001e e e good evening this work session of the Board of Education of the Cleveland Municipal School District will come to order Mr Stockdale will you please call the role miss elod here Mr bips here Mr Briggs here Mrs Jones here Reverend Jones here Mrs LeBron Mrs Peak here Dr RAR here Mrs welcha here there are eight members present thank you I ask everyone who wishes to rise and participate in the pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the repic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you the chair will now entertain a motion to approve the minutes of the board leadership development session of January 24th 2025 and the board business meeting of January 28th 2025 move thank you
002all in favor signify by saying I I I any opposed the eyes have it the minutes are approved next I'm pleased to introduce our CEO to present this evening's CEO report Dr Morgan thank you chair elott and everyone welcome to February uh the year is uh Trucking on along and uh excited to bring some updates uh for you today so since this is a work session we're going to have a school Spotlight but before we do our school Spotlight we have uh just a few things that I want to share within the CEO report uh and I'm going to have uh some of my colleagues uh helping to uh tag team with me on this um but first acknowledging that this is black history month and always really excited to just celebrate the contributions of
003uh blacks and African-Americans in this country and around the world uh because truly black history and African-American history is everyone's history uh just knowing the contributions and uh I know we're doing some videos across the district featuring one of the gared Morgan principles uh Quinn Davis and uh you know he talks about just the legacy of gar Morgan and we're sitting in uh the building uh an amazing africanamerican uh that was here in the city that made major contributions not only locally Nationwide worldwide and so just keeping that in the hearts and minds of everyone this month and every month and every day uh so excited to celebrate that and kicking that off this month uh next I'm us excited to bring up our chief academic officer Dr Selena Florence who's going to talk a
004little bit about our recent nape results uh that have come out and we wanted to make sure we shared some updates of where we are and also in light of thinking about uh some of the future work that we're going to also be doing uh within the system and response to this so Dr Florence and just let me know when you're ready to advance the slides good evening board chair elod Dr Morgan board members um so on the next slide you will see just an overview of nape very quickly um so nape really is an assessment that is given across our country um and it is the only assessment that really measures what students know and can do in various across the country um so there is a one consistent assessment that is across all
005of our nation um it measures overall student performance by key demographics um it CH also measures change over time and also measures the differen differences between the nation state and urban districts um it uses a sampling procedure so not all students in all districts take the assessment um but it tries to get a representative group um from different races ethnic groups so socioeconomic um levels Geographic levels all within one state um then within those schools it also does a sampling of students that are assessed as well so in 2024 about 800 students from cmsd um were tested in all 65 of our K schools um students in grades 4 through eight are tested in math and reading every two years so what you will see on the next two slides for both reading and math
006um is that performance continues to decline across the country um so most districts and also most urban districts um continue to see um declines where cmsd um is in a state of we are not we did not move very much there was not a lot of um improvement over the course of the past two years um we are still in a state of trying to recover from pandemic um levels of uh performance um and as as for reading some of the work that we are doing now is really um rationale to really support this data and to really be able to speak to how we want to see this change over the course of the next two years um math looks very similar um not a lot of change over the course of the past
007two years across the nation and also in cmsd um and we are all still trying to recover and really working to ensure that all the pieces and uh priorities of our strategic plan are put into place to help support this specific piece of data thank you Dr Florence and so just you know echoing what Dr Florence just shared when looking at our nape data uh our district held steady um from 20 our 2022 results uh but looking from where we were in 2019 2019 uh and then the pandemic had showed that we had a major drop off and so I want to show our next slide here uh and this next slide just shows the history uh and we've been part participating in nape since 2003 so you could see the district uh the district
008is the lowest uh Blue Line there there are a couple of highlights I want to let you know here one there is no significant change once again in both reading and math from our 22 uh results so we um you know I wouldn't say that that's a a positive or negative it didn't go up or or significantly uh down um from 2022 we held steady um Ohio constantly as a state outperforms the nation so Ohio is that Top Line that you see uh in the graph there uh and this is looking at our um the these are looking at Ela results here and then the next slide I'm going to show you is is math um but Cleveland consistently underperforms relative to Ohio and the nation and so when we look at and this is
009historically over time Cleveland consistently uh uh underperforms Ohio and the nation and so when we talk about Excellence at scale and the quality that we're trying to do this is the drum beat of the importance uh and I'll show you our math it's a similar story um we held steady from where we were uh in 2022 you saw some uh slight uptick in our fourth grade results uh some slight uh downtick in eighth grade results but no statistically significant ific change and even when we got our Council great City Schools result it's showing it held flat but you still see we're far behind where the state and the nation is and so when we talk about Excellence at scale this is the work we're talking about now some may ask how can you have this
010and think about like what we just celebrated with our uh three star waiting on our report card and that doesn't negate that one I want to let you know this is a sample of students it was 800 students in our system that took this test as opposed to all students in our district who take the state assessment but if you remember our state assess our state report card results most of our work uh that led us to our four-star rating is due to progress and we're proud of that progress we're proud of closing gaps we're proud of our students making gains in progress but achievement still leaves a lot to be desired and we talked about that two star rating and achievement onear in um our early literacy so we have work to do so
011when we talk about every school every scholar every time this is the work we're going to do and this is the importance of the board goals and guard rails work that we're doing the importance of long-term planning it is the work so I just want to make sure that we just continue uh to double down on the work and I know that that's the work that everyone knows uh our our educators are working hard to do as well as our our uh School leaders uh but it just shows that we have uh work to do and that we have pockets of Excellence but we do not have Excellence at scale so um thank you Dr Florence and now I'll bring up Chief stockdell and similar to Dr oh yeah let's let's let's take questions since
