CorpusRecord 215463

Wilmette Public Schools District 39 Committee of the Whole Meeting December 9th, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Wilmette Public Schools District 39
Date
2024-12-09
Location
Burleigh County, ND
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,091 words · about 57 min
Collected
2026-06-26

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001sure I hereby call to order this Committee of the whole meeting for Monday December 9th 2024 the time is 8 o'clock AM will the clerk please call the rooll Aon Stone here Bonnie Kim here Allison pavas here Amy paling Lisa Schneider fabes here John Caesar ready here Ann Hart here I seek a motion to approve the minutes of the November 11th 2024 Committee of the whole meeting I move to approve the minutes of the November 11 2024 Committee of the whole meeting May I have a second second the motion has been made and seconded board members are there any comments errors or omissions to the minutes seeing none will the clerk please call the rooll an har yes Bonnie Kim yes Allison pavis yes Lisa Schneider fabes yes John Caesar ready yes Aon Stone yes

002motion carries I seek a motion to adjourn to SEC exe sorry I seek a motion to adjourn to Executive session to discuss special education individual student matters specific personnel and Collective negotiations so moved may I have a second second motion having been made and seconded will the clerk please call the role bye Kim yes Allison pavas yes Lisa Schneider fabes yes John Caesar ready yes Ann Hart yes Aon Stone yes motion carries we are now adjourned to Executive session and the time is 8:02 am all right we are back in our regular meeting and we're ready for facility development committee Mrs Kim thank you so much um I am going to turn it over to Mr btim share my screen okay so today's topic is taking a look at our Capital project summary uh going

003out five years um so just a little like background as we start to think about what this might look like um you know with the board recently approving that Junior High um first floor classroom air conditioning which is the the bottom row here and highlighted in green um you know one way to look at like how project like capital projects have been here for you know basically a dozen years is that we are now wrapping up what what I kind of view as the Third Kind of initiative that would be coming to a close the first being renovating all the learning Commons you know not all done at once took a few years then we get closer to the end of the 201s and then um you know expanding our our elementary buildings uh so

004they can handle some full day programming for kindergarten and then after that was um you know switching and um focusing on classroom air conditioning and while we did a lot of that in one summer um it definitely took multiple Summers so now we find ourselves where we have really just a couple of projects that we had continued to plan to do um over the last handful of years um in the summer of 26 the next project that we've really talked about would be replacing the windows at the at the Junior High um which uh are believed to be original to the building in in in nearly all parts of the building so that's that's a that's a huge need um but really when we then start to think about well what comes into that next

005you know five to six or even seveny year window um you know thinking of it in terms of initiatives you know something that might be easy for people to you know rally around um I don't really see anything I see you know potentially lots of different things some which are things that we we might like to do and certainly combined with things that um you know we need to do that as we hit the later parts of the 2020s and and and turn into the 2030s where there might be roofs or mechanical equipment or um just other updates that we really just have reached the point where we need to address um so I don't as far as in the in the kind of the process for identifying what takes priority after that Junior High

006window replacement in the summer of 26 um you know that's certainly not a one-day conversation and even not really a conversation for today um I I do plan to be back in the first few months of calendar year 25 and start the process and identify what what do we want to have as our priority and and talk about what is possible so just as a um so really today is just kind of some brief information um you know I have for summmer is 27 28 and 29 I have some smaller amounts relative to maybe what we've historically spent in any given summer um but the perspective for that is that's what when we get to the projections next that is what's available or at least in the Pro actions for right now um to spend

007on projects and then the other the other consideration is is during our bond issuances in the early part of the 2020s especially with the most recent issuance in 23 was we wanted to leave ourselves some flexibility later this decade um to you know to be able to address capital projects that might come up and so I've noted on here um really during fiscal year 29 um District 39 will see some Debt Service expens extension based capacity come available that becomes available with tax year 28 but tax year 28 is paid during calendar year 29 so really as far as when could things be issued it would probably be like late in calendar year 28 or certainly the first month or two of calendar year 29 um and just for perspective depending upon what the interest

008rates are um I think we'd be looking at somewhere of having between 10 and 13 million available to us to issue in bonds um the one thing to keep in mind is just because that's what's available when that time period arrives doesn't mean that the district would have to issue that much um it could certainly be done in in multiple over multiple Summers where you could you know issue three four five million in one summer one one issuance wait a year or two come back and you know as the projects dictate it um overall like um you know I I think we're still in a good spot I think the one thing at least until we hit that um uh potential issuance is that well we I think it'll be good to identify what projects

009get priority you know we TR truly are kind of hitting a period where it's a little bit of wait Andy as we go from year to year waiting to see what happens with each round of um completing a fiscal year how how were the budget actual results what kind of um things that are outside of our control um financially um how did they how did they impact us um those are all things I'll talk about during the five-year projections but certainly what I've tentatively listed here um the size of some of those projects could certainly grow as as funds became available um or or if the need need arose um that's really all I have for today um happy to answer any questions but certainly um somewhere between probably January and and April will'll definitely

010be talking about projects and priorities and um it and it probably won't just be at one meeting Bonnie did you want to call on people do you want me to yes thank you John um thanks Corey super helpful and I I think you've articulated really well kind of the basis for this projection which is more or less anticipated needs um but also hedging that there's going to be more needs there's no way we are going to have physical plant we have and maintain it with M $2 million in 2028 U so I just worry about this kind of thing being taken out of context um like you've given us good context here I wonder if we should we should maybe rename this projection just maybe things we know about now you know because it's if

011you look at our history we've invested a lot more I think in the last 10 years and I can't see you know by year yeah versus in the future I I don't see how we can anticipate investing all that much less so I mean is this a warning that you know maybe some of our U put this some of the expenses that are kind of hitting Us in the near future are are going to put a squeeze on capital projects in the future because that's typically I think what happens I don't think that's our intention at this point I think really it is just an acknowledgement that some major projects have come to conclusion yeah congratulations to the board and and to the community for having been able to accomplish so many of those really

012major projects and I think what um we are simply acknowledging is that that next B we we don't foresee a a big project Beyond um the infrastructure maintenance and ongoing care for our facilities that's not to say that one won't come right now there isn't that next goal in mind um and really it's it's because we have been able to accomplish those three um at enlarge space air conditioning really it's been four pretty significant projects over the last several years that have been goals of our community for quite some time so it's it's really just um kind of acknowledging as we continue to do this five-year projections model we don't have major projects kind of knocking on the door on the horizon so as the board considers going out um for our next strategic planning

