001e e e the board meeting will begin in five minutes e e e you e e I misinformed you on one thing yesterday I told you Bryce Wilson was going to send that model to the entire legislature no you told me to the chair and the governor 7th state board meeting will now come to order good morning and welcome to the February 7th 2025 State Board of Education meeting board members please engage your microphones before speaking and turn them off when you're finished speaking please note that board members may be using their cell phones and laptop computers to access the agenda and information related to this meeting live streaming is available through through the State Board of Education website with the recording secretary please call the role Kristen Christensen here Maggie Douglas here Lisa Shon
002Hoff here Liz rener here Kirk Penner president Sher Jones here Elizabeth TM Here Deborah ner here eight present cor is a established please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all information regarding the open meetings Act is posted as you enter the room from the main entrance doors the open meetings Act is also posted on the State Board of education's website our first item today is CT recognition month um nde staff members Katie Graham and Sydney kobza please make your way to the front of the room for a brief introduction regarding our presentation today good morning thank you all uh for this opportunity
003to recognize and celebrate career in technical Education Month both in Nebraska and wide um as you know CTE plays a critical role in preparing learners for high skill High wage in demand careers right here in the state through these programs and Partnerships with business and industry and opportunities for students to experience work-based learning we know we are helping these students graduate ready for post-secondary education and their careers strengthening both our States's Workforce and economy the other week I casually came across the Nebraska super intendent of public instructions 12th annual education report to the governor it's from 1880 you actually have a copy under your little Ed Rising bag um of a few excerpts which are wonderful to read I'll highlight just maybe the the second paragraph real quick where it talks about um an education
004such as this definition should impart both knowledge and skill an educated man should be trained to do something as well as know something there's a Sentimental view of Education sometimes that ignores this important truth and the acquisition of knowledge without skill is not education in its best sense neither is the acquisition of skill alone properly called education since this time and probably before Nebraska has continued to build out and refine what's now called Career and Technical education which recognizes the importance of knowledge skill and application uh we are thrilled today to have Learners and Educators from York High School 145 years after superintendent Thompson pinned this report to share some exciting and more current work that they have underway that's going to help prepare them for their future so here's to another 145 years of
005career and tech ed in Nebraska happy CT month thank you Katie good morning um we are from York high school and I am ree herfeld I am the President of our FFA chapter I'm Alexis Davis I'm a vice president of our FFA chapter I'm Maggie McCarthy I'm also a vice president of our FFA chapter I'm Keegan Lyon and I'm also a vice president of our FFA chapter good morning we are considered the executive leadership team for our FFA chapter thank you for allowing us to share our story in a recent survey of York's 260 Middle School and High School FFA members results concluded that 6.5% of members have one parent that is directly involved in production agriculture these results are a direct reflection of the growing separation between the consumer and the producer York High
006School lies in the middle of York County a geographical location that is home to some of the most fertile soil in the United States through York's agricultural educational opportunities we provide students with an understanding of how agriculture plays an important role directly and indirectly in everyday lives York's agricultural program has three definite goals in mind for students to give them a good experience expose them to new things and hope that this Fosters a passion for an agriculturally related career path in today's Global Society it is important for our members to realize that agriculture is not cows SS and plows as they perceive it to have been a generous ation ago our school and teachers work hard to provide Hands-On opportunities exposures to new technologies and production practices York continues to break the stereotype that a
007education is only for those young people destined to return back to the family farm through our school's initiative and student centered curriculum we have attracted students from all walks of life and academic life there are there are several courses which are linked to dual credit through Southeast Community College both York a Educators have been certified to teach welding Agronomy animal science and plant science through SEC York College and ncta and often attend continuing education courses to ensure that we are providing the most timely instruction the higher level course offering at York High School have allowed students to enter the workforce directly upon graduating these students have found high levels of success due to the current employment climate 2021 graduate Braden gleeby stated I am very thankful I had the opportunity to take college level welding
008classes in high school upon graduation I chose to enter the workforce and was able to land a $55 paying hour job per hour job within the welding industry we also have great facilities at York for example a direct result of student interest in plant science has been the development of the yhs greenhouse through the through which students grow market and sell produce in Flora through curriculum experiences in biotechnology landscape design and horiculture students learn about plant production process from propagation to installation in the fall students utilize the greenhouse for propagating succulents house plants and other Flora during the Spring season the FFA Greenhouse comes alive with over our with over 7,000 plants for sale students learn about the wholesale ordering process of plant plugs and complete the process of planting carrying and growing healthy vibrant
009Flora for customers to enjoy the yor of fet greenhouse is well known for Quality Plants and creative floor floor old design for hundreds of customers around town in fact in the recent best of York County survey produced by York News Times identified the York FFA Greenhouse as the number two best spot for purchasing annuals the first being Walmart through the program our students have truly learned what the phrase Farm to Market means one of the most successful programs has been the imple inflamation and development of our animal science lab our spacious and interactive lab hosts over 100 species our program is Hands-On and students are responsible for all animal welfare and husbandry this lab reaches all students who come through to see the animals including our special education population the individual relation ship that bonds
010our special needs students develop with animals provides a therapeutic and rewarding environment with over 100 tours given its impl in since its inflammation York's animal lab has become a model which students across the state and even Nation have based their own Labs on the most valuable impact of the animal lab is the way it has challenged students to take an interactive and direct role in animal husbandry the individual experiences provided by York's animal lab have inspired great success among the variety of students breeding programs created in rabbits reptiles hamsters poultry and Swine have sparked Intrigue through a variety of students large animal experiences have also been provided through this animal lab students have learned how to artificially inamin transport embryos observe live animal births in person and on live stream over 6,000 views and provide
011it provide further care for young animals in a way that reflects current production practices our key philosophy within the all Labs used by York's agricultural program is to provide the ability to see touch smell and taste the diverse world of Agriculture as agriculture adapts and changes and changes to the growing of our population demand for workers in the trades are skyrocketing during the 2020 and 2021 school year yps made the decision to make improvements to our welding lab as an investment in our students Futures with growing class numbers plans were made to grow the welding Shop's capacity today we are proud to say that through hard work in planning the yhs welding shop now has 20 welding booths that are designed to house gtaw smw gmaw and oxyacetylene Welding processes this lab has now become
012a hub for aspiring welders as they work to improve their technical skills York a education believes in providing an allinclusive quality education and experiences for the large quality of quantity of students who take interest in these areas for our each year our guidance office takes an interest poll from students to help guide registration processes for the 2024 2025 school year 170 students signed up for animal science 95 for intro to a 70 for structural system in woods 96 for welding 43 for horiculture and 303 students in the middle School industrial Tech courses through these number although these numbers are overwhelming as an agricultural education program we can deduce that our philosophy is attracting students to our program learning in Josie Lee a 20205 yhs graduate said that learning and working in the animal science at
013yhs really helped to inspire me towards wanting to go into agricultural education getting to work with all the different species of animals as well as collaborating with classmates and members of the vet science CDE team made me realize that teaching was a viable option for me it's really thanks to that program and the people within it that brought me into the teaching world today she now is an a educator and FFA adviser at Fullerton High School our program believes that through involvement in supervised agriculture experience or SE sa students will excel through application of classroom knowledge enhanced their FFA leadership and increase their Community contributions through our animal lab and our Greenhouse we are able to provide a variety of sees for over 100 students our community has opened the doors for internships and career
014opportunities to assist our students to develop their SES with only 6.5% of our FFA members living on a working farm we have been deliberate in developing our program to allow students multiple SAE opportunities our students participate in year round work in our Greenhouse animal lab our outdoor community garden cut flower beds and farmers markets students also assist with all FFA community service projects our teachers visit approximately 100 SAE visits in the summer including but not limited to dog breeding grain systems Cut Flower farming pollinating and employment at local stores we believe that FFA is a Cornerstone of service to the community and the development of leadership for the individual through FFA our members plan our members plan develop and operate a program of activities that enrich enrich their classroom experiences through a authentic and releating
015Rel relevant learning our program reinforces the belief that servant leadership connects our students to their Community FFA recognizes those students who have particip ipated in educational and community service programs for example students have changed over 12,000 batteries in smoke alarms over 180 homes for the local elderly our blood drive has collected over 3,000 units of blood since its inion our petting zoo at the community Fair has gardened over 4,500 visitors each year for the past 23 years our animal lab located in our high school has hosted over 500 visit ERS each year except for during Co FFA provides assistance assistance with the local schools summmer educational programs through our FFA contests over 70 students qualified for the state competition in 2023 and 2024 over the years our FFA participants have been awarded over 190 State
016degrees 123 American degrees we work hard daily to continue our program to continue growth to our program collaborate with our community and encourage members to continue to learn learning to do doing to learn earning to live and living to serve through participation in York FFA students have embodied the guide The Guiding themes of ffa's program of activities through detailed planning goal through detailed planning goal setting and strategic outlining FFA members have created outstanding programs of events and services the following quote is from a yorka FFA Alum Who currently who graduated from the West Point Military Academy sums up the experience that York FFA provided being an FFA officer allowed me to understand the importance of serving my community and servant leadership I am a better person today because of my experiences through York FFA I
