CorpusRecord 215304

Jamestown School Board February 17, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Jamestown Video
Date
2025-02-18
Location
Stutsman County, ND
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,346 words · about 69 min
Collected
2026-06-26

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] e for e e are you ready chrisy and this yes okay good evening I'd like to call this regular meeting of the Jamestown Public School Board to order it is Monday February 17th 2025 5:30 p.m. in the Thompson Community room we'd like to welcome all those in the audience this evening note that board member Owen McKenna is joining us by phone today please join me for the Pledge of Allegiance IED of the United States Jamie would you be willing to read the school board Norms of course thank you the board developed Norms are to share and respect opinions and speak with United Voice once a decision has been reached execute all duties of school board in compliance with North Dakota Sentry code properly prepare for meetings commit to assessing board Effectiveness to ensure high

002quality governance for all stakeholders thank you Jamie moving on our agenda nothing under Communications any conflicts of interest to declare any conflicts of interest any conflicts of interest Owen and Jacob you want to declare the same conflict yeah yeah same as last time same as previous okay thanks other than that um any other conflicts of interest okay um consent agenda is there a motion or if there's anything you'd like [Music] removed motion by Steve second by Jamie we have a motion a second for approval of the consent agenda any discussion and if there's anything you'd like removed we can certainly do that any discussion or any clarifications if not assuming roll call vote all those in favor say I I same sign motion approved moving into our regular meeting um nothing under recognition under correspondence

003we have a thank you from the en rumance of the Jerry Miller family under reports we have a boundary study report so we have RSP and Associates here please come forward you by the virtually okay and then are we just on the screen then so RSP is joining us virtually uh as we talked about in the uh in previous meetings we wanted to have uh this boundary study and enrollment analysis as quickly as possible which meant the quickest we could do this uh was to have them attend virtually uh and so they have accommodated us and thank you Mr Armitage and our tech department for making sure that this was uh a workable solution for us and just a reminder uh for these kinds of Zoom calls uh they're linked into our our microphones so

004if you do have a question uh just make sure that you are uh pressing the button so we can uh so they can hear you online okay and then we could just have you state your name for our our minute board minutes before you start my name is Jenna Wallace with RSP is every everyone able to hear me and see the screen yes yep okay perfect well I'll go ahead and get started tonight like I said my name is Jenna Wallace with RSP we're a planning firm based out of Kansas City who work all over the Midwest Assisting School Districts with enrollment planning and other facility decisions tonight I'm going to really have two main topics of information to present to you all the first is the results of the 202442 enrollment analysis so I'm

005going to very briefly kind of go over those main variables how we go through understanding student data and leading into a fiveyear um enrollment analysis that will be used as the foundation for our boundary considerations so part two I have some different visuals to look at a potential boundary um movement for phase one and phase two and then lastly we'll have some next steps and opportunity for you all to ask any questions about any of the information tonight this first part enrollment analysis we have the district um continuing to decrease over these next five years a more stable enrollment with a decrease of about 85 students districtwide you can see here when I get into that the majority of that loss is more at the elementary and middle school as high school um more stabilizes

006these next 5 years we'll talk more about capacity when we get into what those boundary um potential scenarios look like and how we balance our en enrollment to capacity looking at our different facility uses these next five years this first visual of the report is looking at the methodology of the RSP forecasting model and so if you follow this map here um we're showing what one planning area looks like so a planning area is really the building block of the forecasting model all of the information in tonight's report goes into what each planning area is and so we're creating planning areas based on those neighborhood lines natural barriers major roadways the attendance boundaries and then each planning area is individually analyzed in the forecasting model so this really just goes into show how granular were

007able to get with the student data each planning area SL neighborhood is is um analyz for their Census Data their County data the student data and then when we pivot into those boundaries um that's how we can show what the different projections would look like if you move certain neighborhoods around if you move these planning areas what does that mean for projected enrollment so just a little bit into this information about really what is into that sophisticated forecast model everything in the model is going to lean more towards that indication of enrollment growth or indication of enrollment decrease and so what the models doing is taking all that information and right setting the most likely forecast and so some of these variables that I'll pull up later will be more of that growth model and

008some are more limitations this first visual here is looking at the relationship between housing population and enrollment growth and so we've seen um pretty limited Housing Development there was the uptick in 2324 school year um but then these past past couple of years we've leaned more to a population loss and enrollment loss and so that correlation more leaning towards a limited growth model we attract here what the live birth rate is for the county and so looking at um a pretty stable life birth rate R and that birth rate um is really you can see very stable with that population under 5 years of age so we're looking at a very um natural market share of what that potential kindergarten class would be not many swings up and down from this variable our past enrollment

009by grade is definitely a key slide to looking at what enrollment has been happening these past 10 years we've had two years of District loss um that has been creating larger grades in the secondary and smaller grades in the elementary so A good rule of thumb when you're looking at enrollment data is looking at that senior class as they graduate and organically lead this system are they being fully replaced by the incoming kindergarten class and so in this case we are saying um these upcoming senior classes larger than 150 students with our incoming grades closer to around 120 to 130 and so that's going to be a very hard um class to replace as they organically leave and it would be reliant on cohort growth year-to year which leads into this next visual of what

010is the trends of cohort change year to year so as a class of second graders become third graders what's the tendency to pick up kids we do see a great cohort growth at the eth to 9th grade um level likely students coming into that High School experience and some other years where we see more of a cohort loss and so all of that's factored in to that grade byg grade projection our in andout migration focuses on the new students coming into the district that's the orange bars and past students exiting the district that's the green bars and so um we have a pretty net uh low really when we look at the difference of in and out every year a net change of less than 50 students the past two years and so a pretty

011stable migration trend of how many students are coming in are fully replacing those students leaving and then our out of District Trend so this is looking at um all students that when we geocoded their addresses reside out of the District boundary so in this case this variable we have seen some loss from this popul po ation where we're seeing less students residing from out of the District boundary and then the next two visuals are some student maps that look at where students are living in the district so a count change visual here is looking at the different neighborhoods that have been increasing in student count so those are those areas that are dark or orange their neighborhood subdivision life cycle has been increasing while in the green areas we've seen that count change de increase

012maybe some Aging in place or some neighborhoods that aren't turning over and the student count has been decreasing these past 5 years and then we have total student density here in this heat map so the greater that heat and red visual the greater density of students so we know that there's different things happening at that neighborhood level throughout the district some housing units are leaning more toward enrollment growth and some are in the cycle where they're decreasing and we're factoring all that in at that level of the planning areas we've also um included some different Census Data from the housing market so knowing what is the home value household income mortgage and year built all of that goes into those planning areas of what is the relationship of the housing market with our students looking

013at at the recent year bill so looking at how many units have been built over these past 5 years we had the greatest amount of activity in 20123 with eagle Flats Apartments coming online um but other than that these past five years we've been building less than 10 units per year and that correlates with this visual of the student yield rate and so a yield rate is the number of students we have coming from housing units so in this case that purple is the number of students per 100 single family units and then the pink is 100 students per 100 multifam units and then the teal color is students per 100 mobile home units and so all these different housing types have a different relationship with how many students we generally see from that housing

014product and we also track this over time and so we can see with this visual that um we have been seeing a decrease yield rate for our single family units which is a limitation to that residential turnover and generation of students the multifam has been slightly increasing so as likely that new housing inventory Eagle Flats came online we're seeing more students from multifam so Apartments town homes that type of housing product and then the mobile home um Park units a bit more fluctuation over these past 10 years um but generally has a higher yield rate than the past and so we're seeing a bit of an uptick from students from the mobile home households as well all this information helps us put together this visual of what what are the areas that potential housing may

