001e e e good evening I'd like to call this meeting of the Orange County Board of Education to order for Monday July the 13th January the 13th okay let's back up January the 13th um I need a motion to inter close session for reasons so so stated on the agenda do I have a motion motion to go into close session second all in favor I I okay we will move to close session thank you e e e you hola Kevin or that someone that can hear me the interpreters are not assigned as interpreters so please if you can be sure that both of them are assigned as interpreters thank you e interpreters you should be all set e e e [Music] good evening everyone and welcome we are back in uh Open Session and we
002will start uh with our public chart charge that I will read to everyone we welcome you here tonight and um our public charge is the Orange County Board of Education pledges to its citizens to conduct its business in a courteous and productive manner showing respect for fellow board members staff and citizens the board ask its citizens to conduct themselves with the same courtesy toward both School personnel and each other a moment of silence will be observed before each meeting in addition to the moment of silence the board will recite the Pledge of Allegiance the board asks that you check your cell phones and other electronic devices to be certain that they are either turned off or on vibrate to avoid Interruption of this meeting and if we will stand and um say the Pledge of
003Allegiance please I pledge allegiance to the United States of United States of America and to the Republic for stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you we will now observe Our Moment of Silence okay thank you very much we do have some recognitions tonight as you will see on the um board docket if you have seen it there were to be three um since we did not have school today the Orange High School men's cross country 3A team state champions will not be here tonight we will do that on the 27th I believe or at another board meeting where they can attend so we will start our recognitions tonight with uh Martin Luther King Jr day which is next Monday uh January the which is January the 20th and
004uh so Dr Dreer I believe is remotely tonight and she is the one that is going to be discussing this with us Dr Dr Dreer yes good evening can everyone hear me okay yes ma'am wonderful board members OCS leadership and community members I come before you today to recognize the upcoming Dr Martin Luther King Jr Day on January 20th 2025 this marks the 39th anniversary of this important federal holiday and the 31st year it has been designated as a National Day of Service Dr King's Legacy holds special significance for us as educators his unwavering commitment to Justice equality and education as a pathway to opportunity continues to guide our work as he once said the function of education is to teach one to think intensely and to think critically intelligence plus character that is the
005goal of true education at age 35 Dr King became the youngest recipient of the Nobel Peace Prize demonstrating to our students that young people can indeed change the world his philosophy of nonviolent resistance and his leadership in the Civil Rights Movement show us how principled action and peaceful advocacy can transform society today Dr King's Vision challenges us to ensure every student has access to Quality education regardless of their background his dream of equality and justice remains our ongoing mission in our schools and classrooms as we approach this holiday I encourage our educational Community to treat this as a day on not a day off let use this time to engage our students in meaningful service projects Foster discussions about civil rights and social justice and reflect on how we can better serve all students in
006our district Dr King's message of Hope resilience and unity continues to resonate in our schools let us honor his legacy by recommitting ourselves to creating educational environments where every student can Thrive and achieve their full potential thank you thank you very much Dr Dre that was wonderful and um we all here are looking forward to events this coming weekend um honoring Dr Martin Luther King Jr here in Hillsboro and around the area so thank you very much our second um recognition um January is School Board appreciation month and Mr mun is going to um talk about that and and we all As as we came in this evening I think he's going to say something about this as well we all receive cards from students at um River Park Thanking us for being on the
007board of education so we thank our River Park students that's right uh chair pcel Vice chair Richmond members of the board superintendent Jones and the public January is uh School Board appreciation month here in North Carolina and we'd like to take the time to appreciate you all for the countless hours you put in towards the advancement of public educ uh we really appreciate each and every one of you in the time and the effort you take to support public education as chair P mentioned and right in front of your um your microphones is a very special thank you card that was handwritten by the students at River Park Elementary also shout out to Shannon Braxton for helping us out with that so we just like to take the opportunity to thank each and every one
008of you for all the time and effort you spend supporting public education thank you board members thank you thank you all um I'd like to thank my fellow board members for what they do because it is um it's sometimes it's a tireless job but we enjoy it we enjoy working for kids and and students uh our Stu kids and students in the district and our teachers and the folks that come to work every day in the central office and are the support people for for everybody in this district from our bus drivers to our c workers we are so appreciative for everything everybody in this District does to make this District run smoothly and operate as efficiently as it can and we are looking forward to getting our students back to school tomorrow um after
009um our snow ice event and we're probably looking forward to it more than the children are right now but we um I I do think that some of them are ready to come back and U so we hope that tomorrow will run smoothly and we do enjoy and and it's a pleasure to serve on this board and and work for this District so thank you all very much uh we need to adopt our agenda do I have a motion to adopt so Mo uh uh do I have a second I had a request to pull a an email to pull a couple of the policies for discussion okay and that I wrote them down but I don't don't have in uh let's see they were 5150 and okay all right the friendly Amendment to the
010motion absolutely okay uh second all right all in favor and if it's okay we will put those policies in as number right before the work session would that work okay okay we will add a discussion on those then all right um we have public comment tonight I believe so Mr Richmond can you read the charge for public comment yes ma'am we will now hear public com comments speakers will be called in the order which they signed up each speaker will have three minutes yielding time to other speakers is not permitted if a speaker has written materials they would like to share please hand them to our board clerk Franklin mun and he will distribute them to the board the purpose of public comment is for the board to hear from members of the public not
011to engage in back and forth discussions per our policy board members will not respond to speakers during the public comments session the board greatly values public feedback and welcomes all comments regardless of viewpoint however please be reminded that children are often present at these meetings and that our public comment policy prohibits profanity vulgarity and personal abuse of any person we ask that all comments be civil respectful and free of personal attacks any speaker who violates our public comment period or otherwise exceeds the bounds of order and decorum will be given a warning continued violations may result in the speaker being ruled out of order at which point we will move on to the next speaker our first Speaker tonight is Jackie wheelen thank you so much um I'm here to talk about the power school
012and Daybreak um when the power of school information hack came with this community school model all that information regarding children's personal information and mental health could be anywhere now no matter how they try to make it sound all right um does the community school model respect the parents rights I know sometimes they have to opt opt out I think they should have to opt in because knowing how busy parents are they might just miss the the paperwork when Mental Health Services are provided at school once the parent opts in at least what I read with Daybreak a child I believe as young as 10 could receive services and I'm not sure how much the parent is informed with the repeated um help and possible meetings and my concern also is litigation just like with IEP
013plans where parents feel like the IEP plan wasn't um administered or um addressed to their satisfaction which I think is a really important thing for parents to have the right to ask about that but not we can't give students everything that they always need we'd love to do that but similar to when a parent feels that an iup plan was not carried out satisfactorily then how what backing you have that if their mental health needs aren't addressed to their satisfaction that it couldn't come back on you which means it comes back on us um thank you so much I want children to get whatever they need but I also know that a really good solid education might be the best thing that would help a lot of people in their mental health thank you thank
014you so much our next speaker is Jennifer wheen good evening um my name is Jennifer wheen and I agree with uh my sister's comments about um opting in to Health Services because I think that schools can do a lot but I don't know if they can do everything and litigation and cons I'm concerned about the data breach of NC public schools and of Power School teachers parents schools uh students information and anything that the children get as far as Services mental health and otherwise should always be an ongoing communication with the parents never should the parents be left out of the conversation thank you thank you the next speaker is Gretchen SMI good good evening um Bard and Dr Jones um I was going to share some stories comments that I've heard from a few
015teachers and students regarding cell phones and the hook the social media Giants have over the learning environment outcomes real relationships or lack thereof at Orange High School um from one student I learned that they're not able to connect with friends who they have made in person at school but because they do not have social media their friendship is limited to a surface acquaintance they have received the message at school just talking in person is too much and they have to first be filtered by potential friends on social media from another student I learned they never even have a chance to make friends they're a new student um because anytime that they might be able to connect with another student everyone is looking down at their phone I was interested in what teachers had to say
016after hearing about these student experiences uh from the three that I've spoken to so far they've all agreed a minimum of 10 to 15% of class instructional time is spent dealing with phone interruptions which in turn um makes most days in class A Time of tension around the phones and in what is supposed to be a learning environment I was also in asked by each of them to keep their names out of anything shared because the story at OS is that everything is under control in the phone Department under the current phone policy and they have felt um a communication of job insecurity if they bring up issues regarding phones interrupting instructional time which differs from the story about the phone situation being under control right now and being successful um in his 2024 book