017am grateful for the learning how to become the best version of myself Max coature York Community and administration have always been major supporters of the agriculture program we are blessed with the best with this support we have been able to implement new and initiative ways to provide unique student experiences recently the community and administration have come to us with an idea of purchasing an entire agricultural campus to house facilities custom made to facilitate such experiences and we did um provide you with um some information on that with a flyer if you want to look at that but recently the yps foundation purchased the ceva research center this 4 acre three building location will become the future Campus of the worldclass a education program as students officers and York Dukes we are extremely excited for this
018project to take place thank you thank you um York FFA we appreciate you coming do any board members have any questions or comments Kirk you have your hand up so thank you for coming yeah absolutely so York uh I represent you here on this on the board here and I'm an aurora husky true and true so it it pains me to say this but you some at some point somebody else has come here from York and showed what is going on and maybe it was uh you was that it was for that rich God that's right that's right so you're doing wonderful things absolutely wonderful things I applaud you for what you guys are doing it's it's wonderful the one question I did have I'll keep it brief so you did the new welding you
019have 40 was it 40 welding areas was cludy the driving force in that because he needs welders did he work with you guys because he needed welders um so I think it's kind of been a a more like countywide inative so there's a lot of local welding Industries within York and the surrounding communities I know CL was probably part of motivating that project but um I think the welding industry is starving for employees and so we were able to kind of help with that fill that need I will just say something briefly I'm just so impressed that you have 260 members so you're obviously doing something right and also just that your list of events includes things like Duke mates and also the blood drive which are not characteristically um CTE you know focused or
020a focused but I know that just does good and then it develops you as leaders and people so I think that's really important I commend you on that you um Deb and then the commissioner and I'm so inspired and uh I'm going to ask our board president and our commissioner if we can have one of our board meetings in York so I can see this facility like I am so impressed but it also touched my heart the way you included special ed students and uh gave them access and experiences so kudos to all of you for the great work you're doing a couple of things the first comment really is for the the folks in the audience and the board I had an opportunity on Tuesday of this week to go to a ctso breakfast
021and sit with leaders from our Career and Technical School organizations um FFA and and all others and I was in inspired was the right word by the the students that we have in Nebraska and optimistic for the future specific to this presentation I would tell you that very little of what you said surprises me and and I'm going to make this about your instructor the uh Mr hersfeld you are incredibly fortunate to have as an instructor in the York Public Schools um and I say that firsthand as an administrator Ator and as a parent I had um at the time a daughter about the age of you who was in young Mr hirshfeld's class at Centennial and and at that point in time I saw a young lady who was had had nothing to do
022with agriculture who became very interested in horiculture and is still very interested in it today but also became very involved in parliamentary procedure and had some Wonder ful experiences as a student that helped shape her into being a successful adult today but the numbers we had at Centennial in FFA were astronomical and it was because of Mr hersfeld so I'm glad to see that he is still plying his trade in Nebraska and I'm I'm tickled for you that yor High School benefits from his involvement today so kudos to you Mr herfield I'd like to we do have a second teacher this is Rachel St she's phenomenal and she actually was my first student teacher and then Lily stayed on and added as our second teacher and go ahead and we recently just hired a third
023act teacher so with this new facility we're going to have a three actes so glad that you got that your students can join us and also your instructors um I had the privilege when I was in high school not of being in FFA we did not have FFA in North Plat when I was growing up um but we had it was called vika now it's skills USA and I just want to say and you have quotes from some of your Alum but but I don't think you realize until you grow up how these experiences are going to feed into your future and you really don't know where they're going to take you and so I would just encourage each one of you to take advantage to the fullest of every opportunity that you can and
024also thank your instructors um I've had the the blessing of getting to teach alongside um some of my I not I wasn't an EG teacher but I was in the same building as um my skills USA instructors and it's a very they invest a lot and it's it's a lot of time and sacrifice and they really care about you and so thank you for investing in the students of your school which affects Nebraska so thank you so much anybody else before we all right all right L graduates and that's of exper well we will sometimes we have sleepless nights and it'll give us things to watch thank you so much for coming and um Good Luck I am anticipating that you still have your state competition yet this spring so best wishes to all of
025you and thank you thank you thank [Applause] you the next item of business is the commissioner's report commissioner Maher please provide your report thank you president TM uh first item of business there are no items that have been identified to be removed from the consent agenda if board members wish to remove any items from the consent agenda please fill out the form at this time if any are removed from the consent a agenda they will be taken up under additional business now first of all good morning board thanks for being here and uh appreciate you being here as well as those who may be listening at home I have three topics that I'd like to cover during my report today a brief update on legislative activities an overview presentation of nd's budget and a report
026on our nape results I'll start with a couple comments about our work with the legislature over the past several weeks we've enjoyed several produ Ive discussions with our legislators one such engagement I'm especially um excited to highlight was a morning briefing that we did one week ago today um at the capitl where we were we were invited to provide two legislature legislators and their nde and other nde staff um your priorities and some Basics about school Finance I'm truly appreciative of chairman Murman uh for his work in setting up the meeting without him agreeing to us meeting it it wouldn't have happened so shout out to Senator merman uh we'll look for ways to continue this sort of Engagement uh in the future as well as you know our executive committee has been meeting weekly
027to discuss legislative bills aligned to your priorities they've had great discussions and I'm pleased with the processes we've had at this point and more to come as we move forward finally earlier this week I was able to provide testimony and support of lb 140 a bill which would require local boards to have a policy in place pertaining to cell phones or some sort of stance on cell phone use in schools during that testimony I made it clear that you had already begun to contemplate action on such a policy and that the Department of Education stood ready to support in whatever way possible uh we continue to work work closely with staff and Senators to fulfill legislative requests for information and address inconsistencies or issues in legislation and inform legislative processes now we'll turn over to
028a a brief overview of nd's budget our Regulatory and fiduciary re UH responsibilities represent a core part of the work done here at the agency I'm excited for you to hear today from Bryce Wilson who'll provide you with an overview of the fiscal side of our responsibilities Bry all right I think this will be popping up here shortly good morning Bryce Wilson finance officer Department of Education um all right wanted to provide um especially for the new members of the board but just a maybe a refresher for the uh returning members but a very high review of our budget what what it's made up of um I think there's some information in there too that's really helpful to understand as you're um working with the department and all of uh the work that we do
029so I think they'll there probably be you might be a few questions as we go through this but I'm going to start with a question first and see um if anybody knows since we're talking about the department of education's budget if anybody knows why the budget went to school just just an easy question there no the budget to get a little more to get a little more sense so I I should have just left that out but all right yeah all right so jumping into the actual work here um real quick I think one of the things that can be very eye openening for people when they look at the Department's budget uh maybe if they see high level information on it is that it has over two billion dollar that flow through the department
030um that's a big number obviously the interesting part about that though is um we're going to talk about what these different buckets are but it comes to us from the legislature in several different um categories of funding and we cannot move money between those funds how the legislature appropriates it into those different buckets is how it has to be spent so when you look at this py graph there that's breaking out it's really kind of eye catching when you see the vast portion of that py graph is blue and it says education Aid that's the flowthrough funds that come from go through the department so although two over $2 billion are coming through the department over 1.9 almost 1.95 billion of that is passed through Aid that's State that's Federal that's cash funds and we'll
031talk about what those are in a second but um it's significant so the portion that's left for operations of the department is what's left and that's broken into the different categories or different buckets and the commissioner talked a lot to the legislature about this in helping them understand we have the regular education that's the program 025 education Administration and support um that makes up 3.6% of the remaining budget Vocational Rehabilitation um is obviously a significant part of our budget here as well um and they make up 2% of that remaining appropriation of almost $37 million disability determination is the other significant one um that has almost 1% of the overall budget there at 16 million the other two are um services for the Blind and Visually Impaired and services for the deaf and hearted hearing
032and those are both about $2 million total so it's significantly smaller the two big kind of areas that of funding that we get we have flow through Aid we talked about that's the big blue portion of that Circle we just looked at um and that's the The Authority we have to pass those funds through and then there's the operating portion of our budget that's where we're going to do the things that kind of make sense to keep the Department of Education running we're going to pay for the salaries and benefits of the staff um all of us here really appreciate that portion of it um the rent contracts travel supplies the expenses related to the board all of that's going to flow through the operations section of our budget um again just kind of what
033that looks like in total 93% in flow through Aid 7% in operations when when you add all the operations together the funding sources for the Department basically comes in four different categories we have General funds which are going to be the funds appropriated from our state legislature um that come to the state legislature through primarily sales and income tax receipts um that's what they appropriate out and have control over from the state perspective or state side of things there's also cash funds which has increased significantly in the last couple of years because um right up on the slide it says eff but it's education future fund um which was created two years ago and and supplies funding for a lot of a big a good portion of tiosa funding and sped uh reimbursement that goes
034through the state but um there's a few other things that flow through the education future fund as well but Lottery proceeds um grants from non-federal sources there would also be cash funds as well and then federal funds has been significant in the last couple of years as well well it's always been significant but it's been more um a bigger sh share of our budget with the um Esser funds and now we have the literacy Grant that's also significant there that adds to title the title grants and the Ida or the other big federal grants that come through so the revolving fund the last one is kind of an internal accounting fund um that's not a new or additional funds that come in the department it's what they provide for us to move funds or charge
