001hold on I got to get the meeting going okay well he can do his other spiel about oh you need that to read too we're not going to leave the room though right we're iess we can okay I follow this meeting order thanks everybody for coming start with pledge of Alle agance to the flag of the United States of America to the rep for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all word by Montana law members of the community are given an opportunity to make brief comments to the board on any matters not included in their the agenda individuals wishing to be heard shall first be recognized by the chairperson individuals after identifying themselves will proceed make brief comments board would like to remind everyone that to avoid violations of
002individual rights of privacy member of the public wishing to address the board will not be allowed to make comments about any student staff member or member of the general public no action may be taken on any matter discussed during the public portion of the meeting until such time as the matter is specifically noticed on an agenda and the public has been allowed the opportunity to comment Thomas do you have any public comment let's move on with our meeting first item is to approve the minutes for two executive sessions held on December 17 2004 may we do them together or do we have to do them separately you can do them together okay I move to adopt the executive station summary for both sessions that were held on December 17 2024 second we have a motion
003in a second don't believe we can make comment on this so it just comes back to a vote olly I'll call out when it's time for you to vote everyone in here in person all in favor say I I I I OE I motion carries one three four five six to zero new business evaluation process with Sir Thomas Reynolds all right well thank you board did you need this yeah I was going to see how I can uh get that up here BSD boardroom display does enter a pen we're going to watch Craven the hunter m it should come up uh make sure your source is uh input or HDMI can't remember yeah hit that again and a lot of times that does it yeah there you go so Bard I've been here for almost
004going on two years now and um I just like to you know put something in writing get every everybody on the same page for this process works so that we can get it streamlined so that if you know I get hit by a bus one day D you know is not here we can all know what we okay yeah there you go win the lottery after I give some back to the school to help build the the elementary um I'd like to you know I did a lot of research at other what other districts are doing and things like that and just to kind of formalize a process so that it's uh transparent fair for everybody um and that it brings back some communication collaboration uh between the board DD and Carri and the clerk
005um so what I have here is kind of our current process in December we set a meeting to schedule the evaluation we send out the surveys um to the CT admin um we send them out to the the superintendent we we get them back everything's kind of rushed a little bit um in this process and then there's kind of uh you know are we evaluating goals you know are the criteria correct things like that but that's kind of how that's how we're doing it right now um I know Mary Ellen and Holly have worked really hard and established a great foundation for the evaluation metrics and things like that so I'm super appreciative of all that work and just taking this to the next steps uh yeah just making sure we're all on page on
006the evaluation process um like I said I've done a lot of research on this through OPI through other what other districts are doing and you know the timeline pretty much starts right after the evaluation happens where in February or March the discussion between like the superintendent and and the board they start that long range strategic plan goals action plans uh in February and March the evaluation instrument is kind of selected and agreed upon at that time uh goals are finally established um contract discussions usually happen around June um and this is kind of the part where it kind of again uh flexible um superintendent completes their self assessment in August um the board and the superintendent have a formative assessment in September to talk about I call these check-ins you know OPI and other other
007agencies use the school the education term of formative assessment I call these check-ins on checking on the progress so we're not waiting till today to talk about goals that of you know where we at so it's a continuous communication cycle so again my suggestion is that we we meet in September to talk about the goals and progress um October November we're having another meeting about goals another form of assessment uh December you have that summi of assessment the trustees complete their evaluation in December we set the dates for January and um then we kind of pick back up on our on collecting all the data from our certified admin um and then we just start the cycle back over any questions comments goad so in June you have contract discussions what's that so basically the
008superintendent signs a three-year contract in June um it's listed under June right but so we're in the contract right now so if the like last year right we we talked about the superintendent adding another year to their contract so that the three years doesn't kind of last it's always kind of going at every three years we keep it at three years until the superintendent and the board decide otherwise it's standard practice here in Montana for that to happen um and that's where you talk about also compensation at that point as well so you you have that conversation in June but it's not finalized because you have to offer them a contract by February right well we've already offered the contract for three years right so we've already offered a contract for three years so this
009is just a kind of that piece of talking about well do we want to add that third keep on adding that third year at the end and talk about compensation um it's it's interesting right I've been trying to figure out what that timeline looks like alsoe why June so I think you know it could be it could be now and then we obviously need to back up the evaluation and then have another meeting to talk about the contract unless we do it all at the same meeting but if you were ever in a situation where you had concerns about your superintendent and you needed to figure that part out it probably wouldn't work to have it at the same meeting hopefully that never happens and we could do that um I think one of the