017The anxious generation Jonathan hate demonstrates an explanation of what everyone has been observing among the Youth of Generation Z as it relates to their mental health I'm sure some here have already read or listened but if not I would encourage every person who has any connection or influence with anyone 25 or younger to pick up a copy or listen on the digital library loan he demonstrates how the great reiring of childhood is causing an epidemic of mental illness for generation Z the great rewiring devastated the social lives of gen Z by connecting them to everyone in the world and disconnecting them from the people around them increased digital connectivity has led to a real world social disconnection he shares that heavy social media users who are also receiving notifications about everything else are being interrupted
018multiple times per minute how do we consume as much of your time and conscious attention as possible that was from Shan Parker the first president of Facebook in a 20 17 interview describing describing the thought process of the creators of Facebook his suggestions for what schools can do include with ample explanation making Schools phone free by adopting one of the many phone Locker options which have been employed by a growing number of districts and to incorporating more unstructured free play I'm working on getting copies of the book for anyone who would like um a copy of their own thank you thank you and our last speaker for theight is Steve mahaley good evening and uh I want to express my personal appreciation for all that you all do uh on the school board thanks for
019what you're up to um I'm a retired uh school teacher I taught for nine years down in Chapel Hill and uh feel like I have a stake in some of the things that are going on two things one um I'd like to thank you all for keeping the Good News Club at arms length from our schools um I think that uh Katherine Stewart's work uh if you read the book called The Good News Club authored by Katherine Stewart outlines many of the uh pitfalls and dangers that would occur uh for our students if um The Good News Club was allowed to uh operate within the schools um so that's one thing also underscoring the importance of separation of church and state it means that you know keeping that distance between and the and the um
020Power for individuals to choose their own religion or to choose none at all uh those things are important to me and I think um should be respected within our student population and the families that they uh are part of second thing I wanted to talk about just very briefly is the role of school resource officers and the upcoming Administrations position on uh deportation of immigrants um I am very very concerned uh knowing people personally who fall into the category of folks who are undocumented and about what kind of uh alignment and potential Arrangements might be ra made with our uh local law enforcement um and you could uh I can very easily get to a dystopic place um of of officers appearing at schools to to detain parents of students in front of students this
021is a terrible terrible thing I'm hoping that um you all will be talking about this if you haven't started talking already about any kind of arrangements that could be made with our local law enforcement who I don't want to villainize I think they're amazing people and they put their lives on the line all the time uh but I think some clarity around the role of school resource officers Visa um potential portation of of our neighbors and friends who just happen to not have the proper documents thank you very much thank you that concludes public comment okay thank you again everyone um we have board comments tonight um I can't remember where I started last time but miss Hower how about I start with you yeah now just a welcome back to everyone and I feel
022as a board member I feel appreciated just by you all being here in the room and online so thank you looking forward to working together in the new year yeah I would just like to say uh thank you all for coming and speaking tonight also uh thank you to the students of R Park also I just wanted to highlight that wasn't mentioned is we did get a nice little QR code and if you scan it it's actually uh let it snow so very very much thank you for uh taking the time to do that okay um um Miss p uh Happy New Year everyone and thank you for your comments and thank you for being here um I I am hopeful that 2025 is going to be a great year despite everything that is happening
023but I I'm a very hopeful person and I look forward for our community coming together working together this 2025 because we are all Orange County um I can't say it any better than Miss Pia just did so uh Happy New Year everybody Happy New Year I'm glad everyone came out despite the bad weather um and glad the roads are clearing up and kids can get back to school um and I also just want to lift up um and a number of people have alluded to this but just the importance of um lifting up students and uh mental health during um challenging times Mr richond and I will Echo what what most have said is I hope everyone enjoyed their holidays um happy New Year here and I hope everyone also enjoys the upcoming um Dr
024Martin Luther King Jr day um which I am very fortunate to share the same birthday with and since uh the day I was born I've been always reminded by my mom that I share that special day with him so um happy New Year to everyone I just like to Echo as well thank you all for coming out tonight we do appreciate your public comments we do take them we do we to work with what you say um and you know I'm very hopeful for Orange County schools for 2025 I think respect and kindness are the two things that I think about for everybody in this district and well I have a grandson that I take to school um every other week or so and when he gets out of the car I say respect everybody
025else and be kind and he says okay he's eighth grader at orange middle and so I know what orange middle is what middle school is about so that's why I say that but I hope that it's sticking in his um brain and and so far it it has but I I hope that for everybody in this District just be respectful of everybody else and be kind to each other and I think we'll all be all right and we do appreciate you all coming out tonight and and your kind words um and the the kids at River Park Park thank you for um again for uh thinking of us and this job that we do um that's not always easy but it is rewarding and we see the benefit benefits of it every time we walk
026into a school and that's I think I'm speaking for this entire board when I say that's the best part of this job is when we can walk into a school and see teachers and students that are happy and learning and and things are are working the way they should be so thank you all Dr Jones do you have any comments for us tonight yes Madam chair I do um just want to take a moment to share my gratitude to each of the board members um thank you for your service your passion um for supporting our students and our staff and your unwavering support as we work together to um support an enriching and inclusive learning environment for all students and for staff here in Orange County Schools I also wanted to say thank you to
027our hardworking operations team who is operating under the leadership of uh Mr Davis um they have worked tires tirelessly since our return from break to ensure the safety of our students and staff while many of us are watching the news and getting updates and crossing fingers hopefully not right for weather delays and um they're out in frigid temperatures checking the roads and our facilities to ensure we're all able to return to school safely also um just a special thanks to our bus drivers custodians and school nutrition staff they play an integral role in supporting our schools and our students every day but it is also challenging for them when we have delays and any type of inclement weather so um none of the staff that I mentioned take those responsibilities lightly I'm appre itive of
028uh their dedication to our students and to Orange County schools and for Mr Davis's leadership and for the leadership of all of the directors that support um our schools every single day thank you that concludes my comments thank you and I would Echo that as well Dr Jones that they have put in a lot of hours trying to decide what we need to do and and I appreciate that I would also like and I I meant to say this earlier like to thank the Orange County Sheriff's Office because this I don't know whether any of you have noticed but during this snow event um they have posted um pictures of our secondary roads and a lot of times our people in the district don't understand why we're not having school and those secondary roads are
029the main reason we are not having school and I appreciate very much the sheriff's department pointing out the roads that are hard to travel and that you might want to stay off of because they have not been scraped and not been treated and uh while Highway 70 and other roads are perfect some of these off to the side are not and so I I would like to give a shout out Sheriff Blackwood for um I I don't know who posts that I don't know how it gets there but um I think it gives the people an idea of what is safe and what is not safe and I really appreciate that so thank you to him for that so an I just wanted to also mention I know that uh I think you got the
030the text to on uh some of the crews that helped clean the schools our students in our district that work with the company and not only schools but also County property and others but it's one of those Partnerships we have with a company that actually hires students and gives them skills and you know lifelong skills similar to CTE but I'd be remissed if I didn't mention that from um you know some of our students getting that opportunity yes and uh we are very appreciative of everybody who has done everything to make sure that uh our schools are safe and ready to open back up from the roads to the schools so thank you very much uh at this time we need to the page we need a motion to adopt our consent agenda with the
031exclusion of policy 5150 and policy 9110 to discuss motion to approve second all in favor I I okay all right now before we go into our work session we will discuss policy 5150 and 9110 and Miss smiley you had some questions would you like to start that out sure that's thank you very much yeah so I had sent a couple of um suggestions ahead of the policy meeting and then didn't see any of those so I just wanted because I wasn't able to attend the policy meeting just Clarity on those points um and sort of what we're thinking so um I can just take each one or yeah for the first one uh which is talking about the reporting to external agencies um thank you for sending that ahead of time we did discuss that
032in policy and one of the the reasoning and and the question was hey a lot of these we already have in other policies if you're creating this policy you know and because historically what we've done is try to minimize those cross references and this policy is essentially only cross references so that was sort of my thinking like is that actually necessary so go ahead yeah so part of the request was from the staff and the district to have a a policy that they can refer staff to to go consolidate look look at it and have a single place to understand versus sending them oh you can find some here or here or here and to follow along with the school boards Association recommendation of trying to help consolidate that since reporting is so important but
033uh Dr Jones do you have anything else to add or that makes sense to me I I think like we'll just need to be particularly alert to when we add a reporting requirement somewhere that it also gets because then it creates an assumption by staff that if it's that if it's required that it's in that policy so we can't then miss new additions um that's a good point or I don't know of very many reporting requirements that ever get removed but um you know or removal of reporting requirements uh but I mean that's if it's if it's helpful to staff that's fine I think that's one of the reasons we've tried to minimize the cross references is because then you need to update things in multiple places and that tends that doesn't always happen um