012this is a multi by uh stage uh presentation if there any questions of me thank you Dr Morgan Dr Florence any questions or discussion from board members I guess not um what I will say is I appreciate the the sober look and um you know I I have to be honest it's it's very disappointing and sad to look at these results and especially compared to the nation and um we need to do better for our kids so I really really appreciate the the focus and um and the honesty and the directness so we got our work cut out for us absolutely thank you thank you and now Chief stocko and just like I told Dr Florence if you when you need me to Advance let me know yeah you can go ahead um just just
013a couple slides for me tonight and really the first one is about where we are in the financial process uh as far as budget planning so the governor did release his executive uh budget to the general assembly last week um that begins kind of the process where we learn where we are going to end up because we are required to do a multi-year forecast without knowing what the governor's budget will be or what the general assembly will actually adopt so uh that was introduced um on the 3 we are at the point where in the next couple weeks um we will expect to see preliminary State uh Aid estimates and that really drives how much uh State funding we we expect to have over the next two years the initial things that we've we've seen
014are positive in that uh it's continuing to implement the school funding formula there are some areas that we want to work on but we we have some Advocates that we're working with on that um we will be doing school-based budgeting which will uh which kicks off later this month in February and um Dr Florence has a couple of slides on that as well and then central office budgeting in March and April that is all designed to bring to you a 5year forecast and a budget um in in the May timeline so we can meet the state requirements um I will point out that this year is an unusual year every other year we go through this where we have a 2-year State operating budget where we will have to pass a budget based on our
015best assumptions about what the state is going to do um I did want to highlight also some spending controls um this is not the most exciting thing but there has been some interest recently about the way that we're managing funds and so specifically thinking about um our contract spending we implemented new controls this fiscal year uh at Dr Morgan's um direction for um personal service contracts uh basically requiring uh additional levels of approval to make sure that they're in alignment with our spending priorities as well as restrictions on employee travel and meeting expenses and so to give you a a a heads up on where we are so through um December through the end of December with service contracts we were we're trending to about 18% lower so that means thus far this year um
016we've saved about $10 million that's a sizable obviously amount of money and then um and that's that's to um our forecast so really we already reduced it when we reduced the forecast and we're we're doing even better than what we had projected and then the second is employee travel we are uh with these additional um procedures in place we're trending toward about a third lower than last year this one does vary quite a bit throughout the year so we'll keep watching this one but um I wanted to give you a quick update on these items any discussion board members um I have a question without asking you to predict or react to any changes at the federal level can you speak to uh how Federal funding is Incorporated in our budget yes uh Federal funding
017is very significant so if you think about things like special education and title one which is uh funding for students experiencing poverty it's a very substantial part of our budget the the positive thing so far is that uh the direction that we've received from the State Department of Education and what we've received from the US Department of Education there have not been any direct impacts on our grants and so we are continuing to proceed as we were um obviously something that we closely Monitor and um that involves you know seeing what happens with the executive branch as well as with judicial decisions so it's constantly evolving but right now no impact thank you thank you next we'll have some updates on school-based budgeting and I believe this is both Dr Florence and then Aon F
018so miss f is coming up first and Miss fu is our schools officer good evening so uh I've been asked to discuss how we are modifying our school-based budgeting so the why and the how behind the budgeting process so every year a group of principls and uh central office administrators gets together and reviews how we fund our schools and so as part of that um the team made a commitment to keep our total pool right there's always a pool of funds that we use uh for the schools we wanted to hold that St uh despite the deficit reduction plan that being said we also know that inflation the um collective bargaining increases for pay there are there are some changes that needed to be made in terms of how funds were distributed right and so
019into the current funding model that we had we saw some inequities happening in terms of Staffing and non-personnel funding so we worked together to revise the formula to make it more Equitable so that students had Equitable experiences no matter what campus they were on So currently what we see is that personnel and non-personnel are combined so there is a great deal of autonomy for schools that have certain population levels certain populations in terms of what they can choose to do well many of our smaller schools or schools that are kind of on the edge do not have quite that same autonomy and they're funded at What's called the Baseline we do include the title one funding um in the pool um they receive base weights and I was referring to eight additional weights that kind
020of determine how much a particular student is worth in that pool in the past we've kind of said Baseline like we're going to give you another teacher um is 34:1 which is a very large class size right um for schools that cannot operate within that Baseline what we've done is we've taken and we've allocated additional um there were 47 schools last year out of the 96 or so um that were at Baseline and had zero Staffing flexibility so basically you had your 9 K8 teachers and your three Encore teachers and that was all you could have if you were a k that being said we did provide for schools that have unique funding models like the newex campus um the IB schools I should just say campus the IB schools Monas they receive additional funding
021to make sure that they aren't having Z to be able to do anything else but train their teachers so we give them that extra amount so what are we doing to kind of change and make things more Equitable so here are the changes that we've um proposed personnel and non-personnel are being separated so that school leaders and um their community aren't having to make really difficult decisions about class sizes and things like that so we will help them with their allocations and then they will make determinations they will still have the flexibility to choose like their enquor and things like that that is not being taken from them um but they are receiving non pupil Personnel funding so that there is more equity in terms of the experiences they can offer for their students outside
