CorpusRecord 214762

Orange County Board of Education Regular Meeting - December 9, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Orange County, NC Board of Education
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Orange County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
20,238 words · about 113 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good evening I'd like to call this meeting of the board of Orange County Education together um tonight um and we will start by a motion I need a motion to go into Clos session for reasons so stated on the agenda motion to go into Clos session okay I have a motion do I have second second second all in favor I I thank you Mr Aston all right we will move move into Clos session and be back shortly e e e good evening everyone and thank you for your patience I'd like to call this meeting of the um board of education for December the 9th to order and we will start with the public charge I will read the Orange County Board of educ education pledges to its citizens to conduct its business

002in a courteous and productive manner showing respect for fellow board members staff and citizens the board asks its citizens to conduct themselves with the same courtesy toward both School personnel and each other a moment of silence will be observed before each meeting in addition to the moment of silence the board will recite the Pledge of Allegiance the board asks that you check your cell phones and other electronic devices to be certain that they are either turned off or on vibrate to avoid Interruption of this meeting and at this time we will stand for the Pledge of [Music] Allegiance I pledge Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice thank you and now we will observe a moment of

003silence [Music] okay thank you very much all right we have several uh recognitions that we will move into tonight first one being special education day and I see our special education direct Miss um Burns right there so welcome welcome good evening thank you for giving me this opportunity to speak today in recognition of special education day this day is a chance for us to come together and reflect on the value that special education brings to our schools our students and our community as a whole the foundation of special education day lies in the individuals with disabilities Education Act or Ida a landmark law ensuring that students with disabilities have a free the right to a free and appropriate public education Ida emphasizes the importance of meeting the unique needs of each student providing individualized support

004and ensuring that students with disabilities are included in a general education environment wherever possible special education day honors this commitment and recognizes the collective efforts um required to fulfill Ida's promise to our schools we celebrate the achievements of our students who receive special education services and we acknowledge their hard the hard work of their families teachers related service providers and instructional assistance along with our support staff these individuals put in countless hours often navigating unique challenges with dedication and resilience every success whether big or small is a testament to the power of patience persistence and partnership at its core special education day is about Equity it's about ensuring that every student regardless of their abilities or needs has access to an ed education that respects their potentials and supports their growth for each child is

005about nurturing their strengths meeting their needs and building a foundation for lifelong learning and Independence but reaching this goal doesn't happen by chance it requires commitment investment in our Educators equipping our classrooms and fostering our culture where all students feel they belong as we celebrate we also are reminded of the work ahead of us we must continue advocating for resources training and support necessary to provide each student with the quality education they deserve in closing I'd like to thank thank you all for your ongoing support of special education um the support of special education in our schools together we are building a community where every student is valued included empowered to succeed let us keep working together to ensure our schools are places where all students have an opportunity to thrive thank you thank you

006[Applause] Miss okay up next we have our recognition for New Hope Elementary School I think Dr lenir is going to lead that good evening it is an honor and a privilege to recognize the distinguished strategic and instructional servant leader of New Hope Elementary School Dr Meredith Mayer a little known secret before she was a principal at New Hope she was my assistant principal for two years at brogon middle school and we did amazing work together to this day hiring her has been the second best decision I have ever made in my professional career listening to Dr Jones is my first because of her Visionary leadership New Hope Elementary School was honored for closing the achievement gap between student groups with the national Esa distinguished schools award and as a reminder New Hope is currently in

007the top 2% in the state out of 2593 schools for student growth earned an evos index of 7.15 is currently ranked ninth out of all elementary schools in the state and third among all elementary schools in the Triangle so to say that Dr mayor is a rock star is not even putting it into words I'm very very proud of you um I'm proud to call you my colleague and I'm proud of all that you were doing for the students uh in Orange County Schools specifically at New Hope Elementary so go voyagers so please everyone stand to your feet and give a round of applause to Dr conratulations to you and your school for all your um accomplishments okay up next we have the um ncsba Bell award for this entire board I believe and Mr

008mcon is going to tell us about that yes ma'am good evening board chair pcel by shair Richmond superintendent Jones members of the public it's my pleasure tonight to present a recognition to the board so on behalf from the North Carolina School boards Association they're proud to present the school board of Orange County a whole board recognition this honor is given to school boards when every member of the board has earned training credit hours during the previous Academic Year the Bell award is given at two levels a gold Bell award is given for all members who have earned at least 12 hours are training between July 1st 2023 and June 30th 2024 and a Silverbell award is given when all members of the board have earn some training during that time period tonight on behalf of

009the national the North Carolina School Board Association I present two our board a silver bell award for your work last year and I will keep this at King Street congratulations [Applause] thank you Mr mcon okay um next we have uh agenda adoption do I have a motion to adopt our agenda for this evening so second all in favor to what Mr Atherton do we have your vote as well he he did okay I didn't hear it I'm sorry okay sorry but um Madam chair we do want to pull um policy 4150 when we get to to to that portion we just want to share a couple of updates to the board for that policy before it's approved and we will move that into the discussion action before the school spot assignment is is that what

010we yes ma'am that that's it shouldn't take long okay all right this is okay is the board okay with that okay all in favor again with that change I I okay Mr Atherton a motion motion yes I I'm sorry I don't know why y can hear me I I did not make an em motion I just asked if uh everybody was in favor of that so I'll make a motion that we remove policy for uh what is it 51 4150 4150 and discuss it um as action action item a under discussion um do and we have so okay is that so yes okay so all in favor of doing that all right Mr Atherton yes yes okay all right that's where we will move that policy then okay at this time we move into public

011comment and um Mr Richmond you have that all right in front of you we will now hear public comments speakers will be called in the order in which they signed up each speaker will have three minutes yielding time to other speakers is not permited if a speaker has written materials they'd like to share please hand them to our board clerk Franklin mckune and he will distribute them to the board the purpose of public comment is for the board to hear from members of the public not to engage in back and forth discussions per our policy board members will not respond to speakers during the public comment session the board greatly values public feedback and welcomes all comments regardless of viewpoint however please be reminded that children are often present at these meetings and that our

012public comment policy prohibits profanity vulgarity and personal abuse of any person we ask that all comments be civil respectful and free of personal attacks any speaker who violates our public comment period or otherwise exceeds the bounds of order order or decorum will be given a warning continued violations may result in the speaker being ruled out of order at which point we will move on to the next speaker our first Speaker tonight is Bob Fowler thank you so much for allowing me to speak my name is Bob Fowler director of child evangelism Fellowship of North Carolina we sponsor The Good News Club a nurturing welcoming privately sponsored after school enrichment club with with an emphasis on good character it's taught from a Christian biblical perspective attendance is free children may only attend with written permission from

013their parents good news clubs have been provided immediately after school in Orange County for the last 17 years our curriculum relates directly to North Carolina character statutes which require that schools teach principles of character responsibility respect kindness courage Integrity self-discipline and perseverance all these qualities are taught in the Good News Club culum Our concern is that even with our excellent working relationship the last 17 years with many principes teachers and parents warning Us in the schools that these clubs have been stopped we started out it started out when we came to a meeting to work on this year's custodial fees and the superintendent said that we could no longer meet directly after school because our teachers could not be around other non-good news club children we're also concerned about people being around the children all

014of our staff and volunteers are National criminal sex offender background checked most have been background checked already through the school system as school volunteers we brought uh the superintendent to their attention that we there are other great Community um nonprofit groups like girls in the Run offering other activities at no charge to Children immediately after school and that they are still being allowed to meet and that the Supreme Court requires the schools to treat good news clubs equally with other community nonprofits in the ruling of Good News Club versus Milford Central school district June of rather than allowing these great services to our children and their families they were given the same stop instructions reviewing School District policies 5030 and 5035 Orange County Schools is committed to a position of neutrality in matters of religion

015and that they shall not discourage religion but they shall promote an understanding of religious diversity encourage a spirit of Brotherhood and cultivating Harmony maintaining neutrality the board encourages the use of school facilities and grounds by the community for educational recreational Civic cultural activities to the extent possible under District laws and regulations so we believe that this discrimination against good news clubs directly violates your Schoolboard policy our volunteers devote hours materials out of pocket because we love these children we want these children to learn good character and be good citizens we respectfully request a reconsideration and ask that you allow again all Community groups regardless of religious Viewpoint to meet directly after school to serve these children their families and yes our community we ask for your consideration thank you the next speaker is David O'Quinn

016good evening board members and Dr Jones my name is David O'Quinn and I am here as a Good News Club volunteer leader and most of all a 50-year plus Orange County resident and Orange County taxpayer who is very concerned about the recent implemented policy from the school superintendent regarding our after school clubs first I attended and graduated from Orange County Schools have two sons who attended and graduated from Orange County schools and have two grandchildren one of which is currently attends orange middle like many of the volunteers as a parent and grandparent have regularly volunteered with Orange County schools during sporting events field trips fundraisers Etc and as many did homeschooled their children grandchildren during covid working with teachers and staff supporting them when schools were closed this all done with no objection from teachers

017principls or other leadership secondly good news clubs have been consistently a part of Orange County schools for grades K through five for many years one club for over 17 years these clubs have vetted volunteers consisting of teachers retired teachers church leaders Orange County Employees parents and even a Orange County Deputy a retired Orange County Deputy safety is of the utmost importance for our clubs we are and have been supported by the principal staff and parents at these schools our weekly meetings consist of song stories and games that promote respect honesty initiative compassion self-discipline patience and love for others along with a mission story Bible Lesson and a snack at the end of each club meeting this type of teaching would cost the county upwards of $20,000 per semester I believe that all would agree we

018need more of this taught in our schools today while all of this we are committed in helping students to be the best that they can be thirdly beginning with the 2425 school year our clubs have not been able uh to continue the school facilities or at the school facil facilities as they have in Prior years due to the new policy implemented by the superintendent the new policy states to use the school facilities our clubs must begin on or after 6: PM up until this school year our start time has been time of dismissal and we have also been prohibited from using Peach jar the school system's suggested way of communication for non-school sponsored clubs and events to reach parents students this policy has has disproportionately prevented and hindered many students from attending and being part

019of our clubs some of these students have been members for many many years lastly a concerned parent as a concerned parent and grandparent and Good News Club leaders I request that the board and Dr Jones reconsider the change this current policy going forward to benefit all involved I would welcome and respectfully request a meeting with the school board or any school board member or Dr Jones to answer any questions or concerns you may have I would also welcome and invite each of you to attend one of our club meetings to gain more information and see what they are all about thank you for your time tonight thank you next speaker is David Godfrey thank you and believe me I'm out of my comfort zone so just bear with me um I was at home last

020night thinking of what I could possibly say that would help get the Good News Club going back again at the end of school day instead of moving it into um 6:00 so I stand here tonight representing no less than four uh Generations that have been involved with Orange County schools first my mom worked for the school system for over 30 years I and my brothers and sisters graduated from Orange my three children all graduated from OS and now I have five grandchildren in the Orange County School school system so yes I am for the Good News Club but it's more than that um and this I got some comments so just be with me don't cut me off um so yes I'm For the Good News Club it's more than that when I was about

021the fourth or fifth grade I couldn't remember my brother coming home saying just seeing if any kids here I don't want to offend anyone so um I was about fourth fifth grade I can remember my brother coming home saying something like they stabbed him they stabbed him and then I was thinking what if what if they had a Good News Club back in the early 70s what if the ones involved had been in a Good News Club back then the out could have the outcome could have been a lot different so that was over 50 years ago but more recently when our daughter was a junior at Orange Senior High someone fired shots at school from the student par parking lot fortunately there were no injuries so again I thought what if what if they

022had a Good News Club back in the early 2000s what if these students had an opportunity to attend because at the Good News Club we teach more than the Bible we teach character traits we teach about bullying and other subjects so now is a great opportunity to say I'm glad we had a news I'm glad we had the Good News Club in our school system instead of saying What If We Had a Good News Club thank you for your time thank [Applause] you next speaker is Brad Williams [Music] board members Dr Jones thank you for this opportunity and I'd like to thank you for your commitment your efforts to provide safety to our children and a good sound education thank you so very much as I stand before you verse of scripture comes to mind