034okay uh policy 9110 okay so this was about uh let me pull up the name of it use and selection of Architects Engineers surveyors and construction managers at risk I had two thoughts on this one one was um adding design Builders or design building firms to the title to make sure that it covered all of the different uh project delivery methods because it has construction manager at risk um but not that version not that um and then the other suggestion was um adding in the selection criteria adding something like um one of the selection criteria being evidence of meeting performance goals including energy goals when relevant so that was um you know building in as we're evaluating big construction projects um ensuring that we're also weighing in our selection of um of contracts uh some
035um consideration of their history of meeting performance goals and energy goals and if it's okay if we could have Mr Davis to come up to explain um Mr Aon and I will probably mess it up great Dr Jones uh Madam chair Vice chair Frederick Davis with operations um Miss Smiley thank you for your question um and Neil can correct me legally um but the statue is pretty much for the use of Architects and Engineers so your question about design build method um we do um have some information coming later on in the year concerning Bond updates uh it is my understanding that for a delivery method to be put on the table um we would have to go through um what we call um a uh an update to give you all the delivery methods
036that are possible the traditional design bid build um construction manager at risk um as well as um design build the reason why construction manager is in this use is because you don't necessarily have to use the delivery method of a sear firm um you can use a construction manager uh early on set of the project so if Dr Jones wants to uh consult with a construction manager firm on constructability um they may not be doing the actual Construction C which is a delivery method we can select them through this process to provide us the information that we need so U and we will take in consideration your comments in terms of qualifications um there is a note here that the superintendent can use other factors that may be relevant and so we'll check those comments
037and make sure when we develop our RFQ we have performative measures uh that will make sure we have the right candidate to do our work okay great thank you for both of those explanation so um this the this policy doesn't in any way limit our ability to go with like a design buil firm as because it had construction manager at risk and then some of the individual like Architects and Engineers like when we go with sort of the design yes so Architects and Engineers can be a part of a design build method um and the word I was looking for was resolution and so what we plan to do at a later State once we get further on in our bond updates is to bring for the various delivery methods uh and from that discussion
038the board can provide a recommen or we will provide a recommendation for the pros and cons of those delivery methods and then the board will make a resolution per project um what delivery method they want to okay but this doesn't preclude us from going with design build okay and then yeah I mean the the I saw the and other other things the superintendent prioritizes in terms of like the evaluation criteria so that's great I'm glad we're going to consider energy goals as part of that I do think we're at a point now where when we're doing big building projects we should just always be considering that um given the state of the climate um and so um and given like it's the County's priorities it's our priority you know so um to me putting it
039directly in that bullet list makes sense because it sort of communicates from the very beginning it doesn't create opportunity to like not prioritize that but I I guess I don't know how much discussion you all had of that particular point so so part of the discussion was that would probably be more appropriate to put in like policy 9030 and 9040 that are coming up which specifically talks about high performance building design criteria yes and you could put it in that versus this is kind of the role and that was more the discussion is hey those just hadn't come up as we're going through the 9000s it will come up and that that is where it would be added to to highlight that okay yeah that sounds good thank you for those explanations um I will
040motion to approve both of those policies I think they're both first read second yes they are that was a second to the motion that was second the motion and you were correct in what you were saying okay uh do I have a motion to approve I mean do I have a vote to approve excuse me all in favor all in favor I I all right we are approved and a roundabout one okay all right we will add that to the list and thank you um to everyone for your explanations of those all right we have two items on our work session tonight and the first one is the um midar discipline and attendance data and Dr Dreer I think will join us back with Dr lanir Who is here with us am I correct Dr
041laner Dr Dre is going to join us okay I'm here welcome back thank you can you all hear me okay all right excellent um good evening members of the board happy board appreciation month um thank thank you so much for all that you do for us and and supporting us in the work that we do Dr Jones Community stakeholders and fellow cabinet members good evening Dr Dreer and again happy Founders Day tonight Dr J and I are here to present midyear Panorama discipline and attendance data throughout this presentation we will discuss discuss each section supportive measures that are being used to support our Scholars and next steps as we triangulate this data to provide targeted interventions to ensure their success thank you we will start with our core beliefs as stewards of OCS We Believe
042students deserve consistency in use interpretation and application of OCS policies outlined in the code of student conduct students are more likely to uphold expectations when there is consistency in the application of policy among School staff it is also important to note that these expectations must also be taught to students and reinforced consistently at the school level parents and caregivers are essential in our continued efforts to support desirable School Behavior consistent communication is a vital action step in creating a positive climate and culture School administrations should use Equitable supportive measures opportunities strategies and interventions for students to solve problems and correct behaviors the key phrase is Equitable students should see teachers and teachers School professional counselors and administrators as allies rech research states that students are more likely to be successful in school when they are
043able to identify at least one one teacher Ally this is also a cultur responsive strategy and as such no student no one student is the same which is why it is extremely important that these supportive measures are targeted and finally reasonable and fair consequences should be issued at all times slid three and four here we go slides three and four provide a reminder of the goals of priority four empowering culture within our current strategic plan these goals serve as the foundation for the work currently being done at the school and central office level as well as the next steps that will be taken to ensure progress is being made in these areas slides five and six provide an overview of the professional learning that is being delivered and has been delivered by members of the
044equity and student achievement team for principles assistant principles Support Services which comprises of school professional counselors social workers psychologists nurses school-based teams and even substitute teachers to support the work of achieving the goal of priority 4 I will now turn the presentation over to Dr Dreer to briefly discuss the results of the Panorama survey data showing the percent of students by demographic that agree within each specific category and next steps from Fall 2024 Dr Dreer good evening once again um so just going to go over a little bit of information around the Panorama data but before I share with you um the data collected from this survey just wanted to give some updates on the administration of the survey itself um so previously when we did the survey we did grades three through 12 um
045and um also did it as an opt out um with changes to the uh parent Bill of Rights um there were some changes that were required um and so last um school year we did go to an op in on which we had a pretty low uh response rate at about 7% so this year um coming back to the board and speaking with our team um within the district but also with our Panorama team looking again at the details of the parent Bill of Rights um removed grade three um so only tested grades four through 12 um also removing questions from the survey that fall under those eight categories um in the parent Bill of Rights that required uh opt in um so um we were able to then redo the survey as opt out
046um and so approximately 100 students opted out um of that survey and our response rate districtwide grades 4 through 12 um increased back to 75.1% so we'll take a look at um some of the questions I won't read them out to you um but slides eight and nine are showing sample questions from the survey um in each category that are fourth and fifth graders did take um for those those are just sample questions what you see here is uh broken down by student demographics these are percentages of uh favorable responses um so if students chose strongly agree or agree this is the percentage of students that answered in that manner and this information for grades four and five is out of 761 fourth and fifth graders throughout County Schools next going to our secondary students
047and our grades 6 through 12 again that survey was adjusted and questions were removed in an effort to have an opt out situation no grades were removed only questions from this you'll see the next couple of slides 12 13 14 and 15 um again our sample questions um that came from the grade six through 12 in every category um as a reminder uh our fourth and fifth grade our elementary students have five categories that they answer in the survey our secondary students have 11 um and so that's why you see so many sample questions here if we go to this first graph this is out of 37 um students in grade 6 through 12 who responded so this first slide shows shows the first five of those topics um in those response rates um that
048you see there and then the second one shows the remaining five that are there um and you see those are positive rates um where we do see some low below 50% in the social perspective taking um but we'll use this information um to see how we can work with students to increase that next slide thank you um then we're looking at next steps and what that will do for us um so we're looking at using this data um with oural teams this is going to help us to determine if there are needs for small groups individual sessions or whole group guided sessions for students it'll help us determine any needs so if there is a need for us to refer any students to collocated services or in other words uh school-based Mental Health Services or
049other community services then also any school SCH wide behavioral planning and expectations as well as determining any steps for mcss support and placement in the areas of behavior okay over back to Dr lanir thank you Dr Drea for that and just want to make one brief correction there were 10 categories for six through 12 so and as as the slides just showed so um moving forward I will now discuss first semester data and begin with the review of our enrollment data and office referrals as a reminder Educator's handbook is a system that is used for all schools to keep track of both minor and major referrals schools use this system as a catchall meaning any and all documentation around behaviors is captured in the system regardless of the M the behaviors have risen to the
050level of needing administrative intervention it is important to note that the data that will be reviewed throughout the next several slides is reflective of July through the last week of December of 2024 due to Hillsboro Elementary being on a year round calendar in comparisons to the previous school year also reflect the same range of time Educator's handbook also tracks the district's enrollment numbers by demographics as reflected on slide 21 as reflected on slide 21 here are some quick facts about our enrollment we did have a decrease so pulling the uh the enrollment data from educator handbook we did have an increase from 7,136 students in 2023 when this data was pulled to 7,48 currently at at the time that data was pulled there was a decrease in all demographics except indigenous Asian and Hispanic students
