like what will be happening this spring and who will be farming it and the harves thing and we also

026got to pick out different varieties of seeds and we got to look through different books such as Pioneer and Whiffle books and um pick out the variety of seed that best fits the crops since we broke up the land into 40 acres on beans and 40 acres on corn so we just had to figure out which seed would be best for each crop and then the next slim is going to be a picture of spring planting and tillage so dusty n is pictured here and they brought in two planters and they showed us students to difference of two different types of Planters I think there's an old planter and a 32-year old planter and then we have Titan Machinery down there mik Samson and he showed us s Digger the field cultivator and the maintenance

027that goes in with having machinery and then here are just some other pictures too and you can see the Minnesota West kids and the high school kids together and we're all basing knowledge off each other within agriculture cuz we all have different experiences so I think one of the coolest Parts about this project has been uh getting to take students like Autumn um who I think hopes to go back to the farm um and brings a wealth of knowledge and then also getting to bring some of our younger students like seventh and eighth graders out so on the planting day um I was able to walk over with some of our students they got to ride in a track for the first time some of them um so that was just uh us coming over

028on planting day with some middle school students and then next I'm going to talk about our partnership with whiffles and that includes Randy Michaelson So Randy and an intern came to our egg 11 and 12 classes and they talked about it was actually a wet day believe it or not in the spring and so then they brought in samples from the field and we got to test like the corn emergence and the vegetative and grow stages between different types of crops so that was really fun that all of our class got to participate in again uh brought middle school students we dug up some of the plants uh played in the soil we're able to look at Roots um and then trying to find some seeds that hadn't emerged uh what happened to them uh

029then we came back out so that kind of summed up our spring uh came back out in the fall one of the things that we got to do was do a yield estimate lab uh our agriculture exploration 9 class went out with the Minnesota West students broke them up into small groups uh they were able to go through uh actual yield estimates um and work in kind of teams throughout the field to get them of both uh corn and soybeans and just some more pictures of them uh then on harvest day again able to bring a a variety of classes out from uh landscape and design and egg 10 to again some of our middle school students ride in a combine um and just be able to see that process and again talking through the

030combine uh and then we had egg 10 out there as well all right so on this slide then is how everything kind of penel out for us this year uh so this is our profit loss statement on on the 2024 growing season um so um we had 32 acres of corn planted and 38 acres was planted to soybeans um our average yield on corn was 148 bushs per acre with soybeans coming in at 38 bushels an acre uh a couple things to note on here is again the the seed um so whiffles donated uh nine bags of seed corn and then we purchased uh the remaining uh six bags we needed 15 total bags uh and then Pioneer donated all the seed beans and the treatment that went with that um so at the end

031of the uh again and then due to the less than favorable growing season so we started off really wet um and then we ended up really dry so we did claim uh put in for a crop insurance claim which is calculated on there uh so all said and done our net return on corn was $757 and soy beans was $10,00 uh so and looking ahead towards the future we hope to bring out uh some more classes to the land lab the gardening and the concurrent uh college horiculture class um now that we've seen and done some of the labs and learning we hope to align some of our curric culum to mirror and build on the learning that is happening out in the field thanks ask a clarifying question yeah was it 260 students like

032unduplicated unduplicated like if like if I'm taking a couple different ad classes i' gone with your class and someone else's but was it a total of yeah there could be like a handful of Middle School stud middle school students that had me in seventh grade spring and eighth grade fall but otherwise unduplicated of yeah either way that's it's a really large group of kids I think that's that's good I'm just curious how did the EST how did they do an estimating did they did they come out pretty close or or did you have like different different groups doing it and did any group do better than the other obviously yeah some did better than others on estimating um were you were you one of the ones that did so so when we did the estimation

033that day so the the corn estimation yield estimation was done when we were out there for soybean Harvest it was not as accurate because it was more of going through the process than actually doing it correctly so you know we just went on the end row right there it's not like we've went to different sections of the field you know so whatever the that section of the field yielded was probably pretty pretty accurate but we had some drowned out spots and some spots that didn't do as well so yeah and one other question then um they made a profit but we had some donations and stuff you know did did you calculate out how we would have done if we had put all our own costs in and stuff would they have broken even then

