CorpusRecord 209962

Board of Education Special Meeting - December 18, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / FFSDTV
Date
2024-12-19
Location
St. Louis County, MO
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,002 words · about 62 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e for a delay our closed meeting ran longer under provisions of the public meeting law of the state of Missouri the board must by adopt by roll call agenda that includes time date place and attend of Jer for the meeting copy of the notice was posted on Tuesday December 17 2024 in administration Center 8855 Hazelwood Missouri the time is now 6:38 it is December 18 2024 we are calling a special meeting of the Ferguson floron School Board to order um is there a motion to adopt the agenda for the special meeting it's been moved by Tyson second by Thurman any additions changes edits seeing none roll call vote Please Mr Bailey yes Mr Tyson yes uh secretary votes yes Dr Thurman yes Dr Graves yes Dr P Walker yes and Dr Martin yes

002motion carries 70 thank you so much much for being here tonight apologize for delay and for special meeting please not we have another special meeting at 3 p.m. virtually on Friday for the board just let you everyone know I'm calling another special meeting Friday at 3M to vote on the final signed audit uh tonight we're getting the final presentation but the final signed copy will be done on Friday at 3 p.m. for those who are able to make it virtually at 3 p.m. it should be no longer than a nope we're got it tonight never mind good even better news no special meeting needed even better news see news changes so fast there we go with that uh consent agenda is there a motion to approve consent so move move by Graves second by Tyson

003any items we pull all those in favor say I I I extensions Nays eyes have it thank you so much just a note for the record the consent was uh around Early Childhood as the board has learned about adding some Early Childhood classrooms there's some urgent need some furniture to be purchased so Dr Davis certainly I know appreciates the board supporting that and around policy 2012 is suspended until January 29 2025 effective immediately next up is item number seven Financial oversight resolution Ferguson Flores and School Board is committed to transparency and accountability in terms of District finances the Board of Education and District have desired to maintain mutually beneficial working relations rooted in trust and open communication with the community in light of the events that have unfolded in in neighboring school districts regarding Financial

004oversight and accountability there's a shared mutual interest in recognizing the principal consideration at all times is the welfare and quality of education for our students and therefore the board is implementing an additional layer of accountability of oversight effective January 1st 2025 through June 30th 2025 the reason that dates exist is because board policies are being revised with the July 1st oversight and again there's no Financial improprieties this is just due to the recent report that I'm sure many of us read in the newspaper about some uh concerns happening in a neighboring school district and therefore uh is the desire I have gone through legal with this as well as Dr Davis um so with that is there a motion to approve and then we'll have discussion so moved moved by Don second by Thurman just

005a real quick discussion real quick and then I'll ask any questions essentially what it's saying is there will always be two signatures signing off on PE cards payments or reimbursements not on actual expenses uh anyone who needs a reimbursement payment including pecard statements must be approved by a supervisor and a Cabinet member any pecard payments or reimbursements for or from the Chief Financial Officer must be approved by the superintendent and the board vice president any payments reimbursements or pecard statements from the superintendent are to be approved by the board president and board secretary any payments or reimbursements for any board member are to be approved by the board president president and board secretary or board assistant secretary any payments or reimbursements for the board president are to be signed off by the Vice President and

006board secretary or assistant secretary the superintendent is directed to notify all employees of this requirement and resolution any questions seeing none all those in favor say I I extensions Nays eyes have it thank you Dr Davis for your willingness to communicate that out and make sure that we have that again I want to be very clear there's no Financial improprieties it is just solely that the board wants to take some action based on the neighboring school districts Financial reports that we received and just add some extra layers of oversight until our new policies go into effect on July 1st 2025 so thank you for that next up Dr Singleton just uh made us on a happy note so we'll see how long we stay with that of uh having no special meeting so Dr Singleton

007you're up testing all right um good evening uh to the Ferguson floresent uh Board of Education superintendent Dr Joe Davis colleagues and Community uh tonight we will present the results of the 2324 audit uh first let me thank my team who's here tonight uh for the work that they've done on completing the audit uh Finance team will you stand please so I can recognize you of course our finance director lavenia uh our bookkeeper uh TJ um and our new senior accountant uh Mr Oliver uh they have worked very diligent uh the past several weeks uh in culminating what you will see tonight uh as a result of the audit uh next I want to introduce uh Andrew zebel uh he's a principal partner with CLA Clifton Larson Allen LLP um Andrew will present the audit

008results uh and answer any questions the board may have about the audit um Andrew and I have talked around the clock the past several weeks in getting this audit wrapped up as late as 5:00 today we were on the phone finalizing uh plans for the presentation I'm happy to report three things uh that Andrew will expand on uh in his audit report one the Ferguson floron School District received an unmodified audit opinion uh in the accounting world it's the best opinion that you can get reflects a clear and fair audit on our financials number two the Ferguson floron School District received an audit with no findings uh an audit with no findings means that the Auditors reviewed all relevant records and processes during the audit and did not identify any significant issues or areas of

009concern essentially giving a clean report indicating that the organization's financial statements are accurate and compliant with established standards and laws and three the financials that the board will receive tonight are signed and final uh as Dr Martin mentioned there will probably not be a need for a special meeting unless you just want to have one uh but we heard the board loud and clear last week and tonight we have delivered at this time I will turn the presentation over to Andrew and he will share the results of the audit uh with the board and the community please welcome Mr Andrew zel thanks leavon that was that's quite the introduction most of the time people just say here's here's Andrew the auditor um you know before I dig into this I if you think back on

010this past year the organization was was without a CFO kind of during a critical period of time so definitely thank the people that really held it down uh while you guys didn't have a CFO in place so um you know I try to give these presentation in layman's terms but if you guys have any questions you need me to elaborate anything further please let me know um this is kind of accumulation of the work that we have done over the past four five months um and it's a quick summary I'm not going to dig into the actual financial statements but this outlines our audit approach and how we kind of go through and detect uh risk we understand the organiz ation internal controls the risk around this um the accounting activity and the transactions they're

011recording and um that ultimately determines the level of scope and required testing so the scope of our work we do an audit of the financial statements we do an audit of the internal controls over financial reporting we do an audit over the compliance for federal programs because Ferguson receives a significant amount of federal funding that they expend during the year in addition to that there's an examination report uh that covers budgeting transportation and attendance that's required by the state of Missouri we did audit two Federal programs in a year Child Nutrition in S3 um the results is leavon mentioned unmodified opinion we didn't have any findings that required to be included within our uh report uh as Lon noted the status of our audit we are done there is a data collection form Lon that

012we're required to submit within 30 days after the issuance of our audit that you will certify and I'll certify um overall no disagreements with management um you know Dr Martin you requested that we do assessments and Analysis over uh payroll expenditures we did is sampled um employees compared them to what the board approved versus what they were actually paid out during the year there were small differences I mean round it could have been rounding we didn't investigate those further since they're so insignificant uh but we didn't identify any significant differences between between what the board uh approved versus what was actually paid and we sampled about 20 employees um no instance of non-compliance we have provided a management comment to uh to the team to really help lvon I think as he he he takes