051um currently right now our white students make up 46.7% of our total student population black students are 14.1% Hispanic students 29.6 multiracial students 7.2 Asian 2.04 and Indigenous 3% of our district uh student population slide 22 shows the total number of office referrals broken down by demographics you have slide 23 which shows the referrals by numbers of students within each demographic and slide 24 shows the grade location and activity where referrals are coming from it is important to note that the past three leadership meetings with principles and assistant principles have focused on work within plc's and collaborative teams on using all student data to enhance the overall classroom experience of our students meaning having teachers and administrators use this data as well as academic data to make necessary adjustments to keep students in classrooms provide
052rigorous and robust bell-to-bell instruction and differentiate The Learning Experience for diverse Learners and diverse learning styles slide 25 shows the frequency of actions taken as a result of the referrals here you will see that the majority of the actions taken are not punitive in nature so what does the data tell us there has been a decrease in referrals overall for our female students Asian indigenous Black and Hispanic students however we have seen a slight increase with our males and our multi-racial students slide 28 now shows in school suspension data it is important to note here that this includes students that may have served in school suspension for a period or a span of time during the school day not just the entire school day so for example it is possible say for example for a
053an elementary student to have 15 or 20 minutes but a teacher could actually code that or it could be coded as an in school suspension so any change of placement from the classroom is then going to be coded as an in school suspension unless it's actually coded as an out of school suspension So to that end we see those numbers here slide 30 begins our out of school suspension data with the number of incidents by number of students slide 31 shows a percentage rate by demographics and slide 32 shows the number of students who have received two or more suspensions which is a total of 36 students across 13 schools down one from the same time frame in 201 23 so what does that data show us first let's start with the review of goal
054two from Priority four in the Strategic plan goal two states that that that the suspension rate of black and multiracial students will be reduced to 3% by 2026 with a baseline starting at 9% though suspensions have increased for our multiracial students and we have not reached the reduction of the 3% the gold of the gold in the plan we are down from the 9% same is true for our black students as the suspension rate has decreased to 6.8 and we recognize that we definitely have more work to go our suspensions have decreased in every demographic except for males and Indigenous students and Flatline with our Hispanic students the increase in the percent for indigenous students only accounts for one the high percentage is due to the low number of the total number of students enrolled
055and then slide three 34 also provides data on our 36 students who have experienced two or more incidents of out of school suspension so the 36 students only account for a half of percentage point of our total student population in OSS excuse me in OCS the next three slides highlight tier supportive measures tier one being your Baseline led by teachers and school professional counsellors in and out of the classroom tier two targeting students experiencing an incident or repeated incidents of in school suspension and one out of school suspension led by SEO teams again consisting of school professional counselors psychologist and social workers with administrative support and tier three for our students experiencing two or more out of school suspensions led by District Personnel in school administration slides 39-41 provide an overview of Boomerang the services
056they provide our students through their strive program the data we have on referrals broken down by demographics as a reminder Boomerang only serves secondary schools 6 through 12 and the students have to be suspended for a minimum of 3 days in order to be referred and parents have to opt in to Boomerang for their services I will now turn it back to Dr Dreer to discuss attendance data and to close out the presentation Dr Dreer thank you so we are going to go over attendance data um want to start with um average daily attendance and then we will round out with looking at Chronic absences as a refresher um average daily attendance rate in North Carolina is the percentage of students present in a school each day um there is a formal provided for schools
057to get this percentage so what you will see here is the average daily attendance rate broken down by elementary middle and high school each of them are showing what their average daily attendance is from July until December of 2024 um and all of our schools are reaching near uh the goal as set in our strategic plan of 9 5% here you'll see chronically absent students um and as a refresher there um also in North Carolina chronic absenteeism is when a student misses 10% or more of school days in an academic year so for that's an average of about two absences per month um this includes both excused and unexcused absences um and this is not to be confused with treny um when we're looking at treny that is actually unexcused absences for the purposes of
058this slide we're looking at both excused and unexcused um this is broken down by year round which is hes our K8 traditional schools so our elementary and our middle schools and then our 912 traditional want to um take a have you take a look at our 912 traditional schools um and that red bar right there is probably a little bit concerning to you um but what we uh what I want to uh let everyone know if you notice that Aster down there at the bottom beside 912 traditional that is because our high schools look at absences a daily absences a little slightly differently whereas our K8 schools look at Daily absences our 912 schools look at it by class period um so this is for a count of students who have missed any class period
059throughout the day so that is why um it is it it looks higher than um the other grade levels as we look through our supportive measures for each tier um this first tier is zero to three days um and so those are students that are in tier one or all of our students receive this information so attendance lessons any incentives um and any contact with our teachers when you receive three days at tier two um this is early warning or 4 to 9 day is absent where we may add some mentoring some home visits and some referrals to either school-based or Community programming um as it meets the needs of the students and their families and then in tier three we're looking at 10 plus days um so that will be some monitoring um working
060with a mcss team member referrals to those community and school-based agencies and then also if applicable for that student and that family a referral to treny court so as we're looking at next steps we want want to continue to review our uh daily absences for students our class period absences for our high school students and what that looks like for them by conducting some collaborative uh collaborative meetings with our school Personnel to review this data um to take a look at those students um in particular in that tier three realm to see um how we can assist them with halting um those absences for getting any higher um and how to improve those tendance attendance rates as they go through that school year tying this back to cohort graduation rate um and looking at the
061effects of chronic as anism on how our students are making it through each of their uh years of high school and graduating timely um wanting to look at attendance data to determine next steps for mtss support and placement as we know that attendance um matters highly when we're looking at academic success as well as behavioral success and then providing of Family Academy sessions wanting to build capacity in our families on the importance of attendance what our policies are and provide ways how we can provide support to those families if they are struggling in that area are there any questions for us um M do yes thank you so much for um all of this data and for some of the takeaways I have a couple questions um from like takeaways that as they strike me
062and it's possible that I am misinterpreting something um so I'm kind of looking at office referrals and consequences um so noticing as I think was mentioned um uh went down for a number of groups but up for males and a couple of the bar graphs show looks like it like the total office referrals increase more significantly for white so maybe white males um less so for black students and uh and in some cases black students dropped in total number of office referrals so it's like seeming like this slight increase in office referrals for males and maybe white males um I'm a little puzzled like I have a little caveat I don't really understand how like office referrals and attendance like I don't think of those as the same you know what I'm thinking if someone
063having an office referral and it just has to do with attendance I'm not sure what to to make of that but it seems like the consequences um you know lunch detention and restorative activities have dropped in in school suspensions and out of school suspensions have increased um and then it seems like they have increased more for black students so it seems like how are we achieving our goal if there's a disproportionate increase for black students when uh office referrals for black students have actually dropped but their in school suspensions have increased and tell me if I'm like misconstruing what I'm seeing here so I think there there are several ways in which you can and ways in which you can look at this which is one of the reasons why I wanted to give the
064caveat at the very beginning that ultimately again schools are now using educator handbook again like I said as the catch all so that would explain number one why you have an increase and you have such a high number of referrals period And So to that end one of the reasons why I was pointing out um the the consequences that were there when which the vast majority of them are not punitive is because at the end of the day so like say for example you mentioned restorative pract restorative conversations may make going down but what you could also see is that the number of um administrative conversations that were happening were also High educator handbook allows you to C those those things differently so like say for example if I'm an administrator I may just choose
065or may just code and say that I've had the administrator conversation versus saying that I've also had a restorative conversation even though the two could have actually been the same the other piece of it is too it could be something as simple as in when I'm going in and looking at the data I'm also seeing this as well if if seven of you were involved in an incident technically that should be one however if an administrator May opt say for example to group two incidents at the same time so therefore your incident of course is going to increase and then of and then the consequence depending on what it is that you choose might actually Flatline or that also may increase so it just depends on how administrators are choosing to go in and when
066they're when they're actually doing the referrals or when they're actually being written up Andor teachers in terms of how they're actually grouping students or not so that's where you start getting those different numbers so imagine being me on the other end of the screen looking at that and looking at it by school and then of course giving that feedback to principles which is one of the reasons why there is been so much professional learning and professional development around that and why one of the things that we continue to stress is we're wanting consistency in term in terms of the interpretation of the policy so again that kind of um you know points out as to why there's been so much professional learning and there will continue to be professional learning along with um us going