035offices within the department it's it's really an internal internal accounting fund and um not a significant portion of what we direct or or control so looking at the source of funds so we talked about the The Big Three there is going to be the state the federal and the cash funds um when we look at the overall source of funds that are coming through so that over $2 billion number that I talked about earlier the 66% of that is State funds um and what's going to be really interesting so this is the total funds flowing through it it includes operations and Aid when I show the next slide here in a second that pie chart's going to change significantly and I think this is a key point for you guys to understand a little bit
036um but State funds is the biggest chunk of our overall budget includes Aid Federal and cash funds both have the other 177% um again those have both increased in the last couple of years with the Sesser funds in the federal bucket and then cash funds including the education future fund now now when we look at just the operations so we're taking that big chunk the 93% of Aid portion out of this we're just looking at the operations of the department the state the blue portion of that Circle the state portion gets a lot smaller it drops to 27% so when we look at the overall operations of the department 62% of that is federally funded so that means that the federal grants that we receive dictate a lot of what we do at the department
037with when you see that 11% is Cash funds we making out the rest of the circle there um so breaking out then we're sticking with the operations side of what nde does so when we look at our total operating budget how is that split between the different areas of the department so um here we're showing that 60% of our operating budget goes to what we think of kind of regular education the prek through 12 Education Services um 26% to Vocational Rehabilitation are about 37 million death of hard def sorry disability determinations is just under 10% it's at 16 million and then again two a little over 2 million for both um deaf and hard hearing and blind visually impaired so that's really the breakout I think the key piece there is understanding although when you
038look at our budget in total um it's it's significant in the dollar amount the operation portion is significantly a very minimal part of that and then the breakout between the federal funds and state funds that go out um and understanding that operationally we we funded very heavily by the federal government and when we look at the aid portion that a big chunk of that is going out and is flow through Aid going to schools and that and is the primary source for school funding that flows through us so couple of things that are key just to understand our budget process We have basically a couple of different budget processes that we go through at the department um we have the banal budget process that happens every other year um since the since Nebraska is a
039BAL budget State um each even year we have to submit uh a budget request to um the governor's office and that's done in the fall of the year we primarily we bring that information to the board start working with the board three months before we need uh the board approval to submit that budget um so that'll that typically starts around August um June to August of an even year right now we're in the we're in the banial budget process to the point where the governor has presented his recommended budget that was done in January at the end of this month um the commissioner will have the opportunity to testify before the Appropriations Committee to speak to our specific budget and um needs concerns with that and that'll happen on February 27th and then in the
040May time period we'll have our budget finalized for the next two years the other budget process that occurs is what we call the deficit budget process that's an annual process where essentially if there are things that weren't provided in your binal budget maybe they are things that came up after the Bal budget was determined you have an opportunity to go in and ask for funding or and at times too it's actually reducing your budget um if tiosa came under what was estimated that would be a deficit budget item where we would reduce our budget potentially um so there's we have two different budget processes that one happens every every year um the bional happens every other year any question can will you take questions sure all right any questions or comments KK so you talk
041about the nde operations and the the federal money that comes in how much of the federal money is that different than the money that goes to the schools or is that the same thing so it's going to be both so the federal money comes in um when we have it when it comes it'll come in through the aid bucket that the big giant portion of that first pie chart we showed the portion that's flow through so they some of them like say a title Grant will come through and it'll say this much has to be flow through Aid to schools it's going to come and be appropriated to us in the aid bucket but it also allows for a portion to be used and directed by the by the state agency for work or salaries
042administration of that Grant as well and that will come in the 025 or the education bucket in that so if you figured out let's say we don't get any federal dollars and the money comes to the state do you know the number that the federal do you do you know that number the official number that comes from the federal government was that one of those pie charts well it's it's portion of that if we got all of the federal funds cut y that would be 90 million over 90 million of operating budget and um I don't know if I have the A1 A1 broke out with me right now okay that's fine oh yep 300 339 million of Aid okay thank you any other questions and and so board members Bryce's slides are available in
043spark too if you want to review them later all right thank you Bryce thank you Bryce uh the next portion of my report as I previously shared is the national assessment of educational progress or nape nape was released in late January nape is sometimes called the nation's report card and our report card this year was not what we wanted to see and we won't attempt to sugarcoat the results I will save my comments for after our presentation but I'm now inviting paully Bowie up to share the results uh a little more in depth paully is our nape coordinator um for the state of Nebraska welcome and the floor is yours thank you very much GNA get hooked up here yay There It Is Well good morning everyone again my name is paully Bowie and I'm
044I really am happy to be here thank you Dr Maher for inviting me um um I am the nape State coordinator and I love talking about nape so I'm going to give you just a very brief review of what nape is and then we will be sharing some Nebraska results and some national results the uh results just came out about a week and a half ago on January 29th so we have been crunching the numbers and and looking at lots of information and I'm happy to share that with you so I'll get started get this out of here so I do want you to know that nape is the only National Benchmark we have in the United States um the results as Dr Maher said come from the nation's report card and then I also
045have the um website so so you can get on that website and you can spend hours uh looking at nape data uh that's the great thing about nape there's so much information out there so what does Nate measure we get a great measure of overall student performance for key demographic groups we can see changes in achievement over time and then we really like to look at the differences between the nation and States uh Nate produces results for all 50 states Department of Defense and that is that would be all of our military schools district of Columbia and Puerto Rico and I do want you to know that we do not get individual students or and we do not get individual school reports everything is State reported so often people say How are schools selected for
046NP and I'm going to give you a very brief review of that also um I will send uh to nape um the list of of all the eligible schools in Nebraska and then they uh in Washington DC will with the psychometricians pick uh the sampled schools they send that back and then I work with our um uh data people at nde and then we send back a listing of all the students in all the schools that they have asked for and then they select the students and they try to mirror our demographics and so what I mean by that is if we have 20% Hispanic students they will draw 20% of our sample will be hispan Hispanic students same thing for special education 15% about our identified special education so they will pull 15 Stu
047uh percent that have IEPs and then we go to work um I do want you to see uh the national public numbers on the screen you'll see how many schools were selected for fourth and 8th grade you'll see how many students were selected and then the total and students take either math or reading they do not take both subjects now you'll get to see the sample for Nebraska we had 210 schools across the state that were selected in for 24 we had about 4,000 students in math and reading and so about 8,000 students participated in nape nape is administered every other year so we had it in 24 we're gearing up we're going to be giving it again in in 6 um we assess January through March and assessments are done on tablets and we
048bring in uh people from nape come in the facilitators come in and give the assessment um each student again is assessed in math or reading students take a small portion of the total and we do give accommodations for students with disabilities and English Learners you're going to see some scale scores that's what I'll be showing you um um the scale is from 0 to 500 and if you look on the left side you'll see the scale score and then down across the bottom you will see that uh long range um data so here we go we're going to look at fourth grade math results for Nebraska and for the nation I'll let you take a look at that if you look at the dark blue you will see the national public and then the gold
049will be uh Nebraska and you can see that trend line we've got the trend starting from 2003 all the way to 24 and so if you look at the very end on the right side by 24 uh our average scale score for fourth graders was 238 and the nation was 237 okay and now I will share some information about e8th grade you can see um our eth grade trended up a little bit from 22 um from 279 slightly to 280 and then we were above the national average okay now I'll move on to fourth grade reading results and uh you can see too we um took a dip from 22 to 24 and we are just slightly below the national average in reading for fourth grade and then I will share with you e8th grade
050again we went down slightly and we're slightly below the national average again for 8th grade and that is nape and a nutshell for Nebraska 2024 I'd be happy to answer any questions you have um prob let me make a couple of comments first and and then um we'll turn it over to the board if that's okay with president ire thank you um first of all I want to say that these results are unacceptable and we W won't be making excuses for any of the results we have a lot of data and a lot of charts we could have showed you we chose to show you the trend out all the charts are available to you so I don't want you to think we're hiding anything from you all the charts are available to you but
051I think these charts really sum up and give a high level of where we are right right now there are causes for concern nape scores in fourth grade reading have regressed since 2015 and I think we need to get a handle on why that is and how we can reverse that immediately um nap scores have regressed in fourth grade math since 2017 the good news is in math we've started to reverse that Trend we are outperforming the uh the the nation and the Gap is getting wider so there's there's a there's a bit of good news here the bad news is the regression and the regression didn't just start as you can see from the trend line it's been going on for a while U the another piece of good news our previous actions specifically
052in in regard to literacy were underway this board said literacy is a a priority and we need to make sure that we turn literacy results around even before you saw the nape results so I I believe that we need to make sure that our Focus remains in that particular area the result should serve as a call to action and I said this to the legisl legislators that I spoke to Last Friday not just for us in this room but for all of our state all of our policy makers and all of our practitioners that are in the education ecosystem um here in Nebraska finally I believe the focus that you have brought as a board to literacy specifically this past year and expectation you have of me and my team to execute the plan and
