CorpusRecord 214760

Orange County, NC BOE Finance & Capital Needs Committee of the Whole Meeting - January 22, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Orange County, NC Board of Education
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Orange County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,804 words · about 77 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e I'm just testing can you hear me yes ma'am Miss Hower I can hear you good let's try something else that works too right ma'am I can see you can you see screen I can thank you you're welcome thank you for setting this up at the last minute shout out goes to your technology team I'm just here to help the connect the dots but yes shout out to the technology team team I see Joseph I see Ryan every time Jo Joseph every time you show up I think about covid how's it going okay how are you pretty good good remember those days when you were trying to keep us going that was quite a Time yep that it's quite a time good evening Miss Hower thank you for the shout out you bet

002you bet and Ryan I will admit I still don't I just got a two Monon delay on lumos so if my camera goes off it's going to be because I'm getting unstable connection but right now everything in my house is off except this computer so got it so I may be in your house in about 20 minutes Ryan welcome um I went ahead I went ahead and got a good connection so I got I got plenty of bandwidth oh man I'm jealous man I'm jealous I'm only at 400 gigabits and I'm like I'm itching I want the gig I want it well will told me that shiron Grove is getting lumos oh you know which is already had Spectrum you know and down here I'm at bright speed at three megabytes per second at the

003whopping speed of three megabytes per second oh my yeah don't be I can survive that misser get oh what's the what's the satellite one I'd probably be getting that can handle that I I had that I had that for a while it's not very good no even it didn't work and now you know um uh starlink is getting better because they're throwing more satellites up you know a bunch of my neighbors have starlink but I keep thinking that lumos is going to be here and so I think they're saying February now so it's supposed to be June then it got moved to December and now it's February yeah because I feel like we I thought you told me it was they were running the lines down your driveway oh they what they did is they

004ran conduits if you go all over the county they run these orange conduits but they haven't connected that's what those okay they haven't connected any fiber and I would have been happy with a cell tower because even after they do this my cell service isn't great either so there's that yep AT&T what AT&T Verizon what do what do you have out there we have both AT&T is a little better so I'm on AT&T gotcha yeah I got Verizon it's been it's been I've been fairly pleased with it since I moved here so I'm not not complaining it's different in different parts of the county now everybody pretty much has service it's just there are some parts that don't have enough cell towers yeah cover doesn't split all the way across yeah I get it yeah

005and then with the mobile networks what happens is and Ryan correct me if I'm wrong here but as I understand the mobile networks when you go to rush hour you get um lots of competition for the bandwidth so the residential users get kicked off so someone told me I should switch to a a low entry level um commercial plan yeah commercial plan yeah I've heard that too audio and what is selected as your micop um microphone array okay that's the right one and then um so if you hit the if you hit the the little icon there that looks like a mic with a red line on it if you click that does it make your mic hot it's hot now we can hear you we hear you an okay they hear they hear me

006we hear you welcome thank you I couldn't get my microphone to work because I was doing the wrong thing imagine I see Mr Mr Richmond Dr Jones Mr Davis who else there we go Dr pack nobody wants to hear that Mr Richmond fre I'm surprised you came back I am too I just got back in probably one o00 this morning in Raleigh dang well you came home to some cold what that was good way to wake up I came home to a punch in the gut you're supposed to say a Brisk winter day [Laughter] yeah um we're happy that you're back safe and sound well thank you I'm glad to be back honestly I mean you know it's Jamaica was beautiful the food was great and uh I enjoyed it but I was ready to

007come back home especially my wife complaining about seeing her dog well I was going to say I bet Oreo was happy to have you back yes he was well Andre I I adopted Skipper did you really I did you he's mine congratulations he's sitting right here oh yeah yeah so that's good he's a good boy these golden doodles are killers they're really great dogs they are so hello welcome Miss Padilla thank you hello how are you okay you staying warm yes how about you I'm trying it's um it's it's better it's better it's GNA be okay Spring's coming spring is on the horizon I know it is you're right an and the days are you can notice that the days are getting longer so that's a good thing too right more light yeah that's helpful

008so we have more four minutes and Sarah so we have everybody with Sarah M oh Will's not on yet either Sarah and will yeah we're about three uh three minutes everyone looks like Miss Doyle is on as well y hey y'all welcome Miss Doyle good to see you I'm just printing my uh documents so I'm gonna step away real quick sounds good and I didn't [Music] see and Rhonda's not on yet either I saw readed Rhonda Franklin can you hear me yes ma'am my screen does not want to go up and down to show me the agenda oh I'm I'm sharing screen okay this is me I'm controlling that yeah I'll be driving behind the scenes for everybody presenting tonight um I just got an email from Miss Smiley her machine is doing an update

009she said she'd be on in a minute okay good and Miss wrath is out sick so I will be filling in for for her this after this evening okay and Dr P She if there are questions for her she's not feeling well either so she probably won't turn her camera on just to FYI okay I'm sorry everybody's so sick the thing to do then Dr pack is just say oh my internet connection's not going well I'm gonna turn my camera off works great sounds good thank you and if if my camera I've been today right now everything's good famous last words but if U my connection gets unstable I will turn my camera off I apologize in advance if that happens and if anybody asked this is also being streamed on YouTube I just got

010confirmation that it's it's live and up great sounds good so um for everybody in the public now that we know um I I'm I guess I I'm not able to print in my home computer I mean printer so uh but I do have the file and I looked at it so I can go ahead and add the printer to this computer even though it belongs to you I don't want to add any of my personal stuff to the computer personally I guess that would be a Ryan question okay I will talk to Ryan or I will send an email to Dr Jones okay thanks it's good we have we heard from will has anyone heard from will I have not I have not I can message him hey Wendy I end up uh printing the

011documents from my personal computer I kind of go through this extra step for your question I don't I don't know that it matters but it work thank you I I rather not I got you yeah I like to walk a fine line between personal and work thank you I yeah I try to keep them separate too but when it comes to printing it's hard for me to print from the the board computer yeah I yeah thank you is Will Will just came on on and you said Sarah needed a minute Franklin she said her machine was updating about looks about two minutes ago so she would said she would join as soon as that the machine is updated okay that hurt um do you want to do um do we want to go ahead and

012start we have a lot to cover and then we can get through at least the agenda the minutes and see if she'll come on by then is that is that okay everybody you want to give her five more minutes what do you want what's what's the pleasure she's joining now oh there we go great hey there yeah I was gonna about to text uh Franklin and say don't wait for me got it welcome to Smiley thanks Sarah glad you're on GL you're on hey so um let's get started I'll call the meeting to order Bam um and thank you all I just want to thank you all for coming and for your flexibility with rescheduling and with shifting to Virtual and today you know our big goal today is to get everybody's input on the

013uh Capital the 10year CIP and then we we'll talk a little bit about Bond projects and budgets um and I think as you all know that our goal is to get the um CIP ready for Monday so it's so um it could be approved and then go on to the county um so why don't we start agendas um Frankin is can you put up the whole agenda okay any um is everybody okay with the agenda can get a motion do I have to roll call on this or can yes okay yes so um any can I um motion to approve the agenda so moved second okay roll call um um I'm gonna go first name alphabetical Andre yes and yes Harry yes Sarah yes Wendy yes will yes and I vote Yes okay and then

014the minutes so the agenda is approved minutes any comments or questions about the minutes no okay motion to approve second okay roll call we start go in reverse will yes Wendy yes yes Sarah yes Carrie yes an yes Andre yes and I vote Yes okay so we're approved so let's go right into the CIP and uh Fred do you want to take us through that good evening um board members Madame chair um before I begin Dr Jones would you want to summarize anything prior to we diving in into the material nope I think you got it all right um and please forgive me um virtual is is kind of my cryptonite I like to see face- tof face interactions and know that uh what I'm speaking um you have any questions I kind of read

015uh body language so um if I need to stop um I guess raise your hand or I'll try my best to to pause for additional comments um concerning um our slides franking will help us navigate this U thank you so much uh and I just want to say thank you to our operations team even though school was not in session today and tomorrow our team have been essential in making sure when it's safe for students and staff to arrive uh that we have the necessary entrances and roadways safe and clear um and so I just want to make a point of privilege to thank our whole entire operations team from safety security knowing the weather reports Transportation maintenance and even Child Nutrition because we still have deliveries that happen even we're not in school so

016the coordination that goes along with that um and so thank you uh next slide please so uh we are here uh to talk about a couple of things um bring you up to date on our Capital spending and how it is allocated uh by Orange County um municipality um provide updates on the current capital projects that are on the capital Improvement plan list um provide some information of why the numbers that you saw on that Capital Improvement plan uh is formally referred to as a cash flow providing you guidance why we use cash flows and the importance uh when doing a capital Improvement plan and also providing you update on the projects that are in the capital Improvement plan that are significally funded through bonds that were approved in November of 2024 next slide please

