001e e e the board meeting will begin in 2 minutes please find a seat e e e the January 10th state board meeting will now come to order good morning and welcome to the January 10th State Board of Education meeting board members please engage your microphones before speaking and turn them on off when you are finished speaking please note that board members may be using their cell phones and laptop computers to access the agenda and information related to this meeting live streaming is available through the State Board of Education website with the recording secretary please call the rooll Kristen Christensen here Maggie Douglas here Lisa Shoff here Liz rener here Kirk Penner present Sher Jones here Elizabeth tedm Here Deborah ner here commissioner Maher here all present there are eight members present Quorum is established
002please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance information regarding the open meetings Act is posted as you enter the room from the main entrance doors the open meetings Act is also posted on the State Board of Education website agenda item 2.1 Dr lariam poke Chief Executive Officer of the Educational Service Unit coordinating Council please join us at the front of the room for a special presentation I think everything's turned on are we good there we go well good morning thank you so much for giving me the opportunity to speak in front of you today um I it's when I asked to be able to speak to the new board members I was honored to find out I get to speak in front of all of you so I'm I'm looking forward to sharing
003with you information about the esus ESU coordinating Council and hopefully answering some questions that you might have so my name is laran pulk I am the CEO of the ESU coordinating Council since July so I'm pretty new at with this job but I have been part of the esus for decades so the information I can share with you hopefully is is vast but I have 10 minutes so I've got it on my calendar my schedule here so I'll try my hardest to keep the information at 10 minutes um I want to tell you about esus ESU CC how we collaborate with the Department of Education how the legislature really guides and directs all of that and I have nine minutes so I'll try really hard to get to all of that um truly at any
004time ask questions invite me back call um ask me to answer questions for you that's really what I'm here for and I do that for the legislature too so I am a resource please reach out um we can help each other that way all right before I get into the what and the how of what we do I'd like to talk to you a little bit about why we exist and why we're here gives you a little bit of foundation as to understanding the work that we're responsible for I did write the book on esus and my dissertation is on esus so I won't go into page 1 through 250 promise I'll just go through a little bit of the history so you have a brief understanding so in 1965 the esus began so if
005you are a an education history buff like I am you might know in ' 65 some pretty big things were happening at the federal level Esa Elementary and secondary and Education Act passed that year soon after that in the 70s 75 we had all handicap children's act which is now idea individuals with disabilities and education so all of that was going on in the 60s so in Nebraska and across the country there was an effort to figure out how do we get Equitable resources to all students in Nebraska and across the country so there was a lot of momentum then that started in uh Nebraska to get Educational Service units started as well as nationally educational service agencies so in ' 65 lb 301 passed creating the statutes you see there 79 1204 through 44
006so our legislature created us they saw a need we had um testimony from large school districts small school districts County superintendents and everything in between as to the need for this to be able to provide what the Educators knew was coming was a great need for equity and resources for every student so those statutes were created for three things really one to provide the equity of any kind of educational resources that the schools maybe had gaps in do it in a very efficient way so that we weren't taxing resources um overburdening school districts for things that they weren't prepared to do and then uh the legislature stipulated ated three areas that the esus had to provide services in number one staff development support to teachers Educators getting them the resources they need to be better
007tomorrow than they are today number two uh instructional material support that was it used to be you know when you were in school you had a model of the eyeball that came that probably came from the Service Unit now it's more in support of techn of educational resource rollout potentially helping with curriculum in the classroom aligning standards to the instruction materials that are there highquality instruction material work and the third item is technology infrastructure including a a pretty detailed distance Learning Network across our state so we are responsible for taking a look at all of that and providing what we need to in our 17 esus to the school districts that are members we provide that to both public and non-public schools to a varying degree across the state escc then the coordinating Council didn't
008come into existence until 2007 so the reason for that in ' 65 esus were new they didn't have policies they didn't have guidelines there weren't procedures as to how to really coordinate Statewide stuff so as the years from 65 to 07 there was a lot of U collaboration happening with administration at each ESU that led to big decisions being made for the state so the legislature said hey I think we need to give the esus a a public and reliable way to make those decisions transparently and with some accountability so in 2007 they created the ESU coordinating Council which is a public subdivision following the open meetings act and we uh make decisions that are Statewide for Service delivery in a very public way so that we can make sure that everybody is entitled to
009the same information at the same time we also as an educational service unit coordinating Council fall under high level of efficiency doesn't make any sense for us to do it if we can't do it efficiently we also are trying to find how we can reach every student in each corner of our state and we also with the ESU those those uh uh statutes 12:45 to 49 have intentional opportunities where the nde and the ESU coordinating Council collaborate in a year we we collaborate all the time but there are two very uh specific designated times when we we do that in fact this coming Monday will be the second one for this year we'll be having that conversation call those our rule 84 meetings so I'm going to pause for a minute uh before we get
010into the what and of our business if you have questions right now all right so the what so what is it that we actually do so I'm going to take you on a bit of a journey from a school district to the ESU so in Nebraska we have 244 school districts public ones and they do a lot of different things these that I have on the screen are just a few of them um instruction both uh uh regular Ed and special education Safety Not only in the infrastructure but in digital safety instruction materials training to teachers assessment development and Alignment leadership support and man has technology changed over the last couple of decades in school districts what needs to be done so if all of those things if 244 District had gaps in some of
011those services that they need and they were to reproduce that 244 times it would be very inefficient and a poor use of resources right so that's why the esus can come in and help with that so there's 17 of us so rather than doing one of those things 244 times we can do them 17 times or maybe in I I most recently came from esu7 in Columbus that was my ESU before I was in this job there are 19 school districts in esu7 a good example of um efficiency for for training for example happened last week they had 1100 teachers in the esu7 area 1100 teachers support staff converg into Columbus Columbus Public allowed them to use their facility and they had a full day of training specifically aligned to the gaps and the needs
012that those districts had and they were able to provide supports to prek through Co through High School nde came we had other partners that were able to provide supports there in one day if they were to reproduce that 19 times that would have been horribly inefficient so that's an example so then when we were thinking of um over the years are there things that those 17 esus are doing in common Statewide that we as a coordinating council could do more efficiently and that's how the coordinating Council does their Statewide work going to give you one example of likely fall under instructional materials but is our special education student record system in Nebraska the ESU coordinating Council uh has developed and they maintain a student an online student record system for any of the the schools
013that choose to use it they align it we take the the work and and talk with uh legal to align those documents to compliance make sure that they're available and up to date make sure the information can be transferred from one school to another school who uses that system if that were to be done 244 times or 17 times it would really be a tax on resources so we do it once at the escc so I'm going to give you a real life example from start to finish as to how that um how that works in our educational system last year um in 2023 lb75 if you remember was an enormous Omnibus Bill had a a lot of things in it one of those things was the behavior intervention and teacher support act that became
0143602 in section 79 of our statutes that um expectation that bill was collaborated not only with the Department of Education but the esus school districts it was an incredible collaborative conversation when it became statute then the ND has responsibilities many of them aren't on here but one of the things that they are responsible for doing is creating a model policy that's in process right now collaborating with us collaborating with schools and other agencies they're going to create a policy for the school districts that's one element of collaboration ESU coordinating Council then's responsibility was to develop that training curate it put it in a place where all school districts could access it and create a reporting tool so that I can come back to you in December and tell you how we're doing and I can
015talk to the Ed committee this summer and tell them how we're doing the esus then deploy that training so this is an incredible example of how all elements of service to students and Educators across the school across the state really do work together we have a number of different things that escc is working uh in collaboration with nde this is just really a a sliver of of what we're doing but I wanted to give you maybe some more that might be um more immediately relevant to your uh thinking especially that that top one on the list literacy is something I know you be talking about so I want to pause and and uh have an opportunity for you to ask me any questions you might have uh but also I have my contact information on
016there and I really truly do mean to invite me back so you need to have any other questions presid just a quick a quick question just wondering if do most States employ a similar model do you know so Esa is across the country there's about 48 of us across the country um U some of them are um there's probably more like 44 some we're all designed a little bit differently so in Nebraska there is no governance from the Department of Education over the esus there's no governments over the esus by the ESU CC we all are able to um operate autonomously which is very nice so we can have some some um biases or maybe uh not so at play when we're making our decisions uh the role I play the CEO of the escc
017there's only 14 of us in the country so not every state has a another Statewide element like we have here in Nebraska Lisa go ahead I um am excited that you're here this morning because esus are the one of the top things that I want to learn more about and I'm actually going to be at esu7 next Friday Friday I believe it is fantastic very good yeah um and so I guess I heard you say a lot about efficiency and providing Equitable resources in your time working with the esus what's like the biggest success that you've seen boy the biggest success that's probably a tough one to to narrow down I can tell you that um there was a time in our educa ESU history where there wasn't as much collaboration happening between the service
018units sharing of resources making sure that we're uh effectively Reaching Across our borders as there is now probably in the last decade so I think that's that would be my biggest success story for all of us is that we're realizing we can't do all of this can't do all of this that I just showed you by ourselves and we certainly can't do it without reaching out you know if when I talked about being efficient 17 times does not mean that 17 esus are replicating the same thing 17 times that's also not efficient so we have a system an online system that we can access so if I'm an esu7 and I know that I have um the largest responsible um services that I can provide are these 10 but I've got a district that needs
019something that's just a little different maybe one of my bordering esus have that on their service menu and they can help support my schools too so we're starting to do a lot more of that and I think that's a that's an incredible thing and we'll have to say that Dr Maher and his team have been um very open and willing to figure out additional ways that we can um capitalize on all of our efficiencies nde has um expertise in areas that our ESU wouldn't be able to do and vice versa so we're able to tap into each other's strengths and really improve the quality of education for all students regardless of where they are in our state I was wondering um Dr po if you could explain the funding sources for the board so that
020we understand because I know the escc probably has different funding than the individual esus right true so I'll start with the esus so the esus are funded by four different Avenues they do uh Levy a tax so in their region they can Levy up to a Cent and a half and not all of the esus there's about five of the esus that don't Levy to their top so they can Levy a Cent and a half um they have state aid we have a formula that is not as complicated as tiosa but it is a needs minus resources formula so we have um for that region so we have about six esus that receive no state aid we call that core service dollars so we have that and then the other two areas really are contracts