034at that point do you think or or is it for them to to make this a profitable program to draw make a profit of it that they'll probably still need to have some input from donations and things to make this break even or be a profitable Adventure uh yeah so we haven't we haven't gone and done the like putting in what it would have cost had we purchased everything um I think that's a hope of ours so that we can go through that with our classes this spring um when we have egg 12 and egg 11 uh but haven't gotten to that this was also kind of a hard year because of the wet uh planting season so hard to exactly say but yeah okay any more questions for the egg Department sounds like a

035good learning experience for kids yeah thank you guys thank you thank you okay moving on to approval of the agendas 2.1 and 2.2 we need to make a change on the main agenda on 5.8 change the wording to change to option C with that change we can approve the agendas I move approval of both the consent and Main agenda second second by Matt to approve the agendas as presented with the change any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I all those oppos same sign motion carries 3.0 approval of minutes I move approval of 3.1 and 3.2 minutes motion Adam second by Steve to approve the Amendments 3.1 and 3.2 any discussion hearing none all those in favor signify by saying I I all those oppose same sign motion carries 4.0 approve the

036items on the consent agenda I move approval of a consent agenda I'll second Mo Adam second Lori to approve the cons items on the consent agenda any discussion hearing none all those in favor signifi by saying I I oppose same sign motion carries 5.0 main agenda 5.1 monthly Financial overview John yeah so when you look at the monthly Financial overview you will see that currently right now we received 36.5 9% of our Revenue compared to Prior year at just under 30% so it's a little bit of timing that we're getting more of our Revenue at this point um as far as moving to the expenditure side you'll see also our expenditures are a little higher compared to last year some of that is due to increased costs and uh again um we're in line with

037the budget everything seems to be flowing correctly for this part of the year and we're halfway through the year so it seems to be working out well okay any questions for John hearing none we'll move on to 5.2 presentation on District fiscal model by Mike H and he's not here he can't be here so we'll have to move that to another month okay yeah we will pass on that 5.3 approved marching band equipment sale um s there's Surplus property and that was uh oh boy Mr no you got to help me you remember drums drums drums drums and drums stands harnesses cases yeah six of each drums that were replaced a year ago so they excess we need to declare them Surplus so we can get rid of them so move approval to declare Surplus

038property second motion made and second to approve marching ban equipment as C property any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I all those oppos same sign motion carries 5.4 approve resolution directing the reallocation of general education Revenue this is an annual resolution solution and it starts the it it moves money from what I'll call the per pupil funding to cover other costs within the district that's not part of what I'll call the instructional side or building costs so I move approval of the resolution motion by Lori second second by Adam any discussion hearing n a roll call vote Miss dadley hi Mr luren hi Miss shudy I Mr Bloom hi Mr schneer I Mr wibom I resolution passes 5.5 approve resolution directing Administration to make recommendations for possible reductions again it's a

039annual resolution that's done and it has the administration look at um budgets and where potential reductions could occur and uh it's part of the process that needs to start there'll be another one that will come up later um in case there needs to be more major reductions okay we need so move Steve motion by Steve second second by Adam to approve the resolution directing Administration to make red possible reductions any discussion all those in favor signif by saying I resolution Miss Dudley hi Mr Loren hi Miss shudy hi Mr Bloom hi Mr shener hi Mr wbom hi resolution passes 5.6 approve the 2025 res legislative priorities um the legislative priorities are something that we've done for probably 50 15 years um there were minor changes in the education funding one which I believe was um

040bullet three or four or both of them actually so with that uh the recommendation was for approval of these priorities move to approve legislative platform for 2025 I'll second motion Matt second by Lori to approve the legislative priorities as listed any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I I all those opposed same sign motion carries 5.7 consideration approval of 24 Levy payable in 25 um we had the tax hearing this evening and you will see the pay 24 Levy payable 25 in the amount of 9, 336,000 [Music] I Mo approval for setting the budget the levy I mean motion by Steve second second by Matt approve the levy payable in 2025 and as the amount listed 5.68% increase any discussion wasn't supposed to kind of keep stabilizing as we go on correct