017we want to always have our mission and vision at the Forefront of all that we do and so we just want to highlight that the mission here at OCS is to prepare every learner for lifelong service and success and while educating students in a safe inclusive environment where we engage Challenge and Inspire them to reach their maximum potential next slide please so um now we will just go over briefly uh how the county has financed our Capital Improvement and our spending uh next slide please and so it is imperative that we know a little bit to be dangerous about where our funding comes from and because what we don't want to happen is the narrative that we just received a bond uh and what individuals think Bond Fund should be supporting or not necessarily being

018supported in that manner um however we would do a great job as you will see in our transparency while laying out the various buckets as you see here from County financing being you know bond which is majority of the funding supplement of deferred maintenance recurring Capital Lottery funds some debt financing and um article 46 tax proceeds uh as highlighted in the cash flow that was sent um these are going to be on a year-by-year basis again all of these funding sources are tied to the County revenue sources and so we can only forecast for the year that we're going into as uh things may become different year-to year on a year-to-year basis and that's why the capital Improvement plan is for a 10year but every year we will look to re-evaluate and analyze it based

019on U the funding sources provided to us by the county uh next slide please so again this is further reiterating where the $212 million of capital funding over the next 10 years will be appropriated and what those sources of funds will be used for and so when mainly a majority of those will be for a high Capital need such as a new school a replacement school and comprehensive renovations to our building portfolio as well as satisfying some of our other priorities such as life safety making sure we have adequate Ada accessibility upgrades to our hardware and lighting uh as well as making some of the life cycle system improvements like roofs Furniture fixtures playgrounds uh and then continue to improve our indoor air quality by uh changing out the major components such as chillers boilers

020and HVAC controls next slide please and so there was some monies from from last year's budget that rolled over uh and as we continue to be transparent in how we're spending we had approximately 26 million from the fiscal year 2023 to 2024 budget to roll over with an additional 15 million provided to us by the county and fiscal year 2425 which total to amount of $41 million in capital funding provided to us of that 41 million 19 million um is in projects that are currently encumbered meaning that we have contracts involved in all of those projects that are wrapping up or should have been wrapped up um as we speak um as well as we have 11 million in new projects that we'll speak specifically on uh early later on in the slide deck as

021well as we have some projects that are pending approval uh some that you have already approved of the total amount of $10 million so we do have a plan um we thank the county for um the funds that we we have been allocated uh and it looks like we're on the right track to make sure that we are excellent and efficient in our Capital spending next slide please so here's a current update um that spans two fiscal years we're currently in fiscal year 2025 getting ready for fiscal year 2026 so here's a couple of updates uh that we have for you on the projects that are currently underway next slide please and so we have the second phase of the um Orange High School Renovations um some restrooms band rooms um just some major life

022cycle improvements paint um fixtures uh and Equipment along with that project um we will also be Paving the soccer lot and the staff lot and a Orange High School Paving project uh the nor the New Hope Elementary School um building envelope which considers the roof was approved last month uh and we will uh be starting that mid spring summer um that project is a duration of 180 days from uh notice to proceed um the Ceder Ridge High School ad building we are going through the necessary zoning requirements by the County Planning Department uh we are currently on track to bid that workout this spring around March April uh and hopes to start construction um early summer really excited that project uh we've had some Community engagements uh and what we have heard so far is

023that everyone is positive and ready for the exciting structure at Cedar Ridge High School we're continuing the second phase of effn cheats interior upfit Administration has been pleased and that has been going smooth with the transition of moving from one phase to the other with little choice um you could imagine um the work that has to go to navigating that kudos to the principal there at um effin cheeks and then as we continue to make sure that we're safe there were two properties that did not have secure veses uh that was Pathways Elementary uh as well as partnership Academy and so we've hired engineers and designers to uh come up with an efficient way to secure our vestibules for entry uh making sure um people are where they're supposed to be um safe and sound

024we will be uh a part of life cycle renovating um ALS standback middle school with uh hbac Renovations mainly the air handler units which control the amount of air heat and cooling that come out we're replacing eight of those units on that work should begin this summer as well it is in the design procurement stage at this point and then we are constantly improving our technology by uh upgrades to our intercom systems that are outdated and need to be replaced uh next slide please so uh Capital Improvement plan um each year we have to bring our Capital Improvement plan to the county um that showcase the amount of funding that we think will be required for the projects that are currently slated on our list uh next slide please and so uh the importance of

025a a cash flow uh is twofold right it it helps us manage our debt financing uh it prioritizes our projects it helps us monitor our Financial Health uh and ensure sustainability and transparency as well as accountability when you talk about managing debt financing um we get our our majority of our funding will be from bonds which are loans and so ensure that we uh give the county the proper information of when their debt obligations will be upon them a cash flow is beneficial to making sure that we're align um with the county as well as it helps us again to prioritize our needs the cash flow helps us prioritize what are Urgent and what may be safety concerns and what may be educational benefits uh and there also again monitors of financial help each year

026that we do the cash flow uh the revenue sources and the um funding sources may change and so as we see that as well as we continue to match uh the con cost of construction some things may uh Teeter to um another fiscal year um given whatever the Financial Health is of the county at that time and then of course sustainability is a major uh a factor uh that helps with uh Energy Efficiency long term cough s of when we replace certain equipment and fixtures uh and what's most important is the transparency and accountability this will show um the community as the board where we're spending our money when certain facilities are being touched uh so that we are Equitable in our Capital dollar spending uh next slide please all right so Bond planning next

027slide so um we congratulations we received 125 million of the bond that was voted on by citizens in 2024 uh which uh states that we will look to build one new replacement Elementary orange Middle School improvements and new additions and comprehensive Renovations uh districtwide that support school adequacy and 21st Century Learning uh I'll bring this to you your attention because we're at the stage now where if the priorities need to be realigned um our goal is by the end of this fiscal year which is June 30th uh we will provide direction to the county on the first project um that would be um a part of the 125 million over 10 years um once that decision uh is made um the other projects that are on this list will be re re-evaluated uh each year

028as we continue with the first project as fundings uh may be different as well as priorities of the board uh may change and so while these projects have been stated as where we will um move forward uh it is the board who who can ultimately determine on whether or not these are the three projects that uh fully come through fruition over the next 10 years next slide so whenever again we want to always keep to the Forefront that when we looking at our bond outcomes and the decisions that we make um we want to make sure that we always looking to enhance our teaching and learning environments uh advancing a student and educational outcomes we want to make sure that we improve a school utilization provide students with flexible spaces necessary for multiple learning styles

029I want to make sure that we have school adequacy by updating our classroom spaces to meet the tools of new uh educational standards and right sizing our portfolios to make sure that we can provide the support staff like Child Nutrition and transportation um to the facilities that we have in the district uh while making sure we are investing our community that attracts and entertains um residents by providing a per competitive [Music] schools next slide so uh as we gear towards doing the work planning engagement and development um here is a forecast of where we'll need your support as well as the community uh to get all stakehold engagement and so right now um January of this year we're looking at doing some feasibility studies and informational Gathering um on some of our existing facilities as

030well as what would be scenarios that would be feasibility for uh Orange County Schools U we will still continue that planning in February and March um again and bringing you data that talks about cost feasibility based on ncdpi standards of Renovations and demolitions as well as more information through our data collection um that provides you scenarios uh and feasibilities on what will be the first project for Orange County of the 2024 Bond and then along the the late fall winter and spring we will have opportunities to you review that data with many stakeholders yourselves as well as community and administration uh who impact the lives of students in the built environment on a day-to-day basis uh the ultimate goal is in May um based on that information and data collection and presentations that the board

031would have a project uh that will be lifted to the county for our first project using 2024 bond funds next slide please so again here's this a project timeline of where we are and where we want to be keeping us on target um again we're in fiscal year 2025 and so now we're doing the work of planning and engagement and the feasibility of our bond options and projects once that has been established we will begin um with the planning and design of what that project is um by procuring designers and Engineers as well as the board making resolutions and decisions on what type of delivery method um we put this here because we cannot determine what the delivery method would be until we know what that project is there are several projects that could come

032to the surface and there are several delivery methods that have pros and cons based on that project uh that is will be determined um but once that's been determined um of the total project budget that requires around 10% of those finances and the majority which is 80% the bid in construction will happen between uh the fiscal years of 20 26 and 2029 most elementary schools uh around 24 months um and so we've factor that into our timeline and then the last part is the the 10% close out making sure uh we have furniture fixture equipment and the resources um so that the school can open on day one after that is uh finished we will then re-evaluate where we are with Bond funding perhaps during that time there may be some priorities the board would