053accomplish the literacy go goals is well timed and well placed together I truly believe we will deliver and make a difference time will tell and we can't hide the result results so I would um say we won't sugarcoat it uh but we will work and we would have prior to this I think this just makes the urgency all that more relevant so with that I'll I'll turn it over and if you have any questions of poly go ahead and ask and then Deb and then Kirk do they so I don't have to look through do they give you a high so we see the average do we know like the state that just killed it and we have some students that are in that proficient area well no the state since they give you state
054information so Nebraska is maybe a point low do they give you the guys yes they do absolutely we've got a ranking okay so we're in fourth grade reading um yeah we are we not we're not at the bottom but we that's okay it's okay I was just curious which state was at the top and which one was at the bottom well there are I I could give you that information and I can get that information for you if you'd like it I just curious just in the fourth grade reading just to see who's well I will tell you this um the the area the group that is at the top consistently would be the depart Department of Defense military schools right if you would take I if you would take them out of the mix
055um they would yeah there are quite a few states that are significantly above us in fourth I just like like the top one and the bottom one just in fourth grade would come back no I'd like to comment on that too I think that's a really good question and data that we've looked at and I almost look at it with my old coaching hat on see what you know who who's doing well and what's the offense and what should we look at running for the coming year that that sort of thing and one of the things that we've seen as we look at first of all that you can move a lot in the ranking by just moving a point or two and so I want to be I want to be care ful not
056to go too dramatic on one side but the fact of the matter is we've had several States pass us not only is the nation going down um in terms of results but um but we've had as the nation is going down we've had States pass us so um we are researching to see what are they doing and we think there are some exemplars I think that's the point you're trying to make is who's ahead of us and what are they doing that we can learn from and we're and we I think we're on track to do that we were doing that even before the nape scores so that's the good news um but but we're also not there in a number of instances and I think looking at that ranking and and not overemphasizing it
057but learning from it and drawing some wisdom from it makes a lot of sense and not to miss the point we'll get you that information absolutely okay Deborah I have two questions one um where does your money come from for your operations it's Federal okay and is it's not passed through Us in any way absolutely yes it is actually it is passed through us okay I there in fact I've been working on a budget we've been working on a budget where see where's our budget um that is submitted and then that money comes to Nebraska okay yes and it's a federally mandated program for and eth grade reading and federally funded okay so that is included in our pass through dollars that we saw in our budget report thank you okay the second thing I'm
058always curious about um is how does I mean there's so many external factors that play into testing and certain population nuances can certainly change the results of a test and and we see that in our state testing you know that there's a very close alignment to economic uh privilege and test scores and that's just uh well uh researched but in in a test site so it's different students that are selected every two years and so do you look at population train trends like and and what would you say about the population trends of Nebraska like I mean I know we have a huge number of students who have been in this country less than five years and come from settlement camps and you and and so how do those kind of nuances impact the fluctuations
059I I'm just curious well I will say for English Learners if students have been in the country one year or less they're not selected for nape okay and you know we do we look at the demog Graphics I would say for the amount of time that I've been with nape I saw the tailin of 19 and then we did 22 and now 24 our demographics haven't changed that much so they've been pretty consistent um and again we try to we try to mirror that when we select so there haven't been major changes and I'll add to that too and we do we do disaggregate the data within the department and look at subgroups and try to see um how that informs any sort of best practices that we have as well can I just how
060do our subgroups do our our subgroups are are lacking Statewide just like they are lacking nationally depending upon the subgroup that you're talking about thank you right we're going to go Liz and then Lisa thank you um first of all thank you for presenting this I know I know it's not always fun to be the bearer of difficult news but it it's something we have to look at to fix I'm curious if we have and I don't know if this is your area um any data on the um the correlation between the teacher shortage and the decline in testing or in these scores nationally and in Nebraska because as far as I can tell our our students the demographics haven't changed a lot our kids are our kids um and so I'm wondering how much
061of this is the result of just not having as many qualified certified um teachers in classrooms you know of that ex AC an issue just in Nebraska so not all states took a dip some many stayed the same some states were went up um a few few States the scores went down and we're all sort of in the same boat so I don't know that we can pin it on that I don't know what do you have to say about that Dr well I wouldn't I wouldn't um add or refute anything to what you've said I would change it I would change the the uh question a little bit to say have you seen any sort of correlational data or causation data that says since 2015 or 2017 we're we're doing something differently how can
062you explain the results and I don't want to explain them away I think that would be the worst thing we could do right now but one of the things that we that are um questioning has has found so far is that in 2016 as a state we decided to take away um writing prompts or constructed responses in our own State assessment and it's my understanding we're the only state in the Union that does not do a constructed response that takes the nape is that correct poly so so I I wonder and I'm not here to impune anybody's motives I'm sure it was done for um whatever at the time was was well thought out but I wonder today why wouldn't we start again um having some sort of constructed response or writing prompt on our
063Statewide assessments because they are students will necessarily be tested on that on the on the nation's report card so I I think that is um one thing that we're looking at and we're looking for what else has changed since 2015 or 2017 to to begin the regression so we're looking for a number of things like that is it the teacher shortage is it the constructed response is it fill in the blank thank you Lisa first off I just W to say commission thank you I just want to say that I am extremely um honored to work with somebody on this who has a very transparent no excuses called to action way of leadership and so I'm very grateful to you for that um I have spent hours like you said digging through the data and
064uh Kirk to answer your question Louisiana has some of the best results and I have a copy of their plan here if you want to take a look at it it's back from 2021 so thank you okay any other question Kristen hopefully this will be quick um can you tell me a bit about how the scores are calculated is that an average score of all the students in Nebraska that took the test or is it calculated some other you know it's just it's average scale score yes okay thank you that was quick all right anybody else want make sure everyone has a chance okay well thank you so much paully we appreciate your time and we look forward to working with you to help our students be more proficient thank you I'm always happy to
065help yes thank you Paulie thank you Bryce Wilson put back over to you well and you probably didn't need to because I'm going to say that concludes my report that was actually the sentence I was waiting for uh we do not have a president's report much everyone's relief this month um so we will move to public comment so I'll just give you a little heads up as we move to our public comment period this period may be available to any person who wishes to address the board on any matter appearing on the agenda up to 90 minutes will be allowed for the public comment period a majority of board members present and voting may take action to extend the total amount of time allowed for public comment period a majority of members president voting may
066also take action to allow or terminate public comment at any time during the meeting if you're not signed in and wish to speak please sign in at this time those wishing to speak must be signed in at the table outside the meeting room each individual speaking to the board will be required to complete a signing card for identification of oneself individuals are in required to include on the sign-in card their name address and name of any organization represented individuals may be prohibited to speak in public comment if the signing card does not include the required information persons speaking to the board during public comment should State their name city and state at the beginning of their allotted time and may submit printed materials for the board but may not use any other form of media
067anyone refusing to be identified will be prohibited from speaking each person may address the board for up to 5 minutes a majority of members present in voting may take action to reduce or extend the amount of time individual of amount of individual time allotted to all speakers if at any time persons appearing before the board exceed the time limitations set forth in this policy or on the agenda or become abusive or threatening in language or behavior it shall be the responsibility of the president to refuse permission to continue to address the board we have three public comment cards submitted and vice president Neri will announce the names of the first speakers please come forward to the front row of seat of chairs so if the three speakers could come forward and we'll start with Teresa
068Franks if you want to come forward to the podium thank you tresa good morning my name is Teresa Franks I'm a reading interventionist in Omaha Public Schools an Adjunct professor at Uno and I'm president of the Nebraska dyslexia Association I'm a certified academic language therapist and a certified structured literacy dyslexia specialist among other credentials we just heard about Nebraska's performance on the 2024 nape reading scores and it was troubling 72% of Nebraskan fourth graders are not not proficient readers and most alarmingly student performance is on a downward Trend States all across the country are experiencing the same sobering reality we know that reading success is positively correlated with greater health wealth and life satisfaction and that reading success can be a protective factor for our most vulnerable kids we know the stakes are high so
069what do we do let's look to Mississippi when I was a teacher in Tennessee we used to say thank God for Mississippi will never be last but my friends in Tennessee can't say that anymore uh in the last 12 years Mississippi students fourth graders have moved from the 49th to the 9th uh rank in the country in Reading as measured by fourth grade name scores when looking at students in poverty Mississippi students are number one for black students they're number three and they are tied for number one for Hispanic students they are closing those stubborn historical achievement gaps despite having the highest poverty and the most under resource schools in the country you may have read about this phenomenal growth the media loves an alliteration so they call it the Mississippi Miracle but for those
070of us who are there and I taught in Mississippi Public Schools as well we know it was no Miracle we call it the Mississippi Marathon what you may not know is that uh sorry Mississippi's phenomenal growth is connected to dyslexia and how that connection has been overlooked when other states have attempted to replicate Mississippi's success as we look to implement the Nebraska literacy plan you will see many of the same elements that we share with Mississippi but I'm going to share with you today so the crucial differences that have led to Mississippi's dramatic literacy achievements Mississippi enacted one of the first dyslexia laws in the country spurred by a dyslexic State Legislature in coordination with philanthropic partner barkdale Institute and other literacy Advocates and officials Mississippi transformed their colleges of Education to reflect the evidence