041we're not pardon me wasn't it supposed to keep stabilizing just a little more because we've seen some pretty big increases there for a few years correct so are we starting to well part of the increas is due to the enrollment increase MH and that's where the biggest line share of it is we saw increased enrollment so the levy goes up but yes there should be some stabilization coming any any further discussion all those in favor the motion signif by saying I I all those opposed same sign motion carries 5.8 to approve 2526 school calendar option C and the vibe calendar so the calendars that were presented are the um calendars we talked about option b but there was an error found in there there was an extra actually teacher work day and by contract so

042it showed 187 it should have been 186 so the real difference was um the one in service day in September that was removed that's why option C was very similar um and based on the feedback option C was more of the favorite um and Vibe would follow a very similar there's some differences in that um just due to the nature of how they function and then uh Community Ed the preschool would follow close to option C of course they do have some um what I'll call compensation time or slightly different schedule related to that but most of the days are the same so with that the recommendation is option C I move approval of the calendar option C for Vibe and the preschool and regular school any motion Lori second second by Steve to approve

043the calendar is option C any discussion hearing none all those in favor signify by saying I I all those oppos same sign motion carries 5.9 except Prairie Elementary roof replacement bid so we opened bids up related to that and uh of course there was the main bid as well as an alternate a and an alternate or an alternate one and an alternate two um there were two biders on the roof and it if you remember it's a slightly different system system that's part of that so with that the base bid came in on the low bidder of $1,138 th000 we had budgeted $1 million for that so it's slightly higher but pretty close to what was estimated well alternate one came in at 364,000 and Alternate two came in at 218,000 so roughly a total

044of about 1.7 if you were to move forward with the two alternates and Alternate one and Alternate two are planned to be done it's either we do them now under this contract or we would be doing them sometime in the future so if you look at how the building is phased out there was a phase one there would be a phase two and yes that would probably be part of phase two and then there'll be a phase three and four and you could incorporate a couple of these either alternate one or two in some of that phase two or three and try and get it done quicker but uh that's why we bid the alternates to see if we could get good pricing to be able to do it quicker total cost to to do

045the entire building was estimated between 4 to 5 million and if you figure based on these bids it'll come in about 4.5 million depending on inflation costs and other costs down the road Mr chairman my main question is if if the uh the intent is to do the entire project why would we not do the alternates as part of our mobilizing now that I guess I would support doing it's a matter of how you want to expend those dollars right yeah um when you do alternate one and which is Jim a alternate to Kitchen what percent of the entire project is that then do we know that I is it over half of it or is it well when you look at the map it's probably not quite half it's probably closer to 40% of

046of that because the remaining portion would be pods two and three and uh with that hallway piece of the puzzle this gets pod one and over the main entrance and and Lobby if you do alternate one which is the gym section and then alternate two was the kitchen section and if you look at it so it probably will get close to 40% of the rough in the current if you did alternat one and two does does this complete the rest of the school then because we've done some we've done some already does this complete the the school then by doing these at this point or will they be more no this doesn't this is just starting it's the beginning so you're either going to break it into potentially we we plan four phases to do

047the entire building this is phase one of two or or three or four phase one of three or four depending on how much you do and the estimate of cost saving if we do it now compared to waiting and doing these other alternates next year you know the following year is there a uh do we have any idea what the cost would be or or what the added cost would be as we're talking about a 5% increase do we get pretty good bids on this what it's worth pursuing it or is it or or would we see just a cost of living increase if we simply waited till next year I I don't know if you go by what IC shared when you had the conversation on the high school they said potentially a 4%

048increase and that's the number that's stuck with me that's the best I can give you and based on that that's why I would support we do the entire project now or the with the alternates just based on we continuously are hearing the only thing that will happen it'll cost more so I guess that's where my Approach is let's do the uh the and then that's why we asked for additional alternatives to to see what kind of price it would be so now this is longterm facilities maintenance dollars some of it some of it yep which has been specified for maintenance yeah and the budget would handle it all right um well we budgeted um a million we could go to we could do the base bid um we did not plan for the increased additional