067out as a um you know student achievement and Equity team to actually start having and presenting some of this information and some of this data to principles be able to say so we kind of want you to think about this a little differently and then encourage them to start having conversations with teachers around what that actually looks like so again there's more consistency does that answer your question yes that does except can you can you speak to the office um the attendance part how is attendance and office referral like what does that mean exactly so again that could be something as simple as um if a student comes in tardy or a student comes in late then a teacher May write a referral and they may just leave that there for documentation okay and so
068then it's just a matter of again sitting down and having a conversation with a teacher to be able to say so if I'm having a conversation with this student about the importance of getting to class on time then we also need for teachers to then go in and then again think differently is this a major referral or is this a minor referral because again that can also you know waight your data either way so again like I said it just depends on how a teacher Andor a school may be actually you know uh again if they're housing that data in that way in terms of just kind of you know keeping track of that I look at it from the standpoint of my staff when I was a principal they also used educator handbook as
069a catch all before we got um got some other features for Panorama as you as you know within during Public Schools but then you would actually be able to pull that report so if I'm sitting in front of a um in front of a parent I can pull that history of all of that documentation and it's like I said it would be there just for documentation not necessarily saying that there was a consequence that had been assigned to it okay okay so but you are talking about office referrals about attendance in terms of addressing attendance problem not a student stop stopping by the office to like sign in didn't sign in properly you're not talking about that okay no thank you you're welcome Miss Pia thank you thank you for the presentation I do have
070a few questions um and that was one like Miss doel said and I am wondering if you can give us examples as to what is inhouse um suspension and what is out out of school suspension so the public understands and I also understand what what qualifies that um and it when it comes to Chronic should we hold on that and then I'll go go you answer that so let me answer your first question because then when you because I'm going to Pivot to Dr Dreer to be able to answer your question about um about The Chronic aism so if I heard you correctly your question was for me to explain the difference between in school okay no give an example like for example you just said that if if a student comes in late uh
071they get a a tardy slip and then the teacher maybe speaks to them but that is not part of that does not qualify as a suspension I'm getting myself confused now um can you just provide an example as to what qualifies in school suspension and out of school suspension so let me first give a caveat to basically just say that again is to the discretion of um School administration and their interpretation of policy in terms of whether or not they actually issue the consequence I would also go back and this is one of the the reasons again why there's been so much professional learning around um you know the code of student conduct because previous the board previously before your iteration and also mine coming into the district was very keen on making sure that
072the levels when you go into the code of student conduct for a level one or level two that there are several interventions that actually have to be documented in place before you're actually able to get to some type of um suspension and it's I I want to say especially for a level two all of these interventions have to be documented and at Max a student would be able to be excuse me a student would be I don't want to say eligible but in essence a student could be suspended for a maximum of two days it's only when you start getting to a level three of course that you can expand more from that but those other pieces also still have to be documented in place so we would just depend on the policy violation in
073terms of whether or not again and and the severity of the violation of the policy in terms of where the out of school would actually go from an in school suspension to an out of school suspension that's at the discretion of administration okay you still didn't answer my question but okay I apologize so would you restate the question so that way I can make sure that I no I understand the explanation and I appreciate that but I wanted a simple example uh a student hit another student does that qualify as and that's what I was asking you know um my apologies so I'll go back to the example that Miss do was giving so if a student is simple something as simple as a student being tardy for class that's not any anything that would
074qualify as an out of school suspension that would be something that if it were chronic and it was something that was continue to continuing to happen could ultimately lead to an in school suspension and then it would be at the discretion again of administration if they issue that um that in school suspension in terms of if it would be for a period if it would be for a half a day or if it would be for a full day it could even be something as small as or as simple as 30 minutes where they're only missing half of class so again like I said that's at the discretion of administration if you then have have say for example a multiple on one and I'm using that as an example to say if students got into
075a physical ucation where you had three students that were you know again a multiple one three students up against one that would be something that would raise to an out of school suspension so that would be an example did I answer your question yes than okay oh it's okay any other questions I just had something on chronic um absences do we know why and what are we doing um to make sure the students are coming to school um yes I have many more but it's okay Dr so just to make sure I'm clear clear on your question do we know why the students are not coming to school yes okay I can don't have that to share with you tonight but I can get that information to you um as to looking at the reasons
076why um now I will say that how we enter those into Infinite Campus it's coded as excused unexcused um suspension that level um for us to say if it was because of a doctor's appointment that's notated in there it's not coded as a doctor's appointment but we have that information the schools collect that um if they are given Reasons from students Andor parents um about what happens and so we can try to pull those by code um by attendance code to see if they're excused unexcused or suspensions or other um and then see if we can pull some um more anecdotal data on the exact reasons why that's a little bit harder to to pull but okay I I think that if we understand why students are not coming to school um we would have
077a better understanding why we're not also improving our uh achievement Gap so that's why I like to understand and I like the fact that you guys wrote that we're going to be teaching people or the community um the consequences of not having students in our schools so I think parents need to understand and be educated as to the importance of attendance but thank you you're welcome I think sometimes we uh just assume that they know because maybe students have been in school for a couple of years but um just to reiterate again what those policies are what our procedures are um and then just really the importance of being in school building that capacity in our parents um um and our students as well so that they are uh have more awareness and want to
078come to school more so part of the meetings I just want to also throw this piece out as well that kind of goes um further into this question as well that you just raised so part of what we're going to be doing as a department again like I said when we start bringing some of this data to the um to the buildings as well we're going to we're going to be bringing the the data as well from all of the wraparound services that we have currently right now to be able to see if some of those things are actually working if some of the um some of our colleag from our um school-based uh social emotional learning you know teams have actually you know um provided some of those wraparound services for those students as
079well to also keep them in school if they haven't why let's go ahead and offer those those things to parents and that kind of goes back into that Family Academy session that we're also wanting to do so that way we're able to be transparent to be able to say here are all of the things that we have that are at your disposal for us to be able to assist so that that work is also still forthcoming as well thank you miss m um thanks um I have a number of questions but I'm sure others do as well um uh okay um so the I'll just go Section by section okay so the Panorama I was going to ask about year-over-year and everything but now that you reiterated what the response rate was last year I
080totally understand why you didn't do a comparison that totally makes sense um uh it would be help F to know a couple of other cuts of things that I think could be helpful to understand um one is like the difference between middle and high school responses if if there are any patterns there um as well as potentially any patterns in terms of gender um and I'm also curious if you all are um just generally looking at any like intersectionality patterns like are there particular you know are um uh black female students feeling more or less you know a sense of belonging for example like are are you all kind of looking at some of those things because that seems like a um potential yeah so a couple of data request type things and also are
081you all looking at that yes ma'am and yes ma'am um yeah we are looking at that information um that's helpful for us again to either from schoolwide down to classroom down to individual student what that looks like and what those areas so what they already have knowledge of or what gaps we need to fill um so we are definitely looking at that as well um and to that data that you're asking for we absolutely can uh get that pulled awesome um okay uh discipline data um first I appreciate the clarity about the number of incidents versus the number of students sometimes we've had questions about that as a board so I appreciate that you separated those out as well as um sort of like um individuals who've had multiple um incidents of out of school
082suspension um uh and what I have been really eager for sort of across all of these areas is for us to get to a place where we have really consistent reporting where it's the same uh set of stats um year after year at midy year or beginning mid end you know whatever the the pattern that that we are like getting clear on what those particular stats are that matter and I think that this is getting much closer to that so I'm hopeful that this is like the building of of that um uh I do think you have the in the summary of the data you have like the rates like the suspension rates or referral rates and those kinds of things and I think it would be helpful um to um like put that in
083a chart as well just to be able to um I I digust things more easily that way um I'm wondering if um if it's possible as we like get to the version of this that is the more consistent like this is how we report it every time I'm wondering if we can also break out um EC in addition to the other identities since we know that sometimes there are disparities in discipline um for EC students um and so understanding that um and then um also uh Curious whether to the point about like are there any takeaways when you when you break down the data that way are there any like intersectional takeaways I'm thinking of like a session that I went to at a at a conference one time where um they were digging into