022so every student is worth $200 of non-personnel and then for our students with special needs and our students um that are language Learners they receive an additional $50 weight so that those extra supports can be provided for those students so a student could be worth $300 if they are both um a student with special needs and a language learner um we have committed to reducing the class size allocation so there is that does not seem like a ton of money for non-personnel right but part of that is so we could reduce class sizes hopefully um we are still including Title One funding in the school funding pool um something that's important to note is that prek has always been outside of SBB and it will continue to be out umide of SBB so um I
023kind of addressed some of this so School leaders will continue to have autonomy over hiring decisions including their administrative teams they will have autonomy over uh non-personnel they will have autonomy to have an over ask so if they feel like part of um our allocation process was incorrect they can appeal that decision if they feel like they have something else that they need um unique School models are remaining in place we are continuing to fund those um we do expect based on our modeling um that the Staffing baselines should reduce staff transfers um and then finally any staff that might be displaced um through this process which happens every year um and aren't selected through the OPI process are going to be supported in their placement by talent and Human Resources so any questions yes
024sir I do have a couple questions um thank you for that report how do we compare to the other large school systems in um Ohio and the 31 34:1 uh ratio so I am not familiar with that I'll defer um to Mr Stockdale but I would say class siiz ratios I can speak to class siiz ratios I can't speak to how they fund 34 to1 in terms of our funding I don't know but I will say our class sizes are approximately the same as Cincinnati and Columbus okay the other question I have is um how do you come up with the $200 and the $100 and the $50 allocations so in terms of the $200 what we looked at is across um all of our schools what was like the mode and median of current
025allocations was like 14175 I believe I think that was the mode um and so no sorry that was mean and so what we did is we took that and we looked at all the different levels and we said okay if if we think about what a good experience would be for a student and we have an average size school what a dollar amount would that be approximately and the $200 allows for your basic supplies like making sure teachers have enough paper to make copies that they have classroom supplies things like that but also accounting for the fact that you do want to be able to have some field trips you want to be able to do some fun things and so increasing that experience so that's where we landed on the $200 um for our
026our our traditional student right and then in terms of the $50 for the students with special needs and for our students um that are language Learners we kind of looked at what extra things might we need to purchase in terms of supplies in terms of programming and so we kind of looked at that funding and determined that that would be approximately if they have a relatively decent sized population would allow us to buy the things we need to provide them with a good experience and who has the discretion on that the principal the principal working with his or her team okay thank you any other questions thank you Mr Briggs thank you one thing I'll add uh in with uh where they were sharing in terms of the the formula uh that was specifically for
027non-personnel personnel um some of those the the funding in terms of how much we receive per student is Set uh by the state and that uh we we still will be allocating the appropriate staff that that schools will need um and as uh you heard Miss FW mention uh principal still have the autonomy of who of hiring who is in their building um uh the the allocations are just set and and given to them and then they have the process to the over ask to help uh with that uh if they have any discrepancies uh and I believe uh with that I'm turning it over to uh Miss I who is here from kand I know we're going to have a video in a moment but uh you've been a partner with cmsd for years
028and I know you work directly in uh some of our schools uh spreading joy and kindness across Ohio so tell us a little bit about the work you do before we turn you over to the video well appreciate the the invite chair elad and CEO Morgan and board members and and guests uh we started uh our relationship with the district in 1995 as project love many of you especially our former board member Rob Briggs remember project love uh and uh we've had an extensive uh involvement from um uh K to 12 uh in uh uh we also have an involvement with um uh three of the high schools are involved in our Workforce training and our via Workforce training uh gin Academy and John Marshall School of Engineering and uh johnf Kennedy High School with
029great strides that's a 16we soft skills character and values curriculum where we pair the students with corporate mentors and the increase in confidence in communication in Po in presentation is just off the charts in fact we had the uh Department of uh education and Workforce come through last Thursday uh we took them one of the schools that we took them to was John Marshall and uh four students made their showcase presentations of who they are what they stand for and how they're going to win at the game of life and the uh odw people were just blown away so you know congratulations and we have a great principal at uh Dr Primus and a great teacher uh Mr Casal at uh at at John Marshall in 20120 we decided that kindness was um a core
030value that could activate schools and grow organically and so we started the kand movement uh and we initiated kin in 2022 in cmsd and uh we have 40 kindland schools participating in cmsd with different lesson plans and uh different levels of messaging and the great thing about kindland is that it can expand and contract uh with whatever the school wants you know as I was talking to a couple of principles uh before the meeting and they said yeah you know we're doing this kind of an exercise and this kind of an exercise and teachers have come up with their own ideas and parents have come up with their own ideas and that's exactly what we have seen throughout the state that this grows organically and it kind of scales to whatever that particular School wants
031but the objective of kindland is to have have an immersive experience because if you know we liken it to going to the shore of Lake Erie and taking a salt shaker and pouring salt in Lake Erie and thinking that you're going to get salt water you know it's not going to be salt water in Lake Erie un the kindland lesson plans and messaging is designed to have an immersive experience so when the um Cleveland transformation Alliance came to us earlier this year and suggested well why why don't we portray our 11 teachers of excellence and how kindness has impacted them and that's exactly what we're doing tonight we are also inviting all of you and the 11 teachers of Excellence to join us for the local kindland awards ceremony at the city hall rotunda on
