001e e e good evening uh it is December 11 2024 and we are extremely late it is 6:22 and we do apologize for our tardiness as we're finishing up our Clos meeting and we'll be going back to closed after this meeting so uh just remind the board members of the meeting Norms uh that we have set and at this time please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance well thank you everyone for coming to our board meeting this is our only regular scheduled board meeting for the month of December this month so just a reminder for that we hope everyone has a wonderful holiday season ahead and a wonderful end of 2020 24 in a great springing to 2025 our first meeting in 2025 will be virtual due to the winter break so
002we will not be having inperson meeting the very first one it will be a consent only meeting in January virtually and then our regular scheduled meeting will be back in action on the last uh the fourth Wednesday of the month so just a reminder this will be the last one you'll see us here otherwise the next one will be virtual and it should be a short meeting because it's consent only and then we'll be back to our regular schedule so just want to put that on your radar if you're wondering about that item number three under the provisions of the public meeting law for the state of Missouri the board must by adopt by roll call vote and agenda the time date Place intend of agenda for the meeting a copy of the notice and
003agenda for this meeting is posted on Tuesday December 10th 2024 at Administration Center 8855 dun Road Hazelwood Missouri at the same time copies and notices and gend sent to Major radio television stations three newspapers municipalities all schools in the district website is there a motion to approve uh the adopt the agenda as presented moved by Tyson second second by Graves seeing any corrections seeing none all those in favor say I I any opposed extensions I should have done roll call vote let's do roll call just so we know who's also here thank you Dr Graves I uh secretary votes yes Mr Tyson yes Mr Bailey yes Dr Thurman yes um and Dr Martin yes motion carries and Dr Paul Walker's walking in right now just let everyone know item number four Declaration of cany Ferguson
004Flores board members Miss Jillian Dunn and Dr sheal Paula Walker are three-year terms expire April 2025 Declaration of cany May picked up in the office of superintendent 8855 downroad Haywood Missouri from 8:00 a.m. to 400 p.m. on days the districts open under Missouri law the first day of filing was December 10th from 8: a.m. to 4:00 p.m. the last day following December 31st from 3:00 to 5:00 p.m. please note the hours are shorter doing due to the district being closed for winter break filing will be by appointment only the office will be closed December 24th and 25th requests for appointments can be made by emailing uh Jack Wellen mcwell Jay mcwell at fergflor.org in the subject line type candidate filing please include your contact information in the body all the other information is presented and
005that will be for octo April 2025 we'll be conducted by cumulative voting next up is item number five msba update this portion of the meeting is dedicated to an update from a short video from Missouri School Board Association provider a current report of the interest of board members and the community welcome to the December edition of the Missouri school boards Association board report 2024 marked another year of AI continuing to transform classrooms over the past year AI has become more than just just a buzzword it has become an integral part of the learning experience in many of our schools teachers are harnessing AI powered tools to personalized education tailoring lessons to meet each student's unique needs in October the Raymore Peculiar School District hosted an AI and Innovation Summit designed for educators administrators and Tech
006enthusiasts to discover the latest advancements in AI for education and to explore practical applications Raymore Peculiar board president and msba immediate past president Ruth Johnson said that artificial intelligence is a topic that school boards need to address well we need to care because whether we like it or not AI is here it's been here so how can we best utilize it as a tool with our teachers to help educate the students at all levels Emily Craig is an English teacher at rayek high school and she says that having students involved in the process of integrating and questioning AI tools is an example of real world learning that can help them in future careers you know we always talk about what are those those invaluables those skills that students are going to need no matter what
007they're doing and AI Real World Learning soft skills all of those are going to be like how to manage and adapt are all going to be skills that kids are going to need no matter what they're doing and so I think teaching them tools learning how to question tools and also like embrace them but also critique them and that process is going to be a lifelong skill no matter what they're doing rore peculiar High School assistant principal Steven Meek said says that AI is a disruptor in education but in a positive way we're always looking for disruptors whether we want to believe it or not uh we're always looking for disruptors in education to figure out how can we disrupt the classic traditional education that has been going on in schools for the last 20
00830 40 years and I really hope that AI is going to be that disruptor so we can say okay let's stop doing this learning that we can easily create um through Ai and let's start moving it to um you know things that like much more Project based much more uh learning that students are going to need for the 21st in here in the 21st century let's start figuring out like those types of things that makes learning more engaging more fun and we move away from that rope memorization during mba's AI symposium held in conjunction with the msba annual conference in Kansas City students had a chance to speak to the audience about the ways that they use AI during a panel discussion they stress the real world applications of AI and how schools can help
009prepare students I think that in the world where we're going to live in in the future AI is going to be a huge part of that so by by outright saying it's cheating and allowing no AI we're doing a disservice to our students and we're we're almost handicapping them for the future I do think that there is a line though where cheating can be seen but but that can be very that can be very very much kind of minimized be through you know changing your curriculum a little bit to and to like integrate Ai and generative AI into it or changing almost the assignments you're asking or what you're necessarily testing on so that it's harder to use AI as an end all be all answer and AI is less of I'll just plug in
010and get and and get a 100 and more of I'll use AI to help me get towards that answer get towards my finished product um if it was up to me I think AI should be used regularly because in the real world you're going to use Ai and AI is already used in so much stuff it's not like it's just going to randomly be deleted because it's basically used for almost anything and everything nowadays with new information coming out seemingly daily it's difficult to stay on top of a topic as complex as artificial intelligence msba is here to help from beginner to Advanced mba's AI toolkit for K12 education is a great resource for topics ranging from AI policies and procedures and security concerns to ethics and Equity the toolkit is available on the msba
011website and is updated often if you're still feeling unsure about the emergence of artificial intelligence or not sure where to start msba has a webinar for you coming soon the webinar is titled Ai and education what school leaders need to know and it's being held Monday January 13th from 6:30 to 8:00 p.m. mba's AI team will provide a balanced approach to the subject highlighting both the positive and negative aspects of of AI the webinar is free for msba member districts when you register for the webinar make sure to submit questions and topics that you would like to see addressed and as we head into 2025 make sure to mark your calendar for mba's advocacy day on March 11th summer Summit June 16th through the 18th and the 2025 msba annual conference October 23rd through the
01225th that's it for this month's edition of the msba board report thank you for allowing us to have some time at your board meeting and thank you for your day dedication and the amazing work that you've done throughout all of 2024 we'll see you in January 2025 for the next msba board [Music] report thank you so much for msba update next up is item number six public comments I'm going to try my best to read really slow based on some feedback that others have sent in but I can't make promises as I have to think really hard about reading slow but the portion of the uh this portion allocates the meeting to allow stakeholders opportunity to comment on both agenda items and non-agenda items at the start of each board meeting board president will read
013aloud any comments that a pre previously been submitted while all the comments will be included in the board evening material may be found in public comments the board May limit the number of comments read allow due to repetition prior to public comments in person applicant or participants are asked to fill out a card with their name address phone number topic to be addressed and will'll have be allowed 3 minutes members of the audience who wish to speak to the board of course to speak from the podium identify themselves and keep with District policies and shall refrain from making negative comments that are personally identifiable the board will not directly respond to speakers during the public comment period the board president may clar make clarifying REM marks at the end of the comment session to correct
014any misstatements of facts with that we have Sheila Doug and then McLure high school student voice and student group will be our three in person so Sheila you are up first Shelly sorry is it Shelley Sheila Sheila got it speaking about programs for students what is taken place since last year because I know that other I guess I should speak for MCL North because I know other schools have different programs and we don't have our OTC and different things like that at that school at North um and then I do know they have the option to go to North County Tech but some of those programs are not going to have some sort of certified teachers to do some of those programs so then that's going to be lacking possibly next year so who will
015follow up with uh Sheil David Mr Murray will'll follow up with you okay thank you can I ask for clarify sure uh sorry I just want to make sure I understand what your question is so your question is about rooc and that program or other programs just overall like resources that could be helpful for students that either may not be able to afford college or you know so kids don't get lost I just feel like we're lacking in some of those areas of necessity for students that there's so many more programs out there and if we could pull those into some of the schools yeah so I think it may make more sense uh for CU she's been on some of my yeah you I'm making sense what I'm let my office follow my office
016will follow with you that way I can make sure we're on the same page and hopefully give you some answers okay thank you and what school again is it you representing MCL North you said got it okay thank you we just had something ask thank you next up Doug Jackson Career pathway so I had a conversation with um with Dr Crawford this afternoon that kind of blew up what I my carefully crafted thing that I was going to read um so I'm going to kind of wing it so me and all of you and all of you have a bias in in the way we educate our children we've all been to college so we think college right Dr Davis has a very admirable goal of having every kid giving every kid the opportunity uh
017in their education to be able to go to college but only about 20% of our kids go to college and 56% of them are below basic on their test scores we do a lot of career pathing but we do need to do more the career pathing that we do is very much skewed to White Collar jobs um I think the only Blue Collar career path that we have is carpentry we do have northtech but we've kind of maxed out this year how many kids we can send to northtech we're 16% of their enrollment right now um we need to have more kids in those programs um the electrician that came to my home and fixed uh something for me was a wizard I didn't know what he was doing but he got it done and
018it's fixed and it's great we need more of those people and that 56% of kids that are below basic we're likely dooming them to entry level minimum wage jobs for a good chunk of time but if we identify them early and get them into a skilled trade after a year or two of training and a few years of experience they can be making almost six figures and that's the path to the American dream that's the path to home ownership that's the path to getting breaking through Cycles um that our kids might be in second thing is they talked about it at msba is AI a lot of kids are going to be graduating college today or this year and their piece of paper that they got is going to be next to useless because of
019AI because AI is going to do a lot of things that these people are being train to do I can write computer code I can design a home I can design Rockets all in an AI system right now and we're in like the steam engine you know beginning of AI um and no matter if it's a architect you know a team or an architect or a team of Engineers that design a building we still need hundreds of skilled Crafts People to build those things and they are in short supply very very short supply so what we need maybe in partnership with North Tech we need our own tech school we need a school that's like steam but for bluecollar trades um it's a admirable career can make you good money support a family and like
020I said support get you to the American dream and we need to do more of it so um if we're going to and it will also help us put us in a situation where we don't lose as many kids like we did with steam we don't lose kids when they go into junior high if we have a trade school where you know nobody has no most School most districts don't have a trade school but we should because of the way the future looks thank you thank you Mr J I did hear you say you talked to Dr Crawford before do you want someone to follow up with you or do you feel like I I mean it's up to you I I I it's up to you so um a couple things Mr Jackson I
021know you and I talk quite a bit I actually want you to follow up um I'm going to have Mr Bradley Johnson and you have a conversation we just met with siou uh we have a lot of those programs right and I know North Tech has come up a bit and I w't try to get into all that um but I think you'll be excited of some of the work that's happening in fer floor U but I would love for you to have a conversation with Dr Crawford again and Bradley Johnson because I think you will find that we have some um some really good deep work underway around Pathways um and all especially McLure and other Schools are they had a pathway night um and doing a lot of work to cuz everybody that
022go to college actually the last number I had was about 38% of our kiddos go to fouryear schools another 20 some odd perent go to community colleges so if you look at just going to post uh secondary well over 50% of our students do but everybody's not going to necessarily go to a fouryear school they should have the skills right but I won't preach um I'll have Mr Bradley Johnson and Dr Crawford to follow up with it because I think he'll be excited at some of the stuff we're doing yes sir thank you next up is McClure high school student voice and student group and if you need more than a couple than three minutes there's a lot of you speaking so feel free to go over if you need to a little bit I
023was going to ask you for leniency uh good evening my name is Joe hosy and I'm the librarian at McClure high school and the student government sponsor my students would like to provide an update to the school board this evening about the work that they've been doing this year good evening my name is prian Banu and I am a 10th grade student at mccl high school on the student government Association a the student voice committee and student government work together to survey the students at McLure and identify areas of concern for improvement they identified six areas they wanted to focus on uniforms which is adding black restrooms Yonder pouches food in the cafeteria lockers and advisory at McLure we have already presented all of our work to Dr Melendez and Dr Crawford we would like
024to thank our student board representative Leilani B for encouraging us to come here and speak with you also thank you to Dr Melendez and Dr Crawford for listening and working with us on these issues thank you for having me my name is kenaya Gentry and I am a senior at McLure High School in the Student Government after identifying areas of concern we are able to meet with food services in Dr melindes and Dr Crawford as well as as well as send information to the building OTL committee as you are aware Miss Phillips spoke on uniforms concerns last the last school board meeting Food Services is scheduled scheduling new and Specialty items on all items for the minions at items for the minions at at all levels and the student government is working on ways to
025advertise these menu options in an easier format for students to receive information on those options we are excited to share that the pilot lock Locker boxes phone program has been approved for McLure high school for next semester good evening my name is Tristan Edwards I am a senior at McLure High School on the student government to continue with my peers said School restrooms at McLure are being addressed and analyzed as administrations are looking for new Locker opportunities for the future in fact staff and students are looking at new bell schedules to better accommodate the advisory period students recognize that all issues and concerns take time to figure out there is also a chain of command in which concerns and issues within the building that should be addressed self- adequacy is an important part of our