049half million dollars or slightly more so that's something that we we can cover it whether it's assigned or it's it's in the um long-term facility maintenance dollars ltfm we can cover it it's just how you how you go about wisely spending the dollars I think we we had this conversation in the operations committee a few months ago and we talked about that there would be tradeoffs if we did the whole roof at once and I don't know if those tradeoffs or those calculations have changed in the the two or three months that we discussed this um at the operations committee but um Mr landguard do you have thoughts on what what those trade-offs would be if we you know what wouldn't we be doing if we did this roof instead um well it depends on

050what you do the rest of the evening related to potential high school project or if you're going to do something with the middle school or it depends on what you want to do and it again we can manage the budget it just might be in the end the fund balance at the end might not be 13 A5 million it might be 12 million um because there's a certain amount we try and invest and use the the the policy says we use the most restrictive dollars first which is those dollars that are in long-term facility maintenance Capital reserves or those type of dollars so we'll take a look at it can we cover the overall cost yeah you have money to be able to do that um yes me the question would be is if if

051we have some limitation on what we have available in long-term facility maintenance and obviously we would get more the following year does that mean that we we are using other dollars besides the long-term facility maintenance that we could use if we waited another year um well there's just there's those dollars in the reserve account right now um that's why we set it at a million dollars it's a little higher in that Reserve account so you're probably spending down the reserve dollars and then having to look it might be a little bit of the capital reserve dollars to cover the entire amount yeah I guess in my mind it's it's if we if we are we planning on moving all of it Forward by a year or we just talking about doing more of it now

052and then we would do nothing the following year and then we pick it up again are we just are we just combining two years or or whatever to to do it all at one time and then you have it done you save some money that way and then you don't do anything the following year when you would have done it then the following year after that you pick it up again and do it again or you just sliding it all forward by a year moving everything up a year it's a little bit different than how the cash flow yeah it'll be how the cash flows the dollars that are available based in our account and um are we moving ahead yeah you'd be moving it ahead um well I I I think it'd be good

053to I you know we could always determine if we get to the following year whether or not we should move one up another year and do it or or move it back or leave it as it was it depends on how the cash is Flowing at that point you don't really take any risk just you know you could move it ahead if you hav't it you couldn't leave it as it is as it's currently planned in in skipp a year if you have to you're not really hurting yourself at all I agree with Matt you know the more you can get done sooner the better off it is you have the money get it done the longer you wait it's just going to cost you that much more and if we can if we can

054adjust the scheduling in the future you always have the chance of of moving things ahead or back a little bit if you need to to balance out the funding I would make a motion that we go ahead with the uh with the base bid and the two Alternatives second motion made in seconded to move ahead with the base bit and both alternates what I'm hearing any discussion hearing none all those in favor signify by saying I I all is opposed same sign motion carries 5 10 accept Transportation bid so we opened Transportation bids last week and um we had one proposal from buds bus service and I appreciate Darren and Darla being here because if I goof this up they can help answer questions um base bid for this is$ 1,472 31920 that is a

05515% increase from last year um and then it's a 5% for the next two years and we talked about a threeyear and we'll finish figuring that out we ask them to go back and look at a 2 plus two or a 3 plus one I think it's 3 + one is what they were interested in doing which would be a an additional fourth year you can go up to the four years before we B bid um when we met with buds bus part of the rationale or the big percentage increase is the insurance that has gone up um plus they have seven buses when they originally started uh 15 years ago is that right yeah 15 years ago as doing that um they got all the buses at one time so now seven of them

056they're looking to replace and bus costs have gone up almost double for replacing them and then of course there's an increase in service and parts and uh maybe a slight increase on the um unemployment side and again there's just some of those operational costs that have driven the increase as how our conversation went so with that um I guess in our conversation I would recommend you approve the the contract to go to Bud's bus service and we'll finalize the number of years with them I move approval of the transportation bid from buds bus service second Steve Mo Adam seconded to approve the did with buz bus company just go what would be the have we have had had no conversation with on a fourth year at this point or they have they've made a proposal