032March 11th where uh kindland Awards will be given to the 11 teachers of Excellence as well as to councilman penic uh council person Meredith Turner of County C uh mayor KF the longest service serving mayor in kyoga county and uh Joe simpan as our uh nonprofit executive of the year so it's a great ceremony all of you will be receiving invitations and we'll send that through uh CEO Morgan's office um I just want to leave you you have several materials and one thing that we've done with the transformation Alliance is you know we always like to do kind of a a a new push kind of a reboot of kindland in cmsd and all of our other schools every year and so along with the Cleveland transformation Alliance they suggested doing a challenge board we
033call it the school year of kindness so there are different acts of kindness that your Scholars and your teachers and their families in fact can do during the course of the year uh we will Ben crco who is our director of school Partnerships will be monitoring it and working with the individual schools and we hope that that will be distributed through the principes and to the teachers and you know and to the students it would be a great exercise I just want to leave you just with with one thought um kindness is like an allpurpose tool A friend of mine Likens it to a coat hanger he said you know when he was growing up uh in one of the projects uh you know they didn't have a lot but their father had a coat
034hanger and uh when the sing claw they he got the coat hanger out and when when the toilet clogged I hope he didn't use the same coat hanger he got the coat hanger out and when the kids locked the uh keys in the car he got the coat hanger to Jimmy the lock you know we've all been there done that you know this friend of mine also told me that coat hangers are good for constipation you know we don't have to go into that but I do know one thing that kindness is the allpurpose tool for constipation of the heart and that is what we need in our nation right now that's what we need in our community and that's what we need to teach our kids uh without further Ado let's see how kindness
035can talk for itself through your teachers all right thank you and we we'll start this video and we'll see depending on how long it is we may uh start and then uh we'll make sure we have just three just three minutes three minutes okay there we go and yeah can you guys cute it for me yeah [Music] our schools are supposed to be places of Joy compassion and learning and kindness is so important to making that Vision a reality for our schools that's why the kindland initiative is critical to all the work that we're doing at cmsd kindness at jmit uh always reminds me of when we share a meal together as colleagues staff um teachers all of us come together whether it's a PD day whether it's a nice treat from the principles uh
036when we get to share a meal together and sit down discuss things that are going on outside of school um and really just talk about our lives I feel like that's when the most kindness comes out it really makes me feel connected to the people that I work with my physical education teacher in elementary school has such a profound impact on me I became a physical education teacher myself in my classroom we have a quote kindness if it's to be it's up to me and one of our students came up to me and brought me this amazing card that says you're amazing teacher and it's because of kindness if this to be it's up to me kindness has had a profound impact on my life often or ways I didn't expect whether it was a
037small Act of encouragement enement when I needed the most for someone just taking the time to listen kindness has been a powerful reminder of the connections that b us as humans kindness is so important to our Scholars and our Educators when I think about what kindness means in cmsd it means seeing every individual for who they are respecting them seeing them helping them in making sure they achieve their highest goals that's what kindness means to me in cmsd the person who inspired me was my first great principal Dr Dolores Gro on the day that I saw her I witnessed what I could become and throughout my life she has sh me how I can Inspire others as she did for me she always tells me how proud she is of me and she has always
038encouraged me to do things that would Inspire and encourage others how has a teacher impacted my life life well it would be too easy for me to just say it's my dad um retired teacher left the profession in '94 spent some time in cmsd so I'm going to go with Roy woda longtime cmsd science teacher and his impact on me was profound because he reinvented reinvigorated renewed himself every year to the profession made sure that he stayed on top of the latest trends um and just was terrific with the students unfortunately our staff at Nathan Hill experienced tragic loss throughout the years so this year we decided to think about those staff members by having an angel tree so our angel tree is in honor of Nathan Hill Angels who are gone but not forgotten
039kindness impacts me on a daily basis at my school Bure dual Language Academy for our village kindness is definitely the norm from our warm and genuine admin to my amazing talented kind generous colleagues and to my students who sometimes stay after school to write surprise messages for me with love and kindness when I walk in and see messages from my students on the board or even Mrs Baker the music teacher leaves messages for me and my students full of love and kindness it really just gets the day off to a great start and makes me want to pay it forward kindness has impacted me because I had that one teacher that went above and beyond her role for me I now strive to be a teacher who models kindness kindness is contagious and that's why
040people even as young as my preschoolers are being taught to be a light for others congratulations to all of the cmsd teachers of Excellence on achieving this Monumental recognition we are all so very proud of this accomplishment and all of the things that you do every day to support Cleveland's children congratulations to all the amazing teachers who are getting an award today for supporting the kindland initiative you all are heroes you all are inspiring the next generation of leaders at cmsd keep doing the amazing work to inspire the next generation of Cleveland's leaders congratulations to our cmsd family for displaying kindness every day it is the work our Scholars do the work our Educators do to ensure we demonstrate heart every day and that we're kind every day thank [Music] you and we're honored to
041be a part of CMS s d all right thank you much all right and now we're going to move into our school Spotlight and that'll be the last part of the C report and this is principal Irvin from o Perry yes hi good evening good evening cmsd Board of Education members chair and CEO Dr Morgan my name is Britney Irvin I am the proud principal of Oliver H Perry this is my ninth year with cmsd I moved here in 2016 from New York City to join the aspiring principal program it would be a missed opportunity not to emphasize the importance of your leadership at this moment in time your leadership is crucial as we Face challenges to our core values of equity and inclusion and safe and supportive learning cultures we must protect our students
042from intimidation ensure they receive necessary special education services and Stand United against any attempts to dismantle public education I urge you to prioritize these issues to safeguard our students and ensure they receive the education they deserve I stand with you as an educator a school leader and a social justice advocate I look forward to now sharing with you who we are at o Perry including our achievements culture and climate and Equity measures and progress okay so we're just going to start with an overview of who we are we are a preschool through 8th grade school in colinwood here are our Dem Graphics um we are part of network 4 which is the redesigned schools So within our student population 20.3% of our students are students with disabilities this is actually report card data and so