033like to lift up to the Forefront as well as our schools will continue to age and so there may be some other priorities uh given the facility ages of our whole portfolio that may rise to the surface at that time uh either way uh it would be recommended that a new facility condition assessment be performed at that time uh to make sure that we're equable in decisions uh on what projects um to support um after this project is complete next slide please and so here are a couple of factors um that U we can um kick off um that we know will be considered uh when we determine what that project is um land availability and so whether we look to build on an existing site that Orange County Schools currently owns or whether we

034have to uh look for a green site um this me means that additional cost out of that total 125 million will have to be incorporated in the decisions that um this board makes as well as uh are we at standards we don't want to design anything that is below the standard of ncdpi and so we want to make sure that whatever we're designing um conforms to the educational adequacy and standards of the state of North Carolina um the decisions uh also will include capacity how how big where's the growth uh looking at data like saf will help us determine and understand um those decisions that will impact our capacity as well as our overall operations portfolio and management again as we make sure I like to use right sizing the district want to make sure

035we can support students of Staff with those other operational needs such as Child Nutrition Transportation uh and Athletics or extracurricular activities and so um the decision of where that school and what that school is uh taking in those operational management um into factors in consideration will also be uh important as well as overall just operation efficiency um is it going to be feasible and so we're working um with a thirdparty consultant a design engineer um to look at all of these factors and maybe more through this discussion um that you would like us to look at uh to bring with you in the months ahead kind of uh a scenario based decision U that would help you perhaps um get to where we ultimately want to be and kicking off a project fiscal year 2026

036um swing space u whether it is an existing building where do the students go that uh may be in that building during the interim two to threee time frame uh School scheduling uh we have two types of school scheduling year round and are traditional so those also have to be uh factoring as well as always our budget um and they're not making any more land and uh the economy is continuing to move in a direction where uh cost and time will be uh important and then again as we talked about our project delivery method and so uh depending on the project the time the scope um there are various delivery methods that we can bring before this board and determine through a resolution um based on what that project is what type of project delivery

037method um the board would like to use uh and so with that next slide Please Mr Franklin um we'll leave it there for discussion I know that was a lot and I apologize if I may have gone over it fairly quickly but happy to answer any questions um from this presentation and if you were questions from the CIP that you received uh earlier this week or last week thank you so do you want because there's two parts one is um you've talked about kind of the strategy going forward but then there's the CP that we're going to be hopefully approving on Monday and so I don't know if you want if the board wants to which is much different you know as as we all know the CIP is the 10e spending plan and the

038county will kind of look at the whole plan but will commit funding for 2026 so I don't know which would be easier Fred do you want to put those the CIP up is that okay for the board to put the CIP up and focus on that and then come back to this or or start or um are there questions about the material that BR just presented and I say I can't see Arrow um hands up or anything so just shout out uh uh board member Hower if I make a recommendation um I think if there are any specific questions to the CIP um I would prefer they be asked um the CIP is a living document and um it's going to be continue to be refined as we get more information on cost and feasibility

039of those projects that are listed um but I I'll lean to you madam chair if you if you would like for us to post it um yeah let's put up the CIP there are questions very specific questions about the CIP I'll share with the board some of the things that we've discussed and the board has discussed to just bring it get oh Sarah has a question I I mean Bonnie you can finish what you were gonna say and then again I was just gonna say that um you know the the um there's there's been some questions about projects that we've been doing and what's going what's happening and making sure they show up in the CIP I'll give you an example um the Orange High School restrooms very interesting project and um I think most

040of us remember that uh you know the project really had three parts one was the student restrooms one was The Faculty restrooms and one was the Fieldhouse and the um student rest correct me if the student restrooms were done they're beautiful I believe the faculty restaurants are done I haven't seen those but the Fieldhouse restaurant rooms Fred has told me was not in the scope of the original work but is in the scope of is something that you're planning to do this year is that correct that's correct it is a part of those projects that we listed in the presentation that will be happening over this summer right same so that's just an example of a project project that that somehow got lost in the transition and is back on is back on the list

041um another one so and and Fred you spoke about the F1 cheeks that were through the second phase I believe the project had four phases and when I look at the CIP and I I look at the CIP I don't see the later phases in the CIP and are those funds elsewhere it gets a little confusing because some it's a project approv someplace else so I can speak specifically to that and so again this is a living document and so from my um understanding of the history of the project uh as we look at our overall portfolio and our capacity uh there may not be a need to prioritize additional funding for Capital Improvements at effin cheeks given the decisions that the board makes on the next new school uh for instance if the scenario

042is that we build a new school and it's somewhere in close proximity to other schools uh then it wouldn't be in good faith for us to spend money on a school um that doesn't have capacity needs at that time does that make sense actually it doesn't um it doesn't we um although I there's a contro F1 is controversial because we're doing interior improvements and I don't know if those fall under wur one two three but um we did and you just mentioned that we're through phase two it was four phases to essentially do every floor every window every door everything in in the entire school over the next four years and we have I I could see in the budget that we even have the modular units leased out for a couple of years and

043the only question so and you mentioned earlier that we're through phase two um which is wonderful and so the question is are we going to continue on with three and four or have you put a hold on that or you saying I put you put a hold on that till we see where we're going long term we're saying that right now we're not projected to spend money at effin cheeks in that capacity giving the other projects in our building portfolio that take precedent in priority um however uh if that is a need for the district at that time uh we will continue to move money has allocated to support each School in their unique um needs and so um what I'm saying is that we are on track to finish phase two and as that

044is finishing and as the lease of the mobiles that have the students in those spaces while we were renov renovating the old spaces come available offline we will see whether or not an addition um to phase three and four would be needed at that time okay because um is that okay with the board I mean I I I hear that I hear I'm hearing that we're um because the count is going to look at this and they're going to approve fiscal 20 whatever we put on this chart for 2026 and that's what the board really needs to get are people okay with that Sarah you want to well m mine was a a comment on something else in the CIP so I mean I I think you know prioritizing among the very many projects makes

045sense to me and so a lot of these are feel like will part level one two three types of projects roof Replacements and HVAC and security and things like that so um I don't have further thoughts I think on your question about effland um uh my question was about um the alc back hbac replacement so I was glad to see that on there because feel like it had been further down sort of on the priority list but I had been hearing from some staff members there for years about just like the extreme temperature Extremes in some of the rooms and so I was wondering if that HVAC project would solve that problem um and address some of the like temperature variations in the building yes and no um it is one piece of the puzzle

046um we will be needing um to come in like most of our schools and look at some controls um once we have the the main piece of equipment which is the air handler that blows out the air um then we will need to be able to control in temperature per set but it will provide uh much needed thermal Comfort um to those in those spaces that weren't getting enough adequate air flow um so there still be more work to do if that answers your question okay and so that isn't on like the near term uh the like controls and things are not on the it is not um but as we continue to comb through um the needs of the district um what I have found helpful is to uh so the Whooper report uh

047was great um there are things that were not looked under the hood and so uh when we talk about hbac I am recommending that we might look at working with Johnson Controls or Snider to do a more in-depth review of our systems that will provide us a prority list that would include Al standback but other schools so we know what components to put first our monies in uh to um extend the life of our whole systems um and so that hasn't been done yet um but a part of uh how I like to work is through a plan and so uh we will be allocating Monies to develop those plans so we can share that information so you can see how we're prioritizing hbac needs as well as other system needs throughout the county great

048thank you right so um yeah I mean I see it as something that we're asking for for right for this year right which um you know that makes sense to me um any other questions from Carrie Mr Davis and Bonnie feel free to punt this question to another section if you want um I I would like to hear so I have two questions one I would like to hear a little bit more about holding off on the phase three and four of of effin just so I understand but I feel like it's making sense with what Mr Davis is saying about kind of re-evaluating and once certain levels are complete comparing it to other priorities um I also had a question as I was reviewing the minut from November um we talked about how there

049was like a $29 million gap in like our Capital planning um but then we talked about tonight like in slide seven there was a fiscal yield year 24 rollover of 26 million um and I'm just trying to remember how you know where those rollovers come from and do we often have a roll over so the fact that we had a $29 million gap um shared in November um is that something that we aren't ringing our hands about because these rollovers kind of happen as we're as you're going through projects and re-evaluating all did that make sense it does and I hope I can answer it the best way but just let me know if I don't so the first question about effin cheeks um I I have come to this district and have been able