0232 Timothy 1: 7 for God ha not given us the spirit of fear but of power and of love and of a sound mind as I stand before you tonight I have years of public school education my mother retired a public school teacher my great aunt was my fifth grade school teacher she retired public school teacher my dad's two sisters my Aunt Judy and Aunt Diane retired School teach teachers I heard their voices and their voices help me make choices their influence of My Life as a 56 year old man is still etched in my soul and my mind to my right we have 139 years of teaching experience of volunteers that want to invest in the hearts and lives of children our desire is to teach love and respect that all were created equal

024that we were created in the image of God and that we're to love one another and as a community we work together we don't shut each other out we pull together as a community as our state just got hit with a horrible hurricane and our state has come together and citizens have joined hands to help one another and that's what North Carolina CH is about that's what America's about and we appreciate the opportunity to be in the school system and we desire to teach them truth we desire to teach them love and we want to come alongside the teachers as those teachers came alongside my life for all those years and all those years of experience are to provide a future for our CH children that they mo may know Jesus Christ as their savior

025and that they may have peace in their heart and joy and at Christmas time they can understand the real meaning of Christmas and the joys of peace that God has towards all men thank [Applause] you next speaker is Jackie O'Quinn thank you and I appreciate appreciate your time and listening I am not a speaker either so just like Mr Godfrey said bear with me um I'm here in support of the Good News Club in our elementary schools I've lived in Orange County for over 45 years my children my grandchildren all have attended Orange County Public Schools I want the best for my grandchildren I am sure as well as you would I want them to have as many opportunities as they can have to develop into good people people good news clubs offers children the

026ability to learn and grow by building on character lessons teaching them to serve in their communities and to help others the very meaning of Jesus's Ministry was to love forgive and to serve please allow parents and grandparents of Orange County school children to make the vital decisions for their families to allow them to attend good news clubs in our Public Schools how many things today can you say that are truly free The Good News Club is and it gives so much more than what you could ever buy thank you for your time and I respectfully ask that you reconsider the current policy that re was recently established that prevents our club as well well as other community clubs from meeting immediately after school as we have done for the past 17 years I pray for

027you and your families and especially for our precious children thank you for hearing me thank you the next speaker is Craig Carter thank you certain but I like the tie well I'm an Orange County educated kid I've been here all my whole life my father before him my father before him my father before him my father went to high school here so I know a little bit about Orange County education but I'd like to tell you a story about a little boy named David went to school with little David was a kid that kind of got in trouble a lot you know what I mean but we took him to Camp that summer now little David when he pulled his shirt off it looked like somebody shot him in the back with buck shot Little

028David if he brought home a felling grade got a cigarette burnt in his back and that's the way his father done him and I think the new Good News Club could helped someone like that just want somebody to love on a little child other one is a girl her name is Denise she went to Orange County Schools Carl Fox interviewed her father and her in the same room about sexual misbehavior she could have used the Good News Club she needed somebody to love her and I know standards are different now than they were I was young you got to prove something very hard back then but today we don't put up with nobody's abusing one of our children I don't care what religion you are I don't care if you're an atheist you don't abuse

029children and I thank you for your time I thank you for serving and I pray that you do the right decision about clubs and I think all of them are needed not just one all of them thank [Applause] y'all next speaker is Justin Bullock thank you for letting me speak this evening appreciate y'all having us um come to you tonight as a Orange County schools graduate class of 2001 in attendance tonight I have my assistant principal Miss pel which I did not realize hope I was a good kid and I have my first grade teacher my how things have changed also I come to you as a current taxpayer I humbly come to you asking you to reconsider your limits on The Good News Club as I was prepping for the speech tonight the acronym

030te came to mind together everyone achieves more working together makes us stronger and makes us more productive young men and young women without miss pcel and miss Champion's guidance along with the teamwork of my parents working together it's no telling where I'd be today due to current restraints we are unable to reach those less fortunate communities that would otherwise be willing to come I'm sure Sheriff Blackwood and all the Ros at the schools would welcome any help and support any teaching character Concepts and hopefully head off any trouble down the road would be a welcome thing nor you nor I can do this alone we have to work together I've been in health care for over 20 plus years now healthc care is my life I see a lot of things do a lot of

031things when you get a cancer diagnosis one thing you want is a cancer support program that helps you get through the darkest times get through the darkest hours and you have those to support you and around you and that's what we want to offer is the character development and support of those children positive impacts on their lives of the boys and girls I'll close with this in 1993 Jim valeno started the the foundation for cancer research I'm sure we're all aware we watch basketball whether you're State Duke we all believe the same we're all individuals he won an espie that year and in his acceptance speech he su primly said these words cancer may take my life but it cannot take my fight don't give up don't ever give up and that's what we are

032asking for in this meeting is a chance to make a difference to partner with you guys to make a difference in the lives of the young these young boys and girls we will never turn our backs on you the board on you the superintendent on anybody in this room we open we love open dialogue and thank you for your time Jude 22 and some having compassion making a difference I hope you all have a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year thank you next speaker is Millie hanaman good evening thank you um chairman purcel and board and Dr Jones thank you for the chance to speak I'm a mom I'm a PTO member I'm a taxpayer and a voter and I'm a Good News Club leader uh we have been at Central leading the Good

033News Club there since about 2012 and we have found that it's much easier to support Central when we are weekly in the building we're often seen coming in with pizzas for teachers or fruit trays or whatever's needed because it takes a community to take care of our children and we are grateful for your dedication and the time and the effort that you've put into taking care of our children uh my actual physical child is a young adult now and he left Central and we often say we didn't so we went from running science club and when they became a stem school and didn't need science club we started leading Good News Club one of the important things is that as a community member I have been welcomed into Central during the day when students are

034there to Proctor to be on quality assurance team to provide a lunch break for teachers do fi Crips classroom volunteer whatever is needed um a little perplexed that now as a Good News Club leader I'm told that they don't want us in the school at the same time as children that are not in Good News Club we do want to connect the churches and the school so that as part of good news clubs we want to connect churches to be there to support our schools One Church used to come and bring pizza for every PTO meeting free pizza for the whole school and we found that's how you get parents there you feed them we want to be there to support the schools and to support the teachers we often work with teachers when a

035child has a behavioral problem we address that in club we teach the children that they are deeply deeply loved but that also means that everyone they see is deeply loved and deserving of respect and courtesy and so that goes to the whole school we know when a teacher is sick because the children will bring up prayer requests for their teacher and so we find out when something's going on in the school that needs attention or care because the children care about their teachers and they want us to pray for them it's a beautiful thing thank you for the time we have been at Central since 2012 and thank you for letting us have good news club there all these years we ask that you bring us back into the schools right after school so that

036we can support all these children and the staff as well thank you for your time thank you speaker is Connor Williamson good evening thank you for your time I am Connor Williams I'm a resident here in Orange County and also a supporter of the Good News Club and it's no no secret to all of us that our our nation is in a crisis when it comes to the drug epidemic or the the teen suicide rate gang violence in our schools our our children it's no wonder many of them feel like there is no hope and we appreciate all that the Orange County school system does for our children but we believe as parents and as Grandparents of these children that it is our duty our responsibility to come alongside and assist in this never ending

037and over overwhelming job and at the Good News Club we teach these children uh character qualities life lessons that will help them in the future cope with these things uh character qualities such as obedience in the classroom trying to help our teachers and uh loyalty friendship things that they will use the rest of their life we appreciate your time we believe this at the Good News Club if we can give hope to one child then we strengthen that classroom and if we strengthen that classroom we can strengthen our community now I I would ask you to reconsider or consider appealing the policy that was implemented that has made it nearly impossible for us to be in the Good News Club in the after school program and I ask you to do this for one reason

038that we can give hope to one more child thank you for your time good evening next speaker is Kelly subtles hello good evening school board members Dr Jones um parents teachers staff everyone gathered here tonight um I would like to speak tonight about the consequences of the parents Bill of Rights um this was passed about a year and a half ago by the state legislature uh one in four girls and one in 20 boys are sexually abused as children in the United States and 90% of these children know their abuser I know this is uh difficult to hear um but one of the best ways to prevent child sexual abuse is to provide evidence informed prevention education Orange County Schools have been providing excellent instruction through the safe touch program each year materials have been

039sent home and I found them to be informative and entirely age appropriate for my elementary school children this year I was surprised when parents were asked to opt in to the program that had been provided to everyone in the past parents in the audience will understand that we get a lot of email from our teachers administrators and the district and it's hard to keep up with sometimes so it's no surprise that far fewer children received this prevention program this year so that had me asking why this change was made I inquired and I learned that the school district had to make the program an opt in program rather than opt out as it was in the past because of the parents Bill of Rights you may recall that any discussion of sexuality has been banned

040for children younger than fifth grade so in their efforts to create a solution to a problem that did not exist the North Carolina legislature has made our children more vulnerable to sexual abuse I sent a version of this statement to Greg Meyer and re Renee price our Orange County Representatives as well as senator senors Amy gayy Lisa Barnes and Michael Lee who were the primary sponsors of the bill I hope that many of you here will be moved to let the legislature know what a grave mistake they made thank you thank you next speaker is Vicki Hill good evening thank you everyone board superintendent Jones parents in the audience and members of the community um you are in a role to help secure the future of democracy by helping prepare young people to be educated

041engaged voters uh voter education is one of my key interest I observe the Board of Elections meetings and report on them and I'm a Community member that is engaged with extensive voter education efforts in Hillsboro proper uh outside of the schools Orange County is noted for its efforts in voter education and registration at both ends of the County uh it may not be apparent but the it's it's it is when you look at the voter registration uh results the first thing I want to do is give you a pop quiz and I don't want you to raise your hand or anything just write write it down on something um because this is just to raise awareness uh what is the correct answer to one of these three questions uh a young person can pre-register to

042vote at 16 they can register to vote at 17 or they can register to vote when they're 18 in North Carolina 16 17 or 18 in North Carolina okay it's pre-registered to vote at 16 North Carolina is one of 50 states that allows 16y olds to pre-register to vote what that does it it gets them in the in the voter pool so that they will automatically get a reminder when they turn 17 and when they're 18 on general election they can vote when they're 177 if they turn 18 at the general election they can vote in the primary that year at 17 now what election do we have at the primary so one of the things that has had that happens as we do voter registration and education is we find out people aren't familiar

043with the election law like needing to know our social security number some of the voters who were involved with with this 60,000 voter recount are there because they didn't provide their social security number which was part of a law that came through in 23 there were five voters young voters who showed up this year and they thought they were they had registered but they hadn't so there's a lot of voter education that needs to be done and these groups that do it countywide are there to help people answer questions to themselves that they're they're they got a plan to vote and everything's crossed some of us in the community have longed to learn of voter registration efforts in the high school now we know that the Division of Motor Vehicles is an option so is

044the Department of Social Services and they both automatically asked the question do you want to register to vote but just think when did you learn your Social Security number so those youth who go to get their driver's license they also have to provide their social security number this is something when they get the voter application that they're going to need to fill out so if they go to the principal's office to get a voter registration form they're not going to know that they need their social social security number M 60 this year in in November 67% of the students in Orange County School District voted Miss Hill I'm sorry to interrupt I don't know if you're aware time what yeah time is out oh thank you I'm sorry okay thank you thank you thank you

045the next speaker will be Anita Thompson good evening to board members Dr Jones to everyone here it's a blessing just to be standing in the building on such a time as this and as I come as a resident of Orange County for it seemed like a hundred years but it's only been 77 I have seen it all I've been able to be a witness for many of the things that have transpired but I come here mainly just to speak about something that's dear to my heart and that's the Good News Club I speak about it because there are so many benefits I think that we may be missing about concerning our children the need for them to be in be there at the school I'm not going to preach to you but I will deliver

046to you what's in my heart Proverbs 226 says train up a child in the way he should go and when he is old he will not depart from it we at War right now as a society as people who are called by God we have warn not with guns and bullets not with handcuffs tied behind us or having us chained down but we in war because we are fighting um the survival of a a great commodity in this land that commodity truly are our children they're important to me I love them dearly I have been a member of The Good News Club since 2013 in the beginning when I walked in and saw that the first thing all of them needed was nothing but love and sometime love is not easily obtained at home so