015come online the next 5 to 10 years and so the green areas we have Countryside Estates continuing to build out the next couple of years and then some are is identified by speaking with um the city and county planners that be could be potential developments over the next 5 to 10 years um but those areas would require some different infrastructure updates and developer interest um but we want to put that on the radar as some areas for potential development over this next decade so moving a little bit into our projections here this first visual looks at the comparison of our class sizes and so this first visual is looking over time what has been the difference between that kindergarten and 12th grade class we have this forecasted to continue as a greater 12th grade class

016than that incoming kindergarten so we have a pretty stable kindergarten enrollment and with that market share of our birth rate being very stable we forecast kindergarten to maintain around that 130 students um but with our larger grades coming into the high school and positive cooh Port growth from 8th to 9th grade we see those senior classes becoming larger to that kindergarten which is that limitation to that districtwide growth so overall this is your first visual of the overall of projections um we have the elementary enrollment to forecast forecasted to decrease by about 43 students over the next five years Middle School forecasted decrease by 38 student students over the next 5 years and high school forecasted a decrease by just four students and you can say see in some years that comes up and back

017down more of a stable um High School enrollment at around 720 students so the next thing we provide is this is based off all of the um current facility so if you maintain all buildings next year and over the next 5 years what are the projections by building we also break this down by a couple different ways and I'll go through that pretty quickly and just know that our different numbers here are really to help you guys use this tool um in whatever way would be most beneficial so the numbers that we provide in the middle row green font is the number of students projected by reside so how many students do we physically think live in say Guster boundary the blue font bottom row is the number of students we have forecasted to attend

018that building and so there's a difference of reside and attend when we look at intradistrict movement um elll placement as well as maybe just some student options between the schools that impact that not everyone who resides attend and so we're trying to show um what that most realistic number would be through both lenses when I move into our boundary discussion in just a little bit I will be focusing on that reside enrollment um and that's going to be the best way to make boundary decisions and talk about how many students live throughout the district and so I'm going to be focusing on these green numbers reside enrollment the other information on this slide is looking at the projected building enrollment to our district capacity and so the green shading indicates when the building is forecasted

019to occupy less than 70% of that capacity and so you can see we have some underutilization challenges within our current inventory um especially at Lewis LaMore Roosevelt Washington and our middle school and so we don't have any buildings overc capacity but we do have some underutilization challenges so in conclusion there um we have some different variables that are um working together to produce this final enrollment analysis some challenges that we want to address with our next steps of potential boundary and facility usage um all in all trying to get at what is the best distribution of students at all our facilities and how can we plan um to best support those students so before I go into this part two is there any questions on any of those slides is there any information that I

020could explain a bit um more in depth this is not all the slides in the enrollment analysis it's just that executive summary are there any questions from the board Jason on on slide 19 when you when you talk yield rate comparisons are we looking at just Jamestown School Jamestown public school students or is that like demographics of the of the children in Jamestown does that make sense are we only looking at current JPS students yes we're only looking at um official students in the district over the past 10 years not the full like census population just students in your District any other questions if not continue all right perfect so the next part um is going to go through this um boundary analysis that our team has met with District administration on um this process

021here we started with the enrollment analysis so that information that I just PR presented to you was the Baseline for all conversations revolving around potential boundaries we met with the district admin team four times um between really just throughout the month of January and each time the feedback from that meeting guided the boundary conversation a different way to have a very Natural Evolution um to land on tonight's recommendations I do have these boundaries is broken up into two different phases and so phase one when I say that I'm talking about the 2526 implementation and so with Washington um going offline we would need to create a boundary plan that does that and distribute students between the other facilities for that 25 26 and 26 27 school year phase two that's more of your long-term considerations

022as um you guys go out for a potential Bond and talk about what a different building may look like we have two different options to consider if the uh potential rebuild is a two-section or a three section facility and so this uh visual here goes through what those decision points would be for the 2526 decision Point um we have two options for you to consider tonight Phase 1 a is more of a minimal boundary change Phase 1 B is more boundary change not as minimal as Phase 1 a and there's some different pros and cons that we'll talk about and then 2728 when we would reopen Washington the differences of phase 2 a or 2B is whether Washington reopens as a two- section or a three section building some other key considerations that really build

023the foundation of this process and the recommendations I'll present is looking in this box down here and so one goal was to try to minimize student move movement especially between phases so if you are a student that would be potentially impacted in phase one we were trying to not impact you in phase two the next consideration is the location of our e programming and so in the options with as it's currently at Washington and Roosevelt this switches over into our options for gner and Roosevelt becoming the El student schools this helps with some enrollment distribution as well as balancing some demographics in the facilities and that's that last pullup point of while we're looking at balancing enrollment let's try to ensure that we're balancing the demographics of our students as well so the first map

024here this is just to familiarize your guys with your current bound boundaries so the phase one we would be looking at um Washington so that yellow area being redistributed between our other schools and then in phase two when that building comes back online we'll look at the different options of a two-section versus a three section facility with our current projection so this is that same information that was presented in part one focusing on the reside enrollment you can see in this case for Louis LaMore we are projecting around 90 to 85 students residing in that foundary this would be less than that 70% utilization and then Roosevelt around 180 students that would be less than the 70% utilization and then Washington so this is that 115 to about 100 students over the next five years

025we would be looking at how would we redist distribute distribute those students in this phase one of the boundary plan all right so Phase 1 a this is looking at what a more of a minimal change would be for um the next two school years in this case we have area one highlighted which is the current Washington boundary that would be extended into Lincoln so Lincoln Elementary expands West into the original Washington boundary to do this we can't completely keep all of Lincoln and so there's more of some movement um South in that South Lincoln Island so in this case area 2 goes into Louis lore expanding that boundary and increasing enrollment there and then area 3 we have Roosevelt Elementary expanding West to the river um to into that original Lincoln boundary as well

026so trying to balance enrollment between all of our facilities as we move into this period of Washington being offline so the projections for this concept are we're really focused on these two school years starting in 2728 to 2930 would be potentially Changed by that phase two so the numbers here are just to illustrate if phase two doesn't happen what the balance could be but we're really looking at implementation of the 25 26 and 26 27 school year so looking at this potential a distribution of students gner um stabilizes by around 200 120 students that's about an 80% utilization of the facility Lincoln Elementary around students L more increases to about 130 students and that's about an 88% utilization of that building and then Roosevelt added 225 students around an 82% utilization of that facility so

027this is based on that student reside with the movement of our elel students so we were able to take those students and put them into what would be the new eel program so gner and Rosevelt um but then it would be assuming everybody attends where they reside in those boundaries so there may be still a little shifting with that intradistrict movement but this provides a pretty good balance between all four facilities of between that 80 to 90% utilization of each School we also have some different analysis tables for this uh concept so I won't go through all these but just know that there's a lot of data behind each of these visuals in this case the first table is looking at what our potential impact on students would be we would be um adjusting 151

028potential students in this concept and then we have a bit of an improved balance between our demographics and so looking at in ethnicity and ourl and elll balance with Phase 1 a all right so with that that goes in through all that phase one a like I said that's more of the minimal adjustments we're really just focusing on adjusting students from the current Washington boundary and balancing students in the South phase 1B does a little bit more balancing on the Dem graphic lens of our students so you'll see here area one is the same area that would be expanded so when Washington closes Lincoln extends over to the West Side to um expand to the original Washington boundary that's the same as Phase 1 a area 2 and area three that's all the same as

029um Phase 1 a as well as Louie expands North and Roosevelt expands over to the West the difference between 1 a and 1B comes with these areas highlighted number four and so there's a bit more I would say kind of massaging of the boundary between gner and Lincoln to improve balance and demographics between the schools and so the northern part this area that I'm highlighting is originally Guster and it would move into Lincoln and then the um south of 19th Street the two areas labeled for are currently Lincoln areas that would move into guser and so this is something that RSB kind of calls a double move we have some students moving out of a boundary and other students moving in to get at an enrollment and demographic balance that would be desirable it has

