CorpusRecord 214502

MCS School Board Work Session 8-5-19

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Moore County Schools
Date
2025-01-03
Location
Moore County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,223 words · about 118 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good afternoon welcome to the more County Board of Education work session and special called meeting for Monday August 5th 2019 is there a motion to approve agenda okay there was a motion by U Mr Dennison and the second was by who went first Dr Brown Dr Brown um all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 60 please stand for the pledge I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all let's take a moment of silence all right thank you we have a full agenda for today Dr grimy yeah Madam chair at this time I'll invite Dr metcafe and friends forward good afternoon Madam shair members of the

002board we are here to provide an update on the ACT situation at Pine Crest High School principal Phillips is going to provide an update on the supports that are being provided to the students and then miss fall will provide an update on the accountability measures that piece of it and then I'll provide a a quick report on the work of the ACT District fire team that's looking at the testing and we'll start with Miss Phelps thank you good afternoon members of the board superintendent grimy guests and community members watching at home thank you for your time today I want to start out by apologizing to the entire class of 2020 their parents and our school family the district and the Board of Education the mishandling of the ACT answer sheets was a significant error and

003I feel personally responsible for the stress and the anxiety that those students who are impacted have gone through as a result of this error it did happen on my watch and I am ultimately accountable for the successful administration of the act at Pine Crest High School I'm also extremely sorry for the amount of work this has caused everyone impacted by the mishandling of the ACT answer sheets it has taken countless staff hours away from very important other needs at the school and at the district again I want to apologize to the senior class for the inconvenience and stress this has caused I will be meeting with the entire senior class on August 21st and again on on the first day of school to apologize to them in person and begin the Journey of rebuilding their

004trust and confidence in our school administration once again members of the board and superintendent grimy I am sorry the first thing I want to review with you specifically is the immediate test at Ministry ation action plan when Miss fall and I began the first days of the investigation uh we had this action plan in place before she ever left Pine Crest some highlights of that plan are the testing coordinator will become a certified position it was a classified position there will be an assistant principal who will provide direct oversight for the entire testing process with verbal and written communication as to what that process should look like there will will be two testing teams a team for Logistics and a team for testing processes I'm sure the board of education has learned more about act

005than they ever knew before and Logistics is a huge part of that administration at Pine Crest High School because we use Arena testing and you're putting desk in a gym with specific guidelines that that state head to heads three feet both side to side and front to back so that's the importance of having a logistics team added to the action plan the testing coordinator and assistant will be with all test materials at all times until pickup additional highlights the process to submit pitch there will be a process developed to submit pictures of FedEx shipping labels at pickup there will be regularly scheduled meetings to review status updates both before and after testing including both teams and myself after the administration there will be a survey administered to the staff for feedback on test Administration so

006we can continuously improve and this will be the basis of the fire teamw work for the district now for supports we've offered an act preparation class through grab point that course highlights English Math and Science has three different sections in that course registration assistance for the July and September test dates in June our counselors were there and they assisted with the registration process for the month of July my office has been command Central and I have personally registered students along with Miss trogden and then a lead teacher has been in to help as well application for accommodation request why is this support important because our 504 students and our IEP students students have a special process to apply for accommodations and when we're testing outside of a school-based test it's a different process I'll speak

007to that again in a moment um and when the students return we're going to have counselor meetings with students concerned about early admissions the guidance team met on their first day back and they divided up colleges that have an early admission process and they are personally calling colleges to get information directly from them so we can properly advise students to the College of their choice College specific information will be provided to all those students we also pulled all the SAT scores for students and we have those in a spreadsheet so we can also properly advise students advise students based upon their SAT score for early admission as well now the numbers in July we had 10 students test five registered at Pine Crest and then five request reimbursement for the upcoming September test as of

008today updated from your presentation as of today we have 92 students registered 83 registered at Pine Crest High School and then nine have requested reimbursement these numbers may not be an accurate count of all the students who are going to take the ACT administration because not everybody's asking for reimbursement so after this September test date we'll get a report from act which will allow us to know exactly how many students tested in September three students have been approved for special testing why is this important for you to know because those students will test at Pine Crest High School when you get approved for special testing I have to submit paperwork day that states these students can test out our school so they give us a testing window and those students will be testing on Saturdays

009at Pine Crist high school with trained people on staff primarily the guidance department and then our 504 coordinator we have 34 students as of today enrolled in the ACC prep class during the month of June we spoke to 54 parents and students regarding the ACT 20 of those students were personal calls and once again please keep in mind that we are not sure of the official number of students who are going to test in September until we get that report from Act so in terms of the impact of the missing ACT scores on the 1819 data reports the act's participation Pine Crest will be reported as less than 5% for all 201819 reports additionally any reporting of ACT results for example the composite score um as reported out for the district will not include Pine

010Crest High School therefore it's going to be nearly impossible to accurately compare the more County Schools act data point over the years since a large portion of the data is missing for the 1819 year however in terms of the school report card grade that letter grade that's assigned to each School the ACT data sorry the ACT data that is included is based on the senior class and so that means that the 11th grade ACT scores are banked until the following year when the students are seniors so our junior class those scores are banked until their senior year so what's going to happen is that we will have those scores in time to be used for the school report card so um therefore that there is not a negative impact on the calculation for school performance

011grade for the 1920 school year 1819 or 1920 let me be clear this school year the previous school year or the one we're going into um we have worked closely with the North Car Department of Public Instruction to ensure that every student impacted has the opportunity to retest um and that their scores will count for all possible accountability measures at Pine Crest High School and more County Schools any student who takes the test either during the Saturday Administration for the school or at the school administration on October 1st or 15th will be included in accountability measures this will ensure that students who took the assessment in June July or September during the off-site Saturday Administration will not need to test again on October 1st and 15th to be counted for accountability however their scores will

012be included in the composite score reports participation measure and school performance grading well more County schools has opted to afford any Pine Crest student senior the ability to take the ACT the only students who will be included for our accountability measures will be students who were eligible for the ACT Testing during the march 2019 Administration so the late test date the makeup test date for um act Administration that is any student who was enrolled in 11th grade at Pine Crest High School on the March data collection date ncdpi is going to be providing us a list of that of those eligible students students all eligible students will be required to test however we have several opportunities for them to be assessed to be included in the accountability measures those opportun opportunities were previously outlined by

013principal Phillips any student who is on the ncdpi list will take the ACT and their participation scores will count towards accountability measures any student who tests who is not on the ncdpi eligibility list will receive scores but they will not count towards participation in score reports for Pine Crest High School so if you have a student who enrolled after that March date at Pine Crest they will still receive their scores they'll be allowed to retest they'll receive their scores but it will not necessarily count in our accountability measures impacted students who were at Pine Crest High School in March of 2019 and have since transferred to another more County school will be included in the retesting opportunity and will be included in accountability measures so if a student had transferred to Union Pines or northmore

014they will be included in this process we are currently working to identify who those students are that meet that criteria and if there are any we will work with them and their families individually to make sure that the students have equal access impacted students who were at Pine Crest High School impacted students who were at Pine Crest High School and have since transferred outside of more County Schools will not be included for accountability measures so if you had a student who transferred out at the let's say April and they've transferred out they will not be included in our accountability measures however more County Schools will make sure that these students are given the opportunity to retest at no expense to the student and we have already worked with at least one family to ensure that

015that happens students who have taken the act or sat prior to the September Saturday ad sorry sorry prior to the September Saturday Administration who does not wish to participate in the fall 2019 ACT Testing on October 1st must have met certain score requirements um which will be posted on the Pine Crest website these students must provide a copy of their scores to Pine Crest High School and complete a waiver form the waiver form will be submitted to ncdpi for processing all eligible students still enrolled in more County Schools who do not test either during the June July or September Saturday Administration or the October 1st and 15th onsite Administration and who do not meet the waiver requirements will count against the accountability measures for Pine Crest High School and ultimately more County Schools thank you

016uh shortly after the incident at Pine Crest High School Dr grimacy directed us to put together an assessment process review fire team we've already had our first meeting and as you can see there's a Representatives on that fire team from across both the central office as well as across all of the high schools that includes Kate of course Tanya Del con our manager for testing accountability our CTE uh people Tracy mcneel Miss Phillips will represent the High School principles on their team as well as AP coordinator Jennifer Kerney from Pine Crest High School Jos Newton um who works with us at Pine Crest is also the coordinator for San Hills Community College Joseph Patterson the test coordinator at northmore high school Chris Monroe a counselor and AP coordinator at Northern northmore High School Nick caps

017uh who handles testing at Union pance High School Renee portfilio the counselor for up and Melanie Lee Career Development coordinator for Union pin High School in addition Kent eckan will uh provide an advisory role for us as director of Technology if we would like to do some online testing we're going to be looking at more than just the ACT assessment that we give we're also going to be looking at the prea the work keys the advanced placement uh the waeda uh the red to aieve the end of grade the end of course our North Carolina final exams our CTE post assessments all of the State and independent assessments that we are required to give we're going to look at our processes and procedures around them team will do work in this area some of the

018procedures we'll be reviewing the training procedures and our requirements for that our timeline security measures accountability procedures accommodations Logistics and whether we want to go online or paper and pencil Administration these will be the topics of our conversations and the world will guide our our work we want to make sure that we have appropriate procedures in place and that they are consistent from school to school and are applied with that level of consistency we've already met once we met on July 22nd uh not from 2: to 3:30 a.m. we are committed but not that committed I might say uh we actually we from 2: to 3:30 p.m. we had each of our uh High School principles there and and set the ground rules for the work that be was going to become and uh where

019we wanted to have our starting point our next meeting will be August 7th from 8: to 11:30 we'll really dig in into this work uh then again August 29th September 9th Kate will be leading this uh where she will be at an Lea director's meeting and we'll be um meeting with um uh representatives from other schools in our region to get a feel for what their procedures and processes are at their District level and at their school levels in their school districts and she will bring that information back to us we want to make sure we're being consistent and we're not missing something that other schools and other systems have in place that we might not have in place so we're going to be comparing notes with other districts uh and then September 25th is

020our final meeting of course we will continue those meetings if need be but hopefully we'll have processes and procedures in place um for all of these assessments and of course we'll report back to you um as we move through this process we're also as principal Phillips noted providing specific support to the administration on October 1st and October 15th for the ACT um so as this work continues we're going to give special detail special look at the work there to make sure that's done appropriately and we are certainly here to answer any questions that you may have go ahead P um what impact will this have by not having the 95% participation uh because we've been working with DPI so diligently um they just want us to be aware of that 95% usually when you do

021not meet 95% you have to come up with an action plan of how you will avoid that in the future you have to provide documentation about why you didn't meet it all of that has already been handled as a part of this process so they are aware of that 95% they do expect us to meet 95% retest so as a part of this retest um now they've opened it up so it's not just the testing on October 1st and 15th it also includes those Saturday administrations prior to September so when we add all of those together they are anticipating that we meet 95% and if we don't then we will have to provide the action statement all that thank you Stephanie first I want to just acknowledge your initial comments of um taking responsibility and

022accountability going forward uh we certainly recognize um that this incident was human era um and putting a plan in place going forward we we just appre appreciate you uh and the things that you've already done to move forward with this process um one of the questions I have is with the turnaround time following the testing of getting the material together and FedEx and is there a designated time frame from following when the students take the test and getting the out sheets and getting those uh picked up by FedEx yes ma'am schedules FedEx to pick up the next day at the school they have put um a little caveat in there that if they're not ready at that time then you can take them to ship onite or whatever your local FedEx provider is but the

023expectation is that they're sent out the next day and it's such a regular FedEx pickup time that every school has okay um and the students the 10 students that um did the retake in July were all of those students uh part of the initial February March testing that that their information was lost so we didn't have any anybody new to pop up basically okay that was my questions when do we expect the results to come back from the the administrations in September and October it's a 3 to eight week window and can act speed that up at all for us or is that that is set in that's their process yes ma'am it's their process and I will add that it's a little oftentimes it's a little bit longer than the 3 to eight weeks

024for the schools to receive the score reports indiv they go directly to the student correct students go the scores go directly to the students initially and then we also as a school system get the reports which can sometimes be after that three to eight week window and of a an additional point with that is that's one of the things the guidance counselors are calling those early admission colleges for because just because the student gets their ACT score let's let's go with the low end in 3 weeks it doesn't mean that that college pulls at three weeks the colleges have certain dates that they pull scores so you might receive your score in three weeks but the college might not pull it to week four so that's why the guidance team has divided that up to

025get those dates specifically The Pool Date specifically from those early admission colleges thank you for clarifying that I didn't understand that they were calling the colleges themselves and not um the students so thank you for clarifying that there's a decision been made whether the October 1st Administration will be an online Administration or pencil and paper it will be paper pencil because that's the only option available to us through act um they require that those um distri that that District administration be done on paper pencil for this Administration it is possible we go online for future administrations of the act so we anticipate trying to have as many students as possible taking this test again on October one yes and where is the September Administration that's a variety of locations uh O'Neal school has the majority