026high school experience thank you for having me my name is Kimberly Jones and I'm a junior at McClair High School on the student voice committee our student voice presentation and others have already been delivered to Dr melindes and Dr Crawford we are grateful that they are taking our concerns and requests seriously and are working hard to help us come up with options that benefit all students and teachers in our building thank you for listening to for to us tonight we appreciate the school board and would take the time to listen we would like to thank you for hearing us tonight and present these gifts on behalfs of the students at mlar High School EX thank you again thank you so much it's also so great to hear from our students directly and certainly thank you
027Miss Bops for advocating for other students to come forward I know we're not supposed to wait to uh acknowledge but certainly if we can just give them a round of applause because I think it's [Music] [Applause] awesome appreciate Dr Melendez and Dr Crawford as well listening and taking your concern seriously that's how change is made when you see a concern and you bring it up and glad to hear that our next uh one is Mr Taylor from McLure North High School good evening my name is Mark Taylor I have worked within the district for around 18 years I appreciate all of the hours you put into the district to keep the district moving forward the past several years principles have been shifted around the district I understand positions need to be filled and that principles
028themselves look for reassignments as well I hoping we can keep the same principles for more than a year I know that they invest a lot of energy into the students I think that consistent leadership in the building is a really positive experience for our students and parents I would like to see more consistency and leadership as teachers students parents and principles build positive relationships that create a stronger and safer environment for learning thank you for your time who'll be following up Dr Davis Dr Haywood will follow up thank you next up is Alexandria fips uh I'm not sure if this is the right time or place to make this request or if there's another department who handles this my students attending Cross Keys middle and currently there's color coordination for the grade levels this may
029already be the plan but I feel need express my concern can we please allow the color coordination that has been set for current seventh graders to follow them into eighth grade as parents have already spent well beyond the budget to accommodate for what's acceptable throughout the school year this will then make current eighth graders colors set for incoming eighth graders thank you who'll be following up U Dr Crawford Dr Crawford would follow up thank you so much I think that's all of the public comments uh for that next up is Miss Bops our student rep I do want to shout out and then I'm going to put Dr Graves on the spot just let you know I know you don't know but this is her last meeting with us as student rep and uh certainly
030we are going to miss having her voice we look forward to having a new voice and the reason I'm to put Dr graes on the spot is I really feel like this has been kind of like her baby of bringing it to the board and really pushing us to add that and so I appreciate Dr Graves pushing the board to add this and really kind of you got to see everyone interview for the position you got to kind of be part of that voice so thank you for Dr Graves for your vision for that but then also if you don't mind saying a few words about Miss Bops uh as we have get ready to have our last meeting with her and then we'll be going into Miss Bops I will first start off with
031um thank you for all those students who um one just in regards to who were just here I think this is really the power of advocacy and what it looks like and um and I don't want to take all the Thunder because I believe that this was I'm only one of seven but um student voice has always been important to the board and we said it we said it we said it and we wasn't able to really figure out exactly what we wanted it to look like but um I think the representative that you guys chose because we didn't choose it students chose um shows exactly what that needed to look like the person who comes next has some large shoes to feel I can recall the first time I met Leilani it was during
032our Equity journey and she was on the video and we were talking about equity and I was like oh my God what grade is she in and I think she was just in the six 6 s yes and it was like no way is she in that grade and she has been phenomenal ever since um just her leadership her compassion um it's so much that Lani has brought to um this seat and um her last presentation really showed exactly what we were looking for um when we were wanting to have student voice um so as being one of seven I just want to personally thank Leilani for showing us what student voice looks like what it needs to look like what representation looks like and um we all thank you for um getting us started
033so thank you so much thank you Dr Graves as well your turn thank you I feel a little awkward um well back to students so students we had a student voice meeting today um in the afternoon and students were presented with indicators of equity and chose some indicators that they believe could be improved upon in their school environments um some of the things that they chose were including but not limited to parents are not viewed as partners within schools um students are saying that just sending News letters to parents isn't enough and that they need to be more handson with their children's learning and more involved in their school environments um consequences at the schools are reactive and don't discourage repeat offenses slash Behavior so students would like to see some changes and how consequences
034are given out in order to make sure that it's actually effective and that changes are occurring um and students would like to see stronger bonds between them and their teachers they believe that this would be more conducive to their learning and overall morale of the school environment um everything that was talked about at the student voice meeting today will be given to the principles at schools so that we can work on how to improve upon these issues um like stated this is my last board meeting by myself so uh the new student Board of Education Representative election is currently happening um students have already submitted their essays to be graded and once the essays are graded a nominee from each High School be chosen to represent their high school they will do a video interview
035that will be shown to students across the entire district and from there members of student Voice through a sort of electoral college situation will vote on who is the next student voice representative or student board representative um the topic that they wrote the essay on was why is it essential for student leaders to Advocate and practice inclusivity how can they ensure that all students regardless of background feel represent so that is the question that the essay's answered and they are currently being graded and pretty soon we will have our new student board representative to be inducted in January and then uh I just wanted to make sure we give the McClure students another round of applause for coming up here I think this is a big show of faith in our students and respect for
036what they think should be changed in their school environments and I'm really proud of them for like taking an initiative and taking their school environments in their own hands so I'm excited for their pilot programs and for the changes that have already occurred and I wish them nothing but the best and then my last note was just to make sure as parents and teachers you're checking in on your students during final season it is a rough time for students they want all want to do good so just make sure that you're checking in on them make sure they're okay maybe take them out for ice cream or something after finals is over CU especially for the secondary students it can be a really stressful time for them so that is all for me today thank
037you for so much for your last report just a quick question did you ever did we ever change the bottom uh to be black acceptable do you know from last meeting so from last meeting what I understood was that we weren't clear on whether it was a policy or procedure and so before we could move forward we had to decide whether it was a policy or procedure before we changed it got it so I assume Dr Crawford and Dr Davis you guys are still working on that yes got it okay perfect thank you so much much next up is FF nea I said it right today you did okay all right good evening and greetings to our Board of Education Dr Davis a ministrators FFA members and Ferguson Flores community members we have been in
038school for 72 days and today I stand before you to address the pressing concern affecting our students and staff saf and well-being the alarming fights that have taken place in our schools recently there have been verbal threats of violence and physical fights inside of our schools several Ferguson forent School District staff especially our security officers have put themselves at risk and in danger daily to protect students and provide a secure safe and learning environment even more concerning is that these fights have been recorded by students and publicized given the impression that the student expectation code is not being enforced members of the board have asked the question how are the children are the children well well the children are not well and neither are the teachers counselors social workers nurses office professionals custodians Transportation Drivers
039technology Specialists and everyone who supports the students of the Ferguson forest and School District additionally our FFA members having multitude of questions about the Ferguson's floresent board of education budget study and superintendent Dr Davis's internal Staffing audit recently the FFA leadership team invited Chief Financial Officer Dr Singleton to the December building representative meeting during this meeting conversation was held addressing some of their concerns and questions I also have a document of additional questions that our membership is seeking answers to as well board president Dr Kevin Martin extended an invitation to the members of the FFA leadership team to submit fiduciary questions to the board to be addressed during the board of education budget work session on April 24th unfortunately we are still waiting to receive the answers to those questions in summary I encourage each
040of you to acknowledge the essential part we all contribute to in cultivating a safe at atmosphere for our students and staff we must stay United in our efforts to establish educational settings where every individual feels safe and valued I appreciate your attention and commitment to these significant matters thank you so much next up is item number seven consent agenda is there a motion to approve okay so move second it's been moved by Paul Walker second from graes any items we pulled seeing none all those in favor say I I extensions Nays eyes have it next up is item number eight I did ask for this to be pulled just because I'm on that other board so I'll be abstaining St Louis Community College dual enrollment uh Administration recommends that ffsd dual enrollment student tuition books
041at St Louis Community College for the fall 2024 in the amount of $ 52,7 4283 is there motion to approve so moved mooved by Graves second by D any questions all those in favor say I I abstentions me any knows thank you next up is our financial dispersements as you know since we've uh discussed our financial situation financials is no longer on the consent agenda every month we will be having a public presentation about our current financial situation to make sure we are transparent in the process also Dr Singleton will be providing an update about the audit uh and that from today so Dr Singleton right good evening to the Ferguson floron School District uh School Board uh Dr uh Davis and community and colleagues uh tonight I will present the dispersements report uh for
042the month of November all right thank you of course uh we always review the mission and vision of Ferguson floron School District everything we do should align to it uh so the mission of Ferguson floron school district is to provide high quality instruction to every student uh in every neighborhood while PRI prioritizing equity and compassionate relationships our vision of course uh the first and floron school district is for all Learners uh to graduate believing that anything is possible and prepare to realize those possibilities uh in terms of our total approved Staffing this was something that the board asked to be added uh to each of those uh each uh dispersements report um currently we have budgeted 1,344 staff members the actual number uh will certainly be uh adjusted once uh Dr um Dr Davis gets
043done uh with his audit so right now that is still TBD uh to be determined uh and I believe that once Dr Davis completes his audit report uh we will actually know what that number is moving on to the monthly dispersements for the month of November the payroll teacher and non-teacher uh payroll is 14,26 7230 our operational dispersements those are our AP those are our bills uh total about 3,673 46641807 the 30th and so that's one of the few months of the year uh in which three payrolls Falls and so you'll see uh that this payroll compared to the previous uh was a slightly more and again that's attributed to the fact that we had three payrolls in the month of November our total monthly expense total m879 53871 um we'd like to give just
044you know some additional information about the funds as you see me go through the presentation um again our general fund is coded to uh 11 so if you see an 11 uh as the prefix in most of the account numbers uh it falls into the general fund and so again General funds are typically transactions having to do with the operations of the school districts regular programs except those uh accounted for in other funds fund 20 is our special revenue or Teachers Fund uh this account for salary and benefits for certified staff and tuition payments to other districts and private schools uh fund 30 is our debt Services fund we pay any principal and interest payments uh on debt and bond issues from fund3 and fun 40 is our capital projects uh that usually accounts for
045a lot of the work that facilities does uh Acquisitions construction any lease purchase agreements that we might have uh in capital outlay expenses uh so as we look at our uh total revenues by fund um in the general fund you'll see currently through November the 30th uh there is about $1.8 million uh that we've received in revenues uh compared to $73 million that we've budgeted so um uh in fund 20 $18.3 million uh as compared to budget about $ 73.6 million we about about a quarter of the way there uh in debt Services uh $483,000 um as compared to about a $4 million budget so we're running it about 12% there and in fund 40 capital projects 2.9 Million um and we budgeted about 7.8 million about 38% of the way total revenue so far
046uh is 33,6 66,800 of 2425 is 8,731 542 so it looks like we're about 21% of our budgeted revenues that we've received through November the 30th um these are just graphic uh representation showing the same thing so uh the year-to DAT revenues that we've received are in red uh the gray bars represent the original budget and so if you look at what we received compared to to the budget uh those percentages that we looked at on the next p on the previous slide uh gives you some insight as to where we are um and then the blue bar is just the balance it's the difference between the gray and the red uh moving right along we talked about revenues now let's talk about expenditures per fund um the expenses if you look at our general
047fund expenses through November the 30th about $27.2 million uh we budgeted about 68.6 leaving available about 41.3 roughly about 39 almost 40% of expenditures uh in the general fund in fund 20 our special Revenue our Teachers Fund 28.2 million expended so far we budgeted 76.1 we've got about $ 47.9 million re uh available roughly about 37% of the funds have been expended there as well uh uh fund 30 debt Services $652,000 we've spent through November the 30th we budgeted $4.1 million we've got 3.5 available so we're at about 15% of the budget there that's been used uh in fund 40 capital projects uh the expense to date uh through November 30th is5 million our budget is 7.9 million and available $2.8 million putting us at about 63.8% of the funds are the uh expenses that
048have been used in that uh particular fund so far total uh expenses through November the 30th 61,2 51,3 our budget is $16,990 647 available $95 m686 110 puts us at about $39 % of expenses uh actual to budget for uh the fiscal year 2425 uh again this graphic depiction shows uh the same uh same uh concept uh the current expenses are in red the original budget as we read it is in Gray and the difference between the two is the blue what's available uh and what's left to be expended uh moving along to the object description we just described the funds each of the funds but the objects are just as important um and we look at 6100 we're looking at salaries um these are just amounts paid through payroll uh 6200s are all your
049benefits uh they are a BRI product of salaries in most cases but it also includes medical dental vision and retirement under 6300 which is purchase Services uh these are amounts for services rendered by Personnel who are not District employees so these are your outside contractual obligations um and uh 6,400 are supplies uh supplies of material uh to carry out your normal operations uh your 6500s are your Capital outlay these are expenses again most of them are related to the facilities with Acquisitions um expenditures related to land or existing buildings Improvement of grounds construction or equipment uh and then 6600 on the object side refers to long and shortterm debt uh longterm uh is any debt greater than 12 months shortterm is any debt that's repaid within the 12-month period so if we look at salaries
050uh basically salaries are budgeted in two funds uh they are in the general fund and the special Revenue fund uh general fund or your noner certificated individuals so through November the 30th we spit about 12 and half million uh we budgeted 28.6 million we've got about 16 available so we've spent about 43% there in the special Revenue this is just teachers or it's certificated staff $21.6 million through November the 30th 58.2 million in the original budget so we've got about 36.5 million left so roughly about 37% there uh gives us a total on salaries we've spent about 34 .2 million uh through November the 30th 86.9 million in the budget 52.6 million available which puts that us at about 39% of the budget that's been spent so far on salaries bless you benefits uh again