010other challenges with um looking at the superintendent contract now is on negotiation years we don't know where we're headed yet yeah and so to talk about compensation changes for the superintendent I think are premature because we don't we don't know what that looks like in under the bigger picture so I guess I at least in in in negotiation years would see why there would be a reason and we wouldn't have to wait till June I mean it could be earlier in the spring but I think you know there's there's some validity to that timeline I think you selected maybe because it's the end of the school end of the fiscal year right end of the fisc so we the July the contract starts July 1 so you if you if anything in the contract were
011going to change you'd have to do it before July 1 so it could be it could be earlier than that well she if get the only thing I for me it would be we've gotten through the year we we've seen the performance through the year and then we can make a decision right right a decision right Montana law says we have to offer the contract by February so but I already you you've already offered already yeah if you were gonna not if you were gonna stop you have to do it by February 1 exactly that's that's the caveat criteria is about the February deadline is if you weren't gonna but if we don't offer a contract for the third year it's automatic in the state of Montana correct yeah so why are that takes place
012in February so why are something in June I so if you do her contract now and you want to keep it always is in a three-year contract M then you can't do it till June because if you did it now she'd be in a more than a three-year contract so you can't add to a year to her contract until you get to July so but if you decide not to add a year which you guys can do then you it's not until the final year of her three current three-year contract that you have to do it by February by February yes and then every other year you can do it anytime you want it just makes sense to do it in June so that you make that decision and then her new contract starts right
013away in July for the another 3 years because if you did it now it'd be 3 years and four months 5 months and that's against the law in Montana Okay the reason confused was because we just got a we just got that question from Montana School boards Association yeah so it's really not a concern about the February date until the last year of her contract okay yes yeah all right don't know if I'm in agreement but I think I had that right there in the second bullet contract action review if on the third final year of contract right this is why we keep carry around that sounds so final I mean it makes sense if it's rolling we continue to roll that third year we can't do that till June because otherwise it'll be like
014three years of but if it's terminal she if she says I think I want to be done after this three years or if we say maybe we need to evaluate then it's like okay then we'll visit in February and say are do you want to add another three years so it makes sense why to do it that way contract cont from a Contracting perspective or you have things you need to superintendent to work on yeah that's why it's there yeah okay and so again this is just draft um I can send this to all of you and kind of take some time to think about it um but like I said I'd like to have an some kind of definitive process at some point so that yeah we just we kind of so this is
015just for the superintendent yeah and I think the the clerk would follow something similar my contract ends on June 30th as well so and we but I can only have a one-year contract but we hire you at that main meeting well you appoint me but you don't give me a contract until June okay yeah yeah you don't renew my contract so you could appoint me but then not hire me and then you'd have to appoint somebody else safeguards for you car no I'm a year-to-year employee you're just kind of something was to go south three months into your contract there's nothing you could do to work out of that you know what I mean well you guys would have to have reasonable cause to get rid of me just cause to get rid of me
016and then yeah that's it otherwise you're stuck with me until my contract renews June 30th and then you could not renew it yeah yeah that just doesn't give you very much job security I've never had it I've been in a clerk job for over 20 years and that's just how it is and that's really how it is for all School Employees if you're doing it correctly yeah it's just yeah except for teachers because they have the 10-year protection but I don't worry too much I feel like I work hard and hopefully I don't give you a reason to be in that position that depends the Super Bowl go Chiefs you rooting for I thought the most exciting thing about the playoffs was the guy that sang the national anthem yeah the rest of it they
017could all Washington they were like we're gonna invoke a rule that we can add points you guys don't behave and I was like what rule is this watching football my whole life all right now I just want to go on record saying that this this entire evaluation process is subject to change because Holly and I worked this up because we didn't have one yeah so Holly and I are going off the board you can change it anyway and we should probably review it anyway and right yeah but there was a comment about let's evaluate the superintendent um and one board member said well we don't know what the what the teachers think on some of the comments and so you need to look probably at the the document itself the the instrument yeah Thomas and
018I kind of talked about that a little bit last week I've been meaning to fill Jesse in on that too I don't want to go on too much of a tangent but it was too much too boiler plate for me there weren't you know it's like well I would like more specifics yeah for example like my my thing right now is testing scores right so yeah I mean I think you'd have go you know one normally you'd have have set of goals that that each person would have and you do evaluation against those goals and they might change year to year yeah because we're going to move school's going to move in a different direction good good or bad and we may want to change or may goals same thing with Gary I mean if
019the financial situation was different then you know we might have to there might be more heat on her to do something different yeah you know it'll be kind of a combination of the two like some of it makes sense you know like going to public events or you know displaying school spirit or something like that that kind of makes you know 0er to five but then there's got to be some specifics that we we want to see as cons absolutely right and that's difficult to figure out I think the hard part for my position too is I have two positions and you guys only evaluate me on the district clerk position and Dei evaluates me on the finance director and then she makes her recommendation to you guys for renewal of my contract and stuff