013process we may want to um think about what other needs may exist or just simply acknowledge that our facilities need continued maintenance and care but we're not expecting major Renovations of our buildings which then allows us to focus on some other areas which are um super important teaching and learning and professional development and in some of the other areas that have been identified so um really it's it's simply acknowledging kind of where we're at right now and and where we're looking forward as we um think about the next five years oh thanks Carri that was helpful I I remember um since I'm maybe rolling off the board here soon um I remember we did years ago I asked the question about or someone asked the question about new buildings and how old are our buildings

014yeah and they're old so but they're very well maintains as our Architects and Engineers told us so but they're still pretty old true and I think there was a point at which there was some discussion around wow if we're going to invest this much in new roofs and in air conditioning and in expansion for f day kindergarten and in renovation for the learning cin does that make sense or does it make sense instead to raise the building and erect something completely new in contemporary and I think the board made those decis decisions it's put us now in a position that we don't have these major projects and financially I think we're in a pretty good spot so um it really is just a an acknowledgement and we will continue to do this no doubt something

015will um come up at some point but for right now um we have the opportunity to to celebrate some accomplishments and then to think about kind of as we go out to strategic plan for the next five years at the end of next year what what are some of the major goals or initiatives we might want to explore any other questions thanks so much Corey right Stone thank you we will move on to school finance committee Mr Caesar ready thank you person Stone okay I am also G to turn this over to Cory because he has two important items to discuss okay all right uh December meeting it's when we do our five-year Financial projections um it's always you know a nice time to to take a go through this exercise and look at these

016in detail a couple of reasons one usually by now we have a firm grasp on what the prior fiscal year concluded at and to it's been you know a year and there's a lot of different assumptions or things that may have changed it's always good to take a a fresh look so as I walk through um a lot of the assumptions I'm going to really just High try and highlight the ones that have the largest impact um and offer thoughts on those there are many many assumptions uh you know made in any any projections um so first thing we'll start with revenues um since property taxes are our largest driver on the revenue side um this gets the most Focus uh so here here in bullet point one um we detail out what CPI looks

017like which fiscal years are impacted um so the most recently completed year we were at 3.4% okay well that impacts how we compensate individuals through our contracts that's for next fiscal year we're um 10 we know 10 months of data for calendar year 24 and in a couple more days we'll find out what CPI looked like for for SE or November but right now we sit at 2.9% um then the next couple of years the 2.3 and 2.4 those are estimates from um Bloomberg and then the last year is just kind of what their long-term Target is um Bloomberg did not have something for that but you start to see compared to what we've had the previous few years um you start to see when you see number numb in the twos um that's probably

018a little more typical for the long term what we would expect related to CPI then the next area is New Growth um we've got some information related to what the value of new growth is worth to us um that's always going to be a really important component for d39 um you know we get that CPI but then we also get that that new growth bump on top of it and um when we look at you know over the last 10 years we see that the dollar value associated with that additional amount is anywhere from 280 to $760,000 um with with more of your average being around 487 another assumption um embedded in the in the in the projections is our our net collection rate for property taxes so when we look back we're at 98.6

019um you know going back a decade or more that's that's roughly what we average um and just for uh reference if we were to go up or down a half percent that's worth about 338,000 currently um you know it wouldn't be unheard of if any what one given year we ended with either anywhere from like a 98% to a 99% um collection another big thing particularly the last last few years um that has been very beneficial to not only d39 but any District as fund balance is interest Revenue so we finished fiscal year 24 at um 1.96 million and going back uh a number of years almost a couple decades information I could find that was the highest annual amount and when I so then I when we think about any one area that's currently

020sitting at a historical high or in a beneficial position to d39 I start to think about what happens was things regress and in talking with some of the companies that we invest with they've provided um some information about where they think interest rates might go certainly in calendar year 25 and 26 and so what I've got in here is I've listed out what I've done with the projections for interest Revenue um that fiscal year 25 budgets a million eight and then I've kind of stepped it down um 26 and 27 based upon what the economists are projecting the likelihood of rate Cuts over the next couple of calendar years and then after that we're just kind of regressing back to what um our historical average is which is almost a 20-year average of 492,000 um

021one thing to note which shouldn't be a surprise all the years within this projection um do not have any Revenue related to keep 39 fees since the district will be offering a full day uh program starting this upcoming fall um and then state and federal level generally speaking uh very very flat not a lot of a Assumption of of of receiving help from from either of those sources and then the last big Revenue area is somewhat similar to interest Revenue where you know things had been relatively stable corporate personal property property replacement taxes um you know coming out of the pandemic we really shot up um it was not uncommon for us to have five6 700,000 a year in revenue on the sign item and then all of a sudden we were at a million5

022for a couple of years um the last last year and then for this current year we we are starting to see a downward trajectory um I had at the time of the fiscal year 25 budget we had not yet received any information from the ill Department of Revenue um and so I had actually set the fiscal year 25 budget below what we had collected in fiscal year 24 and yet that was not enough that was not enough of a decline to uh mirror what um the only Department Revenue has for us they've got us at barely over 700,000 now so you think about you know a me kind of a meteor meteoric rise and nearly doubling this Revenue item and now we're um you know basically reverting to what we were prior to that to

023that Rise um so in this projections I've got it set at 730,000 um you know certainly if economics were to change within the state that's an area that that could go up um I'm not sure that I see much more of a a downward trajectory for this line item compared to what it is um now switching to the expenditure assumptions uh so on the expenditure side salary and benefits are going to be our biggest cost thankfully we we've um you know have some settled years with our contracts particularly with we so we've got three out of the five years in this projections um we know what our our settled rates will be we can make some assumptions um less so with SSU or Beyond this fiscal year we just have one more year um before

024we would need to be negotiate again another big thing that can can uh offer some some savings is when those certified staff members retire um so I've listed out for the for the fiscal years um within the projections those are the number of known certified staff retirements um the year that we just uh the fiscal year that we're in right now um saw a huge benefit because we had I think 12 or 13 staff members retire and so that that was that was a huge savings for the budget for this current year health insurance cost we have um you know seen fluctuations above and below 5% we've got 5% in there um our most recent renewal was was a good one compared to the prior couple of years um but you know we're part of