021with our school districts so uh fee for service and grants that we can um try to get state and federal grants but I can tell you that a the the um contracts and the grants make up a third or more of what the budgets are the levy makes up about a quarter or less so when I was at ESU 7 our budget was around $18 million and we got two and a half in the levy so after that you know there's uh other resources that we have to tap into esu7 also happened to be one of those non-e equalized we didn't receive core service funding escc on the other hand so that core service dollars that I said gets that six of those ESU don't receive that pot of core service dollars 2% of that
022is slivered off the top and it goes right to ESU CC so 2% of that 13 million goes to ESU coordinating Council and that is our only persistent funding source after that we have contracts with the Department we have federal grants we also have the distance learning um Cooperative which is uh dollars that are funnel from the state also for us to coordinate the distance learning cooperative for the state that's it thank you any further questions all right thank you for your time and for coming in today all right the next item of business is the commissioner's report commissioner Maher please provide your report you oh thank you thank you president TM my first item will be to explain to the board there are no items that have been identified to be removed from the
023consent agenda if board members do wish to remove items from the consent agenda please fill out the form at this time if any are um asked to be removed from the consent agenda will be taking up taken up under additional business now uh from for the rest of my report there will be a a couple of um this will be lengthier than General so I apologize in advance the uh first of all good morning to uh the the entire board and to members of the public in the audience and to those listening and happy New Year to everybody uh I want to start by thanking Dr poke she might have said that's the quietest I've ever seen you why didn't you say anything during my report because I was going to thank you during my
024report I I truly appreciate the work that you do grateful for all 17 esus and uh love the collaboration that we've been able to put together to help the ecosystem of Education in Nebraska so thank you for being here today I'll be at only 10 minutes um to the board I want to say welcome this is your your first official business meeting as a new board with these eight members present I'm anxious to get together and and work with you on executing your priorities as a board and working closely with President TM and vice president ner to have a productive and focused year um right away I know this board will be busy with the legislative session and as you know today marks the third day of the legislature for the 2025 term my team
025and I have spent a lot of time over the off session in preparation including meeting with senators and their staff preparing for Bill and fiscal analysis and anticipating your work in informing the nd's positions and uh advocacy I'm grateful for the opportunity to continue to work with Senator merman who was reelected as the chair of the education committee on Wednesday and working with all members of the education committee and the legislature at large I'm also very much looking forward to kicking off the strategic planning process I know for those of you new to the board when I came and met with each of you I told you that I thought we would be embarking on a strategic planning process so your uh entrance onto this board is coming at a good time I've only talked
026briefly with President TM since the election yesterday about some priorities and this is certainly one of President tm's priorities too I think it'll be great for all of us to have that strategic planning process uh many of you may Rec may recall that the current strategic plan began in 2016 and is set to expire through its uh natural course in 2026 and that still may seem like a long time off but we're halfway through the first month of 2025 and we have to have a strategic plan in place so it it'll be a pretty compressed time even though it may not seem like it here in January of 2025 um only one board member I believe board member ner has had a chance to weigh in on the existing plan so we'll um refresh that
027or with a refresh in 2019 and so it it's time for a new strategic plan Now's the Time to set forth that new or revised Direction and the Strategic plan will serve as our marching orders within the department for the work done in this particular office the board set a strong model through the goals outlined in the legislative priorities which have provided Clarity and coherence for our staff over the last several months and if if you're wondering what those are think law La aw focus on literacy a focus on attendance specifically as it relates to Chronic absenteeism and a focus on Workforce Development specifically as it relates to getting qualified employees in our schools so uh law if you if you're wondering what are we what are you doing now we're working on law um
028we will uh we come to you soon with some with some options on how the logistics of that plan can come together and while I'm telling you we come to you I want you to know that I am fully cognizant that the Strategic plan is your strategic plan and will be my marching orders even though I I I would be coming to you make no mistake it's it's your plan it's not my plan next I don't want any potential board action on cell phone use in schools to get lost in the shuffle I know all of you were here in December as we talked about cell phone use and and you saw some research that uh we did in that regard um I'm hopeful that we can revisit the information and that presentation that was
029shared in December and get direction from the board on any next steps I would also tell you that I think it is likely that we'll see some conversation taking place in the unic Camal on that particular topic so um we'll uh we'll we'll see what the uh appropriate action for this board to take on that is as we move forward but I I don't want to lose sight of that particular topic next you'll see in the agenda an item pertaining to the Nebraska literacy plan you all know of the priority that we have with literacy in our state I was glad that Dr pul found it fitting to talk about that um albeit briefly in her report too I think maybe maybe all of our 245 school districts would tell you they understand that's a
030priority in our state um so we're we're not keeping that a secret you know you all know of the priority of literacy in our state as well I would ask Lane Carr and Alison Den bestie to come forward and give all members a briefing on where we are with the plan and as they come forward um for the board I'm I'm sure you've seen the passing of the literacy plan as an action item later on in the agenda I am asking the board to take no action on that item today and asking you to wait until February to approve or not approve the plan I know all of the current board members were in this room when I made a a similar request in December and the purpose for the request is really grounded in
031two particular areas one there are still some details to work out on that finished product um and that'll probably always be true but I think we can bring you a a better document in February than we can deliver today um we we can have a better product in February and two well I know all of you have some familiarity with the plan um no no matter your length of service to this board four of you are brand new to this body and I want to help you understand why we have put this plan together but also to give you an opportunity to question elements within the plan and provide input to the development of that plan so um I have a I have an ask of you that is also twofold one take no action
032on the plan today and two become more familiar with the plan quickly and provide input to the staff on suggested additions or deletions to that plan that'll give our and I ask you to have those Suggestions by January 24th two weeks from today because I I know you're not doing anything between now and then right so uh and the reason and the reason for that compressed time frame is this well I know that that's quick our staff will need some time to look at suggestions have conversations make additions make revisions to that document but also then prepare that document for submission to the February agenda that doesn't happen at the February board meeting it happens a week prior so I'm really only giving our staff about a week with those revisions so in retrospect two
033weeks is really a lot of time that I'm giving thanks for laughing at that um and I would I would say for uh for you may not see anything new today but I think it's important for us to talk about where are we in the literacy plan right now so um Lane and are representative of the the people and we'll share with you the work that has been done on this project for months and months now so Lane and Allison take it away thank you Dr Maher Allison Den besty academic officer and Lane Carr I'm in the office of policy and strategic initiatives in our Commissioner's Office should this be projecting and we should have slides coming up here shortly you need to duplicate your screen or do something different because he can see your
034deskop duplic duplicate there we go okay okay all right Perfect all right as Dr baher mentioned we are here just to share information about the Nebraska literacy project and I'd like to begin with a vision um I'm not going to read to you but what I really do want to point out in this vision statement is that we are looking to foster a culture of lifelong readers in Nebraska unlocking the potential of each and every student through a focus on evidence-based reading instruction there are three very specific goals associated with the project first and foremost is a goal to increase third grade proficiency on the nscas ELA assessment to 75% by 2030 and of course if we exceed that that would be great uh related goals increasing the percent of Nebraska K3 students who meet
035the Nebraska reading Improvement act approved assessment thresholds and to ensure that 100% of Nebraska educator preparation programs are implementing evidence-based instruction for teachers grounded in the science of reading excellent so we thought it would be important to start with a a reminder of the statutory and policy context that this plan is being built around and that I think is both the why and the what you got to do right so the first thing that I want to make sure that everybody knows is that this is building upon the progress of our state in the passage of the reading improvement improvement act in 2018 you'll see throughout the next couple of slides we bold and italicize some of the the key things that you we hope shows up you can see how it's showing up in
036the plan as those requirements so that really kicked off our uh conversation we were doing a lot of work as a state around literacy obviously but the reading Improvement act solidified that codified that and tries to create consistency and does create consistency about identifying students who have reading deficiencies and then supporting them with an individual reading Improvement plan and then since that time with the with the passage of new legislation last year we had the addition of a professional Learning System tied to that reading Improvement act it builds upon that reading Improvement act so here you'll see that the department us we together have to create a professional Learning System that is fundamentally what this plan is doing this is uh solidifying and codifying your uh Authority and our work together for this professional Learning
037System you'll also see that family literacy and family literacy centers family literacy programming comes up also in this statute so straight out of the 79 2607 you see one the professional Learning System and two the Prof the family literacy centers family literacy programming in addition we've already spoken a little bit about this and we heard from Dr pulk the Partnerships that we're um working through and and expanding in a lot of ways around the regional approach to coaching so making sure that professional development is great but if it isn't followed up on if it isn't uh continued then we know that it's incomplete so that's an opportunity here and a requirement from the legislation that we work closely with our esus the escc to ensure we have Regional coaches across the state we also take
038uh took guidance from the board's position statement on foundational literacy there are a few things that again I want to pull out here it's really small on the screen so over to the left I I pulled it out a little bit further a few things that you'll note and again you'll see uh further in the plan the first is we just need adults reading to kids we need print-rich uh environments we need print-rich environments at home we need printr environments in our schools and we need to focus on uh how we can support our schools in the selection and implementation of Standards aligned high quality instructional materials for English language arts so those pieces are kind of the policy and uh context for which we built out then the plan thank you Lane the plan
039is built around five tenets and this first slide really shows an overview of how we begin with a vision move to the goals and then each of the tenants is aligned as Lane mentioned four of the five tenants directly come from the legislation the one that doesn't that isn't specifically called out in the legislation is tenet 4 which is data collections to evaluate Effectiveness and yet as an agency and as a team working on this we knew that devoting all of our resources to literacy we must have some measures of our Effectiveness terminology becomes very important and so this graphic is really intended just to help show the connections between the science of reading which is really the scientific body of evidence that supports classroom practice in structured literacy ensuring that what's happening in our
040classrooms is evidence-based reading instruction I'm going to quickly just move through the tenants um tenant one is the professional Learning System itself and um we have just a couple of updates about what has happened thus far with each tenant we have developed and partnered to offer some science of reading embedded professional learning options um the nde is currently supporting um an early literacy workshop at the University of Nebraska Omaha the words project at the University of Nebraska Lincoln and then project rise focuses on early literacy at the University of Nebraska Carney and so we see all three of our University Partners represented here we also have convened a Nebraska literacy advisory panel um recognizing that we have tremendous expertise in our state um if you go back to the legislation one of the words in