013on the path of the new CFO position those are really to help him strengthen his internal controls uh Focus around Tim of bank reconciliations as well as performing reconciliations between your general ledger the ASB the ASB is a document that s to the state of Missouri and then the final a it just some things and some feedback for him in his new role um you know as we think forward to fiscal year 2025 some key things that the organization and the finance group is going to need to be aware of is you're implementing a new system okay implementing a new software takes time and takes effort and it's really important that you're get your opening balances recorded accurately the implementation of this new accounting software is going to make Bank reconciliations easier it's going to

014be difficult initially and I've suggested leavon reach out if he has any questions or need any help uh the other feedback and guidance that I've given him is on the financial reporting that they're providing to you guys as well as the management team and the importance of providing financial statements by object or by the type of activity whe whether it's salary present salary try not to break it out in too much detail that confuses the reader of those financial statements um you know it's kind of a summary and a look forward to next year I'm sure you guys are going to have questions so let me know what you have well thank you Andrew certainly appreciate I know you and I had a have a conversation back in I think October uh and I know

015obviously at that point we just learned of the potential and Dr Davis will be reporting on it next of unaccounted for employees and salaries and that's I you know one of the things was just looking at that test so I appreciate that the test did not come back any insignificant or significant differences in terms of what the board was approving and what was in there because that's certainly one important step to make sure that we're accounting for that way uh in that piece and I think we've also took some feedback and I share with the board what you you said about reconciliations as well as uh how we receive information I know Dr Singleton's already adjusted how he's reporting to the board uh so it's a little easier for all of us to understand and

016our community to understand at a higher picture of the big categories of funds rather than each thing we're getting the detail in there if we really want to dive in but we're seeing at least the bigger picture where we're seeing what remains uh and all of that uh a piece of it so I appreciate that feedback that you gave me back in October as well um we will go through questions I just have one real quick question what was the fund balance I guess that the you all found on June 30th because that is a big sticking point for all of this work that we're around yes V the statements uh the fund balance is on page six um fund balance is restricted and it's unassigned unassigned means that's it's typically within the general fund

017that isn't allocated to a specific um activity or type um and that number was 16.2 and then you have approx imately 11.2 million restricted for Debt Service and for teacher salaries so in total is 27.5 million got it and the budget I know not trying to interix two of them but projected it at 30 million is that correct I think it was about 32 projected and yes sir got it so uh this might lead in the next conversation so if it does we can talk about it there I'm just trying to figure out the the Gap that exists cuz this still I don't think was the same number that we got when we started having the conversations in terms of needing to borrow money and I couldn't find that presentation I don't know if anyone

018else has that I felt like it was around 24 million or 21 million yeah so per the as so per the asbr um that's um that we've gone back and forth and had to make some adjustments on we were at about 24.8 million so that was the number that we started um um as of July 1 so I guess how did it just for my own knowledge how did it change from 24.8 to 27.5 part of you guys the district records certain payroll obligations which is a liability as a credit originally when they had the ASV they showed that as a liability which is essentially a reduction of your payroll spend um historically and the way you guys have always shown it in that in your financial statement since you're a cash basis reporter is

019that you'll reverse that liability to offset what your payroll expense actually paid during the year was so that liability was in the ballpark of 2 and a. half million which means it was removed as a liability which it was at the time that the aspr was prepared it was shown as liability and it was recorded as an offset or reduction to your payroll spend I'm not aware of any other changes but you might from the asbr to the um audited financial statements so I I guess thank you for that I think I follow along well basically your cash basis right and you don't really present any other assets or liabilities so I guess my question is then how on July 1st did it's we our cash on hand was not 27.5 million so again the

020audit process just revealed all of these things we've spent the last several weeks going through and I think the last piece of this will be us looking at that asbr and seeing what those differences might be between the final audited uh audited uh financials that we have so um there may be some other adjustments although we were issued a balance letter today I think Dr Davis has sent that information over um so we we'll we'll spend the next you know once we get back from break just trying to make sure that we true up uh that that $24 Million number compared to uh the 20 uh the $27 Million number so got and I know you weren't here so you might not fully know but just curious and I know now you were getting each

021month how much cash is on hand and maybe that will help us fully understand it just seemed like there was a difference and there was urgency of why we were running out of money was around this $8 million difference um piece because now we can go dive into uh hopefully you and your team will be able to dive into why did our fund balance end at 27 a half million versus the 32 million uh projected okay so yeah we we plan on I I don't have that answer for you right now but we're going to we'll dive into there and and certainly report out to the board our findings yeah and I think I think January we're aiming for an amended budget for this year now that we have some additional information February feary got

022it okay thank you I'll go with uh which way is the spirit moving we'll go down here cuz she just took a sip so we'll go down to Mr Bailey I don't have any questions right now thank you Mr Tyson Miss Dunn Dr Thurman Dr Gres Dr Paul Walker wow you got off easy tonight I did need to invite him to all the meetings well thank you so much and I do know the board is also aware of the reconciliation pieces and so we've asked Mr Dr Singleton moving forward when we get dispersements that at least that month is reconciled because we did learn last board meeting that we've not done this fisal years yet so they're going to play catchup but at least moving forward to reconcile and you I heard you say the

023new system should make it easier it will it's the first year or first month that you're doing it's going to be harder and so that's why I'm I'm you know with leavon in this new in the new role it's really important that he gets the opening balance sheet numbers recorded correctly um once you have the opening balance sheet recorded correctly then you're off to the races but um you know I it's it's not going to the first month is going to take longer and so I urge the board just to have a little bit of patience but things will get a lot better thank you one thing came to my mind because Dr Singleton and I talked about it Monday during our finance policy teamwork uh PE cards was that something you tested I know

024there's always as we just passed a resolution about financial oversight certainly that is an area that can cause heart heart uh heartburn because it's just an area of potential fraud pretty easily so and you guys test that at all no we we don't te I mean we do testing over expenditures we don't specifically do testing over credit cards if you know if you guys are interested in understanding how you're spending your credit cards will you we have a um powerbi um application that feeds directly from your credit card system that identifies anomaly unusual type of spending unusual type of vendors that's a relatively inexpensive cost um but it's something that would give you guys insight into your U spending Trends who's spending money when they're spending money and it's not something that you have to

025pull together in the reconciliation it's automated got it thank you so much for that I know Dr Singleton's going to do some PE card work just for the board to know just to try and tighten up those those practices Mr Tyson I did have a question you had mentioned I think I heard you you P you pulled 20 employees to see if there was a discrepancy on what was budget and was spend was those sporadic or was those assigned or do you know what percentage was teachers I you know that's a good question I don't know which ones were teachers versus administrators it was it was a halfhazard selection though okay so you just kind of P okay they can't I only was on the emails because that's the only reason I know but they