025a co-op and um the group takes a look at potential changes and and tries to actively manage what um things that what things that we can do to to keep that annual rate at a reasonable level and then as we start to think about the non non Personnel cost um we have things like purchase services we have supplies and materials including utilities and then we have you know tuition costs for outplaced students or or Capital outlay um in each of those areas generally speaking we're we're assuming uh increases anywhere from like two to three and a half percent things that would typically mirror inflation uh maybe an outlier to that is our um Insurance renewals for liability and workers comp um those have tend to run higher and we um are assuming ranges of 5

026to 8% so those are a lot of the higher level assumptions now let's take a look at what does the operating funds which is the focus of doing this exercise what is the operating funds um percentage of expenditures look like with with with these projections so we've got four years of of known information known fiscal years that that are completed so the most recent one finishing at roughly 52.3% um based upon solely the fiscal year 25 budget 45.45% and then as you can see um you know things di down a little bit but we're still above 40% in in the remaining years one thing to keep in mind as they start to you know talk about certain areas uh you know doing these projections there's always some level of conservativeness you know embedded in there

027um you know particularly we think about fiscal year 25 were not quite to the halfway point um but when I look at the budget to actual I certainly feel very good about where we're at right now and I would expect us to end with a positive budget variance once again um still too early to make any predictions about how large that might be um but certainly I would expect the positive variance coming out of fiscal year 25 which would uh you know impact each of these percentages in in a positive manner all right this particular uh summary is the operating funds it's revenue and expenditures at a very high level um very similar uh to the two to two pages ago one couple of things I'd like to point out um when I look at

028this part page in particular the the first two line items that I look at every single time Surplus deficit which is just revenues minus expenditures I want to know like where how are we doing there um couple of reasons because then when we go to these red numbers where it's the other financing uses we have committed to spending a million dollars of operating funds to repay principal and interest on our debt certificates so we want that Surplus and deficit to always be above a million um and then that then we after we take out the transfers we then get to our other financing um sources in uses Surplus and deficit um that number includes transfers out for those debt certificates plus any transfers that we move from the operating funds to the capital projects fund

029to pay for those larger construction projects um so as you can see these amounts uh you know they they are in many ways the driver of having some smaller capital projects in those out years as I said the one caveat is I have not Incorporated you know any bond issue on them out which would allow us to tackle several projects um but I I I had wanted to create these with without that Bond issuance being in there um and as you can see as that Surplus deficit starts to to whittle down part of that is um you know interest rate Revenue regressing um and just general conservativeness um you know as I look at a page like this my focus is really um fiscal years 26 and 27 thinking about what information that um has

030the highest likelihood of of coming true and then thinking about you know the the back years are they're definitely important to be aware of but the reality is we're going to make so many decisions um operationally financially that you know they're more of a FYI from my perspective um versus anything else here's the just the revenues of the operating funds um breaks it down a little bit more you can see you know cppt has its own line evidence-based funding and then some of the other state revenue um that are embedded in there and then at the bottom you see that um that graph that really illustrates that you know 83% of our our money is coming from property taxes and then when you look at some of the other local sources um you know we're

031heavily dependent upon what happens within the d39 boundaries and then on the expenditure side uh very similar as well not surprising salary and benefits up near that 80% Mark um these are each of the object areas salary benefit and then you know purchase service supplies and materials being our our two biggest other areas um one last thing I want to show even the um I have more documents for for people want to look at it by fund um this graph shows the top half is um five years of actual with our budget for fiscal year 25 always great to see um revenues exceeding expenditures in every year and then even as we look out into our projected years um still great to see that revenues and expenditures um revenues exceed expenditures in each of those

032years uh at this point I'm happy to answer any questions anyone has about any aspect of this or like I said there's so many assumptions that go into it you can you you know literally make you know 100 variations if if you really wanted to scoring that was excellent that's a lot any questions thoughts comments yeah I'll just say thank you this is a lot of work and it shows um prudence and so I just really appreciate that yeah super yeah sorry yeah no I agree with Aaron and I think when I was reading through it um I was glad when I saw the revenue summary and the revenue going up because when you go through all of the points in terms of Revenue they're all flat to down with the exception of new growth

033and then when you walk through all of the expenses they're flat to up with the exception of the retiring teachers so I'm like oh boy this is painting a um could paint a difficult story but again to your point Corey of the um amount that's driven by those T tax dollars so I was glad to see the revenue going up um and um again just appreciate the um careful conservative planning anyone else um I I have I have a couple um so so that was I I loved your slide about evidence-based funding and I think my recollection on how the evidence-based funding reform worked was that we were frozen B more or less as a district and how much subsidy our district got from the state so and that looked Frozen in the projections yeah

034we it's been really consistent since that's been implemented you know we're in that depending on how you look at highest or last tier of like getting yeah F like we're going to get the least amount and all the districts that are in ours you know they're giving us something but it's I think yeah they're giving us like an extra so we're at 2.8 million they're giving us an extra one or 2,000 total each fiscal year right and I I honestly believe the only reason they're doing that is so they can say that every District got yeah some new money right but it was yeah if you were in if you were the complete opposite right where you were heavily relyant yeah you're getting huge increases yeah um okay so this gets me to my related

035question so is it I didn't forgive me for not saying it what what per are we at now in local resources paying for the districts oh I'd have to look that up but I'm pretty sure we're up over a hundred based upon their calculation no I'm saying I'm saying like what for property taxes and oh what percent are are we in the 80s 90s so property taxes like based upon the the operating funds property taxes are 83 but when you add in like local fees replacement taxes um things that are considered local sources uh it usually ends up being a little over 90% and it'll probably go up state funding what it is right right it should go up desire percentage would go up because yeah long term I would expect that to incrementally slowly

036since we're already over 90 yeah yeah it'll slowly slowly go up until something else changes that's a I had it is it's amaz I mean it amazes me because you look at how I've done a little bit of research on on how other states fund their schools and we were I think the re one of the reasons we did evidence-based funding in the state was to provide more State support to less um less economically U supported districts basically and so my understanding is that's working which is good um but it also results in Lo more local resources being needed to fund the district so I was thinking about Ann's question you know it's at some point it's yeah I don't know it'll be in the future who knows be Illinois would have to totally change