047there's something in our heart that says we must be able to give back to them what I believe God or someone has given to us we have War waging Wars in many directions against drugs against all type of vices and evil that possess this land I believe our children must hear what's good because the morality is missing and even if it's missing in a home it must be shown in the school we have a great school district one of the best I went to Orange County Schools all of my children went and now my grandson attends school and he loves it every day when we leave home we pray everyone is not given that opportunity to have someone pray I don't pray for him he prays with me and says what is on his mind

048I know that comes from taking the time to making him fully aware that he has a great life to live and making sure that every person he touch every person he meets every teacher that he's engaged with is one that he feels a love boundary with one of the things that I find is very hard for me to deal with as a grandmother and as a parent is the fact that there are so many children so many babies that are in school and they have been taken care of they've been governed by their grandparents Grand parents don't have their opportunity I'm a grandparent y'all 770 years old I can't Solly see at night so at 6:00 it's a journey sometime trying to get from one destination to the other so when I pick him up

049at 2:30 I try to make sure that I'm back home at least by 5:30 there are so many parents and grandparents that are working and they cannot afford the transportation of children moving from one location at 2:30 from school to another location and then finding someone to return them to back to school at 6 or even to another location mainly because it's expensive and it's something that's called Humanity within us that we must be willing to share and give back I know that's not your problem but guess what our children are our concerns and whatever you can provide for them and love and transportation and whatever you see I beg of you I guarantee if you give for them you will see a greater blessing coming back to you thank you for this brief moment

050to speak I praise God for you and for everything that you're doing in respect of our children thank you the next speaker is Carrie Hamill good evening my name is Carrie Hamill and I am here with concerns about educational inadequate programs services and supports reaching children with disabilities here in the school district I'm proud to be here on National um special education day but it's really the other 364 days that I'm here to ask you to provide many many more resources it gives me great concern that there are six schools listed on the 2223 additional targeted support needed for students with disabilities that includes three of the middle schools and three of the elementary schools I'm I have some specific requests that I would ask this court this um uh board to implement one is

051that this board board engage in public monitoring at meetings of the school Improvement plans for all of the schools that are supposed to be educating these children and that happened on a rotating basis monthly second that this board rapidly choose to ask for restraint and seclusion data as well as contact with students that does not qualify as being appropriate restraint and seclusion for children with disabilities three I ask that at every work work session for every subject moving forward that there be included public comment I might be a little rash tonight what if you take a moment and look at the public facing materials on the EC program update tonight it totals seven slides three of them two of them are cover pages the cover and the back logo and one is do you have

052questions that's only four slides of information I hope tonight will include information of what it takes to qualify to be an at targeted school and what sort of outcomes are happening for those children I must also end on a hopeful note we are incredibly Lucky in this school district to have a superintendent who is a math teacher I'm not ready yet to ask her to be teach teaching math but it could be coming we have in leadership a very successful um uh a very recent successful principal who is joining the excellent other principls and teachers and staff in this school district and I also got to see I didn't know she was the EC director but I got to see her at work tonight we're lucky here I'm hopeful thank you and our final speaker

053for tonight is Allison mahy good evening board I would like to start by thanking you from the bottom of my heart for changing your um school facilities use policy and keeping um good news clubs from meeting directly after school I came before this board in 2015 to warn you about the Good News Club and their agenda they part of a vast Network um that is affiliated with the children child's Evangelical program and they're part of a vast Network that is working to bring Christian nationalism to the United States what I wanted to speak to you about tonight was about hb10 and I think that this is relevant I was planning to only speak about the part of hb10 that has to do with ice detainers and what that will do to our students in our

054Public Schools um where there are uh Sheriff's officers in every one of our schools but given all of this talk about the Good News Club I think it's important for us to talk about the other part of hb10 which is the voucher part of that and how many millions of dollars are now going to go toward religious schools that are unaccountable to me as a taxpayer those are my taxpayer dollars that are going to go to religious schools to indoctrinate children in Christian in Christian beliefs and that system of religion um which is fine parents can have that option of sending their children to Christian schools and now the law is that they can use vouchers to do that but I don't believe that our Public Schools should participate in that kind of indoctrination and

055that kind of Evangelical um perspective that they train these children to have um in the good News Club so thank you for that change in policy um I hope you will look into it further I gifted the entire School Board um the book by investigative reporter Katherine Stewart called The Good News Club um back in 2014 so those might be laying around where you are or I'm happy to give you a new copy of it regarding um the other part of hb10 um I just have a few things a few questions that I would like to leave you with one how are you considering the implications of these new realities of um the promise of mass deportation and of the ice retainers um that are coming with hb10 um how are you considering those implications

056for our students before you renew theou with the Orange County Sheriff's office will you consider the risk versus benefits in every single scho uh that have law enforcement officers in every single School every single day and before you renew theou will you take the time to hear from your constituents about our concerns about having officers in schools and what we want you to do not only to protect our children um but to provide them with a small amount of peace of mind that their schools won't participate in targeting them thank [Applause] you and that includes our public comment session okay thank you to everyone that's here tonight um next we have board comments um Miss Padia do you have any comments oh I get to go first I'm going to let you go you start

057over there I'm going to let you go first okay well thank you uh good evening everyone thank you for being here and all your comments uh we've had a busy month I participated on the Veterans Day celebration at OC Veterans Memorial I went to the um Family Academy and learned um supported how I really enjoyed how parents learn how they can support their children and what their rights are with the um 504s and the IEPs I attend at the um Cedar Ridge Voyager uh Planet children planet Earth that was amazing that it was all put by the students I was a little surprised that I went first so I wasn't quite ready even though I did my notes um I also attended the reality of money at Al standback where children at that school got

058to uh learn how money works and how parents um it's basically financial literacy which I think it's very interesting and um we need to have more of that um in our school so children can learn because not not all parents are able to teach their children about financial litery literacy um I attended the uh the fall um lot conference webinar um and also I participated on the parade I want to do a shout out to all the people that worked um H for to get us all out there it was beautiful the bus and we had our own Santa which was was phenomenal and we had a cool bus um let's see I also participated on the Village Circle with representative price and uh commissioner Earl mck um if anybody wants to know about how

059you can help in your community in learning about what funds are out there to help families to have more funds for power or other needs you can email me and lastly I want to say that it is unfortunate what is happening at 16 West Jones Street with the voucher and the HB Pro hb10 as a member of the community I just want to say that this time this holiday season we should all come together and embrace the entire community and accept everyone for who we are and support each other what I have as a gift for you you this holiday season and always is compassion hope and that is my gift to you love always every year and I hope that is instilled in you this holiday season and every when someone in our community

060hurts we all hurt so just think about that and have a great holiday thank you m um I'll uh keep it pretty brief the parade was excellent um and thank you uh to Mr Albert and to um I think Miss Morris was the one who did a lot of the other planning so um very well planned like people were clearly like very excited to see the little o OCS uh contingent as well as all the individual schools I love seeing more of them participating so fabulous next year we'll just have more candy because I ran out before the end of the parade um okay a couple of other things um uh it's been like a whole month so um uh in November I had a great visit to Orange High School I want to thank

061Mr Johnson for taking me around and showing me some different uh classrooms um I got two um one that was exciting was um a a sort of a setup that they're doing with um I believe the ESL teacher and the science classrooms where they're doing some like alternating for the um English language Learners um to try to integrate those and and help students be able to access more of the science language that was really cool um uh went to the Schoolboard Association conference as well um and um also went to the climate I'm our representative on the climate Council which really only meets twice a year but just wanted to share a couple of updates there we talked about uh some of the um successes and obstacles uh so far in terms of tackling climate

062change in Orange County and some of the successes that came up were um some of the school solar projects um the electric buses that we will be getting at some point to be determined um and then the school bond is like an just a general opportunity for that um and then one of the other topics was also just talking about um how we're engaging youth in climate action across the district so we talked about some of the things that are happening now what are some of the obstacles to engaging youth in participating in more different ways and where were some of our opportunities so hopefully there will be more to come from that um you know each of the towns that participate in the county all have their own sort of like climate action plans

063where they're trying to um make various changes and so they named it a number of opportunities for kids but uh um it seems to me that there's even more opportunity there so hopefully more to come okay Miss doll um thank you for everyone who was here tonight and shared their comments um there's been so much going on in the past month and there are some school things I haven't been able to get to so I was happy about the ones I was able to get to I enjoyed a a Fall Festival at um orange Middle School um and fifth grade M musical at Pathways Elementary um I also was glad that the the Voyager show came back to Cedar Ridge because I was able to see it the second time around um and Shout out

064for their success um as well as IB night um at Cedar Ridge High School um this past week and a really um neat math night at Hillsboro Elementary where they had a whole network of um high school students participating in and running um running activ in different rooms so we just really excited about all the ways our individual schools reach out to the community um and I know that takes a lot of effort um and it means you know staff staying late and putting all this extra effort into that um type of event so I'm just really thankful for all the uh community building that's happening at our schools thank you Mr Anon thank you uh thanks everyone for coming out to speak we really appreciate you sharing your thoughts and concerns um so as

065Minnie mentioned uh few concerts the coral concerts it's always wonderful to hear our students and see how much progress they make and you know engaging our community the IB night uh wonderful to hear the success of our students see their projects understand how we're doing critical thinking preparing them for college or whichever program they would like uh also attended the the uh family Academy on the EC rights thank you Miss Burns for doing that uh multiple School visits I'm not going to list them all but uh one of the things that I did really appreciate seeing is when I went to the middle school during the Avid programs they were all teaching students how to write proper letters and their topic was on thanking a teacher and ensuring they understood how you write a letter

066how you get your point across and ensuring there thoughts were captured on their letter so really appreciated seeing that the other thing I'd mention is I did get a chance to talk to many of the cafeteria workers that are implementing uh new menus uh at least one school um was graly Hill that was spotlighting students that were M making recommendations for AAL and they would highlight that student and it's wonderful to see the students participating in that as well uh very appropriate uh for uh special education day uh attended the Adaptive playground opening uh out at Al standback it's a wonderful Edition uh took a little bit of time to get but really appreciate it it's available and looking forward for us engaging in more of those um the uh School boards uh annual conference

067I think one of the really good sessions that many of us attended was the design build and definitely looking forward to having more discussions around that and you know something what that would look like here um also attended the parade and as many said it was so wonderful seeing the the teachers the staff the students celebrating Orange County schools and our community engagement um and you know I did learn that Santa Drives a bus and uh we are always looking for bus drivers so if you know someone that's interested please uh contact us because we'd love to have them as part of the Orange County Schools family thank you Miss Hower yeah thank you I'll keep this short um and I just wanted to start with a big thank you to the Orange County voters

068who overwhelmingly supported the school bond uh you open the door to an unprecedented investment in our school facilities we know it was a big leap of faith because our facilities plans are still being finalized and please know that we will honor the trust you have placed in us and whether you voted for the bond or not uh we ask that you and please engage in the planning conversations that are be upcoming over the next months so um thank you for that that is a huge deal for us uh second I did want to um thank the community um by welcoming The District in the holiday parade last night it was the first time that I recall that the district actually had its own um entry in the parade um and uh from what I can

069tell that people were really happy to see us um special thanks to Mariah moris and Amber Wilson for organizing and J.R Santa I mean J.R Albert for driving the bus I'm convinced that Santa's naughty and nicel less is coming from school buses now um and just you know there's a lot of things I could talk about but I just want to send my this is our last meeting before the holidays so just my wishes to our students and families our teachers staff and our community and our board for a wonderful holiday season thank you Mr Richmond yeah mine will be even shorter I just want to say happy holidays to all our Orange County Citizens all of our Orange County Schools um staff and all of of our families and children well I've done um

070visited several schools and done several things that have already been mentioned up here tonight but I have to say that the most impressive and the most fun that I had visiting was when we opened the Adaptive playground at Al standback last weekend or last Monday for our students uh with disabilities um it was absolute amazing to watch the smiles on those faces and see them on the equipment that they had been watching being put in place and building for several years it seems like but um they were a happy group of kids a happy group of teachers and I just want to thank everybody with our operations and maintenance department that helped get that done um the teachers Miss Burns was there she was already she and um Miss Banks were already going through lesson

071plans that could be developed around all of the equipment that is out there to help our students and motivate them and just just seeing the smiles and the happiness that that one playground provided was absolutely amazing for this former educator to see so um thank you to every everyone who has done that I too will Echo what everyone else has said that we hope everyone has a nice holiday season uh that you get some rest that you spend time with those children and grandchildren that you have in Orange County schools and uh just enjoy being together and families together and the things around the community that you can do and um so have a wonderful holiday season and a very safeid holiday season Dr Jones do you have any comments to add yes ma'am I