026pulled Miss mcwell pulled a whole bunch of random cloes minutes and open minutes and they sampled from those minutes of boards and I know they were some administrator uh teacher and hourly People based on the sample that was given seeing none is there a motion to approve the fiscal year 2024 annual audit so moved moved by Graves second by Tyson we will do roll call vote because we do have to send this to Des for the official record of who made the motion and who didn't and who the vote so we'll do roll call vote Please Mr Tyson secretary votes yes Dr Thurman yes Dr Graves yes Dr Paul Walker yes Mr Bailey yes and Dr Martin yes motion carries 70 thank you so much for getting it done in a timely manner and we

027appreciate you thanks Miss Dr Singleton and your team you can get some rest now uh thank you Dr Davis the other audit the internal audit uh from auditor Davis call let me let me let me qualify that opinion um from math teacher Davis not auditor Davis all righty um got a little bit of a cold this evening so please forgive me a little bit of congestion um but what what I'm going to do is share with the board and the community the internal audit we did based on the reasons that we got to the tax anticipation note um so let me get my computer up here um board I shared with you um earlier today um the adjusted um numbers we went through and cleaned it up Ryan myself and Charlie um as well as

028so many folks who Finance helped us Oliver um spent a lot of time speaking and meeting with every um principal every uh Department um in this in the district so we looked at every employee um whether they work full-time part-time um you know some of the questions that came up last week about certain schools having you know X numbers of folks over but couple million dollars more and salary and all that so we got all that cleaned up um I sent that to you earlier so hopefully you had an opportunity to look at it um and then I'll go through it is you know fairly straightforward it's just the reporting out of what we found um there's certainly some recommendations that'll come I want to sit with Dr Martin and the board before saying any

029of what that looks like publicly because I think that you know I need your guidance on that piece of it but I just want to give you what we found okay so um this is the internal audit looking at specifically at Personnel comp uh compared to um just Personnel salaries not benefits not pro programs or purchase Services it's specific Al looks at personnel only looking at salaries um for full-time uh and part-time is three categories of people the administrators um the certified and the non-certified those three categories of people this is not working is it no who's who's who's controlling them is it maybe it's this here um I can't afford my slide okay maybe that's it all right got you the M should work perfect how do you um do this this is not

030Apple so I get HIV so I mess with apple how do you um do the slideshow where Charlie you can help me you can navate I'll just talk should be that hard is Ane you upstairs okay can you control I just need you to for to advance my slides is all um so if you can just do like the slideshow and then just advance for me so so here are all the Departments if you take a look on the screen um we had 23 schools U 16 different departments everybody was included um my department has all everybody's salary um administrators um certified non-certified next slide please um what you see here is U the budget this is actually taken from page 73 there a couple pages in the budget itself that you can look through

031and see exactly the slid you see here but I want you to just sort of pay your attention to the um the far left column uh that has 24 25 budget those are the numbers that the board approved in this current budget um 655 certified folks 59 4 non-certified um and 95 administrators giving us the total of 1,344 next slide please um this clicker does this the little um laser so I don't have my laser but I want you to pay attention to a couple of numbers up here because these are important you'll see going into the next uh slide um so if you look on the green column that has 2425 preliminary budget specifically Bally looking at that first number that has 53,723 [Music] M357 618 you have to add that number as well

032go down about four lines uh to where you see classified salary regular and you'll see a number of 22 million 775 224 and then you also have to add the number that has classified part-time classified salaries part-time that's a total of $855,000 so in the next slide you're going to see where those numbers are sort of added together so it gives us what the budget amount was and then we'll take that number and compare it to what we actually found when we went through all the salaries okay so go to the next slide please what you see here is the 1344 again that's the budgeted amount uh I put Finance budgeted employees because even though 1344 is what the board approved 1380 seems like the number that when Ryan pulled all the data from uh

033the spreadsheets that we got from Finance is actually 1380 positions that we kind of started From so it never started at 1344 I'm not sure why but um you know this is exactly what we pulled when we got the data uh and he put it in some spreadsheets for me um what you what you see also in the third column are the actual audited employees that's after sitting now with every department head every principal going through every person that that gets a paycheck full-time or part-time classified non-certified or administrator we have 1,451 employees that get a paycheck from first floor as we speak right now okay so when you take that number 1451 compared to 1344 we're over by 107 people as I stand right now um to this moment so that's where we are

034we're we're over in budget if we go from here all the way to the end of the year nothing changes we'll be over about $1.36 six million compared to what the board approved okay go go back to the sort of um peach color columns if you will where it says border approved budget salary you see the $88 million those four numbers I gave you a minute ago on that green column those four numbers that 53 3 million that 3 million that 22 million 850,000 when you add those numbers together you get the 80 million 75,000 $238 okay so that's what was budgeted what we're spending when you when I met with every employee looked at I mean we pulled up paychecks looked at what folks were making so that we were to the penny on

035what we're paying out and if all things considered we go to the end we will spend $82 m716 19.99 okay and if you do the math you'll get the 1.3 million okay next slide please um what you see here is just um a breakdown one of the questions that came last week I think Dr Martin or somebody asked a question about can we look at it from the administrators uh versus a certified non-certified folks um and so what we did was broke it apart uh you see again on the yellow um um bottom row you see the $80 million number again as well as the $82 Million number that was on the previous slide and we just broke it apart by those three categories of employees the board approved 96 95 administrators we actually have

03696 okay um I can tell you that one position came after we actually did um the work we have um our foundations person our um f full foundations administrator in that in that role so that's where the extra person came in there again this was before we knew that we were going to be over in the budget and so forth CU um that certainly would have had an impact on decisions um 9 so we have 96 um actual employees uh that are administrators of the 95 that were budgeted we have 683 certifi folks um we the board approved 655 um and then same thing with non-certified 672 you see the biggest variance is going to be um with your non-certified folks um and so there's 78 when you look all the way to the the

037far right position differences there's one over in administrators 28 over in certified folks those are classroom teachers um and then the non-certified the 78 is where you see the biggest variance what you'll also see in that 8.7 million green number um it goes back to the budget we saw earlier the 53 million the 3 million that's because some of the administrators are in that certified category when we budget for this 25 26 school year we'll specifically L apart where it's just administrators whether they're School based or District so that's in category as well as certified and non-certified um and and I get in the next couple of slides there only a couple more left we'll talk specifically about how we are going to you prepare for next year um so uh again you'll see in

038the bottom right corner we'll be over by one roughly 1.4 million uh All Things Considered um and then uh the the board budget you have a digital copy but this is the actual budget that I'm referring to when I'm talking about what page is coming from the current budget that was presented uh back in April then revised uh for the June 26 meeting where the board approved the budget for this year next slide please uh what you see here are the schools okay at the very first slide I showed you there are 23 schools here they are we broke them apart um you know the budgeted number of the positions that the board approved then the actual uh we have the amount of budgeted salary the actual salary and then the far right where you