051where you budget salary you tend to budget benefits in those two uh funds general fund and special Revenue uh in the general fund so far in terms of benefit fits $4.4 million budgeted 11.8 available 7.4 we've used about 37% there same thing in fund 20 6.4 million expensed uh 17.1 million budgeted 10.7 available 37% the total benefits $10.8 million uh expensed in both funds through November the 30th $29 million in the budget 18.2 of available for a total of 37% so this tells me that we spent about 37% of the money and benefits uh in this fund uh has been that's has been expensed uh so far uh through November the 30th uh purchase services are 6300 we budget those in three funds general fund special Revenue uh and we've got some small numbers in
052uh in the debt Services column uh um so uh and and I'll just give you those totals so year to date through November the 30 we've spent about $6.3 million in those three funds we budgeted $18.3 million uh and we have available about 16 uh$ 13.6 million so we spent about 35% of that budget uh on purchase service those outside contractual obligations if we look at our supplies most supplies if not all actually are budgeted in the general fund okay okay uh so you've got $4 million expense so far $10.5 million budget 7.6 available 38% of the uh budget has been spent on supplies in this category Capital outlay uh again fund 40 uh this is typically uh facilities uh but this can be any item uh over $1,000 in nature uh that we consider
053a capital purchase so we spent about five uh roughly $5 million $4.9 million uh we budgeted 7.3 we've got available 3.4 so about 67% of this budget has been spent here um as well long and short-term debt uh if we look at it here so far between those three funds our total debt expense is $791,000 we budgeted 4.7 million we have available 3.9 so roughly about 177% uh of the budget uh here for long and short-term debt has been spent uh on this particular page here through November the 30th what I'd like to point out uh is that this looks at our projected fund balance and so if we look at revenues and expenses year to date um and this really is kind of no surprise I think we've been uh you know bringing uh
054bringing the board along and and our our community along uh to kind of where we are uh in in terms of our revenues and expenses um right now um our fund balance is looking uh to the negative at this point about 12% uh the overall fund balance that that looks at the ending Fund in all of the the ending balance in all of the funds is at about a negative uh 4.5% okay uh that is through November the 30th and I will say uh that again November uh if if you can survive through November uh that's typically what most School districts are trying to do at this point uh survive through November uh because we know in December uh that most districts should get a windfall of uh property tax revenues personal and property taxes
055and so we certainly expect the financials next month when we bring them uh to look a little bit better or a lot better uh than where we are okay uh our tax anticipation note update I want to give the board uh we closed on the tax anticipation note uh on October the 29th uh we borrowed $9.5 million it cost us about $50,000 to issue it which left us about $9,450 th000 to draw from uh we did a draw on November 13th of $3 million again that was to help cover the payroll and and accounts payables uh and we did another draw on November the 26th for $2 million uh our total draw to date has been $5 M50 th000 and again the interest rate associated with this draw was 7.35% uh that uh we brought
056to the board as well okay um cash available as of today I wanted to make sure the board was aware that in our UMB bank account we've got about 4, 36,9 and that is this morning's balance in our mocat account $4,840 this is funds that are available to borrow uh um we may not have to tap into the remaining portions hopefully uh but in case uh we do or we need to uh then we've got $4,450 th000 to borrow so we've cash available as of today uh to the school district is about $8 m924 1093 our tax revenues this is a kind of a new slide here I want to bring the board along uh the month of December is when we expect to get a windfall of of tax revenues uh typically uh December
05731st is the deadline for all taxes uh but if you escrow like me and a lot like a lot of you do uh then your pro your mortgage company has probably already paid your per your uh real estate taxes for uh this coming tax season and so uh we did uh on 128 uh we did get a deposit uh of 3,817 , 68026 this was our first deposit from tax revenu so this was our first check from the county that we received um compared to last year it's a lot different okay our first deposit last year was about $1.7 million all right um I personally believe that some of the tax bill mailings could have somewhat of an impact on this I will bring uh you know share the board that we get weekly deposits
058so this is not a one-time deposit uh the first deposits were promised this past Monday uh we do expect another deposit on this coming Monday uh and possibly a couple more deposits uh as we go throughout the month of December uh so we're expecting weekly tax revenue deposits throughout December based on historical dispersements but I did want to let the board know and the superintendent know that we are starting to receive those property tax revenues uh into our school systems uh that concludes the dispersement presentation I do want to give the board at this time an update on the audit as you know as a requirement every year on an annual basis school districts are required to undergo a financial audit um what I want to bring to the board's attention um we only have
059one board meeting planned obviously uh uh December the 11th uh this time last year we would have approved or we would have been approving the audit uh unfortunately there has been some delays on both ends and I want to make sure that the board is aware um that the audit should have been ready in time enough for this meeting but unfortunately there's been some delays and I want to talk about those uh and assure the board and let the board know um that we are expecting the full audit to bring uh before the board uh at a special meeting on December the 18th uh if the board uh will call that special meeting um and so again uh after speaking to the Auditors where are we compared to last year we're probably about 10 days
060behind where we were last year okay um and so uh that's kind of speaking to the Auditors and and them getting the work done that they need uh but there's been a lot of back and forth uh I can tell you uh we were here late yesterday um I spent several hours this morning Mee with some department leaders uh asking questions or answering questions about some of the variances and so there's a lot of back and forth between us and the Auditors in terms of questions that they may have on some variances for instance uh if you spend more money this year than you did last year that's requires an explanation if it's more than 10% um and some of those explanations require some additional time I will tell you in the past we have
061had challenges with reconciling our bank statements in a timely manner okay uh so to be fully transparent uh that has certainly been a challenge in making sure that our bank statements have been reconciled in a timely manner uh as you all aware turnover uh is also a challenge that has that has been uh that has hit our department uh as well okay uh several months ago we had a different CFO who would have been uh whose whose job would have been to make sure that this audit uh was done and push it and so there was some time lapse there also uh we lost our accountant as well uh which is very critical uh to the audit a lot of the entries and things of that nature uh that are being made was certainly uh
062done by the accountant as well so I want to let you let the board know in the community know that turn turnover has certainly um kind of put us in some challeng chenging situations uh and then our conversion uh conversion from one software to another always presents a share of challenges uh but we are uh doing our very best uh to to meet those challenges uh and to move forward uh so I did want to share that update uh again I have talked with the Auditors as early or as late as this morning uh they have assured us that uh contractually uh desie says that the audit needs to be accepted by the board uh no later than December the 31st um we get points on our APR for that as well uh and I
063am very confident uh that uh the audit will be presented to the board in its entirety on the 18th um accepted um and so we will still meet those obligations uh in terms of getting those uh those points as well so uh that is my update on the audit and that also includes the uh concludes the presentation uh on dispersement so there's any questions that I could answer I'd be happy to at this time thank you Madam Secretary can you please read the dispersements and then we'll get a motion for approval then questions yes I can um for payroll teacher and non-teacher we have 14, 26,7 to30 with operational dispers dispersements at 3,673 46641807 expenses of 17,8 79,513 of this year was last year's bills and so we've not received that since the November meeting
064so I'm just curious if you have that number if not if we can have a date when we can get that information by because now just because I think where it helps us understand financially so do you have that today or no no I don't have that I I thought that we had sent that number but I I checked through some sent emails and uh and I I I just I couldn't find it so I I can let you know I think by the end of this week I will try to get that to the superintendent and he can forward it over to the board got it Dr M mcwell you can just make a note by Friday if we can get that with Dr Davis just to help them up thank you uh the
065other thing is I know you talked about the audit and so one of the things I just I talked to Dr Davis about before I just want to confirm before we call a special meeting is that we'll have the full signed audit by the Auditors will sign off on it before we vote on it on the 18th okay so let me in full transparencies what the Auditors have communicated is that the board will receive the full audit signature that the audit will not be signed on the 18th the the the only difference between what will happen on the 18th and what happens a few days after the 18th is the signed piece these audits have to go through a clearing house so there are people there are Auditors that audit the Auditors and so there's
066a that's a final piece of that and so in order for them to sign off that final step has to happen so it's my understanding that on the 18th uh um you know the Auditors will present us a full audit they expect no significant changes uh but I think the final piece of the signatures may not happen on the 18th and that's what was shared with me I just for me as one I know from my understanding from desie we have to have the board has to approve the final signed off audit and so I know we've been in some financial situation so for me as one I know we talk as a board I don't feel comfortable signing approving something that the auditor is not signed off on yet and so I just want
067to work through that and the board can have a discussion but to me we're in financial situation if the otter is not signed off on it and know you said no substantial changes right but any change if our names on it is one of our five like statutory requirements and Des requires us approve the final one with signatures on it I personally don't feel comfortable approving something and then having a different document that we approve sent in to desie I know there a sense of urgency but the 18th is really because the district's closed obviously we're not going to call a meeting on December 25th because many of us won't be around to be able to have a meeting so just as people are thinking of questions please share your thoughts on that as well
068but mine I will not be able to support an audit that's not signed by the Auditors because that's to me what we pay them to do to sign off and say yep we agree everything's right not here it is but things might change and we'll sign off and then that so that's my feeling where are we at in term terms of monthly reconciliation for no are we caught up through November you said one of the things with why the audit is um delayed was not having monthly reconciliations so that was an issue in previous audits for this fisal year are we caught up through November at least or where are we at so we can make sure we know where our cash flow is at and how much we are so so our our monthly
069reconciliations for this year have not we are not caught up through November okay and the reason is because the new system that we're using Skyward has a totally different way of doing the reconciliations and we have not had the training on that so no we have we are not reconciled through November in terms of the uh the bank reconciliation so where we where are we so we've got a training I think there's a training next week uh to get us trained and to to so that we can start getting caught up on those uh those reconciliations so I sorry to be more direct I guess where are we at in terms of Recon like when was the last time they were done this so the reconciliations have been done through the end of June okay
070so the Auditors have right none for this fiscal year so July August September October and November have just not been reconciled uh I guess I'm not going to keep pushing too much but I guess it's just concerning because the new system didn't start till October so July August and September where all the old system which we've been doing and so I think one of the parents at the state of the district came up to I think Dr Thurman and I afterwards and said the number one thing to see about financial as the board member he's an accountant by day don't know his name I don't remember really suggested looking at monthly reconciliations so I guess how do we know what we're receiving here is accurate if we're not even keeping up with our reconciliations in
071terms of payments like how accurate do you think this is if we don't we're not reconciling yeah so I think our financials that we're presenting are are accurate you know I I don't I don't expect any substantial changes if the Auditors tell us to go in and make some adjustments you know we have to consider those but I do I have full confidence in the numbers um I can trace them we can see them where they've coming from we just have not physically gone into the system into this new system uh this this conversion could not have come at a at a worse time and I'm I'm not here to make any excuses you we're going to get the work done we're going to get the uh bank statements reconciled uh but in full transparency
072you asked if that was done through November and at this at this time and day we cannot say that that is that has been done I won't keep pushing I think we'll work with Dr Davis but I think we need a clear timeline moving forward of when we're presenting dispersements I was under the assumption that we are proving reconciled dispersements that we know what we are proving and if we're not I just want to be clear to the board that we're not they're not reconciled they are reconciled so we know this actual amount is 100% down to the penny if we're presenting to the penny so that's just my own personal thoughts that um the system not comeing in place to October July August September certainly I know you were not here for all those
073months to me there's no reason they're not done so if Dr Davis can work with getting us a timeline when we can get caught up and then to me moving forward dispersements need to align with M monthly reconciliations need to be done in order to send us reconcil send us to dispersements other was Dum bring them to the ready in my opinion the last one is it said um why do we borrow why do we draw $ million from the tan if we had eight point if we have $4.3 million in the bank so why do we borrow two more million if we have 4.3 million um help me help me understand where you got those numbers from so on uh uh 1126 24 it says we drew $2 million right and then if you
074look at cash available it says we have 4 million 100,000 in mochet and 44.4 million in tan okay so that's it says we have cash available as of today 8.9 million so yeah so right but I mean if you take that 2 million out that's still 6.9 million yeah so it's the timing uh Dr Martin uh we drew the $2 million on November 26th uhuh okay so that was to meet again we had three payrolls in the month of November that last $2 million was drawn on November 26 so that we could meet our payroll obligations and accounts payables through the end of November okay what you're saying is a what what you're showing available is what's in the bank right now so those those are two different we we're talking about more than almost
07515 days apart but I understand but if you take out that 4 million we have 8.9 on hand is what this is saying which means if you take that 4 million away we still have over $4 million available even if you take the 3 million away from the last cash advance wasn't that Dr Graves you said 3 million or something was the tax amount we got on the eth or something we're still at some a million some dollars in the bank I'm just conf if we're sitting at 8.9 million currently on the bank according to this slide right here why do we borrow two more million yeah so I I'm I'm maybe I'm not explaining it right or maybe I'm not understanding the question we borrowed two so our cash position as of November 26
076um in order to meet that November the 30th payroll we would not have met payroll if we didn't draw that $2 million so let's let's look at let's look at just November's activities all right so through the end of November we needed the additional $2 million to meet payroll and again I don't have those numbers in front of me uh but we needed the additional $2 million to meet payroll as of the end of November that's why that $2 million was drawn but why is it I guess when you go to cash available it's showing we still have it in the bank at 8.9 million yeah but that's only because Dr Dave uh I'm sorry Dr Martin that's only because we got 8.9 million okay let's take the tan out all right that's the tax