072do good evening chair pcel Vice Cher Richmond members of the board students um staff community members um when I first arrived in February I started out on a listening and learning tour that included visiting every school um having meaningful conversations with teachers and staff and learning how we support our students on a daily basis while I haven't really reported out you know listing out schools that I visit just wanted to make sure everyone is aware that that type of Engagement continues um I continue to be impressed also by the feedback that I receive from teachers whether I'm talking with them oneon-one or we meet in our um monthly teacher of the year round table um we talk about the types of support that are meaningful to our teachers the professional development they need to be

073their best selves um as a district our goal is to Foster um an environment where instructional practices are continuously strengthened uh to be on this cycle of continuous Improvement we must Embrace a culture of collaboration feedback and Innovation we must also recognize that the progress we see is often incremental and so understanding that each step brings us a step forward toward the goal that we're trying to achieve as we're working together um as we push forward this work um we have to remember that this this is hard work um and when it's done properly it takes time patience and teamwork I'm thankful for the members of my team The District staff that support schools every day and School staff that are working to make this Vision a reality I'm thankful to have a supportive board

074I'm thankful for all of our community members that support our schools and I wish everyone a happy holiday season thank you thank you okay uh we are down to our consent agenda we have a motion to approve with the one change that we have already made to move our school assignment and transfers to uh discussion so moved second all in favor I I okay we will now move into that discussion item work session with um our policy 41 150 School assignment and transfers Mr coek I think is our speaker here good evening everyone thank you we we had a few last minute changes to um policy 4150 which uh Mr mun is passing out to you all now you'll notice there's just just I've only we've only given you the three pages that are impacted

075which is page six page seven and page 10 um the reason it was pulled is because we needed to um make sure that the policy was legally compliant in one aspect so if you look at the bottom of page six which is the front page um of the three pages that you have in section two you'll see an underlined section there all right um where it says that we need to change the sentence um to say that hearings will be before an impartial hearing officer or board panel as determined by the parent or guardian and it replaces the statement uh selected by the superintendent or design we needed uh that correction to make it compliant with North Carolina statutes so we wanted to bring your attention to that the second um change is on the

076next page the middle page of your three-page packet this is Page seven in section D2 you'll see that we just had to add a verb to the sentence there about the transfers so there's no real substi substit substantive change there we go um but we just needed to say that transfers are available in those situations in addition a correction a couple of cleanup items uh the version that was listed had footnotes there the footnotes will need to be deleted as they are from all policies that was just U an oversight on administration's part and finally to we are also um deleting the cross references because as we're working through these policies some of these policies are there and some are not so um this is not inconsistent with prior practice regarding cross references um and

077so we hope uh we'll certainly be happy to entertain any questions about these uh minor changes um as this is in concert with 4120 as well um to uh for the waiver of second read which um is before the board okay Miss um SMY um thank you yes so I just want to understand this change a little bit more is there a definition of what a hearing officer is in this policy or somewhere else so in the statute it just says an impartial hearing officer um which can be designated and it's a choice um or it can be to a board panel okay and so the as determined by a parent or Guardian they're not selecting members of a panel they are making the decision about whether to have a single hearing officer or a

078board panel correct um and they're not defining what hearing officer is correct we we would Define that yes okay I because that's not clear I guess I'm wondering if we should make that a little bit clearer um hearings will be before an impartial hearing officer or board panel period um the parent or Guardian is the individual who make the I mean I don't know something something like that like saying that those are the two things and that that choice between those two things would be made by the parent or Guardian yeah that they could choose one of those options something that specifically says it's the option not picking the board members or the hearing officer itself yeah that as determined by just it it makes it a little if it helps to on that point

079the language in the statute is if both are designated an applicant or parent Guardian uh must select the entity to hold the hearing so if you wanted to split it in two sentences you could say something like um if well I guess you are saying that a hearing officer and board panel would be both be options um so you could say uh the parent or parent/guardian um if I guess would just say the parent/guardian uh will select whether the hearing will be held before a hearing officer or board panel it's a bit wordy but perhaps clear can I add I appreciate the comments and I'm fine with the suggestion I just am curious where it says selected by the superintendent or designate does that need to stay for who selects the hearing officer if that

080option is picked or is that not what that little Clause there does that refer to hearing officer selection and if so does that need to just stay but move closer to it oh yeah I not I think the selected by the superintendent is language that that staff had added originally and so the main purpose of this revision is to is to be clear that we're not talking about an administrative panel of Staff it would be either a panel of two or more board members or hearing officer you currently have a hearing officer and you can continue using the hearing officer okay this this under this change would give you the option of instead having board panel um and the parent would be the parent or Guardian would choose whether to have the board panel hearing

081or the hearing officer okay any other question sorry I have a simpler way um uh the superintendent or design will notify the applicant of the time place in date in place um the parent the parent or Guardian will determine whether they're hearing whe you know will choose whether to have a hearing in front of an impartial hearing officer or board panel y or something like that yep okay sounds good any anyone else question Mr Aon I just want to thank the staff and everyone that's helped with this uh the the policy committee did spend a significant amount of time as you miss beia know is talking through these on trying to simplify this make it easier for our district so thank you all for all your work done on these thank you very much we

082need a motion to to approve need a motion to approve and if I and if I may I'll just read back the language that Miss Smiley I think helpfully suggested there I think that's a good uh fix the the tweak on that one sentence we were talking about would be the parent or Guardian will choose whether the hearing will be before an impartial hearing officer or board panel motion to approve with the proposed language change um friendly request for the motion to be waving of second reading as well okay we have a motion we a motion before us to accept the changes as stated by Mr um Remy and then to W wave a second reading on this policy second all in favor I I I okay thank you all very much and uh thank

083you Mr coek and Mr Remy for your help with that okay we are down to our school spot reassignment good evening Miss Tolan how are you good evening good evening board members chair purcel and Oh I thought you could hear me my loud voice good evening board members chair purcel and superintendent Jones this evening we're asking you to revisit two approvals the board made in the summer of 2022 in regards to school spot reassignment first we are confirming there is no spot reassignment recommendation for the 25 26 school year in June and also in August of 2022 the board approved spot reassignments of new students in the havenstone neighborhood to attend cedaridge high school school and Central Elementary students that were currently attending Orange High School and effin CHS Elementary were allowed to continue attending

084those schools with transportation services through June of 20123 bus service was indicated to end for the 2324 school year but because of internal communication failures it did not end we have added the bus service for Central Elementary but we continue to provide transportation to effin cheeks and orange high school and we currently have no students riding the bus from the havenstone neighborhood to Central Elementary I'm sorry to Cedar Ridge High School but it would be available if requested tonight the administration is asking the board to reaffirm its previous decisions and proposes to discontinue transportation services for students to effin cheeks and Orange High School from the havenstone neighborhood beginning with the 2526 school year we will send certified notifications to those families and also follow up again in March to make sure that they're aware

085of the bus service discontinuation thank you for considering this request and at this time I turn it over to you for discussion and or action question so just some clarity are you requesting we do this because it was a prior action of the board or is this a request because we should do it because I think originally this was done because there were capacity issues at Orange and Cedar Ridge had the jwing open and there was a lot more capacity there and so I I guess what I'm trying to figure out is does it make more sense for transportation to go to orange instead of all the way to Cedar Ridge because there's no capacity issue now or yall are just trying to fulfill an original board item I'm just trying to understand what what's

086bringing this about the primary is bus efficiency and that we're transporting students we're continuing to transport students to upin cheeks Elementary in addition to Central Elementary and because of the time lapse between when it was supposed to be implemented and our determination to increase bus efficiency uh we wanted to bring it to your attention and have you reaffirm let me ask differently okay I'm with you all the way I'm with you confused so it seems like Cedar Ridge is much more inefficient from that neighborhood than it would be orange High I guess is my question I don't I don't know that I mean y'all are managing the bus routes so I I know that at the time the board did it because of capacity reasons not because that's what we felt and that's what the

087recommendation was and I I I definitely you know want to hear the recommendation but I don't want I guess I'll just say I I don't feel like this H the Cedar Ridge the students and families on this neighborhood have to go to Cedar Ridge unless yall are telling me that that is the most efficient route for them that's I guess what I'm trying to understand go ahead can I just just to add to that we're wondering if you looked at the reverse in fact discontinuing the districting to Central and Cedar Ridge for no other reason than it's a much longer bus ride but even on the redistricting map it always was a little strange to see those spots going to schools out of the district so did we consider keep keeping those kids in their

088originally districted schools tonight we were bringing this to you as an inefficiency uh in action That was supposed to take place that did not um as the board you have um we will throw it back to you to what your wishes are if you choose to um discontinue that it it is a spot redistrict right so it is a spot within a larger area that has been districted to another area um I I I guess my question still is is it less efficient to go to Cedar rge than orange can I so Curr all of them but that's that's the first one listed that's I'm just trying to keep it to asking the first but anyway miss m yeah I just wanted to add that I mapped it for the high schools um and it's

089like a two-minute difference because you can get on board I think it's what oh no you don't get on well I don't know but it's it's a two-minute difference for the high school so it's like 15 minutes to Orange High School and 17 minutes to Cedar Ridge let me clarify my question if there are currently no buses going to Cedar Ridge but the buses are going to Orange yeah does this make sense if you've got a bus in that area that can pick up that neighborhood and come back that's that's why I'm asking not necessarily just the time but the limited number of buses that would have to travel over to this area because originally when we looked at the map there wasn't any buses right and it's like a spot reassignment so if Orange

090High School now has space for students if if none of the students are actually going to Cedar brige and they actually are just going to Orange High School and if there's capacity to Orange High School and I think that's a worthwhile question I was just saying I think like literally the efficiency of which school can you get to faster it's like not really like a wash mine was really bus not time yeah on Central I think central versus F1 cheeks it will make a difference so so there are currently students in the neighborhood who are going to Cedar Ridge but are not using Transportation there are only two students who are going to Orange High School and those are uh upper grad so that some they're currently seniors so they won't be after this year

091impacting the the bus going to Orange so if you did not if you want to what we're asking you to do is to stop do lication of bus services in that area I think I think we we we understand that we're only asking should we be stopping the the bus service should we go back to the original districting rather than continue the spot districting and and go back to and just put the the neighborhood back in the orange high school and the F1 cheeks District so uh we will uh this spring be talking about redistricting um or any options that we have for registering you could choose to push it that decision to them but then it wouldn't be effective until the 26 27 school year uh if you want to make a change for

092the 25 26 school year we would need to go ahead and make that determination soon so that we would give them because we I think by policy it has to be January 1 they need to know if there's any changes so if you're talking about moving students from who who were now currently assigned to Cedar Ridge and Central and allowing them to return to effn cheeks and orange they would need to know about January 1 so but you're saying that the two students that this affects at Cedar Ridge are senior or an orange or seniors at Orange at Orange so those students who were allowed to continue um um so Middle School's not impacted it was just a high school and there are two high school students who are riding the bus who will no

093longer need that service after this year which we would would which would follow polic Mo the point right yeah um and then there are 10 students who are riding the bus uh currently to effin cheeks and so that would end in 25 okay and would this would the students that are going to F1 cheeks be able to remain at F1 cheeks so they remain at the school they just would lose services and we'd be providing services to Central correct and how many students are using those 15 I believe it's uh at least 15 okay so that's really split okay can I yes Miss M I mean I'll just say I approved this recommendation I do think like looking at that spot redistricting as we are looking at all of the redistricting makes sense to me

094but um given what you've explained I support this recommendation and and I'll just note that it's you know we would be making this shift of uh transitioning away from transportation to effin cheeks like three years after we were initially supposed to so I mean you know it's a lot of lot of lead time okay I moved to approve the recommendation if if I'm not interrupting you no ma'am let go right ahead you approved um one one just one Clarity so we will revisit this with more data on what makes sense because essentially we're not tonight shutting anybody's Services down is that correct okay for for for the rest of the year all right and uh we will bring you that data as part of the holistic picture I hear that that you're requesting that so