041there is that ensuring every teacher receives adequate instruction and so to help Define what is adequate instruction there are some very good programs out there and yet we know in a state with 245 districts it's important to offer enough choice that districts can select what works for them while still ensuring a common basis level basic level of knowledge among all of our educators tenant 2 addresses curriculum and teacher preparation aligned with evidence-based reading instruction as Lane referenced um having standards aligned highquality instructional materials is important to challenge students to do the work that we know they're capable of and support the teachers in their instruction um Nebraska districts have autonomy in the selection of their instructional materials and we do encourage our district districts to adopt and Implement materials of high quality uh we also
042connected to rule 20 have the opportunity to provide guidance to our educator prep programs to ensuring that while we are working to support our existing Educators that this pipeline of future Educators comes to us perhaps more prepared than some of our current staff just because of the shifts that we know about evidence-based reading instruction we've mentioned uh Regional literacy coaches again this is embedded in the legislation um so far we have developed job descriptions hiring timeline timelines working in conjunction with the ESU coordinating Council um collaborating with regional literacy coaches and the nde advisory committee to help develop some sustainable processes while it seems that um we do have some funding and we have some resources now we know that there will come a day when the timelines the resources will have come to an
043end we need this work to be self- sustainable excellent and as we think about again the the fourth tenant is focused on how are we doing and knowing that we can't wait until the end of five years the wait end of one year to know how we're doing and if we need to make adjustments so we've put an emphasis in the plan around data collections of the programs that we currently have the non-negotiables for any new programs that we might have and then ultimately uh process in place to measure the effectiveness of all of those throughout and at the end of our project knowing that at the end of the day that big goal is third grade proficiency on nscas the final piece is around family literacy centers and early childhood programming so you'll note
044again in the legislation that it very clearly calls out family literacy centers for the last six or so years we've been working with the national Center for Families learning ncfl that is a leader in family literacy and we have about 177 family literacy centers around the state what you know from that is that 17 and centers are not going to be able to provide that same program support for All Families in all of our schools so we also want to be thinking about the other resources that are out there there's lots of uh resources lots of community organizations and our libraries which I loved this map of the librar showing the distribution of all of those so in what ways can we partner with our libraries in our communities to see more of a collaboration
045in our schools and the other piece here too is one of the uh large Esser Investments that that pandemic relief funding Investments was was focused on the Nebraska growing readers initiative which to date has delivered up over 800,000 books um to littles little students young uh young kids around the state in kindergarten and even pre- kindergarten and more importantly than just handing out the books we've been able to provide support to early childhood education centers and here's how we should have you working with your parents parents here some resources for using these Resources with your kids at home so we're thinking of ways to evaluate that we have to have ways to evaluate that it valuation is currently in motion with that and then how do we keep it sustained how do we keep it
046going and how do we make it unique to each community that wants to continue that work that is our five tenants thank you very much for that there I I've jotted a couple of things down that I wanted to add as you were speaking and one of the things they referenced a goal that third grade reading goal I want you to know that that's not new um that has been around for at least multiple years and it predates me and I'm in my 19th month on the job so the goal is not a a new goal that is that is one that has been around a couple of years there's also when we think about the literacy projects sometimes we think about the funding and it's easy to get um our Focus off of the
047goal when we start thinking about the funding because there are multiple sources that we have for funding one is philanthropy there are folks around the state who are are helping with the initiative but also um we have our regular budget we um the Department of Education didn't start working on literacy in the last month or two our schools didn't start working on literacy in the last month or two so we have our regular and annual budget that that we work with we have Esser funding that was discussed earlier that is uh that is about to expire but it's significant in terms of accomplishing the goal uh so that that's um a funding stream we have the state appropriation that was talked about the $1.8 million for three consecutive years we're in year one right now
048with that appropriation um in and again that's part of accomplishing the goal but but none of those have changed the goal and then we got the clsd um funding about three or four months ago now where where we announced that and so many times within the department we get confused on what the goal is and we confuse the grant with the goal the goal has never changed the goal is to make sure kids in Nebraska can read a little bit better tomorrow than they're reading today that's the goal we have some tremendous funding streams that can now help us accomplish the goal but the goal hasn't changed so as I've asked you to really get um more intimate with the Nebraska literacy plan and think about suggestions that can beef up that plan I want
049I want to uh help draw your mind to think literacy plan not funding and I'm telling you I've made the mistake many many many times in the last several months but keep keep your focus on the goal and know that the funding is a vehicle to accomplish the goal um they're they're so related but they're not the same thing so the literacy plan is is not the funding and I would tell you the clsd the 55 million the big enchilada in terms of funding it's really to confuse the clsd plan with the literacy plan and while they're and while they're not unrelated they are also not the same thing so um hopefully that didn't take a complicated situation and make it more complicated but to the extent that you can if you can um put
050put those separate funding streams in silos and understand that they help us feed that that final goal let's stay focused on that goal I think of it from my days of coaching and how do we how do we try to win the game we focus on blocking and we focus on tackling and we focus on doing those fundamental things well and in the end if we do those sufficiently well we'll win our fair share of games so that's I want to focus on the fundamentals when it comes to the literacy plan so with that I will say are there are there any any comments today I don't expect you to have your questions today and I I I I don't even know that this is the the best forum for those questions but certainly funnel
051those to us and if you have any questions or comments today I would say go ahead and ask them so Lisa I saw you had one and then we'll go to Liz thank you um I have been obviously I um literacy is my passion I know that you know that Allison um I have read through it multiple times and I've tried I've read this book multiple times as well um and I think I have a few just really try to make them really brief questions number one is who was all involved in writing the plan I'm trying to formulate a list because when we recognize the work of people my greatest fear is leaving someone out okay um so it started really internally um across our office and one of the things that I think
052you'll become familiar with is that as an agency we have a fairly long-standing goal of trying to reduce silos and have coherence across the agency um I can remember several conversations with laye Dr fryzen Amy Ron our director of special education um all of us I think had a hand in it certainly Dr Maher contributed to it because when the legislation passed and you'll note that word shall the nde shall do this then we take that as a um that is a an imperative that we're going to get to work on this and so um most of the work was developed internally um to begin with with representatives from several different offices in the agency okay so all within the nde okay and then um my other question is can you tell me more about
053the um the relationship or the partnership with the Nebraska Children and Families Foundation I I had to do some research on them and then also the national Center for Families learning for families learning um I'm wondering how what does that partnership look like and what does that mean is there funding involved given or taken or yeah so to begin the Nebraska Children and Families Foundation is a a Statewide nonprofit entity that partner ERS a lot in the early childhood space and receives a significant amount of funding for that early childhood um work from the Department of Health and Human Services their um presence in the prek through 12 space has really expanded recently and um that has included investments from the nde in um early literacy efforts specifically so for the Nebraska growing readers project
054it is a Esser investment that American Rescue plan Esser investment of funds to the Nebraska Children and Families Foundation which then facilitates the work of the book distribution the professional development Etc so we use I'm not the best with the um funding part so we use our Esser funds to pay them that's right how can I ask how much do you know that i' have to go back and look okay so thank you for and just one more quick question um another thing that a really um something that I've really been trying to research a lot on is what exactly the definition of I mean I know the definition that we have in here but high quality instructional materials and who is to determine whether it's high quality instructional materials because I've seen some materials
055that I actually would have to disagree with so I want to know how do we come to an or how how is that determined the most important characteristic of materials that are considered of high quality is that they are aligned to the standards and within Nebraska we have the Nebraska instruction instructional materials collaborative we have a website um our website has a number of resources and one of the resources available is it um it does point to a review by a nonprofit entity Ed reports now Ed reports is very commonly used by many states to help evaluate instructional resources they align to the Common Core State Standards which I'm sure you're aware Nebraska never adopted and uh we have our own State Standards so one of the most important resources on the Nebraska instructional materials
056collaborative site is the bridge documents that Bridges to Nebraska standards so standards aligned um is really the most important criteria to determine whether or not materials are um of high quality um that is just one of them there's another uh resource listed on there the reading League um evaluates materials there are some states that do their own evaluations that's not been something that the Nebraska Department of Education has ever had the resources to do okay so if I have future questions I can just reach out to both of you okay I think that covers it okay thank you go to Liz now uh mine's a little bit quicker um I want to I got answered that the Nebraska growing readers sorry can you hear me okay Nebraska growing readers program is Esser funded and did
057you say I noticed and was appreciated the discussion of sustainability because those funds are running out and was that one that there's a plan for um it to continue after the funds run out and then the other question I had is I just wanted to know the number again of books that were or materials that were distributed so I'll answer the last one first 800,000 books to thousands of families and parents across the state and um as for the first question you know we're the first step to sustainability is evaluation and trying to sus out what parts of the program have been most successful that we should continue so the answer is yes there is we're working on a plan to to sustain the program and to think through how schools can work even closer
058with that as well so it's in the works wonderful thank you any other questions okay wonderful so January 24th um yeah they'll be available to consult with you I'll hand it back to Dr Maher thank you president techm and thank you Lan and Allison really appreciated and thank you to the board for your engagement in in that activity this will be I think the most important thing that that that we do at least as I sit in this seat so thanks for your attention to this issue um finally I will conclude my report by telling you that it gives me no joy to discuss this next item um you all had a good amount of time yesterday to learn from the font of knowledge that is Brian holstead um I've called him a lot of
059things that might be the first time I've called him a font of knowledge uh Deputy Commissioner hallad has been with the department since August 30th 1990 and the Deputy Commissioner has made it official to me that he will be completing his substantial work with the Department next fall so there's a little bit of good news here I'm not telling you he's leaving tomorrow he's leaving next fall my point of bringing this up today is to um public public L announce his impending retirement and that the nde will have time to send him off with appropriate Fanfare down the down the road that's not the purpose of the announcement today um but I want you to know this will be a loss and if you've spent any time with with Brian you know that's going to