030a greater impact on students um but that's just something to consider when we look at more of a minimal change versus a more change so in this case for the um attendance boundaries we still have a great balance between all four facilities between that 80 to 90% utilization Guster in this case a pretty stable around of 220 students Lincoln around um 215 and then Louis LaMore and Rose Bel that's going to be those same numbers the change with 1B is between gner and Lincoln so really the difference of 1B comes down to this slide on 36 where we have more change if you look at the guser and Lincoln lines where there's more students 41 coming out of Lincoln 31 out of gner into Lincoln and so these numbers work pretty well with keeping enrollment

031the same what they improve is our demographic balance so increasing gner to a more similar frl percentage as the other facilities creating more of an equitable experience between those four facilities and then in this case we have an increase of students impacted so phase one a was looking at that about 150 student impact phase 1B around 220 student impact so that's a pretty highlevel overview of the two differences between this first phase of a boundary consideration some of the pros and cons are listed out here below um in both in Phase 1 a Lincoln would keep its current boundary um on the North side but then in Phase 1B the current Lincoln boundary um on the North side is more redistributed but Guster Phase 1 a Guster geographically is not impacted that the only increase

032in that uh School projections is due to the elll student movement um but then phase 1B Guster has a bit more of that Geographic change um so that all four schools would have a boundary adjustment we have more of an impact here in Phase 1B with the 223 students impacted but then look looking at the frl balance in 1B you have a difference of your schools reduced from a 33% difference to a 10% increase so all schools have a more similar frl percentages Phase 1 a um a pretty similar where the difference between our schools would be 25.8% so still an improvement from um the current demographic balance but phase 1B goes a little bit further to balance that percentages and so that goes through phase one um I can pause here for questions or

033discussions or I can kind of keep going into phase two and then we could have one discussion at the end I can pivot however you guys would like to do this just let's ask see if there's any questions from the board so far um in this process Dan um just kind of looking at the numbers a little bit about the the population shift these are all based off reside right this is not the actual okay so are we accounting for um know which schools take a bigger percentage leap that maybe they how do we prepare for that it's probably not so much a question for RSP but for um just in our planning like the phases like which between the phases there's more impact for one and more of a movement greater percentag yeah Dr

034I want to make sure I understand your question are comp yep well different yeah it really is going to depend on what option we select because I mean really if you look at phase one outside of we know we have a large number of students uh that are Washington students that are absorbing a large portion of that number so 50 to 60 uh students are you know projected to move based on that phase where that gets much significantly higher uh in in 1B uh but yes we would have to be think you know another we would have to be thinking about what that transition would look like how another decision that would need to be made is what would we do with waivers we know the impact of Legacy waivers uh that have had on

035the district for many many years and so you know to make that transition we would have to um make make a make hard decisions in terms of how we want to act with waivers even either understanding that there are going to be um implications to class size uh if we allow waivers to continue uh ver and there'll be movements uh if we did not the the so I'm not sure that I fully understand your question absolutely yes I see what you're saying correct correct yeah yeah and we do have to understand that we have you know in some of our you know we're looking at fairly large numbers but overall class sizes are still even with the change on an average level are still under 20 so yes there will be changes thank you yes

036there's going to be changes but U not insurmountable changes uh but will there be impacts absolutely you're you're taking a single section out of the equation there's Absol absolutely going to be impacts not confident I answered your question more for awareness than anything okay thank you and thank you to our uh technical support here and getting our microphones back online Jacob did you have a question who was that I missed who was first Jacob first maybe or or Melissa go ahead and this again is going to be more question for uh Dr Le um I think with the elel students going into gner how is that going to affect the um the current programs that are there are any of those current programs that are there going to have to be moved to accommodate those

037elll students coming into dner we would not see any um likely change for programming if we're talking you know specifically Early Childhood special education you know I would not see that as as is there being any program loss or shift at this time uh based on this consolidation um there might be time in our future where we look to um you know say there were another building brought on or replacement of Lincoln at that time would it be a consideration um you know if that could be better suited to that program better suited at the new building you know if that were to be the community's wishes I think you could consider that but in the short term I do not see that I yeah that's my biggest concern is that we aren't going to

038move some of those um some of those populations more than once correct yeah I think we can accommodate um right now Jacob yeah if this is an observation kind of for both well for both uh 1B and 1 a is the section of Louie or the area of the Louis more District that was split into two and three on the maps um I'm just wondering if that was specifically because of residential housing numbers um if there's any way for the school to look at how many students are actually living in that uh specifically section 2 uh area just because there is the river is an actual physical boundary and as a parent who drives uh to the Louis lore neighborhood on a daily basis uh getting up there from that area of town isn't the

039easiest that um I would look at if we could potentially look at uh putting those that neighborhood into the Roosevelt uh boundary um and see see what the numbers do it looks like Roosevelt was lower on the capacity um percentages U but just something to consider moving forward that maybe we need a one C uh to kind of account for that just again for an actual physical boundary um that I don't think was accounted for in the planning could we talk about what is the student impact in that number two absolutely that's going to be looking at um the Lincoln area that goes into Louis lore so K4 so um we would take out the current fifth graders because that's next year's um first to fifth grade and it's 32 students that would be in

040um sorry one second this area too um so that could be potentially accommodated by Roosevelt we could look at that the other only other consideration would be is there a different area that could be potentially expanded into Lou lore um to bring that building above that 70% utilization and if it's not area 2 is there somewhere else that would be um better transportation wise does that answer your question well we'll have to take a look at those factors yeah absolutely it's just again from personal experience I think it's something we need to consider um and I don't know if we can pull or or ask families in that neighborhood specifically that might be more on the district side of things um but something to consider maybe parents won't care maybe they want to go to

041to Louie and you know they might choose a waiver to do go up there on their own anyway um but I think something to consider before we start assigning people places and we can get a little more granular to like what are the total numbers in you know what is the impact of that little stretch in there so right and if there yeah if there is a change in that with that group um that would keep Louie pretty obviously very consistent with where it's at right now which is under utilization but pushing that section two in there does push it to the highest at least in um in 1A at 88 percentage 88% utilization which is on the higher range so I I think there is justification to at least look a little deeper into

042that area too Jason I may have missed this basic question somewhere but is the plan then for Guster to be our only elll location Guster and Roosevelt Guster and Roosevelt Roosevelt currently and Roosevelt okay yeah and gner would uh shift right right now Washington and Roosevelt it would shift to gner and Roosevelt any other questions okay please continue absolutely all right so moving into phase two we would be looking at what a potential boundary would look like if um when Washington comes back online if it's a two-section or a three- section building and so the other thing that we are uh trying to promote with phase two is that minimal impact on students there will be the some double impact just there has to be with Washington students um being redistributed to Lincoln and then

043coming back into Washington that's something that we can't get around but as far as the other neighborhoods in the district trying to create a boundary where they're only impacted in that phase one or phase two era so phase 2A where um Washington reopens as a two section we in this case take Lincoln offline so all of that current Lincoln boundary um comes into the Washington boundary and so in this case you'll see the same areas that are highlighted in Phase 1B because this was the best boundary to balance between gner and the new Washington as it reopens with the current Lincoln area in their boundary the area on the South Side those two areas that two and three that we identified those would stay the same so there's no double impact in this case with

0442 a we would just be reopening Washington and saying everybody in the Lincoln boundary would move back into Washington you can think about the difference of the two impacts as a little bit different because it depends on what you do in Phase One and so um if it's Phase 1 a where there's the more minimal adjustment in Phase One there's a bit more impact in phase two if you do more adjustment in phase like in Phase 1 B you have a smoother transition into phase two um and that's just the difference of that student population by not impacting kids twice it's more of a timing element of do you impact these different neighborhoods in the the current so the 25 26 school year or that 27 28 school year so in this case phase 2A