037its model who knows or a far future for there to be any issues okay thank you that's all I right all right let me reshare my screen and we'll go to the last the other topic under the school finance committee then is transportation starting to look at that so Corey will lead us through that discussion as well okay all right so uh regular Transportation so we've talked about this several times last few years um I wanted to so to the goal of today is not necessarily to make any decisions certainly the board can provide feedback or direction as they so choose but that's not necessarily the goal today um I plan to come back hopefully January or February but targeting January where we would present all student fees and the board could take one holistic

038view of everything before they're um making making decisions on what fees might look like for the 25 26 school year but related to Transportation um I wanted the board just at least to have some information and there's one thing that um I will ask as we get get near the end Okay so we've got a history of actual expenditures versus fees collected we've always taken a look at what is that Surplus or loss well each of these years it's it's been the program has been a loss um and so when we look over here on the right hand side where we've got the round trip on the oneway bus fee going back a few years when we realized that we were you know in the neighborhood of 60% of covering our cost you know I

039remember the conversation was we we we could do one massive jump or knowing that demand for the bus may be impacted by the price we decided to make some incremental steps and as we increase from 575 to 695 and then 792 okay yes we certainly made um some improvement in the percentage of fees covered ending fiscal year 24 at 68 a little over 68% covered by writer fees um then then we we have a 20% increase in roughly a 20% increase in the fees charged to the right iders for this current school year and what I've got for the 2425 line is um some estimated expenditures based upon the number of routes and what we've seen in our what we've been build by Northshore so far and so I see we're looking at 981 thou

040a little roughly 981 th000 then on the revenue side um we've collected you know the overwhelming majority of our fees and when I look at where I would anticipate us and it's roughly 759 th000 okay so now our deficit is 222,000 it's dropped by 100,000 and we're covering 77% well couple of factors are in play here when I look at this yes Revenue has gone up but it didn't go up 20% so we definitely lost wrers and I'll get to that in a little bit but the other thing that is uh impacting that equation in in a big way is historically when we've offered sign up starting in the spring to our families what what we've said is if you would like to ride the bus sign up by like the middle of July and

041we'll put you on a bus we've had no capacity constraints no mileage requirements of like how far you can how close you can be to a school or how far away you have to be from a school and once all those data points come in we create the routes and that drives the number of buses that we need getting kids to school you know on time and and going to school for 23 24 fiscal year we had 14 round trip or 14 buses morning and morning and afternoon for this year we have TW 12 and what I call 12 and a half we have 12 in the morning and 13 in the evening so that like is helping to hold down our our expenditure site and that's you know worth a little over 100,000 um

042which is why the with a six and a quarter percent increase in our cost we actually are expecting it to end with lower cost okay so then I looked ahead to next year which we're not necessarily trying to make a decision today on but I've assumed let's just say it's 4 and a half% increase in cost and then we didn't do anything with fees um you would see that we would be dropping assuming that got the same number of writers our our percent of fees would would drop a little bit all right so let's look at a couple other factors um here are the writers at least that I've tracked the last few years um not a lot of of as we made some of those prior price adjustments things were were were fairly similar

043um and while we did drop this year um a couple of things that I I find noteworthy um that is roughly in the neighborhood of i' say a 10% drop in in writers um when we did sign up you know at some point I think we were as we were making these incremental increases in the writer fees at some point I think the board and administration was certainly thinking at some point we will hit a wall and demand for the bus May plummet and certainly when we had our initial sign up I thought maybe we had hit that point um but then at what often happens is in that period from roughly say July 15th through the start of the school year or even like a week or two into school as families go from

044elementary to high Crest or high Crest to Junior High they realize I want the bus and so in the past we've had anywhere from like 30 to 50 like weight listed families where we let the right the rout the routes mature a couple of weeks before we start which usually equates to right after Labor day where we process anybody who is weight listed well this year that was up around like 150 may actually be a little bit more than that so that 150 then got us more to where we're we're at now with with the 950 um you know was that you know I feel like the communications were similar was it slowly the price was it people that just just missed it I don't know but we certainly now have enough data to know

045that like yeah we have decreased writers um so that certainly plays into the decision as we start to think about what my options look like for next year one other thing I wanted to out um round trip just because I know we've talked about it in the past at the current rates roundtrip is $540 a day and in one way is $323 um and then one other thing I wanted to point out before I get into the one question that I I do look for direction today I wanted to to point out um just like how we pay for pay for the busing so this page right here is from our contract our one-ear contract extension I signed last spring or winter um top right you see like the rate per bus per day so

046one of the interesting things is if you think about it from the bus company standpoint nearly all their cost once a bus goes out that's like having the bus having the driver it's expens like from their perspective is expensive now whether that bus driver goes out to say an elementary school and does one route right they pick up one route of kids drop them off and then they go back to their their bus station then they do the same thing in the afternoon that's considered a single tier well that's almost $430 but if we do a double tier which is the majority of our routes it's only an extra $13 and then if you go to a triple tier which we have some of those as well that's only another $13 so there's certainly advantages

047and just for reference um for the regular Ed we have three routes or three buses that do three tiers morning and afternoon we have seven buses that do two tiers morning and afternoon then we have just two buses that do one tier um so it gives you an idea of like where the where the cost savings are so tier means like doing two routes so like I'll give you an example so we like clearly the and I'll give you uh the amounts annual amounts just to give you a reference point a single tier bus for the whole year right 176 days is 75374 but a double tier bus is 77,6 76 and then a three-tier bus is 78825 so like you know on an annual basis like it it definitely is in our interest to

048have those double and triple tier routes and just for reference of like what that might look like I'm just taking one that Services the the older kids Cory and a tier means what what what does it mean to be a single tier versus a double tier like what is that bus actually doing for us right so so here's an example from from from the junior high and and high crust so in the morning a three- tiered bus it goes out does a route picks up um students for band then as soon as it drops them off it goes back out does a route for junior high drops them off at Junior High then it goes out and picks up another group of kids and takes them to high high Crest so it does three essentially

