CorpusRecord 2139

CMSD Board of Education Meeting - December 10, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Cleveland Metropolitan School District
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Cleveland, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,701 words · about 38 min
Collected
2026-05-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e for e for e good evening this business meeting of the Board of Education of the Cleveland Municipal School District district will come to order Mr Stockdale will you please call the role miss elod here Mr bips Mr Briggs here Miss Jones Mr Jones miss lebrone here miss Peak Dr Shar Mrs welcha here there are eight members present thank you I ask everyone who wishes to rise and participate in the pledge of aliance flaged States thank you the chair will now entertain a motion to approve the minutes of the board leadership development sessions of November 22nd and November 23rd and the board work session of December 3rd 2024 so move second thank you all in favor signify by saying I I any opposed the eyes have it the minutes are approved all right as many

002of you have heard or at least probably noticed during roll call uh we are pleased to welcome three new members to the board of Education this evening um over the course of the past week mayor Justin bib filled three vacancies on the board by appointing and administering the oath of office to Jerry bips Ivory Jones III and Caroline Peak Mr bips is a graduate of John Marshall High School and holds a Bachelor of Science from the University of Toledo he works as Juvenile Detention alternative initiative coordinator for kyoga County Juvenile Court he is a parent of four children one of whom is a cmsd graduate and three of whom are current cmsd students Mr bips is also deeply engaged with Grassroots community service in addition to serving as a wrestling coach and volunteering at football

003games in the community he's also an active member of the W 16 Club he's a lifelong Clevelander and lives in the West Park neighborhood Reverend Jones serves as pastor of Grace Missionary Baptist Church he is the parent of three adult children who attended CMS SD schools Reverend Jones attended both the Cleveland and East Cleveland Public Schools and is a graduate of East Cleveland's Shaw High School and went on to study commercial arts and graphic design at Koga Community College and the Cleveland Institute of Art he lives in the union miles neighborhood and last but not least Miss Peak recently retired after 21 years as public service manager of the Collingwood branch of the Cleveland Public Library she previously worked as program coordinator for the Cleveland Summit on education Miss Peak is a longtime School District

004volunteer serving on a number of committies including the community oversight committee the bond accountability commission the superintendent's Advisory Board and several PTA and school Community councils she's the parent of three adult children who attended cmsd schools Miss Peak holds an associate degree from kyoga Community College a Bachelor of Arts from Myers University University and a master of Library science from Kent State University she lives in the Collinwood neighborhood of Cleveland welcome Mr bips Reverend Jones and Miss Peak we all look forward to working with you and we're so excited to have you here for your first board meeting I'd like to invite each of you to say a few words we'll go in alphabetical order Mr bips ah I will be first um thank you all so much for the introduction I really appreciate it

005I'm I'm so blessed and grateful to be able to be a part of this board I I do realize the impact that a a great Public School District can have on a community and the city um and I I just want to help be a part of the work that um helps Drive our our district in the right direction to continue to uh um educate the best kids in the country Reverend Jones all right thank you to the chair and to our CEO and to the entire board um Pastor Ivory Jones III uh in the community for over 30 years pastoring and um um um and just thanking God for my family and my wife who was with me today our children was reared up in the Cleveland school system and we're excited about being

006a part of um working with this team uh to help uh do what we can to enhance and Advance our school system um the best we can um just grateful to be here miss peek good evening everyone my motto is I live a life of service and this is just uh a continuation of that as uh I've worked uh for several years in supporting not only students but our community and I really feel that uh people don't know care how much you know until they know how much you care and so we still want to make sure that we're uh helping to lessen the struggles of the school system by making sure that we continue with the progress that's already been started and we just want to uh so proud to to have this opportunity

007to give back to the community to continue that life of service thank you thank you all and welcome again all right next I'm pleased to introduce Dr Warren Morgan to present this evening's CEO report Dr Morgan thank you so much chair elot and it's great to be here this evening I know this is our last board meeting of the calendar year before we go on a much well-deserved holiday break so what ever you celebrate this holiday or if you don't celebrate anything it's a time of reflection as we come on the end of the year um and being grateful uh I always talk about opening up with an attitude of gratitude uh for Life uh for those who are in our lives and for the work that we get to do to serve so hearing