045when we would bring Washington back online as a 75 capacity building Lincoln um would close so that would those students would be redistributed in this case gner would look at around a 220 to a 240 building Louis LaMore at around 130 students so if you think back to that area that we just talked about for area um number two if we take a there's around 30 to 40 students in that area and so we would be assuming around 100 students in Louis lore but we'll get more in those um first sure projections but you can kind of rationalize that if that area is something you would want to move into Roosevelt and then lastly Washington as it reopens as a two-section in this case it would be around 190 students at about a 70% utilization

046so similar analysis here but you have two tables of that student impacted and it is the dependent on if you did Phase 1 a or if you did phase 1B so I'm hoping that makes sense with everybody if you do phase Phase 1 a where there's more of the minimal adjustments you're impacting around 120 students by the time of 2728 versus 1B when there's more of that initial impact when you get to phase 2 a you would just be taking current Lincoln students back into Washington and impacting um around assumed 100 students in that time period and then the last two tables are that demographic um analysis and these are going to be very similar to the phase 1B demographics where we bring gusar up to around that 38.6% frl so then phase 2B the

047difference here is that when we would bring Washington back online as a three section building we would be potentially moving Lincoln and Louis LaMore offline so in this case Washington boundary becomes reestablished um it has the same boundary before the Roosevelt and Washington break but it extends on the South Side moving students that are currently in that Louis L more boundary into Washington as well so the difference between 2 a and 2 B is really the south side of if the building is a two section or a three section capacity so the values in this table would be looking at Distributing between our three schools Washington you can see that's going to be now a 400 building and so they're able to um serve more students by being three sections in this case this boundary

048has a very good balance between all three schools where they're all between that 80 to 85% utilization Washington would reopen with around 320 students residing in that boundary Roosevelt similar number than what you guys have seen around that 220 and gushner around that 220 to 240 number as well so the same student analysis here on page 45 the difference between um the 2A and 2B there's going to be more impact in this concept because you're redistributing our Louis L more students so in this case you have the 71 um current K2 students residing in that area that would be potentially adjusted into Washington in Phase 2B in Phase 2 a you won't see that 70 students because they're going to stay at their building and then last the same very similar demographic balance as we're

049looking at very similar boundaries with Washington um expanded to that three section they would be looking at around a 41% frl so here then in conclusion the differences between what 2 a and 2B would be looking at is really the size of what Washington gets reopened at and if you retire just Lincoln or Lincoln and Louis LaMore and then the impact range in that bottom foldup point is looking on if you implemented Phase 1 a or with 1B so if it's more of a initial impact um that would be preferred by the community versus waiting until phase two um those are kind of those differences that we want you as the board to waigh in on and see if there's a better plan that you think would be uh most appreciated from the community so

050with that is there any questions or discussion on phase two Melissa I don't know maybe I'm just missing it in here but are are you then assuming that there is going to be zero growth um in the Louis lore area like there will be no students moving there will be no housing development in that area nothing um is going to be happening in that area even though there is all kinds of space up there for that to happen no we do have the potential growth areas factored into the report so um based on those like yield rate analysis and those growth areas that is factored into the building projections list on side 20 there's like some current fivey year and 10 year it was information overload I know there there is um so like in

051a 10e looking uh there's a section for current five and section for fivey year and 10 year in my vision for that Louis lar area that would be fact I'm assuming is factored into this exactly I was looking at that same thing so I can come back to you Melissa if you have other questions Jamie's next I was excuse me just curious um in both two and to B it looks like the new Washington school would be the least utilized capacity wise on both of those models is that that would be accurate yes um and that more so comes into Trying to minimize impact between our other schools and so there might be opportunity for some massaging of the boundaries if you would want to maybe move those students but we might get into the

052situation where um it would be the same student population that may be impacted in Phase One and so that's why in this recommendation it's a little bit lower um but that could be some feedback that we look at if we want to try to expand Washington projections Dan did you have question no it's more more of a clarification from Melissa's question I think um I think the future growth is accounted for in slide 29 is that just make sure we're understanding that slide 29 has all those projections loaded in and then any future ones are just basically redistributing students amongst that table that correct okay yes y any other questions from the board at this time continue on I think there's a few more slides left correct I think so just a couple next steps

053so so um this first speci here just kind of wrapping up so I kind of provided that data Foundation we went into that concept creation and your board input tonight and so really that phase one is um the more important for that shortterm input and making sure you can Implement these facility additions um next year and so I want to just kind of take any final input if there's anything else you need from RSP to look at if it is a phase 1 C or anything else there for these next steps any other questions from the board um Dr L I just had one additional thought as as uh we were going through the the second the the phase two options just did a little math and I uh with uh Mr Meyer's question if

054we made that shift from Roosevelt or I'm sorry from Louis LaMore in that section that number two over to Roosevelt that pushes the capacity uh of Roosevelt in the low to mid 90% capacity so there is impact there that that needs to be considered too I'm not suggesting that you shouldn't want to look at an a one C but just just some quick math show that that would push that capacity probably higher at Roosevelt than it might precipitate some other change or need to to have some other discussion there I just had a whatever Melissa ask about the e um if we um get to the next steps of um a new Washington would would we anticipate and maybe we haven't talked about this yet but would we anticipate El to be offered there space

055there just for spacewise you know like with that free up space at Lincoln or how how would we well I I get I suppose that depends on what option is selected you know if it's a uh if we go down the road of referendum and and it's a you know a two- building section or two section building or a three section building and it and it depends on our e population and that you know if that continues the same growth trajectory as now we might be looking at expanding eel programming to every building at the elementary level it's simply hard to say uh but I would not s i I would not think just because opening Washington you would have elel return to that building unless it's necessary to balance enrollments I think once you

056make that change you make that change and that is what's assumed in those numbers so when we move the eel into gner we're assuming that stays at gner for phase two thank you other questions from the board at this time from RSP yep go ahead if there was a a recommendation I would make a few uh different options available you know we need to look as a district at uh phase one which is our biggest priority there's a few different ways to look at this you have an option of one one a you have an option of 1B there's discussion uh if maybe uh 1 C is is needed to be looked at or if there's additional something that we haven't discussed yet that would be considered a a different option than what's available uh

057my recommendation would be if there if it's not 1 a or 1B that the board is feeling the most comfortable with then I would suggest that you make a motion to refer that to the facilities committee uh and then have greater conversation at the facilities committee level and at the next meeting bring um you know I could continue to work with RSP uh and bring that to facilities committee and we could have a uh a recommendation at the next meeting if you need more time to process or want more discussion away from Simply 1 a or 1 B any is the board interested in heading in any direction Aon go ahead I just want to take a step back on uh just going back to that e discussion uh since that is kind of a

058bigger or a large impact and growing impact um I guess I I'm not smart enough to know um but um you know what is is the best model uh for uh teaching e and um you know just in the case where you know is a is a centralized model better um than a distributed model um you know when you consider somebody who does need that intensive who's coming in right off the um the Port of Entry there and they're they're fresh to the English language and they are on an island by themselves uh in a classroom that is it is that the the best model for for some of these kids um you know as you progress um and and mature through the the L program um yeah I can see a more distributed model

059but does a centralized model make more sense in some cases here and is that's something that we should consider as a part of this as well Dr Le well I think it depends on the a lot of factors including the volume the the needs you know are we talking level one El needs versus a level five need all of those factors come into play uh and I think schools uh in North Dakota across North Dakota Jamestown included are struggling with how to best serve that population because it is an increasing in number uh and I think that's a decision we'll need to make as it goes as you know as we see the trajectory of that population you know is it going to continue to grow if it continues to grow we need to make

060a different uh I think I think the plan needs to look differently um but in terms of what is best for next year you know based on the numbers right now it would seem like two schools is the best model for right now that's something that could be more of a mutually exclusive conversation that doesn't need to be as a part of this boundary I agree with that okay I just think there's so many more factors than just with that particular discussion than just boundaries but in the short term we need to make a decision on because Washington is a a a school that's servicing El School e students um and what you know the impact centralized you know to to have that only be one building um you have to look at the other