049tier equals equals distinct routes um so you get an idea of like adding or deleting routes can have a very large impact on the overall equation um which I guess brings me to to the next question so when I think about where we have been with contracts um we have the last several years at least since more or less I've been here we've been able to go year to year and we could certainly do that again um but one of the things I had been planning to do is for regular Transportation knowing where we're at where the markets at it feels like we have as I saw with the inflation um you know things have started to level out that's at least the feeling um it feels like the right thing to do is to

050go out to bid the benefit of that is it allows for a multi-year a you get potentially competition from another vendor or vendors and you can have multi-year agreement right so like we from our perspective the the interesting thing or the thing I would like about that is as we try to identify like what are we doing or what is how are we going to plan for this is it would give us some C cost certainty and we know what it is for either a three or four or five year period whatever we so choose um as far as length um that said as I'm preparing those documents and getting ready to send that out to to potential vendors I feel like if we were going to do something different more than a minor tweak

051than what we're doing now I would I feel like it would the right thing to do would be to incorporate that into the bid documents and so what I'm asking I guess is given what I've shared with the finances and some of the incremental adjustments um you know we're we're we are certainly limited on the revenue side but on the expenditure side you could probably do things to get that percentage to be where I think most of us would like it to be but when I look at the distance that our writers live you would essentially be to get it to be meaningful and to you would have to eliminate um service to to the younger kids that's essentially where so that's so like when I think about you know steps that could be taken

052that's really what I want to know from the board is that something that the board views as like on the table or do we not feel like we have reached that point yet or or you know reached that point and if that's the case then I can just proceed and drop documents similar to what we have um had in the past okay so there's so much there Cory so I think um so yeah do you want to say something car I could rephrase the question yeah so I think really what we're looking at is going out to Bid And it before doing that um we know that the board's goal is to reduce the subsidy that the board is paying for a user service yeah we can continue to proceed as we've been doing um

053incrementally small incremental adjustments through con with the increase of costs increasing fees um and and trying to offset a bit of that subsidy the reality is we won't be able to get to reduce that subsidy significantly unless we change how we provide service and so what Corey is asking is do you is it is it is it the board's desire to really focus on reducing that subsidy in which case we have to look at ch more significant changes to how we provide service meaning reducing those who are eligible to ride period That's one option the other option is just continue to just make small incremental changes toward reducing the subsidy recognizing that really it it's going to be small there isn't much opportunity to adjust um by just changing fees alone because you you don't

054feel like you can change the fees because you'll lose all the writers I mean like PR price right we could we could increase the fees to just match exactly what the cost of service is and we predict that that would reduce the number of people wanting to use the service and in that interim will end up not really reducing the subsidy right because there'll be fewer Riders to offset the cost so we have to set the cost not knowing how many people will sign up for it okay so right right we could just simply say this is what we estimate the cost to be this is how many riders we estimate that we will get here's the fee and we think what will end up happening is we'll end up with about the same percentage

055of subsidy so so that's that's really to really make a big dent in the subsidy that the board pays for this user service we would have to change the way we provide service and from our brainstorming and consultation with other districts and the bus company the way to do that really would be to say you're not allowed to ride the bus if you live closer than a mile or closer than a half a mile we're just not making the service available to you many districts do that that hasn't been our district stance in the past and so if it's the board's priority to reduce the subsidy we would have to dramatically change how we provide service okay yeah it doesn't feel dramatic to you it would feel dramatic to those who are accustomed to putting

056their child on a bus to school to get to school from their house that is three4 of a mile away from school in our community they've relied on that bus service for a while so it will feel like a significant change to those families whoever relied on that service in other communities it might not feel so significant because they're maybe not getting bus service to start with but here we've we've made bus service available to anyone who wants to sign up um we know the percentage of families that are less than a mile that euse the bus I mean are we talking five families or 20% no no no no so when I've looked at yeah when I've looked at this um well we'll just start with the was threshold because we were kicking around

057um let me find my so for half mile like that like in some other districts that was like something that Dr km SCH and I talked about because in some places like they don't even offer I think where where I previously worked didn't even offer it was actually way less than I thought so at a half mile or less Harper and high Crest had zero McKenzie Central and Junior High each had one and Ramona had five so there's say those numbers again har High yep McKenzie Central Junior High each had one one person one family one one individual one individual who rides the bus for less than half a mile yeah Ramon and Ramona had five um so like that's there but then when we start to talk about it in the context of routes

058so really then the next um thing is you know if you were to go between like a half mile and say a mile and a half um you really got to go to like move the needle where you're you would eliminate routes you have to like push it up over a mile like I think it's closer to a mile and a half and what generally would happen is the lower the lower the elementary schools would not have service and at the 5'8 level it would really be people who just live far east and Far West and um which at the 58 level that it that does make up a huge portion of those writers but um that's roughly where where it works out because like you could go up to a mile but then you

059would still probably have you know five or 10 at an elementary building well you still have the route so you still have the cost so it's a matter of running the route or not running the route at the elementary levels um but how many families use the Elementary bus total including all the miles do you know that number um maybe yes let me just make sure I have the right thing in the mean time I applaud your ability to convey the complexity of all this so hesitate to second guess any of it well it that's exactly five like which is why then it becomes that more dramatic change it essentially means do you want us to continue to Run Elementary bus routes right and recognize that then the board is subsidizing a portion of that

060yeah or do you want us to look at saying kids can walk to school or get transportation from their family to school we're not providing the routes anymore um because anything in between doesn't really make a big enough difference for us to eliminate the routes and the only way to save money is to eliminate a route I have a related sorry um is there like a safety issue with I mean do we have a preference between kids riding the bus and not riding the bus I'm just thinking in terms of what the principles can manage in the morning that kind of thing I think that um buses bring about some benefits and some drawbacks okay I think if if we didn't have buses there would be much longer car poool lines yeah right um at

061arrival and dismissal and that can be a headache but managing bus service can be a headache as well um so you know I think there's probably benefits and drawbacks either way not a strong enough opinion I could certainly gather additional information but probably not a strong enough opinion to guide the board's um decision- making in this regard it it um there's benefits and drawbacks busing can be quite a headache to manage at a building level right when do we have to make a decision well so really the like the way I was looking at it is the first step is whether this is something that was even on the table because we would want to you know have it in the bid documents if if if it we were something we were even thinking about