084discipline disparities of black male EC students um and some of the strategies that a school system was using to address some of those disparities and so I don't know if those disparities exist in Orange County schools for example or not so um uh it would be helpful to know um just sort of generally whether there are any patterns in in like different intersections of identity um I have I have a couple of other things should we pass it around or should I just go through them just go ahead okay I'm gonna okay on a roll okay um great to see the okay and then I okay um it it's great to see that some of um regarding some of our goals like the um out of school suspension for black students has decreased ined um
085it's great to see that that has gone down um what I and then when I looked at it I re I realized that actually the degree of disparity has gone up because the because the decrease was even stronger for white students like the black students are x times more likely to receive an out of school suspension actually is higher than it was last year um which is one of those sort of it's like that the decrease is what we want and when we see whatever strategies we're using decreasing out of school suspensions for white students even more it makes me wonder um what we can learn from that and whether there's any opportunity there um in terms of how we're addressing discipline um does did how I said that make sense I wasn't sure okay
086okay um uh it also is great to see the um the tiered support measures and I'm curious um I really like that we're addressing this in a teered way like this I'm curious if these are like like we've got this like these are applied consistently like each of the schools is clear that these are this is for a tier two student these this is our menu and this is what we're going to do and and making those decisions um uh so that that's a question and then also is there any consideration for students year over year so like a student has a lot of challenges last year this school year has started this could be for attendance or discipline or whatever like this year has started and it might not need to take several incidents
087to be able to like connect back with the family and say like you know let's get ahead of this um those are those are a couple questions about the so I'm going to I'm going to address them quickly just to B to basically go um back and reiterate so again I think that's the reason that there's consistency in and there are multiple professional learning sessions with principles and assistant principles and school-based teams and there will continue to be because again we're going to always strive for that consistency across the buildings um in terms of that and so not only again like I said in terms of the policies but then again how we're looking at a referral period how we're looking at the different strategies that can be used um and and you know things
088not having to necessarily be punitive or thinking outside of the box about some ways in which we can again keep our students in the building restore our students so that way the behaviors change but then also too making sure that we're tying that back to classroom practices because we also recognize that again that if we're not having something that's Bell to Bell and and students are constantly busy like kids will do what we allow them to do and so any of us will right like adults anytime we have some free time we'll we'll pick up the phone and kind of do whatever and we'll start getting distracted as well so we recognize that there there are lots of ways to be able to look at this and so again there that that's the reason that
089there multiple sessions there have been multiple sessions there will continue to be and we're definitely going to uh you know Target the supports that we're actually giving to schools because obviously of course data is different you know based upon the school the level Etc please uh re uh ask your second question again the year-to year like are you are you are schools at the point where they're also thinking about like the pattern from last year and what's happened just in terms of getting ahead of things hopefully like a student we want students to have a fresh start yep and if a pattern is reemerging like is that but that actually goes back to too something that I pointed out at the very beginning around um the research based strategy that is also culturally responsive in
090terms of making sure that that student has an adult that they can actually look to as an ally so that is work that not only has come out of that's come out of some of the trainings and stuff that we've done with again with the various teams um but also making sure too say for example that there is consistency across those relationships having conversations not only from grade to grade but then also from school to school one of the things that I'm I'm sure that uh my principal colleagues are tired of me tired of hearing me say but I will continue to say because it's true the feeder patterns are very very clear here so we know who's going to go from one Elementary School for the most part to a middle school say for
091example if you're an orange middle you're going right across you're going right across the parking lot to Orange High so there's nothing that says that we can't go midy year say for example and start introducing and I'm just using this as an example like introducing that eighth grade student to some of the adults that are over at the high school so that way that bridge just continues on so those conversations have absolutely been had that's also part of the reason why too from our department that we're wanting to actually provide schools with a list to be able to say here's who we've pulled here's who we're identifying let's let's sit down and have the conversation again let's talk about these wraparound Services let's talk about you know some things that we may actually need to
092come in and do whether it be with um you know again with individual students providing individual students uh you know with support or some you know moreal providing some you know staffs with training continuing to you know analyze the data which we will as it is anyway but all of those pieces putting that in place but to your point we're definitely wanting to make sure that we're creating those bridges not only from grade level to grade level but also from school to school because we are small enough that that work can actually be done that's great okay sorry my last thing attendance okay um it is I'm glad that you have the chronic absenteeism sort of broken out um I'm glad two that you know it's like PR rated for the year it's like 10
093at this point would be considered on track for chronic Ally absent um it would be helpful to see all of the attendance data over time so I think that some of those schools have really improved their attendance rates over last year but the attendance data last year was in a totally different format so I you know it would be great to like be able to see that pattern um and um it does seem worth to me like thinking about The Chronic absenteeism in high school because that's like 75% of high school students are chronically absent I think and in tier three is what that chart would mean and that doesn't that doesn't comport with like the attendance rate you know what I mean so there's something that doesn't feel fully captured about like are we
094really getting chronic absenteeism and the tearing at the high school level right um uh so I'll just put that out there that's not a question for you to answer just like a thing I think we need to think about okay and and I think that kind of goes back to that because it's by period yeah not by day it's going to be higher because if I miss first period for a week that's five absences and so it's that rate is going to be higher because it's by portion of the day and not the full day yeah it would just be great if we could break that out like I do think that that matters you know I think like we have athletes missing lots of last period of school kind of stuff too you know
095but like well I'll say to you that we are um D Dr Dre and I say for example we're actually in a um in a virtual meeting today and so again when we talk about you know pulling some of this data um I don't want to say selfishly number well selfishly number one we definitely want to make sure that every single uh student is in class every single day right but then also too when we start thinking about our high school students we want our high school students to graduate on time with their cohort so that's really where we're coming from at this point in time now to be able to start trying to put these supportive measures in place to ensure that that's actually going to occur because we don't want to we don't
096we don't want to rock we don't want students to rock the boat as a result of them as a result of something that could actually be um you know very easily you know solved or again like I said we can kind of put some things in place to be able to support that child and or you know also start working with you know with teachers uh as well for them to be able to I mean something as simple as open up assignments to make sure that they're you know they have time to be able to go back and you know recover whatever it is that they missed so we're coming at it from you know from two areas if that makes any sense yep yep um and then um Wendy asked about the are we
097keeping track of the reasons um I also just want to um suggest that we ask students as well like we just the the qualitative finding out why kids are missing school and then potentially coding that in some additional way so that we can understand those patterns um and that we're also keeping track and sort of counting whatever the success stories are you know like when kids are moving out of tier three uh into tier two and tier one um like there I know that schools are doing a lot to get kids in back in class and so like I hope that we're also keeping track of how many kids were able to move back into strong attendance and keeping track of what worked um as well so and we're getting that from the the wraparound
098data that we're collecting from the schools awesome awesome okay thank you thank you very much Miss Hower yeah thank you um I want to ditto on on I really request for information about the absences and why kids are out and so um and then this question of there structural changes that you know kids missing buses you know we just don't know it would really be helpful to understand the why um I but I really want to start first with a thank you for the creativity around changing the questions in order to improve the response rates very clever and um it obviously worked so very nice to see that um this on Panorama um just a couple questions on discipline in the past the you know be um I think I think it was Sarah s
099for disaggregating uh middle and high school data and and I some people have said fourth and fifth also but to disaggregate the data to say where are the behavior patterns and in the past one of the questions the board has had is do we need to bring in some alternative do some subsets of students need alternative settings smaller classes like partnership for middle school or maybe uh you know even younger grades but we you can't see that from the data and we don't know if that's something that you're looking at or considering but do we need to you know cuz that that's always been the story that we've been we've been gotten and you don't have to answer that I'm just kind of throwing that out here for you to think about um so it'
100be helpful to break out the data elementary middle and high I like the idea of bringing breaking out EC but also economically disadvantaged you know cuz that it seems as a and if you can break that out that might be very formative um and then the you had mentioned that putting kids in uh doing an MTS tiering for the social emotional learning is that something we've done or we're in the process of doing or we hope to do is that aspirational or is that something we've done so what I hear you asking is our students currently are they classified do we know who the tier ones and tier twos and tier 3es are oh absolutely we do okay so we do at the beginning you said one of our principles is that every student should