039see the colors um the pinkish reddish color are is where we're over the green is where we're under um and same thing with the actual difference in terms of the amount of the salaries um so you can take a look at that as well um what I can tell you is the biggest variance that as we um sort of uh did did an analysis the biggest variance is going to be at MCL north um and and we know why um we had a number of Administrators there we had some moving around of folks at the schools and so in the budgeted uh the initial budget there were like four or there there were like four head principal roles there right and that kind the salary was budgeted there even though it didn't end up being

040that way and that's what kind of skews the budget itself but it kind of shakes out once you look at the final numbers so those are all the schools okay and then the last slide I have here is uh for the Departments these are all the 16 departments um that we looked at what I'll start by saying here is we pulled out Safety and Security I told you last week when I met uh with the board to give you a PR preliminary uh sort of view of where we were I'd already met with ran and Jamar in their Department um and what we found is going to make a whole lot of sense going into next fiscal year is making sure we pull out all those roles that are non um teacher roles or or

041instructional roles we're going to put them in their Department that way the board knows how much money are we spending in Safety and Security how much how money are we spending in Food Service how much are we spending uh for custodians and and the like so we'll pull all those out uh Terry and I spent probably a whole day together the other day after I went through his departments because he technically has the biggest departments when you look at the numbers of folks in transportation operations and maintenance met with each of his Department leads and we went through every employee in fact he even did some math himself um to make sure our numbers were accurate and so that was really good um Oliver is lowkey math Weirs he don't tell anybody but he was

042really good about making Mak sure we had accurate numbers too um so here are all departments um where we were with the Departments you'll see the biggest variance there is going to be in transportation at minus 21 what I can tell you there is most Transportation folks are hourly and so the budgeted amount in transportation is kind of over because it's kind of difficult to know what kind of um overtime there a lot of trips and things that are going on outside of the school day so there's a lot of variance there but I think budgeting for um that that additional money will will help us to stay in budget and still be able to provide schools with what they need you know if the football team needs to go somewhere and they need you

043know a driver to do that I mean we have to make sure that we keep um you know our functions of the district going and so so that variance is there but but that's going to help us in in in the end um and likewise with operations because a lot of folks uh work some overtime we have emergencies that happen things happen all the time and you got to be able to make sure that we keep functioning school well um and so these are departments um th this is e everything everybody um that we that we examine and there you have it board um any questions I have a couple of folks I may be able to answer if I can't hopefully some of the folks here can can help me with that um but

044um what questions do you have well thank you Dr Davis I'm just going to make a a joke SL comment but I see 92 cents I'm glad you really got down to the penny when you found one row that was 92 cents off total so appreciate that so we will start with Dr Paul Walker that's okay and we'll go this way down the board if that's okay sure um thanks Dr Davis I just had a couple of I have a a couple of questions and then a comment so um for the Safety and Security number where it is budgeted for eight but the actual positions is 43 is that the same as kind of what we talked about last week where uh these people are spread out all over the district and maybe being counted

045more than once yes ma'am the was where they were actually in the school's budget the 43 is where we took them out of the school's budget and put them all in rashan's department so that we when we go forward it's going to be a whole lot easier for us to be able to account for them okay um I I um I guess I'm just looking at you know thinking about a couple of things one know these are things that we're going to probably be doing but some sort of internal auditing uh to keep this from from happening again yes ma'am I'm also um thinking about the fact that you know there are human beings that are tied to this and these people have families right and so um I think I think this is too

046important for this to happen again does that make you know I just um I don't know you know this is a lot of positions and the board will have to probably think about you know how to get things back on track but it is it is simply too important for us to not have a better process in place to make sure that this doesn't happen again I'm also concerned about uh what this could potentially look like in terms of class sizes uh for you know for students make thinking about the conditions that they might be learning under so so yeah so that's that's basically it this is just something I'm uh something I'm thinking about yeah hey Anya if you could go back a couple C of slides where it had the variance of the

047certified non-certified administrators I think that'll probably um yeah that's the slide um so if you look at there Dr P Walker um the biggest um overages are with non-certified folks um and we have a few part-time quite a few part-time people that work as well um you see the teacher variance though is over by about 28 um and and so class sizes you know some places is you know high schools typically have smaller class sizes than what we want right and so that's an area that I think that's an opportunity the biggest issues are going to be in your elementary schools because we we know Desy has guidelines especially through K5 um so so I think we'll be able to get what we need uh when it comes to making sure we keep that class

048size in a good place um the the the non-certified people you know one of the pieces that you you talk about the whole 107 typically at the end of every year you have attrition right you have folks retiring um and when we when we do bud we're going to look at positions and not people okay and and the reason that's important is because as folks retire leave and go other places they leave that position that position remains open so hopefully as we move attrition will help us to your point around folks having families and got to take care of themselves and so forth attrition normally uh helps us there we we typically have about 90 to 100 new teachers every year um so when you look at the numbers themselves our retention rates pretty solid

049um you know we could certainly do better with the teacher shortage and so forth uh but my hope is that we'll focus on the positions and then as people leave we'll still have room for folks who who remain um so I can't give you any assurances other than we'll work hard here's the one thing we're going to do really clearly we've done in the past and and and and this last uh year it didn't didn't didn't pan out the way I thought it was um is that there will be clear communication with my office HR and finance um as we do Staffing um as we look at positions principles I feel really good about Department folks I feel really good good about cuz they know who the people are they know what they make I

050mean principls have been asking some really good questions about you know the salaries and when somebody leaves at a $90,000 salary and I hire somebody at a you know a salary that's less can I hire two people versus that and you can't do that because you know certainly based on enrollment um but but to your point and your concern um I think attrition will help us some there I can't say it's going to help us all the way through but I think it'll be a huge part of it well I I hope it shakes out that way yes ma'am um but you know when we look at non-certified staff and being 78 over doesn't cover everybody but a lot of those are our people who do some of the more essential things here in the

051district and their salaries are already not as high as you know maybe certified or administrators so that's why I'm particularly concerned about that group of people so I'm hoping it kind of works out in the way that you're uh you're talking about I also say that you this board um raised nobody Mak $15 an hour um and you know I just mean comparatively right absolutely you know that's the that's the group that you know would would take the biggest hit absolutely absolutely we're going to do everything we can to take care of folks thank you Dr palker Dr GES I think my only concern just um about this all is what is needed and what is needed and what's best for children yeah and so if we find that um all of these positions that

052we have people in places are what's need needed what does that look like for the board so I rather go on the need of and what our district needs versus okay we need to slash this we need to cut this because of we trying to get to um a perfect fund balance or whatever the case may be so I want to make sure that when we are deciding on what we're going to do with people in positions that we go based off of need I know I I recall several times that you've talked about this process and when we're looking at Staffing it's been based off of what students needed so if we are over I am thinking hopefully that is because we needed more than what we allow allowed it or budgeted for so