062we would I would want to I would feel like because like what what I'm envisioning the process like documents are going to go out typically there's a pre-bid meeting people can come in can provide some clarity um you know you know I I like I would certainly feel obligated like I wouldn't want to put out a bid document and said hey we have 12 and a half routes That's the basis of this bid which as you saw I think is up around a million dollars and then a year or two in to a five-year deal we're like oh just kidding we're gonna go down to five routes like that that would be pretty tough pill to swallow I think for someone that trying to be partner with so that's why you need to know whether

063we want to stay the course and go incrementally or make a major shift in the premise of how we're is the question is the question are we comfortable eliminating elementary school routes are we thinking that we might that a consideration on the table right that's really what it is is are is is important to the board that they reduce that you reduce the subsidy that would be willing to make a a dramatic change in how we provide service which and a dramatic change would be eliminating routes at the ele level yeah yes okay if you're not willing to do that then that if you don't think you're willing to do that at this point then Corey can proceed with building the bid documents in such a way as to estimate that we have 12 and

064a half routes now and it's pretty likely we'll continue to have about that many he doesn't have to give a qualifier of well maybe in three years will only have five routs um again anything can change but we want to go out to bid in good faith um and we also it is helpful to have the board's kind of Direction on where we're trying to move this be um what I'm what I I feel like I'm hearing and tell me if I'm reading the room incorrectly but um is is the same direction Corey and I lead in which lean in which is let's continue to make incremental changes we're not right now in a position or in a financial need to make a dramatic change to how we provide service I agree with that I

065feel like eliminating Elementary routes is a pretty dramatic change for people in the community I I think that would be yeah a big deal okay can I just ask what the sorry had go no please I just want to know how much money we're talking about well the total cost of the contract is is about $1 million 75% of that or whatever so the subsidy that the board pays or it's estimated to pay is around $250,000 right um for this upcoming year how much would you reduce it well you reduce the costs of of the busing by about half and the other buses are pretty well full um so you could you could reduce that pretty significantly I think you wouldn't reduce it all the way but um you would reduce that subsidy by by

066at least by half if not maybe even more because really the the buses that go to the go to High crust and the junior high are full in a full bus you can recoup the cost of running it so we're talking $30,000 maybe yeah potentially more I mean potentially more I you could you could yeah you could potentially get it if those it could be $260,000 yeah you could yeah to me that's the question oh Bonnie um I have a couple questions um so first of all when you um say that there are like 12 routes in the morning would that would it be safe to say that like four of those are for the elementary schools or or how how many routes go to the elementary schools uh let's see here or is that

067is that tough to say because no no no I've got a sheet uh Harper has one that's that's been consistent um Central has one I believe in the morning Ramon 2 and McKenzie looks like Kenzie has one do you think that will change next year because of full day kindergarten or or or how will that affect I I not not likely that I mean the last few years that we've had the keep 39 program we've was it like 95% or 90 or 95% of the students eligible or at that grade level have chosen to be in the program um so if they're there full day and their their families needed the busing I assume they've been signing up for it so well I mean I was just wondering if that if if the because they're

068half day that that would be or you know would there be a reduction in that that middle part where somebody would be taking the bus because they were leaving after the morning or or oh no oh you that service is not currently okay yeah the last I think at one time but typically um that would have been something but so my my preliminary thoughts are that um that first of all it would be a a shame to um eliminate the Elementary bus program um but I also feel like um trying to maintain like this you know or or as we were incrementally trying to um lower our costs for these um user based fees um is that because of covid and you know when you look at these numbers and like if you have a

069child who started taking the bus in first grade and by the time they're they're leaving um will met J your high the cost has gone up for busing like you know $400 I mean it seems like pretty extraordinary I mean we understand why that happened it's because of covid and the unavailability of drivers and and stuff so like is I mean I would love to see the bus program continue the way it is and that maybe the priority of reducing that our costs you know um in keeping in alignment with um with our um with our views on how to handle like user based fees um that I would like to see you know that that I I don't have that same concern of lowering that I don't know how all how you all feel

070so Bonnie if I just want to make sure I heard you correctly you would like to see us continue with offering the services that we are and simply to make the incremental changes in fees but but you're inclined toward um continuing the service and and not increasing fees dramatically to offset those costs not increasing the fees dramatically and maybe even you know like being okay with holding them yes okay like I'm not like that 77% going down to 74% or like I don't really know where that number you know where the The Sweet Spot is but if we were going towards 80% like just to hold back on that a little bit in the next couple of years thank you right did you guys have your guidance that you think you that you wanted well

071let me see if I can say what I think the board is saying and you all can affirm that um I think the board is saying right now as Corey builds the bid documents for transportation services the board is not anticipating making significant changes to the way in which we offer service and in terms of fees we will continue to look at what those costs will be to the board and then in turn what the fees will be to our community as we get those costs back so we'll go out to bid we'll have estimates of what those costs will be and then we'll have to come back to the board to talk about is 950 roundtrip fee the right fee or do we increase that by CPI by the cost of the increasing contract

072which here Corey has estimated to be I think four and a half percent um or some factor in there really that just becomes a a financial decision on behalf of the board that will impact um how much families need to pay for the service okay so oh sorry so Corey are you intending to do a like a one-year deal or are you trying to do a five-year deal or you don't know so okay so I give you a little bit of History um prior to a a school code change a few years ago um when you went out to bid it was three-year contract in the code and then after that you could do a two-year extension and then after that you could do um oneye extensions at mutual agreement forever unless somebody another vendor

073came to you and said I'm mandating you bid well then they changed it and said because in some communities maybe from a from a bus provider perspective it wasn't they weren't interested in like taking on that as a client or they didn't find it appealing you would have had you theoretically could have had somebody that did a bid in the 90s and then if they keep having a good arrangement and people agree they it could have you know been 30 years or more and so they the limit now is you must bid every 10 but they loosened up the they gave more flexibility in the period of time for the contract so I think like you could bid for 10 but I'm thinking it from if I was in Northshore shoes or a competitor what

074would I be comfortable signing to which is why in Prior years I haven't necessarily recommended going out to bid because if I was in Northshore shoes and inflation was really high and I didn't know what was going to happen with wages and other things that are really expensive for them if I had to fill out a bid form I would just be like okay 12% 10% you know I'd be throwing a high number because I don't want to get caught um so I'm thinking somewhere what I intend the form to say is um have options for three four in five years and then we just look at the numbers and say what's most advantageous to us um gives us a little bit of certainty we can plan um but we're not like you know locked