026of our students testing there we also have students testing at Scotland high school and Richmond High School whatever is convenient yeah and one other question were we noting that the testing coordinator position becomes a certified position that's at all three of the high schools not just at Pine Crest the other two high schools only Pine CR because of their size as a as a coordinator the other two schools use an assistant principal for that particular role so just so I'm clear too because I have not gone through this the act for the October Administration those registrations have not happened yet because that'll happen at school or when do those registrations start happening so it's a little bit different the tests that the students took in July and September are called National test test dates and

027those are individual registrations the October test date is called a state test date and for those administrations we provide a database to act and that's how the registration happens it's not individually student by student okay we just completed the online registration for for Pine Crest to be able to administer in October thank you any other questions May sure Dr CF when would the school board expect to hear back from the U from you and and the fire team uh we will report back in September and definitely October as well as we provide information surrounding you where we're at and any additional information we might have will there be enough substance in September or would you prefer to wait till October we put it under the agenda at this point Dr grimy uh but as uh

028depending on half the progress of the fire team will make a determination whether to pull that out wait till October or whether keep Prov a report to you in September as well one one other question um do we know if Act is looking at their procedures for the receiving of test because I still do wonder why they didn't make note that having shipped supplies to Pine Crest they never receiv received score sheets and and that didn't sound a bell of alarm for them as well so are they they looking into their procedures what we were told from our DPI contact who's communicating with Act is that act has launched an internal investigation as well but odds are we will not ever know the results of that investigation is something that they did realize was a

029was an issue and a concern and they did address that with our DPI yeah even a simple postcard or an email that says all all materials received yeah would would be [Music] reassurance we thank you for your work um this summer we know that um this is something that we hope will never happen again um with all the procedures that are going into place it's sounds like um looking at all of our testing is is the right thing to be doing at this point um to ensure that this won't happen again and my expectation is that I think those eleas that you're going to be talking to in September might actually be looking at us at what we're doing um I've already received at least one EMA I I am sure so I'm sure there'll

030be a lot of reciprocity to ensure that this type of thing doesn't happen in the state again so thank you thank you with your permission Madam chair yes I'll invite Mr bar to come forward for item 2B budget and schedule report for new construction projects this is a new feature to the work session agenda one that we think that we'll begin to include in future work sessions this is our first go at it we see refinements in the future I will turn it over to Mr barath who will lead with the significant um most significant news that being the opening of bids for construction of the new Pinehurst Elementary School Mr brat thank you Dr gri see good afternoon Board of members uh in the uh long narrative there apologize for that we will be

031brief in the next ones moving forward with a lot more imagery pictures and uh schedules and such to talk about uh this one's more a narrative to bring uh the board uh uh with the information on the Pinehurst opening as well the progress on the other schools under construction especially those that are getting ready to open so to start off here with Pinehurst Elementary School the good news is uh we had four biders uh submit bids for the new school last week on August 1st that was good news the apparent low responsive biders Thomas Construction Group based out of Wilmington North Carolina now their base bid amount was $1,750,000 the bid range from the low to the apparent high bid submitted is just about 5.3% the bid difference from the lowest bid and the second

032lowest bid was 6/10 of a percent so this signifies to us that we had a good bid process a good tight bid opening so following uh the bid opening uh the architect uh began working with Thomas construction and uh looking for verification of their bid and uh preparing the certification of the bids that were submitted the identified budget that's the blue sheets that everyone's been looking at all these years for each project broken out in that sheet we had identified $ 28.87 million for the construction of the school that was the the combination of the construction items listed in the top portion of that budget sheet and the uh applicable pro-rated amount of the inflation applied to that to get to the 28.87 million that means the difference between the apparent low bid in the

033uh budget for the project as identified is 2.87 or $2.88 million now staff uh and the design team consisting a ratio Architects LKC Engineers duberry engineering and Thomas Construction Group had a conference call Friday to discuss other opportunities in the project that we want to take a look at to consider opportunities to save want to remind the board that we went through this process on the previous projects everything that came out of the process on those projects for opportunities to save without sacrificing operation or sustainability of the school has been incorporated into this project however this is a different design team this is a different contractor with different Subs so we're hoping that with another whole set of eyes there might be some items that we can identify in here that could bring potential savings

034to the project the group will meet on August 16th to review the entire list of proposed items and then immediately follow up the following week to develop a final recommendation to the school board for uh presentation on September 3rd there are funding opportunities within the total project again keeping in mind that if we look specifically at the Pinehurst Elementary budget sheet there is identifi $945,000 of contingency uh there is a remaining prated amount of the escalation inflation cost of about $195,000 combined that's just over $1.1 million of available funding there if you apply that to the 2.88 million you end up with just over 1.7 million of needed funds now if we were to drain all of the contingency money to put it into the award we must uh exercise caution because the site is

035not an undeveloped site this site had previous structures on it at some time we do not what know what might be encountered as we begin putting in utilities and foundations for the new building as well as a demolition of the existing structures so the design team is going to evaluate the potential risk for all that in our assessment that we bring to the board on the third the current status because again we're working on a $13 million budget that we divided up amongst the three schools but for the overall project of the three elementary schools which means you would include the deficit on Southern Pines Elementary of the $ 2.68 million creates a cumulative deficit of $4.4 million we still have unused funds in the abine and the Southern Pines projects there is contingency for

036those projects we had to take some of it to apply towards the award but we still have remaining contingencies there we also have the remaining pration of uh escalation inflation in there as well when you bring those potential funding items together it's just over $1.4 million which reduces the overall deficit to just over $2.9 million so you can see that there's some opportunities still that remain in the overall project of $103 million to continue to work towards developing a number that is going to fall within the 103 million we also through mcdeeds Creek Elementary School which is done through a direct Finance separate from the bond with the uh Furniture fixtures equipment and Technology purchases that are being finalized there for the final items to be delivered to the school we will have a clear

037understanding of exactly how much of that money may be left over a surplus because each project has the same number of items in them so there's an also opportunity for additional Surplus through those FF and Technology items that would be applied to it that we will know more information on in a later date to help us structure the uh final impact of the overall budget of $103 million joh let's be sure let's be sure we make clear that any surplus on mcdeed Creek is not available for transfer to the bond funded projects correct but it does inform what we might expect as we move into the bond funded project are all board members clear on that yeah make sure there's no confusion make sure there's no confusion on the part of the public um go

038ahead you're gonna add another point I might I might have cut you no at that point I was going to pause there and ask any questions regarding the bids uh that were opened and uh again we will bring a full presentation to at the award at September 3rd we'll pause in between each report on each project Madam chair any questions on on the Pinehurst Elementary bid bid opening process um the the W the award the the apparent Lois bidder have they done work in MO County before or nearby they have done not done work in MO County we are in the process of request in their entire resume of all school projects and scale of projects within the past five to seven years and they're a North Carolina they're based out of well in correct

039okay great thank you okay any other questions thank you um the camp Easter I'm sorry the mcde Creek Elementary School old habit hard um MCD Creek Elementary School is uh in its final stages of wrapping up the small touches left in construction as well as stocking the building with all the furniture fixtures equipment and Technology items uh if you've tried to head out that way you would have noticed that the road is closed out there as they are finalizing work on the traffic roundabout that they're installing out there uh the uh Construction Company JM Thompson and the town of Southern Pines will be conducting their certificate of occupancy inspection of mcdeed Creek Elementary School on the 12th uh the Fire Marshall has already conducted his walkthrough and all his items have been addressed uh at

040this point the issue tying to the occupancy Department uh Beyond just the school is the completion of the roundabout uh the closure of the road has enabled them to expedite their process out there with the construction of it and trying to make sure that we get the roundabout done uh after at the completion of this weekend coming up so the completion of the roundabout the final inspection school will all tie together and have it in place for teachers to respond to the school on the 14th and open the office officially that is the status of it this time does anyone have any questions regarding oh I forgot the most important thing I'm sorry there will be a ribbon cutting ceremony on August 22nd at 10:00 a.m. at the school want to make sure that's on

041the calendars now if there are any questions on the wrapping up of that project oh sorry I was just gonna make a comment real quick um that we got to tour thats C you and um it was just wonderful to see a little made me a little anxious that a lot of stuff wasn't done as far as like furniture and stuff but I know that they probably have it way under control but it was wonderful and amazing to see it actually all all built and all done so it'll be great for the ribbon cuton sorry go Ah that's what I was going to say Everything Is Beautiful it it certainly was beautiful um one question about the Landscaping I know that some of our early plantings have suffered because of the hot weather now is

042that a cost we must absorb or did we go to low and by those plants and they're guaranteed for a year no um all the landscape is warranteed for 14 year uh any type of construction North Carolina is warranteed for one year so those plants we just could not replace them In the Heat of the summer no point in it so all those trees that have unfortunately not survived they will be replaced here in the fall when the temperatures enable us to do that so that that is an item that we identify in our uh substantial completion punch list and we withhold funds until they are complete well it's been a brutal summer so well well understood why it happens the only thing I'd add is um being at the tour last week um really

043brought home for us you know the first of many openings that are coming our way and the amount of work that everybody in this room has done that you have done Dr grimy that our County Commissioners that our public has done to get these um and parents have get have put towards um ensuring that we have appropriate facilities for our students and it is um it was really exciting from that standpoint to to think think about the um where we've come in the past few years so I hope we we acknowledge that too all the hard work that went just to get to this point so thank you job well done the next project talk about is a temporary Pinehurst ele School located Rassy Wicker Park uh the modular units are in place are tied

044down and have power activated to each one uh ramps and stairs are just about done on the units the sidewalk is in its final pouring stages this week we will begin moving into that unit starting tomorrow when we start taking our uh interactive whiteboards the smartboards out of the existing school and placing them in the new one on the walls on Wednesday the uh contractor to move the furniture and the boxes and everything else at the school will begin his work of locating it all in the temporary school and that will go through Saturday this week and so the emptying of the existing school should be complete by the end of this weekend uh the uh school during this period of interruption of having to manage and make sure things are moved and placed in

045the appropriate places at the temporary site will have their offices closed uh beginning Wednesday and set to reopen on uh August 14th at the new site uh that's also because our service that we have for data phones and everything needs to be just a single switch over so they ring at the new place in a seamless manner so for those days the front office will be closed uh officially at Pinehurst Elementary School and reopen on the 14th at the temporary site in the interm any families that still need to enroll a child will be covered by the assistance of central office during that period also so on August 16th at 10:00 a.m. we will conduct a similar walkthrough like we did at mcdees Creek with the board uh with the Commissioners and with the village

046uh to offer a look initial look at the completion of the temporary campus and of course uh parents and such will have that opportunity when they come to their open houses at the school uh lot going on out there but uh it's looking very nice any questions from the board do we have a date of when Pinehurst will be um when you will knock it down is that still all kind of up in the air we don't have a date on that until we get chance with the contractor to look at award a budget and get their calendar for construction however you're again we're not awarding the contract until about mid September and so they wouldn't be scheduling immobilizing to demolish until the end of September beginning of October and we'll be conducting a uh

047demolition ceremony of some kind to notify the board and every one of to witness the first stages and I will also bring in uh to the board in September a list of items from that school that we wish to declare Surplus to auction off to the public again we know that um trying to get our temporary site set up um has um had a lot of work involved so uh again we're appreciate you John and and Dr Bob and everybody that has lended a hand in that effort uh cuz I know it may not have been easy uh especially with the heat and um everything that um they've had to endure so uh we just appreciate the the help in getting that up and ready for school appreciate that it's also been all hands on

048deck with the school staff both for mcde Creek regarding their school Piner Elementary staff uh our own maintenance support staff Roger Leon and planning and also with the support we have from academic Services throughout this and has not been solely me it has been everybody and I'll be sure to pass that on to them as well thank you okay moving on abine Elementary is uh come along well it's just past the 50% completion Mark out there uh they are working towards uh getting to the point of dry in which means that they have the roof structure up and in place uh so the Interiors can be dry and they begin doing uh critical systems work under dry conditions uh with that phase also comes the opportunity with means the bearing which is the exterior masonry

049walls will be complete and they can begin installing the insulation in preparation of facing it with the brick so it's going to start looking a lot different very soon out there um it is uh continuing to uh progress well unfortunately it is not one of those that you could drive by and see easily from the roadway uh you can only see see the school either by uh visiting the website for uh progress photos or by uh traversing back down the construction drive to see it yourself so uh you may not have been able to go by as easily as uh Camp Easter but I'm course available and happy to take you out there anytime you want red brick is is being constructed on the back side of the building forward so you you you happen