057for a fourth year um no we don't have one yet we'd like to do a fourth year probably but we got to work on that one but I'm we're fine with the three-year proposal too got to have bus service so the motion doesn't exclude the option to extend for the fourth year or it does Adam made the motion for the extra the four year yeah the additional four fourth here and there but that would be worked out between the administration and the bus service so it wouldn't come back to the board okay that's what I thought second I just want to make sure what's that that's what I thought I seconded I just want to make sure yeah so it's three years with the option for the fourth year to be worked out any discussion

058further discussion all those in favor of the motion signify by saying I I oppos same sign motion carries 5.11 approve student expulsion um you have student expulsion uh in front of you and it's related to um violation of District policy whether it's Behavior or ethics and uh the fact that it was an immediate dangerous situation so everything's signed everything's taken care of um please remember that you must turn in the paperwork back to Lisa after the board meeting moove approval of the student expulsion Mo by Adam second second by Matt to approve the student expulsion roll call vote M Dy hi Mr L hi Miss shy abstain Mr Bloom hi Mr schneer hi Mr wh hi resolution passes 5.2 approv student teaching agreement um the student teaching agreement would be for field experience with uh

059agreement with Faith Baptist College just like all the other ones um so recommendation is for approval move to approve a student teaching agreement with Faith Baptist Bible College second Mo M second to approve the teachers agreement with Faith Baptist col Bible College any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I all those oppos same sign motion carries 5.13 approve salary benefits contract with the Human Resources Director can we obviously we got three of them in a row can we just look at bundling them I mean is there we know what they are it's bundle of 5.13 5.14 and 5.15 together okay is that your motion well that would be my motion to approve all three of them yeah but I've also got some disc discuss myself um by doing this we have and

060I'm not saying nobody is deserving of this by any means but how are we going to handle the other areas that have taken on an additional workload cuz that this isn't just it I know we've got other areas that were short staffed and theyve taken on a workload and aren't getting extra pay so what are we opening up here by doing this for a select few in the administration but not giving it to the other people that are doing it as well is my concern so do we have a motion in a second we probably should have it before we do this discuss made a motion's no second there's no second I'll second it so we can get the discussion motion made in second to approve 5.13 5.14 4 and 5.15 okay now it's open

061for discussion well as I look at 5.13 and 5.44 the human resource director and the human and the assistant superintendent those are new positions so the job points we Chang those and these are new positions and the salaries that go with them are um in line with what those positions are um and then the Third is a stipend it's not a salary increase it's a stipend so but but are we going to be open to if we have additional people that come forward after this saying hey I got additional workload what about what I'm doing are we are we going to be looking at doing something and how much are we going to be looking at doing because I do think you're going to have that coming forward and I think we have that at

062every negotiations session if it's with the Union uh or if it's an individual contract we talk about those things in the negotiations process every time we negotiate chair yeah I I think like I say we in the contract part of it I to' be negotiated out in contractor we get a memorandum of understanding I think for those teachers and things there's overloads there's there's compensation when they when they use their their propep time and things like that so we do have those types of things in place I think with with a lot of different Union positions so I think it's it's oftentimes covered but I think if we have someone who is doing extra work and it's not being covered I'm sure that there's going to be a request for them to to be compensated

063or at least to be considered so I think it's going to happen I think it's it's been happening and we've been addressing it in different Fashions so I I don't think it's going to be any change as we go forward I think we're going to continue to have we have them now I think it's going to continue and when we find those inequities it's going to be brought to us and the requests are going to be made so I don't think it's going to change any further discussion we have a motion and a second I understand that these three positions are going to cover the one position and it shouldn't really go any further than that at this time as far as extra workload for anybody else as far as I have been told so

064down the road if it does you're going to have to address it so any further discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I I all those oppos same sign motion carries 5.16 approve University of Minnesota gardening plot agreement um this is an agreement that comes from the University of Minnesota for the G plot uh Last Summer they did not get the garden going out at the Kim site or the Intermediate School um this agreement is really an agreement that will help hopefully get that going for them and they'll be able to have the garden plot out there this coming summer the recommendation was for approval move to approve the U ofm gardening plot agreement okay motion by Matt second by L to approve the gardening PL agreement University of Minnesota any discussion Mr