043to date that number is 24.3% um our student makeup so 94.9% of our students are black our teacher makeup 35% of students are black and 65% white I also want to note that for our special education demographic the majority of students are in general education this has been an increase for us over the past eight years okay achievement so these measures uh these Stars will be familiar to you from the state report card system so our overall stars are two stars for achievement are one and three stars in progress so you're going to hear me emphasize progress throughout this presentation so we'll start with Ela proficiency which includes our subgroups uh the text is a little tiny here but you can see that our current overall proficiency for students is at 19% for our black
044students it is 20% and for our students with disabilities it is 0% that is what we are currently at and our goal are listed in that second column for the end of this school year and at the end of a three-year period which we make our school Improvement plan based on the image below that is how we can see if we are making progress as measured by the same assessment the OST um so for ELA based off of their scores from the last OST Administration we had 17.16% of students declining 51.4% holding steady so in the current band they were in and 38.369899 now we're looking at math uh same overview but our math overall for all students for proficiency is 6% for black students it is 6% and for students with disabilities it is
0450% that half band overview shows that 99.8% of students were declining 4842 were holding steady and 56 50% we're improving as of um our fall NWA we do see that we are on track to reach this goal so we have by the end of this school year that we will be 18% proficient for um black students and 11% for students with disabilities okay culture ending climate measures so our academic achievement plan was focused on tier one uh seal instruction we worked hard to establish thresholds for what a tier 2 and tier 3 student would look like in ancl support and what a menu of interventions would be so one of the assessments that we use to see progress comes directly from our students called the conditions for learning assessment so this is our fall results
046for grades 2 through 4 so one thing I do want to note for this school year and Miss Peak you know living in the neighborhood we had a charter school close in our area that our enrollment changed quite a bit uh 37% of our student population was new to our building this school year so there was a major change of culture as the result but we um did show that our overall CFL data for grades 2 through 4 we're at 79% in the category of social emotional Wellness where you can see the district is at 89% and this is how students report adequate to excellent this is their perception of their peers social emotional and problem solving skills and also how they are developing those skills and really in relation to grades attendance Behavior their
047attitudes toward School uh one thing that I want to note is since 2021 these numbers they were at 16 to 24% now we see ranges from 44 to this 79% of adequate to Excellence so we really are making significant progress uh we also want to acknowledge we need to be above and beyond what the district average is um one thing that we are going to do with our unique School structure we have a lower Dean so he supports grades prek through 4 he's going to meet with small students to unpack their responses from this assessment uh one of the areas they said they didn't feel as safe was the hallway and the staircase so he's going to co-create an action plan with them so that we can make some improvements by our spring assessment if
048you look a little deeper into that data you can see how students report by other subgroups so you can see right away that female students are reporting different indicators than their male students you can see second and third grade how there is some variation there um students with disabilities are reporting higher than their peers in these overall areas now we are at fifth through 8th grade a area of Celebration um we typically had ranges in these categories between 5 to 20% that were adequate and excellent where now we are at um 50 to 82% the area that we're going to look at is social emotional Wellness so we are currently at the 68% compared to the district 73 our upper Dean who is concentrated in grades 5 through eight is also going to do the
049same thing meet with small groups and student council to co-create a spring action plan here's digging a Little Deeper by grade level and by other identifi we can see the students are trending higher in how they report if they are a student with disability and that our female students are another group that we need to focus on all right our Equity measure critical data to support our core values um this overview here is our suspension data so our total enrollment to date is 288 students within that total amount 53 students have received a suspension this school year within that total enrollment amount 70 students enrolled at our school are students with disabilities 13 of those students have received a suspension so when we think about the overall percentage of students being suspended it's currently 18.4%
050in our school but it's 25% of students with disabilities so it is disproportionate um to the amount of total enrollment I will note that in 2017 when I started at o Perry the suspension rate was 37% um so we have worked very hard to decrease this but we still have work to do areas of focus and you get to see our beautiful kiddos and Miss Ryan our fifth and sixth grade math and science teacher here um these are the four areas that our school Improvement plan is uh garnered around so for ELA we are focused on implementing new curriculum with Fidelity that has been a district supported process where we have been able to bi-weekly check our classrooms with look fors we also are now in this place Quarter Two we started with our small
051group and struction so teachers are really using the data that they are gathering from the new curriculum to be able to support smaller groups of students in their learning for math we are focused on the major work of the grade um it can be easy sometimes in math to focus on fluency skills that students need and forget that the rigor and the conceptual work in their grade is key to their success in the next grade so we took time in professional Learning and Development with teachers to make sure that was the focus and then how are they leveraging small group instruction to support students School climate we've talked about the universal screener that we're using but that is coupled with instruction so it's not enough to test children and see where they land but what
052are you going to actually do about it so at our school we have seal instruction that's part of our morning meeting advisory really it's embedded into learning because these are skill skills students need regardless um tier two and three thresholds with the menu of interventions and progress monitoring so what does it look like if you're maybe a student who gets an office referral or you have um a repeat Behavior what's in place for you what does that system of support look like and then engagement so we have monthly newsletters from each grade level that share with families what is the learning focus of the month what are the celebrations happening and what the instructional strategy that they can try at home with their child so some celebrations um in the past two years we've decreased