008so much about Service uh that is definitely the attitude I'm entering into and hope that we have that on top of all of our minds as we enter into this break a few things that I want to share uh with the board on uh this uh CEO uh report so a couple of things are just tactical so I have a couple of announcements and then uh Ting up a little bit more of our work around long-term planning uh because we've been talking about this for a while and as we enter into 2025 this is going to be a big part of the work that we're doing not only as a cmsd team but as a board and we'll be talking about it more during board meetings so first and foremost uh talking about the holiday

009season these are some of the things we're doing districtwide and of course there are so many things that are taking place in and out of our schools so check with your school uh leader and uh your your school calendar to find out what holiday events are taking place at your own building uh but I'm excited uh to uh be participating in our All City Winter concert tomorrow evening that's at 6:30 p.m. at the East Technical High School uh I was practicing with our Scholars I dusted off my tuba and was practicing with the scholars today and really looking forward to our concert uh have three three uh numbers I'll be doing with the concert band and one number I'll be doing with our Orchestra so really looking forward to that uh so please come out

010uh and check us out uh tomorrow at East Tech at 6:30 our Scholars have been working really hard I believe it's not only our bands but we have our choirs and I believe um uh some dance uh performances as well and so thankful to all of the Educators who help with that uh and also to Jeffrey Allen who leads our um Fine Arts uh districtwide we also have uh the winter solstice uh with the ures that are taking place at uh the executive Grill uh that party is on December 19th and then we also have the East Tech horiculture Holiday sale so this is all taking place at East Tech uh where poinsettas are on sale we have red and pink and white and some that are speckled and that is uh this Friday so

011uh come check out these events and these are some things that are taking place District wide also as we enter into this season it is the season for sometimes inclement weather which is always a you know very tough days and very challenging days to figure out what what we're going to do around uh calling school or whether we'll be open or not I want to remind everyone that we do have our inclement weather protocol so we gathered all those F FAQs in feedback and we have a protocol that is posted on our website uh the decision is not uh exact science uh so there's a lot that goes into that but this protocol talks a little bit about our decision-making process but one thing I remember hearing feedback last year when we called a snow

012day uh pretty late in the morning I think we had called it at one point around like 6:00 a.m. or when all the announcements came out some of them were as late as 7: a.m. was to make sure we can uh notify our families our Scholars as well as our Educators as soon as possible so on Thursday even when we had the weather report we announced the day before on Wednesday that we intended to be open and so where possible we will make those decisions early so that families Educators staff can make a decision uh and plan accordingly so where we can we will be getting that information to you sooner and as always in the event that we have to make a decision we will try to do that by 5:30 at the latest

013uh but as we did on uh last Wednesday we made a decision the day before put that announcement out uh and we will uh try to intend to get that information as soon as possible but check out our inclement weather guide I know for those families that called with issues uh several of them I spoke to on the phone and followed up with calls uh so we appreciate your calls and your feedback it only makes us uh better uh one of my personal core values and one of the things that we work on is continuous Improvement so that's all we can do and all we can ask of our Scholars uh is to get better uh so that's just some information please check that out on the website so now on to long-term planning so

014one of the things we've been talking about for a while is long-term planning and this is a big part of the work that we're going to be doing in 2025 the definition for long-term planning is twofold uh making sure we increase student experience while also putting our district on a path to financial sustainability uh so while we're doing long-term planning uh those those are the goals of long-term planning increasing the student experience while also putting our district on a path to financial sustainability and I'll talk a little bit about the work we've been doing we got a chance to present this information to our board um not too long ago and we'll be discussing them more during our public board meetings uh just to make sure we had this information out so when think about

015the student experience there's many different things and many different inputs that we look at we look at uh student input staff feedback uh we look into Community input when we think about what a vibrant student experience looks like we also look into best practice research uh and then we also uh look at the experts around the field in terms of what other districts are doing and this is work that every system when I talk to many superintendent CEOs chancellors of school districts across the country uh this is work that uh they're all looking at to make sure that students have the most vibrant uh student experience as possible while also thinking about the district finances uh thinking about footprint and also thinking about enrollment all of these things are combined together and I'm going to

016talk a little bit about uh some of these inputs that we're looking into for student experience when we think about the experience of our Scholars it's not just what happens in a moment in time we have to think about the experience of our Scholars within a 13 sometimes plus year span from the moment we we our Scholars enter us uh in prek sometimes as early as prek to the moment they graduate the experiences that we curate as a system uh and the student experience we provide them all is about the work that we're doing to provide our Scholars uh the opportunities to be vibrant uh citizens post graduating for high school so we're thinking about this throughout the stages it's not just a high school strategy it's not just a preas strategy it is a