071base known as the science of reading they required all primary teachers in the state to be trained in the science of reading and made the training free and available to any interested educator in any grade or subject later they strategically deployed highly trained and credential reading coaches across the state using databased decision rules even before the term structured literacy was coined by the ne excuse me by the international dyslexia Association in 2014 Mississippi Department of Education leaders knew that teacher training was the key if students had access to a teacher who was a certified expert in reading with both the knowledge and the skills to teach all students to read Student Success would follow they looked for those Educators trained in programs specifically designed for dyslexic children Orton Gillingham Wilson slingerland debart and others now
072all under the uh umbrella of structured literacy this specialized training had been difficult to access and expensive to complete but Mississippi remove the barriers and set up some incentives they train their teachers to the same high standards and credentials as dyslexia specialist using the letters program at first but now using a pathway to uh incorporate what they realized was lacking in letters which was that um supervised practicum experience and certification the state offers an annual $6,000 stien for educator who earned the certified academic language therapist or C credential becoming a c requires 100 hours of instruction passing a knowledge exam and 700 supervised practicum hours as result Mississippi has the highest number of Cs in the nation now they have a sustainable network of certified literacy structured literacy experts in their classroom teachers and their
073uh literacy coaches and they are building out their own training programs we can do this in Nebraska we can learn from Mississippi success and from the failure of other states whose implementation has lacked cohesion or commitment we must do this so that all Nebraskan children can read thank you thank you uh Joe gber will you please come forward does the timer start or do I just go just yeah all right I'm I'm Joe Goddard from Lincoln I'm here as a parent of children who have attended private and public schools in Lincoln um I'm on the recently formed ND family literacy advisory committee and I serve as the vice president of the Nebraska dyslexia Association where I mean every day we get Outreach from parents we hear from them and they're desperate for help for helping
074their their children read in school systems that just aren't there yet um you heard a lot from Teresa about how um looking at at reading um Can can help Mississippi and how it can help here so I want to share a little bit more about dyslexia how common it is what it is impacts on literacy where we stand and I think how fixing this system for our um dyslexic students in Nebraska can fix it for all students and I I think that is really because the best reading instruction for students with dyslexia is also the best reading instruction for all children and um so let's start with a little bit about dyslexia it's really it's more common than you think more more common than people know it's one in five students it's 20% of students
075um in Nebraska that's 73,000 K to 12 students students um have dyslexia but we don't currently identify those students in Nebraska so um they're they're out there unknown um a lot of teachers have said they've never taught a student with dyslexia um dyslexia is neurobiological learning difference it's brain-based it affects reading spelling and writing and it's classified as a specific learning disability people with dyslexia processed language differently so um when we talk about the science of reading um unlike speech um which our brains are naturally wired to learn you can just be around people talking and you kind of learn to talk um writing doesn't work that way um uh I mean reading doesn't work that way it requires forming entirely new neural connections that our brain aren't born with um for most for most
076children that process happens over several years of quality education and instruction uh dyslexia impacts the formation of those neural connections and relies on alternative slower processing areas the brain for reading so for students who don't receive uh That highquality explicit evidence-based reading instruction especially those with dyslexia uh they continue to struggle to decode words and that leads to frustration and academic failure and the consequences are really severe without early identification proper intervention children with dyslexia face an increased risk of low self-esteem anxiety depression absenteeism and dropping out and really shockingly um 50% of incarcerated juveniles and adults have dyslexia um it's important to know that dyslexia is not about intelligence it's not laziness or lack of effort it's not about reversing letters it's not related to vision problems it can't be outgrown but with early
077identification and proper instruction students with dyslexia can and do become strong readers so I want to talk a little bit about where what Nebraska has done um when we've done some really cool things um on paper um in 2017 Nebraska defined dyslexia in state law and established a dyslexia technical guide um but a lot of schools still believe they can't say dyslexia and they don't think they can identify students with dyslexia in 2018 we implemented a law requiring evidence-based structured literacy instruction with Fidelity um for all children exhibiting signs of dyslexia they didn't have to have a medical diagnosis they just had to be exhibiting signs um yet there's no oversight no accountability and little implementation of this schools continue to use ineffective reading interventions often delivered by um folks with minimal training uh and
078in 2023 just recently a law um was put in place that mandated District's report data on dyslexia and other learning disabilities uh in its first year the data collected was pretty useless um I think as a board you've probably maybe discussed that um but schools reported they had no reliable way to identify or track these students and Nebraska has Universal screening for reading which is awesome but it's kind of optional and most schools don't do um dislexia RIS screening um which should also be implemented so what needs to be done what could be included in the literacy project plan or what could we do otherwise um we can Implement Universal earlyer dyslexia screening in all schools to identify the risk we can ensure that IEP goals and reading interventions are provided by trained certified dyslexia
079specialist and we could hold schools accountable to the existing laws um so um in closing we just what we can't do is we can't wait another while another generation of Nebraska students struggles with a problem we already know how to solve we just simply don't have a knowledge Gap we've got an action Gap so please take action thank you thank you Joe appreciate it Nancy could you please come forward thank you I'm Nancy Packard um let's see am I to say my address Lincoln Nebraska um I retired about 21 years ago from teaching my last experience was third grade when I retired I said teaching was the most important and the hardest job in the world and today I say teaching is twice as important and twice as hard um uh I want my question
080is is there a comparison of the N EP score to library book reading checking out as I gained confidence as a teacher and as my school was about three blocks from the public library my reading program was to walk my kids to the library and check out their own books and I had to of course develop stuff so that I made sure they were getting whatever they needed in the way of reading um in the process of doing that I decided it I had to rethink the reason to be re a reader is not so we can read Shakespeare but so we can read whatever we need to read be that a a car manual or a cookbook or a joke book um I don't remember we weren't taking those uh related Assessments in those
081days I don't know that my my students um you know got higher grades in reading but I did help them I think to become people who were not afraid to go to the library for inst since I told them one of the places one of the two places you could go and you would always be welcomed and unafraid was a church and a library um so I want to just say I I am have recently become aware of the science of reading and I appreciate any scientific approaches and help we can have but the bottom line is when you get out of school are you going to read will you like it will you find what what you need thank you thank you okay thank you to all of our um people who offered public
082testimony today there is no written public comment for this month uh the board will take a 15minute break from now until 10:30 I guess that's more than 15 depends on which clock you're looking at I'm going going with the one at the back of the room so we'll take a quick break thank you just e e e the board meeting will resume shortly wait if board members could resume their seats okay if board members can resume their seats we will reconvene all right okay we are in agenda item six is there a motion to adopt the consent agenda I move to adopt the consent agenda second it is moved and seconded to adopt the consent agenda per board policy there is no discussion on the motion to adopt the consent agenda with the recording secretary
083please call the rooll shanoff president yes yes Neri yes Christensen yes rener yes Jones yes Douglas yes Henner yes Tech Meyer yes eight yes the affirmative has it and the consent agenda is adopted the next item in business are the reports of the standing committees I will report on behalf of the executive committee the executive committee reports on its February 6 2025 meeting members present were chair Elizabeth TIG Meer Vice chair Deborah ner Sher Jones and Liz rener the committee reviewed proposed legislation that is scheduled for hearings next week and advise the commissioner on the nde positions of legislative bills the committee continues to meet weekly through the legislative session to advise the commissioner on legislative matters the committee reviewed four information items the first item reviewed was the 2025 2027 nde Nebraska Association of
084public employees bargaining agreement and discussed its content and changes this item appears on the consent agenda for approval related the committee was informed on the upcoming revision process for the nde Personnel rules which apply to employees who are not subject to the bargaining agreement revisions to the Personnel rules will be brought forward to the board for approval in the coming months next the committee reviewed and discussed a plan for the development and implementation of a new strategic plan the committee recommends a work session in March to begin board discussions on the strategic planning process finally information was shared on a proposal for the comprehensive literacy State development Grant subawards this includes the executive committee report Elizabeth TM chair are there any questions on the executive committee report agenda item 7.1 uh 20 25 proposed state
085legislation board members are there any questions or discussion on this item and as always uh members who are not on the executive committee you can find the weekly updates usually by Friday afternoon as to what the committee has recommended agenda item 7.2 chair Christen Christensen will report on behalf of the budget and finance committee meeting the budget and finance committee reports that at its Thursday February 6th meeting members were present were Christen Christensen Maggie Douglas Lisa schonhoff and Kirk Penner the committee reviewed three action items the first item was to amend the previously adopted motion to accept the comprehensive literacy State development Grant funds the committee recommends the board's adoption of the proposed amendment the committee then reviewed the funding recommendations for school districts and esus to deliver Mental Health Training for staff no committee
086recommendation was established the last action item reviewed was a contract for training related to the computer science and technology expansion program the committee recommends the board's approval of this item the committee reviewed the monthly board travel expenses noting no concerns last the committee reviewed seven information items including the following a potential contract for an individual to provide FFA content support possible acceptance of funds to support the stronger connect ction technical assistance and capacity building program a grant to support the expansion of the farm to school program information on the allocation of 21st century funds a review of the procurement for an evaluation of the comprehensive literacy Statewide development Grant the replacement of the Department's current survey and data collection tool and the quarterly budget review this concludes the budget and finance committee report Kristen Christensen
087chair are there any questions on the report report okay seeing none um I item 7.2 B the committee recommends adoption and I will read the motion the motion oh actually I need someone to make Madam president so the motion was made to P me right was referred to the committee now it's back on the so we don't need to read it okay just what was made at sure okay so the motion was made at our last board meeting it was referred back to the budget committee as you all remember and so I'll just read what the motion is the motion is to amend the previously adopted a motion to accept the comprehensive literacy State development Grant funds and authorize the commissioner to enter into contracts and sub awwards to carry out Grant activities by striking