053my hope is that we are intentionally really looking at people places and what is needed for our students because um just knowing that um where our um students are levelwise they need as much support as they can get and the relationships that they're building and the people that are in the classrooms and the people who are outside of the classrooms if our students need it then I say let's find the money to get where we need to keep the people versus us um cutting people to get this perfect fund balance that we're looking at yeah and and and I'll say this and Dr Martin I talk on daily um you know again it goes back to positions versus people um I really feel strongly that you know especially after since this process is over um

054charl and Al spend way more time now in schools looking at classrooms looking at the roles of folks and what they do and what's essential and where are some areas that we can uh create opportunity as well as considering the numbers of folks who do leave each year um at the end of the day um you know we've got to have a good margin where we're operating so that we don't find ourselves here having to borrow money again um and then that we start the fiscal year in in a good solid place financially um Dr Singleton and I as well talk daily um and we're a lot Stock and Barrel about what we should do for 2526 um I'll specifically be looking at class sizes across the across the board um particularly at high schools

055in our programs we're going to do an analysis also of our programs because there are some programs that may or may not be what we need versus what we want uh so we'll be much um more fiscally responsible I think the community would want to know how um you know we're taking that approach so that we do get what we need so that's a great great Point Dr thank you Dr Thurman yes thank you Dr Davis I especially want to say thank you for pointing out that there is a need for us to make sure that Finance HR that they're communicating that's and then that you're communicating and then that's communicated to the board um with everything that has happened this year has truly opened my eyes because this is not an area that I

056this is not one of my areas of expertise but I'm learning so much through this um I do want to try and understand on the budget certification under Administration where you have 95 board approved and we had 96 I understand that that number um and that we were one over explain the salary difference that 8.5 million in on that same yes Ma'am why is that one person who that is um but so so so go back that's an excellent question Dr kit go back go back to the previous go back to the previous slide um where I had the budget actually another one please um One More slide please back yeah that one so you know again if you look at the 53 million and the 3 million and add those two together it actually

057has the all the administrators in there okay so if you would have put those numbers together it would account for the additional 8.5 million right uh because um so think about the 8. um5 million that you just saw okay and then you take that number and you add to it that 3.3 million number that's line number two on the green if you add 8.5 and 3.3 you get about 11.8 11.9 don't you okay so so so keep that in mind okay now f fast forward for me Ane a couple of slides um to the the one that actually had it broken apart uh go one more ah there it is so you now look at that first row that says administrators okay and go all the way to the end and you see that number

058you see the 11.9 when you take those numbers the 8.5 or so and the other $3 million or so that was in the budget itself and put those together you get about that same amount what happened was when they actually did the budget itself it actually had the school-based administrators in with the certified people certified teachers okay um and so what we'll do as we go forward is we'll break that apart so it's much clearer here okay if you even go back to you see where it says the 3.57 3357 million on the administrative line if you take that number and sort of add it to the 8.5 million that's over you're going to still get 11.9 okay or thereabouts um and so that's the issue not not one person is making that kind of

059money I want that job and I kind of knew that but this is kind of confusing yeah no absolutely to to read this and and to to see that and same thing with with certified when you go and you say you're 25 28 over yet we're under budget it almost looks like we're underpaying yeah the teachers so this this is really confusing to me is there another way that we can report this out so that people like me sure can understand that's a good point go back to the to the budget again please um so so so this is I would never have gone back and started piing those numbers out what you see there is on page 146 and what I did want to do was change what the board had already approved so

060I could have taken it and repurposed it and showed you in a much more even column right but what I wanted to do was make sure that we use what the board had already done what the community has already seen as to how we've already appropriated those dollars so what you see up here is already uh is in here as well I wanted to leave that there back to those two slides again for me y back to the the the previous one yes there so I wanted to keep that 3 million I could have easily have taken that 8.5 and put it into that area but that's not how it's written in the budget and so I didn't want to change that information because then it it would be more misleading if somebody from the

061community takes a look at the budget book and then they look at these numbers I wanted these numbers to align as much as I could now going forward we'll absolutely make sure that that happens because it is confusing but we wanted to make sure that we stay consistent with the numbers that were out there already does that make sense it may not but but but I hear you loud and clear I hear you loud and clear is that you have okay uh thank you again uh I think one of the questions I know I had how many district administrators are there versus building administrators I I prepped you that I was going to ask that so I just you put it in your notebook um you know I actually was doing some analysis as we

062finished up the numbers and I specifically took a look at I went through the pivot T Ryan created some great pivot tape pivot tables um and when you take um the administrator number that's here Dr Martin 11.9 um 51 938 number I I actually got it down to almost the penny only because it rounds sometimes when you looking at if it's less than a dollar of that $1.95 million that we have for administrators we have 56 administrators um in the school okay we have 40 that are at the district level um the salaries um total of those 56 people at the schools is 6.68 million okay that's 56% so of that $1.9 Million number 56% of that money goes to school-based administrators okay and then then of that same number the other 44% is paid

063in District level salaries um I even broke it down by average salary at the school versus the um versus the central office thank you I think you know to Dr Paul Walker's Point I think as the board is going to make some tough decisions later on it's the bigger we're seeing bigger picture like where's the closest to the children Dr Graves alluded to like are the children taken care of because just helps us make decisions as we see so I think even if we dive in and start breaking non-certified if IED in the bigger category certainly I operations staff have a large role in making our district run and operate abolutely um seeing that versus non-certified directly supporting in a school just to give us that big picture kind of those big picture categories are

064making decisions because obviously we're going have to do something I know you didn't necessarily speak on it but for the rest of the board just to know like so 1.4 Bill million doesn't include salaries retirement and other taxes so you're talking about closer to 1 .7 1.8 million just in benefits and that so I mean there is additional cost that I think you know and I I'm sure if we would call Bermuda and say hey do you feel like you're 10 people overstaffed I have a feeling they probably would say how please tell me how we're 10 over staffed and so I think you know this is is it's good information for us to have as we really think through I think one of the things that historically I feel is one and seven we've

065approved proved a lot of programs thinking there's money in the budget and if I had to choose people over programs I'm going to choose people and so I think really getting some clarity as you dive in next kind of into the programs what is the purpose to back to Dr Graves point I think how do we shift some of that money she didn't say that but like how do we get where the children are people are going to take care of the kids more than programs so how do we really find additional money maybe in supplies and purchases of services to move into salaries cuz we know we're going to have to address salar at some shape because this dollar mounts saying no one's getting a raise right and so certainly we need to continue