050to assess how we have been planning and um determining projects uh and for the effin cheeks face three and four uh I would like to utilize those skill sets on determining whether or not we need to move forward on phase three and four giving the whole entire District portfolio uh and that will come from further assessments as well as decisions that this board makes with the funding that is currently already allocated um and your second question is not abnormal or um for district needs to be less than what districts are funded and so that Gap that you see while it is unfortunate I can tell you um for my time in other counties that Gap is is tremendous ly closer than what most districts see when it comes to Capital Improvement needs versus Municipal funding

051um we will work um with the county um and and again as we see with most um economies now our need has just ballooned um and there's no way given the revenue sources for us to be at a zero sum game we would love to have the need reflect the funding um but again as we go through each year working with the county on the funding projects will be uh tethered and designed so that we can ensure we can get them done with the funding so that means that projects may get pushed back giving the total amount of money that we have in that year as well as giving the priority that this board has set so let me just clarify first of all and I I want to go go back on the effin

052side and you know last year when we approved it I remember having a conversation about exactly what you're doing Fred and that's should we be holding off in order to see what's what the long-term plan looks like so I'm I I actually thank you for doing this and the lease agreement also was giving us the the modular units is also giving us extra capacity in the building that we've needed so so that that all makes sense on the the funding issue that Carrie's talking about and was Rhonda was going to give it to us I don't think she had the chance time to put it together but the board is having some problem with transparency around capital and we've learned the hard way that we had over $40 million in capital that wasn't visible to

053us that W and we didn't know it wasn't being spent and so we've started to spend that but it's hard to tell from this so Ronda was give us a Reconciliation of all and some of it goes back to the 2015 Bond but Ronda was going to give us a Reconciliation of the whole thing um we we won't have that tonight we will get that to the board or let Dr Jones can we get that to the board because um it's it's very confusing it's very confusing um um certainly because we don't know as a board what it looks like I have another question around it I'll hold it but um but that's where that comes from it's not just the cash doesn't just flow we had money that we approved the project it was

054put in a in a pot someplace and never spent and we didn't have visibility to the that we were sitting on all this money and to the point where the county was threatening to take it away and so say if you guys don't need it we'll take it back so that's what we're concerned so we don't have have the full reconciliation of that so I hear what you're saying on so it's it's it's not a need funding issue it's a an accounting issue and a Rec Capital funding reconciliation issue right Carrie mik getting that correct that that's what you're asking about possibly Bonnie not I'm not sure I'm just I'm thinking about this whole rollover and just wondering if the rollovers are you know due to delays or reassessment of needs or you know it

055makes sense that there's always going to be some rollover but I was just wondering if there's more we should know about it or if it's more ordinary which may or may not relate to what you're talking about um because you're more you're more closely connected to that than I am it's hard to tell because both are happening you know just if I could add another wrinkle to it um as I well I don't want to another wrinkle to it so but I think we need we should see if we can get um I I I you know I think I I would be help more comfortable we had a real Capital reconciliation so we knew where all the money was as opposed to the role and the money moves every year would that I mean

056is that something that you want or am I the only one that wants to see that see whatever is feasible you know whatever is feasible I'm just I will I will I don't know I'm gonna sit on that it's hard to tell there a lot of money moving and it's just hard to to to tell are there other questions Bonnie this is well I I do have a couple of questions um so for the 10-year CIP um I didn't see Grady Brown having a cooling tower replacement and I know in the past we've discussed that and I'm curious you know if y'all reviewed that Mr Davis or where do you see the the Grady Brown cooling tower replacement potentially happening so um that is not information that I've been given um again um I'm customary

057to work on having an analysis of all our systems and then being able to say grading Brown's efficiency and operating at a level that uh means that it's time to be replaced I think when you just have discussions about oh we should replace this or we should replace that gets off of its life cycle and then it it really makes it difficult to follow the money uh as well as plan to have things um allocated for those uh projects in a timely fashion um but to answer your question specifically from Grady Brown I'm not certain that it won't be a cooling tower on this list um again there's are projections for the next 10 years um but not that I'm wishing it to happen but there's a major component that could happen on any of

058our schools that will bring it to to the list uh and next year uh you'll be approving a capital Improvement plan that may have other projects uh added to the list and you know moving things out if we can um based on where we are and so um a cooling tower will probably take precedent over uh adding controls to a school um and so that will be the information that we'll provide to help you see while you know last year or this in two years we're supposed to contr use controls at Central Elementary um but the cooling tower at Grady Brown has become a more pressing need and so unfortunately um this the controls at Central Elementary will be moved to the next fiscal year while uh taking care of the higher priority of a

059cooling tower which makes sure your system is running properly at that site okay yeah because I I mean that cooling to is pretty old like yeah and again um you would love to be able to say at year 20 or it is you can replace it but again Kudos as I mentioned before to our maintenance department for being able to keep things running Beyond its life cycle I mean many of our schools are are Beyond its life cycle and so uh while we do take that in consideration um we just want to make sure because we don't have that much money um that we're spending it that will help us stretch the systems and these school facilities uh more just just to confirm Mr Davis the cooling tower would that be part of the evaluation

060or assessment of all of our HVAC units that is correct thank you thank you Dr Jones for the clarity um and and I had a similar question about Pathways in the cooling tower I know I think a year and a half ago it it was mentioned that that cooling tower was undersized for the space that it's covering especially in the um cafeteria uh gym that's shared between where they do PE where they eat and I know it's it it struggles to to keep up um but I guess to Dr Jones Point earlier that would be part of that evaluation um the the last comment I had was um in the timing that you showed for uh the bond money and the feedback I I definitely want to you know request that the board ensures we

061have a public hearing beyond the individual data Gathering right where we have the smaller groups getting the feedback but really having a uh board public hearing to give the opportunity for people to come in and share thoughts directly on you know what the proposals are or concerns thoughts you know and just making sure we you know advertise that and have a good idea of when when that will be I know we've got kind of a a three Monon spam there to to to have those discussions but I definitely want to make sure we have a board level public hearing as well and just closing out with with the thought thank you so much for all hard work on this really appreciate all all the work you're doing digging into this and really you know trying

062to get us a you know that 10e plan and the bond plan thank you and thanks will I did I see Wendy did you have a question I did um but it was answered um I my I was curious as to the why we had a lease for effin but you answer by saying that it was for the Bungalows which I was not aware and um but thank you and but I also want to comment I understand that um Bonnie that you may want the uh accountability to reconcile any Capital uh that was rolled over and I was that was one of my other questions where is this money coming from but it's once he talked about it it's very difficult to ask for why do we have this extra money when all the schools

063have different needs and if we're not getting the funding in time and we're not um Meeting those needs then we roll over the money so it seems like unless I I'm not really understanding that we are readjusting ourselves with this whole new team and with this report that I don't know where I can get it and I want to have access to it so I can really do my homework um but it's difficult to request in my opinion unless I'm wrong for information if all schools have different needs so but thank you for the presentation yeah and I think yeah thank you for that I think the only question is we've been allotted a bunch of money already how much have we spent how much is going forward and and it's un clear sometimes if

064we're if projects that we've approved that are in the second or third year if those are on here or if that you know just a little confusing and just in a spirit of no surprises it was um we just want to know if there's money that's not being spent we don't have the problem now that we were having and that's that no projects were being done the funds were being allotted and nothing was being done so we just want to get kind of caught up to make sure that we're all on the same page that's all and I think once we're moving it should move pretty quickly you have a question Sarah yeah I mean I just want to say I think the idea that nothing was being done is a mischaracterization so I think

065that to your point about wanting to be clear about what has happened you know what happened with the last Bond all of that I think that would be helpful um one thing that I think has been helpful as the team thinks about how best to like track and report this stuff is um the document that we have reviewed I think at a previous one of these committee meetings a couple of times that's like here are all of the current projects underway it might have the funding source on there like here's the status or phase that each one is in like you know to to um that I think was an improvement in terms of being able to like consistently have the same list of these are the ones that are that are on our current

066agenda and where they are in their process so um I think there's probably some parallel to that in terms of like spending down of funds or something that we could do yeah yeah I think that's a good idea we've talked about that um the last meeting I think when once we get the capital Improvement plan we could really start talking about getting some reports out to that will help us monitor it um so I have that as on as a Next Step item um I I have a couple of and you know again the focus for the capital plan is this year but I I just have a couple of other questions um I was fascinated to see the Pod Renovations for Grady Brown um I thought that was great to see last time it

067was like 16 million this time it's six and I was curious if that's just a a placeholder that you're thinking about or if that's something you're really um serious thinking looking at hard prioritizing in the next few years and let me I'll ask them all that's one second is well ask one time let's take that one um if I heard your question correctly uh based on the product specific we have allocated six million over the course of three years for pod renovation um again that's an estimate and it's a forecast as we get closer um and as projects come off the list we'll have to go through uh a project um ordinance to ensure what needs to happen and those Renovations match the funding dollars that have been set aside right so that's you're you're