088this section and authorize the commission to enter into contracts and sub Awards and to carry out Grant activities so the motion if amended would read to accept the comprehensive literacy State development Grant funds is there any discussion on the motion all right I guess the committee hashed it out which is lovely that's the point of our committees so I will reread the motion again the motion is to amend the previously adopted motion to accept the comprehensive literacy State development Grant funds and authorize the commissioner to enter into contracts and sub Awards to carry out Grant activities by striking and authorize the commissioner to enter into contracts and sub Awards and to carry out Grant activities so the motion if amended would read to accept the comprehensive literacy State development Grant funds would the recording secretary
089please call the role Christenson yes Neri yes Jones yes rener yes Douglas yes Sean hop yes Tech Meer yes Penner yes eight yes the affirmative has it and the motion is amended to read to accept the comprehens ensive literacy State development Grant funds okay is there a motion on items 7.2 Point C yes I move to authorize the commissioner to approve funding recommendations for school districts and Educational Service units to support schools in delivering Mental Health Training for staff is moved and seconded to to authorize the commissioner to approve funding recommendations for school districts and Educational Service units to support schools in delivering Mental Health Training for staff is there any discussion on the motion Oh Sherry yes I comment I would like to make because a number of schools in district 6 applied for
090this grant I feel compelled to comment I believe it is important to support the mental health of both students and staff the evidence seems to indicate that what we've been doing over the past five years or so is lacking in Effectiveness this Mental Health First Aid provides more of the same I believe there are school districts in our state that are doing mental health differently and have amazing data to validate what they are doing I believe it's time to do things differently any other comments Lisa I would like to see um clear parameters put in place that ensure that we are um training teachers on an optin versus an opt out program and that there's very clear parameters around um transparency with parents and go ahead I'm sorry no go ahead go ahead thanks de
091so I'm on the same page um where we need to it's we don't have anything on the books here at the State Board um nde about mental health it's a wide swath and I think we need to have some guard rails of what's allowed and what's not allowed um very this grant um very vague a little uh somewhat it's left up to the public schools which I appreciate because it's local control but there there's some things in this area that probably need to be discussed before I adopt or approve any not even any mental health type situation anyone we need to have some guard rails Deborah so I wasn't in that committee so I don't know what the discussion was um but just hearing the comments right now I have a a concern that we
092have a partisan divide and we're going to end up in a 44 vote and that we're going to uh be dismantling an important program that needs funding because we don't we're not saying here's what we recommend we're saying we're not going to fund these mental health supports and so I'd like to just uh hear from those people what they're recommending instead of just obstructing something like what are they recommending this from my understanding is a mandate given to us by the legislature that we have to do and we have to do it in the way they've established and so what steps have we taken as a committee instead of just voting this down what steps proactive leadership type of STS steps have we taken in order to ensure that we're not just dismantling something and
093instead that we are replacing it with something that is going to help our students because honestly the mental health of our students is something that I mean we've all heard the research since 2012 like it is scary and then the and then our pandemic exacerbated things even more and while I understand we don't want to maintain the status quo if it's not working but I haven't seen research that it's not working I've seen research that mental health problems are continuing but I haven't seen that it's related to the fact that our interventions aren't working so I guess where is that information and can we have that discussion instead of quietly hiding behind a vote like I feel like this requires a discussion if we're going to vote it down yeah I I think we need
094guard rails how many schools were involved seven seven schools seven schools distri seven distri right saying we need guard rils isn't an answer that's a political talking point I'm hoping for information about what guard rails you want what proactive steps you're taking we're going to look at this for a long time a long time there's good mental health and there's bad mental health and I don't I don't have to give you reasons or anything my vote is no until we get it figured out there is no policy on the books at nde none there's nothing I'm done I want to okay all right I'm gonna go to Lisa and then back to Deb I think you bring up a a great point um that the that it has to be data driven and the data
095that we requested was um in the meeting was regarding what significant if there has there been any significant improvements as a result of the second step that's been purchased across our state with Esser funds and how that um has impacted student referrals and behaviors and mental health and so um moving forward I think it it it's a great idea to look at some data as well and and tell me what data you think you're going to collect in order to know if mental health intervention prevention strategies are working in a era in our world when mental health problems with students are just escalating at unusual rates what kind of data are we looking for you know I don't we can go through all kinds of scientific data and that type of things the same type
096of data and the best practices and the experts that told us to get rid of the constructive response in our uh assessments so they're not always right um experts are always wrong and so we're going to take time to look at it that's you that's what you're going to get what are you going to look at Kirk I'd just like to know what you're going to look at like how are you going to measure this like this is a political talking point we need to be using real language that talks about what are the mental health outcomes that you're specifically looking for because you're going to be hurting a lot of students by turning down this funding what are you looking for and please don't use any more political talking points yeah I'm done I
097actually have a question um I was bouncing off of your idea I was saying your idea was a great idea um what what is the research that you're looking for because that's actually one of the things that I had asked in our meeting yesterday is what is the data that shows that this is having a significant impact what what are your ideas Deborah so I'm not questioning it you're the one that's questioning and asking for outcomes so I would assume that as a leader you would have an idea of what you wanted to measure I'm not looking for outcomes I know we have a mental health problem with the students in our state I know that we have trusted professionals at leadership levels in our mental health uh staff and therapists like I'm not I'm
098not questioning that what is happening is a problem I'm saying to take it away is a huge huge problem and students are going to be hurt until you have an answer for how you're going to come up with a plan for improving this like let's just say let's approve it today and say you're going to take it back to your committee and come up with something that is a proactive positive plan rather than just dismantling something and hurting thousands of students across the state that need this I come from a place where I've had eight foster kids I will tell you these mental health supports are necessary not just for special needs audiences like I have helped raise but for all of our kids today how can we not see that here we are supporting
099cell phone issues in our schools because of the mental health problems they're causing but we want to take away any supports that are available to our students you're making this a partisan talking point you're not turning this into a positive step that we can do to help our students and to just dismantle something because it feels good because it's going to give you props within your political party is not something that is appropriate for a leader in Nebraska okay I'm going to go to now if there's anybody else who hasn't commented and would like to comment um I do want to just bring the temperature down here just a bit in the room yeah Liz I just have a question for a staff member if I could for zanab if she's here yes um Dr
100Rita can you come to the table thank [Music] you good morning good morning Zena breida student uh Service uh officer hi thank you I just have a question um about the statute that that this is mandated from um was there a timeline in which we had to disperse These funds is there a like an end date where it has to be dispersed by this time it has to be done by this this year okay so by this coming school year like fall of 2025 we have to have the funds out is that correct that is correct okay so we're kind of on a timeline so that we stay in compliance with with statute okay thank you sure okay this yeah I guess um I understand the concerns um that there should be guard rails and
101data um and maybe there are alternative approaches um but I guess where I'm coming from is I don't see this we can always improve but we're not doing harm and in fact we are doing good maybe we're not doing as much good as we could and I would certainly support uh further research and I would like to know what the guard rails are that uh you think are so critical um so I guess I'm just uh I would ask those that are in opposition to think about the kids that uh won't receive the help they need and it may not be perfect help but we do the best we can with what we know uh and the resources that we have um so I guess that's that is my request second the question has been
102called is there a second alling debate all those in favor of ending debate the recorded secretary will call the role shanoff yes Penner yes Jones yes rener no Douglas no ner no Tech Meer yes Christensen no four yes four no okay so debate is motion failed debate is or discussion is it's not a debate this is a discussion um and we will go to people who haven't spoke I will say that um in my time on the board I have never experienced a time when people have to justify their vote to fellow board members um we are each independently elected by the constituents in our area and must answer to them so so I'm a little surprised at the the vein of this conversation um so I do want to open the floor to members
103who haven't had an opportunity and I believe that's um Magie and Kristen you only had one question um I guess what my thinking is yesterday I was kind of confused when we were in committee about if we were talking about what the mental health supports were going to be versus just the grant so when I realiz that the legislature mandated us to approve the grant right that this isn't a question that's where I'm getting kind of confused on this discussion still you don't have to add anymore I just want to give you floor space to do okay all right yes Deb so in any policy leadership position you have have account accountability back to the citizens of the state every state senator who introduces a bill has to repeatedly defend what they're doing we are
104no different and so for four people to say they don't want a continue discussion they just want to dismantle something that doesn't feel like they're doing it for reasons that they want to be transparent about if you can't defend publicly what you're going to do then why are you doing it like just to say I want guardrails as I already said as a partisan talking point but to say these are some ideas I'm going to bring to the committee next month and I'd like these to be considered like if that's what your plan is Sherry like I'm all for that but that's not what I'm hearing ing instead you just wanted to shut down conversation Lisa do you have an idea that you're going to bring forward to the committee and can I are you
105going to give us a taste of it right now or do you want to wait till next month when you're better prepared I can I'm happy to talk now okay something that is going to support the mental health of our thank you um I don't mean to call anyone out but um I have been in conversations so I don't know that I want to speak to the specific program but there is a program in our state that is making a lot of Headway and they have the data to prove it um and so I it's in the works I've been in conversations with people and um I also had mentioned earlier that the parameters for me that I feel are important is that it's opt in versus opt out and that we have parameters around