061impacts you know for those students you know is is a new immigration Center or or a new American Center type of model a better model that would transition out to there's a lot of different ways to to look at our El population and so many of it is triggered at at the enroll you know at what point does that become what needs to happen U so a lot of factors Melissa um I am all for the the least amount of change um and the least amount of transition for for students um I think I be comfortable motioning that we would move forward with Phase 1 a if I'm reading that correctly that is the minimal amount of um students being affected and minimum amount of families being affected okay there's a motion for the bo

062for the district to move um in the outline described in the report to phase follow Phase 1 a for the the boundaries is there a second I'll second by Jason so we have a motion in a second discussion Aaron yeah there's a lot of information that's been put in front of us the last few days here and I don't feel very comfortable at all voting on a recommendation that impacts this level of the community so I I wouldn't know how to vote on this one here to be honest with you um I read through the presentation I understand what the data is in it what I don't understand is the operational impacts and what's best for the district what's best for the parents what's best for the teachers which I I don't know I'm I'm

063just I don't have enough information yet okay other discussion Jacob similar feeling to Aaron uh just wondering if the district has an idea like a deadline of when we do need to have you know a um a decision um or if it's something that could be discussed at the next facilities uh meeting it sounds like that was potentially something to consider one of the things I did discuss with um Dr Le was this is a lot of information to adjust every slide is packed with with data so if the board isn't quite ready to move forward with this one option we'd have is to have Dr luck and Mr gayor meet with the facilities committee and and just granular get into that more granularly the process and then um I I think by the next

064meeting though you know this is going to impact am and I think we need a decision to them also and so if we could somehow if that is you know we have a motion a second on the table but if that is another Direction um that the board would like I think it would have to be done before the next meeting in which isn't that far away so um Dan yeah so the referral notwithstanding we I mean right now we can discuss do we take the minimal impact right now and then potentially having a larger impact on once we decide the two versus three I think that's the Strategic direction that we as a board should have right now so any opinions on that one is um I'm I guess I am kind of leaning

065more towards taking a smaller impact right now uh just to provide guidance to the FI uh thei facilities committee on that direction I think that's a a fair way to move because we know we don't know what those other changes are going to be we don't know whether it's a two section or three section we don't know necessarily how that at least right now we can minimize some impact and U take the bigger impact once those things are decided yeah so what I'm hearing from you is another option would be to accept if we if we would approve the motion and second on the table we still can refer to facilities committee to to H now that now the facilities committee has this data and as they can talk about things in the future there's

066still could be a couple tweaks if if if there's like the on Z so yeah I mean we could I just I just want to get on the table know what what is the feeling of the board so the facilities committee has kind of a an over an insight into that too yes Melissa I also feel that the larger impact once a new school is in place is going to be much more palatable than it is at the beginning so because everybody's going to want to go to the new school Aaron yeah and I'm coming com coming across on this one as I'm not assuming that there's going to be a new school um I don't want to make that leap either so um that one's kind of a a bigger question and assuming that

067there is going to be then that makes this decision a lot easier I agree but I don't want to make that assumption so um that's where I'm kind of I'm on the fence all over on this one here so and even I would like to see maybe just kind of understand what does this balancing the demographics actually mean um I agree that the the least amount of impact um from one perspective is the best um what's the best longterm what's I I just don't know I'd like to do some further evaluation get the facilities committee I would uh challenge them to kind of you know dig in into the Weeds on it and and then get a recommendation of the board for the next meeting um just to you know just V it go through

068due process on it a little bit more Dr just to follow up end of that you know the you know I was leaning closer to 1B understanding that you know the change is never harded making a shift from one to another but the long-term impact to the district of Shifting those demographics and balancing out those uh you know poverty levels uh would have a significant impact on the district uh and how we serve kids uh and that that's probably to me what's the most attractive of one be understanding yes the change would be hard moving moving students around that would never be easy uh we would be asking a lot of our community but that would be a short-term pain you know for to to balance that out in the long term I think would

069be a good thing uh for the district but I understand that that you know making the minimal amount of impact would be you know the most palatable and the easiest Jason did you no okay any other discussion from the board Jamie I guess I would be in favor of making a motion to refer this to the facilities committee or do we have to vote on this prior motion first there's a motion and second on the table yeah I I I prefer like a plan of what you know we can there's always the opportunity to table as well but I I think we need a a a plan and a and and a date so that's what I would like to see Dan uh in that case I move the previous question vote immediately okay um

070Chris you want to do a roll call vote on this one so we have a motion and a second on the table let's just make sure we know what we're voting on that um to accept the phase 1A as presented in the report Melissa gleon yes Owen McKenna no Jamie bear no Heidi LaRon no Jason Roar no Jacob Meyer no Dan tweeton no Aaron Roberts no Steve Belcamp okay is there any other motions Jamie I guess I would make a motion to revert this to the facilities committee and with the understanding that at the next board meeting we would make a decision on the matter so refer to the facilities committee to just dig a little deeper and then meet with Dr L and Mr gayor so that they can understand operationally some of the

071the we we have the report on enrollment but I think some of the questions are operationally and then how also I I think we still always have to keep our strategic plan in mind as well and so and and any other resources that that they might need um to meet with the facilities committees that okay is there a second second by Aon so we have a motion in a second to bring this have facilities review it and bring it back to the next board meeting with the recommendation and we can still have some discussion at that time any discussion Jason oh go ahead Jamie did you want to clarify anything go ahead I do just also want to say I I am more inclined to lean to the least amount of impact for our families

072at this time but it it would be nice to have just a little bit more information for anything that we might be missing because this is a very big decision so Y no I'm I'm in agreement with you and Melissa too about the leas impact and so we'll see where this goes Jason so it sounds like the board is asking for maybe more condensed pros and cons of each plan and the long-term impact of the decision made is that fair okay Dr L did you want to comment well I would just comment too um if uh if it is referred to facilities committee I would uh appreciate the questions that you have because if there's questions that you have about what the operational impact would be those are questions we should be having conversations with

073at central office uh and then at the facilities committee to talk those through so please make sure that you're sharing those questions with me so I can address them with the facilities committee so when we make a recommendation it's the uh it's a vetted well vetted uh recommendation any other discussion do you want us just to email those to you okay we can just email those and um any other discussion if not uh Chris do you want to do so the motion that you're voting on now is um this um report is going to be referred to the facilities committee to review with um Dr Le and Mr gayer and um discuss some of the operational questions that the board will email in and bring back um if not necessarily a recommendation just but more

074of the also include the pros and cons of of of operationally as well each each phase that we 1 a between 1 a and 1B and then the board will take the board will hope to take some action um at the next meeting so that we can let our families have a better understanding of how things are going to look for them in the fall which I think we probably don't want to extend that too much longer so go ahead Owen McKenna yes Jamie Bear yes Heidi Larson yes Jason Roar yes Jacob Meyer yes Dan tweeton yes Aaron Roberts yes Steve belam Melissa gleon Miss all right motion approved and you want to work to schedule schedule that meeting yep you'll get aing get that that meeting scheduled okay very good okay any other questions

075before we move on that was a lot of information so um next um the Strategic plan progress monting we are not going to have tonight we have a lot of reports so you want to comment on that at all or that's in my report also uh we had originally planned to also have an audit report tonight uh unfortunately at the last minute they had canceled so so we'll do that on March 3rd uh as well uh but I've included the updated annual plan so you can see uh where we'll continue our progress monitoring okay thank you Dr L next on our agenda is board education um oh is there oh they just okay um board education number one strategic competency CTE Vision visit thank you Mr Mark Wagner for joining us tonight well thank you

076and it's I think is this on I think it's on okay um thank you guys I want to before I forget thank you for serving and and being such a valuable aspect of the educational setting as being on a on a Schoolboard and I know a lot of times it's fun stuff that I just got to listen to you know some challenging things that you get need to uh decide on but it's so so important and and I thank you as a a former educator uh that worked in education system and also as a parent that you are take such a valuable interest in your community and give back uh a little bit about myself I'm Mark Wagner assistant state director for Career and Technical education um I started my in CT as an a