075in for forever or anything yes okay I did can I add one thing because I had forgotten U on on the prior point of the fiveyear projection because I was making a point about state support and what bugs me about this projection which I'm sure is properly prepared um is is that it doesn't count the the state's contribution to the TRS retirement which is massive and a enormous subsidy for our district of unbelievable proportion and I think we reflect it in our financials yes but just not here so just want to make that point because I did forget thank you that's all hey I think we're ready to move on um we're moving on to the strategy committee Mrs Schneider fabes two update sure thank you uh so as the board is aware um we

076have been giving regular updates to the board on our progress related to our action steps and this seemed um here in December like a good opportunity just to celebrate the work of a a team that came together um to look at culture and climate uh throughout our district as part of our strategic plan so this really is just a a quick update regarding our joint culture and climate leadership team um again looking here at our strategic plan this Falls most significantly in goals two and three but we know really it has an impact across each of our goals um as we look at uh the research that supports how people feel within our schools will affect how they learn how they work and and how connected they feel um to the work that we're doing

077and so um we partnered with the national school climate Center last year um for some professional development for our joint leadership team as well as to help us launch a new survey around culture and climate that survey um took the place of five Essentials and we're hoping that it will continue to take the place of five Essentials moving forward we got some really good and useful information that I think our school teams as well as our joint leadership team um used to inform some improvement efforts um and I'm really proud of this work largely because it has been kind of a Grassroots effort so we formed this joint leadership team we made sure that we had representatives from across the district in all stakeholder groups and then we kind of sat together and and said

078what do we want to do what do we want to accomplish together um and there's been some really uh wonderful um focused efforts as a result of that so this is really just an an opportunity to celebrate that we learned from the national school climate Center about their stages of climate improvement process and really looking at the building and the district as well as our classrooms and Community surrounding students as we evaluate action plan Implement and then re-evaluate this is our uh culture and climate joint leadership team again this is our district team you'll see as you look through here that we have representatives from our wilit Education Association from our support staff Union from our Administration um as well as um myself helping to lead this group and and Leo supporting as well um

079our changes this year we've added a few more people so that each school has at least two Representatives on the team um and again these conversations at the district level have been supportive and organizational in nature but really the real work is what's happening at the school level and our principls and our school level Representatives have taken this work and folded it into their school-based um Improvement efforts so um this is really collaborative work at the Joint leadership level at the district level we have set five meetings this year we've held two of those those meetings have helped us to really focus on the work that um we've chosen for this year which is to collaborate and support the school goals and then to identify any um supports that may need to be supplemented or

080um sustained at the district level and then we're also planning for the csci survey which we anticipate will happen just before um spring break these are some of the celebrations that our school teams have identified um at every school we've uh conceived of or folded in this work into the structure es that are already happening at our school so um there's school-based culture and climate work happening looking really at the the csci results the csci is that um climate survey that um gives us some information about where we're succeeding what our strengths are and then what some opportunities might uh be to continue to improve um we're also celebrating across our district at each School the the work of our foundations teams that are really focused on some of those areas that csci identif IED

081as um areas for improvement so really looking at what are the rules the expectations and the reinforcement of those expectations how are we being proactive in supporting our students and our staff to understand and reinforce those um we've celebrated the deib themes and the team that is supporting that work we have a district team um of Representatives that helps to support that work in really focusing on supporting the the connection and that sense of belonging for each and every individual in ways that are meaningful and relevant to the work um that's happening in our schools um one of the areas that was identified through our csci um as an opportunity for improvement is looking at upstander behavior and how are we supporting that in each of our schools and um we've seen some improvements there

082in our school teams our Representatives on the joint leadership team were really celebrating that there's been some lessons identified for that work um there's some school-based um activities and even speakers who are coming in to address our students and and support this um so again really recognizing that um we're trying to be proactive and teaching our students how to be upstanders how to create a sense of belonging and connection within our schools and to support one another and then the other thing that I wanted to mention that our school teams really celebrated is that um through our csci we learned that um staff inclusion activities and celebrations was an important area for us to continue to expand we've done a number of things over the last several years at the district level to try and

083support that but now our schools are really taking that on and trying to build those connections for our staff in in recognition of the importance there for culture and climate within our school so lots of celebrations and again I think the the the biggest thing I I want to acknowledge and celebrate is these our efforts that are happening as part of the regular and ongoing work of our schools it doesn't I I I don't think feel like an addon to the work that we're already doing but this collaborative approach is allowing us to learn from one another and support each other's work these are just some of the things that our school teams and representatives have celebrated in the work um really um acknowledging that this work has been has allowed our schools to feel

084empowered to really work collaboratively and in aligned ways and then to tailor the work to what the schools want to do so when we first envisioned this joint leadership team I think there were a few worries I know for myself in particular I was worried that this was going to be another District effort that was going to direct what was happening at the schools and in turn instead it's really been schools being empowered to um focus on the areas that they think are most important to them and to make um make adjustments there so so a lot of celebrations here um Next Step areas these are some of the things that our school teams have identified we need to continue to plan for csci administration and there's some key ways in which we want to

085look at that we're still waiting for some information from the state in terms of of timing um we learned from last year's Administration we want to make sure that we're supporting that Administration and then clarifying some of the language of the survey so that students feel like they can adequately respond to that um our our school teams and our district leadership team identified that strengthening our school and District vision and voice um through communication and cross District collaboration um are are some areas that we can continue to to strengthen and grow in um we're doing a lot with seal and our deib efforts and we want to continue that um our deib themes seem to have really taken hold within our schools and so that has been an area of Celebration but we want to

086um continue to build ways to partner with parents to communicate with parents about the work that we're doing and to really integrate that in authentic ways for our our students and for our families um our school teams identified that they would uh love to continue to generate some additional ideas for authentic inclusion of our students with disabilities into activities and projects within our schools and so our joint leadership team has generated some ideas in that regard and then finally I acknowledge that um upstander behavior and inst some supports there that's been an area of Celebration and yet we want to continue to expand that as we move forward um and we're eager for the csci results to help us to inform those next steps so again just kind of celebrating and and wanting to acknowledge