068but you're looking at closing um the closing the walls up or closing the pods up is that that what that is that is that is correct among other things that will make the school more efficient so um but we haven't determined what that project ordinance will be so yeah it's years away I I also noticed that um orange middle went from 70 million to 45 million so I was wondering if there's some some um if you've got some ideas behind that that you want to share today it's a couple again it's a couple years away it just interest it's it's it's really based on what we forecast um from the initial project that the board determines uh and so uh if the pro if the board presents a project that is on a new Greenfield

069site that is um a K5 that matches a capacity given the information um that puts us at a budget of much more than what was originally stated in the wh report we believe that around 45 million may be left uh once that time comes for those types of Renovations um but the beauty of the cash flow and and additional funding sources is that we uh can supplement funding uh for blond projects on Capital Improvements with other sources uh that we have before us and so I would not look or heavily on the dollar amounts again this is just a way to uh communicate to the county of how much spending we think we will be spending uh each fiscal year got it got it all right so and then um you have the painting hallways

070classrooms at Orange High School and I I'm imagining the county commissioner going oh that's priority four and five so are they going to we're GNA have a problem with that and that's not for five years out but I just don't know if they're going to look at that and say well you guys aren't paying attention you know so is that something they're gonna they're gonna have trouble with so we've shared this document uh and we have a meeting with the county on Friday um and we have have um placed this information in their document that talks about the high priority um needs um and so we'll look to have further discussion on Friday um but I think we are um engaging in in aligning on how we see Capital planning and the adjacent funding that

071they project to receive okay and then one final question and I think there's some others that from me um do you want to put a project in like do we need to put any project planning pro project planning consulting or for the capital projects and do we need to put funding in for that and you all know that the county still deciding what to do about project management which is a separate million dollars a year that they're going to budget for this but I just didn't know if we needed to set aside uh money to to support you in your planning for these Bond projects yes so uh in regards to the bond projects the county is discussing um providing us additional funding for Bond project management I have uh based on my knowledge um

072set aside roughly 10% of all these projects for design and project management and so uh you don't see it here but in our um funding sources we've worked with Miss to identify a bucket of money for design and um project management consulting services to ensure um we're being efficient in the dollars that we have yes and I guess what I was asking is before we get into the specific projects do you need money now and I don't know if that's a 100,000 I don't know what that is but do you need money over the next six to 12 months to actually get do these assessments and the planning and the projects no we're using we're using some of the uh deferred rollover money that we talked about um for planning and design of these projects

073that are happening within the six to 12 months so the data collection and the feasibility um we've utilized deferred Capital funding to help us um provide the information um so we know what the first project of 2024 Bond will be so is this going to be the submission to the county these two pages is going to be our fundamentally our capital plan these are good qu any an had I'm sorry the voice an had a question well I just wanted to say thank you to Mr Davis for doing this comprehensive plan and I think that it it's good for us to see that um I do think that the more we see about um how the projects are progressing the fewer questions we have and the more we can answer other people's questions if they

074do have some but one thing I want to throw out and this is this is the principle in me coming out that a lot of these projects are done while children are in the building and that slows things down to a certain degree because you you are working around schedules and a lot of things with children in the building so I you know I understand that you you can't go in and get something finished in x amount of days if you working with children in a building and I think people sometimes need to just remember that we do have children in the building for a lot of these projects and and things that are going on but I do appreciate all the work that you and your team have put into this and I think

075this is you know in in my eyes it's ready to go to the county and and see what they say on Friday if you have a meeting with them on Friday I'd say take it on and see what they say so thank you thank you so just and so just to confirm that so these two pages is essentially going to go forward as our Capital Improvement plan that's is correct that's great any other questions so it will go on our agenda for Monday and I don't know if you want to put it on cons does anyone do we want to put it on agenda for discussion do we want to put it on consent and then let people pull it if there are questions we care I think our plan is to place it on

076consent if there are questions um leading up to that it can be pulled and we'll be happy to discuss okay and um if there are any changes based on Mr Davis's meeting with the county on Friday we'll be sure to communicate that to you as well great anything else else so um I have and this is actually a carryover from our last meeting and now that I mean it's exciting to have rcip and this is we haven't had one for two years so thank you for putting getting this together it's really exciting and really thoughtful by the way so it's really nice to see that um so um so the CIP is is done there was something um that the board has mentioned last time and it came up again today and that's a some

077kind of progress on projects and maybe I don't know if that's something that you're thinking about in the next few months to give us a proposal on what you would like to report on a periodic basis and we even talk last time we talked about putting it on school on the website so that people would know what's going on with projects you know we're working on um creating that list U thank you for your s um our goal is the projects that you saw uh on that list that will be uh starting this spring and summer um tracking those projects um the projects that happened prior to my arrival um they are pretty much complete um those being the tennis courts and tracks there are some small um touchups that they would have to do

078but um from what I've been given all the projects that were slated to be completed by the time they were completed uh in fisal year 2025 will be completed going forward we'll have a a clear document of projects on the CIP and what their status is uh and we can provide that to Dr Jones on a monthly basis uh to see um changes in the status do we want to um what is a board I mean is that how do people feel about that do you want to see it I I'm personally not not interested in seeing it monthly I think that's too much for us but I don't know if others are are you know every quarterly would be amazing once a year would be better than we've ever had okay so would that

079be okay with people once a year we updated this the status of these projects or do you want it more frequently any comments I I agree Bonnie the monthly's too much and because it's not going to change that significantly month over month and I definitely don't want staff spending a lot of time to try to update the lower levels so having quarterly at the earliest to me like you said maybe just yearly because these are long projects these are not things that finish in a couple of days or a week so I'm I'm open to a timing but I I would like to you know get some updat so we can share with uh you know our communities as well very thanks little Carrie say if if for some reason it's easy for staff to

080just like have some process they do every month and then they share it out with us monthly or quarterly but we don't you know dissect it we just are receiving whatever their update is that that would be fine with me um but I agree that definitely doesn't need to be like a um monthly presentation or anything like that Wendy did you have a Wendy um yes oops thank you again for everything and I I think that an update will be great as needed so they're the ones that know when there's change on whatever project and they can say by the way we're going to we're updating you on X Y and Z because this is what's happening currently I think in my opinion that would be better um any any program that needs that is

081going to be required that that they're updating for whatever reason then they know to update us um that is just my opinion but whatever works for everybody because all projects right in different faces and that's what I got Sarah yeah I like the idea of doing the big annual update on projects which I think we have traditionally done often with pictures um some sort of presentation actually like that um I think it would be great to know um you know when a when one of the major projects is completed right so like when the orange high school bathrooms were open and we like saw a little bit of that like that can be like a in the weekly updates that Dr Jones send you know what I mean like it doesn't need to be a

082big thing um but it's nice to know when they're done actually um and then maybe we could also consider having like a midpoint uh moment where you know when projects end up being uh delayed or more expensive than we thought you know there are changes and so it does seem like we'd want to know at some point in the year about the changes rather than like hearing about that at the end of the year so I don't know if that's just like project by projects letting us know through Dr Jones or if there's there's opportunity to like have a more formal moment I'm I'm up for either of those but having some way to know when things have changed um significant things have changed would be helpful yeah I think all of that sounds great

083you you know the thing to remember I'm just very thankful for the work that Mr Davis has come in and done he's it's been less than six months and so I remember my first six months coming in into the district and I don't know what was you know it's just a lot of information to take in and you know having to reassess and to establish some protocols that make sense for all of us and so um as he's working through that if there are any updates that you have you know some you're getting some questions about or you just want to know as an individual board member as a full board please just reach out to either to to me and we'll get that out to you but we'll come up with the system to

084provide some regular updates I I know that that's important for people to be able to have access to yeah yeah and just for the rec I mean in the short that sounds fine that sounds that sounds good and in the short six months um you know in my time with the board you know you look at P cips they have this is the most thoughtful that I've seen since I've been on the board so I just wanted to say double thanks on that and I know it's um it's a lot and plus adding the big Bonds in there you know we're in un we're in uncharted waters for the district for a long time to have this much money to and to and have all these projects and I you know Sarah I appreciated your

085correction before you know we had for my first couple years on the board we had a lot of turnover with several people in the operations leadership role and then when Mr ABY took it over he started to combine projects so we weren't approving little projects all the time he combined them and started to move them but that was just about two years ago which but that's when the backlog came but but it we're really moving you know I do have one other thought on how this approval goes um and maybe it's a um something to think about right now um I've been seeing on our consent agenda you know amendments where there's a $2,000 increase on a large project $2,000 add-on and it just seems like a lot of administration for a small amount of