077education instructor then moved into Information Technology gotten involved and uh did some teaching of post-secondary and some adults and got an Administration level both on the class A and Class B level and then uh became an area Center Director at North Valley the Grafton area and then decided to come to what I always termed as the dark side and I'm at the uh State Department so uh that has come back to haunt me a time or two also that I used to say that so uh but it's a pleasure to be here and it's exciting to talk about the uh what's going on here in Jamestown with the uh James Valley Career and Technology Center um we were here in October it was beautiful here then it's beautiful here again today just a little more

078bite in the air but uh it's still uh good to be in in Jamestown let's talk a little bit about the mission of career in technical education um is the State Board of career and Tech education recognize that a qualified skill Workforce is essential to the economic well-being of North Dakota's business industry and public sector and there's various steps and due to time I'm not going to spend a lot of time on that aspect of it but let's talk about the board state board for career and techn education is in Sentry cold there's three members that that it says has to be on that board and that is State superintendent um christien Basler and also Dr Mark haget the chancellor for Ed and then the uh North Dakota job service Pat Bertoli and then the

079rest are appointed by the governor Miss Sonia M she is a former board member from Oaks and Mr Mike mugh is the aviation a of Mandan um Miss Lindsay ingstrom she's a school board member from West Hope and then you probably know this next name Mr Jason Roar is a school board member from Jamestown and lead by BM is a business manager from West Fargo and then Mr Eric Nelson is a uh business owner in Wilston North Dakota centry code states that we are to administer state and federal funds that support CTE programs facilitate Career Development programs and provide North Dakota Elementary student Entre entrepreneurship program and then also provide authority to operate in governance structure for Area Career and Technology Centers and then provide authority to see to approve post-secondary career schools these are

080the areas that we are involved in the uh post SEC the secondary one areas you're probably most familiar with but then also I just want to mention the career Resource Network we also get into the standards and curriculum and then also educational Equity private schools and and special populations areas ctsos the DECA fbl fccl FFA HOSA skills USA and TSA are all organizations that we support there's our state director um Mr Wade sik with all the presidents of the CTO organizations we bring them all together in June and I've had the pleasure of presenting and working with them for the past number of years and that is so good for someone like myself to see that there is we don't have a problem with youth youth is they're doing okay and we got a Future

081Leaders that are going to be here for a long time so it's always an exciting part to to be a part of our goal goals and opportunities just wanted to touch a little bit about that is the uh transition to a new program where uh reimbursement platform and then access our CT Capital funds you know probably heard we have some new career area centers across the state in the process of getting those finalized and then another goal is to increase enrollment and CT concentrator numbers we have participants we have concentrators concentrators is a student that takes two or more credits in one area for example if they take two credits in business and they are a business education concentrator um study and potentially restructure our CT funding model we've been talking about that I'm going

082be honest with you for six years but we're getting close I think we're going to a flat a flat funding model rather than just based on reimbursement and then another goal that the uh state board has is the coordinate the virtual CT between virtual CT virtual offerings we have a lot of the centers that provide some of that we have the center for distance Ed want to coordinate that and and all work together to make that the best for our students and then expand the work-based learning opportunities through some additional work-based learning coordinators all with a goal to have a future Without Limits that which takes Equity quality program and instructors meaningful public private Partnerships actionable data and then continuous Improvement and collaborative leadership let's talk a little bit about the program Vision vision is

083it what we did what when we were here and the process of it but the purpose is the commitment to Quality North Dakota CT education programs Federal Carl Perkins legislation says we must go out and evaluate the programs it's also a policy from our state board but the real reason that we come out is here is to help and I know that when you work for the state department you come out we're here to help that makes people think okay really but no we are here here to help um to try to learn and grow and to have that vision without any limits and CTE programs such as what's here it's James Valley and Jamestown they're going to equal the success we do 10 to 12 per year it's on a fiveyear rotation everything I'm

084talking about tonight is on our our website also not to go to CTE website if you're interested in further studying it um there select schools through a ranking process uh they're broken into some different categories postsecondary cerent technical centers comprehensive high schools with four more programs and then comprehensive high schools with three or less programs this is a our vision visit schedule we started out at kesa Community College in Fort Totton went to Dun Seath rugby came here to Jamestown had a Rough Rider virtual Center that based in Western North Dakota and then West Fargo High School Southwest area CT Center based out of Dickinson and then we went to the bismar state college actually it wasn't in December we ended up in January because they had another evaluation so we moved it so we

085just completed that not very long ago this is just a fiveyear schedule so everybody's on the schedule schools and Center such as the size of Jamestown we come every five years so what it consists of It's a self- program review all the instructors are sent and administrators are sent to survey and then we come out and do an on-site review and then we have an exit review it's based on 12 standards of qualities you say wait a minute there's 10 listed there they're based on 12 we just combined a couple of them to make sure that uh just was an ease ease and for use to combine them when we did our survey and our process this is just an example of the question here that all the instructors and the CT administrators um get

086it's just a ranking of zero not all achieved one is minimally achieved two is moderately achieved and then three is substantially achieved example of what looks like just the questions they they pick and they there's an area in the bottom there where they can explain their answers um this is an example of the instructors here we just we do not come out and do evaluations of instructors that's somebody else's job we know that a strong instructor usually leads to a strong program but that's not our job to come out and say that instructor is doing good or bad or or indifferent we we do the programs so our on-site review consists of a overview of those standards and self- review with the instructor and then we have a 15minute exit review with the instructor Administration

087and supervisor and then online survey to to get to learn and grow on how we did and then within 10 days we will re you institution will receive a written report from the Department of of CTE there's just a quick example of the uh the agenda the program exits someone gets to sit on all of them it's fun but it's intense I mean it's fun to hear all the good stuff but it's it's a while to to sit there and listen um good thing our super State supervisor are entertaining at times so that's that helps too um so there's accommodations that review consists of the strengths of the programs we know there's lots of good things going on we want to highlight that here recommendations just opportunities that can improve the program um our state

088supervisors go not only to all of these that were listed on the the where the 10 to 12 team evaluation Vision visits they go to all those other ones that are listed for each year so they see they have a lot of windshield time they see a lot of things um and they can share I'm sure they borrowed things from James Valley and Jamestown as well to share with with other schools at times and then violations that's the requirements to fulfill the intent of the law or policy within 10 days if there is any violations um the plan of action is then sent to that schools then the institution requesting that the completed report be returned in 30 days basically that report is action is what who and when what's going to be done when

089and who is it responsible for doing it let's talk a little about the Jamestown program Vision visit and the uh James Valley I'm going to talk about the violations recommendations and accommodations in that order I'd like to end on a positive note and there's lots of positives very minor violations and recommendations I do want to touch on a couple of them one of the violations was updating the coordinated plans of study uh it just didn't match our CTE coordinated plans of study and then also uh they're missing maybe some opportunities for example like one one area the co-op or the work-based learning was not listed as an opportunity for them and then the other one was the advisory committee we have one of the advisory committees is serving business education marketing and information which we

090don't really have a problem with that that's fine if you want to combine them but the issue was that there was there has to be three or more in each of those areas and that there that wasn't the case so the all these things that I'm talking to you about today about recommendation violations have already been taken care of so there that's how minor that they were let's on the other recommendations we uh we never hear storage as an issue when we go out and visit places um as you know schools and centers that's kind of the I shouldn't say the afterthought but a lot of times that's areas that get that cut so we just encourage that explore options to increase space and storage where available to Nance the organization within certain areas and

091then continue to look at the start of CT organizations in the appropriate program areas that has have an impact on the culture and and student involvement questions so far should have told you that at the beginning that you could ask questions at any time but any questions from the board at this point okay thank you let's talk highlight some accommodations some great things that are going on here that I want to just just mention to you um there's a strong commitment to delivering the high quality CT by employing Innovative instructional strategies there's some Project based learning going on uh there's industry Partnerships there's just a awful lot of good things are going on that you should be proud of um to equip those students with the real practical skills you know to be successful in