065chairman just to clarify Mr languard this is a one-year agreement yes right okay thank you chair um location did we come up with a suitable place to locate that plot where it's not going to interfere with other projects or programs we might have going on and obviously we don't to get too close to the field because if there's spraying out there then we don't want it drifting over into the garden I mean just do we have a good location for them to to do that's going be workable it's between the current storage building out there and the pond so on the east side of the pond so farming or the L egg land lab should not yeah have overflow will there be water available then I'm assuming some whether be water into one for the

066pond they'll take they'll pump it out of there then okay good okay motion made and seconded any further discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I all those oppos same sign motion carries 5 point set17 approve the 2526 budget calendar and assumptions so the budget calendar and assumption that's something that's gone on well past my time I believe and uh it's laid out consistent with last year numbers were all updated was presented to the operations committee and the recommendation was for a approval so moved motion by Adam I'll second Steve second by Steve any discussion all those in favor of the motion sting by saying I I the same sign motion carries 5.8 authorized School District to purchase special education and maintenance Vehicles so uh the board number of months ago gave Mr

067sco the approval to purchase vehicles for the special education and maintenance vehicles and of course Mr skog is retiring so um coming back and asking for authority to uh be able to purchase special ad we have a couple that probably need to be replaced in the near future as well as a couple pickups for the maintenance folks Mr chair so what I understand is this has already been approved but we actually named a specific person who had the authority to do it we're just giving another person The Authority or another part of the organization and authority to do that I would move that we give approval to the school administration to uh make the purchases I second motion by stes second by Lori any further discussion Mr chairman a question to Mr languard on the

068the number of vehicles I don't remember if we had specified that when we you didn't specify a number uh or the operations committee when we talked about didn't specify right now um one special ed vehicle for sure maybe two and then two pickups the intent is that to happen in 25 then hopefully yeah hopefully yeah the one of the pickups we might need it sooner than later okay we have a motion and a second any discussion further discussion hearing none all those in favor signify by saying I hi all Theos same sign motion carries 5.19 discussion action on high school facility options so at the operations committee uh it was presented um the B3 plan again with more of a breakout um this was included in your packet so you should have that or been

069have looked at it um the high school option with the addition with the smaller Commons um was there that price tag uh that was the original B3 plan that was n just under 20 million um the kitchen cafeteria um Second Story link office when it's broken out it just that portion is just under 15 million the north Wing improvements which was ltfm funded was 4.4 um a little higher than that million in large the it office excuse me workspace and working on refreshing science current science labs just under 600,000 and then refreshing the ex existing science space in place um 650,000 so the numbers are there the difference in this is on the original form that you looked at there was the $2 million specified for the Middle School field and then there was also

070the 5 million committed for the ice arena um so those came off to hopefully elim eliminate some of the confusion on that sheet you will notice there was an economy of scales factor and basically it listed what the econom of scale of doing the project and for some of them if you do this in a Pac mail there's potential of almost $660,000 of increased cost by doing a peace meal versus a larger project um you can downscale it you can do something different um or you can drop it at this point and the conversation can go on later I just need some direction on what you would like me to do if anything Mr chairman a point of clarification Mr languard that the 5 million is still allocated as our commitment to the ice arena

071just not listed as a it's just not listed on the sheet anymore but it's still yes do still going to come from our original yeah Source yep okay thank you what was the discussion from the operations committee any recommendations that I set in for Adam so we didn't have Adam's opinion but the rest of us there thought that we wanted to bring it to the full board for discussion again so and we didn't talk a lot about it um only that we needed full board discussion right now to speak for the way I understood it was uh part of the discussion was you know what what could be I think one point the question was asked could this be broken out into different pieces I think this is just brings back what those different pieces

072would be the the uh the larger part of it obviously is a cafeteria and one thing pushes another so it becomes a bigger part of the project the other ones could be broken out and done individually you could expand the it office into the library and that's a standalone type thing and the other parts are kind of Standalone but that part uh you know is a larger part and that's the one that has a most push in in in direction if you do the cafeteria push it out into the lobby Lobby's got to be expanded Administration moves so it all that part kind of all goes together and fits together because it needs to be done at one time because one thing affects the other the other three areas or yeah the other three areas