086money and so I'd be curious about planning as projects get approved to have built-in contingencies so you don't have to go crazy over very small overruns for the board you know if the funds are running out if you're changing right that's a whole different thing but but it would be nice to make it easier for your staff to administer these change the change orders yeah Bonnie in in policy uh I believe the superintendent can do up to 50K without talking to us so maybe there's you know I don't know Dr Jones if you're just wanting us to be aware or you know it's it's definitely within our policy that they have that that flexibility yeah we just do that yeah we do that to be as transparent as possible to make you aware what's going

087on when we have projects that are overrun yeah so we have a builtin contingency in the project to begin with that becomes easier so it's just just something to to consider um um yeah anything else before we wrap this so the takeaways are the project status list the an annual update we have a plan that's going forward on consent and then um Fred As you move forward let's go back for a second to the other the the bigger conversation about strategy is there a time where you will be able to give us um an idea of points when you will engage the board with specific decisions or specific data that you're collecting like enrollment or program information or the assessments of the facilities so um like in March you know there'll be c will there

088be decisions that you'll be asking us to make through this process or should we just wait and see you know so I don't know if there's a if you have a specific timeline or plan to bring certain things to us over the next six months yes so we we anticipate um tonight um is the first of many conversations um of course the board meeting on the 27th will bring forth the approval of the CIP on the 24th um we will have another opportunity to provide data and a bond update um and in between the 24th and the board meeting in March um we will look to have our opportunities for stakeholder engagement among um the board and the community as well as Administration um the short answer is there will be some in between meetings

089from meetings that are already put on our calendar such as board meetings for uh engagement and sharing of information okay yeah because it seems like there's a bunch of hot topics that will come up especially if you decide to move forward on Hillsboro element on the Hillsboro Elementary campus and and year round and all that so um so we'll just we'll hear it as so there'll be time before then um and then the other thing is and Dr Jones if it's you know we talked about this if bronda can give us it's really a starting point I think once we are moving it'll be good but I think it'll be nice to have a starting point reconciliation on Capital so for example Fred was saying well we've had this deferred maintenance money that's covering our

090project cost so it it um you know so it's just helpful to understand what where we are with it and then once we have a starting point and we're moving I think it we won't need to see it anymore yeah I think she's prepared to do that for our um planning meeting okay great all right so um I think this this was great I mean thank you again so much for getting this done for us um any other questions on the capital plan we'll move to budget okay let's do it good job so yeah while we're transitioning our slides um as I mentioned before Miss wrath is not able to be with us this evening and so I'm going to um walk us through the B beginning of our budget you know these are our

091initial conversations and Mr coek is going to jump in uh he and Miss wrath have been working together as they should in discussion on um items consider um that we're considering as far as like expansion when it comes to Staffing so um I will let Franklin drive us and um if you go to the next slide Franklin um what I wanted to do um and really what Miss wrath and I wanted to do um because we worked on this a little bit together um is to take a take a look at a quick review of what we did last year um and if you go to the next slide Franklin um you can see that on April the 8th of last year the board approved a budget request totaling 47.8 million uh which was submitted

092to the Orange County Board of Commissioners for funding consideration this request Incorporated the salary and benefit increase approved in the state's bium budget as well as expansion initiatives that we continue to advocate for to support our school communities last year 1.9 million was needed to continue operating Orange County schools at the same level as the previous Academic Year an additional 3.1 million was requested to implement a step increase in the current classified employee pay scales to equate to a half a percent increase for each year of service completed uh an increase to the current certified supplement tiers to be more competitive with our bordering districts when it comes to local supplements uh funds to continue funding NC edore tutoring program additional funding to expand stem throughout our district and um the request was also to

093fund uh to provide funds to ensure that all students have Equitable access to field trips so in total um Orange County Schools asked the Commissioners for 47.8 million for the 2425 school year um which equated to a $5 million increase over the previous year again this is just a review of where we were last year if you go to the next slide Franklin so at the June 18th meeting with the board of County Commissioners um they approved funding for both Orange County and Chapel Hill City schools at 5,000 $666 per pupil so for us in Orange County Schools it equated to 44.9 million in funding um based on our student enrollment uh this approved budget supported funding for Orange County Schools to continue operations at the same level as the previous year and um implement

094the legislated salary and benefit increases which was projected to cost 44.7 million unfortunately um this approved budget did not support funding the expans the expansion initiatives that we mentioned on the previous slide uh next slide Franklin so because we anticipated not being funded for um some of our expansion items and due to the loss of the Esser funding last year we thoughtfully looked um at every budget line item to reallocate or cut existing budgets in the amount of about $700,000 in doing this we were able to fund what you see on this slide so again um unfortunately we were not able to fund any increases to our classified salary scals or an increase to our teacher local supplement but we were able to um fund items that fit into our budget priorities of recruiting and

095retaining high quality Workforce um improving student proficiency and academic growth and making sure we're allocating resources to meet the needs of our students and staff next slide please so now we're going to discuss our um fiscal year 26 budget if you go to the next slide Franklin here um you'll see a list of key dates for adopting our upcoming 2526 local operating budget I'm not going to read through those but they're pretty similar from year to year but we always want to give you this um time where you don't see exact dates is because we're dependent on others to um set some some meeting time so and sometimes those VAR dependent on input that we may get next slide Franklin so each year we present the county with our continuation budget the continuation budget reflects

096the financial resources needed for Orange County Schools to continue existing programs Staffing levels and services at our current level the continuation Bud budget also includes estimated costs due to inflation we have uh prepared three scenarios that include a consistent Consumer Price Index or CPI of three of 3% just as a reminder the CPI measures inflation um salaries are projected at 2 three and 4% where we land will depend on the state's budget um most districts around us are around that 3% range when doing their projections and I think in our conversations with the county we're all looking at the 3% so it will probably be closer to the 3% range next slide please so in preparing for this fiscal year we were anticipating and planning for a tight budget again um all while still being

097committed to what remains to be our budget priorities recruiting and retaining a high quality Workforce ensuring student academic proficiency and growth and allocating resources to meet the needs of our students and staff next slide again because um like I said we anticipated that tighter budget um we still are looking at expanding um our expansion requests to include a increase in our teacher local supplement and our an increase in our classified local supplement skills so if you go to the next slide um Franklin I'm going to at this point turn it over to Mr cowiek and he'll discuss our requests for these uh increases in local classified and certified supplements in a little bit more detail good evening everyone um thanks Franklin so the first what we just wanted to uh show you is our current

098supplements are for our um certified Personnel based on their years of service um you know you can see that the supplement range is from 12% to 18% in the supplement column uh and we also have a breakdown of the approximate number of Staff in each of those categories this is of course certified staff only and then the percentage of our teachers our certified instructional staff in the in those particular ranges ranges from 17% for our instructional certified staff from 14 to 19 years all the way up to 30% for 20 years I mean obviously we can see from that the percentages are pretty even across those four bands except for the the the 14 to 19 and the 20 there's you know up and down there thank you Franklin um what uh our team did

099and I just want to always shout out all folks who did the work for this this this uh information was created by Anda parsley uh in the HR department um working with Ronda with uh as well but as you can see from this slide this is a comparison of this current school year local supplements for Orange County verse other neighboring counties right and um you can see that the orange line is of course the Orange County schools and you know when you look at this graph overall you of course can draw your own conclusions but what you can see is that um you know there seems to be a nestling at the bottom of the range with orange and abss and Person County for uh new staff from 0 to 5 years in the 12

10012 and 10% um while wake Durham and Chapel Hill are up on the 17 18% um we still Orange County Still Remains fairly significantly behind in supplement to Chapel Hill wake and Durham for our teachers in the six to 13ear range um we for whatever reason that happens in the 14 and 19 year range we are definitely seem to have separated a little bit from the Alamance and Person County range and closer to DPS wake and Chapel Hill and then we we are seem to be in our own middle category for our 20 plus years when we're comparing the supplements uh across the board all right next slide please so one of the things that we took a look at is how much would it cost if we um were able to provide this uh

101supp you know increasing the supplement um in the First Column you can see our current OCS supplement there's the dollar what the supplement totals are and underneath it it's a repeat of what our current supplement value is 12% 14 16 and 18 in the second column these are this is some data about if we had a tiered increase in our supplement for example if we increase the 0 to 5year category by 1% to go from 12 to 13 if we did a tiered increase in the six to 13year category again moving it up 1% and then if we moved up 2% for our 14 to 19 years teachers and three years there you can see what that extra cost would be that's the difference in Total Line in the second row um if we follow