060be the case the Deputy Commissioner serves several roles um for the Department of Education and um many people remember him as having a a somewhat narrowly defined role as an attorney in the department but that has changed significantly since he's become the Deputy Commissioner we still many times treat him as the attorney that he is and also he provides guidance to this board um but I would tell you that Brian holstead is a bit of a unicorn um and I have called him that to his face and I hope that comes off with the intended affection that I mean when I when I do say that uh but I'll likely need to do some reorganization reorg reorganizing of those various roles as we begin to to fill the hole or holes that will be left
061when he leaves so it's entirely possible that I tell him that he cannot leave the State Department of Education until and unless he finds a suitable replacement but he tells me it's not him that I would have to argue with but rather somebody else and and his family so I probably will not have that argument um we have a lot of work to do before the Deputy Commissioner leaves I want you to know that um this is not a sendoff but rather I want you to know we will be we will be working to um find a replacement in the coming weeks and months um for the Deputy Commissioner and I will I will let you know how I plan to have all of those holes filled um over time I'm just not prepared to
062tell you that uh today and I'm not prepared to tell you that today because I don't know specifically right now but that will be uh a really important piece to fill over the coming weeks and months and um we'll we'll just uh value the weeks and months that we have left with Deputy Commissioner holstead so on that Downer that concludes my report thank you Dr Maher at this time we are at Agenda item 3.2 IND staff member David jerson please make your way to the front of the room for a brief introduction of Lindsay Wilson the 2025 Nebraska teacher of the year Lindsay is a middle school teacher from Bennington Middle School in Bennington Nebraska good morning David jerson public information and Communications um so I will keep it very brief so about 9 months
063ago or so we started the journey to try to select the 2025 Nebraska teacher of the year part of that process is sending out um requests for nominations letting the public know uh that they that we are accepting nominations we'll be doing that again uh this coming March as well over the course of nine months we received more than 100 unique nominations from across the state um from school districts as large as Ops to the smallest ones that we possibly have um from from every border uh around the state so it was really successful nomination going period now the application process is rather daunting and Lindsay can tell you about that for sure and any teacher of the year that you've talked to um can fill you in on that as well so we had
06417 applicants this year for uh the Nebraska teacher of the year uh which is a great number we had a Review Committee go through that and narrow that down to three finalists and L Wilson is the one that Rose to the top in that finalist presentation um Kirk was part of that and thank you again Kirk uh part of that interview process had some ice yeah he he did a great job Lindsay did a fantastic job in the interview process and we were able to surprise her in September with the teacher of the year presentation uh that's always a lot of fun because uh she has no idea that we are going to come into the classroom she knows that she's a finalist she knows that we are going to be announcing uh the winner
065sometime in the next two weeks um but we really do just show up and open the door and walk in with the commissioner and her superintendent uh principal and others uh and her husband was there as well so um she had some friendly face uh in the room when we did that so looking really forward to working with her throughout the year uh she'll be doing a lot of traveling uh and speaking engagements representing uh Nebraska and this is her first uh introduction to the board officially so she has a presentation for you uh this is Lindsay Wilson from Bennington I do appreciate your enthusiasm at in the interview you did great I did make him do an activity with me so I think I left him a little stumped thank you I still haven't
066told you the answer either I gave him a a box with mystery items and made him try to figure it out he still doesn't know okay perfect okay um first of all I I am Lindsay Wilson um I'm super honored to be here today um as Nebraska teacher of the year 2025 I still it's I'm still trying to get used to saying that um but I'm excited to tell you a little bit about myself and um what has brought me here so as mentioned I am a teacher for the Bennington Public Schools I teach seventh grade science and math I'm in my third year with Bennington Public Schools but I've been a teacher for about 16 um before Bennington Public Schools I was with Omaha public schools for a long time so um just to
067tell you a little bit about myself um my path to becoming a teacher was not a traditional one um I actually had a really hard time in school when I was younger I did not feel like I fit into that traditional model of what school looked like um eventually I did find a place where I could Thrive After High School I decided to pursue higher education at a Hawkeye Community College in Iowa where I plan to study Studio Art uh which is totally different than what I do now but I had the opportunity to volunteer at the time to um go to an alternative school and that changed everything for me so it was really near University of Northern Iowa and that's where I decided to pursue a dual degree in elementary and middle level
068education and it was there where I realized I had this love for teaching Middle School um they are the age group that is equal parts quirky challenging and just absolutely inspiring so I love them um and then later in 2013 I decided to go to Concordia University and get my M's in elementary and secondary Administration on a personal side this is my family um love them all um I've been married to my husband for 16 years we met in high school School actually I used to copy off of his math homework so you know there's quite the story there so we have been raising two very phenomenal kids if I can say so myself um they both attend Bennington Public Schools my daughter is a freshman and my son and is in his last year
069of elementary school we travel a lot and we love it but we have one rule and that's to always try something new and discover new things that philosophy very much influences my personal life but also Al my teaching philosophy I love bringing fresh out ofthe boox ideas out of the box right into my classroom um because if middle schoolers teach you anything is that you have to keep them engaged and keep it fresh otherwise they will very quickly find something else to entertain them right I love these pictures um in 2008 I moved to Nebraska to student teach at King Science and Technology Magnet Center for Omaha Public Schools I was hired immediately after student teaching as a sixth grade math teacher and that kind of started my journey with Omaha Public Schools so for
07013 years at King science and then later at Morton Magnet Center I taught many things Math Science Social Studies gifted Education Service Learning you name it I taught it I even partially left the classroom for a few years to do instructional and magnet facilitator position as well as starting Nebraska's first middle level Zoo Academy in partnership with the Omaha Henry dly zoo in aquarium it was actually that position that very much opened my eyes to the wha ifs of Education I began to ask myself what if we approach teaching where curiosity leads the way or what if um education and learning was an adventure in the zoo Academy the kids had had the opportunity to do Hands-On learning through courses like Zoo architecture and biology and preparing them for Unique career paths along people in
071the profession so yes we did navigate lots of middle schoolers every other day around the zoo yes it was very wild but it was that moment where I realized Nebraska was going to be my home throughout all of these opportunities I've learned the transformative power of Education these exper experiences in my career have been challenging but have expanded my perspective and and helped me grow it's because of them here on this screen that I've embraced this philosophy centered around curiosity critical thinking and creating a classroom where every student feels valued and capable of achieving greatness if there's one thing I've learned in education it's the importance of finding your people some of you in this room May recognize some of those people these are my people some of my most favorites and there's lots still
072missing but surrounding yourself with individuals who see your value encourage your growth and challenge you to dream bigger is important these are the people who recognize your potential your expanders one of my colleagues up on this screen told me that an expander is someone who shows you what's possible and they inspire you to reach for it in education these connections are super critical they remind us that we're not alone that our work matters and that together we can achieve a whole lot more than we can on our own so when I say that any of my accomplishments are not just mine it's because they're a result of a community of Educators students and families who believed in the power of education and each other a colleague once told me we are in the space that
073we're supposed to be in and that is my reminder to embrace challenges and trust my journey um and continue growing as an educator and as a person middle schoolers have also taught me that we grow best when we're challenged we feel loved and we're surrounded around people who encourage us to be bold resilient and our true authentic selves as I said today I proudly teach for the Bennington Public School District my classroom is a mix of energy Innovation and it says a little bit but sometimes it's a lot of chaos right um I in my few short years with Bennington Public Schools I have started the district's first science research team at the middle school supported students and earning top honors at the Metro Science and Engineering Fair particip ated in leadership roles to shapee
074District initiatives my decision to join a smaller District was driven by my desire to be closer to my kids and my family but I've been really Amazed by the dedication and passion of the community I have three goals as Nebraska teacher of the year first advocating for inquiry based learning I want to inspire Educators to embrace Hands-On inquiry based approaches to encourage the engagement in real world application in the classroom the second is to promote equity and access I truly believe that every student deserves high quality engaging education regardless of their resources so together championing for initiatives that bring opportunities to the classrooms where we can ensure that even our most vulnerable students have the support that they need to thrive and third celebrating teachers and elevating the profession teachers are the heart of education
075and and our society I want to Spotlight their stories and successes and through professional development sessions I want to inspire them to be bold with strategies that will Empower them and all Educators Statewide so this year I have a couple initiatives of my own um including a Mars soil simulant project uh to help um amplify our district curriculum bringing a hydroponic system in for interdisciplinary use continued collaboration in science research and my newest initiative a district elementary science Showcase in collaboration with our art Department to provide more opportunities for young people and mentoring teachers my professional development sessions are going to be on topics like inquiry based learning fostering grit and building collaborative cultures and designed to disrupt those traditional models and and Inspire positive change so each year um instead of a resolution I
076give myself a word that word guides my vision and gives me intention and purpose last year my word was impact this year I actually have two words so breaking my rule a little bit uh disrupt and Inspire and it's reflecting on my commitment to challenging norms and sparking meaningful growth in students and teachers alike my focus is always going to be one of optimism resilience and the potential that we have as Educators to disrupt the status quo and innovate the future of Education I want to turn all of those challenges that we face in education into possibilities and embrace things that make our classrooms vibrant no matter where we teach or the resources available to us our shared goals should remain one that's the same to ensure that all students and teachers feel Val valued
077seen and empowered to succeed so I want to thank you for your unwavering support of education and for the opportunity to represent Nebraska teachers this year I look forward to advocating for both teacher and student growth at the local state and National levels and I'm eager to continue disrupting and inspiring every space that I enter so thank you for investing in education and for supporting teachers and for believing in the power of what we do together we are shaping a brighter and more connected world so stay curious Inspire and continue to be inspired by those around you thank you thank you Lindsay um um we're gonna open up just in for a minute for some board comment but I just want to tell you thank you because you get to take us on your journey
078with you as you come back each month or not each month but throughout the year to report and it is an incredible privilege for this board to get to travel vicariously on your journey and and we love it so I'm looking forward to to you experiencing fabulous things this year all right anyone else want to add some okay we'll kind of head around Liz um well first uh it's such a pleasure to meet you and I want to tell you uh your Inspire word you're already doing it it's only January 10th and I've written down a few quotes from you already so I'm looking forward to being inspired by you more but uh I also want to commend you because I think it takes a very special personality to teach middle school and appreciate them
079and bring out the best in them so uh I'm glad that that they have you and our our school system does too um I love that well I don't love that you struggled as a student but I love when people come to teaching from that point of view and I wonder if you or I will be curious to learn what you um think we can do for kids that don't find a place in our our system as it exists and so I'll be I'll be eager to hear your your thoughts about that over the year um but mostly I just want to say congratulations and it's uh I'm excited to watch you over the next year thank you so much Sherry yes um thank you Lindsay for expanding my vocabulary today and I want to