101have an ally in school and I love that question is do do they and especially the kids that are at risk do they have an ally and do we know if they have an ally in their school so that's part of again the data that we're going to be collecting because that's also one of the strategies that needs to be implemented if not and so um what we're wanting to do is wait we have obviously our discipline data right but we're also wanted to do is wait so that we again when I was talking about triangulation of the data we also want to make sure that we're putting in the academic data as well because there could be you know as a result say for example them not feeling a connection to the school because
102they don't have an ally or an adult Ally so then that could also potentially affect their beginning of year data and also their Moi data so we're wanting to we're wanting to bring basically every single thing that we know about this child so that way we can say here's a complete profile based upon what we're able to see and then from that standpoint again what specific targeted supportive measures do we need to do so that will be one of the pieces that we will be asking schools because obviously schools would be the ones to be able to answer that question for us right and so and it's hard from from sitting on the board so you know the real question is how's it going in our schools and what's needed right and so yes that's
103that that's an important question to me is to know that our kids have an ally and would presume you're right it would improve academics it would improve be discipline and it would improve attendance so one of the things that I do want to point out however however is if you go back and look at the presentation the very first category under the Panorama data there were questions around um allyship and questions around relationships that that children also had with adults so you can see ultimately what those percentages ended up being but to your point having a conversation with an individual child versus an entire you know building or entire po population of course is something definitely different so again that is information that we're going to be seeking from those school-based uh teams yeah and
104I can get really you can get really lost in the data so 75% which is a great response on Panorama but if the 25% that didn't respond are the ones that we really need to those are the tier twos and tier 3es absolutely that's where we Absolut need to go um on on um let's see the attendances on the excused versus unexcused us do do we care about the excused absences or are those also of concern to us I'm not yes when we're looking at Chronic absence yes excused and unexcused matter um because if you're out of school you're out of school no matter the reason um and so we want to see what those reasons are are they preventable are they something that we can help support to fix um or uh something that
105maybe a plan needs to be put in place for that student and so we do want to look at both excused and unexcused absences because they do count towards um a student being chronically absent or not got it got it so an accuse excuse absence like if you have a do if you're out sick that would be excused but it also if you missed the bus that could be excused also I will say Miss Hower an absence is an absence is in absence yep um yeah uh let's see I think those those are most of my questions I mean very really good thank you Mr as any question yes um so I I agree with a lot of the questions that were asked one of the things I think is key that Sarah brought up
106is US seeing this in a common format and I I'd like to recommend that we first see it uh in the teered state so we have we spent a lot of time going and saying here are the different rules so tier one tier 2 tier three tier four and say okay K through five what are the tiers that we're seeing what are the numbers middle school high school so every year we see where these are falling versus here's a few samples of of the high numbers because we can't see year-over-year are we seeing lots of tier ones are we seeing lots of tier two three four but just a way for us to see the numbers in a in a in a way that makes some sense of year-over-year and what we're seeing um I
107think that would be very helpful um also I definitely would like to see the breakout of the EC numbers as well as mentioned I do know that we have the 4307 uh regulations and procedures that are different for our EC students so understanding you know where students are falling under there because some of the rules are different like you know if you have an in school suspension but you're not getting Services it's still considered an out of school suspension even though you're in so there's some finer details if we see that data just having some understanding of what what it means and the the mapping of it also I you know concerned about the attendance as well and I just want to say this publicly because I've seen a lot of concerns because schools are
108running contest if you will to show the attendance and of course nobody wants six students at school that is not the purpose of these contests these contests are really to encourage families and the excitement of being at school and the learning not hey can you send a a six student to school and so I just wanted to say that out loud and also I think one of the things that you know was mentioned and people may not realize and we talked about this a lot and the the policy as we walk through this is you know Elementary students that are late or they're not there it's not their fault and that is why it is a tier one we're not I believe and I want the nodding of everybody is that we are not suspending
109students in elementary or metal that have no control of their ability to do their by you know having inch School suspending because of attendance right and high school skipping class and things like that is different but we talked about that and that's why it's a tier one where it's really looking at what supports can they have and the family as well but I just wanted to say that out loud what I'm just going to throw in and kind of pigy back off of what you said to also say too that again within the trainings or whatever that have been given with principles it's one of those things that we have made sure to point out that per policy you can't and is actually in the policy so yeah so I I want to Echo what
110it is that you're saying and say that obviously of course from the floor well you can't do that so that's one of the reasons why um so yes you're absolutely correct because it is a level one and the only reason I mentioned that is because it's very different if you have a high school student skipping a class versus somebody in Elementary in Middle who has some other dis different situation whether it's excused or not I just wanted to highlight that because you know as we talk through these you know a lot of people may not realize the subtle differences on there and one thing we did do a couple of years back is we did add uh Park lot attendance and some Hall monitoring if you will at high school have we seen a difference
111in helping with that and ensuring students aren't leaving or you know going to lunch and not coming back ha have we seen any correlation in the having those in place to help with our high school students so I'm going to be very transparent and tell you that I will have to go and look at that data from you because again I I I until you said that there was a a parking lot attendant I did not know that there was a parking lot attendant keep in mind I'm a middle school person it's my apologies for that knowing but I will absolutely go back and look at that information for you as well okay I appreciate that that is one of the things that came back to us is one thing that would really help out
112and ensuring students aren't leaving during the day um but I I can just add that both High School principles have shared with me the help and support that both of those individuals the um parking lot attendant and the attendants I don't know the exact name um person how they support and help students to stay in school and to leave and come in at appropriate times and they do some other things to around the school but they are very appreciative they probably told me because you know they want to make sure they keep those positions um but they were um very pleased with with those being add it and it's been very supportive yeah any any data we could get on that would be great thank you Mr mman have any questions i' just like to
113say thank you for this data um it's it's much easier to understand this year I think and I greatly appreciate that um the principle in me is asking and thinking has the school Improvement team seen the data any of this data and is that going to be given to school Improvement teams in in our schools and oh absolutely it I thought it was but I just you know want to ask that question um everybody's on the same page absolutely we are actually working on right now um because we're wanting to actually come up with one template one spreadsheet with several tabs down at the bottom so that way all again everybody seeing it the exact same way we're going to have all of our categories across in terms of wraparound Services again attendance at their
114High School how it's affected their cohort graduation rate that was part of the meeting that Dr Dre and I were having today in terms of what the what the design of that will actually look like but we definitely want to make sure that we're also including the um the academic performance date as well because all of those pieces are actually tied together this will also make it very easy say for example someone theseal teams start actually involving parents because I want to go back to the fact that it's very important to uh again to communicate with the parents so again principal to principal right so we have all of that so literally all they're having to do is basically just take that line and plop it down and just say so hey Mom hey Dad
115you know hey caregiver here's what we're seeing and so here are the things that you know that that that we're putting in place to be also to be able to support but you as a cultural broker we also want your input as well so that way we can make sure that we're putting together the right formula so again talking about that targeted intervention for the students to make sure that we're uh we're making some gains and improvements in all those areas absolutely thank you so much you're welcome can I do um yes Miss do sorry you're fine one um follow up with a question about the the disparate um suspensions that that both Sarah and I were mentioning earlier and curious with slide 41 with Boomerang um and I know this has this isn't the
116first time to raise this but just wanted to raise again um how much is that the fact that uh we're still seeing more black students being suspended than white students how much is the access to Boomerang because this slide 41 um shows I guess it's showing who showed up right who took advantage of boomerang because that mentions the total referrals was and it also so that data helpes who actually completed the program so again they have to be suspended for a minimum of 3 days um transportation is no longer a barrier because Boomerang does offer Transportation but it then goes back to two they have to actually complete the program not also just be referred and and parents of course always have the option of opting out of of sending their students to Boomerang regardless
117of the option for transportation and if you'll notice at the bottom of that slide um miss doyo it does show um the total referrals but then also the um no shows or those students who were unsuccessful as well so that kind of gives you a a number to see in comparison of who was referred and uh who completed and did yes thank you all right thank you all so very much we greatly appreciate your information and your hard work on this and we look forward to even more thank you thank you thank you okay up next we have the academic calendar and Dr Pac is going to be uh leading the charge on that so welcome Dr Pac thank you uh good evening board thank you so much for all that you do to support