106ensuring that parents are notified so would you happen to know if that plan aligns with what we are legally required to do with this funding has there been any research about that yes it's basically um it's an alternative to the mental health first aid okay I look forward to hearing about it if you guys are going to vote this down thank you Elizabeth do you have a plan my have you thought about why you're doing why you're going to vote it down or is did I say I was Voting it down well we know I I'm just wondering if if you vote it down are you going to speak up and say why are you just going to hide behind the fact that you have never seen anyone have to defend their decision I've seen
107the votes on this board board too many times quietly happen where you just quietly turn vote against science standards vote against important things you have an obligation not just to the constituents but to all of us we're all trying to do our best to come up with solutions that are going to help the students of Nebraska you have a responsibility to have a conversation with us not just to quietly play partisan games okay well all right so I am going to as the president see if there's anyone else who wants to comment I'm keeping track so that we have a fair um discussion that everybody gets time to to comment I do think that this conversation and the reason I voted to in debate is because it's become very hostile and people are pointing and
108raising voices and that is not appropriate in the boardroom that's why I voted to in discussion would anyone else like to speak to this I do I'm going to just create a fact since you're big into facts that this is the could be the first four four vote besides voting for president and every board I've been on with you it's been your political party that's been in the majority so don't throw that at us one board meeting one vote okay all right anyone else want to comment at this time Deb I can't keep coming back to you well I'm I'm sorry I'm a board member who has a right to have a speak so and we have a policy to go around twice to all board members all right then you can come back to
109me if anyone wants to speak Kristen I could I ask Lisa a question yes um could you tell me a little bit more about the optin and how that might be feasible for um say like uh social skills instruction in the classroom things like that please yes um and so if there's for example example a screener that happens to to determine if there's mental health needs in the school it needs to be something that we're opting into as parents not opting out so I'm definitely behind supporting the parents in my district um because I know that it's very important to my constituents to um have somebody that advocates for parental rights and so we need to make sure that we aren't stepping on their toes and so if there's a screener they need to have
110full um transparency that their kids are being screened and know what's on the screener can I ask a follow-up question um so this particular item pertains to professional development and training for teachers not mental health supports that we are using to screen students but this particular thing is that we are funding training for teachers so I'm just I'm I'm failing to see the connection though I understand what you're saying um failing to see how this optin strategy relates to the issue at hand thank you for your question um correct me if I'm wrong I believe it's um mental health first aid and they do a universal screener and so um if that's what we're going to be training our teachers on I think that we need to look at if we're going to if we're
111going to use that we need to make sure that those parameters are in place unless we go with a different program I from what I understood in committee yesterday it was up to the school district to decide what they were using um that we weren't mandating a particular training but that they it was the local control and they were given the funds to then decide how to use them for their particular training was my understanding but I I could be I could be off base on that right thank thank you okay all right as as is my typical process in committee as well as on the board I usually try to give everybody a chance to speak first um so I have concerns about this I have um had requested a copy of the the
112application and one thing that concerns me uh greatly is that this is a program for teacher training and it says that it focuses on the participants awareness of available Mental Health Resources within the community enabling them to connect students with appropriate care effectively and that should really go through the parents first um I send my students to school to learn reading and math and I would like to be included in any sort of conversations I don't see any mention of that and so that is a a very big concern to me um I think that this gives us the opportunity to work together to come up with something that will enhance the mental health of our students and so I look forward to um future discussions hearing from committee members on what they would like
113to propose for that that's my thoughts Deb so when I hear us talk about the parent discussion and I certainly am somebody that believes in parent involvement in these things but I also want to just give an example as a as a someone who's been a foster care parent for eight children why I think that we do need to give students an opportunity to go talk to uh counselors that can help them even if they can't go to their parent first I had a young boy that lived with me for 5 years and then when his sister who had been bounced around to seven foster homes needed a place to live we took her in so when she came into our house she started being sexually abused by her brother who had been living with
114me for five years she did not feel like she could come to me because she was new to our home and was afraid so if it weren't for the counselors at school she would have had nobody to talk to I mean this is one example and there are millions of examples of kids that might be afraid to go to their parents and say they need they need something uh and we do need to give those students support and this as I said this is one example I think that we are running into the situation where we think we're the experts and we know better I mean we have thousands of mental health workers in this state who are trained in these skills and why do we think that we know better than them about what's
115needed unless you really believe that they're trying to brainwash your children if that's your fear then let's talk about that but I really believe the mental health counselors in our state and the social workers want to do what's best and are trained to do what's best and is there the rare example of somebody who is misguided of course that's all oh yes sorry um I just want to give back to the part about us remaining in compliance with um the legislative directive to address this and I don't know if there's someone that can explain what the process is if this gets stalled out today by a 44 vote what happens next and what are the repercussions if we um aren't in compliance I think that's a great question um I don't know what the repercussions
116are but I would like to speak to us not abiding by State Statute in um effective July 1st 2019 all of the educator prep programs approved by this board were supposed to be in compliance with State Statute which we were the leveraging device we were supposed to ensure that this happened and um it's it hasn't been happening for almost six years and so you know I I feel like there's a lot of areas and I don't mean to money the waters but to try and um to try and force a vote on People based on State Statute is disingenuous um you know we've got kids who can't read Because of Dyslexia the dyslexia law we were not enforcing it and we were the enforcement mechanism and so I I understand that as far as I
117know there's not I'm not hearing a a push from our board members to say never no mental health what I'm hearing is can we go back to the drawing board can we can we have this conversation um I do want to address lizza's question though commissioner do you know about the the financial aspect of it a little bit I do the first of all um not spending the legislature took action to appropriate the funds they didn't compel us to spend those funds the period of time that we have to spend those funds is defined so you wouldn't be out of compliance by not spending those funds um you do still have time to come up with an alternative plan if that would be the wishes of the board but in terms of being out of
118compliance with State Statute you you wouldn't be Deb I just want to point out there's a difference between not enforcing something because we're not an enforcement agency and obstructing something and that's the difference in the discussion here and so I I just want to make sure that we've clarified that I think not following the letter of the law I mean if we're going to throw that up then I mean there there's examples so is there anyone else who hasn't spoken that would like to kind of keep in tally marks to make sure everybody has open space to speak okay seeing no further comments the motion is to authorize the commissioner to approve funding recommendations for school districts and Educational Service units to support schools in delivering Mental Health Training for staff with the recording secretary
119please call the role Jones no ner yes rener yes Douglas yes Penner no Christensen yes Shan Hoff no T Meer no four yes four no the vote was tied and the motion has failed is there a motion on item 7.2 pointd I move to authorize the commissioner to contract for the computer science and technology education fund training and support expansion program second it is moved and seconded to authorize the commissioner to contract for the computer science and technology education fund training and support expansion program is there any discussion on the motion seeing none the motion is to authorize the commissioner to contract for the computer science and technology education fund training and support expansion program with the recording secretary please call the role Douglas yes Penner yes TCH Meer yes Neri yes Christensen yes rener
120yes Jones yes shanoff yes he yes the affirmative has it and the motion to authorize the commissioner to contract for the computer science and technology education fund training and support expansion program is adopted item 7.3 chair Lisa schonhoff will report on behalf of the planning and evaluation committee meeting um yesterday February 6 2024 the planning and evaluation committee reports on their committee meeting um the members present were Lisa schonhoff Sher Jones Deborah ner and Kristen Christensen the committee reviewed an action item related to the Nebraska literacy project plan nde staff provided information on Rev Visions made and answered questions related to statutory requirements the committee reviewed discussion items with nde staff providing summaries and answering the questions related to Media specialist requirements waiver request rule 11 teacher waiver request pilot processes for clinical observations of
121speech language pathology and school psychology candidates the NC te organizational policies the committee reviewed informational items related to Pilot processes for cooperating teachers of world languages approval of plans of Correction approval of non-public and interim program schools model behavioral intervention policy for schools and a Statewide learning platform program nde staff will bring these items to a future meeting meeting for discussion and subsequent approval this concludes the planning and evaluation report thank you are there any questions on the planning and evaluation committee report okay is there a motion on item 7.3 pointa yes I move to approve the Nebraska literacy project plan second is moved and seconded to approve the Nebraska literacy project plan is there any discussion on this motion none okay oh Lisa is that okay um I am super passionate about literacy so
122this is something that I um have been pouring my heart and soul into for the past 24 years and um I am very grateful to the nde staff for all the hard work that they've done and the conversations that we've had there have been uh great there's been great progress in beginning to incorporate phonics and structured literacy back into the into our classrooms and I think that that's imperative I do believe there are still some areas that need worked on um a couple of the areas that I um have been in conversations about are the evidencebased materials that are called high quality instructional materials and the reason why that has been a concern of mine that I've already discussed with several people is because when you look at our um our scores Nationwide scores and
123Nebraska scores my concern is that if we are um using highquality instructional materials in our classrooms that are not getting our kids reading real books a lot they have to be reading real books at their levels they need to be doing at their instructional level they need to be doing a lot of writing um at their instructional level and and there was an oracy piece that I actually just noticed last night was taken out um so with our demographics I know this was brought up earlier as well we've got to include language acquisition which is good for all kids regardless of what demographic you come from um there's just some there's just some um areas that I think that we need to continue our work on before I would feel comfortable with knowing that our