087those team members who are giving of their time and their leadership for this effort it really has been um a focused effort collaborative and aligned throughout our district we're um finding that that stakeholder voice agency and leadership in the process and the decision-making makes it feel like it is owned by many and not just the work of a few so we're really um again proud of the work that has been accomplished I want to thank those who are giving up their time after a long day to to join our joint leadership team and and share their stories and experiences and and learn from one another and then um our csci survey which is the new um culture and climate survey that will be happening again this year um as a reminder we're waiting for some

088additional information from the state um because this is an alternate survey to the five Essentials um but we do anticipate um that we will be able to administer the survey again these are the five areas that the survey focuses on and we get these results back by school and by District so that we can uh guide our Improvement efforts as I mentioned we expect we'll be able to administer the survey about three weeks leading up to spring break Break um but we're awaiting time from um from the state and um this is how our data gets used our joint leadership team and our building based school teams will continue to work together to analyze those results and and continue to to build upon the improvements that we've already seen that's it just kind of a

089a quick update on that work that is happening within our schools and again appreciation for those team members who are leading not only at the district level but more more importantly at the school level I make com um I thank you Carrie this is great I love the team I think that's it's so well represented thank you um so that's my comment I have a question though okay which is um one of the things that's bothered me and about our strategic plan and um and I'm sure this committee is thinking about it but I just I haven't seen it in writing is um socioeconomic concerns you know I see deib and and that probably the idea of socioeconomic issues kind of fits into that um but I'm I'm curious about conversations does that come up

090you know because I think we have a relative I mean you know more diverse probably but there is some significant diversity within our district on the socioeconomic level as far as you know resources that the parents have um so the The Joint leadership team for culture and climate is really looking at the school culture and climate um not the deib efforts and themes specifically um but so so that's not this team that would be the deib um team that is planning out those monthly themes so as we look at those monthly themes um those we have taken an approach of really recognizing and honoring each individual and what makes each of those individual ual special so um we don't um so what we're focusing on for example in September our names are important in October

091our identities are important in November our families are important and each individual brings to the table whatever it is that represents them um so it's a little bit of a different bend on Deb than maybe what you're thinking of which is thinking about the the discrete demographic groups that that comprise our district as a whole um instead we're really focusing on building those connections and that sense of belonging for all individuals regardless of their race color creed yeah socioeconomic background really recognizing that each individual um is special and unique and has the opportunity to be celebrated so this is just not the place for that it sounds like um I I think what you're wanting to discuss is um maybe differences in how yeah I know it's it's hard to discuss right it's it's it's

092economic resources of the kids's parents basically you know and the kid themselves so that I think has a pretty profound effect it does it it certainly does yeah and I just I haven't seen it very much I know I know we've talked about it every once in a while but and and I'm sure it's you know I'm sure we think about it all the time right it's just I don't see it written down so I think what you're asking is when we're looking at diversity and supporting um a sense of connection and belonging for all students you want us to also consider the diversity that is evident in socioeconomic status in addition to race and and color and religion and the other language backgrounds um the other things that we think of maybe more traditionally

093in terms of diversity yeah okay okay great KY thanks for jumping in sure um and that is something that we do talk about at the district um deib committee um level and I think at individual schools one thing that I did want to note was that um as we um as we think about the soci socioeconomic differences we have looked at some of the structures that we have in place so for example the club system that we have put in place at um High Crest in the junior high we've brought many of those internally so the instead of having parents and students pay fees for these clubs we've made them accessible to everybody at the school so we're looking at some of our internal structures to make them more accessible to kids no matter their

094um economic status if you will so that's one one thing that we are considering kind of a different level than maybe lessons or um a monthly theme but trying to put some of those things in place thank you John and I think it's it's valuable feedback for us to continue to think about as We Gather input from our students and families about their sense of connection and belonging to also consider differences that might be evident as a results of their socionomic status so um thank you for for elevating that appreciate it I would just say you're talking about celebrating I'm I'm and you talk about being proud and I have that shared sense of Pride and celebration this is exciting and I think the fact that you talked about it you know not being sort

095of like you know something coming from the top and directed it's it sounds integrated if I'm understanding you correctly it it feels that way and again when we launched this team we weren't quite sure what was going to come of it we just thought we should we should have a focused effort on it and so yes very proud of what our teams are doing yes thank you okay all right we're good this would be the opportunity for the public to address the board but seeing no public here we will move on to Old business which is Elementary class siiz followup I'm going to turn this over to Dr kis Coy thank you uh the board will recall at the November Committee of the whole um the board reviewed Elementary class size and some additional information

096was compiled at that time um and then the board asked for some the board engaged in some discussion and asked for some additional follow-up information that information has been provided and um and reviewed and so at this point um I'm really just bringing this item back so that we can begin to plan for the upcoming school year um my sense is that based on all of this review the board seems comfortable proceeding with our current class siiz guidance um isn't directing any immediate change to that um and we are very grateful that uh the board continues to allow for our careful consideration of those unique circumstances that uh come up from year to year that may cause us to make adjustments to how we're planning for the year um we'll continue to study the impact

097of future adjustments obviously enrollment has a huge impact on that um but wanted to Circle back and give the board the opportunity to either give us some additional feedback direct us otherwise or to Simply affirm that um you want to see us continue with the current guidelines board members um yeah I guess where are we at on that thank you for all that work it was impressive my recollection is the recommendation was to leave the guidance as it is which I would I would be inclined to do so other board members support that as well leaving the guidance as it is and grateful for all the work that's been done over the past month or so and the data was interesting and learned a great deal for from it and feel even more confident with

098the recommendations so thank you okay that's what I'm hearing I'm seeing nods so we're staying the course okay thank you thank you all right um is there any new business okay then I seek a motion to adjourn to Executive session to discuss special education individual student matters specific personnel and Collective negotiations move to adjourn to Executive session to discuss special education individual student matters specific personnel and Collective negotiations may I have a second second motion having been made and seconded will the clerk please call the role Allison pavas yes Lisa Schneider faes yes John cesaretti yes Anne Hart yes Bonnie King yes Aon Stone yes motion carries we are now adjourned to Executive session and the time is 10:02 a

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.