050to go in there loop around and come back out you won't see the red break yet but there's substantial amount of masonry going up on the back side of the building any questions proceed Mr very good uh northmore High School uh that is underway I did Southern Pines I am sorry must be my subconscious at work the uh Southern Pines Elementary School uh project is underway uh one of the first things they are doing out there is building those retaining walls as you recall it's a very steep site that has a lot of tearing of grading coming down and so some of the building does act as retaining walls and so those are the critical items they need to construct first which allows them to continue constructing foundations so uh it is an exciting process

051to watch them form create and pour those uh and as those finish up they are already grading the pad area to have the New Foundations and utilities installed underneath there has been some concern with the heavy heavy rains we've experienced recently where the storm water management basins have breached uh with the uh uh uh duration of rain being so brief with such a high volume uh the contractors has come back and then instance and has repaired everything and restored the uh storm water detention areas back to their original intention and and condition so we hope that uh we get a little break from the heavy downpours here and let the ground stabilize so that we do not run that problem again moving forward but again it's not an easy site to see when you drive

052by you can see it from the end of Glover Street and at the top of Carlow but if you would like to go out anytime just please reach out to me happy to take you to the site there is a site that's being developed right off of Morganton Road that's next to the current building that's there that has the the dental office and the the restaurant that is not our site because a lot of folks are asking me if that's our School site and do you know what that is what that pediatric is going to be building back there but that's also the land owner has agreed to allow the contractor to borrow from there and to build up a site also other where on their property okay so it's not ours it's not ours

053it's General development with the only current um land um business going in there is Sand Hills Pediatrics that's the only one I'm the intent of the developer to develop the property to make it more marketable it's convenient to have a pediatricians office right next to our school which came first yes proceed Mr BR thank you now to northmore high school all right so uh at northmore high school the utility uh relocations where the addition is being buil built out there is ongoing and finalizing its final process through that uh the demolition of the locker rooms on the inside are about done there's some small lightings still to finish up inside there which tied to the utilities power utilities that serve the entire campus so as soon as those are relocated and bridged they will begin

054to be able to conduct some construction inside there um the modular units that have been moved out of the way or set up on the parking lot where the buses used to be and that's over on the west side of the site uh so that bus parking lot is temp turning into our temporary classroom site we have relocated the modular that were at northmore and we have relocated the modulars six modulars from San Hills Farm Life up to there as well because as you will recall one of the buildings on campus is going to be inaccessible during this construction so we had to accommodate them over with the temporary units in the parking lot so as those units this week are being uh finalized and stitched together again uh our maintenance staff is building the

055ramps and walkways out there and power is being set up to service the units this week and again this is another example of all Hands-On deck coming together and plan to make sure that all classrooms are have all the furniture and everything in them by the time Stu uh print teachers arrive on the 14th so we're almost there with that one it'll just take another uh effort by all this week to make sure we get to that point by the 14th but uh I know Dr gy had previously uh sent an image out there from the site you can see where it's been uh started to clear from where the modular units used to reside and we are working with principal Jenny pervis to identify a groundbreaking ceremony date for when the students at the

056school can participate with board as well and the Commissioners during that activity is there a place on campus where a photo of the work that's going to be done or uh this the the schematics are available for students to use is that something that that we will keep at northmore in case there are questions when students walk by that's a great point I will make sure they have one of our presentation Boards out there of the uh new plan board out there will make sure miss purose has that to display I imagine that'd be exciting for the students to see as they're as they're watching this change happening they can have a visual of that um in front of them um we make sure she has that any other questions about the northmore project and

057the only thing tied to that is the uh San Hills Farm life there's still two uh modular units remaining out there that is going to be Lo relocated at by the end of this week which means out at the SOS Farm Life site site we have some remediation of grade out there and elements that need to be restored uh from where these units were so we'll be restoring them back to their original condition raking them out pulling the utilities out of the way getting rid of any broken up concrete and then of course we can't plant any Bermuda seed right now to grow just burn right up we'll make sure we prep it and uh get some rye on it this winter and then get the Bermuda in it next spring so that'll have chance

058to go back to its original condition before modulars were added so there's still a little work out there just to clean it up but all the debris and everything will be cleaned up ahead of the teachers responding to work on the 14th John did we get any um trailers moved from vest Lake View or are they still there no they remain there um that is something that I will be also highlighting and pointing out in my next presentation so this is another one where we should be really excited because just remember back a few years ago when we had to add a couple of Modells to San Hills Farm life and the opening of McD's Creek will now allow us to get rid of rid of them and that that I remember when it went

059right in front right on that front lawn there's no place else to put there was no place else to put and we talked about putting it on the tennis courts and we got a lot of push back from that um and it's going to be a whole new school and I'm I'm just very excited for that community and they'll be reassessing what a smaller size is like they'll have to learn to live that way too it's different um but it's also exciting to have that campus come back to to what it was designed for so I'm EX excited for that so if I drive by that one right in front is gone is that one gone already the two of are gone there was one down by the tennis courts on the side and then

060there were two that were right out front they're all gone they're all gone okay thank you we have to tidy it up a little bit yeah just a little site clean up the modular are gone but it's not pretty yet and that started this whole conversation yes ma' so I think it's um or a part of it at least so thank you you're welcome with your permission Madam chair yes please okay Mr barath you'll invite some friends to join you and I'll Trust you for the and Trust the introductions to you madam chair as they're getting ready today we are going to review factors that justify the need for Student Assignment planning and John will review the history of um the um School Capital plan uh how it came together how enrollment projections drove a

061lot of the decisions we had to make in addition to the need for modernization of some of our schools the need to consolidate some of our schools and so now we've built for we're in the process of building 4 800 student elementary schools but when we U get those built we've got to then look at how we assign students among these schools and so while we're at it given the amount of disruption we have we think that the time in the history of our school district has come where we need to look at the whole school district as we've discussed before for particularly at our middle schools because it's very difficult to reassign student uh students to elementary schools without looking at middle school and then also it's fair to say that as we've moved

062into this process we've learned about some new needs or some needs that maybe turned out to be more urgent than we thought they were John's got all that covered in his presentation he now has his presentation committee together and I've done all the introducing I'm going to do and I hope they're ready because Mr Barat thank you Dr grimy um once again this is not the efforts of me this is an efforts of an entire team of people I just happen to be the face in the vest that is the honor to present it to you today uh but joining me of course we have Dr Tim Lair who has been with us throughout this entire process and working side by side and helping it development everything along the way and appearing for the first

063time we have Josh ranky from Ry Kemp and Associates um he is here as our traffic impact analysis uh specialist that we had brought in on the project and he will be discussing the impacts and potential uh routing solutions that we've been looking at over the many different scenarios for the schools in this presentation so as Dr grimy said we're going to start with a little bit of a uh historical uh path to remind everybody of what got us to where we are here today um so back in 2014 the board had approved a master facility plan and it identified the projects that are associated to this they they knew back then that there needed some something needed to be done to relieve the conditions at the schools that they were experiencing at that time

064in 2013 there were Community meetings that were held and the process began with input from Key stakeholders throughout Moore County and it came to accumulation the development of a M this master facility plan in October 2015 the Board of Education approved an updated Master facility plan this took some time to develop and to come uh to agreement with uh had a lot to do with the order uh because there was not the opportunity to obtain all the funding at one time it was going to have to be broken down into bits of opportunity to fund and grow and begin to implement and so with this as at the time there were the four identified projects the Advanced Career Center along with the new elementary school and the replacement schools so at the time this was

065developed one of the great changes that happened in the process of the 2014 board adopted Master facility plan to this one you will note is the capacities and the built capacity of the schools the original plan had them at 650 student uh back in 200 145 you may recall where we realize that should that hold true that most of the schools would open with possibly modular units on them day one and so at that time the board recognized that the growth of more County and the need required a change to the capacity of the schools this is important because it also provided opportunity at the other adjacent area schools with this uh plan in place the board worked with the Commissioners and began to develop uh plans to finance and provide the funding for the

066projects in January 2018 Moore County uh approved a direct financing of mcdees Creek Elementary School and in May of 2018 the public overwhelmingly approved the bond referendum for the three schools so the planning of the new schools has a base beginning of of identifying the issue at hand that is causing the need for the new schools didn't work there we go uh for pretty much the past two decades uh ored laboratory with the Institute of Transportation research and education at North Carolina State University has been working with more County and more County Schools to develop these charts of tracking and understanding the growth growth of the community and the impact that growth has on the schools they have been presenting these heat charts to the district for those over 20 years and it demonstrates clearly

067in there the areas of great concern as well as some cases areas of opportunity so uh this presentation here is from January 2018 this was the most recent complete land use analysis ored had conducted uh through 2017 that was presented to the board in January of 2018 and you can see in here just again red is bad green is good so you can see what we were looking at as a school district with relation to our ability to accommodate the students at those schools in uh recently uh it's hard to read from where you're at um we have updated the projections to carry out to 2028 uh in there and you can see there really not that much change from what the previous year's uh chart had indicated we also included in here some historical

068uh the 201 1819 school year is blocked out vertically with a darker outline On the Border sort of to the first third point so everything to the left of that is for historical information so you can see and identify Trends and opportunities uh one of the things to keep in mind here is when you take a look at these charts and you start looking at some of the numbers these are facts that have been presented to the board for many years and it's been evident throughout these charts last year there were 2,823 middle school students well we have the capacity for 2848 just another 25 students capacity at all our middle schools we knew this problem we also knew that were over there were over 4,000 students attending the high schools that had the capacity

069for 3,277 these are things that we knew we knew that they we had capacity problems just meeting those grade levels at our schools coming up the results of this has been modular units we have had to place modular units at many of our campuses there were six at West Pine Middle Pinehurst High School School uh Pine Crest I'm sorry high school has 17 and Union Pines has 18 modular classroom units 64% of our modular units reside at middle schools and high schools this has created a an understanding of the need that while we are evaluating that yes we have to in our Master facility plan recognize the need for an additional Middle School recognize the master facility plan the need for Relief at high schools but the first group are projects we needed to look

070at was the elementaries to bring the opportunity for Relief there but then at the same time is there a way that we can have a positive impact on these overc capacity situations we're going to go into greater detail a little later in the presentation on The Guiding principles but I want to put this up as a reminder that this is our guideline as the planning team has gone through the process of evaluating opportunities and options and scenarios for the student assignment process you can see balance efficiency planning and Community these were elements that the board believed that needed to be uh addressed to the greatest extent possible with each of the every scenario that we evaluated and at each and every school we're going to talk about this again in a little bit greater detail

071but it ties together with it and that was after the mcdeeds Creek Elementary School attendance area the board reinforced further areas of focus for the planning team and these were identified in these four areas so we had the need and I should have been flipping these along the way we had the uh guiding principles of the balance and the efficiency the planning in the community and you can see how here they tie together with the planning for the new elementary schools we had some unresolved issues still to address with the m e Creek Elementary School utilization and also to the extent possible demographics and how they all tie in together the middle schools I mentioned earlier as far as uh our capacity and number of middle school students the greatest impact to those are in

072the area one in area three location these are your uh westpine middle your Southern Middle your new century and your cranes Creek Middle Schools so when you combine those schools together you have a combined amount uh capacity of 2,578 seats you can see that in the bar graph the highlighted green area is this forward coming school year the 201920 to the left is a historical and so to the right is where we're going the red line represents our capacity limit and you can see how that is exceeded moving forward and that's new century cranes Creek Southern and West Pine Middle correct this is all students all capacity and we are just now to the place where we have a number of students that's basically equal to the total capacity and going forward the number of

073students will be exceeding that and then as we get out about four or five years it'll start to PR increase well beyond that capacity so we've got about 5 to 10 years to be looking at potentially building another Middle School okay this represents westpine middle school with its historic the current and the forecasted membership and the impact you can see there with its capacity the red line 700 students that is the capacity of that school you can see for every bar on that chart how it exceeds that through our process of evaluating the uh uh choices and the options we look at the schools in considering the growth we also need to make sure we take a look at what does it look like in the school itself when something like this happens in 2028

074according to these numbers that's 1,161 students in a school designed for 700 repeat please 1,161 students at a school with a capacity for 700 students that is a percentage of 166% 2028 this would require at least 20 modular units to be placed out there in addition to the six they already have so it be a total of 26 to of 26 your student meal service times would be dramatically impacted significant if you stop and think about some of these activities and experiences of the student you have your morning drop off with over 1,100 students with that line and the impact on Route 21 would be and the time that line would take to move through you also have the uh additional congestion of having the elementary that is correct you also have your meal service

075times this school was designed to accommodate serving a school capacity of 700 you increase that this dramatically you're going to have students being served lunch before 10: and at well after 1:00 creating that hungry syndrome of you're going to be really hungry throughout your morning or in the afternoon um you're also looking at uh the afternoon pickup line and the time it'll take for that to happen as well as the congestion with 26 individual mobile classroom units out there you also compromise the safety of the site and especially in inclement weather moving students out of those units into other spaces for other coursework and studies as well as students access to other programs these all have impacts to that level and and what that would look like potentially would be this you're looking at an