080repeat that because I think it's good for me and our constituency expanders I love that show you what is possible and encourage you to reach forward so I'm that's a new vocabulary word for me thank you and also I know you're can to have a lot on your mind this next year but if you can remember I'd love just an email invitation to your science showcase if that comes to be so thank you so much right anyone else deah I'm so glad I got to hear this today needed this kind of inspiration and uh Joy I mean you just make me smile like it's it is why we're here and you're uh just a shining star so thank you and I will definitely look forward to your reports back to us uh your goals align
081with our goals and uh we look forward to hearing you know all the ways that you accomplish those and I I want to point out that we have another past teacher of the year here in the room with us and I hope that uh and former uh State Board member paty Co John's and I hope if you haven't connected that you you will uh and just say thank you for the inspiration that you're bringing to us thank you all right thank you Lindsay um we are on agenda item four which is President's report and as my returning board members know I rarely have a president's report um but I am going to take just like three minutes and do a quick president report and then then we will have a a short break um right
082after this so just springboarding enough I had I had made some notes I spoke with our our she's a past president she's teacher of year um honored alumni at Unk um py Coon's just couldn't stay away and we're so glad she came to see us today um and my present's report is actually not even my words py and I had a little conversation right before the meeting and I just I want to share what she said um with with each one of you and she said you guys keep doing great work for kids and I said oh yes we will and then she continued on and she said because in 5 years no one will remember you but they will remember what the state board did for kids and I think if we always keep
083that in our minds um we will we will do great things for kids and so I'm looking forward to 2025 and I love the the the connection we have having py come back and visit us today so at this time it's 10:15 um we will break until 10:30 to allow board members to have conversation with Lindsay before she leaves and have a brief break so we the board is at recess and we'll reconvene at 10:30 that was a e e e the meeting will resume in 3 minutes yeah if anyone who's giving public comment can move to the front row we'd appreciate that we'll start the meeting in just a couple minutes e e e okay everybody's waiting anxiously I hate to start a little bit early but um before we move into public comment
084I do want to acknowledge that we actually have three teachers of the year in this room actually well four with Lindsay Lindsay is our fourth and our newest um we have D Tonk from 1992 the front row [Applause] John heinan from 2000 give us a w and py Co John's would you wave and tell us what [Laughter] year 2006 we think all right there's py yes all right thank you and I love the opportunity to just be a little informal a little audience inter ction it's fun so now we are in agenda item 5.1 which is our public comment period this period may be available to any person who wishes to address the board on any matter appearing on the agenda up to 90 minutes will be allowed for the public comment period a majority
085of members present and voting may take action to extend the total amount of time allowed for the public comment period a majority of members present and voting may also take action to allow or terminate public comment at any time during a meeting if you are not signed in and wish to speak please sign in at this time those wishing to speak must be signed in at the table outside the meeting room each individual speaking to the board will be required to complete a signin card for identification of oneself individuals are required to include on the sign-in card their name address and name of any organization represented individuals may be prohibited to speak in public comment if the signing card does not include the required information persons speaking to the board during public comment should State
086their name city and state at the beginning of their allotted time and may submit printed materials to the board but may not use any other form of media anyone refusing to be identified will be prohibited from speaking each person may address the board for up to five minutes a majority of members present and voting may take action to reduce or extend the amount of a of individual time allotted to the speakers if at any time persons appearing before the board exceed the time limitations set forth in this policy or on the agenda or become abusive or threatening in language or behavior it shall be the responsibility of the president to refuse permission to continue to address the board we have 12 public comments cards submitted and vice president Deborah ner will announce the names of
087the speakers who have submitted who are here for comment a lot okay okay uh I'm going to ask uh you to just for the time efficiency for you to just come forward when the one before you has ended and so we're going to go in this order Al Brook Phillips D tonak and John heinan so just follow one right after the other so Al would you like to come forward and thank you all for being here good morning my name is Al coun I live here in Lincoln uh and thank you for having me uh you might not know this I found this out this morning today is National quitters day so if you started some New Year's resolutions please don't quit keep going keep going uh you may recall that the University of Nebraska
088Board of Regents last year voted to close the theater program at the University of Nebraska at Carney those of us with ties to theater and to Unk or who believe theater improves quality of life hope to reverse that decision uh the majority of theater kids don't get Marquee billing they become Financial analysts retirement home activity directors sound Engineers interior designers theater managers insurance agents worldclass composers New York City policemen bankers and teachers I have letters from some of them that you all have in your hands now including one from uh you mentioned D tonak retired math teacher and former Nebraska teacher of the year who firmly believes that teaching is performance and that every teacher candidate should take a theater class the key ingredient among all these professions a discipline is theater and that's a
089discipline that has helped them this majority of theater kids become successful off the stage Stage Theater has given them confidence it's taught them teamwork it's fostered organizational skills developed their imagination and done so much more in our work on the Unk project we made an unexpected Discovery sometime in the past changes were made to rule 24 as it pertains to speech and theater as we understand it Nebraska kids seeking to teach speech Andor theater can no longer obtain a subject endorsement in those two disciplines in Nebraska Nebraska colleges or universities the best that can be provided is a supplemental endorsement requiring no more than 18 hours too few hours in our estimation particularly when uh pk12 vocal music requires 45 hours and pk2 art offers only a full field endorsement requiring 54 hours any Nebraska
090kid who dreams of becoming a teacher of theater or speech essentially must leave the state to do so and and we have anecdotal evidence that this is happening and I believe this may have had at least some effect on the closure of the Unk theater program I would urge the board uh to consider updating rule 24 to elevate the available speech and theater endorsements from supplemental level to subject level we offered the 25 or so letters that we've submitted today from the majority supporting this request and there are other speakers here today with the same request so on National quitters day please please don't give up on Nebraska theater thank you good morning my name is Brooke Phillips I'm from Omaha Nebraska I'm in my 18th year teaching High School theater in the Omaha Metro
091area and I serve as a co- chapter director for the Nebraska thespians organization whose mission it is to shape lives through theater education Nebraska thespians strongly supports this effort to recognize theater as an endorsement area for secondary education in Nebraska just last week we hosted our annual thespian Festival where over 30 Secondary School theater kids came together to sing dance act and compete in technical Theater events unfortunately during the event we learned that the Benson High School theater director had resigned at the break and their students were left scrambling without guidance this is a heartbreaking example of the urgent need for certified theater Educators in our state Nebraska is facing a critical short of theater teachers every year we see talented Nebraska students many of whom who thrive in our local high school theater organizations
092leaving the state to pursue theater education degrees elsewhere my own recent grad had to Adventure to Central Missouri for her theater endorsement in the last decade theater has not been there has not been a a single year without at least one vacant theater opening in the secondary schools in our state a significant reason for this is that many drama teachers within Ela or English language arts endorsement do not have the specialized skills needed to effectively run a full theater program or teach a scaffolded theater curriculum our teachers deserve to feel qualified in all aspects of theater and the one or two courses required with the ELA certification don't even begin to touch the amount of knowledge required to be proficient in Theater Arts let alone be comfortable enough with the content to teach it in
093my current teaching schedule which I have to get back to today I start my day exploring Theater history radio drama and film and then I skip to my Advanced acting class where I'm talking about periods and styles Shakespeare and doing a deep dive into movement and voice and gestures um I then have a quick lunch and teach theater technology class where teacher where students are learning to design costumes sets makeup and lights and where I physically demonstrate how to work with power tools build platforms and try different painting techniques uh after that I'm asked by my Administration to go to the auditorium and turn on lights for a presentation or an assembly and make sure the microphones are working and then after school I direct uh plays and musicals every single day you can imagine
094why some teachers are overwhelmed by that amount of skill needed to be proficient so we need to get them the proper training currently every Secondary School in Nebraska is encouraged to offer at least one theater class yet we have no theater endorsements in 2018 the state board approved the K through2 Fine Arts standards which include guidelines for visual arts music theater and dance while Visual Arts and music teachers can earn State endorsements theater Educators cannot this Gap in certification must be addressed by creating a theater endorsement we can ensure that Nebraska schools of qualified teachers who are properly trained to practice and teach theater thereby strengthening Arts programs for all of our students across the state clearly this change could make a big impact and is crucial for meeting the growing demand for theater education
095and retaining talented Educators and theater Professionals in Nebraska it will also help ensure that students like those at Benson High School are never left without a theater teacher or director Nebraska thespians are eager to collaborate with you and provide recommendations to make this change a reality thank you for your time and your consideration and making theater its own endorsement area we look forward to working together to strengthen the Arts all across Nebraska thank you good morning I'm Dr D tonak and while 1992 now you know how old I am I am a retired math and physics teacher grades 8 through college level I have also supervised student teachers for the University of Nebraska Lincoln my bachelor's degree is in mathematics and English my master's degree is in mathematics my PhD is in Cur curriculum and
096administration as you know rule 24 governs endorsements in Nebraska K through2 teachers in all areas of study consistency in all areas is a challenge perhaps but inconsistency is quite evident in the areas of theater and speech where rule 24 allows only what are called supplemental in endorsements rather than subject or field endorsements as offered in art and music I believe such inconsistency discounts the importance of theater and speech curriculum strives to encourage the interconnectedness of subject areas you heard that in Lindy Wilson's report right in Connect connecting all sorts of subject areas actually centuries ago the disciplines were not as chopped up as they have become we do not all need to become Leonardo da Vinci I agree with that but our curriculum is missing the emphases that lets our teachers and in turn our
097students experience those connections in my retirement I have enjoyed showing the connections between math and art at the show Museum as a dosent in my oi classes I've enjoyed working with a music instructor to explain the connections between math and music but let me focus in particular on theater and speech in my 40 Years of teaching I have come to believe a key component of teaching Excellence requires skills learned in speech and theater how do you capture the audience attention what's key in the body language you use how do you move about the stage how do you voice inflection and pauses as I have worked with new teachers those traits are hard to teach there have even been books written about how to do this I believe at least I've said this for many decades
098one semester of theater Andor speech should be a part of every teacher's preparation one additional perspective might be that of lifelong learning we want that to be the approach of our teachers and our students again Lindsay Wilson surely demonstrated that in her presentation this morning I would give guess many of you have other interests beyond your initial degrees maybe over lunch talk about all the other things you've learned how to do and be interested in let's set the stage for our teachers and our students please enhance the requirements for speech and theater endorsements in Nebraska both for our teachers and our students and again thank you for all the important work you do thank you after d I'm sorry after John then we'll have Lori long and Dominic long thank you good morning my name