066to be competitive in the market that we're in otherwise we're not going to have people I don't know like for Terry's Department there's 21 bus drivers it looks like that he can still hire does he need 21 more I don't know how many more he really needs type of thing just because they're obviously making buses operate that's not one thing we've heard about we've heard certainly about bus Behavior but not necessarily needing not enough drivers buses aren't showing up so you know I think as we dive into those things just really I think it'll be really helpful to get into uh that the other piece I just have a question on obviously uh we took a stance with you of essentially eliminating all vacancies and then going through a new process so if we did

067not do that we'd probably be in a worse position and so my my question is I know I think yesterday we got a job posting right m i get there's still positions that need to be filled where do those positions that are still out on the website which when I look on the website there's not nearly as many as there used to be are those accounted for in this budget or is that just continue to increase our amount of how much over budget we are yeah if we hire more people it's going to add on to what we already have the deficit that we already have um so technically we need to stop um and take a look at what we need what I said um when I shared this with the board earlier around

068so we didn't do any freezes what we did was we paused to take a look at what the need was um you know anything that got approved had to come through me um and I was clear if it was close to the school the classroom there's never been a teacher that somebody's asked me if we could hire that person especially if we know we had the position that we didn't do it because we do have some long-term Subs that's not accounted for in this as well um and so those long-term sub positions where we can find a certified teacher that we know we can get absolutely we move forward on that um so so so we have to really take a different approach to our fiscal responsibility especially when you talk about the vacancies that

069are there and what we need um even with you know the cash flow situation and now tax dollars are starting to come in we have a little bit of breathing room but we can't keep doing business as we have been doing it right otherwise we're going to find oursel in this place at the end of the year and we don't want to do that so that's why I'm going to dig into the programs themselves but what I will say to a point you made earlier Dr Martin I think he used Bermuda for example if we call them they say they have 10 extra people the reality was when the budget was done there are positions that weren't even included in the budget so when you look at what a school needs you have to do

070a good analysis of what has our Trend being in terms of enrollment and everything else that we've had over the last 3 to five years so we can project what a good solid budget looks like as we go into the next FIS school year and that's what we've done for a long time uh and and that didn't happen last year um so there were some schools that didn't even have a librarian for example that the person's been there for a while but it wasn't included in the budget so the budget was um you know less it didn't meet the Mark is what I'm saying and and we have to make sure and Dr sing and I have had this conversation that as we go into 25 26 and do the budget cycle for this year

071that we're pretty spoton with enrollment programs so that when we appropriate a budget and bring to you in April in a preliminary form that we can have not only tell you how many we need but justify why we need these positions and we'll have time by then to look at these programs to see which ones are effective you know we we adopted a couple of new curricula for ELA so and math so if we are using spring math and Eureka Math why do we have all these other apps and other things that folks are pulling in that are costing dollars it may be $25 a month or whatever but those numbers add up so what we have to do is make sure that we do a clean bill of health when it look when we

072look at what our priorities are strategic plan the goals you have set for me so that when we spend money it's based on what our goals are and not just because somebody likes the program I I appreciate that and certainly I know one things that frequently we can get out of contracts need be is a financial Str and certainly by the board having to borrow $9.5 million is a sign of financial stress just because we've not done that for right a decade so I appreciate you that I guess my one last comment then I move on and Miss done is to me uh certainly I'm hopeful by we've put a a pause on many purchase of services and supplies but we still are meeting the needs of our kids and our teachers uh for that

073is I'm hopeful that when we get the amended budget yeah we can actually see where we the salaries will not be over budget in the amended budget that we can come back with a new Fresh balance budget New Perspective uh for from February through June 30th so that way we're not seeing over budget and we're really seeing how much salaries we spent this year because I I'm sure there's going to be money that you're not going to spend in purchases services and supplies based on your pause right now that you'll be able to move over to these other to really justify I think it'll just be really important for the board to kind of see in February show us an amended budget that actually covers our expenses we know what they are by February we

074should have a clean idea what our tax revenue is going to be to really know what our income is Dr Singleton's already made it very clear we're not going to get the $1.3 million in interest rate because we don't even have that much money to invest so all those things we can factor in uh of that so I would I think I'm hopeful that we'll see an amended budget that's balanced re balanced yes sir I'll use that okay Miss D hello hey um so first I just want to say thank you to you and your team for all of the work that youve put into this audit um anytime we have personel discussed we know that there can be a lot of anxiety around it um and when you started this presentation I just I

075wanted to comment on my appreciation for your transparency that we are going to have some recommendations to come we may not have them tonight but recommendations will be coming um and so I guess my question is even though I know you've said before you don't want to overpromise an under deliver uh do you have an idea of when we'll have another update or um when we might be able to see what recommendations would come out of this that's a great question Miss D um in fact um you know I certainly want to you know meet with the board president as I always do and make sure we're on the same on the same page and then share with the board and make sure the board endorsed is it but I think monthly we can have

076some conversations about what we do going forward um the budgeting process for next year is going to start almost immediately when the new year begins principal already ready because they feel more um Adept um to who's in their buildings what we're spending Etc uh and so I feel confident that they're spending time with their budgets right so we'll be able to you know put together a really good budget but but I think monthly we should be sharing with the board first of course and then the community at large where we are that new amended budget here's where we are um and then monthly uh you know you know here's where we are so we can make sure we stay fully transparent to the community um because they have to trust us and trust that we're

077spending tax dollars well U there's been no mismanagement of course uh Dr Martin has said that and I want to underscore that um but I also want to say that we've got to do a better job at making sure that we're pretty accurate with our data which is why we looked at every person so I think monthly we ought to have some report out um and I'll take my guidance from you all about what that looks like and so just just that I fully understand when you say monthly um I heard you also say we'll get the new budget by February um but even our first board meeting in January there would be some sort of an update are we going to wait until that February piece and then monthly from there yeah I I

078don't I don't want to overpromise anything I want to meet with uh my president and the board and you all give me guidance U but as soon as we can have something for the board in the community uh then you know as soon as you give me the green light we're going to share it okay perfect I just wanted to clarify that because I like like I started off I think that there is a lot of anxiety when we're talking about the Personnel piece and I'm I'm sure that we have people out there watching tonight and who are wondering what's going to come next so just so that it's clear for them that when we come back beginning of January we're not going to have all of the answers I just I want to be

079sure that that is very clear and that's out there so that so that we know um my second question you kind of have already talked about but I just want to understand a little bit more so we know personel is our biggest cost and it made sense that that's like where we're starting in this internal auditing process so what are our next steps going to be I know we've talked about programs tonight but what are those next steps going to be as we're diving into this budget more um and again I know that we're going to be bringing a new budget for the remainder of the Year February to June 30 um but what are those next steps going to look like for us you know it could be a number of ways um you

080know when you look at a budget period you have your salaries and benefits are dependent variable um you know you know you always multiply a salary by 16% so 1.16 and then it's about 10 to $105,000 for a medical uh per person that's full-time um so so we'll look at you know the impact on the benefits as well so we can get a fuller picture of the of the budget itself um and then we'll look at TH those other large categories like uh programs uh which are and our purchase services and then our supplies and so as we look at those large categories especially when we look at programs we want to again examine uh is this something we need um and and is it giving us the board and the community the return on