076aerial of the school on the bottom you can see the drop off little circle parking lot where the front main entry is you can see where the buses are on the left there are six existing mobile classroom units out there on the right side there are three located on the lower right corner and nestled kind of in the middle there above that main entry point or three work into that little Courtyard the blue squares represent the additional units that would need to be placed out there that's not even all that doesn't add up to 20 14 16 18 well 14 would be added now there 20 and there already six there I wonder if by error I will amend this and have it replaced in there I think it might have been on a layer

077that hid I apologize there were 20 added there well it looks a lot like the current pinhurst elementary school even at this point wor where almost half your students are not even in the building yeah there's others not apologize I think when I read them and put them in there they on a separate layer that must be in the background and they didn't come forward that is my fault I will get that correct Ed here work with Sonia to make sure this is made accurate and then make sure board members are prompted when it's ready Miss I'm sorry they'll be done after the meeting today callwell thank you I was just going to say um so you're you would add additional 20 with the six that you have on there or were you counting the

078six with the 14 correct adding 20 okay that's if we didn't do anything assign CH yeah if we did if we did not assign children from westpine middle to some other school then this would be the destiny of westpine Middle School in8 ba based on current projections okay if we take just another sample at the adjacent school westpine elementary school its capacity is 600 students and that's a red line going across there the green bar representing this next school year and you can see how this next school year it's going to be just above its capacity amount but it's Trend obviously is continuing to climb and grow uh past that you will be looking at a school of approximately 830 students for a school designed for 600 again similar situation when you think about the

079potential impacts what this would mean and look at you would look at 12 modular classroom units out there the school currently does not have any and so we would look to strategically place them around the facility and this something uh close to this representation you're also looking at similar impacts to the ability and times that we need to feed the students to pick up drop off queing lines and times that those will take and the impacts this will have moving young students in and out of the school and around to different structures on the campus other examples when we take a look and this is important to look at two you look at Southern Middle School this shows again its capacity of 700 students you can see for the school year we currently completed in

080the one coming up we're really close to that number but the forecast shows a slight dip uh down there to stay under that and yet at westpine we have the inverse happening which continue to spike and climb above that so you can see the opportunity for some capacity here at Southern middle you look at West End Elementary School and that has a growing Trend out there and its capacity of 500 students and how it is going to continue to exceed that moving forward and that is a very challenging site there is not a lot of available space out there to put multiple modular units there is uh geogra or there's geography constraints the back of the site has steep drop offs off to it it's a very narrow linear site as you recall how close

081it feels when you drive by it on 211 so very challenging site to try to accommodate mobile units as a solution out here if at all are we losing any Frontage because of the 211 widening as well uh the plans due currently for the widening project indicate that there is the the easement setback is going to come onto our property some but it will not impact our parking out there so it'll be just eaten up in the lawn area do we know who owns that land right beside like if you're facing the school to the right that it's all ours all the way over those trees where they have the Saturday morning flea market sales and things like that um we own from the church property adjon to it on the West Side all the

082way to the road and at the moment the road name SLS me wherever that you go to the dump that way okay we and there's a ball field on the corner there so more County Board of Education owns everything in between there so whose ball field is that ours or County Board of Education uh cranes Creek Middle School uh this school is unique we'll talk about a little more in this presentation but currently its capacity is 478 students represented by by the red line and you can see how in past years and current years and moving forward for majority of the years how it's going to be below that uh capacity limit New Sentry middle school again a school of 700 student capacity uh has historically been under that limit and you can see it's

083starting to Trend a little growth out there well eventually it will exceed that moving forward some are schools experience the opposite that uh challenges uh Westmore is an example of that when you take a look at its capacity of 400 students and how the historical and the projected Trends are keeping it well below that moving forward we mentioned earlier the challenges of the high schools and uh the ability at all the high schools uh to serve all the students North Moore is uh following a similar Trend that Westmore is it's a uh occurring further out than westore currently is but our current year that we just completed uh North Moore was under its capacity of just about 560 students and moving forward it's going to hover there in then projected a dip a little bit

084based on the grades that'll be moving through the schools that are currently feeding into it so it'll uh continue that decline later on about years 5 through and just as with the other two high schools Union Pines and uh Pine Crest they both have been historically above the capacity when you look at Union Pines uh has historically been that way and continues that same Trend moving forward uh this is put in here as just a reminder that yes we are aware of this and the board is well aware of the high school situation however that is not at this time an item that can be a addressed it is something that needs to be addressed in the near future to bring the ability to get the high schools to a level of service more equivalent

085to its capacity John I I have a question when when Administration presents their U reassignment plan to us well you have charts there showing how the reassignment plan plan will affect all the charts you've shown us here because obviously we're not going to keep keep those schools like they are now uh we we can have the similar charts to show the impacts and changes to them when we do the presentation but that is not the format of that has not been decide this time but we will definitely oh I know I I mean in the future call then we that'll be the only time we can really see when we need to do a new Middle School we'll take that as input Mr Dennis and thank you yeah we take that under consideration we haven't

086started to we haven't finalized the plan it is important to not the data tables that shows us the capacity impact based on scenarios U we're expecting a lot of improvement in this area yes sir I I think what Mr Dennison's getting at is um numerics in the past has provided charts where the numbers are there what we could do um is get rid of the historical data on this one and start with 1920 through 2028 and then um for have these same bar graphs with one bar showing what it would have been without re uh student reassignment and then right next to it what the benefit is of student reassignment that that would not be that complicated to do add it's going to add a little we know it's going to take some time to

087present whatever it is we bring back we'll we'll take that under consideration Mr Dennis and see what we can't do to make that visual representation we'd have to do it school by school and on September 3rd I'm like today we'd have to do all the schools today we're doing a representative sample so just bring your you can't you can't have a chart unless you know what you're going to do for sure you know I wanted to add too although you just mentioned Union Pines and the overcrowding there as well as at Pine Crest a lot of people don't realize what huge modular buildings and uh modular classrooms already sit behind those schools because they're not easily visible that's right but we've got a lot of students already in um mobile units um full-time and we're

088very fortunate that a lot of our students in the high schools are going to Sand Hills Community College for a portion of the day so they're off campus so it's not as dire as it look that's benefiting us in in the short term but in the long term as as those numbers increase we'll we'll uh we'll feel that so thank but I we appreciate the board's input on that very good um and then uh with the work previously done by the board member this has been a two-step process the first step that the board conducted was that they addressed the need to develop a student assignment area for the opening of mcdeeds Creek Elementary school this August so the board uh and uh working with the guy the staff and the planning committee consisting of

089Dr grimy Dr ler myself Dr medf and uh numer had put together through the guiding principles and direction of the board scenarios for consideration which the board responded to and the end result was the adoption of this Student Assignment plan for mcdees Creek and as mentioned before there were some unresolved items in here that still needed to be addressed but going back to the guiding principles because these were the elements that were used to develop that solution that we have continued to carry through in the process to get to what the superintendent will present on September 3rd The Guiding principles uh are intended to provide the direction to the planning committee on elements they need to consider and attempt to resolve to the ex highest extent possible with each and every solution give examples here

090the principle of balance that is intended to improve situations where a school is exceeding its capacity at extreme levels such as what we looked at and talked about at West Pine Middle School and then other schools that have capacity such as Southern Middle School it also is to address large variations in student performance as well so it's schools that may be having lower performance and higher to try to bring that into an equitable level as well let me correct that John no it's more to make sure that student reassignment planning doesn't upset the balance any more than necessary that you make sure that schools that are high performing remain high performing uh and that uh if if if you can do anything to affect those that aren't as low performing then then that's that's a

091benefit but you don't do that on purpose to do that that's a secondary measure that we have I just want to make sure a reporting tool that we have the way you worded that I want to make sure that it's it's it's very specific and very accurate to it's not to have a negative impact and it is a we want to avoid any negative impact right um the prince amol of community is also critical as maintaining transparency of the process seeking input from the communities as well there have been numerous presentations that have been presented to the board that has been presented to the community and forums providing lots of opportunities for input uh and opportunities for voice of opinion also the principle of uh Community leads out to providing a level of highest level

092of information and soliciting feedback and throughout this process that has been a key component of the board and of superintendent grimy to make sure that everything we put out here is accurate is a true reflection of the data and everything that we have seen and it provides ample time for people to respond to not just the board but the community at large efficiency is again goes back to the example Dr grimy had which was about not having negative impacts on solutions to current conditions that they may be experiencing uh whether it's taking a look at ride times for students and uh that they are not moved into longer ride times that come to it no additional operational burden for costs for transportation or Staffing and also on Child Nutrition as well planning is to always

093consider maintain that Vision looking forward we cannot work within a window of just looking at 201920 we must look into a reasonable window of the 10 years that that we have exemplified through these charts we want to make sure also that the planning does not in the future uh impose harm on any adjacent or changed school that's impacted we have worked with the advisory committees uh throughout the process of not just the mcde creek but also for the process we've been going through now uh we have also uh been working in public forums and presentations the board as well as website uh Communications for frequently asked questions and clarifications on plans the desired outcomes which have been also factored in as a emphasis to accompany The Guiding principles are elements in here that again to

094the highest levels that we can and to the extents possible accommodate these situations in the schools there do not exist a lot of opportunities to improve capacity existing schools okay lot of schools you saw are well over capacities you saw examples of some they're slightly under capacities our greatest opportunities is when the core capacity of a school is less than the classroom capacity I'm Sor way around yeah I said that backwards is more than the classroom capacity of the schools what this means is if you take a look at previously identified school with a board Cameron Elementary the current classroom capacity is 66% of the core that means it has ability to service more students than classrooms are on the campus and so they have the opportunity for another 34% students out there which means

095they would need classrooms that's as presented to the board we looked at the opportunity with the addition being built at northmore high school when that is complete we can move that large six classroom unit from northmore over to Cameron and service those students and bring that school up to its core capacity so excuse me another example is Carthage Elementary where it's capacity is 61% of its core capacity that has a site challenge though that is again a site that is bound in and there's no opportunity to place modular units out there cranes Creek Middle School its capacity right now is 70% of the core capacity taking a look at where we currently are with it this is from the previous chart the 478 student capacity that's defined out there and that's restricted by the classrooms

096that are built its core capacity is 700 if we were able to provide classrooms out there we can now take that capacity from 478 to 700 students what that would do is when you think about the middle schools and the challenges that we had there from the previous slides that it provides the opportunity to mitigate some of that by adding mobile classroom units there and creating more capacity without expending a lot of capital funds you jumped ahead a little too fast can we go back to the previous slide please sorry okay and and so before you leave that could you please explain what core is what what what is core capacity thank you uh for reminding me core capacity is the ability of a school to serve the number of students that are there through

097its Central program spaces such as the cafeteria the media center the gym the admin support spaces those are the abilities of those functions to support a number of students in classrooms so in the case of cranes Creek its core was designed to support 700 students at the time it was built to uh reduce the cost they only Built classroom rooms to serve 478 students with the opportunities to expand out there in the future to grow the building to match the core so the suggestion of this slide is that that by some means um short of actual construction if we can bring the classroom capacity up to 700 to match the core capacity we could get 200 more students into cranes Creek and still be add or low capacity exactly we created the opportunity for over

098200 students without breaching capacity of a school right so how might you do that good question Dr grimy and the response to that is we have a sudden and surplus of modular units in the district we have uh thankfully have this Surplus because we did need some to move to northmore high school to F facilitate that construction project we also have some units that are available to go now to other locations if we take a look at northmore high school we relocated the existing units on site to the new temporary location the bus lot at San Hills Farm Life the elements that are highlight the mobile units highlighted in green have been moved to northmore high school so those units have been moved to northmore high school to use right now to facilitate the construction

099of the school and disruption to the existing building the other elements uh elements I'm sorry the other modular units such as those identified in blue for Piner Elementary School are available to move to other locations we can begin because these units still have opportunity for some service to the district and we already know from our previous earlier slides that we do have a problem with our Middle School growth it is far exceeding our ability to provide seats and we will be needing mobile units to solve that problem we have the opportunity to be prepared and move the units into place so that they will be ready uh at the schools to accommodate the growth so at pineer elementary school we can move unit to cranes Creek Middle School this year they would be ready for

100the next school year here uh to be potentially put into use the Highlight in yellow mobile units are units that are in oror conditioned and are being identified as opportunities for Surplus we necessarily do not want to move them have to refurb them to the level they would need to be uh it would be best if they were surplused and disposed of some of them we will move here to the central office to use this temporary storage uh we have some items from Pinehurst element elry that need to be placed into storage until the new school is completed and then which time they can go back so we have that from Piner Elementary School at Farm life we have those elements to go to northmore and at vast Lake View Elementary you'll remember from the