095so just for next year will anybody be losing transportation services well the the effin cheek students will be losing transportation services that troubles me that troubles me I mean I'll just say I mean maybe kids can Caro I mean I don't I don't know like there might there might be some like it it is a real um loss for a family to not be able to continue that um it is also true that as a district like the state uh measures our efficiency of our transportation and our funding varies depending on that and so I think the attention to efficiency across the system is really important um as well so you know this is something we committed to several years ago and um I support following through with it at this point okay we have

096on the floor a motion to approve this change as so stated in explained do we have a second for this I mean a um do what second car a second Carrie made the motion to to do it okay so I'll second it okay do we have a second we have a second all in favor I I okay oppos oh okay opposed one opposal and so the motion passed thank you thank you okay um we have a a letter that has been written to our uh legislative uh representatives and to Senator Greg Meyer and congresswoman Valerie M fori um that explains the fact that inflation has um steadily impacted our teachers and um in fact the whole state of North Carolina over the past few years and um the general assembly last year did not make

097any modifications to the provisions of the education budget that was passed in the 2023 banian budget um the outcome of this decision means that most teachers across our state will have a reduction in their pay when account accounting for inflation and so we have stated on behalf of the Orange County Board of Education we implore you to pass a modified education budget with a Le at least a 5% across the board pay increase for certified non-certified staff um and they have received this request from other boards of Education as well and Orange County is is being a part of what uh we are they we all are requesting so so um this has a spot for every board member to sign and we will send it a copy of each to those four people that

098or five people that I um uh um four people that I talked about and um hopefully it will have an impact for our teachers in Orange County um so do I have a motion that we pass action on this and do I have a second second all right all in favor I I so we will be signing this and getting copies to all of our um elected officials and on behalf of our teachers so thank you all for for doing this and Mr mccon we will sign this after the meeting and give it to you okay all right we now move into our work session with our 2024 safe routes to school plan from our Orange County Schools transportation department thank you very much Dr Jones thank you very much Board of Education board thank

099you very much your school staff and administration for this opportunity to present to you the Orange County safe School plan I'm going to give you a brief background on the plan U go over the scope of work that was approved by this your superintendent Dr Mero at that time and reinforced by Dr Jones give you a quick update on the analysis that was done give you um information about the public engagement process that we went through to the process going to focus on some of the recommendations I'm not going to get into the weeds of all the schools and everything like that but then give you an update on what the conclusion of the process was the original um War County sa School plan started back in 2014 this school plan only adopted three areas

100of the schools Orange High Cedar Ridge and one more area I think was now Central Park Elementary so those three areas were done back in 2014 those schools were done for the sa School plan and we decided to update that because it's been 10 years and this plan has never been updated before this new 2024 safe School plan was a little bit more ambitious we ended up addressing all 13 orang count Public Schools this time um because it was such a heavy lift we decided to get the help of um Consulting fir wsp to help us with the analysis and recommendation part of the process before doing all that we decid put together a scope of work that involved what would be the process what would be the work that was done what would be

101the engagement piece how would what would be the final deliverable and present this to your Dr M at the time Dr Jones and getting your feedback and also the orang outboard recommendation The Advisory Board to say what is the best process and this was going to be a year-long process starting back in January and concluding now when before we came the first before we did the public engagement we decided to do a actual investigation of each of the schools and really appreciate your staff for giving us the input on all the schools and when is the best time for the field to be out there on the field and please uh before I go further the correction is the focus was on around the around the two M radius around the schools not the school

102property itself but the effect and the impact that's been having around the school the two M radius around it so our wsp consultant went to each of the schools during the peak hour morning pickup morning drop off and afternoon pickup to see how was The Pedestrian biking traffic and the vehicle of traffic and what was the issues going on in each of the 13 schools and there's a in in the document you'll see an existing condition analysis and a table for each of the schools over the since Co over the past 10 years traffic and associated with these schools has gotten a lot worse the traffic is now on major state roads us70 n Orange Grove Road NC 86 so the traffic is now in major roow as it's causing safety issues and concerns for

103people that are walking and biking to the schools especially with areas that have no biking walking access and as you can see in some of these pictures people crossing passing cars or people parked on the side of the road in some of these areas while kids and parents are walking and biking around these are areas you know we also decided to do a public engagement part of this process was a stakeholder meeting back in March when we started this process there was some engagement done to that through a survey but we really appreciate all your school and your school staff when the school was over the first when academic year was over during the summer July we decided to do a big public meeting and got all your teachers your principles and vice principles intercept

104together into one virtual meeting to talk about the engagement the results that came out the existing conditions report and some of the recommendations and it was really informative information and learning that some of the areas that people were walking how dangerous it was and some areas where kids are not and it's okay and issues that were associated with it because we know this area is going to grow this more and more people are going to becoming more and more demand is going to be placed on schools as well as the trans Transportation Network so you will also find in your document key recommendations that came out of the the problems and issues that wred identified and what were some of the recommendations to address some of those growing issues and there's two sets of recommendations

105one is the infrastructure piece the recommended bike Lanes sidewalks Greenways and some of the administrative stuff that we can do with do and other agencies like school zones R reducing speeds crosswalks midw walks and addressing some of the traffic issues around it there's also another component of that for engaging in strategies to keep this a living document to keep more people engaged through doing different incentive programs like promoting the use of school buses um UC doing education safety programs bike walk incentives and walking school buses a walking school bus is a group of students walking together with the parents or teacher and and that walk itself is the bus here's an example of some of the recommendations that came out of it this is the AL standback area and and if you look a little

106further south of this area is the New Hope Elementary School so there's two schools on one major road and as you can see this is nc8 six that connects hillsb to Chapel Hill so a lot of trafficking issues and a lot of recommendations came out on how to address some of that as that area grows and develops what to do in ensuring that kids and parents and people can walk and bike safely to these schools this is a living document as I mentioned earlier there's lots of ways of funding and programming and implementing this plan that's going to be going forward um using federal funds to say how safety Improvement programs cation block grants safe R of school Safe Streets for all and other programs including the bond that was passed is using School District

107fonds to help promote some of the stuff as well as working with do and other agencies to do spot administrative improvements like I mentioned earlier intersection improvements crosswalks and things like that that we can work administra with do this is a living document the this plan was updated 10 years from the original plan hopefully this year going forward going after this adoption to update a little bit more frequently like every four years or every 5 years to be updated to keep it more monitoring and living as we go through it is incorporated into the new transition multi Modo plan that shows where all the D Road improvements are going to be done to incorporate into those recommendations and projects as we get more State funding in the future um creating a safe R School Champion

108um establishing steering committee for this program to keep some of these improvements going and continue to do public engagement finding ways and more ways to do funding and evaluating this program every few years as we continue updating it so we're not having to wait another 10 years to update just a little bit more up to date current over the past uh few months there's been a lot of action that's been taken done through this since we're at the end of the conclusion of the process in September our unified Transportation board recommended some of the improvements to this document like encouraging each of the in putting emphasis and narrative into this document to encourage schools to work with state DOT to do a Municipal Traffic Municipal School transportation assistance program to do study you probably seen

109some of the school sa uh schools on being expanded on Orange Grove Road that's one of the results that came out of a previous study that was done um that every recommendation this is a high priority some of them were originally low and medium but anything that came out of it they recommend that all of them be considered high important priorities this has this document has been import endorsed by the regional agencies like Central Pine Regional planning organizations the two Metropolitan plan I said Orange County is part of Orange County Board of County Commissioners has also adopted this past month Boro I think is adopting it right now tonight at the same meeting we're having this and looking for your support and this is the previous slide so I'm happy to answer any questions concerns

110you may have on this document and hopefully getting your support in the future again thank you Dr Jones for helping this opportunity thank you your staff and administration to doing this work and really appreciate the board and for helping get this thing done in coordination together miss m yes um thank you and it it is great to have this level of detail documentation about all of the challenges and some ranking of priority among them and I can see how helpful it would be for the principles too so um that's fabulous um a couple of questions I had about it um and maybe this maybe this comes next I'm not sure but I guess I was hoping for like an overall prioritization of projects so for example like um for um C Ridge and River Park

111there are both re like high level recommendations to add sidewalks along certain routes um and one of them is the bridge over 40 for the high school where I am very concerned someone is going to get hit someone has gotten hit um someone has gotten hit um and the other one is like side streets in the neighborhood around River Park that like uh definitely cars are going by but the speed limits 20 or 25 miles an hour or whatever so it's it's just a whole different level and but they're both kind of rated high for that school and so do we have sort of like a prioritized list of the prioritized list um and and if not like how do we get there yes when because this is a transportation project a transportation plan we

112incorporated all the recommendations and all the the infrastructure improvements into it the call what is called the transportation multimodal plan that we wsp was also the consa that helped us do this and they created a unique partiz process this partiz process we have like bike ped projects 54 Highway projects like 807 Transit projects so we lump them all together and create a unique paration how to organize them what are more important than others how which ones can we pursue and which ones can't through that unique priorization process and one of the priorization elements that determined how how they were scored and how to make it priy is access to schools was become it was like a 22% of a score of if you can get access to schools within a mile quter mile of a

113school it would rank its priority or access to residential neighborhoods and Community things like that so not to go into detail about that privitization process but that pration process was very unique It produced a great result of taking all of these projects as well as those and organizing that whole 400 and some project list into which one's priy more important than the others and the unique thing that came out of it was Orange Grove Road was ranked number one good I think like and we had some projects removed and rescored and it still end up being ranked number one yeah yeah that's good um yeah I wonder if there's more than we should be doing as we think about like pursuing additional funding for some of these projects I wonder if there's even more we

114should be sort of doing on our end and adoption would go a long way yeah but this is this is great information um yeah yes Mr thank you first of all for being here tonight really happy to see this um can you just clarify I thought when we had spoke I thought the Cedar Ridge project would moving forward we were able to move forward small steps I mean we were able to get wsp to go out there and actually do a surveying the surveying work is out there you probably seen survey crews out there with their survey tools to survey the feel that survey is a prerequisite work that's necessary for me to go and pursue a design engineering work for that future sidewalk so we're trying to coordinate with DOT because they're going to

115try to modernize that road add Turnal Lan so hopefully we get a sidewalk through that process we're try I'm trying to find as many we're trying to find as many ways to get that work done because I we have a lot of kids still walking in that area so hopefully when the survey is done in a couple months I'll be able to pursue continue with the design engineering For That Sidewalk then eventually find ways to actually after get a detailed cost and what it's going to cost because it's going to include a pedestrian bridge over 40 as well as something to do with the 85 under the bridge and stuff like that environmental stuff so when we get a cost we'll worry about how to deal with how to pursue the construction of that project

116so there's steps three three or four steps moving forward work on it is there a sense that it's years away decades away I mean I can't give you great great direct answer right now until I get the design engineering done until I get a seal sign drawings to see how we can pursue the construction of a project like that or would do decides to pitch in okay can I get one more yeah um um one of the questions you know we our school we're a rural School District so it makes us really different than others especially when we're talking about bike ped kind of things um if you're in for our schools that are in the town of Hillsboro Hillsboro does sidewalks yes most of our schools are not in the town of Hillsboro even

117though some like effland have density housing density around them so who does that you know there's no town no no state fund let me correct that state funds state law prevents State funds from being used for bike pad projects so it's local funds and federal funds so we had to pursue Federal projects and federal grants to pursue those kind of projects or you other means to do some of those implementations like that mean those areas with the town of Hillsboro Hillsboro State law allows towns to maintain some of their own streets those Town maintained streets town has a lot more Authority and ability to do that County state law prohibits counties from owning any rows or maintaining any rols or anything like that so BLS it's local funds and pursuing federal funds and going through

118that I mean there's been several efforts by the state legislature to change that law but we'll see what happens with the new assembly thank you Mr Aton so I I do know that these projects have been on the books for a long time and I appreciate the detail because that's what I found out early on was the county could want to build it as much as they want the dot has to decide when it's going to build it and that was the net and to a your point the town does have the flexibility to set the priorities and determine which uh sidewalks get done and I even asked the question at the time to to the dot about this and they said well yeah you can build it but you own it and own all