017holistic prek through 12 Continuum of strategies of thinking about that profile of a graduate and those are the things that we're working on as a as a system and making sure we provide that high quality experience when we think about the student experience these are the four key elements now there are many different inputs that we look into but there are four key elements that we look at when we think about a student Experience One career Pathways for postsecondary Readiness that's not just in our high schools career Pathways for post-secondary Readiness as I'll explain in a moment even begins in our elementary schools uh and we'll talk about what that looks like opportunities for our Scholars to explore their co-curricular passions and making sure that we're providing those co-curricular experiences that allow our students to

018explore uh supported teachers and staff because it's our Educators that are delivering the student experience and if our if our educators are not feeling supported if our educators are not feeling connected uh we will not be able to deliver that high quality experience so we must look at the experience of our Educators and our staff and then also making sure we have buildings that are worthy of delivering the highquality experience so let's look at these elements of the student experience first when we think about post-secondary readiness it is looking at uh making sure one that we have safe and welcoming schools I just had the opportunity to have lunch and learns with several of our High School Scholars and hearing from our High School Scholars that many of them actually feel that their school is

019safe and they feel that cmsd is safe what they talked about were anecdotes of getting to and from school which of course is still part of their school experience but when we when we met with our Scholars uh and doing these lunch and learns we asked uh Scholars on a scale of one to five how safe do they feel they building with five being high and one being low uh and there were quite a few fours and fives uh so that means it our the work that our Educators our Safety and Security team is doing in our schools is uh is is working but we they also still talked about instances of getting to school instances of after school that we have to continue to still work on and we're working with the city and

020many other people to make sure we deliver on that but also a post-secondary ready uh curriculum is high quality curriculum we already make are making sure that we have a high quality Ela curriculum our schools have high quality math curriculum uh curricula within our schools we talk about access to Algebra 1 in 8th grade so access to algebra 1 in 8th grade we know that that's a gatekeeper and so that's really important that our Scholars have access to Algebra 1 right now of all of our elementary schools I think we have 63 right now only five of those uh elementary schools are offering algebra one and so we have to think about how do we expand that experience across the board exposure to stem exposure to College and Career Pathways so that when students are

021graduating from high school they have a diploma and a credential that they can graduate with a work-based learning opportuni I know we're working with the mayor's office to ensure that every cmsd scholar has access to work-based learning experiences but this is all part of a post-secondary Readiness uh a highquality post-secondary ready curriculum we have pockets of this within our system there's some schools that are doing this well um and then we have some schools that are not able to offer this and so we have to look at how do we make sure all students have access to this at scale we we must talk about the co-curricular uh activities and Passions so what does it look like to have access to playing an instrument so as I mentioned I'm I'm playing with our Scholars and

022there's some of our Scholars who do play an in instrument but right now the way our our Fine Arts are set up we have some students that learn to play an instrument early on but they can't continue with on when they go to High School uh because it's not offered uh or vice versa their kids that want to uh do choir do band uh but they can't do it their school doesn't offer it and one of those lunch and learns I was meeting with a young lady from Davis and she said when I chose a school my parents chose a school that they thought was safe and was a good school but I don't want to go into Aviation she said I really want acquire uh and my school doesn't offer that and so we

023have to think about these other co-curricular passions how do we allow our Scholars to explore that as well um how do we have access to uh Sports within our schools foreign language at a certain uh level so their students can uh learn a foreign language these are all things that we must look at in the student experience when we thought think about a supported staff right now we have several I wouldn't even say small schools uh one of our uh one of our partners who we were talking about uh talking with said it's almost so small that in some cases can't even operate uh we have some schools that are not able to offer uh even the Core Curriculum uh we have some or some elements of the Core Curriculum just because they're staff they

024don't have the Staffing work where it's it's needed uh we have some schools that there's a teacher that only teaches they're the only teacher that teaches their their uh great level subject so when we talk about Team Planning or uh teachers actually taking different parts of the lesson to lesson plan or co- te we're not able to do that in schools where there's a teacher that they're the only teacher in the building that teaches second grade so what does it look like to make sure that staff have the support that they need not only the support that we're providing as a syst that their school leader is providing but also that there's enough uh work within the system that they can actually collaborate and work together uh these are things that we have to look