101forecast charts uh even with the solutions that were provided uh during the mcde Creek Elementary School student assignment we were still looking at we will exceed the capacity that School in the future with the growth happening down east from that school so we are keeping those units through there as a hedge because we believe that they will be needed in the near years ahead out there at that school that school is going to continue to witness that growth once the units are done uh with northmore high school there's an opportunity to relocate those a large classroom unit would relocate to Cameron Elementary School and 2021 and we can relocate others to cranes Creek Middle School to accommodate the opportunity there to achieve that 700 student capacity level so this is just a chart indicating what

102the potential is to move where and what for what year and what frees up to use at other places and which items we need to keep where they are there are some units that we have not identified at Aberdine primary and Southern Pines Primary at this point uh we will throughout the year ahead evaluate other locations where those may be needed and if in the end they're not needed then they will will bring recommendation of surplus to the board if necessary but this gives you an idea of the opportunity instead of either selling them all off and then turning around and having to buy units in the very near future that we can strategically place them in position to help schools and to help with the ability to provide seats to students Mr might before

103you move on John we're going to miss Carter if you give me just a second I want to emphasize something here these modulars at Pinehurst do you have the option to leave them there no we don't sir uh Piner you've been saying opportunities they're available maybe do we have to move them we absolutely have to move okay they have to go somewhere right move them or sell them and so what are your options so the options are we move them or we sell them okay and if you don't move them to Crane's Creek where are they going to go they're going to go up for uh auction and sold and done okay so why wouldn't we sell them I mean hey there's cash because there is a need to place them into service to hedge

104and provide the opportunity cranes Creek Elementary School to grow okay that's one thing but what if somebody says the money is more important why why wouldn't we just sell them and then if we need them later turn around and and buy some other new ones uh part of that has to do with costs you will not be able to to retrieve the cost of selling that you would for paying for them what does that mean if we were to sell them you we would anticipate a maximum of approximately $5,000 to buy to sell them you will recall that we bought some lightly used ones uh previously to place in the front of San Hills Farm life for $20,000 each so it would come at a greater cost if we were to try to sell these

105for a low return and then have to turn around and buy them at a greater expense so we're suggesting that this saves money it makes better use of the taxpayers um the taxpayer supported buildings that we have in place and and it does in the long run save a lot of money uh moving forward but it would be a way that we can make better use of cranes Creek Middle School given that all the previous charts and graphs show that that's inevitable we're going to need that space at core space okay Excuse Me Miss cor well we've sort of gotten to my answer anyway because what I wanted to know is when you buy one brand new what do you hope the life expectancy will be um one of the things about we call them

106modular units sometimes they call them mobile and Dr grimy and I have had this discussion they're not really as mobile as you think they are uh when you place them on a site that's great for a brand new one one time move one time set the more times you move a unit the more aware that it receives if a unit is to be placed on a campus I will share that there are plenty school districts across North Carolina that have mobile units a date back to the 60s and they have been there since the 60s in the exact same spot and that has been good in the sense that they've been able to sustain that type of life because they're not being moved around but we would anticipate that the more you move one you

107shorten its life cycle dramatically just through the wear of that uh I cannot give you how long it can last you know 40 50 60 years depends how well you maintain it just like with our buildings uh our buildings we have seen that in some cases due to lack of uh funding for maintaining preventive maintenance and replacement of systems the impact that has had on them and shortening their life cycles and so it all comes down to your ability to maintain the structures throughout its life I just know we have them in other places as well and we used to always call those temporary classrooms and somehow temporary has evolved into permanent classrooms and that a lot of times unfortunately is true uh you will see a lot of schools like I mentioned earlier to

108go back to the 60s of being in place okay so what could this potentially look at at cran Creek Min school again this school does have a core capacity that was built for 700 students and then its classroom uh support structures were built shorts of that so we would place out there the blue represents the modular units we would move this year from Pinehurst Elementary School out to that campus and then the uh orangish yellow ones are the units that would move from northmore high school in 2021 out the campus it's just a suggested placement of them we would continue to work with the principal on maybe which side of the courtyard serves better Etc with a placement of them but just to give you an idea of what it would take out there to

109provide the additional space needed to create a 700 student school and to demonstrate that we do have that capacity and ability with our mobile units inventory okay again let's make this abundantly clear make sure there's no confusion the difference between this diagram and other diagrams that we've shown is that these modular classrooms will bring cranes Creek up to its core capacity it's designed for 700 and by adding these modulars you bring it up to that core capacity and no more correct in the previous uh slide that we showed of westpine Middle School those would be modular classrooms that take westpine Middle School well beyond its core capacity it would take it Beyond 700 as much as 1100 at that point the problem with that is is that you no longer have the core to support

110it you don't have the the appropriately sized cafeteria gymnasium Media Center hallways administrative structure for that and so in this case modular classrooms although temporary we we we never think that that's the the final remedy this approach here at least allows us to use the appropriate capacity of cranes Creek Middle School during this next five next uh three to eight year 10 years while the capacity grows be while the number of students exceed the capacity and we're in no position to build another school or build on to cranes Creek this is a remedy that we could employ to manage that mismatch between the number of students in the total capacity of New Century cranes Creek Southern Middle School and westpine Middle School is that correct that's correct and it also begins to provide opportunity to

111uh apply towards the guiding principles of efficiency of balance and of planning okay thank you board members uh questions or thoughts or feedback would we be doing something similar to this for the core capacity of Cameron yes what we talked about correct that we would move the six classroom unit from uh northmore High School in 20121 to Cameron that will bring that school up to its core capacity to serice students and accommodate creating opportunity there as well that has been our plan since we engaged in the um student reassignment planning for mcdeeds Creek and so the public has has been able to manage that I think we've suggested that we might be able to do the same thing at Cranes Creek but it wasn't until we connected the dots between the modular classrooms that had

112to leave the Pinehurst campus and they have to go somewhere we either have to sell them low and then later on buy high or remain use them and reinvest them plant them someplace and not move them any more than necessary so instead of bringing them here and then moving them again later we just move them right to cranes Creek the only other option would be to sell them at a very low price knowing that within five to eight years we're going to have to spend four times as much at least to replace them so this right now is an area where we we would appreciate your at least your informal feedback today to let us know as we continue our planning um in response to this well it it's definitely cost effective and as we

113continue to look at reassignments it gives us an opportunity to make possibly a new shift or for students that may be uh closer to to some of those areas um so moving once definitely would save dollars um especially for I mean we've got some goodlook modular units and to be able to save those and repurpose in a different location would definitely be feasible want to seems to be fiscally responsible as well and we we don't know when we can look at um additional what our additional needs are in the facilities plan if we have a solution at this point that we can use to buy some time um for you know any further construction um I think that's a wise choice on our part for the taxpayers and for us um like you said Why

114move them twice if we don't have to so let's go ahead and and um and make make some of the adjustments now as long as they're in good shape you know don't move any of the ones that are really not going to make it and that's why on this uh previous chart we have gone through already inspected the ones that we definitely do not want to risk and put additional Capital into to the level it needs to be also want to point out that while uh this opportunity for cran Creek is a benefit to that it does not necessar solve the balance of not exceeding our uh seat capacity relative to our cores at the Middle School's of area one and three it does go a long way to helping with that uh does not

115replace still the need for that future Middle School it just buys time yes gives a little breathing in buys time if they're not in use um um how do you how do you secure them so that um how do you secure them and keep them updated so that they don't fall into disrepair well the units um as if there's issues with trim or things on the outside we go out and replace them Roofing uh repair replace as needed so we do our standard maintenance on them just as we do with our buildings as okay so that doesn't really change it's the sequence of construction for these are meant to be light they're meant to flex and things and as things Flex things wear so you don't have to put the steps in or the ramps

116in right away you're just going to place them for now we can place these out there and then come as a work availability permits to build the ramps and the steps over the course of the Year these are not intended to move here from pin Hurston the next two months to cranes Creek and then to immediately put them in service it is to be ready for the school year 21 22 so we have some time for the opportunity for service you've got you on the um the chart back on before you've got four units at vast Lake View and they're marked to remain at vast Lake View yes and that you didn't talk much about the capacity at vast Lake View and anticipated growth as well so we would leave those there thinking we're going

117to be putting them back into service or would they are they still already being used and would continue to be used um they would be placed back in service there would not be the immediate need for them but there soon would be without clicking back approximately 20 slides or something to demonstrate on the uh charts that I can go back look with the impact changes f l VI still is going to exceed its uh core levels in the soon years ahead very soon and so we will need them to remain in service again that is due to the growth that is happening uh down east from the school uh down the peninsula now that that that sheet you're referring to though isn't necessarily because redistricting would affect that sheet the red could potentially impact well

118it will I mean that's the whole reason why we're doing it yeah that that that sheet will no longer be valid So based on that when your statement is correct but it won't be until we finish our student reassignment plan until we can really answer the question so you're given somewhat of a definitive answer but it's more of a speculative answer at this point that the the truth is that those modulars at vast Lake View could still move as of today we we don't we don't know that they would necessarily have to move until we're completed with the student reassignment planning process so that's want to C make sure that we're we're not confusing anybody we hope we're moving enough children Mr says could be accurate but it also is still subject to change as

119we re-evaluate um the student reassignment plan which is heavily dependent on a professional analysis of traffic congestion in bus route times that is isn't it it's a good lead in we need one successful transition we need one um you're done hearing my voice so right now I'm happy to turn it over to Josh rank you through Amy K he will introduce uh himself to you as well as company and then take you through some of the work and process they have and studies they have completed Madam chair before we get into this transition is this a good place for a break five minute break please we usually wait till the end but I will entertain a five minute break if m Thompson would like one yes that would be great I am so sorry would

120you mind we just keyed you up as well e e e all right I call the meeting back to order thank you for the short break leave it with you all right I'm Josh ranky uh with Ry kempin Associates we're a transportation engineering and Planning Group uh I work out of our Raleigh office uh our North Carolina lead for our traffic Engineering Group so I work on projects across the state both public and private uh worked on probably over 50 schools in the past three years alone split my 16 years of experience between the Chicago area and down now down here in North Carolina so it's a little bit a bit about me um we were brought on board to look at the impacts of the potential redistricting on travel times so we started out

121by doing some data collection and the first slide we've got here I'll go through what we did is uh some key Corridor travel times and the first one that comes up there we're calling that the Midland Road roundabout and what we did is on a day that schools were in session typical morning we sent our data collectors out there between 6:30 a.m. and 9:00 a.m. and what they did was continuously run Loops to kind of see what the peak period was and what the travel times were at different locations um so for this this kind of location here the Midland Road roundabout um we looked at each approach and essentially what was done was when they started encountering traffic they started the clock on the timer until they could get through the roundabout um so

122we looked at each segment approach and got some data collected there going through another key Corridor is the nc5 corridor um so essentially we broke that into segments where there are the little round circles there the red circles uh each one of those segments they took the travel time between segments for a total travel time that could be broken up kind of into each segment there um and what they did same thing they just kept doing runs through that segment to see when the peak time was and what the maximum time was to do those runs yes oop Sor stops yes they were key intersections which were primarily stop lights and the next slide will have a breakdown and we can kind of go through those a little more of what each segment was and

123then the we also did the uh what we call the US1 15501 it's just a a corridor there which went from uh Johnson Street to morgon Road or vice versa depending on the direction um and that was broken down into segments also so going through this and I know these numbers are a little small but what we have is the corridor which on the far left you see the Midland Road roundabout and well that has sort of the segment approaches and the the the times it took um in seconds there are no true I guess Corridor numbers because it was just the individual segments when they hit traffic coming in each Direction each leg of the roundabout they took the times uh so the times you see there uh it shows that the peak times

124travel times were between 7:30 and 8:00 a.m. uh one of the things to note with that is the pattern we saw well we'll be talking about throughout this presentation sort of the peak School times a lot of the peak School times occur uh the traffic for the schools would be slightly before some of these Peak travel times so a lot of that'll be work traffic things like that um and the am is typically your worst case PM is sort of offset for schools during the weekday uh so it was the am we focused on so you can see the the Midland Road roundabout um each one of those segments is one of the approaches so it breaks it down there and kind of has the delay times nc5 uh that's where we get the breakdown

125where it had the different um points in between so you can go see it went from nc211 to McKenzie Road Mackenzie Road to morgon and so on and then sort of the second half of that is the flip route so as soon as they did one pass they turned around and took the times for the pass back and kept doing that all morning essentially to come up with when the peak period was and what those delays were for the peak period um so we also had a a little bit of a focus at Mackenzie Road and at nc5 and got some times there as that was an area of concern and then us 15501 as you work your way to the uh right you can see not just the segment times but then the total