099is John Hinman I live here in Lincoln Nebraska and I come before you as the only speech theater and PE endorsed teacher you have ever met because I'm the only one although there's you're going to hear from an inspiring young teacher who is a PE teacher that directs musical so I'm excited to hear from him I come for you today with a deep sense of urgency and passion regarding the inclusion of subject endorsement areas of theater speech and theater speech theater as a community we recognize the transformative powers of the Arts and theater in particular offers a unique platform for our students to develop vital skills that extend far beyond the stage the importance of speech and theater cannot be overstated they are critical art forms that not only nurture creativity but also far Foster
100communication self skills self- expression and confidence in a world with increasingly values the ability to articulate ideas and emotions providing our students with a robust theater education is essential it empowers them to speak with Clarity engage with diverse perspectives and develop empathy skills that are invaluable at any career they choose however to fully realize the potential of theater and speech education in Nebraska we must ensure that our schools are equipped with teachers who are not only passionate about the Arts but also specifically trains in the nuances of speech and theat subject endorsements in these areas would provide necessary framework to prepare Educators to teach these vital skills with expertise and Excellence great teachers can Inspire greatness in their students and it's critical that we have instructors who understand the intricacies of theatrical performance and speech
101communication the benefits of a comprehensive theater program extend well beyond the develop individual development they enhance School culture overall students involved in theater learn Co cab collaboration discipline and resilience they create lasting friendships develop a sense of belonging and gain deep appreciation for the Arts these experiences contribute to the well-rounded education enriching our community and fostering Future Leaders who can communicate effectively and think critically I implore you to consider the long-term impact of adding subject endorsements in theater that would have our students our schools and our state by investing in this vital area of Education we're not only merely adding another subject but opening the doors to creativity expression and connection that will benefit our students for a lifetime let us work together to ensure every child in Nebraska has access to well-rounded education that
102includes the Arts it's time to elevate our commitment to theater education and our Educators in becoming the best they can thank you for the attention to this important matter I look forward to supporting in making theater education a priority in the state thank you good morning my name is Lori long and I am a proud public school teacher in gothamberg Nebraska where I serve as the high school librarian and direct our competitive play production team my words of support for the speech theater subject endorsement come from my experiences as a teacher and Coach but I could just as easily speak from the perspectives of parent and student I believe that involvement in the Arts specifically speech and theater not only teaches students a unique skill set but also provides opportun unties for social emotional development
103collaboration and teamwork and growth and prosperity for our communities at large properly educated and endorsed speech and theater teachers are necessary to facilitate and support these processes and I do have a subject endorsement in speech and theater grades uh 7 through 12 most of the proponents at this endorsement will mention the obvious students who are taught and participate in speech and theater activities become strong communicators who possess Poise and control verbal Acuity confidence and Leadership organizational skills and these descriptors are valid but I have another perspective to share in my school's when act program this year we involved 81 of our 2330 students in grade seven in grades 9 through 12 35% of our student body all are welcome all have a place 49 of those 81 were in the Performing cast but the remaining
10432 contributed as members of our set construction lighting sound prop costuming and promotional Crews while each of those groups worked as independent entities they also needed to be able to integrate their roles with the other subgroups and ultimately as a unified team that used collaboration cooperation problem solving and teamwork to reach that common goal skills that are applicable to every career field those students may follow after graduation theater education involves much more than performance skill additionally students involved in speech and theater are able to investigate experience explore and communicate The Human Condition through performance and storytelling the emotional response that comes from this isn't just felt by the audience and it doesn't go away when the curtain closes or the lights come up by inhabiting the characters of a story students learn and expand their
105own emotional intelligences empathy is a skill that needs nurturing and practice and participating in theater as a performer and as an audience member allows that practice in a risk-free environment these experiences should not be limited to high school students my coaching team supports separate theater programs for elementary and middle school students in our school district and the work of those young performers is uplifting and inspiring but let's be real teachers are in short supply no matter what the subject area while I know my multiplication facts I shouldn't teach algebra simply because I have a degree in education or took a math class in high school having a strong background in training should be the expectation of every subject taught in our schools not just the core areas that are reflected in state standards and testing
106without the support of this endorsement more and more schools May Farm out these roles to anyone with or without a degree with or without age appropriate developmental experience and eventually these programs could be another example of The Haves and Have Nots that further separate more the more populated areas from the rural stretches of our state as I was excuse me as I was working through the draft for this letter at school yesterday the lead actress in my one act came to the library to chat during her free period I told her what I was writing and asked her if she could tell me something she gained from being involved in speech and theater in our school she paused and then she said Mrs long I know you think I'm going to say that now I'm
107more confident when I speak or I perform in front of an audience but really I've learned how to be a friend and a good person how to work with a group for something greater than myself being in theater opened me up to new people and helped me create relationships with other kids that I wouldn't have necessarily connected with otherwise the theater program has something for everyone not to be judgy or anything but theater kids are the most adaptable and accepting people and I wouldn't know that if I wasn't in one act I implore you to support the subject endorsement for speech and theater so that teachers can be trained and supported to provide the best education and experiences for our students the Arts are important the Arts are for all thank you for your time
108thank you Dominic then JD Warden Dr Randall Bretz and then Dan Hayes thank you good morning my name is Dominic long and I am a PE and health teacher here at more Middle School uh I am speaking as a product of speech in theater um first I'd like to thank my colleagues for covering my classes today before I get back after my time I am here in support of elevating theater and speech endorsement from supplemental status to subject status under rule 24 as a physical education and health teacher and as someone who has participated in theater for my entire life I have both lived and witnessed firsthand the transformative power of theater and speech education throughout my high school Arts experience I was a choir member drum major in our school band speech team President
109and leader of one of our one act team and musical program because of my experiences and the skill I obtained in these areas I was able to pursue a childhood dream of mine playing college football unfortunately for me I don't have any quantitative data to support my playing time during my three seasons however from the start I became the best teammate I could be because I embraced my role I was able to be a leader behind the scenes and I was able to inspire and lift up my teammates because of my mentors and teachers in theater I've worked hard to instill these characteristics in my students also all of that can be attributed to what theater and speech have done for me as a human being while playing football I pursued a degree in kinesiology
110and a career in physical therapy after some detours through covid I found myself on a path to education currently I am in the teacher transition program at Unk earning my 712 PE endorsement and I should be done at the end of this semester while this might be a bias stance I feel that I have that I have an elevated president presence and confidence as a teacher who didn't have a traditional path to education because of my experiences in all of the Arts namely speech and theater theater and speech give students the confidence to advocate for themselves and support others they learn to express ideas clearly and uplift their peers creating leaders who can navigate complex social situations and Inspire collaboration moreover theater is a gateway to exploring life's many facets from history to culture and
111ethics it offers lessons that will be seen and felt beyond the classroom benefiting both the participants and audiences alike Nebraska students deserve fully qualified theater and speech Educators elevating these endorsements will ensure teachers have the training and knowledge needed to guide students like me effectively in these vital areas finally I'd like to note that I've been lucky enough to serve as the assistant director of our Middle School Musical and theater program which by the way from last year jumped from 86 students to this year 120 we just completed a very successful showing of Elf JR this past December um those were both onstage and off-stage uh student participants many students want to take theater they want to take theater and they want to participate in Productions Beyond Middle School many of these students need theater
112to unlock all of their untapped potential it's only fair to them that their teachers are fully equipped to give them the most complete education one that is not complete without the Arts all of the Arts thank you for your time and consideration my name is JD Warden I was a speech theater teacher uh in Nebraska for 33 years and you all have my letter I assume because I emailed you most but um to just touch on my letter briefly because I know I only have five minutes one of the most significant uh memories I have of growing up was uh my exposure to drama at the elementary school where we were writing a play and putting it on ourselves with the help of a very creative teacher and it probably wasn't the best script in
113the world but uh we loved doing that and from that point on and painting cardboard to look like Castle Stone and uh Etc props made out of cardboard I developed my love for theater at a very early age unfortunately my high school did not offer any kind of drama uh we did have the speech team but thankfully we had a couple English teachers that were willing to do a Junior and senior class play and and those memories from my speech activities in theater and high school as well as music um set my course uh for being an educator in those areas and so I attended Carney State College and received my BA in speech and theater in 72 I went on to the University of Arkansas receiving my masters in speech and theater I began
114my teaching career in rural ogalala Nebraska believe it or not and the only reason why that happened is because they had a late termination of someone who did the plays so ogalala landed up with the first fully educated Drama teacher with two degrees uh had a great time teaching there for three years uh my work there allowed me to be offered a job at the new high school Bia West um and since that time I cannot begin account how many of my students over the years were involved in all aspects of theater production and have told me on numerous occasions how they continue to enjoy and appreciate theater today because of their participation in drama and speech at BV West they have all encouraged their children to take part in theater programs in school they
115know the value of theater from their experiences and they want to pass that on to their children I also have many students that went on to related careers in theater from teaching in public private college and universities to become professional actors and directors of stage television and film many of my theater friends in college did the same the only people that I know of that don't truly appreciate the art of Life theater are those that for whatever reason never took the opportunity or never had the opportunity to be involved in theater today television and film provide us with our major entertainment almost everyone loves watching television and seeing movies but they easily forget that the majority of those creating all their those aspects of cherish entertainment started their lives in theater with exposure to drama
116in early Public Schools uh therefore the Nebraska Board of Education should be doing all they can to ensure that theater continues to be a part of all public schools throughout the state and that those who are certified to teach speech and drama and direct these programs have an excellent educational background for doing so every student deserves that I close with one last comment I am in utter disbelief and more than disappointed that the board of regions put an end to carne's theater program which was excellent the foundation for my 33-year career and my success as an educator of Theater Arts began with the wonderful college education I received at Carney Nebraska Public Schools need great speech and theater teachers with great educations I can't even think of a major college that doesn't have a theater