077anticipation no that's $4.4 million that is available to draw from all right we don't want to include that in our cash balance that's loan monies that that's still left on the tan so I guess why my question is why is it there why is it here I guess you're just saying cuz we can draw on it okay got yeah it's it's there and got that says we'll only borrow what's needed yes sir got it now that makes sense more thank you sorry about that no worries I was like I don't get how we're getting 8.9 million if we have no all this money left or right where's the energy going we'll go over here Dr Grace I'm good we'll go to Mr Bailey then this way no I I think you kind of covered the
078point CU I was trying to do the math and it wasn't adding but now it makes sense and I do have to agree with Dr Martin I don't feel comfortable signing until we get a hard stance because I mean they're the experts um so we need to make sure that we're very transparent with that and we get a hard stands on where we with uh because they are the experts and that's why we hire external audits to come in to make sure that we are financially um in a financially healthy can I just ask a quick question though yes um and I wonder I don't know the answer to this question I would want to know um when the audit was approved last year um what was the process because what I heard you say
079because I know we did some emails and talking about it some was that the auditor sign off after the board and Dr Martin mentioned that desie says that the board can only approve what's the final so I'm unclear about process because it sounds like a process issue in my head more than anything else cuz for me I want it accurate and I also don't want to lose those two points in I APR because that that's important sure so all that's important and I want to make sure I say that out loud but I want accuracy of course so I just wonder about last year's process sure or previous is for that matter whomever the auditor was um and what came to the board and where that signature page cuz sometimes when we have these kinds
080of things done we actually have folks who are here and they actually do signing that evening so I just wonder about that so I just wanted to put that out there sure oh sorry I just went to the board docs from December 13th there's four documents one's the sign letter to governance the final signed financial statement audit the presentation and then the receipt so there's 11 page letter document that was signed by the Auditors as well as the signed audit itself on December 13th last year does that sir are you good yeah uh Mr Bailey were you done Mr Tyson I guess I just want to know what if they could present the audit why can't the audit on the 18th be signed by them is process yeah if we got 10 days or eight
081days left eight days yeah so I will I will make that uh assertion to the Auditors to to that it's important that uh that if we're going to present the audit on the 18th uh that this be the final draft um that it be signed uh I will make that declaration again in my communication back and forth with the Auditors um you know there's there's still a process that has to happen once the board approves um and so I if I I will see why can't they stick with last year's process if they brought us the audit uh signed on the uh on the 13th of December as he said so I will reiterate that okay any other questions Miss D um thank you for your presentation uh I have one request so similar to
082the tax revenue slide maybe the second to last slide that you showed I was wondering if it would be possible for us to get updates on those deposits that we get those weekly updates with a comparison to last year because that does seem concerning when we're talking about where we're at financially and we've identified this really as a cash flow problem and we're really from my understanding relying on this income that we should be expecting so if we can just have updates on what those deposits are looking like as it's coming in weekly um if everyone is okay with that request um I would like I would like to see that absolutely um I have first a comment and then a question and I want to make the comment because I was having sidebar conversation
083up here um and so I just want to be clear as to what that side our conversation was um I noticed just a couple of the the percentage used all looked great but just a couple of quick little like calculation um like subtracting of funds and the numbers that were on there my uh my mathematical practices were my Spidey senses were tingling the numbers didn't quite make sense for me on the differences there so there were just a couple of things to maybe make sure that all those numbers are being changed um in those presentations as we're bringing presentations up to the board percentages look good we double check that had my second math mind up here helping double check those percentages there um but because of that sidebar I missed when we were talking
084about the projected fund balance which brings me to my question and you probably talked about this um but why are we now seeing those projections as negative percentages instead of positive percentages because that to me looks like a huge difference that's a 24% decrease for the operating fund balance and a 20 I can't read 25% decrease is what it looks like to me just on the numbers compared comparing to our last month's presentation so if you can talk on that a little bit sure so one of the reasons that we're seeing negative numbers now is because our expenses where we are expending this year okay uh versus where um where our Revenue collections are and so um I think we shared that um that we are certainly that's why we had to borrow okay because
085uh our financial situation we were having some cash flow challenges and so um that is one of the reasons that we're seeing um a negative number uh and again as I stress to the board um this is November okay uh this is kind of the the the bleeding here uh for most districts uh if districts can survive through November uh typically in order to get through November you get through November uh by having a healthy fund balance as of July 1st and so we know that you know our fund balance was not what we originally thought it was and so when we were subsequent roughly 7.8 almost $8 million difference that is accounting for some of the negative numbers that you're seeing in terms of our fund balance but we are spending more money than
086we're bringing in that's the reason okay thank you that's helpful so I guess my follow-up question would be so if we are continuing to get these types of reports um as we go through this time in our financials as a district are what what should we expect that fund balance to look like like if I were to put where the fund balances at each month should I be should we be expecting to see it moving because of how expenses and the revenue collections are going is there a certain place it should be at this time of year like if we were to compare this year's to next year's when we're at this time next year like what what does that look like I just hav't we've never looked at it like this before so I'm
087having a hard time kind of wrapping my mind around it sure and if I remember correctly I think Dr Graves had asked kind of a similar question uh about a month ago or two months ago okay um um this is unfortunately this is the time of year uh that we're seeing those negative numbers um as you recall um districts have to live off of what you ended the year with in terms of revenues we get money in every month we get right right we get General state aid in every month we get Transportation dollars in every month that money in no way equals or or should cover or covers all of our expenses that are going out the door okay um and so you know July should be somewhat healthy okay but you start to
088see a decline in those numbers th during those summer months and when school starts all right remember when we start back school in August we've got heavy payrolls new raises go into effect new employees you're hoping you're fully staffed you know over the summertime you got a lot of construction projects because kids are in schools we spend a lot of money during those summer months and so unfortunately fund balance during those times of the year are going to show a little bit lower uh than they normally would when we should see a rise in our fund balance is around th this time of year December January February those are times I can assure you probably next month next time I'll stand up here and give the report um that we will see some significant changes
089uh in a lot of those numbers okay um that's why it's it's and I'm going to say this with full transparency that's why uh Financial uh departments they don't give boards fund balances every month okay cuz one month it looks like you are doing well and then the next month it looks like you're it's Doom and Gloom and so you know what we really look at is the entirety the totality of it um and hopefully by the end of the school school year we have a healthy fund balance and that whatever healthy you know the board defines healthy but but to answer your question generally December January February those are months where we should see our fund balance really pick up uh and and show to the positive so then just for my understanding to
090sum up what you're saying this is typical maybe not this typical but this is typical I think this is typical I think kind of the situation where we are uh is probably not as typical as we wanted it to be because we thought we would probably be somewhere else this time of year but this is very typical but this movement with the fund balance because we are always so focused on whatever that percentage is and in our mind that's the percentage that we see but this type of movement is what's typical within the fund this type of movement is very typical for this time of year perfect thank you Miss phips Dr Thurman I don't know if you're still on or not but if you have questions speak from the scen above you're muted hold
091on one second or your volume's off one of the two I'm not muted on H now you're good to go thank you okay I'm getting feedback I just want to say thank you to Dr Singleton for the report and I have a question that may sound really is um a simple question um are you saying to us that the reason that the report is not being is not ready is because of the new software because you're using the new software and getting used to it no uh no uh Dr Thurman uh thank you for the question so uh no in in no way am I uh uh attributing the audit report uh to the software in fact the audit report is as of June 30th of 2024 okay um and so uh what I'm sharing
092with the board is that uh we've had challenges in the past of reconciling those bank statements which is a part of the audit okay um the timing timely reconciliations but the new software we're hopeful that this new software and that's one of the reasons that people change softwares is because they find something that talks to the asbr they find something that talks to bank reconciliations and I spoke with a CFO who uses this particular software Skyward and he has assured me that this has been a lifesaver for his district in Troy Missouri okay um and so I believe the software will help us uh but we have had some challenges converting over to the software W that was that was my comment okay then this leads into my next question the Auditors that we have
093they do know that there's a deadline that Desy has given us and it will impact us negatively if we don't get the audit done is that correct absolutely yes and I can assure you that the Auditors have assured me that will meet this deadline we there okay so we'll meet the deadline but but my question is you're saying you're wanting us to sign off before it is actually done because I'm I'm not going to do it I I'm one board member but I will not sign sign off on an audit and we will lose our our points if we don't sign off on the on the audit before the deadline yeah so I I and again maybe maybe explanation isn't clear um what what I'm saying at this point um is that the audit will
094be present it to the board in its entirety on December the 18th that's the deadline we've given the Auditors okay um just like any other audit report uh the Auditors will be here to present the report they will answer any questions that we may have and that will be our final audited report there are some external things that happen as a result of the audit that may take a couple of days after the audit is approved by our board in order to generate final signatures that's the only thing that we're going to be missing on the 18th but again let me be clear I heard the direcor from the board the board wanted sign financials and so that is what I'm going to ask the Auditors to see if they can deliver signed financials uh
095to us on the 18 I will be in communication so there is an issue and you don't you don't know for sure you're going to ask them and let them know that the board wants that so right now as you stand here tonight you don't know for sure it if they will be able to accommodate that request yes uh I think you're you're speaking correctly as as of tonight a signed audit uh uh a signed final audit report um was not uh the understanding uh that I got and I think that I shared that information with our superintendent uh and the and I I'm not sure if it was forwarded on to the board I think the question came what's the difference uh between the audit draft and the final version uh and I think
096that the uh the the the explanation came with something about uh a signature so um to answer your question Dr Thurman um I'm not sure that uh that that directive as of my conversation with the board uh I'm sorry with the audit firm uh as early as to uh as late as this this morning um we we will we will now go with a different directive uh and I know that that directive is sign financials so that's that's where we are okay I'm I'm concerned yes ma'am um because I I would really the report was supposed to be done tonight actually is that correct uh yes yes we have one board meeting in December yes and and you ask for an extension to the 18th yes ma'am and now you're saying the 18th it probably
097still won't be totally ready I just want I want the community to understand what's going on so that's why I'm asking these questions so that I you know um that we're being transparent and we are letting Community know and not just the community but our our District employees know what's going on with the budget um yes ma'am yes ma'am so I okay yes ma'am and and part of the reasons I know you made a comment about most people don't have a report every board meeting we're different this is our this is Ferguson Flor and it's needed now because as a board member and I'm speaking as an individual board member member I want to know now because we have had this problem or this concern with with our cash flow I want to know and
098so until further notice I'm going to be requesting that that we have it every month okay and then the other thing that I want to know because this seems to be a difficult question to answer do we know now what our staffing is so EV not because it says you don't have it because it's to be determined yes so I will let Dr Davis share uh the the update on that I think Dr Davis has also given an update tonight uh and I believe that that answer to that question will probably come out in that update uh but Dr Thurman let me be clear and I want to make sure that that I'm I'm I'm very clear with with the statement that I made about uh the fund balance okay um there are times where
099the fund balance looks scary okay I believe in full transparency okay I'm not I'm not the CFO that's going to that's trying to hide every anything okay um you know I believe in being fully transparent um so there are months where the fund balance is going to look negative you saw a negative fund balance today all right right you may not see a negative fund balance next month in January you may see a very respectable fund balance in February you may see that okay but in March April and May you're going to see that number start to go down and so my comment simply was to the to to the to the tune that you know it's not something that boards or that Financial departments report every month but if that is the desire of
100our board and I know that we're all about transparency then we're going to give you that and we're going to put that number on that report every month I absolutely have no problem with that thank you so much appreciate you yes Mr Tyson well I did have one question but now has turned into four um so real quick total transparency since I've been here in four years we've not had this issue so there is no history of this you all okay let's make that clear can you can you tell me what this issue is when you say this this negative fund balance we have to borrow money this is the first time this has come up since I've been here okay so this is obviously not a pattern that something happened right we think we
101know what happened that caused us to be here so this is why we're having to do these things and through this we're learning some new things that we said hey well let's try this let's try that so I just want to throw that out there Ferguson florisa doesn't have a history of being in this C cash flow problem let's throw that out there okay now you stated that the audit is as of June right yes okay then you stated that our reconciliations are as of June but not as of today because of the new software so then my question is so the reconciliations are not affecting our audit because if the audit is as good is June and our reconciliations are as to then that software issue that we talked about and spent a lot
102of time on is really not an issue of why the audit is being delayed so the software uh the reconciliation of the June 30th financials was a challenge when the Auditors first started okay yeah so typically the end of June by the end of July you should have June's financials reconciled that did not happen right so yeah that's what I'm saying it's it's done now but that was one of the causes of the delays in the audit from the beginning because that's that's what I really needed to know why are we having this delay sure and if you're telling me that we needed to get all the way to November and you're not having this training till next year for this audit to be to be done but we really don't need the bank reconciliation