073are independent of each other and wouldn't impact the other each other so that's why it's being brought back to see if if there's uh any parts of it that want to move forward or or uh or uh anything that needs to be done or move ahead with or just leave it all go I expressed during the operations committee meeting that I'm open to having a conversation on some of these off projects but I'm not keen on having a a revote um on of exactly what we voted on last month well I continue to have the same approach that I did after the referendum was Sly defeated that that was the indication of um pumping the brakes on the project I know not all the board agrees with that um reading of our citizens but I

074think that we maybe had a chance to get some of their feedback when we asked for a survey to be filled out primarily used for us to help get feedback on our new superintendent search but we had 315 people that took time and appreciate that to do the survey and there were a couple of questions I think we should look at as a board since it's hard for us to get voter feedback we got it in this case there were 68 respondents that took the time to to talk about the fiscal transparency and there was continuously the answer was the school district is divided about how to fund School operations don't spend money foolishly the community has been upset with spending in the past must be aware of the tensions involved with previous referendums there's

075no common sense spending do not spend much of the taxpayer's money I think that's the messaging that we have to listen to and I think that we need to be very aware of that I think we need to move forward with a plan that allows us to evaluate our needs as we move into different leadership into next year and I don't think we should be afraid of going back with a referendum to our citizens and being able to to show our needs because in the next question that it was also a part of this survey was asked what do you find as challenges in our district and 25 times the words space and overcrowding and need of classrooms at the high school were brought up but our proposal does not address the classroom space that

076the citizen talked about in this survey so I think we have to use this information as important parts of our decision making and uh that's why I do not support any of the suggestions right now although I very strongly believe in the need to address our cafeteria situation at the high school and then to take security as our next priority in classroom space that we approach that in 25 well I think it's got to come to a point two I mean what are we willing to spend are we willing to spend at dry and do nothing for a few years with no funds or yeah you want to spend 15 million do you want to spend 12 and a half do you want to spend 10 what what do we want to do and I'm

077still a firm believer I would like you got the msba convention coming up if anybody's going maybe get options for a second opinion a second look at it to see if we are in line with our prices I don't think we're ready to give up and not do the project and money is there we all agree we got to do something but that's also right I'm not I don't want to be afraid of going back to the people and asking for another vote myself so any further discussion we're you're going to um not act on anything what I'm hearing yeah I just feel like we're kicking the can down the road I'm people know how I feel about this I mean I feel like we need like Adam said we need for how much money

078do we want to spend we can wait and spend it in the new year or whenever um inflation's not going to go backwards I mean it's going to cost us more to do anything um I looked at the prioritization of the cafeteria kitchen that second story link and then for sure the safety piece which is the office administration moving those offices but unfortunately you can't Pac mail that all together that's why the 15 million is what it is to do that all at one time and that's the most um beneficial way to do that in that way and so that's why I've supported that that option um I mean some of our what I feel like I got back from the taxpayers was no new taxes no taxes but we have this money in an

079assigned account for this very thing and we've been building that account for a few years now and I feel like that was the goal of the board to do something at the high school um we asked to do the whole thing the voter said no we're not going to do the $33 million project I heard from some well then do it yourself get it done with the money you have or do as much as you can with the money you have and I still believe that today but I will not bring a motion to the to the floor because we did that last month so the board will address it I'm hearing next year that's you're hearing Adam yeah I don't think we're going to give up on this by any means I think we

080all agree something needs to be done and it needs to go towards our school buildings so we'll let it go back to the future board and decide how to proceed forward right that's what the goal is but I do want to remind you we do have the money set aside for project and it should be done in the near future because it's a need and the longer it goes the higher it's going to go so I just think we need to move forward fairly quickly but we'll let the next uh board decide how to proceed any further discussion um just one you know I think there's some you know I was hoping that in in with with breaking the out and stuff we would we would see that uh some of some of these projects