053suspensions by 11% our CFL data is progressing over time in social emotional learning for our upper grades 5 through eight we are on track to reach our K through three um AAP goal which is our early literacy goal our fall to winner Benchmark data is in so we have some great celebrations for our first grade we had nine students move from high risk to medium and low and we had 26 second graders move from high risk to medium and low uh we are also on track for our implementation goals with the hmh curriculum and we have 20% of our families connected to our powerhub which is our electronic grade book I just want to extend to you to visit at any time um Dr Morgan visited last spring he really celebrated our culture and the
054progress that we are making but we encourage you to see for yourself what makes our school special thank you for your time any questions thank you any discussion from board members Mr bips hey good afternoon thank you for the presentation um I did have a question around not so much of a question but maybe Jess can you kind of go into a little bit of the work that you guys did to um see such a big decrease in the number of suspensions I think you said 11% over the last couple years but since I think you said 2018 it was even a bigger um drop in those suspensions and I I know that I assume that that impacts the um young people's academic performance as well as if they're in school more regularly so is
055there anything in particular that went into um keeping our young people in school yes thank you for that question um we did a partnership with our Cleveland teachers union called the restorative practice pilot it started in 2018 so we actually spent two years as a school being trained um through the international restorative practice Institute our chapter chair now is the Train the trainer for other teachers within Cleveland so we do proactive circles we Circle up we have conflict in our school we don't just send you out the door you have to sit down you have to answer five questions um those five questions live on everybody's ID it's going to tell you what to do and you're going to feel confident as an adult in our school to go through this process uh we also
056do this with adults so if adults are having conflict it works in the same way we do it with parents um we' really learned a lot from the pandemic of how you can use zoom like that maybe the conflict you're not quite ready for the impr space but you could open up this alternative and you could really get some answers to how do we make this right how do we repair the harm that has been caused um so I really attribute a lot of it to the restorative justice practices but I also think our two Dees in our school are a huge support to this culture having like a concentrated like culture celebrator a person who is just really supporting kids in small group they do things like check in check out um one thing
057you'll see if you visit is like kids coming to an adult with a folder that might be a tier 2 kid who has unique goals that they're checking in with an adult about they're proud to show you like here's how many points I got today I walked away from a conflict using a peaceful problem solving strategy so things like that they just added up to give skills alternative to causing harm they had the strategies they needed Dr Shar um thank you for your presentation and uh and thanks for talking about some of the uh strategies that you're working on um I have a question about those two slides that talk about the U Ela and math um achievement you you you touched upon um how um your students are on track to meet the the
0582025 goal um which is rather impressive I mean going from single digits to double digits is incredibly impressive um but um but then you know it's also um critical that going from you know 15 18% to the 40% is a significant jump in two years what kinds of um strategies and plans do you have for making sure that actually does happen that's a good question so the way that our team has looked at what we are doing now is we're laying the foundation where this work can only go up one of the big things for the hmh um curriculum implementation for us as a schools we needed a curriculum that gave us the resources to meet what the standard is asking for the teachers that are with me now and the teachers that come into
059our system will have that resource that's not going to go away so that foundation will not change the students may change but our approach and our strategies are now there the tools we have in our toolkit aren't going to go away so I think that that allows for us to go from 15 to 30 to 45% um I do really I think our new CEO has really held us to a very rigorous standard so I think we are being asked to meet that expectation and when you ask people to do those things they'll rise to that occasion so I do think that we are capable of meeting it does that answer your question yeah good job thank you absolutely yeah again really come oh Perry we're happy to have you have a great night everyone
060thank [Applause] you all right uh this evening we have six resolutions in the areas of Finance academics and equity and culture that will be presented to the board for discussion only the board will be asking to consider the adoption of these resolutions at our February 25th board business meeting Dr Morgan would you please present these resolutions yes first we have our finance resolutions 5.01 authorizing the acceptance of a gift from Martha Holden jinnings foundation and authorizing the CEO to spend the funds in accordance with the terms and conditions of the gift with this resolution the board will be accepting a gift from the Martha Holden Jennings foundation in the amount of $3,000 for a book vending machine at Waverly School thank you is there any discussion from the board all right all right we have
061one academic resolution 6.01 authorizing the uh Cleveland Municipal School District to enter into a primary service agreement with the educational service center of Northeast Ohio as provided by Ohio Revis code 43 with this resolution the board will be authorizing the school district to enter into a another banal primary service agreement with the educational service center of Northeast Ohio this is a routine banal action by the board this agreement is for the 2526 and 26 27 school years the list of services is set forth in the resolution and include in service and continuing education programs for district Personnel curriculum Services research and development programs academic instruction and assistance in the provision of special accommodations and classes for students with disabilities the cost of these Services is $650 cents per student based on the district's enrollment and
062is deducted from The District's State Foundation payments the education center of Northeast Ohio has asked the district to return the executed agreement by March 13 2025 the SE will then file the agreement with the Ohio Department of Education and Workforce by July 1 2025 as required by state law any discussion from board members all right thank you the next four resolutions are equity and cultural resolutions 7.01 are author is authorizing the employment of teaching non-teaching and school-based administrative staff is a routine monthly resolution authorizing a total of 49 new hires this month the details which are set forth in exhibit a attached to the resolution 7.02 authorizing the reclassification of employees there's a routine monthly resolution authorizing the reclassification of a total of 11 employees this month the details which are set forth in the