126Peak Corridor travel time and that's going to be in minutes and seconds for the existing data collected and then the columns directly after that what we did is sort of a comparison so Google Maps allows you the internet is fantastic you can get all sorts of data we wanted to see how this compared so we took typical days uh where you can actually program in the day and say what was the travel time at these periods during the day uh sort of a check to see how was that day that we collected data so you can see well we had times for say the nc5 corridor there about 13 minutes and 40 seconds uh Google travel times we're approximately in that time period between 14 and 16 so pretty comparable um you know as as

127you work your way down I think we have uh the US1 15501 Corridor we have about 5 and 1/2 to 6 and A2 minutes depending on which direction during the peak period and around that time period over an average time of 6 minutes for the Google travel so that was primarily to kind of come up with make sure that the data we collected looked pretty accurate um also that the Google time Google Maps uh times would be a good resource go back second to that yes uh just to further clarify when you're reading this as you come across as he said because a question came up at the segments if you take and start with the block that says nc5 that top there the very first segment is nc211 to McKenzie Road that was 149

128seconds to do that segment the next segment which is from McKenzie Road to Morganton Road took 169 seconds so as you go through and review this data to understand what you're reading and how you're reading it and then when you add up all four of those uh segments you reach the 13 minute 41 second for that direction and that'd be from nc211 South to US1 and it's the same thing for the Midland Road roundabout when you look at the approach ways those are all in seconds from that direction until they flow into the circle so as you go through and analyze this and reflect back upon it just to understand what you're looking at all right in this next table um essentially we've got current bus rider travel times and this was uh data that

129was provided to us essentially we sorted through it came up with maximum root times minimum roote times average route times and median roote times and the to give you an idea the times are based on for traveling to school it's when the first student is on the bus until the bus arrives at the school and parks and then for the PM it's the reverse it's when the the school bus starts to leave the school until the last student is dropped off so your am is that's kind of how they how these were calculated um we then broke these down essentially we had data for across the county we broke it down into the different areas so area one two and three would be corresponding to the high schools so area one is uh Union Pines

130High School area two is North North Moore High School and then three is Pine Crest um so those are kind of at the top of the table there you see see the the different maximum times so some of those are pretty long that's just the the worst case we saw during the data collected uh the minimum times you can see those are significantly lower um than we get into average time so that's pretty typical of what we've seen they correspond pretty well to the median times as well so averages is going to be take all the numbers and whatever when you calculate the number of runs per time that's what you get and then the median is sort of that mid ground there um are there any questions kind of how how we collected that

131data or what we're looking at sorry where are you getting the data from exactly we this was provided by uh more County so they had the bus drivers is it the bus drivers or was there somebody on the buses through our senovia systems where we're able to track and identify when the first student gets on a bus and to win the bus parks at the school so through covia systems we use on our all our buses were're able to download and get all this information to the consultant great thank you and so for for each one of the areas no matter the different directions that they were coming to and from what this is indicating is is that for any given direction for example area one it was uh at an hour and 59 minutes

132is that what you're that is correct for area one it's a maximum for the schools do matter and that's the am so it would be going to school okay um and once again you know sort of patterns we saw are you know there there are it tended to be oddly enough some of the PM ones were higher which is a little surprising sometimes because PM traffic tends to be a little lighter um but this is where it was an average for area one taking all the the data we had and then saying in the morning it's it's the first student gets on until the school parks at at the bus parks at the school and then the reverse in the PM so when the bus leaves the school until the last student gets off and

133so we also broke it down um well we had the areas in the top there then we broke it down between elementary middle and high schools um and you're you've got your same thing Max time mtime average times um there you can see it it appears the high school routes were actually TP typically the shorter routes um Elementary were kind of middle and the middle schools were the longest there um and then we did break down uh the exceptional children we isolated that in its own category there so well you see uh the EC districtwide that is not included in the districtwide so districtwide was everything else and we broke out the EC districtwide in its own little category there um was anything considered in the variables with the um morning times with parents dropping

134the children off for work and not using the bus route per se versus in the afternoons using the children using the bus rout because parents would not be picking them up is that one of the variables in there uh well this is just straight up Based on data collected so that would come into play definitely but there are no adjustments to it for that Dr and board members just to excuse me Dr Brown and and board members just to remind you all the purpose of this chart then uh is for the staff to evaluate impacts of new bus routes related to student reassignment planning don't forget that that's that's why we're doing this so so um it it may be um accurate for um a a family to express concern that the new school that

135they're going to go to the bus route is longer than the school they went to previously um but when compared to the average bus route across allore County that new route to that new school it's a little farther may still be very modest compared to what the average route is for the whole County everybody following me on that so it was important that Ry Kemp and Associates identify the median the average and then the range minimum to maximum so that when we evaluate um U changes in in in bus route times that rather than how the new bus route time compares to your previous bus route time how does it compare to all bus routes in accordance with the range the median and the mode all right and and so as we conduct our as

136we um as as the staff attempts to put the finishing touches on a reassignment plan to present in September um we are going to be using these metrics to evaluate what we're getting ready to present when the time comes and then likewise for the public and for the board once that plan is presented you can use this chart then if you receive concerns about bus route time you'll have this chart to make your own determination about how it Compares with all routes across more County and we'll show you a couple of examples our goal today is not to be exhaustive not to uh evaluate every individual bus route or what that impact would be uh we've had a couple of Draft plans that we've put out there some ideas some of which reive some criticism

137and we've responded to that we've listened to the public and we've we've kept in mind some of the uh critical feedback that we received in the spring some questions that we received we've worked hard and worked very diligently this summer to address some of those things and we're going to use a few of those as examples uh as we finish up here so Josh take it from there one one quick question yeah do we really have an EC student on the bus for three hours and 37 minutes in the afternoon according to the data yeah that's a maximum so it could have been once again you see the minimum is 45 the average is uh just under two hours so whether it was you know I'm not sure if it was inclement conditions or traffic

138issues but that was the maximum that was observed of the data we had long bus ride so at any that that's not the average maximum that is at some point during this year there was a child that it took that long to go home correct and that's the complete range on yeah so yeah it would it would be the last student to get off at the worst possible day of the data collected and that's what that time is there for for the EC districtwide so we'll kind of get into um what we just started discussing and what we've got here is I tried to put Graphics to it and then we'll kind of compare it to the table we had previously so there were certain key communities um that we wanted to look at the

139essentially uh two schools the the one that they currently would attend and the potential redistricting um so here and once again red and green I know we're traffic engineer I don't know why we gravitate towards that it doesn't mean slow and fast or anything like that it was just for color comparison um so what we have is the the blue star in the middle sort of there is the J dowy Road community and what we did was we took the then uh the the data from the previous uh from the from the data collected on the bus routes uh for the existing conditions and then we did projections for the potential future conditions so it's essentially providing a comparison of the school they would attend now to the potential School in the future um so

140for this one you can see these are approximate times it's it's hard when you're looking at the future you're looking at historical data and things like that that um you know obviously there are roadway Improvement projects that will have in the future that could change this somewhat but this is based on the data we collected with the data that we got for the bus routes and essentially we've got this one is pretty com com comparable we have approximately 52 minutes for both of these routes so there wouldn't be any expected change or inconvenience to a rider coming from this neighborhood going to either one of those schools and I guess as you look at this I'll I'll pop to the next slide which kind of we can show where that fits in but are there

141any questions with how we looked at um the two different routes okay so keeping in mind this is approximately 52 minutes um these is this these routes actually are significantly lower than the average times I think we had an hour and 10 minutes um an hour and an hour and 9 minutes for area 2 and area three um the elementary school average there we have an hour and three minutes so once again the 52 minutes is lower there um just kind of we'll go to that that's the same chart we saw earlier right nothing Chang kind of so when I'm flipping through to kind of instead of going back and forth we it reoccurs there so we can keep it'll keep after each one of these slides we put it in there um so the

142next one we have here is going to be uh the Eagle Springs community and what we have there is the the trip to West End Elementary and then to Robins Elementry so this one you can see there is a little variance so we have an hour and 13 minutes for the route to West End Elementary and then to Robin's Elementary although the distance is significantly further as you can see on there um that is just actual distance the travel time is is an hour and 23 now once again these are approximate it is based on the data we had for the bus route which is accurate existing and then uh projections for the increase in travel time or or difference in travel time uh for the potential School uh so with this one uh Robins

143I think is in area two oh sorry yeah area two which is and 10 so that's an hour and 10 is your average there so that's uh going to be a little bit above the average so an hour and 23 minutes is slightly higher than the hour and 10 average and then um the West End is that one is area three and that's typically an hour and nine so the hour and 13 is slightly above that as as an average for that area uh once again keeping in mind that the elementary school average is an hour and three so both of these routes are a little bit higher than that that average for elementary schools and slightly higher for their areas I thought this was interesting if I could elaborate just a little bit bit

144the difference occurs when you get to the junction with 705 and so uh with one route you're going to go north on the route itself the circular uh bus route itself picking children up in the Eagle Springs area is somewhat of a circle not exact but it's it's sort of a triangle or three-sided round triangle let's call it okay and um so a good part of that hour and 13 or hour and 23 is just picking up students so the real comparison then is the difference from The Junction with 705 to West End and Junction of 705 to Robins so if you were to take a ruler and and and measure that red line and then go north on the green line and put a mark there it's that last difference on 705 from that

145Mark to Robins that represents that 10 minutes other than that it's all the same and that 10 minutes the bus is not picking up any students so it's just moving and it's moving at whatever the allowable speed is and what the bus can cover there aren't a lot of stop lights or anything else and so it's it's important to bring that perspective to that with the feedback that we got the concerns that were expressed about distance uh and then to measure that against the average route time for the whole District uh I found that to be real interesting when this when this feedback came back um because it's very pertinent it relates directly to some conversation we had last spring no conclusions it was just it just I just found was interesting board members I'd

146defer to you on that so just a question for clarification so the the the routes that are current so for instance it would be the Westend one those are based on current data that we have and where the pickups are and all of that the um and then the one that's future would be the same pickups in in Eagle Springs but then are there are certain assumptions about how many stops additional it makes or is it a a straight shot that that's where it came into play with the data collected and the Google data that we collected of the times that those travel times would be so we don't have additional stops after it branches off there um so it is just a like I said it's an approximate thing it's coming up with the

147best way to predict the future so it's saying yes it's picking up the same amount here when it branches off the increase in time um is expected once again in Google Maps if if there were a situation this one it's pretty smooth sailing if there were something where there were traffic delays at a certain point not because of stops but because of just general traffic in an area stop lights things like that the the Google and the data we collected would account for that increase but it isn't because of additional stops along the way or anything that's helpful thank you and once again that was the table where we showed those those examples there they were slightly higher than the um averages for the area and a little bit even more so higher for the

148elementary schools um the next one we have is uh considered the Foxfire community area um and there we had the new Aberdine Elementary School and West Pine Elementary School comparison uh so this one is they're fairly similar uh they're expected to be about an hour and 28 minutes for the existing and the future uh so once again flipping to the next table you can see that's a bit higher than the average I believe those are both area three and that's an hour and 9 minutes um so you know we're at an hour and 28 Which is higher um once again that existing is pretty comparable to what would be expected in the future and it is uh significantly higher than the just the average Elementary School um and on this one we have have the

149village Acres Community and then we're starting to look at middle schools here so we have Southern Middle School and West Pine Middle School and uh Southern Middle School is approximately 48 minutes and the expected West Pine Middle School is 43 minutes so this one is one where it's slightly less flip oh sorry current is westpine which is 43 and Southern Middle School is 48 so it's slightly higher for that one um once again it's it assumes similar picking up the students and then splitting off uh kind of the direction it heads to those two schools is very opposite uh and this is one where you know a lot of that data collected comes into play here with the route uh so the the expected does kind of take into consideration so this one they are

150significantly lower both of these routes than your averages uh your averages are an hour and 9 minutes for Area 3 and um for elementary schools it's an hour and 3 minutes sorry middle H hour and 16 minutes so even better and this next one we have the Pinehurst number six community so this is another Middle School study and we're looking at Southern Middle School and West Pine again um these ones are very comparable 42 versus 43 minutes so there's really not much variation there of what would you know what is existing and what would be expected um once again very different routes that they take but the projections kind of take into consideration things like any traffic they'd encounter at those Peak periods Josh were you all able to um get get a picture of

151what impact that we would have on the circle if if if U Village acres and or number six were to uh be reassigned to Southern Middle Schools they were in draft one uh that we considered what what would that add to the to the circle um in terms of increased delay um it is something that you know that there would be potentially some now in this case you know we've got both of these routes going through the circle um as you look at that typically what you see is um with the redistricting you might have certain routes that do go through the circle and then other ones that now no longer so it's I don't want to say there's a distinct amount of time we can add or anything like that ours was more taking