081have Merit and and that the employees who work in these areas uh deserve better and the students who use these areas deserve better um and I would hope that uh that uh some action be taken sooner than later to move some of these things forward the IT department is is is those those working conditions are horrendous and uh and and there like I say there's other things we could do to help improve the learning aspect for the students and for our staff so i' certainly hope that this doesn't get put on a back burner someplace and and and left to drag out because number one it's going to cost us a lot more and number two ultimately these things are probably going to get done I I don't see that when we work through several

082year a few years now prioritizing all these things and coming up with this list it wasn't done by us it was done by staff and other people giving us input and telling us what they thought they need so I would certainly hope that the new board would address this sooner than later to to get these things done number one but number two is to save us as much money by doing it ahead of time instead of waiting till the inflation eats it up more and more then we're out asking for more and more money to do the things we could have done a year or two earlier and saved ourselves a lot of money same thing as we just voted on for the rofs you know the longer we wait on these things if there

083things that need to be done are going to get done let's move them forward and get them done as soon as possible to save us the most amount of money it's so many times we delay things too long and it costs us way more than what it should have cost us to do it upfront and not worry so much about somebody who says I don't want to pay for it well we're always going to have that but we got to look at what's best and what we're going to end up doing because it needs to be done and get it done so just keep that in mind as they move forward that U some decisions are better off made sooner than later and move ahead as quick as possible thank you okay any further discussion

084some hearing none we will move on to the reports John so Mr wcky uh wanted me to remind you that tomorrow morning's The Learning Center breakfast at 7:30 and wanted to make sure board members were aware of the breakfast there um secondly I Mr livb doll gave me an update on the potential project of the Watershed moving forward out on the Kum site they're actually doing a redesign at this point there will be an uh environmental assessment completed the worksheet completed in February um reporting and permitting application in March final design and construction documents in March and bidding in April with hope of construction in June through August so that was information I needed for the egg folks and the learning lab as well since they'll be doing some of that so I need to

085share that with them as well and then lastly I just wanted to take a moment to kind of highlight a couple things related to um finances so back over 20 years ago when I started here on the finances um the budget at that point in time was and I'm talking General fund was uh 19 well actually just under $19 million and the unreserved general fund dollars were roughly 2.5 million currently right now where things are at the budget has grown in the general fund to just about $59 million and the unreserved and assigned fund balance is about $32 million and the reason I'm bringing this up well I better finish going a little further since 2010 um the school board has approved doing major projects whether it's parking lot roofs or buildings or athletic facilities

086of almost 130 million since when 2010 huh since 2010 yeah starting with the middle school project taxpayers are responsible for paying 58 million of that 138 million the rest is paid off and the reason I bring this up and I wanted to bring it up um because Mr schneer Mr Loren are off the B Mr Prince um and there are a number of passport members who have made decisions to put this District not only in what I call a positive spot with the facilities and grounds but also financially and the ability to do things so I just want to say thanks to the folks that are leaving the thanks to those who have are on the board and those who have pass board members because number one without the trust in the administration of doing

087the job that's necessary we wouldn't be in the position we're in right now and we wouldn't be where we're at right now as a district and so I just want you to be aware as board members leaving I appreciate the trust and support that you put in the administration to do that I know that 's been criticism of transparency um this has all been laid out since 2010 uh the materials have all been available so there's been no hidden information or agenda um but that's not the perception and the perceptions happen it's unfortunately like we hear the terms in the buildings of bullying harassment um things are those type of terms are used very Loosely and often times are not accurate so and but again it's perception and as much as we try and communicate

088um if people don't know information they need to ask it communication is two ways and I appreciate because I've had that with current and past board members and I just appreciate all the support that I've gotten over the years so thanks okay thank you John instructional committee report um everything's been covered okay operations committee this was a very operations heavy agenda tonight so I think everything from the meeting last week was covered okay thank you any other reports hearing none we'll go on to any other business yeah I uh I personally would like to thank Steve and Joel for your time and I'm just completing my sixth year and it don't feel like it but we've had many long and short conversations and meetings and I've learned a lot from both of you and I

089appreciate it thank you okay any the future business 8.1 special school board reorganizational meeting is scheduled for January 6th at 7:15 at the district office any other business hearing none we'll call the meeting adjourn

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.