025at when we're thinking about uh supported teachers and staff and there're uh parts of that that we need to be providing as a system but after that when we provide what we need to for uh for our Educators we need to get out their way and let them do their work uh and that's when we talk about the autonomy of doing the job we have many brilliant Educators how do we support them with the work they need to do so they could do their brilliant job and we can get out the way way so this is the work that we need to think about when we think about supported Educators and staff and then finally buildings that are conducive for uh learning uh some of this is 21st century uh learning spaces making sure that

026there's adequate technology uh making sure that our buildings have air conditioning uh they're climate controlled we just did a facility study there was a part of this facility study that was done prior and then we just did another part of the facility study I think on 40 of our buildings to give each of our buildings a building condition score to look at Not only was it recently renovated uh or or not what where actually the these buildings uh land when it comes to uh their building conditions and so we'll be looking forward to to getting that information and and sharing that as part of how we can look at this full uh experience and I know we don't have that information yet but those are different things we're looking at so that we can look

027at all of our building more holistic all right so when you put together all these elements of the student experience it talks about making sure we have well-rounded graduates uh graduates that have a high quality curriculum were able to explore their their their passions uh were in a safe uh and well-run uh environment and then also had Educators that were loving and working well together uh so this is the work that we're doing together and we need to do with the community when we think about this student experience and I shared some anecdotes not of we have pockets across our system where different parts of these elements of the student experience are hitting uh but we don't have enough where all of the uh the elements of the student experience are hitting and we want

028to make sure we we capture that we also want to make sure we capture what goes into the choices that our families uh make when choosing a high school and making sure Scholars are well informed of those choices and have those options within their schools um so if you think about the definition for long-term planning one part is student experience the other part is finances so there's a lot of work we've been doing to make sure that we could we can work on our finances uh we did our deficit reduction plan last year of course we had the levy and the bond uh there are future budget updates that we're thinking to support schools in a much more Equitable way but long-term planning is a big part of the work we could do collectively together

029uh with the boards uh the board will be voting on a our plan that we're putting forth to actually increase student experience while putting the district on the path to financial sustainability this is the definition we talked about what the goal of long-term planning is improve student experience and outcomes while achieving Financial sustainability many of you have already seen our 5-year forecast so grateful for the the levy uh and the bond uh that was just passed and this is the fiveyear forecast and our future outlook that we just looked at a few board meetings ago uh and was approved by this board so if you look at this over the next several years we end the year that's that bottom row we end the year with a positive balance that is what the uh state

030of Ohio asks of us asks us to end the year with the positive balance but when you start to look at school year 2728 we would be in the negative by $96 million if we do nothing uh so this work that we're doing now is to help us move forward uh and uh make this uh make our numbers better there other inputs uh you know there there's work we could do in terms of advocating for State uh uh you know more state aid in areas there's work that we can be doing to uh go after more dollars and those are all things that are on the table but the areas we're going to be mainly focusing on are the things within our locus of control and that is long-term planning the work we could be

031doing as a system to increase uh student experience or improved student experience while also thinking about our costs you've seen this chart uh the gray line going up are are uh expenses over time so expenses continue to grow uh with inflation and other things that happen over time the Blue Line are uh is the revenue that we actually bring in it flattens out uh the Le the levy has helped us uh it makes us that orange line uh so we are closing the Gap but we have more work to do and so we're hoping with long-term planning you will see the the gap between the orange and the gray close uh and that's the work we're going to be doing I ly together so what's the path forward uh 2025 is going to be busy

032there's a lot of work and many different inputs we can do to look at this um and there are many different inputs we will We we'll be looking at a big part of that is community input getting Community feedback um both through in-person meetings through uh virtual meetings uh through surveys uh we also want to have conversations with Educators and students uh sharing more information via our website uh there's also information that was done before uh when uh we did processes like this and then also engaging our board along the way because it's our board uh that makes the decision ultimately and so this is our path forward it is not easy uh work uh and I will I will name that there will probably be many different ideas and thoughts into how we do

033this and we must take the inputs that we have and choose the best path forward uh that doesn't mean that that will be everything that gets taken into consideration uh but we want to be data informed uh we want to learn from history and the past uh and then also look to the Future and we've talked about the S the future of cmsd and think about the experience we want to provide all of our Scholars um so more information will be coming in our January uh uh in January 2025 uh more information will be coming out and then at uh board meetings we'll be sharing more updates uh as well as engaging the board along the way so uh with that there any questions are there any questions from board members Miss Welch thank you