152the delays that would be incurred to go through the circle and implementing them in the projections um in terms of forecasting and things like that um like number of cars that we would add you know yeah I think it would probably the parents would would be the bigger impact than the buses on that and a lot of that like I said a lot of these times that we're looking at are not the Peaks that we observed so while we're saying these delays that that we saw when we did out went out there and did the runs and we collected this data a lot of these times would be sort of off peak a lot of times we've seen also that typically parents driving students to school it's sort of something where they're also probably going

153to work or something not just going there and heading straight back so it might be something where they encounter that Circle so it'd be really hard to project that without knowing are they going specifically just to the school would they have gone through there anyway for work um the time period once again our impacts are sort of at a slightly off peak especially with these elementary and middle schools where the peak times we saw would have been they already be at school or really close to the school if it was a middle school potentially um so while there might be some impact it's typically what we've seen in the in the am hours that we counted and the PM because it's not your typical 4 to 6 it would be sort of off peak so

154I'm not sure it would have as significant an impact very interesting thank you does Pinehurst number six go through the traffic circle now John uh it's a continuous right when they go through the circle now um and I think um our bus uh may actually I'd have to go confirm this but I think our bus may actually go across through Village Acer to pick up some more students and then come out on to 11 I was just curious on the time difference that would be versus going through the traffic circle the whole time yeah well that's one of the benefits of right now the service to westpine is that continuous right turn that you have coming down in circle instead of queuing up to enter the circle and once again kind of to give an

155idea instead of flipping back there I'll see just check out my data for that one that one the uh that's around 7:30 to 8 for the the roundabout was where we saw the worst of the worst out there um that southbound approach was Heavy uh we had 234 seconds of when they hit started hitting the queuing until they got through there um you know typically with these elementary and middle schools it is earlier with the middle school I can't remember the let's see I think it's the 8:00 okay so once again they might be hitting at 7:30 um 28 range for the middle school there so that could be during some of the heavier traffic times one of the interesting elements of this and this is something that Josh and I along with uh his

156associate Nate bramy Kemp discussed when you come down 15501 this case it's very open and free flowing between the circle and your first experience of a traffic light in front of uh Pinehurst or Pine Crest high school and then Morganton after that it's a 6-minute measurement and you're right down to Johnson Street when you head out to 11 there's a series of traffic lights and I've never been successful to get through green lights in my experience but aside from that there is a lot of congestion during this time at the school in 211 so at Archie drive in11 to get to the school there is a lot of congestion that happens there and impacts the times because when you would look at that you would think that as you were alluding to miss calwell coming

157out from there seems pretty simple but at this time of the day when that's occurring that the congestions that occurred just those little stops along the way and then over at Archie getting there versus the flow and pattern of that flow coming south on 1551 were very interesting how comparable it made it John can you remind me what time the buses drop in the morning what's the um the latest one that wants to be at school in terms of allowing students to be there in time for breakfast is what is the window is it a 30 minute before school starts not necessar 30 minutes I think it's about 20 minutes as as tight as we like to get 20 to 15 minutes of the student can get something to eat consume it and then get

158to their destination before instruction starts so is it fair to say that they would be at school if they're riding the bus by 7:35 7:40 for the middle schools and about 7:05 I'd have to pull up a a chart that we've been we've developed that shows all that we saw it just a couple months ago yeah or last month okay with the bell schedule and all the times on there I'd have to confirm that with that chart thank you all right so with this one with the uh 42 and 43 minutes um once again looking at the the averages that we got for middle schools and for the area they're in they're clearly well below your your average Aver of 1 hour and 9 minutes for the area and then for the middle schools the

159hour and 16 minutes um next area we've got there is the Pinehurst Lake community and what we looked here at once again is uh Southern Middle School and West Pine Middle School uh once again these are very comparable uh an hour and 16 minutes and projected to be approximately an hour and 16 minutes uh these these ones are slightly higher than the averages the hour averages being an hour and N minutes and then um for the area and for middle schools it's right on so this is this is about as average as you can get it's an hour and 16 minutes for Middle Schools is the average um time based on existing bus ridership any questions with this one um now again uh you're seeing an update on uh what has gotten us to this

160point so far uh planning committee is going to continue to work with the Consultants we have uh engaged with at Ry campen Associates as well as numeric on continuing to refine and develop the presentation and the recommendation that grimy will present at their work session on September 3rd I want to also point out that there has been since the uh development of the out of capacity chart in the future growth there have been some uh developments for residential homes that have recently been approved that were not contained in the original report done by orid example of that is Blake village located off of nc5 and so that along with the Martin property which is adjacent to the current uh abine construction site uh that property those were not contained in the ored uh projections numer

161is is updating that now and so the presentation on September 3rd won't include that in an updated capacity chart so we are being mindful still of development as it changes and continues around the district uh to make sure to the best of our ability we can account for it in what we're evaluating um so again um I want to also uh note that uh September uh 12th at 6 p.m. there will be a public hearing on the proposed plan uh and uh where where the public has an opportunity to provide feedback to the board on the plan that's being proposed in September 3rd we are now open for discussion and questions any John I I have comments on travel time um the public really needs to understand that uh we have a large percentage of

162students that do not ride the bus and I can guarantee you no matter how efficient we get in the routes um if we if we have fewer students the travel time is going to be more if we have more students it's going to be less and you say well why don't you get more buses well several years ago we made decision to change the bus schedule because we need to save $400,000 and that need is not gone away we still continue to need to save that because the funding we're getting from the state for everything else is is averaging a little less than one excluding employees salaries and wages is averaging a little more less than 1% a year increase over the last eight years thanks any other questions or feedback from board members this

163is really helpful I know the biggest questions people had had was about transportation and about the bus routes and I'm I'm it's it's good to see some of this data come out obviously there's a lot for us to look at so thank you for sharing that today and and for giving us that um look at what the data is starting to show any any other questions all right Madam chairman with your permission yes uh we'll now move into the pending action and discussion items um and uh let's see to begin with we've got uh Dr Kim Bard I believe this is first presentation as our director of exceptional Children's Services welcome Dr Bard and she's going to be here a while yes got a few if she does but fortunately there they um annual renewals

164and um she's not spending any more money so I don't anticipate she's going to get a lot of push back Kim all yours good afternoon Madam chair board members and Dr grimy I am requesting a approval on four contracts related to services that are needed for the exceptional children's Department these are contracts that we have had previously and we are renewing for the upcoming school year all contracts being presented for approval have not had an increase in cost from last school year the first of these contracts being presented for your approval is with John E seon and Associates the contract with John E sexon and Associates provides services for more County School students who need ideological Services the cost of the services will be build at $55 per day and will be rendered three days

165each week there will also be the cost of mileage reimbursement at the approved federal rate The second contract being presented for your approval is with s Hills Children's Center the contract with San Hills children center provides services to our students who meet the criteria for services that need to be provided in a developmental day Center the funds are made available through the State Board of Education to assist in providing special education services to students with disabilities in which the local Lea has placed them in a developmental day Center the state reimbursement rate and agreed upon cost is $999 110 per child per month or the developmental Day program rate issued by the Department of Public Instruction for the 1920 school year and shall be paid in 10 monthly payments an allotment of $50 should be

166paid per child per month for Education supplies and materials children entering the center after September 15th 2019 will receive pro-rated funding the contract will serve no more than 35 students ages 3 through 5 the third contract for your approval is with maximum healthcare maximum healthcare services provide services to our students who need individual nursing service as prescribed by each student individualized education plan the cost of these services will be buil at $37 an hour not to exceed 7 and a half hours per day for each nurse required the final contract being presented for your approval is with All-American interpreters for the DEA contract with All-American interpreters for the de provides services to our students who need sign language interpreting Services the cost of the services will be buil at $45 an hour unless requested with

167less than a 24hour notice and then the billing rate will be 6750 an hour there will also be the cost of mileage reimbursement at the approved federal rate currently these services are required for two students as identified by their individualized education plan thank you madam chairman that was a a a different approach than what we've had before but I was really liking it I like it I got the sense you were liking it so I just let her roll uh you want me to have her do the next few yeah I do the only question normally we stop at the end of each one and we ask if there's any questions but you were do great job we can change that anytime anyhow board members this is your opportunity on any one of these four

168um annual renewals that we have please uh direct any questions you have to Dr Bor I thank you for providing the number of students that these are serving that helps with looking at the cost factors and it appears from from the summary that the services are actually provided to where the students are and the location at the schools versus the students having to go someplace um and I think that's great the only question I have is the developmental day cost the the amount that we re reimburse it doesn't appear that it's changed much over the years ma'am is it a true representation of what the cost is that would be something I would have to find out okay I'm just I I just hope it's enough to support those kids but yes I I know

169that that's all mandated so there's nothing we can do about that but thank you at a previous meeting I made some comments about the number of exceptional children we continue to grow within the system I am sure there are people that don't realize what kind of services are actually provided like nursing services and the uh auditory services and whatnot and how specialized they all have to be I'm very proud of the fact that this $120,000 provides for the health needs of two students I'm proud of that I don't want anybody to read me wrong but I think that it is eye openening to some members of the public and some elected officials that that this is just the health needs of these children this isn't just their educational needs exactly and so this is just

170two of our children and and and thank God we're doing what we're doing I mean these are good services that we provide they're worthwhile but I think it's the reality of the true cost of educating in our in our commitment to our our exceptional children anybody else any uh questions for Dr Bullard well done K very well done you welcome back anytime they like you yeah very good um Mr Cox I had had to get caught up with Dr Bullard there she'd gotten ahead of my ahead of me on my agenda here thank item 3E thank you Dr grimy Madam chair all the members of the board um this is the final budget resolution for the fisc year ending June 30th 2019 um I won't go through each item on here or each PRC on

171here but I will touch each fund um the majority of changes within each fund are related to fiscal year end cleanup where we're moving around dollars to make sure we maximize the state and federal dollars that will revert back if we don't spend them so we're doing a lot of Shifting around related to that so for uh State funds our total budget ending uh June 3 2019 was 78 m 420,475 1,523 over the third quarter um and like I said I'll be happy to answer any questions related to any of the specific uh moves in there if you if you have them I think the word is transfers is it transf is transer there transfer transfer our commissioners don't like the word shift okay I promise I promised a few of them we wouldn't use

172the word I I'll take take not notice of that make sure emphasize transfers I appreciate you breaking it down know because it's um visually it's good to see and some of these transfers have to do with the actual number of students that were utilizing those Services right so we may have budgeted at one point for a certain number we got more in and then had to transfer to cover those additional expenditures or got more money in from the state in this case um to cover cover those students okay because I see that with the EC students and the CTE and it right um so on the local fund which we refer to as fund two uh final budget of 31 million $28,900 which is increase of $435,500 we did um increase or utilize 200 additional

173$1,000 of fund balance to cover those expenditures um Auditors are here now will'll know what our final fund balance is we don't anticipate utilizing the full 200,000 but we did it just to make sure we were covered um once the Auditors come in and go through everything so we should have a uh fund balance at year in after the Auditors finish all their work of just over $2 million still over $2 million sorry which is close because 2 million is the cut off correct yes cash fund balance that we need for federal reimbursements management cash flow management Federal reement that's right so so the so if if we're close to 2 million that means that we've come pretty close to depending on on what we're allowed to on in other words no Surplus correct little

174or no Surplus correct uh the third fund federal funds which we refer to is fund3 8,243 311,000 increase of$ 73,74 over the third quarter there local Capital funds for , 108,687 an increase of $1.4 million there that increase is solely around replacement school buses that the state funds that we have to show on our general ledger no change to school nutrition funds $ 5,485 th000 and in local current operations which is what we refer to as fund eight uh final uh budget of 3,688 31 which was an increase of $346,000 over the third quarter uh the main thing I want to point out there you've heard us talk a lot about uh Bridge funding the five nurses I believe it's five nurses a psychologist and counselor that we've gone to the went to the county

175to ask for um we've been funding out a Medicade uh saying that money will run out we have a fund balance of approximately 7 00,000 of that Medicaid funding which covers $600,000 appropriately or approximately $600,000 uh for that staff so we will be out at the end of this year without some additional funding for that or uh having to do something with those positions so a total budget for the year ending June 30th 2019 is 13,784 um and that is an increase of 2.3 million over uh the third quarter I'll be happy to answer any questions questions questions thank you very much thank you mam chairman for item F in Mr Brat's absence I'll go ahead and proceed uh during your July 8th 2019 regular business meeting you approved a deed of dedication for Water

176and Sewer Service to the temp Pinehurst Elementary School execution of the deed of dedication now requires transfer of the water and sewer services to more County Public Utilities the attached release and waiver conveys the improvements to the public utility and acknowledges that all improvements remain in the warranty of one year and that there are not any claims or leans filed against more County schools for the work performed the document has been reviewed by the board attorney and is recommended uh to me by Mr Barth uh that it be approved um essentially uh what we've done is is we got the deed of dedication approved now we have to transfer the uh um the utilities themselves over the county it's a routine action and it will come with the recommendation of my approval you have any