103to the end of this year or now for the audit to be done we just needed to the end of June Mr Tyson really quick just there is a pattern of monthly reconciliations not getting done on time but yeah but I think part of it gets confused because we miss dispersements with audit and maybe we should have separated the topics out so sorry just keep yeah I would just I just speaking more so on the audit because we have a deadline and things like that okay the next question um and this may not be something you can answer but I would just love to hear if you do have an answer do you have any projections on where are our fund balance may be don't give me that look okay I just was curious I
104was just curious because you know finish your finish your question because I think you've already answered it you answered it with your look uh I didn't think you would but I was like because you don't know what's going to come in you don't we don't know these things we could project from last year but you just showed us already that 11 million came in at this time last year and 3 million came in now so I I get it but I was just curious to know if you had any projections of where our year in Balance fund balance would be um in June to car us over next year or would we be yeah all right will we be in the same the same situation next year so so let yeah let me say this
105I I I do not I do I do not I do not want to guess fund balance fund balance depends on so many things happening in the school year understand fund balance depends on Dr Davis's audit and and his report to the board fund balance depends on if we're fully staffed or if there are vacancies uh fund balance depends on you know you know barring any major emergencies and and so many other things and so so no I I I you will not get me on that one well I didn't think so but it would just be nice to to know CU I guess in my head I'm like we're borrowing money to get through this year we have an expectation of what's coming well based upon the budget we said what we think would
106be coming in but we're already off on that so I'm just curious to know how far away will we be at the end of the year but I guess we won't know that till we get there but yeah that's all yes sir thank you y four questions perfect uh Miss Phillips I just had a question about like the whole labeling it as a cash flow issue so I understand that like we might be budgeting for more than we have coming in is that correct we're spending more than we're bringing in yes so are we bringing in less than we have historically like in past years as a district or is it are we budgeting for things that we hadn't before as a district and that's why the disconnect is happening sure now you answered you
107asked some amazing questions so let me just stop and just say thank you for thinking like this I hope you go be a CFO all right um but let me let me just try to to you know to to tackle what you're asking in terms of you know historically and and you know how all this thing you know uh just came about um I I I think at the end of the year um it's going to look a lot different than what we projected mhm the approved budget by the board that was approved in April of this past year um included a number of things that we already know are not going to happen Okay um it you know our investments for instance I give you guys the information on mocat all right um we
108typically had about $2 million in that fund and we were earning interest that's money that we didn't have have to touch we've drawn down all of our investments and so that that interest that we thought we were going to get that's in the budget is not going to happen okay our expenses may be out of whack again I we're we're going through a a human resources audit people okay and we're trying to figure out where these people are okay um that's going to tell us probably that we've got you know we've got more people than than we expected okay um so it's a number of things that's going to uh play a factor in where we end this year all right um I I'm I'm hopeful I'm optimistic but I'm also realistic and I can
109tell you that I that's not something that I want to guess on that's something that you know we'll bring to the board every month and we'll keep we'll keep you all you know uh up to date Mr Bailey and I know you can't answer that question today but that's the part that as much as I look at the budget that's the part that I'm just so confused upon is the Staffing piece you can't set a budget without having to make sure that the proper staff are in place because your budget 90% of your budget is Staffing and and benefits so I know a lot of positions that we've had in the past like you know you look on our website and again I'm not singling you out or anything like that but you look at
110our website you see vac VES vacancies vacancies but then we're saying that those vacancies aren't really vacancies because we don't really know where the people are at so that's what the confusing part I think to me and I know that I'm if I'm confused on that the community has to be confused on that if school districts are saying that we have all these vacancies but then we're saying that you know we don't know where the people are at that's kind of an issue like like that to me like that is the biggest issue is knowing where we are at with the people knowing how to set the budget but how do you account for all of those vacancies that we have and those positions that we've repurposed and different things like that and I know
111that you know that's not the answer but you don't have the answer off the top of your head is what I'm trying to articulate but that's the part that's confusing to me with all of this just being completely transparent I'm 1 to seven but that is what's confusing for me and I know Dr Davis is going to speak in a second and give an update on that next the I do want to go back to Mr Tyson's question because um already I know we're have a lot going on right now you're new to your position in this District we have negotiations getting started we have taxes coming in we have other things when do you project we would have an adjusted budget based on this year's final Staffing audit this year's you just led to
112an example of for example of um we're not going to have the $1.2 million that we get budgeted to get interest there's no way when you have $100,000 in the bank you're going to get 1.2 million out of that right math doesn't work that way so that's one factor obviously hoping this trend turns around with taxes coming in that it's not as low as it's been historically when do you think the board will get an adjusted budget because by policy and negotiations we have to have Financial presentations for next year I believe in febru April April one by April 1 which really means at the Mar no later than the March meeting which in order to get to next year's budget we have to adjust this year's budget because you're going to have to get
113to at end of the day what's the magical fund balance number you have so that you can start building do you think that will be in the January meeting the February meeting not trying to get a date like are just to kind of help us because there are the audit step one obviously getting tax revenue will be step two kind of see where we get the interest one you already know you could probably predict what that's going to be not very much uh but obviously I'm just curious when you think we can get that because that March you're going to have to present already the financial presentation for the next year sure um you know if I had to just throw a while guest Dr Martin I think that well we're obviously we don't have
114it now it's December's gone uh January may be too soon uh again we've got to get through uh the the audit piece we've got to make sure that those revenues are coming in like we anticipated at the earliest February okay uh but I would say between February and the March meeting that we could present an adjusted budget for this current fiscal year just so we're looking at Kar there's only one meeting in March because of spring break so I just want to make sure if we're doing adjusted budget approving that and approving Financial forecast for the future it's challenging to do just I know there's a lot going on so certainly just want to put that on our Radars March will be here before you know it we'll be a graduation right after that and
115we'll be celebrating uh leani she's staying around another year so she's going to do a fiveyear lap uh for it is that what they call it or is that just College when you do a 5-year lap in college okay any other questions from the board otherwise Dr Davis has a followup uh I just wait to the okay perfect any other questions just want to wrap up kind of the board what I heard I'm going send to Dr Davis an email just to make sure we're all on the same page if there's anything I'm missing please let me know we're going to have by Friday by this week how much was paid from this year's budget of last year's budget stuff uh moving forward just providing a monthly 2023 comparison of tax deposits in our weekly
116update compared to this year's tax deposits uh moving forward so we can kind of have a better idea of that a final signed audit by the 18th for approval similar to December 13th 2023 in order to have that special meeting um and then just time a timeline of the mon monthly reconciliations for July August September October November completion and then just moving forward that the reconciliations for that month are completed prior to dispersements getting approved by the board and did I miss anything from the board okay seeing none the disperson mount was read I won't have Miss D read it again at 17 million something all those oh you oh all those in favor say I I I extensions Nays eyes have it thank you so much thank you next up is Dr Davis with
117the internal audit update Dr Davis this is for board information no action I get more than three minutes right so just a couple of things um I want to bring up based on the last conversation we just had right um and I want to be careful of how I say this to my board um there have been a lot of moving Parts change over of leadership and the finance office and you know actually a couple folks have left new software a lot of things have happened okay what I worry about is everything um but I also worry about those two points and I a Okay so we've got to stay focused there and it may mean I know the 18th and Dr singon and I have talked he you know he he's kind of stepped
118into a hornets nest U so I want to be you know thoughtful about the effort he puts into it um and also everybody who's working hard to try to get all these things done and you know I I want to make sure it may mean that we have have to ask the board to do a zoom meeting at some point on Christmas Eve um I'm joking there hopefully not but I just want to make sure that we don't lose those points because we are working with an outside agency we've had this issue in the past with the auditing we we've gone to a new firm if you remember a couple years ago because of some of the concerns that were raised then and so I just want to put that out there because I don't
119want us to lose those two points because all of those points matter uh when it comes to our accreditation our district we make some good gains this year we're in a full accreditation stat St us um at 73% grew 3.6 percentage points um the three year averages of 71.3 so you know just keep that in mind as we're talking about all these particulars because I want to you know keep the main thing the main thing um I'm going to hold Dr Singleton and everybody on my cabinet accountable like you hold me accountable but I do need your support um as we move in these next couple of weeks to try to get this done and and I just I just wanted to say that out loud um you know the one word I heard was
120typical and this is not typical in Ferg floor so I want to be really clear about that I've been here 10 years we've never had to borrow a dime and I think I so Dr Thurman you asked uh last time when I had would have the audit ready I got with Dr Martin he and I talk almost daily uh always you know the board president superintendent always in Lock Stock and Barrel um I shared with him about a week ago so maybe that I wouldn't so I'm not done on December 11 like I thought I was going to be okay and I'm going to tell you why um I do feel strongly that I'll be done by the 18th we've done Charlie and I have done the line share of the schools um I'm going
121to show you that in just a moment I'm GNA also show you where I think some of the problem is that's Jamal's question Mr Bailey's question is I'm confused about what are these issues L raise some good questions as well are we budgeting more than we need to money coming in money going out and we can't spend $101 if we have $100 you got to stay in your budget and what I can tell you based on what I've done so far and I sat with every one of these schools um we have 17 schools we've done and one Department uh I've done vashon's department so everybody who I'm if I've done their school I've sat with that principal if I've done your department and I've only done her so far it took us a half
122a day just to do Safety and Security and that's not even the biggest department the biggest department is terries and so that's going to probably take a day and a half because I have because we have to go through every employee everybody who gets a paycheck whether they're full-time part-time what have you we've gone through every employee PR some of the principles are here and they sat with me and Charlie and we've gone through those budgets definitively in terms of what the board approved and who we actually have anybody who gets a paycheck I want to know who they are where they are which is why I have to have principles in there because they know their school teams better than anybody else does right and so I'll share that with you in just a
123moment but this isn't typical we haven't had to borrow money in the past and Leilani your question was about you know are we budgeting right on June 30th the end of the fiscal year which is the audit being done for last fiscal year due by this December have we done all those things the right way okay so that's why some of that reconciliation ation stuff that it goes to June 30th but you know the reconciliations for now will be in next audit okay but what we have to do is a better job with our internal controls and so I'm going to say publicly that um the the audit the internal audit isn't finished um I hope you ask some questions I hope I can answer those questions um I know what we're doing because we've
124sat I sat with principles first um back in November and I I sat with them uh I had finance and Ryan deem and uh technology to give every school um and every Department their budgets so the board approved 1344 positions that's your denominator let me add that I'm a math teacher so just be clear that numbers are my are my thing when you specifically look at what the board approved and what we're spending there's some misalignment you talk about vacancies if we've hired more people than we budgeted for we don't have any vacancies you can't it's just numerically impossible right so um and we haven't had to borrow any money because we've stayed inside of our budget with HR and finance communicating these are the people that you have in your budget here the it's
125really about when you do the budget it's not even about people it's about positions so if you have X numbers of positions you got to hire within those positions okay so um I want to say that we haven't had to do had to do a tax anticipation note because we've in the past done the work a little different we're going to get back to that but after I'm done with this audit internally uh we're going to have to tighten our belts like a a lot um so that we end the fiscal year in a better way and Dr Singleton can't make any projections about what it's going to look like because I can't either because we don't know uh we haven't finished the internal part of it yet and that's just salaries that's not benefits
126is a dependent variable you have more people you have more benefits you have less people you going have less benefits obviously right um but we also have um purchase services and supplies that we that I have to go through that's going to be different than what this internal part of it is now so um that's that um if you could pull up the presentation here and again Dr Thurman I want to make sure you know this that I said it was going to be done the 11th I'm not done we're almost there um I've done 17 schools actually 18 we did steam high today with Dr Tan and and Ryan hadn't he didn't include that in here I don't believe um but we've done 17 I've done all the elementary schools sat with those principles
127uh done all the middle schools uh I did restoration as well um and and started on Steam I had to do McLure um McLure North and and Innovation and and those are going to take me at least another day and a half okay and then I'll get all the Departments done um if you could go to the next slide and just um uh this will be brief but I think it'll be an overview of of where we are um we have seven primary schools total I've done all those um six intermediate schools which are the three five schools I've done all those sat with every one of those principles um and gone through their budgets definitively um sat with all the middle schools um and he do have restoration up here but we've done them
128as well and then I did Safety and Security so those are the Departments I've done uh we have 23 schools all together um so restoration and steam should also be up there we have about um like I said three or four more to go but we'll be done with those this week uh next slide now what you see up here um so the budgeted number is important okay of the schools and departments I've done so far remember the number I gave you was 1344 okay when I'm done that budgeted positions is going to be 1344 okay that won't change that's going to be a constant okay so far I've done 602 of those 1344 okay of the folks I've done we were supposed to hire 602 but we've hired 731 now there's some there's an
129explanation there though okay so as I look at the budget I use vashon's department for an example okay so these numbers aren't necessarily they're not done um I've taken all of the Safety and Security Department out of the schools okay and I've put them in veron's department so initially her budget only had about $535,000 in it about maybe eight or nine people okay it makes more sense to have all of Safety secur and Security in their department and then she can move them wherever she needs to as needed that way we have a clean budget okay we're going to do the same thing for custodians and and in every other position cafeteria some schools have cafeteria workers or employees in it and some don't and it gets messy when you have all those pieces so