117arts program can you uh the regions have deprived the high schools particularly in central Nebraska from having qualified teachers and directors of drama what a sad note for public education in the state of Nebraska I pray changes will be made to correct these deficiencies as soon as possible and begin to certify speech and theater teachers throughout the state thank you Dr Bretz Dan Hayes Peg sinard and Steve B well good morning uh president Tech Meer and commissioner and assistant commissioner and members of the State Board of Education thank you for this opportunity just a month ago I was watching CBS Sunday Morning on channel 10 as a matter of fact and they featured a story encouraging about the theater program in the prison it was in New York and it had a significant and positive
118impact on the men in that prison what prison was it Sing Sing we've all heard of it haven't we it was a it is a Maximum Security Prison built with the idea of stick those bad guys in the prison and they'll learn they won't come back but you know what happens 60% of them come back in after they've released a nationwide study by the department of of uh justice said 60% of those who serve their term and released or from that prison go back inside Sing Sing however is a theater program that involves the men in serving time there this program helps them learn how to communicate as though they were on stage and to prepare them to do theater performances it's called the RTA now get this the recidivism of those that involved in
119the RTA is just 3% compared to 60% the men develop and learn Trust respect and empathy which not only changes their outlook on life but they become leaders in the prison and they help change the atmosphere within that prison now I'm not standing here today to say that our public schools are like prison although there's some guys that might think it's like going to prison every day when they go to high school but I'm not saying that but participating in the Performing Arts can and does have a similar impact it helps us students develop trust and respect and empathy just as Mrs long said it also helps them be better friends and good persons and it helps them become leaders in their schools It prepares them to be good citizens participating in a drama program
120in a school brings students together for a common experience that will become a lifelong memory well the problem is that many teachers who were assigned to do the drama program are in inadequately trained if at all well you have before you a proposed amendment to rule 24 that will help Rectify that situation and I urge you to approve and the proposed endorsement for theater certification so I thank you for the opportunity to be here thank you all for your service on the state board and know that my belief that public education is vital to the future of our country thank you can just a reminder speakers please say your name and your town thank you oh it's okay I I it's fine just it's just a gentle reminder Dr Randall Brett that just spoke and
121now we have Dan Hayes good morning I am Dan Hayes I'm from elorn Nebraska and I am the director of theater at Midland University in Fremont um and I do want to say thank you all for your service uh I'm such a believer in education and what you're doing is so important as paty said and and Elizabeth said earlier um thank you for all that I just I'm going to take this on a little bit different take because I've been uh one of the ones pushing for um looking at rule 24 and um the endorsement um instead of a just a supplemental looking at a subject for theater and that comes very personally because I was there um I I W was a a public school educator I taught vocal music for 16 years but
122it came kind of a crazy route and now I teach um I have degrees in theater and vocal music um and now I teach theater and I am teaching a lot of students who want to be theater teachers um and they're having to find another subject to go with that I am not encouraging us to throw out the baby with the bath water I think that the rule 24 works if you have another area that you are interested in but what we're missing is those students who are focused on I want to teach theater and speech and at the college level we can't give that to them right now it's a pretty simple let's change that and allow them to have it I would encourage my students to look at add English add music add
123something else it makes you more marketable but um right now we have students who are coming and being recruited at Midland and they say can I get um a theater education degree and I have to say I can get you u a supplemental degree but you'll have to have another area and they can go to Iowa Missouri um other places and get that all we want at the college level um and I'm only speaking speaking for Midland right now so I won't speak for my colleagues is that we would like to be able to offer that um when I first brought this up I was I was tasked with is there a need for it and I think you can I hope that you can see that there is a need right now I just
124found out about Benson but Ralston is also looking for a theater teacher so is Millard and um Brown Al talber just um hired one of my former students who got certified um in Florida now not in Nebraska and is coming back to teach at Brown out tala so there is a need the other thing is will there be any colleges that are interested and I can tell you that Midland has met we have decided the education department and the arts department met we have a plan on how we can do it without adding any extra faculty or any extra money so it's it's a no-brainer if we could do that but we need the Department of Education and the State Board to say this is something that can be done at the college level um
125that's all I have to say I just I have lots of um evidence I have put some things for you um that you can look at I would love to be involved if there's any way I can help to move this forward and um I again I appreciate all you do please think about let's move this up um to a level where I think it will keep more of our students here and someday I'm going to retire and somebody's going to need to take my job and they need to be certified so I would like that to be a Nebraskan thank you very much Peg card next from Carney and Steve bar Carney after her good morning as she said my name is Peg sinard I am a retired uh music and theater teacher uh
126I a long time in fact I can go all the way back to Country schools so uh but uh the last couple schools that I did teach at were at Amherst Public Schools where as a K12 a um music teacher and also taught did theater and then for 18 years I retired from Gibbon Public Schools where I was the music and theater teacher over there um presently I am the um creator of no not Creator the creative creative arts program coordinator at the beautiful new um YMCA Carney Family YMCA which I would say we're the only we only YMCA that has a creative arts program in the state Nebraska um I have no I have nothing here in front of me but me and that is because I was just um asked and recruited by
127a dear friend of mine Steve um to come yesterday afternoon so I am talking from the top of my head but actually no from my heart and um so I have listened to what some of the other people have said so I will just tell you from my own experience um from from being in the schools these kids love love one act they love musicals they love speech and my kids that I my kids my kids from from Gibbon uh the last guys at they would be they would be at school early in the morning with marching band yep that's me they would be in school all day I would have food in my room to make sure that there was food for them during the day they would go to football practice and then
128they would come to one act sometimes they brought the little brothers and sisters because they were because they had to take care of their kids I'm not saying well look at me I did not mean that in that way I promise I did not mean it in that way I'm just saying these kids w't do that I can I'm just uh uh saying when we did our we did our one act um about the Holocaust the stuff the what the impact that the had that had on those kids and have these kids come back to me and for me to watch what these kids have done since then is is just mindboggling um these are kids that um especially in small school because they do everything but you know they they were playing they were
129playing football too they were doing all that but you know there has to be a place for all kids and there aren't you know there are just some kids that maybe they don't want to play football maybe they don't want to play basketball and you know that you can have the scenarios when they're in a small school but also in a big school you know what there's five on the court for basketball are they all going to make the basketball team nope um I can thank Steve from the bottom my heart with my own grandson um who played football but he also started when he played JoJo in susal back when he was I don't know about 11 years old and now he's a professional actor down in U Memphis Tennessee but it started with
130started with Steve and because of the um acting and theater classes that he had at Carney High School the theater is so important it's so so important speech is so important could people get up here oh if you saw I'm kind of shaking but can people get up and and talk I know and Gibbon they said thank you for the speech and and the theater classes you offered because to graduate as a senior they had to do an English they had to do a a speech and some of those kids they were scared to get up into a speech but the ones that were involved in theater they they did they did much better so please please I I know the amount of teachers that are not really qualified so to speak to teach theater
131but they step up in in schools and they do it because of because of how much our kids love theater and speech and it is very important thank you for all you do and thank you for giving us the time to talk today thank you thank you uh Steve bar Carney next and then Heather schmith after Steve thank you very much I am Steve bar I am the executive um director of crane River theater in Carney and also president of Nebraskans for the Arts and I want to thank all of you for your time in listening to us today um I'm here to advocate for a change to rule 24 regarding the teaching endorsement for theater currently as you have heard the rule only allows a supplemental endorsement for Theater which requires 18 credit hours
132we request that a subject endorsement be offered for theater instead requiring 45 Plus credit hours hour thereby enabling our Statewide post-secondary institutions the ability to offer a theater education degree so why should we do this well theater is the key to communication collaboration and creativity it has been proven time and time again those students that participate in theater are more likely to achieve higher grades and test scores as you have heard additionally theater offers an outlet for expression that is essential in the development of our youth today theater has always played an important role in my life beginning with the Arts education I received at Carney Public Schools so much of that um that went on um so much so that it was important to me I received my ba and my MFA in theater
133from the University of Nebraska at Lincoln following that I went to New York to direct and perform for many years before returning to Carney to start my own Theater Company crane River theater a professional production company that brings in artists from across the country and has educated thousands of Youth across the state as I have traveled Nebraska to more than 60 communities with our Arts education programs I've experienced firsthand the need the need for theater education students teachers administrators are eager to bring in cran RAR theater because of the unique ability the theater has to impact our youth so only a small percentage of students in Nebraska receive any type of theater education why why are there so few courses being offered at high schools well the simple answer is that there are not enough
134qualified teachers it is only with necessary training requirements and appropriate teaching endorsement that Nebraska will be able to offer adequate theater education currently schools are lucky if if there's one theater course that's offered during the year that's not enough let me use Carney high school as an example many years ago there was only one theater course offered to students there but then a qualified educated theater Prof Professor pushed for additional courses based on the interest of students and as a result there are now currently even today still four theater courses being offered with full enrollment a teacher with a supplemental endorsement would not have the appropriate education to create and teach these courses so are high school students in Nebraska interested in a theater education well most definitely play production as you have heard from
135Lori long to is one of the most successful um activities in NSAA there are hundreds of students in every single School small schools larger schools that are taking part in this so clearly they have an interest and an excitement to to to be involved now I'm constantly hearing from teachers and students across Nebraska that they wish that there was more opportunity for theat Education during the school day well we have that opportunity to do this with a simple change to rule 24 okay so high schools are interested are colleges and universities interested in offering a education degree and will the students take advantage of that opportunity well Dan Hayes has already showed you so but here's another interesting bit of information one would argue that they're not only interested these universities but they're depending they're
136depending on this essential degree opportunity for students I recently met with um two dear friends of mine the department chair at the University of Central Missouri Ashley Miller and the academic adviser of school of for Theater of Arts at the University of Northern Colorado Dana Phillips both of which have robust theater education programs not not only are they robust but over half of the theater Majors over half of the theater majors at Central Missouri University are theater education majors and then over um onethird of the majors at University of Northern Colorado are theater degree Majors theater education Majors these are incredibly important programs at these schools and they simply asked me why why would Nebraska not want to offer a subject indorsement why would they not want to have theater education degrees for their students