092the real world um we hear a lot about trades right now it's a Hot Topic we need trades we need trades and all that um and that's good but when I went to to school trades meant that then you went to work right away and that might be the case now but for the most part now they if I'll just use this as an example we had our uh cap at the capital we had well James Valley was there with students were talking about and visit with these young two young men from uh the Watford City area and they were graduated said okay what your plans I always like to find out well I'm going to be an apprentice they were going to be Apprentice to these different manufacturing things oh then then what are

093you thinking about doing goes well if the Apprentice goes well for them and for me they're going to send me to school so what mean they're going to send you to school yep that's kind of a good deal they go no that's a real good deal hopefully that works out so things have changed that there's a lot of opportunities for them to do that um that work-based career ready skills that students get doesn't matter if they're going to four-year you know whatever they're going going into when I was at North Valley I'll just share this also with you had a young lady who decided to go to in the medical she wanted to be a doctor it was obvious she was going to be a doctor um decided not to go to UND UND didn't

094give her as good opportunity as duke did which I think maybe you and missed the boat but sometimes that happens you know that different things uh so she came back and I I asked her I said what was the most valuable class you took in high school setting well I was thinking you know Advanced biology physiology whatever those classes were she go oh that was easy it was my uh med terminology class said really that was one of my first classes he says when I got out out there the other students they didn't understand the Latin terms they didn't so they always had to look stuff up she I was I was ahead of them in that aspect to me that's kind of cool and they come back and they they say those types of

095things that it's valuable for all students um administration's active support of all professional development we heard that loud and clear you should be proud of your Administration it starts with Dr Le and goes down through the channels he supports his CTE people the CTE administrators support the instructors to make sure that they are have the professional development that they need to stay current and to get the job done dedicated and highly qualified at CTE Personnel all of them are qualified CTE certified are a lot of them are leaders and their organizations and take a leadership role in when in making sure that not only is there classroom better but their professionalism is better so I I commend you for that also um maintaining optimal student teacher ratios there's at times like at welding if you

096have 12 welding booths it's pretty tough to have 20 students um you're very careful to make sure there's an adequate um equipment there or or students so they have the opportunity where they can be successful um it makes that environment very conducive to learning it's a very strong commitment that you guys have I appreciate that um in for forging strong Partnerships with local Industries visited with Dr Le earlier about CDL and some of the industries that are stepping up in that that role uh and then promote CT organizations it's nice to walk into that area Center and see the the leadership organizations that are that are available to them but also I want to also compliment Heidi and Adam and that when you walk into that there's also a feel for those students that are

097coming from the other schools and that's important they feel like they that they are not just coming to Jamestown they're coming to an area center located in Jamestown and and they we've heard that from students that they felt didn't weren't intimidated they felt like okay this is my place too this is this is pretty cool uh and then a dedicated work-based learning coordinator you're ah head of the game where you have somebody that's already doing that appreciate that that you've put that in place and and that is in the works we want all our CT programs held the highest standards of excellence how can we help that process and the best practices we use an improvement model how do we improve and we want to work together towards achieving that Vision that concludes my report

098and as you know I'm in the loop of uh legislatively so I stand for any questions I guess what you usually say when you get done making a presentation so thank you very much any questions from the board at this time not even Jason I thought for sure he just set me up somehow with being on the State Board now yeah I got it I'd like to stay longer but I think I'm going to try to beat the weather before it gets too cold too so head head West so thank you Mark thank you guys and a sincere thank you for all that you do appreciate it not only at CTE but what you do for uh across North Dakota and the education and this is awesome to see what you're doing thank you thank

099you for being here amk all right any complaints just for them to Jason right so um under board educ we have uh next on our agenda we have the superintendent's report Dr luck yeah my written report uh one of the one comment I'll point out in personnel there was discussion at our last meeting regarding uh J1 uh cultural exchange uh professionals uh we did go through the process and complete a draft onboarding procedure that that incorporated what we do for onboarding as well as some of the other requirements and recommendations uh for J1 cultural Exchange program teachers uh we will have uh a recommendation for hire at our next meeting for a J1 uh individual there were some additional questions that came up uh in relates in related related to benefits uh so we didn't

100have that individual available at this time um City Larson when I'll just point out quickly um this is a resident teacher program uh participant so you have anou uh not a person personel hire form there's anou uh related to this individual uh and I'm happy to answer questions if you had any about that uh but essentially what we would be doing is paying for coursework uh and uh salary uh which would ensure us to have this individual for three years after the completion of the program so it's it's a really a pretty good deal uh for all involved um lastly under Personnel the Middle School principal timeline I have a draft timeline that we have started for the Middle School principal position um and uh Mr Meyer is representing the board on that hiring process

101um and we'll have uh teachers uh administrators and myself uh in the process has been started last week we'll meet again on Wednesday uh Washington Elementary transition will continue to be uh a place on my report uh until you know throughout the rest of the semester likely uh I've just outlined a few different uh things that have transpired since our last meeting uh we did have that survey that was sent we had 19 total respondents I'll use that to create an FAQ uh we've gotten some good feedback on strategies had an email just today from uh a teacher Emma mikkelson that had some outstanding ideas for activities how we can honor staff honor the building I thought that were really good uh things that we'll continue to work on um and I did go through

102we had uh as I and I talked to our at our last meeting we had the completion of a staff survey uh uh for a preference survey on the 5th of February uh that Friday so the 7th I was able to uh reach out individually to each of those staff members uh to let the each of the certified staff members to let them know either a placement or how we've kind of honed down that big group group of 20 plus things down uh and we were able to do placements for quite a few uh some with non-certified staff as well uh and I've listed all of those positions um but at the very least we're starting to narrow for those that you know we weren't able to make a place but they're not all easy

103uh it's not all you know just moving from A to B I wish it were that simple and I'm sure our staff wishes it was that simple as well um and our priority is going to continue to be those with uh continuing contracts but I do believe that the best solution also uh includes those that have non that are uh non-continuing contracts from a long-term Staffing standpoint um that would be beneficial to us as well uh and so we'll continue to look for those uh options but I have listed like I said all of those uh positions that we have made placements to already some of those certified some of those non-certified um with bargaining units I'm on page three here but bargaining units and there's a recent Supreme Court ruling that you likely heard

104about that uh narrowed the definition there was a ruling called The Hil Hilton ruling that had kind of been a longstanding uh definition of what constitutes a teacher as it relates to North Dakota Century code because it's one of those few positions that it's uh uh it treats teacher different than other employees uh and you know some of that's bargaining and and and uh but there's been a long-standing ruling called the Hilton ruling that Define teachers very very broadly uh and this recent Supreme Court ruling narrowed that definition pretty significantly so we went from a very broad to a much more narrow version uh of what defines a teacher and that's important for the board because bargaining rights could be limited you know based on centry code to a teacher so if a teacher is

105somebody who is more narrowly defined but bargaining in the past was B based on a very broad definition of teacher uh districts across North Dakota right now are grappling that question well do we change our bargaining units then if in the past it was broadly defined and now it's narrowly defined is it beneficial to act on our old definition or act on this new definition um you know that's kind of the simplistic version of that issue but from my perspective um you know my recommendations can is that what we have operated with makes sense I don't see the benefit at this time of of changing what that definition of teacher means uh I think there would be a negative mostly negative impact uh to those that have negotiated under a certain standard uh certain understanding

106I think the process has been Equitable it's been Fair it's been working um and it would feel arbitrary uh without some reason or benefit uh to make that change I think as you go across across the state the bulk of school districts are operating that way uh although there are some that have other factors uh and I'm certainly not judging them because they have factors that they have to work through uh that are making that choice to go with a more narrow definition my recommendation would be to maintain exactly what you have uh because it's worked uh unless you have a reason to make that change or if there is some benefit or need that's pushing you to make that change um the uh the last item outside of Spotlight that I have relates to