081the investment and that so those places that we know it's not um then I'll make a recommendation to the board and you'll give me direction uh but the other part that I want to spend some uh some some really good time in is in schools uh not only looking at these programs and their impact but also being able to support our employees so I can look at class sizes a little deeper um look at where we may need some folks here or not there etc etc so that I only have it on paper but I can physically see what's happening and how I can best support uh the folks on my team and the folks uh out in our uh out in the trenches who actually do the hard work for for our for our

082babies every day so that's why I want to spend my time the next 30 days U I spend it most of mostly in my office doing this audit and I don't regret it I do regret not being able to be in schools more um I will be in schools tomorrow and Friday um but but yeah H hit right okay thank you that's all I have appreciate it thank you Miss Don Mr Tyson what's up um okay hey Dr Davis Hey sir hey um all right and looking well let's first start to go to just so I can be when on page six to Dr Thurman's point just so I'm clear the original budget showed um only District level administrators which is why that says $3 million right so are you on the actual budget six

083page six yeah right there yeah that's one okay okay yes sir but at some point this year you decided to move building administrators to that budget line item which is why now it says 11 million MH hence why that number is over 8 million in the where they were at first is under 8 million yeah not exactly I hear you loud and clear okay so so let's go back to the slide that has the budget on it if you would Ane yeah um you know what let me do a real some real quick math yeah so what I what I was trying to convey Mr Tyson um is that $53 Million number that you see up there that's what was in the budget when the board approved it back in June okay um in that

08453 million 53, 71699 number it also includes administrators School administrators okay um the other $3.3 57 million are uh District level people it's even kind of hard to decipher whether some of them are building or District level but what I can tell you is that if you take those two numbers and add them together you'll have all the administrators and then you'll have all the certified people in one category okay and so what I wanted to do was not change that so it wouldn't confuse someone if they take a look at the budget and then they see my analysis wondering where those numbers come from so I couldn't change that because it's was already there what I tried to do in the actual was show you that $1.9 million of those 56 or 57 million

08511.9 million are all administrators so yes I guess that's kind of the point I'm alluding to is that a lot of these differences that we're seeing is AR real you well because even though you changed the admins from where they're reported yes sir you also did it in Safety and Security and I think that you also did it in another row uh no I think those are the two R okay so then my point so when you look at these differences um you know we see where the greatest you know differences was but it's in these uh from the district or from the building admins to the district admins but I kind of want to know what was the logic you know in making those moves why are we why do we stop reporting admins

086in the building budget versus the the admin budget here you know just kind of share what the logic was behind it because we won't see it like this again because they're going to be in the right line it but my point is now that we're it's just a funny time that you done that because we're dealing with a budget crisis so uh not really a budget crisis okay but go ahead yeah so so go forward for me on you if you will to the slide that Mr Tyson's referring to the next one yes that one so you know again the 3357 number and the 533 number we just saw on the budget itself and then if you move over to the actual I put all the administrators one place I mean it really goes to

087the question that Dr Martin just asked a minute ago how many um administrators are at the school versus how many administrators um are at the district level back to Dr graves's point we want the money as close to the students as possible I couldn't tell you that just looking at the the $3 million one and the 53 million doll one I need to be able to break it apart by category so if you yes sir and so and so that's why I said you know we have three categories of people we have administrators we have certified we have non-certified and and that way as you appro money in the budget for next year you may ask the question how much money are we actually spending on our Safety and Security because I heard somebody say

088I'm not doing another thing un unless it's about safety right I'm not approving another thing so so I'll be able to tell the board this is how much money we're already spending on this particular category so that's why I broke it apart that way so that you could have a clear picture of how we're investing our dollars in the community could as well and another thing that I did just so I'm clear so when I on page seven yes sir when I did the position different say did my totals I came up with 67 right but then I thought about it but wait a minute he said that he moved um people out of the building budget to a different budget for example to to Pas so when I took that number out it really

089only came to 32 but then when you take your admin positions out of that number yeah then really where is your difference in your position difference do you see what I'm saying because the security officers were in the original budget position numbers right yes sir they were in then the actual they're not there anymore they're in her her department now right so then you have these differences over here so I guess my my breakdown number came up to 32 but my point I'm making is that we won't see this differences this way this had a lot to do with the moving of people from where they're being budgeted yeah so so go one more slide on for me to the Departments yeah so if you look here Mr Tyson um specifically look at Safety and

090Security which is about maybe five from the bottom um you see eight that was budgeted but you see 43 that are there now that was me moving all of bash's team from the school's budget to her Department budget okay if you also take a look um at um food service so food service was a little bit of an anomaly because we have a lot of folks that are are part-time as well um and so when we sat with Priscilla uh and she knows everybody like she can tell you drop of her Dy who folks are where they are etc etc um but but what you but what you'll find is that some of the folks few of them were the Food Services were actually in the school's budget but they were also in the district

091um the district level budget so some places folks were accounted for two times and you can't have a budget where you got people double counted right so we made sure that all the folks that she had as is is in the department budget so again we want to take we want to isolate uh instructional so we can say clearly how much money we're spending on what's closest to Children okay as well as those who support teachers um and how much money we're spending there because as Dr power walker said before you know it's the folks who sometimes don't make the most but are the most essential in the work so teachers can do their work so we want to be able to say how we're investing in all of our folks we can also say

092um you know what you know what's the need if we have some folks who are in our custodial Department in operations and maintenance they may need some additional training well how much money are we spending already and then what do we need to do to invest in our folks in those in those places so so what what I'm what I'm after and and and as long as the board is okay with it I want to make sure every department has their own budget and the people in their budget so veran or uh Terry C his operations you can move folks wherever you need them you know if you need a security uh officer at one school one and somebody at a different School different week you need to have the autonomy to be able to

093do that and not mess the budget up um but what what's what's also a problem too and a good point you rais is moving these people out and then HR is not at the table and then you trying to figure out where people are you talk about a mess in an accounting system with these internal controls like you can't do it and then I'll find myself doing internal audits every year I don't want to spend my time doing that uh so what I want to do is make sure that we put folks in those departments so that the department heads can move people as they need them based on what children need we still have our budget intact um and then we can know whether you know what we want to invest more in that

094was the answer I was looking for I may not have asked the question right but I was asking what was the logic behind it that's exactly what I wanted cuz I wanted to hear but I'm sure other people wanted to hear what was the logic behind the moving yes but it only makes sense because like vashan said in one of her presentations you know this this security guard might be in McLure today and budgeted on McClure's budget yeah but she needs them somewhere else right quick but yeah so I app we don't need a we don't need because they're um you know in McClure's budget that they can't go to another school you know now you now you have some restrictions with federal dollars because you know time and effort when you put a person