177questions we can bring them up to John later on but um I also was wondering what this was all about and so fortunately it is one that I I can talk a little bit about but um offer it for your consideration are there any questions from board members no all right thank you very much and now uh the staff would appreciate the board's um um Direction on on any of these items that you would prefer to assign to your consent agenda for next week or those that you would prefer to place on board action all consent yes all consent yeah so we're looking at 3A through F correct all of those for consent yes any questions Miss Potter you got that all right okay thank you thank you and with your permission proceed to board

178action at this time I'll invite Dr alpen fails to come forward and I'll turn it over to her and Dr Brown this would be the second reading of new and revised uh policies that were introduced to the board on July 8th Dr Brown we've deleted some of the policies because they are redundant and are already expressed or um written in other um policies and we also are up have updated the um policies to meet with the North Carolina Schoolboard association's policies so that there's parallel there so I move forward to have these recommended to be accepted unless there are questions you make make a motion yes I second so a motion is on the table with Mr Dennison there's a second with Miss Carter any discussion all those in favor to approve the policy say

179a i a long day like feels we try and keep this short and sweet any any opposed no motion carries 60 thank you madam chairman item 4B is one that the board is managing and the clerk and I are um uh very willing to assist in any way we can but otherwise it's it's up for I defer to your leadership thank you and uh thank you for for passing that off um I'd like to talk about a topic that I know is is difficult for us um at our last board meeting um we um announced and and the whole Community knew that that Bruce Cunningham had passed away and at that time we were not ready it was just a few days after his passing we were not ready as a board to to address

180what that meant for us as a board um it does mean that we have an opening and recall about a year ago just over a year ago when Mr Lambert died um we had the same conversation and at that time it was very close to the election that was coming up in um in 2018 and we decided to wait for the voters to decide at that point um today we find ourselves in a little bit of a different situation we are approximately 18 months out for the next election and Mr Cunningham's term expires at our first meeting in December of 2020 so we're a long time out and Miss Carter and I have conferred with our board attorney and he has advised us that the board should appoint someone to fill the vacancy unless there

181are any major concerns um and guess unless there are any major concerns I'd like to use this work session to solidify what our process would be to actually fill that appointment and then just to be sure that you all understand that the appointment that we would make would be up until uh the December 2020 board meeting where we would swear in a new board member that is elected in the November 2020 election so the person that is appointed would be appointed through that time one thing about process that U Miss Carter and I talked about with um our board attorney is that there really is none stipulated by Statute we could use today to appoint someone um somebody could put a nomination on the floor and we could appoint someone um that's one end of

182the process at the other other end of the process we could take months and and committees and all that type of thing so there's a wide variety if we look back at our history um we have done it before and that might be something we want to consider is the process that we've used in the past um one point of clarification too is that we are looking for someone in District 5 so would have to be the district that um Mr Cunningham um was in and that the term that term is the term that is the unexpired term that we have to to fill so um Miss Carter I know that we've had some conversations with our attorney and um did you want to talk a little bit about a suggestion that we could provide

183certainly um in talking and and reviewing the things that were be were done during the last tance of appointment um the board solicited applications from interested citizens those who were uh willing to serve an uncomplete term and entertained written applications uh consisting of a resume and the answer to several questions is U such as what issues they saw ahead of the board or what they thought they might bring to the board um these were narrowed down to those that fit into the districts necessary and the board had the opportunity to um go through these applications and and filter through to S find the ones that uh met the needs of the board at the time um and it would seem to me that the same sort of process might be used as we approach this

184one we know that our options are a little more limited this time because it is a district five seat and so we will need to ensure that uh anyone who applies meets the uh requirements of being from that school district um I would like to see us move quickly because I think we have some very major decisions ahead decisions that will affect those who live in the southern pinees Aberdine District especially um they're going to get new schools and of course their school lines are going to be changing and it would be um very very helpful for us to have a voice from that region um sitting with us on the board and able to provide input from the other folks who live within that District so it would would seem good if we could

185proceed with that on you know on a fair qu fairly quick basis and bring someone on board so um I would like to I I guess I could make a motion and and um move that we proceed to open um a portal on or an online portal for applications possibly opening it tomorrow and allowing a two- week time period in which we would entertain applications um that applications could be submitted both by email to the board chair or by um snail mail to the school office here or uh by personal drop off here at the school office that we ask people to include a resume as well as um answer a question or two such as uh what do you see the role of a board of education member being and what might you bring

186to a position on the board of education and that we allow about two week that we allow two weeks uh ending the time on August 20th to then allow time to assess the applications that have come in um not yet setting a date for the decision in the event that more applications need to be submitted so I can make that as a motion or we can just discuss it now and and see what other feedback you would like to put into um into that area I think Roberts rules has us as a motion because you've made a motion get that as a motion close I think Miss Thompson was about to speak up I just wanted to know if I need a second if I need to make a comment at this point since there

187was a motion initially presented um I I just want a second then okay so we can have a discussion my motion is that we open a period of two weeks for the submission of applications to fill the District 5 seat requiring a resume and letter of intent addressing the questions what do you see as the role of the Board of Education in Moore County and what do you see you will bring to the board of education at the end of two weeks the evaluations would then be evaluated then I would say that the the it's August 6th through the 20th we want to be specific specific dates that would be a two-e period starting tomorrow is that right and that it would be addressed to me either by email or by uh snail mail or

188by hand delivery there wouldn't be an online portal or anything it would just be an email to me yeah mam chairman with permission yeah uh just checking to make sure that we're capable of putting a portal up technically want a portal by email by email I would just clarified that it would be email to me or drop off here or mail here to address to me is there any discussion about that process any question I just want to give you some history on what happened uh when our friend was released there by the old school board that happened on the 4th uh we had three members resign on the the six um we had one resign on the the 9th and we appointed um um Pam on June the 11 that was June that June

189the 7th and 8th we appointed Pam on U June the 11th we appointed Helena on June the 17th and Stacy and Libby on July the 13th so it all happened very fairly quickly Just for information and you did not do an application you were just appointed as was appointed I I actually um had a conversation with Bruce following um the community Forum at Union Pines um and uh Bruce and I connected and I sent a note to um let him know that um I would be uh available and willing to assist if if the board needed me that was an at large position that was an at large position at that time there was flexibility so um so what happened was as as just as you said um it was uh an off time to

190where I had to reapply and go through that process but it was 2015 through the following uh 2016 year to apply right um and we did the same thing um as Ed indicated um once I was sworn in we got a notebook full of applications of say 6075 that we looked through and we narrowed down um and selected potential candidates um and then we selected and and bought a nomination for to the board to to vote on so there is a motion and a second on the table like to make one one other point too it famam said there at this point there were only three Charles and Bruce and myself so Bruce and I talked and then we talked and what what we talked about then I talked with Charles about so that all

191three of us knew what was going on before any appointments were made Just for information but all individually though not as a group of note I've also spoken with the board of of Elections and because there could be some confusion about residency requirements uh they stand by ready to answer questions for anyone who is interested uh they will make sure that they live in the in District Five and and would meet the criteria so it would take as a a quick call to the Board of Elections and they will know well if they don't what I did is I just took all of them down there the Board of Elections and they told me which ones were in which ones were up any further questions or discussion there's a motion in a second all those

192in favor say I I any opposed motion carries 60 um because it's a two-e turnaround it would be um helpful that this information get out um we have something for you we can draft something for you before we leave today Miss Murphy to put up on the Facebook page um make sure that we get that out and uh obviously reach reach out to um those that might be interested that live in that that area so um board comments is the last item on the agenda is that correct yes it is Miss Thompson or who wants to go you said you want to go first I I have a a piece of information that I'd like to share um in July we had several speakers address the board concerning the Moore County Schools grades as they

193were giving information I did think that all was said was correct so I decided to research this information and my source is the NC DPI Department of Public Instruction website as well as information received from Communications Department and the accountability offices first let me address the grades for more County and our surrounding counties I reviewed eight counties that touch more County and one County where a number of our residents work chadam county has no a grade schools celin has five Harnet has none Hoke has none Lee County has one Moore County has none Randolph County has one Richmond County has one and Scotland County has one what was not said is that all of the a schools with the exception of two are specialty schools their Early College programs or ones that require specialized types

194of magnet areas they're categorized um as with applications and for those students who are specifically selected so the ones with a grades with the exception of the two schools one in both of them in Cumberland County one in elementary school and one a high school um currently 72% of the Early College programs in the state outperform the schools in their districts in reviewing the information about more County from 2016 to 2018 three of the 23 schools were not graded Aberdine ele primary Southern Pine primary and the Community Learning Center at Pinkney 75% or 15 of the schools stayed the same during these three years period 15% or three of the schools came up a letter grade 5% or one of the schools went down a letter grade and 5% or one school went up one

195year and then down the next in 2016 more County schools had only two two schools where the growth was exceeded 15 schools that met growth and three schools that did not meet growth in 2017 more County had five schools that exceeded growth 11 schools that met growth and four schools that did not meet growth in 2018 more County schools had eight schools that exceeded growth eight schools that met growth and four that did not meet growth interestingly there is no consistency as to which which schools exceeded met or did not meet which any good educator means that each year with different students we get different results I have a chart that I'll pass on to um Miss Anna so that she can put this up on the minutes to show which schools are over the

196three-year period And I chose 2016 to 2018 because that's when I came on the board um what I have seen as I charted the schools is that in 2016 we only had two schools that growth was exceeded and in 2018 we now have eight schools that have where growth is exceeded over the three-year period more County schooled average 1633 out of 20 schools tested that either stayed the same or came up in their grades do we have room to grow yes and improve yes but we have plans and our refer people to the individual School Improvement plans which are working to know that we have this and that we have the eight schools that are now exceeding growth that's 400% growth folks I mean I don't know much any place else that has that kind

197of growth which means that something good is happening and something positive is happening in our schools more county is making progress with dedicated teachers competent administrators and caring parents and with this continued support we will carry on making the Positive Growth that we have thank you no comment there I don't have anything I actually do and I don't mean to bring be Debbie Downer but I wasn't here um last time when you all said comments about Bruce and I was wondering if it was okay if I said something to him you may and also next week at our our um session we'll also do a remembrance for him just so you know that oh wonderful but you're free to do it now okay thank you um I have served on the board of education with

198Bruce since 2015 when I was appointed Bruce quickly took me under his wing and I'm so grateful that he did he saw something in me that I at the time didn't see in myself I often SE Bruce's guidance and his viice he always had this way of sorry of just of just listening to me making me feel that my voice matters BR thank you Bruce had has Bruce always had this way of giving me advice and making me see the whole picture and situations without even saying a word to me to say Bruce was a huge advocate for our schools is an understatement he spent countless hours thinking of ways to improve our community and our schools one memory that sticks my head was when he called me up on Sunday day to tell me

199he was driving around all week to look at the traffic patterns for our bus routes another time he told me he was up at 4:00 a.m. thinking about our redistributing plan yes these are behind the scenes of what a board member goes through but but with Bruce Bruce I'm sorry but with Bruce's outside of the box thinking I'm sure an can agree he had many sleepless nights Bruce had visions that he shared with me before he left for Ireland he was so excited about his trip and for the upcoming months ahead he told me he would he told me he would drive by McD's Creek and just sit in the parking lot in awe he was looking forward to the ribbon cutting on that school and Bruce was beyond proud of the new schools being

200built especially one in Southern Pines I know I will honor the friendship and guidance he gave me every day I'm grateful and honored to have known Bruce Bruce was an exceptional board member a lawyer and most of all friend to me he definitely made his mark on this community in our hearts I'm sorry I got motional at the end that's it thank you that was beautiful sorry no and it's important to remember all that he has done for us and for this community and and it'll be remembered I remember doing our tour at mcde Creek the other day you said Bruce and I help pick those colors on the floor we sure did so every time know that every time you see that pattern of tazzo I can't remember where exactly we were standing but

201um we'll think of him he's with us he really is he really is and and thinking about that I I would hope and and um we didn't say this with the resumes but I hope people put their unpaid positions as well as their paid positions because sometimes some of the meaningful work that we do is some is in a volunteer capacity and what we give of ourselves just as Bruce did um for 40 years here in Moore County so I hope I hope that is um something that we all consider anything else Miss Carter sorry no I got emotional for I didn't mean to I wasn't planning on it um and at our next board meeting on Monday we will um have a plaque that we present um to the family and so um it'll

202be our opportunity as a board to to honor him and and remember remember him as well so that'll be next Monday wonderful thank you yes I move meeting I there's a motion in a second all those in favor say I I motion motion carries thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.