119the responsibility and they just went on and on and it's our easement and so it was clear that we could not just do it um but I I do want to point out one of the other things that's important at Cedar Ridge beyond the sidewalk is we do have a lot of students from Cedar Ridge that go across the street to Grady Brown yes and and that's a big concern because there's not great visibility going you know both ways depending on when you're Crossing and you know having some kind of crosswalk in there as well would definitely help with you know the safety of our students going back and forth across that it's scary driving down orang Grove Road and seeing high schoolers walking their younger siblings that are also going right across the school

120and yeah y absolutely thank you so much for bringing this and I I really appreciate appreciate all the details in it and like everyone here I hope we can get this moving especially for Cedar Ridge thank you I would just like to add that it's nice to see this back up again I was in working in the district when this was brought with orange high school and at that time Stanford Middle School and what could be done over there and we talked about a lot of things but nothing ever happened so it's not nice to see this come back up for all of our schools and um hopefully get some sidewalks crosswalks everything built in here that's going to provide safety for our kids absolutely so thank you for um all that you have done

121to get this up and moving again and the answer to miss Howser's questions is yes sometimes it does take decades to U because it's been a decade I think since this was talked about with those two schools over there um so um um but yeah we're very happy I'm very happy to see this back up and just to thank you for one more I want sorry for taking up a little time but I want to give you another thank you for all yall's help and everything like that Orange County in January approved a youth delegate on our Advisory Board and we want to thank you for providing and supporting that youth we have a senior on our Deb delegate board so we thank you for greatly appreciate that opportunity so hopefully we'll be getting some

122more going in the future okay thank you thank you very much okay all right we have our environmental health and safety update for the fall indoor air quality I think is up next good evening board members Dr Jones School staff members of the community I'm William Perry director of environmental health and safety for Orange County Schools with me I have Mr Jeremy Bentley with first call cleaning and registration services who performed our sampling and sent a test off for our air quality testing what is endoor air quality next slide please there you go thank you um end air quality is testing the process and measuring and analyzing air in a building to identify any presence of harmful substances our goal is to ensure a clean healthy safe environment for building occupants IQ tests measure air

123impurities such as allergens mold and others these tests show whether the quality of your indoor air meets the standards of e the Environmental Protection Agency and also Asha next slide please we can help identify the pollutants which is particular uh matter which is uh water droplets or other particles which could be high humidity and right now leaf mold is off the chart it starts about the end of September and runs through all winter when the leaves fall off the trees they have to Decay and mold is what helps them do that that's why we have such high readings right now outside inside our buildings we are in really good shape at the moment uh volatile organic compounds such as formaly Benzene tolene ethylbenzene and and xylin are all found in air fresheners whether they're plugins

124or just sitting on the counter or wax melters or whatever and these are also caused allergens and respiratory issues combustion pollutants are carbon monoxide which can be harmful to human health depending on the concentration we have in every Bower room in our schools carbon monoxide detectors that are run off electricity and they have battery backup the batteries are changed every 6 months when we change the clocks we change the batteries and we have a spreadsheet where we can document everything that we do uh mold there's hundreds and hundreds of species of molds we have to have a certain amount of mold to live if we didn't have it we would never survive the good part is most of what we have around here or in our schools is the good mold it's it's the stuff

125you have to have um mildew we have some Mew in our schools you have in your house it is a flat white grayish colored powdery fluffy substance it's usually in a a damper wet area and when we see this what we try to do is find out the cost remediate it fix it and move on the exact number of uh the moles depends on our testing and the laboratory methods that are used this is where Mr Bentley comes in with the testing Health agencies recommend addressing the visible mold regardless of the specific species if we see it we want to sample it remediate the problem find out what it is to make sure there's no harmful uh mle Sports in our buildings other items we check for is asbest monitoring every six months we do

126a walk through uh with a third party company to make sure that none of our asbest that's in our schools is in a fibrous condition that is solid and intact every three years we have to come in into a complete uh inspection of our schools we actually take samples of uh as an example the uh Estus tile or the mastic that holds it to the floor the glue as long as it's not a fiber State we're okay with it we are in the process now of starting to remediate and remove some of this asbest tile and and mastic and small project expensive for the school system IQ ieq testing is important because it can help identify harmful pollutants before they can cause health problems and reduce energy cost by identifying related issues the process typically

127includes an initial inspection Laboratory Testing for contaminants and recommendations for improvements this past weekend we were at a school Saturday and Sunday cleaning all the coils in the HVAC units this right here is a major major thing that has to happen and we are starting to do this at all our schools uh it's a two-ear program every two years you go in and clean the the coals unless you put in a new system then after the first year you have to go in and clean it then it'll go to the 2-year rotation and by cleaning the coils it helps the U hbac units run more efficient use lessly uh electricity and provide a cleaner environment going through the filters so we have a healthier classroom air quality we also perform monthly IQ um track to

128see what our humidity and temperatures in every classroom uh is kept on a spreadsheet like this right here uh we had one school it it spiked and we couldn't figure out okay why is it Spike and it went from a normal range to up we go to the school we look around we find the teachers are opening the windows well our HVAC units are not designed to bring in outside air to make the inside air better once we educated the teachers on keeping the windows closed we actually started improving our air quality so that that helped a lot cuz when you open the windows you bring in mold spores you bring in humidity the units have to work harder the uh coal coals get dirtier quicker the filters get dirtier quicker so we eliminated that

129party we do annually testing through Mr Bentley and his company first call uh twice a year our spring and fall they do independent Laboratory Testing they get the samples they send the samples off to a third party lab that way there no conflict of interest the humidity ranges for for the EPA is 40 to 60% our schools and we are maintaining levels between 47 and 58% the higher levels occur due to open Windows or HVAC adjustments sometimes we have our dehumidifiers that have to be adjusted to make sure we have a proper balance in our buildings normal temperatures for Asha occupational health and safety administration is 68 to 76° fah which we are maintaining at this time I'm very proud to say with the work of everybody in maintenance third- party people we have a

130100% of Orange County Schools meet or exceed the air quality testing standards we are maintaining good air quality through our service and preventative maintenance program by addressing the issues in a timely manner monthly V and air return cleaning and air quality checks in every building at school we have our custodians they fill out a form every time they do it so we can hold them accountable to make sure we're doing the right thing every 90 days we have a gentleman that goes around and changes all our filters to make sure we have a clean filter and it's doing what it's supposed to every two years we clean our cools or if the need arises before then we'll go in and clean them to make sure they're working properly every 5 years we'll go into to

131our schools we just did uh Pathways last year cleaned all the duck work actually it wasn't as bad as we were anticipating but now it's clean it's good for another 5 years uh remediation plans for roof leaks and other related uh water issues as they arise if we see a water leap we find out where it's coming from what we have to do sometimes it's a gutter we go in and clean the gutters problem solved down spouts we clean them make sure we have proper drainage if it's a roof leap we find where the hole is and we patch it so do we have any questions yes ma'am yes thank you um thank you for this um and so uh just a a background question you know in the past our reports were done by

132a different company and it seems like we've switched how we're doing it um can you just speak to that uh yeah uh he retired and first call reason I I chose first call they've worked with him okay and they're hand in hand and they knew kind of what he did and how he did it and that's what made it simpler okay okay and then is Omega is that the same is that also the first uh is that this who is Omega um Omega safety and environmental they're the lab that does the testing yeah that's that's our third party reviewer okay I'm sorry okay third party reviewer yeah yeah this a third party reviewer okay um I mean for what it's worth like I found the previous reports easier to understand and more informative um and

133so I know this is the first time that we're working together on this I think it would be helpful like um to take a look back at that there in the in in previous years we've gotten like a detailed executive summary that shared some of some of the things that you shared verbally here but it's in a written form that go out in symbl and the public can kind of see it and that kind of thing um and then it also um and I think this was a newer Edition it compared the previous results it indicated repeat findings those kinds of things so that we could keep an idea on what problems were not actually getting solved over time and it also maybe I'm misunderstanding something but um in those reports we were testing for

134mold or fungus those kinds of things twice a year in every school doing readings in multiple spaces here I just saw I think one school right um and then that report also had CO2 levels and carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide levels as well okay do you drink soft drinks uh I do do you exhale yep you're putting carbon dioxide in your body and you're every time you exhale you're putting carbon dioxide in the atmosphere fire extinguishes carbon dioxide carbon dioxide unless you're in a encapsulated suit and it's nothing in there but carbon dioxide then that's going to cause a health issue for you carbon monoxide in small amounts will cause severe health issues and that's why we have the detectors in all our boiler rooms to make sure we don't have that issue the carbon

135dioxide we had added because it was indicated it indicated something about the level of ventilation and the amount of air that was sort of being re recycl like rebreathed um by other people and so as as a strategy for helping keep people healthy right we were interested and and it actually last time it did show some real differences in the schools some of them had much higher carbon dioxide levels and that's why we started cleaning The Cools every two years okay that that's going to increase that greatly and make it a lot better okay I I wish we would bring that measurement back um and then the the the mold uh readings are we did we test for mold in all of the schools what we did uh it it took a long transition to

136go from Dr Kio to this company and we were on kind of a time crunch and that's why we didn't get everything but with the air readings that that the uh first call got and I can let Mr Bentley explain that did not warrant to go in and specifically check for every little mold there was because with the humidity and temperature it wouldn't support the growth of it okay I I'll just say that I would prefer that we go back to testing for M twice a year I I I feel you know with the state of things that happened in Alamance recently where where it was sort of you know I I would I would like to be able to have some measurement over time and as long as I'm here you won't have that

137happen with happen in Alamance trust me I trust I trust that I know we have a great team but I want to make sure that we're doing the sort of the repeated testing not to budgeon we agree um uh mold has three feeders dark damp moist uh and what Mr per and his team is doing is testing the humidity um which is like a cup and so the more water you pour in once it overflows because of humidity that is a key indicator or of organic growth um and what the report uh does talk about are those ingredients to that organic growth and so what we're doing um with the carbon dioxide is bringing in more F fresh air from those coil cleanings um but we will take into consideration on the previous reports that

138you received last year and look how we can have some similar reports hopefully in the spring based on this information um to see how our indoor air quality is performing okay thank you that would be helpful yeah there were a few schools where the humidity level was a bit on the high side and and noted it sort of outside it said the recommended Li level was 50 to 55 but I know some of our schools um the mechanical systems do not call for dehumidifiers in those schools um and of course this is North Carolina and um given uh the high humidity levels unfortunately you are going to see some of those readings in our schools yeah yeah Miss Hower yeah I I just want to support Sarah's Point first of all on the the orange

139Middle School report had different kinds of spores and and moles but as a lay person I have no idea if it's natural stuff or bad stuff or whatever and and honestly the public also we're not experts in this and there's there's good mold and bad mold that that was a good mold what youve seen in Orange County it's okay the the levels were fine and it's as a normal couldn't tell from the report right so so the organic growth is what I like to use instead of mold because there's so many varage of mode uh it's similar to the outdoors and so often times um when you have allergies um that's due to excessive mold spores in the air and so there's a number that you want to have for indoor spores versus outdoor Sports

140in many of our schools uh the outdoor ratings are higher than the indoor so we're working under uh Mr Perry and our maintenance to move some of those barriers so you don't have those levels we we I understand in concept the thing is when you read the report the report never draw so there's there's a presentation that we just received that's very general but the report on orange Middle School is not conclusive about what these findings suggest so just looking for a statement that says these are you know red red green blue would be fine with me second on this part this report was overwhelming to me because of all the Leaky roofs and things and the all the gritty coils and stuff and I realize you say we do this every week but here

141it is almost every school has um problems with coils and other things and and actually with um nothing I didn't see anything about asbest I'd be interested in more on that but um a different company does the asbest okay well it would be especially for our old schools right but um for Al standback on the first says no air testing was performed due to the amount of damage caused by roof leaks this is the report so I don't know how to and and honestly I have to be careful with this because you guys are working really hard and you know it's just overwhelming I just reading the report I cannot imagine what it's like to be looking at this report and say how are we going to prioritize is this so I appreciate every just

142how you know what and you know what's the plan what what's it look like to get all this done and and what is done look like and what's real what's realistic we we just don't know because on our side we're getting calls from people I have headaches in the building or this and that and we don't know if it's because they were drink drank too much or because there's really an issue in the building so um yeah you so we just want have a reasonable conversation with the public about our schools so that we can say hey here thank you yeah and we're in the process now if we see a roof leap we're getting it looked at and addressed so so not an issue but before you I should say be BP before Perry