034chair um thank you for the transparency on the long-term planning process there's a lot that the team needs to do so appreciate that the clarity as we think about financial sustainability does the team have sort of a working definition of what we're working backwards from there so if I think about page 16 right like are we focused on getting that line five getting the red to black or is it let's solve for sorry the page before that um or are we focused on kind oh oh you're talking about this one right here sorry um or are we more focused on the 27 28 28 29 sort of bottom line cash balance and I ask that because when I think about sustainability I'm thinking about that line side right yeah yeah yeah that's a great question

035um right now what we're doing is we're looking at all the inputs and actually seeing what's feasible um in some cases when you look at these numbers I mean 96 million is a big number uh and I've heard uh people say before that that that's simple you know um you know either close schools or do this and do that we've looked at even modeling you know there's only a certain set of numbers even when you're talking about uh School impacts I think it's like one to2 million so you're thinking about6 M uh $96 million there 1 to2 million per school scho you know closing schools is not going to close that Gap um there's not enough if we're talking about increasing the student experience um we can't necessarily cut our way through all the programming

036for this and so it really needs to be a multifaceted approach where we're looking at the student experience we want to provide looking at those inputs and looking at our finances and we will be coming back with more information about that uh it may look like there is a part one to this in terms of what we do and how far that takes takes us and then with some recommendations of what happens in the future other questions Miss Peak I'm just wondering uh when you talk about the student experience what role would the community or Community Partners play and helping us to achieve that yeah now that's a great question uh really taking in input and there's already a lot of input that we we've taken in when you think about the CEO search um

037which now almost was about uh well heading into yeah two years ago three uh three school years ago um we have the listen and learn tour that I did last fall um those are inputs that we got a lot of robust uh Community feedback on uh there's also feedback we get just from you know board meetings or things that we hear on the ground when I'm talking to students through the student advisory Council these lunch and learn so there's a lot of inputs we have so going to the community uh it's continuing to listen to the community in terms of open-ended question that the community may also have but it's also going to the community with ideas based on what we've heard in the past and seeing how that resonates and seeing what updates we

038have for them as well yes I was speaking in more particular to our philanthropic Community our churches our libraries and our other institutions uh Cleveland is uh is in abundance with our Cultural Arts uh appreciation and things of that nature so uh those kind of uh other organizations that are out there uh we you look into uh like after school programs or maybe opportunities for kids to have uh Hands-On learning experiences and things of that nature that's a great point and a great suggestion um of the different groups uh so we'll take note of that I also mentioned when we did the listen and learn tour we actually did break it up by different group face face groups our philanthropic groups our Sports leaders and so we could also be thinking about those different groups

039as we're going back to them and then I also hear from you uh behind your question that we're going to look into to you as well um where where might other resources be so I appreciate that Dr Morgan I have a question you talked a little bit about how um some schools don't have enough Staffing for teachers to be a part of a uh maybe a classroom level or a subject level team how we've got a you know what I would view as a severe shortage of Algebra 1 right across our K through eights can you speak to some of the context around how enrollment influences those situations because I don't want it to sound like people are making the you know I don't think that principles are like well I hate Algebra 1 but

040like helping people understand how the funding um that comes with each student impacts our ability to staff and to offer um different classes as we sort of think about how we make up for that and and fix some of those issues yeah great question and uh one that is complicated uh and I'll begin to answer that now and also we'll be sharing with you uh with the larger Community specifically these analytics because there's enrollment analytics um so I'll just State a few things that we know one um positive thing that is working for us is that enrollment within the system in terms of students who are choosing cmsd has been consistent over the last five years so the group of students roughly that are choosing cmsd is about consistent over the past five years and

041the same the group that are choosing uh private schools also charter schools has been consistent so it's not necessarily competition that is uh uh uh uh hitting our enrollment uh the the other thing we know that's a challenging thing is that birth rates are significantly down um birth rates are down not only within our city state country the world birth rates are down um and so we're we're seeing that and that is showing an enrollment trajectory that over time will continue to hit us and we have to think about that um as you know we get our dollars largely based on how many students we have in the building and we look at a high school so I was meeting with campus International High School and those kids were so brilliant they they had a