107the Legislative Assembly still about a thousand bills um I highlighted a few 2241 relates to public charter school so if you're not familiar with a charter what a charter school is it's kind of in the middle between you know private uh and a public it is a public school but by its name it's operates by a charter and it's creates its own rules as far as what that Charter looks like they have Universal uh enrollment they can't deny members although they may may have limitations but those have to be Equitable to everybody for example you couldn't say well we only have we have no special education students or we you can't do this it has to be open to a lottery or some other mechanism to control your enrollment that's not discriminatory um North Dakota

108is one of the few uh states in the union that uh charter schools are not allowed uh and the reason that has been a longstanding in rule is is because of the very rural nature of North Dakota having two public operating uh operating public schools in a small rural community say bowells uh that would be you know from a cost analysis standpoint from the state that doesn't make a lot of sense to have two competing public uh schools uh and that could happen uh in a in a charter school so that's one of the reasons why Charters have never Advanced uh and and across the country uh you'll see a mixed bag of Charter success you'll see very successful Charters and you'll see unsuccessful Charters um charter schools so um you know that is that's

109currently out there uh 20 or 1244 is an income tax credit for home education students uh 16607 uh 1590 1540 and 2303 those are all related to vouchers esas you know education savings accounts uh those are all uh in that realm uh 1240 or excuse me uh 1540 uh has passed the house already so you can look to see what that one is one of the more aggressive Esa bills that are out there uh did pass the house uh but there are a lot of different versions that haven't been voted on yet um um this is one of those topics that oftentimes you can look at what happens in committee and assume okay well we know what's going to happen on the floor it it it's it's a mixed bag there you know that could

110receive a do not pass out of committee uh and pass uh on the floor uh so so just where it's at in committee isn't necessarily going to help you really determine what I can tell you is that none of these bills uh that you can find on esas is probably the final bill there's going to be a lot of negotiations and discussions this will come to conference committee couple different versions will pass they'll go to conference committee and decide if one does pass you know what is it going to look like so there's a lot of work to do uh in that area before you can even begin to assume what that's going to look like uh I brought up 1369 in the past that is the K12 funding bill uh that right now represents

111a 3% 3% increase and a change to the special education Factor uh 1475 is the surviving Universal meals so that would provide a bill that would provide breakfast and lunch to all students there was another bill out there really the only difference between the two is where it came from is it general fund spending or was it Legacy fund Legacy fund earnings so not directly from the Legacy fund but Legacy fund earnings but that one already failed uh and so the surviving um Universal meal bill is actually 1475 I would make the case that if you really want education savings accounts uh across all different classifications best way to do it Universal meals pay for Universal meals for every student uh K through 12 uh in PR private public um and you have a pretty

112good uh Equitable Esa uh the spotlight that I have one of the most fun things that I get to do every year uh that really tests my pronunciation by the way uh is the spelling be uh we have 16 students in this room about a week ago uh they had a written spelling competition 50 words uh and then five six of them Advanced onto the oral competition and they spell another five words uh they did outstanding in the 12 years of doing this I think this was the hardest collection of 55 words that I've seen uh and they were really really good uh the students not just the students that advanced I've listed here but all the students did really really well uh but first place Parker Geisler uh he's who's in the seventh grade

113this is third straight win uh second place was his brother Carson uh who was a fifth grader looking to continue on the uh the family domination lately uh and then Harper wolf did an amazing job as well she's an eighth grader uh at the middle school here so they did fantastic it was a lot of fun uh we always have families that come and watch um I always challenge them a little bit you know the words start off pretty easy uh they get pretty hard so they do a great job but wanted to Spotlight those students for doing a fantastic job so with that I would stand for questions any questions on the superintendent report okay Dan I I just I just wanted to comment on the bargaining units discussion because uh we did go

114to the negotiations Jason and I did go to the negotiations um seminar to kind of get briefed on what these were and there was a lot of discussion panel the discussion around the room regarding that um ruling and we we kind of came to the same conclusion there's no reason to change that regardless what this the century code definition is we have a good bargaining unit definition it's a like you said it's a it works well for our district and for um the school board and for the Jaa so um that was uh just wanted to Echo that for the rest of the board members too that there was a lot of discussion that we um had last week that's great Dan thank you any other questions comments discussion okay if not moving forward on

115agenda we have nothing under G old business H new business under nothing under activities buildings and grounds curriculum instruction under Finance certificate of deposit renewal Christie did you want to comment on that um as you know we have uh three separate 8 certificates of deposit and two of them are coming due in March um I have called around and um I would recommend just renewing the Dakota Bank CD for 7 months at a 4% and um the bank forward for 12 months at 3.85% that um we have a healthy ending fund balance and we we could get a little extra interest for the next year so that's be my recommendation thank you Christie for the explanation is there a motion motion by Aaron second by Dan we have a motion a second to renew the

116oh Jason I'll I'll declare a conflict on on this as an employee of Bank forward okay thank you Jason so please note that so a motion and second for approval of the two CS as two right that chrisy described and at the current rates and locations any discussion any discussion if not assuming roll call vote all those in favor say I I oppose same sign motion approved B and C are general fund balance and monthly Financial reports for just for your information are there any questions for Christy at this time about those okay if not moving on nothing under operations under Personnel we have approval of Resident teacher memorandum of understanding for Sydney Larson is there a motion motion by Steve second by Jacob we have a motion second for approval resident teacher memorandum understanding

117for Sydney LaRon any discussion any discussion if not assuming roll call vote all those in favor say I I oppose same sign motion approved welcome Sydney B approval of petition of recognition of Representatives organization negotiation unit for administrators is there a motion motion by Dan second by Jason we have a motion second for approval of petition for recognition of Representative organization negotiation unit for administrators any discussion any discussion if not assuming roll call vote all those in favor say I I oppose same sign motion approved oh yeah got it okay Y and then under C we have approval of petition for recognition of Representative Organization for negotiation unit for teachers is there a motion motion by Dan second by Aaron with motion a second for approval of petition for recognition of Representative organization of negotiation

118unit for teachers any discussion any discussion if not assuming roll call vote all those in favor say I I oppose same sign motion approved D approval presentation at the conclusion of the 2024 to 2025 school year Janelle mson is there a motion motion by Jamie second is there a second by Steve motion a second for approval of resignation at the conclusion of the 2024 to 2025 school year for Janelle mson and we appreciate all of her years of service to the district for sure any discussion if not assuming roll call vote all those in favor say I I oppose same sign motion approved superintendent evaluation timeline is there for your information under policy and procedures a approval of policy and procedure number one amended policy iccb disposal of school equipment and supplies is there a

119motion motion by Jamie second by Dan we have a motion a second for approval policies and procedures amended policy iccb disposal of school equipment and supplies any discussion any discussion of not assuming roll call vote all those in favor say I I oppose same sign motion approved nothing under T nothing under other items for future agenda are there any items at this time that you'd like to see on future agendas if not at any time you have something please contact myself or Dr Le to get it on the agenda meetings to be scheduled a health insurance committee meeting on Wednesday February 19th 2025 at 3:45 p.m. in the district office conference room District Improvement committee meeting on Thursday February 20th 2025 at 3:30 p.m. in the high school media center note that's at the high

120school Schoolboard meeting on Monday March 3rd 2024 at 5:30 p.m. in the Thompson Community room at the middle school a finance um or a facilities committee meeting will be scheduled between now and and posted um between now and March 3rd um any other meetings that we're missing at this time on here okay if not um our next agenda item is the possible executive session to discuss negotiation strategies is there a motion for that at this time okay if not then we'll move on our agenda our monthly superintendent evaluation is section one goal and vision setting and section six operation and Resource Management there being no further business before their board this meeting is adjourned thank you everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.