143is that how you know but before you know we've gotten a lot of reports about assessments we rarely get reports on the Improvement so I mean when I first came on the board we got all the reports on the cleaning the Ducks and the vents and we never got a report saying it was done so how how do we how how do and not in general saying like Pro you know school by school project by project is kind of what I you know just as so under my leadership we're working on key performance indicators and so we'll come back uh when the time is appropriate to bring you that information that you requested okay great thank you Mr as so I I also want to say I do want to see the carbon dioxide reports

144and why I want to see it is during covid one of the very important things we learn that to improve the health of our faculty our staff and students is to get that air flow and the exchange and that was a key indicator you know not just Co it could be cold of you know we have Walking Pneumonia that was just released that is there and this is something that would really help us understand you know how our schools are doing with the uh carbon dioxide um I I agree as well of the air quality testing and the way that it used to be done to my recollection was whoever was testing would go in and talk to the principal and say where would you like us to test or you have a concern conern

145and it may be I want you to go into this closet this area and they would go do that testing because it's a closet where they keep you know equipment for uh outdoor play or something and that's how it used to be done and that way we ensured concerns within the school was being looked at to tell us is there something or not um and and I agree you know on the points of it's it's hard to understand what we're taking action on for example when I saw partnership's temperature was 79 and on the same day New Hope was tested and it was 72 and then the recommendations don't mention anything about that is do we have a air conditioning problem or was it just some something odd so and the other thing that I

146thought I think as many were talking about is when I saw some of the items on there I was like I think that's in the Wolford report but I don't have it in front of me but you know it would be helpful to know or these things that are already considered as well or kind of like everybody else was saying some kind of summary to help us understand uh especially if it's something I realize some of these are we're addressing them now we're we're going to do that that would be great for us to know versus hey this is going to take a re-engineering and we need to relay it out and we we get that and hey that be part of our Capital planning with the you know Bond we've got but I I

147just wanted to share those those would be very helpful to just understand you know what the next steps are and to Sarah's point it's very helpful to know what did we find the last time and then you know were this was this something that reoccurred or something we see an improvement on but thank you all so much for bringing the data to us so we could have this conversation about it Miss P thank you for the report and I know I'm new um but I was it it I like what they're pointing out but I also want to say that we need to be patient he just started and we got a new team and so we got to make sure that um we work together and be patient we can't get everything in one

148night and so I just want to say thank you and um I will be patient but I look forward to getting all the information and maybe um the coils instead of every 2 years maybe 6 months so that would be helpful we will look into that yes okay okay Mr Rich yeah I just want to conclude on a personal note um I appreciate all the work that you guys have done I've learned something tonight and um you know my wife this time in a year goes out and tries to buy the biggest candle that she can and so now I can use this information this year say hey my allergies are flared up because of these candles so thank Miss smile okay um um a specific um point I wanted to follow up on so

149there were not a lot of references in the report in to there were a few to the um like the supply and the return I don't know if they're called vents or registers I think they might be called different things in the different versions um and uh in our last report which had been a year before um there uh were 24 references to the vents and all of the recommendations were like these vents are not getting cleaned and we should clean them quarterly now I think you said they're being cleaned once a month now um document there so so the I mean that's fabulous if even more than the last recommendation if it's really happening you know what I mean because that that's the thing is like we were told time after time that it

150was happening um and then the report would come out and say at this school though it's not happening still even though we've said something so can you can you just describe to me like what's the oversight of that like does somebody actually go out there and like check a spot check or something I mean you can't check everything but yeah U we just got a new supervisor for the custodians his name is Mr Bobby Holland and he actually goes out and double checks if they're not doing it then he makes them do it so we do have a check and balance and we have the documentation and with everything else I've created a spreadsheet for the coil cleaning the duct cleaning everything is documented so we got solid evidence and as far as the carbon

151uh deoxide I'll let Mr mentley explain that one when he tested yes so so the uh testing well our testing was mostly microbial nature so carbon dioxide didn't have a bearing in Spore counts and that sort of environment yes yes I yeah I realized that yeah thank you okay m um I just want to say thank you and um and obviously we're a board that likes lots of detail but I still would like to say that I still think Orange County schools has some of the best facilities maintenance um standards met so thank you for all your work doing that I'd just like to add my two cents and say thank you for what you're doing we appreciate it I do agree with Sarah I think the more detailed report we can get the better

152um it helps us when we're answering questions from teachers staff or parents who call so if we can we can help in any way doing that the more details we get the better but thank you for all your work we'll be back in the spring and hopefully we'll have a better Report with all the information We Gather here tonight we look forward to it thank you thank you thank you thank you okay exception exceptional children's programming updates from Miss Stacy Barnes it's me again um okay all right so you can go to the next slide so thank you again for providing me a time to discuss um updates um from the exception children pre- Department I want to first start by highlighting our unwavering commitment to inclusion our Department's work is um firmly aligned with

153the six pillars of idea which is the individuals with Disabilities Act and um we are making sure that every student has access to a Equitable and supportive learning environment additionally we continuously working to force the partner strong Partnerships with families and Educators these Partnerships are vital as we strive to meet the unique needs of our students and throughout our training and collaboration initiatives that we'll discuss um discuss to um further on in the presentation we have established a strong foundation for datadriven instruction individualized support and inclusive practices that remains at the heart of our efforts whether th through preschool classroom walkthroughs or direct Behavior instructional um support at the school level next slide yes so our demographics um you can see we have a a large range of um needs here in the district next

154Slide the next two slides talk about our um gives you a breakdown of our population as a whole and then this one breaks down our disability disabilities by um C Ida categories so we have a diverse population here in the district and we want to ensure that our instructional practices and resources allocations meet the spectrum of disabilities represented in our schools our initiatives such as monthly principal meetings in collaboration with curriculum instruction enable us to develop school specific EC tailor plans um to address these unique demographics next slide so here are our goals through our department goals through June um 2025 where we are strengthening the EC programming so the first goal is focus on parent and Community engagement so we are committed to strengthening our Partnerships with our parents and the broader Community um

155through our family engagement that we had um we want to provide opportunities to build trust and collaboration Partnerships that empowers parents with the knowledge and confidence to be um active participants in their child's education so to further enhance engagement we plan to add short informational videos and resources to our website these materials will provide accessible um practical guidance for our parents reinforcing their role in the IEP process and overall involvement in their child's education one of the things that I'm excited about is um I don't know if we want to call it the uh reboot or the start of um the special needs advisory Council also called snack um in our district um so we want to make sure this Council will be collaborative um where it will consist of parents staff and community members

156focus on identifying and addressing key um issues um to ensure we launch this initiative successfully I'll be working closely with our chief public information officer this collabor our collaboration will raise awareness to recruit a diverse membership and create a clear line of communication with all stakeholders so this may sound a little um you know ambitious but I'm I'm I'm working on I have a plan drafted the goal is to have our first meeting from April at on in April 20125 and so with that in the meantime in collaboration with our chief public information officer we I we will prepare resources and Outreach strategies to ensure that robust participation so I'm excited about this initiative moving forward so goal two is focus using on teacher training and support and so enhancing devel um teacher development is

157the Cornerstone of our efforts we have provided professional development opportunities focus on improving IEP development um data collection for progress and data collection for Progress monitoring I want to highlight again our commitment to enhancing teacher training a robust um training program is fundamental for ensuring that every student with disabilities receives what they need and they receive the individualized support to thrive when teachers are confident they make informed decisions that directly impact student outcomes to address this we are implementing a targeted professional development plan that uses a structured approach to teacher training um it is it will include a phased I do we do you do model where teachers first observe best practices then collaborate with coaches and finally apply what they learn independently so beginning January 20125 in collaboration with human resources we will have

158monthly sessions that will build foundational skills with a focus on beginning teachers that's one years one through three for teachers who join midye there will be an onboarding process to ensure that they gain the um necessary skills um quickly our goal is not only to build teacher capacity but also to Foster confidence in their ability to meet the needs of our students this plan is aligned with both the district's equity and strategic plan goal three is school leadership and collaboration our work with School principles is integral to achieving sustainable improvements monthly principal meetings facilitate the development of EC focused School plan tail it to the unique needs of um their students by aligning these plans with overall District goals we are building a cohesive strategy that prioritize prioritizes equity and Excellence for all students collaboration

159also includes fostering consistency across schools to ensure every child benefits this um from the same high standards and practices these goals represent a robust road map towards strengthening our exceptional Children's Program and achieving sustainable success questions thank you yes um I I'd like for you to please uh clarify to our public that we do have or clarify with me just in case I'm speaking at of turn and I don't know the information that we have people trained to restrain that uh if necessary students EC students is that is that something absolutely we do okay um we have trainers um that through CPI um training that um they actually have to before you can restrain a child you have to be certified in that but there are also some deescalation that is taught and that's tried

160before a restraint so that's the last resort um also one of the goals that will be um that we're working on behind the scenes is actually developing um school teams where there could be there be training for school teams to have deescalation techniques and to be able to intervene when um to keep all students safe great thank you I I just uh believe that not all the public understands that that's why I wanted you to clarify that thank you um and the last one um can you also clarify for the public that um SRO are not involved in this process with EC students restraining yes no um they're there to help deescalate as well but not to be involved in the day-to-day restraining of if and and let me just say this that is a

161last resort to restrain we don't have many restraints in the district at all and is and the ones that I've seen so far are due to safety for the student thank you oh I forgot and I promised last one I've been so quiet because I've had a bad headache it's so hot in here um not mold the last one is um when it comes to EC families that uh do not speak English and that could be any language um are we letting them know that we can translate all that information to them in their native tongue yes ecats is built so documents also in ecats can be translated into um their native language so that's a A plus there but also we have we just had a conversation today about a family needing a language

162and um having to work with the school on how to get that um interpreter there at the meeting okay thank you but there has been training with teachers and there's been training with the interpreters themselves on how to interpret effectively in IEP meeting okay thank you Miss doll um thank you Miss Burns I just wanted to thank you for your presentation and I'm excited to to see the goals um and in particular um the goal of April for the um the rebooted um snack which has been under conversation for like a number of years I mean this this isn't um a new conversation so I'm excited to see um that specific date um elevated which I know has a lot of intentionality behind the date not randomly selected um and I'm sure we will um

163have a bilingual goals around the committee absolutely so diverse is including all of that making sure that everyone is represented there so um drafting the plan very carefully to make sure that everyone is represented teachers um Community me members um whatever background you come from making sure that there's someone there that you can relate to and that can also if um and I don't want anyone um to feel like they can't participate so we're going to work with um the family on to make sure we have interpretation as well great thank you very much Miss W just want to affirm how important that point is um there's I've spoken with people who um work in multiple external organizations who work with some Orange County Schools families whose first language is not English who have said

164so many of the questions that they get from parents around education are around like navigating that process or feeling like their child might have a learning disability or like not knowing what to do so I do think that attention to that is really like I just want to plus one on that um the question that I have the teacher training um is also exciting um is that focused on beginning EC teachers or all teachers so that question came up last week with tops so that is EC beginning teachers but working with principles as well for supporting Genet teachers so principles are reaching out to say they need this type of training hopefully um moving forward as we go through the individual school plans with principles we can start to get more gened initiatives um supporting

165like what every Genet teacher needs to know about EC so this way everyone sitting at the table or whether you're in the classroom understands what need what that student needs and how to implement yeah I do think there's just such opportunity there to continue to like bolster um gened teachers um abilities um in working with uh children who have an IEP or before and so my instructional um speal program specialist is working with curriculum instruction as well and she's been doing some work with co- teing and also attending some of the meetings to try to um we don't want to see e over here and jenet over there we want to make sure that when we sit at the table everyone's getting what they need whether that be the student or the um staff awesome

166um there just an idea to throw out there um which is there were a number of years ago the district was encouraging teachers to like do an AIG add-on uh certificate and so if there's anything like that for EC like just for people who have an interest and want to like continue to develop their skills through external programs um I don't know what I don't know what we can do to encourage that but it seems like it would be valuable for definitely look into that with um I could speak with HR about that yes I I just first wanted to thank you for being here and being you and watching you at the family engagement uh session was UN unbelievable to me just the trust and the confidence that you built with parents including Spanish-speaking