042PowerPoint presentation they had their different areas that they wanted to focus in on and one of the areas they focused in on was really around the student experience they said classes that they they can no longer have anymore uh you know not being able to have the foreign language one young lady was concerned she wouldn't be able to graduate with her IB uh diploma they also talk about staff that they see go and also they talked about a staff that has five preps because there's not that many staff I asked them how many students they have in their building 227 uh when campus International opened it was more than double of that and so what's happening over time where you don't have enough students in there school leaders are making choices and schools are making

043choices in terms of what we can offer and what we can do also on that example around Algebra 1 I know that we have one elementary school that is offering algebra one more two students qualify for it based on their NWA score and based on other um recommendations and the only reason why that element school is able to offer Algebra 1 is because it's co collocated with the high school so those students can actually take it with uh with high school students that is not the case in all of our schools and so this is the reality and our staff our school leaders are doing the best they can with the realities that are here and we need to put the wind at at their back one by defining the student experience we want for

044all kids we have to Define it we have not put our plant and flag or our our flag and planted it and said you know this is the student experience we want to make sure every scholar has uh and then also we need to be making these decisions in light of our current reality and future projections thank you any other discussion all right um I want to Echo Miss how and saying thank you for this um presentation and just note that this is going to be quite the task and quite the challenge ahead of us in 2025 I know that this board and the cmsd team are up for the challenge all right next we will have public participation during this segment of the business meeting we will hear all public comment on either agenda

045or non-agenda items this period of participation will be for persons who previously submitted the online request to speak form to address the board for up to 3 minutes each we will have a timer on each of the screens on either side to help folks keep time if anyone wishing to address the board has any written material that they would like to submit to the board please give it to Mr bitof over to my left raising his hand and he will distribute the material to the board again as usual we will limit each speaker to three minutes all right and today we have one speaker who signed up online Miss Roberta Cathcart Miss Cathcart okay all right hello and good evening my name is Roberta Cathcart and I am a special ed par professional at Joseph

046M Gallagher as a lot of you may know I attend these meetings to Advocate foras but this month I'm going to Pivot and advocate for all students especially scholars in special ed classrooms in Dr Morgan's last CEO Focus letter he says building a safe and supportive culture is at the core of our strategic priorities and that means listening to our Scholars but when teachers advocate for the students who can't speak for themselves teachers will first be told that children are being overidentified and um proceed to plop a child with special needs into any classroom where they see fit take for example a particular child in my classroom his response to any request is to First scream no then he'll either charge at the teacher or throw something if he's not doing that he's running around

047the classroom doing everything in anything to be disruptive so instead of actual teaching and learning happening we're managing the behavior of this one student the chaos usually causes the other kids to also act out and eventually at least one student gets hit in the face with a hard object this happens every single time the child is at school how is this fair is this what Equity is supposed to look like this child has four Professionals advocating for him his teacher his OT speech therapist and school psychologist six if you include school-based admin it is clear and obvious his current classroom is not the proper setting for him please tell me how one administrator who doesn't even know let alone has seen or met this child can Trump the data of an entire team who has

048worked closely with this child even his mother made a call to the special education department and their response let's get him a one-on-one because one more adult in our tiny classroom to add to the chaos is a great answer so are you really concerned about the kids is this truly a safe and supportive environment your are striving for I know that when I come to speak my stories are all anecdotal so what Mr Bert sloth is going to hand you is an invitation it's an invitation for you to come and witness the special education variety show the fifth period lunch in Galler's modular cafeteria is the time and place but you all are more than welcome to come for the pre-show and stay for an encore but wait this invite is actually a two for

049one deal you'll not only get an in-depth listening session but you'll also see for yourself how often some of our pairs are being bitten pinched spat upon etc etc the violence you'll witness will Astound you first graders as big as me with flailing legs and arms wrestling with any educator who tries to help them seems fitting in the new presidential Administration but these working conditions are neither safe nor supportive I hope you all consider coming to see it for yourselves maybe just maybe this will prompt you to do something that will actually help these kids who far too often are being overlooked and getting lost in the shuffle thank you miss cathart that concludes our public participation period next the board will consider the adoption of 11 resolutions in the areas of Board of Education

050finance and equity and culture the board discussed all but one of these resolutions at our November 6th work session excuse me our December work session the chair will now entertain a motion to adopt resolution 6.01 extending collectively bargained labor agreements between the Cleveland Municipal School District and its labor unions for the time period of July 1st 2026 through July June 30th 2027 thank you the board discussed this resolution on December 3rd Dr Morgan any further explanation yes over this past year the board of education has approved nine collective bargaining agreements with our employee unions each of these cbas is for a 2-year period from July 1st 2024 through June 30th 2026 with an extension for an additional Year from July 1st 2026 through June 30th 2027 condition on the district's ability to certify the availability