102that increase and then the last column is what if we could give 3% across the board to every instructional certified staff what is the additional cost that would result um it as you can see that takes us to just about $740,000 more would be needed for that um there is uh and so um and you can see that if we add that 3% um all of a sudden now we become a lot more competitive with our neighboring districts um particularly um in the mid-range from the six to the 19 years of age of experience um we pull extremely close you know one of the things we always like to talk about OCS we're small we're Mighty you know we can get things done as a small District we've got um but we certainly one of

103the things we always hope to avoid is you know we don't want people to choose other districts because they're making an extra th000 $2,000 when they're when they're coming toward us or at other levels even more so um that's why you as I see you know I'm I'm certainly encouraged to see that it was on the expansion budget for last year before I ever got here um and we wanted to run some numbers to see what we could um do now granted we ran this back in the fall before we got the more recent news about what we could might expect from the expansion budget but you know this you know the the old adage the squeaky wheel if you don't ask for things you don't put it out there then you're certainly not going

104to get it right so all right um thanks Franklin next slide so we're also talking um you know we were also talking Rhonda and I and Dr Jones about we'd also like to try to do something to support our classified employees particularly our classified employees at the the lower pay grades um we're not talking about classified employees who are coordinators and above and so um thinking what could it take to um to do something for our lowest paid employees as well next slide please So currently our classified employees there's three different ranges for supplements okay the chart I think speaks for itself the classified employees that's for our folks who are on our classified pay grades um right these are all of our Tas our bookkeepers our bus drivers our maintenance workers right these are

105these are these These are the folks that are making up our classified employee with the 7% supplement and we've got that's the greatest number of them in the district when we're talking about classified employees um uh so one of the things that we had been talking about is what could it take to get to if we could raise all of our classified employees from 7% supplement to 9% supplement I know that's something that Ronda and I were talking about I think over the last week between the weather Ronda not being able to be here um Ronda had started to put together some information is on the next slide please Franklin um so what would it take for example if we were to have a 1% local supplement increase for our roughly 280 employees it would

106take about another $150,000 um if we were able to think about making that to 9% then it would be you know at least double that 300,000 so pieing the sky what we' love to be I'm sure we all would love to do at a minimum would be to say yes we get all of our you know instructional certified staff 3% get our lowest paid classified employees right to you know to a supplement that makes them the same as coordinators the flat rate for that would be the 740,000 for the certified plus the roughly 300,000 if that 1% you see on there was 2% that would be a million over a million but then you have to factor in some you know some other B you know benefits and other retirement costs on top of that

107but that's the scope we're looking at um as you can see Ronda was also putting together some numbers of hey what if we did sort of a you know a a modified or again sort of a graduated 1% local supplement increase for folks who had 15 years of service increased them 1% you could see that the total bill for that would be $65,000 roughly that would impact almost half of our classified employees um with that increase so these are numbers that we're throwing uh that we wanted to present to you to show the work that we've been doing to think about how we can um you know support our employees um and I think that's the last slide Frank yep so any questions that you might have um we'll be I'll be happy to answer

108as Rhonda wrath as best as I can yeah and we'll take any questions and then there'll also be some room if you wanted to share some other priorities for us to discuss we'll take those as well this is really well really informative I thank you so much very different than we've seen in the past Sarah yeah this is very very helpful um I have a a question about some of the early information the projections and then um something on this so um the we are pro I saw some headlines in the news about projections for state employees their benefits costs and things going up so I saw are we projecting for that was it like 24% increase in retirement and something in the hospitalization so that we've Incorporated whatever we know about that already and

109that's to estimated it yeah because we don't know that that's what's hard about um the timing of the state's budget coming out so we have to estimate those and so once we learn that then we kind of revamp and um see where everything falls but yes those are estimated um numbers okay and we are taking into account our discussions how else that impacts with you know we can't just do this without knowing what the state is giving you know as a raise too because that impacts you know the ability too because we if the state gives you know let's say the state gives a 5% raise we have to account for that local supplement increase as well so there you know so Ronde is on top of of all that when when factoring this in

110yeah so Sarah if I could just jump just to clarify you were projecting a $2 million in increase and that assumed a 3% State increase is that what I did I understand that correctly and that would be just Contin technically continuation budget yes I think it was like 1.9 million um that would be if the state gives a raise of 3% that would be what the what we need from the county to continue at our current levels yeah so just to continue from there I am a little concerned that uh about whether we will even be able to get that much um uh so we may be in a position of needing to I mean hopefully we do um because it's the bare minimum you know mandated by the state um but uh it does

111make me you know concerned that it might not be the year to be able to accomplish the things that we want to on the supplements um I think this is really good thinking on those I wanted to just offer a couple of additional thoughts on it um if now's a good time so um first like we're way off with beginning teachers and I think like we we have a lot of people in those very Advanced years and people are retire like we as a district I don't know what it's like in other District but this district has a lot of teachers retire from here and so we need to be making sure that we're competitive at that other end as well um as well as that category of teachers where where it seems like we're

112behind we just have fewer of them and I think it's probably because around that time they go to another District so looking at what we're doing there um and I would like to encourage us to look at the way that wake and Durham are actually doing um their salary schedules and think about doing that so if you go on their websites they have their SC salary schedules and it they don't say it's an x% increase for these number of years of experience what they do is um like the okay let me try to explain this uh the percent you saw in all those years for Durham and wake is is actually quite similar it's like maybe around 18% or something like that but because your salary goes up from the state every year um the

113dollar that that's worth goes up too like that 18% of $43,000 is less than 8% of $54,000 you know so uh you can sort of see that increase more clearly um so that's one thing and then the other thing that I think both of those districts are doing is that those years where the state has like flattened and you get no increases years like 15 through 24 they're giving increases in their supplement so the way they do it is by laying out year by year what the increase is going to be they've built in your 15 you're 16 you're 17 you get a little bit of an increase and here it's just flat and so if there is a way for us to figure out what it would cost to be able to mimic that

114sort of thing in those years 15 through 204 or whatever um I think that would be valuable and I also think just the way they lay out their salaries with a like if you're in your fifth year this is the size of your supplement in dollars is just kind of more transparent it's like easier to process if you're like looking around at different districts too so just generally like that approach of theirs because um I think like they've made a tradeoff in like that percent not increasing as quickly across those years but then addressing separately the um the fact of the state flattening across 15 through 24 other thoughts and comments I I agree completely Sarah I'll talk about it in a little bit but thank you for raising that anything else yeah yeah Bonnie

115this is will uh I agree you know with what Sarah was getting at the the other thing too I think we have to I'm just going to maybe remind or or just say it out loud one of the changes that we made was teacher experience because a lot of districts we found out including Orange County at the time no matter how many years you had been a teacher in North Carolina or somewhere else we started you at zero but then we changed the policy of we're going to give you credit which allowed us to bring people in and get the higher supplements which actually really helped us get more skilled teachers and and I agree we need to be more competitive um with our supplements to attract and retain um and I definitely like seeing

116the data for us to be you know comparable and to Sarah's point about seeing the different years you know we had to do that with uh our our classified right we they used to only have a scale that said you know years one and then you didn't get anything until like year 15 and and we changed that to be Year bye to ensure there would be some some supplement so I I think that's a a good idea to to look at as well others good point yeah I I'll just add you know when we did hill we like you're saying well we decompressed the step the step schedules and the only group I think that didn't get decompressed was the 15 to 25s or 15 to 24s excuse me right and they're the ones that

117are on this flat salary schedule plus the increases so that they're just not getting increases from the state and and Sarah if I did I understand correctly that you you're concerned about us losing the experien staff right I'm concerned on both ends I think we're probably missing plenty of like folks going into teaching or a couple of years of experience because we're so far behind the other districts like if you're like a young person who's not making much money in the first place why are you going to go somewhere making so much less you know um but seeing that we have so few people in that I think it's 15 to 19 age brain you know you showed the breakdown of how many we have in each of those categories it makes me think are

118we losing folks there as well um and then seeing that some of those other districts were giving them increases in those years kind of made me question what was going on there so I'm I'm very much in favor of seeing if we can decompress that that range that 15 to 24 range any other comments Wendy I just want to say thank you for putting and really thinking about the teachers and I I'm in line with Sarah and what will said and um but we need to pay them more and I hope we can't despite the fact that we are having a lot of cuts everywhere thank you other comments just that I appreciate um the presentation and Rhonda and Mr Co and Dr Jones looking ahead at at what possibilities we might have yeah one