130we're going to put everybody in their department and then they have the autonomy to move them as they need to but I'll be able to say to the board that this is how much much money You' invested in Safety and Security for example um all of our cafeteria uh and Food Service workers and that's that's reimbursable we still have to pay it though and we get uh you know uh the large portion of that money back that 602 will be 1344 just looking at where we're are right now we're over but I think that'll it won't be as bad as it looks right now because when you look at our budget and we had this conversation back in April upstairs um you know it's about $86 million that's for salaries okay this doesn't include coaching
131um this doesn't include some of the stiens that are given out that's in a whole different budget we have about 8 million on uh in a budget for um those kinds of things but this is just the base salaries and any other supplements or addenda that goes to those salaries an example of an addenda would be if a teacher went back um and got a stem certification or an elementary math specialist certification um then they get that license it goes through HR and then that's added to their base salary so I've included all things in this audit okay but just looking at what we've done so far um we're over in terms of the actual so there are two columns in any budget money coming in oh I'm sorry um budgeted and then that what
132we actually spend now what I what I'm hoping as I look at these numbers while it looks a little off right now I think it'll be a little bit more in line but we're going to still be over in terms of numbers I believe and again I may I I I I stand to be corrected if I am that's great but I still believe we're going to be well over the 1344 that the board approved in our budget um and and we can't be there so to your question Mr Bailey how many vacancies we have we should have any vacancies right now because we're one auditing um but we will be able to say especially going forward and principles in particular um when we sit with them and talk about their budgets they know their
133budgets better than they ever have I can tell you that um in terms of what what folks make um and how many positions they have so then they know how many vacancies they truly have uh principles have been asking some really great questions because when a teacher retires at $90,000 salary um and we budgeted that money for the school and that hire another teacher who comes in making way less then that adjusts your budget without adjusting the numbers of positions now you'll go spending that money because you could hire a teacher in another role and their salary comes in demanding a higher salary so it kind of averages out sometimes but you ought to be clear about how much money you have going in so that you can stay within that budget okay when we
134get ready for the 25 26 budget all of my principles and Department folks will be really clear about what positions they have what positions they have not people what positions they have and then the people filling those positions so that way when I give them so every year this is what we've done because I've been a part of the meetings for at least the first years of my time here um I sit down with uh HR and finance um everybody's in the same room uh we look at enrollment that's what drives teachers in terms of the numbers of teachers that you appropriate to a school Desi has class sizes it's in the M M 6 document so if you're a K2 school or actually K5 School a 68 School 912 there's some class siiz um
135parameters that we have to stay within so um what will make sure happens this year going forward is that as I sit down as we have in the past finance will be there HR be there we'll look at the projected enrollments and this is at our K8 schools different than high schools high schools are different okay and I'll tell you about what that means and and having been a principal at every one of the levels High School is what I enjoy most because it's so big and so many moving Parts um if I have say for example 300 teachers okay well if I have 300 teachers and class size is 25 then do the math real quick how many 25s on 100 how many 25s they're four they're 425s and 100 right they're four quarters
136and a dollar if you have $3 then how many quarters would you have do you have 12 so if you have 300 students you went ahead too fast if you have so my point is if you have 300 students and the class size is 25 for example I can't give you more than 12 teachers so you have so you have 12 positions and now you have teachers who are already employed you got to put those teachers because they already have contracts in those positions and then you know what positions you have available and then you can go start the hiring process everybody's on the same page we have to budget from the previous year so that we already appropriate certain dollars for that school okay based on the teacher salaries from last year that's a
137good measure right cuz if you have some vacancies you're going to probably have some people who come in that don't make the same salaries it's probably rare you have somebody making the exact same salaries right but you still have that budget and so so what we've been doing I've been doing this meeting with principles so that they are clear about what their budgets are and then the people and positions they have and the people in those positions okay so right now where I am is that we're over 129 okay but remember I said we've moved Safety and Security out of the schools and put them in rashan's Department okay we'll do that for every department so next week Dr Thurman when I come I I will be finished um and we Ryan has not only
138does he have um you know it broken apart by schooling department but he also has a huge uh big database with all 1344 and what we make sure we do I'm not going to put all the budget stuff that they have because that's people's names on it but the big macro or or the big macro document um it uh we want to make sure we don't duplicate right because it's easy if a person's at one school and then they may be an itinerate teacher and go to another school you want to make sure you only count their salary one time okay and that's where some of that tricky stuff comes in which is why you got to have all these moving pieces right um so that's kind of where we are there go to the
139next slide for me so what I've asked him to do with the numbers that you just saw was break it apart by um the types of positions we have administrated three kinds of employees in here right I mean well I always say two teachers and those who support teachers but for the purpose of the budget you have administrators you have certified and you have non-certified okay because I I believe the board would want to know okay so if we're over where are we over in what position categories right um I think we'll be in line with the administrators we we we've always been pretty tight there okay but I can tell you that you know when I look at some of the positions we're going to have to really tighten our bels going get to
140next year y'all um certified teachers for example we have 417 that we budgeted for what I've done so far with the 17 schools I looked at is we've actually hired 447 okay so that's 30 over in just teachers um in non-certified which is all the other employees and that could be a person who's an administrator or a person who um is uh uh it could be a bus driver it could be um a classified employee just a a number of of different categories of employees uh so for the ones I've looked at so far um it's 104 now again Terry's department is biggest because he has Transportation he has maintenance he has operations we have 100 custodians or positions anyway so we have a lot of people that we haven't gotten to yet um but
141even there the place we're over the most is a non-certified so so we're right siiz some of that when we we look at the budget or at least have an accurate number can't say right side but an accurate number there um and then uh grand total is 554 678 okay um and then we just have some numbers over there that goes with the salaries of the people that we've looked at okay go to the next slide this is a little more definitive the next one here because we gone at it by school um and these are all the schools that we've completed um you'll see there at safety security which is third from the bottom it says eight but we've moved again all those people back to that department okay so I'll be able to
142share with you the positions that were budgeted the actual positions by school and then the actual salaries um and then what the difference is so we have budgeted positions we have actual and then you see on that very right side the schools that were um you know we we have more people than we budgeted for uh there are few that we have less fewer than that very few uh the green shows that we're under budget in those places but the pink shows that we're over okay um and there's some places that are way over but again we'll be able to right siiz that when I'm completely done okay I think that's the last slide isn't um and I'll stop there I could go on because there's a lot of details but I but I'll have
143the full um audit internal audit for the board on the 18th and then that'll be complete numbers with the 1344 how many people we actually have what category they in they're in how much money you've budgeted for how much we've actually spent where are we over and then what steps to take as we move for the rest of this year so as we prepare for 25 26 um then we have more accurate data um I'm putting some internal pieces in place so the HR and finance will always be talking so that we don't get it to this place ever again okay so any questions um again this is just an update it's not done it will be done next week U thank you for additional time so we get it done right and accurate well
144thank you Dr Davis I just want to say um certainly as you alluded to you and I have been working hand inand in this this piece we did notify the board once you let me know that you need additional time in so I just want to say I really appreciate you taking on the board's had conversations with you throughout different evaluation pieces and that that we know this is taking time away from the other duties that you have to do and so I can't do anything else right now we and we appreciate you diving in and know that is a lot of work and everyone involved in this and that but we know it's important work that we have to get a handle on how we're spending our salaries just for the rest of the
145board to know generally speaking somewhere in the 20% range is generally what you add on to salaries for benefits which includes taxes retirement insurance and all that so if it's a million you're really talking about 1.3 million give or take a little bit when you're thinking about these number pieces so just want to appreciate all the work that you've done in this really diving in deep and you know it is taking away from other work but we also need to know in order to build a solid budget we need to be able to move forward because also then we need to be able to prioritize where do we want positions do we need put new move positions and I also want to be clear that we are not saying that we might not have to
146eliminate some positions and so I know the board's been clear with you of when we know that we want to notify people early on that positions may be eliminated uh but you don't know that yet want to speak but I want to be clear from a transparency standpoint no one is saying we're going to not have to right siiz some positions based on where we're at and so um I certainly appreciate all the work you've done in this certainly uh when we think about that last April and budget stuff there's a lot of contentious moments and I I appreciate where we're at today to really dive in deep one question I just have really quick and then we'll ask the rest is I kind of like how you explained um Safety and Security made a
147lot of sense moving into that department C one of the things I think for me that would be helpful is if we had like a District administration line and a building Administration line because if we're putting principles in certified it just seems that that we have more certified teachers or counselors or Librarians and so if we could just separate potentially just building Administration and District administrators that way they're not lumped in with kind of like the what most people when they see certified at least when I see certified I think teacher librarian counselor I don't necessarily think school principal because when I see Administration I think personally so that's we'll start with Dr Paul Walker and go down this way any questions or comments okay thank you Dr Martin thank you Dr Davis um I
148appreciate all your hard work on this I had a um I just had a couple of questions so I noticed on the one this sheet that's up now we have the budgeted positions and we have the actual positions obviously some of the schools are over in the number of positions that they were originally budgeted for and I was trying to get a sense of um how that sort of thing happens I was trying to figure out because these people are coming to work every day they're going to do something so does that mean that we underestimated the needs of a building did we have more students to enroll did we have additional responsibilities that popped up in a building does that make sense so I'm just trying to get a sense of uh and I
149know you are you know not a magician to know all things but I'm just curious to know how might something like that happen yeah no that that I think that's a great question um and so it's still up there and yeah so let's just take a look um for example I'll just choose um Ferguson Middle School um you have 58 positions you have uh that are budgeted 63 that are actually there um so that also includes all departments like all the custodians are in there they may have four or five custodians at the school um they may have um you know may also include some of our food service workers and so I'll be moving some of those folks out of the department the budget I'm sorry no that's fine that's fine um when you
150look at the actual budget um let me say this the right way so there were some schools that didn't have that did not have a librarian in the budget but actually the librarian had already always been there so it wasn't a new person it just wasn't included in the budget right and so my question is why not right so the 1344 number that the board approved and my estimation based on what I've done so far was I think under an underestimate okay um I also think um that there were so there so HR and principles and finance folks have had some conversations I don't know where the alignment or the misalignment happened but principles have come in because I asked them how did you hire recommend to hire another person well I got the position
151and I said show me where and and so he bring out a sheet they have Staffing sheet and so some of the Staffing sheets have additional positions but then that conversation never got to the folks in finance and so it wasn't included in the budget so that's why it's important when you're having the budget conversations and vacancy conversations that you may need another person but does the enrollment generate another person and can we afford it you because when you hire folks they're going to show up to get their paycheck right so we've got to figure out where to pay them one of the reasons I think our money couple reasons I think our money our cash flow has been in issues one was because the projections for what our fund balance was supposed to be
152if you remember the $32.8 million actually end up being 24 something million like that misalignment still baffles me and I'm trying to figure it out as I dig into the budget um but that alone was huge because it was about $7.8 million gap if you remember our tax anticipation though was $9.5 Million had we had that $7.8 million that they say we have we probably would have needed a tax anticipation note right so where is that misalignment one um but two how do we make sure that when we hire or rather give a position to the school that the enrollment supports it just because someone say a principal may say and they're gonna argue for their schools because I did when I was a principal I need this position wait a minute now okay certifi
153positions what's your enrollment now I get there's some SCH that have more challenges so we have to come up with a formula of how to more resource those schools but the money got to come from somewhere you can't just pull it out of thin air so if a school doesn't have the numbers of students which is why attendance is so important that generates another position I just can't put a position there because you say you need it you got to justify it I'll also say that you know we have some positions that you know I'm going say have to say to the board listen we can't afford to keep doing this one or these because we've you got to you know physically be more responsible you can't spend more money than you have um so
154so I think that's some of why you know we have a budget and there's been some miscommunication some misalignment um and then using data so that we make sure that we stay within our budget if you have 300 um students that class size 25 I can't give you 14 teachers you know unless I'm pulling it from somewhere else because they're enrollment went down okay and then I just have one other quick question um and my my think already know what the answer to this is but I just want to kind of say it out loud um in light of where we are and the extra work that you're doing uh with Dr Singleton to get all things lined up with the budget I'm curious to know if you all are talking about some sort of
155a uh checks and balances or budget approval process right so that when somebody says they need to hire they do just kind of like what you did that there's this intentional look at that person's budget and enrollment and all the things you just noted um perhaps somehow documented in the system so that we know not you know not a sheet of paper that somebody's marking off but in the system so we know does this line up can we you know yeah so I'm hoping the answer to that is yes but I'm just curious to know are you all working on something it's absolutely yes and let me give you an example um so all of my principles I had um Ryan's Department Ryan Dean who's director of research and eval valuation and he's also our