051of funds to pay for that thir year of the CBA since a 5-year forecast adopted by the board last month demonstrates the district's ability to certify the availability of the necessary funds to support that third year I'm asking that the board adopt this resolution extending each of our cbas for an additional year through June 30th 2027 thank you any discussion from board members hearing no discussion Mr Stockdale will you please call the role Miss elod yes Mr bips Mr Briggs yes Miss Jones yes Reverend Jens yes M lebrone yes Miss Peak yes Mrs welcha yes motion passed with eight votes thank you the resolution is adopted the chair will now entertain a motion to adopt the following three resolutions 7.01 adoption of the fiscal year 2026 2026 alternative tax budget of the Cleveland Municipal School

052District 7.02 authorizing participation in the kyoga county 2025 real property tax advance program and excuse me my list of resolutions just shut itself down 7.03 authorizing the distributions of resources to partnering Community Schools pursuant to issue 68 and issue 49 Second thank you these three are our finance resolutions which the board discussed at our December work session Dr Morgan any further explanation yes resolution 7.01 is a routine annual resolution whereby the board will be approving the requested fiscal year 2026 alternative tax budget to be filed with the kyoga county which which the county uses to determine 2025 tax bills the kyoga county budget office and fiscal office will review cmd's requests and make a final determination of tax rates and then the board will be asked in March or April of 2025 to approve the

053final rates the fiscal year 2026 alternative tax budget recommends 95.5 Ms resolution 7.02 is a routine annual resolution whereby the board again authorizes the district's participation in this tax advance program which enables the district to receive its real property tax receipts earlier than the otherwise scheduled setle settlement dates resolution 7.03 is a routine semiannual resolution under the Cleveland plan legislation adopted by the state legislature in 2012 and consistent with the is the issue 68 tax levy approved by the voters in 2020 and the issue 49 tax levy approved just left month our district distributes our local property tax dollars equal to 1.5 mil from the issue 68 and another .5 mil from issue 49 to our 11 partnering Community or charter schools with this resolution the board will be authorizing that the distribution of those

054partnering uh of the funds to those partnering schools of 2.0 Mills based on the local proper property taxes received from January 1 through June 30th 2025 thank you Dr Morgan any questions discussion from board members all right Mr stockdill will you please call the role Miss elod yes Mr bips yes Mr Briggs yes Miss Jones Reverend Jones yes Mrs lebrone yes Miss Peak yes Mrs welcha yes motion passed with eight votes thank you these resolutions are adopted the chair will now entertain a motion to adopt resolution 8.01 authorizing the CEO to issue a supplier contract agreement to energy cap in in order to maintain utility Management Services for the district beginning January 1st 2025 through January 1st 2026 not to exceed 96,5 184 thank you Dr Morgan any further explanation yes with this resolution the

055district will contract with energy cap and be able to build on our existing practices in support of an energy management plan with this plan the District can utilize energy cap software as a single Source platform for utilities that is flexible accurate and reliable in helping us make sense of energy and sustainability data in order to streamline the te the team's workflows managing utility bills from multiple sources can be a complex time consuming process streamlining data entry and validation reduces errors and duplicate dup uh duplicative entries saving us time and resources for more strategic energy management tasks thank you any discussion from board members Mr Stockdale will you please call the role Miss elott yes Mr bips yes Mr Briggs yes Miss Jones yes Reverend Jones yes Mrs lebrone yes Miss Peak yes Mrs welchel yes

056the motion passes with eight votes thank you the resolution is adopted the chair will now entertain a motion to adopt the following resolutions 9.01 authorizing the Cleveland Municipal School District to enter into an agreement with the Cleveland with the educational service center of the Western Reserve as provided by Ohio Revised Code 33138 45 and 9.02 expressing the intent to renew the sponsorship agreement with Citizens Academy Southeast so move second thank you these two are academic resolutions which the board discussed at our December work session Dr Morgan any further explanation of these resolutions yes with resolution 9.0 one the board will be authorizing the school district to enter into a service agreement with the educational service center of the Western Reserve for services provided to students in the passport program at the Metson bomb center located