167parents it was really pretty wonderful to see your passion your your skill your everything Unstoppable I think thank you um real really happy also to hear that you're moving snack along it's been we've been waiting a long time um I'm going to rob Mr Davis's point about kpis um one of the things that's that's been a challenge for us and it's partly coming out of covid but we've been behind on our IEPs and we've been not always delivering services on a timely manner and I'm just curious um if um if you have plans to help give us and just keep us current on on how that's going just some kind of indicators that that's happening or um so that that's one thing and the other thing I wanted to point out we had a public

168question today about our our at schools and moving them out of the federal designation I was just curious if you have any thoughts on that so the compliance piece of that is there are monthly compliance reports that will be going out to principls um they were going out before now I'm going to take that over myself and so they'll be going out to principls doing principal meetings that's part of the agenda to go over compliance recognize any type of you know um reflex if you will and move things along also meeting with related service providers psychologist speech and language therapists to keep an eye on testing so when students go through through the referral process that we're moving through the 90-day timeline and they're being placed or if not found eligible that we're going through

169that process um within the regulations okay just there there's his start hisorical my date is a little bit old but historically there's been a problem with some cultures where they do not want to be involved with IEPs and get their kids labeled or and you know is are you are you have ideas or thoughts about breaking down do those barriers still exist and and not that I've ENC counted here so far however um that's what the parent and um family night was about and that's what the videos are going to be about hopefully with um getting snack up and running we'll have more of an exposure with just you know the parents and the school you know schools coming together to kind of talk about some of that and then as we train you know

170our teachers in that effective communication how do we talk parents through that whole process so it's not scary so I have an openo policy I've met with several parents they can meet with me and we could talk through that process as well you have me convinced thank you thank you Mr ason thank you so much and you know as many mentioned really appreciate your leadership and you know getting the first meeting together to engage in the parents I'm very frustrated and really appreciate how those conversations happened and uh really understanding you know your perspective on how we engage with our families and Community um I have a few questions um so um first uh how are we working with our schools to be more inclusive in school events that may be different and creative um

171you know I did attend um one of the schools where an autistic child had an actual lead solo part in a music it was amazing um you could tell the child was nervous and you know but did a wonderful job I've seen one other school that you know had lights instead of them singing and those are great things but you know how do we share those things to the to the rest of the schools and really look at how we be you know inclusive like how do we ensure that parents the students you know whether it's headphones you know any over stimulation to to help accommodate you know have have you started thinking about some of those kind of ways we can help engage differently so one um piece of it is looking at all

172of the students who disability placement and making sure that there are opportunities for them to engage whether it be in um so like example like students on the extended content are they engaging in their elective classes um for that um engagement with their non-disabled peers and making sure accommodations are there for the support um them in that setting um also like the playground right there was many many ideas for I I couldn't stop talking about that but there are many ideas to build inclusive PR playgrounds right where we don't have to have a separate one but it can be inclusive and then having ways that um jet peers can come in and because um students with disabilities are general education students first and so making sure that we don't lose that and so also finding

173ways opportunities as talking with princi principl and visiting schools how can we make this more inclusive um we've where I came from before we had students actually participating in sports and so making sure that where there's potential there's a there's access and so and if it's not what do we need to do to get them to that point fantastic um you know very excited about the snack uh I know the superintendent as I am um we do have a board liaison for that as well and definitely would like to ensure the participation happens to be me but I would love to be engaged in that and you know just help in any way I can obviously very passionate about it um one thing I did want to share that may not be known to others

174and maybe some of the board members is you know uh at Pathways I've seen in the self-contained classes some very subtle things that they do for example the First Responders program they have where uh they bring in First Responders to sit and let the students see them you know have conversations on it not just once but many time and I think one of the important things is a lot of people assume that we're doing that just for the students it's actually for the First Responders as well for them to understand that kids have different behaviors they have different needs and how can you engage them especially if in an emergency right and I've even seen them go a little further uh recently when I visited uh during announcements they would have their SRO go in

175with you know kind of their safety gear and you know bright yellow police and they were just in the classroom right you know and they had shared that hey you know this just this week I had one student come up to me and you know pull my hand to come come play and the whole the whole purpose is not for them to attempt to engage but let the students but I just you know I think it's important for our community to know there are so many of these great programs that are going on and that really appreciate you here and your guidance and Leadership on you know how do we take this to the next level absolutely so thank you for being here thank you for having me I appreciate it okay thank you so

176much for your presentation we love look forward to all the great things that you've got planned okay thank you so much Mr mccon we have the last quarter well the second quarterly report on the on BUDs program do we need to extend our time I would I would say yes because we only have five minutes okay can I have a motion to extend Time by 10 minutes 15 minutes 10 minutes tops okay a motion to extend fire 10 minutes second all in favor I okay all right well thank you is yours um coming back tonight to talk about U my on Bud's quarterly report for Q2 so this is be my first one coming back so I do want to start with um a level setting back to the four pillars to understand that those

177are the four areas that we need to make sure they're focused on that's confidentiality informality Independence impartial and informal so this sort of set the stage for everything that I do in the on buds office this is the the level set for everything these are the same things I talk about with all visitors that's a term that I use to describe the people who come to see me they are visitors um when they come and see me so these are the I I speak through with them they have an understanding of what these are all part of so I want to level set with that as a reminder for everyone to know so tonight I'm going to focus on as much data as I can I can give and the reasonings behind that so the

178first one really is going to be the uniform reporting category so in your abstract tonight is a very detailed report from the international OS Association on how they came up with these nine uniform reporting categories what are these These are how I code the visitor visits and this is how I can bring that information back to you this is directly from the International ous Association and it's used by my colleagues all over the world so there's nine individual areas that I will be using to code each and every visitor interaction whether it's in person or whether it's virtual or over the phone so this slide really kind of gives you like the background the history of how the OS Association got to those nine and in your abstract is even more detail so what are

179the nine these are the nine specific areas I'm not going to read through each and every one of them but as I'm having conversations with staff and I go through that information with them that interaction is going to fall into one of these nine categorical areas and this is the kind of information I'm going to be bringing back to you about my interaction with staff this is also what's going to be back to District leadership to help to to follow policy protocol and Elevate the trends which is one of the areas um that's of most importance to the nut's office so like I said level setting so here are the uniform reporting categories this is the same set that my colleagues use all over whether it's K12 whether it's in medical whether in University these

180are the same nine So based on what I'm able to bring to you so the the number of visitors I have I'm not able to bring the to number based on precent with uh the uh best practice with the Ia so be in the Q3 I will be able to bring the total but what I can tell you is at least half of them have been classified and half of them have been certified and by far the uniform reporting category that by far is as all of them is um the peer and colleague relationships that is the one that has risen up as the highest uh the most consistent in the total number I've that I've to spoke with um and there are conversations and interactions with me a little bit about what that means

181so these are questions and concerns or inquiries with directly between peers they're that's um the uniform recording category that really has been the most out of all of the ones that I've seen so far um out of the nine in wrapping this up I want to mention a couple of things so we're moving into semester two I'm going to be going back out on the schools as much more continuing to to raise awareness because I do know that there are still plenty of places for me to continue to raise that awareness I'm benchmarking currently right now K12 institutions with websites about potenti bringing a a website page for ombuds and um benchmarking against those ones so hopefully that as well I'm also working on a trifold trifold brochure that can be handed out it could

182be at schools can be anybody who wants to be able to have it digitally or in person I have that that one as well but really trying to continue to have that FaceTime in the schools and helping people understand that the service and the opportunity was really there for them and coming to me to ask for questions and what I can be doing to support them so that's really the continued effort from that as I I I work through through this this new um opportunity and making sure that I'm there and out and having that FaceTime in our school so that's really the most important parts of where I'm at so it's as you can see a very kind of brief report based on the total numbers that I'm getting you're getting kind of a

183window into the classified versus certified and what are what the the highest number is for um the uniform reporting categories really the next steps is continuing that process it's getting my face out there continuing to have people understand what my role is and working on that promotion ones whether that's second semester more time in schools the tri for for sure I can have a schools and uh benchmarking potential website so with that I will stop and what questions may you have for me Miss do uh thank you Mr mun I just have to say um I really appreciate your presentation I like knowing the the codes that's really interesting um and that helps and and um I appreciate the context of the visits that you've shared and I have a feeling I can't speak for

184all board members but I really assume all of us would be very happy to have your trifolds um to have to pass out and I'm not at all surprised that you've already come up with all kinds of ideas for um enhanced communication so thank you I can't take all the credit I haven't been given good advice and feedback in the past but I'm I'm currently working on it hopefully have't it done soon uh just want to Echo the thanks um and yeah excited that there's going to be some physical materials and stuff that you can put out there um are you going to be um I see that underneath each of those categories peer and colleague relationships there are like subcategories is like this is about like bullying or respect or whatever like are you

185going to be coding it to that level where where we'll be able to have a bit of more of a sense of what kinds of issues with peers or colleagues or whatever I can but obviously the most important thing is going to be confidentiality but I that's the reason why those are there that's also going to come down to the total numbers and things that I get the overall starting point because this is all very new is to code it appropriately within the nine then subcategorize it depending on the numbers I have I can do that but it's going to take I just being fully transparent it's going to take experience and continuing to do that be able to ascertain the conversation with a visitor is it is it a peer relationship but then is

186it this one but then is it the next one so it's going to come through with time and continuing culturation and learning from myself as I continue to build relationships in and around the area I'm very excited to be in a a K12 on buds group that meets monthly and these are kind of things and great questions and feedback I can bring to my direct colleagues and say well how do you code it um because in my foundations training from my understanding most of them coded on the nine the subset categories are there for an understanding of the nine so some of them may some of them may not so it's going to be part of my continued um learning that's great I'm really glad that you have a group of peers like a peer

187Learning Community for yourself um in this UDS work that's fabulous I will just like I do think um ultimately as we get more robust data like understanding what it is about peer and colleague relationships or supervisory relationships or whatever like understanding some more of that Nuance I think will be helpful um once we got the volume my understanding is that's the intentionality of why those subset categories are there so to be able to give as much as you can with without giving all the right M aler yeah I really appreciate the way You' just like hit the ground running thank you um are you finding that people are coming to you that they understand what an ombudsman is what the role is and are excit are happy about that and the reason I'm asking is

188some people have come to me and they're looking for more something more like an employee Advocate which is different so I just curious how people are responding to this and if they understand how you can help and if they so there is a learning curve on it we're still continuing what that's going to look like with staff so yes I get plenty that don't fully grasp it which is why I have a standard discussion with them before we get started because I got to be able to level set the understanding of why you're coming to me because you're coming to me for a reason you've reached out to me for a reason I want to make sure you have a full understanding what I can and cannot do for you so yes there's still a

189lot of opportunity for us to continue to grow that but I take any interaction as an opportunity to to help and support someone so even if they come to me well I have no idea what you're doing but I'm here to I mean that's still part of my role and job to teach them um so I take it all those opportunities but yes to answer your question there are still a lot of Staff who don't fully know but that's also a part of my job is to help them understand yeah fantastic thank you Mr Aston oh so Eko thank you um definitely appreciate everything you're doing especially you know as mentioned working with peers and others um really appreciate seeing the report and evolving it as well um I would like to request we put

190this on the external website um especially for people that are new to the district or coming to the district and specifying it's you know specifically for staff and I think it will help get the word out and I agree I would love to have some of the trifolds and help you so thank you very much noted yes sir I think you can make a poster of the big tries and put it in here one night so everybody could see it I could absolutely do that I could put it in assembly I could put it everywhere I know people in the district can do that and and we could all everybody could see it I think that would be great and I think the uh opportunity to see this on our web page and anywhere else

191you can put it is absolutely great thank you for what you're doing I do want to also say for any the the staff listening public it is there is an internal web page for you have to be a staff member of the state on the inonet so I want to make sure that I would be remiss if I didn't mention that as well uh but the goal is as I've heard the feedback is also on the external website as well nice any other questions yes ma' I just want to comment thank you your energy is always so exciting and we need that so thank you you are most welcome I'm glad to do it all right thank you so much you're most welcome all right we are at the end of our meeting do I

192have a motion to adjourn so move second all in favor I we are so adjourned thank you to all those who visited with us tonight and um I hope each of you has a a wonderful Christmas holiday

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.