156data guy so what he did was he built a datab a database for each school okay so every principal has a database and we did it in quadrants you know the cartisian plane love it and he had two sections on it one was who was actually budgeted at your school and they had they they could only view it they couldn't edit anything there okay and then at the bottom he also has a place that has the actual and the budget and the totals okay so there were so there are two sections um that they had no control over and then there are two other sections on the right side where um they would look at each person and the position is that person still there and so I gave them just some steps now with
157that Google Google Document principes had access to it and I had access to it so Charlie and I can look at their sheet and no other principal can see another principal's stuff right they can't see another person's database but what they do is go through their school to make sure that that person's there they document it um we've get giving them payroll data so you know I had a conversation with Dana and uh Bill and and Beth about this part of it because teachers were a little l i put a video out there and I said you may be called in and sit down folks were nervous about that because we shouldn't have to have a conversation with a person about deductions that they have out that's their business not you know everybody else's business
158so what we did was we were able to pull payroll data give principes all the payroll data which is exactly the money that they get in their check so we can see that information right and be able to cross reference that with the amount we budgeted in that salary so every principal has that document uh I I I I train them on how to use it um and then uh when they sit with me we we double check it so I have Finance in there Charlie and myself we go through every person line by line we pull up payroll we have to go back to mun in some cases because now as Dr s to mention we now have Skyward it went affect October 1 there's some folks who aren't here anymore right and so
159there's somebody who isn't here um but we still pay them I've got to account for that in the budget we had some folks that left in September uh before October 1 so we had to go back to munus pull their data see what we paid them to account for it in this current budget so we've got some internal controls that we're putting in place so that we won't have this problem again okay and then I really this my really my last question Dr Martin I want to ask I just want to ask this question you you as the superintendent are being held accountable for for the budget yes ma'am um and so I'm I'm curious to know if building principles have a budget and I'm sure that at some point when they are evaluated during
160the year I am curious to know if um their ability to you know fiscal you know keep their buildings fiscally healthy staying within budget um is that a part of a building principles evaluation yeah is that something that gets talked about in the evaluation process so so um if you look at our strategic plan and I almost think it's um maybe go 14 and it says that every employee would get a fair and timely evaluation so when I so so I evaluate these folks here and I sat down with all of them for their initial evaluation and I have in there I quote the goals from the um strategic plan uh if it's a CIP goal so that as I hold them accountable especially sha and Jane for example because they are principal supervisors and
161so the both of them have sat down with the principles and gone through their goals right so everybody gets a fair evaluation period whomever you are okay or you you should be getting one I said this to principles and I said it to employees if you're not getting the evaluation then you need to have a conversation with your um supervisor and then if you still don't get something send me an email right but they are evaluating everybody one uh and two your question was about whether the uh the fiscal responsibility was a part of their goals um so it so that particular language may not be in a goal for example going forward though this is a priority because that's not one of my four goals if you think about it even though I'm responsible
162for it's not necessarily uh in my goals those for that you all have for me but I still got to take care of it I still got to keep my attention on it because we can't get out of budget um because I can't do all the other goals right no money no Mission um what what I believe strongly about though is all my principles are more student now on what their school budgets are who the people are uh how much money we put into the schools so so that way as folks retire we have folks already putting in for retirement at higher ends of the salary scale when we start hiring next year and we appropriate these dollars at your budg and your budget at your school then you know what your budget is and
163you you may be able to losing two teachers at $90,000 you may able to get three teachers you know at $50,000 I'm just using that as an example but it's having that knowledge that helps you to be a better fiscal Steward over your resources um because you know what your budget is and I believe strongly that principles are going down that road okay last thing I just want to make a comment my feeling about it is I know that their goals are connected to your goals right in our strategic plan but there's also a part of me that feels like um fiscal responsibility is a standard part of any School principal's job um so whether it is tied to your goals or not it feels like their evaluation should always have a piece in there
164that that sort of just checks in with principal principles about how well they are managing their budget so that's just my opinion a good point yes ma'am thank you Dr Paul Walker Dr graes I guess my my question is kind of um system level question just in regards to are there any policies or policies I would say that the Board needs to be looking at to ensure um steps and procedures are followed and so I'm just kind of I just kind of looked in glance I really didn't see anything but as we're doing this policy work um HR and finance department has a piece to play in this puzzle right and I'm wondering what policy looks like what procedure looks like and are we missing some alignment um in regards to the system that is
165in place and so after all of this is done as a board member I want to see what policy that we're going put in place and I say that as a board and then I would like to make sure that those procedures are in alignment with whatever that policy is because there is some type of Disconnect yeah yeah no I I 100% agree um you know procedures are in you know the administration's perview and but but it has to align to the policies that you all um put in place right and you know just to quickly um this past summer when we did our summer Institute at slooh um I did a piece with all the principles assistant principles everybody there specifically talking about fund 11 which is um the general fund and then fund
16620 which is a special fund right um and we talk specifically about um you know where teachers are paid from which is a special fund and then all other employees are paid from General and now how those dollars are used I did that with principles all administrators at that point I think it's the education um budget is an area that most principles if they said I have an opport Unity that I can grow in then budget's going to probably be that area for for the most part and that's because many folks don't see it as their responsibility but it is like Dr power walker said it's all of our responsibility to be fiduciaries right and make sure that we're spending our money appropriately what I believe strongly in is that as our principles and assistant
167principles because for me it's important for assistant principles to know this work as well because they should be the bench of who's stepping into the principal ship next um you know what is fun1 what is fun 20 how are my folks in my school paid um where do that money come from and and so I think yes um we'll keep watching that I'm actually on the um fiscal uh policy revision committee as well and I looked at a couple places where I think we can do a little bit better um at what our my recommendations to the board on what policies you should adopt so that I and my team can put together procedures that align squarely to those policies thank you which board member has Personnel oh perfect well it sounds like you could
168be aligned to some of that work then Dr Graves hopefully uh we'll do Dr Thurman um giving this report but as I listen to it not but as I listen to it it it just seems like your your idea of how we should be running the the budget and finances in the district it makes a lot of of sense and it just seems like Personnel 101 yeah so as I was thinking about this I was thinking historically if if we would were to like collect the data on how we have been running the district financially I just wonder how much money how many times we've over budgeted and it hasn't reflected in our bottom line in our our budget and the information that's coming to the board will you be able to as you do
169your internal audit be able to look back at any historical data on how we did our budget and if the budget was out of alignment in the past yes ma'am you know um I worked closer with Laur all her years here she's retired um and what I appreciated about our time together was we constantly talked about you know what was going on with what the board had approved and then and there's mostly people because most of your budget is going to be in people okay um so so we can probably look back historically at what was budgeted what was actual um I think what's going to really help us Dr Thurman going forward is for me and then everybody else especially the board and then the community be clear about what true vacancies we have
170because that uh sometimes when folks see a vacant position they think that money is just sitting over there right waiting to be spent well if your numbers are inaccurate then those vacancies aren't true right we want to make sure that when we give the board a budget uh Dr Singleton and I in June by June 30th that is representative of our enrollment our programs all those things so that our budget is more accurate in terms of the numbers of people we need positions rather so we can fill those with people and then we stay within that right um the the policy says we have to have a preliminary one to the board by April 1 okay we were a little behind this past year and then do to April 24th if you remember upstairs but
171we'll meet that deadline this time but I think it's also having a public conversation so that the community is coming along with okay so how much money are we spending how much revenue do we have you know what what is the revenue and then what are the expenditures so so yes ma'am I think I can look back at historically to your question of you know have we been off or own um I think we've been pretty own because we haven't had to borrow uh we're off now because we have to borrow so that's a huge indicator right if you make xll and you know you spend more you then you won't be able to pay your mortgage you won't have way to stay so so you got to be fiscally responsible right so so I
172feel like we've done a pretty good job at that um Dr singon said it and I've had conversations with other superintendents around the region since all this has happened with us and I can tell you and I don't want you know if anybody's listening out their radio land my superintendent bu forgive me um but but but a lot of folks are dealing with this time of year um because you've got to get to December when you start getting your dollars in so it is a cash flow issue which is why it's so important to have a healthy fund balance so that you can make it through these tough months right because your money starts coming in most of the money comes from local and most of that money starts coming in in December and January
173so as he said we're going to see our fund balance go up but but it's not real because you got to keep paying people paying your bills it's the it's the big picture we do have to we do have to ear earn the fact that it was our mistake yes ma'am it was our mistake um and maybe if we had done it the right way we wouldn't have to borrow the money like you said ma' you've been here 10 years and we have never had to do that yes ma'am and the other point I want to make you made a great point about the vacancies um we need to not have that out I mean even if we have that on our website yeah and I'm just wondering how that looks when we've got all
174these vacancies and we know we don't have the vacancies we don't even know what the vacancies are yeah or how many yes ma'am so that I hopefully this this is going to be all cleaned up too yeah and and and I just want to say yes ma'am I I just want to say that you know so I take responsibility which is why I thought this was important based on what the board was saying to me um and I know I got folks in different departments but at the end of the day I'm fully responsible um which is why it's being so important for me to sit down with everybody and be really clear about what we have um so that when we go back to the community with this final report we can say with
175certainty with accur y that here's where our numbers are and then I can say to the board my recommendation is and you can tell me what to do is we're going to have to shave some of these things because we've over budgeted um more we have more people we've hired rather more people than we budgeted for so so so so I take responsibility for uh much of this which is why we're doing this work but I but I feel strongly that when we're done I'll be able to give the board Clarity on where we are and then you can give me direction on what we need to do next thank thank you thank you Dr Thurman miss phips any questions Miss dun um not at this time uh I do want to just say thank
176you though to the work that you are putting in and I look forward to seeing the final update and all I'm sure all questions done than' thank you Mr Tyson okay I have a quick well observation question whatever how you want to call um so when I look at this Dr Davis so yes we're having so like when you Ferguson medals for example the one that you gave um you budgeted 58 that budget was supposed to be 3 million4 3 Mill 3.4 million right we came in at 63 which is a five position difference but that five position difference is costing addition an addition $3 million or is it that tells me either we got five people making $600,000 a year over there or that's a um those 58 people that we only budgeted 3.4
177million for are not making would we budget them to make yeah now when I was a mortgage operations and I had a staff 120 at one point and was hiring fir people if if they gave me a budget and say that you can only hire this this um loan officer or this processor they gave me a Range yeah right uh if that person didn't come within that range that person wasn't getting hirer yeah right but it looks to me because even if you go down to um Robinwood was that Robinwood I saw Yes Robinwood yes when you go to Rob we budgeted 27 at 1.8 we actually got 33 over there which is a six difference but it's only $1,000 difference so we got a six people over there making $18 98 a year you
178know what I'm saying so so yes I get getting to the numbers and the positions but it it appears to me one board member that we're not even hiring the people and paying them what we budgeted to pay them yeah and that that concerns me too because if if if we're going to say back to Ferguson middle that those 58 people were supposed to be making 3.4 well those 58 people are not making 3.4 unless we got five people making 600,000 yeah so that concerns me too and then what back to Courtney's Point what policy or procedure or how you want to look at it is going to be in place to where we're ensuring that the people that were hiring and budgeting for that position are coming in within that budget and because yeah
179that's those are some yeah so so let me let me try to tackle some of what I think I've heard you say um specifically Ferg middle uh being3 million over right what I will tell you and I'm looking at their actual budget right now um and then section c which is sort of the uh quadrant four on the plane um um we have at least you know seven or eight positions here um that aren't even included in the original budget okay so when I give you when I gave Ferg middle their budget um and let's just say they had 27 people on the budget using that or say F middle had 58 people on the actual budget right um where in fact they probably should have had 60 some OD people on the budget there
180are folks who were there last year the position still there but it wasn't included in the budget right so that so the numbers are inaccurate when I look at what was budgeted by School versus what we actually have so as I so so I'm not changing what the budget was I'm leaving it like it is because it's going to give me guidance on what an appropriately budget for this school okay um because you can't you don't have five people making $3 million I want one of those jobs right it's not it's not accurate um so when we did budget we should have we should have budgeted way more people based on the programs and the enrollment but some of the folks were left off why I don't know yet okay um I'll know after I'm
181done with all of them but I'm really going to have to be done with the Departments too so that I can have a better sense because there are some folks in departments that their budget they're budget in the department and not at the school and vice versa some are budgeted at the school and not in the department custodians for example you may have five custodians and if all of them are in the department uh and they should have been in this budget or vice versa then it'll throw the budget off right so here's what I want to make sure happens is when we sit down in March uh February and do our budget for 25 26 I'll be better a able to say these are this is how many people we should have budgeted at