118our students in education um this month and every month um tonight I have uh the pleasure of presenting to you the proposed calendar for the school year school year uh 2526 the process that we went through to get to this point is that we have a calendar committee made up of the folks that are on the screen they represent all of the schools and uh and then departments key departments that um represent folks in our in our district like operations and uh Child Nutrition but transportation folks that are in impacted by the calendar as a reminder when we uh when we develop a calendar we are uh we have to follow the constraint set forth by the calendar law uh the one that is the most restrictive is the first on the list which dictates
119to when we can start school with students and when we have to end school with students and we have to fit all the other stuff in that tight time frame so there really aren't a whole lot of options it's just where you want to put it's a it's like a Jinga game right you where you're going to put the puzzle pieces when we worked with the calendar committee this year the calendar committee had some priorities and the priority was really about balance when you see this uh calendar that's the that was the primary focus balance balance between the needs of our certified staff our classified staff and our students and our families the balance with year round and traditional calendars and so keeping that in mind some of the things that you'll see in these
120calendars is that there is a reduction from 20 teacher work days to 18 teacher work days and that's because when our students aren't in school as Dr Jones indicated earlier our cafeteria workers and our bus drivers don't work and uh we heard we heard from our transportation and our Child Nutrition about how hard it is to find workers when they don't have as many days to work they're going to go find work in other places so we're balancing that with the need for the planning for the teachers and a reminder that students when they're not in school don't have access to meals or other wraparound supports so that was the proposal to reduce those two teacher work days the calendars that are being proposed also was a real effort to align the days off as
121much as possible teacher work days and then we eliminated the 3-hour early release for professional development that was unpopular with staff and also with our families also we have to keep in mind that a teacher's contract is 215 days and putting all the things into place uh what makes up those 215 days are the instructional days the teacher work days the annual leave days and the holidays the holidays and the annual leave days are Set uh based on set numbers so the the only equation that we have to to mess with there is in the instructional vers teacher work days so this calendar that you see before you today um as a proposed has 215 days with 176 instructional days up from 174 last year or this current school year 18 teacher work days 11
122holidays and 10 annual leave days the work days are designated in this calendar but they have not been determined required or optional at this point by law two um two have to be designated as optional and they will be uh but we wanted to expedite because we didn't have a 25 26 calendar yet and this is a time that folks are looking at the summer and year round stuff so we wanted to get this into the hands of the public as soon as possible the calendar committee is reconvening at the end of January to designate those do designate those days and are collecting recommendations from the staff at their schools right now for that consideration as a reminder required days will be designated as school-based or District based primarily for professional learning or planning purposes
123an optional days are designated as days where staff can take accumulated leave and we will not have any scheduled required professional development activities finally the uh calendar Committee created uh two drafts uh for each calendar so there were two traditional drafts and two year round drafts uh we gave uh calendar talking points to the principales and sent them the drafts of these calendars they then turned around and gave that information to their staff and they also had their calendar committee folks to help explain and uh there was Voting at the school level the principals conducted the school voting in December District departments did not vote and uh the traditional schools overwhelmingly selected option b and the year round uh which is Hillsboro Elementary selected year round option A so I want to give you a
124calendar overview and if you'll pop up the traditional calendar while he's pulling that up just thought it would be good for you to look at while um I actually printed them and left them on the printer as I came over here so sorry about that um so in calendar this option be for traditional If You Squirrel up just a little bit the key features are this calendar has a fall break for students the entire week of Thanksgiving which is comprised of two teacher work days one annually vacation day and two holidays there are work days on this calendar in November and March for the election days on the election days because four of our schools are voting sites uh winter break is two weeks for students um and also that comprises nine vacation days for
125staff and one teacher work day uh there is alignment with the yearr round calendar for eight nine days um uh nine work days so there's a beginning day in August um there's a the voting day in November there's the two work days along the um the Thanksgiving week There's a a work day in February the voting day in March a work day in April and then two days at the end of the year after and they also have an aligned start excuse me aligned finish date they don't start on the same because year round starts in July but they end on the same day in June and finally the spring break is aligned with Good Friday holiday and we heard a lot about that they didn't like the separation between the Good Friday holiday and
126and spring break and is also enveloped in the year round intercession all right we'll switch to the excuse me the year round calendar so the year round calendar as you can see is a uh start date for students on July 16th which is a Wednesday um and there are five teacher work days prior to the first day of school it also ends on June 10th as we said which is aligned to the traditional calendar they also have the work days on the November March November and March election days the full week for Thanksgiving and three weeks between Thanksgiving and winter session which is what they were um requesting so tonight before you we have uh the recommended calendars from the calendar committee and the schools voting uh for the 2526 school year just to note
127that Our intention was to bring two calendars for you tonight uh the 25 26 and the 26 27 we ran out of time but we would like to bring those back to you before the end of the school year so that we will be a year ahead for every calendar year uh and this will be we'll do two this year but then we'll just start one next year so what questions do you have m m mine simple first of all thanks for this and I already got compliments about the Thanksgiving week break people are really happy to see that um how do you count today how does today where is a because in a few year this district has had some trouble with inclement weather days so how does that get addressed in the calendar
128so the state law go back to the calendar um law requirements uh we can have um 185 days or 1,25 instructional hours so we can count the school year either way we have chosen Orange County to use the instructional hours so we calculate the number of hours that we have the minimum that we can go to school is 1,25 hours so our current schedule when we build in the time with the 176 instruction days gives us several days over our hours so ultimately we have a few days that we can bank for bad weather or unexpected being out um after that then we trade out work days um but so like today is a banked hour day yeah for students thank you for that yeah very helpful great great job thank you Mr thank you
129all so much and thank you for the detailed explanation of how you all go through this and I I think you know uh ironically connecting to absenteeism I think Thanksgiving and others when you look at the dates these are occurring on you know how is that going to improve because I do know parents have told me hey we want to take this week off but you're only doing this so I think some of that thoughtfulness that you had will help with with that one one request I do have is when we post the calendar could we make it ada8 compliant and look at contrast versus just colors because I do know we do have families that that would be greatly appreciated yes thank you for that and uh reminded me of a talking point that
130I forgot to share with you which is uh when we do uh make this calendar public for um families we're going to have the calendar version which is like what you see with the with the days but also a a word version by month so that um Meeting those different modalities and language needs um and we're excited about that that change so fantastic thank you questions Miss B yes um thank you very much for this um all the hard work of the committee um Sometimes they come but thank you to the committee if you're watching this um a couple of um I'm glad that we have some inclement weather uh banked um uh when we do post this um I think this year's also has like what's the makeup plan for inclement weather on it
131I think that would be helpful um as well as um uh like it says no school where you know if it says AVL it says no school um so that families um understand uh what that means um so hope we will continue with those things as well um uh it this calendar um name specific religious holidays like Good Friday and Christmas and I I think we've decided not to put specific religious holidays on the calendar um so I think certainly it's easy to note no school without saying Good Friday for example um obviously lots of people celebrate Good Friday and not everybody does um and uh and then the other thing was I didn't see um juneth on here as a holiday I know it's not during the school year um and that would be
132on a a staff calendar that we would that would cover the 12 months we we talked about and it actually was on some original drafts but that having it outside of the school the the the 10 month school calendar would could be confusing uh so we um it'll it there'll be a version for staff that talks about um you know the 12- month staff and that will be so we're still acknowledging they still have juneth off it is still a holiday here okay um great thank you and and to your note about the holidays they're listed on here on the draft because uh we have to follow the the holidays that are taken by the state of North Carolina um government office and those are the ones um so they were just listed here for
133our reference but we will remove that forward and it's helpful to see how they how they line up or whatever but yeah thanks any other questions I just want to say thank you and I appreciate I appreciate hearing how much participation there was at at the school level as well as you know seeing all the members of the calendar committee so I know a lot went into this and I appreciate the presentation and where you all ended up I think it looks great thank you and uh I'd like to Echo your thanks to the calendar committee folks you know a lot of them are our school teachers who taught all day long and then came to uh a several hour meeting afterwards and we very passionate um about the calendar uh work that we did
134and so I would like to Echo your thanks um Our intention is to return this to the consent agenda for you at the January 27th meeting um you do have the option if you're if you would like to go ahead and approve it um so I'll give you that option I I would prefer to do it but we must convert it to an action item first right is it just as a procedural issue would it you would since the agenda is already approved you need a two-thirds vote to amend the agenda to make an action item if you want to vote on it now motion to change this to an action item second all in favor I motion to approve second second okay all in favor I I I it's approved thank you our folks
135will be really happy about that thank you and thank you to the under committee too from me because I heard you had some very long meetings and um I we just want to make sure we got the job done well so and you did so thank you very much we appreciate it all right um anything else for tonight do I have a motion to adjourn motion to adjourn second all in favor I I we are adjourned thank you very much