020so I think that makes it really hard too yes um I was going to ask though about things like from a data perspective like test scores are so weird as far as like a valuation thing because like year over year or even like a cycle like four two years over two or four we just we're talking with right um we had a meeting at the high school talking about like actually the data on test scores and how like accurate it is because you have to figure like fundamentally like it you I can't compare test scores in let's say 2020 with test scores today so it's like so hard as like a a reference of like um a job well done for teachers or superintendent did we raise test scores because we have so many confounding
021factors that are going to play into that and I'm not even Let's Pretend Co didn't even happen like not even including something like Co and sort of the repercussions thereafter of you know that but just in general about like our population and even like teacher turnover and teaching styles and I'm looking at this because we were trying to weren't we trying to find a solution of how can we somewhat standardize like our AP score specifically but that one as like a measure of like um value of like our you know superintendent stuff is like a really difficult one for me because like all I can think of is how how do I measure this truly at a scale of data right because like there's so many factors we can't say well test scores didn't go
022up so they're not doing a great job because did we change curriculum what does our school population look like that's where they get paid the big bucks yeah I think I I mean I hear what you're saying but I think that um there's got to be multiple criteria that you're looking at they might well be doing things really well positively but there's still a need to have some level of performance Improvement not that we have to have better than we had in you know 10 years ago or anything like that but we ought to be looking at last year and where we're going forward but again one criteria versus you know four other criteria that are fairly important as well doesn't mean that um you're going to make a swing of a decision just tells
023everybody this is an important component this is something that we've got to have our eye on this ball it just feels like a weird of it feels like a a district like goal rather than a superintendent goal because how I don't see how you could rate a superintendent on did test score increase I know she organizes her Administration she oversees to make sure that teachers are being evaluated yeah but I think you look at Trends in our schools like say we had a thousand Hispanic kids who didn't speak English you could come to us and say this is why our test scars are low and that would be fair she has but yeah just as like a point of like okay on an evaluation you know did test scores go up one two or three
024right that's what I mean like that seems like not a good yeah well that's what I'm talking about I think that's too much in the weeds right so so with the superintendent evaluation it's got to be you're you're about 10,000 feet and so I think they they they kind of say at the best here a defining kind of that um effective educational leaders develop and support rigorous and coherent systems of curriculum instruction and so how does how does DD the superintendent support drive those numbers basically looking at at that level and so going to that right we have our current eval criteria and potential you know to think about um because they there are definitions to these and it helps putting a definition with the evaluation criteria I mean we can keep the ones that
025we have but Define what what does visionary what does visionary leadership mean um instruction yeah totally what how do you want to proceed with I mean I could go off a tangent about five of these right now how do you want to proceed with Val or defining you plan on organizing a group of those well I just put that in I was like maybe get a committee of of of the board yeah I think that would be good because I think everything that everybody is saying all makees sense yeah and I think we have different perspectives what we see as a community too like I'm in the grade schools right and I know you know Rocky's often in high school I think we have these like different perspectives of what like maybe feedback we're hearing
026or seeing and I think maybe like a committee or something would be really beneficial yeah and how do we I guess one other thing I was thinking about was uh should we be talking to teachers I mean there's one flow of information Anonymous to be from surveys but sometimes people will tell us things that they would not tell her right and how do we present that in a form that's helpful well I mean what I guess that's a job for the committee though yeah no I think that's I mean as far as the teachers are concerned we it's pretty hard to get too much input from the teachers because we're really not allowed to well there's three levels of yeah I mean that's that's been The Credo of what we've been talking about this so
027unless we're going to change our approach to that it's a fair thought though doesn't need to be answered now but it's something to consider I mean we are talking about doing like an evaluation or like a employee engagement type survey and so something maybe derivative from that I think this is a topic that needs to be held at a work session for the board and have the board involved in this and not something that we can solve tonight no right nope I was just trying to highlight and get that kind of directive right get that kind of like hey look you know let's let's put let's get a meeting together so we can sorry yeah sounds good once again I got us off on a tangent no worries that's all I have just kind of
028wanted to felt like it was the opportunity time to talk about it while I have's attention and um I will we will set I you know if that's what we want is to set up kind of a yeah I can I can we can add something to the meeting agenda or something like that we'll just talk about it in the next meeting and see who want to volunteer to do it s there do you want to set up a committee or do you want to do a workshop session I think it should be the whole board yeah I like that because the committee was Holly in me and we did our perspectives but if all of you are involved you're going to have much more to say um thank you Thomas this was more than
029what I was hoping for okay so now oh it's recording again but it didn't say recording but it's showing that it's recording you're going back okay we are now in open session we have completed uh the clerk's evaluation carry fish evaluation and now we will proceed back into Clos session because we have determin the matter involves individual privacy that such privacy demands protection of the individual and that little if anything would be gained by publicly discussing the information disclosing the information to be discussed and that the demand for individual privacy clearly exceeds the merits of public disclosure in this matter so we are now back in close session