063exhibit a attached to the resolution 7.03 accepting the retirements resignations and other separations of employees this is a routine monthly resolution accepting a total of 53 separations of employees this month the details which are set forth in exhibit a attached to the resolution in 7.04 authorizing the issuance of limited contracts for differential positions and payment of additional earned compensation to employees this also is a routine monthly resolution authorizing limited contracts for differentials and payment of additional compensation to a total of 59 employees this month the details which are set forth in exhibit a attached to the resolution thank you Dr Morgan is there any discussion for board members all right that concludes the presentation of the resolutions on tonight's agenda is there any old business any new business the next regular board meeting will be
064a board business meeting on Tuesday February 25th at 6:30 p.m. at hi School 7901 Halley Avenue the chair will now entertain a motion that the board enter into executive session for the purpose of considering the appointment and employment of public employees and officials preparing for negotiations with public employees concerning their compensation or the terms and conditions of their employment and confirming with attorneys concerning disputes involving the Board of Education that are the subject of pending or imminent Court action thank you Mr Stockdale please call the role on this motion Miss elod yes Mr bips yes Mr bricks yes Mrs Jones yes Reverend Jones yes Mrs Peak yes Dr Shar yes Mrs Welch motion passes with eight votes thank you the board will now move into executive session following executive session the board will briefly return
065to this room to conduct some further business [Music] you go to the website you type in the access code and you're in your kids pictures are there and you can easily I have a kids at two different schools you can easily switch from school to school and keep up on top of it everything's right there like everybody always has their phone with them so you can easily access it to your phone it's a relief for me knowing that my child has the best chance that they can and knowing every day they wake up they can go to school and you know take advantage of the day [Music] your lettuce is popping [Music] the good thing about am like that [Music] for [Music] say and spell your name for me okay now whenever you're ready okay
066Nelle Campbell officer Patrice Evans hello I'm Adam Goodall his name is LS Kumba Lu CBA junor I've been with the district now 24 years8 years 15 16 years total 28 years in the district if I had to name a superhero that represented our safety officers it would definitely be Batman because all we have to do do is put the light up and they're going to come and help us out they it's all like the flash right it is just immediately um you know something happens and they are working on it right away Mighty Mouse compare it with Mighty Mouse he moves quick he's fast he's speedy and he always saves the day I worked a lot with kids in the neighborhood and I really got a real passion helping the kids I know my father
067a long time ago he was a security officer and my mother was a bus driver for cmsd so I'm part of of like a legacy family and I started being assistant coach at wrestling at Lincoln West and then one day I asked one of the lead officers hey this job seems cool you know can you can you help me out I've been doing it ever since then they trust me the kids they they come to me they trust me with stuff they may not even tell their parents even their teachers they just they they trust me I enjoy it I'm I'm blessed to be a part of their life and you know it's really a blessing when they come back to you say Miss Campbell um I'm working here look this is my lady this
068is my baby and you know just to see the positive things they doing and I really love the ones that come back that works for CSD I love my position I always told them I said when you come back I want you to come back as my white shirt I want you to come back as my boss so I need you to do everything you could do oh miss C I want to be your boss I said I'll be pleasure it'll be a pleasure for you to become my boss so yeah [Music] welcome back to another exciting episode of The District dish I am so glad to be here at John Hay Cleveland School of science and medicine with these wonderful Scholars I see them in their white coat uh so excited to hear from
069them and their experiences and looking forward to diving in you know here at the district dish we tell cmsd stories one dish at time so with that said let's get a chance to meet some of our Scholars my name is Camila and I'm a junior my name is Esther and I'm a 12th grader my name is Elijah and I am a 12th grader all right what is your favorite downtime activity I don't get a lot of downtime activity so um I will will so every morning I work out uh whether that is like just going to the gym like I did this morning or yesterday doing a run that that is a time just to kind of Center myself ground myself before starting the day um but I I love just when I don't have
070anything to do which is very rare but uh I just love to just relax uh catch up on TV I don't get a chance to watch a lot of TV cuz my day start real starts really early and then a lot of times I get in at like 10 or 11 o'clock at night so I may get 30 minutes of TV to watch and it's like okay got to go to bed and start it over again so on days where I have nothing to do I just love to just relax um um and um that's that's probably my favorite activity what what are your favorite downtime activities um I would say um when I do have the chance uh I would say playing the piano which is like my hobby it like relieves my stress
071like from school like outside of school and yeah W that's amazing um I would say running track I run track and I'm day in day out all through the year running track are you cross country uh uh short I do short distance and I hurdle as well oh so um let's go yeah it doesn't feel like it when I'm doing it but that is my favorite downtime activity yeah uh I personally don't consider basketball as a downtime downtime activity it's more like work so the only downtime downtime activity I really get to do is uh play video games I've been playing Black Ops 6 recently okay yeah I'm I'm into video games too I have a Nintendo switch have a Xbox um yeah so yeah I like that a ton of uh uh games on
072my uh phone that I love to play that's another thing on my down time can also create stress cuz you know on some days when you have nothing to do you realize and I'm speaking for myself like I now spent hours playing this video game so it gets like that yeah sorry by by any chance do you want to tell us what your favorite game is my favorite video game I love anything in the Mario series CA I I was so when I was younger there was no Nintendo out yet um like when when I was a real young kid we had Atari and so then when the first Nintendo came out of course the Mario Brothers game and I enjoyed it and then I remember Super Nintendo and finishing that I remember the original
073Mario Kart so anytime that they could have any Mario anything I'm there for it um same thing on the Sega side uh which you can get it for other um other game uh Brands uh but the uh Sonic the Hedgehog so really old school type of games like that so love Mortal Kombat played it uh played a few versions of it so so considering the threats con constantly presented to schools around the country what precautions have been taken or are being taken to ensure the safety of schools in our district yeah that is a great question one of the things that is always top of mind for me our number one strategic priority in um for our district is is safe and supportive schools and a safe and supportive culture um and so we're constantly