137and here's the best statistic that you can take is that both of them told me that they have 100% placement for their theater education Majors so not only is there an interest from high schools and there's an interest from universities we're setting them up for Success because there's 100% placement for this degree why would we not want to do that so the question we should be asking ourselves today is why why are we undervaluing theater education we should follow the lead of these amazing other institutions that have that success we too though in Nebraska can create amazing theater teachers and keep them in our state to educate our youth we do not need to lose them to surrounding states I take a lot of pride in being from Nebraska and when I began my career
13815 years ago I had no idea that I would end up back here and in in educating Youth and having such success for my hometown Community but I love doing so and it's done so because of the leaders that I had teaching me theater that had these degrees so I encourage you to consider this and I thank you so much for your time thank you Heather Schmidt Lincoln good morning or afternoon I guess um my name is Heather Schmidt I'm from Lincoln uh congratulations to the new board members and to Elizabeth and Depp on your re-election to leadership it sounds like our kids have some tenation tenacious Advocates willing to fight for them my family and I have been advocating for dyslexia learners years it is personal for us we've been encouraged by legislation championed
139by state senators across the political Spectrum who have all known that dyslexia is not given the attention it deserves by neglecting dyslexia we are now decades behind as reported by Lauren Wagner in the Omaha World Herald as you work on the policy to meet the requirements in the legislation and the Nebraska literacy plan please Center dyslexia it is beyond time for that disruption thank you you thank you that's all our public speakers today thank you it was a pleasure to to have all of you here that's not in my script but I just want you to know it I really enjoyed it um submitted written public comments are attached in the electronic meeting agenda for the board in public to review a new board members if you need help accessing those let one of your
140fellow board members or staff know and we can help you there is one Unwritten public comment agenda item six is there a motion to adop adopt the consent agenda I move to adopt the consent agenda second it is moved and seconded to adopt the consent agenda per board policy there is no discussion on the motion to adopt the consent agenda with the recording secretary please call the role shanoff here yes Christensen yes rener yes Jones yes Douglas yes Penner yes T Meer yes eight yes the votes are eight yes the affirmative has it and the consent agenda is adopted all right agenda item 7.1 this is uh the Nebraska literacy project plan and per the commissioner's recommendation um we do not take action on that is there any discussion on this item okay thank you
141item 7.2 is there a motion yes I have a motion here and I've put it in front of uh all my uh fellow board members and I will uh read the motion here I move to amend the previously adopted motion to accept the comprehensive literacy State development Grant funds and authorize the commissioner to enter into contracts and sub awwards to carry out Grant activities by striking and what we're striking here the underlined and authorize the commissioner to enter into contracts and sub Awards to carry out Grant activities so that the motion if amended would read to accept the comprehensive literacy State development Grant funds and I'll ask for a second a second y sorry is there a second on this motion I second okay Kirk since you brought this motion would you like to elaborate
142sure just just briefly the the power of the purse is the board and uh it is board policy and I spoke with commissioner Maher about this and he more than welcomes this motion and it's 100% behind this motion to make sure uh for transparency that the funds being spent with the clsd funds uh are uh brought to the full board to spend any other discussion or questions Deborah so uh Thank you Kirk uh for uh I this is thoughtful and when he handed this out this morning and I read it I'm like yeah in theory I really believe in this and I do think it requires a discussion uh and uh I would like to recommend that we uh move this to next month so that it can go through the normal process that any
143board agenda action item would go through and I and I will probably vote as support it next month because then I will have had all the opportunities to ask all the questions and so for the new board members what I'm talking about and something we've tried to do as long as I've been on the board I mean every single action item that comes to us goes through a committee first so that it can be vetted and understood and at least half the board can come with some thoughtful discussion we have tried in the past few years to make sure that the same thing happens with anything that a board member wants to bring through as an agenda item that it needs to go through the same process it needs to go through a committee first
144so that there can be lots of thoughtful discussion with the staff about the impact of anything uh now I've been on the board long enough to know that some of these big grants that we get and the contracts that we do end up in some catch22 situations and I want to understand what those might be I am all all about uh budgetary transparency and going through the normal approval process uh but I don't even know if our new board members know what our normal approval process is yet and so uh I would like to make a motion just to move this topic to go back to the appropriate committee and I don't know if that's Finance or one of the others and I'll let our staff and our board president figure that out but I'd
145like to make a motion to just uh move this since there is no fire on this topic uh move this back to a committee so that it can be vetted in a normal process be before we continue into your motion can does anyone object to continuing the discussion on this motion no getting I'm getting a look from my if somebody seconds what I just said then so there is a there is a motion to refer probably to the budget and finance committee there is a motion on the floor for that so is there okay so it's been motioned and seconded to move this amendment back to the budget and finance committee is there any discussion on this motion on the motion to to refer this to the budget and finance committee Kristen thank you um
146yeah I would agree that uh as a new board member um I have enough background knowledge to understand that this grant is massive uh and also understand that I don't know the full context of what has happened on the board in the past few months surrounding this grant um and just feel I need more time before this is an action item that I'm voting on today to get more information and understand what it is um that we're striking and the implications of that um so would be fully in support of sending this back to committee to just to give myself and the other new board members time to understand um the context and the history of this part of the grant Lisa um I would like to regardless of how we go with this um
147to have this voted on then in prior to the literacy project upcoming because I think this is a huge part of the literacy project right and knowing exactly how the funds are going to be dispersed as an important part of passing the literacy project any further comments or questions I have a question for the commissioner um commissioner Maher will a delay in this motion um can you can you let us know how that will affect the work of the department I'd probably need a little a little more time to think through it more deeply but my knee-jerk reaction would be I don't think it would encumber our work at all I don't I don't think it would have any impact on the day-to-day work that we'll be doing in the office between now and and
148February so I I think there would be no consequence to the staff on on either motion quite frankly thank you for that anyone else Sher you I will add something and and I'm certainly I'm not opposed to this I think this is a good discussion I am wondering do we have a formal policy in writing how everything moves through I'm wondering if we should or is this just kind of a logical way that we should be doing it going through so just some information about that would be helpful I'm let I I love your question thank you you and I I think that we uh the bylaws uh allow us some flexibility if there is something really urgent and we need to bring something directly to the board so that flexibility is there uh now
149I could have sworn you have to have two people approves but that's Kirk remind yeah but Kirk reminded me this morning anyone can put anything on the board agenda but if it's within seven days of the board meeting it does require two people and uh to approve it but I guess what I'm saying is I'm back to your question um yes we have always had a process where something if a board member brings something forward that it goes it the appropriate thing to do is to go through the committee first so that it is vetted in the same way any other action item would be vetted that the staff would bring forward but there is flexibility in the bylaws where if there are exceptions that need to be made I am fine if you want
150to delay this but Dr for can you read the board policy that I'm referring to here is it it is $50,000 or more has to come in front agency management policy so I'm okay in delaying it all you're doing is postponing our board policy to be decided next week has nothing to do with with when the thing was put on the agenda has nothing to do with that anything $50,000 or more has to come to the state board for approval it's our policy we just read our rid our policy a year or two ago that's what it is so I'm okay in delaying it I'm just saying you're just we could be done with it because it's going to come here regardless it has to by board policy come to us I I guess oh
151sorry you're fine and I agree except the wording of it like what you are suggesting taking out all this wording that talks um that gives them the specific permission to enter into contracts and sub boards which they need that in order to uh have conversations with possible vendors I mean what I was thinking is awarding uh change that I would recommend is keeping all that working in and then just adding the words instead of removing those just adding the words uh based on whatever our normal process is or you know something like putting it in that you know using normal approval processes and I was going to just recommend that as a change but then I thought our new board members don't know what our normal approval processes are so that didn't seem fair to
152bring this forward when there's so much unless we want to bring up our finance team and and and do a whole you know explanation of what our normal process is I just think that uh in general everything should be vetted and discussed through a committee okay so so I want to keep our I want to keep our discussion really focused on um we are discussing do we want to refer this or not to budget and finance and I appreciate these and I think these are great conversations that we're going to go deeper into I can see that those are concerns in you know in procedures that we maybe have we saw the little um pyramid that Deputy Commissioner H said had with customs and maybe sometimes Customs need to move into the role of policy
153um and so we can talk about that so we have a motion on the floor to refer this to the budget and finance committee are there any other comments or questions about that Li yeah I just want to I guess address I I get where you're coming from Kirk and it is probably a quick decision that we'll all agree to in a month but out of respect for uh the four new members this is huge and I know it's not a big change because it's the policy but to see something regarding a grant of this um amount and to be told uh 5 minutes before that this is what going to change to and you and the commissioner have already decided this makes sense I trust you both but I think we need to set
154a standard that we do uh follow a procedure protocol for everything because there may be a time when a deal comes up and you rush through and you don't think to ask all the questions or even know yet what to ask so I do want to I hear what you're saying uh and it feels probably a little bit like we're going back backwards to go forwards but I do think as a new board member that we need that uh that thinking time to get to get on speed on board okay okay so so I'm just gonna say that that I I I really respect that I wish that that would have happened my first board meeting we were brought an agenda item and um it had significant impact on our budget on our budget deficit
155and on in our test and I didn't have that opportunity and so because of that I do understand where you all are coming from and um I think this is a great discussion so see no further hands or lights I'm going to repeat the motion the motion is to refer the amendment back to the budget and finance committee with the record secretary please call the role Douglas yes teg Meer yes Christensen yes shanoff yes rener yes ner yes Jones yes Penner yes eight yes the affirmative Hazard and the motion to refer the amendment back to the budget and finance committee is adopted and so the other motion is it come back after the Budget Finance okay all right parliamentary procedure John Hinman is a parliamentarian out there too so to say okay the next items
156on the agenda are items 8.1 through 8 Point 13 these are information items and written reports for the board agenda item nine is good of the order this section of the agenda is intended for board members to offer informal observations of the work of the state board board members may make brief announcements about attendance at future events for the purpose of informing other board members no business or motions or suggested actions of the board may be offered at this point in the agenda nor should nor should board members engage in substantive discussion about other agenda items or introduce new agenda items okay all right all right seeing no comments thank you to those who attended in person and who tuned in to the broadcast the next meetings of the State Board of Education are scheduled
157for February 6th and 7th 202 in Lincoln Nebraska the January 10th 2025 State Board of Education meeting is adjourned for