057in giaga County this is a continuation of services that was previously built through the education service center of Northeast Ohio with resolution 9.02 the board will be expressing its intent to renew our school district's Community School sponsorship agreement with Citizens Academy Southeast and our reapplication process review the School received 129 points out of 150 points if the board adopts this resolution we will then negotiate a new contract with Citizens Academy Southeast to bring that to the board for your approval in the spring thank you any questions from board members Mr Stockdale would you please call the role Miss elod yes Mr bips yes Mr Briggs yes Miss Jones Reverend Jones yes Mrs LeBron yes Miss Pet speak yes Mrs Welch yes motion passes with eight votes thank you these two resolutions are adopted the chair

058will now entertain a motion to adopt the following four resolutions 10.01 authorizing the employment of teaching non-teaching and school-based administrative staff 10.02 authorizing the reclassification of employees 10.03 accepting the retirements resignations and other separations of employees and 10.04 authorizing the issuance of limited contracts for differential positions and the payment of additional earned compensation to employees thank you these four are our equity and talent resolutions which we discussed at our December work session Dr Morgan any further explanation yes with resolution 10.01 it authorizes 50 new hires resolution 10.02 authorizes the reclass reclassification of 34 employees resolution 10.03 accepts 102 separations of employees and resolution 10.04 authorizes limited contracts for differentials and payment of additional compensation to 246 employees fur further details of each resolution are set forth in the exhibit a attached to each resolution thank

059you any discussion from board members all right Mr stockill will you please call the role Miss elod yes Mr bips yes Mr Briggs yes Miss Jones Reverend Jones yes Mrs LeBron yes Miss Peak yes Mrs welcha motion passes with dat votes thank you these resolutions are adopted is there any old business is there any new business all right the next regular board meeting will be the 225 board organization meeting and work session on Tuesday January 14th at 6:30 p.m. at Garrett Morgan High School 4600 Detroit Avenue the chair will now entertain a motion that the board enter into to Executive session for the purpose of considering the appointment and employment of public employees and officials preparing for negotiations with public employees concerning the terms and conditions of their employment and conferring with attorneys concerning disputes

060involving the Board of Education that are the subject of pending or imminent Court action thank you Mr Stockdale please call the RO Miss elod yes Mr bips yes Mr Briggs yes Miss Jones Reverend Jones yes Mrs LeBron yes Miss Peak yes Mrs welcha yes motion passes with eight votes thank you the board will now move into executive session following executive session the board will return to this room to briefly conduct some further business [Music] your lettuce is popping [Music] smile right [Music] here good [Music] Power School honestly is a blessing you go to the website you type in the access code and you're in your kids pictures are there and you could easily I have a kids at two different schools you can easily switch from school to school and keep up on top of

061it everything's right there like everybody always has their phone with them so you can easily access it to your phone like get on power school this is a relief for me knowing that my child has the best chance that they can knowing every day they wake up they can go to school and you know take advantage of the day [Music] your lettuce is popping [Music] come on right [Music] here good thing about like [Music] Power School honestly is a blessing you go to the website you type in the access code and you're in your kids pictures are there and you could easily I have a kids at two different schools you can easily switch from school to school and keep up on top of it everything's right there like everybody always has their phone with

062them so you can easily access it to your phone like get on power school it's a relief for me knowing that my child has the best chance that they can knowing every day they wake up they can go to school and you know take advantage of the day [Music] for [Music] your lettuce is popping [Music] smile right [Music] here the good thing about amaz like [Applause] [Music] Power School all right the board is now back in public session the chair will now entertain a motion to adopt a resolution authorizing the 3-day suspension of a non-teaching employee so move thank you Dr Morgan any explanation on this resolution yes this resolution is to authorize the 3-day suspension of a non-teaching employee for violation of District policies procedures and rules any discussion from board members Mr Stockdale

063will you please call the role Miss elot yes Mr bips yes Mr Briggs yes Miss Jones robing Jones yes Mrs lebrone yes Mrs Peak yes Mrs Welch yes yeah motion passes with eight votes thank you the resolution passes as announced earlier the next regular board meeting will be the 2025 board organization meeting and work session on Tuesday January 14th 6:30 p.m. at Garrett Morgan High School the chair will now entertain a motion to adjourn this board business meeting second hearing no objection this meeting is adjourned good night happy holidays and happy New Year I look forward to seeing everyone in 2025 e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.