182Ferg middle last year based on the enrollment uh based on um and that's certified teachers and then based on the non-certified folks is well right um which are our office staff that all those numbers come in so then I can say to the board we should budget X numbers of positions whether it be administrators certified or non-certified um here are the salaries that those people command that are in those positions so you have to use that as a a projection of what you budget for for that year um and then if folks leave the position's still there okay um but to your point some of many of the school's budgets are inaccurate why I don't know you um I have my thoughts um but you know we're not here to point fingers we're here to
183figure out like where the issues are so that way we don't have the same issue going into next year and the same goes for like Robin Wood again I've sat with all the elementary school folks and there's off a little less than what the secondary ones are I did I'm doing High School last because you have more staff and so you're GNA have more opportunities for erors um but what we will have as we go into next year because high schools are different when you talk about appropriating teachers because you have to look at it by Department uh you have to do the pre the pre-registration you got to see what kids are asking for I may have you know 50 teachers or 75 teachers at the high school and nine of them may be
184math and 10 of them may be English and next year I may need seven math and 12 English just depends on what kids are asking for at the high school but what I'll be able to say to the board is that we need X numbers of positions at McClure High School based on all these factors and then we have an accurate budget right so these budgets we have just are not accurate okay just last question so do you happen to have a total of just in this discrepancy on the last column because I would just be curious to know um what that number and I guess I guess I could have did it myself I was just K yeah and I and I probably wouldn't do that Mr Tyson because you're going to want me
185to finish it because there's some you're going to want me to finish and I'm just being honest you're going to want me to finish it especially these departments so I can put people exactly where they need to be and then I can give you a more accurate account of this is where these numbers are yes sir that's a good point good point yes sir Mr Bailey I don't want to be redundant at all uh I just you made a point that I was really getting ready to ask about you know you have a custodian at a at a high school per se but then he's budgeted it out of uh Terry's department but then they're counting him in the actual budget for the high school yeah so I'm glad that you made that point cuz
186that was kind of my wondering is as well is that it is like he is custodian specifically and I'm not picking on custodians or anything it's is my thought but a custodian specifically is budget to a department but then a school may put that in that budget so basically it's like it's two incomes getting counted for which aren't really accurate at all yeah um so I'm glad that you made that point because that kind of helps understand that I really don't have any other comments until I see the the entire finished but I just appreciate you even standing up there and taking these hard questions cuz that is hard to take even though you are the lead and stuff like that that is still hard to take and you've toen it gracefully and I appreciate
187that I appreciate you sir for saying that what I will say as want to make one point that you said I want to make sure I say really clearly that each person will be counted once okay because you make a good point um you could have a teacher in this side of the budget that also shows up over here and it's going to be really important that you know each person only gets counted one time okay which is why we have the big macro budget um because we have folks moving from school to school and that's what I mean like the high Flex positions it might be hounded Cross Keys and they're going the FD floor that's another whole conversation but that's in the budget and I I get that's why I want to open
188up Pandora's box but what I'm saying is that this understanding that people might be budgeted in multiple spaces because schools accounting for that like a high Flex teacher that's a high need because it's math or science and then you put that in part of your budget as you're if you're the science chair or whatever it is but then you also have to understand that even though it's a person the materials that they need and all of that has to account for that budget so it's multiple needs and multiple schools and different money is being allocated because of different you know needs within the schools yeah uh you know I won't even get into the high Flex piece because that's something something we tried and you know we had some push back on it from some
189of the folks in the community um it's costly um and it's largely done in in math and any other subject we have some folks in other subjects too but it's hard to find Math teachers right I mean we've had a number of our teachers go and get a ma elementary teachers get math certification that's not the high Flex where High Flex is it's at typically at the middle and high schools um so we've got to do a better job at building a pipeline because it's costly to do high Flix and I don't think it's sustainable honestly and I'm I'm I'm just preliminarily saying that uh we we've got to do a better job at those High needs areas uh to get teachers uh in the classrooms nothing's more important than having that that teacher ready
190and and and and one thing I'm happy about is we have a couple of our classroom facilitators who on the other end um of the high Flex model that are actually working on math certifications right so we hope we can keep investing in our people here so we can put them in classrooms in front of live students versus uh and using the high Flex model well thank you Dr Davis I just want to make sure the board is fully aware that we will not receive the final report by Sunday uh as today is Wednesday and so we will receive it the morning of the meeting that way believe we can receive it sometime that morning that way we can at least have a I just want to make sure the board expectations not to receive
191it by Sunday cuz I'm sure he'll still be working on it Monday and Tuesday and probably finalizing it Wednesday morning does that seem reasonable thank you so much I'm I want to make sure I clean it good so it's right cuz it's Wednesday night already and so okay can we just get an email update when it is posted yes ma'am please absolutely absolutely Charlie now I'll make sure that happens perfect thank you Dr Davis next up is policy update uh Team updates we'll start with Dr Thurman then go to Mr Bailey and down the line can you would you allow Dr to talk about ask me Poli J we're actually going to take a f minute break we'll come back at 9:00 thank you okay e e e policy update team updates Dr Thurman you
192are first if you are back and ready if not we're going to start with Mr Bailey providing any team updates but Dr Thurman it looks like I just saw you there so we'll start with you any team updates from your end on policies you have her mic turned off hold on Dr Thurman we can't hear you they have to turn you up still can't hear you yet I can't trying to unmute now we can we're good sorry there you go okay so policy J is enormous and um I just wanted to I did report out on it last time give um Dr pal Walker um an opportunity to talk about that we're working diligently we had oh gosh probably close to 100 pages so this is one of the largest policies but but we're making
193good progress okay slow progress I say that yeah Dr Walker yes I I would agree uh Dr Thurman so I just made a few notes here that I'll share briefly I think we have been able to have some good discussion and uh good input from the people that have been uh participating with the group I think we've had a chance to have a couple of parents be there to share some of their input um one thing I've noticed is that this work has allowed counselors um to kind of really look at their their part in this policy and really try to firm up things to make sure it's in alignment with Asa the American School counseling Association um this work has also allowed us to kind of have some clarifying conversations made like clarifying conversation
194about the difference between the policy that the board and the procedure that comes out of the policy because I think at some point some procedures were included in policy so we've been able to talk about that uh it has indeed been a challenge getting through all of the material um because we want to do a good job we want to be thorough and there's just a lot there to get through some of the topics we've talked about are admissions student attendance dress code uh student conduct on District transportation weapons um conditions under which students can be removed from schools immunizations students with disabilities and how we support them and then students in homeless and Foster Care I'm sure there's probably some things I'm missing but that's the gist of I think what we've been doing
195and and uh we are meeting I think on the 19th to try to wrap up our discussions thank you so much doc Mr Bailey it's going to be doctor soon working on it uh we're doing very well with our uh committee work tooya I don't think she's here today uh she's done a a phenomenal job helping us with the equity piece uh we hope to have one more session if not another one and we hope to wrap it up U hopefully by the end of December if possible thank you Miss Don um our committee work is well underway we are not one meeting away we are two to three depending on which team we have both personnel and instruction um we had pretty hefty um sections to deliver on around 50 plus depending on which
196section you're looking at policies each and there have been some just really great discussions and I just want to thank all of the people on our teams while I wasn't able to go to the most recent I'm getting my sections confused now most recent one of our teams um people are coming prepared people are putting comments on there we're having really great deep discussions um in our team meetings and I think that our team members would agree with that as well um and just also a shout out to Dr Graves who who um is partnering up on those two sections Dr Graves thank you Jillian for the assist um I mean all all things that she said um we're just happy for the work to be um moving as swiftly as possible um one of
197the things that we have talked about is really what is that procedure work going to look like and um that we feel like it's important to kind of start to say now what that plan is um moving forward because a lot of people are really concerned that we're doing all of this policy work but are the procedures going to get done and so I just wanted to go ahead and put that out there so when we are ready to kind of talk about what that next step is going to look like I think it's I think it's something that we need to do sooner rather sooner than later because it's definitely the next step and people want to know okay well what what is that going to look like as well but all in all
198I believe um we're on track with um our personnel as well as instruction well thank you um certainly appreciate all of the work and I know this is the first time we've done a lot of policy work and so um there are some procedures in policies that should be procedures in policies which gets a little tricky so again we'll get through that piece of it um I think to Dr Graves point one of the the sooner we can get this on of the next stage as sooner Dr Davis and his administration can start working on the procedures um I do think publicly I just want to say like once everything is done we will have the cabinet member also present the procedure to the board just a brief overview to make sure it's done make
199sure everyone knows where it is so therefore everyone just knows that it's available for review that way everything will be electronically in symol once everything's done we'll no longer have a printed book everything will be in symol for procedures and that there'll be no login access needed everything will be able to be seen so everyone has that for that just want to remind the the board CU we have so much free time during this time of year we do have the target of Monday of trying to have those other electronic sections done if you can review the best you can certainly um uh I think it was the 15th Monday already 19th your next meeting for the other one the 15th was kind of our Target for our sections if not it's not the end
200of the world it's not a meeting it's just you're doing electronic comment and then we'll go through and schedule a me yep y yes so that tonight uh so appreciate everyone's work I really am excited about this uh work and I want to shout out to Dr Grace when she was here getting us started with msba to get us to this point today because this was two and a half years in the making to get us to this point this was not just something that came up magically this year this has been a work in progress it might have involved with Dr Paul Walker even as well uh for this so it's been quite while for that we have two sections up for our first reading tonight you all we are super excited section A
201and H is ready for our first reading uh so what will happen is Communications team will be sending it out to the community all stakeholders to be able to give a Google form feedback on this it is available for you all to read as a first reading it is also going to msba to give feedback on our first reading and see if there's anything legally that we Chang that we cannot or should not change based on legal advice so with that this is just a first reading of sections A and H and I'll be happy to entertain any questions on either of those readings if not it'll be going out to the community and we'll have a final reading once we hear back from the community based on community feedback will determine if our teams
202need to meet again to incorporate feedback if there's no feedback back then we will just move forward after msba response back that legally we're good to go for a final reading and then that signals administration's chance to then start procedure work so my question would be then as it goes out to The Community what's that deadline going to look like thinking about when we reconvene we do one week was what we we set for the last time we did policies we give the community one week to respond to that email to give feedback okay that was a standard response at the first time we modeled this what was the policy we did for the remember we did I can't remember what it it was a policy yeah it was a policy we did a Google
203form we gave one week yeah so we'll do the one week turnaround time I can't remember yeah what SEC so it's really one week so ideally by Friday we'll be sent out by next Friday before winter break it will be any feedback that way the committee will know if there stuff and that will be the standard one week protocol and then they always can come to a public meeting as well because we'll have a final reading so people also have another chance to present the night of the board meeting when we're doing a final reading for it so you'll always notice now on item 11 it will always say team updates first reading and and then final reading just so we can all kind of keep keep updated Donna thank you is there a way
204that we can alert um the community that it's coming yeah there's going to be communication sent out to all stakeholders and then we can put it on our website as well somewhere yes yep on our website just to say you can do the Google form and all that thank you for that is there any new business I do I'm sorry I do want to mention something um on Saturday Kevin and myself attended um the professional learning committee committee which is a um committee um of board members that are um in our region so that's Hazelwood Jennings Ritner um you city um at this particular meeting we had it was about safety and social emotional safety um physical safety for buildings and um it was one more safety however the one the reason why I want
205to kind of bring this up kind of back to the comment that um the Nea proposed um just in regards to um safety in general for our school in this meeting we had uh St Louis County um police chief we had the police well the over Safety and Security through Missouri school board associ Association um we had a a representative from the FBI that kind of looks at um safety in our area and the question that I proposed or asked was what do we do when we have our students who they feel kind of safe in our schools but they feel even unsa in our community and how do we really address um at as a whole as a unit as a community really what do we do um so we can address those dangers
206that our students face um in our home communities and so that a lot of those behaviors are not brought into um our school setting and so um the um the chief stated basically that we sh um start a task force and so what I'm asking uhhuh we did we did we talked about it a long time ago um and but I think it's really time to bring it back and um because the issue hasn't changed and um I just believe that we can't do this work alone the school district can't and it has to take um the community it has to take uh City officials um I would say nonprofit agencies that um are working with our families in the community so I'm asking the board um about the possibility of once we finish the
207policy work that we start a task force to look at uh safer schools safer communities love it I certainly think uh are you saying after our first reading of policy work so like after the March deadline or like after it's all approved and implemented no no no no no after it's approved and we don't have to do that work anymore got it so more next fiscal year almost I'm saying after we finish all the groups and meetings so once we started getting that rolled out then I have another set of meetings um but I think that is something that um we got to do something basically appreciate that if we will work on a resolution for the board to officially adopt if that works for you so that way we can form the task force
208officially through resolution does that work perfect okay seeing anyone else have new business should we delay it more for Miss bips that's why our meeting went so long tonight we wanted Miss bips to get the full experience on her last meeting uh for this but certainly appreciate that with that as our motion to return to closed so move then mve by Graves second second by done roll call vote please um Mr Bailey yes secretary votes yes Dr Thurman yes Dr Graves yes P Walker yep and Dr Martin yes yes motion carries this meeting adjourned