124kids are going to be able to be where they need to be moving forward and I really look forward to doing that work with all of you thank you Lisa anyone else open question sorry sorry no um I'm curious uh Lisa if this is um your concerns could be something that can continue on past the approval of this plan I hate to see it obstructed or or stopped um there's an entire Department of Education um school districts across the state and students that would benefit from this moving forward but I respect your uh your detailed concern and I'm just wondering if your conversations with the staff have proven to you that they are open to continuing that conversation with the approval of the plan uh I actually had talked to Dr Maher about that and
125um regardless of how I vote today it doesn't sound like it'll have a great impact on what happens with the nde staff going forward um the fact of the matter is is that with my experience and my background in literacy if I voted yes today on something that I didn't think was prepared to get us the growth we need across our State I would be doing our state of disservice and in my conscience I cannot vote um based on that fact any other comments or questions right before we vote I just want to say that I know a lot of time and energy um resources have gone into this plan and I appreciate our staff and I appreciate um the receptiveness of Allison and her team and the hard work um I know we all
126want to see kids read so I just that's my comment I just want to say thanks right so the motion is to approve the Nebraska literacy project plan with the recording secretary please please call the role teg Meer yes Neri yes Penner yes Christensen yes rener yes Jones yes shanoff no Douglas yes seven yes one no the affirmative has it in the motion to approve the Nebraska literacy project plan is adopted agenda um the next few agenda items are discussion items and so we have um item 7.3 pointb this is a waiver request from the Nebraska Correctional youth facility regarding media specialist requirements are there any questions or discussion on this item okay item 7.3 Point C this is Rule 11 teacher waiver request from Skyler Public School board members are there any questions on
127this item I just want to um to just kind of help people who aren't on the rules committee no we we had a really great meeting yesterday and um rule 11 deals with with preschool early childhood education and so we're actually looking at that rule to see how we can best serve the students um who are going to our early childhood programs and and the teachers and staff who lead them and so um while it's not specific to Skyler I just think that that we are going to be looking at that and hope to bring some more information to um the the full board at some point on rule 11 okay um agenda item 7.3 pointd this is a pilot project process for conducting clinical observations for speech language pathology virtually at the University of
128Nebraska Carney board members are there any questions or discussion on this item and I would actually like to can I couple it does anyone oppose I mean we can we can do them separately but also there's another the very next one is for conducting clinical observations for school psychology so we have speech language pathology virtually and school psychology virtually um they're very similar and they're both at the University of Nebraska Carney any discussion on 7.3 pointd or 7.3e Jerry yes may I did make a point that we did pass a similar pilot program process in the past for the Masters in counseling program so we did have a bit of discussion during that time several months ago so I think um Jim did a great job of giving us information at that time the only
129recommendation I gave to Mr Kent yesterday was that the student evaluation I believe needs to be the format needs to be looked at and I and I believe he's willing to take that back to the colleges so I appreciate that I'm excited to see our teacher colleges using the technology rural areas are tricky and um getting someone into to do those observations of your work is is not always easy um not always cost effective and so this option is great and I hope that we can see more people going into these fields because it's um cutting some of that red tape okay we have another discussion item in this agenda and it is 7.3 pointf discuss the NCT organizational policies board members is there any questions or discussion on this item Kirk I would just
130like to know the discussion what was discussed oh okay so so so I'm getting a request from members who are not on the planning evaluation committee to say hey what's going on so all right EXC Sherry I see your lights on okay this will probably take me about 10 minutes so I don't know or I anticipate that so I don't know if you want me to do that now or after lunch break is there a preference when do we break for lunch my preference is that we continue on okay so I will go ahead and share yeah commissioner just said his stomach hasn't growled yet so we're good okay so I will go ahead and share what I shared with the committee yesterday so I'm going to begin by giving some background information for the
131sake of our new board members as well as those tuning in to our meeting according to board operating procedure 1.09 or board operating policy excuse me quote every two years the board shall review the role functions and responsibilities of task forces and advisory committees or councils established by the board and I'll end my quote although the sentence continues the nebr a council of teacher education I'll we now refer to as NCT from here on is a council established by the board according to nde staff the last time the board did a review of the NCT was in 2021 four years ago and so thus a review is overdue and warranted last September as chair of the planning and evaluation committee I placed this item on on the planning and evaluation agenda as an informational item
132and then proposed a tentative timeline for the review prior to the October board meeting committee members were encouraged to read the documents which I know are not on there for this board but they will be on there there's two documents that you will see before our next meeting and in October I met with Dr sceta the current executive director of NCT and nde staff together information and I did Supply our committee yesterday with some of the questions that I asked although I did not have time during that hour meeting to have all of my questions addressed but I um appreciated Dr sca's willingness to meet and she mentioned that she would be willing to meet at a later date with the full board so I appreciate that as well so there's a couple things that
133I proposed first of all I think and this is just minor but that the membership directory document could use some minor tweaks to provide for more for better Clarity in my opinion particularly the listing of the three subgroups within the membership directory which would be higher education School governance and teachers and each of those subgroups provides 16 members to this Council so it is a 48 member Council for your information okay the change I propose is in the selection process of the teacher membership currently there are two State Board of Education appointed teachers although I believe historically the Nebraska Department of Education staff has done the actual selecting with the board giving approval and the other four four the other 14 teachers are from the Nebraska State Education Association I I would like to see
134all teachers in the state be given the opportunity to apply and I'll I'll give some rationale in a minute my proposal is to have two Representatives selected from each of the eight State Board of Education districts which would provide the 16 members count that is now on the committee the council my thought is to have nde facilitate the application process upon receiving the applications nde staff and the respective State Board of Education representative would together select two members perhaps a teacher from PK through 5 and the other from 6 through 12 grade um and these 16 individuals will be then brought forth to the full board for approval um and this would be the terms of of their their terms on the council would correspond to the representatives terms now may I share my rationale
135show my rationale currently we are asked to approve a group of 16 individuals that we know very little about we are given their names addresses contact information and the school of filiation of some of them but not all of them my proposal process would bring about better vetting thus a more informed vote making the application process available to all teachers of Nebraska seems like the right thing to do some teachers may not belong to a teachers organization because of the cost of membership I do not believe one's financial situation should be an impediment to being considered and there are other reasons besides Financial ones that in individuals may have for not being a union member and personally I don't believe membership in any teacher organization makes an individual any better qualified or better suited than
136a non-member to serve on the NCT I believe this would provide balanced Fair representative representation currently of the two State Board of Education appointed members both are from rural Nebraska of the nsse a selected members 11 are from the metro area and three from rural and I'm I'm actually including Grand Island as a rural although I believe it has a lot of Metro characteristics the other two rural members are from Diller and Harrison definitely rural um with my proposal non-public school teachers would also be given an opportunity to apply and then at that point I invited um comments from nde staff and committee members regarding my proposal and so so I would open that up um at this time to the full board thank you okay does anyone have any questions or comments for Sherry
137or just discussion comments in general Deb yeah I keep thinking about our discussion yesterday and I appreciate you're raising the question and I look forward to continuing the discussion and I think you've made some really good points thank you seeing no further comments item 7.4 chair Maggie Douglas will report on behalf of the rules and regulations committee meeting all right my eyes Okay the rules and regulations committee reports on the February 6th 2025 meeting of the committee members present were chair Maggie Douglas Vice chair Liz rener Kirk Penner and Elizabeth TCH Meer nde staff provided an overview of the rul making process committee members reviewed the rules report the committee reviewed the hearing draft of rule three identification of high ability Learners and may provide feedback to the commissioner within the next week before the
138hearing draft is approved the committee reviewed policy issues related to potential revisions of rule 11 regulations for the approval of pre kindergarten programs and a proposed revision timeline the committee reviewed necess necessary revisions for rule 86 breakfast meals served at public schools and a propos osed revision timeline the committee will continue discussions and plans to recommend revisions to the board within the year on both rules last the committee reviewed the approval process for educator preparation programs pursuant to rule 20 and discussed potential revisions to ensure compliance the committee will continue discussions and plans to recommend revisions to the board within the year this concludes the rules and regulations committee report Maggie Douglas chair are there any questions on the rules and regulations committee report any discussion no okay all right um there is no additional
139business because nothing was pulled from the consent agenda so we have items 9.1 and 9.2 these are information items and written reports for the board agenda item 10 good of the order this section of the agenda is intended for board members to offer informal observations of the work of the state board board members may make brief announcements about attendance at future events for the purpose of informing other board members no business or motions or suggested actions of the board may be offered at this point in the agenda nor should board members engage in substantive discussion about other agenda items or or introduce new agenda items Sher I do have something for the good of the order president te Meer um last week Governor pillan issued a proclamation recognizing January 26 through February 1st 2025 as
140Nebraska school choice week as stated on the governor's website I quote school choice is the process of allowing every family to choose the K through2 educational options that best fit their children end of quote I just wanted to share that thank you thank you Sherry anyone else have anything to share okay thank you to those who attended in person and who tuned into to the broadcast the next meetings of the State Board of Education are scheduled for March 6th and 7th 2025 in Lincoln Nebraska the February 7th 2025 state board meeting is adjourned e