095in the school if they'll pay through federal dollars they have to stay there uh but that's mostly instructional though yes I got you I love it thank you yes sir thank you for the work what if you have one person working in two different departments how do you give me an example of what you're talking about say you have someone working in food service but also drives a bus yeah I know that probably not but yeah how would you yeah we actually the difficult part we we we actually have some of that uh that's a good point you raised U and I'll use a a really specific example um and I won't call anybody's name but it's really somebody in rashan's Department too so we have a teacher who teaches an elementary school but that

096teacher also is a crossing guard okay um and so when you pull that teacher's uh or or or any school you pull a teachers um you pull up a paycheck you can see that there is a couple of it line items on their payroll check that has them being a certified teacher but they also get additional monies for being a Crossing garden and it varies right so so you can still do those things um what we want to make sure is that we don't tie the hands of our our leaders so that they can make sure that we serve our children the best way we can and so that's why we have to have our budgets by department so they have that flexibility same thing with food services but prilla knows it way better than

097any of us do and so when she knows she needs someone that cross keys for example and she needs to pull them from Ferguson Middle School she should be able to do that without having to worry about going through through payroll yes yes ma'am yeah um you know I mean other than the example I gave here they're not a whole lot of instances where we have someone doing a lot of different things right most folks are either you know a teacher or an administrator or and the like but we do have folks who make additional based on the the ability you know like the crossing guard component of it most of those are going to be in departments like verons or even uh in teror Department as well um and when we try to be

098really particular when we're looking at the roles um that we put folks in um you know the other part that I'll bring up at this moment are um you know we have a whole different budget when it comes to substitutes and then we have a different budget when it comes to um stiping right and so and so we you know John compass in particular has done a really good job at laying out a format for that so we make sure folks get appropriately compensated for those additional duties uh but we've got to make sure we keep our hands around that but it does happen um and we've been pretty good about keeping it you know where it needs to be but we're going to be even better at it now um once folks are at

099the table Finance HR superintendent Finance HR superintendent because I got to tell you where we are and I want to make sure it's clear in my head Mr tyon you good thank you thank you Mr Bailey yeah by the time it gets to me all the questions are already asked so I don't want to be redundant but we talk about programs and different things like that and everybody knows I'm a big advocate for programs Community stuff I mean that's that's just who I am as a person I really want to know like I understand cutting programs and the effectiveness but I also want to kind of mediate that as well as understanding that even if it's a program it's a lot of free Partnerships that can help supplement those programs so as we looking at

100the list of programs and that part I also would like to update to see kind of what Partnerships around the nation can kind of help supplement those programs because taking away programs are good financially but sometimes the effectiveness does affect the kids uh so we need to make sure that we provide Partnerships because there's and correct me if I'm wrong and this is a number off the top of my head I think it's like 1.6 registered non for-profits in St Louis um so that means that it's a lot of people that have partners ship that can help that are free yeah so really kind of leveraging the relationships that we have as a district and figuring out ways that we can partner with other uh non for-profits or self- serving uh sovereignties to help uh

101supplement that my second point is is and I've always asked this so specifically and I'm not picking on Terry's Department specifically one of the questions I have is the people that are in his number because we've always said too that we do a lot of uh Outsourcing as far as his Department are those truly human like people that are full time within our district those numbers are those people that are that were Outsourcing as well because some buildings have some buildings don't have a full-time District employee they have a person that comes in that we Outsource M so we do have a lot of agency employees uh folks who come from different agencies to work U we work with temporary agencies Terry also does some Contracting for example with of the grounds work uh he

102may bring in someone who is contracted and they actually do some of that work as well so we have folks on the outside um we we have quite a few agency people our early a for example um we're able to get a couple of additional teachers coming in through a particular agency that supplies us with you know the birth to to three-year-old babies um but that's all contracted and so so we have a lot of those Partnerships and and that's that's been really helpful otherwise we probably couldn't feel some of those things that we do um but to the point around those um non for-profit agencies U I'm really excited about the work that Dr Shaw's doing she gives me an update in cabinet every Monday um and she's been spending a lot of time

103in the community bringing folks in in fact I had a meeting the other day um doc U Mr Michael Brown senior he him and his wife were here um and we had a chance to sit in my office and talk Dr Char has been working with a lot of Partners in the community and her being from here is really helpful um but building those relationships and bringing folks in writing grants and finding that money and U and working with those agencies across the entire St Louis region it's really exciting so I think you'll be happy as we move forward I can't make any promises other than know she's working hard at it is making me happy to see folks coming into our district um and being supportive um you know there's a lot of work

104to do um but but what I can tell you I believe strongly as a as a father is it's important that we provide our children with the best quality education that we can and you don't have to be rich and a matter way you black or white rich or poor what matters is you have good conditions quality every day um and as we build these Partnerships in the community I have a meeting with a gentleman um I won't say his name but he's you know you know with McClure he owns a an Architecture Firm and Dr Graves knows him well but you know it's people who want to support our district uh who have the means to be able to do that work um and and and my job is to make sure that we

105you know keep folks coming into our community that want to support our schools we're improving but we still got a lot of work to do and we can't do it alone it's going to take folks in our community to help us and I appreciate you stating and that's why just want to kind of reiterate my point is just making sure that you know as we as we looking at Partnerships and leverages and stuff like that you know is always you know the first thing programs are always the ones to go but a lot of the programs within the school district or or was keeping families within our school district so just ensuring that we can find different leverages of Partnerships I find is very helpful uh I definitely appreciate what you're doing it's hard to

106get up there and be on a hot seat um so I appreciate that I appreciate you being so forthcoming um and I'm not going to kind of repeat what a lot of people have said because I think I share the same sentiments as far as making sure that our kids are served our community is served our staff is served making sure that they're well compensated as well um so I just appreciate that yes sir thank you thank you so much Dr Davis um want to uh recognize for the board just for everyone to know January 8th which why Doc miss dun when you said the first meeting January I kind of gave you a look that one's a virtual consent only agenda so that meeting due to the winter break and then being closed it

107will be a virtual meeting only with consent only on there so just kind of you look at your calendars January 8th will be a virtual consent only agenda potentially board to plug in to add in with the student discipline meetings on the 15th maybe I'll work with Dr Davis about adding a Clos meeting to discuss some of these Personnel issues to get some updates so potentially on January 22nd at our first official in-person meeting for the month we could provide the community with some updates potentially so I'll go with Dr Davis but just uh pencil in on the 15th which we already have a closed meeting for discipline to maybe add on to that based on how many hearings we have to get just kind of a discussion about some of the Personnel issues we

108have no meeting on the 29th so that means uh we would be good to go with that motion to adjourn y go ahead is there a second second roll call vote please secretary votes yes Dr Thurman yes Dr Graves yes Dr Paul Walker yes Mr Bailey yes Mr Tyson yes Dr Martin yes meeting J happy Holidays happy holiday

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.