074working to think about ways we can make the school safe of course this year we have our new cell phone free zones um which as I've been going into schools and even talking to Scholars and actually a lot of them said a lot of positive things about it now there are things we can still learn and things that Scholars want us to um consider uh but that's a way that is helping us keep schools safe uh we are almost at the process of doing a new badging system and I'm really excited about that we've been um asking uh that I've been asking our team to do to help us make our high schools and eventually all of our schools more safe to know who's in the building in terms of you know swiping in and
075out of the building so that's coming and the team has been working really hard on it um so those are things we've been doing we also work really closely with the city so I was in a meeting this morning meeting with the mayor's office uh talking about how do we make the what surrounds the school safer um when I've been meeting doing these small group lunches with groups of students and it's been interesting for the most part kids when we ask kids to rate their school on one to five of how safe their schools are most kids gave their School a high rating on safety um they gave the district a high rating on safety but they mentioned the neighborhood as an area that they don't feel safe or coming to and from school so
076those are is we want to work with the the the city on on making sure it's safe um and then of course we have we have metal detectors in all of our our high schools um not only in all of our high schools in every single one of our buildings and that keeps a lot of things out of our schools we see things of people trying to get things into the schools and it stops it and so um you know those are things that we're doing to really make sure our Scholars are safe um and that's top of mind for us I just had a quick question so you said uh the new badge system will that go for students and uh teachers as as well or just teachers it's going to be for students
077yeah part teachers already have a badge uh we knew we have now a badge system also for volunteers so when there are people who don't work in uh who aren't teachers or staff in the school but they're a volunteer they have to have a certain badge to get in and out of the schools but this will be for students and so uh it'll be I know most students have an ID but we're going to be moving more more towards a required ID system and a required swiping in so that when students go in we actually know that they're in the building safely Dr Morgan what do you hope uh students will get out of to get more opportunity fund uh so I'm excited now because the way we restructured it uh every school will get
078dollars and because every school is different the school can determine and the the the scholars in that school the teachers in that school can determine what's best for that school so that's going to be really helpful when we saw uh in the earlier iteration of it there were uh certain schools that were um mainly going out for the opportunity and we wanted to make sure more Scholars can uh get the opportunity from it but uh we want to learn from it uh this you know the nice thing about hearing the feedback about bringing it back is that we can always bring something back but also make it better so as we do this I expect it to get better and for us to learn more and evolve um but to know that we have 300
07961 applications it just makes me excited I know we won't be able to fund all of those but uh that is exciting um that there's a lot of interest well uh this has been an amazing discussion um once again just really appreciate all that you guys are doing I'm so proud of you guys um you know the work that you guys are doing and you you plan to do just continue to keep going uh High School is challenging and when you get to College it will be even more challenging and life can be challenging but as long as you remember uh that with resilience and hard work the road is yours so just keep going um and know that you have a team of people support uh so uh this was another episode of The
080District dish uh was so happy to be here with our amazing Scholars uh Camila Esther and Elijah join us again next time for another episode of The District dish where we're bringing you cmsd stories one dish at a time [Music] IET scratching on micone [Music] for you go to the website you type in the access code and you're in your kids pictures are there and you can easily I have a kids at two different schools you can easily switch from school to school and keep up on top of it everything's right there like everybody always has their phon with them so you can easily access it to your phone it's a relief for me knowing that my child has the best chance that they can knowing every day they wake up they can go to
081school and you know take advantage of the [Music] day e e e back in public session the chair will now entertain a motion to adopt a resolution authorizing the 3-day suspension of a school-based administrator Dr Morgan any explanation of this resolution yes this resolution is to authorize the 3day suspension of a school-based administrator for violation of District policies procedures and rules is there any discussion from board members Mr Stockdale will you please call the role Miss elod yes Mr Bops yes Mr Briggs yes Mrs Jones yes Reverend Jones yes Mrs Peak yes Dr Shar yes Mrs welcha yes motion passes with eight votes thank you the resolution passes the chair will now entertain a motion to adopt Dr a resolution authorizing the one-day suspension of a non-teaching employee thank you Dr Morgan any explanation on
082this resolution this resolution is to authorize the one-day suspension of a non-teaching employee for violation of District policies procedures and rules is there any discussion from board members Mr Stockdale will you please call the role Miss elod yes Mr bips yes Mr Briggs yes Mrs Jones yes Reverend Jones yes Mrs yes Dr Shar yes Mrs Welch motion passes with eight votes the resolution passes the chair will now entertain a motion to adopt a resolution authorizing the 5-day suspension of a non-teaching employee thank you Dr Morgan any explanation on this resolution yes this is a resolution to authorize the 5day suspension of a non-teaching employee for violation of District policies procedures and rules there any discussion from the board Mr stock will you please call the role Miss elod yes Mr Bops yes Mr Briggs yes
083Mrs Jones yes Reverend Jones yes Mrs Peak yes Dr Shar yes Mrs welcha the motion passes with eight votes the resolution passes the chair will now entertain a motion to adopt a resolution authorizing the one-day suspension of a non-teaching employee second Dr Morgan any explanation on this resolution this resolution is to authorize the one-day suspension of a non-teaching employee for violation of District policies procedures and rules is there any discussion from board members Mr Stockdale will you please call the role Miss elot yes Mr Bops yes Mr Briggs yes Mrs Jones yes Reverend Jones yes Mrs Peak yes Dr Shar yes Mrs welcha motion passes with eight votes the resolution passes is there any other new business there being no further business before the board that the chair will now entertain a motion to adjourn
084this board work session so moved thank you hearing no objection this meeting is adjourned have a good night thank you