119thing you know that we have discussed is well is if we don't get this request this year we want to be prepared right we want to know what it's going to cost us we'll be you know we'll have these on hand and be able to generate numbers more quickly um depending on how many folks are in the categories and when we start talking about decompressing certain scills or um offering different ranges um you know we just we want to make sure we're we're careful in in our analysis of that so that it falls within our budget and we don't um run into issues of over promising and under delivering and so I I think I like you know like a slower approach but I definitely agree with um all of the comments and we'll take

120all of those back and see um where we can provide um a little bit more detail but again um we are going to add where're are going to Advocate especially for our classified and our our teachers that um need that additional funding to I mean inflation is going up and their their raises are very minimal um so we're going to continue to advocate for them so if if there are other expansion items that you wanted to share at this time we're happy to to take those as well Dr Jones I just have to say when in this particular presentation this sub this um presentation last time we said $2 million for raises these were much more precise and much more much more precise um areas for increase and I just don't know if that is

121going to be harder is that's going to hit harder when when it's presented so because what we're asking for are those that are instructional staff so we're not we're not we're asking for those that are student facing um our teachers and our coaches that are and interventionists that are working with um staff and so um I think that helps to not have such a broad um area that we're looking at or just all certified positions but um we thought that just being a little bit more intentional there and you know we can certainly break down all areas within our district but um certainly want to pay attention to those that are student facing and when we're in a crisis trying to get teachers to come and commit and stay and if we can get them

122here we know how to support them we know how to treat them well and to treat them respectfully um but paying them will especially our young teachers will get them to stay with us I I just wonder in the budget presentation do we make should we hit harder and I um on the point that that our EC and our MLL populations are I I believe they're both growing but we've way exceeded the Caps the funding caps so so and and it's just an awareness for to the County Commissioners that our student needs are growing and and the funding that that's available to us is just not you know is not meeting the needs so I just don't know that helps to make our case about and and your team is making it work but it's

123a hardship for us and so just a question does any yeah I'll take that back to miss wrath and to the team and we can um make that kind of drive that point home again this isn't our presentation for the County Commissioners this is what we're bringing to you just to share some of our initial thoughts and get some of your feedback on so that we can make adjustments but yeah that is a good point other thoughts on priorities or things that people want to see in the budget there' have been questions about allotments and some others they really depressed us I I wonder about um oh God I lost my thought um I I'm I'm wondering about um in some cases I've se you know do we have um Team balances or allotments that

124we need to increase we need to bring more te more teachers into more spaces um you know and I'm thinking about places where we have um teams of three versus for in a middle school you know I just uh just curious if there are are allotments or uh resource allocations that we really would like to beef up also English language Learners uh you know I'm sorry ESL teachers um for a growing elll the sheltered classrooms anything that we're doing strategically that really we really need more staff to do it the way we want to so part of our work this year is making sure that we take the time to analyze how we are Staffing in every department and in every school okay and so we're going to get into allotments um a little bit

125later this year with you all I think that's something we plan to do maybe in February if yeah Mr Co shaking his head in February and kind of break those down for you but um we have the starting point has to be the state allotment um otherwise we are we find ourselves to be over alloted and not really knowing why we're doing what we're doing like if we decide to like you you mentioned um add another team at a middle school well and I'm going to confess I was a middle school principal so was miss pcel you know if I if I I could make a case for any given day why I need that and so what we have to rely on is our data um the supports that we currently have in place

126and um and yes we we want our principles to advocate for what they need um and just see how effective the supports that we have are and so we're looking heavily at our data right now um we're having conversations with principles but we have to be careful because once we allocate resources especially Personnel that is year-over-year funding and um we don't want to put ourselves in a position where we over a lot to a point where um we have to drastically remove positions in a building so right now where we're at is we're in a position of analyzing where we are we're meeting with different departments and we're going to review those allotments with with you all the process that we take to look at that and we're going to review that with principles and

127we do that every well we've done that we did it last year and we're going to go into that again um soon in the spring great thank you anything else Gary I just want to emphasize I I appreciate the um tough look you've taken at every Department I I know you will lift up those efforts maybe even share in a little more detail I feel like we've gotten a little more detail from time to time but you know that was a pretty um a careful raking that you know each apartment Department did you know and $700,000 is not nothing and I think you know our district has done really careful work as well as with the allotments and and to avoid you know later cuts and you know I know we can't control the fact

128that we don't have a special district tax tax that our sister district has but you know the difference in supplements it it it is frustrating when I know how carefully um and I'm I'm proud of the work that um your team has done Dr Jones so I hope you just you know take the moments to lift up those efforts when you present to the county yeah absolutely because it that was tough we had we had but we had to find it um otherwise we would have had issues where we were having to look at Personnel or whether or not we're going to carry over specific resources that uh our students and our teachers are relying on and so um to that we are still continuing those efforts we are looking very closely at the resources

129that we um utilize um to see if they if they're being effective um the services that we are Contracting to see if there are ways for us to eliminate some of those and we're we're making some slow and steady progress with that um but that is something that every department is going to continue to do until we get to the point where we understand where every single dollar is going and that we know that it is um being allocated in a manner that impacts students first right and helps to support our teachers in what they have to do from day to day um so that it's a process but we're continuing to engage in some of that work in every single Department other questions comments thoughts on priority Sarah yeah sorry just one more that

130occurred to me in the like supplements and compensation realm is at sometimes we've talked about considering a differentiate supplement for EC uh teachers and Tas and I you know that's a it may cost less to do that and it may be really impactful for retention um in those roles so I'm definitely open to looking at that as well yep and we're happy to look at that if that's something that the board wants us to look at we try to be careful um to not distinguish between um teachers um in that way because it be it it becomes a little bit hard um to justify why we give an EC teacher a supplement versus and not give an ESL teacher a supplement and then we all of our teachers work really hard so I don't I

131don't want to um kind of weigh one um set of teachers against another um and decide where we put our most uh where we put our value um there are other ways that we can look at some of that but we'll definitely bring that to you if that's something that you would like to to request but typically you know I just we we try not to to do that yeah yeah and that I I understand not wanting to like create divides between staff for sure I um if we look at it it would help be helpful to understand what's the turnover rate in those different types of roles regular ta ecta regular uh classroom teacher EC classroom teacher because I I suspect just from board reports that the turnover rates are quite different um and

132Chapel Hill I I believe still they were doing anyway a differentiated supplement for EC as well so um it is potentially a competitive thing as well but not pushing hard for it just think we should look at that given potential turnover rates there yep absolutely and if I'm just if I may just to respond to miss Smiley's comments as well um our classified staff team Phyllis Connie and I we've looked at the classified pay grade we've taken the time to look are they are are our pay grades the way we feel like they should be based on the work that they do right right now we've got four different classes of Tas in one category in one pay grade we would love to be able to make and this is true in other districts right

133where ECT are at a higher grade than a regular ta um but when we sort of put an eye to that this is not like just money growing on trees right so we're looking at that we're like well does this position really warrant this right so there might be ups and downs you know in terms of what in terms of wanting to calibrate it so we are looking at sort of everything as Dr Jones said to see what we can do what can be budget neutral right so so we can you know hopefully put put our resources to the best use for the district that's great thank you it's interesting to think about it as Tas as well as teachers but um and I'm was Sarah the question is what does the data say in

134terms of retention loss ability to attract to fill these positions that that's really the question that has come up title one was another area right it was EC title one and I think ESL were the areas that we wondered about that we've asked in the past about this um anything else I just want to thank the team Dr Jones and her team for everything they're doing and the hard work they're doing um to really think about our teachers our students and staff and making sure that everybody gets uplifted like Carrie said and really be more financially sustainable with working with trying to make lemonade without lemons um and how other districts have special um taxes and and we're doing the best we can and I just want to thank everybody and um we'll do the

135best we can with what we have and I hope that we can give everybody races thank you yeah anybody else yeah I just want you know Dr Jones has been almost a year now and and um and you and you know we have the Dream Team um Fred and Jeff are part of it and um and I think what what I saw tonight was a level of you know this job is getting your job is getting harder every year there's no question but you know what I saw tonight was a level of quality of content and discussion that has been was really exciting to see so thank you so much for raising the bar and kind of raising the bar for us at the board to say you know being transparent about the real issues

136about what we're really facing and and just driving a a really thought and thank you to the board everybody for engaging in such a thoughtful way that was a great conversation is there anything else I think um Dr Jones you have the the things that people asked about so we're we is there anything else that we need to cover eight minutes early motion to oh you good motion to adjourn motion to adjourn second okay roll call um will yes Wendy yes okay by Sarah yes Harry Harry an yes Andre yes me yes we're Jour thank you all so much thank you good night thank you have a good night stay safe you too thank you all very much

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.